article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
a groupoid is a small category whose arrows are all invertible . more precisely we have the following definition .
a * groupoid * over a set @xmath0 is a set of * arrows * @xmath1 along with a * target map * @xmath2 , a * source map * @xmath3 , a * identity section * @xmath4 which is a injective function , a * partially defined operation * ( or product ) @xmath5 on @xmath1 , which is a function : @xmath6 and a * inversion map * @xmath7 , @xmath8 .
these are the structure maps of the groupoid .
they satisfy several identities . 1 .
for any @xmath9 we have @xmath10 2 .
then for any @xmath11 we have also @xmath12 .
this allows us to write the expression @xmath13 and to state that the operation @xmath5 is associative : @xmath14 3 .
for any @xmath15 the identity section satisfies @xmath16 and @xmath17 4 .
the inversion map is an involution : @xmath18 . for any @xmath15 we have @xmath19 and
@xmath20 and @xmath21 [ defgroid ] an equivalent definition of a groupoid emphasizes the fact that a groupoid may be defined only in terms of its arrows .
a groupoid is a set @xmath1 with two operations @xmath22 , @xmath23 , which satisfy a number of properties . with the notations @xmath24 , @xmath25 , these properties are : for any @xmath26 1 . if @xmath27 and @xmath28 then @xmath29 and @xmath30 and we have @xmath31 , 2 .
@xmath32 and @xmath33 , 3 . if @xmath27 then @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
[ defgroid2 ] starting with the definition [ defgroid2 ] , we can reconstruct the objects from definition [ defgroid ] .
the set @xmath36 is formed by all products @xmath37 , @xmath38 . for any @xmath38 we let @xmath39 and @xmath40 .
the identity section is just the identity function on @xmath0 .
a groupoid is denoted either by @xmath41 , or by @xmath42 . in the second case
we shall use the notation @xmath43 . in most of this paper
we shall simply denote a groupoid @xmath42 by @xmath1 .
the transformation @xmath44 is a * morphism of groupoids * defined from @xmath45 to @xmath46 is a pair of maps : @xmath47 and @xmath48 which commutes with the structure , that is : @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 is a morphism of operations , from the operation @xmath5 to operation @xmath54 . a * hausdorff topological groupoid * is a groupoid @xmath1 which is also a hausdorff topological space , such that inversion is continuous and the multiplication is continuous with respect to the topology on @xmath55 induced by the product topology on @xmath56 .
we denote by @xmath57 the * difference function * : @xmath58 we shall consider the convergence of nets @xmath59 of arrows , with @xmath60 a parameter in a directed set @xmath61 . in this paper
the most encountered directed set @xmath61 will be @xmath62 . a * normed groupoid * @xmath63 is a groupoid @xmath41 with a * norm * function @xmath64 , such that : 1 .
@xmath65 if and only if there is a @xmath66 with @xmath67 , 2 . for any @xmath9 we have @xmath68 , 3 . for any @xmath15 we have @xmath69 .
a * norm * @xmath70 * is separable * if it satisfies the property : 1 . if there is a net @xmath71 such that for any @xmath72 @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 then @xmath76 . [ defnorm ]
let @xmath77 be a normed groupoid and @xmath78 its difference function .
the norm @xmath70 composed with the function @xmath78 gives a new function @xmath79 : @xmath80 which induces a distance on the space @xmath81 , for any @xmath82 : @xmath83 the * metric groupoid * @xmath84 associated to the normed groupoid @xmath1 is the following metric groupoid : 1 .
the objects of @xmath84 are the metric spaces @xmath85 , with @xmath86 ; 2 .
the arrows are right translations @xmath87 3 .
the multiplication of arrows is the composition of functions ; 4 .
the norm is defined by : @xmath88 .
[ dmgru ] remark that arrows in the metric groupoid @xmath84 are isometries .
it is also clear that @xmath84 is isomorphic with @xmath1 by the morphism @xmath89 .
the * @xmath90-double groupoid * @xmath91 associated to @xmath1 is another way to assembly the metric spaces @xmath92 , @xmath86 , into a groupoid .
the definition of this groupoid is : 1 .
the arrows are @xmath93 ; 2 .
the composition of arrows is : @xmath94 , the inverse is @xmath95 , therefore as a groupoid @xmath91 is just the union of trivial groupoids over @xmath92 , @xmath86 ; 3 .
it follows that @xmath96 and the induced @xmath90 and @xmath97 maps are : @xmath98 and @xmath99 , for any @xmath100 with @xmath101 ; 4 .
the norm is the function @xmath79 .
[ ddoub ] this groupoid has the property that @xmath78 is a morphism of normed groupoids . finally , suppose that for any @xmath102 there is @xmath15 such that @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
then any separable norm @xmath70 on @xmath1 induces a distance on @xmath105 , by the formula : @xmath106 if the groupoid is not connected by arrows then @xmath107 may take the value @xmath108 and the space @xmath0 decomposes into a disjoint union of metric spaces .
any norm @xmath70 on a groupoid @xmath1 induces three notions of convergence on the set of arrows @xmath1 .
a net of arrows @xmath109 * simply converges * to the arrow @xmath38 ( we write @xmath110 ) if : 1 . for any @xmath111
there are elements @xmath112 such that @xmath113 , 2 .
we have @xmath114 and @xmath115 . a net of arrows @xmath59 * left - converges * to the arrow @xmath38 ( we write @xmath116 ) if for all @xmath117 we have @xmath118 and moreover @xmath119 .
a net of arrows @xmath59 * right - converges * to the arrow @xmath38 ( we write @xmath120 ) if for all @xmath117 we have @xmath121 and moreover @xmath122 .
[ defconv ] it is clear that if @xmath116 or @xmath120 then @xmath123 .
right - convergence of @xmath124 to @xmath125 is just convergence of @xmath124 to @xmath125 in the distance @xmath126 , that is @xmath127 . left - convergence of @xmath124 to @xmath125 is just convergence of @xmath128 to @xmath129 in the distance @xmath130 , that is @xmath131 .
[ propconv ] let @xmath1 be a groupoid with a norm @xmath70 . 1 . if @xmath116 and @xmath132 then @xmath133 . if @xmath120 and @xmath134 then @xmath133 .
2 . the following are equivalent : 1 .
@xmath1 is a hausdorff topological groupoid with respect to the topology induced by the simple convergence , 2 .
@xmath70 is a separable norm , 3 . for any net @xmath109 , if @xmath135 and @xmath136 then @xmath133 .
4 . for any net @xmath109 ,
if @xmath137 and @xmath132 then @xmath133 .
[ [ proof . ] ] proof .
+ + + + + + \(i ) we prove only the first part of the conclusion .
we can write @xmath138 , therefore @xmath139 the right hand side of this inequality is arbitrarily small , so @xmath140 , which implies @xmath133 .
\(ii ) remark that the structure maps are continuous with respect to the topology induced by the simple convergence .
we need only to prove the uniqueness of limits .
@xmath141 4 .
is trivial . in order to prove that 4.@xmath141 3 .
, consider an arbitrary net @xmath109 such that @xmath135 and @xmath136 .
this means that there exist nets @xmath142 such that @xmath143 , @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
let @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
we have then @xmath148 and @xmath149
. then @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
we deduce that @xmath133 .
1.@xmath152 3 .
is trivial .
@xmath141 2 .
we finish the proof by showing that 2 .
@xmath141 3 . by a reasoning made previously ,
it is enough to prove that : if @xmath153 and @xmath154 then @xmath133 .
because @xmath70 is separable it follows that @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
we have then @xmath157 , therefore @xmath158 the norm @xmath70 induces a left invariant distance on the vertex group of all arrows @xmath159 such that @xmath160 .
this distance is obviously continuous with respect to the simple convergence in the group .
the net @xmath161 simply converges to @xmath162 by the continuity of the multiplication ( indeed , @xmath163 simply converges to @xmath162 ) .
therefore @xmath164 .
it follows that @xmath165 is arbitrarily small , therefore @xmath133 .
@xmath166 instead of a norm we may use families of seminorms . a * family of seminorms * on a groupoid @xmath1 is a family @xmath167 of functions @xmath168 with the properties : 1 . for any @xmath66 and @xmath169 we have @xmath170 ; if @xmath171 for any @xmath169 then there is @xmath66 such that @xmath67 , 2 . for any @xmath169 and @xmath172 we have @xmath173 , 3 .
for any @xmath169 and @xmath15 we have @xmath174 . a groupoid @xmath1 endowed with a family of seminorms @xmath167
is called a * seminormed groupoid*. a family of seminorms @xmath167 is separable if it satisfies the property : 1 . if there is a net @xmath175 such that for any @xmath72 @xmath73 , @xmath74 and for any @xmath169 we have @xmath176 then @xmath76 .
[ defseminormedg ] families of morphisms induce families of seminorms .
let @xmath1 be a groupoid and @xmath177 be a normed groupoid . a @xmath177 * family of morphisms * is a set @xmath178 of morphisms from @xmath1 to @xmath179 such that for any @xmath15 there is @xmath180 with @xmath181 .
the following proposition has a straightforward proof which we omit .
let @xmath1 be a groupoid , @xmath177 be a normed groupoid and @xmath178 a @xmath177 family of morphisms .
then the set @xmath182 is a family of seminorms .
definition [ defconv ] can be modified for the case of families of seminorms .
let @xmath183 be a semi - normed groupoid .
a net of arrows @xmath59 * simply converges * to the arrow @xmath38 ( we write @xmath123 ) if : 1 . for any @xmath184
there are elements @xmath112 such that @xmath143 , 2 . for any @xmath169 we have @xmath185 . a net of arrows @xmath59 * left - converges * to the arrow @xmath38 ( we write @xmath116 ) if for all @xmath117 we have @xmath118 and moreover for any @xmath169 we have @xmath186 .
a net of arrows @xmath59 * right - converges * to the arrow @xmath38 ( we write @xmath120 ) if for all @xmath117 we have @xmath121 and moreover for any @xmath169 we have @xmath187 .
[ defconv2 ] with these slight modifications , the proposition [ propconv ] still holds true .
this is visible from the examination of its proof .
let us finally remark that if @xmath188 is a seminormed groupoid , where @xmath178 is a @xmath177 family of morphisms , then a net @xmath189 converges ( simply , left or right ) to @xmath38 if and only if for any @xmath180 the net @xmath190 respectively converges in @xmath177 .
we shall use right - convergence , according to definition [ defconv ] , but left - convergence or simple convergence could also be used . in relation to this
see for example the remark [ rema1 ] .
let @xmath1 be a normed groupoid with a separable norm .
a net @xmath191 of functions @xmath192 * uniformly converges on bounded sets * to the function @xmath193 ( in the sense of the left convergence ) if : 1 . for any @xmath194 and @xmath195 we have @xmath196 , 2 . for any @xmath197
there is @xmath198 such that for any @xmath199 , @xmath200 and any @xmath195 with @xmath201 , @xmath202 , we have : @xmath203 in the case of a groupoid @xmath1 with a separable family of seminorms @xmath167 , the definition of uniform convergence is the same , excepting the modification of ( ii ) above into : for any @xmath197 and any seminorm @xmath169 there is @xmath204 such that for any @xmath199 , @xmath200 and any @xmath195 with @xmath205 , @xmath206 , we have : @xmath207 similarly , in a normed groupoid with a separable norm @xmath70 , the uniform convergence on bounded sets of a net of functions @xmath208 to @xmath209 means that for any @xmath197 there is @xmath198 such that for any @xmath199 , @xmath200 and any @xmath210 with @xmath202 we have : @xmath211 .
sometimes it is interesting to work with normed categories , instead of normed groupoids . briefly said ,
a normed category is a small category endowed with an involutionary antimorphism ( an `` inverse '' ) and with a norm function defined on arrows .
a * normed category * @xmath63 is a small category @xmath212 with inverses : the set of objects is @xmath213 , the set of arrows is identified with @xmath212 ; there are two functions @xmath214 , named * source * and * target * , a * multiplication * @xmath215 ( notation : @xmath216 or @xmath217 ) , where @xmath218 a * inversion map * @xmath219 ( notation @xmath220 ) and a * norm * @xmath221 , which satisfy the following conditions : 1 .
@xmath222 , @xmath223 , for any @xmath224 , 2 .
the multiplication is associative @xmath225 3 .
the inverse is an involution and a antimorphism : @xmath226 , @xmath227 .
4 . @xmath65 if and only if there is @xmath228 such that @xmath229 , 5 . for any @xmath230 we have @xmath68 , 6 . for any @xmath231 we have @xmath69 .
let @xmath232 be defined by @xmath233 , @xmath234 .
the * norm * @xmath70 * is separable * if it satisfies the property : 1 . if there is a net @xmath235 such that for any @xmath72 @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 then @xmath76 . [ defcatnorm ]
seminormed categories are defined further , by making a slight modification of definition [ defseminormedg ] .
let @xmath212 be a category with inverses ( which satisfies ( i)(iv ) definition [ defcatnorm ] ) .
let @xmath236 .
a * family of seminorms * on a category with inverses @xmath212 is a family @xmath167 of functions @xmath237 with the properties : 1 . for any @xmath66 and @xmath169 we have @xmath238
; if @xmath171 for any @xmath169 then @xmath239 , 2 . for any @xmath169 and @xmath240 we have @xmath173 , 3 . for any @xmath169 and @xmath231
we have @xmath174 .
a category @xmath212 with inverses endowed with a family of seminorms @xmath167 is called a * seminormed category*. a family of seminorms @xmath167 is separable if it satisfies the property : 1 . if there is a net @xmath241 such that for any @xmath117 @xmath73 , @xmath74 and for any @xmath169 we have @xmath176 then @xmath76 . [ defseminormedc ]
all considerations made before concerning convergence for normed or seminormed separable groupoids , extend without effort to normed categories , or to seminormed separable categories . a little bit of care
is needed though : everywhere we should replace source and target maps ( of groupoids ) by the ( algebraically defined ) @xmath242 and @xmath243 .
we give several examples of normed groupoids which will be of interest later in this paper .
let @xmath244 be a metric space .
we form the * normed trivial groupoid * @xmath245 over @xmath0 : 1 .
the set of arrows is @xmath246 and the multiplication is @xmath247 therefore we have @xmath248 , @xmath249 , @xmath250 , @xmath251 .
the norm is just the distance function @xmath252 .
it is easy to see that if @xmath253 is a normed trivial groupoid over @xmath0 then @xmath244 is a metric space .
the metric groupoid @xmath254 can be described as the groupoid with objects pointed metric spaces @xmath255 , @xmath66 , arrows @xmath256 , @xmath257 , and norm @xmath258 .
the @xmath90-double groupoid @xmath259 can be described as the groupoid with arrows @xmath260 , composition @xmath261 , inverse @xmath262 and norm @xmath263 .
remark first that @xmath70 is a separable norm , according to definition [ defnorm ] ( iv ) .
indeed , for any @xmath264 there is only one arrow @xmath265 such that @xmath266 , @xmath267 , namely the arrow @xmath268 . any net @xmath109 with @xmath269
, @xmath270 is the constant net @xmath271 . if @xmath272 then @xmath273 , therefore @xmath274 .
we deduce from proposition [ propconv ] that we have only one interesting notion of convergence , which is simple convergence .
in the particular case of normed trivial groupoids the definition [ defconv ] of simple convergence becomes : a net @xmath275 simply converges to @xmath276 if we have @xmath277 that is if the nets @xmath278 converge respectively to @xmath279 .
indeed this is coming from the fact that for any @xmath72 there are unique @xmath280 such that @xmath281 .
these are @xmath282 and @xmath283 .
let @xmath0 be a non empty set , let @xmath284 be a metric spaces and @xmath285 its associated normed trivial groupoid .
any function @xmath286 induces a morphism @xmath287 from the trivial groupoid @xmath288 to @xmath289 by @xmath290 .
any family @xmath291 of functions from @xmath0 to @xmath292 with the separation property : for any @xmath293 @xmath294 there is @xmath295 with @xmath296 , gives us a @xmath297 family of morphisms , which in turn induces a family of seminorms on @xmath288
. we can construct normed groupoids starting from definition [ ddoub ] of @xmath90-double groupoids .
let @xmath245 be a groupoid and @xmath298 the associated @xmath90-double groupoid .
then for any @xmath299 and for any @xmath300 with @xmath301 we have @xmath302 conversely , suppose that @xmath1 is a groupoid and that for any @xmath86 we have a distance @xmath303 . if ( [ leftdis ] ) is true for any @xmath304 and for any @xmath300 with @xmath305 then @xmath306 define a norm on @xmath1 such that @xmath307 is the associated @xmath90-double groupoid .
[ pdoub ] therefore any normed groupoid @xmath245 can be seen as the bundle of metric spaces @xmath308 , such that ( a ) each fiber @xmath81 has a distance @xmath309 , and ( b ) the distances @xmath310 are right invariant with respect to the groupoid composition , in the sense of relation ( [ leftdis ] ) .
[ [ proof.-1 ] ] proof .
+ + + + + + for the first implication remark that @xmath311 .
moreover let @xmath312 , @xmath313 .
then @xmath314 , therefore @xmath315 for the converse implication , we have to prove that if @xmath314 then @xmath316 , with @xmath70 defined as in the formulation of the proposition .
this is easy : let @xmath317 , then @xmath318 , @xmath319 and ( [ pdoub ] ) implies the desired equality .
the verification that @xmath70 is indeed a norm on @xmath1 is straightforward , as well as the fact that @xmath79 is the induced norm on @xmath320 .
@xmath321 let @xmath1 be a group with neutral element @xmath322 , which acts from the left on the space @xmath0 .
associated with this is the * action groupoid * @xmath323 over @xmath0 .
the action groupoid is defined as : the set of arrows is @xmath324 and the multiplication is @xmath325 therefore @xmath326 , @xmath327 , @xmath328 , @xmath329 , as a particular case of definition [ defnorm ] , a * normed action groupoid * is an action groupoid @xmath323 endowed with a norm function @xmath330 with the properties : 1 .
@xmath331 if and only if @xmath332 , 2 .
@xmath333 , 3 .
@xmath334 .
remark that the norm function is no longer a distance function . in the case of a free action (
if @xmath335 for some @xmath66 then @xmath336 ) we may obtain a norm function from a distance function on @xmath0 .
indeed , let @xmath337 be a distance .
define then @xmath338 by @xmath339 then @xmath340 is a normed action groupoid .
the associated @xmath90-double groupoid can be seen as @xmath341 , with composition @xmath342 and inverse @xmath343 . for any @xmath66
we have a distance @xmath344 , defined by @xmath345 conversely , according to proposition [ pdoub ] and relation ( [ leftdis ] ) , a norm on a action groupoid can be constructed from a function @xmath346 which associates to any @xmath66 a distance @xmath310 on g , such that for any @xmath66 and @xmath347 we have @xmath348 in this case we can define the norm on the action groupoid by @xmath349 . a particular case is @xmath350 , when a normed action groupoid is just a group endowed with a right invariant distance .
the norm @xmath70 is separable if the following condition is satisfied : for any @xmath293 and any net @xmath351 with the property @xmath352 for all @xmath353 , if @xmath354 then @xmath76 .
let @xmath355 and @xmath356 be two groupoids .
we denote by @xmath357 the groupoid which has as objects sub - groupoids of @xmath356 and invertible morphisms between sub - groupoids of @xmath356 as arrows .
a groupoid action of @xmath1 on @xmath356 is just a morphism @xmath53 of groupoids from @xmath1 to @xmath357 . in fewer words , for any @xmath15 let @xmath358 be the associated morphism of sub - groupoids , defined from the sub - groupoid denoted by @xmath359 to the sub - groupoid denoted by @xmath360 .
for any @xmath361 we use the notation @xmath362 .
compositions in @xmath1 and in @xmath356 are denoted multiplicatively .
let @xmath363 be the set @xmath364 the action of @xmath1 on @xmath356 satisfies the following conditions : 1 . for any @xmath365 such that @xmath366 we have @xmath367 , @xmath368 and for any @xmath369 we have @xmath370 ; 2 .
for any @xmath300 and @xmath371 we have @xmath372 .
any groupoid action induces a groupoid structure on @xmath363 , by the composition law @xmath373 . at a closer look
we may notice an example of a groupoid action in proposition [ pdoub ] .
indeed , let @xmath1 be a groupoid and @xmath374 the associated @xmath90-double groupoid .
then @xmath1 acts on @xmath374 by @xmath375 , for any @xmath300 and any @xmath376 such that @xmath377 . therefore @xmath378 and the associated action groupoid is @xmath379 with multiplication defined by @xmath380 relation ( [ leftdis ] ) in proposition [ pdoub ] tells that @xmath1 acts on the normed groupoid @xmath381 by isometries .
in general , the action groupoid induced by the action of a groupoid @xmath1 on a normed groupoid @xmath356 _ by isometries _ may be an object as interesting as a normed groupoid .
the references used are glickenstein @xcite and lott @xcite section 5 .
a smooth tale groupoid @xmath1 is riemannian if there is a riemannian metric on @xmath382 such that the germs of the arrows ( arrows are seen as local diffeomeorphisms on @xmath382 ) are isometries .
a riemannian groupoid is not a normed groupoid .
a good reference for this section is @xcite chapters 5 and 6 .
much more details could be found , for instance , in @xcite .
let @xmath244 be a a complete , separable metric space ( polish space ) .
the class of borel probabilities on @xmath0 is denoted by @xmath383 . if @xmath384 are polish spaces then @xmath385 is also a polish space , with the distance @xmath70 defined by @xmath386 .
if @xmath387 is a borel map and @xmath388 then the push - forward of @xmath389 through @xmath390 is the measure @xmath391 defined by : for any @xmath392 @xmath393 in particular , the projections @xmath394 , @xmath395 , @xmath396 , define push - forwards from @xmath397 to @xmath398 .
let @xmath0 , @xmath292 be polish spaces .
a measure - valued map @xmath399 is a borel map if for any borel set @xmath400 the function @xmath401 is borel .
the following is the disintegration theorem @xcite theorem 5.3.1 ( see also references therein ) .
( in @xcite the theorem is formulated for radon spaces , here we stay in the frame of polish spaces ) .
let @xmath402 be two polish spaces , @xmath403 a borel map and @xmath404 , @xmath405 .
then there exists a borel measure - valued function @xmath406 , which is @xmath407-a.e .
uniquely determined , such that : 1 . for @xmath407-a.e .
@xmath408 we have @xmath409 , 2 . for every borel map
@xmath410 $ ] @xmath411 [ disthm ] in the particular case @xmath412 , @xmath413 and @xmath414 , @xmath415 , the disintegration theorem implies that for any @xmath416 with marginals @xmath417 there exist borel measure - valued maps @xmath418 , @xmath389-a.e .
uniquely determined , and @xmath419 , @xmath407-a.e .
uniquely determined , such that for any borel function @xmath420 $ ] we have : @xmath421 @xmath422 for any two probability measures @xmath389 , @xmath407 on @xmath0 the set of all transport plans between @xmath389 and @xmath407 is defined as : @xmath423 the category @xmath424 of transport plans on @xmath0 is the category with inverses which has as objects the elements of @xmath383 and the class of arrows between @xmath425 is @xmath426 .
the composition of arrows is given by composition of transport plans , defined further .
let @xmath427 and @xmath428 . by the disintegration theorem [ disthm ] , there are @xmath407-a.e .
uniquely defined measure - valued maps @xmath429 such that for any borel function @xmath420 $ ] we have : @xmath430 @xmath431 then the composition @xmath432 is defined by : for any borel function @xmath420 $ ] @xmath433 finally , this category has a contravariant `` inverse '' functor , which associates to each arrow @xmath434 the arrow @xmath435 defined by : for any borel function @xmath420 $ ] @xmath436 we denote by @xmath437 the class of 1-lipschitz maps from @xmath0 to @xmath438 .
the category @xmath439 is a separable seminormed category , with the family @xmath167 of seminorms : for any @xmath440 and any @xmath441 @xmath442 @xmath439 it is also a normed category , with the norm : @xmath443 the following relation between the norm @xmath70 in the transport category and the seminorms @xmath444 , is related to kantorovich formulation of the transport problem and the dual of this problem : for any @xmath445 and any @xmath441 we have @xmath446 the topology of @xmath424 with the norm @xmath70 is called `` strong topology '' , while the topology of @xmath424 as a seminormed groupoid is called the `` weak topology '' . for any pair formed by a borel function @xmath447 and by a measure @xmath448
, there is an associated transport plan @xmath449 .
if @xmath450 is representable as a measure @xmath451 then we say that @xmath452 is induced by a transport map .
the category @xmath453 is the subcategory of @xmath424 with objects elements of @xmath383 and arrows transport plans induced by transport maps .
several facts deserve to be mentioned .
notice that if @xmath454 then @xmath455 @xmath389-a.e . in @xmath0
. also , in the category @xmath453 the composition of arrows is the following : @xmath456 finally , the sub - category @xmath457 of @xmath453 with objects elements of @xmath383 and arrows @xmath451 such that there exists a borel function @xmath159 with @xmath458 , is a groupoid .
let @xmath245 be a normed groupoid with a separable norm .
a deformation of @xmath245 is basically a `` local action '' of a commutative group @xmath459 on @xmath1 which satisfies several properties .
@xmath460 is a commutative group endowed with a group morphism @xmath461 to the multiplicative group of positive real numbers .
this morphism induces a invariant topological filter over @xmath459 ( a end of @xmath459 ) .
further we shall write @xmath462 for @xmath353 converging to this end , and meaning that @xmath463
. the neutral element of @xmath459 is denoted by @xmath322 . to any @xmath199
is associated a transformation @xmath464 , which may be called a dilatation , dilation , homothety or contraction . for the precise properties of the domains and codomains of @xmath465 for @xmath199 see the subsection [ bordet ] . for the moment is sufficient to know that for any @xmath199 we have @xmath466 and @xmath467
. basically the domain and codomain of @xmath465 are neighbourhoods of @xmath0
. moreover , these sets are chosen so that various compositions of transformations @xmath465 are well defined . in the formulation of properties of deformations
we shall use a uniform convergence on bounded sets .
we explain further what uniform convergence on bounded sets means in the case of nets of functions indexed with the directed net the group @xmath459 ( ordered such that limits are taken in the sense @xmath468 .
a * dilation of a separated normed groupoid * @xmath245 is a map assigning to any @xmath199 a transformation @xmath469 which satisfies the following : 1 . for any @xmath199 @xmath470 .
moreover @xmath471 is an action of @xmath459 on @xmath1 , that is for any @xmath472 we have @xmath473 , @xmath474 and @xmath475 .
2 . for any @xmath86 and
any @xmath199 we have @xmath476 .
moreover the transformation @xmath477 contracts @xmath478 to @xmath105 uniformly on bounded sets , which means that the net @xmath479 converges to the constant function @xmath480 , uniformly on bounded sets , in the sense of definition [ defcon ] .
moreover the domains and codomains @xmath478 , @xmath481 satisfy the conditions from definition [ dax0 ] , section [ bordet ] .
a * dilation of a separated normed or seminormed category * is defined in the same way as a dilation of a normed groupoid , only that @xmath90 and @xmath97 functions are no longer the source and arrow functions , but @xmath482 and @xmath483 .
[ ddefor ] the dilation @xmath484 of @xmath245 induces a right - invariant dilation of the normed groupoid @xmath485 .
the proof of the following proposition is straightforward and we do not write it . for any @xmath199 we define
@xmath486 on @xmath487 , given by : @xmath488 this is a deformation of the normed groupoid @xmath489 is a normed groupoid and moreover @xmath78 is a morphism of normed groupoids ( that is a norm preserving morphism of groupoids ) , which commutes with dilations in the sense : for any @xmath490 @xmath491 .
[ pdefindd ] let @xmath492 and @xmath493 be two dilations of the normed groupoids @xmath494 , @xmath495 respectively .
then @xmath496 is a morphism of dilations if : @xmath53 is a morphism of groupoids , it preserves the norms ( it is a isometry ) and it commutes with dilations ( it is `` * linear * '' ) . dilations are locally defined .
this is explained in the following definition , which should be seen as the axiom a0 of dilations . the domains and codomains of a dilation of @xmath245
satisfy the following axiom a0 : 1 .
for any @xmath199 @xmath466 and @xmath497 , 2 . for any bounded set @xmath498
there are @xmath499 such that for any @xmath199 , @xmath500 : @xmath501 @xmath502 3 . for any bounded set @xmath498 there are @xmath503 and @xmath504 $ ] such that for any @xmath199 , @xmath505 and any @xmath506 we have : @xmath507 [ dax0 ] concerning ( iii ) definition [ dax0 ] , the first part of a1 definition [ ddefor ] implies that @xmath508 is well defined for any @xmath509 such that @xmath510 .
the purpose of this section is to define several deformations of normed groupoids , such that the diagram from figure [ figure2 ] becomes a commutative diagram of morphisms of dilations .
let us consider a triple @xmath511 with @xmath245 a normed groupoid and @xmath484 a dilation .
for any @xmath512 there are two normed induced groupoids , such that the arrows in the diagram ( [ figure2 ] ) are morphisms .
as dilatations are not globally defined and they are used to transport groupoid operations , it follows that the transported objects ( operation , norms , ... ) are not globally defined
. therefore the induced groupoids are not groupoids , but `` local '' groupoids , in a sense which is clear in the context .
[ rkdom ] the deformation @xmath513 is equal to @xmath1 as a set and its operations , norm and dilation are transported by the map @xmath514 ( with the precautions concerning the domains of definition of the transported objects mentioned in remark [ rkdom ] ) .
the deformation @xmath515 is equal to @xmath91 as a groupoid and its norm and dilation are transported by the map @xmath516 .
[ defdia ] more precisely , the deformation @xmath513 is described by : 1 .
@xmath517 as a set , @xmath518 and @xmath519 , which follow from the computations using a1 , a2 definition [ ddefor ] : @xmath520 also @xmath521 .
the composition operation and inverse are @xmath522 these are well defined ( at least locally ) because of the axiom a0 definition [ dax0 ] .
notice that @xmath523 from the diagram [ figure2 ] appears as the difference function associated with the operation @xmath524 , defined as @xmath525 3 . the norm @xmath526 is defined as : @xmath527 4 .
we may transport the dilation @xmath484 of @xmath245 into a dilation @xmath528 of @xmath529 , but from the commutativity of @xmath459 we get that @xmath530 therefore it is the same dilation .
the deformation @xmath515 is described by : 1 .
@xmath531 as a groupoid ; remark that this is compatible with the transport of operations using the map @xmath532 ( because this map is an endomorphism of the groupoid @xmath91 ) , 2 . with respect to the relation ( [ dfird ]
) , notice that @xmath533 and @xmath523 as represented in figure [ figure2 ] is a morphism of groupoids , 3 . the norm @xmath534 is defined as : @xmath535 and it is easy to check that @xmath523 is also a isometry .
we transport the dilation @xmath536 of @xmath537 into a dilation @xmath538 @xmath539 the commutativity of the diagram [ figure2 ] is clear now .
at the core of the introduction of dilations lies the fact that we can construct group operations from them .
more precisely we are able to construct , by using compositions of dilations and the groupoid operation , approximately associative operations which shall lead us eventually to group operations in the tangent groupoid of a dilation .
let @xmath511 be a dilation and @xmath540 the associated dilation of the @xmath90-double groupoid .
further we shall be interested only in the properties of the following map .
for any @xmath86 and any @xmath199 we define the * dilatation * : @xmath541 [ defdilc ] the domain of definition of @xmath542 is in fact only a subset of @xmath543 , according to the axiom 0 explained in definition [ dax0 ] section [ bordet ] .
this map comes from the definition ( [ rtransdel ] ) of the dilation @xmath544 , namely @xmath545 for any @xmath199 with @xmath546 sufficiently small we can define @xmath547 ( as in figure [ figure2 ] ) from ( a subset of ) @xmath548 to @xmath1 .
remark that @xmath549 , therefore the following composition is well defined : @xmath550 then @xmath551 .
related to the function @xmath552 is the following @xmath553 the following expression makes sense too , for any pair of elements @xmath554 from ( a subset of ) @xmath555 : @xmath556 \label{sumdef}\ ] ] it is also true that @xmath557 .
these three functions are interesting operations .
the function @xmath558 is an approximate difference operation , @xmath559 is an approximate inverse and @xmath560 is an approximate sum operation .
a look at the figure [ figure1 ] will help . there is graphically explained how @xmath561 is constructed .
.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] let us imagine that we are looking at a figure in the euclidean plane .
then @xmath562 is just a homothety , @xmath159 , @xmath563 are vectors with the same origin @xmath101 , @xmath564 is the difference of vectors @xmath565 ( or @xmath566 , it s the same as long as we are in a commutative world ) . in the euclidean plane ,
as @xmath546 goes to @xmath480 , the `` vector '' @xmath567 slides towards @xmath568 and @xmath561 is obtained from @xmath567 by composition with the vector @xmath569 . thus @xmath570 has the meaning of a approximate difference of vectors @xmath159 , @xmath563 .
the functions @xmath558 , @xmath559 and @xmath560 can be expressed in terms of dilatations introduced in definition [ defdilc ] .
indeed , let us define , for any triple @xmath347 with @xmath571 , and such that @xmath572 are sufficiently small , the following approximate difference function with three arguments : @xmath573 the approximate inverse function with two arguments : @xmath574 and the following approximate sum function with three arguments : @xmath575 we have then : @xmath576 we are in the framework of emergent algebras and idempotent right quasigroups , as introduced in @xcite .
we recall here the definition of a idempotent right quasigroup and induced operations .
an idempotent right quasigroup ( irq ) is a set @xmath0 endowed with two operations @xmath577 and @xmath578 , which satisfy the following axioms : for any @xmath579 1 .
@xmath580 2 .
@xmath581 we use these operations to define the sum , difference and inverse operations of the irq : for any @xmath582 1 .
the difference operation is @xmath583 . by fixing the first variable @xmath584 we obtain the difference operation based at @xmath584 : @xmath585 .
the sum operation is @xmath586 . by fixing the first variable @xmath584 we obtain the sum operation based at @xmath584 : @xmath587 .
the inverse operation is @xmath588 . by fixing the first variable @xmath584 we obtain the inverse operator based at @xmath584 : @xmath589 . for any @xmath590
we define also the following operations : 1 .
@xmath591 , @xmath592 , 2 . for
any @xmath593 let @xmath594 and @xmath595 , 3 .
for any @xmath596 let @xmath597 and @xmath598 .
[ dplay ] for any @xmath599 the triple @xmath600 is a irq .
we denote the difference , sum and inverse operations of @xmath600 by the same symbols as the ones used for @xmath601 , with a subscript `` @xmath602 '' . for any @xmath199 and for any @xmath66
we can define a irq operation on @xmath81 by @xmath603 .
we have then : @xmath604 by computation it follows that @xmath605 .
the approximate difference , sum and inverse operations are exactly the ones introduced in the preceding section . in @xcite we introduced idempotent right quasigroups and then iterates of the operations indexed by a parameter @xmath606 .
this was done in order to simplify the notations mostly . here , in the presence of the group @xmath459
, we might define a @xmath459-irq .
let @xmath459 be a commutative group .
a @xmath459-idempotent right quasigroup is a set @xmath0 with a function @xmath607 such that @xmath608 is a irq and moreover for any @xmath472 and any @xmath293 we have @xmath609 [ defgammairq ] it is then obvious that if @xmath610 is a irq then @xmath611 is a @xmath612-irq ( we define @xmath613 ) .
the following is a slight modification of proposition 3.4 and point ( k ) proposition 3.5 @xcite , for the case of @xmath459-irqs ( the proof of this proposition is almost identical , with obvious modifications , with the proof of the original proposition ) . in any irq
@xmath614 be a @xmath459-irq .
then we have the relations : 1 .
@xmath615 2 .
@xmath616 3 .
@xmath617 4 .
@xmath618 5 .
@xmath619 6 .
@xmath620 7 .
@xmath621 8 . for any @xmath622 and
any @xmath623 we have the distributivity property : @xmath624 [ pplay ] later we shall apply this proposition for the irq @xmath92 with the operations induced by dilatations @xmath465 .
as @xmath625 the components of the deformations indexed by @xmath389 from the diagram [ figure2 ] ( namely the operation , norm and respective dilation maps ) may converge in the sense of section [ secdefconv ] to the components of another normed groupoid with dilations . 1 .
there is a function @xmath626 which is the limit @xmath627 uniformly on bounded sets in the sense of definition [ defcon ] .
moreover the convergence with respect to @xmath628 is the same as the convergence with respect to @xmath629 and in particular @xmath630 implies @xmath631 .
2 . there is a dilation @xmath632 of the normed groupoid @xmath633 such that for any @xmath199 the transformation @xmath634 converges uniformly on bounded sets to @xmath635 . indeed ,
these properties of the function @xmath628 come from the following observation .
let us define on @xmath91 the function : @xmath641 then for any @xmath86 the function @xmath70 ( with two arguments ) gives a distance on the set @xmath81 . in the case of a @xmath484-structure
the axiom a3 can be written as : @xmath642 uniformly on bounded sets .
this gives properties ( b ) , ( c ) above from a passage to the limit of the properties of the distance @xmath70 .
for any @xmath86 the restriction of the norm @xmath629 on the trivial groupoid @xmath643 gives a distance on the space @xmath81 .
the dilatation @xmath644 has the property : for any @xmath199 and @xmath86 @xmath645 therefore we can define @xmath646 from ( a subset of ) @xmath647 to @xmath647 by : @xmath648 suppose that @xmath511 is a gw @xmath484-structure . then for any @xmath86 the triple @xmath649 is a dilatation structure , with @xmath484 defined by ( [ firstcomright ] ) and @xmath650 restrictioned to @xmath81 .
the proof is just a translation of the definition [ defgdsweak ] in terms of metric spaces , using the equivalence between metric spaces and normed trivial groupoids . at the end
we obtain definition [ defweakstrong ] of dilatation structures on metric spaces , given further . for simplicity we shall list the axioms of a dilatation structure @xmath651 without concerning about domains and codomains of dilatations . for the full definition of dilatation structure , as well as for their main properties and examples , see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
the notion appeared from my efforts to understand the last section of the paper @xcite ( see also @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . 1 . in the following definition [ defweakstrong ] we are no longer asking the metric space @xmath244 to be locally compact .
also , uniform convergence in compact sets is replaced by uniform convergence in bounded sets .
2 . because of the modifications explained at ( a ) , we have to ask explicitly that the uniformities induced by @xmath652 and @xmath70 are the same .
3 . finally
, dilatation structures in the sense of the following definition [ defweakstrong ] are a bit stronger than dilatation structures in the sense introduced and studied in @xcite , @xcite , namely we ask for the existence of a `` limit dilatation '' , see the last axiom .
this limit exists for strong dilatation structures , but not for dilatation structures in the sense introduced in @xcite , @xcite . 1 .
for any point @xmath66 the function @xmath484 induces an action @xmath656 , where @xmath657 is the collection of all continuous , with continuous inverse transformations @xmath658 such that @xmath659 .
the function @xmath660 is continuous . moreover , it can be continuously extended to @xmath661 by @xmath662 and the limit @xmath663 is uniform with respect to @xmath664 in bounded set .
3 . there is @xmath665 such that for any @xmath584 there exists a function @xmath666 , defined for any @xmath667 in the closed ball ( in distance d ) @xmath668 , such that @xmath669 uniformly with respect to @xmath584 in bounded set .
moreover the uniformity induced by @xmath670 is the same as the uniformity induced by @xmath70 , in particular @xmath671 implies @xmath672 .
( for metric spaces ) the following limit exists : @xmath673 for any @xmath512 , uniformly with respect to @xmath674 in bounded sets . in axiom
a2 we may alternatively put that the limit is uniform with respect to @xmath678 .
similarly , we may ask in axiom a4weak ( for metric spaces ) that the limit is uniform with respect to @xmath679 , @xmath680 . 1 .
if @xmath244 is locally compact then the function @xmath681 is continuous as an uniform limit of continuous functions on a compact set .
if @xmath244 is also separable then from the existence of the limit @xmath652 and from axiom a1 we obtain the fact that @xmath681 and @xmath70 induce the same uniformities .
2 . by definition @xmath652
is symmetric and satisfies the triangle inequality , but it can be a degenerated distance function : there might exist @xmath682 such that @xmath683.but the end of axiom a2 eliminates this possibility .
let @xmath684 be a dilatation structure , @xmath66 , and let @xmath685 then the net of metric spaces @xmath686 converges in the gromov - hausdorff sense to the metric space @xmath687 .
moreover this metric space is a metric cone , in the following sense : for any @xmath512 such that @xmath688 we have @xmath689 and @xmath690 the first part of the proposition is just a reformulation of axiom a3 , without the condition of uniform convergence . for the second part remark that @xmath691 and also that @xmath692 therefore if we pass to the limit with @xmath462 in these two relations we get the desired conclusion
. @xmath321 let @xmath651 be a dilatation structure .
the translation groupoid @xmath693 has as objects the distances @xmath694 for all @xmath66 and all @xmath199 .
the arrows are of the form @xmath695 , with @xmath696 composition of arrows is composition of functions .
[ transgrou ] @xmath693 is a groupoid .
moreover , arrows are isometries , in the sense that for any @xmath199 and @xmath697 the arrow @xmath698 is an isometry from the source to the range : for ant @xmath699 we have : @xmath700 use proposition [ pplay ] .
for example , the fact that composition of arrows is well defined is equivalent with ( e ) from the mentioned proposition .
invertibility of arrows is ( a ) , and so on .
the isometry claim follows from a straight computation .
@xmath321 a * groupoid strong @xmath484-structure * ( or a gs @xmath484-structure ) is a triple @xmath701 such that @xmath484 is a map assigning to any @xmath199 a transformation @xmath469 which satisfies the axioms a1 , a2 from definition [ defgdsweak ] and the following axioms a3mod and a4 : m. buliga , dilatation structures in sub - riemannian geometry , ( 2007 ) , contemporary geometry and topology and related topics , cluj - napoca , cluj university press ( 2008 ) , 89 - 105 , http://arxiv.org/abs/0708.4298 | we study normed groupoids with dilations and their induced deformations .
addtoresetfiguresection @figureh , t addtoresettablebsection @tableh , t addtoresetequationsection [ section ] [ thm]proposition [ thm]lemma [ thm]corollary [ thm]definition [ thm]remark [ section ] |
quantized control problems have been an active research topic in the past two decades .
discrete - level actuators / sensors and digital communication channels are typical in practical control systems , and they yield quantized signals in feedback loops .
quantization errors lead to poor system performance and even loss of stability .
therefore , various control techniques to explicitly take quantization into account have been proposed , as surveyed in @xcite . on the other hand ,
switched system models are widely used as a mathematical framework to represent both continuous and discrete dynamics . for example , such models are applied to dc - dc converters @xcite and to car engines @xcite .
stability and stabilization of switched systems have also been extensively studied ; see , e.g. , the survey @xcite , the book @xcite , and many references therein . in view of the practical importance of both research areas and common technical tools to study them , the extension of quantized control to switched systems
has recently received increasing attention .
there is by now a stream of papers on control with limited information for discrete - time markovian jump systems @xcite .
moreover , our previous work @xcite has analyzed the stability of sampled - data switched systems with static quantizers . in this paper , we study the stabilization of continuous - time switched linear systems with quantized output feedback .
our objective is to solve the following problem : given a switched system and a controller , design a quantizer to achieve asymptotic stability of the closed - loop system .
we assume that the information of the currently active plant mode is available to the controller and the quantizer . extending the quantizer in @xcite for the non - switched case to the switched case
, we propose a lyapunov - based update rule of the quantizer under a slow - switching assumption of average dwell - time type @xcite .
the difficulty of quantized control for switched systems is that a mode switch changes the state trajectories and saturates the quantizer . in the non - switched case @xcite , in order to avoid quantizer saturation , the quantizer is updated so that the state trajectories always belong to certain invariant regions defined by level sets of a lyapunov function .
however , for switched systems , these invariant regions are dependent on the modes .
hence the state may not belong to such regions after a switch . to keep the state in the invariant regions
, we here adjust the quantizer at every switching time , which prevent quantizer saturation .
the same philosophy of emphasizing the importance of quantizer updates after switching has been proposed in @xcite for sampled - data switched systems with quantized state feedback .
subsequently , related works were presented for the output feedback case @xcite and for the case with bounded disturbances @xcite .
the crucial difference lies in the fact that these works use the quantizer based on @xcite and investigates propagation of reachable sets for capturing the measurement .
this approach also aims to avoid quantizer saturation , but it is fundamentally disparate from our lyapunov - based approach . this paper is organized as follows . in section
ii , we present the main result , theorem [ thm : stability_theorem ] , after explaining the components of the closed - loop system .
section iii gives the update rule of the quantizer and is devoted to the proof of the convergence of the state to the origin . in section iv , we discuss lyapunov stability
. we present a numerical example in section v and finally conclude this paper in section vi .
the present paper is based on the conference paper @xcite . here
we extend the conference version by addressing state jumps at switching times .
we also made structural improvements in this version .
_ notation : _ let @xmath0 and @xmath1 denote the smallest and the largest eigenvalue of @xmath2 .
let @xmath3 denote the transpose of @xmath4 .
the euclidean norm of @xmath5 is denoted by @xmath6 .
the euclidean induced norm of @xmath4 is defined by @xmath7 . for a piecewise continuous function @xmath8 , its left - sided limit at @xmath9
is denoted by @xmath10 .
for a finite index set @xmath11 , let @xmath12 be a right - continuous and piecewise constant function .
we call @xmath13 a _ switching signal _ and the discontinuities of @xmath13 _ switching times_. let us denote by @xmath14 the number of discontinuities of @xmath13 on the interval @xmath15 $ ] .
let @xmath16 be switching times , and consider a switched linear system @xmath17 with the jump @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the state , @xmath20 is the control input , and @xmath21 is the output .
assumptions on the switched system are as follows .
[ ass : system ] _ for every @xmath22 , @xmath23 is stabilizable and @xmath24 is observable .
we choose @xmath25 and @xmath26 so that @xmath27 and @xmath28 are hurwitz . _
furthermore , the switching signal @xmath13 has an average dwell time @xcite , i.e. , there exist @xmath29 and @xmath30 such that @xmath31 we need observability rather than detectability , because we reconstruct the state by using the observability gramian . in this paper
, we use the following class of quantizers proposed in @xcite .
let @xmath32 be a finite subset of @xmath33 .
a quantizer is a piecewise constant function @xmath34 .
this implies geometrically that @xmath35 is divided into a finite number of the quantization regions @xmath36 @xmath37 . for the quantizer @xmath38 ,
there exist positive numbers @xmath39 and @xmath40 with @xmath41 such that @xmath42 the former condition gives an upper bound of the quantization error when the quantizer does not saturate .
the latter is used for the detection of quantizer saturation .
we place the following assumption on the behavior of the quantizer near the origin .
this assumption is used for lyapunov stability of the closed - loop system .
[ @xcite ] [ ass : near origin ] _ there exists @xmath43 such that @xmath44 for every @xmath45 with @xmath46 .
_ we use quantizers with the following adjustable parameter @xmath47 : @xmath48 in , @xmath49 is regarded as a `` zoom '' variable , and @xmath50 is the data on @xmath51 transmitted to the controller at time @xmath52 .
we need to change @xmath49 to obtain accurate information of @xmath53 .
the reader can refer to @xcite for further discussions .
the quantized output @xmath54 may chatter on boundaries among quantization regions .
hence if we generate the input @xmath55 by @xmath54 , the solutions of must be interpreted in the sense of filippov @xcite .
however , this generalization does not affect our lyapunov - based analysis as in @xcite , because we will use a single quadratic lyapunov function between switching times .
similarly to @xcite , we construct the following dynamic output feedback law based on the standard luenberger observers : @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the state estimate .
the estimate also jumps at each switching times @xmath58 : @xmath59 then the closed - loop system is given by @xmath60 if we define @xmath61 and @xmath62 by @xmath63 then we rewrite in the form @xmath64 the state @xmath61 of the closed - loop system jumps at each switching time @xmath58 : @xmath65 where @xmath66 we see from assumption [ ass : system ] that @xmath67 is hurwitz for each @xmath22 . for every positive - definite matrix @xmath68 ,
there exist a positive - definite matrix @xmath69 such that @xmath70 we define @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , and @xmath74 by @xmath75 \underline \lambda_q : = { \displaystyle \min_{p \in \mathcal{p } } \lambda_{\min}(q_p ) } , \quad c_{\max } : = { \displaystyle \max_{p \in \mathcal{p}}\|c_p\|}. \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] fig .
[ fig : cssqof ] shows the closed - loop system we consider . by adjusting the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49
, we can achieve global asymptotic stability of the closed - loop system .
this result is a natural extension of theorem 5 in @xcite to switched systems . _
[ thm : stability_theorem ] define @xmath76 by @xmath77 and let @xmath39 be large enough to satisfy @xmath78 if the average dwell time @xmath79 in is larger than a certain value , then there exists a right - continuous and piecewise - constant function @xmath49 such that the closed - loop system has the following two properties for every @xmath80 and every @xmath81 : _ _
( i ) convergence to the origin : _ @xmath82 . _
( ii ) lyapunov stability : _ to every @xmath83 , there corresponds @xmath84 such that @xmath85 we shall prove convergence to the origin and lyapunov stability in sections iii and iv , respectively .
we also present an update rule of the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 in section 3 . the sufficient condition on @xmath79
is given by in theorem [ lem : convergence_to_origin ] below .
define @xmath86 and @xmath87 by @xmath88 we split the proof into two stages : the `` zooming - out '' and `` zooming - in '' stages .
since the initial state @xmath89 is unknown to the quantizer , we have to capture the state @xmath61 of the closed - loop system by `` zooming out '' , i.e. , increasing the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 .
we first see that @xmath61 can be captured if we have a time - interval with a given length that has no switches .
[ lem : capture_non_switched ] _ consider the closed - loop system . set the control input @xmath90 .
choose @xmath91 , and define @xmath92 and the observability gramian @xmath93 assume that there exists @xmath94 such that we can observe @xmath95 for all @xmath96 .
let the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 be piecewise continuous and monotone increasing in @xmath97 .
if we set the state estimate @xmath98 at @xmath99 by @xmath100 and if we choose @xmath101 so that @xmath102 then @xmath103 .
_ since no switch occurs by , we can easily obtain this result by extending theorem 5 in @xcite for the non - switched case .
we therefore omit the proof ; see also the conference version @xcite .
it follows from theorem [ lem : capture_non_switched ] that in order to capture the state @xmath61 , it is enough to show the existence of @xmath94 satisfying and for all @xmath104 . to this end , we use the following lemma on average dwell time @xmath79 : [ lem : adt_upperbound ] _ fix an initial time @xmath105 .
suppose that @xmath13 satisfies the average dwell - time assumption .
let @xmath106 . if we choose @xmath107 so that @xmath108 then there exists @xmath109 $ ] such that @xmath110 .
_ let us denote the switching times by @xmath16 , and fix @xmath107 .
suppose that @xmath111 for all @xmath109 $ ] .
then we have @xmath112 indeed , if @xmath113 for some @xmath114 and if we let @xmath115 be the smallest such integer , then we obtain @xmath116 and @xmath117 .
this contradicts with @xmath118 $ ] .
thus we have . from
, we see that for @xmath119 , @xmath120 it follows from that @xmath121 therefore @xmath122 satisfies the following inequality : @xmath123 since @xmath124 was arbitrary , is equivalent to @xmath125 thus we have shown that if holds for all @xmath109 $ ] , then @xmath126 satisfies .
the contraposition of this statement gives a desired result .
[ thm : non_switch_interval ] _ consider the closed - loop system with average dwell - time property
. set the control input @xmath90 .
fix @xmath127 , @xmath128 , and @xmath106 .
increase @xmath49 in the following way : @xmath129 for @xmath130 , @xmath131 for @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
then there exists @xmath94 such that and hold for all @xmath104 . _
if @xmath134 switches occur in the interval @xmath135 $ ] , then we have @xmath136 since @xmath137 , it follows from that @xmath138 clearly , this inequality holds in the case when no switches occur .
since shows that @xmath139 and since the growth rate of @xmath140 is larger than that of @xmath141 , there exists @xmath142 such that @xmath143 in conjunction with , this implies that holds for every @xmath144 .
let @xmath122 be an integer satisfying .
then lemma [ lem : adt_upperbound ] guarantees the existence of @xmath145 $ ] such that holds for every @xmath96 .
this completes the proof .
it follows from theorems [ lem : capture_non_switched ] and [ thm : non_switch_interval ] that if we update the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 as in and if we set the state estimate @xmath98 by , then the state @xmath61 of the closed - loop system can be captured .
[ rem : brief_remark_for_lyap ] if the initial state @xmath89 is sufficiently small , then @xmath146 in is zero . in this situation
, we can capture @xmath61 by @xmath147 for all switching signal with average dwell - time property .
we use this fact for the proof of lyapunov stability ; see section 4 .
next we drive the state @xmath61 of the closed - loop system to the origin by `` zooming - in '' , i.e. , decreasing the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 . since @xmath49 increases at each switching time during this stage , the term `` zooming - in stage '' may be misleading .
however , @xmath49 decreases overall under a certain average dwell - time assumption , so we use the term `` zooming - in '' as in @xcite .
let us first consider a fixed `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 .
the following lemma shows that if no switches occur , then the state trajectories move from a large level set to a small level set of the lyapunov function @xmath148 in a finite time that is independent of the mode @xmath149
: [ lem : fix_zoom_parameter ] _ define @xmath67 and @xmath150 as in and , respectively .
fix @xmath22 , and consider the non - switched system @xmath151 choose @xmath152 . if @xmath39 satisfies @xmath153 where @xmath71 , @xmath72 @xmath74 , and @xmath76 are defined by and , then the following two level sets of the lyapunov function @xmath154 are invariant regions for every trajectory of : @xmath155 furthermore , if @xmath156 for all @xmath157 $ ] , then @xmath158 for every @xmath22 . hence if @xmath159 satisfies @xmath160 then every trajectory of with an initial state @xmath161 satisfies @xmath162 _
since the mode @xmath22 is fixed , this lemma is a trivial extension of lemma 5 in @xcite for single - modal systems .
we therefore omit its proof ; see also the conference version @xcite . using lemma [ lem : fix_zoom_parameter ]
, we obtain an update rule of the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 to drive the state @xmath61 to the origin . [
lem : convergence_to_origin ] _ consider the system under the same assumptions as in lemma [ lem : fix_zoom_parameter ] .
assume that @xmath163 .
for each @xmath164 with @xmath165 , the positive definite matrices @xmath166 and @xmath167 in the lyapunov equation satisfy @xmath168 for some @xmath169 .
define @xmath170 and @xmath171 by @xmath172 @xmath173 fix @xmath174 so that is satisfied , and set the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath175 for all @xmath176 and @xmath177 $ ] in the following way : if no switches occur in the interval @xmath178 $ ] , then @xmath179 otherwise , @xmath180 where @xmath181 are the switching times in the interval @xmath178 $ ] .
then @xmath182 for all @xmath183 .
furthermore , if @xmath79 satisfies @xmath184 then @xmath185 .
_ to prove that @xmath182 for all @xmath183 , it is enough to show that if @xmath186 , then @xmath187 let us first investigate the case without switching on the interval @xmath188 $ ] .
we see from lemma [ lem : fix_zoom_parameter ] that @xmath182 for all @xmath189 and that @xmath190 .
since @xmath191 , a routine calculation shows that @xmath192 .
we now study the switched case .
let @xmath193 be the switching times in the interval @xmath188 $ ] .
let us define @xmath194 for simplicity of notation .
lemma [ lem : fix_zoom_parameter ] implies that @xmath195 ( @xmath196 ) are invariant sets for all @xmath197 , @xmath198 . moreover , by , if @xmath199 , then @xmath200 ( @xmath196 ) for all @xmath201 .
hence @xmath202 leads to @xmath203 to obtain @xmath204 we show that @xmath205 .
assume , to reach a contradiction , that @xmath206 since @xmath207 is an invariant region for all @xmath208 , we also have @xmath209 define a lyapunov function @xmath148 for each @xmath22 .
since a filippov solution is ( absolutely ) continuous , @xmath210 exists for each @xmath211 . from , we obtain @xmath212 on the other hand , since @xmath213 for all @xmath214 $ ] , gives @xmath215 and hence we have from @xmath216 that @xmath217
if we repeat this process and use , then @xmath218 which contradicts . thus we obtain @xmath219 and hence holds . from and , we derive the desired result , because @xmath220 .
finally , since @xmath221 , gives @xmath222 for every @xmath223 and @xmath224 . if @xmath225 , that is , if the average dwell time @xmath79 satisfies , then @xmath226 .
since @xmath182 for all @xmath183 , we obtain @xmath227 .
( a ) we can compute @xmath228 by linear matrix inequalities . moreover , if the jump matrix @xmath229 in is invertible , then lemma 13 of @xcite gives an explicit formula for @xmath228 .
( b ) the proposed method is sensitive to the time - delay of the switching signal at the `` zooming - in '' stage .
if the switching signal is delayed , a mode mismatch occurs between the plant and the controller .
here we do not proceed along this line to avoid technical issues .
see also @xcite for the stabilization of asynchronous switched systems with time - delays .
( c ) we have updated the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 at each switching time in the `` zooming - in '' stage .
if we would not , switching could lead to instability of the closed - loop system .
in fact , since the state @xmath61 may not belong to the invariant region @xmath230 without adjusting @xmath49 , the quantizer may saturate .
( d ) similarly , `` pre - emptively '' multiplying @xmath49 at time @xmath231 by @xmath232 does not work , either .
this is because such an adjustment does not make @xmath230 invariant for the state trajectories .
for example , consider the situation where the state @xmath61 belongs to @xmath233 at @xmath234 due to this pre - emptively adjustment .
then @xmath61 does not converge to the origin .
let @xmath235 be a switching time .
since @xmath236 may not be a subset of @xmath237 , it follows that @xmath61 does not belong to the invariant region @xmath230 at @xmath238 in general .
let us denote by @xmath239 the open ball with center at the origin and radius @xmath240 in @xmath241 . in what follows , we use the same letters as in the previous section and assume that the average dwell time @xmath79 satisfies .
the proof consists of three steps : 1 .
obtain an upper bound of the time @xmath242 at which the quantization process transitions from the `` zoom - out '' stage to the `` zoom - in '' stage .
2 . show that there exists a time @xmath243 such that the state @xmath61 satisfies @xmath244 for all @xmath245 .
3 . set @xmath84 so that if @xmath246 , then @xmath244 for all @xmath247 .
we break the proof of lyapunov stability into the above three steps .
\1 ) let @xmath126 satisfy and let @xmath84 be small enough to satisfy @xmath248 we see from the state bound that @xmath249 for @xmath250 $ ] from assumption [ ass : near origin ] .
as we mentioned in remark [ rem : brief_remark_for_lyap ] briefly , lemma [ lem : adt_upperbound ] implies that the time @xmath242 , at which the stage changes from `` zooming - out '' to `` zooming - in '' , satisfies @xmath251 for every switching signal with the average dwell - time assumption .
\2 ) fix @xmath252 . by , @xmath253 , and
hence we see from that @xmath254 achieving @xmath186 can be chosen so that @xmath255 where @xmath256 is defined by @xmath257 note that @xmath256 is independent of switching signals .
let @xmath258 be the smallest integer satisfying @xmath259 define @xmath260 .
since @xmath221 and @xmath225 , and give @xmath261 for all @xmath262 and @xmath224 . since @xmath263 satisfies
, it follows that that @xmath264 lies in @xmath239 for all @xmath245 .
recall that @xmath265 and that @xmath264 is an invariant region for all @xmath183 from theorem [ lem : convergence_to_origin ] .
thus we have @xmath266 \3 ) define @xmath267 since @xmath268 , it follows from , and that @xmath269 for all @xmath270 $ ] .
set @xmath84 so that @xmath271 since @xmath272 , by , , , and , assumption [ ass : near origin ] gives @xmath273 in the interval @xmath274 $ ] , so @xmath275 and @xmath276 in the same interval . combining this with ,
we obtain @xmath277 for all @xmath247 .
thus @xmath278 from and , we see that lyapunov stability can be achieved .
consider the continuous - time switched system with the following two modes : @xmath280 with jump matrices @xmath281 . as the feedback gain and the observer gain of each mode ,
we take @xmath282 let @xmath38 be a uniform - type quantizer with parameters @xmath283 , @xmath284 the parameters @xmath285 in the `` zooming - out '' stage are @xmath286 , @xmath287 , and @xmath288 . also , define @xmath289 and @xmath290 in and @xmath291 in by @xmath292 , @xmath293 @xmath294 , where @xmath295 means a diagonal matrix whose diagonal elements starting in the upper left corner are @xmath296
. then we obtain @xmath297 in , @xmath298 in , @xmath299 in , and @xmath300 in .
figure [ fig : cont_simulation ] ( a ) and ( b ) show that the euclidean norm of the state @xmath301 and the estimate @xmath98 , and the `` zoom '' parameter @xmath49 , respectively , with initial condition @xmath302^{\top}$ ] and @xmath303 .
the vertical dashed - dotted line indicates the switching times @xmath304 . in this example ,
the `` zooming - out '' stage finished at @xmath305 .
we see the non - smoothness of @xmath306 and the increase of @xmath49 at the switching times @xmath304 because of switches and quantizer updates . not surprisingly , the adjustments of @xmath49 in and are conservative .
we have proposed an update rule of dynamic quantizers to stabilize continuous - time switched systems with quantized output feedback .
the average dwell - time property has been utilized for the state reconstruction in the `` zooming - out '' stage and for convergence to the origin in the `` zooming - in '' stage .
the update rule not only periodically decreases the `` zoom '' parameter to drive the state to the origin , but also adjusts the parameter at each switching time to avoid quantizer saturation .
future work involves designing the controller and the quantizer simultaneously , and addressing more general systems by incorporating disturbances and nonlinear dynamics . | in this paper , we study the problem of stabilizing continuous - time switched linear systems with quantized output feedback .
we assume that the observer and the control gain are given for each mode .
also , the plant mode is known to the controller and the quantizer . extending the result in the non - switched case
, we develop an update rule of the quantizer to achieve asymptotic stability of the closed - loop system under the average dwell - time assumption .
to avoid quantizer saturation , we adjust the quantizer at every switching time
. switched systems , quantized control , output feedback stabilization . |
quantum key distribution ( qkd ) is often said to be unconditionally secure @xcite .
more precisely , qkd can be proven to be secure against any eavesdropping _ given _ that the users ( alice and bob ) devices satisfy some requirements , which often include mathematical characterization of users devices as well as the assumption that there is no side - channel .
this means that no one can break mathematical model of qkd , however in practice , it is very difficult for practical devices to meet the requirements , leading to the breakage of the security of practical qkd systems . actually , some attacks on qkd have been proposed and demonstrated successfully against practical qkd systems @xcite . to combat the practical attacks , some counter - measures @xcite , including device independent security proof idea @xcite , have been proposed .
the device independent security proof is very interesting from the theoretical viewpoint , however it can not apply to practical qkd systems where loopholes in testing bell s inequality @xcite can not be closed . as for the experimental counter - measures ,
battle - testing of the practical detection unit has attracted many researchers attention @xcite since the most successful practical attack so far is to exploit the imperfections of the detectors .
recently , a very simple and very promising idea , which is called a measurement device independent qkd ( mdiqkd ) has been proposed by lo , curty , and qi @xcite . in this scheme
, neither alice nor bob performs any measurement , but they only send out quantum signals to a measurement unit ( mu ) .
mu is a willing participant of the protocol , and mu can be a network administrator or a relay .
however , mu can be untrusted and completely under the control of the eavesdropper ( eve ) .
after alice and bob send out signals , they wait for mu s announcement of whether she has obtained the successful detection , and proceed to the standard post - processing of their sifted data , such as error rate estimation , error correction , and privacy amplification .
the basic idea of mdiqkd is based on a reversed epr - based qkd protocol @xcite , which is equivalent to epr - based qkd @xcite in the sense of the security , and mdiqkd is remarkable because it removes _ all _ the potential loopholes of the detectors without sacrificing the performance of standard qkd since alice and bob do not detect any quantum signals from eve . moreover , it is shown in @xcite that mdiqkd with infinite number of decoy states and polarization encoding can cover about twice the distance of standard decoyed qkd , which is comparable to epr - based qkd .
the only assumption needed in mdiqkd is that the preparation of the quantum signal sources by alice and bob is ( almost ) perfect and carefully characterized .
we remark that the characterization of the signal source should be easier than that of the detection unit since the characterization of the detection unit involves the estimation of the response of the devices to unknown input signals sent from eve .
with mdiqkd in our hand , we do not need to worry about imperfections of mu any more , and we should focus our attention more to the imperfections of signal sources .
one of the important imperfections of the sources is the basis - dependent flaw that stems from the discrepancy of the density matrices corresponding to the two bases in bb84 states .
the security of standard bb84 with basis - dependent flaw has been analyzed in @xcite which show that the basis - dependent flaw decreases the achievable distance .
thus , in order to investigate the practicality of mdiqkd , we need to generalize the above works to investigate the security of mdiqkd under the imperfection .
another problem in mdiqkd is that the first proposal is based on polarization encoding @xcite , however , in some situations where birefringence effect in optical fiber is highly time - dependent , we need to consider mdiqkd with phase encoding rather than polarization encoding . in this paper , we study the above issues simultaneously .
we first propose two schemes of the phase encoding mdiqkd , one employs phase locking of two separate laser sources and the other one uses the conversion of phase encoding into polarization encoding .
then , we prove the unconditional security of these schemes with basis - dependent flaw by generalizing the quantum coin idea @xcite . based on the security proof , we simulate the key generation rate with realistic parameters , especially we employ a simple model to evaluate the basis - dependent flaw due to the imperfection of the phase modulators .
our simulation results imply that the first scheme covers shorter distances and may require less accuracy of the state preparation , while the second scheme can cover much longer distances when we can prepare the state very precisely .
we note that in this paper we consider the most general type of attacks allowed by quantum mechanics and establish unconditional security for our protocols .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : protocol ] , we give a generic description of mdiqkd protocol , and we propose our schemes in sec . [ sec : phase encoding scheme i ] and sec .
[ sec : phase encoding scheme ii ] .
then , we prove the unconditional security of our schemes in sec . [ sec : proof ] , and we present some simulation results of the key generation rate based on realistic parameters in sec . [ sec : simulation ] . finally , we summarize this paper in sec . [
sec : summary ] .
in this section , we introduce mdiqkd protocol whose description is generic for all the schemes that we will introduce in the following sections . the mdiqkd protocol runs as follows .
step ( 1 ) : each of alice and bob prepares a signal pulse and a reference pulse , and each of alice and bob applies phase modulation to the signal pulse , which is randomly chosen from @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 . here , @xmath4 ( @xmath5 ) defines @xmath6 ( @xmath7)-basis .
alice and bob send both pulses through quantum channels to eve who possesses mu .
step ( 2 ) : mu performs some measurement , and announces whether the measurement outcome is successful or not .
it also broadcasts whether the successful event is the detection of type-0 or type-1 ( the two types of the successful outcomes correspond to two specific bell states @xcite ) .
step ( 3 ) : if the measurement outcome is successful , then alice and bob keep their data .
otherwise , they discard the data .
when the outcome is successful , alice and bob broadcast their bases and they keep the data only when the bases match , which we call sifted key . depending on the type of the successful event and the basis that they used , bob may or may not perform bit - flip on his sifted key .
step ( 4 ) : alice and bob repeat ( 1)-(3 ) many times until they have large enough number of the sifted key .
step ( 5 ) : they sacrifice a portion of the data as the test bits to estimate the bit error rate and the phase error rate on the remaining data ( code bits ) .
step ( 6 ) : if the estimated bit error and phase error rates are too high , then they abort the protocol , otherwise they proceed .
step ( 7 ) : alice and bob agree over a public channel on an error correcting code and on a hash function depending on the bit and phase error rate on the code bits . after performing error correction and privacy amplification , they share the key .
the role of the mu in eve is to establish a quantum correlation , i.e. , a bell state , between alice and bob to generate the key .
if it can establish the strong correlation , then alice and bob can generate the key , and if it can not , then it only results in a high bit error rate to be detected by alice and bob and they abort the protocol . as we will see later , since alice and bob can judge whether they can generate a key or not by only checking the experimental data as well as information on the fidelity between the density matrices in @xmath6- basis and @xmath7-basis , it does not matter who performs the measurement nor what kind of measurement is actually done as long as mu broadcasts whether the measurement outcome was successful together with the information of whether the successful outcome is type-0 or type-1 . in the security proof
, we assume that mu is totally under the control of eve . in practice , however , we should choose an appropriate measurement that establishes the strong correlation under the normal operation , i.e. , the situation without eve who induces the channel losses and noises . in the following sections , we will propose two phase encoding mdiqkd schemes .
in this section , we propose an experimental setup for mdiqkd with phase encoding scheme , which is depicted in fig .
[ setup1 ] .
this scheme will be proven to be unconditionally secure , i.e. , secure against the most general type of attacks allowed by quantum mechanics . in this setup , we assume that the intensity of alice s signal ( reference ) pulse matches with that of bob s signal ( reference ) pulse when they enter mu . in order to lock the relative phase , we use strong pulses as the reference pulses . in pl unit in the figure , the relative phase between the two strong pulses is measured in two polarization modes separately . the measurement result is denoted by @xmath8 ( here , the arrow represents two entries that correspond to the two relative phases ) . depending on this information @xmath8 , appropriate phase modulations for two polarization modes
are applied to incoming signal pulse from alice .
then , alice s and bob s signal pulses are input into the 50/50 beam splitter which is followed by two single - photon threshold detectors .
the successful event of type-0 ( type-1 ) in step ( 2 ) is defined as the event where only d0 ( d1 ) clicks . in the case of type-1 successful detection event
, bob applies bit flip to his sifted key ( we define the phase relationship of bs in such a way that d1 never clicks when the phases of the two input signal coherent pulses are the same ) . .
then , the phase shift of @xmath8 for each polarization mode is applied to one of the signal pulses , and they will be detected by d0 and d1 after the interference at the 50:50 beam splitter bs .
[ setup1 ] ] roughly speaking , our scheme performs double bb84 @xcite , i.e. , each of alice and bob is sending signals in the bb84 states , without phase randomization @xcite .
differences between our scheme and the polarization encoding mdiqkd scheme include that alice and bob do not need to share the reference frame for the polarization mode , since mu performs the feed - forward control of the polarization , and our scheme intrinsically possesses the basis - dependent flaw .
to see how this particular setup establishes the quantum correlation under the normal operation , it is convenient to consider an entanglement distribution scheme @xcite , which is mathematically equivalent to the actual protocol . for the simplicity of the discussion
, we assume the perfect phase locking for the moment and we only consider the case where both of alice and bob use @xmath6-basis .
we skip the discussion for @xmath7-basis , however it holds in a similar manner @xcite . in this case , the actual protocol is equivalently described as follows .
first , alice prepares two systems in the following state , which is a purification of the @xmath6-basis density matrix , @xmath9 and sends the second system to mu through the quantum channel .
here , @xmath10 and @xmath11 represent coherent states that alice prepares in the actual protocol ( @xmath12 represents the mean photon number or inetensity ) , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are eigenstate of the computational basis ( @xmath6 basis ) , which is related with @xmath7-basis eigenstate through @xmath15 and @xmath16 . for the later convenience ,
we also define @xmath17-basis states as @xmath18 and @xmath19 .
moreover , the subscript of @xmath20 in @xmath21 represents that alice is to measure her qubit along @xmath6-basis , the subscript of @xmath22 in @xmath12 refers to the party who prepares the system , and the superscript @xmath23 represents the relative phase of the superposition .
similarly , bob also prepares two systems in a similar state @xmath24 , sends the second system to mu , and performs @xmath6-basis measurement . note that @xmath6-basis measurement by alice and bob can be delayed after eve s announcement of the successful event without losing any generalities in the security analysis , and we assume this delay in what follows .
in order to see the joint state of the qubit pair after the announcement , note that the beam splitter converts the joint state @xmath25 into the following state @xmath26 @xmath27 here , for the simplicity of the discussion , we assume that there is no channel losses , we define @xmath28 , and @xmath29 represents the vacuum state .
moreover , the subscripts @xmath30 and @xmath31 represent the output ports of the beam splitter . if detector d0
( d1 ) detects photons and the other detector d1 ( d0 ) detects the vacuum state , i.e. , type-0 ( type-1 ) event , it is shown in the appendix a that the joint probability of having type-0 ( type-1 ) successful event and alice and bob share the maximally entangled state @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) is @xmath34 .
we note that since @xmath35 , alice and bob do not always share this state , and with a joint probability of @xmath36 , they have type-0 ( type-1 ) successful event and share the maximally entangled state with the phase error , i.e. , the bit error in @xmath7-basis , as @xmath37 ( @xmath38 ) .
note that the bit - flip operation in type-1 successful detection can be equivalently performed by @xmath2 rotation around @xmath17-basis before bob performs @xmath6 basis measurement .
in other words , @xmath2 rotation around @xmath17-basis before @xmath6-basis measurement does not change the statistics of the @xmath6-basis measurement followed by the bit - flip .
thanks to this property , we can conclude that alice and bob share @xmath32 with probability of @xmath39 and @xmath37 with probability of @xmath40 after the rotation .
this means that even if alice and bob are given the successful detection event , they can not be sure whether they share @xmath37 or @xmath32 , however , if they choose a small enough @xmath41 , then the phase error rate ( the rate of the state @xmath37 in the qubit pairs remaining after the successful events or equivalently , the rate of @xmath7-basis bit error among all the shared qubit pairs ) becomes small and they can generate a pure state @xmath32 by phase error correction , which is equivalently done by privacy amplification in the actual protocol @xcite .
we note that the above discussion is valid only for the case without noises and losses , and we will prove the security against the most general attack in sec .
[ sec : proof ] without relying on the argument given in this section .
we remark that in the phase encoding scheme i , it is important that alice and bob know quite well about the four states that they prepare .
this may be accomplished by using state tomography with homodyne measurement involving the use of the strong reference pulse @xcite .
[ scheme ii ] in this section , we propose the second experimental setup for mdiqkd with phase encoding scheme .
like scheme i , this scheme will also be proven to be unconditionally secure . in this scheme , the coherent pulses that alice and bob
send out are exactly the same as those in the standard phase encoding bb84 , i.e. , @xmath42 where subscripts @xmath43 and @xmath44 respectively denote the signal pulse and the reference pulse , @xmath45 is a completely random phase , @xmath46 is randomly chosen from @xmath47 to encode the information . after entering the mu ,
each pulse pair is converted from a phase coding signal to a polarization coding signal by a phase - to - polarization converter ( see details below ) .
we note that thanks to the phase randomization by @xmath45 , the joint state of the signal pulse and the reference pulse is a classical mixture of photon number states . in fig .
[ setup2 ] , we show the schematics of the converter . this converter performs the phase - to - polarization conversion : @xmath48 to @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is a projector that projects the joint system of the signal and reference pulses to a two - dimensional single - photon subspace spanned by @xmath51 where @xmath0 and @xmath52 represent the photon number , and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) represents the horizontal ( vertical ) polarization state of a single - photon . to see how it works ,
let us follow the time evolution of the input state .
at the polarization beam splitter ( pbs in fig .
[ setup2 ] ) , the signal and reference pulses first split into two polarization modes , h and v , and we throw away the pulses being routed to v mode .
then , in h mode , the signal pulse and the reference pulse are routed to different paths by using an optical switch , and we apply @xmath2-rotation only to one of the paths to convert h to v. at this point , we essentially have @xmath55 , where the subscripts of `` @xmath56 '' and `` @xmath57 '' respectively denote the upper path and the lower path .
finally , these spatial modes @xmath56 and @xmath57 are combined together by using a polarization beam splitter so that we have @xmath49 in the output port depicted as `` out '' . in practice , since the birefringence of the quantum channel can be highly time dependent and the polarization state of the input pulses to mu may randomly change with time , i.e. , the input polarization state is a completely mixed state , we can not deterministically distill a pure polarization state , and thus the conversion efficiency can never be perfect .
in other words , one may consider the same conversion of the v mode just after the first polarization beam splitter , however it is impossible to combine the resulting polarization pulses from v mode and the one from h mode into a single mode .
we assume that mu has two converters , one is for the conversion of alice s pulse and the other one is for bob s pulse , and the two output ports `` out '' are connected to exactly the same bell measurement unit @xcite in the polarization encoding mdiqkd scheme in fig .
[ bell m ] @xcite .
this bell measurement unit consists of a 50:50 beam splitter , two polarization beam splitters , and four single - photon detectors , which only distinguishes perfectly two out of the four bell states of @xmath38 and @xmath33 .
the polarization beam splitters discriminate between @xmath58 and @xmath59 ( note that we choose @xmath60 and @xmath61 modes rather than h and v modes since our computational basis is @xmath60 and @xmath61 ) .
suppose that a single - photon enters both from alice and bob . in this case
, the click of d0 + and d0- or d1 + and d1- means the detection of @xmath38 , and the click of d0 + and d1- or d0- and d1 + means the detection of @xmath33 ( see fig .
[ bell m ] ) . in this scheme , since the use of coherent light induces non - zero bit error rate in @xmath7-basis ( @xmath62-basis ) , we consider to generate the key from @xmath63-basis and we use the data in @xmath7-basis only to estimate the bit error rate in this basis conditioned on that both of alice and bob emit a single - photon , which determines the amount of privacy amplification . by considering a single - photon polarization input both from alice and bob , one can see that bob should not apply the bit flip only when alice and bob use @xmath7-basis and @xmath64 is detected in mu , and bob should apply the bit flip in all the other successful events to share the same bit value .
accordingly , the bit error in @xmath6-basis is given by the successful detection event conditioned on that alice and bob s polarization are identical .
as for @xmath7-basis , the bit error is @xmath64 detection given the orthogonal polarizations or @xmath65 detection given the identical polarization .
assuming completely random input polarization state , our converter successfully converts the single - photon pulse with a probability of @xmath66 .
note in the normal experiment that the birefringence effect between alice and the converter and the one between bob and the converter are random and independent , however it only leads to fluctuating coincidence rate of alice s and bob s signals at the bell measurement , but does not affect the qber .
moreover , the fluctuation increases the single - photon loss inserted into the bell measurement .
especially , the events that the output of the converter for alice is the vacuum and the one for bob is a single - photon , and vice versa would increase compared to the case where we have no birefringence effect .
however , this is not a problem since the bell measurement does not output the conclusive events in these cases unless the dark counting occurs .
thus , the random and independent polarization fluctuation in the normal experiment is not a problem , and we will simply assume in our simulation in sec .
[ simulationii ] that this fluctuation can be modeled just by @xmath66 loss .
we emphasize that we do not rely on these assumptions at all when we prove the security , and our security proof applies to any channels and mus . for the better performance and also for the simplicity of analysis , we assume the use of infinite number of decoy states @xcite to estimate the fraction of the probability of successful event conditioned on that both of alice and bob emit a single - photon .
one of the differences in our analysis from the work in @xcite is that we will take into account the imperfection of alice s and bob s source , i.e. , the decay of the fidelity between two density matrices in two bases .
we also remark that since the h and v modes are defined locally in mu , alice and bob do not need to share the reference frame for the polarization mode , which is one of the qualitative differences from polarization encoding miqkd scheme @xcite .
this section is devoted to the unconditional security proof , i.e. , the security proof against the most general attacks , of our schemes .
since both of our schemes are based on bb84 and the basis - dependent flaw in both protocols can be treated in the same manner , we can prove the security in a unified manner .
if the states sent by alice and bob were basis independent , i.e. , the density matrices of @xmath6-basis and @xmath7-basis were the same , then the security proof of the original bb84 @xcite could directly apply ( also see @xcite for a bit more detailed discussion of this proof ) , however they are basis dependent in our case .
fortunately , security proof of standard bb84 with basis - dependent flaw has already been shown to be secure @xcite , and we generalize this idea to our case where we have basis - dependent flaw from both of alice and bob . in order to do so , we consider a virtual protocol @xcite that alice and bob get together and the basis choices by alice and bob are made via measurement processes on the so - called quantum coin . in this virtual protocol of the phase encoding scheme i ,
alice and bob prepare joint systems in the state @xcite @xmath67 since just replacing the state , for instance @xmath68 where @xmath52 and @xmath0 in the ket respectively represents the single - photon and the vacuum , is enough to apply the following proof to the phase encoding scheme ii , we discuss only the security of the phase encoding scheme i in what follows . in eq .
( [ coin - joint - state ] ) , the first system denoted by @xmath69 is given to eve just after the preparation , and it informs eve of whether the bases to be used by alice and bob match or not .
the second system , denoted by @xmath70 , is a copy of the first system and this system is given to bob who measures this system with @xmath71 basis to know whether alice s and bob s bases match or not . if his measurement outcome is @xmath72 ( @xmath73 ) , then he uses the same ( the other ) basis to be used by alice ( note that no classical communication is needed in order for bob to know alice s basis since alice and bob get together ) .
the third system , which is denoted by @xmath22 and we call `` quantum coin '' , is possessed and to be measured by alice along @xmath74 basis to determine her basis choice , and the measurement outcome will be sent to eve after eve broadcasts the measurement outcome at mu . moreover ,
all the second systems of @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath24 , and @xmath77 are sent to eve .
note in this formalism that the information , including classical information and quantum information , available to eve is the same as those in the actual protocol , and the generated key is also the same as the one of the actual protocol since the statistics of alice s and bob s raw data is exactly the same as the one of the actual protocol .
thus , we are allowed to work on this virtual protocol for the security proof . the first system given to eve in eq .
( [ coin - joint - state ] ) allows her to know which coherent pulses contain data in the sifted key and she can post - select only the relevant pulses .
thus , without the loss of any generalities of the security proof , we can concentrate only on the post - selected version of the state in eq .
( [ coin - joint - state ] ) as @xmath78 the most important quantity in the proof is the phase error rate in the code bits . the definition of the phase error rate is the rate of bit errors along @xmath7-basis in the sifted key if they had chosen @xmath7-basis as the measurement basis when both of them have sent pulses in @xmath6-basis . if alice and bob have a good estimation of this rate as well as the bit error rate in the sifted key ( the bit error rate in @xmath6-basis given alice and bob have chosen @xmath6-basis for the state preparation ) , they can perform hashing in @xmath7-basis and @xmath6-basis simultaneously @xcite to distill pairs of qubits in the state whose fidelity with respect to the product state of the maximally entangled state @xmath32 is close to @xmath52 . according to the discussion on the universal composability @xcite , the key distilled via @xmath6-basis measurement on such a state
is composably secure and moreover exactly the same key can be generated only by classical means , i.e. , error correction and privacy amplification @xcite .
thus , we are left only with the phase error estimation . for the simplicity of the discussion , we assume the large number of successful events @xmath79 so that we neglect all the statistical fluctuations and we are allowed to work on a probability rather than the relative frequency . the quantity we have to estimate is the bit error along @xmath7-basis , denoted by @xmath80 , given alice and bob send @xmath81 state , which is different from the experimentally available bit error rate along @xmath7-basis given alice and bob send @xmath82 state .
intuitively , if the basis - dependent flaw is very small , @xmath80 and @xmath83 should be very close since the states are almost indistinguishable . to make this intuition rigorous
, we briefly review the idea by @xcite which applies bloch sphere bound @xcite to the quantum coin .
suppose that we randomly choose @xmath17-basis or @xmath6-basis as the measurement basis for each quantum coin .
let @xmath84 and @xmath85 be fraction that those quantum coins result in @xmath52 in @xmath17-basis and @xmath6-basis measurement , respectively . what bloch sphere bound , i.e. , eq .
( 13 ) or eq .
( 14 ) in @xcite or eq .
( a1 ) in @xcite , tells us in our case is that no matter how the correlations among the quantum coins are and no matter what the state for the quantum coins is , thanks to the randomly chosen bases , the following inequality holds with probability exponentially close to @xmath52 in @xmath79 , @xmath86 by applying this bound separately to the quantum coins that are conditional on having phase errors and to those that are conditional on having no phase error , and furthermore by combining those inequalities using bayes s rule , we have @xmath87 here , @xmath88 is equivalent to the probability that the measurement outcome of the quantum coin along @xmath6-basis is @xmath14 given the successful event in mu .
note that this probability can be enhanced by eve who chooses carefully the pulses , and eve could attribute all the loss events to the quantum coins being in the state @xmath13 .
thus , we have an upper bound of @xmath88 in the worst case scenario as @xmath89 and @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the frequency of the successful event .
note that we have not used the explicit form of @xmath92 and @xmath93 , where @xmath94 , in the derivation of eqs .
( [ phase error bound ] ) , ( [ fdelta ] ) , and ( [ delta ] ) , and the important point is that the state @xmath92 and @xmath93 are the purification of alice s and bob s density matrices for both bases .
since there always exists purification states of @xmath95 and @xmath96 , which are respectively denoted by @xmath97 and @xmath98 , such that @xmath99 , @xmath100 can be rewritten by @xmath101/2\ , , \label{fiddelta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath102 represents alice s density matrix of @xmath6 basis and all the other density matrices are defined by the same manner .
our expression of @xmath100 has the product of two fidelities , while the standard bb84 with basis - dependent flaw in @xcite has only one fidelity ( the fidelity between alice s density matrices in @xmath6 and @xmath7 bases ) .
the two products may lead to poor performance of our schemes compared to that of standard qkd in terms of the achievable distances , however our schemes have the huge advantage over the standard qkd that there is no side - channel in the detectors .
finally , the key generation rate @xmath103 , given @xmath6-basis , in the asymptotic limit of large @xmath79 is given by @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the bit error rate in @xmath6-basis , @xmath106 is the inefficiency of the error correcting code , and @xmath107 .
we can trivially obtain the key generation rate for @xmath7-basis just by interchanging @xmath6-basis in all the discussions above to @xmath7-basis .
we remark in our security proof that we have assumed nothing about what kind of measurement mu conducts but that it announces whether it detects the successful event and the type of the event ( this announcement allows us to calculate @xmath108 and the error rates ) .
thus , mu can be assumed to be totally under the control of eve .
in the following subsections , we show some examples of the key generation rate of each of our schemes assuming typical experimental parameters taken from gobby - yuan - shields ( gys ) experiment @xcite unless otherwise stated .
moreover , we assume that the imperfect phase modulation is the main source of the decay of the fidelity between the density matrices in two bases , and we evaluate the effect of this imperfection on the key generation rate . in the phase encoding scheme
i , the important quantity for the security @xmath100 can be expressed as @xmath109\ , .
\label{delta11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that this quantity is dependent on the intensity of alice s and bob s sources . as we have mentioned in sec .
iii , this quantity may be estimated relatively easily via tomography involving homodyne measurement . ) of @xmath110 and @xmath111 . dashed line : ( a ) mu is at bob s side , i.e. , @xmath112
. solid line : ( b ) mu is just in the middle between alice and bob .
the lines achieving the longer distances correspond to @xmath110 of @xmath113 .
see also the main text for the explanation .
[ fig : key33 ] ] ) that outputs fig .
[ fig : key33 ] as a function of the distance between alice and bob .
[ fig : intensity33 ] ] to simulate the resulting key generation rate , we assume that the bit error stems from the dark counting as well as alignment errors due to imperfect phase locking or imperfect optical components . the alignment error is assumed to be proportional to the probability of having a correct click caused only by the optical detection not by the dark counting .
moreover , we make assumptions that all the detectors have the same characteristics for the simplicity of the analysis , and alice and bob choose the intensities of the signal lights in such a way that the intensities of the incoming pulses to mu are the same . finally , we assume the quantum inefficiency of the detectors to be part of the losses in the quantum channels .
with all the assumptions , we may express the resulting experimental parameters as @xmath114(1-p_{\rm dark})\nonumber\\ & + & ( 1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-2\alpha_{\rm in}}p_{\rm dark}\nonumber\\ \gamma_{\rm suc}&=&\gamma_{\rm suc}^{(x)}+\gamma_{\rm suc}^{(y)}\nonumber\\ \delta_x&=&\delta_y=\big[e_{\rm ali}(1-p_{\rm dark})^2(1-e^{-2\alpha_{\rm in}})\nonumber\\ & + & ( 1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-2\alpha_{\rm in}}p_{\rm dark}\big]/\gamma_{\rm suc}^{(x)}\nonumber\\ \alpha_{\rm in}&\equiv&\alpha_{a}\eta_{a}=\alpha_{b}\eta_{b}\nonumber\\ \eta_{a}&=&\eta_{{\rm det } , a}10^{-\xi_{a } l_{a}/10}\nonumber\\ \eta_{b}&=&\eta_{{\rm det } , b}10^{-\xi_{b } l_{b}/10}\ , . \label{ex data i}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath115 is the dark count rate of the detector , @xmath113 is the alignment error rate , @xmath116 is alice s ( bob s ) overall transmission rate , @xmath117 ( @xmath118 ) is the quantum efficiency of alice s ( bob s ) detector , @xmath119 is alice s ( bob s ) channel transmission rate , and @xmath120 ( @xmath121 ) is the distance between alice ( bob ) and mu .
the first term and the second term in @xmath122 or @xmath123 respectively represent the alignment error , which is assumed to be proportional to the probability of having correct bit value due to the detection of the light , and errors due to dark counting ( one detector clicks due to the dark counting while the other one does not ) .
we take the following parameters from gys experiment @xcite : @xmath124 , @xmath125 , @xmath126 ( db / km ) , @xmath127 , and @xmath128 , and we simulate the key generation rate as a function of the distance between alice and bob in fig .
[ fig : key33 ] . in the figure
, we consider two settings : ( a ) mu is at bob s side , i.e. , @xmath112 ( b ) mu is just in the middle between alice and bob .
the reason why we consider these setting is that the basis - dependent flaw is dependent on intensities that alice and bob employ , and it is not trivial where we should place mu for the better performance .
since mdiqkd polarization encoding scheme without basis - dependent flaw achieves almost twice the distance of bb84 @xcite , we may expect that the setting ( b ) could achieve almost twice the distance of bb84 without phase randomization that achieves about 13 ( km ) @xcite with the same experimental parameters .
the simulation result , however , does not follow this intuition since we have the basis - dependent flaw not only from alice s side but also from bob s side .
thus , the advantage that we obtain from putting mu between alice and bob is overwhelmed by the double basis - dependent flaw . in each setting , we have optimized the intensity of the coherent pulses @xmath12 for each distance ( see fig .
[ fig : intensity33 ] ) . in order to explain why the optimal @xmath129 is so small
, note that scheme i intrinsically suffers from the basis - dependent flaw due to eq .
( [ delta11 ] ) .
this means that if we use relatively large @xmath129 , then we can not generate the key due to the flaw .
actually , when we set @xmath130 , which is a typical order of the amplitude for decoy bb84 , one can see that the upper bound of the phase error rate is @xmath131 even in the zero distance , i.e. , @xmath132 , and we have no chance to generate the key with this amplitude .
thus , alice and bob have to reduce the intensities in order to suppress the basis - dependent flaw .
also , as the distance gets larger and the losses get increased , alice and bob have to use weaker pulses since larger losses can be exploited by eve to enhance the basis - dependent flaw according to eq .
( [ fdelta ] ) , and they can reduce the intensities until it reaches the cut - off value where the detection of the weak pulses is overwhelmed by the dark counts . in the above simulation , we have assumed that alice and bob can prepare states very accurately , however in reality , they can only prepare approximate states due to the imperfection of the sources .
this imperfection gives more basis - dependent flaw , and in order to estimate the effect of this imperfection , we assume that the fidelity between the two actually prepared density matrices in two bases is approximated by the fidelity between the following density matrices ( see appendix b for the detail ) @xmath133 and @xmath134 where we assume an imperfect phase modulator whose degree of the phase modulation error is proportional to the target phase modulation value , and @xmath135 represents the imperfection of the phase modulation that is related with the extinction ratio @xmath136 as @xmath137 in this equation , we assume that the non - zero extinction ratio is only due to the imperfection of the phase modulators . since imperfect phase modulation results in the same effect as the alignment errors , i.e. , the pulses are routed to a wrong output port , we assume that the alignment error rate is increased with this imperfection . thus , in the simulation accommodating the imperfection of the phase modulation , we replace @xmath113 with @xmath138 . here , we have used a pessimistic assumption that the effect of the phase modulation becomes @xmath139-times higher than before since each of alice and bob has one phase modulator and mu has two phase modulators for the phase shift of two polarization modes ( note from eq .
( [ mimperfect phase modulator ] ) that @xmath136 is approximately proportional to @xmath140 , thus 4 times degradation in terms of the accuracy of the phase modulation results in @xmath139-times degradation in terms of the extinction ratio ) .
we also remark that in practice , it is more likely that the phase encoding errors are independent , in which case a factor of 4 will suffice and the key rate will actually be higher than what is presented in our paper . on the other hand , we have to use the following @xmath100 when we consider the security : @xmath141/2\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in figs .
[ fig : keyimpferfectpmi ] and [ fig : intensityimpferfectpmi ] , we plot the key generation rate and the corresponding optimal alice s mean photon numbers ( @xmath12 ) as a function of the distance between alice and bob . in the figures , we define @xmath142 that satisfies @xmath143 as @xmath144 , where @xmath145 is the typical order of @xmath136 in some experiments @xcite .
we have confirmed that we can not generate the key when @xmath145 .
however , we can see in the figures that if the accuracy of the phase modulation is increased three times or five times , i.e. , @xmath146 and @xmath147 , then we can generate the key . like the case in fig .
[ fig : intensity33 ] , the small optimal mean photon number can be intuitively understood by the arguments that we have already made in this section . in order to investigate the feasibility of the phase encoding scheme i with the current technologies , we replace @xmath125 , @xmath127 , and @xmath128 with @xmath148 , @xmath149 @xcite , and @xmath150 @xcite .
we see in fig . [
fig : keyimpferfectpminew ] that the key generation is possible over much longer distances with those parameters assuming the precise control of the intensities of the laser source .
we also show the corresponding optimal mean photon number @xmath129 in fig .
[ fig : intensityimpferfectpminew ] .
we note that thanks to the higher quantum efficiency , the success probability becomes higher , following that alice and bob can use larger mean photon number @xmath129 compared to those in figs .
[ fig : intensityimpferfectpmi ] and [ fig : intensityimpferfectpminew ] . ) of @xmath110 and imperfect phase modulators .
@xmath151 represents the typical amount of the phase modulation error , and we plot the key rate for smaller imperfection of @xmath152 and @xmath153 . dashed line : mu is at bob s side , i.e. , @xmath112 .
solid line : mu is just in the middle between alice and bob.[fig : keyimpferfectpmi ] ] ) that outputs fig .
[ fig : keyimpferfectpmi ] as a function of the distance between alice and bob .
[ fig : intensityimpferfectpmi ] ] with @xmath148 , @xmath149 @xcite , and @xmath151 . dashed line :
mu is at bob s side , i.e. , @xmath112 .
solid line : mu is just in the middle between alice and bob.[fig : keyimpferfectpminew ] ] ) that outputs fig .
[ fig : keyimpferfectpminew ] as a function of the distance between alice and bob .
[ fig : intensityimpferfectpminew ] ] in the phase encoding scheme ii , note that we can generate the key only from the successful detection event in mu given both of alice and bob send out a single - photon since if either or both of alice and bob emit more than one photon , then eve can employ the so - called photon number splitting attack @xcite .
thus , the important quantities to estimate are @xmath154 , @xmath155 , @xmath105 , @xmath156 , which respectively represents gain in @xmath6-basis given both of alice and bob emit a single - photon , the phase error rate given alice and bob emit a single - photon , overall bit error rate in @xmath6-basis , and overall gain in @xmath6-basis . to estimate these quantities stemming from the simultaneous single - photon emission ,
we assume the use of infinite number of decoy states for the simplicity of analysis @xcite .
another important quantity in our study is the fidelity @xmath157 ( @xmath158 ) between alice s ( bob s ) @xmath6-basis and @xmath7-basis density matrices of only single - photon component , _ not _ whole optical modes .
if this fidelity is given , then we have @xmath159 for the simplicity of the discussion , we consider the case of @xmath160 in our simulation .
the estimation of the fidelity only in the single - photon part is very important , however to the best of our knowledge we do not know any experiment directly measuring this quantity .
this measurement may require photon number resolving detectors and very accurate interferometers .
thus , we again assume that the degradation of the fidelity is only due to the imperfect phase modulation given by eq .
( [ mimperfect phase modulator ] ) , and we presume that the fidelity of the two density matrices between the two bases is approximated by the fidelity between the following density matrices ( see appendix b for the detail ) @xmath161\nonumber\\
\rho_{y}^{(1)}&=&\frac{1}{2}\big[{\hat p}\left(\frac{{\left| 0_z \right\rangle}+i e^{i|\delta|/2}{\left| 1_z \right\rangle}}{\sqrt{2}}\right)\nonumber\\ & + & { \hat p}\left(\frac{{\left| 0_z \right\rangle}-i e^{-i|\delta|/2}{\left| 1_z \right\rangle}}{\sqrt{2}}\right)\big]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] with these parameters , we can express the key generation rate given alice and bob use @xmath6-basis as @xcite @xmath162-f(\delta_{x})q_{x}h(\delta_{x})\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath163 is the @xmath164 version of @xmath80 in eq .
( [ key rate ] ) . to simulate the resulting key generation rate ,
the bit errors are assumed to stem from multi - photon component , the dark counting , and the misalignment that is assumed to be proportional to the probability of obtaining the correct bit values only due to the detection by optical pulses .
like before , we also assume that all the detectors have the same characteristics , alice and bob choose the intensities of the signal lights in such a way that the intensities of the incoming pulses to mu are the same , and all the quantum inefficiencies of the detectors can be attributed to part of the losses in the quantum channel .
finally , alice s and bob s coherent light sources are assumed to be phase randomized , and the imperfect phase modulation is represented by the increase of the alignment error rate . with these assumptions , we may have the following resulting experimental parameters @xmath165\nonumber\\ & + & w^{(2,1)}+w^{(2,0)}\nonumber\\ \delta_{x}^{(1,1)}&=&\big\{4\alpha_{a}\alpha_{b}\eta_{a}\eta_{b}e^{-2(\alpha_{a}+\alpha_{b})}p_{\rm dark}(1-p_{\rm dark})^2/2\nonumber\\ & + & 2(e_{\rm ali}+4\eta_{\rm ex})\alpha_{a}\alpha_{b}\eta_{a}\eta_{b}e^{-2(\alpha_{a}+\alpha_{b})}(1-p_{\rm dark})^2\nonumber\\ & + & ( w^{(2,1)}+w^{(2,0)})/2\big\}/q^{(1,1)}_{x}\nonumber\\ q^{(1,1)}_{y}&=&q^{(1,1)}_{x}\nonumber\\ \delta^{(1,1)}_{y}&=&\delta^{(1,1)}_{x}\nonumber\\ w^{(2,1)}&\equiv&8\alpha_{a}\alpha_{b}e^{-2(\alpha_{a}+\alpha_{b})}\big[\eta_{a}(1-\eta_{b})+(1-\eta_{a})\eta_{b}\big]\nonumber\\ & \times&p_{\rm dark}(1-p_{\rm dark})^2\nonumber\\ w^{(2,0)}&\equiv&16\alpha_{a}\alpha_{b}(1-\eta_{a})(1-\eta_{b})e^{-2(\alpha_{a}+\alpha_{b})}\nonumber\\ & \times&p_{\rm dark}^2(1-p_{\rm dark})^2\nonumber\\ q_{x}&=&2\left[1-(1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-\alpha_{\rm in}}\right]^2(1-p_{\rm dark})^2e^{-2\alpha_{\rm in}}+v \nonumber\\ \delta_{x}&=&v+(e_{\rm ali}+4\eta_{\rm ex})2\left(1-e^{-\alpha_{\rm in}}\right)^2 \nonumber\\ & \times&(1-p_{\rm dark})^2e^{-2\alpha_{\rm in}}\nonumber\\ v&\equiv&\frac{p_{\rm dark}(1-p_{\rm dark})}{2\pi}\nonumber\\ & \times&\int_{0}^{2\pi}d\theta\big[1-(1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-\alpha_{\rm in}|1+e^{i\theta}|^2}\big ] \nonumber\\ & \times&\big[(1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-\alpha_{\rm in}|1-e^{i\theta}|^2}\big]\nonumber\\ & + & \frac{p_{\rm dark}(1-p_{\rm dark})}{2\pi}\nonumber\\ & \times&\int_{0}^{2\pi}d\theta\big[1-(1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-\alpha_{\rm in}|1-e^{i\theta}|^2}\big ] \nonumber\\ & \times&\big[(1-p_{\rm dark})e^{-\alpha_{\rm in}|1+e^{i\theta}|^2}\big]\nonumber\\ \alpha_{\rm in}&\equiv&\alpha_{a}\eta_{a}=\alpha_{b}\eta_{b}\nonumber\\ \eta_{a}&=&\eta_{{\rm det } , a}10^{-\xi_{a } l_{a}/10}/2\nonumber\\ \eta_{b}&=&\eta_{{\rm det } , b}10^{-\xi_{b } l_{b}/10}/2\ , \label{exp - data - ii}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath12 ( @xmath166 ) represents each of the intensity of alice s ( bob s ) signal light and the reference light , _ not _ the total intensity of them , and @xmath167 and @xmath168 are divided by @xmath169 since the conversion efficiency of our converter is @xmath66 .
@xmath170 in @xmath171 again comes from the pessimistic assumption that each of alice s and bob s phase modulator is imperfect , and @xmath172 ( @xmath173 ) represents the probability of the event where both of alice and bob emit a single - photon and only one ( zero ) photon is detected but the successful detection event is obtained due to the dark counting . on the other hand , the quantity that quantifies the basis - dependent flaw @xmath88 in the present case is upper bounded by @xmath174\nonumber\\ q^{(1,1)}&\equiv&(q^{(1,1)}_{x}+q^{(1,1)}_{y})/2\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath175 is the probability that mu receives a single - photon both from alice and
bob simultaneously conditioned on that each of alice and bob sends out a single - photon .
we remark that @xmath100 in this scheme is only dependent on the accuracy of the phase modulation .
this is different from scheme i where the manipulation of the intensities of the pulses can affect the basis - dependent flaw . in the simulation
, we again assume gys experimental parameters and we consider two settings : ( a ) mu is at bob s side and ( b ) mu is just in the middle between alice and bob .
note that @xmath100 is independent of @xmath12 and @xmath166 in the phase encoding scheme ii case . in fig .
[ f1 ] , we plot the key generation rates of ( a ) and ( b ) for @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 ( recall from eq .
( [ mimperfect phase modulator ] ) that @xmath180 that corresponds to the typical extinction ratio of @xmath181 ) , which respectively correspond to @xmath182 , @xmath183 , @xmath184 , and @xmath185 , and the achievable distances of ( a ) and ( b ) increase with the improvement of the accuracy , i.e. , with the decrease of @xmath135 .
we have confirmed that no key can be distilled in ( a ) and ( b ) when @xmath186 .
the figure shows that the achievable distance drops significantly with the degradation of the accuracy of the phase modulator , and the main reason of this fast decay is that @xmath88 is approximated by @xmath187 and this dominator decreases exponentially with the increase of the distance .
we also plot the corresponding optimal @xmath129 in fig .
notice that the mean photon number increases in some regime in some cases of ( a ) , and recall that this increase does not change @xmath100 .
if we increased the intensity in scheme i with the distance , then we would have more basis - dependent flaw , resulting in shortening of the achievable distance .
this may be an intuitive reason why we see no such increase in figs .
[ fig : intensity33 ] , [ fig : intensityimpferfectpmi ] , and 9 . like in the phase encoding scheme i
, we investigate the feasibility of the phase encoding scheme ii with the current technologies by replacing @xmath125 , @xmath127 , and @xmath128 with @xmath148 , @xmath149 @xcite , and @xmath150 @xcite . with this upgrade
, we have confirmed the impossibility of the key generation , however if we double the quantum efficiency of the detector or equivalently , if we assume the polarization encoding so that the factor of @xmath131 , which is introduced by the phase - to - polarization converter , is removed both from @xmath167 and @xmath168 in eq .
( [ exp - data - ii ] ) , then we can generate the key , which is shown in fig . [ f1new ] ( also see fig .
finally , we note that our simulation is essentially the same as the polarization coding since the fact that we use phase encoding is only reflected by the dominator of 2 in @xmath188 and @xmath189 in eq .
( [ exp - data - ii ] ) .
thus , the behavior of the key generation rate against the degradation of the state preparation is the same also in polarization based mdiqkd .
also note that even in the standard bb84 , @xmath88 decays exponentially with increasing distance .
thus , we conclude that very precise state preparation is very crucial in the security of not only mdiqkd but also in standard qkd
. we also note that our estimation of the fidelity might be too pessimistic since we have assumed that the degradation of the extinction ratio is only due to imperfect phase modulation . in reality
, the imperfection of mach - zehnder interferometer and other imperfections should contribute to the degradation , and the fidelity should be closer to @xmath52 than the one based on our model . .
solid line : ( b ) mu is just in the middle between alice and bob .
we plot the key generation rates of each case when @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 where @xmath135 is proportional to the amount of the phase modulation error , and for each case of ( a ) and ( b ) the key generation rates monotonously increase with the decrease of @xmath135 .
, i.e. , with the improvement of the phase modulation . the key rates of ( a ) and ( b ) when @xmath190 are almost superposed . see also the main text for the explanation .
[ f1 ] ] ) that outputs fig .
the bold lines correspond to ( a ) .
see also the main text for the explanation .
[ f2 ] ] , @xmath191 , and @xmath151 .
note that we double @xmath192 compared to the one of @xcite , or we effectively consider the polarization encoding @xcite .
dashed line : ( a ) mu is at bob s side , i.e. , @xmath112 . solid line : ( b ) mu is just in the middle between alice and bob .
the key rates are almost superposed .
see also the main text for the explanation .
[ f1new ] ] ) that outputs fig .
[ f1new ] .
the bold lines correspond to ( a ) .
see also the main text for the explanation .
[ f2new ] ]
in summary , we have proposed two phase encoding mdiqkd schemes .
the first scheme is based on the phase locking technique and the other one is based on the conversion of the pulses in the standard phase encoding bb84 to polarization modes .
we proved the security of the first scheme , which intrinsically possesses basis - dependent flaw , as well as the second scheme with the assumption of the basis - dependent flaw in the single - photon part of the pulses .
based on the security proof , we also evaluate the effect of imperfect state preparation , and especially we focus our attention to the imperfect phase modulation .
while the first scheme can cover relatively short distances of the key generation , this scheme has an advantage that the basis - dependent flaw can be controlled by the intensities of the pulses .
thanks to this property , we have confirmed based on a simple model that 3 or 5 times of the improvement in the accuracy of the phase modulation is enough to generate the key . moreover , we have confirmed that the key generation is possible even without these improvements if we implement this scheme by using the up - to - date technologies and the control of intensities of the laser source is precise . on the other hand , it is not so clear to us how accurate we can lock the phase of two spatially separated laser sources , which is important for the performance of scheme i. our result still implies that scheme i can tolerate up to some extent of the imperfect phase locking errors , which should be basically the same as the misalignment errors , but further analysis of the accuracy from the experimental viewpoint is necessary . we leave this problem for the future studies .
-basis when @xmath176 , @xmath193 , @xmath194 where @xmath135 is the amount of the phase modulation error .
[ sf1 ] ] ) that outputs fig .
[ sf2 ] ] the second scheme can cover much longer distances when the fidelity of the _ single - photon components _ of @xmath7-basis and @xmath6-basis density matrices is perfect or extremely close to perfect . when we consider
the slight degradations of the fidelity , however , we found that the achievable distances drop significantly .
this suggests that we need a photon source with a very high fidelity , and very accurate estimation of the fidelity of the single - photon subspace is also indispensable . in our estimation of the imperfection of the phase modulation
, we simply assume that the degradation of the extinction ratio is only due to imperfect phase modulation , which might be too pessimistic , and the imperfection of mach - zehnder interferometer and other imperfections contribute to the degradation .
thus , the actual fidelity between the density matrices of the single - photon part in two bases might be very close to 1 , which should be experimentally confirmed for the secure communication .
we note that the use of the passive device to prepare the state @xcite may be a promising way for the very accurate state preparation .
we remark that the accurate preparation of the state is very important not only in mdiqkd but also in standard qkd where eve can enhance the imbalance of the quantum coin exponentially with the increase of the distance . to see this point , we respectively plot in fig .
[ sf1 ] and fig .
[ sf2 ] the key generation rate of standard bb84 with infinite decoy states in @xmath6-basis and its optimal mean photon number assuming @xmath148 , @xmath195 @xcite , @xmath150 , @xmath124 , and @xmath126 .
again , @xmath196 is the typical value of the phase modulation error , and we see in the figure that the degradation of the phase modulator in terms of the accuracy significantly decreases the achievable distance of secure key generation .
one notices that standard decoy bb84 is more robust against the degradation since the probability that the measurement outcome of the quantum coin along @xmath6-basis is @xmath14 given the successful detection of the signal by bob is written as @xmath197 rather than @xmath198 . on the other hand
, one has to remember that we trust the operation of bob s detectors in this simulation , which may not hold in practice .
finally , we neglect the effect of the fluctuation of the intensity and the center frequency of the laser light in our study , which we will analyze in the future works . in summary ,
our work highlights the importance of very accurate preparation of the states to avoid basis - dependent flaws .
we thank x. ma , m. curty , k. azuma , t. yamamoto , r. namiki , t. honjo , h. takesue , y. tokunaga , and especially g. kato for enlightening discussions .
part of this research was conducted when k. t and c - h .
f. f visited the university of toronto , and they express their sincere gratitude for all the supports and hospitalities that they received during their visit .
this research is in part supported by the project `` secure photonic network technology '' as part of `` the project uqcc '' by the national institute of information and communications technology ( nict ) of japan , in part by the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) through its funding program for world - leading innovative r@xmath199d on science and technology ( first program ) " , in part by rgc grant no .
700709p of the hksar government , and also in part by nserc , canada research chair program , canadian institute for advanced research ( cifar ) and quantumworks .
in this appendix , we give a detailed calculation about how scheme i works when there is no channel losses and noises . in order to calculate the joint probability that alice and bob obtain type-0 successful event , where only the detector d0 clicks , and they share the maximally entangled state @xmath32
, we introduce a projector @xmath200 that corresponds to type-0 successful event . here
, @xmath201 represents the non - vacuum state .
the state after alice and bob have the type-0 successful event @xmath202 ( see eq .
( [ normal schi ] ) for the definition of @xmath26 ) can be expressed by @xmath203 here , @xmath204 is an identity operator on @xmath205 and @xmath206 , @xmath207 and @xmath208 are complex numbers , and @xmath209 and @xmath210 are orthonormal bases , which are related with each other through @xmath211 by a direct calculation , one can show that latexmath:[\ ] ] here , @xmath240 , @xmath241 , and @xmath242 , and @xmath243 is defined by @xmath244 where @xmath245 is a purification of @xmath246 , which is the state that alice actually prepares for the bit value @xmath247 in basis @xmath248 , and @xmath249 is alice s qubit system .
one can choose any purification for @xmath245 , and in particular it should be chosen in such a way that it maximizes the inner product in eq .
( c2 ) or ( c3 ) .
one can similarly define @xmath250 , and @xmath46 is introduced via considering a joint state involving the quantum coin as @xmath251 due to this change , the figures for the key generation rate have to be revised . as the examples of revised figures , we show the revised version of figs . 8 , 9 , 12 , and 13 , which are the most important figures for our main conclusions to hold .
notice that there are only minor changes in figs . 8 and 9 and
the changes in figs .
12 and 13 are relatively big
. however , the big changes do not affect the validity of the main conclusions in our paper , which is the importance of the state preparation in mdiqkd and the fact that our schemes can generate the key with the practical channel mode that we have assumed . for the derivation of eq .
( [ 0 ] ) , we invoke koashi s proof @xcite .
to apply koashi s proof , it is important to ensure that i ) one of the two parties holds a virtual * qubit * ( rather than a higher dimensional system ) and ii ) the fictitious measurements performed on the virtual qubit have to form * conjugate * observables .
therefore , it is not valid to consider fidelity alone ( which allows arbitrary purifications that may not satisfy the conjugate observables requirement ) .
fortunately , it turns out to be easy to modify our equation to satisfy the above two requirements . since the difference between eq .
( c2 ) and eq .
( c3 ) comes from whether we consider alice s virtual qubit or bob s virtual qubit , we focus only on eq .
( c2 ) and the same argument holds for eq .
( c3 ) . in koashi s
proof , the security is guaranteed via two alternative tasks , ( i ) agreement on x ( key distillation basis ) and ( ii ) alice s or bob s preparation of an eigenstate of y , the conjugate basis of x , with use of an extra communication channel . the problem with the original ( i.e. uncorrected ) version of eq .
( 9 ) is the following .
if we use the uncorrected version of eq .
( 9 ) in our paper , then the use of the fidelity means that the real part in eq .
( c2 ) is equivalent to @xmath252 with the maximization over _ all possible _ local unitary operators @xmath253 . in this case , if alice performs a measurement along x basis , then it violates the correspondence between her sending state @xmath246 and her qubit state @xmath254 in general , and thus , in the uncorrected version of eq .
( 9 ) in our paper , the argument based on the fidelity does not guarantee the security of the protocol .
in contrast , with the corrected version of eq .
( 9 ) in our paper , since the maximization over @xmath46 and @xmath255 in eq .
( c2 ) preserves the relationship between alice s sending state and her qubit state as well as the conjugate relationship between x and y , we can apply koashi s proof for the security argument of the protocol .
b. qi , c .- h .
f. fung , h .- k .
lo and x. ma , quant .
73 - 82 ( 2007 ) , y. zhao , c .- h .
f. fung , b. qi , c. chen and h .- k .
lo , phys .
a 78 , 042333 ( 2008 ) , c .- h .
f. fung , b. qi , k. tamaki and h .- k .
lo , phys .
a 75 , 032314 ( 2007 ) , f. xu , b. qi and h .- k .
lo , new j. phys .
12 , 113026 ( 2010 ) .
l. lydersen , c. wiechers , c. wittmann , d. elser , j. skaar and v. makarov , nature photonics 4 , pp .
686 - 689 ( 2010 ) , z. l. yuan , j. f. dynes and a. j. shields , nature photonics 4 , pp .
800 - 801 ( 2010 ) , l. lydersen , c. wiechers , c. wittmann , d. elser , j. skaar and v. makarov , nature photonics 4 , 801 ( 2010 ) , i. gerhardt , q. liu , a. lamas - linares , j. skaar , c. kurtsiefer and v. makarov , nature comm . 2 , 349 ( 2011 ) , l. lydersen , m. k. akhlaghi , a. h. majedi , j. skaar and v. makarov , arxiv : 1106.2396 .
f. fung , k. tamaki , b. qi , h .- k .
lo and x. ma , quant .
inf . comp .
9 , 131 ( 2009 ) , l. lydersen , j. skaar , quant .
inf . comp . * 10 * , 0060 ( 2010 ) , .
mary , l. lydersen , j. skaar , phys .
a * 82 * , 032337 ( 2010 ) .
d. mayers and a. c .- c .
yao , in proceedings of the 39th annual symposium on foundations of computer science ( focs98 ) , ( ieee computer society , washington , dc , 1998 ) , p. 503
, a. acin , n. brunner , n. gisin , s. massar , s. pironio , and v. scarani , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 230501 ( 2007 ) .
the definition of the four bell state is as follows .
@xmath257=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[{\left| 0_x \right\rangle}_{a1}{\left| 0_x \right\rangle}_{b1}-{\left| 1_x \right\rangle}_{a1}{\left| 1_x \right\rangle}_{b1}]$ ] , @xmath258=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[{\left| 0_x \right\rangle}_{a1}{\left| 1_x \right\rangle}_{b1}+{\left|
1_x \right\rangle}_{a1}{\left| 0_x \right\rangle}_{b1}]$ ] , @xmath259=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}[{\left| 0_x \right\rangle}_{a1}{\left| 0_x \right\rangle}_{b1}+{\left|
1_x \right\rangle}_{a1}{\left| 1_x \right\rangle}_{b1}]$ ] , and @xmath260 .
one of the most simplest proofs is shor - preskill s proof @xcite .
the intuition of this proof is as follows .
note that if alice and bob share some pairs of @xmath32 , ( i.e. , alice has one half of each pair and bob has the other half ) , then they can generate a secure key by performing @xmath6-basis measurement .
the reason of the security is that this state is a pure state , which means that this state has no correlations with the third system including eve s system .
due to the intervention by eve , alice and bob do not share this pure state in general , but instead they share noisy pairs .
the basic idea of the proof is to consider the distillation of @xmath32 from the noisy pairs .
for the distillation , note that @xmath32 is only one qubit pair state that has no bit errors in @xmath6-basis ( we call this error as the bit error ) and has no bit errors in @xmath7-basis ( we call this error as the phase error ) .
it is known that if alice and bob employ the so - called css code ( calderbank - shor - steane code ) @xcite , then the noisy pairs are projected to a classical mixture of the four bell states , i.e. , @xmath32 , @xmath37 ( @xmath32 with the phase error ) , @xmath33 ( @xmath32 with the bit error ) , and @xmath38 ( @xmath32 with both the phase and bit errors ) .
moreover , if alice and bob choose a correct css code , which can be achieved by random sampling procedure , then css code can detect the position of the erroneous pair with high probability .
thus , by performing bit and phase flip operation depending on the detected error positions , alice and bob can distill some qubit pairs that are very close in fidelity to the product state of @xmath32 .
in general , implementation of the above scheme requires a quantum computer .
fortunately , shor - preskill showed that the bit error detection and bit flip operation can be done classically , and the phase error detection and phase flip operation need not be done , but exactly the same key can be obtained by the privacy amplification , so that we do not need to possess a quantum computer for the key distillation .
r. renner , and r. koenig , proc . of tcc 2005 , lncs , springer , vol .
* 3378 * ( 2005 ) , m. ben - or , and dominic mayers , arxiv : quant - ph/0409062 , m. ben - or , michal horodecki , d. w. leung , d. mayers , j. oppenheim , theory of cryptography : second theory of cryptography conference , tcc 2005 , j.kilian ( ed . )
springer verlag 2005 , vol . * 3378 * of lecture notes in computer science , pp .
386 - 406 . | in this paper , we study the unconditional security of the so - called measurement device independent quantum key distribution ( mdiqkd ) with the basis - dependent flaw in the context of phase encoding schemes .
we propose two schemes for the phase encoding , the first one employs a phase locking technique with the use of non - phase - randomized coherent pulses , and the second one uses conversion of standard bb84 phase encoding pulses into polarization modes .
we prove the unconditional security of these schemes and we also simulate the key generation rate based on simple device models that accommodate imperfections .
our simulation results show the feasibility of these schemes with current technologies and highlight the importance of the state preparation with good fidelity between the density matrices in the two bases .
since the basis - dependent flaw is a problem not only for mdiqkd but also for standard qkd , our work highlights the importance of an accurate signal source in practical qkd systems .
+ * note : we include the erratum of this paper in appendix c. the correction does not affect the validity of the main conclusions reported in the paper , which is the importance of the state preparation in mdiqkd and the fact that our schemes can generate the key with the practical channel mode that we have assumed . * |
in this letter , we will focus on holographic qcd from d4 branes .
we will discuss some problems with the usual correspondence between the confinement / deconfinement transition in qcd and the scherk - schwarz transition between a solitonic d4 brane and a black d4 brane in the gravity dual .
some of these problems were first discussed in @xcite .
we will specifically show that the black d4 brane can not be identified with the ( strong coupling continuation of the ) deconfinement phase in qcd in four dimensions . as a resolution of these problems
, we will propose an alternative scenario in which the confinement / deconfinement transition corresponds to a gregory - laflamme transition @xcite between a uniformly distributed soliton and a localized soliton in the iib frame .
the scenario we propose suggests that we need to reconsider several previous results in holographic qcd including phenomena related to the sakai - sugimoto model @xcite .
in this section , we will review the construction of four dimensional @xmath0 pure yang - mills theory ( ym4 ) from @xmath1 d4 branes @xcite .
let us first consider a 10 dimensional euclidean spacetime with an @xmath2 and consider d4 branes wrapping on the @xmath2 .
we define the coordinate along this @xmath2 as @xmath3 and its periodicity as @xmath4 .
the effective theory on this brane is a 5 dimensional supersymmetric yang - mills theory ( sym5 ) on the @xmath5 . for the fermions on the brane
, the boundary condition along the circle can be ap ( antiperiodic ) or p ( periodic ) ; to specify the theory , we must pick one of these two boundary conditions .
let us take the ap boundary condition .
this gives rise to fermion masses proportional to the kaluza - klein scale @xmath6 , leading to supersymmetry breaking ( this is called the ss scherk - schwarz mechanism ) .
this , in turn , induces masses for the adjoint scalars and for @xmath7 , which are proportional to @xmath8 at one - loop .
therefore , if @xmath9 is sufficiently small and the dynamical scale @xmath10 and temperature are much less than both the above mass scales , then the fermions , adjoint scalars and kk modes are decoupled and the 5 dimensional supersymmetric yang - mills theory is reduced to a four dimensional pure yang - mills theory .
the precise conditions to obtain ym4 from sym5 are @xmath11 by taking the large @xmath1 ( maldacena ) limit of this system @xcite at low temperatures , we obtain the dual gravity description of the compactified 5 dimensional sym theory @xcite , which consists , at low temperatures , of a solitonic d@xmath12 brane solution wrapping the @xmath5 .
the explicit metric is given by @xmath13 , \nonumber \\
& f_4(u)=1-\left ( \frac{u_0}{u}\right)^3 , \quad e^{\phi}=\frac{\lambda_5}{(2\pi)^2n } \left(\frac{u^{3/2}}{\sqrt{d_5 \lambda_5 } } \right)^{1/2 } , \quad u_0=\frac{\pi \lambda_4}{9 l_4 } , \label{metric - sd4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
this gravity solution is not always valid .
e.g. in order that the stringy modes can be ignored , we should ensure that the curvature in string units must be small @xcite .
this condition turns out to be equivalent to @xmath16 this is opposite to the condition ( [ gauge - cond ] ) .
thus , the gravity solution can describe sym5 but can not directly describe ym4 .
this is a common problem in the construction of holographic duals of non - supersymmetric gauge theories .
however , in principle , leading order effects of stringy modes can be computed by perturbatively evaluating @xmath17 corrections in the gravity theory and , as in case of the standard strong coupling expansion in gauge theory ( see , e.g. @xcite ) , we may obtain appropriate weak coupling results , _ provided no phase transition occurs between the weak and strong coupling regimes_. although the gravity solution ( [ metric - sd4 ] ) is just the leading term of such an expansion , we should be able to infer qualitative properties of the gauge theory by extrapolating .
many interesting results , including the qualitative predictions in @xcite , have been obtained using this prescription
. we will proceed to describe the thermodynamics of yang - mills theory from gravity in this spirit .
in this section we investigate the thermodynamic phase structure of the gravity solutions and compare the result with the phase structure of pure yang - mills theory . to discuss holographic qcd at finite temperatures ,
we begin by compactifying euclidean time in the boundary theory on a circle with periodicity @xmath18 . in order to determine the gravitational theory , we need to fix the periodicity of fermions in the gauge theory along the time cycle .
let us recall that the gauge theory of interest here is pure yang mills theory in four dimensions , which does not have fermions .
fermions reappear when the validity condition of the gravity description ( [ gravity - cond - sd4 ] ) is enforced and @xmath10 goes above the kk scale @xmath6 . in this sense , fermions are an artifact of the holographic method and in the region of validity of the pure ym theory , the periodicity of the fermion should not affect the gauge theory results . indeed we can obtain the thermal partition function of ym4 from sym5 on @xmath19 with either the ( ap , ap ) or ( p , ap ) boundary condition here and elsewhere the boundary conditions will always refer to those of the boundary theory along @xmath20 , respectively . ] : @xmath21 where the limit ensures that the fermions and adjoint scalars are decoupled because of large mass . since we recover pure ym4 in both cases , it is pertinent to study gravity solutions corresponding to both these boundary conditions . the gravity solutions appearing in the ( ap , ap ) case @xcite are summarized as @xmath22 here the metric of the black d4 solution is given by @xmath23 , ~~ u_0=\frac{\pi \lambda_4 l_4}{9\beta^2 } \label{metric - bd4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that this metric is related to the solitonic d4 brane ( [ metric - sd4 ] ) through the @xmath24 symmetry : @xmath25 .
thus , the free energies of these solutions are coincident at the self - dual point @xmath26 and a phase transition called scherk - schwarz transition happens there . in ( [ table - apap ] ) ,
@xmath27 and @xmath28 are the polyakov loop operators : @xmath29 vacuum expectation values of these operators characterize the phases of the gauge theory .
these also act as order parameters for the @xmath30 ` centre symmetry ' ( see @xcite for details ) and their vanishing is related to large-@xmath1 volume independence @xcite .
the gravity solutions appearing in the ( p , ap ) case are @xmath31 note that we need to take a t - dual along the temporal @xmath32 circle and go to the iib frame to see the high temperature region , since the masses of the winding modes of the iia string wrapping along the temporal circle become light when @xmath33 .
this t - dual maps the solitonic d4 solution in the iia to solitonic d3 branes uniformly smeared along the dual temporal circle in the iib , with metric given by @xmath34 .
\label{metric - ssd3 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath35 is the dual of @xmath36 , hence @xmath37 has a periodicity @xmath38 .
this uniform configuration becomes meta - stable above a critical temperature @xmath39 , and the solitonic d3 branes get localized on the dual temporal circle .
this phase transition is a gregory - laflamme ( gl ) type transition @xcite .
the metric of the localized solitonic d3 brane is approximately described in @xcite .
the phases in the 4 dimensional pure yang - mills theory are @xmath40 here @xmath28 makes an appearance because ym4 is viewed as a limit of sym5
. that @xmath41 follows from the fact that kk reduction from sym5 to ym4 only works in this phase ; in the phase with vanishing @xmath28 the thermodynamics is independent of @xmath4 ( through the large @xmath1 volume independence mentioned above ) and can not describe the kk reduction .
note , further , that the above table works for either p or ap boundary condition for the sym5 fermions along the temporal circle , as we argued in ( [ 4d - limit ] ) .
let us now compare this phase structure in yang - mills theory with the one found above for gravity . in the low temperature regime ,
the properties of the polyakov loop operators in the solitonic d4 brane agree with those of the confinement phase . thus these two phases may be identified . in the high temperature regime
, it is the localized d3 soliton which matches the deconfinement phase in terms of properties of @xmath27 and @xmath28 whereas the black d4 brane solution does not .
this , in particular , means that the @xmath30 symmetry is realized in the same was in the localized d3 soliton phase as in the deconfinement phase , whereas it is realized differently in the black d4 solution .
thus the localized d3 solution may correspond to the deconfinement phase but the black d4 brane does not .
indeed the expected phase structures of sym5 with the ( ap , ap ) and ( p , ap ) boundary condition are shown in figure [ fig - d4-phase ] . in the ( ap , ap ) case , at least one phase transition has to occur between the black d4 brane solution and the deconfinement phase .
( this is also expected through the @xmath24 symmetry : @xmath42 @xcite .
see also @xcite . )
therefore the previous conjecture that the black d4 brane corresponds to the deconfinement phase of the yang - mills theory is not correct , since these two phases are not smoothly connected ( see the remarks below in _ italics _ ) .
by contrast ,
in the ( p , ap ) case , the gravity solutions in the strong coupling regime may smoothly continue to the phases of the weakly coupled 4 dimensional yang mills theory .
thus we propose that we should look at these gravity solutions in the ( p , ap ) case to investigate the dynamics of the yang - mills theory .
especially the gl transition between the smeared d3 soliton and the localized d3 soliton would correspond to the confinement / deconfinement transition in the yang - mills theory where d4 branes are replaced by d1 branes .
this provides support for the proposal presented in this paper . ] . with the ( ap , ap ) and ( p , ap ) boundary condition .
the gravity analysis is valid in the strong coupling region ( the blue region ) .
the 4 dimensional ym description is valid in the upper green region , see ( [ gauge - cond ] ) .
the lower green region in the ( ap , ap ) case is the mirror of the upper one via the @xmath24 symmetry @xmath25 .
the solid black lines correspond to a minimal extrapolation of the phase boundaries through the intermediate region .
the dotted line denotes another possible phase transition which is allowed by the @xmath24 symmetry . ]
our proposal opens up the interesting possibility of a relation between the gl transition and the hagedorn transition .
it is known that the gl instability is an instability of the kk modes of the graviton along the compact circle @xcite ( such modes develop an imaginary frequency and grow exponentially ) . in our case ,
the kk modes along the dual temporal circle , which cause the gl instability in the iib description , would be mapped to winding modes around the temporal circle through the t - duality @xcite .
this indicates that the gl transition is associated with the tachyonic instability of the winding modes of the iia string .
this is similar to the hagedorn transition in string theory @xcite , where the temporal winding modes cause the instability .
thus the gl transition in the iib description might correspond to the hagedorn transition in the iia description .
note that on the gauge theory side also , the confinement / deconfinement transition has been shown to be related to the hagedorn transition @xcite .
this makes it plausible that the hagedorn transition in the yang - mills theory continues to the hagedorn transition in the iia string , which , as we argued above , is possibly the dual of the gl transition in the iib supergravity .
in this study , we showed that the identification between the deconfinement phase and the black d4 brane solution in the ( ap , ap ) boundary condition is not correct and proposed a resolution by using the ( p , ap ) boundary condition .
this result suggests that we need to reconsider several previous results , in which the black d4 brane was employed in high temperature holographic qcd including the sakai - sugimoto model @xcite .
one important ingredient in the sakai - sugimoto model is the mechanism of chiral symmetry restoration at high temperatures @xcite . in @xcite , we proposed a new mechanism for chiral symmetry restoration in our framework .
another important issue is to explore what geometry corresponds to the deconfinement phase in the real time formalism ; this is important , e.g. , for the investigation of the viscosity ratio .
problems similar to the above had also been encountered in the study of two dimensional bosonic gauge theory in @xcite .
this indicates that the issues addressed in this paper are rather general in the discussion of holography for non - supersymmetric gauge theories at finite temperatures .
we would like to thank ofer aharony , avinash dhar , saumen datta , koji hashimoto , yoshimasa hidaka , elias kiritsis , matthew lippert , shiraz minwalla , rene meyer , rob myers , vasilis niarchos , tadakatsu sakai , shigeki sugimoto and tadashi takayanagi for valuable discussions and comments .
is partially supported by regional potential program of the e.u .
fp7-regpot-2008 - 1 : cretehepcosmo-228644 and by marie curie contract pirg06-ga-2009 - 256487 .
999 e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space , thermal phase transition , and confinement in gauge theories , '' adv .
theor . math .
* 2 * ( 1998 ) 505 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803131 ] .
o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , `` large n field theories , string theory and gravity , '' phys . rept .
* 323 * , 183 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9905111 ] .
d. j. gross and h. ooguri , `` aspects of large n gauge theory dynamics as seen by string theory , '' phys .
d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 106002 [ arxiv : hep - th/9805129 ] .
m. kruczenski , d. mateos , r. c. myers and d. j. winters , `` towards a holographic dual of large - n(c ) qcd , '' jhep * 0405 * ( 2004 ) 041 [ arxiv : hep - th/0311270 ] . t. sakai and s. sugimoto , `` low energy hadron physics in holographic qcd , '' prog
. theor .
* 113 * ( 2005 ) 843 [ arxiv : hep - th/0412141 ] . o. aharony , j. sonnenschein and s. yankielowicz , `` a holographic model of deconfinement and chiral symmetry restoration , '' annals phys .
* 322 * ( 2007 ) 1420 [ arxiv : hep - th/0604161 ] .
r. gregory and r. laflamme , `` the instability of charged black strings and p - branes , '' nucl .
b * 428 * ( 1994 ) 399 [ arxiv : hep - th/9404071 ] .
t. harmark and n. a. obers , `` black holes on cylinders , '' jhep * 0205 * ( 2002 ) 032 [ hep - th/0204047 ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla and t. wiseman , `` black hole - black string phase transitions in thermal 1 + 1-dimensional supersymmetric yang - mills theory on a circle , '' class .
* 21 * , 5169 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0406210 ] .
t. harmark and n. a. obers , `` new phases of near - extremal branes on a circle , '' jhep * 0409 * ( 2004 ) 022 [ arxiv : hep - th/0407094 ] . h. kudoh and t. wiseman , `` connecting black holes and black strings , '' phys .
lett . * 94 * ( 2005 ) 161102 [ hep - th/0409111 ] .
b. kol , `` the phase transition between caged black holes and black strings : a review , '' phys .
* 422 * ( 2006 ) 119 [ hep - th/0411240 ] .
n. itzhaki , j. m. maldacena , j. sonnenschein and s. yankielowicz , `` supergravity and the large n limit of theories with sixteen supercharges , '' phys .
d * 58 * ( 1998 ) 046004 [ arxiv : hep - th/9802042 ] . j. m. drouffe , c. itzykson , `` lattice gauge fields , '' phys . rept .
* 38 * , 133 - 175 ( 1978 ) .
t. eguchi and h. kawai , `` reduction of dynamical degrees of freedom in the large n gauge theory , '' phys .
lett . * 48 * , 1063 ( 1982 ) .
a. gocksch and f. neri , `` on large n qcd at finite temperature , '' phys .
* 50 * ( 1983 ) 1099 .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla , k. papadodimas , m. van raamsdonk and t. wiseman , `` the phase structure of low dimensional large n gauge theories on tori , '' jhep * 0601 * , 140 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0508077 ] .
s. catterall , a. joseph , t. wiseman , `` thermal phases of d1-branes on a circle from lattice super yang - mills , '' jhep * 1012 * ( 2010 ) 022 .
[ arxiv:1008.4964 [ hep - th ] ] .
t. harmark , v. niarchos and n. a. obers , `` instabilities of black strings and branes , '' class .
* 24 * ( 2007 ) r1 [ arxiv : hep - th/0701022 ] .
s. f. ross , t. wiseman , `` smeared d0 charge and the gubser - mitra conjecture , '' class .
* 22 * ( 2005 ) 2933 - 2946 .
[ hep - th/0503152 ] .
b. sundborg , `` the hagedorn transition , deconfinement and n=4 sym theory , '' nucl .
b * 573 * , 349 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9908001 ] .
o. aharony , j. marsano , s. minwalla , k. papadodimas and m. van raamsdonk , `` the hagedorn - deconfinement phase transition in weakly coupled large n gauge theories , '' adv .
* 8 * ( 2004 ) 603 [ arxiv : hep - th/0310285 ] .
g. mandal , t. morita , `` phases of a two dimensional large n gauge theory on a torus , '' phys .
* d84 * ( 2011 ) 085007 .
[ arxiv:1103.1558 [ hep - th ] ] . | we study the gravity dual of four dimensional pure yang - mills theory through d4 branes , as proposed by witten ( holographic qcd ) . in this holographic qcd
, it has been widely believed that the confinement phase in the pure yang - mills theory corresponds to the solitonic d4 brane in gravity and the deconfinement phase corresponds to the black d4 brane .
we inspect this conjecture carefully and show that the correspondence between the black d4 brane and the deconfinement phase is not correct . instead , by using a slightly different set up
, we find an alternative gravity solution called `` localized soliton '' , which would be properly related to the deconfinement phase . in this case
, the confinement / deconfinement transition is realized as a gregory - laflamme type transition .
we find that our proposal naturally explains several known properties of qcd .
tifr / th/11 - 49 + cctp-2011 - 39 # 1([#1 ] ) |
in the past 30 years , the development of linear algebra libraries has been tremendously successful , resulting in a variety of reliable and efficient computational kernels .
unfortunately these kernels are limited by a rigid interface that does not allow users to pass knowledge specific to the target problem .
if available , such knowledge may lead to domain - specific algorithms that attain higher performance than any traditional library @xcite .
the difficulty does not lay so much in creating flexible interfaces , but in developing algorithms capable of taking advantage of the extra information . in this paper , we present preliminary work on a linear algebra compiler , written in mathematica , that automatically exploits application - specific knowledge to generate high - performance algorithms .
the compiler takes as input a target equation and information on the structure and properties of the operands , and returns as output algorithms that exploit the given information .
in the same way that a traditional compiler breaks the program into assembly instructions directly supported by the processor , attempting different types of optimization , our linear algebra compiler breaks a target operation down to library - supported kernels , and generates not one but a family of viable algorithms .
the decomposition process undergone by our compiler closely replicates the thinking process of a human expert .
we show the potential of the compiler by means of a challenging operation arising in computational biology : the _ genome - wide association study _ ( gwas ) , an ubiquitous tool in the fields of genomics and medical genetics @xcite . as part of gwas
, one has to solve the following equation @xmath0 where @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 are known quantities , and @xmath4 is sought after .
the size and properties of the operands are as follows : @xmath5 , @xmath6 is full rank , @xmath7 is symmetric positive definite ( spd ) , @xmath8 , @xmath9 , and @xmath10 ; @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 is either @xmath15 or of the order of @xmath16 . at the core of gwas
lays a linear regression analysis with non - independent outcomes , carried out through the solution of a two - dimensional sequence of the generalized least - squares problem ( gls ) @xmath17 while gls may be directly solved , for instance , by matlab , or may be reduced to a form accepted by lapack @xcite , none of these solutions can exploit the specific structure pertaining to gwas . the nature of the problem , a sequence of correlated glss , allows multiple ways to reuse computation . also , different sizes of the input operands demand different algorithms to attain high performance in all possible scenarios .
the application of our compiler to gwas , eq . [ eq : probdef ] , results in the automatic generation of dozens of algorithms , many of which outperform the current state of the art by a factor of four or more .
the paper is organized as follows .
related work is briefly described in section [ sec : related ] .
sections [ sec : principles ] and [ sec : system - overview ] uncover the principles and mechanisms upon which the compiler is built . in section
[ sec : generation - algs ] we carefully detail the automatic generation of multiple algorithms , and outline the code generation process . in section [ sec : performance ]
we report on the performance of the generated algorithms through numerical experiments .
we draw conclusions in section [ sec : conclusions ] .
a number of research projects concentrate their efforts on domain - specific languages and compilers . among them , the spiral project @xcite and the tensor contraction engine ( tce ) @xcite , focused on signal processing transforms and tensor contractions , respectively .
as described throughout this paper , the main difference between our approach and spiral is the inference of properties .
centered on general dense linear algebra operations , one of the goals of the flame project is the systematic generation of algorithms .
the flame methodology , based on the partitioning of the operands and the automatic identification of loop - invariants @xcite , has been successfully applied to a number of operations , originating hundreds of high - performance algorithms .
the approach described in this paper is orthogonal to flame .
no partitioning of the operands takes place . instead , the main idea is the mapping of operations onto high - performance kernels from available libraries , such as blas @xcite and lapack .
in this section we expose the human thinking process behind the generation of algorithms for a broad range of linear algebra equations . as an example
, we derive an algorithm for the solution of the gls problem , eq .
[ eq : fgls ] , as it would be done by an expert .
together with the derivation , we describe the rationale for every step of the algorithm .
the exposed rationale highlights the key ideas on top of which we founded the design of our compiler
. given eq .
[ eq : fgls ] , the * first concern is the inverse operator * applied to the expression @xmath18 .
since @xmath19 is not square , the inverse can not be distributed over the product and the expression needs to be processed first .
the attention falls then on @xmath20 .
the inversion of a matrix is costly and not recommended for numerical reasons ; therefore , since @xmath21 is a general matrix , we * factor * it . given the structure of @xmath21 ( spd ) , we choose a cholesky factorization , resulting in @xmath22 where @xmath23 is square and lower triangular .
as @xmath23 is square , the inverse may now be distributed over the product @xmath24 , yielding @xmath25 .
next , we process @xmath26 ; we observe that the quantity @xmath27 * appears multiple times * , and may be computed and reused to * save computation * : @xmath28 at this point , since @xmath29 is not square and the inverse can not be distributed , there are two * alternatives * : 1 ) multiply out @xmath30 ; or 2 ) factor @xmath29 , for instance through a qr factorization . in this example , we choose the former : @xmath31 one can prove that @xmath32 is spd , suggesting yet another factorization .
we choose a cholesky factorization and distribute the inverse over the product : @xmath33 now that all the remaining inverses are applied to triangular matrices , we are left with a series of products to compute the final result . since all operands are matrices except the vector @xmath34 , we compute eq . [
eq : exalg1step4 ] from right to left to * minimize the number of flops*. the final algorithm is shown in alg .
[ alg : exalg - chol ] , together with the names of the corresponding blas and lapack building blocks . ....
$ l l^t = m$ ( ! \sc potrf ! ) $ w : = l^{-1 } x$ ( ! \sc trsm ! ) $ s : = w^t w$ ( ! \sc syrk ! ) $ g g^t = s$ ( ! \sc potrf ! ) $ y : = l^{-1 } y$ ( ! \sc trsv ! ) $ b : = w^t y$ ( ! \sc gemv ! ) $ b : = g^{-1 } b$ ( ! \sc trsv ! ) $ b : = g^{-t } b$ ( ! \sc trsv ! ) .... three ideas stand out as the guiding principles for the thinking process : * the first concern is to deal , whenever it is not applied to diagonal or triangular matrices , with the inverse operator .
two scenarios may arise : a ) it is applied to a single operand , @xmath35 . in this case
the operand is factored with a suitable factorization according to its structure ; b ) the inverse is applied to an expression .
this case is handled by either computing the expression and reducing it to the first case , or factoring one of the matrices and analyzing the resulting scenario .
* when decomposing the equation , we give priority to a ) common segments , i.e. , common subexpressions , and b ) segments that minimize the number of flops ; this way we reduce the amount of computation performed . *
if multiple alternatives leading to viable algorithms arise , we explore all of them .
our compiler follows the above guiding principles to closely replicate the thinking process of a human expert . to support the application of these principles , the compiler incorporates a number of modules ranging from basic matrix algebra support to analysis of dependencies , including the identification of building blocks offered by available libraries . in the following ,
we describe the core modules .
matrix algebra : : the compiler is written using mathematica from scratch .
we implement our own operators : addition ( plus ) , negation ( minus ) , multiplication ( times ) , inversion ( inv ) , and transposition ( trans ) .
together with the operators , we define their precedence and properties , as commutativity , to support matrices as well as vectors and scalars .
we also define a set of rewrite rules according to matrix algebra properties to freely manipulate expressions and simplify them , allowing the compiler to work on multiple equivalent representations .
inference of properties : : in this module we define the set of supported matrix properties . as of now : identity , diagonal , triangular , symmetric , symmetric positive definite , and orthogonal . on top of these properties
, we build an inference engine that , given the properties of the operands , is able to infer properties of complex expressions .
this module is extensible and facilitates incorporating additional properties . building blocks interface : : this module contains an extensive list of patterns associated with the desired building blocks onto which the algorithms will be mapped
. it also contains the corresponding cost functions to be used to construct the cost analysis of the generated algorithms . as with the properties module ,
if a new library is to be used , the list of accepted building blocks can be easily extended .
analysis of dependencies : : when considering a sequence of problems , as in gwas , this module analyzes the dependencies among operations and between operations and the dimensions of the sequence . through this analysis , the compiler rearranges the operations in the algorithm , reducing redundant computations .
code generation : : in addition to the automatic generation of algorithms , the compiler includes a module to translate such algorithms into code .
so far , we support the generation of matlab code for one instance as well as sequences of problems . to complete the overview of our compiler
, we provide a high - level description of the compiler s _ reasoning_. the main idea is to build a tree in which the root node contains the initial target equation ; each edge is labeled with a building block ; and each node contains intermediate equations yet to be mapped .
the compiler progresses in a breadth - first fashion until all leaf nodes contain an expression directly mapped onto a building block .
while processing a node s equation , the search space is constrained according to the following criteria : 1 .
if the expression contains an inverse applied to a single ( non - diagonal , non - triangular ) matrix , for instance @xmath20 , then the compiler identifies a set of viable factorizations for @xmath21 based on its properties and structure ; 2 .
if the expression contains an inverse applied to a sub - expression , for instance @xmath36 , then the compiler identifies both viable factorizations for the operands in the sub - expression ( e.g. , @xmath37 ) , and segments of the sub - expression that are directly mapped onto a building block ( e.g. , @xmath38 ) ; 3 . if the expression contains no inverse to process ( as in @xmath39 , with @xmath40 and @xmath23 triangular )
, then the compiler identifies segments with a mapping onto a building block .
when inspecting expressions for segments , the compiler gives priority to common segments and segments that minimize the number of flops .
all three cases may yield multiple building blocks . for each building block
either a factorization or a segment both a new edge and a new children node are created
. the edge is labeled with the corresponding building block , and the node contains the new resulting expression .
for instance , the analysis of eq .
[ eq : exalg1step2 ] creates the following sub - tree : in addition , thanks to the _ inference of properties _ module , for each building block , properties of the output operands are inferred from those of the input operands .
each path from the root node to a leaf represents one algorithm to solve the target equation . by assembling the building blocks attached to each edge in the path ,
the compiler returns a collection of algorithms , one per leaf .
our compiler has been successfully applied to equations such as pseudo - inverses , least - squares - like problems , and the automatic differentiation of blas and lapack operations .
of special interest are the scenarios in which sequences of such problems arise ; for instance , the study case presented in this paper , genome - wide association studies , which consist of a two - dimensional sequence of correlated gls problems .
the compiler is still in its early stages and the code is not yet available for a general release .
however , we include along the paper details on the input and output of the system , as well as screenshots of the actual working prototype .
we detail now the application to gwas of the process described above .
box [ box : input ] includes the input to the compiler : the target equation along with domain - specific knowledge arising from gwas , e.g , operands shape and properties . as a result ,
dozens of algorithms are automatically generated ; we report on three selected ones .
.... equation = { equal[b , times [ inv[times [ trans[x ] , inv[plus [ times[h , phi ] , times[plus[1 , minus[h ] ] , i d ] ] ] , x ] ] , trans[x ] , inv[plus [ times[h , phi ] , times[plus[1 , minus[h ] ] , i d ] ] ] , y ] ] } ; operandproperties = { { x , { `` input '' , `` matrix '' , `` fullrank '' } } , { y , { `` input '' , `` vector '' } } , { phi , { `` input '' , `` matrix '' , `` symmetric '' } } , { h , { `` input '' , `` scalar '' } } , { b , { `` output '' , `` vector '' } } } ; expressionproperties = { inv[plus [ times[h , phi ] , times[plus[1 , minus[h ] ] , i d ] ] ] , `` spd '' } ; sizeassumptions = { rows[x ] > cols[x ] } ; .... to ease the reader , we describe the process towards the generation of an algorithm similar to alg .
[ alg : exalg - chol ] .
the starting point is eq .
[ eq : probdef ] .
since @xmath19 is not square , the inverse operator applied to @xmath41 can not be distributed over the product ; thus , the inner - most inverse is @xmath42 .
the inverse is applied to an expression , which is inspected for viable factorizations and segments . among the identified alternatives
are a ) the factorization of the operand @xmath43 according to its properties , and b ) the computation of the expression @xmath44 . here
we concentrate on the second case .
the segment @xmath44 is matched as the scal - add building block ( scaling and addition of matrices ) ; the operation is made explicit and replaced : @xmath45 now , the inner - most inverse is applied to a single operand , @xmath21 , and the compiler decides to factor it using multiple alternatives : cholesky ( @xmath46 ) , qr ( @xmath47 ) , eigendecomposition ( @xmath48 ) , and svd ( @xmath49 ) .
all the alternatives are explored ; we focus now on the cholesky factorization ( potrf routine from lapack ) : @xmath50 after @xmath21 is factored and replaced by @xmath24 , the inference engine propagates a number of properties to @xmath23 based on the properties of @xmath21 and the factorization applied .
concretely , @xmath23 is square , triangular and full - rank .
next , since @xmath23 is triangular , the inner - most inverse to be processed in eq .
[ eq : alg1step1 ] is @xmath51 . in this case
two routes are explored : either factor @xmath19 ( @xmath23 is triangular and does not need further factorization ) , or map a segment of the expression onto a building block .
we consider this second alternative .
the compiler identifies the solution of a triangular system ( trsm routine from blas ) as a common segment appearing three times in eq .
[ eq : alg1step1 ] , makes it explicit , and replaces it : @xmath52 since @xmath23 is square and full - rank , and x is also full - rank , @xmath29 inherits the shape of @xmath19 and is labelled as full - rank .
as @xmath29 is not square , the inverse can not be distributed over the product yet .
therefore , the compiler faces again two alternatives : either factoring @xmath29 or multiplying @xmath30 .
we proceed describing the latter scenario while the former is analyzed in sec .
[ subsec : alg - two ] .
@xmath30 is identified as a building block ( syrk routine of blas ) , and made explicit : @xmath53 the inference engine plays an important role deducing properties of @xmath32 . during the previous steps , the engine has inferred that @xmath29 is full - rank and rows[w ] > cols[w ] ; therefore the following rule states that @xmath29 is spd .
is spd if @xmath54 is full rank and has more rows than columns . ] .... isspdq [ times [ trans [ a_?isfullrankq ] , a _ ] / ; rows[a ] > cols[a ] : = true ; ....
this knowledge is now used to determine possible factorizations for @xmath32 .
we concentrate on the cholesky factorization : @xmath55 in eq .
[ eq : alg1step4 ] , all inverses are applied to triangular matrices ; therefore , no more treatment of inverses is needed .
the compiler proceeds with the final decomposition of the remaining series of products .
since at every step the inference engine keeps track of the properties of the operands in the original equation as well as the intermediate temporary quantities , it knows that every operand in eq .
[ eq : alg1step4 ] are matrices except for the vector @xmath34 .
this knowledge is used to give matrix - vector products priority over matrix - matrix products , and eq .
[ eq : alg1step4 ] is decomposed accordingly . in case
the compiler can not find applicable heuristics to lead the decomposition , it explores the multiple viable mappings onto building blocks .
the resulting algorithm , and the corresponding output from mathematica , are assembled in alg .
[ alg : alg - chol ] , chol - gwas . ....
$ m : = h\phi + ( 1-h)i$ ( ! \sc scal - add ! )
$ l l^t = m$ ( ! \sc potrf ! ) $ w : = l^{-1 } x$ ( ! \sc trsm ! ) $ s : = w^t w$ ( ! \sc syrk ! ) $ g g^t = s$ ( ! \sc potrf ! ) $ y : = l^{-1 } y$ ( ! \sc trsv ! ) $ b : = w^t y$ ( ! \sc gemv ! ) $ b : = g^{-1 } b$ ( !
\sc trsv ! ) $ b : = g^{-t } b$ ( ! \sc trsv ! ) .... in this subsection
we display the capability of the compiler to analyze alternative paths , leading to multiple viable algorithms . at the same time
, we expose more examples of algebraic manipulation carried out by the compiler .
the presented algorithm results from the alternative path arising in eq .
[ eq : alg1step3 ] , the factorization of @xmath29 .
since @xmath29 is a full - rank column panel , the compiler analyzes the scenario where @xmath29 is factored using a qr factorization ( geqrf routine in lapack ) : @xmath56 at this point , the compiler exploits the capabilities of the _ matrix algebra _ module to perform a series of simplifications : @xmath57 first , it distributes the transpose operator over the product .
then , it applies the rule .... times [ trans [ q_?isorthonormalq , q _ ] - > i d , .... included as part of the knowledge - base of the module .
the rule states that the product @xmath58 , when @xmath59 is orthogonal with normalized columns , may be rewritten ( - > ) as the identity matrix .
next , since @xmath60 is square , the inverse is distributed over the product .
more mathematical knowledge allows the compiler to rewrite the product @xmath61 as the identity . in eq .
[ eq : alg2step4 ] , the compiler does not need to process any more inverses ; hence , the last step is to decompose the remaining computation into a sequence of products .
once more , @xmath34 is the only non - matrix operand .
accordingly , the compiler decomposes the equation from right to left .
the final algorithm is put together in alg .
[ alg : alg - qr ] , qr - gwas . ....
$ m : = h\phi + ( 1-h)i$ ( ! \sc scal - add ! )
$ l l^t$ = $ m$ ( ! { \sc potrf } ! ) $ w$ : = $ l^{-1 } x$ ( ! { \sc trsm } ! ) $ q r = w$ ( ! { \sc geqrf } ! ) $ y$ : = $ l^{-1 } y$ ( ! { \sc trsv } ! ) $ b$ : = $ q^t y$ ( ! { \sc gemv } ! ) $ b$ : = $ r^{-1 } b$ ( ! { \sc trsv } ! ) .... this third algorithm exploits further knowledge from gwas , concretely the structure of @xmath21 , in a manner that may be overlooked even by human experts .
again , the starting point is eq .
[ eq : probdef ] .
the inner - most inverse is @xmath62 . instead of multiplying out the expression within the inverse operator
, we now describe the alternative path also explored by the compiler : factoring one of the matrices in the expression .
we concentrate in the case where an eigendecomposition of @xmath43 ( syevd or syevr from lapack ) is chosen : @xmath63 where @xmath64 is a square , orthogonal matrix with normalized columns , and @xmath29 is a square , diagonal matrix . in this scenario ,
the _ matrix algebra _
module is essential ; it allows the compiler to work with alternative representations of eq .
[ eq : alg3step1 ] .
we already illustrated an example where the product @xmath58 , @xmath59 orthonormal , is replaced with the identity matrix .
the freedom gained when defining its own operators , allows the compiler to perform also the opposite transformation : .... i d - > times [ q , trans [ q ] ] ; i d - > times [ trans [ q ] , q ] ; .... to apply these rules , the compiler inspects the expression @xmath65 for orthonormal matrices : @xmath64 is found to be orthonormal and used instead of @xmath59 in the right - hand side of the previous rules .
the resulting expression is @xmath66 the algebraic manipulation capabilities of the compiler lead to the derivation of further multiple equivalent representations of eq .
[ eq : alg3step2 ] .
we recall that , although we focus on a concrete branch of the derivation , the compiler analyzes the many alternatives . in the branch under study ,
the quantities @xmath64 and @xmath67 are grouped on the left- and right - hand sides of the inverse , respectively : @xmath68 then , since both @xmath64 and @xmath69 are square , the inverse is distributed : @xmath70 finally , by means of the rules : .... inv [ q_?isorthonormalq ] - > trans [ q ] ; inv [ trans [ q_?isorthonormalq ] ] - > q ; .... which state that the inverse of an orthonormal matrix is its transpose , the expression becomes : @xmath71 the resulting equation is @xmath72 the inner - most inverse in eq .
[ eq : alg3step3 ] is applied to a diagonal object ( @xmath29 is diagonal and @xmath73 a scalar ) .
no more factorizations are needed , @xmath69 is identified as a scal - add building block , and exposed : @xmath74 @xmath75 is a diagonal matrix ; hence only the inverse applied to @xmath76 remains to be processed . among the alternative steps
, we consider the mapping of the common segment @xmath77 , that appears three times , onto the gemm building block ( matrix - matrix product ) : @xmath78 from this point on , the compiler proceeds as shown for the previous examples , and obtains , among others , alg .
[ alg : alg - eigen ] , eig - gwas . ....
$ z w z^t$ = $ \phi$ ( ! { \sc syevx } ! ) $ d : = h w + ( 1 - h ) i$ ( ! { \sc add - scal } ! ) $ k : = x^t z$ ( ! { \sc gemm } ! ) $ v : = k d^{-1}$ ( ! { \sc scal } ! ) $ s$ : = $ v k^t$ ( ! { \sc gemm } ! ) $ q r$ = $ s$ ( ! { \sc geqrf } ! ) $ y : = z^t y$ ( ! { \sc gemv } ! )
$ b : = v y$ ( ! { \sc gemv } ! ) $ b : = q^t b$ ( ! { \sc gemv } ! ) $ b : = r^{-1 } b$ ( ! { \sc trsv } ! ) .... at first sight , alg .
[ alg : alg - eigen ] might seem to be a suboptimal approach .
however , as we show in sec .
[ sec : performance ] , it is representative of a family of algorithms that play a crucial role when solving a certain sequence of gls problems within gwas . we have illustrated how our compiler , closely replicating the reasoning of a human expert , automatically generates algorithms for the solution of a single gls problem . as shown in eq .
[ eq : probdef ] , in practice one has to solve one - dimensional ( @xmath79 ) or two - dimensional ( @xmath80 ) sequences of such problems . in this context
we have developed a module that performs a loop dependence analysis to identify loop - independent operations and reduce redundant computations . for space reasons
, we do not further describe the module , and limit to the automatically generated cost analysis .
the list of patterns for the identification of building blocks included in the _ building blocks interface _ module also incorporates the corresponding computational cost associated to the operations .
given a generated algorithm , the compiler composes the cost of the algorithm by combining the number of floating point operations performed by the individual building blocks , taking into account the loops over the problem dimensions .
table [ tab : cost ] includes the cost of the three presented algorithms , which attained the lowest complexities for one- and two - dimensional sequences . while qr - gwas and chol - gwas share the same cost for both types of sequences , suggesting a very similar behavior in practice , the cost of eig - gwas differs in both cases .
for the one - dimensional sequence the cost of eig - gwas is not only greater in theory , the practical constants associated to its terms increase the gap . on the contrary , for the two - dimensional sequence , the cost of eig - gwas is lower than the cost of the other two .
this analysis suggests that qr - gwas and chol - gwas are better suited for the one - dimensional case , while eig - gwas is better suited for the two - dimensional one . in sec .
[ sec : performance ] we confirm these predictions through experimental results . [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the translation from algorithms to code is not a straightforward task ; in fact , when manually performed , it is tedious and error prone . to overcome this difficulty
, we incorporate in our compiler a module for the automatic generation of code . as of now
, we support matlab ; an extension to fortran , a much more challenging target language , is planned .
we provide here a short overview of this module .
given an algorithm as derived by the compiler , the code generator builds an _ abstract syntax tree _ ( ast ) mirroring the structure of the algorithm .
then , for each node in the ast , the module generates the corresponding code statements .
specifically , for the nodes corresponding to _ for _ loops , the module not only generates a for statement but also the specific statements to extract subparts of the operands according to their dimensionality ; as for the nodes representing the building blocks , the generator must map the operation to the specific matlab routine or matrix expression . as an example of automatically generated code , the matlab routine corresponding to the aforementioned eig - gwas algorithm for a two - dimensional sequence
is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : eig - code ] .
we turn now the attention to numerical results . in the experiments ,
we compare the algorithms automatically generated by our compiler with lapack and genabel @xcite , a widely used package for gwas - like problems . for details on genabel
s algorithm for gwas , gwfgls , we refer the reader to @xcite .
we present results for the two most representative scenarios in gwas : one - dimensional ( @xmath81 ) , and two - dimensional ( @xmath82 ) sequences of gls problems .
the experiments were performed on an 12-core intel xeon x5675 processor running at 3.06 ghz , with 96 gb of memory .
the algorithms were implemented in c , and linked to the multi - threaded gotoblas and the reference lapack libraries .
the experiments were executed using 12 threads .
we first study the scenario @xmath81 .
we compare the performance of qr - gwas and chol - gwas , with genabel s gwfgls , and gels - gwas , based on lapack s gels routine .
the results are displayed in fig .
[ fig : oney ] .
as expected , qr - gwas and chol - gwas attain the same performance and overlap .
most interestingly , our algorithms clearly outperform gels - gwas and gwfgls , obtaining speedups of 4 and 8 , respectively . , @xmath83 , @xmath81 .
the improvement in the performance of our algorithms is due to a careful exploitation of both the properties of the operands and the sequence of gls problems . ]
next , we present an even more interesting result . the current approach of all state - of - the - art libraries to the case @xmath82 is to repeat the experiment @xmath14 times with the same algorithm used for @xmath79 . on the contrary
, our compiler generates the algorithm eig - gwas , which particularly suits such scenario . as fig .
[ fig : manyy ] illustrates , eig - gwas outperforms the best algorithm for the case @xmath79 , chol - gwas , by a factor of 4 , and therefore outperforms gels - gwas and gwfgls by a factor of 16 and 32 respectively . , @xmath83 , @xmath84 .
chol - gwas is best suited for the scenario @xmath79 , while eig - gwas is best suited for the scenario @xmath85 . ]
the results remark two significant facts : 1 ) the exploitation of domain - specific knowledge may lead to improvements in state - of - the - art algorithms ; and 2 ) the library user may benefit from the existence of multiple algorithms , each matching a given scenario better than the others . in the case of gwas
our compiler achieves both , enabling computational biologists to target larger experiments while reducing the execution time .
we presented a linear algebra compiler that automatically exploits domain - specific knowledge to generate high - performance algorithms .
our linear algebra compiler mimics the reasoning of a human expert to , similar to a traditional compiler , decompose a target equation into a sequence of library - supported building blocks .
the compiler builds on a number of modules to support the replication of human reasoning . among them ,
the _ matrix algebra _
module , which enables the compiler to freely manipulate and simplify algebraic expressions , and the _ properties inference _ module , which is able to infer properties of complex expressions from the properties of the operands .
the potential of the compiler is shown by means of its application to the challenging _ genome - wide association study _ equation .
several of the dozens of algorithms produced by our compiler , when compared to state - of - the - art ones , obtain n - fold speedups . as future work
we plan an extension to the _ code generation _ module to support fortran .
also , the asymptotic operation count is only a preliminary approach to estimate the performance of the generated algorithms . there is the need for a more robust metric to suggest a `` best '' algorithm for a given scenario .
the authors gratefully acknowledge the support received from the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( german research association ) through grant gsc 111 .
bientinesi , p. , eijkhout , v. , kim , k. , kurtz , j. , van de geijn , r. : sparse direct factorizations through unassembled hyper - matrices .
computer methods in applied mechanics and engineering * 199 * ( 2010 ) 430438 anderson , e. , bai , z. , bischof , c. , blackford , s. , demmel , j. , dongarra , j. , du croz , j. , greenbaum , a. , hammarling , s. , mckenney , a. , sorensen , d. : users guide .
third edn .
society for industrial and applied mathematics , philadelphia , pa ( 1999 ) pschel , m. , moura , j.m.f . ,
johnson , j. , padua , d. , veloso , m. , singer , b. , xiong , j. , franchetti , f. , gacic , a. , voronenko , y. , chen , k. , johnson , r.w .
, rizzolo , n. : : code generation for dsp transforms . proceedings of the ieee , special issue on `` program generation , optimization , and adaptation '' * 93*(2 ) ( 2005 ) 232 275 baumgartner , g. , auer , a. , bernholdt , d.e . , bibireata , a. , choppella , v. , cociorva , d. , gao , x. , harrison , r.j . , hirata , s. , krishnamoorthy , s. , krishnan , s. , chung lam , c. , lu , q. , nooijen , m. , pitzer , r.m . ,
ramanujam , j. , sadayappan , p. , sibiryakov , a. , bernholdt , d.e . , bibireata , a. , cociorva , d. , gao , x. , krishnamoorthy , s. , krishnan , s. : synthesis of high - performance parallel programs for a class of ab initio quantum chemistry models . in : proceedings of the ieee .
( 2005 ) 2005 fabregat - traver , d. , bientinesi , p. : knowledge - based automatic generation of partitioned matrix expressions . in gerdt , v. , koepf , w. , mayr , e. , vorozhtsov , e. ,
eds . : computer algebra in scientific computing .
volume 6885 of lecture notes in computer science . ,
springer berlin / heidelberg ( 2011 ) 144157 fabregat - traver , d. , bientinesi , p. : automatic generation of loop - invariants for matrix operations . in : computational science and its applications , international conference , los alamitos , ca , usa , ieee computer society ( 2011 ) 8292 fabregat - traver , d. , aulchenko , y.s . ,
bientinesi , p. : fast and scalable algorithms for genome studies . technical report , aachen institute for advanced study in computational engineering science ( 2012 ) available at http://www.aices.rwth-aachen.de:8080/aices/preprint/documents/aices-2012-05-01.pdf . | we present a prototypical linear algebra compiler that automatically exploits domain - specific knowledge to generate high - performance algorithms .
the input to the compiler is a target equation together with knowledge of both the structure of the problem and the properties of the operands .
the output is a variety of high - performance algorithms , and the corresponding source code , to solve the target equation .
our approach consists in the decomposition of the input equation into a sequence of library - supported kernels . since in general
such a decomposition is not unique , our compiler returns not one but a number of algorithms .
the potential of the compiler is shown by means of its application to a challenging equation arising within the _ genome - wide association study_. as a result , the compiler produces multiple `` best '' algorithms that outperform the best existing libraries . |
supersymmetry is a well - motivated way to extend the standard model ( sm ) .
most impressively , supersymmetry can stabilize the large disparity between the size of the electroweak scale and the planck scale @xcite .
in addition , the minimal supersymmetric extension of the sm @xcite , the mssm , leads to an excellent unification of the @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 gauge couplings @xcite near @xmath4 gev , a scale that is large enough that grand - unified theory ( gut ) induced nucleon decay is not a fatal problem .
the mssm also contains a new stable particle if @xmath5-parity is an exact symmetry .
this new stable particle can potentially make up the dark matter .
the main obstacles facing supersymmetric extensions of the sm come from the requirement that supersymmetry be ( softly ) broken . to preserve the natural supersymmetric hierarchy between @xmath6 and @xmath7 ,
every mssm operator that breaks supersymmetry should be accompanied by a dimensionful coupling of size less than about a tev . however , for a generic set of soft terms of this size , consistent with all the symmetries of the theory , the amount of flavor mixing and cp violation predicted by the model is much greater than has been observed . instead
, the experimental constraints require that the soft terms be nearly flavor - diagonal in the super - ckm basis @xcite , and that nearly all the independent cp violating phases be very small @xcite , or finely - tuned to cancel @xcite . from the low - energy perspective
, it is not clear why this should be so .
a number of approaches to the supersymmetric flavor and cp problems have been put forward , such as adding new flavor symmetries to the mssm @xcite , or mediating supersymmetry breaking through gauge interactions @xcite or the superconformal anomaly @xcite .
these models also face new difficulties .
new flavor symmetries typically require additional matter fields and hence the complications that go with them .
gauge mediation generates flavor - universal soft masses and trivially small @xmath8 terms , but does not fully solve the cp problem , and makes it difficult to generate both the @xmath9 and @xmath10 terms with the correct size .
anomaly mediation in its most simple form suffers from tachyonic slepton soft masses @xcite .
a more radical approach to the flavor and cp problems is to push the scale of the soft supersymmetry breaking scalar couplings to be much larger than the electroweak scale @xcite .
if this is done while keeping the gauginos relatively light , it is possible to preserve gauge unification and a good dark matter candidate @xcite . of course
, supersymmetry would no longer directly solve the gauge hierarchy problem if the scalar superpartners are very heavy . another way to address the supersymmetric flavor problem , and
the one we consider in the present work , is to have the soft scalar masses and the @xmath8 terms vanish simultaneously at a scale @xmath0 @xcite .
if this scale is much larger than the electroweak scale , and if the gaugino masses do not vanish at @xmath0 , non - zero values for the scalar soft terms will be generated by radiative effects as the theory is evolved to lower energies . since the scalar soft terms thus induced are family - universal , the resulting soft spectrum does not have a flavor problem .
the supersymmetric cp problem is also improved but not solved by this approach . besides the ckm phases , the only remaining phases are those of the gaugino soft masses , and the @xmath9 and @xmath10 terms .
if the gaugino soft mass phases are universal , there are three new phases of which two can be removed by making field redefinitions @xcite . the remaining phase can be eliminated as well within particular models @xcite .
near - vanishing soft scalar terms can arise in a number of ways .
the canonical examples are the no - scale models of gravity mediated supersymmetry breaking . in these models , the absence of scalar soft terms is related to the flatness of the hidden sector potential that allows the gravitino mass to be determined by loop - corrections due to light fields @xcite .
a more recent construction that leads to near - vanishing soft scalar operators is gaugino - mediated supersymmetry breaking @xcite . here
, the mssm chiral multiplets are separated from the source of supersymmetry breaking by an extra - dimensional bulk , while the gauge multiplets propagate in the bulk .
locality in the extra dimension(s ) leads to gaugino masses that are much larger than the scalar soft terms .
small scalar soft terms can also be obtained from strong conformal dynamics in either the visible or the hidden sectors . in these constructions ,
the conformal running suppresses the scalar soft terms exponentially relative to the gaugino soft masses @xcite .
the main difficulty with very small input scalar soft masses is that the lightest sm superpartner particle is usually a mostly right - handed slepton , which can be problematic for cosmology .
this is nearly always the case if gaugino universality is assumed to hold above @xmath11 , and @xmath12 . on the other hand ,
if @xmath0 is an order of magnitude or more above @xmath11 ( with gaugino universality ) , the lightest superpartner becomes a mostly bino neutralino .
a viable low - energy spectrum can be obtained in this way @xcite . for @xmath13 ,
a neutralino lsp can be obtained by relaxing the requirement that all soft scalar terms vanish at @xmath0 .
one such generalization that does not re - introduce a flavor problem is to allow the higgs soft masses @xmath14 and @xmath15 to be non - zero at @xmath0 .
these soft masses contribute to the running of the slepton masses through a hypercharge fayet - iliopoulos @xmath16-term , and can push the slepton masses above that of the lightest neutralino @xcite . in the present work , we study the phenomenology of the mssm subject to vanishing scalar soft terms .
we generalize our study by including non - vanishing higgs boson soft masses , as well as a higgs boson bilinear @xmath17 term .
this does not reintroduce a flavor problem .
inspired by grand - unified theories , we take our input scale to be @xmath11 , and demand universal gaugino masses at this scale . after imposing consistent electroweak symmetry breaking , the independent parameters of this theory , which we call higgs exempt no - scale ( hens ) supersymmetry , are m_1/2 , , m_h_u^2 , m_h_d^2 , sgn ( ) , where @xmath18 is the universal gaugino mass at @xmath11 , @xmath19 is the ratio of the higgs boson expectation values , @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the soft higgs masses at @xmath11 , and @xmath20 is the sign of the supersymmetric higgs bilinear @xmath9 term .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section [ theo ]
we motivate this scenario , and show how it can emerge in a number of different ways .
section [ mass ] discusses the low - energy mass spectrum of the model , the acceptable regions of parameter space , and the most important constraints on these regions . in section [ dark ]
we investigate the prospects for dark matter in the model , and discuss some of the potential signatures this might induce .
section [ coll ] contains an investigation of some of the potential collider signatures of the model at the tevatron and the lhc , as well as a discussion of the discovery prospects at these machines .
finally , section [ conc ] is reserved for our conclusions .
while this work was in preparation , we became aware of refs .
@xcite , which investigate the mass spectrum and dark matter prospects of gaugino mediation with unsuppressed higgs soft masses
. there is some overlap between their work and the material in sections [ mass ] and [ dark ] of this paper .
however , unlike refs @xcite , we allow negative higgs soft squared masses at the input scale @xcite , and have a more extensive discussion of the phenomenological constraints . on the other hand , they consider specific details of gaugino mediated models , and discuss the possibility of gravitino dark matter in more detail than we do .
our primary motivation for considering models with small scalar soft terms is data driven : they provide a simple and elegant reason for small flavor violations induced by supersymmetry .
even so , it is comforting that this framework can arise from a number of theoretical constructions . in this section
we describe some of these models , and discuss how they can be modified to allow for non - vanishing soft masses for the higgs fields . vanishing scalar soft terms
have traditionally been associated with no - scale models @xcite .
these models are attractive because the gravitino mass , and therefore the scale of supersymmetry breaking , is determined dynamically .
the basic assumption underlying no - scale constructions is that the effective superspace khler density and superpotential have the form @xcite & = & -3m_pl^2 + f(x ) + f^(x^ ) + g(,^),[g - noscale ] + & = & w(),where @xmath21 is a hidden sector field , @xmath22 represents a visible sector field , and @xmath23 is a holomorphic cubic function . with this form of the khler density and superpotential ,
the tree - level potential along the direction of the hidden sector field @xmath21 is flat , the gravitino mass , @xmath24 is undetermined , and no soft terms are generated for the visible sector scalars .
supersymmetry breaking is communicated to the visible sector by non - trivial @xmath21-dependent gauge kinetic functions , which generate gaugino soft masses on the order of @xmath24 .
the one - loop corrections from the gauginos lift the potential in the @xmath21 direction and fix the value of @xmath24 to lie close to the electroweak scale , which is determined dynamically by the large top yukawa coupling @xcite .
it is difficult to maintain @xmath25 in no - scale models if there are other larger scales in the theory because of the radiative corrections these contribute to the effective potential for @xmath24 @xcite .
if such large scales exist , such as in a gut , the heavy sector must be completely sequestered from the supersymmetry breaking , since in the supersymmetric limit , they do not alter the effective potential . within a gut where the higgs superfields are components of complete multiplets that also contain heavy fields , it is therefore essential to prevent these gut multiplets from obtaining a supersymmetry breaking mass .
having separated the higgs in this way , it is natural to sequester the other chiral multiplets as well .
this is the origin of the vanishing scalar soft terms in no - scale models .
gaugino masses can be induced by a non - minimal kinetic function for those and only those components of the gut vector multiplet that remain light .
thus if the higgs multiplets are components of a larger gut multiplet , of which some components develop gut scale masses , it is not possible to generate soft masses for the higgs fields without destabilizing @xmath24 . on the other hand ,
soft higgs masses might be possible in more general unification scenarios in which the higgs fields do not belong to complete gut multiplets @xcite .
the form of the no - scale khler density and superpotential , eq .
( [ g - noscale ] ) , is an input to these models .
such a form does arise to lowest order in several string- and m - theory constructions , but is typically corrected at higher orders @xcite . more generally , a superspace khler density in which the visible and hidden sectors appear as disjoint terms , as in eq . ( [ g - noscale ] ) ,
is said to be _ sequestered _
@xcite . a sequestered khler density and superpotential guarantees that no direct soft terms are generated .
this is a necessary ingredient for anomaly mediation @xcite .
complete sequestering can be obtained geometrically by confining the visible and hidden sectors to branes separated by an extra - dimensional bulk @xcite .
a partial sequestration can also be realized if the mssm gauge multiplets are allowed to propagate in the bulk , as in gaugino mediated supersymmetry breaking @xcite .
if so , the gauginos will develop soft masses through their local couplings to the hidden sector , while the soft terms of the chiral multiplets will only be generated by loops passing across the bulk .
the resulting supersymmetric spectrum at the compactification scale of the extra dimension is therefore close to the one we are interested in : non - zero gaugino masses , and much smaller soft scalar terms . by allowing the higgs multiplets to propagate in the bulk , non -
zero higgs soft terms can be generated as well .
this is perhaps the simplest way to realize the hens models we shall consider .
sequestering can also be realized in four dimensions through strongly - coupled conformal dynamics in the hidden sector @xcite . even without strong conformal
running , the contributions to the gaugino masses and the trilinear @xmath8 are naturally suppressed relative to the gravitino mass if there are no singlets in the hidden sector .
this is not true for the scalar soft masses , which are generated by terms like d^4^_i_j x^x _ i^*_j , [ softmass ] where @xmath26 is the messenger scale , @xmath21 is a hidden sector field , and @xmath27 is a visible field .
operators of the form of eq .
( [ softmass ] ) can be suppressed relative to the gravitino mass by strong conformal dynamics in the hidden sector that couples at the renormalizable level to @xmath21 @xcite . if all such soft mass contributions are sufficiently suppressed , and if there are no hidden sector singlets , the visible sector is sequestered and the leading contribution to the soft terms comes from anomaly mediation . by allowing singlets in the hidden sector , both gaugino masses and @xmath8 terms can be generated that are much larger than the anomaly - mediated terms @xcite .
this is close to , but not quite , the spectrum we are interested in , because it is unclear how to avoid suppressing the higgs soft masses while squashing the rest . a partial sequestration of soft terms , as well as an explanation for the yukawa hierarchy , can also be obtained from strong conformal dynamics in the visible sector @xcite . in these constructions , there is a new gauge group @xmath28 that approaches a strongly - coupled fixed point in the ir .
the mssm fields are not charged under @xmath28 , but they do couple to fields that are through cubic operators in the superpotential .
as the theory flows towards the fixed point , the mssm fields develop large anomalous dimensions which suppress their corresponding ( physical ) yukawa couplings .
since different ( linear combinations of ) fields develop distinct anomalous dimensions , related to their effective superconformal @xmath5 charges , a yukawa hierarchy can be generated in this way @xcite .
the conformal running also produces a general suppression of the soft scalar masses , as well as a hierarchy of trilinear @xmath8 terms that mirrors the yukawa couplings @xcite .
conversely , the gaugino masses are largely unaffected because they do not couple directly to the strongly - coupled sector .
the third generation multiplets and the higgs multiplets must also be shielded from the conformal running effects to avoid suppressing the top quark yukawa coupling . as a result , the third generation and
the higgs soft masses do not get suppressed .
thus , the spectrum from visible sector conformal running is similar to one we shall consider , but augmented by third generation soft masses and @xmath8 terms .
we expect the phenomenology of both scenarios to be similar over much of the allowed parameter space . from the discussion above
, we see that a hens soft mass spectrum can arise from gaugino mediation with the higgs multiplets in the bulk , or from conformal running in the hidden sector up to additional contributions to the third generation states . before proceeding
, however , let us comment on our choice of @xmath11 as the input scale for the soft spectrum . in gaugino mediation ,
the input scale is on the order of the compactification scale , @xmath29 .
, is less than the cutoff of the theory . ] for visible - sector conformal running , the input scale for the soft spectrum is the scale at which the conformal running ceases , which we will also call @xmath29 .
our motivation to set @xmath30 is partly conventional , but is also motivated by gauge unification and our wish to strongly suppress the scalar soft masses . in both cases ,
gauge unification can be preserved with @xmath31 , but the process will be more complicated than in the standard picture . in gaugino mediation , kaluza - klein states appear above @xmath29 and can lead to an accelerated power - law running @xcite . with conformal dynamics in the visible sector , the sm gauge coupling beta functions will be modified by the large anomalous dimensions of the mssm fields .
gauge unification will still occur , albeit at a lower scale , provided the conformal dynamics respects a global symmetry into which the sm gauge group can be embedded @xcite .
thus , in each case having @xmath29 below @xmath11 can induce an effective unification of the sm gauge couplings below the apparent unification scale @xmath32 .
this is problematic for many gut completions of the mssm , which predict baryon and lepton number violation .
typically , some additional structure is needed if @xmath29 is much smaller than @xmath11 .
this motivates us to consider @xmath33 .
it is clear that gauge unification can also be maintained with @xmath34 .
if @xmath29 is larger than @xmath11 , the renormalization group running from @xmath29 down to @xmath11 will induce non - vanishing ( flavor - universal ) soft masses at @xmath11 .
the size of these corrections from running above @xmath11 depends on the precise @xmath35 completion of the theory , but even for minimal @xmath35 models they can be significant , on the order of @xcite a & & c_a ( ) m_1/2,[abovemg ] + m^2 & & c_m^2 ( ) m_1/2 ^ 2,where @xmath36 is the gut coupling , and @xmath37 and @xmath38 are dimensionless constants on the order of or slightly larger than unity .
these contributions can be large enough for an acceptable low - energy spectrum to be obtained @xcite .
on the other hand , in both gaugino mediation and conformal sequestering , @xmath29 can not be more than about an order of magnitude above @xmath11 because the suppression of soft terms ( and yukawa couplings ) requires a separation of scales .
let @xmath39 be the scale at which conformal running begins in the case of conformal dynamics , or the @xmath40 cutoff of the extra - dimensional gauge theory in gaugino mediation .
presumably @xmath41 .
the amount of suppression of the soft scalar terms from conformal running is expected to be an order - one power of @xmath42 , whereas the required suppression is typically on the order of @xmath43 @xcite .
an even stronger upper bound on @xmath0 can be obtained if the conformal dynamics are responsible for the small electron yukawa coupling as in ref .
the condition for this is y_e ( ) ( ) ^(_l+_e)/2 , where @xmath44 denote the anomalous dimensions of @xmath45 and @xmath46 , which are generally smaller than 2 .
if we take this bound seriously , @xmath29 can be at most only slightly larger than @xmath11 .
in gaugino mediation , flavor - mixing contact interactions between the mssm chiral multiplets and hidden sector operators , arising from bulk states with masses above the uv cutoff scale , are suppressed by a factor of @xmath47 @xcite .
again this factor must be less than about @xmath43 to avoid various experimental flavor constraints , which translates into @xmath0 being within an order of magnitude larger than @xmath11 ( for @xmath48 ) . given the above considerations , we will set @xmath30 throughout this paper , and not concern ourselves with the precise mechanism by which the scalar soft terms are suppressed .
while beyond the scope of the present work , it also interesting to speculate that the breaking of the gut symmetry is related to the geometry of the extra dimension , or the escape from conformal running .
such a construction would further justify our choice of @xmath30 .
finally , let us also note that within particular models there is typically some residual flavor violation due to an incomplete suppression of the scalar terms at @xmath29 .
the amount of flavor suppression can be close to the level probed by current experiments .
however , without specifying a particular model , it is not possible to perform an analysis of the constraints due to flavor physics .
thus , we assume as our starting point that at the scale @xmath49 , all scalar masses except those of the higgs bosons are precisely zero and that corrections to that assumption are inconsequential to the phenomenology discussed below .
the essential features of the hens mass spectrum are well illustrated by a simple one - loop analysis . at this order ,
the ratio @xmath50 , @xmath51 , is scale invariant for all three gaugino masses .
if the gauge couplings unify and the gaugino masses are universal at @xmath11 , it follows that at lower scales q , @xmath52 ^ 2 m_{1/2}$ ] . for @xmath53
, this gives m_1 ( 0.43)m_1/2 , m_2 ( 0.83)m_1/2 , m_3 ( 2.6)m_1/2.[2:m12 ] the one - loop running of the scalar soft masses is given by @xcite ( 4)^2 x_i -8_ac^a_ig_a^2|m_a|^2 + g_1 ^ 2y_is , [ 2:msoftrun ] where @xmath54 depends on the soft masses and @xmath8 terms and is usually proportional to yukawa couplings , @xmath55 is the quadratic casimir for the representation @xmath56 under gauge group @xmath57 , and s = ( m_h_u^2-m_h_d^2 ) + tr_f(m_q^2 - 2m_u^2+m_e^2+m_d^2-m_l^2 ) , [ 2:sterm ] with the trace above running over flavors .
at one - loop order , the rg equation for the @xmath58 term is particularly simple , ( 4)^2 = g_1 ^ 2s .
because of this simple form , the effect of the @xmath58-term on the low - scale soft masses is to simply shift the value they would have with @xmath59 by the amount m_i^2 = -s_gut -(0.052)y_is_gut , where @xmath60 evaluated at @xmath11 . neglecting yukawa effects ,
the low - scale slepton soft masses at @xmath61 are m_l^2 & & ^2 + ( 0.052)s_gut , [ 2:mslepton ] + m_e^2 & & ^2 - ( 0.052)s_gut . if mixing effects are small , the physical slepton masses will be close to @xmath62 and @xmath63 , up to the @xmath3 @xmath16-term contributions .
the mass of the lightest neutralino is usually close to @xmath64 ( under the assumption of gaugino universality ) unless @xmath9 is relatively small . comparing eq . with eq .
, we see that for @xmath65 , @xmath66 is less than @xmath64 and the lightest superpartner tends to be a mostly right - handed slepton . on the other hand , if @xmath67 , the right - handed slepton soft mass is pushed up relative to @xmath64 , allowing for a mostly bino neutralino lsp . for @xmath68
very large and negative , the lsp can be a mostly left - handed slepton .
relative to the sleptons and the electroweak gauginos , the squarks and gluino are very heavy because the @xmath1 gauge coupling grows large in the infrared . to confirm the simple analysis given above , we have performed a scan over the hens parameter space using suspect 2.34 @xcite .
this code performs the renormalization group running at two - loop order with one - loop threshold effects , and includes radiative and mixing corrections to the physical particle masses .
we take @xmath69 @xcite and @xmath70 gev @xcite in our analysis . for each model parameter point
we require consistent electroweak symmetry breaking , and superpartner masses above the lep ii and tevatron bounds ( @xmath71 gev , @xmath72 , @xmath73 ) .
we also impose the lower - energy constraints & & [ -8,24]10 ^ -4 @xcite + br(bs ) & & [ 3.0,4.0]10 ^ -4 @xcite + a _ & & [ -5,50]10 ^ -10 @xcitethese ranges correspond approximately to the @xmath74 allowed values , although we have allowed a slightly larger range for @xmath75 .
the constraint from the muon magnetic moment is particularly interesting in hens scenarios , and we shall discuss it more extensively below . in the immediate analysis
we do not include the lep ii bound on the lightest higgs boson mass .
we will discuss this constraint below as well . and
the differently colored regions in the figure indicate the identity of the lightest superpartner .
the quantities @xmath14 and @xmath15 are evaluated at the input scale @xmath11.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] and @xmath77 .
the differently colored regions in the figure indicate the identity of the lightest superpartner .
the quantities @xmath14 and @xmath15 are evaluated at the input scale @xmath11.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] and @xmath77 .
the differently colored regions in the figure indicate the identity of the lightest superpartner .
the quantities @xmath14 and @xmath15 are evaluated at the input scale @xmath11.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] figures [ lsp-10 - 300 ] , [ lsp-10 - 500 ] , and [ lsp-30 - 500 ] show the allowed regions of @xmath78 and @xmath79 , for @xmath80 equal to @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 , subject to the constraints described above .
the soft higgs masses in these plots are re - expressed in terms of the more convenient combinations @xmath84 , and @xmath85 , where @xmath86 denotes the signed square root ( @xmath87 ) .
also shown in these plots is the identity of the lightest superpartner at each allowed parameter point .
these figures confirm our previous approximate analysis .
when @xmath68 is positive or zero , the lsp is a mostly right - handed stau or selectron . as @xmath68 becomes more negative
, a neutralino becomes the lsp , while for very large and negative values of @xmath68 the lsp is a sneutrino . for
extremely large positive or negative values of @xmath68 , one of the slepton soft masses becomes tachyonic .
the allowed parameter region is cut off at larger positive values of @xmath88 because @xmath89 only has a negative solution , implying that electroweak symmetry breaking is not possible .
reaches zero by the @xmath90 and the chargino mass constraints .
] note that in fig .
[ lsp-10 - 500 ] , there is a thin strip along the upper border of the allowed region in which the lsp is a neutralino . in this strip ,
the @xmath9 term is smaller than @xmath64 and the neutralino lsp is mostly higgsino . for larger negative values of @xmath88 , @xmath91 and
the parameter space gets cut off by the bound from @xmath90 .
as @xmath88 becomes even smaller , electroweak symmetry breaking ceases to occur .
the effects of the @xmath92 yukawa coupling and left - right mixing can be seen by comparing figs .
[ lsp-10 - 500 ] and [ lsp-30 - 500 ] . in the models we are considering , the value of the yukawa - dependent term in eq . for the right - handed stau soft mass is x_e_3 2|y_|^2m_h_d^2 .
the left - right mixing is also proportional to the @xmath92 yukawa . as @xmath19 increases ,
so too does the @xmath92 yukawa , and therefore also the yukawa effect on the running and the mixing .
left - right mixing tends to push the lighter stau mass lower , and for this reason it is more difficult to obtain a neutralino lsp at larger values of @xmath19 . however , there is also a competing effect from the influence of the @xmath92 yukawa on the running of @xmath93 .
when @xmath15 is large and negative , the @xmath94 term increases the value of @xmath93 at low energies .
thus , a selectron or an electron sneutrino is the lsp in some parts of the parameter space . in parts of the parameter space shown in figs .
[ lsp-10 - 300]-[lsp-30 - 500 ] the value of @xmath14 is large and negative , while the slepton soft masses are considerably smaller in magnitude ( but positive ) . in these regions , it is likely that the standard mssm minimum is only metastable , and that a deeper charge - breaking minimum exists at large field values @xcite .
the precise constraints on the existence of such non - standard global minima depend on the details of the thermal history of the universe @xcite , and we do not investigate them in the present work .
however , a necessary condition is that the lifetime of the metastable mssm vacuum at @xmath95 should be greater than the age of the universe . while beyond the scope of the present work , it is possible that some regions of the parameter space shown in figs . [ lsp-10 - 300]-[lsp-30 - 500 ] , especially the lower left region and at larger values of @xmath19 , may not be populated after a more detailed analysis .
since the sleptons in hens models are relatively light , the corrections to the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon , @xmath97 can be significant @xcite .
currently , the measured value of @xmath98 exceeds the sm prediction by about two standard deviations @xcite , a _ = a_^exp - a_^sm = ( 2210)10 ^ -10 .
this result is suggestive of new physics . in the mssm
, there are additional contributions to @xmath99 from loops involving a virtual chargino and muon sneutrino , and loops with a virtual neutralino and smuon . for the hens scenarios we are studying ,
in which all masses scale predominantly with @xmath18 and the gaugino masses are universal ( and assumed real and positive ) , the leading supersymmetry contribution to @xmath98 is proportional to @xmath19 , scales roughly as @xmath100 , and has a sign equal to the sign of the @xmath9 term , @xmath20 @xcite .
given the tension between the measured value of @xmath75 and the sm prediction , @xmath101 is strongly favored .
indeed , we find that negative @xmath20 is only possible for very large values of @xmath18 .
conversely , if @xmath20 is positive the new supersymmetric contribution can help to explain this possible discrepancy between the sm prediction and experiment . as a function of @xmath18 for several ranges of @xmath19 , and @xmath101 .
the spread of points come from scanning over the acceptable input values of @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the red points indicate @xmath102 , the green points @xmath103 , the blue points @xmath104 , and the magenta points @xmath105 .
, scaledwidth=70.0% ] the value of @xmath106 is shown as a function of @xmath18 in fig .
[ g2-mu ] . in generating this figure ,
we have taken @xmath101 , and have scanned over input values of @xmath14 and @xmath15 at @xmath11 .
the distribution for @xmath107 looks the same , except the sign of @xmath108 is opposite . with @xmath109 ,
the new physics contribution is frequently too large , and from this we obtain a lower bound on @xmath18 as a function of @xmath19 . for @xmath110 ,
this bound is @xmath111 , while for @xmath112 , it increases to @xmath113 . plane of solutions that respect the bounds of @xmath114 and @xmath115 . due to uncertainty in the top quark mass , and the theoretical uncertainty in the computation of @xmath116 , a more conservative constraint on this theoretically computed value of @xmath116 is @xmath117 , which is also shown in the figure.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] a further constraint on hens models , and one we have not yet imposed , is that the sm higgs boson mass should exceed the lep ii bound @xcite , m_h > 114.4 .
this bound also applies to the lightest cp - even higgs boson in much of the parameter space of the mssm .
however at tree - level in the mssm , the lightest cp - even higgs boson has a mass below @xmath118 .
it is only because of large loop corrections to the mass , predominantly due to the scalar tops , that this higgs state can be raised above the lep ii bound . with vanishing input scalar soft masses , the stop masses scale with @xmath18 .
the higgs boson mass bound therefore imposes a further lower bound on the universal input gaugino mass .
the combined bounds on @xmath18 as a function of @xmath19 from the conditions @xmath119 and @xmath120 gev are shown in fig .
[ tanb - m12 ] .
we impose a slightly weaker @xmath117 lower bound on the higgs boson mass than the @xmath121 lep ii bound to account for various uncertainties associated with the theoretical computation of @xmath116 .
we have taken @xmath122 in our analysis . at smaller @xmath19 ,
less than about 15 , the higgs mass bound imposes the stronger constraint , while the upper bound on @xmath75 is more significant for values of @xmath123 . for any value of @xmath19
, @xmath18 must be greater than about @xmath124 gev if we impose the weaker higgs mass bound ( @xmath125 gev ) , and larger than about @xmath126 gev to satisfy the stronger bound ( @xmath127 gev ) .
note that as @xmath18 grows , the phenomenological constraints on the model tend to weaken , but usually at the cost of increased fine - tuning in the higgs sector @xcite .
in the previous section , we found that in a large region of the hens parameter space a slepton or a sneutrino is the lsp .
such an lsp can be problematic for cosmology .
if the lsp is a charged slepton , the very strong constraints that exist for charged stable particles imply that such a scenario is all but ruled out @xcite .
these bounds do not apply to a sneutrino lsp , but in this case the direct detection rate is much too high ( for a mass of @xmath128 ) @xcite . without invoking some additional and interesting mechanisms that allow the sneutrino as a more viable lsp @xcite
, we will focus on the case of a neutralino lsp . also ,
a slepton as the lightest superpartner particle , charged or not , may still provide a consistent picture of dark matter if the gravitino is the lsp @xcite .
we will comment briefly on that possibility later .
we investigate the relic density of neutralino lsps at various points in the allowed parameter space with the aid of darksusy 4.1 @xcite .
this computer program performs a fully relativistic computation of the relic density , and includes all relevant coannhilation channels .
figures [ 10 - 300 ] and [ 10 - 500 ] show the neutralino lsp relic density for @xmath110 , @xmath129 gev and @xmath126 gev , and @xmath130 for the full range of allowed input values of @xmath14 and @xmath15 at @xmath49 . in both figures
the black plus signs indicate the regions in which the lightest neutralino is not the lsp , but that are otherwise allowed .
the red triangles correspond to parameter points where the neutralino relic density is acceptably small , @xmath131 .
this is to be compared with the observed dark matter density @xcite , h^2 = 0.1045^+0.0072_-0.0095 ( ) . in the blue , green , and magenta regions , the neutralino relic density exceeds @xmath132 .
these regions can still be consistent with the wmap measurements if there is a late - time injection of entropy into the universe after the neutralinos have frozen out @xcite . , @xmath129 gev , and @xmath133 .
the region in which the lightest neutralino is not the lsp is denoted by the black plus signs .
the red triangles indicate parameter points where the neutralino lsp relic density is less than @xmath131 . in the blue and green regions ,
the neutralino lsp relic density exceeds this value.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] , @xmath134 gev , and @xmath133 .
the region in which the lightest neutralino is not the lsp is denoted by the black plus signs .
the red triangles indicate parameter points where the neutralino lsp relic density is less than @xmath131 . in the blue , green , and magenta regions ,
the neutralino lsp relic density exceeds this value.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] the shape of the neutralino relic density contours in figs . [
10 - 300]-[10 - 500 ] can be understood in terms of the mass spectrum of the model . in most of the parameter space ,
the lightest neutralino is predominantly bino .
the main annihilation channels in this bulk region are @xmath135-channel slepton exchanges .
this is not efficient enough to reduce the relic density to an acceptable level for the values of @xmath18 that are relevant , although it does come close for @xmath129 gev . along the left and right edges of the neutralino region , the mass of the neutralino lsp approaches that of the lightest slepton .
this near degeneracy allows for coannihilation between the neutralino lsp and the lightest slepton to become effective , pushing the neutralino relic density to a value well below the wmap value .
moving away from these edges towards the bulk region , the coannihilation efficiency falls off quickly , roughly as @xmath136 $ ] , and the neutralino density goes up . in this transitional region , where slepton coannihilation is only moderately efficient , the correct dark matter density is obtained .
the strip of low relic density along the top of the neutralino lsp region arises because the @xmath9 parameter becomes small . in this strip ,
the neutralino lsp develops a significant higgsino component allowing it to annihilate effectively through gauge bosons , and by coannihilation with the lightest chargino . , @xmath134 gev , and @xmath133 .
the region in which the lightest neutralino is not the lsp is denoted by the black plus signs .
the red triangles indicate parameter points where the neutralino lsp relic density is less than @xmath131 . in the blue , green , and magenta regions ,
the neutralino lsp relic density exceeds this value.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] in the regions where the lightest neutralino is not the lightest sm superpartner ( denoted by black plus signs in figs .
[ 10 - 300]-[10 - 500 ] ) the lightest superpartner is always a slepton . on the left - hand side of the neutralino region
, this particle is either a tau or an electron sneutrino , as illustrated in figs .
[ lsp-10 - 300]-[lsp-30 - 500 ] . on the right ,
the lightest superpartner is a mostly right - handed stau or selectron .
the annihilation of sleptons is very efficient in the early universe .
if such a particle were stable , the relic density in the regions discussed above would be on the order of @xmath137 .
a relic density of heavy charged particles of this size is firmly ruled out by direct searches @xcite . even for a stable sneutrino , a relic density of this size
is ruled out by dark matter direct detection searches @xcite .
a charged or neutral slepton lighter than the lightest neutralino may still be acceptable provided the gravitino is the true lsp . since the gravitino couples very weakly to the mssm states , the slepton nlsp would freeze out as if it were the lsp , and decay into gravitinos at a much later time . the final gravitino density produced by these decays
is determined by the quasi - stable nlsp density , @xmath138 , through the relation @xcite _
3/2^decay h^2 = _ h^2 , where @xmath24 is the gravitino mass . in the parameter regions we are considering , this density is too small to account for all the dark matter if nlsp decays are the only source of relic gravitinos .
however , there are other possible sources of relic gravitinos , such as thermal production after inflationary reheating @xcite and non - thermal production through heavy particle decays @xcite that can bring the total gravitino relic density up to the value needed to explain all the dark matter .
let us also note that this scenario is constrained by the requirement that the late - time decays not overly disrupt the predictions of big - bang nucleosynthesis or the black - body spectrum of the cosmic microwave background radiation .
these constraints are relatively weak for a sneutrino nlsp , but they are quite severe for a charged slepton ( or neutralino ) nlsp , and require @xmath139 mev for most of the range of nlsp masses we are considering @xcite . we have also examined the effect of varying @xmath19 on the predictions for dark matter within the model .
smaller values of this ratio , @xmath140 , do not change the qualitative features of the picture described above . for @xmath141
, there are a couple of important changes .
most importantly , larger values of @xmath19 induce more mixing between the left- and right - handed staus , which has the effect of lowering the mass of the lightest stau . because of this , for @xmath112 and @xmath134 gev there is no longer an acceptable region of parameter space in which the lightest neutralino is both the lightest superpartner , and mostly higgsino . in fig .
[ 30 - 500 ] we plot the neutralino lsp relic density for @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath133 .
the thin slice of acceptable @xmath144 arises due to the coannihilation of the lsp with a light slepton .
the prospects for direct and indirect detection of neutralino dark matter were investigated using darksusy 4.1 @xcite . for the most part ,
the direct and indirect detection signals within our scenario are very similar to those of a generic msugra model with a mostly bino lsp @xcite . in general , these potential signals are very weak .
however , much stronger signals can arise when the neutralino lsp has a significant higgsino component . and @xmath134 gev .
the black plus signs indicate the parameter region that is consistent with various phenomenological constraints , but need not have a neutralino lsp .
the red , green , blue , magenta points indicate parameter points for which a neutralino is the lsp , for several ranges of @xmath145.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] dark matter in the local halo can be detected directly by its elastic scattering with heavy nuclei .
the most strongly constrained neutralino - nucleus cross - sections are the spin - independent ones .
it is conventional to express the experimental limits on these cross - sections in terms of an effective neutralino - proton cross - section .
the values of the effective spin - independent cross - sections in the present model , for @xmath110 and @xmath18 = 500 gev , are shown in fig .
[ dd-10 - 500 ] .. ] except in a thin strip at the top of the allowed region , where the neutralino lsp is predominantly higgsino , these cross - sections are much smaller than the current experimental bound ( for a standard set of assumptions about the local halo density ) of @xmath146 pb @xcite for the range of neutralino masses we consider here . the scattering cross - sections in the higgsino region are within an order of magnitude this bound . and @xmath129 , 500 , and 700 gev , as well as for @xmath112 and @xmath147 , as a function of the ratio @xmath148 .
the current experimental limit for standard assumptions about the local halo density is @xmath146 pb for the range of neutralino masses we consider here @xcite . , scaledwidth=70.0% ] spin - independent scattering between a neutralino and a nucleon
is mediated predominantly by the exchange of cp - even higgs bosons and squarks . in the allowed parameter regions discussed above
, the squarks tend to be much heavier than the neutralino lsp , thereby suppressing their contribution .
thus , the leading contribution to the spin - independent neutralino - nucleon cross - section usually comes from cp - even higgs exchange .
since the neutralino higgs vertices are proportional to the higgsino component of the neutralino , the effective cross - section depends sensitively on the ratio @xmath148 .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ dd - mu - m1 ] for @xmath110 and @xmath149 gev , as well as for @xmath112 and @xmath147 .
the dependence on other parameters such as @xmath150 and @xmath151 is much weaker . and @xmath134 gev
. a detector threshold of 1gev is assumed .
the best current bound is @xmath152 coming from super - kamiokande @xcite .
future sensitivities from icecube and antares are @xmath153 . , scaledwidth=70.0% ]
relic neutralinos can also be searched for indirectly by looking for their annihilation products in regions where they tend to clump , and have a local density much larger than the average value . in these particularly dense patches ,
the rate of neutralino annihilation can become large enough that their products are potentially observable .
the most stringent of these indirect detection constraints on neutralino dark matter usually comes from their annihilation in the core of the sun and the earth .- channel cp - odd higgs resonance . ]
the neutrinos produced by this process can lead to a signal , in the form of a muon flux , in neutrino telescopes .
the best current bound on such a muon flux comes from the super - kamiokande experiment @xcite , and is on the order of @xmath152 .
this sensitivity or bound is expected to be tightened to @xmath154 in the next few years by icecube @xcite and antares @xcite .
the values of @xmath155 due to annihilation in both the core of the earth and the sun in the present model with @xmath110 and @xmath134 gev are shown in fig .
[ muflux ] as a function of the ratio @xmath148 , assuming a detector threshold of @xmath156 . as for the direct detection signal ,
the largest indirect detection signal is obtained when @xmath148 is on the order of unity and the neutralino lsp has a significant higgsino component .
in fact , for @xmath157 , the signal as at or slightly above the super - kamiokande bound . for larger values of @xmath148
the signal falls off very quickly to values that are well below the reach of upcoming experiments .
in hens scenarios , the sleptons and the electroweak gauginos are generally very light relative to the squarks and the gluino . if the lightest neutralino is the lsp , which we assume throughout this section , the distinguishing feature of these scenarios at colliders are multi - lepton events with missing @xmath158 . in this section
we discuss the prospects for discovery and identification of hens models at the tevatron and the lhc .
the most promising search channel at the tevatron is the trilepton signal with missing @xmath158 @xcite .
this can be induced , for example , by the electroweak production of @xmath159 , with subsequent cascades of the form @xmath160 and @xmath161 .
for @xmath162 , the significant source of susy events comes from the electroweak production of gauginos , making this channel a copious and clean one . in hens scenarios ,
the @xmath163 and @xmath164 states tend to be mostly wino and have two - body decays into left - handed sleptons . because of this feature , the branching fractions of the abovementioned decay cascades can be significant , leading to a sizeable trilepton cross - section .
indeed , the mass spectrum derived from hens models is close to being optimal for trilepton production . to estimate the effective tevatron trilepton cross - sections , we have simulated susy production from @xmath165 collisions at @xmath166 tev using isajet 7.74 @xcite . following the treatment in ref .
@xcite , we use the isajet subroutines calsim and calini ( in the isaplt package ) as a simple detector model with coverage in the range @xmath167 , and calorimeter cells of size @xmath168 . to simulate energy resolution uncertainties ,
the electromagnetic calorimeter cells are smeared by an amount @xmath169 , while the hadronic calorimeter cells are smeared by an amount @xmath170 .
we define jets as hadronic clusters with @xmath171 gev within a cone of size @xmath172 , and use the getjet subroutine to perform the clustering .
isolated leptons are defined to be @xmath173 s or @xmath9 s having @xmath174 gev , with net visible hadronic activity @xmath175 gev within a cone of size @xmath176 about the lepton direction .
we focus on a particular set of cuts , corresponding to the hc2 set in ref .
@xcite , that is well - suited to the hens mass spectrum @xcite . in each event
, we require three isolated leptons with @xmath177 , and @xmath178 .
in addition to this , the total missing @xmath158 must exceed @xmath179 gev , the invariant mass of same - flavor opposite - sign dileptons must lie in the range @xmath180 , and the transverse invariant mass between each lepton and the missing @xmath158 vector must lie outside the range @xmath181 .
the dilepton invariant mass veto is designed to remove background events from off - shell @xmath182 and @xmath183 decays , while the @xmath184 veto removes leptons from @xmath23 decays . with these cuts ,
the sm background is estimated to be @xmath185 @xcite , and is due mostly to the remaining @xmath186 and @xmath187 events in which both off - shell gauge bosons decay leptonically . and @xmath110 .
the estimated background is @xmath188
, scaledwidth=70.0% ] in fig .
[ tevscan ] we show the trilepton cross - section subject to the cuts for @xmath129 gev and @xmath110 .
this value of @xmath18 is about as small as possible within the model given the lower bound on the light higgs boson mass , and represents a best - case scenario at the tevatron .
note that for considerably larger values of @xmath19 , the constraint from the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon requires larger values of @xmath18 as well , as can be seen in fig .
[ tanb - m12 ] . like in the previous plots ,
the values of @xmath14 and @xmath15 in fig .
[ tevscan ] are those at the input scale , @xmath30 . the dependence of the trilepton cross - section on @xmath14 and @xmath15 can be understood in terms of the mass spectrum .
except in the upper - right portion of the allowed parameter space , the effective cross - section increases smoothly from bottom to top as the value of @xmath9 decreases . in most of the parameter space , @xmath9 is larger than @xmath189 and the @xmath163 and @xmath190 states are mostly wino . as @xmath9 approaches @xmath189 ,
these states develop a larger higgsino fraction and their masses are reduced by the mixing .
the heavier chargino and neutralino states become lighter as well . on account of these effects ,
the total gaugino cross section is increased leading to more trilepton events .
this pattern is broken in the upper right corner of the parameter space because the mass of the @xmath163 state approaches the left - handed slepton masses from above , again due to higgsino mixing . when this mass difference becomes small
, the branching fraction for @xmath191 goes down .
the leptons produced by the cascades become relatively soft as well .
since this decay mode plays a prominent role in the trilepton signal subject to the hc2 cuts , the effective cross - section falls off rapidly when the decay fraction is suppressed .
the effective cross - section in this region can be increased by using slightly weaker lepton @xmath192 cuts , such as the sc2 set discussed in ref .
@xcite , but at the expense of an increase in background .
the effective trilepton cross - sections shown in fig .
[ tevscan ] fall within the range of @xmath193 .
given the estimated background of @xmath194 , the signal significance level is marginal .
for example , the poisson probability @xmath195 for a total of ten events , corresponding to the maximal expected signal and background with @xmath196 , is about @xmath197 .
while this is unfortunately not enough for a discovery , an excess of clean trilepton events at the tevatron would provide a tantalizing hint of a light hens scenario .
we also note that other event signatures involving leptons can be searched for in these scenarios .
of particular noteworthiness is the same - sign dilepton signature , which has small standard model background .
if nature is supersymmetric and has a hens spectrum , the prospects for discovery at the lhc with @xmath198 of data are excellent provided @xmath18 is less than about 700 gev . to quantify this , we focus on six inclusive lhc susy search channels , classified by the number of isolated leptons in the event : @xmath199 ; @xmath200 ; @xmath201 ; @xmath202 ; @xmath203 ; @xmath204 @xcite .
( here , @xmath205 and @xmath206 refer to opposite - sign and same - sign dileptons , respectively . ) besides an excess of events in these channels , which is expected in many susy scenarios , the relative numbers of events within different channels can point towards small input scalar soft masses .
supersymmetric events at the lhc were simulated using isajet 7.74 @xcite .
we use the isajet subroutines calsim and calini ( in the isaplt package ) as a simple detector model with coverage in the range @xmath207 , and calorimeter cells of size @xmath208 . a gaussian smearing of the calorimeter cells
is included to simulate energy resolution uncertainties .
the electromagnetic calorimeter cells are smeared by an amount @xmath209 , where @xmath210 denotes addition in quadrature .
hadronic calorimeter cells are smeared by an amount @xmath211 for @xmath212 , and @xmath213 for @xmath214 .
we define jets as clusters with @xmath215 gev and @xmath212 within a cone of size @xmath172 , and use the getjet subroutine to perform the clustering .
isolated leptons are defined to be @xmath173 s or @xmath9 s having @xmath216 gev and @xmath217 , with total visible activity @xmath218 gev within a cone of size @xmath219 about the lepton direction . for all channels studied ,
we choose a cut energy @xmath220 and demand that each event have at least two hard jets , @xmath221 , with @xmath222 , as well as missing transverse energy @xmath223 .
this cut substantially reduces the sm backgrounds relative to the susy signals .
would be preferable to reduce the large sm backgrounds in the @xmath224 channel .
however , the @xmath225 susy signal is still easily distinguishable from the large background for the parameter points we consider here . ]
we also require that the transverse sphericity of the event satisfies @xmath226 to reduce the dijet background @xcite . in zero - lepton events , we demand that the transverse angle between the missing momentum vector and the nearest jet must lie in the range @xmath227 . in the one - lepton channel , we require a single isolated lepton with @xmath228 , as well as @xmath229 to reduce the leptonic @xmath23 background . for events with two or more isolated leptons , we demand that @xmath230 for the two hardest leptons . and @xmath110 for the five sample points described in the text . for comparison ,
the sm backgrounds are estimated to be about @xmath231 , @xmath232 , @xmath233 , @xmath234 , @xmath235 , and @xmath236 for the @xmath225 , @xmath237 , @xmath238 , @xmath239 , @xmath240 and @xmath241 channels respectively @xcite.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] the cross sections after cuts for @xmath242 and @xmath110 are given in fig .
[ lhcbar ] for five sample points . for comparison ,
the sm backgrounds are estimated to be about @xmath243 , @xmath244 , @xmath245 , @xmath246 , @xmath247 , and @xmath248 for the @xmath225 , @xmath237 , @xmath238 , @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath241 channels respectively @xcite .
the locations of the sample points , @xmath249 and @xmath250 , in the @xmath251 plane are listed in the appendix , and are also indicated in figs . [ 10 - 500-scan-3l ] and [ 10 - 500-scan-1l ] . among the five sample points ,
@xmath8 and @xmath252 have a neutralino relic density within the wmap allowed range , while the other points lead to relic densities that are too large ( but could be acceptable with a non - standard cosmology ) . at point e ,
the @xmath9 term is on the same order as @xmath253 , but it is greater than @xmath254 at the other sample points .
thus , except for point e , the lsp is a mostly bino neutralino , while the lightest chargino and the next - to - lightest neutralino are predominantly wino . at point
e where @xmath255 , all the chargino and neutralino states are fairly light and have significant higgsino components , which , as we shall discuss below , is the reason for the increase in the @xmath240 and @xmath241 rates .
cross - sections after cuts at the lhc for @xmath256 and @xmath110 .
the estimated background is @xmath247.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] in each of the six search channels , the susy signal is easily distinguishable from the background with @xmath257 of luminosity at the lhc .
a more challenging task beyond an initial discovery is to distinguish this class of models from other ( susy ) scenarios and to deduce the model parameters .
the number of leptonic events relative to the number of @xmath224 events is useful in this regard .
compared to a generic msugra input spectrum with @xmath258 , the ratio of @xmath259 events to @xmath224 events is much larger for a given value of @xmath18 .
for example , in msugra with @xmath260 , the ratio of @xmath261 to @xmath259 events is greater than four , whereas this ratio is close to unity for all five sample points considered .
the ratio of the number of @xmath224 events to the number of @xmath262 events is also much larger in a generic msugra framework than it is here .
this is the consequence of having left - handed sleptons lighter than the @xmath163 and @xmath164 states , which are in turn light enough to be generated by squark decays .
for example , cascade chains such as @xmath263 have a significant branching probability , and are a rich source of leptons .
the dependence of the effective @xmath240 cross - section on the input higgs soft mass parameters is shown in fig .
[ 10 - 500-scan-3l ] . for the most part ,
this dependence is fairly mild except in the upper right portion of the allowed region . here
, the @xmath9 term approaches the bino mass @xmath64 , and in the thin tail extending to the right , @xmath9 even falls below @xmath64 . in this region , all the neutralinos and charginos are significantly lighter than the squarks and gluinos . as a result ,
the decay cascades initiated by the strong superpartners are frequently very long , involving several chargino and neutralino states . at each step in the cascade chain
there is a chance of producing a lepton , and thus the total fraction of events containing multiple leptons is very high .
for example , the decay chain @xmath264 is kinematically allowed when @xmath9 is small , and has a significant branching fraction .
the preponderance of leptons can be so high that the number of @xmath225 and @xmath237 events ( and even to some extent some @xmath265 events ) are significantly suppressed .
this can be seen in fig .
[ 10 - 500-scan-1l ] , which shows the @xmath237 effective cross section for @xmath147 and @xmath110 .
note that the small @xmath9 region is strongly constrained by direct and indirect searches for dark matter , and will be probed by upcoming experiments , as was discussed above .
cross - sections after cuts at the lhc for @xmath256 and @xmath110 .
the estimated background is @xmath244.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] in the leftmost portion of the allowed region of fig .
[ 10 - 500-scan-3l ] , there is also a net decrease in the cross section , which occurs in the other leptonic channels as well . within this region ,
leptons typically originate from decays of the mostly wino @xmath163 and @xmath164 states into left - handed sleptons and sneutrinos , which subsequently decay into the neutralino lsp .
however , these left - handed states are only slightly heavier than the lsp , so the lepton emitted from the slepton decays tends to be soft , making it less likely to pass the lepton @xmath192 cuts .
a particularly distinctive signature of the hens models are inclusive @xmath241 events .
we find effective cross - sections above @xmath266 for @xmath110 and @xmath147 , which is sufficient for a @xmath196 lhc discovery given the sm background of about @xmath236 @xcite .
there is a sharp increase in the @xmath241 cross - section in the small @xmath9 region at the upper right of the parameter space .
the dominant sources of this increase are cascades initiated by right - handed squarks of the type described previously .
furthermore , because the left - handed sleptons are lighter than @xmath267 but heavier than @xmath268 and @xmath269 in this region , superpartner cascades such as @xmath270 accompanied by many leptons have a non - trivial branching fraction and can produce three leptons from the single squark parent .
is very small in this part of the parameter space .
however , the other two leptons in the cascade tend to be quite hard . ] as a result , @xmath241 rates greater than @xmath271 can occur .
we have also investigated the exclusive clean trilepton channel .
it does not appear to be as promising as the inclusive channels . and @xmath112 for the five sample points described in the text .
for comparison , the sm backgrounds are estimated to be about @xmath231 , @xmath232 , @xmath233 , @xmath234 , @xmath235 , and @xmath236 for the @xmath225 , @xmath237 , @xmath238 , @xmath239 , @xmath240 and @xmath241 channels respectively @xcite.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] varying @xmath19 does not qualitatively affect our findings .
the cross sections after cuts for @xmath242 and @xmath112 are given in fig .
[ lhcbar30 ] for five sample points , @xmath272 .
details of these sample points are given in the appendix .
the cross sections in all six channels are similar to those in fig .
[ lhcbar ] with @xmath110 .
in particular , the ratio of @xmath225 to @xmath237 events is still close to unity , and the @xmath240 and @xmath241 rates are observably large .
the main difference that occurs at larger values of @xmath19 is that there is no small @xmath9 region .
since the entire mass spectrum in hens models scales with @xmath18 , so too do the event rates .
we have checked that for @xmath18 as large @xmath273 , corresponding to a gluino mass of @xmath274 , the inclusive event rates in all channels other than the @xmath225 and @xmath241 are large enough that a discovery with @xmath275 of lhc data is feasible . on the other hand ,
the event rates become even larger for smaller values of @xmath18 , making discovery even easier .
supersymmetry has been recognized as a viable theory of physics beyond the standard model for many years now .
it was quickly realized that it was not only viable , but also potentially useful in the quest to understand stability of the electroweak potential , radiative electroweak symmetry breaking , grand unification , dark matter , and baryogenesis . in subsequent years
, there has been much effort devoted to understanding how supersymmetry breaking is to be achieved without creating additional phenomenological problems , such as too large fcnc .
there are two particularly simple alternatives that keep the good features of supersymmetry while ( mostly ) dismissing the bad features .
one approach is to raise the scalar masses significantly higher than the supersymmetric fermion masses .
this is the idea of split supersymmetry discussed in the introduction .
one drawback of this scenario is the apparent finetuning in the electroweak sector .
the approach we pursue in this article is in some sense the opposite of split supersymmetry . here , rather than introduce a huge hierarchy of scalar masses over fermion masses , we wish to zero out the superpartner scalar masses at some scale ( i.e. , splat supersymmetry " ) .
the simplest model of all scalar masses having a zero boundary condition does not work .
however , applying a small alteration to the most minimal idea , namely that the higgs bosons are exempt from zero boundary condition requirement , preserves the good features of these theories , while satisfying the phenomenological requirements described in the text .
this idea of higgs exempt no - scale ( hens ) supersymmetry has many phenomenological implications worthy of consideration at current and future experimental facilities . for example
, we have found that the scenario can accommodate the tantalizing ( but small ) deviation of @xmath276 of the muon compared to the sm prediction .
it also suggests a near maximal leptonic signal for the tevatron , and thus provides an excellent benchmark theory for the tevatron to either discover this form of supersymmetry or rule out large regions of parameter space in a clean way .
furthermore , the lhc signatures are of many multi - lepton events .
perhaps the most distinctive of them is the inclusive @xmath241 channel which can effectively rule out hens models up to gaugino mass scales that are uncomfortably large from the normal finetuning point of view . for the most part ,
this form of supersymmetry is rather straightforward for the lhc to find .
an important exception is the lightest higgs boson , whose mass is pressured in this scenario to be low , and thus perhaps close to the current bound of @xmath121 . given the difficulties of finding a higgs boson less than @xmath277 @xcite , discovering the higgs boson might be one of the more challenging steps in confirming the complete structure of this theory .
* acknowledgements * we would like to thank p. kumar for discussions , and for contributions at the early stages of this work .
we also wish to thank g. kane , s. martin , a. pierce and s. thomas for helpful discussions .
this work is supported in part by the department of energy and the michigan center for theoretical physics .
in this appendix , we list the relevant properties of the sample points @xmath278 chosen for @xmath110 and @xmath242 . the locations of these points in the @xmath279 plane are shown in figs .
[ 10 - 500-scan-3l ] and [ 10 - 500-scan-1l ] .
we also list properties of the points @xmath280 corresponding to @xmath112 and @xmath147 .
.model parameters and particle masses for sample points @xmath278 , all with @xmath110 and @xmath147 .
all dimensionful quantities in the table are listed in gev units .
the @xmath144 values are valid computations for the assumption of standard thermal cosmological evolution and stable lightest neutralino .
viability of points @xmath17 and @xmath16 require alterations to the standard assumptions .
[ 10 - 500table ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] for reviews , see for example h. e. haber and g. l. kane , phys .
* 117 * , 75 ( 1985 ) ; s. p. martin , hep - ph/9709356 ; d. j. h. chung et al . , phys .
* 407 * , 1 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0312378 ] ; m. a. luty , hep - th/0509029 . s. dimopoulos and h. georgi , nucl .
b * 193 * , 150 ( 1981 ) .
s. dimopoulos , s. raby and f. wilczek , phys .
d * 24 * , 1681 ( 1981 ) .
see for example , f. gabbiani , e. gabrielli , a. masiero and l. silvestrini , nucl .
b * 477 * , 321 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9604387 ] , m. misiak , s. pokorski and j. rosiek , adv .
high energy phys .
* 15 * , 795 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9703442 ] .
m. dugan , b. grinstein and l. j. hall , nucl .
b * 255 * , 413 ( 1985 ) .
m. leurer , y. nir and n. seiberg , nucl .
b * 398 * , 319 ( 1993 ) [ hep - ph/9212278 ] .
y. nir and n. seiberg , phys .
b * 309 * , 337 ( 1993 ) [ hep - ph/9304307 ] .
m. leurer , y. nir and n. seiberg , nucl .
b * 420 * , 468 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9310320 ] .
m. dine , r. g. leigh and a. kagan , phys .
d * 48 * , 4269 ( 1993 ) [ hep - ph/9304299 ] .
l. j. hall and h. murayama , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 3985 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9508296 ] .
r. barbieri , g. r. dvali and l. j. hall , phys .
b * 377 * , 76 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9512388 ] .
r. barbieri , l. j. hall and a. romanino , phys .
b * 401 * , 47 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9702315 ] . for a review , see g. f. giudice and r. rattazzi , phys . rept . *
322 * , 419 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9801271 ] , and references therein .
l. randall and r. sundrum , nucl .
b * 557 * , 79 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9810155 ] .
g. f. giudice , m. a. luty , h. murayama and r. rattazzi , jhep * 9812 * , 027 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9810442 ] .
n. arkani - hamed and s. dimopoulos , jhep * 0506 * , 073 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0405159 ] . g. f. giudice and a. romanino , nucl .
b * 699 * , 65 ( 2004 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 706 * , 65 ( 2005 ) ] [ hep - ph/0406088 ] .
n. arkani - hamed , s. dimopoulos , g. f. giudice and a. romanino , nucl .
b * 709 * , 3 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0409232 ] .
see also a. pierce , phys .
d * 70 * , 075006 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0406144 ] .
a. arvanitaki and p. w. graham , phys .
d * 72 * , 055010 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0411376 ] .
a. masiero , s. profumo and p. ullio , nucl .
b * 712 * , 86 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0412058 ] .
b. thomas , phys .
d * 72 * , 023519 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0503248 ] . n. arkani - hamed , a. delgado and g. f. giudice , nucl . phys .
b * 741 * , 108 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0601041 ] .
u. chattopadhyay , d. das , p. konar and d. p. roy , hep - ph/0610077 .
m. ibe , t. moroi and t. t. yanagida , hep - ph/0610277 .
r. mahbubani and l. senatore , phys .
d * 73 * , 043510 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0510064 ] .
d. e. kaplan , g. d. kribs and m. schmaltz , phys .
d * 62 * , 035010 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9911293 ] ; z. chacko , m. a. luty , a. e. nelson and e. ponton , jhep * 0001 * , 003 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9911323 ] .
for a review , see a. b. lahanas and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
* 145 * , 1 ( 1987 ) ; a. b. lahanas , cern - th-7092 - 93 _ lectures given at international school of subnuclear physics : 31th course : from supersymmetry to the origin of space - time , erice , italy , 4- 12 jul 1993 _ m. a. luty and r. sundrum , phys .
d * 65 * , 066004 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0105137 ] .
m. luty and r. sundrum , phys .
d * 67 * , 045007 ( 2003 ) [ hep - th/0111231 ] .
m. ibe , k. i. izawa , y. nakayama , y. shinbara and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 73 * , 015004 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0506023 ] .
m. ibe , k. i. izawa , y. nakayama , y. shinbara and t. yanagida , phys .
d * 73 * , 035012 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0509229 ] .
m. schmaltz and r. sundrum , hep - th/0608051 .
m. schmaltz and w. skiba , phys .
d * 62 * , 095005 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0001172 ]
. m. schmaltz and w. skiba , phys .
d * 62 * , 095004 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0004210 ] .
d. e. kaplan and t. m. p. tait , jhep * 0006 * , 020 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0004200 ] .
w. buchmuller , j. kersten and k. schmidt - hoberg , jhep * 0602 * , 069 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0512152 ] .
s. komine and m. yamaguchi , phys .
d * 63 * , 035005 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0007327 ] . c. balazs and r. dermisek , jhep
* 0306 * , 024 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0303161 ] .
w. buchmuller , l. covi , j. kersten and k. schmidt - hoberg , [ hep - ph/0609142 ] . for a recent discussion of negative values of @xmath281 in msugra ,
see : j. l. feng , a. rajaraman and b. t. smith , phys .
d * 74 * , 015013 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0512172 ] .
e. cremmer , s. ferrara , c. kounnas and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
b * 133 * , 61 ( 1983 ) .
j. r. ellis , a. b. lahanas , d. v. nanopoulos and k. tamvakis , phys .
b * 134 * , 429 ( 1984 ) .
j. r. ellis , c. kounnas and d. v. nanopoulos , nucl .
b * 241 * , 406 ( 1984 ) .
j. r. ellis , c. kounnas and d. v. nanopoulos , nucl .
b * 247 * , 373 ( 1984 ) .
see , for example , n. weiner , hep - ph/0106097 ; c. csaki , g. d. kribs and j. terning , phys .
d * 65 * , 015004 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0107266 ] .
e. witten , phys .
b * 155 * , 151 ( 1985 ) .
g. camara , l. e. ibanez and a. m. uranga , nucl .
b * 689 * , 195 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0311241 ] .
k. choi , a. falkowski , h. p. nilles and m. olechowski , nucl .
b * 718 * , 113 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0503216 ] .
a. e. nelson and m. j. strassler , jhep * 0009 * , 030 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0006251 ] .
a. e. nelson and m. j. strassler , jhep * 0207 * , 021 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0104051 ] .
t. kobayashi and h. terao , phys . rev .
d * 64 * , 075003 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0103028 ] .
t. kobayashi , h. nakano , t. noguchi and h. terao , phys .
d * 66 * , 095011 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0202023 ] .
k. r. dienes , e. dudas and t. gherghetta , phys .
b * 436 * , 55 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9803466 ] ; k. r. dienes , e. dudas and t. gherghetta , nucl .
b * 537 * , 47 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9806292 ] .
a. e. nelson and m. j. strassler , phys .
d * 56 * , 4226 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9607362 ] .
s. p. martin and m. t. vaughn , phys .
d * 50 * , 2282 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9311340 ] .
a. djouadi , j. l. kneur and g. moultaka , [ hep - ph/0211331 ] .
w. m. yao _ et al .
_ [ particle data group ] , j. phys .
g * 33 * , 1 ( 2006 ) .
e. brubaker _
[ tevatron electroweak working group ] , hep - ex/0608032 .
e. barberio _ et al .
_ [ heavy flavor averaging group ( hfag ) ] , hep - ex/0603003 .
see , for example , j. a. casas , a. lleyda and c. munoz , nucl .
b * 471 * , 3 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9507294 ] .
a. kusenko , p. langacker and g. segre , phys .
d * 54 * , 5824 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9602414 ] .
m. carena , m. quiros and c. e. m. wagner , phys .
b * 380 * , 81 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9603420 ] .
t. falk , k. a. olive , l. roszkowski , a. singh and m. srednicki , phys .
b * 396 * , 50 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9611325 ] .
r. barate _
[ lep working group for higgs boson searches ] , phys .
b * 565 * , 61 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ex/0306033 ] .
d. e. morrissey and j. d. wells , phys .
d * 74 * , 015008 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0512019 ] .
see r. barbieri and g. f. giudice , nucl .
b * 306 * , 63 ( 1988 ) , and references thereto .
a. gould , b. t. draine , r. w. romani and s. nussinov , phys .
b * 238 * , 337 ( 1990 ) ; a. de rujula , s. l. glashow and u. sarid , nucl .
b * 333 * , 173 ( 1990 ) ; s. dimopoulos , d. eichler , r. esmailzadeh and g. d. starkman , phys . rev .
d * 41 * , 2388 ( 1990 ) .
t. falk , k. a. olive and m. srednicki , phys .
b * 339 * , 248 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9409270 ]
. l. j. hall , t. moroi and h. murayama , phys .
b * 424 * , 305 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9712515 ] .
n. arkani - hamed , l. j. hall , h. murayama , d. r. smith and n. weiner , phys .
d * 64 * , 115011 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0006312 ] .
d. hooper , j. march - russell and s. m. west , phys .
b * 605 * , 228 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0410114 ] .
t. asaka , k. ishiwata and t. moroi , phys .
d * 73 * , 051301 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0512118 ] .
s. gopalakrishna , a. de gouvea and w. porod , jcap * 0605 * , 005 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0602027 ] . for a nice review of these scenarios ,
see : j. l. feng , annals phys .
* 315 * ( 2005 ) 2 .
p. gondolo , j. edsjo , p. ullio , l. bergstrom , m. schelke and e. a. baltz , jcap * 0407 * , 008 ( 2004 ) [ astro - ph/0406204 ] .
d. n. spergel _ et al .
_ , [ astro - ph/0603449 ] .
for some recent examples , see g. gelmini , p. gondolo , a. soldatenko and c. e. yaguna , phys .
d * 74 * , 083514 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0605016 ] .
d. e. morrissey and j. d. wells , hep - ph/0606234 .
d. s. akerib _ et al .
_ , nucl .
instrum .
a * 559 * , 390 ( 2006 ) .
j. r. ellis , a. d. linde and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
b * 118 * , 59 ( 1982 ) .
see , for example , m. dine , r. kitano , a. morisse and y. shirman , phys .
d * 73 * , 123518 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0604140 ] , and references therein .
see , for example , h. baer , a. belyaev , t. krupovnickas and j. ofarrill , jcap * 0408 * , 005 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0405210 ] ; j. r. ellis , k. a. olive , y. santoso and v. c. spanos , phys . rev .
d * 71 * , 095007 ( 2005 ) [ hep - ph/0502001 ] .
s. desai _ et al .
_ [ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , phys .
d * 70 * , 083523 ( 2004 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 70 * , 109901 ( 2004 ) ] [ hep - ex/0404025 ] .
p. a. toale [ icecube collaboration ] , [ astro - ph/0607003 ] .
j. hossl [ antares collaboration ] , _ prepared for idm 2004 : 5th international workshop on the identification of dark matter , edinburgh , scotland , united kingdom , 6 - 10 sep 2004 _ see , for example , h. baer and x. tata , phys .
d * 47 * , 2739 ( 1993 ) ; s. mrenna , g. l. kane , g. d. kribs and j. d. wells , phys .
d * 53 * , 1168 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9505245 ] ; v. d. barger , c. kao and t. j. li , phys .
b * 433 * , 328 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9804451 ] ; e. accomando , r. arnowitt and b. dutta , phys .
b * 475 * , 176 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9811300 ] ; v. d. barger and c. kao , phys .
d * 60 * , 115015 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9811489 ] ; j. d. lykken and k. t. matchev , phys .
d * 61 * , 015001 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9903238 ] .
k. t. matchev and d. m. pierce , phys . rev .
d * 60 * , 075004 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9904282 ] ; k. t. matchev and d. m. pierce , phys .
b * 467 * , 225 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9907505 ] .
h. baer , m. drees , f. paige , p. quintana and x. tata , phys .
d * 61 * , 095007 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/9906233 ]
. f. e. paige , s. d. protopopescu , h. baer and x. tata , hep - ph/0312045 .
h. baer , c. h. chen , f. paige and x. tata , phys .
d * 52 * , 2746 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9503271 ] .
h. baer , c. h. chen , f. paige and x. tata , phys .
d * 53 * , 6241 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9512383 ] .
atlas detector and physics performance .
technical design report .
2 , cern - lhcc-99 - 15 , atlas - tdr-15 , may 1999 . | one of the most straightforward ways to address the flavor problem of low - energy supersymmetry is to arrange for the scalar soft terms to vanish simultaneously at a scale @xmath0 much larger than the electroweak scale .
this occurs naturally in a number of scenarios , such as no - scale models , gaugino mediation , and several models with strong conformal dynamics .
unfortunately , the most basic version of this approach that incorporates gaugino mass unification and zero scalar masses at the grand unification scale is not compatible with collider and dark matter constraints
. however , experimental constraints can be satisfied if we exempt the higgs bosons from flowing to zero mass value at the high scale .
we survey the theoretical constructions that allow this , and investigate the collider and dark matter consequences .
a generic feature is that the sleptons are relatively light . because of this
, these models frequently give a significant contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon , and neutralino - slepton coannihilation can play an important role in obtaining an acceptable dark matter relic density .
furthermore , the light sleptons give rise to a large multiplicity of lepton events at colliders , including a potentially suggestive clean trilepton signal at the tevatron , and a substantial four lepton signature at the lhc .
mctp-06 - 32 + higgs boson exempt no - scale supersymmetry + and its collider and cosmology implications + jason l. evans , david e. morrissey , james d. wells + michigan center for theoretical physics ( mctp ) + physics department , university of michigan , ann arbor , mi 48109 |
single electron tunneling ( set ) devices@xcite are promising candidates for a wide variety of nanoelectronics applications , such as sensitive electrometers@xcite , thermometers@xcite , electron pumps and turnstiles for current standards@xcite , and quantum bits for quantum information processing@xcite . in recent years
, silicon has drawn a lot of attention as a candidate for practical set devices for several reasons .
these advantages include compatibility with complementary metal oxide semiconductor ( cmos ) processing , good electrostatic control of the tunnel barriers@xcite , greater device stability as demonstrated by a lack of charge offset drift@xcite , and a relative lack of nuclear spins , an important source of decoherence in spin - based quantum information applications@xcite .
however , to become truly viable in any of these applications , devices must be fabricated which overcome the device to device variations and low yield associated with the single device processing typical of small scale research programs .
although , at the single device level , the gate voltage variation from one device to another may not be an important parameter , uniform device operation becomes crucial when trying to operate several set devices simultaneously , e.g. , in the large scale integration of set devices .
the choice of device architecture can also impact the integrability of devices .
for example , gate to gate variations in an architecture where more than one gate@xcite controls a single tunnel barrier can make finding the desired operating point a laborious iterative process . in this paper
we demonstrate robust behavior and good unformity of easily - tuned , fully cmos single electron devices , which contain only silicon , thermally grown silicon dioxide ( sio@xmath3 ) and phorphorous doped polycrystalline silicon ( poly si ) in the active device region .
the motivation for a fully cmos approach to fabrication is twofold : 1 ) to minimize the number of impurities and defects near the active device region and 2 ) to avoid the instabilities associated with metallic oxides and , in particular , aluminum oxide . in this way , we avail ourselves of the best opportunity to fabricate uniform , robust devices .
below , we will discuss and demonstrate the robustness of our devices with respect to basic metal oxide semiconductor field
effect transistor ( mosfet ) characteristics and set device operation . in particular , we show that these devices exhibit only small variations of the threshold voltage from device to device , dielectrics which are robust against breakdown , and charge offset stability of the order of 0.01 e over a period of several days .
( color online ) ( a ) a schematic view of a sample . device operation is described in the text .
( b ) left : an optical micrograph of a sample .
right : an sem micrograph ( before upper gate deposition ) of the active device area , and schematics of an electrical measurement circuit ( does not show v@xmath4 ) .
lower gates lgs , lgc and lgd are poly
si and the conducting channel ( s / d ) is single crystal si .
channel and lower gates sit on top of the buried silicon oxide ( box ) .
the white arrow next to the finger gate indicates the dimension we call gate length .
( c ) a cross sectional sem image of a device along the dashed white line in ( b ) .
the darker areas are si , the gray areas are sio@xmath5 and the bright layer on top is a protective layer of pt deposited prior to the fib cut . ]
flow chart of the condensed fabrication process described in the text . ]
our devices each contain a lightly boron doped ( p type ) mesa etched single crystal si nanowire , n@xmath6type source and drain , and two layers of gates ; see fig .
[ sample ] ( a ) . the topmost gate layer , which we call the upper gate ( ug ) , covers the entire device between the heavily doped source and drain .
applying a positive voltage to the upper gate inverts the underlying si nanowire and provides conduction .
the second gate layer , which we call the lower gates ( lg ) , consists of three finger gates which wrap around the si nanowire .
these are denoted as lgs ( closest to the source ) , lgc ( center gate ) and lgd ( closest to the drain ) ; see fig .
[ sample ] ( b ) .
the lower gate fingers are primarily used to locally deplete the electron gas and therefore to create electrostatically controlled tunnel barriers ( lgs and lgd ) , or to modulate the electrostatic potential of a quantum dot ( lgc ) .
the devices are fabricated on a 6 inch silicon on insulator ( soi ) wafer , with doping density of about 10@xmath7 @xmath8 , an initial soi thickness of 100 nm , and a buried oxide ( box ) thickness of 200 nm . to minimize the interface trap density at the gate oxide interface of the nanowire@xcite
, we fabricate the soi nanowires at a 45@xmath9 angle with respect to the flat ( @xmath10110@xmath11 ) of the wafer in order to obtain a @xmath10100@xmath11 crystallographic equivalent orientation on each facet of the nanowire .
as previously mentioned , we fabricate these devices with a fully cmos process flow developed at the center for nanoscale science and technology ( cnst ) nanofabrication user facility at nist .
the fabrication process is presented in fig .
[ fabflowchart ] .
the nanowire , lower gate and upper gate lithography and etching are performed with negative tone electron beam lithography ( ebl ) using hydrogen silsesquioxane ( hsq ) as a resist and dry etching in cl@xmath3 chemistry . source and drain areas located about 10 @xmath12 m away from the active device area are implanted with phosphorous at 30 kev with a dose of 10@xmath7 @xmath13 .
we grow sacrificial oxide on both the nanowire and the lower gate layer in order to remove possible etch damage produced during the dry etch . both sacrificial oxide and the gate oxide on the nanowire
are grown in a tube furnace at 850 @xmath9c and 950 @xmath9c , respectively .
the sacrificial oxide is removed with a short 100:1 hf dip . the lower and upper gate layers are 75 nm thick _ in situ _ phosphorous doped poly
si deposited by low pressure chemical vapor deposition ( lpcvd ) at 625 @xmath9c .
both gate layers are degenerately doped to ensure electrical conduction at low temperatures with a typical resistivity of 1030 m@xmath14 cm ( determined from two terminal measurement at 2.2 k ) . the sacrificial oxide on the lower gate and the isolation oxide between the lower gate and the upper gate are grown with rapid thermal oxidation ( rto ) at 1000 @xmath9c .
the final steps of the process are metallization of ohmic contacts with sputter deposited al1%si and a forming gas anneal at 425 @xmath9c for 30 min . to date
, we have fabricated devices on two 6 inch wafers which we call a and b@xcite ; see fig .
[ fabflowchart ] .
the main differences between the wafers are the nominal gate oxide thickness and the finger gate lengths .
the soi nanowire width and length are 70 nm and 800 nm respectively for both wafers .
each wafer contained 48 dies : 36 with two devices as in fig .
[ sample ] on each and 12 diagnostics dies located on the diagonals of the wafer .
the diagnostics dies contained conventional field
effect transistors ( fet ) with a 70 nm wide soi nanowire as a channel , and test structures to measure the resistance of ohmic contacts and the resistivity of the poly
si . a cross - sectional sem image produced by a focused ion beam ( fib ) cut along the lgc finger ( white dashed line in fig . [ sample](b ) ) of a finished device is shown in fig [ sample](c ) .
the darker areas in the micrograph are si and the gray areas are sio@xmath5 .
the cross sectional image shows that both poly si films of upper gate and lower gate layers conformally coat the layers underneath as is expected from lpcvd growth , and that the oxides are continuous , as needed for electrical isolation .
we characterized many devices and fets from randomly chosen dies across both wafers at room temperature and at 2.2 k. in addition , one of the devices was cooled down and measured in a dilution refrigerator to 30 mk .
the summary of the electrical characterization is presented in table [ samplesummary ] .
figure [ 3gchar ] ( a ) shows turn on characteristics of different devices ( as in fig .
[ sample ] ) on wafer a ( 40 nm gate oxide ) .
the solid lines and dashed lines correspond to data taken at 300 k and 2.2 k , respectively . at room temperature the threshold voltages ,
as obtained by linearly extrapolating the current to zero@xcite , were @xmath15 v with the standard deviation of 0.1 v and there was a threshold shift of about 0.6 v when devices were cooled down .
a simple estimate of the threshold voltage@xcite which ignores the presence of any fixed oxide charge and which treats the devices as planar fets yields @xmath16 v at room temperature and @xmath17 v at 2.2 k , which is in reasonable agreement with our measured values .
wafer b ( 25 nm gate oxide ) showed uniform turn on characteristics with @xmath18 v at room temperature and a nearly equal shift in the threshold when cooled down .
the diagnostic transistors on each wafer also showed similar turn on behavior .
a typical subthreshold slope for these devices was 80 mv / decade at room temperature ( the ideal subthreshold slope is 60 mv / decade@xcite ) with an on off ratio of 10@xmath19 , see inset in fig .
[ 3gchar ] ( a ) .
typical turn off characteristics for each of the finger gates ( lgs , lgc and lgd ) measured at both room temperature and 2.2 k for wafer b are shown in fig .
[ 3gchar ] ( b ) .
the room temperature data was taken with an upper gate voltage @xmath20 v , while the low temperature data was taken with @xmath21 v. the range for turn off voltages , i.e. the lower gate voltage @xmath22 at 100 pa of drain current @xmath23 , was from -1.5 v to -1 v at room temperature and -1 v to -0.5 v at 2.2 k for all measured lower gates for all devices .
( color online ) turn on characteristics , i.e. drain current as a function of gate voltage of a mosfet transistor with 25 nm gate oxide thickness .
data was taken with the drain voltage @xmath24 of 1 mv .
solid ( black ) line is initial turn on curve , dashed ( red , gray ) line is turn on curve after @xmath2510 v ( 4 mv / cm ) excursion in the gate voltage .
the indentical curves indicate immunity to dielectric breakdown up to @xmath254 mv / cm . ]
we also tested the robustness of the gate oxide and the isolation oxide on wafer b. in these tests , the gate voltage was swept in steps up to @xmath2510 v while the source - drain and leakage currents were simultaneously measured to the other gates and to the channel .
all leakage resistances between the channel and either layer of gates or between gates were @xmath1110 g@xmath1 up to gate voltages of @xmath2510 v. after each gate voltage excursion , the turn on characteristics were remeasured in order to determine if there was a change in the threshold voltage or slope .
diagnostic fets were immune to electric fields up to 4 mv / cm ( @xmath26 v ) , showing no change in @xmath27 nor generation of a leakage path ( fig . [ transistor ] ) .
similar robustness measurements for set devices showed no threshold shift up to 2.8 mv / cm ( @xmath257 v ) and only a small ( 0.05 v and 0.2 v ) threshold shift after a gate excursion of 4 mv / cm ( @xmath2510 v ) in two out of four devices .
no observable leakage path developed during the sweep . a typical literature value of the breakdown field of metal oxide semiconductor capacitor ( moscap ) is about 10 mv / cm , before generating a leakage path@xcite .
we also performed robustness measurements of the isolation oxide between lg and ug on about 50 different lower gate fingers on different devices across the wafer .
only three fingers developed a breakdown path during the @xmath2510 v sweep . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] ( color online ) set oscillations of a device at 2.2 k , vertical dashed lines ( red , gray ) are separated by a period of 12.9 mv .
the data show good uniformity of the gate capacitance over 90 periods . ]
( color online ) coulomb diamonds measured at 30 mk for an set device , n is the electron number . charging energy @xmath281.2 mev , drain capacitance @xmath29=7 af and total capacitance of the island @xmath30=70 af , extracted from the diamond data . ]
above , we have discussed the robustness and uniformity of devices in terms of mosfet performance , and in the following we present device characteristics when operated in a single electron device mode .
first , we discuss ease of tuning . the right hand side of fig .
[ sample ] ( b ) shows a schematic of a typical measurement circuit for a device .
tuning the device to display set oscillations took very little time , on the order of minutes , because there was very little cross capacitance between gates and each barrier was controlled by a single gate voltage . to tune a device into set mode
, we first applied a small bias voltage to the drain ( of order 1 mv ) and set the upper gate to a voltage ( obtained from a short upper gate sweep , typically about 2 v ) which gave about 1 na of current .
next , a two dimensional sweep of @xmath31 and @xmath32 ( with @xmath33 well above the turn off voltage ) was performed to find the voltages where each of these gates began to turn off conduction .
typically , the barrier voltages were about -0.6 v. we note that barrier resistances responded symmetrically to @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
after fine tuning @xmath31 and @xmath32 , we measured set oscillations by sweeping @xmath33 with the other gate voltages fixed .
coulomb oscillations of a device taken at 2.2 k are presented in fig .
[ setosc ] .
the oscillations were very regular with period of 12.9 mv over an lgc gate voltage range of 1.2 v , corresponding to about 90 periods .
the capacitance of lgc to the dot , extracted from the set oscillation period , was about 12 af .
coulomb diamond data recorded at 30 mk for the same device is shown in fig .
[ diamonds ] . the charging energy and lever arm @xmath34 , which converts the gate voltage to the electrostatic potential of the island @xmath35 , extracted from the diamond data were 1.2 mev and 0.09 , respectively .
the capacitance between the dot and each of the other two lower gates ( lgs and lgd ) was measured relative to the lgc capacitance by following the position of a current peak when sweeping lgs ( or lgd ) and lgc ( data not shown ) .
the capacitance values for both lgs and lgd were about 5 af , indicating the dot was located in the center of the device .
this , together with the agreement between the measured capacitance to lgc ( 12 af ) and that calculated from the geometry ( 14 af ) gives us confidence that the dot being modulated was an intentional dot formed through electrostatic control of lgs and lgd rather than through barriers formed by defects . as a more strict test of the quality of our fabrication we performed charge offset drift measurements on several devices .
this measurement consisted of repeatedly measured coulomb blockade oscillations at a fixed time interval over several days .
figure [ cbdata ] ( a ) shows a typical collection of set oscillations taken at 2.2 k and spanning the total duration of the charge offset drift measurement . to obtain charge offset drift values for each curve , a sinusoidal function of the form @xmath36 $ ] was fit to the measured data . here
@xmath37 is the amplitude of the oscillations , @xmath38 is the gate voltage and @xmath39 the oscillation period .
the phase of the sinusoidal fit function , @xmath40 , is a charge offset value for each curve .
the result of this procedure is shown in fig .
[ cbdata ] ( b ) . the devices exhibited very stable behavior with a drift in @xmath41 e over 8 days of measurement .
moreover , these results rival those of similar si devices fabricated in other foundries@xcite .
in addition , after eight days of measurement , we thermally cycled the device to room temperature .
figure [ cbdata ] shows this data as well .
while the thermal cycle resulted in a shift in the charge offset value of about ( 0.1@xmath42 ) e , the level of drift observed was identical both before and after the thermal cycle .
finally , a measurement of @xmath43 vs. @xmath33 voltage with the same lgs , lgd , and ug voltages after the thermal cycle not only reproduced the set oscillations at the same value @xmath33 with charge offset of 0.1 e , but also reproduced the aperiodic features which become prominent when the gate begins to turn off conduction ( inset of fig . [ cbdata ] ) . while the previous results indicate that the cleanliness of our cmos fabrication is quite good , many devices in this first device run failed electrically by either not turning on or through an inability to turn off conduction with the lower gate fingers .
this drove our yield of fully functioning ( in which we were able to measure intentional coulomb blockade ) devices down to 4/34 devices measured .
we have been able to identify the gross fabrication failures , by cross - sectioning devices with fib in conjunction with the electrical results . in brief , the failure modes are the result of over oxidation of the soi nanowire and the lg fingers , as well as the overall amount of oxide removed in the processing .
we believe further development of our process flow will ameliorate these failures .
( color online ) ( a ) an example of single electron oscillations taken at different times with interval of about 3 hours ; curves are offset vertically for clarity .
( b ) charge offset drift derived from coulomb oscillations , red and blue ( gray ) dashed horizontal lines are a guide for the eye .
the gray area indicates the time interval of the thermal cycle . after the thermal cycle the charge offset value @xmath40 changed by 0.1 e , but remained as stable as before .
inset : drain current as a function of lgc voltage @xmath44 before ( black line ) and after ( red , gray line ) the thermal cycle .
the data in the inset before and after the thermal cycle are taken with the same gate voltages .
all features in the data are reproduced after the thermal cycle . ]
in summary , we have demonstrated devices which show good uniformity in electrical characteristics from device to device within a wafer and between wafers . moreover , the devices are quite robust against dielectric breakdown up to electric fields of 4 mv / cm .
finally , and most importantly , when operated as a single electron device , these devices show very stable behavior . taken together ,
these characteristics indicate a relatively clean and stable electrostatic environment throughout the fabrication process .
we attribute these successes to the minimization of impurities and defects which result from our cmos processing and material restrictions . to further improve the usefulness of these devices as current standards and quantum information devices , our next tasks include i ) substantially increasing the yield , and ii ) making shorter finger gates so that we can use those gates to both generate barriers and as plunger gates .
while these results indicate that a fully cmos process pays dividends in device performance , it also complicates the fabrication .
we believe that our results in terms of reliability , ease of tuning , and clean set behavior all justify the cost of the increased complexity of fabrication .
we thank ted thorbeck , john bonevich , jerry bowser , and vincent luciani for fruitful discussions .
we also thank jerry bowser and vincent luciani for guidance with the fabrication .
research was performed in part at the nist center for nanoscale science and technology ( cnst ) .
20ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo
secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ _ ,
( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) | we present electrical data of silicon single electron devices fabricated with cmos techniques and protocols .
the easily tuned devices show clean coulomb diamonds at @xmath0 mk and charge offset drift of 0.01 e over eight days .
in addition , the devices exhibit robust transistor characteristics including uniformity within about 0.5 v in the threshold voltage , gate resistances greater than 10 g@xmath1 , and immunity to dielectric breakdown in electric fields as high as @xmath2 mv / cm . these results highlight the benefits in device performance of a fully cmos process for single electron device fabrication . |
recently , the generalizations of the logarithmic and exponential functions have attracted the attention of researchers .
one - parameter logarithmic and exponential functions have been proposed in the context of non - extensive statistical mechanics @xcite , relativistic statistical mechanics @xcite and quantum group theory @xcite .
two and three - parameter generalization of these functions have also been proposed @xcite .
these generalizations are in current use in a wide range of disciplines since they permit the generalization of special functions : hyperbolic and trigonometric @xcite , gaussian / cauchy probability distribution function @xcite etc .
also , they permit the description of several complex systems @xcite , for instance in generalizing the stretched exponential function @xcite .
as mentioned above , the one - parameter generalizations of the logarithm and exponential functions are not univoquous .
the @xmath1-logarithm function @xmath2 is defined as the value of the area underneath the non - symmetric hyperbole , @xmath3 , in the interval @xmath4 $ ] @xcite : @xmath5 this function is _ not _ the ordinary logarithmic function in the basis @xmath1 , namely @xmath6 $ ] , but a generalization of the natural logarithmic function definition , which is recovered for @xmath7 .
the area is negative for @xmath8 , it vanishes for @xmath9 and it is positive for @xmath10 , independently of the @xmath1 values . given the area @xmath11 underneath the curve @xmath12 , for @xmath13 $ ] , the upper limit @xmath14 is the generalized @xmath1-exponential function : @xmath15 .
this is the inverse function of the @xmath1-logarithmic @xmath16=x=\ln_{\tilde q}[e_{\tilde q}(x)]$ ] and it is given by : @xmath17 this is a non - negative function @xmath18 , with @xmath19 , for any @xmath1 . for @xmath20 ,
one has that @xmath21 , for @xmath22 and @xmath23 , for @xmath24 .
notice that letting @xmath9 one has generalized the euler s number : @xmath25 instead of using the standard entropic index @xmath26 in eqs .
( [ eq : gen_log ] ) and ( [ eq : eqtilde ] ) , we have adopted the notation @xmath27 .
the latter notation permits us to write simple relations as : @xmath28 or @xmath29 , bringing the inversion point around @xmath30 .
these relations lead to simpler expressions in population dynamics problems @xcite and the generalized stretched exponential function @xcite contexts .
also , they simplify the generalized sum and product operators @xcite , where a link to the aritmethical and geometrical averages of the generalized functions is established . this logarithm generalization , as shown in ref .
@xcite , is the one of non - extensive statistical mechanics @xcite .
it turns out to be precisely the form proposed by montroll and badger @xcite to unify the verhulst ( @xmath31 ) and gompertz ( @xmath32 ) one - species population dynamics model .
the @xmath33-logarithm leads exactly to the richards growth model @xcite : @xmath34 where @xmath35 , @xmath36 is the population size at time @xmath37 , @xmath38 is the carrying capacity and @xmath39 is the intrinsic growth rate .
the solution of eq .
( [ eq : richard_model ] ) is the _
@xmath1-generalized logistic _
equation @xmath40 } = e_{-{\tilde q}}[-\ln_{\tilde q}(p_0^{-1})e^{-\kappa t } ] = e_{-{\tilde q}}[\ln_{-\tilde q}(p_0)e^{-\kappa t}]$ ] .
the competition among cells drive to replicate and inhibitory interactions , that are modeled by long range interaction among these cells .
these interactions furnish an interesting microscopic mechanism to obtain richards model @xcite .
the long range interaction is dependent on the distance @xmath41 between two cells as a power law @xmath42 .
these cells have a fractal structure characterized by a fractal dimension @xmath43 . here
we call the attention to eq . ( 7 ) of ref
. @xcite , namely @xmath44\}$ ] , where @xmath45^{1-\gamma / d_f}-1\right\}/[d_f(1-\gamma / d_f)]$ ] . here
, @xmath46 is a constant related to geometry of the problem , @xmath47 is the mean intrinsic replication rate of the cells and @xmath48 is the interaction factor . using eq .
( [ eq : gen_log ] ) , one can rewrite it simply as : @xmath49/{d_f}$ ] . calling , @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 ,
this equation is the richard s model [ eq .
( [ eq : richard_model ] ) ] with an effort rate @xmath53 . in this context
the parameter @xmath33 acquires a physical meaning related to the interaction range @xmath54 and fractal dimension of the cellular structure @xmath43 . if the interaction does not depend on the distance , @xmath55 , and it implies that @xmath56 .
this physical interpretation of @xmath33 has only been possible due to richards model underlying microscopic description .
introduced by nicholson in 1954 @xcite , scramble and contest are types of intraspecific competition models that differ between themselves in the way that limited resources are shared among individuals . in scramble competition , the resource is equally shared among the individuals of the population as long as it is available . in this case , there is a critical population size @xmath57 , above which , the amount of resource is not enough to assure population survival . in the contest competition ,
stronger individuals get the amount of resources they need to survive .
if there is enough resources to all individuals , population grows , otherwise , only the strongest individuals survive ( strong hierarchy ) , and the population maintains itself stable with size @xmath38 . from experimental data , it is known that other than the important parameter @xmath39 ( and sometimes @xmath38 ) , additional parameters in more complex models are needed to adjust the model to the given population .
one of the most general discrete model is the @xmath0-ricker model @xcite .
this model describes well scramble competition models but it is unable to put into a unique formulation the contest competition models such as hassel model @xcite , beverton - holt model @xcite and maynard - smith - slatkin model @xcite . our main purpose is to show that eq .
( [ eq : limite ] ) is suitable to unify most of the known discrete growth models into a simple formula .
this is done in the following way . in sec .
[ sec : loquistic ] , we show that the richards model [ eq .
( [ eq : richard_model ] ) ] , which has an underlying microscopic model , has a physical interpretation to the parameter @xmath33 , and its discretization leads to a generalized logistic map .
we briefly study the properties of this map and show that some features of it ( fixed points , cycles etc . )
are given in terms of the @xmath1-exponential function .
curiously , the map attractor can be suitably written in terms of @xmath33-exponentials , even in the logistic case . in sec .
[ sec : generalized_theta_ricker ] , using the @xmath1-exponential function , we generalize the @xmath0-ricker model and analytically calculate the model fixed points , as well as their stability . in sec .
[ sec : generalizedskellam ] , we consider the generalized skellam model .
these generalizations allow us to recover most of the well - known scramble / contest competition models .
final remarks are presented in sec [ sec : conclusion ] .
to discretize eq . (
[ eq : richard_model ] ) , call @xmath58 and @xmath59^{\tilde q}$ ] , which leads to : @xmath60 where @xmath61 .
we notice that @xmath1 keeps its physical interpretation of the continuous model . in eq .
( [ eq : loquistic ] ) , if @xmath62 and @xmath63 , with @xmath64 $ ] , one obtains the _ logistic map _ , @xmath65 , which is the classical example of a _ dynamic system _ obtained from the discretization of the verhulst model .
although simple , this map presents a extremely rich behavior , universal period duplication , chaos etc .
@xcite .
let us digress considering the feigenbaum s map @xcite : @xmath66 , with @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
firstly , let us consider the particular case @xmath62 .
if one writes @xmath70 , with @xmath71 being a constant , then : @xmath72 $ ] . imposing that @xmath73 leads to @xmath74 and calling @xmath75 , one obtains the logistic map with @xmath76 , so that @xmath77 .
one can easily relate the control parameter of these two maps , making the maps equivalent . for arbitrary values of @xmath33 ,
there is not a general closed analytical form to expand @xmath78 and one can not simply transform the control parameters of eq .
( [ eq : loquistic ] ) to the feigenbaum s map . here , in general ,
these two maps are not equivalent .
it would be then interesting , to study the sensitivity of eq .
( [ eq : loquistic ] ) with respect to initial conditions as it has been extensively studied in the feigenbaum s map @xcite . returning to eq .
( [ eq : loquistic ] ) , in the domain @xmath79 , @xmath80 ( non - negative ) , for @xmath81 .
since @xmath82 is real only for @xmath83 , @xmath84 is real only for @xmath85 .
the maximum value of the function is @xmath86 which occurs at @xmath87 i. e. , the inverse of the generalized euler s number @xmath88 [ eq .
( [ eq : eqtilde ] ) ] . for the generalized logistic map , @xmath89 ,
so that @xmath90 , it leads to the following domain for the control parameter @xmath91 : @xmath92 the map fixed points @xmath93 $ ] are @xmath94 the fixed point @xmath95 is stable for @xmath96 and @xmath97 is stable for @xmath98 , where @xmath99 notice the presence of the @xmath33-exponentials in the description of the attractors , even for the logistic map @xmath62 .
the generalized logistic map also presents the rich behavior of the logistic map as depicted by the bifurcation diagram of fig .
the inset of fig .
[ fig1 ] displays the lyapunov exponents as function of the central parameter @xmath100 . in fig .
[ fig2 ] we have scaled the axis to @xmath101/ ( \rho_{max}\tilde{q})$ ] , where @xmath102 is given by eq .
( [ eq : rho_max ] ) and we plotted the bifurcation diagram for @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
we see that the diagrams display the same structure but each one has its own scaling parameters .
the role of increasing @xmath33 is to lift the bifurcation diagram to relatively anticipating the chaotic phase .
the period doubling region start at @xmath105^{1/\tilde{q}}$ ] , so that for @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath108 . when @xmath109 , then @xmath110 . in fig .
[ fig3 ] we show the histograms of the distribution of the variable @xmath111 .
we see that as @xmath33 increases , the histograms have the same shape as the logistic histogram has , but it is crooked in the counter clock sense around @xmath112 .
the _ @xmath0-ricker _ model @xcite is given by : @xmath113 } , \label{eq : theta_ricker}\ ] ] where @xmath114 . notice that @xmath115 is the relevant variable , where @xmath116 . in this way eq .
( [ eq : theta_ricker ] ) can be simply written as @xmath117 . for @xmath118 ,
one finds the standard _
model @xcite . for arbitrary @xmath0 , expanding the exponential to
the first order one obtains the generalized logistic map [ eq .
( [ eq : loquistic ] ) ] which becomes the logistic map , for @xmath118 .
the @xmath0-ricker , ricker and quadratic models are all scramble competion models . if one switches the exponential function for the @xmath119-generalized exponential in eq .
( [ eq : theta_ricker ] ) , one gets the _ generalized @xmath0-ricker model _ : @xmath120 = \frac{\kappa_1 x_i}{\left[1 + \tilde{q } r \left ( \frac{x_i}{\kappa}\right)^{\theta } \right]^{1/\tilde{q } } } \ ; . \label{eq : generalized_theta_ricker_model}\ ] ] to obtain standard notation , write @xmath121 and @xmath122 , so that @xmath123 @xcite .
the generalized model with @xmath118 , leads to the _ hassel _ model @xcite , which can be a scramble or contest competition model .
one well - known contest competition model is the _ beverton - holt _ model @xcite , which is obtained taking @xmath124 . for @xmath125 ,
one recovers the ricker model and for @xmath126 , one recovers the logistic model .
it is interesting to mention that the beverton - holt model @xcite is one of the few models that have the time evolution explicitly written : @xmath127 $ ] . from this equation
, one sees that @xmath128 , for @xmath129 and @xmath130 for @xmath131 . using arbitrary values of @xmath0 in eq .
( [ eq : generalized_theta_ricker_model ] ) , for @xmath125 one recovers the @xmath0-ricker model , and for @xmath132 , the _ maynard - smith - slatkin _
model @xcite is recovered .
the latter is a scramble / contest competition model . for @xmath126 ,
one recovers the generalized logistic map .
the trivial linear model is retrieved for @xmath133 . in terms of the relevant variable @xmath134 , eq .
( [ eq : generalized_theta_ricker_model ] ) is rewritten as : @xmath135 where @xmath136 and we stress that the important parameters are @xmath137 , @xmath33 and @xmath114 .
( [ eq : final ] ) is suitable for data analysis and the most usual known discrete growth models are recovered with the judicious choice of the @xmath1 and @xmath0 parameters as it shown in table [ tabela ] .
some typical bifurcation diagrams of eq .
( [ eq : final ] ) are displayed in fig .
[ figbdtrm ] .
.summary of the parameters to obtain discrete growth models from eq .
( [ eq : final ] ) . in the competition type column ,
_ s _ and _ c _ stand for scramble and contest models , respectively .
the symbol @xmath138 stands for arbitrary values .
[ cols="<,^,^ , < " , ]
we have shown that the @xmath33-generalization of the exponential function is suitable to describe discrete growth models .
the @xmath1 parameter is related to the range of a repulsive potential and the dimensionality of the fractal underlying structure . from the discretization of the richard s model
, we have obtained a generalization for the logistic map and briefly studied its properties .
an interesting generalization is the one of @xmath0-ricker model , which allows to have several scramble or contest competition discrete growth models as particular cases .
equation ( [ eq : final ] ) allows the use of softwares to fit data to find the most suitable known model throughout the optimum choice of @xmath1 and @xmath0 .
furthermore , one can also generalize the skellam contest model .
only a few specific models mentioned in ref .
@xcite are not retrieved from our generalization .
actually , we propose a general procedure where we do not necessarily need to be tied to a specific model , since one can have arbitrary values of @xmath1 and @xmath0 .
the authors thank c. a. s. terariol for fruitful discussions .
asm acknowledges the brazilian agency cnpq ( 303990/2007 - 4 and 476862/2007 - 8 ) or support .
rsg also acknowledges cnpq ( 140420/2007 - 0 ) for support .
ale acknowledges cnpq for the fellowship and fapesp and mct / cnpq fundo setorial de infra - estrutura ( 2006/60333 - 0 ) . | here we show that a particular one - parameter generalization of the exponential function is suitable to unify most of the popular one - species discrete population dynamics models into a simple formula .
a physical interpretation is given to this new introduced parameter in the context of the continuous richards model , which remains valid for the discrete case . from the discretization of the continuous richards model ( generalization of the gompertz and verhuslt models ) , one obtains a generalized logistic map and we briefly study its properties .
notice , however that the physical interpretation for the introduced parameter persists valid for the discrete case .
next , we generalize the ( scramble competition ) @xmath0-ricker discrete model and analytically calculate the fixed points as well as their stability .
in contrast to previous generalizations , from the generalized @xmath0-ricker model one is able to retrieve either scramble or contest models .
complex systems , population dynamics ( ecology ) , nonlinear dynamics 89.75.-k , 87.23.-n , 87.23.cc , 05.45.-a |
the intensity anisotropy pattern of the cmbr has already been measured to an extraordinary precision , which helped significantly to establish the current cosmological paradigm of a flat universe with a period of inflation in its first moments and the existence of the so called dark energy @xcite .
the polarization anisotropies of the cmbr are an order of magnitude smaller than the intensity anisotropies and provide partly complementary information .
the polarization pattern is divided into two distinct components termed e- and b - modes which are scalar ( pseudoscalar ) fields .
the e - modes originate from the dynamics due to the density inhomogeneities in the early universe .
the b - modes are caused by lensing of the e - modes by the matter in the line of sight and by gravitational waves in the inflationary period in the very early universe and are expected to be at least one order of magnitude smaller than the e - modes .
the status of the e - mode measurements is summarized in figure [ emodes ] from which it becomes obvious that the measurements are consistent with the theoretical model but not yet giving meaningful constraints .
of special importance and interest are the b - modes expected from gravitational waves in the inflationary epoch , since a detection would allow unique access to the very first moments of the universe .
the size of this contribution can not be predicted by theory , but is parametrized by the tensor - to - scalar ratio , @xmath1 @xcite .
interesting inflationary energy scales of the order of the grand unifying theory ( gut ) scale of 10@xmath2 gev correspond to an @xmath1 of @xmath310@xmath0 , which would give rise to detectable signals of a few 10 nk .
the tiny signal requires unprecedented sensitivity and control of systematics and foregrounds . by
now receivers have reached sensitivities close to fundamental limits , so that the sensitivity will only be increased with the number of receivers .
recent developments at the jet propulsion laboratory ( jpl ) led to the successful integration of the relevant components of a polarization - sensitive pseudo - correlation receiver at 90 and 40 ghz in a small chip package .
this opened the way to future inexpensive mass production of large coherent receiver arrays and led to the formation of the q / u imaging experiment ( quiet ) collaboration .
experimental groups from 12 international institutes have joined the experiment and are working on the first prototype arrays which are planned for deployment for 2008 in chile .
a w - band ( 90 ghz ) array of 91 receivers and a q - band ( 40 ghz ) array of 19 receivers will be deployed on new 1.4 m telescopes mounted on the existing platform of the cosmic background imager ( cbi ) in the atacama desert at an altitude of 5080 m. it is foreseen to expand the arrays for a second phase of data taking ( 2010++ ) to arrays with 1000 receivers . for the expansion it is planned to mount more 1.4 m telescopes on the platform and relocate the 7 m crawford hill antenna from new jersey to chile to also access small angular scales .
a sketch of one receiver and its components can be seen in figure [ receiver ] .
the incoming radiation couples via a feedhorn to an orthomode transducer ( omt ) and from that to the two input waveguides of the chip package .
the chip contains a complete radiometer with high electron mobility transistors ( hemts ) implemented as monolithic microwave integrated circuits ( mmics ) , phase shifters , hybrid couplers and diodes .
the outputs of the four diodes of the radiometer provide measurements of the stokes parameters q and u and fast ( 4khz ) phase switching reduces the effects of the 1/f drifts of the amplifiers . for 10@xmath4 of the receivers
the omt will be exchanged by a magic tee assembled in a way that the receivers measure temperature differences between neighboured feeds .
the signals from the diodes are processed by a digital backend , sampling at 800 khz with subsequent digital demodulation .
this allows unique monitoring of high - frequency noise as well as the production of null - data sets with out - of - phase demodulation giving a valuable check of possible subtle systematics .
the receiver arrays together with the feedhorns are assembled in large cryostats and the chip radiometers are kept at 20 k to ensure low noise from the hemts . for a single element a bandwidth of 18(8 ) ghz and a noise temperature of 45 ( 20 ) k is aimed for at 90 ( 40 ) ghz , leading to expected sensitivites in chile of 250 ( 160 ) @xmath5k@xmath6 per element .
a prototype array of 7 elements with one omt mounted on top of one chip radiometer is shown on the right hand side of figure [ receiver ] .
the hexagonal prototype arrays of 91 and 19 elements are being assembled from similar subarrays .
the omts were built in cost - effective split - block technique and the corrugated horn arrays were produced as platelet arrays where 100 plates with feed - hole patterns are mounted together by diffusion bonding .
the increase in sensitivity is a necessary but not yet sufficient condition for the successful measurement of b - modes as the signal of interest is smaller than the one from astrophysical foregrounds .
the diffuse emission ( synchrotron , dust ) from our galaxy and extragalactic sources produces polarized signals of which the distribution and characteristics are not yet known to the precision required for a full removal .
multifrequency observations are mandatory to study the foreground behaviour and enable the clean extraction of the cmbr polarization anisotropies .
quiet in its observations will use two frequencies which frame the frequency where the contamination from foregrounds in polarization is expected to be minimal , around 70 ghz . also , it will coordinate the patches to be observed with other polarization experiments to gain additional frequency information .
fields were selected in which minimal foreground contamination is expected .
the b - modes from gravitational waves will suffer from yet another foreground ( which in intself is of scientific interest ) which is the lensing of e - modes into b - modes .
using the observations at small angular scales quiet will be able to determine a lensing correction and , with that , be able to remove that contribution properly .
while currently ongoing cmbr experiments ( bicep , quad ) are running with tens of receivers all future experiments are aiming for large arrays with several hundreds of receivers , all of them ( but quiet ) using bolometers .
figure [ comparison ] visualizes the main parameters of quiet in comparison to other ongoing and planned cmb experiments ( no interferometers are shown ) .
some of the experiments have their main focus on observations of the sunyaev zeldovich effect ( marked accordingly ) and not polarization observations , but may still upgrade their detector arrays for polarization sensitivity .
the parameters of the future experiments were taken from recent papers and talks about the various efforts , but since some of the technologies are not yet fully established and not all of the experiments are completely funded , it is clear that some of the parameters may change in the course of the production . both the left and middle plot display beam size versus frequency for the different experiments while the size of the squares indicates different parameters of the experiments .
since some experiments ( quiet , polarbear ) are planned to operate in different phases , they have several squares at the same position . in the left panel
the square area is proportional to the total sensitivity of the experiments , which means the smaller the square the more sensitive the experiment .
as can be seen the next generation of cmb experiments will achieve the desired level of a few nk sensitivity . except for the space - based mission
planck and the balloon experiment spider all ground - based experiments focus their sensitivity on small fractions of the sky . in this way it is possible to avoid
regions of high foreground contamination and also gain a higher signal - to - noise ratio in the maps , which helps characterizing foregrounds and systematics . in order to compare the sensitivity on a map the middle figure displays squares which are in size proportional to the sensitivity in @xmath5k / square degree .
the right figure then shows the corresponding white noise level for the different polarization experiments as a function of multipole l in comparison to the different polarization power spectra .
as can be seen the white noise power is for planck a factor of 100 higher than for the ground - based experiments , which means the noise on a quiet map is about one order of magnitude lower than on the maps expected from planck .
the main sensitivity of planck for the measurement of b - modes from gravitational waves comes from the reionization peak at low multipoles of l while the ground - based experiments like quiet will constrain @xmath1 from measuring at the maximum of the gravitational wave signal at @xmath7=100 , corresponding to an angular scale of 2 degrees .
quiet is complementary to other experiments in many different ways : * quiet is the only ground - based effort using coherent receivers and thus dealing with different systematics than the bolometric systems . *
it is the only experiment to measure the stokes parameters q and u simultaneously in one pixel which provides a good handle on several systematic effects . *
the array at 40 ghz complements the high frequencies of the bolometer arrays and thus allows to account for the contamination from synchrotron radiation which dominates at low frequencies .
* by using different telescope sizes quiet will be able to measure both large and small angular scales with the same receivers .
= 0.36 ( lensing contribution not shown).,width=449 ] already in phase i quiet will be able to measure the e - mode spectrum to an unprecedented precision . the expected e- and b - mode power spectra for the phase ii of quiet with 1000 elements are shown in figure [ powspec ] .
only the sensitivity of the w - band ( 90 ghz ) arrays from the 1.4 m telescopes was used assuming that the q - band sensitivity is used for foreground removal .
the results were derived by including several real - data effects : a realistic observing strategy has been simulated and the method used in capmap to remove ground - pickup by mode - removal in single scans has been applied @xcite . the simulations also incorporate effects from e - b leakage where the b - mode measurement is degraded due to the e - mode signal leakage into the b - mode spectrum due to the finite size of the observed patch @xcite .
additionally , the errors include a marginalization over the power in adjacent @xmath7-bins and for b - modes also over e power .
the expected precision on cosmological parameters assuming initial adiabatic conditions is summarized in table [ cosmpar ] .
note that these estimates had been performed before the publication of wmap results , but do agree well with the published wmap parameter errors . from the table
one can see that quiet will improve the wmap parameter errors to a size competitive to the expected precision of planck . adding
the quiet measurements to planck will only bring a small improvement in most of the parameters
. however , quiet will already in phase i be able to constrain the tensor - to - scalar ratio together with planck to a level significantly smaller than planck is expected to . adding quiet phase ii will bring the limit on @xmath1 down to the level of 10@xmath0 .
3cmllllll & a & b & c & d & e + @xmath8 & 6 & 4 & 1 & 1 & 1 + @xmath9 & 8 & 7 & 4 & 2 & 2 + @xmath10 & 15 & 14 & 8 & 4 & 3 + @xmath11 & 34 & 23 & 14 & 7 & 6 + @xmath12 & 4 & 2 & 1 & 1 & 1 + @xmath13 & 1.35 & 0.021 & 0.009 & 0.042 & 0.009 + + +
we are entering an era where probing gut scale physics is possible .
a number of experiments are in preparation for seeing the signature of inflation in the b - modes . of these quiet
is the only one using coherent detectors .
a convincing discovery of the tiny signal will need consistent measurements from complementary techniques and observing frequencies . already within the next years
quiet will reach the sensitivity to probe , together with other experiments , interesting levels of @xmath1 . | a major goal of upcoming experiments measuring the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmbr ) is to reveal the subtle signature of inflation in the polarization pattern which requires unprecedented sensitivity and control of systematics .
since the sensitivity of single receivers has reached fundamental limits future experiments will take advantage of large receiver arrays in order to significantly increase the sensitivity . here
we introduce the q / u imaging experiment ( quiet ) which will use hemt - based receivers in chip packages at 90(40 ) ghz in the atacama desert .
data taking is planned for the beginning of 2008 with prototype arrays of 91(19 ) receivers , an expansion to 1000 receivers is foreseen . with the two frequencies and a careful choice of scan regions there is the promise of effectively dealing with foregrounds and reaching a sensitivity approaching 10@xmath0 for the ratio of the tensor to scalar perturbations .
[ 1999/12/01 v1.4c il nuovo cimento ] |
not only are block copolymers promising materials for nano - patterned structures @xcite , drug delivery @xcite , and photonic applications @xcite , but they are also the ideal system for studying the influence of molecule architecture on macromolecular self - assembly @xcite . because of the ongoing interest in novel macromolecular organization , theoretical predictions based on heuristic characterization of molecular architecture offer crucial guidance to synthetic , experimental , and theoretical studies .
though the standard diblock copolymer phase diagram @xcite was explained nearly a quarter of a century ago , the prediction and control of phase boundaries is fraught with subtle physical effects : weak segregation theory provides an understanding of the order - disorder transition @xcite , strong segregation theory ( sst ) predicts most of the ordered morphologies @xcite , and numerically exact , self - consistent field theory ( scft ) @xcite can resolve the small energetic differences between a variety of competing complex phases . in previous work , we argued that in diblock systems , that as the volume fraction of the inner block grows , ab interfaces are deformed into the shape of the voronoi polyhedra of micelle lattice , and therefore , the free - energy of micelle phases can be computed simply by studying properties of these polyhedra . in particular , we predicted that as volume fraction of inner micelle domain grows the a15 lattice of spheres should minimize the free energy as long as the hexagonal columnar phase ( hex ) did not intervene @xcite .
we corroborated this prediction by implementing a spectral scft @xcite for branched diblock copolymers : in this paper we probe the regime of validity of our analytic analysis through both strong segregation theory and scft .
though there is extremely small variation in the energy between different interfacial geometries , so too is the variation in energy between different stable phases . thus , we compare these two approaches not only by the phase diagram but also through the details of the ordering in the mesophases . since our original _
ansatz _ hinged on the ( minimal ) area of the interface between the incompatible blocks , we will focus strongly on the shape and structure of this interface .
we will explore in detail the relationship between molecule architecture and the polyhedral distortion of the ab interface induced by the lattice packing of micelles to study hexagonal columnar phases .
our results motivate the search for a stable a15 phase which we find in scft . in order to render the sphere - like phases stable in comparison to the hex phase ,
we are obliged to consider asymmetric diblocks ; while symmetric , linear diblock copolymers with an a and a b block have equivalent `` inside - out '' bulk morphologies when the a volume fraction @xmath1 is replaced with the b volume fraction @xmath2 , copolymers with branched or otherwise asymmetric architectures have no such symmetry , and therefore , tend to favor morphologies with one of the two components on the outside " a of curved ab interface ( i.e. on the outside of micelles ) . indeed , our previous scft analysis of branched diblocks is consistent with these findings . because of the challenge of accounting for all the competing effects , in section
ii we implement a full scft for diblocks with the ab@xmath0 architecture to explore the mean field behavior of mitkoarm melts . in section iii
we develop a strong - segregation theory approach for the hexagonal columnar phase which allows us to parameterize a large class of configurations and to explicitly assess the accuracy of the unit - cell approximation ( uca ) , which assumes the lattice voronoi cell to be perfectly cylindrical ( or spherical for three - dimensional lattices ) .
our calculation builds on the kinked - path " calculation of milner and olmsted @xcite , and allows us to explore the influence of the hexagonal micelle lattice on the cylindrical morphology .
we find that the shape of the voronoi cell of the lattice strongly influences the shape of the ab interface . in section
iv we compare the predictions of the full scft calculation to the sst calculation in order to assess the accuracy of the latter .
in addition , we demonstrate how the sst results of section iii can be used to compute an accurate phase boundary for transitions between lamellar ( lam ) to hex configurations .
we briefly discuss the inverse phases ( where the b blocks are on the inside ) in section v. finally , we conclude in section vi .
approximate self - consistent field theory calculations have explored the mean field phase behavior of linear diblocks with asymmetric monomer sizes @xcite which were confirmed through numerically exact scft @xcite .
milner developed sst , applicable in the @xmath3 limit ( @xmath4 is the flory - huggins parameter for a and b monomers and @xmath5 is the degree of polymerization of the copolymers ) , for melts of a@xmath0b@xmath6 miktoarm star copolymers which also incorporates asymmetric monomer sizes @xcite .
generally , the results of all of these calculations show that equilibrium morphologies which have blocks with stronger effective spring constants ( i.e. more arms or smaller statistical segment lengths ) on the outside of curved interfaces are favored over a much larger region of the phase space than in the symmetric diblock case .
the details of the calculation implemented here will be reported elsewhere as a specific case of more general scft calculation for multiply - branched diblocks @xcite .
the method is an extension of matsen and schick s spectral scft calculation for melts of linear @xcite and starblock copolymers @xcite .
given the space group of a copolymer configuration , the mean field free - energy can be computed to arbitrary accuracy .
the results of these scft calculations are accurate to the extent that mean field theory is correct and composition fluctuations can be ignored .
the contributions of these fluctuations tends to zero in the @xmath7 limit @xcite , and therefore we can expect to capture the equilibrium results observed in the ps - pi miktoarm star experiments , for which @xmath8 @xcite .
we consider a melt of fixed volume and number of copolymers , with each molecule composed of @xmath5 total monomers .
the volume fraction of the a - type monomer is @xmath1 . in general
, we could accomodate monomer asymmetry by allowing for two different statistical segment lengths , @xmath9 and @xmath10 , for the a and b species , respectively . in this case , each statistical segment length can be scaled appropriately so that the physical packing length " , @xmath11 , is fixed to the proper value for each of the two chemical species @xcite .
thus , without loss of generality we define a common segment density for the two monomer types , @xmath12 .
moreover , for our scft calculations in this section we will restrict ourselves to the case @xmath13 .
the asymmetry of the copolymers we study arises entirely from their architecture .
each copolymer is composed of one block of pure a monomer joined to @xmath14 blocks of pure b monomer at a common junction point ( see figure [ fig : figure1 ] ( a ) ) .
we computed the full phase behavior for @xmath15 for @xmath16 . to achieve a numerical accuracy of @xmath17 for our free - energy calculations we employ up to 712 basis functions .
this allows a precision in the phase boundary calculations which is better that @xmath18 for @xmath1 and @xmath19 for @xmath20 .
the computed scft phase diagrams are shown in figures [ fig : figure2 ] and [ fig : figure3 ] .
the first notable feature of these phase diagrams is that they are not symmetric about @xmath21 , as is the case for symmetric diblocks phase boundaries are shifted to the right .
this indicates that phases with the @xmath14 b blocks on the outside of curved interfaces are favored . by adopting an interface with non - zero mean - curvature
, the configuration relaxes the blocks on the outside of the ab interface at the expense of an increase in stretching of the inner blocks @xcite . due to the additional asymmetry introduced by the molecular architecture ,
the stability of phases with the b blocks on the outside of highly curved interfaces is enhanced .
moreover , this effect is generally amplified by further increasing the number of b blocks in the molecule .
if we look , for instance , at the boundary between flat and curved interfaces which separates the gyroid ( gyr ) from the lamellar ( lam ) phase , we see that for @xmath22 the transition occurs at @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 for @xmath28 , 2 , 3 , 4 , and @xmath29 , respectively .
likewise , the inverted " morphologies , with b blocks on the inside of curved interfaces , are suppressed because curving the interface inward towards the b domain introduces excess stretching in these blocks .
this pushes the phase boundaries to greater @xmath1 for the inverse structures as well .
we also note the appearance of a stable a15 phase of spherical micelles ( see figure [ fig : figure1 ] ( b ) ) . the a15 phase is also observed in experiments and simulations of another soft molecular system , namely neat mixtures of low molecular weight dendrons @xcite . the stability of this phase has been attributed to the fact that the area of the a15 voronoi cell is the minimal among the voronoi cells of three dimensional periodic structures ( for a given number density ) @xcite .
we have argued that this minimal area makes the a15 lattice stable in the phase diagram of a 3-generation , multiply - branched copolymer @xcite : in the ( extreme ) limit that the ab interface adopts the flat shape of the voronoi cell of the micelle lattice , the a15 phase is stable over other sphere phases , such as bcc and fcc .
thus , the appearance of the a15 phase in these phase diagrams is evidence of a highly distorted ab interface when b blocks compose the outer domains of micelles . due to melt incompressibilty , copolymer configurations must fill the lattice voronoi cell so that the monomer density is uniform @xcite .
the tension of the outer block chains stretching towards the corners of the cell pulls on the interface , distorting it towards the polyhedral shape of the voronoi cell . of course
, the interfacial tension of the ab interface and the tension of the inner blocks will frustrate this distortion , and the interface will actually distort into a rounded polyhedra of the same symmetry as the voronoi cell . in the next sections we will return to this point and will show , nonetheless , that the approximation of flat - faced ab interfaces improves as the number of outer arms grows .
indeed , from figures [ fig : figure2 ] and [ fig : figure3 ] it is clear that increasing the asymmetry increases the stability of the a15 phase ; the window of a15 stability increases further in both the larger @xmath1 and smaller @xmath1 directions . since increasing @xmath14 , the number of b blocks per molecule , stabilizes sphere - like phases over cylindrical phases for larger @xmath1 the a15-hex boundary should move to larger @xmath1 .
moreover , as @xmath14 grows the effective spring constant in the outer blocks grows as @xmath30 : for fixed number of b monomers @xmath31 , there are @xmath14 entropic springs with spring constant @xmath32^{-1}$ ] .
this increased resistance to stretching will lead to a greater polyhedral distortion of the ab interface .
this interfacial distortion is apparent in the oblate shape of the a domains of a15 phase in figure [ fig : figure1 ] ( b ) , corresponding to the oblate shape of voronoi cells of lattice sites on the faces of the @xmath33 unit cube . for larger values of @xmath14 interfaces
approach the shape of voronoi cell at smaller values of @xmath1 and thus the bcc - a15 transition occurs at lower @xmath1 .
of course , for the inverted micelles we expect the opposite to be true ; the tension of the highly stretched inner domains will prefer a spherical interface , ignoring the shape of the voronoi cell .
therefore , we would not expect that the inverse a15 phase is stable at large @xmath1 and we do not find it within scft . at low segregations , near the order - disorder transition ( odt ) , the predicted phase behavior is dramatically altered from the case of linear diblocks . generally , the odt is shifted up to higher @xmath20 , or lower temperature . for symmetric diblocks the critical point , indicating a mean field , second - order disordered ( dis ) to lamellar transition
, occurs at @xmath34 and @xmath21 @xcite .
the critical points of the miktoarm star copolymer melts are shifted , for example , @xmath35 and @xmath36 for @xmath37 and @xmath38 and @xmath39 for @xmath40 .
the upward @xmath20 shift in the odt is consistent with other scft calculations for conformationally asymmetric copolymers @xcite and indicates that chain fluctuations near the odt are systematically altered by molecular asymmetry .
finally , we note that neither the cubic double - diamond nor the hexagonal - perforated lamellar phases are stable in these systems as with symmetric , linear diblocks . in order to compute the strong segregation phase behavior of ab@xmath0 miktoarm star copolymer melts ,
we compute the dis - bcc , bcc - hex , and hex - lam phase boundaries at @xmath41 @xcite . due to the numerical difficulties of considering the gyr and a15 phases for large @xmath20 we do not include these phases in our stability analysis . additionally , we ignore the window of stable closed - packed spheres , fcc , which is predicted by scft calculations to occur near the odt . since we expect
that the free - energy differences between the sphere phases will be relatively small at these strong segregations @xcite our calculation should capture the change from spheres to cylinders .
likhtman and semenov developed a general sst calculation to assess the stability of bicontinuous phases in the limit @xmath3 .
their calculation shows that the gyr phase is unstable when chain fluctuations are ignored @xcite .
it is not known whether the bicontinuous gyr phase is stable for finite but large @xmath20 even within the well studied scft phase diagram of symmetric , linear diblocks @xcite .
recent experiments on melts of fluorinated pi - pee diblocks indeed suggest that this morphology is an equilibrium phase for @xmath42 @xcite , and we expect that the same may be true for more asymmetric copolymers , such as these miktoarm stars .
although we can not prove its stability with our scft calculations , we expect that the gyr phase appears at compositions intermediate to the stable hex and lam regions . in figure
[ fig : figure4 ] we compare our scft results for ab@xmath6 copolymers to the experimental results on polyisoprene ( pi)-polystyrene ( ps ) a@xmath43b@xmath43 @xcite , ab@xmath43 @xcite , ab@xmath44 @xcite , and ab@xmath45 @xcite miktoarm star copolymer melts .
milner showed that sst phase boundaries depend only on @xmath1 , and the asymmetry parameter , @xmath46 , where @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the number of a and b chains per molecule @xcite .
since we are considering symmetric monomers , @xmath13 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 for our ab@xmath0 copolymers , we have simply @xmath51 .
we see from figure [ fig : figure4 ] that scft very accurately captures the observed phase behavior of miktoarm star copolymer melts .
therefore , ignoring composition fluctuations , as scft dictates , does not alter the phase behavior at this level of segregation .
moreover , as the data suggest , the effect of the molecular asymmetry seems to saturate for @xmath52 , and phase boundaries do not change significantly as a function of @xmath1 for further asymmetry @xmath14 .
it has been suggested that the saturation of phase boundaries occurs when the spheres or cylinders of the inner block reach close packing , _ i.e. _ @xmath53 for hex and @xmath54 for the body - centered cubic ( bcc ) lattice @xcite . in the next section
we employ sst to explore how the symmetry of the micelle lattice frustrates their self - assembly , and moreover , how this frustration is related to the saturation of phase boundaries for @xmath55 .
the appearance of a stable a15 phase suggests that the shape of the ab interface is strongly affected by the lattice symmetry for highly asymmetric diblock melts .
tension in the outer block chains maintains a uniform outer domain thickness and consequently distorts the interface into the shape of the voronoi cell .
however , previous studies have demonstrated that for symmetric ab diblocks the shape of the interface , and therefore , the calculation of the free - energy are insensitive to the shape of the voronoi cell @xcite .
the free energy is dominated by the tension of the ab interface , and so the minimal - area cylinder is favored .
because of this , a unit - cell approximation ( uca ) is often taken for the domain shape of the micelles .
for instance , in the columnar and spherical phases , the voronoi cell is approximated by a perfect cylinder or sphere , respectively .
however , packing these cylinders or spheres into a space - filling lattice leaves voids in the interstices which is incompatible with the incompressible melt state .
therefore , the uca can only provide an estimate for the free - energy of these morphologies .
in fact , this estimate is a lower - bound to the true free - energy since distorting the round , approximate unit cells can only raise the free energy either by stretching the outer block or distorting the interface . as our results in the last section suggest , the `` packing frustration '' @xcite between the surface tension and the stretching is highly dependent on molecular asymmetry .
it is also unlikely that the uca can capture the saturation as a function of the number of blocks , @xmath14 ; the close - packing limitation can not be captured in the uca since the inner volumes can fill 100% of the approximate unit - cell without overlap @xcite . in order to quantitatively
explore the role of packing frustration in miktoarm star copolymer melts , we build upon the sst calculation of the hex phase free energy for miktoarm star copolymers @xcite .
olmsted and milner developed a kinked - path " _ ansatz _ for the extension of the copolymer chains , which allows the configuration to maintain a cylindrical ab interface while satisfying the constraints of melt incompressibility ( see figure [ fig : figure5 ] ) . here ,
we extend that calculation allowing the interface to adopt a more general class of interfaces , allowing us to systematically explore the effect of packing frustration in this morphology . within sst we ignore chain fluctuations , in addition to the composition fluctuations absent from the full scft .
we assume that each chain extends only along its classical trajectory , and these paths must be consistent with the constant monomer concentration of the melt state .
following @xcite we divide the hexagonal unit cell into infinitesimal wedges which extend along the direction of the chain paths .
due to incompressibility we must have wedges with a volume fraction of a domain @xmath1 and a volume fraction of b domain @xmath2 .
unless the ab interface adopts the same shape as the voronoi cell , the chains , and consequently the wedges must bend towards the cell corners in order to distribute the volume of the chains evenly .
each chain starts with an a block that extends from the center of the micelle radially to the ab interface at an angle , @xmath56 ( see figure [ fig : figure5 ] ( b ) ) .
this path extends along the vector , @xmath57 , which parameterizes the interface as function of @xmath56 . from that point on the interface
, the outer blocks extend to some other point , at angle @xmath58 , on outer wall of the unit cell , along the vector @xmath59 .
the vector which extends from the center of the micelle to the outer wall of the unit cell at @xmath58 is given by @xmath60 .
we can parameterize the kinking of the wedges by the function @xmath61 which maps the chain position at the interface to the position at the wall of the cell .
therefore , the extension of the b portion of the wedge is given by @xmath62 .
the hexgonal unit cell is parameterized for @xmath63 by @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the cross - sectional area of the micelle and @xmath66 is the radial unit vector . because the configuration is strongly segregated and the inner domain is composed only of a monomers , we consider a class of interfaces which encloses a constant area fraction , @xmath1 , of the total micelle area .
in particular , we would like to consider a class of interfaces which vary from area - minimizing and uniformly curved ( circle ) to stretch - minimizing and polygonal ( hexagon ) .
such a one parameter family of interfaces is : @xmath67 when @xmath68 this is the circle and when @xmath69 it traces out an affinely shrunken version of the hexagonal unit cell ( [ eq : r ] ) . for all other values of @xmath70 $ ]
, the shape interpolates the two extremes ( figure [ fig : figure6 ] ) . by construction
the enclosed area of the interface is @xmath71 for all @xmath72 .
we compute the free energy as a function of @xmath72 and minimize in search of a variational ground state .
we expect the ground state to favor the minimal area , round interface ( @xmath68 ) in the low @xmath1 limit because differences in stretching to the walls and corners of the voronoi cell are small on the scale of the radius of gyration of the outer blocks , @xmath73^{1/2 } $ ] . in the other limit , @xmath74 ,
differences in chains stretching towards the corners and walls becomes large on this length scale , and the hexagonal interface ( @xmath69 ) will be preferred .
we refer to the former case as the round - interface limit ( ril ) and the latter as the polyhedral - interface limit ( pil ) .
of course , there is no guarantee that the true ground state belongs to this class of configurations .
nonetheless , minimizing the free energy over @xmath72 will provide a variational upper - bound on the ground state free energy which is lower than either that from the straight - path calculation or the circular interface calculation .
the essence of the kinked - path approximation is that each wedge must locally satisfy the volume constraint for the diblock so that : @xmath75\times \frac{d}{d \theta } \left[{\bf r}(\theta)+{\bf r}_a(\theta)\right ] = \\ ( 1-f ) { \bf r}_a(\theta)\times \frac{d}{d \theta } { \bf r}_a(\theta)\end{gathered}\ ] ] given the parameterizations introduced in eqs .
( [ eq : r ] ) and ( [ eq : r_alpha ] ) we find that @xmath76 where @xmath77 .
it is easy to verify that @xmath78 has the appropriate limits : when @xmath68 , eq .
( [ eq : tantheta ] ) reduces to the results of ref .
@xcite , and when @xmath79 , @xmath80 , which is the straight - path _ ansatz_.
the free energy has three parts , arising from the interfacial energy , the stretching of the a blocks and the stretching of the b blocks : @xmath81 the interfacial energy per molecule ( in units of @xmath82 ) is given by the effective surface tension , @xmath83 @xcite , times the area of the ab interface divided by the number of chains per micelle : @xmath84 where @xmath65 is the cross sectional area of the micelle and , @xmath85 is the area of the ab interface measured in units of the area of circular interface enclosing the same volume .
we compute the stretching free - energy using the self - consistent parabolic brush potential for melts @xcite as is shown in ref .
for the inner a domain we have @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the reduced stretching moment of the a domain , introduced in ref . @xcite . the stretching term due to the outer b domain is given by @xmath88 where the stretching moment of the b blocks is given by the integral @xmath89 with @xmath90 and @xmath91 with @xmath92 .
combining these terms we have the total free - energy per molecule and minimizing over the dimension of the micelle , @xmath93 , we compute the micelle free - energy per chain in units of @xmath82 : @xmath94^{1/3 } \ , \ ] ] where @xmath95 and @xmath96 is proportional to @xmath97and is independent of composition @xcite .
the inner domain stretching , @xmath98 , and the interfacial area , @xmath99 , are minimized by circular interface at @xmath68 , while the outer domain stretching , @xmath100 , is always minimized for @xmath101 ( though we are only considering @xmath70 $ ] ) .
as @xmath74 the only finite energy configuration is the hexagonal interface with @xmath102 .
minimizing over alpha for @xmath103 and @xmath104 we find the optimum energy interface configurations and show the results in figure [ fig : figure6 ] . in the low @xmath1 limit a round interface is favored due to the relatively lower tension in the b chains . for larger @xmath1 ,
the stretching term of the b chains ( [ eq : f(alpha ) ] ) begins to dominate , distorting the interface towards the hexagon . because of the @xmath105 increase in the effective spring of the outer chains
, it follows that for larger asymmetry the onset of this polyhedral distortion occurs at lower compositions @xmath1 . for high molecular asymmetries , @xmath106 , and a volume fractions larger than @xmath107
, we find equilibrium shapes with @xmath108 . in this case
, the interface is bowed in , away from the walls , and pulled out towards the corners . however , because it is the only finite energy configuration , each solution approaches @xmath102 as @xmath74 .
we expect that the true ground state prefers an interface which asymptotically approaches a hexagonal shape , rather than overshooting " @xmath69 before returning to the @xmath74 limit .
the bowing inward of the interface is due to the oversimplified representation of the interface which does not allow the corners of the interface to relax smoothly towards the corners of the voronoi cell .
nevertheless , this simple representation of the interface shape proves sufficient to capture the effect of the packing frustration introduced by the hexagonal symmetry of the micelle lattice . in order to make contact with the results of scft and experiment
, we need to estimate the value of @xmath72 for an arbitrary interface .
we introduce a numerical measure of the distortion from the circular shape . for copolymer melts in the large @xmath20 limit the ratio of the interfacial thickness to the domain size scales as @xmath109 @xcite ; thus , in the strong segregation limit the interface becomes infinitely thin on the scale of the domain .
we find the location of the interface by the contour for which the volume fraction of a is 0.5 .
one of these contours is shown in the inset of figure [ fig : figure6 ] . using this contour we measure the minimum and maximum distance from the center of the micelle to the interface , @xmath110 and @xmath111 , respectively . as a measure of the distortion from a circular interface
, we introduce @xmath112 which is similar to the normalized amplitude of the @xmath113 modulation of the interface @xcite .
since @xmath114 for the circular interface and @xmath115 for a hexagonal interface , we may define @xmath116 in the two limits @xmath117 and @xmath118 and it can be shown that @xmath119 is never greater than @xmath120 for the class of interfaces parameterized by @xmath121 .
in particular , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 for @xmath124 , and @xmath125 , respectively . by using scft for linear diblock copolymers , matsen and
bates showed that @xmath126 for @xmath1 as large as @xmath127 @xcite , and they concluded that there is negligible distortion so that the effect of packing frustration can be ignored for the hex phase .
however , we find that even for the @xmath28 diblock case , interfacial distortion becomes appreciable for @xmath128 .
while the hex phase is unstable at these compositions for ab diblocks , experiments for melts of abc triblocks yield stable hex phases with a composite ab inner domain volume fraction of about @xmath129 @xcite . for these triblocks , the interface separating the outermost c domain and the b domain
is found to be very nearly hexagonal , demonstrating that packing - frustration in the hex phase is indeed amplified as the volume fraction of the inner domain is increased .
indeed , this frustration can be relieved by adding c - type homopolymer which aggregates in the corners of the hexagonal unit cell , allowing the bc interface to relax to uniform curvature @xcite .
we plot the free - energy of the optimal configuration as a function of composition for the various asymmetries in figure [ fig : figure7 ] . for lower compositions
the free - energy is nearer the uca lower bound . as the composition increases the free - energy approaches the pil upper - bound .
clearly , for large @xmath130 and large @xmath1 the free - energy of our configuration is best approximated by the straight - path upper bound @xcite .
this suggests that for asymmetric copolymers , the ab interface of the hex micelle is significantly deformed from the uniformly - curved configuration over compositions ranges where this phase competes for stability .
we review the consequences of this conclusion for the phase calculation in the next section .
we compare the results of our sst calculation for asymmetric miktoarm star copolymer melts to the more exact " results of our scft calculations for the hex phase .
since the sst approximation results from an asymptotic expansion of the full scft partition function in the @xmath3 limit @xcite , we expect that sst and scft results should agree provided that we have used the approximately correct shape of the ab interface .
strictly speaking we should consider our sst results to be an upper bound on the free - energy of the hex phase since we did not minimize over all possible ground state interface and chain configurations .
nevertheless , we argue that this bound is sufficiently close to the true ground state to capture the phase behavior of asymmetric miktoarm stars .
we use the correspondence between @xmath72 and @xmath131 for @xmath121 as a basis for direct comparison of the predicted values from sst and the `` measured '' values of @xmath131 from scft .
a comparison is made in figure [ fig : figure6 ] for @xmath37 and @xmath40 . despite our simplified representation of interface shape , @xmath121 , and the crude means of measuring the equilibrium scft shape parameter ,
the predicted @xmath72 and computed @xmath131 compare remarkably well .
in particular , the scft results confirm that increasing @xmath1 and @xmath130 increases the equilibrium shape distortion .
there is a systematic tendency in sst to overestimate the hexagonal distortion for low inner domain volume fractions .
this can be attributed to the inadequacy of our interface parameterization , @xmath121 , at low distortions where the ab interface is likely best represented as a constant radius with a superposed @xmath132 modulation @xcite .
nevertheless , the agreement at larger @xmath1 can be taken as evidence that we have accurately accounted for packing frustration for our sst hex phase calculation .
the effect of interfacial distortion on the location of the predicted lam - hex phase boundary for miktoarm star copolymers is shown in figure [ fig : figure8 ] .
there we show ( with dashed lines ) the calculated phase boundaries using both the lower- and upper - bound approximations which assume that the interface and voronoi cell are either both circular ( _ i.e. _ the uca ) or both hexagonal ( _ i.e. _ the pil ) , respectively @xcite .
note that there is no difference between the round and polyhedral voronoi cell for the lam phase , and therefore , no approximation is necessary for this geometry . since the uca calculation underestimates the hex free - energy it overestimates the composition at which the hex phase becomes unstable against the lam phase .
likewise , the upper - bound calculation underestimates the location of the lam - hex phase boundary .
we expect , therefore , that the true lam - hex sst phase boundary should lie between these two approximate boundaries . though the upper - bound of the round - interface limit is close to the uca lower - bound for symmetric diblocks @xcite , the latter can not be used to predict the phase behavior for asymmetric diblock melts in sst , as experimental results suggest @xcite .
this discrepancy is illustrated in figure [ fig : figure8 ] : while scft predicts that the effect of increasing asymmetry saturates for @xmath106 , the uca predicts that the phase boundaries move to larger @xmath1 as @xmath130 increases .
the solid line in figure [ fig : figure8 ] shows the sst phase lam - hex phase boundary computed with the results of the previous section . for @xmath133
the ab interface is nearly undistorted and circular ; thus , the free - energy is best approximated by the lower - bound , uca calculation .
hence , our lam - hex phase boundary follows the uca phase boundary for low asymmetry .
however , for @xmath134 the effect of interfacial distortion becomes important , and the free - energy is closely approximated by the upper - bound , pil calculation .
therefore , for large asymmetry our sst lam - hex boundary tends toward the hexagonal - interface approximation phase boundary .
this transition from the round to the hexagonal interface approximation is also reflected in the scft boundary . indeed , our sst and scft lam - hex phase boundaries agree well in this entire parameter range ( @xmath135 ) .
similarly , we see that hex - bcc boundary computed from scft tends to follow the uca boundary for @xmath136 and follows the polyhedral - interface approximation boundary for @xmath137 , confirming our picture of the effect of packing frustration on asymmetric copolymers .
again , we know that interfacial distortion must be important along the phase boundary between sphere and columnar phases because the a15 , with its minimal interfacial area , is the favored sphere phase there . it would be interesting to pursue a one - parameter class of interfaces that interpolated between a spherical and polyhedral ab interface .
such a calculation would not only predict the spherical - cylindrical micelle phase boundary but it would also elucidate the transition from bcc spheres with nearly spherical interfaces at small @xmath1 to a15 sphere - like micelles with polyhedral interfaces for larger @xmath1 .
we can also see that within the polyhedral - interface approximation calculations , the effect of increasing asymmetry begins to saturate for @xmath138 , as seen in experiment @xcite .
again , this stems from the relative @xmath139 increase in stretching energy of the b blocks over the a blocks . in the large @xmath130 limit
the a block stretching can be ignored , and ( [ eq : f(alpha ) ] ) can be approximated by @xmath140^{1/3}$ ] , where we have assumed that @xmath141 .
the same is true for the free - energy of other morphologies , namely @xmath142 , where @xmath143 lam , a15 , bcc , _ etc .
_ and @xmath144 is some function specific to the morphology which depends only on composition @xcite .
because all free - energies scale the same way with @xmath130 , the location of the transition between any two phases depends only on composition and is independent of @xmath130 in this limit .
it should be noted that the effect of increasing asymmetry saturates for the uca bounds as well , though this occurs very close to @xmath145 for both the lam - hex and hex - bcc boundaries .
the location of phase boundaries computed using the polyhedral - interface approximation saturates near @xmath146 and @xmath147 , for the hex - bcc and lam - hex boundaries , respectively .
while the agreement between , experiment , our scft calculations and our sst analysis for @xmath148 is improved over previous efforts , the sst results appears still to overestimate the effect of increasing asymmetry .
we should note , however , that sst is an asymptotic expansion of the full scft near @xmath3 , and at finite values of @xmath20 we need to assess the importance of higher order corrections .
it is known that lowest order , strong - segregation results are @xmath149 $ ] and that the leading corrections which can distinguish between phases are @xmath150 .
one of these corrections is associated with fluctuations of chain ends and junction points and are thus proportional to @xmath151 @xcite .
the other is associated with a proximal layer near the interface , where the stretching energy of the chains deviates from the predictions of the parabolic brush potential @xcite . at @xmath41
this correction can be as high as @xmath152 , and will surely effect the relative free - energies of competing phases .
further errors arise from the implicit assumption of a parabolic chemical potential used to compute the free - energy associated with molten polymer brushes @xcite .
it has been shown that this approximation is equivalent to allowing for a negative chain end - density near the surface of a convex brush ; nevertheless , it has been shown that relaxing the constraint of a non - negative end - distribution hardly perturbs the free - energy of a two - dimensional convex brush @xcite .
however small , this parabolic chemical - potential underestimates the constrained stretching free - energy of domains on the outside of cylindrical and spherical domains .
a correction to the stretching energy of b domains at large asymmetries of 1% leads to a correction of the full free - energy of order 0.3% .
while this seems small , the difference between upper- and lower - bound sst free - energies is only 3.6% and 6.8% , for the hex and bcc phases , respectively . since even small corrections to the free - energy lead to significant changes in the predicted phase behavior
, we expect approximations of this order may be relevant .
we have applied the sst analysis here to the hex phase where the a domain composes the interior of the micelle and the multiple b blocks compose the outer domain .
these asymmetric configurations have the stiffer " blocks on the outside of micelle , hence , they are responsible for appreciable interfacial distortion .
however , we could also use our sst results to determine the phase behavior of the inverse micelles , where the multiple b blocks composed the inner domain .
assuming that all b chains extend radially from the center of the micelle to the ab interface , we can compute the inverse micelle free - energy by the substitutions @xmath153 and @xmath154 in eq .
( [ eq : f(alpha ) ] ) .
we find , however , that such a calculation produces overestimates of the free - energy .
moreover , the assumption that the b chains stretch only radially is inconsistent with scft results for the inverse phases . figure [ fig : figure9 ] ( a ) shows a real - space a monomer distribution for the hex phase with @xmath155 , @xmath156 and @xmath157 . figure [ fig : figure9 ] ( b ) plots the distribution of a monomer along a horizontal line extending across the micelle for @xmath157 and the inverse phase at @xmath158 . clearly , both configurations are strongly segregated with the volume fraction of the a monomer , @xmath159 , constant outside the inner domain ( @xmath160 for @xmath157 and @xmath161 for @xmath158 ) . however , while the volume - fraction of b component is zero inside the @xmath157 micelle , the volume fraction a component is never zero inside the inverse micelle at @xmath158 .
this shows that in the inverse micelle , the miktoarm star junction points are not strictly confined to a narrow ab interface .
rather , junction points are located somewhere within the inner domain and some of the chains must bend back towards the outer domain instead of stretching radially towards the center of the micelle .
thus the simple sst analysis of section iii does not apply to inverse phases since the assumption that junction points are confined to the ab interface is clearly violated . in order to account for this we would parameterize the distribution of junction points in the micelle , and
minimize the free - energy over the distribution .
moreover , we would need to find the optimal configuration of b blocks , bending inwards and outwards in the micelle .
such a calculation introduces many more degrees of freedom ; minimizing over these is likely very difficult . since scft provides numerically exact results for even very large segregations , it is a much better approach to finding the inverse micelle configurations to determining the phase behavior .
we have implemented sst and scft calculations which elucidate the coupling between the molecular asymmetry of diblock copolymers and packing frustration introduced by the micelle lattice . in particular , we find that the shape of the ab interface is highly sensitive to molecular asymmetry , in the case of our miktoarm star copolymers , the number of b blocks per molecule . for linear diblocks , or otherwise nearly symmetric architectures , we show that the ab interface of micelles in the hex phase is rather insensitive to the shape of voronoi cell and maintains a nearly constant mean curvature shape . however , for ab@xmath0 miktoarm star copolymers with @xmath162 the interface is highly distorted towards the hexagonal shape of the voronoi cell in regions where the hex phase competes for stability .
the effect of this distortion is to shift the predicted hex - lam phase boundary to lower compositions than is predicted by approximating the voronoi cell as a perfect cylinder . as a consequence of the importance of interfaces
, we expect the a15 phase of spherical micelles to be stable for highly asymmetric copolymers due to the minimal area of its voronoi cell amongst lattices in three - dimensions .
this prediction is borne out by our numerical scft calculations which compute the full phase behavior of ab@xmath0 miktoarm star copolymers for @xmath16 .
indeed , we find that as molecular asymmetry is increased , the stability of the a15 phase is enhanced indicating that the polyhedral approximation for the ab interface is more valid as the copolymer architecture becomes more asymmetric .
it is worth noting that the a15 phase of spherical micelles has yet to be identified experimentally in melts of highly asymmetric diblock copolymers .
pochan , gido and coworkers report the appearance of an equilibrium cubic phase of spheres in ps - pi ab@xmath43 copolymer melts in regions of the @xmath163 phase space where we might expect a15 to be stable @xcite .
however , they note that the small - angle x - ray scattering data from these melts can not distinguish between a simple - cubic or bcc micelle lattice ; nor does the data rule out the possibility of the a15 lattice which contains all of the reflections of the bcc lattice .
experiments on sphere phases of more asymmetric miktoarm star copolymers in parameter ranges where a15 should be stable tend to yield poorly ordered arrangements of micelles @xcite . because the a15 and bcc phase are nearly degenerate ( with a free - energy difference on the order of 0.2% ) , the system may be kinetically trapped in some sort of glassy intermediate state in these parameter ranges . despite these difficulties , however , both the robustness of the minimal voronoi cell area principle and the scft calculations strongly indicate that the a15 phase of spherical micelles is an equilibrium phase of copolymer melts of sufficient molecular asymmetry .
it is a pleasure to acknowledge stimulating discussions with b. didonna , g. fredrickson , s. gido , and v. percec .
this work was supported by nsf grants dmr01 - 29804 , dmr01 - 02549 , and int99 - 10017 , by the state of pennsylvania under the nanotechnology institute , and by the university of pennsylvania research foundation .
all boundaries are computed for @xmath156 with the exception of the low-@xmath1 bcc - hex and hex - lam boundaries for @xmath40 , 4 and 5 .
for @xmath40 these boundaries are computed for @xmath164 , and for @xmath155 and 5 these boundaries are computed at @xmath165 . as @xmath3
the phase boundaries become independent of the degree of segregation , @xmath20 , @xcite and thus , we expect that the phase boundaries computed at lower segregation should very closely approximate the higher segregation results . when considering close - packed lattices of spherical micelles , hexagonally close - packed and fcc lattices are known to have degenerate free - energies within mean field theory @xcite . here
, we consider only the free - energy of the phase of @xmath166 symmetry , the fcc phase . | we study ab@xmath0 miktoarm star block copolymers in the strong segregation limit , focussing on the role that the ab interface plays in determining the phase behavior .
we develop an extension of the kinked - path approach which allows us to explore the energetic dependence on interfacial shape .
we consider a one - parameter family of interfaces to study the columnar to lamellar transition in asymmetric stars .
we compare with recent experimental results .
we discuss the stability of the a15 lattice of sphere - like micelles in the context of interfacial energy minimization .
we corroborate our theory by implementing a numerically exact self - consistent field theory to probe the phase diagram and the shape of the ab interface . |
the dynamics studied in this paper owes its origin to a work of bullett @xcite and to a series of articles motivated by @xcite most notably @xcite .
the object of study in @xcite is the dynamical system that arises on iterating a certain relation on @xmath9 .
this relation is the zero set of a polynomial @xmath10 $ ] of a certain form such that : * @xmath11 and @xmath12 are generically quadratic ; and * no irreducible component of @xmath13 is of the form @xmath14 or @xmath15 , where @xmath16 .
the form of @xmath17 above is such that , if @xmath18 denotes the biprojective completion of @xmath13 in @xmath19 and @xmath20 denotes the projection onto the @xmath21th factor , then the set - valued maps @xmath22 are both @xmath23-valued ( counting intersections according to multiplicity ) . in @xcite , this set - up was extended to polynomials @xmath10 $ ] of arbitrary degree that induce relations @xmath24 such that the first map given by is @xmath25-valued and the second map is @xmath26-valued , @xmath27
. it would be interesting to know whether such a correspondence exhibits an equidistribution property in analogy to brolin s theorem ( * ? ? ? * theorem 16.1 ) .
this problem is the starting point of this paper
. the reader will be aware of recent results by dinh and sibony @xcite that , it would seem , should immediately solve the above problem .
_ however , key assumptions in the theorems of @xcite fail to hold for many interesting correspondences on @xmath1 .
_ we shall discuss what this assertion means in the remainder of this section .
we will need several definitions to be able to state our results rigorously , which we postpone to section [ s : results ] . on the dynamics of multivalued maps between complex manifolds : results of perhaps the broadest scope are established in @xcite .
we borrow from @xcite the following definition .
[ d : holcorr ] let @xmath28 and @xmath29 be two compact complex manifolds of dimension @xmath30 .
we say that @xmath31 is a _
holomorphic @xmath30-chain _ in @xmath32 if @xmath31 is a formal linear combination of the form @xmath33 where the @xmath34 s are positive integers and @xmath35 are distinct irreducible complex subvarieties of @xmath32 of pure dimension @xmath30 .
let @xmath36 denote the projection onto @xmath37 .
we say that the holomorphic @xmath30-chain _ @xmath31 determines a meromorphic correspondence of @xmath28 onto @xmath29 _ if , for each @xmath38 in , @xmath39 and @xmath40 are surjective .
@xmath31 determines a set - valued map , which we denote as @xmath41 , as follows : @xmath42 we call @xmath41 a _ holomorphic correspondence _ if @xmath43 is a finite set for every @xmath44 .
[ rem : explcorr ] it is helpful to encode holomorphic correspondences as holomorphic chains .
circumstances arise where , in the notation of , @xmath45 .
for instance : even if we start with a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 determined by an _ irreducible _
variety @xmath46 , composing @xmath47 with itself ( see section [ s : keydefns ] ) can result in a variety that is not irreducible and some of whose irreducible components occur with multiplicity@xmath48 .
suppose @xmath49 is a compact khler manifold of dimension @xmath30 ( @xmath50 denoting the normalised khler form ) and @xmath0 is a meromorphic correspondence of @xmath51 onto itself .
one of the results in @xcite says , roughly , that if @xmath52 , where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the dynamical degrees of @xmath0 of order @xmath55 and @xmath30 respectively , then there exists a probability measure @xmath2 satisfying @xmath56 , such that @xmath57 when @xmath58 , the assumption @xmath52 translates into the assumption that the ( generic ) number of pre - images under @xmath0 is _ strictly larger _ than the number of images under @xmath0 , both counted according to multiplicity . when @xmath59 , the assumption @xmath52 is a natural one
however , none of the techniques in the current literature are of help in studying correspondences @xmath0 for which @xmath60 , even when @xmath61 ( in this paper @xmath62 will denote the khler form associated to the fubini study metric )
. why should one be interested in the dynamics of a correspondence @xmath63 for which @xmath60 ? the work of bullett and collaborators suggest several reasons in the case @xmath64 .
thus , _ we shall focus on correspondences on @xmath1 _ ( although parts of our results hold true for riemann surfaces ) .
a mating of two monic polynomials on @xmath9 is a construction by douady @xcite that , given two monic polynomials @xmath65 $ ] of the same degree , produces a continuous branched covering @xmath66 of a topological sphere to itself whose dynamics emulates that of @xmath67 or of @xmath17 on separate hemispheres . for certain natural choices of pairs @xmath68 , one can determine in principle see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.1 ) when @xmath66 is semiconjugate to a rational map on @xmath1 . in a series of papers @xcite , bullett and collaborators
extend this idea to matings between polynomial maps and certain discrete subgroups of the mbius group or certain hecke groups .
the holomorphic objects whose dynamics turn out to be conjugate to that of matings in this new sense are holomorphic correspondences on @xmath1 .
such correspondences are interesting because they expose further the parallels between the dynamics of kleinian groups and of rational maps .
it would be interesting to devise an ergodic theory for such matings .
_ in all known constructions where a holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 of @xmath1 models the dynamics of a mating of some polynomial with some group , @xmath69_. in this context , to produce an invariant measure and , especially , to give an explicit prescription for it would require that the techniques in @xcite be supplemented by other ideas .
we now give an informal description of our work ( rigorous statements are given in section [ s : results ] ) .
since we mentioned brolin s theorem , we ought to mention that an analogue of brolin s theorem follows from and certain other results in @xcite when @xmath70 . to be more precise
: there exists a polar set @xmath71 such that @xmath72 where @xmath2 is as in with @xmath64 .
this means that we have extremely precise information about the measure @xmath2 .
our first theorem ( theorem [ t : d_1more ] ) uses this information to show that the support of @xmath2 is disjoint from the normality set of @xmath0 , where `` normality set '' is the analogue of the fatou set in the context of correspondences .
when @xmath0 ( a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 ) satisfies @xmath73 , there is no reason to expect .
indeed , consider these examples : @xmath74 , in which case @xmath75 ; or the holomorphic correspondence @xmath76 determined by the @xmath77completion of the zero set of the rational function @xmath78 , in which case @xmath79 . when @xmath73 , we draw upon certain ideas of mcgehee @xcite . we show that if @xmath0 admits a repeller @xmath80 in the sense of mcgehee , which extends the concept of a repeller known for maps having certain properties , then there exists a neighbourhood @xmath81 and a probability measure @xmath2 satisfying @xmath82 , such that @xmath83 a rigorous statement of this is given by theorem [ t : d_1less ] .
the condition that @xmath0 admits a repeller is very natural , and was motivated by the various examples constructed by bullett _
et al_. we take up one class of these examples in section [ s : example ] and show that the conditions stated in theorem [ t : d_1less ] hold true for this class .
observe that differs from in that it does not state that @xmath84 is polar ( or even nowhere dense ) , but this is the best one can expect ( see remark [ rem : care ] below ) .
the measure @xmath2 appearing in and is not , in general , invariant under @xmath0 in the usual measure - theoretic sense ; it is merely @xmath85-invariant .
we direct the reader to the paragraph preceding corollary [ c : d1_less ] for more details . however , equidistribution is a phenomenon that arises in many situations ( see , for instance , the work of clozel , oh and ullmo @xcite , which involves correspondences in a different context ) and is revealing from the dynamical viewpoint .
but if , for a holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 on @xmath1 , @xmath86 , then we can show that there exists a measure that _ is _ invariant under @xmath0 in the usual sense .
this is the content of corollary [ c : d1_less ] below .
in this section , we isolate certain essential definitions that are somewhat long .
readers who are familiar with the rule for composing holomorphic correspondences can proceed to section [ ss : normality ] , where we define the normality set of a holomorphic correspondence .
there are significant differences _ at the level of formalism _ between our definition of the normality set and those that have appeared in the literature earlier .
this definition , which is also a bit involved , thus has a subsection , section [ ss : normality ] , dedicated to it .
let @xmath51 be a complex manifold of dimension @xmath30 .
for any holomorphic @xmath30-chain @xmath31 on @xmath51 , we define the _ support _ of @xmath31 , assuming the representation , by @xmath87 consider two holomorphic correspondences , determined by the @xmath30-chains @xmath88 in @xmath89 .
the @xmath30-chains @xmath90 , @xmath91 have the alternative representations @xmath92 where the primed sums indicate that , in the above representation , the irreducible subvarieties @xmath93 , are _ not necessarily distinct _ and are repeated according to the coefficients @xmath94 .
we define the holomorphic @xmath30-chain @xmath95 by the following two requirements : @xmath96 where the @xmath97 s are the distinct irreducible components of the subvariety on the right - hand side of , and @xmath98 is the generic number @xmath99 s as @xmath100 varies through @xmath97 for which the membership conditions on the right - hand side of are satisfied .
finally , we define the @xmath30-chain @xmath101 if @xmath102 and @xmath103 determine holomorphic correspondences on @xmath51 , then so does @xmath104 .
it requires a certain amount of intersection theory to show this , but the interested reader is directed to section [ s : basic ] for an _ elementary _ proof of this fact when @xmath105 .
the @xmath26-fold iterate of @xmath31 will be denoted by @xmath106 .
given a @xmath30-chain @xmath31 on @xmath51 ( @xmath51 as above ) , we may view @xmath107 as a relation of @xmath51 to itself . in certain sections of this paper
, we will need to make essential use of mcgehee s results from @xcite on the dynamics of closed relations on compact spaces .
let @xmath102 and @xmath103 be as above .
then , the composition of the two relations @xmath108 and @xmath109 in the classical sense ( denoted here by @xmath110 ) which is the sense in which the term is used in @xcite is defined as @xmath111 it is easy to see that for holomorphic correspondences @xmath112 in what follows , we shall adopt a notational simplification . given a @xmath30-chain @xmath31 that determines a holomorphic correspondence , and
there is no scope for confusion , we shall simply denote @xmath41 by @xmath0 .
let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on a compact riemann surface @xmath113 .
the motivation for the concept of the _ normality set of @xmath0 _ is quite simple .
however , we will need some formalism that enables good book - keeping . in this subsection
, we will use the representation for a holomorphic correspondence @xmath31 .
the set of integers @xmath114 will be denoted by @xmath115}$ ] .
given @xmath116 , we say that @xmath117}^n$ ] ( see for the meaning of @xmath118 ) is _ a path of an iteration of @xmath0 starting at @xmath119 , of length @xmath120 _ , or simply an _
@xmath120-path starting at @xmath119 _
, if @xmath121 next , given any two irreducible subvarieties @xmath122 and @xmath123 in the decomposition of @xmath31 in the sense of , we define @xmath124 in general , for any multi - index @xmath125}^j$ ] , @xmath126 , we recursively define @xmath127 in all discussions on the normality set of @xmath0 , we shall work with only those @xmath120-paths @xmath128 that satisfy * _ for each @xmath129 , @xmath130 is an irreducible subvariety of @xmath131 for every sufficiently small ball @xmath132 .
_ an @xmath120-path will be called an _ admissible @xmath120-path _ if it satisfies @xmath133 .
now fix a @xmath134 and @xmath116 , and set @xmath135 we will denote an element of @xmath136 either by @xmath137 or by @xmath138}^n$ ] , depending on the need . observe that if @xmath137 is an admissible @xmath120-path , @xmath139 , then there is a _
unique _ irreducible component of @xmath140 to which @xmath141 belongs , @xmath142 .
hence , if @xmath137 is an admissible @xmath120-path , let us write @xmath143 finally , let @xmath144 , where @xmath145 is a compact riemann surface , denote the desingularization of @xmath146 .
we now have the essential notations needed to define the normality set .
the definitions that follow are strongly influenced by the notion introduced by bullett and penrose @xcite . yet , what we call a `` branch of an iteration '' will look vastly different from its namesake in @xcite .
this is because , for our purposes , we need to attach more detailed labels to all the maps involved than what the notation in @xcite provides .
i.e. , the difference is largely in formalism . the one departure that we make from the bullett
penrose definition is that , in defining a holomorphic branch of an iteration along @xmath137 , we assume that @xmath137 is admissible .
the only purpose of this restriction is that , in proving theorem [ t : d_1more ] , we will require precise accounting of all the branches involved , but _
we do not want the simple motivation for the normality set to be obscured by too much book - keeping paraphernalia .
_ the normality set of @xmath0 is the analogue of the fatou set .
the need for the extra formalism in definition [ d : prenset ] is summarised by the following : * the analogue for the family of all iterates of a map must be the collection of local maps defined by the germ of @xmath147 at @xmath148 , _ whenever this makes sense _ ( around a chosen @xmath119 ) for every @xmath149 and for every @xmath116 . * if one of the germs in @xmath150 has a singularity ( at some point in @xmath151 ) or does not project injectively under @xmath152 , then the above notion of `` local maps '' _ will not _ make sense .
we must replace maps by parametrisations in that event .
let @xmath153 and @xmath154 denote the following projections : @xmath155 where @xmath156 .
we now have all the notations for the key definition needed on the way to defining the normality set of @xmath0 .
a schematic drawing is presented on the following page to give an impression of the various objects occurring in the following definition .
[ d : prenset ] let @xmath113 be a compact riemann surface and let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath113 .
let @xmath116 , @xmath134 , and let @xmath157 . write @xmath158 .
we call the list @xmath159 a _ holomorphic branch of an iteration of @xmath0 along @xmath137 _ if @xmath137 is an admissible @xmath120-path , @xmath160 and @xmath161 are as described above , @xmath162 is a connected neighbourhood of @xmath119 and @xmath163 are holomorphic mappings defined on a planar domain @xmath164 containing @xmath165 such that , for each @xmath129 : * @xmath166 .
* @xmath167 is a finite - sheeted ( perhaps branched ) covering map onto @xmath168 , and @xmath160 maps the latter set homeomorphically onto @xmath169 . * the set @xmath170the irreducible component of @xmath171 containing @xmath141 , where we define @xmath172 , & \text{if $ j\geq 2$. } \end{cases}\ ] ] note that @xmath173 is a ( perhaps branched ) covering map . *
@xmath174 , provided @xmath175 .
[ rem : paramet ] as @xmath137 is admissible , @xmath169 in condition(3 ) is well - defined and the set @xmath168 is a smooth patch parametrising it ( not necessarily diffeomorphically ) ; see , for instance , ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 7 ) .
note that if @xmath0 is a non - constant rational map on @xmath1 then @xmath176 where @xmath164 is a small disc around @xmath165 , satisfy all the conditions in the above definition .
this is the situation that definition [ d : prenset ] generalises .
having defined holomorphic branches , we can give the following definition .
[ d : nset ] let @xmath113 be a compact riemann surface and let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath113 .
a point @xmath134 is said to belong to the _ normality set of @xmath0 _ , denoted by @xmath177 , if there exists a connected neighbourhood @xmath162 of @xmath119 and a _ single _ planar domain @xmath164 containing @xmath165 , which depends on @xmath119 , such that * for each @xmath178 and each @xmath179 , there exists a holomorphic branch @xmath180 of an iteration of @xmath0 along @xmath137 with @xmath181 for every @xmath182 . *
the family @xmath183 is a normal family on @xmath164 .
the set @xmath177 is open , although it is not necessarily non - empty .
if @xmath184 and @xmath162 is the neighbourhood of @xmath119 as given by definition [ d : nset ] , then it is routine to show that @xmath185 .
we need to present some formalisms before we can state our first result . given a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath51 , @xmath186 , determined by a holomorphic @xmath30-chain @xmath31 , its _ adjoint correspondence _
is the meromorphic correspondence determined by the @xmath30-chain ( assuming the representation for @xmath31 ) @xmath187 note that , in general , @xmath188 may not determine a holomorphic correspondence .
however , when @xmath189 , it is easy to see that _ any meromorphic correspondence of @xmath51 is automatically holomorphic_. thus , if @xmath190 is a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 , then so is @xmath191 . in the abbreviated notation introduced in section [ s : keydefns ]
, we shall henceforth write : @xmath192 given a holomorphic @xmath30-chain @xmath31 on @xmath89 , @xmath31 detemines a current of bidimension @xmath193 via the currents of integration given by its constituent subvarieties @xmath38 .
we denote this current by @xmath194 $ ] .
if @xmath0 is the holomorphic correspondence determined by @xmath31 , we _ formally _ define the action of @xmath0 on currents @xmath195 on @xmath51 of bidegree @xmath196 , @xmath197 , by the prescription : @xmath198\right),\ ] ] where , as usual , @xmath20 denotes the projection of @xmath89 onto the @xmath21th factor .
this prescription would make sense for those currents for which the pullback by @xmath199 makes sense and the intersection of this new current with @xmath194 $ ] also makes sense . that this is the case is easy to see when @xmath195 is a smooth @xmath196 form ( hence a current of bidegree @xmath196 on @xmath51 ) .
the reader is referred to ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.4 ) for details .
if @xmath200 is a finite , positive borel measure , then the intersection with @xmath194 $ ] in makes sense . here , @xmath200 is viewed as a current of bidegree @xmath193 .
let us work out @xmath201 for a specific example that is central to this paper .
let @xmath202 and let @xmath203 be the dirac mass at @xmath204 .
the prescription is interpreted as @xmath205 , \pi_1^*\varphi \right\rangle \ : = & \ \sum_{j=1}^n
m_j\langle(\left.\pi_2\right|_{\gamma_j})^*(\delta_x ) ,
\pi_1^*\varphi \rangle \notag \\ = & \
\sum_{j=1}^n m_j\langle \delta_x , \big(\left.\pi_2\right|_{\gamma_j}\big ) _ * ( \pi_1^*\varphi ) \rangle , \label{e : pullbackdirac1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where each summand in the last expression is just the way we define the pullback of a current under a holomorphic mapping ( in this case , @xmath206 ) of an analytic space that is submersive on a zariski open subset .
if @xmath207 is a zariski - open subset of @xmath51 such that @xmath208 is a covering space for each @xmath129 , then , for @xmath209 , @xmath210 is just the sum of the values of @xmath67 on the fibre @xmath211 for any @xmath212 .
thus , when @xmath209 , equals the quantity @xmath213(x ) \qquad x\in { \omega}.\ ] ] for any fixed _ continuous _
function @xmath214 , @xmath215 $ ] extends continuously to each @xmath216 .
we shall denote this continuous extension of the left - hand side of also as @xmath215 $ ] .
in other words , @xmath217 can be defined as a measure supported on the set @xmath218 , and @xmath219(x ) \ ; \ ; \forall x\in x , \ ; \ ; \forall \varphi\in { \mathcal{c}}(x).\ ] ] the arguments preceding continue to be valid if , in , @xmath203 is replaced by @xmath200 , a finite , positive borel measure on @xmath51 .
the push - forward of a current @xmath195 by @xmath0 is defined by the equation @xmath220 whenever the latter makes sense .
we define two numbers that are essential to the statement of our theorems . with @xmath0 as above , let @xmath221 denote the generic number of preimages under @xmath0 of a point in @xmath1 , counted according to multiplicity .
what we mean by `` counted according to multiplicity '' @xmath222 being any zariski - open set of the form discussed prior to the equation , and the @xmath223-chain @xmath31 having the representation is the number @xmath224 which is independent of the choice of @xmath225 . in other words , @xmath221 is the _ topological degree of @xmath0 _ , often denoted as @xmath226 .
define @xmath227 .
we will first consider a holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 of @xmath1 such that @xmath228 .
a very special case of a result of dinh and sibony ( * ? ? ?
* corollaire 5.3 ) is that there exists a probability measure @xmath2 such that @xmath229 where @xmath62 denotes the fubini
study form on @xmath1 , treated as a normalised area form .
let us call this measure the _ dinh sibony measure associated to @xmath0_. since equidistribution is among the main themes of this paper , we should mention that for a generic @xmath230 , @xmath2 is the asymptotic distribution of the iterated pre - images of @xmath3 .
more precisely : [ l : clarify ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 such that @xmath231 and let @xmath2 be the dinh
sibony measure associated to @xmath0 .
there exists a polar set @xmath71 such that for each @xmath232 @xmath233 consequently , @xmath234 .
the above follows by combining with another result from @xcite .
we shall make this clearer for the convenience of readers who are unfamiliar with @xcite through a few remarks at the beginning of section [ s : proof - d_1more ] .
however , fact [ l : clarify ] will have _ no role to play _ herein except to set the context for our first result .
it establishes that the following theorem is a partial generalisation of brolin s observation on the support of the brolin measure @xmath235 ( associated to a polynomial map @xmath67 on @xmath9 ) .
[ t : d_1more ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 and assume that @xmath231 . let @xmath2 be the dinh
sibony measure associated to @xmath0 .
then , @xmath236 is disjoint from the normality set of @xmath0 .
the principle underlying the proof of the above theorem is as follows . for @xmath237
, we shall show that one can apply marty s normality criterion in such a manner as to deduce that the volumes of any compact @xmath238 with respect to the measures induced by @xmath239 are bounded independent of @xmath26 .
the result follows from this , together with the fact that @xmath240 .
the situation is _ very different _ when @xmath241 . to repeat
: we should not expect asymptotic equidistribution of preimages in general , even when @xmath242 , as the holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 whose graph is the @xmath77completion of the zero set of the rational function @xmath78 illustrates .
we require some dynamically meaningful condition for things to work .
it is this need that motivates the next few definitions
. let @xmath51 be a compact hausdorff space and let @xmath243 be a relation of @xmath51 to itself such that @xmath244 .
for any set @xmath245 , we write @xmath246 we define the @xmath26th iterated relation by @xmath247 where the composition operation @xmath248 is as understood from above .
it is useful to have a notion of omega limit sets in the context of iterating a relation analogous to the case of maps .
this definition is provided by mcgehee in ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) . following mcgehee , for a subset @xmath245 ,
let us write @xmath249 ( with the understanding that @xmath250 is the diagonal in @xmath89 ) .
omega limit set of @xmath195 under @xmath67 _ , denoted by @xmath251 , is the set @xmath252 we say that a set @xmath253 is an _ attractor _ for @xmath67 if @xmath254 and there exists a set @xmath162 such that @xmath255 and such that @xmath256 .
these concepts motivate the following two definitions in the context of holomorphic correspondences .
[ d : repeller ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on a riemann surface @xmath51 given by the holomorphic @xmath223-chain @xmath31 .
a set @xmath253 is called an _ attractor _ for @xmath0 if it is an attractor for the relation @xmath107 in the sense of @xcite ( i.e. , as discussed above ) .
a set @xmath257 is called a _ repeller _ for @xmath0 if it is an attractor for the relation @xmath258 .
we must note here mcgehee calls the relation on @xmath51 induced by @xmath258 the _ transpose _ of @xmath107 , and our @xmath258 is @xmath259 in the notation of @xcite .
[ d : strongrep ] let @xmath0 be as above and let @xmath257 be a repeller for @xmath0 .
we say that @xmath257 is a _
strong repeller _ for @xmath0 if there exists a point @xmath260 and an open set @xmath261 such that for each @xmath262 , there exists a sequence @xmath263 such that * @xmath264 ; and * @xmath265 as @xmath266 .
the term _ strong attractor _ has an analogous definition .
we call @xmath267 a _ critical value _ if there exists an irreducible component @xmath38 such that at least one of the irreducible germs of @xmath38 at some point in @xmath268 is either non - smooth or does
_ not _ project injectively under @xmath199 .
we are now in a position to state our next result .
[ t : d_1less ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 for which @xmath241 .
assume that @xmath0 has a strong repeller @xmath257 that is disjoint from the set of critical values of @xmath0 .
then , there exist a probability measure @xmath2 on @xmath1 that satisfies @xmath234 and an open set @xmath81 such that @xmath269 it may seem to the reader that could be stronger , since the theorem does not state that @xmath84 is polar ( or even nowhere dense ) .
however , given that @xmath241 , this is very much in the nature of things .
in this regard , we make the following remark .
[ rem : care ] if @xmath0 is as in theorem [ t : d_1less ] , we _ can not conclude , in general , that the set @xmath84 is polar . _
the following example constitutes a basic obstacle to @xmath84 being even nowhere dense .
let @xmath270 be any polynomial whose filled julia set has non - empty interior .
consider the holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 determined by @xmath271 here , @xmath272 .
note that @xmath273 is a strong repeller .
however , @xmath274 can not contain any points from the filled julia set of @xmath270 .
[ rem : obvbutess ] the reader might ask why one should even address correspondences for which @xmath275 in theorem [ t : d_1less ] , since one gets an invariant measure for such an @xmath0 by merely applying the results in @xcite to @xmath5 .
this is a reasonable question and gives rise to corollary [ c : d1_less ] below but it misses two vital points : * finding invariant measures is not an end in itself in holomorphic dynamics . the goal is to find measures that are sufficiently well - adapted to the correspondence in question that they enable the study of various geometric features of its dynamics . * in many respects , especially concerning the equidistribution - of - preimages phenomenon , correspondences @xmath0 that satisfy @xmath275 behave in ways that are similar to the behaviour of correspondences @xmath276 for which @xmath277 . in studying such phenomena , it makes sense to study both cases as a unified whole .
we will not elaborate on @xmath150 at this juncture .
but theorem [ t : d_1more ] is an illustration of this point .
regarding @xmath278 : consider the polynomial @xmath270 described in remark [ rem : care ] but , this time , also assume that the leading coefficient , say @xmath279 , satisfies @xmath280 .
write @xmath281 , let @xmath282 and let @xmath0 be the correspondence given by @xmath31 .
once again , @xmath273 is a strong repeller for @xmath0 .
it takes a little more effort to show that , with suitable choices for the coefficients of the lower - degree terms , @xmath283 has non - empty interior . as in the example in remark [ rem : care ] , @xmath0 admits a large set @xmath284 such that the iterated inverse images of any @xmath285 equidistribute , but whose complement is _ not polar .
_ this is the similarity that @xmath278 of remark [ rem : obvbutess ] alludes to .
however , in contrast to remark [ rem : care ] , here @xmath286 . from the perspective of studying the problem of equidistribution of _ inverse _ images , theorem [ t : d_1less ] is , to the best of our knowledge , the first theorem concerning the equidistribution problem for holomorphic correspondences @xmath0 such that @xmath241 .
we must point out that , in general , given @xmath228 , the dinh
sibony measure is _ not _ an invariant measure .
( it is what one calls an @xmath85-invariant measure . )
yet there is much that one can do even with this weak sense of invariance which is what is implied by @xmath150 above .
a borel measure @xmath200 is said to be _ invariant under @xmath0 _ if its push - forward by @xmath0 preserves ( compensating for multiplicity if @xmath0 is not a map ) measure of all borel sets i.e. , if @xmath287 .
thus , under the condition @xmath241 , we can actually construct measures that are invariant under @xmath0 : [ c : d1_less ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 for which @xmath241 . 1 .
if @xmath288 , there exists a measure @xmath2 that is invariant under @xmath0 .
2 . suppose @xmath286 .
if @xmath0 has a strong attractor that is disjoint from the critical values of @xmath5 , then there exists a measure @xmath2 that is invariant under @xmath0 .
the proof of theorem [ t : d_1less ] relies on techniques developed by lyubich in @xcite .
given our hypothesis on the existence of a repeller @xmath257 , one can show that there exists a compact set @xmath289 such that @xmath290 and @xmath291 .
this allows us to define a perron frobenius - type operator @xmath292 , where @xmath293 with @xmath294 being the operator given by with @xmath289 replacing @xmath295 .
our proof relies on showing that the family @xmath296 satisfies the conditions of the main result in @xcite .
this goal is achieved , _ in part _ , by showing that for each @xmath297 there are , for each @xmath178 , sufficiently many holomorphic branches of @xmath26-fold iteration of the correspondence @xmath5 .
the examples in remarks [ rem : care ] and [ rem : obvbutess ] have some very special features .
one might ask whether there are plenty of holomorphic correspondences @xmath0 on @xmath1 with @xmath241 _ without _ such rigid features as in the correspondences in remarks [ rem : care ] and [ rem : obvbutess ] that satisfy the conditions stated in theorem [ t : d_1less ] .
one might also ask whether any of the correspondences alluded to in section [ s : intro ] satisfy the conditions in theorem [ t : d_1less ] .
the reader is referred to section [ s : example ] concerning these questions . in the next section
, we shall establish a few technical facts which will be of relevance throughout this paper .
the proofs of our theorems will be provided in sections [ s : proof - d_1more ] and [ s : proof - d_1less ] .
we begin by showing that the composition of two holomorphic correspondences on @xmath1 , under the composition rule , produces a holomorphic correspondence . one way to see this is to begin with how one computes @xmath298 if one is given exact expressions for @xmath299 and @xmath76 .
let @xmath300 be the graph of @xmath301 , @xmath302 , and consider the representations given by .
fix indices @xmath21 and @xmath303 such that @xmath304 and @xmath305 .
it follows that there exist irreducible polynomials @xmath306 $ ] such that @xmath307 see , for instance , @xcite .
now , given any polynomial @xmath308 $ ] , set @xmath309 then , there is a choice of projective coordinates on @xmath1 such that @xmath310,[w_0:w_1])\in { \mathbb{p}^1}\times{\mathbb{p}^1 } : z_0^{d_z(p_1)}w_0^{d_w(p_1)}p_1(z_1/z_0,w_1/w_0)=0\ } , \notag \\ { \gamma^\bullet}_{2,\,l } \ =
\ \{([z_0:z_1],[w_0:w_1])\in { \mathbb{p}^1}\times{\mathbb{p}^1 } : z_0^{d_z(p_2)}w_0^{d_w(p_2)}p_2(z_1/z_0,w_1/w_0)=0\}. \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] with these notations , we are in a position to state our first proposition . [
p : nolines ] let @xmath311 and @xmath312 be irreducible subvarieties belonging to the holomorphic @xmath223-chains @xmath102 and @xmath103 respectively .
let @xmath313 and @xmath314 be the defining functions of @xmath315 and @xmath316 respectively . 1 .
let @xmath317 , where @xmath318 denotes the resultant of two univariate polynomials .
let @xmath319 denote the biprojective completion in @xmath19 of @xmath320 . then @xmath321 .
@xmath319 has no irreducible components of the form @xmath322 or @xmath323 , @xmath324 .
let us write @xmath325 . since two polynomials @xmath326 $ ] have a common zero if and only if @xmath327 , @xmath328 hence , as @xmath47 is the biprojective completion of @xmath329 in @xmath19 , @xmath330 follows . to prove @xmath331 ,
let us first consider the case when @xmath332 $ ] .
then , it suffices to show that @xmath333 has no factors of the form @xmath334 or @xmath335 .
we shall show that @xmath333 has no factors of the form @xmath334 .
an analogous argument will rule out factors of the form @xmath335 . to this end , assume that there exists an @xmath16 such that @xmath336 in @xmath337 $ ] .
this implies @xmath338 thus , for each @xmath339 , the polynomial @xmath340 has a zero in common with @xmath341 $ ] .
note that @xmath342 because , otherwise , @xmath343 , which would contradict the fact that @xmath344 is surjective , @xmath302 .
thus , there exists an uncountable set @xmath345 and a point @xmath346 such that @xmath347 but this implies @xmath348 , i.e. that @xmath349 .
this is impossible , for exactly the same reason that @xmath350 .
hence @xmath333 has no factors of the form @xmath351 .
note that , if we write @xmath352\in { \mathbb{p}^1}:z_1\neq 0\}$ ] , then , arguing as in the beginning of this proof , @xmath353 where @xmath354 is as defined in the beginning of this section .
if we define @xmath355 $ ] by @xmath356 then we get @xmath357 in @xmath337 $ ] .
thus , @xmath358\}\times{\mathbb{p}^1}$ ] is not an irreducible component of @xmath47 . by a similar argument ,
@xmath359\}$ ] is not an irreducible component of @xmath47 either .
it is now easy to see that @xmath104 determines a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 .
let us pick @xmath311 and @xmath312 as in proposition [ p : nolines ] and let @xmath360 be an irreducible component of @xmath361 . by the fundamental theorem of algebra , @xmath362 would fail to be surjective for some @xmath363 only if @xmath360 is of the form @xmath322 or @xmath323 , @xmath324 .
this is impossible by part @xmath331 of proposition [ p : nolines ] .
hence , we have the following : [ c : allokay ] let @xmath102 and @xmath103 be two holomorphic correspondences on @xmath1 .
then @xmath104 is a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1
. the next lemma will be useful in simplifying expressions of the form @xmath364 or @xmath365 .
its proof is entirely routine , so we shall leave the proof as an exercise . [
l : iterate ] let @xmath51 be a compact complex manifold and let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath51
. then @xmath366 .
the final result in this section is important because it establishes that the measures @xmath367 appearing in theorem [ t : d_1less ] are probability measures .
the result below is obvious if @xmath0 is a map .
we could not find a proof of any version of proposition [ p : degreeseq ] in the literature , _ nor could several colleagues to whom we wrote suggest a reference . _
since it appears to be a folk lemma , we provide a proof in the case of @xmath1 .
[ p : degreeseq ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1
. then @xmath368 .
[ rem : moregeneral ] the proof of the above proposition with @xmath1 replaced by _ any _ compact complex manifold @xmath51 is almost exactly the one below .
the only difference is that when @xmath369 those parts of the proof below that rely on part@xmath331 of proposition [ p : nolines ] will follow from the following : * _ let @xmath51 be a compact complex manifold and let @xmath311 and @xmath312 be as in .
the projections @xmath152 and @xmath199 are surjective when restricted to each irreducible component of @xmath361 .
_ since we have not given a proof of the above when @xmath369 doing so would be a considerable digression we state proposition [ p : degreeseq ] for @xmath370 only
. we shall use induction .
the above formula is a tautology for @xmath371 .
assume that it is true for @xmath372 for some @xmath373 .
let @xmath31 be the holomorphic @xmath223-chain that determines @xmath0 .
following the representation , let us denote @xmath374 and let @xmath31 be precisely as in .
then @xmath375 let @xmath376 be a zariski - open subset of @xmath1 such that @xmath377 , @xmath378 and @xmath379 are covering spaces for each @xmath380}\times{[{1}\,.\,.\,{n}]}$ ] .
we can then find a zariski - open subset @xmath47 of @xmath381 such that * @xmath382 , @xmath383 is an at most finite union of lines of the form @xmath322 or @xmath323 , and for each @xmath380}\times{[{1}\,.\,.\,{n}]}$ ] , @xmath384 and @xmath385 @xmath386 . that there is a @xmath47 for which @xmath387 holds true for all pertinent @xmath388 follows easily from part@xmath331 of proposition [ p : nolines ] .
( we shall provide an argument below for a fact analogous to @xmath387 ; a simpler version that argument gives @xmath387 . )
let us write @xmath389 we now fix a @xmath380}\times{[{1}\,.\,.\,{n}]}$ ] .
let us write @xmath390 .
let @xmath97 s , @xmath391 , be the distinct irreducible components of @xmath392 .
it follows from a standard intersection - theory argument ( note that @xmath97 is _ irreducible _ ) , the fact that @xmath393 , and from the structure of @xmath47 , that there is subset @xmath394 such that @xmath395 is a zariski - open subset of @xmath47 and @xmath396 for each @xmath391 and @xmath380}\times{[{1}\,.\,.\,{n}]}$ ] , where @xmath397 is as given immediately after the composition rule . consider the set
@xmath398 this set is clearly a zariski - open subset of @xmath395 , but we claim that @xmath399 is a _ non - empty _ zariski - open set . to this end , consider the sets @xmath400 owing to the part@xmath331 of proposition [ p : nolines ] and the structure of @xmath47 , @xmath401 and @xmath402 are finite sets .
hence @xmath403 then , owing to the property @xmath387 @xmath404 whence our claim .
now , for each @xmath405 , define @xmath406 by the construction of @xmath399 , @xmath407 .
then , by the construction of @xmath47 , @xmath408 let @xmath409 denote the set of all points in @xmath392 that belong to more than one @xmath97 .
then , by @xmath410 recalling our definitions : @xmath411 now let @xmath412 be a zariski - open subset of @xmath1 such that @xmath413 are covering spaces for every @xmath391 and every @xmath380}\times{[{1}\,.\,.\,{n}]}$ ] . then , writing @xmath414 , we have by definition @xmath415 in view of and , the above equation simplifies as follows : @xmath416 .
\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] by induction , the result follows .
we begin this section with a few remarks on fact [ l : clarify ] . for this purpose , we need to invoke one of the results of @xcite
. we shall paraphrase it _ specifically in the context of correspondences on @xmath1 .
_ we leave to the reader the task of verifying our transcription of ( * ? ? ?
* thorme 4.6 ) to the present context .
it might however be helpful for those readers who are unfamiliar with @xcite if we mention a couple of identities .
we shall not define here the notion of _ intermediate degrees of @xmath0 of order @xmath417 _ ; the reader is referred to ( * ? ? ?
* section 3.1 ) .
( the proof of the following fact just involves writing out the relevant definitions in two different ways . )
[ l : topdeg ] let @xmath49 be a compact khler manifold of dimension @xmath30 and assume @xmath418 .
let @xmath419 be a holomorphic correspondence .
let @xmath420 denote the intermediate degree of @xmath0 of order @xmath417 , @xmath421 . then : * @xmath422 .
* @xmath423 . in what follows @xmath62 shall denote the fubini
study form normalised so that @xmath424 .
the key result needed is : [ r:1stres ] let @xmath425 , @xmath426 , be holomorphic correspondences of @xmath1 .
suppose the series @xmath427 converges .
then , there exists a polar set @xmath428 such that for each @xmath232 , @xmath429 for each @xmath430 and , in fact , this convergence is uniform on subsets that are bounded with respect to the @xmath431-norm .
let us take the @xmath432 s of result [ r:1stres ] to be @xmath433 , @xmath434 since any function in @xmath435 can be approximated in the sup - norm by functions in @xmath436 , the weak@xmath437 convergence asserted by fact [ l : clarify ] follows from , result [ r:1stres ] and proposition [ p : degreeseq ] .
one concern that ( perhaps ) arises when we use the results of @xcite is the way we compose two holomorphic correspondences .
the composition rule presented in @xcite appears to be _ very different _ from that given by .
if either @xmath102 or @xmath103 determines a meromorphic , _ non - holomorphic _ correspondence , then may not result in a meromorphic correspondence .
this is the phenomenon that the composition rule in @xcite addresses . in our setting
, this problem does not arise .
in fact , the rule in @xcite is equivalent to when both @xmath102 and @xmath103 are holomorphic ; see ( * ? ? ?
* section 4 ) for more details .
we now present : we assume that @xmath237 ; there is nothing to prove otherwise .
let us fix a @xmath184 .
then , any @xmath179 is admissible , and by property(4 ) of definition [ d : prenset ] , assuming that @xmath438 , we get @xmath439 iterating this argument , we deduce the following : @xmath440 let us now _ fix _ a disc @xmath441 around @xmath442 such that @xmath443 ( where @xmath164 is as given by definition [ d : nset ] ) .
define @xmath444}}\bigcap_{x\in \pi_1^{-1}\{z_0\}\cap{\gamma^\bullet}_j } \pi^0_1\circ\nu_{((z_0,\pi_2(x);\,j),1)}\circ\psi_{((z_0,\pi_2(x);\,j),1)}({\overline{\delta}}).\ ] ] clearly , there is a region @xmath445 , containing @xmath165 , such that @xmath446 where @xmath447 is our abbreviation for the subscript @xmath448 and @xmath449 is as described in property(3 ) of definition [ d : prenset ] . from the above fact and we deduce the following : @xmath450 we can deduce from definitions [ d : prenset ] and [ d : nset ] that @xmath451 . as @xmath452 has non - empty interior , it suffices to show that for any _ non - negative _ function @xmath453 with @xmath454 , @xmath455 .
hence , let us pick some function @xmath453 as described . for any path @xmath456 ,
let us write @xmath457 we adopt notation analogous to that developed just before definition [ d : prenset ] .
for any multi - index @xmath125}^j$ ] , @xmath126 , @xmath458 , let us define @xmath459 then , @xmath460 is a @xmath461-open neighbourhood of the point @xmath462 .
furthermore , by our constructions in definition [ d : prenset ] , @xmath463 is covered by the sets @xmath460 as @xmath137 varies through @xmath464 .
hence , by definition : @xmath465 it is routine to show that @xmath466 is a branched covering map onto its image . as @xmath467 maps @xmath468 homeomorphically onto @xmath469 , the topological degree of @xmath470 equals the the topological degree of @xmath466 .
let us denote this number by @xmath471 . by the change - of - variables formula ,
we get : @xmath472 since @xmath460 , in general , has singularities , we discuss briefly what is meant above by `` change - of - variables formula '' .
note that : * the magnitude of the form @xmath473 stays bounded on punctured neighbourhoods of any singular point of @xmath460 . * @xmath474 after at most finitely many punctures is the image of a zariski - open subset of @xmath468 under a @xmath471-to-1 covering map .
given these facts , it is a standard calculation that the right - hand side of transforms to the last integral above . for each @xmath179 ,
let us write @xmath475 by the change - of - variables formula for branched coverings of finite degree , we get : @xmath476 the last expression arises from and the fact that @xmath454 .
endow @xmath1 with homogeneous coordinates .
in view of the argument made below , we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath477 does not contain _ both _
@xmath478 $ ] and @xmath479 $ ] ( if not , then for each @xmath26 and each @xmath179 for which this happens , we split the relevant integral below into a sum of integrals over a two - set partition of @xmath164 ) . write @xmath480,\ ] ] where @xmath481 and have no common zeros in @xmath164 , and define @xmath482\in \pi^n_n\circ\nu_{({\boldsymbol{\mathcal{z}}},n)}\circ\psi_{({\boldsymbol{\mathcal{z}}},n)}({d})$ } , \\
y_{({\boldsymbol{\mathcal{z}}},n)}/x_{({\boldsymbol{\mathcal{z}}},n ) } , & \text{if $ [ 1:0]\in \pi^n_n\circ\nu_{({\boldsymbol{\mathcal{z}}},n)}\circ\psi_{({\boldsymbol{\mathcal{z}}},n)}({d})$}. \end{cases}\ ] ] from the expression for the fubini study metric in local coordinates and from
, we have the estimate @xmath483 since , by hypothesis , @xmath484 is a normal family , it follows by marty s normality criterion see , for instance , conway ( * ? ? ?
* chapter vii/3 ) that the family @xmath485 is locally uniformly bounded . as @xmath445 , there exists an @xmath486 such that @xmath487 given @xmath178 , the number of summands in is at most @xmath488 .
the equality is a consequence of proposition [ p : degreeseq ] and lemma [ l : iterate ] . from it and
the last two estimates , it follows that @xmath489^n\!m^2 { \sf area}(\overline{g } ) \;{\longrightarrow}\ ; 0 \ \text{as $ n\to \infty$,}\ ] ] since , by hypothesis , @xmath70 . in view of (
* corollaire 5.3 ) applied to @xmath1 with @xmath490 , i.e. the limit , and by , we have @xmath491 in view of our remarks earlier , the theorem follows .
as the paragraphs in section [ s : results ] preceding the statement of theorem [ t : d_1less ] would suggest , its proof relies on several notions introduced in @xcite .
we therefore begin this section with a definition and a couple of results from @xcite .
[ d : attrblock ] let @xmath51 be a compact hausdorff space and let @xmath243 be a relation of @xmath51 to itself such that @xmath244 .
a set @xmath492 is called an _ attractor block _ for @xmath67 if @xmath493 .
we recall that , given a relation @xmath67 and a set @xmath245 , @xmath494 is as defined in section [ s : results ] .
[ r : mcg_block ] let @xmath51 be a compact hausdorff space and let @xmath243 be a relation of @xmath51 to itself such that @xmath244 .
assume @xmath67 is a closed set .
if @xmath289 is an attractor block for @xmath67 , then @xmath289 is a neighbourhood of @xmath495 .
[ r : mcg_chooseblock ] let @xmath51 be a compact hausdorff space and let @xmath243 be a relation of @xmath51 to itself such that @xmath244 .
assume @xmath67 is a closed set .
if @xmath496 is an attractor for @xmath67 and @xmath47 is a neighbourhood of @xmath496 , then there exists a closed attractor block @xmath289 for @xmath67 such that @xmath497 and @xmath498 .
we clarify that , given two subsets @xmath279 and @xmath289 of some topological space , @xmath289 is called a neighbourhood of @xmath279 here ( as in @xcite ) if @xmath499 . before we can give the proof of theorem [ t : d_1less ] , we need one more concept . for this purpose
, we shall adapt some of the notations developed in section [ ss : normality ] . here
, @xmath0 will denote a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 .
firstly : given @xmath116 , we say that @xmath500}^n$ ] ( see for the meaning of @xmath118 ) is _ a path of a backward iteration of @xmath0 starting at @xmath501 , of length @xmath120 _ , if @xmath502 in analogy with the notation in section [ ss : normality ] , we set : @xmath503 next , we say that a point @xmath267 is a _ regular value _ of @xmath0 if it is not a critical value ( recall that we have defined this in section [ s : results ] ) .
we can now make the following definition : [ d : invregbr ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 , let @xmath116 , and let @xmath504 .
let @xmath505 .
we call the list @xmath506 a _ regular branch of a backward iteration of @xmath0 along @xmath507 _ if : * @xmath508 are regular values . * for each @xmath129 , @xmath509 is a holomorphic function defined by @xmath510 where @xmath511 is a _ local _
irreducible component of @xmath512 at the point @xmath513 such that : @xmath150 @xmath511 is smooth ; @xmath278 @xmath199 restricted to @xmath511 is injective ; and @xmath514 @xmath515 when @xmath516 .
the above is a paraphrasing for the scenario in which we are interested of the notion of a `` regular inverse branch of @xmath0 of order @xmath120 '' introduced by dinh in @xcite .
the following is the key proposition needed to prove theorem [ t : d_1less ] .
[ p : key - d_1less ] let @xmath0 be a holomorphic correspondence of @xmath1 having all the properties stated in theorem [ t : d_1less ] and let @xmath257 be a strong repeller that is disjoint from the set of critical values of @xmath0 . then , there exists a closed set @xmath517 such that @xmath518 and such that : * the operator @xmath519 , where @xmath294 is as defined in with @xmath289 replacing @xmath295 , maps @xmath520 into itself .
* there exists a probability measure @xmath521 that satisfies @xmath522 and such that @xmath523-{\int_{\raisebox{1pt}{$\scriptstyle { { b}}$}}\!{\varphi}}\,d\mu_b\right| \
= \ 0 \quad\forall \varphi\in { \mathcal{c}}(b;{\mathbb{c}}).\ ] ] let @xmath260 and let @xmath162 be an open set containing @xmath257 such that : * for each @xmath262 , there is a sequence @xmath263 such that @xmath524 for each @xmath26 , and @xmath265 as @xmath266 .
* @xmath162 contains no critical values of @xmath0 . by result [ r : mcg_block ] and
result [ r : mcg_chooseblock ] , we can find an open neighbourhood @xmath525 of @xmath257 such that @xmath526 and @xmath527 is a closed attractor block for the relation @xmath258 .
repeating the last argument once more , we can find a closed attractor block , @xmath289 , for @xmath258 such that @xmath528 by the above chain of inclusions and by the definition of the term `` attractor block '' , it follows that the operator @xmath529 maps @xmath520 into itself .
* claim 1 . *
_ for each fixed @xmath530 , @xmath531\}_{n\in { \mathbb{z}}_+}$ ] is an equicontinuous family . _
it is easy to see that @xmath257 is a closed _ proper _ subset .
we can thus make a useful observation : * we can choose @xmath525 so that @xmath532 is non - empty .
hence , we can choose coordinates in such a way that we may view @xmath525 as lying in @xmath9 , and that @xmath533 .
we shall work with respect to these coordinates in the remainder of this proof .
let us pick a point @xmath501 in @xmath289 ( which , by construction , is a regular value ) and let @xmath534 be a small disc centered at @xmath501 such that @xmath535 .
let us fix an @xmath536 and consider a path @xmath537 . recall that , by construction : @xmath538 we can infer from that there exists a regular branch @xmath506 of a backward iteration of @xmath0 along @xmath507 . to see why , first note that , as @xmath501 is a regular value and @xmath535
, we get : 1 . there is an open neighbourhood @xmath539 of @xmath501 containing only regular values .
2 . writing @xmath540 and defining @xmath541any one of the irreducible components of the ( local ) complex - analytic variety @xmath542 , the function @xmath543 3 .
the open set @xmath544 and hence contains only regular values .
the assertion @xmath545 follows from the fact that @xmath546 and that the latter contains no critical values .
let us now , for some @xmath156 , @xmath547 , _ assume _ the truth of the statements @xmath548 , @xmath549 and @xmath550 , which are obtained by replacing all the subscripts @xmath165 and @xmath223 in @xmath551 , @xmath552 and @xmath545 ( _ except _ the subscript in @xmath152 ) by @xmath553 and @xmath30 , respectively .
now , @xmath554 follows from @xmath550 . defining @xmath555 in exact analogy to @xmath556 , and writing @xmath557 the holomorphicity of @xmath558 follows from @xmath554 and our definition of a regular value of @xmath0 .
thus @xmath559 holds true .
we get @xmath560 by appealing once again to and using the fact that @xmath561 . by induction
, therefore , a regular branch of a backward iteration of @xmath0 along @xmath507 exists .
we thus conclude the following : * @xmath562 ; and * @xmath563 ( see @xmath564 above ) .
recall that @xmath507 was arbitrarily chosen from @xmath565 and that the arguments in the last two paragraphs hold true for any choice of @xmath511 , @xmath566 , and for any @xmath116 .
thus , by montel s theorem , we infer the following important fact : the family @xmath567 pick a @xmath530 and let @xmath568 . as @xmath289 is compact , there exists a number @xmath569 such that : @xmath570 we pick a @xmath571 . by taking @xmath572 in the discussion in the previous paragraph
, we infer from the normality of the family @xmath573 that we can find a sufficiently small number @xmath574 such that : @xmath575 now , for each @xmath571 write : @xmath576 if @xmath577 is a path of backward iteration ( with @xmath578 being the above @xmath579 ) , basic intersection theory tells us that the local intersection multiplicity of @xmath512 with @xmath580 at @xmath581 equals the number of distinct branches @xmath582 one can construct according to the above inductive prescription ( this number is greater than @xmath223 if @xmath512 has a normal - crossing singularity at @xmath581 ) . from this , and from the iterative construction of the @xmath583 s above , it follows that : @xmath584 \ = \ d_1(f)^n \;\;\ ; \forall { \zeta}\in b.\ ] ] from , and , we get : @xmath585(\xi)-{\mathbb{a}}_b^n[\varphi]({\zeta})| \ = \ & \left|\sum_{(\psi,{\boldsymbol{\mathcal{w}}})\in { \mathscr{i\!\!b}}(n,{\zeta})}\!\!\!d_1(f)^{-n } ( \varphi\circ\psi({\zeta})-\varphi\circ\psi(\xi))\right| \notag \\
\leq \ & d_1(f)^{-n}\!\!\!\sum_{(\psi,{\boldsymbol{\mathcal{w}}})\in { \mathscr{i\!\!b}}(n,{\zeta})}\!\!\!|\varphi\circ\psi({\zeta})-\varphi\circ\psi(\xi)| \
< \ { \varepsilon}\notag \\ & \forall\xi \in b \ \text{such that $ |\xi-{\zeta}| < r({\varepsilon},\xi)$ and $ \forall n\in { \mathbb{z}}_+$. } \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above holds true for each @xmath571 .
this establishes claim 1 . in what follows
, the term _ unitary spectrum _ of an operator on a complex banach space will mean the set of all eigenvalues of the operator of modulus @xmath223 , which we will denote by @xmath586 .
it follows from the above claim and from @xcite that @xmath587 .
* claim 2 : * _ @xmath588 , and the eigenspace associated with @xmath223 is @xmath9 .
_ the ingredients for proving the above claim are largely those of @xcite .
however , to make clear the role that the properties of @xmath257 play , we shall rework some of the details of lyubich s argument .
let us fix a @xmath589 and let @xmath590 be an associated eigenfunction .
let @xmath591 be such that @xmath592 . by definition @xmath593 the above equality would fail if , for some @xmath594 occurring above , @xmath595 .
furthermore , if , for some @xmath594 occurring above , @xmath596 and @xmath597 do not lie on the same ray through @xmath442 , then cancellations would lead to ( recall the fact and that @xmath598 ) @xmath599 which is a contradiction .
thus @xmath600 .
iterating , we get @xmath601 since , by construction , @xmath602 , there exists an @xmath603 , such that @xmath604 .
therefore , owing to , the sequence @xmath605 is a convergent sequence . as @xmath606 ( by definition )
, this implies that @xmath607 .
observe that , having determined that @xmath608 , also gives @xmath609 note that @xmath610 } = { \mathbb{a}}[\overline{\varphi } ] \
\forall\varphi\in { \mathcal{c}}(b;{\mathbb{c}})$ ] .
hence , @xmath611 and @xmath612 are also eigenvectors of @xmath613 associated to @xmath608 .
thus , we have the following analogue of : @xmath614 where @xmath615 stands for either a point of global maximum or a point of global minimum of @xmath611 . using the above as a starting point instead of and repeating , with appropriate modifications , the argument that begins with and ends at ,
we get : @xmath616 similarly , we deduce that : @xmath617 combining the above with , we conclude that , for any eigenvector @xmath618 associated to @xmath608 , @xmath619 .
this establishes claim 2 . to complete this proof , we need the following : [ r : lyubich_abs ] let @xmath620 be a complex banach space .
let @xmath621 be a linear operator such that @xmath622 is a relatively - compact subset of @xmath620 for each @xmath623 .
assume that @xmath624 and that @xmath223 is a simple eigenvalue .
let @xmath625 be an invariant vector of @xmath279 .
then , there exists a linear functional @xmath200 that satisfies @xmath626 and @xmath627 , and such that @xmath628 for each @xmath623 .
take @xmath629 in the above theorem .
note that @xmath630|$ ] is bounded by @xmath631 for @xmath434 thus , in view of claims 1 and 2 , @xmath529 satisfies all the hypotheses of result [ r : lyubich_abs ] .
hence ( recall that the function that is identically @xmath223 on @xmath289 is an eigenvector of @xmath529 ) there is a regular complex borel measure @xmath632 on @xmath289 such that @xmath633 , and @xmath634-{\int_{\raisebox{1pt}{$\scriptstyle { { b}}$}}\!{\varphi}}\,d\mu_b\right| \
= \ 0 \quad\forall \varphi\in { \mathcal{c}}(b;{\mathbb{c}}).\ ] ] it is clear from the above equation that @xmath632 is a positive measure .
hence it is a probability measure on @xmath289 .
let @xmath289 be any closed set having the properties listed in the conclusion of proposition [ p : key - d_1less ] .
let @xmath632 be the probability measure associated to this @xmath289 .
we claim that @xmath2 is given by defining : @xmath635 we must show that @xmath2 does not depend on the choice of @xmath289 .
the proof of this is exactly as given in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem1 ) .
we fix a point @xmath636 .
so , @xmath637 for any choice of @xmath289 .
thus , @xmath638(z ) & & ( \text{by proposition~\ref{p : key - d_1less } } ) \notag \\ & = \
\lim_{n\to \infty}d_1(f)^{-n}{\boldsymbol{\lambda}}^n[\varphi](z ) , & & ( \text{since $ { { } ^\dagger\!f}^n(z)\subset { { } ^\dagger\!f}^n({\mathcal{r}})\subset { \mathcal{r}}$ } ) \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath639 is as described in the passage following .
the last line is independent of @xmath289 .
hence the claim . by the above calculation
, we also see that @xmath640 .
thus , @xmath2 is a probability measure .
let @xmath162 be the open set described at the beginning of the proof of proposition [ p : key - d_1less ] .
we now define : @xmath641 we see from the proof of proposition [ p : key - d_1less ] that , owing to our hypotheses , @xmath642 is non - empty .
hence @xmath643 is a non - empty open set that contains @xmath257 .
let @xmath297 .
there exists a @xmath644 such that @xmath645 .
a close look at the essential features of its proof reveals that this @xmath289 has all the properties listed in the conclusion of proposition [ p : key - d_1less ] .
consider any @xmath646 .
we now apply lemma [ l : iterate ] to get @xmath647(z ) & & ( \text{from \eqref{e : pullbackdirac2 } and lemma~\ref{l : iterate } } ) \notag \\
= \ & { \mathbb{a}}_b^n[\varphi](z ) & & ( \text{since $ { { } ^\dagger\!f}^n(z)\subset { { } ^\dagger\!f}^n(b^\circ)\subset b$ } ) \notag \\ & { \longrightarrow}\ { \int_{\raisebox{1pt}{$\scriptstyle { { { \mathbb{p}^1}}}$}}\!{\varphi}}\,d\mu_f \;\ ; \text{as $ n\to \infty$ } , \label{e : quasi - eqd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and this holds true _ for any @xmath297_. the last line follows from our observations above on @xmath2 . now note that , by construction , @xmath648 for each @xmath297 .
therefore , in view of equation , it follows from that @xmath82 .
we are now in a position to provide : recall that , by definition , for any borel measure @xmath200 , @xmath649 .
thus , the proof of corollary [ c : d1_less ] involves , in each case , applying one of the results above to @xmath5 .
the proof @xmath330 follows from fact [
l : clarify ] applied to @xmath5 . in view of definitions [ d : repeller ] and [ d : strongrep ] and the hypothesis of part @xmath331
, @xmath5 satisfies the conditions of theorem [ t : d_1less ] ( i.e. , with @xmath5 replacing @xmath0 ) .
thus , @xmath331 follows from theorem [ t : d_1less ] .
the purpose of this section is to provide concrete examples that illustrate some of our comments in sections [ s : intro ] and [ s : results ] about the extent to which our results apply to interesting correspondences on @xmath1 .
we shall begin by showing that it is easy to construct examples of holomorphic correspondences on @xmath1 that satisfy all the conditions stated in theorem [ t : d_1less ] , but , unlike the examples discussed in remarks [ rem : care ] and [ rem : obvbutess ] , have `` large '' repellers .
after this , we shall discuss one of the classes of holomorphic correspondences studied by bullett and collaborators .
for each correspondence @xmath0 in this class , @xmath650 , and we shall show that theorem [ t : d_1less ] and corollary [ c : d1_less]@xmath331 are applicable to these examples . choose a complex polynomial @xmath651 with @xmath652 such that its julia set @xmath653 and such that no critical values of @xmath651 lie in @xmath654 . it follows see , for instance , @xcite that there is a compact set @xmath289 such that @xmath655 and avoids the critical values of @xmath651 , and such that @xmath656 .
next , choose a polynomial @xmath657 with @xmath658 and having the following properties : next , we define : @xmath662 , [ w_0:w_1 ] ) : w_0^{{\rm deg}(q)}z_1-w_0^{{\rm deg}(q)}z_0\,q(w_1/w_0 ) = 0\ } , \notag \\
\gamma_2 \ & : = \ \{([z_0:z_1 ] , [ w_0:w_1 ] ) : w_1z_0^{{\rm deg}(p)}-w_0z_0^{{\rm deg}(p)}p(z_1/z_0 ) = 0\}. \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] the projective coordinates are so taken that @xmath478 $ ] stands for the point at infinity .
we set @xmath663 and let @xmath0 denote the correspondence determined by @xmath31 .
clearly @xmath664 . in this type of construction
, we will have @xmath288 in general .
however , apart from satisfying the rather coarse properties @xmath150 and @xmath278 above , @xmath651 and @xmath657 can be chosen with considerable independence from each other .
thus , this construction will also produce holomorphic correspondences @xmath0 that satisfy @xmath286 . by construction , @xmath665 .
in other words , @xmath289 an attractor block for the relation @xmath258 .
therefore , it follows from result [ r : mcg_block ] and definition [ d : repeller ] that @xmath0 has a repeller @xmath290 ; this repeller is just @xmath666 .
it is easy to see that @xmath667 ( the reader may look up ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.1 ) for a proof ) .
the above implies that @xmath668 thus , the correspondence @xmath0 defined above has a repeller that is disjoint from the set of critical values of @xmath0 . owing to @xmath150 and @xmath278 above , for each @xmath669
, there exists a point @xmath524 such that @xmath670 .
hence , @xmath257 is a strong repeller . unlike the examples in remarks
[ rem : care ] and [ rem : obvbutess ] , @xmath257 is `` large '' in a certain sense .
the ideas developed in the last section are of relevance to the correspondences alluded to in section [ s : intro ] introduced by bullett and his collaborators .
we shall examine one such class of correspondences .
we shall not elaborate here upon what precisely is meant by the mating between a quadratic map on @xmath1 and a kleinian group .
the idea underlying this concept is simple , but a precise definition requires some exposition .
we will just state here ( rather loosely ) that such a mating provides a holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 on @xmath1 , and partitions @xmath1 into an open set and two - component closed set ( denoted below by @xmath671 ) both totally invariant under @xmath0 such that the action of the iterates of @xmath0 on @xmath672 resembles the action of the given kleinian group on its regular set , and the iterates of distinguished branches of @xmath0 and @xmath5 on the components of @xmath671 , respectively resemble the dynamics of the given quadratic map on its filled julia set .
we refer the reader to the introduction of @xcite or to @xcite .
the example we present here is that of a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 that realises a mating between certain faithful discrete representations @xmath673 in @xmath674 of @xmath675 and a quadratic map @xmath676 . in this discussion ,
@xmath673 and @xmath677 will be such that : the fact that is pertinent to this discussion is that the mating of the above two objects is realisable as a holomorphic correspondence @xmath0 on @xmath1 .
this is the main result of the article @xcite by bullett and harvey .
for such an @xmath0 , @xmath650 .
( in fact , ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) establishes the latter fact for a much larger class of maps @xmath678 . for simplicity , however , we shall limit ourselves to the assumptions above . )
let @xmath31 denote the holomorphic @xmath223-chain that determines the correspondence provided by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) .
let us list some of the features of @xmath0 that are relevant to the present discourse ( we will have to assume here that readers are familiar with @xcite ) : * there exists a closed subset @xmath681 that is totally invariant under @xmath0 and is the disjoint union of two copies @xmath682 and @xmath683 of a homeomorph of a closed disc .
* there exist two open neighbourhoods @xmath684 and @xmath685 of @xmath683 such that * * @xmath686 ; * * @xmath687 is the union of the graphs of two functions @xmath688 , @xmath689 ; * * @xmath690 ; * * there is a quasiconformal homeomorpism of @xmath684 onto an open neighbourhood @xmath691 of @xmath679 that carries @xmath683 onto @xmath679 , @xmath692 onto the julia set of @xmath678 , is conformal in the interior of @xmath683 , and conjugates @xmath693 to @xmath694 . * * @xmath695 .
* there exist two open neighbourhoods @xmath696 and @xmath697 , @xmath698 , of @xmath682 and a pair of functions @xmath699 such that @xmath700 and the analogues of the properties @xmath701@xmath702 obtained by swapping the `` @xmath703 '' and the `` @xmath704 '' superscripts hold true .
* @xmath705 and @xmath706 .
we must record that property @xmath707 is stated in @xcite without some of the features stated above .
however , it is evident from sections 3 and 4 of @xcite that ( under the assumptions stated at the beginning of this subsection ) there is a hybrid equivalence , in the sense of douady hubbard , between @xmath708 and @xmath709 .
the julia set of @xmath678 , @xmath710 , is a strong repeller for @xmath678 in the sense of definition [ d : strongrep ] .
furthermore ( see @xcite , for instance ) there exists a neighbourhood basis of @xmath710 , @xmath711 , say , such that @xmath712 also note that , from properties @xmath713@xmath702 , the generic number of pre - images of any @xmath714 under @xmath0 equals @xmath23 . from this and
, we can deduce that there exists a closed set @xmath289 such that @xmath715 , @xmath716 and @xmath717 since @xmath716 , it is not hard to show ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 5.4 ) , for instance , for a proof ) that the right - hand side above equals @xmath718 .
then , by definition , we have : furthermore , as @xmath710 is a strong repeller for the map @xmath678 , invoking property @xmath719 ( along with the fact that the generic number of pre - images of any @xmath714 under @xmath0 equals @xmath23 ) gives us : now , let @xmath721 be the quasiconformal homeomorphism such that @xmath722 .
assume @xmath692 contains a critical value of @xmath693 .
by the construction described above , and by property @xmath719 , @xmath692 is totally invariant under @xmath693 .
hence , there exists a point @xmath723 such that @xmath724 .
there is a small connected open neighbourhood @xmath276 of @xmath578 such that @xmath725 and @xmath726 contains two distinct pre - images under @xmath693 of each point in @xmath684 belonging to a sufficiently small deleted neighbourhood of @xmath727 .
as @xmath728 and @xmath657 is a homeomorphism , an analogous statement holds true around @xmath729 . by the inverse function theorem ,
this is impossible because @xmath710 contains no critical points of @xmath678 .
the last statement is a consequence of hyperbolicity see , for instance ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.13 ) .
hence , our assumption above must be false .
finally , by property @xmath702 , any critical values of @xmath730 lie away from @xmath683 .
thus , we conclude our discussion of the present example by observing that , in view of property @xmath732 above and an argument analogous to the one that begins with the equation , with @xmath0 replacing @xmath5 and @xmath682 replacing @xmath683 , we can also show that corollary [ c : d1_less]@xmath331 applies to this example
. * acknowledgements . * a part of this work was carried out during a visit by shrihari sridharan to the indian institute of science in 2012 .
he thanks the department of mathematics , indian institute of science , for its support and hospitality .
gautam bharali thanks shaun bullett for his helpful answers to several questions pertaining to the example in section [ ss : kleinian ] . | this paper is motivated by brolin s theorem .
the phenomenon we wish to demonstrate is as follows : if @xmath0 is a holomorphic correspondence on @xmath1 , then ( under certain conditions ) @xmath0 admits a measure @xmath2 such that , for any point @xmath3 drawn from a `` large '' open subset of @xmath1 , @xmath2 is the weak@xmath4-limit of the normalised sums of point masses carried by the pre - images of @xmath3 under the iterates of @xmath0 .
let @xmath5 denote the transpose of @xmath0 . under the condition @xmath6 , where @xmath7 denotes the topological degree , the above phenomenon was established by dinh and sibony .
we show that the support of this @xmath2 is disjoint from the normality set of @xmath0 .
there are many interesting correspondences on @xmath1 for which @xmath8 .
examples are the correspondences introduced by bullett and collaborators . when @xmath8 , equidistribution can not be expected to the full extent of brolin s theorem .
however , we prove that when @xmath0 admits a repeller , the above analogue of equidistribution holds true . |
the main asteroid belt is a relic from the formation of the solar system .
although much of its mass has been lost , it retains a great deal of information about solar system history and presents us with a laboratory in which we can study collisional processes that once operated throughout the circumsolar disk in which earth and the other planets were formed .
one of the most straightforward observables constraining such processes is the asteroid belt s size - frequency distribution ( sfd ; bottke et al .
the current main belt s sfd can be successfully modeled as the result of 4.5 billion years of collisional evolution @xcite .
while such models fit the ` collisional wave ' set up by 100 km asteroids able to survive unshattered through the age of the solar system , they can not be observationally tested in the 100 meter size range .
objects in this size range are very interesting , because they supply most near - earth asteroids and meteorites by shattering one another and/or migrating inward via yarkovsky and resonance effects @xcite .
modern 8 - 10 meter telescopes can detect them , but monitoring them over many nights to determine an orbit requires a prohibitively large time investment for such powerful telescopes ( e.g. , 710 nights ; gladman et al .
thus their distances and sizes remain unknown , and detailed analyses are confined to larger objects @xcite or use only rough statistical distances @xcite . we present a method to obtain precise distances to main belt asteroids ( mbas ) using only two nights of observations . distances translate directly into absolute magnitudes and hence to sizes given a reasonable assumption for the albedo distribution .
this method , which we refer to as rotational reflex velocity ( rrv ) , will greatly increase the efficiency of surveys aimed at probing collisional evolution in the solar system by measuring the sfds for extremely small mbas .
we demonstrate rrv distance determination using a data set from the 0.9-meter wiyn telescope , which we have analyzed using digital tracking @xcite in order to enhance our sensitivity to faint asteroids .
digital tracking is a method for detecting faint moving objects that was first applied to the kuiper belt ( e.g. bernstein et al .
2004 ) , and very recently has begun to be applied to asteroids @xcite . although the rrv distances we calculate herein are all based on our digital tracking analysis , the rrv method is equally useful for asteroids detected by more conventional means , or by other specialized methods such as those of @xcite and @xcite .
suppose that at a given instant , an asteroid located a distance @xmath0 from an earth - based observer is moving with velocity @xmath1 , while the observer is moving with velocity @xmath2 ( e.g. , the orbital velocity of the earth ) .
the angular velocity at which the observer sees the asteroid move relative to distant stars is given by : @xmath3 where the @xmath4 subscript indicates the vector component perpendicular to the line of sight , so that @xmath5 is the projection of the asteroid s relative velocity onto the plane of the sky .
although @xmath2 can be accurately calculated for any earth - based observation , the velocity @xmath1 of a newly discovered asteroid is always unknown initially , and hence the distance can not be calculated by simply plugging the measured value of @xmath6 into equation [ eq : bot ] . given appropriate measurements , however , we can isolate the component of @xmath6 that reflects the observer s motion around the geocenter due to earth s rotation , and from this calculate the distance .
this is the essence of the rrv method for distance determination .
the velocity @xmath2 of an observer on the surface of the earth can be expressed as the sum of earth s orbital velocity @xmath7 and the velocity @xmath8 with which the earth s axial rotation carries the observer around the geocenter . neglecting the slight asphericity of the earth , @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the observer s terrestrial latitude and @xmath11 is the earth s equatorial rotation velocity of 1674.4 km / hr . for convenience ,
we define @xmath12 as the asteroid s velocity relative to the geocenter : @xmath13 .
the angular velocity @xmath14 that would be measured by an ideal observer located at the geocenter then depends only on @xmath12 and the distance , but the angular velocity @xmath15 that is measured by a real observer based on the earth s surface depends also on @xmath8 .
the two angular velocities are given by : @xmath16 @xmath17 if we could measure @xmath14 , we could therefore calculate the distance : @xmath18 where we have dropped the @xmath4 subscript , because it will henceforward apply to all physical velocities in our calculations .
now suppose that the asteroid is observed near midnight on two different nights , that the two observations are separated by exactly one sidereal day , and that the position and angular velocity @xmath15 are recorded for each observation .
the angular distance the asteroid moved between the two observations will thus be accurately known ; call this @xmath19 . because exactly one full rotation of the earth elapsed between the two observations , the observer s position relative to the geocenter is the same for both of them .
thus , the average geocentric angular velocity of the asteroid in between the two measurements is @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the elapsed time between the observations : one sidereal day .
let the measured values of @xmath15 on the first and second nights be @xmath22 and @xmath23 , and similarly let the perpendicular rotational velocities ( which are obtained by calculation , not measurement ) be @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
we can then evaluate the difference between geocentric and observer angular velocities twice : the average of @xmath26 and @xmath27 will be a factor of @xmath28 more precise than a single measurement if the uncertainty on @xmath14 measurement is much smaller than on @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
this is likely to be the case , since @xmath14 is based on a longer temporal baseline .
the distance is then given by : @xmath29 so far we have assumed that @xmath12 and @xmath0 show no appreciable change over the 24 hour period of the measurements , so that @xmath26 and @xmath27 are effectively two measurements of the same quantity .
we will now determine the errors that result when this assumption is violated .
we will first consider changes in @xmath12 and @xmath0 that are linear in time : that is , when the first time derivatives @xmath30 and @xmath31 are significant but the second derivatives @xmath32 and @xmath33 are not .
we will parameterize the change in @xmath12 by @xmath34 , and the change in @xmath0 by @xmath35 . for convenience
, we will also use @xmath36 since the observations do not have to be taken exactly one sidereal day apart , and hence the earth s projected rotational velocity may vary . for well - optimized observations
@xmath37 should always be close to zero .
note that while @xmath38 and @xmath37 are unit - less , fractional changes , @xmath39 still has units of linear velocity .
we then obtain : @xmath40 we substitute these into equation [ eq : av01 ] .
retaining terms only to second order in the variational quantities @xmath39 , @xmath38 , and @xmath37 , after a good deal of algebra we find that the fractional error on the calculated distance is : @xmath41 for main belt asteroids @xmath38 is always very small ( i.e. @xmath42 ) .
this renders @xmath37 innocuous even though it can reach 0.3 for poorly - planned observations ( section [ sec : nonopt ] ) . the velocity change @xmath39 approaches zero for asteroids at opposition , where the accuracy of equation [ eq : av01 ] can be better than @xmath43 , but even months from opposition the error remains only of order @xmath44 .
equation [ eq : av01 ] is therefore very accurate under all conditions where the required input data could reasonably be obtained , and the uncertainties even of highly accurate measurements ( section [ sec : measprec ] ) will generally be larger than the equation s intrinsic error .
we caution the reader against a much less accurate alternative to equation [ eq : av01 ] that may appear more attractive because it is obtained simply by applying equation [ eq : vel2 ] individually to each night and then averaging the resulting two distance measurements : @xmath45 despite its intuitive simplicity , this equation should never be used .
its fractional error expansion contains the term @xmath46 , which has very large values for objects more than a few days from opposition , as illustrated by figure [ fig : reflexerrors ] .
by contrast , for equation [ eq : av01 ] the precursors of the @xmath46 term and several other error terms cancel in the denominator , leaving only the very much smaller error terms given by equation [ eq : err02 ] .
equation [ eq : av00 ] should therefore be avoided , and equation [ eq : av01 ] ( or its generalized form , equation [ eq : newav01 ] ) should always be used for rrv distances .
for simplicity , the discussion in section [ sec : math ] assumed the observer could make instantaneous angular velocity measurements . in practice , of course , angular velocity measurements must be made over a period of time .
this has very little effect on our mathematical derivation .
the only change is that the projected velocities of the observer relative to the geocenter , @xmath24 and @xmath25 , should not be considered as instantaneous but rather as averages over the same period of time in which the angular velocities @xmath22 and @xmath23 were measured
. positions and angular velocities of asteroids are measured in terms of right ascension ( ra ) and declination ( dec ) on the celestial sphere , and thus are two dimensional .
for example , an observer could measure an asteroid as having an angular velocity of -37.36 arcsec / hr in ra ( the negative sign indicating westward rather than eastward motion ) and 10.32 arcsec / hr in dec , with the positive sign indicating the object is moving toward celestial north . in principle , independent versions of equation [ eq : av01 ] could be constructed for each dimension , with angular velocities in ra corresponding exactly to projected east - west motion of the observer and dec velocities corresponding to projected north - south motion . however , the true rotational velocity of the observer is always strictly east - west , and although its projection @xmath8 can have a north - south component , this component is usually small i.e. , less than 10% of the east - west component for observations with mean hour angle in the range @xmath47 targeting asteroids within @xmath48 of the celestial equator .
as we will find below , for our test observations only the ra velocity components are large enough to supply useful distances .
we expect this will generally be the case . in most asteroid surveys , many fields are observed , and each field is visited at least three times per night .
each visit yields a single celestial position of each detected asteroid .
two observations of each asteroid on each night will suffice for our purposes . using the traditional symbols @xmath49 and @xmath37 for ra and dec ,
suppose that on night 1 we obtain observations @xmath50 at time @xmath51 and @xmath52 at time @xmath53 , and similarly on night 2 .
then we can also define mean positions and the mean time @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 , with the analogous quantities being calculated for night 2 .
note that the times here are measured on a continuous sequence and not reset when the date changes . for simplicity , at present
we will suppose further that the time of each measurement on night 2 is exactly one sidereal day later than the time of the corresponding measurement on night 1 : thus @xmath57 one sidereal day .
the required angular velocities are then given by the following equations , where for simplicity we show only the ra component : @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 where the denominator of the last equation is of course also equal to one sidereal day .
n , roughly the latitude of mauna kea ) , but they are separated by an elapsed time of 3.989 hr , corresponding to 60@xmath61 of sidereal rotation .
the rotational velocity of earth s surface at 20@xmath61 n lat is 1573.4 km / hr .
the effect on the asteroid s measured positions is determined by the projected distance moved between the observations , which has eastward and northward components as labeled .
the projected rotational velocity @xmath8 that should be used in the rrv distance calculation ( equation [ eq : av01 ] or equation [ eq : newav01 ] ) is therefore @xmath62 km / hr eastward and @xmath63 km
/ hr northward .
[ fig : earth ] ] the only other quantities needed for the distance calculation are @xmath24 and @xmath25 , the observer s projected rotational velocities relative to the geocenter .
as illustrated by figure [ fig : earth ] , the observer s projected motion relative to the geocenter traces out a segment of an ellipse whose axis ratio is the sine of the asteroid s declination
. the projected distance of the observer from the geocenter is given by : @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 are positive toward the east and north ; @xmath67 is the observer s latitude on the earth ; @xmath37 is the declination of the asteroid ; @xmath68 is the time of the observation ; @xmath69 is the time when the asteroid stands at zero hour angle for the observer ; and @xmath70 is the length of a sidereal day . note that the argument @xmath71 is the hour angle at which the observer sees the asteroid : at @xmath72 the asteroid crosses the meridian and stands closest to the observer s zenith and in the best sky position for observing . for observations at @xmath51 and @xmath53 , the projected linear velocity @xmath24 in the east - west ( @xmath65 ) and north - south ( @xmath66 ) directions
is : @xmath73 @xmath74 figure [ fig : earth ] illustrates a specific example of two observations of an asteroid at -12@xmath61 dec , made from a single observing site at 20@xmath61 n lat on the earth s surface . the first observation is made when the asteroid is rising , and the second about four hours later , shortly after it has crossed the meridian .
the rotational velocity of earth at 20@xmath61 n lat is 1573.4 km / hr and is of course strictly eastward , but projecting the velocity into a plane perpendicular to the line of sight reduces the absolute magnitude and introduces a north - south component ( except for asteroids exactly at 0@xmath61 dec ) . in this example the projected velocities east and north
are 1410.3 km / hr and 106.2 km / hr .
since celestial ra and dec correspond exactly to terrestrial longitude and latitude , the east - west physical velocity of equation [ eq : proj2x ] can be combined with the ra components of the angular velocities from equations [ eq : meas01][eq : meas03 ] and plugged directly into equation [ eq : av01 ] to yield the distance .
we will now provide a simplified but basically realistic example .
suppose the mba illustrated by figure [ fig : earth ] is being observed at opposition
. it will be in its retrograde loop , and hence its motion in ra will be negative ( westward ) .
the angular velocity @xmath75 measured by the observer will be faster to the west than the geocentric angular velocity @xmath14 , because on the night side of the earth the rotational velocity adds to the orbital velocity , making the asteroid fall back westward at a faster rate .
arcsec / hr and @xmath77 arcsec / hr .
the rotational reflex velocity , given by the difference @xmath78 , is then 1 arcsec / hr or @xmath79 rad / hr . taking the physical and angular velocities to be exactly the same on the second night for simplicity , equation
[ eq : av01 ] reduces to : @xmath80 with equation [ eq : calc01 ] we have calculated the distance to an asteroid based on the known properties of earth s rotation .
interestingly , @xcite have developed a closely analogous method for determining the distance to a kuiper belt object using the known properties of earth s
_ orbit_. just as our derivation does not ( explicitly ) include the effects of earth s orbit , that of @xcite does not include the effects of earth s rotation .
neglecting earth s orbit works in our case because , as we have demonstrated in section [ sec : math ] , the dominant errors due to orbital acceleration of both the earth and the asteroid cancel when the correct form of the distance equation is used .
similarly , @xcite can safely neglect earth s rotation because the kuiper belt objects whose distances they aim to measure are sufficiently far away that their rrv signature is negligible .
it follows that the method of @xcite should not be directly applied to measuring asteroid distances without some form of correction for the rrv signal , although ( as they point out ) it is useful for distinguishing true kuiper belt objects from asteroids that have similar angular velocities for a few days near their turnaround points . up to now
we have assumed for simplicity that the observations obtained on successive nights are exactly one sidereal day apart . while it is not difficult to plan and execute observations that satisfy this criterion to within a few minutes , clouds or instrument failures could intervene , or one could be processing an archival data set that was not taken with rrv distances in mind .
in such cases the mean times @xmath81 and @xmath82 may be separated by up to a couple of hours less or more than one sidereal day .
a direct calculation of the geocentric angular velocity @xmath14 then becomes impossible . in its place
, we must use instead the mean angular velocity across the two nights , defined by : @xmath83 we will define three additional quantities .
the time @xmath84 is the moment exactly one sidereal day before @xmath82 ( in the ideal case , @xmath81 would have been equal to @xmath84 ) .
the projected rotational velocity @xmath85 is the observer s mean projected rotational velocity over the time interval between @xmath81 and @xmath84 .
finally , the fractional parameter @xmath86 is given by : @xmath87 note that @xmath86 goes to zero in the case of optimally - timed measurements .
the distance formula analogous to equation [ eq : av01 ] becomes : @xmath88 the error terms for equation [ eq : newav01 ] are the same as those given in equation [ eq : err02 ] , with the addition of an @xmath89 term . for main belt asteroids
, this will always be negligible . in closing our discussion of error in the case of non - optimal observation timing
, we note that @xmath37 , the fractional change in projected rotational velocity from night 1 to night 2 , is likely to be considerably larger in this case , up to 0.3 .
however , in the error terms for equation [ eq : newav01 ] it is always multiplied by @xmath38 , which is always of order @xmath44 or smaller for mbas , and thus should not constitute a major source of error .
equation [ eq : newav01 ] is therefore the central formula for asteroid distance determination with rrv .
in addition to our analytical error calculation ( equation [ eq : err02 ] ) , we have probed the errors of our approximations numerically using ephemerides of known objects from the jpl horizons ephemeris generator . note that no actual observations are involved in this test , only ephemeris positions and velocities for objects with well - known orbits . in figure
[ fig : reflexerrors ] we plot the error of equation [ eq : newav01 ] as determined by this test .
in contrast to our analytical error calculations , this test intrinsically includes the contributions of second and higher - order time derivatives of @xmath0 and @xmath12 , since it uses jpl horizons ephemerides for real objects .
the plotted errors are affected by roundoff error in the ephemerides ( accurate only to 0.15 arcsec in ra ) , which introduces pseudo - noise such that only the lower envelope of the plotted points can be meaningfully compared with our analytical error estimates .
nevertheless , the plots show that equation [ eq : newav01 ] produces accurate distances out to at least 60 days from opposition ; that accurate distances can be obtained from observations that are not optimally timed ; and that the second - order time derivatives @xmath32 and @xmath33 do not introduce significant error .
figure [ fig : reflexerrors ] , although based on calculated ephemerides and not actual data , shows that relatively small position errors can create distance inaccuracies at the level of a few percent .
we now consider the measurement precision that is necessary to yield distances to various levels of accuracy . in equation [ eq : calc01 ] ,
the difference between the night - to - night mean angular velocity in ra ( @xmath90 ) and the angular velocity in ra observed within a given night ( @xmath91 ) was one arcsec / hr , and this rotational reflex velocity corresponded to a distance of about 2 au .
this is typical for observations obtained near opposition at terrestrial latitudes of 2030@xmath61 .
the fractional uncertainty of the distance is equal to that of @xmath92 .
this will generally be dominated by the uncertainty in @xmath91 , since it is calculated within a single night and is thus based on a smaller temporal baseline than @xmath90 .
thus , if @xmath91 is measured with an accuracy of 0.1
arcsec / hr , we should expect the distance to have an accuracy of only 10% at 2 au . at 1 au
, the rrv signature is twice as large : @xmath92 will therefore be about 2 arcsec / hr , and the calculation will be accurate to 5% . as we will now illustrate , one can usually obtain angular velocity measurements with better than 0.1 arcsec / hr uncertainties in practice . in our current paradigm , @xmath91 is based on two measurements of celestial positions separated by a time @xmath93 ( i.e. , equation [ eq : meas01 ] or [ eq : meas02 ] ) .
if the uncertainty on ra for these measurements is @xmath94 , the uncertainty on @xmath91 will be : @xmath95 based on our experience , well - sampled ( e.g. @xmath96 arcsec / pixel ) images taken in @xmath97 arcsecond seeing can yield @xmath94 = 0.030.05 arcsec for bright objects ( e.g. , those at least several times brighter than the 10@xmath98 detection threshold ) .
for faint objects near the detection limit , uncertainties of @xmath99 arcsec are more typical ) rather than being obtained from two positions . ] a temporal baseline of 5 hr is easy to obtain near opposition .
thus , we can expect @xmath100 = 0.0080.014 arcsec / hr for bright objects and @xmath100 = 0.03 arcsec / hr for fainter objects .
at 2 au , distances will therefore be accurate to about 3% for faint objects and 11.5% for bright objects , while at a distance of 1 au , the accuracy should be about 1.5% even for faint objects .
these accuracies are sufficient for good analyses of the size statistics of small mbas , especially given that their albedos are unknown and must be treated as a statistical distribution spanning a factor of @xmath10110 @xcite . where the objects are faint or distant ( e.g. 35 au ) , or where extremely accurate distances are desired , it may be possible to obtain smaller values of @xmath94 by obtaining each ra measurement not from a single image but from the average over a set of images acquired close together in time . extending the same principle further
, we can use the technique of digital tracking to obtain accurate measurements for objects too faint even to be detected in individual images , as we describe below .
the observations we use to demonstrate the usefulness of rotational reflex distances for asteroids were obtained using digital tracking , as described in our companion paper @xcite .
these data consist of 126 two - minute exposures of a single starfield that we acquired using the wiyn 0.9-meter telescope at kitt peak on the night of april 19 , and 130 identically acquired images from the following night .
very briefly , a digital tracking search involves shifting and stacking such sets of images to reveal moving objects too faint to be detected on any individual frame .
a separate trial stack is produced for each angular velocity vector in a finely - sampled grid that spans the full range of possible sky velocities for the target population .
for mbas , a digital tracking data set can span only one night @xcite , hence we analyze our april 19 and april 20 observations independently .
digital tracking has been used to great effect for kuiper belt objects
( e.g. allen et al . 2001 , fraser & kavelaars 2009 , and many others ) , but has not typically been used for faster - moving asteroids where a larger numbers of trial vectors must be probed .
it is now computationally tractable even for asteroids , however , and produces a factor of @xmath102 increase in sensitivity over conventional methods .
this sensitivity increase enables us to detect 215 asteroids within the 1-degree field of our test observations , despite using only a small , 0.9-meter telescope .
we obtained precise angular velocity measurements on both nights for 197 of these asteroids , including 48 previously known objects with accurate orbits .
these last allow us to test the accuracy of rrv distance measurements using real data .
the geocentric angular velocity @xmath14 of an asteroid detected on two subsequent nights is determined in exactly the same way with digital tracking observations as with conventional data .
the determination of the observed angular velocities @xmath15 on each individual night is different , however particularly because digital tracking enables the accurate measurement of asteroids that can not even be detected on an individual image .
any asteroid detection in a digital tracking search occurs on a particular trial image stack , which corresponds to a particular angular velocity .
thus , for example , our automated digital tracking routine might search for objects with angular velocities between -50 and -20 arcsec / hr in ra and -10 and + 20 arcsec / hr in dec , using a grid spacing of 0.2 arcsec / hr , and might detect a particular asteroid as a bright point source on a trial stack whose shifts correspond to an angular velocity of -41.2 arcsec / hr in ra and 11.8 arcsec / hr in dec .
we improve on the relatively crude angular velocity measurement that is implicit in such a detection by probing a new , much more finely spaced grid of angular velocity vectors , using small postage - stamp images centered on the detected asteroid to make the search computationally tractable . for each trial stack in this finely sampled grid
, we calculate the measured flux of the asteroid within a small aperture of radius roughly equal to the half - width of the point spread function ( psf ) of our image .
we then perform a 2-d quadratic fit to the measured flux as a function of the trial angular velocity . the angular velocity at which the quadratic fit reaches its peak value then constitutes an accurate measurement of @xmath15 for that asteroid , and the uncertainty on @xmath15 is derived from the uncertainty of the quadratic fit , which is naturally larger for faint objects that are more affected by sky background noise . all the inputs required to calculate the distance using equation [ eq : newav01 ] are now available except @xmath8 .
as in the case of discrete observations , equation [ eq : proj1 ] indicates how @xmath8 should be calculated , but there is one subtle aspect .
the appropriate value of @xmath8 is not a projected distance divided by an elapsed time as it was in the discrete case ( figure [ fig : earth ] ) , but neither is it the time average of the projected velocities @xmath103 and @xmath104 . instead , the value of @xmath8 that corresponds to the angular velocity measured by digital tracking is given by the slopes of the best linear fits to @xmath65 and @xmath66 as functions of time .
figure [ fig : proj1 ] illustrates the difference between linear fit velocities and average velocities . for our data ,
the linear fit velocities of the kitt peak observer were 1340.0
km / hr eastward and -4.8 km
/ hr northward on april 19 ; and 1337.3 km / hr eastward and -16.3 km / hr northward on april 20 ; by contrast the average velocities were 1286.6
km / hr eastward and -6.9 km
/ hr northward on april 19 and 1283.0 km / hr eastward and -14.6 km / hr northward on april 20 . in this case ,
the north - south velocities are negligible for practical purposes .
our observations on 2013 april 19 span a temporal range of 5.72 hr .
those obtained on april 20 have the same range , and are centered 23.968 hr later in time . as
this interval is only 2 minutes longer than a sidereal day , the timing of our observations is almost exactly optimal as defined in section [ sec : opt ] : the parameter @xmath86 from equation [ eq : meas08 ] is only 0.0014 .
we detected a total of 215 asteroids through digital tracking analysis of our observations in a field of view only slightly larger than 1 square degree .
we reported positions and brightnesses for all of these objects to the minor planet center .
of these 215 mbas , 202 were detected on both april 19 and april 20 , and 197 of these two - night objects had sufficiently accurate measurements on both nights for good distance calculations .
of these , 48 were previously discovered objects with accurately known orbits , nine were previously discovered objects with poorly known orbits prior to our observations , and the remaining 140 were new discoveries for which we received designations from the minor planet center .
@xcite provides further details .
we have used equation [ eq : newav01 ] to calculate distances for all 197 objects with sufficient measurements .
the 48 objects in this sample with well - known orbits allow us to test the accuracy of rotational reflex distances using real data .
the mean absolute error of our calculated distances for these objects is 0.042 au , and the mean absolute fractional error is 2.2% . as expected , errors are smaller for more nearby objects
. distances with 2% accuracy are more than sufficient to analyze the size statistics of mbas .
nevertheless , even better results are possible , as we will see below .
close investigation reveals some evidence of systematic error in the distance calculations described in section [ sec : initdist ] .
the weighted average signed fractional error for the 48 known objects is @xmath105 : i.e. , the calculated distances are 1.8% too small on average , and the offset is 10@xmath98 significant .
it might be suspected that this bias is due to using the wrong value for @xmath8 i.e. , that we were wrong to use linear fit velocities rather than time - averaged velocities ( section [ sec : angdigi ] ) .
this is easily demonstrated not to be the case , however . substituting averaged values in place of linear fit values for
@xmath8 changes the result too much and in the wrong direction : the mean systematic offset goes from -1.8% to -5.2% .
the true cause of the bias is more subtle , and points to a further interesting measurement that can be extracted from our data . with digital tracking ,
our measurement of the single - night observed angular velocity @xmath15 is made over a period of time equal to the temporal span of our observations on each night .
the instantaneous angular velocity over this interval is continuously changing , with the rotational reflex velocity itself being the dominant source of change .
for example , the rotation of the earth causes the westward sky motions of the asteroids to be slightly faster near midnight than they are at the beginning and end of each night s observations ( see figure [ fig : proj1 ] ) . as we stated in section [ sec : angdigi ] and illustrated by figure [ fig : proj1 ] , we can account for the acceleration and curvature of an asteroid s observed motion by using a value for @xmath8 that is obtained by a linear fit to the observer s projected coordinates @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
this assumes , however , that the angular velocity measurement is effectively an _ unweighted _ fit to angular position as a function of time .
such is not necessarily the case .
for example , the images taken near midnight , when the westward sky motion is at its fastest , may be more sensitive due to better seeing or lower atmospheric extinction .
the digital tracking stack will then effectively weight them more highly and produce a mean angular velocity that is systematically too fast .
this effect would produce a systematic underestimation of the asteroids geocentric distances : exactly what we observe for known asteroids in our data
. the effective weighting of different images will not necessarily be the same for different asteroids .
an asteroid that passes too close to a bright star near midnight will only be measured near the beginning and end of the night , resulting in a measured angular velocity slower than the true average value .
asteroids can also exhibit significant brightness changes during the night due to their own rotation , which will change the effective weighting of different images in the final measurement of their angular velocities .
if asteroids actually moved in straight lines at constant velocity , none of these weighting effects would introduce error into our angular velocity determinations .
if we could _ predict _ the curvature and acceleration of each asteroid s track due to the earth s rotation , and apply small shifts to each image in our digital tracking stacks in order to linearize the motion , we would therefore remove the bias in our angular velocity determinations .
we now describe how to do this .
the angular distances between the position an observer measures for an asteroid and the position it would have if measured from the geocenter are simply a reflection of equation [ eq : proj1 ] , scaled by the distance : @xmath108 averaged over the span of a digital tracking integration , @xmath109 and @xmath110 contribute a constant offset to the measured position of an asteroid , and their first time derivatives @xmath111 and @xmath112 produce a constant offset ( i.e. the rrv signal itself ) to its measured angular velocity .
neither of these constant offsets concerns us here : we wish to isolate and remove only the component that represents curvature and acceleration .
thus , we create new functions @xmath113 and @xmath114 that behave exactly like @xmath115 and @xmath116 except that over the span of our digital tracking integrations , their means and the means of their first time derivatives are zero : @xmath117 where the notation @xmath118 denotes the time - average of the enclosed quantity over the span of a digital tracking integration .
the left panel of figure [ fig : curve ] presents equation [ eq : curve2 ] in graphical form , plotting the curved track of an asteroid in @xmath119 space over the course of our april 19 observations .
the calculation of @xmath120 and @xmath121 of course requires knowledge of the asteroid s distance @xmath0 , but the 2% accurate values from section [ sec : initdist ] are more than sufficient for this purpose .
thus , we adjust the methodology described in section [ sec : angdigi ] for measuring precise angular velocities from digital tracking data : we apply additional shifts equal to @xmath122 to each postage stamp image before the final stack .
this straightens the asteroid s track so that curvature can no longer influence the calculated angular velocity .
the distance can be recalculated based on the resulting new , de - biased angular velocities .
note that because equation [ eq : curve2 ] subtracts _ average _ reflex velocities , we must now use averaged rather than linear - fit values for @xmath8 ( section [ sec : angdigi ] and figure [ fig : proj1 ] illustrate how the velocities differ ) .
compared to the calculation in section [ sec : initdist ] , our curvature correction reduces the mean absolute error of the distances for known objects from 0.042 au to 0.032 au , and the mean absolute fractional error from 2.2% to 1.6% .
more significantly , the new calculation changes the weighted average signed fractional error from @xmath105 to @xmath123 .
the systematic offset is thus reduced by a factor of six , and the new value of -0.3% is statistically consistent with zero .
the left panel of figure [ fig : distmag ] illustrates the precision of our measured distances for known objects .
we emphasize that these distance measurements were entirely calculated from first principles and known quantities describing the earth .
we have used the known asteroids in our data to quantify our errors , but not to determine any of the parameters used in the distance calculation . beyond removing systematic errors in our measurements of asteroids mean angular velocities
, we can in principle use equation [ eq : curve2 ] to _ measure _ the curvatures of asteroid tracks within just a single night s data .
this is an extremely challenging measurement because the curvatures are so small : the rms curvature amplitude , defined as the root mean of @xmath124 , is less than 0.1 arcsec for an asteroid at 2 au .
we attempt to measure it using our curvature - corrected postage - stamp analysis as described in section [ sec : two_precise ] , but instead of calculating @xmath125 and @xmath126 based on a previously - calculated approximate distance , we probe a range of rms curvature amplitudes for each asteroid . for each trial curvature amplitude
we calculate @xmath125 and @xmath126 , apply the appropriate shifts to the postage stamp images , and perform a quadratic fit to flux as a function of angular velocity as described in section [ sec : angdigi ] .
we compare the peak asteroid flux values produced by the quadratic fits for the different trial curvature amplitudes , and identify the curvature amplitude that yields the highest peak asteroid flux .
this should be the curvature value that resulted in all of the individual asteroid images being most accurately registered . as the curvature amplitudes map uniquely to distances ( equations [ eq : curve1 ] and [ eq : curve2 ] )
, our identification of the best - fit amplitude constitutes a distance measurement , in principle .
however , the uncertainty of curvature amplitudes measured from the current data set is large enough that we do not choose to calculate individual curvature - based distances .
instead , we plot the best - fit curvature amplitudes as a function of the known rrv distances calculated in section [ sec : two_precise ] . a clear inverse relationship emerges , as predicted by equation [ eq : curve1 ] .
the relationship gets tighter when we reject the minority of asteroids with out - of - range best - fit curvature values and all asteroids fainter than @xmath127 mag , which can not be measured as accurately .
the 48 objects meeting these criteria in our april 19 observations are plotted in the right - hand panel of figure [ fig : curve ] , which shows the rms curvature amplitude as a function of geocentric distance in au , and compares the data with the predicted curve from equations [ eq : curve1 ] and [ eq : curve2 ] .
although there is a mild systematic offset , the slope of the best linear fit to curvature as a function of @xmath128 for these 48 asteroids is 9@xmath98 significant , matches the predicted value to within 0.4@xmath98 , and has an intercept only 1.4@xmath98 away from the predicted value of zero .
the rms error of the measured curvature amplitudes relative to their predicted values is only 0.03 arcsec .
thus we have effectively performed astrometry of moving , 20th magnitude objects with a precision of 30 milli - arcsec using only an 0.9 m telescope . in principle
, our success at measuring asteroid curvatures within a single night s data means that digital tracking can be used to measure the geocentric distances to asteroids based on observations from only one night .
however , our current curvature measurements have uncertainties that are too large to yield useful distances for individual objects : we have been able to demonstrate the efficacy of our curvature - measuring methodology only by recourse to an ensemble of 48 asteroids with distances known by other means . with a larger telescope ,
more accurate curvature measurements of fainter asteroids would be possible , especially in good seeing .
these could conceivably yield meaningful distance measurements for unknown main - belt asteroids over just a single night , albeit only for objects considerably brighter than the digital tracking detection limit .
by contrast , the two - night rrv calculations of sections [ sec : initdist ] [ sec : two_precise ] yield precise distances even for faint objects just above the detection threshold .
there is therefore little reason to use the curvature method for asteroids measured on more than one night .
however , where only one night s data is available , distances based on digital - tracking curvature measurements could be very valuable .
this is particularly true in at least two cases that may arise in future surveys .
the first is the case of an neo survey where some objects perhaps due to their fast motion have inadvertently been measured on only one night .
being much closer to the earth than mbas , neos will show much larger and more easily measurable curvature , which is likely to yield useful distances .
such distances could enable the inclusion in a statistical analysis of objects that were otherwise unusable due to their one - night status .
the second case is the one - night detection of a nearby neo moving at nearly the same space velocity as earth , such that its slow angular velocity mimics that of a much more distant object .
this scenario is statistically rare but troubling , because such an object would likely be overlooked in an neo survey and yet could be an incoming earth - impactor .
if the discovery survey used digital tracking , a curvature analysis would reveal the object s actual , very small geocentric distance .
we note in closing that curvature measurements can in principle be performed on asteroids detected with conventional methods rather than digital tracking , but they will normally be less accurate because of the smaller number of images available . while our current data only suggest the possibility of curvature - based distance measurements from a single night , they allow precise two - night distance measurements from rotational reflex velocity ( section [ sec : two_precise ] ) .
these precise distance measurements enable us to calculate the absolute magnitudes of each of our detected asteroids , and hence their physical diameters modulo the uncertainty in albedo .
the histograms of these values are shown in the right - hand panel of figure [ fig : distmag ] .
at least half of the asteroids we have measured are smaller than 1 km . by contrast ,
only a small fraction of known mbas are in this size range .
the smallest objects we have detected are 300 meters in diameter under the assumption of low , 5% albedo , but could be as small as 150 meters if their albedo is 25% .
the statistics of mbas in this size range are already known @xcite based on a sample several times larger than we present herein .
given this , the detailed completeness analysis that would be required to convert our detections into a measurement of the sfd is not worthwhile .
the aims of the current work and our companion paper @xcite are instead the validation of the rrv technique and of digital tracking for asteroids , respectively .
similar observations using a larger telescope , however , would extend to much smaller objects and accurately measure the sfd of a previously unexplored size regime in the main belt .
we have described how the reflex angular velocity of asteroids due to earth s rotation can be used to determine the distances to main belt asteroids based on only two nights of observations .
we refer to this as the rotational reflex velocity ( rrv ) method for measuring asteroid distances ( equation [ eq : newav01 ] ) .
the required approximations are accurate to about @xmath44 ( equation [ eq : err02 ] ) , and measurement uncertainties are typically 1 - 3% .
such distances can be used to calculate precise size statistics of small main belt asteroids using a much smaller investment of time on a large telescope than has previously been required .
accurate rrv distances may be calculated either from conventional asteroid - search observations , from data analyzed by the technique of digital tracking @xcite , or from any other specialized asteroid - observation technique ( e.g. milani et al .
1996 or gural et al . 2005 ) that accurately measures the celestial coordinates of the asteroids .
we have tested rrv distance determination with a data set acquired on april 19 and 20 , 2013 using the wiyn 0.9-meter telescope at kitt peak . using measurements based on digital tracking , we have calculated distances to 197 asteroids in this data set . while the majority of these were new discoveries in our data , 48 of them are previously known objects with accurate orbits .
these allowed us to test the accuracy of rotational reflex distances .
a preliminary analysis yielded distances with a mean fractional error of only 2.2% . without digital tracking , our detections would be confined to substantially brighter asteroids ( or , the observations would require a larger telescope ) , but the accuracy of rrv distances for detected objects would likely be at least this good ( see section [ sec : measprec ] ) .
we have identified a 1.8% systematic error in our preliminary rrv distances .
we have linked this error to the curvature of the asteroids observed tracks that results from earth s rotation .
this curvature , combined with the non - uniform sensitivity of images obtained under conditions of different seeing and airmass , causes a slight bias in the angular velocity measurements obtained from our digital tracking image - stacks . finding our initial distance measurements more than sufficient to predict curvature amplitudes ,
we have calculated the form and amplitude of the curvature for each of our asteroids .
we have applied a curvature correction to our image stacks to linearize the asteroid motions .
re - calculating the distances using angular velocities from curvature - corrected image stacks reduces the systematic bias from 1.8% to @xmath129% , and thus eliminates it as a significant effect .
the corrected distances have a mean fractional error of only 1.6% for the 48 known objects in our data .
note that such a curvature correction would not be needed for rrv distances based on asteroids detected on discrete images .
the calculation of accurate rrv distances would therefore be simpler for conventional asteroid detections , although digital tracking can detect much fainter objects . besides correcting our digital tracking angular velocity measurements for the curvature due to earth s rotation , we have attempted to measure this curvature by creating several different image stacks for each asteroid at a range of different curvature amplitudes . as the curvature amplitude is proportional to @xmath130 ,
this constitutes a rotational reflex velocity measurement of an asteroid s distance based on just a single night s data .
we find that we can indeed measure the curvature amplitudes for asteroids brighter than @xmath131 mag with a precision of about 30 milli - arcsec .
the measured curvature values for 48 asteroids brighter than this limit show the expected @xmath130 dependence at 9@xmath98 significance , and the best - fit slope is within 0.4@xmath98 of the predicted value .
while distance measurements based on single - night curvature amplitudes are too noisy to be useful for asteroids in our current data set ( and are not needed given our highly precise two - night values ) , single - night distances could be valuable in specific cases for future surveys .
in particular , curvature measurements can identify nearby objects moving at slow angular velocities characteristic of a much more distant population .
our precise distances from two - night rrv measurements allow us to calculate absolute magnitudes and hence approximate diameters for our newly discovered asteroids .
our faintest objects have @xmath132 mag and hence diameters of 130300 meters depending on their albedo .
while the current census of the main belt becomes substantially incomplete at a diameter of about 2 km , we have detected dozens of new asteroids in the 200500 meter size range with an 0.9 m telescope .
based on observations at kitt peak national observatory , national optical astronomy observatory ( noao prop .
i d : 2013a-0501 ; pi : aren heinze ) , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy ( aura ) under a cooperative agreement with the national science foundation .
this publication makes use of the simbad online database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france , and the vizier online database ( see @xcite ) .
we have also made extensive use of information and code from @xcite .
we have used digitized images from the palomar sky survey ( available from http://stdatu.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/dss_form ) , which were produced at the space telescope science institute under u.s .
government grant nag w-2166 .
the images of these surveys are based on photographic data obtained using the oschin schmidt telescope on palomar mountain and the uk schmidt telescope .
allen , r. l. , bernstein , g. m. , & malhotra , r. 2001 , , 549 , l241 bernstein , g. & kushalani , b. 2000 , , 120 , 3323 bernstein , g. m. , trilling , d. e. , allen , r. l. , brown , m. e. , holman , m. , & malhotra , r. 2004 , , 128 , 1364 bottke , w. f. jr . ,
durda , d. d. , nesvorn , d. , jedicke , r. , morbidelli , a. , vokrouhlick , d. , & levison , h. 2005 , icarus , 175 , 111 bottke , w. f. jr . ,
durda , d. d. , nesvorn , d. , jedicke , r. , morbidelli , a. , vokrouhlick , d. , & levison , h. f. 2005 , icarus , 179 , 64 de ela , g. c. & brunini , a. 2007 , , 466 , 1159 farinella , p. , froeschl , chr . ,
froeschl , cl . , gonczi , r. , hahn , g. , morbidelli , a. , & valsecchi , g. b. 1994 , nature , 371 , 314 fraser , w. c. & kavelaars , j. j. 2009 , , 137 , 72 gladman , b. j. , davis , d. r. , neese , c. , jedicke , r. , williams , g. , kavelaars , j. j. , petit , j - m . , scholl , h. , holman , m. , warrington , b. , esquerdo , g. , & tricarico , p. 2009
, icarus , 202 , 104 gural , p. s. , larsen , j. a. , & gleason , a. e. 2005 , , 130 , 1951 heinze , a. n. , metchev , s. , & trollo , j. 2015 , , submitted masiero , j. r. , mainzer , a. k. , bauer , j. m. , grav , t. , nugent , c. r. , & stevenson , r. 2013 , , 770 , 7 milani , a. , villani , a. , & stiavelli , m. 1996 , earth , moon , and planets , 72 , 257 ochsenbein , f. , bauer , p. & marcout , j. 2000 , , 143 , 23o pravec , p. , harris , a. w. , kusnirk , p. , galad , a. , & hornoch , k. 2012 , icarus , 221 , 365 press , w. h. , teukolsky , s.a . , vetterling , w. t. , & flannery , b. p. 1992
, numerical recipes in c ( second edition ; new york , ny : cambridge university press ) yoshida , f. , nakamura , t. , watanabe , j. 2003 , pasj , 55 , 701 yoshida , f. & nakamura , t. 2007 , p&ss , 55 , 1113 zhai , c. , shao , m. , nemati , b. , werne , t. , zhou , h. , turyshev , s. g. , sandhu , j. , hallinan , g. , & harding , l. k. 2014 , , 792 , 60 | we present a method for calculating precise distances to asteroids using only two nights of data from a single location far too little for an orbit by exploiting the angular reflex motion of the asteroids due to earth s axial rotation .
we refer to this as the rotational reflex velocity method .
while the concept is simple and well - known , it has not been previously exploited for surveys of main - belt asteroids .
we offer a mathematical development , estimates of the errors of the approximation , and a demonstration using a sample of 197 asteroids observed for two nights with a small , 0.9-meter telescope .
this demonstration used digital tracking to enhance detection sensitivity for faint asteroids , but our distance determination works with any detection method .
forty - eight asteroids in our sample had known orbits prior to our observations , and for these we demonstrate a mean fractional error of only 1.6% between the distances we calculate and those given in ephemerides from the minor planet center .
in contrast to our two - night results , distance determination by fitting approximate orbits requires observations spanning 710 nights .
once an asteroid s distance is known , its absolute magnitude and size ( given a statistically - estimated albedo ) may immediately be calculated .
our method will therefore greatly enhance the efficiency with which 4-meter and larger telescopes can probe the size distribution of small ( e.g. 100 meter ) main belt asteroids .
this distribution remains poorly known , yet encodes information about the collisional evolution of the asteroid belt and hence the history of the solar system . |
dislocation behavior in solids under dynamic conditions ( e.g. shock loading @xcite ) has recently attracted renewed attention , @xcite partly due to new insights provided by molecular dynamics studies .
@xcite whereas theoretical investigations mainly focused on the stationary velocities that regular or twinning dislocations can attain as a function of the applied stress ( possibly intersonic or even supersonic with respect to the longitudinal wave speed @xmath0),@xcite one other major concern is to establish an equation of motion @xcite ( eom ) suitable to instationary dislocation motions towards or from such high velocities , and which is computationally cheap
. this would be an important step towards extending dislocation dynamics ( dd ) simulations @xcite to the domain of high strain rates , in order to better understand hardening processes in such conditions .
the key to instationary motion of dislocations lies in the inertia arising from changes in their long - ranged displacement field , which accompany the motion .
these retarded rearrangements take place at finite speed , through wave emission and propagation from the dislocation . as a consequence , dislocations possess an effective inertial mass,@xcite which has bearings on the process of overcoming dynamically obstacles such as dipoles , etc .
@xcite inertial effects are non - local in time , and are related to effective `` viscous '' losses . for small velocities where the eom is linear,@xcite
this relation takes the form of the kramers - krnig relations between the reactive and dissipative parts of the causal mass kernel.@xcite one major ingredient of the eom should thus be the effective visco - inertial force exerted on the dislocation by its own wave emission.@xcite an eom results from balancing it by the applied stress , and by drags of various origins.@xcite eoms with effective masses , but which ignore retardation ( e.g. , ref . ) , can not truly capture visco - inertial effects .
previous works on these questions having mainly been confined to the linear regime , their influence in the relativistic domain remains largely unexplored in spite of analytical progresses , partly due to the complexity of the formalism ( especially for edge dislocations ) .
hereafter , eshelby s eom for screws with a rigid core,@xcite valid at small velocities , is first re - examined , and cast under a simple form which suggests a straightforward regularization procedure for finite core effects .
this allows us to appeal to previous results for point dislocations valid at high velocities.@xcite we then build in an heuristic way an eom for accelerated or decelerated screw and edge dislocations in the drag - dominated subsonic regime , that consistently accounts for saturation effects at velocities comparable to the sound speed . results from the equation are compared to quasi - exact calculations from a numerical method of the phase - field type .
having in mind applications to dd simulations , the scope of the study is limited to continuum theory , so that dispersion effects due to the atomic lattice,@xcite or to the influence of the peierls potential,@xcite are not explicitly considered .
within the peierls - nabarro model in isotropic elasticity,@xcite and with the usual @xmath1 ansatz for the relative displacement @xmath2 of the atoms on both sides of the glide plane , eshelby computed the visco - inertial force @xmath3 experienced by a screw dislocation of burgers vector @xmath4 , centered on position @xmath5 at time @xmath6 , moving with a velocity @xmath7 small compared to the shear wave speed @xmath8:@xcite @xmath9^{1/2}}\\ & & { } + m_0\int_{-\infty}^t \hspace{-1em}{\rm d}\!\tau \frac{t_{\rm s}^2}{\left[(t-\tau)^2+t_{\rm s}^2\right]^{3/2 } } \frac{\rm d}{{\rm d}\tau}\left(\frac{x(t)-x(\tau)}{t-\tau}\right)\nonumber.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the dislocation is assumed to have a _ rigid _ core of half - width @xmath10 .
then @xmath11 is the time of shear wave propagation over the core width .
the mass per unit dislocation length @xmath12 depends on the shear modulus @xmath13 . in ref .
( and in ref . as well )
, an incorrect factor @xmath14 is present in front of the second integral , and has been removed here .
this factor is of no important physical consequence , save for different values of the linear response kernels ; see below .
that ( [ eq : eshforce ] ) is correct can be verified as follows .
starting from eshelby s expression of the force as a double integral in eq .
( 26 ) of ref . , and
expanding it to linear order in the velocity @xmath15 or in @xmath16 , the following expression is easily obtained : @xmath17\right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath18 . using integrations by parts over @xmath19 , each of eq .
( [ eq : eshforce ] ) and ( [ eq : flin1 ] ) can be put under the following irreducible form : @xmath20^{3/2}},\ ] ] which shows them to coincide . by the same token
, we check that ( [ eq : eshforce ] ) can be further simplified as : @xmath21^{1/2}}\frac{\rm d}{{\rm d}\tau}\left(\frac{x(t)-x(\tau)}{t-\tau}\right).\ ] ] by fourier transforming @xmath22 [ under the form ( [ eq : canonical ] ) ] and by writing @xmath23\,x(\omega),\ ] ] we identify effective mass @xmath24 and viscosity @xmath25 kernels .
@xcite their expression in closed form involves the modified bessel and struve functions @xmath26 , @xmath27 and @xmath28 : [ eq : masskercf ] @xmath29\right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to leading orders in the pulsation @xmath30 , [ eq : massker ] @xmath31 where @xmath32 is euler s constant .
moreover , we observe that @xmath33 result ( [ eq : massker ] ) coincides to leading order with eshelby s , @xcite as @xmath34 . the mass increase with wavelength as @xmath35 implies very different behaviors for , e.g. , quasi - static and shock loading modes , since the latter involves a wider frequency range .
we note that @xmath36 as @xmath34 , since losses should be absent from the model in the stationary subsonic regime .
@xcite the non - analytical behavior of the kernels at @xmath37 ( due to @xmath38 ) , and its associated non - locality in time has been emphasized in ref . .
the finite `` instantaneous '' viscosity ( [ eq : viscoinfty ] ) stems from the first term in the r.h.s . of ( [ eq : canonical ] ) , and is responsible for a velocity jump @xmath39 undergone by the dislocation when subjected to a jump @xmath40 in the applied force.@xcite from ( [ eq : viscoinfty ] ) we deduce : @xmath41 the velocity jump ( [ eq : vjump ] ) increases with core width .
it was first predicted by eshelby from his equation,@xcite and can be understood as follows for a screw dislocation along the @xmath42 axis : the force jump @xmath40 is due to a shear stress jump @xmath43 attaining simultaneously all the points of the whole glide plane ( e.g. , as the result of shear loading applied on faces of the system containing the plane , parallel to the latter ) . neglecting material inertia of the atoms on both sides of the dislocation plane , the medium undergoes an elastic strain jump @xmath44 , determined by a material velocity jump @xmath45 .
the latter is equilibrated through outward emission of a shear wave with velocity @xmath8 . on the other hand ,
the slope of the displacement function near the core is @xmath46 , so that @xmath45 is related to the dislocation velocity jump @xmath39 by @xmath47 . combining these relationships yields ( [ eq : vjump ] ) , up to a numerical constant factor .
the same argument applies to other types of dislocations . in case of several relaxation waves ( e.g. , longitudinal and shear waves for an edge dislocation ) , that of lowest celerity controls the amplitude of the velocity jump .
it should be borne in mind , however , that accounting for material inertia from the atoms on both sides of the glide plane results in an instantaneous inertial force of order @xmath48 to be added to ( [ eq : eshforce]).@xcite by balancing the forces , it is seen that this force should spread the velocity jump over a short rise time @xmath49
no expression analogous to ( [ eq : eshforce ] ) is available for edge dislocations .
however , clifton and markenscoff computed the force acting on a _ point _ screw or edge dislocation moving with any subsonic velocity in an isotropic medium , that jumps instantaneously at instant @xmath50 from rest to a constant velocity @xmath51.@xcite a generalization to anisotropic media is available.@xcite to maintain its velocity constant , this dislocation must be subjected , at time @xmath52 , to the time - decaying force @xmath53 where the function @xmath54 depends on its character and on anisotropy .
@xcite we now construct heuristically a force for accelerated motion by interpreting such a motion as a succession of infinitesimal velocity jumps . assuming that , for instationary motion , @xmath51 in ( [ eq : fcm ] ) can be interpreted as @xmath15 , the elementary force that would arise from the elementary jump @xmath55 at @xmath50 is : @xmath56\delta v(\tau)$ ] @xmath57 @xmath58 .
then , the total force experienced by the dislocation results from integrating such elementary forces over past history : @xmath59 comparing ( [ eq : newforce0 ] ) to ( [ eq : flin2 ] ) shows , firstly , that the relevant `` accelerations '' at linear order are different .
however , we remark that @xmath60/(t-\tau)\}\to \dot{v}(\tau)$ ] as @xmath61 , and moreover that for a screw dislocation , @xmath62 .
@xcite hence , since we interpret @xmath51 in ( [ eq : fcm ] ) as @xmath15 , the numerator of the integrand in ( [ eq : newforce0 ] ) is correct at least for small velocities and for small times @xmath61 .
its relevance for large velocities is demonstrated below through comparisons to full - field calculations .
next , integral ( [ eq : newforce0 ] ) is singular at @xmath63 , due the point - dislocation hypothesis at the root of ( [ eq : fcm ] ) .
however , using ( [ eq : flin2 ] ) as a physical motivation , we propose a regularization consisting in replacing the kernel @xmath64 in ( [ eq : newforce0 ] ) by @xmath65^{1/2}$ ] where @xmath66 , the counterpart of @xmath67 in ( [ eq : eshforce ] ) , is some time characteristic of sound propagation over a core diameter . in sec .
[ sec : appli ] , @xmath66 is chosen alternatively proportional to @xmath11 and to @xmath68 in the case of edge dislocations for illustrative purposes , whereas @xmath66 is proportional to @xmath67 for screws
. the proportionality factor , 1/2 in all cases , is justified below . from a physical point of view
, inertia is controlled by the slowest wave so that better results are expected using @xmath8 for all types of dislocations .
given eshelby s rigid - core hypothesis in ( [ eq : flin2 ] ) , and the approximations made , it would be pointless to refine this treatment .
another kind of regularization is used in ref .
( p. 195 ) , which consists in replacing the upper bound @xmath6 of integral ( [ eq : newforce0 ] ) by @xmath69 ( in ref .
, the integrand assumes that @xmath70 ) . with the above regularization
the force eventually reads : @xmath71^{1/2}}\dot{v}(\tau).\ ] ] its fourier transform for small velocities where @xmath72 yields , in terms of modified bessel and struve functions of order 0 , [ eq : masskercfapprox ] @xmath73\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{\pi}{2}|\omega|+o(t_{\rm s}|\omega|^2)\\ \label{veshcfapproxinf}\eta(|\omega|\to\infty)/g'(0)&=&1/t_0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the approximation therefore preserves the logarithmic character of the mass , and the viscosity , to leading order . the mass is slightly decreased , the constant @xmath74 in ( [ mesh ] ) being absent .
this difference is insignificant given the approximations made . in the limit of small velocity for a screw dislocation , our approximation amounts to retaining in ( [ eq : eshforce ] ) the first integral only . in order to recover a correct velocity jump for screws
, we must take @xmath75 since the instantaneous viscosity ( [ veshcfapproxinf ] ) is different from ( [ eq : viscoinfty ] ) .
this `` calibration '' is used in the next section for screws and ( somewhat arbitrarily ) for edges as well . in the stationary limit , the visco - inertial force ( [ eq : newforce1 ] ) vanishes . for @xmath76 ,
the asymptotic velocity should be determined by a viscous drag force , mainly of phonon origin,@xcite @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the viscosity .
this force is modified ( in the context of the peierls - nabarro model ) by the relativistic contraction of the core , into @xmath79 . for subsonic velocities , @xmath80 , where:@xcite @xmath81^{1/2},\ ] ] with @xmath82
, is an effective viscosity - dependent core contraction factor , such that the core length in the laboratory frame reads : @xmath83 .
the purely relativistic contraction factor @xmath84 is , with @xmath85:@xcite @xmath86 with this drag , and introducing the applied stress @xmath87 , the eom finally reads : @xmath88^{1/2}}+f_{\rm drag}(v(t))=b\sigma_a,\ ] ] where @xmath89 , and where:@xcite @xmath90/v,\quad\text{for edge dislocations}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is our main result . by construction
, it reproduces the asymptotic velocities of ref . .
we checked numerically that the replacement of @xmath10 by @xmath91 in @xmath66 does not change by more than a few percent the overall results described in the following section .
since this change in @xmath66 would bring in nothing useful , we choose to use @xmath10 in @xmath66 in the following section .
upper : relationship between dimensionless applied stress @xmath92 and asymptotic velocity @xmath93 provided by the png code , @xcite for an accelerated edge dislocation in the stationary regime of an accelerated dislocation ( dots ) , compared to that predicted by rosakis s model i@xcite ( lines ) for different viscosity parameters @xmath94 , for a screw dislocation in the subsonic regime .
lower : normalized velocity - dependent core width @xmath95 measured under same conditions .
@xmath96 is the rayleigh velocity.,width=302 ]
setting @xmath97 , eq .
( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) is solved numerically for edge and screw dislocations , in an implicit way with a time step @xmath98 small enough .
results are compared with numerical points obtained with the _ peierls - nabarro - galerkin _ ( png ) approach @xcite used here as a benchmark .
this method is less noisy than molecular dynamics , allows for full - field dynamic calculations of the displacement and stress fields in the whole system , accounting for wave propagation effects , and allows for better flexibility .
we can thus , e.g. , control boundary conditions by applying analytically computed forces , so as to prevent image dislocations from perturbing the simulation window .
firstly , to check the accuracy of the benchmark , asymptotic velocities of screw and edge dislocations were compared to the stationary predictions of rosakis model 1.@xcite in the png method , the permanent lattice displacement field ( which is part of the full atomic displacement , @xmath99 ) is relaxed by means of a landau - ginzburg equation , with viscosity parameter @xmath100 .
an exact correspondence holds between this viscosity and rosakis s viscosity parameter @xmath94 , namely @xmath101 , as can be shown by specializing to one dimension the general field equations of ref .. a @xmath32-potential @xmath102 , with @xmath103 , is used .
the material is an elastically cubic material , with elastic moduli taken such that @xmath104 to insure isotropy .
due to the elastic correction made to the @xmath32-surface potential in order to remove its quadratic elastic part,@xcite the core at rest is a bit larger in the png results than in the peierls - nabarro solution .
the time dependent core width @xmath105 is measured from the numerical simulations by using @xmath106 ^ 2 $ ] ( the value corresponding to a core of the arctan type ) .
two - dimensional calculations are carried out using a simulation box of size @xmath107 @xmath108 , with a unique horizontal glide plane along @xmath109 .
eight nodes per burgers vector are used in both directions .
forces are applied on the top and bottom sides so as to induce shear on the unique glide plane .
free boundary conditions are used on sides normal to the @xmath109 axis .
measurements are done near the center of the box , where the mirror attracting forces these sides generate on the dislocation , are negligible .
the box is wide enough so that the dislocation accelerates and reaches its terminal velocity
. comparisons between png results and rosakis model are displayed in fig .
[ fig : rosakis ] for different viscosities @xmath94 , in the case of an edge dislocation .
the core scaling factor @xmath110 and the asymptotic velocity @xmath93 , are directly measured from simulations under different applied stresses @xmath111 , and compared to theory .
@xcite the png asymptotic velocities were found to be @xmath112 systematically lower than the theoretical results .
this correction is accounted for in the figure .
the overall agreement is excellent .
it is emphasized that core contraction effects in the viscous drag [ eq . ( [ eq : contract ] ) ] are required in order to obtain a good match .
velocities vs. time for accelerated screw dislocations : white dots , png code ; solid , ref . ; dots ( in left curve only ) , eq .
( [ eq : eshforce ] ) ; dash - dots , linear approximation to ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) ; dashes , fully relativistic equation ( [ eq : pdpeq]).,width=321 ] velocities vs. time for accelerated edge dislocations : white dots , png code ; solid , ref . ; dash - dots , linear approximation to ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) ; dashes , fully relativistic equation ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) .
curves obtained from ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) are duplicated , using either @xmath66 computed with @xmath8 ( upper ) , or with @xmath0 ( lower ) , see text.,width=321 ] next , comparisons in the accelerated regime are made with eq .
( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) and with other models . fig .
[ fig : step_vis ] displays , as a function of time , the velocity of a screw dislocation accelerated from rest by a constant shear stress @xmath87 applied at @xmath113 .
low and high shear stresses are examined .
these stresses lead to terminal asymptotic velocities @xmath114 and @xmath115 , computed from ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) .
the results displayed are obtained : ( i ) with the png approach ( white dots ) ; ( ii ) with eq .
( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) using fully `` relativistic '' expressions of @xmath116 and @xmath110 ( dashes ) ; ( iii ) with linear small - velocity approximations of @xmath116 , but with the full expression of @xmath110 , in order to emphasize the importance of relativistic effects in the retarded force ( dash - dots , for the case @xmath117 ) ; ( iv ) with a previous eom,@xcite using a typical cut - off radius @xmath118 nm in the logarithmic core term ( solid ) corresponding to a typical dislocation density of @xmath119/m@xmath120 .
the result arising from using ( [ eq : eshforce ] ) in the eom is also displayed for the lowest speed ( dots , left figure only ) .
figure [ fig : step_coin ] presents similar curves for an edge dislocation . for the latter , @xmath66 is taken either as @xmath121 or as @xmath122 , @xmath68 , thus providing two limiting curves .
the curves with @xmath67 provide the best matches , consistently with the above observation that the wave of lowest velocity @xmath123 should provide the main contribution to inertia . at low and high speeds
, good agreement is obtained between png points and eq .
( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) , provided that fully `` relativistic '' expressions are used for @xmath124 ( especially for edge dislocations ) ; otherwise , inertia is strongly underestimated . in all the curves ,
the relativistic expression of the non - linear viscous terms was used .
moreover , variations of the core width with velocity,@xcite implicitly present in png calculations , and ignored in the expression of @xmath66 used in the visco - inertial term of ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) , are not crucial to accelerated or to decelerated motion ( see fig . [
fig : deceler ] ) ; still , the core width shrinks by 20% during the acceleration towards @xmath125 . on the other hand , retardation effects in the effective mass are crucial : curves with non - local inertial forces are markedly different from the solid ones using the masses of ref . , computed at constant velocity
the version of the png code used here does not include the above - mentioned effects of material inertia in the glide plane , so that the full - field velocity curves indeed display what resembles a velocity jump , like the eom .
owing to ( [ eq : risetime ] ) , this lack of accuracy solely concerns the time interval between the time origin and the first data point : hence we can consider that the velocity jump is a genuine effect , and not an artefact , at least from the point of view of full - field calculations in continuum mechanics .
however , we should add that , to our knowledge , this effect has not been reported so far in molecular dynamics simulations .
velocities vs. time for a decelerated screw dislocation .
comparison between the png method ( white dots)@xcite and equation ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) with ( dashes ) or without ( dot - dash ) fully relativistic expressions.,width=321 ] figure [ fig : deceler ] displays the velocity of screw and edge dislocations decelerated from the initial velocity @xmath126 .
comparisons between eoms and png calculations are then harder to make than in the accelerated case . indeed , the non - relativistic ( resp .
relativistic ) theoretical curves from eq.([eq : pdpeq ] ) ( dashed - dot ) [ resp . ( dashed ) ] are obtained by assuming that an applied stress abruptly vanishes at @xmath113 .
this induces a negative velocity jump in the curves .
this jump is larger if non - relativistic expressions are used , which demonstrates in passing the higher inertia ( i.e. `` mass '' ) provided by relativistic expressions .
the same loading was tried in the png calculations as well , but led to non - exploitable results due to multiple wave - propagation and reflection phenomena .
therefore , png curves for decelerated motion were obtained instead using a somewhat artificial loading : the medium was split in a zone of constant stress , separated from a zone of zero stress by an immobile and sharp boundary . the dislocation is then made to accelerate in the zone of constant stress . due to the finite core width , the boundary is crossed in a finite time @xmath127 , which explains the smoothed decay of the velocity in the png data points .
this type of loading can not be realistically implemented within the framework of eq.([eq : pdpeq ] ) because the dislocation core is not spatially resolved . hence , though the curves strongly suggest that relativistic effects are as important in deceleration as in acceleration , and that ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) reproduces well the png points , the comparison between the latter and theoretical curves should be taken here with a grain of salt . on the other hand , the eom of ref .
( solid ) is once again clearly imprecise . as a final remark
, we expect our neglecting of retardation effects in the nonlinear viscous term of ( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) to induce an underestimation of damping effects .
this may explain why the png curves decay faster than that from eq .
( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) .
an empirical relativistic equation of motion for screw and edge dislocations , accounting for retardation effects in inertia , eq .
( [ eq : pdpeq ] ) , has been proposed .
we compared it , together with another available approximate eom , to a quasi - exact numerical solution of a dynamical extension of the peierls - nabarro model , provided by the _ peierls - nabarro galerkin _
code.@xcite the latter was beforehand shown to reproduce very well the asymptotic velocities of rosakis s model 1@xcite in the subsonic regime .
the best matches with full - field results were found with our eom , both for accelerated and for decelerated motion , thus illustrating quantitatively the importance of retardation and of relativistic effects in the dynamic motion of dislocations . to these effects
, our eom provides for the first time a satisfactory approximation for high velocities in the subsonic range .
our comparisons rule out the use of masses computed at constant velocity .
one of the restrictions put forward by eshelby to his eom was its limitation to weakly accelerated motion , mainly due to the rigid core assumption.@xcite ours makes no attempt to explicitly overcome this simplification .
however , comparisons with full - field calculations , where the core structure is not imposed from the start , but emerges as the result of solving the evolution equation for the displacement field , shows that this rigid - core assumption is acceptable on a quantitative basis as far as inertia is concerned , at least for velocities high , but not too close to @xmath128 .
99 e. hornbogen , acta metall .
* 10 * , 978 ( 1962 )
clifton and x. markenscoff , j. mech
. solids . *
29 * , 227 ( 1981 ) .
d. tanguy , m. mareschal , p.s .
lomdahl , t.c .
germann , b.l .
holian and r. ravelo , phys .
b * 68 * , 144111 ( 2003 ) .
hirth , h.m .
zbib and j.p .
lothe , modelling simul.mater .
* 6 * , 165 ( 1998 ) .
p. gumbsch and h. gao , science * 283 * , 965 ( 1999 ) .
j. marian , w. cai and v.v .
bulatov , nature materials * 3 * , 158 ( 2004 ) . c. denoual , phys .
b * 70 * , 024 106 ( 2004 ) .
l. pillon , c. denoual , r. madec and y .- p .
pellegrini , j. phys .
iv ( france ) * 134 * , 49 ( 2006 ) . c. denoual , comput .
methods appl .
engrg . * 196 * , 1915 ( 2007 ) .
j. weertman in _ mathematical theory of dislocations _ , edited by t. mura ( asme , new york , 1969 ) , p. 178 .
p. rosakis , phys .
* 86 * , 95 ( 2001 ) .
eshelby , phys .
* 90 * , 248 ( 1953 ) .
b. devincre and l.p .
kubin , mater .
a * 234 * -*236 * , 8 ( 1997 ) . v.v .
bulatov , l.l .
hsiung , m. tang , a. arsenlis , m.c .
bartelt , w. cai , j.n .
florando , m. hiratani , m. rhee , g. hommes , t.g . pierce and t. diaz de la rubia , nature * 440 * , 1174 ( 2006 ) . z.q .
wang , i.j .
beyerlein and r. lesar , los alamos preprint la - ur-06 - 3602 ( unpublished ) .
e. bitzek and p. gumbsch mater .
a * 400 * , 40 ( 2005 ) .
eshelby , proc .
r. soc .
london , ser .
a * 266 * , 222 ( 1962 ) .
alshitz , v.l . indenbom and a.a .
shtolberg , zh . eksp .
fiz . * 60 * , 2308 ( 1971 ) [ sov .
jetp * 33 * , 1240 ( 1971 ) ] .
nabarro , proc .
r. soc .
london , ser .
a * 209 * , 278 ( 1951 ) .
alshits and v.l .
indenbom , in _ dislocations in solids _ vol . 7 , edited by f.r.n . nabarro ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1986 ) . s. ishioka , j. phys . soc .
japan * 34 * , 462 ( 1973 ) .
r. peierls , proc .
soc . * 52 * , 34 ( 1940 ) .
nabarro , proc .
soc . * 59 * , 256 ( 1947 ) .
wu , acta mechanica * 158 * , 85 ( 2002 ) .
hirth and j.p .
lothe , _ theory of crystal dislocations _
( krieger , new york , 1982 ) .
j. weertman , in _ response of materials to high velocity deformations _ , edited by p.g .
shewmon and v.f .
zackay ( interscience , new york,1961 ) , p. 205 .
eshelby , proc .
a * 62 * , 307 ( 1949 ) . | an approximate equation of motion is proposed for screw and edge dislocations , which accounts for retardation and for relativistic effects in the subsonic range .
good quantitative agreement is found , in accelerated or in decelerated regimes , with numerical results of a more fundamental nature . |
in the field of disordered systems , the interest has been first on self - averaging quantities , like the free - energy per degree of freedom , or other thermodynamic observables that determine the phase diagram .
however , it has become clear over the years that a true understanding of random systems has to include the sample - to - sample fluctuations of global observables , in particular in disorder - dominated phases where interesting universal critical exponents show up . besides these typical sample - to - sample fluctuations , it is natural to characterize also the large deviations properties , since rare anomalous regions are known to play a major role in various properties of random systems . among the various global observables that are interesting , the simplest
one is probably the ground - state energy @xmath0 of a disordered sample .
since it is the minimal value among the energies of all possible configurations , the study of its distribution belongs to the field of extreme value statistics .
whereas the case of independent random variables is well classified in three universality classes @xcite , the problem for the correlated energies within a disordered sample remains open and has been the subject of many recent studies ( see for instance @xcite and references therein ) . for many - body models with @xmath1 degrees of freedom ( @xmath1 spins for disordered spin models , @xmath1 monomers for disordered polymers models )
, the interest lies \(i ) in the scaling behavior of the average @xmath2 and the standard deviation @xmath14 with @xmath1 . following the definitions of ref .
@xcite , the ` shift exponent ' @xmath15 governs the correction to extensivity of the averaged value @xmath16 whereas the ` fluctuation exponent ' @xmath17 governs the growth of the standard deviation @xmath18
\(ii ) in the asymptotic distribution @xmath19 of the rescaled variable @xmath20 in the limit @xmath21 @xmath22 this scaling function @xmath5 describes the typical events where the variable @xmath23 is finite .
\(iii ) in the large deviations properties . in the standard large deviation
formalism ( see for instance the recent review @xcite and references therein ) , one is interested in the exponentially rare events giving rise to a _ finite difference _
@xmath24 between the intensive observable @xmath25 and its averaged value @xmath26 @xmath27 in disordered systems , the probability distributions of these rare events is not necessarily exponentially small in @xmath1 but can sometimes involve other exponents @xmath28 ( see examples below in the text ) @xmath29 in this paper , we discuss these properties for two types of disordered models : for the directed polymer of length @xmath1 in a two - dimensional medium , where many exact results exist , and for the sherrington - kirkpatrick ( sk ) spin - glass model of @xmath1 spins , where various possibilities have been proposed from numerical results or theoretical arguments .
the main conclusions we draw from these two cases are the following : \(a ) it is very instructive to study _ the tails _ of the full probability distribution @xmath5 of eq .
[ scalinge0 ] : these tails are usually described by the following form @xmath30 where the two tails exponents @xmath7 are usually different and in the range @xmath31 . in particular ,
the very common fits based on generalized gumbel distributions are very restrictive and very misleading since they correspond to the unique values @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
we also discuss the consequences of eq .
[ defetamu ] for the moments @xmath10 of order @xmath34 ( either positive or negative ) of the partition function @xmath35 at very low temperature .
\(b ) simple rare events arguments can usually be found to obtain explicit relations between @xmath7 and @xmath4 .
the probability distributions of these rare events usually correspond to anomalous large deviation properties of the generalized forms @xmath36 the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec_dp ] , we recall the exact results concerning the directed polymer in a two - dimensional random medium , and discuss their meaning for the above points ( a ) and ( b ) . in section [ sec_sk ] , we discuss the case of the sherrington - kirkpatrick spin - glass model , and we present numerical results obtained for small sizes but with high statistics .
our conclusions are summarized in section [ sec_conclusion ] .
the directed polymer model in a two - dimensional random medium ( see the review @xcite ) is an exactly soluble model that has the following properties : \(i ) a single exponent @xcite @xmath37 governs both the correction to extensivity of the average @xmath2 ( eq . [ e0av ] ) and the width @xmath38 ( eq . [ deltae0 ] ) .
\(ii ) the rescaled distribution @xmath5 of eq .
[ scalinge0 ] is the tracy - widom distribution of the largest eigenvalue of random matrices ensembles @xcite . in particular , the two tails exponents of eq .
[ defetamu ] read @xmath39 \(iii ) the exponents of the large deviations forms of eq .
[ largedeve0 ] are respectively @xcite @xmath40 after this brief reminder of known results , we now turn to their physical interpretation . as explained in detail in @xcite , the large deviation exponents of eq .
[ etapmdp ] can be understood as follows ( - ) to obtain a ground state energy which is extensively lower than the typical , it is sufficient to draw @xmath1 anomalously good on - site energies along the ground state path
. this will happen with a probability @xmath41 corresponding to @xmath42 of eq .
[ gammapmdp ] . ( + ) to obtain a ground state energy which is extensively higher than the typical , one needs to draw @xmath43 bad on - site energies ( i.e. in the whole sample )
. this will happen with a probability @xmath44 corresponding to @xmath45 of eq .
[ gammapmdp ] .
note that in the asymmetric exclusion process language , the interpretation is that to slow down the traffic , it is sufficient to slow down a single particle , whereas to speed up the traffic , one needs to speed up all particles @xcite . in the random matrix language
, the interpretation is that to push the maximal eigenvalue inside the wigner sea , one needs to reorganize everything , whereas to pull the maximal eigenvalue outside the wigner sea , one may leave the wigner sea unchanged for the other eigenvalues @xcite .
the fact that these large deviation exponents @xmath28 can be guessed via simple physical arguments is an important lesson that is very useful in other disordered models which are not exactly solvable : in particular , these arguments can be easily extended to the directed polymer in a random medium of higher dimensionality @xcite , or to other observables in various models @xcite . for an arbitrary probability distribution ,
the typical fluctuations in the bulk and the rare fluctuations in the far tails are in general different questions . however , for the probability distribution of the ground state energy @xmath46 ( or more generally the probability distributions of other global observables ) in disordered statistical physics models , it is very natural , from a physical point of view , to expect some matching between the typical fluctuation scaling regime where @xmath47 and the large deviations scaling regime where @xmath48 .
more precisely , the tails in the regions @xmath49 of the rescaled distribution @xmath5 of typical fluctuations should match smoothly the large deviation region regime where the variable @xmath24 of eq .
[ defv ] is finite , which corresponds to the regime where the variable @xmath23 of eq .
[ defu ] is of order @xmath50 . if one plugs this scaling into the asymptotic form of eq .
[ defetamu ] , and if one insists that one should then recover the large deviations exponents of eq .
[ largedeve0 ] , one obtains the very simple relations between exponents @xcite @xmath51 for the directed polymer in a two - dimensional random medium , these relations are satisfied by the values quoted in eqs [ omegadp],[etapmdp ] and [ gammapmdp ] .
this smooth matching has also been discussed in the equivalent problems concerning the current in the asymmetric exclusion process @xcite and the largest eigenvalue of gaussian random matrices @xcite .
this matching property between typical fluctuation and large deviations is again an important lesson that can be used in other disordered models which are not exactly solvable .
these relations have been checked in detail for the directed polymer in dimension @xmath52 @xcite as well as on hierarchical lattices @xcite .
this matching property has also been used recently for the distribution of the dynamical barriers @xcite .
it is also interesting from a physical point of view , because the asymmetry @xmath53 seen in the distribution of typical events can be seen as a consequence of the asymmetry of rare events @xmath54 . since
a direct calculation of the probability distribution of the ground state of a disordered model is usually very difficult , analytical calculations usually focus on the moments @xmath55 of the partition function @xmath35 .
then one can use two types of arguments to relate the distribution of @xmath56 to the distribution @xmath57 of the ground state energy @xmath46 : ( 1 ) at very low temperature @xmath58 , the partition function will be dominated by the ground state @xmath59 ( 2 ) moreover in some models , where the disorder - dominated phase @xmath60 is governed by a zero - temperature fixed point , one expects that in the whole region of temperatures @xmath60 , the probability distribution of the free - energy @xmath61 will actually have the same properties as the distribution of @xmath0 . since ( 2 ) is valid for the directed polymer model , but
can not be taken for granted in all disordered models , we will restrict here to the point of view ( 1 ) of very low temperature @xmath58 .
there exists a simple argument that has been proposed by zhang @xcite on the specific case on the directed polymer , that relates the scaling behaviors of the moments @xmath55 with the size @xmath1 and with the replica index @xmath34 to the properties of @xmath57 .
the idea is to evaluate the moments by using the rescaled distribution of eq .
[ scalinge0 ] @xmath62 for the case @xmath63 considered by zhang @xcite , the integral can be then evaluated by a saddle point method in the region @xmath64 , where one may use the asymptotic behavior of eq .
[ defetamu ] with the exponent @xmath65 : the saddle point is of order @xmath66 that should be large @xmath67 , and one obtains @xmath68 for the case @xmath69 , the equivalent calculation yields in term of the other tail exponent @xmath70 : @xmath71 for the directed polymer in a two - dimensional random medium , one obtains , using @xmath72 with the explicit values of eqs [ omegadp],[etapmdp ] @xmath73 where one recognizes the combination @xmath74 that appears in the bethe ansatz replica calculation of ref .
moreover , in zhang s argument @xcite , one actually imposes that the non - trivial term of eq .
[ zhang2 ] should be extensive in @xmath1 ( because for positive integer @xmath34 , the moments of the partition function can be formulated in terms of the iteration of some transfer matrix , and thus they have to diverge exponentially in @xmath1 with some lyapunov exponent ) to obtain the relation @xmath75 ( which is equivalent here to the relation of eq .
[ matchingtyplarge ] obtained previously by the rare event interpretation ) . for @xmath69 ,
the obtained behavior @xmath76 is rather different : the only extensive contribution of order @xmath1 in the exponential comes from @xmath2 .
the leading contribution due to fluctuations is only of subleading order @xmath77 , and it involves a non - integer power of the replica index @xmath78 . to the best of our knowledge , the behavior of these negative moments has not been much discussed in the literature , in contrast to the case @xmath63 .
these saddle - point calculations based on the facts that the tails exponents satisfy @xmath79 can be very useful in other non - exactly soluble models , for instance in the sherrington - kirkpatrick spin - glass model that we now consider .
for short - ranged spin - glasses in any finite dimension @xmath80 , it has been proven that the fluctuation exponent of eq .
[ deltae0 ] is exactly @xmath81 @xcite .
accordingly , the rescaled distribution @xmath82 of eq .
( [ scalinge0 ] ) was numerically found to be gaussian in @xmath83 and @xmath84 @xcite , suggesting some central limit theorem . on the contrary , in mean - field spin - glasses ,
the width does not grows as @xmath85 and the distribution is not gaussian , as will be discussed in more details in this section .
studies on long - ranged one - dimensional spin - glasses @xcite have confirmed that non - mean - field models are characterized by gaussian distributions , whereas mean - field models are not .
the statistics of the ground state energy of the sherrington - kirkpatrick spin - glass model @xcite @xmath86 where the couplings @xmath87 are random quenched variables of zero mean @xmath88 and of variance @xmath89 , has been much studied recently with the following outputs : \(i ) there seems to be a consensus ( see for instance @xcite and references therein ) on the shift exponent of eq .
[ e0av ] @xmath90 whereas the ` fluctuation exponent ' @xmath17 is still under debate between the value ( see @xcite and references therein ) @xmath91 and the value ( see @xcite and references therein ) @xmath92 \(ii ) the asymptotic distribution @xmath5 of eq .
[ scalinge0 ] has been measured numerically by various authors ( see @xcite and references therein ) , but unfortunately it has almost always been fitted by generalized gumbel distributions of the form @xmath93 containing a single free - parameter @xmath94 for the shape .
however these fits are very restrictive and very misleading since the tails exponents are fixed to be @xmath95 for any value of the parameter @xmath94 . in this paper
, we propose instead that these exponents are in the range @xmath96 .
\(iii ) the large deviation properties have been also very controversial . in @xcite
, numerical results have been interpreted with the following values for the exponents @xmath28 of eq .
[ largedeve0 ] @xmath97 : } \ \ \gamma_- & & \simeq 1.2 \nonumber \\
\gamma_+ & & \simeq 1.5 \label{ldandeanov}\end{aligned}\ ] ] other proposals are ( see @xcite and references therein ) @xmath98 : } \ \ \gamma_- & & = 1 \nonumber \\
\gamma_+ & & = 2 \label{ldrizzo}\end{aligned}\ ] ] after this brief summary of conflicting proposals , we now turn to the analysis along the same line as in the previous section concerning the directed polymer model . the simplest rare events one may consider for the sk model are the following : ( - ) to obtain a ground state energy which is much lower than the typical
, it is natural to consider the anomalous ferromagnetic samples @xcite that appear with a small probability of order @xmath44 ( one needs to draw @xmath43 positive couplings in eq .
[ defsk ] ) , and that will corresponds to anomalously low energy of order @xmath99 .
these events corresponds to the very large deviation of the generalized form of eq .
[ genelargedeve0 ] with the values @xcite @xmath100 this form has been checked numerically in @xcite .
( + ) to obtain a ground state energy which is much higher than the typical , one could consider the anomalous antiferromagnetic samples that appear with a small probability of order @xmath44 ( one needs to draw @xmath43 negative couplings ) and that will give an energy extensively higher .
in the large deviation form of eq . [ largedeve0 ] , this would corresponds to @xmath101 this value corresponds to the proposal of eq .
[ ldrizzo ] from ref .
@xcite , but disagrees with the numerical proposal of eq . [ ldandeanov ] from ref .
the question is whether to obtain an extensively higher energy , it is sufficient to draw anomalously only a number of order @xmath102 random couplings instead of @xmath43 .
we are presently not aware of any simple argument in favor of this smaller power @xmath102 . in the ( + ) region
, the matching between typical fluctuation and rare events leads to the same relation as in eq .
[ matchingtyplarge ] @xmath103 in particular , the possible values of @xmath104 and @xmath4 leads to the following values for the tail exponent @xmath105 : @xmath106 or @xmath107 in the ( - ) region , the matching between typical fluctuation and the very large deviations of eq .
[ ldandeanov ] leads to the relation @xmath108 using the values of eq .
[ ferro ] one obtains the two possible values for @xmath109 @xmath110 if this matching works , the region of large deviation of eq .
[ largedeve0 ] which is between the typical region and the very large deviation region , is constrained by consistency to involve the exponent @xmath111 the two possible values read @xmath112 both are close to the numerical value of eq .
[ ldandeanov ] proposed by ref .
both disagree with the value @xmath113 of eq .
[ ldrizzo ] used in replica calculations of @xcite . as explained in detail in section [ moments ] ,
the moments of the partition function @xmath35 are then expected to follow eqs [ zhang2 ] and [ zhang3 ] @xmath114 for positive @xmath63 : the two possible values of @xmath4 and of the associated tail exponent @xmath109 ( see eq .
[ etamoins ] ) correspond to the behaviors @xmath115 we note that in both cases , the non - trivial part is sub - extensive in @xmath1 , in contrast to the replica calculations of @xcite , but in agreement with the replica calculations of @xcite .
it is also clear that the non - trivial part @xmath116 for the case @xmath117 , is simpler than the term @xmath118 for the case @xmath119 . in both cases ,
the powers of @xmath34 that appear are different from the value @xmath120 of perturbative replica calculations @xcite . for negative @xmath69 : for the case @xmath121 of eq .
[ etaplusantiferro ] , the possible behaviors are @xmath122 for the case @xmath123 of eq .
[ ldandeanov ] proposed in ref .
@xcite , the behavior of the moments can be similarly evaluated using eq .
[ etaplus3/2 ] .
again in all cases , the non - trivial part is sub - extensive in @xmath1 , as already proposed in @xcite .
concerning the powers of @xmath78 , the exponent @xmath124 for the case @xmath125 is in agreement with the replica calculations of @xcite . in the sk model : ( a ) the histograms @xmath126 of the rescaled variable @xmath23 of eq .
[ defu ] measured for even sizes in the range @xmath127 almost coincide : this shows that the convergence in @xmath1 towards the asymptotic form is very rapid .
( b ) same data in log - scale to see the tails : one sees that the left tail does not change , whereas finite - size effects are visible on the right tail .
, title="fig:",height=226 ] in the sk model : ( a ) the histograms @xmath126 of the rescaled variable @xmath23 of eq .
[ defu ] measured for even sizes in the range @xmath127 almost coincide : this shows that the convergence in @xmath1 towards the asymptotic form is very rapid .
( b ) same data in log - scale to see the tails : one sees that the left tail does not change , whereas finite - size effects are visible on the right tail .
, title="fig:",height=226 ] : examples of fits of our numerical rescaled histogram ( step function ) corresponding to the size @xmath128 ( a ) the smooth curve corresponds to the best three - parameter fit in the range @xmath129 by the form @xmath130 : the left tail exponent is of order @xmath131 .
( b ) the smooth curve corresponds to the best three - parameter fit in the range @xmath132 by the form @xmath133 : the right tail exponent is of order @xmath134 .
, title="fig:",height=226 ] : examples of fits of our numerical rescaled histogram ( step function ) corresponding to the size @xmath128 ( a ) the smooth curve corresponds to the best three - parameter fit in the range @xmath129 by the form @xmath130 : the left tail exponent is of order @xmath131 .
( b ) the smooth curve corresponds to the best three - parameter fit in the range @xmath132 by the form @xmath133 : the right tail exponent is of order @xmath134 .
, title="fig:",height=226 ] most numerical works on the distribution of the ground state energy in the sk model have followed the strategy to study the biggest sizes @xmath1 as possible , to measure the averaged value and the variance ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
an opposite strategy has been followed in ref .
@xcite where an exact enumeration of the disordered samples with the binomial distribution @xmath135 was performed for small sizes . as mentioned in @xcite , the results for the rescaled distribution @xmath5 at @xmath136 are already very good when compared to the results for larger @xmath1 . in other cases , we have also found that the distribution of rescaled variables converge much more rapidly than other observables @xcite . in the following ,
we thus follow the same strategy : we study the distribution of @xmath46 for the small sizes with a high statistics of disordered samples . on fig .
[ fighisto ] ( a ) , we show the measured histograms @xmath126 of the the rescaled variable @xmath23 of eq .
[ defu ] for even sizes in the range @xmath127 with a statistics of @xmath137 disordered samples : one clearly sees that all these histograms almost coincide .
our conclusion is thus that the convergence in @xmath1 towards the asymptotic form is very rapid , so that these small - size data should provide a reliable measure of the asymptotic @xmath5 .
as explained before , we are mainly interested into the tails exponents @xmath7 of eq .
[ defetamu ] : as shown on fig .
[ fighisto ] ( b ) the convergence of the left tail is extremely good , whereas the convergence of the right tail presents much stronger finite - size effects .
let us first consider the left tail .
the three - parameter fit of @xmath5 in the range @xmath129 by the form @xmath130 yields the value ( see fig [ figfit ] ( a ) ) @xmath138 that corresponds exactly to the value associated to @xmath139 ( see eq .
[ etamoins ] ) . of course , it is probably not far enough from the alternative value @xmath140 corresponding to @xmath141 ( see eq .
[ etamoins ] ) to really rule out the value @xmath141 .
let us now turn to the right tail .
the three - parameter fit of @xmath5 in the range @xmath132 by the form @xmath133 yields values for @xmath142 that are less precise , as a consequence of the finite - size effects visible on fig . [ fighisto ]
we have already found in other studies that the right tail is usually more difficult to measure than the left tail @xcite .
nevertheless our non - precise values of @xmath105 in the range @xmath143 $ ] ( see fig [ figfit ] ( b ) ) seem more compatible with the value @xmath144 than with the value @xmath145 ( see eq .
[ etaplusantiferro ] and [ etaplus3/2 ] ) . in summary ,
even if a definitive agreement on the precise value of the fluctuation exponent @xmath4 remains difficult to reach ( see @xcite and references therein ) , our conclusions concerning the sk model are the following : \(i ) the numerical measure of the left tail exponent @xmath109 is in agreement with the matching argument based on rare ferromagnetic samples described by the very - large deviation form of eq .
[ genelargedeve0 ] with the values of eq .
[ ferro ] from ref . @xcite .
then the large deviation form of eq .
[ largedeve0 ] is constrained to involve an exponent @xmath146 given by eq .
[ matchingskmoins ] @xmath147 this explains the numerical value of eq .
[ ldandeanov ] proposed in ref .
@xcite , and excludes the value @xmath113 of eq .
[ ldrizzo ] used in the replica calculations of @xcite .
we note moreover that this usual large deviation value @xmath113 would be satisfied only for the value @xmath148 , i.e. only if the fluctuation exponent @xmath4 would coincide with the shift exponent @xmath149 of eq .
[ shiftsk ] .
\(ii ) although less precise , the numerical measure of the right tail exponent @xmath105 is more in favor of the large deviation exponent @xmath144 , that can be justified with a simple rare events argument ( see eq .
[ antiferro ] ) .
\(iii ) finally , the facts that the tails exponents satisfy @xmath150 induces non - trivial behavior for the moments of the partition function ( see eqs . [ zhangsk ] ) when @xmath151 becomes large . in particular , from eqs [ zhangskpos ] and [ zhangskneg ] ,
our conclusion is that the only extensive term in @xmath1 comes from the trivial term @xmath2 both for negative and positive @xmath34 .
moreover , the non - trivial sub - extensive terms can a priori involve non - integer powers of the replica index @xmath34 .
in this paper , we have discussed the statistics of the ground state energy @xmath46 in two types of disordered models : ( i ) for the directed polymer of length @xmath1 in a two - dimensional medium , where many exact results exist ( ii ) for the sherrington - kirkpatrick spin - glass model , where various possibilities are still under debate both numerically and theoretically .
our main conclusions are the following .
besides the behavior of the disorder - average @xmath2 and of the standard deviation @xmath3 , it is very instructive to study the full probability distribution @xmath5 of the rescaled variable @xmath6 : \(a ) numerically , the convergence towards @xmath5 is usually very rapid , so that data on rather small sizes but with high statistics allow to measure the tails exponents @xmath7 that satisfy generically @xmath9 ( whereas the very common fits based on generalized gumbel distributions correspond to the unique values @xmath32 and @xmath33 ) .
moreover , if one wishes to measure tails beyond the region probed via simple sampling , one may uses a monte - carlo procedure in the disorder , as done in @xcite for the sk model , and in @xcite for the directed polymer model .
\(b ) simple rare events arguments can usually be found to obtain explicit relations between @xmath7 and @xmath4 .
these rare events usually correspond to anomalous large deviation properties of the generalized form @xmath152 ( the usual large deviations formalism corresponding to @xmath13 is too restrictive for disordered models , as shown on explicit examples in the text ) .
\(c ) we have also discussed the consequences of @xmath9 for the moments @xmath10 of order @xmath34 ( either positive or negative ) of the partition function @xmath35 . in the regime
where @xmath11 $ ] becomes large , a saddle - point calculation leads to explicit non - trivial terms in the asymptotic behaviors of the moments @xmath10 of the partition function .
we have shown in detail how this analysis for the directed polymer is in agreement with all known exact results . for the sk model ,
we have explained how this analysis agrees or disagrees with various possibilities debated in the literature . in conclusion , we believe that this type of analysis based on the matching between typical fluctuations and rare events is very useful to study disordered systems . here we have focused on the statistics of the ground state energy , but it can also be used for other global observables such as the maximal dynamical barrier of a disordered sample @xcite , or for the statistics of large excitations in ferromagnets and spin - glasses @xcite . | for the statistics of global observables in disordered systems , we discuss the matching between typical fluctuations and large deviations .
we focus on the statistics of the ground state energy @xmath0 in two types of disordered models : ( i ) for the directed polymer of length @xmath1 in a two - dimensional medium , where many exact results exist ( ii ) for the sherrington - kirkpatrick spin - glass model of @xmath1 spins , where various possibilities have been proposed . here
we stress that , besides the behavior of the disorder - average @xmath2 and of the standard deviation @xmath3 that defines the fluctuation exponent @xmath4 , it is very instructive to study the full probability distribution @xmath5 of the rescaled variable @xmath6 : ( a ) numerically , the convergence towards @xmath5 is usually very rapid , so that data on rather small sizes but with high statistics allow to measure the two tails exponents @xmath7 defined as @xmath8 . in the generic case
@xmath9 , this leads to explicit non - trivial terms in the asymptotic behaviors of the moments @xmath10 of the partition function when the combination @xmath11 $ ] becomes large ( b ) simple rare events arguments can usually be found to obtain explicit relations between @xmath7 and @xmath4 .
these rare events usually correspond to anomalous large deviation properties of the generalized form @xmath12 ( the usual large deviations formalism corresponds to @xmath13 ) .
# 1#2 # 1#2 |
supermassive central black holes ( bh ) have now been discovered in more than a dozen nearby galaxies ( e.g. , kormendy & richstone 1995 ; ford et al .
1998 ; ho 1998 ; richstone 1998 , and van der marel 1999a for recent reviews ) .
bhs in quiescent galaxies were mainly found using stellar kinematics while the bhs in active galaxies were detected through the kinematics of central gas disks .
other techniques deployed are vlbi observations of water masers ( e.g. , miyoshi et al .
1995 ) and the measurement of stellar proper motions in our own galaxy ( genzel et al . 1997 ; ghez et al .
the bh masses measured in active galaxies are all larger than a few times @xmath8 , while the bh masses in quiescent galaxies are often smaller .
the number of accurately measured bhs is expected to increase rapidly in the near future , especially through the use of stis on board hst .
this will establish the bh ` demography ' in nearby galaxies , yielding bh masses as function of host galaxy properties . in this respect
two correlations in particular have been suggested in recent years .
first , a correlation between bh mass and host galaxy ( spheroid ) optical luminosity ( or mass ) was noted ( e.g. , kormendy & richstone 1995 ; magorrian et al .
1998 ; van der marel 1999b ) .
however , this correlation shows considerable scatter ( a factor @xmath9 in bh mass at fixed luminosity ) .
the scatter might be influenced by selection effects ( e.g. , it is difficult to detect a low mass bh in a luminous galaxy ) and differences in the dynamical modeling .
second , a correlation between bh mass and either core or total radio power of the host galaxy was proposed ( franceschini , vercellone , & fabian 1998 ) . however , the available sample is still small and incomplete .
establishing the bh masses for a large range of optical and radio luminosities is crucial to determine the nature of galactic nuclei .
an accurate knowledge of bh demography will put constraints on the connection between bh and host galaxy formation and evolution and the frequency and duration of activity in galaxies harboring bhs . in this paper
we measure the bh mass of ic 1459 .
ic 1459 is an e3 giant elliptical galaxy and member of a loose group of otherwise spiral galaxies .
it is at a distance of @xmath10 with @xmath11 ( faber et al .
williams & schwarzschild ( 1979 ) noted twists in the outer optical stellar isophotes .
stellar spiral ` arms ' outside the luminous stellar part of the galaxy were detected in deep photographs ( malin 1985 ) .
several stellar shells at tens of kpc from the center were discovered by forbes & reitzel ( 1995 ) .
a remarkable feature is the counter - rotating stellar core ( franx & illingworth 1988 ) with a maximum rotation of @xmath12 .
ic 1459 also has an extended emission gas disk ( diameter @xmath13 ) with spiral arms ( forbes et al . 1990 ,
goudfrooij et al . 1990 ) aligned with the galaxy major axis .
the disk rotates in the same direction as the outer part of the galaxy ( franx & illingworth 1988 ) . the nuclear region of ic 1459 has line ratios typical of the liner class ( see e.g. , heckman 1980 , osterbrock 1989 for the definition of liners ) . a warped dust lane is also present .
it is misaligned by @xmath14 from the galaxy major axis and some dust patches are observed at a radius of @xmath15 ( carollo et al .
ic 1459 has a blue nuclear optical source with @xmath16 ( carollo et al .
1997 ; forbes et al .
1995 ) which is unresolved by hst .
it also has a variable compact radio core ( slee et al .
there is no evidence for a radio - jet down to a scale of @xmath17 ( sadler et al .
ic 1459 has a hard x - ray component , with properties typical of low - luminosity agns ( matsumoto et al .
1997 ) . given the abovementioned properties , ic 1459 might best be described as a galaxy in between the classes of active and quiescent galaxies .
this makes it an interesting object for extending our knowledge of bh demography , in particular since there are only few other galaxies similar to ic 1459 for which an accurate bh mass determination is available .
we therefore made ic 1459 , and in particular its central gas disk , the subject of a detailed study with the hubble space telescope ( hst ) .
we observed the emission gas of ic 1459 with the second wide field and planetary camera ( wfpc2 ) through a narrow - band filter around h@xmath2+[nii ] and took spectra with the faint object spectrograph ( fos ) at six locations in the inner @xmath17 of the disk . in section
[ s : wfpc2 ] we discuss the wfpc2 observations and data reduction . in section [ s : spec ] we describe the fos observations and data reduction , and we present the inferred gas kinematics . to interpret the data we construct detailed dynamical models for the kinematics of the h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] emission lines in section [
s : modelh ] , which imply the presence of a central bh with mass in the range @xmath18@xmath5 . in section [
s : species ] we discuss how the kinematics of other emission line species differ from those for h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] , and what this tells us about the central structure of ic 1459 . in section [ s : starkin ] we present dynamical models for ground - based stellar kinematical data of ic 1459 , for comparison to the results inferred from the hst data .
we summarize and discuss our findings in section [ s : discon ] .
we adopt @xmath19 throughout this paper .
this does not directly influence the data - model comparison for any of our models , but does set the length , mass and luminosity scales of the models in physical units .
specifically , distances , lengths and masses scale as @xmath20 , while mass - to - light ratios scale as @xmath21 .
we observed ic 1459 in the context of hst program go-6537 .
we used the wfpc2 instrument ( described in , e.g. , biretta et al .
1996 ) on september 20 , 1996 to obtain images in two narrow - band filters .
the observing log is presented in table [ t : wfpc2 ] .
the ` linear ramp filters ' ( lrfs ) of the wfpc2 are filters with a central wavelength that varies as a function of position on the detector .
the lrf fr680p15 was used as ` on band ' filter , with the galaxy position chosen so as to center the filter transmission on the h@xmath2+[nii ] emission lines .
the narrow - band filter f631n was chosen as ` off - band ' filter , and covers primarily stellar continuum6300 emission , but the equivalent width of this line is small enough to have negligible influence on the off - band subtraction . ] .
the position of the galaxy on the chip in the off - band observations was chosen to be the same as in the on - band observations . in all images
the galaxy center was positioned on the pc chip , yielding a scale of @xmath22/pixel .
the images were calibrated with the standard wfpc2 ` pipeline ' , using the most up to date calibration files .
this reduction includes bias subtraction , dark current subtraction and flat - fielding .
a flatfield was not available for the lrf filter , so we used the flatfield of f658n , a narrow - band filter with similar central wavelength ( 6590 ) .
three back to back exposures were taken through each filter . in each case
, the third exposure was offset by ( 2,2 ) pc pixels to facilitate bad pixel removal .
the alignment of the exposures ( after correction for intentional offsets ) was measured using both foreground stars and the galaxy itself , and was found to be adequate . for each filter
we combined the three available images without additional shifts , but with removal of cosmic rays , bad pixels and hot pixels .
construction of a h@xmath2+[nii ] emission image requires subtraction of the stellar continuum from the on - band image . to this end we first fitted isophotes to estimate the ratio of the stellar continuum flux in the on - band and off - band image . this ratio could be fitted as a slowly varying linear function of radius in regions with no emission flux .
the off - band image was multiplied by this ratio and subtracted from the on - band image .
the resulting h@xmath2+[nii ] emission image was calibrated to units of @xmath23 using calculations with the stsdas / synphot package in iraf .
the resulting flux scale was found to be in agreement with that inferred from our fos spectra ( see section [ s : spec ] ) .
figure [ f : images ] shows both the f631n stellar continuum image of the central region of ic1459 , as well as the h@xmath2+[nii ] image .
the continuum image shows a weakly obscuring warped dust lane across the center which is barely visible in the emission image .
this dust lane is evident even more clearly in a @xmath24 image of ic 1459 ( carollo et al .
the lane makes an angle of @xmath25 with the stellar major axis .
the h@xmath2+[nii ] emission image shows the presence of a gas disk .
the existence of this disk was already known from ground - based imaging , which showed that it has a total linear extent of @xmath13 ( goudfrooij et al .
1990 ; forbes et al .
the outer parts of the disk show weak spiral structure and dust patches . inside the central @xmath26
the disk has a somewhat irregular non - elliptical distribution , with filaments extending in various directions .
our hst image shows that the distribution becomes more regular again in the central @xmath27 . throughout its radial extent ,
the position angle ( pa ) of the disk coincides with the pa of the stellar distribution . in the case of the central @xmath28
, we derive from isophotal fits @xmath29 for the gas disk .
this agrees roughly with the pa of the major axis of the stellar continuum in the same region , for which the f631n image yields @xmath30 . assuming an intrinsically circular disk , forbes & reitzel ( 1995 ) infer from the ellipticity @xmath31 of the gas disk at several arcseconds an inclination of @xmath32 .
we performed a fit to the contour levels of the extended gas emission published by goudfrooij et al .
( 1994 ) , which also yields an inclination of @xmath32 .
by contrast , the gas distribution in the central @xmath28 of the hst image is rounder than that at large radii
. the ellipticity increases from @xmath33 at @xmath34 to @xmath35 at @xmath36 ( approximately the smallest radius at which the ellipticity is not appreciably influenced by the hst point spread function ( psf ) ) .
while this could possibly indicate a change in the inclination angle of the disk , it appears more likely that the gas disk becomes thicker towards the center .
this latter interpretation receives support from an analysis of the gas kinematics , as we will discuss below ( see section [ ss : ctiocomp ] ) . in the following we therefore assume an inclination angle of @xmath32 for ic 1459 , as suggested by the ellipticity of the gas disk at large radii . for the purpose of dynamical modeling
we need a model for the stellar mass density of ic 1459 .
carollo et al .
( 1997 ) obtained a hst / wfpc2 f814w ( i.e. , @xmath37-band ) image of ic 1459 , and from isophotal fits they determined the surface brightness profile reproduced in figure [ f : sbprof ] .
carollo et al .
corrected their data approximately for the effects of dust obscuration through use of the observed @xmath24 color distribution , so dust is not an important factor in the following analysis . to fit the observed surface brightness profile we adopt a parameterization for the three - dimensional stellar luminosity density @xmath38 .
we assume that @xmath38 is oblate axisymmetric , that the isoluminosity spheroids have constant flattening @xmath39 as a function of radius , and that @xmath38 can be parameterized as @xmath40^{\beta } , \quad m^2 \equiv r^2 + z^2 q^{-2 } .
\label{e : lumdendef}\ ] ] here @xmath41 are the usual cylindrical coordinates , and @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 are free parameters .
when viewed at inclination angle @xmath44 , the projected intensity contours are aligned concentric ellipses with axial ratio @xmath45 , with @xmath46 .
the projected intensity for the luminosity density @xmath38 is evaluated numerically . in the following we adopt @xmath47 , based on the discussion in section [ ss : wfpc2_ana ] .
we take @xmath48 based on the isophotal shape analysis of carollo et al .
( their figure 1o ) , which shows an ellipticity @xmath49 of @xmath50 in the inner @xmath26 with variations @xmath51 .
the isophotal pa is almost constant , with a monotonic increase of @xmath52 between @xmath17 and @xmath26 .
the carollo et al .
results show larger variations in @xmath49 and pa in the inner @xmath17 , but these are probably due to the residual effects of dust obscuration .
our model with constant @xmath49 and pa is therefore expected to be adequate in the present context .
the projected intensity of the model was fit to the observed surface brightness profile between @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
the best fit model has @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
its predictions are shown by the solid curve in figure [ f : sbprof ] .
the fit was restricted to the range @xmath59 . as a result ,
the fit is somewhat poor at larger radii .
this can of course be improved by extending the fit range , but with the simple parametrization of equation ( [ e : lumdendef ] ) this would have led to a poorer fit in the region @xmath60 . since this is the region of primary interest in the context of our spectroscopic hst data ( described below ) , we chose to accept the fit shown in the figure .
the central @xmath53 were excluded from the fit because ic 1459 has a nuclear point source .
this point source has a blue @xmath24 color .
it is most likely of non - thermal origin ( similar to the point source in m87 ; kormendy 1992 ; van der marel 1994 ) and associated with the core radio emission in ic 1459 .
if so , the point source does not contribute to the mass density of the galaxy ( which is what we are interested in here ) , and it is therefore appropriate to exclude it from consideration . in section [ s : discon ]
we briefly discuss the implications of the alternative possibility that the point source is a cluster of young stars .
we used the red side detector of the fos ( described in , e.g. , keyes et al .
1995 ) on november 30 , 1996 to obtain spectra of ic 1459 .
the costar optics corrected the spherical aberration of the hst primary mirror .
the observations started with a ` peak - up ' target acquisition on the galaxy nucleus .
the sequence of peak - up stages was similar to that described in van der marel , de zeeuw & rix ( 1997 ) and van der marel & van den bosch ( 1998 ; hereafter vdmb98 ) .
we then obtained six spectra , three with the 0.1-pair square aperture ( nominal size , @xmath61 ) and three with the 0.25-pair square aperture ( nominal size , @xmath62 ) .
the g570h grating was used in ` quarter - stepping ' mode , yielding spectra with 2064 pixels covering the wavelength range from 4569 to 6819 .
periods of earth occultation were used to obtain wavelength calibration spectra of the internal arc lamp . at the end of the observations
fos was used in a special mode to obtain an image of the central part of ic 1459 , to verify the telescope pointing .
galaxy spectra were obtained on the nucleus and along the major axis .
a log of the observations is provided in table [ t : fossetup ] .
target acquisition uncertainties and other possible systematic effects caused the aperture positions on the galaxy to differ slightly from those commanded to the telescope .
we determined the actual aperture positions from the data themselves , using the independent constraints provided by the target acquisition data , the fos image , and the ratios of the continuum and emission - line fluxes observed through different apertures .
this analysis was similar to that described in appendix a of vdmb98 .
the inferred aperture positions are listed in table [ t : fossetup ] , and are accurate to @xmath63 in each coordinate .
the roll angle of the telescope during the observations was such that the sides of the apertures made angles of @xmath64 and @xmath65 with respect to the galaxy major axis .
figure [ f : aperpos ] shows a schematic drawing of the aperture positions .
henceforth we use the labels ` s1'`s3 ' for the small aperture observations , and ` l1'`l3 ' for the large aperture observations .
most of the necessary data reduction steps were performed by the hst calibration pipeline , including flat - fielding and absolute sensitivity calibration .
we did our own wavelength calibration using the arc lamp spectra obtained in each orbit , following the procedure described in van der marel ( 1997 ) .
the relative accuracy ( between different observations ) of the resulting wavelength scale is @xmath66 ( @xmath67 ) .
uncertainties in the absolute wavelength scale are larger , @xmath68 ( @xmath69 ) , but influence only the systemic velocity of ic 1459 , not the inferred bh mass .
the spectra show several emission lines , of which the following have a sufficiently high signal - to - noise ratio ( @xmath70 ) for a kinematical analysis : h@xmath3 at 4861 ; the [ oiii ] doublet at 4959 , 5007 ; the [ oi ] doublet at 6300 , 6364 ; the h@xmath2+[nii ] complex at 6548 , 6563 , 6583 ; and the [ sii ] doublet at 6716 , 6731 . to quantify the gas kinematics we fitted the spectra under the assumption that each emission line is a gaussian .
this yields for each line the total flux , the mean velocity @xmath71 and the velocity dispersion @xmath72 . for doublets
we fitted both lines simultaneously under the assumption that the individual lines have the same @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
the h@xmath2+[nii ] complex is influenced by blending of the lines , and for this complex we made the additional assumptions that h@xmath2 and the [ nii ] doublet have the same kinematics , and for the [ nii ] doublet that the ratio of the fluxes of the individual lines equals the ratio of their transition probabilities ( i.e. , 3 ) .
figure [ f : emlines ] shows the observed spectra for each of the five line complexes listed above , with the gaussian fits overplotted .
the figure shows that the observed emission lines are not generally perfectly fit by gaussians ; they often have a narrower core and broader wings .
it was shown in vdmb98 that this arises naturally in dynamical models such as those constructed below . in the present paper
we will not revisit the issue of line shapes , but restrict ourselves to gaussian fits ( both for the data and for our models ) .
the mean and dispersion of the best - fitting gaussian are well - defined and meaningful kinematical quantities , even if the lines themselves are not gaussians .
the gaussian fit parameters for each of the line complexes are listed in table [ t : fosgaskin ] .
the listed velocities are measured with respect to the systemic velocity of ic 1459 .
the systemic velocity was estimated from the hst data themselves , by including it as a free parameter in the dynamical models described below ( see section [ ss : dyn_mod ] ) .
this yields @xmath73 ( but with the possibility of an additional systematic error due to uncertainties in the fos absolute wavelength calibration ) .
this result is a bit higher than values previously reported in the literature ( e.g. , @xmath74 by sadler 1984 ; @xmath75 by franx & illingworth 1988 ; @xmath76 by da costa et al .
in fact , systemic velocities that are up to @xmath77 smaller than our value have been reported as well ( e.g. , davies et al .
1987 ; drinkwater et al .
1997 ) .
figure [ f : gaskin ] shows the inferred kinematical quantities for the five line complexes as function of major axis distance .
the observational setup provides only sparse sampling along the major axis and with apertures of different sizes , but nonetheless , two items are clear .
first , for all apertures and line species there is a steep positive mean velocity gradient across the nucleus ( i.e. , between observations s1 and s2 , or l1 and l2 ) .
second , the velocity dispersion tends to be highest for the smallest aperture closest to the nucleus ( observation s1 ) ; this is true for all line species with the exception of [ sii ] , for which the dispersion peaks for observation s2 .
the steep central velocity gradient and centrally peaked velocity dispersion profile are similar to what has been found for other galaxies with nuclear gas disks ( e.g. , ferrarese , ford & jaffe , 1996 ; macchetto et al .
1997 ; bower et al .
1998 ; vdmb98 ) .
the kinematical properties of the different emission line species show both significant similarities and differences .
for example , the kinematics of h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] are in excellent quantitative agreement .
by contrast , [ oiii ] shows a significantly steeper central mean velocity gradient , and both [ oiii ] and [ oi ] have a higher velocity dispersion for several apertures ; the central velocity dispersion for [ oiii ] exceeds that for h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] by more than a factor two .
the kinematics of the [ sii ] emission lines deviates somewhat from that for h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] , but only for the small apertures .
there is no a priori reason to expect identical flux distributions , and hence identical kinematics for the different species , because they differ in their atomic structure , ionization potential , critical density , etc .
differences of similar magnitude have been detected in the kinematics of other gas disks as well ( e.g. , harms et al .
1994 ; ferrarese , ford & jaffe 1996 ) .
the former authors studied the gas disk in m87 , and also found that the [ oiii ] line indicates a larger mean velocity gradient and higher dispersion than h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] .
we discuss the differences in the kinematics of the different line species in section [ s : species ] , after first having analyzed in detail the kinematics of h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] in section [ s : modelh ] .
in our modeling it proved useful to complement the fos spectroscopy with ground - based data that extends to larger radii .
we therefore reanalyzed a major axis long - slit spectrum of ic 1459 obtained at the ctio 4 m telescope .
the data were taken with a @xmath78-wide slit using a ccd with @xmath79 pixels , in seeing conditions with fwhm @xmath80 .
the spectra have a smaller spectral range than the fos spectra , but do cover the emission lines of h@xmath3 and [ oiii ] .
fluxes and kinematics for these lines were derived using single gaussian fits , as for the fos spectra .
the inferred gas kinematics are listed in table [ t : ctio ] .
the stellar kinematics implied by the _ absorption _
lines in the same spectrum ( presented previously by van der marel & franx 1993 ) are used in section [ s : starkin ] for the construction of stellar dynamical models .
the fos spectra of the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 lines yield similar relative fluxes ( cf . figure [ f : fluxfit ] below ) and similar mean velocities and dispersions ( cf
. figure [ f : gaskin ] ) .
we therefore assume that these emission lines have the same intrinsic flux distributions and kinematics .
we start in sections [ ss : flux_gas][ss : ctiocomp ] with the construction of models for the h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] gas kinematics in which the gas disk is assumed to be an infinitesimally thin structure in the equatorial plane of the galaxy .
however , as discussed in section [ ss : wfpc2_ana ] , this assumption may not be entirely appropriate at small radii , where the projected isophotes of the gas disk become rounder . in section [ ss : asymdrift ]
we therefore discuss models in which the gas distribution is extended vertically . to model the h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] gas kinematics we need a description of the intrinsic ( i.e. , the deconvolved and de - inclined ) flux profile for these emission lines .
we model the ( face - on ) intrinsic flux distribution as a triple exponential , @xmath81 and assume that the disk is infinitesimally thin and viewed at an inclination @xmath82 , ( cf
. section [ ss : wfpc2_ana ] ) .
the total flux contributed by each of the three exponential components is @xmath83 ( @xmath84 ) , and the overall total flux is @xmath85 .
the best - fitting parameters of the model flux distribution were determined by comparison to the available data .
flux data are available for h@xmath2+[nii ] from both the wfpc2 imaging and fos spectra .
for h@xmath3 they are available from the fos and the ctio spectra . for the spectra we determined the fluxes in the relevant lines ( and their formal errors )
using single gaussian fits . for the wfpc2 image data we included for simplicity
not the full two - dimensional brightness distribution in the fit , but only image cuts along the major and minor axes .
image fluxes outside @xmath86 are dominated by read - noise , and were excluded .
the errors for each image data - point were computed taking into account the poisson - noise and the detector read - noise .
the combined flux data from all sources are shown in figure [ f : fluxfit ] .
we performed an iterative fit of the triple exponential to all the available flux data , taking into account the necessary convolutions with the appropriate psf , pixel size and aperture size for each setup .
the hst and ctio fluxes constrain the flux distribution predominantly for @xmath87 and @xmath88 , respectively , due to their relatively narrow and broad psf .
the wfpc2 data have a pixel area that is @xmath89 and @xmath90 times smaller than the respective fos apertures , and therefore provide the strongest constraints on the flux distribution close to the center .
the solid line in figure [ f : fluxfit ] shows the predictions of the model that best fits all available data ( which we will refer to as ` the standard flux model ' ) .
this model has parameters @xmath91 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
the absolute calibration gives @xmath97 for h@xmath2+[nii ] and @xmath98 for h@xmath3 .
the total h@xmath2+[nii ] flux inferred from our model agrees to within 25% with that inferred from a previous ground - based observation of ic 1459 ( macchetto et al .
figure [ f : fluxprof ] shows the intrinsic flux distribution as function of radius for the standard flux model .
approximately one quarter of the total flux is contained in a component that is essentially unresolved at the spatial resolution of hst .
the standard flux model provides an adequate fit to the observed fluxes , but the fit is not perfect .
the model predicts too little flux in the central wfpc2 pixel , while at the same time predicting too much flux in the small fos aperture closest to the galaxy center .
so the different data sets are not fully mutually consistent under the assumptions of our model .
this is presumably a result of uncertainties in the psfs and aperture sizes for the different observations . to explore the influence of this on the inferred flux distribution we performed fits to two subsets of the flux data
the first subset consists only of the fos and ctio data , while the second subset consists only of the wfpc2 and ctio data .
the flux distribution models that best fit these subsets of the data are also shown in figure [ f : fluxprof ] .
the results show that the standard flux model represents a compromise between the fos and the wfpc2 data . at small radii
the fos data by themselves would imply a broader profile , while the wfpc2 data by themselves would imply a narrower profile . at larger radii
the situation reverses . as will be discussed in section [ ss : bestfit ] ,
the uncertainties in the intrinsic flux distribution have only a very small effect on the inferred bh mass .
our thin - disk models for the gas kinematics are similar to those employed in vdmb98 .
the galaxy model is axisymmetric , with the stellar luminosity density @xmath99 chosen as in section [ ss : mass_stars ] to fit the available surface photometry .
the stellar mass density @xmath100 follows from the luminosity density upon the assumption of a constant mass - to - light ratio @xmath101 .
the mass - to - light ratio can be reasonably accurately determined from the ground - based stellar kinematics for ic 1459 .
this yields @xmath102 in solar @xmath37-band units , cf .
section [ s : starkin ] below .
we keep the mass - to - light ratio fixed to this value in our modeling of the gas kinematics .
we assume that the gas is in circular motion in an infinitesimally thin disk in the equatorial plane of the galaxy , and has the circularly symmetric flux distribution @xmath103 given in section [ ss : flux_gas ] .
we take the inclination of the galaxy and the gas disk to be @xmath82 , as discussed in section [ ss : wfpc2_ana ] .
the circular velocity @xmath104 is calculated from the combined gravitational potential of the stars and a central bh of mass @xmath105 .
the line - of - sight velocity profile ( vp ) of the gas at position @xmath106 on the sky is a gaussian with mean @xmath107 and dispersion @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the radius in the disk .
the velocity dispersion of the gas is assumed to be isotropic , with contributions from thermal and non - thermal motions : @xmath110 .
we refer to the non - thermal contribution as ` turbulent ' , although we make no attempt to describe the underlying physical processes that cause this dispersion .
it suffices here to parameterize @xmath111 through : @xmath112 .
\label{eq : turbdef}\ ] ] the parameter @xmath113 was kept fixed to @xmath114 , as suggested by the ctio data for h@xmath3 with @xmath115 ( see figure [ f : modelctio ] below ) .
the predicted vp for any given observation is obtained through flux weighted convolution of the intrinsic vps with the psf of the observation and the size of the aperture .
the convolutions are described by the semi - analytical kernels given in appendix a of van der marel et al .
( 1997 ) , and were performed numerically using gauss - legendre integration .
a gaussian is fit to each predicted vp for comparison to the observed @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
the model was fit to the fos gas kinematics for h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 .
rotation velocity and velocity dispersion measurements were both included , yielding a total of 24 data points .
three free parameters are available to optimize the fit : @xmath105 , and the parameters @xmath116 and @xmath117 that describe the radial dependence of the turbulent dispersion .
the temperature of the gas is not an important parameter : the thermal dispersion for @xmath118 is @xmath119 , and is negligible with respect to @xmath111 for all plausible models .
we define a @xmath120 quantity that measures the quality of the fit to the kinematical data , and the best - fitting model was found by minimizing @xmath120 using a ` downhill simplex ' minimization routine ( press et al .
1992 ) .
the curves in figure [ f : modelfos ] show the predictions of the model that provides the overall best fit to the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 kinematics , using the standard flux model of section [ ss : flux_gas ] .
its parameters are : @xmath121 , @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
this model ( which we will refer to as ` the standard kinematical model ' ) adequately reproduces the important features of the hst kinematics , including the central rotation gradient and the nuclear velocity dispersion . to determine the range of bh masses that provides an acceptable fit to the data we compared the predictions of models with different fixed values of @xmath105 , while at each @xmath105 varying the remaining parameters to optimize the fit .
the radial dependence of the intrinsic velocity dispersion of the gas is essentially a free function in our models , so the observed velocity dispersion measurements can be fit equally well for all plausible values of @xmath105 .
thus only the predictions for the hst rotation velocity measurements depend substantially on the adopted @xmath105 . to illustrate the dependence on @xmath105 , figure [ f : rotfits ] compares the predictions for the hst rotation measurements for three different models .
the solid curves show the predictions of the standard kinematical model defined above .
the dotted and dashed curves are the predictions of models in which @xmath105 was fixed a priori to @xmath124 and @xmath125 , respectively .
the model without a bh predicts a rotation curve slope which is too shallow and the model with @xmath126 predicts a rotation curve slope which is too steep .
both these bh masses are ruled out by the data at more than the @xmath127 confidence level ( see discussion below ) . to assess the quality of the fit to the hst rotation velocity measurements we define a new @xmath120 quantity , @xmath128 , that measures the fit to these data only . at each @xmath105 ,
the parameters @xmath116 and @xmath117 are fixed almost entirely by the velocity dispersion measurements .
these parameters can therefore not be varied independently to improve the fit to the hst rotation velocity measurements . as a result , @xmath128 is expected to follow approximately a @xmath120 probability distribution with @xmath129 degrees of freedom ( there are 12 hst measurements , and there is one free parameter , @xmath105 ) .
the expectation value for this distribution is @xmath130 .
however , for the standard kinematical model we find @xmath131 . to determine the cause of this statistically poor fit we inspected the goodness of fit as function of bh mass for each line species separately .
figure [ f : mbhrange ] shows @xmath128 as function of @xmath105 for both h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 .
the kinematics of h@xmath2+[nii ] are formally poorly fitted , despite the apparently good qualitative agreement in figure [ f : modelfos ] . in particular ,
the observed h@xmath2+[nii ] velocity gradient between the fos-0.1 apertures s1 and s2 is steeper than predicted by the best - fit model with @xmath121 , which suggests that the bh mass may actually be twice as high ( since @xmath132 in our models ) . the poor formal fit may not be too surprising , given that our modeling of the gas as a flat circular disk in bulk circular rotation with an additional turbulent component is almost certainly an oversimplification of what in reality must be a complicated hydrodynamical system .
the fits to the kinematics of h@xmath3 are statistically acceptable , but this may be in part because the formal errors on the h@xmath3 kinematics are twice as large as for h@xmath2+[nii ] .
this would cause any shortcomings in the models to be less apparent for this emission line .
nonetheless , an important result in figure [ f : mbhrange ] is that the bh masses implied by the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 kinematics are virtually identical .
formal errors on the bh mass can be inferred using the @xmath133 statistic , as illustrated in figure [ f : mbhrange ] . for
h@xmath3 this yields @xmath134 at @xmath135% confidence ( i.e. , 1-@xmath72 ) , and @xmath136 at 99% confidence .
the formal @xmath133 confidence intervals inferred from the h@xmath2+[nii ] lines are smaller , but this is not necessarily meaningful since the @xmath120 itself is not acceptable for these lines .
in section [ ss : flux_gas ] we showed that there is some uncertainty in the flux distributions of h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 .
the mean velocities and velocity dispersions predicted by the dynamical model are flux - weighted quantities , and therefore depend on the adopted flux distribution . to assess the influence on the inferred bh mass we repeated the analysis using the two non - standard flux distributions shown in figure [ f : fluxprof ] . with these distributions we found fits to the kinematical data of similar quality as for the standard kinematical model .
the inferred values of @xmath105 agree with those for the standard kinematical model to within 10% .
this shows that the uncertainties in the flux distribution have negligible impact on the inferred bh mass . the model parameters in section [ ss : bestfit ]
were chosen to best fit the fos data . here
we investigate what this model predicts for the setup of the ctio data .
figure [ f : modelctio ] shows the resulting data - model comparison ( without any further changes to the model parameters ) . at radii
@xmath137 the standard kinematical model fits the data acceptably well .
the agreement in the velocity dispersion is trivial since it is the direct result of our choice of the model parameter @xmath113 .
however , the agreement for the rotation velocities is quite important .
it shows that outside the very center of the galaxy , the observations are consistent with the assumed scenario of gas rotating at the circular velocity in an infinitesimally thin disk .
moreover , it suggests that the value of mass - to - light ratio @xmath101 used in the models ( derived from ground - based stellar kinematics ) is accurate .
by contrast , the fit to the ctio data is less good at radii @xmath138 . in particular ,
the predicted rotation curve is too steep , and the central peak in the predicted velocity dispersion is too high .
these discrepancies can not be attributed to possible errors in the assumed value for the seeing fwhm for the ctio observations .
the latter was calibrated from the spectra themselves . due to their superior spatial resolution
, the wfpc2 data set the inner intrinsic flux profile .
we could therefore determine the ctio psf by optimizing the agreement between the predicted and observed central three ctio fluxes using this intrinsic inner flux profile .
the resulting fwhm determination ( @xmath139 ) is quite accurate , and is inconsistent with the large fwhm values needed to make the standard kinematical model fit the ctio data .
the discrepancies must therefore be due to an inaccuracy or oversimplification in the modeling .
the models discussed so far assume that the observed velocity dispersion is due to local turbulence in gas that has bulk motion along circular orbits .
however , an alternative interpretation could be that the gas resides in individual clouds , and that the observed dispersion of the gas is due to a spread in the velocities of individual clouds . in this case
the gas would behave as a collisionless fluid obeying the boltzmann equation .
an important consequence would be that the velocity dispersion @xmath72 of the gas clouds would provide some of the pressure responsible for hydrostatic support , so that the mean rotation velocity @xmath140 would be less than the circular velocity @xmath141 by a certain amount @xmath142 .
this effect is know as asymmetric drift ( for historical reasons having to do with the stellar dynamics of the milky way ; see e.g. , binney & merrifield 1998 ) .
the presence of a certain amount of asymmetric drift would simultaneously explain several observations .
first , if close to the center the gas receives a certain amount of pressure support from bulk velocity dispersion , and if this dispersion would be near - isotropic , it would induce a thickening of the disk .
this would cause the isophotes of the gas close to the center to be rounder than those at larger radii , which is exactly what is observed ( cf .
sections [ ss : wfpc2_ana ] and [ s : discon ] ) .
second , asymmetric drift would cause the gas to have a mean velocity less than the circular velocity , which would explain why the models of section [ ss : bestfit ] overpredict the observed rotation velocities ( cf . figure [ f : modelctio ] ) .
third , the central peak in the velocity dispersion seen in the ground - based data is due in part to rotational broadening ( spatial convolution of the steep rotation gradient near the center ) .
so if the mean velocity of the gas in the models were lowered due to asymmetric drift , then the predicted central velocity dispersion would go down as well .
this would tend to improve the agreement between the predicted and the observed velocity dispersions in figure [ f : modelctio ] .
if the gas in ic 1459 indeed has a non - zero asymmetric drift at small radii , then the models of section [ ss : dyn_mod ] would have _ under_-estimated the enclosed mass within any given radius ( and models without a bh would be ruled out at even higher confidence than already indicated by figure [ f : mbhrange ] ) . in the following
we address how much of an effect this would have on the inferred bh mass . in the limit
@xmath143 one has that @xmath144 ^ 2)$ ] ( e.g. , binney & tremaine 1987 ) , and any asymmetric drift correction to @xmath105 would be fairly small .
however , at the resolution of hst we find that @xmath145 , so the approximate formulae that exist for the limit @xmath143 can not be used . for a proper analysis
the gas kinematics would have to be modeled as a ` hot ' system of point masses , using any of the techniques that have been developed in the context of stellar dynamical modeling of elliptical galaxies ( e.g. , merritt 1999 ) . while fully general collisionless modeling of the gas in ic 1459 is beyond the scope of the present paper , it is important to establish whether such an analysis would yield a very different bh mass . to address this issue we constructed spherical isotropic models for the gas kinematics using the jeans equations , as in van der marel ( 1994 ) .
the three - dimensional density of the gas was chosen so as to reproduce the major axis profile given by equation ( [ e : fluxparam ] ) after projection .
as before , the gravitational potential of the system was characterized by a variable @xmath105 and a fixed @xmath102 .
any turbulent velocity dispersion component of the gas was assumed to be zero .
we then calculated the rms projected line - of - sight velocity @xmath146 predicted for the smallest fos aperture positioned on the galaxy center .
the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 observations yield @xmath147^{1/2 } \approx 600 { \>{\rm km}\,{\rm s}^{-1}}$ ] ( cf . table [ t : fosgaskin ] ) .
we found that the spherical isotropic jeans models require @xmath148 to reproduce this value .
larger bh masses would be ruled out because they predict more rms motion than observed . in more general collisionless models
the required bh mass will depend on the details of the model , but not very strongly . velocity anisotropy and axisymmetry influence the projected dispersion of a population of test particles in a kepler potential only at the level of factors of order unity ( de bruijne , van der marel & de zeeuw 1996 ) .
so as expected , if the velocity dispersion of the gas is interpreted as gravitational motion of individual clouds , then the bh mass must be larger than inferred in section [ ss : bestfit ] .
however , the increase would only be a factor of @xmath894 .
models without a bh would remain firmly ruled out .
we emphasize that both types of model that we have studied are fairly extreme .
in one case we assume that the gas resides in an infinitesimally thin disk , and has a large turbulent ( or otherwise non - thermal ) velocity dispersion and no bulk velocity dispersion or asymmetric drift . in the other case
we assume the opposite , that the gas is in a spherical distribution , and has no turbulent velocity dispersion but instead a large bulk velocity dispersion .
the truth is likely to be found somewhere between these extremes , and we therefore conclude that ic 1459 has a bh with mass in the range @xmath149@xmath5 .
spectroscopic information is not only available for h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 , but also for three other line species : [ oi ] , [ oiii ] and [ sii ] .
interestingly , the flux distributions and kinematics of these lines show some notable differences from those of h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] . we have no narrow - band imaging for [ oi ] , [ oiii ] and [ sii ] ,
so information on the flux distributions of these lines is available only from the six apertures for which we obtained fos spectra .
figure [ f : speciesflux ] shows the relative surface brightness @xmath150 for the different apertures and line species , using the definition @xmath151 \ > \big / \
> [ f { \rm ( l2,species ) } / a { \rm ( l2 ) } ] , \label{eq : relfluxdef}\ ] ] where @xmath152 is the flux observed through an aperture for a given species , and @xmath153 is the area of the aperture ; the aperture l2 is the observation with the large 0.25-pair aperture on the nucleus ( cf . figure [ f : aperpos ] ) .
the relative surface brightnesses for the different species as seen through the large aperture are all quite similar . by contrast , those for the small 0.1-pair aperture differ considerably .
the profiles for [ oi ] and especially [ oiii ] are more centrally peaked than that for h@xmath2+[nii ] , while the profile for [ sii ] is less centrally peaked than that for h@xmath2+[nii ] . to quantify this ,
we have defined a measure of the peakedness of the surface brightness profile as @xmath154 .
\label{eq : peakedness}\ ] ] the values of this quantity for the different species are @xmath155 , @xmath156 , @xmath157 , @xmath158 and @xmath159 for h@xmath3 , [ oiii ] , [ oi ] , h@xmath2+[nii ] and [ sii ] , respectively
. the kinematics for the different species also show differences , as already pointed out in section [ ss : spec_ana ] .
figure [ f : gaskin ] shows that the most pronounced differences are seen in the value of the velocity dispersion as observed through the smallest aperture on the nucleus ( observation s1 ) .
this quantity varies from @xmath160 for [ sii ] to @xmath161 for [ oiii ] , cf .
table [ t : fosgaskin ] .
such differences in the line width for different species have previously been found in the central regions of other liner galaxies and seyferts , and have been extensively modeled ( e.g. , whittle 1985 ; simpson & ward 1996 ; simpson et al . 1996 ; and references therein ) .
one result from these studies has been that there is generally a correlation between velocity dispersion and critical density of the lines .
we find a similar result for the nucleus of ic 1459 .
figure [ f : critical]a shows the velocity dispersion for the different lines observed through aperture s1 , versus the critical density ( the balmer lines are not plotted because for them interpretation of the critical density is complicated by the effects of radiative transfer for permitted lines ; see e.g. filippenko & halpern 1984 ) .
there is indeed a rough correlation .
the fact that [ oiii ] has a larger dispersion than [ oi ] is somewhat surprising in view of this , but this has also been found for other galaxies ( whittle 1985 ) .
it has been hypothesized that at a basic level the approximate correlation between velocity dispersion and critical density can be understood as the result of differences in the spatial distribution of the line flux for different species ( osterbrock 1989 , p. 366 ) .
lines with a high critical density tend to be more strongly concentrated towards the ionizing source in the galaxy nucleus than species with a low critical density .
so for a line with a high critical density , the observed flux will on average come from smaller radii .
either the presence of a central bh or increased turbulence ( cf.equation [ eq : turbdef ] ) would naturally cause the gas at smaller radii to move faster , which qualitatively explains the correlation . to make detailed quantitative predictions one would need to model the complete ionization structure ( ionizing flux , electron density , temperature , etc . as function of radius ) and kinematics of the gas , which can generally be done only with simplifying assumptions .
however , even without a detailed model we can test the basic interpretation in an observational sense .
figure [ f : speciesflux ] shows that we are observing different flux distributions for the different lines , which implies that we are actually resolving the region from which the emission arises .
thus we can test directly whether the lines for which the velocity dispersion is high have a flux that is strongly concentrated towards the nucleus .
figure [ f : critical]b confirms this .
it shows the velocity dispersion for the different lines observed through aperture s1 versus the flux - peakedness parameter @xmath162 .
the strong correlation provides direct support for the proposed interpretation . in our dynamical models ,
the gas motions are a function of position in the disk only ; they do not depend on the physical properties of the line species .
hence , differences in the observed kinematics of the lines must be due entirely to differences in their flux distributions . for accurate modeling
it is therefore essential that the intrinsic flux distributions are well - constrained by the observations .
this is true for h@xmath2+[nii ] , for which a narrow - band image is available at the wfpc / pc resolution of @xmath22/pixel .
however , this is not true for [ oi ] , [ oiii ] and [ sii ] , for which only the six fos spectral flux measurements are available , with resolutions no better than @xmath61/aperture .
this is insufficient for accurate modeling .
hence , we can not test in detail whether the different line species all independently indicate the same bh mass .
however , a very simple argument can be used to set an upper limit on how much the bh masses implied by the [ oi ] , [ oiii ] and [ sii ] data could differ from that inferred in section [ ss : bestfit ] from the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 data .
none of the line species have either a central rotation velocity gradient @xmath163 or a central velocity dispersion @xmath164 that exceeds the value for h@xmath2+[nii ] by more than a factor of @xmath165 ( cf .
table [ t : fosgaskin ] ) . in the models of section [ ss : dyn_mod
] one has approximately @xmath166 , while in the models of section [ ss : asymdrift ] one has approximately @xmath167 .
so if we would assume ( incorrectly ) that all species have the same flux distribution , then we would infer bh masses that exceed that inferred from the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 data by at most a factor @xmath168 . however , this is a very conservative upper limit since the flux distributions for e.g. [ oi ] and [ oiii ] _ are _ actually more peaked than for h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 , which would tend to reduce the inferred bh mass .
so the data provide no compelling reason to believe that the [ oi ] , [ oiii ] and [ sii ] observations imply a very different bh mass than inferred from h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 , but we can not test this in detail . for [ sii ] , both the mean velocity and the velocity dispersion profiles are quite irregular .
the [ sii ] lines have a relatively low equivalent width and form a blended doublet , so this could be due to systematic problems in the extraction of the kinematics from the data . on the other hand , irregularities in the dispersion profiles are also seen for [ oiii ] and [ oi ] as observed through the small apertures . although such irregularities are not seen for h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] , this may indicate that our modeling of the gas flux distribution ( eq . [ [ e : fluxparam ] ] ) and the turbulent velocity dispersion ( eq . [ [ eq : turbdef ] ] ) as smooth functions is somewhat oversimplified .
we compared the observed line ratios for ic 1459 with modeled values for shocks ( allen et al .
1998 ; dopita et al .
1997 ) and found them to be consistent .
shocks could naturally explain the turbulence that we invoke in our models of ic 1459 .
at the same time , it would suggest that the gas properties could easily possess more small - scale structure than the smooth functions that we have adopted .
ground - based stellar kinematical data are available from the same major axis ctio spectrum for which the emission lines were discussed in section [ ss : spec_ground ] .
the stellar rotation velocities @xmath71 and velocity dispersions @xmath72 inferred from this spectrum were presented previously in van der marel & franx ( 1993 ) . to interpret these data we constructed a set of axisymmetric stellar - dynamical two - integral models for ic 1459 in which the phase - space distribution function @xmath169 depends only on the two classical integrals of motion .
as before , the mass density was taken to be @xmath170 , with the luminosity density @xmath99 given by equation ( [ e : lumdendef ] ) .
the gravitational potential is the sum of the stellar potential and the kepler potential of a possible central bh .
predictions for the root - mean - square ( rms ) stellar line - of - sight velocities @xmath147^{1/2}$ ] were calculated by solving the jeans equations for hydrostatic equilibrium , projecting the results onto the sky , and convolving them with the observational setup .
this modeling procedure is equivalent to that applied to large samples by , e.g. , van der marel ( 1991 ) and magorrian et al .
the calculations presented here were done with the software developed by van der marel et al .
( 1994 ) .
figure [ f : starkin ] shows the data for @xmath146 as function of major axis distance .
the value of @xmath101 in the models was chosen so as to best fit the data outside the central region , yielding @xmath171 .
this leaves @xmath105 as the only remaining free parameter .
the curves in figure [ f : starkin ] show the model predictions for various values of @xmath105 .
a model without a bh predicts a central dip in @xmath146 , which is not observed .
the models therefore clearly require a bh .
none of the models fits particularly well , but models with @xmath172@xmath173 provide the best fit .
this exceeds the bh mass inferred from the hst gas kinematics by a factor of 10 or more .
this suggests that the assumptions underlying the stellar kinematical analysis may not be correct .
the velocity dispersion anisotropy of a stellar system can have any arbitrary value , and the sense of the anisotropy can have a large effect on inferences about the nuclear mass distribution .
two - integral @xmath169 models can be viewed as axisymmetric generalizations of spherical isotropic models .
such models will overestimate the bh mass if galaxies are actually radially anisotropic ( binney & mamon 1982 ) .
van der marel ( 1999a ) showed that @xmath169 models can easily overestimate the bh mass by a factor of 10 when applied to ground - based data of similar quality as that available here , even for galaxies that are only mildly radially anisotropic .
support that this may be happening comes from various directions .
first , several detailed studies of bright galaxies similar to ic 1459 have concluded that these galaxies are radially anisotropic ( e.g. , rix et al .
1997 ; gerhard et al . 1998 ; matthias & gerhard 1999 ; saglia et al . 1999 ; cretton , rix & de zeeuw 2000 ) .
second , detailed three - integral distribution function modeling of stellar kinematical hst data for several galaxies ( gebhardt et al .
2000 ) does indeed yield bh masses that are many times smaller than inferred by magorrian et al .
( 1998 ) from @xmath169 models for ground - based data for the same galaxies . and
third , models of adiabatic bh growth for hst photometry also suggest that @xmath169 models for ground - based data yield bh masses that are too large ( van der marel 1999b ) .
so in summary , the fact that the bh mass inferred from @xmath169 models for ground - based ic 1459 data does not agree with that inferred from the hst gas kinematics provides little reason to be worried .
it simply shows that one can not generally place very meaningful constraints on bh masses from ground - based stellar kinematics of @xmath174 spatial resolution .
while the bh mass inferred from ground - based stellar kinematical data is generally very sensitive to assumptions about the structure and dynamics of the galaxy , this is not true for the inferred mass - to - light ratio .
models with different inclination ( van der marel 1991 ) or anisotropy ( van der marel 1994 ; 1999a ) yield the same value of @xmath101 to within @xmath90% .
additional support for the accuracy of the inferred @xmath102 comes from the fact that this value yields a good fit to the observed rotation velocities of the gas outside the central few arcsec ( cf .
figure [ f : modelctio ] ) .
we have presented the results from a detailed hst study of the central structure of ic 1459 .
the kinematics of the gas disk in ic 1459 was probed with fos observations through six apertures along the major axis . in our modeling of the observed kinematics we took into account the stellar mass density in the central region by fitting wfpc2 broad - band imaging , and we determined the flux distribution of the emission - gas from wfpc2 narrow - band imaging . from the models we have determined that ic1459 harbors a black hole with a mass in the range @xmath175 @xmath176 , with the exact value depending somewhat on whether we model the gas as rotating on circular orbits , or as an ensemble of collisionless cloudlets . while the dynamical models that we have constructed provide good fits to the observations ,
the true structure of ic 1459 could of course be more complex than our models .
below we discuss several aspects of this .
ground - based observations ( goudfrooij et al . 1994 ; forbes & reitzel 1995 ) indicate an ellipticity @xmath31 for the gas disk at radii larger than a few arcseconds , implying an inclination angle @xmath82 .
by contrast , from our hst emission - line image we found a monotonic increase in ellipticity from @xmath35 to @xmath177 between @xmath36 to @xmath178 . in our modeling
we have assumed that these rounder inner isophotes are due to a thickening of the gas disk caused by asymmetric drift , and we estimated the effect of this on the inferred @xmath105 ( see sections [ ss : ctiocomp ] and [ ss : asymdrift ] ) .
however , an alternative interpretation would be to assume that the disk is warped .
the presence of a dust lane slightly misaligned with the gas disk , a counter - rotating stellar core , and stellar shells and ripples in the outer galaxy make it plausible that the central gas and dust were accreted from outside , displaying warps as it settles down . in this interpretation
we infer an increase in inclination angle from @xmath179 to @xmath180 between @xmath36 to @xmath178 .
the bh mass in the models of section [ ss : dyn_mod ] scales as @xmath181 due to the projection of the rotational velocities .
hence the inferred differences in inclination angle would amount to an increase in @xmath105 by only a factor @xmath182 , which would not significantly change our results .
ic 1459 hosts an unresolved blue nuclear point source .
carollo et al .
( 1997 ) estimated a luminosity of @xmath183 .
so far , we have assumed that this light is non - stellar radiation from the active nucleus .
however , one could assume alternatively that the blue light is emitted by a cluster of young stars .
if the cluster were to have a mass equal to the mass @xmath105 that we have inferred from our models , this would require @xmath184 .
depending on age and metallicity , stellar evolution models typically predict @xmath185 for a young cluster ( e.g. , worthey 1994 ) .
thus the assumption that the point source is stellar in origin can not lift the need for a central concentration of non - luminous matter , most likely a bh .
the data show differences between the fluxes and kinematics for the various line species .
the main characteristics of the observed kinematics are similar for all species , but we see that for the species with higher critical densities the flux distribution is generally more concentrated towards the nucleus and the observed velocities are higher . this can be well understood qualitatively in the framework of a single @xmath105 .
however , to actually verify quantitatively whether each species implies the same value for @xmath105 would require information on the flux distributions for each species at high spatial resolution as well as detailed knowledge on the ionization structure of the gas , neither of which is available .
an extremely conservative upper limit on the differences in the @xmath105 implied by the different line species is obtained by assuming that all species have the same flux distribution ( not actually correct ) , in which case @xmath105 values are obtained that are up to @xmath168 times larger than inferred from h@xmath3 and h@xmath2+[nii ] .
irregularities in the velocity dispersion profiles of [ oiii ] , [ oi ] and [ sii ] suggest localized turbulent motions .
we incorporated turbulent motion in our models in a very simple manner ( cf .
equation [ eq : turbdef ] ) , using a parametrization that fits the main trend of an increase of the velocity dispersion toward the nucleus .
nevertheless , going to the extreme , one could assume that all observed motions have a non - gravitational origin .
the overall kinematics would then be due to in- or outflows .
there are several objections to this interpretation .
a spherical in- or outflow could not produce any net mean velocity .
a bi - directional flow is unlikely since no hint of this is seen in the hst h@xmath2+[nii ] emission image .
next we consider the location of ic 1459 with respect to the correlations between @xmath105 and host total optical and radio luminosity , mentioned in the introduction .
the ratio of @xmath105 and galaxy mass is in the range @xmath6@xmath7 .
this is somewhat lower than the average value of @xmath186 seen for other galaxies ( kormendy & richstone 1995 ) , but still comfortably within the observed scatter .
as discussed in the introduction , ic 1459 is probably the end - product of a merger between two galaxies .
apparently , this merger history has not moved ic 1459 to an atypical spot in the @xmath105 vs. galaxy mass scatter diagram .
the fact that ic 1459 has a liner type spectrum and core radio emission , but no jets , makes it interesting to see where it is located on a @xmath187 plot .
ic 1459 has a radio luminosity of @xmath188 at 5 ghz ( wright et al .
interestingly , this puts ic 1459 within the scatter observed around the correlation between @xmath105 and total radio luminosity inferred for a small sample of galaxies with available bh mass determinations , but quite off the correlation with core radio luminosity ( see figs . 3 and 4 of franceschini , vercellone , & fabian 1998 ) .
however , one should be weary of beaming and variability of core radio sources , and possible resolution differences among the observations .
our dynamical modeling has used the gas disk in ic 1459 as a diagnostic tool to constrain @xmath105 . a logical next step to improve on our work would be to obtain better two - dimensional coverage of the gaseous and stellar kinematics . a definite advance in our understanding of nuclear gas disks
would also be obtained if we had a better knowledge of properties of the gas disk such as the electron density , metallicity , and the ionization structure and ionization mechanism .
one could then try to simultaneously understand these properties and the gas dynamics .
we now know that quite likely most , or even all , bright ellipticals host a massive central bh .
more detailed knowledge of the chemical properties and kinematics of the dust and gas surrounding the bh could tell us about the origin of this material : accretion of small satellites , stripping of companions , or internal mass loss from stars .
this would immediately constrain the frequency and probability with which any bright elliptical hosts this material .
a better understanding of the kinematics , such as the importance of dissipative shocks generated by turbulence , could then help to determine the accretion rate of the black hole .
these pieces of information together could tell us what fraction of the observed @xmath105 could have come from this process over the life time of a galaxy .
knowledge on the ratio of black hole and stellar mass as function of time would be valuable for understanding the formation and evolution of early - type galaxies in general .
support for this work was provided by nasa through grant number # go-06537.01 - 95a , and through c.m.c.s hubble fellowship # hf-01079.01 - 96a , awarded by the space telescope science institute which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , incorporated , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
the authors would like to thank marijn franx for helpful comments on an earlier version of the manuscript .
s1 & h@xmath3 & -22 & 60 & 599 & 63 + & [ oiii ] & -146 & 57 & 1014 & 47 + & [ oi ] & -55 & 45 & 748 & 46 + & h@xmath2+[nii ] & -108 & 26 & 545 & 23 + & [ sii ] & 34 & 32 & 211 & 25 + + s2 & h@xmath3 & 185 & 73 & 473 & 76 + & [ oiii ] & 328 & 40 & 491 & 40 + & [ oi ] & 241 & 50 & 414 & 50 + & h@xmath2+[nii ] & 247 & 21 & 422 & 19 + & [ sii ] & 531 & 226 & 409 & 133 + + s3 & h@xmath3 & 162 & 56 & 363 & 56 + & [ oiii ] & 277 & 68 & 562 & 68 + & [ oi ] & 243 & 91 & 630 & 98 + & h@xmath2+[nii ] & 116 & 17 & 280 & 13 + & [ sii ] & -35 & 42 & 241 & 35 + + l1 & h@xmath3 & -158 & 39 & 381 & 40 + & [ oiii ] & -395 & 44 & 848 & 36 + & [ oi ] & -99 & 43 & 526 & 48 + & h@xmath2+[nii ] & -121 & 10 & 321 & 8 + & [ sii ] & -113 & 22 & 216 & 15 + + l2 & h@xmath3 & 92 & 31 & 408 & 30 + & [ oiii ] & 39 & 45 & 920 & 38 + & [ oi ] & 62 & 38 & 564 & 41 + & h@xmath2+[nii ] & 72 & 15 & 473 & 13 + & [ sii ] & 75 & 43 & 311 & 32 + + l3 & h@xmath3 & 55 & 54 & 202 & 53 + & [ oiii ] & 252 & 35 & 243 & 36 + & [ oi ] & 43 & 35 & 158 & 34 + & h@xmath2+[nii ] & 106 & 17 & 280 & 13 + & [ sii ] & 91 & 26 & 188 & 19 + 4.65 & 2 & 335 & 21 & 122 & 22 & 343 & 10 & 125 & 10 + 3.55 & 1 & 284 & 26 & 125 & 27 & 313 & 15 & 154 & 15 + 2.82 & 1 & 249 & 30 & 110 & 31 & 301 & 12 & 132 & 12 + 2.09 & 1 & 245 & 25 & 144 & 26 & 265 & 17 & 185 & 17 + 1.36 & 1 & 104 & 20 & 195 & 21 & 104 & 15 & 261 & 16 + 0.63 & 1 & 31 & 11 & 212 & 12 & 47 & 9 & 296 & 9 + -0.10 & 1 & 0 & 10 & 218 & 10 & 0 & 7 & 320 & 8 + -0.83 & 1 & -50 & 10 & 172 & 10 & -63 & 9 & 285 & 9 + -1.56 & 1 & -81 & 13 & 157 & 14 & -130 & 10 & 183 & 10 + -2.29 & 1 & 164 & 23 & 138 & 24 & -159 & 13 & 170 & 13 + -3.02 & 1 & 191 & 21 & 107 & 22 & -223 & 15 & 155 & 15 + -3.75 & 1 & 212 & 18 & 66 & 17 & -267 & 19 & 133 & 19 + -4.85 & 2 & 346 & 53 & 138 & 55 & -315 & 21 & 151 & 22 + | the peculiar elliptical galaxy ic 1459 ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 ) has a fast counterrotating stellar core , stellar shells and ripples , a blue nuclear point source and strong radio core emission .
we present results of a detailed hst study of ic 1459 , and in particular its central gas disk , aimed a constraining the central mass distribution .
we obtained wfpc2 narrow - band imaging centered on the h@xmath2+[nii ] emission lines to determine the flux distribution of the gas emission at small radii , and we obtained fos spectra at six aperture positions along the major axis to sample the gas kinematics .
we construct dynamical models for the h@xmath2+[nii ] and h@xmath3 kinematics that include a supermassive black hole , and in which the stellar mass distribution is constrained by the observed surface brightness distribution and ground - based stellar kinematics . in one set of models
we assume that the gas rotates on circular orbits in an infinitesimally thin disk .
such models adequately reproduce the observed gas fluxes and kinematics .
the steepness of the observed rotation velocity gradient implies that a black hole must be present .
there are some differences between the fluxes and kinematics for the various line species that we observe in the wavelength range 4569 to 6819 .
species with higher critical densities generally have a flux distribution that is more concentrated towards the nucleus , and have observed velocities that are higher .
this can be attributed qualitatively to the presence of the black hole .
there is some evidence that the gas in the central few arcsec has a certain amount of asymmetric drift , and we therefore construct alternative models in which the gas resides in collisionless cloudlets that move isotropically .
all models are consistent with a black hole mass in the range @xmath4@xmath5 , and models without a black hole are always ruled out at high confidence .
the implied ratio of black holes mass to galaxy mass is in the range @xmath6@xmath7 , which is not inconsistent with results obtained for other galaxies .
these results for the peculiar galaxy ic 1459 and its black hole add an interesting data point for studies on the nature of galactic nuclei . |
the black - hole binary grs 1915 + 105 is highly variable in x - rays ( belloni et al .
2000 , and references therein ) .
still , even its hardest spectra are relatively soft , consisting of a blackbody - like component and a high - energy tail ( vilhu et al .
they are softer than those of other black - hole binaries in the hard state , which @xmath1 spectra peak at @xmath2 kev ( e.g. , cyg x-1 , gierliski et al .
1997 ) , and are similar to their soft state ( e.g. , cyg x-1 , gierliski et al . 1999 , hereafter g99 ; lmc x-1 , lmc x-3 , wilms et al .
2001 ) .
the blackbody component arises , most likely , in an optically - thick accretion disk . on the other hand
, there is no consensus at present regarding the origin of the tail .
all three main models proposed so far involve comptonization of the blackbody photons by high - energy electrons .
they differ , however , in the distribution ( and location ) of the electrons , which are assumed to be either thermal ( maxwellian ) , non - thermal ( close to a power law ) , or in a free fall onto the black hole . a discussion of these models is given in zdziarski ( 2000 ) , who shows that the thermal and free - fall models of the soft state of black hole binaries can be ruled out , mostly by the marked absence of a high - energy cutoff around 100 kev in the _ cgro _ data ( grove et al .
1998 ; g99 ; tomsick et al . 1999 ; mcconnell et al .
the present best soft - state model appears to involve electron acceleration out of a maxwellian distribution ( i.e. , a non - thermal process ) , which leads to a hybrid electron distribution consisting of both thermal and non - thermal parts ( zdziarski , lightman & macioek - niedwiecki 1993 ; poutanen & coppi 1998 ; g99 ; coppi 1999 ) . in this _ letter _ , we present all osse observations of grs 1915 + 105 .
we then choose two osse spectra corresponding to the lowest and highest x - ray flux and fit them together with spectra from simultaneous _
rxte _ pointed observations .
the spectra , showing extended power laws without any cutoff up to at least 600 kev , provide strong evidence for the presence of non - thermal comptonization .
more extensive presentation of the combined x - ray / osse data will be given elsewhere .
table 1 gives the log of the 9 osse observations , together with results of power - law fits and basic data about the corresponding x - ray and radio states .
the osse instrument accumulated spectra in a sequence of 2-min .
measurements of the source field alternated with 2-min . , offset - pointed measurements of background .
the background spectrum for each source field was derived bin - by - bin with a quadratic interpolation in time of the nearest background fields ( see johnson et al .
figure [ fig : osse ] shows the osse spectra ( including standard energy - dependent systematic errors ) , which were fitted up to energies at which the source signal was still detected .
the uncertainty for a fitted parameter corresponds hereafter to 90% confidence ( @xmath3 ) .
we see that the source went through wide ranges of radio and x - ray fluxes and types of x - ray variability during those observations . in spite of that variety , 8 out of 9 osse spectra
are best - fitted by a power law with a photon index of @xmath4 and the flux varying within a factor of 2 .
the only exception is the osse spectrum corresponding to the highest x - ray flux measured by the asm ( 1999 april 2127 ) , which is much harder , @xmath5 , and has a much lower flux .
we then consider the osse spectra corresponding to the extreme x - ray fluxes measured by the _
rxte_/asm , i.e. , from 1997 may 1420 ( vp 619 ) and 1999 april2127 ( vp 813 ) .
we fit them together with spectra from the pointed _ rxte _ observations of 1997 may 15 and 1999 april 23 ( the observation ids are 20187 - 02 - 02 - 00 , 40403 - 01 - 07 - 00 ; 1% systematic error is added to the pca data with the responses of 2001 february ) .
these pca data correspond to the variability classes ( belloni et al .
2000 ) of @xmath6 and @xmath7 , in which the variability is moderate and the source spends most of the time in two basic low ( @xmath8 ) and high ( @xmath9 ) x - ray flux state , respectively .
we fit the data with the xspec ( arnaud 1996 ) model eqpair ( coppi 1999 ; g99 ) , which calculates self - consistently microscopic processes in a hot plasma with electron acceleration at a power law rate with an index , @xmath10 , in a background thermal plasma with a thomson optical depth of ionization electrons , @xmath11 .
the electron temperature , @xmath12 , is calculated from the balance of compton and coulomb energy exchange , as well as @xmath13 pair production ( yielding the total optical depth of @xmath14 ) is taken into account .
the last two processes depend on the plasma compactness , @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is a power supplied to the hot plasma , @xmath17 is its characteristic size , and @xmath18 is the thomson cross section .
we then define a hard compactness , @xmath19 , corresponding to the power supplied to the electrons , and a soft compactness , @xmath20 , corresponding to the power in soft seed photons irradiating the plasma ( which are assumed to be emitted by a blackbody disk with the maximum temperature , @xmath21 ) .
the compactnesses corresponding to the electron acceleration and to a direct heating ( i.e. , in addition to coulomb energy exchange with non - thermal @xmath13 and compton heating ) of the thermal @xmath13 are denoted as @xmath22 and @xmath23 , respectively , and @xmath24 .
details of the model are given in g99 .
= 8.7 cm we also take into account compton reflection with a solid angle of @xmath25 ( magdziarz & zdziarski 1995 ) and an fe k@xmath26 emission from an accretion disk assumed to extend down to @xmath27 ( which results in a relativistic smearing ) .
the equivalent width , @xmath28 , with respect to the _ scattered _ spectrum only is tied to @xmath25 via @xmath29 ev ( george & fabian 1991 ) .
the elemental abundances of anders & ebihara ( 1982 ) , an absorbing column of @xmath30 @xmath31 ( dickey & lockman 1990 ; vilhu et al .
2001 ) , and an inclination of @xmath32 are assumed . as discussed in g99 , @xmath33 depends weakly on @xmath20 in a wide range of this parameter .
an increase of @xmath20 leads to increasing @xmath13 pair production , which then leads to an annihilation feature around 511 kev .
the presence of such a feature is compatible with the osse data ( fig .
[ fig : osse ] ) , but only very weakly constrained .
g99 found that @xmath34 provides a good fit to cyg x-1 data . here , we find that a good fit is provided with @xmath35 , compatible with the high luminosity of grs 1915 + 105
. for example , for 1/2 of the eddington luminosity , @xmath36 , and spherical geometry , the size of the plasma corresponds then to @xmath37 .
this model provides very good description of our two broad - band spectra ( as well as of other _
rxte_-osse spectra , s. v. vadawale et al .
, in preparation ) . for vp 619 , we assume a free relative normalization of the hexte and osse spectra with respect to those from the pca . on the other hand
, the hexte spectrum for vp 813 has relatively few counts at its highest energies , and thus we use the actual osse normalization in that fit .
table 2 gives the fit results , and figure [ f : data ] shows the spectra .
= 8.2 cm our model predicts the power law emission extending with no cutoff well above 1 mev and a weak annihilation feature ( with the plasma allowed to be pair - dominated , i.e. , with @xmath38 , for vp 619 ) .
those predictions can be tested by future soft @xmath7-ray detectors more sensitive than the osse .
we note that the comptel has already detected a power law tail up to @xmath39510 mev in the soft state of cyg x-1 ( mcconnell et al .
2000 ) .
figure [ f : model]a shows the spectral components of the fit to the vp-619 spectrum .
compton reflection with @xmath40 is detected at a very high significance ( @xmath41 gives @xmath42 , corresponding to the chance appearance of reflection of @xmath43 from the @xmath44-test ) , and it is responsible for the convex curvature in the @xmath3910100 kev spectrum .
figure [ f : model]a also shows that the scattered component has a spectral break at @xmath2 kev but continues as a power law ( with addition of the broad annihilation feature ) above it due to the domination of non - thermal scattering at those energies .
comptonization by the thermal electrons dominates at energies close to the blackbody component and thus pca data of grs 1915 + 105 can be reasonably modeled up to 60 kev by thermal comptonization of a disk blackbody ( vilhu et al .
when the osse data are included , the probability that non - thermal electrons are not present ( i.e. , @xmath45 ) is only @xmath46 . the best - fit thermal compton model shown by the long dashes in figure [ f : model]a strongly underestimates the flux above 100 kev .
the statistical significance of the presence of non - thermal electrons can be further increased by fitting the _ rxte _ spectrum together with the average spectrum from osse , which has virtually identical shape to that of vp 619 , but much better statistics .
then , allowing for @xmath47 reduces @xmath48 from @xmath49 to @xmath50 , which corresponds to the chance probability of @xmath51 .
thus , we strongly rule out the pure - thermal comptonization model . during the vp 813 ,
compton reflection is statistically not required , as indeed expected at the large @xmath52 of the scattering medium covering the disk ( which would completely smear out any disk reflection and fluorescence features ) .
thus , we set @xmath41 is the fit .
the presence of non - thermal electrons is now required at an extremely high significance ( @xmath53 ) due to the presence of the very distinct hard high - energy tail above the thermally cut - off spectrum , see figures [ f : data ] , [ f : model]b .
= 8.4 cm on the other hand , shrader & titarchuk ( 1998 ) have fitted a model of bulk - motion comptonization of blackbody photons to _ rxte _ and batse data from a hard state of grs 1915 + 105 similar to that of vp 619 .
we fit their model ( bmc in xspec ) at a free @xmath54 to our broad - band spectra , and find it is completely unacceptable statistically , with @xmath55 and @xmath56 for vp 619 and 813 , respectively . however , the _ specific _ feature of bulk - motion comptonization is a high - energy cutoff at @xmath57 kev due to the effects of compton recoil and gravitational redshift close to the black - hole horizon ( e.g. laurent & titarchuk 1999 ) .
such a cutoff is _ not _ included in the bmc model ( and its inclusion would further worsen the fits above ) .
thus , we use monte carlo results of laurent & titarchuk ( 1999 ) , which include the cutoff , to test whether the osse data ( regardless of the data at lower energies ) are compatible with its presence .
we find that their theoretical spectrum for the accretion rate of @xmath58 matches well the slope of the average osse spectrum at low energies ( the histogram in fig .
[ f : bmc ] ) .
the monte - carlo spectrum can then be very well reproduced by a power law times a step function convolved with a gaussian ( model plabs(step ) in xspec , with the cutoff energy of 150 kev and the gaussian width of 35 kev , the solid curve in fig .
[ f : bmc ] ) .
we see that the osse average spectrum lies well above that model at @xmath57 kev .
quantitatively , the bulk - motion compton model yields @xmath59 . in comparison ,
the power - law and eqpair models yield @xmath60 and @xmath61 , respectively .
thus , the bulk - compton model is completely ruled out .
further problems with that model are discussed in zdziarski ( 2000 ) .
= 7.0 cm also , the commonly used phenomenological models of disk blackbody and either a power law or an e - folded power law give very bad fits to our data .
the latter yields @xmath62 , @xmath63 for vp 619 , 813 , respectively .
in fact , even the thermal part of the vp-813 spectrum is very poorly described by a disk blackbody , with @xmath64 for a fit to the 3.520 kev pca data , whereas the same data are well modeled by thermal comptonization , @xmath65 ( with neither model including a high - energy tail ) .
thus , we find physical models of the spectra of grs 1915 + 105 in terms of thermal and non - thermal comptonization and ( in some cases ) compton reflection to be vastly superior to any other model proposed so far .
we have found that broad - band spectra of grs 1915 + 105 in its two main spectral states ( @xmath9 , @xmath8 ) are very well fitted by comptonization of disk blackbody photons in a ( hybrid ) plasma with both electron heating and acceleration .
the presence of strong reflection indicates the plasma is located in coronal regions ( possibly magnetic flares ) above the disk .
this physical model is the same as that fitted to the soft state of cyg x-1 by g99 .
differences in the variability properties of cyg x-1 and grs 1915 + 105 are likely to be due to the disk being stable in the former case and unstable in the latter , most likely due to its much higher @xmath66 .
the corona is unstable in both cases .
the comptonizing medium in the high-@xmath67 state ( @xmath9 ) is thomson - thick , and it can represent the surface layer of an overheated disk accreting at a super - eddington rate ( beloborodov 1998 ) .
an issue to be addressed by future research is the origin of the hardening of the tail in this state as compared to other ones ( fig . [
fig : osse ] ) .
our model predicts broad annihilation features , although their strength depends on the unknown size of the plasma .
grs 1915 + 105 was in the power - law @xmath7-ray state in the classification of grove et al .
( 1998 ) during the 9 osse observations .
this state usually corresponds to the high / soft x - ray state .
indeed , x - ray spectra observed so far from grs 1915 + 105(vilhu et al .
2001 ) are substantially softer than those with @xmath68 and a sharp thermal cutoff at @xmath69 kev , characteristic to the hard state of other black - hole binaries .
we thank p. coppi and m. gierliski for their work on the eqpair model , w. n. johnson for help with the osse data reduction , and ph .
laurent for supplying his monte carlo results .
this research has been supported by grants from kbn ( 2p03d00614 and 2p03c00619p1,2 ) , the foundation for polish science ( aaz ) , and the swedish natural science research council and the anna - greta and holger crafoord fund ( jp ) .
jp and aaz acknowledge support from the royal swedish academy of sciences , the polish academy of sciences and the indian national science academy through exchange programs .
zdziarski , a. a. 2000 , in iau symp .
195 , highly energetic physical processes and mechanisms for emission from astrophysical plasmas , ed .
martens , s. tsuruta & m. a. weber ( san francisco : asp ) , 153 ( astro - ph/0001078 ) | grs 1915 + 105 was observed by the _
cgro_/osse 9 times in 1995 - 2000 , and 8 of those observations were simultaneous with those by _ rxte_. we present an analysis of all of the osse data and of two _ rxte_-osse spectra with the lowest and highest x - ray fluxes .
the osse data show a power - law like spectrum extending up to @xmath0 kev without any break .
we interpret this emission as strong evidence for the presence of non - thermal electrons in the source .
the broad - band spectra can not be described by either thermal or bulk - motion comptonization , whereas they are well described by comptonization in hybrid thermal / non - thermal plasmas . |
we would like to thank bruce reed for introducing us to the classical version of the locker puzzle and richard cleve for pointing out the perfect quantum search of @xcite .
this work was partially supported by an an nserc discovery grant and an nserc postdoctoral fellowship . | the _ locker puzzle _ is a game played by multiple players against a referee .
it has been previously shown that the best strategy that exists can not succeed with probability greater than , no matter how many players are involved .
our contribution is to show that quantum players can do much better they can succeed with . by making the rules of the game significantly stricter ,
we show a scenario where the quantum players still succeed perfectly , while the classical players win with vanishing probability .
other variants of the locker puzzle are considered , as well as a cheating referee .
* keywords : quantum complexity , grover search , locker puzzle * 10000 10000 grover s quantum algorithm @xcite provides a quadratic speedup over the best possible classical algorithm for the problem of unsorted searching in the query model . while grover s search method has been shown to be optimal @xcite , our results reveal that in the context of multi - player query games , applying grover s algorithm yields success probabilities that are much better than the success probabilities of classical optimal protocols .
specifically , we show that in the case of the _ locker puzzle _ , quantum players succeed with probability 1 while the known optimal classical success probability is bounded above by . in order to amplify this separation , we prove that a significantly stricter version of the locker puzzle has vanishing classical success probability , while still admitting a perfect quantum strategy .
we also consider the empty locker and the coloured slips versions of the locker puzzle , and the possibility of a cheating referee .
[ sec : locker puzzle ] the _ _ locker puzzle _ _ is a cooperative game between a team of @xmath0 players numbered @xmath1 and a referee . in the initial phase of the game , the referee chooses a random permutation @xmath2 of @xmath3 , and for each player @xmath4 she places number @xmath4 in locker @xmath5 . in the following phase , each player
is individually admitted into the locker room .
once in the room , each player is allowed to open @xmath6 lockers , one at a time , and look at their contents ( for simplicity , we ll take @xmath0 to be even ) .
after the player leaves the room , all lockers are closed .
the players are initially allowed to discuss strategy , but once the game starts , they are separated and can not communicate .
an individual player @xmath4 _ wins _ if he opens a locker containing number @xmath4 , while the team of @xmath0 players _ wins _ if all individual players win .
we would like to know what is the best strategy for the team of @xmath0 players .
a nave approach is for each player to independently choose @xmath6 lockers to open .
each players wins independently with probability @xmath7 , hence the team wins with probability @xmath8 .
surprisingly , it is known that the players can do much , much better !
we will review in section [ section : optimal - classical - locker ] an optimum strategy by which , for any @xmath0 , the players can win with probability at least @xmath9 .
the locker puzzle was originally considered by peter bro miltersen , and was first published in @xcite ; a journal version appears in @xcite .
sven skylum is credited for the pointer - following strategy that we will give in the next section .
a proof of optimality for this strategy is given by eugene curtin and max warshauer @xcite .
our presentation of the classical puzzle and its solution follows along the lines of their article .
many variations have been proposed @xcite .
we will consider the variations of _ empty lockers _ in section [ section : empty - lockers ] , _ coloured slips _ in section [ section : coloured - slips ] ( to be accurate , the locker and the coloured slips puzzles are variants of the empty locker puzzle ) , and a _ cheating referee _ in section [ sec : cheating ] .
[ section : optimal - classical - locker ] we saw that a nave solution allows the players to win with an exponentially small probability .
how can we devise a strategy that does better ? the reader avid to search for a solution on his or her own is encouraged to do so now .
the key is to find a solution where the individual success probabilities are not independent .
consider the following strategy : when first entering the locker room , player @xmath4 opens locker number @xmath4 .
a number is revealed ; this is used to indicate which locker to open next ( i.e. if number @xmath10 is revealed , the next locker opened is locker @xmath10 ) .
each player executes this pointer - following strategy until @xmath6 lockers are opened . to analyze the success probability , note that the team will win provided that the _ permutation _ that corresponds to the placement of numbers in lockers by the referee does not contain a cycle of length longer than @xmath6 .
the probability of such a long cycle occurring is : @xmath11 it can be shown that as @xmath12 , @xmath13 and that the sum increases with @xmath0 .
hence the probability that the team wins is decreasing to @xmath14 . using a reduction to another game
, this strategy can be shown to be optimal @xcite .
[ sec : quantum solution ] we now present our first contribution : a quantum solution to the locker puzzle , which performs better than the classical solution . as before the referee chooses a random permutation @xmath2 and she places numbers in the lockers according to this permutation . in the quantum solution , we allow the players to open locker doors in _ superposition _ , each player working with his own quantum register .
this is analogous to the quantum query model . for the quantum case
, we need to modify the goal of the game which , for player @xmath4 , becomes to _ correctly guess _ the locker containing number @xmath4 after @xmath6 queries , and _ not _ to open locker containing number @xmath4 , because this would be too easy to do in superposition ! we show that quantum players can always win at the locker game .
in fact , our results are stronger : we give a stricter version of the locker puzzle for which the optimal classical solution succeeds with vanishing probability , while a quantum strategy always succeeds ! [ imp ]
the main idea is to apply grover s quantum search algorithm to the locker puzzle . for player @xmath4
, we consider the action of opening a locker as a query to the oracle which when input locker number @xmath15 , @xmath16 , outputs the following : @xmath17 note that this oracle is weaker than the oracle in the original puzzle which would output @xmath18 .
we discuss this further in section [ subsection : optimality ] and in the conclusion .
grover s search algorithm @xcite was thoroughly analyzed in @xcite , where it was shown that in a black - box search scenario where it is known that a single solution exists , @xmath19 queries yield a failure probability no greater than @xmath20 , where @xmath0 is the number of elements in the search space ( here , @xmath0 is assumed to be large ) .
this was further improved in @xcite , where is was shown that the same amount of queries is sufficient to find a solution with _
certainty_.
applying this directly to the quantum players of the locker puzzle yields the following : 1 .
[ step : groverquery]each player performs @xmath19 queries ( this is less than the @xmath21 queries in the classical solution ) .
2 . each player wins independently with certainty , implying that the team wins with certainty .
[ sec : reducing - number - queries ] we ve seen that quantum players of the locker game can succeed with probability 1 .
our solution only requires @xmath19 oracle queries per player .
hence , we now consider the asymptotically stricter version of the locker puzzle , where players are allowed to open at most @xmath22 lockers .
the next theorem state that the success probability for classical players goes quickly to 0 .
[ thm : classic ] in the locker puzzle with @xmath22 queries , classical players win with probability at most @xmath23 .
let @xmath24 .
we upper bound the success probability of the first @xmath25 players , when each player is allowed to open @xmath26 lockers . since @xmath27 ,
this upper bounds the success probability of all @xmath0 players .
consider a new game where the first player opens exactly @xmath26 lockers and publicly reveals all of their contents . if the first player s number is not revealed the players lose and the game is over .
otherwise the @xmath26 revealed players have successfully located their lockers .
these @xmath26 lockers and players are now removed from the game .
the first player has success probability at most @xmath28 . in successive rounds ,
a player is chosen from amongst those not yet removed from the game .
he continues in the same way by choosing @xmath26 of the remaining lockers and revealing their contents .
if he finds his label , again @xmath26 lockers and players are removed from the game .
the game stops whenever a chosen player does not find his label .
otherwise it continues for @xmath26 rounds and terminates with a win for the players .
the success probability of the new game is at most @xmath29 the original game with no revealing of numbers can not do better . [
subsection : optimality ] in the quantum query model with oracle ( [ eq : oracle ] ) the total number of queries required to obtain a success probability of one for the players is in @xmath30 .
first consider a variation of the quantum game where the players act sequentially in the order @xmath31 and are allowed to announce their results to the other players .
the number of queries performed by player 1 must be in @xmath32 or he will not succeed with probability one .
this follows from the analysis of grover s algorithm , see @xcite . the only information given by the oracle @xmath33 is the location of the locker containing label @xmath34 .
suppose player 2 is allowed to receive this information and remove that locker from consideration .
the permutation @xmath2 induces a random permutation on the remaining @xmath35 lockers .
player 2 s success probability is then one only if his number of queries is in @xmath36 .
continuing , the @xmath4-th player must ask a number of queries in @xmath37 .
the total number of queries is therefore in @xmath30 . in the modified game we share all information available to all players that have not already played .
so this shows a lower bound of the same order for the original version of the quantum game where no information is shared .
let us now compare the strength of oracle ( [ eq : oracle ] ) with the stronger oracle where @xmath38 . in the classical setup
, the weaker oracle ( [ eq : oracle ] ) merely tells a given player whether or not his label is in a requested locker .
there are an even number @xmath0 of lockers and he can ask @xmath39 queries . again
we consider a sequential version of the game as described above , where each player reveals his results .
if he succeeds , he reveals the locker with his number and that locker is removed . for the other lockers he queried
, the only information he has is that they did not contain his label .
therefore after his locker is removed , the other players have no further information .
the success probability of this variation of the locker game is : @xmath40 where we have used stirling s formula twice .
this is exponentially small and provides an upper bound on the success probability of the classical locker game with the weak oracle ( [ eq : oracle ] ) . by comparison , as we saw in section [ section : optimal - classical - locker ] the players can win with constant probability using the stronger oracle .
an open question is whether the quantum algorithm can be improved by using this stronger oracle .
the original motivation for the locker puzzle came from the study of time - space tradeoffs for the substring search problem in the context of _ bit probe complexity _
@xcite . there , a version with both _
empty lockers _ and _ coloured slips _ was presented .
we now examine these two variations separately and consider the quantum case .
[ section : empty - lockers ] suppose there are a total of @xmath41 lockers .
the referee selects an unordered subset @xmath2 of @xmath42 with cardinality @xmath0 and she puts label @xmath4 into locker @xmath43 for @xmath44 .
the remaining @xmath45 lockers are empty .
assume @xmath46 is even , and we allow the players to open up to @xmath47 lockers .
an optimum winning strategy for this more general situation is unknown : the pointer algorithm fails if an empty locker is opened .
even for the case @xmath48 , where half of the lockers are empty , it is still unknown if there is a classical strategy with success probability bounded away from zero @xcite .
however , the quantum strategy given in section [ sec : quantum solution ] still succeeds with probability one with a number of queries in @xmath49 per player , for a total of @xmath50 queries .
it suffices to modify the oracle ( [ eq : oracle ] ) so that @xmath15 runs over the range @xmath51 , and query it @xmath52 times .
if it turns out that for these same parameters , the classical success probability vanishes , then the power of the quantum world would be once more confirmed , as in section [ sec : reducing - number - queries ] . and section [ subsection : optimality ] .
[ section : coloured - slips ] consider the empty lockers game with @xmath41 lockers , again with @xmath0 players and @xmath0 slips of paper , each labelled @xmath53 .
this time the referee colours each slip either red or blue as she chooses , and places them in a randomly selected subset of @xmath0 lockers . as before ,
each player @xmath4 may open @xmath47 lockers using any adaptive strategy , and based on this , must make a guess about the colour of the slip labelled @xmath4 .
the players win if every player correctly announces the colour of his slip . with @xmath54 ,
this can be solved with the pointer - following algorithm and the players have success probability about 0.31 . in the quantum setting
, the players can win with probability one at the colour guessing game also , by changing the oracle ( [ eq : oracle ] ) .
let @xmath55 be the colour of the slip for player @xmath4 .
define for @xmath51 and @xmath56 : @xmath57 now we use the protocol described in section [ imp ] with each player querying this new oracle @xmath52 times .
if for player @xmath4 @xmath58 , then there is exactly one @xmath15 for which @xmath59 and grover s algorithm returns @xmath60 with probability one .
otherwise , if @xmath61 then @xmath62 is identically zero and grover s algorithm may return any value @xmath15 .
the player now makes one further call to oracle ( [ eq : oracle1 ] ) with the returned value @xmath15 and guesses red if the oracle returns one and blue otherwise .
[ sec : cheating ] a cheating referee can obviously beat the players in the locker game .
she simply has to omit the label of one of the players .
this could be easily exposed by requiring that all the lockers be opened and checked at the end of the game .
a more subtle way of cheating is if the referee can somehow choose the permutation @xmath2 . in the original locker game ,
let @xmath63 , and let @xmath64 be a random unordered subset of @xmath65 players .
she may set @xmath66 , @xmath67 , and fill out the rest of @xmath2 at random from the remaining players .
it is easy to verify that , using the pointer algorithm , player @xmath68 opens @xmath6 lockers @xmath69 and does not find his label .
he has to guess and loses with probability about @xmath70 .
the same thing happens for each of the players @xmath71 .
( incidentally , the reason for not choosing @xmath72 is that the players not finding their label may guess the locker number they see in the last locker they open , winning the game with probability one ! ) .
using variants of this idea the referee may cheat successfully for some time before the players catch on .
if the players have access to shared randomness ( which is unknown to the referee ) , they can circumvent this problem by first applying their own permutation on the lockers before opening any of them .
interestingly , our quantum protocol is impervious to a referee who maliciously chooses the permutation , and does not require shared randomness .
[ sec : conclusion ] it was previously known that the locker puzzle has an intriguing classical optimal solution .
now we know that the locker puzzle and its variants also have interesting quantum solutions which perform significantly better than the classical ones . we have given a quantum solution in the black - box query complexity model that _ does not use the pointer - following technique that is crucial to the classical optimal solution_. it would be interesting to see if using the stronger classical oracle could lead to a quantum solution that works with a reasonable probability of success using @xmath73 total queries . with this stronger oracle ,
perhaps shared entanglement could help the players ?
it would also be interesting to see if , analogous to the classical case , our results have any consequences for time - space tradeoffs for data structures @xcite . |
axial killing fields play an important role in classical general relativity when defining the angular momentum of a black hole or a similar compact , gravitating body .
the simplest example is the komar angular momentum , which applies to regions of spacetime that admit a global axial killing field @xmath1 .
the formula is @xmath2 where @xmath3 is a spacelike 2-sphere , @xmath4 is the area bivector normal to @xmath3 , @xmath5 is the extrinsic curvature of a cauchy surface @xmath6 containing @xmath3 , @xmath7 is the spacelike normal to @xmath3 within @xmath6 , and @xmath8 is the intrinsic area element on @xmath3
. similar integrals such as the quasi - local formulae due to brown and york @xcite and for dynamical horizons @xcite apply more generally , when only the _
intrinsic , two - dimensional _ metric on @xmath3 is symmetric .
but the definition of each does rely on the existence of such an intrinsic symmetry . in order to justify an integral like ( [ komar ] ) as a physical angular momentum
, @xmath1 should have some standard , global characteristics of an axial killing field .
in particular , for a general riemannian geometry @xmath9 , these characteristics include that 1 .
@xmath1 vanishes at at least one fixed point @xmath10 , 2 .
every orbit of the flow @xmath11 generated by @xmath1 is either a fixed point or a circle , and 3 .
all of the circular orbits close only at integer multiples of a common period @xmath12 .
one may then scale @xmath1 by a constant as needed so that @xmath13 , the standard period for a group of rigid rotations .
the angular momenta mentioned above take unique values only when one restricts to this preferred normalization .
if @xmath14 happens to be a ( topological ) 2-sphere , then condition ( a ) is usually strengthened to 1 .
@xmath1 vanishes at exactly two fixed points @xmath15 and @xmath16 in @xmath14 .
these conditions distill the intuitive , geometric features of axial symmetries in standard geometries ( _ i.e. _ , euclidean , gaussian , or lobachevskian ) .
the purpose of this note is to show that the conditions above are redundant .
the _ global _ conditions ( b ) and ( c ) as well as condition ( a ) when @xmath14 derive from condition ( a ) and one other _ local _ condition at @xmath15 , which is that @xmath17 that is , any killing field @xmath1 with at least one fixed point @xmath15 , whose derivative satisfies the local condition ( [ fcon ] ) , is necessarily an axial killing field in the global sense described above .
furthermore , ( [ fcon ] ) _ always _ holds if @xmath18 is 2- or 3-dimensional , so in those cases any killing field with a fixed point is an axial killing field .
finally , every vector field on a 2-sphere must vanish at at least one point , so every killing field on a 2-sphere is axial .
condition ( a ) then follows by a topological argument .
one can also show that conditions ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) hold whenever @xmath14 is a 2-sphere ( * ? ? ?
* see 3 ) using the classical uniformization theorem : every metric @xmath19 on a 2-sphere is conformally related to a round metric @xmath20 .
any killing field of @xmath19 must also be a killing field of @xmath20 , and therefore must satisfy conditions ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) .
the approach we take here is more direct , and actually lays the foundation @xcite for a proof of the uniformization theorem via ricci flow @xcite . here
we extend this direct approach to arbitrary riemannian geometries and highlight its utility in physical applications .
the global flow @xmath11 generated by a killing field @xmath1 on a riemannian manifold @xmath9 is closely related to the corresponding inifnitesimal flow @xmath21 induced on the tangent space @xmath22 at any point @xmath15 where @xmath1 vanishes .
the key point is that the latter form a subgroup of the symmetry group @xmath23 for the euclidean geometry @xmath24 .
the natural flow @xmath21 in the tangent space at @xmath15 consists of the differentials @xmath25 of the diffeomorphisms @xmath11 in the global flow on @xmath18 .
the differential of a diffeomorphism @xmath26 is just the natural push - forward map @xmath27 on vectors .
if @xmath28 is fixed , then @xmath29 becomes a linear map from the tangent space @xmath30 to itself .
furthermore , if @xmath31 is a global isometry of the riemannian geometry @xmath9 that fixes @xmath32 , then @xmath29 is a linear isometry of the euclidean geometry @xmath33 .
it follows that @xmath34 is a one - parameter group of linear isometries of a eucliean vector space
. they must be rotational isometries , not translational , because they fix the origin of @xmath22 .
thus , each orbit of @xmath21 must either be a fixed point or a circle .
this is the tangent - space analogue ( b@xmath35 ) of condition ( b ) above .
next , recall that the lie derivative along @xmath1 of a vector field @xmath36 is defined in terms of the push - forward under the flow @xmath11 generated by @xmath1 : @xmath37_{t = 0}.\ ] ] when @xmath1 vanishes at @xmath38 , this determines the generator , in the ordinary sense of matrices , of the one - parameter group of linear isometries @xmath21 via @xmath39_{t = 0 } = - \lie_\varphi\ , v^b \bigr|_{p_0 } = v^a\ , \grad\!_a\ , \varphi^b \bigr|_{p_0}.\ ] ] thus , the tensor @xmath40 from ( [ fcon ] ) generates the rotations @xmath21 in @xmath22 in the sense that @xmath41 one can always find an orthonormal basis for @xmath24 that puts an anti - symmetric tensor like @xmath40 in canonical , block - diagonal form with one or more @xmath42 anti - symmetric blocks along the diagonal , possibly followed by one or more zeroes .
there can be at most one non - zero block if @xmath18 is 2- or 3-dimensional , but in higher dimensions there may be several . in principle , each block could have a different pair of values @xmath43 for its off - diagonal elements .
but the period of @xmath44 within the 2-dimensional subspace of @xmath22 corresponding to one of these blocks is @xmath45 .
these periods are equal if ( [ fcon ] ) holds because , working in the preferred basis , we have @xmath46 for each @xmath47 .
thus , ( [ fcon ] ) yields the tangent - space analogue ( c@xmath35 ) of condition ( c ) .
to summarize , the rigid , euclidean geometry of @xmath24 suffices to prove the tangent - space analogues of our claims above .
more precisely , we have shown that 1 .
the 1-parameter group of linear isometries @xmath21 fixes the origin in @xmath22 , _ whence _ 2 .
every other orbit of @xmath21 in @xmath22 is either a fixed point or a circle , and 3 .
all of those circular orbits close for a common period @xmath12 as long as ( [ fcon ] ) holds .
in addition , ( [ fcon ] ) holds identically if @xmath18 is 2- or 3-dimensional . finally , note that the natural normalization of @xmath40 sets each @xmath48 , which is equivalent to @xmath49 this one normalization condition implies that _ all _ orbits of @xmath21 close at @xmath13 .
the results in the tangent space @xmath22 extend back to the whole manifold @xmath18 essentially because the global isometries @xmath11 map geodesics of @xmath9 to other geodesics . recall the exponential map @xmath50 where @xmath51 denotes the unique geodesic of @xmath9 starting from @xmath52 , having initial tangent @xmath53 , and affinely parameterized so that @xmath54 for all @xmath55 .
each global isometry @xmath11 maps this geodesic to another one , @xmath56 , which of course has its initial tangent rotated in @xmath22 . in short , @xmath57 for all @xmath58 and all @xmath59 .
if @xmath18 is connected , compact , and without boundary , then there exists at least one geodesic between @xmath15 and any of its other points .
it therefore follows from ( [ pcomm ] ) that every orbit of @xmath11 in @xmath18 must be the image under the exponential map of at least one orbit of @xmath21 in @xmath22 . the exponential generally is not invertible , of course , so the orbit in @xmath22 generally is not unique . but the orbits of @xmath11 can not intersect one another , or themselves , non - trivially .
thus , although the exponential mapping of orbits may be many - to - one , and may map circular orbits of @xmath21 to fixed - point orbits of @xmath11 , it nonetheless preserves orbits .
it follows in particular that each orbit of @xmath11 must either be a fixed point or a closed circle . in other words ,
condition ( b ) for the orbits of @xmath11 follows from condition ( b@xmath35 ) for the orbits of @xmath21 .
it is also clear that every circular orbit of @xmath11 must close with the same period as one of the orbits of @xmath21 that is mapped to it by the exponential .
but all orbits of @xmath21 have the same period as long as ( [ fcon ] ) holds , and condition ( c ) for the orbits of @xmath11 then follows from condition ( c@xmath35 ) for the orbits of @xmath21 . let us summarize the chain of arguments here . condition ( a ) on a killing field on a riemannian geometry @xmath9 implies condition ( a@xmath35 ) for the linear isometries @xmath21 of the euclidean geometry @xmath24 .
this in turn implies conditions ( b@xmath35 ) and ( c@xmath35 ) , as long as ( [ fcon ] ) holds .
finally , these imply conditions ( b ) and ( c ) globally on @xmath18 via the exponential map .
note that the _ local _ normalization condition ( [ fnorm ] ) at @xmath15 therefore dictates the _ global _ scaling of the killing field @xmath1 such that all of its orbits have the desired period @xmath13 .
every vector field , and thus every killing field , on a 2-sphere @xmath3 vanishes at at least one point , and ( [ fcon ] ) holds identically in 2 dimensions .
every killing field on a 2-sphere therefore satisfies conditions ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) .
but the intuitive picture of an axial killing field on a 2-sphere is that it should vanish at exactly two poles , as in condition ( a ) , not just at a single point .
we now show that this is necessarily the case .
suppose that a 2-sphere geometry @xmath60 admits an axial killing field @xmath1 , which we take to be normalized according to ( [ fnorm ] ) .
each point @xmath61 in @xmath3 lies on a unique orbit of @xmath1 , which divides the sphere into two regions .
let @xmath62 denote the area of the region bounded by that orbit and containing the fixed point @xmath15 .
equivalently @xcite , we may set @xmath63 the smooth function @xmath62 takes both maximum and minimum values somewhere on the ( compact ) sphere , and each must occur at a fixed point where @xmath64 vanishes .
the minimum value is zero , and occurs only at @xmath38 .
the maximum value @xmath65 also occurs at a fixed point @xmath16 , which can not coincide with @xmath15 because any fixed point of @xmath1 must be _ one - sided_. that is , the local topology of @xmath66 is that of the 2-dimensional plane , so the fixed points of @xmath1 must be isolated from one another , and each must be surrounded by a _
single _ family of circular orbits .
( if two distinct families of circular orbits surrounded a given fixed point , then @xmath3 would have the local topology of a two - sided cone there . ) similarly , every circular orbit of @xmath1 must be _ two - sided _ in the sense that there are exactly two distinct families of circular orbits surrounding it .
( there can not be only one such family because @xmath3 has no boundary , and there can not be more than two because this would violate the assumed manifold structure of @xmath3 at each point of such an orbit . )
the manifold of orbits @xmath67 of @xmath1 therefore has the topology of a closed interval @xmath68 $ ] , with exactly two fixed points at the two ends and only circular orbits in the interior .
thus , @xmath1 must have exactly two isolated fixed points .
finally , we show that the exponential map maps a closed disk with _ finite _
radius @xmath69 in @xmath70 onto _ all _ of @xmath3 , with the entire circular boundary of that disk mapped to the conjugate fixed point @xmath71 .
this mapping is invertible in the interior of the disk , but obviously not on the boundary . to see this ,
observe that @xmath72{\dot\gamma_v(s ) } = 0 \qquad\text{and}\qquad \grad\!_{\dot\gamma_v(s)}\ , \bigl ( \varphi \cdot \dot\gamma_v(s ) \bigr ) = 0\ ] ] because @xmath51 in ( [ expdef ] ) is an affinely parameterized geodesic and @xmath1 is a killing field .
it follows that the tangent to @xmath51 has constant norm equal to @xmath73 for all @xmath55 and , since @xmath1 vanishes at @xmath15 , is everywhere orthogonal to the circular orbits of @xmath1 .
the proper distance in @xmath3 along @xmath51 from @xmath15 to @xmath74 is therefore equal to @xmath73 in @xmath75 .
( this holds generally , not just on the 2-sphere . )
it also follows from ( [ gprop ] ) that the proper geodetic distance from @xmath15 to @xmath16 is @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the proper radius of the orbit of @xmath1 through any given point , and primes denote derivatives with respect to @xmath78 .
this integral is irregular because @xmath79 vanishes at both endpoints .
but the integral converges nonetheless because the conditions to avoid conical singularities in @xmath3 at @xmath15 and @xmath16 are @xmath80 thus , although @xmath81 diverges at both endpoints in ( [ sigint ] ) , the indefinite integral of @xmath82 vanishes like @xmath79 near @xmath83 .
the difference @xmath84 likewise vanishes like @xmath79 near @xmath85 .
there can be no other irregular points with @xmath86 , so the integral ( [ sigint ] ) is well - defined and @xmath69 is finite .
we have seen that any killing field @xmath1 that vanishes at at least one point @xmath15 in a riemannian manifold @xmath9 , and satisfies ( [ fcon ] ) there , necessarily has only fixed - point and closed , circular orbits throughout @xmath18 , the latter all having the same period @xmath87 .
this offers a convenient way to characterize axial killing fields in terms of local data at a fixed point .
furthermore , scaling @xmath1 globally such that ( [ fnorm ] ) holds locally at @xmath15 guarantees that the period of every circular orbit is @xmath0 .
the condition ( [ fcon ] ) is not needed in 2 or 3 dimensions , and in fact one might imagine abandoning it altogether for manifolds of arbitrary dimension .
the main disadvantage of this would be that some orbits of @xmath21 may no longer be closed .
rather , if some of the @xmath88 from ( [ fivals ] ) were incommensurate , some orbits @xmath21 would densely fill a torus in @xmath22 . the same would then apply to the orbits of @xmath11 by the same methods used above . although this would be rather less convenient , and less physical ,
such `` quasi - axial '' symmetries could potentially be interesting in certain applications .
one additional feature of these results is that they suggest a natural and convenient way to normalize an _ approximate _ killing field on a riemannian geometry @xmath9 that has no actual symmetries @xcite .
namely , suppose that a candidate approximate killing field @xmath89 can be found up to constant scaling on @xmath18 and vanishes at at least one point , which again is guaranteed if @xmath14 .
then , one may define @xmath90}$ ] , and use ( [ fnorm ] ) to normalize @xmath89 throughout @xmath18 without having to compute the orbits of @xmath89 and ensure that they close , etc .
we explore this proposal further in a companion paper @xcite . | this note describes a local scheme to characterize and normalize an axial killing field on a general riemannian geometry .
no global assumptions are necessary , such as that the orbits of the killing field all have period @xmath0 .
rather , any killing field that vanishes at at least one point necessarily has the expected global properties . |
the extraction of the cosmic far infrared background ( cfirb ) , induced by the emission of light from distant galaxies ( partridge & peebles , 1967 ; bond et al . , 1986 and references therein ) , requires an accurate subtraction of the interstellar medium ( ism ) foreground emissions .
the two instruments dirbe and firas on board the cobe satellite provide actually the best available data to study , on the whole sky , the distribution and properties of the ism far infrared ( far - ir ) emission .
+ boulanger et al .
( 1996 ) have extensively studied the emission of the dust associated with the hi component using the spatial correlation between the far - ir dust emission as measured by dirbe and firas and the 21 cm hi emission as measured by the leiden / dwingeloo survey of the northern hemisphere .
the dust emission spectrum derived from this correlation ( for n@xmath10 4.5 10@xmath11 @xmath12 ) can be quite well represented by a single modified planck curve characterized by t=17.5 k and @xmath13 @xmath8 .
this emissivity law is very close to the one predicted by the draine @xmath14 lee ( 1984 ) dust model .
+ dust emission associated with molecular clouds has been recently studied through far - ir and submillimeter ( submm ) observations with the dirbe , firas and spm / pronaos instruments . in a previous paper ( lagache et al . , 1998 ) , we have extensively studied the spatial distribution of the temperature of the dust at thermal equilibrium using the dirbe and firas experiment .
we have found at large angular scale the presence of a cold dust component ( with a median temperature of 15 k ) , very well correlated with molecular complexes with low star forming activity such as taurus .
the lowest values of the temperature found in the cold regions ( @xmath15 k ) are comparable with that obtained for dense clouds in star forming regions by the balloon - borne experiment spm / pronaos ( ristorcelli et al . , 1996 , 1998 , serra et al . , 1997 ) .
the association between the cold dust component and molecular clouds is further demonstrated by the fact that all sky pixels with significant cold emission have an excess ir emission with respect to the high latitude ir / hi correlation .
a threshold value of the column density , n@xmath16=2.5 @xmath17 h @xmath12 , below which cold dust is not detected within the firas beam of @xmath18 has been deduced .
this knowledge on the spatial distribution of the dust associated with cold molecular clouds is important for the search of the cfirb since it allows to select parts of the sky for which cold dust is not detected .
+ on the other hand , the knowledge of the dust emission associated with the h@xmath0 component is very poor .
observations of h@xmath19 emission at high galactic latitudes and of dispersion measures in the direction of pulsars at high @xmath20 indicate that the low - density ionised gas ( the warm interstellar medium , wim ) accounts for some 30@xmath2 of the gas in the solar neighborhood ( reynolds , 1989 ) .
there is also evidence that part of the wim is spatially correlated with the hi gas ( reynolds et al . , 1995 ) .
consequently , a significant fraction of the far - ir emission associated with the wim may contribute to the spectrum of the dust associated with the hi gas .
however , the scale height of the h@xmath0 medium is much larger than the hi one , so a significant part of the h@xmath0 is completely uncorrelated with the hi .
since most of the grain destruction is expected to occur in the low - density component of the ism ( mc kee 1989 ) , the wim could also be dust poor .
depletion studies of elements that form the grains show that grains are indeed partly destroyed in the low density phases of the ism ( review by savage & sembach , 1996 ) . measuring
the dust emission from the wim could allow to understand the evolution of the dust in the low - density gas . however , this measure is difficult because one can not easily separate the contribution of the h@xmath0 gas from that of the hi .
boulanger & perault ( 1988 ) unsuccessfully searched in the 100 @xmath4 iras all - sky map for such a contribution .
the unfruitful analysis may be due to the spatial correlation between the hi and h@xmath0 emissions .
boulanger et al .
( 1996 ) have searched for such a component in the residual firas emission after the removal of the hi component .
they found that the residual emission is consistent with an emission spectrum like that of the hi gas for n@xmath21 4 10@xmath22 @xmath12 .
however , they consider this as an upper limit for the contribution of the h@xmath0 component since they could have measured emission from low contrasted molecular clouds .
arendt et al .
( 1998 ) have also investigated potential ir wim dust emission .
they conclude that they were unable to detect any ir emission associated with low density ionised gas at high galactic latitude ( the fraction of the sky used is less than 0.3@xmath2 ) .
however , very recently , howk & savage ( 1999 ) have pointed out , for the first time , the existence of al- and fe - bearing dust grains towards two high - z stars .
they have shown that the degree of grain destruction in the ionised medium , through these two stars , is not much higher than in the warm neutral medium .
if dust is present in the wim , one should detect its infrared emission .
+ the cfirb is expected to have two components : direct starlight redshifted in the far - ir and submm , and the stellar radiation absorbed by dust .
we concentrate here on the submm part of this background .
its detection is very difficult because of the strong and fluctuating galactic foregrounds .
first , upper limits have been reported : hauser et al .
( 1995 ) from dirbe data and mather et al .
( 1994 ) from firas data .
lower limits on the cfirb have been obtained from the deepest iras and k galaxy counts ( hauser et al . , 1994 and references therein ) .
the first direct detection of the cfirb has been reported by puget et al .
all the galactic foregrounds were modeled and removed using independant dataset in addition to the firas data .
its spectrum indicates the presence of sources at large redshift . the main uncertainty on the cfirb comes from galactic foregrounds .
therefore , we stress that the puget et al . ( 1996 ) results were confirmed in the cleanest parts ( n@xmath23 @xmath12 in a 7@xmath24 beam ) of the sky ( guiderdoni et al . , 1997 ) .
more recently , fixsen et al . ( 1998 ) and hauser et al . (
1998 ) have also confirmed the detection of the cfirb using firas and dirbe data . +
a general problem with all these determinations of the cfirb comes from a potential far - ir emission from the wim which has never been determined .
the goal of this paper is to push our knowledge of the galactic emission one step forward by deriving the far - ir spectrum of the wim dust emission .
then , we use our understanding of the interstellar dust emissions associated with the hi and h@xmath0 components to give a more accurate estimate of the cfirb spectrum .
the paper is organised as follow : in sect .
[ sect_data_prep ] , we present the data we have used
. the variations of the dust emission spectrum associated with different hi gas column densities are studied in sect .
[ sect_hi_var ] . in sect .
[ sect_effect_hii ] , we show that the spatial variations of the dust emission spectrum in the low hi column density regions can be due to the presence of the non - correlated h@xmath0 component . after the removal of the dust hi component , we detect a residual galactic emission which is attributed to the wim ( sect .
[ sect_hii_spec ] ) .
this is the first detection of the wim dust emission .
we show ( sect .
[ sect_cfirb_lh ] ) that the firas spectra in the very low hi column density regions exhibit a large excess over the emission of dust associated with hi and h@xmath0 components . in these regions ,
the cfibr dominates the firas emission .
we test its isotropy in sect .
[ sect_cfirb_iso ] .
all the results are summarised in sect .
[ sect_cl ] .
the firas instrument is a polarising michelson interferometer with @xmath25 resolution and two separate bands which have a fixed spectral resolution of 0.57 @xmath26 ( fixsen et al .
1994 ) . the low frequency band ( 2.2 to 20 @xmath27 was designed to study the cmb ( cosmic microwave background ) and the high frequency band ( 20 to 96 @xmath26 ) to measure the dust emission spectrum in the galaxy .
we use the so - called llss ( left low short slow ) and rhss ( right high short slow ) data from the `` pass 3 '' release which cover the low and high frequency bands respectively ( see the firas explanatory supplement ) .
+ dirbe is a photometer with ten bands covering the range from 1.25 to 240@xmath28 with 40 arcmin resolution ( silverberg et al .
we choose to use annual averaged maps because they have a higher signal to noise ratio than maps interpolated at the solar elongation of @xmath29 ( see the dirbe explanatory supplement ) . in our analysis
, we only use the 140 and 240 @xmath4 maps .
the present study is based on `` pass 2 '' data .
+ since in our analysis we combine the firas and dirbe data at 140 and 240 @xmath4 , we convolve the dirbe maps with the firas point spread function ( psf ) . the psf is not precisely known for all wavelengths , so we use the approximation suggested by mather ( private communication ) of a @xmath25 diameter circle convolved with a line of @xmath30 length perpendicular to the ecliptic plane ( mather et al .
+ before studying the far - ir emission , we have subtracted the cmb and its dipole emission from the firas data using the parameters given by mather et al .
( 1994 ) and fixsen et al .
( 1994 ) . to remove the interplanetary ( ip ) dust emission , we first consider the @xmath31 map as a spatial template for the ip dust .
then , we compute the ip dust emission at 100 @xmath4 using the zodiacal emission ratio given by boulanger et al .
( 1996 ) : @xmath32 .
we remove the ip dust emission at @xmath33 using the ip emission template at 100@xmath4 and considering a zodiacal spectrum @xmath34 ( reach et al . , 1995 ) .
+ the hi data we used are those of the leiden / dwingeloo survey , which covers the entire sky down to @xmath35 with a grid spacing of 30 in both l and b ( hartmann @xmath14 burton , 1997 ) .
the 36 half power beam width ( hpbw ) of the dwingeloo 25-m telescope provides 21-cm maps at an angular resolution which closely matches that of the dirbe maps .
these data represent an improvement over earlier large scale surveys by an order of magnitude or more in at least one of the principal parameters of sensitivity , spatial coverage , or spectral resolution .
details of the observationnal and correction procedures are given by hartmann ( 1994 ) and by hartmann @xmath14 burton ( 1997 ) .
the 21cm - hi data are convolved with the firas psf .
we derive the hi column densities with 1 k km s@xmath36=1.82 @xmath37 h @xmath12 ( optically thin emission ) . + throughout this paper , diffuse parts of the sky are selected following lagache et al .
( 1998 ) . to remove molecular clouds and hii regions , we use the dirbe map of the 240 @xmath4 excess with respect to the 60@xmath4 emission : @xmath38s = s@xmath39(240)- c@xmath40s@xmath39(60 ) with [email protected] .
this map shows as positive flux regions , the cold component of the dust emission , and as negative flux regions , regions where the dust is locally heated by nearby stars ( like the hii regions ) .
therefore , diffuse emission pixels are selected with @xmath41 , @xmath3 being evaluated from the width of the histogram of @xmath38s and @xmath42 being chosen for our different purposes .
for example , in sect .
[ sect_hii_spec ] , we take @xmath43 , which is very restrictive , to ensure that the selected pixels are mostly coming from the diffuse medium ; in sect .
[ sect_cfirb_iso ] , we take @xmath44 , since we need a fraction of the sky as large as possible .
+ we also use the 240 @xmath4/hi map excess of reach et al .
regions for which this excess is greater than 3@xmath3 are systematically discarded .
+ from lagache et al .
( 1998 ) , we have for each line of sight the spectrum of the cold component of the dust emission ( if cold dust is detected ) and the cirrus spectrum .
these spectra are used to compute the contribution of the cold dust emission in sect .
[ sect_hi_var ] ( table [ tbl-1 ] ) .
in this part , we first concentrate on the spatial variations of the dust emission spectrum with the hi gas column densities .
we deduce a column density threshold above which the contribution of the cold dust component induces a significant submm excess with respect to the @xmath45 emissivity law .
then , we investigate the spectrum of the dust associated with regions containing hi column densities below this threshold .
+ [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ , < " , ] + @xmath46 hauser et al . , 1998 @xmath47 schlegel et al . , 1998
+ = 8.cm = 7.cm + the cfirb can also be determined at 240 and 140 @xmath4 using dirbe data for the same part of the sky .
results are presented in table [ cfirb_dirbe ] together with previous determinations . in this table , uncertainties on total emissions are the dispersions measured for the selected pixels , uncertainties on the hi dust emissions are given by eq .
[ emiss_hi ] , and uncertainties on the wim dust emissions correspond to the 21@xmath2 dispersion observed in the four bins of galactic longitude ( table [ tbl - var - hii - long ] ) .
our residual emissions ( res2 in table [ cfirb_dirbe ] ) are significantly lower than the ones reported in hauser et al .
( 1998 ) and schlegel et al .
( 1997 ) since they have neglected the contribution of the dust associated with the wim .
we clearly see that it is essential to take into account the dust emission associated to the wim below 240 @xmath4 . in firas data at 240 @xmath4 , the cfirb emission ( fig .
[ firback_lh_fir ] ) is very close to our dirbe value . at 140 @xmath4 ,
the comparison between dirbe and firas data is not possible due to the considerable increase of the firas data noise ( that is why we have prefered to cut the spectrum at 200 @xmath4 in fig .
[ firback_lh_fir ] ) .
we test in this part the isotropy of the cfirb on large scales since we do not know the spatial distribution of the wim dust emission at small angular scales .
this test at large scales is important to detect potential systematic effects caused by an inacurate subtraction of ism dust emissions . as expected from our detection of the wim dust emission , we show that the cfirb is isotropic only if we consider the emission of dust associated with the h@xmath48 component .
+ = 8.cm = 7.cm + thus , we have to compute the cfirb spectrum on a fraction of the sky as large as possible .
for that , we prefer to use a galactic template based on far - ir emissions rather than hi gas , ( 1 ) to take into account variations in the dust temperature from place to place and ( 2 ) to avoid the large hole in the southern hemisphere of the leiden / dwingeloo survey .
we combine the dirbe 140 and 240 @xmath4 data with firas spectra .
first , we extract from dirbe data ( at 7@xmath24 resolution ) a galactic emission template .
then , the dirbe galactic emission is extrapolated to longer wavelengths and subtracted from each individual selected firas spectrum to derive the cfirb emission and test its isotropy . +
the two ( 140 and 240 @xmath4 ) galactic dirbe templates , @xmath49 , are computed by removing the cfirb ( table [ cfirb_dirbe ] ) from the dirbe emissions . assuming a @xmath45 emissivity law , temperature and optical depth of each pixel are estimated using the two dirbe galactic templates .
the residual firas emission is computed in the following way .
first , we discard pixels located in known molecular clouds or hii regions .
we keep pixels with @xmath50 and work at @xmath51 ( 51@xmath2 of the sky ) .
then , for each selected pixel with its associated temperature , we derive the ratio @xmath52 between the modified planck curve computed at each firas wavelength and the modified planck curve computed at 240 @xmath4 .
finally , the residual emission is computed in the following way : @xmath53 the mean residual emission spectrum is shown fig .
[ 51_cfirb ] together with the spectrum obtained on 0.54@xmath2 of the sky and its analytical determination ( eq . [ analy_cfirb ] ) .
the two spectra agree very well .
= 8.cm = 7.cm + = 8.cm = 7.cm = 8.cm = 7.cm +
the isotropy of our residual emission is addressed by looking at its variation with the galactic longitude or latitude .
the variation of our residual with the galactic longitude is derived by computing the mean residual emission ( in the [ 300 , 609 ] @xmath4 band ) in 8 different longitude bins ( each bin representing around 3.5@xmath2 of the sky ) .
the profile , shown in fig .
[ cfirb_long ] , does not show any particular galactic structure . to test the isotropy with the galactic latitude , we compute the emission profile versus the latitude ( cosecant variation ) of our residual emission ( fig .
[ cfirb_lat]a ) .
we clearly see a residual galactic component .
the slope of the fitted cosecant law is @xmath54 7 10@xmath55 w m@xmath56 sr@xmath36 which is 4 times smaller than the slope of the h@xmath57 cosecant component .
+ the pixels selected before represent only the diffuse medium but contain both the neutral and ionised emission and thus can not be very well represented by a single temperature component .
therefore , our residual firas emission could be affected by an inaccurate subtraction of the interstellar medium emissions . to test the effect of the presence of the wim dust emission on our residual emission
, we apply the same method as previously but remove from the dirbe data , before determining the temperatures , the h@xmath58 dust emission defined as @xmath59 @xmath16@xmath60 with @xmath61 ( see sect .
[ sect_effect_hii ] ) .
@xmath62 represents the non - correlated @xmath63 spectrum derived in sect .
[ sect_hii_spec ] .
the firas residual emission is computed in the following way : @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 represent the new ratio and dirbe 240 @xmath4 neutral galactic template respectively , obtained after removing the contribution of the dust emission associated with the non - correlated hii component .
the mean residual emission is in very good agreement with the previous estimates ( fig .
[ 51_cfirb ] ) .
moreover , we see no more residual cosecant variations ( fig . [
cfirb_lat]b ) : the residual component of fig .
[ cfirb_lat]a was due to the non - correlated @xmath67 emission .
+ in conclusion , we clearly show that the main uncertainty to the cfirb determination on individual pixels of the sky comes from dust emission associated with the non - correlated h@xmath48 component .
a new analysis of the correlation between gas and dust at high galactic latitude has been presented .
for the first time , we are able to present a decomposition of the far - ir emission over the hi , h@xmath48 and h@xmath1 gas with the determination of the dust emission spectrum for each of these components .
this decomposition is important to study the evolution of interstellar dust as well as to give new constraints on the cfirb ( spectrum and test of isotropy ) .
the data used in this analysis are the cobe far - ir data and the leiden - dwingeloo hi survey .
our decomposition is based on the ir / hi correlation and dirbe and firas ir colors .
the main quantitative results of this work follow : + 1 ) dust emission spectrum associated with the hi gas : + we confirm that the emission spectrum of dust in hi gas is well fitted by a modified planck curve with a @xmath45 emissivity law and a temperature of 17.5 k. however , the emissivity normalised per h atom varies by about 30@xmath2 depending on the pieces of the sky used to compute the spectrum .
we show that this variation may be explained by the emission of the dust associated with the h@xmath48 component . taking into account this contribution
, we derive a new value of the dust emissivity nomalised per hydrogen atom : @xmath68= 8.7@xmath6 0.9 @xmath69 @xmath8 with a temperature of 17.5 k , slightly lower than the previous determination of boulanger et al .
+ 2 ) dust emission spectrum associated with the h@xmath48 gas : + the existence of far - ir emission from the wim is demonstrated by the latitude dependance of the residuals of the ir / hi correlation .
this cosecant variation gives a spectrum which is clearly different from the hi dust spectrum .
this component is detected at a 10@xmath3 level in the [ 200 - 350 ] @xmath4 band .
dust associated with the wim has an emissivity @xmath70 3.8@xmath6 0.8 @xmath7 @xmath8 with a temperature of 29.1 k. with a spectral index equal to 2 , the emissivity law becomes @xmath5 1.0 @xmath6 0.2 @xmath9 @xmath8 with a temperature of 20 k. the variation in dust spectrum from the hi to the wim dust component can be explained by only changing the upper cutoff of the big grain size distribution from 0.1 @xmath4 to 30 nm .
+ 3 ) cosmic far - ir background ( cfirb ) : + firas spectra in low hi column density regions ( 0.54@xmath2 of the sky ) clearly show the presence of a component which is not associated with the hi and h@xmath0 gas and which is interpreted , following puget et al . ( 1996 ) , as the cfirb due to the integrated light of distant galaxies .
the determination of this component on 51@xmath2 of the sky confirms its isotropy at large scale on a suitable fraction of the sky . with our determination of the wim contribution to the far - ir sky emission
, we find for the cfirb values at 140 and 240 @xmath4 , @xmath71 10@xmath72 and @xmath73 10@xmath72 w m@xmath56 sr@xmath36 respectively , which are significantly lower than the hauser et al .
( 1998 ) determinations .
the contribution of the ir dust emission from the wim relative to the cfirb is negligible at longer wavelengths .
arendt , r.g .
et al . , 1998 ,
apj 508 , 74 bohlin , r.c .
, 1978 , apj 224 , 132 bond , r.j .
1986 , apj 306 , 428 boulanger , f. , & prault , m. 1988 , apj 330 , 964 boulanger , f. et al .
1996 , a&a 312 , 256 dsert , f.x . ,
boulanger , f. , puget , j.l .
1990 , a&a 237 , 215 draine , b.t .
& lee , h.m . 1984 , apj 285 , 89 fixsen , d.j .
1994 , apj 420 , 457 fixsen , d.j .
et al . 1998 , apj 508 , 123 gispert , r. , lagache , g. & puget , j.l . in preparation
guiderdoni , b. et al . , 1997 ,
nature 390 , 257 hartmann , d. 1994 , ph.d .
thesis , university of leiden hartmann , d. & burton , w.b .
, `` atlas of galactic neutral hydrogen '' , cambridge university press , 1997 hauser , m.g .
et al . , in `` examining the big bang and diffuse background radiations , iau symp .
168 '' , the hague , 1994 hauser , m.g .
et al . , in `` unveiling the cosmic infrared background '' ed .
e. dwek , aip conf .
1995 hauser , m.g .
et al . , 1998 ,
apj 508 , 25 howk , j.c .
& savage , b.d . , apj , in press jahoda , k. , lockman , f.j . ,
mccammon , d. 1990 , apj 354 , 184 jones , a.p .
et al . , 1996 , apj 469 , 740 lagache , g. , abergel , a. , boulanger , f. , puget , j.l .
1998 , a&a 333 , 709 mather , j.c .
1986 , app opt 25 , 16 mather , j.c .
1994 , apj 420 , 439 mckee , c.f .
1989 , in `` interstellar dust '' , eds l.j . allamandola and a.g.g.m .
tielens , p431 , kluwer osterbrock , d.e , `` astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei '' , university science book , 1989 partridge , r.b . & peebble , p.j.e .
1967 , apj , 148 , 377 puget , j.l .
1996 , a&a 308 , l5 reach , w.t .
1998 , apj 507 , 507 reach , w.t .
1995 , in `` unveiling the cosmic infrared background '' ed .
e. dwek , aip conf .
reynolds , r.j .
, 1984 , 282 , 191 reynolds , r.j . 1989 , apj 339 , l29 reynolds , r.j .
1991 , apj 372 , l17 reynolds , r.j .
1992 , apj 392 , l35 reynolds , r.j .
et al . , 1995 ,
apj 448 , 715 reynolds , r.j .
, 1998 , pasa 15 , 14 ristorcelli , i. , et al .
1998 , to be submitted ristorcelli , i. et al .
1996 , in `` diffuse infrared radiation and the irts '' , ed .
h. okuda , t. matsumoto , t. roelling tufte , s.l . ,
et al . , 1996 , baas , 28 , 890 savage , b.d & sembach , k.r .
1996 , araa , 34 , 279 schlegel , d.j .
, finkbeiner , d.p . , davis , m. 1998 , apj 500 , 525 serra , g. et al .
1997 , in `` the far infrared and submillimetre universe '' , esa sp-401 silverberg , r.f .
1993 , in spie conference proc .
2019 on infrared spaceborne remote sensing , san diego | we present a new analysis of the far - ir emission at high galactic latitude based on cobe and hi data .
a decomposition of the far - ir emission over the hi , h@xmath0 and h@xmath1 galactic gas components and the cosmic far infrared background ( cfirb ) is described .
+ for the first time the far - ir emission of dust associated with the warm ionised medium ( wim ) is evidenced .
this component determined on about 25@xmath2 of the sky is detected at a 10@xmath3 level in the [ 200 , 350 ] @xmath4 band .
the best representation of the wim dust spectrum is obtained for a temperature of 29.1 k and an emissivity law @xmath5 3.8 @xmath6 0.8 @xmath7 @xmath8 . with a spectral index equal to 2
, the emissivity law becomes @xmath5 1.0 @xmath6 0.2 @xmath9 @xmath8 , with a temperature of 20 k , which is significantly higher than the temperature of dust associated with hi gas .
the variation in the dust spectrum from the hi to the wim component can be explained by only changing the upper cutoff of the big grain size distribution from 0.1 @xmath4 to 30 nm .
+ the detection of ir emission of dust in the wim significantly decreases the intensity of the cfirb , especially around 200 @xmath4 which corresponds to the peak of energy . + |
after the first successful space flight use of the x - ray charge coupled device ( ccd ) of the sis ( @xcite ) on board asca , the ccd has been playing a major role in imaging spectroscopy in the field of x - ray astronomy . however , the charge transfer inefficiency ( cti ) of x - ray ccds increases in orbit due to the radiation damage ; the cti is defined as the fraction of electrons that are not successfully moved from one ccd pixel to the next during the readout . since the amount of charge loss depends on the number of the transfers , the energy scale of x - ray ccds depends on the location of an x - ray event .
furthermore , there is a fluctuation in the amount of the lost charge .
therefore , without any correction , the energy resolution of x - ray ccds in orbit gradually degrades . in the case of the x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis )
@xcite on board the suzaku satellite @xcite launched on july 10 , 2005 , the energy resolution in full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) at 5.9 kev was @xmath0140 ev in august 2005 , but had degraded to @xmath0230 ev in december 2006 .
the increase of the cti is due to an increase in the number of charge traps at defects in the lattice structure of silicon made by the radiation .
since the trap distribution is not uniform , it would be best if we could measure the cti of each pixel as chandra acis @xcite . in the case of the xis , however , it is impossible to measure the cti values of all the pixels , mainly because the onboard calibration sources do not cover the entire field of view of the xis
. therefore , we use the cti of each column to correct the positional dependence of the energy scale .
the xis is equipped with a charge injection structure @xcite which can inject an arbitrary amount of charge in arbitrary positions . using this capability
, we can precisely measure the cti of each column @xcite . by applying the column - to - column cti correction ,
the positional dependence of the cti corrected energy scale is greatly reduced , and the over - all energy resolution is also improved @xcite . in @xcite ,
the results of the cti correction was mainly based on the ground - based charge injection experiments .
in - orbit measurements were limited within one year after the launch . this paper reports more comprehensive and extended in - orbit experiments up to two years after the launch .
the results are based on the data with the normal full window mode @xcite without a spaced - row charge injection @xcite , and have been implemented to the suzaku calibration database and applied to all the data obtained with the same mode .
all the errors are at the 1@xmath1 confidence level throughout this paper unless mentioned .
the xis is the set of four x - ray ccd camera systems .
three sensors ( xis 0 , 2 , and 3 ) contain front - illuminated ( fi ) ccds and the other ( xis 1 ) contains back illuminated ( bi ) ccd .
the xis 2 sensor became unusable on november 9 , 2006 .
therefore there are no data for xis 2 after that day .
the detailed structure of the ccd has been provided in @xcite . in this paper
, we define a `` row '' and a `` column '' as a ccd line along the @xmath2 and @xmath3 axes , respectively ( see figure 3 in @xcite ) . in the imaging area , the _ actx _ value runs 0 to 1023 from the segment a to d , while the _ acty _ value runs from 0 to 1023 from the readout node to the charge injection structure .
the charge injection structure lies adjacent to the top row ( _ acty _
= 1023 ) in the imaging area .
we can inject charges from @xmath0 50 e@xmath4 to @xmath0 4000 e@xmath4 per pixel ; the equivalent x - ray energy ranges from @xmath00.2 kev to @xmath015 kev .
a charge packet generated by an incident x - ray is transferred to the readout node , then is converted to a pulse - height value .
we define @xmath5 to be the original pulse height generated by the x - ray . in the real case ,
the readout pulse height of the packet ( @xmath6 ) is smaller than @xmath5 , because some amount of charges is lost during the transfer . to measure the charge loss
, we have to know both @xmath5 and @xmath7 .
however , we can usually measure only @xmath6 , and hence it is difficult to obtain @xmath5 .
@xcite and @xcite reported a technique to solve this problem by the charge injection method , and @xcite applied this technique to the xis .
we briefly repeat by referring figure 3 in @xcite .
first , we inject a `` test '' charge packet into the top ccd row ( _ acty _
then , after the gap of a few rows , five continuous packets are injected with the same amount of charge of the test packet .
the former four packets are called `` sacrificial '' charge packets , while the last one is called a `` reference '' charge packet .
the test packet loses its charge by the charge traps . on the other hand
, the reference packet does not suffer from the charge loss , because the traps are already filled by the preceding sacrificial packets .
thus we can measure the charge loss by comparing the pulse - height values of the reference charge ( @xmath8 ) and the test charge ( @xmath9 ) .
the relation between sacrificial charge packets and reference charge packets is described in gendreau ( 1995 ) .
we can obtain a checker flag pattern by these injected packets in the x - ray image ( right panel of figure 3 in @xcite ) because of the onboard event - detection algorithm @xcite . therefore in this paper , we call this technique a `` checker flag charge injection ( cfci ) . ''
a charge packet in the xis loses its charge during ( a ) the fast transfer ( 24 @xmath10s pixel@xmath11 ) along the _ acty _ axis in the imaging area , ( b ) the fast transfer along the _ acty _ axis in the frame - store region , ( c ) the slow transfer ( 6.7 ms pixel@xmath11 ) along the _ acty _ axis in the frame - store region , ( d ) the fast transfer to the readout node along the _ actx _ axis .
the cti depends on many parameters such as the transfer speed and the number density of the charge traps @xcite .
the frame - store region is covered by the shield and is not exposed to the radiation directly .
furthermore , the pixel size of the frame - store region ( 21 @[email protected] @xmath10 m ) is different from that of the imaging area ( 24 @xmath10m@xmath1224 @xmath10 m ) .
thus the number of traps per pixel may be different between the imaging area and the frame - store region .
then we assumed that the four transfers have different cti values .
we examined the transfer ( d ) by using the calibration source data taken in april 2007 , and found no significant decrease of the pulse height along the _ actx _ axis .
we , therefore , ignore the charge loss in the transfer ( d ) .
we define that @xmath13 is the transfer number in the imaging area ( @xmath13=@xmath3 + 1 ; here , @xmath3 is a coordinate value where an incident x - ray generates a charge packet ) .
then the relation between @xmath6 and @xmath5 is expressed as , @xmath14 where @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the cti values in the transfers ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) , respectively .
here we used the fact that the cti values are much smaller than 1 .
thus we can separate the charge loss into @xmath13-dependent component ( the second term in the right - hand side of equation [ eq : cti_def_0 ] ) and constant component ( the third term ) .
we therefore substitute the cti with cti1 ( the former component ) and cti2 ( the latter component ) , which have the cti values of @xmath18 and @xmath19 , respectively
. then equation [ eq : cti_def_0 ] can be written as @xmath20 since the cti values depend on the amount of transfer charge which is proportional to the pulse height , we assume the cti is described by a power function of the pulse height ( prigozhin et al .
2004 ) and expressed as @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are scale factors for the cti1 and cti2 , and the index @xmath24 is common to the cti1 and cti2 .
we have conducted the cfci experiments six times in orbit . effective exposure time for
each experiment ranges from a few to @xmath020 ks .
the equivalent x - ray energy of the injected charge packets ranges from @xmath00.3 kev to @xmath08 kev .
since june 2006 , we injected various amounts of charge in one experiment .
the log is summarized in table 1 . in the cfci experiments ,
the test charge is injected to the row at @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) , and hence @xmath27 .
the reference charge should be equal to the original charge which does not suffer from the charge loss , and hence @xmath28 .
then equation [ eq : cti_def ] can be written as @xmath29 we determined @xmath30 by measuring the ratio @xmath31 for each column . from equation 3 , we can obtain the relation in the cfci experiments as , @xmath32 the index @xmath24 and @xmath33 were derived by fitting equation [ eq : cfci_cti2 ] to the values of @xmath30 obtained with the cfci experiments with multiple amount of charge injections ( multiple @xmath8s ; log number 36 in table 1 ) .
the mean and standard deviation of the best - fit @xmath24 of equation [ eq : cfci_cti2 ] averaged over each sensor are shown in figure [ fig : ctipow ] .
the mean value of @xmath24 shows no time variation , and the time averaged values of xis 0 , 1 , and 3 are 0.31 , 0.22 , 0.15 for xis 0 , 1 , and 3 , respectively . as for xis 2
, there was only one data point , and we obtained @xmath34 .
if a charge packet has a volume proportional to the number of electrons and is spherically symmetric , the probability that one electron encounters a charge trap is proportional to the cross section of the charge packet . in this case
, we can expect @xmath35 . from equation [ eq : cfci_cti ] ,
the cti value is proportional to @xmath36 , and hence @xmath37 .
thus the simple model is roughly consistent with the observed @xmath24 values .
using the results of all the cfci experiments ( log number 16 in table 1 ) and above determined @xmath24 values , we then re - estimated @xmath22 and @xmath23 separately . in this process
, we assumed @xmath38 is equal to @xmath39 which was estimated by the 6.4 kev line from the sgr c region to be 0.67 and 1.5 for the fi and bi ccd , respectively ( @xcite ) . from this @xmath22
, we can obtain the final value of @xmath40 .
figure [ fig : baratuki ] shows an example of the distribution of @xmath40 in july 2006 .
we can see significant column - to - column dispersion .
figure [ fig : ctihenka ] shows the change of @xmath40 from july 2006 to september 2007 .
we can see that the cti values of all columns increased , but the increasing rate was different from column to column .
the results of figures 2 and 3 indicate that the cti correction at the column level is strongly required . in figure
[ fig : ctijikanhatten ] , we show the column - averaged @xmath40 value as a function of time .
since the cfci experiments were only sparsely conducted ( see table 1 ) , we interpolate the @xmath40 and @xmath41 values for the observations of inter - cfci epochs . as for the determination of the cti values before the first cfci experiment ,
see appendix .
a cti correction , which is the conversion of @xmath42 to @xmath5 , is made with equation [ eq : cti_def ] , where @xmath40 and @xmath41 are calculated from equation 3 by using the @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 values determined in section 3 .
we used the emission lines from the onboard calibration sources , the perseus cluster of galaxies , and the supernova remnant 1e0102.2@xmath437219 .
we retrieved the data from the data archives and transmission system of isas / jaxa .
all data were acquired with the normal full window mode and the 3@xmath123 or 5@xmath125 editing mode @xcite .
we used the data with the asca grades of 0 , 2 , 3 , 4 , and 6 . as is mentioned in @xcite , a small fraction of the charge in a pixel
is left behind ( trailed ) to the next pixel in the same column during the transfer .
all data used in this paper were corrected for the trail phenomenon .
the observations are summarized in table [ tab : objlog ] .
the calibration source @xmath44fe produces the mn k@xmath45 line .
the theoretical line center energy is 5895 ev @xcite .
we used the data from august 2005 to april 2007 .
this is one of the x - ray brightest clusters of galaxies in the sky .
the x - ray spectrum is that of a thin thermal plasma with the strong k@xmath45 line of fe .
the plasma temperature changes smoothly from @xmath46 4 kev to @xmath0 7 kev toward the outer region @xcite , and the center energy of the fe k@xmath45 triplet is almost constant ( @xmath06.56 kev at @xmath47 ) within this temperature range . its radius of @xmath48 can cover the entire field of view of the xis ( @xmath49 ) .
thus this source is suitable for measuring the positional dependence of the energy scale .
this is one of the brightest supernova remnants in the small magellanic cloud . with the spatial resolution of suzaku
, it can be regarded as a point source .
there are many bright emission lines originated from thermal plasma in the x - ray spectrum below 2 kev .
these lines are resolved with the xmm - newton rgs , and the accurate energies of the line centroids are known @xcite .
this object has been used by many instruments for the calibration in the low - energy band , and an empirical model to describe the spectrum has been established .
we used this source as the energy - scale calibrator in the low - energy band .
for the data of the perseus cluster of galaxies , we divided the imaging area into four regions along the _ acty _ axis , and extracted a spectrum from each region .
then we fitted the spectra in the 57.3 kev band with a power - law model and a gaussian function , and obtained the center pulse height of the fe k@xmath45 line .
figure [ fig : perseus ] shows the center pulse height as a function of @xmath13 . triangles and circles indicate the data before and after the cti correction , respectively
. we can see no significant @xmath13 dependence after the cti correction , and this supports the validity of our correction .
the goal is to determine a relation of @xmath5 and x - ray energy @xmath51 . from the ground experiments
, we found that the @xmath5-@xmath51 relation can be expressed as a broken - linear function linked at the si - k edge energy of 1839 ev @xcite .
we then determined the @xmath5-@xmath51 relation of each segment by using the lines of the calibration sources ( mn k@xmath45 line at 5895 ev ) and 1e@xmath50 ( k@xmath45 lines of o , ne and ne around 6501020 ev ) .
we show the results after the cti correction and the @xmath5-@xmath51 conversion .
figure [ fig : calpeak ] shows measured center energies of the mn k@xmath45 line as a function of time .
each mark in the plot has an effective exposure of more than 60 ks .
the mean values of the center energy are 5896.2 , 5895.4 , 5895.0 , and 5895.4 ev for xis 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 , respectively .
the deviation around the theoretical center energy ( 5895 ev ) is 7.8 , 4.4 , 6.6 , and 7.8 ev for xis 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 , respectively .
therefore , the time - averaged uncertainty of the absolute energy is @xmath52 0.1 % for the mn k@xmath45 line of the calibration sources .
we also studied the time evolution of the deviation around the theoretical center energy , and the results are shown in figure [ fig : peakbunsanhenka ] .
we can see that the deviation gradually increases with time .
figure [ fig : sciofflowpeak ] shows the center energy of the o k@xmath45 line from the 1e@xmath50 data .
the mean values of the center energy are 652.6 , 653.8 , 652.7 , and 652.8 ev for xis 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 , respectively .
the deviation around the center energy of the empirical model ( 653 ev ) is 1.4 , 1.4 , 2.3 , and 1.1 ev for xis 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 .
therefore , the uncertainty of the absolute energy is @xmath53 0.2% for the o k@xmath45 line of 1e@xmath50 .
we examined the energy resolution in fwhm ( @xmath54 ) @xcite for each sensor ; @xmath54 is common to all segments .
we expressed @xmath54 as @xmath55 where @xmath56 and @xmath57 are time dependent parameters and @xmath58 is the energy resolution determined by the ground experiments and obtained using equation 1 in @xcite .
we determined @xmath56 and @xmath57 by using the time history of the calibration sources and 1e@xmath50 .
the @xmath54 values obtained in this way is incorporated into the redistribution matrix file ( rmf ) .
figure [ fig : segcolumn ] shows the energy resolution of the mn k@xmath45 line after the column - to - column cti correction .
we also plot the results of the cti correction , where we used the cti values averaged over a segment ( the column - averaged cti correction ) .
we can see that the energy resolution is greatly improved by the column - to - column cti correction .
for example , the energy resolution in december 2006 was greatly improved from @xmath0230 ev to @xmath0 190 ev . on the other hand , with the column - averaged cti correction ,
the energy resolution is @xmath0230 ev and is not significantly improved . in figure
[ fig : calsig ] , we compared the energy resolution of the mn k@xmath45 line with our rmf model .
the deviation of the data points around our model is 5.6 , 4.9 , 3.4 , and 6.3 ev for xis 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 , respectively .
we have conducted the cfci experiments six times in orbit .
the cti correction has been done with the cfci results .
we calibrated the energy scale of the xis precisely using the onboard calibration sources and 1e@xmath50 .
our calibration results have been applied to all the data obtained with the normal full window mode without the spaced - row charge injection .
the results of the cfci experiments and the current calibration status are summarized as follows : 1 .
we determined the cti1 and cti2 values of each column precisely based on the data of the cfci experiments .
we also found that the pulse height dependence of the cti does not change with time .
2 . after the column - to - column cti correction , we determined the @xmath5-@xmath51 relation .
we also modeled the time - dependent energy resolution .
the uncertainty of the energy scale is @xmath59 0.2 % for the o k@xmath45 line ( @xmath0 0.65 kev ) of 1e@xmath50 , and @xmath59 0.1 % for the mn k@xmath45 line ( @xmath605.9 kev ) of the calibration sources .
4 . with the column - to - column cti correction , the energy resolution at 5.9 kev in december 2006
was greatly improved from @xmath0230 ev to @xmath0 190 ev .
the authors thank all the xis members for their support and useful information .
this work was supported by the grant - in - aid for the global coe program `` the next generation of physics , spun from universality and emergence '' from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan .
m.o . , h.u . , and h.n .
are financially supported by the japan society for the promotion of science .
is also supported by the mext , grant - in - aid for young scientists ( b ) , 18740105 , 2008 , and by the sumitomo foundation , grant for basic science research projects , 071251 , 2007 .
h.t . and k.h .
were supported by the mext , grant - in - aid 16002004 .
first , we determined the cti values of the segments a and d in august 2005 .
we combined the data of the calibration sources from august 11 to 31 , 2005 , and obtained the @xmath6 of the mn k@xmath45 line .
we also estimated @xmath5 at 5895 ev from the @xmath5-@xmath51 relation determined by the ground experiments , and obtained the ratio @xmath61 . from equation [ eq : cti_def ] ,
the ratio can be expressed approximately as @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the mean transfer number of the calibration events ( typically @xmath0900 ) .
we determined @xmath40 and @xmath41 at 5895 ev from @xmath61 with the @xmath39 ratio fixed to the values shown in section 3 .
the @xmath40 and @xmath41 for other pulse - height values were calculated from equation [ eq : cti_ph ] , where we used the column - averaged and time - averaged @xmath24 values determined in section 3
. then for segments b and c , we took the average cti values of the segments a and d. we regard the cti values obtained in this procedure as those on august 11 , 2005 ( the day of the xis first light ) .
note that these values are determined for each segment , not for each column . | the x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis ) on board the suzaku satellite is an x - ray ccd camera system that has superior performance such as a low background , high quantum efficiency , and good energy resolution in the 0.212 kev band . because of the radiation damage in orbit , however , the charge transfer inefficiency ( cti ) has increased , and hence the energy scale and resolution of the xis has been degraded since the launch of july 2005 . the ccd has a charge injection structure , and the cti of each column and the pulse - height dependence of the cti are precisely measured by a checker flag charge injection ( cfci ) technique .
our precise cti correction improved the energy resolution from 230 ev to 190 ev at 5.9 kev in december 2006 .
this paper reports the cti measurements with the cfci experiments in orbit . using the cfci results ,
we have implemented the time - dependent energy scale and resolution to the suzaku calibration database . |
oscillators providing stable sub-100 fs pulses in the near - infrared region around 1.5 @xmath0 m are of interest for a number of applications including infrared continuum generation @xcite and high - sensitivity gas spectroscopy @xcite .
to date , the typical realization of such sources is based on a femtosecond er : fiber oscillator with an external pulse amplification .
a promising alternative to such combination is a solid - state cr@xmath1:yag mode - locked oscillator @xcite .
such an oscillator allows a direct diode pumping and possesses the gain band providing the few - optical cycle pulses .
however , attempts to increase the pulse energy in a cr : yag oscillator is limited by its relatively small gain coefficient .
because of the low gain , the oscillator has to operate with low output couplers and , thereby , the intra - resonator pulse energy has to be high . as a result , the instabilities appear @xcite . to suppress the instabilities in the negative dispersion regime ( ndr ) a fair amount of the group - delay - dispersion ( gdd )
is required .
the resulting pulse is a relatively long soliton with reduced peak power .
such a pulse is nearly transform - limited and is not compressible .
a remedy is to use the positive dispersion regime ( pdr ) , when the pulse is stabilized due to substantial stretching ( up to few picoseconds ) caused by a large chirp @xcite .
such a pulse is dispersion - compressible down to few tens of femtoseconds . for both ndr and pdr , the oscillator will eventually become unstable at high power .
the main scenarios of the pulse destabilization have been identified with the multipulsing in the ndr @xcite and the cw - amplification in the pdr @xcite .
it has been found , that the higher - order dispersions ( i.e. , the frequency dependent gdd ) and losses significantly modify the stability conditions @xcite .
hence , the study of the stability conditions affected by both linear and nonlinear processes inherent in a mode - locked oscillator remains an important task .
here , we present a study of the destabilization mechanisms of a cr : yag mode - locked oscillator , operating in both ndr and pdr .
we put a special emphasis on the influence of the spectral dependence of gdd and losses on the oscillator stability .
the cr : yag oscillator has been built on the basis of the scheme published in refs .
the mode - locking and the dispersion control were provided by sesam and chirped - mirrors ( cms ) , respectively .
the gdd of intra - resonator elements as well as the net - gdd are shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] . as a result of the gdd variation of the 51-layer cms and the uncertainty of the sesam dispersion ,
the real net - gdd has some uncertainty , too ( gray region in fig .
[ fig1 ] , _ a _ ) .
a ) gdd of three sets of chirped mirrors cm ( as designed ) , the yag crystal , and the sesam .
b ) the net dispersion of the resonator of cr@xmath1:yag oscillator .
black line : as designed , grey area - uncertainty region due to the chirped mirrors.,height=302 ] selection of the different cm combinations allows over- and under - compensation of the dispersion . selecting a 2cm@xmath2 + 2cm@xmath2 allows stabilizing the oscillator at the 144.5 mhz pulse repetition rate and 150 mw average output power . the corresponding spectra shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] have truncated profiles , that is typical for an oscillator operating in the pdr @xcite .
a ) spectra of the cr : yag oscillator operating in the pdr at different values of intracavity pulse energy .
b ) spectra of the cr : yag oscillator with different output couplers.,height=302 ] to study the stability limits of pdr , the numerical simulations based on the nonlinear cubic - quintic complex ginzburg - landau model @xcite have been realized .
the evolution of the slowly varying field envelope @xmath3 can be described in the following way : @xmath4p - \kappa \varsigma p^2 \right\}a . \hfill\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath5 is the propagation distance normalized to the cavity length @xmath6 ( i.e. , the cavity round - trip number ) , @xmath7 is the local time
. the reference time frame moves with the pulse group - velocity defined at the reference frequency @xmath8 corresponding to the gain maximum at @xmath91.5 @xmath0 m .
the term @xmath10 describes the action of the gain spectral profile in parabolic approximation .
parameter @xmath110.028 is the saturated gain coefficient at @xmath8 , and it is close to the net - loss value at this frequency .
parameter @xmath129.5 fs is the inverse gain bandwidth .
the term @xmath13 describes the net - gdd action in the fourier domain .
the term @xmath14 describes the action of the net loss spectral profile in the fourier domain .
frequency @xmath15 corresponds to the transmission minimum of the output coupler at @xmath161.53 @xmath0 m .
mw@xmath18 describes the self - phase modulation inside the active medium , @xmath190.05@xmath20 is the self - amplitude modulation parameter , @xmath210.6@xmath20 is the parameter defining saturation of the self - amplitude modulation with power @xcite .
parameter @xmath22 is the difference between the saturated gain @xmath23 and the net loss at the reference frequency @xmath8 .
it was assumed , that this parameter depends on the full pulse energy:@xmath24 , where @xmath25 corresponds to the full energy stored inside an oscillator in the cw regime @xcite .
parameter @xmath26 equals to -0.03 .
it was found , that the gdd decrease in the pdr results in the cw - amplification ( see the black curve in fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
the cw - amplification appears in the vicinity of the spectral net - loss minimum , where the saturated net - gain becomes positive .
the latter occurs because gain saturation decreases with gdd approaching to zero .
simultaneously , the spectrum gets broader , which enhances the spectral losses and , thereby reduces the pulse energy .
( a ) - simulated spectra , ( b ) - intensity profiles in the positive dispersion regime .
gdd corresponds to @xmath27 200 fs@xmath28 ( gray curves ) and 150 fs@xmath28 ( black curves).,height=302 ] when the gdd is spectrally dependent ( i.e. , there are the higher - order dispersions ) , the scenario of destabilization with an approaching of gdd to zero changes ( fig .
[ fig4 ] , _ a _ ) . in this case , the chaotic oscillations of the peak power appear ( _ chaotic mode - locking _
the spectrum edges in such a regime become smoothed and the spectrum shifts to the local gdd - minimum .
it was found @xcite , that the pdr stability is improved in the vicinity of the local minimum of the gdd ( i.e. , when the fourth - order dispersion is positive ) .
[ fig4 ] , _ b _ shows the spectrum ( gray curve ) corresponding to the lower on gdd stability border of pdr .
the spectrum is asymmetrical , `` m - shape '' , and the spectrum maximum is situated in the vicinity of the gdd local minimum .
simulated spectra ( solid curves ) , with different net - gdd ( dashed curves ) . @xmath291.54
@xmath0 m , other parameters correspond to fig .
[ fig3 ] , the case without spectrally - dependent losses.,height=302 ]
in the ndr and in the absence of higher - order dispersions , the pulse can be stabilized only by a signifivant amount of the negative gdd ( @xmath30 - 9900 fs@xmath28 in our case ) .
however , the contribution of higher - order dispersions can stabilize the pulse in the immediate vicinity of zero gdd ( black curves in fig .
[ fig5 ] ) .
the pulse is stable if even a part of spectrum is situated within the positive gdd range ( left picture in fig .
[ fig5 ] ) .
gdd spectral profiles ( dashed ) and corresponding simulated pulse spectra without ( black ) and with ( gray ) spectral dependence of the losses .
the losses are assumed to have a local minimum at 1.53 @xmath0 m about -0.025 fs@xmath18 , height=226 ] however , the ndr stability in the vicinity of zero gdd is very sensitive to the spectral dependence of the losses .
presence of such dependence leads to the multipulsing ( harmonic mode - locking , gray curves in fig .
[ fig5 ] ) . as it was found @xcite
, the source of multipulsing is the insufficiently saturated net - gain , which appears in the vicinity of zero gdd due to decrease of the pulse energy caused by the spectral losses . in analogy with the pdr
, the spectral dependence of gdd can initiate the chaotic mode - locking , when the negative gdd approaches zero ( gray curve in fig .
[ fig4 ] ) .
the spectrum shifts from the region , where the local minimum of gdd is located .
this behaviour is reverse in the comparison with that in the pdr .
thus , the stability regions of pdr and ndr are disjointed by a region of chaotic mode - locking in the vicinity of zero gdd . just as the `` m - shaped '' spectra appear in the pdr , when the fourth - order dispersion leads to the gdd growth on the spectrum edges , the humps of the spectrum envelope exist in the ndr ( fig .
[ fig6 ] ) .
in contrast to the pdr , the local spectral maxima appear in the vicinity of local maxima of gdd .
gdd spectral profile ( dashed ) and corresponding simulated pulse spectrum in the negative dispersion regime with modulated dispersion and no spectral dependence of the losses.,height=302 ]
we have studied stability conditions of a cr : yag oscillator in both , positive and negative dispersion regimes . in the ndr , the oscillator exhibits strong tendency to harmonic mode - locking ( i.e. , multipulsing ) , which can be suppressed only by a significant amount of the negative gdd .
the gdd value providing the multipulsing suppression depends on the gdd shape , so that the soliton - like regime can exist even if the part of the spectrum lies within the positive dispersion range .
the spectrum maximum shifts in the region , where the local maximum of gdd is located .
the presence of the spectrally - dependent losses enhances the multipulsing in the vicinity of zero gdd .
when the gdd is frequency - dependent , the positive- and negative - dispersion single - pulse regimes are disjointed by the gdd ranges with chaotic and harmonic mode locking . in the pdr , approaching of the gdd to zero results in a cw - amplification or a chaotic mode - locking .
the last regime appears if the gdd is frequency - dependent .
the stabilizing factor of such frequency dependence is the presence of a local minimum ( for the pdr ) or maximum ( for the ndr ) of gdd in the vicinity of the pulse spectrum .
e. sorokin , v. l. kalashnikov , s. naumov , j. teipel , f. warken , h. giessen and i. t. sorokina,``intra- and extra - cavity spectral broadening and continuum generation at 1.5 @xmath0 m using compact low - energy femtosecond cr : yag laser , '' _ appl .
* b 77 * , pp . 197204 , 2003 . v. l. kalashnikov , e. sorokin , s. naumov , i. t. sorokina , v. v. ravi kanth kumar and k. george , `` low - threshold supercontinuum generation from an extruded sf6 pcf using a compact cr@xmath1:yag laser , '' _ appl .
phys . _ * b 79 * , pp . 591596 , 2004 . j. mandon , g. guelachvili , n. picqu , f. druon and p. georges , `` femtosecond laser fourier transform absorption spectroscopy , '' _ opt .
lett . _ * 32 * , pp . 16771679 , 2007 . s. naumov , e. sorokin , v. l. kalashnikov , g. tempea , i. t. sorokina , `` self - starting five optical pulse generation in cr@xmath1:yag laser , '' _ appl .
b _ * 76 * , pp .
111 , 2003 . c. g. leburn , a. a. lagatsky ,
c. t. a. brown , and w. sibbett , `` femtosecond cr@xmath1:yag laser with 4 ghz pulse repetition rate , '' _ electron .
_ * 40 * , pp . 805807 , 2004 . v.
l. kalashnikov , e. sorokin , and i. t. sorokina , `` multipulse operation and limits of the kerr - lens mode - locking stability , '' _ ieee j. quant .
_ * 39 * , pp . 323336 , 2003 . s. naumov , a. fernandez , r. graf , p. dombi , f. krausz , and a. apolonski , `` approaching the microjoule frontier with femtosecond laser oscillators , '' _ new journal of physics _ * 7 * , p. 216
v. l. kalashnikov , e. podivilov , a. chernykh , a. apolonski , `` chirped - pulse oscillators : theory and experiment , '' _ appl .
_ b * 83 * , pp .
503510 , 2006 . v. l. kalashnikov , a. fernndez , a. apolonski , `` high - order dispersion in chirped - pulse oscillators , '' _ optics express _ , pp . 42064216 , 2008 . v. l. kalashnikov , e. sorokin , s. naumov , and i. t. sorokina , `` spectral properties of the kerr - lens mode - locked cr@xmath1:yag laser , '' _ j. opt
_ * 20 * , pp . 20842092 , 2003 . s. naumov , e. sorokin , i. t. sorokina , _ osa trends in optics and photonics vol .
83 , advanced solid - state photonics _ * 83 * , p. 163
n. n. akhmediev , a. ankiewicz , _ solitons : nonlinear pulses and beams _ , chapman & hall , london , 1997 . | we analyze the influence of spectrally modulated dispersion and loss on the stability of mode - locked oscillators . in the negative dispersion regime
, a soliton oscillator can be stabilized in a close proximity to zero - dispersion wavelength , when spectral modulation of dispersion and loss are strong and weak , respectively . if the dispersion is close to zero but positive , we observe _ chaotic _ mode - locking or a stable coexistence of the pulse with the cw signal .
the results are confirmed by experiments with a cr : yag oscillator . |
over the last decade several diagnostic diagrams have been proposed to quantify the contribution of star formation and agn activity to the infrared luminosity of infrared galaxies based on mid - infrared ( to far - infrared ) continuum slope , pah line - to - continuum ratio , pah to far - infrared luminosity ratio and the ratio of a high to a low ionization forbidden line such as [ nev]/[neii ] @xcite . however
, none of these diagrams takes into account the effects of strong obscuration of the nuclear power source . with the advent of the infrared spectrograph ( _ irs _ ; * ? ? ?
* ) on board the _ spitzer _ space telescope @xcite astronomers have been handed a powerful tool to study the 537@xmath0 m range for a wide range of galaxy types at an unprecedented sensitivity .
this enables for the first time a systematic study of a large number of galaxies over the wavelength range in which amorphous silicate grains have strong opacity peaks due to the si
o stretching and the o si o bending modes centered at 9.7 and 18@xmath0 m , respectively . here
we will introduce the strength of the 9.7@xmath0 m silicate feature as a tool to distinguish between different dust geometries in the central regions of ( ultra-)(luminous ) infrared galaxies as part of a new diagnostic diagram and mid - infrared galaxy classification scheme .
the results presented in this paper are based on both _
spitzer irs _ and _ iso - sws _ observations .
the core sample is formed by the irs gto ulirg sample ( pid 105 ; j.r.houck pi ) , which comprises @xmath1100 ulirgs in the redshift range 0.02 @xmath2 0.93 .
this sample is compared to samples of agn and starburst templates from the irs gto programs 14 @xcite and 96 and to selected agns from the gto programs 82 and 86 @xcite .
additional irgs , lirgs and ulirgs were taken from program 159 ( ngc1377 ; * ? ? ?
* ) and from the spitzer ddt program 1096 .
iso - sws _ spectra of starburst nuclei were taken from @xcite .
the _ spitzer _ observations were made with the short - low ( sl ) and long - low ( ll ) modules of the _ irs_. the spectra were extracted from droop level images provided by the spitzer science center ( 34 using pipeline version s11.0.2 , 131 using pipeline version s14.0 ) and background - subtracted by differencing the first and second order apertures . the spectra were calibrated using the _ irs _ standard stars hd173511 ( 5.219.5@xmath0 m ) and @xmath3dra ( 19.538.5@xmath0 m ) . after flux calibration the orders were stitched to ll order 1 , requiring order - to - order scaling adjustments of typically less than 10% .
for all the spectra in our sample we have measured the equivalent width of the 6.2@xmath0 m pah emission feature as well as the strength of the 9.7@xmath0 m silicate feature and plotted the two quantities in a diagnostic diagram ( fig.[fig1 ] ) .
the flux in the 6.2@xmath0 m pah emission band is measured by integrating the flux above a spline interpolated local continuum from 5.956.55@xmath0 m . the equivalent width ( ew ) of the pah feature
is then obtained by dividing the integrated pah flux by the interpolated continuum flux density below the peak ( @xmath1 6.22@xmath0 m ) of the pah feature .
the apparent strength of the 9.7@xmath0 m silicate feature is inferred by adopting a local mid - infrared continuum and evaluating the ratio of observed flux density ( f@xmath4 ) to continuum flux density ( f@xmath5 ) at 9.7@xmath0 m and defining @xmath6 for sources with a silicate absorption feature @xmath7 can be interpreted as the negative of the apparent silicate optical depth .
given the great diversity among our mid - infrared galaxy spectra , there is no `` one - size - fits - all '' procedure to define the local continuum in all spectra .
we therefore developed separate methods for three distinctly different types of mid - infrared galaxy spectra : continuum - dominated spectra , pah - dominated spectra and absorption - dominated spectra .
these methods are illustrated in fig.[fig2 ] and described in its caption .
we are forcing the local continuum to touch down at 14.014.5@xmath0 m , because the ism dust cross - section decreases between the two silicate peaks in this region .
detailed radiative transfer calculations verify that our interpolation procedure properly reproduces the emission that would be generated by dust stripped of its silicate features ( sirocky et al . in preparation ) .
the galaxy spectra in fig.[fig1 ] are classified into 9 different classes based on their 6.2@xmath0 m pah ew and 9.7@xmath0 m silicate strength .
the parameter space covered by the various classes is indicated by shaded rectangles in fig.[fig1 ] .
average mid - infrared spectra for the eight populated classes are shown in fig.[fig3 ] .
the average spectra were constructed by normalizing all spectra to unity at 14.5@xmath0 m flux before the averaging process . in order to maximize the signal - to - noise ( s / n ) of the average spectra , low s
/ n spectra were discarded from the process .
below we describe the 8 average spectra in the order ( bottom to top ) they are presented in fig.[fig3 ] . the ninth class , 3c , is not populated .
the class 1a spectrum is characterized by a nearly featureless hot dust continuum with a very weak silicate absorption feature at 9.7@xmath0 m .
the class 1b spectrum differs from the class 1a spectrum by clearly showing the family of pah emission features at 6.2 , 7.7 , 8.6 , 11.2 , 12.7 and 17.3@xmath0 m on top of a hot dust continuum .
this hot dust continuum is nearly absent in the class 1c spectrum , allowing the pah emission features to dominate the mid - infrared spectral appearance .
silicate absorption at 9.7@xmath0 m becomes noticable in the class 2c spectrum as an increased depth of the depression between the 69 and 1113@xmath0 m pah emission complexes .
another marked difference with the class 1c spectrum is the steepening of the 2030@xmath0 m continuum and the appearance of an 18@xmath0 m silicate absorption feature . in the class 2b spectrum
the pah features appear weaker than in the class 2c spectrum .
in addition , the spectrum starts to show a 6@xmath0 m water ice and a 6.85@xmath0 m aliphatic hydrocarbon absorption band . in the class 3b spectrum
these absorption features reach their maximum depths , while the 9.7 and 18@xmath0 m silicate features continue to increase in depth up to class 3a .
absorption features of _ crystalline _ silicates @xcite appear in the spectra of the classes 3b and 3a at 16 , 19 and 23@xmath0 m .
equivalent widths of pah emission features and emission lines decrease from class 2b to 3b and 3a .
note especially the change in shape of the 7.7@xmath0 m pah feature as it first broadens and then disappears going from class 2b to 3b and 3a .
finally , the class 2a spectrum differs from the class 3a spectrum mainly by a clearly lower apparent depth of the 9.7 and 18@xmath0 m silicate features .
note that the spectral structure in individual spectra may differ substantially from the average properties of the classes . in fig.[fig3 ] this is represented by the 1-@xmath8 dispersion ranges around the individual average spectra .
the galaxies shown in fig.[fig1 ] are color - coded according to their galaxy classification .
however , their positions may differ from their original assignments , as in fig.[fig1 ] the 6.2@xmath0 m pah ew has been corrected for the effect of 6@xmath0 m water ice absorption on the 6.2@xmath0 m continuum through substitution of the observed 6.2@xmath0 m continuum by the 6.2@xmath0 m continuum that was defined to infer the 9.7@xmath0 m silicate strength . the ice - correction is justified assuming that the ice is part of the obscuring medium _ behind _ the pah emitting region .
the correction is applied only to spectra clearly showing the imprint of water ice absorption , as found among the spectra of classes 2b , 2c , 3a and 3b .
the extent of the correction for individual spectra is indicated in fig.[fig1 ] by horizontal dotted lines .
the ulirgs , seyferts , quasars and starburst galaxies shown in fig.[fig1 ] are not distributed randomly through the diagram . instead , the galaxies appear to be distributed along two branches .
one extending horizontally from the positions of the prototypical seyfert-1 nucleus ngc4151 @xcite to the prototypical starburst nucleus ngc7714 @xcite , the other branch extending diagonally from the prototypical deeply obscured nucleus of ngc4418 @xcite to the starburst nuclei of m82 @xcite and ngc7714 . very few sources are found above and to the right of the diagonal branch and in between the two branches ( the class 2a domain ) .
the three extremes distinguish between agn - heated hot dust spectra ( class 1a ) , pah - dominated spectra ( classes 1c and 2c ) and absorption - dominated spectra ( class 3a ) .
the galaxies lined up along the two branches in between the extremes show signatures of both extremes to varying proportions .
the galaxies along the horizontal branch may be thought of as combinations of agn and starburst activity , while the galaxies along the diagonal branch may be thought of as intermediate stages in between a fully obscured galactic nucleus and an unobscured nuclear starburst .
the latter is illustrated by the two dotted lines in fig.[fig1 ] , which represent mixing lines between the spectrum of ngc4418 on one extreme and either ngc7714 or m82 on the other . the large majority of galaxies on the diagonal branch fall in between these mixing lines .
one notable exception is arp220 .
relatively few galaxies are found in the section between the two branches : the domain of the class 2a sources .
spectroscopically , there are several simple scenarios which will populate this class from adjacent classes .
a class 3a galaxy can be turned into a class 2a galaxy by adding a featureless hot dust continuum to the class 3a absorbed continuum spectrum .
the main effect of this continuum dilution is the filling in of the deep 9.7@xmath0 m silicate feature , resulting in a less pronounced feature . increasing the dilution
not only further decreases the depth of the silicate feature but also increases the continuum at 6.2@xmath0 m , resulting in both a less negative silicate strength and a lower 6.2@xmath0 m pah ew .
the effect of this type of continuum dilution is illustrated in fig.[fig1 ] by a curved arrow .
alternatively , a class 1a galaxy may be turned into class 2a galaxy by passing its mid - infrared spectrum through a foreground cold dust screen .
the path that a galaxy will take is straight up , since the pah ew is not affected by cold foreground extinction .
the presence of foreground dust or dust mixed in within the pah emitting region may also explain the difference between class 1c and 2c starburst galaxies , and the difference between the classification of the prototypical starburst galaxies ngc7714 and m82 in particular .
in the latter case this may be primarily an orientation effect , as the nuclear starburst in ngc7714 is observed face - on , whereas the starburst ring in m82 is seen under an inclination of @xmath180 degrees . finally , the complete absence of galaxy spectra classified as 3c must imply that strong , pure foreground , cold dust obscuration is not common in starburst nuclei .
the obscuring dust instead contributes to the continuum underlying the 6.2@xmath0 m pah feature , reducing its ew .
we have constructed a diagnostic diagram of two mid - infrared spectral quantities , the equivalent width of the 6.2@xmath0 m pah feature and the apparent 9.7@xmath0 m silicate strength , for the purpose of classifying infrared galaxies according to their mid - infrared spectral shape ( fig.[fig1 ] ) .
the large majority of galaxies ( @xmath990% ) are dispersed around two branches : a horizontal one extending from continuum - dominated spectra to pah - dominated spectra and a diagonal one spanned between absorption - dominated spectra and pah - dominated spectra .
seyfert galaxies and quasars ( square plotting symbols in fig.[fig1 ] ) are found exclusively on the horizontal branch characterized by the absence of pronounced silicate features .
starburst galaxy spectra ( triangular plotting symbols ) are concentrated toward the extreme right tip of the two branches , the locus of pah - dominated spectra . of the ulirgs and hylirgs in our sample
( round plotting symbols ) about a quarter occupy the same space as the agns and starbursts in our sample . the large majority ,
however , are distributed along the diagonal branch , characterized by increasingly apparent silicate absorption and less pronounced pah emission features , with deeply obscured galactic nuclei such as ngc4418 @xcite and ngc1377 @xcite as the only non - ulirg , non - seyfert end members on this branch .
note that low - metallicity galaxies ( not included in this study ) would be distributed along the horizontal branch .
the existence of two distinct regimes of apparent silicate absorption , as suggested by the two distinct branches in fig.[fig1 ] , is intriguing and likely points to clear differences in the nuclear dust distribution between galaxies on the two branches .
clumpy distributions produce only shallow absorption features @xcite , and are the likely explanation for the horizontal branch .
the deep silicate absorption found on the slanted branch requires the nuclear source to be deeply embedded in a smooth distribution of dust that is both geometrically and optically thick @xcite .
the transition from clumpy geometry to one dominated by a smooth dust distribution is a possible explanation for the sources located between the branches .
the distribution of ulirg spectra along the full length of both the horizontal and the diagonal branch once again illustrates the diverse nature of the ulirg family .
it , however , also raises the issue of ulirg evolution .
for instance , what evolutionary path has taken iras08572 + 3915 to its extreme class 3a position in which the central power source is deeply buried ?
did the interaction start with both nuclei classified as class 1c/2c starburst galaxies , which then gradually moved up the diagonal branch as the interaction stengthened and more dust accumulated on the remnant nuclei ? and how will iras08572 + 3915 evolve from there , once the obscuring screen breaks up and the hidden power sources are revealed ? in case of a hidden starburst the source likely will move back diagonally toward the starburst locus .
however , if the dominant power source is an agn , will the source cross into the sparsely populated class 2a regime , evolving directly toward the agn - dominated class 1a regime , or will it first undergo a starburst before settling somewhere along the horizontal branch ?
the sparse population of the class 2a domain either indicates that the crossing time is brief with few ulirgs caught in transformation or that deeply obscured ulirg nuclei mostly evolve to starbursts ( first ) . in a more extensive paper ( spoon et al . in preparation ) we will present correlations of additional parameters within the diagram ( e.g. mid - ir line ratios , l@xmath10 , l@xmath11/l@xmath10,absorption features , nuclear separation , optical classification ) .
the authors wish to thank jernimo bernard - salas , nancy levenson , hlne roussel , matthew sirocky , alexander tielens and dan weedman for discussions , and vandana desai for help with the data reduction .
support for this work was provided by nasa through contract number 1257184 issued by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under nasa contract 1407 .
hwws was supported under this contract through the spitzer space telescope fellowship program . | we present a new diagnostic diagram for mid - infrared spectra of infrared galaxies based on the equivalent width of the 6.2@xmath0 m pah emission feature and the strength of the 9.7@xmath0 m silicate feature . based on the position in this diagram we classify galaxies into 9 classes ranging from continuum - dominated agn hot dust spectra and pah - dominated starburst spectra to absorption - dominated spectra of
deeply obscured galactic nuclei .
we find that galaxies are systematically distributed along two distinct branches : one of agn and starburst - dominated spectra and one of deeply obscured nuclei and starburst - dominated spectra .
the separation into two branches likely reflects a fundamental difference in the dust geometry in the two sets of sources : clumpy versus non - clumpy obscuration .
spectra of ulirgs are found along the full length of both branches , reflecting the diverse nature of the ulirg family . |
the observable properties of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) and black hole x - ray binaries ( bhxrbs ) are consequences of accretion on to a black hole at a variety of rates , in a variety of ` states ' , and within a variety of environments .
the major difference between the aforementioned classes of object is the black hole mass .
bhxrbs typically have a black hole mass @xmath010m@xmath5 while for agn it is @xmath6 .
theoretically , the central accretion processes should be relatively straightforward to scale with mass , and this is supported by several observed correlations .
these include a relation between the x - ray and radio luminosities and the black hole mass ( merloni , heinz & di matteo 2003 ; falcke , krding & markoff 2004 ) , and between x - ray variability timescales , mass accretion rate and mass ( mchardy et al .
more quantitative similarities between accretion ` states ' and radio jet production have also been demonstrated ( krding , jester & fender 2006 ; for the current picture of accretion states in bhxrbs and their relation to radio jets see fender , belloni & gallo 2004 ) .
studying the delays between different emission regions gives us a further handle on the scalability of black hole accretion , as signals propagate from , for example , the accretion flow to the jet .
variability studies have so far shown that a correlation exists between the x - ray and optical emitting regions of both bhxrbs and agn , typically reporting small lags , which are consistent with at least some of the optical variations being due to x - ray heating of the disc @xcite .
a recent study by @xcite has shown that a correlated time lag of @xmath0 100 ms exists between the x - ray and ir regions ( ir lagging x - rays ) for the bhxrb gx339 - 4 , indicating a close coupling between the hot accretion flow and inner regions of the jet . in the case of the bhxrb grs 1915 + 105 a variable x - ray to radio lag of @xmath7 mins ( radio lagging x - ray )
has been measured @xcite .
discrete ejection events have been resolved in both the agn 3c120 @xcite and grs 1915 + 105 @xcite .
the linear scaling with mass of the characteristic timescale around a black hole means that there are advantages to studying each class of object . in bhxrbs
we can track complete outburst cycles , from the onset of disc instabilities through major ejection events , radio - quiet disc - dominated states , and a return to quiescence , on humanly - observable timescales ( typically years ) . for a typical agn
the equivalent cycle may take many millions of years .
however , for an agn we are able to resolve individual variations of the source on time - scales that are comparable to or shorter than the shortest physical time - scales in the system ( e.g. the dynamical time - scale ) , something which is currently impossible for bhxrbs . in ` black hole time ' we are able to observe the evolution of sources in fast - forward for bhxrbs and in detailed slow - motion for agn . in this paper
we present the results of a long term ( @xmath8 years ) regular monitoring campaign in the x - ray and radio bands of the low luminosity active galactic nucleus ( llagn ) ngc 7213 .
previous x - ray studies show that ngc 7213 is accreting at a low rate @xmath9 l@xmath2 @xcite .
the hard state in bhxrbs is typically observed at bolometric luminosities below @xmath10 eddington , and seems to be ubiquitously associated with a quasi - steady jet . above @xmath10 , sources can switch to a softer x - ray state , the jets are suppressed @xcite ; furthermore transition to this softer state is usually associated with major transient ejection events . as ngc 7213 is considerably below l@xmath11
1% we therefore consider it a good candidate for comparison with other bhxrbs in the low / hard state .
if we consider agn to be ` scaled up ' versions of bhxrbs by exploring the time lag between the x - ray and radio emitting regions we can compare , contrast and hopefully relate the accretion and jet production scenarios for agn and bhxrbs . a correlation has been established by @xcite and gallo et al .
( 2003 , 2006 ) relating the radio luminosity ( @xmath12 ) and x - ray luminosity ( @xmath13 ) for bhxrbs in the low / hard and quiescent states , where @xmath14 .
@xcite - hereafter mhdm03 and @xcite extended the bhxrb relationship using two samples of agn to form the ` fundamental plane of black hole activity ' . by accounting for the black hole mass ( m ) the relationship
@xmath14 has been extended to cover many orders of magnitude in black hole mass and luminosity .
further refinements were made to the fundamental plane by @xcite - hereafter kfc06 , using an augmented and updated sample to examine the fitting parameters . throughout this paper
we define the ` intrinsic ' behaviour of agn and bhxrbs as multiple measurements ( in the radio and x - ray ) of the _ same _ source .
we define the ` global ' behaviour as single ( or average ) measurements of _ multiple _ sources , both with respect to the fundamental plane . for the bhxrbs in the low / hard state
the relationship described above has not only been established globally but in some cases intrinsically , i.e gx 339 - 4 , v404 cyg and a small number of other systems have been shown to move up and down the correlation seen in the fundamental plane @xcite .
however , in recent years an increasing number of outliers have been found below the correlation , i.e. less radio - loud then expected ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) as well as some sources which move in the plane with a different slope ( e.g @xcite ) . to date the correlation found from the fundamental plane has only been measured globally for agn , not intrinsically .
note , with respect to the global measurements of the agn population , the specific measurements of the radio and x - ray flux used in the correlation are sometimes taken at different times and thus could be a source of error in the correlation @xcite .
as well as establishing the time lags , another goal of this work , is to establish , through quasi - simultaneous observations the intrinsic relationship between @xmath12 , @xmath13 and m observed in an llagn and its relevance to the fundamental plane of black hole activity .
we use the mhdm03 and kfc06 samples for comparison both with an updated bhxrb sample taken from fender , gallo & russell ( 2010 ) - hereafter fgr10 .
we also explore the possible scatter in agn data points away from the fundamental plane and place limits on this deviation .
ngc 7213 is a face - on sa galaxy hosting a seyfert 1.5 nucleus located at a distance of 25 mpc assuming h@xmath15=71kms@xmath16mpc@xmath16 .
low ionisation emission lines are observable in its nuclear spectrum , also making it a member of the liner class @xcite . the radio properties of ngc 7213 are intermediate between those of radio - loud and radio - quiet agn .
previous radio studies at 8.4 ghz have not resolved any jet emission from the nucleus on scales 3 mas to 1 arcsec ( @xcite , @xcite,@xcite).the long baseline array ( lba ) is an australian six station vlbi instrument @xcite ; lba observations at 1.4 and 0.843 ghz have shown some evidence for larger scale emission that could be due to jet - fed radio lobes @xcite . however , as the nucleus remains unresolved it could be that the jet is oriented to some degree in the direction of the observer . as suggested by @xcite , the lower frequency emission
could possibly be associated with a ` kink ' in the jet at a larger distance .
this could be consistent with a general model proposed by @xcite where radio - intermediate objects are in fact radio -quiet objects whose jets are to some extent aligned in the observers direction and relativistically boosted .
previous x - ray studies have so far failed to show significant evidence for a soft x - ray excess ; compton reflection ; or a broad fe k@xmath17 line in the ngc 7213 spectrum e.g. see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . a narrow fe k@xmath17 line is observed and @xcite show evidence that it is produced in the broad line region ( blr ) .
@xcite also report that the expected uv bump is either absent or extremely weak .
the weakness or absence of these signatures suggests that the inner accretion disc is missing , perhaps replaced by an advection dominated accretion flow ( adaf ) ( as suggested by @xcite ) or similar hot flow , consistent with the low / hard state interpretation of ngc 7213 .
@xcite estimate the black hole mass of ngc 7213 using the nuclear velocity dispersion calculation of @xcite and the velocity - dispersion versus black - hole - mass relationship of @xcite to obtain @xmath18 .
bi - weekly monitoring was obtained with the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) .
the interferometer setup was such that 128 channels of 1 mhz bandwidth were used to form two continuum channels centred at 4.8 and 8.4 ghz respectively .
the radio observations have been reduced using the miriad radio reduction package @xcite .
flux and bandpass calibration was achieved using ( in most cases ) pks j1939 - 6342 ( b1934 - 638 ) and for the phase calibration pks j2218 - 5038 ( b2215 - 508 ) . a variety of fitting techniques
were then tested to extract the flux density of the source from the observations . these included testing point and gaussian fitting to the source in the image and uv plane .
as atca is an east - west array and observations were short in duration ( @xmath02 hours ) an elongated synthesised beam was typically produced .
image - plane fitting often failed to converge and/or produced non - physical results .
therefore fitting was discarded in the image plane for the more reliable uv plane method .
the final radio light curves and spectral indexes ( between the radio bands only ) are shown in figure [ lightcurve ] . to complement the snapshot observations a full 12 hour integration was performed on 2008 june 29
; the purpose of which was to explore the polarisation properties of the jet , and to detect any faint extended structure .
additional steps were taken to ensure adequate polarisation calibration was performed .
this observation was also used to make a deep image of the source ; beyond the 0.5@xmath19 beam no weak extended radio emission was observed above a noise level @xmath20=78@xmath21j at 4.8 ghz .
daily monitoring was obtained using 1 ksec snapshots obtained with the rossi x - ray timing explorer ( rxte ) proportional counter array ( pca ) , allowing a long - term light curve to be obtained in the 2 - 10 kev band .
the data were reduced using ftools v6.8 , using standard extraction methods and acceptance criteria .
the background was calculated from the most recent background models which corrects for the recent problems with the @xmath22 saa ( south atlantic anomaly ) history file .
the final 2 - 10 kev fluxes were calculated by fitting a power law to the observed spectra .
this allows us to take into account changes in the instrumental gain over the duration of the monitoring .
the final un - binned x - ray light curve is shown in figure [ lightcurve ] and is used in all subsequent analysis . versus time .
center bottom : radio flux @xmath23 versus time .
the errors are too small to show on both radio flux figures but are typically @xmath00.4 mjy / beam .
bottom : spectral index ( 8.4 - 4.8 ghz ) @xmath17 versus time where @xmath24 . ]
figure [ lightcurve ] shows x - ray flux ( top panel ) , radio flux ( middle panels ) and radio spectral index @xmath17 where @xmath25 ( bottom panel ) versus time .
the x - ray light curve shows a general decrease in flux until mjd 54600 .
two distinct x - ray flares are observed at mjd 53920 and mjd 54390 , both appear to be correlated with events in the radio bands .
we use the discrete correlation function ( dcf ) method of @xcite to calculate the cross - correlation coefficients between the entire x - ray and radio bands to find the lag . to calculate the centroid lag @xmath26 , we use a weighted mean of the positive lags above an 85% threshold of the peak dcf value .
we use @xmath26 , rather than the peak value @xmath27 , because the centroid has been shown to better represent the physical lag @xcite .
it has been shown that it is difficult to interpret @xmath27 as a physical quantity , and if it is used to calculate the lag , it usually offers an underestimate when compared with @xmath26 @xcite .
the centroid width is calculated as [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the long term radio variability at 8.4 ghz is plotted in the lower panel of figure [ archiveplot ] . the flux values were taken from a variety of instruments and publications ( which are referenced on the plot ) . in order of increasing time the first point on the plot was taken from @xcite using the parkes - tidbindilla interferometer ( pti ) .
then near simultaneous data points were taken with the vla @xcite and then atca @xcite .
the flux from the long baseline array ( lba ) observation by @xcite was the last point plotted prior to the atca monitoring which is presented in this paper .
when comparing the flux expected from the start of our atca monitoring with the lba data point , the lba point seems too low .
the core is un - resolved with all of the radio telescopes described above .
the pti observations constitutes the first data point in figure [ archiveplot ] and the lba the last ( before atca monitoring ) .
note , the parkes - tidbindilla baseline is part of the lba network .
@xcite comment that in the lba observations , no decrease in flux was observed with respect to baseline length i.e it was not resolved ; they conclude from this that the decrease in flux with respect to the other observations is accurate .
however , both the pti and the lba are not sensitive to the same spatial resolutions as the vla and atca ( the largest atca baseline is 6 km and the shortest lba baseline used in the archival observation is 113 km ) .
it is possible that some flux ( on atca equivalent baselines ) is not accounted for : which could plausibly give a decrease in flux i.e indicating brighter , larger scale structure .
the logical consequence of this is that the pti data point is also missing some flux as it samples on a singular baseline of 275 km .
we will discuss these measurements within the context of the fundamental plane and attempt to draw some conclusions in section 5.2 a full 12 hour synthesis atca observation was performed on 2008 june 29 at 8.4 and 4.8 ghz .
the purpose of this observation was to perform a reliable polarisation calibration to ascertain an accurate measurement of the percentage linear polarised ( lp ) flux from the source .
@xcite showed that from a sample of 11 llagn the mean lp was @xmath28 .
@xcite from a survey of 22 blazars report a mean lp @xmath29 with a standard deviation @xmath30 . at the time of observation
the polarisation of ngc 7213 was @xmath31 at 4.8 and 8.4 ghz respectively , which is more consistent with the reported value of typical llagn and not blazars .
the percentage polarisation was calculated at other epochs , however without a full 12 hour synthesis parallactic angle calibration the values were often suspect and will not be presented here .
we have shown that a weak but statistically significant delay exists between the x - ray and radio emitting regions , with the radio lagging behind the x - ray .
a number of models have been proposed to explain and interpret the x - ray to radio lag in both bhxrbs and agn .
the most notable of these are the ` internal shock model ' @xcite and a ` plasmon model ' @xcite .
we will briefly explore these models and comment on the relevance - if any - to our data .
we first consider a plasmon model .
after the accretion mechanism(s ) have pushed matter into the jet , an adiabatically expanding initially self - absorbed synchrotron emitting plasmon travels at relativistic speeds down the path of the jet . at a given time and
frequency the matter becomes optically thin and is ` detectable ' at that given frequency ( in this case either 8.4 and 4.8 ghz ) .
if the jet is fed at a constant mass rate , density and velocity the delay time for material to become optically thin will be constant .
if these parameters are not constant the delay between x - ray and radio will be variable ( e.g. see @xcite ) assuming that the disk and the jet are indeed coupled @xcite .
note , the higher frequency radio emission ( 8.4 ghz ) will become optically thin first , thus a delay from 8.4 to 4.8 ghz is always expected .
another model for explaining the emission seen in jets is the ` internal shock model ' @xcite .
the synchrotron lifetime of an emitting region is too short to adequately explain the scales of jets observered in agn .
these emitting regions - commonly referred to as ` knots ' - are often displaced from the central core emission .
localised shocks within these regions are needed to explain the time - scales of variation observed @xcite .
jet shock scenarios have also been used to model the common flat spectrum jet observered in bhxrbs and agn ( e.g. see @xcite ) .
figure [ lightcurve ] shows the evolution of spectral index ; indicating that during a flare event @xmath17 increases ( @xmath32 ) , flattens and steepens ( @xmath33 ) shortly afterwards .
the initial re - energisation given by a shock would push / compress the plasma into the optically thick regime ; subsequently this process moves the material into the optically thin regime .
the variable time lag seen in the dcf could be interpreted as the time taken for newly injected matter to ` catch up ' with older matter expanding adiabatically in the jet to shock and produce a flare .
the lag would be dependent on the lorentz factor of the newly injected material which in turn is related to the accretion rate @xcite .
although both of these models can adequately explain the variations observed in our light curves , we can not completely disentangle them .
it is possible that both of these models are in some part responsible for the behaviour .
as the jet remains unresolved we can not identify an area of localised shocks or indeed discrete resolved events that we could use to support a particular model .
to explore - in a very simplistic sense - how the time lags seen in bhxrbs scale up to agn we offer two comparisons ; that of a simple mass scaling and also mass - eddington ratio scaling .
for example , discrete resolved ejection events have been seen in grs 1915 + 105 with a variable time lag between x - ray and radio ( ghz ) , with the clearest examples of events having lags of @xmath34 20 - 30 mins @xcite .
taking the characteristic timescale of x - ray - radio lags measured in grs 1915 + 105 and scaling up to ngc 7213 with mass only ( assuming the mass of grs 1915 + 105 as @xmath0 10m@xmath5 and the mass of ngc 7213 as 9.6 @xmath35m@xmath5 and using @xmath36 ) we infer @xmath37 2 @xmath38 days , much longer than we observe .
grs 1915 + 105 is however accreting at a much higher rate , therefore including a scaling by the ratio of the eddington luminosities ( using @xmath39 and taking @xmath40 ) we find @xmath41 140 days , reasonably comparable to our measured lag . the difficulty in comparing the actual x - ray - radio time lag measured for ngc 7213 , and that of the grs 1915 + 105 scaled time lag is that the radio emitting regions being probed are significantly different : in a broader view the spectral energy distributions are different .
in fact until the structure of jets and how it scales with accretion rate and mass at a given frequency are better understood , such attempts at quantitative comparison are of marginal value , although the qualitative comparison is valuable .
the fundamental plane of black hole activity @xcite shows that the correlation @xmath42 holds over many orders of magnitude of x - ray and radio luminosities , and black hole masses .
figure [ full_plane ] shows ; at high luminosities a sample of agn taken from mhdm03 , and at the low luminosities an updated bhxrb sample taken from fgr10 . the updated bhxrb x - ray data were observed in the 0.5 - 10 kev energy range , therefore careful steps were taken ( using webpimms ) to correctly convert into the 2 - 10 kev range to compare with the mhdm03 and ngc 7213 data points .
we plot on figure [ full_plane ] the best fit parameters @xmath43 log @xmath44 log @xmath45 as defined by mhdm03 .
note , we do not re - fit the best fit line for the updated bhxrb sample .
we paired the x - ray and radio data points to calculate the correlation by finding the closest x - ray point ( in time ) , to the radio , because the x - ray sampling was more frequent .
the average for ngc 7213 sits well on the predicted correlation .
the right hand panel of figure [ full_plane ] shows a close up of the ngc 7213 data .
a least squared best fit for the ngc 7213 data points only is shown and parametrised by @xmath46 log @xmath47 ( the constant includes the mass term in the context of mhdm03 ) .
we include in figure [ full_plane ] the correlation found from the archival x - ray and radio data ; however , as they were not simultaneous we do not include them in the best fit .
we paired the x - ray and radio data points to calculate the correlation according to the closest in time .
if either two x - ray , or two radio points were very close in time , both are included in the correlation . also note that these data were calculated between 8.4 ghz and 2 - 10 kev and not 4.8 ghz . assuming that the same correlation ( i.e @xmath0 flat spectrum ) holds between the 8.4 and 4.8 ghz observations the plot seems to show that two of the archival points do not follow the trend predicted by the fundamental plane . to assess whether the deviation / scatter in the archival points ( and indeed the other mhdm03 agn ) away from the fundamental plane can be explained due to a delay in sampling the x - ray and radio fluxes
; we take the fraction rms scatter in the rxte / atca x - ray and radio data and plot this errorbar with the archival points .
we find the fractional x - ray rms to be @xmath48=26% and the fractional radio rms @xmath49=11% .
the full light curve presented in this paper spans @xmath0 1000 days and the longest change in time between the archival observations is @xmath0 500 days ( see table [ achival_table ] ) .
although this method only offers an estimate of the error between sampled data points , it does allow us to assess outliers . within this framework
it appears that the first ( pti correlation ) and last ( lba correlation ) data points that were used in the correlation are outliers : the atca and vla correlation points sit close to the best fit .
even when taking into account the full rms from the 1000 day light curve the error bars do not bring the data points close to the mhdm03 best fit .
we have also speculated earlier that there could be a certain amount of missing flux associated with these long baseline observations . moving both the pti and lba points up by some set amount will still leave the pti point away from the correlation .
although applying the intrinsic variation of the source to the archival points can not bring all points onto or close to the correlation ; the scatter in these points is within that permitted by the other mhdm03 points shown on the plot . by using the fractional rms of x - ray and radio variability from our study
we have placed a constraint in the deviation of the archival data points away from the fundamental plane .
these constraints suggest that other forms of scatter ( apart from bad sampling and missing flux ) could be affecting the data . as summarised in kfc06 other forms of scatter
could be attributed to beaming , source peculiarities and spectral energy distribution - but note , these should remain relatively constant for the @xmath50 source . in figure [ kfc ]
we plot a llagn @xmath51 sample and best fit parameters taken from kfc06 with the updated bhxrb sample .
note , the x - ray data in the kfc06 sample are taken in the 1 - 10 kev band . as the ngc 7213
data points are in the 2 - 10 kev band we assume a photon index of @xmath52=1.8 and add a correction factor to the ngc 7213 data points to make them comparable . we apply a similar correction to the bhxrb sample . from this plot
it is clear that the ngc 7213 data points are positioned slightly above the best fit line .
considering the postion of ngc 7213 on the fundamental plane with respect to other llagn ( see figure 6 ) , we calculate its radio loudness parameter to assess the differentiation .
we calculate the radio loudness parameter @xmath53 ( where @xmath54 and @xmath55 are the radio and optical luminosities ) ; we use a @xmath56 band magnitude of 16.3 , and find the optical flux @xmath57 using @xmath58log@xmath59 @xcite : giving @xmath60 = 134.8 . in this scheme
radio - loud sources are typically defined as having an @xmath60 parameter @xmath61 10 , while radio - quite range between 0.1 - 1 @xcite . using the alternative radio loudness parameter of @xcite which utilises the x - ray instead of optical luminosity , @xmath62
, we find log@xmath63 -3.28 .
@xcite show that for a sample of low - luminosity seyfert galaxies log@xmath64 while for a sample of low - luminosity radio galaxies ( llrgs ) log@xmath65 . therefore , with respect to the x - ray radio loudness , ngc 7213 is only slightly higher than that of a sample of low - luminosity seyfert galaxies ; while under the standard definition of radio loudness it is indeed radio loud .
these results are consistent with the position of ngc 7213 on figure [ kfc ] . as was discussed earlier in this paper there is an apparent time lag between events in the x - ray and radio .
therefore comparing the fitting parameters found from the ngc 7213 data with the mhdm03 relationship without correcting for the lag might give rise to errors as we are not matching the correct data points .
the width in the cross - correlation peaks shows that the time lag is variable .
thus , for example , the two radio flares could have different lag times associated with them . therefore shifting the entire radio light curve back by a set amount to match the x - ray
could still give a scatter . to simplify this problem we separated out the data for the first flare only because we have a more accurate measurement of the lag in this specific case .
we then shifted the radio data -35 days which was the time lag measured for this singular flare using the dcf at 4.8 ghz ( see table [ lag_table ] ) .
the top panel of figure [ shifted ] shows the uncorrected data on the mhdm03 plot while the middle panel shows the corrected data ; for completeness the bottom panel shows all radio data points shifted back .
for the first flare correcting the data appears to reduce the scatter and increase the gradient more in line with the mhdm03 best fit .
it is now described by @xmath66 log @xmath67 . to check the statistical significance of this we measured the gradient for a variety of shifts . from 0 - 25 days
the gradient gradually steepens until it gets close to 1 ( giving a coefficient of @xmath0 0.6 ) . from 30 - 50
days it plateaus @xmath0 1 and from 50 days the gradient decreases towards 0 .
thus it does appear that moving the flare back by the amount given from the dcf function does seem to better represent the data with respect to the mhdm03 fit .
however , it should be noted that as this is a log / log plot , measuring gradients from such a small range of values should be treated with care .
it would , however , be interesting in future studies to assess the importance of this parameter .
we have used the australian telescope compact array and the rossi x - ray timing explorer to conduct a long term study of agn variability in the llagn ngc 7213 .
we have used the cross - correlation function to show that a complex and weakly significant correlated behaviour exists between the x - ray and radio emitting regions .
although the statistics only show a weak correlation , this study is the first definitive campaign to probe this type of behaviour .
we have shown that ngc 7213 sits well on the predicted fundamental plane of black hole activity plot when compared with the mhdm03 sample .
however we have shown that when comparing ngc 7213 with a revised bhxrb and llagn sample that the data points are above the expected correlation ; which is however consistent with the calculated radio and x - ray loudness parameters . we have also shown some support that by correcting for the time lag between events in x - ray and radio the gradient of data points agree better with the best fit derived from the mhdm03 sample on the fundamental plane .
m.e.bell would like to thank sera markoff , anthony rushton and sadie jones for their useful comments and discussion .
the australia telescope is funded by the commonwealth of australia for operation as a national facility managed by csiro .
this research has made use of the tartarus ( version 3.1 ) database , created by paul oneill and kirpal nandra at imperial college london , and jane turner at nasa / gsfc .
tartarus is supported by funding from pparc , and nasa grants nag5 - 7385 and nag5 - 7067 . | we present the results of a @xmath0 3 year campaign to monitor the low luminosity active galactic nucleus ( llagn ) ngc 7213 in the radio ( 4.8 and 8.4 ghz ) and x - ray bands ( 2 - 10 kev ) . with a reported x - ray eddington ratio of @xmath1 l@xmath2 , ngc 7213
can be considered to be comparable to a hard state black hole x - ray binary .
we show that a weak correlation exists between the x - ray and radio light curves .
we use the cross - correlation function to calculate a global time lag between events in the x - ray and radio bands to be 24 @xmath3 12 days lag ( 8.4 ghz radio lagging x - ray ) , and 40 @xmath3 13 days lag ( 4.8 ghz radio lagging x - ray ) .
the radio - radio light curves are extremely well correlated with a lag of 20.5 @xmath3 12.9 days ( 4.8 ghz lagging 8.4 ghz ) .
we explore the previously established scaling relationship between core radio and x - ray luminosities and black hole mass @xmath4 , known as the ` fundamental plane of black hole activity ' , and show that ngc 7213 lies very close to the best - fit ` global ' correlation for the plane as one of the most luminous llagn . with a large number of quasi - simultaneous radio and x - ray observations , we explore for the first time the variations of a single agn with respect to the fundamental plane .
although the average radio and x - ray luminosities for ngc 7213 are in good agreement with the plane , we show that there is intrinsic scatter with respect to the plane for the individual data points .
[ firstpage ] agn jets radio x - ray lag |
nonlocality is an important phenomenon in nature , particularly in quantum world .
the direct recognition of quantum nonlocality comes from the fact that a quantum wave is spatially extended , in contrast to the point model for classical particles . in this paper
we mainly discuss how the nonlocality affects the interactions between material particles of spin-@xmath0 .
the problem is intriguing since the nonlocality has been gleamingly implied by the renormalization of conventional quantum field theory ( cqft ) , whence most relevant calculations have to be regulated by momentum cutoff to contain the non - point effect .
the technique however , is usually available only at high energy scale , the case where the wavelengths of particles are ultra short .
here we take into account the nonlocal effect emerging within the range of interactions possibly a few wavelengths ; but we do nt get involved in the hotly discussed long distance effects relating to entangled states and their applications such as quantum information , quantum communication and quantum computation etc .. up to date , we have recognized that one can not accurately measure the spatial coordinates of a proton by making an accelerated electron as probe , unless its wavelength is much shorter than the diameter of the proton .
but the proton would be smashed and some other hadrons will be involved in the final state ( and thus the scattering becomes inelastic ) if making the electron s wavelength short enough . in the case of elastic scattering ,
the detected proton becomes a * singularity * for the electron s wave .
the reason may be that , in the measurements , the quantity ( coordinates ) we inquire is not at the same spatial level as that the quantum entities settled in
the coordinate is a four - dimension quantity but the electron s or proton s wave is eight - dimension , or put it in mathematical terminology , the quantity we inquire is real but a quantum object is complex . it is concluded from purely mathematical point of view that , only located in a space with dimension equal to or larger than that of the detected objects can an observer get complete information of direct measurement . as a tentative method and a starting point , in this paper we propose an * equal observer * , e.g. an electron , is also put into the hilbert space to observe another electron or other fermions such as protons .
presumably , they are at the same spatial level . therefore the electron can use the metric ( gauge ) appropriate for the observed objects to measure physical observables .
the method of * equal observer * is conducive to describing the observed quantum wave ( * nonlocal entity * ) as a whole with possibly less interaction - information lost , unlike in conventional quantum mechanics ( cqm ) where quantum wave is expressed on the basis of space - time points .
the dynamics for the equal observer of a quantum wave is believed to be different from cqm . in this paper
we employ the similarity between quantum * singularity * and gravitational * singularity * to describe how one fermion observes ( interacts with ) another fermion , and dynamically apply the formalism of general relativity ( gr ) by generalizing its space from real to complex [ fig . 1 ] . as for the elastic scattering of electron and proton , in calculating the radiative corrections to the lowest order of scattering process by employing quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) , we encounter the divergence rooted from leading - order potential form @xmath10 while making momentum @xmath11 . in calculating the collision of two heavy celestial bodies by using gr ,
the similar singularity rooted also from the form @xmath10 is encountered , but there the puzzle of divergence is automatically circumvented by carrying out a horizon , the outer of which is physical region , and the inner of which , now known as black hole region , is unphysical .
quantum mechanically , the nonlocal region is usually unobservable in our space - time , and thus unphysical .
enlightened by such physical scenario , we expect to define physical region for elemental fermions in complex space . in analogy to gr , the principle of nonlocality for two interacting fermions is : * there always exists a complex frame for observer * ( one fermion ) * in which the observed fermion * ( another fermion ) * looks like a plane wave , no matter the existence of interaction . *
cqft itself can also lead us to perceive the implicit and profound relationship between nonlocality ( quantum wave ) and complex - curvature .
generally , we interpret the scattering matrix between initial state @xmath12 and final state @xmath13 as @xmath14 , where @xmath15 @xmath16 can be any state of a complete set . in this formalism , the operator @xmath17 ( or alternatively , the hamiltonian ) is assumed known .
then the matrix elements @xmath18whose square is proportional to transition rate between initial and final states can be evaluated .
whereas from an equal observer angle , all the states @xmath19 are known and the state @xmath20 can be observed , so the operator @xmath17 can be carried out formally @xmath21 , consequently the interaction becomes known .
this latter opposite thought reminds us of the physics in gr , where the force can be realized by the curving of space - time .
so , if only the @xmath17matrix is defined locally in complex - space ( a quantum wave is viewed as a point in such space , and as a whole ) , the differential geometry for * nonlocal entity * would definitely occur .
[ note : for convenience , in what follows we will not employ the language of @xmath17matrix , though relevant . ] the further understanding of the relationship between nonlocality and curvature is achieved in section 10 , where the local conservation laws do nt exist . in summary ,
one will gradually be aware of that all of the above intuitive knowledge on nonlocality could be _ transferred _ to and _ interpreted _ by the complex geometry we used , _ via _ the motion equation for fermions and the field equation for bosons in section 8@xmath229 .
the main results of the paper are as follows : from our dynamical motion equation we can restore all the terms appearing in the quadratic form of dirac equation . for the @xmath23 field [ generalized qed ] , if electromagnetic fields @xmath4 and @xmath3 satisfy @xmath24 , the bosons will gain masses .
based on the discussion of physical region , we can attain two qualitative understandings of quark confinement . in order not to make readers confused by mathematical details
, we only list some main results of the real and complex geometry with detailed explanations and the necessary calculating techniques , then immediately apply them to physics problems discussion of dynamical equations and the definition of physical region .
the remainder of this paper is arranged as follows . in sections 2 - 5
we introduce the necessary calculating techniques of geometry , the readers familiar with the contents can neglect this part and directly turn to section 6 . then in sections 6 - 9
we apply them to construct the motion equations for fermions and field equation for bosons .
the conservation laws are sketched in section 10 . in section 11 , the physical region
is defined for @xmath23 field [ generalized qed ] and @xmath6 field [ generalized qcd ] .
consequently the qualitative understandings to confinement of quarks is presented under the approximation of interaction vertex @xmath25 .
finally a concluding section is presented to summarize the paper and give some remarks on the applicability of the theory . in appendix
a , the derivation of motion equation for fermions is elaborated .
exterior product proves to be a powerful tool in calculating tensors .
it obeys the rules of grassman algebra .
one of its usages is to give rise to new tensors of higher order .
for example , let @xmath27 be of coordinates for a space , and @xmath28 an arbitrary scalar function with respect to these coordinates , then the total differential of the function @xmath29 is d@xmath30 .
we call @xmath31 a one - order tensor , or a vector , and @xmath32 the basis in the neighborhood of a given point @xmath33 . in terms of exterior product the d@xmath29
is called differential 1-form .
now we can construct 2-form on the basis of the 1-form : dd@xmath34 . the sign @xmath35 denotes the exterior product .
it satisfies the antisymmetric rule : @xmath36 , according to which one can easily conclude dd@xmath37 .
conventionally , an @xmath38-form is written as @xmath39 the repeated index henceforth in this whole paper means summation . here
the @xmath40 are components of the @xmath41order tensor , and the exterior products @xmath42 are the bases .
the above forms can be readily extended to complex variables , e.g. , the two complex variables \{_z , z_}. and the only 2-form of these complex variables is @xmath43 @xmath44 @xmath35__@xmath45 where @xmath43 is a function of _ z _ and _ z. _ here _ z _ and _ z _ are independent variables .
usually a space is called @xmath38-dimension manifold if it can be formed as smoothly as possible by affixing many infinitesimally flat patches of @xmath46(@xmath38-dimension real space ) , @xmath47(@xmath38-dimension complex space ) , or other sorts of @xmath38-dimension spaces .
in fact in this paper we are only concerned about a particular sort of differential manifolds , but for convenience we will call it manifold without specification . above all , an important property for a given space is the existence of derivatives , which is essential to build up a description of differential geometry . as for hilbert space ,
the existence of derivatives may be determined by that of wave function @xmath48 in it . in general , the existence of derivatives of a real function can be understood intuitively . however , for a complex function , that demands the cauchy - riemann condition be satisfied . when the complex derivative can be defined everywhere ,
the function is said to be * analytic*. now we review it in respect of complex geometry .
conventionally , we identify an @xmath38-dimension complex manifold with a @xmath49-dimension real manifold .
the complex coordinates and real coordinates have the relation @xmath50 then the following 1-form is written straightforwardly @xmath51 and subsequently @xmath52 @xmath53 the reverse of the above equations yields @xmath54 @xmath55 here the sign @xmath26 above the equals sign means a * definition*. perform exterior - product upon an arbitrary complex scalar function @xmath56 , it results in a 1-form @xmath57 make @xmath58 , we note that @xmath59 is just the cauchy - riemann relation @xmath60 another important property of a given space is its transformation .
commonly , the vector fields spanned by basis @xmath61 [ real space ] or by basis \{@xmath62d@xmath63d@xmath64 @xmath65 } [ complex space ] on manifolds are the objects responsible for addressing the geometry of the manifolds .
how do these fields transform from one point to another infinitesimal neighboring point of the manifolds ?
the transformations are usually constrained by some groups as done in the well - known classical mechanics or quantum fields .
we will return to this topic later .
now let s turn to the affection of cauchy - riemann relation on a vector basis .
ignoring some unnecessary details , we assume that the transformation of the @xmath38-dimension complex manifold has the general form @xmath66 as an application of eq.(3.6 ) , replacing the function @xmath29 by @xmath67 , and writing the @xmath67 of eq.(3.7 ) explicitly as @xmath68 , the form of the eq.(3.6 ) now reads @xmath69 make @xmath70 @xmath71 and introduce a @xmath72 matrix @xmath73@xmath74 which satisfies @xmath75 , @xmath76 denoting the identity matrix of rank @xmath49 , then the cauchy - riemann relation ( 3.8 ) can be written @xmath77 and correspondingly an identical relation holds @xmath78 write out the eq .
( 3.10 ) alternatively as @xmath79 and regardless of @xmath73 on @xmath80 , we obtain @xmath81 combining it with the equation ( 3.4 ) gives @xmath82 @xmath83 consistently the results ( 3.13)(3.14 ) can also be expressed using the basis @xmath84 and @xmath85d@xmath86,d@xmath87 , respectively as @xmath88 and @xmath89 @xmath90 from eq .
( 3.16 ) , we note that the d@xmath91 and d@xmath92 are eigen forms of the matrix @xmath73 , and the relations are independent of the choice of the coordinates . in this respect @xmath73
is called the * complex structure * of the complex manifold .
a manifold with complex structure is called * almost * complex manifold .
the above mathematical formulae will become more meaningful if we replace @xmath93 and @xmath94 by the wave function @xmath95 and @xmath96 from the hilbert space ( manifold ) , which will be recognized in following sections . for convenience ,
henceforth we will put @xmath97 in a more general space , with hilbert space only as a special case .
before giving the general definition of metric ( gauge ) , it is helpful to recall its definition in three - dimensional ( 3-d ) space . using the cartan method of moving frames [ 1 ]
, let every point @xmath98 in 3-d space correspond to a frame @xmath99as following .
if the point @xmath100 varies with a curvilinear net defined by @xmath101 i.e. , @xmath102 , the total differential of @xmath100 then takes the form @xmath103 if setting @xmath104 and @xmath105 , then from eq.(4.1 ) the point @xmath100 relates to frame @xmath106 as follows @xmath107 now define metric tensor as @xmath108 the parenthesis denotes the inner product of common sense . combining these definitions ,
the metric of @xmath109 reads @xmath110 from eq.(4.2 ) , the differential of basis @xmath111 can be formally written as @xmath112 where @xmath113 is also a 1-form similar to @xmath114 , then the differential for @xmath115 can be calculated as follows @xmath116 the above general forms is suitable for any frame @xmath117 .
now let s turn to some special cases relevant to concrete frames .
a well - known metric form for coordinates frames is the orthogonal one , i.e. @xmath118 . with this relation , eq.(4.4 ) becomes @xmath119 and eqs .
( 4.6 ) , ( 4.7 ) give rise to @xmath120 another general / important frame is the * natural frame * , in which @xmath121 is defined by @xmath122 then ( 4.1 ) is directly written as @xmath123 and ( 4.4 ) reads @xmath124 the natural frame is of elicitation in studying manifold , which can help us extend the above discussion to n - dimensional space .
the space continuously generated by curvilinear net @xmath125 is a manifold .
now let s turn to its natural bases @xmath126 . according to the terminology of quantum mechanics ,
@xmath111 is made by two parts : a matrix ( operator ) @xmath127 and a vector @xmath128 .
since the operator parts @xmath127 are the same for different points @xmath100 , we usually write @xmath129 for general cases while @xmath130 for a given point @xmath100 . in this sense
, the general form of inner product @xmath115 becomes @xmath131 for a given point @xmath33 on manifold , @xmath132 gives rise to a mapping that maps two arguments @xmath133 and @xmath134 to a real or complex number . then what is the relationship between the basis @xmath135 which has been mentioned in section ii and this @xmath136 ? that can be recognized by the integral @xmath137 where @xmath29 is an arbitrary function , the integrand @xmath138 is unaltered after integration .
so it is reasonable to write @xmath139 the contravariant metric tensor @xmath140 is thus defined by @xmath141 with @xmath142 .
the above arguments equally hold in complex space . for a given space , there may exist several ways to define its metric form , _
i.e. , _ the gauge to measure the space . in the physical respect ,
we are only interested in the forms like eq .
( 4.14 ) , even for complex manifold .
the construction of metrics includes another important feature , i.e. the constructed metric @xmath143 should be of geometrically invariant quantity with respect to the transformation between frames of the different points of the manifold / space . for a given space , there may exist many ways to jump from one point to another point in its infinitesimal neighborhood . to address
the manner of the jump is to determine the transformation group between the corresponding frames .
the transformation group is also a key element to define manifold , different groups correspond to different manifolds
. now let s turn to the general form of differential geometry .
perform the infinitesimal group transformation upon the vector basis @xmath144 , the change of @xmath145 is then analogous to eq .
( 4.5 ) @xmath146 @xmath147 is 1-form ( the similar meaning as the above @xmath148 ) on the manifold .
conventionally , we take the explicit form @xmath149 in which @xmath150 ( not a tensor ) is known as * connection * , referring to the manner how to affix the infinitesimal flat - space - patches to form a larger curved space .
according to above definition eq .
( 4.15 ) , the variation of a vector @xmath151 under the transformation yields @xmath152 where @xmath153 is known as covariant differential .
the above expressions indicate that the notations @xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath147 are identical:@xmath156 , which leads us to a conventional denotation @xmath157 where @xmath153 and @xmath158 are both viewed as operators .
if for all components @xmath159 is met , the differential @xmath160 is called the parallel displacement for vector @xmath161 , and the path along which the displacement would occur is solvable from the equation @xmath162 .
the connection @xmath147 can be carried out by demanding that it should preserve the inner product of two vector @xmath161 and @xmath163 @xmath164 if they are parallelly displaced , i.e. @xmath165 . in the above equation @xmath166 and @xmath167 and @xmath168
are 1-form .
we see that @xmath169 leads to @xmath170 i.e. @xmath171 the parallel displacement @xmath159 and the conclusion that the connection preserves the metric @xmath172 , i.e. eq . ( 4.21 ) , are equivalent they can bring out each other .
note that all the components of @xmath173 form a matrix @xmath174 , and likewise components of @xmath115 form a matrix @xmath175 , eq .
( 4.21 ) can be written in terms of matrices @xmath176 @xmath177 means the transpose of the matrix @xmath178 .
the relation eq .
( 4.22 ) puts a way which we will elucidate later to carry out the connection @xmath179 with respect to the metric @xmath115 . let s turn to the most important quantity of manifold the curvature tensor which is an invariant 2-form under a certain transformation group that specifies the manifold .
conventionally , the curvature matrix is defined by @xmath180 taking @xmath181 and bearing in mind that @xmath182 , we can express it explicitly @xmath183 the denotation @xmath184 in subscripts stands for the derivative with respect to the @xmath185-th variable .
then by tr@xmath186 i.e. making @xmath187 in ( 4.24 ) [ summation convention is applied too .
] one gets the ricci tensor @xmath188 above formulae pertain to all manifolds with the metric form like eq .
the analytic property of complex manifold is determined completely by the complex structure , so any connection possessed by complex manifold is demanded to preserve the complex structure .
i.e. @xmath189 where @xmath190 means performing differential on a given basis @xmath191 , i.e. @xmath192 . apply eq .
( 5.1 ) to eq . ( 4.15 ) , remembering the eq.(3.14 ) [ please note : for a complex manifold , we use denotations @xmath193 and @xmath194 hereafter ] , then @xmath195 however , if we apply eq.(5.1 ) to @xmath196 , the result becomes @xmath197 which violates eq.(5.1 ) .
therefore , eq.(5.1 ) holds only if @xmath198 replace @xmath199 by @xmath200 and repeat the same procedure , we have @xmath201 eqs.(5.4 ) suggest only the 1-form @xmath147 and @xmath202 are permitted in the complex manifold .
if the connection of a manifold preserves the complex structure @xmath73 , then the manifold is called almost complex manifold , this statement is equivalent to aforementioned definition .
furthermore if the repeat of the differential @xmath203 , i.e. @xmath204 always turns to null , @xmath205 ( other equivalent conditions are @xmath206 and @xmath207 ) , then the almost complex manifold becomes complex manifold .
( the proof of these statements is omitted in this paper . ) in this paper only complex manifolds are concerned .
@xmath208 is called @xmath209 $ ] type connection , and @xmath210 is called @xmath211 $ ] type connection .
the group transformation can not change the type of connection . in this paper , for simplicity we employ only @xmath209 $ ] type connections , and @xmath212 $ ] type connections are thus all trivial .
it seems that the expression in section iv is only developed for real geometry , but in fact it also pertains to complex geometry .
here we iterate the results in terms of complex geometry .
first of all , let s assume that we have chosen a metric for the complex space , @xmath214 it is an additional requirement to real geometry that the indices @xmath215 and @xmath216 belong to two different types , one is normal component , the other is its complex conjugate , @xmath217 .
the reason why we choose this particular metric form will be explained in the next section . following the process of the last section ,
let s make the connection preserve the metric @xmath218 .
having chosen the @xmath219,@xmath220 as basis @xmath221 , the result is easily obtained from eq.(4.19 ) that @xmath222 in obtaining the above equation , we have used the following equations due to the parallel displacement @xmath223 @xmath224 where @xmath225and @xmath226 are components for the vector @xmath161 and @xmath227 @xmath228 @xmath229 . in analogy with the form ( 4.22 ) ,
eq.(5.6 ) can be expressed in the following matrix form @xmath230 where @xmath231 refers to the matrix with components @xmath232 . performing exterior product on the above equation turns the left hand trivial , and @xmath233 where @xmath234 , in which the minus sign comes from the transpose of matrices .
( 5.9 ) suggests the curvature matrix and metric matrix are of anticommute . in eq.(5.8 ) , if @xmath177 is the @xmath209 $ ] type , then @xmath231 is the @xmath211 $ ] type .
bearing in mind that @xmath235 , eq.(5.8 ) gives rise to @xmath236 i.e. @xmath237 the inverse of matrix @xmath238 is so defined that @xmath239 then due to ( 5.10b ) the component form of @xmath178 is @xmath240 consequently the curvature form ( 4.23 ) and ( 4.24 ) certainly hold , with the variables now being complex @xmath241 from @xmath242 , and taking into account the definition of the components form of curvature , @xmath243 , it is straightforward to obtain @xmath244 here the meaning of @xmath245 is the same as that of @xmath246 , and likewise for @xmath247 . from this form
it is obvious that the curvature is antisymmetric with respect to the last two indices @xmath185 , @xmath248 . except the requirement eq .
( 5.4 ) due to analytic condition , the manifold in virtue of @xmath249 adds no more constraint to the connection . on the basis of the above general complex manifold , if we demand the metric matrix @xmath238 satisfy @xmath251 with components form as @xmath252 i.e.
if @xmath238-matrix is hermitian conjugate to itself , then the metric is called the hermitian metric .
all the components of the hermitian metric form the hermitian matrix ( hermitian operator ) .
this kind of operator is well known in quantum mechanics and has many good properties . to keep the hermitian metric @xmath253 and corresponding curvature invariant
, the transformation group must be a unitary group @xmath250 .
additionally , as for an hermitian manifold , if the connection @xmath254 is symmetric with respect to the indices @xmath215 and @xmath255 , the manifold then is called khler manifold .
the transformation group for khler manifold is @xmath256 . to summarize the above results relevant to curvature , we note that it subjects to three constraints as the following .
\(i ) as shown in eq .
( 5.4 ) , the form of connection like @xmath257 and @xmath258 is trivial , \(ii ) we only use [ 1 , 0 ] type connection , so the [ 0 , 1 ] type connection @xmath259 , \(iii ) the curvature form is [ 1 , 1 ] type , so the forms @xmath260 or @xmath261 vanish . under these constraints , one can calculate the following curvature components one by one according to the explicit form ( 4.24 ) : @xmath262 , @xmath263 , @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269 , @xmath270 , @xmath271 , @xmath272 , @xmath273 .
finally one concludes that only four of them are nonzero @xmath274 @xmath275 @xmath276 @xmath277 the above four equations hold independent of the torsion [ the torsion is defined as @xmath278 since the evaluating process has nothing to do with it . when the torsion is absent , the first two curvatures in eq .
( 5.14 ) display more symmetries @xmath279 , @xmath280 .
the constraints certainly affect the ricci tensor .
based on eq.(5.14 ) , the ricci tensors are obtained by tracing @xmath281 in eq . ( 4.23 ) , @xmath282 the equation suggests only two independent forms of ricci tensor , @xmath283 and @xmath284 , exist .
furthermore , the curvature component @xmath285 is antisymmetric with respect to the indices @xmath286 and @xmath287 , i.e. @xmath288 , whence only one form of ricci tensor would occur .
we will return to this antisymmetry in section ix .
now the ricci tensor defined by ( 5.15 ) can be explicitly written as @xmath289 here the notation @xmath238 stands for determinant @xmath290 , and the last step is obtained by applying the differential relation of a matrix determinant @xmath291 to the derivatives of @xmath292@xmath293 the above discussions set no limit on transformation group , hence pertain to general situations , say , @xmath249 . for the hermitian or khler manifold , the independent components of curvature and ricci tensor should decrease .
if @xmath294 is hermitian , then @xmath295 and @xmath296 , applying ( 5.14a ) , ( 5.14d ) or ( 5.14b ) , ( 5.14c ) to ( 5.18 ) , the following expression can be achieved @xmath297 the specification of khler manifold adds no more constraint to the form of ricci tensor except the symmetric indices of connection in equation ( 5.14a ) , ( 5.14b ) .
now let s count the number of the independent components of the ricci tensor .
apart from the fact that the two indices are antisymmetric , the group @xmath298 adds no constraints .
so in this case the set @xmath299 , with @xmath300 being over @xmath301 , has totally @xmath302 elements . while @xmath303 need not be taken into account for antisymmetry .
the freedom of @xmath294 , however , is totally @xmath304 components , so it requires @xmath305 gauge conditions to solve the field eq .
furthermore , if the manifold is hermitian , i.e. the eq.(5.19 ) holds , @xmath306 , then the elements of set @xmath307 decrease to @xmath308 , and the freedom of @xmath294 also shrinks to @xmath309 , hence @xmath310 additional equations are needed to resolve the @xmath294 , almost the same as that of @xmath298 .
a quantum fermion field is customarily expressed by dirac spinor @xmath311 , and the inner product of @xmath311 is prescribed as @xmath312 where @xmath313 to be consistent with conventional quantum field theory ( cfqt ) , here the @xmath314 is defined as @xmath315 , which is different from previous denotation @xmath316 .
henceforth we distinguish the difference by whether or not the subscripts or superscripts are used : if used , then the latter definition is available , otherwise the former definition holds .
the former definition @xmath317 is meaningful in making the inner product @xmath318 invariant under the transformation group @xmath319 , which is the spinor - representation of lorentz group .
the invariance is a direct corollary of lorentz invariance of dirac equation [ 2 ] . to apply the differential geometry ,
let s generalize the inner product .
to do so the definition of metric should be valid only within a very small region of the complex space , e.g. the inner product @xmath320 should be generalized to @xmath321 , and only in this sense does the inner product remain invariant under the transformation of group @xmath322 .
any infinitesimal transformation is now performed on @xmath323 instead of on @xmath324 .
@xmath325 can be viewed as plane wave locally and @xmath324 has conventional meaning on a larger scale .
the above inner product holds when there is no interaction , if any interaction arises , the product has to be interpreted by a general metric form @xmath326 .
the above form @xmath327 is only a special case while @xmath328 , @xmath329 for @xmath330 and @xmath331 for @xmath332 . in conclusion
, the metric of the quantum field is demanded to be @xmath333 which does not violate experiences from qed .
in a two - dimension ( 2-d ) plane , the curves of hyperbolic or elliptic type can be interpreted by the equations like @xmath334 or @xmath335 .
general linear transformations in 2-d [ known to be @xmath336 group .
they have the general form @xmath337 , with @xmath338 being real numbers ] ca nt change the types of curves , since the performance of linear transformations has two identical manners : one is to change the objective curves ; the other is to change the coordinate axes . applying the latter manner ,
the types of the curves are obviously reserved . in other words , under general linear transformations within 2-d , if a curve in 2-d is ever a type , it will forever be the type . in this paper
we take into account only the quadratically homogeneous forms for variables , so considering these two types is enough .
the above argument is expected to hold also in four dimension space ( 4-d ) . * * it becomes complicate in this case , since a 4-d curve being hyperbolic in one projected plane may be an ellipse in another .
so the definition of hyperbolic or elliptic type has to be extended : for a 4-d curve , if there exists at least one 2-d plane so that the curve projected into it is hyperbolic , then curve is called hyperbolic , otherwise it is elliptic . in our concerns
the 4-d interval [ in this paper metric means the same as interval ] @xmath339 in special relativity is hyperbolic type , because if the equation @xmath340 is projected into any 2-d subspace including the time axis , the resultant curve is a hyperbolic type .
lorentz group preserves the interval @xmath341 , so the hyperbolic characteristic is also the main feature of lorentz group , which is called noncompact in terminology of group theory . in contrast , the group @xmath342 is compact for it preserve the interval @xmath343 , which is a elliptic type . instead of requiring the transformation groups to preserve the interval , now we only require the types of interval to be preserved
. then we can find that hyperbolic characteristic of the interval @xmath339 will not change under the general linear group @xmath344 , similar to the above 2-d case .
generally , to keep the type of an @xmath38-d interval of quadratic homogeneous form , that the transformation is linear is sufficient . here and hereafter the explanations of concepts relevant to group are rough and only for later application .
the above definitions of hyperbolic and elliptic type in 2-d are for the global space . in a local region of the whole space ,
the two types should be interpreted by @xmath345 and @xmath346 respectively .
correspondingly , if special relativity is treated locally , then the metric is @xmath347 in a small local region , the infinitesimal transformations of @xmath344 can not change the types of the curves . therefore , even though a transformation changes ( 7.1 ) to a general form @xmath348 , by which we can not tell its type directly , the type of the metric @xmath349 remains the same as eq .
( 7.1 ) .
now we extend the above discussions and knowledge to complex space . in following three paragraphs
, we construct the * parallelisms * between the metrics of real space and complex space , as well as the * parallelisms * between the groups preserving them , then generalize our understanding of hyperbolic and elliptic type in real space to the understanding of complex space .
let s consider the complex - space metrics defined in the last section , @xmath350 , where @xmath351 is a complex spinor @xmath352 .
this metric is invariant under the transformations of group @xmath322 , @xmath353 means that the elemental variables in the group are complex ones .
. it can be verified [ 3 ] that there exists a two - to - one mapping between all the elements of the group @xmath319 and all the elements of the proper , orthochronous lorentz group .
hereby the group @xmath322 is viewed as * complex parallellism * of the lorentz group ( which is born from physics in real space - time ) .
now let s elucidate the relationship between group @xmath322 and aforementioned metric @xmath354 .
the quantities which are transformed according to lowest - dimensional nontrivial representation of @xmath322 are called two - component _ spinors _ , which are doublets as states for spin . on the basis of higher dimensional representation of @xmath322 other spinors with more components can be constructed . in our case
the four - component spinor @xmath355 is transformed according to named @xmath356 representation of @xmath322 [ involving @xmath357-matrices ] , their relationship can be derived from the covariance of dirac equation and we omit all the relevant details here .
also it can be confirmed that the metric form @xmath358 remains unaltered under the transformation of @xmath359 representation of @xmath322 . in a word
, the metric @xmath360 is the * complex parallellism * to the real interval @xmath339 .
consequently the * complex parallelism * to eq .
( 7.1 ) should be @xmath361 now we know @xmath362and hence @xmath363is hyperbolic .
however , we do nt know what is the largest group which includes @xmath322 as a subgroup that makes the type of metric @xmath364 unchanged .
searching for what is exactly the largest group would be a tedious work and might simultaneously deviate us from the main line of developing this theory . in this paper
we simply assume the latest group is @xmath365 ( in fact must be a subgroup of @xmath298 ) and bearing in mind that it is for hyperbolic type .
the * metric parallelism * between elliptic types of real space and complex space can be constructed by directly generalizing each of real axes to a complex one .
we are familiar with the metric defined in the 3-d space @xmath366 * , * which is invariant under the rotation group @xmath367 .
suppose a complex space spanned by wave functions with only three components , @xmath368 , corresponding to metric @xmath369 * * and consistent with the probability in quantum mechanics , we conclude that its metric should be of the form @xmath370 , where the integration over the configuration space is implied .
to preserve the probability in the whole complex space , the quantum mechanics requires any transformations performed on the wave function @xmath371 should be elements of special unitary group @xmath8 or its subgroups .
@xmath1 groups are compact , just as @xmath372 .
hereby the metric @xmath373 and group @xmath1 are viewed as the * complex parallellism * to that of elliptic type of real space .
the caution should be practiced that it is not perfect to generalize the rotation transformation in real space directly to conservation of angular momentum as done in quantum mechanics to achieve the same result that metric @xmath374 and @xmath1 are elliptic type .
since the lorentz group includes a spatial rotation part besides the boost part , from the noether theorem of quantum field theory one can also derive the conservation of angular momentum
. then there will be confusions between the two types .
the degrees of freedom of elliptic type presented in this paper are those degrees of freedom such as electro - charges , isospins , or colours etc . , other than spins and spatial angular momentum .
the largest group to preserve the elliptic type of the metric @xmath375 is certainly @xmath376 groups .
we have endowed the lorentz symmetry and special unitary symmetry with hyperbolic type and elliptic type , the corresponding types of metric defined according to these two symmetries remain stable even after the groups are appropriately extended . we know
@xmath376 group will not change the type of metric @xmath377 , and a subgroup of @xmath298 will not change the type of @xmath378 .
it is the extended groups that provide more degrees of freedom over which the complex space spanned by wave functions is curved . corresponding to the two symmetries , there are two types of curvings . since for a fermion , such as quark , it has both the curving characteristics
hyperbolic type and elliptic type
spinor and colour , we should combine the two types of metric into one general form @xmath379 where we generalize @xmath380 to @xmath381 are colour indices , @xmath215 , @xmath382-are spinor indices .
the metric matrix @xmath383 may be written separately as a hyperbolic part multiplied by an elliptic part .
after reviewing the geometrical method , let s turn to its application to physical problems . as an equal level observer , assumedly an electron can test another electron without losing any information . to an observer what is the motion equation of the observed electron ?
for an observer in space - time the right equation is certainly the schrdinger equation or the dirac equation . but as an equal level observer , it constructs the equation as follows : there always exists a complex local frame for the observer in which the observed electron looks like a plane wave ( a free electron ) , in spite of the existence of interaction similar to that happens in general relativity
saying that there always exists a local frame in space - time in which the observed particle looks like a free one moving along a straight line , in spite of the gravitation .
in terms of geometry , it means that the motion of electron is just a geodetic line in complex space , i.e. , the parallel transport ( displacement ) .
conventionally a free electron is described by plane wave @xmath384 , @xmath385 is dirac spinor
. the complex space here should be of 4-dimension since @xmath385 possesses four components , furthermore , it should be hyperbolic as argued in the preceding section . in this respect
the transformation group for the space should be @xmath298 .
since the complex space is continuously spanned by components of local spinor @xmath386 , its natural bases are @xmath387 .
consequently , @xmath388 , then the parallel displacement ( 5.6a ) @xmath389 turns out to be @xmath390 similarly , another equation for @xmath97 holds , @xmath391 above two equations are the general forms of motion equation for fermions . in eq .
( 8.2 ) the component @xmath392 is an infinitesimal change of @xmath393 relative to its neighboring points , which is determined by @xmath393 and the transformation performed on it .
suppose that after a transformation the wave function @xmath393 changes to @xmath394 then resembling the form of eq.(3.7 ) , the wave function @xmath395 can be expressed by variables @xmath396 , @xmath397 now the differential form @xmath392 can be written explicitly as @xmath398 the derivative @xmath399 in the above equation however , is not operable in practical calculation .
practically , we want to know how far the eqs .
( 8.1 ) , ( 8.2 ) deviate from the conventional dirac equation . or to put it alternatively , how can the terms in dirac equation be finally restored in local region by reducing aforementioned parallel displacement ? to obtain a form of dirac equation , let s first recall the replacement used in gr : @xmath400 .
that reminds us to replace the differential operator @xmath26 in eqs .
( 8.1 ) , ( 8.2 ) by some forms of derivatives with respect to space - time . in view of the quadratic form of eqs .
( 8.1 ) , ( 8.2 ) , it is helpful to know the following quadratic form [ 2 ] of dirac equation before we do some replacement of operator @xmath26 , @xmath401 { \psi } = m^2 { \psi } \text { , } \tag{8.5}\ ] ] where @xmath402 is the field tensor of common sense . in
what follows , we put @xmath403 .
then the explicit form of eq .
( 8.5 ) is @xmath404 by using a weaker lorentz condition @xmath405 of gupta and bleuler [ 5 ] instead of the original one @xmath406 , the above equation changes to @xmath407 as a reasonable approximation to leading - order qed , the quadratic terms of @xmath408 , such as @xmath409 in the above equation and similar terms in our following calculation will be temporarily omitted .
now let s turn to treating the equation ( 8.2 ) .
first let s substitute the explicit form of @xmath410 , @xmath411 , into the equation ( 8.2 ) , concerning only the second term , it yields @xmath412 then the form of motion equation ( 8.2 ) becomes @xmath413 extending the discussion of eqs .
( 6.1)(6.3 ) straightforwardly by considering
the vertex @xmath414 used in qed , we can interpret the metric tensor @xmath415 with interaction as @xmath416 ( henceforth we continue to use @xmath417 to express the field potential .
take care not to confuse it with the metric tensor @xmath418 ) .
it is easy to verify that @xmath419 . to obtain a form of dirac equation , comparing the second term of eq .
( 8.8 ) with the term @xmath420 in eq . ( 8.6 ) , we find it is effective to replace @xmath26 by @xmath421 .
obviously , the replacement @xmath422 @xmath421 performed to the first term of eq .
( 8.8 ) directly induces @xmath423 .
furthermore , by analyzing the dimensions of eq .
( 8.8 ) , we find the dimensions of the first term and that of the second term are not equal . in the natural units ,
the first term of the above equation has the dimension of energy square if assuming @xmath424 dimensionless . as for the second term
, the form @xmath425 can be simplified as @xmath426 , and @xmath427 [ @xmath428 is energy square too , but the derivative performed on @xmath424 also contribute the dimension of an energy , so an extra energy dimension exists . to remedy the**unequal dimensions of two sides and according to our experience of treating the schrdinger equation with a nonlocal interaction - potential [ 6 ] , we add a line integral with respect to space - time @xmath429 to the second term .
the integration is accompanied by the purely imaginary number @xmath430according to requirement restoring the dirac equation . now
the form of equation ( 8.8 ) becomes @xmath431 consistently , the infinitesimal integral measurement @xmath432 should also be linked with @xmath255-matrix , assumed as @xmath433 .
now let s evaluate the results of the second term @xmath434 in eq .
it is convenient to write out the integral in terms of matrix @xmath435 here @xmath436 is a four - component vector , @xmath437 and @xmath438 all in their matrix forms , @xmath439 and @xmath440 .
we will mainly deal with the first integral in ( 8.10 ) , since the second term includes two @xmath417 factors we temporarily omit it as second - order perturbation .
the calculation involves the formulae of @xmath441matrices in simplifying the product @xmath442 . the detailed evaluation on the first integral is put to appendix a
, here we only show the result in ( a. 7 ) @xmath443 where @xmath444 . submitting the integral result back into ( 8.9 ) yields @xmath445
it is found that the terms @xmath446and @xmath447 are just those required by ( 8.6b ) .
however , quite a few other terms like @xmath448 , @xmath449 , etc . accompany the required ones .
some of the redundant terms , such as @xmath450,@xmath451 , @xmath452 , with integrand relevant to local angular momentum @xmath453 , which is assumed second order small in perturbation theory according to our numerical experience , can be omitted temporarily .
the contributions of remainder terms like @xmath454 , @xmath455 , @xmath456 , @xmath457 can not be judged reasonably , so these terms can not be thrown off and may show their significance in some situations when the wavelength of fermions is sufficiently long .
for instance , @xmath458 is an operator , and it renders the results of @xmath459 dependent on the variation of the wave function @xmath424 . accordingly
this sort of terms is possibly relevant to the nonlocal effect of aharonov - bohm type [ 7 ] .
the terms @xmath460 , @xmath461 would behave in similar ways . but the term @xmath462 , without the factor @xmath463 before it , is the exceptional case as discussed in the following . comparing the eq . ( 8.12 ) with eq . ( 8.6 ) , it is noted that there lacks a mass term @xmath464 in the right hand of eq . ( 8.12 ) .
there are two ways to remedy this flaw .
first , one can directly add a mass term to the right hand of equation ( 8.9 ) , then the equation ( 8.2 ) would have a nonzero term in its right hand too .
that obviously violates our original hypothesis that motion equation is just the geodetic line .
another way out is to accept the term @xmath465 as the mass term .
the reason is that according to the klein - gordon equation of the next section the double derivatives on potential @xmath466 would induce a mass factor and the integration @xmath467 would induce a phase factor depending on closed paths ( loops ) of fermions [ 7 ] , thus the total effect of the term @xmath468 seems equal to a mass term for motion equation of fermions .
if the paths are not closed , then the mass of fermions would become dependent on potential @xmath466 .
the claims of this paragraph are only qualitative , further confirmation is necessary .
the relevant works are in process .
apart from the above qualitative display , all of the four nontrivial terms , @xmath469 , @xmath470 , @xmath471 and @xmath472 , are surely nonlocal since they obviously ruin the local conservation law @xmath473 [ where @xmath474 , which can be directly derived from the conventional dirac equation ( 8.5 ) .
if the approximation @xmath475 is not used here , the replacement @xmath422 @xmath476 would not be reasonable . in general case
the matrix @xmath477 should be expanded to all possibilities of @xmath441matrices ( the total number of matrices is 16 ) without respecting only the vector form of interaction .
but we think there leaves little arbitrariness to extend the theory to include more sorts of interaction .
if surely the approximation @xmath478 holds for fundamental interactions , then accordingly we would extend the replacement @xmath479 @xmath421 to @xmath422 @xmath480 , @xmath481gellmann matrices , when we are concerned about the colour interaction between quarks . that will cause more integrations and other intricate terms to enter into eq .
we will not detail that issue here . in conventional quantum field theory ( cqft )
, we only regard the part @xmath482 being responsible for the physical process .
however , in view of the nonlocal ( curving ) effects , it has been stated in ref . [
8 ] that the @xmath482 is not complete in describing all physics . even under our rough approximation
, it can be seen in eq .
( 8.12 ) that more terms are present than required .
it includes not only the normal terms @xmath483 but also some other terms on account of nonlocal effect .
moreover , the definition of the connection and thus the physical meaning of @xmath408 now are not the same as those in cqft , since in cqft , @xmath417 ( potential ) is assumed as connection and @xmath483 as the curvature tensor . but here the @xmath417 is viewed only as components of metric tensor and @xmath483 as connection ( force ) .
correspondingly the dimension of motion equation here is also different from that of schrdinger equation , the former is a force , and the latter a potential .
a discrepancy of energy dimension appears under natural unit .
the differential problem in fact has arisen in calculating the terms @xmath485 and @xmath486 . as a hypothesis ,
we have required the wave function to change with respect to space - time variables @xmath487 , with which the terms in dirac equation for electrodynamics are restored . however ,
in fact , since we are discussing the property in complex space , the differential @xmath488 should change with respect to complex variables as showed in eq .
( 8.3 ) , i.e. @xmath489 . making every coefficient of @xmath490 vanish , then eq.(8.2 ) yields @xmath491 this equation should be thoroughly respected by the electron as an equal level observer to another observed electron .
although it is impossible for the electron to release all information it carries by projecting its complex space to our space - time , @xmath492 , we have to do so to get some physical observerbles in space - time .
just for the physical reason and for consistence , in this section we directly make the replacements of the differential forms @xmath493 and @xmath494 , or the equivalent forms @xmath495 and @xmath496 , as follows : @xmath497 @xmath498 this subsection is devoted to explaining a subtle but important aspect in calculating the curvature tensor .
it can be seen from the definition of eq.(4.24 ) that the curvature tensor @xmath500 is explicitly antisymmetric with respect to the indices @xmath185 and @xmath248 . however , the antisymmetry seems lost from the expression ( 5.14 ) .
now let us impose that antisymmetry on the interpretation of eq.(5.14 ) and see what will be the result .
substitute the explicit form of connection @xmath501 into eq.(5.14 ) , the components of curvature become explicit functions with respect to metric tensor : @xmath502 we only calculate the first one as an example , the others can be obtained by properly changing the indices .
impose the antisymmetric property on the first equation of eq.(9.3 ) @xmath503 then the left hand and the right hand can be changed respectively to @xmath504=-\frac{\partial a^{\alpha \bar \gamma } } { \partial { z}^k}\frac{\partial a_{\bar \gamma \beta } } { \partial { \bar z}^j}-a_{\bar \gamma \beta } \frac \partial { % \partial { \bar z}^j}\frac \partial { \partial { z}^k}a^{\alpha \bar \gamma } \text { , } \tag{9.5a}\ ] ] @xmath505 the equality of the two sides directly gives @xmath506 i.e. @xmath507 the relation seems trivial in this form , but making the replacement of ( 9.2 ) results in @xmath508 which is a reasonable result telling that the operator @xmath499 is hermitian .
so now we can insist on the antisymmetry in ricci tensor without worrying about any unexpected contradiction . as a byproduct of applying the above argument to ricci tensor ( 5.18 )
, a rule is gained that for any product of two derivatives like @xmath509 , @xmath238 arbitrary , the result should be antisymmetric if permuting @xmath510 and @xmath511 , @xmath512 .
now let s introduce the field equation for bosons , e.g. photons in electrodynamics . for a boson field without any source , we are concerned about the case when the interaction is absent , i.e. , the connection ( force ) of complex space is trivial , and thus all the components of curvature tensor @xmath513 vanish . in that case
the boson field satisfies the equation @xmath514 .
the equation will not change under certain transformations in question ( e. g. @xmath515 group for photons ) since @xmath513 is a tensor .
that is to say , the field equation will not change with the appearance of interaction .
but as a general equation for a boson field the condition @xmath514 seems too strict , so we introduce a weaker constraint by merely demanding that ricci tensors vanish , @xmath516 that not only holds for free fields , but also is expected to hold while a source appears at a point infinitely far away . as in gr , we can add the source term to the right hand of equation , whose physical meaning will be clarified later , @xmath517 the coefficient @xmath518 can be determined by comparing it with the klein - gordon equation .
next we will study what can be derived from this field equation , and what are its differences with the klein - gordon equation as well .
we had better resolve the field equation ( 9.8 ) precisely before discussing the field property .
but here we expect to understand the field properties by substituting some good approximations into the field equation . as argued in section vi , in the absence of interaction
the metric matrix is of the form @xmath519 and after a period of interaction , according to the perturbative theory ( in this whole paper we respect the perturbative results of cqft ) , the matrix evolves into @xmath520 if only the electronic part is present , eq .
( 9.10 ) gives @xmath521 moreover , if we choose the large components approximation , which is validated by qed , then the form of @xmath522 yields @xmath523 now we briefly review the reasonability of the above approximation .
the large components and the small components appear in solution of dirac equation when both the electric part ( scalar potential ) and magnetic part ( vector part ) of the boson field are small and the kinetic energy of fermion is very low : in general , the dirac equation can be written [ 2 ] , @xmath524 where @xmath525 is kinetic energy , @xmath526 the scalar potential and @xmath527 the vector potential .
divide the four components @xmath528 into two parts composed respectively of the first two components and the last two components , @xmath529 with this denotation the dirac equation is readily reduced into two equations , @xmath530 after carrying out @xmath531 as @xmath532 , we see that when @xmath533 , @xmath526 and @xmath527 are all small , the two components @xmath534 and @xmath535 obey the relation @xmath536 so in the large component approximation * , * the potential @xmath537 in the last two diagonal elements in ( 9.11 ) can be ignored reasonably since it contributes to @xmath538 the terms two orders less than that of the first two diagonal elements . consequently the approximation ( 9.12 )
does hold . under this approximation
, the ricci tensor reads @xmath539 replacing the differential @xmath540 following eq .
( 9.2 ) , and assuming that the scalar field does not vary with time , then up to @xmath541 order the field equation @xmath542 turns out to be @xmath543 which is just the poisson equation satisfied by the electric field in vacuum . in the next subsection
it will be shown that the approximation without the electric field is also heuristic .
now let s turn to the approximation without electric field or source term , i.e. , the case that only radiation field exists .
computing the similar form of ricci tensor in ( 9.17 ) by using the metric form ( 9.10 ) and making @xmath544 , we have @xmath545 we will treat the equation explicitly to construct its relation to the electric and magnetic energy forms @xmath546 and @xmath547 , where @xmath548 and @xmath549 .
the calculation of ( 9.19 ) includes two parts @xmath550 and @xmath551 where the underlines denote the inner products between the vectors . and the sign @xmath552 is the tensor product for dyads , for example , @xmath553 @xmath554 .
if an inner product is emphasized by underlines then the regular product order between dyads is not followed , e.g. @xmath555 .
usually we only use the underlines while the gradient operator @xmath556 appears .
now let s express the magnetic energy @xmath557 in terms of vector potential @xmath558 to further simplify the eq .
( 9.22 ) , the following relations are useful , @xmath559 @xmath560 \nonumber \\ \ & = & ( \vec \nabla \underline{\vec a}):(\vec \nabla \underline{\vec a})+\vec a% \cdot \vec \nabla ^2\vec a-\vec \nabla \underline{\vec a}:\underline{\vec \nabla } \vec a-(\vec a\cdot \vec \nabla ) ( \vec \nabla \cdot \vec a)\text { , } { ( 9.23b ) } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath561=(\vec a\cdot \vec \nabla ) ( \vec \nabla \cdot \vec a)-\vec a\cdot \vec \nabla ^2\vec a\text { . }
\tag{9.23c}\ ] ] applying relations in ( 9.23 ) to ( 9.22 ) , we obtain @xmath562 the last step holds for transverse fields in the coulomb gauge , @xmath563 . now the eq .
( 9.20 ) and eq .
( 9.21 ) can be simplified to @xmath564 @xmath565 combine them into ( 9.19 ) @xmath566 consequently , the following equation holds , @xmath567 heuristically , the eq . ( 9.27 ) suggests if the inequality @xmath568 holds , then the equation for field @xmath569can automatically gain a mass term @xmath570 where the klein - gordon equation takes shape . for electrodynamics ,
since @xmath571 coincidentally and accurately vanishes , the net mass of photon is zero . in qed ,
the lagrangian density for photon field is @xmath572 the field tensor @xmath573 is defined in the preceding section . in terms of @xmath3 and @xmath4 ,
the lagrangian can be transformed to @xmath574 coincident with lagrange undetermined multiplier method , now it is natural to extend the lagrangian of qed by adding a mass term @xmath575 from which the klein - gordon equation for massive bosons can be obtained by using variational method . in the frame of this paper
we do nt respect gauge invariance of the lagrangian .
but the variational method would always be valid from mathematical viewpoint .
now let s clarify the meaning of source term in eq .
( 9.8b ) . in quantum field theory
the klein - gordon equation with source term is @xmath576 , hence according to eq .
( 9.29 ) @xmath577
the right hand is just the interaction hamiltonian . remembering that we have in eq .
( 9.2 ) replaced the derivatives with respect to @xmath578 by the derivatives with respect to space - time , and noticing the form @xmath579 , the above equation and eq .
( 9.17 ) suggest that the source term corresponding to eq .
( 9.8 ) should be of a double integrals with @xmath580 as integrand and @xmath581 as its infinitesimal integral measurement .
we define @xmath582 , then @xmath583 here the @xmath584 refers to a source field induced by fermions , though it looks formally like from @xmath585 .
the term @xmath586 should not be associated with @xmath584 since it is derived from the equation for free boson field . in above subsections the discussions are applicable in fact only to @xmath23 case , in which @xmath585 has no intrinsic degrees of freedom except spatial polarization .
as stated in the previous section , if other intrinsic degrees are involved [ e. g. see ( 7.3 ) , @xmath587 , the replacement @xmath422 @xmath421 will not hold any longer . consequently , the replacement of eq . ( 9.2 ) becomes abated .
instead we should employ the replacement @xmath422 @xmath588 , @xmath589 being generators of a unitary group .
when the group is @xmath590 , whose representation can use pauli matrices , the replacement performing on double differential @xmath493 will induce the similar form to @xmath23 case , @xmath591 . in this case the field equation in space - time would be @xmath592 however , in @xmath8 case , the gellmann matrices @xmath593 have not the property of @xmath594 , so that the cross - terms do nt vanish .
therefore , in @xmath8 case , the field equation in space - time can written only as @xmath595
make exterior differential to both sides of eq .
( 4.23 ) , one gets the following bianchi identity @xmath596 and its matrix form is @xmath597 write it out in components form @xmath598 on the other hand , the covariant differential of @xmath599 can be obtained by definition @xmath600 combining the above two , one gets @xmath601 in the case that torsion is absent , the right side is equal to zero , hence @xmath602}^a=0\;\text{. } \tag{10.6}\ ] ] the bracket @xmath603 $ ] means the left side also includes the terms with the indices of cyclic permutation .
substituting the nonzero components in eq.(5.14 ) one by one to the above equation , for instance substituting the ( 5.14a ) , it becomes @xmath604}^\alpha & = & r_{\beta \bar jk;m}^\alpha + r_{\beta m\bar j% ; k}^\alpha + r_{\beta km;\bar j}^\alpha \nonumber \\ \ & = & r_{\beta \bar jk;m}^\alpha + r_{\beta m\bar j;k}^\alpha \stackrel{\text{% contracting } \alpha \text { and } \beta } { = } r_{\bar jk;m}+r_{m\bar j;k}=0\;% \text{. } { ( 10.7 ) } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the other three forms of eq.(5.14 ) will give rise to the same form of the ricci identity @xmath605 .
it has been proved in sec.v that the metric is invariant under covariant differential , @xmath606 .
so with the definition of scalar curvature @xmath607 , the ricci identity possesses the following form @xmath608 i.e. , @xmath609 applying the relation @xmath610 to above equation , with @xmath611 , the eq .
( 10.9 ) can be changed to @xmath612 now the field equation can be rewritten by regarding the bianchi identity , @xmath613 its equivalence to eq .
( 9.8 ) can be demonstrated as follows : contracting the indices of eq .
( 10.11 ) results in @xmath614 , then substituting @xmath615 back to eq . ( 10.11 ) , finally the eq .
( 9.8 ) is restored .
furthermore , the above equation can be extended to include source term @xmath616 as mentioned in the last section , the approximation ( 9.10 ) is good for perturbative theories . in such case , the metric reads [ 9 ] @xmath617 where the @xmath618 is required to be small comparing with @xmath619 , whose nonvanishing elements are only those diagonal ones , being @xmath620 . here
the linear metric @xmath619 is used to raise or lower the indices of metric and curvature of linear part , e.g. @xmath621 . only in this sense
, the following defined @xmath622 is different from the normal definition of the ricci tensor @xmath623 , though they have almost the same form .
the linear part of the ricci tensor is @xmath624 the rest part then is @xmath625 similar to the treatment in general * * relativity [ * 7 * ] , we separate the left hand of the field eq . ( 10.12 ) into two parts @xmath626 , then eq . ( 10.12 ) can be written @xmath627 we can prove that the differential performed on the left hand of eq .
( 10.16 ) gives zero @xmath628 the first term is zero since the antisymmetric tensor @xmath629indices @xmath630 are antisymmetric@xmath631 is multiplied by symmetric tensor @xmath632 , i.e. , @xmath633 ; and the second term is trivial since the symmetric tensors @xmath634,@xmath635 and @xmath636 are accompanied with the antisymmetric tensor @xmath637 , so @xmath638 is directly zero before differential is performed . from ( 10.10 ) ,
( 10.12 ) we conclude that the source term @xmath639 is conservative in covariant sense , @xmath640 .
whereas from ( 10.16 ) , ( 10.17 ) we conclude that the sum @xmath641 is conservative in sense of common differential , @xmath642 .
the two sorts of conservation directly bring out three conclusions : \(i ) as for the existence of the conserved equation @xmath643 it is natural to view the sum @xmath644 as the total energy - momentum tensor including both the fermion part @xmath645 and the boson part @xmath646 , which suggests in a complex infinitesimal local region the energy and momentum may transfer between @xmath639 and @xmath646 .
\(ii ) since the @xmath647 will not be a tensor for the loss of nonlinear terms , it can be inferred from ( 10.16 ) that the boson part @xmath648 does not satisfy @xmath649 ( this equation and ( 10.18 ) ca nt be satisfied at the same time ) , and thus ca nt be a locally conserved quantity . partly for this reason
the theory in this paper is *
nonlocal*. \(iii ) it seems that the aforementioned mass terms @xmath650 should be included in the boson self - energy term @xmath646 , but the last word on that requires more investigation .
if that is the case , what about the remaining parts in @xmath646 ?
the conclusions of this section are obtained in the absence of torsion .
if torsion is present , then the forms of formulae will be more complicated .
from now on we will work in the approximation of metric tensor shown in ( 9.10 ) : @xmath651 which is justified by the success of cqft for perturbative interaction .
the metric , as stated in section vi , is @xmath652 correspondingly the ricci curvature for it is @xmath653 the present goal is to determine the physical region on the basis of the above formulae . substituting eq .
( 9.10 ) to the eq .
( 11.2 ) , we find the main quantity to be evaluated is the determinant of matrix @xmath654 .
the determinant of ( 9.10 ) is @xmath655 suggested by the horizon of black hole in gr , the horizon - like boundary of the physical region may exist also for those fields with the same theoretical frame as gr . as a tentative step ,
let s first examine the physical region ( or alternatively , the singularity ) for electrons ( whose dynamics is governed by qed ) to get some rules and then apply them to quarks ( the dynamics is mostly governed by qcd ) . from the form of eq.(11.2 )
, it is noted that if @xmath656 then the logarithm function in ricci tensor becomes divergent .
the solutions of the equation are defined as the singularities of ricci tensor . in the large component approximation and @xmath657
, we obtain @xmath658 for the electron in a hydrogen atom , @xmath537 is the coulomb form @xmath10 , then eq . ( 11.5 ) leads to @xmath659 . in the atomic ( natural ) unit , that means
the length of @xmath660 is the average radius of the ground state of the hydrogen atom , which suggests that the zero singularity of logarithm function possibly symbolizes one side of physical region . on the other hand ,
if @xmath661 , then @xmath662 , the electron tends to be free ( asymptotically free ) . in summary
we achieve the following conclusion held for electrons , @xmath663 now let s take this conclusion as a rule : even in other situations , @xmath664 and @xmath665 represent the two sides of boundary of * physical region * , beyond which there are singularities [ fig . 2 ] . as for a electron in hydrogen atom
the singularity region ( * nonlocal region * ) is the region within the range of proton s wavelength . as for the bound - state side of physical region , even in electrodynamics [ 10 ]
, one may encounter alternatives in which a particular approximation of @xmath666 seems unnecessary .
for instance , that @xmath667 resulting in @xmath668 looks also reasonable .
however , in a perturbative theory there is no chance for any components of potential to have a value larger than @xmath665 .
so in perturbative case , the only way to meet @xmath669 is to make @xmath670 and @xmath671 .
but the requirement to the asymptotically
free side is loose , because in any case the alternative solution @xmath672 ( additional to aforementioned @xmath673 , @xmath674 ) of @xmath675 is by no means forbidden . in section
vi , we have noted that the metric form is relevant to the interaction vertex of cqft . in qcd
, we adopt the colour - spin - independent form to express its interaction vertex . apart from a coupling constant
, the vertex reads @xmath676 in which @xmath481 ( @xmath677 ) are gell - mann matrices .
correspondingly , the wave function for quarks can be also written in a separable form @xmath678 where @xmath679 is the familiar spinor part [ being transformed under the group @xmath298 ] and @xmath681 the colour part [ being transformed under the group @xmath682 . in this respect , the complete form of metric for colour interaction can be written @xmath683 where the metric tensor @xmath684 may be further decomposed into @xmath685 we have mentioned in section iv how the connection , curvature and the ricci tensor are derived from @xmath686 .
being multiplied by an additional matrix element @xmath687 , the forms of the aforementioned geometry quantities constructed from @xmath686 , particularly the ricci tensor , will not be changed since we can make the indices @xmath688 , @xmath689 fixed temporarily so that the factor @xmath687 becomes a constant .
the same procedure is equally applicable to fixing the indices @xmath215 , @xmath690 and letting @xmath691 form the corresponding curvature and ricci tensor . combining the two procedures we obtain the ricci tensor for the whole metric @xmath692 where @xmath693 is for spinor and @xmath694 for colour*. * in view of section vii , we recognize that the metric tensor @xmath294 is for the hyperbolic space and tensor @xmath687 is for ellipse colour space , i.e. , @xmath693 and @xmath694 are subject to different geometries ( different curvings ) though their forms are similar .
consequently , the field equation @xmath695 now becomes @xmath696 for simplicity in form , we assume that the constants or other variables before @xmath697 and @xmath698 have been absorbed in @xmath699 and @xmath694 .
the above equation provides us with a way to give rise to mass term alternatively , or reversely to eliminate the mass term in eq .
( 9.29 ) . in section - ix
we have obtained the field equation in space - time @xmath700 , which can be derived from @xmath693 in eq.(11.12 ) . on the other hand
, @xmath701 can contribute a nontrivial term to the field equation in space - time , and roughly we denote such a term by @xmath702 . so far the field equation for colour field
is given by @xmath703 from this equation one recognizes that even when @xmath704 can a mass term be provided by @xmath705 , if only the dimension of boson field is larger than @xmath665[@xmath23 ] .
possibly the term @xmath705 can offer a mechanism to give rise to mass for gluons .
but the reverse possibility exists simultaneously : if @xmath24 , the term @xmath702 may happen to eliminate the contribution from @xmath586when their signs are the same .
so at the present formula - level it ca nt be asserted whether the gluon owns mass or not . from both experiments and the theory of qcd ,
it has been well known that the colour interaction is asymptotically free , i.e. while the transferred momenta of quarks are very large , the coupling constant of colour interaction tends to zero and the interaction becomes a perturbative one . in this case , following the condition @xmath707 in eq.(11.6 ) , we have @xmath674 , @xmath673 or @xmath708 @xmath709 .
the other side of boundary of quarks physical region , where the quarks are tightly confined , is assumed to correspond to the case of bound electron in hydrogen atom .
now we begin to discuss this side of boundary of physical region for colour interaction . when two quarks are in their ground state ( a low momentum state ) , according to eq.(11.6 ) and the parallelism between confined quarks and bound electrons [ fig .
2 ] , the condition @xmath710 should hold .
the eq.(11.11 ) means that either @xmath711 or @xmath712 is satisfied . among others ,
@xmath712 deserves more attention .
obviously it makes the rank of the colour matrix decrease at least by one , from @xmath8 to @xmath590 or @xmath23 , which suggests that quarks condense to hadrons , or possibly others , and thus no free quark appears .
this conclusion seems able to account for the confinement of quarks , at least as a mechanism .
next we examine the meaning of @xmath710 in more details . under our approximation
( 11.7 ) , we have expressed the metric matrix as @xmath713 , in which the metric tensors of spinor part and colour part become separable .
this separable form gives an understanding to colour confinement in the last paragraph .
the understanding however , will not be abated even if the two parts of metric tensor get entangled , since anyway the condition @xmath710 makes the rank of matrix @xmath714 decrease at least by * one * , * which * belongs to either the spinor or colour space .
therefore in what follows we take into account the general matrix form with two parts entangled together .
the following approximation of @xmath715 can be of an entangled form @xmath716 the use of eq .
( 11.14a ) can free us from writing out the explicit space - time indices or colour indices in some special problems .
for instance , in what follows we can only write @xmath527 to imply the inclusion of colour part , as @xmath717 , @xmath718 for a perturbative interaction , it is impossible for scalar potential and vector potential to satisfy the relation @xmath719with @xmath720 . to avoid the coincidence with perturbative interaction , for colour interaction we prefer the condition @xmath721 rather than @xmath722 , @xmath723 to give the solution of @xmath724 .
so we turn to the case @xmath720 and @xmath725 .
we recognize that this case does nt rule out the possibility that while keeping the difference @xmath726 equal to @xmath665 , we can at the same time make both @xmath569and @xmath537 continuously decrease until @xmath537 approaches the _ perturbative _ situation @xmath723with @xmath727(infinitesimal value )
. therefore @xmath720 seems also coincident with _
perturbative _ situation , then we have to consider @xmath728 . without affecting the main conclusion ,
let s assume that the limiting situation @xmath729 holds .
under this situation , we have @xmath730 ( @xmath731 is the corresponding real vector ) .
now let s take into account the explicit form @xmath717 .
since every component of @xmath527 is a matrix , for example @xmath732 @xmath733 , the value of any component should be one of the eigenvalues ( of the corresponding matrix ) or their combination ( the coefficients @xmath734 , @xmath677 , are real ) after tracing out the degree of freedom of colour interaction by , e.g. @xmath735 where the subscript @xmath736 and @xmath29 represent initial and final states respectively .
it can be asserted all values of components are real because the generators @xmath481 ( @xmath677 ) of group @xmath8 are hermitian ( we choose gellmann matrices as the generators ) .
then it appears to be inconsistent with the previous conclusion @xmath730 which is a pure imaginary vector .
one way to treat the inconsistency is to extend the @xmath737generators of @xmath8 to @xmath738generators of @xmath6 @xmath739 in which an additional pure imaginary generator @xmath740 is introduced , we denote it as @xmath741 .
we find @xmath741 , with @xmath742 , is not a hermitian matrix , so that its eigenvalues are not real .
now we conclude that when the confinement happens only the first coefficient @xmath743 is nontrivial , it yields @xmath744 on condition that @xmath745 , the same extension of
@xmath746generators to @xmath747generators would be necessary , and @xmath527 is a complex number accordingly .
the above extension of generators is reasonable because if a space is curved , then some extra dimensions begin to get involved . for instance , after a plane is curved , one must choose three - dimension space and the corresponding transformation group in it to describe the curving .
we choose @xmath9 space as the curved quark space in order to satisfy the confining condition . in summary , in this subsection
the equation @xmath748 leads us to two explanations of the colour confinement : first , it gives the decrease of the rank of colour matrix , which is a general conclusion independent of separable approximation .
second , it induces the curving of colour space , which is a conclusion dependent on the approximation ( 11.14 ) and ( 9.10 ) .
_ relationship with conventional quantum field theory ( cqft ) _ the geometry model presented in this paper can also be viewed as a theory for elemental quantum fields , but it lacks many characteristics of cqft . as for symmetries , the transformations responsible for the groups @xmath249 or @xmath250 are used in this paper . whereas the concept of gauge transformation , under which the invariance of lagrangian or action is respected in cqft , is assumed to be irrelevant here .
so the conservation laws due to invariant lagrangian are not appropriate to discuss in this frame . however ,
from purely geometrical angle , we respect the invariance of geometric quantities such as metric and curvature etc . under the transformation of structure group . generally speaking ,
in a nonlocal theory any conservation law holds only when some integrations are carried out over certain spaces , and thus the square root of jaccobian should appear in the forms of conservation law , as that in gr and implied in sections 810 .
furthermore , generally in cqft the lagrangian depends on the fields and their first derivatives only .
but in differential geometric , it allows for up to two derivatives of fields , which can be noticed in the quadratic form of motion equation for fermions and field equation for bosons . in view of the distinguished success of cqft in describing the purterbative interactions
, the results from these sectors are respected .
first , the dirac equation and klein - gordon equation in qed , the asymptotically freedom in qcd etc . are employed to compare with the results of our model . in that respect ,
the quadratic forms of dirac equation and klein - gordon equation are regained under some approximations .
second , the interaction vertices of qed and qcd are used to design appropriate approximations of metric tensor used in the second half of the paper . however , the technique of renormalization is assumed unnecessary in this theory . because the inclusion of the nonlocal characteristics of quantum wave in this theory would automatically make the value of particles momentum within a limited range . _
relationship with general relativity ( gr ) _ as stated in the introduction , the formalism developed in this work is similar to that of gr .
the difference is that we have generalized the space from real to complex .
the important characteristic of our model is that the base manifold is complex . if the space - time is initially used as the base manifold , it is impossible to clarify physical meanings of dynamics or to get the results of this paper .
additionally , the manifolds under concern are not necessarily riemann manifold , i.e. the metric tensor is not necessarily symmetric , @xmath749 . in gr , only one type of curving
riemann curving ( hyperbolic curving)appears , but in our theory two curvings are present both hyperbolic and elliptic curvings .
they are represented by two different structure groups @xmath249 and @xmath250 , which correspond to two differential geometries .
the geometry with structure group @xmath250 is relevant to riemann manifold [ e.g. @xmath750 gives riemann metric ] , but @xmath249 not . in non - abelian case ,
the metric tensors from two geometries may be entangled as shown in ( 11.14 ) . _
the approximations used in this paper _ all the meaningful results are dependent on the four approximations in eqs .
( 9.10 ) , ( 10.13 ) , ( 11.10 ) and ( 11.14 ) .
the credibility of the results relies on the reasonability of the approximations .
the approximations follow from our understanding of the interaction vertex in cqft .
the appreciated aspect of these approximations is the restoration of the terms of quadratic dirac equation and klein - gordon equation by the aids of the replacement @xmath751 . on the other hand , the appearance of mass term for bosons and the understanding to quark confinement also follow from above approximations and the replacement . from complex space to real space
we use @xmath751 as a projection , we have to do so to get some physical observables in space - time . in doing so
some information is inevitably lost , but it can not be avoided
the observed space is complex , the observing space is real . strictly speaking
, the replacement @xmath752 is not an approximation , but rather a technique following the approximation @xmath753 .
it helps us gain the form of motion equation for fermions , though with quite a few additional integrations involved . to resolve that intricate motion equation
possibly requires us to convert it back to the dirac - equation form by using some special techniques .
_ remarks on applicability of the theory _ although the model is designed for a low - energy nonperturbative interaction , at present almost all the approximations imposed on the model have perturbative forms and originations . and
thus all the results here rely on both the theory and the approximations .
we have noticed some results , such as the additional terms in motion equation and the meaning of @xmath754 etc . , do not completely fit to the perturbative cases , which is expected to be the nonperturbative signals of our model .
so after the model is reduced to get the main essences of cqft , we hope it can be perfectly useful for nonperturbative interaction [ e. g. in phenomenological study of the light quark excited states . ] or , long wavelength low energy region of perturbative interaction [ e. g. strong correlations of fermions in ultra low temperature . ] , as anticipated initially .
_ future development of the theory _
first , we should search for a smaller group than @xmath515 to accurately describe the hyperbolic curving ( lorentz violation of spinors transformation ) , as stated in sec .
the search progress may involve some new physics , not a merely mathematical problem .
second , we should present a more reliable way to give the mass term in fermion motion equation in sec .
c , some numerical calculation may be involved .
third , we hope the theory applicable to weak interaction too .
relevantly , the final understanding of mass problem relies undoubtedly on the issues of weak interaction .
a lot of thanks to prof .
w. t. geng for his constructive suggestions in preparing this manuscript .
in this appendix we give the detailed steps and methods of evaluating the first integration in eq .
( 8.10 ) .
@xmath755 here @xmath436 is a four - component vector , @xmath437 and @xmath438 are all in their matrix forms , @xmath439 and @xmath756 .
we will mainly deal with the first integration in ( 8.10 ) , since the second term includes two @xmath417 factors we temporarily omit it as second - order perturbation .
@xmath757 henceforth in this appendix we use @xmath758 to express the product @xmath759 when @xmath760 .
we evaluate the above two terms in ( a.1 ) separately .
the first term @xmath761 to evaluate the second term in ( a.1 ) , the following relation is useful : @xmath762 substituting this relation to second term in ( a.1 ) yields , @xmath763 we will leave the first term of ( a. 4 ) as it is and turn to cope with the second term , @xmath764 where @xmath765 . then performing the integration by parts , it yields @xmath766 where @xmath444 . in the first term of the right hand
we have converted the expansion @xmath767 back to its original form for there is no way integrating out the coordinates to simple form . now substituting eq .
( a.6 ) and eq .
( a.2 ) into eq .
( a.1 ) leads to @xmath768 [ 1 ] shiing - shen chern , w. h. chen , k. s. lan , _ lectures on differential geometry _ , world scientific publishing co. pte .
( 1999 ) . +
[ 2 ] r.p.feynman , _ quantum electrodynamics_-a lecture note and reprint volume .
w. a. benjamin , inc .
+ [ 3 ] moshe carmeli and shimon malin , _ theory of spinors : an introduction _ , world scientific publishing co. pte . ltd .
( 2000 ) , chapter 3 and chapter 4 .
+ [ 4 ] n. n. bogolubov , a. a. logunov , i. t. todorov , _ introduction to axiomatic quantum field theory _
, w. a. benjamin , inc ( 1975 ) : chapter 5 and chapter 7 , relavant part on group @xmath322 .
+ [ 5 ] s. gupta , proc .
london a63 , 681 ( 1950 ) ; k. bleuler , helv .
acta 23 , 567 ( 1950 ) .
see also , s. weinberg , _ the quantum theory of fields _ , cambridge university press ( 1996 ) : volume ii , pp .
+ [ 6 ] hai - jun wang , hui yang , and jun - chen su , phys .
c 68 , 055204 ( 2003 ) : eq .
[ 7 ] y. aharonov and d. bohm , phys .
115 , 485 ( 1959 ) ; y. aharonov and l. vaidman , phys .
a * 61 * , 052108 ( 2000 ) . +
[ 8 ] t. t. wu and c. n. yang , phys . rev .
d 12 , 3845(1975 ) . +
[ 9 ] s. weinberg , _ gravitation and cosmology : principles and applications of the general theory of relativity _ , john wiley & sons , inc .
, 1972 : pp.165 .
+ [ 10 ] we use electrodynamics to discriminate it from conventional quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) , though in fact they share the same objectives ; as for qcd , we use quarkdynamics to discriminate the similar situation .
fig . 1 : to describe how one fermion observes ( interacts with ) another fermion
, we employ the formalism of general relativity by generalizing its space from real to complex . in gragh , only three axes are displayed , in fact we work in four - dimension space .
2 : patterns of physical region in three - dimension space , respectively for electrons ( a ) and quarks ( b ) . likewise
the singularity and physical region for complex space are defined in sec .
11 by adding constraints to interaction potential . | the natural recognition of quantum nonlocality follows from the fact that a quantum wave is spatially extended .
the waves of fermions display nonlocality in low energy limit of quantum fields . in this
_ ab initio _ paper we propose a complex - geometry model that reveals the affection of nonlocality on the interaction between material particles of spin-@xmath0 . to make nonlocal properties appropriately involved in a quantum theory , the special unitary group @xmath1 and spinor representation @xmath2 of lorentz group
are generalized by making complex spaces which are spanned by wave functions of quantum particles curved .
the curved spaces are described by the geometry used in general relativity by replacing the real space with complex space and additionally imposing the analytic condition on the space .
the field equations for fermions and for bosons are respectively associated with geodesic motion equations and with local curvature of the considered space .
the equation for fermions can restore all the terms of quadratic form of dirac equation . according to the field equation it is found that , for the u(1 ) field [ generalized quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) ] , when the electromagnetic fields @xmath3 and @xmath4 satisfy @xmath5 , the bosons will gain masses . in this model , a physical region is empirically defined , which can be characterized by a determinant occurring in boson field equation . applying the field equation to @xmath6 field [ generalized quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) ] ,
the quark - confining property can be understood by carrying out the boundary of physical region . and it is also found out that under the conventional form of interaction vertex , @xmath7 , only when the colour group @xmath8 is generalized to @xmath9 is it possible to understand the strongly bound states of quarks .
pacs : 02.40.tt , 12.20.-m , 12.38.aw , 11.15.tk |
smart and responsive complex materials can be achieved by self - organization of simple building blocks . by now , a broad range of functionalized colloidal and polymeric building blocks have been proposed and designed .
@xcite this comprises synthetic colloidal structures , e.g. , patchy or janus colloids @xcite or biological molecules such as dna duplexes .
@xcite these building blocks are able to self - organized into gel - like structures , e.g. , hydrogels , which are able to undergo reversible changes in response to external stimuli.@xcite thereby , rodlike molecules , such as viruses @xcite or telechelic associative polymers , @xcite exhibit novel scaffold - like structures , and theoretical and experimental studies have been undertaken to unravel their structural and dynamical properties in suspensions . here ,
polymer flexibility and end - interactions are the essential parameters to control the properties of the self - assembled network structures .
@xcite the appearing structures can be directed and controlled by external parameters , specifically by the application of external fields such as a shear flow.@xcite here , a fundamental understanding of the nonequilibrium response of a network structure is necessary for the rational design of new functional materials and that of already existing synthetic and biological scaffold - like patterns .
@xcite computer simulations are an extremely valuable tool to elucidate the self - organized structures of functionalized polymers .
monte carlo @xcite and molecular dynamics simulation @xcite studies of coarse - grained models of end - functionalized flexible , semiflexible , and rodlike polymers in solution have shown that in thermal equilibrium self - organized scaffold - like network structures form above a critical attraction strength and within a range of concentrations .
this network formation is strongly affected by the polymer flexibility , because flexible polymers can span a larger range of distances between connections points , even form loops , and deform easily thereby generating softer networks .
the molecular dynamics simulation studies of telechelic polymers of ref .
predict flower - like micellar aggregates for flexible polymers . for stiffer polymers , significant morphological changes
appear , with liquid - crystalline - like order of adjacent polymers and inter - connected structures.@xcite recent nonequilibrium simulations of end - functionalized rodlike polymers exhibit further structural changes under shear flow .
@xcite at low shear rates , the scaffold structure compactifies , while at intermediate shear rates novel bundle - like structures appear with nematically ordered rods . in the limit of very strong flows ,
all structures are dissolved and the rodlike polymers align in a nematic fashion . in this article , we extend the previous studies and investigate the influence of shear flow on the scaffold - like network structure of end - functionalized _ semiflexible _ polymers .
both , the structure properties under shear flow as well as the rheological properties are analyzed for various shear rates .
we find that an initial scaffold structure breaks up and densified aggregates are formed at low shear rates , while the structural integrity is completely lost at high shear rates . thereby , flexibility gives rise to particular compact aggregates at intermediate shear rates .
in addition , the relaxation behavior of shear - induced structures after cessation of flow is analyzed in part in order to elucidate the reversibility of the shear - induced structures .
we apply a hybrid simulation approach , which combines the multiparticle collision dynamics ( mpc ) method for the fluid , @xcite which accounts for hydrodynamic interactions , @xcite with molecular dynamics simulations for the semiflexible polymers .
@xcite the mpc method has successfully been applied to study the equilibrium and nonequilibrium dynamical properties of complex systems such as polymers , @xcite colloids , @xcite vesicles and blood cells , @xcite as well as various active systems .
@xcite the combination of coarse - grained modeling of end - functionalized polymers and a particle - based mesoscale hydrodynamic simulation technique is ideally suited for such a study .
on the one hand , we want to elucidate the general principles of structure formation under nonequilibrium conditions . the achieved insight will be useful to understand the behavior of a broad spectrum of experimental systems , ranging from highly flexible synthetic polymers , e.g. , telechelics , to stiff biological macromolecules , such as dna segments .
on the other hand , mesoscale hydrodynamic simulation approaches are essential , because only they allow to reach the large length and time scales , which are required to capture the long structural relaxation times in shear flow with typical shear rates of @xmath0 hz .
@xcite in addition and most importantly , particle - based hydrodynamic simulation approaches naturally include thermal fluctuations , which are indispensable for a proper description of polymer entropy and entropic elasticity .
of course , coarse - grained modeling has its limitations in predicting the behavior of particular experimental systems quantitatively . here
, additional simulations of atomistic models are required to predict binding energies and bending rigidities .
this paper is organized as follows .
the simulation approaches are introduced in section [ sec2 ] .
the deformation of the polymer network under shear and rheological properties are discussed in section [ sec3 ] , and the dependence on the polymer flexibility is addressed .
relaxation of shear - induced structures is discussed as well .
section [ sec4 ] summarizes our findings .
our hybrid simulation approach combines the multiparticle collision dynamics method for the fluid with molecular dynamics simulations for the semiflexible polymers .
@xcite in the mpc method , the fluid is represented by @xmath1 point particles of mass @xmath2 , which interact with each other by a stochastic process .
@xcite the dynamics proceeds in two steps streaming and collision . in the streaming step ,
the particles move ballistically and their positions are updated according to @xmath3 here , @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the position and velocity vector of the _ _ i__th particle , and @xmath6 is the time between collisions . in the collision step , the particles are sorted into cells of a cubic lattice with lattice constant @xmath7 , and their velocities are rotated relatively to the center - of - mass velocity @xmath8 of the cell @xmath9,\ ] ] where @xmath10 is the rotation matrix for the rotation around a randomly oriented axis by the fixed angle @xmath11 .
the orientation of the axis is chosen independently for every collision cell and collision step .
a semiflexible polymer is modeled as a linear sequence of @xmath12 mass points of mass @xmath13 .
these monomers are connected by harmonic springs with bond potential @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the position of monomer @xmath16 , @xmath17 is the equilibrium bond length , and @xmath18 is the spring constant .
semiflexibility is implemented by the bending potential @xmath19 here , @xmath20 is the bending rigidity , where @xmath21 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath22 is the temperature , and @xmath23 is the persistence length .
excluded - volume interactions between monomers are taken into account by the shifted and truncated lennard - jones potential ( lj ) @xmath24 & r < { r_c } \\ 0 & r \ge { r_c } \end{array } \right . , \ ] ] where @xmath25 is the diameter of a monomer and @xmath26 is the interaction strength . aside from the polymer ends , all monomer interactions are purely repulsive , with the cutoff distance @xmath27 and the shift @xmath28 . for the attractive ends ,
the cutoff is set to @xmath29 and @xmath30 is varied according to the desired attraction strength . the polymer - solvent coupling is implemented by including the monomers in the collision step .
hence , the particle center - of - mass velocity of a cell containing monomers is @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the number of solvent and monomer particles in the cell , respectively .
@xcite we consider a cubic simulation box of side length @xmath34 . the parameters for the mpc fluid are @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and the mean number of fluid particles in a collision cell @xmath37 .
we choose the bond length @xmath38 as length unit and set for the collision - cell size @xmath39 .
moreover , we set @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 .
the latter ensures that the bond lengths remain close to the equilibrium value even under shear flow for all considered shear rates .
the equations of motion for the monomers are solved by the velocity - verlet algorithm with time step @xmath43 .
@xcite in total , 2000 polymers of length @xmath44 are considered .
approximating a polymer by a cylinder of length @xmath45 , the polymer - volume fraction is @xmath46 .
initially , the polymers are distributed randomly in the simulation box and are equilibrated without end - attraction .
then , the end - attraction is turned on and the system is again equilibrated until expectation values reach a steady state .
shear flow is imposed on equilibrium structures by lees - edwards boundary conditions , @xcite with the flow direction along the @xmath47 axis and the gradient along the @xmath48 axis of the cartesian reference system .
shear is characterized by the weissenberg number @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the shear rate and @xmath51 is the end - to - end vector relaxation time of a polymer in dilute solution .
@xcite explicitly , the values of the relaxation time are @xmath52 and @xmath53 for the persistence lengths @xmath54 and @xmath55 , respectively.@xcite in the following , we will refer to polymers with @xmath56 and @xmath55 as _ semiflexible _ and _ rodlike _ , respectively . for an efficient simulation of the polymer and mpc fluid dynamics ,
we exploit a graphics - processing - unit ( gpu ) based version of the simulation code .
@xcite and the end - attraction strengths @xmath57 .
open symbols correspond to the numbers at equilibrium without flow .
error bars display the magnitude of the fluctuation in the steady state .
the ines are guides for the eye.,width=321 ] , the end - attraction strength @xmath58 and various shear rates .
the dashed lines are fits to guide the eye , with a gaussian function for @xmath59 and an exponential function for @xmath60.,width=321 ]
for an end - end attraction strength @xmath61 , scaffold structures appear under equilibrium conditions .
@xcite this equilibrium scaffold - like network structure undergoes severe structural rearrangement under shear flow .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fgr : shear ] , where polymer configurations are shown for the persistence length @xmath56 , the end - attraction strength @xmath62 , and various shear rates . as shear flow is applied , the network breaks up and for low shear rates ( @xmath59 ) densified aggregates are formed .
the scaffold structure persists , but the network phase separates into polymer - rich and polymer - poor domains . at intermediate shear rates
@xmath63 , smaller , partially connected domains are formed , which are reminiscent to micellar structures .
@xcite finally , for high shear rates @xmath60 , the structural integrity is completely lost and polymers are aligned in a nematic - like manner along the flow direction .
the initial separation ( for @xmath64 ) into polymer - rich and polymer - poor domains appears in a similar fashion for rodlike polymers.@xcite hence , it seems to be a generic feature of such network structures .
however , the shear - induced micellar structures are only observed for more flexible polymers . here , the flow is sufficiently strong to bend the polymers and induce an attraction between the ends of the same polymer .
the nematic alignment at high shear rates is again similar to rodlike polymers .
it is caused by the shear forces and appears also for dilute solutions of flexible polymers.@xcite to characterize these structures , we determine the average coordination number @xmath65 , which is defined as the number of end - beads in proximity of each other , i.e. , within distances @xmath66 .
figure [ fgr : bond]a shows @xmath65 as a function of the shear rate for the end - attraction strengths @xmath67 and @xmath68 . for the lowest value @xmath69 , no scaffold is formed at equilibrium .
@xcite in addition , the @xmath70 is independent of shear rate , which indicates that there is no shear - induced network structure either . naturally , the polymers are aligned by the flow , in a similar fashion as non - attractive polymers .
@xcite in systems with scaffold structures , the equilibrium coordination number at zero shear exceeds that of disordered systems considerably , as discussed in more detail in ref . .
this equilibrium scaffold structure is gradually broken by the shear flow for @xmath71 , and the average coordination number decreases . the number of free ends @xmath72 , which are not adjacent to any other end - bead , increases simultaneously .
in contrast , for @xmath62 , the average coordination number first increases with increasing shear rate and passes through a maximum at @xmath73 .
this is associated with the compactification of the scaffold structure visible in fig .
[ fgr : shear ] .
the attraction is evidently so strong that the shear - induced structural changes lead to an enhanced binding of polymer ends .
the values of @xmath70 decrease rapidly with increasing shear rate for @xmath74 , and the value of an equilibrium non - attractive assembly of polymers is assumed .
simultaneously , the number of free end - beads @xmath72 increases as the shear rate increases , as shown in fig .
[ fgr : bond]b .
we present the distribution of the coordination number for various shear rates in fig .
[ fgr : bnd ] .
the dashed lines are fits to guide the eye , with a gaussian function for @xmath59 and an exponential function for @xmath75 .
evidently , nodes with a larger number of end - beads are induced at low shear rates ( @xmath59 ) compare to the distribution without flow ( @xmath76 ) . for high shear rates ( @xmath74 ) ,
the coordination number is significantly small .
corresponding mean values are shown in fig .
[ fgr : bond]a .
a qualitative similar behavior of @xmath77 is found for systems at equilibrium and various attraction strengths.@xcite for attraction strengths @xmath78 , @xmath77 decreases exponentially with increasing @xmath79 . for larger values of @xmath30 ,
a maximum of the distribution function appears , as also shown in fig .
[ fgr : bnd ] .
the exponential decay indicates the lack of a network structure either due to too weak attraction or too strong external forces . ) for the end - attraction strength @xmath62 , and different persistence lengths , ( a ) @xmath56 , @xmath80 and ( b ) @xmath81 , @xmath82 .
only beads with the slice @xmath83 are shown .
the color code corresponds to the number of adjacent ends .
( multimedia view),width=321 ] = 4.0 and the persistence lengths @xmath84.,width=321 ] between bundles for the end - attraction strength @xmath85 = 4.0 and the persistence lengths @xmath84.,width=321 ] polymer flexibility strongly affects the appearing shear - induced structures .
this is reflected in fig .
[ fgr : shear_f ] ( multimedia view ) , where structures are displayed for the persistence lengths @xmath56 and @xmath55 . for semiflexible polymers ( @xmath86 ) , the original scaffold network breaks up and micellar structures are formed .
in contrast , rodlike polymers ( @xmath87 ) are strongly aligned along the flow direction and form thick bundles , an effect already observed for various end - attraction strengths in ref . . in both cases , the end - beads assemble in nodes . for the semiflexible polymers ,
this can be achieved by significant shear - induced conformational changes of an individual polymer , which gives rise to micellar - like aggregates .
the two ends of a polymer can even meet at the same node .
@xcite this is not possible for rodlike polymers .
their two ends can only participate in two different nodes.@xcite in consequence , more dense structures are formed with well aligned rods .
the respective coordination number distributions are shown in fig .
[ fgr : bnd_f ] .
rodlike polymers form nodes with a large number of end - beads , in agreement with the thick bundles ( cf .
[ fgr : shear_f]b ) . to further characterize the shear - induced structure , fig .
[ fgr : theta_f ] presents the distribution @xmath88 of angles @xmath89 between bundles for the two different persistence lengths . here
, a bundle is defined as a connection of two neighboring nodes by two or more polymers . for semiflexible polymers ( @xmath86 ) ,
the distribution exhibits a broad peak at @xmath90 .
note that a peak at @xmath90 is a characteristics of a scaffold network , @xcite which is more pronounced in equilibrium structure without flow , @xcite while a peak at @xmath91 indicates parallel alignment of bundles along the flow direction . for rodlike polymers ( @xmath87 ) ,
the peak at @xmath91 is much more pronounced , as expected for bundles .
peaks at @xmath90 and @xmath92 are also present for rodlike polymers , which implies that the initial scaffold - like connectivity is not completely lost . , the end - attraction strength @xmath62 , and various shear rates . ,
width=340 ] ) as a function of shear rate for different persistence lengths and end - attraction strengths .
, width=321 ] in the small - strain region for the persistence length @xmath56 , the end - attraction strength @xmath62 , and various shear rates .
, width=321 ] in the small - strain region for the persistence length @xmath56 , the end - attraction strength @xmath62 , and various shear rates .
the inset shows the number including large - strain region .
, width=321 ] the structural rearrangement under shear flow affects the rheological properties of the system .
@xcite figure [ fgr : vel ] shows average monomer velocity profiles along the flow - gradient direction for @xmath56 and @xmath62 .
the flow profiles are non - monotonic for shear rates @xmath59 , which has also been observed in previous studies of rodlike polymers . @xcite the bands in the velocity profile can be understood as a consequence of the structural inhomogeneity under shear flow .
the low - shear - rate regions correspond to polymer - rich domains , where a densified network resists the applied shear .
in contrast , polymer - poor domains can flow easily , which yields high - shear - rate regions . for higher shear rates ,
the velocity profile becomes smoother and we observe a linear monotonic profile for @xmath93 . here
, the structural integrity is lost and polymers are aligned along the flow direction ( cf .
[ fgr : shear ] ) . for both , rodlike@xcite and semiflexible polymers ,
a monotonic velocity profile is observed for weak end - attraction strengths ( @xmath94 ) , where the network is either not formed or not strong enough to resist flow .
we present the polymer contribution to the shear viscosity @xmath95 as a function of shear rate in fig .
[ fgr : strall ] .
the polymer contribution to the shear stress @xmath96 is determined by the virial expression @xmath97 where the forces @xmath98 follow from the potentials of eqs .
( [ eq : eq3 ] ) , ( [ eq : eq4 ] ) , and ( [ eq : eq5 ] ) .
@xcite the viscosity is then calculated as @xmath99 . for semiflexible polymers ( @xmath56 ) ,
the viscosity increases with increasing attraction strength for all shear rates ( cf .
[ fgr : strall ] ) .
in particular , for @xmath62 , the viscosity of systems of rodlike networks ( @xmath81 ) is somewhat larger than those comprised of semiflexible polymers ( @xmath56 ) .
evidently , the rodlike nature enhances polymer end contacts , and thus , leads to more stable structures . the systems exhibit shear - thinning behavior for the range of applied shear rates , and a newtonian plateau
is observed for weak end - attraction strength ( @xmath100 ) at low shear rates .
the shear stress @xmath96 in the small - strain region @xmath101 is plotted in fig .
[ fgr : str ] for @xmath62 .
the stress increases initially in a linear manner .
the end of this elastic regime is reached at the strain @xmath102 . for larger strains , the network deforms plastically and
reaches its maximum strength for @xmath103 . for even larger strains , the stress decreases again .
the initial elastic response and yield suggests that there is no newtonian viscosity plateau for large attraction strengths . to shed light on the structural change in the vicinity of the maximum strength , we present the average coordination number as a function of strain in fig .
[ fgr : bondt ] .
initially ( @xmath104 ) , @xmath70 is constant for low shear rates ( @xmath59 ) . in this regime ,
the network structure is stable and the deformation energy is stored , i.e. , the structure behaves elastically . as strain increases , @xmath70 starts to decrease and reaches a minimum at @xmath103 , where the network structure breaks up . for @xmath105 ,
@xmath70 increases again slowly ( cf . inset of fig .
[ fgr : bondt ] ) , which implies that shear - induced aggregates form . for high shear rates ( @xmath74 ) ,
@xmath70 decreases monotonically and an asymptotic low steady - state value is assumed . here
, the network breaks up continuously as shear flow is applied . and the end - attraction strength @xmath62 .
polymers are relaxed without flow after sheared with ( a ) @xmath80 and ( b ) @xmath106
. only beads with the slice @xmath83 are shown .
the color code corresponds to the number of adjacent ends .
, width=321 ] and the end - attraction strength @xmath62 .
polymers are relaxed without flow after sheared with different shear rates .
the dashed lines are fits to guide the eye , with a gaussian function , width=321 ] in order to elucidate the uniqueness of the observed structures , we allow the shear - induced structures to relax after cessation of flow .
figure [ fgr : relx ] shows snapshots of structures after relaxation from initially sheared states for @xmath56 and @xmath62 .
shear - induced aggregates , which are formed at low shear rates ( @xmath107 ) remain after relaxation , and the initial scaffold - like network structure is not fully recovered .
when the structural connectivity is fully destroyed for larger shear rates ( @xmath108 ) , the system relaxes back to a scaffold - like network .
the coordination number distributions for the two structures are shown in fig .
[ fgr : bnd_relx ] .
in addition , the distribution of @xmath109 of the initial , non - sheared structure is displayed .
the recovered structure after high shear rates ( @xmath110 ) shows a similar distribution of the coordination number as the initial scaffold - like network . however , the coordination number is clearly larger for the relaxed structure after application of a low shear rate ( @xmath111 ) . here , a new ( equilibrium ) structure is formed , which is at least metastable . our studies of networks with weak end - attraction strengths ( @xmath94 )
reveal that the scaffold - like network structure is recovered after relaxation regardless of pre - applied shear rate .
the dependence of the network structure on the initial configuration for strong end - attraction ( @xmath112 ) has also been observed at equilibrium .
@xcite hence , care has to be taken on equilibrated state of the system .
the nonequilibrium structural and dynamical properties of end - functionalized semiflexible polymer suspensions have been investigated by mesoscale hydrodynamic simulations . under flow ,
the scaffold - like network structure of polymers breaks up and densified aggregates are formed at low shear rates , while the structural integrity is completely lost at high shear rates .
we find that network deformation is strongly affected by the polymer flexibility .
shear - induced aggregates , which are formed at low shear rates and strong end - attraction , show different structures depending on the polymer flexibility .
for semiflexible polymers , the scaffold network breaks up under shear and micellar structures are formed .
in contrast , rodlike polymers are more strongly aligned along the flow direction and form thick bundles of smectic - like stacks . for high attraction strengths @xmath113 , we find that shear - induced dense aggregates remain after relaxation , while the system relaxes back to a scaffold - like network when the structural connectivity is fully destroyed under high shear . for lower attraction strengths ,
the equilibrium structure is fully recovered .
our studies shed new light on the nonequilibrium properties of self - organized scaffold structures , specifically their formation and deformation under flow .
we expect this knowledge to be useful and provide the basis for further theoretical and experimental studies of such systems .
73ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ]
# 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.238301 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1039/c5sm01678a [ ( ) , 10.1039/c5sm01678a ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) | the nonequilibrium dynamical behavior and structure formation of end - functionalized semiflexible polymer suspensions under flow are investigated by mesoscale hydrodynamic simulations .
the hybrid simulation approach combines the multiparticle collision dynamics method for the fluid , which accounts for hydrodynamic interactions , with molecular dynamics simulations for the semiflexible polymers . in equilibrium ,
various kinds of scaffold - like network structures are observed , depending on polymer flexibility and end - attraction strength .
we investigate the flow behavior of the polymer networks under shear and analyze their nonequilibrium structural and rheological properties .
the scaffold structure breaks up and densified aggregates are formed at low shear rates , while the structural integrity is completely lost at high shear rates .
we provide a detailed analysis of the shear - rate - dependent flow - induced structures .
the studies provide a deeper understanding of the formation and deformation of network structures in complex materials . |
low - dimensional quantum systems are a formidable arena for the study of many - body physics : in one or two spatial dimensions ( 1d or 2d ) , the effects of strong correlations and interactions are enhanced and lead to dramatic effects . celebrated examples from condensed matter physics include such diverse cases as the fractionalization of charge and emergence of topological order in the quantum hall effect , high-@xmath0 superconductivity , or the breakdown of landau s fermi liquid theory in 1d , replaced by the luttinger liquid paradigm @xcite . in the past decade , breakthroughs in the field of
optically trapped ultra - cold atomic gases @xcite have lead to a new generation of quantum experiments that allow to directly observe fundamental phenomena such as quantum phase transitions @xcite and coherent quantum dynamics @xcite in low - dimensional systems , including 1d gases @xcite .
these revolutionary experiments are an ideal playground for the interplay with theory , as they allow to directly realize , in the laboratory , ideal setups that were previously regarded only as oversimplified thought experiments . on the theory side
, many exact results in 1d can be obtained by a blend of methods that comprises lattice integrability @xcite and non - perturbative field theory approaches , in particular 2d ( 1 + 1d ) conformal field theory ( cft ) @xcite and integrable field theory @xcite .
cft has been incredibly successful at making exact universal predictions for 1d condensed matter systems at a quantum critical point ; these include the kondo effect and other quantum impurity problems @xcite , and the many insights on quantum quenches @xcite as well as universal characterization of entanglement at quantum criticality @xcite .
entanglement entropies , in particular , are currently in the limelight , as they have become experimentally measurable both in- @xcite and out - of - equilibrium @xcite , opening the route to a direct comparison between experimental data and many exact analytical results obtained by cft .
indeed , entanglement entropies are usually difficult to compute in microscopic models @xcite , but their scaling limit is obtained within the powerful cft approach by solving elementary exercises on riemann surfaces @xcite . there is a caveat in the cft approach to 1d physics though : since it describes low - energy excitations around some fixed energy scale ( _ e.g. _ the fermi energy ) , cft does not accommodate strong variations of that scale throughout the system .
this rules out _ a priori _ the possibility of tackling _ inhomogeneous _
systems , in which the relevant energy scale varies .
this caveat is important , as inhomogeneous systems are the rule rather than the exception in the realm of quantum experiments : quantum gases at equilibrium always lie in trapping potentials ( often harmonic ) and therefore usually come with a non - uniform density ; this is also the case of many out - of - equilibrium situations , such as trap releases . in this paper , we make one step forward .
we focus on the example of the free fermi gas , in a few illustrative in- and out - of - equilibrium inhomogeneous situations .
the free fermi gas is technically simpler than interacting models , and yet it allows to draw interesting lessons that will hold more generally .
we find that the varying energy scale is taken into account rather naturally in the effective field theory , in the form of varying parameters in the action .
interestingly , the _ metric _ is one such parameter , so one generically ends up with a cft in curved 2d space .
these conclusions are very general and hold under the reasonable assumption of separation of scales : there must exist an intermediate scale @xmath1 which is simultaneously large compared to the microscopic scale ( the inter - particle distance @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the density ) , but small compared to the scale on which physical quantities vary macroscopically ( of order @xmath4 ) . indeed , at the intermediate scale @xmath1 , the system is well described by continuous fields because @xmath5 , and is locally homogeneous because @xmath6 , so one knows that it corresponds to a standard ( i.e. flat - space , translation - invariant ) field theory .
from there , it is clear that unravelling the global theory for the _ inhomogeneous _ system is a problem of geometric nature : it is about understanding the global geometric data ( _ e.g. _ metric tensor , coupling constants , gauge fields , _ etc .
_ ) that enter the action .
this is the program we illustrate with the few simple examples below .
we demonstrate the power of this formalism by providing new exact asymptotic formulas for entanglement entropies .
let us start by considering a free fermi gas in 1d @xmath7 c(x ) , \ ] ] in the absence of an external potential , i.e. @xmath8 . for the reader s convenience , we briefly review the well known relation between this ( homogeneous ) 1d system and the cft of massless dirac fermions in 2d euclidean space - time .
the question is : _ what is the proper field theory framework that captures the behavior of long - range correlations of arbitrary local observables @xmath9 _ ? here and below , the @xmath10-coordinate is imaginary time .
the starting point to answer this question is the ground - state propagator @xmath11 } , \ ] ] where @xmath12 is the dispersion relation and @xmath13 is the fermi momentum .
its large distance behavior is obtained by linearizing the dispersion relation around the two fermi points @xmath14 , @xmath15 with fermi velocity @xmath16 .
one finds straightforwardly , for @xmath17 , @xmath18 } \\
% \nonumber & \simeq & \int_{-\infty}^{k_f } \frac{dk}{2\pi } e^{- i \left [ k x + i ( k - k_{\rm f } ) v_{\rm f } y \right ] } + \int_{-k_f}^{\infty } \frac{dk}{2\pi } e^{- i \left [ k x - i ( k+k_{\rm f } ) v_{\rm f } y \right ] } \\ & = & \frac{i}{2\pi } \left [ \frac{e^ { - i k_{\rm f } x } } { x + i v_{\rm f } y } - \frac{e^ { i k_{\rm f } x } } { x - i v_{\rm f } y } \right ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] these two terms coincide with the right(r)-/left(l)-components of a massless dirac fermion in 2d euclidean spacetime , @xmath19 , that derive from the action ( with @xmath20 ) : @xmath21 .\ ] ] the action ( [ eq : dirac_flat ] ) is invariant under conformal transformations @xmath22 , @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is a holomorphic function of @xmath25 . the phase factors in ( [ eq : prop_transl ] ) may be incorporated into ( [ eq : dirac_flat ] ) with a chiral gauge transformation @xmath26 .
here we do not keep track of these phase factors , as they are unimportant for our purposes , and simply discard them ; these aspects are discussed in appendix [ app:1 ] . from wick s theorem
, it then follows that the large - scale behavior of arbitrary multi - point correlations of the original fermions can be obtained from correlators in the massless dirac theory .
consider the fermi gas ( [ eq : fermi_gas ] ) in a harmonic potential @xmath27 .
we ask : _ what is the underlying dirac action _ ?
the system is now _ inhomogeneous _ , so there should be parameters in the effective action that vary with position .
but _ what are these parameters _ in ( [ eq : dirac_flat ] ) ? in order to understand this , one needs to find the density profile first .
the latter is obtained from the exact solution of the microscopic problem in the thermodynamic limit , which in this case is extremely simple .
the single - particle eigenstates are just those of the harmonic oscillator , and the many - body ground state is obtained by simply filling up all eigenstates with negative energies . in the thermodynamic limit ( @xmath28 ) , the density profile follows the wigner semicircle law @xmath29 which is non - vanishing in the interval @xmath30 $ ] with @xmath31 . here and in the following , we set @xmath32 .
the total number of particles is @xmath33 .
away from the edges @xmath34 , there is an intermediate scale @xmath1 such that @xmath35 . at this scale
, the system can be viewed as homogeneous , with a local fermi momentum @xmath36 : in a window of width @xmath37 around the position @xmath38 , the system consists of all states filled in the interval @xmath39 $ ] .
thus , around a point @xmath40 \times \mathbb{r}$ ] in spacetime , the behaviour of the propagator must be the same as in the translation - invariant gas with @xmath41 : @xmath42 \ , , \quad\ ] ] where @xmath43 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 is its complex conjugate .
like in ( [ eq : prop_transl ] ) , we would like to view the terms @xmath46 as the r-/l - components of a massless dirac field . of course
, in the neighborhood of @xmath47 , one can always do that .
but the real question is : _ is there a consistent dirac theory defined globally on the entire domain @xmath48 \times \mathbb{r}$ ] , such that its propagator has the required local behavior everywhere _ ?
if the reader is familiar with quantum field theories in curved background , they will probably have guessed that eq .
( [ eq : prop_local_harm ] ) is , in fact , related to the propagator of the massless dirac fermion _ in curved space_. the action of the latter theory in 2d is @xmath49,\ ] ] written in isothermal coordinates @xmath50 and in a fixed frame ( see appendix [ app:1 ] for all details ) .
the underlying riemannian metric is @xmath51 to connect this theory to eq .
( [ eq : prop_local_harm ] ) , notice that , in the coordinate @xmath25 , the propagator behaves locally as @xmath52 thus , to prove that eq .
( [ eq : prop_local_harm ] ) is the propagator of a dirac fermion in a curved metric , it is sufficient to exhibit a map @xmath53 such that @xmath54 for some real - valued function @xmath55 .
this equation can be solved easily .
first , notice that it is equivalent to @xmath56 , @xmath57 .
writing that @xmath58 , we find a constraint on @xmath59 : @xmath60 . looking for a solution that is independent of @xmath10 , we can set @xmath61 , which implies @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
the solution is straightforward : up to an additive constant , we find the complex coordinate system @xmath64 , which lives on the infinite strip @xmath65 \times \mathbb{r}$ ] : @xmath66 this fixes the underlying geometry of the problem .
to illustrate the power of this approach , we exhibit new exact results for the entanglement entropies of the fermi gas in external trapping potentials .
such calculations are , in general , difficult . but within the framework we just developed , they boil down to elementary manipulations of complex analytic functions .
the renyi entanglement entropies of a subsystem @xmath67 are defined as @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the reduced density matrix of @xmath67 and @xmath70 is an arbitrary real number . for @xmath71
, @xmath72 reduces to the von neumann entropy of the subsystem which is usually referred to as entanglement entropy .
the main property we will use in the following is that the renyi entanglement entropies are related to the expectation values of the twist fields @xmath73 @xcite which under conformal mapping share the same transformation properties of primaries with dimension @xmath74 with @xmath75 the central charge of the cft ( @xmath76 for the free fermi gas ) .
let us now apply eqs .
( [ eq : metric])-([eq : coordinates_harm ] ) to the problem of calculating the entanglement entropy in a harmonic trap .
we start with the case of a bipartition @xmath77 consisting of two semi - infinite systems , @xmath78 $ ] , @xmath79 $ ] . in a homogeneous system ,
the renyi entanglement entropy is @xcite @xmath80 @xmath81 is a uv cutoff , sometimes dismissed in homogeneous systems , because it simply appears in the form of a non - universal constant offset . in _
inhomogeneous _ situations , however , it is crucial to have a closer look at this cutoff : since the energy scale changes throughout the system , why should nt @xmath81 vary as well ? and , if @xmath82 varies , then it must obviously affect the dependence of @xmath72 on @xmath38 . and indeed , there is a good reason why @xmath81 should vary with position : the continuous fermi gas is locally galilean invariant , and the only relevant microscopic scale is the inverse density @xmath83 , or equivalently @xmath84 .
so the uv cutoff must simply be proportional to that scale : @xmath85 , for some dimensionless constant @xmath86 .
coming back to the harmonic potential , we now make use of the coordinate system @xmath87 , with @xmath88 .
the conformal mapping @xmath89 maps the @xmath90strip to the upper half plane . to evaluate @xmath91
, we first perform a weyl transformation @xmath92 , which changes @xmath91 into @xmath93 .
next , we notice that , under the conformal mapping @xmath94 from the strip onto the upper half - plane , @xmath95 becomes @xmath96 . the latter factor , which is the one - point function in the upper half - plane , is equal to @xmath97 . putting everything together ,
@xmath98 hence , using eq .
( [ seps ] ) with @xmath85 , we finally have for the entanglement entropy @xmath99 } % \ , + \ ,
o(1 ) .
s_{n } \ , = \ , \frac{n+1}{12 \,n } \ln \bigg [ k_f(x)\ , e^{\sigma ( z,\bar{z } ) } \ , \left| \frac{dg(z)}{dz } \right|^{-1 } \ , { \rm i m } \,g(z ) \bigg],\ ] ] up to an additive constant and subleading corrections , which we systematically drop from now on .
this gives @xmath100 .%\
, + \ , o(1).\ ] ] a more complicated bipartition @xmath77 that can be considered in our framework is @xmath101 $ ] and @xmath102 \cup [ x_2 , + \infty]$ ] , where @xmath103 .
the calculation is straightforward , but rather cumbersome and so we report it in appendix [ app : finite ] .
the final result , setting @xmath104 , can be written as @xmath105 , % \ , + \ , o(1 ) \ , , \ ] ] which is a highly non - trivial generalization of recent results ( for @xmath106 ) obtained by means of random matrix theory @xcite .
we checked the validity of this formula against exact finite size computations for lattice and continuous fermi gases using the approaches of refs .
@xcite . of particles
so as to have a finite density inside each well
. our analytic prediction for the entanglement entropy is checked against numerical data for @xmath107 : the agreement is excellent , and improves further when increasing @xmath108 .
inset : in phase space , the quasi - classical orbitals are equipotentials enclosing an area that is an integer multiple of @xmath109 . , scaledwidth=80.0% ] the generalization to arbitrary @xmath110 is very simple , even though the single particle problem is not always exactly solvable for a general potential .
indeed , we are always interested in the thermodynamic limit , where the single particle states that matter are those up in the spectrum , and for which the semi - classical approximation becomes _
exact_. thus , focusing on the thermodynamic limit ( @xmath28 ) , we proceed as follows : semi - classically , the single - particle eigenstates correspond to the equipotentials @xmath111 that satisfy the bohr - sommerfeld quantization rule . to get the many - body ground state ,
one simply fills up all eigenstates with negative energies .
the equipotentials can be locally parametrized as @xmath112 , where @xmath113 the position - dependent fermi velocity is @xmath114 .
the metric that underlies the problem is @xmath115 , one can obtain a complex coordinate system on the worldsheet just like before ; the result for a general potential @xmath110 reads @xmath116 notice that the real part of @xmath117 is the time that a massless excitation takes to arrive at point @xmath38 , starting from some reference point @xmath118 with @xmath119 .
the coordinate @xmath25 always lives on an infinite strip @xmath120 \times \mathbb{r}$ ] , whose width @xmath121 depends on @xmath110 and @xmath122 , and which can be conformally mapped onto the upper half - plane by @xmath123 .
correlation functions are then evaluated exactly as in the harmonic case above .
formula ( [ eq : s_kf ] ) holds , and can be used to derive new exact results for the entanglement entropy .
for instance , considering @xmath124 one recovers the results from the so - called trap size scaling @xcite .
one example that , to the best of our knowledge , can not be solved with other means is that of a double well potential @xmath125 in fig .
[ fig1 ] we compare some exact finite size calculations for this potential with our novel prediction .
the figure shows that ( apart from well - known finite size oscillations @xcite ) exact numerical results match perfectly our cft prediction .
we now show how the above framework can be adapted to deal with out - of - equilibrium situations .
the most natural problem to attack is the fermi gas ( [ eq : fermi_gas ] ) released from a harmonic trap .
however , this problem may be solved by other methods , and it is known , for instance , that various observables obey a dynamical symmetry @xcite , including the entanglement entropy @xcite .
this symmetry relates time - dependent quantities to their time - independent , ground - state , counterpart , simply by rescaling the coordinate @xmath38 to @xmath126 .
since the dynamical symmetry allows to deal with this problem in an efficient way , it is not the most illustrative example for our purposes . instead
, we turn to a lattice gas , released from a semi - infinite box : the initial state is such that all sites @xmath127 are filled , and all sites @xmath128 are empty ( this is also known as a quench from a domain wall initial state @xcite ) . at @xmath129 , one lets the system evolve with the hamiltonian @xmath130 \ , .\ ] ] in fourier space the hamiltonian is ( up to an additive constant ) @xmath131 with dispersion relation @xmath132 . is defined as ( [ eq : densitydef ] ) .
green colors correspond to a density close to one , blue to a density close to zero . in both cases
the system is said to be `` frozen '' : observables do not fluctuate at all .
intermediate colors correspond to finite densities , and have non trivial fluctuations .
the fluctuating region is a disk of radius @xmath133 , with density given by ( [ eq : densitydef]).,width=453 ] the relevant regime for an effective field theory description is that of large distances and late times , in a way such that the ratio @xmath134 is kept finite . in this limit
the density profile at time @xmath135 is @xcite @xmath136 again , the question we want to answer is : _ what is the effective theory that captures long - range correlators @xmath137 in this inhomogeneous system ? _ we expect that it should be a ( lorentzian ) dirac theory in curved 1 + 1d spacetime .
there are technical issues , however , associated with the lorentzian formulation of the problem for instance , the metric would be degenerate , @xmath138 , and there would be no clear distinction between right- and left - movers , so we chose to look at the problem in imaginary time , as routinely done in quench problems in cft @xcite . in this imaginary time approach to quantum quenches ,
the initial state becomes a boundary condition on the two sides of an infinite strip of width @xmath139 in imaginary time direction @xmath10 @xcite .
real - time correlators are recovered by first performing a wick rotation @xmath140 , and then sending @xmath141 .
we focus on correlators @xmath142 , where @xmath143 $ ] ( see fig .
[ fig : arctic ] for the application to the domain wall quench ) .
for example , the imaginary - time density profile is @xcite @xmath144 which gives back the real - time profile ( [ rhoreal ] ) after performing the wick rotation @xmath145 and taking the limit @xmath146 .
the density is different from zero or one only inside the disc @xmath147 ; thus , there is a phase separation phenomenon , known as _ arctic circle _ @xcite .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig : arctic ] . in ref .
@xcite , the field theory that describes long - range correlations inside the disc was unraveled : it is a dirac theory in curved space , with euclidean metric @xmath148 once we know this , it is again a straightforward exercise in cft to compute correlation functions . as an illustration , we calculate again the entanglement entropy , for the bipartition @xmath149 with @xmath150 $ ] , @xmath79 $ ] at times @xmath151 ( without loss of generality we assume @xmath152 ) .
this can be done by performing elementary manipulations similar to those of sec .
[ sec : eeharmtrap ] the main difference with the previous calculation is that , due to the presence of a finite lattice spacing , eq . needs to be modified .
namely , the position - dependent cut - off is no longer simply proportional to @xmath153 . in the _ homogeneous _ problem ,
it is known from the exact lattice solution @xcite that the cut - off enters the formula for the renyi entropies as @xmath154 , instead of @xmath153 in the continuous gas . as a consequence of separation of scales , in the inhomogeneous case
, we thus need to replace the local cut - off @xmath155 in eq . by @xmath156 .
this leads to the following formula for the renyi entropies in imaginary time , @xmath157.\ ] ] here the complex coordinate @xmath158 must be compatible with the conformal structure of the metric ( [ eq : metric_arctic ] ) , _ i.e. _ one must have @xmath159 , for some function @xmath160 .
both @xmath25 and @xmath160 are given in ref .
@xcite , @xmath161 the function @xmath162 maps the interior of the disc @xmath147 , namely the interior of the critical region in the @xmath47 plane , onto the infinite strip @xmath163\times\mathbb r$ ] . the strip itself can be sent to the upper half plane by the conformal map @xmath164 . finally , recalling that @xcite @xmath165=\arccos \frac{x}{\sqrt{r^2-y^2 } } \,,\ ] ] elementary algebraic manipulations and the use of lead to the following expression for the renyi entropies in imaginary time @xmath166.\ ] ] the analytic continuation to real time is obtained by first substituting @xmath167 , and then sending @xmath168 .
this gives @xmath169 \ , , \ ] ] a formula which was guessed from numerics in ref .
@xcite , and was calling for an analytic derivation .
we just provided this derivation , which crucially relies on the metric ( [ eq : metric_arctic ] ) that underlies the whole problem . in figure
[ fig2 ] , we report a comparison of this prediction with numerical data and the agreement is perfect , up to the usual finite - size effects .
the entanglement entropy for other bipartitions can be calculated as well , but the resulting formulas are more complicated and are therefore deferred to the appendix [ app : dwfinite ] .
we mention that it is also possible to study different dispersion relations , but the results are rather technical ; they are reported in appendix [ app : dispersion ] .
after a quench from the domain wall initial state .
the numerical simulations are performed using a finite system with @xmath170 sites .
data for @xmath171 are reported ( black circles ) and compared to our analytical prediction ( red line ) : the agreement is nearly perfect .
inset : corresponding density profile @xmath172 after the quench.,scaledwidth=60.0% ]
inhomogeneous 1d quantum systems are difficult to tackle and this is motivating an enormous activity in order to provide exact results in some regimes , as for example the recently developed integrable hydrodynamics @xcite ( anticipated in @xcite ) which may have important ramifications into transport in 1d systems @xcite such as quantum wires . to shed some light on these timely problems ,
we have shown here , with a few free fermion examples , that cft methods may be extended to attack this class of problems .
the key assumption of our work is separation of scales : the system is locally homogeneous ( but only locally ) , which is also the working limit of all approaches constructed so far @xcite . in this regime
, one can write a field theory action with varying parameters . in the examples tackled in this paper
, we found that the metric tensor should vary , leading to cft in curved space .
in particular , this new approach allows us to compute in a simple manner the entanglement entropies of these inhomogeneous systems ( both in- and out - of - equilibrium ) which are otherwise very difficult ( in most cases impossible ) to obtain with other methods .
it is important to stress that the background metric and the inhomogeneous cut - off are non - universal functions and must be viewed as _
inputs _ of the formalism .
they should be obtained a priori by a proper microscopic computation .
we believe anyway that the results of this paper should open the door to several new developments .
for example , by following the cft approach of ref .
@xcite , our method could be used not only to determine the entanglement entropy , but also the entanglement negativity which is a proper measure of entanglement in mixed states @xcite and it is not yet known how to compute it exactly for free fermionic systems .
another interesting development would be to recover by random matrix techniques @xcite the results we obtained for the entanglement entropy in a harmonic potential , possibly unveiling new structures of the random matrices . having exact results also for arbitrary trapping potential could also help understanding whether these general cases could be tackled by random matrix techniques . from a physical point of view , the main open problem is how to describe inhomogeneous interacting 1d systems , most importantly luttinger liquids such as heisenberg spin chains and lieb - liniger gases . in these cases ,
one expects also the coupling constant ( or luttinger parameter @xmath173 ) to vary with position in spacetime .
fixing such parameters is a challenging problem .
we hope that this paper will stimulate activity in that direction .
we thank nicolas allegra and masud haque for collaboration on closely related topics @xcite , and viktor eisler for useful discussions .
[ [ funding - information ] ] funding information + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this work was supported partially by the erc under starting grant 279391 edeqs ( pc ) , and by the cnrs interdisciplinary mission and rgion lorraine ( jd ) .
jd , jms , and jv thank sissa for hospitality .
here we explain the form of the dirac action in a curved space - time , that was used in the main text .
the most generic form of the dirac action in a curved two - dimensional eulidean space - time is given by @xmath174,\ ] ] where we chose @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 and @xmath178 .
the @xmath179 are the usual pauli matrices . in this representation
the two components of the spinor @xmath180 are the chiral components @xmath181 and @xmath182 ; the function @xmath183 and @xmath184 are the vector and axial gauge field associated with the @xmath185 gauge symmetry and the ( anomalous ) chiral symmetry . the matrix @xmath186 is called a tetrad : it maps the tangent space of the manifold into @xmath187 while preserving the inner product .
it satisfies @xmath188 , where @xmath189 is the metric tensor and @xmath190 the flat metric . in two dimensions , it is convenient to use complex coordinates @xmath191 and @xmath192 . the metric is conformally flat and off - diagonal , the line element thus reads @xmath193 .
the tetrad is diagonal if one chooses complex coordinates both in the tangent space and in @xmath187 .
its only non - vanishing components are complex conjugated and have with modulus @xmath194 .
using finally @xmath195 we can then rewrite the dirac action in complex coordinates as @xmath196\psi_r+ \frac{1}{2\pi}\int d^2z~e^{\sigma - i\theta}[\psi_l^{\dagger}(\stackrel{\leftrightarrow}{\partial_{z}}+i\bar{a}^{(v)}-i\bar{a}^{(a)})]\psi_l,\ ] ] where @xmath197 and @xmath198 are the complex @xmath199 components of the vector and axial potential .
the rotation of angle @xmath200 in between the tangent space of the manifold and the flat euclidean space does not alter any of the conformal maps discussed in the main text .
this holds because the twist fields needed to compute the entropy are spinless@xcite .
the extra phase factors in the fermionic propagators may be restored by performing a @xmath185 gauge transformation and a chiral transformation .
the former acts on the chiral fermions as @xmath201 , and on the gauge field as @xmath202 , @xmath203 ; the chiral transformation instead acts as @xmath204 , and the gauge fields get modified as @xmath205 and @xmath206 .
the entropies of a finite interval @xmath207 $ ] are slightly more complicated to calculate than the case of the semi - infinite line ( cf . eq . ( [ eq : s_harm ] ) ) . following ref .
@xcite , the renyi entanglement entropy of order @xmath70 is related to the two - point function of the twist field @xmath73 on the desired geometry . here
we work out the generalization to inhomogeneous systems and in particular for the case of fermions in a harmonic trap . in this case , the two - point function can be related to the one of the upper half plane by the combined action of a weil transformation and the conformal mapping @xmath208 from the strip @xmath65\times \mathbb{r}$ ] to the upper half - plane .
this allows us to write such two - point function in the @xmath25 coordinate as @xmath209 the field @xmath210 is the conjugated twist field @xcite .
the calculation of two - point functions of twist fields in the upper half plane is , in general , a very challenging problem ( indeed by images trick , it can be turned into a four point function in the complex plane which have been considered e.g. in refs .
however , in the case of the massless free fermion field - theory , this two - point function in the half plane simplifies considerably and our desired object boils down to @xcite ( up to unimportant multiplicative constants ) @xmath211^{\delta_n}.\ ] ] in our setup @xmath212 and @xmath213 . using again @xmath208 and ( [ eq : coordinates_harm ] ) , we obtain @xmath214 , \label{harm - int}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath215 is given in eq .
( [ eq : s_harm ] ) .
this is the result reported in the main text . for the case of a finite interval ,
the renyi entanglement entropy are easily obtained by using eq . and
the conformal mapping from the strip @xmath163\times \mathbb{r}$ ] to the upper half - plane @xmath164 . setting @xmath216 ( i.e. equal imaginary times ) and using ( [ eq : zimag ] ) , we get @xmath217.\end{gathered}\ ] ] analytically continuing the result to real time and using the rescaled variables @xmath218 we obtain @xmath219.\ ] ] this formula is valid in the regime @xmath220 . notice that this is very similar to eq .
( [ harm - int ] ) , and indeed it has the same dependence of the rescaled variables @xmath221
. however , the leading dimensional term in one case scales like @xmath222 while in the other as @xmath223 ( times @xmath224 in both cases ) .
this is somehow reminiscent of a similar anomalous scaling found in local quenches @xcite and it is unclear whether there is a connection between the two .
here we come back to the entropy of a single interval @xmath225 $ ] following a domain wall quench , but with a more general dispersion relation .
we consider hamiltonian with a dispersion relation of the form @xmath226 which contains only odd fourier modes .
the reason for choosing this special form is mainly technical . as we shall see it makes explicit computations much simpler due to the symmetries @xmath227 and @xmath228 . in real time
the stationary phase equation governing the long time dynamics is@xcite @xmath229 and may be used to compute systematically all correlation functions .
now , due to the form ( [ eq : dispersion ] ) , if @xmath230 is a solution , then so is @xmath231 . in the following we will assume that there are at most two solutions @xmath230 and @xmath231 to the previous equation . under these assumptions ,
the density profile is @xmath232 as is emphasized in the main text and above , it is convenient to think of this problem in imaginary time . the stationary phase equation for the imaginary time problem reads@xcite @xmath233 with @xmath234 the hilbert transform of @xmath235 .
in case there are only a finite number of fourier modes in the dispersion , solving ( [ eq : imstatphase ] ) amounts to solving algebraic equations in @xmath236 , which can be done in principle systematically .
now we make the extra assumption that there are only two solutions @xmath237 and @xmath238 . the new variable @xmath25 lives in an infinite strip @xmath239 .
the metric then reads @xmath240 the conformal distance to the boundary may be obtained by mapping the infinite strip to the upper half plane .
such a mapping is once again provided by @xmath164 , so we obtain @xmath241 separating the real and imaginary parts @xmath242 , the above reads @xmath243 where @xmath244 and @xmath245 satisfy the system of equations @xmath246 & = & x,\\\label{eq : genstatphase2 } \sum_n ( 2n+1 ) a_{2n+1 } \sin ( 2n+1)\kappa \left[y\cosh ( 2n+1)q+r\sinh(2n+1)q\right ] & = & 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the reasoning to get the entanglement entropy should be clear at this point :
first we get @xmath244 and @xmath245 from the above set of equations , and then we use them to compute the conformal distance to be plugged in the appropriate equation for the entropy .
for example in the case of the standard cosine dispersion relation , using this procedure , we find the already known result @xmath247 , which can then be continued to real time @xmath248 .
it is important to stress that the concept of conformal distance only makes sense in imaginary time : in principle only after computing @xmath249 in imaginary time we are allowed to make the analytic continuation to real time . in practice
, one can avoid finding the general solution of the above system of equations .
indeed , because of their analytic structure , we can perform the analytic continuation at the level of eqs .
( [ eq : genstatphase1 ] ) and ( [ eq : genstatphase2 ] ) , relaxing the requirement that @xmath244 and @xmath245 are real .
plugging @xmath250 and taking the limit @xmath168 , we find that @xmath251 is a trivial solution to ( [ eq : genstatphase2 ] ) , due to the absence of even fourier modes .
the variable @xmath244 is then the solution of @xmath252 = v(\kappa+\pi/2),\ ] ] and so we get @xmath253 .
the analytic continuation of the conformal distance becomes @xmath254 putting back the contribution from the uv cutoff , @xmath255 , we finally obtain @xmath256 let us briefly comment on the case with more than two solutions to the stationary phase equation ( [ eq : realstatphase ] ) . with the form ( [ eq : dispersion ] ) of the dispersion
they always come in pairs . we label them as @xmath257 and @xmath258 for @xmath259 .
@xmath260 may be interpreted as a number of fermi seas . as before we compute the entanglement entropy using field theory , and add to this the contribution coming from the position - dependent uv cutoff .
the generalization of our field - theoretical framework to account for several fermi seas is straightforward : we simply introduce @xmath260 different species of dirac fermions , one for each fermi sea ( pair of stationary modes ) .
being non - interacting particles , all the dirac species contribute independently to the entanglement entropy . obtaining
the position - dependent cutoff is more tricky , but can nevertheless be done using exact equilibrium results obtained for several fermi seas .
we refer to ref .
@xcite for the details .
the lattice cutoff takes now the more complicated form @xmath261 the final result for the entropy reads @xmath262 after a quench from the domain wall initial state , for dispersion relation @xmath263 and @xmath264 .
he numerical simulations are performed using a finite system with @xmath170 sites .
data for @xmath171 are reported ( black circles ) and compared to our analytical prediction ( red lines ) : the agreement is nearly perfect .
inset : corresponding density profile @xmath172 after the quench.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] let us now work out an example where the formula ( [ eq : main ] ) may be computed explicitely .
we consider a dispersion of the form @xmath265 the restriction on @xmath266 ensures that there are at most two solutions to the stationary phase equation , @xmath230 and @xmath231 .
@xmath267 may be obtained by solving a cubic equation : @xmath268,\qquad b(x , t)=\sqrt{9\alpha(x / t)^2+(1-\alpha)^3}-3\sqrt{\alpha}(x / t).\ ] ] the density profile in the inhomogeneous region @xmath269 is then given by @xmath270,\ ] ] and the entropy is obtained by plugging ( [ eq : statsolution ] ) in ( [ eq : main ] ) . in fig .
[ figapp ] we report the numerical data for the von neumann entanglement entropy for the dispersion relation with @xmath271 : this shows perfect agreement with our prediction .
b. paredes , a. widera , v. murg , o. mandel , s. folling , i. cirac , g. v. shlyapnikov , t. w. hnsch , and i. bloch , _ tonks - girardeau gas of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice _ ,
nature * 429 * , 277 ( 2004 ) , .
g. pagano , m. mancini , g. cappellini , p. lombardi , f. schafer , h. hu , x .- j .
liu , j. catani , c. sias , m. inguscio , and l. fallani , _ a one - dimensional liquid of fermions with tunable spin _ , nature phys .
* 10 * , 198 ( 2014 ) , .
p. calabrese and j. cardy , _ entanglement entropy and quantum field theory _
, j. stat .
p06002 ( 2004 ) , ; + p. calabrese and j. cardy , _ entanglement entropy and conformal field theory _
, j. phys .
a * 42 * , 504005 ( 2009 ) , .
v. knizhnik , _ analytic fields on riemann surfaces .
ii _ , communications in mathematical physics , vol . 112 , no .
567 - 590 ( 1987 ) , ; + l. dixon , d. friedan , e. martinec , and s. shenker , _ the conformal field theory of orbifolds _ , nuclear physics b , vol . 282 , pp .
13 - 73 ( 1987 ) , i. peschel and v. eisler , _ reduced density matrices and entanglement entropy in free lattice models _ ,
a * 42 * , 504003 ( 2009 ) , ; + i. peschel , _ calculation of reduced density matrices from correlation functions _
a * 36 * , l205 ( 2003 ) , .
p. calabrese , m. mintchev , and e. vicari , _ entanglement entropy of one - dimensional gases _
lett . * 107 * , 020601 ( 2011 ) , ; + p. calabrese , m. mintchev , and e. vicari , _ the entanglement entropy of one - dimensional systems in continuous and homogeneous space _ , j. stat .
p09028 ( 2011 ) , .
m. campostrini and e. vicari , _ equilibrium and off - equilibrium trap - size scaling in one - dimensional ultracold bosonic gases _ , phys .
a * 82 * , 063636 ( 2010 ) , ; + m. campostrini and e. vicari , _ quantum critical behavior and trap - size scaling of trapped bosons in a one - dimensional optical lattice _ , phys .
a * 81 * , 063614 ( 2010 ) , ; + m. campostrini and e. vicari , _ scaling of bipartite entanglement in one - dimensional lattice systems with a trapping potential _ , j. stat .
mech . p08020 ( 2010 ) , .
n. laflorencie , e. s. sorensen , m .- s .
chang , and i. affleck , _ boundary effects in the critical scaling of entanglement entropy in 1d systems _ , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 100603 ( 2006 ) , ; + p. calabrese , m. campostrini , f. essler and b. nienhuis , _ parity effect in the scaling of block entanglement in gapless spin chains _ , phys .
lett * 104 * , 095701 ( 2010 ) , ; + j. cardy and p. calabrese , _ unusual corrections to scaling in entanglement entropy _
, j. stat .
p04023 ( 2010 ) , ; + m. fagotti and p. calabrese , _ universal parity effects in the entanglement entropy of xx chains with open boundary conditions _ , j. stat . mech .
p01017 ( 2011 ) , .
a. minguzzi and d. m. gangardt , _ exact coherent states of a harmonically confined tonks - girardeau gas _ , phys .
94 * , 240404 ( 2005 ) , ; + a. polkovnikov and v. gritsev , _ breakdown of the adiabatic limit in low - dimensional gapless systems _ , nature phys . * 4 * , 477 ( 2008 ) , .
m. collura , s. sotiriadis , and p. calabrese , equilibration of a tonks - girardeau gas following a trap release , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 245301 ( 2013 ) ; + m. collura , s. sotiriadis , and p. calabrese , quench dynamics of a tonks girardeau gas released from a harmonic trap , j. stat . mech .
( 2013 ) p09025 .
t. antal , z. rcz , a. rkos , and g. schtz , _ transport in the xx chain at zero temperature : emergence of flat magnetization profiles _
e * 59 * , 4912 ( 1999 ) , .
m. rigol and a. muramatsu , _ emergence of quasicondensates of hard - core bosons at finite momentum _
( 93 ) , 230404 ( 2004 ) , .
d. gobert , k. kollath , u. schollwck and g. schtz , _ real - time dynamics in spin-1/2 chains with adaptive time - dependent density matrix renormalization group _
e 71 , 036102 ( 2005 ) , .
t. antal , p. l. krapivsky , and a. rkos , _ logarithmic current fluctuations in nonequilibrium quantum spin chains _ , phys .
e 78 , 061115 ( 2008 ) , .
t. sabetta and g. misguich , _ nonequilibrium steady states in the quantum xxz spin chain _ , phys . rev .
b 88 , 245114 ( 2013 ) , .
j. viti , j .-
stphan , j. dubail and m. haque , _ inhomogeneous quenches in a free fermionic chain : exact results _ , epl * 115 * , 40011 ( 2016 ) , .
p. calabrese and j. cardy , _ time dependence of correlation functions following a quantum quench _
lett . * 96 * , 136801 ( 2006 ) , ; + p. calabrese and j. cardy , _ quantum quenches in extended systems _ , j. stat .
p06008 ( 2007 ) , ; + p. calabrese and j. cardy , _ evolution of entanglement entropy in one - dimensional systems _
, j. stat .
p04010 ( 2005 ) , .
d. bernard and b. doyon , _ conformal field theory out of equilibrium : a review _ , j. stat .
mech ( 2016 ) 064005 , .
p. calabrese , j. cardy , and e. tonni , _ entanglement negativity in quantum field theory _
lett . * 109 * , 130502 ( 2012 ) , ; + p. calabrese , j. cardy , and e. tonni , _ entanglement negativity in extended systems : a quantum field theory approach _
, j. stat .
p02008 ( 2013 ) , .
p. calabrese , j. cardy , and e. tonni , _ entanglement entropy of two disjoint intervals in conformal field theory _
, j. stat .
p11001 ( 2009 ) , ; + p. calabrese , j. cardy , and e. tonni , _ entanglement entropy of two disjoint intervals in conformal field theory ii _
, j. stat .
p01021 ( 2011 ) , .
p. calabrese and j. cardy , _ entanglement and correlation functions following a local quench : a conformal field theory approach _
, j. stat .
p10004 ( 2007 ) , ; + j .-
stphan and j. dubail , _ local quantum quenches in critical one - dimensional systems : entanglement , the loschmidt echo , and light - cone effects _ , j. stat .
mech . p08019 ( 2011 ) , . | * conformal field theory ( cft ) has been extremely successful in describing large - scale universal effects in one - dimensional ( 1d ) systems at quantum critical points .
unfortunately , its applicability in condensed matter physics has been limited to situations in which the bulk is uniform because cft describes low - energy excitations around some energy scale , taken to be constant throughout the system . however , in many experimental contexts , such as quantum gases in trapping potentials and in several out - of - equilibrium situations , systems are strongly inhomogeneous .
we show here that the powerful cft methods can be extended to deal with such 1d situations , providing a few concrete examples for non - interacting fermi gases .
the system s inhomogeneity enters the field theory action through parameters that vary with position ; in particular , the metric itself varies , resulting in a cft in curved space .
this approach allows us to derive exact formulas for entanglement entropies which were not known by other means . * ' '' '' ' '' '' |
we live in interesting times . in the world of high energy and nuclear physics the relativistic heavy ion collider ( rhic ) at brookhaven national laboratory is beginning its search into the new realm of high temperatures and low but nonzero chemical potentials .
these experiments will surprise us .
experiments have a habit of doing that .
they humble us .
they will show us new directions .
they will make this talk obsolete .
i want to emphasize that lattice gauge theory , which has become an evolutionary rather than a revolutionary field , should take a more active part in these developments .
it should rise to the challenge of real data to find new methods and ideas and extend its comfortable euclidean ways to describe , predict and learn from scattering experiments .
pioneering has the potential of reinvigorating the field .
lattice gauge theory has provided a solid estimate for the critical temperature to make the quark gluon plasma as well as not - so - solid estimates of the required energy density , the magnitudes of screening lengths etc .
but there is much more to predict ... hopefully before the experiments ... and doing so will be particularly exciting . and fun .
i think that there are promising areas for such developments and i will discuss some throughout this talk .
light - cone wavefunctions of nuclei , dense with gluons , quarks and anti - quarks , collisions with unexpectedly high multiplicities and signs of early development of a quark - gluon plasma will be reviewed . along the way suggestions for additional or new lattice based research will be made .
other subfields of high energy physics are already interacting with the data .
lattice gauge theorists should become more active participants .
it hardly needs to be emphasized here that when lattice gauge theory develops a method to analyze a problem , it can do so from first principles , with ultimately no approximations .
emphasis on the word `` ultimately '' , because our lattices are yet too small , our quark masses are yet too large , our statistics are yet too few , etc .
but the field is making steady progress on all these issues , helped particularly by its use of improved but practical actions .
lattice gauge theory is the only approach that can handle the physics of the three crucial length scales of hadronic dynamics at one time , in a consistent calculation . at sufficiently short distances lattice calculations and simulations
confirm asymptotic freedom , which is so essential to exposing the underlying gluon and quark degrees of freedom of qcd as experiments enter the quark - gluon plasma phase . at more moderate distances where the running coupling is in the intermediate range and semi - classical instanton configurations
are breaking the anomalous @xmath0 symmetry and , through properties of their ensemble , are breaking chiral symmetry and are producing the constituent quark masses , lattice gauge theory is at its best elucidating the complex crossover physics of this range of length scales . finally ,
at greater length scales , lattice methods confirm confinement , the fact that hadronic states are color singlets and the confining dynamics comes through thin , discernable but breakable flux tubes .
qcd will not be fully understood until these three qualitatively different ranges of phenomena are incorporated into one tractable analytic approach .
crucial hints needed to accomplish this will come from lattice studies .
these are grand , and over - stated words .
but progress is occurring .
it is a pity that progress is not occurring on the challenge of producing a lattice simulation method for qcd at nonzero baryon chemical potential @xmath1 and vanishing temperature @xmath2 .
the infamous sign problem of the fermion determinant continues to stand in our way .
the same problem has bedeviled condensed matter physicists for almost 40 years .
a theme of this talk is that studying extreme environments teaches us how qcd works under ordinary conditions .
i believe that when we have licked the sign problem , or have found a new formulation of nonperturbative qcd free of it , we will be at a new level in our understanding of how qcd really works and makes its low lying baryonic excitations . in the second half of this review
i will discuss several interesting contributions at this conference .
these will include progress in mapping out the low @xmath1 ( chemical potential ) , high @xmath2 ( temperature ) part of the phase diagram of qcd , following the seminal work of fodor and katz .
real time spectral functions for the production of lepton pairs will be discussed as will the dispersion relation of pions below but near the transition to the plasma . a first step toward simulating phenomenologically interesting cutoff four fermi models of the transition
will also be mentioned briefly .
as emphasized by e. shuryak @xcite , the mass scales of the quark gluon plasma are different and , importantly , smaller than those of the more familiar hadronic phase .
the hadronic phase breaks chiral symmetry , the quark gluon plasma does not .
the hadronic phase confines quarks , the quark gluon plasma does not .
the binding mechanism in the hadronic phase is nonperturbative while the screening mechanism in the quark gluon plasma is perturbative . we know from deep inelastic scattering that the substructure scale in the hadronic phase is @xmath3 gev .
at this @xmath4 the running coupling is becoming large enough that perturbation theory is failing to give accurate estimates and nonperturbative effects are competitive .
by contrast perturbative screening masses in the quark gluon plasma are @xmath5 gev . and @xmath6 gev .
for temperature above but near @xmath7 where the plasma first appears .
the finer level spacings in the plasma act as a fine resolution grid to the dynamics in the hadronic phase .
a collision which starts in the hadronic phase and ends in the plasma phase is especially sensitive to the levels and dynamics of the hadronic phase because of the relative wealth of open channels in the plasma phase .
rhic collisions can be analyzed in four stages which are thought to be characterized by distinct time scales .
first , viewed from the center of momentum frame , there are right moving ( positive @xmath8 ) and left moving ( negative @xmath8 ) nuclei .
each of them can be described by infinite momentum frame wavefunctions which give the probability amplitudes for each nuclei to consist of ensembles of quarks and gluons .
the parton model , suitably improved with asymptotic freedom to describe its short distance features , should provide a framework for these initial states .
second , there is the collision between the constituents in each nuclei .
experiments will shed light on the typical momentum transfers and multiplicities of these underlying collisions .
third , there is the development of a thermalized plasma of quarks and gluons . and
fourth , there is the development of the final states of hadronic debris from the hot soup of colliding and produced constituents .
begin with the lightcone wavefunctions of the projectiles .
the rightmover is , @xmath9 recall from infinite momentum frame @xcite or light cone perturbation theory @xcite that @xmath10 is the longitudinal fraction of the i@xmath11 constituent .
it is a positive variable , @xmath12 and the constituents in each wavefunction @xmath13 account for the longitudinal fraction of the projectile , @xmath14 .
the absence of vacuum structure in @xmath15 makes this wavefunction a useful formulation of the initial state of the collision .
the bulk features of the wavefunctions of the projectiles are conveniently displayed on a rapidity plot , @xmath16 $ ] .
the rapidity is particularly handy because it simply translates under a boost along the @xmath17 axis .
one can plot the density of partons of both projectiles on a rapidity plot and deep inelastic experiments at a fixed @xmath4 indicate that the plot is essentially flat and boost invariant and of extent @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the usual scattering variable , four times the square of the center of momentum energy .
3 in 3 in experiments indicate that parton rapidity distributions have some simple , statistical features .
short range correlations in rapidity .
the parton distributions lose memory , with a correlation length of @xmath20 units , in rapidity .
screening in rapidity is an essential feature .
therefore , features like the quantum numbers of each projectile are limited to the edges of the rapidity plot .
unfortunately , this means that in very high energy heavy ion collisions , most of the partons are not influenced by the baryon number of the projectiles .
the collisions can be characterized by a high energy density and temperature but not high chemical potential @xmath1 .
the `` central region '' and is universal and `` vacuum like '' .
the length of the central region grows like @xmath18 .
although first principle calculations of light cone wavefunctions are beyond us , models having these features have been known for decades .
multiperipheral graphs of qcd can populate the rapidity axis uniformly and have suggested that gluons are the most likely parton species in the central region @xcite .
asymptotic freedom effects these considerations profoundly .
recall that in the naive parton model , partons interact only softly with one another , never exchanging high transverse momenta .
but if we consider the structure of the wavefunctions at high spatial resolution where the running coupling is small and perturbative asymptotic freedom applies , then high transverse momentum exchanges and short distance additional structure are inevitable @xcite .
call the gluon distribution function in momentum space @xmath21 .
this is the distribution function that would be resolved by a probe with resolving power @xmath22 .
models and theoretical analysis of scattering data suggests that @xmath21 approaches a constant for small @xmath23 and fixed @xmath4 .
however , as @xmath4 is increased one discovers that gluons can split perturbatively into three or four gluons of lesser longitudinal fractions @xmath10 .
so , for sufficiently small @xmath23 , @xmath21 must be an increasing function of @xmath4 .
this is a general feature of the asymptotically free parton model @xcite and perturbative evolution equations make this simple physical idea quantitative @xcite . for quark distribution functions which are accessible to deep inelastic electron and neutrino scattering , these ideas are well tested phenomenologically .
if we view the parton density on the plane transverse to the collision axis @xmath8 , then at low @xmath4 we see just a few gluons of size @xmath22 , but as @xmath4 is taken larger we resolve many more gluons of smaller size .
this progressive development has lead to the idea of `` gluon saturation '' in the light cone wavefunction of a nucleus @xcite .
to understand this idea , consider the wave function and imagine that it is coming at you and you have a snapshot of the transverse plane .
call the transverse size of the nucleus @xmath24 .
each parton of transverse momentum @xmath25 in the wavefunction occupies an area @xmath26 , as suggested by the uncertainty principle .
the parton s cross section is proportional to the square of the running coupling and its geometrical size , @xmath27 . but
partons will overlap in the transverse plane when their number @xmath28 becomes comparable to @xmath29 which is @xmath30 .
one supposes that when @xmath28 is this large , the overlap stops further growth in the density and `` saturation '' has been achieved @xcite .
the transverse momentum of the partons at saturation is @xmath31 .
the number of partons at the saturation level is @xmath32 and these are the number of partons of size scale @xmath33 which could materialize in the quark gluon plasma . in addition
@xmath34 sets the scale for the transverse momenta of partons in the central region of the rapidity plot , @xmath35 .
these formulas can be made more precise by considering longitudinal fractions @xcite .
the discussion here is just a simplified , but , hopefully , intriguing introduction . when numbers for the various nuclei and the energies available at experimental facilities are substituted here
, one finds that @xmath36 gev .
this means that applying perturbative qcd is suspect and competitive nonperturbative effects should be expected .
this is potentially the realm of lattice gauge theory .
the relationship of euclidean lattice calculations and the minkowski scattering formulation appropriate to heavy ion collisions must be addressed .
let s comment on the four different stages of a heavy ion collision separately .
the physics issues in each are quite distinct .
wave functions approach on another .
as reviewed above , the phase space parton density is quite large @xmath37 .
classical and semi - classical estimates should apply .
in particular , the color per volume is large , so the lack of commutivity , @xmath38=if^{abc}q^c$ ] , appears to be a relatively small effect , and the gluon field can be treated classically for many purposes @xcite .
\2 . interactions .
the gluon saturation picture suggests that the characteristic time of interactions is quite small , @xmath39 fm./c and the energy density is very , very large , @xmath40 gev./fm.@xmath41 .
such a large energy density would place the system deep in the quark gluon plasma phase .
this is good news !
estimates of @xmath42 in the past were much more modest , on the order of several gev./fm.@xmath41 , at most .
thermalization . after the collision
the quark gluon matter expands and thermalizes .
the experimental data and models suggest that the time scale for this to occur is @xmath43 fm / c .
rhic data , especially that showing the spatial distribution of particles produced in non - head - on collisions , strongly suggests that the interactions at early times are strong and the quark gluon plasma appears very early in the evolution of the final state @xcite .
the basic parton - parton interactions must be strong and involve high multiplicities .
perturbative processes alone are not sufficient to explain the data .
hydrodynamic expansion .
the quark gluon plasma maintains thermalization and expands until decoupling sets in at @xmath44fm./c . in the expansion and production of the final state hadrons ,
the fastest particles are produced last , as in the `` inside - outside '' cascade of electron - positron annihilation processes @xcite .
the expansion process is essentially one - dimensional , along the collision axis , until the latest stages of the development of the final state .
a particle s rapidity turns out to be strongly correlated with the space - time rapidity , @xmath45 $ ] , of its point of creation .
rhic experiments are hard and complicated and subject to many phenomenological models
. typically several models , each in stark contradiction to the other , can describe a limited set of heavy ion data equally well .
the `` smoking gun '' for the existence of the quark gluon plasma has yet to be found , but there are several pieces of data which are nicely explained , or at least , accommodated by it .
consider a few pieces of the puzzle .
jet quenching .
the heavy ion collisions show little or no sign of jets for @xmath46 gev .
this is interesting in light of the fact that if you scale single particle hadron spectra from proton - proton data to a - a data , you overshoot the jet data very significantly @xcite . it has been argued that this is evidence for the existence of an extended space - time region of the quark gluon plasma .
the idea is that two colliding gluons in the plasma annihilate into an energetic quark anti - quark pair with sizeable tranverse momenta , but their interactions with the plasma medium saps the energy out of the energetic quark and its partner , eliminating ( `` quenching '' ) those jet - like characteristics .
of course , very high energy jets are uneffected by the medium because of the short range nature of the most prevalent interactions on the rapidity axis , and jets with energies much larger than @xmath47 gev .
are seen .
suggestions of deconfinement and chiral symmetry restoration .
lepton pairs have long been cited as effective probes into the internal dynamics of the quark gluon plasma . in particular ,
if the @xmath48 and @xmath49 existed in the plasma , then the leptonic decays , @xmath50 and @xmath51 would be easily seen , as in proton - a collisions .
these peaks are missing , however @xcite .
it is tempting to interpret this experimental result as evidence that the light hadrons have `` melted '' in the hot plasma .
we will consider some lattice gauge theory data concerning these peaks in the second half of this talk .
screening and j/@xmath52 suppression .
one of the first theoretical suggestions for a signal of the existence of the quark gluon plasma concerned the heavy quark states j/@xmath52 .
it was argued and backed up with potential model calculations , that quasi - free quark and gluon thermal screening would reduce the attractive forces between the heavy quarks sufficiently to eliminate the binding energies and the j/@xmath52 states themselves @xcite .
in fact , the suppression of these states , again implied by the absence of the associated lepton pairs , is much more dramatic than that expected in hadron absorption models .
rhic experiments suggest that there are early , strong , high multiplicity parton - parton collisions in heavy ion scattering processes .
perturbation theory , such as the qcd multiperipheral diagrams @xcite which can fill the rapidity plot with a uniform density of gluons , fall far short of describing the data .
this suggests that larger length scales where the running coupling is in the intermediate coupling range are involved .
this is the domain where semi - classical collective excitations of qcd are important .
e. shuryak has suggested that instantons and sphalerons @xcite may be causing some of the surprising scattering events seen at rhic .
we have taken a short survey into topics of interest to heavy ion physicists .
can lattice theorists have much impact here ?
much of the physics here is stated in minkowski space , natural to scattering processes .
employing euclidean lattice methods to tackle some of these questions will certainly take new initiatives and methods . as we will review in the second half of this
talk , lattice methods do provide information on real time processes even within the present techniques we use .
these include power spectra , maximum entropy methods and lepton pair rates .
however , more comprehensive methods closer to first principles can probably be developed , too .
let s look at a few such topics .
the parton picture of qcd structure requires the use of the infinite momentum frame , or , equivalently light cone quantization .
each parton has a particular tranverse and longitudinal momentum in a wavefunction expansion , as written above .
infinite momentum frame hamiltonians have been written down in this language and two dimensional hamiltonians which control the transverse dynamics have been studied .
lattice gauge theory versions of these systems can be constructed @xcite and equivalent three dimensional lagrangian systems derived .
one can hope that formulations of this sort could be used to address issues of parton saturation in the context of lattice methods which can handle honestly the intermediate coupling character of these problems .
the infinite momentum frame idea will eliminate vacuum fluctuations from the nonzero longitudinal fraction parts of the problem . in the context of continuum methods , there have been recent attempts along these lines by heavy ion physicists .
an ambitious attempt to formulate deep inelastic scattering in euclidean terms has been pioneered by o. nachtmann @xcite .
this looks like particularly fertile ground for a lattice incursion .
as i will review in the second half of this talk , the region of the qcd phase diagram for small @xmath1 in the vicinity of the quark gluon transition @xmath7 is accessible to conventional simulation methods .
this is a recent development that opens up experimentally relevant lattice calculations to the whole field .
the thermodynamics of the formation of the quark gluon plasma for @xmath2 near @xmath7 and small baryon chemical potential @xmath1 should be studied very professionally now .
some of the projects will be reviewed in the second half of this talk .
we would certainly like to know how quickly the underlying physical mechanisms responsible for the transition from the hadronic phase to the quark gluon plasma phase change as @xmath1 is turned on for @xmath54 .
we know that there are substantial interactions in the quark gluon plasma just above @xmath7 .
how are these mechanisms and how are bulk thermodynamic quantities effected as @xmath1 is taken nonzero ?
the role of instantons in the formation and character of the quark gluon plasma needs more elucidation even at the @xmath55 edge of the qcd phase diagram . according to the instanton liquid model @xcite
, the instanton ensemble is disordered in the hadronic phase .
this is essential for the model to produce chiral symmetry breaking and phenomenologically reasonable numbers .
it is believed that as @xmath2 passes through @xmath7 , instantons and anti - instantons pair up and form `` neutral '' molecules .
chiral symmetry is restored in such an ordered ensemble .
it would be interesting to verify this `` binding - unbinding '' picture of the phase transition by lattice methods and to provide estimates of the scales of the phenomena involved .
this will not be easy because instantons and anti - instanton molecules will tend to `` fall through '' the lattice and be hard to identify , let alone measure .
improved actions will probably be needed .
such studies would be worth doing because we know from other simulations that there are substantial interactions in the quark gluon plasma just above @xmath7 .
we would also like to know how instanton dynamics change as @xmath1 is turned on for @xmath54 .
these are interesting questions which are experimentally relevant .
conventional lattice methods can address them now .
perturbative @xcite and instanton @xcite methods have been used to predict color superconductivity for low temperatures and asymptotically large @xmath1 .
a large gap has been found as well as interesting symmetries ( `` color - flavor locking '' @xcite ) .
the large gap in the spectrum of the cooper quark - quark pairs suggests that this state of matter should occur in natural phenomena , such as the interiors of neutron stars , at high but not inaccessible densities .
the lattice has been unable to contribute to this field because of the sign problem in the euclidean fermion determinant in @xmath56 lattice gauge theory .
the weak coupling , perturbative and instanton , approaches to color superconductivity have not addressed the numerical impact of confinement on their considerations , so estimates of a critical density are suspect .
much of the research has concentrated on @xmath57 color which is qualitatively different from qcd .
cooper pairs in the @xmath57 model are color singlets and are degenerate with ordinary meson states because of the self - conjugate nature of quark and anti - quarks in this case . at chemical potentials greater than half the pion mass ,
the ground state of the model becomes a superfluid .
instanton enthusiasts have noted that their model provides attractive forces which favor the appearance of scalar @xmath58 diquarks @xcite .
the forces are only half as strong as the analogous ones in the @xmath57 model where diquark states are degenerate with mesons .
this suggests one should find considerable scalar @xmath58 diquark correlations in ordinary hadronic physics . to my knowledge , there are none . perhaps lattice spectroscopists could scour their baryon wavefunctions and search for diquark correlations in their three body states . aside from the issue of color superconductivity
, it would be good to settle the old controversy concerning the possible viability of diquark models of baryon structure .
weak coupling descriptions of color superconductivity do nt need diquark correlation enhancements in ordinary hadronic states to be successful and accurate at nonzero chemical potentials .
this is because the cooper pairs of the bcs theory have very large , `` floppy '' wavefunctions which are much larger than protons @xcite .
the parallel sessions at lattice 2002 concerning qcd in extreme environments contained a number of interesting contributions . because of the lack of space i will discuss just four topics that generated the most discussion .
i will have to point the reader to the writeups of the parallel talks for details .
the four topics will be : 1 .
the high @xmath2 , low @xmath1 edge of the qcd phase diagram , 2 .
thermal dilepton rates , 3 .
real - time pion propagation in hot qcd , and 4 .
four dimensional four fermi models at nonzero @xmath1 . following the seminal work of fodor and katz last year @xcite
, the field has realized that the high @xmath2 , low @xmath1 edge of the qcd phase diagram is accessible to a variety of mature lattice techniques .
fodor and collaborators @xcite presented arguments that their multi - parameter generalization of the glasgow method has an efficiency which only falls off as a power , @xmath59 with @xmath60 , as the size of the lattice grows large . de forcrand and philipsen @xcite have done simulations at imaginary chemical potentials using conventional hybrid molecular dynamics algorithms and have found convincing , controlled results for @xmath61 .
the bielefeld - swansea group @xcite have presented taylor expansions in @xmath1 of the fodor - katz method .
sinclair @xcite simulated @xmath56 lattice gauge theory at nonzero isospin chemical potential @xmath62 and found that @xmath63 resembles the curve @xmath64 predicted by the other groups .
before we consider the first two contributions in more detail , recall some elementary points .
the transition from the hadronic phase to the quark gluon plasma phase at @xmath65 and @xmath66 is actually a rapid crossover for the range of quark masses presently under investigation .
most lattice theorists believe that it is also a rapid crossover for realistic quark masses , @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 , but larger scale simulations are needed here .
as @xmath1 is turned on one expects that the crossover @xmath64 to decrease slowly .
however , for sufficiently large @xmath1 one expects the crossover to become a first order transition and it is this point `` e '' , the critical endpoint , @xmath70 and @xmath71 , that one would like to know @xcite .
present simulations indicate that @xmath71 is quite large @xcite . however , those simulations are on small lattices with relatively large quark masses
. they should be repeated on large lattices with realistic quark masses to get a relevant answer for @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
if @xmath71 turns out to be very small , there would be dramatic effects , potentially , in the projectile fragmentation regions at rhic .
3 in 3 in fodor and katz @xcite introduced multi - parameter reweighting to improve the overlap of lattice configurations on the edge of the phase diagram with particular points inside the phase diagram , @xmath72 this formula organizes the calculation of the partition function at a point inside the phase diagram , by making configurations on the edge of the phase diagram ( first line ) and reweighting ( second line ) in two variables , @xmath1 and @xmath73 .
the idea is that configurations at @xmath7 experience both the hadron and the quark gluon plasma phase so there should be a considerable overlap with configurations nearby but at different @xmath1 and @xmath73 values .
care must be taken here : as @xmath1 is increased , @xmath73 must be increased slightly so the system remains near the crossover coupling for that @xmath1 value , @xmath74 .
as @xmath1 and @xmath73 are increased , one monitors the acceptance rate and keeps it near 50 percent @xcite . in this way lines essentially parallel to @xmath74 but displaced into the hadronic or the plasma phase
have also been investigated and the equation of state has been calculated for a range of @xmath2 and @xmath1 values .
they have shown that the crossover sharpens as @xmath1 grows and the endpoint `` e '' is approached @xcite .
the position of the endpoint was found in last year s contribution but studying the finite size scaling properties of the lee - yang zeros of the partition function @xcite . 3 in 3 in following the paths in phase space where the authors monitor the efficiency of their overlap method
, they are now computing the equation of state @xcite .
the crossover is predicted to sharpen considerably as @xmath75 increases .
the authors argue that at least for volumes up to @xmath76 , they can simulate chemical potentials up to @xmath77 with @xmath78 . and
they argue that the efficiency of their multi - parameter overlap method scales as @xmath59 with @xmath60 , so the method should allow fairly large lattices to be simulated before its inefficiencies become overwhelming .
the reader should consult the parallel session contribution by these authors for plots and details @xcite .
the second contribution presented on this topic by de forcrand and philipsen @xcite simulated lattice at imaginary chemical potential using the conventional hybrid molecular dynamics algorithm .
it followed the crossover , @xmath74 , by computing the plaquette susceptibility and monitoring its peak as a function of @xmath73 for fixed values of the imaginary chemical potetial .
the authors argue that the curve @xmath74 is an even , analytic function of @xmath1 . writing @xmath79 , they find that only the first two terms are needed to describe the data accurately . the analytic continuation to real
@xmath1 is , therefore , trivial .
their resulting curve is in agreement with that of fodor and katz , although they havent investigated the order of the transition as a function of @xmath1 yet .
the imaginary chemical potential method is very conservative and effective .
it will work on large lattices with the efficiency of an ordinary hybrid molecular dynamics code .
it can only treat small chemical potentials because imaginary chemical potentials induce tunnelling to other @xmath80 vacua when the imaginary chemical potential equals @xmath81 @xcite . for @xmath2 near @xmath82 mev .
, the method is limited to @xmath83 mev .
the reader is referred to the relevant contribution at the parallel session for quantitative details .
in addition , similar work has appeared by delia and lombardo @xcite .
we can look forward to considerable progress in understanding this strip of the qcd phase diagram now that several simulation methods and groups are involved .
dilepton rates were discussed above as an informative probe into the dynamics of the quark gluon plasma .
this topic also provides a nice example of traditional lattice gauge theory confronting new experimental scattering data .
the dilepton rate , which is a function of frequency @xmath84 and momentum @xmath85 , can be written in the form @xcite , @xmath86 where the spectral function @xmath87 is related to the current - current correlation function , @xmath88 , on the periodic lattice as , @xmath89 on a @xmath90 lattice , one can measure the correlation function @xmath91 at each `` time '' slice , @xmath92 , @xmath93 and then attempt to invert the relation between the spectral function and the correlation function .
there are two approaches to executing this inversion .
first , one might use a model dependent functional form which depends on several parameters and determine @xmath87 .
this approach has had only limited success .
alternatively , one might use the maximum entropy method ( mem ) @xcite and find the `` most probable '' spectral function . since the lattice simulation gives the correlation function only at a discrete set of points @xmath94 , each with statistical errors ,
the problem of finding the continuous function @xmath95 of the continuous variable @xmath84 is ill - posed .
the maximum entropy method can only produce a `` most probable '' answer with a measure of its reliability .
the method , however , is well - known and quite successful in optics , where it is used for image reconstruction .
again , the reader should consult the parallel sessions for a wealth of examples that illustrate the method s strengths and weaknesses . at past conferences
the bielefeld group has presented data @xcite which have shown that the @xmath48 and @xmath49 peaks in the dilepton spectra are suppressed in the presence of the quark gluon plasma , in qualitative accord with the experimental trends . however , the dilepton signal is still somewhat larger than that found for free but hot quarks and gluons , at least for @xmath96 between 4 and 8 .
these simulations were done above the transition , at @xmath97 and @xmath98 , so measureable attraction in these light quark states at these high temperatures is somewhat surprising .
results such as these suggest that although bulk thermodynamic behavior of the quark gluon plasma might be close to the stephan - boltzmann limit , detailed hadronic structures are not completely washed out . at this conference s. datta
@xcite presented bielefeld simulation results at @xmath99 and @xmath100 for the charmonium states .
the s - wave states had a diminished , perhaps by a factor of 2 , signal above the transition where potential models predicted there would be no signal at all .
the p - wave signal , however , was reduced by a factor of about 7 across the transition suggesting that screening has removed these charmonium states from the spectrum .
a study of effective lagrangians by stephanov and son @xcite has uncovered curious features in the propagation of pions as the quark gluon plasma is approached by heating hadronic matter , @xmath101 .
in fact , the pion dispersion relation is found to be determined by temperature dependent features of the system which are accessible to conventional euclidean lattice simulations .
the three features one needs are 1 . the pion screening mass , 2 . the pion decay constant , and 3 .
the axial isospin susceptibility .
this work constitutes a nice , informative example where `` real - time '' quantities are accessible to static simulations . of course , the most popular example of this is the relation of the speed of sound @xmath102 in a system to its bulk thermodynamics , @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is the bulk pressure and @xmath105 is the energy density .
other examples exist in condensed matter physics , as well .
for example , the propagation features of spin waves in anti - ferromagnets are determined in large part by static correlation functions .
these authors @xcite determine the real part of the soft pion dispersion relation , @xmath106 where we identify @xmath107 , the pion s speed , @xmath108 , the pion s screening mass , and @xmath109 , the pion s `` pole mass '' .
the authors derive three low energy theorems at nonzero @xmath2 .
first , @xmath110 , where @xmath111 is the pion decay constant and @xmath112 is the axial isospin susceptibility .
these last two quantities are related by the other two theorems , which represent the generalizations of the gell - mann oakes renner relation to finite temperatures , @xmath113 .
since these quantities are accessible to conventional lattice simulations , we have a nice illustration of determining `` real time '' physical quantities from static , euclidean simulations .
the strategy of this development is interesting and quite general .
one begins with the microscopic quark lagrangian underlying lattice qcd , @xmath114 as well as the low energy effective lagrangian that describes the properties of the low energy mesons , @xmath115 where @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .
the effective lagrangian should be familiar from strong interaction phenomenology and its extension to nonzero chemical potential is determined by the symmetries of the underlying microscopic lagrangian without any numerical or phenomenological ambiguity @xcite . by matching the predictions of the microscopic theory with those of the low energy lagrangian , the authors determine their low energy theorems .
note how curious pion propagation is as @xmath2 approaches @xmath7 .
the pion propagation speed appraoches zero , as does the pion decay constant @xmath111 .
a further investigation of the scaling laws governing the approach to the quark gluon transition reveals that @xmath107 vanishes faster as @xmath2 approaches @xmath7 than the screening mass @xmath108 diverges @xcite , so the pole mass @xmath118 approaches zero as @xmath2 approaches @xmath7 .
since the pion s speed vanishes in this limit while its pole mass does also , perhaps we can call the pion an `` infinitely massive massless '' state ! hopefully , some of these features will show up in final state studies at rhic .
as advertised in the first part of this talk , it would be good for all concerned if there were more interaction between the lattice community and the phenomenologists interested in the quark gluon plasma and in color superconductivity .
one step in this direction has been taken by the swansea group @xcite which has found diquark condensation in strongly cutoff @xmath119 dimensional nambu jona - lasinio models , of the sort discussed by nuclear theorists , instanton phenomenologists and others . the value in the lattice simulations is , as usual , that their results are exact in principle , because they include all the fluctuations .
the lagrangian which has been simulated is just one of the original nambu jona - lasinio models , @xmath120 + \frac{i}{2}[j(\bar{\psi}_i^{tr } c
\gamma_5 \tau_2 \epsilon_{ij } \psi_j)+ \nonumber \\ \bar{j}(\bar{\psi}_i c \gamma_5 \tau_2 \epsilon_{ij } \bar{\psi}_j^{tr})]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last two terms are source terms for diquark condensation which are taken to zero ( @xmath121 ) at the end of a simulation meant to calculate the diquark condensate .
these terms play the same role as a small bare fermion mass term in a lattice simulation of the chiral condensate
the simulation must pick out a preferred direction in the space of the condensate , calculate the condensate and see if it survives in the limit where the source is taken away .
in fact , simulations of this model indicate that as @xmath1 increases , a diquark condensate appears in the system and its @xmath1 dependence and magnitude are close to the predictions of the leading term in the large @xmath122 expansion .
the reader should consult the parallel sessions of these conference proceedings for plots @xcite .
one notable feature of this calculation is that it is the first lattice simulation in @xmath119 dimensions with a traditional fermi surface at nonzero chemical potential .
future work in this direction will be the study of additional four fermi models suggested by the instanton liquid model .
one complication will be the cutoff nature of these models these models are logarithmically trivial and they are useful only when strongly cutoff , with their parameters adjusted so that observables such as the pion decay constant and the chiral condensate take on physical values .
luckily , the nuclear physics community has used such models for some time and know the `` best '' way to deal with these issues .
the lattice model may reach an impasse , however , because when complicated four fermi interactions are entertained , it becomes impossible to avoid complex fermion determinants .
in addition , these models do not confine quarks in their low temperature phase , so they are subject to criticisms discussed earlier .
nonetheless , these studies should be informative and represent a test of some of the analytic , approximate approaches to the high @xmath1 , low @xmath2 superconductivity phase .
lattice gauge theory has had much to say about the finite temperature behavior of qcd because it can handle the three length scales of qcd , perturbative behavior at weak coupling and short distances , semi - classical coherent behavior at intermediate couplings and intermediate distances , and confinement at strong couplings and large distances .
it is now able to study the variable @xmath2-low @xmath1 strip of the phase diagram and make predictions relevant to heavy ion experiments .
i hope that its lessons will lead to additional formulations and strategies to study real time physics relevant to collisions and nuclear structure in the not - too - distant future
. 99 e. shuryak , hep - ph/0205031 .
j.b . kogut and l. susskind , phys . rep .
8 , 75 ( 1973 ) .
lipatov , sov .
23 , 338 ( 1976 ) .
kogut and l. susskind , phys .
d9 , 3391 ( 1974 ) .
g. altarelli and g. parisi , nucl .
b 126 , 298 ( 1977 ) .
e. iancu , a. leonidov and l. mclerran , hep - ph/0202270 .
d. kharzeev , plenary talk , lattice 2002 .
bjorken , phys .
d27 , 140 ( 1983 ) .
t. matsui and h. satz , phys .
b178 , 416 ( 1986 ) .
e. shuryak and i. zahed , phys .
62 , 085014 ( 2000 ) .
a. krasnitz and r. venugopalan , hep - ph/9706329 .
t. schaefer and e. shuryak , rev .
70 , 323 ( 1998 ) .
o. nachtmann , hep - ph/0206284 .
m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , phys .
b422 * , 247 ( 1998 ) .
r. rapp , t. schafer , e.v .
shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 53 ( 1998 ) .
r. rapp , t. schaefer , e. shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys .
81 , 53 ( 1998 ) .
k. rajagopal , comment at lattice 2002 .
z. fodor and s.d .
katz , nucl.phys.proc.suppl .
106 , 441 ( 2002 ) .
f. csikor , g.i .
egri , z. fodor , s.d .
katz , k.k .
szabo amd a.i .
toth , lattice 2002 .
p. de forcrand and o. philipsen , hep - lat/0205016 .
allton , s. ejiri , s. hands , o. kaczmarek , f. karsch , e. laermann , ch .
schmidt and l. scorzato , hep - lat/0204010 .
sinclair , lattice 2002 .
a. roberge and n. weiss , nucl .
b275 , 734 ( 1986 ) .
m. delia and m .-
lombardo , hep - lat/0205022 .
f. karsch , e. laermann , p. petreczky , s. stickan and i. wetzorke , hep - lat/0110208 .
m asakawa , y. nakahara and t. hatsuda , prog .
46 , 459 ( 2001 ) .
s. datta , lattice 2002 .
d. son and m. stephanov , hep - ph/0111100 , 0204226 .
kogut , m.a .
stephanov and d. toublan , phys . lett . *
b464 * , 183 ( 1999 ) .
d. walters , lattice 2002 . | i review present challenges that qcd in extreme environments presents to lattice gauge theory .
recent data and impressions from rhic are emphasized .
physical pictures of heavy ion wavefunctions , collisions and the generation of the quark gluon plasma are discussed , with an eye toward engaging the lattice and its numerical methods in more interaction with the experimental and phenomenological developments .
controversial , but stimulating scenarios which can be confirmed or dismissed by lattice methods are covered . in the second half of the talk ,
several promising developments presented at the conference lattice 2002 are reviewed . |
knowledge - base systems must typically deal with imperfection in knowledge , in particular , in the form of incompleteness , inconsistency , and uncertainty . with this motivation ,
several frameworks for manipulating data and knowledge have been proposed in the form of extensions to classical logic programming and deductive databases to cope with imperfections in available knowledge .
abiteboul , _ et al . _
@xcite , liu @xcite , and dong and lakshmanan @xcite dealt with deductive databases with incomplete information in the form of null values .
kifer and lozinskii @xcite have developed a logic for reasoning with inconsistency .
extensions to logic programming and deductive databases for handling uncertainty are numerous .
they can broadly be categorized into non - probabilistic and probabilistic formalisms .
we review previous work in these fields , with special emphasis on probabilistic logic programming , because of its relevance to this paper .
* non - probabilistic formalisms * _ ( 1 ) fuzzy logic programming _ :
this was essentially introduced by van emden in his seminal paper on quantitative deduction @xcite , and further developed by various researchers , including steger _
@xcite , schmidt _
_ @xcite .
_ ( 2 ) annotated logic programming _ :
this framework was introduced by subrahmanian @xcite , and later studied by blair and subrahmanian @xcite , and kifer and li @xcite . while blair and subrahmanian s focus was paraconsistency , kifer and li extended the framework of @xcite into providing a formal semantics for rule - based systems with uncertainty .
finally , this framework was generalized by kifer and subrahmanian into the generalized annotated programming ( gap ) framework @xcite ) .
all these frameworks are inherently based on a lattice - theoretic semantics .
annotated logic programming has also been employed with the probabilistic approach , which we will discuss further below . _ ( 3 ) evidence theoretic logic programming _ : this has been mainly studied by baldwin and monk @xcite and baldwin @xcite ) .
they use dempster s evidence theory as the basis for dealing with uncertainty in their logic programming framework .
* probabilistic formalisms * indeed , there has been substantial amount of research into probabilistic logics ever since boole @xcite .
carnap @xcite is a seminal work on probabilistic logic .
fagin , halpern , and megiddo @xcite study the satisfiability of systems of probabilistic constraints from a model - theoretic perspective .
gaifman @xcite extends probability theory by borrowing notions and techniques from logic .
nilsson @xcite uses a possible worlds " approach to give model - theoretic semantics for probabilistic logic .
@xcite notion of probabilistic entailment is similar to that of nilsson .
some of the probabilistic logic programming works are based on probabilistic logic approaches , such as ng and subrahmanian s work on probabilistic logic programming @xcite and ng s recent work on empirical databases @xcite .
we discuss these works further below .
we will not elaborate on probabilistic logics any more and refer the reader to halpern @xcite for additional information .
works on probabilistic logic programming and deductive databases can be categorized into two main approaches , annotation - based , and implication based .
* annotation based approach * : ng and subrahmanian @xcite were the first to propose a probabilistic basis for logic programming .
their syntax borrows from that of annotated logic programming @xcite , although the semantics are quite different .
the idea is that uncertainty is always associated with individual atoms ( or their conjunctions and disjunctions ) , while the rules or clauses are always kept classical . in @xcite ,
uncertainty in an atom is modeled by associating a probabilistic truth value with it , and by asserting that it lies in an interval .
the main interest is in characterizing how precisely we can bound " the probabilities associated with various atoms . in terms of the terminology of belief and doubt , we can say , following kifer and li @xcite , that the combination of belief and doubt about a piece of information might lead to an interval of probabilities , as opposed a precise probabilities .
but , as pointed out in @xcite , even if one starts with precise point probabilities for atomic events , probabilities associated with compound events can only be calculated to within some exact upper and lower bounds , thus naturally necessitating intervals .
but then , the same argument can be made for an agent s belief as well as doubt about a fact , they both could well be intervals . in this sense
, we can say that the model of @xcite captures only the belief .
a second important characteristic of this model is that it makes a conservative assumption that nothing is known about the interdependence of events ( captured by the atoms in an input database ) , and thus has the advantage of not having to make the often unrealistic independence assumption .
however , by being conservative , it makes it impossible to take advantage of the ( partial ) knowledge a user may have about the interdependence among some of the events . from a technical perspective
, only annotation constants are allowed in @xcite .
intuitively , this means only constant probability ranges may be associated with atoms .
this was generalized in a subsequent paper by ng and subrahmanian @xcite to allow annotation variables and functions .
they have developed fixpoint and model - theoretic semantics , and provided a sound and weakly complete proof procedure .
_ @xcite have proposed a sound ( propositional ) probabilistic calculus based on conditional probabilities , for reasoning in the presence of incomplete information . although they make use of a datalog - based interface to implement this calculus , their framework is actually propositional . in related works ,
ng and subrahmanian have extended their basic probabilistic logic programming framework to capture stable negation in @xcite , and developed a basis for dempster - shafer theory in @xcite . * implication based approach * : while many of the quantitative deduction frameworks ( van emden @xcite , fitting @xcite , debray and ramakrishnan @xcite , etc . )
are implication based , the first implication based framework for probabilistic deductive databases was proposed in @xcite .
the idea behind implication based approach is to associate uncertainty with the facts as well as rules in a deductive database .
sadri @xcite in a number of papers developed a hybrid method called information source tracking ( ist ) for modeling uncertainty in ( relational ) databases which combines symbolic and numeric approaches to modeling uncertainty .
lakshmanan and sadri @xcite pursue the deductive extension of this model using the implication based approach .
lakshmanan @xcite generalizes the idea behind ist to model uncertainty by characterizing the set of ( complex ) scenarios under which certain ( derived ) events might be believed or doubted given a knowledge of the applicable belief and doubt scenarios for basic events .
he also establishes a connection between this framework and modal logic .
while both @xcite are implication based approaches , strictly speaking , they do not require any commitment to a particular formalism ( such a probability theory ) for uncertainty manipulation .
any formalism that allows for a consistent calculation of numeric certainties associated with boolean combination of basic events , based on given certainties for basic events , can be used for computing the numeric certainties associated with derived atoms .
recently , lakshmanan and shiri @xcite unified and generalized all known implication based frameworks for deductive databases with uncertainty ( including those that use formalisms other than probability theory ) into a more abstract framework called the parametric framework .
the notions of conjunctions , disjunctions , and certainty propagations ( via rules ) are parameterized and can be chosen based on the applications .
even the domain of certainty measures can be chosen as a parameter . under such broadly generic conditions
, they proposed a declarative semantics and an equivalent fixpoint semantics .
they also proposed a sound and complete proof procedure .
finally , they characterized conjunctive query containment in this framework and provided necessary and sufficient conditions for containment for several large classes of query programs .
their results can be applied to individual implication based frameworks as the latter can be seen as instances of the parametric framework .
conjunctive query containment is one of the central problems in query optimization in databases .
while the framework of this paper can also be realized as an instance of the parametric framework , the concerns and results there are substantially different from ours . in particular , to our knowledge ,
this is the first paper to address data complexity in the presence of ( probabilistic ) uncertainty .
* other related work * fitting @xcite has developed an elegant framework for quantitative logic programming based on bilattices , an algebraic structure proposed by ginsburg @xcite in the context of many - valued logic programming .
this was the first to capture both belief and doubt in one uniform logic programming framework . in recent work ,
lakshmanan _ et al .
_ @xcite have proposed a model and algebra for probabilistic relational databases .
this framework allows the user to choose notions of conjunctions and disjunctions based on a family of strategies .
in addition to developing complexity results , they also address the problem of efficient maintenance of materialized views based on their probabilistic relational algebra .
one of the strengths of their model is not requiring any restrictive independence assumptions among the facts in a database , unlike previous work on probabilistic relational databases @xcite . in a more recent work , dekhtyar and subrahmanian @xcite developed an annotation based framework where the user can have a parameterized notion of conjunction and disjunction . in not requiring independence assumptions , and being able to allow the user to express her knowledge about event interdependence by means of a parametrized family of conjunctions and disjunctions , both @xcite have some similarities to this paper .
however , chronologically , the preliminary version of this paper @xcite was the first to incorporate such an idea in a probabilistic framework . besides , the frameworks of @xcite are substantially different from ours . in a recent work ng @xcite studies _ empirical _ databases , where a deductive database is enhanced by empirical clauses representing statistical information .
he develops a model - theoretic semantics , and studies the issues of consistency and query processing in such databases .
his treatment is probabilistic , where probabilities are obtained from statistical data , rather than being subjective probabilities .
( see halpern @xcite for a comprehensive discussion on statistical and subjective probabilities in logics of probability . )
ng s query processing algorithm attempts to resolve a query using the ( regular ) deductive component of the database . if it is not successful , then it reverts to the empirical component , using the notion of _ most specific reference class _ usually used in statistical inferences .
our framework is quite different in that every rule / fact is associated with a confidence level ( a pair of probabilistic intervals representing belief and doubt ) , which may be subjective , or may have been obtained from underlying statistical data .
the emphasis of our work is on ( _ i _ ) the characterization of different modes for combining confidences , ( _ ii _ ) semantics , and , in particular , ( _ iii _ ) termination and complexity issues .
the contributions of this paper are as follows .
* we associate a _ confidence level _ with facts and rules ( of a deductive database ) .
a confidence level comes with both a _ belief _ and a _ doubt _ ( in what is being asserted ) [ see section [ motiv ] for a motivation ] .
belief and doubt are subintervals of @xmath0 $ ] representing probability ranges .
* we show that confidence levels have an interesting algebraic structure called _ trilattices _ as their basis ( section [ lattice ] ) .
analogously to fitting s bilattices , we show that trilattices associated with confidence levels are interlaced , making them interesting in their own right , from an algebraic point of view .
in addition to providing an algebraic footing for our framework , trilattices also shed light on the relationship between our work and earlier works and offer useful insights . in particular ,
trilattices give rise to three ways of ordering confidence levels : the truth - order , where belief goes up and doubt comes down , the information order , where both belief and doubt go up , and the precision order , where the probability intervals associated with both belief and doubt become sharper , the interval length decreases .
this is to be contrasted with the known truth and information ( called knowledge there ) orders in a bilattice . * a purely lattice - theoretic basis for logic programming
can be constructed using trilattices ( similar to fitting @xcite ) . however , since our focus in this paper is probabilistic uncertainty , we develop a probabilistic calculus for combining confidence levels associated with basic events into those for compound events based on them ( section [ prob - calc ] ) . instead of committing to any specific rules for combining confidences
, we propose a framework which allows a user to choose an appropriate mode " from a collection of available ones . *
we develop a generalized framework for rule - based programming with probabilistic knowledge , based on this calculus .
we provide the declarative and fixpoint semantics for such programs and establish their equivalence ( section [ prob - ddb ] ) .
we also provide a sound and complete proof procedure ( section [ proof - theory ] ) . *
we study the termination and complexity issues of such programs and show : ( 1 ) the closure ordinal of @xmath1 can be as high as @xmath2 in general ( but no more ) , and ( 2 ) when only _ positive correlation _
is used for disjunction , the data complexity of such programs is polynomial time .
our proof technique for the last result yields a similar result for van emden s framework ( section [ termination ] ) .
* we also compare our work with related work and bring out the advantages and generality of our approach ( section [ termination ] ) .
in this section , we discuss the motivation for our work as well as comment on our design decisions for this framework .
the motivation for using probability theory as opposed to other formalisms for representing uncertainty has been discussed at length in the literature @xcite .
probability theory is perhaps the best understood and mathematically well - founded paradigm in which uncertainty can be modeled and reasoned about .
two possibilities for associating probabilities with facts and rules in a ddb are van emden s style of associating confidences with rules as a whole @xcite , or the annotation style of kifer and subrahmanian @xcite .
the second approach is more powerful : it is shown in @xcite that the second approach can simulate the first .
the first approach , on the other hand , has the advantage of intuitive appeal , as pointed out by kifer and subrahmanian @xcite . in this paper
, we choose the first approach .
a comparison between our approach and annotation - based approach with respect to termination and complexity issues is given in section [ termination ] .
a second issue is whether we should insist on precise probabilities or allow intervals ( or ranges ) .
firstly , probabilities derived from any sources may have tolerances associated with them .
even experts may feel more comfortable with specifying a range rather than a precise probability .
secondly , fenstad @xcite has shown ( also see @xcite ) that when enough information is not available about the interaction between events , the probability of compound events can not be determined precisely : one can only give ( tight ) bounds .
thus , we associate ranges of probabilities with facts and rules .
a last issue is the following .
suppose ( uncertain ) knowledge contributed by an expert corresponds to the formula @xmath3 .
in general , we can not assume the expert s knowledge is perfect .
this means he does not necessarily know _ all _ situations in which @xmath3 holds . nor
does he know _ all _ situations where @xmath3 fails to hold ( @xmath4 holds ) .
he models the proportion of the situations where he knows @xmath3 holds as his _ belief _ in @xmath3 and the proportion of situations where he knows @xmath4 holds as his _
doubt_. there could be situations , unknown to our expert , where @xmath3 holds ( or @xmath4 holds ) .
these unknown situations correspond to the gap in his knowledge .
thus , as far as he knows , @xmath3 is _ unknown _ or _ undefined _ in these remaining situations .
these observations , originally made by fitting @xcite , give rise to the following definition .
[ defn : cf ] ( _ confidence level _ ) denote by @xmath5 $ ] the set of all closed subintervals over @xmath6 $ ] .
consider the set @xmath7 \times { \cal c}[0 , 1]$ ] .
a _ confidence level _ is an element of @xmath8 .
we denote a confidence level as @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] . in our approach confidence levels
are associated with facts and rules .
the intended meaning of a fact ( or rule ) @xmath3 having a confidence @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] is that @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the lower and upper bounds of the expert s _ belief _ in @xmath3 , and @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the lower and upper bounds of the expert s _ doubt _ in @xmath3 .
these notions will be formalized in section [ prob - calc ] .
the following example illustrates such a scenario .
( the figures in all our examples are fictitious . )
consider the results of gallup polls conducted before the recent canadian federal elections .
\1 . of the people
surveyed , between 50% and 53% of the people in the age group 19 to 30 favor the liberals .
between 30% and 33% of the people in the above age group favor the reformists .
+ 3 . between 5% and
8% of the above age group favor the tories .
the reason we have ranges for each category is that usually some tolerance is associated with the results coming from such polls .
also , we do not make the proportion of undecided people explicit as our interest is in determining the support for the different parties .
suppose we assimilate the information above in a probabilistic framework .
for each party , we compute the probability that a _
randomly _ chosen person from the sample population of the given age group will ( not ) vote for that party .
we transfer this probability as the _ subjective _ probability that _ any _ person from that age group ( in the actual population ) will ( not ) vote for the party .
the conclusions are given below , where @xmath14 says @xmath15 will vote for party @xmath16 , @xmath17-@xmath18 says @xmath15 belongs to the age group specified above .
@xmath19 , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 are constants , with the obvious meaning .
@xmath22 @xmath23 , [ 0.35 , 0.41]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath17-@xmath18 .
@xmath24 : @xmath25 , [ 0.55 , 0.61]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath17-@xmath18 .
@xmath26 : @xmath27 , [ 0.8 , 0.86]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath17-@xmath18 . as usual ,
each rule is implicitly universally quantified outside the entire rule .
each rule is expressed in the form @xmath28,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } body\ ] ] where @xmath29 $ ] .
we usually require that @xmath30 and @xmath31 . with each rule ,
we have associated two intervals .
@xmath32 $ ] ( @xmath33 $ ] ) is the _ belief _ ( _ doubt _ ) the expert has in the rule .
notice that from his knowledge , the expert can only conclude that the proportion of people he _ knows _ favor @xmath20 or @xmath21 will not vote for @xmath19 .
thus the probability that a person in the age group 19 - 30 will not vote for liberals , according to the expert s knowledge , is in the range @xmath34 $ ] , obtained by summing the endpoints of the belief ranges for reform and tories . notice that in this case @xmath35 ( or @xmath36 ) is not necessarily @xmath37 .
this shows we can not regard the expert s doubt as the complement ( with respect to 1 ) of his belief .
thus , if we have to model what _ necessarily _ follows according to the expert s knowledge , then we must carry both the belief and the doubt explicitly . note that this example suggests just one possible means by which confidence levels could be obtained from statistical data . as discussed before
, gaps in an expert s knowledge could often directly result in both belief and doubt . in general
, there could be many ways in which both belief and doubt could be obtained and associated with the basic facts . given this
, we believe that an independent treatment of both belief and doubt is both necessary and interesting for the purpose of obtaining the confidence levels associated with derived facts . our approach to independently capture belief and doubt makes it possible to cope with incomplete knowledge regarding the situations in which an event is true , false , or unknown in a general setting .
kifer and li @xcite and baldwin @xcite have argued that incorporating both belief and doubt ( called disbelief there ) is useful in dealing with incomplete knowledge , where different evidences may contradict each other .
however , in their frameworks , doubt need not be maintained explicitly .
for suppose we have a belief @xmath38 and a disbelief @xmath39 associated with a phenomenon .
then they can both be absorbed into one range @xmath40 $ ] indicating that the effective certainty ranges over this set .
the difference with our framework , however , is that we model what is _ known _ definitely , as opposed to what is _
possible_. this makes ( in our case ) an explicit treatment of belief and doubt mandatory .
fitting @xcite has shown that _ bilattices _
( introduced by ginsburg @xcite ) lead to an elegant framework for quantified logic programming involving both belief and doubt . in this section , we shall see that a notion of _ trilattices _ naturally arises with confidence levels .
we shall establish the structure and properties of trilattices here , which will be used in later sections .
[ conf - lattice ] denote by @xmath5 $ ] the set of all closed subintervals over @xmath6 $ ] .
consider the set @xmath7 \times { \cal c}[0 , 1]$ ] .
we denote the elements of @xmath8 as @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] .
define the following orders on this set .
let @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$}}$ ] , @xmath42,~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}$ ] be any two elements of @xmath8 .
@xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } \leq_t { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}$ ] iff @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 , @xmath46 + @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } \leq_k { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}$ ] iff @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath47 , @xmath48 + @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } \leq_p { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}$ ] iff @xmath43 , @xmath49 and @xmath47 , @xmath46 some explanation is in order .
the order @xmath50 can be considered the _ truth _ ordering : truth " relative to the expert s knowledge increases as belief goes up and doubt comes down .
the order @xmath51 is the _ knowledge _ ( or information ) ordering : knowledge " ( the extent to which the expert commits his opinion on an assertion ) increases as both belief and doubt increase .
the order @xmath52 is the _ precision _ ordering : precision " of information supplied increases as the probability intervals become narrower .
the first two orders are analogues of similar orders in bilattices .
the third one , however , has no counterpart there .
it is straightforward to see that each of the orders @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 is a partial order .
@xmath8 has a least and a greatest element with respect to each of these orders . in the following ,
we give the definition of meet and join with respect to the @xmath50 order .
operators with respect to the other orders have a similar definition .
[ meet - join ] let @xmath53 be as defined in definition [ conf - lattice ] .
then the meet and join corresponding to the truth , knowledge ( information ) , and precision orders are defined as follows .
the symbols and denote meet and join , and the subscripts @xmath54 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 represent truth , knowledge , and precision , respectively .
@xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes_t$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}~=~$ ] @xmath57,$ ] @xmath58\rangle$ ] .
\2 . @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \oplus_t$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}~=~$ ] @xmath59 $ ] , @xmath60\rangle$ ] . \3 . @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes_k$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}~=~$ ] @xmath61 $ ] , @xmath60\rangle$ ] .
\4 . @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \oplus_k$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}~=~$ ] @xmath62 $ ] , @xmath58\rangle$ ] . \5 . @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes_p$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}~=~$ ] @xmath63 $ ] , @xmath64\rangle$ ] .
\6 . @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \oplus_p$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}~=~$ ] @xmath65 $ ] , @xmath66\rangle$ ] . the top and bottom elements with respect to the various orders are as follows .
the subscripts indicate the associated orders , as usual .
@xmath67 , [ 0 , 0]\rangle$ ] , @xmath68 , [ 1 , 1]\rangle$ ] , + @xmath69 , [ 1 , 1]\rangle$ ] , @xmath70 , [ 0 , 0]\rangle$ ] , + @xmath71 , [ 1 , 0]\rangle$ ] , @xmath72 , [ 0 , 1]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath73 corresponds to total belief and no doubt ; @xmath74 is the opposite .
@xmath75 represents maximal information ( total belief and doubt ) , to the point of being probabilistically inconsistent : belief and doubt probabilities sum to more than 1 ; @xmath76 gives the least information : no basis for belief or doubt ; @xmath77 is maximally precise , to the point of making the intervals empty ( and hence inconsistent , in a non - probabilistic sense ) ; @xmath78 is the least precise , as it imposes only trivial bounds on belief and doubt probabilities .
fitting @xcite defines a bilattice to be _ interlaced _ whenever the meet and join with respect to any order of the bilattice are monotone with respect to the other order .
he shows that it is the interlaced property of bilattices that makes them most useful and attractive .
we say that a trilattice is _ interlaced _ provided the meet and join with respect to any order are monotone with respect to any other order .
we have [ lem : interlaced ] the trilattice @xmath53 defined above is interlaced .
* proof . * follows directly from the fact that @xmath79 and @xmath80 are monotone functions .
we show the proof for just one case .
let @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } \leq_p { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{3},\beta_{3}],~ [ \gamma_{3},\delta_{3}]\rangle$}}$ ] and @xmath42,~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$ } } \leq_p { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{4},\beta_{4}],~ [ \gamma_{4},\delta_{4}]\rangle$}}$ ] . then @xmath41,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes$}}_t { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$ } } = $ ] @xmath81 , [ max\{\gamma_1 , \gamma_2\ } , max\{\delta_1 , \delta_2\}]\rangle $ ] @xmath82,~ [ \gamma_{3},\delta_{3}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes$}}_t { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{4},\beta_{4}],~ [ \gamma_{4},\delta_{4}]\rangle$ } } = $ ] @xmath83 , [ max\{\gamma_3 , \gamma_4\ } , max\{\delta_3 , \delta_4\}]\rangle$ ] since @xmath84
, we have @xmath85 , and @xmath86 . similarly , @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
this implies @xmath89,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes_t$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$ } } \leq_p { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{3},\beta_{3}],~ [ \gamma_{3},\delta_{3}]\rangle$ } } { \mbox { $ \otimes_t$}}{\mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{4},\beta_{4}],~ [ \gamma_{4},\delta_{4}]\rangle$}}\ ] ] other cases are similar .
trilattices are of independent interest in their own right , from an algebraic point of view .
we also stress that they can be used as a basis for developing quantified / annotated logic programming schemes ( which need not be probabilistic ) .
this will be pursued in a future paper . in closing this section
, we note that other orders are also possible for confidence levels .
in fact , fitting has shown that a fourth order , denoted by @xmath90 in the following , together with the three orders defined above , forms an interlaced `` quadri - lattice '' @xcite .
he also pointed out that this `` quadri - lattice '' can be generated as the cross product of two bilattices .
intuitively , a confidence level increases according to this fourth ordering , when the precision of the belief component of a confidence level goes up , while that of the doubt component goes down .
that is , @xmath89,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$ } } \leq_f { \mbox{$\langle[\alpha_{2},\beta_{2}],~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$ } } \mbox { iff } \alpha_1 \leq \alpha_2 , \beta_2 \leq \beta_1 \mbox { and } \gamma_2 \leq \gamma_1 , \delta_1 \leq \delta_2\ ] ] in our opinion , the fourth order , while technically elegant , does not have the same intuitive appeal as the three orders truth , knowledge , and precision mentioned above . hence
, we do not consider it further in this paper .
the algebraic properties of confidence levels and their underlying lattices are interesting in their own right , and might be used for developing alternative bases for quantitative logic programming .
this issue is orthogonal to the concerns of this paper .
given the confidence levels for ( basic ) events , how are we to derive the confidence levels for compound events which are based on them ? since we are working with probabilities , our combination rules must respect probability theory .
we need a model of our knowledge about the interaction between events . a simplistic model studied in the literature ( see barbara _ et al .
@xcite ) assumes _ independence _ between all pairs of events .
this is highly restrictive and is of limited applicability .
a general model , studied by ng and subrahmanian @xcite is that of _ ignorance _ : assume no knowledge about event interaction .
although this is the most general possible situation , it can be overly conservative when _ some _ knowledge is available , concerning some of the events .
we argue that for real - life " applications , no single model of event interaction would suffice . indeed , we need the ability to parameterize " the model used for event interaction , depending on what _ is _ known about the events themselves . in this section ,
we develop a probabilistic calculus which allows the user to select an appropriate mode " of event interaction , out of several choices , to suit his needs .
let * l * be an arbitrary , but fixed , first - order language with finitely many constants , predicate symbols , infinitely many variables , and no function symbols .
we use ( ground ) atoms of * l * to represent basic events .
we blur the distinction between an event and the formula representing it .
our objective is to characterize confidence levels of boolean combinations of events involving the connectives @xmath91 , in terms of the confidence levels of the underlying basic events under various modes ( see below ) .
we gave an informal discussion of the meaning of confidence levels in section [ motiv ] .
we use the concept of _ possible worlds _ to formalize the semantics of confidence levels .
[ defn : semantics ] ( _ semantics of confidence levels _ ) according to the expert s knowledge , an event @xmath3 can be true , false , or unknown .
this gives rise to 3 possible worlds .
let @xmath92 respectively denote _ true _ , _ false _ , and _
unknown_. let @xmath93 denote the world where the truth - value of @xmath3 is @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and let @xmath96 denote the probability of the world @xmath93 then the assertion that the confidence level of @xmath3 is @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] , written @xmath97,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] , corresponds to the following constraints : @xmath98 where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the lower and upper bounds of the _ belief _ in @xmath3 , and @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the lower and upper bounds of the _ doubt _ in @xmath3 . equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) imposes certain restrictions on confidence levels .
[ defn : consistentcf ] ( _ consistent confidence levels _ ) we say a confidence level @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] is _ consistent _ if equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) has an answer .
it is easily seen that : [ prop : consistentcf ] confidence level @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] is _ consistent _ provided _ ( i ) _ @xmath30 and @xmath31 , and _
( ii ) _ @xmath99 .
the consistency condition guarantees at least one solution to equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) .
however , given a confidence level @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] , there may be @xmath100 values in the @xmath32 $ ] interval for which no @xmath101 value exists in the @xmath33 $ ] interval to form an answer to equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) , and vice versa .
we can `` trim '' the upperbounds of @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] as follows to guarantee that for each value in the @xmath32 $ ] interval there is at least one value in the @xmath33 $ ] interval which form an answer to equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) .
[ defn : reducedcf ] ( _ reduced confidence level _ ) we say a confidence level @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] is _ reduced _ if for all @xmath102 $ ] there exist @xmath101 , @xmath103 such that @xmath100 , @xmath101 , @xmath103 is a solution to equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) , and for all @xmath104 $ ] there exist @xmath100 , @xmath103 such that @xmath100 , @xmath101 , @xmath103 is a solution to equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) .
it is obvious that a reduced confidence level is consistent .
[ prop : reducedcf ] confidence level @xmath9,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] is _ reduced _ provided _ ( i ) _ @xmath30 and @xmath31 , and _
( ii ) _ @xmath105 , and @xmath106 . [ prop : reduction ] let @xmath107,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] be a consistent confidence level .
let @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
then , the confidence level @xmath110 , [ \gamma , min(\delta,\delta')]$ ] is a reduced confidence level .
further , @xmath111 and @xmath112 are probabilistically equivalent , in the sense that they produce exactly the same answer sets to equation ( [ eq : possibleworlds ] ) .
data in a probabilistic deductive database , that is , facts and rules that comprise the database , are associated with confidence levels . at the atomic level
, we require the confidence levels to be consistent .
this means each expert , or data source , should be consistent with respect to the confidence levels it provides .
this does not place any restriction on data provided by different experts / sources , as long as each is individually consistent .
data provided by different experts / sources should be combined , using an appropriate combination mode ( discussed in next section ) .
we will show that the combination formulas for the various modes preserve consistent as well as reduced confidence levels .
now , we introduce the various modes and characterize conjunction and disjunction under these modes .
let @xmath3 and @xmath113 represent two arbitrary ground ( variable - free ) formulas .
for a formula @xmath3 , @xmath114 will denote its confidence level . in the following ,
we describe several interesting and natural modes and establish some results on the confidence levels of conjunction and disjunction under these modes .
some of the modes are well known , although care needs to be taken to allow for the 3-valued nature of our framework . _
ignorance : _ this is the most general situation possible : nothing is assumed / known about event interaction between @xmath3 and @xmath113 . the extent of the interaction between @xmath3 and @xmath113 could range from maximum overlap to minimum overlap .
independence : _ this is a well - known mode . it simply says ( non-)occurrence of one event does not influence that of the other .
positive correlation : _ this mode corresponds to the knowledge that the occurrences of two events overlap as much as possible .
this means the conditional probability of one of the events ( the one with the larger probability ) given the other is 1 .
negative correlation : _ this is the exact opposite of positive correlation : the occurrences of the events overlap minimally .
mutual exclusion : _ this is a special case of negative correlation , where we know that the sum of probabilities of the events does not exceed 1 .
we have the following results .
let @xmath3 be any event , and let @xmath97,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] .
then @xmath115,~[\alpha , \beta]\rangle$ ] .
thus , negation simply swaps belief and doubt .
* follows from the observation that @xmath97,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] implies that @xmath116 and @xmath117 , where @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) denotes the probability of the possible world where event @xmath3 is _ true _ ( _ false _ ) . the following theorem establishes the confidence levels of compound formulas as a function of those of the constituent formulas , under various modes .
[ thm : combinations ] let @xmath3 and @xmath113 be any events and let @xmath118,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$}}$ ] and @xmath119,~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}$ ] .
then the confidence levels of the compound events @xmath120 and @xmath121 are given as follows .
( in each case the subscript denotes the mode . )
@xmath122 @xmath123,$ ] @xmath124 , @xmath125 @xmath126\rangle$ ] .
@xmath127 , [ max\{0 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 -1\}$ ] , @xmath128\rangle$ ] .
@xmath129 , [ 1 - ( 1 - \gamma_1 ) \times ( 1 - \gamma_2 ) , 1 - ( 1 - \delta_1 ) \times ( 1 - \delta_2)]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath130 , [ \gamma_1 \times \gamma_2 , \delta_1 \times \delta_2]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath131 , [ max\{\gamma_1 , \gamma_2\ } , max\{\delta_1 , \delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath132 , [ min\{\gamma_1 , \gamma_2\ } , min\{\delta_1 , \delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath133 @xmath134 , [ min\{1 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2\ } , min\{1 , \delta_1 + \delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath135 @xmath136 , [ max\{0 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 - 1\ } , max\{0 , \delta_1 + \delta_2 - 1\}]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath137 , [ min\{1 , \gamma_1+\gamma_2\ } , min\{1 , \delta_1+\delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] .
@xmath138 , [ max\{0 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 - 1\ } , max\{0 , \delta_1 + \delta_2 - 1\}]\rangle$ ] .
* proof . *
each mode is characterized by a system of constraints , and the confidence level of the formulas @xmath139 are obtained by extremizing certain objective functions subject to these constraints .
the scope of the possible interaction between @xmath3 and @xmath113 can be characterized as follows ( also see @xcite ) . according to the expert s knowledge ,
each of @xmath140 can be true , false , or unknown .
this gives rise to 9 possible worlds .
let @xmath92 respectively denote _ true _ , _ false _ , and _
unknown_. let @xmath141 denote the world where the truth - value of @xmath3 is @xmath94 and that of @xmath113 is @xmath142 , @xmath143 .
, @xmath144 is the world where @xmath3 is true and @xmath113 is false , while @xmath145 is the world where @xmath3 is false and @xmath113 is unknown .
suppose @xmath146 denotes the probability associated with world @xmath141 .
then the possible scope of interaction between @xmath3 and @xmath113 can be characterized by the following constraints .
@xmath147 the above system of constraints must be satisfied for all modes .
specific constraints for various modes are obtained by adding more constraints to those in equation ( [ ign - eq ] ) . in all cases ,
the confidence levels for @xmath148 and @xmath149 are obtained as follows . @xmath150,\\ & & [ min(\sigma_{{\mbox { $ w_{ij}$}}\not \models f\circ g } { \mbox { $ w_{ij}$ } } ) , max(\sigma_{{\mbox { $ w_{ij}$}}\not \models f\circ g } { \mbox { $ w_{ij}$}})]\rangle\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath151 is @xmath152 or @xmath153 . : _
ignorance_. the constraints for ignorance are exactly those in equation ( [ ign - eq ] ) .
the solution to the above linear program can be shown to be @xmath154,$ ] @xmath124 , @xmath125 @xmath126\rangle$ ] , @xmath155 , [ max\{0 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 -1\}$ ] , @xmath128\rangle$ ] .
the proof is very similar to the proof of a similar result in the context of belief intervals ( no doubt ) by ng and subrahmanian @xcite . : _
independence_. independence of events @xmath3 and @xmath113 can be characterized by the equation @xmath156 , where @xmath157 is the conditional probability of the event @xmath3 given event @xmath113 .
more specifically , since in our model an event can be _ true _ , _ false _ , or _ unknown _ , ( in other words , we model belief and doubt independently ) we have : @xmath158 then the constraints characterizing independence is obtained by adding the following equations to the system of constraints ( [ ign - eq ] ) .
@xmath159 the belief in @xmath160 , and doubt in @xmath161 can be easily verified from the system of constraints [ ign - eq ] and [ ind - eq ] @xmath162 to obtain the doubt in @xmath160 we need to compute the minimum and maximum of @xmath163 .
it is easy to verify that : @xmath164 the belief in @xmath161 is obtained similarly ( in the dual manner . )
thus , we have verified that @xmath129 , [ 1 - ( 1 - \gamma_1 ) \times ( 1 - \gamma_2 ) , 1 - ( 1 - \delta_1 ) \times ( 1 - \delta_2)]\rangle$ ] .
+ @xmath130 , [ \gamma_1 \times \gamma_2 , \delta_1 \times \delta_2]\rangle$ ] . : _ positive correlation _ : two events @xmath3 and @xmath113 are positively correlated if they overlap as much as possible .
this happens when either ( _ i _ ) occurrence of @xmath3 implies occurrence of @xmath113 , or ( _ ii _ ) occurrence of @xmath113 implies occurrence of @xmath3 . in our framework
we model belief and doubt independently , and positive correlation is characterized by 4 possibilities : \(a ) occurrence of @xmath3 implies occurrence of @xmath113 , and non - occurrence of @xmath113 implies non - occurrence of @xmath3 .
+ ( b ) occurrence of @xmath3 implies occurrence of @xmath113 , and non - occurrence of @xmath3 implies non - occurrence of @xmath113 .
+ ( c ) occurrence of @xmath113 implies occurrence of @xmath3 , and non - occurrence of @xmath113 implies non - occurrence of @xmath3 .
+ ( d ) occurrence of @xmath113 implies occurrence of @xmath3 , and non - occurrence of @xmath3 implies non - occurrence of @xmath113 .
each of these four condition sets generates its own equations . for example , ( a ) can be captured by adding the following equations to the system of constraints [ ign - eq ] .
@xmath165 hence , for condition ( a ) , the system of constraints [ ign - eq ] becomes @xmath166 the analysis is further complicated by the fact that the confidence levels of @xmath3 and @xmath113 determine which of these cases apply , and it may be different for the lowerbound and upperbound probabilities .
for example , if @xmath167 ( @xmath168 ) , then the lowerbound ( upperbound ) for belief in @xmath169 is obtained when occurrence of @xmath3 implies occurrence of @xmath113 .
otherwise , these bounds are obtained when occurrence of @xmath113 implies occurrence of @xmath3 .
the solution to these linear programs can be shown to be @xmath170 , [ max\{\gamma_1 , \gamma_2\ } , max\{\delta_1 , \delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] , and + @xmath132 , [ min\{\gamma_1 , \gamma_2\ } , min\{\delta_1 , \delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] .
a more intuitive approach to the derivation of confidence levels for conjunction and disjunction of positively correlated events is to rely on the observation that these events overlap to the maximum extent possible . in our framework
it means the worlds where @xmath3 is _ true _ and those where @xmath113 is _ true _ overlap maximally , and hence , one is included in the other .
similarly , since we model belief and doubt independently , the worlds where @xmath3 is _ false _ and those where @xmath113 is _ false _ also overlap maximally .
the combination formulas can be derived directly using these observations . : _ negative correlation _ :
negative correlation is an appropriate mode to use whenever we know that events @xmath3 and @xmath113 overlap as little as possible .
this is to be contrasted with positive correlation , where the extent of overlap is the greatest possible .
mutual exclusion , is a special case of negative correlation where the sum of the probabilities of the two events does not exceed 1 . in this case
the two events do not overlap at all . in the classical framework , mutual exclusion of two events @xmath3 and @xmath113
is characterized by the statement : ( _ i _ ) occurrence of @xmath3 implies non - occurrence of @xmath113 , and vice versa . on the other hand ,
if the two events @xmath3 and @xmath113 are negatively correlated but not mutually exclusive , we have : ( _ ii _ ) non - occurrence of @xmath3 implies occurrence of @xmath113 , and vice versa . in case ( _ i _ ) the sum of the probabilities of the two events is at most 1 , while in case ( _ ii _ )
this sum exceeds 1 and hence the two events can not be mutually exclusive . in our framework
we model belief and doubt independently , and each of the above conditions translates to two conditions as follows .
note that in our framework , `` not _ true _ '' means `` _ false _ or _ unknown _ '' , and `` not _ false _ '' means `` _ true _ or _ unknown _ '' .
* event @xmath3 is _ true _ implies @xmath113 is not _ true _ , and vice versa .
this condition generates the equation @xmath171 . *
the dual of condition ( a ) , when the non - occurrence of the two events do nt overlap .
event @xmath3 is _ false _ implies @xmath113 is not _
false _ , and vice versa .
this condition generates the equation @xmath172 .
* event @xmath3 is not _ true _ implies @xmath113 is _ true _ , and vice versa .
this condition generates the equations @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 , and @xmath176 . *
the dual of ( _ c _ ) , @xmath3 is not _
_ implies @xmath113 is _ false _ , and vice versa , which generates the equations @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 , and @xmath176 .
similar to the case for positive correlation , the confidence levels of @xmath3 and @xmath113 determine which of these cases apply .
for example , if @xmath180 , then case ( c ) should be used to determine the lowerbound for belief in @xmath181 .
alternatively , and more intuitively , we can characterize negative correlation by observing that the worlds where @xmath3 is _ true _ and those where @xmath113 is _ true _ overlap minimally , and the worlds where @xmath3 is _ false _ and those where @xmath113 is _ false _ also overlap minimally .
the confidences of @xmath148 and @xmath121 can be obtained using the equations , or directly from the alternative characterization : @xmath133 @xmath134 , [ min\{1 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2\ } , min\{1 , \delta_1 + \delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] @xmath135 @xmath136 , [ max\{0 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 - 1\ } , max\{0 , \delta_1 + \delta_2 - 1\}]\rangle$ ] : _ mutual exclusion _ : mutual exclusion is a special case of negative correlation .
the main difference is that it requires the sum of the two probabilities to be at most 1 , which is not necessarily the case for negative correlation ( see the previous case ) . in the classical framework ,
if two events are mutually exclusive , their negation are not necessarily mutually exclusive .
rather , they are negatively correlated . in our framework , however , one or both conditions ( _ a _ ) and ( _ b _ ) , discussed in the previous case , can hold .
the appropriate condition is determined by the confidence levels of the two mutually exclusive events , and the corresponding combination formula can be obtained from the combination formulas of negative correlation .
the following formulas , for example , are for mutually exclusive events @xmath3 and @xmath113 where @xmath182 ( but no other restriction ) .
@xmath137 , [ min\{1 , \gamma_1+\gamma_2\ } , min\{1 , \delta_1+\delta_2\}]\rangle$ ] . + @xmath138 , [ max\{0 , \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 - 1\ } , max\{0 , \delta_1 + \delta_2 - 1\}]\rangle$ ] . next , we show that the combination formulas for various modes preserve consistent as well as reduced confidence levels . the case for reduced confidence levels
is more involved and will be presented first .
the other case is similar , for which we only state the theorem .
[ thm : reduced ] suppose @xmath3 and @xmath113 are any formulas and assume their confidence levels are reduced ( definition [ defn : reducedcf ] ) .
then the confidence levels of the formulas @xmath148 and @xmath121 , obtained under the various modes above are all reduced .
* let @xmath118,~ [ \gamma_{1},\delta_{1}]\rangle$}}$ ] and @xmath119,~ [ \gamma_{2},\delta_{2}]\rangle$}}$ ] .
since the confidence levels of @xmath3 and @xmath113 are reduced , we have : @xmath183 + @xmath184 + @xmath185 + @xmath186 + the consistency of the confidence levels of the combination events @xmath148 and @xmath121 in different modes as derived in theorem [ thm : combinations ] follow from the above constraints . for example
let us consider @xmath187 , [ max\{\gamma_1 , \gamma_2\ } , min\{1 , \delta_1 + \delta_2\}]\rangle\ ] ] we need to show \(1 ) @xmath188 + ( 2 ) @xmath189 + ( 3 ) @xmath190 + ( 4 ) @xmath191 to prove ( 1 ) : if @xmath192 then ( 1 ) holds
. otherwise , assume , without loss of generality , that @xmath193 .
we can write @xmath194 + @xmath195 and hence @xmath196 and ( 1 ) follows .
inequality ( 2 ) follows easily from @xmath197 . to prove ( 3 ) : if @xmath192 then ( 3 ) holds .
otherwise , we can write @xmath198 + @xmath199 and hence @xmath200 and ( 3 ) follows . note that if @xmath201 then @xmath202 follows from the above constraint . to prove ( 4 ) let @xmath203 and @xmath204 where @xmath205 . then @xmath206 .
proving the consistency of the confidence levels of other combinations and other modes are similar and will not be elaborated here .
[ thm : consistent ] suppose @xmath3 and @xmath113 are any formulas and assume their confidence levels are consistent ( definition [ defn : consistentcf ] ) .
then the confidence levels of the formulas @xmath148 and @xmath121 , obtained under the various modes above are all consistent .
* proof is similar to the previous theorem and is omitted .
in this section , we develop a framework for probabilistic deductive databases using a language of probabilistic programs ( p - programs ) .
we make use of the probabilistic calculus developed in section [ prob - calc ] and develop the syntax and declarative semantics for programming with confidence levels .
we also provide the fixpoint semantics of programs in this framework and establish its equivalence to the declarative semantics .
we will use the first - order language * l * of section [ prob - calc ] as the underlying logical language in this section .
* syntax of p - programs : * a _ rule _ is an expression of the form @xmath207 , @xmath208 , where @xmath209 are atoms and @xmath210,~ [ \gamma,\delta]\rangle$}}$ ] is the confidence level associated with the rule ) . ] .
when @xmath211 , we call this a _ fact_. all variables in the rule are assumed to be universally quantified outside the whole rule , as usual . we restrict attention to range restricted rules , as is customary .
a _ probabilistic rule _
( p - rule ) is a triple @xmath212 , where @xmath213 is a rule , @xmath214 is a mode indicating how to conjoin the confidence levels of the subgoals in the body of @xmath213 ( and with that of @xmath213 itself ) , and @xmath215 is a mode indicating how the confidence levels of different derivations of an atom involving the head predicate of @xmath213 are to be disjoined .
we say @xmath214 ( @xmath216 is the mode associated with the body ( head ) of @xmath213 , and call it the _ conjunctive _ ( _ disjunctive _ ) mode .
we refer to @xmath213 as the underlying rule of this p - rule .
when @xmath213 is a fact , we omit @xmath214 for obvious reasons .
a _ probabilistic program _
( p - program ) is a finite collection of p - rules such that whenever there are p - rules whose underlying rules define the same predicate , the mode associated with their head is identical .
this last condition ensures different rules defining the same predicate @xmath217 agree on the manner in which confidences of identical @xmath217-atoms generated by these rules are to be combined .
the notions of herbrand universe @xmath218 and herbrand base @xmath219 associated with a p - program @xmath16 are defined as usual .
a p - rule is ground exactly when every atom in it is ground .
the herbrand instantiation @xmath220 of a p - program is defined in the obvious manner .
the following example illustrates our framework .
[ medical - ex ] people are assessed to be at high risk for various diseases , depending on factors such as age group , family history ( with respect to the disease ) , etc .
accordingly , high risk patients are administered appropriate medications , which are prescribed by doctors among several alternative ones .
medications cause side effects , sometimes harmful ones , leading to other symptoms and diseases . here , the extent of risk , administration of medications , side effects ( caused by medications ) , and prognosis are all uncertain phenomena , and we associate confidence levels with them . the following program is a sample of the uncertain knowledge related to these phenomena .
@xmath221-@xmath222 @xmath223 , [ 0.1,0.1]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath224 , @xmath225-@xmath226 @xmath227 .
@xmath228 @xmath229 , [ 0,0]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath230-@xmath222 , @xmath231 @xmath232 .
@xmath233 @xmath234 , [ 0.12,0.12]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath230-@xmath235 .
@xmath233 @xmath236 , [ 0.70,0.70]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } $ ] @xmath237 , @xmath238-@xmath239 @xmath240 .
we can assume an appropriate set of facts ( the edb ) in conjunction with the above program .
for rule 1 , it is easy to see that each ground atom involving the predicate @xmath230-@xmath241 has at most one derivation . thus , a disjunctive mode for this rule will be clearly redundant , and we have suppressed it for convenience .
a similar remark holds for rule 2 .
rule 1 says that if a person is midaged and the disease @xmath242 has struck his ancestors , then the confidence level in the person being at high risk for @xmath242 is given by propagating the confidence levels of the body subgoals and combining them with the rule confidence in the sense of @xmath243 .
this could be based on an expert s belief that the factors @xmath244 and @xmath225-@xmath245 contributing to high risk for the disease are independent .
each of the other rules has a similar explanation .
for the last rule , we note that the potential of a medication to cause side effects is an intrinsic property independent of whether one takes the medication .
thus the conjunctive mode used there is independence .
finally , note that rules 3 and 4 , defining @xmath246 , use positive correlation as a conservative way of combining confidences obtained from different derivations . for simplicity , we show each interval in the above rules as a point probability .
still , note that the confidences for atoms derived from the program will be genuine intervals .
* a valuation based semantics : * we develop the declarative semantics of p - programs based on the notion of valuations .
let @xmath16 be a p - program .
probabilistic valuation _ is a function @xmath247 which associates a confidence level with each ground atom in @xmath219 .
we define the satisfaction of p - programs under valuations , with respect to the truth order @xmath50 of the trilattice ( see section [ prob - calc ] ) .
we say a valuation @xmath248 _ satisfies _ a ground p - rule @xmath249 , denoted @xmath250 , provided @xmath251 @xmath252 .
the intended meaning is that in order to satisfy this p - rule , @xmath248 must assign a confidence level to @xmath253 that is no less true ( in the sense of @xmath50 ) than the result of the conjunction of the confidences assigned to @xmath254 s by @xmath248 and the rule confidence @xmath111 , in the sense of the mode @xmath214 .
even when a valuation satisfies ( all ground instances of ) each rule in a p - program , it may not satisfy the p - program as a whole .
the reason is that confidences coming from different derivations of atoms are combined strengthening the overall confidence .
thus , we need to impose the following additional requirement .
let @xmath255 be a ground p - rule , and @xmath248 a valuation .
then we denote by @xmath256-@xmath257 the confidence level propagated to the head of this rule under the valuation @xmath248 and the rule mode @xmath214 , given by the expression @xmath258 .
let @xmath259 be the partition of @xmath220 such that ( i ) each @xmath260 contains all ( ground ) p - rules which define the same atom , say @xmath261 , and ( ii ) @xmath261 and @xmath262 are distinct , whenever @xmath263 .
suppose @xmath264 is the mode associated with the head of the p - rules in @xmath260 .
we denote by @xmath265-@xmath266 the confidence level determined for the atom @xmath261 under the valuation @xmath248 using the program @xmath16 .
this is given by the expression @xmath267-@xmath268 .
we now define satisfaction of p - programs .
[ def : satisfaction ] let @xmath16 be a p - program and @xmath248 a valuation .
then @xmath248 satisfies @xmath16 , denoted @xmath269 exactly when @xmath248 satisfies each ( ground ) p - rule in @xmath220 , and for all atoms @xmath270 , @xmath265-@xmath271 .
the additional requirement ensures the valuation assigns a strong enough confidence to each atom so it will support the combination of confidences coming from a number of rules ( pertaining to this atom ) .
a p - program @xmath16 logically implies a p - fact @xmath272 , denoted @xmath273 , provided every valuation satisfying @xmath16 also satisfies @xmath272 .
we next have let @xmath248 be a valuation and @xmath16 a p - program .
suppose the mode associated with the head of each p - rule in @xmath16 is positive correlation .
then @xmath269 iff @xmath248 satisfies each rule in @xmath220 .
* proof*. we shall show that if @xmath256-@xmath274 for all rules @xmath275 defining a ground atom @xmath253 , then @xmath265-@xmath271 , where the disjunctive mode for @xmath253 is positive correlation .
this follows from the formula for @xmath276 , obtained in theorem [ thm : combinations ] .
it is easy to see that @xmath277 .
but then , @xmath256-@xmath274 implies that @xmath278-@xmath279 and hence @xmath265-@xmath271 .
the above proposition shows that when positive correlation is the only disjunctive mode used , satisfaction is very similar to the classical case . for the declarative semantics of p - programs ,
we need something like the least " valuation satisfying the program .
it is straightforward to show that the class of all valuations @xmath280 from @xmath219 to @xmath8 itself forms a trilattice , complete with all the 3 orders and the associated meets and joins .
they are obtained by a pointwise extension of the corresponding order / operation on the trilattice @xmath8 .
we give one example . for valuations
@xmath281 , @xmath282 iff @xmath283 , @xmath284 ; @xmath283 , @xmath285 .
one could investigate least " with respect to each of the 3 orders of the trilattice . in this paper
, we confine attention to the order @xmath50 .
the least ( greatest ) valuation is then the valuation * false * ( * true * ) which assigns the confidence level @xmath74 ( @xmath73 ) to every ground atom .
we now have [ lem : lvaluation ] let @xmath16 be any p - program and @xmath281 be any valuations satisfying @xmath16 .
then @xmath286 is also a valuation satisfying @xmath16 .
in particular , @xmath287 is the least valuation satisfying @xmath16 . *
* we prove this in two steps .
first , we show that for any ground p - rule + @xmath255 + whenever valuations @xmath288 and @xmath248 satisfy @xmath289 , so does @xmath286 .
secondly , we shall show that for a p - program @xmath16 , whenever _ atom - conf_@xmath290 and _ atom - conf_@xmath291 , then we also have _ atom - conf_@xmath292 .
the lemma will follow from this .
\(1 ) suppose @xmath293 and @xmath294 .
we prove the case where the conjunctive mode @xmath214 associated with this rule is ignorance .
the other cases are similar .
it is straightforward to verify the following .
\(i ) @xmath295 .
+ ( ii ) @xmath296 . from ( i ) and
( ii ) , we have @xmath297 , showing @xmath298 .
\(2 ) suppose @xmath281 are any two valuations satisfying a p - program @xmath16 .
let @xmath299 be the set of all ground p - rules in @xmath220 whose heads are @xmath253 .
let @xmath300 _ rule - conf_@xmath301 and @xmath302 _ rule - conf_@xmath303 .
since @xmath304 and @xmath305 , we have that @xmath306 and @xmath307 , where @xmath215 is the disjunctive mode associated with @xmath253 .
again , we give the proof for the case @xmath215 is ignorance as the other cases are similar .
let @xmath308 _ rule - conf_@xmath309 .
clearly , @xmath310 and @xmath311 .
thus , @xmath312 and @xmath313 .
it then follows that @xmath314 , which was to be shown .
we take the least valuation satisfying a p - program as characterizing its declarative semantics .
consider the following p - program @xmath16 .
@xmath315,~[0.3,0.45]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } ~b;~~ind,~pc)$ ] .
@xmath316,~[0.1,0.2]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } ~c;~~ign,~pc)$ ] . + 3 .
@xmath317,~[0,0.1]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } ; ~~\_,~ind)$ ] . 4 .
@xmath318,~[0.1,0.2]\rangle}}{{\mbox{$<\hspace*{-9pt } \rule[2pt]{80pt}{0.5pt}$ } } } $ } } ; ~~\_,~ind)$ ] . in the following
we show three valuations @xmath319 , of which @xmath320 and @xmath321 satisfy @xmath16 , while @xmath322 does not .
in fact , @xmath321 is the least valuation satisfying @xmath16 .
@xmath323,~[0,0]\rangle & \langle[0.8,0.9],~[0.05,0.1]\rangle & \langle[0.5,0.9],~[0,0]\rangle \\ v_2 & \langle[0.9,1],~[0,0]\rangle & \langle[0.9,1],~[0,0]\rangle & \langle[0.5,0.7],~[0.1,0.4]\rangle \\
v_3 & \langle[0.9,0.95],~[0,0.1]\rangle & \langle[0.7,0.8],~[0.1,0.2]\rangle & \langle[0.45,0.8],~[0.1,0.4]\rangle \end{array}$ ] for example , consider @xmath320 .
it is easy to verify that @xmath320 satisfies @xmath16 .
rules 1 through 4 are satisfied by @xmath320 since : @xmath324,~[0.3,0.45]\rangle \wedge_{ind } \langle[0.9,1],~[0,0]\rangle = \langle[0.45,0.7],~[0,0]\rangle \le_t \langle[0.5,0.9],~[0,0]\rangle$ ] @xmath325,~[0.1,0.2]\rangle \wedge_{ign } \langle[0.8,0.9],~[0.05,0.1]\rangle = $ ] @xmath326,~[0.1,0.3]\rangle \le_t \langle[0.5,0.9],~[0,0]\rangle$ ] @xmath327,~[0,0.1]\rangle \le_t \langle[0.9,1],~[0,0]\rangle$ ] @xmath328,~[0.1,0.2]\rangle \le_t \langle[0.8,0.9],~[0.05,0.1]\rangle$ ] further , the confidence level of @xmath253 computed by the combination of rules 1 and 2 is also satisfied by @xmath320 , namely , @xmath329,~[0.3,0.45]\rangle \wedge_{ind } \langle[0.9,1],~[0,0]\rangle ) \vee_{pc } ( \langle[0.6,0.8],~[0.1,0.2]\rangle$ ] @xmath330,~[0.05,0.1]\rangle ) = \langle[0.45,0.8],~[0,0 ] \le_t \langle[0.5,0.9],~[0,0]\rangle$ ] * fixpoint semantics : * we associate an immediate consequence " operator @xmath1 with a p - program @xmath16 , defined as follows .
[ tp - defn ] let @xmath16 be a p - program and @xmath220 its herbrand instantiation .
then @xmath1 is a function @xmath331 , defined as follows .
for any probabilistic valuation @xmath248 , and any ground atom @xmath270 , @xmath332 there exists a p - rule @xmath333 such that @xmath334 . call a valuation @xmath248 _ consistent _ provided for every atom @xmath253 , @xmath335 is consistent , as defined in section [ lattice ] .
[ thm : tpmonotone ] ( 1 ) @xmath1 always maps consistent valuations to consistent valuations .
( 2 ) @xmath1 is monotone and continuous .
* proof . *
( 1 ) this fact follows theorem [ thm : consistent ] , where we have shown that the combination functions for all modes map consistent confidence levels to consistent confidence levels . ( 2 ) this follows from the fact that the combination functions for all modes are themselves monotone and continuous .
we define bottom - up iterations based on @xmath1 in the usual manner .
+ @xmath336 ( which assigns the truth - value @xmath74 to every ground atom ) .
+ @xmath337 , for a successor ordinal @xmath10 .
+ @xmath338 , for a limit ordinal @xmath10 .
we have the following results . [ prop : fixpoint ] let @xmath248 be any valuation and @xmath16 be a p - program
. then @xmath248 satisfies @xmath16 iff @xmath339 .
* proof . * _ ( only if ) .
_ if @xmath248 satisfies @xmath16 , then by definition [ def : satisfaction ] , for all atoms @xmath270 , @xmath265-@xmath271 and hence @xmath339 . _
_ if @xmath339 , then by the definition of @xmath1 ( definition [ tp - defn ] ) for all atoms @xmath270 , @xmath265-@xmath271 and hence @xmath248 satisfies @xmath16 .
the following theorem is the analogue of the van emden - kowalski theorem for classical logic programming .
[ thm : lfplvaluation ] let @xmath16 be a p - program . then the following claims hold
. + ( i ) @xmath340 the @xmath50-least valuation satisfying @xmath16 .
+ ( ii ) for a ground atom @xmath253 , @xmath341 iff @xmath273 . *
* follows lemma [ lem : lvaluation ] , theorem [ thm : tpmonotone ] and proposition [ prop : fixpoint ] .
proof is similar to the analogous theorem of logic programming and details are omitted .
since confidences coming from different derivations of a fact are combined , we need a notion of disjunctive proof - trees .
we note that the notions of substitution , unification , etc .
are analogous to the classical ones .
a variable appearing in a rule is _ local _ if it only appears in its body .
[ dpt ] let @xmath113 be a(n atomic ) goal and @xmath16 a p - program .
then a _ disjunctive proof - tree _ ( dpt ) for @xmath113 with respect to @xmath16 is a tree @xmath342 defined as follows .
@xmath342 has two kinds of nodes : _ rule _ nodes and _ goal _ nodes .
each rule node is labeled by a rule in @xmath16 and a substitution .
each goal node is labeled by an atomic goal .
the root is a goal node labeled @xmath113 .
let @xmath288 be a goal node labeled by an atom @xmath253 . then
every child ( if any ) of @xmath288 is a rule node labeled @xmath343 , where @xmath213 is a rule in @xmath16 whose head is unifiable with @xmath253 using the mgu @xmath344 .
we assume that each time a rule @xmath213 appears in the tree , its variables are renamed to new variables that do not appear anywhere else in the tree .
hence @xmath213 in the label @xmath343 actually represents a renamed instance of the rule .
if @xmath288 is a rule node labeled @xmath343 , then whenever an atom @xmath345 occurs in the body of @xmath346 , @xmath288 has a goal child @xmath248 labeled @xmath345 .
+ 4 . for any two substitutions
@xmath347 occurring in @xmath342 , @xmath348 , for every variable @xmath349 . in other words ,
all substitutions occurring in @xmath342 are compatible . a node without children
is called a leaf .
a _ proper _ dpt is a finite dpt @xmath342 such that whenever @xmath342 has a goal leaf labeled @xmath253 , there is no rule in @xmath16 whose head is unifiable with @xmath253 .
we only consider proper dpts unless otherwise specified .
a rule leaf is a _
node ( represents a database fact ) while a goal leaf is a _ failure _ node .
* remarks : * \(1 ) the definition of disjunctive proof tree captures the idea that when working with uncertain information in the form of probabilistic rules and facts , we need to consider the disjunction of all proofs in order to determine the best possible confidence in the goal being proved .
\(2 ) however , notice that the definition does _ not _ insist that a goal node @xmath253 should have rule children corresponding to all possible unifiable rules and mgu s .
\(3 ) we assume without loss of generality that all rules in the p - program are standardized apart by variable renaming so they share no common variables .
\(4 ) a goal node can have several rule children corresponding to the same rule .
that is , a goal node can have children labeled @xmath350 , where @xmath213 is ( a renamed version of ) a rule in the program .
but we require that @xmath351 , @xmath352 , be distinct .
\(5 ) we require all substitutions in the tree to be compatible .
the convention explained above ensures there will be no conflict among them on account of common variables across rules ( or different invocations of the same rule ) .
\(6 ) note that a dpt can be finite or infinite .
\(7 ) in a proper dpt , goal leaves are necessarily failure nodes ; this is not true in non - proper dpts .
\(8 ) a proper dpt with no failure nodes has only rule leaves , hence , it has an odd height .
confidences are associated with ( finite ) dpts as follows .
[ dpt - conf ] let @xmath16 be a p - program , @xmath113 a goal , and @xmath342 any finite dpt for @xmath113 with respect to @xmath16 .
we associate confidences with the nodes of @xmath342 as follows .
each failure node gets the confidence @xmath353,~[1,1]\rangle$}}$ ] , the * false * confidence level with respect to truth ordering , @xmath74 ( see section [ lattice ] ) .
each success node labeled @xmath343 , where @xmath213 is a rule in @xmath16 , and @xmath111 is the confidence of rule @xmath213 , gets the confidence @xmath111 .
suppose @xmath288 is a rule node labeled @xmath343 , such that the confidence of @xmath213 is @xmath111 , its ( conjunctive ) mode is @xmath214 , and the confidences of the children of @xmath288 are @xmath354 .
then @xmath288 gets the confidence @xmath355 .
suppose @xmath288 is a goal node labeled @xmath253 , with a ( disjunctive ) mode @xmath215 such that the confidences of its children are @xmath356 .
then @xmath288 gets the confidence @xmath357 .
we recall the notions of identity and annihilator from algebra ( see ullman @xcite ) .
let @xmath358 be any element of the confidence lattice and @xmath359 be any operation of the form @xmath360 or of the form @xmath361 , @xmath362 being any of the modes discussed in section [ prob - calc ] .
then @xmath111 is an _ identity _ with respect to @xmath359 , if @xmath363 .
it is an _ annihilator _ with respect to @xmath359 , if @xmath364 .
the proof of the following proposition is straightforward .
[ identity - annihilator ] the truth - value @xmath365,~[1,1]\rangle$}}$ ] is an identity with respect to disjunction and an annihilator with respect to conjunction .
the truth - value @xmath366,~[0,0]\rangle$}}$ ] is an identity with respect to conjunction and an annihilator with respect to disjunction .
these claims hold for all modes discussed in section [ prob - calc ] . in view of this proposition
, we can consider only dpts without failure nodes without losing any generality .
we now proceed to prove the soundness and completeness theorems .
first , we need some definitions .
a _ branch _ @xmath345 of a dpt @xmath342 is a set of nodes of @xmath342 , defined as follows .
the root of @xmath342 belongs to @xmath345 .
whenever a goal node is in @xmath345 , exactly one of its rule children ( if any ) belongs to @xmath345 .
finally , whenever a rule node belongs to @xmath345 , all its goal children belong to @xmath345 .
we extend this definition to the subtrees of a dpt in the obvious way .
a _ subbranch _ of @xmath342 rooted at a goal node @xmath113 is the branch of the subtree of @xmath342 rooted at @xmath113 .
we can associate a substitution with a ( sub)branch @xmath345 as follows .
( 1 ) the substitution associated with a success node labeled @xmath343 is just @xmath344 .
( 2 ) the substitution associated with an internal goal node is simply the substitution associated with its unique rule child in @xmath345 .
( 3 ) the substitution associated with an internal rule node @xmath288 in @xmath345 which is labeled @xmath343 is the composition of @xmath344 and the substitutions associated with the goal children of @xmath288 . the substitution associated with a branch is that associated with its root .
we say a dpt @xmath342 is _ well - formed _ if it satisfies the following conditions : ( i ) @xmath342 is proper , ( ii ) for every goal node @xmath113 in @xmath342 , for any two ( sub)branches @xmath367 of @xmath342 rooted at @xmath113 , the substitutions associated with @xmath368 and @xmath369 are distinct .
the second condition ensures no two branches correspond to the same classical proof " of the goal or a sub - goal . without this condition ,
since the probabilistic conjunctions and disjunctions are not idempotent , the confidence of the same proof could be wrongly combined giving an incorrect confidence for the ( root of the ) dpt .
henceforth , we will only consider well - formed dpts , namely , dpts that are proper , have no failure nodes , and have distinct substitutions for all ( sub ) branches corresponding to a goal node , for all goal nodes .
[ soundness ] [ soundness ] let @xmath16 be a p - program and @xmath113 a ( ground ) goal . if there is a finite well - formed dpt for @xmath113 with respect to @xmath16 with an associated confidence @xmath111 at its root , then @xmath370 .
* proof . *
first , we make the following observations regarding the combination functions of theorem [ thm : combinations ] : \(1 ) conjunctive combination functions ( all modes ) are monotone .
+ ( 2 ) disjunctive combination functions ( all modes ) are monotone .
+ ( 3 ) if @xmath3 and @xmath113 are confidence levels , then @xmath371 and @xmath372 for all conjunctive and disjunctive combination functions ( all modes ) .
we prove the soundness theorem by induction on the height of the dpt .
assume the well - formed dpt @xmath342 of height @xmath373 is for the goal @xmath113 .
note that @xmath342 has an odd height , @xmath374 for some @xmath375 , since it is a proper dpt with no failure nodes ( see remark 7 at the beginning of this section ) . :
@xmath376 . in this case
the dpt consists of the goal root labeled @xmath113 and one child labeled @xmath377 , where @xmath213 is a rule in @xmath16 whose head is unifiable with @xmath113 .
note that this child node is a success leaf .
it represents a fact . obviously , in the first iteration of @xmath1 , @xmath378 , where @xmath379 is the confidence level of @xmath213 .
it follows from the monotonicity of @xmath1 , that @xmath380 . :
@xmath381 . assume the inductive hypothesis holds for every dpt of height @xmath382 , where @xmath383 .
consider the dpt @xmath342 for @xmath113 .
the root @xmath113 has rule children @xmath384 labeled @xmath385 .
each @xmath384 is either a fact , or has goal children @xmath386 .
consider the subtrees of @xmath342 rooted at these goal grand children of @xmath113 . by the inductive hypothesis , the confidence levels @xmath387 associated with the goal grand children @xmath388 by the dpt are less than or equal to their confidence levels calculated by @xmath1 , , @xmath389 .
hence , by properties ( 1)-(3 ) above , the confidence level associated to @xmath113 by @xmath342 is less than or equal to the confidence level of @xmath113 obtained by another application of @xmath1 , @xmath390 .
hence @xmath370 .
note that @xmath342 must be well - formed otherwise this argument is not valid .
[ completeness ] [ completeness ] let @xmath16 be a p - program and @xmath113 a goal such that for some number @xmath391 , @xmath392 .
then there is a finite dpt @xmath342 for @xmath113 with respect to @xmath16 with an associated confidence @xmath111 at its root , such that @xmath393 .
* let @xmath55 be the smallest number such that @xmath394 .
we shall show by induction on @xmath55 that there is a dpt @xmath342 for @xmath113 with respect to @xmath16 such that the confidence computed by it is at least @xmath395 . :
this implies @xmath397,~[1,1]\rangle$}}$ ] .
this case is trivial .
the dpt consists of a failure node labeled @xmath113 . :
suppose the result holds for a certain number @xmath398 .
we show that it also holds for @xmath399 .
suppose @xmath253 is a ground atom such that @xmath400 .
now , @xmath401 there exists a rule @xmath213 such that @xmath214 is the mode associated with its body , and @xmath215 is the mode associated with its head , and there exists a ground substitution @xmath344 such that @xmath402 .
consider the dpt for @xmath253 obtained as follows .
let the root be labeled @xmath253 .
the root has a rule child corresponding to each rule instance used in the above computation of @xmath403 .
let @xmath248 be a rule child created at this step , and suppose @xmath404 is the rule instance corresponding to it and let @xmath344 be the substitution used to unify the head of the original rule with the atom @xmath253 .
then @xmath248 has @xmath405 goal children with labels @xmath406 respectively . finally , by induction hypothesis
, we can assume that ( i ) a dpt for @xmath254 is rooted at the node labeled @xmath254 , and ( ii ) the confidence computed by this latter tree is at least @xmath407 , @xmath408 .
in this case , it readily follows from the definition of the confidence computed by a proof - tree that the confidence computed by @xmath342 is at least @xmath409 is a rule defining @xmath253 , @xmath379 is the confidence associated with it , @xmath214 is the mode associated with its head , and @xmath215 is the mode associated with its body@xmath410 .
but this confidence is exactly @xmath403 .
the induction is complete and the theorem follows .
theorems [ soundness ] and [ completeness ] together show that the confidence of an arbitrary ground atom computed according to the fixpoint semantics and using an appropriate disjunctive proof tree is the same .
this in turn is the same as the confidence associated according to the ( valuation based ) declarative semantics .
in particular , as we will discuss in section [ termination ] , when the disjunctive mode associated with all recursive predicates is positive correlation , the theorems guarantee that the exact confidence associated with the goal can be effectively computed by constructing an appropriate finite dpt ( according to theorem [ completeness ] ) for it .
even when these modes _ are _ used indiscriminately , we can still obtain the confidence associated with the goal with an arbitrarily high degree of accuracy , by constructing dpts of appropriate height .
in this section , we first compare our work with that of ng and subrahmanian @xcite ( see section [ intro ] for a general comparison with non - probabilistic frameworks ) . first , let us examine the ( only ) mode " for disjunction used by them .
they combine the confidences of an atom @xmath253 coming from different derivations by taking their intersection . indeed , the bottom of their lattice is a valuation ( called formula function " there ) that assigns the interval @xmath0 $ ] to every atom . from the trilattice structure ,
it is clear that ( i ) their bottom corresponds to @xmath78 , and ( ii ) their disjunctive mode corresponds to @xmath411 .
[ problem1 ] @xmath412 : @xmath413 { \mbox{$\leftarrow$}}e(x , z ) : [ v_1 , v_2 ] , ~~$]@xmath414 $ ] . + @xmath415 : @xmath416 { \mbox{$\leftarrow$}}e(x , y ) : [ v_1 , v_2]$ ]
. + @xmath417 : @xmath418 $ ] .
+ @xmath419 : @xmath420 $ ] .
+ @xmath421 : @xmath422 $ ] .
this is a pf - program in the framework of ng and subrahmanian @xcite . in a pf - rule
each literal is annotated by an interval representing the lower - bound and upper - bound of belief .
variables can appear in the annotations , and the annotation of the head predicate is usually a function of body literals annotations .
the program in this example is basically the transitive closure program , with independence as the conjunctive mode in the first rule .
the disjunctive function for the @xmath56 predicate , as explained above , is interval intersection .
let us denote the operator @xmath1 defined by them as @xmath423 for distinguishing it from ours .
it is not hard to see that this program is inconsistent in their framework , and @xmath424would assign an empty probability range for @xmath425 .
this is due to the existence of two derivations for @xmath425 , with non - overlapping intervals .
this is quite unintuitive .
indeed , there is a definite path ( with probability 1 ) corresponding to the edge @xmath426 .
one may wonder whether it makes sense to compare this approach with ours on an example program which is inconsistent according to their semantics .
the point is that in this example , there is a certain path with probability [ 1,1 ] from 1 to 2 , and an approach that regards this program as inconsistent is not quite intuitive .
now , consider the p - program corresponding to the annotated program @xmath427 @xmath428 , obtained by stripping off atom annotations in @xmath429 and shifting the annotations in @xmath430 to the associated rules .
also , associate the confidence level @xmath431,~[0,0]\rangle$}}$ ] with @xmath429 . for uniformity and ease of comparison , assume the doubt ranges are all @xmath432 $ ] . as an example , let the conjunctive mode used in @xmath429 be independence and let the disjunctive mode used be positive correlation ( or , in this case , even ignorance ! ) . then @xmath433 would assign the confidence @xmath434,~[0,0]\rangle$ ] to @xmath435 , which agrees with our intuition . our point , however , is not that intersection is a
wrong " mode .
rather , we stress that different combination rules ( modes ) are appropriate for different situations .
[ problem2 ] now consider the following pf - program ( @xmath412 and @xmath415 are the same as previous example ) : @xmath412 : @xmath413 { \mbox{$\leftarrow$}}e(x , z ) : [ v_1 , v_2 ] , ~~$]@xmath414 $ ]
. + @xmath415 : @xmath416 { \mbox{$\leftarrow$}}e(x , y ) : [ v_1 , v_2]$ ]
. + @xmath436 : @xmath437 $ ] .
+ @xmath438 : @xmath439 $ ] . in this case , the least fixpoint of @xmath423 is only attained at @xmath2 and it assigns the range @xmath440 $ ] to @xmath441 and @xmath425 .
again , the result is unintuitive for this example . since @xmath423 is not continuous , one can easily write programs such that no reasonable approximation to @xmath424 can be obtained by iterating @xmath423 an arbitrary ( finite ) number of times .
( , consider the program obtained by adding the rule @xmath442 : @xmath443~{\mbox{$\leftarrow$}}~p(x , y ) : [ 0,0]$ ] to @xmath444 . )
notice that as long as one uses any arithmetic annotation function such that the probability of the head is less than the probability of the subgoals of @xmath412 ( which is a reasonable annotation function ) , this problem will arise .
the problem ( for the unintuitive behavior ) lies with the mode for disjunction .
again , we emphasize that different combination rules ( modes ) are appropriate for different situations . now , consider the p - program corresponding to the annotated program @xmath445 , obtained in the same way as was done in example [ problem1 ] .
let the conjunctive mode used in @xmath429 be independence and let the disjunctive mode be positive correlation or ignorance
. then @xmath433 would assign the confidence level @xmath446~[0,0]\rangle$ ] to @xmath435 .
this again agrees with our intuition . as a last example , suppose we start with the confidence @xmath447,~[0,0]\rangle$ ] for @xmath448 instead .
then under positive correlation ( for disjunction ) @xmath449,~[0,0]\rangle$ ] , while ignorance leads to @xmath450,~[0,0]\rangle$ ] .
the former makes more intuitive sense , although the latter ( more conservative under @xmath52 ) is obviously not wrong .
also , in the latter case , the @xmath451 is reached only at @xmath2 .
now , we discuss termination and complexity issues of p - programs .
let the _ closure ordinal _ of @xmath1 be the smallest ordinal @xmath10 such that @xmath452 .
we have the following [ thm : ordinal ] let @xmath16 be any p - program .
then the closure ordinal of @xmath1 can be as high as @xmath2 but no more .
* proof . *
the last p - program discussed in example [ problem2 ] has a closure ordinal of @xmath2 . since @xmath1 is continuous ( theorem [ thm : tpmonotone ] ) its closure ordinal is at most @xmath2 .
[ defn : datacomplexity ] ( _ data complexity _ ) we define the _ data complexity
_ @xcite of a p - program @xmath16 as the time complexity of computing the least fixpoint of @xmath1 as a function of the size of the database , the number of constants occurring in @xmath16 .
it is well known that the data complexity for datalog programs is polynomial .
an important question concerning any extension of ddbs to handle uncertainty is whether the data complexity is increased compared to datalog .
we can show that under suitable restrictions ( see below ) the data complexity of p - programs is polynomial time .
however , the proof can not be obtained by ( straightforward extensions of ) the classical argument for the data complexity for datalog . in the classical case , once a ground atom is derived during bottom - up evaluation , future derivations of it can be ignored . in programming with uncertainty , complications arise because we _ can not _ ignore alternate derivations of the same atom : the confidences obtained from them need to be combined , reinforcing the overall confidence of the atom .
this calls for a new proof technique .
our technique makes use of the following additional notions .
define a _ disjunctive derivation tree _ ( ddt ) to be a well - formed dpt ( see section [ proof - theory ] for a definition ) such that every goal and every substitution labeling any node in the tree is ground .
note that the height of a ddt with no failure nodes is an odd number ( see remark 7 at the beginning of section [ proof - theory ] ) .
we have the following results . [ ddt - bu - eval ]
let @xmath16 be a p - program and @xmath253 any ground atom in @xmath219 .
suppose the confidence determined for @xmath253 in iteration @xmath453 of bottom - up evaluation is @xmath111 .
then there exists a ddt @xmath342 of height @xmath454 for @xmath253 such that the confidence associated with @xmath253 by @xmath342 is exactly @xmath111
. * proof . *
the proof is by induction on @xmath55 . :
@xmath376 . in iteration 1
, bottom - up evaluation essentially collects together all edb facts ( involving ground atoms ) and determines their confidences from the program . without loss of generality , we may suppose there is at most one edb fact in @xmath16 corresponding to each ground atom ( involving an edb predicate ) .
let @xmath253 be any ground atom whose confidence is determined to be @xmath111 in iteration 1 . then there is an edb fact @xmath455 in @xmath16 .
the associated ddt for @xmath253 corresponding to this iteration is the tree with root labeled @xmath253 and a rule child labeled @xmath213 .
clearly , the confidence associated with the root of this tree is @xmath111 , and the height of this tree is @xmath37 ( @xmath456 , for @xmath457 . :
assume the result for all ground atoms whose confidences are determined ( possibly revised ) in iteration @xmath55 .
suppose @xmath253 is a ground atom whose confidence is determined to be @xmath111 in iteration @xmath458 .
this implies there exist ground instances of rules @xmath459 , @xmath460 ; @xmath461 such that ( i ) the confidence of @xmath254 @xmath462 computed at the end of iteration @xmath55 is @xmath463 ( @xmath464 ) , and ( ii ) @xmath465 @xmath466 @xmath467 @xmath468 , where is the disjunctive mode for the predicate @xmath253 . by induction hypothesis , there are ddts @xmath469 , @xmath470 , each of height @xmath471 or less , for the atoms @xmath406 , @xmath472 which exactly compute the confidences @xmath354 , @xmath473 respectively , corresponding to iteration @xmath55 .
consider the tree @xmath474 for @xmath253 by ( i ) making @xmath475 rule children of the root and ( ii ) making the @xmath469 , ( @xmath476 ) subtrees of @xmath412 ( @xmath477 ) .
it is trivial to see that @xmath474 is a ddt for @xmath253 and its height is @xmath478 .
further the confidence @xmath474 computes for the root @xmath253 is exactly @xmath479
@xmath466 @xmath467 @xmath468 .
this completes the induction and the proof .
proposition [ ddt - bu - eval ] shows each iteration of bottom - up evaluation corresponds in an essential manner to the construction of a set of ddts one for each distinct ground atom whose confidence is determined ( or revised ) in that iteration .
our next objective is to establish a termination bound on bottom - up evaluation .
ddt branches are defined similar to those of dpt .
let @xmath342 be a ddt .
then a branch of @xmath342 is a subtree of @xmath342 , defined as follows .
\(i ) the root belongs to every branch .
+ ( ii ) whenever a goal node belongs to a branch , exactly one of its rule children , belongs to the branch .
+ ( iii ) whenever a rule node belongs to a branch , all its goal children belong to the branch .
let @xmath253 be a ground atom and @xmath342 any ddt ( not necessarily for @xmath253 ) .
then @xmath342 is @xmath253-non - simple provided it has a branch containing two goal nodes @xmath288 and @xmath248 such that @xmath288 is an ancestor of @xmath248 and both are labeled by atom @xmath253 .
a ddt is @xmath253-simple if it is not @xmath253-non - simple .
finally , a ddt is simple if it is @xmath253-simple for every atom @xmath253 .
let @xmath342 be a ddt and @xmath254 be a branch of @xmath342 in which an atom @xmath253 appears .
then we define the _ number of violations of simplicity _ of @xmath254 with respect to @xmath253 to be one less than the total number of times the atom @xmath253 occurs in @xmath254 .
the number of violations of the simplicity of the ddt @xmath342 with respect to @xmath253 is the sum of the number of violations of the branches of @xmath342 in which @xmath253 occurs .
clearly , @xmath342 is @xmath253-simple exactly when the number of violations with respect to @xmath253 is 0 .
our first major result of this section follows .
[ term - bound ] let @xmath16 be a p - program such that only positive correlation is used as the disjunctive mode for recursive predicates .
let @xmath480a@xmath481 , and @xmath482 is any simple ddt for @xmath483 = @xmath454 , @xmath453 .
then at most @xmath458 iterations of naive bottom - up evaluation are needed to compute the least fixpoint of @xmath1 .
essentially , for p - programs @xmath16 satisfying the conditions mentioned above , the theorem ( i ) shows that naive bottom - up evaluation of @xmath16 is guaranteed to terminate , and ( ii ) establishes an upper bound on the number of iterations of bottom - up evaluation for computing the least fixpoint , in terms of the maximum height of any simple tree for any ground atom .
this is the first step in showing that p - programs of this type have a polynomial time data complexity .
we will use the next three lemmas ( lemmas [ lem : key][lem : boundfora ] ) in proving this theorem .
[ lem : key ] let @xmath484 be any ground atom , and let @xmath342 be a ddt for @xmath253 corresponding to @xmath485 , for some @xmath486 .
suppose @xmath342 is @xmath345-non - simple , for some atom @xmath345 .
then there is a ddt @xmath487 for @xmath253 with the following properties : \(i ) the certainty of @xmath253 computed by @xmath487 equals that computed by @xmath342 .
+ ( ii ) the number of violations of simplicity of @xmath487 with respect to @xmath345 is less than that of @xmath342 .
* proof*. let @xmath342 be the ddt described in the hypothesis of the claim .
let @xmath253 be the label of the root @xmath288 of @xmath342 , and assume without loss of generality that @xmath345 is identical to @xmath253 .
( the case when @xmath345 is distinct from @xmath253 is similar . )
let @xmath248 be the last goal node from the root down ( e.g. in the level - order ) , which is distinct from the root and is labeled by @xmath253 . since @xmath342 corresponds to applications of the @xmath1 operator , we have the following . (
* ) every branch of @xmath248 must be isomorphic to some branch of @xmath288 which does not contain the node @xmath248 .
this can be seen as follows .
let @xmath488 be the iteration such that the subtree of @xmath342 rooted at @xmath248 , say @xmath489 , corresponds to @xmath490 .
then clearly , every rule applicable in iteration @xmath56 is also applicable in iteration @xmath55 .
this means every branch of @xmath489 constructed from a sequence of rule applications is also constructible in iteration @xmath55 and hence there must be a branch of @xmath342 that is isomorphic to such a branch .
it follows from the isomorphism that the isomorphic branch of @xmath342 can not contain the node @xmath248 .
associate a logical formula with each node of @xmath342 as follows .
\(i ) the formula associated with each ( rule ) leaf is * true*. + ( ii ) the formula associated with a goal node with rule children @xmath491 and associated formulas @xmath492 , is @xmath493 .
+ ( iii ) the formula associated with a rule parent with goal children @xmath494 and associated formulas @xmath495 is @xmath496 . let the formula associated with the node @xmath248 be @xmath3 . to simplify the exposition , but at no loss of generality , let us assume that in @xmath342 , every goal node has exactly two rule children . then the formula associated with the root @xmath288 can be expressed as @xmath497 . by ( * ) above , we can see that @xmath3 logically implies @xmath498 , @xmath499 . by the structure of a ddt
, we can then express @xmath498 as @xmath500 , for some formula @xmath113 . construct a ddt @xmath487 from @xmath342 by deleting the parent of the node @xmath248 , as well as the subtree rooted at @xmath248 .
we claim that ( * * ) the formula associated with the root of @xmath487 is equivalent to that associated with the root of @xmath342 . to see this , notice that the formula associated with the root of @xmath342 can now be expressed as @xmath501 . by simple application of propositional identities
, it can be seen that this formula is equivalent to @xmath502 .
but this is exactly the formula associated with the root of t , which proves ( * * ) .
finally , we shall show that @xmath276 , together with any conjunctive mode , satisfy the following absorption laws : @xmath503 .
+ @xmath504 .
the first of these laws follows from the fact that for all modes @xmath362 we consider in this paper , @xmath505 , where @xmath50 is the lattice ordering .
the second is the dual of the first . in view of the absorption laws
, it can be seen that the certainty for @xmath253 computed by @xmath487 above is identical to that computed by @xmath342 .
this proves the lemma , since @xmath487 has at least one fewer violations of simplicity with respect to @xmath253 .
[ lem : simple ] let @xmath342 be a ddt for an atom @xmath253 .
then there is a simple ddt for @xmath253 such that the certainty of @xmath253 computed by it is identical to that computed by @xmath342 .
* proof*. follows by an inductive argument using lemma [ lem : key ] .
[ lem : boundfora ] let @xmath253 be an atom and @xmath506 be the maximum height of any simple ddt for @xmath253
. then certainty of @xmath253 in @xmath485 is identical to that in @xmath507 , for all @xmath508 .
* proof*. let @xmath342 be the ddt for @xmath253 corresponding to @xmath485 .
note that height(@xmath509 .
let @xmath111 represent the certainty computed by @xmath342 for @xmath253 , which is @xmath510 . by lemma [ lem : simple ]
, there is a simple ddt , say @xmath487 , for @xmath253 , which computes the same certainty for @xmath253 as @xmath342 .
clearly , height(@xmath511 .
let @xmath112 represent the certainty computed by @xmath487 for @xmath253 , @xmath512 . by the soundness theorem , and monotonicity of @xmath1 , we can write @xmath513 .
it follows that @xmath514 .
now we can complete the proof of theorem [ term - bound ] .
* proof of theorem [ term - bound]*. let @xmath515 be the maximum height of any simple ddt for any atom .
it follows from the above lemmas that the certainty of any atom in @xmath485 is identical to that in @xmath516 , for all @xmath517 , from which the theorem follows .
it can be shown that the height of simple ddts is polynomially bounded by the database size .
this makes the above result significant .
this allows us to prove the following theorem regarding the data complexity of the above class of p - programs .
[ complexity ] let @xmath16 be a p - program such that only positive correlation is used as the disjunctive mode for recursive predicates . then its least fixpoint can be computed in time polynomial in the database size . in particular ,
bottom - up naive evaluation terminates in time polynomial in the size of the database , yielding the least fixpoint .
* by theorem [ term - bound ] we know that the least fixpoint model of @xmath16 can be computed in at most @xmath458 iterations where @xmath518 is the maximum height of any simple ddt for any ground atom with respect to @xmath16 ( @xmath55 iterations to arrive at the fixpoint , and one extra iteration to verify that a fixpoint has been reached . )
notice that each goal node in a ddt corresponds to a database predicate .
let @xmath519 be the maximum arity of any predicate in @xmath16 , and @xmath398 be the number of constants occurring in the program .
notice that under the data complexity measure ( definition [ defn : datacomplexity ] ) @xmath519 is a constant .
the maximum number of distinct goal nodes that can occur in any branch of a simple ddt is @xmath520 .
this implies the height @xmath373 above is clearly a polynomial in the database size @xmath398 .
we have thus shown that bottom - up evaluation of the least fixpoint terminates in a polynomial number of iterations .
the fact that the amount of work done in each iteration is polynomial in @xmath398 is easy to see .
the theorem follows .
we remark that our proof of theorem [ complexity ] implies a similar result for van emden s framework . to our knowledge , this is the first polynomial time result for rule - based programming with ( probabilistic ) uncertainty .
we should point out that the polynomial time complexity is preserved whenever modes other than positive correlation are associated with non - recursive predicates ( for disjunction ) . more generally , suppose @xmath521 is the set of all recursive predicates and @xmath522 is the set of non - recursive predicates in the kb , which are possibly defined in terms of those in @xmath521 .
then any modes can be freely used with the predicates in @xmath522 while keeping the data complexity polynomial .
finally , if we know that the data does not contain cycles , we can use any mode even with a recursive predicate and still have a polynomial time data complexity .
we also note that the framework of annotation functions used in @xcite enables an infinite family of modes to be used in propagating confidences from rule bodies to heads .
the major differences with our work are ( i ) in @xcite a fixed mode " for disjunction is imposed unlike our framework , and ( ii ) they do not study the complexity of query answering , whereas we establish the conditions under which the important advantage of polynomial time data complexity of classical datalog can be retained .
more importantly , our work has generated useful insights into how modes ( for disjunction ) affect the data complexity .
finally , a note about the use of positive correlation as the disjunctive mode for recursive predicates ( when data might contain cycles ) .
the rationale is that different derivations of such recursive atoms could involve some amount of overlap ( the degree of overlap depends on the data ) .
now , positive correlation ( for disjunction ) tries to be conservative ( and hence sound ) by assuming the extent of overlap is maximal , so the combined confidence of the different derivations is the least possible ( under @xmath50 ) .
thus , it _ does _ make sense even from a practical point of view .
we motivated the need for modeling both belief and doubt in a framework for manipulating uncertain facts and rules .
we have developed a framework for probabilistic deductive databases , capable of manipulating both belief and doubt , expressed as probability intervals .
belief doubt pairs , called confidence levels , give rise to a rich algebraic structure called a trilattice .
we developed a probabilistic calculus permitting different modes for combining confidence levels of events .
we then developed the framework of p - programs for realizing probabilistic deductive databases .
p - programs inherit the ability to parameterize " the modes used for combining confidence levels , from our probabilistic calculus .
we have developed a declarative semantics , a fixpoint semantics , and proved their equivalence .
we have also provided a sound and complete proof procedure for p - programs .
we have shown that under disciplined use of modes , we can retain the important advantage of polynomial time data complexity of classical datalog , in this extended framework .
we have also compared our framework with related work with respect to the aspects of termination and intuitive behavior ( of the semantics ) .
the parametric nature of modes in p - programs is shown to be a significant advantage with respect to these aspects .
also , the analysis of trilattices shows insightful relationships between previous work ( ng and subrahmanian @xcite ) and ours . interesting open issues which merit further research include ( 1 ) semantics of p - programs under various trilattice orders and various modes , including new ones , ( 2 ) query optimization , ( 3 ) handling inconsistency in a framework handling uncertainty , such as the one studied here .
the authors would like to thank the anonymous referees for their careful reading and their comments , many of which have resulted in significant improvements to the paper .
kifer , m. , & li , a. ( 1988 ) . on the semantics of rule - based expert systems with uncertainty .
gyssens , m. , paradaens , j. , & van gucht , d. ( eds ) , _
conf . on database theory_. bruges ,
belgium : springer - verlag lncs-326 .
lakshmanan , l. v. s. , & shiri , n. ( 1997 ) . a parametric approach to deductive databases with uncertainty . .
( a preliminary version appeared in proc .
workshop on logic in databases ( lid96 ) , springer - verlag , lncs-1154 , san miniato , italy ) .
ng , r. t. , & subrahmanian , v. s. ( 1991 ) . .
report umiacs - tr-91 - 49 , cs - tr-2647 .
institute for advanced computer studies and department of computer science university of maryland , college park , md 20742 . | we propose a framework for modeling uncertainty where both belief and doubt can be given independent , first - class status .
we adopt probability theory as the mathematical formalism for manipulating uncertainty .
an agent can express the uncertainty in her knowledge about a piece of information in the form of a _ confidence level _ , consisting of a pair of intervals of probability , one for each of her belief and doubt .
the space of confidence levels naturally leads to the notion of a _ trilattice _ ,
similar in spirit to fitting s bilattices .
intuitively , the points in such a trilattice can be ordered according to truth , information , or precision .
we develop a framework for _ probabilistic deductive databases _ by associating confidence levels with the facts and rules of a classical deductive database .
while the trilattice structure offers a variety of choices for defining the semantics of probabilistic deductive databases , our choice of semantics is based on the truth - ordering , which we find to be closest to the classical framework for deductive databases .
in addition to proposing a declarative semantics based on valuations and an equivalent semantics based on fixpoint theory , we also propose a proof procedure and prove it sound and complete .
we show that while classical datalog query programs have a polynomial time data complexity , certain query programs in the probabilistic deductive database framework do not even terminate on some input databases .
we identify a large natural class of query programs of practical interest in our framework , and show that programs in this class possess polynomial time data complexity , not only do they terminate on every input database , they are guaranteed to do so in a number of steps polynomial in the input database size .
[ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] |
strong interactions are described by su(3 ) yang - mills field theory , and the fundamental degrees of freedom of quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) are gluons and quarks . at high temperature
this theory is weakly coupled , allowing for the use of perturbative methods .
the leading order contributions to the characteristic collective excitations and the equation of state of a quark - gluon plasma were already determined many years ago @xcite . a gauge invariant approach to non - leading corrections
was derived more recently in form of the hard thermal loop ( htl ) approximation @xcite and its improved versions @xcite .
the theory of qcd predicts the appearance of a phase transition between the quark - gluon dominated high energy region and the hadronic state in the low energy region .
the two states are characterized by a dramatic difference in the number of degrees of freedom .
perturbative qcd can describe successfully only the asymptotic state at very high momenta , but it fails close to this phase transition where non - perturbative effects become dominant . where the perturbative region begins is still a matter of debate @xcite .
the numerical method of lattice qcd can describe both sides of this phase transition .
recent developments of this field have yielded dramatic improvements both in the extrapolation to the continuum limit and for the inclusion of dynamical fermions .
the existence of this phase transition generated a large experimental effort to create it in the laboratory and investigate it in detail through heavy ion collisions .
however , to verify the appearance of a deconfined state in such experiments we need accurate knowledge about its subsequent hadronization .
there is a general interest to create phenomenological models for this phase transition which agree with the perturbative results at high energy and with the lattice qcd data at low energies .
such models must specify the basic degrees of freedom in the plasma state which will participate in the formation of hadrons during the confinement phase transition .
the experience from phase transitions in solid state physics and other fields suggests the introduction of quasi - particles with effective masses generated through the interactions among the basic constituents .
if a large part of the interaction can be included into the effective masses , then a quasi - particle description of the interacting matter can be generated in which the quasi - particles move freely or interact only weakly @xcite .
such a model would be a preferable starting point for phenomenological hadronization models and for a description of the strongly interacting matter near the phase transition .
our goal is to identify the appropriate degrees of freedom through an analysis of lattice qcd data .
similar attempts started as soon as good lattice qcd results on the equation of state of strongly interacting matter became available , and they developed in parallel with the improvements of the lattice data .
it was observed already quite some time ago that the formula for the free energy density of a massive ideal gas gives a quite satisfactory description of the numerical lattice qcd simulations @xcite . in ref .
@xcite temperature dependent screening masses and coupling constants were extracted from su(2 ) lattice data @xcite and compared with perturbative results . in ref .
@xcite it was shown that the obtained thermal mass can be indeed used as an effective mass in the equation of state , comparing favorably with su(2 ) lattice qcd data .
early ( very poor ) lattice data on the pressure and energy density of pure su(3 ) gauge theory in the temperature region @xmath0 @xcite were interpreted with a constant gluon mass , @xmath1 mev , and a constant bag constant @xcite .
newer su(3 ) lattice data of better quality @xcite made a reanalysis of the gluonic equation of state possible which yielded a new expression for the temperature dependent coupling constant in the thermal gluon mass @xcite . a quasi - particle based , thermodynamically consistent analysis of the su(2 ) @xcite and su(3 ) @xcite lattice data was performed in ref .
@xcite whose authors investigated in detail the temperature dependence of the thermal gluon mass and of the bag constant .
new su(3 ) lattice data with a complete continuum extrapolation appeared in refs .
@xcite , and again a phenomenological analysis proved the applicability of an equation of state with massive gluons @xcite .
furthermore it was shown @xcite that at @xmath2 the debye screening mass extracted from lattice qcd correlation functions and the thermal gluon mass fitted to the lattice qcd equation of state are consistent with each other , such that at high temperature the perturbative qcd with effective massive degrees of freedom provides a good description of the lattice qcd results @xcite .
in ref . @xcite the lattice data fit yielded @xmath3 gluon degrees of freedom , supporting the presence of massive _ transverse _ modes only .
a direct investigation of the screening mass in su(3 ) lattice calculations was performed in ref .
@xcite on both sides of the phase transition .
a somewhat different analysis of pure su(3 ) lattice data was presented in ref .
it assumes the existence of massless gluons above a certain minimal momentum ( `` cut - off model '' ) together with glueball - like non - perturbative massive excitations .
this model could reproduce the su(3 ) lattice data quite well @xcite .
all of the above analyses were performed for the case of pure su(2 ) and su(3 ) gauge theories , because sufficiently high - quality lattice qcd data existed only in these cases ( for su(3 ) the latest results can be found in refs .
@xcite ) . however , new lattice data including dynamical fermions appeared recently , with @xmath4 @xcite and @xmath5 @xcite quark flavors .
extended investigations are under evaluation for the cases @xmath6 and @xmath7 ( see ref .
@xcite ) , but in their present state they can not yet be used to extract temperature dependent thermal masses .
these new lattice results can now be used for the extraction of a phenomenological equation of state for the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) containing massive gluons and quarks , which to our knowledge has not been published elsewhere .
similar work is under way in the group of a. peshier and b. kmpfer @xcite .
the understanding of the dynamical generation of effective quark and gluon masses could be very important in many research fields .
dynamical mass generation is an essential ingredient for the solution of the infrared catastrophe in hot gauge theories @xcite and the formulation of effective field theoretical approaches to thermal qcd @xcite .
it is at the heart of recent new approximation schemes such as the `` screened perturbation theory '' @xcite .
screening masses have also successfully been used to regulate the low-@xmath8 behavior in the parton cascade approach to ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions @xcite .
massive quarks are the basic degrees of freedom in hadronization models : the phenomenological model alcor is based on the coalescence of massive quarks and antiquarks into hadrons @xcite ; transport descriptions of the hadronization based on the nambu - jona - lasinio model contain massive quarks as well @xcite .
massive quarks and gluons obtained from htl approximation @xcite were already applied to estimate charm production at rhic and lhc energies @xcite . in sec .
[ sec2 ] we summarize the present knowledge about the thermal and screening masses in perturbative thermal qcd . in sec .
[ sec3 ] we overview the equation of state of quasi - particles , its most important thermodynamical properties and discuss the criterium of thermodynamical consistency . in sec .
[ sec4 ] we analyze pure su(3 ) lattice qcd results ; we determine the relevant number of gluonic degrees of freedom , the temperature dependent gluon mass and coupling constant , the temperature dependent bag constant and investigate the screening mass . in sec .
[ sec5 ] we repeat this analysis on lattice data with @xmath4 and @xmath5 dynamical fermion species . in sec .
[ sec6 ] we generate the equation of state of the qgp in general and investigate the speed of sound in this system . in sec .
[ sec7 ] we include hadronic matter into our investigation and describe phenomenologically the phase transition between qgp and hadronic matter on the basis of our new equation of state obtained from lattice qcd data . in sec .
[ sec8 ] we discuss our results .
there are essentially two ways to define an effective dynamical gluon mass : via the pole of the effective gluon propagator , or via the long - range behavior of the potential between two heavy color sources . in both cases one has to address the question of gauge invariance of the result for the mass , since the defining objects are not themselves gauge invariant . on a perturbative level
, it was noticed by klimov @xcite and weldon @xcite that the leading term in a high - temperature expansion of the 1-loop gluon polarization tensor was gauge invariant .
it was later shown by heinz @xcite that the same result for the gluon polarization tensor could be obtained from classical color kinetic theory in the linear response approximation . from this expression for the polarization tensor weldon
@xcite derived the following dispersion relation for transverse gluons with momenta @xmath9 : @xmath10 one might object that the high temperature limit in which the polarization tensor was obtained is inconsistent with the limit @xmath9 under which eq .
( [ weld1 ] ) was derived .
however , rebhan et al . showed recently @xcite that the validity of eq .
( [ weld1 ] ) does not depend on the high temperature limit taken in ref .
@xcite ; indeed , near the light cone the transverse 1-loop polarization function is given by the gauge invariant result @xmath11 independent of the magnitude of @xmath12 relative to @xmath13 . since for large momenta @xmath14 the gluon dispersion relation moves arbitrarily close to the light cone , @xmath15 can be interpreted as the thermal gluon mass in the high momentum limit .
its inclusion as a gluon mass term in higher orders of perturbation theory removes certain classes of collinear singularities near the light cone , and within the context of hard thermal loop resummation @xcite it leads to the so - called `` improved htl resummation scheme '' @xcite .
the `` debye screening mass '' @xmath16 , on the other hand , is related to the behavior of gluonic excitations at small momenta .
it can be defined either through the static limit of the gluon polarization tensor @xmath17 for @xmath18 or via the behavior of the potential between two heavy color charges at large distances , @xmath19 @xcite . in the first case
a gauge invariant result can be obtained from the leading term of the high temperature expansion for the 1-loop gluon polarization operator @xcite or , equivalently , from the 1-loop result within the htl resummation scheme @xcite for the gluon polarization operator at momenta @xmath20 . in the second case
, care must be taken to make the external sources gauge invariant @xcite . in the htl approximation one
obtains from the behavior of + the debye mass @xcite @xmath21 this result is related to the 1-loop plasmon frequency , @xmath22 , obtained from the gluon dispersion relation ( pole of the propagator ) for @xmath23 , by @xmath24 .
similarly to the gluon propagator , one can study the quark propagator in the 1-loop approximation . in the high temperature or low - momentum limit @xmath25 @xcite or , equivalently , in the htl approximation @xcite
one obtains @xmath26 this can be interpreted as the effective quark mass for soft quarks with momenta @xmath27 . for high momenta @xmath28 the fermion dispersion relation again approaches the light cone , and one can make use of the gauge invariant light cone limit of the 1-loop fermion self energy @xcite :
@xmath29 again this is an exact 1-loop result , independent of the value of @xmath12 , and @xmath30 can be interpreted as the thermal quark mass for high momentum quarks , @xmath14 .
the thermal gluon and quark masses obtained from perturbative qcd are displayed in eqs .
( [ infmg ] ) and ( [ infmq ] ) .
all masses depend on the temperature @xmath13 and the strong coupling constant @xmath31 . at higher orders of the loop expansion ,
the coupling @xmath31 begins to run as a function of @xmath13 , giving rise to a temperature dependent effective coupling constant @xmath32 . in @xmath33 gauge theory at @xmath34 , in the presence of @xmath35 quark flavors the 1-loop expression for the running coupling constant as a function of the momentum transfer @xmath36 is @xmath37 here @xmath38 is the cut - off parameter . it was shown in ref .
@xcite that in a thermal system it makes sense to introduce a temperature dependent function @xmath39 by the following parametrization : @xmath40 we expect @xmath41 to be linear in the region where perturbation theory is valid @xcite . in other words ,
writing @xmath42 we expect @xmath43 to be a constant in the perturbative region , i.e. at high @xmath13 . at low @xmath13 a possible @xmath13-dependence of @xmath44
reflects non - perturbative corrections . in su(3 )
at different @xmath35 we have different critical temperatures @xmath45 and different normalization parameters @xmath46 @xcite : @xmath47 for @xmath4 the critical temperature in su(3 ) was determined as @xmath48 mev @xcite , but the normalization factor @xmath46 is not known by the authors . from eqs .
( [ tla1 ] ) and ( [ tla2 ] ) we will estimate this value by interpolation and we will use @xmath49 . we will try to fit the lattice data with a non - interacting gas of massive quarks and gluons , with masses given by the perturbative expressions ( [ infmg ] ) and ( [ infmq ] ) , but with @xmath50 replaced by a phenomenological running coupling @xmath39 . using eqs .
( [ gfun1 ] ) and ( [ gfun2 ] ) we can then extract a function @xmath43 . in a very early work @xcite in pure su(3 )
gauge theory this function @xmath43 was determined from a similar fit to the heavy quark - antiquark potential ; the fit result was a constant , @xmath51 .
however , the authors of ref . @xcite used @xmath52 which differs strongly from the now accepted value . with our normalization ( [ tla1 ] ) , @xmath51 would correspond to @xmath53 .
another result was obtained recently from a numerical fit of the equation of state in pure su(3 ) gauge theory @xcite : @xmath54 obviously , this parametrization differs from eq .
( [ gfun2 ] ) .
our expectation is to obtain a constant @xmath43 function in that temperature region where perturbative qcd and the quasi - particle picture of the lattice qcd results overlap .
a strong temperature dependence of @xmath43 implies non - perturbative effects .
we summarize our results on the function @xmath43 for different values of @xmath35 in sects .
[ sec4 ] and [ sec5 ] .
in this section we introduce the equation of state of a pure gluon plasma and a quark - gluon plasma consisting of massive quasi - particles .
this equation of state ( resp . its parameters ) will be determined from the su(3 ) lattice data .
the key point is to consider temperature dependent effective masses , @xmath55 , which are dynamically generated .
we can introduce the dispersion relation for quasi - particles : @xmath56 here @xmath57 is the momentum of the quasi - particle and @xmath58 is its energy .
a pure gluon plasma contains only gluons ( @xmath59 , @xmath60 ) , a qgp consists of quarks and antiquarks also ( @xmath61 , @xmath62 ) .
we can define the bose or fermi distribution functions @xmath63 for the quasi - particles as @xmath64^{-1 } = [ \exp ( \omega_i /t ) \pm 1 ] ^{-1 } \ . \label{dist}\ ] ] in addition to the effective masses @xmath55 we also need the effective number of degrees of freedom of the quasi - particles to determine pressure and energy density .
the correct value for the number of effective gluonic degrees of freedom is not obvious , since a massless vector boson has two helicity states , but massive vector bosons have three spin states .
one possibility is to introduce a temperature dependent effective degeneracy factor @xmath65 for the gluons .
we will determine the value of @xmath65 in a pure gluon plasma ( @xmath60 ) , where quark degrees of freedom do not interfere .
later we can assume the same value for @xmath65 in a qgp .
another possibility is to fix the number of gluonic degrees of freedom ( e.g. at its perturbatively expected value @xmath66 ) as well as the number of quark and antiquark degrees of freedom . in this case we have the freedom to introduce an effective interaction term for those contributions of the strong interaction which can not be absorbed by the presence of effective masses .
we parametrize this term by a temperature dependent `` bag constant '' , @xmath67 .
this interaction term @xmath67 can be determined in a pure gluon plasma as well as in a quark - gluon plasma . as we will see in the following section , in the qgp phase quarks and anti - quarks will also contribute to @xmath67 , so its physical meaning differs from the bag constant parameter of the mit bag model
; nevertheless we will use the same notation for convenience .
let us first consider pure su(3 ) gauge theory where we wish to find out the number of contributing gluonic quasi - particle degrees of freedom , @xmath65 .
a strongly interacting gluon plasma contains not only the transverse gluon modes , but at low momenta @xmath68 there exist also longitudinal plasma excitations .
it was shown in ref .
@xcite that at high momenta @xmath14 the longitudinal modes disappear , in the sense that the residue of the corresponding pole in the propagator becomes exponentially small .
since the equation of state is dominated by particles with momenta @xmath69 , we expect at high temperatures @xmath70 ( where @xmath31 becomes small ) the contribution of the longitudinal modes to be negligible . on the other hand , at low temperatures ( where @xmath31 can become of order 1 or larger ) their contribution may be relatively large .
therefore we can not a priori neglect them from the analysis of lattice qcd data .
we will introduce a temperature dependent effective number of gluon degrees of freedom @xmath65 , generalizing the approach of ref .
@xcite where @xmath71 was taken as a constant ( temperature independent ) fit parameter .
we expect that in the high temperature limit there are only transverse gluonic quasi - particle modes , yielding @xmath72 . at low temperatures
the longitudinal gluons are expected to also contribute , giving @xmath73 . with these assumptions
the thermodynamical pressure @xmath74 of pure gluon matter ( which is nothing but the grand canonical thermodynamical potential ) can be written as @xmath75 from the thermodynamic identity @xmath76 ( we work at zero net baryon density , @xmath77 ) one obtains the following relation for the energy density : @xmath78 here @xmath79 summarizes the extra terms stemming from the temperature derivative of the effective mass and effective number of degrees of freedom .
on the other hand , a consistent quasi - particle picture demands @xmath80 @xcite . requiring this identity yields a differential equation for @xmath65 : @xmath81 here @xmath82 is an integration constant . if the functions @xmath15 and @xmath65 satisfy this selfconsistency condition , then we have a thermodynamically consistent quasi - particle description .
lattice calculations yield numerical values for the functions @xmath74 and @xmath83 .
these two sets of data are sufficient to determine for each value of @xmath13 the quantities @xmath15 and @xmath65 such that they satisfy eqs .
( [ dpt]-[det ] ) with @xmath84 . since the lattice results were created in a thermodynamically consistent way we expect that the resulting functions @xmath15 and @xmath65 will satisfy eq .
( [ dt ] ) .
we will check this as a test for the consistency of our extraction procedure for @xmath15 and @xmath65 .
our numerical results on @xmath15 and @xmath65 will be summarized in sec .
[ sec4 ] .
we can also investigate the high temperature limit from another point of view @xcite .
let us fix the value of the gluonic degrees of freedom at every temperature to @xmath85 , assuming that only transverse gluons contribute to the thermodynamic quantities , and calculate directly any extra contribution to the pressure and the energy density . in this way
both pure gluon matter and a quark - gluon plasma can be investigated .
we will here consider a qgp with @xmath35 quark flavors and the usual number of quark degrees of freedom : @xmath86 .
the effective quark mass @xmath87 will be related to the effective gluon mass @xmath15 through the value of the temperature dependent coupling constant @xmath32 via the perturbative expressions in eqs .
( [ infmg ] ) and ( [ infmq ] ) for the effective masses .
this means that we absorb non - perturbative features into a common non - perturbative fit function @xmath32 , without touching the perturbative form of the eqs .
( [ infmg ] ) and ( [ infmq ] ) itself .
the deviation of @xmath88 and @xmath89 from the ideal gas values corresponding to the effective masses @xmath55 and the fixed degeneracy factors @xmath90 , @xmath91 and @xmath92 will be parametrized by a temperature dependent function @xmath67 . at high temperature , where we expect a perturbative picture based on free quarks and transverse gluons to be valid , @xmath67 should vanish . at lower temperature
, @xmath67 provides another measure for non - perturbative physics which can not be absorbed into effective quark and gluon masses .
both quarks and gluons contribute to @xmath67 .
we introduce @xmath67 by writing the pressure in the form @xmath93 motivated by the mit bag model .
thermodynamic identities yield the following relation for the energy density : @xmath94 here @xmath95 summarizes the extra terms obtained from the temperature derivative of @xmath67 and of the effective mass @xmath55 .
similarly as above thermodynamic consistency of our quasi - particle model requires @xmath96 .
this yields to the following integral representation for @xmath67 @xcite : @xmath97 again @xmath82 is an integration constant . if this expression is satisfied by the functions @xmath55 and @xmath67
, we have a thermodynamically correct quasi - particle description containing effective gluons and quarks with effective thermal masses .
similarly as above , from the numerical values for the functions @xmath98 and @xmath99 obtained from lattice qcd and assuming @xmath100 , we can determine the appropriate values for @xmath55 ( resp .
@xmath32 ) and @xmath67 through eqs . ( [ pt ] ) and ( [ et ] ) . as before we expect that the obtained functions @xmath55 and @xmath67 will satisfy eq .
( [ bt ] ) .
once again this is a good numerical consistency check for our extraction of the functions @xmath55 , @xmath67 .
we analyze the latest lattice data in the continuum limit for pure su(3 ) gauge theory @xcite . the calculations of ref .
@xcite show a @xmath101 error on the data for @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath102 .
we include this error into our analysis ; it will be indicated in figs . 1 , 2 and 3 by dotted lines above and below the solid lines corresponding to the results extracted from the mean values .
we begin by determining the effective number of gluonic quasi - particle degrees of freedom in a gluon plasma , extracting the functions @xmath15 and @xmath65 as explained in sec .
[ sec3.1 ] .
1a shows the temperature dependent effective gluon mass , @xmath15 , while in fig .
1b we display the effective number of gluonic degrees of freedom , @xmath65 . at high temperature , @xmath103 ,
the number of degrees of freedom is rather constant , @xmath104 .
please note that the @xmath105 error of the lattice data results in an uncertainty of about 1 gluon degree of freedom . within this uncertainty
the result is surprisingly close to the naive expectation that at high temperature only the transverse gluonic modes are present . in the low temperature region , @xmath106 , the function @xmath65 increases , which one may wish to associate with the increasing contribution of the longitudinal modes .
however , for @xmath107 , @xmath65 rises very strongly and exceeds even the value of @xmath108 expected for massive gluons with @xmath109 color and @xmath110 helicity states .
this indicates the presence of strong non - perturbative effects at low temperature not all of which can be absorbed by the effective gluon mass . in fact , part of the strong rise in @xmath65 is driven by the strong increase of the effective gluon mass which leads to exponential suppression of the thermodynamical contributions to @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
we consider this behavior of @xmath65 as physically unreasonable and believe that a parametrization of these non - perturbative effects via an extra interaction term makes more sense . to this end
we fix the effective number of gluonic modes to @xmath66 as suggested by the behavior of @xmath65 in fig .
1b and our perturbative prejudice at large @xmath13 .
this means that we consider only transverse effective gluons as quasi - particle states and subsume all further interaction effects into a non - perturbative `` bag constant '' @xmath67 .
the procedure is described in sec .
[ sec3.2 ] .
2a shows the temperature dependent transverse gluon mass @xmath15 resulting from this approach . comparing with fig .
1a one sees that at large values of @xmath13 the effective mass is now somewhat larger , compensating for the choice of a fixed @xmath66 instead of the best fit value @xmath111 in fig .
1b . for smaller temperatures ,
however , the rise of @xmath15 is much weaker than in fig . 1a , and @xmath15 also shows a much weaker sensitivity to the statistical error of the lattice data on @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
this indicates that this type of parametrization provides a more reasonable fit to the lattice data than the one above in terms of @xmath15 and @xmath65 .
please note that the effective gluon masses shown in fig .
2a correspond in the region @xmath112 to a coupling constant @xmath113 , in agreement with other extraction procedures : for example , the authors of ref .
@xcite obtained from the interquark potential at small distances the value @xmath114 which translates into @xmath115 .
2b shows the function @xmath116 , the interaction term relative to the total energy density . at high temperatures , @xmath117 ,
the bag constant is very small , only about @xmath118 of the total energy density , although slightly negative .
we take the smallness of @xmath67 as confirmation for the validity of a quasi - particle picture at large temperature . near @xmath119 @xmath67 changes sign , increasing for smaller values of @xmath13 , but never exceeding a value of @xmath120 of the total energy density even at @xmath45 .
note that this relatively small deviation from an ideal quasi - particle picture gave rise to the dramatic and unphysical behavior of @xmath65 ( and @xmath15 ) in the alternative approach above .
clearly , the parametrization via @xmath67 is more economical and leads to a more selfconsistent picture . the dashed line in fig .
2b shows the result of an integration of eq .
( [ bt ] ) , using the extracted @xmath15 from fig .
2a and choosing boundary conditions @xmath121 at @xmath122 .
the agreement with the numerically extracted values for @xmath67 is nearly perfect indicating the thermodynamical consistency of the lattice data and our extraction procedure .
from the temperature dependent gluon mass , @xmath15 , one can determine the temperature dependent coupling constant , @xmath32 , and extract the function @xmath43 given in eq .
( [ gfun2 ] ) . the result for pure su(3 ) gauge theory
is shown in fig .
the dotted lines again indicate the @xmath101 systematic error of the lattice data .
one can see that at high temperature we obtain a constant value , @xmath123 . at
low temperature @xmath43 decreases indicating a larger coupling constant and a larger thermal gluon mass .
close to the phase transition the function approaches the value @xmath124 ; the precise value depends , however , on the latent heat at the phase transition point which is still under intensive investigation in lattice qcd calculations .
the obtained curve can be fitted rather well with the following function ( dashed line in fig .
3 ) : @xmath125 if we start from this approximate function of @xmath43 for the coupling constant @xmath32 , we obtain an analytically parametrized , approximate thermal gluon mass @xmath15 ( see eqs .
( [ infmg],[gfun1],[gfun2 ] ) ) .
once we fix the boundary condition @xmath121 at @xmath126 as determined from the numerical analysis of the lattice data ( see fig .
2b ) , the bag constant @xmath67 can be uniquely reconstructed by integrating eq .
( [ bt ] ) . with @xmath15 and @xmath67
known , @xmath98 and @xmath99 are easily evaluated using eqs .
( [ pt],[et ] ) ( with @xmath127 ) .
this means that eq .
( [ kfun ] ) together with the value for @xmath82 provide a complete analytical parametrization of the equation of state . in fig .
4 we compare the original lattice qcd data ( diamonds ) with the thus reconstructed values ( dashed and dash - dotted lines ) .
the dash - dotted lines neglect the interaction term @xmath67 and thus represent only the quasi - particle contribution to @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
clearly the agreement between the model and the lattice data is at most qualitative in this case .
including the bag term , however , ( dashed lines ) we obtain nearly perfect reproduction of the lattice data . fig .
4 demonstrates the usefulness of a thermodynamically consistent quasi - particle picture .
the deviation from the stefan - boltzmann values indicates that the massless degrees of freedom can not provide a satisfactory description , while the quasi - particle model plus bag term leads to qualitative improvements .
newest lattice calculations including dynamical fermions can be used to determine the equation of state for a realistic quark - gluon plasma including light quarks .
the numerical lattice qcd results can be found in refs .
@xcite for @xmath4 and in ref .
@xcite for @xmath5 . following these articles we interpolated the expected continuum result in both cases . from ref .
@xcite for @xmath4 we used the data for a current quark mass @xmath131 ( octagons in figs . 9 and 10 in ref .
@xcite and circles in fig . 7 here ) .
the statistical error of the lattice data is small , @xmath132 for the pressure and @xmath133 for the energy density . from ref .
@xcite for @xmath5 we used the data set for a current quark mass @xmath134 and we considered their extrapolation of the energy density to the chiral limit ( see @xmath135 in fig . 4 of ref .
@xcite and in fig . 7 here ) .
in this case the statistical errors are even smaller , but the systematic errors resulting from the extrapolations to the chiral and continuum limits are hard to judge . to estimate the possible influence of errors on the lattice data for our extraction procedure we will consider a universal @xmath136 error in both cases ; the corresponding uncertainty will be indicated by dotted lines in figs . 5 and 6 . in the framework of perturbation theory
the effects of dynamical quarks on the gluon dynamics are small and can be simply included into the thermal gluon mass and debye screening length .
no additional gluonic collective modes arise .
however , at small momenta there are additional fermionic collective modes , the `` plasminos '' @xcite . based on our experience in pure gluodynamics
they are not expected to contribute to the equation of state at high temperature ; again the residues of their poles in the quark propagator vanish exponentially for moments @xmath14 @xcite .
we will therefore assume a fixed number of degrees of freedom , given by the perturbative values at high @xmath13 , @xmath66 , @xmath137 , and include all collective interaction effects into an interaction term @xmath67 as for the purely gluonic system above .
the obtained results are qualitatively very similar to the previous ones for the purely gluonic case .
5a shows the obtained results for the effective gluon mass , @xmath138 . since @xmath139 , fig .
5a can be viewed as giving the temperature dependence of the effective coupling constant @xmath32 which according to eq .
( [ infmq ] ) also determine the effective quark mass . from fig . 5 and eq .
( [ infmg ] ) we extract @xmath140 in the region @xmath141 for @xmath5 , somewhat larger than for the purely gluonic case .
5b shows the interaction term relative to the total energy density @xmath116 both for @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
similarly to the result in pure su(3 ) gauge theory , the interaction term @xmath67 remains small at @xmath142 , and does not exceed @xmath120 of the energy density in the low temperature region . in the case
@xmath4 the lattice data allow us to extract @xmath15 and @xmath67 only in the temperature region @xmath143 , however the characteristics of the obtained curves are close to the results obtained for @xmath5 .
6 displays the obtained functions @xmath43 ( solid lines ) together with the expected errors ( dotted lines ) stemming from an assumed typical @xmath101 uncertainty in the lattice data . for all three cases , @xmath144 0 , 2 and 4 , the functions @xmath43 are very similar ( within the admittedly large error bars ) . within the existing uncertainties
we can thus define a universal function @xmath43 ; differences due to variations of @xmath145 and @xmath35 can be largely absorbed into @xmath45 and @xmath146 in eq .
( [ gfun2 ] )
. it would be very interesting to see whether the existence of such a universal function @xmath43 is confirmed by future higher quality lattice data .
since the data for purely gluonic su(3 ) span a much larger range than those including dynamical fermions , we will use the analytical form ( [ kfun ] ) extracted from the gluonic case also in our quasi - particle picture for the full qgp .
for the zero point of @xmath67 we will again choose the value @xmath147 determined in the purely gluonic su(3 ) case , although ( modulo large numerical uncertainties ) the @xmath148 data seem to favor a somewhat smaller value .
for a qgp with @xmath4 quark flavours fig .
7a shows the lattice data ( circles for pressure and energy density ) and the reconstructed values for @xmath99 and @xmath98 , both including the bag constant ( dashed lines ) and neglecting the interaction term ( dash - dotted lines ) . for @xmath5 quark
flavours the analogous quantities are displayed in fig .
the squares give directly the lattice data from ref .
@xcite for the energy density , while the diamonds represent the continuous line for the pressure given in fig . 2 of ref .
@xcite . in each case
inclusion of the interaction term @xmath67 improves the picture .
the agreement is weaker than in the pure su(3 ) case ( see fig .
4 ) , but the pressure is reproduced rather nicely as well as the energy density at high temperature . note that here we used the function @xmath43 from eq .
( [ kfun ] ) .
the discrepancy in the region @xmath149 may be connected to the use of massive current quarks in the actual lattice simulations and associated uncertainties in the extrapolation to the chiral limit ( for a discussion see ref .
@xcite ) . in view of those the @xmath150 discrepancy between the reconstructed curves and data is surprisingly small , especially if we remember that we used here the parametrization which was obtained from the pure su(3 ) case .
in hydrodynamical models of strongly interacting matter the dynamical behavior is mostly determined by the value of the speed of sound : @xmath151 since the energy density @xmath99 was obtained from eq .
( [ entr ] ) we can rewrite this as @xmath152 which is more directly connected to the lattice data . for a noninteracting ( @xmath153 ) gas of massless particles
the speed of sound is @xmath154 . in ref .
@xcite , using eq .
( [ spe1 ] ) , it was found that even for a non - interacting ( @xmath153 ) massive quark - gluon gas the speed of sound remains very close to @xmath154 .
( in that work thermal masses from earlier htl calculations @xcite and a running coupling constant according to eqs .
( [ gfun1],[gfun2 ] ) with a constant @xmath43 were used . )
if there are , however , strong remaining interactions which can not be absorbed in the masses but require a non - vanishing and possibly strongly @xmath13-dependent @xmath67 , this will generate deviations of @xmath155 from the ideal gas value , especially near @xmath45 @xcite .
a strong drop of @xmath155 near @xmath45 will give rise to a `` soft point '' in the equation of state at which the ability of the matter to generate expansion flow is minimal .
since in our analysis the interaction term @xmath67 remains small and changes smoothly with @xmath13 , we expect only weak modifications of the speed of sound around @xmath45 .
8 displays the speed of sound @xmath155 for @xmath156 in our quasi - particle picture and confirms this expectation .
including the bag term @xmath67 ( dashed lines ) , @xmath157 in the high temperature limit , and @xmath155 decreases to a minimum value @xmath158 around @xmath45 .
if we neglect the interaction term @xmath67 and calculate the speed of sound @xmath159 from the expression @xmath160 where @xmath161 and @xmath162 , then ( see dash - dotted line in fig . 8) the speed of sound shows only a very weak temperature dependence , decreasing from @xmath163 at @xmath164 to @xmath165 at @xmath45 .
if we instead use eq .
( [ spe1 ] ) also in this case ( as in ref .
@xcite ) , where @xmath67 cancels in the numerator , then the resulting speed of sound is very close to the full result ( dashed line ) , because of the small influence of @xmath67 on the energy density in the denominator of eq . ( [ spe1 ] ) .
our result agrees with the calculations in ref .
@xcite in the high temperature region and differs around @xmath45 because of the non - linear behavior of @xmath43 indicating non - perturbative effects .
these results on the speed of sound show that a massive quark - gluon plasma will expand rapidly and that therefore the phase transition should be a fast process without detectable duration effects .
even where the pressure already shows large ( @xmath166 ) deviations from the massless ideal gas law , the speed of sound still deviates by less than 10% from the value @xmath167 . in this way
our analysis of lattice qcd results favors fast hadronization models @xcite of the deconfined phase .
in this section we investigate some phenomenological consequences of the large effective quark and gluon masses .
9 displays the effective masses in gev for @xmath156 .
all masses behave similarly , since they are connected to each other by the function @xmath43 in the effective coupling constant @xmath32 . just above the critical temperature
the effective masses drop , but then they remain rather constant in the temperature region @xmath168 . the mass values for the case @xmath4 are smaller than for @xmath60 due to the smaller critical temperature @xmath169 mev instead of 260 mev . for @xmath5
they increase again due to the larger contribution from quark loops and the somewhat larger @xmath170 mev .
the gluon masses are large in the cases @xmath171 , of order @xmath172 mev in the temperature region @xmath173 ( solid lines ) . in the same temperature region
the quark masses are of order @xmath174 mev ( dashed lines ) .
large effective masses yield smaller number density at the same energy density .
thus the density of these massive quasi - particles will be smaller than in the massless case .
10 demonstrates this by displaying the density ratio of the massive quasi - particles and the massless ones , @xmath175 ( solid lines for gluons and dotted lines for quarks ) as a function of temperature . at large temperature
the ratio flattens and eventually approaches 1 , but close to the critical temperature the ratio drops very quickly to values much smaller than 1 .
this indicates that the massive quark - gluon plasma is much more dilute than a massless qgp , especially near @xmath45 .
now we compare the abundances of quarks and gluons relative to each other .
( [ infmg ] ) and ( [ infmq ] ) imply that in our model the gluon effective mass is always larger than the quark effective mass by the ratio @xmath176 which even increases with the number of quark flavor @xmath35 .
each gluon degree of freedom will thus be suppressed compared to each quark degree of freedom . after multiplying the corresponding degeneracy factors we can compute the density ratio for gluons @xmath177 which is shown in fig .
11 as a function of @xmath13 .
the horizontal lines show the ratio @xmath178 for the massless qgp .
the deviation caused by the effective mass is clearly seen , and a considerable suppression of the relative gluon number occurs near the phase transition . near @xmath45 , for @xmath4 we have @xmath179 which means that only 25% of the particles are gluons while the remaining 75% are quarks and antiquarks . for @xmath5
the gluon suppression is even stronger and near @xmath45 we find only 10% gluons and 90% quarks and anti - quarks .
these results show that the massive qgp is a dilute system dominated by massive quarks and antiquarks .
gluons are much heavier than quarks and their number densities are suppressed .
these properties indicate that lattice qcd results support the formation of a quark - antiquark dominated plasma state just above the critical temperature , which contains mostly massive quarks and antiquarks .
this system hadronizes quickly .
fast hadronization is also favored by the fact that the effective quark masses are already close to the masses in the `` constituent quark '' picture of hadrons .
clusterization of these massive quarks leads directly to multiquark states with similar masses as those of the finally observed hadrons , allowing for immediate hadron formation without having to wait for further energy transfer .
lattice data in pure su(3 ) gauge theory and new lattice results with @xmath4 and @xmath5 dynamical fermions suggest that beyond the phase transition temperature strong non - perturbative effects dominate the deconfined state . in order to understand this phenomenon and to facilitate the application of lattice results in dynamical descriptions of the evolution of the deconfined phase and its hadronization we analyzed the lattice data in a phenomenological model assuming the appearance of massive quasi - particles , namely massive quarks and massive transverse gluons .
we determined a temperature dependent effective coupling constant @xmath32 , which determines the effective masses , and the interaction term @xmath67 , which summarizes contributions not to be included into the effective masses .
we found that such a quasi - particle picture works very well .
the interaction term @xmath67 remains small and the extracted dynamical mass is consistent with perturbative qcd results at high temperature while it includes non - perturbative contributions at low temperature . in all cases , @xmath156 ,
the obtained characteristics are very similar .
if we determine @xmath32 in the purely gluonic case and extend it in an appropriate way for @xmath180 , we can reproduce approximately the @xmath130 lattice data .
this fact suggest the existence of a universal description of non - perturbative effects in the fermionless and fermionic cases .
our analysis leads to a thermodynamically consistent quasi - particle model for the qgp equation of state which is parametrized via an effective coupling constant @xmath32 through eqs .
( [ gfun1],[gfun2],[kfun ] ) and the zero point @xmath82 of the interaction term @xmath67 .
further lattice data with improved quality over a wider temperature region are needed to fix @xmath32 and @xmath82 more accurately .
the successful reproduction of lattice data by this quasi - particle model indicates the validity of such an approximation .
the consequences of the appearance of these quasi - particles are very interesting : near @xmath45 lattice results indicate the existence of a qcd phase which is dominated by massive quarks and anti - quarks , while the even heavier gluons are suppressed .
this quark - antiquark plasma can be characterized by a relatively large speed of sound which indicates fast dynamical evolution and the lack of long time delays during hadronization .
massive quarks and anti - quarks can form clusters , 2- and 3-body objects , which can be easily associated with the hadronic mass spectra : massive quarks ( @xmath181 mev ) above the critical temperature turn into similarly massive `` constituent quarks '' inside hadrons below @xmath45 in a smooth but rapid hadronization process .
discussions with t.s .
bir , e. laermann , b. mller , a. schfer , m. thoma , j. zimnyi , and especially with b. kmpfer and a. peshier , are gratefully acknowledged .
p.l . is grateful for the warm hospitality of the institute fr theoretische physik at universitt regensburg .
this work was supported in part by daad by the national scientific research fund ( hungary ) otka grant nos . f019689 and t016206 ( p.l . ) , and by dfg , bmbf and gsi ( u.h . ) . 99 j. kapusta , nucl . phys . * b148 * ( 1979 ) 461 . v.v .
klimov , zh .
* 82 * ( 1982 ) 336 ( sov .
jetp * 55 * ( 1982 ) 199 ) .
weldon , phys . rev .
* d26 * ( 1982 ) 1394 ; * d26 * ( 1982 ) 2789 .
pisarski , physica * a158 * ( 1989 ) 146 . j. frenkel and j.c .
taylor , nucl . phys .
* b334 * ( 1990 ) 199 ; + e. braaten and r.d .
pisarski , nucl . phys .
* b337 * ( 1990 ) 569 . m. le bellac , _ thermal field theory _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 1996 ) ; + m. h. thoma , hep - ph/9503400 .
r. baier , s. peigne , and d. schiff , z. phys . *
c62 * ( 1994 ) 337 ; + f. flechsig , a.k .
rebhan , and h. schulz , phys . rev .
* d52 * ( 1995 ) 2994 ; + u. krmmer , a.k .
rebhan , and h. schulz , ann . phys .
* 238 * ( 1995 ) 286 .
u. krmmer , m. kreuzer , and a.k .
rebhan , ann . phys .
* 201 * ( 1990 ) 223 ; + f. flechsig and a.k .
rebhan , nucl . phys .
* b464 * ( 1996 ) 279 .
k. kajantie , m. laine , j. peisa , a. rajantie , k. rummukainen , and m. shaposhnikov , phys .
. lett . * 79 * , 3130 ( 1997 ) .
gorenstein and s.n .
yang , phys . rev .
* d52 * ( 1995 ) 5206 .
f. karsch , z. phys .
* c38 * ( 1988 ) 147 ; + f. karsch , nucl .
* b9 * ( 1989 ) 357 .
f. karsch , m.t .
mehr , and h. satz , z. phys .
* c37 * ( 1988 ) 617 .
j. engels , j. fingberg , k. redlich , h. satz , and m. weber , z. phys .
* c42 * ( 1989 ) 341 .
v. goloviznin and h. satz , z. phys .
* c57 * ( 1993 ) 671 .
a. ukawa , nucl . phys .
* a498 * ( 1989 ) 227c .
bir , p. lvai , and b. mller , phys . rev . * d42 * ( 1990 ) 3078 .
j. engels , j. fingberg , f. karsch , d. miller , and m. weber , phys .
* b252 * ( 1990 ) 625 .
a. peshier , b. kmpfer , o.p .
pavlenko , and g. soff , phys . lett . *
b337 * ( 1994 ) 235 .
g. boyd , j. engels , f. karsch , e. laermann , c. legeland , m. ltgemeier , and b. petersson , phys .
* 75 * ( 1995 ) 4169 ; nucl .
* b469 * ( 1996 ) 419 .
e. laermann , nucl . phys .
* a610 * ( 1996 ) 1c .
a. peshier , b. kmpfer , o.p .
pavlenko , and g. soff , phys . rev .
* d54 * ( 1996 ) 2399 .
b. grossman , s. gupta , u.m .
heller , and f. karsch , nucl
* b417 * ( 1994 ) 289 .
rischke , m.i .
gorenstein , a. schfer , h. stcker , and w. greiner , phys . lett .
* b278 * ( 1992 ) 19 ; + d.h .
rischke , j. schaffner , m.i .
gorenstein , a. schfer , h. stcker , and w. greiner , z. phys . *
c56 * ( 1992 ) 325 . c. bernard , t. blum , c. detar , s. gottlieb , k. rummukainen , u.m .
heller , j.e .
hetrick , d. toussaint , l. krkkinen , r.l .
sugar , and m. wingate , phys . rev .
* d55 * ( 1997 ) 6861 .
s. gottlieb , u.m .
heller , a.d .
kennedy , s. kim , j.b .
kogut , c. liu , r.l .
renken , d.k .
sinclair , r.l .
sugar , d. toussaint , and k.c .
wang , phys . rev .
* d55 * ( 1997 ) 6852 .
j. engels , r. joswig , f. karsch , e. laermann , m. ltgemeier , and b. petersson , phys .
* b396 * ( 1997 ) 210 .
lattice95 conf .
( proc . suppl . )
* b47 * ( 1996 ) ; + lattice96 conf .
( proc . suppl . )
* b53 * ( 1997 ) .
b. kmpfer , o.p .
pavlenko , a. peshier , m. hentschel , and g. soff , fzr-189 ( 1997 ) , j. phys .
* g * in print .
e. braaten , phys .
* 74 * ( 1995 ) 2164 .
e. braaten and a. nieto , phys
* d51 * ( 1995 ) 6990 .
f. karsch , a. patks , and p. petreczky , phys . lett .
* b401 * ( 1997 ) 69 .
drummond , r.r .
horgan , p.v .
landshoff , and a. rebhan , hep - ph/9708426 .
eskola , b. mller , and x.n .
wang , phys .
* b374 * ( 1996 ) 20 . t.s .
bir , p. lvai , and j. zimnyi , phys . lett .
* b347 * ( 1995 ) 6 ; + j. zimnyi , t.s .
bir , t. csrg , and p. lvai , heavy ion phys . * 4 * ( 1996 ) 55 .
p. rehberg , s.p .
klevansky , and j. hfner , phys . rev .
* c53 * ( 1996 ) 410 .
p. lvai and r. vogt , phys
* c56 * ( 1997 ) in press , ( hep - ph/9704360 ) u. heinz , ann . phys .
* 168 * ( 1986 ) 148 .
rebhan , phys . rev .
* d48 * ( 1993 ) 3967 .
k. kajantie and j. kapusta , ann . phys .
* 160 * ( 1985 ) 477 .
j. fingberg , u. heller and f. karsch , nucl . phys .
* b392 * ( 1993 ) 493 . c. michael and the ukqcd coll
. , nucl phys . *
b * ( proc .
suppl . ) * 30 * ( 1993 ) 509 ; + g.s .
bali and k. schilling , nucl .
* b * ( proc .
suppl . ) * 30 * ( 1993 ) 513 .
d. h. rischke and m. gyulassy , nucl . phys .
* a597 * ( 1996 ) 701 ; nucl .
* a608 * ( 1996 ) 479 . t. csrg and l.p .
csernai , phys . lett .
* b333 * ( 1994 ) 494 ; + l.p .
csernai and i. mishustin , phys . rev .
* 74 * ( 1995 ) 5005 .
j. letessier , a. tounsi , u. heinz , j. sollfrank , and j. rafelski , phys .
* d51 * ( 1995 ) 3408 .
fig . 1 : : : the temperature dependent effective gluon mass , @xmath15 , in units of temperature @xmath13 ( a ) and the effective number of gluonic quasi - particle degrees of freedom , @xmath65 ( b ) in pure su(3 ) gauge theory ( @xmath35=0 ) as a function of @xmath182 . the horizontal line in fig .
1b indicates @xmath66 .
fig . 2 : : : the temperature dependent effective gluon mass , @xmath15 , in units of temperature @xmath13 ( a ) and the interaction term @xmath67 normalized by the energy density @xmath99 ( b ) for pure su(3 ) gauge theory ( @xmath35=0 ) as a function of @xmath182 .
for details see text .
fig . 3 : : : the function @xmath43 for the effective coupling constant @xmath32 in pure su(3 ) gauge theory .
the solid line shows the mean values , the dotted lines show the influence of a @xmath183 systematic error of the lattice data on the function @xmath43 . the fitted function eq .
( [ kfun ] ) is denoted by the dashed line , and the horizontal line at @xmath184 indicates its asymptotic value .
fig . 4 : : : lattice data for pure su(3 ) gauge theory on @xmath185 and @xmath186 ( diamonds ) @xcite , their reconstruction with a free quasi - particle picture with @xmath153 ( dash - dotted lines ) , and including the interaction term @xmath67 ( dashed lines ) .
the horizontal line at @xmath187 indicates the stefan - boltzmann value for massless non - interacting particles .
fig . 5 : : : the temperature dependent effective gluon mass , @xmath15 , in units of temperature @xmath13 ( a ) and the interaction term @xmath67 normalized by the energy density @xmath99 ( b ) in su(3 ) gauge theory for @xmath35=2 and @xmath35=4 as a function of @xmath182 .
: : : the function @xmath43 from the effective coupling constant @xmath32 in su(3 ) gauge theory @xmath156 ( solid lines ) and the influence of @xmath101 systematic error of lattice data on the function @xmath43 .
: : : su(3 ) lattice data ( symbols ) and our model reconstruction ( lines ) : @xmath4 @xcite ( a ) and @xmath5 @xcite ( b ) .
the reconstructed quantities are denoted by dash - dotted lines in a simple quasi - particle picture and dashed lines if the interaction term @xmath67 is included .
horizontal lines indicate the stefan - boltzmann values for massless non - interacting particles , 12.17 and 19.08 , respectively .
: : : the speed of sound @xmath155 , calculated for @xmath156 .
the dash - dotted lines denote the results @xmath159 from the free quasi - particle model ( @xmath153 ) while the dashed lines with asymptotic value @xmath188 indicate the results including the interaction term @xmath67 .
note that the differences between @xmath144 0 , 2 and 4 are hardly visible . fig . 9
: : : the effective masses of quarks ( dashed curves ) and gluons ( solid curves ) in su(3 ) gauge theory with @xmath1440 , 2 and 4 quark flavour .
10 : : : the density ratios between massive ( @xmath189 ) and massless ( @xmath190 ) quarks and gluons in su(3 ) gauge theory for @xmath1440 , 2 and 4 .
fig . 11 : : : the relative gluon density @xmath191 for massive , @xmath178 for massless particles in @xmath4 ( solid lines ) and in @xmath5 ( dashed lines ) qgp . | we analyze recent results of su(3 ) lattice qcd calculations with a phenomenological parametrization for the quark - gluon plasma equation of state based on a quasi - particle picture with massive quarks and gluons . at high temperature
we obtain a good fit to the lattice data using perturbative thermal quark and gluon masses from an improved htl scheme . at temperatures close to the confinement phase transition the fitted masses increase above the perturbative value , and a non - zero ( but small ) bag constant
is required to fit the lattice data .
= 7.2pt = 7.2pt 14.5pt |
_ * `` ... an infinite series of times , in a dizzily growing , ever spreading network of diverging , converging and parallel times . this web of time
the strands of which approach one another , bifurcate , intersect or ignore each other through the centuries embraces every possibility . ''
[ borges ] * _ _ `` quid est ergo tempus ?
si nemo ex me quaerat , scio ; si quaerenti explicare velim , nescio . '' _ @xcite as augustinus hipponensis present physicists are in the situation where time is an essential physical parameter whose meaning is intuitively clear , but several problems arise when they try to provide a clear definition of time .
first of all the definition of time is different in different branches of physics as classical and non - relativistic quantum mechanics ( a fixed background parameter ) , special relativity ( a proper time for each observer , time as fourth coordinate ; set of privileged inertial frames ) or general relativity ( time is a general spacetime coordinate : not at all an absolute time , time non orientability , closed timelike curves)@xcite .
more specifically , the problem of time @xcite in physics consists in the fact that a straightforward quantization of the general relativistic evolution equation and constraints generates the wheeler - de witt equation @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the global hamiltonian of the universe and @xmath2 is its state .
obviously , this means that the state of the universe must be static , which clashes with our everyday experience of an evolving world .
apart from the wheeler - de witt equation , one can also consider that a time shift of the state of the whole universe must be unobservable from a purely physical consideration : if shifting the state of the whole universe , there is nothing external that can keep track of this shift , so this shift must be unobservable ( it is a trivial application of mach s principle ) .
same considerations would apply , of course , also to the spatial degrees of freedom : a global shift in position of the whole state of the universe must similarly be unobservable , so the universe must be in an eigenstate of its momentum operator . in the following
we will only consider temporal degrees of freedom .
incidentally , this idea of a static universe surprisingly re - proposes , of course rephrased in modern language , ideas stemming from the work of parmenides of elea [ `` the phenomena of movement and change are simply appearances of a static , eternal reality '' ] and then diffused in roman - hellenistic word [ `` tempus item per se non est , sed rebus ab ipsis consequitur sensus , transactum quid sit in aevo , tum quae res instet , quid porro deinde sequatur '' titus lucretius carus , de rerum natura ] . the page and wootters scheme @xcite , which developed some previous ideas @xcite , is based on the fact that there exist states of a system composed by entangled subsystems that are stationary , but one can interpret the component subsystems as evolving .
one can then suppose that the global state of the universe as one of this static entangled state , whereas the state of the subsystems ( us , for example ) can evolve .
this solves in an extremely elegant way the problem of time .
incidentally , page and wootters proposal naturally embodies the philosophy of relationalism @xcite and operationalism , since time is only defined in relation to clocks and to its measurement procedure @xcite . up to now
, all these considerations were of theoretical character .
here we epitomize an experimental approach @xcite to this problem by providing an emblematic example of page and wootters idea at work , visualizing how time could emerge from a static ( with respect to an abstract external time ) entangled state .
even though the total state of a system is static , time is recovered as correlations between a subsystem that acts as a clock and the rest of the system that evolves according to such a clock .
we use a system composed of two entangled photons ( a paradigmatic system for several emblematic experiments @xcite ) : the rotation of the polarization of the first acts as a clock for proving an evolution of the polarization of the second .
nonetheless , we demonstrate that the joint polarization state of both photons does not evolve .
the page - wooters mechanism has been criticised @xcite , and gambini et al . have proposed some new ideas @xcite to overcome these criticisms .
out experiment demonstrates also some aspects of these ideas .
the experimental setup is schematically depicted in figure 1 .
it consists of two blocks , `` preparation '' and `` measurement '' .
the preparation block allows producing a family of ququarts biphoton polarization states @xcite of the form : @xmath3 basis ; bs for beam splitter.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] it includes two orthogonally oriented bbo crystals ( @xmath4 ) that , pumped by a @xmath5 mw cw ar laser operating at @xmath6 nm , generate a pair of the basic ququart states via type - i spontaneous parametric down conversion in collinear , frequency degenerate regime around the central wavelength of @xmath7 nm . the basic state amplitudes are controlled with the help of a thompson prism ( v ) , oriented verticaly and the half - wave plate @xmath8 at an angle @xmath9 .
two @xmath10 mm quartz plates ( qp ) , that can be rotated along the optical axis , introduce a phase shift @xmath11 between horizontally and vertically polarized type - i entangled @xcite biphotons .
non - linear crystals and quartz plates are placed into a temperature - stabilized closed box for achieving stable phase - matching conditions all the time .
the preparation block also includes a non - polarizing beam splitter ( bs ) , which is used to split the initial ( collinear ) biphoton field into two spatial modes @xmath12 . for preparing the singlet bell state @xmath13 parameters @xmath14 , were selected and an additional half - wave plate @xmath8 at @xmath15 was introduced in the transmitted arm .
the measurement part can be mounted in two different modes `` observer '' and `` super - observer '' .
`` observer '' mode ( figure 1 , block a ) serves as proving that one subsystem ( polarization of the upper photon ) evolves with respect to a clock constituted by the other subsystem ( polarization of the lower photon ) . in the `` super - observer '' mode ( ( figure 1 , block b ) )
we show that the global state of the two photons is static with respect to any `` external '' clock .
let us analyze the observer mode first .
* `` observer '' mode : * each arm of a measurement block contains interference filters ( if ) with central wavelength @xmath7 nm ( fwhm @xmath10 nm ) and polarizing beam splitter ( pbs ) .
four avalanche photodiode detectors ( apd ) are placed at the ends and connected to a coincidence count scheme ( cc ) with @xmath16 ns time window . in this mode
the polarization of the photon in the lower arm is used as a clock for proving an evolution of the polarization of the photon in the upper arm . in other words ,
the first polarizing beam splitter pbs acts as a non - demolition measurement that measures ( in the h / v basis ) the polarization of the second photon in the state @xmath17 ( [ eq : singlet ] ) .
once it is initialized in the @xmath18 state , the polarization of both photons evolves in the birefringent quarts plates ( a ) at @xmath15 as @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the materials optical thickness .
the clock readout is performed on the lower detectors , which measure whether the photon is @xmath21 or @xmath22 .
this clock is extremely primitive , since it has a dial with only two values : either it found with @xmath18 polarization , corresponding to time @xmath23 or with @xmath24 polarization , corresponding to time @xmath25 . in the `` observer '' mode
we do not have access to any external clock , the only information we obtain are correlations ( coincidences ) between the detectors .
thus , this primitive clock allows extracting the information about the polarization of the upper photon in a defined state , for example @xmath22 , only from registering coincidence counts between the detectors @xmath26 ( that corresponds to the measurement at the moment time @xmath23 ) or 2 - 3 ( that corresponds to time @xmath25 ) .
furthermore , one does not have any knowledge about the past time after the clock initialization ( knowledge about this time is equivalent to the presence of an external clock ) , so we have to record all events taking place in selected points of time @xmath23 and @xmath25 . from the experimental point of view
it means measurements of coincidences between the detectors 1 - 3 and 2 - 3 for all possible thicknesses of the birefringent plates a @xcite .
averaging the number of counts from detectors 1 - 3 and 2 - 3 over the total number of photon pairs from all detectors 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 , gives the probability of finding the upper photon in polarization state @xmath22 @xmath27 and @xmath28 at two points of time . to obtain a more interesting clock ,
we perform the same conditional probability measurement introducing varying time delays to the clock photon , implemented through quartz plates of variable thickness ( dashed box b in figure [ f : schema ] , block b ) .
[ even though he has no access to abstract coordinate time , he can have access to systems that implement known time delays , that he can calibrate separately .
] now , we obtain a sequence of time - dependent values for the conditional probability : @xmath29 and @xmath30 , where @xmath31 is the time delay of the clock photon obtained by inserting the quartz plate b with thickness @xmath32 in the clock photon path .
the experimental results are presented in fig .
[ f : resultsgp ] , where each colour represents a different delay : the yellow points refer to @xmath33 ; the red points to @xmath34 , etc .
[ f : resultsgp ] _ _ our results are in very good agreement with the theory ( dashed line ) @xcite .
the reduction in visibility of the sinusoidal time dependence of the probability is caused by the decoherence effect due to the use of a low - resolution clock ( our clock outputs only two possible values ) , a well known effect @xcite .
* `` super - observer '' mode : * the former parter of the experiment is addressed to show that one photon `` evolves '' when using the other photon as a clock .
now we have to show that the global state of two photons is static with respect to any `` external '' clock . to do so , we need to repeat the whole experiment in `` super - observer '' mode , and show that for arbitrary thicknesses of the birefringent plates which represent an `` external '' time the state is invariant .
this setup of the experiment is shown in figure 1(block b ) . here
the @xmath35 beam splitter ( bs ) on the output of a balanced interferometer is performing a quantum erasure of the polarization measurement performed by the polarizing beam splitter pbs1 .
in the ideal case the beam splitter should coherently transmit a photon that passes in the upper arm and reflects a photon that passes in the lower arm of the interferometer without affecting its polarization . without loss of generality , in our setup we use a conventional beam splitter and post - selection on one of the exits .
for temporal stability the interferometer was placed into a closed box and narrow interference filters ( @xmath7 nm , fwhm=@xmath10 nm ) were inserted before the detectors .
a set of quartz plates ( a ) with different thicknesses are used to introduce an `` external '' time . for analyzing an output state of transformed ququarts we used the quantum state tomography procedure .
necessary projective measurements were realized by polarization filters placed in front of detectors .
each filter consists of a sequence of quarter- and half - wave plates and a polarization prism which transmits vertical polarization .
two apds linked to a coincidence scheme with 1.5 ns time window were used as single photon detectors . in our experiment
we used the protocol of ref .
registering the coincidence rate for 16 different projections , that were realized by half and quarter plates and a fixed analyzer , it was possible to reconstruct the arbitrary polarization state of ququarts .
the accuracy of quantum tomography is estimated through the fidelity @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the initial ( theoretical ) density matrix and @xmath38 is the reconstructed density matrix after transformation .
our results are summarized in table i , demonstrating the stationarity of the global state respect to the evolution .
in summary , by running our experiment in two different modes ( `` observer '' and `` super - observer '' mode ) we have experimentally shown how the same energy - entangled hamiltonian eigenstate can be perceived as evolving by the internal observers that test the correlations between a clock subsystem and the rest ( also when considering two - time measurements ) , whereas it is static for the super - observer that tests its global properties .
our experiment is a practical implementation of the page and wooters@xcite and gambini et al .
@xcite mechanisms but , obviously , it can not discriminate between this and other proposed solutions for the problem of time @xcite , representing only an `` illustration '' of this phenomenon .
developments to higher dimensional systems could eventually be envisaged by using atoms @xcite . in closing
, we note that the time - dependent graphs of fig .
[ f : resultsgp ] have been obtained without any reference to an external time ( or phase ) reference , but only from measurements of correlations between the clock photon and the rest representing an implementation of a ` relational ' measurement of a physical quantity ( time ) relative to an internal quantum reference frame @xcite , i.e. an example of relational metrology .
this research was supported by the john templeton foundation ( the opinions expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the john templeton foundation ) , e.v.moreva acknowledges the support from the dynasty foundation and russian foundation for basic research ( project 13 - 02 - 01170-a ) .
aurelius augustinus hipponensis quid est ergo tempus ?
si nemo ex me quaerat , scio ; si quaerenti explicare velim , nescio confessiones , xi , 14 anderson e 2012 _ ann .
phys . _ * 524 * 757 ( _ preprint _ gr - qc/1009.2157v3 sorkin r d 1994 _ int
. j. theor .
phys . _ * 33 * 523 ; kiefer c 2009 _ preprint _ gr - qc/0909.3767 ; vedral v 2014 _ preprint _ quant - ph/1408.6965 merali z 2013 the origins of space and time _ nature _ * 500 * 516 - 519 nikolic h 2014 _ international journal of quantum information in press _ doi : 10.1142/s0219749915600011 ; nikolic h 2012 _ international journal of quantum information in press _ * 10 * 1250024 .
nicolis s 2014 _ preprint _ quant - ph/1411.7293 briggs j s and rost j m 2001 _ found .
_ * 31 * 693 ; pegg d t 1991 _ j.phys . a _ * 24 * 3031 aharonov y , popescu s and tollaksenet j 2013 _ preprint _ quant - ph/1305.1615 wootters w k 1984 _ int .
* 23 * 701 page d n and wootters w k 1983 _ phys .
* 27 * 2885 vedral v and mott n 1931 _ proc .
* 27 * 553 ; banks t 1985 _ nucl .
b _ * 249 * 332 ; brout r 1987 _ found .
* 17 * 603 ; brout r , horwitz g and weil d 1987 _ phys .
b _ * 192 * 318 ; brout r 1987 _ z. phys .
b _ * 68 * 339 james d f v , kwiat p g , munro w j and white a g 2001 _ phys .
a _ * 64 * 052312 kwiat p , waks e , white a , appelbaum i and eberhard p 1991 _ phys .
a _ * 60 * 773(r ) dewitt b s 1967 quantum theory of gravity .
i. the canonical theory _ phys . rev . _ * 160 * 1113 - 48 hartle j b and hawking s w 1983 wave function of the universe _ phys .
* 28 * 2960 - 75 page d n and wootters w k 1983 evolution without evolution : dynamics described by stationary observables _
* 27 * 2885 page d n 1993 clock time and entropy _ physical origins of time asymmetry _ ( cambridge univ . press ) gambini r , porto r a , pullin j and torterolo s 2009 conditional probabilities with dirac observables and the problem of time in quantum gravity _ phys .
d _ * 79 * 041501(r ) peres a 1980 measurement of time by quantum clocks _ am .
j. phys . _
* 48 * 552 rovelli c 1996 relational quantum mechanics _ int .
j. of theor .
phys . _ * 35 * 1637 rovelli c 1991 , _ phys . rev
. d _ * 43 * , 442 unruh w g and wald r m 1989 time and the interpretation of canonical quantum gravity _ phys .
* 40 * 2598 gambini r , pintos
l p g and pullin j 2011 an axiomatic formulation of the montevideo interpretation of quantum mechanics _ studies his .
phys . _ * 42 * , 256 - 263 einstein a 1905 zur elektrodynamik bewegter krper _ ann
. phys . _ * 17 * 891 ( translated in 1923 _ the principle of relativity _ methuen & co. london ) scully m o , englert b g and walther h 1991 quantum optical tests of complementarity _ nature _ * 351 * 111 drr s , nonn t and rempe g 1998 origin of quantum - mechanical complementarity probed by a ` which - way ' experiment in an atom interferometer _ nature _ * 395 * , 33 preskill j _ lecture notes for physics _ 229 ( at http://www.theory.caltech.edu/people/preskill/ph229 , pg .
68 ) gambini r , pintos l p g and pullin j 2010 undecidability and the problem of outcomes in quantum measurements it found
. phys . * 40 * 93 - 115 egusquiza
i l garay l j and raya j m 1999 quantum evolution according to real clocks _ phys .
a _ * 59 * 3236 bartlett s d , rudolph t and spekkens w 2007 reference frames , superselection rules , and quantum information _ rev .
* 79 * 555 wiseman h m 2004 defending continuous variable teleportation : why a laser is a clock , not a quantum channel _ j.opt .
b : quantum semiclass
* 6 * s849 tiefenbacher f. , schmitt - manderbach t. , weier , h. scheidl , t. lindenthal , m. blauensteiner , b. jennewein , t. perdigues , j. , trojek , p. , mer , b. , et al .
2007 entanglement - based quantum communication over 144 km . _ nature physics _ * 3 * 481 ; boschi d. , branca s. , de martini f. , hardy l. and popescu s. 1998 , experimental realization of teleporting an unknown pure quantum state via dual classical and einstein - podolsky - rosen channels _ phys .
lett . _ * 80 * 1121 ; kwiat , p.g .
2001 , experimental entanglement distillation and ` hidden ' non - locality
. _ nature _ * 409 * 1014 ; yamamoto , t. et al.2003 , experimental extraction of an entangled photon pair from two identically decohered pairs .
_ nature _ * 421 * 343 ; pan . , j.w .
2001 , entanglement purification for quantum communication .
nature * 410 * 1067 ; brida g et al .
2012 , _ phys
a _ * 68 * , 033803 ; brida g et al .
2006 , _ physical review letters _ * 96 * 143601 .
genovese m 2005 _ phys .
rep . _ * 413 * 319 moreva
e v , brida g , gramegna m , giovannetti v , maccone l and genovese m 2014 _ phys .
a _ * 89 * 052122 bogdanov yu i , brida g , genovese m , shurupov a p , moreva e v and kulik s p 2010 _ phys . rev .
_ * 105 * 010404 bogdanov yu i , moreva e v , maslennikov g a , galeev r f , straupe s s and kulik s p 2006 _ phys .
a _ * 73 * 063810 brida g , degiovanni i p , florio a , genovese m , giorda p , meda a , paris m and shurupov a 2010 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 104 * 100501 massar s , spindel p , varn a f and wunderlichet c 2014 _ preprint _ quant - ph 1410.6683 | the `` problem of time '' in present physics substantially consists in the fact that a straightforward quantization of the general relativistic evolution equation and constraints generates for the universe wave function the wheeler - de witt equation , which describes a static universe .
page and wootters considered the fact that there exist states of a system composed by entangled subsystems that are stationary , but one can interpret the component subsystems as evolving : this leads them to suppose that the global state of the universe can be envisaged as one of this static entangled state , whereas the state of the subsystems can evolve . here
we synthetically present an experiment , based on pdc polarization entangled photons , that shows a practical example where this idea works , i.e. a subsystem of an entangled state works as a `` clock '' of another subsystem . |
on a daily basis , people undergo numerous interactions with objects that barely register on a conscious level . for instance , imagine a person shopping at a grocery store as shown in figure [ fig : main ] .
suppose she picks up a can of juice to load it in her shopping cart .
the distance of the can is maintained fixed due to the constant length of her arm .
when she checks the expiration date on the can , the distance and orientation towards the can is adjusted with respect to her eyes so that she can read the label easily . in the next aisle
, she may look at a lcd screen at a certain distance to check the discount list in the store .
thus , this example shows that spatial arrangement between objects and humans is subconsciously established in 3d . in other words , even though people do not consciously plan to maintain a particular distance and orientation when interacting with various objects , these interactions usually have some consistent pattern .
this suggests the existence of an egocentric object prior in the person s field of view , which implies that a 3d salient object should appear at a predictable location , orientation , depth , size and shape when mapped to an egocentric rgbd image .
our main conjecture stems from the recent work on human visual perception @xcite , which shows that _ humans possess a fixed size prior for salient objects_. this finding suggests that a salient object in 3d undergoes a transformation such that people s visual system perceives it with an approximately fixed size . even though , each person s interactions with the objects are biased by a variety of factors such as hand dominance or visual acuity , common trends for interacting with objects certainly exist . in this work
, we investigate whether one can discover such consistent patterns by exploiting egocentric object prior from the first - person view in rgbd frames .
our problem can be viewed as an inverse object affordance task @xcite . while the goal of a traditional object affordance task is to predict human behavior based on the object locations , we are interested in predicting potential salient object locations based on the human behavior captured by an egocentric rgbd camera .
the core challenge here is designing a representation that would encode generic characteristics of visual saliency without explicitly relying on object class templates @xcite or hand skin detection @xcite .
specifically , we want to design a representation that captures how a salient object in the 3d world , maps to an egocentric rgbd image . assuming the existence of an egocentric object prior in the first - person view , we hypothesize that a 3d salient object would map to an egocentric rgbd image with a predictable shape , location , size and depth pattern .
thus , we propose an egoobject representation that represents each region of interest in an egocentric rgbd video frame by its _ shape _ , _ location _ , _ size _ , and _
depth_. note that using egocentric camera in this context is important because it approximates the person s gaze direction and allows us to see objects from a first - person view , which is an important cue for saliency detection . additionally , depth information is also beneficial because it provides an accurate measure of object s distance to a person .
we often interact with objects using our hands ( which have a fixed length ) , which suggests that depth defines an important cue for saliency detection as well . thus assuming the existence of an egocentric object prior
, our egoobject representation should allow us to accurately predict pixelwise saliency maps in egocentric rgbd frames . to achieve our goals , we create a new egocentric rgbd saliency dataset .
our dataset captures people s interactions with objects during various activities such as shopping , cooking , dining . additionally , due to the use of egocentric - stereo cameras
, we can accurately capture depth information of each scene .
finally we note that our dataset is annotated for the following three tasks : saliency detection , future saliency prediction , and interaction classification .
we show that we can successfully apply our proposed egocentric representation on this dataset and achieve solid results for these three tasks .
these results demonstrate that by using our egoobject representation , we can accurately characterize an egocentric object prior in the first - person view rgbd images , which implies that salient objects from the 3d world map to an egocentric rgbd image with predictable characteristics of shape , location , size and depth .
we demonstrate that we can learn this egocentric object prior from our dataset and then exploit it for 3d saliency detection in egocentric rgbd images .
region proposals . for each of the regions
@xmath1 we then generate a feature vector @xmath2 that captures shape , location , size and depth cues and use these features to predict the 3d saliency of region @xmath1 . ]
* saliency detection in images . * in the past , there has been much research on the task of saliency detection in 2d images .
some of the earlier work employs bottom - up cues , such as color , brightness , and contrast to predict saliency in images @xcite .
additionally , several methods demonstrate the importance of shape cues for saliency detection task @xcite . finally , some of the more recent work employ object - proposal methods to aid this task @xcite . unlike the above listed methods that try to predict saliency based on contrast , brightness or color cues , we are more interested in expressing an egocentric object prior based on shape , location , size and depth cues in an egocentric rgbd image .
our goal is then to use such prior for 3d saliency detection in the egocentric rgbd images .
* egocentric visual data analysis .
* in the recent work , several methods employed egocentric ( first - person view ) cameras for the tasks such as video summarization @xcite , video stabilization @xcite , object recognition @xcite , and action and activity recognition @xcite . in comparison to the prior egocentric approaches we propose a novel problem , which can be formulated as an inverse object affordance problem : our goal is to detect 3d saliency in egocentric rgbd images based on human behavior that is captured by egocentric - stereo cameras .
additionally , unlike prior approaches , we use * egocentric - stereo * cameras to capture egocentric rgbd data . in the context of saliency detection ,
the depth information is important because it allows us to accurately capture object s distance to a person .
since people often use hands ( which have fixed length ) to interact with objects , depth information defines an important cue for saliency detection in egocentric rgbd environment . unlike other methods , which rely on object detectors @xcite , or hand and skin segmentation @xcite
, we propose egoobject representation that is based solely on shape , location , size and depth cues in an egocentric rgbd images .
we demonstrate that we can use our representation successfully to predict 3d saliency in egocentric rgbd images .
based on our earlier hypothesis , we conjecture that objects from the 3d world map to an egocentric rgbd image with some predictable _ shape _ , _ location _ , _ size _ and _ depth_. we encode such characteristics in a region of interest @xmath3 using an egoobject map , @xmath4 \in \mathds{r}^{n_s\times n_l \times n_b \times n_d \times n_c}$ ] where @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 are the number of the feature dimension for shape @xmath10 , location @xmath11 , size @xmath12 , depth @xmath13 , and context @xmath14 , respectively .
a shape feature , @xmath15^\mathsf{t}$ ] captures a geometric properties such as area , perimeter , edges , and orientation of @xmath3 .
* @xmath16 : perimeter divided by the squared root of the area , the area of a region divided by the area of the bounding box , major and minor axes lengths .
* @xmath17 : we employ boundary cues @xcite , which include , sum and average contour strength of boundaries in region @xmath3 and also minimum and maximum ultrametric - contour values that lead to appearance and disappearance of the smaller regions inside @xmath3 @xcite .
* @xmath18 : eccentricity and orientation of @xmath3 and also the diameter of a circle with the same area as region @xmath3 . a location feature @xmath19^\mathsf{t}$ ]
encode spatial prior of objects imaged in an egocentric view : * @xmath20 : normalized bounding box coordinates and the centroid of a region @xmath3 .
* @xmath21 : we also compute horizontal and vertical distances from the centroid of @xmath1 to the center of an image , and also to the mid - points of each border in the image . a size feature @xmath22^\mathsf{t}$ ]
encodes the size of the bounding box and area of the region . *
@xmath23 : area and perimeter of region @xmath3 . *
@xmath24 : area and aspect ratio of the bounding box corresponding to the region @xmath3 .
@xmath25^\mathsf{t}$ ] encodes a spatial distribution depth within @xmath3 .
* @xmath26 : minimum , average , maximum , depth and also standard deviation of depth in a region @xmath3 .
* @xmath27 : @xmath28 spatial depth histograms over the region @xmath3 .
* @xmath29 : @xmath30 depth histograms over the region @xmath3 aligned to its major axis . * @xmath31 : @xmath28 spatial _
normalized _ depth histograms over the region @xmath3 . *
@xmath32 : @xmath30 _ normalized _ depth histograms over the region @xmath3 aligned to its major axis .
in addition , we include a context feature @xmath14 that encodes a spatial relationship between near regions in the egocentric image .
given two regions , @xmath33 computes a distance between two features , i.e. , @xmath34^\mathsf{t}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] given a target region , @xmath3 , the context feature @xmath35^\mathsf{t}$ ] computes the relationship with @xmath36 neighboring regions , @xmath37 : * @xmath38 : @xmath39 * @xmath40 : @xmath41 * @xmath42 : @xmath43 * @xmath44 : @xmath45 where @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the feature vector constructued by the min - pooling and max - pooling of neighboring regions for each dimension .
@xmath48 takes average of neighboring features and @xmath49 is the feature of the top @xmath50 nearest neighbor .
* summary . * for every region of interest @xmath3 in an egocentric rgbd frame
, we produce a @xmath51 dimensional feature vector denoted by @xmath52 .
we note that some of these features have been successfully used previously in tasks other than 3d saliency detection @xcite . additionally , observe that we do not use any object - level feature or hand or skin detectors as is done @xcite .
this is because , in this work , we are primarily interested in studying the idea that salient objects from the 3d world are mapped to an egocentric rgbd frame with a consistent shape , location , size and depth patterns .
we encode these cues with our egoobject representation and show its effectiveness on egocentric rgbd data in the later sections of the paper .
given an rgbd frame as an input to our problem , we first feed rgb channels to an mcg @xcite method , which generates @xmath53 proposal regions .
then , for each of these regions @xmath3 , we generate our proposed features @xmath52 and use it as an input to the random forest classifier ( rf ) . using a rf
, we aim to learn the function that takes the feature vector @xmath52 corresponding to a particular region @xmath3 as an input , and produces an output for one our proposed tasks for region @xmath3
( i.e. saliency value or interaction classification ) .
we can formally write this function as @xmath54 .
we apply the following pipeline for the following three tasks : 3d saliency detection , future saliency prediction , and interaction classification . however ,
for each of these tasks we define a different output objective @xmath55 and train rf classifier according to that objective separately for each task .
below we describe this procedure for each task in more detail . * 3d saliency detection . *
we train a random forest _
regressor _ to predict region s @xmath3 intersection over union ( iou ) with a ground truth salient object . to train the rf regressor we sample @xmath56 regions from our dataset , and extract our features from each of these regions .
we then assign a corresponding ground truth iou value to each of them and train a rf regressor using @xmath57 trees .
our rf learns the mapping @xmath58 $ ] where @xmath55 denotes the ground truth iou value between the @xmath3 and the ground truth salient object . to deal with the imbalance issue
, we sample an equal number of examples corresponding to the iou values of @xmath59,[0.25,0.5],[0.5,0.75]$ ] , and @xmath60 $ ] . at testing time
, we use mcg @xcite to generate @xmath53 regions of interest .
we then apply our trained rf for every region @xmath3 and predict @xmath61 , which denotes the saliency of a region @xmath3 .
we note that mcg produces the set of regions that overlap with each other .
thus , for the pixels belonging to multiple overlapping regions @xmath62 , we assign a saliency value that corresponds to the maximum predicted value across the overlapping regions ( i.e. @xmath63 ) .
we illustrate the basic pipeline of our approach in fig .
[ fig : method ] . * future saliency prediction . * for future saliency prediction , given a video frame , we want to predict , which object will be salient ( i.e. used by a person ) after @xmath64 seconds .
we hypothesize that the gaze direction is one of the most informative cues that are indicative of person s future behavior
. however , gaze signal may be noisy if we consider only a single frame in the video .
for instance , this may happen due to the person s attention being focused somewhere else for a split second or due to the shift in the camera .
to make our approach more robust to the fluctuations of person s gaze , we incorporate simple temporal features into our system .
our goal is to use these temporal cues to normalize the gaze direction captured by an egocentric camera and make it more robust to the small camera shifts .
thus , given a frame @xmath65 which encodes time @xmath66 , we also consider frames @xmath67 .
we pair up each of these frames @xmath68 with @xmath65 and compute their respective homography matrix @xmath69 .
we then use each @xmath69 to recompute the image center @xmath70 in the current frame @xmath65 . for every region
@xmath1 we then recompute its distance @xmath71 to the new center @xmath70 for all @xmath72}$ ] and concatenate these new distances to the original features @xmath52 .
such gaze normalization scheme ensures robustness to our system in the case of gaze fluctuations .
seconds , where the same object is salient .
our goal here is to predict an object that will be salient after @xmath66 seconds .
] seconds , where the same object is salient .
our goal here is to predict an object that will be salient after @xmath66 seconds .
] seconds , where the same object is salient .
our goal here is to predict an object that will be salient after @xmath66 seconds .
] seconds , where the same object is salient .
our goal here is to predict an object that will be salient after @xmath66 seconds .
] seconds , where the same object is salient .
our goal here is to predict an object that will be salient after @xmath66 seconds .
] seconds , where the same object is salient .
our goal here is to predict an object that will be salient after @xmath66 seconds . ] * interaction classification .
* most of the current computer vision systems classify objects by specific object class templates ( cup , phone , etc ) .
however , these templates are not very informative and can not be used effectively beyond the tasks of object detection . adding object s function , and
the type of interaction related to that object would allow researchers to tackle a wider array of problems overlapping vision and psychology . to predict an interaction type at a given frame , for each frame we select top @xmath73 highest ranked regions @xmath74 according to their predicted saliency score .
we then classify each of these regions either as sight or touch . finally , we take the majority label from these @xmath73 classification predictions , and use it to classify an entire frame as sight or touch .
| c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c | c ? c & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap & mf & ap + fts @xcite & 7.3 & 0.6 & 8.9 & 1.3 & 10.6 & 1.2 & 5.8 & 0.5 & 4.5 & 1.1 & 17.2 & 2.0 & 20.0 & 2.5 & 5.0 & 0.7 & 9.9 & 1.2 + mcg @xcite & 10.4 & 4.7 & 13.8 & 7.0 & 21.1 & 12.7 & 7.1 & 2.9 & 12.5 & 5.7 & 23.6 & 12.2 & 31.2 & 14.9 & 11.1 & 5.1 & 16.4 & 8.1 + gbmr @xcite & 8.0 & 3.0 & 15.6 & 6.8 & 14.7 & 7.0 & 6.8 & 3.0 & 4.3 & 1.3 & 32.7 & 18.3 & 46.0 & 30.2 & 12.9 & 5.7 & 17.6 & 9.4 + salobj @xcite & 7.2 & 2.7 & 19.9 & 7.4 & 21.3 & 10.0 & 15.4 & 5.1 & 5.8 & 2.2 & 24.1 & 9.2 & 49.3 & 28.3 & 9.0 & 3.4 & 19.0 & 8.5 + gbvs @xcite & 7.2 & 3.0 & 21.3 & 11.4 & 20.0 & 10.6 & 16.1 & 8.8 & 4.3 & 1.4 & 23.1 & 13.8 & 50.9 & * 50.2 & 11.6 & 5.7 & 19.3 & 13.1 + objectness @xcite & 11.5 & 5.6 & * 35.1 & * 24.3 & 39.2 & 29.4 & 11.7 & 6.9 & 4.7 & 1.9 & 27.1 & 17.1 & 47.4 & 42.2 & 13.0 & 6.4 & 23.7 & 16.7 + * ours ( rgb ) & 25.7 & 16.2 & 34.9 & 21.8 & 37.0 & 23.0 & 23.3 & 14.4 & * 28.9 & * 18.5 & 32.0 & 18.7 & * 56.0 & 39.6 & 30.3 & 21.8 & 33.5 & 21.7 + * ours ( rgb - d ) & * 36.9 & * 26.6 & 30.6 & 18.2 & * 55.3 & * 45.4 & * 26.8 & * 19.3 & 18.8 & 10.5 & * 37.9 & * 25.4 & 50.6 & 38.4 & * 40.2 & * 28.5 & * 37.1 & * 26.5 + * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
we now present our egocentric rgbd saliency dataset . our dataset records people s interactions with their environment from a first - person view in a variety of settings such as shopping , cooking , dining , etc .
we use egocentric - stereo cameras to capture the depth of a scene as well .
we note that in the context of our problem , the depth information is particularly useful because it provides an accurate distance from an object to a person .
since we hypothesize that a salient object from the 3d world maps to an egocentric rgbd frame with a predictable depth characteristic , we can use depth information as an informative cue for 3d saliency detection task .
our dataset has annotations for three different tasks : saliency detection , future saliency prediction , and interaction classification .
these annotations enables us to train our models in a supervised fashion and quantitatively evaluate our results .
we now describe particular characteristics of our dataset in more detail . * data collection . *
we use two stereo gopro hero 3 ( black edition ) cameras with @xmath75 baseline to capture our dataset .
all videos are recorded at @xmath76 with @xmath77 .
the stereo cameras are calibrated prior to the data collection and synchronized manually with a synchronization token at the beginning of each sequence
. * depth computation . *
we compute disparity between the stereo pair after stereo rectification .
a cost space of stereo matching is generated for each scan line and match each pixel by exploiting dynamic programming in a coarse - to- fine manner .
* sequences . *
we record @xmath78 video sequences that capture people s interactions with object in a variety of different environments .
these sequences include : cooking , supermarket , eating , hotel @xmath79 , hotel @xmath80 , dishwashing , foodmart , and kitchen sequences .
* saliency annotations .
* we use grabcut software @xcite to annotate salient regions in our dataset .
we generate @xmath81 annotated frames for kitchen , cooking , and eating sequences , @xmath82 and @xmath83 annotated frames for supermarket and foodmart sequences respectively , @xmath84 and @xmath85 annotated frames for hotel @xmath79 and hotel @xmath80 sequences respectively , and @xmath86 annotated frames for dishwashing sequence ( for a total of @xmath87 frames with per - pixel salient object annotations ) . in fig .
[ fig : data_po ] , we illustrate a few images from our dataset and the depth channels corresponding to these images . to illustrate ground truth labels , we overlay these images with saliency annotations . additionally , in fig . [
fig : data_stats ] , we provide statistics that capture different properties of our dataset such as the location , depth , and size of annotated salient regions from all sequences . each video sequence from our dataset is marked by a different color in this figure .
we observe that these statistics suggest that different video sequences in our dataset exhibit different characteristics , and captures a variety of diverse interactions between people and objects .
* annotations for future saliency prediction . *
in addition , we also label our dataset to predict future saliency in egocentric rgbd image after @xmath64 frames .
specifically , we first find the frame pairs that are @xmath64 frames apart , such that the same object is present in both of the frames .
we then check that this object is non - salient in the earlier frame and that it is salient in the later frame .
finally , we generate per - pixel annotations for these objects in both frames .
we do this for the cases where the pair of frames are @xmath88 , and @xmath89 seconds apart .
we produce @xmath90 annotated frames for kitchen , @xmath91 for cooking , @xmath92 for eating , @xmath93 for supermarket , @xmath90 for hotel @xmath79 , @xmath94 for hotel @xmath80 , @xmath95 for foodmart , and @xmath90 frames dishwashing sequences .
we present some examples of these annotations in fig .
[ fig : data_fut ] . * annotations for interaction classification . *
to better understand the nature of people s interactions with their environment we also annotate each interaction either as _ sight _ or as _ touch_.
in this section , we present the results on our egocentric rgbd saliency dataset for three different tasks , which include 3d saliency detection , future saliency prediction and interaction classification .
we show that using our egoobject feature representation , we achieve solid quantitative and qualitative results for each of these tasks .
to evaluate our results , we use the following procedure for all three tasks .
we first train random forest ( rf ) using the training data from @xmath96 sequences .
we then use this trained rf to test it on the sequence that was not used in the training data .
such a setup ensures that our classifier is learning a meaningful pattern in the data , and thus , can generalize well on new data instances .
we perform this procedure for each of the @xmath78 sequences separately and then use the resulting rf model to test on its corresponding sequence . for the saliency detection and future saliency prediction tasks , our method predicts pixelwise saliency for each frame in the sequence . to evaluate our results we use two different measures : a maximum f - score ( mf ) along the precision - recall curve , and average precision ( ap ) . for the task of interaction classification
, we simply classify each interaction either as sight or as touch .
thus , to evaluate our performance we use the fraction of correctly classified predictions .
we now present the results for each of these tasks in more detail . detecting 3d saliency in an egocentric rgbd setting
is a novel and relatively unexplored problem .
thus , we compare our method with the most successful saliency detection systems for 2d images . sequences .
these visualizations demonstrate that in each of these sequences , our method captures an egocentric object prior that has a distinct shape , location , and size pattern . ]
these visualizations demonstrate that in each of these sequences , our method captures an egocentric object prior that has a distinct shape , location , and size pattern . ]
these visualizations demonstrate that in each of these sequences , our method captures an egocentric object prior that has a distinct shape , location , and size pattern . ]
these visualizations demonstrate that in each of these sequences , our method captures an egocentric object prior that has a distinct shape , location , and size pattern . ]
these visualizations demonstrate that in each of these sequences , our method captures an egocentric object prior that has a distinct shape , location , and size pattern . ]
these visualizations demonstrate that in each of these sequences , our method captures an egocentric object prior that has a distinct shape , location , and size pattern . ] in table [ po_table ] , we present quantitative results for the saliency detection task on our dataset .
we observe that our approach outperforms all the other methods by @xmath97 and @xmath98 in mf and ap evaluation metrics respectively .
these results indicate that saliency detection methods designed for _ non - egocentric _
images do not generalize well to the _ egocentric _ images .
this can be explained by the fact that in most _ non - egocentric _ saliency detection datasets , images are displayed at a pretty standard scale , with little occlusions , and also close to the center of an image .
however , in the egocentric environment , salient objects are often occluded , they appear at a small scale and around many other objects , which makes this task more challenging . furthermore , we note that none of these baseline methods use depth information . based on the results , in table [ po_table ] ,
we observe that adding depth features to our framework provides accuracy gains of @xmath99 and @xmath100 according to mf and ap metrics respectively . finally , we observe that the results of different methods vary quite a bit from sequence to sequence .
this confirms that our egocentric rgbd saliency dataset captures various aspects of people s interactions with their environment , which makes it challenging to design a method that would perform equally well in each of these sequences
. based on the results , we see that our method achieves best results in @xmath96 and @xmath89 sequences ( out of @xmath78 ) according to mf and ap evaluation metrics respectively , which suggests that exploiting egocentric object prior via shape , location , size , and depth features allows us to predict visual saliency robustly across all sequences . additionally , we present our qualitative results in fig . [
fig : po_preds ] .
our saliency heatmaps in this figure suggest that we can accurately capture different types of salient interactions with objects . furthermore , to provide a more interesting visualization of
our learned egocentric object priors , we average our predicted saliency heatmaps for each of the @xmath89 selected sequences and visualize them in fig . [
fig : avg_preds ] .
we note that these averaged heatmaps have a certain shape , location , and size characteristics , which suggests the existence of an egocentric object prior in egocentric rgbd images . in fig .
[ fig : feats ] , we also analyze , which features contribute the most for the saliency detection task . the feature importance is quantified by the mean squared error reduction when splitting the node by that feature in a random forest . in this case , we manually assign each of our @xmath51 features to one of @xmath78 groups .
these groups include shape , location , size , depth , shape context , location context , size context and depth context features ( as shown in fig .
[ fig : feats ] ) . for each group , we average the importance value of all the features belonging to that group and present it in figure [ fig : feats ] . based on this figure , we observe that shape features contribute the most for saliency detection .
additionally , since location features capture an approximate gaze of a person , they are deemed informative as well .
furthermore , we observe that size and depth features also provide informative cues for capturing the saliency in an egocentric rgbd image .
as expected , the context feature are least important . in this section ,
we present our results for the task of future saliency prediction .
we test our trained rf model under three scenarios : predicting a salient object that will be used after @xmath88 , and @xmath89 seconds respectively .
as one would expect , predicting the event further away from the present frame is more challenging , which is reflected by the results in table [ fut_table ] .
for this task , we aim to use our egoobject representation to learn the cues captured by egocentric - stereo cameras that are indicative of person s future behavior .
we compare our future saliency detector ( fsd ) to the saliency detector ( sd ) from the previous section and show that we can achieve superior results , which implies the existence and consistency of the cues that are indicative of person s future behavior .
such cues may include person s gaze direction ( captured by an egocentric camera ) , or person s distance to an object ( captured by the depth channel ) , which are both pretty indicative of what the person may do next . in fig .
[ fig : fut_preds ] , we visualize some of our future saliency predictions .
based on these results , we observe , that even in a difficult environment such as supermarket , our method can make meaningful predictions .
.future saliency results according to max f - score ( mf ) and average precision ( ap ) evaluation metrics .
given a frame at time @xmath66 , our future saliency detector ( fsd ) predicts saliency for times @xmath101 , and @xmath102 ( denoted by seconds ) . as our baseline
we use a saliency detector ( sd ) from section [ tech_approach ] of this paper .
we show that in every case we outperform this baseline according to both metrics .
this suggests that using our representation , we can consistently learn some of the egocentric cues such as gaze , or person s distance to an object that are indicative of people s future behavior . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in this section , we report our results on the task of interaction classification . in this case , we only have two labels ( sight and touch ) and so we evaluate the performance as a fraction of correctly classified predictions .
we compare our approach with a depth - based baseline , for which we learn an optimal depth threshold for each sequence , then for a given input frame , if a predicted salient region is further than this threshold , our baseline classifies that interaction as _ sight _ , otherwise the baseline classifies it as _
touch_. due to lack of space , we do not present the full results .
however , we note that our approach outperforms depth - based baseline in @xmath89 out of @xmath78 categories and achieves @xmath103 higher accuracy on average in comparison to this baseline .
we also illustrate some of the qualitative results in fig .
[ fig : po_preds ] .
these results indicate that we can use our representation to successfully classify people s interactions with objects by sight or touch .
in this paper , we introduced a new psychologically inspired approach to a novel 3d saliency detection problem in egocentric rgbd images . we demonstrated that using our psychologically inspired egoobject representation we can achieve good results for the three following tasks : 3d saliency detection , future saliency prediction , and interaction classification .
these results suggest that an egocentric object prior exists and that using our representation , we can capture and exploit it for accurate 3d saliency detection on our egocentric rgbd saliency dataset . | on a minute - to - minute basis people undergo numerous fluid interactions with objects that barely register on a conscious level .
recent neuroscientific research demonstrates that humans have a fixed size prior for salient objects .
this suggests that a salient object in 3d undergoes a consistent transformation such that people s visual system perceives it with an approximately fixed size .
this finding indicates that there exists a consistent egocentric object prior that can be characterized by shape , size , depth , and location in the first person view . in this paper
, we develop an egoobject representation , which encodes these characteristics by incorporating shape , location , size and depth features from an egocentric rgbd image .
we empirically show that this representation can accurately characterize the egocentric object prior by testing it on an egocentric rgbd dataset for three tasks : the 3d saliency detection , future saliency prediction , and interaction classification .
this representation is evaluated on our new egocentric rgbd saliency dataset that includes various activities such as cooking , dining , and shopping . by using our egoobject representation ,
we outperform previously proposed models for saliency detection ( relative @xmath0 improvement for 3d saliency detection task ) on our dataset .
additionally , we demonstrate that this representation allows us to predict future salient objects based on the gaze cue and classify people s interactions with objects . |
recently , the both schools of takemura and takayama have developed a quite interesting minimization method called holonomic gradient descent method(hgd ) .
it utilizes grbner basis in the ring of differential operator with rational coefficients .
grbner basis in the differential operators plays a central role in deriving some differential equations called a pfaffian system for optimization .
hgd works by a mixed use of pfaffian system and an iterative optimization method .
it has been successfully applied to several maximum likelihood estimation ( mle ) problems , which have been intractable in the past .
for example , hgd solve numerically the mle problems for the von mises - fisher distribution and the fisher - bingham distribution on the sphere ( see , sei et al.(2013 ) and nakayama et al.(2011 ) ) .
furthermore , the method has also been applied to the evaluation of the exact distribution function of the largest root of a wishart matrix , and it is still rapidly expanding the area of applications(see , hashiguchi et al.(2013 ) ) . on the other hand , in statistical models ,
it is not rare that parameters are constrained and therefore the mle problem with constraints has been surely one of fundamental topics in statistics . in this paper
, we develop hgd for mle problems with constraints , which we call the constrained holonomic gradient descent(chgd ) .
the key of chgd is to separate the process into ( a ) updating of new parameter values by newton - raphson method with penalty function and ( b ) solving a pfaffian system .
we consider the following the constrained optimization problem .
@xmath2 where @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 are all assumed to be continuously differentiable function .
@xmath6 is an equality constraint function and @xmath7 is an inequality constraint function . in this paper ,
the objective function @xmath8 is assumed to be holonomic .
we call the interior region defined by the constraint functions _ the feasible region_. a penalty function method replaces a constrained optimization problem by a series of unconstrained problems
. it is performed by adding a term to the objective function that consists of a penalty parameter @xmath9 and a measure of violation of the constraints . in our simulation
, we use _ the exact penalty function method_. the definition of the exact penalty function is given by ( see yabe ( 2006 ) ) . @xmath10
assume that we seek the minimum of a holonomic function @xmath8 and the point @xmath11 which gives the minimum @xmath8 .
in hgd , we use the iterative method together with a pfaffian system . in this paper
, we use the the newton - raphson iterative minimization method in which the renewal rule of the search point is given by @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 is the hessian of @xmath8 at @xmath15 .
hgd is based on the theory of the grbner basis . in the following ,
we refer to the relation of a numerical method and the grbner basis .
let @xmath16 be the differential ring written as @xmath17 \langle \partial_1, ..
,\partial_n \rangle \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath18 $ ] are the rational coefficients of differential operators .
suppose that @xmath19 is a left ideal of @xmath16 , @xmath20 $ ] is a field and @xmath21\langle \partial_1, .. ,\partial_n \rangle \in i$ ] .
if an arbitrary function @xmath22 satisfies @xmath23 for all @xmath24 , then @xmath22 is a solution of @xmath25 .
that is @xmath26 when @xmath22 satisfies equation ( [ eq_h ] ) , @xmath22 is called _
holonomic function_. let @xmath27 $ ] , with @xmath28 be a standard basis in the quotient vector space @xmath29 which is a finite dimensional vector spaces .
let @xmath30 be the grbner basis of @xmath25 .
the rank of arbitrary differential operations can be reduced by normalization by @xmath30 .
assume that @xmath31 holds .
for a solution @xmath22 of @xmath25 put @xmath32 .
then , it holds that ( see , e.g.,nakayama et al.(2011 ) ) @xmath33 where @xmath34 is a @xmath35 matrix with @xmath36 as a @xmath37 element @xmath38_{j } , \ \
i=1, ... ,n,\ \ j=1 ... ,t\end{aligned}\ ] ] this proves the assertion . the above differential equations are called _ pfaffian differential equations _ or _ pfaffian system _ of @xmath25 .
so we can calculate the gradient of @xmath39 by using pfaffian differential equations .
then , @xmath40 and @xmath41 are also given by pfaffian differential equations .
( see hibi et al.(2012 ) ) let @xmath42 be the normal form of @xmath43 by @xmath30 and @xmath44 be the normal form of @xmath45 by @xmath30 . then we have , @xmath46 where @xmath47 denotes the first entry of a vector @xmath48 . for hgd , we first give an ideal @xmath49 for holonomic function @xmath8 and calculate the grbner basis @xmath30 of @xmath25 and then the standard basis @xmath50 are given by @xmath30 .
the coefficient matrix @xmath34 for pfaffian system is led by this standard basis , and @xmath41 and @xmath40 are calculated from @xmath50 by starting from a initial point @xmath51 through the pfaffian equations .
after these , we can compute automatically the optimum solution by a mixed use of then newton - raphson method .
the algorithm is given by below .
* set @xmath52 and take an initial point @xmath53 and evaluate @xmath54 . *
evaluate @xmath40 and @xmath55 from @xmath39 and calculate the newton direction , @xmath56 * update a search point by @xmath57 . *
evaluate @xmath58 by solving pfaffian equations numerically .
* set @xmath59 and calculate @xmath58 and goes to step.2 and repeat until convergence .
the key step of the above algorithm is step 4 .
we can not evaluate @xmath58 by inputting @xmath60 in the function @xmath8 since the hgd treats the case that @xmath8 is difficult to calculate numerically .
instead , we only need calculate @xmath61 and @xmath62 numerically for a given initial value @xmath51 .
now , we propose the method in which we add constraint conditions to hgd and call it the constrained holonomic gradient descent method(chgd ) . for treating constraints we use the penalty function and add it to objective function and make a new objective function and can treat it as the unconstrained optimization problem .
we use hgd for evaluation of gradients and hessian and use the exact penalty function method for constraints .
the value of updating a search point can be obtained as the product of directional vector and step size .
the step size @xmath63 is chosen so that the following armijo condition is satisfied .
in fact we chose @xmath63 such that @xmath64 where @xmath65 and @xmath66 is the approximation of @xmath67 given by .
@xmath68 the initial value of @xmath63 is set @xmath69 and then @xmath63 is made smaller iteratively until @xmath63 satisfies equation ( [ eq_s ] ) , or @xmath70 . in our algorithm ,
holonomic gradient descent plays a role to calculate the gradient vectors and then the penalty function plays a role to control the step size iteratively .
we apply chgd for mle for von mises distribution(vm ) .
the process of applying for hgd is shown in nakayama et al.(2011 ) .
the density function of vm is given by @xmath71 .
the parameters of vm , @xmath72 and @xmath73 , show concentration and mean of angle data @xmath74 respectively .
we set the parameters for mle @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
now we solve the constrained optimization problem given by .
@xmath77 let @xmath74 be sample data .
let @xmath78 be sample size .
then , @xmath79 and @xmath80 . in our simulation
, we set the vm s parameter @xmath81 of which the true value @xmath82 and the initial value @xmath83 . we tried the 2 patterns of constraints .
both of the case worked under the same condition except constraints . in figure 1
, the constraint is @xmath84 . in figure 2 ,
the constraint is @xmath85 .
figures 1,2 are the drawing of the trace of the search point . the result of simulation , the convergence point of hgd is @xmath86 . in figure 1 ,
the convergence point of chgd is @xmath87 . in figure 2 ,
the convergence point of chgd is @xmath88 . in the chgd ,
the search direction is almost same as the hgd , because the direction is decided by the hgd s algorithm . while , the constraints play the role to judge the search point is within the feasible region or not and decide the step size .
chgd is the effective method for optimization with constraints .
however , whenever chgd increases the cost of runtimes than hgd regardless of whether the solution is in the feasible region or not .
the following table shows the runtimes when the optimization solution is within the feasible region . in table
[ tb1 ] , all numbers are the means of 500 times trials . the optimization problem is equation ( [ optvm ] ) .
sample data is drawn from the vm with @xmath89 .
the third column of table [ tb1 ] is the result with only newton - raphson method which optimize @xmath8 directly , not use pfaffian system .
thus , we see that hgd and chgd is faster than newton - raphson method .
we see that the runtimes of chgd is longer than hgd in general , where the both of solutions are almost the same value when the solution is inside the feasible region .
sometimes the process finishes early by constraints , when the solution is outside the feasible region .
although , we need consider the cost of calculation of chgd . 99 hashiguchi , h. , numata , y. , takayama , n. , takemura , a. ( 2013 ) .
_ `` the holonomic gradient method for the distribution function of the largest root of a wishart matrix''_. journal of multiva , riate analysis 117 ( 2031 ) 296 - 312 nakayama , h. , nishiyama , k. , noro , m. , ohara , k. , sei , t. , takayama , n. , takemura , a. ( 2011 ) .
_ `` holonomic gradient descent and its application to the fisher
bingham integral''_. advances in applied mathematics , 47(3 ) , 639 - 658 .
yabe , h. ( 2006 ) .
_ `` introduction and application of optimization problem(japanese)''_. surikougakusha publisher .
cox , d. a. , little , j. , oshea , d. ( 2007 ) .
_ `` ideals , varieties , and algorithms : an introduction to computational algebraic geometry and commutative algebra ( vol .
10)''_. springer verlag . | recently , the school of takemura and takayama have developed a quite interesting minimization method called _ holonomic gradient descent method _
( hgd ) .
it works by a mixed use of pfaffian differential equation satisfied by an objective holonomic function and an iterative optimization method .
they successfully applied the method to several maximum likelihood estimation ( mle ) problems , which have been intractable in the past . on the other hand , in statistical models , it is not rare that parameters are constrained and therefore the mle with constraints has been surely one of fundamental topics in statistics . in this paper we develop hgd with constraints for mle . * holonomic decent minimization method for restricted maximum likelihood estimation * + rieko sakurai@xmath0 , and toshio sakata @xmath1 + @xmath0 _ graduate school of medicine , kurume university 67 asahimachi , kurume 830 - 0011 , japan _
+ @xmath1 _ faculty of design human science , kyushu university , 4 - 9 - 1 shiobaru minami - ku , fukuoka 815 - 8540 , japan _ + email : [email protected] _ key words : holonomic gradinet descent method , newton - raphson method with penalty function , von mises - fisher distribution _ |
recent progress in quantum communication technology has confirmed that the biggest challenge in using quantum methods of communication is to provide scalable methods for building large - scale quantum networks @xcite .
the problems arising in this area are related to physical realizations of such networks , as well as to designing new protocols that exploit new possibilities offered by the principles of quantum mechanics in long - distance communication .
one of the interesting problems arising in the area of quantum internetworking protocols is the development of methods which can be used to detect errors that occur in large - scale quantum networks . a natural approach for developing such methods is to construct them on the basis of the methods developed for classical networks @xcite .
the main contribution of this paper is the development of a method for exploring quantum networks by mobile agents which operate on the basis of information stored in quantum registers .
we construct a model based on a quantum walk on cycle which can be applied to analyse the scenario of exploring quantum networks with a faulty sense of direction .
one should note that the presented model allows studying the situations where all nodes in the network are connected .
the reason for this is that a move can result in the shift of the token from the current position to any other position in the network .
thus we do not restrict ourselves to a cycle topology .
this paper is organized as follows . in the remaining part of this section we provide a motivation for the considered scenario and recall a classical scenario described by magnus - derek game . in section [ sec : quantum - magnus - derek ]
we introduce a quantum the scenario of quantum network exploration with a distracted sense of direction . in section [ sec : application - quantum ] we analyse the behaviour of quantum mobile agents operating with various classes of strategies and describe non - adaptive and adaptive quantum strategies which can be employed by the players . finally , in section [ sec : final ] we summarize the presented work and provide some concluding remarks . as quantum networks
consist of a large number of independent parties @xcite it is crucial to understand how the errors , that occur during the computation on nodes , influence their behaviour . such errors may arise , in the first place , due to the erroneous work of particular nodes .
therefore it is important to develop the methods that allow the exploration of quantum networks and the detection of malfunctioning nodes .
one of the methods used to tackle this problem in classical networks is the application of mobile agents , _
i.e. _ autonomous computer programs which move between hosts in a network .
this method has been studied extensively in the context of intrusion detection @xcite , but it is also used as a convincing programming paradigm in other areas of software engineering @xcite . on the other hand , recent results concerning the exploration of quantum graphs suggest that by using the rules of quantum mechanics it is possible to solve search problems @xcite or rapidly detect errors in graphs @xcite . in this paper
we aim to combine both methods mentioned above .
we focus on a model of mobile agents used to explore a quantum network . for the purpose of modelling such agents we introduce and study the quantum version of the magnus - derek game @xcite .
this combinatorial game , introduced in @xcite , provides a model for describing a mobile agent acting in a communication network .
the magnus - derek game was introduced in @xcite and analysed further in @xcite and @xcite .
the game is played by two players : derek ( from _ direction _ or _ distraction _ ) and magnus ( from _ magnitude _ or _ maximization _ ) , who operate by moving a token on a round table ( cycle ) with @xmath0 nodes @xmath1 .
initially the token is placed in the position @xmath2 . in each round ( step ) magnus decides about the number @xmath3 of positions for the token to move and derek decides about the direction : clockwise ( @xmath4 or @xmath2 ) or counter - clockwise ( @xmath5 or @xmath6 ) .
magnus aims to maximize the number of nodes visited during the game , while derek aims to minimize this value .
derek represents a distraction in the sense of direction . for example , a sequence of moves @xmath7 allowing magnus to visit three nodes , can be changed to @xmath8 due to the influence of derek represented by the @xmath4 and @xmath5 signs .
the possibility of providing biased information about the direction prevents magnus permanently from visiting some nodes . in the classical scenario
one can introduce a function @xmath9 which , for a given number of nodes @xmath0 , gives the cardinality of the set of positions visited by the token when both players play optimally @xcite .
it can be shown that this function is well defined and @xmath10 with @xmath11 being the smallest odd prime factor of @xmath0 .
by @xmath12 we denote the number of moves required to visit the optimal number of nodes . in the case
@xmath13 , the number of moves is optimal and equals @xmath14 .
et al . _
proved @xcite that if @xmath15 is a positive integer not equal to a power of @xmath16 , then there exists a strategy allowing magnus to visit at least @xmath9 nodes using at most @xmath17 moves .
we distinguish two main types of regimes adaptive and non - adaptive . in the adaptive regime ,
both players are able to choose their moves during the execution of the game . in the non - adaptive regime
, magnus announces the sequence of moves he aims to perform .
in particular , if the game is executed in the non - adaptive regime , derek can calculate his sequence of moves before the game . in the classical case
the problem of finding the optimal strategy for derek is @xmath18-hard @xcite and is equivalent to the partition problem @xcite .
let us now assume that the players operate by encoding their positions on a cycle in an @xmath0-dimensional pure quantum states .
thus the position of the token is encoded in a state @xmath19 . at the @xmath20-th step of
the game magnus decides to move @xmath21 and derek decides to move in direction @xmath22 .
one can easily express the classical game by applying the notation of quantum states .
the evolution of the system during the move described above is given by a unitary matrix of the form @xmath23 where @xmath24 .
clearly , as the above permutation operators express only the classical subset of the possible moves , by using it one can not expect to gain with respect to the classical scenario . in particular , the operators @xmath25 as introduced above do not allow the preparation of a move by using the information encoded in a superposition . in order to exploit the possibilities offered by quantum mechanics in the magnus - derek scheme
, we can use a quantum walk controlled by two registers . to achieve this
we need to offer the players a larger state space .
we introduce a quantum scheme by defining the following quantum version of the magnus - derek game . 1 .
the state of the system is described by a vector of the form @xmath26 2 .
the initial state of the system reads @xmath27 .
3 . at each step
the players can choose their strategy , possibly using unitary gates . 1 .
magnus operates on his register with any unitary gate @xmath28 resulting in a operation of the form @xmath29 performed on the full system .
2 . derek operates on his register with any unitary gate @xmath30 .
if his actions are position - independent the operation performed on the full system takes the form @xmath31 .
however , in section [ sec : position_control ] we also allow position - controlled actions , resulting in the operator of the form @xmath32 .
[ game:3b ] 4 .
the change of the token position , resulting from the players moves , is described by the shift operator @xmath33 where the addition and the subtraction is in the appropriate ring @xmath34 .
the single move in the game defined according to the above description is given by the position - independent operator @xmath35 taking this into account the state of the system after the execution of @xmath36 moves reads @xmath37 where each matrix @xmath38 depends on the move of each party .
the distribution of the position on the cycle after @xmath36 moves is described by a reduced density matrix @xmath39 which represents the state of the token register after tracing - out the subsystems used to process the strategies . here
@xmath40 represents the operation of tracing - out the subsystems used by magnus and derek to encode their strategies .
the key part of this procedure is how the players choose their strategies .
the selection of the method influences the efficiency of the exploration .
below we study the possible methods and show how they influence the behaviour of the quantum version of the magnus - derek game . clearly , by using the unitary gates magnus and derek are able to prepare the superpositions of base states .
for this reason , one needs to provide the notion of node visiting suitable for analysing quantum superpositions of states .
therefore , we introduce the notion of _ visiting _ and _ attaining _ a position .
we say that the position @xmath41 is visited in @xmath42 steps , if for some step @xmath43 the probability of measuring the position register in the state @xmath44 is 1 , _
i.e._@xmath45 in order to introduce the notion of attaining we use the concepts of measured quantum walk @xcite and concurrent hitting time .
a @xmath44-measured quantum walk from a discrete - time quantum walk starting in a state @xmath46 is a process defined by iteratively first measuring with the two projectors @xmath47 and @xmath48 . if @xmath49 is measured the process is stopped , otherwise a step operator is applied and the iteration is continued .
a quantum random walk has a @xmath50 concurrent @xmath51 hitting - time if the @xmath44-measured walk from this walk and initial state @xmath52 has a probability @xmath53 of stopping at a time @xmath54 . we say that the position @xmath41 is attained in @xmath42 steps , if @xmath44-measured exploration walk has a @xmath55 concurrent @xmath56 hitting time , i.e. the exploration walk with initial state @xmath46 has a probability of stopping at a time @xmath57 equal to @xmath6 . with the help of these definitions , one can introduce the concepts of _ visiting strategy _ and _ attaining strategy_. [ def : visiting - strategy ] if for the given sequence of moves performed by magnus , there exists @xmath42 such that each position on the cycle is visited in @xmath42 steps , then we call such sequence of moves a _ visiting strategy_. [ def : attaining - strategy ] if for the given sequence of moves performed by magnus , each position on the cycle is attained , then we call such sequence of moves an _ attaining strategy_.
the quantum scheme introduced in the previous section extends the space of strategies which can be used by both players .
as there is a significant difference in situations where @xmath13 and @xmath58 , we will consider these cases separately .
we start by considering the case @xmath13 . in this situation
we have two possible alternatives . in
the first one magnus uses the quantum version of the optimal classical strategy and derek while derek performs any possible quantum moves . in the second scenario
both players are able to explore all possible quantum moves .
let us first consider the quantum scheme executed by magnus with the use of the classical optimal strategy . as in the classical case
derek is not able to prevent magnus from visiting all the nodes , it is natural to ask if he can achieve any advantage using unitary moves .
if the number of nodes is equal to @xmath59 , for some integer @xmath36 , the optimal strategy for magnus can be computed at the beginning of the game . this strategy _
i.e. _ a sequence of magnitudes is given as ( see lemma 2 in @xcite ) @xmath60 where @xmath61 denotes the repetition of the moves starting from the beginning of the sequence until the move preceding the @xmath61 and excluding it .
the first few sequences resulting from eq .
( [ eqn : classical - optimal-2k ] ) are presented in table [ tab : magnus2-moves - examples ] .
.optimal moves to be performed by magnus when the number of nodes is equal to @xmath59 .
magnus is able to visit all @xmath0 positions in @xmath62 moves by using this strategy . [
cols="<,<",options="header " , ] by using this strategy in the classical case , magnus is able to visit all nodes using @xmath62 moves and derek is not able to prevent him from doing this .
moreover , the bound for the number of moves required to visit all the nodes in the classical case is tight .
let us now assume that magnus is using quantum moves constructed for the classical optimal strategy , but derek can use arbitrary quantum moves . for example , if @xmath63 magnus optimal strategy is realized by the following sequence of unitary gates @xmath64 first of all , as the moves performed by magnus allow him the sampling of the space of positions using @xmath65 steps , it can be easily seen that derek is not able to prevent magnus from attaining all nodes using @xmath12 moves . on the other hand ,
derek is able to prevent magnus from visiting all nodes .
he can achieve this using the strategy given as follows .
[ str:2k - strategy - h - id ] for steps @xmath66 perform the following gate @xmath67 where @xmath68 denotes the hadamard gate .
the probabilities of finding a token at each position for the scheme with magnus using the optimal strategy and derek using strategy [ str:2k - strategy - h - id ] is presented in fig .
[ fig : qpos-2k - strategy - h - id ] .
clearly , magnus is able to attain all the nodes is in @xmath69 steps .
however , derek can prevent him from visiting all nodes in @xmath69 steps .
this is expressed in the following .
[ tw : vs - optimal ] let us take @xmath70 .
then , there exists a strategy for derek preventing magnus from visiting all nodes in @xmath69 steps .
moreover , there is no strategy for derek that enables him to prevent magnus from attaining all nodes in @xmath69 steps . _
proof._the first part follows from the construction of the strategy [ str:2k - strategy - h - id ] .
in fact , any strategy of this form , not necessarily using hadamard gate , will prevent magnus from visiting all nodes .
the second part follows from the construction of the magnus strategy .
let s assume that there is a strategy that allows derek to prevent magnus from attaining a position @xmath41 i.e. this position is not attained .
then a @xmath44-measured walk has no @xmath71 concurrent hitting time .
thus , there is a non - zero probability that the process will not stop in @xmath0 steps .
this means that at each step @xmath42 there is a non - zero amplitude for some state @xmath72 with @xmath73 _ i.e. _ the state will not get measured by effect @xmath74 .
the sequence of directions resulting from the above @xmath75 used by derek in a classical version of the game would give him a strategy forbidding a visit in position @xmath41 .
it is a contradiction of the properties of magnus classical strategy .
@xmath76 the above proposition can be easily extended as , by using a quantum strategy with only one hadamard gate , derek can prevent magnus from visiting more than two nodes .
this result shows that by using quantum moves against the classical strategy , derek is not able to exclude additional positions .
however , he gains in comparison to the classical case as he is able to introduce more distraction in terms of the reliability of the exploration .
in the situation @xmath77 , the quantum strategies used by derek to distract the sense of directions can depend on the type of information which is available to him . without the possibility to perform position - controlled operations he can only use classical information about history of choices of magnus unitaries that gives him an estimate of the current state . on the other hand , if he is able to decide about his move using the current position , the resulting strategy is more robust . in the classical case the adaptive strategy allows derek to use the knowledge about magnus move to choose a step according to the position of a token in the moment of the decision . in the quantum case , when a superposition of positions is possible and no measurement is allowed , derek s decision can not depend on the position of the token .
instead , derek can maintain only information about the history and the current state of the walk in order to choose the optimal move . in this section
we provide such quantum adaptive strategy for derek under the principles of the game introduced in section [ sec : quantum - magnus - derek ] , _ i.e. _ without using controlled operations , which can be used by derek to execute his move .
using the presented strategy derek can reduce the number of visited positions to 2 ( or even one in the case of odd @xmath0 ) at the cost of increasing the number of attained positions .
the main result of this section can be stated as follows .
[ tw : pm1 ] in the case when @xmath78 contains in its decomposition two distinct odd prime numbers @xmath11 and @xmath79 there exists a strategy for derek that allows him to assert that : 1 . only the starting position ( and the symmetric one in the case of even @xmath0 ) will be visited , 2 .
the total number of attained positions during the walk will be at most @xmath80m = n-(n / q
- n / pq)$ ] , assuming that magnus uses only permutation operators .
one should note that for @xmath81 magnus can not apply the provided strategy .
moreover , the strategy could be applied recursively by excluding subsequent pairs of least odd prime divisors in order to slightly improve this result not all multiplications of @xmath82 need to be attained and the number of attained positions would be at most @xmath83 , for @xmath84 . in order to prove this , we provide a method for constructing a strategy for derek , which allows him to obtain the desired result .
we show that the provided strategy guarantees that the amplitudes of a state , at every step corresponding to a fixed set of positions , will be equal to zero and , as a consequence , there is zero probability of measuring any such positions during the walk _
i.e. _ none of them is attained .
the first requirement for derek is the choice of the set of _ restricted positions _ , _
i.e. _ positions which will be protected from being visited or attained by magnus .
restricted positions have to be distributed on the cycle in a regular way .
more precisely , we have the following .
[ fact : structure ] a set of restricted positions which can be chosen by derek in order to construct a strategy in proposition [ tw : pm1 ] is a subset of @xmath85 where @xmath11 is a divisor of @xmath0 . _
_ to show that the set of restricted position has to be of this form it is sufficient to prove that the intervals between subsequent restricted positions have to be equal .
let us assume that this is not the case and consider three subsequent restricted positions .
if the distance between two of them is even , magnus , after visiting the position in the middle , would be able to visit one of the restricted positions .
if both distances are odd , but different , then the sum of them is even and by repeating the reasoning track we obtain that magnus is able to visit at least one of the restricted positions .
@xmath76 after choosing the set @xmath86 and for a given position on the cycle , derek can choose his move independently from the magnus choice .
when we assign the positions with possible directions according to particular magnitudes it turns out that some of the positions are not distinguishable from derek s point of view .
let us call two positions _ symmetric _ if their distance to the nearest restricted position in the direction indicated by the coin register is identical .
this allows us to state the following .
[ fact : symmetric ] considering two symmetric positions the sets of directions that can be chosen by derek in order to avoid visiting restricted positions are identical for every magnus call .
one can note that the relation of being symmetric is invariant under the action of the step operator .
two facts stated above allow derek to restrict the choice of moves in such manner that he is able prevent magnus from visiting the set of restricted positions . however , the most important part of derek s strategy is steering the state of the system into a superposition of symmetric states .
such a state guarantees the possibility to perform a strategy in which none of the states will be visited ( only attained ) .
when such a superposition is achievable from the beginning , derek achieves the result similar to the classical case ( equal number of restricted positions ) assuming that none of the states is visited . on the other hand ,
when he needs to adopt to the standard situation when the starting state is a base state with one particular position , then the number of states that are attained is greater than the number of the positions visited in the classical scenario .
[ fact : distance ] if a superposition of two symmetric states has been created from a base state , the beginning position must be equally distant from two closest positions from every set of the restricted positions .
_ if this were not the case , the resulting states in a superposition would not be equally distant from restricted positions and , as the result , not symmetric .
@xmath76 the above stated facts allow the formulation of the proof of proposition [ tw : pm1 ] .
_ proof of proposition [ tw : pm1 ] .
_ as a consequence of fact [ fact : distance ] , the starting point has to belong to every restricted set .
using fact [ fact : structure ] , magnus can design a strategy that allows him to visit all positions from an arbitrarily fixed set @xmath86 ( by calling appropriate multiplications of @xmath11 ) even when restricted to the permutation operators .
thus derek has to choose two prime divisors of @xmath0 and decide which will be used as the restricted positions set , according to the magnus first move .
the optimal choice is to use two smallest factors . in this case
the optimal strategy for magnus would be to call @xmath87 and visit all positions that are multiplications of @xmath82 , and then switch to @xmath11 .
for this reason derek uses the restricted set which is identical as in the case of restricting @xmath88 excluding all the positions numbered with common multiplications of @xmath11 and @xmath79 .
from fact [ fact : symmetric ] it follows that each strategy excluding a given set of positions allows the exclusion of the same set while operating on a superposition .
taking into account the above considerations , we define the strategy for derek , which fulfills the requirements of proposition [ tw : pm1 ] .
[ str : adaptive - no - control ] for any classical strategy used by magnus , derek has to perform the following steps : * step :* apply the hadamard gate . if magnus chooses a magnitude equal to @xmath89 , for some @xmath36 , apply @xmath90 and repeat this step .
+ if magnus chooses other magnitude go to * step 3*. if magnus chooses a multiplication of @xmath11 ( respectively @xmath79 ) , set the restricted positions to be @xmath91 ( respectively @xmath92 ) .
apply the classical strategy @xcite . having strategy [ str : adaptive - no - control ] , while magnus applies the magnitude equal to @xmath89 and derek performs step 2 , no positions restricted in terms of prop .
[ tw : pm1 ] . will be attained .
starting from the moment that magnus chooses some other magnitude derek applies unitaries that correspond to the classical strategy .
this ensures that none of the restricted positions will be attained ( otherwise magnus would be able to visit more than @xmath93 positions in the classical @xmath94 case , see proof of prop .
[ tw : vs - optimal ] ) .
@xmath76 an example of state evolution in the game executed using strategy [ str : adaptive - no - control ] is presented in fig .
[ fig : nocontrol ] .
the starting position is the only one that is visited .
[ fig : nocontrol ] as it was shown in the previous section a strategy allowed for derek in the scenario introduced at the beginning of this paper is not sufficient to maintain the number of restricted positions characteristic for classical strategy and limiting magnus only to attain positions .
however , the notion of adaptive strategies for derek can be transferred into quantum scenario . in order to let derek use position information in his strategy we have to modify the model introduced in section [ sec : quantum - magnus - derek ] .
we do this by replacing the local operators @xmath95 available to derek with the position - controlled operators of the form @xmath96 .
having such operators at his disposal , derek is able to apply a different strategy to each part of the state separately .
let us consider magnus - derek game on @xmath94 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 positions with @xmath11 being the least prime divisor of @xmath0 .
when the set of operators available for derek includes the operators of the form @xmath99 where @xmath36 is an arbitrary position and @xmath100 is an arbitrary local unitary operation then the maximum number of attained positions for magnus is equal to @xmath101 ( as in the classical case ) and the total number of visited positions is at most 2 ( respectively 1 if @xmath0 is an odd number ) .
_ proof._in the simplest case derek leads to a superposition of two states . in this case
he needs only to ensure that the superposition will not vanish .
an example of such strategy is presented in fig .
[ fig : controlled - one - hadamard ] .
[ str : adaptive - controled ] for any magnus strategy based on permutation operators , when @xmath102 and @xmath11 is a prime number , derek has to perform the following steps : * step :* apply the hadamard gate .
if @xmath0 is even do nothing as long as magnus move is equal to @xmath103 .
if @xmath0 is odd go to * step 3*. find a set of @xmath104 equally distant positions that is disjoint with already visited positions .
apply classical strategy to both parts of the state using position
controlled operators .
the strategy is based on the classical one that is proven to be optimal .
if there would be a strategy for magnus that allows him to attain additional position , there would be also an analogous classical strategy ( see proof of prop .
[ tw : vs - optimal ] ) .
@xmath76 one can also consider a modification of the above strategy with the additional ability of operating on the superposition of more than two base states . the main restriction on the strategy executed by derek is , in this case , the equality of amplitudes @xmath105 for every position @xmath41 and current magnus call @xmath106 . when the condition is satisfied derek is able to set an arbitrary direction in every position of the cycle using the @xmath107 and @xmath108 operators .
the example is shown in the fig .
[ fig : pos_controled ] .
after the second step the state of the token is a superposition of at least three states . as the consequence , the probabilities are more distributed over the cycle .
the presented game provides a model for studying the exploration of quantum networks .
the model presented in this paper is based on a quantum walk on a cycle . despite its simplicity
, the presented model can be used to describe complex networks and study the behaviour of mobile agents acting in such network .
one should note that in the case of the magnus - derek game the main objective is to optimize the number of nodes visited during the game .
the actual goal of visiting depends on the computation which is required to take place at the nodes . we have shown that by extending the space of possible moves , both players can significantly change the parameters of the exploration . in particular ,
if magnus uses the sequence of moves optimal for the classical case , derek is able to prevent him from visiting all nodes .
we have assumed that in the quantum scenario not only the number of attained positions is at stake but also the number of positions that are visited by magnus .
we have considered a modification of a classical strategy that enables both players to preform their tasks efficiently .
this analysis provides an interesting insight into the difficulty of achieving quantum - oriented goals .
we have also shown that without a proper model of adaptiveness , it is not possible for derek to obtain the results analogous to the classical case ( the number of restricted positions is lower or the no - visiting condition is validated ) . performing a strategy optimized in order to reduce the number of visited slots
requires a trade - off with the total number of attained positions . with additional control resources
the total number of attained positions is maintained if the number of visited positions is strictly limited .
the authors acknowledge the support by the polish national science centre ( ncn ) under the grant number dec-2011/03/d / st6/00413 .
jam would like to acknowledge interesting discussions with m. mc gettrick and c. rver .
bernardes and e. dos santos moreira .
implementation of an intrusion detection system based on mobile agents . in _ proceedings of the international symposium on software engineering for parallel and distributed systems , 2000
_ , pages 158164 , 2000 .
t. e. chapuran , p. toliver , n. a. peters , j. jackel , m. s. goodman , r. j. runser , s. r. mcnown , n. dallmann , r. j. hughes , k. p. mccabe , j. e. nordholt , c. g. peterson , k. t. tyagi , l. mercer , and h. dardy .
optical networking for quantum key distribution and quantum communications .
, 11:105001 , 2009 . | we develop a model which can be used to analyse the scenario of exploring quantum network with a distracted sense of direction . using this model we analyse the behaviour of quantum mobile agents operating with non - adaptive and adaptive strategies which can be employed in this scenario .
we introduce the notion of node visiting suitable for analysing quantum superpositions of states by distinguishing between visiting and attaining a position .
we show that without a proper model of adaptiveness , it is not possible for the party representing the distraction in the sense of direction , to obtain the results analogous to the classical case .
moreover , with additional control resources the total number of attained positions is maintained if the number of visited positions is strictly limited .
+ keywords : quantum mobile agents ; quantum networks ; two - person quantum games = 1 |
schrdinger s cat sums up one of the most striking and counter - intuitive features of quantum systems that is the ability to exist in coherent superpositions of states , which , in the classical world , would mutually exclude each other .
while the conceptual ambiguities arising due to this phenomenon have been highly debated in the early days of quantum mechanics , during the last decades , it has been pointed out that quantum coherence might serve as valuable resource , especially for information processing . among the first suggestions in this direction were the brassard - bennett protocol and the deutsch
jozsa algorithm promising respectively intrinsically eavesdrop - secure communication and an exponential speedup of computation by exploiting the quantum superposition principle @xcite .
although theses schemes are of little practical use so far , they reveal the enormous potential of quantum technologies , which nowadays becomes all the more significant due to recent experiments showing the accessibility of quantum effects even under ambient conditions @xcite .
information thermodynamics @xcite provides another , yet much less explored , area of research , which might benefit from the utilization of quantum coherence .
the development of this field was originally triggered by maxwell s famous thought experiment challenging the second law by invoking a small intelligent being , which is able to separate the molecules of a gas in thermal equilibrium according to their velocity , thus establishing a spontaneous temperature gradient @xcite .
building on maxwell s idea , szilrd invented a microscopic engine consisting of a single molecule confined in a container , which is in contact with a thermal reservoir of constant temperature @xcite .
an external agent might operate this setup by first dividing the container in two chambers , second , detecting the position of the molecule and , third , adiabatically expanding the chamber the molecule was found in , thus extracting work from a single heat bath .
half a century after its discovery , this apparent contradiction with the second law was resolved by bennett @xcite , who showed that , due to landauer s principle @xcite , the reduction of entropy associated with the measurement in the second step must be eventually compensated when the external agent discards the gathered information from its memory , which can not be inexhaustible .
hence , effectively , the information acquired during the measurement is converted into work .
meanwhile a fairly complete and experimentally confirmed theoretical framework exists @xcite at least for classical systems , which , on a general level , provides precise extensions of the second law accounting for information as a physical quantity thus relating it to traditional thermodynamic variables such as entropy and work . in the quantum realm ,
additional intricacies arise , which are not yet fully explored @xcite .
as a consequence of the superposition principle even the hilbert space of a simple two - level system ( tls ) contains infinitely many orthonormal pairs of realizable states , each of which is associated with a specific observable , which , in principle , might be measured . moreover , according to the projection postulate , a measurement will typically alter the state of the system and thereby its mean energy .
therefore , in strong contrast to the classical case , a projective quantum measurement is not only accompanied by a decrease in entropy but also by an intrinsic change in internal energy , which must be taken into account for thermodynamic considerations .
jacobs argued that this energetic cost should be attributed to the external observer and derived an inequality , which incorporates it in an upper bound on the work extractable from a quantum system in thermal equilibrium after a single measurement @xcite .
here , we go one step further by relaxing the assumption on the initial state and allowing multiple measurements in finite intervals . using a simple argument based on the first and the second law ,
we show that jacobs bound holds whenever the probability to obtain a certain outcome does not change from one measurement to the next .
this result , in particular , implies a bound on the average work delivered by information driven quantum engines operating periodically and in finite time .
moreover , it provides a natural definition for the efficiency of such machines .
one of the first specific , fully quantum mechanical models for a measurement controlled device was proposed by lloyd @xcite . in the spirit of szilrd
s pioneering work , he considers a single spin@xmath0 system in contact with a thermal heat bath .
an external controller can extract work in form of photons from this system by measuring the energy of the spin and applying a @xmath1-pulse at the larmor frequency if the excited state is detected .
after the spin - flip , or , if initially the ground state was observed , the system is allowed to return to thermal equilibrium , before the procedure repeats .
lloyd demonstrates that his engine can completely convert the information acquired by the measurement into work .
furthermore , he argues that the efficiency of this process will inevitably decrease , due to decoherence effects , if any observable different from energy is used to determine the state of the system .
however , his reasoning strongly relies on the assumption that the spin has relaxed to thermal equilibrium before any measurement , which , in fact , would require an infinite waiting time . in this work , by generalizing the setup described above , we show that triggering a laser pulse by measuring an observable that does not commute with the hamiltonian of the system can enhance the efficiency if the model is operated in finite time .
specifically , we investigate a quantum - optical tls , whose relaxation dynamics is modeled using a quantum master equation . after a projective von - neumann measurement , the system is assumed to be detached from the heat bath such that its time evolution during the laser pulse is governed by a time - dependent schrdinger equation .
we note that such a separation of system and environment has recently been argued to be realistic in the context of quantum heat engines @xcite . for our model
, we analytically calculate the time - dependent density matrix characterizing the system in the cyclic operation mode and numerically determine the optimal observable to control the feedback protocol as a function of the relaxation time and the spacing of the energy levels .
our findings show that exploiting quantum coherences can enhance the efficiency of information engines beyond classically achievable values .
the paper is structured as follows . as our first main result
, we derive a new bound on the average work output of quantum information engines in section 2 . in section 3
, we introduce a specific model for such a machine and solve its dynamics .
section 4 is devoted to the optimization of its efficiency .
we conclude in section 5 .
we begin this section by introducing a general scheme for a cyclic quantum information engine . to this end , we consider a finite quantum system with hamiltonian @xmath2 , which is in contact with a heat bath of temperature @xmath3 and whose density matrix is initially given by @xmath4 .
this setup is now operated by an external agent in two steps .
first , an instantaneous projective measurement of the observable @xmath5 is carried out , which yields the outcome @xmath6 and leaves the system in the state @xmath7 with probability @xmath8 here , the @xmath6 are the eigenvalues of @xmath5 , which we assume to be non - degenerate , and @xmath9 denotes the normalized eigenvector of @xmath5 corresponding to @xmath6 .
second , to convert the acquired information into useful work , a control operation is applied to the system , which is conditioned on the result of the preceding measurement and leads to the evolved density matrix @xmath10,\ ] ] where @xmath11 , in principle , can be any positive , trace preserving map @xcite . practically , such an operation can be realized by intermediately manipulating the hamiltonian of the system or its coupling to the heat bath over a certain time interval .
the agent now iterates the sequence of steps one and two , where , in the @xmath12^th^ operation cycle , the measurement outcome @xmath13 is obtained with probability @xmath14 .
it is readily seen that these quantities fulfill the recursion relation @xmath15p_{m}^{(i-1)}\ ] ] with the conditional probability @xmath16 = { \langle\psi_{m'}|}\tilde{{\rho}}_{m}{|\psi_{m'}\rangle } = { \langle\psi_{m'}|}{\mathcal{v}}_{m}\big[{|\psi_{m}\rangle } { \langle\psi_{m}|}\big]{|\psi_{m'}\rangle},\ ] ] since the initial density matrix of each cycle is the result of the control operation applied in the foregoing one , as shown in figure [ fig : flow_diag ] . moreover , since the transition probability does not depend on the cycle index @xmath12 but rather is fully determined by the control operation @xmath11 and the observable @xmath5 , after sufficiently many iterations a stationary distribution @xmath17 satisfying @xmath18q_{m}\ ] ] will be approached .
once this steady state is reached , the system works as a periodic information engine .
is measured and the control operation @xmath11 conditioned on the measurement outcome @xmath6 is applied to the system .
symbols are explained in the main text . ] for a thermodynamic analysis of the scheme outlined above , we have to calculate the changes in internal energy @xmath19\equiv { { { \rm tr}}\left\{h{\rho}\right\}}$ ] and entropy @xmath20\equiv-{k_\mathrm{b}}{{{\rm tr}}\left\{{\rho}\ln{\rho}\right\}}$ ] of the system associated with the steps one and two , where @xmath21 is boltzmann s constant . considering an operation cycle with initial density matrix @xmath22 and measurement outcome @xmath13
, we find @xmath23- e[\tilde{{\rho}}_{m } ] = { \langle\psi_{m'}|}h{|\psi_{m'}\rangle } -{{{\rm tr}}\left\{h\tilde{{\rho}}_{m}\right\ } } , \label{demeas}\\ \delta{s_{{\rm sys}}}^{{\rm meas}}(m',m ) & = { s_{{\rm sys}}}[{\rho}_{m'}]- { s_{{\rm sys}}}[\tilde{{\rho}}_{m } ] = { k_\mathrm{b}}{{{\rm tr}}\left\{\tilde{{\rho}}_{m}\ln\tilde{{\rho}}_{m}\right\ } } \label{dsmeas}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the measurement and @xmath24- e[{\rho}_{m ' } ] = { { { \rm tr}}\left\{h\tilde{{\rho}}_{m'}\right\}}-{\langle\psi_{m'}|}h{|\psi_{m'}\rangle},\\ \delta{s_{{\rm sys}}}^{{\rm con}}({m ' } ) & = { s_{{\rm sys}}}[\tilde{{\rho}}_{m'}]-{s_{{\rm sys}}}[{\rho}_{m ' } ] = -{k_\mathrm{b}}{{{\rm tr}}\left\{\tilde{{\rho}}_{m'}\ln\tilde{{\rho}}_{m'}\right\}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the control operation , where we used @xmath25=0 $ ] due to @xmath26 representing a pure state
. since the total entropy production during the control step @xmath27 must be nonnegative by virtue of the second law , it follows that the change in entropy of the heat bath @xmath28 is bounded from below by @xmath29 and thus the heat taken up by the system @xmath30 during the control operation @xmath31 is bounded from above by @xmath32 .
consequently , the first law @xmath33 implies the bound @xmath34 on the work @xmath35 the agent can extract from the system using the operation @xmath31 .
since the measurement outcome @xmath6 occurs with probability @xmath36 in the steady state , yields the bound @xmath37 on the average work extracted per operation cycle .
furthermore , the average energetic cost and entropy reduction per cycle associated with the measurement read @xmath38 and @xmath39 respectively . here ,
@xmath40q_{m}$ ] is the probability to measure @xmath13 and @xmath6 in two consecutive operation cycles . inserting and into and and using the steady state condition as well as the sum rule @xmath41 = 1\ ] ] expressing probability conservation yields @xmath42 by comparing and with , we obtain the bound @xmath43 this inequality , which constitutes our first main result , provides a universal upper bound on the average work extractable per operation cycle in terms of quantities that are related to the measurement process only .
it generalizes similar results obtained in @xcite for single stroke operations . following the arguments of jacobs @xcite
, we consider the energetic cost of the measurement @xmath44 as work input provided by the measurement apparatus and thus infer from the natural definition @xmath45 for the efficiency , at which information is converted to work in cyclic quantum engines .
we note that , while @xmath46 is readily seen to be always nonnegative , in contrast to the setup considered in @xcite , @xmath47 can , in principle , become negative , since , for finite cycle times , the system will typically not be in thermal equilibrium before the measurement is performed
. moreover , the quantity @xmath47 is of pure quantum origin and vanishes in the quasi - classical situation , where the observable @xmath5 commutes with the hamiltonian of the system @xmath2 .
as an application of the general theory discussed so far , we propose a generalization of a paradigmatic model for a quantum information engine originally invented by lloyd @xcite and analyze its thermodynamic properties . specifically , we consider an optical tls with hamiltonian @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the energetic spacing between the ground state @xmath50 and the excited state @xmath51 .
the external agent measures the observable @xmath52 @xmath53 with eigenvalues @xmath54 and corresponding eigenvectors @xmath55 which reduce to the eigenstates of @xmath2 for @xmath56 . in order to extract work in form of photons ,
after a measurement of the state @xmath57 , the system is detached from the heat bath and a coherent laser pulse on resonance is applied for an interval @xmath58 . after a measurement of @xmath59 ,
the system is kept in contact with the thermal environment for a time @xmath60 without any action of the agent to allow the absorption of additional heat before the next measurement is carried out . .
if the outcome of this measurement is @xmath61 , the internal energy of the tls is used to coherently amplify an externally generated laser pulse ( b ) .
if the outcome is @xmath62 , the susceptibility of the system for further energy uptake is exploited to extract heat from the environment ( c ) . in any case , the density matrix at the end of the operation cycle serves as initial state for the subsequent one . for further explanations of the symbols ,
see main text . ] for a quantitative description of this procedure , which is summarized in figure [ fig : tls_scheme ] , we need to specify the control operations @xmath63 . during the interaction ( @xmath64 ) with the laser pulse
, the density matrix @xmath65 of the system evolves unitarily according to the liouville - von neumann equation @xmath66 \equiv \mathcal{l}_+(\tau){\rho}(\tau),\ ] ] where , on the semiclassical level and within the rotating wave approximation , the time - dependent hamiltonian is given by @xmath67 with real rabi frequency @xmath68 and @xmath69 being the phase of the dipole matrix element @xcite . to describe the interaction of the tls with the heat bath during @xmath70
, we use the quantum optical master equation @xcite @xmath71 + \gamma n\left(l{\rho}(\tau)l^\dagger -\frac{1}{2}l^\dagger l{\rho}(\tau ) -\frac{1}{2}{\rho}(\tau)l^\dagger l\right)\nonumber\\ & \hspace{2.23 cm } + \gamma ( n+1)\left(l^\dagger{\rho}(\tau)l -\frac{1}{2}ll^\dagger{\rho}(\tau ) -\frac{1}{2}{\rho}(\tau)ll^\dagger\right)\nonumber\\ & \equiv { \mathcal{l}}_-{\rho}(\tau ) , \label{meq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath72 is a lindblad operator , @xmath73 - 1)$ ] denotes the planck distribution evaluated for the level spacing @xmath74 and @xmath75 is a damping rate quantifying the coupling strength between the tls and the thermal reservoir .
this time evolution equation , which is of lindblad form and therefore preserves trace and positivity of the density matrix , can be derived from a microscopic model in the weak coupling limit , where the role of the heat bath is played by the thermal radiation field , for details , see @xcite .
such master equations are a well established method for the description of open quantum systems , which has previously lead to substantial insights in the context of quantum heat engines , see for example @xcite . in terms of the super operators
@xmath76 , the control operations admit the formal representations @xmath77 = \overrightarrow{\mathcal{t}}e^{\int_0^{t_f}\!\!\ ! d\tau\;{\mathcal{l}}_+(\tau)}{\rho}\quad\text{and}\quad { \mathcal{v}}_-[{\rho } ] = e^{{\mathcal{l}}_- t_r}{\rho},\ ] ] where @xmath78 indicates time ordering . solving the equations and for a general initial condition yields the explicit expressions @xcite @xmath79 & = u{\rho}u^\dagger \quad\text{with}\quad\nonumber\\ u & = \cos\frac{\omega t_f}{2}\left ( e^{i\omega_0t_f/2}{|g\rangle}{\langleg| } + e^{-i\omega_0t_f/2}{|e\rangle}{\langlee|}\right)\nonumber\\ & \qquad -i\sin\frac{\omega t_f}{2}\left ( e^{i\left(\omega_0t_f/2-\phi\right)}l^\dagger + e^{-i\left(\omega_0t_f/2-\phi\right)}l\right ) \label{copp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xcite @xmath80 = e^{{\mathcal{l}}_- t_r}{\rho } & = \frac{1}{4}\left(1+e^{-{\gamma}t_r}+2e^{-{\gamma}t_r/2 } \cos\omega_0 t_r\right){\rho}\nonumber\\ & + \frac{1}{4}\left(1+e^{-{\gamma}t_r}-2e^{-{\gamma}t_r/2 } \cos\omega_0 t_r\right)l_0{\rho}l_0\nonumber\\ & -\frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{\gamma}{{\gamma}}(1-e^{-{\gamma}t_r } ) -2ie^{-{\gamma}t_r/2}\sin\omega_0 t_r\right){\rho}l_0\nonumber\\ & -\frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{\gamma}{{\gamma}}(1-e^{-{\gamma}t_r } ) + 2ie^{-{\gamma}t_r/2}\sin\omega_0 t_r\right)l_0{\rho}\nonumber\\ & + ( 1-e^{-{\gamma}t_r})\left(\frac{\gamma ( n+1)}{{\gamma}}l^\dagger{\rho}l + \frac{\gamma n}{{\gamma } } l{\rho}l^\dagger\right ) , \label{copm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we introduced the abbreviations @xmath81 and @xmath82 .
the work extracted within an operation cycle with measurement outcome @xmath61 can be determined form the first law @xmath83 - e[\tilde{{\rho}}_+ ] = e[{\rho}_+ ] - e[{\mathcal{v}}_+[{\rho}_+]],\ ] ] since the tls is decoupled from the environment and thus no heat is exchanged during the control operation @xmath84 .
inserting @xmath85 and into gives @xmath86 to keep the subsequent analysis as simple as possible , from here onwards , we fix the pulse duration @xmath58 and the dipole phase @xmath87 such that assumes the maximal value @xmath88 with respect to these parameters , i.e. , we put @xmath89 this choice ensures that the tls ends up in the ground state after the laser pulse , i.e. , @xmath90 .
furthermore , it leads to the fairly simple expressions @xmath91 & = \sin^2\frac{{\theta}}{2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath92 & = \frac{1}{2}\left(1-\frac{\cos { \theta}}{2n+1}-e^{-{\gamma}t_r/2}\sin^2{\theta}\cos\omega_0 t_r -e^{-{\gamma}t_r}\cos{\theta}\left[\cos { \theta}-\frac{1}{2n+1 } \right ] \right)\label{condprob}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the conditional probabilities defined in . since @xmath93 $ ] and @xmath94 $ ]
are determined by the sum rules , the steady state probabilities @xmath95 can now be obtained from the fixed point condition .
specifically , we find @xmath96}{1-p[+|+]+p[+|- ] } = 1-q_-.\ ] ] we are now ready to calculate the quantities entering the efficiency .
first , the average work per cycle reads @xmath97 since no contribution arises from operation cycles with measurement outcome @xmath62 .
second , the average energy spent on the measurement becomes @xmath98- e\big[{\mathcal{v}}_m[{\rho}_m]\big]\big)\nonumber\\ & = \langle w\rangle + q_-\frac{\hbar\omega_0}{2 } \left(1- e^{-{\gamma}t_r}\right)\left(\frac{1}{2n+1}-\cos{\theta}\right ) \label{etademeas}\end{aligned}\ ] ] upon using @xmath99 and the expressions and for the control operations .
third , since @xmath100 represents a pure state due to the control operation @xmath84 being unitary , the average entropy reduction in the system associated with the measurement arises only from cycles with initial state @xmath101 . after some algebra again using ,
we thus obtain @xmath102\ln{\mathcal{v}}[{\rho}_-]\right\ } } \nonumber\\ & = \frac{q_-}{2}{k_\mathrm{b}}\left(\ln d + \sqrt{1 - 4d}\ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1 - 4d } } { 1-\sqrt{1 - 4d}}\right)\right ) \qquad\text{with}\label{etadsmeas}\\ d&\equiv \frac{1}{4}\left(1- \left(e^{-{\gamma}t_r}\cos{\theta}-\frac{e^{-{\gamma}t_r}-1}{2n+1}\right)^2 - e^{-{\gamma}t_r}\sin^2{\theta}\right ) .
\label{etaddef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the expressions - , the efficiency @xmath103 of this quantum optical information engine can be evaluated for any complete set of parameters comprising the level spacing @xmath74 , the temperature of the heat bath @xmath3 , the angle @xmath104 , the damping rate @xmath105 and the relaxation time @xmath60 .
in this section , we focus on the question whether coherences , i.e. , a choice @xmath106 for the basis , in which the measurement is performed , can enhance the efficiency @xmath103 . in order to reduce the number of free parameters , we choose from now on the temperature such that @xmath107 leading to @xmath108 .
we then find by inspection that @xmath103 depends only on @xmath104 and the two dimensionless parameters @xmath109 and @xmath110 .
a numerical optimization procedure yields the maximal efficiency @xmath111 and optimal angle @xmath112 , which are both shown in upper panels of figure [ fig : eta_theta ] .
these plots exhibit two qualitatively different regimes separated by @xmath113 . and @xmath114 .
the upper panel shows the maximum efficiency @xmath115 on the left and the corresponding optimal angle @xmath116 on the right . along the dashed lines
, the condition is fulfilled .
the solid lines , which have a spacing of @xmath117 and constant offset @xmath118 , were introduced for graphical purposes . in the lower panel ,
the work output @xmath119 ( left ) and the average energy input required per measurement @xmath120 ( right ) is plotted in units of @xmath74.,scaledwidth=99.0% ] first , for @xmath121 , we recover the quasi - classical regime originally considered by lloyd @xcite , within which the tls can relax to thermal equilibrium in each operation cycle with measurement outcome @xmath62 . as argued in @xcite , the largest efficiency
can then be obtained for @xmath56 .
consistently , we observe that @xmath116 is effectively zero in this regime and , independent of @xmath110 , the optimal efficiency settles at the constant value @xmath122 second , in the coherent regime @xmath123 , we find a characteristic oscillatory pattern , which can be traced back to the structure of the conditional probability . the crucial role of this quantity , which is , in fact , the only ingredient of the efficiency depending on @xmath110 , can be explained by the following argument .
if the tls is found in the state @xmath57 after being in contact with the thermal environment for the time @xmath60 , the heat absorbed during this period together with the energy invested for the measurement can be converted into work by applying a laser pulse .
a measurement indicating the state @xmath59 , however , leads to another relaxation cycle , within which no work can be extracted and the previously gained information is inevitably wasted .
consequently , the efficiency , at which acquired information is converted into work , can be expected to increase as the frequency of such idle cycles decreases . for @xmath123 , the corresponding probability @xmath124 & = 1- p[+|-]\nonumber\\ & = \frac{1}{2}\left ( 1+\frac{\cos{\theta}}{3}+e^{-3{\gamma}t_r/2}\sin^2{\theta}\cos { \omega}_0 t_r+ e^{- 3{\gamma}t_r}\cos{\theta}\left[\cos{\theta}-\frac{1}{3 } \right]\right ) \label{condprobic}\end{aligned}\ ] ] can be substantially reduced by the contribution proportional to @xmath125 , which arises solely due to quantum coherences and vanishes for @xmath56 .
this effect becomes most pronounced for @xmath126 and @xmath127 accordingly , the hyperbolas are in good agreement with the local maxima of the efficiency @xmath115 in the @xmath128,@xmath129-plane and @xmath130 comes close to @xmath131 in their vicinity .
the deviations from this pattern for @xmath132 can be explained by the remaining terms in , which come with a prefactor @xmath133 and thus give a non - negligible contribution only in these regions .
most importantly , in this regime , we find as our second main result that the efficiency is enhanced by exploiting coherences .
specifically , it can overcome the quasi - classical value and even approach its upper bound @xmath134 in the limit @xmath135 . the average work output for the optimal angle @xmath116 , @xmath136 ,
is plotted in the lower panel of figure [ fig : eta_theta ] .
clearly , this quantity features the same characteristic dependence on @xmath137 and @xmath114 as the maximized efficiency @xmath115 . like @xmath115 ,
the average work @xmath138 exceeds its quasi - classical limit @xmath139 in the coherence - enhanced regime and becomes maximal in the same range of parameters like @xmath115 , i.e. , in the vicinity of the hyperbolas . finally , we consider the average energetic cost per measurement @xmath140 .
this additional input is inevitably necessary for the exploitation of quantum coherence and therefore becomes non - negligible whenever @xmath116 significantly deviates from @xmath141 , hence , in particular , in the regions of the parameter space , where our numerical procedure reveals @xmath115 to be large .
consequently , in the range of high efficiencies , the input of the device is mainly delivered by the measurement apparatus rather than the heat bath .
this result underlines the crucial role of the measurement process in the quantum realm , which , besides delivering information , can alter the state of the system and thus bears the character of an additional control operation .
in this paper , we have derived a universal upper bound on the average work output delivered in finite time by cyclically operating quantum information engines , which takes into account the energetic cost intrinsically associated with quantum measurements .
this bound provides a benchmark for the performance of quantum mechanical information - to - energy converters , which , in contrast to their classical counterparts , see for example @xcite , can exploit the superposition principle and thus might be able to overcome classical limitations .
we have explicitly investigated the benefit of quantum coherences in the second part of the paper by considering a specific model consisting of a quantum optical tls , which , conditioned on the outcome of a projective measurement , is repeatedly either coupled to a heat bath or used to amplify a coherent laser pulse . in the regime of long relaxation times , this setup corresponds to a model originally proposed by lloyd , whose properties are reproduced qualitatively in our analysis within this limit .
we emphasize , however , that the definition of efficiency used in @xcite is different from ours , since it explicitly refers to landauer s principle by invoking the minimal heat that must be dissipated in a second heat bath of different temperature to achieve the entropy production necessary to reset the memory of the external agent .
viewed in this way , the model acts effectively as a heat engine , whose efficiency is bounded by the carnot value . in our approach , we consider the system as an information engine and define its efficiency in terms of quantities directly associated with the system and the measurement process , leaving aside how the agent eventually erases the gathered information . in the coherent regime , which is characterized by short cycle times , we find that utilizing a non - classical observable @xmath52 , whose eigenstates are coherent superpositions of the energy eigenstates , can enhance the performance significantly . remarkably , it turns out that both , efficiency and average work output per cycle , can be substantially increased if the relaxation time is properly adjusted to the level spacing . since , in the corresponding regions of the parameter space , the optimal angle @xmath116 strongly deviates from the quasi - classical value @xmath141 and even comes close to @xmath131 , the device is then mainly supplied by the measurement apparatus rather than the heat bath . in fact , jacobs argued that , for thermodynamical consistency , this type of energy input must be considered as work rather than heat @xcite .
it should , however , also be clearly distinguished from the work output extracted by external control operations . further clarification of the role of the measurement process in this context , using e.g. a scheme proposed in @xcite , constitutes an important and challenging subject for future research .
10 f. dolde , i. jakobi , b. naydenov , n. zhao , s. pezzagna , c. trautmann , j. meijer , p. neumann , f. jelezko , and j. wrachtrup , `` room - temperature entanglement between single defect spins in diamond , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys2545[_nature phys . _ * 9 * ( 2013 ) 139143 ] .
g. waldherr , y. wang , s. zaiser , m. jamali , t. schulte - herbruggen , h. abe , t. ohshima , j. isoya , j. f. du , p. neumann , and j. wrachtrup , `` quantum error correction in a solid - state hybrid spin register , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature12919[_nature_ * 506 * ( 2014 ) 204207 ] .
d. g. england , g. fisher , kent a. j .-
w. maclean , p. j. bustard , r. lausten , k. j. resch , and b. j. sussman , `` storage and retrieval of thz - bandwidth single photons using a room - temperature diamond quantum memory , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.114.053602[_phys .
* 114 * ( 2015 ) 053602 ] .
s. deffner and c. jarzynski , `` information processing and the second law of thermodynamics : an inclusive , hamiltonian approach , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevx.3.041003[_phys .
x _ * 3 * ( 2013 ) 041003 ] .
a. c. barato and u. seifert , `` unifying three perspectives on information processing in stochastic thermodynamics , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.112.090601[_phys .
* 112 * ( 2014 ) 090601 ] .
s. toyabe , t. sagawa , m. ueda , e. muneyuki , and m. sano , `` experimental demonstration of information - to - energy conversion and validation of the generalized jarzynski equality , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys1821[_nature phys . _
* 6 * ( 2010 ) 988 ] .
a. brut , a. arakelyan , a. petrosyan , s. ciliberto , r. dillenschneider , and e. lutz , `` experimental verification of landauer s principle linking information and thermodynamics , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature10872[_nature_ * 483 * ( 2012 ) 187189 ] . m. o. scully , m. s. zubairy , g. s. agarwal , and h. walther , `` extracting work from a single heat bath via vanishing quantum coherence , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.1078955[_science_ * 299 * ( 2003 ) 862864 ] .
h. t. quan , y. d. wang , y .- x .
liu , c. p. sun , and f. nori , `` maxwell s demon assisted thermodynamic cycle in superconducting quantum circuits , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.97.180402[_phys . rev
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 180402 ] .
a. e. allahverdyan , r. s. johal , and g. mahler , `` work extremum principle : structure and function of quantum heat engines , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreve.77.041118[_phys .
* 77 * ( 2008 ) 041118 ] .
k. jacobs , `` quantum measurement and the first law of thermodynamics : the energy cost of measurement is the work value of the acquired information , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreve.86.040106[_phys .
* 86 * ( 2012 ) 040106 ] .
d. gelbwaser - klimovsky , n. erez , r. alicki , and g. kurizki , `` work extraction via quantum nondemolition measurements of qubits in cavities : non - markovian effects , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreva.88.022112[_phys .
a _ * 88 * ( 2013 ) 022112 ] . p. strasberg , g. schaller , t. brandes , and m. esposito , `` thermodynamics of quantum - jump - conditioned feedback control , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreve.88.062107[_phys .
* 88 * ( 2013 ) 062107 ] .
s. gasparinetti , p. solinas , a. braggio , and m. sassetti , `` heat - exchange statistics in driven open quantum systems , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1367-2630/16/11/115001[_new j. phys . _
* 16 * ( 2014 ) 115001 ] . s. an , j .- n .
zhang , m. um , d. lv , y. lu , j. zhang , z .- q .
yin , h. t. quan , and k. kim , `` experimental test of the quantum jarzynski equality with a trapped - ion system , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys3197[_nature phys . _
* 11 * ( 2015 ) 193199 ] .
o. abah , j. ronagel , g. jacob , s. deffner , f. schmidt - kaler , k. singer , and e. lutz , `` single - ion heat engine at maximum power , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.109.203006[_phys .
* 109 * ( 2012 ) 203006 ] .
j. ronagel , o. abah , f. schmidt - kaler , k. singer , and e. lutz , `` nanoscale heat engine beyond the carnot limit , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.112.030602[_phys .
lett . _ * 112 * ( 2014 ) 030602 ]
. h .- h .
hasegawa , j. ishikawa , k. takara , and d. driebe , `` generalization of the second law for a nonequilibrium initial state , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physleta.2009.12.042[_phys .
a _ * 374 * ( 2010 ) 1001 1004 ] . e. geva , r. kosloff , and j. l. skinner , `` on the relaxation of a two - level system driven by a strong electromagnetic field , '' http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.468844[_j .
* 102 * ( 1995 ) 85418561 ] .
h. nakazato , y. hida , k. yuasa , b. militello , a. napoli , and a. messina , `` solution of the lindblad equation in the kraus representation , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreva.74.062113[_phys . rev
. a _ * 74 * ( 2006 ) 062113 ] .
d. mandal and c. jarzynski , `` work and information processing in a solvable model of maxwell s demon , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1204263109[_proc .
_ * 109 * ( 2012 ) 1164111645 ] .
j. m. horowitz , t. sagawa , and j. m. r. parrondo , `` imitating chemical motors with optimal information motors , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.111.010602[_phys .
lett . _ * 111 * ( 2013 ) 010602 ] .
h. sandberg , j .- c .
delvenne , n. j. newton , and s. k. mitter , `` maximum work extraction and implementation costs for nonequilibrium maxwell s demons , '' http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physreve.90.042119[_phys .
* 90 * ( 2014 ) 042119 ] .
a. e. allahverdyan , r. balian , and t. m. nieuwenhuizen , `` understanding quantum measurement from the solution of dynamical models , '' http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2012.11.001 [ _ phys .
_ * 525 * ( 2013 ) 1 166 ] . | a genuine feature of projective quantum measurements is that they inevitably alter the mean energy of the observed system if the measured quantity does not commute with the hamiltonian .
compared to the classical case , jacobs proved that this additional energetic cost leads to a stronger bound on the work extractable after a single measurement from a system initially in thermal equilibrium [ phys .
rev . a 80 , 012322 ( 2009 ) ] . here
, we extend this bound to a large class of feedback - driven quantum engines operating periodically and in finite time .
the bound thus implies a natural definition for the efficiency of information to work conversion in such devices . for a simple model consisting of a laser - driven two - level system ,
we maximize the efficiency with respect to the observable whose measurement is used to control the feedback operations .
we find that the optimal observable typically does not commute with the hamiltonian and hence would not be available in a classical two level system .
this result reveals that periodic feedback engines operating in the quantum realm can exploit quantum coherences to enhance efficiency .
= 1 |
@xcite attributed the production of the isotopes heavier than the iron group to three processes of nucleosynthesis , the @xmath10- and @xmath11-processes of neutron addition , and the @xmath0-process of proton addition .
the conditions they specified for the @xmath0-process , proton densities @xmath13 g @xmath14 and temperatures @xmath15 k , were difficult to realize in nature and so other processes and sites were sought . @xcite and @xcite attributed the production of the @xmath0-process nuclei to photodisintegration , a series of ( @xmath16n ) , ( @xmath16p ) and ( @xmath17 ) reactions flowing downward through radioactive proton - rich progenitors from lead to iron .
their `` @xmath7-process '' operated upon previously existing @xmath11-process seed in the star to make the @xmath0-process , and was thus `` secondary '' in nature ( or even `` tertiary '' since the @xmath11-process itself is secondary ) .
it could only happen in a star made from the ashes of previous stars that had made the @xmath11-process .
arnould suggested hydrostatic oxygen burning in massive stars as the site where the necessary conditions were realized ; woosley and howard , who discovered the relevant nuclear flows independently , discussed explosive oxygen and neon burning in a type ii supernova as the likely site . over the years
, increasingly refined calculations showed that a portion of the @xmath0-nuclei could actually be produced as woosley and howard described ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
a nagging deficiency of @xmath0-process production in the mass range a = 92 - 124 still persisted though .
the production of @xmath1mo posed a particular problem since , unless the star had previously experienced a strong @xmath11-process , enhancing the abundance of seed above a = 95 , there simply was not enough seed . in massive stars
the @xmath11-process does not go above mass 90 and so the necessary seed enhancement does not occur .
@xcite found that large abundances of some @xmath0-nuclei , and @xmath18mo in particular , could be synthesized in the neutrino - powered wind blowing from a young neutron star ( see also * ? ? ? * ) . while this wind had chiefly been seen as a way of making the @xmath10-process @xcite , for electron mole numbers , @xmath19 , the @xmath0-nuclei @xmath20zn , @xmath21se , @xmath22kr , @xmath23sr , and @xmath18mo
were produced in great abundance .
it is important to note in this regard that , while @xmath24 is nominally neutron rich ( @xmath25 = 0.5 corresponds to neutron , proton equality ) , it is still a lot more proton - rich than the @xmath0-nuclei themselves ( z / n for @xmath18mo = 0.457 ) , so the nucleonic gas contained some free protons .
the @xmath0-nuclei here were also primary , in the sense that a star with no initial metallicity would still make the same composition in its neutrino wind .
there were potential problems , however , in that the ejection of only a small amount of mass with @xmath25 just a little lower than 0.485 resulted in disastrous overproduction of n = 50 nuclei like @xmath26sr , @xmath27y , and @xmath28zr .
also the neutron - rich wind failed to produce adequate amounts of p - process nuclei above a = 92 . though this paper focuses on early proton - rich outflows , the sn model we study
is calculated to eject a sizable amount of neutron - rich material .
it remains to be seen if very recent simulations predict neutron - rich outflows that satisfy the conditions needed for efficient synthesis of @xmath18mo , or if neutrino interactions facilitate production of @xmath29 in the neutron rich ejecta predicted by these models @xcite .
based upon calculations by jim wilson , @xcite pointed out that @xmath25 in the wind would naturally evolve though the points necessary to make these @xmath0-nuclei and would actually start with a value greater than 0.5 .
as other detailed models for core - collapse supernovae became available , nucleosynthesis was explored in this `` hot , proton - rich bubble '' by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
the latter two studies found substantial production of nuclei up to a = 84 , including some nuclei traditionally attributed to the @xmath0-process .
it seems probable that these winds have also contributed appreciably to the solar abundances of @xmath30sc , @xmath31ti and @xmath20zn , and , possibly in a measurable way , to other rare abundances in metal poor stars .
however , since these same nuclei were already made by other processes @xcite , there seemed to be no clear diagnostic of the proton - rich wind . here ,
following the suggestion of @xcite , we have revisited our calculations of the proton - rich wind including , in addition to the proton captures , the effect of a neutron flux created by p(@xmath5n .
these neutrons have the effect of bridging the long - lived isotopes along the path of the @xmath6-process by ( n , p ) reactions and accelerating the flow to heavier elements . for our standard assumptions regarding expansion rate and neutrino fluxes
@xcite , we find substantial production of @xmath0-process nuclei up to pd , whereas previously the heaviest major production was zn .
if the entropy of the expansion is artificially increased by a factor of 3 to account for extra energy deposition in the wind @xcite , magnetic confinement @xcite , or alfvn wave dissipation @xcite , the production of @xmath0-nuclei extends up to a = 170 .
interestingly , the relevant conditions , @xmath32 g @xmath14 and t = @xmath33 k resemble those originally proposed for the @xmath0-process by b@xmath34fh .
key differences , however , are that all the species produced here are primary and the process occurs on a shorter time scale - just a few seconds - owing to the `` effective '' acceleration of weak decays by ( n , p ) reactions .
our fiducial model for exploring nucleosynthesis in the proton - rich wind is the explosion of a 15@xmath35m@xmath36 star @xcite
. an earlier paper ( * ? ? ? * henceforth paper i ) studied nucleosynthesis in this same model but did not account for the influence of neutrino interactions .
the present study includes charged - current capture on free nucleons @xcite and neutral - current spallation of nucleons from alpha particles @xcite .
many other details of the supernova model and associated nuclear - network calculations relevant to this work can be found in paper i. the ejecta of the deepest layers of the supernova can be divided into two categories - hot bubble ejecta and winds .
material in the hot bubble originates from a region outside the neutron star that is driven convectively unstable by neutrino heating .
this material does not have to escape the deep gravitational well found at the neutron star surface . as a result
, modest conditions characterize these outflows : @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
winds originate from the surface of the neutron star and are pushed outwards along gentle pressure gradients caused by neutrino heating @xcite .
these outflows have relatively high entropies ( @xmath39 ) , high electron fractions ( @xmath25 as large as 0.57 ) , and short initial expansion timescales .
tables 2 & 3 in paper i provide a brief summary of initial conditions in different bubble and wind trajectories . in the absence of neutrinos ,
very little synthesis occurs in the early proton - rich outflows for nuclei heavier than a= 64 . compared to observed solar abundances , proton - rich winds that are not subject to a neutrino fluence are copious producers of @xmath30sc and @xmath40 .
bubble trajectories , on the other hand , tend to favor the synthesis of @xmath41 , @xmath42 and some co or ni isotopes .
the nuclear flow stops at @xmath20ge for two reasons : the long weak decay lifetime ( with respect to the expansion timescale of the neutrino winds ) of this and other even - z even - n waiting point nuclei and the small q values for proton capture on these nuclei .
the simulations of @xcite followed the explosion of the supernova in 2 dimensions until about 450 ms after core bounce . at this time
, typical temperatures in the bubble trajectories were around 4 billion degrees . at the end of the 2d simulation
the sn was mapped onto a 1d grid .
the subsequent evolution of the sn , including winds emitted by the neutron star , was followed until about 1300 ms after core bounce . at this last time typical asymptotic temperatures in the early wind were just over 2 billion degrees .
since most of the interesting nucleosynthesis occurs for @xmath43 , it is necessary to extrapolate outflow conditions to later times .
details of the extrapolation were described in paper i which considered two estimates . in the first , the expansion already calculated is assumed to continue homologously with no deceleration .
this gives a useful lower bound on the expansion timescale .
however , in reality the outflow will quickly catch up to the outgoing shock .
it is more reasonable then to assume that escaping matter enters a phase where it moves with the shock speed .
conditions for this can be estimated from 1d supernova simulations . for the present paper
we focus on the more realistic extrapolation that mimics the late time slowing of the wind .
the temperature and density evolution was extrapolated as in paper i. specifically , the trajectories found by @xcite were smoothly merged with those calculated for the inner zone of the same @xmath44 star by @xcite . to avoid discontinuities in the entropy at the time where the two calculations were matched the density in the previous 1d calculation
was changed to match that in the trajectories found by janka et al .
our procedure likely leads to an underestimate of the expansion timescale at late times because the explosion energy and shock velocity in the calculations of woosley & weaver were somewhat larger than in the more recent 2d simulations . in order to include the influence of the neutrinos from the cooling neutron star additional assumptions
are needed . for the neutrino temperatures and luminosities we used the same values calculated at approximately 1 second in the simulation of @xcite .
these values are shown in table [ nutable ] and are assumed to remain constant .
this may be a questionable assumption - neutrino spectra actually harden and their luminosities fall as the neutron star shrinks .
however , it is estimated that uncertainties in the extrapolation of trajectories to low temperatures are greater than uncertainties arising from our simple treatment of the neutrino spectral evolution . to obtain the integrated neutrino exposure seen by outflowing material ,
it is also necessary to make assumptions about the evolution of the radial velocity . in all cases
, it was assumed that the radial velocity at times greater than those followed in the simulations was constant at @xmath45 .
this is close to the velocity of the outgoing shock in the 2d calculation of this fairly low energy explosion .
again , there may be some inconsistency between our treatment of the late time expansion and our adopted asymptotic radial velocity .
a more sophisticated approach might scale the expansion time estimated from the calculations of woosley & weaver to reflect the relatively small shock velocity found in the 2d simulations .
it is shown in section [ modest ] that our calculations for nucleosynthesis are relatively insensitive to changes in the late - time outflow velocity .
figure [ allfig ] shows results of our calculations that include neutrino captures for production factors characterizing nucleosynthesis in proton - rich outflows leaving the early sn .
the production factor for an isotope @xmath46 is defined here as @xmath47 in this equation , the sum is over all trajectories , @xmath48 is the mass fraction of nuclide @xmath46 in the @xmath49th trajectory , @xmath50 is the mass fraction of nuclide @xmath46 in the sun @xcite , @xmath51 is the mass in the @xmath49th trajectory , and @xmath52 is the total mass ejected in the sn explosion .
the lower panel in figure [ allfig ] shows production factors characterizing nucleosynthesis in just the hot bubble .
this is comprised of the 40 trajectories described in table 1 of paper i. by comparing with table 5 from paper i we see that nucleosynthesis in the bubble material is not greatly changed when neutrino captures are included .
this is because the bubble material is far from the neutron star and experiences few neutrino captures relative to the number of seed nuclei in this low entropy environment .
the story is much different for the early wind shown in the middle panel of figure [ allfig ] .
this wind is comprised of the 6 trajectories defined in table 2 of paper i. in these outflows , neutrinos convert free protons into neutrons .
capture of these neutrons by ( n , p ) reactions on long - lived nuclei along the path of the @xmath6-process accelerate the progress to nuclei as heavy as pd .
final conditions for these wind trajectories are provided in table [ 5512570_final ] .
we defer a discussion of the nuclear flows and the potential for production of heavier elements to section [ broaderstudy ] . for comparison
, we also show , in figure [ allfignoneutrinos ] , the integrated results ( summed over the same six wind trajectories ) of calculations that do _ not _ include neutrino capture on protons .
apart from the neglect of neutrinos the trajectories studied here are identical to those described in the middle panel of figure [ allfig ] .
the differences are dramatic .
when neutrino captures are ignored nucleosynthesis stops some 40 mass units lower than when they are included .
the calculations in the previous section are quite uncertain owing to both an uncertainty in the supernova explosion model and to our procedure for extrapolating expansion after the explosion calculation has stopped .
modest alterations are reasonable to the asymptotic wind velocity , the electron fraction of the wind , and neutrino capture rates in the outflow .
more extreme changes that might reflect the influence of novel physical processes operating in the early wind are explored in section [ broaderstudy ] .
* influence of a larger asymptotic wind velocity + the supernova studied by janka et al . has a relatively low kinetic energy at infinity , 0.6@xmath53 erg .
more energetic explosions would give rise to shock velocities larger than the @xmath54 adopted here . to estimate nucleosynthesis in more energetic supernovae
, we show in the first column of table [ modesttable ] production factors for nuclei synthesized in a wind characterized by an asymptotic velocity of @xmath55 .
this is more typical of supernovae with late time kinetic energies near @xmath56 erg .
apart from the increase in asymptotic velocity all other properties of the 6 trajectories comprising the early wind were kept unchanged from those found by simulation . + by comparing with the middle panel of figure [ allfig ]
, one sees that changing the asymptotic outflow velocity has little effect on nucleosynthesis
. this may be partly an artifact of our definition of `` asymptotic '' as applying only to times after the last point given by the supernova simulation .
to test this we also ran simulations where the outflow velocity was set to @xmath55 once the temperature of the wind fell below 2.5 billion degrees . again
the differences were small .
* effect of 5@xmath57 changes to @xmath25 + uncertainty in the neutrino spectral evolution or the dynamics of the wind near the neutron star could affect @xmath25 in the wind .
the second and third columns of table [ modesttable ] show the influence of changing the electron fraction up or down by @xmath58 .
this change was applied to all 6 trajectories comprising the early wind .
other characteristics of these trajectories were left unchanged . + it is evident that relatively small changes to the electron fraction can have a big impact on nucleosynthesis . if @xmath25 is decreased by 5@xmath57 production of @xmath0-isotopes near mass 100 is lost and replaced by modest synthesis of some proton - rich kr and sr isotopes .
a 5@xmath57 increase in @xmath25 leads to large production of pd and cd isotopes .
the reason for the large impact of changing @xmath25 can be understood in terms of the number of protons available for capturing neutrinos .
the most proton - rich trajectory found by simulations had @xmath59 .
this corresponds to a mass fraction of free protons @xmath60 .
increasing @xmath25 by five percent corresponds to a 40 percent increase in @xmath61 .
* changes to the neutrino capture rates + the last two columns of table [ modesttable ] show the influence of halving and doubling the luminosity of electron neutrinos and anti - neutrinos .
such large changes to the luminosities are probably unlikely , but might reflect plausible uncertainties in the local neutrino capture rate experienced by the wind . for example , the wind material might first catch up with the outgoing shock at a larger radius than found by simulations .
our neglect of the temporal evolution and finer spectral details of the neutrinos might also result in modest changes to the capture rates .
+ from table [ modesttable ] it is seen that halving or doubling the charged current neutrino captures rates is roughly equivalent to decreasing or increasing @xmath25 by 5@xmath57 .
galactic chemical evolution studies indicate that production factors in the whole star for isotopes exclusively produced in core - collapse supernovae must be of order 10 @xcite . as noted before @xcite
, this implies that the current simulations predict a hot bubble ejecta that could explain the origin of @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
implications for the early wind are more interesting . without any tuning or rescaling of wind conditions , the simulations of @xcite
predict a wind that efficiently synthesizes several interesting @xmath0-nuclei - including the elusive isotopes @xmath62 and @xmath63 - in near solar relative proportions .
overall these predict about 5 - 10 times too much yield of the most proton - rich stable ru and pd isotopes . in the previous section
it was shown that small and plausible changes to the electron fraction can alleviate this overproduction .
in this section we consider nucleosynthesis in outflows for which neutrino , proton , and neutron - induced reactions on heavy seed can produce still heavier nuclei .
this may occur because the proton to seed ratio is higher - as happens if the entropy is higher - or the production of neutrons by p(@xmath64n is greater .
reasons why the entropy might be higher are discussed in the conclusions .
qualitatively , the nucleosynthesis we are describing occurs in three , or possibly four stages .
first , in the outgoing wind , all neutrons combine with protons leaving an excess of unbound protons - much like in the big bang .
as this combination of alphas and protons cools below @xmath65 k , a small fraction of the alphas recombine to produce nuclei in and slightly above the iron group - @xmath66ni , @xmath67zn , and @xmath20ge . flow beyond @xmath20ge
is inhibited however by strong reverse flows , especially ( p,@xmath4 ) reactions .
the second stage occurs as the temperature declines below @xmath68 k. a combination of ( p,@xmath69 and ( n , p ) reactions carries the flow , still close to the z = n line , to heavier nuclei . for a@xmath7092
the flow in the present calculations passes through the even - even n = z nuclei .
after @xmath71 ( @xmath26ru ) the character of the flow changes .
effective synthesis of the next even - even nucleus ( @xmath18pd ) is prevented in part by the small proton separation energy of @xmath72rh - the proton capture parent of @xmath18pd .
as in the analogous @xmath10-process , just how far the flow goes in a particular trajectory depends on the proton - to - seed ratio and especially on the number of neutrons per seed produced by p(@xmath64n . all interesting nuclei in this stage
are made as proton - rich progenitors .
the third stage occurs as the temperature drops below @xmath73 k and charged - particle reactions freeze out .
neutrons are still being produced by p(@xmath64n , however , albeit at a reduced rate ( both because the neutrino luminosity declines and the distance to the neutron star is getting greater ) .
( n , p ) reactions now drive material towards the valley of beta stability . because the nuclei involved are unstable to positron decay anyway , this only accelerates the inevitable .
the atomic mass , a , does not change
. it should be noted , however , that just as the @xmath10-process can contribute to nuclei made by the @xmath11-process that are unshielded against @xmath74 decay of more neutron - rich isobars , so too can the @xmath75 process considered here contribute to @xmath11-nuclei that are unshielded on the proton - rich side .
that is , in addition to nuclei that are designated as `` @xmath76 '' , there may also be nuclei one should consider as `` @xmath77 '' .
the fourth stage only occurs in the most extreme situation where the number of neutrons produced by neutrinos is quite large compared with the number of seed nuclei .
then ( n , p ) reactions not only carry the flow at low temperature back to the valley of beta stability , but ( n,@xmath7 ) reactions carry it beyond - _ to the neutron rich side of the periodic chart _ , even in the presence of a large abundance of free protons .
this is a novel version of the @xmath10-process that actually works best when the _ proton _ abundance is large but the temperature too low for proton addition .
the protons are just a source of neutrons .
the most interesting part of the nucleosynthesis occurs during the later stages of the outflow as the material cools . in the absence of an important neutrino flux
the final isotopic yields are determined by an interplay between @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 processes as well as details of how these reactions fall out of equilibrium .
when neutrino capture on free protons is important , nuclei are pushed to higher isospin and mass via @xmath82 and ( n,@xmath7 ) reactions . as a first approximation neutrinos will be important if they create an appreciable number of neutrons per heavy nucleus .
the ratio of created free neutrons to heavy nuclei is @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the mass fraction of elements heavier than @xmath4 particles and @xmath85 is an effective average atomic number . in eq .
[ yneq ] @xmath86 is the net number of neutrinos captured per free proton at temperatures smaller than about @xmath87k . here
@xmath88 is the rate at which each free proton captures @xmath89 s @xcite . in eq .
[ lambdanu ] @xmath90 is the luminosity of electron anti - neutrinos , @xmath91 is an effective temperature for these neutrinos and @xmath10 is the radius of the material from the neutrino sphere . to estimate the relation between @xmath78 and nucleosynthesis consider a mass element of unit volume co - moving with the wind .
the number of free protons in this mass element is @xmath92 these free protons are destroyed by anti - neutrino capture at a rate @xmath93 neutrons created when anti - neutrinos capture onto protons are subsequently absorbed by nuclei .
the evolution of the free neutron abundance is then set by a competition between neutrino and nuclear processes @xmath94 here the sum is over all isotopes @xmath46 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 represent the atomic number and rate at which species @xmath46 absorbs free neutrons . as a matter of convention @xmath96 here represents the rate at which a single atom of species @xmath46 absorbs neutrons when the free neutron density is one mol per unit volume . if we introduce an average neutron absorption rate @xmath97 the destruction rate appearing on the right hand side of eq .
[ xndot ] can be written @xmath98 neutrons are principally absorbed in ( n , p ) and @xmath99 reactions , with @xmath100 reactions playing a smaller role ( due to the larger coulomb barrier in the exit channel ) .
table [ reprates ] shows rates for a sample of nuclei found in proton - rich outflows . at 2 billion degrees typical values of @xmath96 for even - even proton - drip line nuclei ( those bordering the line separating the proton - bound nuclei from the proton - unbound nuclei ) with mass near a@xmath10172 are around @xmath102 .
this implies a very rapid neutron destruction rate .
for example , at a typical density of @xmath103 g @xmath14 and a mass fraction of heavy nuclei equal to @xmath104 , a neutron is absorbed in less than a microsecond . since this is much shorter than the material expansion rate it is fair to treat the neutron abundance as being in equilibrium @xmath105 an estimate for the abundance of free neutrons
also gives an estimate for the destruction rate of an atom of species @xmath46 : @xmath106 here we have defined an effective destruction rate that reflects the competition between different nuclear species for scarce neutrons @xmath107 which is enormous .
this equation says for plausible outflow conditions a given species can be entirely destroyed by neutrino - produced neutrons in times as short as @xmath108 ms .
it also implies a very small equilibrium neutron abundance : @xmath109 for @xmath110 g @xmath14 .
one of the most interesting questions relates to how high in mass the nucleosynthesis will proceed . for the purpose of making first estimates
we can suppose the starting inventory of nuclei to be concentrated near mass 60 .
we will also suppose that @xmath96 is independent of species for nuclei with @xmath111 . in this case
the number of neutrons captured by a heavy nucleus is just @xmath78 . a more careful treatment of @xmath96 is not presented since results from detailed network - based calculations are given in the next section . with the above assumptions the mass fraction of species @xmath49 is @xmath112 here we have defined a species to include all nuclei of a given isotone . depending on just how fast the effective absorption rates @xmath113 are one might or might not suppose that decay of nuclei with odd - n is dominated by weak processes .
this is because odd - n drip - line nuclei can have rather fast @xmath81 rates ( see table [ reprates ] ) .
when the neutron absorption rates are slower than these weak rates one would take @xmath114 in the above equation .
though eq .
[ howhigh ] is crude it can be used as a rough guide to gauge the influence of free neutrons created from neutrino captures . as an example , suppose one neutron is created per heavy nucleus ( @xmath115 ) . in this case eq .
[ howhigh ] suggests that the relative mass fraction of nuclei that have captured a single neutron is about @xmath116 , while the relative mass fraction of nuclei that have captured 4 neutrons is about 20 times smaller .
if we use a factor of ten decrease in mass fraction as a rough cutoff , this implies that an appreciable abundance of nuclei with mass up to a@xmath117 will be synthesized .
here we have supposed that a unit increase in neutron number is accompanied by a unit increase in proton number .
neutron capture on odd - n proton - drip line nuclei has been neglected since the @xmath81 rates of these nuclei are much faster than the assumed neutron capture rate of @xmath118sec .
as another example , suppose that @xmath119 . in this case
the relative mass fraction of nuclei that have captured 5 neutrons is about 20/@xmath120 , while the relative mass fraction of nuclei that have captured 11 neutrons is about 20 times smaller .
this suggests appreciable synthesis of nuclei up to mass @xmath121 .
here we have again assumed that the change in atomic number is twice the change in neutron number and that weak processes alone destroy odd - n nuclei .
these assumptions probably lead to an overestimate for the increase in @xmath122 in this case because a neutron capture rate of @xmath123sec is comparable to the weak rates of many proton drip - line nuclei .
the above considerations suggest a first constraint on conditions synthesizing @xmath0-nuclei with mass near 130 @xmath124 a second constraint comes from considering the evolution of the outflow at low temperatures .
as @xmath125 falls below about 1.5@xmath126k charged - particle capture rates begin to freeze out .
neutrons , on the other hand , are still rapidly absorbed .
these neutron captures push the flow toward stability and away from progenitors of @xmath0-nuclei .
if low - temperature neutrino - induced neutron production is significant , even the very neutron - rich @xmath10-process nuclei are synthesized .
minimal destruction of @xmath0-nuclei implies a second constraint @xmath127 conversely , efficient synthesis of @xmath10-process isotopes in these proton - rich outflows requires the production of several neutrons per heavy nucleus at low temperatures .
outflows characterized by the production of many free neutrons per heavy nucleus ( large @xmath78 ) can be realized in different ways .
for example , the timescale characterizing the expansion of the outflow around the time that @xmath4-particles are synthesized might be small , the flow might be held close to the neutron star for an extended period , or @xmath25 might be very large . for simplicity
we consider implications of changing the entropy of the outflow .
apart from the influence of neutrino captures occurring at low temperature , the precise mechanism by which @xmath78 is increased is not so important for nucleosynthesis .
changes to the entropy of the hot bubble are not considered .
neutrino capture is not very pronounced in this portion of the outflow .
as well , the hot bubble material does not begin close to the neutron star , so it is hard to see how an appreciable increase in the entropy of this material could be achieved .
figure [ 2sfig ] shows the influence of doubling the entropy in the early wind . like the middle panel of figure [ allfig ] ,
this figure gives integrated production factors for a wind comprised of six trajectories .
each of these trajectories has twice the entropy , but is otherwise identical to , a counterpart trajectory from the simulation . for definiteness
the increase in entropy was assumed to influence only the density evolution .
the evolution of temperature with time was assumed to be the same as that found from simulation .
to a fair approximation doubling or tripling of the entropy corresponds to dividing the density by a factor of two or three .
doubling the entropy in the early wind results in values of @xmath78 ranging from about 0.6 to 10 .
the increased number of neutron captures results in efficient synthesis of nuclei as heavy as mass 125 .
by contrast , for all of the unmodified wind trajectories @xmath78 is less than about 3 and efficient synthesis stops around ru .
figure [ 3sfig ] shows the influence of tripling the entropy in the early wind .
again - this shows integrated production factors for six trajectories that each have larger entropy , but that are otherwise identical to , unaltered trajectories described by the middle panel of figure [ allfig ] .
these modified high entropy wind trajectories have values of @xmath78 ranging from about 1 to 22 .
this results in efficient synthesis of nuclei as heavy as mass 170 .
in other words , increasing the number of neutrons captured per heavy nucleus by 10 pushes the flow some 40 units higher in mass .
though outflows predicted by simulations have values of @xmath78 that are too small to allow synthesis of @xmath128 @xmath0-nuclei , they naturally satisfy the constraint ( eq . [ con2 ] ) on the relative number of neutrino captures occurring while the wind material is so cold that charged particle captures have frozen out .
figure [ ev1 ] shows the evolution of @xmath129 as a function of temperature for the wind outflow characterized by @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
it is seen that the fraction of neutrino captures occurring at low temperatures smaller than 1.5 billion degrees is quite small , less than about @xmath58 . to illustrate
the influence of neutrino captures occurring while the outflow is cold enough that charged particle reactions have frozen out we modified the entropy doubled version of trajectory 6 ( table [ 5512570_final ] ) to be held close to the neutron star at temperatures less than 1.5 billion degrees . a relatively modest modification in the outflow results in the capture of about 5 neutrons per heavy nucleus at temperatures lower than @xmath132k .
the first four columns of table [ slowcompare ] shows a comparison between nucleosynthesis in this slow outflow and nucleosynthesis in an outflow with the nominal radial velocity of @xmath133 .
since the only difference between these two trajectories is the evolution of radius with time at low temperatures , all differences in nucleosynthesis arise from late - time neutron production .
it is seen that a couple of neutrons produced at the wrong time can be detrimental to the synthesis of some @xmath0-process isotopes .
we also show in table [ slowcompare ] the influence of a great number of neutrons produced at low temperatures . again ,
this was studied by modifying just the radial profile at temperatures less than 1.5 billion degrees of the entropy doubled version of trajectory 6 .
the last two columns of the table show nucleosynthesis in this trajectory in which about 20 free neutrons are created per heavy nucleus at low temperatures .
most of the isotopes shown are @xmath10-process isotopes .
it is perhaps remarkable that the 2nd and possibly 3rd @xmath10-process peak elements can be synthesized in these proton - rich environments .
it may be difficult , however , to have ejecta that are both cold enough and close enough to the neutron star to experience the necessary neutrino irradiation . in all trajectories studies , regardless of initial electron fraction or entropy ,
nucleosynthesis begins with @xmath134c produced early on by the reaction sequence @xmath4(@xmath4n,@xmath7)@xmath135be(@xmath4,n)@xmath134c . by the time t@xmath136 the iron group has already been assembled .
strong @xmath137 and pairs of ( p,@xmath7 ) and ( @xmath4,p ) reactions continue to populate the even - z even - n @xmath4-nuclei up to @xmath66ni and @xmath67zn .
the flow mostly travels along the z = n line and does not stray more than two neutrons from it for any element up to zinc .
this continues until the charged - particle reactions freeze out ( t@xmath138 ) .
characteristics of the nucleosynthesis at lower temperatures depends sensitively on the influence of neutrino captures .
to illustrate the influence of p(@xmath139n reactions we begin with a discussion of nucleosynthesis in trajectory 6 , which is characterized by the weak production of a few neutrons per heavy nucleus .
important nuclear flows occurring when material in this trajectory has a temperature @xmath140k are shown in figure [ j570_s1_psp_zn2sn ] .
it is seen that the dominant flows ( red arrows ) are due to proton - capture ( p,@xmath7 ) reactions .
these can proceed until a proton unbound ( denoted by a white square ) or small ( blue ) @xmath141 energy is encountered .
unlike the @xmath6-process , here we have a neutron abundance and though small it allows ( n , p ) or @xmath81 reactions to populate the next lowest isobar .
the ( p,@xmath7 ) flow is governed by the separation energies . the end result for this trajectory is the production of the light @xmath0-process nuclei from kr to pd . the ( n , p ) reactions can continue to carry the flow even at low temperatures because such reactions on targets a few neutrons to the proton side of stability typically have positive q - values ( i.e. no thresholds ) .
the flow to heavier nuclei eventually stops when the charged particle reactions freeze out ( t@xmath142 ) and at late times ( once the waiting points are passed ) when ( n , p ) and ( n,@xmath7 ) reactions or weak decay direct the flows toward stability .
an interesting although unfortunate occurrence is the low ( relative to ru and pd ) production of the most abundant @xmath0-nucleus in nature , @xmath18mo . as the proton capture flow moves up the n=46 isotones ( see figure [ j570_s1_psp_zn2sn ] ) it is stopped in part because @xmath72rh has a small proton separation energy .
this prevents efficient population of @xmath143 ( z = n=46 ) and so breaks the pattern of synthesizing the even - even n = z nuclei . as a consequence the flow detours towards stability until reaching n=47 and n=48 .
the result is that the radioactive progenitor for @xmath18mo is now the odd - odd nucleus @xmath18rh .
the flow moves very quickly through this nucleus ( as well as through @xmath18ru ) , and little is left for decay at the end of this trajectory .
it is notable that the heavier @xmath0-nuclei , @xmath2ru and @xmath8pd , are co - produced in amounts that might explain their solar abundances .
their radioactive progenitors are associated with nuclei in the two nearby closed shells .
heavier @xmath144 nuclei ( @xmath8cd etc . ) are not made here because the flow failed to populate isotopes in the z=50 proton shell .
@xmath18mo is the only one of these intermediate @xmath0-nuclei that ( for now ) appears to have an odd - z progenitor .
we note however that the flow goes through regions where the possible error on @xmath141 is potentially large ( indicated by the t , meaning the value of @xmath141 was from an extrapolation from measured values ) .
more accurate measurements here would be most welcome , and would have significant impact on our understanding of @xmath0-process nuclei and their solar abundances since this material is ejected ( unlike the case in x - ray bursts ) . as an example , the uncertainty in the proton separation energy of @xmath145 is about 600 kev . a plausible 1 mev increase in this separation energy results in a 50@xmath57 increase in the yield of @xmath18mo in trajectory 6 .
figure [ j570_s2_tc2xe ] shows nucleosynthesis in a trajectory characterized by the production of many free neutrons per heavy nucleus .
this trajectory has an initial electron fraction @xmath59 and entropy @xmath146 .
it was constructed by doubling the entropy in the 2-d simulation of trajectory 6 ( table [ 5512570_final ] ) . for this modified outflow @xmath147 .
when material in this modified trajectory reaches a temperature of about t@xmath148 , ( p,@xmath7 ) reactions on @xmath149sn ( with @xmath150 mev ) pierce the z=50 closed proton shell . at the time
shown in figure [ j570_s2_tc2xe ] ( 2.21 sec , t@xmath151 ) , the charged particle reactions have frozen out , but the flow has entered an area where weak decay has yet to dominate . instead , ( n , p ) and ( n,@xmath7 ) reactions carry the flow rapidly toward stability .
the @xmath0-nuclei of ru , pd , and cd are all made as radioactive progenitors in the closed neutron ( ru ) and proton ( pd & cd ) shells .
we are in a very novel regime , where one can synthesize @xmath0-nuclei ( like @xmath152sn and @xmath9te ) via neutron capture reactions .
current supernova simulations , without modification , provide the necessary conditions required to explain the origin of a number of @xmath0-process isotopes between a = 92 and 126 whose origin in nature has always been unclear .
the site is the proton - rich bubble that powers the explosion and the early neutrino - powered wind that develops right behind it .
the synthesis is primary , so a neutron star derived from a metal poor progenitor star would produce the same yields ( so long as the neutron star itself had the same properties ) .
very metal deficient stars formed from these ejecta would be characterized by a excess of both @xmath0-process nuclei and @xmath10-process nuclei compared to the @xmath11-process , but since there is no element that is dominantly @xmath0-process , observational diagnostics may be difficult . in particular , large quantities of @xmath62 and @xmath153pd
are produced in our calculations ( fig .
[ allfig ] ) .
synthesis of @xmath0-process isotopes as heavy as @xmath154 can also be achieved by only factor - of - two modifications to the entropy of the baseline simulation .
it is interesting in this regard to note that an even larger increase in entropy is needed later in the _
neutron_-rich wind for the efficient synthesis of the @xmath10-process isotopes ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
this is quite possibly informing us of some additional heating mechanism that operates in the mass outflow during the first few seconds of a neutron star s life .
possible mechanisms are magnetic field entrainment of the outflowing matter @xcite , magnetic energy dissipation @xcite , acoustic energy input @xcite , or alfvn wave dampening @xcite
. none of these were included in the present supernova model , but we varied the entropy to determine qualitatively their effect . in the more extreme , but still physically reasonable case
that the entropy is multiplied by three , the synthesis extends all the way to @xmath155yb , with the accompanying production of many isotopes normally attributed to the @xmath11-process and even the @xmath10-process .
somewhat disappointingly , none of our calculations produce a large overabundance of @xmath18mo compared to surrounding isotopes ( though some do make 10% of the necessary value ) .
this may reflect either the fact that @xmath18mo has another origin , e.g. , the same neutrino - powered wind a few seconds later when @xmath25 = 0.485 , or uncertainties in the nuclear physics . in the current study , the @xmath18mo that is made
is produced as the odd - odd progenitor @xmath18rh .
this does not take advantage of the extra stability that would be afforded by an even - even nucleus like @xmath18pd , let alone the magic neutron shell of @xmath18mo itself .
indeed the binding energies and lifetimes of nuclei in the vicinity of @xmath18pd are quite uncertain .
an important aspect of the synthesis calculated here is that none of the @xmath0-nuclei are made as themselves ; all have proton - rich progenitors .
many of these progenitors are so unstable that even their masses and lifetimes are not measured , let alone their cross sections for interacting with neutrons and protons .
a similar situation is encountered in the @xmath6-process in type i x - ray bursts ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , a critical difference being that the isotopes made here are actually ejected and contribute to the solar inventory of heavy elements .
the study of these is a major goal for nuclear astrophysics experiments of the future , like the rare isotope accelerator ( http://www.anl.gov/ria/index.html ) . for
now , we can only note that these nuclear uncertainties are almost certainly responsible for a large fraction of the spread in production factors in , e.g. figs .
[ allfig ] and [ 2sfig ] .
this study has explored only a relatively limited set of outflow parameter space based upon simple modifications to trajectories found in one particular simulation .
further studies will surely be carried out by us and others , but we have identified a key physical parameter , @xmath78 ( eq .
2 ) , which characterizes the solution for various combinations of time scale , @xmath25 , and entropy .
@xmath78 is essentially a dimensionless measure of the number of neutrons produced by neutrino capture on protons compared to the number of heavy seed nuclei .
surveys on a finer grid of @xmath78 than were used here will be interesting .
this work was performed under the auspices of the u.s .
department of energy by the university of california lawrence livermore national laboratory under contract w-7405-eng-48 .
it was also supported , in part , by the scidac program of the us department of energy ( dc - fc02 - 01er41176 ) , the national science foundation ( ast 02 - 06111 ) , and nasa ( nag5 - 12036 ) and , in germany , by the research center for astroparticle physics ( sfb 375 ) and the transregional collaborative research center for gravitational wave astronomy ( sfb - transregio 7 ) . and density @xmath156 . the net nuclear flow ( in units of sec@xmath157 )
is defined as the product of abundance , density , and reaction rate in the forward ( charge or mass increasing ) direction minus a similar quantity for the inverse reaction .
strong and electromagnetic flows begin at the center of a target nucleus and end as an arrow in the product nucleus . any flow that starts off - center represents weak decay .
net nuclear flows are plotted in three strengths : red ( strong ) , green ( intermediate ) and blue ( weak ) , with values that are between a factor of 1.0 to 0.1 , 0.1 to 0.02 , and 0.02 to 0.01 of the value of the largest flow in the figure , respectively .
the largest flow here is @xmath158zn(p,@xmath7)@xmath159ga ( @xmath160 sec@xmath157 ) .
stable species are represented by a filled black square in the upper left corner .
each nucleus is color coded according to the legend by the value of its proton separation energy .
proton unbound nuclei are colored white .
nuclei with @xmath161 mev are colored gray .
a `` t '' is plotted in the upper right - hand corner for nuclei whose binding energy was extrapolated from measured masses @xcite .
production factors at the time shown are given in the inset ( the stable isotopes depicted include the abundances of all radioactive progenitors that will eventually decay to them ) .
as discussed in the text the classical @xmath162process waiting points ( @xmath20ge , @xmath163se , @xmath164kr , and @xmath165sr ) are bypassed by ( n , p ) reactions .
[ j570_s1_psp_zn2sn ] ] . at the time shown here
t@xmath151 , @xmath166 , and @xmath167 . the reactant mass fractions are x(p)=0.122 , x(n)=@xmath168 , and x(@xmath4)=0.865 .
the largest abundance is x(@xmath169sn)@xmath170 , the largest flow depicted is @xmath171sn(n,@xmath7)@xmath149sn ( @xmath172 sec@xmath157 ) .
the charged particle reactions have frozen out , leaving ( n , p ) and ( n,@xmath7 ) reactions to carry the flow rapidly towards stability ( before the onset of weak decay ) .
this allows @xmath144nuclei like @xmath152sn and @xmath9te to be made as themselves via neutron capture reactions .
[ j570_s2_tc2xe ] ] ccccccccc 1 & 0.539 & 54.8 & 0.078 & 0.614 & 0.307 & 0.244 & 80 & 0.2 + 2 & 0.548 & 58.0 & 0.095 & 0.714 & 0.190 & 0.135 & 71 & 0.4 + 3 & 0.551 & 76.7 & 0.101 & 0.822 & 0.075 & 0.043 & 57 & 1.7 + 4 & 0.551 & 71.0 & 0.102 & 0.796 & 0.101 & 0.063 & 62 & 1.1 + 5 & 0.556 & 74.9 & 0.113 & 0.831 & 0.054 & 0.025 & 46 & 2.9 + 6 & 0.558 & 76.9 & 0.115 & 0.840 & 0.043 & 0.014 & 33 & 3.2 + cccccccccc @xmath174ru & 2.09 & @xmath23sr & 1.22 & @xmath8pd & 3.14 & @xmath23sr & 1.25 & @xmath8pd & 3.07 + @xmath8pd & 2.06 & @xmath175kr & 0.93 & @xmath153cd & 2.72 & @xmath175kr & 0.91 & @xmath176ru & 2.90 + @xmath176ru & 1.86 & @xmath22kr & 0.92 & @xmath176ru & 2.69 & @xmath176ru & 0.82 & @xmath153cd & 2.71 + @xmath23sr & 1.72 & @xmath31ti & 0.74 & @xmath174ru & 2.65 & @xmath174ru & 0.71 & @xmath174ru & 2.66 + @xmath177mo & 1.36 & @xmath165se & 0.69 & @xmath169cd & 2.10 & @xmath22kr & 0.65 & @xmath169cd & 2.14 + @xmath175kr & 1.20 & @xmath176ru & 0.56 & @xmath178pd & 1.98 & @xmath31ti & 0.59 & @xmath23sr & 1.94 + @xmath179mo & 0.99 & @xmath21se & 0.39 & @xmath23sr & 1.79 & @xmath165se & 0.56 & @xmath178pd & 1.92 + @xmath180nb & 0.89 & @xmath20zn & 0.34 & @xmath181ru & 1.76 & @xmath177mo & 0.55 & @xmath177mo & 1.86 + @xmath153cd & 0.87 & @xmath177mo & 0.30 & @xmath177mo & 1.70 & @xmath8pd & 0.39 & @xmath181ru & 1.82 + @xmath182ru & 0.83 & @xmath164ge & 0.23 & @xmath182ru & 1.61 & @xmath20zn & 0.26 & @xmath183ru & 1.77 + cccc @xmath184 & 6.4@xmath185 & 4.5@xmath186 & 0.01 + @xmath187 & 7.7@xmath185 & 9.6@xmath186 & 7.24 + @xmath188 & 7.6@xmath185 & 1.1@xmath189 & 0.02 + @xmath190 & 1.0@xmath191 & 2.0@xmath189 & 8.67 + @xmath192 & 1.6@xmath191 & 4.5@xmath189 & 0.18 + @xmath193 & 3.3@xmath194 & 1.7@xmath195 & 0 .
+ ccccccc @xmath169cd & 7.33 & @xmath196sn & 7.20 & @xmath197sn & 6.45 + @xmath153cd & 6.99 & @xmath198 in & 7.08 & @xmath199sn & 6.22 + @xmath9te & 6.87 & @xmath152sn & 7.00 & @xmath200cd & 6.13 + @xmath198 in & 6.82 & @xmath169cd & 6.87 & @xmath149pd & 6.01 + @xmath152sn & 6.75 & @xmath201sn & 6.85 & @xmath202sb & 6.01 + @xmath8pd & 6.50 & @xmath9te & 6.55 & @xmath203pd & 5.89 + @xmath201sn & 6.48 & @xmath8pd & 6.43 & @xmath204rh & 5.87 + @xmath199xe & 6.41 & @xmath153cd & 6.34 & @xmath178ru & 5.80 + @xmath196sn & 6.37 & @xmath174ru & 6.25 & @xmath205cd & 5.76 + @xmath149cd & 6.31 & @xmath206xe & 6.00 & @xmath207sb & 5.71 | one of the outstanding unsolved riddles of nuclear astrophysics is the origin of the so called `` p - process '' nuclei from a = 92 to 126 .
both the lighter and heavier @xmath0-process nuclei are adequately produced in the neon and oxygen shells of ordinary type ii supernovae , but the origin of these intermediate isotopes , especially @xmath1mo and @xmath2ru , has long been mysterious . here
we explore the production of these nuclei in the neutrino - driven wind from a young neutron star .
we consider such early times that the wind still contains a proton excess because the rates for @xmath3 and positron captures on neutrons are faster than those for the inverse captures on protons .
following a suggestion by @xcite , we also include the possibility that , in addition to the protons , @xmath4-particles , and heavy seed , a small flux of neutrons is maintained by the reaction p(@xmath5n .
this flux of neutrons is critical in bridging the long waiting points along the path of the @xmath6-process by ( n , p ) and ( n,@xmath7 ) reactions . using the unmodified ejecta histories from a recent two - dimensional supernova model by @xcite , we find synthesis of @xmath0-rich nuclei up to @xmath8pd . however , if the entropy of these ejecta is increased by a factor of two , the synthesis extends to @xmath9te
. still larger increases in entropy , that might reflect the role of magnetic fields or vibrational energy input neglected in the hydrodynamical model , result in the production of numerous @xmath10- , @xmath11- , and @xmath0-process nuclei up to a @xmath12 170 , even in winds that are proton - rich . |
the study of processor shared queues has received much attention over the past 45 or so years .
the processor sharing ( ps ) discipline has the advantage over , say , first - in first - out ( fifo ) , in that shorter jobs tend to get through the system more rapidly .
ps models were introduced during the 1960 s by kleinrock ( see @xcite , @xcite ) . in recent years
there has been renewed attention paid to such models , due to their applicability to the flow - level performance of bandwidth - sharing protocols in packet - switched communication networks ( see @xcite-@xcite ) .
perhaps the simplest example of such a model is the @xmath1-ps queue . here
customers arrive according to a poisson process with rate parameter @xmath2 , the server works at rate @xmath3 , there is no queue , and if there are @xmath4 customers in the system each gets an equal fraction @xmath5 of the server .
ps and fifo models differ significantly if we consider the `` sojourn time '' .
this is defined as the time it takes for a given customer , called a `` tagged customer '' , to get through the system ( after having obtained the required amount of service ) .
the sojourn time is a random variable that we denote by @xmath6 . for the simplest @xmath1 model ,
the distribution of @xmath6 depends on the total service time @xmath7 that the customer requests and also on the number of other customers present when the tagged customer enters the system .
one natural variant of the @xmath1-ps model is the finite population model , which puts an upper bound on the number of customers that can be served by the processor .
the model assumes that there are a total of @xmath8 customers , and each customer will enter service in the next @xmath9 time units with probability @xmath10 . at any time there are @xmath11 customers being served and the remaining @xmath12 customers are in the general population .
hence the total arrival rate is @xmath13 $ ] and we may view the model as a ps queue with a state - dependent arrival rate that decreases linearly to zero . once a customer finishes service that customer re - enters the general population .
the service times are exponentially distributed with mean @xmath14 and we define the traffic intensity @xmath15 by @xmath16 .
this model may describe , for example , a network of @xmath8 terminals in series with a processor - shared cpu .
this may be viewed as a closed two node queueing network .
the finite population model does not seem amenable to an exact solution .
however , various asymptotic studies have been done in the limit @xmath17 , so that the total population , or the number of terminals , is large .
if @xmath8 is large it is reasonable to assume either that @xmath18 , the arrival rate of each individual customer , is small , of the order @xmath19 , or that the service rate @xmath3 is large , of the order @xmath20
. then @xmath16 will remain @xmath21 as @xmath17 .
previous studies of the finite population model were carried out by morrison and mitra ( see @xcite-@xcite ) , in each case for @xmath17 .
for example , the moments of the sojourn time @xmath6 conditioned on the service time @xmath7 are obtained in @xcite , where it was found that the asymptotics are very different according as @xmath22 ( called `` normal usage '' ) , @xmath23 ( called `` heavy usage '' ) , or @xmath24 ( called `` very heavy usage '' ) . in @xcite the unconditional sojourn time distribution is investigated for @xmath17 and the three cases of @xmath15 , in @xcite the author obtains asymptotic results for the conditional sojourn time distribution , conditioned on the service time @xmath7 , in the very heavy usage case @xmath24 , and in @xcite the results of @xcite are generalized to multiple customer classes ( here the population @xmath8 is divided into several classes , with each class having different arrival and service times ) . in @xcite the authors analyze the multiple class model and obtain the unconditional sojourn time moments for @xmath17 in the normal usage case , while in @xcite heavy usage results are obtained . in this paper
we study the spectral structure of the finite population model as @xmath17 .
we denote the sojourn time by @xmath25 and its conditional density we call @xmath26 with @xmath27.\ ] ] here @xmath28 denotes the number of other customers present in the system immediately before the tagged customer arrives , and thus @xmath29 .
then we define the column vector @xmath30 .
@xmath31 satisfies a system of odes in the form @xmath32 where @xmath33 is an @xmath34 tridiagonal matrix , whose entries depend on @xmath16 and @xmath8 .
the eigenvalues of @xmath33 are all negative and we denote them by @xmath35 @xmath36 with the corresponding eigenvectors being @xmath37
. we shall study this eigenvalue problem for @xmath17 and three cases of @xmath15 : @xmath22 , @xmath24 and @xmath38 . in each case
we obtain expansions of the @xmath39 and then the @xmath40 , for various ranges of @xmath41 .
often the eigenvectors can be expressed in terms of hermite polynomials for @xmath17 .
since @xmath33 is a finite matrix the spectrum is purely discrete , but as the size of the matrix becomes large we sometimes see the eigenvalues coalescing about a certain value . ordering the eigenvalues as @xmath42 , the tail behavior of @xmath26 and @xmath43 for @xmath44 is determined by the smallest eigenvalue @xmath45 , where @xmath43 is the unconditional sojourn time density with @xmath46.\ ] ] it is interesting to note that while previous studies ( see @xcite-@xcite ) of the finite population model lead to the scaling @xmath23 , the spectrum involves the transition scale @xmath38 .
our basic approach is to use singular perturbation methods to analyze the system of odes when @xmath8 becomes large .
the problem can then be reduced to solving simpler , single differential equations whose solutions are known , such as hermite equations .
our analysis does make some assumptions about the forms of various asymptotic series , and about the asymptotic matching of expansions on different scales .
we also comment that we assume that the eigenvalue index @xmath47 is @xmath21 ; thus we are not computing the large eigenvalues here .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we state the mathematical problem and obtain the basic equations . in section 3
we summarize our final asymptotic results for the eigenvalues and the ( unnormalized ) eigenvectors .
the derivations are relegated to section 4 .
some numerical studies appear in section 5 ; these assess the accuracy of the asymptotics .
throughout the paper we assume that time has been scaled so to make the mean service time @xmath48 .
the conditional sojourn time density @xmath26 satisfies the following linear system of ordinary differential equations , or , equivalently , differential - difference equation : @xmath49p_n(t),\;0\le n\le n-1.\ ] ] the above holds also at @xmath50 if we require @xmath51 to be finite , and when @xmath52 ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) becomes @xmath53 the initial condition at @xmath54 is @xmath55 and we note that ( [ s2_fs_pn ] ) follows from integrating ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) from @xmath54 to @xmath56 .
here we focus on obtaining the eigenvalues ( and corresponding eigenvectors ) for the matrix @xmath57 , which corresponds to the difference operator in the right - hand side of ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) , specifically @xmath58\ ] ] which has size @xmath34 .
it follows that the solution of ( [ s2_fs_rec])-([s2_fs_pn ] ) has the spectral representation @xmath59 here @xmath35 are the eigenvalues of @xmath33 , indexed by @xmath60 and ordered as @xmath61 , @xmath40 is the eigenvector corresponding to eigenvalue @xmath39 , and the spectral coefficients @xmath62 in ( [ s2_fs_sum ] ) can be calculated from ( [ s2_fs_pn ] ) , hence @xmath63 from ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) we can easily establish orthogonality relations between the @xmath64 , and these lead to an explicit expression for the @xmath62 : @xmath65 we note that the tail of the sojourn time , in view of ( [ s2_fs_sum ] ) , is given by @xmath66 this asymptotic relation holds for @xmath67 and large times .
our analysis will assume that @xmath0 but for sufficiently large @xmath68 ( [ s2_fs_sim ] ) must still hold .
we shall study the behavior of @xmath69 for @xmath17 and for various ranges of the parameter @xmath15 .
we shall show that the behavior of the eigenvalues is very different for the cases @xmath22 , @xmath24 , and @xmath70 ( more precisely @xmath38 ) .
furthermore , within each range of @xmath15 the form of the expansions of the eigenfunctions @xmath40 is different in several ranges of @xmath41 .
our analysis will cover each of these ranges , but we restrict ourselves to the eigenvalue index @xmath47 being @xmath21 .
note that the matrix @xmath33 has @xmath71 eigenvalues so that @xmath47 could be scaled as large as @xmath20 .
we are thus calculating ( asymptotically for @xmath17 ) only the first few eigenvalues and their eigenfunctions .
obtaining , say , the large eigenvalues , would likely need a very different asymptotic analysis . when @xmath72 we shall see that the eigenfunctions and their zeros are concentrated in a narrow range of @xmath73 , which represents the fraction of the customer population that is using the processor .
since @xmath40 are functions of the discrete variable @xmath41 , by `` zeros '' we refer to sign changes of the eigenvectors . if the eigenvalue index @xmath47 were scaled to be also large with @xmath8 , we would expect that these sign changes would be more frequent , and would occur throughout the entire interval @xmath74 .
we comment that to understand fully the asymptotic structure of @xmath75 for @xmath17 requires a much more complete analysis than simply knowing the eigenvalues / eigenfunctions , as the spectral expansion may not be useful in certain space / time ranges .
however , ( [ s2_fs_sim ] ) will always apply for sufficiently large times , no matter how large @xmath8 is , as long as @xmath8 is finite .
we also comment that in ( [ s1_pt ] ) , by results in @xcite , we have @xmath76=\frac{(\frac{\rho}{n})^n(n-1)!}{(n-1-n)!}\bigg/\sum_{l=0}^{n-1}\frac{(\frac{\rho}{n})^l(n-1)!}{(n-1-l)!},\ ] ] which says that the distribution of @xmath28 coincides with the steady state distribution of @xmath11 in a finite population queue with population @xmath71 .
the tail of the unconditional sojourn time is then @xmath77e^{-\nu_0t},\;t\to\infty,\ ] ] where @xmath78^{-1}$ ] .
we give results for the three cases : @xmath22 , @xmath24 and @xmath38 . within each case of @xmath15
the eigenvectors @xmath40 have different behaviors in different ranges of @xmath41 .
for @xmath22 the eigenvalues are given by @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 we observe that the leading term in ( [ s31_nu ] ) ( @xmath82 ) is independent of the eigenvalue index @xmath47 and corresponds to the relaxation rate in the standard @xmath1 queue .
for the standard @xmath1-ps model ( with an customer population ) , it is well known ( see @xcite , @xcite ) that the tail of the sojourn time density is @xmath83t^{-5/6},\ ; t\to\infty\ ] ] where @xmath84 is a constant .
this problem corresponds to solving an infinite system of odes , which may be obtained by letting @xmath17 in the matrix @xmath33 ( with a fixed @xmath22 ) .
the spectrum of the resulting infinite matrix is purely continuous , which leads to the sub - exponential and algebraic factors in ( [ s31_ptsim ] ) .
the result in ( [ s31_nu ] ) shows that the ( necessarily discrete ) spectrum of @xmath85 has , for @xmath22 and @xmath17 , all of the eigenvalues approaching @xmath86 , with the deviation from this limit appearing only in the third ( @xmath87 ) and fourth ( @xmath19 ) terms in the expansion in ( [ s31_nu ] ) .
note that @xmath88 in ( [ s31_nu ] ) is independent of @xmath47 . comparing ( [ s31_ptsim ] ) to ( [ s2_fs_ptsim ] ) with ( [ s31_nu ] ) and @xmath89
, we see that the factors @xmath90t^{-5/6}$ ] in ( [ s31_ptsim ] ) are replaced by @xmath91 $ ] .
note that ( [ s31_ptsim ] ) corresponds to letting @xmath17 and then @xmath44 in the finite population model , while ( [ s2_fs_ptsim ] ) has @xmath44 with a finite large @xmath8 .
the expansion in ( [ s31_nu ] ) breaks down when @xmath47 becomes very large , and we note that when @xmath92 , the three terms @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 become comparable in magnitude .
the expansion in ( [ s31_nu ] ) suggests that @xmath47 can be allowed to be slightly large with @xmath8 , but certainly not as large as @xmath20 , which would be needed to calculate all of the eigenvalues of @xmath33 . as we stated before , here we do not attempt to get the eigenvalues of large index @xmath47 .
now consider the eigenvectors @xmath37 , for @xmath22 and @xmath17 .
these have the expansion @xmath96\ ] ] where @xmath41 and @xmath97 are related by @xmath98 and @xmath99 @xmath100\frac{d}{dz}\big[e^{-z^2/4}\mathrm{he}_j(z)\big]+\big(\frac{\alpha}{2}-\frac{2}{3}\beta\big)ze^{-z^2/4}\mathrm{he}_j(z),\ ] ] with @xmath101 here @xmath102 is the @xmath103 hermite polynomial , so that @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
the constant @xmath106 is a normalization constant which depends upon @xmath47 , @xmath15 and @xmath8 , but not @xmath41 .
apart from the factor @xmath107 in ( [ s31_phi ] ) we see that the eigenvectors are concentrated in the range @xmath108 and this corresponds to @xmath109 .
the zeros of the hermite polynomials correspond to sign changes ( with @xmath41 ) of the eigenvectors , and these are thus spaced @xmath110 apart .
we next give expansions of @xmath40 on other spatial scales , such as @xmath67 , @xmath111 and @xmath112 , where ( [ s31_phi ] ) ceases to be valid .
these results will involve normalization constants that we denote by @xmath113 , but each of these will be related to @xmath114 , so that our results are unique up to a multiplicative constant .
note that the eigenvalues of @xmath33 are all simple , which can be shown by a standard sturm - liouville type argument . for @xmath115 ( hence @xmath116 ) we find that @xmath117 where @xmath118 @xmath119^{2j+1}}\exp\big[(2j+1)(1-\sqrt{\rho})^{1/4}\sqrt{x}\big].\ ] ] the normalization constants @xmath114 and @xmath120 are related by @xmath121,\ ] ] by asymptotic matching between ( [ s31_phi ] ) and ( [ s31_phisim ] ) .
next we consider @xmath112 and scale @xmath122 .
the leading term becomes @xmath123\ ] ] with @xmath124\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{\rho-4\sqrt{\rho}+2}{2\rho}\log\big[\frac{\rho\xi+2 - 2\sqrt{\rho}+\sqrt{\rho^2\xi^2 + 4\rho\xi(1-\sqrt{\rho})}}{2(1-\sqrt{\rho})}\big]\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{1}{2}\log\bigg[\frac{(\rho-2\sqrt{\rho}+2)\xi+2(1-\sqrt{\rho})-(\sqrt{\rho}-2)\sqrt{\rho\xi^2 + 4\xi(1-\sqrt{\rho})}}{2(1-\sqrt{\rho})}\bigg],\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath125,\ ] ] @xmath126\ ] ] and @xmath127 can be written as the integral @xmath128\ ] ] where @xmath129\bigg\}\ ] ] and @xmath130 and @xmath131 are , respectively , the derivatives of ( [ s31_f ] ) and ( [ s31_f1 ] ) . note that @xmath132 and @xmath133 are independent of the eigenvalue index @xmath47 , while @xmath134 and @xmath135 do depend on it .
the constants @xmath136 and @xmath120 are related by @xmath137 , by asymptotic matching between ( [ s31_phisim ] ) and ( [ s31_phileading ] ) .
finally we consider the scale @xmath67 .
the expansion in ( [ s31_phisim ] ) with ( [ s31_fg ] ) develops a singularity as @xmath138 and ceases to be valid for small @xmath139 . for @xmath67
we obtain @xmath140 where the contour integral is a small loop about @xmath141 , and by asymptotic matching of ( [ s31_phisim ] ) as @xmath142 with ( [ s31_phisim3 ] ) as @xmath143 ,
@xmath144 we next consider @xmath17 with @xmath24 .
the eigenvalues are now small , of the order @xmath19 , with @xmath145 note that now we do not see the coalescence of eigenvalues , as was the case when @xmath22 , and the eigenvalue index @xmath47 appears in the leading term in ( [ s31_nuj ] ) . the form in ( [ s31_nuj ] )
also suggests that the tail behavior in ( [ s2_fs_sim ] ) is achieved when @xmath146 .
now the zeros of the eigenvectors will be concentrated in the range where @xmath147 , and introducing the new spatial variable @xmath148 , with @xmath149 we find that @xmath150 where @xmath102 is again the @xmath103 hermite polynomial , and @xmath114 is again a normalization constant , possibly different from ( [ s31_phi ] ) . on the @xmath151-scale with @xmath73
we obtain @xmath152 and @xmath114 and @xmath120 are related by @xmath153 by asymptotic matching between ( [ s31_phijx ] ) and ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) .
note that @xmath154 and for the first two eigenvectors ( @xmath155 ) , ( [ s31_phijx ] ) is a special case of ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) .
the expression in ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) holds for @xmath156 and for @xmath157 , but not for @xmath158 or @xmath159 . for the latter we must use ( [ s31_phijx ] ) and for @xmath67 we shall show that @xmath160 where @xmath161 is a closed loop that encircles the branch cut , where @xmath162 and @xmath163 $ ] , in the @xmath164-plane , with the integrand being analytic exterior to this cut . by expanding ( [ s31_phiint ] ) for @xmath165 and matching to ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) as @xmath166
we obtain @xmath167 in contrast to when @xmath22 , the eigenvectors now vary smoothly throughout the interval @xmath74 ( cf .
( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) ) but their sign changes are all concentrated where @xmath159 and the spacings of these changes are of the order @xmath168 , and approximately the same as the spacings of the zeros of the hermite polynomials ( cf .
( [ s31_x ] ) and ( [ s31_phijx ] ) ) .
finally we consider the case @xmath70 and introduce the parameter @xmath170 by @xmath171 this case will asymptotically match , as @xmath172 , to the @xmath24 results and , as @xmath173 , to the @xmath22 results .
now a two - term asymptotic approximation to the eigenvalues is @xmath174 where @xmath175 @xmath176 @xmath177 thus given @xmath170 we must solve ( [ s31_gammaa ] ) to get @xmath178 and then compute @xmath179 and @xmath180 .
we can explicitly invert ( [ s31_gammaa ] ) to obtain @xmath181^{1/3}.\ ] ] we also note that if @xmath182 we have @xmath183 and then @xmath184 , @xmath185 , and @xmath186 .
the expression in ( [ s31_nu2term ] ) shows that the eigenvalues are small , of the order @xmath187 , and to leading order coalesce at @xmath188 . the second term , however , depends linearly on the eigenvalue index @xmath47 .
the expansions of the eigenvectors will now be different on the four scales @xmath67 , @xmath189 , @xmath190 and @xmath112 .
it is on the third scale that the zeros of @xmath40 become apparent , and if we introduce @xmath191 by @xmath192 we obtain the following leading order approximation to the eigenvectors @xmath193 thus again the hermite polynomials arise , but now on the scale @xmath194 , which corresponds to @xmath195 .
the spacing of the zeros ( or sign changes ) of @xmath40 for the case @xmath38 is thus @xmath196 which is comparable to the case @xmath24 , and unlike the case @xmath22 where ( cf .
( [ s31_ny ] ) ) the spacing was @xmath110
. on the spatial scale @xmath197 , ( [ s31_phieig ] ) ceases to be valid and then we obtain @xmath198 where this applies for all @xmath199 except @xmath200 , where ( [ s31_phieig ] ) holds , and @xmath201 is given by @xmath202 @xmath203,\ ] ] where @xmath204 is as in ( [ s31_fa ] ) .
note that @xmath201 is independent of the eigenvalue index @xmath47 , and if @xmath205 then @xmath206 , which follows from ( [ s31_gammaa ] ) and ( [ s31_fa ] ) . thus the discriminant in ( [ s31_fpm ] ) vanishes when @xmath205 , and in fact it has a double zero at this point .
thus the sign switch in @xmath207 as @xmath208 crosses @xmath209 is needed to smoothly continue this function from @xmath210 to @xmath211 .
the function @xmath212 is given by @xmath213^{j}\exp\bigg\{\int_0^v\big[\frac{1}{4w}-\frac{j}{w - a}-h^{(1)}_+(w , j)\big]dw\bigg\},\ ; 0\le v < a\ ] ] and @xmath214^{j}\exp\bigg\{\int_0^a\big[\frac{1}{4w}-\frac{j}{w - a}-h^{(1)}_+(w , j)\big]dw\bigg\}\nonumber\\ & & \times\exp\bigg\{-\int_a^v\big[\frac{j}{w - a}+h^{(1)}_-(w , j)\big]dw\bigg\},\ ; v > a.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can show that @xmath215 as @xmath216 and @xmath217 as @xmath218 , so that the integrals in ( [ s31_gv < a ] ) and ( [ s31_gv > a ] ) are convergent at @xmath219 and @xmath220 . by expanding ( [ s31_phiv ] ) for @xmath218 we can establish the asymptotic matching of the results on the @xmath208-scale ( cf .
( [ s31_phiv ] ) ) and the @xmath191-scale ( cf .
( [ s31_phieig ] ) ) and then relate the constants @xmath114 and @xmath120 , leading to @xmath221dw\bigg\}.\ ] ] next we consider the scale @xmath222 with @xmath223 , and now the eigenvectors have the expansion @xmath224 where @xmath225 and @xmath226\ ] ] where @xmath180 and @xmath179 are as in ( [ s31_fa ] ) and ( [ s31_ga ] ) .
the constants @xmath136 and @xmath120 are related by @xmath227/3}a^{-g(j,\gamma)+\gamma f(\gamma)+j-1/4}\exp\bigg\{\int_0^a\big[\frac{1}{4w}-\frac{j}{w - a}-h^{(1)}_+(w , j)\big]dw\bigg\}\nonumber\\ & & \times\exp\bigg\{n^{1/3}\big[\frac{f(\gamma)}{3}\log n - f(\gamma)\log a-\frac{1-\gamma f(\gamma)}{a}+\int_0^a\mathcal{f}_+'(w)dw\big]\bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath67 , ( [ s31_phisim3 ] ) holds with @xmath228 , but now @xmath229^jk_1 $ ] . to summarize , we have shown that the eigenvalues have very different behaviors for @xmath22 ( cf .
( [ s31_nu ] ) ) , @xmath24 ( cf .
( [ s31_nuj ] ) ) and @xmath38 ( cf .
( [ s31_nu2term ] ) ) . in the first case , as @xmath17
, the eigenvalues all coalesce about @xmath86 which is the relaxation rate of the standard @xmath1 model .
however , higher order terms in the expansion show the splitting of the eigenvalues ( cf .
@xmath230 and @xmath231 in ( [ s31_nu ] ) ) , which occurs at the @xmath87 term in the expansion of the @xmath39 . for @xmath24 the eigenvalues are small , of order @xmath19 , but even the leading term depends upon @xmath47 ( cf .
( [ s31_nuj ] ) ) . when @xmath232 there is again a coalescence of the eigenvalues , now about @xmath233 where @xmath178 is given by ( [ s31_ab ] ) .
the splitting now occurs at the first correction term , which is of order @xmath19 .
we also note that the leading order dependence of the @xmath69 on @xmath47 occurs always in a simple linear fashion .
our analysis will also indicate how to compute higher order terms in the expansions of the @xmath39 and @xmath40 , for all three cases of @xmath15 and all ranges of @xmath41 .
ultimately , obtaining the leading terms for the @xmath40 reduces in all 3 cases of @xmath15 to the classic eigenvalue problem for the quantum harmonic oscillator , which can be solved in terms of hermite polynomials .
we proceed to compute the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the matrix @xmath33 above ( [ s2_fs_sum ] ) , treating respectively the cases @xmath22 , @xmath24 and @xmath38 , in subsections 4.1 - 4.3 .
we always begin by considering the scaling of @xmath41 , with @xmath8 , where the oscillations or sign changes of the eigenvectors occur , and this scale also determines the asymptotic eigenvalues .
then , other spatial ranges of @xmath41 will be treated , which correspond to the `` tails '' of the eigenvectors .
we recall that @xmath234 so that @xmath22 means that the service rate @xmath3 exceeds the maximum total arrival rate @xmath235 .
when @xmath22 and @xmath17 the distribution of @xmath28 in ( [ s2_fs_probn ] ) behaves as @xmath236\sim ( 1-\rho)\rho^n$ ] for @xmath67 , which is the same as the result for the infinite population @xmath1-ps queue .
we introduce @xmath237 as in ( [ s31_ny ] ) , and set @xmath238 and @xmath239 . then setting @xmath240 in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) and noting that changing @xmath41 to @xmath241 corresponds to changing @xmath97 to @xmath242 , we find that @xmath243\bigg(\frac{\sqrt{n}}{\sqrt{1-\sqrt{\rho}}}+yn^{3/8}+1\bigg)\phi_j(y).\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we also multiplied ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) by @xmath244 , which will simplify some of the expansions that follow .
letting @xmath17 in ( [ s41_expany ] ) leads to @xmath245 so we conclude that @xmath246 as @xmath17 and @xmath22 .
the form of ( [ s41_expany ] ) , which has the small parameter @xmath247 , then suggests that we expand @xmath248 as @xmath249 and we also expand @xmath250 as @xmath251 then we obtain from ( [ s41_expany ] ) the limiting ode @xmath252\phi_j^{(0)}(y)=0,\ ] ] where we set , for convenience , @xmath253 . letting @xmath254 be the differential operator @xmath255f(y)$ ] , at the next two orders ( @xmath256 and @xmath257 ) we then obtain @xmath258 and @xmath259 note that the coefficients @xmath260 in ( [ s41_expandcy ] ) will depend upon @xmath15 and also the eigenvalue index @xmath47 .
we also require the eigenfunctions @xmath248 to decay as @xmath261 .
changing variables from @xmath97 to @xmath164 with @xmath262 we see that @xmath263 , where @xmath264f(z)$ ] . thus solving ( [ s41_limitode ] )
corresponds to @xmath265 , which is a standard eigenvalue problem .
the only acceptable solutions ( which decay as @xmath266 ) correspond to @xmath267 and the ( unnormalized ) eigenfunctions are @xmath268 here @xmath102 is the hermite polynomial , which satisfies @xmath269 for @xmath266 .
we proceed to compute the correction term @xmath270 in ( [ s41_expandphiy ] ) , and also @xmath271 and @xmath231 in ( [ s41_expandcy ] ) . in terms of @xmath164 , ( [ s41_order1 ] )
becomes @xmath272=-\frac{c_3}{2\sqrt{\rho}(1-\sqrt{\rho})^{3/4}}\phi_j^{(0)}-\frac{(1-\sqrt{\rho})^{1/8}}{4\sqrt{2}}z^3\phi_j^{(0)}+\frac{\sqrt{\rho}}{\sqrt{2}(1-\sqrt{\rho})^{7/8}}\frac{d}{dz}\phi_j^{(0)}\ ] ] where @xmath273=f''(z)+\big(j+1/2-{z^2}/{4}\big)f(z)$ ] , in view of ( [ s41_c2 ] ) .
we determine @xmath274 by a solvability condition for ( [ s41_lphi1 ] ) .
we multiply ( [ s41_lphi1 ] ) by @xmath275 and integrate from @xmath276 to @xmath277 , and use the properties of hermite polynomials ( see @xcite ) .
then we conclude that @xmath278 for all @xmath47 .
thus there is no @xmath279 term in the expansion in ( [ s31_nu ] ) . to solve for @xmath270 we write the right - hand side of ( [ s41_lphi1 ] ) as @xmath280 where @xmath281 and @xmath282 are as in ( [ s31_ab ] ) .
then we can construct a particular solution to ( [ s41_lphi1 ] ) ( with @xmath278 ) in the form @xmath283 where @xmath284 , @xmath285 , and @xmath286 are determined from @xmath287 solving ( [ s41_abc ] ) leads to @xmath270 as in ( [ s31_phi1 ] ) .
to compute @xmath288 , the @xmath19 term in ( [ s31_nu ] ) , we use the solvability condition for the equation ( [ s41_order2 ] ) for @xmath289 .
we omit the detailed derivation .
we note that ( [ s31_c4 ] ) is singular in the limit @xmath290 , while @xmath230 in ( [ s31_c1c2 ] ) vanishes in this limit . also , @xmath288 is quadratic in @xmath47 while @xmath291 is linear in @xmath47 , so that ( [ s31_nu ] ) becomes invalid both as @xmath290 and as the eigenvalue index @xmath47 becomes large .
we next consider the @xmath40 on the spatial scales @xmath111 , @xmath112 and @xmath67 . for @xmath115 ( @xmath116 ) ,
the expansion in ( [ s31_phi ] ) ceases to be valid .
we expand the leading term @xmath292 in ( [ s31_phi ] ) as @xmath293 to obtain @xmath294,\ ] ] which suggests that we expand the eigenvector @xmath40 in the form ( [ s31_phisim ] ) on the @xmath139-scale , noticing also that @xmath295 .
we set @xmath296 in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) with @xmath39 given by ( [ s31_nu ] ) and @xmath40 having the form in ( [ s31_phisim ] ) .
for @xmath17 we obtain the following odes for @xmath297 and @xmath298 : @xmath299 ^ 2+(\sqrt{\rho}-1)x-\frac{1}{x}+\frac{c_1}{\sqrt{\rho}}=0\ ] ] and @xmath300g_j(x)=0.\ ] ] using @xmath88 and @xmath230 in ( [ s31_c1c2 ] ) , ( [ s41_xf(x)ode ] ) and ( [ s41_xg(x)ode ] ) can be easily solved and the results are in ( [ s31_fg ] ) .
we note that ( [ s41_xf(x)ode ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath301 ^ 2=\big(\sqrt{1-\sqrt{\rho}}\sqrt{x}-1/\sqrt{x}\big)^2.$ ] after taking the square root , we choose the solution with the negative sign since @xmath297 should achieve a maximum at @xmath302 .
now consider the scale @xmath303 .
letting @xmath304 in the exponential terms @xmath305 in ( [ s31_phisim ] ) ( with ( [ s31_fg ] ) ) and noticing that @xmath306 , we conclude that the expansion on the @xmath151-scale should have the form in ( [ s31_phileading ] ) . using @xmath296 with ( [ s31_nu ] ) and ( [ s31_phileading ] ) in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) and expanding for @xmath17
, we obtain the following odes for @xmath132 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 : @xmath307 @xmath308f_1'+\frac{c_1}{\sqrt{\rho}}=0,\ ] ] @xmath309f_2'+\frac{c_2(j)}{\sqrt{\rho}}=0,\ ] ] and @xmath310g'+\bigg\{\frac{c_4(j)+\rho}{\sqrt{\rho}}-e^{f'}-\frac{1}{\xi}e^{-f'}+\big(1-\frac{\sqrt{\rho}}{2}\xi\big)\big[f''+(f_1')^2\big]\bigg\}g=0.\ ] ] solving ( [ s41_odef ] ) for @xmath311 leads to @xmath312 integrating the logarithm of ( [ s41_ef ] ) leads to ( [ s31_f ] ) . from ( [ s41_ef ] )
we also have @xmath313 , and then solving ( [ s41_odef1])-([s41_odeg ] ) leads to ( [ s31_f1])-([s31_g ] ) .
finally we consider the scale @xmath67 .
we assume the leading order approximation of @xmath40 is @xmath314.\ ] ] then using @xmath296 in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) with @xmath40 in ( [ s41_phin ] ) and letting @xmath17 , we obtain the following limiting difference equation for @xmath315 : @xmath316 with @xmath317 finite ( thus ( [ s41_depsi2 ] ) holds for all @xmath318 ) . from ( [ s41_depsi2 ] ) we conclude that @xmath315 is independent of the eigenvalue index @xmath47 , except via a multiplicative constant . solving ( [ s41_depsi2 ] ) with the help of generation functions
leads to ( [ s31_phisim3 ] ) .
when @xmath24 the distribution of @xmath28 in ( [ s2_fs_probn ] ) is approximately , for @xmath17 , a gaussian which is centered about @xmath319 and this corresponds to the fraction of the population that is typically served by the processor .
we thus begin by considering the scale @xmath147 , setting @xmath320 we thus scale the eigenvalue parameter @xmath321 to be small , of order @xmath19 , which is necessary to obtain a limiting differential equation . setting @xmath322 and omitting for now the dependence of @xmath321 and @xmath323 on the index
@xmath47 , ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) becomes @xmath324+\psi\big(x-\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big)\nonumber\\ & & -\psi(x)-\frac{1}{n(1-\rho^{-1})+\sqrt{n}x}\psi\big(x-\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] then expanding @xmath325 and @xmath326 as @xmath327 and multiplying ( [ s42_psixexpan ] ) by @xmath8 we obtain the limiting ode @xmath328 this can be easily transformed to the hermite equation by setting @xmath329 . in terms of @xmath330 , ( [ s42_psiode ] ) becomes @xmath331 which is the standard hermite equation ( in contrast to the parabolic cylinder equation in ( [ s41_limitode ] ) ) . equation ( [ s42_psixtildode ] ) admits polynomial solutions provided that @xmath332 which yields the leading order eigenvalue condition , and then the solution to ( [ s42_psixtildode ] ) is @xmath333 from ( [ s42_nu*poly ] ) and ( [ s42_nuxexpan ] ) we have thus derived ( [ s31_nuj ] ) , while ( [ s31_phijx ] ) follows from ( [ s42_psi0 ] ) .
higher order terms can be obtained by refining the expansion of ( [ s42_psixexpan ] ) using ( [ s42_nuxexpan ] ) , which will lead to inhomogeneous forms of the hermite equation ; the correction terms @xmath334 for @xmath335 will follow from appropriate solvability conditions . next we consider ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) on a broader spatial scale , introducing @xmath73 , which is essentially the fraction of the population in the system ( not counting the tagged customer ) .
letting @xmath336 in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) and scaling again @xmath337 leads to @xmath338\big[\varphi\big(\xi+\frac{1}{n}\big)-\varphi(\xi)\big]+\big(1-\frac{1}{n\xi+1}\big)\varphi\big(\xi-\frac{1}{n}\big)-\varphi(\xi).\ ] ] for @xmath17 ( [ s42_phixiexpan ] ) leads to the limiting differential equation @xmath339\varphi'(\xi)+\big(\nu_*-\frac{1}{\xi}\big)\varphi(\xi)=0\ ] ] with solution @xmath340 we argue that if the right - hand side of ( [ s42_phixisolu ] ) is to be real and finite for all @xmath74 we must have @xmath341 a non - negative integer , and this regains the eigenvalue condition in ( [ s31_nuj ] ) . alternately ,
since we have already fixed @xmath342 by considering the scale @xmath343 , we can view ( [ s42_phixisolu ] ) as simply giving the approximation to the eigenfunctions on the @xmath151-scale , as given by ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) .
note that for @xmath89 and @xmath344 the zeros of ( [ s42_phixisolu ] ) and ( [ s42_psi0 ] ) coincide , but for @xmath345 the expression in ( [ s42_phixisolu ] ) has a zero of order @xmath47 at @xmath346 while ( [ s42_psi0 ] ) has @xmath47 simple zeros at points where @xmath347 is at a zero of @xmath348 . the expression in ( [ s42_phixisolu ] )
vanishes as @xmath166 for @xmath24 , and we thus need another expansion for the @xmath40 for small values of @xmath151 .
we re - examine ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) on the scale @xmath67 .
setting @xmath349 and @xmath350 , ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) becomes @xmath351 and if @xmath352 for @xmath17 with @xmath67 , the leading term must satisfy @xmath353 solving ( [ s42_qleading ] ) using generating functions or contour integrals leads to the formula in ( [ s31_phiint ] ) .
to analyze the cases @xmath182 and @xmath169 we first note that when @xmath290 the eigenvalues for @xmath22 , which concentrate about @xmath86 , behave as @xmath354 ( here first @xmath17 , then @xmath290 ) . the result for @xmath24 ( cf .
( [ s31_nuj ] ) ) leads to @xmath355 as @xmath356 , which again shows that the eigenvalues begin to coalesce .
also , @xmath357 balances @xmath358 when @xmath38 and this suggests the appropriate scaling for the transition region where @xmath169 .
we thus define @xmath170 by @xmath359 the behavior of @xmath39 for @xmath360 indicates that the eigenvalues on the transition scale coalesce about some value that is @xmath187 as @xmath17 , so we set @xmath361 asymptotic matching as @xmath362 to the case @xmath24 and as @xmath173 to the case @xmath22 leads to the following behaviors of @xmath363 @xmath364 this analysis suggests that the eigenvalues may be expanded in the form ( [ s31_nu2term ] ) , where the correction term @xmath365 can also be argued by matching higher order terms in the expansions of @xmath39 for @xmath360 . to argue what the appropriate scaling of @xmath41 should be when @xmath38 , we examine ( [ s31_ny ] ) as @xmath290 , which becomes @xmath366 similarly , as @xmath356 the scaling in ( [ s31_x ] ) becomes @xmath367 in view of ( [ s43_ngamma ] ) and ( [ s43_nx ] ) we scale @xmath41 as in ( [ s31_u ] ) , where @xmath284 is to be determined . by asymptotic matching @xmath178 must behave as @xmath368 and @xmath369 .
we then set @xmath370 where @xmath371 is another parameter , that will be determined to insure that @xmath372 satisfies a limiting differential equation for @xmath17 .
for now we suppress the dependence of @xmath321 and @xmath372 on the eigenvalue index @xmath47 , and use ( [ s43_pntu ] ) in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) to obtain @xmath373\nonumber\\ & & -\frac{1}{n^{2/3}a+\sqrt{n}u+1}\exp\big(-\frac{\widetilde{a}}{n^{1/3}}\big)\phi\big(u-\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big)\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{\gamma}{n^{1/3}}\big[\phi\big(u+\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big)-\phi(u)\big]\nonumber\\ & & + \big[\exp\big(\frac{\widetilde{a}}{n^{1/3}}\big)-1\big]\big[1+\frac{\gamma}{n^{1/3}}\big]\phi\big(u+\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big)\nonumber\\ & & -\big[\exp\big(\frac{\widetilde{a}}{n^{1/3}}\big)-1\big]\big(\frac{a}{n^{1/3}}+\frac{u}{\sqrt{n}}+\frac{1}{n}\big)\big(1+\frac{\gamma}{n^{1/3}}\big)\phi\big(u+\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big)\nonumber\\ & & + \big[\exp\big(-\frac{\widetilde{a}}{n^{1/3}}\big)-1\big]\phi\big(u-\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equation in ( [ s43_phiuexpan ] ) is an exact transformation of ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) using the scaling in ( [ s31_u ] ) , ( [ s43_gamma ] ) and ( [ s43_pntu ] ) , and we rearranged the terms in the right - hand side of ( [ s43_phiuexpan ] ) in such a way that they are easier to expand for @xmath17 .
next we assume that @xmath39 can be expanded in the form in ( [ s31_nu2term ] ) . with the help of taylor expansions , we see that the right side of ( [ s43_phiuexpan ] ) will have terms that are @xmath187 , @xmath374 , and @xmath19 , with the rest being @xmath375 , and this would balance the error term(s ) in the eigenvalue expansion in ( [ s31_nu2term ] ) .
balancing the @xmath187 terms , which includes @xmath179 in ( [ s31_nu2term ] ) , leads to @xmath376\phi(u),\ ] ] the @xmath374 terms lead to @xmath377 and the @xmath19 terms give @xmath378\phi(u).\ ] ] in view of ( [ s43_fphiu ] ) we must have @xmath379 which is one equation relating @xmath179 , @xmath284 and @xmath371 to the `` detuning '' parameter @xmath170 . in order to obtain the second order equation in ( [ s43_n-1term ] ) as the leading term we must set @xmath380 and @xmath381
this yields two additional relations between @xmath371 and @xmath284 , and if we eliminate @xmath371 we obtain precisely the equation ( [ s31_gammaa ] ) that relates @xmath170 and @xmath284 , and then setting @xmath382 in ( [ s43_faa ] ) leads to @xmath383 , which is ( [ s31_fa ] ) .
finally , using @xmath382 in ( [ s43_n-1term ] ) and setting @xmath384 leads to @xmath385\widetilde{\phi}(u)=0.\ ] ] if we further scale @xmath191 as @xmath386 ( [ s43_phitilde ] ) becomes @xmath387\widetilde{\phi}=0,\ ] ] which is the parabolic cylinder equation in standard form .
solutions that have appropriate decay as @xmath191 ( or @xmath388 ) @xmath389 require that @xmath390 then the solution to ( [ s43_odephibar ] ) is proportional to a hermite polynomial , with @xmath391 , so we have derived ( [ s31_ga ] ) and ( [ s31_phieig ] ) . in view of the form of ( [ s43_phiuexpan ] ) , we can expand the eigenfunctions in powers of @xmath392 and calculate higher order correction terms , obtaining an expansion of the form @xmath393 .
it is likely that the expansion of the eigenvalues @xmath39 involves only powers of @xmath394 . from ( [ s31_gammaa ] )
we can easily obtain @xmath395 as @xmath362 , and @xmath396 as @xmath173 , which can be used to verify the matching conditions in ( [ s43_fgammasim])-([s43_nx ] ) .
we have thus shown that analysis of the case @xmath169 is quite intricate , but ultimately , with the appropriate scaling , we again reduced the problem to the standard eigenvalue problem for the hermite or parabolic cylinder equations .
next we examine the eigenvectors @xmath40 on the scales @xmath189 , @xmath112 and @xmath67 , since ( [ s31_phieig ] ) no longer applies in these ranges .
we first consider the scale @xmath197 .
letting @xmath397 in ( [ s31_phieig ] ) suggests that on the @xmath208-scale the eigenvector @xmath40 is in the form ( [ s31_phiv ] ) . using ( [ s31_phiv ] ) in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) and noticing that changing @xmath41 to @xmath241 corresponds to changing @xmath208 to @xmath398 , we obtain the following odes for @xmath399 and @xmath400 : @xmath401 ^ 2+(\gamma - v)\mathcal{f}'(v)+f(\gamma)-\frac{1}{v}=0,\ ] ] @xmath402 ^ 2}{2\mathcal{f}'(v)-v+\gamma}\mathcal{g}(v , j)=0.\ ] ] solving ( [ s43_fode ] ) and ( [ s43_gode ] ) leads to the results in ( [ s31_mathcalf])-([s31_gv > a ] ) .
next we consider the scale @xmath303 with @xmath403 .
letting @xmath404 in ( [ s31_mathcalf ] ) and ( [ s31_gv > a ] ) , we find that the eigenvectors have an expansion in the form in ( [ s31_phixi ] ) . using ( [ s31_phixi ] ) in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) yields @xmath405 and @xmath406g(\xi , j)=0,\ ] ] which can be easily solved to give ( [ s31_fxi ] ) and ( [ s31_gxi ] ) .
finally we consider the @xmath67 scale .
this is necessary since @xmath400 in ( [ s31_gv < a ] ) is singular as @xmath216 , with @xmath407 .
we assume that the leading order approximation to @xmath40 is @xmath408 and use this in ( [ s2_fs_rec ] ) .
similarly to the analysis of @xmath67 in subsection 4.1 , we find that @xmath409 satisfies @xmath410 , which leads to the contour integral in ( [ s31_phisim3 ] ) with @xmath228 .
we assess the accuracy of our asymptotic results , and their ability to predict qualitatively and quantitatively the true eigenvalues / eigenvectors .
recall that @xmath40 is the @xmath411 eigenvector with @xmath412 and @xmath413 . in figure [ f1 ]
we plot the exact ( numerical ) @xmath414 for @xmath415 $ ] , where @xmath416 and @xmath417 .
our asymptotic analysis predicts that @xmath414 will undergo a single sign change , and on the scale @xmath343 , ( [ s31_phijx ] ) shows that @xmath414 should be approximately linear in @xmath148 , with a zero at @xmath418 which corresponds to @xmath419 ( @xmath420 ) , in view of ( [ s31_x ] ) .
the exact eigenvector undergoes a sign change when @xmath41 changes from 74 to 75 , in excellent agreement with the asymptotics .
while the eigenvector is approximately linear near @xmath419 , figure [ f1 ] shows that it is not globally linear , and achieves a minimum value at @xmath421 .
but our analysis shows that on the @xmath422 scale , we must use ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) , and when @xmath423 and @xmath344 , ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) achieves a minimum at @xmath424 , which corresponds to @xmath425 .
this demonstrates the necessity of treating both the @xmath148 and @xmath151 scales . in figure
[ f2 ] we retain @xmath416 and @xmath423 , but now plot the second eigenvector @xmath426 .
we see that typically @xmath427 , and its graph is approximately tangent to the @xmath41-axis near @xmath428 . in figure [ f3 ]
we `` blow up ''
the region near @xmath419 , plotting @xmath426 for @xmath429 $ ] .
now we clearly see two sign changes , and these occur as @xmath41 changes from 69 to 70 , and 79 to 80 .
our asymptotic analysis suggests that near @xmath430 the eigenvector is proportional to @xmath431 , which has zeros at @xmath432 , and in view of ( [ s31_x ] ) this corresponds to @xmath433 , which is again in excellent agreement with the exact results . in the range
@xmath434 $ ] figure [ f3 ] shows roughly a parabolic profile , as predicted by ( [ s31_phijx ] ) , but the larger picture in figure [ f2 ] again demonstrates that the @xmath151-scale result in ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) must be used when @xmath148 is further away from @xmath435 , as ( [ s31_phijk1 ] ) will , for example , predict the minimum value seen in figure [ f2 ] .
next we consider @xmath182 , maintaining @xmath416 . now
the asymptotic result in the main range is in ( [ s31_u ] ) and ( [ s31_phieig ] ) , and when @xmath182 we have @xmath436 . in figure [ f5 ]
we plot @xmath414 ( @xmath344 ) in the range @xmath437 $ ] , and we see a single sign change when @xmath41 increases from 26 to 27 . for @xmath344 the asymptotic formula in ( [ s31_phieig ] )
predicts a zero at @xmath438 , which corresponds to @xmath439 . in figure [ f6 ]
we have @xmath440 and @xmath441 $ ] ; there are two sign changes , between @xmath442 and 22 , and @xmath443 and 35 .
now @xmath444 and the approximation in ( [ s31_phieig ] ) has zeros where @xmath445 , which corresponds to @xmath446 , leading to the numerical values of @xmath447 and @xmath448 .
next we consider @xmath22 . now
the main range is the @xmath97-scale result in ( [ s31_phi])-([s31_ab ] ) .
for @xmath22 we now plot the `` symmetrized '' eigenvector(s ) @xmath449 . in figures [ f8 ] and [ f9 ] we always have @xmath450 and @xmath416 .
figure [ f8 ] has @xmath451 for @xmath452 $ ] and shows a single sign change between @xmath453 and 16 .
the leading term in ( [ s31_phi ] ) predicts a sign change at @xmath454 , so that @xmath455 . since @xmath456 in ( [ s31_phi1 ] ) ( with ( [ s31_ab ] ) ) , the correction term would improve on the accuracy of the sign change prediction . figure [ f9 ] plots @xmath457 and shows two sign changes , between @xmath458 and 13 , and @xmath459 and 23 .
now the leading term in ( [ s31_phi ] ) has zeros at @xmath460 which correspond to the numerical values @xmath461 and @xmath462 from ( [ s31_ny ] ) .
we note that figures [ f8 ] and [ f9 ] show that the eigenvector becomes very small as @xmath41 increases toward 99 , and this is indeed predicted by the expansion in ( [ s31_phileading ] ) , which applies on the @xmath73 scale . we have thus shown that our asymptotic results predict quite well the qualitative properties of the eigenvectors @xmath40 for @xmath8 large and moderate @xmath47 .
we get very good quantitative agreement when @xmath24 , but less so when @xmath182 or @xmath22 , for the moderately large value @xmath416 .
next we consider the accuracy of our expansions for the eigenvalues @xmath39 . in table
[ table1 ] we take @xmath450 and increase @xmath8 from 10 to 100 , and give the two - term , three - term , and four - term asymptotic approximations in ( [ s31_nu ] ) for the zeroth eigenvalue @xmath45 , along with the exact numerical result .
we also give the relative errors , defined as @xmath463 .
we note that the leading term would simply give @xmath464 , independent of @xmath8 , which is not very accurate .
table [ table1 ] shows that the correction terms in ( [ s31_nu ] ) do lead to accurate approximations , and indeed when @xmath416 the four - term approximation is accurate to three significant figures . in table
[ table2 ] we take @xmath417 , in which case we only computed the leading term in ( [ s31_nuj ] ) , but now the eigenvalue index @xmath47 appears to leading order .
table [ table2 ] gives the exact values of @xmath45 and @xmath465 , along with the leading order approximations in ( [ s31_nuj ] ) , for @xmath8 increasing from 10 to 100 .
the agreement is again very good , with the relative errors decreasing to about @xmath466 when @xmath416 .
we next do some numerical studies to see how rapidly the unconditional sojourn time density settles to its tail behavior , for problems with moderately large @xmath8 . here
we compute @xmath43 exactly ( numerically ) , using ( [ s2_fs_sum ] ) and ( [ s2_fs_probn ] ) in ( [ s1_pt ] ) , and compare the result to the approximation in ( [ s2_fs_ptsim ] ) , which uses only the zeroth eigenvalue @xmath45 . tables [ table3]-[table5 ] compare the exact @xmath467 $ ] to the corresponding approximation from ( [ s2_fs_ptsim ] ) , and we note that both must approach @xmath45 as @xmath44 .
our asymptotic analysis predicts that for @xmath17 and @xmath22 , the @xmath89 term in ( [ s2_fs_sum ] ) should dominate for times @xmath468 , while if @xmath38 or @xmath24 , the @xmath89 term dominates for times @xmath469 . in table
[ table3 ] we take @xmath450 and let @xmath470 and @xmath471 . for @xmath470 , the largest eigenvalue is @xmath472 , which we list in the last row of the table , and the second largest eigenvalue is @xmath473 . for @xmath474 , we have @xmath475 and @xmath476 . in table
[ table4 ] we take @xmath182 . now
@xmath477 and @xmath478 when @xmath470 , and @xmath479 and @xmath480 when @xmath474 . in table
[ table5 ] we take @xmath423 and @xmath481 , @xmath482 when @xmath470 , and @xmath483 , @xmath484 when @xmath474 .
tables [ table3]-[table5 ] show that the approximation resulting from ( [ s2_fs_ptsim ] ) is quite accurate , though it may take fairly large times before the exact and approximate results ultimately reach the limit @xmath45 .
the relative errors improve as we go from @xmath450 to @xmath182 to @xmath423 , which is again consistent with our asymptotic analysis , as when @xmath22 there is the most coalescence ( for @xmath17 ) of the eigenvalues , making it hard to distinguish @xmath45 from the others .
+ 5 & 0.5398 & 0.5415 & 0.32% & 0.3383 & 0.3387 & 0.14% + 10 & 0.3362 & 0.3363 & 0.03% & 0.2024 & 0.2024 & 0.01% + 15 & 0.2679 & 0.2680 & 2.4e-05 & 0.1570 & 0.1570 & 1.5e-05 + 20 & 0.2338 & 0.2338 & 2.2e-06 & 0.1343 & 0.1343 & 1.6e-06 + 30 & 0.1996 & 0.1996 & 1.9e-08 & 0.1207 & 0.1207 & 1.7e-07 + 50 & 0.1722 & 0.1722 & 1.6e-12 & 0.1002 & 0.1002 & 2.1e-10 + 100 & 0.1517 & 0.1517 & @xmath4861.0e-12 & 0.0934 & 0.0934 & 2.6e-12 + @xmath487 & 0.1312 & 0.1312 & & 0.0662 & 0.0662 & + 2 l. kleinrock , _ analysis of a time - shared processor _
, naval research logistics quarterly 11 ( 1964 ) , 59 - 73 .
+ l. kleinrock , _ time - shared systems : a theoretical treatment _ , j. acm 14 ( 1967 ) , 242 - 261 .
+ d. p. heyman , t. v. lakshman , and a. l. neidhardt , _ a new method for analysing feedback - based protocols with applications to engineering web traffic over the internet _
acm sigmetrics ( 1997 ) , 24 - 38 .
+ l. massouli and j. w. roberts , _ bandwidth sharing : objectives and algorithms _ , proc .
ieee infocom , new york , ny , usa ( 1999 ) , 1395 - 1403 .
+ m. nabe , m. murata , and h. miyahara , _ analysis and modeling of world wide web traffic for capacity dimensioning of internet access lines _ ,
evaluation , 34 ( 1998 ) , 249 - 271 .
+ d. mitra and j. a. morrison , _ asymptotic expansions of moments of the waiting time in closed and open processor - sharing systems with multiple job classes _ , adv .
in appl . probab .
15 ( 1983 ) , 813 - 839 .
+ j. a. morrison and d. mitra , _ heavy - usage asymptotic expansions for the waiting time in closed processor - sharing systems with multiple classes _ , adv . in appl .
17 ( 1985 ) , 163 - 185 .
+ j. a. morrison , _ asymptotic analysis of the waiting - time distribution for a large closed processor - sharing system _ , siam j. appl .
46 ( 1986 ) , 140 - 170 .
+ j. a. morrison , _ moments of the conditioned waiting time in a large closed processor - sharing system _ , stochastic models 2 ( 1986 ) , 293 - 321 .
+ j. a. morrison , _ conditioned response - time distribution for a large closed processor - sharing system in very heavy usage _ , siam j. appl .
47 ( 1987 ) , 1117 - 1129 .
+ j. a. morrison , _ conditioned response - time distribution for a large closed processor - sharing system with multiple classes in very heavy usage _ , siam j. appl .
48 ( 1988 ) , 1493 - 1509 .
+ k. c. sevcik and i. mitrani , _ the distribution of queueing network states at input and output instants _ , j. acm 28 ( 1981 ) , 358 - 371 .
+ f. pollaczek , _ la loi dattente des appels tlphoniques _ , c. r. acad .
paris 222 ( 1946 ) , 353 - 355 .
+ j. w. cohen , _ on processor sharing and random service ( letter to the editor ) _ , j. appl .
prob . 21 ( 1984 ) , 937
. + w. magnus , f. oberhettinger , and r. p. soni , formulas and theorems for the special functions of mathematical physics , springer - verlag , new york , 1966 . | we consider sojourn or response times in processor - shared queues that have a finite population of potential users .
computing the response time of a tagged customer involves solving a finite system of linear odes . writing the system in matrix form , we study the eigenvectors and eigenvalues in the limit as the size of the matrix becomes large .
this corresponds to finite population models where the total population is @xmath0 . using asymptotic methods we reduce the eigenvalue problem to that of a standard differential equation , such as the hermite equation .
the dominant eigenvalue leads to the tail of a customer s sojourn time distribution . +
* keywords : * finite population , processor sharing , eigenvalue , eigenvector , asymptotics . |
a relativistic motion of grb sources was advocated by @xcite from that the energies released exceed by many orders of magnitude the eddington luminosity for a stellar - mass object , especially if grbs are at cosmological distances ( see also @xcite ) .
the detection by cgro / egret of photons with energy above 1 mev during the prompt burst emission ( e.g. @xcite ) shows that grb sources are optically thin to such photons .
together with the sub - mev burst isotropic - equivalent output of @xmath1 ergs ( e.g. @xcite ) and the millisecond burst variability timescale , the condition for optical thickness to high energy photons gives another reason why grbs must arise from ultra - relativistic sources , moving at lorentz factor @xmath2 ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the same conclusion is enforced by the measurement of a relativistic expansion of the radio afterglow source .
that expansion was either measured directly , as for grb 030329 ( @xmath3 ) , whose size increased at an apparent speed of 5c , indicating a source expanding at @xmath4 at 12 months @xcite , or was inferred from the rate at which interstellar scintillation @xcite quenches owing to the increasing source size , as for grb 970508 , whose expansion speed is inferred to be close to @xmath5 at 1 month @xcite .
the adiabatic dynamical evolution of a blast - wave , @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the mass of the ambient medium , leads to @xmath8 for a homogeneous medium ( @xmath9 being the observer - frame photon arrival time ) .
then , @xmath10 extrapolated to the burst time implies @xmath11 . extrapolating to such early times
is justified by that most optical afterglow light - curves display a power - law decay starting after the burst , which sets a lower limit on the source lorentz factor at that time . whether the grb ejecta are a cold baryonic outflow accelerated by the adiabatic losses of fireball s initial thermal / radiation energy ( e.g. @xcite ) , or relativistic pairs formed through magnetic dissipation in a poynting outflow , as in the electromagnetic model of @xcite , their interaction with ambient medium will drive two shocks : a reverse shock crossing the ejecta and a forward - shock sweeping the circumburst medium , as illustrated in figure [ bw ] .
both shocks energize their respective media , accelerate relativistic particles and generate magnetic fields through some plasma - instability related process , such as the two - stream weibel instability driven by an anisotropic particle distribution function @xcite .
the original magnetic field of the fireball at @xmath12 cm becomes too weak by the time the fireball reaches the @xmath13 cm radius ( where the burst and afterglow emissions are produced ) for the synchrotron emission to account for the sub - mev burst emission and for the longer - wavelength , ensuing afterglow emission , even if the fireball was initially magnetically dominated @xcite .
the evolution of the synchrotron and inverse - compton fluxes produced by the blast - wave at a fixed frequency ( i.e. the light - curve ) is determined by how the characteristics of the spectrum ( break frequencies and peak flux ) change with time .
figure [ spek ] shows the expected afterglow synchrotron spectrum , whose characteristics depend on the blast - wave radius , number of radiating electrons , their distribution with energy , magnetic field strength , and lorentz factor . if the typical electron energy and magnetic field energy correspond to some fixed fraction of the post - shock energy , or if they start from such a fixed fraction and then evolve adiabatically ( as for adiabatically colling ejecta ) , then the afterglow light - curve depends on ( 1 ) the evolution of the blast - wave lorentz factor , the blast - wave radius being @xmath14 ( with @xmath9 the photon - arrival time measured since burst trigger ) ( 2 ) the spectrum of the blast - wave emission ( i.e. the distribution of electrons with energy ) , and , in the case of the reverse - shock , ( 3 ) the evolution of the incoming mass .
the power - law deceleration of the blast - wave ( @xmath15 for @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the radial stratification of the ambient medium density ) and the power - law afterglow spectrum ( @xmath18 ) are two factors which lead to a power - law afterglow light - curve ( @xmath19 ) , with the decay index @xmath20 being a linear function of the spectral slope @xmath21 .
these are the only two factors at work for the forward - shock emission and the ejecta emission during the adiabatic cooling phase ( which starts when the reverse shock has crossed the ejecta shell ) , the two models that yield power - law afterglow light - curves in the most simple and natural way .
in contrast , for the reverse - shock emission ( i.e. the ejecta emission while the shock exists ) , the light - curve depends also on the radial distribution of ejecta mass and of their lorentz factor , thus the observed power - law light - curves require additional properties to be satisfied by the relativistic ejecta .
such properties seem _ ad - hoc _ when it comes to explaining single power - law afterglows whose flux displays an unchanged decay over 24 decades in time ( such as the x - ray afterglows of grbs 050801 , 050820a , 06011b , 060210 , 060418 , 061007 ) , but they also provide the flexibility required to account for the prevalent x - ray afterglow light - curves that exhibit one or more breaks .
i consider first the afterglow emission at early times , when the blast - wave is sufficiently relativistic that the observer receives boosted emission from a region of half - angle opening @xmath22 ( as seen from the center of the blast - wave ) that is smaller than the half - aperture @xmath23 of the collimated outflow . in that case
, the observer does not `` see '' yet the angular boundary of the outflow and the received emission is as bright as for a spherical blast - wave .
the evolution of the spectral characteristics of the emission from ejecta and the swept - up ambient medium are presented below , the resulting power - law decay indices of the synchrotron flux being listed in table 1 . for a short - duration ejecta release , the reverse shock crosses the ejecta shell over an observer - frame time that depends primarily on the ejecta lorentz factor @xmath24 : @xmath25 s , where @xmath26 is the isotropic - equivalent ejecta kinetic energy in @xmath27 erg
, @xmath28 is the ambient medium density in protons per @xmath29 , and @xmath30 . in this case , the reverse shock is semi - relativistic and , more likely , radiates below the optical .
after @xmath31 , the input of energy into the shocked structure ceases and the blast - wave begins to decelerate .
if the ejecta release is an extended process , the deceleration timescale depends primarily on the duration @xmath32 over which the ejecta are expelled : @xmath33 . in this case , the reverse shock is relativistic and could produce a bright optical emission .
the separation between these two cases is set by @xmath34 , `` short - duration ejecta release '' meaning @xmath35 s. for a wind medium , the deceleration timescale is @xmath36 s for a short - duration ejecta release , where @xmath37 is the wind density parameter , normalized to that resulting for @xmath38 being ejected at a terminal velocity of 1000 km / s , @xmath31 being the same as for a homogeneous medium in the case of a long - duration ejection ( which occurs for @xmath39 s ) . at the deceleration radius ,
@xmath40 of the ejecta energy has been transferred to the swept - up ambient medium , which moves at @xmath41 for @xmath42 and a lower @xmath43 for @xmath44 .
taking into account that the energy per particle in the post forward - shock gas is @xmath43 , it follows that , at @xmath31 , the ejecta mass is larger than that of the forward shock by at most a factor @xmath45 .
this implies that , at @xmath31 , the peak flux of the reverse - shock emission spectrum is a factor @xmath46 larger than the peak flux of the forward - shock spectrum , hence , the optical flash from the reverse shock could be up to 5 magnitudes brighter than the optical emission from the forward shock . as mentioned above ,
when there is a reverse shock crossing the ejecta , its emission flux should depend on the density and lorentz factor of the incoming ejecta .
semi - analytical calculations of the ejecta synchrotron emission when there is a reverse shock have been done by @xcite and @xcite for a density and lorentz factor of the incoming ejecta tailored to produce x - ray light - curve plateaus , hydrodynamical calculations of the reverse - shock dynamics have been presented by @xcite , and calculations of the ejecta emission after the reverse shock has crossed the ejecta ( i.e. during adiabatic cooling ) have been published by @xcite . however , analytical calculations of the ejecta emission while there is a reverse shock @xcite have yet to be done . assuming a uniform ejecta density & lorentz factor and an extended ejecta release , for which the reverse shock is relativistic and the shocked ejecta
are slightly decelerated even before @xmath31 , owing to the progressive dilution of the incoming ejecta , i find that the _ reverse - shock _ peak flux @xmath47 and break frequencies @xmath48 ( injection ) and @xmath49 ( cooling ) evolve as @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 for a homogeneous medium and @xmath53 , @xmath54 , @xmath55 for a wind . as for the _ ejecta _ emission decay during the adiabatic cooling phase ,
the evolution of the spectral characteristics is approximately @xmath56 , @xmath57 for a homogeneous medium , and @xmath58 , @xmath59 for a wind . for @xmath60 , the cooling ejecta flux should decay with an index @xmath61 , for either type of medium . above @xmath48 but below @xmath49 ,
the decay index is @xmath62 for a homogeneous medium and @xmath63 for a wind .
depending on the treatment of the ejecta dynamics and adiabatic cooling , other researchers reached slightly different results @xmath64 with @xmath65 and @xmath66 in @xcite , @xmath67 and @xmath68 in @xcite , @xmath69 and @xmath70 in @xcite .
after @xmath49 falls below @xmath71 owing to adiabatic cooling , the observer receives no emission from the area of angular opening @xmath22 moving directly toward the observer ( because of the exponential cut - off of the synchrotron emissivity above the synchrotron peak ) but receives emission from the fluid moving at increasing angles larger than @xmath22 . that emission ( called _ large - angle _ emission , lacking a better name )
was released at the same time as the emission from angles less than @xmath22 , but arrives later at observer because of the spherical curvature of the emitting surface and finite speed of light , and is less beamed relativistically .
as shown by @xcite , the large - angle emission is characterized by @xmath72 , @xmath73 , the power - law decay index being @xmath74 ( see also @xcite ) these are general results , arising only from relativistic effects , and independent of the emission process .
the only assumption made in its derivation is that the surface emissivity properties are angle - independent . before deceleration of the blast - wave begins , the shocked ambient medium moves at a constant @xmath75 , if the reverse shock is semi - relativistic , or is slowly decelerating as @xmath76 , if the reverse shock is relativistic . for a _ semi - relativistic
_ reverse shock , the spectral characteristics of the _ pre - deceleration _ forward - shock synchrotron emission evolve as @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 for a homogeneous medium , and @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 for a wind . for a
_ relativistic _
reverse shock , the above scalings become @xmath83 , @xmath84 , @xmath52 for @xmath85 , and @xmath53 , @xmath86 , @xmath55 for @xmath87 . the forward - shock synchrotron emission _
after deceleration _ has received the most attention ( e.g. @xcite ) . under the usual assumptions of constant blast - wave energy and micro - physical electron and magnetic field parameters , the forward - shock peak flux and spectral break frequencies evolution is @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 for a homogeneous medium , and @xmath91 , @xmath89 , @xmath92 for a wind . from here
, it follows that the flux below @xmath48 should rise slowly as @xmath93 for a homogeneous medium or be constant for a wind medium . for @xmath94 ,
the forward - shock flux decay is a power - law of index @xmath95 , with @xmath96 if ambient medium has a wind - like stratification ( as expected for a massive stellar long - grb progenitor ) and if @xmath97 , @xmath98 for a homogeneous medium ( which , surprisingly , is more often found to be compatible with the observed afterglows than a wind ) if @xmath97 , and @xmath99 if @xmath100 , for any type of medium .
all the above results hold for a spherical outflow or a collimated one before the jet boundary becomes visible to the observer . at the jet - break time @xmath101 ,
when deceleration lowers the jet lorentz factor to @xmath102 , the emission from the jet edge is no longer relativistically beamed away from the direction toward the observer . at @xmath103 , the lack of emitting fluid at angles larger than @xmath23 leads to a steepening of the afterglow decay by @xmath104 for a homogeneous medium and @xmath105 for a wind .
simultaneously , the lateral spreading of the jet becomes important and leads to a faster deceleration of the jet , which switches from a power - law in the blast - wave radius to an exponential @xcite , yielding an extra steepening of the afterglow decay of magnitude smaller or comparable to @xmath106 above .
together , these two _ jet effects _ lead to @xmath107 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 , rather independent of the ambient medium stratification , and a post jet - break forward - shock flux decay of index @xmath110 below @xmath48 , while for @xmath111 , one obtains @xmath112 below @xmath49 and @xmath113 above @xmath49 . & & & & + model & @xmath114&@xmath115&@xmath116&@xmath117&@xmath118 & @xmath114&@xmath115&@xmath116&@xmath117&@xmath118 + rs(1 ) & 1/5 & 1/15 & 1/5 & 3/5 & 3/5 & 1/9 & 5/9 & @xmath119 & 0 & @xmath120 + rs(2 ) & 0.3 & 0.3 & @xmath121 & & @xmath122 & 0.3 & 0.3 & @xmath123 & & @xmath122 + fs(1 ) & -3 & -11/3 & -3 & -2 & -2 & -1/3 & 1/3 & @xmath21 & -1/2 & @xmath124 + fs(2 ) & -1 & -19/15 & @xmath125 & -1/5 & @xmath126 & -1/9 & 5/9 & @xmath127 & 0 & @xmath128 + fs(3 ) & -1/2 & -1/6 & @xmath129 & 1/4 & @xmath130 & 0 & 2/3 & @xmath131 & 1/4 & @xmath132 +
@xcite were the first to predict the existence of radio afterglows following the burst phase . @xcite
have analyzed two models for the reverse shock emission and one for the forward shock , predicting long - lived optical afterglows with a flux decaying as a power of time .
the first detection of an afterglow and measurement of a power - law flux decay followed soon ( grb 970228 @xcite ) , with many other optical @xcite and x - ray afterglows @xcite having been observed until today . in general , the broadband ( radio , optical , x - ray ) emission of grb afterglows display the expected power - law spectra and light - curves , as well as other features , which , in chronological order of their _ prediction _ are : radio scintillation ( @xcite & @xcite ) , optical counterpart flashes ( @xcite & @xcite ) , jet - breaks ( @xcite & @xcite ) , dimmer afterglows for short bursts ( @xcite & @xcite ) .
grb afterglows display sufficient diversity ( e.g. wide luminosity distributions at all observing frequencies , non - universal shock micro - physical parameters ) and puzzling features ( slowly - decaying radio fluxes , x - ray light - curve plateaus , chromatic x - ray light - curve breaks ) to challenge the standard external - shock model and warrant various modifications .
below , i discuss some of these issues . according to the temporal scalings identified in the previous section
, the light - curves of grb afterglows should display rises in the early phase , if the forward - shock emission is dominant ( because the reverse - shock flux is most often expected to decay ) , followed by a decay , both being power - laws in time .
furthermore , the broadband afterglow spectra are expected to be rising at ( radio ) frequencies below the spectrum peak and fall - off at higher ( x - ray ) photon energies . also expected is that the light - curve decay indices @xmath20 and spectral slopes @xmath21 satisfy one or more closure relationships and that , there is a positive correlation between @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( from that @xmath133 $ ] ) .
figure [ aglows ] illustrates the flux power - law decays and power - law spectra typically observed for grb afterglows .
the light - curves chosen there display long - lived power - law decays , but many afterglows exhibit more diversity , their light - curves showing two or three power - law decays , sometimes even rising at earlier times , rarely exhibiting brightening episodes ( in optical or x - ray ) or sudden drops ( in x - ray ) .
the broadband spectrum of grb afterglow 030329 shown in figure [ aglows ] displays an optically thick part ( to self - absorption ) in the radio , at earlier times , a constant peak flux up to 10 days , during which the radio flux rises slowly , followed by a decreasing peak flux and decreasing radio flux . for @xmath60 , as required by the radio spectrum ( right panel ) , the rise of the radio flux , @xmath134 ( left panel ) , is consistent with that expected from a decelerating forward - shock interacting with a homogeneous medium ( @xmath135 ) , and marginally consistent with the forward - shock pre - deceleration emission for either a semi - relativistic reverse shock and wind medium ( @xmath136 ) or a relativistic reverse shock and homogeneous medium ( @xmath137 ) .
the evolution of spectral breaks is generally hard to determine observationally and use for identifying the correct afterglow model : self - absorption affects only the early radio emission , when the large flux fluctuations are caused by interstellar scintillation , while the cooling break is too shallow and evolves too slowly to be well measured even if it fell in the optical or x - ray bands .
the best prospects for this test is offered by the injection break , which should cross the radio domain at tens of days , when the scintillation amplitude is reduced by the larger source size .
sufficient radio coverage to construct radio afterglow spectra at many epochs and determine the peak frequency @xmath48 and flux @xmath47 is rarely achieved .
grb 030329 is one such case ( figure [ radiopk ] ) , the evolution of @xmath48 being slower than expected for a spherical blast - wave or a jet that does not expand ( yet or ever ) laterally ( for either , @xmath138 for any medium stratification ) , while that of @xmath47 is close to that expected for a jet spreading laterally ( for which @xmath107 ) .
thus , the evolutions of @xmath48 and @xmath47 for grb afterglow 030329 seem mutually inconsistent .
the slower - than - expected evolution of @xmath48 requires that shock micro - physical are not constant ( as assumed in the standard model ) , but the evolution of @xmath47 can be accounted for by a spherical blast - wave provided that the ambient medium density decreases as @xmath139 . rising optical light - curves have been seen for more than a dozen afterglows up to 1 ks after trigger ( figure [ rises ] ) .
if interpreted as the due to the pre - deceleration emission from the forward shock ( e.g. @xcite ) , they require smaller than average initial ejecta lorentz factors ( if the reverse shock is semi - relativistic ) or longer - lasting ejections .
the existence of energetic ejecta with a significantly smaller ejecta lorentz factor could also explain the late ( 12 d ) sharp rise displayed by the optical afterglow of grb 970508 ( figure [ aglows ] ) .
however , late - rising afterglows could also be due to a structured outflow endowed with two `` hot spots '' , one moving directly toward the observer and giving the prompt grb emission , and another one moving slightly off the direction toward the observer @xcite , at an angle @xmath140 , its emission becoming visible when the outflow lorentz factor decreases to @xmath141 .
the same result could be accomplished with an axially symmetric outflows having a bright core that yields the burst emission and a bright ring that produced the rising afterglow when it becomes visible .
thus , a late - rising afterglow may be a relativistic effect rather than the signature of some ejecta with a lower initial lorentz factor , either shock ( reverse or forward ) being a possible origin of the rising afterglow .
in fact , this model is found to account better for the peak luminosity
peak time anti - correlation exhibited by a dozen optical afterglows with early , fast rises than the pre - deceleration external - shock model @xcite , although it should be noted that only half of that correlation is real ( i.e. optical peaks do not occur later and are not brighter than a certain linear limit in log - log space ) while the other half is just an observational bias , as there are many optical afterglows exhibiting decaying fluxes from first measurement that fall below the peak flux peak time relation found for the fast - rising afterglows ( figure [ rises ] ) .
most afterglow observations were made during the decay phase , where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are expected to be correlated and satisfy one or more closure relationships .
the left panel of figure [ ab ] shows the temporal and spectral indices of optical and x - ray afterglows measured before the jet break and the expectations for the ( post - deceleration ) forward - shock model ( as it seems more likely that the reverse shock dominates the afterglow emission only until at most 1 ks ) .
surprisingly , no significant correlation can be seen between @xmath20 and @xmath21 , which may be taken either as indication that the standard forward - shock model does not account for the diversity of afterglows ( e.g. departures from its assumptions of constant shock parameters would be required to explain the decays below the `` s1 '' model , which are too slow ) or that more than one variant of it realized which , combined with a small baseline in @xmath20 and @xmath21 , requires a much larger sample to reveal the expected underlying correlation .
a bright optical emission arising from the reverse shock was predicted by @xcite and may have been observed for the first time in the optical counterpart ( i.e. during the burst ) accompanying grb 990123 @xcite and in the early afterglow emission following grb 021211 , but without any further candidates until recently . lacking a continuous , long - lived injection of new ejecta , and because of the adiabatic cooling , the reverse - shock emission should be confined to the early afterglow .
then , the early afterglow emissions of grb 990123 and 021211 being brighter than the extrapolation of the later flux and decaying faster are two reasons for attributing those two early optical emissions to the reverse shock . the larger brightness ( by 2.5 mag for 990123 and by 1 mag for 021211 ) could be explained by that the number of ejecta electrons is , at deceleration ( i.e. around burst end ) , larger by a factor @xmath142 than in the forward shock , and by a smaller factor at later times ( as for 021211 ) , with some relative dimming of the reverse shock optical flux attributed to the peak of the reverse - shock synchrotron spectrum being lower than that of the forward shock . however , both the above reasons disappear if the origin of time is not at trigger but sometime later , e.g. at 3040 s ( corresponding to the peak of grb 990123 optical flash )
. then , the early optical emission appears as a small deviation of the extrapolation of the late flux and the entire afterglow light - curve is consistent with a single power - law , indicating a unique dissipation mechanism .
thus , absent spectral information , the evidence for a reverse shock origin of the early optical emissions of grb 990123 and 021211 is circumstantial .
such spectral information has been acquired only recently , for the early optical emission of grb afterglows 061126 and 080319b .
for the former , @xcite finds that the steeper - decaying early ( up to 200 s ) optical emission is harder than at later times ( after 1 ks ) .
the indices @xmath143 and @xmath144 of the early optical emission of grb 061126 are consistent with the closure relation expected for adiabatic cooling ejecta .
the spectral evolution observed simultaneously with the slowing of light - curve decay suggests the emergence of a different component after 1 ks .
the optical afterglow of grb 080319b also displayed a spectral hardening simultaneous with the reduction in the flux decay rate @xcite , supporting a reverse - shock origin of the early fast - decay phase and forward - shock origin of the later slower - decaying emission .
however , the decay at early times is too fast ( for the measured spectral slope ) to be attributed to the adiabatic cooling of ejecta .
in fact , the decay index @xmath145 is consistent with the expectations for the large - angle emission released during the burst .
however , that does not exclude a reverse - shock origin of the early optical flux , as the cooling frequency may have fallen below the optical , revealing the large - angle emission . the slow softening of the optical spectrum of grb afterglow 080319b after 1 ks was a surprise .
if the rather flat ( @xmath146 ) spectral slope at 1 ks were due to the peak energy of the forward - shock synchrotron spectrum being in the optical , then a much faster softening is expected , given that the injection frequency evolution @xmath89 is also fast .
energy injection in the blast - wave or an increasing electron / magnetic shock parameters could account for slow decrease of @xmath48 required by the slow spectral softening of grb 080319b afterglow optical emission .
a tight collimation of grb ejecta , into a jet of half - aperture less than 10 degrees , is desirable to reduce the isotropic - equivalent grb output , reaching @xmath147 erg , to lower values , below @xmath148 erg , compatible with what the mechanisms for production of relativistic jets by solar - mass black - holes can yield .
besides the @xmath149 closure relationship being satisfied self - consistently ( i.e. by a forward - shock model with same features before and after the jet - break ) , _ achromaticity _ of the break ( i.e. simultaneous occurrence at all frequencies ) is an essential test of this model .
the steepening of the afterglow flux decay due to collimation of ejecta was predicted by @xcite and was observed for the first time in the optical emission of grb afterglow 990123 @xcite .
about 3/4 of well - monitored pre - swift optical afterglows displayed jet - breaks at 0.53 day , as shown in the compilation of @xcite .
the x - ray coverage of pre - swift afterglow extended over at most 1 decade in time and was insufficient to test for the existence of an x - ray light - curve break simultaneous with that seen in the optical . a smaller fraction
, between 1/3 and 2/3 , of swift x - ray afterglows also exhibit jet - breaks @xcite , defined as a steepening occurring after 0.1 day from a power - law decay with @xmath150 to one with @xmath151 . comparing the post jet - break temporal and spectral indices with the expectations for the forward - shock model ( right panel of figure [ ab ] ) shows that that model accounts for observations of post jet - break decays if jets are both both spreading and conical .
however , just as for pre jet - break decays , the expected @xmath149 correlation is not seen . while there are many examples of potential jet - breaks in the x - ray light - curve monitored by swift , few are sufficiently well - monitored in the optical to test for the achromaticity of the break .
figure [ jets ] shows the only 3 afterglows sufficiently sampled and followed sufficiently late to search for achromatic light - curve breaks . besides the simultaneity of the optical and light - curve breaks , note the equality of the pre and post - break decay indices
. the smaller fraction of swift x - ray afterglows that exhibit jet - breaks , relative to that of pre - swift such optical afterglows , could be due to swift detecting and localizing afterglows that are fainter than those followed in the optical prior to swift .
the argument here is that , if all jets had the same energy ( e.g. @xcite ) , then the afterglow flux and jet - break time should be anti - correlated : @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( for a wind - like medium ) , leading to @xmath154 , where @xmath155 is the forward - shock s kinetic energy per solid angle , thus dimmer afterglows should display later jet - breaks .
as shown in figure [ ox ] , the afterglows with jet - breaks at 0.310 days are brighter by a factor @xmath0 than those without jet - breaks detected until 10 days , thus the anti - correlation between afterglow flux and jet - break time expected for a universal jet energy is confirmed , even though jet energies inferred from the timing of afterglow light - curve breaks have a broad distribution ( e.g. @xcite ) . that ratio of 10 between the average brightness of afterglows with breaks and of those without breaks until 10 days and the above - derived @xmath154 imply that the latter type of afterglows should display a break at 3100 days , which could be missed if monitoring does not extend for sufficiently long times . for this reason
, some of the dimmer x - ray afterglows detected by swift may have breaks that are too late to be observed , leading to an apparent paucity of swift x - ray afterglows with jet - breaks , as noted by @xcite .
the long - time monitoring of radio afterglows showed that often there is an incompatibility between the radio and optical flux decays .
after the peak of the forward - shock synchrotron spectrum falls below the radio domain , which should happen within @xmath0 days and is , indeed , observed in the radio spectra of grb afterglows 970508 @xcite , 021004 , and 030329 ( figure [ radiopk ] ) , the radio and optical flux decays are expected to be similar , up to a difference @xmath156 that could occur if the cooling break is in between radio and optical and if the jet is not laterally spreading . in a set of nine pre - swift afterglows with long temporal coverage at both frequencies , i find that the above expectation is met by only four : grb afterglows 980703 , 970508 , 000418 , and 021004 , but that the radio flux of grb afterglows 991208 , 991216 , 000301c , 000926 , and 010222 decay much slower than in the optical , with @xmath157 , respectively @xcite ( see also @xcite ) .
for all the above three cases for which the optical and radio decays are well - coupled , the decays are slower than @xmath158 , indicating a wide jet , while for all the five cases of decoupled radio and optical decays , the optical displays a decay steeper than @xmath158 after a @xmath159 day break that could be interpreted as a jet - break .
thus , whenever the optical flux decays fast , there seems to be a mechanism which produces radio emission in excess of that expected for the forward - shock model .
an example of each type of radio afterglow is shown in figure [ or ] .
because the slow radio flux decay is observed _ at the same time _ as the faster optical decay , the decoupling of radio and optical light - curves can not be attributed to energy injection in the blast - wave , to a structured outflow , or to evolving micro - physical parameters ( mechanisms which have also been used to explain the slow early decays seen in swift x - ray afterglow plateaus ) , nor to the transition to non - relativistic dynamics . instead
, the decoupled radio and optical light - curve decays may indicate that these emissions arise from different parts of the relativistic outflow .
that could happen if the outflow endowed with angular structure ( in the sense that its kinetic energy per solid angle is anisotropic ) , with a core that dominates the optical emission , yielding the jet - break , and an outer , wider envelope that produces the radio emission .
the problem with this model @xcite is that , optical and radio afterglows being long - lived , the spectral break frequencies of the core and envelope emissions evolve substantially , making it impossible for their emissions to be dominant over such long timescales at only one frequency , i.e. without `` interfering '' with the emission of the other part of the outflow .
shortly put , it is quite likely that the emission from the radio envelope would soon dominate the optical emission from the core and change the initially steep optical flux decay into a slower one .
( while that is a general issue for explaining decoupled afterglow light - curves with a structured outflow , @xcite shows that it can be avoided for grb 080319b , whose optical and x - ray light - curve decays are decoupled for until 1 day ) .
another possibility is that the optical emission arises in the forward shock while the radio is from the reverse shock . for adiabatic cooling ,
the ejecta emission should decay slowly , even when observations are at a frequency below that of the spectral peak , thus a reverse shock energizing the ejecta is required to account for the flat or slowly rising part of radio light - curves ( up to about 10 days ) . in this case , the light - curve decay depends on the law governing the injection of fresh ejecta into the reverse shock , the observed radio light - curve indices being close to the closure relations derived in the previous section for a uniform radial distribution of the incoming ejecta mass . in the reverse - forward shock model for afterglows with different radio and optical light - curve decays ,
the cross - interference issue may also exist , as the forward - shock synchrotron peak flux , being larger than @xmath160 mjy at 1 day ( to account for the @xmath161 20 magnitude optical flux ) , could over - shine the reverse - shock radio emission at some later time , when the peak energy of the forward - shock emission spectrum reaches the radio domain .
this issue is best addressed with numerical calculations of the blast - wave dynamics and radiation . in this way
, i found @xcite that the most likely solution for the decoupled radio and optical light - curves is that the radio afterglow emission is dominated by the reverse shock during the first decade in time , with the forward - shock emission peaking in the radio at about 100 days , overtaking that from the reverse shock sometime during the second decade . by itself , each component would display a decay faster than observed , but their sum resembles a shallow power - law over two decades in time .
the swift satellite has opened a new temporal window for observations of x - ray afterglows , which previously were monitored by bsax only after 8 hours after trigger . the major surprise ( i.e. a feature not predicted ) in swift observations was that , although it appeared that the x - ray afterglow emission at hours and days extrapolated back to the burst time would match the grb flux , implying a smooth transition from counterpart to afterglow emission , the x - ray flux from burst end to several hours is much less than that back - extrapolation , displaying at 0.310 ks a phase of slow decay , with @xmath162 .
in fact , that should have been a partial surprise because bsax has observed a sharply decaying grb tail in at least three cases , indicating that a phase of slow x - ray decay must exist at the burst end .
figure [ 0315 ] illustrates the `` plateau '' phase observed for grb afterglow 050315 . in the simplest form of the blast - wave model ,
the magnitude of the light - curve decay steepening at the end of the plateau requires the peak of the synchrotron spectrum to fall below the x - ray band at the end of the plateau .
however , that explanation is ruled out by that , observationally , the plateau end is most often not accompanied by the a spectral evolution @xcite , although exceptions exist @xcite . because the plateau phase is followed by a `` normal '' decay , compatible with the expectations of the standard forward - shock model , it is natural to think that departures from the assumptions of that standard model are the cause of x - ray plateaus : ( 1 ) increase of the average energy per solid angle of the blast - wave area visible to the observer by means of ( 1a ) energy injection in the blast - wave owing to some late ejecta catching - up with the forward - shock @xcite , or by absorbing low - frequency electromagnetic radiation from a millisecond pulsar @xcite , ( 1b ) an anisotropic outflow @xcite , ( 2 ) evolving shock micro - physical parameters @xcite , and ( 3 ) blast - wave interacting with an `` altered '' ambient medium , shaped by a grb precursor @xcite . the effect on the afterglow flux decay of the above mechanisms for a variable `` apparent '' kinetic energy of the blast - wave
were first investigated by @xcite , the x - ray plateaus discovered by swift several years later providing the first tentative confirmation that those mechanisms may be at work .
however , the discovery of _ chromatic _ light - curve breaks at the end of the x - ray plateau @xcite , which are not seen in the optical as well , soon showed that neither of the above mechanisms for x - ray plateaus provide a complete picture of the afterglow phenomenon , as in all those models the break should be _ achromatic _ , manifested at all frequencies .
evolution of shock parameters for electron and magnetic field energies could `` iron out '' the optical light - curve break produced by the other mechanisms listed above , provided that the cooling frequency is between optical and x - ray ( to allow a way of decoupling the optical and x - ray light - curves ) , however there is no reason for their evolution to conspire and hide the optical light - curve break so often ( universality of the required micro - physical parameter evolutions with blast - wave lorentz factor would provide some support to this contrived model ) . to date
, i find that there are 11 good cases of chromatic x - ray breaks , 6 good cases of achromatic breaks , and 3 afterglows displaying well - coupled optical and x - ray light - curves : a single power - law decay , of same decay index at both frequencies , extending over over three decades in time .
figure [ xbr ] shows two examples of achromatic breaks , one with discrepant post - break optical and x - ray decay indices , and one chromatic x - ray break . to explain
the chromatic x - ray breaks , @xcite and @xcite have proposed that the _ entire _ afterglow emission is produced by the reverse shock and have shown that , by placing either the injection or the cooling frequency between optical and x - ray , decoupled light - curves can be obtained . just as energy injection in the blast - wave , this mechanism relies on the existence of a long - lived central engine that expels ejecta until the last afterglow measurement ( the existence of a reverse shock at days is also required by the slow decays seen in a couple of radio afterglows ) . on the other hand
, the transition observed in two optical afterglows from a fast - decaying phase to one of slower decay at 1 ks , accompanied by spectral evolution , argue in favour of the reverse - shock emission being dominant only up to 1 ks , after which it seems more natural to attribute the afterglow emission to the forward - shock .
furthermore , the results shown by @xcite show a softening of the reverse - shock optical spectrum at the transition from fast to slow decay , which is in contradiction with the hardening observed in grb afterglows 061126 and 080319b .
thus , the reverse - shock model may not provide a correct description of the entire afterglow emission .
on average , the x - ray to optical flux ratio is larger for afterglows with chromatic x - ray breaks than for afterglows with coupled optical and x - ray light - curves ( i.e. with achromatic breaks or single power - law decays ) , as shown in figure [ fxfo ] .
this indicates that chromatic x - ray breaks are due to a mechanism whose emission over - shines an underlying one only in the x - rays , but not in the optical .
thus , it seems that the diversity of optical vs. x - ray light - curve behaviours should be attributed to the existence of two mechanisms for afterglow emission and not to a unique origin .
so far , three proposals along that line have been put forth : dust - scattering of the blast - wave emission , bulk and inverse - compton scattering of the same emission , and a central - engine mechanism that could be the same internal shocks in a variable wind that are believed to produce the prompt burst emission @xcite .
@xcite have proposed that x - ray plateaus result from scattering by dust in the host galaxy , much like the expanding rings produced by dust - scattering in our galaxy in grb afterglows 031203 @xcite and 050713a @xcite .
however , for dust - scattering , harder photons are those scattered at a smaller angle , thus they arrive earlier at observer , leading to a strong spectral softening of the x - ray light - curve plateau , of @xmath163 , and to a strong dependence of the plateau duration on the photon energy , @xmath164 , both of which are clearly refuted by afterglow observations @xcite .
@xcite have proposed that , in some afterglows , the `` central engine '' makes a substantial contribution to the afterglow x - ray flux .
this model requires a central engine that operates until the last afterglow detection ; the dissipation mechanism may be shocks in a variable outflow , which can also account for the bright and short - lived flares observed in many swift x - ray afterglows ( e.g. @xcite ) . given that the forward - shock model with cessation of energy injection at the plateau end can explain the achromatic breaks and that the standard forward - shock model accounts for the coupled single power - law light - curves , it would be more desirable to identify a mechanism for producing decoupled x - ray and optical light - curves that is related to the forward shock and which dominates its emission only occasionally .
bulk and inverse - compton scattering of the forward - shock photons by an outflow interior to the blast - wave is such a mechanism . in this model @xcite ,
all the afterglow emission originates in the forward shock , which explains so naturally the long - lived , power - law decay of grb afterglows , coupled optical and x - ray light - curves resulting when the scattered emission is dimmer than the forward - shock s , while chromatic x - ray light - curve breaks occur when the scattered emission is dominant in the x - ray . for this model to work , the scattering outflow must be almost purely leptonic , to ensure a sufficiently high ( sub - unity ) optical depth to electron scattering to account for the observed x - ray flux , assuming that the kinetic energy of the scattering outflow is not much larger than that of the forward shock .
the same outflow also injects energy into the blast - wave and , if that energy is larger than the forward shock s , then it mitigates the blast - wave deceleration , producing a light - curve plateau ending with an achromatic break when the injected energy falls below that of the forward shock and stops being dynamically important .
therefore , a delayed outflow is the origin of both chromatic and achromatic light - curve breaks , the former occurring when the scattered emission is dominant , while the latter happening when the forward - shock emission is dominant .
still , the achromatic break of grb 050730 ( figure [ xbr ] ) , followed by an x - ray flux decay much steeper than that of the optical can not be explained with only cessation of energy injection at the time of the break , and requires an extra feature , that the shock micro - physical parameters are not constant .
the above scattering model also explains late x - ray flares , which arise from dense or hot ( i.e. with relativistic electrons ) sheets within the outflow . when dominant , the scattered x - ray emission received at time @xmath9 reflects the properties ( density , lorentz factor ) of the outflow at @xmath165 behind the forward shock , sharp drops of the x - ray flux as that observed for grb afterglow 070110 at 30 ks being due to a gap in the scattering outflow . for an instantaneous release of all the ejecta , the kinematics of outflow radial - spreading owing to different initial lorentz factors , followed by deceleration of the forward - shock , leads to that , when the ejecta of lorentz factor @xmath166 catch up with the forward shock , moving at @xmath167 , the lorentz factor contrast is @xmath168 ( i.e. 2 for a homogeneous medium and @xmath169 for a wind ) .
that ratio is too small for bulk - scattering to boost enough the forward - shock emission to dominate that arriving directly from the forward shock .
but , if the scattering outflow was energized by internal shocks , inverse - compton scatterings by relativistic electrons ( of comoving frame energy @xmath170 ) can achieve that goal .
in fact the properties of the scattered emission depend only on the product @xmath171 .
thus , for a sudden release of ejecta to lead to a sufficiently bright scattered emission , the scattering outflow should be hot .
alternately , if the scattering outflow is cold , then the larger ratio @xmath172 necessary for the scattered flux to over - shine that from the forward shock requires a long - lived engine . as a general test of all models that explain
decoupled optical and x - ray afterglows by attributing them to different mechanisms , there should not be any afterglows whose optical and x - ray light - curves evolve from decoupled ( i.e. with a chromatic break ) to coupled ( i.e. with an achromatic break ) , or vice - versa , unless one of the light - curves displays a sudden flux or spectral change that would indicate a second mechanism becoming dominant .
so far , i find only two cases of afterglows whose optical and x - ray light - curves evolve from decoupled to coupled ( grb afterglows 070110 and 080319b ) , but their x - ray light - curves display , indeed , a sharp drop ( at 20 ks , in both cases ) .
the temporal and spectral properties of grb afterglows are , in general , consistent with those predicted for the synchrotron emission from the blast - wave produced when highly relativistic ejecta ( initial lorentz factor above 100 ) interact with the ambient medium . as expected from shocks accelerating particles with a power - law distribution with energy , power - laws
are observed in the optical and x - ray afterglow continua .
a spectral softening ( i.e. decrease of peak frequency ) is expected owing to the blast - wave deceleration and is observed in radio afterglows spectra and in the behaviour of afterglow radio light - curves , which rise slowly until the synchrotron spectrum peak reaches the radio domain and fall - off afterward .
rising afterglow light - curves are seen at early times in the optical , and are consistent with the pre - deceleration emission from the forward shock , although a structured outflow with a hot - spot that gradually becomes visible to the observer is also possible , in which case the rising afterglow emission could also be explained with the reverse shock .
much more often , afterglow light - curves display power - law decays of indices that are not correlated with the spectral slopes , as would be expected for the external - shock model . that inconsistency could be due to a substantial intrinsic scatter in decay indices and spectral slopes , owing to more than one variant of the blast - wave model occurring in grb afterglows , combined with a small range of those indices being realized .
bright optical flashes accompanying the burst emission were predicted to arise from the reverse shock , owing to the larger number of ejecta electrons than in the forward shock .
fast - falling optical light - curves have been observed at 1001000s in two afterglows ( 991023 and 021211 ) , followed by a slower of the decay , which was taken as evidence for the reverse - shock emission dominating the early afterglow , although spectral information was not available to test that hypothesis .
more recently , the early optical spectral slopes were measured for two afterglows ( 061126 and 080319b ) , the decay of the former being consistent with that from adiabatically - cooling ejecta , while the later is faster than expected and consistent with it being the large - angle emission released at an earlier time . for the above two optical afterglows with spectral information at early times , the slowing of the optical flux decay at 1 ks is accompanied by a spectral evolution , which indicates the transition from one mechanism to another .
most naturally , that is the transition from ejecta emission to forward - shock emission , with the reverse - shock emission being relevant for the optical afterglow only during its early phase .
evidence for a reverse - shock emission is also provided by the slow radio flux decays observed after 10 day in several afterglows .
adiabatically cooling ejecta would yield a decay faster than observed , particularly if the synchrotron cooling frequency were to fall below the radio , thus a reverse - shock accelerating ejecta electrons is required to operate for days and produce a radio emission decaying much slower than the optical at the same time , the latter being attributed to the forward shock .
together with the above conclusion regarding the contribution of the reverse shock to the early optical afterglow , this suggests that the reverse shock is the main afterglow source for a duration that decreases with observing frequency , perhaps never being dominant in the x - rays and having no connection with the chromatic x - ray light - curve breaks seen at @xmath0 ks in most afterglows . that the x - ray - to - optical flux - ratio is larger ( by a factor 5 ) for afterglows with chromatic x - ray light - curve breaks than for those with coupled optical and x - ray light - curves ( i.e. with achromatic breaks or similar power - law decays ) , indicates the existence of a different mechanism producing the x - ray emission of afterglows with chromatic x - ray breaks , coupled light - curves resulting when the emission from that novel mechanism is negligible .
long - lived internal shocks or scattering of the blast - wave emission by an outflow located behind it are two possibilities that could explain chromatic x - ray breaks , as well as the flares seen in many x - ray light - curves . the latter mechanism is also related to energy injection in the blast - wave , whose cessation accounts naturally for achromatic light - curve breaks .
thus , in the scattering model , the diversity of optical and x - ray light - curve relative behaviours is attributed to the interplay between the scattered and direct blast - wave emissions , combined with the changing dynamics of the blast - wave produced when the scattering outflow brings into the shock more energy than already existing . on energetic grounds
, grb outflows should be collimated into jets narrower than 10 degrees .
the steepening of the afterglow flux decay when the jet boundary becomes visible to the observer was another major prediction confirmed by observations .
just as for the pre jet - break phase , more than one jet model is required to account for the measured decay indices ( given the observed spectral slopes ) .
swift x - ray afterglows display light - curve jet - breaks less often than pre - swift optical afterglows , which could be due to that the former afterglows ( being dimmer ) arise from wider jets whose jet - breaks occur later and could , thus , be missed more often . | + i discuss some theoretical expectations for the synchrotron emission from a relativistic blast - wave interacting with the ambient medium , as a model for grb afterglows , and compare them with observations . an afterglow flux evolving as a power - law in time , a bright optical flash during and after the burst , and light - curve breaks owing to a tight ejecta collimation are the major predictions that were confirmed observationally , but it should be recognized that light - curve decay indices are not correlated with the spectral slopes ( as would be expected ) , optical flashes are quite rare , and jet - breaks harder to find in swift x - ray afterglows . the slowing of the early optical flux decay rate is accompanied by a spectral evolution , indicating that the emission from ejecta ( energized by the reverse shock ) is dominant in the optical over that from the forward shock ( which energizes the ambient medium ) only up to 1 ks .
however , a long - lived reverse shock is required to account for the slow radio flux decays observed in many afterglows after @xmath0 day .
x - ray light - curve plateaus could be due to variations in the average energy - per - solid - angle of the blast - wave , confirming to two other anticipated features of grb outflows : energy injection and angular structure .
the latter is also the more likely origin of the fast - rises seen in some optical light - curves . to account for the existence of both chromatic and achromatic afterglow light - curve breaks
, the overall picture must be even more complex and include a new mechanism that dominates occasionally the emission from the blast - wave : either late internal shocks or scattering ( bulk and/or inverse - compton ) of the blast - wave emission by an outflow interior to it .
address= isr-1 , los alamos national laboratory , los alamos , nm 87545 , usa |
when monte carlo methods are used to compute the spectra of astronomical sources , it is advantageous to work with _ indivisible _ monochromatic packets of radiant energy and to impose the constraint that , when interacting with matter , their energy is conserved in the co - moving frame .
the first of these constraints leads to simple code and the second facilitates convergence to an accurate temperature stratification . for a static atmosphere
, the energy - conservation constraint automatically gives a divergence - free radiative flux even when the temperature stratification differs from the radiative equilibrium solution .
a remarkable consequence is that the simple @xmath0-iteration device of adjusting the temperature to bring the matter into thermal equilibrium with the monte carlo radiation field results in rapid convergence to the close neighbourhood of the radiative equilibrium solution ( lucy 1999a ) .
an especially notable aspect of this success is that this temperature - correction procedure is geometry - independent , and so these methods readily generalize to 2- and 3-d problems . for an atmosphere in differential motion , the energy - conservation constraint yields a radiative flux that is rigorously divergence - free in every local matter frame .
determining the temperature stratification by bringing matter into thermal equilibrium with such a radiation field - i.e. , by imposing radiative equilibrium in the co - moving frame - is an excellent approximation if the local cooling time scale is short compared to the local expansion time scale .
this condition is well satisfied for the spectrum - forming layers of supernovae ( sne ) and of hot star winds ( klein & castor 1978 ) .
the constraint that the energy packets be indivisible is advantageous from the point of view of coding simplicity .
the interaction histories of the packets are then followed one - by - one as they propagate through the computational domain , with there being no necessity to return to any of a packet s interactions in order to continue or complete that interaction .
this is to be contrasted with a monte carlo code that directly simulates physical processes by taking its quanta to be a sampling of the individual photons .
absorption of a monte carlo quantum is then often followed by the emission of several quanta as an atom cascades back to its ground state .
multiple returns to this interaction are then necessary in order to follow the subsequent paths of each of these cascade quanta .
the resulting coding complexity is of course compounded by some of these quanta creating further cascades .
although coding simplicity argues strongly for indivisible packets , a counter argument is the apparent implied need to approximate the treatment of line formation .
thus , in monte carlo codes for studying the dynamics of stellar winds ( abbott & lucy 1985 ; lucy & abbott 1993 ) or for synthesizing the spectra of sne ( lucy 1987 ; mazzali & lucy 1993 ) , the integrity of the packets could readily be maintained since lines were assumed to form by coherent scattering in the matter frame . but significantly , an improved sn code has recently been described ( lucy 1999b ) in which branching into the alternative downward transitions is properly taken into account without sacrificing indivisibility .
accordingly , an obvious question now is whether monte carlo techniques can be developed that enforce energy - packet indivisibility and yet do not have to adopt _ any _ simplifications with regard to line formation .
if this can be achieved , then monte carlo codes for general nlte transfer problems become feasible .
as discussed in sect .
1 , it is common in monte carlo transfer codes to quantize radiation into monochromatic energy packets .
but matter is not quantized , neither naturally into individual atoms nor artificially into parcels of matter .
instead , the continuum description of matter is retained , with macroscopic absorption and scattering coefficients governing the interaction histories of the energy packets . nevertheless , it now proves useful to imagine that matter is quantized into _ macro - atoms _ whose properties are such that their interactions with energy packets asymptotically reproduce the emissivity of a gas in statistical equilibrium . but
these macro - atoms , unlike energy packets , do not explicitly appear in the monte carlo code .
as conceptual constructs , they facilitate the derivation and implementation of the monte carlo transition probabilities that allow in an accurate treatment of line formation .
the general properties of macro - atoms are as follows : \1 ) each macro - atom has discrete internal states in one - to - one correspondence with the energy levels of the atomic species being represented .
\2 ) an inactive macro - atom can be activated to one of its internal states @xmath1 by absorbing a packet of kinetic energy or a packet of radiant energy of an appropriate co - moving frequency .
\3 ) an active macro - atom can undergo an internal transition from state @xmath1 to any other state @xmath2 without absorbing or emitting an energy packet .
\4 ) an active macro - atom becomes inactive by emitting a packet of kinetic energy or a packet of radiant energy of an appropriate co - moving frequency .
\5 ) the de - activating packet has the same energy in the macro - atom s frame as the original activating packet .
figure 1 illustrates these general rules .
an inactive macro - atom , with internal states shown schematically , encounters a packet of energy @xmath3 and is activated to one of these states .
the active macro - atom then undergoes two internal transitions before de - activating itself by emitting a packet of energy @xmath3 .
subsequently , energy packets will in general be referred to as @xmath4-packets but also as @xmath5- or @xmath6-packets when specifying their contents to be radiant or kinetic energy , respectively .
2 , the concept of a macro - atom was introduced by stating some general properties concerning its interaction with @xmath4-packets .
the challenge now is to derive explicit rules governing a macro - atom s activation , its subsequent internal transitions , and its eventual de - activation .
asymptotically , the result of obeying these rules must be the emissivity corresponding to statistical equilibrium . for the moment , we drop the notion of a macro - atom and consider a real atomic species interacting with its environment .
let @xmath7 denote the excitation _ plus _ ionization energy of level @xmath1 and let @xmath8 denote the radiative rate for the transition @xmath9 .
the rates per unit volume at which transitions into and out of @xmath1 absorb and emit radiant energy are then @xmath10 respectively , where @xmath11 .
note the summation convention adopted for the suffix @xmath12 , which ranges over all levels @xmath13 , including those of lower ions .
similarly , below , the suffix @xmath14 implies summation over all levels @xmath15 , including those of higher ions . the corresponding rates at which kinetic energy is absorbed from , or contributed to , the thermal pool by transitions to and from level @xmath1 are @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the collisional rate per unit volume for the transition @xmath9 .
if we now define the total rate for the transition @xmath9 to be @xmath18 , then the net rate at which level @xmath1 absorbs energy is @xmath19 this is an identity that follows directly from the defining eqs.(1 ) and ( 2 ) ; it is therefore quite general and does not assume statistical equilibrium .
we now assume that the level populations @xmath20 are in statistical equilibrium . for level @xmath1 , this implies that @xmath21 a useful alternative representation of statistical equilibrium is obtained by multiplying eq.(4 ) by @xmath7 and then eliminating the term @xmath22 using eq.(3 ) .
the result can be written in the form @xmath23 eq.(4 ) , the conventional equation of statistical equilibrium , balances the rates at which basic atomic processes excite and de - excite level @xmath1 . as such , it directly relates to nature s quantization of radiation into photons and of matter into atoms .
in contrast ,
eq.(5 ) , though mathematically equivalent , deals with macroscopic energy flow rates in a finite volume element .
these flows can now be quantized into indivisible @xmath4-packets .
moreover , we can think of the volume element as a macro - atom with discrete energy states .
eq.(5 ) expresses the fact that in statistical equilibrium the contribution from level @xmath1 to the energy content of unit volume is stationary . in consequence ,
the net rate at which level @xmath1 gains energy - the right - hand side of eq.(5 ) - equals the net rate of loss - the left - hand side .
but the importance here of eq.(5 ) lies in the various terms contributing to gains and losses by level @xmath1 and their relevance for constucting transition rules for macro - atoms
. the net rate of gain comprises the expected absorption terms @xmath24 and @xmath25 plus the terms @xmath26 and @xmath27 that clearly represent energy flows into @xmath1 from upper and lower levels .
similarly , the net rate of loss comprises the expected emission terms @xmath28 and @xmath29 plus the terms @xmath30 and @xmath31 representing energy flows out of @xmath1 to upper and lower levels .
the above remarks imply definitive values for the energy flows between level @xmath1 and other levels . but
this is not true .
if eq.(4 ) is rewritten as @xmath32 then comparison with eq.(5 ) shows immediately that an arbitrary quantity of energy @xmath33 may be added to @xmath7 and @xmath34 without invalidating this equation .
but this merely shifts the zero point of the energy scale for excitation and ionization , which we are always free to do .
nevertheless , this freedom implies a corresponding indefiniteness in the energy flow rates between levels . notwithstanding this indefiniteness , we now interpret eq.(5 ) in terms of macro - atoms absorbing and emitting @xmath4-packets or undergoing transitions between internal states . in this interpretation , the terms @xmath24 and
@xmath25 obviously represent the activation of macro - atoms to state @xmath1 due to the absorption of @xmath5-packets and of @xmath6-packets , respectively . now consider an ensemble of active macro - atoms in state @xmath1 .
for this ensemble to reproduce the behaviour of the real system , the relative numbers of the macro - atoms that subsequently de - activate with the emission an @xmath5- or @xmath6-packet or which make a transition to another internal state must be proportional to the relative values of the corresponding terms on the left - hand side of eq.(5 ) . accordingly , for an individual macro - atom in state @xmath1 , the probabilities that it de - activates with the emission of an @xmath5-packet or a @xmath6-packet are @xmath35 where @xmath36 similarly , the probabilities that it makes an internal transition to _ particular _ upper or lower states are @xmath37 unlike transition probabilities for real atoms , these analogues for macro - atoms depend on ambient conditions . consequently , in the course of a nlte calculation , they are iterated on just as are eddington factors in various other radiative tranfer schemes ( auer & mihalas 1970 ; hummer & rybicki 1971 ) .
moreover , as with eddington factors , the monte carlo transition probabilities are dimensionless ratios that are likely to converge faster than do their dimensional numerators and denominators . when eq.(5 ) is summed over all energy levels , the energy flows between different levels cancel , giving @xmath38 thus , in statistical equilibrium , the energy stored in the form of excitation and ionization is stationary . for the macro - atoms ,
this is obeyed rigorously by each activation - de - activation event since the emitted packet s energy equals that of the absorbed packet - see figure 1 .
monte carlo transition probabilities have been defined in sect . 3 , but their non - negativity was not established . of concern in this regard
is stimulated emission when level populations are inverted .
however , in anticipation of this issue , radiative rates were introduced without specifying whether stimulated emission contributes positively to @xmath8 or negatively to @xmath39 .
we now exploit this flexibility in order to avoid negative probabilities . in the general case
, inverted level populations may occur - i.e. , @xmath40 for some @xmath41 . in order to prevent the probabilities becoming negative when levels invert
, stimulated emissions must be added to spontaneous emissions and _ not _ treated as negative absorptions .
accordingly , for bound - bound ( b - b ) transitions , the radiative rates per unit volume are defined to be @xmath42 where @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the mean intensities averaged over the line s emission and absorption profiles - see mihalas ( 1978 , p78 ) .
similarly , for free - bound ( f - b ) and bound - free ( b - f ) transitions , we define @xmath45 here @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the rate coefficients for spontaneous and stimulated recombinations to level @xmath1 , and @xmath48 is the uncorrected rate coefficient for photoionizations from level @xmath1 . each of these three quantities can be expressed as an integral over frequency involving the b - f absorption coefficient for an atom excited to level @xmath1 - see mihalas ( 1978 , pp130 - 131 ) .
for collisions , a population inversion gives a negative rate if de - excitations are treated as negative excitations .
this is avoided by defining @xmath49 with these expressions for the radiative and collisional rates , the probabilities defined by eqs.(7 ) and ( 9 ) are non - negative provided only that the @xmath7 s are non - negative .
this latter condition is satisfied with the standard convention that the ground state of the neutral atom has zero excitation energy . because @xmath50 and therefore @xmath24 are here defined without correcting for stimulated emission , the macroscopic line- and continuum - absorption coefficients that determine the flight paths of @xmath5-packets
must also be defined without this correction .
this ensures a positive absorption coefficient even for a transition with a population inversion .
if the monte carlo transition probabilities result in a macro - atom de - activating radiatively from state @xmath1 , the next step is to determine the frequency of the photons comprising the emitted @xmath5-packet .
first we suppose that @xmath1 corresponds to a bound level . because @xmath51 and therefore @xmath28 here include stimulated emission , the process that radiatively de - activates the macro - atom may be either a spontaneous or a stimulated emission .
the ratio of the probabilities of these alternatives is @xmath52 , where @xmath53 are the contributions to @xmath54 from spontaneous and stimulated emissions .
knowing @xmath55 , we can choose between the two alternatives with a standard monte carlo procedure .
thus , if @xmath56 is a random number from the interval @xmath57 , we select spontaneous emission if @xmath58 and stimulated otherwise .
having thus decided the emission process , we must next choose a downward transition .
for spontaneous line emission , the transition @xmath9 is selected with probability @xmath59 . for stimulated emission , on the other hand , the selection probability is @xmath60 .
with the transition thus determined , the frequency @xmath61 of the @xmath5-packet is selected by randomly sampling the line s emission profile @xmath62 .
thus , if @xmath56 again denotes a random number from @xmath57 , then @xmath61 is determined by the equation @xmath63 this equation can of course always be solved numerically for @xmath61 . however ,
elegant and efficient procedures for sampling standard profiles are available ( lee 1974a , b ) .
now we consider a macro - atom that de - activates from a continuum state @xmath64 . in this case , the probabilities of spontaneous and stimulated emission are in the ratio @xmath65 , where @xmath66 are the contributions to @xmath67 from spontaneous and stimulated emissions .
thus @xmath61 is selected by first deciding between spontaneous and stimulated emission and then randomly sampling the energy distribution of the chosen process s recombination continua .
if the above selection procedure rules that an @xmath5-packet is emitted spontaneously , then a new direction of propagation is chosen in accordance with this process s isotropic emission . on the other hand , for stimulated emission , the new direction of propagation is that of the stimulating photon . thus , the new direction will be in solid angle @xmath68 at @xmath69 with probability @xmath70 , where @xmath61 is the frequency of the emitted @xmath5-packet .
accordingly , a monte carlo code that treats stimulated emission separately must store a complete description of the radiation field - i.e. , @xmath71 . for problems where population inversions are not anticipated
, we can usefully make the traditional assumption that lines have identical emission and absorption profiles and treat stimulated emissions as negative absorptions - see mihalas ( 1978 , p78 ) .
the radiative rates for b - b transitions are then @xmath72 similarly , for f - b and b - f transitions , we define @xmath73 where the photionization coefficient is now corrected for stimulated recombinations . for collisions ,
the absence of population inversions allows us to treat de - excitations as negative excitations without the risk that eqs.(7 ) and ( 9 ) will give negative probabilities .
accordingly , we now define @xmath74 this then implies that @xmath75 and therefore also @xmath76 for all @xmath1 .
energy transfer from the radiation field to the thermal pool then occurs _ explicitly _ only via f - f absorptions .
because @xmath77 and therefore @xmath24 are here defined with the correction for stimulated emission included , the macroscopic line- and continuum - absorption coefficients must also include this correction . in the posited absence of population inversions , these absorption coefficients are positive .
because @xmath51 and therefore @xmath28 now exclude stimulated emission , the process that radiatively de - activates a macro - atom is always a spontaneous emission .
if @xmath1 is a bound state , the frequency @xmath61 of the emitted @xmath5-packet is then decided as follows : the transition @xmath9 is selected with probability @xmath78 , and then @xmath61 is selected by randomly sampling this transition s emission profile , as in sect .
4.1.3 . for de - activation from a continuum state
, @xmath61 is selected by randomly sampling the energy distribution of the spontaneous recombination continua . because the de - activating process is in this case spontaneous emission
, the new direction of propagation is selected according to isotropic emission .
thus , we now do not need to store @xmath71 .
in fact , from the monte carlo radiation field generated at one iteration , we only require the mean intensities @xmath79 .
these allow us to compute transition probabilities from eqs.(7 ) and ( 9 ) for use during the next iteration .
the procedures described in sects . 4.1 and 4.2 apply to
both static and moving media .
but for some important problems involving moving media , a substantial speeding up of the calculation with negligible loss of accuracy is possible by applying sobolev s theory of line formation . in doing so
, we take advantage of a small dimensionless quantity - the ratio of a line s doppler width to the typical flow velocity , which implies an essentially constant velocity gradient over the zone in which a given pencil of radiation interacts with a particular line .
the monte carlo codes for hot star winds and sne cited in sect .
1 treat line formation in the sobolev approximation .
the simplest case of this kind is that of homologous spherical expansion , as is commonly assumed for sne . this case will be treated here since it will be used in the test calculations of sect .
generalization to a spherically - symmetric stellar wind is readily carried out by referring to castor & klein ( 1978 ) .
we also assume no population inversions and so treat stimulated emissions as negative absorptions , as in sect . 4.2 .
the radiative rates for b - b transitions are then @xmath80 here @xmath81 is the mean intensity at the far blue wing of the transition @xmath82 , and @xmath83 is the sobolev escape probability for this transition , given by @xmath84 \;\;\ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath85 , the transition s sobolev optical depth , is @xmath86 with @xmath87 being the elapsed time since the sn exploded .
for f - b and b - f transitions , the rates are as in eq.(18 ) . for collisions ,
the rates are as in eq.(19 ) .
the absorption of @xmath5-packets by lines is determined by the sobolev optical depths given by eq.(22 ) .
absorption of an @xmath5-packet to the continuum is determined by the conventional macroscopic absorption coefficient corrected for stimulated emission .
the frequency of an emitted @xmath5-packet is decided as follows : for de - activation from a bound state @xmath1 , the transition @xmath9 is selected with probability @xmath88 , where @xmath28 is evaluated with eq.(1 ) using the decay rates from eq.(20 ) , and the emitted packet is assigned frequency @xmath89 - i.e. , it is in the far red wing of a line whose emission profile is approximated by a delta function .
the packet s next possible b - b transition is therefore with the next line to the redward of @xmath90 ( abbott & lucy 1985 ) .
for de - activation from a continuum state , the new frequency is , as in sect .
4.2.3 , selected by randomly sampling the energy distribution of the spontaneous recombination continua .
if an @xmath5-packet is emitted from a continuum state , the new direction of propagation is selected according to isotropic emission since the emission in this case is spontaneous . for de - activation from a bound state ,
the emission is also isotropic since , for homologous expansion , there is no kinematically - preferred direction .
this is not true for a stellar wind .
the monte carlo transition probabilities derived in sect .
3 are designed to reproduce asymptotically the emissivity of an atomic species whose level populations are in statistical equilibrium . to test this ,
we now consider one - point problems with specified and fixed ambient conditions .
such tests sensibly precede application to a general nlte problem , for then the local ambient conditions are everywhere being adjusted iteratively as the global solution is sought . in the initial tests ,
the monte carlo transition probabilities are applied to the model fe ii ion with @xmath91 levels used previously ( lucy 1999b ) to investigate the accuracy of approximate treatments of line formation in sne envelopes .
the energy levels of the fe ii ion and the f - values for permitted transitions were extracted from the kurucz bell ( 1995 ) compilation by m.lennon ( munich ) .
einstein a - values for forbidden transitions are from quinet et al.(1996 ) and nussbaumer & storey ( 1988 ) .
collision strengths , needed for sect.5.1.5 , are from zhang & pradhan ( 1995 ) and van regemorter ( 1962 ) . in the first fe
ii test , we neglect collisional excitations and , as previously ( lucy 1999b ) , take the ambient radiation field determining the quantities @xmath81 in eq.(20 ) to be @xmath92 with @xmath93 and dilution factor @xmath94 , corresponding to @xmath95 .
the density parameter is @xmath96 , and the time since explosion is @xmath97 . with parameters specified , this one - point statistical equilibrium problem - eq.(4 ) for @xmath98 levels plus a normalization constraint
- is non - linear in the unknowns @xmath20 because the rate coefficients in eq.(20 ) depend on the @xmath20 through the sobolev escape probabilities .
fortunately , repeated back substitutions give a highly accurate solution @xmath99 in @xmath100 10 iterations . with @xmath99 determined , the fe ii level emissivites @xmath28 and absorption rates @xmath24
can be computed from eq.(1 ) .
we now test the monte carlo transition probabilities by seeing how accurately they reproduce these values @xmath28 .
note that it is sufficient to test _ level _ emissivities since if these are exact so also are the line emissivities computed as described in sect .
4.3.3 . in the following monte carlo experiment ,
@xmath101 packets of radiant energy are absorbed and subsequently emitted by a macro - atom representing a macroscopic volume element of fe ii ions in the ambient conditions specified above .
the energies of these packets are taken to be equal and given by @xmath102 , where @xmath103 .
the calculation proceeds step - by - step as follows : \1 ) @xmath104 of the packets activate the macro - atom to internal state @xmath1 .
\2 ) the transition probabilities @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 for a macro - atom in state @xmath1 are computed from eqs.(7 ) and ( 9 ) .
\3 ) the transition probabilities sum to one , so each corresponds to a segment @xmath108 of the interval ( 0,1 ) . a particular transition is therefore selected by computing a random number @xmath56 in ( 0,1 ) and finding in which segment it falls .
\4 ) if the selected transition is the de - activation of the macro - atom , we update @xmath109 to @xmath110 and then return to step 3 ) to process the next activation of state @xmath1 , or to step 2 ) to process the first of the packets that activate the macro - atom to state @xmath111 .
\5 ) if the selected transition is an internal transition to state @xmath2 , then we return to step 2 ) with @xmath2 replacing @xmath1 .
\6 ) when all @xmath101 packets have been processed , the final elements of the vector @xmath109 are the estimates of the level emissivities @xmath28 as a single measure of the accuracy of the estimated level emissivities , we compute the quantity @xmath112 this is the mean of the absolute fractional errors of the @xmath109 when weighted by @xmath28 . figure 2 shows the values of @xmath113 , expressed as percentage errors , found in a series of trials with @xmath101 increasing from @xmath114 to @xmath115 . the values of @xmath113 decrease monotonically with increasing @xmath101 , falling to @xmath116 percent for @xmath117 .
more importantly , the errors accurately follow an @xmath118 line , as expected if the only source of error are the sampling error at step 3 ) of the monte carlo experiments . accordingly , to the accuracy of these experiments , macro - atoms obeying the transition probabilities derived in sect .
3 do indeed reproduce the emissivity of a gas in statistical equilibrium .
also included in fig.2 are values of @xmath113 obtained when the transition probabilities are computed with excitation energies @xmath7 increased by 5ev .
this is to investigate the consequences of the dependence of the energy flow terms in eq.(5 ) - and therefore also of the transition probabilities - on the zero point of the scale of excitation energy .
these results also track an @xmath118 line and so indicate that the predicted emissivities are asymptotically independent of the zero point .
but since the open circles are marginally higher , there is an indication that increasing the zero point gives slighty less accurate emissivities at a given @xmath101 . in the monte carlo codes for hot star winds and sne cited in sect .
1 , line formation is treated approximately , with either resonant scattering or downward branching being assumed .
for both assumptions , @xmath119 , corresponding to a macro - atom for which de - activation always immediately follows activation - i.e. , @xmath120 for all @xmath1 . in this case , as indicated on fig.2 , @xmath121 percent .
thus , when the points in fig.2 drop below this value , the success must be due to the internal , radiationless transitions governed by the probabilities @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
the above experiments show that despite the formidable complexity of its level structure the fe ii ion s reprocessing of radiation is accurately simulated by the monte carlo transition probabilities .
nevertheless , from a computational standpoint , a remaining concern is how many internal transitions - or jumps - does this require ? to answer this ,
the number of jumps before de - activation was recorded for each absorbed packet in the @xmath117 trial and used to derive @xmath122 , the number of packets requiring @xmath2 jumps . from @xmath122 , we find that the expected number of jumps is @xmath123 and that the probability of immediate de - activation - i.e. , zero jumps - is @xmath124 .
evidently , fears of numerous , time- consuming internal transitions are ill - founded .
figure 3 is a logarithmic plot of @xmath122 .
this reveals a power - law decline with increasing @xmath2 but with alternating deviations indicating that an even number of jumps before de - activation is favoured .
a simple model suggests the origin of this curious behaviour . consider a 3-level atom with @xmath125 and suppose that level 2 is metastable with @xmath126 . because @xmath127 , the macro - atom can only be activated to state 3 ; and because @xmath128 , the macro - atom can not de - activate from state 2 .
moreover , since @xmath129 , eq.(9 ) gives @xmath130 , and so state 1 of the macro - atom can not be reached .
accordingly , following activation at state 3 , the macro - atom de - activates with probability @xmath131 or jumps to state 2 with probability @xmath132 , from whence it returns to state 3 with probability @xmath133 .
it is now simple to prove that the probabilty of @xmath2 jumps before de - activation is @xmath134 if @xmath2 is even , and @xmath135 if @xmath2 is odd . the fe ii ion s numerous low - lying metastable levels are presumably playing the role of level 2 and thereby favouring an even number of jumps .
histograms @xmath122 have also been computed for two other cases .
first , the above trial was repeated with the @xmath7 s increased by 5ev as in sect .
this change increases @xmath136 - to 4.54 - as expected since the probabilities @xmath106 and @xmath107 are thereby increased and @xmath105 correspondingly decreased .
evidently , the standard choice of energy - level zero point leads to the most computationally - efficient set of transition probabilities . in the second case
, @xmath137 is decreased from 0.5 to 0.067 , corresponding to @xmath138 .
this change decreases @xmath136 - from 2.19 to 1.29 - as expected given the weakening of the radiative excitation rates . in the above experiment
, the emission derives entirely from radiative excitation since collisions were neglected .
now we consider the opposite extreme by setting the ambient radiation field to zero but including collisions .
the only parameters of this test are the electron temperature and density , and these are assigned the values @xmath139 and @xmath140 .
the resulting statistical equilibrium problem is linear and so solved without iteration .
for this solution , accurate values of the level emissivities @xmath28 are again computed from eq.(1 ) .
the next step is to derive estimates of the level emissivities by repeating the monte carlo experiment of sect.5.1.2 .
the only changes needed are the following : first , since the solution has population inversions the general formulation of sect .
4.1 must be adopted to avoid negative probabilities .
secondly , since a macro - atom is now always activated by a @xmath6-packet , their energies are taken to be @xmath141 , where @xmath142 .
correspondingly , at step 1 ) of the experiment , @xmath143 .
thirdly , since a macro - atom can now de - activate by emitting either an @xmath5- or a @xmath6-packet , only the former results in an updating of @xmath109 .
the emission of a @xmath6-packet represents the return of energy @xmath3 to the therrmal pool .
apart from these changes , the convergence experiment proceeds as in sects .
5.1.2 and 5.1.3 .
the result is a plot similar to fig.2 , but with @xmath144 percent for @xmath117 .
evidently , the monte carlo transition probabilities are equally applicable to problems where collisional excitation is a source of emission .
although the fe ii experiments demonstrate the validity of the monte carlo transition probabilities , a test including b - f and f - b transitions is of interest .
accordingly , a convergence experiment at one point in a sn s envelope has also been carried out for a 15-level model of the h atom , with level 15 being the continuum @xmath64 .
the 14 bound levels correspond to principal quantum numbers @xmath145 , with each level having consolidated statistical weight @xmath146 .
as for fe ii , the ambient radiation field incident on the blue wings of the b - b transitions is @xmath147 , but now with @xmath148 and @xmath149 .
however , beyond the lyman limit , we assume zero intensity , so that photoionizations occur only from excited states .
correspondingly , recombinations to @xmath150 are excluded on the assumption of immediate photoionization .
collisional excitations and ionizations are neglected .
the density parameter is @xmath151 , the electron temperature @xmath152 , and the time since explosion @xmath153 . with parameters specified ,
this non - linear statistical equilibrium problem can also be solved with repeated back substitutions , giving a highly accurate solution @xmath99 in @xmath154 iterations .
with @xmath99 determined , monte carlo experiments as described in sect .
5.1.2 were carried out to test if level emissivities are also recovered in this case . in fig.4 , two such trials , with @xmath155 and @xmath156 , are compared with the exact solution .
the results show that excellent agreement is achieved for @xmath157 .
note in particular the success with @xmath158 , which is the rate of ionization energy loss due to recombinations , and with @xmath159 , whose very low value is due to the strong trapping of @xmath160 photons .
thus far , a monte carlo procedure has been used to validate the transition probabilities developed in sect.3 .
this has the advantage of following closely and therefore illustrating their use in realistic nlte calculations .
but for feasible values of @xmath101 , sampling errors limit the accuracy of such tests . in order to test to higher precision ,
approximate level emissivities @xmath161 can be computed recursively according to the following scheme : @xmath162 where @xmath105 is the radiative de - activation probability from eq.(7 ) and @xmath163 is the increment at cycle @xmath5 to the summation approximating the rate at which level @xmath1 gains energy - i.e. the right - hand side of eq.(5 ) .
this increment is derived from the previous increment by applying the transition probabilities from eq.(9 ) .
thus @xmath164 and the recursion cycles are initiated by setting @xmath165 this procedure is now applied to the fe ii test problem of sect .
as with that experiment , the accuracy of the vectors @xmath161 are measured by computing @xmath113 defined by eq.(23 ) . for @xmath166 , @xmath113 drops below the value 0.36 percent found in sect.5.1.3 with @xmath117 - see fig.2 . as the recursion procedure continues further
, @xmath113 decreases monotonically until at @xmath167 it drops to a value of @xmath168 , at which point machine precision or accumulated roundoff errors halt further progress .
this test clearly confirms and strengthens the earlier tests of the monte carlo transition probabilities .
the experiments of sect.5 demonstrate that , when computed with the exact level populations @xmath99 , the monte carlo transition probabilities applied to indivisible @xmath4-packets reproduce the exact level emissivities as @xmath169 .
but this success , though necessary , does not of itself imply that the technique will be successful when applied to nlte problems .
for example , if the monte carlo emissivities were to undergo large changes in response to small changes in @xmath20 , then we would reasonably suspect that the iterations inevitably required for a nlte problem would converge very slowly - or might even diverge . on the other hand ,
if the emissivities are insensitive to changes in @xmath20 , then the prospects for successful applications are excellent
. this crucial question of sensitivity can be investigated by repeating the calculations of fe ii emissivities reported in sect.5.1 , but with @xmath20 perturbed away from @xmath99 . a convenient way of doing this is to replace @xmath99 by the boltzmann distribution at excitation temperature @xmath170 .
then , for given @xmath170 , the corresponding level emissivities @xmath109 are obtained from a monte carlo trial with @xmath171 packets , and so are negligibly affected by sampling errors ( cf .
fig.2 ) .
now , for the given @xmath170 , we can also compute @xmath28 , the level emissivities predicted by the fundamental formulae - eqs.(1 ) and ( 20 ) in this case .
this represents the standard approach to nlte transfer problems whereby the radiation field is computed from the radiative transfer eq .
( rte ) with emissivity coefficients evaluated using the current estimates of @xmath20 .
thus by comparing these two emissivity estimates @xmath109 and @xmath28 , we can see whether this monte carlo technique is potentally capable of yielding a superior estimate of the radiation field . in fig.5 ,
the quantities @xmath109 and @xmath28 obtained for @xmath172 are plotted against @xmath173 , the exact statistical equilibrium level emissivities - i.e. , the values corresponding to @xmath99 .
remarkably , figure 5 shows that the monte carlo emissivities are far less sensitive to the departure of @xmath20 from @xmath99 than are the emissivities computed directly from the fundamental formula . for the most part , the @xmath109 are in error by @xmath174 dex , with little evidence of bias , while the @xmath28 are systematically offset by @xmath175 dex .
to investigate whether this insensitivity is characteristic of the monte carlo procedure , the above test is now repeated with @xmath170 ranging from @xmath176 to @xmath177 and the resulting mean errors defined by eq.(23 ) plotted in fig.6 .
we see that @xmath28 gives reasonably accurate emissivities only in the immediate neighbourhood of the minimum at @xmath178 . on the other hand , the values @xmath109 are accurate to @xmath179 dex across the entire range .
the causes of these astonishing differences in sensitivity are of considerable interest . for @xmath28 , the strong sensitivity to @xmath170
is readily understood .
because the sum @xmath180 , an error in the population of the emitting level translates directly into an error in @xmath28
. now consider @xmath109 .
this quantity is determined by the rate at which active macro - atoms reach state @xmath1 , and this happens by direct absorptions of packets into this state or by transitions from other states .
either way , the accuracy of the source vectors @xmath24 and @xmath25 is clearly fundamental to the accuracy of the vector @xmath109 .
but the dominant contributors to the elements of these source vectors - see eqs.(1 ) and ( 2 ) - are transitions from the ground state and from low - lying metastable levels , and the estimated populations of these levels are unlikely to be seriously in error . in particular , with an assumed boltzmann distribution over excited states , the @xmath20 of these low levels is insensitive to @xmath170 and do not differ much from @xmath99 .
in contrast , the populations of high levels are quite likely to be badly estimated and are acutely sensitive to @xmath170 .
another way of appreciating the differences in these approaches to calculating emissivities is as follows .
the monte carlo procedure applies only to a state of statistical equilibrium and , as such , constrains every level s emissivity to be consistent with the rates of processes populating that level .
in contrast , the fundamental emissivity formula applies also to states out of statistical equilibrium and so takes no account of whether the levels populations can be maintained .
accordingly , with this monte carlo technique , the principle of statistical equilibrium is _ incorporated _ ( approximately ) as the radiation field is being calculated . on the other hand , when emissivities are computed from the fundamental formula , any consideration of statistical equilibrium is effectively being deferred until the updated radiation field has been determined .
the likely beneficial impact of this insensitivity on the iterations needed to derive nlte solutions is worth stressing . with the conventional rte approach , an erroneously overpopulated upper level
@xmath1 pollutes the radiation field with spurious line photons at frequencies @xmath181 , and these are sources of excitation for level @xmath1 when level populations are next solved for .
similarly , an erroneously overpopulated upper ion pollutes the radiation field with recombination photons that are subsequent sources of photoionization for the lower ion . to some degree , therefore , such errors are _ self - perpetuating _ and so are not rapidly eliminated .
this persistency contributes to the slow convergence typical of nlte codes .
in contrast , with the monte carlo approach , this pollution does not happen and so - for sufficiently large @xmath182 - a high quality radiation field is obtained immediately provided that the initial populations of the low - lying levels are estimated sensibly .
the monte carlo transition probabilities allow statistical equilibrium to be incorporated into the calculation of radiation fields for nlte problems .
moreover , this is achieved without imposing the constraint of radiative equilibrium .
accordingly , in principle at least , the technique applies equally to problems with non - radiative heating , such as stellar chromospheres . in the absence of non - radiative heating , a nlte transfer problem
must be solved subject to the constraint of radiative equilibrium .
the incorporation of this _ additional _ constraint into the macro - atom formalism is readily understood .
first suppose that collisional processes are neglected .
the absorbed and the emitted @xmath4-packets are then always @xmath5-packets and they have identical energies - see fig.1 . thus , the constraint of radiative equilibrium is obeyed rigorously since it holds exactly for every activation - de - activation event , all of which are of the form @xmath183 , where @xmath184 denotes an active macro - atom .
note also that since active macro - atoms do not appear spontaneously within the computational domain ( d ) , every monte carlo quantum s interaction history starts and ends as an @xmath5-packet crossing a boundary of d. now suppose that collisions are included . in this case
, a macro - atom activated by an @xmath5-packet can de - activate itself by emitting a @xmath6-packet , so that radiative equilibrium no longer holds exactly for each individual activation - de - activation event .
however , the emitted @xmath6-packet is re - absorbed _ in situ _ by another macro - atom and thereby ( eventually ) converted into an @xmath5-packet . since this has the same energy as the original @xmath5-packet , radiative equilibrium holds for every sequence of in situ events that starts with the absorption of an @xmath5-packet and ends with the next emission of an @xmath5-packet .
a typical in situ sequence is @xmath185 .
if such sequences are abbreviated as @xmath186 \rightarrow r$ ] , we see that the inclusion of collisions has not fundamentally changed the procedure and that radiative equilibrium is still rigorously obeyed . in the presence of non - radiative heating ,
the nlte problem is not subject to the additional constraint of radiative equilibrium .
statistical equilibrium is incorporated with the macro - atom formalism as before , and the challenge now is to incorporate the creation of radiant energy within d due to the additional heating .
this is accomplished by allowing for the spontaneous and random appearance within d of active macro - atoms with their number , locations and internal states @xmath1 all controlled by the collision source vector @xmath25 - cf .
note that because this sampling of @xmath25 takes full account of the collisional creation of excitation , the emission of a @xmath6-packet is not now followed by its in situ re - absorption ; instead , the interaction history of that monte carlo quantum then ends and its energy is added to the thermal pool ( cf . sect.5.1.5 . ) .
the radiation field generated by this procedure is not divergence - free but reflects the collisional creation of radiant energy due to an elevated temperature profile maintained by the non - radiative heating .
the limited aim of this paper has been to see if monte carlo transfer codes whose quanta are indestructable energy packets can be constructed without resorting to simplified treatments of line formation . to this end
, the concept of a macro - atom has been introduced and rules established governing its activation and de - activation as well as its transitions between internal states .
these rules - the monte carlo transition probabilities - have been derived by demanding that the macro - atom s emission of @xmath5-packets asymptotically reproduces the local emissivity of a gas in statistical equilibrium ; and these rules validity has been confirmed with one - point test problems .
evidently , the next step is to implement these transition probabilities in a code to solve a realistic nlte problem for a stratified medium and thus to investigate the practicality of this technique for problems of current interest . in a companion paper , a monte carlo nlte code treating the formation of h lines in a type ii sn envelope
will be described and used to illustrate the convergence behaviour of iterations to obtain both the level populations and the temperature stratification .
abbott d.c .
, lucy l.b . 1985 ,
apj 288 , 679 auer l.h . ,
mihalas d. 1970 , mnras 149 , 65 hummer d.g . , rybicki g.b .
1971 , mnras , 152 , 1 klein r.i .
, castor j.i .
1978 , apj 220 , 902 kurucz r.l . ,
bell b. , 1995 , kurucz cd - rom no .
23 lee j .- s .
1974a , apj 187 , 159 lee j .- s .
1974b , apj 192 , 465 lucy l.b . , 1987 , in : danziger i.j .
eso workshop on sn 1987a , p. 417
1999a , a&a 344 , 282 lucy l.b .
1999b , a&a 345 , 211 lucy l.b . , abbott d.c .
1993 , apj 405 , 738 mazzali p.a .
, lucy l.b .
1993 , a&a 279 , 447 mihalas d. , 1978 , stellar atmospheres ( 2nd ed . ) .
w.h.freeman & co. , san francisco | transition probabilities governing the interaction of energy packets and matter are derived that allow monte carlo nlte transfer codes to be constructed without simplifying the treatment of line formation .
these probabilities are such that the monte carlo calculation asymptotically recovers the local emissivity of a gas in statistical equilibrium .
numerical experiments with one - point statistical equilibrium problems for fe ii and hydrogen confirm this asymptotic behaviour .
in addition , the resulting monte carlo emissivities are shown to be far less sensitive to errors in the populations of the emitting levels than are the values obtained with the basic emissivity formula . |
based on low temperature resistivity and heat capacity measurements in applied magnetic fields ybagge was recently classified as a new heavy fermion material with long range , possibly small moment , magnetic order below 1 k @xcite that shows magnetic field induced non - fermi - liquid ( nfl ) behavior @xcite .
the critical field required to drive ybagge to the field - induced quantum critical point ( qcp ) is anisotropic ( @xmath3 45 koe , @xmath4 80 koe ) and conveniently accessible by many experimental groups @xcite .
ybagge is one of the _ rarae aves _ of intermetallics ( apparently only second , after the extensively studied ybrh@xmath5si@xmath5 @xcite ) a _ stoichiometric _ , yb - based , heavy fermion ( hf ) that shows magnetic field induced nfl behavior and as such is suitable to serve as a testing ground for experimental and theoretical constructions relevant for qcp physics . among the surfeit of detailed descriptions developed for a material near the antiferromagnetic qcp
we will refer to the outcomes @xcite of two more general , competing , pictures : in one viewpoint the qcp is a spin density wave ( sdw ) instability @xcite of the fermi surface ; within the second picture that originates in the description of heavy fermions as a kondo lattice of local moments @xcite , heavy electrons are composite bound states formed between local moments and conduction electrons and the qcp is associated with the breakdown of this composite nature .
it was suggested @xcite that hall effect measurements can help distinguish which of these two mechanisms may be relevant for a particular material near a qcp . in the sdw scenario the hall coefficient is expected to vary continuously through the quantum phase transition , whereas in the composite hf scenario the hall coefficient is anticipated to change discontinuously at the qcp .
perhaps more importantly , in both scenarios a clear and sharp change in the field dependent hall effect ( for the field - induced qcp ) is anticipated to occur at low temperatures , near the critical field value .
although hall effect measurements appear to be a very attractive method of gaining insight into the nature of the qcp , one has to keep in mind that an understanding of the different contributions to the measured hall coefficient , in particular in magnetic or strongly correlated materials , is almost inevitably difficult and potentially evasive @xcite .
therefore measurements on samples well characterized by other techniques @xcite as well as comparison with non - magnetic as well as non - hf members of the same series can be beneficial . in this work we present
temperature- and field- dependent hall effect measurements on ybagge single crystals . the non - magnetic member of the same ragge ( r = rare earth ) series , luagge , and the magnetic , essentially non - hybridizing , tmagge were used for common sense checks , or calipers , of the ybagge measurements .
ybagge , luagge and tmagge single crystals in the form of clean , hexagonal - cross - section rods of several mm length and up to 1 mm@xmath6 cross section were grown from high temperature ternary solutions rich in ag and ge ( see @xcite for details of the samples growth ) .
their structure and the absence of impurity phases were confirmed by powder x - ray diffraction .
temperature and field dependent hall resistivity , @xmath7 , and auxiliary high field magnetization measurements were performed down to 1.9 k , in an applied magnetic field of up to 140 koe in a quantum design ppms-14 instrument . for ybagge hall measurements
were extended down to 0.4 k using the he-3 option of the ppms-14 . a four probe , ac technique ( @xmath8 = 16 hz , @xmath9 = 1 - 0.1 ma ) , was used for the hall measurements .
samples were polished down to a plate - like shape with thicknesses of 0.3 - 0.4 mm .
pt leads were attached to the sample with epotek h20e silver epoxy so that the current was flowing along the crystallographic @xmath10 axis . for the @xmath11 case hall resistivity ( @xmath12 )
was measured in the hexagonal crystallographic plane ( approximately along @xmath13 $ ] direction ) with the magnetic field applied perpendicular to both the current and the hall voltage directions ( approximately along @xmath14 $ ] direction ) ( see the lower inset to figure [ rhlutm ] ) . in the @xmath2 case
, current was flowing in the hexagonal plane , approximately in @xmath13 $ ] direction , the hall voltage was measured along @xmath14 $ ] direction . due to rod - like morphology of the crystals , samples that were cut and polished for @xmath2 measurements
were smaller and the error bars in the absolute values ( due to geometry and position of the contacts ) are larger than for the @xmath11 data sets . to eliminate the effect of inevitable ( small ) misalignment of the voltage contacts ,
the hall measurements were taken for two opposite directions of the applied field , @xmath15 and @xmath16 , and the odd component , @xmath17 was taken as the hall resistivity . to determine the hall resistivity in the limit of low field , linear fits of the initial ( linear ) parts of the @xmath18 data in both quadrants
were used .
he-4 hall measurements for ybagge and luagge were performed on two samples of each material , the results were the same within the error bars in sample dimensions and contact position measurements . during the measurements
particular care was taken to avoid rotation and/or misplacement of the tmagge sample due to its magnetic anisotropy .
the field - dependent hall resistivity for luagge for @xmath11 is shown in the upper inset to fig . [ rhlutm](a ) for several temperatures .
@xmath12 is only slightly non - linear in field over the whole temperature range .
this minor non - linearity causes some difference in the @xmath19 _ vs. _ @xmath20 data obtained in different applied fields ( fig .
[ rhlutm](a ) ) .
the hall coefficient , @xmath21 , is measured to be negative .
the overall temperature dependence is monotonic , slow and featureless with approximately a factor of two increase in the absolute value of @xmath19 from room temperature to low temperatures .
this temperature - dependency of the hall coefficient of the non - magnetic material possibly reflects some details of its electronic structure ( for example , comparable factor of 2 changes in @xmath22 were recently observed in latin@xmath23 , t = rh , ir , co , @xcite ) . overall the temperature- and field - dependence of the hall coefficient for tmagge ( fig . [ rhlutm](b ) ) is similar to that of luagge with two main differences : ( i)the long range order and metamagnetism of tmagge @xcite is reflected in hall measurements as a low temperature decrease in @xmath24 and as anomalies in @xmath25 for @xmath26 2 k that are consistent with the fields of the metamagnetic transitions ; ( ii)the absolute values of the @xmath27 data for tmagge are a factor of 3 - 4 smaller than for luagge . the temperature dependent hall coefficient and the dc susceptibility data for ybagge with the same orientation of the magnetic field with respect to the crystallographic axis are shown in fig .
[ rhmtyb ] .
the susceptibility , @xmath28 , is field - independent above 50 k ( _ i.e. _ @xmath29 is linear below 140 koe in this temperature range ) and is similar to the data reported in @xcite .
the hall coefficient , @xmath22 , is field - independent above approximately 25 k. the temperature dependencies of the susceptibility and the hall coefficient at high temperatures closely resemble each other . at low temperatures a field - dependent maximum in @xmath22 ( see inset to fig .
[ rhmtyb ] ) is observed .
qualitatively the temperature dependence of the hall coefficient is consistent with the picture presented in @xcite ( see also @xcite for a comprehensive review ) . within this picture
the temperature dependence of the hall coefficient in heavy fermion materials is a result of two contributions : a residual hall coefficient , @xmath30 , and a hall coefficient due to the intrinsic skew scattering , @xmath31 .
the residual hall coefficient is ascribed to a combination of the ordinary hall effect and residual skew scattering by defects and impurities and , to the first approximation , is considered to be temperature - independent , although , realistically , both the ordinary hall effect and the residual skew scattering may have weak temperature dependence .
the temperature - dependent , intrinsic skew scattering contribution ( @xmath32 ) at high temperatures ( @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the kondo temperature ) increases as the temperature is lowered in a manner that is mainly due to the increasing magnetic susceptibility . at lower temperatures @xmath32 passes through a crossover regime , then has a peak at a temperature on the order of the coherence temperature , @xmath35 , and finally , on further cooling rapidly decreases ( in the coherent regime of skew scattering by fluctuations ) to zero ( _ i.e. _ @xmath22 ultimately levels off to the @xmath36 value at very low temperatures @xcite ) . in the high temperature ( @xmath33 ) limit we can ( very roughly , within an order of magnitude ) separate these two contributions to the observed temperature - dependent hall coefficient using a phenomenological expression @xmath37 @xcite with the temperature - dependent skew scattering contribution written as @xmath38 where @xmath39 , @xmath40 is the curie constant , and @xmath41 is the weiss temperature . using @xmath42 = -15.1 k from @xcite we can plot @xmath43 _ vs. _
@xmath44 ( fig .
[ rht ] ) and from the linear part of the curve we can estimate @xmath45 0.02 n@xmath46 cm / oe and @xmath47 -0.17 n@xmath46 cm
it seems peculiar that our estimate of @xmath48 for ybagge differs noticeably from the hall coefficient measurements for luagge and tmagge ( see fig .
[ rhlutm ] ) . regarding this discrepancy
it should be mentioned that besides possible experimental ( mainly geometrical ) errors these three materials may have different residual skew scattering and , additionally , as indicated by the preliminary results of band structure calculations @xcite , the density of states at the fermi level can be considerably different for all three compounds under consideration . although the magnetic susceptibility , @xmath49 of tmagge above the nel temperature has a clear curie - weiss behavior @xcite , in contrast to the case of ybagge , the temperature dependence of the hall coefficient for tmagge ( fig .
[ rhlutm](b ) ) does not have a similar functional form .
the reason for this difference is apparently the very small skew scattering contribution ( @xmath50 ) to the hall coefficient in tmagge .
similarly small couplings of local moment magnetism with the hall effect has been seen in other rare earth intermetallics , _
e.g. _ rni@xmath5b@xmath5c ( r = rare earth ) borocarbides @xcite .
in order to further explore the low temperature behavior of the hall coefficient , measurements down to 0.4 k were performed .
the results ( on a semi -_log _ scale ) are shown in fig .
[ rhltyb ] .
the data taken in applied fields of 75 koe and higher show the expected levelling off of the @xmath24 as @xmath51 .
it is noteworthy that the measured value of @xmath52 is close to the aforementioned estimate of the residual hall coefficient .
this agreement suggests that at the lowest temperatures the hall coefficient is dominated by @xmath48 and , barring the residual skew scattering contribution , can probe the concentration of the electronic carriers . whereas the higher field values of the hall coefficient vary smoothly with temperature ( fig .
[ rhltyb ] ) , the low field data , below @xmath53 3 k , show large variations .
although the signal to noise ratio in the low field measurements is inherently lower , these variations appear to be above the noise level ( fig .
[ rhltyb ] , inset ) and the peaks slightly above 0.6 k and 1.0 k are understood as the signatures of the magnetic transitions in ybagge @xcite that are suppressed ( in this orientation ) when a 75 koe , or higher , magnetic field is applied . to further study the field - induced qcp in ybagge , field
dependent hall resistance measurements were performed at different temperatures ( fig .
[ rhhyb ] ) .
although the theoretical constructions are usually formulated in terms of the hall _ coefficient _ , not hall _ resistivity _ , in the case of ybagge the magnetic field itself is a control parameter for the qcp that makes the proper definition of the hall coefficient ambiguous .
we will continue presenting our data as hall resistivity , since it is a quantity unambiguously extracted from the measurements , and leave the discussion on the suitable definition of the hall coefficient for the appendix . for temperatures at and above @xmath5410
k , the @xmath25 behavior is monotonic and , at higher temperatures , eventually linear ( fig .
[ rhhyb](b ) ) .
this type of behavior has been observed in a number of different materials in the paramagnetic state @xcite .
the low temperature evolution of the @xmath25 behavior is more curious ( fig .
[ rhhyb](a ) ) and ought to be compared with the phase diagram obtained for ybagge ( @xmath11 ) in @xcite ( an augmented version of which is shown in fig .
[ pd ] below ) .
the lines in fig . [
rhhyb](a ) roughly connect the points according to the phase lines in @xcite ( see also fig . [ pd ] below ) .
it can be seen that the lower @xmath55 magnetically ordered phase line possibly has ( despite the scattering of the points ) correspondent features in @xmath25 , and the coherence line in @xcite ( and fig .
[ pd ] ) roughly corresponds to the beginning of the high field linear behavior in @xmath25 . on the other hand ,
the higher @xmath55 magnetically ordered phase line can not unambiguously be associated with any feature in @xmath25 curves .
the most interesting feature shown in fig .
[ rhhyb](a ) though is the presence of the pronounced peak , or local maximum , in @xmath25 that occurs at @xmath56 koe for the @xmath26 0.4 k curve and can be followed up to temperatures above long range magnetic order transition temperatures . for @xmath26 2.5 k a broad , local maximum in @xmath12 , centered at @xmath57 koe
can just barely be discerned .
as temperature is reduced this feature sharpens and moves down in field . for @xmath26 1 k the local maximum in @xmath12
is clearly located at @xmath58 koe and by @xmath59 k @xmath12 has sharpened almost to the point of becoming discontinuous with @xmath60 koe .
the temperature dependence of @xmath61 is shown in fig .
[ pd ] clearly demonstrating that as @xmath62 , @xmath63 for the qcp .
independent of any theory these data clearly show that ( i ) @xmath12 is an extremely sensitive method of determining @xmath64 of qcp , ( ii ) @xmath61 has a clear temperature dependence , and ( iii ) the qcp influences @xmath12 up to @xmath65 k , a temperature significantly higher than the @xmath66 antiferromagnetic ordering temperature . the new phase line ( shown as stars in fig .
[ pd ] ) associated with @xmath12 maximum is distinct from the lines inferred from @xmath67 and @xmath68 data @xcite . as @xmath51 this line approaches @xmath64 , but for finite @xmath20 it is well separated from the coherence line that was determined by the onset of @xmath69 resistivity behavior .
this new @xmath61 line rather clearly locates @xmath64 at @xmath70 koe , the field at which the long range antiferromagnetic order appears to be suppressed .
since the response of ybagge to an applied magnetic field is anisotropic @xcite , it is apposite to repeat the hall measurements for the magnetic field applied parallel to the crystallographic @xmath10-axis .
the temperature - dependent hall coefficient taken in different applied fields is presented in fig .
[ rhltybc ] ( the low - field data were obtained as described above ) .
the @xmath24 behavior for @xmath2 is qualitatively similar to that for @xmath11 with a broad maximum being shifted to @xmath71 k ( as compared to @xmath72 k for @xmath11 ) and being less sensitive to the applied field .
the low temperature , field - dependent hall resistivity for @xmath2 is shown in fig .
[ rhhybc ] . in many aspects
the overall behavior is similar to that for @xmath11 : there are no apparent features associated with the phase lines derived from magnetoresistance and specific heat measurements @xcite ( shown as lines in fig .
[ rhhybc ] ) , however there is the presence of a pronounced minimum in @xmath25 that occurs at @xmath73 koe for the @xmath26 0.4 k curve and can be followed up to the temperatures well above the zero - applied - field magnetic transition temperatures . for @xmath26 2
k a broad , local minimum in @xmath12 , centered at @xmath74 koe can still be recognized and at @xmath75 k a local minima occurs just at the edge of our field range . as temperature is reduced this feature sharpens and moves down in field .
the temperature dependence of @xmath76 is shown in fig .
[ pdc ] clearly demonstrating that , akin to the @xmath11 case , as @xmath51 , @xmath77 for the qcp .
the @xmath25 behavior for this orientation is more complex , and there is an additional , broad maximum in lower fields ( @xmath58 koe at 0.4 k ) that fades out with increasing temperature .
this highly non - monotonic in field behavior is the origin of the dissimilarities in the low temperature @xmath24 data ( fig .
[ rhltybc ] ) taken in different applied fields .
the high field minimum in @xmath25 ( fig . [ rhhybc ] ) defines a new phase line ( shown as stars in fig .
[ pdc ] ) which is clearly different from the lines inferred from @xmath67 and @xmath68 data @xcite . as @xmath51 this line approaches @xmath64 , but for finite @xmath20 it is well separated from the coherence line that was determined by the onset of @xmath69 resistivity behavior . for this orientation of the applied field
this new @xmath76 line rather clearly locates @xmath64 at @xmath78 koe , the field at which the long range antiferromagnetic order appears to be suppressed .
it should be noted that the new lines in the @xmath55 phase diagrams were established from different types of extrema in @xmath25 , _ maximum _ for @xmath11 and _ minimum _ for @xmath2 .
we neither consider this difference as a reason for particular discomfort nor do we necessarily view it as a potential clue to deeper understanding of the nature of the field - induced qcp in this material .
the preliminary band structure calculations @xcite on luagge , the non - magnetic analogue of the title compound , suggest that the members of the ragge series have a complex fermi surface consisting of multiple sheets .
in such a case a change in the fermi surface may possibly have different signatures in the hall measurements with different field orientation .
in addition , existing qcp models appear not to be at the level of considering different shapes and topologies of the fermi surfaces .
whereas these new , @xmath79 lines on the @xmath80 phase diagrams ( figs .
[ pd ] and [ pdc ] ) appear to be closely related with the qcp their detailed nature and temperature dependencies will require further experimental and theoretical attention .
the temperature- and field - dependent hall resistivity have been measured for ybagge single crystals with @xmath11 and @xmath2 orientation of the applied magnetic field .
the temperature dependent hall coefficient of ybagge behaves similarly to other heavy fermion materials .
low temperature , field - dependent measurements reveal a local maximum ( @xmath11 ) or minimum ( @xmath2 ) in @xmath25 for @xmath65 k that occurs at a value that approaches @xmath81 koe ( @xmath11 ) and @xmath82 koe ( @xmath2 ) as @xmath51 .
these data indicate that ( i ) the hall resistivity is indeed a useful measurement for the study of qcp physics and ( ii ) the influence of the qcp extends to temperatures significantly higher than the @xmath66 antiferromagnetic ordering temperature .
coleman _ et al . _
@xcite suggest that @xmath83 data ( where @xmath84 is a control parameter , _
i.e. _ @xmath15 in our case ) can be used to distinguish between two possible qcp scenarios : diffraction off of a critical spin density wave or a breakdown of the composite nature of the heavy electron , with the former manifesting a change of slope at @xmath85 and the latter manifesting a divergence in the slope of @xmath83 at @xmath85 . since in our case
the magnetic field is itself the control parameter , it in not clear if @xmath21 , @xmath86 or just simply @xmath12 should be used for comparison with the theory .
@xmath87 curves determined by two aforementioned ways are presented in fig .
[ drhhyb ] ( @xmath11 ) and fig .
[ drhhybc ] ( @xmath2 ) .
for both definitions and both orientations the evolution of a clear feature in @xmath87 ( defined as a local extremum for @xmath19 and as a mid - point between two different field - dependent regimes for @xmath88 ) replicates ( albeit with slight @xmath15-shift ) the behavior of the hall resistivity ( figs .
[ rhhyb](a ) , [ rhhybc ] ) . given that the new phase line in figs .
[ pd ] and [ pdc ] is fairly insensitive to the data analysis we feel that the use of @xmath25 data is currently the least ambiguous data set to analyze . on the other hand
, if the form of the anomaly near @xmath64 is to be analyzed in detail it will be vital to have a more detailed theoretical treatment of magneto - transport in field - induced qcp materials .
it is tempting to say that for the case of applied field as a control parameter the quantity @xmath89 ( rather than @xmath90 ) serves the role of the low - field hall coefficient and should be compared with the prediction of the models .
if this point of view is accepted , then for @xmath11 the shape and evolution of the @xmath89 curves ( fig . [ drhhyb](b ) ) suggest that possibly the composite fermion model of the qcp is more relevant to the case of ybagge , although for @xmath2 the shape and evolution of the @xmath89 curves ( fig .
[ drhhybc](b ) ) are at variance with the simple theoretical views .
the lack of the @xmath91 k data and an absence of more detailed , realistic - fermi - surface - tailored , model do not allow us to choose the physical picture of the field - induced qcp in ybagge unambiguously .
ames laboratory is operated for the u.s .
department of energy by iowa state university under contract no .
this work was supported by the director for energy research , office of basic energy sciences .
we thank h. b. rhee for assistance in growing some of the additional crystals needed for this work .
, of luagge measured in different applied fields ( @xmath11 ) .
upper inset : field - dependent hall resistivity of luagge measured at different temperatures .
lower inset : the sample , current and applied field geometry used during the measurements .
( b ) similar data for tmagge.,title="fig:",width=377 ] , of luagge measured in different applied fields ( @xmath11 ) .
upper inset : field - dependent hall resistivity of luagge measured at different temperatures .
lower inset : the sample , current and applied field geometry used during the measurements .
( b ) similar data for tmagge.,title="fig:",width=377 ] , of ybagge measured in different applied fields ( @xmath11 ) .
inset : enlarged , low temperature part of the data .
lower panel : dc susceptibility of ybagge ( @xmath15 along @xmath14 $ ] direction ) .
the low h label in the legend refers to the low field hall resistivity ( see experimental section ) and for susceptibility measured in @xmath15 = 1 koe.,width=453 ] ) measured in different applied fields down to 0.4 k. open symbols - he-4 measurements ( 2 - 300 k ) , filled symbols - measurements using he-3 option ( 0.4 - 10 k ) .
inset : enlarged low temperature part of the low field data with the estimated error bars.,width=453 ] ) measured at different temperatures : ( a)low temperature data : the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k , are shifted by @xmath93 cm increments for clarity ; the lines represent the phase lines from the phase diagram in fig .
10(a ) of the ref .
2 ; the triangles mark the position of the local maximum in @xmath25 ; ( b)intermediate and high temperature data .
note : @xmath94 k data is shown in both plots for reference and is un - shifted in ( b ) .
, title="fig:",width=340 ] ) measured at different temperatures : ( a)low temperature data : the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k , are shifted by @xmath93 cm increments for clarity ; the lines represent the phase lines from the phase diagram in fig .
10(a ) of the ref .
2 ; the triangles mark the position of the local maximum in @xmath25 ; ( b)intermediate and high temperature data .
note : @xmath94 k data is shown in both plots for reference and is un - shifted in ( b ) . , title="fig:",width=340 ] phase diagram for @xmath95 .
long range magnetic order ( lrmo ) and the coherence temperature lines marked on the phase diagram are taken from ref .
2 . filled stars and corresponding dashed line as a guide to the eye are defined from the maximum in the @xmath25 curves.,width=453 ] ) ; the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k ,
are shifted by @xmath93 cm increments for clarity ; the lines represent the phase lines from the phase diagram in fig .
10(b ) of the ref .
2 ; the triangles mark the position of the peak in @xmath25 . , width=453 ] phase diagram for @xmath96 . long range magnetic order ( lrmo ) and the coherence temperature lines marked on the phase diagram are taken from ref .
filled stars are defined from the minimum in the @xmath25 curves .
dashed lines are guides to the eye.,width=453 ] ) , defined as ( a ) @xmath21 and ( b ) @xmath97 , measured at different temperatures
. the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k , are shifted by ( a ) 0.02 n@xmath46 cm and ( b ) 0.2 n@xmath46 cm increments for clarity ; the triangles mark the position of the feature in @xmath87 : a local maximum in @xmath19 and a mid - point of the transition between two different field - dependent regimes ( see _ e.g. _ 0.8 k curve)in @xmath88 .
curves in the ( b ) panel were obtained by differentiation of the 5-adjacent - points - smoothed @xmath25 data .
small downturn at @xmath98 koe in some @xmath88 curves ( panel ( b ) ) is most likely an artifact of using digital smoothing and differentiation.,title="fig:",width=283 ] ) , defined as ( a ) @xmath21 and ( b ) @xmath97 , measured at different temperatures . the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k ,
are shifted by ( a ) 0.02 n@xmath46 cm and ( b ) 0.2 n@xmath46 cm increments for clarity ; the triangles mark the position of the feature in @xmath87 : a local maximum in @xmath19 and a mid - point of the transition between two different field - dependent regimes ( see _ e.g. _ 0.8 k curve)in @xmath88 .
curves in the ( b ) panel were obtained by differentiation of the 5-adjacent - points - smoothed @xmath25 data .
small downturn at @xmath98 koe in some @xmath88 curves ( panel ( b ) ) is most likely an artifact of using digital smoothing and differentiation.,title="fig:",width=283 ] ) , defined as ( a ) @xmath21 and ( b ) @xmath97 , measured at different temperatures .
the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k , are shifted by ( a ) 0.02 n@xmath46 cm and ( b ) 0.1 n@xmath46 cm increments for clarity ; the triangles mark the position of the feature in @xmath87 : a local minimum in @xmath19 and a mid - point of the transition between two different field - dependent regimes ( see _ e.g. _ 0.8 k curve)in @xmath88 .
curves in the ( b ) panel were obtained by differentiation of the 5-adjacent - points - smoothed @xmath25 data .
small downturn at @xmath98 koe in some @xmath88 curves ( panel ( b ) ) is most likely an artifact of using digital smoothing and differentiation.,title="fig:",width=283 ] ) , defined as ( a ) @xmath21 and ( b ) @xmath97 , measured at different temperatures . the curves , except for @xmath20 = 0.4 k ,
are shifted by ( a ) 0.02 n@xmath46 cm and ( b ) 0.1 n@xmath46 cm increments for clarity ; the triangles mark the position of the feature in @xmath87 : a local minimum in @xmath19 and a mid - point of the transition between two different field - dependent regimes ( see _ e.g. _ 0.8 k curve)in @xmath88 .
curves in the ( b ) panel were obtained by differentiation of the 5-adjacent - points - smoothed @xmath25 data .
small downturn at @xmath98 koe in some @xmath88 curves ( panel ( b ) ) is most likely an artifact of using digital smoothing and differentiation.,title="fig:",width=283 ] | temperature- and field - dependent hall effect measurements are reported for ybagge , a heavy fermion compound exhibiting a field - induced quantum phase transition , and for two other closely related members of the ragge series : a non - magnetic analogue , luagge and a representative , good local moment , magnetic material , tmagge . whereas the temperature dependent
hall coefficient of ybagge shows behavior similar to what has been observed in a number of heavy fermion compounds , the low temperature , field - dependent measurements reveal well defined , sudden changes with applied field ; in specific for @xmath0 a clear local maximum that sharpens as temperature is reduced below 2 k and that approaches a value of 45 koe - a value that has been proposed as the @xmath1 quantum critical point .
similar behavior was observed for @xmath2 where a clear minimum in the field - dependent hall resistivity was observed at low temperatures .
although at our base temperatures it is difficult to distinguish between the field - dependent behavior predicted for ( i ) diffraction off a critical spin density wave or ( ii ) breakdown in the composite nature of the heavy electron , for both field directions there is a distinct temperature dependence of a feature that can clearly be associated with a field - induced quantum critical point at @xmath1 persisting up to at least 2 k. |
a subset @xmath4 of a metric space is a _ @xmath0-distance set _ if there are exactly @xmath0 non - zero distances occuring between points of @xmath4 .
we also call a @xmath5-distance set an _
equilateral set .
_ in this paper we find upper bounds for the cardinalities of @xmath0-distance sets in _ minkowski spaces _ , i.e. finite - dimensional banach spaces ( see theorems [ tha ] to [ up ] ) , and make a conjecture concerning tight upper bounds . in euclidean spaces
@xmath0-distance sets have been studied extensively ; see e.g. @xcite , and the books @xcite and ( * ? ? ? * and f3 ) . for general @xmath1-dimensional minkowski spaces
it is known that the maximum cardinality of an equilateral set is @xmath6 , with equality iff the unit ball of the space is a parallelotope , and that if @xmath7 , there always exists an equilateral set of at least @xmath8 points @xcite .
it is unknown whether there always exists an equilateral set of @xmath9 points ; see @xcite and ( * ? ? ?
* , p. 308
problem 4.1.1 ) .
however , brass @xcite recently proved that for each @xmath10 there is a @xmath11 such that any @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space has an equilateral set of at least @xmath10 points .
see @xcite for problems on equilateral sets in @xmath12 spaces .
equilateral sets in minkowski spaces have been used in @xcite to construct energy - minimizing cones over wire - frames .
see also @xcite .
as far as we know , @xmath0-distance sets for @xmath13 have not been studied in spaces other than euclidean .
our main results are the following .
[ tha ] if the unit ball of a @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space is a parallelotope , then a @xmath0-distance set in @xmath14 has cardinality at most @xmath2 .
this bound is tight .
[ cor1 ] given any set @xmath4 of @xmath10 points in a @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space with a parallelotope as unit ball , there exists a point in @xmath4 from which there are at least @xmath15 distinct non - zero distances to points in @xmath4 .
this bound is tight .
[ thb ] the cardinality of a @xmath0-distance set in a @xmath3-dimensional minkowski space is at most @xmath16 , with equality iff the space has a parallelogram as unit ball .
[ cor2 ] given any set of @xmath10 points in a @xmath3-dimensional minkowski space , there exists a point in @xmath4 from which there are at least @xmath17 distinct non - zero distances to points in @xmath4 . [ up ]
the cardinality of a @xmath0-distance set in a @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space is at most @xmath18 . in the light of theorems
[ tha ] and [ thb ] and the results of @xcite , we make the following the cardinality of a @xmath0-distance set in any @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space is at most @xmath19 , with equality iff the unit ball is a parallelotope .
as mentioned above , @xcite shows that this conjecture is true for @xmath20 . by theorem [ thb ]
the conjecture is true if @xmath21 , and by theorem [ tha ] if the unit ball is a parallelotope . in the sequel
, @xmath22 is a @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space with norm @xmath23 , @xmath24 is the closed ball with centre @xmath25 and radius @xmath26 , and @xmath27 the _ unit ball _ of the space .
recall that two @xmath1-dimensional minkowski spaces are isometric iff their unit balls are affinely equivalent ( by the mazur - ulam theorem ; see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.1.2 ) ) .
in particular , a minkowski space has a parallelotope as unit ball iff it is isometric to @xmath28 , where @xmath29 .
we define a _ cone _
( or more precisely , an _ acute cone _ ) @xmath30 to be a convex set in @xmath31 that is positively homogeneous ( i.e. , for any @xmath32 and @xmath33 we have @xmath34 ) and satisfies @xmath35 . recall that such a cone defines a partial order on @xmath31 by @xmath36 .
we denote the cardinality of a set @xmath4 by @xmath37 . for measurable @xmath38 ,
let @xmath39 denote the lebesgue measure of @xmath4 . for later reference we state lyusternik s version of the brunn - minkowski inequality ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 8.1.1 ) ) . if @xmath40 are compact , then @xmath41 if equality holds and @xmath42 , then @xmath43 and @xmath44 are convex bodies such that @xmath45 for some @xmath46 and @xmath47 .
we may assume without loss of generality that the space is @xmath48 .
we introduce partial orders on @xmath31 following blokhuis and wilbrink @xcite . for each @xmath49 , let @xmath50 be the partial order with cone @xmath51 for each @xmath25 in a @xmath0-distance set @xmath4 , let @xmath52 be the length of the longest descending @xmath50-chain starting with @xmath25 , i.e. @xmath52 is the largest @xmath53 such that there exist @xmath54 for which @xmath55 .
since @xmath56 , for all distinct @xmath57 there exists @xmath58 such that @xmath59 or @xmath60 .
exactly as in @xcite , it follows that the mapping @xmath61 is injective , and thus @xmath62 , where @xmath63 it remains to show that @xmath64 .
suppose not .
then for some @xmath65 and some @xmath58 there exist @xmath66 such that @xmath67 . since @xmath4 is a @xmath0-distance set , @xmath68 for some @xmath69 .
also , @xmath70 .
now note that if @xmath71 with @xmath72 , then @xmath73 and @xmath74 are @xmath50-incomparable ; in particular , @xmath75 .
therefore , @xmath76 , a contradiction .
the set @xmath77 is a @xmath0-distance set of cardinality @xmath2 .
note that it is not difficult to see that in fact the only @xmath0-distance sets of cardinality @xmath2 are of the form @xmath78 for some @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
consider the mapping @xmath81 in the proof of theorem [ tha ] . if @xmath53 is the length of the longest @xmath82-chain over all @xmath58 , then @xmath83 .
thus there is a @xmath82-chain @xmath84 of length @xmath85 . by the last paragraph of the proof of theorem [ tha ] , the distances @xmath86 are all distinct .
any @xmath87 such that @xmath88 has exactly @xmath15 distinct distances in the norm @xmath89 .
the following corollary is easily gleaned from the proof of theorem [ tha ] .
[ cor ] suppose that @xmath90 is a family of cones in a minkowski space @xmath91 satisfying @xmath92 and @xmath93 then a @xmath0-distance set in @xmath91 has cardinality at most @xmath94 .
[ metriclemma ] let @xmath4 be a @xmath0-distance set in a metric space @xmath95 with distances @xmath96 .
if @xmath97 , then for some @xmath98 , the relation @xmath99 is an equivalence relation .
the relation @xmath100 is reflexive and symmetric .
if it is not transitive , there exist @xmath101 such that @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
thus @xmath104 .
if this holds for all @xmath98 , we obtain @xmath105 .
[ up1 ] the cardinality of a @xmath0-distance set in a @xmath1-dimensional minkowski space is at most @xmath106 .
let @xmath107 be a @xmath0-distance set with distances @xmath96 .
set @xmath108 .
then we have @xmath109 also , @xmath110 , since if @xmath111 , there exist @xmath58 and @xmath112 such that @xmath113 , @xmath114 .
thus @xmath115 therefore , @xmath116 substituting and into the brunn - minkowski inequality @xmath117 we obtain @xmath118 , and @xmath119 .
if @xmath120 , there is nothing to prove .
otherwise , @xmath121 , and by lemma [ metriclemma ] , @xmath122 is an equivalence relation for some @xmath123 . by induction on @xmath0
we obtain that each equivalence class , being an @xmath58-distance set , has at most @xmath124 points . by choosing a representative from each equivalence class ,
we obtain a @xmath125-distance set with at most @xmath126 points
. therefore , @xmath127 . in the proof of theorem [ thb ] ,
we need the following geometric lemma , which is a modification of ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 3.2.6 ) in @xmath3 dimensions .
[ auerbach ] let @xmath128 be the convex hull of @xmath129 and @xmath130 the square @xmath131 ^ 2 $ ] . for any symmetric convex disc @xmath132 in @xmath133 there exists an invertible linear transformation taking @xmath132 to @xmath134 such that @xmath135 and such that any straight - line segment contained in the boundary of @xmath134 lies completely in one of the four coordinate quadrants .
we consider all triangles with vertices @xmath136 , where @xmath25 and @xmath137 are on the boundary of @xmath132 . by compactness there
exist @xmath138 and @xmath139 such that the area of the triangle is a maximum .
then @xmath140 is a support line of @xmath132 at @xmath138 , since otherwise we can replace @xmath138 by a point on the side of the line opposite @xmath141 to enlarge the area of the triangle .
similarly , @xmath142 is a support line of @xmath132 at @xmath139 .
since @xmath132 is symmetric , it follows that @xmath132 is contained in the parallelogram @xmath143 .
see figure [ auerfig ] .
if @xmath138 is an interior point of a straight - line segment contained in the boundary of @xmath132 , we may shift @xmath138 to a boundary point of such a segment , without changing the area of the triangle .
thus @xmath132 is still contained in a parallelogram as above .
a similar remark holds for @xmath139 .
we now apply the linear transformation sending @xmath138 and @xmath139 to the standard unit vectors @xmath144 and @xmath145 , respectively ( see figure [ auerfig2 ] ) .
we have to find two cones @xmath146 and @xmath147 satisfying and of corollary [ cor ] . by lemma [ auerbach ]
we may replace the space by an isometric space @xmath148 such that the unit ball @xmath44 of @xmath23 lies between @xmath128 and @xmath130 , and such that any straight - line segment contained in the boundary of the unit ball lies completely in a quadrant of the plane .
we provisionally let @xmath146 be the closed first quadrant , and @xmath147 the closed second quadrant .
see figure [ auerfig2 ] . then is satisfied .
the only way that could fail is if there is a straight - line segment contained in the boundary of the unit ball parallel to either the x - axis or the y - axis , lying in @xmath146 or @xmath147 .
if there is a segment in the boundary of the unit ball in @xmath146 parallel to the x - axis , say , we remove the positive x - axis @xmath149 from @xmath146 .
if in this case there were another straight - line segment in the boundary parallel to the x - axis in @xmath147 , then there would be a straight - line segment in the boundary lying in the first and second quadrants , giving a contradiction .
thus we do not have to remove the negative x - axis from @xmath147 , and is still satisfied .
we do the same thing for segments parallel to the y - axis , and for @xmath147 . in the end ,
the modified @xmath146 and @xmath147 satisfy and , and we deduce @xmath150 from corollary [ cor ] .
if equality holds , then the mapping @xmath151 in the proof of theorem [ tha ] is a bijection from @xmath4 to @xmath152 .
we now denote a point @xmath65 by @xmath153 , where @xmath154 .
suppose that two of the distances @xmath155 ( @xmath156 ) are equal , say @xmath157 with @xmath158 .
then , since @xmath159 , we have @xmath160 , contradicting .
it follows that the distances @xmath155 , @xmath156 are distinct , and thus are exactly the @xmath0 different distances in increasing order .
similarly , the distances @xmath161 , @xmath162 are in increasing order . if @xmath163 , the three points @xmath164 again contradict .
thus these distances are @xmath165 in increasing order , etc . in the end
we find that @xmath166 for all @xmath58 .
thus @xmath167 , by the triangle inequality . using the brunn - minkowski inequality as in the proof of lemma [ up1 ]
, we find that equality holds in and , implying that for @xmath168 we have @xmath169 , and @xmath170 and @xmath171 are homothetic .
thus @xmath171 is a ball that is perfectly packed by smaller balls . by a result of @xcite
, this implies that the unit ball is a parallelogram
. follows from the proof of theorem [ thb ] in the same way that theorem [ cor1 ] follows from theorem [ tha ] .
lemma [ up1 ] already gives part of the theorem . for the remaining part we apply corollary [ cor ] . in order for a cone @xmath30 to satisfy ,
it is sufficient that @xmath172 to see this , suppose that @xmath30 does not satisfy the condition in , i.e. there exist distinct @xmath173 such that @xmath174 and @xmath175 .
let @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , and @xmath179 .
then @xmath180 , and @xmath181 implying @xmath182 . in order for to be satisfied too
, we need a cover of the unit sphere by sets such that , if they are extended to positive cones , are convex .
we do this with the following construction : let @xmath183 be a maximal set of unit vectors satisfying @xmath184 for all @xmath185 .
then for any unit vector @xmath25 there exists @xmath58 such that @xmath186 or @xmath187 . for @xmath188 ,
let @xmath189 be the cone generated by @xmath190 i.e. @xmath191 .
then the @xmath189 s satisfy by the maximality of @xmath132 .
each @xmath189 satisfies : let @xmath192 , where @xmath193 and @xmath194 .
then @xmath195 also , since @xmath196 we obtain @xmath197 , and @xmath198 . a volume argument gives the upper bound for @xmath199 : the balls @xmath200 have disjoint interiors and are contained in the ball @xmath201 .
therefore , @xmath202 giving @xmath203 .
this paper is part of the author s phd thesis written under supervision of prof .
w. l. fouch at the university of pretoria .
i thank the referees as well as graham brightwell for their suggestions on the layout of the paper . | a subset of a metric space is a _ @xmath0-distance set _ if there are exactly @xmath0 non - zero distances occuring between points .
we conjecture that a @xmath0-distance set in a @xmath1-dimensional banach space ( or _ minkowski space _ ) , contains at most @xmath2 points , with equality iff the unit ball is a parallelotope .
we solve this conjecture in the affirmative for all @xmath3-dimensional spaces and for spaces where the unit ball is a parallelotope .
for general spaces we find various weaker upper bounds for @xmath0-distance sets . |
computer simulation is widely regarded as complementary to theory and experiment @xcite . at present
there are only a few physical phenomena that can not be simulated on a computer .
one such exception is the double - slit experiment with single electrons , as carried out by tonomura and his co - workers @xcite .
this experiment is carried out in such a way that at any given time , only one electron travels from the source to the detector @xcite . only after a substantial ( approximately 50000 ) amount of electrons
have been detected an interference pattern emerges @xcite .
this interference pattern is described by quantum theory .
we use the term `` quantum theory '' for the mathematical formalism that gives us a set of algorithms to compute the probability for observing a particular event @xcite .
of course , the quantum - mechanics textbook example @xcite of a double - slit can be simulated on a computer by solving the time - dependent schrdinger equation for a wave packet impinging on the double slit @xcite .
alternatively , in order to obtain the observed interference pattern we could simply use random numbers to generate events according to the probability distribution that is obtained by solving the time - independent schrdinger equation . however , that is not what we mean when we say that the physical phenomenon can not be simulated on a computer .
the point is that it is not known how to simulate , event - by - event , the experimental observation that the interference pattern appears only after a considerable number of events have been recorded on the detector .
quantum theory does not describe the individual events , e.g. the arrival of a single electron at a particular position on the detection screen @xcite . reconciling the mathematical formalism (
that does not describe single events ) with the experimental fact that each observation yields a definite outcome is often referred to as the quantum measurement paradox and is the central , most fundamental problem in the foundation of quantum theory @xcite . if computer simulation is indeed a third methodology to model physical phenomena it should be possible to simulate experiments such as the two - slit experiment on an event - by - event basis . in view of
the fundamental problem alluded to above there is little hope that we can find a simulation algorithm within the framework of quantum theory .
however , if we think of quantum theory as a set of algorithms to compute probability distributions there is nothing that prevents us from stepping outside the framework that quantum theory provides . therefore we may formulate the physical processes in terms of events , messages , and algorithms that process these events and messages , and try to invent algorithms that simulate the physical processes . obviously , to make progress along this line of thought
, it makes sense not to tackle the double - slit experiment directly but to simplify the problem while retaining the fundamental problem that we aim to solve .
the main objective of the research reported in this paper is to answer the question : `` can we simulate the single - photon beam splitter and mach - zehnder interferometer experiments of grangier et al .
@xcite on an event - by - event basis ? '' .
these experiments display the same fundamental problem as the single - electron double - slit experiments but are significantly easier to describe in terms of algorithms .
the main results of our research are that we can give an affirmative answer to the above question by using algorithms that have a primitive form of learning capability and that the simulation approach that we propose can be used to simulate other quantum systems ( including the double - slit experiment ) as well . in section [ illu ]
we introduce the basic concepts for constructing event - based , deterministic learning machines ( ) .
an essential property of these machines is that they process input event after input event and do not store information about individual events .
a can discover relations between input events ( if there are any ) and responds by sending its acquired knowledge in the form of another event ( carrying a message ) through one of its output channels . by connecting an output channel to the input channel of another we can build networks of . as the input of a network receives an event , the corresponding message is routed through the network while it is being processed and eventually a message appears at one of the outputs . at any given time during the processing , there is only one input - output connection in the network that is actually carrying a message .
the process the messages in a sequential manner and communicate with each other by message passing .
there is no other form of communication between different .
although networks of can be viewed as networks that are capable of unsupervised learning , there have very little in common with neural networks @xcite .
the first described in section [ illu ] is equivalent to a standard linear adaptive filter @xcite but the that we actually use for our applications do not fall into this class of algorithms . in section [ ndim ]
we generalize the ideas of section [ illu ] and construct a which groups @xmath0-dimensional data in two classes on an event - by - event basis , i.e. , without using memory to store the whole data set .
we demonstrate that this is capable of detecting time - dependent trends in the data and performs blind classification .
this example shows that can be used to solve problems that have no relation to quantum physics . in section [ qi ]
we show how to construct -networks that generate output patterns that are usually thought of as being of quantum mechanical origin .
we first build a -network that simulates photons passing through a polarizer and show that quantum theory describes the output of this deterministic , event - based network .
then we describe a -network that simulates a beam splitter and use this network to build a mach - zehnder interferometer and two chained mach - zehnder interferometers .
we demonstrate that quantum theory also describes the behavior of these networks .
quantum theory gives us a recipe to compute the frequency of events but does not predict the order in which the events will be observed @xcite .
in genuine experiments the detection of events appears to be random @xcite , in a sense which , as far as we know , has not been studied systematically . in our simulation approach , this apparent randomness can be accounted for by a marginal modification of the , as explained in section [ slm ] .
this modification does not change the deterministic character of the learning process .
it merely randomizes the order in which the activate their output channels .
a summary and outlook is given in section [ summ ] .
we consider a that has one input and two output channels labeled by @xmath1 ( see fig . 1 ) .
the internal state of the after processing the @xmath2-th input event ( @xmath3 ) is uniquely defined by the real variable @xmath4 . at the next event
@xmath5 the receives as input a real number @xmath6 . for simplicity , but without loss of generality , we assume that @xmath7 $ ]
. the responds by sending a message containing @xmath6 through one of the two output channels @xmath8 . the selects the output channel @xmath9 or @xmath10 by minimizing the cost function @xmath11 defined by @xmath12 updates its internal state according to the rule @xmath13 and sends a message with the input value @xmath6 on the selected output channel @xmath14 . the parameter @xmath15 that enters eqs . and controls the decision process . for simplicity
we assume that @xmath16 is fixed during the operation of the machine .
it is easy to see that @xmath9
if @xmath17 and @xmath10 if @xmath18 . thus , for this particular we have @xmath19 hence the update rule eq . can be written as the familiar recursion @xmath20 the solution of eq .
reads @xmath21 where @xmath22 denotes the initial value of the internal variable . as an illustration of how this learns
, we consider the most simple example where @xmath23 for all @xmath24 .
then from eq .
we find that @xmath25 as @xmath15 , we conclude that @xmath26 .
thus the `` learns '' the value of the input variable @xmath27 . from eq .
it follows that @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) implies @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) .
hence @xmath4 approaches @xmath27 monotonically ( and @xmath32 is the same for all @xmath2 ) .
therefore , if @xmath33 , the always sends the value of @xmath34 through the same output channel .
( 8,6 ) ( -5,1 ) by passing the input to one of the two output channels @xmath8 .
the value of @xmath14 depends on the current state of the , encoded in the variable @xmath35 , the input @xmath6 , and the update rule eq .
in which @xmath16 appears as a control parameter .
right : evolution of the internal variable @xmath35 as a function of the number of events @xmath2 .
solid line : @xmath36 for @xmath37 and @xmath38 for @xmath39 ; dashed line : random sequence of @xmath40 .
, title="fig:",width=340 ] ( 4,0 ) by passing the input to one of the two output channels @xmath8 .
the value of @xmath14 depends on the current state of the , encoded in the variable @xmath35 , the input @xmath6 , and the update rule eq .
in which @xmath16 appears as a control parameter .
right : evolution of the internal variable @xmath35 as a function of the number of events @xmath2 .
solid line : @xmath36 for @xmath37 and @xmath38 for @xmath39 ; dashed line : random sequence of @xmath40 .
, title="fig:",width=340 ] a distinct feature of this machine is its ability to adapt to changes in the input pattern .
we illustrate this important property by two examples .
let @xmath41 for @xmath42 and @xmath43 for @xmath44 . during the first 1000 events the machine will learn @xmath45 . after 1000 events
only @xmath46 is being presented as input .
then , the machine `` forgets '' @xmath45 and learns @xmath46 as shown in the right panel of fig .
[ exam01 ] . in this simulation @xmath47 . alternatively ,
if @xmath34 is a random sequence of @xmath48 ( each with the same probability ) the machine has to learn @xmath45 and @xmath46 simultaneously . because of this it can not `` forget '' and it ends up oscillating around the mean of the input values ( zero in this example ) as illustrated in the right panel of fig .
[ exam01 ] .
let us now assume that our machine has reached this oscillating state .
all input events @xmath49 give @xmath50 and hence the machine sends @xmath46 over the @xmath51 channel . a second machine attached to this channel only receives @xmath46 events and will learn @xmath46 .
this suggests that a network of these machines can be used as an adaptive classifier .
( 8,12 ) ( -4.5,3 ) .
right : evolution of the internal variables @xmath35 of the as a function of the number of events @xmath2 . the machine number is used to label the corresponding line .
top right : first three ; bottom right : third - level
. , title="fig:",width=302 ] ( 4,6 ) .
right : evolution of the internal variables @xmath35 of the as a function of the number of events @xmath2 . the machine number is used to label the corresponding line .
top right : first three ; bottom right : third - level
. , title="fig:",width=340 ] ( 4,0 ) .
right : evolution of the internal variables @xmath35 of the as a function of the number of events @xmath2 . the machine number is used to label the corresponding line .
top right : first three ; bottom right : third - level . ,
title="fig:",width=340 ] consider the network of three layers of shown in the left panel of fig .
[ exam03 ] .
each machine in the network learns the average of the numbers it receives at its input channel and sends the numbers which are smaller ( larger or equal ) than the number it learned to the -1 ( + 1 ) output channel . in our numerical experiments we set @xmath47 .
we start with 5000 events of random numbers @xmath52 , each occurring with equal probability .
machine 1 learns the average ( zero in this example ) and sends the negative ( positive ) @xmath6 over the @xmath53 ( @xmath51 ) channel to the input of machine 2 ( 3 ) .
machine 2 ( 3 ) learns -0.50 ( 0.50 ) , as shown in the top right panel of fig .
[ exam03 ] , and sends -0.75 ( 0.25 ) over its -1 output channel and -0.25 ( 0.75 ) over its + 1 output channel .
machines 4 to 7 learn -0.75,-0.25,0.25 and 0.75 , respectively , as shown in the bottom right panel of fig .
[ exam03 ] .
each of these machines forwards the received input on its + 1 ( -1 ) output channel if the initial value of its internal variable is smaller ( larger ) than the received input value .
let us now assume that after 5000 events the input data set changes to @xmath54 . as can be seen from the right panel of fig .
[ exam03 ] , machines 1 , 3 and 7 `` forget '' the number they learned and replace it by -0.0625 , 0.375 and 0.50 , respectively .
all other machines are unaffected because they never get 0.50 as input .
after another 5000 events we change the set of input values once more , this time to @xmath55 , i.e. , we add one element .
now , machine 1 learns -0.17 , machine 2 learns -0.53 and the internal state of machine 3 remains unchanged .
machine 4 can now receive two numbers on its input channel , namely -0.75 and -0.60 . as a consequence , machine 4 learns -0.675 , i.e. , the average of the two possible input numbers .
machine 4 puts -0.60 on its + 1 output channel and -0.75 on its -1 output channel .
in order for the network to learn all the numbers of the input set , we would have to attach one extra to each output channel of machine 4 .
( 8,6 ) ( -5,0 ) of the machine defined by eqs . and .
the input events are @xmath56 , @xmath47 , and the initial value @xmath57 .
for @xmath58 the internal variable @xmath4 oscillates about @xmath27 . for @xmath59 the sequence of increments ( @xmath9 ) and decrements ( @xmath10 ) of @xmath4 repeats itself after 8 events ( data not shown ) .
lines are guides to the eyes .
right : the number of increments of the internal variable ( @xmath9 ) divided by the total number of events as a function of the value of the input variable @xmath27 .
bullets : each data point is obtained from a simulation of 1000 events with a fixed , randomly chosen value of @xmath60 , using the last 500 events to count the number of @xmath9 events . solid line : @xmath61 . , title="fig:",width=340 ] ( 4,0 ) of the machine defined by eqs . and .
the input events are @xmath56 , @xmath47 , and the initial value @xmath57 . for @xmath58 the internal variable @xmath4 oscillates about @xmath27 . for @xmath59 the sequence of increments ( @xmath9 ) and decrements ( @xmath10 ) of @xmath4 repeats itself after 8 events ( data not shown ) .
lines are guides to the eyes .
right : the number of increments of the internal variable ( @xmath9 ) divided by the total number of events as a function of the value of the input variable @xmath27 . bullets : each data point is obtained from a simulation of 1000 events with a fixed , randomly chosen value of @xmath60 , using the last 500 events to count the number of @xmath9 events . solid line : @xmath61 .
, title="fig:",width=340 ] for the defined by eqs . and ,
formulating the operation of the through the minimization of the difference between the input and internal variable may seem a little superfluous and indeed , for this particular machine it is . however , this formulation is a convenient starting point for defining machines that can perform more intricate tasks .
for instance , let us make an innocent looking change to the update rule eq .
by writing @xmath62 and replace the cost function eq . by the corresponding expression @xmath63 for @xmath9 we have @xmath64 and for @xmath10 we have @xmath65 .
therefore , if @xmath66 and @xmath67 , the internal variable will always be in the range @xmath68 $ ] . at each event
the internal variable either increases by @xmath69 ( if @xmath9 ) or decreases by @xmath70 ( if @xmath10 ) . in both cases
this change is always nonzero , except if @xmath71 which can only occur if @xmath72 .
the ratio of the step sizes is @xmath73 .
the machine defined by eqs . and behaves differently from the machine defined by eqs . and .
to see this , it is instructive to consider the case @xmath74 for all @xmath24 ( the case @xmath75 can be treated in the same manner ) . for concreteness
we assume that @xmath76 . at the first event ,
minimization of eq .
yields @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
in other words , the internal variable @xmath79 moves towards @xmath27 . as long as @xmath80 , the selects @xmath9 , always increasing its internal variable @xmath4 .
for some some @xmath81 we must have @xmath82 . then , making another move in the positive @xmath79-direction allows for two different decisions .
if the error that results is larger than the error that is obtained by moving in the negative direction the decides to set @xmath10 .
otherwise it makes another move in the positive @xmath79-direction ( @xmath9 ) . in any case , for some @xmath83 the machine will select @xmath10 .
note that when this happens , we must have @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
this implies that after this @xmath2-th event ( that we denote by @xmath86 ) the internal variable will oscillate ( forever ) around the input value @xmath27 .
this process is illustrated in fig .
[ figline ] ( left ) .
for @xmath87 we have @xmath88 . thus , if @xmath89 , the amplitude of the oscillations is small .
the `` learns '' the input value @xmath27 and the ratio of the increments to decrements is @xmath90 . in this stationary regime of oscillating behavior ,
the number of times the actives the + 1 ( -1 ) channel is given by @xmath61 ( @xmath91 ) .
the simulation results shown in fig .
[ figline ] ( right ) confirm the correctness of this analysis .
for a fixed ( unknown ) value of the input variable , the rate at which the machine defined by the rules eqs . and activates one of its output channels is determined by the value of its internal variable .
therefore , this rate reflects the value that the machine has learned by processing the input events . depending on the application ,
the message that is sent through the active output channel can contain @xmath92 or the input value @xmath6 ( there is nothing else that can be send ) .
obviously we can make the learning process more precise by increasing @xmath93 .
of course , a larger value of @xmath16 also results in slower learning : in general it will take more events for the internal variable to reach the value where it starts to oscillate . in going from the first to the second example of section [ illu ] we changed the update rule such that the variable @xmath4 is constrained to lie in the interval @xmath68 $ ] .
we now consider the two - dimensional analogue of the described in section [ illub ] for which the internal vector @xmath94 and input vector @xmath95 represent points on a circle .
this receives as input a sequence of angles @xmath96 defined by @xmath97 and responds by activating one of the two output channels . for all @xmath98 ,
the update rules are defined by @xmath99 where @xmath100 and @xmath15 . in order that the internal vector @xmath101 stays on the unit circle
we must have @xmath102 \pm\sqrt{1-\alpha^2+\alpha^2[x_{1,n}^2\theta_{n+1 } + x_{2,n}^2(1-\theta_{n+1 } ) ] } .
\label{circ2}\ ] ] substitution of eq . in eq .
gives us four different rules : @xmath103 where @xmath104 takes care of the fact that for each choice of @xmath105 , the has to decide between two quadrants .
the cost function is defined by @xmath106 obviously , the cost function eq .
is nothing but the inner product of the vectors @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
the new internal state itself is determined by calculating the cost eq . for each of the four candidate update rules listed in eq . and selecting the rule that yields the minimum cost .
note that the minimum of the cost function eq . does not depend on the length of the vector of input variables @xmath95 . from eq .
it follows that if @xmath109 .
the value of @xmath110 is obtained by rescaling of @xmath111 and @xmath112 is adjusted such that @xmath113 . for @xmath114 we interchange
the role of the first and second element of @xmath107 .
( 8,6 ) ( -5,0 ) ( 4,0 ) in general the behavior of the defined by rules eqs . and is difficult to analyze without the use of a computer .
however , for a fixed input vector @xmath115 it is clear what the will try to do : it will minimize the cost eq . by rotating its internal vector @xmath107 to bring it as close as possible to @xmath116 .
however , @xmath107 will not converge to a limiting value but instead it will keep oscillating about the input value @xmath116 .
an example of a simulation is given in fig .
[ c30 ] ( left ) . for a fixed input vector
@xmath115 the reaches a stationary state in which its internal vector oscillates about @xmath116 . in this stationary state
the output signal consists of a finite sequence of ones and zeros .
the repeats this sequence over and over again . obviously , the whole process is deterministic .
the details of the approach to the stationary state depend on the initial value of the internal vector @xmath117 , but the stationary state itself does not .
these observations are of much more general nature than the example given in fig .
[ c30 ] ( left ) suggests .
in fact , as the applications discussed below amply illustrate , the stationary - state analysis is a very useful tool to predict the behavior of the . assuming that @xmath89 and that we have reached the stationary regime in which the internal vector performs small oscillations about @xmath118 , a simple calculation shows that @xmath119 in the stationary regime , we have @xmath120 where @xmath121 ( @xmath122 ) is the number of @xmath109 ( @xmath114 ) events . from eq .
it then follows immediately that @xmath123 and @xmath124 .
the results of this analysis are in excellent agreement with the simulation results shown in fig .
[ c30 ] ( right ) . the conventional approach to regard the variables @xmath105 as
input is fundamentally different from the approach adopted in this paper .
this can be seen by reformulating the update rules in terms of difference equations and to assume that the @xmath100 are independent , uniform random variables with mean @xmath125 .
the four rules eq . can be written as @xmath126 formally eq .
has the same structure as eq . .
averaging over many realizations of @xmath127 and taking the limit @xmath128 we obtain @xmath129 in other words , a machine that operates according to the rules eq . and
receives as input the random sequence @xmath105 will ( on average ) approach a state in which the direction of its internal vector gives us an estimate of the @xmath130 .
in contrast , a that minimizes the cost eq . and updates its internal state according to eq .
responds on either output channel @xmath109 or output channel @xmath114 , with a frequency that is directly related to the difference between the current input angle and the angle defined by the internal vector .
consider a sequence of events , characterized by vectors @xmath131 for @xmath98 .
the vector @xmath108 is the input for the .
the internal state of the is described by a @xmath0-dimensional unit vector @xmath132 .
we define the @xmath133 candidate update rules @xmath134 by @xmath135 note that @xmath136 implies @xmath137 for each of the @xmath133 update rules .
the responds to the input @xmath108 by selecting from the @xmath133 possible rules in eq . ,
the update rule that minimizes the cost @xmath138 and by sending a message containing @xmath108 ( or , depending on the application , @xmath107 ) on one of its output channels .
note that the minimum of the cost function eq . does not depend on the length of the vectors @xmath107 or @xmath108 . disregarding the variables @xmath139 that merely serve to determine the sign of @xmath140 there are @xmath0 rules .
hence there can be as many as @xmath0 output channels .
however , depending on the application , it may be expedient to reduce the number of output channels by arranging them in groups .
the analyzed in the previous subsections have one input channel that receives input and two output channels , only one of which sends out data ( a message ) at a particular event .
an obvious generalization is to construct that accept , at a given instance , input from one out of two different sources .
this is absolutely necessary if we want to build machines in which events can communicate or , in physical terms , interact with each other .
we now demonstrate that the that we introduced above already have the capability to let events interact with each other .
therefore we do not need to add a new feature or rule to the .
consider a that has two input channels 0 and 1 and an internal vector @xmath141 with @xmath142 components . at the @xmath5-th event , either input channel 0 receives the two - component vector @xmath143 or input channel 1 receives the two - component vector @xmath144 . in the former case
the transforms this input into the input vector @xmath145 of four elements by using the current internal vector as a source for the missing elements .
similarly , in the latter case the input vector becomes @xmath146 .
then the uses @xmath147 to determine the cost and selects the update rule according to the procedure described in section [ hyp ] ( with @xmath147 replacing @xmath108 ) .
this learns the two - dimensional vectors @xmath143 and @xmath144 separately , as if it consists of two separate , independent two - dimensional , with the additional crucial feature that the internal vector represents a point on a 4-dimensional unit sphere .
it is not difficult to imagine what this does in the case that it receives events on only one of the two input channels ( say 0 ) .
irrespective of the initial value of the internal vector @xmath148 , the will always select the update rule with @xmath149 ( see eq . ) and the two components @xmath150 and @xmath151 will vanish exponentially fast with increasing @xmath2 ( recall that @xmath15 ) .
thus , after a few events the internal state of the indicates that the receives events on only one channel .
if the machine receives input on both channels ( but never simultaneously ) , eq
. implies that the only scales the two components of the internal state that it uses to provide the missing elements for building the input @xmath147 .
therefore , in the stationary regime , the length of the two - dimensional vector @xmath94 ( @xmath152 ) is proportional to the number of events on input channel 0 ( 1 ) .
furthermore the number of @xmath149 ( @xmath153 ) events is approximately equal to the number of events on input channel 0 ( 1 ) .
although this may seem a very elementary form of communication , it is sufficient to construct that perform very complicated tasks .
the described above are simple deterministic machines that make decisions .
the responds to the input event by choosing from all possible alternatives , the internal state that minimizes the error between the input and the internal state itself .
then the sends a message through one of its output channels .
the message contains information about the decision the took while updating its internal state and , depending on the application , also contains other data that the can provide . by updating its internal state ,
the learns " about the input it receives and by sending messages through one of its two output channels , it tells its environment about what it has learned . in the sequel
we will call such a machine a * deterministic learning machine * ( dlm ) . for a particular choice of the update rule ( see section [ illua ] ) , the performs linear estimation but as the other examples of this section amply demonstrate , minor modifications to this rule and/or cost function yield that may behave in a substantially different manner .
the of section [ illua ] learns about the input data by moving a point on a line .
obviously , this point separates two parts of the line .
the generalization to @xmath0-dimensional space is a @xmath154-dimensional hyperplane that divides the space into two parts .
thus , to interpret two - dimensional data the should learn a line instead of a point .
we represent the line by a segment @xmath155 defined by its mid - point @xmath156 and its direction @xmath157 . as the receives an event @xmath108 , i.e. a point in a two - dimensional plane , the updates its internal line segment @xmath155 and sends the information describing @xmath155 through the -1 ( + 1 ) channel , depending on whether it lies on the left ( right ) side of the line .
the update procedure consists of two steps .
first we define two support points @xmath158 and @xmath159 on either side of @xmath156 along the direction @xmath157 by @xmath160 and we update the two support points according to @xmath161 where @xmath15 controls the learning process . then we compute the new mid - point and direction of the line segment : @xmath162 from eq .
it follows that the support point farthest away from @xmath108 makes the largest move .
therefore , as new input data is received by the , both the mid - point and the direction of the line segment change . note that the update rule eq .
is non - linear in the difference between internal and input vector .
although a linear update rule also works , our numerical experiments ( results not shown ) indicate that the non - linear rule eq
. performs much better . in general @xmath156
will converge to the mean of the input vectors and @xmath158 and @xmath159 will be pulled most strongly in the direction of largest variance
. therefore @xmath155 will be ( approximately ) perpendicular to the largest principal component of the covariance matrix of the input data .
in other words , the defined above can find the eigenvector that corresponds to the largest eigenvalue of the covariance matrix by processing data points in a sequential manner , i.e. , without actually having to compute the elements of the covariance matrix .
( 14,10 ) ( 0,5 ) and means @xmath163 .
each panel shows the output of the -based classifier after it has processed , point - by - point , the 100 data points shown .
the classifier smoothly follows the rotation of the means .
in contrast to the event - by - event processing of the -based classifier , the principal - component - based classifier processes the whole set of 100 data points simultaneously .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] ( 5,5 ) and means @xmath163 .
each panel shows the output of the -based classifier after it has processed , point - by - point , the 100 data points shown .
the classifier smoothly follows the rotation of the means .
in contrast to the event - by - event processing of the -based classifier , the principal - component - based classifier processes the whole set of 100 data points simultaneously .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] ( 10,5 ) and means @xmath163 .
each panel shows the output of the -based classifier after it has processed , point - by - point , the 100 data points shown .
the classifier smoothly follows the rotation of the means .
in contrast to the event - by - event processing of the -based classifier , the principal - component - based classifier processes the whole set of 100 data points simultaneously .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] ( 0,0 ) and means @xmath163 .
each panel shows the output of the -based classifier after it has processed , point - by - point , the 100 data points shown .
the classifier smoothly follows the rotation of the means .
in contrast to the event - by - event processing of the -based classifier , the principal - component - based classifier processes the whole set of 100 data points simultaneously .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] ( 5,0 ) and means @xmath163 .
each panel shows the output of the -based classifier after it has processed , point - by - point , the 100 data points shown .
the classifier smoothly follows the rotation of the means .
in contrast to the event - by - event processing of the -based classifier , the principal - component - based classifier processes the whole set of 100 data points simultaneously .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] ( 10,0 ) and means @xmath163 .
each panel shows the output of the -based classifier after it has processed , point - by - point , the 100 data points shown .
the classifier smoothly follows the rotation of the means .
in contrast to the event - by - event processing of the -based classifier , the principal - component - based classifier processes the whole set of 100 data points simultaneously .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] as an illustration of the capabilities of the introduced in this section , let us consider a classification task in which we want to blindly group events into two categories .
the input data @xmath143 are generated through a gaussian random process described by : @xmath164 where @xmath165 is a uniform random bit .
the random numbers @xmath166 and @xmath167 are drawn from the normal distribution @xmath168 . in our numerical example
we take @xmath169 and @xmath47 . from eq .
it is clear that the input events consist of points in a plane that are drawn from one of two ( @xmath170 ) gaussian distributions , the centers of which rotate with a period of 10000 events .
the mean of all input data is @xmath171 and there is no preferred direction of largest variance .
the reason of course is that the center of the gaussian distributions slowly moves on the unit circle .
clearly , this kind of classification task can only be performed by permanently updating the estimate of the direction and that is exactly what the does . in fig .
[ 2dp2 ] we present results of a blind classification experiment that illustrates the operation of the defined by the rules eqs .
the processes event - by - event , each time updating its estimate for the separatrix . for comparison
we also show the result obtained by the principal component analysis @xcite using as input the group of 100 most recent data points processed by the .
the differences between both classifiers are rather small so that it is clear that the -based classifier performs very well .
the two - dimensional described above can easily be extended to a that processes @xmath0-dimensional input data . instead of a line segment
the has to learn a segment of a @xmath154-dimensional hyperplane .
this can be done by extending the procedure used in the two - dimensional case .
the hyperplane segment is described by a mid - point @xmath156 and @xmath172 orthonormal directions @xmath173 for @xmath174 .
we choose @xmath0 points @xmath175 on the hyperplane defined by @xmath176 and @xmath156 such that the distance between each pair of points is one . as new input data @xmath108 is received by the these points
are updated according to ( the generalization of ) eq . .
as in the two - dimensional case , from the updated points we can calculate the new mid - point and the new directions .
however , unlike in the two - dimensional case , these directions do not need to be orthonormal .
the orthonormality is then restored by using the ( modified ) gramm - schmidt procedure @xcite .
( 14,7 ) ( -1.75,0 ) ( 7,0 ) [ p25 ] ( 14,7 ) ( -1.,0 ) ( 7,0 ) [ 3pol ]
we demonstrate that the defined by eqs . and and a passive element that performs a plane rotation are sufficient to perform a deterministic simulation of the quantum theory @xcite of photon polarization .
we start by recalling some elementary facts about photon polarization @xcite .
some optically active materials like calcite split an incoming beam of light into two spatially separated beams @xcite .
the light intensity of these beams is related to the angle of polarization @xmath177 of the electromagnetic wave , relative to the orientation @xmath178 of the material @xcite .
we disregard all imperfections of real experiments and assume that the experimental data are in exact agreement with the wave mechanical theory .
then the intensities @xmath179 of beam 0 and @xmath180 of beam 1 are given by @xcite @xmath181 respectively .
if the incident beam has a random polarization , averaging of eq .
over all @xmath177 shows that half of the light intensity will go to beam 0 and the other half to beam 1 .
if the conventional light source is replaced by a source that emits one photon at a time , the photon leaves the material either in the direction of beam 0 or beam 1 , never in both @xcite .
collecting photons over a sufficiently long period shows that eq .
still gives the number of photons detected in the direction of beam 0 ( 1 ) , divided by the total amount of detected photons @xcite .
quantum theory @xcite describes the polarization in terms of a two - dimensional ( complex - valued ) vector and the action of the material is to rotate this vector by an angle @xmath178 ( set by the experimentalist ) @xcite .
the probability to observe photons in beam 0 ( 1 ) is given by the square of the 0-th ( 1-st ) element of the vector @xcite .
in addition , as the photon leaves the material in beam 0 ( 1 ) , its polarization is @xmath178 ( @xmath182 ) @xcite .
thus the piece of material can be used to prepare and also determine the polarization of the photons and is called a `` polarizer '' @xcite . according to quantum theory @xcite , the polarizer rotates the vector of polarization amplitudes in the following manner @xcite : @xmath183 still according to quantum theory @xcite , the intensity in beam 0 ( 1 ) is given by @xmath184 ( @xmath185 ) .
an incident beam with an angle of polarization @xmath177 is described by the vector @xmath186 . from eq .
we obtain @xmath187 and hence @xmath188 and @xmath189 , in agreement with eq . .
we now construct a simple deterministic machine that generates events of which the distribution agrees with the probability distributions predicted by quantum theory @xcite .
the layout of this `` polarizer '' is shown in fig .
[ figpol ] . the incoming event ( photon ) carries an ( unknown ) angle @xmath190 .
the purpose of the passive element @xmath191 is to perform a rotation @xmath192 of the input vector @xmath193 by the angle @xmath178 .
the resulting vector @xmath194 is sent to the input of a that operates according to eqs . and . if @xmath109 , the responds by sending the vector @xmath195 through the output channel 0 .
if @xmath114 , the responds by sending the vector @xmath196 through the output channel 1 . clearly this procedure is strictly deterministic .
we emphasize that the processes information event by event and does not store the data contained in each event . in fig .
[ p25 ] ( right ) we show simulation results for the machine depicted in fig .
[ figpol ] ( left ) .
each data point represents the intensity in beam 0 ( 1 ) , i.e. , the number of @xmath197 @xmath198 events divided by the total amount of events .
the machine is initialized once by choosing a random direction of the vector @xmath148 .
the angle of rotation @xmath178 is kept fixed for 1000 events , then a uniform random number is used to select another direction , and this procedure is repeated 100 times . in all these numerical experiments we set @xmath47 . fig .
[ p25 ] shows the results for two different numerical experiments : in the first set of 100 runs , the direction of polarization @xmath177 of the incoming photons is also determined by means of uniform random numbers . in the second set of 100 runs , the direction of polarization of the incoming photons is fixed ( @xmath199 ) . from fig .
[ p25 ] ( right ) it is clear that quantum theory @xcite provides a very good description of the input - output behavior of the shown in fig .
[ figpol ] ( left ) . as a second illustration we use the same to simulate an experiment with three polarizers described by feynman @xcite .
the diagram of this experiment is shown in fig .
[ fig3pol ] .
a randomly polarized beam of photons passes through the first polarizer ( without loss of generality we set its angle @xmath200 equal to zero ) .
each output channel is used as input to another polarizer .
both these polarizers are tilted by the same angle @xmath201 . according to quantum theory @xcite ,
the intensity at the output of these four channels is ( from top to bottom , see fig .
[ fig3pol ] ) @xmath202 , @xmath203 , @xmath203 , and @xmath202 .
the results of our numerical experiments are shown in fig .
the simulation procedure is the same as the one used to generate the data of fig .
also in these numerical experiments we set @xmath47 .
we emphasize once more that the randomness in these discrete - event simulations only enters through the characterization of the photon source and through our procedure of selecting the direction of the polarizer for each set of 1000 events .
actually , the latter only serves to counter the possible objection that the apparent quantum mechanical behavior would be caused by monotonically changing the direction of the polarizers .
as in the previous example , it is clear that quantum theory @xcite describes the input - output behavior of the three- network very well .
we now show that two @xmath142 and two passive devices that perform a plane rotation by @xmath204 are sufficient to build a network that behaves as if it where a single - photon beam splitter .
first we describe the network and then we demonstrate that it acts as a beam splitter .
( 14,7 ) ( -1.75,0 ) ( 7,0 ) [ one - bs ] ( 14,7 ) ( -1.75,0 ) ( 7,0 ) [ figmz ] the network shown in fig.[figbs ] has two input channels ( 0 and 1 ) and two output channels ( 0 and 1 ) .
the network receives events at one of the two input channels .
each input event carries information in the form of a two - dimensional unit vector .
either input channel 0 receives @xmath95 or input channel 1 receives @xmath205 .
the input is fed into the device described in section [ twoone ] .
the purpose of this front - end is to transform the information contained in two - dimensional input vectors ( of which only one is present for any given input event ) , into a four - dimensional unit vector .
the four - dimensional internal vector of this device is split into two groups of two - dimensional vectors @xmath206 and @xmath207 and each of these two - dimensional vectors is rotated by @xmath204 . put differently
, the four - dimensional vector is rotated once in the ( 1,4)-plane about @xmath204 and once in the ( 3,2 ) plane about @xmath204 .
the order of the rotations is irrelevant .
the resulting four - dimensional vector is then sent to the input of a second @xmath142 .
this back - end sends @xmath208 through output channel 0 if it used rule @xmath149 ( see eq . ) to update its internal state .
otherwise it sends @xmath209 through output channel 1 .
the operation of the network depicted in fig.[figbs ] can be analyzed analytically if we disregard transient effects and assume that the information carried by events on channel 0 ( 1 ) is given by @xmath210 ( @xmath211 ) .
we denote by @xmath212 the number of events on input channel 0 divided by the total number of events .
then , the number of events on input channel 1 is given by @xmath213 . in the stationary regime , the internal state @xmath214 of the front - end
( see fig.[figbs ] ) learns @xmath215 . carrying out the two plane rotations of @xmath204 we see that the back - end receives as input the four - dimensional vector @xmath216 . in the stationary regime ,
the internal vector @xmath217 of the back - end oscillates about @xmath216 .
therefore , in the stationary regime and for fixed two - dimensional vectors on input channels 0 and 1 , the input - output relation of the bs network of fig .
[ one - bs ] can be written as @xmath218 using two complex numbers instead of four real numbers eq .
can also be written as @xmath219 in quantum theory @xcite the presence of photons in the input modes 0 or 1 is represented by the probability amplitudes ( @xmath220 @xcite . according to quantum theory @xcite
, the probability amplitudes ( @xmath221 of the photons in the output modes 0 and 1 of a beam splitter are given by @xcite @xmath222 identifying @xmath223 with @xmath224 and @xmath225 with @xmath226 it is clear that by construction , the network in fig .
[ figbs ] will allow us to simulate a beam splitter , not by calculating the amplitudes eq .
but by a deterministic event - by - event simulation . in fig .
[ one - bs ] ( right ) we present results of discrete - event simulations using the network depicted in fig
. [ figbs ] ( left ) .
before the simulation starts , the internal vectors of the are given a random value ( on the unit sphere ) .
each data point represents 10000 events .
all these simulations were carried out with @xmath47 . for each set of 10000 events ,
a uniform random number in the range @xmath227 $ ] generates two angles @xmath228 and @xmath229 .
input channel 0 receives @xmath230 with probability @xmath231 .
input channel 1 receives @xmath232 with probability @xmath233 .
random processes only enter in the procedure to generate the input data .
the network processes the events sequentially and deterministically . from fig .
[ one - bs ] it is clear that the output of the deterministic -based beam splitter reproduces the probability distributions as obtained from quantum theory @xcite .
( 14,14 ) ( -1,7 ) ( 7,7 ) ( -1,0 ) ( 7,0 ) ( 14,14 ) ( -1,7 ) ( 7,7 ) ( -1,0 ) ( 7,0 ) in quantum physics @xcite , single - photon experiments with one beam splitter provide direct evidence for the particle - like behavior of photons @xcite .
the wave mechanical character appears when one performs single - particle interference experiments . in this subsection
we construct a network that displays the same interference patterns as those observed in single - photon mach - zehnder interferometer experiments @xcite . the schematic layout of the network is shown in fig . [ figmz ] .
not surprisingly , it is exactly the same as that of a real mach - zehnder interferometer .
the bs network described in the previous subsection is used for the beam splitters .
the phase shift is taken care of by a passive device that performs a plane rotation .
clearly there is a one - to - one mapping from each relevant component in the interferometer to a processing unit in the network . recall that the processing units in the network only communicate with each other through the message ( photon ) that propagates through the network . according to quantum theory @xcite ,
the probability amplitudes ( @xmath221 of the photons in the output modes 0 ( @xmath234 ) and 1 ( @xmath235 ) of the mach - zehnder interferometer are given by @xcite @xmath236 note that in a quantum mechanical setting it is impossible to simultaneously measure ( @xmath237 , @xmath238 ) and ( @xmath239 , @xmath240 ) : photon detectors operate by absorbing photons .
however , in our deterministic , event - based simulation there is no such problem . in fig .
[ one - mz ] we present a small selection of simulation results for the mach - zehnder interferometer built from .
we assume that input channel 0 receives @xmath230 with probability one and that input channel 1 receives no events .
this corresponds to @xmath241 .
we use uniform random numbers to determine @xmath228 . in all these simulations @xmath47 .
the data points are the simulation results for the normalized intensity @xmath242 for i=0,2,3 as a function of @xmath243 .
lines represent the corresponding results of quantum theory @xcite . from fig .
[ one - mz ] it is clear that quantum theory provides an excellent description of the deterministic , event - based processing by the network . the examples presented in fig .
[ one - mz ] do not rule out that there may be settings for the angles @xmath228 , @xmath244 and @xmath200 for which quantum theory fails to give a good description of the behavior of the network
. however extensive series of simulations show that this is not the case . instead of presenting the results of these simulations we will demonstrate that quantum theory @xcite also describes the stationary - state input - output behavior of more extended networks . as an example we consider the network depicted in fig .
[ fig2mz ] . obviously this network maps exactly onto two chained mach - zehnder interferometers @xcite .
now there are seven parameters @xmath231 , @xmath228 , @xmath229 , @xmath244 , @xmath200 , @xmath245 , and @xmath246 that may be varied , so simply plotting selected cases is not the proper procedure to establish that quantum theory describes the stationary - state behavior of the network .
therefore we adopt the following strategy .
for each set of 10000 events , we use seven random numbers to fix the parameters @xmath231 , @xmath228 , @xmath229 , @xmath244 , @xmath200 , @xmath245 , and @xmath246 .
then we collect the data for these 10000 events and compare the intensity in output channel 0 ( @xmath247 ) and 1 ( @xmath248 ) with the corresponding results of quantum theory @xcite .
the latter is given by @xmath249 for each choice of @xmath250 we compute the differences @xmath251 and @xmath252 .
@xmath247 ( @xmath248 ) is the number of events in the output channel 0 ( 1 ) of the third beam splitter .
@xmath253 is the total number of events ( 10000 in this case ) . in fig .
[ two - mz ] we show @xmath251 as a function of @xmath231 , @xmath254 , @xmath255 , and @xmath256 . in all these simulations @xmath47 .
once again it is clear that quantum theory @xcite provides a very good description of a -based simulation of two chained mach - zehnder interferometers .
all simulations that we presented in this section have been performed for @xmath47 . from the description of the learning process
it is clear that @xmath16 controls the rate of learning or , equivalently , the rate at which learned information can be forgotten . furthermore it is evident that the difference between a constant input to a and the learned value of its internal variable can not be smaller than @xmath257 . in other words
, @xmath16 also limits the precision with which the internal variable can represent a sequence of constant input values . on the other hand
, the number of events has to balance the rate at which the can forget a learned input value .
the smaller @xmath257 is , the larger the number of events has to be for the to adapt to changes in the input data .
we use the last example of section [ mzi ] to illustrate the effect of changing @xmath16 and the total number of events @xmath258 . in fig .
[ two - mz - b ] we show the results of repeating the procedure used to obtain the data shown in fig .
[ two - mz ] but instead of @xmath47 and @xmath259 events per data point , we used @xmath260 and @xmath261 event per data point . as expected , the difference between the simulation data and the results of quantum theory decreases if @xmath257 decreases and @xmath258 increases accordingly .
comparing fig .
[ two - mz ] with fig .
[ two - mz - b ] it is clear that the decrease of this difference is roughly proportional to the inverse of the square root of the number of events .
note that each data point in fig .
[ two - mz ] is generated without the use of random processes .
in the stationary regime , the sequence of messages that a ( network ) generates is strictly deterministic . for some applications , e.g. for quantum physics @xcite , it may be desirable to randomize these sequences .
a marginal modification turns a into a stochastic learning machine ( slm ) . here
the term _ stochastic _ does not refer to the learning process but to the method that is used to select the output channel that will carry the outgoing message .
in the stationary regime the components of the internal vector represent the probability amplitudes . comparing the ( sums of ) squares of these amplitudes with a uniform random number @xmath262
gives the probability for sending the message over the corresponding output channel .
for instance , in the case of the beam splitter bs ( see fig . [ figbs ] ) we replace the back - end dlm by a slm .
this slm will send a message over output channel 0 if @xmath263 .
otherwise it will activate output channel 1 .
although the learning process of this modified bs network is still deterministic , in the stationary regime the output messages are randomly distributed over the two output channels .
of course , the distribution of output messages is the same as that of the original -network . replacing by slms in a -network changes the order in which messages are being processes by the network but leaves the content of the messages intact .
therefore , in the stationary regime , the distribution of messages over the outputs of the slm - network is essentially the same as that of the original dlm network . as an illustration of the use of slms ,
we replace the two back - end in the mach - zehnder interferometer network ( see fig
. [ figmz ] ( left ) ) by their `` randomized '' version and repeat the procedure that generates the data of fig .
[ figmz ] ( right ) .
the results of these simulations are shown in fig .
[ one - mz - random ] .
not unexpectedly , the randomness in the output channel selection is reflected by a ( small ) increase of the scatter on the data points . in this simulation ,
the output channels 0 and 1 of each beam splitter are activated in a random manner and the functional dependence of @xmath237 , @xmath238 , @xmath264 and @xmath265 on @xmath178 is still in full agreement with quantum theory @xcite . in other words ,
this slm - network performs a genuine , event - by - event simulation of the ideal ( perfect detectors , etc . ) version of both the single - photon beam splitter and mach - zehnder interferometer experiments by grangier et al @xcite .
we have proposed a new procedure to construct deterministic algorithms that have primitive learning capabilities .
we have used these algorithms to build deterministic learning machines ( dlms ) .
a dlm learns by processing event after event but does not store the data contained in an individual event . connecting the input of a dlm to the output of another dlm
yields a locally connected network of dlms .
a dlm within the network locally processes the information contained in an event and responds by sending a message that may be used as input for another dlm .
a distinct feature of a dlm network is that at any given time , only one event ( message ) is propagating through the network .
the dlms process messages in a sequential manner and only communicate with each other by message passing . we have demonstrated that dlm networks can discover relationships between successive events ( see section [ ndim ] ) and that certain classes of dlm networks exhibit behavior that is usually only attributed to quantum systems . in sections [ qi ] and [ slm ] we have presented dlm networks that simulate quantum interference on an event - by - event basis .
more specifically , we map each physical part of the real mach - zehnder interferometer onto a dlm and the messages ( phase shifts in this case ) are carried by photons .
no ingredient other than simple geometry is used to specify the update rules of the dlms .
as the network processes event after event , the network generates output events that build an interference pattern that is described by the quantum theory @xcite of the single - photon beam splitter and mach - zehnder interferometer . to illustrate that dlm networks are indeed capable of simulating quantum interference on an event - by - event basis we also simulate an experiment involving three beam splitters ( i.e. two chained mach - zehnder interferometers ) and demonstrate that quantum theory @xcite also describes the behavior of this network .
the results presented in sections [ qi ] and [ slm ] suggest that we may have discovered a systematic procedure to construct algorithms that simulate quantum phenomena using deterministic , local , and event - by - event - based processes .
we emphasize that our approach is not a proposal for another interpretation of quantum mechanics .
our approach is not an extension of quantum theory in any sense : the probability distributions of quantum theory appear as the result of a deterministic , causal learning process , and not vice versa ( see section [ qi ] ) @xcite .
our results suggest that quantum mechanical behavior may originate from an underlying deterministic process @xcite . indeed
, it is somewhat ironic that in order to mimic the apparent randomness with which events are observed in experiments , we have to explicitly randomize the output of the dlms to mask the underlying deterministic processes ( see section [ slm ] ) .
to the best of our knowledge , this paper contains the first demonstration that quantum interference can be simulated on an event - by - event basis using local , causal , and deterministic processes , and without using concepts such as wave fields or particle - wave duality . at this point
it may be worthwhile to recall what a dlm actually does . in a simple physical picture ,
a dlm is a device ( e.g. beam splitter , polarizer ) that exchanges information with the particles that pass through it .
the dlm tries to do this in an effective manner .
it learns by comparing the message carried by an event with predictions based on the knowledge acquired by the dlm during the processing of previous events .
effectively this comparison amounts to a minimization of the squared error ( see section [ illu ] ) .
schrdinger used exactly the same principle to derive his famous equation @xcite but called this approach `` unverstndlich '' in a subsequent publication @xcite . in a future publication
we will show that the approach introduced in this paper can be employed to perform event - based simulations of a universal quantum computer @xcite .
it has been shown that the time evolution of the wave function of a quantum system can be simulated on a quantum computer @xcite .
therefore it should be possible to compute the real - time dynamics of these systems ( including the double - slit experiment mentioned in the introduction ) through discrete - event simulation by constructing appropriate dlm networks .
we thank s. miyashita for extensive discussions .
we make a distinction between quantum theory and quantum physics .
we use the term _ quantum theory _ when we refer to the mathematical formalism , i.e. , the postulates of quantum mechanics ( with or without the wave function collapse postulate ) @xcite and the rules ( algorithms ) to compute the wave function .
the term _ quantum physics _ is used for microscopic , experimentally observable phenomena that do not find an explanation within the mathematical framework of classical mechanics .
an interactive program that performs the event - based simulations of a beam splitter , one mach - zehnder interferometer , and two chained mach - zehnder interferometers can be found at http://www.compphys.net/dlm m. nielsen and i. chuang , _ quantum computation and quantum information _ , cambridge university press , cambridge ( 2000 ) g. t hooft , `` determinism beneath quantum mechanics '' , quant - ph/0105105 g. t hooft , `` quantum mechanics and determinism '' , quant - ph/0212095 e. schrdinger , ann .
* 79 * , 361 ( 1926 ) | we propose and analyse simple deterministic algorithms that can be used to construct machines that have primitive learning capabilities .
we demonstrate that locally connected networks of these machines can be used to perform blind classification on an event - by - event basis , without storing the information of the individual events .
we also demonstrate that properly designed networks of these machines exhibit behavior that is usually only attributed to quantum systems .
we present networks that simulate quantum interference on an event - by - event basis .
in particular we show that by using simple geometry and the learning capabilities of the machines it becomes possible to simulate single - photon interference in a mach - zehnder interferometer . the interference pattern generated by the network of deterministic learning machines is in perfect agreement with the quantum theoretical result for the single - photon mach - zehnder interferometer . to illustrate that networks of these machines are indeed capable of simulating quantum interference we simulate , event - by - event , a setup involving two chained mach - zehnder interferometers .
we show that also in this case the simulation results agree with quantum theory .
# 1 # 1#1 # 1#1 # 1#1 # 1#2#1 # 2 # 1([#1 ] ) |
starting from the pioneering measurements of the @xmath2 mass difference @xmath3 and of the cp - violating parameter @xmath4 , continuing with the precision measurements of the @xmath5 mixing parameters @xmath6 and @xmath7 and with the recent determination of the @xmath8 oscillation frequency @xmath9 and the first bounds on the mixing phase @xmath10 , until the very recent evidence of @xmath11 mixing , @xmath1 processes have always provided some of the most stringent constraints on new physics ( np ) .
for example , it has been known for more than a quarter of century that supersymmetric extensions of the standard model ( sm ) with generic flavour structures are strongly constrained by @xmath12 mixing and cp violation @xcite .
the constraints from @xmath12 mixing are particularly stringent for models that generate transitions between quarks of different chiralities @xcite .
more recently , it has been shown that another source of enhancement of chirality - breaking transitions lies in the qcd corrections @xcite , now known at the next - to - leading order ( nlo ) @xcite .
previous phenomenological analyses of @xmath1 processes in supersymmetry @xcite were affected by a large uncertainty due to the sm contribution , since no determination of the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa @xcite ( ckm ) cp - violating phase was available in the presence of np .
a breakthrough was possible with the advent of @xmath13 factories and the measurement of time - dependent cp asymmetries in @xmath13 decays , allowing for a simultaneous determination of the ckm parameters and of the np contributions to @xmath1 processes in the @xmath14 and @xmath15 sectors @xcite .
furthermore , the tevatron experiments have provided the first measurement of @xmath16 and the first bounds on the phase of @xmath8 mixing . combining all these ingredients
, we can now determine allowed ranges for all np @xmath1 amplitudes in the down - quark sector . to complete the picture , the recent evidence of @xmath17 mixing allows to constrain np contributions to the @xmath18 amplitude @xcite .
our aim in this work is to consider the most general effective hamiltonian for @xmath1 processes ( @xmath19 ) and to translate the experimental constraints into allowed ranges for the wilson coefficients of @xmath19 .
these coefficients in general have the form @xmath20 where @xmath21 is a function of the ( complex ) np flavour couplings , @xmath22 is a loop factor that is present in models with no tree - level flavour changing neutral currents ( fcnc ) , and @xmath23 is the scale of np , _ i.e. _ the typical mass of the new particles mediating @xmath1 transitions . for a generic strongly - interacting theory with arbitrary flavour structure ,
one expects @xmath24 so that the allowed range for each of the @xmath25 can be immediately translated into a lower bound on @xmath23 .
specific assumptions on the flavour structure of np , for example minimal @xcite or next - to - minimal @xcite flavour violation ( mfv or nmfv ) , correspond to particular choices of the @xmath21 functions , as detailed below .
our study is analogous to the operator analysis of electroweak precision observables @xcite , but it provides much more stringent bounds on models with non - minimal flavour violation . in particular , we find that the scale of heavy particles mediating tree - level fcnc in models of nmfv must lie above @xmath26 tev , making them undetectable at the lhc .
this bound applies for instance to the kaluza - klein excitations of gauge bosons in a large class of models with ( warped ) extra dimensions @xcite .
flavour physics remains the main avenue to probe such extensions of the sm .
the paper is organised as follows . in sec .
[ sec : exp ] we briefly discuss the experimental novelties considered in our analysis . in sec .
[ sec : mi ] we present updated results for the analysis of the unitarity triangle ( ut ) in the presence of np , including the model - independent constraints on @xmath1 processes , following closely our previous analyses @xcite . in sec .
[ sec : eh ] we discuss the structure of @xmath19 , the definition of the models we consider and the method used to constrain the wilson coefficients . in sec .
[ sec : results ] we present our results for the wilson coefficients and for the scale of np .
conclusions are drawn in sec .
[ sec : concl ] .
we use the same experimental input as ref .
@xcite , updated after the winter @xmath27 conferences .
we collect all the numbers used throughout this paper in tables [ tab : expinput ] and [ tab : hadinput ] .
we include the following novelties : the most recent result for @xmath28 @xcite , the semileptonic asymmetry in @xmath29 decays @xmath30 @xcite and the dimuon charge asymmetry @xmath31 from d@xmath32 @xcite and cdf @xcite , the measurement of the @xmath29 lifetime from flavour - specific final states @xcite , the determination of @xmath33 from the time - integrated angular analysis of @xmath34 decays by cdf @xcite , the three - dimensional constraint on @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and the phase @xmath37 of the @xmath29@xmath38 mixing amplitude from the time - dependent angular analysis of @xmath39 decays by d@xmath32 @xcite .
.values of the experimental input used in our analysis .
the gaussian and the flat contributions to the uncertainty are given in the third and fourth columns respectively ( for details on the statistical treatment see @xcite ) .
see text for details . [
cols="<,^,^,^ " , ] + we conclude that any model with strongly interacting np and/or tree - level contributions is beyond the reach of direct searches at the lhc . flavour and cp violation remain the main tool to constrain ( or detect ) such np models .
weakly - interacting extensions of the sm can be accessible at the lhc provided that they enjoy a mfv - like suppression of @xmath1 processes , or at least a nmfv - like suppression with an additional depletion of the np contribution to @xmath40 .
we thank guennadi borissov , brendan casey , stefano giagu , marco rescigno , andrzej zieminski , and jure zupan for useful discussions .
we aknowledge partial support from rtn european contracts mrtn - ct-2004 - 503369 `` the quest for unification '' , mrtn - ct-2006 - 035482 `` flavianet '' and mrtn - ct-2006 - 035505 `` heptools '' .
99 j. r. ellis and d. v. nanopoulos , phys .
b * 110 * ( 1982 ) 44 ; j. f. donoghue , h. p. nilles and d. wyler , phys .
b * 128 * ( 1983 ) 55 ; j. m. frere and m. belen gavela , phys .
b * 132 * ( 1983 ) 107 ; m. j. duncan and j. trampetic , phys . lett .
b * 134 * ( 1984 ) 439 ; j. m. gerard , w. grimus , a. raychaudhuri and g. zoupanos , phys .
b * 140 * ( 1984 ) 349 ; j. m. gerard , w. grimus and a. raychaudhuri , phys .
b * 145 * ( 1984 ) 400 ; j. m. gerard , w. grimus , a. masiero , d. v. nanopoulos and a. raychaudhuri , nucl .
b * 253 * ( 1985 ) 93 .
g. beall , m. bander and a. soni , phys .
lett . * 48 * ( 1982 ) 848 .
f. gabbiani and a. masiero , nucl .
b * 322 * ( 1989 ) 235 .
e. gabrielli , a. masiero and l. silvestrini , phys .
b * 374 * ( 1996 ) 80 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9509379 ] ; f. gabbiani , e. gabrielli , a. masiero and l. silvestrini , nucl .
b * 477 * ( 1996 ) 321 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9604387 ] .
j. a. bagger , k. t. matchev and r. j. zhang , phys .
b * 412 * ( 1997 ) 77 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9707225 ] .
m. ciuchini , e. franco , v. lubicz , g. martinelli , i. scimemi and l. silvestrini , nucl .
b * 523 * ( 1998 ) 501 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9711402 ] ; a. j. buras , m. misiak and j. urban , nucl .
b * 586 * ( 2000 ) 397 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0005183 ] .
m. ciuchini , e. franco , d. guadagnoli , v. lubicz , v. porretti and l. silvestrini , jhep * 0609 * ( 2006 ) 013 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0606197 ] .
m. ciuchini _ et al .
_ , jhep * 9810 * ( 1998 ) 008 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9808328 ] .
d. becirevic _ et al .
_ , nucl .
b * 634 * ( 2002 ) 105 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0112303 ] .
n. cabibbo , phys .
lett . * 10 * ( 1963 ) 531 ; m. kobayashi and t. maskawa , prog .
* 49 * ( 1973 ) 652
. m. bona _ et al .
_ [ utfit collaboration ] , jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 080 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0509219 ] .
m. bona _ et al . _
[ utfit collaboration ] , phys .
lett . *
97 * ( 2006 ) 151803 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0605213 ] .
m. ciuchini , e. franco , f. parodi , v. lubicz , l. silvestrini and a. stocchi , _ in the proceedings of 2nd workshop on the ckm unitarity triangle , durham , england , 5 - 9 apr 2003 , pp wg306 _ [ arxiv : hep - ph/0307195 ] ; s. laplace , z. ligeti , y. nir and g. perez , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 094040 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0202010 ] ; z. ligeti , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 20 * ( 2005 ) 5105 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0408267 ] ; f. j. botella , g. c. branco , m. nebot and m. n. rebelo , nucl .
b * 725 * ( 2005 ) 155 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0502133 ] ; l. silvestrini , int .
j. mod .
a * 21 * ( 2006 ) 1738 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0510077 ] ; f. j. botella , g. c. branco and m. nebot , nucl .
b * 768 * ( 2007 ) 1 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0608100 ] .
m. ciuchini , e. franco , d. guadagnoli , v. lubicz , m. pierini , v. porretti and l. silvestrini , phys .
b * 655 * ( 2007 ) 162 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0703204 ] .
y. nir , jhep * 0705 * ( 2007 ) 102 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0703235 ] ; p. ball , j. phys .
g * 34 * ( 2007 ) 2199 [ arxiv:0704.0786 [ hep - ph ] ] ; e. golowich , j. hewett , s. pakvasa and a. a. petrov , arxiv:0705.3650 [ hep - ph ] .
e. gabrielli and g. f. giudice , nucl .
b * 433 * ( 1995 ) 3 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 507 * ( 1997 ) 549 ] [ arxiv : hep - lat/9407029 ] ; m. misiak , s. pokorski and j. rosiek , adv .
high energy phys . * 15 * ( 1998 ) 795 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9703442 ] ; m. ciuchini , g. degrassi , p. gambino and g. f. giudice , nucl .
b * 534 * ( 1998 ) 3 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9806308 ] ; c. bobeth , m. bona , a. j. buras , t. ewerth , m. pierini , l. silvestrini and a. weiler , nucl . phys .
b * 726 * ( 2005 ) 252 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0505110 ] ; m. blanke , a. j. buras , d. guadagnoli and c. tarantino , jhep * 0610 * ( 2006 ) 003 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0604057 ] .
a. j. buras , p. gambino , m. gorbahn , s. jager and l. silvestrini , phys .
b * 500 * ( 2001 ) 161 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0007085 ] .
g. dambrosio , g. f. giudice , g. isidori and a. strumia , nucl .
b * 645 * ( 2002 ) 155 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207036 ] .
k. agashe , m. papucci , g. perez and d. pirjol , arxiv : hep - ph/0509117 . b. grinstein and m. b. wise , phys .
b * 265 * ( 1991 ) 326 ; a. belyaev and r. rosenfeld , mod .
a * 14 * ( 1999 ) 397 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9805253 ] ; r. barbieri and a. strumia , phys .
b * 462 * ( 1999 ) 144 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9905281 ] ; r. barbieri , a. pomarol , r. rattazzi and a. strumia , nucl . phys .
b * 703 * ( 2004 ) 127 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0405040 ] .
k. agashe , g. perez and a. soni , phys .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 201804 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406101 ] ; k. agashe , g. perez and a. soni , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 016002 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0408134 ] .
a. abulencia _ et al . _
[ cdf collaboration ] , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 )
242003 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0609040 ] . v. m. abazov _ et al .
_ [ d0 collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 98 * ( 2007 )
151801 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0701007 ] . v. m. abazov _ et al . _
[ d0 collaboration ] , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 092001 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0609014 ] .
cdf collaboration , cdf note 9015 , + ` http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/bottom/070816.blessed-acp-bsemil/ ` .
d. buskulic _ et al . _
[ aleph collaboration ] , phys .
b * 377 * ( 1996 ) 205 ; f. abe _ et al .
_ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev .
d * 59 * ( 1999 ) 032004 [ arxiv : hep - ex/9808003 ] ; p. abreu _ et al .
_ [ delphi collaboration ] , eur . phys .
j. c * 16 * ( 2000 ) 555 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0107077 ] ; k. ackerstaff _ et al .
_ [ opal collaboration ] , phys .
b * 426 * ( 1998 ) 161 [ arxiv : hep - ex/9802002 ] ; v. m. abazov _ et al .
_ [ d0 collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 241801 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0604046 ] ; cdf collaboration , cdf note 7386 , + ` http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/bottom/050303.blessed-bhadlife/ ` ; + cdf collaboration , cdf note 7757 , + ` http://www-cdf.fnal.gov/physics/new/bottom/050707.blessed-bs-semi_life/ ` ; e. barberio _ et al . _
[ heavy flavor averaging group ( hfag ) ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0603003 .
d. e. acosta _ et al .
_ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 94 * ( 2005 )
101803 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0412057 ] . v. m. abazov _ et al . _
[ d0 collaboration ] , phys .
* 98 * ( 2007 )
121801 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0701012 ] .
m. ciuchini _ et al .
_ , jhep * 0107 * ( 2001 ) 013 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0012308 ] .
a. s. dighe , i. dunietz and r. fleischer , eur . phys .
j. c * 6 * ( 1999 ) 647 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9804253 ] .
a. s. dighe , i. dunietz , h. j. lipkin and j. l. rosner , phys .
b * 369 * ( 1996 ) 144 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9511363 ] .
a. lenz and u. nierste , jhep * 0706 * ( 2007 ) 072 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0612167 ] .
g. kramer and w. f. palmer , phys . rev .
d * 45 * , 193 ( 1992 ) .
m. neubert , phys .
* 245 * , 259 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9306320 ] .
m. beneke , j. rohrer and d. yang , nucl .
b * 774 * , 64 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0612290 ] .
b. aubert _ et al . _
[ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 032005 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0411016 ] .
f. abe _ et al . _
[ cdf collaboration ] , phys .
d * 57 * ( 1998 ) 5382 .
k. hartkorn and h. g. moser , eur .
j. c * 8 * ( 1999 ) 381 .
y. grossman , y. nir and g. raz , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 151801 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0605028 ] .
e. m. aitala _ et al .
_ [ e791 collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 77 * ( 1996 )
2384 [ arxiv : hep - ex/9606016 ] ; j. m. link _ et al . _ [ focus collaboration ] , phys . lett .
b * 485 * ( 2000 ) 62 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0004034 ] ; k. abe _ et al .
_ [ belle collaboration ] , phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 162001 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0111026 ] ; s. e. csorna _ et al . _
[ cleo collaboration ] , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 092001 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0111024 ] ; b. aubert _ et al .
_ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
* 91 * ( 2003 ) 121801 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0306003 ] ; b. aubert _ et al . _
[ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 091102 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0408066 ] ; c. cawlfield _ et al . _
[ cleo collaboration ] , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 077101 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0502012 ] ; d. m. asner _
[ cleo collaboration ] , phys .
d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 012001 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0503045 ] ; u. bitenc _ et al . _
[ belle collaboration ] , phys .
d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 071101 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0507020 ] ; d. m. asner _
[ cleo collaboration ] , int .
j. mod .
phys . a * 21 * ( 2006 ) 5456 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0607078 ] ; b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0607090 ; b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 221803 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0608006 ] ; b. aubert _ et al . _
[ babar collaboration ] , phys .
* 98 * ( 2007 )
211802 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0703020 ] ; k. abe _ et al .
_ [ belle collaboration ] , arxiv:0704.1000 [ hep - ex ] ; m. staric _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys .
* 98 * ( 2007 ) 211803 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0703036 ] ; b. aubert _ et al . _
[ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 014018 [ arxiv:0705.0704 [ hep - ex ] ] .
j. m. soares and l. wolfenstein , phys .
d * 47 * ( 1993 ) 1021 ; n. g. deshpande , b. dutta and s. oh , phys .
* 77 * ( 1996 ) 4499 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9608231 ] ; j. p. silva and l. wolfenstein , phys .
d * 55 * ( 1997 ) 5331 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9610208 ] ; a. g. cohen , d. b. kaplan , f. lepeintre and a. e. nelson , phys .
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 2300 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9610252 ] ; y. grossman , y. nir and m. p. worah , phys .
b * 407 * ( 1997 ) 307 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9704287 ] .
m. bona _ et al . _ [ utfit collaboration ] , jhep * 0610 * ( 2006 ) 081 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0606167 ] .
z. ligeti , m. papucci and g. perez , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 101801 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0604112 ] ; p. ball and r. fleischer , eur .
j. c * 48 * ( 2006 ) 413 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0604249 ] .
m. ciuchini , e. franco , a. masiero and l. silvestrini , phys .
d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 075016 [ erratum - ibid .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 079901 ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/0212397 ] ; j. foster , k. i. okumura and l. roszkowski , jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 044 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0510422 ] .
m. ciuchini _ et al .
_ , in preparation .
a. donini , v. gimenez , l. giusti and g. martinelli , phys .
b * 470 * ( 1999 ) 233 [ arxiv : hep - lat/9910017 ] ; r. babich , n. garron , c. hoelbling , j. howard , l. lellouch and c. rebbi , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 073009 [ arxiv : hep - lat/0605016 ] ; y. nakamura _ et al . _
[ cp - pacs collaboration ] , pos * lat2006 * ( 2006 ) 089 [ arxiv : hep - lat/0610075 ] .
d. becirevic , v. gimenez , g. martinelli , m. papinutto and j. reyes , jhep * 0204 * ( 2002 ) 025 [ arxiv : hep - lat/0110091 ] . | we update the constraints on new - physics contributions to @xmath0 processes from the generalized unitarity triangle analysis , including the most recent experimental developments . based on these constraints ,
we derive upper bounds on the coefficients of the most general @xmath1 effective hamiltonian .
these upper bounds can be translated into lower bounds on the scale of new physics that contributes to these low - energy effective interactions .
we point out that , due to the enhancement in the renormalization group evolution and in the matrix elements , the coefficients of non - standard operators are much more constrained than the coefficient of the operator present in the standard model .
therefore , the scale of new physics in models that generate new @xmath1 operators , such as next - to - minimal flavour violation , has to be much higher than the scale of minimal flavour violation , and it most probably lies beyond the reach of direct searches at the lhc . |
since its isolation on an adhesive tape @xcite , graphene has quickly become a material of intensive attention .
many researches have revealed various interesting aspects of the material ; see e.g. refs .
@xcite for reviews .
one of the most interesting features emerges particularly when we apply a magnetic field to it @xcite .
the landau levels due to the magnetic field form a structure different from the simple two - dimensional electron gas in that there are levels of zero energy and in that the non - zero energy levels are spaced not equally but proportionally to the square root of the level number . in the present paper
, we apply to graphene yet another ingredient of recent interest , namely the @xmath0 symmetry @xcite . in order to attract attention of condensed - matter physicists ,
let us briefly describe the @xmath0 symmetry here .
it refers to the parity - and - time symmetry of a hamiltonian .
the simplest example of the @xmath0-symmetric hamiltonian may be the two - by - two matrix @xmath4 which we can interpret as a two - site tight - binding model : the two sites are coupled with a real coupling parameter @xmath5 ; the first site has a complex potential @xmath6 , which can represent injection of particles from the environment , because the amplitude of the wave vector would increase in time as @xmath7 if the site were isolated ; the potential @xmath8 of the second site can represent removal of the particles to the environment .
the @xmath9 operator swaps the first and second sites , which is represented by the linear operator @xmath10 the @xmath11 operator is complex conjugation , which is an anti - linear operator .
it is easy to confirm that the hamiltonian @xmath12 in eq .
satisfies @xmath13 the parity operation @xmath9 swaps @xmath6 and @xmath8 but the time operation @xmath11 switches them back to the original .
this is what we mean by the @xmath0 symmetry of the hamiltonian .
the hamiltonian @xmath12 has the eigenvalues @xmath14 which are real for @xmath15 , although @xmath12 is non - hermitian ; @xmath16 . for @xmath17 ,
on the other hand , the eigenvalues become complex ( pure imaginary in this specific model ) .
this transition between real and complex eigenvalues physically means the following . in the strong - coupling case @xmath15
, the particles injected to the first site can flow abundantly into the second site , where they are removed at the same rate as the injection .
this constitutes a stationary state of a constant flow , which is indicated by the reality of the eigenvalues . in the weak - coupling case @xmath17 ,
on the other hand , the particles tend to build up in the first site , while they keep becoming scarcer in the second site .
this instability is indicated by the non - reality of the eigenvalues .
the first situation is often called the @xmath0-symmetric phase , whereas the second one is the @xmath0-broken phase . at the transition point @xmath18 , not only the two eigenvalues coalesce with each other , but the corresponding two eigenvectors become parallel .
this is therefore not the standard degeneracy , but often called an exceptional point @xcite , which has a huge literature recently , including experimental studies @xcite . at the exceptional point ,
the eigenvectors are not complete and the hamiltonian @xmath12 is not diagonalizable .
( in fact , non - hermitian matrices are _ generally diagonalizable _ except at the exceptional points . ) the transition at an exceptional point between the two phases indeed happens in a very wide class of @xmath0-symmetric operators .
suppose that a general @xmath0-symmetric hamiltonian has an eigenvector @xmath19 with an eigenvalue @xmath20 : @xmath21 inserting the symmetry relation , we have @xmath22 where we used the fact @xmath23 . when the eigenvalue @xmath20 is real , the operator @xmath0 passes it , yielding @xmath24 which means that @xmath25 is also an eigenvector with the same eigenvalue .
if we assume no degeneracy of the eigenvalue @xmath20 for simplicity , we conclude that @xmath26 ; indeed , we can choose the phase of @xmath19 so that we can make @xmath27 ; namely , the eigenvector is @xmath0-symmetric .
this is what happens in the @xmath0-symmetric phase .
when the eigenvalue @xmath20 is complex , on the other hand , we have , instead of eq . , @xmath28 where @xmath29 denotes the complex conjugate of @xmath20 .
this means that we always have a complex - conjugate pair of eigenvalues @xmath20 and @xmath29 with the eigenvectors @xmath19 and @xmath25 ; each eigenvector is not @xmath0-symmetric anymore in spite of the fact that the hamiltonian is still @xmath0-symmetric .
this is what happens in the @xmath0-broken phase . in typical situations including the example ,
two neighboring real eigenvalues in the @xmath0-symmetric phase , as we tune system parameters , are attracted to each other , collide at the exceptional point , and then become a pair of complex - conjugate eigenvalues in the @xmath0-broken phase , which repel each other ; see fig .
[ fig - exceptional point ] .
-symmetric and @xmath0-broken phases .
as we tune system parameters from the @xmath0-symmetric phase to the exceptional point and further on to the @xmath0-broken phase , two real eigenvalues neighboring on the real axis are attracted to each other ( indicated by the blue horizontal arrows on the real axis ) , collide at the exceptional point ( indicated by a green dot ) , and become a complex - conjugate pair , which repel each other ( indicated by the red vertical arrows).,scaledwidth=40.0% ] questions of interest include the following : is it possible to formulate a standardized quantum mechanics for non - hermitian but @xmath0-symmetric hamiltonians with real energy eigenvalues , namely in the @xmath0-symmetric phase ? what is the general theoretical structure of the @xmath0-broken phase , on the other hand ?
a more specific subject of study is to find @xmath0-symmetric models that describe physically interesting situations . in the present paper
, we introduce the potential @xmath6 to one sublattice of graphene under a magnetic field and the potential @xmath8 to its other sublattice , which constitutes a @xmath0-symmetric situation .
it is quite common to introduce a staggered chemical potential to graphene , that is , @xmath30 to one sublattice and @xmath31 to the other sublattice , which may be indeed realized by hexagonal lattice of boron - nitride @xcite , in which boron atoms are on the a sublattice and nitride atoms are on the b sublattice .
our @xmath0-symmetric situation may be also realized in the following way : suppose that we put a hexagonal lattice of two elements , such as boron - nitride , on a substrate ; assume that the substrate is an electron - doping material for one element but hole - doing for the other
. this can materialize our @xmath0-symmetric situation . for completeness
, we should observe that few other @xmath0 , or non - hermitian , versions of the graphene have been proposed in recent years , but in a different spirit with respect to ours @xcite .
let us now describe the model in more detail .
graphene forms a hexagonal lattice , which is a bipartite lattice ; see fig .
[ fig2 ] . a unit cell , indicated by red broken lines in fig . [ fig2 ] , consists of two sites , one on the a sublattice and the other on the b sublattice . if we assume that the electrons , specifically @xmath32 electrons , hop only to nearest - neighbor lattice points , those on a site on the a sublattice hop only to sites on the b sublattice , and vice versa .
the tight - binding hamiltonian in the real - space representation therefore is of the following form : on the diagonal , we have two - by - two blocks @xmath33 which is the local hamiltonian inside a unit cell with the chemical potentials @xmath34 and @xmath35 for the a and b sublattices , respectively , and with the non - zero off - diagonal intra - unit - cell hopping elements @xmath36 between the two sites . in addition , the total hamiltonian has the inter - unit - cell hopping elements @xmath36 between different unit cells . by fourier
transforming the basis set with respect to the unit cells , we end up with the block - diagonalized hamiltonian @xmath37 with @xmath38 where @xmath39 and @xmath40 are indicated in fig .
we thereby have two energy eigenvalues for each wave number @xmath41 , which form two energy bands in the two - dimensional wave - number space , as shown in fig .
[ fig - bands ] for @xmath42 . with @xmath42 .
the energy unit in the vertical axis is given by @xmath36 , while the unit of the wave numbers @xmath43 and @xmath44 are given by the inverse of the lattice constant , which we put to unity here.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] among the blocks of the block - diagonalized hamiltonian , the most important are the blocks of the two specific wave numbers , namely the dirac points @xmath1 and @xmath2 , respectively specified by @xmath45 at which the energy eigenvalues are degenerate to zero for @xmath42 .
because the fermi energy for graphene is zero , these points control the elementary excitation of graphene .
the upper and lower energy bands touch at these points , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig - bands ] , forming dirac cones around the points , which are schematically shown in fig .
[ fig4](a ) . and
@xmath2 points for @xmath42 .
the fermi energy of graphene is zero , which coincides with the dirac points @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
( b ) the landau levels are formed under a magnetic field .
the levels are spaced proportionally to @xmath46 ; see sec . [ sectsam ] for the definition of the quantum number @xmath47 .
( c ) shifts of the landau levels for @xmath48 .
the levels are spaced as @xmath49 . the central landau level @xmath50 has already become complex .
( d ) further shifts for @xmath51 .
the levels with @xmath52 have collided with each other and become complex.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] in the standard graphene , therefore , the low - energy excitations follow relativistic quantum mechanics ; this is one big feature of graphene , namely , the desktop relativity . as we predicted above , we apply two ingredients to the graphene tight - binding model , namely a magnetic field and a @xmath0-symmetric chemical potential .
first , the spectrum is quantized to the landau levels under a magnetic field . focusing on the dirac cones around the @xmath1 and @xmath2 points , we can write down the effective hamiltonian as in eq . below . as is well studied ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite ) , which we will repeat in our way in sec .
[ sectsam ] , the landau levels are not equally spaced as in the standard two - dimensional electron gas , but spaced proportionally to @xmath46 , as shown schematically in fig . [ fig4](b ) ; see sec .
[ sectsam ] for the definition of the quantum number @xmath47 .
each landau level has an infinite number of degeneracy because of another quantum number @xmath53 .
we then further apply the @xmath0-symmetric potential to the model .
we set the potentials to @xmath54 for the a sublattice and @xmath55 for the b sublattice , as is represented in eq .
below . let us define the @xmath9 operation as the mirror reflection with respect to the horizontal axis of fig .
[ fig2 ] ; it then swaps the a and b sublattices with each other , changes the sign of the potentials @xmath56 , which is represented by the transformation @xmath57 the @xmath11 operation , which is the complex conjugation , then changes the hamiltonian back to the original one .
see the end of sec .
[ sec1.1 ] for a possible materialization of the @xmath0-symmetric situation .
we will show in sec .
[ sec3 ] that the landau levels are then spaced proportionally to @xmath49 ( after proper parameter normalization ) under a set of biorthogonal eigenstates .
therefore , as we increase the potential @xmath3 , two landau levels labeled by @xmath58 approach each other , collide with each other when @xmath59 , which is an exceptional point , and then split into a pair of two pure imaginary eigenvalues @xmath60 ; see fig .
[ fig4](c d ) .
we will deduce that at this exceptional point , the eigenvectors of the two landau levels become parallel , which makes the set of biorthogonal eigenstates incomplete . note that each landau level still has an infinite number of degeneracy because of the other quantum number @xmath61 .
note also that the central level @xmath50 becomes a complex eigenvalue as soon as we introduce the @xmath0-symmetric potential @xmath3 ; see fig .
[ fig4](b c ) .
we show that the central level @xmath50 of the @xmath1 point coalesces with the central level @xmath50 of the @xmath2 point and becomes complex as @xmath56 .
this particular coalescence , however , is not an exceptional point but a degeneracy because it occurs in the hermitian limit @xmath62 .
these are probably the main results of the present paper .
this article is organized as follows : in the next section [ sectsam ] we briefly review the hermitian version of the model under a magnetic field and some of its main mathematical characteristics . in sec .
[ sec3 ] we introduce our @xmath0-symmetrically deformed version of the model with @xmath56 and consider the consequences of this deformation .
our conclusions and future perspective are given in sec .
[ sec5 ] . to make the paper
self - contained , we have added [ appa ] with some useful facts for non - hermitian hamiltonians .
let us first consider a layer of graphene in an external constant magnetic field along @xmath63 : @xmath64 , which can be deduced from @xmath65 with a vector potential in the symmetric gauge , @xmath66 .
the hamiltonian for the two dirac points @xmath1 and @xmath2 can be written as @xcite @xmath67 where , in the units @xmath68 , we have @xmath69 while @xmath70 is just its transpose : @xmath71 . here
@xmath72 and @xmath73 are the canonical , hermitian , two - dimensional position and momentum operators , which satisfy @xmath74=[y , p_y]=i{1 \!\ !
1}$ ] with all the other commutators being zero , where @xmath75 is the identity operator in the hilbert space @xmath76 .
the factor @xmath77 is the so - called fermi velocity .
the scalar product in @xmath78 will be indicated as @xmath79 .
let us now introduce the parameter called the magnetic length , @xmath80 , as well as the following canonical operators : @xmath81 these operators can be used to define two different pairs of bosonic operators : we first put @xmath82 and @xmath83 , and then @xmath84 the following commutation rules are satisfied : @xmath85=[a_y , a_y^\dagger]=[a_1,a_1^\dagger]=[a_2,a_2^\dagger]={1 \!\ ! 1 } , \label{22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the other commutators being zero . in terms of these operators
, @xmath86 appears particularly simple .
indeed , we find @xmath87 for @xmath88 and @xmath89 for @xmath90 .
note that @xmath91 and @xmath92 are different expressions of the same hamiltonian .
it is evident that @xmath93 , and a similar conclusion can also be deduced for @xmath70 .
it is also clear that neither @xmath91 nor @xmath94 depends on @xmath95 and @xmath96 , so that their eigenstates possess a manifest degeneracy .
the same is true for @xmath92 nor @xmath97 , which do not depend on @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
however , from now on , we will essentially concentrate on @xmath100 and @xmath94 , except for what is discussed in appendix b. most of what we are going to discuss from now on can be restated easily for @xmath101 and @xmath97 .
for instance , the eigenvectors of @xmath101 could be found from those of @xmath94 , replacing the operators @xmath95 and @xmath96 with @xmath98 and @xmath99 , and vice versa .
now , let @xmath102 be the non - zero vacuum of @xmath95 and @xmath98 : @xmath103
. then we introduce , as usual , @xmath104 the set @xmath105 is an orthonormal basis for @xmath78 , being the same as the one for a two - dimensional harmonic oscillator . rather than working in @xmath78 , in order to deal with
@xmath91 it is convenient to work in a different hilbert space , namely the direct sum of @xmath78 with itself , @xmath106 : @xmath107 in the new hilbert space @xmath108 , the scalar product @xmath109 is defined as @xmath110 and the square norm is @xmath111 , for all @xmath112 , @xmath113 in @xmath108 .
introducing now the vectors @xmath114 we have an orthonormal basis set @xmath115 for @xmath108 .
this means , among other things , that @xmath116 is complete in @xmath108 : the only vector @xmath117 which is orthogonal to all the vectors of @xmath116 is the zero vector . in view of application
to graphene it is more convenient to use a different orthonormal basis of @xmath108 , the set @xmath118 , where @xmath119 quite often , in the rest of the paper , we call this vector simply @xmath120 . for @xmath121 ,
we have @xmath122 it is easy to check that these vectors are mutually orthogonal , normalized in @xmath108 , and complete .
hence , @xmath123 is an orthonormal basis , as stated before .
this is not surprising , since its vectors are indeed the eigenvectors of @xmath91 : @xmath124 where @xmath125 .
more compactly we can simply write @xmath126 .
we see explicitly that the eigenvalues have an infinite degeneracy with respect to the quantum number @xmath61 , which can be removed by using the angular momentum @xcite .
we will not consider this aspect here , since it is not relevant for us .
of course , both @xmath116 and @xmath123 can be used to produce two different resolutions of the identity .
indeed we have @xmath127 for all @xmath117 .
* remark : * what we have seen so far can be easily adapted to the analysis of the hamiltonian for the other dirac cone , @xmath94 , which is simply the transpose of @xmath91 , and , as we have already pointed out , also to @xmath92 and @xmath97 .
we will say more on the other dirac cone in sec .
[ sec3.2 ] , in the presence of the @xmath0-symmetric potential .
we now introduce the @xmath0-symmetric chemical potential to eq .
( [ 23 ] ) as follows : @xmath128 where @xmath3 is assumed to be a strictly positive ( real ) quantity .
as we show the details in [ appb ] , for @xmath62 , the _ set _ of dirac cones at @xmath1 and @xmath2 are time - reversal symmetric as well as parity symmetric . for @xmath129
, it observes neither symmetries but does the @xmath0 symmetry .
an easy extension of the standard arguments allows us to deduce that the general expression of the eigenvectors are still , as in the case with @xmath62 , of the form ( [ 28 ] ) , but with some essential difference , which is also reflected in the form of the eigenvalues .
in particular we first find that @xmath130 which reduces to the known value if @xmath131 , and which is still independent of @xmath61 .
a major difference appears as follows : if @xmath132 , then the values of the energy are real ; we are in the @xmath0-symmetric region .
as soon as @xmath133 , however , the energy turns out to be complex , and we are in the @xmath0-broken region .
we will come back to this later on .
going now to the eigenvectors , we first observe that @xmath134 is an eigenvector of @xmath135 with the eigenvalue @xmath136 . on the other hand
, we can prove that there is no non - zero eigenstate corresponding to @xmath137 .
in fact , if we assume that such a non - zero vector @xmath138 does exist , it must satisfy the equation @xmath139 , which implies in turn that @xmath140 and @xmath141 should satisfy the equations @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
acting on this last with @xmath98 and using the first , we obtain @xmath144 , so that @xmath145 and therefore @xmath146 . then we have @xmath147 for this last equality to be satisfied , we must have @xmath148 . hence @xmath141 must be zero . the fact that @xmath149 also is now a consequence of the equality above @xmath143 , at least if @xmath129 .
then the trivial vector @xmath150 is the only solution that satisfies the equation @xmath139 . in the limit @xmath62 ,
on the other hand , the equation @xmath143 does not imply that @xmath149 and in fact a nontrivial ground state in this case does exist , as discussed in sec .
[ sectsam ] .
the reason for this is that , if @xmath62 , there is no difference between @xmath151 and @xmath152 , which are both zero . as for the levels with @xmath121 ,
the normalized eigenstates are deformed versions of those in eq .
( [ 28 ] ) .
more in detail , defining the following quantities , which are in general complex , @xmath153 we can write @xmath154 with these definitions we have @xmath155 it is easy to see what happens for @xmath156 , since this can be recovered from @xmath135 just replacing everywhere @xmath3 with @xmath157 .
in particular , since the eigenvalues are quadratic in @xmath3 , @xmath135 and @xmath156 turn out to be isospectral . concerning the eigenstates ,
these are deduced from the eigenvectors @xmath158 just with the same substitution .
more in details , calling @xmath159 for all @xmath121 , we can write @xmath160 and @xmath161 analogously to what happens for @xmath135 , only one ground state of @xmath156 does exist , which coincides with @xmath162 above . however , the corresponding eigenvalue is now @xmath137 , so that we conclude that @xmath163 . on the other hand ,
no non - zero eigenvector does exist which corresponds to @xmath136 .
we thus deduce a similar situation with respect to the one observed for @xmath135 .
we therefore conclude that the case @xmath50 is really exceptional ; indeed we have @xmath164 , while neither @xmath165 nor @xmath166 do exist .
this should be remembered in the rest of the paper , since all the formulas considered from now on , and in particular those in section [ sec3.1 ] , are valid only when these particular vectors are not involved .
* remarks : * ( i ) in the limit @xmath167 , all the result reduces to the ones discussed in sec .
[ sectsam ] .
in particular the fact that @xmath163 agrees with the fact that , in this limit , @xmath168 . it is also interesting to observe that the coefficients @xmath169 and @xmath170 simply returns @xmath171 or @xmath172 , as in formula ( [ 28 ] ) .
( ii ) the choice of normalization in ( [ 35 ] ) and ( [ 38 ] ) is such that @xmath173 .
we prefer this choice , rather than the one which could also be used which makes the scalar product between @xmath158 and @xmath174 equal to unity , since this biorthogonality strongly refer to the value of @xmath3 .
this will be evident in the next section .
let us call @xmath175 and @xmath176 .
because of their particular forms and because of the orthogonality of the vectors @xmath177 , it is clear that @xmath178 for all @xmath179 , and for all choices of @xmath180 and @xmath181 .
it is also possible to check that , @xmath182 therefore , eigenstates of @xmath135 corresponding to different eigenvalues are not mutually orthogonal .
this is not surprising , since @xmath135 is not hermitian in the present settings .
however , we can check that the orthogonality is recovered when @xmath3 is sent to zero , i.e. , when @xmath135 becomes hermitian .
what still remains , as quite often in situations like ours , is the possible biorthogonality of the sets @xmath183 and @xmath184 .
in fact , this is not so automatic , and needs some care .
the point is the following : if @xmath12 is not hermitian but two of its eigenvalues @xmath185 and @xmath186 are real , then the states @xmath187 and @xmath188 that satisfy @xmath189 and @xmath190 are guaranteed to be mutually orthogonal .
if @xmath185 or @xmath186 , or both , are complex , on the other hand , this is no longer granted in general .
we will show that in our particular situation of the @xmath0-broken region , the biorthogonality of the sets @xmath183 and @xmath184 is recovered only when properly pairing the eigenstates .
first we observe that @xmath191 can only be different from zero if @xmath192 .
otherwise these scalar products are all zero .
now , if we compute @xmath193 for instance , we deduce that , neglecting an unnecessary multiplication factor , @xmath194 the result of this computation depends on the values of @xmath58 and @xmath3 .
in fact , we can check that for @xmath132 , we have @xmath195 , but for @xmath196 this is not true .
hence @xmath197 similarly we can check that @xmath198 is zero for @xmath132 , but is not zero otherwise .
it is also interesting to notice that a completely opposite result is deduced in the @xmath0-broken region , i.e. for purely imaginary eigenvalues .
in fact , for @xmath133 , we deduce that the different pair satisfies @xmath199 so that they are biorthogonal , while they are in general not for @xmath200 : @xmath201 for @xmath200 .
these results are of course related to the reality of the eigenvalues of @xmath135 and @xmath156 .
in fact , when @xmath132 , the eigenvalues @xmath202 are all real , and we know for general reasons that @xmath158 must be orthogonal to @xmath203 , but not , in general , to @xmath174 . on the other hand , when the eigenvalues are purely imaginary , @xmath158 are necessarily orthogonal to @xmath174 , but not to @xmath203 .
this has consequences on the possibility of introducing a metric , at least in the way which is discussed in ref .
@xcite for instance ; see [ appa ] . here
, in fact , the intertwining operator between @xmath135 and @xmath156 has the formal expression @xmath204 ( we recall that @xmath205 ) . however this operator acts in different ways depending on whether we are in the @xmath0-symmetric or @xmath0-broken region .
for instance , for @xmath200 ( @xmath0-symmetric region ) , @xmath206 is proportional to @xmath207 .
however , for @xmath133 ( @xmath0-broken region ) , we can find that @xmath206 is proportional to @xmath208 .
therefore , except for some multiplicative coefficients which can be fixed properly , @xmath209 can change eigenstates @xmath210 of @xmath156 either into the eigenstates @xmath207 or into the eigenstates @xmath208 of @xmath135 , depending on the parameter region .
of course , a similar behavior is expected for an operator @xmath211 defined in analogy with @xmath209 .
an interesting issue to consider now is the completeness of the sets @xmath183 and @xmath184 . in many applications in quantum mechanics with non - hermitian hamiltonians
the eigenvectors of a given @xmath12 and @xmath212 are , in fact , non - orthogonal but complete in their hilbert space . what may or may not be true is that they are also bases for such a hilbert space @xcite .
hence , it is surely worth to investigate this kind of properties for @xmath183 and @xmath184 . in the present case ,
we obtain the following interesting result : if @xmath3 is such that @xmath213 is not a natural number , then @xmath183 and @xmath184 are complete in @xmath108 . if , on the other hand , @xmath213 is a positive integer number @xmath214 , then @xmath183 and @xmath184 are not complete .
let @xmath215 be a vector which is orthogonal to all the eigenvectors @xmath158 .
we would like to show if and in which condition @xmath216 is zero .
first of all , since @xmath217 in particular , it follows that @xmath218 for all @xmath219 .
moreover , we also have , for @xmath121 and for all @xmath61 , @xmath220 then , by subtraction , we have @xmath221 but , since @xmath222 , it follows that , if @xmath213 is not equal to any natural numbers , then @xmath223 for all @xmath61 and for all @xmath121 .
then , because of the completeness of the set @xmath224 , we conclude that @xmath225 .
this result , together with ( [ 310 ] ) , now implies that @xmath226 for all @xmath61 and for @xmath121 .
since we also have that @xmath218 , however , it follows that @xmath227 after using again the completeness of @xmath224 . hence @xmath228 .
let us now check what happens if @xmath229 , for some particular natural number @xmath214 . in this case
we find that @xmath230 for all @xmath61 , and therefore @xmath231 we see that we are _ losing one vector _ , so that it is not really surprising that the set @xmath183 ceases to be complete .
in fact , a simple computation shows that , for instance , the non - zero vector @xmath232 is orthogonal to all the eigenvectors @xmath158 as well as to @xmath233 for all fixed @xmath219 .
a similar proof can be repeated for the set @xmath184 .
* remarks : * ( i ) the content of this proposition can be understood in terms of exceptional points : we have an exceptional point when @xmath229 , for a natural number @xmath214 , while no exceptional point exists if @xmath213 is not natural .
it is exactly the presence of an exceptional point which makes two eigenvectors collapse into a single one , and this prevent @xmath183 to be a basis .
\(ii ) the above result implies that in order for @xmath183 or @xmath184 to be bases for @xmath108 , @xmath3 must be such that its square is not a natural number , since any basis must be , first of all , complete and , in this situation , our sets are not . on the other hand ,
whenever @xmath213 is not an integer , @xmath183 or @xmath184 could be bases , but the question is , for the time being , still open .
we believe that , even if this is often not so for non - hermitian hamiltonians @xcite , it is probably true in the present situation .
it is now interesting to observe that the results that we have deduced so far can be easily adapted to the other dirac cone at @xmath2 .
this is because the hamiltonian @xmath234 in this case is simply the transpose of @xmath135 in eq .
( [ 31 ] ) .
hence we have @xmath235 if we now compare the generic eigenvalue equations for @xmath236 and @xmath234 , @xmath237 it is easy to see that the second equation is mapped into the first one if we put @xmath238 , @xmath239 and @xmath240 .
hence the conclusion is that the eigenvectors of @xmath234 are just those which we have deduced previously after this changes , and that the eigenvalues are just those of @xmath236 but with signs exchanged .
more in details we find that , for all @xmath219 and @xmath121 , @xmath241 where @xmath242 and @xmath243 when @xmath50 we have @xmath244 where @xmath245 , and @xmath246 combining @xmath247 for @xmath234 with @xmath136 for @xmath236 ( see below eq . ) , we see that these two eigenvalues become complex as in fig .
[ fig - exceptional point ] but without the horizontal arrows . notice that , similarly to what happened for @xmath236 , the hamiltonian @xmath234 has no ( non - zero ) eigenstate corresponding to @xmath248 .
similar features as those considered for @xmath236 arise also here , as for instance the completeness of the sets of eigenstates of @xmath234 and of its adjoint , and the conclusions do not differ from what we have found so far ; we will not repeat similar considerations here .
in this paper we have considered an extended non - hermitian version of the graphene hamiltonian close to the dirac points @xmath1 and @xmath2 . on a mathematical side
we have shown that , depending on the value of the parameter @xmath3 measuring this non - hermiticity , exceptional points may arise , which breaks down the existence of a basis for @xmath108 .
in fact , the set of eigenstates of @xmath236 is not even complete at the exceptional points .
we have also deduced an interesting behavior concerning the zeroth eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the model : while @xmath162 does exist , no @xmath166 can be found in @xmath108 , at least if @xmath249 .
similarly , @xmath250 does exist , but @xmath165 does not .
hence , introducing @xmath3 in the hamiltonian creates a sort of asymmetry between the plus and the minus eigenstates , at least for the ground state .
this asymmetry disappears as soon as @xmath3 is sent to zero .
if we compare the conclusion for the @xmath0-symmetric graphene with the physical view of the simplest case that we described in introduction , we may say the following .
the electrons doped on one sublattice may not be carried to the other sublattice through the central channels @xmath50 as soon as we introduce the @xmath0-symmetric chemical potential .
the other channels remain open until @xmath251 , when the corresponding @xmath58th channel is closed .
it may be an interesting future work to drive the system around an exceptional point to see the state swapping @xcite .
this work was supported by national group of mathematical physics ( gnfm - indam ) .
f.b . also acknowledges partial support by the university of palermo .
this paper does not contain any computational solution .
this work did not involve any active collection of human data .
this work does not have any experimental data .
we have no competing interests .
fb cured the mathematical part of the paper , with the help of nh .
nh cured the physical interpretation of the results , with the help of fb .
both authors gave final approval for publication .
this work was partly supported by gnfm - indam and by the university of palermo .
we here briefly describe the general notion of the intertwining operator that we have introduced in sec .
[ sec3.1 ] . in order to avoid mathematical problems , we focus here on finite - dimensional hilbert spaces . in this way
our operators are finite matrices .
the main ingredient is an operator ( i.e. a matrix ) @xmath12 , acting on the vector space @xmath252 , with @xmath253 and with exactly @xmath254 distinct eigenvalues @xmath20 , @xmath255 , where the hermitian conjugate @xmath256 of @xmath12 is the usual one , i.e. the complex conjugate of the transpose of the matrix @xmath12 . because of what follows , and in order to fix the ideas , it is useful to remind here that the hermitian conjugate @xmath257 of an operator @xmath258 is defined in terms of the _ natural _ scalar product @xmath259 of the hilbert space @xmath260 : @xmath261 , for all @xmath262 , where @xmath263 , with obvious notation . in this appendix
we will restrict to the case in which all the eigenvalues @xmath20 are real , and with multiplicity one .
hence @xmath264 the set @xmath265 is a basis for @xmath252 , since the eigenvalues are all different .
then an unique biorthogonal basis of @xmath78 , @xmath266 , surely exists @xcite : @xmath267 , for all @xmath268 .
it is easy to check that @xmath269 is automatically an eigenstate of @xmath256 , with eigenvalue @xmath270 : @xmath271 using the bra - ket notation we can write @xmath272 , where , for all @xmath273 , we define @xmath274 . we now introduce the ` intertwining ' operators @xmath275 and @xmath276 , following ref .
these are bounded positive , hermitian , invertible operators , one the inverse of the other : @xmath277 .
moreover @xmath278 and we also get the following intertwining relations involving @xmath12 , @xmath256 , @xmath279 and @xmath211 : @xmath280 notice that the second equality follows from the first one , by left and right multiplying @xmath281 with @xmath279 . to prove the first equality , we first observe that @xmath282 for all @xmath283 .
hence our claim follows because of the basis nature of @xmath284 .
* remark : * it might be interesting to recall that the intertwining operators , such as @xmath279 and @xmath211 , are quite useful in quantum mechanics , @xmath0-symmetric or not @xcite , in order to deduce eigenvectors of certain hamiltonians connected by intertwining relations . for instance ,
let us assume that @xmath285 is an eigenstate of a certain operator @xmath286 with eigenvalue @xmath20 : @xmath287 , and let us also assume that two other operators @xmath288 and @xmath258 exist such that @xmath289 and that the intertwining relation @xmath290 is satisfied .
this is exactly what happens in ( [ a4 ] ) , identifying @xmath258 with @xmath211 , @xmath286 with @xmath12 and @xmath288 with @xmath256 .
then , it is a trivial exercise to check that the non - zero vector @xmath291 is an eigenstate of @xmath288 , with eigenvalue @xmath20 .
indeed we have @xmath292 note that the fact that @xmath286 and @xmath288 are hermitian or not and the fact that @xmath20 is real or not play no role .
note also that the fact that @xmath293 can be deduced out of @xmath285 simply by applying @xmath258 , is exactly what happens in our situation ; see eq .
( [ a3 ] ) .
this explains why the intertwining operators are so important in concrete applications ; they can be used , for instance , to find eigenstates of new operators starting from eigenstates of old ones .
* remark : * it is probably worth mentioning that not all we have discussed here can be easily extended if @xmath294 . for instance , considering the intertwining relations in ( [ a4 ] ) , if , for instance , @xmath12 and @xmath279 are unbounded , taken @xmath295 , the domain of @xmath279 , there is no reason _ a priori _ for @xmath296 to belong to @xmath297 , so that @xmath298 needs not to be defined .
in this appendix we will briefly discuss the role of the @xmath11 and @xmath9 symmetries in our model .
the @xmath11 operator works as follows : @xmath299 note that , as expected for physical reasons , the time - reversal operator flips the magnetic field too .
we therefore have @xmath300 when we apply @xmath11 to @xmath301 we have @xmath302 we thus realize that the time reversal of the dirac cone at @xmath1 is the negative of the dirac cone at @xmath2 . for @xmath62 , we can flip the sign by the diagonal unitary transformation @xmath303 as in @xmath304 .
similarly we have @xmath305 .
note that @xmath91 and @xmath92 are different expressions of the same hamiltonian , expressions which depend on the direction of the magnetic field along @xmath63 .
the model for @xmath62 is time - reversal symmetric in this sense . under @xmath11 , the dirac cone at @xmath1
is transformed to the one at @xmath2 , which in turn is transformed to the one at @xmath1 .
therefore , the set of the two dirac cones for @xmath62 has the time - reversal symmetry .
the time - reversal symmetry is broken when @xmath129 because @xmath306 .
this is also true for the parity operation @xmath307 for which we have @xmath308 for @xmath62 , this is isomorphic to @xmath97 but for @xmath129 , @xmath309 is isomorphic to @xmath310 , which is not equal to @xmath311 .
k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos , a. a. firsov , two - dimensional gas of massless dirac fermions in graphene , nature * 438 * , 197200 ( 2005 ) . c. dembowski , h .-
grf , h. l. harney , a. heine , w. d. heiss , h. rehfeld , a. richter , experimental observation of the topological structure of exceptional points , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 787790 ( 2001 ) .
m. brandstetter , m. liertzer , c. deutsch , p. klang , j. schberl , h. e. treci , g. strasser , k. unterrainer , s. rotter , reversing the pump dependence of a laser at an exceptional point , nature commun .
* 5 * , 4034 ( 2014 ) . c. r. dean , a. f. young , i. meric , c. lee ,
l. wang , s. sorgenfrei , k. watanabe , t. taniguchi , p. kim , k. l. shepard , j. hone , boron nitride substrates for high - quality graphene electronics , nature nanotech . * 5 * , 722726 ( 2010 ) .
l. ci , l. song , c. jin , d. jariwala , d. wu , y. li , a. srivastava , z. f. wang , k. storr , l. balicas , f. liu , p. m. ajayan , atomic layers of hybridized boron nitride and graphene domains , nature materials * 9 * , 430435 ( 2010 ) .
m. yankowitz , j. xue , d. cormode , j. d. sanchez - yamagishi , k. watanabe , t. taniguchi , p. jarillo - herrero , p. jacquod , b. j. leroy , emergence of superlattice dirac points in graphene on hexagonal boron nitride , nature physics * 8 * , 382386 ( 2012 ) .
f. bagarello , m. g. gianfreda , @xmath313deformed and susy - deformed graphene : first results , in _ non - hermitian hamiltonians in quantum physics _ - selected contributions from the 15th international conference on non - hermitian hamiltonians in quantum physics , palermo , italy , 18 - 23 may 2015 , springer ( 2016 ) f. bagarello , deformed canonical ( anti-)commutation relations and non - hermitian hamiltonians , in _ non - hermitian operators in quantum physics : mathematical aspects _ , f. bagarello , j. p. gazeau , f. h. szafraniek and m. znojil , eds . , john wiley and sons , new jersey ( 2015 ) | we propose a @xmath0-symmetrically deformed version of the graphene tight - binding model under a magnetic field .
we analyze the structure of the spectra and the eigenvectors of the hamiltonians around the @xmath1 and @xmath2 points , both in the @xmath0-symmetric and @xmath0-broken regions .
in particular we show that the presence of the deformation parameter @xmath3 produces several interesting consequences , including the asymmetry of the zero - energy states of the hamiltonians and the breakdown of the completeness of the eigenvector sets .
we also discuss the biorthogonality of the eigenvectors , which turns out to be different in the @xmath0-symmetric and @xmath0-broken regions . * @xmath0-symmetric graphene under a magnetic field * + fabio bagarello + dipartimento di energia , ingegneria dellinformazione e modelli matematici , + facolt di ingegneria , universit di palermo , + i-90128 palermo , italy + e - mail : [email protected] + home page : www.unipa.it/fabio.bagarello naomichi hatano + institute of industrial science , university of tokyo , + komaba 4 - 6 - 1 , meguro , tokyo 153 - 8505 , japan + e - mail : [email protected] + |
proteins are essential building blocks of living organisms .
they function as catalyst , structural elements , chemical signals , receptors , etc . the molecular mechanism of protein functions are closely related to their structures .
the study of structure - function relationship is the holy grail of biophysics and has attracted enormous effort in the past few decades .
the understanding of such a relationship enables us to predict protein functions from structure or amino acid sequence or both , which remains major challenge in molecular biology .
intensive experimental investigation has been carried out to explore the interactions among proteins or proteins with other biomolecules , e.g. , dnas and/or rnas . in particular , the understanding of protein - drug interactions is of premier importance to human health .
a wide variety of theoretical and computational approaches has been proposed to understand the protein structure - function relationship .
one class of approaches is biophysical . from the point of view of biophysics , protein structure , function , dynamics and transport are , in general , dictated by protein interactions .
quantum mechanics ( qm ) is based on the fundamental principle , and offers the most accurate description of interactions among electrons , photons , atoms and even molecules .
although qm methods have unveiled many underlying mechanisms of reaction kinetics and enzymatic activities , they typically are computationally too expensive to do for large biomolecules . based on classic physical laws , molecular mechanics ( mm ) @xcite can , in combination with fitted parameters , simulate the physical movement of atoms or molecules for relatively large biomolecular systems like proteins quite precisely .
however , it can be computationally intractable for macromoelcular systems involving realistic biological time scales . many time - independent methods like normal mode analysis ( nma ) @xcite , elastic network model ( enm ) @xcite , graph theory @xcite and flexibility - rigidity index ( fri ) @xcite are proposed to capture features of large biomolecules .
variational multiscale methods @xcite are another class of approaches that combine atomistic description with continuum approximations .
there are well developed servers for predicting protein functions based on three - dimensional ( 3d ) structures @xcite or models from the homology modeling ( here homology is in biological sense ) of amino acid sequence if 3d structure is not yet available @xcite .
another class of important approaches , bioinformatical methods , plays a unique role for the understanding of the structure - function relationship .
these data - driven predictions are based on similarity analysis .
the essential idea is that proteins with similar sequences or structures may share similar functions .
also , based on sequential or structural similarity , proteins can be classified into many different groups .
once the sequence or structure of a novel protein is identified , its function can be predicted by assigning it to the group of proteins that share similarities to a good extent .
however , the degree of similarity depends on the criteria used to measure similarity or difference .
many measurements are used to describe similarity between two protein samples .
typical approaches use either sequence or physical information , or both . among them , sequence alignment can describe how closely the two proteins are related .
protein blast @xcite , clustalw2 @xcite , and other software packages can preform global or local sequence alignments .
based on sequence alignments , various scoring methods can provide the description of protein similarity @xcite .
additionally , sequence features such as sequence length and occurrence percentage of a specific amino acid can also be employed to compare proteins .
many sequence based features can be derived from the position - specific scoring matrix ( pssm ) @xcite . moreover
, structural information provides an efficient description of protein similarity as well .
structure alignment methods include rigid , flexible and other methods .
the combination of different structure alignment methods and different measurements such as root - mean - square deviation ( rmsd ) and z - score gives rise to various ways to quantify the similarity among proteins .
as per structure information , different physical properties such as surface area , volume , free energy , flexible - rigidity index ( fri ) @xcite , curvature @xcite , electrostatics @xcite etc . can be calculated .
a continuum model , poisson boltzmann ( pb ) equation delivers quite accurate estimation for electrostatics of biomolecules .
there are many efficient and accurate pb solvers including pbeq @xcite , mibpb @xcite , etc .
together with physical properties , one can also extract geometrical properties from structure information .
these properties include coordinates of atoms , connections between atoms such as covalent bonds and hydrogen bonds , molecular surfaces @xcite and curvatures @xcite .
these various approaches reveal information of different scales from local atom arrangement to global architecture .
physical and geometrical properties described above add different perspective to analyze protein similarities .
due to the advance in bioscience and biotechnology , biomolecular structure date sets are growing at an unprecedented rate .
for example , the http://www.rcsb.org/pdb/home/home.do[protein data bank ( pdb ) ] has accumulated more than a hundred thousand biomolecular structures .
the prediction of the protein structure - function relationship from such huge amount of data can be extremely challenging .
additionally , an eve - growing number of physical or sequence features are evaluated for each data set or amino - acid residue , which adds to the complexity of the data - driven prediction . to automatically analyze excessively large data sets in molecular biology , many machine learning methods
have been developed @xcite .
these methods are mainly utilized for the classification , regression , comparison and clustering of biomolecular data .
clustering is an unsupervised learning method which divides a set of inputs into groups without knowing the groups beforehand .
this method can unveil hidden patterns in the data set .
classification is a supervised learning method , in which , a classifier is trained on a given training set and used to do prediction for new observations .
it assigns observation to one of several pre - determined categories based on knowledge from training data set in which the label of observations is known .
popular methods for classification include support vector machine ( svm ) @xcite , artificial neural network ( ann ) @xcite , deep learning @xcite , etc . in classification ,
each observation in training the set has a feature vector that describes the observation from various perspectives and a label that indicates to which group the observation belongs . a model trained on the training set indicates to which group a new observation belongs with feature vector and unknown label . to improve the speed of classification and reduce effect from irrelevant features
, many feature selection procedures have been proposed @xcite .
machine learning approach are successfully used for protein hot spot prediction @xcite .
the data - driven analysis of the protein structure - function relationship is compromised by the fact that same protein may have different conformations which possess different properties or delivers different functions . for instance , hemoglobins have taut form with low affinity to oxygen and relaxed form with high affinity to oxygen ; and ion channels often have open and close states .
different conformations of a given protein may only have minor differences in their local geometric configurations .
these conformations share the same sequence and may have very similar physical properties .
however , their minor structural differences might lead to dramatically different functions .
therefore , apart from the conventional physical and sequence information , geometric and topological information can also play an important role in understanding the protein structure - function relationship .
indeed , geometric information has been extensively used in the protein exploration . in contrast , topological information has been hardly employed in studying the protein structure - function relationship . in general , geometric approaches are frequently inundated with too much geometric detail and are often prohibitively expensive for most realistic biomolecular systems , while traditional topological methods often incur in too much reduction of the original geometric and physical information .
persistent homology , a new branch of applied topology , is able to bridge traditional geometry and topology .
it creates a variety of topologies of a given object by varying a filtration parameter , such as a radius or a level set function . in the past decade
, persistent homology has been developed as a new multiscale representation of topological features .
the 0-th dimensional version was originally introduced for computer vision applications under the name size function " @xcite and the idea was also studied by robins @xcite .
the persistent homology theory was formulated , together with an algorithm given , by edelsbrunner et al .
@xcite , and a more general theory was developed by zomorodian and carlsson @xcite
. there has since been significant theoretical development @xcite , as well as various computational algorithms @xcite .
often , persistent homology can be visualized through barcodes @xcite , in which various horizontal line segments or bars are the homology generators which survive over filtration scales .
persistence diagrams are another equivalent representation @xcite .
computational homology and persistent homology have been applied to a variety of domains , including image analysis @xcite , chaotic dynamics verification @xcite , sensor network @xcite , complex network @xcite , data analysis @xcite , shape recognition @xcite and computational biology @xcite .
compared with traditional computational topology @xcite and/or computational homology , persistent homology inherently has an additional dimension , the filtration parameter , which can be utilized to embed some crucial geometric or quantitative information into the topological invariants . the importance of retaining geometric information in topological analysis has been recognized @xcite , and topology has been advocated as a new approach for tackling big data sets @xcite . recently , we have introduced persistent homology for mathematical modeling and prediction of nano particles , proteins and other biomolecules @xcite .
we have proposed molecular topological fingerprint ( mtf ) to reveal topology - function relationships in protein folding and protein flexibility @xcite .
we have employed persistent homology to predict the curvature energies of fullerene isomers @xcite , and analyze the stability of protein folding @xcite .
more recently , we have introduced resolution based persistent topology @xcite .
most recently , we have developed new multidimensional persistence , a topic that has attracted much attention in the past few years @xcite , to better bridge geometry and traditional topology and achieve better characterization of biomolecular data @xcite .
we have also introduced the use of topological fingerprint for resolving ill - posed inverse problems in cryo - em structure determination @xcite .
the objective of the present work is to explore the utility of mtfs for protein classification and analysis .
we construct feature vectors based on mtfs to describe unique topological properties of protein in different scales , states and/or conformations .
these topological feature vectors are further used in conjugation with the svm algorithm for the classification of proteins .
we validate the proposed mtf - svm strategy by distinguishing different protein conformations , proteins with different local secondary structures , and proteins from different superfamilies or families .
the performance of proposed topological method is demonstrated by a number of realistic applications , including protein binding analysis , ion channel study , etc .
the rest of the paper is organized as following .
section [ sec : methods ] is devoted to the mathematical foundations for persistent homology and machine learning methods .
we present a brief description of simplex and simplicial complex followed by basic concept of homology , filtration , and persistence in section [ persistenthomology ] .
three different methods to get simplicial complex , vietoris - rips complex , alpha complex , and ech complex are discussed .
we use a sequence of graphs of channel proteins to illustrate the growth of a vietoris - rips complex and corresponding barcode representation of topological persistence . in section [ svm+roc ] , fundamental concept of support vector machine
is discussed .
an introduction of transformation of the original optimization problem is given .
a measurement for the performance of classification model known as receiver operating characteristic is described .
section [ feature+preprocessing ] is devoted to the description of features used in the classification and pre - processing of topological feature vectors . in section [ sec : numerical ]
, four test cases are shown .
case 1 and case 2 examine the performance of the topological fingerprint based classification methods in distinguishing different conformations of same proteins . in case 1 , we use the structure of the m2 channel of influenza a virus with and without an inhibitor . in case 2 , we employ the structure of hemoglobin in taut form and relaxed form .
case 3 validates the proposed topological methods in capturing the difference between local secondary structures . in this study
, proteins are divided into three groups , all alpha protein , all beta protein , and alpha+beta protein . in case 4 ,
the ability of the present method for distinguishing different protein families is examined .
this paper ends with some concluding remarks .
this section presents a brief review of persistent homology theory and illustrates its use in proteins . a brief description of machine learning methods is also given .
the topological feature selection and construction from biomolecular data are described in details .
* simplex * a @xmath0-simplex denoted by @xmath1 is a convex hull of @xmath2 vertices which is represented by a set of points @xmath3 where @xmath4 is a set of affinely independent points .
geometrically , a @xmath5-@xmath6 is a line segment , a @xmath7-simplex is a triangle , a @xmath8-simplex is a tetrahedron , and a @xmath9-simplex is a @xmath10-cell ( a four dimensional object bounded by five tetrahedrons ) .
a @xmath11face of the @xmath0-simplex is defined as a convex hull formed from a subset consisting @xmath12 vertices .
* simplicial complex * a simplicial complex @xmath13 is a finite collection of simplices satisfying two conditions .
first , faces of a simplex in @xmath13 are also in @xmath13 ; second , intersection of any two simplices in @xmath13 is a face of both the simplices .
the highest dimension of simplices in @xmath13 determines dimension of @xmath13 .
* homology * for a simplicial complex @xmath13 , a @xmath0-chain is a formal sum of the form @xmath14 $ ] , where @xmath15 $ ] is oriented @xmath0-simplex from @xmath13 . for simplicity
, we choose @xmath16 .
all these @xmath0-chains on @xmath13 form an abelian group , called chain group and denoted as @xmath17 .
a boundary operator @xmath18 over a @xmath0-simplex @xmath1 is defined as , @xmath19,\ ] ] where @xmath20 $ ] denotes the face obtained by deleting the @xmath21th vertex in the simplex .
the boundary operator induces a boundary homomorphism @xmath22 .
an very important property of the boundary operator is that the composition operator @xmath23 is a zero map , @xmath24+\sum_{j > i}(-1)^i(-1)^{j-1}[u_0, ... ,\widehat{u_j}, ... \widehat{u_i}, ... u_k ] \\ & = 0 \end{aligned}\ ] ] a sequence of chain groups connected by boundary operation form a chain complex , @xmath25{}}c_n(\mathcal{k})\xrightarrow{\makebox[.27in]{$\partial_n$}}c_{n-1}(\mathcal{k})\xrightarrow{\makebox[.27in]{$\partial_{n-1}$}}\cdots\xrightarrow{\makebox[.27in]{$\partial_1$}}c_0(\mathcal{k } ) \xrightarrow{\makebox[.27in]{$\partial_0$}}0.\ ] ] the equation @xmath26 is equivalent to the inclusion @xmath27 , when @xmath28 and @xmath29 denotes image and kernel
. elements of @xmath30 are called @xmath0th cycle group , and denoted as @xmath31=ker@xmath18 .
elements of @xmath32 are called @xmath0th boundary group , and denoted as @xmath33=im@xmath34 .
a @xmath0th homology group is defined as the quotient group of @xmath31 and @xmath33 .
@xmath35 the @xmath0th betti number of simplicial complex @xmath13 is the rank of @xmath36 , @xmath37 betti number @xmath38 is finite number , since @xmath39 .
betti numbers computed from a homology group are used to describe the corresponding space . generally speaking ,
the betti numbers @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are numbers of connected components , tunnels , and cavities , respectively . *
filtration and persistence * a filtration of a simplicial complex @xmath13 is a nested sequence of subcomplexes of @xmath13 .
@xmath43 with a filtration of simplicial complex @xmath13 , topological attributes can be generated for each member in the sequence by deriving the homology group of each simplicial complex .
the topological features that are long lasting through the filtration sequence are more likely to capture significant property of the object .
intuitively , non - boundary cycles that are not mapped into boundaries too fast along the filtration are considered to be possibly involved in major features or persistence .
equipped with a proper derivation of filtration and a wise choice of threshold to define persistence , it is practicable to filter out topological noises and acquire attributes of interest . the @xmath44-persistent @xmath0th homology group of @xmath45 is defined as @xmath46 where @xmath47 and @xmath48 . the consequent @xmath44-persistent @xmath0th betti number is @xmath49 .
a well chosen @xmath44 promises reasonable elimination of topological noise .
* vietoris - rips complex * based on a metric space @xmath50 and a given cutoff distance @xmath51 , an abstract simplicial complex can be built .
if two points in @xmath50 have a distance shorter than the given distance @xmath51 , an edge is formed between these two points . consequently , simplices of different dimensions are formed and a simplicial complex is built . for a point cloud data ,
natural metric space based on euclidean distance or other metric spaces based on alternative definition of distance can be used to build a vietoris - rips complex .
for example , any correlation matrix can be used directly to form a vietoris - rips complex .
figure [ fig : ex1 ] illustrates growth of vietoris - rips complex along with increment of @xmath51 over the point set of @xmath52 atoms from m2 chimera channel .
there are many ways of constructing complex other than vietoris - rips complex , including alpha complex , cech complex , cw complex , etc . in the present work ,
we used vietoris - rips complex in part because of its intuitive nature and in part because of the moderate size of the systems we studied .
the computational topology package javaplex@xcite was used for computation of persistent homology .
the results were represented in the form of barcodes @xcite .
figure [ fig : ex2 ] illustrates barcodes computed from a point cloud data extracted from @xmath53 atoms of protein i d 2ljc .
svm is a machine learning method that can be applied to classification and regression problems .
it computes a hyperplane which maximizes margin between positive and negative training sets . in this work , classification svm type 1 ,
also known as c - support vector classification ( c - svc ) @xcite is used .
for the problem of classification , with pre - determined classes , a classifier is trained on a data set with the description of samples and their classes and it predicts the class of a new observation .
the input for svm is a set of samples .
each sample has a feature vector that describes the properties of the sample and a label that implies to which class the sample belongs .
given the input which is the training set , svm will generate a hyperplane in the feature space or higher dimensional spaces depending on which kernel it uses that separates the classes .
for two - class svm , it looks for a hyperplane @xmath54 that separates the classes . the determination of the coefficients @xmath55 and @xmath56 breaks down to a constrained optimization problem as @xmath57 subject to @xmath58 where @xmath59 denotes the feature vector of the @xmath21th sample , @xmath60 is the label of the @xmath21th sample which takes value of either @xmath5 or @xmath61 , and @xmath62 is a penalty coefficient for misclassified points . to handle linearly inseparable data ,
one maps the data into a higher dimensional space as @xmath63 with @xmath64 . since in the optimization problem and in scoring function of the classifier ,
the operator used is dot product , @xmath65 does not need to be explicitly found . a decaying kernel @xmath66 function is used to represent @xmath67 .
commonly used kernel functions include linear function : @xmath68 , polynomial : @xmath69 , radial basis functions ( rbfs ) such as gaussian @xmath70 .
in fact , the admissible kernels of fleibility - rigidity index ( fri ) @xcite work too . in this work ,
the gaussian kernel is used and a 5-fold cross validation was applied to search for optimized training parameters for problems with large amount of samples . to solve the optimization problem ,
the original problem is transformed into the corresponding lagrange dual problem . for a contained optimization problem
@xmath71 the lagrange function of this problem is defined as @xmath72 where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are lagrange multipliers .
the lagrange dual problem is defined as @xmath75 where @xmath76 .
the lagrange function of the original optimization problem ( [ eq : opt-1 ] ) is formulated as @xmath77 tthe corresponding dual problem with karush - kuhn - tucker conditions is defined as @xmath78 the dual problem can be solved with sequential minimal optimization ( smo ) method @xcite .
roc is a plot that visualizes the performance of a binary classifier @xcite . a binary classifier uses a threshold value to decide the prediction label of an entry . in testing process , we define true positive rate ( tpr ) and false positive rate ( fpr ) for the testing set . @xmath79 an roc space is a two dimensional space defined by points with @xmath80 coordinate representing fpr and @xmath81 coordinate representing tpr . in the prediction process of a binary classifier , a score is assigned to a sample by the classifier .
a test sample may be labeled as positive or negative with different threshold value used by the classifier .
corresponding to a certain threshold value , there is a pair of fpr and tpr values which is a point in the roc space .
all such points will fall in the box @xmath82\times[0,1]$ ] .
points above the diagonal line @xmath83 are considered as good predictors and those below the line are considered as poor predictors . if a point is below the diagonal line , the predictor can be inverted to be a good predictor . for points that are close to the diagonal line
, they are considered to act similarly to random guess which implies a relatively useless predictor .
roc curve is obtained by plotting fpr and tpr as continuous functions of threshold value .
the area between roc curve and @xmath80 axis represents probability that the classifier assigns higher score to a randomly chosen positive sample than to a randomly chosen negative sample if positive is set to have higher score than negative .
the area under the curve ( auc ) of roc is a measure of classifier quality .
intuitively , a higher auc implies a better classifier . in this work ,
algebraic topology is employed to discriminate proteins . specifically , we compute mtfs through the filtration process of protein structural data .
mtfs bear the persistence of topological invariants during the filtration and are ideally suited for protein classification .
to implement our topological approach in the svm algorithm , we construct protein feature vectors by using mtfs .
we select distinguishing protein features from mtfs .
these features can be both long lasting and short lasting betti 0 , betti 1 , and betti 2 intervals . table [ tab : features ] lists topological features used for classification
. detailed explanation of these features is discussed .
the length and location value of bars are in the unit of angstrom ( ) for protein data . | protein function and dynamics are closely related to its sequence and structure
. however prediction of protein function and dynamics from its sequence and structure is still a fundamental challenge in molecular biology .
protein classification , which is typically done through measuring the similarity between proteins based on protein sequence or physical information , serves as a crucial step toward the understanding of protein function and dynamics .
persistent homology is a new branch of algebraic topology that has found its success in the topological data analysis in a variety of disciplines , including molecular biology .
the present work explores the potential of using persistent homology as an independent tool for protein classification . to this end
, we propose a molecular topological fingerprint based support vector machine ( mtf - svm ) classifier .
specifically , we construct machine learning feature vectors solely from protein topological fingerprints , which are topological invariants generated during the filtration process . to validate the present mtf - svm approach , we consider four types of problems .
first , we study protein - drug binding by using the m2 channel protein of influenza a virus .
we achieve 96% accuracy in discriminating drug bound and unbound m2 channels .
additionally , we examine the use of mtf - svm for the classification of hemoglobin molecules in their relaxed and taut forms and obtain about 80% accuracy .
the identification of all alpha , all beta , and alpha - beta protein domains is carried out in our next study using 900 proteins .
we have found a 85% success in this identification . finally , we apply the present technique to 55 classification tasks of protein superfamilies over 1357 samples . an average accuracy of 82% is attained .
the present study establishes computational topology as an independent and effective alternative for protein classification .
key words : persistent homology , machine learning , protein classification , topological fingerprint .
* running title : topological protein classification * |
the light source of our experiment is a continuous - wave ( cw ) ti : sapphire laser operating at the wavelength of 860 nm .
in addition to the setup shown in fig .
1a , there are two optical cavities which are omitted from fig . 1a .
one cavity is a second - harmonic generator , which is a bow - tie - shaped cavity and contains a periodically - poled ktiopo@xmath1 ( ppktp ) crystal as a nonlinear optical medium . the resulting continuous output beam at the wavelength of 430 nm is , after a frequency shift by an acousto - optic modulator , directed as a pump beam to each memory cavity , which contains a periodically - poled ktiopo@xmath1 ( ppktp ) crystal as a nonlinear optical medium and works as a non - degenerate optical parametric oscillator ( nopo ) .
the pumping power at each memory cavity is about 3 mw .
optionally , the pump beams can be individually blocked after a herald in order to prevent further production of photons , but this was not employed in this demonstration , because the probability of such unwanted events is small .
the other cavity is a mode - cleaning cavity , by which the transverse mode of the local oscillators is purified to a tem@xmath2 mode in order to maximize the interference visibility at the homodyne detections .
the power of each local oscillator is about 18 mw . the concatenated - cavity - based memory systems ( memory-1 , memory-2 ) have the same design , similar to our previous experiment @xcite but with parameters slightly different from before .
the design of the concatenated - cavity - based memory system is as follows .
the transmissivity of the coupling mirror that couples the memory cavity and the shutter cavity is 1.6 % and the transmissivity of the outcoupling mirror at the exit of the shutter cavity is 24.7% .
the former transmissivity corresponds to a compromise between long lifetime and phase - locking stability , while the latter is set in accordance with the former in order to operate the system nearly at the critical damping condition @xcite .
the memory cavity has a free spectrum range ( fsr ) of 214.1 mhz .
spontaneous parametric down conversion inside the memory cavity produces signal and idler photons which are separated by this fsr .
the shutter cavity contains an electro - optic modulator ( eom ) , which is a rbtiopo@xmath1 ( rtp ) crystal with an aperture size of 4 mm @xmath3 4 mm .
it is driven by a high - voltage switch ( bergmann messgerte entwicklung kg ) , whose voltage is around 900 v to match the frequency shift to the fsr of the memory cavity . in order to stabilize the whole setup ,
all of the resonant frequencies of the cavities and the phases of the local oscillators are each electronically controlled by using a feedback loop .
each controller is composed of an analog feedback controller , an error detector of locking , and a digital scanner for the error recovery .
the error detection signals from all of the controllers are brought together by logical or gates , and then sent to the timing controller in order to pause the measurement when there is an error .
the timing controller is a field - programmable gate array ( fpga ) ( virtex-4 , xilinx ) , which processes the heralding signals and controls the timing of the photon release .
the same timing controller actually also controls the sequence of the switching between the feedback phase and the measurement phase , as explained below . for the analog feedback control ,
we monitor the optical systems by means of bright beams .
however , such bright beams , except for the local oscillator beams and the pump beams , represent an extra complication in our single - photon - level experiment .
therefore we cyclically switch the optical systems .
one phase is the feedback phase where the bright beams are injected to the cavity systems .
the other is the measurement phase where the bright beams are blocked and the two - photon interference is tested .
the switching rate is 5 khz , and the duty cycle is 40% for the measurement phase .
as mentioned above , the fpga controls the release timing of photons .
the fpga clock frequency is 100 mhz , and thus , in our system , the release timings are synchronized with 10 ns intervals .
note that the timing jitter of the driving signals in the timing controller was negligibly small ( less than 1 ns ) , compared to the width of the wavepackets of photons ( about 100 ns ) .
the photon arrival times of the two inputs are matched by adjusting the electric cable lengths from the timing controller to the eoms , as well as the optical path lengths from the exits of the shutter cavities to the balanced beam splitter of the hom interferometer .
the lengths of the two output arms to the data - storage oscilloscope are also matched .
these were tested in the preliminary experiment . in the hom experiment ,
the photons are released when both heralding events of memory-1 and memory-2 happen within 2 @xmath4 .
if the second herald does not occur by 2 @xmath4 , the timing controller becomes idle and waits for 5 @xmath0s , which is long enough compared to the memory lifetime of about 2 @xmath0s . during this dead time ,
the heralded photon is almost lost and the memory systems are almost initialized again .
in the preliminary experiment , we tested our memory systems by using a highly reflective mirror as the replaceable mirror ( rm ) . for each memory-@xmath5 , we repeated single - photon generation and homodyne detection 43,404 times for each variable set storage time @xmath6 after the herald , changed from 0 ns to 500 ns at 50-ns intervals . from the results , we estimated the shapes of the wavepackets @xmath7 by utilizing principal component analysis @xcite , as shown in fig . 1b , and calculated the single - photon purities @xmath8 ( corresponding to the respective single - photon fractions ) , as shown in fig .
the single - photon purities are shown to degrade for longer storage times indicating a finite memory lifetime , but the wigner - function - negativity condition @xcite with purities above 0.5 is still satisfied for up to about 0.4 @xmath0s . as shown in fig .
1c , the maximum storage time @xmath9 of the synchronization can be set much longer than this 0.4 @xmath0s , thus preserving the negativity .
the shapes of the estimated wavepackets @xmath7 , shown in fig . 1b , are independent of @xmath6 , excluding pre - leakage .
furthermore , they are almost the same between memory-1 and memory-2 .
the overlap @xmath10 was 0.992 .
we defined the signal wavepacket for the hom experiment as an average temporal mode : @xmath11/ \sqrt{\int dt | f_1(t ; 0 ) + f_2(t ; 0)|^2}$ ] .
the overlap between the signal wavepacket and the estimated wavepacket released from the individual memory-@xmath5 after @xmath6 , defined as @xmath12 , was larger than 0.96 for up to @xmath6 = 500 ns , as listed in supplementary table [ table : modefunction ] .
this high value contributes to the visibility of the hom interference and the purities of the input states .
the estimated purities @xmath8 corresponding to the estimated wavepackets @xmath7 in fig .
1bare listed in table [ table : modefunction ] , corresponding to the exact values of the points in fig . s1a .
in order to exclude the influence of the mode mismatches on the input purities , we also calculated purities @xmath13 by using the time - shifted signal wavepacket @xmath14 , as also shown in table [ table : modefunction ] . from the values below
, we can see that the contribution of the pre - leakage is very small .
the decay of the purity is thus due to the optical losses in each memory system .
these results are fitted with an exponential decay curve @xmath15 , where @xmath16 means the initial purity and @xmath17 means the memory lifetime for the memory system . in the hom experiment , we synchronized the photon sources , created an initial dual - single - photon state , and then obtained an output hom state by replacing the highly - reflective rm in fig .
1a with a balanced beam splitter .
the storage time of each event was recorded together with the homodyne outcomes .
then , in order to observe the dependence on @xmath9 , we analyzed those events associated with a storage time between 0 and @xmath9
. figure s1b shows the obtained number of events with respect to each @xmath9 .
it indicates a linear increase of the dual - heralding event rate for any extension of @xmath9 .
here we discuss how the maximum storage time @xmath9 is dependent on the dual - heralding event rate .
we assume that the individual heralding events of the memories occur at random and independently , i.e. they follow the poisson distributions with average event rates @xmath18 for each memory-@xmath5 ( @xmath19 ) .
considering the ( dimensionless ) measurement duty @xmath20 and ignoring the 5-@xmath0s dead time for simplicity , the theoretical dual - heralding event rate is given by @xmath21 , when @xmath9 is much smaller than @xmath22 and @xmath23 . here
the factor of 2 effectively stems from the fact that the first heralding event may occur in either of memory-1 and memory-2 .
this linear relationship of the dual - heralding event rate for @xmath9 can be confirmed in fig .
the experimental parameters were @xmath24 counts per second ( cps ) , and @xmath25 .
from above , the predicted dual - heralding event rate for @xmath26 1.8 @xmath4 is @xmath27 cps , which agrees well with the experimental value of about 90 cps .
in order to estimate the enhancement by the memories in the dual - heralding event rate , here we discuss the coherence time of the wavepacket without synchronization , from the aspect of the 0.5-bound of the wigner - function - negativity condition .
however , we note that this is a problem dependent on how the signal wavepacket is defined .
a reasonable definition of the signal wavepacket is to set the temporal origin of the signal wavepaket to the mean of the two heralding event timings : when individual heralding events happen at @xmath28 and @xmath29 , then a signal wavepacket @xmath30 has a balanced overlap with both of @xmath31 and @xmath32 . by using this definition , we calculate the average purity for various timing - mismatched events @xmath33 as a function of the maximum time difference @xmath34 .
then we find that the average purity crosses the 0.5-bound of the wigner - function - negativity condition at @xmath34 = 72 ns .
comparing this @xmath34 of 72 ns with the @xmath9 of 1.8 @xmath4 for the synchronized case , and taking into account the linear dependence on @xmath9 , the memory enhancement in the event rate can be estimated at a factor of 25 .
let us now discuss the image of the hom state in the wave basis by considering wavefunctions ( probability amplitudes ) in fig .
s2 . theoretically , vacuum _ math _ , single - photon _ math _ , and two - photon _ math _ states have zero , one , and two nodes in their schrdinger standing wave functions _ math _ for the field quadrature amplitude _ math _ , respectively ( fig .
the two - mode wave functions of separable states _ math _ , _ math _ , and _ math _ are products of the single - mode wave functions ( figs .
s2b d ) . when _ math _ and _ math _ are coherently superimposed to obtain the hom state , _ math _
, the probability amplitudes at the origin destructively or constructively interfere depending on _ math_. as a result , the superimposed wave function corresponds to a four - leaf clover for _ math _ ( fig .
s2e ) and a concentric pattern for _ math _ ( fig .
s2f ) . comparing fig .
s2e with fig .
s2d representing the input state _ math _ , we can see that the interference at the balanced beam splitter for _ math _ corresponds to a 45@xmath35 rotation of the pattern . the probability distributions _
math _ are the absolute squares of the wave functions ( figs .
s2g h ) .
[ [ experimental - quadrature - distributions - for - the-36-measurement - bases ] ] experimental quadrature distributions for the 36 measurement bases ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ in the hom experiment , the optical phases @xmath36 of the two measured quadratures @xmath37 , @xmath38 are independently set to @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 .
the quadrature distributions for the tested @xmath45 combinations are shown in fig .
these are the results for a @xmath9 of 400 ns as a typical example .
the distributions for equal relative phases , as can be seen in the plots along the diagonal of fig .
s3 , are almost the same , thus reflecting the phase - insensitivity of the input single - photon states .
the characteristic results of the output for the relative phase _ math _ of @xmath39 and _ math _ are collected in fig .
s4 , together with those of phase - insensitive input state .
[ [ quantitative - evaluation - of - the - entanglement - of - the - output - hom - state ] ] quantitative evaluation of the entanglement of the output hom state ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ here we quantitatively evaluate the output state with regards to its correlations , interference visibility , and entanglement .
the intensity cross - correlation factor , which corresponds to the depth of the hom dip , @xmath46 , is 0.24 @xmath47 0.01 .
the interference visibility , defined as @xmath48 is 0.902 @xmath47 0.005 .
this is much higher than the phase - randomized coherent light limit of 0.5 , which confirms the non - classicality of the output state . in order to verify the quantum entanglement in the two output ports
, we calculated the entanglement criterion @xcite .
the logarithmic negativity @xcite of the output state was @xmath49 , where the superscript of @xmath50 means partial transpose with respect to mode 1 . in order to exclude the contribution of undesired photon - number components to the entanglement
, we also calculated the logarithmic negativity of the output state after numerically applying local filters @xmath51 to individual modes .
the local filters do not increase the entanglement but just remove irrelevant photon - number components and transform the output state to @xmath52 . here
, @xmath53 is the filtered density operator of @xmath54 in the hilbert space spanned by @xmath55 , and @xmath56 , @xmath57 is the probability fraction of the filtered components which was experimentally 0.470 , and @xmath58 is a non - entangled state in the orthogonal hilbert space . for this filtered output state ,
the logarithmic negativity was @xmath59 .
from comparison of these two values , we can see the main contribution of the entanglement came from the superposition of @xmath60 and @xmath61 , but there is also a small discrepancy of the log - negativities which is mainly due to the higher - order photon components @xmath62 and @xmath63 of the input states .
the non - zero log - negativities of the filtered and unfiltered states confirm the entanglement of our output hom state . by using the density matrices of the input states ( fig .
s5 a , b ) , we theoretically calculated a density matrix of the output state with the ideal balanced beam splitter ( fig .
s5 e , f ) .
compared to this simulation , the density matrix of the experimental output hom state has a similar structure ( fig .
s5 c , d ) .
additional important information about the phase - space characteristics of the entangled hom state can be obtained by analyzing its wigner function .
we calculated the wigner function of the output state in order to verify the strong non - classicality of this state .
the wigner function of a two - mode state @xmath64 is defined ( @xmath65 ) in four - dimensional space as @xmath66 where @xmath67 correspond to a pair of rotated quadratures . in fig .
s6 , the wigner function of the ideal hom state and that of the experimental output state are shown , for different vertical scales . as the wigner function is very sensitive to the non - classical properties of a quantum state , its value quickly changes owing to experimental imperfections .
however , the wigner function of the output state still shows the distinctive shape of the ideal hom state : it has a positive value at the origin and negative values at four points around the origin in fig .
s6c , which come from the strongly non - classical single - photon inputs , thus confirming that the output state maintains the strong non - classicality after the photon interference . | a fundamental element of quantum information processing with photonic qubits is the nonclassical quantum interference between two photons when they bunch together via the hong - ou - mandel ( hom ) effect .
ultimately , many such pure photons must be processed in complex interferometric networks , and for this it is essential to synchronize the arrival times of the flying photons preserving their purity . here
we demonstrate for the first time the hom interference of two heralded , pure optical photons synchronized through two independent quantum memories . controlled storage times up to 1.8 @xmath0s for about 90 events per second were achieved with purities sufficiently high for a negative wigner function confirmed with homodyne measurements .
optical photons are a fundamental resource to encode flying quantum bits for quantum communication and computation .
in particular , in linear - optics quantum information processing @xcite , universal two - qubit gates rely upon nonclassical quantum interferences , where photons tend to bunch due to their bosonic nature .
the elementary manifestation for this is the so - called hong - ou - mandel ( hom ) effect @xcite : when two indistinguishable single photons _
math _ enter a balanced beam splitter , they bunch in either of the two output ports , resulting in a hom state _ math _ with some relative phase _ math_. for large - scale quantum computation , many pure single photons must be available simultaneously at the input ports of large interferometric networks , in order to apply the corresponding gate sequences at the same time on all the initial qubits .
numerous tests of the hom effect have been performed over the past few decades mainly in order to characterize single - photon sources , such as parametric down converters @xcite , trapped single neutral atoms @xcite , ions @xcite , atomic ensembles @xcite , quantum dots @xcite , and nitrogen vacancy centers in diamond @xcite .
however , the simultaneous occurrence of two single photons at a beam splitter has depended on a random coincidence between two independent statistical sources .
one possible way toward scalability is to combine statistical photon sources with quantum memories , by which a photon is stored until the other photon is available too @xcite .
however , such quantum storage must not be at the expense of the single - photon purity . only in a very recent experiment ,
optical single - photon states sufficiently pure to show a negative dip in their wigner functions @xcite were released in a controlled fashion ( quasi on demand ) from a memory system based on optical cavities @xcite or atomic ensembles @xcite . here
we report the next significant step beyond this : the controlled hom interference of two nearly pure photons that emerge from two independent quantum memories employing the cavity - storage method @xcite .
the resulting states still have single - photon purities above 0.5 , which is sufficient for a negative wigner function .
thanks to the memories , utilizing controlled storage times of up to 1.8 @xmath0s , the output hom state can be synchronized .
compared to previous works with atomic memories , the memory times of our all - optical system are of similar order @xcite , however , the purities of the synchronized photons are raised to an unprecedented , qualitatively different level .
we believe that this controlled , almost on - demand demonstration of the hom effect represents a breakthrough toward scaling up photonic quantum interference experiments , with direct applications in linear - optics quantum computation @xcite , quantum communication @xcite , and boson sampling @xcite .
another important aspect of our approach , making it distinct from all postselective schemes based on particle - like click - by - click photon detections , is the characterization of the resulting hom state from a wave - like perspective using homodyne measurements of field quadrature amplitudes . here
we will show that a characteristic pattern in the wave basis survives even after the active synchronization with quantum memories .
a fundamental feature of quantum mechanics is the wave - particle duality , and our demonstration looks at the famous hom effect from a completely wave - like angle .
this is not only of fundamental interest but also practically important for optical hybrid quantum information processing , where both continuous wave and discrete particle properties are exploited for quantum state preparation , processing , and detection @xcite . since the first demonstration @xcite
, the hom effect has been always demonstrated as a dip in the coincidence probability of photon detections at both output ports of the beam splitter .
however , the hom dip only reflects a particle - like aspect of the hom state , in which photonic particle bunching becomes manifest .
the more general , actual quantum nature of that prominent optical quantum state , such as quantum entanglement , can not be revealed by correlation measurements in a fixed particle basis .
the wave - basis image of the hom state that we present here as a counterpart to the particle - basis hom dip is a correlation pattern similar to a four - leaf clover that vanishes and reappears depending on the relative phase _ math _ @xcite .
the phase - dependent pattern is actually sufficient for fully characterizing the hom state and obtaining its density matrix @xcite .
however , the pattern is very fragile against optical losses and detection noises mostly because the homodyne detection is sensitive to vacuum fluctuations , unlike the hom dip whose shape is in principle unchanged even for large optical losses .
therefore , in order to observe the phase - sensitive clover pattern , highly pure single photons must be prepared simultaneously and detected with very low - noise homodyne detectors , which became possible only very recently @xcite .
our experimental setup is schematically shown in fig . 1a , where every one of the two single - photon sources is enclosed by a memory system ( memory-1 or memory-2 ) which is composed of two concatenated cavities @xcite .
each individual single - photon creation corresponds to an ordinary quantum optical heralding scheme , where photons are probabilistically but simultaneously produced in pairs by nonlinear optical effects and one photon serves as the herald of the other @xcite .
single - photon sources based on such nonlinear optical effects have good controllability of the wavelength unlike other on - demand - type sources .
the special interference inside the concatenated cavities ensures that the photon to be measured is released to the outside while the photon to be prepared stays inside . after heralding ,
the stored single photon is released on demand by rapidly switching the cavity resonance via an electro - optic effect @xcite , which is also different from a simple storage - loop switching scheme @xcite . in a preliminary experiment
, we tested the performance of the individual memory systems by using a highly reflective mirror as the replaceable mirror ( rm ) in fig .
1a .
for both input ports , we estimated the wavepackets of the released single photons for various fixed storage times after the heralding @xcite .
figure 1b shows the longitudinal modes of the released wavepackets in the time domain , vertically shifted depending on the corresponding storage times .
it can be confirmed that the single - photon wavepackets are correctly shifted by the memories without deformation , and also that the wavepackets from the two independent memories are almost identical .
this sameness ( indistinguishability ) of the wavepackets is critical for the hom interference effect . in the hom experiment
, we synchronized the photon sources and then obtained an output hom state .
we acquired two - mode quadrature data for 390,636 events when both single photons were heralded within 2 @xmath0s .
this large number of events was acquired within only 3 hours .
the storage time of each event was recorded together with the homodyne outcomes .
then , in order to observe the dependence on the maximum storage time _ math _
, we analyzed those events associated with a storage time between 0 and _ math_. figure 1c shows the individual input single - photon purities , calculated with the maximum - likelihood method @xcite for each _ math_. although the single - photon purities degrade for longer storage times due to a finite memory lifetime @xcite , the purities were kept above the 0.5-bound of the wigner - function - negativity condition for up to about 1.8 @xmath0s , which corresponds to about 90 events per second .
the coherence time of the wavepackets for the 0.5 criteria without synchronization is estimated at 72 ns @xcite , and thus the memory enhancement in the event rate can be calculated as a factor of 25 .
let us now discuss the image of the hom state in the wave basis , as shown in fig . 2 .
theoretically , vacuum _ math _ , single - photon _ math _ , and two - photon _ math _ states have one , two , and three peaks in their quadrature distributions , respectively , and thus the two - dimensional distributions of the separable states _ math _ and _ math _ look like those in fig .
2a and fig . 2b , respectively .
when _ math _ and _ math _ are coherently superimposed to obtain the hom state , _ math _ , the probability amplitudes at the origin destructively or constructively interfere depending on _ math _ @xcite . as a result ,
the remaining distribution patterns are the four - leaf clover for _ math _ ( fig .
2c ) and a concentric pattern for _ math _ ( fig .
2d ) .
these characteristic distribution patterns are indeed observed in our experiment by homodyne detections . in figs .
3a , b , the distributions of the output for _ math _ and _ math _ are shown , together with the individual histograms of the single - mode quadratures .
these are the results for a _ math _ of 400 ns as a typical example .
the output barely exhibits side fringes reflecting a large two - photon component ( top and right panels in figs .
3a , b ) .
the two - mode distributions of the output completely change depending on _ math_. the four - leaf clover is most pronounced at _ math _ whereas the clover totally disappears at _ math _ as expected from figs .
2c , d @xcite .
these distributions are totally different from that of the case without synchronization ( fig .
3c ) .
the results here are only particular examples , and the full results are presented in the supplementary information @xcite , together with those for the phase - independent input dual - single - photon state .
so far , we have discussed the relative phase _ math _ of the hom state _
math _ , where _ math _ is the phase - shift operator acting on the second mode . from a different viewpoint , this can be reinterpreted as a phase shift of the measured quadratures _ math _ for the fixed state _ math _ , since _
math_. in the latter interpretation , the wave - basis two - mode distributions with various measurement phases contain the complete information for estimating the quantum state @xcite . in fig .
3d , the density matrix of the output state _ math _ is shown in the number basis .
the ideal density operator of the hom state is _ math _ , and this structure also becomes apparent in the experimental output state _ math _ : the diagonal elements of _ math _ and _ math _ indicate the photon bunching effect on the _ math_-component of the input @xcite , while the presence of the off - diagonal , negative elements of _ math _ and _ math _ proves that the bunched components are quantum - mechanically superimposed rather than classically , incoherently mixed .
these off - diagonal elements are ( necessary and ) sufficient for the entanglement between the two output modes .
quantitatively @xcite , a logarithmic negativity _ math _ is obtained , while _ math _ in the ideal case .
moreover , strong nonclassicality of the output state is evident from its negative wigner function _
math_. the cross section _
math _ has negative values in a structure reflecting the four - leaf - clover pattern .
a further evaluation can be found in the supplementary information @xcite . in conclusion , we have experimentally demonstrated the famous hom interference effect in a way that is potentially scalable for large - scale quantum information processing . to achieve this ,
two nearly pure single photons enter a beam splitter almost on demand after their synchronized release from two independent optical ( cavity - based ) quantum memories .
we have also shown the wave - like aspect of the resulting hom state via homodyne detections , characterized by a phase - dependent appearance of a four - leaf clover pattern .
the quality of the states is sufficient to exhibit a negative wigner function and entanglement even after the memory storage .
the hom state interpreted as a noon state @xcite is also potentially useful in quantum metrology and sensing .
99 e. knill , r. laflamme , g. j. milburn , nature ( london ) * * 409 * * , 4652 ( 2001 ) . c. k. hong , z. y. ou , l. mandel , * 59 * , 20442046 ( 1987 )
. h. de riedmatten , i. marcikic , w. tittel , h. zbinden , n. gisin , * 67 * , 022301 ( 2003 ) . j. beugnon _ et al .
_ nature ( london ) * * 440 * * , 779782 ( 2006 ) .
p. maunz , _ et al .
_ nat .
phys . *
* 3 * * , 538541 ( 2007 ) .
t. chanelire _ et al .
_ * 98 * , 113602 ( 2007 ) .
e. b. flagg _ et al .
_ * 104 * , 137401 ( 2010 ) .
h. bernien _ et al . _
* 108 * , 043604 ( 2012 ) .
d. felinto _ et al .
_ nat .
phys . *
* 2 * * , 844848 ( 2006 ) .
z. -s .
yuan _ et al . _
* 98 * , 180503 ( 2007 ) .
a. i. lvovsky _ et al .
_ * 87 * , 050402 ( 2001 ) .
j. yoshikawa , k. makino , s. kurata , p. van loock , a. furusawa , phys .
rev .
x * * 3 * * , 041028 ( 2013 ) .
j. yoshikawa , k. makino , a. furusawa , in _ engineering the atom - photon interaction .
_ a. predojevi , m. mitchell , eds .
( springer , cham , 2015 ) , chap . 8 .
e. bimbard _ et al . _
* 112 * , 033601 ( 2014 ) .
see the supplementary information .
n. sangouard , c. simon , h. de riedmatten , n. gisin , * 83 * , 3380 ( 2011 ) . s. aaronson , a. arkhipov , in proceedings of the acm symposium on theory of computing ( acm , new york , 2011 ) , pp .
333342 .
s. takeda , t. mizuta , m. fuwa , p. van loock , a. furusawa , nature ( london ) * * 500 * * , 315318 ( 2013 ) .
y. miwa _ et al .
_ * 113 * , 013601 ( 2014 ) .
y. hashimoto , k. makino , j. yoshikawa , h. ohdan , p. van loock , a. furusawa , in _ frontiers in optics 2014 osa technical digest ( online ) _
paper fw4c.3 ( 2014 ) .
j. etesse , m. bouillard , b. kanseri , r. tualle - brouri , * 114 * , 193602 ( 2015 ) .
a. i. lvovsky , m. g. raymer , * 81 * , 299332 ( 2009 )
. t. b. pittman , j. d. franson , * 66 * , 062302 ( 2002 ) .
o. morin , c. fabre , j. laurat , * 111 * , 213602 ( 2013 ) .
m. b. plenio , * 95 * , 090503 ( 2005 ) .
t. nagata , r. okamoto , j. l. obrien , k. sasaki , s. takeuchi , science * * 316 * * , 726729 ( 2007 ) .
m. r. ray , s. j. van enk , * 83 * , 042318 ( 2011 ) .
[ [ acknowledgments ] ] acknowledgments : + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this work was partly supported by gia , pdis , apsa of the mext of japan , refost of japan , the scope program of the mic of japan . p.v.l . was supported in germany by qcom ( bmbf ) and hipercom ( era - net chist - era ) .
k.m . acknowledges support from jsps .
* supplementary information for + synchronization of optical photons for quantum information processing * + + + + + + s addtoresettablesection makecaption#1#2 tempboxa*#1 . *
# 2 tempboxa > # 2 minipagefalse |
massive stars play a fundamental role in driving the energy flow and material cycles that influence the physical and chemical evolution of galaxies . despite receiving much attention
, their formation process remains enigmatic .
observationally , the large distances to the nearest examples and the clustered mode of formation make it difficult to isolate individual protostars for study .
it is still not certain , for instance , whether massive stars form via accretion ( similar to low mass stars ) or through mergers of intermediate mass stars .
advances in instrumentation , have enabled ( sub ) arcsecond resolution imaging at wavelengths less affected by the large column densities of material that obscure the regions at shorter wavelengths .
recent observations exploiting these capabilities have uncovered the environment surrounding _ individual _ massive protostellar systems . from analysis of @xmath42.3 @xmath0 m co bandhead emission ,
@xcite have inferred keplerian disks very closely surrounding ( within a few au ) four massive young stellar objects , while interferometric , mm - continuum observations , find the mass - function of protostellar dust clumps lies close to a salpeter value down to clump radii of 2000au @xcite .
these high resolution observations point toward an accretion formation scenario for massive stars .
further discrimination between the two competing models is possible by examining the properties , in particular the young stellar populations , of hot molecular cores .
the mid - infrared ( mir ) window ( 7 - 25 @xmath0 m ) offers a powerful view of these regions .
the large column densities of material process the stellar light to infrared wavelengths , and diffraction limited observations are readily obtained .
recent observations indicate that class ii methanol masers exclusively trace regions of massive star formation @xcite and are generally either not associated or offset from uchii regions @xcite .
@xcite ( hereafter m05 ) have carried out multi - wavelength ( mm to mir ) observations toward five star forming complexes traced by methanol maser emission to determine their large scale properties .
they found that maser sites with weak ( @xmath510mjy ) radio continuum flux are associated with massive ( @xmath650m@xmath7 ) , luminous ( @xmath610@xmath8l@xmath7 ) and deeply embedded ( a@xmath940 mag ) cores characterising protoclusters of young massive ( proto)stars in an earlier evolutionary stage than uchii regions .
the spatial resolution of the observations ( @xmath68@xmath2 ) was , however , too low to resolve the sources inside the clumps .
details of the regions from observations in the literature are described in m05 .
we have since observed three of the m05 regions at high spatial resolution to uncover the embedded sources inside the cores at mir wavelengths .
the data were obtained with michelle . ] on the 8-m , gemini north telescope in queue mode , on the 18@xmath10 , 22@xmath11 and 30@xmath10 of march 2003 .
each pointing centre was imaged with four n band silicate filters ( centred on 7.9 , 8.8 , 11.6 and 12.5 @xmath0 m ) and the qa filter ( centred on 18.5 @xmath0 m ) with 300 seconds on - source integration time .
g173.49 and g188.95 were observed twice on separate nights and g192.60 observed once .
the n and q band observations were scheduled separately due to the more stringent weather requirements at q band .
the standard chop - nod technique was used with a chop throw of 15@xmath2 and chop direction selected from msx images of the region , to minimise off - field contamination .
the spatial resolution calculated from standard star observations was @xmath4 0.36@xmath2 at 10 @xmath0 m and @xmath4 0.57@xmath2 at 18.5 @xmath0 m .
the 32@xmath2x24@xmath2 field of view fully covered the dust emission observed by m05 in each region .
particular care was taken to determine the telescope pointing position but absolute positions were determined by comparing the mir data to sensitive , high resolution , cm continuum , vla images of the 3 regions ( minier et al . in prep ) .
similar spatial distribution and morphology of the multiple components allowed good registration between the images .
the astrometric uncertainty in the vla images is @xmath41@xmath2 .
flux calibration was performed using standard stars within 0.3 airmass of the science targets .
there was no overall trend in the calibration factor as a result of changes in airmass throughout the observations .
the standard deviation in the flux of standards throughout the observations was found to be 7.4 , 3.1 , 4.4 , 2.4 and 9% for the four n - band and 18.5 @xmath0 m filters respectively . the statistical error in the photometry
was dominated by fluctuations in the sky background .
upper flux limits were calculated from the standard deviation of the sky background for each filter and a 3@xmath12 upper detection limit is used in table 1 .
similarly , a 3@xmath12 error value is quoted for the fluxes in table 1 ( typical values for the n and q band filters were 0.005 and 0.03 jy respectively ) .
the flux densities for the standard stars were taken from values derived on the gemini south instrument , t - recs which shares a common filter set with michelle .
regions confused with many bright sources were deconvolved using the lucy - richardson algorithm with 20 iterations .
this was necessary to resolve source structure and extract individual source fluxes .
the instrumental psf was obtained for each filter using a bright , non - saturated standard star .
the results were reliable and repeatable near the brighter sources when using different stars for the psf and observations of the objects taken over different nights .
as a further check , the standard stars were used to deconvolve other standards and reproduced point sources down to 1% of the peak value after 20 iterations , so only sources greater than 3% of the peak value were included in the final images .
the resulting deconvolutions are shown in fig 1 .
[ tab_sources ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] as the large scale clump dust and gas morphology appears simple and centrally peaked ( see m05 ) , we make the reasonable assumption that the protocluster centres coincide with the central peak of dust emission .
the spatial distribution of the point sources within the protocluster is similar between the clumps with close point sources toward the cluster centre .
the methanol masers are found closest to the brightest mir point source ( within the assumed 1@xmath2 pointing error from image registration ) .
these sources have temperatures sufficient to evaporate methanol ice from the dust grains into the gas phase ( @xmath690k ) as well as sufficient luminosity of ir photons to pump the masing transition
conditions models suggest are required for such emission @xcite .
it is known that more massive stars favour cluster centres ( e.g. @xcite ) , but it is unclear whether they form there or migrate in from outside .
we have used the simple - harmonic model of ballistic motion developed by @xcite to consider the motion of sources within the cores . using the measured column density and radius from m05 ( listed in table 2 ) ,
the time required for migration from the edge to the centre is @xmath4 @xmath13 years .
this is comparable to the predicted hmc lifetime of 10@xmath14 years @xcite so we can not rule out the possibility of migration within the clumps .
any sources having migrated to the centre in this way would have acquired a velocity of @xmath4 2 kms@xmath15 with respect to the clump .
massive stars in clusters are observed to have a high companion star fraction @xcite . in the m16 cluster ,
@xcite observed massive stars ( earlier than b3 ) with visual companions separated by 1000 - 3000au .
if multiple systems are bound from birth , it is likely some of the sources we have observed will belong to multiple systems , even though the companions may lie below the detection limit .
however , all three regions show two or more point sources at close angular separation ( see insets of figure 1 ) corresponding to linear separations of 1700 to 6000au . we can not determine whether these stars are physically bound or simply close due to projection effects but we can calculate the instrumental sensitivity required to confirm or deny the association .
assuming they are physically bound in a keplerian orbit , the maximum proper motions ( projection angle = 0@xmath16 ) of @xmath4 0.1 mas / year are too small to be detected on short temporal baselines . the maximum velocity difference ( projection angle = 90@xmath16 )
@xmath4 2 kms@xmath15 is achievable by high spectral resolution observations of any line features .
the mass distribution of stars is generally well described as a power law through the initial mass function ( imf ) .
given the mass of gas available to form stars , we may estimate the likelihood that a cluster will end up with the most massive stars that are observed in it .
the fraction of gas that forms stars is given by the star formation efficiency ( sfe ) and is observationally found to be less than 50% in any cloud and to be @xmath17 33% for nearby embedded clusters @xcite . for a cluster whose total stellar mass is 120 ( 50 , 320 ) m@xmath7 ( equivalent to the gas mass determined for the three cores ) , @xcite estimate that the mean maximum mass that a star may have in it is 10 ( 5 , 20 ) m@xmath7 .
this is comparable to the largest observed mass in two out of the three cases .
however , we also observed several other stars in each cluster so can estimate the probability of generating stars of equal or greater mass than the remaining mass distribution .
we did this by running monte - carlo simulations to populate 10@xmath14 clusters using @xcite , @xcite and @xcite imfs until the available gas mass was exhausted .
we only considered clusters which contained a star of at least equal mass to the most massive observed .
the simulations show that even using the salpeter form of the imf ( most biased toward forming high - mass stars ) and allowing 50% of the gas to form stars , it is difficult to generate the observed mass distributions ( probabilities @xmath18 10@xmath19 , 10@xmath20 , 10@xmath15 for the three cores respectively ) . by itself , this may not be significant for a single cluster .
however , since the probability is low for all three sources studied , it is unlikely that the mass distribution of the most massive stars can be produced by sampling a standard form of the imf from the reservoir of gas available for star formation .
this conclusion would not hold if there was a substantial stellar mass already in the cluster that remains unseen , or if much of the original gas mass had already been dispersed from the core due to star formation .
the former requires a sfe close to unity and given the relatively quiescent state of the cores , the latter seems unlikely .
a larger sample of young , massive protoclusters is required to draw general conclusions . however , in all three hot molecular cores traced by methanol maser emission we have found : * multiple , mir sources which can be separated into three morphological types : unresolved point sources ( p ) ; unresolved point source with weak surrounding extended emission ( pe ) and extended sources ( e ) . * the point sources lie at close angular separations .
future high spatial and spectral resolution observations may be able to determine whether or not they are physically bound . *
the methanol masers are found closest to the brightest mir point source ( within the assumed 1@xmath2 pointing accuracy ) .
* cooler , extended sources dominate the luminosity . *
the time scale for a source at the core edge to migrate to the centre is comparable to the hot molecular core lifetime , so it is not possible to rule out large protostellar motions within the core .
* from the derived gas mass of the core and mass estimates for the sources , monte carlo simulations show that it is difficult to generate the observed distributions for the most massive cluster members from the gas in the core using a standard form of the imf .
this conclusion would not hold , however , if most of the original gas has already formed stars , or has been dispersed such that the original core mass is much greater than now observed .
s.l . would like to thank alistair glass , scott fisher , tony wong and melvin hoare for helpful discussion of the data and scientific input .
we thank the anonymous referee for the thorough response and insightful comments .
this work was made possible by funding from the australian research council and unsw .
the gemini observatory is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under a cooperative agreement with the nsf on behalf of the gemini partnership : nsf ( usa ) , pparc ( uk ) , nrc ( canada ) , conicyt ( chile ) , arc ( australia ) , cnpq ( brazil ) and conicet ( argentina ) .
b. t. , 1989 , interstellar extinction in the infrared .
infrared spectroscopy in astronomy , proceedings of the 22nd eslab symposium held in salamanca , spain , 7 - 9 december , 1988 . edited by b.h . kaldeich .
esa sp-290 .
european space agency , 1989 . ,
p.93 , pp 93+ g. , bouvier j. , eislffel j. , simon t. , 2001 , in asp conf .
ser . 243 : from darkness to light : origin and evolution of young stellar clusters statistical properties of visual binaries as tracers of the formation and early evolution of young stellar clusters . | we present high resolution , mid - infrared images toward three hot molecular cores signposted by methanol maser emission ; g173.49 + 2.42 ( s231 , s233ir ) , g188.95 + 0.89 ( s252 , afgl-5180 ) and g192.60 - 0.05 ( s255ir ) . each of the cores was targeted with michelle on gemini north using 5 filters from 7.9 to 18.5 @xmath0 m .
we find each contains both large regions of extended emission and multiple , luminous point sources which , from their extremely red colours ( @xmath1 ) , appear to be embedded young stellar objects .
the closest angular separations of the point sources in the three regions are 0.79 , 1.00 and 3.33@xmath2 corresponding to linear separations of 1,700 , 1,800 and 6,000au respectively .
the methanol maser emission is found closest to the brightest mir point source ( within the assumed 1@xmath2 pointing accuracy ) .
mass and luminosity estimates for the sources range from 3 - 22 m@xmath3 and 50 - 40,000 l@xmath3 . assuming the mir sources are embedded objects and
the observed gas mass provides the bulk of the reservoir from which the stars formed , it is difficult to generate the observed distributions for the most massive cluster members from the gas in the cores using a standard form of the imf .
masers stars : formation techniques : high angular resolution stars : early type stars : mass function infrared : stars . |
even though the mn containing oxides with the perovskite - like structure have been studied for more than a half century,@xcite various phase transitions occurring on doping in these materials are not fully understood .
in particular , lamno@xmath0 exhibit rich and interesting physical properties because of the strong interplay between lattice distortions , transport properties and magnetic ordering . this compound also have a very rich phase diagram depending on the doping concentration , temperature and pressure ; being either antiferromagnetic ( af ) insulator , ferromagnetic ( f ) metal or charge ordered ( co ) insulator.@xcite the magnetic behavior of the lamno@xmath0 perovskite is particularly interesting , because the jahn - teller ( jt ) distortion is accompanied by the so - called a - type antiferromagnetic ( a - af ) spin ( moment ) and c - type orbital ordering ( oo ) , i.e , alternative occupation of @xmath5 and @xmath6 in the @xmath1 plane and same type of orbital occupation perpendicular to the @xmath1 plane.@xcite recently manganites have also been subjected to strong interest due to their exhibition of negative colossal magnetoresistance ( cmr ) effects.@xcite in particular the perovskite - oxide system la@xmath7ae@xmath8mno@xmath0 , where @xmath9 is a divalent alkali element such as ca or sr , have attracted much attention primarily due to the discovery of a negative cmr effect around the ferromagnetic transition temperature @xmath10 , which is located near room temperature.@xcite the mutual coupling among the charge , spin , orbital and lattice degrees of freedom in perovskite - type manganites creates versatile intriguing phenomena such as cmr,@xcite field - melting of the co and/or oo state(s ) accompanying a huge change in resistivity,@xcite field - induced structural transitions even near room temperature,@xcite field control of inter - grain or inter - plane tunneling of highly spin - polarized carriers,@xcite etc .
several mechanisms have been proposed for cmr , such as double exchange,@xcite dynamical jt effect,@xcite antiferromagnetic fluctuation,@xcite etc . , but no consensus has been attained so far about the importance of those mechanisms . since the spin , charge , orbital and structural ordering phenomena may affect cmr at least indirectly it is important to obtain a full understanding of the mechanism stabilizing the observed a - af order in the undoped insulating mother compound lamno@xmath0 . it has been suggested that an understanding of hole - doped lamno@xmath0 must include , in addition to the double - exchange mechanism,@xcite strong electron correlations,@xcite a strong electron - phonon interaction@xcite and cooperative jt distortions associated with mn@xmath11 .
several theoretical studies have been made on this material using the mean - field approximation@xcite , numerical diagonalization,@xcite gutzwiller technique,@xcite slave - fermion theory,@xcite , dynamical mean - field theory@xcite , perturbation theory@xcite and quantum monte - carlo technique.@xcite nevertheless it is still controversial as to what is the driving mechanism of the experimentally established properties , particularly the strongly incoherent charge dynamics , and what the realistic parameters of theoretical models are .
by calculating and comparing various experimentally observed quantities one can get an idea about the role of electron correlations and other influences on the cmr effect in these materials .
hence , theoretical investigations of ground state and excited state properties are important to understand the exotic physical properties of these materials . the importance of spin and lattice degrees of freedom on the metal - insulator transition in lamno@xmath0 is studied extensively.@xcite popovic and satpathy@xcite showed how the cooperative jt coupling between the individual mno@xmath12 centers in the crystal leads to simultaneous ordering of the distorted octahedron and the electronic orbitals .
it is now accepted that oo and magnetic ordering ( mo ) are closely correlated and that the anisotropy in the magnetic coupling originates from oo.@xcite so in order to understand the origin of oo , it is important to study the energetics of different spin - ordered states .
ahn and millis@xcite calculated the optical conductivity of lamno@xmath0 using a tight - binding parameterization of the band structure .
they noted a troubling discrepancy with lsda band - theory calculations@xcite of the optical conductivity and concluded with the need for further work to find the origin of the difference .
hence , accurate calculations of optical properties is expected to give more insight into the origin of the discrepancy .
an appreciable faraday rotation has been observed in hole - doped lamno@xmath0 thin films@xcite and hence it has been suggested that these ferromagnetic films may be used to image vortices in high - temperature superconductors .
further , due to the half - metallic behavior in the f phase of lamno@xmath0 one can expect a large magneto - optical effect .
for this reason , we have calculated the optical and magneto - optical properties of this material .
the simultaneous presence of strong electron - electron interactions within the transition - metal 3@xmath2 manifold and a sizable hopping interaction between transition metal ( @xmath13 = ti@xmath14cu ) 3@xmath2 and o 2@xmath15 states are primarily responsible for the wide range of properties exhibited by transition - metal oxides . often the presence of a strong intraatomic coulomb interaction makes a single - particle description of such systems inadequate . due to this deficiency , the density - functional calculations often fail@xcite to predict the insulating behavior of lamno@xmath0 . to correct this deficiency of the local spin - density approximation ( lsda ) to give the right insulating properties of the perovskites ,
lsda+@xmath16 theory@xcite is applied , where @xmath16 is the intrasite coulomb repulsion . from experimental and theoretical studies
it has been believed that the electron correlations in the la@xmath13o@xmath0 ( @xmath13 = ti@xmath14cu ) series are very important and should be considered more rigorously beyond lsda .
hence , lda+@xmath16 is applied@xcite to obtain magnetic moments and fundamental gap in good agreement with experiment .
the calculations for la@xmath13o@xmath0 by solovyev _
@xcite showed that the correlation correction was significant for ti , v , co but less important for mn .
however , in this study the calculated intensity of the optical conductivity were found to be much smaller than the experimental results in the whole energy range .
hu _ et al._@xcite reported that to get the correct experimental ground state for lamno@xmath0 , it is necessary to take jt distortion , electron - electron correlation and af ordering simultaneously into consideration . from the observation of large on - site coulomb @xmath16 and exchange @xmath17 ,
obtained from `` constrained lda calculations '' , satpathy _
et al._@xcite indicated the importance of correlation effects in lamno@xmath0 . held and vollhardt,@xcite using the dynamical mean - field theory , emphasize the importance of electronic correlations from the local coulomb repulsion for understanding the properties of manganites .
et al._@xcite pointed out that the electron correlations remain strong even in the metallic state of doped manganites .
photoemission studies on doped manganites gave an electron - electron correlation effect with @xmath16 = 7.5ev for the coulomb repulsion.@xcite in contrast to the above observations , it has been shown that many aspects of the ground state as well as single - electron excited state properties of lamno@xmath0 and related compounds can be described satisfactorily in terms of lsda energy bands.@xcite density functional calculations also show strong couplings between lattice distortions , magnetic order , and electronic properties of lamno@xmath0 .
in particular , it is found that without lattice distortions lamno@xmath0 would have a f metallic ground state , and even if forced to be a - af , it would still be metallic.@xcite further , sarma _ et al._@xcite indicated that the electron - electron correlation is unimportant due to a relatively large hopping parameter @xmath18 and a large screening effect . the lsda studies@xcite show that substantially hybridized bands derived from majority - spin mn @xmath4 and o @xmath15 states dominate the electronic structure near the fermi energy ( @xmath19 ) .
x - ray absorption spectroscopy ( xas ) data show that several apparent peaks exist up to 5ev above @xmath19 , but some disputes still remain about the origins of these conduction - band peaks.@xcite the reported positions of the @xmath20 bands in lamno@xmath0 differ.@xcite the above mentioned studies indicate that it is important to study the significance of correlation effects in lamno@xmath0 .
some of the features lacking in most of the theoretical studies on lamno@xmath0 originate from the fact that they have often resulted from the use of the atomic - sphere approximation ( asa ) , i.e. the calculations have not included the nonspherical part of the potential and also used a minimal basis set .
further the cubic perovskite structure is frequently assumed@xcite and the significant structural distortions are not taken into account . apart from these , owing to the presence of magnetic ordering , relativistic effects such as spin - orbit coupling may be of significance in this material , which was not been included in earlier studies .
moreover , it is shown that instead of using the uniform electron gas limit for exchange and correlations ( corresponding to lsda ) one can improve the outcome by including the inhomogeneity effects through the generalized - gradient approximation ( gga).@xcite to overcome the above mentioned deficiencies we have used a generalized - gradient - corrected , relativistic full - potential method with the experimentally observed orthorhombic distorted perovskite structure as the input in the present calculation .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . the structural aspects and the computational details about the calculations of the electronic structure , energetics of different magnetic phases , optical properties , magneto - optical properties , xps and xanes features
are given in sec.[sec : details ] .
in sec.[sec : resdis ] we give the orbital , angular momentum and site - projected density of states ( dos ) for lamno@xmath0 in the ground state , the spin - projected dos for various magnetic state .
the calculated band structure for the a - af and f phases of the distorted orthorhombic structure are given .
the role of the structural distortion on the electronic structure , optical and magnetic properties is analyzed .
calculated magnetic properties are compared with available experimental and theoretical studies .
the origin of excited state properties such as xps , bis , xanes , optical properties and magneto - optical properties is analyzed through the electronic structure and compared with available experimental spectra . finally in sec.[sec
: con ] we have summarized the important findings of the present study .
lamno@xmath0 is stabilizes in the orthorhombic gdfeo@xmath0-type structure@xcite ( comprising four formula units ; space group @xmath21 ) as shown in fig.[fig : str ] .
it can be viewed as a highly distorted cubic perovskite structure with a quadrupled unit cell ( @xmath22 , @xmath22 , 2@xmath23 where @xmath23 is the lattice parameter of the cubic perovskite structure .
the structural parameters used in the calculations are taken from a 4.2k neutron diffraction study@xcite with @xmath24 = 5.742 , @xmath25 = 7.668 and @xmath26 = 5.532 and atom positions : la in 4c ( 0.549 0.25 0.01 ) , mn in 4a ( 0 0 0 ) , o(1 ) in 4c ( @xmath140.014 0.25 @xmath140.07 ) and o(2 ) in 8d ( 0.309 0.039 0.244 ) .
the electronic configuration of mn@xmath11 in lamno@xmath0 is postulated as @xmath27 and hence , it is a typical jt system .
basically , two different types of distortions are included in the structure shown in fig.[fig : str ] .
one is a tilting of the mno@xmath12 octahedra around the cubic [ 110 ] axis as in gdfeo@xmath0 so that the mn - o - mn angle changes from 180@xmath28 to @xmath29 160@xmath30 which is not directly related with the jt effect , but is attributed to the relative sizes of the components , say , expressed in terms of the tolerance factor @xmath31 , where @xmath32 , @xmath33 and r@xmath34 are the ionic radii for la , mn and o respectively giving @xmath35 = 0.947 for lamno@xmath0 .
the rotation of the mno@xmath12 octahedra facilitates a more efficient space filling .
the second type of crystal distortion in lamno@xmath0 is the deformation of the mno@xmath12 octahedra caused by the jt effect , viz .
originating from orbital degeneracy .
this may be looked upon as a cooperative shifting of the oxygens within the @xmath1 plane away from one of its two nearest neighboring mn atoms towards the others , thus creating long and short mn - o bond lengths ( modified from 1.97 for cubic case to 1.91,1.96 and 2.18 for the orthorhombic variant ) perpendicularly arranged with respect to the mn atoms .
the long bonds can be regarded as rotated 90@xmath28 within @xmath1 on going from one mn to the neighboring mn.@xcite the structural optimization@xcite wrongly predicts that the ground state of lamno@xmath0 is close to that of cubic perovskite with the f state lower in energy than the experimentally observed af state .
hence it is important to study the relative stability between the orthorhombic and cubic phases for different magnetic arrangements .
consequently we have made calculations both for the orthorhombic ( @xmath21 ) as well as the ideal cubic perovskite variants .
for the calculations of the undistorted cubic variant we have used the experimental equilibrium volume for the orthorhombic structure .
when lamno@xmath0 is in the af state there are three possible magnetic arrangements according to interplane and intraplane couplings within ( 001 ) plane .
( i ) with interplane af coupling and intraplane f coupling the a - af structure arises .
( ii ) the opposite structure of a - af , where the interplane coupling is f , but the intraplane coupling is af is called c - af structure . in the c - type cell
all atoms have two f and four af nearest neighbors whereas the reverse is true for a - type af .
( iii ) if both the inter- and intraplane couplings are af the g - af structure should arise.@xcite in the g - type af lattice , each mn atom is surrounded by six mn neighbors whose spins are antiparallel to the chosen central atom . among the several possible magnetic orderings ,
the experimental studies show that for lamno@xmath0 the a - af ordering is the ground state with a nel temperature of 140k . in the cubic case
we have made calculations for the af structures in the following way .
the a - af structure contains two formula units , and is a tetragonal lattice with @xmath24 = @xmath25 = @xmath23 and @xmath26 = 2@xmath23 .
the c - af structure is also tetragonal with @xmath24 = @xmath25 = @xmath36 and @xmath26 = a@xmath37 .
finally , the g - af structure is a face centered cubic structure with @xmath24 = @xmath25 = @xmath26 = 2@xmath38 with eight formula units , where two nonequivalent 3@xmath2 metals with spins up and down replace na and cl in an nacl configuration .
this magnetic structure can be viewed as consisting of two interpenetrating face - centered lattices with opposite spin orientation .
these investigations are based on _ ab initio _ electronic structure calculations derived from spin - polarized density - functional theory ( dft ) . for the xanes , orbital - projected dos and the screened plasma frequency calculations we have applied the full - potential linearized - augmented plane wave ( fplapw ) method@xcite in a scalar - relativistic version , i.e. without spin - orbit ( so ) coupling . in the calculation we have used the atomic sphere radii ( @xmath39 ) of 2.2 , 2.0 and 1.5 a.u . for la , mn and o , respectively . since the spin densities are well confined within a radius of about 1.5 a.u .
, the resulting magnetic moments do not depend strongly on the variation of the atomic sphere radii .
the charge density and the potentials are expanded into lattice harmonics up to @xmath40 = 6 inside the spheres and into a fourier series in the interstitial region .
the initial basis set included 4@xmath41 , 4@xmath15 , 3@xmath2 functions and 3@xmath41 , 3@xmath15 semicore functions at the mn site , 6@xmath41 , 6@xmath15 , 5@xmath2 valence and 5@xmath41 , 5@xmath15 semicore functions for the la site and 2@xmath41 , 2@xmath15 and 3@xmath2 functions for the o site .
this set of basis functions was supplemented with local orbitals for additional flexibility in representing the semicore states and for relaxing the linearization errors generally . due to the linearization errors dos
are reliable to about 1@xmath142ry above the fermi level .
so , after selfconsistency was achieved for this basis set we included a few high - energy local orbitals ; 6@xmath2- , 4@xmath42-like function for la , 5@xmath41- , 5@xmath15-like functions for mn and 3@xmath15-like functions for o atoms .
the effects of exchange and correlation are treated within the generalized - gradient - corrected local spin - density approximation using the parameterization scheme of perdew _
et al._@xcite to ensure convergence for the brillouin zone ( bz ) integration 243*k * points in the irreducible wedge of first bz were used .
self - consistency was achieved by demanding the convergence of the total energy to be smaller than 10@xmath43ry / cell .
this corresponds to a convergence of the charge below 10@xmath44 electrons / atom .
the full - potential lmto calculations@xcite presented in this paper are all electron , and no shape approximation to the charge density or potential has been used .
the base geometry in this computational method consists of a muffin - tin part and an interstitial part .
the basis set is comprised of augmented linear muffin - tin orbitals.@xcite inside the muffin - tin spheres the basis functions , charge density and potential are expanded in symmetry - adapted spherical harmonic functions together with a radial function and a fourier series in the interstitial . in the present calculations the spherical - harmonic expansion of the charge density , potential and basis functions were carried out up to @xmath40 = 6 .
the tails of the basis functions outside their parent spheres are linear combinations of hankel or neumann functions depending on the sign of the kinetic energy of the basis function in the interstitial region . for the core charge density
, the dirac equation is solved self - consistently , i.e. no frozen core approximation is used .
the calculations are based on the generalized - gradient - corrected - density - functional theory as proposed by perdew _
et al._@xcite the so term is included directly in the hamiltonian matrix elements for the part inside the muffin - tin spheres , thus doubling the size of the secular matrix for a spin - polarized calculation .
even though the la @xmath45 states are well above @xmath19 their contribution to the magnetic and structural properties are very important.@xcite
so we have included these orbitals in all our calculations .
moreover , the present calculations make use of a so - called multibasis , to ensure a well converged wave function .
this means that we use different hankel or neuman functions each attaching to its own radial function .
we thus have two @xmath46 , two @xmath47 , two 6@xmath15 , two 5@xmath2 and two 4@xmath42 orbitals for la , two @xmath48 , two @xmath47 and three 3@xmath2 orbitals for mn , two @xmath49 , three @xmath50 and two @xmath51 orbitals for o in our expansion of the wave function . in the method used here , bases corresponding to multiple principal quantum numbers are contained within a single , fully hybridizing basis set .
the direction of the moment is chosen to be ( 001 ) .
the calculations were performed for the cubic perovskite structure as well as the orthorhombic gdfeo@xmath0-type structure in nonmagnetic ( p ) , f , a - af , c - af and g - af states .
the * k*-space integration was performed using the special point method with 284 * k * points in the irreducible part of first bz for the orthorhombic structure and the same density of * k * points were used for the cubic structure in the actual cell as well as the supercell .
all calculations were performed using the experimental structural parameters mentioned in sec.[ssec : str ] for both the nonmagnetic and spin - polarized cases . using the self - consistent potentials obtained from our calculations ,
the imaginary part of the optical dielectric tensor and the band structure of lamno@xmath0 were calculated for the a - af and f cases .
the density of states were calculated for the p , f , a - af , c - af and g - af phases in the cubic as well as orthorhombic structure using the linear tetrahedron technique .
once energies @xmath52 and functions @xmath53 for the @xmath54 bands are obtained self consistently , the interband contribution to the imaginary part of the dielectric functions @xmath55(@xmath56 ) can be calculated by summing transitions from occupied to unoccupied states ( with fixed * k * vector ) over bz , weighted with the appropriate matrix element for the probability of the transition . to be specific , the components of @xmath55(@xmath56 ) are given by @xmath57 here ( @xmath58,@xmath59,@xmath60 ) = * p * is the momentum operator and @xmath61 is the fermi distribution .
the evaluation of the matrix elements in eq .
( [ e2 ] ) is done over the muffin - tin and interstitial regions separately .
further details about the evaluation of matrix elements are given elsewhere.@xcite due to the orthorhombic structure of lamno@xmath0 the dielectric function is a tensor . by an appropriate choice of the principal axes we can diagonalize it and restrict our considerations to the diagonal matrix elements .
we have calculated the three components @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 of the dielectric constants corresponding to the electric field parallel to the crystallographic axes @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 , respectively . the real part of the components of the dielectric tensor @xmath65(@xmath56 )
is then calculated using the kramer - kronig transformation .
the knowledge of both the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric tensor allows the calculation of important optical constants . in this paper
, we present the reflectivity @xmath66 ) , the absorption coefficient @xmath67 ) , the electron energy loss spectrum @xmath68 ) , as well as the refractive index @xmath54 and the extinction coefficient @xmath69 .
the calculations yield unbroadened functions . to reproduce the experimental conditions more correctly ,
it is necessary to broaden the calculated spectra .
the exact form of the broadening function is unknown , although comparison with measurements suggests that the broadening usually increases with increasing excitation energy .
also the instrumental resolution smears out many fine features . to simulate these effects
the lifetime broadening was simulated by convoluting the absorptive part of the dielectric function with a lorentzian , whose full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) is equal to @xmath70ev .
the experimental resolution was simulated by broadening the final spectra with a gaussian , where fwhm is equal to 0.02 ev .
the magneto - optic effect can be described by the off - diagonal elements of the dielectric tensor which originate from optical transitions with a different frequency dependence of right and left circularly polarized light because of so splitting of the states involved . for the polar geometry , the kerr - rotation ( @xmath71 ) and ellipticity ( @xmath72 ) are related to the optical conductivity through the following relation : @xmath73 where @xmath74 in terms of conductivities are @xmath75 for small kerr - angles , eq . ( [ eq : kerr1 ] ) can be simplified to@xcite @xmath76 the magnetic circular birefringence , also called the faraday rotation @xmath77 , describes the rotation of the polarization plane of linearly polarized light on transmission through matter magnetized in the direction of the light propagation .
similarly , the faraday ellipticity @xmath78 , which is also known as the magnetic circular dichroism , is proportional to the difference of the absorption for right- and left - handed circularly polarized light.@xcite thus , these quantities are simply given by@xcite @xmath79 where @xmath26 is the velocity of light in vacuum , and @xmath2 is the thickness of the thin film . within the so - called single - scatterer final - state approximation@xcite ( free propagation of the photoelectrons through the crystal , loss of *
k*-dependent information and neglect of surface effects ) the photocurrent is a sum of local ( atomic like ) , partial ( @xmath80-like ) dos weighted by cross sections ( transition probabilities ) . as the theoretical framework of the xps intensity calculations
is given earlier,@xcite only a brief description of the main points is outlined here . for high incident energies of xps
( @xmath29 1.5kev ) the low - energy electron - diffraction function@xcite can be simplified and the fully relativistic angle - integrated intensity @xmath81 can be written as @xmath82 @xmath83 where @xmath56 denotes the energy of the incident photons .
this expression has been cast into a fermi golden - rule form , where @xmath84 are the partial dos functions for the @xmath85 channel at the @xmath86 site , and are obtained from full - potential lmto calculation .
the partial , angular momentum - dependent cross sections @xmath87 of the species @xmath88 can be obtained from @xmath89^{2}\ ] ] where @xmath90 in eq.[eqn : sigma ] the radial functions @xmath91 and @xmath92 differ conceptually only by different single - site scattering normalizations .
the radial gradients @xmath93 refer to the @xmath88-th scattering potential .
the wigner 3j - symbols @xmath94 automatically take care of the dipole selection rules .
the relativistic cross sections @xmath95 are calculated using the muffin - tin part of the potential over the energy range @xmath96 of the dos functions for the fixed incident photon energy @xmath56 .
this expression has been evaluated for lamno@xmath0 from the potentials and dos functions by a fully relativistic full - potential lmto self - consistent calculation . because the cross sections ( matrix elements ) are energy dependent , the theoretically predicted spectra will depend on the energy chosen for the calculation . to be consistent with the reported xps data
, we have made all calculations with the fixed incident photon energy @xmath56 = 1253.6ev ( mg@xmath97 line ) used in the experimental study .
the finite lifetime of the photoholes was taken into account approximately by convoluting the spectra using a lorentzian with a energy - dependent half - width .
the fwhm of this lorentzian is zero at @xmath19 and increases linearly with the binding energy , as 0.2(@xmath98 ) .
in addition to the lorentzian life - time broadening , the spectra were broadened with a gaussian of halfwidth 0.8ev to account for spectrometer resolution .
the procedure we adapt to calculate xps and bis spectra is as follows .
first , we take the partial dos functions ( @xmath99 for xps and @xmath100 for bis ) from a full - potential lmto calculations .
we multiply these by the calculated @xmath80 dependent cross - sections for all band energies and sum them to get a total spectral - like function . next , to get a good fit to the data we broaden this with an energy - dependent lorentzian function to simulate what we call inherent life - time effects due to the coupling of the excited outgoing electron from the crystal .
this broadening is zero at @xmath19 and goes as the square of the energy below @xmath19 .
then we fit the leading edge to the experimental data with a gaussian broadening to simulate the instrument resolution .
this broadening is same for all states .
finally we add a background function to get the experimental profile .
while the calculations were performed at the one - electron level , we believe this procedure should capture the essence of the photoemission process and lead to a meaningful comparison between calculated and observed spectra .
the theoretical x - ray absorption spectra for lamno@xmath0 were computed within the dipole approximation from the flapw@xcite partial dos along the lines described by neckel _
et al._@xcite the intensity @xmath101 arising from transitions from initial vb states ( energy @xmath96 and and angular momentum @xmath80 ) to a final core state ( @xmath102,@xmath103 ) is given by @xmath104 where the matrix elements are given by @xmath105^{2 } } { \int_{0}^{r_{\tau}}p_{\ell^{\tau}}(r , e)^{2}dr}\ ] ] @xmath106 represent principal and angular momentum quantum numbers for the core states .
@xmath107 is the partial dos of atom @xmath88 with angular momentum @xmath80 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 are the radial wave function and atomic sphere radii of atom @xmath88 .
the transition coefficient @xmath110 can be calculated analytically according to the following equation , @xmath111 in the case of absorption spectra @xmath112 . to account for instrument resolution and life - time broadening of both core and valence states
we have broadened the calculated spectra using the lorentzian function with fwhm of 1ev .
let us first discuss qualitative distinctions among the electronic band structures of lamno@xmath0 with various magnetic configurations without considering the structural distortion . with full cubic symmetry , @xmath3 and e@xmath113 orbitals are three - fold and two - fold degenerate , respectively .
the orbital - projected dos of mn 3@xmath2 electrons in the f phase of cubic lamno@xmath0 are shown in fig.[fig : cldos ] , where the @xmath3 states are away from @xmath19 and also rather narrow .
however , the @xmath4 levels are broadly distributed in the dos profile .
the electrons at @xmath19 have both @xmath114 and the @xmath115 electrons as shown in fig.[fig : cldos ] . against the pure ionic picture ( where the @xmath4 electrons only are expected to be closer to @xmath19 )
there is considerable amount of @xmath4 electrons present around @xmath146ev .
these states originate from the covalent interaction between the mn @xmath4 electrons and o 2@xmath15 states which produce the @xmath4 bonding ( around @xmath146ev ) and antibonding ( above @xmath142ev ) hybrids .
the @xmath3 states are energetically degenerate with the o 2@xmath15 states in vb indicating that there are finite covalent interactions between these states . owing to this covalent interaction along with the exchange interaction between the @xmath3 and @xmath4 states , a finite dos of @xmath3 electrons in the energy range @xmath147 to @xmath145ev
is created . with @xmath19
positioned in the middle of the @xmath4 band , a jt instability is produced which causes the oxygen octahedra to distort and removes the orbital degeneracy . for the undistorted cubic perovskite structure ,
the total dos is shown in fig.[fig : ctdos ] for the nonmagnetic ( paramagnetic = p ) , f and the a- , c- and g- type af spin configurations . without the jt - caused lattice distortion ,
the lsda calculations show that lamno@xmath0 is metallic for all these magnetic states . in all the cooperative magnetic states ,
the hund splitting is large and induces an empty minority - spin band at the mn site .
the dos for the p phase given in fig.[fig : ctdos ] shows a large value at @xmath19 .
this is a favorable condition for providing a magnetic splitting and hence the cooperative magnetic phase is more stable than the p phase . from dos
for the f state of the undistorted structure ( see fig.[fig : ctdos ] ) one can see that there is a finite number of states present in both spin channels . on the other hand the half - metallic character clearly appeared in the f state of the orthorhombic structure ( fig.[fig : tdos ] ) .
the different hybridization nature of the cubic and the orthorhombic phases and the noninvolvement of jt effects in the cubic phase are the possible reasons for the absence of the half - metallic character in the cubic phase .
the total dos of the af phases are much different from that of the f phase ( fig.[fig : ctdos ] ) . owing to large exchange splitting
there is a smaller dos at the fermi level [ @xmath116 for the f and af phases compared with the p phase .
the calculated value of @xmath117 for the p phase is 146.6states/(ry .
f.u . ) and 16.7 , 20.5 , 25.1 and 17.8states/(ry f.u . ) for a- , c- and g - af as well as f phases , respectively .
let us now focus on the role of the structural distortion on the electronic structure of lamno@xmath0 .
it is believed that lamno@xmath0 is a charge - transfer - type ( ct ) insulator@xcite according to the zaanen - sawatzky - allen scheme,@xcite in which the lowest - lying gap transition corresponds to the ct excitation from the o 2@xmath15 to mn 3@xmath2 state and has four @xmath2 electrons per mn@xmath11 site with a configuration of @xmath118 .
this electronic configuration with one electron for the two @xmath4 orbitals implies that lamno@xmath0 is a typical jt system .
so , this electronic configuration is susceptible to a strong electron - phonon coupling of the jt type that splits the @xmath4 states into filled @xmath119 and empty @xmath120 , and thus , produces large asymmetric oxygen displacements .
the important factors governing the formation of the electronic structure of orthorhombic lamno@xmath0 are the exchange splitting owing to spin polarization , the ligand field splitting of @xmath121 and @xmath3 states and the further splitting of the @xmath121 states owing to the jt distortion .
early theoretical work focused on the undistorted perovskite aristotype structure and it was found that usual lsda can not produce the correct insulating ground state for lamno@xmath0.@xcite using the lapw method , pickett and singh@xcite obtained a gap of 0.12ev for the distorted lamno@xmath0 when they include the jt effect and a - af ordering . as noticed in earlier studies,@xcite two unexpected behaviors
appear when one includes the structural distortion ; the stabilization of the a - af over the f phase and an opening of a gap and large rearrangement of bands .
the valence band dos of lamno@xmath0 are derived primarily from mn 3@xmath2 and o 2@xmath15 admixture with dominant mn 3@xmath2 character ( fig.[fig : pdos ] ) . from the projected density of states ( pdos )
it can be seen that the mn 3@xmath2 @xmath14 o 2@xmath15 hybridization is spin dependent . for the case of the majority - spin channel both mn 3@xmath2 and o 2@xmath15 strongly mix with each other in the whole vb . on the contrary , owing to the presence of mn 3@xmath2 in the high spin state , the minority - spin vb is nearly empty for the mn 3@xmath2 states .
hence , there is little overlap between mn 3@xmath2 and o 2@xmath15 states in the minority - spin channel .
because of ct from la and mn to the o 2@xmath15 states , the latter are almost filled and their contribution to the unoccupied state is minimal .
the o 2@xmath41 states are well localized and are present around @xmath1418ev .
vb of lamno@xmath0 is generally composed of four regions .
the lowest energy region contains mainly o 2@xmath41 bands , above this the la 5@xmath15 bands are distributed in the region between @xmath1417ev and @xmath1414ev .
both the o 2@xmath41 and la 5@xmath15 bands are well separated from the bands in the vicinity of @xmath19 , and consequently they hardly contribute to the chemical bonding or to transport properties .
the o 2@xmath15 bands are present in the energy range @xmath147ev to @xmath142ev and energetically degenerate with the mn 3@xmath2 states in the whole vb region indicating covalent interaction between mn and o in lamno@xmath0 .
the present observation of strong covalency in the ground state of lamno@xmath0 is consistent with the conclusion drawn from photoemission and x - ray - absorption spectroscopy.@xcite the negligible contribution of la electrons in the vb region indicates that there is an ionic interaction between la and the mno@xmath12 octahedra .
it has been pointed out by goodenough@xcite that the covalency between the a site and oxygen is important for the gdfeo@xmath0-type distortion .
however our pdos profile shows that there is only a negligible amount of electrons present in vb from the a ( la ) site indicating that the covalent interaction between la and o is rather unimportant in lamno@xmath0 . from pdos along with the orbital - projected dos
we see that both mn @xmath3 and @xmath4 electrons participate in the covalent interaction with the neighboring oxygens .
the top of vb is dominated by the majority - spin mn 3@xmath2 states indicating the importance of mn 3@xmath2 states in transport properties such as cmr observed in hole - doped lamno@xmath0 .
the bottom of cb is dominated by the minority - spin mn 3@xmath2 electrons and above the la 4@xmath42 electrons are present in a very narrow energy range between 2.6 and 3.5ev ( fig.[fig : pdos ] ) .
o 3@xmath2 and mn 4@xmath15 states are found around 10ev above @xmath19 . as the mn @xmath2 states are playing an important role for the magnetism and other physical properties of lamno@xmath0 , it is worthwhile to investigate these in more detail .
an approximately cubic crystal field stemming from the oxygen octahedron around mn would split the mn 3@xmath2 levels into @xmath3 and @xmath4 levels . for mn@xmath11 in lamno@xmath0 , three electrons would occupy localized @xmath3 levels , and one electron a linear combination of two @xmath4 levels .
the general view of the electronic structure of lamno@xmath0 is that both @xmath3 and e@xmath113 orbitals hybridize with o 2@xmath15 orbitals , @xmath3 mainly with 2@xmath15 @xmath122 and @xmath4 mainly with 2@xmath15 @xmath123 .
the @xmath3 electrons hybridize less with o 2@xmath15 states and hence may be viewed as local spins ( @xmath124 = 3/2 ) .
in contrast to that , @xmath121 orbitals , which hybridize more strongly produce rather broad bands . the strong exchange interaction with the @xmath125 subbands along with
the jt distortion lead to the splitting of @xmath4 into half occupied @xmath114 and unoccupied @xmath126 bands .
our calculations show that @xmath3 bands forms intense peaks in both vb and cb , and majority - spin @xmath3 bands are almost completely filled owing to the high spin state of mn in lamno@xmath0 .
contrary to the general opinion , our orbital projected dos ( fig.[fig : ldos ] ) show that both @xmath4 and @xmath3 electrons are present throughout vb and hence both types of electrons participate in the covalent bonding with oxygen .
the orbital projected dos ( fig.[fig : ldos ] ) clearly shows that there is almost equal amounts of both @xmath4 and @xmath3 electrons at the top of vb and certainly not@xcite dominated by mn @xmath4 bands alone .
the dos in fig.[fig : ldos ] @xmath119 states are shifted to a lower energy than @xmath120 and is more populated .
a comparison of the orbital projected dos for the mn @xmath2 states of the f cubic phase with that of the af orthorhombic phase show significant differences . in the f cubic case the @xmath4 levels are well separated from the @xmath3 levels and there is no @xmath125 electrons present in the vicinity of @xmath19 . in the a - af orthorhombic phase
both @xmath125 and @xmath114 electrons are present in the vicinity of @xmath19 .
both @xmath4 and @xmath3 electrons are energetically degenerate throughout the vb range and in particular the electrons in the @xmath119 orbitals are well localized and degenerate with the electrons in @xmath127 and @xmath128 .
importantly , the jt distortion split the @xmath4 states in the a - af orthorhombic phase and hence we find semiconducting behavior .
photoemission studies@xcite show that the character of the bandgap of lamno@xmath0 is of the @xmath15-to-@xmath2 ct type .
our site projected doss predict that there is considerable @xmath15 and @xmath2 character present at the top of vb as well as in the low energy region of cb .
the vb photoemission study@xcite has been interpreted to suggest that dos closer to @xmath19 in vb contains contributions from mn @xmath114 .
in contrast , our calculations ( fig.[fig : ldos ] ) show that dos closer to @xmath19 in vb contains contribution from both mn @xmath114 and @xmath125 electrons . owing to the jt distortion
the @xmath4 electrons are subjected to an oo effect in lamno@xmath0 .
as the jt distortion influences the stability of the orbital configuration , one can expect that it also should affect the electronic structure of lamno@xmath0 differently for different magnetic orderings .
hence , we next focus our attention to the electronic structure of orthorhombic lamno@xmath0 in different magnetic configurations . the calculated total dos for orthorhombic lamno@xmath0 in the p , f and a- , c- and g - af arrangements are shown in fig.[fig : tdos ] . from dos at @xmath19 in the p phase , one can deduce pertinent information concerning the magnetism in lamno@xmath0 .
this shows that lamno@xmath0 is a very favorable compound for cooperative magnetism since it has a large dos value at @xmath19 in the p state ( fig.[fig : tdos ] ) .
owing to the splitting of @xmath4 states by the jt distortion , a gap opens up @xmath19 in doss for both the a - af and g - af phases ( fig.[fig : tdos ] ) .
it is interesting to note that the cubic phase of lamno@xmath0 is always metallic irrespective of the magnetic ordering considered in the calculations .
thus the structural distortion is the key ingredient to account for the stabilization of the insulating behavior of lamno@xmath0 , consistent with the earlier studies.@xcite from fig.[fig : tdos ] it is interesting to note that the p , f and c - af phases of lamno@xmath0 are found to exhibit metallic conduction even when we include the structural distortions in the calculation .
this shows that apart from structural distortion , the af ordering also plays and important role for stabilizing the insulating behavior of lamno@xmath0 .
usually , the @xmath4 splitting caused by the jt effect is somewhat underestimated in the asa calculations@xcite and a discrepancy could reflect an uncertainty introduced by the asa approach . the energy separation between the @xmath4 and @xmath3 levels , caused by the crystal - field splitting ,
is known to be larger than 1ev.@xcite owing to strong overlap between the @xmath4 and @xmath3 levels in the a - af orthorhombic phase , we are unable to estimate the crystal field splitting energy . however , owing to the well separated @xmath4 and @xmath3 levels in the cubic phase we estimated this energy to be @xmath290.96ev .
the jt distortion lifts the degeneracy of the @xmath4 level .
the @xmath4 level splitting in our calculation is found to be 0.278ev and this is nothing but the ( semiconducting ) bandgap in this material .
the mn @xmath2 exchange splitting obtained from our calculation is 3.34ev and this is found to be in agreement with 3.5ev found by pickett and singh@xcite by a lapw calculation and 3.48ev reported by mahadevan _
et al._@xcite from lmto - asa calculations .
the lmto - asa@xcite calculations reveals that the splittings between the spin - up and spin - down states on introduction of the orthorhombic distortion are slightly asymmetric for the two types of mn .
however , our more accurate full potential calculations do not show any asymmetry of the splitting and the magnetic moments are completely canceled due to the af interaction between the mn ions .
the total dos in fig.[fig : tdos ] show clearly that there is a gap opening near @xmath19 in the g - af phase with a value of 0.28ev , comparable with that of the a - af phase . as there is no bandgap in the c - af and f phases ,
the above results indicate that the af coupling between the layers plays an important role in opening up the bandgap in lamno@xmath0 .
the dos for the f phase shows a half - metallic feature , viz . , the finite total dos around @xmath19 comes from one of the spin channels while there is a gap across @xmath19 for the other spin channel .
both spin - up and spin - down e@xmath113 states extend over a wide energy range . owing to the f ordering within the @xmath1 plane in the a - af phase and within @xmath129 in the c - af phase , the dos for these phases bears resemblance to that of the f phase .
on the other hand , dos for the g - af phase ( dominated by the af superexchange interactions ) is quite different from that of the a- , c - af and the f phases ( fig.[fig : tdos ] ) .
moreover , in the g - af phase the width of the @xmath4 state is narrower than that in the a- , c - af and f phases and the partially filled @xmath4 states in these phases are well separated from the empty @xmath3 states . as the jt coupling between the @xmath4 electrons and the distortion modes for the mno@xmath12 octahedra plays an important role for the physical properties of lamno@xmath0 ,
a magnetic - property study of the undistorted cubic phase of lamno@xmath0 is important .
we have calculated the total energies and magnetic moments for lamno@xmath0 in the undistorted cubic perovskite structure as well as for the orthorhombic structure with different magnetic configurations .
the calculated total energies for the p , f , a- , c- and g - af states of lamno@xmath0 with the cubic perovskite structure relative to the a - af phase with the orthorhombic structure is given in table[table : de ] .
according to these data the cubic phase of lamno@xmath0 should be stabilized in the f phase .
stabilization of the f phase in the cubic structure concurs with earlier findings.@xcite the lapw calculations of hamada _
et al._@xcite for undistorted lamno@xmath0 show that the a - af phase is 1ev above the f phase , whereas pickett and singh@xcite found a difference of only 110mev .
our calculations shows that the a - af phase is 60mev above the f phase in the cubic perovskite structure ( table[table : de ] ) .
we used gga , so coupling and a large number of * k * points along with a well converged basis set .
this may account for the difference between the present work and the earlier studies .
our orbital projected dos for the @xmath2 electrons of mn ( fig.[fig : cldos ] ) show that the @xmath4 electrons are only distributed in the vicinity of @xmath19 in the majority - spin channel .
the removal of the jt distortion enhances the exchange interaction originating from the @xmath4 states drastically and also reduces the negative exchange from the @xmath3 state .
hence , the total interplane exchange interaction is positive and the system stabilizes in the f phase .
the calculated total energies of various magnetic configurations for lamno@xmath0 in the orthorhombic structure ( table[table : de ] ) shows that the orthorhombic structure with the a - af ordering of the moments is the ground state for lamno@xmath0 .
the stabilization of the a - af state is consistent with the neutron diffraction findings.@xcite further , our calculations predict that the f phase is only 24mev higher in energy than the ground state . on the other hand ,
the p phase is @xmath291.4ev higher in energy than the ground state . from the total energy of the various possible magnetic arrangements it is clear that intralayer exchange interactions in lamno@xmath0 are f and considerably stronger than the af interlayer couplings , the latter being very sensitive to lattice distortions .
this observation is in agreement with the conclusion of terakura _
et al._@xcite from electronic structure studies and in qualitative agreement with inelastic neutron scattering results.@xcite the present observation of a small energy difference between the a - af and f phases is consistent with earlier theoretical studies.@xcite it should be noted that lmto - asa calculations@xcite predict the f state to be lower in energy than the af state also for the orthorhombic structure ( table[table : de ] ) .
however , the lsda+@xmath16 calculations@xcite with lattice distortion yielded the correct ground state .
hence , it has been concluded that the correlation effect plays an important role for obtaining the correct electronic structure of lamno@xmath0 .
it should also be noted that the theoretically optimized crystal - structure theory predicts@xcite that f is more stable than the observed a - af state in lamno@xmath0 . on the other hand , our calculations , without the inclusion of the correlation effect , give the correct ground state for lamno@xmath0 indicating that the correlation effect is not so important in this case .
if the interlayer f coupling is stronger than the intralayer af coupling the system will be stabilized in the c - af phase .
however , our calculations show that c - af phase is higher in energy than the a - af and f phases . due to the jt instability of mn @xmath130
, a substantial energy gain is expected when we include the actual structural distortions in our calculations .
hence , a gain of 0.323ev / f.u . is found for f and 0.407ev / f.u . for a - af
( table[table : de ] ) when the structural distortions were included .
the magnetic ordering is such that the difference in total energy between f and a - af ( c - af ) give information about the exchange - coupling energy within the plane ( perpendicular to the plane for c - af ) .
our calculations show that the af intraplane exchange interaction energy is smaller ( 24mev for the orthorhombic phase and 59mev for the cubic phase ) than the af interplane exchange interaction energy ( 41mev for the orthorhombic phase and 92mev for the cubic phase ) .
the present findings are consistent with the experimental studies in the sense that neutron scattering measurements@xcite on a lamno@xmath0 single crystal showed a strong intraplane f coupling and a weak af interplane coupling .
now we will try to understand the microscopic origin for the stabilization of a - af in lamno@xmath0 . in the ideal cubic lattice the hybridization between the mn @xmath3 and @xmath4 states is nearly vanishing .
as expected for a half - filled @xmath3 band , the @xmath3-type interatomic exchange facilitates af ordering .
our orbital - projected dos show that the @xmath120 electrons are distributed in the whole vb region and are mainly populated in the top of vb .
the jt distortion induces orbital ordering in which the orbitals confined to the @xmath1 plane ( @xmath131 and @xmath6 ) are dominantly populated and the counter @xmath4 orbitals of @xmath119 symmetry are less populated in the vicinity of @xmath19 . in this case itinerant band ferromagnetism is operational in the @xmath1 plane and is responsible for the f ordering with in the plane .
the electrons in the @xmath127 and @xmath119 orbitals are well localized and these make the interplane exchange interaction af , which in turn stabilizes the a - af phase . however , the electrons in the @xmath128 orbitals are well delocalized and have almost the same energy distribution as @xmath120 .
this weakens the af coupling between the layers and in turn makes the energy difference between the f and a - af phases very small . the cmr effect in manganites
may be understood as follows .
when charges are localized by strong electron - electron interactions the system becomes an af insulator , but this state is energetically very close to the metallic f state in lamno@xmath0 .
consequently , aligning of spins with an external magnetic field will activate the metallic f states and cause a large gain of kinetic energy , i.e. a cmr phenomenon .
table[table : moment ] lists the calculated magnetic moment at the mn site in lamno@xmath0 for different spin configurations in the undistorted cubic perovskite structure as well as the distorted orthorhombic structure , including for comparison corresponding values from other theoretical studies and experimental neutron diffraction results . without hybridization ,
the mn spin moment should take an appropriate integer value ( 4@xmath132/mn atom in the case of high spin state ) and the oxygen moment should be negligible . owing to the covalent interaction between the mn @xmath2 and o @xmath15 states , experimental as well as theoretical studies will give smaller mn moments than predicted by the ionic model .
for the f phase in the orthorhombic structure , mn polarizes the neighboring oxygens and the induced moment at the o(1 ) site is 0.07@xmath132/atom and at the o(2 ) 0.059@xmath132/atom and these moments are coupled ferromagnetically with the local moments of mn@xmath11 .
there are small differences in the magnetic moments for the different magnetic arrangements indicating that these moments have a distinct atomic - like character . from table[table : moment ] it should be noted that the lmto - asa approach generally gives larger moments than the accurate full - potential calculation .
the reason for this difference is that the full - potential calculations estimate the moments using the spin density within the muffin - tin spheres so that the spin - density in the interstitial region is neglected .
our calculated magnetic moment at the mn site in the a - af orthorhombic structure is comparable with the experimental value ( table[table : moment ] ) .
the electric field gradient for mn in the f phase obtained by the flapw calculation is 3.579 @xmath133 10@xmath134 v / m@xmath135 as compared with @xmath141.587 @xmath133 10@xmath134 v / m@xmath135 for the a - af phase .
the asymmetry parameter @xmath136 of the electric field gradient tensor follows from the relation @xmath137 , which gives @xmath136=0.95 for mn in the a - af phase in good agreement with @xmath136 = 0.82 obtained from low temperature perturbed - angular - correlation spectroscopy.@xcite the magnetic hyperfine field at the mn site derived from our flapw calculation is 198 kg for the a - af phase and 176 kg for the f phase .
a comment on the appearence of the f state by doping of divalent elements in lamno@xmath0 is appropriate .
it has long been believed that the appearence of the f ground sate in metallic la@xmath7_ae_@xmath8mno@xmath0 can be explained by the double - exchange interaction of mn@xmath11 ( @xmath138 ) and mn@xmath139 ( @xmath140 ) .
recent experiments and theoretical investigations have revealed many discrepancies in the simple double - exchange model .
et al._@xcite pointed out that the simple double - exchange model is methodologically inappropriate for predicting the af insulating phase ( 0.1 @xmath141 0.15 , @xmath13 @xmath142 @xmath143 ) , for the canted af insulating phase with large canting angle or large magnetic moment estimated by kawano _
et al._@xcite in the f phase region .
millis _ et al._@xcite proposed that in addition to the double - exchange mechanism , a strong electron - phonon interaction arising from the jt splitting of the outer mn @xmath2 level is important .
as our calculations predict the cubic phase of lamno@xmath0 to be the f state , there must be another mechanism than the doping by the divalent elements which reduces the jt distortion and in turn increases the interlayer exchange coupling to stabilize the f state .
moreover , our calculations show that within the @xmath1 plane the mn ions are f coupled without involvement of mn in different ionic states .
if the double - exchange mechanism is operational in lamno@xmath0 one can expect a charge imbalance between the mn atoms in the @xmath1 plane ( with f alignment ) this suggests that the f coupling in lamno@xmath0 can be explained within the frame work of itinerant band ferromagnetism .
the magneto - optical ( mo ) kerr - effect can be described by the off - diagonal elements of the dielectric tensor which in a given frequency region originates from optical transitions with different frequency dependence for right and left circularly polarized light caused by the so splitting of the states involved.@xcite considerable interest has recently been focused on studying mo properties of materials owing to their potential for application in rewritable high - density data storage . for magneto - optical information storage one
requires materials with a large kerr - effect as well as perpendicular magnetic anisotropy .
uniaxial magnetic anisotropy is observed for la@xmath144ca@xmath145mno@xmath0 films grown on srtio@xmath0 [ 001 ] substrates@xcite and confirmed theoretically.@xcite the energy difference between the a - af and f states of lamno@xmath0 is very small and hence a small magnetic field could drive a transition from a - af to f. also , it is interesting to note that lamno@xmath0 produced by annealing in a oxygen atomosphere shows@xcite a simple f structure below @xmath10 = 140k , with moments oriented along @xmath26 .
manganites exhibiting the cmr effect are also in the f state and hence it is interesting to study the f phase of lamno@xmath0 in more detail .
polar kerr - rotation measurements on hole doped lamno@xmath0 show that bi doping enhances the kerr - rotation to a value of 2.3@xmath30 at wavelength of 0.29 nm at 78k.@xcite it may be recalled that the large mo effect in mnptsb is usually linked with its half - metallic behavior.@xcite hence , as the f phase of lamno@xmath0 also possesses half - metallic behavior with a bandgap of 2.38ev ( between top of the minority - spin vb and the bottom of cb in fig.[fig : tdos ] at @xmath19 ) , it is interesting to examine its mo properties . in the case of f state lamno@xmath0 ,
our calculations predicted half - metallic behaviour and hence the intraband contribution will be of importance to predict the mo property reliably .
therefore , we have taken into account the intraband contribution using the drude formula with the same relaxation time as earlier.@xcite we have calculated the unscreened plasma frequency by integrating over the fermi surface using the flapw method . for f state la@xmath146ca@xmath147mno@xmath0 pickett and singh predicted@xcite a plasma frequency of 1.9ev .
several groups have reported an anomalously small drude weight in both la@xmath146ca@xmath147mno@xmath0 and la@xmath146sr@xmath147mno@xmath0.@xcite interpreting the latter findings in terms of enhanced optical mass , the effective mass values established optically are much greater than those derived from the specific - heat measurements.@xcite the theoretically established half - metallic feature of the f state in lamno@xmath0 suggests that the small drude weight is originating from large exchange splitting which contracts the drude contribution coming from the minority - spin channel . in accordance with the half - metallic nature of the f state ,
our calculated dos at @xmath19 is very small [ 3.36states/(ry f.u . ) ] as a result , the calculated unscreened plasma frequency along @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 are 1.079 , 1.276 and 0.926ev , respectively . owing to the half - metallic nature of this material
there is no intraband contribution arising from the majority - spin channel .
hence , we conclude that the experimentally observed@xcite anomalously small drude weight in la@xmath146ca@xmath147mno@xmath0 and la@xmath146sr@xmath147mno@xmath0 is due to half - metallic behavior .
our calculated mo spectra for f state lamno@xmath0 is given in fig.[fig : moke ] .
our recent moke studies@xcite of fept shows that kerr - rotation spectra can be reliably predicted even up to as high energies as 10ev with the formalism adopted here .
hence , we have depicted the calculated mo spectra up to 8ev in fig.[fig : moke ] .
the kerr - rotation ( @xmath148 ) shows a positive or negative peak when the kerr - ellipticity ( @xmath72 ) passes through zero .
the frequency dependent kerr - rotation and ellipticity spectra are experimentally established@xcite for hole - doped lamno@xmath0 . as there are no experimental mo spectra available for comparison with our theoretical spectra for ( pure ) f state lamno@xmath0 , we have made comparison with the experimetal spectrum for hole - doped lamno@xmath0 ( fig.[fig : moke ] ) .
mo effects are proportional to the product of the so - coupling strength and the net electron - spin polarization .
this makes mo effects sensitive to the magnetic electrons , i.e. the 3@xmath2 electrons of mn in lamno@xmath0 . in order to promote the understanding of the microscopic origin of the mo effect
, we present the off - diagonal elements of the imaginary part of the dielectric tensor in fig.[fig : e2 ] .
note that the @xmath149 spectra can have either positive or negative sign since it is proportional to the difference in the absorption of rcp and lcp light .
the sign of @xmath149 is thus directly related to the spin polarization of the electronic states that contributes to the mo effect .
owing to the half - metallic behavior of the f state of lamno@xmath0 the off - diagonal components of the dielectric tensor below 2.46ev originates only from the majority - spin electrons ( see fig.[fig : e2 ] ) .
so , the peaks at 0.4 , 0.9 and 2ev in the kerr - rotation spectra stem from transition from mn @xmath150 to the hybridized mn@xmath14o mn(@xmath151o 2@xmath15)@xmath152 bands . the experimental @xmath149 spectra show@xcite two peaks , one at 1.2ev and the other at 3.5ev .
these two peaks are assigned to be @xmath153 transitions involving @xmath154 minority - spin electrons .
electrons , respectively .
the absence of the 3.5ev peak in our theoretical spectra indicate that it is an effect of the hole - doping .
it is experimentally observed that kerr - rotation spectra change significantly with the temperature@xcite as well as with the doping level.@xcite our calculated mo spectra are valid only for the stoichiometric f state lamno@xmath0 at low temperature .
the polar mo kerr - rotation data for la@xmath146sr@xmath147mno@xmath0 at 78k was taken from the experimental spectra of popma and kamminga@xcite .
even though the experimental mo spectra la@xmath155sr@xmath156mno@xmath0 were measured@xcite at 300k with a magnetic field of 2.2koe , our calculated kerr - rotation spectrum is comparable in the lower energy region ( fig.[fig : moke ] ) .
the discrepancy between the experimental and theoretical kerr - spectra in the higher - energy region may be explained as a temperature and/or hole doping effect .
we hope that our theoretical findings may motivate to measurements on fully magnetized lamno@xmath0 at low temperatures .
et al._@xcite have performed theoretical calculation on mo properties such as kerr - rotation and ellipticity for lamno@xmath0 for different canted - spin configurations .
as the f state is only 24mev above the ground state , it is quite possible that the f state can be stabilized experimentally .
however , since we have studied the mo properties of f state lamno@xmath0 our result can not be compared with the findings of solovyev _
et al._@xcite lawler _ et al._@xcite found strong faraday rotation at 1.5ev ( @xmath157 1 @xmath133 10@xmath158 @xmath28/cm ) and 3ev ( @xmath159 4.10@xmath158 @xmath28/cm ) for la@xmath7ca@xmath8mno@xmath0 when ( 0.2 @xmath141 0.5 ) .
our theoretical faraday rotation spectra also show two prominent peaks at 1.5 and 4ev , the latter having the highest value ( @xmath29 1.25@xmath13310@xmath160 @xmath28/cm ) in the spectrum .
the lower - energy peak in the experimental spectrum@xcite of la@xmath7ca@xmath8mno@xmath0 is interpreted as associated with both ligand - to - metal charge transfer and @xmath2-@xmath2 transitions . however , there are as yet no experimental frequency - dependent faraday rotation and ellipticity measurements available .
a deeper understanding of optical properties is important from a fundamental point of view , since the optical characteristics involves not only the occupied and unoccupied part of the electronic structure but also the character of the bands .
so , in order to compare the band structure of lamno@xmath0 directly with experimental facts@xcite we have calculated the optical spectra for lamno@xmath0 ( for earlier theoretical studies see refs . ) .
the experimental reflectivity spectra are rather confusing and controversial ( see the discussion in ref . ) .
recent experiments@xcite indicate that the optical spectrum of the manganites is very sensitive to the condition at the surface .
as the optical properties of materials originate from interband transitions from occupied to unoccupied bands it is more instructive to turn to the electronic energy - band structure .
the calculated energy - band structure of lamno@xmath0 in the a - af state orthorhombic structure is shown in fig.[fig : bnd ] . from this illustration
it is immediately clear that lamno@xmath0 is an indirect bandgap semiconductor where the bandgap is between the s - y direction on the top of vb and the @xmath161 point at the bottom of cb .
there are two energy bands present in the top of vb , well separated from the rest of the vb .
our detailed analysis shows that these two energy bands have mainly mn @xmath120 and @xmath128 character with a small contribution from o @xmath15 .
the la 4@xmath42 electrons contribute with a cluster of bands between 2.5 to 3.5ev in cb ( fig.[fig : bnd ] ) .
the mn 3@xmath2 and o 2@xmath15 electrons are distributed over the whole energy range of vb .
saitoh _ et al._@xcite reported strong covalency and suggested that the energy gap in lamno@xmath0 should be considered as of the ct type .
the bandgap estimated from our dos studies for a - af state lamno@xmath0 is 0.278ev and this is found to be in good agreement with the value of 0.24ev obtained from resistivity measurements by mahendiran _
et al._@xcite whereas jonker@xcite reported 0.15ev . however , our value for the direct gap ( 0.677ev ) between occupied and empty states at the same location in bz is too low in comparison with optical ( 1.1ev)@xcite and photoemission ( 1.7ev)@xcite measurements .
( it should be noted however that optical gaps are usually defined at the onset of an increase in spectral intensity in the measured optical variable . )
it is also useful to compare our calculated bandgap with other theoretical results .
the lsda and lsda+@xmath16 calculations of yang _
et al._@xcite using the lmto - asa method gave a bandgap of 0.1 and 1.0ev , respectively .
the lsda+@xmath162 approach ( where @xmath16 is applied only to the @xmath3 electrons)@xcite yielded a bandgap of 0.2ev .
hence , our bandgap is somewhat larger than that of other lsda calculations . on the other hand
, hartree fock calculations@xcite gave an unphysically large gap ( 3ev ) for lamno@xmath0 .
as all the linear optical properties can be derived from @xmath162 we have illustrated this quantity in fig.[fig : e2 ] and we have compared our theoretical spectra with the experimental @xmath162 spectra derived from reflectivity measurements .
the illustration shows that our calculated spectra are in good agreement with the experimental data at least up to 20ev .
this indicates that unlike earlier reported @xmath55 spectra obtained from asa calculations@xcite , accurate full - potential calculations are able to predict the electronic structure of lamno@xmath0 reliably not only for the occupied states but also for the excited states .
it is interesting to note that we are able to predict correctly the peaks around 1.5 , 4.7 , 8.8 and 20ev without the introduction of so - called scissor operations .
this suggests that electron - correlation effects are less significant in lamno@xmath0 .
the peak around 4.7ev is reasonably close to the experimental feature reported by of arima _
et al._@xcite ( fig.[fig : e2 ] ) .
our theoretical peak at 8.8ev in the spectra is in quantitative agreement with both sets of experimental data included in the figure .
our calculations are also able to predict correctly the experimentally observed peak at 20ev by jung _ et al._@xcite ( which arima _
et al._@xcite failed to record ) .
now we will try to understand the microscopic origin of the optical interband transitions in lamno@xmath0 .
the peak around 1.5ev has been assigned@xcite as intra - atomic @xmath163 transitions .
note that such @xmath164 transitions are not allowed by the electric dipole selection rule , but it has been suggested@xcite that a strong hybridization of the @xmath4 bands with the o 2@xmath15 bands will make such @xmath164 transitions optically active .
the interband transition between jt split bands gives low - energy transitions in the @xmath162 spectra and the sharp peak features present in @xmath165 and @xmath166 are attributed to such interband transition .
the partial dos for lamno@xmath0 given in fig.[fig : pdos ] show that there is a considerable amount of o 2@xmath15 states present at the top of vb as well as at the bottom of cb arising from strong covalent interaction between mn @xmath2 and o @xmath15 states .
hence , we propose that the lower energy peak in the @xmath167 spectra originates from [ ( mn @xmath120 @xmath128;o @xmath15 hybridized ) @xmath168 ( mn @xmath2;o @xmath15 ) ] optical interband transition .
the peak around 4.7ev in the @xmath63 @xmath162 spectrum originates mainly from hybridized ( mn @xmath119,o @xmath15 ) states to unoccupied hybridized ( mn 3@xmath2;o @xmath15 ) states .
all the majority - spin @xmath2 electrons participate in the interband transition from 3ev up to 10ev in in fig.[fig : e2 ] . in the cubic case
, @xmath162 is a scalar , and in the orthorhombic case it is a tensor .
so we have calculated the dielectric component with the light polarized along @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 as shown in fig.[fig : e2 ] .
the optical anisotropy in this material can be understood from our directional - dependent , optical dielectric tensor shown in fig.[fig : e2 ] . from the calculations we see that the @xmath162 spectra along @xmath24 and @xmath26 are almost the same .
large anisotropy is present in the lower energy region of the @xmath162 spectra . in particular the sharp peaks present for @xmath62 and @xmath64 which is less pronounced for @xmath63 .
the optical conductivity obtained by ahn and millis@xcite from tight - binding parameterization of the band structure also shows a sharp peak feature in the lowest energy part of @xmath169 whereas this feature is absent in their @xmath170 spectrum .
our calculation predicts that the interband transition due to jt splitting is less pronounced in the @xmath55 spectrum corresponding to @xmath63 . in order to confirm these theoretical predictions polarized
optical property measurements on lamno@xmath0 are needed .
soloveyev@xcite suggested that the optical anisotropy in a - af state lamno@xmath0 is due to two factors : ( i ) owing to large exchange splitting the minority - spin @xmath119 states near @xmath19 will contribute less to @xmath171 .
( ii ) owing to a - af ordering and jt distortion , the contribution of @xmath119 character to the states with @xmath172 and @xmath119 symmetry is significantly reduced and hence the intensity of @xmath171 in the low - energy region should also be reduced . in order to understand the role of the jt distortion for the optical properties of lamno@xmath0
, we calculated also the optical dielectric tensor for lamno@xmath0 in the cubic perovskite structure with a - af ordering ( fig.[fig : e2 ] ) . just like for the orthorhombic a - af phase
, there is large optical anisotropy present in the lower - energy ( @xmath142 2ev ) part of the spectrum .
this indicates that the a - af spin ordering is responsible for the large anisotropy in the optical dielectric tensor which in turn is a result of different spin - selection rules applicable to in - plane and out - of - plane optical transitions .
however , the optical anisotropy in the orthorhombic a - af phase is much larger than the corresponding undistorted cubic phase ( fig.[fig : e2 ] ) indicating that apart from a - af ordering , the jt distortion also contributes to large optical anisotropy in the lower energy region of the optical spectra of lamno@xmath0 . in order to compare our calculated spectra with those obtained by the lmto - asa method , we have plotted the optical dielectric tensors obtained by solovyev _
et al._@xcite from lsda calculation in fig.[fig : e2 ] .
our calculated @xmath63 spectrum below 2ev is found to be in good agreement with the @xmath173 and @xmath174 spectra of these authors .
however , their @xmath175 spectra is much smaller in the lower - energy region than our results as well as the experimental findings ( fig.[fig : e2 ] ) . from the optical spectrum calculated by the lda+@xmath16 method , solovyev _
et al._@xcite found that the low - energy part ( up to 3ev ) reflects excitations from o @xmath15 to an unoccupied band formed by alternating mn @xmath176 and @xmath177 orbitals .
however , their study poorly described the higher - energy excitations
. this discrepancy may be due to the limitations of asa or the minimal basis they have used in the calculation ( la 4@xmath42 states where not included ) . bouarab _
et al._@xcite calculated optical conductivity spectra for lamno@xmath0 .
they used the lmto - asa method where nonspherical contributions to the potential are not included .
further , these calculations are made with a minimal basis set and for the undistorted cubic perovskite structure rather than the actual distorted perovskite structure .
hence , it does not make sense to compare our calculated optical spectra directly with the latter findings .
as the linear optical spectra are directly measurable experimentally , we have reported our calculated optical spectra in fig.[fig : optic ] . also , to understand the anisotropy in the optical properties of lamno@xmath0 we show the linear optical spectra for lamno@xmath0 along the @xmath24 and @xmath25 axis in the same illustration .
a large anisotropy in the optical properties for the low - energy region is clearly visible in the reflectivity as well as the extinction coefficient spectra .
( fig.[fig : optic ] shows the experimentally measured reflectivity by jung _
et al._@xcite , arima _ et al._@xcite and takenaka _
et al._@xcite in comparision with calculated spectra from our optical dielectric tensors . ) .
the reflectivity measured by takenaka _ et al . _ above 8.4ev is found at a higher value than found in the spectra of other two experiments ( fig.[fig : optic ] ) .
overall our calculated reflectivity spectra are found to be in good qualitative agreement with the experimental spectra up to 30ev in fig.[fig : optic ] .
the peaks around 10 and 25ev in our reflectivity spectra concur with the findings of takenaka _
et al._.@xcite as the optical properties of lamno@xmath0 are anisotropic , it is particularly interesting to calculate the effective number of valence electrons , @xmath178 , participating in the optical transitions in each direction .
hence , we have calculated ( see ref . ) the number of electrons participating in the optical interband transitions in different crystallographic directions , and the comparison between @xmath178 the @xmath62 and @xmath63 shows significant differences in the low - energy ( fig.[fig : optic ] ) . except for the reflectivity
there is no optical properties measurements for lamno@xmath0 available .
hopefully our findings will motivate such studies . in spite of intense experimental@xcite and theoretical@xcite efforts to understand the electronic structure of lamno@xmath0
, there are still a number of ambiguities concerning the vb features . both x - ray
( xps ) and ultraviolet photoemission spectroscopy ( ups ) experiments showed a double peak structure between @xmath1410ev and @xmath19.@xcite even though it is widely accepted that the double - peak structure arises from o @xmath15 and mn @xmath2 bands , an important controversy still remains in that some authors@xcite have argued that the o @xmath15 band lies below the mn @xmath3 bands , while others@xcite have suggested the opposite . in fig.[fig : xps ] we have compared our calculated value of vb xps intensity with the experimental spectra.@xcite in all the experimental studies , the main vb features have a marked increase in binding energy around 1.5@xmath142ev , remaining large in the region 2@xmath146ev , and falling off in the range 6@xmath148ev .
the experimental xps data show three peak intensity features between @xmath147 and @xmath143ev . as can be seen from fig.[fig : xps ] , these three peaks are well reproduced in the calculated profile .
the large experimental background intensity makes a direct comparison with the calculated peak feature around @xmath141.8ev difficult .
the overall agreement between the theoretical and experimental positions of peaks and shoulders in the xps spectra is very satisfactory ( fig.[fig : xps ] ) .
note that the experimental xps spectra does not exhibit any appreciable intensity in a correlation - induced satellite at higher - binding energies in contrast to intense satellite features usually found in transition metal monoxides , e.g. nio .
thus , the good agreement between experimental and theoretical spectra indicates that the on - site coulomb correlation effect is not significant in lamno@xmath0 .
knowledge of the theoretically calculated photoemission spectra ( pes ) has the advantage that one can identify contributions from different constituents to the pes intensity in different energy ranges . from fig.[fig :
xps ] it is clear that the xps intensity in the energy range @xmath143.5ev to @xmath19 mainly originates from mn @xmath2 states .
the o @xmath15 electrons contribute to the pes intensity in the energy range @xmath147 to 3.5ev .
below @xmath144ev both la and mn atoms contribute equally to the pes intensity .
pickett and singh@xcite compared their theoretical dos with pes and found significant differences .
thus , the good agreement between the experimental and our theoretical xps indicates that the matrix - element effect is important in lamno@xmath0 .
we now turn to a discussion of the bis spectra .
the physical process in bis is as follows .
an electron of energy @xmath179 is slowed down to a lower energy level @xmath180 corresponding to an unoccupied valence state of the crystal .
the energy difference is emitted as bremsstrahlung radiation , which reflects the density of unoccupied valence states.@xcite our calculated bis spectrum is compared with the experimental spectrum@xcite in fig.[fig : xps ] which show that theory is able to reproduce the experimentally observed peak at 2ev .
there is an intense peak above 3.5ev in the experimental spectrum which originates from the la 4@xmath42 electrons , but owing to its large intensity this is not shown in fig.[fig : xps ] .
another experimental technique that provides information about cb is x - ray absorption spectroscopy .
calculated o @xmath181 , mn @xmath181 and mn @xmath182 xanes spectra for lamno@xmath0 are shown in fig.[fig : xanes ] .
because of the angular momentum selection rule ( dipole approximation ) , only o 2@xmath15 states and mn 4@xmath15 states contribute to the o @xmath183-edge and mn @xmath183-edge spectra , respectively .
the mn 4@xmath41 and mn 3@xmath2 states contribute to the mn @xmath182 spectrum . the calculated x - ray absorption spectrum for the o @xmath183 edge ( vb @xmath168 1@xmath41 ) is given in the upper panel of fig.[fig : xanes ] along with available experimental data .
the experimental spectrum has two prominent peaks in the low - energy range and both are well reproduced in our theoretical spectra even without including the core - hole effect in the calculation . as reflected in different mn - o distances
there are two kinds ( crystallographically ) of oxygens present in lamno@xmath0 and results in considerable differences in peak positions in the xanes spectra .
the calculated @xmath182 spectrum is shown in the middle panel of fig.[fig : xanes ] . due to the nonavailability of experimental mn @xmath182 spectra for lamno@xmath0
we have compared our calculated spectrum with that experimentally established@xcite for mn@xmath11 in mn@xmath184o@xmath0 . the calculated mn @xmath183-edge spectrum for lamno@xmath0
is given in the lower panel of fig.[fig : xanes ] along with the available experimental @xmath183-edge spectra .
although dos are large for the empty @xmath114 and @xmath115 bands , they are not directly accessible in @xmath183-edge absorption via dipole transitions . thus the main @xmath183-edge absorption begins where the large part of the @xmath185 states are highly delocalized and extend over several mn atoms .
et al._@xcite show that the intensity of the mn @xmath183-edge spectrum increases with an increasing degree of local lattice distortion and is insensitive to the magnetic order .
the experimental mn @xmath183-edge spectra show two peaks in the lower energy region and these are well reproduced in our theoretical spectrum . in particular our mn @xmath183-edge spectrum is found to be in very good agreement with that of subias _
et al._@xcite in the whole energy range we have considered .
the good agreement between experimental and calculated xanes spectra further emphasizes the relatively little significance of correlation effects in lamno@xmath0 and also shows that the gradient - corrected full - potential approach is able to predict even the unoccupied spectra quite correctly .
transition metal oxides are generally regarded as a strongly correlated systems which are believed to be not properly treated by electronic structure theory .
the present paper has demonstrated , however , that accurate full - potential calculations including so coupling and generalized - gradient corrections can account well for several features observed for lamno@xmath0 . we have presented a variety of results based on the _ ab initio _ local spin - density approach that are broadly speaking in agreement with experimental results for both ground and excited state properties .
the present study strongly support experimental@xcite and theoretical models@xcite in which a strong coupling of the conduction electrons to a local jahn - teller distortion is considered to be important for understanding the basic physical properties of manganites .
in particular we found the following : + 1 .
the mn ions are in the high - spin state in lamno@xmath0 and hence the contribution to the minority - spin channel from the mn 3@xmath2 electrons are negligible small .
+ 2 . both mn @xmath3 and the @xmath4 electrons are present in the entire valence band region .
the @xmath4 electrons with the @xmath186 symmetry are well localized compared with those of @xmath120 symmetry and hence the @xmath119 contribution in the vicinity of @xmath19 is negligible . on the other hand , the @xmath3 electrons with @xmath128 character
have large electron distributions on the top of the valence band comparable with the distribution of @xmath120 electrons .
the insulating behavior in lamno@xmath0 originates from the combined effect of jahn - teller distortion and a - type antiferromagnetic ordering .
+ 4 . without jahn - teller distortion lamno@xmath0
is predicted to be a ferromagnetic metal .
+ 5 . unlike the lmto - asa calculations,@xcite without inclusion of the correlation effects in the calculations we are able to predict the correct a - type antiferromagnetic insulating ground state for lamno@xmath0 indicating that the importance of correlation effect has been exaggerated for this material .
the large changes in energy and the development of an energy gap resulting from the structural distortion along with exchange splitting indicate strong magnetostructural coupling
. this may be the possible origin for the observation of cmr in hole - doped lamno@xmath0 .
our calculation support the view point that the stabilization of the cubic phase is the prime cause for the occurrence of the ferromagnetic state by hole doping rather than the often believed double - exchange mechanism .
the density - functional approach works well for not only the ground - state properties but also the excited state properties of lamno@xmath0 .
+ pr is thankful for the financial support from the research council of norway .
also wish to acknowledge y.tokura , t.arima , k.takenaka and j.jung for generously sending there experimental optical data for comparison .
part of these calculations were carried out on the norwegian supercomputer facilities .
pr is grateful to igor solovyev and lars nordstrm for the useful communications and r. vidya for the comments and critical reading of this manuscript .
john wills , karlheinz schwarz and peter blaha for making their programs available for the present study .
o.e is grateful to the swedish research foundation and the swedish foundation for strategic research ( ssf ) .
g. jonker and j. van santen , physica ( amsterdam ) , * 16 * , 337 ( 1950 ) .
wollan and w.c .
koehler , phys .
100 * , 545 ( 1955 ) ; w.c .
koehler and e.o .
wollan , j. phys .
chem . solids .
, * 2 * 100 ( 1957 ) .
p. schiffer , a.p .
ramirez , a.p .
bao and s.w .
cheong , phys . rev .
, * 75 * , 3336 ( 1995 ) . t. mizokawa , d.i . khomskii and g.a .
sawatsky , phys .
b , * 60 * , 7309 ( 1999 ) . r.m .
kusters , j. singleton , d.a .
keen , r. mcgreevy and w. hages , physica b , * 155 * , 362 ( 1989 ) ; k. chahara , t. ohno , m. kasai and y. kozono , appl .
lett . , * 63 * , 1990 ( 1993 ) ; r. von helmolt , j. wecker , b. holzapfel , l. schultz and k. samwer , phys .
lett . , * 71 * , 2331 ( 1993 ) ; s. jin , t.h .
tiefel , m. mccormack , r.a .
fastnacht , r. ramesh , and l. chen , science , * 264 * , 413 ( 1994 ) ; h.l .
ju , c. kwon , r.l .
green and t. vankatesan , appl .
* 65 * , 2108 ( 1994 ) ; y. tomioka , a. asamitsu , y. moritomo , h. kuwahara and y. tokura , phys . rev .
, * 74 * , 5108 ( 1995 ) ; p. schiffer , a.p .
ramires , w. bao and s. -w .
cheong , phys .
lett . , * 75 * , 3336 ( 1995 ) ; y. tomiaka , a. asamitsu , y. moritomo , h. kuwahara and y. tokura , j. phys .
jpn . , * 64 * , 3626 ( 1995 ) ; h. kuwahara , y. tomioka , a. asamitsu , y. moritomo and y. tokura , j. phys .
jpn . , * 64 * , 3626 ( 1995 ) .
a. asamitsu , y. moritomo , t. arima and y. tokura , nature , * 373 * , 407 ( 1995 ) ; a. asamitsu , y. moritomo , r. kumai , y. tomioka and y. tokura , phys .
b , * 54 * , 1716 ( 1996 ) . h.y . hang , s. -w .
cheong , n.p .
ong , and b. batlogg , phys .
lett . , * 77 * , 2041 ( 1996 ) ; t. kimura , y. tomioka , h. kuwahara , a. asamitsu , m. tamura and y. tokura , science * 274 * , 1698 ( 1996 ) . c. zener , phys
. rev . * 82 * , 403 ( 1951 ) ; p.w .
anderson and h. hasegawa , phys . rev .
* 100 * , 675 ( 1955 ) ; p.g .
de gennes , phys .
rev . * 118 * , 141 ( 1960 ) .
a.j . millis , b.i .
shraiman and r. mueller , phys .
* 77 * , 175 ( 1996 ) .
m. kataoka and m. tachiki , physica b , 237 - 238 , 24 ( 1997 ) .
y. tokura , a. urushibara , y. moritomo , t. arima , a. asamitsu , g. kido and n. furukawa , j. phys . soc .
jpn . , * 63 * , 3931 ( 1994 ) .
a.j . millis , p.b .
littlewood and b.i .
shraiman , phys .
* 74 * , 5144 ( 1995 ) ; a.j .
millis , phys .
b , * 55 * , 6405 ( 1997 ) . k.i . kugel and d.i .
khomski , sov .
jetp , * 37 * , 725 ( 1973 ) .
r. maezono , s. ishihara and n. nagaosa , phys .
b , * 83 * , 11583 ( 1998 ) . w. koshibae , s. ishihara , y. kawamura , s. okamota , j. inone and s. maekawa , physica b , * 230 - 232 * ( 1997 ) .
h. rder , j. zang and r. bishop , phys .
* 76 * , 1356 ( 1996 ) .
s. ishihara , m. yamanaka and n. nagaosa , phys .
b , * 56 * , 686 ( 1997 ) .
a.j . millis , p.b .
littlewook and b.i .
shraimann , phys .
, * 74 * , 5144 ( 1995 ) .
brito and h. shiba , phys .
b , * 57 * , 1539 ( 1998 ) . a. takahashi and h. shiba , euro .
j. b , * 5 * , 413 ( 1998 ) .
y. motome and m. imada , j. phys .
, * 68 * , 16 ( 1999 ) .
mryasov , r.f .
sabiryanov , a.j .
freeman and s.s .
jaswal , phys .
b , * 56 * , 7255 ( 1997 ) . z. popovic and s. satpathy , phys .
lett . , * 84 * , 1603 ( 2000 ) .
solovyev and k. terakura , j. korean phys .
* 33 * , 375 ( 1998 ) .
ahn and a.j .
millis , j. appl .
phys . , * 87 * , 5013 ( 2000 ) .
solovyev , n. hamada and k. terakura , phys .
b , * 53 * , 7158 ( 1996 ) . j.f .
lawler , j.g .
lunney and j.m.d .
coey , appl .
, * 65 * , 3017 ( 1994 ) .
g. pari , s.m .
jaya , g. subramoniam and r. asokamani , phys .
b. * 51 * , 16575 ( 1995 ) .
z. yang , l. ye and x. xie , j. phys .
, * 12 * , 2737 ( 2000 ) .
anisimov , j. zaanen and o.k .
andersen , phys .
b , * 44 * , 943 ( 1991 ) .
solovyev , p.h .
dederichs and v.i .
anisimov , phys .
b , * 50 * , 16861 ( 1994 ) .
qian , q.q .
zheng , h.q .
lin and h.k .
wang , phys .
b , * 61 * , 1223 ( 2000 ) .
s. satpathy , z.s .
popovic and f.r .
vakajlovic , phys .
lett . , 76 , 960 ( 1996 ) .
k. held and d. vollhardt , phys .
lett . , * 84 * , 5168 ( 2000 ) .
j. inoue and s. mackama , phys .
lett . , * 74 * , 3407 ( 1995 ) .
bocquet , t. mizokawa , t. saitoh , h. namatame and a. fujimori , phys .
b , * 46 * , 3771 ( 1992 ) .
sarma , n. shanthi and r. mahadevan , phys .
b , * 53 * , 1622 ( 1996 ) .
pickett , and d.j .
singh , phys .
b , * 53 * , 1146 ( 1996 ) .
solovyev , n. hamada and k. terakura , phys .
lett . , * 76 * , 4825 ( 1996 ) .
sarma , n. shanthi , s.r .
barman , n. hamada , h. sawada and k. terakura , phys .
lett . , * 75 * , 1126 ( 1995 ) .
d.j . singh and w.e .
pickett , phys .
b , * 57 * , 88 ( 1998 ) .
p. ravindran , a. delin , b. johansson , o. eriksson and j.m .
wills , phys .
b , * 59 * , 1176 ( 1999 ) .
m. abbate , f. de groot , j. fuggle , a. fujimori , o. strrebel , f. lopez , m. domke , g. kaindl , g. sawatzky , m. takano , y. takeda , h. eisaki , and s. uchida , phys .
b , * 46 * , 4511 ( 1992 ) . j
park , c.t .
chen , s .- w .
cheong , w. bao , g. meigs , v. chakarian , and y.u .
idzerda , phys .
, * 76 * , 4215 ( 1996 ) .
t. saitoh , a.e .
bocquet , t. mizokawa , h. namatame , a. fujimori , m. abbate , y. takeda and m. takano , phys .
b , * 51 * , 13942 ( 1995 ) . s. bouarab , a. vega and m.a .
khan , phys .
b , * 54 * , 11271 ( 1996 ) .
h. sawada , y. morikawa , k. tarakura and n. hamada , phys .
b , * 56 * , 12154 ( 1997 ) . g. matsumoto , j. phys . soc .
jpn . , * 29 * , 606 ( 1970 ) . j.b.a.a .
elemans , b.v .
laar , k.r.v.d . veen and b.o .
looptra , j. solid state chem . , * 3 * , 238 ( 1971 ) .
goodenough , phys . rev . *
100 * , 564 ( 1955 ) . p. blaha , k. schwarz and j. luitz , wien97 , vienna university of technology , 1997 ( improved and updated unix version of the original copyrighted wien code , which was published by p. blaha , k. schwarz , p. sorantin and s.b .
trickey , comput .
phys . commun . ,
* 59 * 399 ( 1990 ) .
perdew , s. burke and m. ernzerhof , phys .
lett . , * 77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) .
wills , o. eriksson , m. alouani and d.l .
price in in _ electronic structure and physical properties of solids _ , p.148 , ed . h. dreysse , springer , berlin ( 2000 ) ; j.m .
wills and b.r .
cooper , phys .
b , * 36 * , 3809 ( 1987 ) ; d.l . price and b.r .
cooper , phys .
b , * 39 * , 4945 ( 1989 ) .
o.k . andersen , phys . rev .
b , * 12 * , 3060 ( 1975 ) . m. alouani and j.m .
wills , phys .
b , * 54 * , 2480 ( 1996 ) ; r. ahuja , s. auluck , j.m . wills , m. alouani , b. johansson and o. eriksson , phys .
b , * 55 * , 4999 ( 1997 ) .
f.j . kahn , p.s .
pershan and j.p .
remeika , phys . rev . * 186 * , 891 ( 1969 ) .
m. faraday , phil .
* 136 * , 1 ( 1846 ) .
w. reim and j. schoenes in _ ferromagnetic materials _ , eds .
buschow and e.p .
wohlfarth , elsevier , netherland , * 5 * chap.2 ( 1990 ) .
h. winter , p.j .
durham and g.m .
stocks , j. phys .
f , * 14 * , 1047 ( 1984 ) .
j. redinger , p. marksteiner and p. weinberger , z. phys .
b , * 63 * , 321 ( 1986 ) .
p. marksteiner , p. weinberger , r.c .
albers , a.m. boring and g. schadler , phys .
b , * 34 * , 6730 ( 1986 ) .
a. neckel , k. schwarz , r. eibler and p. rastl , microchim .
acta , suppl .
* 6 * , 257 ( 1975 ) .
t. arima , y. tokura and j.b .
torrance , phys .
b , * 48 * , 17006 ( 1993 ) .
j. zaanen , g.a .
sawatzky and j.w .
allen , phys .
* 55 * , 418 ( 1985 ) .
goodenough , _ magnetism and the chemical bond _ , wiley , new york ( 1963 ) .
jung , k.h .
kim , k.j .
eom , t.w .
noh , e.j .
choi , j. yu , y.s .
kwon , and y. chung , phys .
b * 55 * , 15489 ( 1997 ) .
y. okimoto , t. katsufuji , t. ishikawa , a. urushibara , t. arima , and y. tokura , phys .
* 75 * , 109 ( 1995 ) .
p. mahadevan , n. shanthi and d.d .
sarma , j. phys . condens . matter .
, * 9 * , 3129 ( 1997 ) .
n. hamada , h. sawada and k. terakura , in _ spectroscopy of mott insulators and correlation metals _ , edited by a. fujimori and y. tokura , springer - verlag , berlin ( 1995 ) .
w.c . koehler and e.o .
wollan , j. phys .
solids , * 2 * , 100 ( 1957 ) .
k. terakura , i.v .
solovyev and h. sawada , in _ advances in condensed matter science : colossal magnetoresistive oxides _ , ed .
y. tokura , gordan breach , tokyo , ( 1999 ) .
k. hirota , n. kanedo , a. nishizawa and y. endoh , j. phys .
jpn . , * 65 * , 3736 ( 1996 )
. f. moussa , m. hennion , j. rodriguez - carvajal , h. moudden , l. pinsard and a. revcolevschi , phys .
b , * 54 * , 15149 ( 1996 ) .
t. hotta , s. yunoko , m. mayr and e. dagotto , phys .
b , * 60 * , r15009 ( 1999 )
rasera and g.l .
catchen , phys .
b , * 58 * , 3218 ( 1998 ) .
a. urushibara , y. moritomo , t. arima , a. asamitsu , g. kido and y. tokura , phys .
b , * 51 * , 14103 ( 1995 ) . h. kawano , r. kajimoto , m. kubota and h. yoshizawa , phys . rev .
b , * 53 * r14709 ( 1996 ) y.r . shen , phys . rev . * 133 * , 511 ( 1964 ) . j.o .
donnell , m.s .
rzchowski , j.n .
eckstein and i. bozovic , appl .
* 72 * , 1775 ( 1998 ) .
shick , phys .
b , * 60 * , 6254 ( 1999 ) .
q. huang , a. santoro , j.w .
lynn , r.w .
erwin , j.a .
borchers , j.l .
peng and r.l .
greene , phys .
b , * 55 * , 14987 ( 1997 ) .
popma , m.g.j .
kamminga , solid state commun . , * 17 * , 1073 ( 1975 ) .
de groot , f.m .
mueller , p.g .
van engen and k.h.j .
buschow , phys .
, * 50 * , 2024 ( 1983 ) w.e.pickett and d.j.singh , j. magn .
, * 172 * , 237 ( 1997 ) .
kim , j.h .
jung and t.w .
noh , phys .
* 81 * , 1517 ( 1998 ) .
hamilton , e. l. keatley , h. l. ju , a. k. raychaudhuri , v. n. smolyaninova , and r. l. greene , phys .
b , * 54 * , 14926 ( 1996 ) .
p. ravindran _ et al .
_ , ( unpublished )
. s. yamaguchi , y. okimoto , k. ishibashi and y. tokura , phys .
b , * 58 * , 6862 ( 1998 ) .
solovyev , phys .
b , * 55 * , 8060 ( 1997 ) .
k. takenaka , k. iida , y. sawaki , s. sugai , y. moritomo and a. nakamura , j. phys .
* 68 * , 1828 ( 1999 ) .
r. mahendiran , s.k .
tiwary , a.k .
raychaudhuri , t.v .
ramakrishnan , r. mahesh , n. rangavittal , c.n.r .
rao , phys .
b , * 53 * , 3348 ( 1996 ) . g.h .
jonker , physica , * 20 * , 1118 ( 1954 ) .
z. yang , z. huang , l. ye and x. xie , phys .
b , * 60 * , 15674 ( 1999 ) .
t. mizokawa and a. fujimori , phys .
b , * 54 * , 5368 ( 1996 ) . j.h .
jung , k.h .
kim , t.w .
noh , e.j .
choi and j. yu , phys .
b , * 57 * , r11043 ( 1998 ) .
solovyev , phys .
metals and metallog . submitted ( 2001 ) .
k. takenaka , k. iida , y. sawaki , s. sugai , y. moritomo and a. nakamura , phys .
b , * 215 * , 637 ( 1999 ) .
a. chainani , m. matthew and d.d .
sarma , phys .
b , * 47 * , 15397 ( 1993 ) .
w. speier , j.c .
fuggle , r. zeller , b. ackermann , k. szot , f.u .
hillebrecht and m. campagna , phys .
b , * 32 * , 3597 ( 1985 ) .
h. kurata , e. lefevre and c. colliex , r. brydson , phys .
b , * 47 * , 13763 ( 1993 )
. m. takahashi , j. igarashi and p. fulde , j. phys .
jpn . , * 68 * , 2530 ( 1999 ) .
g. subias , j. garcia , j. blasco and m.g .
proietti , phys .
b , * 58 * , 9287 ( 1998 ) . g.m .
zhao , k. ghosh , h. keller and r.l .
greene , phys .
b , * 59 * , 81 ( 1999 ) .
billinge r. g. difrancesco , g. h. kwei , j. j. neumeier , and j. d. thompson , phys .
b , * 77 * , 715 ( 1996 )
. m. jaime m. b. salamon , m. rubinstein , r. e. treece , j. s. horwitz , and d. b. chrisey , phys .
b , * 54 * , 11914 ( 1996 ) . t.t.m .
palstra , a. p. ramirez , s - w .
cheong , b. r. zegarski p. schiffer and j. zaanen phys .
b , * 56 * , 5104 ( 1997 ) . c.h .
booth , f. bridges , g. h. kwei , j. m. lawrence , a. l. cornelius , and j. j. neumeier phys .
* 80 * , 853 ( 1998 ) .
f. bridges , c.h .
booth , g.h .
kwei , j.j .
neumeier and g.a .
sawatzky , phys .
b , * 61 * , r9237 ( 2000 ) .
m. croft , d. sills , m. greenblatt , c. lee , s .- w .
cheong , k.v .
ramanujachary and d. tran , phys .
b , * 55 * , 8726 ( 1997 ) .
m. abbate , g. zampieri , f. prado , a. caneiro , a.r.b .
castro , solid state commun .
, * 111 * , 437 ( 1999 ) . .
total energy ( relative to the lowest energy state in mev / f.u . ) for lamno@xmath0 in a- , c- , g - af , f and p states with undistorted cubic ( refered as cubic ) and orthorhombic structures .
[ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,<",options="header " , ] | the ground state and excited state properties of the perovskite lamno@xmath0 , the mother material of colossal magnetoresistance manganites , are calculated based on the generalized - gradient - corrected relativistic full - potential method .
the electronic structure , magnetism and energetics of various spin configurations for lamno@xmath0 in the ideal cubic perovskite structure and the experimentally observed distorted orthorhombic structure are obtained .
the excited state properties such as the optical , magneto - optical , x - ray photoemission ( xps ) , bremsstrahlung isochromat ( bis ) , x - ray absorption near edge structure ( xanes ) spectra are calculated and found to be in excellent agreement with available experimental results .
consistent with earlier observations the insulating behavior can be obtained only when we take into account the structural distortions and the correct antiferromagnetic ordering in the calculations .
the present results suggest that the correlation effect is not significant in lamno@xmath0 and the presence of ferromagnetic coupling within the @xmath1 plane as well as the antiferromagnetic coupling perpendicular to this plane can be explained through the itinerant band picture . as against earlier expectations ,
our calculations show that the mn 3@xmath2 @xmath3 as well as the @xmath4 electrons are present in the whole valence band region .
in particular significantly large amounts of @xmath3 electrons are present in combination with the @xmath4 electrons at the top of the valence band against the common expectation of presence of only pure @xmath4 electrons .
we have calculated the hyperfine field parameters for the a - type antiferromagnetic and the ferromagnetic phases of lamno@xmath0 and compared the findings with the available experimental results .
the role of the orthorhombic distortion on electronic structure , magnetism and optical anisotropy are analyzed . |
let @xmath2 be the euclidean ball in @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) centered at the origin with radius @xmath5 .
let @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 . consider local minimizers of the dirichlet functional @xmath9 over the closed convex set @xmath10 i.e. functions @xmath11 which satisfy @xmath12 this problem is known as the _ ( boundary ) thin obstacle problem _ or the _ ( elliptic ) signorini problem_. it was shown in @xcite that the local minimizers @xmath13 are of class @xmath14 . besides , @xmath13 will satisfy @xmath15 the boundary condition is known as the _ complementarity _ or _ signorini boundary condition_. one of the main features of the problem is that the following sets are apriori unknown : @xmath16 where by @xmath17 we understand the boundary in the relative topology of @xmath18 .
the free boundary @xmath19 sometimes is said to be _ thin _ , to indicate that it is ( expected to be ) of codimension two .
one of the most interesting questions in this problem is the study of the structure and the regularity of the free boundary @xmath19 . to put our results in a proper perspective , below we give a brief overview of some of the known results in the literature
. the proofs can be found in @xcite and in chapter 9 of @xcite .
we start by noting that we can extend solutions @xmath13 of the signorini problem to the entire ball @xmath2 in two different ways : either by even symmetry in @xmath20 variable or by odd symmetry
. the even extension will be harmonic in @xmath21 , while the odd extension will be so in @xmath22 . in a sense
, those two extensions can be viewed as two different branches of a two - valued harmonic function .
this gives a heuristic explanation for the monotonicity of almgren s _ frequency function _
@xmath23 which goes back to almgren s study of multi - valued harmonic functions @xcite
. in particular , the limiting value @xmath24 for @xmath25 turns out to be a very effective tool in classifying free boundary points . by using the monotonicity of the frequency @xmath26
, it can be shown that the rescalings @xmath27 converge , over subsequences @xmath28 , to solutions @xmath29 of the signorini problem in @xmath30 .
such limits are known as _
blowups _ of @xmath13 at @xmath31 .
moreover , it can be shown that such blowups will be homogeneous of degree @xmath32 , regardless of the sequence @xmath33 .
it is readily seen from the the definition that the mapping @xmath34 is upper semicontinuous on @xmath19 .
furthermore , it can be shown that @xmath35 for every @xmath25 and , more precisely , that the following alternative holds : @xmath36 this brings us to the notion of a regular point .
a point @xmath37 is called _ regular _ if @xmath38 . by classifying all possible homogeneous solutions of homogeneity @xmath39 ,
the above definition is equivalent to saying that the blowups of @xmath13 at @xmath31 have the form @xmath40 after a possible rotation of coordinate axes in @xmath41 . in what follows
, we will denote by @xmath42 the set of regular free boundary points , and call it the _ regular set _ of @xmath13 : @xmath43 the upper semicontinuity of @xmath44 , and the gap of values between @xmath39 and @xmath45 implies that @xmath42 is a relatively open subset of @xmath19 . besides , it is known that @xmath42 is locally a @xmath46 regular @xmath47-dimensional surface . in this paper
, we are interested in the higher regularity of @xmath42 .
since the codimension of the free boundary @xmath19 is two , this question is meaningful only when @xmath4 .
in fact , in dimension @xmath48 the complete characterization of the coincidence set and the free boundary was already found by lewy @xcite : @xmath49 is a locally finite union of closed intervals .
we will use fairly standard notations in this paper . by @xmath3
we denote the @xmath50-dimensional euclidean space of points @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 . for any @xmath54
we denote @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
we also identify @xmath57 with @xmath58 , thereby effectively embedding @xmath41 into @xmath3 .
similarly , we identify @xmath59 with @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
for @xmath62 ,
@xmath63 if @xmath31 is the origin , we will simply write @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 . let @xmath68 be the euclidean distance between two sets @xmath69 .
in this paper we are interested in local properties of the solutions and their free boundaries only near regular points and therefore , without loss of generality , we make the following assumptions .
we will assume that @xmath13 solves the signorini problem in @xmath70 and that all free boundary points in @xmath71 are regular , i.e. @xmath72 furthermore , we will assume that there exists @xmath73 with @xmath74 such that @xmath75 next we assume @xmath76 and that @xmath77 moreover , we will also assume the following nondegeneracy property for directional derivatives in a cone of tangential directions : for any @xmath78 , there exist @xmath79 and @xmath80 such that @xmath81 for any @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the unit normal in @xmath41 to @xmath19 at @xmath31 outward to @xmath49 and @xmath84 for a unit vector @xmath85 .
we explicitly remark that if @xmath13 is a solution to the signorini problem , then the assumptions - hold at any regular free boundary point after a possible translation , rotation and rescaling of @xmath13 ( see e.g. @xcite , @xcite ) . following the approach of kinderlehrer and nirenberg @xcite in the classical obstacle problem , we will use the partial hodograph - legendre transformation method to improve on the known regularity of the free boundary .
the idea is to straighten the free boundary and then apply the boundary regularity of the solution to the transformed elliptic pde .
this works relatively simply for the classical obstacle problem , and allows to prove @xmath86 regularity and even the real analyticity of the free boundary . in the signorini problem ,
the free boundary @xmath19 is of codimension two , and in order to straighten both @xmath19 and @xmath49 we need to make a partial hodograph transform in two variables .
namely , for @xmath13 satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] , consider the transformation @xmath87 consider also the associated partial legendre transform of @xmath13 given by @xmath88 formally , the inverse of @xmath89 is given by @xmath90 and we can recover the free boundary in the following way : @xmath91 however , we note that the mapping @xmath89 is only @xmath0 regular and even the local invertibility of such mapping is rather nontrivial . besides , even if one has a local invertibility of @xmath89 , the function @xmath92 will satisfy a degenerate elliptic equation , and apriori it is not clear if the equation will have enough structure to be useful .
concerning the first complication , we make a careful asymptotic analysis based the precise knowledge of the blowups , and this does allow to establish the local invertibility of @xmath89 .
[ thm : t - invert ] let @xmath13 be a solution of the signorini problem in @xmath70 , satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] .
then , there exists a small @xmath93 such that the partial hodograph transformation @xmath89 in is injective in @xmath94 .
then via an asymptotic analysis of @xmath92 at the straightened free boundary points , we observe that the fully nonlinear degenerate elliptic equation for @xmath92 has a subelliptic structure , which can be viewed as a perturbation of the baouendi - grushin operator . then using the @xmath1 theory for the baouendi - grushin operator and a bootstrapping argument
, we obtain the smoothness and even the real analyticity of @xmath92 .
[ thm : fb - regul ] let @xmath13 be as in theorem [ thm : t - invert ] and @xmath92 be given by
. then exists @xmath95 such that the mapping @xmath96 is real analytic on @xmath97 .
in particular , @xmath98 is locally an analytic surface .
the signorini problem is just one example of a problem with thin free boundaries .
many problems with thin free boundaries arise when studying problems for the fractional laplacian and using the caffarelli - silvestre extension @xcite to localize the problem at the expense of adding an extra dimension ( which makes the free boundary `` thin '' ) .
thus , the signorini problem can be viewed as an obstacle problem for half - laplacian , see @xcite .
we hope that the methods in this paper can be used to study the higher regularity of the free boundary in many such problems .
a different approach to the study of the higher regularity of thin free boundaries is being developed by de silva and savin @xcite . in particular , in @xcite they prove the @xmath86 regularity of @xmath99 free boundaries in the thin analogue of alt - caffarelli minimization problem @xcite . their method is based on schauder - type estimates rather than hodograph - legendre transform used in this paper . at about the same time as we completed this work , de silva and savin @xcite extended their approach to include the signorini problem , as well as lowered the initial regularity assumption on the free boundary to @xmath46 .
the main ingredient in their proof is an interesting new higher order boundary harnack principle , applicable to regular , as well as slit domains ( see also @xcite ) .
the paper is organized as follows : - in section [ sec : nond - prop ] we study the so - called @xmath39-homogeneous blowups of the solutions near regular points .
this is achieved by a combination a boundary hopf - type principle in domains with @xmath46 slits , as well as weiss- and monneau - type monotonicity formulas . - in section [ sec : hodograph ] we introduce the partial hodograph transformation and show it is a homeomorphism in a neighborhood of the regular free boundary points .
this is achieved by using the precise behavior of the solutions near regular free boundary points established in section [ sec : nond - prop ] . - in section [ sec : legendre - funct - nonl ] we consider the corresponding legendre transform @xmath92 and show some basic regularity of @xmath92 inherited from @xmath13 . - in section [ sec : smoothness ] we study the fully nonlinear pde satisfied by @xmath92 , which is the transformed pde of @xmath13 .
we show the linearization of the pde is a perturbation of the baouendi - grushin operator . using the @xmath1 estimates available for this operator , and a bootstrapping argument
, we obtain the smoothness of @xmath92 , which in turn implies the smoothness of the free boundary . - in section [ sec : analyticity ] , we give more careful estimates on the derivatives of @xmath92 which imply that @xmath92 , and consequently @xmath19 , is real analytic .
we start our study by establishing a stronger nondegeneracy property for the tangential derivatives @xmath100 than the one given in .
namely , we want to improve the lower bound in to a multiple of @xmath101 . to achieve this
, we construct a barrier function by using the @xmath46-regularity of @xmath19 , to obtain a result that can be viewed as a version of the boundary hopf lemma for the domains of the type @xmath102 .
to proceed , we introduce some notations . for @xmath103 ,
let @xmath104 [ lem : hopf - barrier ] there exists a continuous function @xmath105 on @xmath106 and a small @xmath107 such that @xmath108 and @xmath109 inspired by the construction in @xcite , we will show that the following function satisfies the conditions of the lemma : @xmath110 we next verify each of the properties in the lemma . first of all , is immediate .
next , since @xmath111 , we have @xmath112 therefore , on @xmath113 one has @xmath114 hence there exists @xmath107 such that @xmath115 on @xmath116 . this implies .
further , to show , notice that @xmath117 which yields @xmath118 for small @xmath119 , as claimed .
next , we show .
it is easy to check that @xmath120 and @xmath121 satisfy @xmath122 @xmath123 combining , we obtain that for @xmath124 @xmath125 \\\geq\frac{1}{2}\left(\hat f''_\alpha(u)+(2n-3)\frac{\hat f'_\alpha(u)}{u}\right)-\frac{1}{2}\left(\hat f''_\alpha(|x|^{1/2})+(2n-3)\frac{\hat f'_\alpha(|x|^{1/2})}{|x|^{1/2}}\right).\end{gathered}\ ] ] since @xmath126 and @xmath127 is decreasing on @xmath128 , then by we have @xmath129 in @xmath130 .
this shows .
finally , by , we have @xmath131 this completes the proof of the lemma . using the function constructed in lemma [ lem : hopf - barrier ] as a barrier
, we have the improvement of the nondegeneracy for nonnegative harmonic functions in @xmath130 .
[ cor : hopf1 ] let @xmath132 be a nonnegative superharmonic function in @xmath130 , @xmath133 and @xmath134 on @xmath135 .
moreover , suppose that @xmath132 satisfies @xmath136 then there exists @xmath137 and @xmath138 such that @xmath139 let @xmath140 and @xmath119 be as in lemma [ lem : hopf - barrier ] .
then by and the continuity of @xmath140 , there exists @xmath141 such that @xmath142 which combined with gives that @xmath143 then , by the maximum principle @xmath144 in particular , @xmath145 for @xmath146 with @xmath107 small . from lemma [ cor : hopf1 ]
, we obtain the following nondegeneracy property for the tangential derivatives of the solution to the elliptic signorini problem .
[ prop : hopf ] let @xmath13 be a solution to the elliptic signorini problem in @xmath70 satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] . then for each @xmath82 and @xmath78 , there exist @xmath147 depending on @xmath148 , such that @xmath149 for each @xmath82 , we can rotate a coordinate system in @xmath41 so that @xmath150
. then we have @xmath151 where @xmath152 since @xmath13 is harmonic in @xmath153 and @xmath154 satisfies the nondegeneracy condition , then @xmath100 satisfies the assumptions of lemma [ cor : hopf1 ] , with a small difference that there is constant @xmath155 in the definition of the set @xmath156 above .
however , by a simple scaling , we can make @xmath157 .
thus , there exists @xmath158 and @xmath159 such that holds . for our further study
, we need to consider the following rescalings @xmath160 with @xmath37 .
note that these are different form rescalings in the sense that the @xmath161 norm of @xmath13 is not preserved under the rescaling , but it is better suited for the study of regular points .
first , from the growth estimate ( see e.g. @xcite ) @xmath162 for @xmath82 , where @xmath163 and @xmath164 , we know that the family @xmath165 is locally uniformly bounded . moreover , by the interior @xmath166 estimate ( see e.g. @xcite ) @xmath167 we get that @xmath165 is uniformly bounded in @xmath168 .
thus there exists @xmath169 such that @xmath170 in @xmath171 , for any @xmath172 over a certain subsequence @xmath173 .
it is also immediate to see that @xmath174 is a global solution of the signorini problem , i.e. , a solution of in @xmath30 .
furthermore , it is important to note that @xmath174 is nonzero , because of the nondegeneracy provided by proposition [ prop : hopf ] .
sometimes we will refer to the function @xmath175 as the _
@xmath39-homogeneous blowup _ to indicate the way it was obtained . the following weiss - type monotonicity formula
, whose proof can be found in @xcite , implies that @xmath174 is a homogeneous global solution of the signorini problem of degree @xmath39 .
[ lem : weiss ] let @xmath13 be a nonzero solution of the signorini problem in @xmath176
. for any @xmath25 and @xmath177 define @xmath178 then @xmath179 is nondecreasing in @xmath180 .
moreover , for a.e.@xmath181 we have @xmath182 furthermore , @xmath183 for @xmath184 if and only if @xmath13 is homogeneous of degree @xmath39 with respect to @xmath31 in @xmath185 , i.e. @xmath186 [ rem : weiss ] the weiss - type monotonicity formula above is specifically adjusted to work with rescalings .
namely , by a simple change of variables , one can show that @xmath187 besides , by the definition of regular points , we also have that @xmath188 since @xmath189 . [ prop : unique ] let @xmath13 be a solution of the signorini problem in @xmath70 , satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] .
then there exist two positive constants @xmath190 and @xmath191 , depending only on @xmath13 such that if @xmath192 and that @xmath193 over a sequence @xmath28 , then @xmath194 with a constant @xmath195 satisfying @xmath196 we have already noticed at the beginning of section [ sec : blowups ] that @xmath175 is a nonzero global solution of the signorini problem .
besides , by the weiss - type monotonicity formula , we will have @xmath197 for any @xmath198 .
hence , by lemma [ lem : weiss ] , @xmath175 is a homogeneous of degree @xmath39 in @xmath199 .
then , by proposition 9.9 in @xcite , we must have the form @xmath200 for some @xmath201 and a tangential unit vector @xmath202 .
we claim that @xmath203 .
indeed , we have @xmath204 provided @xmath205 so that @xmath206 . passing to the limit @xmath207 , we therefore have @xmath208 hence ,
for any @xmath78 @xmath209 this is possible only if @xmath203 .
thus , we have the claimed representation @xmath210 the estimates on constant @xmath195 now follow from the growth estimate and the nondegeneracy proposition [ prop : hopf ] , which are preserved under the @xmath39-homogeneous blowup .
[ rem : unique ] this proposition also holds for the rescaling family with varying centers : @xmath211 where @xmath212 , @xmath213 and @xmath214 .
indeed , by lemma [ lem : weiss ] we have @xmath215 hence applying dini s theorem form the classical analysis to the family of monotone continuous functions @xmath216 on the compact set @xmath217 , we have that the above convergence is uniform on @xmath217 . hence passing to the limit @xmath218 ,
we obtain @xmath219 for any @xmath198 . arguing as in proposition [ prop : unique ] , we conclude that @xmath220 . in order to get the uniqueness of the blowup limit , we need to show that the constant @xmath195 in proposition [ prop : unique ] does not depend on the subsequence @xmath221 but only depends on @xmath31 .
this is a consequence of the following monneau - type monotonicity formula @xcite . without apriori knowledge on the free boundary ,
this formula is known to hold only at so - called singular points , i.e. , @xmath37 with @xmath222 , @xmath223 .
however , using the @xmath46 regularity of the free boundary , we will be able to establish this result also at regular points .
[ lem : monneau ] let @xmath13 be a solution of the signorini problem in @xmath70 , satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] . for any @xmath224 , @xmath164 , and a positive constant @xmath225 , we define @xmath226 where @xmath227 then there exists a constant @xmath228 which depends on the @xmath46 norm of @xmath229 , @xmath191 in , @xmath225 , and @xmath230 , such that @xmath231 is monotone nondecreasing for @xmath232 . for simplicity
we assume @xmath233 and write @xmath234 , @xmath235 . letting @xmath236 and using the scaling properties of @xmath237
, we have @xmath238 next , we compute the weiss energy functional @xmath239 by remark [ rem : weiss ] , @xmath240 hence @xmath241 an integration by parts gives @xmath242 noticing that @xmath243 we have @xmath244 similarly , integrating by parts and using @xmath245 in @xmath65 , we obtain @xmath246 combining , we have @xmath247 since @xmath175 is homogeneous of degree @xmath39 , the second integral above is zero . moreover , using @xmath248 on @xmath66 , we have the third integral is equal to @xmath249 recalling , we have @xmath250 noticing that @xmath251 for @xmath164 by lemma [ lem : weiss ] and @xmath252 , @xmath253 on @xmath254 , we have @xmath255 using the growth estimate for @xmath13 and explicit expression for @xmath175 , we have @xmath256 since the free boundary @xmath257 is a @xmath46 graph and @xmath258 , we have @xmath259 where @xmath260 is a constant depending on @xmath261 .
hence @xmath262 which implies the claim of the lemma with @xmath263
. we can now establish the main result of this section .
[ prop : uni ] let @xmath13 be a solution of the signorini problem in @xmath70 , satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] .
then for @xmath224 , there exists a constant @xmath264 such that @xmath265 where @xmath266 moreover , the function @xmath267 is continuous on @xmath268 . furthermore , for any @xmath269 and @xmath5 , @xmath270 we first show @xmath271 does not depend on the converging sequences .
given @xmath82 , let @xmath272 be a converging sequence such that @xmath273 in @xmath171 for some @xmath271 satisfying @xmath274 . by lemma [ lem : monneau ] , the mapping @xmath275 is nonnegative , monotone nondecreasing on @xmath276 , hence @xmath277 this implies @xmath271 does not depend on the converging sequences @xmath272 .
next we show that @xmath271 depends continuously on @xmath278 .
fix @xmath82 .
for any @xmath279 , let @xmath280 be such that @xmath281 for @xmath282 fixed , by the continuity of @xmath13 we have @xmath283 is continuous on @xmath284 .
moreover , from the explicit formulation of @xmath285 as well as the @xmath286 continuity of @xmath287 , the function @xmath288 is continuous .
therefore , there exists a positive @xmath289 small enough , such that for all @xmath290 with @xmath291 , @xmath292 for @xmath293 , by lemma [ lem : monneau ] @xmath294 let @xmath295 in , then @xmath296 by the explicit expression of @xmath285 , there is a constant @xmath297 such that @xmath298 for any @xmath299 .
this together with gives @xmath300 this shows the continuity of @xmath267 .
finally , we show .
in fact , @xmath301 is continuous on the compact set @xmath217 and it monotonically decreases to zero as @xmath302 decreases to zero for each @xmath31 .
hence by dini s theorem , @xmath303 as @xmath295 uniformly on @xmath217 . thus one has @xmath304
it is not hard to see that @xmath305 are subharmonic in @xmath106 ( after the even reflection of @xmath13 about @xmath20 ) .
hence by the @xmath306 estimates for the subharmonic functions we have @xmath307 by an interpolation of hlder spaces , i.e. for some absolute constant @xmath308 , @xmath309 for @xmath310 and @xmath311 , as well as a rescaling argument we obtain .
the continuous dependence on @xmath31 of @xmath271 gives the uniqueness of the blowups with varying centers .
[ cor : varicenter ] let @xmath13 be a solution of the signorini problem in @xmath70 , satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] .
let @xmath312 , such that @xmath313 as @xmath218 .
let @xmath207 as @xmath218 .
then for any @xmath310 and @xmath314 defined in theorem [ prop : uni ] , @xmath315 this follows from the uniform continuity of @xmath316 and theorem [ prop : uni ] .
let @xmath13 be a solution of the signorini problem in @xmath70 satisfying the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] .
following the idea in the classical obstacle problem @xcite , we would like to use the method of partial hodograph - legendre transforms to study the higher regularity of the free boundary in the signorini problem .
since @xmath19 has codimension two , the most natural hodograph transformation to consider is the one with respect to variable @xmath317 and @xmath20 : @xmath318 ( the reader can easily check that if we do the partial hodograph transform in @xmath317 variable only , it will still straighten @xmath19 , however , the image of @xmath319 will not have a flat boundary and this will render this transformation rather useless . ) by doing so , we hope that there exists a small neighborhood @xmath320 of the origin , such that @xmath89 is one - to - one on @xmath321 .
however , due to the @xmath166 regularity of @xmath13 , the mapping @xmath89 is only @xmath0 near the origin .
hence the simple inverse function theorem ( which typically requires the transformation @xmath89 to be from class @xmath322 ) can not be applied here . instead
, we will make use of the blowup profiles , which contain enough information to catch the behavior of the solution near the free boundary points . before stating the main results , we make several observations .
a. by the assumptions in section [ sec : assumptions ] , @xmath323 in @xmath324 and @xmath325 on @xmath254 .
this together with the complementary boundary condition gives us @xmath326 + ( 300,163)(25,0 ) ( 0,0 ) .
shown for even extension of @xmath13 in @xmath20 variable.,title="fig : " ] ( 55,90 ) ( 90,85)@xmath327 ( 188,0 ) . shown for even extension of @xmath13 in @xmath20 variable.,title="fig : " ] ( 226,120)@xmath328 ( 240,85)@xmath329 ( 130,120)@xmath330^{t}_{\substack{y''=x''\\y_{n-1}=u_{x_{n-1}}\\y_n = u_{x_n } } } & & } $ ] b. if we extend @xmath13 across @xmath331 to @xmath106 by the even symmetry or odd symmetry in @xmath20 , then the resulting function will satisfy @xmath332 hence @xmath13 is analytic in @xmath333 . from , @xmath89 is also analytic in @xmath333 . c. to better understand the nature of @xmath89 , consider the solution @xmath334 of the signorini problem and find an explicit formula for @xmath335 .
a simple computation shows that using complex notations the mapping @xmath335 is given by @xmath336 where by the latter we understand the appropriate branch . loosely speaking
, this tells that @xmath89 behaves like @xmath337 function in the last two variables .
+ the observation above also suggests us to compose @xmath89 with the mapping @xmath338 which can be expressed , by using complex notations ( denote @xmath339 by @xmath132 ) , as @xmath340 more explicitly , alongside @xmath89 , we consider the transformation @xmath341 @xmath342 now @xmath343 maps @xmath344 to the upper half space @xmath345 and @xmath254 to the hyperplane @xmath346 .
moreover , @xmath343 straightens the free boundary @xmath19 as @xmath89 and satisfies @xmath347
d. the advantage of @xmath343 is that by arguing as in ( ii ) above and making odd and even extensions of @xmath13 in @xmath20 , we can extend it to a mapping on @xmath106 .
moreover , this extension will be the same in both cases ( unlike for the mapping @xmath89 ) .
in particular , this makes @xmath343 a single - valued mapping on @xmath106 , which is real analytic in @xmath348 . in what follows , we will prove the injectivity of @xmath343 in a neighborhood of the origin .
for that we will need the make the following direct computations .
( 338,163)(25,0 ) ( 0,0),title="fig : " ] ( 55,90 ) ( 90,85)@xmath327 ( 188,0),title="fig : " ] ( 243,90 ) ( 278,85)@xmath349 ( 138,120)@xmath330^{t_1}_{\substack{w''=x''\\w_{n-1}=u_{x_{n-1}}^2-u_{x_n}^2\\w_n=-2u_{x_{n-1 } } u_{x_n } } } & & } $ ] [ prop : computeu0 ] let @xmath350 be given by @xmath351 for @xmath352 , @xmath353 $ ] .
then we have the following identities @xmath354 direct computation .
from now on , we will use a slightly different notation from theorem [ prop : uni ] to denote the blowup limit , i.e. for @xmath355 , we let @xmath356 the following proposition is a consequence of theorem [ prop : uni ] and the @xmath357 regularity of @xmath229 .
[ prop : uniformity2 ] for any @xmath279 , there exists @xmath358 depending on @xmath359 and @xmath13 , such that for all @xmath360 and @xmath361 , we have : 1 .
@xmath362 ; + 2 .
@xmath363 has a harmonic extension at any @xmath364 with @xmath365 ( by making even or odd reflection about @xmath20 ) .
hence if we let @xmath366 then for any multi - index @xmath367 with @xmath368 we have @xmath369 \(i ) given any @xmath279 , by there is a positive constant @xmath370 depending on @xmath13 such that for any @xmath371 , @xmath372 on the other hand , there exists @xmath373 depending on @xmath359 , modulus of continuity of @xmath271 and @xmath46 norm of @xmath229 such that @xmath374 taking @xmath375 we proved ( i ) .
\(ii ) we observe that for small enough @xmath302 and @xmath376 , the rescaled free boundary @xmath377 satisfies @xmath378 when @xmath379 .
this follows immediately from the assumption @xmath380 .
the rest of ( ii ) then follows from the estimates for the higher order derivatives of harmonic functions .
the next proposition is a consequence of proposition [ prop : computeu0 ] and proposition [ prop : uniformity2 ] , which is useful to understand the transformation @xmath89 .
since @xmath89 fixes the first @xmath381 coordinates , it is more convenient to work on a `` tubular '' neighborhood of @xmath19 defined as follows : first we consider the projection map @xmath382 since @xmath383 , @xmath384 is continuous in @xmath106 .
moreover , it is easy to verify that for some constant @xmath385 , @xmath386 next for @xmath387 , we let @xmath388 @xmath389 by the continuity of @xmath384 and , @xmath390 is a tubular neighborhood of the part of the free boundary @xmath19 lying in @xmath391 . [
prop : square ] given any @xmath279 , let @xmath392 be the same constant as in proposition [ prop : uniformity2 ] .
then for any @xmath393 , we have @xmath394 \(i ) first we observe that latexmath:[\[\label{eq : ob1 } for @xmath393 , let @xmath396 applying proposition [ prop : uniformity2](i ) to @xmath397 we have , @xmath398 , @xmath399 together with implies @xmath400 rescaling back to @xmath13 and using , we obtain ( i ) .
\(ii ) the proof of ( ii ) is similar to that of ( i ) . in @xmath401
, @xmath89 is a smooth mapping , and @xmath402 given @xmath403 , consider @xmath397 and rescaled point @xmath404 as above . by proposition [ prop : uniformity2](ii )
, @xmath405 this together with the explicit expression for @xmath406 in proposition [ prop : computeu0 ] gives @xmath407 it is easy to check the following rescaling property @xmath408 this combined with gives ( ii ) .
now we are ready to prove the main theorem of the section .
let @xmath409 [ thm : injective ] there exists a small constant @xmath95 , such that @xmath89 is a homeomorphism from @xmath410 to @xmath411 , which is relatively open in @xmath412 .
moreover , if we extend @xmath89 to @xmath413 via the even ( odd ) reflection of @xmath13 about @xmath20 , then it is a diffeomorphism from @xmath414 ( @xmath415 ) onto an open subset in @xmath3 . by observation ( iii ) and
( iv ) , instead of @xmath89 , we consider the map @xmath416 which is first defined in @xmath417 as and then extended to @xmath106 via even or odd reflection of @xmath13 in @xmath20 variable
. we will first show @xmath343 is a homeomorphism from @xmath390 to @xmath418 for sufficiently small @xmath419 .
this is divided into three steps .
_ there exists @xmath95 , such that for any @xmath360 and @xmath420 , @xmath421 is injective in @xmath422 . here
@xmath423 in fact , by proposition
[ prop : uniformity2 ] and the definition of @xmath343 , for any @xmath279 , there exists @xmath424 such that @xmath425 from proposition [ prop : computeu0 ] , @xmath426 is a nondegenerate linear map .
hence if we take @xmath427 sufficiently small , @xmath428 will be injective on the compact set @xmath422 .
_ @xmath343 is injective in @xmath390 for @xmath419 chosen as above .
it is clear that @xmath343 is injective on @xmath19 , since it maps @xmath429 to @xmath61 .
thus , it will be sufficient if we show the injectivity of @xmath343 in @xmath430 .
indeed , suppose there exist @xmath431 such that @xmath432 .
necessarily @xmath433 .
let @xmath434 , @xmath435 , @xmath436 and w.l.o.g assume @xmath437 .
a simple rescaling gives @xmath438 on the other hand , @xmath432 implies @xmath439 then recalling , by proposition [ prop : square](i ) for small enough @xmath359 ( by choosing @xmath419 small in step 1 ) one has @xmath440 note that @xmath441 and @xmath442 have first @xmath381 coordinates equal to zero , thus @xmath443 . but this contradicts the injectivity of @xmath444 on @xmath422 obtained in step 1 .
_ @xmath343 is a homeomorphism from @xmath390 to @xmath418 .
now @xmath445 is an injective map .
moreover , it is continuous because of the continuity of @xmath446 .
thus by the brouwer invariance of domain theorem @xmath418 is open and @xmath343 is a homeomorphism between @xmath390 and @xmath418 .
now we proceed to show @xmath447 is a homeomorphism for @xmath419 chosen as above . indeed , recalling @xmath448 we obtain the injectivity of @xmath89 from the injectivity of @xmath343 .
next we note that @xmath449 is injective in @xmath412 , which contains @xmath450 by observation ( i ) , thus @xmath451 for any subset @xmath452 .
thus , @xmath89 is an open map from @xmath453 to @xmath412 , since @xmath343 is open and @xmath449 is continuous . combining with the continuity of @xmath89
, we obtain that @xmath89 is an homeomorphism from @xmath453 to @xmath454 .
finally , we notice that @xmath89 is smooth on @xmath414 ( or @xmath455 ) after even ( or odd ) extension of @xmath13 about @xmath20 .
moreover , by proposition [ prop : square](ii ) , @xmath456 is nonvanishing there for sufficiently small @xmath419 .
hence @xmath89 is a diffeomorphism by the implicit function theorem .
( 200,200 ) ( 0,134 ) and extension of @xmath89.,title="fig : " ] ( 134,134 ) and extension of @xmath89.,title="fig : " ] ( 90,180)@xmath457^t & } $ ] ( 90,160)@xmath458^{t^{-1}}}$ ] ( -25,170)@xmath459 ( 0,67 ) and extension of @xmath89.,title="fig : " ] ( 120,67 ) and extension of @xmath89.,title="fig : " ] ( 90,110)@xmath457^t & } $ ] ( 90,90)@xmath458^{t^{-1}}}$ ] ( -25,100)@xmath460 ( 0,0 ) and extension of @xmath89.,title="fig : " ] ( 120,0 ) and extension of @xmath89.,title="fig : " ] ( 90,40)@xmath457^t & } $ ] ( 90,20)@xmath458^{t^{-1}}}$ ] ( -7,30)@xmath461 ( 200,30)@xmath462 next we construct a space @xmath461 by gluing two copies of @xmath453 , @xmath463 together properly and extend @xmath13 as well as @xmath89 to @xmath461 . the advantage of doing this is
, the straightened free boundary @xmath464 will be contained in @xmath465 , which is an open neighborhood of the origin in @xmath3 .
this transfers the boundary singularity into the interior singularity , which will be easier for us to deal with .
more precisely , we fix the @xmath419 chosen in theorem [ thm : injective ] and consider @xmath466 , a family of subsets in @xmath3 , where @xmath467 define @xmath468 as follows : @xmath469 , where @xmath13 is the solution to the signorini problem satisfying the assumptions in the introduction ; @xmath470 is the even reflection of @xmath13 about @xmath20 ; @xmath471 and @xmath472 .
let @xmath473 be the corresponding partial hodograph - legendre transform defined in .
consider the disjoint union of @xmath474 : @xmath475 , and denote the elements of it by @xmath476 for @xmath477 , @xmath478 .
define @xmath479 now we define an equivalence relation on @xmath480 as follows : @xmath481 it is easy to check from the definition of @xmath482 and theorem [ thm : injective ] that this equivalence relation identifies the points @xmath476 and @xmath483 if ( i ) @xmath484 , @xmath485 or @xmath486 ; ( ii ) @xmath487 , @xmath488 or @xmath489 . in particular , for @xmath490 , @xmath476 and @xmath483 are identified for all @xmath491 .
let @xmath492 denote the quotient space .
consider on @xmath461 : @xmath493 it is immediate that @xmath494 is continuous and injective .
moreover , it is open from @xmath461 to @xmath3 by theorem [ thm : injective ] and the special way we glue @xmath474 .
hence we obtain that @xmath494 is a homeomorphism from @xmath461 to @xmath495 .
in particular , @xmath495 is an open neighborhood of the origin in @xmath3 , which contains the straightened free boundary @xmath464 .
we still denote the set @xmath496 by @xmath19 .
it is not hard to observe that @xmath497 is a double cover of @xmath498 with the covering map @xmath499 .
hence @xmath497 can be given a smooth structure which makes @xmath500 into a local diffeomorphism .
in the local coordinate charts @xmath501 , we have @xmath502 , where @xmath13 is the extended function via the even or odd reflection about @xmath49 or @xmath327 , hence @xmath503 is continuous on @xmath461 , smooth in @xmath497 and @xmath504 there .
similarly , one can compute @xmath505 , which is a diffeomorphism on @xmath506 by theorem [ thm : injective ] ( apply theorem [ thm : injective ] for the extended @xmath13 ) .
this shows that @xmath507 is a diffeomorphism .
from now on , with slight abuse of the notation we will still denote @xmath503 by @xmath13 and @xmath494 by @xmath89 . in the following
, we will simply write @xmath508 , @xmath509 , etc . while having in mind that we are taking the derivatives in the local coordinates .
in this section we study the partial legendre transform of @xmath13 and the fully nonlinear pde it satisfies . we let @xmath510 which is an open neighborhood of the origin and @xmath511 be the straightened free boundary . for @xmath512
, we define the partial legendre transform of @xmath13 by the identity @xmath513 where @xmath514 .
it is immediate to check the following properties of @xmath92 : a. @xmath92 is odd about @xmath515 and even about @xmath516 .
b. @xmath92 is continuous in @xmath517 , smooth in @xmath518 and @xmath519 on @xmath520 . c. a direct computation shows that in @xmath521 @xmath522 hence @xmath523 can be written as @xmath524 the jacobian matrix of @xmath92 is then @xmath525 where @xmath526 since @xmath527 and its differential has an continuous extension to @xmath19 , this together with the continuity of @xmath523 and imply that @xmath528 .
d. the restriction of @xmath523 to @xmath529 is given by @xmath530 which gives a local parametrization of the free boundary @xmath19 .
thus , the regularity of the free boundary is directly related to the regularity of @xmath531 , restricted to @xmath529 .
a direct computation using and shows that @xmath532 @xmath533 since @xmath534 in @xmath535 , the legendre function @xmath92 satisfies the following fully nonlinear equation in @xmath536 @xmath537 multiplying both sides of by @xmath538 we can write it in the form @xmath539 which can be further rewritten as @xmath540 where @xmath541 , @xmath542 , is the @xmath543 matrix @xmath544 in order to study the asymptotic of higher derivatives of @xmath92 at the straightened free boundary @xmath529 , we study the blowup of @xmath92 at points on @xmath520 .
let @xmath545 be the legendre function of @xmath314 as in , where @xmath546 .
it is not hard to compute that @xmath547 where @xmath548 is the unit outer normal of @xmath49 at @xmath31 . in particular , at the origin , @xmath549 for @xmath550 and @xmath62 , we consider the non - isotropic dilation @xmath551 and the rescaling at @xmath552 ( note @xmath553 ) @xmath554 from , and , one can easily check that @xmath555 here rescaling family @xmath556 and @xmath557 are defined on @xmath558 , where @xmath559 are the topological spaces obtained by gluing four rescaled copies @xmath560 together as in the construction of @xmath461 .
to study the convergence of @xmath561 to @xmath545 , we first show a lemma which concerns about in the local coordinate charts the uniform convergence of @xmath562 to @xmath563 .
the following two facts are easy to verify : a. @xmath557 is bijective and @xmath564 , where @xmath565 is the non - isotropic dilation in . in particular , we have @xmath566 . b. let @xmath567 and let @xmath568 then for any sufficiently small @xmath302 and @xmath569 , we have @xmath570 , i.e.
@xmath557 always maps the copy @xmath571 into the corresponding `` quarter '' domain @xmath572 .
let @xmath573 with @xmath574 denote the restriction of the covering map to @xmath575 .
[ lem : dilation ] let @xmath576 and @xmath577 .
then @xmath578 uniformly in any compact subset @xmath579 , @xmath580 .
moreover , this convergence is also uniform for @xmath552 varying in a compact subset of @xmath529 . given @xmath576 and a compact set @xmath581 , by ( i ) and ( ii ) above , there is a positive @xmath582 , such that @xmath583 for any @xmath584 . by the rescaled version of proposition [ prop : uniformity2](i )
, there exists @xmath585 small such that @xmath586 , which is a bounded subset in @xmath3 , for any @xmath587 . we know from the @xmath588 convergence of @xmath556 to @xmath314 that @xmath589 moreover , the limit @xmath590 is continuous on @xmath572 by a direct computation . therefore , @xmath591 uniformly in @xmath592 . by theorem [ prop : uni ] and the continuous dependence of @xmath563 on @xmath31
, we have the above convergence is uniform for @xmath552 in any compact subset of @xmath529 .
next we show the following compactness results .
[ prop : compact - v ] let @xmath592 be a compact subset in @xmath593 .
then for any multi - index @xmath230 , @xmath594 uniformly in @xmath592 .
moreover , the above convergence is also uniform for @xmath552 varying in a compact subset of @xmath529 . given @xmath576 , let @xmath595 .
for @xmath596 and @xmath597 , using and , we can easily conclude from lemma [ lem : dilation ] together with the uniform convergence of @xmath556 to @xmath314 that , @xmath598 converges to @xmath599 uniformly in @xmath592 . for @xmath600 ,
using and one can express @xmath598 in terms of @xmath601 with @xmath602 , i.e. for fixed @xmath230 , @xmath603 where @xmath604 is some polynomial . for @xmath605 compact , @xmath606 is also compact and @xmath607 . by the local uniform convergence of @xmath562 to @xmath563 ( lemma [ lem : dilation ] ) as well as the flatness of the free boundary @xmath608 ( i.e. the hausdorff distance between @xmath609 and @xmath608 goes to zero as @xmath302 goes to zero ) , there exists @xmath610 compact and @xmath611 small , such that for all @xmath612 , we have @xmath613 and @xmath614 note that implies that for any @xmath612 and @xmath580 , @xmath615 are harmonic in @xmath616 . thus for any multi - index @xmath230 , we have @xmath617 uniformly in @xmath616 . this combined with , and lemma [ lem : dilation ] gives the conclusion .
due to theorem [ prop : uni ] and lemma [ lem : dilation ] , the above convergence is uniform in @xmath552 varying the compact subset of @xmath529 . from proposition [ prop : compact - v ] one can get continuous extension of higher order ( properly weighted ) derivatives of @xmath92 at @xmath529 .
[ cor : extension ] for each @xmath576 , @xmath577 , we extend the following functions to @xmath552 by setting @xmath618 then after such extension the above functions are continuous on @xmath517 . the proof is based on the following two facts ( a ) ( b ) and a blowup argument .
\(a ) for @xmath619 , @xmath620 , @xmath621 \(b ) from the @xmath46 regularity of @xmath19 and the explicit expression of @xmath545 , we have the map @xmath622 is continuous from @xmath529 to @xmath623 , where @xmath624 compact .
this together with proposition [ prop : compact - v ] gives that for any multi - index @xmath230 @xmath625 we proceed to show the extended functions are continuous at @xmath576 .
first they are continuous on @xmath529 from the @xmath286 dependence of @xmath83 on @xmath31 .
next for @xmath626 , we use @xmath627 to denote @xmath628 and let @xmath629 then @xmath630 as @xmath631 , we have @xmath295 and @xmath632 .
thus by ( b ) above , for a fixed @xmath624 , which is compact and contains the set @xmath633 , we have @xmath634 from the explicit expression of @xmath545 ( see ) we have @xmath635 this together with ( a ) and gives ( i)-(iv ) .
in this section we show the fully nonlinear equation @xmath636 in has a subelliptic structure in @xmath462 .
let @xmath637 be the space of @xmath638 symmetric matrices and we may consider @xmath639 as a smooth function on @xmath637 .
let @xmath640 for @xmath641 be the linearization of @xmath639 at @xmath642 .
a direct computation shows that for @xmath643 and @xmath644 , the linearization of @xmath639 at @xmath645 has the form @xmath646 observe that one can write @xmath647 , with @xmath648 and @xmath649 symmetric matrices of the following forms : @xmath650 @xmath651 where @xmath652 with @xmath653 for @xmath654 , and for @xmath655 , @xmath656 note that @xmath657 is smooth in @xmath658 due to the smoothness of @xmath92 there .
moreover , by corollary [ cor : extension](iii)(iv ) and the intermediate value theorem , @xmath659 thus @xmath657 has a continuous extension on @xmath520 . in particular , @xmath660 hence , @xmath657 is positive definite in a small neighborhood of the origin , which implies that the linearized operator @xmath661 has a subelliptic structure near the origin . moreover , using we have @xmath662 which is the coefficient matrix for the _ baouendi - grushin type operator _ :
@xmath663 this indicates us to view the linearization of @xmath639 in a neighborhood of the origin as a perturbation of baouendi - grushin type operator .
we first recall the classical @xmath1 estimate for the baouendi - grushin operator . for @xmath664 , @xmath665 , @xmath666 ,
the baouendi - grushin operator is @xmath667 in order to study the weak solution associated with @xmath668 , it is natural to consider the following function space associated with the hrmander vector fields @xmath669 for @xmath670 , @xmath671 a bounded open subset , we define @xmath672 by theorem 1 in @xcite , @xmath673 is a separable banach space for @xmath674 with the norm @xmath675 denote by @xmath676 the closure of @xmath677 in @xmath673 .
it is not hard to prove by using mollifier that if @xmath678 and has compact support in @xmath679 , then @xmath680 , @xmath674 . in this paper
only the spaces with @xmath681 are involved .
we list them below separately : @xmath682 to simplify the notation , we will denote @xmath683 we will need the sobolev embedding theorem for @xmath684 and the @xmath1 estimate for @xmath668 .
similar results for more general subelliptic operators can be found in lots of literature like @xcite and @xcite .
since our case is much simpler , we provide a relatively shorter and self - contained proof in the appendix .
[ lem : embedding ] let @xmath685 be a bounded domain in @xmath686 . 1 .
if @xmath687 , then @xmath688 for @xmath689 satisfying @xmath690 , i.e. there exists @xmath691 such that for all @xmath692 @xmath693 2 .
if @xmath694 , then @xmath695 , i.e. there exists @xmath696 such that for all @xmath697 , @xmath698 see appendix .
[ thm : grushin ] let @xmath685 be a domain in @xmath686 , @xmath699 and @xmath700 is even .
let @xmath701 with @xmath702 . then there is a positive constant @xmath703 which only depends on @xmath384 such that @xmath704 see appendix .
next we state the local @xmath1 estimates for the perturbed operator @xmath705 where @xmath706 can be decomposed into the form @xmath707 with @xmath708 and @xmath709 a positive definite matrix with continuous entries and for some small positive @xmath710 it satisfies @xmath711 where @xmath712 if @xmath713 and @xmath714 if @xmath715 . from now on , we will work on the following scale - invariant `` cylinder '' ( w.r.t @xmath668 ) centered at the origin : for @xmath62 @xmath716 [ prop : perturb - grushin ] let @xmath717 satisfy @xmath718 where @xmath719 is a perturbed baouendi - grushin operator given by
. then if is satisfied for sufficiently small @xmath720 , there exists @xmath691 such that for any @xmath721 , @xmath722 we write @xmath723 if @xmath724 , then by @xmath725 hence if we choose @xmath726 in , for any @xmath727 we have @xmath728 now we remove the compact support condition .
let @xmath721 be fixed and let @xmath729 .
let @xmath730 be a smooth cut - off function in @xmath731 , where @xmath732 satisfy @xmath733 when @xmath734 , @xmath735 when @xmath736 ; @xmath737 when @xmath738 , @xmath739 when @xmath740 .
moreover , @xmath741 , @xmath742 , @xmath743 , @xmath744 .
let @xmath745 , then @xmath746 u.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by we have @xmath747u\|_{p,{\mathcal{c}}_{\sigma ' r}}\right).\ ] ] compute @xmath748u$ ] directly .
using the estimates for the coefficient matrix @xmath749 with @xmath710 chosen less than 1 , as well as the cut - off functions , we obtain the following ( for simplicity we write @xmath750 ) @xmath751u\|_{p } \leq c\left(\frac{1}{(1-\sigma')r}\|\nabla_x u\|_p+\frac{1}{(1-\sigma')r^2}\||x|^2 \nabla_t u\|_p\right)+\\ + \frac{c}{(1-\sigma')^2r^2}\|u\|_p+\frac{c}{(1-\sigma')r}\||x|\nabla_t u\|_p,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath752 is some absolute constant . now using the interpolation between the classical sobolev spaces ( for @xmath753 ) and young s inequality we have for any @xmath279 , @xmath754 hence by rescaling and then taking the supreme in @xmath755 , we have @xmath756 @xmath757 @xmath758 combining - and choosing @xmath359 , @xmath759 small enough , depending on @xmath384 , we obtain the inequality . in this section
we show that the legendre function @xmath92 which satisfies the fully nonlinear pde is smooth in a neighborhood of the origin .
we will work on the non - isotropic cylinder at the origin : @xmath760 before proving the main theorem , we make the following two remarks : a. by corollary [ cor : extension ] and the discussion in section [ sec : subelliptic - coeff ] , there is @xmath761 small enough such that @xmath762 for any @xmath674 and the linearized operator @xmath661 can be viewed as a perturbation of the baouendi - grushin type operator in @xmath763 .
b. we note the following rescaling property : if @xmath92 solves in @xmath763 , then @xmath764 with @xmath765 and @xmath766 the non - isotropic dilation in will solve @xmath767 hence by multiplying a nonzero constant , we may assume that the coefficient matrix @xmath768 is of the form @xmath707 in @xmath763 with @xmath649 continuous and satisfying for sufficiently small @xmath710 , where @xmath710 is chosen such that the @xmath1 estimate ( proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ] ) applies . the idea to show the smoothness is then to apply iteratively to the first order difference quotient of @xmath769 , but each step we need to be careful that the non - homogeneous rhs coming from differentiation is bounded in @xmath1 . for notation simplicity , in what follows we will discuss the case when @xmath770 .
then equation is simply @xmath771 the arguments for @xmath772 are the same .
[ thm : smoothness - v ] let @xmath92 be the legendre function of @xmath13 defined in .
let @xmath761 such that in @xmath763 , corollary [ cor : extension ] holds for @xmath92 and @xmath768 can be written in the form of with @xmath749 satisfying for sufficiently small @xmath710 .
then @xmath92 is smooth at the origin .
we let @xmath773 denote the first difference quotient of @xmath92 in @xmath774 direction .
_ step 1 : _ show @xmath775 for any @xmath702 , @xmath587 . by corollary [ cor :
extension ] , it is enough to show it for @xmath776 .
in fact , @xmath762 implies that @xmath777 and @xmath778 on @xmath779 for @xmath780 .
moreover , by taking @xmath781 on both sides of we get @xmath782 satisfies @xmath783 with @xmath784 since a translation in @xmath785 direction does not change the subelliptic structure of the operator ( by corollary [ cor : extension ] and the @xmath286 dependence of @xmath786 on @xmath31 ) , i.e. @xmath787 is still a perturbed baouendi - grushin operator in the form of , with @xmath749 satisfying in @xmath788 . then by proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ]
there exists @xmath691 such that for any @xmath789 @xmath790 note that the rhs of is uniformly bounded in @xmath140 .
moreover , @xmath791 and @xmath792 ( here we slightly abuse of the notation to let @xmath793 denote the weighted second order derivatives and first order derivatives w.r.t . @xmath515 and @xmath516 ) .
thus @xmath794 for any @xmath587 with @xmath795 depending on @xmath796 , @xmath797 and @xmath384 .
_ step 2 : _
show @xmath798 , @xmath587 .
take @xmath799 to both sides of . from step 1 ,
@xmath800 and it satisfies @xmath801 applying @xmath802 to with @xmath803 , then @xmath804 and it satisfies @xmath805 with @xmath806 to estimate the @xmath807 , we first notice that @xmath229 ( up to a translation @xmath808 ) is a summation of the following terms : @xmath809 next , since @xmath810 for any @xmath811 , then by hlder s inequality , for @xmath812 satisfying @xmath813 we have @xmath814 apply hlder to estimate @xmath815 .
for some @xmath816 satisfying @xmath817 we have @xmath818 by corollary [ cor : extension](iv ) , the second term on the rhs of is bounded . from the boundedness of @xmath819 shown in step 1 ,
the third term is uniformly bounded in @xmath140 . hence combining we have @xmath820
is uniformly bounded in @xmath140 .
similarly by using corollary [ cor : extension ] , and step 1 , we have @xmath821 , @xmath822 are uniformly bounded in @xmath140 .
therefore , applying the @xmath1 estimate ( proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ] ) to , one can find a constant @xmath823 independent of @xmath140 , such that for any @xmath721 , @xmath824 since the rhs is uniformly bounded in @xmath140 , this implies @xmath825 from we know @xmath826 , @xmath827 , @xmath828 . multiplying a cut - off function to extend the functions to @xmath3 and applying the sobolev embedding lemma [ lem :
embedding](i ) we have , for @xmath829 ( with @xmath830 the homogeneous dimension associated with @xmath661 ) , @xmath831 repeat the above arguments starting from with @xmath832 replaced by @xmath833 ( note @xmath834 if @xmath835 ) .
after finite steps @xmath700 ( which only depends on the dimension ) we will get @xmath826 , @xmath836 with @xmath816 larger than the homogeneous dimension @xmath830 , and hence by embedding lemma [ lem : embedding](ii ) are in @xmath837 . applying proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ]
again we obtain @xmath838 for @xmath702 .
noting that @xmath839 is chosen arbitrary , we complete the proof for step 2 .
_ show @xmath840 , @xmath841 with @xmath842 . first from step 1 , @xmath843 for @xmath844 with @xmath845 .
this together with the boundedness of @xmath846 obtained in step 2 gives @xmath847 next we estimate @xmath848 with @xmath849 and @xmath828 .
similar as , @xmath848 satisfies @xmath850 with @xmath851 by we immediately have @xmath852 is uniformly bounded in @xmath140 for any @xmath702 . applying the @xmath1 estimate ( proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ] ) we have @xmath853 is uniformly bounded in @xmath140 , and therefore completes the proof for step 3 .
_ show @xmath854 for @xmath855 , with @xmath856 depending on @xmath857 and dimension .
this is done in the same way as for @xmath841 .
more precisely , we first consider the equation of @xmath858 in @xmath859 @xmath860 with @xmath861 bounded uniformly in @xmath140 for some @xmath862 .
then we apply the sobolev embedding lemma and the @xmath1 estimate iteratively to obtain the boundedness of @xmath863 with some @xmath864 , as well as the boundedness of @xmath865 for any @xmath702 . in particular , this combined with the fact that @xmath840 for all @xmath866 gives that @xmath867 is bounded with @xmath868 for any @xmath702 .
next , we consider the equation for @xmath869 , @xmath870 , @xmath871 and @xmath842 .
similar as in step 3 , one easily get the uniform boundedness of @xmath872 for any @xmath702 due to the boundedness of @xmath873 , @xmath874 .
applying @xmath1 estimate again we obtain the conclusion . [
cor : freeboundary ] let @xmath13 be a solution to the signorini problem in @xmath70 , and let @xmath19 be the regular set of the free boundary .
then @xmath19 is smooth .
take @xmath37 a regular free boundary point , in a coordinate chart centered at @xmath31 , by @xcite @xmath19 can be locally expressed as the graph of a @xmath46 function @xmath875 with @xmath876 .
consider in a neighborhood of @xmath31 the partial hodograph - legendre transform and the corresponding legendre function @xmath92 defined in section [ sec : legendre - transf - its ] . by theorem [ thm : smoothness - v ] , @xmath92 is smooth at the origin . since @xmath877
hence the smoothness of @xmath92 at the origin implies the smoothness of @xmath229 at @xmath878 .
in this section , we show that the legendre transform @xmath92 is analytic in a neighborhood of the origin ( theorem [ thm : fb - regul ] ) .
[ thm : main ] let @xmath92 be the legendre transform defined in section [ sec : legendre - funct - nonl ] . then @xmath92 is real analytic in a neighborhood of the origin .
we first make some more assumptions and observations .
+ 1 . for simplicity
we work on @xmath879 . by the scaling invariant property mentioned at the beginning of section [ sec : smoothness - free - bound ]
we may assume @xmath92 is smooth in @xmath880 and solves the fully nonlinear equation there .
denote @xmath881 from corollary [ cor : extension](iii)(iv ) and the intermediate value theorem , we have @xmath882 + 2 .
the following multi - index notation will be used : + for a multi - index @xmath883 , @xmath884 let @xmath885 , @xmath886 be two multi - index in @xmath887 , we say @xmath888 iff @xmath889 , @xmath890 ; and @xmath891 iff @xmath892 , @xmath893 , where @xmath894 .
the strategy to prove the analyticity is as follows : given @xmath895 , taking @xmath896 on both sides of and using the summation convention on @xmath897s , we obtain that @xmath769 satisfies @xmath898 where @xmath899 is the set of all permutations of @xmath900
. we will apply proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ] for to get a fine estimate of the @xmath1 norm of @xmath769 . in order to do so
, usually one needs a sequence of domains with properly shrinking radius as well as the corresponding sequence of cut - off functions . in this paper
, we use the trick introduced in @xcite to avoid this technical trouble . in the following
we take and fix a cut - off function @xmath901 which satisfies @xmath902 we will estimate @xmath903 with @xmath904 by @xmath903 with @xmath905 .
+ 4 . from now
on we will simply write @xmath906 if the integral domain is @xmath907 .
we will fix a @xmath384 larger than the homogeneous dimension @xmath830 . by a universal constant we mean an absolute constant which only depends on @xmath908 , @xmath237 , dimension ( which is @xmath909 in our setting ) or @xmath384 chosen , in particular independent of @xmath910 .
the following observation will be useful in the proof : @xmath911 which implies @xmath912 hence for multi - index @xmath230 with @xmath913 , @xmath914 for some @xmath915 , @xmath916 with @xmath917 and @xmath918 .
the following proposition is the main proposition of this section .
[ prop : induction ] there exist universal constants @xmath919 , @xmath920 and @xmath921 such that for any @xmath922 @xmath923 theorem [ thm : main ] will follow from proposition [ prop : induction ] . indeed , by proposition [ prop : induction ] there exists a universal @xmath5 such that @xmath924 hence by the classical sobolev embedding @xmath925 for @xmath835 chosen above , one has @xmath926 hence @xmath92 is in gevrey class @xmath927 , which is the same as the class of real analytic functions . before proving proposition [ prop : induction ] , we first show a lemma on the @xmath928-norm of @xmath769 , which roughly speaking is a consequence of the sobolev embedding lemma ( lemma [ lem : embedding](ii ) ) .
[ lem : embedding2 ] for @xmath929 , assume proposition [ prop : induction ] holds for @xmath930 and @xmath910 .
then there is a universal constant @xmath931 such that @xmath932 \(i ) first by lemma [ lem : embedding2](ii ) , there is a universal constant @xmath752 such that @xmath933 applying to the rhs of above inequality , we have @xmath934 by proposition [ prop : induction](i ) for @xmath930 and @xmath910 , there exists a universal constant @xmath935 , which can be chosen larger than @xmath237 such that @xmath936 the estimate for @xmath937 follows from the classical sobolev embedding , , and the assumption .
\(ii ) similar to ( i ) .
\(iii ) use corollary [ cor : extension ] and ( ii ) above .
this is done by induction .
assume ( i ) and
( ii ) hold for @xmath938 .
we want to show they hold for @xmath910 .
let @xmath230 be a multi - index with @xmath904 . from
, @xmath939 satisfies the following equation @xmath940 where @xmath941 by the @xmath1 estimate for the perturbed baouendi - grushin operator ( proposition [ prop : perturb - grushin ] ) , there is a universal @xmath942 such that @xmath943 the estimate of @xmath944 is standard .
in fact , @xmath945 for some @xmath946 with @xmath947 . by the induction assumption ( i)(ii ) for @xmath930 ,
the above rhs is bounded by @xmath948 similarly there is some @xmath949 with @xmath950 such that @xmath951 hence @xmath952 next we estimate @xmath953
. _ proof of ( i ) .
_ let @xmath954 , @xmath955 , @xmath956 .
then @xmath957 we discuss the following two cases : @xmath958 . if @xmath959 , then @xmath960 which is by lemma [ lem : embedding2](iii ) and the induction assumption ( i ) for @xmath930 bounded by @xmath961 if @xmath962 , then @xmath963 which is by lemma [ lem : embedding2](iii)(i ) and the induction assumption ( i ) for @xmath930 bounded by @xmath964 hence @xmath965 by stirling s formula and the fact that @xmath966 , there is a universal constant @xmath967 such that @xmath968 hence @xmath969 @xmath970 or @xmath971 .
we only discuss when @xmath972 .
similarly we consider @xmath973 and @xmath974 . if @xmath973 , the estimate is indeed included in case 1 . if @xmath974 , then we simply have @xmath975 arguing similarly as in case 1 we have @xmath976 combining the above two cases we have , @xmath977 we combine , for @xmath978 and , and use the induction assumption ( i ) for @xmath979 to estimate @xmath980
. then @xmath981 where @xmath982 is a universal constant . by for @xmath978 , @xmath983 thus combining with induction assumption ( i ) for @xmath930 and @xmath984 , we have @xmath985 where @xmath986 .
choosing @xmath987 we proved ( i ) .
_ proof of ( ii ) .
_ the key step is to estimate @xmath953 , which is done similarly as for ( i ) . more precisely , lemma [ lem : embedding2](i ) and ( with @xmath987 ) imply @xmath988 this together with the induction assumption ( ii ) up to @xmath930 yields , for any multi - index @xmath230 , @xmath989 , @xmath990 in the estimate of @xmath953 , we first consider when @xmath991 : by lemma [ lem : embedding2](ii ) and , @xmath992 hence @xmath993 since for @xmath230 with @xmath904 fixed , we have the following identity ( e.g. proposition 2.1 in @xcite ) : @xmath994 then if we let @xmath995 , @xmath996 , @xmath997 , the rhs of is bounded by @xmath998 by stirling s formula and if we still use @xmath999 to denote the universal constant from it , then the above quantity is bounded by @xmath1000 the arguments for the case @xmath1001 are exactly the same .
hence @xmath1002 the rest of the proof for ( ii ) is the same as for ( i ) and we do not repeat here .
in the appendix , we give a short proof for lemma [ lem : embedding ] ( the sobolev embeddings for @xmath1003 , see also @xcite ) and theorem [ thm : grushin ] ( the @xmath1 estimates for baouendi - grushin operator ) .
both statements are well known , and available in much greater generality .
checking that the general results apply , however , requires familiarity with the theory of subelliptic operators . for completeness and the convenience of the reader we provide complete proofs .
we first prove ( i ) .
suppose that @xmath1004 and extend @xmath13 to be zero outside @xmath679 .
for every @xmath1005 , @xmath1006 with @xmath1007 , @xmath1008 where @xmath1009 is a @xmath322 function satisfying @xmath1010 , @xmath1011 .
let @xmath1012 then by a direct computation @xmath1013 hence @xmath1014 which by a change of variable @xmath1015 gives @xmath1016 by young s inequality for convolution and fubini , for @xmath1017 , @xmath1018 observe that for @xmath1019 , @xmath1020 for any @xmath1021 , and for @xmath1022 , @xmath1023 . hence if we let @xmath1024 after integrating over @xmath1025 , by fubini and a change of variable we have @xmath1026 by the hardy - littlewood - sobolev inequality , for the chosen @xmath816 satisfying @xmath1027 we have @xmath1028 next we prove ( ii ) .
since this property is local in nature , given @xmath1029 we may assume by multiplying a characteristic function that @xmath1030 in @xmath1031 .
hence the integration in can be written from @xmath878 to @xmath155 for some @xmath1032 large enough .
next we give a short proof for the @xmath1 estimate for baouendi - grushin operator @xmath668 .
the idea is to treat @xmath668 as the projected operator of sub - laplacian on the heisenberg - reiter type group onto certain quotient space .
the transference method in @xcite links the @xmath1 estimate on the group to the @xmath1 estimate for @xmath668 in the quotient space .
consider @xmath1037 equipped with the group law @xmath1038 where @xmath1039 is the space of @xmath1040 real matrices , and @xmath1041 are understood as the matrix multiplication .
let @xmath1042 .
@xmath1043 is an example of heisenberg - reiter group , which is by @xcite a nilpotent lie group of step @xmath45 , with dilation @xmath1044 and homogeneous dimension @xmath1045 .
it is also immediate that the lebesgue measure @xmath1046 is a left and right haar measure on @xmath1043 .
now we recall several facts about the nilpotent lie groups with dilations .
a direct computation shows that the horizontal vector fields in the lie algebra @xmath1047 that agree at the origin with @xmath1048 and @xmath1049 are @xmath1050 consider the sub - laplacian in @xmath1043 @xmath1051 it is easy to check that @xmath1052 , @xmath1053 are hrmander vector fields , then @xmath1054 is hypoelliptic . by theorem 2.1 in @xcite
, there exists a unique fundamental solution of type @xmath45 ( i.e. smooth away from @xmath878 and homogeneous of degree @xmath1055 ) for @xmath1054 , which we denote by @xmath1056 . for @xmath1057
we have @xmath1058 .
since @xmath1059 and @xmath1053 are left - invariant , then @xmath1060 where @xmath642 is a quadratic polynomial in @xmath1059 and @xmath1053 . by @xmath1061 estimates for the singular integral in homogeneous groups
( see for example xiii 5.3 in @xcite ) , we have @xmath1062 and in particular , using we have @xmath1063 now let @xmath1064 .
one can easily verify that @xmath1065 is a closed subgroup of @xmath1043 with a bi - invariant measure the lebesgue measure @xmath1066 .
let @xmath1067 be the quotient space and @xmath1068 the natural quotient mapping .
given @xmath1069 , define @xmath1070 by theorem 15.21 in @xcite , the above correspondence @xmath1071 defines a linear mapping of @xmath1072 onto @xmath1073 .
we identify @xmath1074 with @xmath1075 .
a direct computation gives @xmath1076 since the lebesgue measure @xmath1077 and @xmath1078 are bi - invariant on @xmath1043 and @xmath1065 correspondingly , then by theorem 15.24 in @xcite , there exists a unique right - invariant measure ( up to a constant ) on @xmath1079 , which is necessarily the lebesgue measure @xmath1080 .
consider the following vector fields , which are the ` push - down ' vector fields of @xmath1059 , @xmath1053 on @xmath1081 @xmath1082 @xmath1083 note that the baouendi - grushin operator can be written as @xmath1084 to see that they are indeed the push - down vector fields on @xmath1074 , we notice that for @xmath1057 , @xmath1085 similarly , using one can check that @xmath1086 hence @xmath1087 let @xmath919 be the representation of @xmath1043 acting on @xmath1088 given by the right translation , i.e. given @xmath1089 @xmath1090 it is easy to check that @xmath1091 are bounded from @xmath1088 to @xmath1088 by @xmath597 .
given @xmath1092 , @xmath702 , we consider the following linear map @xmath89 on @xmath1088 : @xmath1093 notice that @xmath1043 is locally compact and by the convolution operator @xmath1094 is bounded in @xmath1095 . thus the transference method ( theorem 2.4 in @xcite ) applies and we have for @xmath1096 , @xmath1097 in particular if we take @xmath1098 , then @xmath1099 in the end we show that @xmath1100 . indeed , by and @xmath1101 by and fubini , then using and we have @xmath1102 observing that @xmath1103 , @xmath1104 , @xmath1105 , and @xmath1106 can be written as @xmath1107 for some quadratic polynomial @xmath642 , we complete the proof of the theorem . | in this paper we study the higher regularity of the free boundary for the elliptic signorini problem . by using a partial hodograph - legendre transformation
we show that the regular part of the free boundary is real analytic .
the first complication in the study is the invertibility of the hodograph transform ( which is only @xmath0 ) which can be overcome by studying the precise asymptotic behavior of the solutions near regular free boundary points .
the second and main complication in the study is that the equation satisfied by the legendre transform is degenerate .
however , the equation has a subelliptic structure and can be viewed as a perturbation of the baouendi - grushin operator . by using the @xmath1 theory available for that operator , we can bootstrap the regularity of the legendre transform up to real analyticity , which implies the real analyticity of the free boundary . |
`` materials by design '' , the ability to design and create a material with specified correlated electron properties , is a long - standing goal of condensed matter physics .
superlattices , in which one or more component is a transition metal oxide with a partially filled @xmath0-shell , are of great current interest in this regard because they offer the possibility of enhancing and controlling the correlated electron phenomena known @xcite to occur in bulk materials as well as the possibility of creating electronic phases not observed in bulk.@xcite following the pioneering work of ohtomo and hwang,@xcite heterostructures and heterointerfaces of transition metal oxides have been studied extensively .
experimental findings include metal - insulator transitions,@xcite superconductivity , @xcite magnetism @xcite and coexistence of ferromagnetic and superconducting phases.@xcite solid solution in plane of carrier concentration ( changed by sr concentration ) and tilt angle in @xmath1 structure but with all three glazer s angles nearly equal .
dashed line indicates relation between carrier concentration and rotation amplitude in physically occurring bulk solid solution . from ref . .
] in this paper we consider the possibility that appropriately designed superlattices might exhibit ferromagnetism .
our work is partly motivated by a recent report@xcite of room - temperature ferromagnetism in superlattices composed of some number @xmath2 of layers of lavo@xmath3 ( lvo ) separated by one layer of srvo@xmath3 ( svo ) , even though ferromagnetism is not found at any @xmath4 in the bulk solid solution la@xmath5sr@xmath6vo@xmath3 .
our study is based on a previous analysis@xcite of the possibility of obtaining ferromagnetism in variants of the crystal structure of bulk solid solutions of the form la@xmath5sr@xmath6vo@xmath3 .
a key result of the previous work was that ferromagnetism is favored by a combination of large octahedral rotations and large doping away from the mott insulating lavo@xmath3 composition . a schematic phase diagram is shown in fig .
[ fig : bulkpd ] .
however , as indicated by the dashed line in the figure , in the physical bulk solid solution , doping away from the mott insulating concentration reduces the amplitude of the octahedral rotations so that the physical materials remain far from the magnetic phase boundary .
the motivating idea of this paper is that in the superlattice geometry , octahedral rotation amplitude may be decoupled from carrier concentration .
the rotations can be controlled by choice of substrate while the carrier concentration can be controlled by choice of chemical composition and may vary from layer to layer of a superlattice . in effect , an appropriately designed superlattice could enable the exploration of different paths in fig . [
fig : bulkpd ] . in this study
, we combine single - site dynamical mean field approximation@xcite with realistic band structure calculations including the effects of the octahedral rotations to determine the ferromagnetic - paramagnetic phase diagram in superlattices with the crystal structures believed relevant@xcite to the experiments of ref . .
unfortunately we find that the experimentally determined crystal structure is in fact less favorable to ferromagnetism than the one found in the bulk solid solution , but we indicate structures that may be more favorable .
the paper has following structure .
the model and methods are described in sec .
[ sec : model ] .
[ sec : cubicsuperlattice ] establishes the methods via a detailed analysis of the phase diagram of superlattices with no rotations or tilts . in sec .
[ sec : tiltedsuperlattice ] we present the magnetic properties of superlattices with octahedral rotations similar to those observed experimentally .
section [ sec : conclusions ] is a summary and conclusion .
this paper builds on a previous study of the magnetic phase diagram of bulk vanadates.@xcite the new features relevant for the superlattices studied here are ( i ) the change in geometrical structure , including the differences from the bulk solid solution in the pattern of octahedral tilts and rotations and ( ii ) the variation of electronic density arising from superlattice structure . in the rest of this section
we briefly summarize the basic theoretical methodology ( referring the reader to ref . for details ) , define the crystal structures more precisely , explain the consequences for the electronic structure and explain how the variation of density appears in the formalism .
we study superlattices composed of layers of srvo@xmath3 ( svo ) alternating with layers of lavo@xmath3 ( lvo ) . if we idealize the structures as cubic perovskites , then the layers alternate along the @xmath7 $ ] direction . in bulk
, svo crystallizes in the ideal cubic perovskite structure,@xcite while lvo crystallizes in a lower symmetry @xmath1 structure derived from the cubic perovskite via a four unit - cell pattern of octahedral tilts .
@xcite the crystal structure of bulk solid solutions la@xmath5sr@xmath6vo@xmath3 interpolates between that of the two end - members with the rotation amplitude decreasing as @xmath4 increases . in the superlattice , the presence of a substrate and the breaking of translation symmetry can lead to different rotational distortions of the basic perovskite structure and also to a difference between lattice constants parallel and perpendicular to the growth direction .
octahedral rotations in perovskites can be described using glazer s notation.@xcite in the coordinate system defined by the three v - o bond directions of the original cubic perovskite , there are 3 tilt angles @xmath8 and @xmath9 with corresponding rotation axes @xmath10,[010]$ ] and @xmath7 $ ] .
the tilt is in - phase if successive octahedra rotate in the same direction , and anti - phase if they rotate in opposite directions .
rotational distortions of the cubic perovskite @xmath11o@xmath3 structure may be denoted by @xmath12 where @xmath13 can be @xmath14 or @xmath15 denoting in - phase , anti - phase or no tilting , respectively and @xmath16.@xcite bulk lvo ( @xmath1 ) is of the type @xmath17 with @xmath18 and @xmath19.@xcite for superlattices , substrate - induced strain may change the situation in a way which depends on the growth direction .
experiments@xcite confirm that the growth direction for the experimentally relevant superlattices is @xmath7 $ ] ( in the ideal cubic perovskite notation ) and we focus on this case here .
recent experimental studies of superlattices@xcite and of lavo@xmath3 thin films , which apparently have the same growth direction,@xcite suggest that the rotations are of the type @xmath20@xcite and indicate that the dominant rotation is around the axis defined by the growth direction : @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
this distortion pattern is different from that occurring in bulk .
to explore its effects we set @xmath23 and consider the consequences of varying @xmath9 . in bulk la@xmath5sr@xmath6vo@xmath3 ,
while the 4-sublattice @xmath1 structure implies a difference in lattice constants , all v - o bond lengths are the same.@xcite the difference in lattice constants arises from a difference in tilting pattern .
superlattices are typically grown on a substrate , and in epitaxial growth conditions the lattice constants perpendicular to the growth direction ( which we denote here by @xmath24 ) are fixed by the substrate , while the lattice parameter along the growth direction ( @xmath25 ) is free to relax . the result is a @xmath26 ratio typically @xmath27 contributed by both tilting and anisotropy in v - o bond lengths and possibly varying from layer to layer of the superlattice . for the experimentally studied superlattices , @xmath28 .
@xcite the v - o bond lengths have not been determined but , as discussed in more detail in the appendix , our studies indicate that all v - o bonds have essentially the same length .
further we show that a few percent differences have no significant effect on our study of ferromagnetism .
in the rest of the paper we therefore ignore these distortions , setting all v - o bond lengths to be equal .
we study superlattices designed to be similar to the system studied in ref . .
in these superlattices , units of @xmath2 layers of lavo@xmath3 are separated by one layer of srvo@xmath3 . to define the superlattice , we begin from lvo in the appropriate bulk structure , then break translation invariance along the @xmath7 $ ] ( @xmath29-direction ) by replacing every ( m+1)@xmath30 lao plane with an sro plane . fig .
[ fig : cartoon]a shows such a superlattice with @xmath31 .
we assume that the superlattice is grown epitaxially so that in - plane bond lengths and other aspects of the local structure including rotations are the same for all layers .
we therefore take the electron transfer integrals which define the band structure to the be same for all layers . in this case
the electronic structure of a superlattice is defined by adding the electrostatic potentials of the sr and la ions to the basic translationally invariant hopping hamiltonian describing the bulk materials . in our calculations
we follow the common practice in studies of early transition metal oxides by assuming that the energy splitting between transition metal @xmath0-bands and oxygen @xmath32-bands is large enough to justify the use of a `` frontier orbital '' model focusing on the @xmath32-@xmath0 antibonding bands which are mainly composed of vanadium @xmath33-symmetry @xmath0-states .
the hamiltonian for the superlattice is thus @xmath34 where @xmath35 describes the electron - ion interaction and electron - electron interaction between different sites and @xmath36 describes the @xmath0-@xmath0 interactions , which we take to be on - site .
@xmath37 is a tight binding model , derived by using maximally - localized wannier function ( mlwf ) techniques@xcite to fit the @xmath33-derived antibonding bands .
the detailed procedure is described in our previous work.@xcite ( color online ) ( a ) schematic of superlattice lattice structure ( lavo@xmath3)@xmath38(srvo@xmath3)@xmath39 with @xmath31 .
vanadium sites indicated as circles with charge density indicated by shading : heavy shading ( black online ) indicating higher charge density and light shading ( yellow online ) indicating lower charge density .
lao and sro planes are shown as solid and dashed lines respectively .
nearest neighbor ( @xmath40 ) and next - nearest neighbor ( @xmath41 ) hoppings between vanadium sites indicated by arrows .
the numbers on the right are vo@xmath42 layer indices .
( b ) inset : @xmath43 hopping between @xmath33 orbital and @xmath32-orbital .
main panel : two - dimensional nearest neighbor hopping @xmath40 made of two @xmath43 hoppings from @xmath44 orbital of one vanadium site to oxygen @xmath45 or @xmath46 orbital , then to @xmath44 orbital of another vanadium site . ]
the kinetic hamiltonian has the quadratic form @xmath47 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are electron creation and annihilation operators in reciprocal space with wavevector @xmath50 . @xmath51 and @xmath52 are orbital and layer indices , and @xmath53 is the spin index .
we assume that the interaction takes the standard slater - kanamori form @xcite which following ref .
we write as @xmath54 where the values of the on - site interaction @xmath55 and the hund s coupling @xmath56 are @xmath57 and @xmath58ev so that lvo is an insulator in bulk while svo is a metal . in the approximation employed here ,
the superlattice is defined by the coulomb interaction between the la / sr ions and electrons .
this , and the off - site part of the electron - electron interaction is contained @xcite in @xmath59 to construct @xmath60 , we assume that the whole ion charge of svo or lvo unit cell comes into the sr or la site .
consider srvo@xmath3 , the valence of v is @xmath61 ( @xmath62 .
if this one @xmath0-electron is removed , the svo unit cell will have charge @xmath63 , hence , in our model , sr site has charge @xmath63 . similarly , lavo@xmath3 has v@xmath64 ( @xmath65 ) , thus la site has charge @xmath66 . as a result
, @xmath60 has the form @xmath67 where @xmath68 is electron - occupation operator at v - site @xmath69 , @xmath70 is the relative dielectric constant .
the part @xmath71 is the inter - site coulomb interaction of vanadium @xmath0-electrons @xmath72 @xmath71 is treated in the hartree approximation .
note that in eq .
, @xmath73 is the operator giving the total @xmath0-electron occupation of site @xmath69 , while @xmath74 is the expectation value of @xmath0-electron occupancy at site @xmath75 , which is determined self consistently . from @xmath35 , the coulomb potential @xmath76 for site @xmath69
is calculated using ewald summation.@xcite the dielectric constant @xmath70 is an important parameter in eqs .
( [ eqn : hel - ion ] , [ eqn : hel - el ] ) .
it accounts for screening on the scale of a lattice constant so bulk measurements are not directly relevant and an appropriate value has not been determined .
values ranging from @xmath77 to @xmath78 have been reported in the literature for similar systems.@xcite because the appropriate value of @xmath70 has not been determined , we have studied several cases and present results mainly for @xmath79 .
we treat the on - site interaction terms using single - site dynamical mean field theory ( dmft)@xcite with the hybridization expansion continuous time quantum monte carlo ( ctqmc ) solver.@xcite the superlattice effect is taken into account by the coulomb potential @xmath80 .
we use the superlattice dynamical mean field theory introduced by potthoff and nolting @xcite in the form given in ref . .
here each v site @xmath69 has a self energy ( site local but dependent on site ) determined from the solution of a quantum impurity model which has parameters fixed by the dmft self - consistency equation linking the site local term of the lattice green function @xmath81 to the quantum impurity model green function@xcite @xmath82^{-1}\right\}_{ii},\ ] ] where @xmath83 is a site dependent quantity , diagonal in spin and orbital indices but linking different sites , derived from eqs .
( [ eqn : hel - ion ] , [ eqn : hel - el ] ) .
the layers are coupled by a self - consistency condition which as discussed in refs .
fixes both the hybridization function of the quantum impurity model and the layer - to - layer variation in the charge density . as described in ref .
, it is advantageous to perform a site - local rotation to align the orbital basis to the local v - o bond directions of each octahedron before solving the impurity model .
this reduces the sign problem in the ctqmc impurity solver and restores in - plane translation invariance in the sense of making the self - consistency equations the same for all sites in a given plane . in a superlattice composed of @xmath84 layers ,
it is in principle necessary to solve @xmath84 dynamical mean field problems , coupled by the self - consistency condition .
however , we find ( see section [ sec : cubicsuperlattice ] ) that the susceptibility for a given layer of the superlattice may be determined from a bulk computation at the same local density and crystal structure . because the layer dependent density has no significant dependence on the temperature or the many - body physics , it may be determined once from a band structure calculation and then bulk results with the appropriate density for a wide range of temperature may be used to infer the curie temperature , substantially reducing the computational burden .
the curie temperature for ferromagnetism is determined by extrapolating the inverse susceptibility @xmath85 to @xmath15 based on curie - weiss law @xmath86 .
the test for the reliability of this method for @xmath87 has been done in ref . .
a similar approach can be found in literature.@xcite
in this section , we demonstrate that the magnetic phase diagrams of superlattice systems may be inferred , to reasonable accuracy , from the study of appropriately chosen bulk systems .
this enables a considerable reduction in the computation resources required .
( color online ) panel ( a ) : non - interacting density of states for bulk system at carrier density @xmath88 .
panels ( b ) : non - interacting density of states for different layers of ( lvo)@xmath3(svo)@xmath39 superlattice for two different values of dielectric constant @xmath89 ( solid ) and @xmath90 ( dashed ) with hopping parameters @xmath91ev and @xmath92ev .
sro plane is between layers @xmath15 and @xmath93 ( the index is defined in fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] ) .
the fermi energy is at @xmath15 . ]
we begin with a study of `` untilted '' or `` cubic '' superlattices : those in which all v - o - v bond angles are @xmath94 .
we focus specifically on @xmath7 $ ] superlattices in which the unit cell contains @xmath2 layers lvo and one layer svo , where @xmath95 . for orientation , we present the density of states ( dos ) of the non - interacting system in fig . [
fig : dos ] . in obtaining these densities of states we used the simple tight binding parametrization .
the dos for the bulk system is shown in panel ( a ) .
one sees the typical three - fold degenerate dos for @xmath33 band , the van hove singularity is visible as a peak near the upper band edge .
it is at high energy because the next - nearest neighbor hopping @xmath96 .
the remaining panels show the layer - resolved densities of states for the @xmath31 superlattice .
the upper two panels show layers sandwiched by la on both sides ; the lower two panels show the layers adjacent to the sro plane .
the superlattice - induced changes in the density of states are seen to be relatively minor : the main effects are a weak splitting of the van hove peaks reflecting the breaking of translational invariance in the @xmath29-direction , and a relative shift in the positions of the van hove peaks arising from band bending associated with the different charges of the sr and la ions .
[ fig : slchi ] shows the layer - resolved charge density and inverse susceptibility @xmath97 plotted against temperature for three different superlattice structures corresponding to @xmath98 . as expected from electrostatic considerations , the charge is lower for the vo@xmath42 planes nearer the sro layer and the charge variation between layers is controlled by the dielectric constant .
the magnetization @xmath2 at the v sites on each layer was computed at field @xmath99 and the inverse susceptibility was obtained as @xmath100 .
linearity was verified by repeating the computation using @xmath101 ( not shown ) . for the @xmath102 case ( fig .
[ fig : slchi]a ) , we extended the computation to the lower temperature @xmath103ev ; for the other two cases @xmath104ev was the lowest temperature studied .
the inverse susceptibilities are approximately linear in temperature at higher temperatures and in all cases , extrapolation to @xmath105 reveals @xmath106 , implying absence of ferromagnetism .
( color online ) temperature - dependent layer - resolved inverse magnetic susceptibilities for symmetry - inequivalent layers of untilted ( lvo)@xmath38(svo)@xmath39 superlattice structures with different numbers of lvo layers @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
layer @xmath15 is adjacent to sro and layers @xmath109 and @xmath110 are between two lao layers .
the relative dielectric constant is @xmath90 , magnetic field @xmath99 .
the @xmath85 obtained from solution of bulk cubic systems with charge density set to the density on the given layer are also shown .
`` bulk l0 '' ( `` bulkl2 '' ) denotes a calculation performed for a bulk system with density the same as for @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) layer density .
inset : the electron layer density distribution corresponding to the susceptibility plot , @xmath4-axis is the layer index , @xmath113-axis is the layer density . on - site interactions
@xmath114ev , @xmath58ev . ] especially for the layer nearest the sro plane the @xmath115 curves exhibit weak upward curvature at the lowest temperatures studied . as shown in ref . , the curvature is a signature that the system is entering a fermi - liquid coherence regime .
the fermi liquid coherence temperature is highest for the layers nearest the sro because the charge in these planes is farther from the @xmath116 mott insulating state . to verify this we followed ref . and computed the wilson ratio @xmath117 for each layer of the superlattice for the case @xmath118 , finding ( not shown ) that for each layer the @xmath117 extrapolates to @xmath109 at low temperature .
the approach to the low temperature value is faster for layers with low density ( near sro planes ) than for layers with high density ( far from sro planes ) .
@xmath119 is the value for a kondo lattice , while ferromagnetism is characterized by an @xmath120.@xcite we therefore believe that for `` untilted '' superlattices , the differences in @xmath115 among layers arise from differences in quasiparticle coherence scale , there is no evidence for ferromagnetism in this system , consistent with the solution of the corresponding bulk problem . to gain insight into the physics underlying the layer dependence of @xmath115 we have computed @xmath85 for the cubic bulk system ( @xmath121 , @xmath37 is constructed from the two - dimensional dispersion @xmath122 ) for carrier densities equal to those on the different vo@xmath42 layers . in fig .
[ fig : slchi ] , we present bulk calculations for @xmath123 and @xmath124 corresponding to the densities calculated for layer @xmath15 and @xmath109 of the superlattice for all cases @xmath98 . for @xmath124 , bulk @xmath115 at @xmath125 and @xmath126ev
are very close to those of @xmath112 layer of @xmath31 superlattice , which has the same density . for @xmath127 superlattices , bulk @xmath124 , @xmath85 (
not shown ) almost coincides with those of @xmath112 layer . for bulk @xmath123
, the difference between bulk and superlattice @xmath111 layer is small .
these calculations demonstrate a general rule : within the single - site dmft approximation , the layer - resolved properties of a superlattice correspond closely to those of the corresponding bulk system at a density equal to that of the superlattice .
( color online ) comparison between bulk lvo partial dos ( positive curves ) and ( lavo@xmath3)@xmath3(srvo@xmath3)@xmath39 superlattice layer dos of layers near sro ( negative curves ) derived from band structure calculations ( dft+mlwf ) .
both systems have the same lattice structure for each case : untilted structure for the top panel and @xmath128 structure ( glazer s notation @xmath20 ) with @xmath129 and @xmath130 and @xmath131 for other panels .
the dos of bulk system is shifted towards higher energy so that bulk carrier density is the same as layer density of superlattices for the layers near sro ( @xmath132 ) .
the vertical dashed line marks the fermi level . ]
the superlattices of experimental relevance have crystal structures which are distortions of the `` untilted '' one , involving in particular a @xmath128 structure characterized by a rotational distortion of the @xmath20 type@xcite involving a large rotation about an axis approximately parallel to the growth direction and much smaller rotations about the two perpendicular axes .
[ fig : dos_bulk_sl ] compares the non - interacting dos of bulk and ( lvo)@xmath3(svo)@xmath39 superlattice systems ( both with the same @xmath128 structure ) calculated using dft and a mlwf parametrization of the frontier bands .
the dos of bulk system is shifted so that it has the same carrier density as layers of the superlattices near sro plane . for three different structures ( untilted structure and @xmath128 structure with @xmath133 and @xmath131 ) ,
the basic features of the partial dos are similar between bulk and superlattice .
the translation symmetry breaking in @xmath29-direction leads to small extra peaks in the superlattice dos .
these differences are smoothed out by the large imaginary part of the dmft self energy .
because the dmft equations depend only on the density of states it is reasonable to expect that , as in the untilted case , they will therefore give the same results in the superlattice as in the bulk material with corresponding density of states .
( color online ) comparison in temperature dependent inverse susceptibility between bulk lvo ( solid lines ) and ( lavo@xmath3)@xmath3(srvo@xmath3)@xmath39 superlattice ( dashed lines ) .
both have the same lattice structure @xmath128 with tilt angle @xmath134 and @xmath135 .
bulk system has the same densities as those of layers of superlattice near and far from sro planes ( @xmath136 ) .
left column : the plots in wide temperature range .
right column : the expanded views near zero temperature . ] to verify that this is the case we have also compared bulk and superlattice susceptibilities for tilted structures .
the four vo@xmath137 octahedra in a unit cell are related by rotation , so an appropriate choice of local basis means that only one calculation needs to be carried out for a given layer .
[ fig : bulkvslayertilted ] compares the inverse susceptibilities for an @xmath31 superlattice to calculations performed on a bulk system with the same @xmath128 structure .
in these calculations , we choose @xmath138 and dielectric constant @xmath139 .
we see that in this case , as in the `` untilted '' case , the superlattice inverse susceptibilities @xmath85 are almost the same as those for bulk system calculated at the same density , with differences only resolvable in the expanded view for the largest tilt angles .
in this section we present and explain our results for the magnetic phase diagram of ( lvo)@xmath38(svo)@xmath39 superlattices with the @xmath128 structure ( glazer s notation @xmath20 ) reported for the experimental systems.@xcite in these structures in - plane rotation along the growth direction @xmath141 $ ] is large @xmath130 ( presumably because of the strain imposed by the substrate ) , while the out - of - plane rotation is small ( @xmath129 ) perhaps because the system is free to relax along the growth direction .
we concentrate on the effect of the large rotation by fixing the in - plane angles to @xmath142 while varying the out - of - plane angles over a wide range from @xmath143 .
( color online ) partial dos derived from dft+mlwf for `` bulk '' @xmath128 structure ( glazer s notation @xmath20 ) with @xmath129 and @xmath144 changing from @xmath145 to @xmath131 .
only @xmath33 bands are plotted because @xmath146 bands are negligible in this range of energy . ]
based on the results of section [ sec : cubicsuperlattice ] we generate a phase diagram for the superlattice from calculations for a bulk system which is a @xmath128 distortion of the ideal cubic perovskite structure of chemical composition lavo@xmath3 .
the bulk system results are presented as a phase diagram in the plane of carrier concentration and @xmath9-rotation .
specific layers of the superlattice will correspond to particular points on the phase diagram , with the layer dependent density fixed by number of lvo layers @xmath2 and the dielectric constant @xmath70 and the rotation fixed by the substrate lattice parameter .
we use dft+mlwf methods to obtain the frontier orbital band structure for the @xmath33-derived antibonding bands
[ fig : pdos_p21 m ] presents representative results for the orbitally resolved local density of states . in this figure
the orbitals are defined with respect to the local basis defined by the 3 v - o bonds of a given vo@xmath137 octahedron .
we define @xmath141 $ ] as the axis ( approximately parallel to the growth direction ) about which the large rotation occurs .
[ fig : pdos_p21 m ] shows that @xmath147 and @xmath148 orbitals are almost degenerate , while @xmath44 orbital is strikingly different .
the dos of @xmath44 orbital maintains the shape of a two - dimensional energy dispersion with a van hove peak well above the chemical potential , similar to the bulk cubic structure ( see e.g. fig .
[ fig : dos]a ) .
there are noticeable differences only at very high rotation angles . on the other hand , @xmath147 and @xmath148
orbitals are spread out with two small peaks , because hoppings along @xmath4 or @xmath113 directions ( more distorted ) are different from those along @xmath29-direction ( less distorted ) .
when the distortion gets larger , the @xmath0-bandwidth becomes smaller , the @xmath44 peak gets larger and slightly closer to the fermi level , and @xmath147 and @xmath148 peaks near the fermi level also develop . based on @xmath149 generated by dft+mlwf , we carry out dmft calculations for in - plane rotation angle @xmath9 to get @xmath115 curves whose extrapolations define the curie temperatures @xmath87 .
[ fig : tc_evolve ] shows how @xmath87 evolves when the rotation angle @xmath9 increases from @xmath150 to @xmath135 . in this figure ,
we consider two different carrier densities @xmath151 and @xmath152 , corresponding to the band structure prediction for the layer densities of layers near and far from sro planes in the superlattice .
@xmath87 for @xmath153 is a slow function of rotation and is always negative for the range of @xmath9 under consideration , while @xmath87 for @xmath151 increases faster , so that the system becomes ferromagnetic when @xmath9 is between @xmath154 and @xmath131 .
ferromagnetism is therefore expected only in superlattices with very large rotations , and then only in the layers with large hole doping ( i.e. the layers closest to the sro planes ) .
( color online ) inverse susceptibility @xmath115 vs. temperature @xmath155 for bulk @xmath128 structure of lavo@xmath3 at densities @xmath151 ( black circle solid lines ) and @xmath153 ( red diamond dashed lines ) for rotation angle @xmath9 increasing from @xmath156 . on - site interaction @xmath114ev and @xmath58ev . left column : the circles and diamonds are data points , the solid and dashed lines are fitted from these data points .
right column : expanded view at small @xmath115 region .
the vertical dashed line marks zero temperature . ] from a range of calculations such as those shown in fig .
[ fig : tc_evolve ] we have constructed the superlattice magnetic phase diagram shown in fig .
[ fig : phase_diagram ] .
similar to ref . , there are uncertainties in our extrapolation for curie temperature , we consider @xmath157ev as the error bar for positions on the phase diagram .
thus , @xmath158ev is considered as @xmath159 within the error bar .
we see that ferromagnetism is favored only for very large rotations , much larger than the @xmath160 determined experimentally , and only for carrier concentrations far removed from @xmath116 .
we may locate the experimentally studied superlattices on this phase diagram . for an @xmath31 superlattice , band structure calculations indicate layer densities @xmath161 for layers near sro plane and @xmath152 for the other layers .
the experimentally determined rotation angle is @xmath162 .
these two points are indicated by squares in fig .
[ fig : phase_diagram ] .
( color online ) the magnetic phase diagram with @xmath4-axis carrier density @xmath163 and @xmath113-axis tilt and rotation angle along @xmath141 $ ] direction @xmath9 for bulk system lvo with the same type of distortion as for ( lvo)@xmath38(svo)@xmath39 superlattices ( @xmath128 structure ) , in - plane tilt angles @xmath164 . on - site interactions
@xmath114ev , @xmath58ev .
the white regime indicates absence of ferromagnetism ( @xmath165 ) , the colored regime indicates ferromagnetism with @xmath87 indicated by the color bar .
also indicated are results for bulk la@xmath5sr@xmath6vo@xmath3 in the @xmath1 structure , from ref . .
note that in the calculations for the @xmath1 structure all three tilt angles are almost the same . ]
it is interesting to compare our results to those previously obtained @xcite for the bulk solid solution la@xmath5sr@xmath6vo@xmath3 ( @xmath1 structure ) .
the dashed line in fig .
[ fig : phase_diagram ] shows the theoretically estimated phase diagram for the bulk solid solution .
we see that the bulk structure is more favorable for ferromagnetism than the superlattice structure .
an important difference between the @xmath1 structure and the @xmath128 of the superlattice is that in the former case all three tilt angles are of comparable magnitude whereas in the @xmath128 structure only one rotation is large .
we believe that this difference is responsible for the difference in phase boundary .
in this paper , we have studied the possibility of ferromagnetism in superlattice structures of vanadium oxides derived from lavo@xmath3 and srvo@xmath3 .
our investigation was based on the idea that ferromagnetism depends on an interplay between carrier density and octahedral rotation , and while these are coupled in bulk ( see the solid solution curve in fig .
[ fig : phase_diagram ] ) they may be decoupled in the superlattice . in particular
, the charge density varies across the superlattice , being lowest near the sro planes , while the rotation angle is controlled by the substrate .
thus in an appropriately designed superlattice at least some portions of the system might be moved closer to ( or perhaps into ) the ferromagnetic region . in several important aspects
this idea is consistent with calculations .
we find that the local carrier density determines the local magnetic susceptibility ( see section [ sec : cubicsuperlattice ] ) and the density / tilt angle relationship may be significantly altered ( see solid line and square points in fig .
[ fig : phase_diagram ] ) . however , we find that the @xmath128 octahedral rotation pattern characteristic of experimentally discovered superlattices is in fact less favorable to ferromagnetism than the @xmath1 pattern characteristic of bulk materials ( compare the phase boundaries in fig . [
fig : phase_diagram ] ) .
thus while the general idea that an appropriately designed superlattice might provide conditions favorable for ferromagnetism thereby providing a potential explanation for the remarkable experimental report of room - temperature ferromagnetism in ( lavo@xmath3)@xmath38(srvo@xmath3)@xmath39 superlattices with @xmath166 by lders et .
al.,@xcite ( even though there is no ferromagnetism in the bulk solid solution ) , our detailed findings are not consistent with the experimental result .
our results indicate that designing ferromagnetism into a vanadate superlattice will require both large amplitude rotations about the growth axis and also substantial rotations about the other two axes .
rotations about the growth axis arise from substrate - induced strain , so choosing substrates with smaller lattice parameter would be desirable .
introduction of rotations about the orthogonal axes may be done by replacing the la with a smaller counterion such as y. our study has certain limitations .
the calculations employ a frontier orbital model which includes only the @xmath33-derived antibonding bands .
dft+dmft calculations based on correlated atomic - like @xmath0-states embedded in the manifold of non - correlated oxygen states provide a more fundamental description .
our previous work@xcite indicates that the two models give very similar results if both calculations are tuned so that bulk lavo@xmath3 is a mott insulator , but the implications of the full ( but computationally very heavy ) dft+dmft procedure for the superlattice problem remain an open problem for future research .
further , our calculations are based on the single - site dmft approximation , which includes all local effects but misses inter - site correlations . while it is generally accepted that these calculations give the correct trends and qualitative behavior , the quantitative accuracy of the methods
is not known .
unfortunately , as yet cluster extensions of dmft are prohibitively expensive for the multiband models considered here .
the experimental results of lders et .
al.@xcite therefore provide an interesting challenge to materials theory .
they indicate that superlattices display ferromagnetism when the corresponding bulk solid solutions do not , whereas the present state of the art of real materials dynamical mean field calculations suggests that superlattices should be less likely to display magnetism than the corresponding bulk solid solutions .
this discrepancy requires further investigation .
we thank u. lders and j. okamoto for helpful conversations . we acknowledge support from doe - er046169 .
htd acknowledges partial support from vietnam education foundation ( vef ) .
we acknowledge travel support from the columbia - sorbonne - science - po ecole polytechnique alliance program and thank ecole polytechnique ( htd and ajm ) and jlich forschungszentrum ( htd ) for hospitality while portions of this work were conducted .
a portion of this research was conducted at the center for nanophase materials sciences , which is sponsored at oak ridge national laboratory by the scientific user facilities division , office of basic energy sciences , u.s .
department of energy .
we use the code for ct - hyb solver@xcite written by p. werner and e. gull , based on the alps library.@xcite
cccccccc atom & @xmath4 & @xmath113 & @xmath29 & atom & @xmath4 & @xmath113 & @xmath29 + la@xmath167 & 0 & 0.25 & 0 & la@xmath168 & 0.5 & 0.25 & 0.5 + v@xmath167 & 0.5 & 0 & 0 & v@xmath168 & 0 & 0 & 0.5 + o@xmath169 & 0.4662 & 0.25 & 0.0660 & o@xmath170 & 0.0392 & 0.25 & 0.4392 + o@xmath171 & 0.7638 & -0.0138 & 0.2362 & o@xmath172 & 0.2652 & -0.0493 & 0.2652 + + & @xmath173()&@xmath174( ) & @xmath175( ) & @xmath176 & @xmath24 ( ) & @xmath25 ( ) & @xmath26 ratio + exp .
lvo thin film@xcite & 5.55 & 7.82 & 5.55 & @xmath177 & 3.91 & 3.945 & 1.008 + exp .
superlattice@xcite & na & na & na & na & 3.88 & 3.95 & 1.018 + calculated with @xmath178 & 5.5988 & 7.8290 & 5.5821 & @xmath179 & 3.915 & 3.988 & 1.019 + calculated with @xmath180 & 5.5512 & 7.7623 & 5.5346 & @xmath179 & 3.881 & 3.954 & 1.019 + in this appendix , we present a more complete discussion of the strain - induced lattice distortions .
the in - plane lattice constant of a superlattice epitaxially grown on a substrate matches that of the substrate and may therefore be different from the lattice constant preferred in a free - standing film or bulk material .
the out - of - plane lattice constant is typically free to relax , and in the presence of an in - plane strain may also be different from that found in bulk materials . a difference in v - v distance may arise from a change in v - o bond length or from a difference in buckling of v - o bonds .
we consider both possibilities here , but first remark that the main differences in structure between bulk and experimentally studied superlattices arise from differences in octahedral rotation . in the experimentally - studied superlattices ,
the in - plane v - v distance is in fact slightly less than the v - v distance in lvo .
the v - o bond lengths have not been measured for the superlattice , but to a high degree of accuracy we are able to reconstruct the measured superlattice using the measured tilt angles given from experiments@xcite structure , assuming that all v - o bond lengths are equal . assuming the @xmath128 structure , we varied the in - plane and out - of - plane v - o bond lengths to fit the experimental data and found that @xmath181 only when the mean bond length @xmath0 is found in the range from @xmath182 to @xmath109 depending on which experimental result is fit but in all cases the v - o bond lengths are found to be equal to within an accuracy of @xmath183
. therefore , we believe that all the v - o bond lengths should , to a good approximation , be the same .
the structure used in our calculations is presented in table .
[ table : p21m_struct ] .
although there are slight mismatches in in - plane angle and lattice constants , the @xmath181 ratio and bond angles are compatible with the experiment .
( color online ) partial dos for bulk lvo with @xmath184 with the @xmath26 ratio due to a change in v - o bonds ( panel ( a ) ) and to @xmath128 lattice structure with @xmath185 ( similar to superlattice structure)(panel ( b ) ) .
the dashed blue curve is the @xmath44 orbital , the solid red curve is the degenerate @xmath147 ( or @xmath148 ) orbital .
the dashed vertical line marks the fermi level . ]
changing the amount of rotation has a different effect on the electronic structure than does changing the ratio of v - o bond lengths .
[ fig : bondlength_pdos ] compares the partial dos for the two cases , using as example a hypothetical lavo@xmath3 crystal with @xmath184 .
the upper panel presents the dos for the untilted structure with straight v - o - v bonds and the @xmath26 ratio induced by a difference in in - plane and out - of - plane v - o bond lengths .
the lower panel presents the case of all equal v - o bonds , with the @xmath26 ratio produced by octahedral rotations about the @xmath29 axis .
the densities of states are quite different , but can be understood from the simple energy dispersion @xmath186 where @xmath187 and @xmath188 are the in - plane and out - of - plane nearest neighbor hopping integrals and @xmath189 are the second neighbor hoppings .
the lower band edge is assumed to be the same for all orbitals but we assume that the lattice distortions lead to different values for the in - plane and out of plane hoppings .
( color online ) inverse susceptibility vs. temperature for cubic structure of bulk hole - doped lvo .
the in - plane and out - of - plane bondlengths are changed so that the octahedral volume is unchanged : tensile strain ( @xmath190 - black lines ) , no strain ( @xmath191 - red lines ) and compressive strain ( @xmath184 - blue lines ) . two levels of hole doping are considered : @xmath151 ( solid lines ) and @xmath153 ( dashed lines ) .
these lines are linear fits for the data points . ]
the lower band edge is defined to be zero and is independent of the distortion .
the energy of the upper edge of the @xmath44 band is @xmath192 and of the @xmath193 bands is @xmath194 .
the positions of the van hove singularities are at @xmath195 or @xmath196 . for @xmath44 band
there is only one van hove peak , at @xmath197 ; while for @xmath198 band , there are two van hove peaks at @xmath199 and @xmath200 .
when @xmath188 is different from @xmath187 , the difference in bandwidth of @xmath44 and @xmath148 orbitals is @xmath201 , which is also the distance between the two van hove peaks of @xmath148 band @xmath202 . with these definitions , we are in a position to understand the changes in the band structure . when the v - o bond lengths change ( fig .
[ fig : bondlength_pdos]a ) so that the @xmath29-bond is longer and the in - plane bond is shorter but the octahedral volume is unchanged , the band structure calculation indicates that @xmath188 decreases but @xmath187 increases slightly .
the difference between the bandwidth of the @xmath44 and @xmath198 bandwidths is @xmath201 which is the same as the splitting between the van hove peaks in the @xmath193 bands . on the other hand , if the @xmath26 ratio is produced by rotation , ( fig .
[ fig : bondlength_pdos]b ) , the change is opposite
. the in - plane hopping @xmath187 decreases because of the buckled in - plane v - o - v bonds , while the out - of - plane hopping @xmath188 is unchanged .
the @xmath44 band therefore narrows substantially relative to the @xmath193 bands .
in addition the splitting of the van hove peaks is greater . from the bandwidth of @xmath44 and @xmath148 bands ( fig .
[ fig : bondlength_pdos]b ) , @xmath203ev , @xmath204ev , the van hove peak distance is @xmath205ev , which is compatible with the peak positions shown in fig . [
fig : bondlength_pdos]b .
we tested with dmft calculations for the curie temperatures with the v - o bondlength changed .
[ fig : chi_bondlength ] is the temperature - dependent inverse susceptibility derived from dmft for the bulk cubic structure with the @xmath26 ratio changing from 0.98 ( tensile strain ) to 1.02 ( compressive strain ) .
for all the levels of hole doping under consideration , the results are nearly the same for every case of @xmath26 ratio .
we conclude that even when the v - o bondlength changes within the physical range , the ferromagnetism is not affected .
however , we also found that when the v - o bondlength is such that @xmath206 or @xmath207 , there is large orbital polarization and the ferromagnetism can be largely affected .
but that range is unphysical and can be neglected in the context of this work . | motivated by recent reports ( phys .
rev . b**80 * * , 241102 ) of room - temperature ferromagnetism in vanadium - oxide based superlattices , a single - site dynamical mean field study of the dependence of the paramagnetic - ferromagnetic phase boundary on superlattice geometry was performed .
an examination of variants of the experimentally determined crystal structure indicate that ferromagnetism is found only in a small and probably inaccessible region of the phase diagram .
design criteria for increasing the range over which ferromagnetism might exist are proposed . |
of the three most fundamental parameters of a star
mass , age and composition age is arguably the most difficult to obtain an accurate measure . direct measurements of mass ( e.g. , orbital motion , microlensing , asteroseismology ) and atmospheric composition ( e.g. , spectral analysis ) are possible for individual stars , but age determinations are generally limited to the coeval stellar systems for which stellar evolutionary effects can be exploited ( e.g. , pre - main sequence contraction , isochronal ages , post - main sequence turnoff ) .
individual stars can be approximately age - dated using empirical trends in magnetic activity , element depletion , rotation or kinematics that are calibrated against cluster populations and/or numerical simulations ( e.g. , @xcite )
. however , such trends are fundamentally statistical in nature , and source - to - source scatter can be comparable in magnitude to mean values .
age uncertainties are even more problematic for the lowest - mass stars ( m @xmath5 0.5 m@xmath2 ) , as post - main sequence evolution for these objects occurs at ages much greater than a hubble time , and activity and rotation trends present in solar - type stars begin to break down ( e.g. , @xcite ) . for the vast majority of intermediate - aged ( 110 gyr ) , very low - mass stars in the galactic disk , barring a few special cases ( e.g. , low - mass companions to cooling white dwarfs ; @xcite ) age determinations are difficult to obtain and highly uncertain .
ages are of particular importance for even lower - mass brown dwarfs ( m @xmath5 0.075 m@xmath2 ) , objects which fail to sustain core hydrogen fusion and therefore cool and dim over time @xcite .
the cooling rate of a brown dwarf is set by its age - dependent luminosity , while its initial reservoir of thermal energy is set by gravitational contraction and hence total mass .
as such , there is an inherent degeneracy between the mass , age and observable properties of a given brown dwarf in the galactic field population ; one can not distinguish between a young , low - mass brown dwarf and an old , massive one from spectral type , luminosity or effective temperature alone .
this degeneracy can be resolved for individual sources through measurement of a secondary parameter such as surface gravity , which may then be compared to predictions from brown dwarf evolutionary models ( e.g. , @xcite ) . however , surface gravity determinations are highly dependent on the accuracy of atmospheric models , which are known to have systematic problems at low temperatures due to incompleteness in molecular opacities ( e.g. , @xcite ) and dynamic atmospheric processes ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
discrete metrics such as the presence of absence of absorption ( depleted in brown dwarfs more massive than 0.065 m@xmath2 at ages @xmath6200 myr @xcite ) , are generally more robust but do not provide a continuous measure of age for brown dwarfs in the galactic field population .
binary systems containing brown dwarf components can be used to break this mass / age degeneracy without resorting to atmospheric models .
specifically , systems for which masses can be determined via astrometric and/or spectroscopic orbit measurements , and component spectral types , effective temperatures and/or luminosities assessed , can be compared directly with evolutionary models to uniquely constrain the system age ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
furthermore , by comparing the inferred ages and masses for each presumably coeval component , such systems can provide empirical tests of the evolutionary models themselves .
a benchmark example is the young ( @xmath7300 myr ) binary and perhaps triple brown dwarf system gliese 569b @xcite . with both astrometric and spectroscopic orbit determinations , and resolved component spectroscopy , this system has been used to explicitly test evolutionary model tracks and lithium burning timescales @xcite as well as derive component ages , which are found to agree qualitatively with kinematic arguments ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
other close binaries with astrometric or spectroscopic orbits have also been used for direct mass determinations ( e.g. , @xcite ) , but these systems generally lack resolved spectroscopy and therefore precise component characterization .
they have also tended to be young , preventing stringent tests of the long - term evolution of cooling brown dwarfs .
older , nearby very low - mass binaries with resolved spectra ( e.g. , @xcite ) generally have prohibitively long orbital periods for mass determinations .
recently , we identified a very low - mass binary system for which a spectroscopic orbit and component spectral types could be determined : the late - type source 2mass j03202839@xmath00446358 ( hereafter 2mass j0320@xmath00446 ; @xcite ) .
our independent discoveries of this system were made via two complementary techniques .
* hereafter bl08 ) identified this source as a single - lined radial velocity variable , with a period of 0.67 yr and separation @xmath70.4 au , following roughly 3 years of high - resolution , near - infrared spectroscopic monitoring ( see @xcite ) .
* hereafter bu08 ) demonstrated that the near - infrared spectrum of this source could be reproduced as an m8.5 plus t5@xmath11 unresolved pair , based on the spectral template matching technique outlined in @xcite .
the methods used by these studies have yielded both mass and spectral type constraints for the components of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 , and thus a rare opportunity to robustly constrain the age of a relatively old low - mass star and brown dwarf system in the galactic disk . in this article
, we determine a lower limit for the age of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 by combining the radial velocity measurements of bl08 and component spectral type determinations of bu08 with current evolutionary models . our method is described in @xmath8 2 , which includes discussion of sources of empirical uncertainty and systematic variations from four sets of evolutionary models .
we obtain lower limits on the age , component masses , and orbital inclination of the system , and compare our age constraint to expectations based on kinematics , magnetic activity and rotation of the primary component . in @xmath8
3 we discuss our results , focusing in particular on how future observations could provide bounded limits on the age and component masses of this system , and thereby facilitate tests of the evolutionary models themselves at late ages .
evolutionary models predict the luminosities and effective temperatures of cooling brown dwarfs over time , parameters that have been shown to correlate well with spectral type ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
luminosity is the more reliable parameter , being based on the measured distance and broad - band spectral flux of a source , as opposed to model - dependent determinations of photospheric gas temperature and/or radius .
however , in the case of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 , neither distance nor component fluxes have been measured , the latter due to the fact that this system is as yet unresolved ( and for the near future , unresolvable ; see @xmath8 3 ) .
we therefore used the component spectral types of this system and luminosity measurements for similarly - classified , single ( unresolved ) sources from @xcite and @xcite to estimate the component luminosities .
for the m8.5 primary , there are 13 m8m9 field dwarfs with bolometric luminosities ( parallax distance and broad - band spectral flux measurements ) reported in the studies listed above .
two of the sources the m8 lhs 2397a , a known binary @xcite ; and the m9 lp 944 - 20 , believed to be a younger system ( @xmath7500 myr , @xcite)are unusual sources and therefore excluded from this analysis .
the mean bolometric magnitude of the remaining stars is @xmath9 = [email protected] mag , corresponding to @xmath10 = [email protected] . for the t5@xmath11 secondary
, there are fewer field brown dwarfs with reliable luminosity measurements ( 1 t4.5 dwarf and 5 t6 dwarfs ) and these show considerably greater scatter in their bolometric magnitudes : @xmath9 = [email protected]
. this scatter may be due in part to unresolved multiplicity , which appears to be enhanced amongst the earliest - type t dwarfs @xcite .
hence , we estimated the luminosity of 2mass j0320@xmath00446b using the @xmath11/spectral type relation of @xcite } = [ 1.37376e1 , 1.90250e-1 , 1.73083e-2 , 7.40013e-3 , -1.75144e-3 , 1.14234e-4 , -2.32248e-06 ] , where @xmath11 = @xmath12spt@xmath13 and spt(t0 ) = 10 , spt(t5 ) = 15 , etc . ] .
a mean @xmath9 = [email protected] ( @xmath10 = [email protected] ) was adopted , where we have taken into account the uncertainty in the secondary spectral type and the @xmath11/spectral type relation ( 0.22 mag ) .
this value agrees well with estimates from ( * ? ? ?
* @xmath9 = [email protected] ) and ( * ? ? ?
* @xmath9 = [email protected] ) . in order to assess systematic uncertainties in the derived age and component properties
, we considered four different sets of evolutionary models in our analysis : the cloudless models of ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* hereafter tucson models ) , the `` cond '' cloudless models of ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter cond models ) , and the cloudless and cloudy models from ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter sm08 models ) .
all four sets of models assume solar metallicity , which is appropriate given that composite red optical and near - infrared spectra of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 show no indications of subsolar metallicity ( * ? ? ?
the choice of `` cloudless '' evolutionary models ( referring to the absence of condensate clouds in atmospheric opacities ) is driven partly by their availability .
in addition , the spectral energy distributions of the m8.5 and t5 components of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 are minimally affected by condensate cloud opacity ( e.g. , @xcite ) . however , cloud opacity in the intermediate l dwarf stage may slow radiative cooling during this phase and bias the inferred age of the t - type secondary ( sm08 ) , although @xcite have claimed that clouds have only a `` small effect '' on evolution . to test this possibility , we chose to examine both the cloudless and cloudy sm08 models , the latter of which takes into account photospheric cloud opacity in thermal evolution through the use of atmospheric models generated according to the prescriptions outlined in @xcite and sm08 .
figure [ fig_models ] compares the luminosity estimates for the two components of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 to the evolutionary tracks of each model set .
the luminosities ( and their uncertainties ) constrain the mass / age parameter space of each component , as illustrated in figure [ fig_mvst ] .
component masses generally increase with system age , as more massive low mass stars and brown dwarfs take longer to radiate their greater reservoir of heat energy from initial contraction .
the mass of the primary of this system reaches an asymptotic value of @xmath70.080.09 m@xmath2 for ages @xmath61 gyr , consistent with a hydrogen - fusing very low - mass star .
if the system is younger than @xmath7400 myr , the primary could be substellar .
note that ages @xmath5300 myr ( primary masses @xmath140.065 m@xmath2 ) can be ruled out based on the absence of absorption at 6708 in the unresolved red optical spectrum of this source @xcite .
the mass of the secondary increases across the full age range shown in figure [ fig_mvst ] as this component is substellar up to 10 gyr .
there is some divergence in the evolutionary tracks at late ages for this component , however ; the tucson models predict a mass near the hydrogen - burning limit , while the sm08 cloudless and cloudy models predict masses above and below the li - burning minimum mass , respectively .
the kink in the mass / age relation of 2mass j0320@xmath00446b at ages of 200 - 300 myr , particularly in the cond and sm08 models , reflects the prolonged burning of deuterium in brown dwarfs with masses just above 0.013 m@xmath2 , producing higher luminosities at this temporary stage of evolution .
the mass ratio of the system , @xmath15 m@xmath16/m@xmath17 , also increases as a function of age , ranging from @xmath70.2 at 100 myr to a maximum of @xmath70.8 at 10 gyr . with constraints in the mass / age phase space provided by the component luminosities and evolutionary models
, we can now use the radial velocity orbit to break the mass / age degeneracy .
the radial velocity variations measured by bl08 only probe the recoil velocity of the primary of the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 system .
these observations provide a coupled constraint between the masses and inclination of the system : @xmath18 ( bl08 ) where @xmath19 is the inclination angle of the orbit , and m@xmath17 and m@xmath16 are the masses of the primary and secondary components in solar mass units , respectively .
we can make a geometric constraint that @xmath20 , which yields a transcendental equation for the lower limit of the secondary component mass of the system as a function of the primary component mass . using our age - dependent lower bound for the latter based on the evolutionary models ( including luminosity uncertainties ) the constraint on @xmath21 from eqn .
1 translates into a minimum secondary mass as a function of age , as shown in figure [ fig_mvst ] .
finally , the age at which the upper bound of the secondary component mass ( based on the evolutionary models ) crosses the radial velocity minimum mass line corresponds to the minimum age of the system .
all four models predict a minimum age for 2mass j0320@xmath00446 in the range 1.72.2 gyr ( table [ tab_modelfit ] ) . this age is in qualitative and quantitative agreement with those inferred by bl08 from the kinematics of the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 system space motions of this system
are @xmath22 = -38@xmath15 km s@xmath23 , @xmath24 = -20@xmath13 km s@xmath23 and @xmath25 = -32@xmath14 km s@xmath23 , where we assume an lsr solar motion of @xmath26 = 10 km s@xmath23 , @xmath27 = 5.25 km s@xmath23 and @xmath28 = 7.17 km s@xmath23 @xcite .
@xcite , equation 8 , predicts an age @xmath291.6 gyr at the 95% confidence level for these kinematics . ] and
stellar age / activity trends . in the case of the latter , the optical spectrum of 2mass
j0320@xmath00446 shows no detectable h@xmath30 emission @xcite , even though @xmath2990% of nearby m8m9 dwarfs exhibit such emission @xcite .
for comparison , @xcite estimate an `` activity lifetime '' ( i.e. , timescale for h@xmath30 emission to drop below detectable levels ) of 8@xmath31 gyr for m7 dwarfs
. this age may be too high of an estimate for 2mass j0320@xmath00446 , as the increase in activity lifetimes for spectral types m2m7 observed by @xcite may not continue for later spectral types .
magnetic field lines are increasingly decoupled from lower - temperature photospheres , and the frequency and strength of h@xmath30 emission decrease rapidly beyond type m7/m8 ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
hence , the absence of magnetic emission from 2mass j0320@xmath00446a is merely indicative of an older age , as is its kinematics .
rotation is a third commonly - used empirical age diagnostic for stars , based on the secular angular momentum loss observed amongst solar - type stars through the emission magnetized stellar winds ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , so - called gyrochronological relations calibrated for these stars are not necessarily applicable to lower - mass objects , due both to the fully convective interiors of the latter and the decoupling of field lines from low - temperature atmospheres ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
indeed , 2mass j0320@xmath00446a proves to be a relatively rapid rotator , with an equatorial spin velocity of @xmath32 = [email protected] km s@xmath23 and a rotation period @xmath14 7.4 hr ( bl08 ) . for solar - type stars
, this rapid rotation generally indicates a young age ; an extrapolation ( in color ) of gyrochronology relations by ( * ? ? ?
* equation 3 , assuming @xmath33 @xmath34 2.1 for 2mass j0320@xmath00446a ; e.g. , @xcite ) yields an age of only @xmath70.1 myr .
this is inconsistent with the absence of absorption , space kinematics and lack of magnetic emission from this source .
clearly , rotation does not provide a useful age metric for the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 system , further emphasizing the breakdown of age / angular momentum trends in the lowest - mass stars .
the derived minimum age and radial velocity constraints of the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 system allow us to constrain model - dependent minimum masses for its components as well ; m@xmath17 @xmath35 0.0800.082 m@xmath2 and m@xmath16 @xmath35 0.0530.054 m@xmath2 .
the ranges in these values reflect variations between the four evolutionary models ( table [ tab_modelfit ] ) .
note that there is essentially no difference in the minimum masses inferred from the cloudy and cloudless sm08 models .
the minimum mass ratio of the system , @xmath36 0.600.62 , is also consistent across the evolutionary models , and in accord with the general preference of large mass ratio systems observed amongst very low - mass binaries ( @xmath2990% of known binaries with @xmath37 m@xmath2 have @xmath38 ; see @xcite ) . finally , while the minimum ages and masses of 2mass j0320@xmath00446 are inferred assuming @xmath20 , it is possible to constrain the maximum masses and minimum orbital inclination of this system assuming an upper age limit .
adopting @xmath39 10 gyr , we infer @xmath40 0.800.86 , corresponding to @xmath41 53@xmath4259@xmath42 .
this constraint is only slightly more restrictive than the @xmath43 lower limit determined by bl08 assuming that the fainter secondary must have a lower mass than the primary .
it does not significantly improve the chances that this system is an eclipsing edge - on system ( @xmath70.3% by geometry ) .
maximum primary ( 0.088 m@xmath2 ) and secondary masses ( 0.0660.075 m@xmath2 ) are effectively set by the luminosity constraints and evolutionary models .
here we see the most significant difference between the models , a 13% discrepancy in the maximum mass of the secondary component , likely due to different treatments of light element fusion near the li- and h - burning minimum masses .
this variation confirms the importance of older binary systems as tests of long - term brown dwarf evolution , particularly near fusion mass limits .
we also note that there is little difference ( @xmath74% ) in the maximum masses inferred from the sm08 cloudy and cloudless models , illustrating again the negligible role of cloud opacity in the long - term evolution of brown dwarfs like 2mass j0320@xmath00446b .
the combination of component luminosities , radial velocity orbit of the primary and evolutionary models have allowed us to estimate the minimum age of the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 system and its component masses .
the ages are consistent between four evolutionary models of brown dwarfs , and are more precise ( although not necessarily more accurate ) than estimates based on as - yet poorly - constrained statistical trends in kinematics , magnetic activity and angular momentum evolution .
however , a bounded age estimate remains elusive due to the unknown inclination of the system and determination of component masses . as discussed in bl08 ,
the inclination of the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 orbit is irrelevant if the radial velocity orbit of the secondary can be determined . in that case , one need only compare the derived system mass ratio and component luminosities to evolutionary models to obtain a bounded age estimate .
measurement of the secondary motion in the @xmath44-band data of bl08 was not possible due to the very large flux contrast between the components ; bl08 rule out a contrast ratio of @xmath510:1 at these wavelengths ; spectral template fits from bu08 predict a contrast ratio of @xmath6350:1
. a more effective approach would be the acquisition of radial velocity measurements in the 1.2 - 1.3 @xmath4 band where the t dwarf secondary is considerably brighter and the contrast ratio is closer to 20:1 ( depending on the absolute magnitude scale ; see discussion in bu08 ) . at these contrasts , the radial velocity of the secondary can be measured using existing techniques for high - contrast spectroscopic binary systems ( e.g. , @xcite ) . alternately , if this system is observed to eclipse , then @xmath45 and the age of the system is uniquely determined .
table [ tab_modelfit ] lists the ages corresponding to this scenario , ranging from 2.5@xmath46 gyr to 3.2@xmath47 gyr for the four models examined ( uncertainties include the full range of possible primary and secondary masses for which eqn . 1 and the luminosity constraints are satisfied ) .
the relatively small age uncertainties estimated in this scenario ( 2560% ) are dominated by uncertainties in the component luminosities , which could be measured from primary and secondary eclipse depths over a broad range of optical and infrared wavelengths ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
such measurements are currently more feasible than resolved imaging measurements , as the tight separation inferred from the radial velocity orbit , @xmath48 = @xmath49 0.4 au ( bl08 , assuming @xmath50 ) , implies a projected separation of @xmath517 mas , below the diffraction limit of the keck 10 m telescope at near - infrared wavelengths . yet the scientifically valuable measurements possible in an eclipsing scenario must be tempered by this scenario s low probability . for a maximum age of 10 gyr , we can only constrain the inclination of the 2mass j0320@xmath00446 system to @xmath3 , and hence an eclipse probability of @xmath70.3% . regardless of whether 2mass j0320@xmath00446 is an eclipsing pair ,
determination of its orbit inclination and/or component masses is a necessary step for testing brown dwarf evolutionary models at late ages , specifically through agreement of system parameters with model isochrones ( c.f .. , @xcite ) .
the power of such a test is the long lever arm of time provided by older field binaries such as 2mass j0320@xmath00446 , resulting in large differences in luminosities and effective temperatures for the more common near equal - mass systems ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
there may in fact be many such systems to exploit in this manner .
simulations by bu08 of brown dwarf pairs in the vicinity of the sun predict that 12 - 25% of all m8l5 dwarf binaries have component spectral types that can be inferred from unresolved , near - infrared spectroscopy using the method outlined in @xcite .
perhaps as many as 50% of these systems may be short - period radial velocity variables @xcite .
identification and follow - up of these systems would complement the evolutionary model tests currently provided by younger systems @xcite and would more robustly address uncertainties associated with low - temperature light - element fusion , interior thermal transport , and substellar interior structure as their effects are compounded over time .
the authors thank i. baraffe , a. burrows , m. marley and d. saumon for making electronic versions of their evolutionary models available ; and m. liu for identifying the roundoff errors in the @xmath11/spectral type relation in @xcite .
we also thank our referee , k. luhman , for his helpful critique of the original manuscript .
cb acknowledges support from the harvard origins of life initiative . this publication has made use of the vlm binaries archive maintained by nick siegler at http://www.vlmbinaries.org .
burgasser , a. j. , reid , i. n. , siegler , n. , close , l. m. , allen , p. , lowrance , p. j. , & gizis , j. e. 2007 , in planets and protostars v , eds .
b. reipurth , d. jewitt and k. keil ( univ .
arizona press : tucson ) , p. 427
wilson , j. c. , miller , n. a. , gizis , j. e. , skrutskie , m. f. , houck , j. r. , kirkpatrick , j. d. , burgasser , a. j. , & monet , d. g. 2003 , in brown dwarfs ( iau symp .
211 ) , ed .
e. martn ( san francisco : asp ) , p. 197
lcccc minimum age ( gyr ) & 1.7 & 2.2 & 2.2 & 2.0 + minimum @xmath51 & 0.80 ( 53@xmath42 ) & 0.82 ( 55@xmath42 ) & 0.83 ( 56@xmath42 ) & 0.86 ( 59@xmath42 ) + m@xmath17 ( m@xmath2 ) & 0.0820.088 & 0.0800.088 & 0.0820.088 & 0.0820.088 + m@xmath16 ( m@xmath2 ) & 0.0540.075 & 0.0530.070 & 0.0540.069 & 0.0540.066 + m@xmath16/m@xmath17 & 0.620.89 & 0.600.87 & 0.610.84 & 0.610.80 + age for @xmath52 ( gyr ) & 2.5@xmath46 & 3.2@xmath47 & 3.0@xmath53 & 2.8@xmath54 + | 2mass j03202839@xmath00446358ab is a recently identified , late - type m dwarf / t dwarf spectroscopic binary system for which both the radial velocity orbit for the primary and spectral types for both components have been determined . by combining these measurements with predictions from four different sets of evolutionary models ,
we determine a minimum age of [email protected] gyr for this system , corresponding to minimum primary and secondary masses of 0.080 m@xmath2 and 0.053 m@xmath2 , respectively .
we find broad agreement in the inferred age and mass constraints between the evolutionary models , including those that incorporate atmospheric condensate grain opacity ; however , we are not able to independently assess their accuracy
. the inferred minimum age agrees with the kinematics and absence of magnetic activity in this system , but not the rapid rotation of its primary , further evidence of a breakdown in angular momentum evolution trends amongst the lowest luminosity stars . assuming a maximum age of 10 gyr
, we constrain the orbital inclination of this system to @xmath3 . more precise constraints on the orbital inclination and/or component masses of 2mass 0320@xmath00446ab , through either measurement of the secondary radial velocity orbit ( optimally in the 1.21.3 @xmath4 band ) or detection of an eclipse ( only 0.3% probability based on geometric constraints ) , would yield a bounded age estimate for this system , and the opportunity to use it as an empirical test for brown dwarf evolutionary models at late ages . |
modern astronomy requires state - of - the - art technology for the efficient detection of the faintest light from the farthest reaches of the universe .
it is not uncommon for the technologies developed by astronomers to find uses in everyday life .
rosenberg et al,@xcite have compiled numerous examples of such technology transfer including , but not limited to : ccds popularized by the _ hubble space telescope _ and now used in practically every digital camera ; wireless local area networking utilizing algorithms from image processing in radio astronomy ; computerized tomography in modern medical scanners based on aperture synthesis techniques from radio interferometry ; and gamma ray spectrometers for lunar / planetary surface composition analysis now used to probe historical buildings and artefacts .
ongoing successes in sub - millimeter astronomy ( e.g. the _ _
herschel__@xcite and _ _
planck__@xcite space telescopes ) and the ever present demand for instruments with improved sensitivities and mapping speeds at terahertz ( thz ) frequencies have spurred the development of highly sensitive detectors , sophisticated optical components , cutting edge electronics , and advanced data processing techniques .
kinetic inductance detectors ( kids ) are contemporary superconducting pair - breaking detectors that operate across the spectrum from x - ray to sub - thz frequencies@xcite . compared to alternative thz technologies such as semiconductor or transition edge sensor ( tes ) bolometers , kids are relatively simple to fabricate and read out . as such , they provide a practical and cost - effective solution to the manufacture and operation of the large format arrays required for advances in many fields of thz astronomy . a variant known as the lumped element kid , or lekid@xcite ,
has been demonstrated to provide state - of - the - art performance at millimeter - wavelengths@xcite and has seen first light as part of the nika@xcite instrument at the iram 30-m telescope .
projects such as the next generation blast experiment@xcite , nika-2@xcite and a - mkid are currently under way to incorporate multi - kilopixel kid arrays into astronomical cameras with the potential for thz megapixel imaging within the next decade . beyond astronomy , the thz region of the electromagnetic spectrum ( 0.1 - 10thz ) has applications in a range of fields academic and industrial@xcite .
in addition to the presence of a multitude of interesting spectral features , many typically opaque materials become transparent when viewed in this frequency range . various disciplines including biomedical
sensing , non - destructive testing , and security screening now have the opportunity to benefit from the highly sensitive and highly multiplexable detector technology being developed by astronomers .
for example , thz radiation is being used to study protein dynamics@xcite , to investigate thz induced dna damage@xcite , and as a potential imaging modality for the improved delineation of certain types of skin cancers@xcite . however , there are currently no off - the - shelf thz imaging spectrometers or cameras available to help proceed more rapidly with these investigations . the analysis and restoration of cultural artefacts benefits from the unique differential penetration of thz radiation , making it ideal for the non - destructive investigation of the internal paint layers in pieces of art@xcite .
time domain techniques have been used to show that unique information can be gleaned at thz frequencies to verify the age , chemical composition and structure of works of art . however ,
such time - domain techniques are not necessarily time efficient .
far larger potential demand is associated with the detection of hidden objects ( such as land mines@xcite ) , process control in manufacturing@xcite , and security screening@xcite .
active mm - wave scanners are now widely deployed in airports across the globe and large format kid arrays could be used to produce systems with improved sensitivity at a comparable cost .
the capacity for truly passive imaging , and the fast time - response of lekid detectors ( typically @xmath2sec ) enables , for the first time , the possibility of capturing images at video rate for so called `` walk through '' systems .
this is regarded as desirable by ecac ( the european civil aviation conference ) and opens up the possibility of use in situations where requiring people to stand one - by - one in a booth is not practical@xcite .
furthermore , multi - spectral observations would improve image contrast and reduce the number of false positives a common occurrence with current active systems . to demonstrate these capabilities ,
we have built and characterized a simple field scanning camera based on a 152 element linear array of lekids operating at 350ghz .
the detectors have been optimized to perform under the optical loads present at ambient room temperatures ( @xmath1300k ) , which are substantially higher than the backgrounds present during astronomical observations .
the instrument , in its present configuration , is comparable in performance to other recent passive imaging systems including those based on room temperature microbolometer fpas@xcite , cooled bolometer arrays@xcite , and superconducting tes arrays@xcite . in this article
we describe the camera and its achieved performance as a quasi - video - rate system .
we conclude with discussions of the improvements which will be implemented for the next generation camera in order to achieve a full video - rate , photon - noise limited imaging system .
our goal was to demonstrate a video rate scanner capable of imaging variations in the thermal thz radiation received from a moving target ( a person ) with sufficient sensitivity to detect and identify concealed objects - akin to airport - style security scanners or other stand - off scanning instruments .
the basic requirements were for a simple - to - use system with the necessary spatial resolution , scanning speed and sensitivity to identify objects of a few cm in size concealed behind clothing or inside bags or other luggage .
the camera is designed to provide a @xmath3 m useful field of view ( typical of body scanners ) with operation at a distance of 3 - 5 m from the target and a linear resolution of roughly 1 cm . the camera observes in the 350ghz transparent atmospheric window with a @xmath4% wide band to minimize the loading and thermal fluctuations present at less transparent frequencies . as a demonstration system , quasi - video rate imaging with frames updating at least every second was deemed acceptable although the goal would be to reach full 25hz video rate
. a 0.1k noise equivalent temperature difference , ne@xmath5 t , in each frame is required as this is necessary to identify the shape of concealed objects@xcite .
finally , the superconducting detectors need to be operated at sub - kelvin temperatures , so the camera requires a completely dry cryogenic system which , unlike wet systems , can be easily deployed in the field . ideally , the noise performance of the system would be limited by variance in the arrival of photons from the source rather than from any components of the camera itself . the noise equivalent power due to photons measured at the detector focal plane in a diffraction limited optics system
is given by@xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 is planck s constant , @xmath8 is the frequency , @xmath9 is the optical bandwidth , and @xmath10 for a detector absorbing light in both polarizations .
@xmath11 is the power in a band of width @xmath9 : @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the camera tendue , @xmath14 is the emissivity and @xmath15 is the blackbody radiance of a source at temperature @xmath16 , while @xmath17 and @xmath18 are respectively the optics and detector efficiencies .
note that both shot and wave noise are accounted for in equation [ nep ] .
the camera employs a linear array of detectors housed in a research cryostat retrofitted with a large ( 250 mm diameter ) window in the base .
incoming radiation is coupled to the detectors through a refractive optics system and a flat beam - folding mirror .
a thin horizontal section of the object plane is observed in any one instant and this section is scanned continuously in the vertical direction by oscillation of the beam - folding mirror .
this is illustrated in figure [ fig : kidcam ] .
the orientation of the mirror is recorded with an absolute encoder and images are reconstructed in real time by the acquisition electronics in a scheme no dissimilar to that of a common office desktop scanner .
a photo of the current system ( left ) and a schematic ( right ) of the system overlaid with the zemax model and ray traces .
the camera sees a small horizontal strip of the object plane in one instance with the oscillating fold mirror providing full sampling in the vertical direction . ]
a fast ( @xmath19 ) triplet of high - density polyethylene ( hdpe ) lenses was designed to keep the optics simple and compact given limitations on where the focal plane array could be situated within the cryostat . to achieve the desired resolution at these frequencies , a large diameter ( 440 mm ) primary lens , l1 , was chosen .
the focal distance of the camera is designed to be adjustable between 3 and 5 meters depending on the position of the secondary lens , l2 . at a distance of 3.5 m ,
the scannable field of view is [email protected] m and the working depth of field is approximately @xmath21150 mm inside and outside of the focus .
the third lens , l3 , visible in the cad model in figure [ fig : cryo - composite]a , is housed within the cryostat behind the hdpe window and a number of thermal blocking filters@xcite ( not shown in the figure ) .
the lens and window absorptivities were measured in band and are non - negligible , with combined losses of up to 45% expected through the optics chain .
furthermore , the hdpe components are not anti - reflection coated and are uncooled ( except l3 ) .
consequently , stray light from these sources contributes significantly to detector loading .
the oscillating beam - folding mirror is constructed from a thin , polished sheet of aluminum ( 800 mm long by 550 mm wide ) braced with strut profile and mounted to the camera s main frame via a set of bearings on the central horizontal axis .
the oscillation is brought about by a crank wheel driven by a servo motor located behind the mirror .
a small steel rod with bearings at each end connects the mirror to the wheel .
the oscillation rate is controlled by a motor driver that is configured via usb from the control station .
this mechanism can modulate the field of view at a maximum frequency of 2 - 3 frames per second , this ultimately limits the video rate output .
cross sections of the cryostat and focal plane assembly .
( a ) the model shows the focal plane array ( green ) mounted via various thermally isolating support structures to the 4k base plate and connected to the helium-10 fridge ( yellow ) .
optical paths from the focal plane , through the quasi - optical filters , baffles ( not shown ) , cold lens and the cryostat window are indicated by the transparent cones .
( b ) the schematic shows the coupling mechanism for a single array element .
the aluminum lekid device is back - illuminated through the silicon substrate via a back - to - back conical feedhorn and the final band - defining filter .
any radiation that is not absorbed by the detector is caught by a layer of silicon carbide infused epoxy at the back of the array packaging . ] a series of quasi - optical metal - mesh filters@xcite define the optical bandwidth of the system .
currently , three low - pass edges with cut - offs at 630ghz , 540ghz , and 450ghz and two 10% wide band - pass filters define a combined 6% wide band centered at 347ghz
. the additional bandpass filter was added as a precaution against detector saturation with the effect of reducing the overall bandwidth and the camera optical efficiency .
the filter profiles were measured by a fourier transform spectrometer ( fts ) from 200ghz to 1thz with 1ghz resolution and are displayed in figure [ fig : filters ] .
inset to the figure is a plot of the total transmittance of the filter stack .
the peak in - band transmission is 45% and the out - of - band rejection at high frequency is better than 100db .
the spectral transmittance of the band - defining quasi - optical filters .
the product of these profiles is indicated by the black line and is re - plotted on a log scale in the inset to show the high out of band rejection .
thermal filters are excluded for clarity as these have @xmath1100% transmission in band . ]
the large cryostat window and the requirement for fast optics make the focal plane susceptible to off axis radiation .
to lessen the effects , sic blackened metal baffles are arranged at the entrances to the three radiation shields and a copper horn - plate is mounted to the detector array at the focal plane , see figure [ fig : cryo - composite]b .
the feedhorns are each approximately @xmath22 and although this helps prevent stray light reaching the detectors , there is a slight mismatch with the @xmath19 refracting optics .
the cylindrical waveguides connecting the back - to - back horns admit at most two transverse electromagnetic modes , the te@xmath23 and tm@xmath24 modes . the number of detectors in the array needed to achieve the required performance is estimated . each lens in the system
is characterized by its emissivity and transmission properties . l1 and l2 and the window operate at 300k , while l3 is estimated to be at 150k .
having measured the hdpe transmission , we estimate the overall lens transmission using zemax .
the overall instrument efficiency , including the filters , is 23% , corresponding to an expected optical load of 131pw per detector at the focal plane assembly .
the photon noise ( including both the shot noise and wave noise components ) at the focal plane is then calculated from equation [ nep ] to be 3.0mk@xmath25 .
this allows us to estimate that in order to achieve an image sensitivity of @xmath10.1k per frame at a 25hz frame rate and a 1 cm resolution , 150 detectors are required .
note that to first order this is independent from the detector and optical efficiencies , as it is wave noise that currently dominates the noise budget .
the detector array in use for this demonstration system is composed of 152 lekids arranged in 8 rows of 19 columns .
the columns are skewed such that the instantaneous field of view is nyquist sampled in the horizontal direction ( see figure [ fig : array ] ) . the array and packaging .
the detectors are arranged to nyquist sample a horizontal section of the object plane . for readout
, each detector modulates a small range of the total bandwidth of the probe signal that propagates along the feedline .
the feedline can be seen winding between the rows of detectors and is terminated to sma type connectors at each end . ] in general , a kinetic inductance detector ( kid ) is fabricated by patterning a thin film of superconducting material in such a way as to create an @xmath26 resonant circuit with frequency @xmath27 .
the inductance of the superconductor , @xmath28 , has two key components , @xmath29 .
these depend , respectively , on the shape of the deposited film and the density of cooper pairs in the film .
photons that couple into the resonator with sufficient energy to overcome the superconducting gap will break cooper pairs into unbound pairs of quasiparticle excitations , leading to a decrease in @xmath30 .
then , any variations in incident optical power are monitored by measuring the variations in @xmath30 .
this is achieved by monitoring the complex transmission of a probe signal that is fed through a microwave transmission line adjacent to the resonator .
multiple resonators , each with a different @xmath30 , may be coupled to the same transmission line and read out simultaneously with a superposition of probe signals .
this inherent multiplexing capability considerably reduces the requirement for complex cryogenic circuitry .
lumped - element kids as opposed to distributed kids are designed such that the absorbing element of the detector is part of the resonator structure itself . in this configuration
it is possible to achieve very high filling factors in focal plane arrays without the need for additional coupling optics such as microlens or feedhorn arrays .
note that the feedhorns used in this system are for stray light reduction and would not be necessary in a well baffled optical system .
each lumped resonator in the current focal plane array has three sections : an inductor , an interdigital capacitor and a coupling capacitor .
these are highlighted by the different colored sections in the design and the equivalent circuit in figure [ fig : detector]a .
the inductor section is a 4th order hilbert curve which efficiently couples to both orthogonal polarizations of incoming radiation@xcite .
variations in the length of the interdigital capacitor sections have been designed to set a range of resonant frequencies centered at 1.5ghz and each separated by 3mhz .
the detectors are capacitively coupled to a coplanar waveguide ( cpw ) feedline , with the length of the coupling capacitor section and its distance from the feedline limiting the q - factor of the resonators to be of the order of 10,000 .
the array is fabricated from a 40 nm aluminum film thermally deposited onto a 500@xmath0 m high resistivity float - zone silicon wafer .
the array design was patterned into the aluminum in a single photolithographic cycle with a wet etch of orthophosphoric acid , nitric acid , and water in a 25:2:6 ratio .
the cpw line is cross - bonded with wire bridges at regular intervals to ensure a constant potential across the ground plane , thus inhibiting problematic slotline modes in the cpw line .
figure [ fig : cryo - composite]b shows a cross section of a single detecting element in the focal plane assembly .
optical coupling is optimised by back - illumination of the detectors through the silicon substrate .
thin film aluminum has a superconducting transition temperature of @xmath31k and kid arrays require cooling to at least @xmath32 in order to sufficiently reduce the density of quasiparticles in the superconducting film .
the current system utilizes a cryomech pt400 series pulse - tube - cooler ( ptc ) and air - cooled compressor unit that operate off mains electricity only so that no liquid cryogens are required .
a closed - cycle helium-10 adsorption fridge from chase cryogenics@xcite cools the focal plane assembly to the required sub - kelvin temperatures .
thermometry and fridge - cycling are fully automated and may be monitored / controlled remotely .
cool - down of the current system from room temperature takes around 36 hours with the ptc cold plate settling at 3.2k .
the optical baffles on the radiation shields settle at 4.2k and 60k respectively , and the cold lens settles with a radial temperature gradient ranging between 100 - 150k . in the present configuration , fridge cycles continue for approximately 16 - 18 hours at 250mk and require up to 4 hours for recycling .
the electronic readout system consists of cryogenic , warm and digital components ( see figure [ fig : readout ] ) , as well as a suite of software to control the camera components , to monitor the housekeeping system and to generate and display images in real - time .
the nature of multi - channel kid read out is such that the complexity of the cryogenic electronics is reduced to an absolute minimum . aside from the detector
array itself , a single attenuator , a single low noise amplifier , and a single set of coaxial cables are the only components required within the cold stages .
an overview of the readout system .
tones are output by the nikel digital electronics system , mixed up to the required kid resonant frequency range , and passed into the cryostat through a single coaxial cable .
the probe signal is attenuated before reaching the detectors and then boosted by a si - ge cryogenic low noise amplifier at the 4kelvin stage . outside of the cryostat
the signal is mixed back down to the daq band and read back in to the nikel electronics for spectral decomposition .
the i and q components of up to 400 tones are sent over network to the control computer for processing and image generation . ]
the cpw transmission is wire - bonded to sma connectors mounted to the copper array packaging .
stainless steel semi - rigid coaxial cable then feeds out to the 4k stage .
a cold attenuator on the input channel reduces the power ( and therefore the thermal noise ) of the multiplexed probe signal prior to the detector array . a high gain , low noise , caltech citlf4 sige amplifier on the output channel boosts the probe signal prior to readout .
copper semi - rigid coaxial cable then feeds out to hermetic sma connectors on the cryostat exterior .
a schematic of the cryogenic readout system is presented in figure [ fig : detector](b ) .
a room temperature analog mixing circuit converts the probe signal to and from the 1.25 - 1.75ghz detector readout band and the 0 - 500mhz digital electronics band .
an r&s smf100a signal generator is used as the lo input for a pair of marki iq mixers and a combination of amplifiers and variable attenuators are in place to balance the incoming and outgoing power levels .
the digital system is a nikel@xcite ( new iram kid electronics ) frequency domain multiplexing system developed for the nika astronomical camera .
it has the ability to output the in - phase and quadrature ( i and q ) components of the superposition of up to 400 cordic - generated tones across 500mhz of dac bandwidth .
a single adc feeds into a polyphase filter bank and the resultant 400 independent decomposed i and q timestreams ( as well as the mirror encoder values and other housekeeping data ) are decimated and sent via the on - board computer over ethernet to the control station .
the sample rate is limited to 477hz which provides a data rate of 24mbps .
the control station is a desktop computer equipped with a custom software suite for control of the readout electronics , data acquisition , image generation and graphical display .
the readout electronics system is initialized with commands sent over udp to the nikel on - board computer .
the detector responses ( variations in @xmath30 , aka @xmath33 ) are computed from linear transformations of the raw i and q timestreams using coefficients from frequency sweep data taken across the resonators during initialization .
a flat field calibration is performed at the start of each run where the detector responses are measured between a 30@xmath34c glow bar and a room temperature section of the field of view .
the raw i and q , the transformed amplitude , phase , and @xmath33 , and the calibrated response time - streams can be accessed and displayed alongside their power spectral densities using the real - time plotting software kst . otherwise , image generation is performed on a scan - by - scan basis by reading the latest data , applying the transformations and calibrations , binning these products into a map , and updating the graphical interface with a new frame . broken or poorly performing detectors can cause blank or noisy columns in the image frames however these can be digitally filtered or interpolated over in real - time to improve the overall image quality .
the optics system was tested with a measurement scheme based on raster scans of a chopped 50@xmath35c blackbody across the object plane .
maps of the beam profiles for each working detector were made down to a 25db signal to noise level . a typical beam ( figure [ fig : beammap]a )
is approximately gaussian and the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) is 11 mm at 3.5 m after deconvolution of the 10 mm diameter source aperture .
this provides a resolution close to that expected for a diffraction limited system in this configuration , although , some channels show mild broadening and aberrations ( figure [ fig : beammap]b ) , particularly at one edge of the focal plane .
there is also some indication of localized leakage from adjacent feedhorns at a level typically less than 5 - 10% .
beam profile maps and central slices from two channels measured with a 50@xmath34c chopped blackbody source of 10 mm circular aperture .
( a ) is from a typical detector with a measured fwhm of 13 mm at a distance of 3.5 m .
( b ) is from a detector on the right edge of the array with a broader 15 mm fwhm beam and some strong aberration .
both beams show some off - center low - level response attributable to light leaks from neighboring feedhorns . ]
the operational yield of the current detector array is 85% with the majority of unusable pixels suffering from the effects of resonator overlap due to non - uniformity of the thickness / resistivity of the aluminum film . aside from this resonator clash
there is no indication of any other electromagnetic cross coupling between resonators down to the measured 25db level .
a noise power spectrum for a typical detector channel sampled at the maximum rate of 477hz is presented in the inset to figure [ fig : net ] .
the spectrum shows white noise down to @xmath11hz .
the excess below this knee frequency is attributed to the warm electronics system , as are the spurious components at 95.5hz and 191hz .
these unwanted narrowband features are digitally filtered from the detector timelines prior to image generation .
the filters are implemented as fifth - order , butterworth bandstop filters that operate on the timelines in the time domain on a frame - by - frame basis .
the distribution of nets sampled at the white noise frequencies is indicated in the histogram in figure [ fig : net ] .
the distribution is approximately log - normal with a peak net value of 6.1mk@xmath25 , a factor of 2 higher than the expected limit from photon noise in this system .
the excess is thought to be due to stray infrared radiation leaking from the 4k stage . a normalized histogram of noise equivalent temperature measured at the white noise levels over each of the @xmath36 detectors .
the distribution is well approximated by a log - normal function ( black curve ) , the modal value of which is 6.1mk@xmath25 . a noise spectrum , calculated from a typical detector timeline , is included in the inset .
] the constraint set by the scanning mechanism and the higher than expected noise currently limit the update rate to 2 frames per second for an ne@xmath37 t of 0.1k per frame with the camera in its present configuration . figure [ fig : composite ] shows a single frame taken from a combined `` three - color '' video . the sensitivity is clearly sufficient to identify objects that are invisible to thermal nir cameras and standard digital video cameras .
a snap shot from a 2 fps video in which the 350ghz frames ( left ) were displayed simultaneously with frames from a standard web - cam ( center ) and a thermal nir camera ( right ) .
objects such as ( a ) a wallet , ( b ) an air pistol , and ( c ) some loose change , are hidden by the high opacity of the coat at higher frequencies but become apparent at 350ghz . ]
in most respects , the camera presented here has achieved the required specifications .
the presence of parasitic optical loading on the detector array limits the noise performance so that full video rate could not be achieved even if a faster field modulation system was employed .
however , a second generation system could overcome this in a number of ways .
for example , by utilizing a reflective optics approach , especially one with a cold aperture stop within the cryostat . this would help to inhibit stray light loads on the detectors and also eliminate the requirement for feedhorn coupling .
additionally , the field scanning mechanism of the present system is purely linear and thus does not employ any cross linking between detector channels .
as such , the video frames suffer from vertical striping due to broken / noisy detectors and low frequency gain fluctuations between individual detectors .
transitioning to a dual - axis circular or lissajous style scanning strategy would remedy this and is an advisable approach for any future system . a general purpose instrument similar to that presented here would benefit from a modular ( rather than fixed ) optics system .
providing an additional image plane located externally to the cryostat would enable fast turnaround between a variety of application specific imaging formats without the need for any modification to the cryogenic platform .
kinetic inductance detectors originally developed for far - infrared astronomy are now suitable for use in a range of applications requiring high sensitivity and/or fast mapping of objects at terahertz frequencies .
the instrument presented here mimics stand - off imaging systems for the detection of concealed items but could easily be transformed for other applications by modification of the optics platform .
this lekid based system operates close to the ideal photon noise limited sensitivity and is comparable in performance to the latest passive thz imaging systems .
the development of larger kid arrays is ongoing and next generation instruments will benefit from order of magnitude increases in detecting elements with no considerable penalty in array fabrication or readout complexity .
the authors acknowledge the uk science and technology facilities council for supporting the development of kid technology for astronomy applications .
40ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201014759 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201014519 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201014535 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201014698 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201116464 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/200912975 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/200912853 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1038/nature02037 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2390664 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1086/674013 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201014727 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/s10909 - 007 - 9685 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10909 - 013 - 1069 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10909 - 013 - 0985 - 4 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1142/s2251171714400017 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1109/22.989974 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1109/jproc.2007.898906 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/boe.4.000559 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase 10.1023/a:1024409329416 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/oe.21.017800 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1117/12.503414 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/jps.20225 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1364/ao.49.00e106 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop `` , '' ( ) in link:\doibase 10.1109/comcas.2013.6685254 [ _ _ ] ( , ) in link:\doibase 10.1109/irmmw - thz.2014.6956015 [ _ _ ] ( , ) in link:\doibase 10.1117/12.852932 [ _ _ ] , ( , ) in link:\doibase 10.1117/12.976849 [ _ _ ] , ( , ) in @noop _ _ ( ) pp .
link:\doibase 10.1364/ao.25.000870 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1117/12.673159 [ _ _ ] , , vol .
( ) p. in link:\doibase 10.1117/12.673162
[ _ _ ] , , vol .
( ) @noop ( ) , @noop link:\doibase 10.1088/1748 - 0221/7/07/p07014 [ * * , ( ) ] , | we have developed a passive 350ghz ( 850@xmath0 m ) video - camera to demonstrate lumped element kinetic inductance detectors ( lekids ) designed originally for far - infrared astronomy as an option for general purpose terrestrial terahertz imaging applications .
the camera currently operates at a quasi - video frame rate of 2hz with a noise equivalent temperature difference per frame of @xmath10.1k , which is close to the background limit .
the 152 element superconducting lekid array is fabricated from a simple 40 nm aluminum film on a silicon dielectric substrate and is read out through a single microwave feedline with a cryogenic low noise amplifier and room temperature frequency domain multiplexing electronics . |
modified theories of gravity have attained much attention after the discovery of expanding accelerated universe .
the basic ingredient responsible for this tremendous change in cosmic history is some mysterious type force having repulsive nature dubbed as dark energy .
the enigmatic nature of this energy has motivated many researchers to unveil its hidden characteristics which are still not known .
modified gravity approach is considered as the promising and optimistic scenario among several other proposals that have been presented to explore the salient features of dark energy .
these modified theories are established by adding or replacing curvature invariants and their corresponding generic functions in the einstein - hilbert action .
lovelock theory of gravity is the direct generalization of general relativity ( gr ) in @xmath3-dimensions which coincides with gr in @xmath4-dimensions @xcite .
the ricci scalar @xmath5 is known as first lovelock scalar while gauss - bonnet ( gb ) invariant is the second lovelock scalar yielding einstein - gauss - bonnet gravity in @xmath6-dimensions @xcite .
the gb invariant is a linear combination with an interesting feature that it is free from spin-2 ghost instabilities defined as @xcite @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the ricci and riemann tensors , respectively .
this quadratic curvature invariant is a topological term in 4-dimensions which possesses trivial contribution in the field equations . to discuss the dynamics of gb invariant in 4-dimensions ,
there are two interesting scenarios either to couple @xmath1 with scalar field or to add generic function @xmath10 in the einstein - hilbert action .
the first scheme naturally appears in the effective action in string theory which investigates singularity - free cosmological solutions @xcite .
the second approach known as @xmath10 gravity is introduced as an alternative for dark energy which successfully discusses the late - time cosmological evolution @xcite .
this modified theory of gravity is endowed with a quite rich cosmological structure as well as consistent with solar system constraints @xcite .
the current cosmic accelerated expansion has also been discussed in modified theories of gravity involving the curvature - matter coupling .
harko et al .
@xcite established @xmath11 gravity to study the curvature - matter coupling .
recently , we introduced the curvature - matter coupling in @xmath10 gravity named as @xmath0 theory of gravity @xcite .
this coupling yields non - zero covariant divergence of the energy - momentum tensor and an extra force appears due to which massive test particles follow non - geodesic trajectories while geodesic lines of geometry are followed by the dust particles .
shamir and ahmad @xcite constructed some cosmologically viable models in @xmath0 gravity using noether symmetry approach .
it is mentioned here that cosmic expansion can be obtained from geometric as well as matter components in such coupling .
the reconstruction as well as stability of cosmic evolutionary models in modified theories of gravity are the captivating issues in cosmology . in reconstruction technique ,
any known cosmic solution is used in the modified field equations to find the corresponding function which reproduces the given evolutionary cosmic history . in stability analysis , the isotropic and homogeneous perturbations are usually considered in which hubble parameter as well as energy density are perturbed to examine the background stability as time evolves @xcite .
nojiri et al .
@xcite formulated the reconstruction scheme to reproduce some cosmological models in @xmath12 gravity .
elizalde et al .
@xcite applied the same scenario for @xmath13cdm cosmology ( @xmath13 denotes cosmological constant while cdm stands for cold dark matter ) in @xmath14 gravity as well as in modified gb theories of gravity .
the stability of power - law solutions are also discussed in modified gravity theories @xcite .
sez - gmez @xcite explored the cosmological solutions in @xmath12 horava - lifshitz gravity and analyzed their stability against first order perturbations around frw universe .
myrzakulov and his collaborators @xcite discussed the cosmological models and found that @xmath10 gravity could successfully explain the cosmic evolutionary history .
jamil et al .
@xcite reconstructed the cosmological models in @xmath11 gravity and found that numerical analysis for hubble parameter is in good agreement with observational data for redshift parameter @xmath15 .
the stability of de sitter , power - law solutions as well as @xmath13cdm are analyzed in the context of @xmath14 gravity @xcite .
salako et al .
@xcite studied the cosmological reconstruction , stability as well as thermodynamics including first and second laws for @xmath13cdm model in generalized teleparallel theory of gravity .
sharif and zubair @xcite demonstrated that @xmath11 gravity can reproduce @xmath13cdm model , phantom or non - phantom eras , de sitter universe and power - law cosmic history .
they also analyzed the stability of reconstructed de sitter as well as power - law solutions . in this paper , we reconstruct various cosmological models including de sitter universe , power - law solutions , phantom or non - phantom eras and @xmath13cdm model in @xmath0 theory .
we also analyze the stability against linear homogeneous perturbations for de sitter as well as power - law solutions .
the paper has the following format . in section
* 2 * , we formulate the modified field equations while section * 3 * is devoted to reconstruct some known cosmological solutions in this gravity .
section * 4 * analyzes the stability of specific solutions against linear perturbations around frw universe model .
the results are summarized in the last section .
the action for @xmath0 gravity is defined as @xcite @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 represent coupling constant , determinant of the metric tensor ( @xmath19 ) and lagrangian associated with matter distribution , respectively .
varying eq.([1 ] ) with respect to @xmath19 , we obtain the field equations @xmath20f_{\mathcal{g}}(\mathcal{g},t ) \\\nonumber&-&[2rg_{\alpha\beta } \box-4r_{\alpha\beta}\box-2r\nabla_{\alpha}\nabla_{\beta } + 4r^{\mu}_{\beta}\nabla_{\alpha}\nabla_{\mu } + 4r^{\mu}_{\alpha}\nabla_{\beta}\nabla_{\mu}\\\label{2}&- & 4g_{\alpha\beta}r^{\mu\nu } \nabla_{\mu}\nabla_{\nu}+4r_{\alpha\mu\beta\nu } \nabla^{\mu}\nabla^{\nu}]f_{\mathcal{g}}(\mathcal{g},t)=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath21 ( @xmath22 denotes a covariant derivative ) and @xmath23 is the energy - momentum tensor .
the expressions for @xmath23 and @xmath24 are @xcite @xmath25 where we have assumed that @xmath18 depends only on @xmath19 rather than its derivatives . the non - zero divergence of @xmath23 is given by @xmath26.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above equations indicate that the complete dynamics of @xmath0 gravity is based on the suitable choice of @xmath18 .
the energy - momentum tensor for perfect fluid is @xmath27 where @xmath28 and @xmath29 represent the four velocity , energy density and pressure of matter distribution , respectively . in this case , the expression for @xmath24 becomes @xmath30 where @xmath31 .
the line element for frw universe model is given by @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the scale factor .
using eqs.([5])-([7 ] ) in ( [ 2 ] ) , we obtain the corresponding field equation as follows @xmath34 where @xmath35 and dot represents derivative with respect to time .
the non - zero continuity equation ( [ 4 ] ) takes the form @xmath36.\ ] ] the standard conservation law holds if right hand side of this equation vanishes . for equation of state @xmath37 (
@xmath38 is the equation of state parameter ) , eq.([9 ] ) yields @xmath39 with additional constraint @xmath40 we rewrite the above equations in terms of new variable @xmath41 known as e - folding instead of @xmath42 which is also related with redshift parameter @xmath43 as @xcite @xmath44 using the above definition of @xmath41 , eqs.([8 ] ) and ( [ 9 ] ) become @xmath45,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath46 and prime denotes derivative with respect to @xmath41 .
the simplest choice of @xmath0 model is @xmath47 which possesses no direct non - minimally coupling between curvature and matter . for this particular model , the field equation ( [ 13 ] )
splits into a set of two ordinary differential equations as @xmath48 @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
the field equations for perfect fluid matter distribution in @xmath10 gravity is recovered if @xmath52 vanishes while gr is achieved for @xmath53 .
in this section , we reproduce different cosmological scenarios including de sitter universe , power - law solutions , phantom / non - phantom eras and @xmath13cdm model in @xmath0 gravity . the de sitter cosmic evolution is interesting and well - known as it elegantly describes current expansion of the universe .
the scale factor of this evolutionary model grows exponentially with constant hubble parameter @xmath54 , defined as @xcite @xmath55 where @xmath56 is an integration constant .
equation ( [ 10 ] ) gives energy density of the form @xmath57 where @xmath58 and @xmath59 is a constant .
using eqs.([1d ] ) and ( [ 2d ] ) in ( [ 8 ] ) , we obtain @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the gb invariant at @xmath54 .
the solution of the above differential equation is @xmath62 where @xmath63 s @xmath64 are integration constants . since we have used the continuity equation ( [ 10 ] ) in eq.([3d ] ) , so we must constrain its solution . using the above equation with eq.([11 ] ) , we obtain the following functions @xmath65 where @xmath66 s @xmath67 are constants in terms of @xmath38 and @xmath68 given in appendix * a*. for the model ( [ 15 ] ) , we have @xmath69 where the first equation corresponds to de sitter universe in the absence of matter contents in @xmath10 gravity @xcite . using the constraint ( [ 11 ] )
, the second equation becomes @xmath70 the solution of eqs.([7d ] ) and ( [ 8d ] ) leads to @xmath71 where @xmath72 s are constants of integration . equations ( [ 4d ] ) and ( [ 9d ] ) indicate that de sitter expansion can also be described in @xmath0 gravity .
power - law solutions have significant importance to discuss different evolutionary phases of the universe in modified theory .
these solutions describe the decelerated as well as accelerated cosmic eras which are characterized by the scale factor as @xcite @xmath73 the cosmic decelerated phase is observed for @xmath74 including the radiation @xmath75 as well as dust @xmath76 dominated eras while @xmath77 covers the accelerated phase of the universe .
for this scale factor , the gb invariant takes the form @xmath78 using eqs.([10 ] ) , ( [ 1p ] ) and ( [ 2p ] ) , the field equation becomes @xmath79 whose solution is given by @xmath80 where @xmath81 s are integration constants and @xmath82,\\\nonumber\gamma_{2}&=&\left[\frac{3}{4}\lambda \tilde{c}_{2}(1+\omega)\{2\tilde{c}_{2}\lambda(1+\omega)+2(\lambda-1 ) -8\}+\frac{1}{4}(\lambda-1)(\lambda-7)+4\right.\\\nonumber&+&\left .
8\tilde{c}_{2}(\lambda-1)\left(\frac{1+\omega}{1 - 3\omega}\right ) \right]^{\frac{1}{2}},\quad\gamma_{3}=-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{1 - 3\omega } { 1+\omega}\right),\quad\gamma_{4}=\frac{2\kappa^2}{\omega-3},\\\nonumber \gamma_{5}&=&\left(\frac{18\lambda^{3}(1 - 3\omega)^{\frac{3\lambda ( 1+\omega)-2}{3\lambda(1+\omega)}}}{3\lambda(1 - 3\omega)+4}\right ) \rho_{0}^{\frac{-2}{3\lambda(1+\omega)}},\quad\gamma_{6}=\frac{2 } { 3\lambda(1+\omega)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] inserting eq.([4p ] ) in ( [ 11 ] ) , we obtain @xmath83 where @xmath84 s and @xmath85 s @xmath86 are given in appendix * a*. now we find the expression of @xmath0 for the choice of model ( [ 15 ] ) . the differential equation ( [ 3p ] ) yields two ordinary differential equations in variables @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
the first is the second order cauchy - euler s equation related to curvature given by @xmath87 whose solution is given by @xmath88 where @xmath89 s are constants of integration which is consistent with power - law solutions in @xmath10 gravity @xcite .
the second equation is obtained using the additional constraint ( [ 11 ] ) as @xmath90 the solution of this equation corresponds to matter distribution given by @xmath91}\left(\frac{t}{\rho_{0}(1 - 3\omega)}\right ) ^{\frac{2}{3\lambda(1+\omega)}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath92 s @xmath93 are integration constants .
consequently , @xmath0 model becomes @xmath94}\\\label{7p}&\times & \left(\frac{t}{\rho_{0}(1 - 3\omega)}\right)^{\frac{2}{3\lambda(1+\omega)}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , the power - law solutions are reconstructed which may be helpful to explore the expansion history of the universe in this modified theory of gravity .
here , we reconstruct @xmath0 model which can explain the system including both phantom and non - phantom eras . in the einstein gravity ,
the hubble parameter describing the phantom as well as non - phantom matter distribution is given by @xcite @xmath95 where @xmath96 and @xmath97 represent the model parameter , energy densities of phantom and non - phantom matter fluids , respectively .
when the scale factor is large , the first term on right hand side dominates which corresponds to the phantom era of the universe with @xmath98 .
the non - phantom era in the early universe is observed for @xmath99 when the scale factor is small and the second term dominates .
we rewrite @xmath100 in terms of a new function @xmath101 as @xmath102 so that eq.([1q ] ) becomes @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath105 .
the gb invariant takes the form @xmath106 inserting eq.([2q ] ) in ( [ 3q ] ) , we obtain a quadratic equation in @xmath107 whose solution is given by @xmath108 for the sake of simplicity , we consider @xmath109 so that it reduces to @xmath110 using eqs.([2q ] ) and ( [ 4q ] ) in ( [ 8 ] ) , we have @xmath111 which is a complicated partial differential equation whose analytical solution can not be found . to find the reconstructed @xmath0 model , we consider its particular form ( [ 15 ] ) which provides the following set of differential equations @xmath112 where we have used the additional constraint in the second equation . solving these equations
, it follows that @xmath113-\frac{2\kappa^{2}t}{1 - 3\omega}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath114 s are constants of integration .
thus , phantom and non - phantom cosmic history can be discussed in @xmath0 gravity .
now we apply the usual reconstruction technique to reproduce the @xmath13cdm cosmology in this gravity . in gr ,
the @xmath13cdm cosmological evolution is discussed by adding @xmath13 in the einstein - hilbert action whereas we reconstruct such evolution in the absence of @xmath13 in the action ( [ 1 ] ) .
the hubble parameter for @xmath13cdm model is given by @xcite @xmath115 the first term indicates the contribution of cdm while the second term corresponds to @xmath13 .
the hubble parameter in terms of gb invariant takes the form @xmath116 equation ( [ 1h ] ) gives @xmath117 using eqs.([2h ] ) and ( [ 3h ] ) in ( [ 13 ] ) , we obtain @xmath118 this equation can not be solved analytically hence we solve it for a specific @xmath0 model ( [ 15 ] ) with dust fluid .
the corresponding equations become @xmath119 using constraint ( [ 11 ] ) , the solution of eq.([4h ] ) is given by @xmath120 where @xmath121 s are constants of integration while solution of eq.([5h ] ) can not be found .
let us consider the case when @xmath122 with the assumption @xmath123 which reduces eq.([5h ] ) to @xmath124 whose solution yields @xmath125 where @xmath126 s are integration constants .
consequently , @xmath0 takes the form @xmath127 provided that @xmath128 . here
@xmath0 gravity can not explain @xmath13cdm cosmological evolution rather it corresponds to cdm evolution .
in this section , we analyze stability of some cosmological evolutionary solutions about linear homogeneous perturbations in this modified gravity .
we construct the perturbed field as well as continuity equations using isotropic and homogeneous universe model for both general and particular cases including de sitter and power - law solutions .
we assume a general solution @xmath129 which satisfies the basic field equations for frw universe model in @xmath0 gravity . in terms of the above solution ,
the expressions for @xmath130 and @xmath131 are @xmath132 for any particular @xmath0 model that can regenerate the above solution ( [ 1 t ] ) , the following equation of motion as well as non - zero divergence of the energy - momentum tensor must be satisfied @xmath133,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where superscript @xmath134 denotes that the function and its corresponding derivatives are calculated at @xmath135 and @xmath136 . if the conservation law holds , we get energy density in terms of @xmath137 as @xmath138 the first order perturbations in hubble parameter and energy density are defined as @xmath139 where @xmath140 and @xmath141 are the perturbation parameters . in order to analyze first order perturbations about the solution ( [ 1 t ] ) ,
we apply the series expansion on the function @xmath0 as @xmath142 where @xmath143 involves the terms proportional to quadratic or higher powers of @xmath1 and @xmath2 while only the linear terms are considered . using eqs.([6 t ] ) and ( [ 7 t ] ) in ( [ 8 ] ) , we obtain the following perturbed field equation @xmath144 where @xmath145 s @xmath146 are given in appendix * a*. inserting these perturbations in eq.([9 ] ) , the perturbed continuity equation is @xmath147 where @xmath148 s are provided in appendix * a*. if the conversation law holds in this modified gravity , eq.([9 t ] ) reduces to @xmath149 the perturbed equations ( [ 8 t ] ) and ( [ 9 t ] ) are helpful to analyze the stability of any specific frw cosmological evolutionary model in @xmath0 gravity . for the particular model ( [ 15 ] ) , these perturbed equations reduce to @xmath150 where the coefficients of @xmath151 and their derivatives are expressed in appendix * a*. in the following subsections , we investigate the stability of de sitter and power - law solutions . consider the de sitter solution @xmath152 , the perturbed equation ( [ 8 t ] ) takes the form @xmath153 f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{0}-3456\rho_{*}h_{0}^{8}(1 - 3\omega)(1+\omega ) f_{\mathcal{gg}t}^{0}\right)\delta+12\rho_{*}h_{0}^{3}\\\nonumber & \times&(1 - 3\omega)f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{0}\dot{\delta}_{m}+\left(\kappa^{2 } \rho_{*}+\frac{1}{2}\rho_{*}(3-\omega)f_{t}^{0}+\rho_{*}^{2}(1 - 3\omega ) ( 1+\omega)f_{tt}^{0}\right.\\\nonumber&-&\left.12\rho _ { * } h_{0}^{2}(1 - 3\omega)[h_{0}^{2}+3(1+\omega)h_{0}^{2}]f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{0 } -36\rho_{*}^{2}h_{0}^{4}(1 - 3\omega)^{2}(1+\omega ) \right.\\\label{13t}&\times&\left.f_{\mathcal{g}tt}^{0}\right)\delta_{m}=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the superscript @xmath154 represents that the function and its corresponding derivatives are evaluated at @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
we consider the conserved perturbed equation for stability analysis since the de sitter solutions are constructed using the constraint ( [ 11 ] ) in the previous section .
the numerical technique is used to solve eqs.([10 t ] ) and ( [ 13 t ] ) for the model ( [ 5d ] ) .
the evolution of @xmath140 and @xmath141 are shown in figure * 1*. we consider @xmath157 and @xmath158 throughout the stability analysis of de sitter universe models whereas integration constants are @xmath159 and @xmath160 .
figure * 1 * shows smooth behavior of @xmath140 ( left ) and @xmath141 ( right ) which do not decay in late times indicating that de sitter model ( [ 5d ] ) is unstable .
the stability analysis of model ( [ 6d ] ) with same integration constants is shown in figure * 2*. in the left panel , it is observed that small oscillations are produced about @xmath161 while it decays in late times , thus the model ( [ 6d ] ) shows stable behavior against perturbations . for model ( [ 9d ] ) , eq.([13 t ] ) becomes @xmath162 figure * 3 * represents the behavior of @xmath140 and @xmath141 for model ( [ 9d ] ) with integration constants @xmath163 and @xmath164 .
it is shown that oscillations in perturbation parameters are produced initially as shown in figure * 3*. this oscillating behavior is clearly observed in figure * 4 * which decays in future for both @xmath140 as well as @xmath141 and hence the solution becomes stable . here
we investigate the stability of power - law solutions .
these solutions describe the accelerated as well as decelerated cosmological evolutionary phases in the background of frw universe .
we first consider the reconstructed power - law solution ( [ 5p ] ) and numerically solve eqs.([8 t ] ) and ( [ 10 t ] ) .
for this model , we choose integration constants @xmath165 and @xmath166 figure * 5 * shows the oscillating behavior of perturbed parameters @xmath167 for the cosmic accelerated era with @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
the perturbations around the power - law solutions decay in future leading to stable results .
the radiation ( @xmath170 and @xmath171 ) as well as matter ( @xmath172 and @xmath173 ) dominated eras can not be discussed for the model ( [ 5p ] ) because singular as well as complex terms appear which lead to non - physical case .
secondly , we consider the model ( [ 6p ] ) and analyze its behavior against linear perturbations .
figure * 6 * shows the fluctuating behavior of considered perturbations in the cosmic accelerated phase with @xmath168 and @xmath169 . here
, we choose @xmath174 and @xmath166 it is observed that the oscillating behavior disappears in future while both perturbation parameters will not decay in late times leading to unstable cosmological solutions .
the considered model can not explain the cosmological evolution corresponding to matter and radiation dominated eras like previous model ( [ 5p ] ) .
lastly , we explore the stability of model ( [ 7p ] ) with integration constants @xmath175 and @xmath176 . figure * 7 * represents the evolution of ( @xmath177 ) versus time for @xmath178 with @xmath168 .
the left panel shows that the oscillations of @xmath140 decay in late times while fluctuations of @xmath141 remain present in future . since a complete perturbation against any cosmological solution includes the matter perturbations therefore ,
the solutions are unstable .
in this paper , we have employed the reconstruction scheme to @xmath0 gravity in the background of isotropic and homogeneous universe model to reproduce some important cosmological models .
the basic aspect of this modified gravity is the coupling between curvature and matter components which yields non - zero divergence of the energy - momentum tensor .
we have imposed additional constraint to obtain the standard conservation equation which has been used to explain the cosmic evolution in this gravity .
the de sitter and power - law solutions have been reconstructed for general as well as particular cases which are of great interest and have significant importance in cosmology .
we have also reconstructed the @xmath0 model which can explain cosmic history of the phantom as well as non - phantom phases of the universe .
similar reconstruction technique is carried out for @xmath13cdm model . in this case
, we have found that the considered gravity fails to reproduce @xmath13cdm cosmology for both cases .
for the specific form of function , this result is consistent with @xmath10 gravity in the absence of matter @xcite .
on physical grounds , the stability analysis of different forms of generic function leads to classify the modified theories of gravity .
we have applied the first order perturbations to hubble parameter and energy density to analyze the stability of models which reproduce de sitter and power - law cosmic history .
we have perturbed the field equation as well as conservation law whose numerical solutions provide the stable / unstable results .
* for the de sitter universe , the evolution of perturbation has been plotted against time as shown in figures * 1 * -*4*. these indicate that models ( [ 6d ] ) and ( [ 9d ] ) are stable against linear perturbations . * for the power - law universe , the stability analysis is given in figures * 5 * -*7*. it is found that @xmath0 gravity fails to reproduce matter and radiation dominated eras while stable results are obtained for accelerated phase of the universe for model ( [ 5p ] ) .
we conclude that the cosmological reconstruction and stability analysis might restrict @xmath0 gravity in the background of frw universe .
the expressions for @xmath179 s in eqs.([5d ] ) and ( [ 6d ] ) are @xmath180\\\nonumber & \times&[1+\omega-36c_{1}h_{0}^{4}(1 - 3\omega)]^{-2},\\\nonumber \xi_{2}&=&18c_{1}h_{0}^{4}[(1 - 11\omega)(1-\omega^{2})-8c_{1 } h_{0}^{4}\{2(2 + 59\omega^{2})-11\omega(5 - 3\omega^{2})\}]\\\nonumber & \times&[(1+\omega)(1 - 24c_{1}h_{0}^{4})\{1+\omega-6c_{1}h_{0}^{4 } ( 5 - 4\omega-33\omega^{2})\}]^{-1},\\\nonumber\xi_{3}&=&-[18c_{1 } h_{0}^{4}(1 - 32c_{1}h_{0}^{4})-3\omega\{1 - 6c_{1}h_{0}^{4}(3 - 352c_{1 } h_{0}^{4})\}\\\nonumber&-&2\omega^{2}\{1 - 9c_{1}h_{0}^{4 } ( 7 - 1248c_{1}h_{0}^{4})\}+\omega^{3}\{1 - 54c_{1}h_{0}^{4}(7 - 480c_{1 } h_{0}^{4})\}]\\\nonumber&\times&[(1 - 3\omega)(1 - 24c_{1}h_{0}^{4 } ) \{1+\omega-6c_{1}h_{0}^{4}(5 - 4\omega-33\omega^{2})\}]^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expressions for @xmath84 s and @xmath85 s in eqs.([5p ] ) and ( [ 6p ] ) are @xmath181 where @xmath182,\\\nonumber\gamma_{8}&=&\frac{\tilde{c}_{2 } } { 6\lambda}\left[6\tilde{c}_{2}\lambda(1+\omega)^{2}-3\lambda ( 1 + 5\omega+2\omega^2)+2(\gamma_{1}-\gamma_{2})\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the values of @xmath145 s in eq.([8 t ] ) are given as follows @xmath183f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{*}-864(1+\omega)(1 - 3\omega)\rho _ { * } h_{*}^{6}(4h_{*}^{2}\\\nonumber&+&\dot{h}_{*})f_{\mathcal{gg}t}^ { * } , \\\nonumber\chi_{4}&=&12(1 - 3\omega)\rho_{*}h_{*}^{3}f_{\mathcal{g}t}^ { * } , \\\nonumber\chi_{5}&=&\kappa^{2}\rho_{*}-\frac{1}{2}(\omega-3 ) \rho_{*}f_{t}^{*}+(1 - 3\omega)(1+\omega)\rho_{*}^{2}f_{tt}^{*}-12 ( 1 - 3\omega)\rho_{*}h_{*}^{2}\\\nonumber&\times&[(4 + 3\omega)h_{*}^{2 } + \dot{h}_{*}]f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{*}+288(1 - 3\omega)\rho_{*}h_{*}^{4 } ( 4h_{*}^{2}\dot{h}_{*}+2\dot{h}_{*}^{2}+h_{*}\ddot{h } _ { * } ) \\\nonumber&\times&f_{\mathcal{gg}t}^{*}-36(1+\omega ) ( 1 - 3\omega)^{2}\rho_{*}^{2}h_{*}^{4}f_{\mathcal{g}tt}^{*}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expressions for @xmath148 s are @xmath184f_{\mathcal{g}t}^ { * } -72\rho_{*}^{2}h_{*}^{2}(1 - 3\omega)(1+\omega)^{2}(4h_{*}^{2 } \\\nonumber&+&\dot{h}_{*})f_{\mathcal{g}tt}^{*}+576\rho_{*}h_{*}^{3 } ( 1+\omega)(4h_{*}^{2}+\dot{h}_{*})(4h_{*}^{2}\dot{h}_{*}+2 \dot{h}_{*}^{2}\\\nonumber&+&4h_{*}\ddot{h}_{*})f_{\mathcal{gg}t}^ { * } , \\\nonumber\upsilon_{2}&=&-12\rho_{*}h_{*}^{2}(1+\omega)\left[3h_{*}^{2 } ( 1-\omega)-4(2h_{*}^{2}+3\dot{h}_{*})\right]f_{\mathcal{g}t}^ { * } + 576\rho_{*}h_{*}^{2}\\\nonumber&\times&(1+\omega)(4h_{*}^{2 } \dot{h}_{*}+2\dot{h}_{*}^{2}+h_{*}\dot{h}_{*})f_{\mathcal{gg}t}^ { * } -72\rho_{*}^{2}h_{*}^{4}(1 - 3\omega)\\\nonumber&\times&(1+\omega^{2 } ) f_{\mathcal{g}tt}^{*},\\\nonumber\upsilon_{3}&=&24\rho_{*}h_{*}^{3 } ( 1+\omega)f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{*},\\\nonumber\upsilon_{4}&=&-\frac{3}{2 } \rho_{*}h_{*}(1+\omega)\left[(1-\omega)f_{t}^{*}+2\rho_{*}^{2 } ( 1+\omega)(1 - 3\omega)^{2}f_{ttt}^{*}\right]-\frac{15}{2 } \rho_{*}^{2}h_{*}\\\nonumber&\times&(1 - 3\omega)(1+\omega)^{2}f_{tt}^ { * } + 24\rho_{*}h_{*}(1+\omega)(4h_{*}^{2}\dot{h}_{*}+2\dot{h}_{*}^{2}+h _ { * } \ddot{h}_{*})\\\nonumber&\times&\left[f_{\mathcal{g}t}^{*}+\rho _ { * } ( 1 - 3\omega)f_{tt\mathcal{g}}^{*}\right],\\\nonumber\upsilon_{5 } & = & \rho_{*}\left(\kappa^2+\frac{1}{2}(3-\omega)f_{t}^{*}\right ) + ( 1+\omega)(1 - 3\omega)\rho_{*}^{2}f_{tt}^{*}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for model ( [ 15 ] ) , the coefficients of @xmath151 have the following expressions @xmath185-\frac{15}{2 } \rho_{*}^{2}h_{*}\\\nonumber&\times&(1 - 3\omega)(1+\omega)^{2 } \mathcal{f}_{tt}^{*},\\\nonumber\hat{\upsilon}_{5}&=&\rho _ { * } \left(\kappa^2+\frac{1}{2}(3-\omega)\mathcal{f}_{t}^{*}\right ) + ( 1+\omega)(1 - 3\omega)\rho_{*}^{2}\mathcal{f}_{tt}^{*}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] | the aim of this paper is to reconstruct and analyze the stability of some cosmological models against linear perturbations in @xmath0 gravity ( @xmath1 and @xmath2 represent the gauss - bonnet invariant and trace of the energy - momentum tensor , respectively ) .
we formulate the field equations for both general as well as particular cases in the context of isotropic and homogeneous universe model .
we reproduce the cosmic evolution corresponding to de sitter universe , power - law solutions and phantom / non - phantom eras in this theory using reconstruction technique . finally , we study stability analysis of de sitter as well as power - law solutions through linear perturbations .
* keywords : * reconstruction ; stability analysis ; modified gravity . + * pacs : * 04.50.kd ; 98.80.-k . |
when considering regression with a large number of predictors , variable selection becomes important .
numerous methods have been proposed in the literature for the purpose of variable selection , ranging from the classical information criteria such as aic and bic to regularization based modern techniques such as the nonnegative garrote [ breiman ( @xcite ) ] , the lasso [ tibshirani ( @xcite ) ] and the scad [ fan and li ( @xcite ) ] , among many others .
although these methods enjoy excellent performance in many applications , they do not take the hierarchical or structural relationship among predictors into account and therefore can lead to models that are hard to interpret .
consider , for example , multiple linear regression with both main effects and two - way interactions where a dependent variable @xmath0 and @xmath1 explanatory variables @xmath2 are related through @xmath3 where @xmath4 .
commonly used general purpose variable selection techniques , including those mentioned above , do not distinguish interactions @xmath5 from main effects @xmath6 and can select a model with an interaction but neither of its main effects , that is , @xmath7 and @xmath8 .
it is therefore useful to invoke the so - called effect heredity principle [ hamada and wu ( @xcite ) ] in this situation .
there are two popular versions of the heredity principle [ chipman ( @xcite ) ] . under _
strong heredity _
, for a two - factor interaction effect @xmath5 to be active both its parent effects , @xmath6 and @xmath9 , should be active ; whereas under _ weak heredity _ only one of its parent effects needs to be active .
likewise , one may also require that @xmath10 can be active only if @xmath6 is also active .
the strong heredity principle is closely related to the notion of marginality [ nelder ( @xcite ) , mccullagh and nelder ( @xcite ) , nelder ( @xcite ) ] which ensures that the response surface is invariant under scaling and translation of the explanatory variables in the model .
interested readers are also referred to mccullagh ( @xcite ) for a rigorous discussion about what criteria a sensible statistical model should obey .
li , sudarsanam and frey ( @xcite ) recently conducted a meta - analysis of 113 data sets from published factorial experiments and concluded that an overwhelming majority of these real studies conform with the heredity principles .
this clearly shows the importance of using these principles in practice .
these two heredity concepts can be extended to describe more general hierarchical structure among predictors . with slight abuse of notation ,
write a general multiple linear regression as @xmath11 where @xmath12 and @xmath13 . throughout this paper
, we center each variable so that the observed mean is zero and , therefore , the regression equation has no intercept . in its most general form , the hierarchical relationship among predictors can be represented by sets @xmath14 , where @xmath15 contains the parent effects of the @xmath16th predictor .
for example , the dependence set of @xmath5 is @xmath17 in the quadratic model ( [ 2way ] ) . in order that the @xmath16th variable can be considered for inclusion , all elements of @xmath15
must be included under the strong heredity principle , and at least one element of @xmath15 should be included under the weak heredity principle .
other types of heredity principles , such as the partial heredity principle [ nelder ( @xcite ) ] , can also be incorporated in this framework .
the readers are referred to yuan , joseph and lin ( @xcite ) for further details . as pointed out by turlach ( @xcite )
, it could be very challenging to conform with the hierarchical structure in the popular variable selection methods . in this paper
we specifically address this issue and consider how to effectively impose such hierarchical structures among the predictors in variable selection and coefficient estimation , which we refer to as _ structured variable selection and estimation_. despite its great practical importance , structured variable selection and estimation has received only scant attention in the literature .
earlier interests in structured variable selection come from the analysis of designed experiments where heredity principles have proven to be powerful tools in resolving complex aliasing patterns .
hamada and wu ( @xcite ) introduced a modified stepwise variable selection procedure that can enforce effect heredity principles .
later , chipman ( @xcite ) and chipman , hamada and wu ( @xcite ) discussed how the effect heredity can be accommodated in the stochastic search variable selection method developed by george and mcculloch ( @xcite ) .
see also joseph and delaney ( @xcite ) for another bayesian approach . despite its elegance
, the bayesian approach can be computationally demanding for large scale problems .
recently , yuan , joseph and lin ( @xcite ) proposed generalized lars algorithms [ osborne , presnell and turlach ( @xcite ) , efron et al .
( @xcite ) ] to incorporate heredity principles into model selection .
efron et al .
( @xcite ) and turlach ( @xcite ) also considered alternative strategies to enforce the strong heredity principle in the lars algorithm .
compared with earlier proposals , the generalized lars procedures enjoy tremendous computational advantages , which make them particularly suitable for problems of moderate or large dimensions .
however , yuan and lin ( @xcite ) recently showed that lars may not be consistent in variable selection .
moreover , the generalized lars approach is not flexible enough to incorporate many of the hierarchical structures among predictors .
more recently , zhao , rocha and yu ( @xcite ) and choi , li and zhu ( @xcite ) proposed penalization methods to enforce the strong heredity principle in fitting a linear regression model . however , it is not clear how to generalize them to handle more general heredity structures and their theoretical properties remain unknown . in this paper
we propose a new framework for structured variable selection and estimation that complements and improves over the existing approaches .
we introduce a family of shrinkage estimator that is similar in spirit to the nonnegative garrote , which yuan and lin ( @xcite ) recently showed to enjoy great computational advantages , nice asymptotic properties and excellent finite sample performance .
we propose to incorporate structural relationships among predictors as linear inequality constraints on the corresponding shrinkage factors .
the resulting estimates can be obtained as the solution of a quadratic program and very efficiently solved using the standard quadratic programming techniques .
we show that , unlike lars , it is consistent in both variable selection and estimation provided that the true model has such structures .
moreover , the linear inequality constraints can be easily modified to adapt to any situation arising in practical problems and therefore is much more flexible than the existing approaches .
we also extend the original nonnegative garrote as well as the proposed structured variable selection and estimation methods to deal with the generalized linear models .
the proposed approach is much more flexible than the generalized lars approach in yuan , joseph and lin ( @xcite ) .
for example , suppose a group of variables is expected to follow strong heredity and another group weak heredity , then in the proposed approach we only need to use the corresponding constraints for strong and weak heredity in solving the quadratic program , whereas the approach of yuan , joseph and lin ( @xcite ) is algorithmic and therefore requires a considerable amount of expertise with the generalized lars code to implement these special needs .
however , there is a price to be paid for this added flexibility : it is not as fast as the generalized lars .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows .
we introduce the methodology and study its asymptotic properties in the next section . in section [ sec3 ]
we extend the methodology to generalized linear models .
section [ sec4 ] discusses the computational issues involved in the estimation .
simulations and real data examples are presented in sections [ sec5 ] and [ sec6 ] to illustrate the proposed methods .
we conclude with some discussions in section [ sec7 ] .
the original nonnegative garrote estimator introduced by breiman ( @xcite ) is a scaled version of the least square estimate .
given @xmath18 independent copies @xmath19 of @xmath20 where @xmath21 is a @xmath22-dimensional covariate and @xmath0 is a response variable , the shrinkage factor @xmath23 is given as the minimizer to @xmath24 where , with slight abuse of notation , @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 is a @xmath22 dimensional vector whose @xmath28th element is @xmath29 and @xmath30 is the least square estimate based on ( [ 1.1 ] ) . here
@xmath31 is a tuning parameter .
the nonnegative garrote estimate of the regression coefficient is subsequently defined as @xmath32 , @xmath33 . with an appropriately chosen tuning parameter @xmath34 ,
some of the scaling factors could be estimated by exact zero and , therefore , the corresponding predictors are eliminated from the selected model .
following yuan , joseph and lin ( @xcite ) , let @xmath15 contain the parent effects of the @xmath16th predictor . under the strong heredity principle , we need to impose the constraint that @xmath35 for any @xmath36 if @xmath37 . a naive approach to incorporating effect
heredity is therefore to minimize ( [ shrink ] ) under this additional constraint .
however , in doing so , we lose the convexity of the optimization problem and generally will end up with problems such as multiple local optima and potentially np hardness . recall that the nonnegative garrote estimate of @xmath38 is @xmath39 . since @xmath40 with probability one , @xmath6 will be selected if and only if scaling factor @xmath41 , in which case @xmath42 behaves more or less like an indicator of the inclusion of @xmath6 in the selected model .
therefore , the strong heredity principles can be enforced by requiring @xmath43 note that if @xmath41 , ( [ strong ] ) will force the scaling factor for all its parents to be positive and consequently active .
since these constraints are linear in terms of the scaling factor , minimizing ( [ shrink ] ) under ( [ strong ] ) remains a quadratic program .
figure [ fig : strong ] illustrates the feasible region of the nonnegative garrote with such constraints in contrast with the original nonnegative garrote where no heredity rules are enforced .
we consider two effects and their interaction with the corresponding shrinking factors denoted by @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 , respectively . in both situations
the feasible region is a convex polyhedron in the three dimensional space .
( left ) and the relaxed constraint @xmath47 ( right ) . ] similarly , when considering weak heredity principles , we can require that @xmath48 however , the feasible region under such constraints is no longer convex as demonstrated in the left panel of figure [ fig : weak ] .
subsequently , minimizing ( [ shrink ] ) subject to ( [ weaknon ] ) is not feasible . to overcome this problem , we suggest using the convex envelop of these constraints for the weak heredity principles : @xmath49 again
, these constraints are linear in terms of the scaling factor and minimizing ( [ shrink ] ) under ( [ weak ] ) remains a quadratic program .
note that @xmath41 implies that @xmath50 and , therefore , ( [ weak ] ) will require at least one of its parents to be included in the model .
in other words , constraint ( [ weak ] ) can be employed in place of ( [ weaknon ] ) to enforce the weak heredity principle .
the small difference between the feasible regions of ( [ weaknon ] ) and ( [ weak ] ) also suggests that the selected model may only differ slightly between the two constraints .
we opt for ( [ weak ] ) because of the great computational advantage it brings about .
to gain further insight to the proposed structured variable selection and estimation methods , we study their asymptotic properties .
we show here that the proposed methods estimate the zero coefficients by zero with probability tending to one , and at the same time give root-@xmath18 consistent estimate to the nonzero coefficients provided that the true data generating mechanism satisfies such heredity principles .
denote by @xmath51 the indices of the predictors in the true model , that is , @xmath52 .
write @xmath53 as the estimate obtained from the proposed structured variable selection procedure
. under strong heredity , the shrinkage factors @xmath54 can be equivalently written in the lagrange form [ boyd and vandenberghe ( @xcite ) ] @xmath55 subject to @xmath56 for some lagrange parameter @xmath57 . for the weak heredity principle
, we replace the constraints @xmath58 with @xmath59 .
[ thm1 ] assume that @xmath60 and @xmath61 is positive definite . if the true model satisfies the strong / weak heredity principles , and @xmath62 in a fashion such that @xmath63 as @xmath18 goes to @xmath64 , then the structured estimate with the corresponding heredity principle satisfies @xmath65 for any @xmath66 , and @xmath67 if @xmath68 .
all the proofs can be accessed as the supplement materials .
note that when @xmath69 , there is no penalty and the proposed estimates reduce to the least squares estimate which is consistent in estimation .
the theorems suggest that if instead the tuning parameter @xmath70 escapes to infinity at a rate slower than @xmath71 , the resulting estimates not only achieve root-@xmath18 consistency in terms of estimation but also are consistent in variable selection , whereas the ordinary least squares estimator does not possess such model selection ability .
the nonnegative garrote was originally introduced for variable selection in multiple linear regression .
but the idea can be extended to more general regression settings where @xmath0 depends on @xmath21 through a scalar parameter @xmath72 where @xmath73 is a @xmath74-dimensional unknown coefficient vector .
it is worth pointing out that such extensions have not been proposed in literature so far . a common approach to estimating @xmath75 is by means of the maximum likelihood .
let @xmath76 be a negative log conditional likelihood function of @xmath77 .
the maximum likelihood estimate is given as the minimizer of @xmath78 for example , in logistic regression , @xmath79 more generally , @xmath80 can be replaced with any loss functions such that its expectation @xmath81 with respect to the joint distribution of @xmath20 is minimized at @xmath82 . to perform variable selection , we propose the following extension of the original nonnegative garrote .
we use the maximum likelihood estimate @xmath83 as a preliminary estimate of @xmath84 .
similar to the original nonnegative garrote , define @xmath85 .
next we estimate the shrinkage factors by @xmath86 subject to @xmath87 and @xmath88 for any @xmath33 . in the case of normal linear regression , @xmath89 becomes the least squares and it is not hard to see that the solution of ( [ gnng ] ) always satisfies @xmath90 because all variables are centered .
therefore , without loss of generality , we could assume that there is no intercept in the normal linear regression .
the same , however , is not true for more general @xmath89 and , therefore , @xmath91 is included in ( [ gnng ] ) .
our final estimate of @xmath92 is then given as @xmath93 for @xmath33 . to impose the strong or weak heredity principle
, we add additional constraints @xmath94 or @xmath95 , respectively .
theorem [ thm1 ] can also be extended to more general regression settings .
similar to before , under strong heredity , @xmath96 subject to @xmath56 for some @xmath57 . under weak heredity principles
, we use the constraints @xmath97 instead of @xmath98 .
we shall assume that the following regularity conditions hold : @xmath99 is a strictly convex function of the second argument ; the maximum likelihood estimate @xmath83 is root-@xmath18 consistent ; the observed information matrix converges to a positive definite matrix , that is , @xmath100 where @xmath101 is a positive definite matrix .
[ thm2 ] under regularity conditions , if @xmath62 in a fashion such that @xmath102 as @xmath18 goes to @xmath103 , then @xmath65 for any @xmath104 , and @xmath105 if @xmath68 provided that the true model satisfies the same heredity principles .
similar to the original nonnegative garrote , the proposed structured variable selection and estimation procedure proceeds in two steps .
first the solution path indexed by the tuning parameter @xmath34 is constructed .
the second step , oftentimes referred to as tuning , selects the final estimate on the solution path .
we begin with linear regression . for both types of heredity principles ,
the shrinkage factors for a given @xmath34 can be obtained from solving a quadratic program of the following form : @xmath106 where @xmath107 is a @xmath108 matrix determined by the type of heredity principles , @xmath109 is a vector of zeros , and @xmath110 means `` greater than or equal to '' in an element - wise manner .
equation ( [ qpsvs ] ) can be solved efficiently using standard quadratic programming techniques , and the solution path of the proposed structured variable selection and estimation procedure can be approximated by solving ( [ qpsvs ] ) for a fine grid of @xmath34 s .
recently , yuan and lin ( @xcite ) showed that the solution path of the original nonnegative garrote is piecewise linear , and used this to construct an efficient algorithm for building its whole solution path .
the original nonnegative garrote corresponds to the situation where the matrix @xmath107 of ( [ qpsvs ] ) is a @xmath111 identity matrix .
similar results can be expected for more general scenarios including the proposed procedures , but the algorithm will become considerably more complicated and running quadratic programming for a grid of tuning parameter tends to be a computationally more efficient alternative .
. the objective function of ( [ qpsvs ] ) can be expressed as @xmath113 because @xmath114 does not depend on @xmath115s , ( [ qpsvs ] ) is equivalent to @xmath116\\[-8pt ] & & \qquad \mbox{subject to } \sum _ { j=1}^p \theta_j\le m \mbox { and } h\theta\succeq{\mathbf0},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] which depends on the sample size @xmath18 only through @xmath117 and the gram matrix @xmath118 .
both quantities are already computed in evaluating the least squares .
therefore , when compared with the ordinary least squares estimator , the additional computational cost of the proposed estimating procedures is free of sample size @xmath18 .
once the solution path is constructed , our final estimate is chosen on the path according to certain criterion .
such criterion often reflects the prediction accuracy , which depends on the unknown parameters and needs to be estimated .
a commonly used criterion is the multifold cross validation ( cv ) .
multifold cv can be used to estimate the prediction error of an estimator .
the data @xmath119 are first equally split into @xmath120 subsets @xmath121 . using the proposed method , and data @xmath122 ,
construct estimate @xmath123 .
the cv estimate of the prediction error is @xmath124 we select the tuning parameter @xmath34 by minimizing @xmath125 .
it is often suggested to use @xmath126 in practice [ breiman ( @xcite ) ] .
it is not hard to see that @xmath127 estimates @xmath128 since the first term is the inherent prediction error due to the noise , one often measures the goodness of an estimator using only the second term , referred to as the model error : @xmath129 clearly , we can estimate the model error as @xmath130 , where @xmath131 is the noise variance estimate obtained from the ordinary least squares estimate using all predictors .
similarly for more general regression settings , we solve @xmath132 for some matrix @xmath107 .
this can be done in an iterative fashion provided that the loss function @xmath89 is strictly convex in its second argument .
at each iteration , denote @xmath133}_0,\theta^{[0]})$ ] the estimate from the previous iteration .
we now approximate the objective function using a quadratic function around @xmath133}_0,\theta ^{[0]})$ ] and update the estimate by minimizing @xmath134}+\theta ^{[0]}_0\bigr ) \bigl[\mathbf{z}_i\bigl(\theta-\theta^{[0]}\bigr)+\bigl(\theta_0- \theta^{[0]}_0\bigr ) \bigr ] \\ & & \qquad{}+{\frac{1}{2 } } \ell''\bigl(y_i,\mathbf{z}_i\theta^{[0]}+\theta ^{[0]}_0\bigr ) \bigl[\mathbf{z}_i\bigl(\theta-\theta^{[0]}\bigr)+\bigl(\theta_0- \theta^{[0]}_0\bigr ) \bigr]^2 \biggr ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] subject to @xmath87 and @xmath135 , where the derivatives are taken with respect to the second argument of @xmath136 .
now it becomes a quadratic program .
we repeat this until a certain convergence criterion is met . in choosing the optimal tuning parameter @xmath34 for general regression
, we again use the multifold cross - validation .
it proceeds in the same fashion as before except that we use a loss - dependent cross - validation score : @xmath137
in this section we investigate the finite sample properties of the proposed estimators .
to fix ideas , we focus our attention on the usual normal linear regression .
we first consider a couple of models that represent different scenarios that may affect the performance of the proposed methods . in each of the following models , we consider three explanatory variables @xmath138 that follow a multivariate normal distribution with @xmath139 with three different values for @xmath140 : @xmath141 and @xmath142 . a quadratic model with nine terms @xmath143 is considered .
therefore , we have a total of nine predictors , including three main effects , three quadratic terms and three two - way interactions . to demonstrate the importance of accounting for potential hierarchical structure among the predictor variables , we apply the nonnegative garrote estimator that recognizes strong heredity , weak heredity and without heredity constraints .
in particular , we enforce the strong heredity principle by imposing the following constraints : @xmath144 to enforce the weak heredity , we require that @xmath145 we consider two data - generating models , one follows the strong heredity principles and the other follows the weak heredity principles : the first model follows the strong heredity principle : @xmath146 the second model is similar to model i except that the true data generating mechanism now follows the weak heredity principle : @xmath147 for both models , the regression noise @xmath148
. for each model , 50 independent observations of @xmath149 are collected , and a quadratic model with nine terms is analyzed .
we choose the tuning parameter by ten - fold cross - validation as described in the last section .
following breiman ( @xcite ) , we use the model error ( [ me ] ) as the gold standard in comparing different methods .
we repeat the experiment for 1000 times for each model and the results are summarized in table [ tab : ex1 ] .
the numbers in the parentheses are the standard errors .
we can see that the model errors are smaller for both weak and strong heredity models compared to the model that does not incorporate any of the heredity principles .
paired @xmath150-tests confirmed that most of the observed reductions in model error are significant at the 5% level .
= 9.2 cm 9.2cm@lccc@ & * no heredity * & * weak heredity * & * strong heredity * + + @xmath151 & 1.79 & 1.70 & 1.59 + & ( 0.05 ) & ( 0.05 ) & ( 0.04 ) + @xmath152 & 1.57 & 1.56 & 1.43 + & ( 0.04 ) & ( 0.04 ) & ( 0.04 ) + @xmath153 & 1.78 & 1.69 & 1.54 + & ( 0.05 ) & ( 0.04 ) & ( 0.04 ) + + @xmath151 & 1.77 & 1.61 & 1.72 + & ( 0.05 ) & ( 0.05 ) & ( 0.04 ) + @xmath152 & 1.79 & 1.53 & 1.70 + & ( 0.05 ) & ( 0.04 ) & ( 0.04 ) + @xmath153 & 1.79 & 1.68 & 1.76 + & ( 0.04 ) & ( 0.04 ) & ( 0.04 ) + for model i , the nonnegative garrote that respects the strong heredity principles enjoys the best performance , followed by the one with weak heredity principles .
this example demonstrates the benefit of recognizing the effect heredity .
note that the model considered here also follows the weak heredity principle , which explains why the nonnegative garrote estimator with weak heredity outperforms the one that does not enforce any heredity constraints . for model
ii , the nonnegative garrote with weak heredity performs the best .
interestingly , the nonnegative garrote with strong heredity performs better than the original nonnegative garrote .
one possible explanation is that the reduced feasible region with strong heredity , although introducing bias , at the same time makes tuning easier . to gain further insight
, we look into the model selection ability of the structured variable selection .
to separate the strength of a method and effect of tuning , for each of the simulated data , we check whether or not there is any tuning parameter such that the corresponding estimate conforms with the true model . the frequency for each method to select the right model
is given in table [ tab : ex1f ] , which clearly shows that the proposed structured variable selection methods pick the right models more often than the original nonnegative garrote .
note that the strong heredity version of the method can never pick model ii correctly as it violates the strong heredity principle .
we also want to point out that such comparison , although useful , needs to be understood with caution . in practice ,
no model is perfect and selecting an additional main effect @xmath154 so that model ii can satisfy strong heredity may be a much more preferable alternative to many .
@lccc@ & * no heredity * & * weak heredity * & * strong heredity * + + @xmath151 & 65.5% & 71.5% & 82.0% + @xmath152 & 85.0% & 86.5% & 90.5% + @xmath153 & 66.5% & 73.5% & 81.5% + + @xmath151 & 65.5% & 75.5% & 0.00% + @xmath152 & 83.0% & 90.0% & 0.00% + @xmath153 & 56.5% & 72.5% & 0.00% + we also checked how effective the ten - fold cross - validation is in picking the right model when it does not follow any of the heredity principles .
we generated the data from the model @xmath155 where the set up for simulation remains the same as before .
note that this model does not follow any of the heredity principles . for each run
, we ran the nonnegative garrote with weak heredity , strong heredity and no heredity .
we chose the best among these three estimators using ten - fold cross - validation .
note that the three estimators may take different values of the tuning parameter . among 1000 runs , 64.1% of the time
, nonnegative garrote with no heredity principle was elected .
in contrast , for either model i or model ii with a similar setup , less than 10% of the time nonnegative garrote with no heredity principle was elected .
this is quite a satisfactory performance .
the next example is designed to illustrate the effect of the magnitude of the interaction on the proposed methods .
we use a similar setup as before but now with four main effects @xmath156 , four quadratic terms and six two - way interactions .
the true data generating mechanism is given by @xmath157 where @xmath158 and @xmath159 with @xmath160 chosen so that the signal - to - noise ratio is always @xmath161 .
similar to before , the sample size @xmath162 .
figure [ fig : revsim1 ] shows the mean model error estimated over 1000 runs .
we can see that the strong and weak heredity models perform better than the no heredity model and the improvement becomes more significant as the strength of the interaction effect increases .
to fix the idea , we have focused on using the least squares estimator as our initial estimator .
the least squares estimators are known to perform poorly when the number of predictors is large when compared with the sample size . in particular , it is not applicable when the number of predictors exceeds the sample size .
however , as shown in yuan and lin ( @xcite ) , other initial estimators can also be used . in particular , they suggested ridge regression as one of the alternatives to the least squares estimator . to demonstrate such an extension
, we consider again the regression model ( [ eq : effectsize ] ) but with ten main effects @xmath163 and ten quadratic terms , as well as 45 interactions .
the total number of effects ( @xmath164 ) exceeds the number of observations ( @xmath162 ) and , therefore , the ridge regression tuned with gcv was used as the initial estimator .
figure [ fig : aoasrevsim ] shows the solution path of the nonnegative garrote with strong heredity , weak heredity and without any heredity for a typical simulated data with @xmath165 . :
solution for different versions of the nonnegative garrote . ]
it is interesting to notice from figure [ fig : aoasrevsim ] that the appropriate heredity principle , in this case strong heredity , is extremely valuable in distinguishing the true effect @xmath166 from other spurious effects .
this further confirms the importance of heredity principles .
in this section we apply the methods from section [ sec2 ] to several real data examples .
the first is the prostate data , previously used in tibshirani ( @xcite ) .
the data consist of the medical records of @xmath167 male patients who were about to receive a radical prostatectomy .
the response is the level of prostate specific antigen , and there are 8 explanatory variables .
the explanatory variables are eight clinical measures : log(cancer volume ) ( lcavol ) , log(prostate weight ) ( lweight ) , age , log(benign prostatic hyperplasia amount ) ( lbph ) , seminal vesicle invasion ( svi ) , log(capsular penetration ) ( lcp ) , gleason score ( gleason ) and percentage gleason scores 4 or 5 ( pgg45 ) .
we consider model ( [ 2way ] ) with main effects , quadratic terms and two way interactions , which gives us a total of 44 predictors .
figure [ fig : prostate ] gives the solution path of the nonnegative garrote with strong heredity , weak heredity and without any heredity constraints .
the vertical grey lines represent the models that are selected by the ten - fold cross - validation . to determine which type of heredity principle to use for the analysis
, we calculated the ten - fold cross - validation scores for each method .
the cross - validation scores as functions of the tuning parameter @xmath34 are given in the right panel of figure [ fig : prostate - cv ] .
cross - validation suggests the validity of heredity principles .
the strong heredity is particularly favored with the smallest score . using ten - fold cross - validation ,
the original nonnegative garrote that neglects the effect heredity chooses a six variable model : _ lcavol , lweight , lbph , gleason@xmath168 , lbph : svi _ and _ svi : pgg45_. note that this model does not satisfy heredity principle , because _ gleason@xmath168 _ and _ svi : pgg45 _ are included without any of its parent factors .
in contrast , the nonnegative garrote with strong heredity selects a model with seven variables : _ lcavol , lweight , lbph , svi , gleason , gleason@xmath168 _ and _ lbph : svi_. the model selected by the weak heredity , although comparable in terms of cross validation score , is considerably bigger with 16 variables . the estimated model errors for the strong heredity , weak heredity and no heredity nonnegative garrote are @xmath169 , @xmath170 and @xmath171 , respectively , which clearly favors the methods that account for the effect heredity .
to further assess the variability of the ten - fold cross - validation , we also ran the leave - one - out cross - validation on the data .
the leave - one - out scores are given in the right panel of figure [ fig : prostate - cv ] .
it shows a similar pattern as the ten - fold cross - validation . in what follows
, we shall continue to use the ten - fold cross - validation because of the tremendous computational advantage it brings about . to illustrate the strategy in more general regression settings , we consider a logistic regression for the south african heart disease data previously used in hastie , tibshirani and friedman ( @xcite ) .
the data consist of 9 different measures of 462 subjects and the responses indicating the presence of heart disease .
we again consider a quadratic model .
there is one binary predictor which leaves a total of 53 terms .
nonnegative garrote with strong heredity , weak heredity and without heredity were applied to the data set .
the solution paths are given in figure [ fig : heart - path ] .
the cross - validation scores for the three different methods are given in figure [ fig : heart - cv ] .
as we can see from the figure , nonnegative garrote with strong heredity principles achieves the lowest cross - validation score , followed by the one without heredity principles . to gain further insight on the merits of the proposed structured variable selection and estimation techniques ,
we apply them to seven benchmark data sets , including the previous two examples . the ozone data , originally used in breiman and friedman ( @xcite ) , consist of the daily maximum one - hour - average ozone reading and eight meteorological variables in the los angeles basin for 330 days in 1976 . the goal is to predict the daily maximum one - hour - average ozone reading using the other eight variables .
the boston housing data include statistics for 506 census tracts of boston from the 1970 census [ harrison and rubinfeld ( @xcite ) ] .
the problem is to predict the median value of owner - occupied homes based on 13 demographic and geological measures .
the diabetes data , previously analyzed by efron et al .
( @xcite ) , consist of eleven clinical measurements for a total of 442 diabetes patients .
the goal is to predict a quantitative measure of disease progression one year after the baseline using the other ten measures that were collected at the baseline .
along with the prostate data , these data sets are used to demonstrate our methods in the usual normal linear regression setting . to illustrate the performance of the structured variable selection and estimation in more general regression settings , we include two other logistic regression examples along with the south african heart data .
the pima indians diabetes data have 392 observations on nine variables .
the purpose is to predict whether or not a particular subject has diabetes using eight remaining variables .
the bupa liver disorder data include eight variables and the goal is to relate a binary response with seven clinical measurements .
both data sets are available from the uci repository of machine learning databases [ newman et al .
( @xcite ) ] .
we consider methods that do not incorporate heredity principles or respect weak or strong heredity principles . for each method
, we estimate the prediction error using ten - fold cross - validation , that is , the mean squared error in the case of the four linear regression examples , and the misclassification rate in the case of the three classification examples .
table [ tab : real ] documents the findings .
similar to the heart data we discussed earlier , the total number of effects ( @xmath22 ) can be different for the same number of main effects ( @xmath1 ) due to the existence of binary variables . as the results from table [ tab : real ] suggest , incorporating the heredity principles leads to improved prediction for all seven data sets .
note that for the four regression data sets , the prediction error depends on the scale of the response and therefore should not be compared across data sets .
for example , the response variable of the diabetes data ranges from 25 to 346 with a variance of 5943.331 .
in contrast , the response variable of the prostate data ranges from @xmath172 to 5.48 with a variance of 1.46 .
@ld3.0d2.0d3.0d4.3cc@ * data * & & & & & & + boston & 506 & 13 & 103 & 12.609 & & 12.661 + diabetes & 442 & 10 & 64 & 3077.471 & & 3116.989 + ozone & 203 & 9 & 54 & 16.558 & & 15.397 + prostate & 97 & 8 & 44 & 0.624 & 0.632 & * 0.584 * + bupa & 345 & 6 & 27 & 0.287 & 0.279 & * 0.267 * + heart & 462 & 9 & 53 & 0.286 & 0.275 & * 0.262 * + pima & 392 & 8 & 44 & 0.199 & 0.214 & * 0.196 * +
when a large number of variables are entertained , variable selection becomes important . with a number of competing models that are virtually indistinguishable in fitting the data , it is often advocated to select a model with the smaller number of variables .
but this principle alone may lead to models that are not interpretable . in this paper we proposed structured variable selection and estimation methods that can effectively incorporate the hierarchical structure among the predictors in variable selection and regression coefficient estimation .
the proposed methods select models that satisfy the heredity principle and are much more interpretable in practice .
the proposed methods adopt the idea of the nonnegative garrote and inherit its advantages .
they are easy to compute and enjoy good theoretical properties .
similar to the original nonnegative garrote , the proposed method involves the choice of a tuning parameter which also amounts to the selection of a final model . throughout the paper ,
we have focused on using the cross - validation for such a purpose .
other tuning methods could also be used . in particular
, it is known that prediction - based tuning may result in unnecessarily large models .
several heuristic methods are often adopted in practice to alleviate such problems .
one of the most popular choices is the so - called one standard error rule [ breiman et al .
( @xcite ) ] , where instead of choosing the model that minimizes the cross - validation score , one chooses the simplest model with a cross - validation score within one standard error from the smallest .
our experience also suggests that a visual examination of the solution path and the cross - validation scores often leads to further insights .
the proposed method can also be used in other statistical problems whenever the structures among predictors should be respected in model building . in some applications , certain predictor variables
may be known apriori to be more important than the others .
this may happen , for example , in time series prediction where more recent observations generally should be more predictive of future observations .
boyd , s. and vandenberghe , l. ( 2004 ) .
_ convex optimization_. cambridge univ .
press , cambridge .
breiman , l. ( 1995 ) .
better subset regression using the nonnegative garrote .
_ technometrics _ * 37 * 373384 .
breiman , l. and friedman , j. ( 1985 ) .
estimating optimal transformations for multiple regression and correlation .
_ j. amer .
assoc . _ * 80 * 580598 .
breiman , l. , friedman , j. , stone , c. and olshen , r. ( 1984 ) . _
classifcation and regression trees_. chapman & hall / crc , new york .
chipman , h. ( 1996 ) .
bayesian variable selection with related predictors .
j. statist . _
* 24 * 1736 .
chipman , h. , hamada , m. and wu , c. f. j. ( 1997 ) . a bayesian variable selection approach for analyzing designed experiments with complex aliasing . _ technometrics _ * 39 * 372381 .
choi , n. , li , w. and zhu , j. ( 2006 ) .
variable selection with the strong heredity constraint and its oracle property .
technical report .
efron , b. , johnstone , i. , hastie , t. and tibshirani , r. ( 2004 ) .
least angle regression ( with discussion ) .
statist . _
* 32 * 407499 .
fan , j. and li , r. ( 2001 ) .
variable selection via nonconcave penalized likelihood and its oracle properties .
_ j. amer .
assoc . _ * 96 * 13481360 .
george , e. i. and mcculloch , r. e. ( 1993 ) .
variable selection via gibbs sampling . _ j. amer . statist .
assoc . _ * 88 * 881889 .
hamada , m. and wu , c. f. j. ( 1992 ) .
analysis of designed experiments with complex aliasing .
_ journal of quality technology _ * 24 * 130137 .
harrison , d. and rubinfeld , d. ( 1978 ) .
hedonic prices and the demand for clean air .
_ journal of environmental economics and management _ * 5 * 81102 .
hastie , t. , tibshirani , r. and friedman , j. ( 2003 ) . _ the elements of statistical learning : data mining , inference , and prediction_. springer , new york .
joseph , v. r. and delaney , j. d. ( 2007 ) . functionally induced priors for the analysis of experiments .
_ technometrics _ * 49 * 111 .
li , x. , sundarsanam , n. and frey , d. ( 2006 ) .
regularities in data from factorial experiments .
_ complexity _ * 11 * 3245 .
mccullagh , p. ( 2002 ) .
what is a statistical model ( with discussion ) .
_ * 30 * 12251310 .
mccullagh , p. and nelder , j. ( 1989 ) .
_ generalized linear models _ , 2nd ed
chapman & hall , london .
nelder , j. ( 1977 ) . a reformulation of linear models .
a _ * 140 * 4877 .
nelder , j. ( 1994 ) .
the statistics of linear models .
_ statist .
comput . _ * 4 * 221234 .
nelder , j. ( 1998 ) .
the selection of terms in response - surface models how strong is the weak - heredity principle ? _
statist . _ * 52 * 315318 .
newman , d. , hettich , s. , blake , c. and merz , c. ( 1998 ) .
uci repository of machine learning databases .
information and computer science , univ .
california , irvine , ca .
available at http://www.ics.uci.edu/\textasciitilde mlearn / mlrepository.html[http://www.ics.uci.edu/\textasciitilde mlearn / mlrepository.html ] .
osborne , m. , presnell , b. and turlach , b. ( 2000 ) . a new approach to variable selection in least squares problems .
_ i m a j. numer .
* 20 * 389403 .
tibshirani , r. ( 1996 ) .
regression shrinkage and selection via the lasso .
b _ * 58 * 267288 .
turlach , b. ( 2004 ) .
discussion of `` least angle regression . '' _ ann .
statist . _
* 32 * 481490 .
yuan , m. , joseph , v. r. and lin , y. ( 2007 ) .
an efficient variable selection approach for analyzing designed experiments .
_ technometrics _ * 49 * 430439
. yuan , m. and lin , y. ( 2006 ) .
model selection and estimation in regression with grouped variables .
b _ * 68 * 4967 .
yuan , m. and lin , y. ( 2007 ) . on the the nonnegative garrote estimator .
b _ * 69 * 143161 . | in linear regression problems with related predictors , it is desirable to do variable selection and estimation by maintaining the hierarchical or structural relationships among predictors . in this paper
we propose non - negative garrote methods that can naturally incorporate such relationships defined through effect heredity principles or marginality principles .
we show that the methods are very easy to compute and enjoy nice theoretical properties .
we also show that the methods can be easily extended to deal with more general regression problems such as generalized linear models .
simulations and real examples are used to illustrate the merits of the proposed methods . , . |
long gamma - ray bursts ( lgrbs , see the reviews by * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) are energetic radiation events , lasting between 2 and @xmath21000 seconds , and with photon energies in the range of kev mev .
our current understanding of these sources indicates that the emission is produced during the collapse of massive stars , when the recently formed black hole accretes the debris of the stellar core . during the accretion , highly collimated ultrarelativistic jets consisting mainly of an expanding plasma of leptons and photons ( fireball )
are launched , which drill the stellar envelope .
internal shocks in the fireball accelerate leptons and produce the @xmath3-ray radiation through synchrotron and inverse compton processes .
external shocks from the interaction of the jets with the interstellar medium produce later emission at lower energies , from x - rays to radio ( afterglow ) .
optical afterglow spectra allowed the measurement of lgrb redshifts @xcite , locating these sources at cosmological distances ( @xmath4 ) , and revealing that their energetics is similar to that of supernovae ( sne ) .
some lgrbs have indeed been observed to be associated to hydrogen - deficient , type ib / c supernovae ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
afterglows allowed also the identification of lgrb host galaxies ( hgs ) , which turned out to be mostly low - mass , blue and subluminous galaxies with active star formation @xcite .
although the general picture is clear enough , its details are still a matter of discussion . among other unanswered questions , the exact nature of the lgrb stellar progenitors is still being debated .
stellar evolution models provide a rough picture of the production of a lgrb in a massive star . according to the _ collapsar _ model @xcite ,
lgrbs are produced during the collapse of single wolf - rayet ( wr ) stars .
wr stars have massive cores that may collapse into black holes , and are fast rotators , a condition needed to support an accretion disc and launch the collimated jets .
wrs have also large mass - loss rates , needed to lose their hydrogen envelope before collapsing , that would otherwise brake the lgrb jet .
this model agrees with the observed association between lgrbs and hydrogen deficient sne
. however , wrs large mass - loss rates imply large angular momentum losses that would brake their cores , which would inhibit the production of the lgrb . to overcome this problem , @xcite proposed low - metallicity wrs ( wos ) as progenitors .
wos have lower mass - loss rates , diminishing the braking effect , but also preventing the loss of the envelope .
another possibility was proposed by @xcite . according to these authors , low - metallicity , rapidly rotating massive stars evolve in a chemically homogeneous way , hence burning the hydrogen envelope , instead of losing it .
low - metallicity progenitor models are consistent with different pieces of evidence .
first , the works of @xcite and @xcite show that the collapse of high - metallicity stars produces mainly neutron stars , while those of low - metallicity stars form black holes .
second , lgrb hgs have been found to be low - metallicity systems @xcite .
finally , the analysis of the statistical properties of the population of lgrbs suggests that their cosmic production rate should increase with respect to the cosmic star formation rate at high redshift , which could be explained as an effect of the low metallicity of the progenitors , combined with the cosmic metallicity evolution @xcite . another possibility for wr to lose
the envelope without losing too much angular momentum is to be part of binary systems as proposed by @xcite .
understanding the nature of lgrb progenitors is beyond the interest of only stellar evolution , black hole formation , and high energy astrophysics .
the visibility of lgrbs up to very high redshifts ( @xmath5 ) , allows their use as tools to explore star formation and galaxy evolution in the early universe . on the other hand , observations of the environment and hgs of lgrbs
could reveal important clues about the progenitors of these phenomena . given that star formation shifts outward within a galaxy due to the depletion of gas in the central regions
as the galaxy evolves , that the interstellar medium of galaxies is not chemically homogeneous , and that the chemical enrichment is affected by variations of the star formation rate and the production of different types of sne , it is expected that both the lgrb positions within a galaxy and the chemical properties of the environment in which lgrbs occur depend on redshift and on the metallicity of the lgrb progenitors . using high - precision astrometry , @xcite and @xcite
have measured the positions of @xmath235 lgrbs with respect to the centres of their hosts , supporting the collapsar model against the ( now disproved ) neutron star merger model .
the question of the metallicity dependence of lgrb progenitors could also be investigated comparing these data with model predictions .
the chemical abundances of lgrb circumburst and hg environments were investigated by several authors @xcite .
however , only in a few cases of low - redshift bursts a direct measure of the metallicity of the star - forming region that produced the lgrb is available . at intermediate redshift observers
usually measure the mean hg metallicity , while at high redshift they must resort to grb - dla techniques , which give the metallicity of galactic clouds intercepting the line of sight to the lgrb , but not necessarily associated with the burst itself @xcite . in this paper
, we use cosmological hydrodynamical simulations which include star formation and sn feedback to investigate the predictions of different progenitor scenarios regarding the positions of lgrbs and the chemical abundances of their environment . since galaxy formation is a highly non - linear process , cosmological numerical simulations @xcite are the best tools to investigate these lgrb properties . in the past
, this method has been used by several authors to investigate different aspects of the lgrb environment and hgs . @xcite
have shown that requiring hgs to have high star formation efficiency , the observed hg luminosity function can be reproduced .
@xcite developed a monte carlo simulation to synthesize lgrb and hg populations in hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation , in the framework of the collapsar model .
they have found that a bias to low - metallicity progenitors ( @xmath6 ) is needed to explain the observed properties of hgs . @xcite and
@xcite used semi - analytical models of galaxy formation to study the properties of hg populations .
particularly @xcite developed a new approach to model the detectability of the lgrbs .
both teams explored models with mass and metallicity cut - offs for lgrb progenitors , finding that models with a metallicity cut - off could explain the hg properties , and hence supporting previous claims that lgrbs are biased tracers of star formation . however in these semi - analytical models , the spatial distribution of individual stellar populations within hgs can not be investigated .
the chemical abundances of lgrb - dlas were investigated using numerical simulations by @xcite , finding that the clouds producing the absorption lie at galactocentric distances of the order of 1 kpc . in this work ,
we use cosmological numerical simulations of galaxy formation to construct synthetic lgrb populations , which allow us to investigate the properties of individual stellar populations within hgs .
our simulations are similar to those of @xcite , but with a higher resolution , and include the effects of the energy feedback of sne into the interstellar medium .
the metallicities of each stellar populations can be estimated , and used to construct different metallicity - dependent scenarios for lgrb production within the collapsar model . as stated by @xcite ,
the detectability of lgrbs and their hgs is an important aspect that should not be disregarded for a proper comparison with the observed samples , hence we included it in our population synthesis in the same way as these authors .
this work is organized as follows . in sections [ sim ] and [ mod ]
we describe the cosmological simulations of galaxy formation used , and our lgrb population synthesis models , respectively .
we present our results and compare the to available observational data in section [ res ] .
finally , in section [ con ] we present our conclusions .
we analyse hydrodynamical cosmological simulations performed with a version of gadget-3 which includes star formation , metal - dependent cooling , chemical enrichment , multiphase gas and supernova feedback ( for further details see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) the simulated regions represent periodic volumes of 10 mpc @xmath7 side and are consistent with a @xmath8-cdm universe with the following cosmological parameters : @xmath9=0.7 , @xmath10=0.3 , @xmath11=0.04 , @xmath12=0.9 and @xmath13=100 @xmath14 where @xmath15=0.7 .
the feedback model considers type ii and type ia supernovae ( snii and snia , respectively ) .
the energy per sn event released into the interstellar medium is @xmath16 .
the model assumes that stars with masses greater than @xmath17 end their life as snii with lifetime @xmath18yr .
lifetimes for the progenitors of snia are randomly selected in the range @xmath19 gyr .
the chemical yields for snii are given by @xcite while those of snia correspond to the w7 model of @xcite .
initially gas particles are assumed to have primordial abundances of x@xmath20=0.76 and x@xmath21=0.24 .
the chemical algorithm follows the enrichment by 12 isotopes : @xmath22h , @xmath23he , @xmath24c , @xmath25o , @xmath26 mg , @xmath27si , @xmath28fe , @xmath29n , @xmath30ne , @xmath31s , @xmath32ca and @xmath33zn @xcite .
we would like to stress that this model has proven to be successfull at regulating the star formation activity and at driving powerful mass - loaded galactic winds without the need to introduce mass - depend parameters @xcite .
we analyse two simulations : s230 and s320 , which have been also used by @xcite to study the tully - fisher relation obtaining very good agreement with observations .
s230 has initially @xmath34 with dark matter masses of @xmath35 and initial gas mass of @xmath36 .
s320 initially has @xmath37 with dark matter of @xmath38 and initial gas mass of @xmath39 .
s320 was only run to @xmath40 because of lack of computational power .
we use this simulation to assess possible numerical resolution problems . from the general mass distribution , we select virialized structures by using the friends - of - friends technique and then identify all substructures within the virial radius by applying the subfind algorithm @xcite .
we select as simulated galaxies those substructures sampled with more than 3000 particles .
@xcite found that the mass - metallicity relation ( mzr ) of galaxies in these simulations differs at low redshifts from that reported by @xcite so that galaxies have lower mean metallicity than observed although the shape of the observed mzr is very well reproduced . because of this , we renormalized the simulated abundances to make them consistent with observations .
for that purpose , we adopted the results of @xcite who proposed a model to describe the evolution of observed mzr which matched available observations at z=0.07 , 0.7 and 2.2 . with this adjustement , our simulated mzr reproduce observations at different redshifts . for illustration purposes , we show our analysis at four redshifts : @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
to construct synthetic lgrb populations from the stellar populations described by the simulations we adopt the collapsar model , in which lgrb progenitors are massive stars possibly with low metallicity .
we investigate four scenarios in which progenitors have a mass greater than a certain minimum @xmath43 . for scenario 1
this is the only condition , while for the others a maximum metallicity @xmath44 is assumed for the progenitors .
the values of @xmath43 and @xmath44 were taken from @xcite , who derived them by fitting the lgrb rate observed by batse , and are listed in table [ scenarios2 ] .
we estimate the number of massive stars in each simulated galaxy at each analysed redshift by assuming a initial mass function given by @xcite .
we included all stars born within @xmath45 .
this time interval is larger than the mean lifetime of snii progenitors but it allow us to minimize numerical fluctuations and it is small compared to sfr variations .
the selected progenitors defined the scenario 1 . for scenarios 2 , 3 , and 4 we impose a requirement on the mean metallicity , considering only new born stars with @xmath46 , respectively . following @xcite , for each stellar population represented by a particle @xmath47 with mass @xmath48 at redshift @xmath49 satisfying the above requirements , we calculated the number of lgrbs produced as the number of stars with @xmath50 , @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the initial mass function with @xmath53 and @xmath54 its lower and upper mass cut - offs , respectively .
.properties of the four scenarios proposed for lgrbs .
the values of minimal masses where taken from @xcite with the initial mass function of @xcite . [ cols="<,<,>,>,>,>,<,>,<,>",options="header " , ] the intrinsic lgrb rate for a stellar population in any scenario is then @xmath55 we are interested in computing observable properties of the stellar populations selected by lgrb observations , such as metallicites , @xmath1-elements abundances , and distances to their hg centre . as discussed by @xcite , selection effects introduced by observations
can be modeled by weighting the properties of simulated stellar populations by their contribution to the total observed lgrb rate at the earth .
we applied the method developed by @xcite to estimate the probability that a certain lgrb produced at a given @xmath49 could be observed at earth .
however , there might be other biases introduced by observations which are difficult to model because of their dependence on sensitivity and spectral bands of the detectors and telescopes .
particularly , the afterglow observations , on which the precise positioning of lgrbs is based , are usually made in the optical range and could be affected by dust absoption , biasing the samples towards low metallicity systems . as claimed by @xcite , about 40 per cent of lgrbs
might be dust obscured .
dust effects have not been included in our scenarios hence , caution should be taken when comparing our results with observations .
we will point out posible dust effects when appropriate .
at fixed redshift , the weights depend only on the intrinsic lgrb rate of the corresponding stellar population , becoming @xmath56 where the sum extends over all the stellar populations @xmath57 producing lgrbs at a given redshift . for any observable property @xmath58 of these stellar populations ,
its mean observed value at @xmath49 must then be @xmath59
we first investigate the spatial distribution of lgrbs in our scenarios . for this purpose
, we calculate the distance between the lgrb and the centre of mass of its galaxy @xmath60 . to eliminate the effects produced by the growth of galaxies
as the structure in the universe assembles , we normalize @xmath60 by taking the ratio @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is the optical radius of the galaxy , defined as the radius encompassing 83 per cent of its baryonic mass @xcite . in the fig .
[ bnorm ] we present the distribution of @xmath61 for the lgrbs at different redshifts ( @xmath63 ) , weighted by their detectability as explained in section [ mod ] .
we observe that lgrb progenitors tend to reside in the inner regions galaxies at high redshift , and to be progressively located at larger distances from the centre as redshift decreases .
this is consistent with the fact that the main sites of star formation shift outwards as time evolves and the galactic structure gets assembled in a hierarchical fashion .
this effect is stronger in our scenarios with higher @xmath64 , because low metallicity populations tend to be formed in the outer regions of galaxies which are less enriched since all simulated systems exhibit metallicity gradients .
( solid lines ) , 2 ( dashed lines ) , 1 ( dotted line ) , and 0 ( dot - dashed lines).,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in fig .
[ bmedian ] , we plot the median values of @xmath61 in our scenarios as a function of redshift , together with the available observations of the lgrbs positions within their hosts @xcite .
these authors measure the distance of lgrb to the centre of their hosts , projected onto the plane of the sky , and normalised by the galaxy half - light radius @xmath65 .
as these authors point out , this normalisation is a crude way of deprojecting the values of @xmath60 . to transform them into @xmath61
, we assume that lgrb hosts can be modeled by an exponential disc , for which @xmath66 .
[ bmedian ] shows that our scenarios are consistent with observations , except at very low redshifts in which the observed median value of @xmath61 drops abruptly , while our scenarios remain almost constant . by analysing the lgrbs contributing to the lowest-@xmath49 point in fig .
[ bmedian ] , we find that almost half of them ( 3 out of 7 ) have @xmath61 values consistent with zero .
interestingly , the hosts of these lgrbs show evidence of interaction or close companions .
hence , the presence of nuclear star formation activity could be explained as triggered by galaxy interactions as suggested by observations @xcite and numerical simulations @xcite .
then , the discrepancy can be attributed to the fact that our simulated galaxy sample does not reflect the effects of this mode of star formation at low redshift since our analysed galaxies are dominated by systems with low gas reservoir @xcite . a further piece of evidence for this explanation is provided by a recalculation of the lowest-@xmath49 point , excluding the three quoted lgrbs ( filled circle in fig .
[ bmedian ] ) .
the new point lies within @xmath67 of our scenarios , showing a better agreement than the original one .
the large error bars of the observations , which originate in the low number of lgrbs with precise positions , prevent us from using a goodness - of - fit estimator to determine the scenario that better fits the observations .
however the fact that the observed values are always higher than the predictions of scenarios sc1 and sc2 implies that it is very improbable that these scenarios could explain the observations .
hence our results suggest that lgrb progenitors would have low metallicities ( @xmath68 ) . in the case
that dust effects introduce important biases in the impact parameter distribution , the preference for low metallicity progenitors obtained from fig .
[ bmedian ] would have to be re - considered .
observations providing new insights on the location of dark grbs may help to resolve this issue .
to analyse the chemical abundances of the lgrb progenitors in our scenarios , we use the ratio [ fe / h ] as a measure of the iron abundance , and [ si / fe ] as a measure of the relative abundance of @xmath1 elements to iron . in fig .
[ feh ] we present the distribution of [ fe / h ] for the lgrb progenitors in our scenarios at different redshifts , wheighed by the detectability in the same way as in the previous section .
we observe that the abundance of iron increases as redshift decreases in all scenarios .
this can be understood in terms of the chemical evolution of the interstellar medium .
as time evolves sne contribute to the enrichment of the medium with iron , hence stellar populations born at low redshifts exhibit higher iron abundances .
this enrichment is stronger in scenarios sc1 and sc2 , where the metallicity cut - offs are not so restrictive .
( solid line ) , 2 ( dashed line ) , 1 ( dotted line ) , and 0 ( dot - dashed line).,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in fig .
[ cum_sife ] we present the distribution of [ si / fe ] for lgrb progenitors .
we observe that , for all our scenarios , they exibit a higher [ si / fe ] as redshift increases , indicating an enhacement in @xmath1 elements at high redshifts .
this is consistent with the fact that snia and snii enrich the interstellar medium .
due to the fact that snia progenitors have lifetimes @xmath69 while those of snii live only @xmath70 , at high redshift only the contribution of the latter to the interstelar medium enrichment is significant , rendering stellar populations rich in @xmath1 elements .
as redshift decreases , the contribution of snia becomes important , decreasing the abundance of @xmath1 elements relative to iron .
the trend of [ si / fe ] to decrease towards lower redshift is also observed in fig.[medians_sife_feh ] ( right panel ) , where we plot the median value of the ratio [ si / fe ] as a function of redshift . in this figure
we also observe that the values of [ si / fe ] of the lgrb progenitors is lower and evolve more strongly with redshift in the scenarios where the metallicity cut - off is more restrictive . in the left panel of fig .
[ medians_sife_feh ] we show the median value of the ratio [ fe / h ] as a function of redshift .
we find that the median value of [ fe / h ] decreases with @xmath44 as expected for cut - offs progressively more restrictive in metallicity .
these results indicate that the metallicity cut - off tends to eliminate old stellar populations highly enriched by snii , located mainly in the central regions of galaxies and originated in first outbreaks of star formation .
this interpretation agrees with the shift of the normalized impact parameters of lgrb progenitors observed in fig .
[ bnorm ] . for @xmath71 ( solid line ) , 2 (
dashed line ) , 1 ( dotted line ) , and 0 ( dot - dashed line ) in all scenarios proposed.,scaledwidth=45.0% ]
aiming at understanding the relation between lgrbs and star formation , we analysed the spatial distribution and chemical abundances of stellar populations producing these phenomena .
we investigated four different scenarios for the progenitors of lgrbs based on the collapsar model with different metallicity cut - offs .
we compared the spatial distribution of lgrbs within their hgs in our scenarios and with the available observations .
we found that in all our scenarios lgrb progenitors reside on average in the outer regions of their galaxies at low redshifts , shifting toward the centre as redshift increases .
scenarios favouring low metallicity progenitors tend to produce lgrbs further out from the central regions than those allowing high metallicity progenitors .
the confrontation of our models with available observations supports scenarios with low metallicity cut - offs , in agreement with previous results @xcite .
particulary we best reproduce current available observations for a model where lgrb progenitors are massive stars with @xmath72 .
further precise lgrb position measurements would help to confirm these trends .
regarding [ fe / h ] abundances of the stellar populations producing lgrbs , we found that in all our scenarios [ fe / h ] increases as redshift decreases .
this effect is less conspicuous in the scenarios with low metallicity progenitors , as in these cases the metallicity cut - off restricts the chemical abundances of the stellar populations producing lgrbs
. the @xmath1-enhancement decreases with redshift in all our scenarios , as a result of the different contributions of snii and snia .
contrary to the detected trend in [ fe / h ] , the @xmath1-enhancement shows a stronger evolution with redshift as @xmath44 decreases .
as previously discussed , these chemical trends can be understood within the context of chemical evolution in hierarchical clustering scenarios .
considering that the results on the spatial distribution of lgrb progenitors favours low - metallicity progenitor models , one would expect that the iron abundance of the stellar populations producing lgrbs remains low at all redshifts with little variations ( @xmath73}\sim-1 $ ] ) .
on the other hand , one would expect that the @xmath1-enhancement strongly decreases with redshift ( by 0.2 dex between @xmath71 and @xmath74 ) .
this means that , if lgrbs are produced by low metallicity massive stars , their location will be shifted on average from the central regions to the outskirts of galaxies .
if lgrbs can trace the chemical properties of the interestelar medium , they may map different regions of galaxies at different redshifts .
a test of these prediction could be set up as further dust - corrected measurements of the chemical abundances of the stellar populations producing lgrbs become available .
ljp acknowledges funding by argentine anpcyt , through grant pict 2006 - 02015 and 2007 - 00848 .
this work was partially supported by pict 2005 - 32342 , pict 2006 - 245 max planck and pip 2009 - 0305 . | we analyse the spatial distribution within host galaxies and chemical properties of the progenitors of long gamma ray bursts as a function of redshift . by using hydrodynamical cosmological simulations which include star formation , supernova feedback and chemical enrichment and based on the hypothesis of the collapsar model with low metallicity
, we investigate the progenitors in the range @xmath0 .
our results suggest that the sites of these phenomena tend to be located in the central regions of the hosts at high redshifts but move outwards for lower ones .
we find that scenarios with low metallicity cut - offs best fit current observations .
for these scenarios long gamma ray bursts tend to be [ fe / h ] poor and show a strong @xmath1-enhancement evolution towards lower values as redshift decreases .
the variation of typical burst sites with redshift would imply that they might be tracing different part of galaxies at different redshifts .
[ firstpage ] gamma - rays : bursts galaxies : abundances , evolution |
since the beginning of accelerator physics , mass spectroscopy has been playing a leading role in the discovery of particle and resonance states , and understanding of the fundamental interactions in the standard model ( sm ) .
for example , the first signals of charm and bottom quarks were in fact detected through the formation of @xmath0 and @xmath1 bound states .
on the other hand , current colliders like the lhc , or the ilc in a farther future , will likely continue this discovery program beyond the sm .
it is conceivable that new ( super ) heavy bound states can be formed and , contrary to e.g. the toponium system , their basic constituents are prevented from decaying before the binding is effective .
the goal of this paper is to perfom a prospective study of the spectroscopy of such exotic massive states , by making several reasonable assumptions about the interacting potential among the new - physics constituents which may differ from standard qcd .
furthermore , we will estimate leptonic decay widths of very heavy bound states by making specific assumptions on the quantum numbers of constituents , although not in a comprehensive way . during the last years , minimal extensions of the sm containing additional heavy particles charged under a new unbroken non - abelian gauge group @xmath2 with fermions _
q,@xmath3 _ have been proposed under the general name of @xmath4hidden valley
models @xcite , which is a very general scenario containing such heavy particles but as well new sectors of lightweight particles to be observed . in these models
all sm particles would be neutral under such the new @xmath2 group , while new particles charged under @xmath2 but neutral under the sm group would show up if large energy scales are probed .
higher dimension operators , induced e.g. by a @xmath5 or a loop involving heavy particles carrying both @xmath6 and @xmath2 charges , should connect both sm and new physics sectors through rather weak interactions .
in particular , if the @xmath2 group corresponds to @xmath7 , the fermions in the fundamental representation have been recently named as @xmath4quirks " @xcite or iquarks @xcite .
@xcite actually this theory can be viewed as a certain limit of qcd where light quarks are removed and the typical scale @xmath8 where the new interaction becomes strong is much smaller than the heavy flavor masses .
more generally , such kind of scenario can be put in correspondence with a class of @xmath4hidden valley
models as pointed out in @xcite . in these models ,
quirks are defined to be new massive fermions transforming under both @xmath6 and a general ( not only @xmath9 ) non - abelian gauge group @xmath2 .
it has been considered so far in the literature that @xmath8 is smaller than @xmath10 , but as well the particular case of hidden valleys with quirks in which @xmath8 is greater than @xmath10 has been studied in the literature @xcite,@xcite,@xcite .
the name of _ infracolour _ is used to design of the new gluonic degrees of freedom when @xmath8 is much smaller than the quirk mass ; in this work we will refer to it as i - colour ( i - qcd ) in correspondence with the name quirk .
in this section we will focus on the bound states of quirks .
the phenomenology of such bound states has first studied in @xcite , and later an analysis on the spectroscopy of these systems was done by the authors of @xcite .
+ it is well - known that the large mass of the top quark in the sm prevents toponium to be formed since the constituents quarks would decay away too fast .
a criterion for existence of such bound states is that the binding energy should be larger than the total decay width . for heavy onia states beyond the sm ,
however , the situation could be different .
in particular , in the case of quirks @xcite,@xcite,@xcite , its decay is prevented from the conservation of a quantum number .
regarding the dynamics of these quirks , according to @xcite , one can distinguish among three possible energy scales : the first one is the @xmath11 range , where the quirk strings are macroscopic ; the mesoscopic strings can be find at the range @xmath12 ( which is large compared to the atomic scales ) ; and finally we find the microscopic scale at @xmath13 .
+ on the other hand , assuming that the scale of i - colour is below the weak scale , bound states of the new sector are kinematically accessible to present and future collider experiments .
however , since the sm particles are uncharged under i - colour , ( quirk ) loops would be required to couple both sectors leading to highly supressed production rates . moreover , from reference @xcite , quirks are defined to be charged under ( some ) gauge groups of the sm ( for example , charged under the electroweak interaction ) quirks could be pair produced through electroweak processes .
+ likewise , in ref.@xcite quirks are considered as vectors with respect to the electroweak gauge group without carrying qcd colour , but carrying i - colour charge .
therefore notice that there is no yukawa coupling between the higgs boson and quirks .
thus we discard the possible binding force which has been postulated for ultraheavy quarkonium taking over gluon - exchange . at this point , for the sake of clarity , it must be stressed that , taking simple assumptions , through this work we will focus on the case of uncoloured quirks .
+ in this scenario , quirks can be copiously pair - produced at the lhc not through qcd interactions but via electromagnetic and electroweak interactions . as quirks
would be long - lived particles as compared to the collider / detection time scale , different detection strategies can be undertaken according to the possible aforementioned micro , meso or macroscopic regimes .
+ finally , notice that possible quirky signals of folded supersymmetry in colliders have been studied in @xcite , focusing on the scalar quirks ( _ squirks _ ) .
contrary to usual supersymmetric partners of quarks , squirks ( choosing a simple scenario ) are expected to be uncolored , but instead charged under a new confining group , equivalent to i - qcd as introduced above .
the study of spectroscopy performed in this paper is actually not sensitive to possible scalar nature of new fermions , and the main lines could be applicable to squirkonium as well .
according to @xcite , when the quirk pair is produced an excited bound state can be formed with invariant mass given approximately by the total center of momentum energy of the hard partonic scattering giving raise to the pair . in the microscopic regime this bound state would loose energy by emitting i - glueballs and bremsstrahlung towards low - lying states .
once they loose most of their kinetic energy these bound states ( to be dubbed quirkonium ) could decay via electroweak interaction .
however , it is also possible other scenario in which the neutral and colourless quirk pair might have a prompt annihilation before they can loose energy enough to form the low lying quirkonium state .
however , due to the non perturvative nature of the mechanisms it is difficult to estimate in advance the proportion of the events falling in each scenario , and therefore the possibility to detect these low lying states can not be discarded . through this work , in particular we will focus on neutral bound states which can decay , e.g. to final - state dileptons , providing a clean signature even admits a huge hadronic background as at the lhc experiments .
+ new particles with a mass of up to several hundred gev can be pair copiously produced at the lhc .
one expects that quirks will be in general produced with kinetic energy quite larger than @xmath8 .
a significant fraction of this energy should be lost by emission of photons and i - glueballs prior to pair - annihilation .
the two quirks will fly off back - to - back , developing a i - qcd string or flux tube . in usual qcd with light matter
the string is broken up promptly by creating light quark - antiquark pair ; in i - qcd this mechanism is practically absent .
the two heavy ends of the string would continue to move apart , eventually stopping once all the kinetic energy was stored in the string .
the quirks would be then pulled together by the string beginning an oscillatory motion .
most examples of late - decaying particles that have been addressed in the literature yield missing energy , while quirks would annihilate into visible energy in most modes .
besides , as explained in @xcite and @xcite , only i - colour singlet states could be observed .
as commented before , in a optimistic scenario , the excited bound state will emit i - glueballs and bremsstrahlung , towards low - lying states ; then they would annihilate into a hard final state : di - lepton , di - jet , or di - photon .
+ if we want to investigate whether or not it is possible to disentangle different state levels under the assumption of a given ( large ) quirk mass and a specific form of new i - colour interaction , then we could focus on a dimuon signal from the annihilation of a _ narrow _ resonance , since it is the most promising channel @xcite ; it then becomes crucial if the level spacing of different @xmath14-wave states is enough to the foreseen mass resolution based on invariant mass reconstruction from a dimuon system . according to the reference @xcite the detection of bound states at hadron colliders
is reliable because the signal production is strong and peaked in invariant mass , and the dominant background is electroweak and diffuse . on the other hand ,
dimuon backgrounds from sources other than drell - yan can be suppressed by requiring no extra hard jets or missing energy . besides
, at the lhc , trigger and detector efficiencies are expected to be very high for high - mass dimuon events .
+ concerning other channels , it is expected that quirkonium annihilation into a electron pair could be also a useful signal since the invariant mass peak is expected to yield a similar peak to dimuon but smaller and wider due to detector effects .
on the other hand , in the squirkonium case , according to the reference @xcite the radiative decay ( by soft radiation ) from the highly excited states to the ground state can be ultimately detected by means of unclustered soft fotons in the uncolored case .
also , in ref .
@xcite it is pointed out the possibility to use the invariant mass peak of @xmath15photon , since this channel dominates the squirkonium annhilation at or near the ground state . if necessary , all these signals could aid to distinguish among different states .
+ focusing again on the dimuon signal , as it can be seen from atlas and cms reports @xcite,@xcite one can consider a @xmath16 accuracy for the transverse momentum of muons even at high momentum . since the dimuon invariant mass should coincide to a good approximation , for small ( pseudo)rapidities , with the transverse momentum error , @xmath17 ( since @xmath18 ) ; letting @xmath19 vary along the range @xmath20 $ ] gev , the mass resolution should roughly take the values along the interval @xmath21 $ ] gev .
hereafter we restrict our analysis to the range of @xmath8 given by @xmath22 but in the microscopic regime , namely @xmath23 as is well - known long ago , a non - relativistic treatment of the potential for conventional heavy quarkonium has proved to be suitable on account of the asymptotic freedom of qcd . moreover
, one distinguishes between short- and long - distance dynamics of constituents in the bound state leading to an effective ( static ) potential of the type : @xmath24 in particular we will write @xmath25 where the first term with @xmath26 would correspond to a coulombic interaction , and the second one with @xmath27 to a linear confining interaction . in this work
we will consider firstly a coulomb plus linear potential ( cpl ) with @xmath26 and @xmath27 ; later we will use a more general coulomb plus power law potential ( cpp ) with @xmath26 and @xmath28 as tentative possibilities .
the motivation for the insertion of these power law potentials comes up from the clasical studies of quarkonia ( see refs .
@xcite , @xcite , @xcite . )
in which are considered coulomb like , linear and cornell potentials , but as well the power law potentials are taken into account in order to cover possible deviations from them .
in this way and focusing on the case of quirkonium , in reference @xcite a pure linear potential is taken into account , in reference @xcite a coulomb - like potential were considered . therefore tracking the same philosophy than in the quarkonia case possible deviations
are also considered within this study .
moreover , the interaction accounting for the above static potential can be parameterized by the fermion ( quirk ) mass @xmath29 , where @xmath30 and an additional @xmath31 gauge coupling ( @xmath32 stands for the i - colour number ) which can be related with a i - colour scale @xmath8 .
in this work we will specify @xmath33 in eq.([eq : potential2 ] ) as @xmath34 to be interpreted as cpl ( @xmath27 ) and cpp ( @xmath28 ) potentials . here
@xmath35 corresponds to the i - color string tension and we have introduced a i - color coupling @xmath36 , alongside a group theory factor @xmath37 , in close analogy to qcd potential models ; hence , making a simple assumption , such group factor is taken as a mirror from qcd potentials ( @xmath38 ) and included into the infracolour coupling : i.e. , in calculations we set @xmath39 .
of course , other numerical choices for @xmath37 can be done , but @xmath36 depends on the @xmath8 scale which is actually uncertain as we shall discuss later .
+ on the other hand , in analogy to conventional qcd - inspired potential models , the i - colour string tension can be interpreted as a linear energy density ( @xmath40 ) , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
hence the relation @xmath43 is expected to remain ( approximately ) valid , likewise the equivalent qcd expression @xmath44 ( also derived from lattice calculations @xcite ) , and finally @xmath45 ^ 2\ \sigma_{s}\ ] ] in other words , a proportionality depending on the respective @xmath8 and @xmath10 between both string tensions could be expected from the above arguments .
basically , eq.([sigmalambda ] ) implies that @xmath35 and @xmath8 parameters are not independent of each other . for the sake of simplicity
, the unknown proportionality factor will be set equal to unity , so that by fixing @xmath8 one gets @xmath35 ( for given @xmath10 and @xmath46 values ) .
focusing on the @xmath8 scale , in this work in principle it corresponds to the microscopic @xmath47 scale depicted in ref.@xcite . numerically speaking ,
as it will be seen , the values of @xmath8 were taken below and above of the qcd scale in a bandwidth ; i.e. @xmath48 with @xmath49 to take into account the uncertainity about this quantity . in this way , the equation([sigmalambda ] ) can be regarded as a comparison between the strength of the linear potential in both sectors @xmath50 and the new gauge group @xmath51 , and it is intended to be an ansatz or a hint to determine numerically a proportionality between @xmath52 and @xmath35 , in which subsequently the numerical uncertainity about the proportionality factor is diluted , taking into account the lack of knowledge about @xmath8 . besides , this comparison between diferent theories can be viewed to some extent in a similar way than in classical physics , in which the strength of gravitational and the electrostatic forces are compared .
+ concerning the i - colour coupling constant , @xmath36 , it would be related with @xmath8 ; as we are dealing with a non - abelian i - colour binding force it implies @xmath36 is scale dependent .
we will compute @xmath36 value at the running scale @xmath53 according to @xcite : @xmath54 where @xmath32 is the i - colour number , and @xmath55 the number of quirk generation at the running scale . from eq.([sigmalambda ] ) and eq.([eq : alpha_s ] ) , one can see that both parameters @xmath35 and @xmath36 are depending on @xmath8 , so that they are not independent quantities .
nonetheless , all those constraints have to be taken with a grain of salt and one should consider as well values deviating from those given in eqs .
( [ sigmalambda ] - [ eq : alpha_s ] ) , as we will see later . in case of more quirk generations ,
additional active quirk should be taken into account at different energy scale thresholds . nevertheless
, for the sake of simplicity , and in view of still many unknowns in the different models , we will assume @xmath56 and @xmath57 throughout this work .
+ as previously mentioned , we consider that the quirk mass lies in the range @xmath58
. therefore one can reasonably expect that the bound system indeed meets a truly non - relativistic regime , i.e. the relative quirk velocity @xmath59 in the center of mass frame being substantially smaller than the value for bottomonium ( @xmath60 ) . focusing on quirkonium , a formal derivation of such non - relativistic limit from the relativistic degrees of freedom can be found in @xcite ; besides according to reference @xcite and @xcite , the bound state is formed in a highly excited state then it decays to the lower states loosing the main part of its kinetic energy .
therefore it is expected that in the lower levels near to the ground state this kinetic energy could be low enough to assume a non - relativistic aproximation . also , as we shall see later , the numerical results obtained for the expected quirk velocity @xmath61 in the com frame justify this approximation .
since we are interested to perform spectroscopy for very heavy non - relativistic bound states , the schrdinger radial equation must be solved : in a analytical way it could be done by means of a expansion of the quirkonium wave function in a complete basis ; nevertheless here we will choose to solve it numerically , and therefore one should expect that the method to get the resulting mass spectroscopy followed in the _ qq - onia _ package @xcite based on the resolution of the schrdinger radial equation using the numerov @xmath62 technique , should work appropriately for our analysis of quirkonium .
however , we are confronted here to the lack of experimental data to set the ground state of quirkonium , in sharp contrast with , e.g. , the bottomonium or charmonium systems .
nevertheless , let us stress that in this work we are here mainly interested in estimating the mass spacing between different state levels rather than their absolute values .
+ as commented in the introduction , new interactions and particles can form very massive bound states . in this section
we show the results for quirk @xmath63 bound state system by sweeping through the scale range , @xmath64 characterizing the i - colour force .
first we will look at the results using a coulomb plus linear potential ( cpl ) ( with @xmath26 and @xmath27 ) ; later using a coulomb plus power law potential ( cpp ) ( with @xmath26 and @xmath28 ) .
concerning the quirk mass , first we use @xmath65 gev , and later @xmath66 gev as representative values ( nevertheless in some calculations we will take additional values ) .
the energy levels , @xmath67 shown in tables correspond to @xmath68 where @xmath69 ( or @xmath70 ) is the quirkonium mass level . in all cases
, we set the ground state to be @xmath71 . besides as relevant calculations we will display also the squared radial wave function at the origin ( wfo ) ( or their derivatives ) , the size of each quirkonium level , and the mean value of the relative quirk velocity @xmath59 in their center of mass frame , since it is used in some calculations @xcite ; besides , the obtained velocities will check the non - relativistic approximation .
let us start by considering the cpl potential .
all tables cited in this and successive sections can be found in appendix .
results for the quirkonium spectrum with @xmath73 gev and @xmath74 mev are shown in table [ table:1 ] .
the corresponding parameters are @xmath75 and @xmath76 . concerning the mean radius , for the ground state we find a size similar to the bohr radius @xmath77 , and increases for higher states as expected up to @xmath78 ; moreover , with these parameters we can found ( @xmath79 ) states with sizes beyond @xmath80 , which is in accordance with @xmath81 .
the quirk velocity in the com frame @xmath82 slowly increasing with the @xmath83 and @xmath84 quantum numbers ; these low @xmath59 values plainly justify the non relativistic regime resulting from the qq - onia package .
+ we provide the squared wfo and derivatives divided by powers of the quirk mass obtained in our calculations , following the same behaviour with @xmath83 and @xmath84 as found in standard quarkonium ( see for instance @xcite and references therein ) . from the ground state wfo value we realize that @xmath85 state follows mainly a coulombic behaviour @xcite .
this is not the case for higher resonances , for the p states case we find that a coulombic ( derivative ) wfo underestimates the numerical value obtained from this potential .
let us stress that the energy level spacing ( notably between s - wave resonances , of order of tens of mev ) would not permit the experimental discrimination by using the dimuon annihilation channel ( and likely any other else ) .
table [ table:2 ] shows the results for @xmath86 ( @xmath87 and @xmath88 ) .
the @xmath89 level spacings turn out to be somewhat larger than in the previous case but still not enough to permit experimental discrimination .
something similar can be expected for @xmath90 mev as can be seen from table [ table:3 ] , with ( @xmath91 and @xmath92 ) . here
we find lower values for sizes of resonances with respect to previous case ( as expected since @xmath8 increases ) .
besides , we observe a wfo value for the ground state somewhat greater than the expected for a coulombic behaviour . the results shown in table [ table:4 ] ( appendix ) corresponds to the microscopic scale @xmath93 .
here @xmath94 , and @xmath95 .
the string tension turns to be much stronger than in the qcd case .
the energy levels reach the gev scale and the wfo grow to the @xmath96 gev@xmath97 values ; according with previous trend the corresponding derivatives are growing also .
the wfo value for the lowest state is @xmath98 times greater than the expected for a coulombic behaviour .
concerning the level spacing this case is interesting since values among @xmath14-wave states turns out to be of order of @xmath99 gev , likely enough to be disentangled .
we now set the quirk mass equal to 500 gev , so quirkonium mass is of order of the tev scale . in table
[ table:5 ] the @xmath89 spectrum is shown for @xmath101 ( @xmath102 gev @xmath103 and @xmath104 ) . in table
[ table:6 ] we show the results for @xmath93 .
here @xmath105 , and @xmath106 gev @xmath103 .
again , as in the @xmath107 gev case at this scale , the level spacing among @xmath14-wave states could be enough to distinguish experimentally these levels .
+ let us now give @xmath108 values in the long - range term of eq.([eq : potential3 ] ) different from unity .
as in qcd , a larger ( smaller ) @xmath108 leads to stronger ( weaker ) long - distance interaction .
the general trends are similar to the cpl case seen in the previous section .
tables [ table:7 ] and [ table:8 ] show the @xmath89 spectrum for @xmath110 and @xmath111 respectively for @xmath112 .
as we can see the sizes of bound states are similar to the bottomonium case @xcite,@xcite
. tables [ table:9 ] and [ table:10 ] ( appendix ) provides again the corresponding @xmath89 spectrum for @xmath113 and @xmath100 , but this time having set @xmath114 .
here we observe values of wfo for the ground state similar to the ones expected for a coulombic behaviour ; however higher resonances do not behave in this manner . to cover possible deviations from linear behaviour of the long distance part of the potential
we analyze the cpp potential setting @xmath115 .
tables [ table:11 ] and [ table:12 ] ( appendix ) show the @xmath89 spectrum for with @xmath101 for @xmath107 gev and @xmath116 gev respectively .
tables [ table:13 ] and [ table:14 ] display the corresponding results for the @xmath89 spectrum for @xmath107 gev and @xmath116 gev with @xmath93 . + in order to compare the effect of the above mentioned potentials , in figure 1 we plot the @xmath117 level spacings @xmath118 of quirkonium found with the cpl and cpp potentials ( @xmath119 respectively ) for different @xmath29 and @xmath8 values .
as far as we are interested in disentangling peaks of @xmath14-wave resonances , it becomes apparent that this would be only possible in some cases ( i.e. @xmath93 ) where the level spacing is @xmath120 gev or larger . finally , to take into account other contributions which could be entangled in the short distance part of the potential
, we consider higher ( non perturbative ) @xmath121 effective values . in order to consider this scenario , we do not use the eq.([eq : alpha_s ] ) for @xmath36 but we take it as a free parameter . on the other hand
we keep the explicit dependence of @xmath8 ( eq.([sigmalambda ] ) ) in @xmath35 . in this case
we also increase the @xmath8 values from @xmath114 up to @xmath122 . by using _
qq - onia _ code we find the results with @xmath116 gev for the mass level spacing @xmath123 which are shown in table [ table:15 ] ( appendix ) .
as we can see from these situations , we find separation between levels tens of gev , thus , in principle , we should be able to discriminate at least between these resonances .
next let us analyze the wfo dependence w.r.t .
the quirk mass using the above explained cpp potentials .
here we focus on the @xmath85 ground level , by taking quirk mass values from @xmath124 up to @xmath125 .
again we will take @xmath126 for each potential . for intermediate @xmath29 values
@xmath35 does not change w.r.t .
the mass values , however here @xmath127 changes for each case according to eq.([eq : alpha_s ] ) .
figure 2 displays the obtained results .
once computed the squared wfo , we can evaluate numerically the partial decay widths of neutral ( @xmath128 ) quirkonium ( @xmath129 ) to different final states .
all of them are proportional to the ratio @xmath130 , where @xmath70 is the quirkonium mass .
subsequently we make estimates of the respective branching ratios ( @xmath131 ) . + we will follow a similar treatment as the authors of @xcite,@xcite who considered the following @xmath129 decay modes : * decay to standard model fermion pairs ( @xmath132leptons and quarks ) @xmath133 where @xmath134 stands for functions containing the i - colour number , squared mass ratios @xmath135 , the quirk electric charge @xmath136 . the @xmath137 label means that those sm parameters involved in this calculation parameters are included .
* decay to a @xmath138 pair @xmath139 where @xmath140 stands for a function entangling the i - colour number , squared mass ratios @xmath141 , and @xmath137 parameters .
* decay to i - gluons ( @xmath142 ) .
quirks couple to the i - gluon field of the @xmath31 with coupling strength @xmath143 , where @xmath144 is given by eq.([eq : alpha_s ] ) .
@xmath145 + here , @xmath146 is a function of the i - colour number and the i - colour @xmath36 coupling .
@xmath147 @xmath148 to make the reading easy , the explicit form of @xmath149 coefficients can be found in references @xcite,@xcite .
once set the numerical values of parameters in the above expressions , the @xmath150 values from tables [ table:1 ] to [ table:14 ] ( appendix ) allow one to compute the decay widths of @xmath151 to @xmath137 quarks ( @xmath152 , [ @xmath153 if above the threshold ] ) , leptons ( @xmath154 ) , and other boson decays ( @xmath155 ) .
the results are shown in table [ table:16 ] for cpl and cpp ( with @xmath156 ) potential using @xmath157 and @xmath158 at the above considered scales . in all cases
the decay mode to @xmath137 quarks is the dominant channel .
decay to leptons shares roughly with a @xmath159 for electron , muon and @xmath160 pair respectively .
as we can see , for @xmath161 case if we take into account only the @xmath85 decay , the total width is quite narrow @xmath162kev , but we find similar values than in the heavy quarkonia case @xcite . for @xmath163 case
the total width increases roughly one order of magnitude .
nevertheless , if necessary , this analysis could be improved by adding upper @xmath117 levels contributions decays , which are proportional to @xmath130 . ] : for instance if we compute the whole @xmath117 contribution using the @xmath164 case , with a cpl potential we find a total width @xmath165 times the @xmath85 total width ; using cpp @xmath115 and @xmath109 potentials we find a factor @xmath166 and @xmath167 respectively .
+ concerning @xmath168-wave resonances ( @xmath169 ) , the corresponding widths satisfy @xmath170 so that , those contributions are suppressed with respect to the @xmath117 decays by a ( @xmath171 ) factor @xmath172 taking @xmath173 values in the cpl case from tables , we find @xmath174 $ ] in the @xmath175 case and @xmath176 $ ] for @xmath177 . regarding the dependence of the brs on the quirk mass ( @xmath131 are independent of the ratio @xmath130 , but @xmath70 enters also thorugh the functions @xmath178 ) : in the range of interest @xmath179 we find variations on the different @xmath131 less than a @xmath180 .
we can also check the @xmath131 variations with the i - colour number @xmath32 : by replacing for instance in the above expressions @xmath181 , the @xmath131 to bosons varies mainly @xmath182 and the corresponding @xmath131 to @xmath137 quarks @xmath183 ( @xmath131 to leptons @xmath184 respectively ) .
spectroscopy of exotic states might play a fundamental role in the discovery strategy of new physics at the lhc and ilc . in this paper
we have focused on a simple extension of the sm , when a new @xmath185 gauge group is added to the sm .
the new interaction and new associated fermions have been dubbed i - color , quirks respectively .
we assume that quirks are colorless , but otherwise carry sm quantum numbers , thereby coupling to gauge @xmath186 and @xmath187 bosons .
quirks can bind forming very peculiar structures reminding . in this work we have focused on neutral @xmath89 states called quirkonium , when the states are microscopic .
we have performed a prospective study of quirkonium spectroscopy by employing a coulomb plus linear and coulomb plus power law potentials as representative possibilities with parameters according to i - qcd requirements , as well as other effective contributions to analyze their impact .
taking into account the wide range where the @xmath89 bound state might be found , we have chosen the scale range , mev @xmath188 gev with different i - colour @xmath8 scales and quirk masses , finding sizes of several @xmath189 resonances and their squared wfo values of states ( or derivatives for @xmath169 ) .
we also extracted the level spacing among resonances using different @xmath8 scenarios to determine whether or not it would be possible to discriminate different state levels .
we also have computed total and partial decay widths .
i am grateful to miguel angel sanchis - lozano for calling my attention to quirkonium systems , to point out all the details concerning detection by means of the dimuon channel , and many discussions
. 1 m. j. strassler and k. m. zurek , phys .
b * 651 * , 374 ( 2007 ) .
[ arxiv : hep - ph/0604261 ] .
j. kang , m.a .
jhep * 0911*,065(2009).[arxiv:0805.4642[hep - ph ] ] .
k. cheung , w - y .
keung , t .- ch .
yuan nucl.phys.b * 811*,274 ( 2009).[arxiv:0810.1524v2[hep - ph ] ] .
time ago okun @xcite dubbed such new particles as @xmath4thetons in his pioneering study triggered by theoretical curiosity .
okun , nucl .
phys.b * 173*,1 ( 1980 ) .
juknevich , d. melnikov , m .
strassler , jhep 0907 ( 2009 ) 055 .
[ arxiv:0903.0883[hep - ph ] ] .
martin phys.rev .
d83 ( 2011 ) 035019 .
[ arxiv:1012.2072 [ hep - ph ] ] .
kribs , t.s .
roy , j. terning , k.m .
zurek phys.rev .
d81 ( 2010 ) 095001 [ arxiv:0909.2034 [ hep - ph ] ] .
g. burdman , z. chacko , h. s. goh , r. harnik and c. a. krenke , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 075028 [ arxiv:0805.4667 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. harnik , t. wizansky .
d80 ( 2009 ) 075015 , [ arxiv:0810.3948 hep - ph ] .
atlas collaboration , atlas : detector and physics performance technical design report .
vol.1,cern - lhcc-99 - 14 , atlas - tdr-14 .
cms collaboration , `` cms physics technical design report volume i : detector performance and software '' , cern - lhcc-2006 - 001 ; cms - tdr-008 - 1 .
d. flamm , f. schoberl , introduction to the quark model of elementary particles vol.1 , gordon and breach science publishers ( 1982 ) . c. quigg , j.l .
rosner phys.rept . 56 ( 1979 ) 167 .
eichten , c. quigg , phys.rev .
d49 ( 1994 ) 5845 [ hep - ph/9402210 ] .
donoghue , e. golowich , b.r .
holstein , dynamics of the standard model ( cambridge monographs on particle physics ) cambridge university press ( 1996 ) .
domenech - garret and m.a .
sanchis - lozano , comput .
. commun . * 180*,768 ( 2009 ) .
[ arxiv:0805.2704 [ hep - ph ] ] . according to @xcite and assuming @xmath190 ( as a qcd mirror ) , for the lowest state @xmath191 and @xmath192 v. barger , e.w.n .
glover , k. hikasa , w .- y .
keung , m.g .
olsson c.j .
suchyta iii and x.r .
tata , phys .
rev.d * 35 * , 3366 ( 1987 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 38*,1632(1988 ) ] .
eitchten , k. gotfried , t. kinoshita , k
. lane , t. yan , phys .
d * 21 * , 203 ( 1980 ) . c. amsler et al .
( particle data group ) , physics letters b**667 * * , 1 ( 2008 ) . comparative plot of the @xmath117 energy levels w.r.t .
the @xmath85 state , taken as the ground level , found with the cpl and cpp potentials ( @xmath119 respectively ) for different @xmath29 and @xmath8 values : m100 and m500 stands for the quirk mass value .
l , 10l denotes @xmath193 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=302 ] comparative plot of the @xmath117 energy levels w.r.t .
the @xmath85 state , taken as the ground level , found with the cpl and cpp potentials ( @xmath119 respectively ) for different @xmath29 and @xmath8 values : m100 and m500 stands for the quirk mass value .
l , 10l denotes @xmath193 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=302 ] values of @xmath194 ( in @xmath195 ) corresponding to the @xmath85 level vs. @xmath196 ( in @xmath195 ) using cpp potentials with @xmath197 ( labeled as cpp05 , cpp15 respectively ) .
l , 10l denote @xmath193 , respectively .
the curve corresponding to @xmath27 lies in between.,width=377 ]
.mass level spacings with respect to the ground state : @xmath198 ( mev ) , using a coulomb plus linear potential with @xmath73 gev ; @xmath199 mev ; @xmath200 ( in gev ) , and mean square radius ( in fm ) . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] | in addition to well - motivated scenarios like supersymmetric particles , the so - called exotic matter ( quirky matter , hidden valley models , etc . ) can show up at the lhc and ilc , by exploring the spectroscopy of high mass levels and decay rates . in this paper
we use qcd - inspired potential models , though without resorting to any particular one , to calculate level spacings of bound states and decay rates of the aforementioned exotic matter in order to design discovery strategies .
we mainly focus on quirky matter , but our conclusions can be extended to other similar scenarios . |
synoptic surveys for gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) , and subsequent ground - based observational follow - up at radio through optical wavelengths , has highlighted the importance of transient celestial phenomena ( masetti 2001 ) .
the new parameter space of the transient cosmos has been emphasized in the design of future telescopes , such as the optical large synoptic survey telescope ( tyson & angel 2001 ) , and the radio square kilometer array ( van haarlem 1999 ) .
while it is well documented that flat spectrum radio sources can be variable ( aller et al . 1985 ) , the areal density of such sources has not been well quantified through multi - epoch , wide field blind surveys . at high flux density levels ( @xmath8 mjy at 1.4 ghz )
, one can make a rough estimate of the areal density of variable radio sources by simply assuming that all flat spectrum sources are variable .
for instance , the areal density of all sources @xmath9mjy is @xmath10 arcmin@xmath2 , and the fraction of flat spectrum sources is about 10@xmath11 , implying an areal density of variable radio sources of @xmath12 arcmin@xmath2 ( gruppioni et al .
1999 ; white et al . 1997 ; windhorst et al .
1985 ; hopkins et al . 2000 , 2002 ) .
this number is consistent with the ( null ) results of frail et al .
( 1994 ) in their search for highly variable mjy - level sources associated with grbs .
source populations at these high flux densities are dominated by agn . below about 1 mjy
the slope of the source counts flattens , and star forming galaxies are thought to dominate the faint source population ( windhorst et al .
1985 ; georgakakis et al .
1999 ; hopkins et al . 2000 , 2002 ) .
hence , when considering the areal density of variable sub - mjy radio sources , one can not simply extrapolate the results from high flux density source samples to low flux densities .
knowledge of the areal density of variable sub - mjy radio sources is critical for setting the back - ground , or ` confusion ' , level for studies of faint variable source populations , such as grbs ( frail et al .
. a recent comparison of the nvss and first surveys by levinson et al .
( 2002 ) sets a conservative upper limit of @xmath13 arcmin@xmath2 to the areal density of ` orphan ' grb radio afterglows ( i.e. grbs for which the @xmath14-ray emission is not beamed toward us ) with s@xmath15 mjy .
they also argue that the areal density of radio supernovae will be considerably smaller . while the area of the sky covered by levinson et al .
( 2002 ) was much larger that the study presented herein , their flux density limit was higher than any grb radio afterglow yet recorded . in this paper
we present a smaller area study , but we consider variable sources at flux density levels ( @xmath16mjy ) applicable to typical grb radio afterglows . in general , variability of radio sources at the sub - mjy level is an essentially unexplored part of parameter space a part of parameter space which may fundamentally drive the design of future radio telescopes , such as the ska ( carilli et al .
herein we present the first study to delve into this part of parameter space , by exploring systematically the variability of the sub - mjy radio source population at 1.4 ghz .
we examine variability on timescales of 17 months and 19 days .
note that the lsst will probe similar variability timescales in the optical , with sampling on weekly to yearly timescales .
observations were made using the using the vla at 1.4 ghz in the b configuration ( maximum baseline = 10 km ) .
the region observed is in the lockman hole centered at : ( j2000 ) 10@xmath17 52@xmath18 56.00@xmath19 , 57@xmath20 29@xmath21 06.0@xmath22 .
table 1 summarizes the observations .
column 1 gives the observing date , column 2 gives the observed hour angle range , and column 3 gives the rms in the final image .
these observations are part of a larger multiwavelength program to study the evolution of dusty star forming galaxies ( bertoldi et al . in prep ) .
standard wide field imaging techniques were employed in order to generate an unaberrated image of the full primary beam of the vla ( fwhm = 32@xmath21 ) .
the absolute flux density scale was set using 3c286 .
we then generated a clean component model of the field using self - calibrated data taken on sept .
the data from all days were then self - calibrated in amplitude and phase without gain renormalization using this model .
this process should ensure that all the data are on the same flux scale .
images made before and after this process showed that the absolute flux scale changed by at most 1@xmath11 .
we also checked to see if variable sources could be removed ( or added ) due to using a single model to self - calibrate data from all the different days .
components at the 0.1 to 0.2 mjy level were added to the self - calibration model at random positions in the field , and the self - calibration process was repeated . in no case was a new source generated .
this gives us confidence that the self - calibration process is robust to small perturbations in the model , i.e. that the problem is over - constrained and that the input self - calibration model is dominated by non - varying sources .
images for each day were generated using the wide field imaging capabilities in the aips task imagr ( perley 1999 ) . to remove problems with `
beam squint ' ( slightly different pointing centers for right and left circular polarizations ) the right and left polarizations were imaged separately .
the images were then summed , weighted by the rms on each image .
the final image using data from all the observing days is shown in figure 1 .
the rms noise on this image is 7@xmath4jy beam@xmath23 and the restoring clean beam is circular with fwhm = 4.5@xmath22 .
we searched for source variations over 17 months by comparing images made in april 2001 with those made in august / september 2002 , and also on timescales of 19 days by comparing images made on august 17 and september 5 , 2002 .
we searched for variable sources out to the 10@xmath11 point of the primary beam , and we limited the analysis to sources with variations @xmath24 .
images from all epochs were convolved to 6@xmath22 resolution to mitigate differences that might occur due to the non - linear process of deconvolution .
the rms on the images used for variability analysis was 12.5 @xmath4jy for the 17 month comparison , and 17@xmath4jy for the 19 day comparison .
the images from different epochs were both subtracted and averaged .
a fractional variability image was then generated by dividing these two images , blanking at the 5@xmath25 level ( in absolute value ) .
for the 17 months variability analysis @xmath25 was 17@xmath4jy on the differenced image , and 9@xmath4jy on the averaged image .
the corresponding numbers for the 19 day analysis were 26@xmath4jy and 15@xmath4jy , respectively .
the difference image for the 17 month analysis is shown in figure 2 .
some artifacts are seen around the brighter extended sources arising from differences in deconvolution and residual calibration errors . beyond these artifacts ,
the difference images are remarkably free of sources .
this result gives us confidence that the imaging process ( self - calibration and deconvolution ) does not generate spurious sources at the @xmath26 level , and tells us right away that the radio sky is not highly variable at the 100@xmath4jy level .
variable sources were identified in the divided image .
five variable sources were found at the @xmath27 level in the 17 month comparison , while four sources were found in the 19 day analysis .
we then returned to the original images to find the flux densities of the sources at each epoch .
table 2 lists source positions ( columns 1 and 2 ) , flux densities at the two epochs ( columns 3 and 4 ) , and the distance from the phase center ( column 5 ) for the 17 month analysis , and table 3 lists the corresponding values for the 19 day analysis .
note that the source j1051 + 5734 was seen to vary on both timescales . in fact , this source varied between september 5 and september 9 from 1.53 mjy to 0.71 mjy .
the september 2002 value listed in table 2 is the weighted average of these two measurements .
we next consider the sensitivity of our observations to variable sources at some absolute level , @xmath28s .
the analysis is complicated by the roughly gaussian roll - off of the primary beam of the vla , with fwhm @xmath29 .
identification of variable sources was done using the non - primary beam corrected maps in order to have uniform noise across the field .
of course , the final flux densities and noise levels for the variable sources were corrected for the primary beam attenuation . given a @xmath28s
, one can calculate the maximum primary beam correction , f , for which a change in flux density @xmath28s could be detected at the 5@xmath25 level , where @xmath25 is the noise at the field center on the difference /@xmath28s .
the value of f then sets the distance from the pointing center , r , to which such variation could have been detected , given the primary beam shape of the vla .
values for @xmath28s , f , and r are listed in columns 1 , 2 , and 3 , respectively in table 4 .
column 4 lists the number of variable sources over 17 months that meet these criteria .
column 5 lists the number of sources within the specified radius with flux density , s @xmath30 @xmath28s/2 .
this flux density sets the limit for 100@xmath11 variability , e.g. a source could be 100@xmath4jy on day 1 , and 0 @xmath4jy on day 2 , leading to a value on the difference image of 100 @xmath4jy and a value on the average image of 50@xmath4jy .
column 6 lists the areal density of sources with s@xmath30@xmath28s/2 on our lockman hole image , while column 7 lists the corresponding values from the recent study of fomalont et al .
( 2002 ) comprised of a number of different fields .
we have investigated the source sizes using the b array observations at 4.5@xmath22 resolution .
two of the sources are partially resolved . for j1051 + 5708 gaussian fitting to the profile
yields a peak surface brightness , i@xmath31 mjy beam@xmath23 , a total flux density , s@xmath32 mjy , and a ( deconvolved ) size of @xmath33 , with major axis position angle ( pa ) = @xmath34 .
the corresponding numbers for j1055 + 5718 are : i@xmath35 mjy beam@xmath23 , s@xmath36 mjy , and @xmath37 at pa @xmath38 .
the rest of the sources are unresolved , with upper limits between 1@xmath22 and 2@xmath22 depending on signal - to - noise .
the nature of this analysis is such that we are not sensitive to very rapid variations , e.g. timescales of minutes or less .
for instance , a 50 mjy flare of 1 min duration would average down to about 100@xmath4jy over 7 hours . while our nominal sensitivity would be adequate to detect such an event ,
the existence of such a transient source in the visibility data would lead to errors in the self - calibration and imaging process which would manifest themselves clearly on the images .
of course , it is possible that such a bright , short timescale event was mis - identified as interference in the data editing process , and removed .
for the analysis on 17 month timescales we could have detected sources with @xmath28s @xmath0jy out to a radius of 7.8@xmath21 , but none were detected .
this sets an upper limit to the areal density of such sources of @xmath39 arcmin@xmath2 .
another interesting point is that within this radius there are 46 sources between 50 and 100 @xmath4jy on the averaged image .
hence , we set an upper limit of about 2@xmath11 to the fraction of sources in this flux density regime that are highly ( @xmath40 ) variable .
these results are grossly consistent with the idea that below 1 mjy at 1.4 ghz the radio source population is dominated by star forming galaxies , as compared to agn which dominate at high flux densities ( hopkins 2000 , 2002 ) .
the exact distribution of agn vs. starbursts vs. other source types as a function of radio flux density is not fully determined at this time , and is an area of active current research ( hopkins et al .
2002 ; georgakakis et al . 1999
; richards 2001 ; fomalont et al . 2002 ) . as a rough guide
we consider the models of hopkins et al .
they suggests that at @xmath30 10 mjy the source population is 90@xmath11 steep spectrum radio sources , 10@xmath11 flat spectrum radio sources , and @xmath41 star forming galaxies .
again , at high flux density levels the flat spectrum sources correspond to the variable radio source population . at 100 @xmath4jy
the models suggests that the proportions change to roughly 80@xmath11 star forming galaxies , 15@xmath11 steep spectrum agn , and 5@xmath11 flat spectrum agn .
these models have not considered truly transient source populations , such as grb radio afterglows , which have timescales of 10 s of days .
the statistics of radio afterglows of grbs are such that in an area of 7.8@xmath21 radius one would expect to see @xmath42 sources above 0.1 mjy at 1.4 ghz at any given time , assuming grbs are highly beamed ( see below ) .
hence , the fact that we did not see such a source is not surprising .
more importantly , the results presented herein allow us to set a limit on the variable source confusion level for grb radio afterglow searches , again at a flux density level relevant to the observed population .
for example , radio searches are needed for localizing an important subclass of afterglows known as ` dark grbs ' ( e.g. , djorgovski et al .
2001 ) , for which optical emission from the grb is not detected .
it has been suggested that the absence of optical emission from these sources is the result of either dust obscuration , or the gunn - peterson effect , i.e. ly@xmath43 absorption by the neutral intergalactic medium .
this latter effect would place the sources at @xmath44 ( fan et al .
an upper limit to the areal density of @xmath39 arcmin@xmath2 for variable sources at the 100@xmath4jy level implies a lower limit of 200 arcmin@xmath45 to the area that can be safely searched at 1.4 ghz before one such source is expected to be detected by chance . for comparison ,
the typical grb error circle is @xmath4630 arcmin@xmath45 , but larger error circles are not uncommon .
this result can also be used to derive a rough limit on the mean beaming angle for grbs ( perna & loeb 1998 ) . from a sample of 25 radio afterglows ( frail et al . in prep ) we estimate that 10 - 25% will be visible above the 100 @xmath4jy level at 1.4 ghz , with an average lifetime of one month .
the grb event rate is approximately 600 per year ( fishman & meegan 1995 ) so we expect to find only @xmath47 arcmin@xmath2 .
however , if grbs are highly beamed , as recent studies seem to suggest ( frail et al . 2001 ) , then our upper limit to areal density of @xmath39 arcmin@xmath2 implies a beaming factor @xmath48 , or a mean jet opening angle @xmath49 .
this value is not very constraining compared to existing limits , but to our knowledge this is the first time a survey for variability has been done at the appropriate flux level for radio afterglows .
more stringent limits will require sensitive , larger area surveys with existing or planned instruments ( totani & panaitescu 2002 ) .
a final point we consider is cosmic variance .
it is possible that the lockman hole region we have sampled was just statistically - poor in transient sources .
a rough indication of the effect of cosmic variance comes from the overall source counts ( columns 6,7 in table 4 ) .
the source counts we derive agree to within 20@xmath11 with those found by fomalont et al .
( 2002 ) in other areas of the sky .
in general , it has been found that for 30@xmath21 fields - of - view the maximum field - to - field scatter in the sub - mjy source counts is about a factor two ( fomalont et al .
we consider this an upper limit to the effect cosmic variance has on the areal density of variable source presented herein .
the national radio astronomy observatory ( nrao ) is operated by associated universities , inc . under a cooperative agreement with the national science foundation .
we thank f. owen , e. fomalont , r. becker , and j. condon for useful comments concerning this work , and the referee for careful and insightful criticism .
hopkins , a.m. , afonso , j.m . , chan , b. , cram , l.e . ,
georgakakis , a. , mobasher , b. 2002 , in `` galaxy evolution : theory and observations '' , eds .
v. avila - reese , c. firmani , c. frenk , & c. allen , revmexaa sc .
tyson , a. & angel , r. 2001 , in ` the new era of wide field astronomy , asp conference series , vol . 232 , ' eds . roger clowes , andrew adamson , and gordon bromage , ( san francisco : astronomical society of the pacific ) , p.347 | we present 1.4 ghz vla observations of the variability of radio sources in the lockman hole region at the level of @xmath0jy on timescales of 17 months and 19 days .
these data indicate that the areal density of highly variable sources at this level is @xmath1 arcmin@xmath2 .
we set an upper limit of @xmath3 to the fraction of 50 to 100@xmath4jy sources that are highly variable ( @xmath5 ) .
these results imply a lower limit to the beaming angle for grbs of 1@xmath6 , and give a lower limit of 200 arcmin@xmath7 to the area that can be safely searched for grb radio afterglows before confusion might become an issue . |
in this paper , we consider numerical methods for the computation of the @xmath0-gradient flow of a planar curve : @xmath1 where @xmath2 is a time - dependent planar curve .
the gradient flow is energy dissipative , since @xmath3 = - \int |\operatorname{grad}e({\mathbf{u}})|^2 ds \le 0.\ ] ] here , @xmath4 is an energy functional , and @xmath5 is the frchet derivative with respect to the @xmath0-structure with line integral @xmath6 .
thus , the curvature flow ( the curve shortening flow ) @xmath7 and the elastic flow ( the willmore flow ) @xmath8 have energy functionals @xmath9 = \int ds , \quad \text{and } \quad e[{\mathbf{u } } ] = \varepsilon^2 \int |{\bm{\upkappa}}|^2 ds + \int ds,\ ] ] where @xmath10 is the curvature vector , and @xmath11 is the tangential derivative ( example [ ex : gf ] ) .
note that the elastic flow is a fourth - order nonlinear evolution equation .
we consider a dissipative numerical scheme for , that is , a scheme which has the discrete energy dissipative property @xmath12 \le e[{\mathbf{u}}_h^n]$ ] at each time step . in general , a numerical method that retains a certain property for a target equation is called structure - preserving .
it is known that the numerical solutions obtained by these methods are not only physically realistic but also have the advantage of numerical stability ( cf .
in particular , structure - preserving methods are suitable for computations over long time intervals . here ,
we consider in more detail the energy dissipation for the gradient flow . as is well known , the ( classical ) solution of the curvature flow blows up in finite time .
in particular , if the initial curve is self - crossing , a cusp appears . on the other hand , the elastic flow , which is a regularized version of , has a unique global solution @xcite .
moreover , as @xmath13 , the solution of converges to that of under conditions when the classical solution of ( see @xcite ) exists . note that the elastic flow formally degenerates to the curvature flow as @xmath13 .
let @xmath14 be the time at which a cusp appears .
then , we are interested in determining the limit of the elastic flow as @xmath13 after time @xmath14 . therefore , the structure - preserving method is effective for investigating numerically the long - time behavior of the elastic flow with self - crossing initial curves .
there are many works that consider the numerical computation of equations and ( for example , @xcite ) .
however , none of them explicitly consider the discrete energy dissipation property .
although some numerical examples in these works seem to be dissipative , no mathematical proofs are given .
moreover , all of them use the p1-finite element method , which approximates solutions using polygonal curves . therefore , since they can not handle higher order derivatives directly , it is necessary to consider the mixed formulation for fourth - order equations .
it is remarkable that these studies present numerical schemes for individual problems , and do not give a general framework for approximating gradient flows .
there is a further issue regarding the arrangement of nodal points , when a curve evolution equation is discretized with polygonal curves .
however , we do not consider this issue in detail in this paper .
for gradient flows of graphs , there are some general frameworks to construct dissipative numerical schemes . in @xcite , a structure - preserving finite difference scheme , the so - called discrete variational derivative method ,
is proposed to approximate the solution of the equation @xmath15 over an interval in @xmath16 . here , @xmath17 is the frchet derivative of the energy functional @xmath4 with respect to the usual @xmath0-structure , i.e. , the @xmath0 space with respect to the lebesgue measure .
finite element schemes , called discrete partial derivative methods ( dpdm ) , for the same problems are presented in @xcite .
the main idea of these studies is to discretize the chain rule . in @xcite ,
discrete partial derivatives are introduced and a discretization of the chain rule is obtained .
a similar approach is used in our scheme .
see also @xcite for local discontinuous galerkin schemes for the above problems .
in the present paper , we apply the idea of dpdm to the discretization of the time variable .
we obtain the discrete chain rule formula with respect to the @xmath18-structure .
in contrast to problems such as , our problem is accompanied by the line element @xmath6 , which increases the complexity of the problem . due to the inclusion of the line element
, we can not use the dpdm for .
therefore , we will present a generalization of the dpdm and derive a new scheme for weak forms of general gradient flows ( scheme [ scheme : semi - disc ] ) . for the approximation of curves , we use b - spline curves ( cf .
@xcite ) . the b - spline approach ( also called nurbs in general )
is widely used to compute the solution to large - scale deformation problems , such as fluid - structure interaction ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
this method is called isogeometric analysis @xcite .
it is worth emphasizing that a b - spline curve of degree @xmath19 ( definition [ def : b - spline ] ) is a @xmath20 curve .
hence we can directly address higher order derivatives , and we can derive the fully discretized scheme by the galerkin method ( scheme [ scheme : full - disc ] ) . this procedure is independent of the properties of the energy functional , and thus , our scheme gives a general framework for the approximation of gradient flows .
we can also obtain the discrete energy dissipation with our scheme ( lemma [ lem : dissipation ] ) . in this study
, we do not consider solvability or error estimates .
this paper is structured as follows . in section
[ section : preliminary ] , we present some necessary definitions and notation for gradient flows on planar curves ( subsection [ subsec : gf ] ) , and then illustrate the use of the dpdm ( subsection [ subsec : dpdm ] ) and formally define b - spline curves ( subsection [ subsec : bspline ] ) . in section [ section :
scheme ] , we derive our energy dissipative scheme ( scheme [ scheme : full - disc ] ) under the framework of the dpdm , and introduce the discrete energy dissipation property ( lemma [ lem : dissipation ] ) .
finally , we present some numerical examples of our scheme in section [ section : num_exp ] , and compute the elastic flow . a topology - changing solution and more complicated evolution
are reported , which have not previously been shown in the literature .
videos illustrating our method are available on youtube .
in this subsection , we summarize the basic properties of the geometric gradient flows of planar curves .
let @xmath21 and @xmath22 for @xmath23 , @xmath24 . here
, the space @xmath25 is the @xmath26-th order sobolev space of @xmath0-type .
note that the space @xmath27 is embedded into the space of the planar closed @xmath28-curves .
we define an energy functional @xmath29 as @xmath9 = \int f({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{u } } ' , \dots , { \mathbf{u}}^{(m ) } ) ds , \quad { \mathbf{u}}\in { \mathbf{h}}^m_\pi , \label{eq : eng}\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the energy density function , and @xmath31 is the line element of the curve @xmath2 .
let @xmath5 be the frchet derivative of the functional @xmath4 in the topology of @xmath18 .
that is , @xmath32 then , the gradient flow for @xmath4 is represented by the following evolution equation : @xmath33 examples of the gradient flow are now considered .
[ ex : gf ] 1 .
( curvature flow ) if @xmath34 = \int ds$ ] , then equation is the curvature flow @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the curvature vector , and @xmath37 is the arc - length parameter .
2 . ( elastic flow ) if @xmath34 = \varepsilon^2 \int |{\bm{\upkappa}}|^2 ds + \int ds$ ] , then equation is the elastic flow ( or willmore flow ) @xmath38 where @xmath39 , and @xmath40 . in this paper
, we focus on the energy dissipation property , which is given as follows : @xmath3 = \int \operatorname{grad}e({\mathbf{u } } ) \cdot { \mathbf{u}}_t ds = - \int |\operatorname{grad}e({\mathbf{u}})|^2 ds \le 0.\ ] ] in this subsection , we introduce the dpdm , which was first presented in @xcite .
let @xmath41 be an energy functional that is defined as @xmath42 = \int_0 ^ 1 g(u_\zeta , u_{\zeta\zeta } ) d\zeta , \quad u = u(\zeta ) \in h^2_\pi(0,1 ) , \label{eq : eng - graph}\ ] ] where @xmath43 is the energy density function .
although we can consider more general energy functionals and density functions , we consider energy functionals @xmath4 such as for simplicity .
let us denote the first variation of @xmath4 by @xmath44 , i.e. , @xmath45 the @xmath0-gradient flow for the energy @xmath4 is the evolution equation @xmath46 this equation also has the energy dissipation property as in . indeed , @xmath47
= \int_0 ^ 1 \frac{\delta e}{\delta u } u_t d\zeta = - \int_0 ^ 1 \left| \frac{\delta e}{\delta u } \right|^2 d\zeta \le 0.\ ] ] dpdm is an energy dissipative numerical scheme for the case of equation . in dpdm ,
the discrete partial derivatives @xmath48 and the others are defined as the functions that satisfy the following relation : @xmath49 for all @xmath50 . note that the partial derivatives which solve this relation may not be unique .
when @xmath51 is written in a certain form , a method for deriving the partial derivatives is given in @xcite .
next , we define the discrete analogue of the first variation as @xmath52 note that this function satisfies the relation @xmath42 - e[v ] = \int_0 ^ 1 \frac{\delta e_{\mathrm{d}}}{\delta(u , v ) } ( u - v ) d\zeta .
\label{eq : disc - chain - graph}\ ] ] therefore , we can derive the discretized equation @xmath53 following @xcite , we can derive an energy dissipative time - discretization for as follows .
the following scheme is the weak form of equation .
let @xmath54 and @xmath55 be given .
find @xmath56 that satisfies @xmath57 for all @xmath58 .
we can now check the discrete energy dissipation property with the following lemma . here
we give the proof for comparison with our scheme ( see lemma [ lem : dissipation ] ) .
let @xmath59 and @xmath60 satisfy the relation .
then , we have @xmath61 - e[u^n]}{\delta t } = - \left\| \frac{u^{n+1 } - u^n}{\delta t } \right\|_{l^2(0,1)}^2 \le 0\ ] ] for all @xmath54 and @xmath62 .
let us write @xmath63 then , substituting @xmath64 into the weak form , , we can derive @xmath65 - e[u^n]}{\delta t } & = \int_0 ^ 1 \frac{g(u^{n+1}_\zeta , u^{n+1}_{\zeta\zeta } ) - g(u^{n}_\zeta , u^{n}_{\zeta\zeta})}{\delta t } d\zeta \\ & = \left ( \frac{\partial g_{\mathrm{d}}}{\partial(u^{n+1}_\zeta , u^n_\zeta ) } , \partial_{\mathrm{d}}u^n_\zeta \right ) + \left ( \frac{\partial g_{\mathrm{d}}}{\partial(u^{n+1}_{\zeta\zeta},u^n_{\zeta\zeta } ) } , \partial_{\mathrm{d}}u^n_{\zeta\zeta } \right ) \\ & = - \|\partial_{\mathrm{d}}u^n\|_{l^2(0,1)}^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the key point is substituting @xmath64 into .
therefore , this proof can be derived also in the case of the galerkin method . in our scheme ,
we use b - spline curves to discretize the solution curves .
we say that a set of points @xmath66 is a _ knot vector _ if @xmath67 for all @xmath68 .
let @xmath69 , @xmath54 , and @xmath70 be a knot vector . 1 .
the _ @xmath68-th b - spline basis function of degree @xmath19 _ with respect to @xmath71 is a piecewise polynomial function @xmath72 that is generated by the following formula : @xmath73 for @xmath74 and @xmath75 , where @xmath76 is the characteristic function of @xmath77 . here , if @xmath78 ( resp .
@xmath79 ) , then the term @xmath80 ( resp .
@xmath81 ) is null . 2 .
a curve @xmath82 \to { \mathbb{r}}^2 $ ] is a _ b - spline curve of degree @xmath19 _ if @xmath2 is represented by @xmath83,\ ] ] for some knot vector @xmath71 and @xmath54 .
the coefficient @xmath84 is called a _
control point_. in fact , if the knot vector is disjoint ( i.e. , @xmath85 ) , then it is known that @xmath72 is a @xmath20-function . for more details on the properties of b - spline functions ,
we refer the reader to @xcite . in the present paper ,
we only consider the periodic b - spline functions and curves .
let @xmath86 \subset { \mathbb{r}}$ ] be an interval , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath89 .
we define a knot vector @xmath71 as @xmath90 and let @xmath72 be the corresponding b - spline basis function .
note that @xmath91 $ ] . then , if @xmath92 , we can see that @xmath93 for @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
therefore , the function @xmath96 , \\
n^\xi_{p , i+n}(\zeta ) , & \zeta \in [ \xi_{i+n},b ] , \\ 0 , & \text{otherwise } \end{cases } \quad i=1,2,\dots , p \label{eq : periodic - b - spline}\ ] ] is a periodic @xmath20-function in @xmath86 $ ] .
the restriction @xmath97}$ ] for @xmath98 is also @xmath20-periodic on @xmath86 $ ] .
then , we define a closed b - spline curve as follows .
[ def : b - spline ]
let @xmath86 \subset { \mathbb{r}}$ ] be an interval , @xmath87 , @xmath88 with @xmath99 , and @xmath89 .
then , we define a _ periodic b - spline basis function of degree p _ @xmath100 by for @xmath101 and by @xmath102}$ ] for @xmath103 , where @xmath71 is a knot vector defined by .
we also define a _ closed b - spline curve _ as a curve @xmath82 \to { \mathbb{r}}^2 $ ] expressed by @xmath104,\ ] ] for some @xmath105 .
it is clear that a closed b - spline curve is a @xmath20-curve .
in this section , we derive a numerical scheme for geometric gradient flows for the energy functional @xmath4 given by .
we first consider the time discretization , and recall the idea of the dpdm . using a similar approach as for the dpdm , we derive a discretization of the chain rule .
the definition of the partial derivatives is a discrete analogue of the chain rule formula @xmath106 for a smooth function @xmath107 . in our case
, the corresponding chain rule can be expressed as @xmath3 = \int \operatorname{grad}e({\mathbf{u } } ) \cdot { \mathbf{u}}_t ds({\mathbf{u } } ) .
\label{eq : chain}\ ] ] here , we denote the line element of @xmath2 by @xmath108 to emphasize the dependence on @xmath2 .
now , we discretize the chain rule .
we first change the time derivatives to time differences by expressing @xmath109 $ ] and @xmath110 as @xmath34 - e[{\mathbf{v}}]$ ] and @xmath111 , respectively .
moreover , the line element @xmath108 should be changed appropriately . in the original formula ,
there is one function @xmath2 only .
however , in the discretization , there are two functions @xmath2 and @xmath112 as in .
therefore , we have some choices to discretize the term @xmath108 , for example , @xmath108 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 . here
, we use @xmath114 .
then , we define a discrete gradient , @xmath115 , with a function that satisfies the following formula : @xmath9 - e[{\mathbf{v } } ] = \int \operatorname{grad}_{\mathrm{d}}e({\mathbf{u } } , { \mathbf{v } } ) ds\left ( \frac{{\mathbf{u}}+{\mathbf{v}}}{2 } \right ) , \quad \forall { \mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{v}}\in { \mathbf{h}}^m_\pi .
\label{eq : disc - chain}\ ] ] thus , according to , the strong form of the time - discrete problem is written as follows : @xmath116 the discrete chain rule can then be expressed as @xmath9 - e[{\mathbf{v } } ] = \int_0 ^ 1 \left| \frac{{\mathbf{u}}_\zeta+{\mathbf{v}}_\zeta}{2 } \right| \operatorname{grad}_{\mathrm{d}}e({\mathbf{u } } , { \mathbf{v } } ) \cdot ( { \mathbf{u}}- { \mathbf{v } } ) d\zeta , \quad \forall { \mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{v}}\in { \mathbf{h}}^m_\pi , \label{eq : disc - chain2}\ ] ] and comparing with , we can derive the relationship between @xmath117 and the discrete first derivative @xmath118 as follows .
@xmath119 here @xmath118 is a vector - valued function . letting @xmath120 ,
the energy @xmath4 is expressed by @xmath9 = \int_0 ^ 1 g({\mathbf{u } } , { \mathbf{u}}_\zeta , \dots , \partial_\zeta^m { \mathbf{u } } ) d\zeta,\ ] ] and thus the discrete first derivative is given by @xmath121 here , we define the ( vector - valued ) partial derivatives , @xmath122 as functions that satisfy the relation @xmath123 for all @xmath124 .
note that , as in the previous case ( subsection [ subsec : dpdm ] ) , the partial derivative may not be unique .
now , instead of solving , we may solve the equation @xmath125 and the weak form of gives our semi - discrete scheme for the gradient flow .
note that the time increment @xmath126 can differ at each step .
[ scheme : semi - disc ] find @xmath127 that satisfies @xmath128 for given @xmath129 .
we now consider the full discretization of the gradient flow .
let @xmath130 be the space of closed b - spline curves of degree @xmath19 as defined in definition [ def : b - spline ]
. then , by the sobolev embedding theorem , @xmath131 if @xmath132 .
thus , we can derive a fully discretized problem by the galerkin method .
[ scheme : full - disc ] let @xmath88 , @xmath89 , and @xmath132 .
assume @xmath133 is given .
find @xmath134 that satisfies @xmath135 for all @xmath136 .
then , we can establish the discrete energy dissipation property .
[ lem : dissipation ] let @xmath137 and @xmath138 satisfy the relation .
then , we have @xmath139 - e[{\mathbf{u}}_h^n]}{\delta t_n } = - \int_0 ^ 1 \left| \frac{{\mathbf{u}}^{n+1}_{h,\zeta } + { \mathbf{u}}^n_{h,\zeta}}{2 } \right| \left| \frac{{\mathbf{u}}_h^{n+1 } - { \mathbf{u}}_h^n}{\delta t_n } \right|^2 d\zeta \le 0.\ ] ] substituting @xmath140 into the scheme , we have @xmath141 - e[{\mathbf{u}}_h^n]}{\delta t_n},\end{aligned}\ ] ] by the definition of the partial derivatives .
hence we can establish the desired assertion .
in this section , we show some numerical examples of the elastic flow computed by our scheme . here , the functional is the elastic energy @xmath9 = \varepsilon^2 \int |{\bm{\upkappa}}|^2 ds + \int ds = \int_0 ^ 1 \left ( \varepsilon^2 \frac{\det({\mathbf{u}}_\zeta,{\mathbf{u}}_{\zeta\zeta})^2}{|{\mathbf{u}}_\zeta|^5 } + |{\mathbf{u}}_\zeta| \right ) d\zeta , \label{eq : elastic - energy}\ ] ] where @xmath142 it is known that equation has a unique time - global solution ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.2 ) ) .
therefore , the turning number @xmath143 is invariant . to calculate the discrete partial derivatives for @xmath4 ,
let @xmath144 for @xmath145 .
then , the energy density function for @xmath4 is @xmath146 . we can compute the partial derivatives of @xmath147 since @xmath148 which implies @xmath149 we can derive the partial derivatives of @xmath150 in several ways . in the following examples ,
these derivatives are computed by dividing @xmath151 as follows : @xmath152 the first and the second terms of the right - hand side are calculated as @xmath153 \\ & \times \big[v_{2,\zeta\zeta}(u_{1,\zeta}-v_{1,\zeta } ) - v_{1,\zeta\zeta}(u_{2,\zeta}-v_{2,\zeta } ) \\ & - u_{2,\zeta}(u_{1,\zeta\zeta}-v_{1,\zeta\zeta } ) + u_{1,\zeta}(u_{2,\zeta\zeta}-v_{2,\zeta\zeta } ) \big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath154 respectively .
although we have omitted them , we can derive partial derivatives of @xmath150 with these equations . before showing numerical examples
, we recall the steady - state solutions for the elastic flow .
it is known that steady closed curves of the elastic energy are circles of radius @xmath155 , the figure - eight - shaped curve with scale @xmath155 , and their multiple versions @xcite ( see figure [ fig : steady ] ) .
their energies are @xmath156 = 4 \pi \varepsilon , \quad e[\text{eight - shaped } ] \approx \varepsilon \cdot 21.2075,\ ] ] respectively .
the exact value of the latter energy is expressed by the elliptic integrals ( cf .
@xcite ) . in our numerical examples , we set the time increment as @xmath157 and @xmath158 - e[{\mathbf{u}}_h^{n-1}]}{\delta t_{n-1 } } \right)^{-2 } \right\ } , \quad n \ge 1.\ ] ] we found these values empirically .
we solved equation at each step with the newton method .
moreover , in each step , when two adjacent control points are too close ( more precisely , when the distance is less than @xmath159 ) , one of them was removed .
note that the energy may increase when control points are eliminated ; however , the shape of the curve will be less affected ( see figure [ fig : elim ] ) . with respect to the control points as shown in the upper figure .
the right two figures show the b - spline curves of the same degree with respect to the control points except for the point @xmath160 . ]
we show six examples here . in all examples
, we use the b - spline curves of degree @xmath161 .
therefore , every curve below is of class @xmath162 . videos of the following examples are available on youtube .
[ ex : circle_0 ] the first example is shown in figure [ fig : circle_0 ] .
the initial curve is a circle.the parameters are @xmath163 in this example , the elimination of control points was not necessary .
figure [ fig : circle_0-curve ] shows the evolution of the curve at @xmath164 .
the energy at @xmath165 is @xmath166 .
note that the exact value of the energy at the steady state is @xmath167 .
figure [ fig : circle_0-energy ] shows the evolution of the energy .
the discrete energy dissipation property is clearly visible . in figure [ fig :
circle_0-curve ] , one can observe that the curve shrinks as the curvature flow until @xmath168 , and it stops shrinking when the radius approaches @xmath155 .
.45 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] [ ex : eight_0 ] the second example is shown in figure [ fig : eight_0 ] .
the initial curve is figure - eight - shaped .
the parameters are @xmath169 as in the previous case , the elimination of control points is not necessary .
figure [ fig : eight_0-curve ] shows the evolution of the curve at @xmath170 and figure [ fig : eight_0-energy ] shows the evolution of the energy .
the energy at @xmath171 is @xmath172 .
note that the exact value of the energy at the steady state is approximately @xmath173 . in figure
[ fig : eight_0-curve ] , first the small loop ( the right loop ) shrinks faster than the larger one .
when the scale of the right loop becomes @xmath155 , shrinking stops , and the left one begins to shrink .
finally , the left one also stops shrinking , and the curve approaches the steady state .
.45 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] [ ex : double_0 ] the third example is shown in figure [ fig : double_0-curve ] .
the initial shape of the curve is a cardioid - like curve as shown in figure [ fig : double_0 - 1 ] .
the initial parameters of the curve are @xmath174 as in the previous cases , the elimination of control points is not necessary .
figure [ fig : double_0-curve ] shows the evolution of the curve at @xmath175 and figure [ fig : double_0-energy ] shows the evolution of the energy . in this case , the steady - state is a double - looped circle with radius @xmath176 .
therefore , the energy of the solution at @xmath165 ( @xmath177 ) is approximately twice the value of that of example [ ex : circle_0 ] .
the behavior of the curve is similar to example [ ex : eight_0 ] .
that is , first the smaller loop shrinks until the scale is approximately @xmath155 .
then , the larger one shrinks and the curve approaches the steady state .
.49 .,title="fig : " ] .49 .,title="fig : " ] + .49 .,title="fig : " ] .49 .,title="fig : " ] . ]
[ ex : circle_1 ] this example shows a topology - changing solution .
the initial curve is the one shown in figure [ fig : circle_1 - 1 ] , and figure [ fig : circle_1-curve ] shows its evolution .
figures [ fig : circle_1-energy ] and show the evolution of the energy and the number of control points , respectively .
the parameters are @xmath178 one can observe that the topology of the curve changes at around @xmath179 ( figures [ fig : circle_1 - 5 ] and ) . at the same time , the energy decreases drastically ( figure [ fig : circle_1-energy ] ) , and some control points become concentrated ( figure [ fig : circle_1-elim ] ) .
as mentioned earlier , we implement an algorithm that deletes a control point if it is too close to the adjacent point .
therefore , the elimination of control points occurs when the topology changes , and the number of control points finally converges to @xmath180 .
.32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] + .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] + .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] + .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] .32 at the times described as in the figures .
the small circles represent control points , @xmath181 is the number of control points , and the gray colored curve is the solution.,title="fig : " ] [ ex : eight_1 ] the following two examples investigate problems with more complicated solutions .
the initial shape of the curve is shown in figure [ fig : eight_1 - 1 ] , and figure [ fig : eight_1-curve ] shows its evolution .
figures [ fig : eight_1-energy ] and show the evolution of the energy and the number of control points , respectively .
the parameters are @xmath182 in this example , the topology of the curve changes frequently .
for example , the loop in the upper left of the curve disappears at around @xmath183 .
when the topology changes , the energy decreases rapidly as in example [ ex : circle_1 ] , and the number of control points also decreases at the same time . the final value of @xmath181 is @xmath184 .
.32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] + .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] [ ex : circle_3 ] the initial curve for the final example is shown in figure [ fig : circle_3 - 1 ] , and figure [ fig : circle_3-curve ] shows its evolution .
figures [ fig : circle_3-energy ] and show the evolution of the energy and the number of control points , respectively .
the parameters are @xmath185 the solution displays complicated behavior as in example [ ex : eight_1 ] , and the topology changes frequently . however , since the turning number of the initial curve is one , the steady state is a circle with radius @xmath155 .
the energy and the number of control points decrease drastically when the topology changes , and the final number of control points is @xmath186 .
.32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] + .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .32 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ] .45 .,title="fig : " ]
i would like to thank prof .
yoshihiro tonegawa and dr .
takahito kashiwabara for bringing this topic to my attention and encouraging me through valuable discussions .
this work was supported by the program for leading graduate schools , mext , japan , and by jsps kakenhi ( no .
15j07471 ) . | in this paper , we develop an energy dissipative numerical scheme for gradient flows of planar curves , such as the curvature flow and the elastic flow .
our study presents a general framework for solving such equations . to discretize time
, we use a similar approach to the discrete partial derivative method , which is a structure - preserving method for the gradient flows of graphs . for the approximation of curves , we use b - spline curves . owing to the smoothness of b - spline functions ,
we can directly address higher order derivatives . in the last part of the paper , we consider some numerical examples of the elastic flow , which exhibit topology - changing solutions and more complicated evolution .
videos illustrating our method are available on youtube . |
the origin and nature of quark and lepton masses and mixings remains one of the most intriguing questions left unanswered by the standard model ( sm ) of particle physics . within the sm , quark and lepton masses and mixings arise from yukawa couplings which are essentially free and undetermined . in extensions such as grand unified theories ( guts ) ,
the yukawa couplings within a particular family may be related , but the mass hierarchy between different families is not explained and supersymmetry ( susy ) does not shed any light on this question either .
indeed , in the sm or guts , with or without susy , a specific structure of the yukawa matrices has no intrinsic meaning due to basis transformations in flavour space .
for example , one can always work in a basis in which , say , the up quark mass matrix is taken to be diagonal with the quark sector mixing arising entirely from the down quark mass matrix , or _ vice versa _ , and analogously in the lepton sector ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
this is symptomatic of the fact that neither the sm or guts are candidates for a theory of flavour .
the situation changes somewhat once these theories are extended to include a family symmetry spontaneously broken by extra higgs fields called flavons .
this approach has recently received a massive impetus due to the discovery of neutrino mass and approximately tri - bimaximal lepton mixing @xcite whose simple pattern strongly suggests some kind of a non - abelian discrete family symmetry might be at work , at least in the lepton sector , and , assuming a gut - type of structure relating quarks and leptons at a certain high energy scale , within the quark sector too .
the observed neutrino flavour symmetry may arise either directly or indirectly from a range of discrete symmetry groups @xcite .
examples of the direct approach , in which one or more generators of the discrete family symmetry appears in the neutrino flavour group , are typically based on @xmath3 @xcite or a related group such as @xmath4 @xcite or @xmath5 @xcite .
models of the indirect kind , in which the neutrino flavour symmetry arises accidentally , include also @xmath6 @xcite as well as @xmath7 @xcite and the continuous flavour symmetries like , e.g. , @xmath8 @xcite or @xmath9 @xcite which accommodate the discrete groups above as subgroups @xcite .
theories of flavour based on a spontaneously broken family symmetry are constructed in a particular basis in which the vacuum alignment of the flavons is particularly simple .
this then defines a preferred basis for that particular model , which we shall refer to as the `` flavour basis . '' in such frameworks , the resulting low energy effective yukawa matrices are expected to have a correspondingly simple form in the flavour basis associated with the high energy simple flavon vacuum alignment .
this suggests that it may be useful to look for simple yukawa matrix structures in a particular basis , since such patterns may provide a bottom - up route towards a theory of flavour based on a spontaneously broken family symmetry .
unfortunately , experiment does not tell us directly the structure of the yukawa matrices , and the complexity of the problem , in particular , the basis ambiguity from the bottom - up perspective , generally hinders the prospects of deducing even the basic features of the underlying flavour theory from the experimental data .
we are left with little alternative but to follow an _ ad hoc _ approach pioneered some time ago by fritzsch @xcite and currently represented by the myriads of proposed effective yukawa textures ( see e.g. @xcite ) whose starting assumption is that ( in some basis ) the yukawa matrices exhibit certain nice features such as symmetries or zeros in specific elements which have become known as `` texture zeros . '' for example , in his classic paper , fritzsch pioneered the idea of having six texture zeros in the 1 - 1 , 2 - 2 , 1 - 3 entries of the hermitian up and down quark yukawa ( or mass ) matrices @xcite .
unfortunately , these six - zero textures are no longer consistent with experiment , since they imply the bad prediction @xmath10 , so texture zerologists have been forced to retreat to the ( at most ) four - zero schemes discussed , for example , in @xcite which give up on the 2 - 2 texture zeros allowing the good prediction @xmath11 .
however , four - zero textures featuring zeros in the 1 - 1 and 1 - 3 entries of both up and down hermitian mass matrices may also lead to the bad prediction @xmath12 unless @xmath13 results from the cancellation of quite sizeable up- and down - type quark 2 - 3 mixing angles , leading to non - negligible induced 1 - 3 up- and down - type quark mixing @xcite .
another possibility is to give up on the 1 - 3 texture zeros , as well as the 2 - 2 texture zeros , retaining only two texture zeros in the 1 - 1 entries of the up and down quark matrices @xcite .
here we reject both of these options , and instead choose to maintain up to four texture zeros , without invoking cancellations , for example by making the 1 - 1 element of the up ( but not down ) quark mass matrix nonzero , while retaining 1 - 3 texture zeros in both the up and down quark hermitian matrices , as suggested in @xcite .
in this paper we discuss phenomenologically viable textures for hierarchical quark mass matrices which have both 1 - 3 texture zeros and negligible 1 - 3 mixing in both the up and down quark mass matrices .
such textures clearly differ from the textures discussed in @xcite and @xcite , but include some cases discussed in @xcite , as remarked above .
our main contribution in this paper is to derive quark mixing sum rules applicable to textures of this type , in which @xmath0 is generated from @xmath1 as a result of 1 - 2 up - type mixing , in direct analogy to the lepton sum rules derived in @xcite .
another important result of our study is to use the sum rules to show how the right - angled unitarity triangle , i.e. , @xmath2 , can be accounted for by a remarkably simple scheme involving real mass matrices apart from a single element of either the up or down quark mass matrix being purely imaginary .
fritzsch and xing have previously emphasized how their four - zero scheme with 1 - 1 and 1 - 3 texture zeros in the hermitian up and down mass matrices can be used to accommodate right unitarity triangles @xcite , but since their scheme involves large 2 - 3 and non - negligible 1 - 3 up and down quark mixing , our sum rules are not applicable to their case . therefore , the textures in refs .
@xcite and @xcite do not allow us to explain @xmath2 by simple structures with a combination of purely real and purely imaginary matrix elements .
recently , it has become increasingly clear that current data is indeed consistent with the hypothesis of a right unitarity triangle , with the best fits giving @xmath14 @xcite , and this provides additional impetus for our scheme . the phenomenological observation that @xmath15 has also motivated other approaches ( see e.g. @xcite ) which are complementary to the approach developed in this paper .
the layout of the rest of the paper is as follows . in section 2
, we derive the quark mixing sum rules , assuming zero up and down quark 1 - 3 mixing angles . in section 3 , using the sum rules , we discuss the phenomenological viability of quark mass matrix textures with 1 - 3 texture zeros , show how modifications in the up sector can achieve viability , and show how @xmath2 allows each matrix element to be either real or purely imaginary . in section 4 ,
in the framework of guts , we discuss the implications of zero 1 - 3 mixing for the charged lepton and neutrino sectors , and show that the quark mixing sum rules may be used to yield an accurate prediction for the reactor angle .
finally , section 5 concludes the paper .
appendix a shows that textures with nonzero 1 - 3 elements in the up sector are disfavoured .
the mixing matrix in the quark sector , the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa ( ckm ) matrix @xmath16 , is defined as the unitary matrix occurring in the charged current part of the sm interaction lagrangian expressed in terms of the quark mass eigenstates .
these mass eigenstates can be determined from the mass matrices in the yukawa sector , namely @xmath17 where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the mass matrices of the up - type and down - type quarks , respectively .
the change from the flavour into the mass basis is achieved via bi - unitary transformations @xmath20 where @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 are unitary @xmath25 matrices .
the ckm matrix @xmath26 ( in the `` raw '' form , i.e. before the `` unphysical '' phases were absorbed into redefinitions of the quark mass eigenstate field operators ) is then given by @xmath27 in this paper we shall use the standard ( or so - called particle data group ( pdg ) @xcite ) parameterisation for the ckm matrix ( after eliminating the `` unphysical '' phases ) with the structure [ updg ] u_ckm = r_23u_13r_12 , where @xmath28 denote real ( i.e. orthogonal ) matrices , and the unitary matrix @xmath29 contains the observable phase @xmath30 . for more details , see e.g. @xcite .
other alternative parametrisations , motivated by the observation of @xmath2 ( see e.g. @xcite ) have been suggested , but we prefer to stick to the standard one here .
let us now suppose that @xmath55 . from the sm point of view
, this corresponds to just a convenient choice of basis but , as discussed in the introduction , it becomes a nontrivial assumption at the level of a specific underlying model of flavour . for models
where zero 1 - 3 mixing is realised with flavour symmetries , see e.g. @xcite . for @xmath55 , eq . ( [ eq : param3 ] ) simplifies to [ eq : param5 ] u_ckm = u^u_l_12^^u^d_l_23 u^d_l_12 . then , by equating the right - hand sides of eqs .
( [ eq : param4 ] ) and ( [ eq : param5 ] ) and expanding to leading order in the small mixing angles , we obtain the following relations ( up to cubic terms in the physical quark mixing angles ) : [ f1 ] _ 23e^-i_23&= & _ 23^de^-i_23^d -_23^ue^-i_23^u , + [ f2 ] _ 13e^-i_13&= & -_12^ue^-i_12^u ( _ 23^de^-i_23^d - _ 23^ue^-i_23^u ) , + [ f3 ] _ 12e^-i_12&= & _ 12^de^-i_12^d -_12^ue^-i_12^u .
let us first consider eq .
( [ f2 ] ) , which can be transformed into @xmath56 where @xmath57 and @xmath58 stand for the measurable 1 - 3 and 2 - 3 mixing angles in the quark sector , respectively . taking the modulus of eq .
( [ eq : theta13withphases ] ) , the 1 - 2 angle entering the up - sector rotation ( @xmath31 ) in the flavour basis obeys @xmath59 where the 1@xmath60 errors are displayed @xcite .
similarly , combining eq .
( [ f3 ] ) with eq .
( [ eq : theta13withphases ] ) one receives @xmath61 this , together with the identification eq .
( [ eq : deltafromparam1 ] ) gives rise to the quark sector sum rule , the sum rule may be further simplified to @xmath62 . for similar considerations in the lepton sector ,
see e.g. @xcite . ]
@xmath63 which is valid up to higher order corrections . the present best - fit value and the 1@xmath60 errors are also displayed . needless to say ,
the relations ( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) and ( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) apply at the scale at which the flavour structure emerges , often close to the scale of grand unification .
thus , in principle , the renormalisation group ( rg ) effects should be taken into account .
however , due to the smallness of the mixing angles in the quark sector and the hierarchy of the quark masses , the rg corrections to the above relations are very small and can be neglected to a very good approximation .
it is interesting that , with the 1 - 2 mixing angles in the up and down sector derived from the physical parameters , the 1 - 2 phase difference in the up and down sectors can also be determined . indeed , combining all three equations ( [ f1])-([f3 ] ) , one obtains @xmath64 using eqs . ( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) and ( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) we can solve eq .
( [ eq : deltadu ] ) for @xmath65 and obtain ( at 1@xmath60 level ) @xmath66 which is remarkably close to @xmath67 .
we emphasise that this is a consequence of zero 1 - 3 mixing in the up and down sectors , @xmath68 .
we now show that , assuming quark textures with negligible 1 - 3 up and down quark mixing , corresponding to 1 - 3 texture zeros for hierarchical quark mass matrices , @xmath65 is approximately equal to @xmath69 .
this comes from the definition of the unitarity triangle angle @xmath69 : @xmath70 for the second term in the argument , we can use eqs .
( [ f1 ] ) , ( [ f2 ] ) and ( [ f3 ] ) @xmath71 thus , one can see that the angle @xmath69 is nothing but the phase difference @xmath72 , corresponding to a very simple phase sum rule [ phase ] _
12^d - _ 12^u .
according to the phase sum rule in eq .
( [ phase ] ) , the experimental observation that @xmath2 , or the equivalent determination in eq .
( [ phasediff ] ) , suggests looking at quark mass matrices with 1 - 3 texture zeros and with @xmath74 or @xmath75 at the special values @xmath76 .
this would correspond to a set of rather specific textures of the quark mass matrices with , for example , purely imaginary 1 - 2 elements in either @xmath18 or @xmath19 while the 2 - 2 elements remain real .
for example , in @xcite the relation between the phases of the mixing angles and the phases of the matrix elements is discussed .
for instance , the following patterns naturally emerge : @xmath77 and/or @xmath78 where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are real parameters , and the elements marked by `` * '' are irrelevant as long as the hierarchy of the mass matrix is large enough , or , equivalently , as long as the mixing angles in @xmath81 and @xmath82 are small .
these textures are all phenomenologically viable , and consistent with @xmath83 , and their simple phase structure provides a post justification of our assumption of 1 - 3 texture zeros and negligible 1 - 3 up- and down - type quark mixing .
however , the above textures are clearly not the most predictive ones and , for example , do not relate the up and down quark 1 - 2 mixing angles to masses .
this requires additional assumptions , such as additional texture zeros and hermitian or symmetric matrices , as we now discuss . under the additional assumptions of symmetric or hermitian mass matrices in the 1 - 2 block and zero textures in the 1 - 1 positions of the quark mass matrices ,
i.e. , @xmath84 we obtain as additional predictions the gatto - sartori - tonin ( gst ) relations @xcite with 1@xmath60 errors displayed , @xmath85 here we already see a conflict in the up sector .
the prediction for @xmath86 from the sum rule in eq .
( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) is quite different ( several @xmath60 away ) from the gst relation above .
that suggests that the texture in the up sector should be modified to be in good agreement with experiment .
by contrast the prediction from the sum rule in eq .
( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) for @xmath87 is in very good agreement ( within the errors ) with the gst result in eq .
( [ eq : m_d_over_m_s ] ) , and therefore it is quite plausible to keep the simple texture ansatz for the down sector . combining eqs .
( [ eq : m_u_over_m_c ] ) and ( [ eq : m_d_over_m_s ] ) with the sum rules in eqs .
( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) and ( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) , the two relations [ eq : qsplusgst1 ] |_12 - e^- i _ | = and [ eq : qsplusgst2 ] = emerge .
we emphasize that these results do not hold for the textures in @xcite where the 2 - 3 up and down quark mixings are large and the 1 - 3 up and down quark mixings are non - negligible . ) .
the blue lines indicate the predicted values of @xmath88 for given @xmath89 under the assumptions of section [ sec : sumruleplusgst ] , and the dashed horizontal and vertical black lines ( and solid black lines ) show the @xmath90 errors ( and best - fit values ) for @xmath88 and @xmath89 , respectively . ]
the compatibility of eq .
( [ eq : qsplusgst1 ] ) with the experimental results for the down - type quark masses and mixing parameters @xcite is illustrated in fig . 1 .
we note that rg running for the quark masses , as well as their potential susy threshold corrections , are very similar for the first two generations and thus cancel out in their ratio . for our estimates , we have considered the running quark masses at the top mass scale @xmath91 @xcite .
@xmath88 is extracted for given @xmath89 .
the solid blue line shows the relation for best - fit values of the parameters while the dashed blue lines indicate the range with @xmath90 errors included .
the dashed horizontal and vertical black lines ( and solid black lines ) show the @xmath90 errors ( and best - fit values ) for @xmath88 and @xmath89 , respectively .
the relation of eq .
( [ eq : qsplusgst1 ] ) is well compatible with the present data .
future more precise experimental measurements ( for instance at lhcb or @xmath92 factories ) and , in particular , an improved knowledge on @xmath93 ( e.g. from lattice qcd ) are required to test it more accurately . in the following ,
we consider some examples of possible modifications to the textures in the up sector which are phenomenologically acceptable , while leaving the successful down sector texture unchanged , and retaining the successful real and imaginary scheme which leads to the right unitarity triangle .
as discussed in appendix a , the idea of relaxing the up quark 1 - 3 texture zero is disfavoured , so we restrict ourselves to either relaxing the up quark 1 - 1 texture zero , or relaxing symmetry in the 1 - 2 up quark sector , as discussed below .
one possible modification is to introduce a nonzero element in the 1 - 1 position of the up quark mass matrix , i.e.@xmath94 as a result , we obtain the up sector relation @xmath95 which allows to adjust @xmath96 , which is of the order of the up quark mass , while @xmath97 has to be equal to the value obtained in eq .
( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) using the sum rule . for the down sector
, there is still the successful prediction from eq .
( [ eq : m_d_over_m_s ] ) leading to the successful sum rule relation of eq .
( [ eq : qsplusgst1 ] ) .
furthermore , as discussed in section [ sec : deltackm ] , the dirac phase of the ckm matrix is correct .
we note that there exist several variants of the texture .
for example , we can choose the 1 - 2 element of @xmath19 real , the 1 - 2 element of @xmath18 purely imaginary and all the other elements also real .
these variants are valid as long as @xmath98 is real and @xmath99 is purely imaginary , or _ vice versa_. we emphasize that the elements marked by `` * '' are irrelevant as long as the hierarchy of the mass matrix is large enough , so they may be replaced by zeros or , if the matrices are hermitian , the 3 - 1 elements may be zero while the 3 - 2 elements are determined by hermiticity . since the sum rule in eq .
( [ f1 ] ) shows that @xmath1 is determined only by the difference in 2 - 3 mixing angles in the up and down sectors , it is also possible to set either @xmath100 or @xmath101 equal to zero without changing the physical predictions . in this way it is possible to arrive at some of the four - zero textures discussed , for example , in @xcite .
however , we emphasize that here we are additionally assuming the real and imaginary structures consistent with the right unitarity triangle and this was not discussed in @xcite . a second option for a texture consistent with experimental data
consists in relaxing the symmetry of the 1 - 2 block in the up sector , while keeping the texture zero in the 1 - 1 position : @xmath102 the two up - sector relations @xmath103 can be simultaneously fulfilled by choosing @xmath104 and @xmath105 appropriately .
the prediction from eq .
( [ eq : m_d_over_m_s ] ) and the prediction for @xmath30 do not change and remain compatible with data .
we note that there exist several variants of the texture . as before ,
it is sufficient to have @xmath98 real and @xmath99 purely imaginary , or _ vice versa_.
extending the notion of zero 1 - 3 mixing to the lepton sector ( i.e. under the assumption of @xmath106 ) , the presently unknown mixing angle @xmath107 of the leptonic ( mns ) mixing matrix satisfies the relation ( analogous to eq .
( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) ) ^mns_13 = ^mns_23 ^e_12 , where @xmath108 is the 1 - 2 mixing in the charged lepton mass matrix @xmath109 .
this relation has emerged before , for example , in the context of lepton sum rules in @xcite . in many classes of gut models of flavour
, the 1 - 2 mixing angles corresponding to @xmath109 and @xmath19 are related by a group theoretical clebsch factor , for example @xmath110 @xcite . in general , it is usually assumed that @xmath111 is of the order of the cabibbo angle , leading to a prediction @xmath112 @xcite .
however , in the context of fritzsch - type textures , which are based on hermitian matrices with 1 - 1 , 2 - 2 and 1 - 3 texture zeros , this prediction can be made more precise by using the sum rule which relates @xmath111 to down - type quark masses .
thus , applying eq .
( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) at low energies and taking the present experimental data for the quark mixing angles , and for @xmath113 ( taken from @xcite ) , one can make the rather precise prediction [ eq : mns13mixing ] ^mns_13 = ( 2.84^+0.22_-0.18 ) ^which gives @xmath114 and holds under the assumption of texture zeros in the 1 - 3 elements of the mass matrices ( or more precisely @xmath115 ) and @xmath110 .
of course , eq . ( [ eq : mns13mixing ] ) is only a single example out of a larger variety of predictions which may arise in unified flavour models ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
we emphasise that the main use of eq .
( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) in this context is that it allows to `` determine '' the down quark mixing @xmath111 , which is generically involved in relations between quark and lepton mixing angles , from measurable quantities .
we note that in the lepton sector , the rg corrections ( see e.g. @xcite ) can be significant , depending on the absolute neutrino mass scale ( and on @xmath116 in a susy framework ) and other effects such as canonical normalisation on the mixing angles can also be sizeable @xcite . furthermore , relaxing the 1 - 1 texture zero in the up quark sector may switch on a nonzero 1 - 3 mixing angle in the neutrino sector via partially constrained sequential dominance @xcite .
in this paper we have discussed phenomenologically viable textures for hierarchical quark mass matrices which have both 1 - 3 texture zeros and negligible 1 - 3 mixing in both the up and down quark mass matrices .
such textures differ from the textures discussed in @xcite and @xcite .
our main contribution in this paper has been to derive quark mixing sum rules applicable to textures of this type , in which @xmath0 is generated from @xmath1 as a result of 1 - 2 up - type mixing , in direct analogy to the lepton sum rules derived in @xcite .
an important result of our study is to show how the right - angled unitarity triangle , i.e. , @xmath2 , can be accounted for by a remarkably simple scheme involving real mass matrices apart from a single element of either the up or down quark mass matrix being purely imaginary .
the experimental result that @xmath2 therefore provides an impetus for having hierarchical textures compatible with negligible 1 - 3 mixing in both the up and down quark mass matrices .
this is probably the most important take - home message of this paper .
the quark mixing sum rules in eqs .
( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) and ( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) relate the up and down quark 1 - 2 mixing angles to observable parameters in the ckm matrix . using these sum rules the four - zero texture with 1 - 1 and 1 - 3 texture zeros and a 2 - 1 symmetric or hermitian structure ,
is shown to be viable for the down quark sector but not for the up quark sector .
however , it is possible to have four - zero textures compatible with our sum rules by , for example , filling in the up quark 1 - 1 texture zero , then having hermitian matrices with either of the 2 - 3 elements in the up or down sector set equal to zero as in @xcite .
however , we emphasize that here we are additionally assuming the real and imaginary structures consistent with the right unitarity triangle and this was not discussed in @xcite . in the framework of guts
, it is natural to have 1 - 3 texture zeros for both the quark and charged lepton sectors , and in such a case we have shown that the quark mixing sum rules may be used to yield an accurate prediction for the reactor angle ; see eq .
( [ eq : mns13mixing ] ) .
however , we caution that this prediction is subject to considerable theoretical uncertainty due to the model dependence of the quark - lepton mixing angle relations , rg and canonical normalisation effects , as well as the assumption that the underlying neutrino 1 - 3 mixing angle is zero . indeed , relaxing the 1 - 1 texture zero in the up quark sector will switch on a nonzero 1 - 3 mixing angle in the neutrino sector via partially constrained sequential dominance @xcite .
finally , we emphasise that the strategy of exploring particular textures for yukawa matrices , though necessarily rather _ ad hoc _ , is meaningful from the perspective of theories of flavour based on spontaneously broken family symmetry , where , in the flavour basis defined by the high energy theory , simple yukawa matrix structures are expected .
indeed , the study of simple yukawa textures may provide the only bottom - up way of deducing a high energy theory of flavour from experimental data .
we have shown that @xmath2 may provide a clue towards such a high energy theory of flavour via rather simple yukawa matrices involving 1 - 3 texture zeros whose nonzero elements are either real or purely imaginary .
such patterns could be achieved , in principle , by appropriate alignment of the vacuum expectation values of flavour symmetry breaking flavon fields , and in particular their phases
. it would be interesting to build a theory of flavour along these lines .
we would like to thank jonathan flynn for discussions and christoph luhn for carefully reading the manuscript and providing helpful comments .
we are indebted to nordita for the hospitality and support during the programme `` astroparticle physics a pathfinder to new physics '' held in stockholm in march 30 - april 30 , 2009 during which part of this study was performed .
sfk is very grateful for the support and hospitality provided by the max - planck - institute of physics during his stay in munich while this paper was being finalized .
sa and ms acknowledge partial support by the dfg cluster of excellence `` origin and structure of the universe . '' the work of mm is supported by the royal institute of technology ( kth ) , contract no
. sii-56510 .
sfk acknowledges partial support from the stfc rolling grant no .
st / g000557/1 and a royal society leverhulme trust senior research fellowship .
with nonzero 1 - 3 elements , @xmath30 depends not only on @xmath117 but also on other parameters ( in particular @xmath118 and @xmath119 ) and the simple quark mixing sum rules in eqs .
( [ eq : quarkrelation ] ) and ( [ eq : quarksumrule ] ) are no longer valid .
examples of this type of texture include ( with real parameter @xmath120 ) @xmath121 and @xmath122 but also variations with different elements chosen either purely imaginary or real .
we will demonstrate our approach for this case by means of the texture in eq .
( [ eq : futexture1 ] ) .
the starting point is here ( similar to eqs .
( [ f1])-([f3 ] ) ) [ g1 ] _ 23e^-i_23&= & _ 23^de^-i_23^d -_23^ue^-i_23^u , + [ g2 ] _ 13e^-i_13&= & -_13^ue^-i_13^u -_12^u _ 23e^-i(_12^u + _ 23 ) , + [ g3 ] _ 12e^-i_12&= & _ 12^de^-i_12^d -_12^ue^-i_12^u , where we have also neglected terms of order @xmath123 . from our texture ansatz , we know the phases @xmath124 , @xmath125 and @xmath126 . for the values of @xmath127 , we take the values from the gst relations , i.e. eq . ( [ eq : m_u_over_m_c ] ) , which hold here because of the zeros in the 1 - 1 position and the symmetric structure for the first two generations
. then we can calculate @xmath128 and @xmath30 in terms of the known quantities and obtain @xmath129 .
this result is several standard deviations away from the measurements .
beyond the particular example discussed above , we found that the inconsistency of the prediction for @xmath30 also appears in all other cases with @xmath130 , @xmath124 and @xmath131 @xmath132 .
furthermore , the same happens for textures with @xmath133 and @xmath134 , where @xmath135 denotes the 1 - 3 element of @xmath19 .
we conclude that under these conditions textures with nonzero 1 - 3 elements are disfavoured . s. f. king and c. luhn , arxiv:0908.1897 [ hep - ph ] . c. s. lam , arxiv:0907.2206 [ hep - ph ] .
e. ma and g. rajasekaran , phys .
d * 64 * ( 2001 ) 113012 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0106291 ] .
g. altarelli , arxiv : hep - ph/0611117 ; g. altarelli , f. feruglio and y. lin , nucl .
b * 775 * ( 2007 ) 31 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0610165 ] ; g. altarelli and f. feruglio , nucl .
b * 741 * ( 2006 ) 215 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0512103 ] ; g. altarelli and f. feruglio , nucl .
b * 720 * ( 2005 ) 64 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0504165 ] ; m. c. chen and s. f. king , jhep * 0906 * ( 2009 ) 072 [ arxiv:0903.0125 [ hep - ph ] ] ; t. j. burrows and s. f. king , arxiv:0909.1433 [ hep - ph ] .
i. de medeiros varzielas , s. f. king and g. g. ross , phys .
b * 648 * ( 2007 ) 201 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0607045 ] .
s. f. king and m. malinsky , jhep * 0611 * ( 2006 ) 071 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0608021 ] ; s. f. king , jhep * 0508 * ( 2005 ) 105 ; s. antusch and s. f. king , nucl .
b * 705 * ( 2005 ) 239 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0402121 ] .
s. f. king and g. g. ross , phys .
b * 520 * ( 2001 ) 243 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0108112 ] ; s. f. king and g. g. ross , phys .
b * 574 * ( 2003 ) 239 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0307190 ] ; i. de medeiros varzielas and g. g. ross , nucl .
b * 733 * ( 2006 ) 31 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0507176 ] .
h. fritzsch and z. z. xing , prog . part .
* 45 * ( 2000 ) 1 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9912358 ] . g. k. leontaris and n. d. vlachos , arxiv:0909.4701 [ unknown ] ; s. dev , s. verma and s. gupta , arxiv:0909.3182 [ unknown ] ; b. adhikary , a. ghosal and p. roy , arxiv:0908.2686 [ hep - ph ] ; s. goswami , s. khan and w. rodejohann , phys .
b * 680 * ( 2009 ) 255 [ arxiv:0905.2739 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. goswami , s. khan and a. watanabe , arxiv:0811.4744 [ hep - ph ] ; s. choubey , w. rodejohann and p. roy , nucl . phys .
b * 808 * ( 2009 ) 272 [ erratum - ibid .
* 818 * ( 2009 ) 136 ] [ arxiv:0807.4289 [ hep - ph ] ] ; g. c. branco , d. emmanuel - costa , m. n. rebelo and p. roy , phys .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 053011 [ arxiv:0712.0774 [ hep - ph ] ] ; h. a. alhendi , e. i. lashin and a. a. mudlej , phys . rev .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 013009 [ arxiv:0708.2007 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. kaneko , h. sawanaka , t. shingai , m. tanimoto and k. yoshioka , arxiv : hep - ph/0703250 ; g. c. branco , m. n. rebelo and j. i. silva - marcos , phys . rev .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 033008 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0612252 ] ; c. s. lam , phys .
d * 74 * ( 2006 ) 113004 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0611017 ] ; s. kaneko , h. sawanaka , t. shingai , m. tanimoto and k. yoshioka , prog .
theor . phys .
* 117 * ( 2007 ) 161 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0609220 ] ; k. fuki and m. yasue , nucl .
b * 783 * ( 2007 ) 31 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0608042 ] ; n. haba and k. yoshioka , nucl .
b * 739 * ( 2006 ) 254 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0511108 ] ; h. d. kim , s. raby and l. schradin , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 092002 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0401169 ] ; i. jack , d. r. t. jones and r. wild , phys .
b * 580 * ( 2004 ) 72 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309165 ] ; i. jack and d. r. t. jones , nucl .
b * 662 * ( 2003 ) 63 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0301163 ] ; f. caravaglios , p. roudeau and a. stocchi , nucl .
b * 633 * ( 2002 ) 193 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0202055 ] ; l. l. everett , g. l. kane and s. f. king , jhep * 0008 * ( 2000 ) 012 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0005204 ] ; z. berezhiani and a. rossi , nucl .
b * 594 * ( 2001 ) 113 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0003084 ] ; t. k. kuo , s. w. mansour and g. h. wu , phys .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 093004 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9907314 ] ; d. falcone and f. tramontano , phys .
d * 59 * ( 1999 ) 017302 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9806496 ] .
r. g. roberts , a. romanino , g. g. ross and l. velasco - sevilla , nucl .
b * 615 * ( 2001 ) 358 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0104088 ] ; p. ramond , r. g. roberts and g. g. ross , nucl .
b * 406 * ( 1993 ) 19 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9303320 ] .
s. f. king , jhep * 0508 * ( 2005 ) 105 ; i. masina , phys .
b * 633 * ( 2006 ) 134 ; s. antusch and s. f. king , phys .
b * 631 * ( 2005 ) 42 .
s. antusch , s. f. king and m. malinsky , arxiv:0810.3863 [ hep - ph ] ; s. boudjemaa and s. f. king , arxiv:0808.2782 [ hep - ph ] ; s. antusch , s. f. king and m. malinsky , jhep * 0805 * ( 2008 ) 066 [ arxiv:0712.3759 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. antusch , s. f. king and m. malinsky , phys .
b * 671 * ( 2009 ) 263 [ arxiv:0711.4727 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. f. king , phys .
b * 659 * ( 2008 ) 244 [ arxiv:0710.0530 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. antusch , p. huber , s. f. king and t. schwetz , jhep * 0704 * ( 2007 ) 060 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0702286 ] ; s. antusch and s. f. king , phys . lett .
b * 631 * ( 2005 ) 42 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0508044 ] .
ckmfitter group ( j. charles et al . ) , eur .
j. c41 ( 2005 ) 1 , hep - ph/0406184 , updated results and plots : http://ckmfitter.in2p3.fr ; m. bona et al .
( utfit collaboration ) , hep - ph/0701204 .
h. fritzsch and z. z. xing , phys .
b * 413 * ( 1997 ) 396 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9707215 ] ; h. fritzsch and z. z. xing , phys .
d * 57 * ( 1998 ) 594 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9708366 ] .
f. harrison , d. r. j. roythorne and w. g. scott , phys .
b * 657 * ( 2007 ) 210 [ arxiv:0709.1439 [ hep - ph ] ] ; p.
f. harrison , d. r. j. roythorne and w. g. scott , arxiv:0805.3440 [ hep - ph ] ; p. f. harrison , d. r. j. roythorne and w. g. scott , arxiv:0904.3014 [ hep - ph ] ; p. f. harrison , s. dallison and w. g. scott , phys .
b * 680 * ( 2009 ) 328 [ arxiv:0904.3077 [ hep - ph ] ] ; p. f. harrison and w. g. scott , arxiv:0906.2732 [ hep - ph ] .
g. couture , c. hamzaoui , s. s. y. lu and m. toharia , arxiv:0910.3132 [ unknown ] .
s. m. barr , phys .
d * 42 * ( 1990 ) 3150 ; i. s. sogami and t. shinohara , phys . rev .
d * 47 * ( 1993 ) 2905 .
l. e. ibanez and g. g. ross , phys .
b * 332 * ( 1994 ) 100 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9403338 ] ; v. jain and r. shrock , phys .
b * 352 * ( 1995 ) 83 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9412367 ] ; a. pomarol and d. tommasini , nucl . phys .
b * 466 * ( 1996 ) 3 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9507462 ] ; a. mondragon and e. rodriguez - jauregui , phys .
d * 59 * ( 1999 ) 093009 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9807214 ] ; r. barbieri , p. creminelli and a. romanino , nucl .
b * 559 * ( 1999 ) 17 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9903460 ] ; r. barbieri , l. giusti , l. j. hall and a. romanino , nucl .
b * 550 * ( 1999 ) 32 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9812239 ] ; k. s. babu and j. kubo , phys . rev .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 056006 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0411226 ] ; n. haba and k. yoshioka , nucl .
b * 739 * ( 2006 ) 254 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0511108 ] ; i. masina and c. a. savoy , phys .
b * 642 * ( 2006 ) 472 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0606097 ] ; f. bazzocchi , s. kaneko and s. morisi , jhep * 0803 * ( 2008 ) 063 [ arxiv:0707.3032 [ hep - ph ] ] ; k. s. babu and y. meng , phys . rev .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 075003 [ arxiv:0907.4231 [ hep - ph ] ] ; h. ishimori , y. shimizu and m. tanimoto , prog .
* 180 * ( 2010 ) 61 [ arxiv:0904.2450 [ hep - ph ] ] ; s. morisi and e. peinado , arxiv:1001.2265 [ hep - ph ] .
s. antusch and m. spinrath , arxiv:0902.4644 [ hep - ph ] .
s. antusch , j. kersten , m. lindner and m. ratz , nucl .
b * 674 * ( 2003 ) 401 ; s. antusch , j. kersten , m. lindner , m. ratz and m. a. schmidt , jhep * 0503 * ( 2005 ) 024 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0501272 ] . s. f. king , arxiv:0903.3199 [ hep - ph ] . | in analogy with the recently proposed lepton mixing sum rules , we derive quark mixing sum rules for the case of hierarchical quark mass matrices with 1 - 3 texture zeros , in which the separate up and down type 1 - 3 mixing angles are approximately zero , and @xmath0 is generated from @xmath1 as a result of 1 - 2 up type quark mixing . using the sum rules
, we discuss the phenomenological viability of such textures , including up to four texture zeros , and show how the right - angled unitarity triangle , i.e. , @xmath2 , can be accounted for by a remarkably simple scheme involving real mass matrices apart from a single element being purely imaginary . in the framework of grand unified theories ,
we show how the quark and lepton mixing sum rules may combine to yield an accurate prediction for the reactor angle . |
the spatial correlation function of galaxy clusters provides an important cosmological test , as both the amplitude of the correlation function and its dependence upon mean intercluster separation are determined by the underlying cosmological model . in hierarchical models of structure formation , the spatial correlation length , @xmath3 , is predicted to be an increasing function of cluster mass , with the precise value of @xmath3 and its mass dependence determined by @xmath4 ( or equivalently @xmath5 , using the constraint on @xmath6 from the local cluster mass function ) and the shape parameter @xmath7 . low density and low @xmath7 models generally predict stronger clustering for a given mass and a greater dependence of the correlation length upon cluster mass . in this paper we utilize the las campanas distant cluster survey ( lcdcs ) to provide a new , independent measurement of the dependence of the cluster correlation length upon the mean intercluster separation ( @xmath8 ) at mean separations comparable to existing abell and apm studies .
we first measure the angular correlation function for a series of subsamples at @xmath9 and then derive the corresponding @xmath3 values via the cosmological limber inversion @xcite .
the resulting values constitute the first measurements of the spatial correlation length for clusters at @xmath10 .
popular structure formation models predict only a small amount of evolution from @xmath11 to the present - a prediction that we test by comparison of our results with local observations .
the recently completed las campanas distant cluster survey is the largest published catalog of galaxy clusters at @xmath12 , containing 1073 candidates @xcite .
clusters are detected in the lcdcs as regions of excess surface brightness relative to the mean sky level , a technique that permits wide - area coverage with a minimal investment of telescope time .
the final statistical catalog covers an effective area of 69 square degrees within a @xmath13 strip of the southern sky ( @xmath14 @xmath15 mpc at @xmath1=0.5 for @xmath5=0.3 @xmath16cdm ) .
gonzalez et al . ( 2001@xmath17 ) also provide estimated redshifts ( @xmath18 ) , based upon the brightest cluster galaxy ( bcg ) magnitude - redshift relation , that are accurate to @xmath215% at @xmath19 , and demonstrate the existence of a correlation between the peak surface brightness , @xmath20 , and velocity dispersion , @xmath21 .
together these two properties enable construction of well - defined subsamples that can be compared directly with simulations and observations of the local universe . to compute the two - point angular correlation function
, we use the estimator of landy & szalay ( 1993 ) .
we measure the angular correlation function both for the full lcdcs catalog and for three approximately velocity dispersion - limited subsamples at @[email protected] ( figure [ fig : fig1]@xmath17 ) .
we restrict all subsamples to @[email protected] to avoid incompleteness , while the maximum redshift is determined by the surface brightness threshold of the subsample .
the angular correlation function for the entire lcdcs catalog is shown in the upper panel of figure [ fig : fig1]@xmath23 , with logarithmic angular bins of width @xmath24=0.2 . modeling this correlation function as a power law , @xmath25 a least - squares fit for all lcdcs clusters over the range 2@xmath26 - 5@xmath27 yields @[email protected] and @xmath30=56@xmath31 .
the angular correlation function for the lowest redshift subsample is shown in the lower panel of figure [ fig : fig1]@xmath23 , overlaid with a best - fit power law .
we derive best - fit values both allowing @xmath28 to vary as a free parameter and also fixing @xmath28=2.1 equivalent to the best - fit value for the lowest redshift subsample and the best fit value for the rosat all - sky survey 1 bright sample @xcite .
we then apply a correction to these best - fit values to account for the impact of false detections in the lcdcs catalog , which for this data set act to suppress the amplitude of the observed correlation function .
if we assume that the contamination is spatially correlated and can be described by a power law with the same slope as the cluster angular correlation function ( a reasonable approximation because for galaxies which are likely the primary contaminant @[email protected] - 1.9 [ e.g. 2 , 19 ] ) , then the observed value of @xmath32 is @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the fractional contamination . for detections induced by isolated galaxies of the same magnitude as bcg s at @xmath35 ( and identified as galaxies by the automated identification criteria described in gonzalez et al .
( 2001@xmath17 ) , we measure that @xmath36 is comparable to @xmath37 , the net clustering amplitude for all lcdcs candidates at 0.3@xmath0@[email protected] . for detections identified as low surface brightness galaxies ( including some nearby dwarf galaxies )
we measure @xmath38 .
while these systems are strongly clustered , we expect that they comprise less than half of the contamination in the lcdcs .
for multiple sources of contamination the effective clustering amplitude @xmath39 , so the effective clustering strength of the contamination is @xmath40 even including the lsb s .
the observed angular correlation function can be used to determine the three - space correlation length if the redshift distribution of the sample is known .
this is accomplished via the cosmological limber inversion @xcite . for a power - law correlation function with redshift dependence @xmath41 , @xmath42
the corresponding comoving spatial correlation length is @xmath43 , and the limber equation is @xmath44 } \left [ \frac{\int_{z1}^{z2 } ( dn / dz)^2 e(z ) d_{a}(z)^{1-\gamma } f(z ) ( 1+z ) dz } { \left(\int_{z1}^{z2 } ( dn / dz ) dz\right)^2}\right]^{-1},\ ] ] where @xmath45 is the redshift distribution of the sample , @xmath46 is the angular diameter distance , and @xmath47 is defined as in peebles ( 1993 ) .
because little evolution in the clustering is expected over the redshift intervals spanned by our subsamples ( see figure [ fig : cfvslocal ] ) , @xmath41 can be pulled out of the integral . for the lcdcs we estimate the true redshift distributions of our subsamples based upon the observed distribution of estimated redshifts .
if we approximate the redshift error distribution as gaussian with @xmath48 at @xmath1=0.5 @xcite , then the actual redshift distribution @xmath45 is approximately equal to the observed redshift distribution @xmath49 for a given subsample convolved with this gaussian scatter . to test the validity of this approach
, we also try modeling @xmath45 using the theoretical mass function of sheth & tormen ( 1999 ) convolved with redshift uncertainty . comparing these two methods
we find that the derived spatial correlation lengths agree to better than 3% for all subsamples .
ccccccc & & & + range & @xmath50 & @xmath3 & @xmath50 & @xmath3 & @xmath50 & @xmath3 + + 0.35 - 0.475 & 38.4 & 15.1@xmath51 & 33.8 & 13.2@xmath52 & 30.9 & 12.1@xmath53 + 0.35 - 0.525 & 46.3 & 18.5@xmath54 & 40.6 & 16.1@xmath55 & 36.9 & 14.7@xmath56 + 0.35 - 0.575 & 58.1 & 22.1@xmath57 & 50.8 & 19.1@xmath58 & 46.0 & 17.3@xmath59 + + + [ tab : ro ]
table [ tab : ro ] lists the correlation lengths ( @xmath3 ) and mean intercluster separations ( @xmath50 ) that we derive for the three lcdcs subsamples .
the values of @xmath3 and @xmath50 are cosmology - dependent , so we list these quantities for three different cosmologies @xmath16cdm ( @xmath5=0.3,@xmath7=0.2 ) , ocdm ( @xmath5=0.3,@xmath7=0.2 ) , and @xmath60cdm ( @xmath7=0.2 ) .
we opt to fix @xmath28=2.1 when deriving the correlation lengths in table [ tab : ro ] because @xmath28 is strongly covariant with @xmath32 and hence poorly constrained by the lcdcs data set . in no instance does this choice alter the derived @xmath3 value by more than 10% from the value obtained when @xmath28 is treated as a free parameter , but we caution that it can systematically bias the observed dependence of @xmath3 upon @xmath50 . for subsamples with best - fit values of @[email protected] ,
fixing gamma slightly increases the derived value of @xmath3 , which results in a mild steepening of the dependence of @xmath3 upon @xmath50 for the lcdcs subsamples .
the cluster correlation function is predicted to not evolve significantly between @xmath1=0.5 and the present ; we thus compare the lcdcs results directly with local observations , as is shown in figure [ fig : cfvslocal ] for @xmath16cdm and @xmath60cdm . for both cosmologies
the lcdcs values of @xmath3 are comparable to those from the edinburgh - durham galaxy catalogue @xcite , apm survey @xcite , and the mx survey northern sample @xcite , but smaller than those found by peacock & west ( 1992 ) for the abell catalog . also shown
are the lowest @xmath50 data points for the xbac catalog @xcite , which probe higher masses than our study .
we also plot theoretical predictions for comparison with the observational data .
results from the virgo consortium hubble volume simulations are shown as a dot - dash line in figure [ fig : cfvslocal]@xmath17 @xcite .
the other lines are analytic predictions based upon the work of sheth & tormen ( 1999 ) . like the apm data , the lcdcs results are consistent with the low - density models ( independent of @xmath61 ) .
in contrast , the plotted @xmath60cdm model systematically underestimates both the local and @xmath1=0.5 data .
@xmath60cdm can be made to match the data only by decreasing @xmath7 to values that are inconsistent with constraints from the galaxy power spectrum @xcite . to assess the robustness of these results
, we also quantify potential systematic biases ( see gonzalez et al .
2001@xmath23 for more detail ) .
we find that our results can only be significantly altered if the uncertainty in the estimated redshifts is underestimated .
if so , then the correlation lengths we derive would be systematically too small ( by @xmath22 @xmath15 mpc if @xmath62=0.25 , for example ) . the second most significant potential systematic arises from fixing @xmath28 , which as mentioned above may lead us to overestimate the dependence of @xmath3 upon @xmath50 .
treating @xmath28 as a free parameter would reduce the derived @xmath3 values for the three subsamples ( in order of increasing @xmath50 ) by 0% , 7% , and 10% , but would not qualitatively change our results .
the las campanas distant cluster survey is the largest existing catalog of clusters at @[email protected] , providing a unique sample with which to study the properties of the cluster population .
we use the lcdcs to constrain the cluster - cluster angular correlation function , providing the first measurements for a sample with a mean redshift @[email protected] . from the observed angular correlation function ,
we derive the spatial correlation length , @xmath3 , as a function of mean separation , @xmath50 . only modest evolution in the clustering amplitude
is predicted between @xmath11 and present , and we thus compare our results directly with local data .
we find that the lcdcs correlation lengths agree with results from local samples , and observe a dependence of @xmath3 upon @xmath50 that is comparable to the results of croft et al .
( 1997 ) for the apm catalog .
this clustering strength , its dependence on number density , and its minimal redshift evolution are consistent with analytic expectations for low density models , and with results from the @xmath16cdm hubble volume simulations .
consequently , while statistical uncertainty limits our ability to discriminate between cosmological models , our results are in concordance with the flat @xmath16cdm model favored by recent supernovae and cosmic microwave background observations @xcite .
a final result of this analysis is that it demonstrates the utility of large catalogs like the lcdcs that are statistical in nature . while the properties of any particular cluster in the lcdcs catalog are rather uncertain , the properties of the sample as a whole are well - defined , which is sufficient for constraining properties such as the clustering strength and evolution in the comoving number density .
this statistical approach requires a relatively small investment in telescope time , and so can be extended in the future to much larger samples than the lcdcs .
abadi , m. g. , lambas , d. g. , & muriel , h. 1998 , , 507 , 526 cabanac , r. a. , de lapparent , v. , & hickson , p. 2000 , , 364 , 349 colberg et al .
2000 , , 319 , 209 croft , r. a. c. , dalton , g. b. , efstathiou , g. , sutherland , w. j. , & maddox , s. j. 1997 , , 291 , 305 de bernardis , p. et al .
2001 , astro - ph/0105296 efstathiou , g. , bernstein , g. , katz , n. , tyson , a. j. , & guhathakurta , p. 1991
, , 380 , 47 eisenstein , d. j. & zaldarriaga , m. 2000 , , 546 , 2001 gonzalez , a. h. , zaritsky , d. , dalcanton , j. j. , & nelson , a. e. 2001@xmath17 , accepted by gonzalez , a. h. , zaritsky , d. , & wechsler , r. 2001@xmath23 , submitted to hudon , j. d. , & lilly , s. j. 1996 , , 469 , 519 landy , s. d. , & szalay , a. s. 1993 , , 412 , 64 miller , c. j. , batuski , d. j. , slinglend , k. a. , hill , j. m. 1999 , , 523 , 492 moscardini , l. , matarrese , s. , de grandi , s. , & lucchin , f. 2000 , , 314 , 647 nichol , r. c. , collins , c. a. , guzzo , l. , lumsden , s. l. 1992 , , 255 , 21 peacock , j. a. & west , m. j. 1992 , , 259 , 494 peebles , p. j. e. 1980 , the large - scale structure of the universe ( princeton : princeton university press ) peebles , p. j. e. 1993 , physical cosmology ( princeton : princeton university press ) pryke , c. et al . 2001 , astro - ph/0104490 roche , n. , & eales , s. a. 1999 , , 307 , 703 riess , a. g. et al .
2001 , astro - ph/0104455 sheth , r. k. & tormen , g. 1999 , , 308 , 119 | we utilize a sample of galaxy clusters at 0.35@xmath0@[email protected] drawn from the las campanas distant cluster survey ( lcdcs ) to provide the first non - local constraint on the cluster - cluster spatial correlation function .
the lcdcs catalog , which covers an effective area of 69 square degrees , contains over 1000 cluster candidates . estimates of the redshift and velocity dispersion exist for all candidates , which enables construction of statistically completed , volume - limited subsamples . in this analysis we measure the angular correlation function for four such subsamples at @[email protected] . after correcting for contamination ,
we then derive spatial correlation lengths via limber inversion .
we find that the resulting correlation lengths depend upon mass , as parameterized by the mean cluster separation , in a manner that is consistent with both local observations and cdm predictions for the clustering strength at @xmath1=0.5 . |
coined quantum walks ( qws ) on graphs were firstly defined in ref .
@xcite and have been extensively analyzed in the literature @xcite .
many experimental proposals for the qws were given previously @xcite , with some actual experimental implementations performed in refs .
the key feature of the coined qw model is to use an internal state that determines possible directions that the particle can take under the action of the shift operator ( actual displacement through the graph ) .
another important feature is the alternated action of two unitary operators , namely , the coin and shift operators .
although all discrete - time qw models have the `` alternation between unitaries '' feature , the coin is not always necessary because the evolution operator can be defined in terms of the graph vertices only , without using an internal space as , for instance , in szegedy s model @xcite or in the ones described in refs .
@xcite .
more recently , the staggered quantum walk ( sqw ) model was defined in refs .
@xcite , where a recipe to generate unitary and hermitian local operators based on the graph structure was given .
the evolution operator in the sqw model is a product of local operators .
moves the particle to the neighborhood of @xmath0 , but not further away . ]
the sqw model contains a subset of the coined qw class of models @xcite , as shown in ref .
@xcite , and the entire szegedy model @xcite class .
although covering a more general class of quantum walks , there is a restriction on the local evolution operations in the sqw demanding hermiticity besides unitarity .
this severely compromises the possibilities for actual implementations of sqws on physical systems because the unitary evolution operators , given in terms of time - independent hamiltonians having the form @xmath1 , are non - hermitian in general . to have a model , that besides being powerful as the sqw , to be also fitted for practical physical implementations , it would be necessary to relax on the hermiticity requirement for the local unitary operators . in this work
, we propose an extension of the sqw model employing non - hermitian local operators .
the concatenated evolution operator has the form @xmath2 where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are unitary and hermitian , @xmath5 and @xmath6 are general angles representing specific systems energies and time intervals ( divided by the planck constant @xmath7 ) .
the standard sqw model is recovered when @xmath8 and @xmath9 . with this modification , sqw with hamiltonians
encompasses the standard sqw model and includes new coined models . besides , with the new model
, it is easier to devise new experimental proposals such as the one described in ref .
@xcite .
[ sqwwh_graph1 ] depicts the relation among the discrete - time qw models .
szegedy s model is included in the standard sqw model class , which itself is a subclass of the sqw model with hamiltonians .
flip - flop coined qws that are in szegedy s model are also in the sqw model .
flip - flop coined qws using hadamard @xmath10 and grover @xmath11 coins , as represented in fig .
[ sqwwh_graph1 ] , are examples .
there are coined qws , which are in the sqw model with hamiltonians general class , but not in the standard sqw model , as for example , the one - dimensional qws with coin @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the pauli matrix @xmath14 , with angle @xmath15 not a multiple of @xmath16 .
those do not encompass all the possible coined qw models , as there are flip - flop coined qws , which although being built with non - hermitian unitary evolution , can not be put in the sqw model with hamiltonians .
for instance , when the fourier coin @xmath17 is employed , where @xmath18 and @xmath19 , being @xmath20 the hilbert space dimension .
the structure of this paper is as follows . in sec .
[ sec2 ] , we describe how to obtain the evolution operator of the sqw with hamiltonians on a generic simple undirected graph . in sec .
[ sec3 ] , we calculate the wave function using the fourier analysis for the one - dimensional lattice and the standard deviation of the probability distribution . in sec .
[ sec4 ] , we characterize which coined qws are included in the class of sqws with hamiltonians . finally , in sec .
[ sec5 ] we draw our conclusions .
let @xmath21 be a simple undirected graph with vertex set @xmath22 and edge set @xmath23 .
a tessellation of @xmath24 is a partition of @xmath22 so that each element of the partition is a clique .
a clique is a subgraph of @xmath24 that is complete .
an element of the partition is called a polygon .
the tessellation covers all vertices but not necessarily all edges .
let @xmath25 be the hilbert space spanned by the computational basis @xmath26 , that is , each vertex @xmath0 is associated with a vector @xmath27 of the canonical basis .
each polygon spans a subspace of the @xmath25 , whose basis comprises the vectors of the computational basis associated with the vertices in the polygon .
let @xmath28 be the number of polygons and let @xmath29 be a polygon for some @xmath30 .
a unit vector _ induces _
polygon @xmath29 if the following two conditions are fulfilled : first , the vertices of @xmath29 is a clique in @xmath24 .
second , the vector has the form @xmath31 so that @xmath32 for @xmath33 and @xmath34 otherwise .
the simplest choice is the uniform superposition given by @xmath35 for @xmath33 .
there is a recipe to build a unitary and hermitian operator associated with the tessellation , when we use the following structure : @xmath36 @xmath3 is unitary because the polygons are non - overlapping , that is , @xmath37 for @xmath38 .
@xmath3 is hermitian because it is a sum of hermitian operators .
then , @xmath39 .
an operator of this kind is called an _
orthogonal reflection _ of graph @xmath24 .
each @xmath29 induces a polygon and we say that @xmath3 induces the tessellation .
the idea of the staggered model is to define a second operator that must be independent of @xmath3 .
define a second tessellation by making another partition of @xmath24 with polygons @xmath40 for @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the number of polygons .
for each polygon @xmath40 , define unit vectors @xmath43 so that @xmath44 for @xmath45 and @xmath46 otherwise .
the simplest choice is the uniform superposition given by @xmath47 for @xmath45 .
likewise , define @xmath48 @xmath4 is an orthogonal reflection . to obtain the evolution operator we demand that the union of tessellations @xmath49 and @xmath50 should cover the edges of @xmath24 , where tessellation @xmath49 is the union of polygons @xmath29 for @xmath51 and tessellation @xmath50 is the union of polygons @xmath40 for @xmath41 .
this demand is necessary because edges that do not belong to the tessellation union can be removed from the graph without changing the dynamics .
the standard sqw dynamics is given by the evolution operator @xmath52 where the unitary and hermitian operators @xmath3 and @xmath4 are constructed as described in eqs .
( [ h_0 ] ) and ( [ h_1 ] ) .
however , such graph - based construction of the operators does not correspond , in general , to the evolution of the real physical systems which are unitary but non - hermitian instead .
actually , the unitary and non - hermitian operators do not have a nice representation as in eqs .
( [ h_0 ] ) and ( [ h_1 ] ) . in the following ,
we introduce and analyze a method for constructing `` physical evolutions '' using the graph - based unitary and hermitian operators .
we define the staggered qw model with hamiltonians by the evolution operator @xmath53 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are angles .
@xmath54 can be written as @xmath55 the standard sqw model is obtained when @xmath56 and @xmath57 . the staggered qw model with hamiltonians
is characterized by two tessellations and the angles @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
the evolution operator is the product of two _ local _ unitary operators .
local in the sense discussed before , that is , if a particle is on vertex @xmath0 , it will move to the neighborhood of @xmath0 only .
some graphs are not 2-tessellable as discussed in ref . @xcite . in this case
, we have to use more than two tessellations until covering all edges and eq .
( [ u ] ) must be extended accordingly .
one of the simplest example of a sqw model with hamiltonians is the one - dimensional lattice ( or chain ) as in fig .
[ 1dlattice ] .
if we wish to use the minimum number of tessellations that cover all vertices and edges , the only choice are the two tesselations represented in the figure and correspond to two alternate interactions between first neighbors .
therefore the evolution operator in the one - dimensional case with @xmath58 is given by @xmath59 where @xmath60 and @xmath61 for the sake of simplicity , we choose @xmath49 and @xmath50 to be independent from @xmath62 .
@xmath54 is defined on hilbert space @xmath25 , whose computational basis is @xmath63 . while the diagonal forms of the hamiltonians ( [ h0 ] ) and ( [ h1 ] ) with @xmath64-eigenvectors ( [ eq : genual_0 ] ) and ( [ eq : genual_1 ] ) , respectively , are more appropriate to the qw related computations
, one can not immediately see the connections to interactions energies that they usually represent . for actual implementations , it is more convenient to write down it in terms of bosonic operators as @xmath65 in that form the first term represents the occupations of each site and the second one represents hopping hamiltonians .
note that since the qw models considered here are single particles quantum walks , the corresponding picture in terms of hamiltonians ( [ h00 ] ) and ( [ h11 ] ) implementation is to consider a single excitation in the encoding physical system .
the joint hamiltonian @xmath66 describes a large number of physical systems , from cold atoms trapped in optical lattices @xcite to a linear array of electromechanical resonators @xcite .
however the alternated action of the two local unitary operators in ( [ unit ] ) requires that the hamiltonians @xmath3 and @xmath4 be applied independently .
this requires a more involved process of alternating interactions in the system , which demands an external control particular to each physical system .
a proposal on how to implement it in a one dimensional array of coupled superconducting transmission line resonators is discussed elsewhere @xcite . to start our analysis , in fig .
[ fig : sqwwh_graph2 ] we show the probability distribution for the 1d sqw with hamiltonians ( [ h0 ] ) and ( [ h1 ] ) after 60 steps with parameters @xmath67 , @xmath68 , and @xmath69 .
the initial condition assumed was @xmath70 .
a quantum walk with those parameters was analyzed by ref .
note the typical profile , which is similar to the coined qw , but certainly not to the continuous - time qw @xcite .
, @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and initial condition @xmath70 . ]
in order to find the spectral decomposition of the evolution operator , we perform a basis change that takes advantage of the system symmetries .
let us define the fourier basis by the vectors @xmath71 where @xmath72 $ ] .
for a fixed @xmath73 , those vectors define a plane that is invariant under the action of the evolution operator , which is confirmed by the following results : @xmath74 where @xmath75 the analysis of the dynamics can be reduced to a two - dimensional subspace of @xmath25 by defining a reduced evolution operator @xmath76.\ ] ] @xmath77 is unitary since @xmath78 a vector in this subspace is mapped to hilbert space @xmath25 after multiplying its first entry by @xmath79 and its second entry by @xmath80 .
the eigenvalues of @xmath77 ( the same of @xmath54 ) are @xmath81 , where @xmath82 note that @xmath83 in ( [ eq : a ] ) depends on @xmath73 , as well as others parameters .
the non - trivial eigenvectors of @xmath77 are @xmath84 where @xmath85 the eigenvectors of the evolution operator @xmath54 associated with eigenvalues @xmath81 are @xmath86 and we can write @xmath87 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and initial condition @xmath88 . ]
if we take @xmath89 as the initial condition , the quantum walk state at time @xmath90 is given by @xmath91 where @xmath92 and @xmath93 the probability distribution is obtained after calculating @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
the probability distribution would not be symmetric in this case ( localized initial condition ) , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : sqwwh_graph2a ] . those results
extend the corresponding ones obtained in ref .
@xcite .
the results of ref .
@xcite can be extended in order to include parameter @xmath15 of the sqw with hamiltonians .
the asymptotic expression for the odd moments with initial condition @xmath89 is @xmath96^{2n}dk+o(t^{2n-2}),\ ] ] and for the even moments is @xmath97 the square of the standard deviation is @xmath98 for @xmath99 and @xmath69 , it simplifies asymptotically to @xmath100 as function of @xmath15 and @xmath49 .
the value of @xmath101 at the center of the plot is zero . ]
[ fig : sqwwh_graph5 ] shows the plot of @xmath101 as function of @xmath15 and @xmath49 .
the maximum value of @xmath101 is @xmath102 , which is achieved for the points on a circle with center at @xmath103 and radius @xmath104 , for instance , @xmath105 when @xmath106 and @xmath68 . when @xmath68 and @xmath69 , @xmath3 is the direct sum of pauli @xmath13 matrices
@xmath107 , \ ] ] likewise @xmath4 , with a diagonal shift of one entry .
any flip - flop coined qw on a graph @xmath21 with a coin operator of the form @xmath108 , where @xmath3 is an orthogonal reflection of @xmath24 , is equivalent to a sqw with hamiltonians on a larger graph @xmath109 .
the procedure to obtain @xmath109 is described in ref .
we briefly review it in the next paragraph . and a degree-3 vertex @xmath110 .
edge @xmath111 has label @xmath112 .
the other edges have labels @xmath113 to @xmath114 . ]
, one has to replace a degree-@xmath115 vertex by a @xmath115-clique .
the vertex labels of the enlarged graph have the form `` @xmath116 '' , where @xmath0 is the label of the vertex in the original graph and @xmath117 is the edge incident on @xmath0 . ] let @xmath118 be the vertex labels and let @xmath119 be the edge labels of graph @xmath24 .
the action of the flip - flop shift operator on vectors of the computational basis associated with @xmath24 is @xmath120 where @xmath0 and @xmath110 are adjacent and @xmath112 is the label of the edge @xmath111 as shown in fig .
[ fig : sqwwh_graph6a ] . @xmath121 as @xmath122 for all edges @xmath111 .
the @xmath64-eigenvectors are @xmath123 and there is a @xmath64-eigenvector for each edge @xmath111 .
we are assuming that @xmath124 .
then @xmath125 @xmath126 induces the red polygons of fig .
[ fig : sqwwh_graph6b ] . after replacing each degree-@xmath115 vertex of @xmath24 by a @xmath115-clique
, we obtain graph @xmath127 of fig .
[ fig : sqwwh_graph6b ] on which the equivalent sqw is defined .
the degree-5 vertex is converted into a 5-clique and the degree-3 vertex is converted into a 3-clique .
the vertex labels of @xmath127 have the form `` @xmath116 '' , where @xmath0 is the label of the vertex in the original graph and @xmath117 is the edge incident on @xmath0 . with this notation , it is straightforward to check that the unitary and hermitian operator that induces the red tessellation is @xmath126 given by eq .
( [ s ] ) , when we use vectors in uniform superposition .
now , we can cast the evolution operator in the form demanded by the staggered model with hamiltonians . since @xmath128
, the shift operator can be put in the form e@xmath129 with @xmath130 and @xmath131 modulo a global phase .
if the coin is @xmath108 and @xmath3 is an orthogonal reflection then any flip - flop coined qw on @xmath24 is equivalent to a sqw on @xmath127 with evolution operator @xmath132 operator @xmath3 induces the blue tessellation depicted in fig . [ fig : sqwwh_graph6b ] .
it is known that grover s algorithm @xcite can be described as a coined qw on the complete graph using a flip - flop shift operator and the grover coin @xcite .
therefore , grover s algorithm can also be reproduced by the sqw model @xcite .
extensions of grover s algorithm analyzed by long _ et al . _
@xcite and hyer @xcite use operator @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the unit uniform superposition of the computational basis and @xmath135 is an angle , in place of the usual grover operator @xmath136 .
this kind of extension can be reproduced by sqw model with hamiltonians because @xmath108 when @xmath3 is given by eq .
( [ h_0 ] ) can be written as @xmath137 modulo a global phase .
we can choose values for @xmath5 and @xmath28 that reproduce eq .
( [ new_form ] ) .
we have introduced an extension of the standard staggered qw model by using orthogonal reflections as hamiltonians .
orthogonal reflections are local unitary operators in the sense that they respect the connections represented by the edges of a graph . besides , orthogonal reflections are hermitian by definition .
this means that if @xmath3 is an orthogonal reflection of a graph @xmath24 , then @xmath1 is a local unitary operator associated with @xmath24 . in order to define a nontrivial evolution operator ,
we need to employ a second orthogonal reflection @xmath4 of @xmath24 .
the generic form of the evolution operator of the sqw with hamiltonians for 2-tessellable graphs is @xmath138 , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are angles .
this form is fitted for physical implementations in many physical systems , such as , cold atoms trapped in optical lattices @xcite and arrays of electromechanical resonators @xcite .
we have obtained the wave function of sqws with hamiltonians on the line and analyzed the standard deviation of the probability distribution . for a localized initial condition at the origin ,
the maximum spread of the probability distribution for an evolution operator of the form @xmath139 is obtained when @xmath106 .
we have also characterized the class of coined qws that are included in the sqw model with hamiltonians and we have described how to convert those coined qws on a graph @xmath24 into their equivalent formulation in terms of sqws on an extended graph obtained from @xmath24 by replacing degree-@xmath115 vertices into @xmath115-cliques . as a last remark , we call attention that recently it was shown numerically that searching one marked vertex using the original sqw on the two - dimensional square lattice has no speedup compared to classical search using random walks @xcite . on the other hand ,
the sqw with hamiltonians with @xmath67 is able to find the marked vertex after @xmath140 steps at least as fast as the equivalent algorithm using coined quantum walks @xcite .
rp acknowledges financial support from faperj ( grant n. e-26/102.350/2013 ) and cnpq ( grants n. 303406/2015 - 1 , 474143/2013 - 9 ) and also acknowledges useful discussions with pascal philipp and stefan boettcher .
jkm acknowledges financial support from cnpq grant pdj 165941/2014 - 6 .
mco acknowledges support by fapesp through the research center in optics and photonics ( cepof ) and by cnpq .
dorit aharonov , andris ambainis , julia kempe , and umesh vazirani .
quantum walks on graphs . in _ proceedings of the thirty - third annual acm symposium on theory of computing _ , stoc 01 , pages 5059 , new york , ny , usa , 2001 .
acm .
j. lozada - vera , a. carrillo , o. p. de
s neto , j. khatibi moqadam , m. d. lahaye , and m. c. de oliveira .
quantum simulation of the anderson hamiltonian with an array of coupled nanoresonators : delocalization and thermalization effects .
, 3(9):116 , 2016 . | quantum walks are recognizably useful for the development of new quantum algorithms , as well as for the investigation of several physical phenomena in quantum systems
. actual implementations of quantum walks face technological difficulties similar to the ones for quantum computers , though .
therefore , there is a strong motivation to develop new quantum - walk models which might be easier to implement . in this work
, we present an extension of the staggered quantum walk model that is fitted for physical implementations in terms of time - independent hamiltonians .
we demonstrate that this class of quantum walk includes the entire class of staggered quantum walk model , szegedy s model , and an important subset of the coined model . |
there is a strong observational evidence that active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , x - ray transients and gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) are associated with accretion onto black holes , and that these sources are able to form collimated , ultrarelativistic flows ( relativistic jets ) .
the exact mechanisms to explain the production of jets are still uncertain , but they probably involve the interaction between a spinning black hole , the accretion disk and electromagnetic fields in strong gravitational fields ( see , for example , @xcite-@xcite and references therein ) . thus , a reasonably accurate general relativistic model of an agn would require an exact solution of einstein - maxwell field equations that describes a superposition of a kerr black hole with a stationary disk and electromagnetic fields .
not even an exact solution of a stationary black hole - disk system has been found yet .
solutions for static thin disks without radial pressure were first studied by bonnor and sackfield @xcite , and morgan and morgan @xcite , and with radial pressure by morgan and morgan @xcite .
several classes of exact solutions of the einstein field equations corresponding to static thin disks with or without radial pressure have been obtained by different authors @xcite-@xcite .
thin rotating disks were considered in @xcite .
perfect fluid disks with halos @xcite and charged perfect fluid disks @xcite were also studied , whereas thick relativistic disks were reported in @xcite .
several solutions of the einstein equations coupled to matter that represent disks has also been studied by the jena group @xcite-@xcite .
the static superposition of a disk and a black hole was first considered by lemos and letelier @xcite .
zellerin and semerk @xcite found a stationary metric that reduces to the superposition of a disk and a black hole in the static limit and thus may represent a stationary disk - black hole system .
the analysis of their solution is complicated by the fact that the metric functions can not be analytically computed . for a survey on self gravitating relativistic thin disks ,
see for instance @xcite .
the aim of this paper is to consider the gravitational field of an agn through a simple model : the _ static _ superposition of a black hole with a chazy - curzon disk and two rods placed on the symmetry axis , which will represent jets .
our principal interest here is to see how the presence of the rods affect the matter properties and stability of the disk .
the article is divided as follows . in sec .
[ sec_disk ] we review the `` displace , cut and reflect '' method used to construct thin disks from a known solution of einstein field equations in weyl coordinates .
[ sec_sup ] summarizes the formalism to superpose thin disks and other weyl solutions .
[ sec_sol ] discusses schwarzschild solution and the metric of a finite rod in weyl coordinates . in sec .
[ sec_model ] the results of sec . [ sec_sup ] and [ sec_sol ] are then applied to construct the superposition of disk , black hole and rods and the resulting energy - momentum tensor . in sec .
[ sec_osc ] the disk stability is studied through small horizontal and vertical oscillations about equatorial circular geodesics . in sec .
[ sec_orbits ] some geodesic orbits for the superposed metric are numerically calculated .
finally , sec .
[ sec_discuss ] is devoted to discussion of the results .
we take units such that @xmath0 .
in absense of matter , the general metric for a static axially symmetric spacetime in weyl s canonical coordinates @xmath1 is given by @xmath2 where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are functions of @xmath5 and @xmath6 only .
einstein vacuum field equations for the metric eq .
( [ eq_weyl_metric ] ) yield @xcite @xmath7=\frac{1}{2}\int r \left [ ( \phi_{,r}^2-\phi_{,z}^2)\mathrm{d}r+ 2\phi_{,r}\phi_{,z}\mathrm{d}z \right ] \label{eq_eins2 } \mbox{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] given a solution of eq .
( [ eq_eins1])-([eq_eins2 ] ) , one can construct a thin disk by using the well known `` displace , cut and reflect '' method , due to kuzmin @xcite .
first , a surface @xmath8 is chosen so that it divides the usual space in two parts : one with no singularities or sources , and the other with them .
then the part of the space with singularities or sources is disregarded . at last
, the surface is used to make an inversion of the nonsingular part of the space .
the result will be a space with a singularity that is a delta function with support on @xmath9 .
the method is mathematically equivalent to make a transformation @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a constant . the application of the formalism of distributions in curved spacetimes to the weyl metric eq .
( [ eq_weyl_metric ] ) is exposed in @xcite .
one finds that the components of the distributional energy - momentum tensor @xmath12 $ ] on the disk are @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the dirac distribution with support on the disk and is understood that @xmath15 .
the `` true '' energy density and azimuthal pressure are , respectively , @xmath16 to explain the disk stability in absence of radial pressure , one may assume the counterrotating hypothesis , where the particles on the disk move in such a way that there are as many particles moving in clockwise as in counterckockwise direction .
the velocity @xmath17 of counterrotation of the particles in the disk is given by @xcite @xmath18 if @xmath19 , the particles travel at sublumial velocities .
the specific angular momentum @xmath20 of particles on the disk moving in circular orbits along geodesics reads @xmath21 the stability of circular orbits on the disk plane can be determined with an extension of rayleigh criteria of stability of a fluid at rest in a gravitational field : @xmath22 @xcite .
using eq .
( [ eq_ang_mom ] ) this is equivalent to @xmath23
an important property of the weyl metric eq .
( [ eq_weyl_metric ] ) is that the field equation ( [ eq_eins1 ] ) for the potential @xmath3 is the laplace equation in cylindrical coordinates .
since laplace s equation is linear , if @xmath24 and @xmath25 are solutions , then the superposition @xmath26 is also a solution . the other metric function eq .
( [ eq_eins2 ] ) is nonlinear , and so can not be superposed .
but one can show that the relation @xmath27=\nu[\phi_1]+\nu[\phi_2]+2\nu[\phi_1,\phi_2 ] \mbox{,}\ ] ] where @xmath28=\frac{1}{2}\int r[(\phi_{1,r}\phi_{2,r}-\phi_{1,z } \phi_{2,z})\mathrm{d}r+(\phi_{1,r}\phi_{2,z}+\phi_{1,z}\phi_{2,r})\mathrm{d}z ] \mbox{,}\ ] ] holds .
other useful relations are given in @xcite .
the energy - momentum tensor of the combined system disk and black hole has been computed by lemos and letelier @xcite .
let @xmath29 and @xmath30 be the metric potentials of the disk and of the black hole , respectively .
then the components @xmath12 $ ] of the superposition are @xmath31 \phi_{d , z } \delta(z ) \mbox { , } \label{eq_ttt_sup } \\
t^{\varphi}{}_{\varphi } & = e^{\phi_{d}+\phi_{bh}-\nu}r(\phi_{d}+\phi_{bh})_{,r } \phi_{d , z } \delta(z ) \mbox { , } \label{eq_tphi_sup } \\
t^r{}_r & = t^z{}_z=0 \mbox{,}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath32 $ ] , and again @xmath33 . the `` true '' energy density and azimuthal pressure read @xmath34 eq . ( [ eq_ttt_sup])-([eq_tphi_sup ] ) show that the potential of the black hole interacts with the disk and changes its matter properties .
although eq .
( [ eq_ttt_sup])-([eq_p_sup ] ) have been derived for superposition of disk and black hole , they are also valid when the potential function @xmath30 is a sum of other weyl solutions , like the superposition of a black hole and rods .
the schwarzschild black hole metric function @xmath30 in weyl coordinates is given by @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the function @xmath38 can be related to the newtonian potential @xmath39 by @xmath40 thus , the metric potential @xmath41 of a finite rod of linear mass density @xmath42 lying on the @xmath6 axis and located along @xmath43 $ ] is @xmath44 \mbox{.}\ ] ] the calculation of the other metric function @xmath4 for eq .
( [ eq_sch1 ] ) , ( [ eq_bar1 ] ) and later for the superposed metric , is considerably simplified when one defines the following @xmath45 function @xmath46 where @xmath47 is an arbitrary constant .
this function is a natural consequence of the formalism of the inverse scattering method @xcite .
( [ eq_sch1 ] ) and ( [ eq_bar1 ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath48 where we defined @xmath49 on using eq .
( [ eq_nu_rel1 ] ) @xmath50=\nu[\ln \mu_i]+\nu[\ln \mu_j]-2\nu[\ln \mu_i,\ln \mu_j ] \mbox{;}\ ] ] the result @xmath51=\ln ( \mu_i-\mu_j ) \mbox{,}\ ] ] which also follows from the inverse scattering method ; and the identity @xmath52 one obtains following expressions for the metric function @xmath4 @xmath53 \mbox { , } \label{eq_nu_bh}\\ \nu_{r } & = 4\lambda^2 \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_3 \mu_4)^2}{(r^2+\mu_3 ^ 2)(r^2+\mu_4 ^ 2 ) } \right ] \mbox{. } \label{eq_nu_rod}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
we now consider the superposition illustrated in fig .
[ fig_1 ] : a black hole with mass @xmath54 whose center is on @xmath9 , two rods with equal mass density @xmath42 , each one with mass @xmath55 located along @xmath56 $ ] and @xmath43 $ ] on the @xmath6 axis , and a disk on the plane @xmath9 constructed with the `` displace , cut and reflect method '' from the chazy - curzon solution with mass @xmath57 , whose singularity lies on @xmath58 : @xmath59 it should be remembered that in weyl coordinates a black hole with mass @xmath54 is represented by a rod with length @xmath60 , thus in fig .
[ fig_1 ] we put a dotted circle around the rod in the middle . , two rods and a chazy - curzon disk on the plane @xmath9 . ]
such a configuration is not gravitationally stable : a consequence of the nonlinearity of eq .
( [ eq_eins2 ] ) is the appearence of gravitationally inert singular structures like struts between the rods and the black hole that keeps them appart ; also in the superposition of the disk with the black hole , superlumial regions @xmath61 exist because there is matter up to the event horizon .
the metric function @xmath3 of the superposition can be expressed as @xmath62 with @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
now we consider the case when both rods just touch the horizon of the black hole , that is , when @xmath65 .
then @xmath66 and @xmath67 . from eq . ( [ eq_ttt_sup])-([eq_tphi_sup ] ) and eq .
( [ eq_vel ] ) , we get following conditions : @xmath68 \notag \\ & + 2\lambda ( \tilde{r}^2+\tilde{a}^2)^{3/2 } \left ( \sqrt{\tilde{r}^2+\tilde{c}_2 ^ 2 } -\tilde{c}_2\sqrt{1+\tilde{r}^2 }
\right ) > 0 \mbox { , } \label{eq_cond_sigma } \\ p & > 0 \rightarrow \sqrt{\tilde{r}^2+\tilde{c}_2 ^ 2 } \left[\alpha \tilde{r}^2\sqrt{1+\tilde{r}^2 } + ( \tilde{r}^2+\tilde{a}^2)^{3/2 } \right ] \notag \\ & -2\lambda ( \tilde{r}^2+\tilde{a}^2)^{3/2 } \left ( \sqrt{\tilde{r}^2+\tilde{c}_2 ^ 2 } -\tilde{c}_2\sqrt{1+\tilde{r}^2 } \right ) > 0 \mbox { , } \label{eq_cond_p } \\
v^2 & < 1 \rightarrow \sqrt{\tilde{r}^2+\tilde{c}_2 ^ 2 } \left [ 2\alpha \tilde{r}^2\sqrt{1+\tilde{r}^2 } + ( \tilde{r}^2+\tilde{a}^2)^{3/2}(2-\sqrt{1+\tilde{r}^2 } ) \right ] \notag \\ & -4\lambda ( \tilde{r}^2+\tilde{a}^2)^{3/2 } \left(\sqrt{\tilde{r}^2+\tilde{c}_2 ^ 2}-\tilde{c}_2\sqrt{1+\tilde{r}^2 } \right ) < 0 \mbox { , } \label{eq_cond_v}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
the conditions imposed are that of weak energy @xmath75 , azimuthal pressure @xmath76 and sublumial velocity @xmath77 of counterrotation of particles on the disk . for @xmath78 ,
all three conditions are satisfied . in the regions where @xmath19
, the weak energy condition is always satisfied , as can be seen by inequalities ( [ eq_cond_sigma ] ) and ( [ eq_cond_v ] ) .
( dotted curves ) and of @xmath79 ( solid curves ) for the chazy - curzon disk in presence of a black hole and two rods .
we keep the mass of each rod constant @xmath80 and vary its mass density @xmath42 . in ( a)-(b )
we take , respectively , @xmath81 and @xmath82.,title="fig : " ] + ( dotted curves ) and of @xmath79 ( solid curves ) for the chazy - curzon disk in presence of a black hole and two rods .
we keep the mass of each rod constant @xmath80 and vary its mass density @xmath42 . in ( a)-(b )
we take , respectively , @xmath81 and @xmath82.,title="fig : " ] fig .
[ fig_2](a)-(c ) shows curves of @xmath83 ( dotted curves ) and of @xmath79 ( solid curves ) as function of @xmath42 and @xmath84 for three different values of @xmath85 .
the mass of each rod is kept constant @xmath80 and the cut parameter takes values @xmath81 and @xmath82 in ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively . at the right of each dotted curve we have @xmath19 and the unstable regions of the disk appear between the curves of @xmath79 .
we note that in general with increasing mass of the disk and smaller length of the rods , the disk becomes more unstable and the regions of superlumial velocity also increase .
there is , however , an interval of values for the rod s mass density where the zone of stability is increased , as can be seen in the lower part of the curve @xmath79 for @xmath86 in fig .
[ fig_2](a ) .
this is probably due to the prolate quadrupole moment of the rods , which scale as @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is their length .
thus , for larger rods , the effect of prolate deformations may overwhelm the effect of the oblate quadrupole moment of the disk , and increase stability ( see @xcite for a detailed discussion of the effect of quadrupolar fields on the stability of circular orbits ) .
( dotted curves ) and of @xmath79 ( solid curves ) for the chazy - curzon disk in presence of a black hole and two rods .
we keep the length of each rod constant @xmath89 and vary its mass density @xmath42 ( or equivalent , its mass ) . in ( a)-(b ) we take , respectively , @xmath81 and @xmath82.,title="fig : " ] + ( dotted curves ) and of @xmath79 ( solid curves ) for the chazy - curzon disk in presence of a black hole and two rods .
we keep the length of each rod constant @xmath89 and vary its mass density @xmath42 ( or equivalent , its mass ) . in ( a)-(b )
we take , respectively , @xmath81 and @xmath82.,title="fig : " ] fig .
[ fig_3](a)-(b ) shows again curves of @xmath83 ( dotted curves ) and of @xmath79 ( solid curves ) as function of @xmath42 and @xmath84 for three different values of @xmath85 , but now the length of each rod is kept constant @xmath90 and the cut parameter takes values @xmath81 and @xmath82 in ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively . with increasing masses of the disk and of the rods , the zones of instability and superlumial velocity of the disk are enhanced . in fig .
[ fig_4 ] ( a)-(d ) we plot the energy density @xmath91 , azimuthal pressure @xmath92 , square of the counterrotating velocity @xmath17 and specific angular momentum @xmath93 as functions of @xmath84 for @xmath82 , @xmath94 , @xmath89 ( constant length ) and different values of the rod s linear mass density @xmath42 .
the curves were computed using eq .
( [ eq_ttt_sup])-([eq_p_sup ] ) , eq .
( [ eq_vel])-([eq_ang_mom ] ) and eq .
( [ eq_phi_sup ] ) .
the expression for the corresponding metric function @xmath4 is given in the appendix .
energy density is lowered for a fixed radius as the rods become more massive , while pressure is slightly increased . velocity of counterrotation and specific angular momentum are enhanced by increasing mass of the rods , as can also be deduced from fig . [
fig_3](b ) . ,
( b ) azimuthal pressure @xmath95 ,
( c ) counterrotating velocity @xmath96 and ( d ) specific angular momentum @xmath97 as functions of @xmath84 for @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath89 and three different values for the rod s mass density @xmath42.,title="fig : " ] , ( b ) azimuthal pressure @xmath95 , ( c ) counterrotating velocity @xmath96 and ( d ) specific angular momentum @xmath97 as functions of @xmath84 for @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath89 and three different values for the rod s mass density @xmath42.,title="fig : " ] + , ( b ) azimuthal pressure @xmath95 , ( c ) counterrotating velocity @xmath96 and ( d ) specific angular momentum @xmath97 as functions of @xmath84 for @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath89 and three different values for the rod s mass density @xmath42.,title="fig : " ] , ( b ) azimuthal pressure @xmath95 , ( c ) counterrotating velocity @xmath96 and ( d ) specific angular momentum @xmath97 as functions of @xmath84 for @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath89 and three different values for the rod s mass density @xmath42.,title="fig : " ]
it is interesting to study the disk stability through the computation of horizontal ( epicyclic ) and vertical oscillation frequencies from perturbations of equatorial circular geodesics .
semerk and ek @xcite have done such calculations for the superposition of a schwarzschild black hole with the lemos - letelier disk .
they found that heavier disks are more stable with respect to horizontal perturbations near their inner rims , whereas they are less stable with respect to vertical perturbations . for astrophysical relevance , it is important to determine not only the stability of circular motion on the disk plane , but also stability in the vertical direction . using the perturbed equations for equatorial circular geodesics , the epicyclic frequency with respect to infinity @xmath98 and the vertical oscillation frequency with respect to infinity @xmath99 for the metric ( [ eq_weyl_metric ] )
are given by ( see @xcite for a detailed deduction ) @xmath100 \mbox{. } \label{eq_osc_v}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ eq_osc_v ] ) the function @xmath101 is obtained from the limit @xmath102 and @xmath103 follows from eq .
( [ eq_eins1 ] ) .
stable horizontal and vertical orbits are only possible where @xmath104 and @xmath105 , respectively . note that condition @xmath104 is equivalent to condition ( [ eq_stab ] ) which follows from rayleigh stability criteria .
we compute first the frequencies for an isolated chazy - curzon disk , since is seems that such a calculation has not been done before for this class of disks . in fig .
[ fig_5](a ) we plot the epicyclic frequency as functions of radius @xmath106 and cut parameter @xmath107 . for @xmath108
the disks always are stable and the epicyclic frequency is lowered for less relativistic disks .
highly relativistic disks ( curve with @xmath109 for example ) develop annular regions of instability .
the curves of vertical oscillation frequencies are depicted in fig .
[ fig_5](b ) .
we note that in this case highly relativistic disks are more stable in the vertical direction . in eq .
( [ eq_osc_v ] ) the term with @xmath101 is small compared to @xmath103 , thus if we consider only @xmath110 we note that vertical oscillations are zero at @xmath111 , so the regions of vertical stability are enlarged as the cut parameter @xmath11 is decreased . and ( b ) the vertical oscillation frequency @xmath112 for an isolated chazy - curzon disk.,title="fig : " ] + and ( b ) the vertical oscillation frequency @xmath112 for an isolated chazy - curzon disk.,title="fig : " ] now we consider the superposition of a curzon disk and a black hole _ without _ rods .
[ fig_6 ] shows curves of ( a ) horizontal @xmath113 and ( b ) vertical @xmath114 oscillation frequencies of the disk with @xmath94 and four different values of the `` cut '' parameter @xmath115 .
now we always have regions of horizontal instability that begin at the innermost stable circular orbit and decrease for less relativistic disks . with respect to vertical oscillations , it is seen from fig .
[ fig_6](b ) that there are no regions of vertical instabilities .
thus one can conclude that the black hole desestabilizes the curzon disk in the horizontal direction , whereas the opposite is true for the vertical direction . , @xmath81 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118.,title="fig : " ] + , @xmath81 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118.,title="fig : " ] , @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121.,title="fig : " ] + , @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath119 , @xmath120 and @xmath121.,title="fig : " ] in fig .
[ fig_7](a)-(b ) we graph again @xmath113 and @xmath114 , respectively , for the chazy - curzon disk with black hole and rods , with their length fixed and vary the linear mass density @xmath42 . as expected from the curves of fig .
[ fig_3](b ) , the more massive the rods , the larger are the disk s unstable regions in the horizontal direction .
the rods also tend to lower the vertical oscillation frequencies near the disk s center , but unstable regions do not appear .
in the previous section perturbations of equatorial circular geodesics were used to discuss disk stability for the system disk + black hole + rods .
now we solve numerically the geodesic equations of motion @xmath122 for metric eq .
( [ eq_weyl_metric ] ) , where @xmath123 are the christoffel symbols and the dot denote differentiation with respect to the proper time . defining the orthonormal tetrad @xmath124 where @xmath125 the tetrad components of the four - velocity @xmath126 read @xmath127 with @xmath128 .
the specific energy and angular momentum of the test particle are @xmath129 as initial conditions we take a position at radius @xmath130 on the disk s plane and components of the four - velocity @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is equal to the tangential velocity of circular orbits at radius @xmath130 .
we choose initial radii such that the energy is slightly higher than the escape energy .
[ fig_8](a)-(b ) shows the orbits of particles in the presence of the black hole and curzon disk without rods .
the parameters are @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 and different initial angles @xmath135 . fig .
[ fig_8](a ) is a projection of the orbits on the @xmath136 plane .
the coordinates have been transformed from weyl to schwarzschild coordinates @xmath137 via the relations @xmath138 and then to @xmath139 , @xmath140 and @xmath141 . in fig .
[ fig_9](a)-(d ) we have computed some orbits now with the rods .
the parameters are @xmath94 , @xmath82 , @xmath142 , @xmath143 , @xmath89 , @xmath134 and different initial angles @xmath135 .
the orbit with @xmath144 has been placed in a separate graph for better visualization . for low initial angles ,
the rods have little effect on the trajectories , but this is not true as the particles approach the @xmath6 axis . the orbit in fig .
[ fig_9](c)-(d ) even suggests that we can expect chaotic behaviour for orbits that pass very near the rods .
in fact , it has been shown @xcite that prolate quadrupole deformations can introduce chaotic motion of geodesic test particles . in the oblate case ,
only regular motion was found . , @xmath82 , @xmath134 , @xmath133 .
( a ) projection on the @xmath136 plane of the curves in ( b).,title="fig : " ] + , @xmath82 , @xmath134 , @xmath133 . ( a ) projection on the @xmath136 plane of the curves in ( b).,title="fig : " ] , @xmath82 , @xmath143 , @xmath89 , @xmath134 @xmath142 .
the curve for @xmath144 is displayed in ( c ) and ( d ) for better visualization.,title="fig : " ] , @xmath82 , @xmath143 , @xmath89 , @xmath134 @xmath142 .
the curve for @xmath144 is displayed in ( c ) and ( d ) for better visualization.,title="fig : " ] + , @xmath82 , @xmath143 , @xmath89 , @xmath134 @xmath142 .
the curve for @xmath144 is displayed in ( c ) and ( d ) for better visualization.,title="fig : " ] , @xmath82 , @xmath143 , @xmath89 , @xmath134 @xmath142 .
the curve for @xmath144 is displayed in ( c ) and ( d ) for better visualization.,title="fig : " ]
we presented a very simplified , although exact , general relativistic model of an active galactic nuclei based on a superposition of a schwarzschild black hole , a chazy - curzon disk and two rods placed on the symmetry axis , representing jets .
we found that the presence of the rods enhances the disk regions with superlumial velocities . using an extension of rayleigh criteria of stability
, it was found that in general the rods also increase the regions of instability , but when the rods are large and the disk s mass is low they can contribute to stabilize the disk .
also disk stability in the vertical direction was studied through perturbation of circular geodesics .
the rods contribute to lower the vertical oscillation frequencies near the disk s center .
some geodesic orbits calculated numerically for the system black hole + disk + rods show the possibility of chaotic trajectories near the rods .
the model here presented should be viewed as a first approach . as was stated in the introduction
, more realistic models of active galactic nuclei should incorporate rotation and electromagnetic fields .
however , the analysis of such a model would not be trivial , because of the large number of free parameters involved . * acknowledgments * d. v. thanks capes for financial support .
p. s. l. thanks cnpq and fapesp for financial support .
the metric function eq .
( [ eq_eins2 ] ) for the superposition of a black hole , two rods and a disk generated from chazy - curzon solution can be calculated as follows .
we rewrite potential eq .
( [ eq_phi_sup ] ) as @xmath145 where @xmath146 with @xmath147 and @xmath148 . in the limit
@xmath149 expression for @xmath150 reduces to the chazy - curzon disk eq .
( [ eq_curzon ] ) on @xmath151 .
thus all terms can be expressed as @xmath45 potentials .
using repeatedly properties ( [ eq_nu_rel2])-([eq_ident ] ) we get @xmath152=\nu [ \phi_{r1}]+\nu [ \phi_{bh}]+\nu [ \phi_{r2}]+\nu [ \phi_{d}^+ ] \notag \\ & + 2\nu [ \phi_{r1},\phi_{bh}]+2\nu [ \phi_{r1},\phi_{r2}]+ 2\nu [ \phi_{r1},\phi_{d}^+]+2\nu [ \phi_{bh},\phi_{r2 } ] \notag \\ & + 2\nu [ \phi_{bh},\phi_{d}^+]+2\nu [ \phi_{r2},\phi_{d}^+ ] \mbox { , } \label{eq_nu_sup}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath153= 4\lambda^2 \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_3 \mu_4)^2}{(r^2+\mu_3 ^ 2)(r^2+\mu_4 ^ 2 ) } \right ] \mbox { , } \\
\nu & [ \phi_{bh}]= \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_1 \mu_2)^2}{(r^2+\mu_1 ^ 2)(r^2+\mu_2 ^ 2 ) } \right ] \mbox { , } \\
\nu & [ \phi_{r2}]= 4\lambda^2 \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_5 \mu_6)^2}{(r^2+\mu_5 ^ 2)(r^2+\mu_6 ^ 2 ) } \right ] \mbox { , } \\
\nu & [ \phi_{d}^{+}]=-\frac{m^2r^2}{[r^2+(z+a)^2]^2 } \mbox { , } \\
\nu & [ \phi_{r1},\phi_{bh}]=2\lambda \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_1\mu_3)(r^2+\mu_2\mu_4)}{(r^2+\mu_1\mu_4)(r^2+\mu_2\mu_3 ) } \right ] \mbox { , }
\\ \nu & [ \phi_{r1},\phi_{r2}]=4\lambda^2 \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_3\mu_6)(r^2+\mu_4\mu_5)}{(r^2+\mu_3\mu_5)(r^2+\mu_4\mu_6 ) } \right ] \mbox { , } \\
\nu & [ \phi_{r1},\phi_{d}^+]=\frac{2\lambda m}{(a+c_1)(a+c_2)\sqrt{r^2+(a+z)^2 } } \left [ ( a+c_2)\sqrt{r^2+(c_1-z)^2 } \right . \notag \\ & \left .
-(a+c_1)\sqrt{r^2+(c_2-z)^2}+(c_1-c_2)\sqrt{r^2+(a+z)^2 } \right ] \mbox{,}\\ \nu & [ \phi_{bh},\phi_{r2}]=2\lambda \ln \left [ \frac{(r^2+\mu_1\mu_5)(r^2+\mu_2\mu_6)}{(r^2+\mu_1\mu_6)(r^2+\mu_2\mu_5 ) } \right ] \mbox { , } \\
\nu & [ \phi_{bh},\phi_{d}^+]=\frac{m}{(a^2-m^2)\sqrt{r^2+(a+z)^2 } } \left [ ( a+m)\sqrt{r^2+(m+z)^2 } \right . \notag \\ & \left .
-(a - m)\sqrt{r^2+(m - z)^2}-2m\sqrt{r^2+(a+z)^2}\right ] \mbox{,}\\ \nu & [ \phi_{r2},\phi_{d}^+ ] = \frac{2\lambda m}{(a - c_1)(a - c_2)\sqrt{r^2+(a+z)^2 } } \left [ ( c_2-a)\sqrt{r^2+(c_1+z)^2 } \right . \notag \\ & \left .
-(c_1-a)\sqrt{r^2+(c_2+z)^2}+(c_1-c_2)\sqrt{r^2+(a+z)^2 } \right ] \mbox{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the particular case @xmath65 @xmath154 and @xmath155 , and on @xmath9 , eq .
( [ eq_nu_sup ] ) simplifies to @xmath156= \notag \\ & \ln \left [ \frac{r^{16 \lambda^2 - 8\lambda+2}(r^2+\mu_1\mu_6)^{8\lambda^2 - 4\lambda}(r^2+\mu_2\mu_3)^{8\lambda^2 - 4\lambda } } { ( r^2+c_2 ^ 2)^{4\lambda^2}(r^2+m^2)^{4\lambda^2 - 4\lambda+1}(r^2+\mu_1\mu_3)^{8\lambda^2 - 4\lambda}(r^2+\mu_2\mu_6)^{8\lambda^2 - 4\lambda } } \right ] \notag \\ & -\frac{m^2r^2}{(r^2+a^2)^2}+\frac{8\lambda m}{(a^2-c_2 ^ 2)(a^2-m^2)\sqrt{r^2+a^2 } } \left [ c_2(a^2-m^2)\sqrt{r^2+c_2 ^ 2 } \right . \notag \\ & \left .
-m(a^2-c_2 ^ 2)\sqrt{r^2+m^2}+(m - c_2)(a^2+mc_2)\sqrt{r^2+a^2 } \right ] \notag \\ & + 4mm\frac{(\sqrt{r^2+m^2}-\sqrt{r^2+a^2})}{(a^2-m^2)\sqrt{r^2+a^2 } } \mbox{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] 99 w. kundt ( ed . ) , _ jets from stars and galactic nuclei _ , proceedings , lecture notes in physics , 471 , springer , 1996 .
j. h. krolik , _ active galactic nuclei : from the central black hole to the galactic environment _ , princeton university press , princeton , new jersey , 1999 .
r. d. blandford , _ prog .
* 143 * , 182 ( 2001 ) .
w. a. bonnor and a. sackfield , _ comm .
* 8 * , 338 ( 1968 ) .
t. morgan and l. morgan , _ phys .
rev . _ * 183 * , 1097 ( 1969 ) .
l. morgan and t. morgan , _ _ phys .
rev . d__**2 * * , 2756 ( 1970 ) .
d. lynden - bell and s. pineault , _ mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . _ * 185 * , 679 ( 1978 ) .
p. s. letelier and s. r. oliveira , _ j. math
_ * 28 * , 165 ( 1987 ) .
j. p. s. lemos , _ class .
quantum grav . _
_ 6 _ , 1219 ( 1989 ) .
s. lemos and p. s. letelier , _ class .
quantum grav . _ * 10 * , l75 ( 1993 ) .
j. bik , d. lynden - bell and j. katz , _ _ phys .
rev . d__**47 * * , 4334 ( 1993 ) .
j. bik , d. lynden - bell and c. pichon , _ mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . _ * 265 * , 126 ( 1993 ) .
s. lemos and p. s. letelier , _ _ phys
d__**49 * * , 5135 ( 1994 ) .
j. p. s. lemos and p. s. letelier , _ _ int .
phys . d__**5 * * , 53 ( 1996 ) .
g. gonzlez and o. a. espitia , _ phys .
d _ * 68 * , 104028 ( 2003 ) .
g. garca and g. gonzlez , _ phys .
d _ * 69 * , 124002 ( 2004 ) .
j. bik and t. ledvinka , _ phys .
lett . _ * 71 * , 1669 ( 1993 ) .
g. gonzlez and p. s. letelier , _ _ phys .
rev . d__**62 * * , 064025 ( 2000 ) .
d. vogt and p. s. letelier , _ _ phys .
d__**68 * * , 08410 ( 2003 ) .
d. vogt and p. s. letelier , _ exact relativistic static charged perfect fluid disks_. to appear in phys .
d. g. gonzlez and p. s. letelier , _ _ phys .
rev . d__**69 * * , 044013 ( 2004 ) . c. klein , _ class .
quantum grav . _
* 14 * , 2267 ( 1997 ) .
g. neugebauer and r. meinel , _ phys .
lett . _ * 75 * , 3046 ( 1995 ) . c. klein and o. richter ,
_ * 83 * , 2884 ( 1999 ) . c. klein ,
rev . d__**63 * * , 064033 ( 2001 ) .
j. frauendiener and c. klein , _ _ phys . rev . d__**63 * * , 084025 ( 2001 ) .
c. klein , _ _ phys .
rev . d__**65 * * , 084029 ( 2002 ) . c. klein , _ _ phys .
d__**68 * * , 027501 ( 2003 ) .
c. klein , _ ann .
* 12 * ( 10 ) , 599 ( 2003 ) .
t. zellerin and o. semerk , _ class .
quantum grav . _
* 17 * , 5103 ( 2000 ) .
v. karas , j. m. hur and o. semerk , _ class .
quantum grav . _
* 21 * , r1 ( 2004 ) .
h. weyl , _ ann .
_ * 54 * , 117 ( 1917 ) .
h. weyl , _ ann .
phys . _ * 59 * , 185 ( 1919 ) .
g. g. kuzmin , _ astron .
* 33 * , 27 ( 1956 ) .
j. p. s. lemos , _ mon . not .
r. astron .
_ * 230 * , 451 ( 1988 ) .
lord rayleigh , _ proc .
london a _ * 93 * , 148 ( 1917 ) ; see also l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , _ fluid mechanics _
( pergamon press , oxford , 1987 ) , 27
. v. a. belinsky and v. e. zakharov , _ zh . eksp .
_ * 75 * , 1955 ( 1978 ) [ sov
jetp * 48 * , 985 ( 1978 ) ] .
v. a. belinsky and v. e. zakharov , _ zh . eksp .
fiz . _ * 77 * , 3 ( 1979 ) [ sov . phys .
jetp * 50 * , 1 ( 1979 ) ] .
p. s. letelier , _ phys .
. d _ * 68 * , 104002 ( 2003 ) .
o. semerk and m. ek , _ publ .
soc . japan _ * 52 * , 1067 ( 2000 ) .
e. gueron and p. s. letelier , _ phys .
e _ * 63 * , 035201(r ) ( 2001 ) , * 66 * , 046611 ( 2002 ) . | an exact but simple general relativistic model for the gravitational field of active galactic nuclei is constructed , based on the superposition in weyl coordinates of a black hole , a chazy - curzon disk and two rods , which represent matter jets .
the influence of the rods on the matter properties of the disk and on its stability is examined .
we find that in general they contribute to destabilize the disk .
also the oscillation frequencies for perturbed circular geodesics on the disk are computed , and some geodesic orbits for the superposed metric are numerically calculated .
pacs numbers : 04.20.jb , 04.40.-b , 98.58 fd , 98.62 mw |
the standard model is the theory of strong and electroweak interactions : they are described in terms of quarks and leptons , the basic constituents of matter , and gauge bosons , which are the carriers of the fundamental forces .
this model is kept endlessly under inspection by comparing measured observables , such as couplings , masses , integral and differential cross sections or branching ratios , with the theory expectations .
the interplay between theory , which is continuosly improving its predictions , and experiments , whose measurements are carried out with increasing accuracy , consolidates the standard model itself . at the same time
, however , the standard model presents some drawbacks which open the road to new physics ; the forthcoming experiments at the large hadron collider will provide us with a unique chance to address these open problems .
we present in the following our perspective , from both theoretical and experimental viewpoints , on the current situation of the standard model and discuss some of its open issues , which call for new physics extensions .
quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) , an unbroken renormalizable theory based on the colour @xmath0 gauge symmetry , is a main part of the standard model of particle physics , as it is the theory of strong interactions . at present and future colliders , having full control of qcd
is fundamental , since events mediated by the strong interaction may mimic new physics signals .
because of asymptotic freedom , at high energies qcd observables can be computed as fixed - order expansions in the coupling constant @xmath1 ( perturbative qcd ) .
most cross sections have been computed at next - to - leading order ( nlo ) , whereas a few have been provided with next - to - next - to - leading order ( nnlo ) corrections as well .
in fact , as nlo corrections can be as large as a factor of two , leading - order ( lo ) results can just estimate the order of magnitude of an observable , with the nlo giving the first reliable prediction .
nnlo computations are nonetheless still necessary to reduce the theoretical uncertainty and weaken the dependence , _ e.g. _ , on the choice of parton distributions or fragmentation functions . among recent nlo calculations , we can mention the corrections to the production of three vector bosons at the lhc , namely @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 : the results on the transverse momentum @xmath6 spectrum show that the nlo has a relevant impact , indeed up to a factor of two , at small @xmath7 @xcite .
while fixed - order calculations are reliable enough to predict inclusive observables , such as total cross sections and widths , differential distributions can exhibit contributions where @xmath1 is multiplied by logarithmic coefficients , which become large for soft or collinear parton radiation .
resumming such terms is mandatory to describe exclusive quantities .
a remarkable example , where the interplay between fixed - order and resummed computation is crucial , is higgs - boson production in the @xmath8 channel , the dominant one at the lhc . the higgs rapidity and transverse momentum spectra
have been computed to nnlo accuracy ; moreover , the logarithms @xmath9 , large at small @xmath7 , where one is mostly sensitive to soft and collinear emissions , have been resummed in the next - to - next - to - leading logarithmic ( nnll ) approximation and included in the monte carlo code hqt @xcite . at low energy , however ,
one is faced with non - perturbative power corrections which can not be calculated in perturbative qcd .
in fact , one may address non - perturbative phenomena , such as hadronisation or underlying event , following several models and approaches , which are typically based on fits to experimental data .
as far as hadronisation is concerned , an alternative possibility consists in defining an effective strong coupling constant , free from the landau pole , which at large energy coincides with the standard coupling and at small energy includes non - perturbative power corrections .
studies have shown that the effective - coupling model , used along with a resummed calculation in the framework of perturbative fragmentation functions , yields a reasonable description of data on @xmath10- and @xmath11-flavoured hadrons at lep and sld , without tuning any parameter to such data @xcite .
another approach to non - perturbative qcd parametrises low - energy physics by means of the frozen coupling constant , defined as the integral of @xmath12 , where @xmath7 is some transverse momentum characteristic of the process , from zero to an upper limit , fitted to experimental data . in this way , one can , _ e.g. _ , study jet observables at the tevatron or the lhc , obtaining results in reasonable agreement with monte carlo generators , such as herwig or pythia , which implement their own models for hadronisation and underlying event , tuned to lep or tevatron data @xcite . along with the intensive applications of qcd to collider phenomenology
, work has been lately undertaken to construct a dual model of qcd , in the fashion of the ads / cft correspondence . in the framework of such a model , called holographic qcd , one can perform a linear fit of the experimental spectrum of @xmath13 mesons and give predictions for masses and decay constants of the @xmath14 glueballs @xcite .
the electroweak sector of the standard model is based on a @xmath15 symmetry , spontaneously broken into @xmath16 .
although the electroweak theory has been successfully tested in several experimental environments , the higgs boson , a crucial ingredient of the model , as it is responsible of the mass generation mechanism , has not been discovered yet .
there are , however , indications that a mass mechanism in the fashion of the higgs one should exist : for instance , the observed longitudinal polarisations of @xmath17 and @xmath18 bosons are indeed manifestations of a broken symmetry
. furthermore , the relation between their masses , namely @xmath19 , @xmath20 being the weinberg angle , valid up to very small radiative corrections , confirms the so - called custodial @xmath21 symmetry of the standard model and that the higgs boson has to be a weak - isospin doublet .
the lhc has been designed to solve the higgs problem , as it will be able to search for a standard model higgs boson , with a mass up to @xmath22 tev / c@xmath23 .
on the theory side , the lack of the higgs discovery has opened the road to other scenarios beyond the standard model , including the possibility that the higgs may not exist ( higgsless models ) or that it is an approximate goldstone boson of a broken global symmetry ( composite higgs models ) . also
, conceptual drawbacks , and especially the well - known hierarchy problem , namely the quadratical divergence of the higgs mass after radiative corrections , requiring fine tuning of several orders of magnitude , call for extensions of the standard model . among these ,
one of the most appealing and widely studied is surely supersymmetry , with its minimal formulation , the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) .
calculations and computing codes implementing supersymmetric processes have been available for a few years .
work has been lately carried out to provide such computations with radiative corrections , which are likely to have a remarkable impact at the lhc , and must be taken into account in any reliable analysis .
an example is given by the inclusion of nlo electroweak corrections to squark - antisquark pair production at hadron colliders , included in the monte carlo program prospino @xcite .
a common feature of several new physics models is that they predict the existence of new heavy vector bosons @xmath24 .
indeed , @xmath24 production in drell yan type processes , followed by leptonic decays , are among the first new physics signals possibly visible at the lhc .
@xcite discusses @xmath24 production in the so - called left - right symmetric free - fermionic model , which enlarges the gauge structure of the standard model by an extra heterotic - string inspired @xmath25 ( see @xcite for more details ) .
the free - fermionic model is constructed in such a way to suppress proton decay ; moreover , it is anomaly - free and consistent with the see - saw mechanism for neutrino masses , with family universality and yukawa - like couplings . within this model ,
@xmath24-production processes have been provided with qcd corrections to nnlo accuracy and should be visible at the lhc in the channels @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
although the electroweak precision tests seem to favour a possibly light higgs , as will be discussed in detail in the next section , it is nonetheless still possible to accommodate a heavy higgs beyond the standard model , since new physics effects can contribute to electroweak observables and make a heavy higgs consistent with present data .
an example is the so - called @xmath28susy model , based on an extension of the mssm , which predicts the existence of a heavy higgs @xmath29 , with mass , _
e.g. _ , 500 - 600 gev / c@xmath23 , mainly decaying , via @xmath30 , into a pair of lighter higgses @xmath31 , having mass @xmath32 200 - 300 gev / c@xmath23 . the properties of the lighter higgs @xmath31 are supposed to be pretty similar to the standard model one .
in fact , new physics contributions , _ e.g. _ to the oblique parameters @xmath33 and @xmath34 , make @xmath28susy still compatible with the constraints of the electroweak precision tests , which do seem to favour a rather light higgs , but only within the standard model and without assuming any new physics effect @xcite .
the @xmath28susy model is expected to be possibly observable at the lhc with 100 fb@xmath35 of integrated luminosity .
nevertheless , a possible alternative is to try to describe the electroweak interactions and solve the hierarchy problem in the framework of the so - called higgsless models . a process which has been thoroughly investigated is @xmath36 scattering : in the standard model , the exchange of an intermediate @xmath29 moderates the growth of the cross section for longitudinal boson scattering , and the requirement of unitarity sets the limit @xmath37 tev / c@xmath23 on the higgs mass . in higgsless models ,
the starting point is typically a @xmath38 chiral symmetry , spontaneously broken to @xmath39 : in this way , one or more new heavy vector bosons replace the higgs and delay the unitarity issue to a few tev / c@xmath23
. ref .
@xcite discusses the four - site higgsless model , which presents four new vector bosons , _
i.e. _ two charged @xmath40 and two neutral @xmath41 . at the lhc , @xmath42 and @xmath24 bosons can be produced in drell yan like processes , thus giving rise to visible resonances .
thanks to these new gauge bosons , the problem of unitarity violation is delayed to energy scales which are much higher than those actually probed at the lhc . unlike other higgsless models , such vector bosons are not ` fermiophobic ' , as the electroweak precision data do allow sizeable couplings with fermions . before closing this section , we point out that , for the sake of experimental analyses , any new physics model needs to be implemented in monte carlo generators , in order to account for multiple initial- and final - state radiation , hadronisation and underlying event .
in fact , work towards this direction has seen tremendous improvements in the latest few years . as for @xmath36 scattering
, it is worthwhile to mention the phantom code , which implements final states with six fermions , and includes the option of no intermediate higgs boson as well . by using phantom
, it will be possible to study @xmath36 scattering at the lhc and , in the phase of 100 fb@xmath35 luminosity , discriminate between , _
e.g. _ , a standard model scenario with a higgs of mass @xmath43 gev / c@xmath23 and the no - higgs case @xcite .
the standard model continues to be explored in different experiments based on accelerators or not .
the tevatron , colliding beams of protons and antiprotons with the currently highest energy of @xmath44 tev , represents a very favourable environment where to perform an extensive study of the major ingredients of the standard model , _
i.e. _ quarks and gauge bosons .
figure [ tev_proc ] shows , as an example , the production cross section at the tevatron for different categories of processes : the production of @xmath10-hadrons , @xmath17 and @xmath18 bosons , events containing the top quark , and finally the possible production of the higgs boson .
these and other processes are thouroughly studied by the two multi - purpose experiments operating at the tevatron , namely cdf and d . given the cross sections and the current integrated luminosity ( about 3 fb@xmath35 ) , the production of events containing @xmath17 or @xmath18 bosons is large , of the order of a few hundred thousand events .
also , even if the tevatron can not be really considered a top factory , the production of top quarks is quite abundant , with yields , so far , of about @xmath45 @xmath46 pairs and about @xmath47 single - top events per year . on the other hand ,
the production of the higgs boson is expected to be very rare at the tevatron and only the total integrated luminosity before the final shutdown , which is foreseen to be about 6 - 8 fb@xmath35 , along with a full exploration and combination of all possible channels , might enable to obtain some results .
the situation taking place at the tevatron will change drastically once the lhc , colliding beams of protons with @xmath48 tev , reaches its full power .
the production cross sections at lhc will increase , with respect to the tevatron ones , by one order of magnitude for @xmath49 production and by two orders for top production .
this , along with the higher - design instantaneous luminosity , will make lhc a real top - factory , and a promising environment for higgs discovery .
given the different yields of the processes described in figure [ tev_proc ] , it is suitable to divide the experimental studies of the major standard model processes into three subfields : @xmath49 physics , production of top quarks and searches for the standard model higgs boson .
in addition , we shall briefly discuss the exploration for new physics beyond the standard model .
the study of the @xmath49 boson production , within the standard model , is crucial because it can provide accurate tests of both electroweak and strong interactions ; qcd corrections to the production cross section are in fact available in the nnlo approximation .
cdf and d typically measure @xcite the production cross sections for leptonic final states , _
i.e. _ @xmath50 and @xmath51 , along with their ratio and the @xmath17-width @xmath52 .
the size of the samples also enables the study of differential distributions .
the measurement of the @xmath17 mass is very important , due to its link through radiative electroweak corrections to the higgs boson mass .
the mass is measured at the tevatron using the large sample of inclusive @xmath17 events , where the @xmath17 decays into @xmath53 or @xmath54 .
the @xmath17 transverse mass , @xmath55 , is reconstructed using the missing transverse energy , as a measure of @xmath56 , measuring the azimuthal angle @xmath57 between the lepton and the direction of the missing transverse energy , and is finally fitted to the expected distributions for different values of the @xmath17 mass . this measurement is a very delicate one , because it relies on a very precise calibration of the lepton momenta , and even the underlying event and additional @xmath58 interactions must be taken into account . with this technique , and using only @xmath59 of the luminosity currently available , cdf already reaches an accuracy better than what was measured by the various experiments at lep , thus improving the world average .
the study of diboson production @xmath36 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 is accessible in spite of the relatively low production cross sections ( respectively about 10 , 4 and 1 pb ) .
the investigation of these events is quite interesting not only in itself , but also because they represent relatively rare processes , with topologies similar to what can be expected for higgs boson production .
in fact , @xmath60 production has been clearly observed and there are first hints of @xmath61 evidence . at the lhc ,
given the high energy and luminosity , a large number of @xmath17 and @xmath18 events will be collected shortly after the machine turn - on , with a very clean leptonic signature . even before providing accurate measurements of @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 , and performing other tests of the electroweak theory , such events will be quite useful for calibration and alignment of the detector @xcite . once the detector is well understood , the study at the lhc of diboson production will become interesting to search for the higgs boson and for deviations from the standard model .
the top quark , discovered thirteen years ago at the tevatron , is the heaviest quark and , for this reason , it plays an important role in loop corrections to several electroweak observables .
indeed , together with the accurate measurement of the @xmath17 mass , the top - mass measurement constrains the mass of the higgs boson .
the measurement of the top quark mass with the highest precision is one of the major goals of cdf and d .
these two experiments already managed to measure the mass with a ( combined ) 1.4 gev / c@xmath23 precision , exceeding past expectations @xcite .
the goal now is to reach a precision smaller than 1 gev / c@xmath23 , before the tevatron definitive turn - off . as for the production cross section ,
the uncertainty reached by cdf and d is of the order of 10% ( per experiment ) and comparable to the theoretical uncertainties , thus enabling a test of nlo / nll predictions .
electroweak production of single top has a cross section about 1/3 of @xmath46 pair production .
therefore , it has been more difficult to find evidence for it and to measure the single - top cross section , which gives also a direct measurement of the cabibbo kobayashi
maskawa matrix element @xmath65 .
in addition to mass and cross sections , other top properties are measured , such as its charge , lifetime , decay branching ratios and the @xmath17 helicity in top decays @xmath66 .
also , due to its large mass , top quarks might couple to new physics at high energy scales and act as probes for these processes . for this reason ,
exotic decays or production mechanisms have been explored , but there is so far no evidence of heavy resonances or fourth - generation quarks
. the measurement at the lhc of the top quark properties will reach high statistical accuracy , given the large yield expected for top events .
precise measurements will require , however , a detailed modelling of the detector response , along with a good understanding of the sources of systematic uncertainty . top events themselves can be used , through _ in - situ _ calibration of the jet energy scale , to help reduce such uncertainties @xcite .
curve derived from high-@xmath67 precision electroweak measurements , performed at lep and by sld , cdf , and d , as a function of the higgs boson mass , assuming the standard model .
the yellow band on the left - hand side refers to the lep2 direct search limit . from @xcite.,width=226 ] curve derived from high-@xmath67 precision electroweak measurements , performed at lep and by sld , cdf , and d , as a function of the higgs boson mass , assuming the standard model .
the yellow band on the left - hand side refers to the lep2 direct search limit . from @xcite.,width=226 ] the measurements of @xmath17 and top masses , together with other precision electroweak measurements , lead to the limit for the standard model higgs - boson mass of @xmath68 gev / c@xmath23 ( see figure [ blue ] ) , with a 95% c.l .
upper limit of 160 gev / c@xmath23 .
if one also includes the results from direct searches at lep , yielding @xmath69 gev / c@xmath23 , the 95% c.l .
limit becomes 190 gev / c@xmath23 .
such a ( relatively low ) expected mass sets higgs - boson production possibly within reach of the tevatron experiments , but , at the same time , the smallness of the production cross section makes it very hard to search for its evidence .
this challenging task requires the experiments to aim at high sensitivity by combining all possible channels , improving efficiencies and reducing systematic uncertainties .
specific strategies need to be implemented for a low mass higgs ( @xmath70 gev / c@xmath23 ) , where the associated production ( @xmath71 or @xmath72 ) has the best chances , and for a ( relatively ) high mass ( @xmath73 gev / c@xmath23 ) , where the channels @xmath74 are the most favourable ones .
the cdf+d sensitivity reaches its optimum around 160 gev / c@xmath23 where they could be able to reach some results before the tevatron turn - off either in terms of exclusion or of evidence @xcite . as for cms and atlas ,
once the detector is well calibrated and its response known , they are expected to be sensitive to the discovery already with @xmath75 fb@xmath35 of data , if the higgs mass is above 140 gev / c@xmath23 , in the decay channels @xmath76 and @xmath74 . for lower higgs masses , more luminosity , about 5 - 10 fb@xmath35 , will be needed and several channels will have to be included , in order to be sensitive to its observation @xcite . as discussed in section 2 , many extensions of the standard model are introduced in order to address open issues , such as the hierarchy problem , or to provide different mechanisms of symmetry breaking or unify the fundamental forces .
the searches currently performed at the tevatron are either inspired by a specific model or instead based on a specific signature .
searches for supersymmetric particles , new gauge bosons , extra dimensions , leptoquarks or higgs compositeness belong to the first case . as for the second case , anomalous production of leptons ,
bosons and photons , as well as missing @xmath77 , have been searched .
no signal of supersymmetry , exotic particles or anomalous production has yet been found at the tevatron and limits ( more or less stringent , depending on the cases ) have been set @xcite .
new physics is searched also at hera where , for instance , limits on contact interactions have been set @xcite . given the large luminosity that will be integrated , the lhc experiments will have the potential for important discoveries , either within the susy framework @xcite or in other scenarios beyond the standard model @xcite .
statistical uncertainties will not be a problem in most cases , but it will be crucial to understand the systematics in order to be able to find evidence of new signals .
in this summary we have briefly reviewed the current status of the standard model of strong and electroweak interactions and underlined some of its drawbacks .
we discussed improvements in the theory and their applications to collider phenomenology , as well as the most recent measurements carried out at present colliders , mostly at the tevatron accelerator , and commented on the features of future measurements which will be carried out at the lhc .
on the theory side , qcd stands as a robust theory , which continuously yields predictions which are confirmed very well by the experiments .
nevertheless , more accurate perturbative calculations and a better understanding and modelling of its non - perturbative aspects are still of great interests , in order to fully control the backgrounds for many new physics searches . as for the electroweak interactions ,
the ultimate confirmation of the standard model awaits the discovery of the higgs boson : as discussed , the lhc should be able to give a final answer to this point .
moreover , the absence of any higgs signal so far , along with the open problems of the standard model , has pushed the development of a few new ideas on the electroweak symmetry breaking , which are theoretically well formulated and not in contradiction with the available electroweak precision tests . as only experimental measurements , _
e.g. _ the @xmath36 scattering cross section , can help to verify or disprove such models , we can just eagerly await for the next start of the lhc . 0
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings . these proceedings .
http://lepewwg.web.cern.ch / lepewwg/. these proceedings . these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings .
these proceedings . | in this summary we present the current status of the standard model of strong and electroweak interactions from the theoretical and experimental point of view .
some discussion is also devoted to the exploration of possible new physics signals beyond the standard model .
[ 1999/12/01 v1.4c il nuovo cimento ] |
non - linear sigma models [ 1 - 3 ] are prototypes of a remarkable class of integrable two dimensional models which contain an infinite number of conserved local and non - local charges [ 4 - 7 ] .
the algebraic relations obeyed by such charges are supposed to be an important ingredient in the complete solution of those models [ 8 - 11 ] .
the local charges form an abelian algebra . opposing to that simplicity ,
the algebra of non - local charges is non - abelian and actually non - linear [ 12 - 28 ] . in ref.[29 ] the @xmath0 sigma model
was investigated and a particular set of non - local charges called _ improved _ charges was found to satisfy a cubic algebra related to a yangian structure . in this work
we intend to extend that result to the corresponding supersymmetric case [ 30 - 32 ] .
the introduction of supersymmetry might have rendered a much more involved algebra [ 33 ] .
however , it has been conjectured [ 29,32 ] that , in the sigma model , the algebra of supersymmetric non - local charges would remain the same as in the bosonic theory and we shall present results that confirm such conjecture . this paper is organized as follows . in sect.2
we briefly review the results from the purely bosonic theory .
a graphic technique to compute charges and their algebra is introduced in sect.3 . in sect.4
we discuss the supersymmetric model and the main results of the paper .
another application of graphic rules is shown in sect .
5 concerning the @xmath0 gross - neveu model .
sect.6 is left for conclusions while an appendix contains examples of the graphic technique .
the two - dimensional non - linear @xmath0 sigma model can be described by the constrained lagrangean = 12__i^_i , _
i=1^n ^2_i = 1 .
associated to the @xmath0 symmetry we have a matrix - valued conserved curvature - free current @xmath1 = 0 \qquad , \end{aligned}\ ] ] whose components satisfy the algebra [ 29 ] @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the @xmath4 identity matrix . above
we have introduced the intertwiner field ( j)_ij = _ i_j and the @xmath0 @xmath5-product defined in ref . [
29 ] as ( ab)_ij , kla_ikb_jl - a_ilb_jk + a_jlb_ik - a_jkb_il .
this model is known to have infinite non - local conserved charges .
the standard set of charges can be iteratively built up by means of the potential method of brzin _ et .
al . _ [ 5 ] . however , in ref . [ 29 ] an alternative set of _ improved _ charges @xmath6 has been defined and it was shown that they obey the non - linear algebra \
{ q^(m)_ij , q^(n)_kl } = ( iq^(n+m ) ) _ ij , kl - _ p=0^m-1_q=0^n-1 ( q^(p )
q^(q ) q^(m+n - p - q-2))_ij , kl .
these charges were named _ improved _ because they brought up an algebraic improvement :
the non - linear part of the algebra is simply cubic , as opposed to the algebra of the standard charges previously used in the literature [ 14 ] .
the jacobi identity and other properties of the improved cubic algebra were thoroughly discussed in ref .
but there is a way to abbreviate that algebra , which is the first among the new results of this paper and which will be presented now .
.5truecm we shall define a hermitean generator of improved charges q ( ) i + i_n=0^^n+1 q^(n ) , where @xmath7 will be called the spectral parameter . therefore one can summarize the algebra ( 6 ) as follows : i\ { q_ij(),q_kl ( ) } = ( f ( , ) q()- q ( ) ) _ ij , kl , where f(,)e ( q()q()^-1 -^-1 ) = i - _ m , n=0^^m+1^n+1q^(m)q^(n)^-1 -^-1 .
the quadratic non - linearity encoded in @xmath8 can be related to the known yangian structure that underlies this model [ 17 - 26,29 ] .
the advantage in writing the algebra as in ( 8) is not only aesthetic . recalling the monodromy matrix of standard charges , and its algebra expressed in terms of the classical @xmath9-matrix , @xmath10 \quad , \\ & & r(\lambda , \mu ) = { i_a\otimes i_a\over \lambda ^{-1}-\mu ^{-1}}\quad , \quad [ i_a , i_b ] = f_{abc}i_c \quad , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we remark that the generator @xmath11 and the @xmath12-matrix play similar rles to those of the monodromy matrix and classical @xmath9-matrix in the standard approach [ 17 - 26 ] .
we do not fully understand the relationship between ( 8) and ( 10 ) but we expect to be able to use this analogy to establish a precise translation between the different sets of charges [ 35 ] . we also hope that a complete knowledge about the conserved charges and their algebra will become an decisive ingredient in off - shell scattering calculations . .5truecm now let us consider the graphic methods announced in the introduction .
we recall that in ref . [
29 ] the improved charges were constructed by means of an iterative algebraic algorithm that uses @xmath13 as a step - generator , as indicated by the relation ( iq^(n+1 ) ) = linear part of \{q^(1),q^(n ) } . after a tedious calculation " the authors in ref . [
29 ] managed to construct the charges @xmath14 and their algebra up to @xmath15 . in the next section we will present a _ graphic _ method that makes the calculation simpler , less tedious and convenient for a further supersymmetric extension .
let us associate white and black semicircles to the @xmath0 current components , j -.1 cm 2truecm j -.1 cm a continuous line and an oriented line to the identity and the anti - derivative operator respectively , i .07 cm 2truecm 2 .07 cm the operator @xmath16 above follows the same convention adopted in ref .
[ 29 ] , a(x ) = 12 y ( x - y)a(y ) , ( x)= . below one finds some diagrams and the corresponding expressions : @xmath17 we have noticed [ 29 ] that every improved charge can be written as an integral over symmetrized chains of @xmath18 s and @xmath19 s connected by the operator @xmath20 .
therefore we can associate a diagram to each improved charge , as exemplified by the second non - local charge @xmath21 : q^(2)=dx @xmath22 if one is interested in constructing charges , there is an iterative graphic procedure , inspired by the lessons taken from ref . [ 29 ] and which will be described now . consider the following properties : .3truecm
\(a ) the improved non - local charges have the general form @xmath23 where @xmath24 is a combination of terms which one can always write as j _
2(j_s+s^^tj _ ) , where @xmath25 is some chain and @xmath26 its transposed .
.5truecm ( b ) the algebraic definition of improved charges is ( iq^(n+1))_ij , kl= linear part of \{q_ij^(1),q_kl^(n ) } and we note that the linear part of @xmath27 comes exclusively from terms like dx ( \{q_ij^(1),(j_)_ka}2s_al-(k l ) ) .
.5truecm ( c ) using the definition of @xmath13 and the elementary current algebra and dropping non - linear terms , we verify that dx\{q_ij^(1),(j__0)_ka}2s_al - ( k l ) =( i dx[j__12s+j__02(j__02s ) + 2js ] ) _ ij , kl .
@xmath28 dx \{q_ij^(1),(j__1)_ka}2s_al - ( k l ) =(
i dx[2j__0j2s+j__0 2(j__1s ) ] ) _ ij , kl . @xmath29 where some new symbols were introduced , @xmath30 -.1 cm 1truecm 1truecm -.1 cm 2=
i the previous expressions justify the following prescription : .3truecm
\i ) we start from the diagram of @xmath14 .
.5truecm ii ) then we replace the left
tip " of each chain according to the rules : .5truecm iii ) the resulting diagram corresponds to @xmath31 . .5truecm
we remark that the substitution rules above can be directly read from the following basic brackets : @xmath32 in addition , one should not forget the constraints satisfied by the @xmath0 current @xmath33 , given below , _ + = j _
2truecm -.1 cm 0.5 cm 2j__1js= ( j__1s+js ) 2truecm -.1 cm the half - white / half - black semicircle means @xmath34 or @xmath19 generically .
we have tested the efficiency of this method : comparing to the explicit algebraic algorithm in ref . [
29 ] we have taken much less time and space to construct the improved charges . for the sake of clarity we have gathered a few examples in appendix a. .3truecm we have also developed a diagrammatic technique to calculate the algebra itself .
it can be seen as a set of contraction rules between the chains that constitute the charges .
indeed , in computing the algebra of non - local charges we have to consider all possible contractions " ( i.e. dirac brackets ) between symmetrized chains .
after some partial integrations we end up with elementary contractions of the following general kind : s_ia(x)t_bj(x ) \{(j_)_ab(x),(j_)_cd(y ) } u_kc(y)v_dl(y ) -(i j ) - ( k l ) .
the current algebra ( 3 ) tells us that a contraction @xmath35 may produce a current - like term @xmath36 or a schwinger term .
let us discuss the first kind , in which case ( 28 ) produces 4 terms : @xmath37_{ij , kl } \quad .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can associate each of the 4 terms above to one of the 4 possible contractions between the 2 pairs of symmetrized chains . in the presence of a schwinger term we must take into account extra contributions involving the intertwiner and partial integrations . in any event , the contractions between chains can be resumed by the following rules : .5truecm * step 1 : choice * .2truecm in calculating @xmath38 we take one chain from @xmath39 and other from @xmath14
. then we pick up the internal " current components we intend to contract .
this is symbolized by the generic diagram below : .5truecm * step 2 : isolation * .2truecm in each chain we must localize " the current components chosen in step 1 .
this was explicitly made in ( 28 ) by means of partial integrations .
within the diagrams this is achieved by inverting some arrows until all of them are pointing towards the chosen semicircle ( i.e. the current component we are isolating ) .
eventually a minus sign will be picked up , depending on the number of inversions .
finally have have this sort of diagrams : .2truecm the next step is just a graphic bending of chains , as a preparation to the final contraction . the chains from ( 31 )
should be bended in the following way : notice that the sub - chains @xmath40 and @xmath41 were transposed as eq .
( 31 ) demands .
actually the graphic bending implies the transposition , as exemplified below where the transposed current components are naturally represented as @xmath42 .5truecm * step 4 : contraction * .2truecm finally we perform the contraction in ( 32 ) according to the rules below : where we introduced a symbol corresponding to the @xmath5-product , -.6 cm = ( ab)=(ba ) .
for instance , a typical contraction between @xmath43 components would be @xmath44 = dx(su^^tt^^tj__0v ) . of course one must repeat all steps for every possible contraction . .2truecm the current @xmath33 obeys another constraint [ 27 ] involving the @xmath5-product , namely ( j_j)= 0 = -.6 cm which must also be taken into account .
.3truecm we mention that the elementary contractions in ( 35 ) are nothing but the graphic representation of the current algebra ( 3 ) , where the diagrams containing the intertwiner field come from schwinger terms followed by partial integrations .
these rules were applied to compute various brackets and in all cases the algebra ( 6 ) was confirmed .
one can also find an example in appendix a. the most remarkable outcome of this graphic procedure is that it poses an easy and straightforward way to the supersymmetric extension and possibly other generalizations .
the supersymmetric non - linear @xmath0 sigma model is defined [ 30 - 32 ] by the lagrangean _ s=__i^_i+ _ i /_i+ ( _ i_i)^2 , where @xmath45 are scalars and @xmath46 are majorana fermions satisfying the constraints _ i=1^n_i^2 - 1=0 , _ i=1^n_i_i=0 .
we also have a conserved @xmath0 current @xmath47 which can be split into bosonic and fermionic parts @xmath48 whose curvature obeys the equation f _ = _ j_-_j_+2[j_,j_]= -(_b_- _ b _ ) . even though its curvature is not null
, one can construct non - local conserved charges out of @xmath49 [ 30,31 ] . here
we shall deal with an algebraic procedure to derive these charges .
therefore it is necessary to start from the elementary @xmath0 current algebra , listed below , @xmath50_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y ) \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \{(j_{{}_0})_{ij}(x),(j_{{}_1})_{kl}(y)\}= ( i\circ j_{{}_1})_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y)+(i\circ j)_{ij , kl}(y)\delta'(x - y ) \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \{(j_{{}_1})_{ij}(x),(j_{{}_1})_{kl}(y)\}=0 \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \nonumber \\ & & \{(b_{{}_0})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_0})_{kl}(y)\}= [ ( i\circ b_{{}_0})-(j\circ b_{{}_0})]_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y ) \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \{(b_{{}_0})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_1})_{kl}(y)\}= [ ( i\circ b_{{}_1})-(j\circ b_{{}_1})]_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y ) \quad , \\ & & \{(b_{{}_1})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_1})_{kl}(y)\}= [ ( i\circ b_{{}_0})-(j\circ b_{{}_0})]_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y ) \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \nonumber \\ & & \{(j_{{}_0})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_0})_{kl}(y)\}= ( j\circ b_{{}_0})_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y ) \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \{(j_{{}_0})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_1})_{kl}(y)\}= ( j\circ b_{{}_1})_{ij , kl}(x)\delta(x - y ) \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \{(j_{{}_1})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_0})_{kl}(y)\}=0 \quad , \nonumber \\ & & \{(j_{{}_1})_{ij}(x),(b_{{}_1})_{kl}(y)\}=0 \quad , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the intertwiner and the @xmath5-product were already defined in ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) . the @xmath0 local charge and the first non - local charge are given [ 30,31 ] by the integrals @xmath51 some other supersymmetric _ standard _ non - local charges can be found in the literature [ 30 - 32 ] .
however , as in the bosonic case , we are searching for _ improved _ charges satisfying the simplest algebra . using the algebraic method proposed in ref .
[ 29 ] we have computed the improved charges and their brackets up to @xmath52 , finding the _ same cubic algebra _ given by ( 6 ) .
calculation is hopelessly longer than in the bosonic theory , but we have been able to develop some graphic rules which rather simplified our work . this diagrammatic method is a direct extension of the one proposed for the bosonic theory .
for instance , one can show that the supersymmetric step - generator @xmath13 satisfies the following algebraic relations : @xmath53 as in the bosonic model ( recall eqs.(23 - 25 ) ) these relations lead us to the proper transformation rules for the construction of charges .
one can use the following iterative procedure : .3truecm
\i ) we propose the symbolic notation @xmath54 b__0 -.1 cm , b__1 -.1 cm @xmath55 @xmath56 .5truecm ii ) we take the diagram associated to @xmath14 and replace the left tip " of each chain as follows : these transformations are a direct translation of eqs .
( 45 - 48 ) .
.5truecm iii ) after using the constraints on @xmath33 and @xmath57 you will have the diagram of @xmath31 .
.5truecm in order to calculate the algebra between the non - local charges , one should follow the same algorithm ( choice , isolation , bending and contraction ) , using the contraction rules below @xmath58 @xmath59 which is the graphic version of the algebra ( 43 ) .
we also have a new constraint , b_j = jb_= 0 = -.1 cm to be added to the list in ( 26,27,38 ) .
as before , the half - white / half - black triangle means @xmath60 or @xmath61 in general .
.5truecm we have used this procedure to construct several charges and confirmed the algebra ( 6 ) .
this is actually the main result of this paper , confirming previous conjectures .
.3truecm to complete the algebraic analysis , we have also considered the conserved supersymmetry current and charge , given by @xmath62 using the equations of motion , we have checked that \
{ q , q^(n ) } = 0 , n0 which means that every non - local charge is invariant under supersymmetry on - shell as already pointed in ref .
therefore the non - local charges in the supersymmetric sigma model are all bosonic .
however we must stress that this is not a general property : for instance , in ref . [
34 ] one finds an integrable supersymmetric theory the supersymmetric two boson hierarchy
containing fermionic non - local charges
whose graded algebra exhibits cubic terms similar to those of eq .
it would be very interesting to develop graphic rules for this kind of model [ 35 ] .
this model consists of an @xmath63-plet of majorana fermions transforming as a fundamental representation of the @xmath0 group , with a quartic interaction .
its lagrangean reads [ 7 ] _ _ gn = _
( _ i_i)^2 , and it can be regarded as the limit of null bosonic field ( @xmath64 ) in the supersymmetric model ( 39 ) notice that the constraints ( 40 ) disappear . the noether current associated to the @xmath0 rotations is ( b_)_ij = -i_i__i , _ b^=0 and it satisfies the curvature - free condition _ b_-_b_+ [ b_,b _ ] = 0 and the algebraic relations @xmath65 as before , we may construct an infinite number of conserved non - local currents using the potential algorithm : we consider a conserved current @xmath66 and the corresponding potential @xmath67 , b_^(n)= _
then we define the current @xmath68 as b_^(n+1 ) = 2 ( _ + b _ ) ^(n ) .
the properties ( 56 ) and ( 57 ) imply that @xmath68 is also conserved . starting out with @xmath69 we find an infinite number of conserved charges @xmath70 . after applying this algorithm to build up some of them
, it is straightforward to check that this method is equivalent to the following graphic procedure : one chooses some symbols to represent @xmath60 and @xmath61 , for instance , b__0 -.1 cm 2truecm b__1 -.1 cm then one takes the sequence of chains associated to @xmath14 and uses the replacement rules for left - tips on the other hand , this is precisely the limit @xmath71 of the transformation rules ( 50 ) in the supersymmetric theory .
.3truecm this provides an alternative derivation of the graphic rules to construct charges in the gross - neveu model .
moreover it implies that those charges defined by the algorithm ( 60 ) are actually the improved charges and thus they must obey the cubic algebra ( 6 ) .
diagrammatic methods are frequently used in physics to simplify long calculations and so we have proposed a graphic procedure to construct and compute the algebra of non - local charges in non - linear sigma models . applying such procedure
we have been able to verify that the ( improved ) non - local charges in the supersymmetric @xmath0 sigma model obey a cubic yangian - like algebra which can be expressed as in eq .
.2truecm one could easily recover the bosonic model from the supersymmetric theory by taking the no - fermion limit @xmath72 .
moreover , the @xmath0 invariant gross - neveu model can be obtained after erasing the bosonic fields ( @xmath64 ) .
the improved charges in these models may be different but their algebra is exactly the same . in the gross - neveu model ,
the improved charges could be computed by means of two different methods and therefore the corresponding graphic rules could be confirmed and further understood .
we expect to find a similar confirmation in the sigma models but the presence of the intertwiner field within the diagrams has impeded us so far . .2truecm it is also interesting to consider the inclusion of wess - zumino terms , which modify the current algebra ( see for instance ref .
[ 28,29 ] ) and derive the corresponding graphic rules .
this problem and the general application of diagrammatic methods to integrable theories is presently under investigation [ 35 ] .
2truecm * acknowledgements * .5truecm we would like to thank e. abdalla and m.c.b .
abdalla for helpful comments .
we also thank j.c .
brunelli for suggestions and for his participation in the early stages of this work .
[ [ graphic - derivation - of - q1q1-in - the - non - linear - sigma - model ] ] graphic derivation of @xmath79 in the non - linear sigma model ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ notice that we have computed two minus signs : one from the inversion of an arrow ( along the isolation step ) and other from the transposition of @xmath80 ( during the bending step ) .
the first contribution is this commented example may seem rather long , not revealing the actual power of the graphic method .
but we can assure the reader that , after practicing the contraction rules for a while and skipping the intermediate comments we have been able to compute many dirac brackets very efficiently .
maillet , j .-
: hamiltonian structures for integrable classical theories from graded kac - moody algebras .
167b * , 401 - 405 ( 1986 ) ; new integrable canonical structures in two - dimensional models .
b269 * , 54 - 76 ( 1986 ) .
haldane , f.d . , ha , z.n.c . , talstra , j.c . ,
bernard , d. , pasquier , v. : yangian symmetry of integrable quantum chains with long - range interactions and a new description of states in conformal field theory .
. lett . * 69 * , 2021 - 2025 ( 1992 ) .
mackay , n.j .
: on the bootstrap structure of yangian - invariant factorized @xmath25-matrices .
print-92 - 0535 ( durham ) .
bulletin board : hep - th - 9211091 . in tianjin 1992 , proceedings ,
differential geometric methods in theoretical physics 360 - 363 . | we propose a graphic method to derive the classical algebra ( dirac brackets ) of non - local conserved charges in the two - dimensional supersymmetric non - linear @xmath0 sigma model . as in the purely bosonic theory
we find a cubic yangian algebra .
we also consider the extension of graphic methods to other integrable theories .
epsf.tex = 6.5 in = -.3 in = -.5 in j j__0 j j__1 |
majorana fermions ( mfs ) are real solutions of the dirac equation and which are their own antiparticles @xmath0 @xcite .
although proposed originally as a model for neutrinos , mfs have recently been predicted to occur as quasi - particle bound states in engineered condensed matter systems @xcite .
this exotic particle obeys non - abelian statistics , which is one of important factors to realize subsequent potential applications in decoherence - free quantum computation @xcite and quantum information processing @xcite . over the recent few years , the possibility for hosting mfs in exotic solid state systems focused on topological superconductors @xcite .
currently , various realistic platforms including topological insulators @xcite , semiconductor nanowires ( snws ) @xcite , and atomic chains @xcite have been proposed to support majorana states based on the superconducting proximity effect . although various schemes have been presented , observing the unique majorana signatures
experimentally is still a challenging task to conquer .
mfs are their own antiparticles , and they are predicted to appear in tunneling spectroscopy experiments , in which majoranas manifest themselves as characteristic zero - bias peaks ( zbps ) @xcite .
the theoretical predictions of zbps have been observed experimentally in snws which are interpreted as the signatures of mfs mourikv , dasa , dengmt , churchillhoh , finckadk .
remarkably , nadj - perge et al .
@xcite recently designed a chain of magnetic fe atoms deposited on the surface of an s - wave superconducting pb with strong spin - orbit interactions , and reported the striking observation of a zbp at the end of the atomic chains with stm , which provides evidence for majorana zero modes . however , these above experimental results can not serve as definitive evidences to prove the existence of mfs in condensed matter systems , and it is also a major challenge in these experiments to uniquely distinguish majoranas from conventional fermionic subgap states .
the first reason is that the zero - bias conductance peaks can also appear in terms of the other mechanisms @xcite , such as the zero - bias anomaly due to kondo resonance @xcite and the disorder or band bending in the snw @xcite .
the second one is that andreev bound states in a magnetic field can also exhibit a zero - energy crossing as a function of exchange interaction or zeeman energy @xcite , and therefore give rise to similar conductance features .
as far as we know , most of the experimental evidences for majorana bound states largely relies on measurements of the tunneling conductance at present , and the observation of majorana signature based on electrical methods still remains a subject of debate .
identifying mfs only through tunnel spectroscopy is somewhat problematic .
therefore , to obtain definitive signatures of mfs , alternative setups or proposals for detecting mfs are necessary . here , we will propose an alternative all - optical scheme to detect mfs .
benefitting from recent advances in nanotechnology and nanofabrication , nanostructures such as quantum dots ( qds ) and nanomechanical resonators ( nrs ) have been obtained significant progress in modern nanoscience and nanotechnology .
qd , as a simple stationary atom with well optical property @xcite , lays the foundation for numerous possible applications urbaszekb .
due to high natural frequencies and large quality factors of nrs @xcite , if qds coupled to nrs @xcite to form hybrid systems , the coherent optical properties will be enhanced remarkably , which will be an alternative ultrasensitive detection means .
although probing mfs with qds @xcite have been proposed , we notice that all the schemes are still based on electrical means . in the present work , we propose an optical measurement scheme to detect the existence of mfs in iron chains on the superconducting pb surface @xcite via a coupled hybrid qd - nr system with optical pump - probe scheme @xcite . compared with electrical detection means where the qds are coupled to mfs via the tunneling @xcite , in our optical scheme , there is no direct contact between mfs and the hybrid qd - nr system , which can effectively avoid introducing other signals disturbing the detecting of mfs .
the interaction between mfs in iron chains and qd in hybrid qd - nr system is mainly due to the dipole - dipole interaction , and the distance between the two systems can be adjusted by several tens of nanometers , therefore the tunneling between the qd and mfs can be neglected safely . in addition ,
the qd is considered as a two - level system rather than a single resonant level with spin - singlet state , and once mfs appear in the end of iron chains and couple to the qd , the majorana signature will be carried out via the coherent optical spectrum of the qd .
the change in the coherent optical spectrum as a possible signature for mfs is another potential evidence in the iron chains .
this optical scheme will provide another method for the detection of mfs , which is very different from the zero - bias peak in the tunneling experiments mourikv , dasa , dengmt , churchillhoh , finckadk , nadj - perges2 .
furthermore , in order to investigate the role of the nr in the hybrid system , we further introduce the exciton resonance spectrum to detect mfs .
the results shows that the vibration of the nr acting as a phonon cavity will enhance the exciton resonance spectrum significantly and make mfs more sensitive to be detectable .
the technique proposed here provide a new platform for applications ranging from robust manipulation of mfs and mfs based quantum information processing .
figure 1(b ) shows the schematic setup that will be studied in this work , where iron ( fe ) chains on the superconducting pb(110 ) surface nadj - perges2 , and we employ a two - level qd with optical pump - probe technology to detect mfs .
the fe chain is ferromagnetically ordered nadj - perges2 with a large magnetic moment , which takes the role of the magnetic field in the nanowire experiments @xcite .
different from the proposal of mourik et al .
@xcite , this `` magnetic field '' is mostly localized on the fe chain , with small leakage outside , and superconductivity is not destroyed along the chain . in this setup , the energy scale of the exchange coupling of the fe atoms is typically much larger than that of the rashba spin - orbit coupling and the superconducting pairing .
figure 1(c ) displays that a qd is implanted in the nr to form a coupled hybrid qd - nr system .
the whole system includes two kinds of couplings which are qd - mf coupling and qd - nr coupling as shown in fig .
1(a ) . in the following
, we will discuss the two kinds of coupling in detail , respectively . in the hybrid qd - nr system ,
the qd is modeled as a two - level system consisting of the ground state @xmath1 and the single exciton state @xmath2 at low temperatures zrennera , stuflers , and the hamiltonian of the qd can be described as @xmath3 with the exciton frequency @xmath4 , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the pseudospin operator describing the two - level exciton with the commutation relation @xmath7 = \pm s^{\pm } $ ] and @xmath8 = 2s^{z}$ ] . for the nr ,
the thickness of the beam is much smaller than its width , the lowest - energy resonance corresponds to the fundamental flexural mode that will constitute the resonator mode @xcite which can be characterized by a quantum harmonic oscillator with hamiltonian @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the resonator frequency and @xmath11 is the annihilation operator of the resonator mode .
since the flexion induces extensions and compressions in the structure @xcite , this longitudinal strain will modify the energy of the electronic states of qd through deformation potential coupling .
then the coupling between the resonator mode and the qd is described by @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the coupling strength between the resonator mode and qd wilson - raei .
thus we obtain the hamiltonian of the coupled hybrid qd - nr system@xmath14 for the qd - mf coupling , as each mf is its own antiparticle , we introduce an operator @xmath15 with @xmath16 and @xmath17 to describe mfs .
supposed that the qd couples to the nearby mf @xmath18 in the end of iron chains , then the hamiltonian is written by liude , flensbergk , leijnsem , caoys , lij @xmath19to detect mfs , it is helpful to switch the majorana representation to the regular fermion one via the exact transformation @xmath20 and @xmath21 @xmath22 , where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the fermion annihilation and creation operators obeying the anti - commutative relation @xmath25 .
accordingly , in the rotating wave approximation @xcite , the above hamiltonian can be rewritten as@xmath26where the first term gives the energy of mf with frequency @xmath27 and @xmath28 with the iron chains length ( @xmath29 ) and the pb superconducting coherent length ( @xmath30 ) .
if the iron chains length ( @xmath29 ) is large enough , @xmath31 will approach zero . in the following
, we will discuss the two conditions of @xmath32 and @xmath33 , and define the two conditions as coupled mfs ( @xmath34 ) and uncoupled mfs ( @xmath33 ) , respectively .
the second term describes the coupling between the nearby mf and the qd with the coupling strength @xmath35 , where the coupling strength is related to the distance between the hybrid qd - nr system and the iron chains .
it should be also noted that the term of non - conservation for energy , i.e. @xmath36 , is generally neglected .
we have made the numerical calculations ( not shown in the following figures ) and shown that the effect of this term is too small to be considered in our theoretical treatment .
currently , the optical pump - probe technique has become a popular topic , which affords an effective way to investigate the light - matter interaction .
the optical pump - probe technology includes a strong pump laser and a weak probe laser @xcite . in the optical pump - probe technology ,
the strong pump laser is used to stimulate the system to generate coherent optical effect , while the weak laser plays the role of probe laser .
therefore , the linear and nonlinear optical effects can be observed via the probe absorption spectrum based on the optical pump - probe scheme .
xu et al . have obtained coherent optical spectroscopy of semiconductor qd when driven simultaneously by two optical fields @xcite .
their results open the way for the demonstration of numerous quantum level - based applications , such as qd lasers , optical modulators , and quantum logic devices . in terms of this scheme , we apply the pump - probe scheme to the qd of the hybrid qd - nr system simultaneously .
when the optical pump - probe technology is applied on the qd , the majorana signature will be carried out via the coherent optical spectrum .
the hamiltonian of the exciton of the qd coupled to the two fields is given by @xcite @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the dipole moment of the exciton , and @xmath39 is the slowly varying envelope of the field .
therefore , we obtain the whole hamiltonian of the hybrid system as @xmath40 . in a rotating frame at the pump field frequency @xmath41 , we obtain the total hamiltonian of the system as @xmath42where @xmath43 is the detuning of the exciton frequency and the pump frequency , @xmath44 is the rabi frequency of the pump field , and @xmath45 is the detuning of the probe field and the pump field .
@xmath46 is the detuning of the mf frequency and the pump frequency .
actually , we have neglected the regular fermion like normal electrons in the nanowire that interact with the qd in the above discussion . to describe the interaction between the normal electrons and the exciton in qd
, a tight binding hamiltonian of the whole iron chains is introduced chenhj . according to the heisenberg equation of motion and introducing the corresponding damping and noise terms , the quantum langevin equations of the whole system
are derived as@xmath47@xmath48s^{-}+2(\beta f - i\omega _ { pu})s^{z}-\frac{2i\mu e_{pr}}{\hbar } e^{-i\delta t}s^{z}+\hat{% \tau}(t)\text{,}\]]@xmath49@xmath50where @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) is the exciton spontaneous emission rate ( dephasing rate ) , @xmath53 is the position operator , @xmath54 is the decay rate of the nr , and @xmath55 is the decay rate of the mf .
@xmath56 is the @xmath57-correlated langevin noise operator , which has zero mean @xmath58 and obeys the correlation function @xmath59 .
the resonator mode is affected by a brownian stochastic force with zero mean value , and @xmath60 has the correlation function@xmath61,\]]where @xmath62 and @xmath63 are the boltzmann constant and the temperature of the reservoir of the coupled system .
mfs have the same correlation relation as the resonator mode as @xmath64.\]]in eq.(9 ) and eq.(10 ) , both the nr and majorana mode will be affected by a thermal bath of brownian and non - markovian processes @xcite . in the low temperature , the quantum effects of both the majorana and nr mode
are only observed in the case of @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
due to the weak coupling to the thermal bath , the brownian noise operator can be modeled as markovian processes .
in addition , both the qd - mfs coupling and qd - nr mode coupling in the hybrid system are stronger than the coupling to the reservoir that influences the two kinds coupling . in this case , owing to the second order approximation gardinercw , we can obtain the form of the reservoir that affects both the nr mode and majorana mode as eq.(9 ) and eq.(10 ) . to go beyond weak coupling ,
the heisenberg operator can be rewritten as the sum of its steady - state mean value and a small fluctuation with zero mean value@xmath67since the driving fields are weak , but classical coherent fields , we will identify all operators with their expectation values , and drop the quantum and thermal noise terms .
simultaneously , inserting these operators into the langevin equations eqs.(5)-(8 ) and neglecting the nonlinear term , we can obtain two equation sets about the steady - state mean value and the small fluctuation .
the steady - state equation set consisting of @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 is related to the population inversion ( @xmath71 ) of the exciton which is determined by@xmath72 + 4w_{0}\gamma _ { 2}\omega _ { pu}^{2}(\delta _ { m}^{2}+\kappa _ { m}^{2}/4)=0.\end{gathered}\]]for the equation set of small fluctuation , we make the ansatz @xcite @xmath73 ( @xmath74 ) . solving the equation set and working to the lowest order in @xmath75 but to all orders in @xmath76 , we can obtain the linear susceptibility as @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is given by@xmath79\gamma _ { 2}}{\pi { % _ { 2}\pi _ { 4}^{\ast } -\lambda _ { 1}\lambda _ { 2}\pi _ { 1}\pi _ { 3}^{\ast } } } , \]]@xmath68 , @xmath70 and @xmath69 can be derived from the steady - state equations , and @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath83/(\gamma _ { 1}-i\delta ) $ ] , @xmath84/(\gamma _
{ 1}-i\delta ) $ ] , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 ( @xmath90 indicates the conjugate of @xmath91 ) .
the imaginary and real parts of @xmath92 indicate absorption and dissipation , respectively .
in addition , the average population of the exciton states can be obtained as@xmath93}{\pi { _ { 2}\pi _ { 4}^{\ast } -\lambda _ { 1}\lambda _ { 2}\pi _ { 1}\pi _ { 3}^{\ast } } } , \]]which is benefited for readout the exciton states of qd .
for illustration of the numerical results , we choose the realistic hybrid systems of the coupled qd - nr system @xcite and the iron chains on the superconducting pb surface @xcite . for an inas qd in the coupled qd - nr system ,
we use parameters @xcite : the exciton relaxation rate @xmath94 ghz , the exciton dephasing rate @xmath95 ghz .
the physical parameters of gaas nr are @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 ghz , @xmath99 kg , @xmath100 , where @xmath101 , @xmath97 , and @xmath102 are the resonator frequency , the effective mass , and quality factor of the nr , respectively .
the decay rate of the nr is @xmath103 @xmath104 khz , and the coupling strength between the qd and nr is @xmath105 . for mfs , there are no experimental values for the lifetime of the mfs and the coupling strength between the exciton and mfs in the recent literature .
however , according to a few recent experimental reports @xcite , it is reasonable to assume that the lifetime of the mfs is @xmath106 mhz .
since the coupling strength between the qd and nearby mfs is dependent on their distance , we also expect the coupling strength @xmath107 ghz via adjusting the distance between the hybrid qd - nr system and the iron chains .
figure 2(a ) shows the coherent optical properties of the qd as functions of probe - exciton detuning @xmath108 at the detuning of the exciton frequency and the pump frequency @xmath109 , i.e. , the absorption ( @xmath110 ) and dissipation ( @xmath111 ) properties of the qd without considering any coupling ( @xmath112 ) , which indicates the normal absorption and dissipation of the qd , respectively . turning on the qd - nr coupling ( @xmath105 ) and without considering the qd - mf coupling ( @xmath113 )
, two sharp peaks will appear in both the absorption and dissipation spectra as shown in fig .
2(b ) . from the curves , we find that the two sharp peaks at both sides of the spectra just correspond to the vibrational frequency of the nr .
the physical origin of this result is due to mechanically induced coherent population oscillation , which makes quantum interference between the resonator and the beat of the two optical fields via the qd when the probe - pump detuning is equal to the nr frequency @xcite .
this reveals that if fixing the pump field on - resonance with the exciton and scan through the frequency spectrum , the two sharp peaks can obtain immediately in the coherent optical spectra , which also indicates a scheme to measure the frequency of the nr .
this phenomenon stems from the quantum interference between the vibration nr and the beat of the two optical fields via the exciton when probe - pump detuning @xmath114 is adjusted equal to the frequency of the nr .
therefore , the qd - nr coupling play a key role in the hybrid system , and if we ignore the coupling ( @xmath115 ) , the above phenomenon will disappear completely as shown in fig .
compared with fig.2(b ) , in fig.2(c ) , we consider the qd coupled with the nearby mf @xmath18 without taking the qd - nr coupling into account , i.e. the condition of @xmath115 and @xmath107 ghz . as
the mfs appear in the ends of iron chains and coupled to the qd , both the probe absorption ( the blue curve ) and dissipation ( the green curve ) spectra will present an remarkable signature of mfs under @xmath116 ghz .
the physical origin of this result is due to the qd - mf coherent interaction and we can interpret this physical phenomenon with dressed state between the exciton and mfs .
the qd coupled to the nearby mf will induce the upper level of the state @xmath117 to split into @xmath118 and @xmath119 ( @xmath120 denotes the number states of the mfs ) .
the left peak in the coherent optical spectra signifies the transition from @xmath1 to @xmath121 while the right peak is due to the transition of @xmath122 to @xmath119 chenhj . to determine this signature is the true mfs rather than the normal electrons that couple with the qd
, we have used a tight binding hamiltonian to describe the electrons in whole iron chains , the numerical results indicate the signals in the absorption and dissipation spectra are the true mfs signature @xcite . if we consider both the two kinds coupling , i.e. the qd - nr coupling ( @xmath105 ) and qd - mfs coupling ( @xmath107 ghz ) as shown in fig .
2(d ) , not only the two sharp peaks locate at the nr frequency induced by its vibration , i.e. two peaks are at @xmath123 ghz ( @xmath124ghz ) , there is also mfs signal appear at @xmath125 ghz ( @xmath116 ghz ) induced by the qd - mf coupling . in fig .
2(c ) , we only consider the situation of @xmath34 .
in fact , if the iron chains length @xmath29 is much larger than the pb superconducting coherent length @xmath30 , @xmath31 will approach zero .
therefore , it is necessary to consider the conditions of @xmath126 and @xmath33 , and we define them as coupled mfs mode ( @xmath32 ) and uncoupled mfs mode ( @xmath33 ) , respectively .
figure 3(a ) and figure 3(b ) show the absorption and dissipation spectra as a function of detuning @xmath127 with qd - mf coupling constants @xmath128 ghz under @xmath34 and @xmath33 , respectively . compared with the coupled mfs mode
, the uncoupled qd - mf hamiltonian will reduce to @xmath129 which is analogous j - c hamiltonian of standard model under @xmath33 , and the probe absorption spectrum ( the blue curve ) shows a symmetric splitting as the qd - mf coupling strength @xmath107 ghz which is different from of coupled mfs mode presenting unsymmetric splitting due to a detuning @xmath130 ghz .
therefore , our results reveal that the signals in the coherent optical spectra is a real signature of mf , and the optical detection scheme can work at both the coupled majorana edge states and the uncoupled majorana edge states . in fig .
3(c ) , we further make a comparison of the probe absorption spectrum under the coupled mfs mode ( @xmath34 ) and uncoupled mfs mode ( @xmath131 ) .
it is obvious that the probe absorption spectrum display the analogous phenomenon of electromagnetically induced transparency ( eit ) @xcite under both the two conditions .
the dip in the probe absorption spectrum goes to zero at @xmath132 and @xmath133 ghz with @xmath33 and @xmath34 , respectively , which means the input probe field is transmitted to the coupled system without absorption .
such a phenomenon is attributed to the destructive quantum interference effect between the majorana modes and the beat of the two optical fields via the qd . if the beat frequency of two lasers @xmath57 is close to the resonance frequency of mfs , the majorana mode starts to oscillate coherently , which results in stokes - like ( @xmath134 ) and anti - stokes - like ( @xmath135 ) scattering of light from the qd .
the stokes - like scattering is strongly suppressed because it is highly off - resonant with the exciton frequency .
however , the anti - stokes - like field can interfere with the near - resonant probe field and thus modify the probe field spectrum . here
the majorana modes play a vital role in this coupled system , and we can refer the above phenomenon as majorana modes induced transparency , which is analogous with eit in atomic systems @xcite .
on the other hand , we can propose a means to determine the qd - mf coupling strength @xmath35 via measuring the distance of the two peaks with increasing the qd - mf coupling strength in the probe absorption spectrum .
figure 3(d ) indicates the peak - splitting width as a function of the qd - mf coupling strength @xmath35 under the condition of the coupled mfs mode ( @xmath136 ) and the uncoupled mfs mode ( @xmath33 ) which follows a nearly linear relationship .
it is obvious that the two lines ( the uncoupled mfs and the coupled mfs mode ) have a slight deviation .
however , the deviation becomes slighter with increasing coupling strength .
therefore , it is essential to enhance the coupling strength for a clear peak splitting via adjusting the distance between the qd and the nearby mfs . in this case
the coupling strength can obtain immediately by directly measuring the distance of the two peaks in the probe absorption spectrum . as shown in fig .
2(d ) , there are not only two sharp peaks locate at the nr frequency induced by its vibration but also the mfs signal appear at @xmath137 induced by the qd - mf coupling in the probe absorption spectrum ( the blue curve ) under the two kinds coupling . in fig .
4(a ) , we further consider switching the detuning @xmath116 ghz to @xmath138 ghz at small exciton - pump detuning @xmath139 ghz .
it is obvious that the resonance amplification process ( 1 ) and the resonance absorption process ( 2 ) in the probe absorption spectrum without considering the qd - mf coupling ( the blue curve , @xmath113 ) will accordingly transform into the the resonance absorption process ( 3 ) and the resonance amplification process ( 4 ) due to the qd - mf coupling ( the green curve , @xmath140 ghz ) .
return to fig .
1(a ) , there are two kinds of coupling which are qd - nr coupling and qd - mf coupling in the hybrid system . for the qd - nr system
, the two sharp peaks in the probe absorption corresponding to the resonance amplification ( 1 ) and absorption process ( 2 ) can be elaborated with dressed states @xmath141 , @xmath142 , @xmath143 , @xmath144 ( @xmath145 denotes the number state of the resonance mode ) , and the two sharp peaks indicate the transition between the dressed states @xcite .
however , once mfs appear in the ends of iron chains and coupled to the qd , the ground state @xmath146 and the exciton state @xmath2 of the qd will also modify by the number states of the mfs @xmath120 and induce the majorana dressed states @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath118 , @xmath149 . with increasing the qd - mf coupling , the majorana dressed states will affect the amplification ( 1 ) and absorption process ( 2 ) significantly , and even realize the inversion between the absorption ( 3 ) and amplification ( 4 ) process due to the qd - mf coherent interaction ( the green curve ) . to illustrate the advantage of the nr in the hybrid system
, we introduce the exciton resonance spectrum to investigate the role of nr in the coupled qd - nr , which is benefited for readout the exciton states of qd . in fig .
4(b ) , we adjust the detuning @xmath116 ghz to @xmath150 ghz , therefore , the location of the two sideband peaks induced by the qd - mf coupling coincides with the two sharp peaks induced by the vibration of nr , thus the nr is resonant with the coupled qd - mf system and makes the coherent interaction of qd - mf more strong .
figure 4(b ) shows the exciton resonance spectrum of the probe field as a function of the probe detuning @xmath151 with the detuning @xmath139 ghz under the coupled mfs mode @xmath34 .
the black and red curves correspond to @xmath115 and @xmath152 for the qd - mf coupling @xmath153 ghz , respectively .
it is obvious that the role of nr is to narrow and to increase the exciton resonance spectrum . in this case
, the nr behaves as a phonon cavity will enhance the sensitivity for detecting mfs .
we have proposed an all - optical means to detect the existence of mfs in iron chains on the superconducting pb surface with a hybrid qd - nr system .
the signals in the coherent optical spectra indicate the possible majorana signature , which provides another supplement for detecting mfs . due to the vibration of nr ,
the exciton resonance spectrum becomes much more significant and then enhances the detection sensitivity of mfs .
in addition , the qd - mf coupling in our system is a little feeble , while ref .
[ 35 ] presents a strong qd - mf coupling and the coupling strength can reach kilohertz , which is beneficial for mfs detection . on the other hand , if we consider embedding a metal nanoparticle - quantum dot ( mnp - qd ) complex chenhj , lijj in the nr , the surface plasmon induced by the mnp will enhance the coherent optical property of qd , which may be robust for probing mfs .
the concept proposed here , based on the quantum interference between the nr and the beat of the two optical fields , is the first all - optical means to probe mfs .
this coupled system will provide a platform for applications in all - optically controlled topological quantum computing based on mfs .
the authors gratefully acknowledge support from the national natural science foundation of china ( no.11574206 , no.10974133 , no.11274230 , no.61272153 , no.61572035 , no.51502005 , and no.11404005 ) , the key foundation for young talents in college of anhui province ( no .
2013sqrl026zd ) , and the foundation for phd in anhui university of science and technology .
i. yeo , p. l. de assis , a. gloppe , e. dupont - ferrier , p. verlot , n. s. malik , e. dupuy , j. claudon , j. m. grard , a. auffves , g. nogues , s. seidelin , j. p. poizat , o. arcizet , and m. richard , nat . nanotechnol .
* 9 * , 106 ( 2014 ) .
fig.1 sketch of the proposed setup for optically detecting majorana fermions ( mfs ) .
( a ) the energy - level diagram of a qd coupled to mfs and nr , which includes two kinds coupling , i.e. the qd - mf coupling ( the dotted frame ) and the qd - nr coupling ( the dashed frame ) .
( b ) the iron chains on the superconducting pb surface , and a pair of mfs appear in the ends of the iron chains .
the nearby mf is coupled to ( c ) a qd embedded in a nanomechanical resonator ( nr ) with optical pump - probe technology .
fig.2 the absorption ( the blue curve ) and dispersion ( the green curve ) spectra of probe field as a function of the probe detuning @xmath127 under different conditions .
( a ) without considering any coupling , i.e. , @xmath115 and @xmath113 .
( b ) the qd - nr coupling strength is @xmath105 and @xmath113 .
( c ) the qd - mf coupling strength is @xmath107 ghz and @xmath115 .
( d ) considering both the qd - nr coupling and qd - mf coupling , i.e. , @xmath105 and @xmath154 ghz .
the parameters used are @xmath94 ghz , @xmath95 ghz , @xmath155 khz , @xmath124 ghz , @xmath156 mhz , @xmath157(ghz)@xmath158 , @xmath116 ghz , and @xmath109 .
fig.3 ( a ) and ( b ) show the probe absorption ( the blue curve ) and dispersion ( the green curve ) spectra with qd - mf coupling strengths @xmath107 ghz under @xmath34 and @xmath33 , respectively .
( c ) the probe absorption spectrum under @xmath34 ( the green curve ) and @xmath131 ( the blue curve ) , respectively .
( d ) the linear relationship between the distance of peak splitting and the coupling strength of qd - mf @xmath159 .
the other parameters used are the same as in fig.2 .
fig.4 ( a ) the probe absorption spectrum as a function of the probe detuning @xmath160 with considering ( the blue curve , @xmath153 ghz ) and without considering ( the green curve , @xmath113 ) the qd - mf coupling under the qd - nr coupling strength @xmath105 .
( b ) the exciton resonance spectrum as a function of @xmath127 with @xmath115 and @xmath105 at the qd - mf coupling strength @xmath153 ghz .
@xmath150 ghz , @xmath139 ghz , @xmath161(ghz)@xmath158 , the other parameters used are the same as fig.2 . under different conditions .
( a ) without considering any coupling , i.e. , @xmath115 and @xmath162 .
( b ) the qd - nr coupling strength is @xmath105 and @xmath163 .
( c ) the qd - mf coupling strength is @xmath164 ghz and @xmath115 .
( d ) considering both the qd - nr coupling and qd - mf coupling , i.e. , @xmath105 and @xmath164 ghz .
the parameters used are @xmath165 ghz , @xmath166 ghz , @xmath167 khz , @xmath168 ghz , @xmath169 mhz , @xmath170(ghz)@xmath158 , @xmath116 ghz , and @xmath109.,width=453 ] ghz under @xmath171 and @xmath172 , respectively .
( c ) the probe absorption spectrum under @xmath173 ( the green curve ) and @xmath174 ( the blue curve ) , respectively .
( d ) the linear relationship between the distance of peak splitting and the coupling strength of qd - mf @xmath175 .
the other parameters used are the same as in fig.2.,width=453 ] with considering ( the blue curve , @xmath176 ghz ) and without considering ( the green curve , @xmath162 ) the qd - mf coupling under the qd - nr coupling strength @xmath105 .
( b ) the exciton resonance spectrum as a function of @xmath127 with @xmath115 and @xmath152 at the qd - mf coupling strength @xmath177 ghz .
@xmath138 ghz , @xmath139 ghz , @xmath178(ghz)@xmath158 , the other parameters used are the same as fig.2.,width=453 ] | motivated by a recent experiment [ nadj - perge et al . , science 346 ,
602 ( 2014 ) ] providing evidence for majorana zero modes in iron chains on the superconducting pb surface , in the present work , we theoretically propose an all - optical scheme to detect majorana fermions , which is very different from the current tunneling measurement based on electrical means .
the optical detection proposal consists of a quantum dot embedded in a nanomechanical resonator with optical pump - probe technology . with the optical means ,
the signal in the coherent optical spectrum presents a distinct signature for the existence of majorana fermions in the end of iron chains .
further , the vibration of the nanomechanical resonator behaving as a phonon cavity will enhance the exciton resonance spectrum , which makes the majorana fermions more sensitive to be detectable .
this optical scheme affords a potential supplement for detection of majorana fermions and supports to use majorana fermions in fe chains as qubits for potential applications in quantum computing devices . |
properties of rotating spinor bose - einstein condensates attract a lot of attention now .
first examples of these systems with hyperfine spin @xmath0 were found in optically trapped @xmath1na @xcite .
vortex phase diagram of spinor condensates is very rich , since the order parameter has three components in @xmath0 case and five components in @xmath2 case .
topological excitations in spinor condensates were studied theoretically in a large number of articles see , e.g. , refs mizushima1,isoshima1,reijnders , ueda1,pogosov . at the same time , an interest is now growing to temperature effects in atomic condensates .
@xcite study theoretically the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) transition associated with the proliferation of thermally - excited vortex - antivortex pairs . for instance , in ref .
@xcite it was shown that in quasi two - dimensional condensates bkt transition can occur at rather low temperatures , @xmath3 , at number of particles in the system @xmath4 .
recently , some signatures of possible bkt phase were also found close to the critical temperature @xmath5 in experimental work bktexper , where condensates in optical lattice have been studied .
finally , experimental evidence for the bkt transition in trapped condensates was reported in ref .
@xcite deal with the thermal fluctuations of positions of vortices in rotated scalar condensates .
note that , according to the mermin - wagner - hohenberg theorem , bose - einstein condensation is not possible in 2d homogeneous systems .
however , application of the trapping potential leads to the macroscopic occupation of the ground state of bose gas .
the aim of the present paper is to study the effect of thermal fluctuations in rotated quasi two - dimensional _ spinor _ condensates .
these systems have a specific degree of freedom , associated with the relative angle among different components of the order parameter corresponding to different hyperfine state .
in other words , this angle determines coherence among components of the order parameter .
also it influences a transverse magnetization of the condensate . in this paper , we focus on thermal fluctuations of this angle .
note that experimentally , at present time , it is possible to study the condensate phase @xcite , see also ref @xcite .
in addition , recently , a new and nondestructive method for measuring the local magnetization of the condensate was proposed and successfully applied in ref .
@xcite .
we show that the relative angle among hyperfine components of the order parameter in 2d case can experience strong thermal fluctuation even at low temperatures .
the reason is the weakness of the spin energy of the system as compared to interactions in density channel .
also fluctuations of this angle lead to significant relative fluctuations of the local transverse magnetization of the condensate , which are much larger in the antiferromagnetic case than in the ferromagnetic one .
this paper is organized as follows . in section
ii , we give a basic formulation of the problem . in section
ii , we discuss our main results for the fluctuations of angle and spin textures .
we conclude in section iii .
we consider harmonically - trapped quasi 2d bose - einstein condensate with spin @xmath0 .
the trapping potential is given by @xmath6 where @xmath7 is a trapping frequency , @xmath8 is the mass of the atom , and @xmath9 is the radial coordinate .
the system is rotated with the angular velocity @xmath10 , well below the critical rotation speed @xmath11 , and the number of atoms in the cloud is @xmath12 . in this paper , we restrict ourselves on the range of temperatures much smaller than @xmath13 .
therefore , we can neglect a noncondensate contribution to the free energy of the cloud .
the total energy of the system in this approximation coincides with the energy of the condensate . for the number of condensed particles
, we use the ideal gas result:@xmath14 .
\label{2}\]]at the same time , @xmath15 where @xmath16 is a riemann zeta function , @xmath17 .
( 2 ) and ( 3 ) remain accurate even for the case of interacting particles @xcite .
we also introduce a dimensionless temperature @xmath18 .
since we are considering low temperatures , @xmath19 , temperature dependence of condensed particles number can be neglected , @xmath20 .
the order parameter in the @xmath0 condensate has three components @xmath21 @xmath22 .
the free energy of the system can be written as machida , ho@xmath23 , \label{4}\end{aligned}\]]where the integration is performed over the system area , repeated indices are summed , @xmath24 @xmath25 is the angular momentum operator , which can be expressed in a matrix form through the usual pauli matrices , @xmath26 is the one - body hamiltonian , given by@xmath27 constants @xmath28 and @xmath29 characterize interactions in density and spin channels and are given by @xmath30 @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are scattering lengths for atoms with total spin 0 and 2 , and @xmath34 is the concentration of atoms in longitudinal direction . in real spinor condensates ,
@xmath35 , since @xmath36 .
typically , @xmath37 , and this ratio can be tuned . in this paper , we study the case of relatively dilute condensate and take @xmath38 .
we will consider different values of @xmath12 but at fixed value of interaction parameter @xmath28 .
this is possible , since , in the case of a single layer cloud , we can always tune the trapping frequency in the longitudinal direction keeping @xmath28 constant . to ensure the regime of quasi - two - dimensionality , we can also tune @xmath7 . in this case
, we have to change the rotation speed to keep the dimensionless rotation speed the same , and the themperature to fix dimensionless @xmath39 . in real atomic condensates
, @xmath40 is approximately several nanometers .
the most realistic value of @xmath12 for this @xmath28 is close to @xmath41 , and to illustrate the effect of @xmath12 we will consider the following range : @xmath42 .
the total magnetization of the condensate is fixed : @xmath43 magnetization @xmath44 is normalized in terms of @xmath12 and maximum of @xmath45 is equal to 1 .
one has also to take into account the normalization condition for the order parameter : @xmath46 the spatial profiles of all the components of the order parameter in the equilibrium can be found from the condition of minimum of energy ( 4 ) .
it is also convenient to introduce the longitudinal @xmath47 and transverse @xmath48 local magnetizations of the condensate : @xmath49 @xmath50 the spin energy in this case can be represented as @xmath51 in this paper , we restrict ourselves only to the case of axially - symmetric phases , when moduli of all the components of the order parameter are independent on the azimuthal angle and depend only on the radial coordinate @xmath52 . note that equilibrium vortex phases in this situation were studied in refs .
@xcite for the spin @xmath0 condensate and in ref .
@xcite for @xmath2 system . for the axially - symmetric phases ,
each component of the order parameter can be represented as @xmath53where @xmath54 is a polar angle , @xmath55 is a winding number , and @xmath56 is a relative phase .
we will denote such phases as ( @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 ) . as it was shown in ref .
@xcite , an axial symmetry of the solution implies that winding numbers satisfy the relation : @xmath60 . in this case , according to eqs .
( 11 ) and ( 12 ) , the spin energy depends on relative angle @xmath61 it is important to note that only a spin contribution to the total energy ( 4 ) depends on phases @xmath62 via the spin - mixing term . for the stationary state , which is a local minimum of gross - pitaevskii functional ( 4 ) ,
the value of @xmath63 is determined by the sign of interaction constant in a spin channel @xmath64 . for positive @xmath64 ( antiferromagnetic case ) ,
a minimum of @xmath65 is attained at @xmath66 , whereas for negative @xmath67 ( ferromagnetic case ) @xmath68 .
according to the results of ref .
@xcite , for the antiferromagnetic state ( @xmath69 ) , phases ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) and ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) are energetically favorable in the region of small and moderate values of magnetization @xmath44 .
phase ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) is realized at low rotation frequencies @xmath70 and ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) at higher @xmath70 . in ref .
@xcite , it was shown that ( 0 , 1 , 2 ) state is favorable in the ferromagnetic case ( @xmath71 ) in a region of moderate values of @xmath70 and @xmath72 in these phases , all three hypefine states are populated .
fluctuations of @xmath63 have a sense only in this case , since the @xmath63-dependent part of the energy is equal to zero identically , if one of the components of the order parameter is zero . in this paper
, we will concentrate on these three vortex states , since they are appropriate candidates for the illustration of the effect of thermal fluctuations .
note that in homogeneous spin-1 condensate atoms populate only two or one hyperfine state(s ) ; they can populate three states only if the system is trapped and experiences rotation , which generates vortices .
an important feature of real atomic spinor bose - einstein condensates is a weakness of the spin interactions comparing to the interaction in density channel ( @xmath73 ) . at the same time
, the coherence among the different components of the order parameter ( angle @xmath63 ) is fully determined by the spin interaction .
angle @xmath63 also influences the transverse magnetization of the condensate , as seen from eq . (
note that a longitudinal component of magnetization is independent on @xmath63 .
smallness of @xmath64 comparing to @xmath28 leads to the fact that thermal fluctuations of relative angle @xmath63 become significant at much lower temperatures than fluctuations of the density of particles .
therefore , at relatively low temperatures , one can assume that the moduli of all the components of the order parameter remain fixed ( that can be also checked numerically ) , whereas @xmath63 is fluctuating . for the case of small fluctuations of @xmath63 , one can use a harmonic approximation and represent the deviation of the energy of the system from the equilibrium , @xmath74 , as a quadratic function in terms of the deviation of angle @xmath63 from the equilibrium @xmath75 :
@xmath76where @xmath77 . under these assumptions ,
the average square of the deviation of @xmath63 from the equilibrium is given by @xmath78 integrals in eq .
( 15 ) can be calculated analytically . after taking into account eq .
( 3 ) , we get:@xmath79we also introduce a quantity @xmath80 , which can be considered as an average deviation of angle @xmath63 from the equilibrium .
we see that @xmath81 depends on dimensionless temperature @xmath82 , the number of particles @xmath12 and integral @xmath83 . for a given vortex phase ,
@xmath83 is also a function of total magnetization @xmath44 .
it is important to emphasize that the scaling relation ( 16 ) has a sense only if @xmath28 is independent of @xmath12 , as discussed above . in order to calculate @xmath83
, we use a variational method , which was previously applied by us in ref .
@xcite to evaluate energies of various axially - symmetric vortex phases in spin @xmath2 condensate . in this approach , each component of the order parameter is modeled by a trial function and values of variational parameters are found from the condition of minimum of total energy . in fig .
1 we plot calculated dependence of @xmath81 ( measured in degrees ) as a function of the number of particles in the system for different vortex phases at @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
this value of @xmath28 is close to typical experimental ones ( @xmath86 nm , @xmath87 nm@xmath88 ) , see also calculations of ref .
we assume that , for ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) and ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) states , @xmath89 and @xmath90 , whereas for ( 0 , 1 , 2 ) , @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
note that @xmath93 for the particular phase is independent on @xmath70 , since @xmath83 has the same property .
we see that even for quite low temperatures , @xmath94 can be rather large and the coherence among different components of the order parameter is practically destroyed . for smaller value of @xmath95 ,
fluctuations of @xmath63 are , of course , even stronger . to illustrate the effect of temperature , in the inset to fig . 1
, we show the dependence of @xmath81 on @xmath96 for ( 0 , 1 , 2)-phase ( curve 1 ) , ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) phase ( curve 2 ) , and ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) phase ( curve 3 ) at fixed number of atoms @xmath97 , @xmath98 for the first curve and @xmath99 for two others .
note that @xmath81 is almost independent on total magnetization @xmath44 of the condensate .
as we already pointed out , fluctuations of @xmath63 lead to that of @xmath48 . in a harmonic approximation , one can express the average deviation of @xmath100 from the equilibrium @xmath101 through the deviation of @xmath102 : @xmath103 where @xmath104 for the antiferromagnetic case and @xmath105 for the ferromagnetic one .
if in the antiferromagnetic state the total magnetization is not large , @xmath106 , one can expect that @xmath107 , and , therefore , even small fluctuations of @xmath63 lead to strong relative fluctuations of @xmath108 . at the same time , for ferromagnetic case , @xmath105 in this equation , and relative fluctuations of @xmath100 are much smaller .
we have calculated @xmath109 for different vortex phases and our calculations revealed that @xmath110 is almost independent on radial coordinate @xmath9 for vortex phases ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) and ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) .
this is due to the fact that @xmath111 for these states , therefore , @xmath112 is nearly proportional to @xmath113 , and , according to eq .
( 15 ) , @xmath114 should only slightly depend on @xmath9 . in fig .
2 we present @xmath115 as a function of total magnetization of the condensate for ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) state at @xmath84 , @xmath89 ( antiferromagnetic case ) , and @xmath116 .
we see that relative fluctuations of transverse magnetization can be significant even at low temperature .
value of @xmath115 decreases with increase of @xmath44 .
this result is natural , since condensate becomes more polarized with growing @xmath44 .
an absolute value of @xmath109 also remains sizable .
although value of fractional quantity @xmath115 is growing with decreasing of @xmath44 , the value of @xmath108 itself becomes smaller .
therefore , we found that the most appropriate values of @xmath44 to observe fluctuations of transverse magnetization is around @xmath117 , where both @xmath118 and @xmath108 are high : @xmath119 , whereas @xmath48 is comparable to the longitudinal magnetization @xmath47 in the fully polarized state at @xmath120 , where it should be easily detectable experimentally .
value of @xmath118 depends also on the vortex phase ; we found that in ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) state it is even much larger than in ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) state .
also we have calculated @xmath109 for the ferromagnetic ( 0 , 1 , 2 ) phase . as can be expected , in this case , relative fluctuations of @xmath121 are much weaker .
physically , this is because @xmath121 is proportional to the ferromagnetic order parameter @xcite , which is responsible for the ferromagnetic ordering .
therefore , one can expect that in the ferromagnetic phase this order parameter is more robust with respect to thermal fluctuations , than in the antiferromagnetic one .
in addition , average deviation of @xmath121 from the equilibrium is negative and its modulus is growing with increase of @xmath44 , in contrast to the antiferromagnetic system .
thermal fluctuations should also be important in the case of @xmath2 condensate , where there are two interaction constants in spin channel and two characteristic angles .
therefore , one can expect more complicated behavior , as compared to @xmath0 condensate .
for instance , in homogeneous @xmath2 system , a cyclic state can have a lowest energy ; in this case atoms populate three hyperfine states , and the spin energy depends on the coherence among them .
fluctuation problem for this system was analyzed in ref .
a new method to create such entangled states in spin-1 condensate was recently applied experimentally in ref .
@xcite , where a microwave energy was injected to the system . as a result , particles redistribute from spin @xmath122 state to spin @xmath123 and @xmath124 states , and all three magnetic sublevels become populated . the spin - mixing dynamics in @xmath0 condensate was studied theoretically in ref .
@xcite . note that in eq .
( 14 ) we have assumed that fluctuating @xmath63 is spatially independent that is not true in general case
. however , spatial gradients of @xmath102 give some additional contribution to the kinetic energy of the system , which is much larger than the spin energy . therefore , gradients of @xmath102 result in rather large increase of total energy , and we can neglect them for the trapped system , at least for our range of parameters . in other words ,
healing length for @xmath63 far exceeds the thomas - fermi radius of the system , and , therefore , although @xmath63 is fluctuating inside the cloud , it remains nearly constant @xcite , except of the surface layer , where the density of particles is low .
thermal fluctuations of @xmath63 should be also noticeable in three - dimensional condensates at low and moderate temperatures .
in general , the dependences of the number of condensed particles on the reduced temperature and critical temperature on the total number of atoms for 3d case are similar to that in 2d system , which are described by eqs .
( 2 ) and ( 3 ) .
the main difference is the powers of @xmath39 and @xmath12 in the right hand sides of eqs .
( 2 ) and ( 3 ) that are @xmath125 and @xmath126 ( @xmath127 ) , respectively .
however , in this case one has to take accurately into account the possibility of long wave length fluctuations of @xmath102 in longitudinal direction and formation of kinks @xcite .
in this paper , we have studied the effect of thermal fluctuations on the coherence among different components of the order parameter in quasi 2d rotating @xmath0 bose - einstein condensate , when all three hyperfine states are populated .
different axially - symmetric vortex phases were considered .
we have shown that the deviation of the relative phase @xmath128 from the equilibrium can be very significant even at low temperatures , much smaller than @xmath5 .
fluctuations of relative angle induce sizable fluctuations of the spin texture , namely , local transverse magnetization of the condensate .
we have shown that these fluctuations are much more pronounced in antiferromagnetic case than in the ferromagnetic one .
the recently proposed in ref .
@xcite direct and nondestuctive method for the imaging of spinor bec spatial magnetization ( or some of its modification ) can be applied for the experimental study of the thermal fluctuations of spin textures , since it enables multiple - shot imaging and one can directly observe the dynamics of a single sample .
authors acknowledge useful discussions with t. k. ghosh and t. mizushima .
w. v. pogosov is supported by the japan society for the promotion of science .
j. stenger , d. m. stamper - kurn , h. j. miesner , a. p. chikkatur , and w. ketterle , nature * 396 * , 345 ( 1999 ) .
t. mizushima , k. machida , and t. kita , phys .
lett . * 89 * , 030401 ( 2002 ) .
t. isoshima and k. machida , phys .
a * 66 * , 023602 ( 2002 ) .
j. w. reijnders , f. j. van lankvelt , k. schoutens , and n. read , phys .
lett . * 89 * , 120401 ( 2002 ) .
k. kasamatsu , m. tsubota , and m. ueda , int .
j. of mod .
b * 19 * , 1835 ( 2005 ) .
w. v. pogosov , r. kawate , t. mizushima , and k. machida , phys .
a * 72 * , 063605 ( 2005 ) .
a. trombettoni , a. smerzi , and p. sodano , new j. phys .
* 7 * , 57 ( 2005 ) .
t. p. simula , m. d lee , and d. a. w. hutchinson , phil . mag .
( in press ) , cond - mat/0412512 . m. holzmann , g. baym , j. p. blaizot , and f. laloe , cond - mat/0508131 .
t. p. simula and p. b. blakie , phys .
* 96 * , 020404 ( 2006 ) .
d. schumayer and d. a. w. hutchinson , cond - mat/0601500 .
s. stock , z. hadzibabic , b. battelier , m. cheneau , and j. dalibard , phys .
95 * , 190403 ( 2005 ) .
z. hadzibabic , p. kruger , m. cheneau , b. battelier , and j. dalibard , to be published in nature ; cond - mat/0605291 .
y. castin , z. hadzibabic , s. stock , j. dalibard , and s. stringari , cond - mat/0511330 .
w. v. pogosov and k. machida , cond - mat/0601604 .
y. j. wang , d. z. anderson , v. m. bright , e. a. cornell , q. diot , t. kishimoto , m. prentiss , r. a. saravanan , s. r. segal , and s. wu , phys .
* 94 * , 090405 ( 2005 ) .
m. h. wheeler , k. m. mertes , j. d. erwin , and d. s. hall , phys .
* 93 * , 170402 ( 2004 ) .
m. saba , t. a. pasquini , c. sanner , y. shin , w. ketterle , and d. e. pritchard , science , * 307 * , 1945 ( 2005 ) .
m. s. chang , q. qin , w. zhang , l. you , and m. s. chapman , nature physics * 1 * , 111 ( 2005 ) .
j. m. higbie , l. e. sadler , s. inouye , a. p. chikkatur , s. r. leslie , k. l. moore , v. savalli , and d. m. stamper - kurn , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 050401 ( 2005 ) . c. gies , b. p. van zyl , s. a. morgan , and d. a. w. hutchinson , phys .
a * 69 * , 023616 ( 2004 ) .
t. ohmi and k. machida , j. phys .
jpn . * 67 * , 1822 ( 1998 ) .
t. l. ho , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 742 ( 1998 ) .
w. v. pogosov and k. machida , cond - mat/0604505 .
h. pu , c. k. law , s. raghavan , j. h. eberly , and n. p. bigelow , phys .
a * 60 * , 1463 ( 1999 ) .
* fig . 1 . * dependences of @xmath81 ( in degrees ) on the number of particles in the system for different vortex phases at fixed value of interaction constant @xmath85 ( see in the text ) and @xmath84 . in the ( -1 , 0 , 1 )
phase , @xmath89 , @xmath90 ; in the ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) state , @xmath129 , @xmath90 ; in the ( 0 , 1 , 2 ) state , @xmath91 , @xmath130 .
inset shows @xmath81 as a function of temperature for ( 0 , 1 , 2 ) phase ( curve 1 ) , ( 1 , 1 , 1 ) phase ( curve 2 ) , and ( -1 , 0 , 1 ) phase ( curve 3 ) at the same values of @xmath44 , @xmath28 and @xmath39 .
number of atoms is @xmath116 , interaction constants are @xmath98 for the first curve and @xmath131 for two others . | we consider the effect of thermal fluctuations on rotating spinor @xmath0 condensates in axially - symmetric vortex phases , when all the three hyperfine states are populated .
we show that the relative phase among different components of the order parameter can fluctuate strongly due to the weakness of the interaction in the spin channel .
these fluctuations can be significant even at low temperatures
. fluctuations of relative phase lead to significant fluctuations of the local transverse magnetization of the condensate .
we demonstrate that these fluctuations are much more pronounced for the antiferromagnetic state than for the ferromagnetic one . |
in our single source model ( updated version is in @xcite ) we explained the knee as the effect of a local , recent supernova , the remnant from which accelerated mainly oxygen and iron .
these nuclei form the intensity peaks which perturb the total background intensity .
the comprehensive analysis of the world s data gives as our datum the plots given in the figure 1 ; these are deviations from the running mean for both the energy spectrum mostly from cherenkov data and the summarised electron size spectrum .
it is against these datum plots that our comparison will be made . in the present work we endeavour to push the subject forward by examining a number of aspects .
they are examined , as follows : + ( i ) can we decide whether the solar system is inside the supernova shock or outside it ?
+ ( ii ) is the identification of oxygen and iron in the peaks correct ? + ( iii ) can both the peaks be due to protons rather than nuclei ? in view of claims from a few experiments ( dice , blanca ) that the mean mass is low in the pev region , it is wise to examine this possibility .
the appreciation that the frequency of sn in the local region of the interstellar medium ( ism ) has been higher than the galactic average , over the past million years , has improved the prospects for the ssm being valid @xcite and thereby increases the probability that we are close to the surface of a remnant .
it is doubtlessly possible for particles to escape from an snr shock and propagate ahead .
such a situation has been considered in the berezhko - model. the problem concerns uncertainties in the diffusion coefficient for the ism ; however , estimates have been made @xcite and figure 1 shows the result for the sun being outside the shock at the distance of 1.5@xmath0 for the center of snr ( @xmath0 is the radius of the remnant ) .
it is seen that the result does not fit well the datum points at all .
the model tested must be rejected in its given form .
it is possible to restore it by taking an energy spectrum of more nearly the form for the inside snr location or at the position outside , but very close to the shell .
the corresponding cureves are shown in figure 1 by full lines .
a tolerable astrophysical case could be made for helium and oxygen rather than oxygen and iron , and the direct measurements at lower energies than the knee region do not really rule it out .
figure 2 shows the @xmath1-values for the corresponding spectra .
the separation of the he and o peaks is a little greater than for o and fe ( 8/2 compared with 26/8 ) and this causes the he , o pattern to be displaced somewhat . although the fit to the datum points is not as good as for o , fe , the he , o combination can not be ruled out on the basis of the @xmath1-plots alone .
the absence of the preferred - by - us nuclei between the two peaks is a worry , though ( incertion of carbon does not help to fill the gap between two peaks ) .
the fe peak would then be expected at log(@xmath2 ) = 1.1 .
calculations have been made for the case of two proton peaks , the proton spectra having been taken to be the standard interior - to - the snr form . the result is also shown in figure 2 .
an interesting situation develops here .
although it is possible to tune either the energy spectrum or the size spectrum to fit the @xmath1-results , it is not possible to choose an energy spectrum which fits both .
this arises because of the sensitivity of the number of electrons at the detection level to the primary mass . in figure 2 the separation of the proton peaks in the energy spectrum
was chosen such that the @xmath1-distribution for shower size was a reasonable fit to the data .
however , the separation of the peaks in the energy spectrum necessary for the shower size fit is less than that for o , fe by 0.15 ; the result is that after the necessary binning ( 0.2 in @xmath3 units ) for the energy spectrum there is no agreement there .
it is evident from the foregoing that the two - proton peak model is unacceptable .
this result cast doubt on the analyses of eas data which conclude that the mean primary mass is low ( @xmath4 ) in the pev region .
as mentioned already , it is our view that some , at least , of the models used in the mass analyses are inappropriate for the interactions of nuclei , particularly for the production and longitudinal development of the electromagnetic component .
it is interesting to know , in connection with mean mass estimates , that the recent work using the tibet eas array @xcite has given strong support for the result - favoured by us - in which the average cosmic ray mass increases with energy .
in fact , their mass is even higher than ours : @xmath5 , compared with our 2.4 , at 1 pev , and 3.3 , compared with 3.0 at 10 pev . equally significant
is the fact that the sharpness of the iron component that they need to fit the overall data is quite considerable : @xmath6 = 1.4 .
it will be remembered that straightforward galactic diffusion - the conventional model - gives @xmath7 for any one mass component and @xmath8 for the whole spectrum @xcite .
returning to the question of our location with respect to the snr it seems difficult to account for the @xmath1-distribution if we are some distance outside the shell , unless the diffusion coefficient for cosmic ray propagation in the ism is almost energy - independent .
we appear to be inside , or only just outside .
finally , concerning the nature of the peaks : o , fe or he , o , it is difficult to rule out the latter from the @xmath1-plots alone , although the lack of an iron peak is surprising . however , there is some evidence from the tunka-25 cherenkov experiment for a further peak at roughly the correct energy for the third ( fe ) peak @xcite .
there is also a hint of a peak in kascade spectrum , which is observed at an even higher energy than in tunka-25 @xcite .
most other experiments - but not all - do not have the sensitivity to detect a further peak so the situation here is still open . we still prefer our original suggestion , viz . that the peaks are due to o and fe , and their shape is the consequence of the sharp cut - off in the energy spectrum of particles accelerated by snr .
the main reason for the preference is the fact that o and fe spectra extrapolate and fit direct measurements of those components rather well @xcite and there are good astrophysical reasons favouring these nuclei .
the single source model , with its explanation of the knee in the cosmic ray energy spectrum in terms of particles ( probably principally nuclei of oxygen and iron ) from a recent , local sn , has been examined further .
it is true that the identity of the nuclei is not completely secure and it is just possible that rather than o , fe , the combination is he , o : however , we still prefer the original explanation . the question of the nature of the particles responsible for the knee is , therefore , still somewhat uncertain ; however , that there is structure in the spectrum , indicative of a single source , seems to be rather secure .
99 erlykin a.d . ,
wolfendale a.w . , 2001 ,
g : nucl . part .
phys . , * 27 * , 1005 erlykin a.d . , wolfendale a.w . , 2001 , j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
* 27 * , 941 erlykin a.d . ,
wolfendale a.w . , 2001 ,
g : nucl . part .
* 27 * , 959 berezhko e.g. et al . , 1996 , jetp ,
* 82*,1 berezhko e.g. , 1999 ( private communication ) amenomori m. et al
. 2000a , phys .
d , * 62 * , 112002 ; 2000b , phys .
d , * 62 * , 072007 erlykin a.d .
, wolfendale a.w . , 1997 , j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
phys . , * 23 * , 979 ; 1998a , astropart
* 8 * , 265 ; 1998b , j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
* 9 * , 213 budnev n. et al .
2002 , 18 ecrs , moscow ( to be published ) schatz g. , 2002 , astropart . phys . ,
* 17 * , 13 erlykin a.d .
1998 , astropart .
* 8 * , 283 | an analysis is made of the masses and spectral features for cosmic rays in the pev region , insofar as they have a bearing on the problem of the interaction of cosmic ray particles . in our single source model
we identified two peaks seen in a summary of the world s data on primary spectra , and claimed that they are probably due to oxygen and iron nuclei from a local , recent supernova . in the present work
we examine other possible mass assignments .
we conclude that of the other possibilities only helium and oxygen ( instead of o and fe ) has much chance of success ; the original suggestion is still preferred , however . concerning our location with respect to the snr shell , the analysis suggests that we are close to it - probably just inside . |
millisecond pulsars ( msps ) have for some time been known to exhibit exceptional rotational stability , with decade long observations providing timing measurements with accuracies similar to atomic clocks ( e.g. ) .
such stability lends itself well to the pursuit of a wide range of scientific goals , e.g. observations of the pulsar psr b1913 + 16 showed a loss of energy at a rate consistent with that predicted for gravitational waves @xcite , whilst the double pulsar system psr j0737 - 3039a / b has provided precise measurements of several ` post keplerian ' parameters allowing for additional stringent tests of general relativity @xcite . for a detailed review of pulsar timing
refer to e.g. @xcite . in brief , the arrival times of pulses ( toas ) for a particular pulsar will be recorded by an observatory in a series of discrete observations over a period of time .
these arrival times must all be transformed into a common frame of reference , the solar system barycenter , in order to correct for the motion of the earth . a model for the pulsar
can then be fitted to the toas ; this characterises the properties of the pulsar s orbital motion , as well as its timing properties such as its orbital frequency and spin down .
this is most commonly carried out using the tempo2 pulsar - timing packages @xcite , or more recently , the bayesian pulsar timing package temponest @xcite . when performing this fitting process , both tempo2 and temponest assume purely gaussian statistics in the properties of the uncorrelated noise . in realistic datasets , however , this assumption is not necessarily correct .
if the underlying probability density function ( pdf ) for the noise is not gaussian , for example , if there is an excess of outliers relative to a gaussian distribution , modifiers to the toa error bars that scale their size are used to find the best approximation to a gaussian distribution .
this can be performed using a single modifier for a given receiving system determined across an entire dataset , or as in the ` fixdata ' plugin for tempo2 @xcite , where the modifier is determined separately for a series of short time lags .
while the latter of these two approaches can better account for a non - gaussian distribution in the uncorrelated noise , it does so at the expense of a potentially large number of additional free parameters , and ultimately does not address the core issue , that the underlying distribution is not gaussian .
both approaches then have the direct consequence of decreasing the precision with which one can estimate the timing parameters , and any other signals of interest , such as intrinsic red spin noise due to rotational irregularities in the neutron star @xcite or correlated noise due to a stochastic gravitational wave background ( gwb ) generated by , for example , coalescing black holes ( e.g. @xcite ) .
indeed , currently all published limits on the signals induced by a gwb have been obtained under the assumption that the statistics of the toa errors are gaussian ( see e.g. @xcite ) . in this paper
we introduce a method of performing a robust bayesian analysis of non - gaussianity present in pulsar timing data , simultaneously with the pulsar timing model , and additional stochastic parameters such as those describing the red noise , and dispersion measure variations .
the parameters used to define the presence of non - gaussianity are zero for gaussian processes , giving a simple method of defining the strength of non - gaussian behaviour . in section [ section : bayes ]
we will describe the basic principles of our bayesian approach to data analysis , giving a brief overview of how it may be used to perform model selection , and introduce multinest . in sections [ section :
nongausslike ] and [ section : toy ] we introduce the non - gaussian likelihood we will use in our pulsar timing analysis , and apply it to a simple toy problem . in section [ section : pulsarnongaussian ] we then extend this likelihood to the subject of pulsar timing , and apply it to both simulated and real data in sections [ section : pulsarsims ] and [ section : realdata ] respectively , before finally offering some concluding remarks in section [ section : conclusion ] .
this research is the result of the common effort to directly detect gravitational waves using pulsar timing , known as the european pulsar timing array ( epta ) @xcite .
given a set of data @xmath1 , bayesian inference provides a consistent approach to the estimation of a set of parameters @xmath2 in a model or hypothesis @xmath3 . in particular ,
bayes theorem states that : @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the posterior probability distribution of the parameters , @xmath6 is the likelihood , @xmath7 is the prior probability distribution , and @xmath8 is the bayesian evidence .
since the evidence is independent of the parameters @xmath2 it is typically ignored when one is only interested in performing parameter estimation . in this case inferences
are obtained by taking samples from the ( unnormalised ) posterior using , for example , standard markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) sampling methods . for model selection ,
however , the evidence is key , and is defined simply as the factor required to normalise the posterior over @xmath2 : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the dimensionality of the parameter space . as the evidence is just the average of the likelihood over the prior
, it will be larger for a simpler model with a compact parameter space if more of that parameter space is likely .
more complex models where large areas of parameter space have low likelihood values will have a smaller evidence even if the likelihood function is very highly peaked , unless they are significantly better at explaining the data .
thus , the evidence automatically implements occam s razor .
the question of model selection between two models @xmath11 and @xmath12 can be answered via the model selection ratio @xmath13 , commonly referred to as the ` bayes factor ' : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the a priori probability ratio for the two models , which in this work we will set to unity but occasionally requires further consideration .
the bayes factor then allows us to obtain the probability of one model compared the other simply as : @xmath16 in practice when performing bayesian analysis we do not work with the likelihood , but the log likelihood . in this case
the quantity of interest is the log bayes factor , which is simply the difference in the log evidence for the two models .
for example , a difference in the log evidence of 3 for two competing models gives a bayes factor of @xmath17 , which in turn gives a probability of @xmath18 .
we use the difference in the log evidence in sections [ section : pulsarsims ] and [ section : realdata ] to perform model selection between our gaussian and non - gaussian models .
while many techniques exist for calculating the evidence , such as thermodynamic integration @xcite , it remains a challenging task both numerically and computationally , with evidence evaluation at least an order - of - magnitude more costly than parameter estimation .
nested sampling @xcite is an approach designed to make the calculation of the evidence more efficient , and also produces posterior inferences as a by - product .
the multinest algorithm ( @xcite ) builds upon this nested sampling framework , and provides an efficient means of sampling from posteriors that may contain multiple modes and/or large ( curving ) degeneracies , and also calculates the evidence .
since its release multinest has been used successfully in a wide range of astrophysical problems , including inferring the properties of a potential stochastic gravitational wave background in pulsar timing array data @xcite , and is also used in the bayesian pulsar timing package temponest .
this technique has greatly reduced the computational cost of bayesian parameter estimation and model selection , and is employed in this paper .
in this section we will outline the method adopted for including non - gaussian behaviour in our analysis .
we use the approach developed in @xcite , which is based on the energy eigenmode wavefunctions of a simple harmonic oscillator .
we will describe this in brief below in order to aid future discussion .
we begin by considering our data , the vector @xmath19 of length @xmath20 , as the sum of some signal @xmath21 and noise @xmath22 such that : @xmath23 we can then construct the likelihood that the residuals after subtracting our model signal from the data follows an uncorrelated gaussian distribution of width @xmath24 as : @xmath25,\ ] ] with @xmath26 the diagonal noise covariance matrix for the residuals , such that @xmath27 , and @xmath28 the determinant of @xmath26 .
we now extend this to the general case in order to allow for non - gaussian distributions by modelling our pdf as the sum of a set of gaussians , modified by hermite polynomials @xmath29 ( see e.g. @xcite for previous uses of hermite polynomials in describing departures from gaussianity ) , defined as : @xmath30 therefore , for a general random variable @xmath31 the pdf for fluctuations in @xmath31 can be written : @xmath32\left|\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\alpha_nc_nh_n\left(\frac{x}{\sqrt{2}\sigma}\right)\right|^2\ ] ] with @xmath33 free parameters that describe the relative contributions of each term to the sum , and @xmath34 is a normalization factor
. equation [ eq : prx ] forms a complete set of pdfs , normalised such that : @xmath35c_nh_n\left(\frac{x}{\sqrt{2}\sigma}\right)c_mh_m\left(\frac{x}{\sqrt{2}\sigma}\right ) = \delta_{mn},\ ] ] with @xmath36 the kronecker delta , where the ground state , @xmath11 , reproduces a standard gaussian pdf , and any non - gaussianity in the distribution of @xmath31 will be reflected in non - zero values for the coefficients @xmath33 associated with higher order states .
the only constraint we must place on the values of the amplitudes @xmath37 is : @xmath38 with @xmath39 the maximum number of coefficients to be included in the model for the pdf .
this is performed most simply by setting : @xmath40 we can therefore rewrite eq . [
eq : gausslike ] in this more general form as : @xmath41\nonumber \\ & \times&\prod_{i=1}^{n_d}\left|\sum_{n=0}^{n_{\mathrm{max}}}\alpha_nc_nh_n\left(\frac{d_i - s_i}{\sqrt{2}\sigma}\right)\right|^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the advantage of this method is that one may use a finite set of non - zero @xmath33 to model the non - gaussianity , without mathematical inconsistency .
any truncation of the series still yields a proper distribution , in contrast to the more commonly used edgeworth expansion ( e.g. @xcite ) .
before applying the formalism described in section [ section : nongausslike ] to the practice of pulsar timing , we first demonstrate its use in a toy problem .
here our data vector @xmath19 contains 10000 points drawn from a non - gaussian distribution obtained using eq .
[ eq : prx ] , with parameters listed in table [ table : toyparams ] .
.parameters used to generate non - gaussian noise in a simple toy problem . [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] [ table : logevidence ] table [ table : logevidence ] lists the log evidence values for different sets of non - gaussian coefficients , normalised such that the log evidence for no additional coefficients ( i.e. assuming gaussian statistics ) is 0 .
we see that there is a significant increase in the log evidence ( @xmath42 39 ) when including even just two coefficients , indicating definitive support for their inclusion in the model . as the number increases the rise in evidence increases , reaching a maximum with 4 included coefficients .
given the timing model , red noise and dispersion measure variation solutions that were subtracted from the data were obtained from a gaussian analysis , we will however still include coefficients up to and including @xmath43 in the full analysis .
given the large dimensionality of the problem this analysis can not be carried out using multinest . as such we make use of the guided hamiltonian sampler used previously in pulsar timing analysis in @xcite .
this sampler makes use of both gradient information in the likelihood , and also the hessian in order to efficiently sample from large parameter spaces .
table [ table:0437 ] lists the timing model parameter estimates and their nominal standard deviations for both the gaussian and non - gaussian analysis . in all cases
we find the parameter estimates and their uncertainties to be consistent between both methods . in fig .
[ figure:0437noise ] ( top ) we show the one and two - dimensional marginalised posterior distributions for the red noise and dispersion measure variation power law amplitudes and spectral indicies for the non - gaussian ( left ) and gaussian ( right ) analysis .
both are also extremely consistent with one another , however when overlaying the two sets of 1-dimensional posterior distributions for each of the 4 parameters separately ( bottom 4 panels ) some differences become apparent between the non - gaussian ( blue dashed lines ) and gaussian ( red solid lines ) analysis . in particular
the dispersion measure variation power law parameter estimates show a slight shift towards higher amplitudes and shallower spectral indices in the non - gaussian case . despite these similarities in the timing and stochastic parameter estimates between the gaussian and non - gaussian analysis , fig .
[ figure:0437pdf ] indicates a definitive detection of non - gaussianity in the dataset , in agreement with the difference in the log evidence for the noise only analysis . in the top plot
we show the one and two - dimensional marginalised posterior distributions for the 5 non - gaussian coefficients fit in the analysis of j0437@xmath04715 .
vertical lines are included at 0 where visible in the plots , however , except for @xmath44 all the coefficients are inconsistent with this value . in the bottom plot
we then show the set of equally weighted pdfs obtained from the non - gaussian analysis ( black lines ) setting @xmath45 .
in addition we over plot the mean of the distribution ( red line ) and a unit gaussian ( blue line ) all of which have been normalised to have a sum of 1 .
the difference between the gaussian and non - gaussian pdfs is clear , with a larger probability for both small ( @xmath46 ) and larger ( @xmath47 ) deviations than given by the gaussian pdf . that such a significant detection of non - gaussianity does not lead to larger changes in the parameter estimates
can potentially be attributed to a frequency dependence on the significance of the @xmath48 parameters . in @xcite
the 10 cm j0437@xmath04715 data was found to be describable through gaussian statistics alone .
this would suggest that the non - gaussianity we detect exists primarily at low frequencies . in figure
[ figure:0437normres ] we show the normalised residuals from fig .
[ figure:0437noise ] separated into its 10 cm , 20 cm and 50 cm components , along with histograms for each wavelength . here
the increase in non - gaussian behaviour can clearly be seen as the wavelength increases .
given the lowest frequencies have the greatest degree of non - gaussianity it is less surprising that there is little impact on the timing or red spin noise parameters , as the low frequency data contributes the least to these parts of the model .
the low frequencies do , however , contribute greatly to the constraints on dispersion measure variations , and it is here we see the greatest difference between the gaussian and non - gaussian models .
lcc + pulsar name & j0437@xmath04715 + mjd range & 50191.055619.2 + data span ( yr ) & 14.86 + number of toas & 5052 + + model parameter & non gaussian & gaussian + right ascension , @xmath48 ( rad ) & 1.20979650940(10 ) & 1.20979650943(11 ) + declination , @xmath49 ( rad ) & @xmath00.82471224153(8 ) & @xmath00.82471224154(8 ) + pulse frequency , @xmath50 ( s@xmath51 ) & 173.6879458121850(3 ) & 173.6879458121849(4 ) + first derivative of pulse frequency , @xmath52 ( s@xmath53 ) & @xmath01.728365(4)@xmath54 & @xmath01.728365(4)@xmath54 + dispersion measure , dm ( @xmath55pc ) & 2.64462(11 ) & 2.64461(11 ) + first derivative of dispersion measure , @xmath56 ( @xmath55pcyr@xmath51 ) & @xmath06(6)@xmath57 & @xmath07(7)@xmath57 + dm2 ( @xmath55 pc yr@xmath53 ) & @xmath01(2)@xmath58 & @xmath01(2)@xmath58 + proper motion in right ascension , @xmath59 ( masyr@xmath51 ) & 121.439(3 ) & 121.441(3 ) + proper motion in declination , @xmath60 ( masyr@xmath51 ) & @xmath071.474(3 ) & @xmath071.474(3 ) + parallax , @xmath61 ( mas ) & 6.4(2 ) & 6.3(2 ) + orbital period , @xmath62 ( d ) & 5.7410462(3 ) & 5.7410461(3 ) + epoch of periastron , @xmath63 ( mjd ) & 54530.1722(3 ) & 54530.1721(3 ) + projected semi - major axis of orbit , @xmath31 ( lt - s ) & 3.36671463(8 ) & 3.36671464(8 ) + longitude of periastron , @xmath64 ( deg ) & 1.35(2 ) & 1.36(2 ) + orbital eccentricity , @xmath65 & 1.91800(14)@xmath57 & 1.91796(15)@xmath57 + first derivative of orbital period , @xmath66 & 3.724(6)@xmath67 & 3.724(6)@xmath67 + first derivative of @xmath31 , @xmath68 ( @xmath69 ) & 1(2)@xmath54 & 1(2)@xmath54 + periastron advance , @xmath70 ( deg / yr ) & 0.0150(12 ) & 0.0150(13 ) + companion mass , @xmath71 ( @xmath72 ) & 0.223(14 ) & 0.223(15 ) + longitude of ascending node , @xmath73 ( degrees ) & 208.0(12 ) & 208.3(13 ) + orbital inclination angle , @xmath74 ( degrees ) & 137.1(8 ) & 137.3(8 ) + [ table:0437 ] + + @xmath75{ngnoise.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=100mm]{gaussnoise.pdf } \\ \hspace{-1.5 cm } \includegraphics[width=100mm]{redamp.pdf } & \hspace{-1.5 cm } \includegraphics[width=100mm]{redspec.pdf } \\ \hspace{-1.5 cm } \includegraphics[width=100mm]{dmamp.pdf } & \hspace{-1.5 cm } \includegraphics[width=100mm]{dmspec.pdf } \\ % \vspace{-1.5 cm } \end{array}$ ] @xmath76{ngterms.pdf } \\
\includegraphics[width=120mm]{ngpdfs.png } \\ % \end{array}$ ] @xmath77{j043710cmnormres_scissored.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=85 mm , height=65mm]{10cmnormreshistogram.png } \\
\includegraphics[width=80mm]{j043720cmnormres_scissored.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=85 mm , height=65mm]{20cmnormreshistogram.png } \\ \includegraphics[width=80mm]{j043750cmnormres_scissored.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=85 mm , height=65mm]{50cmnormreshistogram.png } \\ % \end{array}$ ]
in this paper we have introduced a method of performing a robust bayesian analysis of non - gaussianity present in the residuals in pulsar timing analysis , simultaneously with the pulsar timing model , and additional stochastic parameters such as those describing the red noise , and dispersion measure variations present in the data .
deviations from gaussianity are described using a set of parameters @xmath37 that act to modify the probability density of the noise , such that @xmath78 describes gaussian noise , and any non zero values provide support for non - gaussian behaviour .
the advantage of this method is that one may use a finite set of non - zero @xmath79 to model the non - gaussianity , without mathematical inconsistency .
any truncation of the series still yields a proper distribution , in contrast to the more commonly used edgeworth expansion ( e.g. @xcite ) .
we applied this method to two simulated datasets . in simulation one
the noise was drawn from a non - gaussian distribution , and in simulation 2 it was purely gaussian . in simulation 1 ,
the effect of the non - gaussianity was to introduce a higher proportion of outliers relative to a gaussian distribution .
this resulted in an overestimation of the toa uncertainties when assuming a gaussian likelihood , and decreased the precision with which the timing model parameters could be extracted compared to an analysis that correctly incorporated the non - gaussian behaviour on the noise . in the second case we showed that the parameter estimates of the timing model parameters of interest were consistent when including , or not , the @xmath37 parameters , as is to be expected when the noise is gaussian .
we then applied this method to the publicly available parkes pulsar timing array ( ppta ) data release 1 dataset for the binary pulsar j0437@xmath04715 .
we detect a significant non - gaussian component in the non - thermal component of the uncorrelated noise , however as the non - gaussianity is most dominant in the lowest frequency data the impact on the timing precision in the pulsar is minimal , with only the parameter estimates of the power law dispersion measure variations being visible changed between the gaussian and non - gaussian analysis .
janssen g. h. , stappers b. w. , kramer m. , purver m. , jessner a. , cognard i. , 2008 , in bassa c.,wang z. , cumming a. , kaspiv.m .
, eds , aip conf . proc .
983 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more .
phys . , new york , p. 633
skilling j. , 2004 , in fischer r. , preuss r. , von toussaint u. , eds , aip conf .
735 , bayesian inference and maximum entropy methods in science and engineering .
, new york , p. 395 | we introduce a method for performing a robust bayesian analysis of non - gaussianity present in pulsar timing data , simultaneously with the pulsar timing model , and additional stochastic parameters such as those describing red spin noise and dispersion measure variations .
the parameters used to define the presence of non - gaussianity are zero for gaussian processes , giving a simple method of defining the strength of non - gaussian behaviour .
we use simulations to show that assuming gaussian statistics when the noise in the data is drawn from a non - gaussian distribution can significantly increase the uncertainties associated with the pulsar timing model parameters .
we then apply the method to the publicly available 15 year parkes pulsar timing array data release 1 dataset for the binary pulsar j0437@xmath04715 . in this analysis we present a significant detection of non - gaussianity in the uncorrelated non - thermal noise , but we find that it does not yet impact the timing model or stochastic parameter estimates significantly compared to analysis performed assuming gaussian statistics .
the methods presented are , however , shown to be of immediate practical use for current european pulsar timing array ( epta ) and international pulsar timing array ( ipta ) datasets .
[ firstpage ] methods : data analysis , pulsars : general , pulsars : individual |
the dense knots that populate the closest bright planetary nebula ngc 7293 ( the helix nebula ) must play an important role in mass loss from highly evolved intermediate mass stars and therefore in the nature of enrichment of the interstellar medium ( ism ) by these stars .
it is likely that similar dense condensations are ubiquitous among the planetary nebulae ( odell et al .
2002 ) as the closest five planetary nebulae show similar or related structures .
they are an important component of the mass lost by their host stars , for the characteristic mass of individual knots has been reported as @xmath4 ( from co emission , huggins et al .
2002 ) , @xmath5 ( from the dust optical depth determination by meaburn et al .
( 1992 ) , adjusted for the improved distance ) , and about @xmath6 m@xmath7 ( odell & burkert 1997 , again from the dust optical depth but with better spatial resolution ) , and their number has been variously estimated to be from 3500 ( odell & handron 1996 ) from optical observations to much larger numbers ( 23,000 meixner et al .
2005 , henceforth mx05 ; 20,00040,000 hora et al .
2006 , henceforth h06 ) from infrared imaging .
therefore , these condensations contain a significant fraction to a majority of all the material ejected .
it is an extremely important point to understand if the ism is being seeded by these knots and if they survive long enough to be important in the general properties of the ism and also the process of formation of new stars . to understand those late phases ,
long after the knots have escaped the ionizing environment of their central stars , one must understand their characteristics soon after their formation - which is the subject of this study .
there has been a burst of interest in the helix nebula and its knots beginning with the lower resolution groundbased study of meaburn et al .
( 1992 ) and the hubble space telescope ( hst ) images at better than 0.1 resolution ( odell & handron 1996 , odell & burkert 1997 ) in the optical window . the entire nebula has been imaged in the h@xmath1 _ v_=1 - 0 s(1 ) 2.12 @xmath0 m line at scales and resolutions of about 4 ( speck et al .
2002 ) , and 1.7/pixel ( h06 ) , while huggins et al .
2002 ) have studied one small region at 1.2 resolution , and the nic3 detector of the nicmos instrument of the hst has been used by meixner et al .
( 2004 , mx05 ) to sample several outer regions at about 0.2 resolution .
a lower resolution ( 2 ) study in the longer wavelength 0 - 0 rovibrational lines has imaged the entire nebula with the spitzer space telescope ( h06 ) , extending a similar investigation by cox et al .
( 1998 , henceforth cox98 ) at 6/pixel with the infrared space observatory .
radio observations of the co ( huggins et al .
2002 , young et al .
1999 ) and h i ( rodrguez et al .
2002 ) emission have even lower spatial resolution , but , the high spectral resolution allows one to see emission from individual knots .
the three dimensional model for the helix nebula has also evolved during this time .
we now know that the inner part of the nebula is a thick disk of 500 diameter seen at an angle of about 23 from the plane of the sky ( odell et al .
2004 , henceforth omm04 ) .
this disk has a central core of high ionization material traced by he ii emission ( 4686 ) , and a series of progressively lower ionization zones until its ionization front is reached .
the more easily visible lower ionization portions of the inner - disk form the inner - ring of the nebula .
there are polar plumes of material perpendicular to this inner disk extending out to at least 940 ( omm04 ) to both the northwest and southeast .
there is an apparent irregular outer - ring which meaburn et al .
( 2005 , henceforth m05 ) argue is a thin layer of material on the surface of the perpendicular plumes , whereas omm04 ) and odell ( 2005 ) argue that this is due to a larger ring lying almost perpendicular to the inner disk . the nature of the knots has attracted considerable attention .
odell & burkert ( 1997 ) determined the properties using hst wfpc2 emission line images in h@xmath8 , [ n ii ] , and [ o iii ] , while odell et al .
( 2000 , henceforth ohb00 ) analyzed hst slitless spectra of the bright knot 378 - 801 in h@xmath8 and [ n ii ] , an investigation extended in a study ( odell et al , henceforth ohf05 ) with better slitless images in the same lines and also the [ o i ] line at 6300 .
we will adopt the position based designation system described in odell & burkert ( 1997 ) and the trigonometric parallax distance of 219 pc from harris et al .
the object 378 - 801 is the best studied of the knots and the primary target for the program reported upon in this paper . at 219 pc distance from the sun , the 1.5 chord of the bright cusp surrounding the neutral central core of 378 - 801
is @xmath9 cm .
odell & burkert ( 1997 ) estimate that the peak density in the ionized cusp is about 1200 @xmath10 and the central density of the core , derived from the optical depth in dust , is @xmath11 @xmath10 , a number similar to the h@xmath1 density of @xmath1210@xmath13 @xmath10 necessary to produce the thermalized population distribution found for the j states within the @xmath14 levels of the electronic
( x @xmath15 ) ground state by cox98 .
cox98 determined that two sample regions of knots were close to a population distribution of about 900 k , a similar result is found by an analysis ( 4.2 ) of new observations ( h06 ) of different regions of knots . as was argued in odell & handron ( 1996 ) ,
the knots are neutral condensations ionized on the side facing the central star .
lpez - martn et al .
( 2001 ) have shown that the early apparent discrepancy between the observed and predicted surface brightness of the bright cusps is resolved once one considers the dynamic nature of the flow from the cusp ionization front , which depresses the recombination emission from the ionized gas .
the central cores are molecular , being visible in co ( huggins et al .
2002 ) , and producing the multiple velocity components one sees in the low spatial resolution - high velocity resolution co studies ( young et al .
the h@xmath1 emission is produced in a thin layer of material immediately behind the ionized cusp ( huggins et al .
ohb00 show that the optical structure within the ionized cusp can only be explained if the material is heated on a timescale that is longer than the time for cool material to flow from the ionization front across the width of the cusp .
this slow heating rate means that forbidden lines are seen only further away from the ionization front ( because these require energetic electrons to cause their collisional excitation ) whereas recombination lines like h@xmath8 arise preferentially from the cool regions closer to the ionization front .
a succession of papers ( burkert & odell 1998 ; ohb00 , ohf05 ) attempting to simultaneously account for both the ionization and flow of material have produced a general model where cool material in the molecular central core flows towards the ionization front , is slowly heated , and upon passing through the ionization front is more rapidly heated and accelerated . at first examination the most recent models look satisfactory .
however , the models fail because the theoretically expected zone of 900 k gas has much too low a column density to account for the observed surface brightness in h@xmath1 ( ohf05 ) .
these h@xmath1 observations must be telling us about something overlooked in previous models . as we discuss in 4.4 , this missing ingredient seems to be that the earlier models were for a static structure , whereas the knots are actually in a state of active flow .
this paper reports on work intended to clarify the nature of the knots in the helix nebula .
new observations with all three of the imaging instruments on the hst were made and are described in
2 , then analyzed in 3 .
a new and more refined theoretical model is presented in 4 , while these and other recent observations and models are discussed in 5 .
in this investigation we draw on both our own new observations made with the hst and published observations made with a variety of telescopes .
these observations range from the optical through the infrared .
the new hst observations were made during eight orbits over the period 2006 may 22 - 24 as program go 10628 ( co - author odell as principlal investigator ) .
the helix nebula is sufficiently large that we could simultaneously observe it with the three operating imaging instruments , the wfpc2 ( holtzman et al . 1995 ) , the nicmos ( thompson et al . 1998 ) , and the acs ( gonzaga , s. et al . 2005 ) . by careful selection of the pointing and orientation of the spacecraft , we were able to sample three regions that are useful for understanding the knots and their structure . in each case
the new observations are either unique or of substantially longer exposure time than previous similar observations .
the placement of the fields of view are shown in figure 1 .
the nicmos observations were made with the nic3 camera ( 256x256 pixels , each about 0.2/pixel ) , with eight exposures in both the f212n ( isolating the 2.12 @xmath0 m h@xmath1 line and the underlying continuum ) and the f215n ( isolating primarily the underlying continuum as there are no strong lines in this region ) filters .
each of the sixteen exposures was 1280 s duration .
the pointing was changed in a four position pattern , with steps of 5 .
the on - the - fly standard processing image products were our starting point .
these images were combined using iraf and tasks from the hst data processing stsdas package provided by the space telescope science institute ( stsci ) .
the method of calibration used in ohf05 was adopted , where the nebular and instrumental continuum was subtracted using the signal from the f215n filter .
the resultant image is shown in figure 2 along with aligned wfpc2 optical emission line images from programs go 5086 and 5311 .
the knot 378 - 801 is located in the low central region of each image and details of its bright cusp and tail are analyzed in 3.1 and 3.2 .
it is notable that all of the h@xmath1 cusps have corresponding h@xmath8 and [ n ii ] counterparts and that all of the h@xmath8 and [ n ii ] cusps have h@xmath1 counterparts on these well exposed , high resolution images .
a field to the southsoutheast of the central star and falling into the outer - ring portion of the helix nebula was imaged with the acs camera .
eight exposures of nominally 1200 s each were made in both the f658n filter ( which passes the h@xmath8 and [ n ii ] 6583 lines equally well ) and the f502n filter ( dominated by the [ o iii ] 5007 line ) .
the field of view shown in figure 1 overlaps only slightly with the acs mosaic built up during the go 9700 survey with the same filter pairs ( omm04 ) . the signal to noise ratio was much higher than in the go 9700 survey since that study used total exposures of about 850 s in both of filters .
the images in the four offset pointings were combined using tasks within the stsdas package .
no attempt at absolute calibration was made because of the f658n filter requiring additional observations with the f660n filter , which is dominated by [ n ii ] ( odell 2004 ) . the resulting image for f658n
is shown in figure 3 .
originally of 0.05 pixels , it has been averaged into 2x2 samples in order to increase the signal to noise ratio . since the finest features are larger than the size of the resultant pixels ( 0.1 ) no loss of detail was incurred .
the f502n image is much lower signal and is not presented here , although portions of it are reproduced and discussed in 3.4 .
sixteen exposures of 1100 s each were made with the wfpc2 f469n filter that isolates the he ii recombination line at 4686 .
the images from the four pointings were combined using the stsdas package of _ dither _ tasks and the results are shown in figure 4 . for comparison ,
a matching section of the acs mosaic that was derived as part of program go 9700 ( omm04 ) is also shown .
there are three recent papers that contain observations pertinent to our discussion of the nature of the knots in the helix nebula .
these include two space infrared observations and one groundbased study . in a recent paper h06
present the results of an extensive observational study of the helix nebula .
they have imaged the object out to the northeast - arc ( omm04 ) with the irac camera ( fazio et al .
2004 ) in four broad filters centered on 3.6 @xmath0 m , 4.5 @xmath0 m , 5.8 @xmath0 m , and 8.0 @xmath0 m .
these filters are dominated by emission from rovibrational lines within the @xmath14 ground electronic state , although an atomic continnum must be present in addition to a few collisionally excited forbidden and recombination emission lines .
the resolution of these images is about 2 , so that one can not resolve structure within the cusps , but one can see structure along radial lines passing through the bright cusps and their much longer tails .
spectra were obtained with the irs ( houck et al .
2004 ) at three positions , two falling in the outer - ring at locations north and southwest of the central star and the third location ( used for background subtraction ) falling directly on the fainter northeast - arc feature .
they present calibrated fluxes for rovibrational lines of h@xmath1 from 0 - 0 s(7 ) at 5.51 @xmath0 m out to 0 - 0 s(1 ) at 17.0 @xmath0 m .
they also present a groundbased image in a filter centered on the 2.12 @xmath0 m h@xmath1 line which is of comparable spatial resolution but wider field of view that the speck et al .
( 2002 ) study .
this image is not flux calibrated but appears to go fainter than the speck et al .
( 2002 ) image . in the program go 9700 study that produced a continuous mosaic of acs images mx05 also obtained parallel nic3 images in the f212n filter at six science positions and one sky position .
each position was actually a double exposure of two pointings , which allowed a slight overlap of the nic3 fields .
the total exposure at each position was about 750 s and double that in the regions of overlap .
the method of calibration was different as only f212n images were obtained ( the few f175w images were not useful for calibration of the f212n images ) . it was assumed that the sky images included all the background signal that need to be subtracted , which means that it did not subtract nebular continuum .
the nic3 images are under - sampled ( the pixel size of 0.2 is about the same as the telescope s resolution at this wavelength ) as in our new observations of the field around 378 - 801 . when comparing the data , one should note that the maximum effective exposure time is about 1500 s for the go 9700 f212n images , while in our study it is 10,240 s. as discussed in 3.4 , our acs field overlaps with much of the mx05 position 2 field , allowing a more meaningful comparison of optical and infrared images of this region than was possible in the mx05 study .
these new images of the helix nebula with three different hst cameras provide new information on a number of subjects related to the nature and formation of the knots .
the nicmos h@xmath1 image allows a discussion of the cusp and tail structure , the he ii image places constraints on the location of the knots to the southwest , and the acs images allow a more complete comparison of early h@xmath1 images to the south and southeast with comparable resolution optical emission line images .
the new nic3 h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m line observations were scaled to the same pixel size as the wfpc2 ( 0.0996/pixel ) using bilinear interpolation and carefully aligned .
although this region has been imaged numerous times in this line , this is clearly the best image in terms of both its resolution and signal .
the three primary optical line images and the new h@xmath1 image are shown in figure 2 . in order to make a quantitative analysis ,
the images were rotated and a sample three pixels wide along the axis of the cusp - core - tail was made .
the results are shown in figure 5 , where the peak value of the h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m and [ nii ] emission is normalized to unity as are the outer portions of the [ oiii ] profiles . 2.12 @xmath0 m infrared line .
the 2.12 @xmath0 m image has lower resolution ( about two pixels ) and a comparison of the appearance in the different lines is discussed in the text . ]
the optical line results are similar to those found by odell & burkert ( 1997 ) , burkert & odell ( 1998 ) , odell , henney , & burkert ( 2000 ) and ohf05 in that the ionization occurring furthest from the knots ionization front ( [ o iii ] ) is weak and extended , this intrinsic low brightness allows one to see the core of the knot in silhouette against the background nebular emission in this line .
although the extinction peaks in the core of the knot , it extends to about 5 from the bright cusp .
the [ n ii ] emission is strong and displaced ( 0.05 ) away from the ionization front with respect to the h@xmath8 emission .
one sees extinction in h@xmath8 from the core out to almost the same distance as in [ o iii ] .
the lack of apparent extinction in [ n ii ] must be due to there being relatively more emission in that line in the sheath of ionized gas surrounding the shadow of the knot .
the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the h@xmath8 and the [ n ii ] images are 0.48 and since the fwhm of the stars in the field of view is 0.25 , quadratic subtraction of this instrumental component leaves an intrinsic line width in those emission lines of 0.41 .
the fwhm of the h@xmath1 line is 0.61 and the nearby star s is 0.42 , leaving an intrinsic fwhm for h@xmath1 of 0.44 with a peak displaced 0.11 towards the core of the knot from the h@xmath8 peak .
the fwhm corresponds to a length of @xmath16 cm and the displacement to @xmath17 cm .
the ionized line characteristics are similiar to those found in the previous studies , but we have added here the important characteristic of the small but certain displacement of the broader h@xmath1 .
the earlier h@xmath1studies lacked the resolution to determine this characteristic , or in the case of mx05 , lacked the high resolution optical lines necessary for the comparison .
the calibrated peak surface brightness in the cusp of 378 - 801 is @xmath18 @xmath19 in the h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m line .
this agrees well with the peak value of @xmath20 @xmath19 found by huggins et al .
( 2002 ) , where they used the calibration of speck et al .
( 2002 ) and utilized a spatial resolution that would not have recognized the narrowness of the peak . the well defined tail in 378 - 801 is primarily formed by a shadow in the ionizing lyman continuum ( lyc ) radiation cast by the optically thick core , with illumination occurring by diffuse ( recombination ) lyc photons and direct radiation grazing the edge of the core .
the first order theory describing this situation was presented by cant et al .
( 1998 ) and applied to the tails of the helix nebula and the shadows behind the orion nebula proplyds soon after ( odell 2000 ) . ohf05 discussed the structure in tail of 378 - 801 within the light of this theory and its next order refinements ( wood et al .
2004 ) , but were unable to explain the details of what was being seen .
h@xmath1 in the tails was first detected by walsh & ageorges ( 2003 ) and we are able to establish with our new observations where this emission arises . we present in figure 6 results from traces across the tail of 378 - 801 extending from 3.1 to 6.0 behind the peak of the cusp in h@xmath8 .
this region does not extend as far as the partially obscured knot lying on the east side of the tail with its cusp 8.3 beyond 378 - 801 s h@xmath8 cusp .
one sees that there is a well defined signature of a limb brightened sheath in both h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m and h@xmath8 , with the peaks of the h@xmath1 emission occuring inside the h@xmath8 , as expected if the h@xmath8 is associated with a local ionization front .
since the gas ionized by diffuse radiation should be much cooler than the directly illuminated nebular gas , the h@xmath8 emissivity would be high and the ionized sheath is well defined .
these observations establish that conditions in the tail do allow an ionization front to form , while cant et al .
( 1998 ) and odell ( 2000 ) had expected that the shadowed region may be fully ionized .
it is not surprising that no [ o iii ] emission is seen , rather , that the dust in the tail , concentrated to the middle of the tail ( as noted by ohf05 ) , causes extinction of the background nebular light .
the apparent quandary , noted in ohf05 , is that the [ n ii ] emission appears to come from inside the ionized sheath of the tail .
we already noted that the h@xmath8 and h@xmath1 structure indicates that an ionization boundary occurs at the edge of the radiation shadow , so there is an apparent contradiction in finding ionized nitrogen emission originating inside an ionization front .
this contradiction is removed by comparison of the [ n ii ] emission and the optical depth , as determined by the [ o iii ] image .
figure 7 shows a comparison of the dust optical depth and the [ n ii ] intensity .
the similarity of the distribution of the optical depth and the [ n ii ] brightness argues that the [ n ii ] is actually nebular or cusp light scattered by the only marginally optically thick ( peak value @xmath21=0.2 column of dust ) .
this feature is easy to see because the expected low electron temperature of the sheath s ionization front would suppress the collisionally excited [ n ii ] .
if our intepretation of [ n ii ] is correct , then there should be a similar component of scattered h@xmath8 radiation .
this may be what somewhat fills - in the region between the two limb - brightened components ( in addition to the low level of surface brightness expected when examining a thin shell ) . in the cusp [ n ii ] is stronger than h@xmath8 emission whereas in this part of the nebula the opposite is true .
this point argues that much of the scattered [ n ii ] emission arises from the nearby bright cusp , rather than the surrounding nebula .
the similar distribution of each argues that the [ n ii ] emission is caused by scattering of nebular [ n ii ] emission , as discussed in the text . ]
the distribution along the tail core is discussed in detail in ohf05 ( their 4.1.2 ) and only a few comments need be added .
the question is complex because the knots seem to originate near the nebular ionization front , then are shaped by the radiation field as the ionization front expands beyond them ( odell et al .
this means that material in the shadowed region will have never seen direct ionizing radiation and could represent pre - knot material from the planetary nebula s photon dominated region ( pdr )
. the other source of tail material could be neutral gas accelerated outwards by the rocket effect ( e.g. mellema et al . 1998 ) .
unfortunately , the high velocity resolution study of co by huggins et al . (
2002 ) does not really illuminate the question .
their angular resolution was a gaussian beam of @xmath22 , with the long axis aligned almost along the axis of the tail of 378 - 801 .
since there was a strong co component coming from the partially shadowed knot lying 8.3 beyond 378 - 801 s h@xmath8 bright cusp , this means that there is a not a clear resolution of the co emission from the core of 378 - 801 and the partially shadowed knot . as a result , one can not hope to interpret the small differences in the position of the peak emission at different velocities as core - tail differences .
this could be done with higher spatial resolution co observations .
figure 4 shows our deep heii images alongside the same field covered at comparable resolution with the acs in h@xmath8+[n ii ] and [ o iii ] .
a detailed comparison of the two images indicates that there is no case of a heii feature corresponding to a h@xmath8+[n ii ] or [ o iii ] feature , nor any heii only features .
the part of the wfpc2 field closest to the central star is 144 distance .
the profile of the heii core of the central disk , to which the knots in this part of the nebula belong ( omm04 ) derived from a wide field of view heii image ( odell 1998 ) shows that the core is down almost to 50% of its peak emission at this distance . if any knots actually occur within the nebula s heii core , we would expect that in the simplest knot models , we would see a heii cusp outside the [ o iii ] zone of each knot and this is not the case .
however , the basic model is not that simple .
the detailed models of ohb00 and ohf05 show that the normal progression of ionization states in the cusp are preserved , that is , closest to the ionization front there is an he@xmath23+h@xmath24 zone , outside of which there is a he@xmath25+h@xmath24 zone , and outside of that a he@xmath26+h@xmath24 . in a nearly constant electron temperature
nebula the innermost zone is best traced by the [ n ii ] emission , the next zone by the [ o iii ] emission , and the outermost zone by the heii emission .
things are not so simple in the case of the knots . as the gas flows through the cusp
it is heated only slowly , so that the collisionally excited [ n ii ] emission peaks further out , where the gas is hotter , more than making up for the lower fraction of n@xmath27 ions . by the time that the second zone is reached
the density has dropped significantly and the [ o iii ] emission is broad and weak .
one would expect to find a heii zone associated with a knot only if the knot lies within the nebula s heii core
. this heii zone would be quite weak because the density of the knot s gas would have been greatly decreased this far out .
moreover , the gas has probably nearly reached the temperature of the nebula and these higher temperatures suppress the emission of this recombination line .
this means that it will be hard to actually detect by their heii emission any knots within the heii core of the nebula .
probably the strongest evidence that no knots exist in the heii core lies in the fact that we do nt see any objects in extinction in any of the observed emission lines . as noted in 2.1.2 ,
our acs field overlapped with one of the double - pointings made with nic3 in f212n as part of program go 9700 ( mx05 ) .
mx05 compared their f212n images with the corresponding five fields in omm04 , where the resolution was about 1and groundbased images were used because the hst acs mosaic did not extend out this far .
this factor of five difference in resolution made it difficult to draw firm conclusions about differences and similarities of appearance .
they did , however , conclude that even their short ( 750 s ) overlapping double exposures were sufficient to establish that the knot cusps were more visible in h@xmath1 . in
2.1.1 we showed that in the vicinity of 378 - 801 that the knots are equally visible in both the ionization cusps and the h@xmath1 cusps . in figure 8
we see a comparison of the go 9700 f212n ( h@xmath1 ) images with our new acs images .
there is an excellent correlation of appearance , although the contrast of the h@xmath1 emission above the essentially zero nebular background is higher than in f658n ( h@xmath8+[n ii ] ) and as usual the knots are only easily seen in the f502n ( [ o iii ] ) when the knot is in the foreground and can be seen in extinction against the background nebular emission . after considering the flexibility of display of the high signal to noise h@xmath8+[n ii ] images , it is difficult to support the conclusion that h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m images are a better way of searching for knot cusps , except for any regions where there is high obscuration . through the new h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m nic3 images in the current program ( go 10628 ) and the earlier mx05 study with shorter exposures ,
there is a larger and hopefully representative sample of resolved h@xmath1 cusps over a wide range of stellar distances ( @xmath28 ) . to look for systematic differences
, we have identified isolated cusps in each of the fields available .
we selected the three closest knots in the go 10628 field , three in both of mx05 s positions one and two , and two in mx05 s positions three and four , no isolated cusps being available in mx05 s position five . in each case
we measured the surface brightness at the peak of the h@xmath1 cusp , the approximate chord across the knot s center , the width of the h@xmath1 cusp , and determined @xmath28 .
the go 10628 and mx05 positions 1 - 4 had average @xmath28 values of 139 , 290 , 278 , 375 , and 464 respectively .
the average surface brightnesses ( in @xmath19 ) of the cusp peaks were @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 .
the average cusp widths were 0.6 , 0.3 , 0.5 , 0.8 , and 1.1 .
the average chord values were 1.5 , 2.5 , 2.2 , 2.4 , and 2.7 .
the most pronounced change in knot characteristic is the cusp peak surface brightness , dropping about linearly with @xmath28 , with the cusp width growing slowly and the chord width more steadily with @xmath28 .
the physical interpretation of these patterns awaits a better understanding of individual knots .
it should be pointed out that the relative physical distances from the stars is likely to be increasing more rapidly than the relative values of @xmath28 .
this is because in the 3-d model of the helix nebula in omm04 , the main disk is inclined at an angle about 23 out of the plane of the sky , with the northwest side closer to the observer , while the outer - disk is inclined about 53 out of the plane of the sky , with the southsoutheast side closer to the observer .
objects associated with the inner - disk would have a distance multiplication factor of 1.09 and those in the outer - disk a multiplication factor of 1.66 .
the objects in the go 10628 nic3 field are almost certainly associated with the inner - disk .
mx05 s positions 1 and 2 could belong with either system ( accurate radial velocities would determine this ) and their positions 3 and 4 are almost certainly associated with the outer - disk .
figure 2 demonstrates the remarkable similarity of appearance of the knots in h@xmath8 and in our f212n ( 2.12 @xmath0 m ) images and we discussed the quantitative properties of 378 - 801 in 3.1 and 3.2 .
we have investigated the similarities of the knots by selecting the nine objects ( including 378 - 801 ) within the nic3 field of view that are sufficiently isolated to allow a good background subtraction .
the peak surface brightness in each cusp was derived in both 2.12 @xmath0 m and h@xmath8 for a sample 3 wfpc2 pixels wide ( 0.3 ) .
the peak surface brightness in the tail of each object was determined in a sample 11 wfpc2 pixels wide ( 1.1 ) across the tail , the closer end of the sample being 20 wfpc2 pixels ( 2.0 ) displaced from the tip of the bright cusp .
we used the 2.12 @xmath0 m calibration described in
2.1.1 and the h@xmath8 calibration of odell & doi ( 1999 ) , expressing the surface brightnesses in units of photons @xmath34 s@xmath35 sr@xmath35 .
the average cusp surface brightness ratio in 2.12 @xmath0m / h@xmath8 was [email protected] .
the average surface brightness ratio for the tail as compared with the cusp was [email protected] in 2.12 @xmath0 m and [email protected] in h@xmath8 .
this means that in the cusp the h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m line alone is putting out more than five times as many photons as in h@xmath8 and that the contrast between the tail and cusp may be slightly higher ( the ratio is lower ) in h@xmath8 than in 2.12 @xmath0 m .
the remarkable similarity of the knots in a recombination line that follows photoionization of atomic hydrogen and emission in a molecular line heretofore assumed to be the result of radiative pumping between electronic states is discussed in 4.5 .
our understanding of the physics of the knots has evolved with a better understanding of a model that satisfactorily explains the knots .
the initial descrepancy between the cusp surface brightness and the simplest photoionization model ( odell & handron 1996 ) was resolved by lpez - martn et al .
( 2001 ) when it was shown that the advection - dominated nature of the flow through the knot ionization fronts leads to a total rate of recombinations in the ionized gas that is significantly below what is predicted from naive models of ionization equilibrium . the peculiar photoionization structure of h@xmath8 and [ n ii ] emission can also be understood in similar terms the heating timescale of the ionized gas is comparable with the dynamic timescales for flow away from the knot surface , leading to resolvable temperature gradients , which strongly affect the relative distribution of recombination line and collisional line emission .
the most refined model is that of ohf05 , which included both the effects of the radiation field and also the hydrodynamic expansion of the knot s ionization front .
it is probably accurate to say that the photoionized portions of the knots are now adequately understood , or at least that the models are broadly consistent with the best observations .
the structure in the tails is only beginning to be understood . to the first order , the tails are the effects of radiation shadows in the dominant ionizing species , the lyc photons ( cant et al .
1998 , odell 2000 ) .
with this paper ( 3.2 ) we have now determined that the well observed tails are ionization bounded , with h@xmath1 sheaths inside the zone of ionized gas that occurs at the edge of the lyc shadow .
the inner part of the tail is dense enough in dust to scatter surrounding nebular light , although the origin of this material as arising from the original process that forms the knots or as material that is moving back from the knot remains uncertain .
the greatest quandary surrounds the explanation of the h@xmath1 zone that is observed immediately inside the ionized cusps of the knots .
the approximate location of this zone of observed h@xmath1 is qualitatively where one would expect it . for reasons given below ,
it is almost certainly not excited by shocks .
other models ( e.g. natta & hollenbach 1998 ) argue that the heating is by absorption of soft x - rays and others that the excitation mechanism is probably fluorescence , where non - ionizing photons from the stellar continuum excite molecules to the b @xmath37 and c @xmath38 electronic states , which then decay , producing the populations of the ground electronic state that give rise to the observed infrared lines . within the core of the knot the density is sufficiently high and the temperature sufficiently low that multiple heavier molecules are formed and the observed co is simply the most easily observed abundant tracer of these heavy molecules .
an alternative method of exciting the h@xmath1 molecules is by shocks . at first
this idea seems attractive because planetary nebulae as a class are known to possess high velocity stellar winds and large scale mass flows with sufficient energy to excite the low lying energy states of h@xmath1 that give rise to the observed infrared lines .
cox98 first pointed out that the lack of a stellar wind ( cerruti - sola & perinotto 1985 ) rules out excitation by wind - driven shocks . a more complete assessment of shocks as the exciting source was given in ohf05 ( their 4.3.2 ) , where it is shown that although h@xmath1 is heated sufficiently immediately behind a transient shock this shock would quickly move through the knot and up the tail .
the well defined location of the h@xmath1 emission zones immediately behind the ionized cusps and the ionized sheath of the tail strongly argues that we are dealing with a quasi - stationary process , rather than something quite dynamic , like shocks .
h06 base their interpretation of h@xmath1 emission on the assumption of shock excitation .
their assumption is based on the weakness of the h@xmath1 1 - 1 s(7 ) line , stating that the radiative models they use predict strong emission in that line , which they do not observe in their spectra .
the shortcomings of that criterion for determining that the excitation comes from shocks , rather than radiative processes is discussed below in 4.1 . as we show in 4.2 ,
the h06 spectra also argue for a high excitation temperature , as found by cox98 .
the h06 shock interpretation of the relative population distribution of the h@xmath1 energy states used six free parameters as it required three different shock velocities , each with a different relative intensity .
this means that one ca nt use the population distribution to confirm that method of excitation . a key element of understanding the h@xmath1 emission is the excitation temperature of the gas .
cox98 used spectra of the h@xmath1 0 - 0 s(2 ) to s(7 ) lines to derive the population of their upper states and found that their two sampled regions matched an excitation temperature of 900@xmath3650 k. we show below ( 4.2 ) that the new spectra of h06 of the h@xmath1 0 - 0 s(1 ) to s(7 ) lines in two additional regions agree with the results of cox98 and support the idea that the h@xmath1 emission comes from gas that is much hotter than the 50 k conditions expected ( ohf05 ) in the core of the knots . ohf05 demonstrated that even their most detailed pdr models could not explain the high surface brightness in h@xmath1 of the knot cusps , an argument first made by cox98 from more general considerations .
the argument reduces to the fact that the observed surface brightness in h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m radiation is too high to be explained by the column density of 900 k h@xmath1 that is predicted .
ohf05 did not have high resolution h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m images of their sample knot ( 378 - 801 ) and a comparison using the results of the new observations reported here are given in 4.5 .
several papers , including the recent mx05 study , have reported that the surface brightnesses are compatible with earlier the theoretical models of natta & hollenbach ( 1998 ) in spite of the fact that those authors point out that the knots do not adhere to their general model and would have a higher surface brightness .
a more complete critique of earlier claims of agreement of theory and observations is given in ohf05 ( 4.3.3 ) . in this section
we present the total flux from the central star and nebula in 4.1 , establish that the knots commonly have high excitation temperatures ( 4.2 ) , show that the absence of strong 1 - 1 s(7 ) emission is not a strong argument for shock excitation of the h@xmath1 ( 4.3 ) , compare the recent data on h@xmath1 emission with the best models ( 4.4 ) , determine that there is no evidence for radial features extending into the middle of the nebula ( 4.5 ) , and critique a recent paper that argues for the tails being formed primarily by hydrodynamic processes in 4.6 .
the emission from the nebula is in at least quasi - equilibrium with radiation from the central star .
this means that the relative fluxes in various nebular and cusp emission lines and in the stellar continuum impose important constraints that must be observed by the correct model for the cusp h@xmath1 emission .
the stellar continuum has been well defined down to 1200 by bohlin et al .
( 1982 ) , who conclude that the star has a luminosity of @xmath39 ( corrected to the trigonometric parallax distance ) and an effective temperature of 123,000 k. in the long wavelength end of the continuum , the flux per wavelength interval is very close to @xmath40 , as expected when one looks at much lower energies than where the peak emission occurs .
this total luminosity corresponds to a flux at the earth of @xmath41 @xmath42 .
natta & hollenbach ( 1998 ) argue that the h@xmath1 is heated by x - rays of greater than 100 ev because only these high energy photons would penetrate the ionization boundary .
there are two emitters in the high energy end of the spectrum , the central star and a high temperature component of about ( 10@xmath43 k ) ( leahy et al .
1994 , leahy et al .
1996 , guerrero et al .
the central star emission in the 0.1 - 2.0 kev range is @xmath44 @xmath42 and the emission from the 10@xmath43 k component is @xmath45 ( leahy et al .
1994 ) .
the wavelength range for the fluorescent pumping mechanism is from about 912 to 1100 as determined by the minimum energy for exciting the lyman bands and the cutoff imposed by the lyc absorption of hydrogen .
extrapolating the continuum from the slightly longer wavelengths that have been observed gives a total flux in this interval of @xmath46 @xmath42 .
if the heating is due to photons above the ionization threshold for neutral hydrogen , then the calculated flux for a 123,000 k blackbody of 120 l@xmath47 in the interval from 13.6 ev through 100 ev is @xmath48 @xmath42 , representing the largest amount of power coming from the central star .
the observed and predicted properties of the star s flux are summarized in table 1 .
[ tab : fluxes ] .nominal fluxes at earth from the helix central star@xmath49 [ cols= " < , > , < ,
< , < " , ] [ tab : gary ] h06 argues that the weakness of the 1 - 1 s(7 ) line shows that the h@xmath50 emission must be shock excited rather than photo excited . since their subsequent interpretation of the observed features of the nebula
are based on this assumption , it merits critical examination .
h06 state , without presenting detailed proof , that the 1 - 1 s(7 ) line is normally strong " under photo excitation .
they did not detect this line , but they did detect the nearby 0 - 0 s(7 ) line . therefore , we base our discussion on the flux ratio of 1 - 1 s(7 ) to the 0 - 0 s(7 ) line .
examination of their spectra ( h06 figure 9 ) indicates that the flux ratio must be less than about 0.1 .
the 1 - 1 s(7 ) appears to be present in the cox98 spectra at a level giving a line ratio of about 0.1 .
figure 10 shows the results for a series of calculations in which isothermal clouds with a range of temperatures and densities was exposed to the radiation field of the central star .
the central star was approximated as a blackbody and the x - ray continua as a series of free - free emitters with the published luminosities and temperatures .
the total continuum was attenuated by an effective column density of 10@xmath51 @xmath34 to approximate the extinction of the ionizing radiation by the h@xmath27 region .
typical planetary nebula abundances and ism grains were assumed .
the clouds had a thickness of @xmath52 cm .
the figure shows the 1 - 1 s(7)/0 - 0 s(7 ) line ratio .
the predicted ratio is generally quite small for the values of the h@xmath1density and temperature considered , approaching the upper limit that we identify above only at combinations of low h@xmath1 density and temperature .
cox98 argue that the total density must exceed 10@xmath13 @xmath10 in order for collisions to dominate and produce the closely single - temperature population distribution .
this would be the density to combine with the derived temperature of 900 k for comparison with the s(7 ) line ratio , if the emitting zone were dominantly molecular hydrogen . in that case
the predicted line ratio is much lower than the upper limit of the observations and one concludes that the observed weakness of the 0 - 0 s(7 ) line is not a useful indicator of the excitation mechanism as assumed by h06 .
ohf05 derived a density of the molecular hydrogen from observations of the 2.12 @xmath0 m line , finding a value of @xmath53 @xmath10 .
however , they assume that the population of the level producing the transition was in lte at 900 k , which seems to be the case as the upper state producing the 2.12 @xmath0 m line falls right on the population distribution for this temperature . using this density
would also still indicate that the s(7 ) line ratio is not a useful indicator of the excitation mechanism .
however , the challenge remains of explaining the unexpected combination of temperature and density .
most of the existing calculations of h@xmath50 population distributions and resulting emission spectra have been done for the case of a pdr near an hii region ( black & van dishoeck 1987 ) .
the stellar radiation field of an o or b star peaks near the wavelengths that excite the electronic transitions of h@xmath1 , about 1000 .
the main effect of illumination by this continuum is absorption into excited electronic states which then decay into excited vibration - rotation levels within the ground electronic state of h@xmath1 . a very non - thermal distribution is produced by these electronic photo excitations , as h06 points out .
however , the cox98 and h06 spectra discussed in the preceding section show that the population distribution within lower levels of h@xmath1 is well matched by a thermal distribution at about 900k .
the non - thermal population distribution produced by o - star photo - excitation is simply not seen .
this is not surprising since the environment is so dissimilar from that near a main sequence o or b star .
the stellar radiation field of the helix nebula central star peaks at much shorter wavelengths than that of an o star , and
4.1.2 shows that the observed stellar continuum in the 912 - 1100 interval is too small to account for the luminosity of the h@xmath1 lines by photo - excitation , since the excitation of the fluorescent lines uses but a small fraction of the total energy in the 912 - 1100 interval .
we agree with h06 , that the pure rotational h@xmath1lines are not photon pumped , but not for the reasons they give .
they are far too bright to be produced by photo - excitation by the current stellar continuum .
we established in 4 that the pdr s of the knots almost certainly can not be powered by shocks .
another energy source is needed . in
4.1.1 and 4.1.2 we examined the energy budget for the helix nebula , establishing that only the central star radiation more energetic than 13.6 ev ( the extreme ultraviolet radiation or euv ) has enough power to drive the large total flux of h@xmath1 emission that is observed , thus expanding upon and quantifying the conclusions in cox98 .
this means that the soft x - ray heating processes and 912 - 1100 ( fuv ) photo - excitation mechanisms ( natta & hollenbach 1998 ) do not explain the helix observations .
the absence of a stellar wind and other time - scale considerations have already established ( ohf05 ) that shocks can not be powering the h@xmath1 emission and in 4.3 we showed why the justification of h06 for a shocks interpretation is incorrect .
although phillips ( 2006 ) established a loose correlation between soft x - ray flux and h@xmath1 emission , this correlation is probably secondary rather than primary , as there is insufficient x - ray emission to power the h@xmath1 emission ; but , the stars that are strong h@xmath1 emitters have high temperatures , like the central star in the helix nebula .
this means that these stars share the property of the euv radiation being dominant over fuv radiation .
clearly a new process is required .
based on this observational foundation , we identify a new state of equilibrium that may be common , but has not previously been identified .
a new mechanism utilizing the euv radiation is briefly described here and will be elaborated upon in a future publication .
the ionized flows from the knots are _ advection dominated _ , meaning that recombinations are relatively unimportant ( henney 2001 ) . as a result , neither the fuv or x - ray models ( hollenbach & tielens 1997 , natta & hollenbach 1998 ) is relevant to the dissociation fronts in the helix knots . instead , the dissociation front merges with the ionization front ( bertoldi & draine 1996 ) and the dissociation of h@xmath50 in this merged front is controlled by the _ ionizing _ euv .
the fact that neutral hydrogen 21 cm is not observed in the inner region of the helix nebula ( rodrguez et al .
2002 ) where the optically bright knots are found supports this model and the appearance of 21 cm emission from the more distant and fainter outer - ring knots indicates that a neutral hydrogen zone is only present there .
the low ionization parameter found in the helix knots leads to substantial deviations from ionization and thermal equilibrium since the dynamical time is shorter than the ionization and heating times .
the effects of this upon the emission from the ionized gas was discussed at length in ohf05 .
the dissociation of h@xmath50 in such a front is predominantly due to chemical reactions with ionized species such as o@xmath54 , and is therefore a strong function of the ionization fraction , which is determined by the absorption of euv radiation .
the radiation field is largely determined by the opacity in the fraction of hydrogen that is neutral , the key element being its determination of the amount of o@xmath54 .
it is the reaction of o@xmath54 with h@xmath1 that destroys the h@xmath1 rather than the much slower rate of photo - dissociation of h@xmath1 .
this is essentially a one - way process , with h@xmath1 entering the zone from the cold molecular core and being converted directly to h@xmath27 .
this transition zone is heated by the photo - ionization of neutral hydrogen and can be quite broad and the preliminary models indicate that it can produce warm h@xmath1 column densities of about 10@xmath55 @xmath34 , as required by the observations ( ohf05 ) . to the best of our knowledge , no models of such euv - dominated dissociation regions have been calculated .
we are calculating detailed models of such regions , which will be reported upon in a future paper and restrict ourselves here to this brief description .
it is likely that the same process determines the emission seen from the sheath of the tails in 2.12 @xmath0 m .
the first - order theory for shadowed columns behind optically thick knots was presented by cant et al .
they illustrated that the shadowed regions are illuminated by lyc photons emitted from recombining hydrogen , that this radiation was closer to 13.6 ev than the ionizing stellar radiation , and that the flux density of these diffuse lyc photons was about 0.15 that of the direct lyc flux from the central star .
these diffuse lyc photons are almost certainly the source of the heating of the h@xmath1 in the tails as the surface brightness in 2.12 @xmath0 m is about [email protected] that in the directly illuminated bright cusp ( 3.6 ) .
the implausibility of shocks is also true here and the shortfall of energy from the fuv radiation is even greater than in the cusps because having a strong diffuse fuv radiation field would demand a large optical depth in dust for the nebula as a whole , which is not indicated by its emission line spectrum . a separate detailed h@xmath1 model is required for the tail because the illuminating fuv will be of lower energy and the density much lower than in the bright cusp . in a recent paper , meaburn et al .
( 2005 ) presented the analysis of images made in the center of the helix nebula in h@xmath8+[n ii ] in 1992 ( technical details described in meaburn et al .
they present a high contrast rendering of the image ( their figure 10 ) and argue that radial `` spokes '' can be seen to faintly continue inside the boundary of the `` cometary globules '' to within about 30 from the central star . an arguably superior image of the region is available in the cerro tololo interamerican observatory 4-m mosaic images made in a similar filter ( h@xmath8+[nii ] ) and resolution , with a pixel scale ( 0.26/pixel ) .
the individual exposures were 300 s and in the central region , where the fields of the four different pointings overlap , the effective exposure was 1200 s. a straightforward examination of this image using various levels of brightness and contrast did not reveal the features posited by meaburn et al .
( odell 2005 ) .
we have now more intensively examined the same images , by employing median filters of 20x20 pixels and 40x40 pixels and dividing the original images by these , a technique previously employed ( omm04 ) to enhance the visibility of radial features in the outer parts of the nebula .
the results are shown in figure 11 in negative depiction or the highly stretch range of intensities of 0.97 - 1.03 .
one sees no indication of radial features extending inside the radius at which the knots disappear .
we argue that our images are a better test of such features since one can see numerous stars and galaxies that do not appear in the meaburn et al .
( 2005 ) image .
this non - detection of such features , even only slightly inside the position of the easily visible bright cusp knots is a strong argument that this boundary indicates where knots were first formed and does not represent a boundary where knots have been destroyed .
an attractive model for generating the initial irregularities that develop into the knots is presented in the calculations of garca - segura et al .
( 2006 ) , who argue that these should arise at the boundary of shocked material as the initial fast - wind phase of the nebula ends , which is likely to be at about this position within the nebula . in a series of papers , dyson and collaborators have developed a model for the structure of the helix knots based on the hydrodynamic interaction that results when ionized gas is injected into a subsonic stream that flows past the injection source ( dyson et al .
1993 , 2006 ) .
although the injected ionized gas is assumed to arise from an ionization front on the head of a neutral globule , the radiation transfer and ionization process is not explicitly included in the models .
this makes it very difficult to make meaningful comparison between the results of these models and observations of the helix nebula .
our new h@xmath1 observations clearly show ( 3.2 ) that the limb - brightened edges of the knot tails correspond to an ionization front . additionally , the width of the tail is equal to the width of the bright cusp at the head of the knot and its conic projection ( odell 2000 ) .
this would seem to conclusively establish that radiation shadowing , rather than hydrodynamic interactions , is the _ primary _ determinant of the structure of the tails . in the stream - source model , although tail widths are predicted to be of the same order as the width of the injection source , there is no reason to expect them to be equal , unless the parameters are fine - tuned . the kinematic arguments given in support of the stream - source model ( meaburn et al .
2006 ) also do not stand up to close scrutiny .
they are based on the ground - based echelle spectroscopic observations of meaburn et al .
( 1998 ) , which seem to show an acceleration of gas along the tail of the knot 378801 . however , a comparison with the much higher resolution _ hst _ observations ( e.g. , odell et al . 2005 , and also the image available at http://hubblesite.org/gallery/album/entire_collection/pr199613b ) . clearly shows that the sample regions used in that observational study all correspond to independent knots that are merely projected onto the tail of 378801 .
therefore , the observed variation in velocity does not represent an acceleration along the tail , but simply a tendency towards higher velocities in knots that are farther from the central star , which has already been noted from co observations ( young et al .
we have been able to use existing and new observations to reach a number of important conclusions about the knots in the helix nebula .
there is sufficient energy to power the nebula s
h@xmath1 emission only in extreme ultraviolet radiation from the central star with energies @xmath5613.6 ev , thus eliminating photo - excitation by the 912 - 1100 and x - ray flux that has been assumed in previous general models .
there is no evidence from infrared emission lines for shock excitation of the knots h@xmath1 emission , the lack of a driving stellar wind and previous arguments of time - scale having come to the same conclusion .
spectrophotometry of multiple lines in four sample regions and the total nebular flux ratio in the h@xmath1 0 - 0 s(5 ) and 2.12 @xmath0 m lines indicates that the h@xmath1 emitting zones are all about 988@xmath36119 k , closely resembling lte .
the 2.12 @xmath0 m emission from individual knots falls immediately inside the ionized gas zone traced by h@xmath8 emission .
this is true for both the bright cusps and their fainter tails , the latter establishing that the tails are primarily ionizing radiation shadows , rather than the result of purely hydrodynamic processes .
the advection dominated nature of the knot cusps means that there is no extended neutral hydrogen zone between the cold molecular knot core and the ionized gas layer .
this zone of irradiation of h@xmath1 by euv photons is probably the region producing the observed hot gas in the cusps on the star - facing side of the molecular knots and the shadowed regions of the tails .
no evidence was found for knots within the he ii core nor were earlier claims verified of linear features extending nearly in to the central star , arguing that the knots have only been created outside the high ionization core .
anton koekemoer of the space telescope science institute provided valuable guidance in the use of the drizzle package of tasks , making possible the smooth combination of our multiple observations of the same fields .
we are grateful to angela speck for providing the calibrated 2.12 @xmath0 m image from her speck et al .
( 2002 ) paper and to pierre cox for his comments on the h@xmath1 physical processes .
cro thanks the centro de radioastronoma y astrofsica , unam , mexico for generously supporting a two - week visit in february 2006 , during which initial work for this paper was carried out and to grant go 10628 from the space telescope science institute .
gjf s work was supported in part by grant ar-10653 from the space telescope science institute , nasa grant nng05gd81 g , and nsf grant ast 0607028 .
wjh acknowledges financial support from dgapa - unam , mexico , project in112006 .
bertoldi , f. , & draine , b. t. 1996 , apj , 458 , 222 black .
j. h. , & van dishoek , e. f. 1987 , apj , 322 , 412 bohlin , r. c. , harrington , j. p. , & stecher , t. p. 1982 , apj , 252 , 635 burkert , a. , & odell , c. r. 1998 , apj , 503 , 792 cant , j , raga , a. , steffen , w. , & shapiro , p. r. 1998 , apj , 5002 , 695 cerruti - sola , m. , & perinotto , m. 1985 , apj , 291 , 237 cox , p. , boulanger , f. , huggins , p. j. , tielens , a. g. g. m. , forveille , t. , bachiller , r. , cesarsky , d. , jones , a. p. , young , k. , roelfsema , p. r. , & cernicharo , j. 1998 , apj , 495 , l23 ( cox98 ) dabrowski , i. 1984 , canadian j. phys . , 62 , 1639 dyson , j. e. , hartquist , t. w. , & biro , s. , 1993 , mnras , 261 , 430 dyson , j. e. , pittard , j. m. , meaburn , j. , & falle , s. a. e. g. 2006 , a&a , 457 , 561 fazio , g. et al .
2004 , apjs , 154 , 10 garca - segura , g. , lpez , j. a. , steffen , w. , meaburn , j. , & manchado , a. 2006 , apj , in press gonzaga , s. , et al .
2005 , acs instrument handbook , version 6.0 , ( baltimore : stsci ) guerrero , m. a. , chu , y .- h . ,
gruendl , r. a. , williams , r. m. , & kaler , j. b. 2001 , apj , 553 , l55 harris , h. c. , dahn , c. c. , canzian , b. , guetter , h. h. , leggett , s. k. , levine , s. e. , luginbuhl , c. b. , monet , a. k. b. , monet , d. g. , pier , j. r. , stone , r. c. , tilleman , t. , vrba , f. j. , & walker , r. l. 2007 , aj , in press henney , w. j. 2001 , rmxac , 10 , 57 hollenbach , d. j. , & tielens , a. g. g. m. 1997 , araa , 35 , 179 hora , j. l. , latter , w. b. , smith , h. a. , & marengo , m. 2006 , apj , in press ( h06 ) holtzman , j. a. , burrows , c. j. , castertano . s. , hester , j. j. , trauger , j. t. , watson , a. m. , & worthey , g. 1995 , pasp , 107 , 1065 houck , j. r. et al . 2004 , apjs , 154 , 18 huggins , p. j. , forveille , t. , bachiller , r. , cox , p. , ageorges , n. , & walsh , j. r. 2002 , apj , 573 , l55 .
lpez - martn , l. , raga , a. c. , melleman , g. , henney , w. j. , & cant , j. 2001 , apj , 548 , 288 leahy , d. a. , zhang , c. y. , & kwok , s. 1994 , apj , 422 , 205 leahy , d. a. , zhang , c. y. , volk , k. , & kwok , s. 1996 , apj , 466 , 352 meaburn , j. , boumis , p. , lpez , j. a. , harman , d. j. , bryce , m. , redman , m. p. , & mavromatakis , f. 2005 , mnras , 360 , 963 m05 meaburn , j. , clayton , c. a. , bryce , m. , walsh , j. r. , holloway , a. j. , & steffen , w. 1998 , mnras , 294 , 201 meaburn , j. , walsh , j. r. , clegg , r. e. s. , walton , n. a. , & taylor , d. 1992 , mnras , 255 , 177 meixner , m. , mccullough , p. , hartman , j. , odell , c. r. , & speck , a. k. 2004 , in asp conf .
313 , asymmetrical planetary nebulae iii : winds , structure , and the thunderbird , ed .
m. meixner et al .
( san francisco : asp ) , 234 meixner , m. , mccullough , p. r. , haartman , j. , son , m. , & speck , a. k. 2005 , aj , 130 , 1784 ( mx05 ) mellema , g. , raga , a. c. , cant , j. , lundqvist , p. , balick , b. , steffen , w. , & noriega - crespo , a. 1998 , a&a , 331 , 335 natta , a. , & hollenbach , d. 1998 , a&a , 337 , 517 odell , c. r. 1998 , aj , 116 , 1346 odell , c. r. 2000 , aj , 119 , 2311 odell , c. r. 2004 , pasp , 116 , 729 odell , c. r. 2005 rmxac , 23 , 5 odell , c. r. , balick , b. , hajian , a. r. , & henney , w. j. 2002 , aj , 123 , 3329 odell , c. r. , & burkert , a. 1997 , in iau symp . 180 , 332 odell , c. r. , & doi , t. 1999 , pasp , 111 , 1316 planetary nebulae , ed . h. j. habing & h. j. g. l. m. lambers ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 332 odell , c. r. , & handron , k. d. 1996 , aj , 111 , 1630 odell , c. r. , henney , w. j. , & burkert , a. 2000 , aj , 119 , 2910 ( ohb00 ) odell , c. r. , henney , w. j. , & ferland , g. j. 2005 , aj , 130 , 172 ( ohf05 ) odell , c. r. , mccullough , p. r. , & meixner , m. 2004 , aj , 128 , 2339 ( omm04 ) phillips , j. p. 2006 ,
mnras , 368 , 819 rauch , t. 2003 , , 403 , 709 rodrguez , l. f. , goss , w. m. , & williams , r. 2002 , apj , 574 , 179 shaw , g. , ferland , g. j. , abel , n.p . , stancil , p. c. , & van hoof , p. a. m. 2005 , apj , 624 , 794 speck , a. k. , meixner , m. , fong , d. , mcculough , p. r. , moser , d. e. , & ueta , t. 2002 , aj , 123 , 346 thompson , r. i. , rieke , m. , schneider , g. , hines , d. c. , & corbin , m. r. 1998 , apj , 492 , l95 walsh , j. r. , & ageorges , n. 2004 , in iau symp . 209
_ planetary nebulae : their evolution and role in the universe _ , eds . s. kwok , m. dopita , & r. sutherland , 275 wolniewicz , l. , simbotin , i. , & dalgarno , a. 1998 , apjs , 115 , 293 wood , k. , mathis , j. s. , & ercolano , b. 2004 , mnras , 348 , 1337 young , k. , cox , p. , huggins , p. j. , forveille , t. , & bachiller , r. 1999 , apj , 522 , 387 | we use new hubble space telescope and archived images to clarify the nature of the ubiquitous knots in the helix nebula , which are variously estimated to contain a significant to majority fraction of the material ejected by its central star .
we employ published far infrared spectrophotometry and existing 2.12 @xmath0 m images to establish that the population distribution of the lowest ro - vibrational states of h@xmath1 is close to the distribution of a gas in local thermodynamic equilibrium ( lte ) at @xmath2 k. in addition , we present calculations that show that the weakness of the h@xmath1 0 - 0 s(7 ) line is not a reason for making the unlikely - to - be true assumption that h@xmath1 emission is caused by shock excitation .
we derive a total flux from the nebula in h@xmath1 lines and compare this with the power available from the central star for producing this radiation .
we establish that neither soft x - rays nor 9121100 radiation has enough energy to power the h@xmath1 radiation , only the stellar extreme ultraviolet radiation shortward of 912 does .
advection of material from the cold regions of the knots produces an extensive zone where both atomic and molecular hydrogen are found , allowing the h@xmath1 to directly be heated by lyman continuum radiation , thus providing a mechanism that will probably explain the excitation temperature and surface brightness of the 2.12 @xmath0 m cusps and tails .
new images of the knot 378 - 801 in the h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m line reveal that the 2.12 @xmath0 m cusp lies immediately inside the ionized atomic gas zone .
this property is shared by material in the tail region .
the h@xmath1 2.12 @xmath0 m emission of the cusp confirms previous assumptions , while the tail s property firmly establishes that the tail " structure is an ionization bounded radiation shadow behind the optically thick core of the knot .
the new 2.12 @xmath0 m image together with archived hubble images is used to establish a pattern of decreasing surface brightness and increasing size of the knots with increasing stellar distance .
although the contrast against the background is greater in 2.12 @xmath0 m than in the optical lines , the higher resolution and signal of optical images remains the most powerful technique for searching for knots .
a unique new image of a transitional region of the nebula s inner disk in the heii 4686 line fails to show any emission from knots that might have been found in the he@xmath3 core of the nebula .
we also re - examined high signal - to - noise ratio ground - based telescope images of this same inner region and found no evidence of structures that could be related to knots . |
galaxy clusters provide an independent means of examining any viable model of cosmic structure formation through the growth of structure and by the form of their equilibrium mass profiles , complementing cosmic microwave background and galaxy clustering observations
. a consistent framework of structure formation requires that most of the matter in the universe is in the hitherto unknown form of dark matter , of an unknown nature , and that most of the energy filling the universe today is in the form of a mysterious `` dark energy '' , characterized by a negative pressure .
this model actually requires that the expansion rate of the universe has recently changed sign and is currently accelerating .
clusters play a direct role in testing cosmological models , providing several independent checks of any viable cosmology , including the current consensus @xmath11 cold dark matter ( @xmath11cdm ) model .
a spectacular example has been recently provided from detailed lensing and x - ray observations of the `` bullet cluster '' ( aka , ie0657 - 56 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , which is a consequence of a high - speed collision between two cluster components with a mass ratio of the order of @xmath12 @xcite , displaying a prominent bow shock preceding a cool bullet lying between the two clusters , implying these clusters passed through each other recently @xcite . here
the bullet system reveals lensing mass contours that follow the bimodal distribution of cluster members , demonstrating that the bulk of the dark matter is relatively collisionless as galaxies @xcite , as also shown by a comprehensive analysis of galaxy and dark - matter dynamics for a1689 @xcite .
other cases of merging systems show that in general displacement of the hot gas relative to the dark matter is related to interaction @xcite . for dynamically - relaxed clusters ,
the form of the equilibrium mass profile reflects closely the distribution of dark matter ( see * ? ? ? * ) which , unlike galaxies , does not suffer from halo compression by adiabatic contraction of cooled gas .
the majority of baryons in clusters are in the form of hot , diffuse x - ray emitting gas , and represents only a minor fraction of the total lensing mass near the centers of clusters @xcite . the predicted navarro - frenk - white profile ( hereafter , nfw ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) derived from simulations based on collisionless , cold ( non - relativistic ) dark matter has a continuously - declining logarithmic gradient @xmath13 towards the center of mass , much shallower than the isothermal case ( @xmath14 ) within the characteristic scale radius , @xmath15 ( @xmath16 for cluster - sized halos )
. a useful index of the degree of concentration , @xmath17 , compares the virial radius , @xmath1 , to @xmath15 of the nfw profile , @xmath18 .
this has been confirmed thoroughly with higher resolution simulations @xcite , with some intrinsic variation related to the individual assembly history of a cluster @xcite .
gravitational lensing observations are underway to provide reliable and representative cluster mass profiles to test this since the first careful measurements showed that the nfw profile provides a good fit to the entire mass profile when weak and strong lensing are combined .
other well studied clusters with similarly high quality data are also in good agreement providing strong support for the cdm scenario ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
interestingly these studies reveal that although the dark matter is consistent with being cold , the predicted profile concentration of the standard @xmath11cdm model falls short of some lensing results ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this observed tendency for higher proportion of mass to lie at smaller radius in projection is also indicated by the generally large einstein radii determined from strong lensing of well studied clusters @xcite finding a substantial discrepancy with the predictions despite careful accounting for potential selection biases inherent to lensing @xcite .
these observations could suggest either substantial mass projected along the line of sight , perhaps in part due to halo triaxiality @xcite , or a large overconcentration of mass ; the latter could imply modification within the context of the cdm family of models .
the abundance of massive clusters is very sensitive to the amplitude of the initial mass power spectrum @xcite representing the most massive objects to have collapsed under their own gravity , and confirmed by @xmath19-body simulations of hubble volumes @xcite .
such calculations predict for example that the single most massive cluster to be found in the universe is expected to be with @xmath20 out to @xmath21 ( see figure 5 of * ? ? ?
* ) , similar to the most massive known clusters detected locally @xcite .
is currently the most massive known cluster measured reliably by lensing , @xmath22 .
] at higher redshifts this comparison becomes more sensitive to the cosmological model , with an order of magnitude decline in the abundance of @xmath23 clusters at @xmath24 compared to the present @xcite .
hence , the existence of such massive clusters like xmmuj2235 - 25 at @xmath25 @xcite , from lensing work , begins to motivate alternative ideas such as departures from gaussian initial density fluctuation spectrum , or higher levels of dark energy in the past @xcite , although some non - gaussian models can be ruled out by using the cosmic x - ray background measurements @xcite .
the main attraction of gravitational lensing in the cluster regime ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) is the model - free determination of mass profiles allowed over a wide range of radius when the complementary effects of strong and weak lensing are combined @xcite . in practice , the quality of data required challenges with few facilities , which are able to generate data of sufficient precision to provide a significant detection of the weak lensing signal on an individual cluster basis . in this paper
we aim to pursue in greater depth the utility of massive clusters for defining highest - precision mass profiles by combining all lensing information available in the cluster regime .
in particular , we shall make a full use of the magnification information , afforded by measuring spatial variations in the surface number density of faint background galaxies @xcite , which we show here is readily detectable in the high - quality images we have obtained for this purpose . in our earlier work , particularly on a1689 and cl0024 + 17 ,
the magnification information determined from the background counts was used only as a consistency check of distortion measurements @xcite .
recently , we have shown in @xcite how to overcome the intrinsic clustering of background galaxies , which otherwise perturbs locally the magnification signal , and how to combine the two independent weak - lensing data sets to improve the quality of two - dimensional mass reconstruction using regularized maximum - likelihood techniques . here
we further explore new statistical methods designed to obtain an optimal combination of the complementary lens distortion and magnification effects .
our aim here is to develop and apply techniques to a sample of five well - studied , high - mass clusters with @xmath26 , a1689 , a1703 , a370 , cl0024 + 17 , and rxj1347 - 11 , for examining the underlying mass profiles extracted from the combined weak - lensing data sets .
we then add to this detailed strong - lensing information for the inner @xmath27kpc region of these clusters , for which we have identified many new sets of multiple images from advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) observations @xcite with the _ hubble space telescope _
( _ hst _ ) , to derive improved inner mass profiles for a full determination of the entire mass profiles of the five well - studied clusters .
the paper is organized as follows .
we briefly summarize in
[ sec : basis ] the basis of cluster weak gravitational lensing . in [ sec : method ] we present our comprehensive lensing method in a bayesian framework for a direct reconstruction of the projected cluster mass profile from combined weak - lensing shape distortion and magnification bias measurements . in
[ sec : results ] we apply our method to subaru weak - lensing observations of five massive clusters to derive projected mass profiles to beyond the cluster virial radius ; we also combine our new weak - lensing mass profiles with inner strong - lensing based information from _ hst_/acs observations to make a full determination of the entire cluster mass profiles .
finally , summary and discussions are given in
[ sec : discussion ] . throughout this paper ,
e use the ab magnitude system , and adopt a concordance @xmath11cdm cosmology with @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 .
errors represent a confidence level of @xmath31 ( @xmath32 ) unless otherwise stated .
the deformation of the image for a background source can be described by the jacobian matrix @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) of the lens mapping .
the real , symmetric jacobian @xmath35 can be decomposed as @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is kronecker s delta , @xmath38 is the lensing convergence , and @xmath39 is the trace - free , symmetric shear matrix , @xmath40 with @xmath41 being the components of spin-2 complex gravitational shear @xmath42 . in the strict weak lensing limit where @xmath43 , @xmath39 induces a quadrupole anisotropy of the background image , which can be observed from ellipticities of background galaxy images @xcite .
the local area distortion due to gravitational lensing , or magnification , is given by the inverse jacobian determinant , @xmath44 where we assume subcritical lensing , i.e. , @xmath45 .
the lens magnification @xmath46 can be measured from characteristic variations in the number density of background galaxies ( * ? ? ?
* see also
[ subsec : magbias ] ) .
the lensing convergence @xmath38 is a weighted projection of the matter density contrast along the line of sight ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . for gravitational lensing in the cluster regime ( e.g. ,
* ) , @xmath38 is expressed as @xmath47 , namely the projected mass density @xmath48 in units of the critical surface mass density for gravitational lensing , defined as @xmath49,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 are the proper angular diameter distances from the observer to the source , from the observer to the deflecting lens , and from the lens to the source , respectively , and @xmath53 is the mean distance ratio averaged over the population of source galaxies in the cluster field . in general , the observable quantity for quadrupole weak lensing is not the gravitational shear @xmath54 but the complex _ reduced _ shear ( see [ subsec : gt ] ) , @xmath55 in the subcritical regime where @xmath56 ( or @xmath57 in the negative parity region with @xmath58 ) .
the reduced shear @xmath59 is invariant under the following global linear transformation : @xmath60 with an arbitrary scalar constant @xmath61 .
this transformation is equivalent to scaling the jacobian matrix @xmath62 with @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and hence leaves the critical curves @xmath65 invariant .
furthermore , the curve @xmath66 , on which the gravitational distortions disappear , is left invariant under the transformation ( [ eq : invtrans ] ) .
this mass - sheet degeneracy can be unambiguously broken by measuring the magnification effects ( see [ subsec : magbias ] ) , because the magnification @xmath46 transforms under the invariance transformation ( [ eq : invtrans ] ) as @xmath67 alternatively , the constant @xmath63 can be determined such that the mean @xmath38 averaged over the outermost cluster region vanishes , if a sufficiently wide sky coverage is available .
such that the enclosed mass within a certain aperture is consistent with cluster mass estimates from some other observations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
in this section we develop a bayesian method to reconstruct the projected cluster mass profile @xmath68 from observable lens distortion and magnification profiles , without assuming particular functional forms for the mass distribution , i.e. , in a model - independent fashion .
although the methodology here is presented for the analysis of individual clusters , it can be readily generalized for a statistical analysis using stacked lensing profiles of a sample of clusters . in [ subsec : stack ] , alternatively , we provide a method to stack reconstructed projected mass profiles of individual clusters to obtain an ensemble - averaged profile .
the observable quadrupole distortion of an object due to gravitational lensing is described by the spin-2 reduced shear , @xmath69 ( equation [ [ eq : redshear ] ] ) , which is coordinate dependent . for a given cluster center on the sky
, one can form coordinate - independent quantities , the tangential distortion @xmath70 and the @xmath71 rotated component , from linear combinations of the distortion coefficients as @xmath72 and @xmath73 , with @xmath74 being the position angle of an object with respect to the cluster center . in the strict weak - lensing limit , the azimuthally - averaged tangential distortion profile @xmath75 satisfies the following identity ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) : @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the azimuthal average of @xmath78 at radius @xmath79 , and @xmath80 is the mean convergence interior to radius @xmath79 . with the assumption of quasi - circular symmetry in the projected mass distribution ( see * ? ? ?
* ) , the tangential distortion is expressed as @xmath81 in the nonlinear but subcritical ( @xmath45 ) regime . to the first order of @xmath38 . see 3.4 of @xcite for details . ] in the absence of higher order effects , weak lensing only induces curl - free tangential distortions , while the azimuthal averaged @xmath82 component is expected to vanish . in practice
, the presence of @xmath82 modes can be used to check for systematic errors . from shape measurements of background galaxies ,
we calculate the weighted average of @xmath83 in a set of @xmath19 radial bands ( @xmath84 ) as @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the center of the @xmath87th radial band of @xmath88 $ ] , the index @xmath89 runs over all of the objects located within the @xmath87th annulus , @xmath90 is the tangential distortion of the @xmath89th object , and @xmath91 is the statistical weight ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) for the @xmath89th object , given by @xmath92 with @xmath93 being the variance for the shear estimate of the @xmath89th galaxy and @xmath94 being the softening constant variance ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) . in our analysis , we choose @xmath95 , which is a typical value of the mean rms @xmath96 over the background sample ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we use the continuous limit of the area - weighted band center for @xmath86 ( see equation [ [ eq : medianr ] ] ) .
we perform a bootstrap error analysis to assess the uncertainty @xmath97 in the tangential distortion profile @xmath98 .
lensing magnification , @xmath99 , influences the observed surface density of background sources , expanding the area of sky , and enhancing the observed flux of background sources @xcite .
the former effect reduces the effective observing area in the source plane , decreasing the number of background sources per solid angle ; on the other hand , the latter effect amplifies the flux of background sources , increasing the number of sources above the limiting flux .
the net effect is known as magnification bias , and depends on the intrinsic slope of the luminosity function of background sources .
the number counts for a given magnitude cutoff @xmath100 , approximated locally as a power - law cut with slope @xmath101 ( @xmath102 ) , are modified in the presence of lensing as @xmath103 @xcite , where @xmath104 is the unlensed counts , and @xmath46 is the magnification , @xmath105 . in the strict weak lensing limit , the magnification bias is @xmath106 . for the number counts to measure magnification ,
we use a sample of _ red _ background galaxies , for which the intrinsic count slope @xmath107 at faint magnitudes is relatively flat , @xmath108 , so that a net count depletion results @xcite . on the other hand , the faint blue background population tends to have a steeper intrinsic count slope close to the lensing invariant slope ( @xmath109 ) .
the count - in - cell statistic @xmath110 is measured from a flux - limited sample of red background galaxies on a regular grid of equal - area cells , each with a solid angle of @xmath111 .
note that a practical difficulty of the magnification bias measurement is contamination due to the intrinsic clustering of background galaxies , which locally can be larger than the lensing - induced signal in a given cell . in order to obtain a clean measure of the lensing signal ,
such intrinsic clustering needs to be downweighted ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . for a mass profile analysis
, we calculate the mean number density @xmath112 of the red background sample as a function of radius from the cluster center , by azimuthally averaging @xmath113 , using the same radial bins ( @xmath84 ) as done for the distortion measurement .
the lens magnification bias is expressed in terms of the number density of background galaxies as @xmath114 with @xmath115 being the unlensed mean surface number density of background galaxies .
the normalization and slope parameters ( @xmath116 ) can be estimated from the source counts in cluster outskirts using wide - field imaging data ( [ subsec : back ] ) . in practice , we adopt the following prescription : * a positive tail of @xmath117 cells is excluded in each annulus to remove inherent small scale clustering of the background @xcite . *
each grid cell is weighted by the fraction of its area lying within the respective annular bins @xcite . *
the uncertainty @xmath118 in @xmath119 includes not only the poisson contribution but also the variance due to variations of the counts along the azimuthal direction , i.e. , contributions from the intrinsic clustering of background galaxies @xcite .
* the cell size @xmath120 can be as large as the typical radial band width for a mass profile analysis , which can cause an additional variance due to poisson and sampling errors .
we thus average over a set of radial profiles obtained using different girds offset with respect to each other by half a grid spacing in each direction . * the masking effect due to bright cluster galaxies , bright foreground objects , and saturated pixels is properly taken into account and corrected for @xcite . in our analysis , we use method b of appendix [ appendix : mask ] developed in this work . the relation between distortion and convergence is nonlocal , and
the convergence derived from distortion data alone suffers from a mass - sheet degeneracy ( [ sec : basis ] ) .
however , by combining the distortion and magnification measurements the convergence can be obtained unambiguously with the correct mass normalization . here
we aim to derive a discrete convergence profile from observable lens distortion and magnification profiles ( see [ subsec : gt ] and [ subsec : magbias ] ) within a bayesian statistical framework , allowing for a full parameter - space extraction of model and calibration parameters .
a proper bayesian statistical analysis is of particular importance to explore the entire parameter space and investigate the parameter degeneracies , arising in part from the mass - sheet degeneracy . in this framework , we sample from the posterior probability density function ( pdf ) of the underlying signal @xmath121 given the data @xmath122 , @xmath123 .
expectation values of any statistic of the signal @xmath121 shall converge to the expectation values of the a posteriori marginalized pdf , @xmath123 . in our problem , the signal @xmath121 is a vector containing the discrete convergence profile , @xmath124 @xmath125 , and the average convergence within the inner radial boundary @xmath126 of the weak lensing data , @xmath127 , so that @xmath128 , being specified by @xmath129 parameters .
the bayes theorem states that @xmath130 where @xmath131 is the likelihood of the data given the model ( @xmath121 ) , and @xmath132 is the prior probability distribution for the model parameters .
we combine complementary and independent weak lensing information of tangential distortion and magnification bias to constrain the underlying cluster mass distribution @xmath133 .
the total likelihood function @xmath134 of the model @xmath121 for combined weak lensing observations is given as a product of the two separate likelihoods , @xmath135 , where @xmath136 and @xmath137 are the likelihood functions for distortion and magnification , respectively .
the log - likelihood for the tangential distortion is given as @xmath138 ^ 2}{\sigma_{+.i}^2 } + { \rm const}.,\ ] ] where @xmath139 is the theoretical prediction for the observed distortion @xmath140 , and the errors @xmath141 ( @xmath84 ) due primarily to the variance of the intrinsic source ellipticity distribution can be conservatively estimated from the data using bootstrap techniques ( [ subsec : gt ] ) .
similarly , the log - likelihood function for the magnification bias is given as @xmath142 ^ 2}{\sigma_{\mu.i}^2 } + { \rm const}.,\ ] ] where @xmath143 is the theoretical prediction for the observed counts @xmath144 , and the errors @xmath145 include both contributions from poisson errors in the counts , @xmath146 , and contamination due to intrinsic clustering of red background galaxies , @xmath147 , as discussed in
[ subsec : magbias ] : @xmath148 the lensing observables @xmath140 and @xmath144 ( @xmath84 ) can be readily expressed by the given model parameters @xmath121 , as shown in appendices [ appendix : avkappa ] and [ appendix : lprof ] . for each parameter of the model @xmath121 , we consider a simple flat prior with a lower bound of @xmath149 , that is , @xmath150 additionally , we account for the calibration uncertainty in the observational parameters , i.e. , the normalization and slope parameters @xmath151 of the background counts and the relative lensing depth @xmath152 due to population - to - population variations between the background samples used for the magnification and distortion measurements ( see appendix [ appendix : lprof ] ) .
cccccc a1689 & 0.183 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 & 0.82 & 1 + a1703 & 0.281 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 & 0.78 & 2,3 + a370 & 0.375 & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & 0.60 & 2,3 + cl0024 + 17 & 0.395 & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & 0.80 & 4 + rxj1347 - 11 & 0.451 & @xmath159 & @xmath158 & 0.76 & 2,3 + ccc a1689 & @xmath160 @xmath161 & 1,2 + a1703 & @xmath162 @xmath163 & 3 , 4 , 5 + a370 & @xmath164 @xmath165 & 6 , 7 + cl0024 + 17 & @xmath166 @xmath167 & 8 + rxj1347 - 11 & @xmath168 @xmath169 & 7 , 9 , 10 + c|ccc|ccc|c a1689 & 8.8 & @xmath170 & @xmath171 & 12.0 & @xmath170 & @xmath171 & @xmath172 + a1703 & 10.0 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & 6.9 & @xmath175 & @xmath176 & @xmath177 + a370 & 16.7 & @xmath178 & @xmath179 & 21.6 & @xmath180 & @xmath181 & @xmath182 + cl0024 + 17 & 17.2 & @xmath183 & @xmath184 & 17.8 & @xmath185 & @xmath186 & @xmath187 + rxj1347 - 11 & 6.4 & @xmath188 & @xmath189 & 7.7 & @xmath190 & @xmath191 & @xmath192 + cccc a1689 & @xmath193 & @xmath194 & @xmath195 + a1703 & @xmath196 & @xmath197 & @xmath198 + a370 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & @xmath201 + cl0024 + 17 & @xmath202 & @xmath203 & @xmath204 + rxj1347 - 11 & @xmath199 & @xmath205 & @xmath206 + @xmath207{f1a.eps } & \includegraphics[width=45mm , angle=0]{f1b.eps } & \includegraphics[width=45mm , angle=0]{f1c.eps } \end{array } $ ] @xmath208{f1d.eps } & \includegraphics[width=45mm , angle=0]{f1e.eps } \end{array } $ ] @xmath209{f2a.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2b.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2c.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2d.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2e.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2f.eps}\\ \end{array } $ ] @xmath209{f2g.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2h.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2i.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2j.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2k.eps } & \includegraphics[width=20mm , angle=270]{f2l.eps}\\ \end{array } $ ] @xmath210{f3a.eps } & \includegraphics[width=40mm , angle=270]{f3b.eps } & \includegraphics[width=40mm , angle=270]{f3c.eps } \\ \end{array } $ ] @xmath211{f3d.eps } & \includegraphics[width=40mm , angle=270]{f3e.eps}\\ \end{array } $ ] in this section we apply our bayesian mass reconstruction method to a sample of five well - studied high - mass clusters ( @xmath26 ) at intermediate redshifts , a1689 ( @xmath212 ) , a1703 ( @xmath213 ) , a370 ( @xmath214 ) , cl0024 + 17 ( @xmath215 ) , and rxj1347 - 11 ( @xmath216 ) , observed with the wide - field camera ( @xmath217 ; see * ? ? ?
* ) on the 8.2 m subaru telescope .
table [ tab : sample ] gives a summary of cluster observations .
the clusters were observed deeply in several optical passbands , with exposures in the range 200010000s per passband , with seeing in the detection images ranging from @xmath218 to @xmath219 ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these massive clusters are known as strong lensing clusters , displaying prominent strong - lensing features and large einstein radii of @xmath220 ( e.g. , for a fiducial source redshift @xmath221 ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for the clusters , the central mass distributions have been recovered in detail by our strong - lens modeling @xcite . here
the models were constrained by a number of multiply - lensed images identified previously in very deep multi - color imaging with _
hst_/acs ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
table [ tab : rein ] gives a summary of the einstein radii of the five clusters as constrained from our detailed strong lens modeling with the acs observations . here
we will add to our high - quality spin-2 shape measurements @xcite the independent magnification information based on deep multi - band imaging with subaru , in order to achieve the maximum possible lensing precision .
full details of the subaru observations and weak - lensing shape analysis of these clusters were presented in a series of our papers ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* see also table [ tab : sample ] ) .
the level of shear calibration bias with our implementation of the ksb+ method @xcite has been assessed by @xcite using simulated subaru suprime - cam images ( m. oguri 2010 , in private communication ; * ? ? ?
we find , typically , @xmath222 of the shear calibration bias , and @xmath223 of the residual shear offset which is about 1 order of magnitude smaller than the typical distortion signal in cluster outskirts .
this level of calibration bias is subdominant compared to the statistical uncertainty ( @xmath224 ) due to the intrinsic scatter in galaxy shapes , and to the dilution effect which can lead to an underestimation of the true signal for @xmath225 by a factor of 25 ( see figure 1 of * ? ? ?
a careful background selection is critical for a weak - lensing analysis so that unlensed cluster members and foreground galaxies do not dilute the true lensing signal of the background @xcite .
we use undiluted samples of background galaxies derived in our previous lensing work , as summarized in table [ tab : back ] .
when deep multi - color photometry is available in our cluster fields , we use the background selection method of ( * ? ? ?
* see also umetsu et al .
2010 ) to define blue and red background samples ( a1703 , a370 , cl0024 + 17 , rxj1347 - 11 ) , which relies on empirical correlations for galaxies in color - color space derived from the deep subaru photometry , by reference to the deep photometric - redshift survey in the cosmos field @xcite .
otherwise , we use the color - magnitude selection method @xcite to define a sample of red galaxies ( a1689 ) whose colors are redder than the red sequence of cluster e / s0 galaxies .
these red galaxies are expected to lie in the background by virtue of @xmath226-corrections which are greater than the red cluster sequence galaxies , as convincingly demonstrated spectroscopically by @xcite .
apparent magnitude cuts are applied in the reddest band available for each cluster to avoid incompleteness near the detection limit .
a flux - limited sample of red background galaxies is used for the magnification analysis ( see [ subsec : magbias ] ) . for the distortion analysis
, we use a full composite sample of red and blue ( if available ) background galaxies , where the galaxies used are well resolved to make reliable shape measurements ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
table [ tab : back ] lists for respective color samples the mean surface number density @xmath227 of background galaxies , the effective source redshift , @xmath228 , , corresponding to the mean depth @xmath229 , is defined as @xmath230 . for details , see 3.4 of @xcite . ] and the mean distance ratio @xmath229 averaged over the source redshift distribution .
we also quote in table [ tab : back ] the values of the relative mean depth , @xmath231 , between the background samples used for the magnification and distortion measurements ( see [ subsubsec : prior ] and appendix [ appendix : lprof ] ) .
we adopt a conservative uncertainty of @xmath232 in the relative mean depth @xmath152 for all of the clusters based on our previous work @xcite .
the conversion from the observed counts into magnification depends on the normalization @xmath115 and the slope parameter @xmath107 of the unlensed number counts , which can be reliably estimated thanks to the wide field of view of subaru / suprime - cam ( see [ subsec : massrec ] ) .
table [ tab : magbias ] lists the magnitude cuts ( @xmath100 ) and unlensed count parameters ( @xmath116 ) as measured from the red background counts in outermost annular regions in cluster outskirts ( @xmath233 ) .
following the methodology outlined in
[ subsec : gt ] and [ subsec : magbias ] ( see also appendix [ appendix : mask ] ) , we derive lens distortion and magnification profiles of five massive clusters from subaru observations . in order to obtain meaningful radial profiles
, one must carefully define the center of the cluster .
it is often assumed that the cluster mass centroid coincides with the position of the brightest cluster galaxy ( bcg ) , whereas the bcgs can be offset from the mass centroids of the corresponding dark matter halos @xcite .
here we utilize our detailed mass maps in the cluster cores recovered from strong - lens modeling of acs observations ( [ subsec : sample ] ) , providing an independent mass - centroid determination .
we find that for these five clusters there is only a small offset of typically @xmath234 ( @xmath235kpc@xmath236 at the highest cluster redshift of our study , @xmath237 ) between the bcg and the dark - matter center of mass ( see also
4.2 of * ? ? ?
* ) , often implied by other massive bright galaxies in the vicinity of the bcg .
this level of cluster centering offset is substantially small as compared to the typical inner radial boundary of weak lensing observations , @xmath238 . in the present work
, we therefore simply assume that the cluster mass centroid coincides with the location of the bcg , which is adopted as the cluster center in our one - dimensional profile analysis .
the lensing profiles were calculated in @xmath19 discrete radial bins over the range of radii @xmath239 $ ] , with a constant logarithmic radial spacing of @xmath240 , where the inner radial boundary @xmath241 is taken such that @xmath242 ( see table [ tab : rein ] ) .
the typical inner boundary is @xmath243 for cluster weak lensing .
the outer radial boundary @xmath244 was chosen to be sufficiently larger than the typical virial radius of high mass clusters with @xmath245 , @xmath246mpc , but sufficiently small ( @xmath247 ) with respect to the size of the suprime - cam s field - of - view so as to ensure accurate psf ( point spread function ) anisotropy correction .
the number of radial bins @xmath19 was determined for each cluster such that the per - pixel detection signal - to - noise ratio ( @xmath248 ) is of the order of unity , which is optimal for an inversion problem .
the radial binning scheme is summarized in table [ tab : data ] .
cccccc a1689 & @xmath249 & 11 & 13.8 & 8.8 & 17.8 + a1703 & @xmath250 & 10 & 9.9 & 7.1 & 12.7 + a370 & @xmath251 & 14 & 17.3 & 11.0 & 23.8 + cl0024 + 17 & @xmath252 & 12 & 13.0 & 8.5 & 18.5 + rxj1347 - 11 & @xmath253 & 11 & 9.7 & 5.7 & 12.6 in figure [ fig : data ] we show the resulting distortion and magnification profiles for our sample of five massive lensing clusters . in all the clusters , a strong depletion of the red galaxy counts
is seen in the central , high - density region of the cluster , and clearly detected out to several arcminutes from the cluster center .
the statistical significance of the detection of the depletion signal is in the range @xmath254@xmath255 ( see table [ tab : data ] ) .
the detection significance of the tangential distortion derived from the full background sample ranges from @xmath256 to @xmath257 , and is better than the red counts .
the @xmath82-component is consistent with a null signal in most of radial bins , indicating the reliability of our weak - lensing analysis .
the magnification measurements with and without the masking correction are roughly consistent with each other .
typically , the masking area is negligible ( a few % ) at large radii , and increases up to @xmath258 of the sky close to the cluster center ( see appendix [ appendix : mask ] ) . to test the consistency between our distortion and depletion measurements ,
we calculate the depletion of the counts expected for the best - fitting nfw profile derived from the distortion measurements ( figure [ fig : data ] ) , normalized to the observed density @xmath115 ( table [ tab : magbias ] ) .
this comparison shows clear consistency between two independent lensing observables with different systematics ( see 5.5 of umetsu & broadhurst 2008 ) , which strongly supports the reliability and accuracy of our weak - lensing analysis ( see also supplemental material presented in appendix [ appendix : supplement ] ) .
c|cccc|ccccc a1689 & @xmath259 & @xmath260 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 & @xmath263 & @xmath264 & @xmath265 & @xmath266 & @xmath267 + a1703 & @xmath268 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 & @xmath271 & @xmath272 & @xmath273 & @xmath274 & @xmath275 & @xmath276 + a370 & @xmath277 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & @xmath280 & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 & @xmath284 & @xmath285 + cl0024 + 17 & @xmath286 & @xmath287 & @xmath288 & @xmath289 & @xmath290 & @xmath291 & @xmath292 & @xmath293 & @xmath294 + rxj1347 - 11 & @xmath295 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 & @xmath298 & @xmath299 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 & @xmath303 we use a markov chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) approach with metropolis - hastings sampling to reconstruct the discrete cluster mass profile @xmath304 within a bayesian statistical framework ( [ subsec : bayesian ] ) .
we largely follow the sampling procedure outlined in @xcite , but employ the gelman - rubin @xmath305 statistic @xcite as a simple but reasonable convergence criterion of generated chains .
once convergence to a stationary distribution is achieved , we run a long final chain of @xmath306 steps , which adequately samples the underlying posterior probability distribution . for all of the parameters ,
the number of iterations required for convergence is much less than our final chain length .
note , only the final chain is used for our parameter estimations and error analysis .
we estimate the location of the maximum a posteriori probability for each model parameter using the bisection method in conjunction with bootstrap techniques .
the covariance matrix @xmath307 ( @xmath308 ) for the discrete mass profile @xmath121 is estimated from the mcmc samples . as an example
, we show in figure [ fig : post ] one - dimensional marginalized posterior pdfs for the mass profile @xmath121 of a1689 @xmath309 .
the results are marginalized over all other parameters , including the observational parameters @xmath310 .
the resulting posterior distributions are all clearly single - peaked , and approximately gaussian for most of the parameters .
it is clearly evident that the mass - sheet degeneracy is broken thanks to the inclusion of magnification information on the local area distortion .
excluding magnification data , on the other hand , strongly modifies the gaussian shape of the marginalized posterior pdfs , producing long non - gaussian tails and broadening the distribution function , resulting in large errors for the reconstructed mass profile .
the improvement here from adding the magnification measurements is significant , @xmath10 in terms of cluster mass profile measurements ( see table [ tab : data ] ) .
figure [ fig : kplot ] shows the lensing convergence profiles @xmath311 , for the five clusters reconstructed using our bayesian method from combined subaru distortion and magnification data . also shown for comparison
are independent reconstructions from the same tangential distortion data ( but without the magnification data combined ) using the one - dimensional method of ( * ? ? ?
* see also umetsu et al .
2010 ) based on the nonlinear extension of aperture mass densitometry , which employs an outer boundary condition on the mean convergence in the outermost radial bin , @xmath312 . here
@xmath313 for an isolated nfw halo can be negligibly small if the outermost radii are taken as large as the cluster virial radius ( see * ? ? ?
this method has been applied successfully to subaru weak lensing observations of massive clusters including a1689 @xcite , a1703 @xcite , and cl0024 + 17 @xcite .
our results with different combinations of lensing measurements and boundary conditions , having different systematics , are in agreement with each other .
this consistency clearly demonstrates that our results are robust and insensitive to the choice of boundary condition as well as to systematic errors in the lensing measurements , such as the shear calibration error , as found by @xcite .
unlike the distortion effect , the magnification bias due to the local area distortion falls off sharply with increasing distance from the cluster center .
we find from the reconstructed mass profiles that the lens convergence at large radii of @xmath314 $ ] is of the order @xmath315 .
the expected level of the depletion signal in the weak - lensing limit is @xmath316 for a _ maximally_-depleted sample with @xmath317 , indicating a depletion signal of @xmath318 in the cluster outskirts where we have estimated the unlensed background counts , @xmath115 .
this level of signal is smaller than the fractional uncertainties in estimated unlensed counts @xmath115 of @xmath319 , thus consistent with the assumption .
note that the calibration uncertainties in our observational parameters @xmath310 have been properly taken into account and marginalized over in our bayesian analysis . in the presence of magnification ,
one probes the number counts at an effectively fainter limiting magnitude : @xmath320 .
the level of magnification is on average small in the weak - lensing regime but for the innermost bin reaches a factor of 2 to 4 depending on the cluster .
here we use the count slope at the fainter effective limit ( @xmath321 ) when making the magnification estimate , to be self - consistent . in our analysis
we have implicitly assumed that the power - law behavior ( equation [ [ eq : magbias ] ] ) persists down to @xmath322 mag fainter than @xmath100 where the count slope may be shallower . for a given level of count depletion
, an overestimation of the count slope could lead to an overestimation of the magnification , thus biasing the resulting mass profile .
however , the number count slope for our data flattens only slowly with depth varying from @xmath108 to @xmath323 from a limit of @xmath324 to @xmath325 , so that this introduces a small correction of only typically 8%11% for the most magnified bins ( @xmath326 ) .
in fact , we have found a good consistency between the purely shear - based results and the results based on the combined distortion and magnification data ( see figure [ fig : kplot ] ) . to quantify and characterize the cluster mass distribution , we compare the reconstructed @xmath38 profile with the physically and observationally motivated nfw model . here
we consider a generalized parametrization of the nfw model of the following form @xcite : @xmath327 which has an arbitrary power - law shaped central cusp , @xmath328 , and an asymptotic outer slope of @xmath329 .
this reduces to the nfw model for @xmath330 .
we refer to the profile given by equation ( [ eq : gnfw ] ) as the generalized nfw ( gnfw , hereafter ) profile .
it is useful to introduce the radius @xmath331 at which the logarithmic slope of the density is isothermal , i.e. , @xmath14 . for the gnfw profile , @xmath332 , and
thus the corresponding concentration parameter reduces to @xmath333 .
we specify the gnfw model with the central cusp slope , @xmath334 , the halo virial mass , @xmath335 , and the concentration , @xmath336 .
we employ the radial dependence of the gnfw lensing profiles given by @xcite .
we first fix the central cusp slope to @xmath330 ( nfw ) , and constrain @xmath337 from @xmath338 fitting to the discrete cluster mass profile @xmath304 reconstructed from the combined weak - lensing distortion and magnification measurements . the @xmath338 function for weak lensing
is defined by @xmath339 c^{-1}_{ij } \big [ s_j-\hat{s}_j(m_{\rm vir},c_{\rm vir } ) \big],\ ] ] where @xmath340 is the nfw model prediction for the discrete mass profile @xmath121 .
the resulting constraints on the nfw model parameters and the predicted einstein radius @xmath341 are shown in table [ tab : nfw ] .
for all the cases , the best - fit nfw model from weak lensing properly reproduces the observed location of the einstein radius , consistent with the independent strong - lensing observations ( see table [ tab : rein ] ) . in table
[ tab : data ] we quote the values of the total detection @xmath342 in the reconstructed mass profile @xmath121 based on the combined distortion and magnification data .
@xmath210{f4a.eps } & \includegraphics[width=40mm , angle=270]{f4b.eps } & \includegraphics[width=40mm , angle=270]{f4c.eps } \\ \end{array } $ ] @xmath211{f4d.eps } & \includegraphics[width=40mm , angle=270]{f4e.eps}\\ \end{array } $ ] c|cc|cc|cc|cc a1689 & @xmath343 & @xmath344 & @xmath345 & @xmath346 & @xmath347 & @xmath348 & @xmath349 & @xmath350 + a1703 & @xmath351 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 & @xmath354 & @xmath355 & @xmath356 & @xmath357 & @xmath358 + a370 & @xmath359 & @xmath360 & @xmath361 & @xmath362 & @xmath363 & @xmath364 & @xmath365 & @xmath366 + cl0024 + 17 & @xmath367 & @xmath368 & @xmath369 & @xmath370 & @xmath371 & @xmath372 & @xmath373 & @xmath374 + rxj1347 - 11 & @xmath375 & @xmath376 & @xmath377 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 & @xmath380 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 our comprehensive bayesian analysis of the weak lensing distortion and magnification of background galaxies allows us to recover the mass normalization , given as the mean convergence @xmath383 within the innermost measurement radius @xmath241 ( @xmath384 ) , without employing inner strong lensing information .
we use the non - parametric deprojection method of @xcite to derive for each cluster three - dimensional virial quantities ( @xmath385 ) and values of @xmath386 within a sphere of a fixed mean interior overdensity @xmath387 with respect to the critical density @xmath388 of the universe at the cluster redshift @xmath389 .
we first deproject the two - dimensional mass profiles obtained in [ subsec : massrec ] and derive non - parametric three - dimensional mass profiles @xmath390 simply assuming spherical symmetry , following the method introduced by @xcite .
this method is based on the fact that the surface - mass density @xmath391 is related to the three - dimensional mass density @xmath392 by an abel integral transform ; or equivalently , one finds that the three - dimensional mass @xmath390 out to spherical radius @xmath393 is written in terms of @xmath391 as @xmath394 where @xmath395 @xcite , ) , which can be readily avoided by a suitable coordinate transformation . ] and the first term of the right - hand side can be obtained as @xmath396 with @xmath397 .
the errors are estimated from monte carlo simulations based on the full covariance matrix of the lensing convergence profile ( for details , see * ? ? ?
* ) . in figure
[ fig : m23 ] we show the non - parametric cumulative projected ( blue - hatched ) and spherical ( gray - shaded ) mass profiles , @xmath398 and @xmath399 , separately for the five clusters .
table [ tab : m3d ] gives a summary of the spherical mass estimates @xmath400 corresponding to @xmath401 , and 2500 from our non - parametric deprojection analysis , where @xmath402 is the virial overdensity of the spherical collapse model evaluated at the cluster redshift @xmath389 .
overall , we find a good agreement between the virial mass estimates from the parametric and non - parametric deprojection approaches ( see [ subsec : wl+sl ] for the results of gnfw fits to the combined weak and strong lensing data ) .
our virial mass estimate of a1689 is obtained as @xmath403 from the combined distortion and magnification profiles , consistent with the results of @xcite , who combined strong lensing , weak lensing distortion and magnification data in a full two - dimensional analysis , and derived @xmath404 , where this @xmath32 error includes both statistical and systematic uncertainties ( see also * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
( the errors represent only the statistical one ) from an entropy - regularized maximum - likelihood combination of subaru distortion and magnification data sets , in excellent agreement with the one dimensional results in this work . ]
this is also in good agreement with the results from the recent high - resolution lensing observations by @xcite , @xmath405 .
these lensing results are consistent with careful dynamical work by @xcite , who obtained a virial mass estimate of @xmath406 for a1689 . as found early by @xcite , our comprehensive weak - lensing analysis implies a370 is the most massive cluster now known , @xmath407 .
our virial mass estimate is slightly higher than that derived in our earlier weak - lensing work combined with the inner einstein radius information , @xmath408 @xcite , where the difference is primarily due to our improved background selection and depth estimate presented in @xcite . for rxj1347 - 11
, we find its nfw virial mass is slightly overestimated compared to the non - parametric estimate of @xmath409 due to the projection of subclumps associated with the large scale structure around the cluster ( see * ? ? ?
our non - parametric mass estimates are in good agreement with independent x - ray , dynamical and lensing analyses @xcite . for a1703 and cl0024 + 17 ,
our new mass estimates are fully consistent with our recent weak - lensing results derived from the subaru distortion data alone ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* see also
[ subsec : massrec ] ) . the statistical precision of lensing constraints can be further improved by stacking the signal from an ensemble of clusters with respect to their centers , providing average properties of cluster mass profiles . as discussed by @xcite
, this stacking analysis has several important advantages .
a notable advantage of the stacking analysis is that the resulting average profile is insensitive to the inherent asphericity and substructure ( in projection ) of individual cluster mass distributions , as well as to uncorrelated large - scale structure projected along the same line of sight .
consequently , the statistical precision can be boosted by stacking together a number of clusters , especially on small angular scales ( see * ? ? ?
to do this , we first define a new set of radial bands in which the mass profiles of individual clusters are re - evaluated for a stacking analysis . here
we scale each cluster mass profile according to the cluster virial radius @xmath1 obtained by our non - parametric method ( see [ subsec : rvir ] ) .
for each cluster , we construct an @xmath410 _ projection _ matrix @xmath411 that projects the mass profile @xmath412 ( @xmath84 ) of the cluster onto the new radial bands scaled in units of @xmath1 ( @xmath413 ) . assuming a constant density in each radial band , the projection matrix @xmath411 is uniquely specified by the conservation of mass . with this projection matrix , the mass profile in the new basis
is written as @xmath414 accordingly , the error covariance matrix in the new basis is @xmath415 with the mass profiles of individual clusters on a common basis , we can stack the clusters to produce an averaged mass profile .
here we re - evaluate the mass profiles of the individual clusters in @xmath416 logarithmically - spaced radial bins over the range of radii @xmath417r_{\rm vir}$ ] .
since the noise in different clusters is uncorrelated , the mass profiles of individual clusters can be co - added according to ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) @xmath418 where the index @xmath419 runs over all of the clusters , and @xmath420 is the inverse critical surface mass density for the @xmath419th cluster , @xmath421 .
the error covariance matrix for the stacked mass profile @xmath422 is obtained as @xmath423 where the index @xmath419 runs over all of the clusters .
we show in the top panel of figure [ fig : stack ] the resulting model - independent average mass profile @xmath424 with its statistical @xmath32 uncertainty as a function of the scaled projected radius @xmath425 , obtained by stacking the five clusters using equations ( [ eq : stack ] ) and ( [ eq : covar_stack ] ) ( see also * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we note that the effect of different cluster redshifts has been taken into account by proper error propagation in terms of the lensing efficiency functions ( @xmath420 ) of individual clusters to average over .
the stacked mass profile exhibits a fairly smooth radial trend , and is detected at a high significance level of @xmath2 out to @xmath426 .
in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : stack ] , we plot the logarithmic density slope @xmath427 of the stacked mass profile as a function of the scaled projected radius along with nfw model predictions with @xmath428 and @xmath429 .
the logarithmic gradient of the average profile shows a slight steepening trend with increasing radius in projection , consistent with nfw profiles with @xmath430 .
finally , we quote model - independent constraints on the average logarithmic density slope to be @xmath5 at @xmath431 and @xmath7 at @xmath432 for the five clusters .
the subaru data allow the weak lensing profiles of individual clusters to be accurately measured in several independent radial bins in the subcritical regime ( @xmath433 ) .
the projected mass profile can be unambiguously recovered on an individual cluster basis from combined weak - lensing shape distortion and magnification bias measurements . here
we combine our weak - lensing profiles with detailed strong - lensing information for the inner @xmath27kpc region of these clusters , for which we have identified many new sets of multiple images from deep _
hst_/acs observations @xcite , for a full determination of the entire mass profiles of the five well - studied clusters .
figure [ fig : fullmass ] shows a sample of joint mass profiles for our five clusters recovered over two decades of radius ranging from 10kpc@xmath236 to @xmath434kpc@xmath236 .
note in this comparison we have excluded the central weak - lensing bin @xmath435 and the strong - lensing data points at radii overlapping with the subaru data . in each case , the weak and strong lensing are in excellent agreement where the data overlap ( typically around @xmath436kpc@xmath437 ) , and the joint mass profiles form well - defined radial profiles with a continuously - steepening radial trend from the central region to beyond the virial radius ( @xmath438 ) . our high - quality lensing data , covering the entire cluster ,
allow us to place useful constraints on the gnfw structure parameters ( [ subsec : lprof ] ) , namely , the central cusp slope @xmath334 as well as the nfw virial mass and concentration parameters . using our full lensing constraints , we obtain for each cluster the best - fit gnfw model as summarized in table [ tab : nfw ] . for the halo mass and concentration parameters ( @xmath439 ) , we find good agreement between the results with and without the inner strong - lensing profile combined ( for cl0024 + 17 , see also * ? ? ?
our joint mass profiles for the entire cluster region are consistent with a generalized form of the nfw density profile with modest variations in the central cusp slope ( @xmath440 ) , except for the ongoing merger rxj1347 - 11 ( see * ? ? ?
* ) , for which we find an unacceptable fit with a reduced @xmath338 of @xmath441 for @xmath442 degrees of freedom , due to various local deviations from the model , especially in the inner mass profile which is tightly constrained by strong lensing .
the best - fit value of @xmath334 derived for the relaxed cluster a1703 is @xmath443 , being consistent with nfw ( @xmath330 ) , which is in excellent agreement with independent lensing results by @xcite , @xmath444 , and @xcite , @xmath445 .
we have developed a new method for a direct reconstruction of the projected mass profile of galaxy clusters from combined weak - lensing distortion and magnification measurements ( [ subsec : gt ] and [ subsec : magbias ] ) within a bayesian statistical framework , which allows for a full parameter - space extraction of the underlying signal .
this method applies to the full range of radius outside the einstein radius , where nonlinearity between the surface mass density and the observables extends to a radius of a few arcminutes , and recovers the absolute mass normalization .
a proper bayesian statistical analysis is essential to explore the entire parameter space and investigate the parameter degeneracies ( [ subsec : bayesian ] ) , arising from the mass - sheet degeneracy ( [ sec : basis ] ) .
this method can be readily generalized for a statistical analysis using stacked lensing profiles of a sample of clusters .
we have applied our comprehensive lensing method to a sample of five high - mass clusters for which detailed strong - lensing information is readily available from _
hst_/acs observations .
the deep subaru multi - band photometry , in conjunction with our background - selection techniques @xcite , allows for a secure selection of uncontaminated blue and red background populations . in each cluster
, a strong depletion of the red galaxy counts has been detected at a significance level of @xmath254@xmath255 ( table [ tab : data ] ) .
a comparison shows clear consistency between two independent lensing observables with different systematics , ensuring the reliability of our weak - lensing analysis ( figure [ fig : data ] ) .
the combination of independent subaru distortion and magnification data breaks the mass - sheet degeneracy , as examined by our bayesian statistical analysis ( figure [ fig : post ] ) . excluding magnification data , on the other hand ,
strongly modifies the gaussian shape of the marginalized posterior pdfs , producing long non - gaussian tails and broadening the distribution function , resulting in large reconstruction errors .
the improvement here from adding the magnification measurements is significant , @xmath10 in terms of cluster mass profile measurements ( table [ tab : data ] ) .
we have formed a model - independent mass profile from stacking the clusters , which is detected at @xmath2 out to beyond the virial radius , @xmath3 .
we found that the projected logarithmic slope , @xmath446 , steepens from @xmath5 at @xmath6 to @xmath7 at @xmath8 , consistent with nfw profiles with @xmath430 .
we also obtained for each cluster inner strong - lensing based mass profiles from deep _
hst_/acs observations , which we have shown overlap well with the outer subaru - based profiles and together are well described by a generalized navarro - frenk - white profile , except for the ongoing merger rxj1347 - 11 @xcite , with modest variations in the central cusp slope ( @xmath440 ) , perhaps related to the dynamical state of the cluster .
these high - mass lensing clusters with large einstein radii appear to be centrally concentrated in projection , as found in several other well studied massive clusters from careful lensing work .
an accurate characterization of the observed sample is crucial for any cluster - based cosmological tests .
it has been suggested that clusters selected with giant arcs represent a highly biased population in the context of @xmath11cdm . for those clusters with large einstein radii ( say , @xmath447 ) ,
a large statistical bias of about @xmath448 is derived from @xmath19-body simulations @xcite , representing the most triaxial cases .
the mean level of mass concentration inferred from our weak lensing analysis is high , @xmath449 ( simply ignoring the mass and redshift dependencies ) , for our sample with @xmath450 , as compared to the @xmath11cdm predictions , @xmath451 , evaluated at the median redshift of our sample , @xmath452 .
this represents an overall discrepancy of @xmath453 with respect to the predictions , without taking into account the effects of projection bias .
this apparent discrepancy is also evident when the weak - lensing mass profiles are combined with the inner strong - lensing information from deep acs observations ( [ subsec : wl+sl ] ) .
applying a bias correction of @xmath454 ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the discrepancy in @xmath455 is reduced to the @xmath456 level .
another possible source of systematic errors in the mass profile determination is the cluster off - centering effect ( [ subsec : lprof ] ) .
the effect is essentially the smoothing of the central lensing signal ( see * ? ? ?
* ) , which flattens the recovered convergence profile below the offset scale , and therefore reduces the derived mass concentration ( @xmath457 ) and cusp slope ( @xmath334 ) parameters . for our sample of clusters
, we found a cluster centering offset of typically @xmath458 using our detailed strong - lensing models .
this level of centering offset ( @xmath459kpc@xmath236 ) is much smaller than the estimated values for the inner characteristic radius of our clusters , @xmath460 , and hence may not significantly affect our concentration measurements .
however , this could potentially lead to an underestimation of the central cusp slope @xmath334
. our results are consistent with previous lensing work which similarly detected a concentration excess in the lensing - based measurements for strong - lensing clusters @xcite .
our findings could imply , for these clusters , either substantial mass projected along the line of sight , due in part to intrinsic halo triaxiality , or a higher - than - expected concentration of dark matter .
nevertheless , the overall level of uncertainties may be too large to robustly test the cdm predictions with the present sample .
the forthcoming space telescope cluster survey , clash , will provide a definitive derivation of mass profiles for a larger , lensing - unbiased sample of relaxed x - ray clusters ( @xmath461kev ) , combining high - resolution panchromatic space imaging with deep , wide - field subaru weak - lensing observations , for a definitive determination of the representative mass profile of massive clusters .
we thank the anonymous referee for a careful reading of the manuscript and and for providing invaluable comments .
we are very grateful for discussions with doron lemze , sandor molnar , masahiro takada , masayuki tanaka , nobuhiro okabe , and sherry suyu , whose comments were very helpful . k.u .
acknowledges yuji chinone for helpful comments on mcmc techniques .
we thank nick kaiser for making the imcat package publicly available .
the work is partially supported by the national science council of taiwan under the grant nsc97 - 2112-m-001 - 020-my3 .
for the cluster magnification analysis , the masking effect due to bright cluster galaxies , bright foreground objects , and saturated objects has to be properly taken into account and corrected for @xcite . here
we describe two different approaches for estimating the effect of masking in the magnification bias measurement . in this method ( method a ) , we describe each masking object as an ellipse specified by its structure parameters , such as the size , axis ratio , and position angle .
sextractor provides such useful estimates of object properties ( magnitude , size , axis ratio , position angle , and so on ) for calculating masking areas and the resulting correction . in practice , we account for the masking of observed sky by excluding a generous area @xmath462 around each masking object , where @xmath463 and @xmath464 are defined as @xmath465 times the major ( a_image ) and minor axes ( b_image ) computed from sextractor , corresponding roughly to the isophotal detection limit ( see @xcite and @xcite ) .
we then calculate the correction factor for this masking effect as a function of radius from the cluster center , and renormalize the number density accordingly .
note that the actual choice of @xmath466 is insensitive to the resulting magnification measurement @xmath467 @xcite , as this effect will cancel out when taking a ratio of the local surface density @xmath468 to the unlensed mean number density @xmath115 ( see 5.5.3 of umetsu & broadhurst 2008 ) .
however , this method is not suitable for estimating masking areas by saturated stars and stellar trails , which can not be described by simple ellipses . for this case
, we manually place a rectangular region mask around each saturated object to exclude a proper area .
this approach has been commonly adopted in previous studies of cluster magnification bias @xcite . in the top panel of figure [ fig : mask ] , we show as an example the masked region in a1689 based on the subaru @xmath154-band photometry , as obtained using method a ( see also umetsu & broadhurst 2008 ) .
the gray area shows bright masking objects ( @xmath469 ab mag ) , each described as an ellipse .
the black rectangular regions are masked areas for saturated stars and bright stellar trails .
we show in figure [ fig : fmask ] the level of mask area correction in a1689 as a function of radius from the cluster center .
the masking area is negligible ( a few % ) at large radii , and increases up to @xmath470 of the sky close to the cluster center .
typically , the level of masking correction is found to be sufficiently small ( @xmath471 ) , so that the uncertainty in the masking correction is of the second order , and hence negligible .
here we describe an alternative method ( method b ) for the masking correction which we have developed in this work .
this method has practical advantages in comparison to method a : that is , it is easy to implement and can be fully automated once the configuration of analysis parameters is tuned , especially useful for large scale sky surveys such as the subaru hsc survey . in this approach ,
we use a pixelized flag image to exclude masking regions , namely those connected pixels that belong to bright foreground objects , bright cluster galaxies , saturated stars , and stellar trails .
this can be done using sextractor s check - image output with @xmath472 .
we tune sextractor configuration s detection parameters in order to optimize the detection for a particular object size and brightness . in our analysis of subaru images , the per - pixel detection threshold above the local sky background is set to @xmath453 ( @xmath473 ) , and the minimum number of connected pixels above threshold is set to @xmath474 ( @xmath475 ) with @xmath476 sampling . the bottom panel of figure [ fig : mask ] shows the distribution of masked regions in a1689 as obtained using method b. figure [ fig : fmask ] compares the masking correction factor in a1689 obtained using methods a and b , shown as a function of radius from the cluster center . it is shown that the two methods give consistent results in terms of both shape and amplitude of the radial profile of the correction factor .
in this appendix , we aim to derive a discrete expression for the mean interior convergence @xmath477 using the azimuthally - averaged convergence @xmath77 . in the continuous limit , the mean convergence @xmath478 interior to radius @xmath79 can be expressed in terms of @xmath77 as @xmath479 for a given set of @xmath129 annular radii @xmath480 @xmath481 , defining @xmath19 radial bands in the range @xmath482 , a discretized estimator for @xmath483 can be written in the following way : @xmath484 with @xmath485 and @xmath486 being the area - weighted center of the @xmath87th annulus defined by @xmath487 and @xmath488 ; in the continuous limit , we have @xmath489
we derive expressions for the binned tangential distortion @xmath83 and magnification @xmath46 in terms of the binned convergence @xmath38 , using the following relations : @xmath490 where both the quantities depend on the mean convergence @xmath491 interior to the radius @xmath86 , which is the center of the @xmath87th radial band of @xmath88 $ ] ( see appendix [ appendix : avkappa ] ) . by assuming a constant density in each radial band and by noting that @xmath86 is the _
median _ radius of the @xmath87th radial band , @xmath492 can be well approximated by @xmath493 where @xmath494 and @xmath495 can be computed using the formulae given in appendices [ appendix : avkappa ] and [ appendix : lprof ] .
if we are to combine background samples of different populations ( @xmath463 and @xmath464 ) and different lensing depths @xmath229 , we should take into account population - to - population variations in the lensing depth , @xmath496 , which can be measured from deep multi - band imaging , such as the 30-band cosmos database @xcite .
the tangential distortion @xmath497 for population ( @xmath464 ) can be expressed in terms of the convergence @xmath498 for population ( @xmath463 ) as @xmath499 similarly , the magnification @xmath500 for population ( @xmath464 ) can be expressed in terms of @xmath501 .
in this supplemental material section , we compare observed tangential - distortion ( shear ) @xmath70 and count - depletion ( magnification ) @xmath468 radial profiles with their respective reconstructed profiles , taking a370 at @xmath502 ( figure [ fig : a370 ] ) and cl0024 + 17 at @xmath503 ( figure [ fig : cl0024 ] ) as examples .
we note that this supplemental material is added for the arxiv version only , and is not included in the published apj version ( umetsu et al .
2011 , apj , 729 , 127 ) . | we directly construct model - independent mass profiles of galaxy clusters from combined weak - lensing distortion and magnification measurements within a bayesian statistical framework , which allows for a full parameter - space extraction of the underlying signal .
this method applies to the full range of radius outside the einstein radius , and recovers the absolute mass normalization .
we apply our method to deep subaru imaging of five high - mass ( @xmath0 ) clusters , a1689 , a1703 , a370 , cl0024 + 17 , and rxj1347 - 11 , to obtain accurate profiles to beyond the virial radius ( @xmath1 ) . for each cluster
the lens distortion and magnification data are shown to be consistent with each other , and the total signal - to - noise ratio of the combined measurements ranges from 13 to 24 per cluster .
we form a model - independent mass profile from stacking the clusters , which is detected at @xmath2 out to @xmath3 . the projected logarithmic slope @xmath4 steepens from @xmath5 at @xmath6 to @xmath7 at @xmath8 .
we also derive for each cluster inner strong - lensing based mass profiles from deep advanced camera for surveys observations with the _ hubble space telescope _ , which we show overlap well with the outer subaru - based profiles and together are well described by a generalized form of the navarro - frenk - white profile , except for the ongoing merger rxj1347 - 11 , with modest variations in the central cusp slope ( @xmath9 ) .
the improvement here from adding the magnification measurements is significant , @xmath10 in terms of cluster mass profile measurements , compared with the lensing distortion signal . |
according to the principle of emergence , the rich properties and the many different forms of materials originate from the different ways in which the atoms are ordered in the materials .
landau symmetry - breaking theory provides a general understanding of those different orders and resulting rich states of matter.@xcite it points out that different orders really correspond to different symmetries in the organizations of the constituent atoms . as a material changes from one order to another order ( i.e. , as the material undergoes a phase transition )
, what happens is that the symmetry of the organization of the atoms changes . for a long time
, we believed that landau symmetry - breaking theory describes all possible orders in materials , and all possible ( continuous ) phase transitions .
however , in last twenty years , it has become more and more clear that landau symmetry - breaking theory does not describe all possible orders . after the discovery of high @xmath0 superconductors in 1986,@xcite some theorists believed that quantum spin liquids play a key role in understanding high @xmath0 superconductors@xcite and started to introduce various spin liquids.@xcite despite the success of landau symmetry - breaking theory in describing all kinds of states , the theory can not explain and does not even allow the existence of spin liquids .
this leads many theorists to doubt the very existence of spin liquids . in 1987 , in an attempt to explain high temperature superconductivity , an infrared stable spin liquid
chiral spin state was discovered,@xcite which was shown to be perturbatively stable and exist as quantum phase of matter ( at least in a large @xmath1 limit ) .
at first , not believing landau symmetry - breaking theory fails to describe spin liquids , people still wanted to use symmetry - breaking to describe the chiral spin state .
they identified the chiral spin state as a state that breaks the time reversal and parity symmetries , but not the spin rotation symmetry.@xcite however , it was quickly realized that there are many different chiral spin states that have exactly the same symmetry , so symmetry alone is not enough to characterize different chiral spin states .
this means that the chiral spin states contain a new kind of order that is beyond symmetry description.@xcite this new kind of order was named@xcite topological order .
the key to identify ( and define ) new orders is to identify new universal properties that are beyond the local order parameters and long - range correlations used in the landau symmetry breaking theory . indeed ,
new quantum numbers , such as ground state degeneracy@xcite , the non - abelian berry s phase of degenerate ground states@xcite and edge excitations@xcite , were introduced to characterize ( and define ) the different topological orders in chiral spin states .
recently , it was shown that topological orders can also be characterized by topological entanglement entropy.@xcite more importantly , those quantities were shown to be universal ( robust against any local perturbation of the hamiltonian ) for chiral spin states.@xcite the existence of those universal properties establishes the existence of topological order in chiral spin states .
near the end of 1980 s , the existence of chiral spin states as a theoretical possibility , as well as their many amazing properties , such as fractional statistics,@xcite spin - charge separation,@xcite chiral gapless edge excitations,@xcite were established reliably , at least in the large @xmath1-limit introduced in .
even non - abelian chiral spin states can be established reliably in the large @xmath1-limit.@xcite however , it took about 10 years to establish the existence of a chiral spin state reliably without using large @xmath1-limit ( based on an exactly soluble model on honeycomb lattice).@xcite soon after the introduction of chiral spin states , experiments indicated that high - temperature superconductors do not break the time reversal and parity symmetries .
so chiral spin states do not describe high - temperature superconductors .
thus the theory of topological order became a theory with no experimental realization .
however , the similarity between chiral spin states and fractional quantum hall ( fqh ) states allows one to use the theory of topological order to describe different fqh states.@xcite just like chiral spin states , different fqh states all have the same symmetry and are beyond the landau symmetry - breaking description . also like chiral spin states ,
fqh states have ground state degeneracies@xcite that depend on the topology of the space.@xcite those ground state degeneracies are shown to be robust against any perturbations .
thus , the different orders in different quantum hall states can be described by topological orders , and the topological order does have experimental realizations . the topology dependent ground state degeneracy , that signal the presence of topological order , is an amazing phenomenon . in fqh states ,
the correlation of any local operators are short ranged .
this seems to imply that fqh states are `` short sighted '' and they can not know the topology of space which is a global and long - distance property .
however , the fact that ground state degeneracy does depend on the topology of space implies that fqh states are not `` short sighted '' and they do find a way to know the global and long - distance structure of space .
so , despite the short - range correlations of any local operators , the fqh states must contain certain hidden long - range correlation .
but what is this hidden long - range correlation ?
this will be one of the main topic of this paper .
since high @xmath0 superconductors do not break the time reversal and parity symmetries , nor any other lattice symmetries , some people concentrated on finding spin liquids that respect all those symmetries and hoping one of those symmetric spin liquids hold the key to understand high @xmath0 superconductors . between 1987 and 1992 , many symmetric spin liquids were introduced and studied.@xcite the excitations in some of constructed spin liquids have a finite energy gap , while in others there is no energy gap .
those symmetric spin liquids do not break any symmetry and , by definition , are beyond landau symmetry - breaking description . by construction
, topological order only describes the organization of particles or spins in a gapped quantum state .
so the theory of topological order only applies to gapped spin liquids .
indeed , we find that the gapped spin liquids do contain nontrivial topological orders@xcite ( as signified by their topology dependent and robust ground state degeneracies ) and are described by topological quantum field theory ( such as @xmath2 gauge theory ) at low energies .
one of the simplest topologically ordered spin liquids is the @xmath2 spin liquid which was first introduced in 1991.@xcite the existence of @xmath2 spin liquid as a theoretical possibility , as well as its many amazing properties , such as spin - charge separation,@xcite fractional mutual statistics,@xcite topologically protected ground state degeneracy,@xcite were established reliably ( at least in the large @xmath1-limit introduced in ) .
later , kitaev introduced the famous toric code model which establishes the existence of the @xmath2 spin liquid reliably without using large @xmath1-limit.@xcite the topologically protected degeneracy of the @xmath2 spin liquid was used to perform fault - tolerant quantum computation .
the study of high @xmath0 superconductors also leads to many gapless spin liquids . the stability and the existence of those gapless spin liquid were in more doubts than their gapped counterparts .
but careful analysis in certain large @xmath1 limit do suggest that stable gapless spin liquids can exist.@xcite if we do believe in the existence of gapless spin liquids , then the next question is how to describe the orders ( the organizations of spins ) in those gapless spin liquids .
if gapped quantum state can contain new type of orders that are beyond landau s symmetry breaking description , it is natural to expect that gapless quantum states can also contain new type of orders . but how to show the existence of new orders in gapless states ?
just like topological order , the key to identify new orders is to identify new universal properties that are beyond landau symmetry description . clearly we can no longer use the ground state degeneracy to establish the existence of new orders in gapless states . to show the existence of new orders in gapless states , a new universal quantity projective symmetry group ( psg )
was introduced.@xcite it was argued that ( some ) psgs are robust against any local perturbations of the hamiltonian that do not change the symmetry of the hamiltonian.@xcite so through psg , we establish the existence of new orders even in gapless states .
the new orders are called quantum order to indicate that the new orders are related to patterns of quantum entanglement in the many - body ground state.@xcite
what is missed in landau theory so that it fails to describe those new orders ?
what is the new feature in the organization of particles / spins so that the resulting order can not be described by symmetry ? to answer those questions , let us consider a simple quantum system which can be described with landau theory the transverse field ising model in two dimensions : @xmath3 , where @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 are the pauli matrices on site @xmath7 . in @xmath8 limit , the ground state of the system is an equal - weight superposition of all possible spin - up and spin - down states : @xmath9 , where @xmath10 label a particular spin - up ( @xmath11 ) and spin - down ( @xmath12 ) configuration . in the @xmath13 limit , the system has two degenerate ground states @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the transverse field ising model has a @xmath16 symmetry .
the ground state @xmath17 respect such a symmetry while the ground state @xmath18 ( or @xmath19 ) break the symmetry .
thus the small @xmath20 ground state @xmath17 and the small @xmath21 ground state @xmath18 describe different phases since they have different symmetries .
we note that @xmath18 is the exact ground state of the transverse field ising model with @xmath22 .
the state has no quantum entanglement since @xmath18 is a direct product of local states : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is an up - spin state at site @xmath7 .
the state @xmath17 is the exact ground state of the transverse field ising model with @xmath25 .
it is also a state with no quantum entanglement : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is a state with spin in @xmath28-direction at site @xmath7 .
we see that the states ( or phases ) described by landau symmetry breaking theory has no quantum entanglement at least in the @xmath25 or @xmath22 limits . in the @xmath29 and @xmath30 limits , the two ground states of the two limits still represent two phases with different symmetries
. however , in this case , the ground states are not unentangled . on the other hand
since the ground states in the @xmath25 or @xmath22 limits have finite energy gaps and short - range correlations , a small @xmath20 or a small @xmath21 can only modify the states locally .
thus we expect the ground states have only short - range entanglement .
the above example , if generalized to other symmetry breaking states , suggests the following conjecture : _ _ if a gapped quantum ground state is described by landau symmetry breaking theory , then it has short - range quantum entanglement . _ _ the direct - product states and short - range entangled states only represent a small subset of all possible quantum many - body states .
thus , according to the point of view of the above conjecture , we see that what is missed by landau symmetry breaking theory is long - range quantum entanglement .
it is this long - range quantum entanglement that makes a state to have nontrivial topological / quantum order .
however , mathematically speaking , the above conjecture is a null statement since the meaning of short - range quantum entanglement is not defined . in the following
, we will try to find a more precise description ( or definition ) of short - range and long - range quantum entanglement .
we will start with a careful discussion of quantum phases and quantum phase transitions .
to give a precise definition of quantum phases , let us consider a local quantum system whose hamiltonian has a smooth dependence on a parameter @xmath31 : @xmath32 .
the ground state average of a local operator @xmath33 of the system , @xmath34 , naturally also depend on @xmath31 .
if the function @xmath34 , in the limit of infinite system size , has a singularity at @xmath35 for some local operators @xmath33 , then the system described by @xmath32 has a quantum phase transition at @xmath35 . after defining phase transition
, we can define when two quantum ground states belong to the same phase : let @xmath36 be the ground state of @xmath37 and @xmath38 be the ground state of @xmath39 . if we can find a smooth path @xmath32 , @xmath40 that connect the two hamiltonian @xmath37 and @xmath39 such that there is no phase transition along the path , then the two quantum ground states @xmath36 and @xmath38 belong to the same phase .
we note that `` connected by a smooth path '' define an equivalence relation between quantum states .
a quantum phase is an equivalence class of such equivalence relation .
such an equivalence class is called an universality class .
if @xmath36 is the ground state of @xmath37 and in the limit of infinite system size all excitations above @xmath36 have a gap , then for small enough @xmath31 , we believe that the systems described by @xmath32 are also gapped.@xcite in this case , we can show that , the ground state of @xmath32 , @xmath41 , is in the same phase as @xmath36 , for small enough @xmath31 , the average @xmath34 is a smooth function of @xmath31 near @xmath42 for any local operator @xmath33.@xcite after scaling @xmath31 to @xmath43 , we find that : @xmath44 $ , then there is no phase transition along the path $ g$. } } \ ] ] in other words , for gapped system , a quantum phase transition can happen only when energy gap closes@xcite ( see fig .
[ trans ] ) .
is finite for all @xmath31 in the segment @xmath45 $ ] , show that the algebra of local operators for different @xmath31 s are isomorphic to each other at low energies , using a quasi - adiabatic continuation of quantum states . ] here , we would like to assume that the reverse is also true : a closing of the energy gap for a gapped state always induces a phase transition . or more precisely @xmath46 $ , and $ |\phi(0)\>$ and $ |\phi(1)\>$ are ground states of $ h(0)$ and $ h(1)$ respectively . } } \ ] ] the above two boxed statements imply that two gapped quantum states are in the same phase @xmath47 if and only if they can be connected by an adiabatic evolution that does not close the energy gap .
given two states , @xmath36 and @xmath38 , determining the existence of such a gapped adiabatic connection can be hard .
we would like to have a more operationally practical equivalence relation between states in the same phase . here
we would like to show that _ two gapped states @xmath36 and @xmath38 are in the same phase , if and only if they are related by a local unitary ( lu ) evolution .
_ we define a local unitary(lu ) evolution as an unitary operation generated by time evolution of a local hamiltonian for a finite time .
that is , @xmath48 |\phi(0)\>\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 is the path - ordering operator and @xmath50 is a sum of local hermitian operators .
note that @xmath51 is in general different from the adiabatic path @xmath32 that connects the two states .
first , assume that two states @xmath36 and @xmath38 are in the same phase , therefore we can find a gapped adiabatic path @xmath32 between the states .
the existence of a gap prevents the system to be excited to higher energy levels and leads to a local unitary evolution , the quasi - adiabatic continuation as defined in , that maps from one state to the other .
that is , @xmath52\ ] ] the exact form of @xmath51 is given in and will be discussed in more detail in appendix . in the hamiltonian .
( a , b ) for gapped system , a quantum phase transition can happen only when energy gap closes .
( a ) describes a first order quantum phase transition ( caused by level crossing ) .
( b ) describes a continuous quantum phase transition which has a continuum of gapless excitations at the transition point .
( c ) and ( d ) can not happen for generic states .
a gapped system may have ground state degeneracy , where the energy splitting between the ground states vanishes when system size @xmath53 : @xmath54 .
the energy gap @xmath55 between ground and excited states on the other hand remains finite as @xmath53 . ] on the other hand , the reverse is also true : _ if two gapped states @xmath36 and @xmath38 are related by a local unitary evolution , then they are in the same phase .
_ since @xmath36 and @xmath38 are related by a local unitary evolution , we have @xmath56 |\phi(0)\ > $ ] .
let us introduce @xmath57 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] assume @xmath36 is a ground state of @xmath37 , then @xmath58 is a ground state of @xmath59 .
if @xmath60 remains local and gapped for all @xmath61 $ ] , then we have found an adiabatic connection between @xmath36 and @xmath38 .
first , let us show that @xmath60 is a local hamiltonian . since @xmath62 is a local hamiltonian , it has a form @xmath63 where @xmath64 only acts on a cluster whose size is @xmath65 .
@xmath65 is called the range of interaction of @xmath62 .
we see that @xmath60 has a form @xmath66 , where @xmath67 . to show that @xmath68 only acts on a cluster of a finite size
, we note that for a local system described by @xmath51 , the propagation velocities of its excitations have a maximum value @xmath69 .
since @xmath70 can be viewed as the time evolution of @xmath64 by @xmath71 from @xmath72 to @xmath73 , we find that @xmath68 only acts on a cluster of size @xmath74,@xcite where @xmath75 is the range of interaction of @xmath76 . thus @xmath60 are indeed local hamiltonian .
if @xmath62 has a finite energy gap , then @xmath60 also have a finite energy gap for any @xmath77 .
as @xmath77 goes for @xmath78 to @xmath43 , the ground state of the local hamiltonians , @xmath60 , goes from @xmath36 to @xmath38 .
thus the two states @xmath36 and @xmath38 belong to the same phase .
this completes our argument that states related by a local unitary evolution belong to the same phase .
thus through the above discussion , we show that @xmath79 a more detailed and more rigorous discussion of this equivalence relation is given in appendix a , where exact bounds on locality and transformation error is given .
the relation defines an equivalence relation between @xmath36 and @xmath38 .
the equivalence classes of such an equivalence relation represent different quantum phases .
so the above result implies that the equivalence classes of the lu evolutions are the universality classes of quantum phases for gapped states .
using the lu evolution , we can obtain a more precise description ( or definition ) of short - range entanglement : @xmath80 if a state can not be transformed into an unentangled state through a lu evolution , then the state has long - range entanglement .
we also see that @xmath81 thus all states with short - range entanglement belong to the same phase .
the local unitary evolutions we consider here do not have any symmetry .
if we require certain symmetry of the local unitary evolutions , states with short - range entanglement may belong to different symmetry breaking phases , which will be discussed in section [ symtop ] . since a direct - product state is a state with trivial topological order
, we see that a state with a short - range entanglement also has a trivial topological order .
this leads us to conclude that a non - trivial topological order is related to long - range entanglement .
since two gapped states related by a lu evolution belong to the same phase , thus two gapped states related by a local unitary evolution have the same topological order .
in other words , @xmath82 or more pictorially , topological order is a pattern of long - range entanglement . in
, it was shown that the `` topologically non - trivial '' ground states , such as the toric code,@xcite can not be changed into a `` topologically trivial '' state such as a product state by any unitary locality - preserving operator .
in other words , those `` topologically non - trivial '' ground states have long - range entanglement . .
the green shading represents a causal structure . ]
the lu evolutions introduced here is closely related to _ quantum circuits with finite depth_. to define quantum circuits ,
let us introduce piece - wise local unitary operators .
a piece - wise local unitary operator has a form @xmath83 where @xmath84 is a set of unitary operators that act on non overlapping regions .
the size of each region is less than some finite number @xmath85 .
the unitary operator @xmath86 defined in this way is called a piece - wise local unitary operator with range @xmath85 . a quantum circuit with depth @xmath87 is given by the product of @xmath87 piece - wise local unitary operators ( see fig . [ qc ] ) : @xmath88 . in quantum information theory ,
it is known that finite time unitary evolution with local hamiltonian ( lu evolution defined before ) can be simulated with constant depth quantum circuit and vice - verse .
therefore , the equivalence relation can be equivalently stated in terms of constant depth quantum circuits : @xmath89 where @xmath87 is a constant independent of system size .
because of their equivalence , we will use the term `` local unitary transformation '' to refer to both local unitary evolution and constant depth quantum circuit in general .
the lu transformation defined through lu evolution is more general .
it can be easily generalized to study topological orders and quantum phases with symmetries ( see section [ symtop]).@xcite the quantum circuit has a more clear and simple causal structure .
however , the quantum circuit approach breaks the translation symmetry .
so it is more suitable for studying quantum phases that do not have translation symmetry .
in fact , people have been using quantum circuits to classify many - body quantum states which correspond to quantum phases of matter . in
, the local unitary transformations described by quantum circuits was used to define a renormalization group transformations for states and establish an equivalence relation in which states are equivalent if they are connected by a local unitary transformation .
such an approach was used to classify 1d matrix product states . in
, the local unitary transformations with disentanglers was used to perform a renormalization group transformations for states , which give rise to the multi - scale entanglement renormalization ansatz ( mera ) in one and higher dimensions .
the disentanglers and the isometries in mera can be used to study quantum phases and quantum phase transitions in one and higher dimensions . later in this paper
, we will use the quantum circuit description of lu transformations to classify 2d topological orders through classifying the fixed - point lu transformations .
in the above discussions , we have defined phases without any symmetry consideration . the @xmath51 or @xmath86 in the lu transformation does not need to have any symmetry and can be sum / product of any local operators . in this case , two hamiltonians with an adiabatic connection are in the same phase even if they may have different symmetries .
also , all states with short - range entanglement belong to the same phase ( under the lu transformations that do not have any symmetry ) . on the other hand , we can consider only hamiltonians @xmath62 with certain symmetries and define phases as the equivalent classes of symmetric local unitary transformations : @xmath90 where @xmath51 or @xmath91 has the same symmetries as @xmath62 .
we note that the symmetric local unitary transformation in the form @xmath92 always connect to the identity transformation continuously
. this may not be the case for the transformation in the form @xmath91 . to rule out that possibility
, we define symmetric local unitary transformations as those that connect to the identity transformation continuously .
the equivalent classes of the symmetric lu transformations have very different structures compared to those of lu transformations without symmetry .
each equivalent class of the symmetric lu transformations is smaller and there are more kinds of classes , in general . without any symmetry .
( b ) the possible phases for a hamiltonian @xmath93 with some symmetries .
the shaded regions in ( a ) and ( b ) represent the phases with short range entanglement ( those ground states can be transformed into a direct product state via a generic lu transformations that do not have any symmetry . ) ] fig .
[ topsymm ] compares the structure of phases for a system without any symmetry and a system with some symmetry in more detail . for a system without any symmetry ,
all the short - range - entangled ( sre ) states ( those ground states can be transformed into a direct product state via a generic lu transformations that do not have any symmetry ) are in the same phase ( sre in fig .
[ topsymm](a ) ) . on the other hand , long range entanglement ( lre )
can have many different patterns that give rise to different topological phases ( lre 1 and lre 2 in fig .
[ topsymm](a ) ) .
the different topological orders usually give rise to quasiparticles with different fractional statistics and fractional charges . for a system with some symmetries
, the phase structure can be much more complicated .
the short - range - entangled states no longer belong to the same phase , since the equivalence relation is described by more special symmetric lu transformations : + ( a ) states with short range entanglement belong to different equivalent classes of the symmetric lu transformations if they have different broken symmetries .
they correspond to the symmetry - breaking ( sb ) short - range - entanglement phases sb - sre 1 and sb - sre 2 in fig .
[ topsymm](b ) .
they are landau s symmetry breaking states .
+ ( b ) states with short range entanglement can belong to different equivalent classes of the symmetric lu transformations even if they do not break any symmetry of the system .
( in this case , they have the same symmetry . )
they correspond to the symmetric ( sy ) short - range - entangled phases sy - sre 1 and sy - sre 2 in fig .
[ topsymm](b ) .
we say those states have symmetry protected topological orders .
haldane phase@xcite and @xmath94 phase of spin-1 chain are examples of states with the same symmetry which belong to two different equivalent classes of symmetric lu transformations ( with parity symmetry).@xcite band and topological insulators@xcite are other examples of states that have the same symmetry and at the same time belong to two different equivalent classes of symmetric lu transformations ( with time reversal symmetry ) .
also , for a system with some symmetries , the long - range - entangled states are divided into more classes ( more phases ) : + ( c ) symmetry breaking and long range entanglement can appear together in a state , such as sb - lre 1 , sb - lre 2 , in fig . [
topsymm](b ) .
the topological superconducting states are examples of such phases.@xcite + ( d ) long - range - entangled states that do not break any symmetry can also belong to different phases such as the symmetric long - range - entanglement phases sy - lre 1 , sy - lre 2 , in fig .
[ topsymm](b ) .
the many different @xmath2 symmetric spin liquids with spin rotation , translation , and time - reversal symmetries are examples of those phases.@xcite some time - reversal symmetric topological orders were also called topological mott - insulators or fractionalized topological insulators.@xcite
after defining topological order as the equivalent classes of many - body wave functions under lu transformations , we like to ask : how to describe ( or label ) the different equivalent classes ( the different topological orders or patterns of long - range entanglement ) ? one simple way to do so is to use the full wave function which completely describe the different topological orders .
but the full wave functions contain a lot of non - universal short - range entanglement . as a result ,
such a labeling scheme is a very inefficient many - to - one labeling scheme of topological orders . to find a
more efficient or even one - to - one labeling scheme , we need to remove the non - universal short - range entanglement . into a direct - product state , if and only if the state @xmath95 has no long - range quantum entanglement .
here , a dot represents a site with physical degrees of freedom .
a vertical line carries an index that label the different physical states on a site .
the presence of horizontal lines between dots represents quantum entanglement . ] into a direct product . removing / adding the degrees of freedom in the form of direct product defines an additional equivalence relation that defines the topological order ( or classes of long - range entanglement ) . ] as the first application of the notion of lu transformation , we would like to describe a wave function renormalization group flow introduced in , .
the wave function renormalization can remove the short - range entanglement and simplify the wave function . in
, the wave function renormalization for string - net states is generated by the following two basic moves @xmath96{xikljo } \epm = & \delta_{ij } \phi \bpm \includegraphics[height=0.3in]{xi0 } \epm \\ \label{fmv } \phi \bpm \includegraphics[height=0.3in]{xijklmxo } \epm = & \sum_{n } f^{jim^*}_{lk^*n^ * } \phi \bpm \includegraphics[height=0.3in]{xijklnxo } \epm\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( note that the definition of the f - tensor in is slightly different from the definition in this paper . )
the two basic moves can generate a generic wave function renormalization which can reduce the string - net wave functions to very simple forms.@xcite later in , the wave function renormalization for generic states was discussed in a more general setting , and was called mera . the two basic string - net moves and correspond to the isometry and the disentangler in mera respectively . in the mera approach ,
the isometries and the disentanglers are applied in a layered fashion , while in the string - net approach , the two basic moves can be applied arbitrarily . in this section
, we will follow the mera setup to describe the wave function renormalization . later in this paper
, we will follow the string - net setup to study the fixed - point wave functions .
note that we can use a lu transformation @xmath97 to transform some degrees of freedom in a state into direct product ( see fig .
[ entre ] ) .
we then remove those degrees of freedom in the form of direct product .
such a procedure does not change the topological order .
the reverse process of adding degrees of freedom in the form of direct product also does not change the topological order .
we call the local transformation in fig .
[ entre ] that changes the degrees of freedom a generalized local unitary ( glu ) transformation .
it is clear that a generalized local unitary transformation inside a region @xmath98 does not change the reduced density matrix @xmath99 for the region @xmath98 .
this is the reason why we say that ( generalized ) local unitary transformations can not change long - range entanglement and topological order .
similarly , the addition or removal of decoupled degrees of freedom to or from the hamiltonian , @xmath100 , will not change the phase of the hamiltonian ( the ground states of @xmath62 and @xmath101 are in the same phase ) , if those degrees of freedom form a direct product state ( the ground state of @xmath102 is a direct product state ) .
let us define the glu transformation @xmath97 more carefully and in a more general setting .
consider a state @xmath95 .
let @xmath99 be the reduced density matrix of @xmath95 in region @xmath98 .
@xmath99 may act in a subspace of the total hilbert space @xmath103 in region a , which is called the support space @xmath104 of region @xmath98 .
the dimension @xmath105 of @xmath104 is called support dimension of region @xmath98 . now the hilbert space @xmath103 in region a can be written as @xmath106 .
let @xmath107 , @xmath108 be a basis of this support space @xmath104 , @xmath107 , @xmath109 be a basis of @xmath110 , where @xmath111 is the dimension of @xmath103 , and @xmath112 , @xmath113 be a basis of @xmath103 .
we can introduce a lu transformation @xmath114 which rotates the basis @xmath112 to @xmath107 .
we note that in the new basis , the wave function only has non - zero amplitudes on the first @xmath105 basis vectors .
thus , in the new basis @xmath107 , we can reduce the range of the label @xmath115 from @xmath116 $ ] to @xmath117 $ ] without losing any information .
this motivates us to introduce the glu transformation as a rotation from @xmath112 , @xmath113 to @xmath118 , @xmath108 .
the rectangular matrix @xmath97 is given by @xmath119 .
we also regard the inverse of @xmath97 , @xmath120 , as a glu transformation .
a lu transformation is viewed as a special case of glu transformation where the degrees of freedom are not changed . clearly @xmath121 and @xmath122 are two projectors .
the action of @xmath123 does not change the state @xmath95 ( see fig .
[ glut](b ) ) .
we note that despite the reduction of the degrees of freedom , a glu transformation defines an equivalent relation .
two states related by a glu transformation belong to the same phase .
the renormalization flow induced by the glu transformations always flows within the same phase .
acts in region a of a state @xmath95 , which reduces the degree freedom in region a to those contained only in the support space of @xmath95 in region a. ( b ) @xmath121 is a projector that does not change the state @xmath95 . ]
as an application of the wave function renormalization , in this section , we will study the structure of fixed - point wave functions under the wave function renormalization , which will lead to a classification of topological order ( without any symmetry ) .
we note that as wave functions flow to a fixed point , the glu transformations in each step of the renormalization also flow to a fixed point .
so instead of studying fixed - point wave functions , here , we will study the fixed - point glu transformations .
for this purpose , we need to fix the renormalization scheme . in the following
, we will discuss a renormalization scheme motivated by the string - net wave function.@xcite after we specify a proper wave function renormalization scheme , then the fixed - point wave function is simply the wave function whose `` form '' does not change under the wave function renormalization . since those fixed - point glu transformations do not change the fixed - point wave function , their actions on the fixed - point wave function
do not depend on the order of the actions .
this allows us to obtain many conditions that glu transformations must satisfy . from those conditions
, we can determine the forms of allowed fixed - point glu transformations .
this leads to a general description and a classification of topological orders and their corresponding fixed - point wave functions .
the renormalization scheme that we will discuss was first used in to characterize the scale invariant string - net wave function .
it is also used in to simplify the string - net state in a region , which allows us to calculate the entanglement entropy of the string - net state exactly .
a similar approach was used in to show quantum - double / string - net wave function to be a fixed - point wave function and its connection to 2d mera.@xcite in the following , we will generalize those discussions by not starting with string - net wave functions .
we just try to construct local unitary transformations at a fixed point .
we will see that the fixed - point conditions on the glu transformations lead to a mathematical structure that is similar to the tensor category theory the mathematical framework behind the string - net states .
since the wave function renormalization may change the lattice structure , we will consider quantum states defined on a generic trivalence graph @xmath124 : each edge has @xmath125 states , labeled by @xmath126 ( see fig .
[ nijkv ] ) .
we assume that the index @xmath115 on the edge admits an one - to - one mapping @xmath127 : @xmath128 that satisfies @xmath129 . as a result
, the edges of the graph are oriented .
the mapping @xmath128 corresponds to the reverse of the orientation of the edge ( see fig .
[ llstar ] ) .
each vertex also has physical states , labeled by @xmath130 ( see fig .
[ nijkv ] ) . each labeled graph
( see fig .
[ nijkv ] ) corresponds to a state and all the labeled graphs form an orthonormal basis .
our fixed - point state is a superposition of those basis states : @xmath131{strnet}\emm \right ) \left |\bmm \includegraphics[scale=0.2]{strnet}\emm\right \>$ ] .
here we will make an important assumption about the fixed - point wave function .
we will assume that the fixed - point wave function is `` topological '' : two labeled graphs have the same amplitude if the two labeled graphs can be deformed into each other continuously on the plane without the vertices crossing the links .
for example @xmath132{gs1}\epm = \psi_\text{fix}\bpm \includegraphics[scale=0.25]{gs2}\epm $ ] .
due to such an assumption , the topological orders studied in this paper may not be most general .
we also assume that all the fixed - point states on each different graphs to have the same `` form '' .
this assumption is motivated by the fact that during wave function renormalization , we transform a state on one graph to a state on a different graph .
the `` fixed - point '' means that the wave functions on those different graphs are all determined by the same collection of the rules , which defines the meaning of having the same `` form '' .
however , the wave function for a given graph can have different total phases if the wave function is calculated by applying the rules in different orders .
those rules are noting but the fixed - point glu transformations . .
there are @xmath125 states on each edge which are labeled by @xmath133 .
there are @xmath134 states on each vertex which are labeled by @xmath130 . ]
corresponds to the reverse of the orientation of the edge ] . if the three edges of a vertex are in the states @xmath115 , @xmath135 , and @xmath136 respectively , then the vertex has @xmath137 states , labeled by @xmath138 .
note the orientation of the edges are point towards to vertex .
also note that @xmath139 runs anti - clockwise . ] before describing the wave function renormalization , let us examine the structure of entanglement of a fixed - point wave function .
first , let us consider a fixed - point wave function @xmath140 on a graph .
we examine the wave function on a patch of the graph , for example , @xmath141{f1g}\emm$ ] .
the fixed - point wave function @xmath142{f1g}\epm$ ] ( only the relevant part of the graph is drawn ) can be viewed as a function of @xmath143 : @xmath144{f1 g } \epm$ ] if we fix @xmath145 and the indices on other part of the graph .
( here the indices on other part of the graph is summarized by @xmath146 . )
as we vary the indices @xmath146 on other part of graph ( still keeping @xmath115 , @xmath135 , @xmath136 , and @xmath85 fixed ) , the wave function of @xmath143 , @xmath147 , may change .
all those @xmath147 form a linear space of dimension @xmath148 .
@xmath149 is an important concept that will appear later .
we note that the two vertices @xmath150 and @xmath151 and the link @xmath152 form a region surrounded by the links @xmath145 .
so we will call the dimension-@xmath148 space the support space @xmath153 and @xmath148 the support dimension for the state @xmath140 on the region surrounded by the fixed boundary state @xmath145 .
similarly , we can define @xmath154 as the support dimension of the @xmath142{ijkal}\epm$ ] on a region bounded by links @xmath155 .
since the region contains only a single vertex @xmath150 with @xmath134 physics states , we have @xmath156 .
we can use a local unitary transformation on the vertex to reduce the range of @xmath150 to @xmath157 where @xmath158 . in the rest of this paper
, we will implement such a reduction .
so , the number of physical states on a vertex depend on the physical states of the edges that connect to the vertex .
if the three edges of a vertex are in the states @xmath115 , @xmath135 , and @xmath136 respectively , then the vertex has @xmath137 states , labeled by @xmath138 ( see fig .
[ nijk ] ) . here
we assume that @xmath159 we note that in the fixed - point wave function @xmath142{f1g}\epm$ ] , the number of choices of @xmath143 is @xmath160 .
thus the support dimension @xmath148 satisfies @xmath161 . here
we will make an important assumption the saturation assumption : _ the fixed - point wave function saturate the inequality : _ @xmath162 we will see that the entanglement structure described by such a saturation assumption is invariant under the wave function renormalization .
our wave function renormalization scheme contains two types of renormalization .
the first type of renormalization does not change the degrees of freedom and corresponds to a local unitary transformation .
it corresponds to locally deform the graph @xmath163{f1 g } \emm$ ] to @xmath163{f2 g } \emm$ ] .
( the parts that are not drawn are the same . )
the fixed - point wave function on the new graph is given by @xmath142{f2g}\epm$ ] .
again , such a wave function can be viewed as a function of @xmath164 : @xmath165{f2 g } \epm$ ] if we fix @xmath145 and the indices on other part of the graph .
the support dimension of the state @xmath142{f2g}\epm$ ] on the region surrounded by @xmath145 is @xmath166 . again
@xmath167 , where @xmath168 is number of choices of @xmath164 .
the saturation assumption implies that @xmath169 .
the two fixed - point wave functions @xmath142{f1g}\epm$ ] and @xmath142{f2g}\epm$ ] are related via a local unitary transformation .
thus @xmath170 , which implies @xmath171 we express such an unitary transformation as @xmath172 or graphically as @xmath173{f1 g } \epm \simeq \sum_{n=0}^n \sum_{\chi=1}^{n_{kjn^ * } } \sum_{\del=1}^{n_{nil^ * } } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{kln,\chi\del } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{f2 g } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath174 means equal up to a constant phase factor .
( note that the total phase of the wave function is unphysical . )
we will call such a wave function renormalization step a f - move .
we would like to remark that relates two wave functions on two graphs @xmath175 and @xmath176 which only differ by a local reconnection .
we can choose the phase of @xmath177 to make @xmath174 into @xmath178 : @xmath179{f1 g } \epm = \sum_{n=0}^n \sum_{\chi=1}^{n_{kjn^ * } } \sum_{\del=1}^{n_{nil^ * } } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{kln,\chi\del } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{f2 g } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] but such choice of phase only works for a particular pair of graphs @xmath175 and @xmath176 . to use @xmath177 to relate all pair of states that only differ by a local reconnection , in general , we may have a phase ambiguity , with the value of phase depend on the pair of graphs .
so can only be a relation up to a total phase factor . for fixed @xmath115 , @xmath135 , @xmath136 , and @xmath85 , the matrix @xmath180 with matrix elements
@xmath181 is a @xmath182 dimensional matrix ( see ) .
the mapping @xmath183 generated by the matrix @xmath180 is unitary .
since , as we change @xmath146 , @xmath184 and @xmath147 span two @xmath182 dimensional spaces .
thus @xmath180 is a @xmath185 unitary matrix @xmath186 where @xmath187 when @xmath188 , @xmath189 , @xmath190 , and @xmath191 otherwise
. we can deform @xmath192{f1 g } \emm$ ] to @xmath192{f1ga } \emm$ ] , and @xmath192{f2 g } \emm$ ] to @xmath192{f2ga } \emm$ ] .
we see that @xmath193{f1ga } \epm
\simeq \sum_{n=0}^n \sum_{\chi,\del } f^{kl^*m^*,\bt\al}_{ij^*n^*,\del\chi } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{f2ga } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqn .
( [ ihwave ] ) and eqn .
( [ ihwavea ] ) relate the same pair of graphs , and thus @xmath194 ( where we have used the condition @xmath195 . ) using the relation , we can rewrite as @xmath196{f2 g } \epm \simeq \sum_{m=0}^n \sum_{\al,\bt } ( f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{kln,\chi\del})^ * \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{f1 g } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can also express @xmath197{f2 g } \epm $ ] as @xmath198{f2 g } \epm \simeq \sum_{m=0}^n \sum_{\al,\bt } f^{jkn,\chi\del}_{l^*i^*m^*,\bt\al } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{f1 g } \epm\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the relabeled .
so we have @xmath199 since the total phase of the wave function is unphysical , the total phase of @xmath177 can be chosen arbitrarily .
we can choose the total phase of @xmath177 to make @xmath200 if we apply twice , we reproduce . thus is not independent and can be dropped .
from the graphic representation , we note that @xmath201 when @xmath202 or @xmath203 , the left - hand - side of is always zero .
thus @xmath204 when @xmath202 or @xmath205 . when @xmath206 or @xmath207 , wave function on the right - hand - side of is always zero .
so we can choose @xmath204 when @xmath206 or @xmath207 .
the f - move maps the wave functions on two different graphs through a local unitary transformation .
since we can locally transform one graph to another graph through different paths , the f - move must satisfy certain self consistent condition .
for example the graph @xmath208{pent1 g } \emm $ ] can be transformed to @xmath209{pent3 g } \emm $ ] through two different paths ; one contains two steps of local transformations and the other contains three steps of local transformations as described by .
the two paths lead to the following relations between the wave functions : @xmath210{pent1 g } \epm & \simeq \sum_{q,\del,\eps } f^{mkn,\bt\chi}_{lpq,\del\eps } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{pent2 g } \epm \simeq \sum_{q,\del,\eps;s,\phi,\ga } f^{mkn,\bt\chi}_{lpq,\del\eps } f^{ijm,\al\eps}_{qps,\phi\ga } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{pent3 g } \epm , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath211{pent1 g } \epm & \simeq \sum_{t,\eta,\vphi } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{knt,\eta\vphi } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{pent4 g } \epm \simeq \sum_{t,\eta,\vphi;s,\ka,\ga } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{knt,\eta\vphi } f^{itn,\vphi\chi}_{lps,\ka\ga } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{pent5 g } \epm \nonumber\\ & \simeq \sum_{t,\eta,\ka;\vphi;s,\ka,\ga;q,\del,\phi } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{knt,\eta\vphi } f^{itn,\vphi\chi}_{lps,\ka\ga } f^{jkt,\eta\ka}_{lsq,\del\phi } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{pent3 g } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the consistence of the above two relations leads a condition on the @xmath212 tensor . to obtain such a condition ,
let us fix @xmath115 , @xmath135 , @xmath136 , @xmath85 , @xmath213 , and view @xmath214{pent1 g } \epm$ ] as a function of @xmath215 : @xmath216{pent1 g } \epm$ ] .
as we vary indices on other part of graph , we obtain different wave functions @xmath217 which form a dimension @xmath218 space . in other words , @xmath218 is the support dimension of the state @xmath140 on the region @xmath215 with boundary state @xmath219 fixed ( see the discussion in section [ entstru ] ) .
since the number of choices of @xmath215 is @xmath220 , we have @xmath221 . here
we require a similar saturation condition as in : @xmath222 similarly , the number of choices of @xmath223 in @xmath214{pent3 g } \epm $ ] is also @xmath224 . here
we again assume @xmath225 , where @xmath226 is the support dimension of @xmath214{pent3 g } \epm $ ] on the region bounded by @xmath219 .
so the two relations and can be viewed as two relations between a pair of vectors in the two @xmath218 dimensional vector spaces .
as we vary indices on other part of graph ( still keeping @xmath219 fixed ) , each vector in the pair can span the full @xmath218 dimensional vector space .
so the validity of the two relations and implies that @xmath227 which is a generalization of the famous pentagon identity ( due to the extra constant phase factor @xmath228 ) .
we will call such a relation projective pentagon identity .
the projective pentagon identity is a set of nonlinear equations satisfied by the rank-10 tensor @xmath177 and @xmath229 .
the above consistency relation is equivalent to the requirement that the local unitary transformations described by on different paths all commute with each other up to a total phase factor .
the second type of wave function renormalization does change the degrees of freedom and corresponds to a generalized local unitary transformation .
one way to implement the second type renormalization is to reduce @xmath208{4to1a } \emm $ ] to @xmath192{4to1b } \emm $ ] ( the part of the graph that is not drawn is unchanged ) : @xmath230{4to1a } \epm \simeq \sum_{\la=1}^{n_{ijk } } f ^{abc,\al\bt\ga } _ { ijk,\la } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{4to1b } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] but we can define a simpler second type renormalization , by noting that @xmath163{4to1a } \emm$ ] can be reduced to @xmath163{tpolij } \emm$ ] via the first type of renormalization steps ( see fig .
[ tritpol ] ) , which are local unitary transformations . in the simplified second type renormalization ,
we want to reduce @xmath163{tpolij } \emm$ ] to @xmath163{iline } \emm$ ] , so that we still have a trivalence graph .
this requires that the support dimension @xmath231 of the fixed - point wave function @xmath232{tpolij } \epm $ ] is given by @xmath233 this implies that @xmath234{tpolij } \epm \simeq \del_{ii ' } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{tpol } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the simplified second type renormalization can now be written as ( since @xmath235 ) @xmath236{tpol } \epm \simeq p_i^{kj,\al\bt } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{iline } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we will call such a wave function renormalization step a p - move.@xcite here @xmath237 satisfies @xmath238 and @xmath239 the condition ensures that the two wave functions on the two sides of have the same normalization .
we note that the number of choices for the four indices @xmath240 in @xmath241 must be equal or greater than @xmath43 : @xmath242 notice that @xmath243{tpol } \epm \simeq \sum_{m,\la,\ga } f^{jj^*k,\bt\al}_{i^*i^*m^*,\la\ga } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{buble } \epm \nonumber\\ & \simeq \sum_{m,\la,\ga , l,\nu,\mu } f^{jj^*k,\bt\al}_{i^*i^*m^*,\la\ga } f^{i^*mj,\la\ga}_{m^*i^*l,\nu\mu } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{tpolud } \epm\end{aligned}\ ] ] using and its variation @xmath244{tpolud } \epm \simeq p_{i^*}^{lm,\mu\nu } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{iline } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can rewrite as @xmath245 which is a condition on @xmath241 .
more conditions on @xmath177 and @xmath241 can be obtained by noticing that @xmath234{f1gp } \epm \simeq \sum_{n=0}^n \sum_{\chi,\del } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{kln,\chi\del } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{f2gp } \epm , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which implies that @xmath246{ikl1 } \epm \nonumber\\ & \simeq \sum_{n,\chi,\del } f^{ijm,\al\bt}_{kln,\chi\del } p^{jp,\chi\eta}_{k^ * } \del_{kn } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{ikl2 } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we find @xmath247 in the last section , we discussed the conditions that a fixed - point glu transformation @xmath248 must satisfy . after finding a fixed - point glu transformation @xmath248 , in this section , we are going to discuss how to calculate the corresponding fixed - point wave function @xmath140 from the solved fixed - point glu transformation @xmath248 .
first we note that , using the two types of wave function renormalization introduced above , we can reduce any graph to @xmath192{oi } \emm$ ] .
so , once we know @xmath214{oi } \epm$ ] , we can reconstruct the full fixed - point wave function @xmath140 on any connected graph .
let us assume that @xmath234{oi } \epm = a^i = a^{i^*}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath249 satisfy @xmath250 the condition @xmath251 is simply the normalization condition of the wave function .
the condition @xmath252 come from the fact that the graph @xmath163{oi } \emm$ ] can be deformed into the graph @xmath192{oia } \emm$ ] on a sphere . to find the conditions that determine @xmath249 ,
let us first consider the fixed - point wave function where the index on a link is @xmath115 : @xmath253{iga1 } \epm$ ] , where @xmath146 are indices on other part of graph .
we note that the graph @xmath163{iga1 } \emm$ ] can be deformed into the graph @xmath192{iga2 } \emm$ ] on a sphere .
thus @xmath197{iga1 } \epm= \phi_\text{fix}\bpm \includegraphics[scale=.35]{iga2 } \epm$ ] .
using the f - moves and the p - moves , we can reduce @xmath192{iga2 } \emm$ ] to @xmath192{oi } \emm$ ] : @xmath254{iga1 } \epm= \phi_\text{fix}\bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{iga2 } \epm \simeq f(i,\ga ) \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{oi } \epm\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see that @xmath255{oi } \epm = a^i\neq 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath115 .
otherwise , any wave function with @xmath115-link will be zero . to find more conditions on @xmath249
, we note that @xmath234{ooijm } \epm \simeq p^{mj,\ga\la}_i \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{oi } \epm = p^{mj,\ga\la}_ia^i .\end{aligned}\ ] ] by rotating @xmath192{ooijm } \emm$ ] by 180@xmath256 , we can show that @xmath257 or @xmath258 we also note that @xmath234{thetaijk } \epm & \simeq \sum_{m,\la,\ga } f^{ijk^*,\al\bt}_{j^*im,\la\ga } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{ooijm } \epm .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this allows us to show @xmath259 where @xmath260{thetaijk } \epm \nonumber\\ & \phi^\th_{ikj,\al\bt } = \e^{\imth \th_{a2 } } \phi^\th_{kji,\al\bt } , \nonumber\\ & \phi^\th_{ikj,\al\bt}=0 , \text { if } n_{ikj}=0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the condition @xmath261 comes from the fact that the graph @xmath192{thetaijk } \emm$ ] and the graph @xmath192{thetakij } \emm$ ] can be deformed into each other on a sphere .
also , for any given @xmath262 that satisfy @xmath263 , the wave function @xmath264{ijkga } \epm$ ] must be non - zero for some @xmath146 , where @xmath146 represents indices on other part of the graph . then after some f - moves and p - moves
, we can reduce @xmath192{ijkga } \emm$ ] to @xmath192{thetakij } \emm$ ] .
so , for any given @xmath262 that satisfy @xmath263 , @xmath214{thetakij } \epm$ ] is non - zero for some @xmath151 .
since such a statement is true for any choices of basis on the vertex @xmath150 , we find that for any given @xmath262 that satisfy @xmath263 and for any non - zero vector @xmath265 , @xmath266{thetakij } \epm$ ] is non - zero for some @xmath151 .
this means that the matrix @xmath267 is invertible , where @xmath267 is a matrix whose elements are given by @xmath268{thetakij } \epm $ ] .
let us define @xmath269{thetakij } \epm \big ] = \det(m_{kji})$ ] , we find that @xmath270{thetakij } \epm \big ] = \det [ \phi^\th_{kji,\al\bt } ] \neq 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above also implies that @xmath271 the conditions eqns .
( [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] ) allow us to determine @xmath249 ( and @xmath272 ) . from , we see that relation @xmath197{thetaijk } \epm = \phi_\text{fix}\bpm \includegraphics[scale=.35]{thetakij } \epm$ ] leads to some equations for @xmath273 , @xmath241 , and @xmath249 .
more equations for @xmath273 , @xmath241 , and @xmath249 , can be obtained by using the relations @xmath274{tetra1 } \epm & = \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{tetra2 } \epm \nonumber\\ & = \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{tetra3 } \epm , \end{aligned}\ ] ] from the tetrahedron rotation symmetry@xcite and @xmath275{tetra1 } \epm \simeq \sum_{\ga\la } f^{ijm^*,\al\bt}_{kln,\ga\la } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{sq00 } \epm \nonumber\\ & \simeq \sum_{\ga\la , p\si\eps } f^{ijm^*,\al\bt}_{kln,\ga\la } f^{ln^*i^*,\del\la}_{nlp^*,\si\eps } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{osqo } \epm \nonumber\\ & \simeq \sum_{\ga\la , p\si\eps } f^{ijm^*,\al\bt}_{kln,\ga\la } f^{ln^*i^*,\del\la}_{nlp^*,\si\eps } p^{pl^*,\si\eps}_{n } \phi_\text{fix } \bpm \includegraphics[scale=.40]{sqo } \epm \nonumber\\ & = \sum_{\ga\la , p\si\eps } f^{ijm^*,\al\bt}_{kln,\ga\la } f^{ln^*i^*,\del\la}_{nlp^*,\si\eps } p^{pl^*,\si\eps}_{n } \phi^\th_{kjn^*,\ga\chi } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is not clear if and will lead to new independent equations or not . in the following discussions , we will not include and .
we find that , at least for simple cases , the equations without and are enough to completely determine the solutions .
to summarize , the conditions ( [ nnnn ] , [ di ] , [ nnstar ] , [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] , [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] ) form a set of non - linear equations whose variables are @xmath137 , @xmath273 , @xmath241 , @xmath249 , and @xmath276 .
finding @xmath137 , @xmath273 , @xmath241 , and @xmath249 that satisfy such a set of non - linear equations corresponds to finding a fixed - point glu transformation that has a non - trivial fixed - point wave function .
so the solutions @xmath277 give us a characterization of topological orders .
this may lead to a classification of topological order from the local unitary transformation point of view .
in this section , let us find some simple solutions of the fixed - point conditions ( [ nnnn ] , [ di ] , [ nnstar ] , [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] , [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] ) for the fixed - point glu transformations @xmath278 and the fixed - point wave function @xmath249 . formally , the solutions of the fixed - point conditions are not isolated .
they are parameterized by several continuous phase factors . in this section
, we will discuss the origin of those phase factors .
we will see that those different phase factors do not correspond to different states of matter ( different equivalence classes of glu transformations ) .
so after removing those unimportant phase factors , the solutions of the fixed - point conditions are isolated ( at least for the simple examples studied here ) .
we notice that , apart from two normalization conditions , all of the fixed - point conditions are linear in @xmath241 and @xmath249
. thus if @xmath279 is a solution , then @xmath280 is also a solution .
however , the two phase factors @xmath281 do not lead to different fixed - point wave functions , since they only affect the total phase of the wave function and are unphysical .
thus the total phases of @xmath282 and @xmath249 can be adjusted .
we can use this degree of freedom to set , say , @xmath283 and @xmath284 .
similarly the total phase of @xmath273 is also unphysical and can be adjusted .
we have used this degree of freedom to reduce to .
but this does not totally fix the total phase of @xmath273 .
the transformation @xmath285 does not affect .
we can use such a transformation to set the real part of a non - zero component of @xmath273 to be positive .
the above three phase factors are unphysical .
however , the fixed - point solutions may also contain phase factors that do correspond to different fixed - point wave functions .
for example , the local unitary transformation @xmath286 does not affect the fusion rule @xmath137 , where @xmath287 is the number of links with @xmath288-state and @xmath289-state .
such a local unitary transformation changes @xmath279 and generates a continuous family of the fixed - point wave functions parameterized by @xmath290 .
those wave functions are related by local unitary transformations that continuously connect to identity .
thus , those fixed - point wave functions all belong to the same phase .
similarly , we can consider the following local unitary transformation @xmath291 that acts on each vertex with states @xmath292 on the three edges connecting to the vertex .
such a local unitary transformation also does not affect the fusion rule @xmath137 .
the new local unitary transformation changes @xmath279 and generates a continuous family of the fixed - point wave functions parameterized by the unitary matrix @xmath293 .
again , those fixed - point wave functions all belong to the same phase . in the following ,
we will study some simple solutions of the fixed - point conditions .
we find that , for those examples , the solutions have no addition continuous parameter apart from the phase factors discussed above .
this suggests that the solutions of the fixed - point conditions correspond to isolated zero - temperature phases .
let us first consider a system where there are only two states @xmath295 and @xmath296 on each link of the graph .
we choose @xmath297 and the simplest fusion rule that satisfies , , is @xmath298 since @xmath299 , there is no states on the vertices .
so the indices @xmath300 labeling the states on a vertex can be suppressed .
the above fusion rule corresponds to the fusion rule for the @xmath294 loop state discussed in .
so we will call the corresponding graphic state @xmath294 loop state .
due to the relation , the different components of the tensor @xmath301 are not independent .
there are only four independent potentially non - zero components which are denoted as @xmath302, ... ,@xmath303 : @xmath304 \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f_{0 } \nonumber\\ f^{000}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkaa \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{011}_{100 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkaa \mlnkbb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=(f^{101}_{010 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^ * \nonumber\\ & = f^{110}_{001 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm = f_{1 } \nonumber\\ f^{011}_{011 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbb \klnkaa \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{101}_{101 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkaa \klnkbb \llnkaa \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{2 } \nonumber\\ f^{110}_{110 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox
\ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f_{3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that @xmath301 in relates wave functions on two graphs . in the above we have drawn the two related graphs after the @xmath212 tensor , where the first graph following @xmath212 corresponds to the graph on the left - hand side of and the second graph corresponds to the graph on the right - hand side of .
the doted line corresponds to the @xmath295-state on the link and the solid line corresponds to the @xmath296-state on the link .
there are four potentially non - zero components in @xmath282 , which are denoted by @xmath305, ... ,@xmath306 : @xmath307 we can adjust the total phases of @xmath308 and @xmath249 to make @xmath309 and @xmath310 .
we can also use the local unitary transformation @xmath311 with @xmath312 to make @xmath313 , since the @xmath212 s described by @xmath314 in are the only @xmath212 s that change the number of @xmath296-links .
the fixed - point conditions ( [ nnnn ] , [ di ] , [ nnstar ] , [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] , [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] ) form a set of non - linear equations on the ten variables @xmath315 , @xmath308 , and @xmath249 .
many of the non - linear equations are dependent or even equivalent .
using a computer algebraic system , we simplify the set of non - linear equations .
the simplified equations are ( after making the phase choice described above ) @xmath316 where @xmath317 .
the above simplified equations can be solved exactly .
we find two solutions parameterized by @xmath317 : @xmath318 we also find @xmath319 the @xmath320 fixed - point state corresponds to the @xmath2 loop condensed state whose low energy effective field theory is the @xmath2 gauge theory.@xcite we call such a state , simply , the @xmath2 state .
the @xmath321 fixed - point state corresponds to the double - semion state whose low energy effective field theory is the @xmath322 chern - simons gauge theory@xcite @xmath323 to obtain another class of simple solutions , we modify the fusion rule to @xmath324 while keeping everything the same .
the above @xmath137 also satisfies , , and .
the new fusion rule corresponds to the fusion rule for the @xmath294 string - net state discussed in .
so we will call the corresponding graphic state @xmath294 string - net state . again , due to the relation , the different components of the tensor @xmath301 are not independent .
now there are seven independent potentially non - zero components which are denoted as @xmath302, ... ,@xmath325 : @xmath326 \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f_{0 } \nonumber\\ f^{000}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkaa \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{011}_{100 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkaa \mlnkbb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=(f^{101}_{010 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^ * \nonumber\\ & = f^{110}_{001 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm = f_{1 } \nonumber\\ f^{011}_{011 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbb \klnkaa \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{101}_{101 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkaa \klnkbb \llnkaa \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{2 } \nonumber\\ f^{011}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{101}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkaa \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f^{111}_{011 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkaa \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm \nonumber\\ & = ( f^{111}_{101 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkaa \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{3 } \nonumber\\ f^{110}_{110 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f_{4 } \nonumber\\ f^{110}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkaa \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{111}_{110 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{5 } \nonumber\\ f^{111}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbb \jlnkbb \klnkbb \llnkbb \mlnkbb \nlnkbb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f_{6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath212 s described by @xmath314 and @xmath327 are the only @xmath212 s that change the number of @xmath296-links and the number of @xmath328-vertices .
so we can use the local unitary transformation @xmath329 to make @xmath314 and @xmath327 to be positive real numbers .
( here @xmath330 is the total number of @xmath296-links and @xmath331 is the total number of @xmath328-vertices . )
we also use the freedom of adjusting the total sign of @xmath301 to make re@xmath332 .
there are five potentially non - zero components in @xmath282 , which are denoted by @xmath305, ... ,@xmath333 : @xmath334 we use the freedom of adjusting the total phase of @xmath282 to make @xmath305 to be a positive number .
we can also use the freedom of adjusting the total phase of @xmath249 to make @xmath335 to be a positive number .
the fixed - point conditions ( [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] , [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] ) form a set of non - linear equation on the variables @xmath315 , @xmath308 , and @xmath249 , which can be simplified .
the simplified equations have the following form @xmath336 let @xmath337 be the positive solution of @xmath338 : @xmath339 .
we see that @xmath340 .
the above can be written as @xmath341 we also find @xmath319 the fixed - point state corresponds to the @xmath294 string - net condensed state@xcite whose low energy effective field theory is the doubled @xmath342 chern - simons gauge theory.@xcite the above simple examples correspond to non - orientable string - net states . here
we will give an example of orientable string - net state .
we choose @xmath343 , @xmath345 , @xmath346 , @xmath347 , and @xmath348 the above @xmath137 satisfies , , and . due to the relation ,
the different components of the tensor @xmath301 are not independent .
there are eight independent potentially non - zero components which are denoted as @xmath302, ... ,@xmath349 : @xmath326 \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f_{0 } \nonumber\\ f^{000}_{111 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkbc \llnkbc \mlnkaa \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{011}_{200 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbc \klnkcb \llnkaa \mlnkbc \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f^{120}_{002 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkcb \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm \nonumber\\ & = ( f^{202}_{020 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkcb \mlnkcb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{1 } \nonumber\\ f^{000}_{222 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkaa \klnkcb \llnkcb \mlnkaa \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{022}_{100 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkcb \klnkbc \llnkaa \mlnkcb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=(f^{101}_{010 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkaa \klnkaa \llnkbc \mlnkbc \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*\nonumber\\ & = f^{210}_{001 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkbc \klnkaa \llnkaa \mlnkaa \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm = f_{2 } \nonumber\\ f^{011}_{011 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbc \klnkaa \llnkbc \mlnkbc \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = f^{022}_{022 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkcb \klnkaa \llnkcb \mlnkcb \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm = ( f^{101}_{202 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkaa \klnkcb \llnkaa \mlnkbc \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*\nonumber\\ & = ( f^{202}_{101 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkaa \klnkbc \llnkaa \mlnkcb \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{3 } \nonumber\\ f^{011}_{122 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkbc \klnkbc \llnkcb \mlnkbc \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{101}_{121 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkaa \klnkbc \llnkcb \mlnkbc \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f^{112}_{021 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkbc \klnkaa \llnkcb \mlnkcb \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm \nonumber\\ & = ( f^{112}_{102 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkbc \klnkbc \llnkaa \mlnkcb \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{4 } \nonumber\\ f^{022}_{211 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkaa \jlnkcb \klnkcb \llnkbc \mlnkcb \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{202}_{212 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkaa \klnkcb \llnkbc \mlnkcb \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f^{221}_{012 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkcb \klnkaa \llnkbc \mlnkbc \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm \nonumber\\ & = ( f^{221}_{201 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkcb \klnkcb \llnkaa \mlnkbc \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{5 } \nonumber\\ f^{112}_{210 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkbc \klnkcb \llnkbc \mlnkcb \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{120}_{221 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkcb \klnkcb \llnkcb \mlnkaa \nlnkbc \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=(f^{210}_{112 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkbc \klnkbc \llnkbc \mlnkaa \nlnkcb \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^ * \nonumber\\ & = f^{221}_{120 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox
\ilnkcb \jlnkcb \klnkbc \llnkcb \mlnkbc \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm = f_{6 } \nonumber\\ f^{120}_{110 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkbc \jlnkcb \klnkbc \llnkbc \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm & = ( f^{210}_{220 } \bmm\begin{tikzpicture}[scale=0.26 ] \fbox \ilnkcb \jlnkbc \klnkcb \llnkcb \mlnkaa \nlnkaa \end{tikzpicture}\emm ) ^*=f_{7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] there are nine potentially non - zero components in @xmath282 , which are denoted by @xmath305, ... ,@xmath350 : @xmath351 using the transformations discussed in section [ fixphase ] , we can fix the phases of @xmath314 , @xmath352 , @xmath325 , and @xmath305 to make them positive . the fixed - point conditions ( [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] , [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] )
form a set of non - linear equation on the variables @xmath315 , @xmath308 , and @xmath249 , which can be solved exactly .
after fixing the phases using the transformations discussed in section [ fixphase ] , we find only one solution @xmath353 we also find @xmath319 the fixed - point state corresponds to the @xmath344 string - net condensed state@xcite whose low energy effective field theory is the @xmath322 chern - simons gauge theory@xcite @xmath354 which is the @xmath344 gauge theory .
we note that all the above simple solutions also satisfy the standard pentagon identity , although we solved the weaker projective pentagon identity .
it is not clear if we can find non - trivial solutions that do not satisfy the standard pentagon identity .
there are several ways to define time reversal operation for the graphic states .
the simplest one is given by @xmath355 where @xmath146 represents the labels on the vertices and links which are not changed under @xmath356 .
( this corresponds to the situation where the different states on the links and the vertices are realized by different occupations of scalar bosons . ) for such a time reversal transformation , @xmath357 and the real solutions of the fixed - point conditions ( [ nnnn ] , [ di ] , [ nnstar ] , [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] , [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] ) give us a classification of time reversal invariant topological orders in local spin systems .
note that the time reversal invariant topological orders are equivalent class of local orthogonal transformations that connect to the identity transformation continuously .
different real solutions @xmath358 of the fixed - point conditions do not always correspond to different time reversal invariant topological orders .
the solutions differ by some unimportant phase factors ( which are @xmath359 signs ) correspond to the same topological order . to understand the above result
, we notice that , from the structure of the fixed - point conditions , if @xmath279 is a solution , then @xmath360 is also a solution , where @xmath361 , @xmath362 , and @xmath363 .
however , the three phase factors @xmath364 , @xmath365 , and @xmath366 do not lead to different fixed - point wave functions , since they only affect the total phase of the wave function and are unphysical .
on the other hand , the fixed - point solutions may also contain phase factors that do correspond to different fixed - point wave functions .
for example , the local orthogonal transformation @xmath367 does not affect the fusion rule @xmath137 , where @xmath287 is the number of links with @xmath288-state and @xmath289-state .
such a local orthogonal transformation changes @xmath279 and generates a discrete family of the fixed - point wave functions .
similarly , we can consider the following local orthogonal transformation @xmath368 that acts on each vertex with states @xmath292 on the three edges connecting to the vertex .
such a local orthogonal transformation also does not affect the fusion rule @xmath137 . the new local orthogonal transformation changes @xmath279 and generates a family of the fixed - point wave functions parameterized by the orthogonal matrix @xmath369 .
now the question is that do those solutions related by local orthogonal transformations have the same time reversal invariant topological order or not .
we know that two gapped wave functions have the same time reversal invariant topological order if and only if they can be connected by local orthogonal transformation that _ connects to identity continuously_. it is well known that an orthogonal matrix whose determinant is @xmath370 does not connect to identity .
thus it appears that local orthogonal transformations some times can generate different time reversal invariant topological orders .
however , when we use the equivalent classes of local orthogonal transformations to define time reversal invariant topological orders , we not only assume the local orthogonal transformations to connect to identity continuously , we also assume that we can expand the local hilbert spaces ( say by increasing the range of the indices @xmath115 and @xmath150 that label the states on the edges and the vertices ) .
the local orthogonal transformations can act on those enlarged hilbert spaces and can connect to identity in those enlarged hilbert spaces . even when a local orthogonal transformation can not be deformed into identity in the original hilbert space , it can always be deformed into identity continuously in an enlarged hilbert space .
thus two real wave functions related by a local orthogonal transformation always have the same time reversal invariant topological order .
for example , an orthogonal matrix @xmath371 that acts on states @xmath295 and @xmath296 does not connect to identity within the space of two by two orthogonal matrices . however , we can embed the above orthogonal matrix into a three by three orthogonal matrix that acts on @xmath295 , @xmath296 , and @xmath372 : @xmath373 .
such a three by three orthogonal matrix does connect to identity within the space of three by three orthogonal matrices .
this completes our argument that all local orthogonal transformations can connect to identity continuously at least in an enlarged hilbert space .
so , after factoring out the unimportant phase factors discussed above , the real solutions of the fixed - point conditions may uniquely correspond to time reversal invariant topological orders .
the four types of real solutions discussed in the last section are examples of four different time reversal invariant topological orders . for the @xmath294 loop states and the @xmath294 string - net state
, we only have two states on each link . in this case
, we can treat the two states as the two states of an electron spin .
the time reversal transformation now becomes @xmath374 on each link .
for such a time reversal transformation @xmath375 .
the two @xmath294 loop states and the @xmath294 string - net state are not invariant under such an time - reversal transformation .
once the fixed - point states have been identified and the labeling of topological orders has being found , we then face the next important issue : given a generic ground state wave function of a system , how to identify the topological orders in the state ?
in other words , how to calculate the data @xmath376 that characterize the topological orders from a generic wave function ? one way to address the above issue is to have a general renormalization procedure which flows other states in the same phase to the simple fixed - point state so that we can identify topological order from the resulting fixed - point state .
that is , we want to find a local unitary transformation which removes local entanglement and gets rid of unnecessary degrees of freedom from the state . how to find the appropriate unitary transformation for a specific state is then the central problem in this renormalization procedure .
such a procedure for one dimensional tensor product states(tps ) ( also called matrix product states ) has been given in .
here we will propose a method to renormalize two dimensional tps , where nontrivial topological orders emerge .
the basic idea is to use the glu transformation discussed in section [ wvrg ] .
note that , through the glu transformation , we can reduce the number of labels in a region a to the minimal value without loosing any quantum information ( see fig .
[ glut ] ) .
this is because the glu transformation is a lossless projection into the support space of the state in the region a. by performing such glu transformations on _ overlapping _ regions repeatedly ( see fig .
[ qc]a ) , we can reduce a generic wave function to the simple fixed - point form discussed above .
it should be noted that any state reducible in this way can be represented as a mera @xcite . in the following
, we will present this renormalization procedure for two dimensional tps where we find a method to calculate the proper glu transformations .
the tensor product states are many - body entangled quantum states described with local tensors . by making use of the entanglement information contained in the local tensors
, we are able to come up with an efficient algorithm to renormalize two dimensional tps . this algorithm can be very useful in the study of quantum phases .
due to the efficiency in representation , tps has found wide application as variational ansatz states in the studies of quantum many - body systems @xcite .
suppose that in a variational study we have found a set of tensors which describe the ground state of a two dimensional many - body hamiltonian and want to determine the phase this state belongs to .
we can apply our renormalization algorithm to this tensor product state , which removes local entanglement and flows the state to its fixed point . by identifying the kind of order present in the fixed - point state , we can obtain the phase information for the original state . in this section
, we will give a detailed description of the algorithm and in the next section we will present its application to some simple ( but nontrivial ) cases .
the states we are concerned with have translational symmetry and can be described with a translational invariant tensor network . to be specific ,
we discuss states on a hexagonal lattice .
generalization to other regular lattices is straight - forward .
consider a two - dimensional spin model on a hexagonal lattice with one spin ( or one qudit ) living at each vertex .
the hilbert space of each spin is @xmath377-dimensional .
the state can be represented by assigning to every vertex a set of tensors @xmath378 , where @xmath115 labels the local physical dimension and takes value from @xmath43 to @xmath377 .
@xmath379 are inner indices along the three directions in the hexagonal lattice respectively .
the dimension of the inner indices is @xmath380 .
note that the figures in this note are all sideviews with inner indices in the horizontal plane and the physical indices pointing in the vertical direction , if not specified otherwise . representing a 2d quantum state on hexagonal lattice .
@xmath115 is the physical index , @xmath379 are inner indices .
right : a tensor product state where each vertex is associated with a tensor .
the inner indices of the neighboring tensors connect according to the underlying hexagonal lattice.,width=336 ] the wave function is given in terms of these tensors by @xmath381 where @xmath382 denotes tensor contraction of all the connected inner indices on the links of the hexagonal lattice .
a renormalization procedure of quantum states is composed of local unitary transformations and isometry maps such that the state flows along the path @xmath383 , @xmath384 , @xmath385, ... and finally towards a fixed point @xmath386 . with the tensor product representation ,
flow of states corresponds to a flow of tensors @xmath387 , @xmath388 , @xmath389 ... we will give the detailed procedure of how the tensors are mapped from one step to the next in the following section . in one round of renormalization , we start from tensor @xmath390 , do some operation to it which corresponds to local unitary transformations on the state , and map @xmath390 to @xmath391 .
the whole procedure can be broken into two parts : the f - move and the p move , in accordance with the two steps introduced in the previous section . in the f - move ,
we take a @xmath392{f1}\emm$ ] configuration in the tensor network and map it to a @xmath393{f2}\emm$ ] configuration by doing a local unitary operation .
we will see that the tensor product representation of a state leads to a natural way of choosing an appropriate unitary operation for the renormalization of the state . in order to do so
, first we define the double tensor @xmath394 of tensor @xmath395 as @xmath396 graphically the double tensor @xmath394 is represented by two layers of tensor @xmath395 with the physical indices connected .
represented as two layers of tensor @xmath395 with the physical indices contracted .
the gray layer is the lower layer.,width=144 ] the tensor @xmath395 giving rise to the same double tensor @xmath394 is not unique .
any tensor @xmath397 which differs from @xmath395 by an unitary transformation @xmath97 on physical index @xmath115 gives the same @xmath394 as @xmath97 and @xmath398 cancels out in the contraction of @xmath115 . on the other hand ,
an unitary transformation on @xmath115 is the only degree of freedom possible , i.e. any @xmath397 which gives rise to the same @xmath394 as @xmath395 differs from @xmath395 by a unitary on @xmath115 .
therefore , in the process of turning a tensor @xmath395 into a double tensor @xmath394 and then split it again into a different tensor @xmath397 , we apply a non - trivial local unitary operation on the corresponding state .
a well designed way of splitting the double tensor will give us the appropriate unitary transformation we need , as we show below . and
@xmath399 on neighboring sites into a single double tensor @xmath394 ( 2)splitting double tensor @xmath394 into tensor @xmath400 ( 3 ) svd decomposition of tensor @xmath400 into tensors @xmath401 and @xmath402.,width=336 ] f - move has the following steps .
first , construct double tensors for two neighboring sites on the lattice and combine them into a single double tensor with @xmath403 inner indices .
@xmath404 note that with respect to the bipartition of indices @xmath405 and @xmath406 , @xmath394 is hermitian @xmath407 and positive semidefinite .
therefore it has a spectral decomposition with positive eigenvalues @xmath408 .
the corresponding eigenvectors are @xmath409 @xmath410 this spectral decomposition lead to a special way of decomposing double tensor @xmath394 into tensors .
define a rank @xmath403 tensor @xmath400(as shown in fig .
[ fig : f - move ] after step 2 ) as follows : @xmath411 @xmath400 has four inner indices @xmath412 of dimension @xmath380 and four physical indices @xmath413 also of dimension @xmath380 which are in the direction of @xmath412 respectively . as @xmath409 form an orthonormal set , it is easy to check that @xmath400 gives rise to double tensor @xmath394 .
going from @xmath414 and @xmath415 to @xmath400 , we have implemented a local unitary transformation on the physical degrees of freedom on the two sites , so that in @xmath400 the physical indices and the inner indices represent the same configuration . in some sense
, we are keeping only the physical degrees of freedom necessary for entanglement with the rest of the system while getting rid of those that are only entangled within this local region .
now we do a singular value decomposition of tensor @xmath400 in the direction orthogonal to the link between @xmath414 and @xmath415 and @xmath400 is decomposed into tensors @xmath401 and @xmath402 .
@xmath416 this step completes the f - move .
ideally , this step should be done exactly so we are only applying local unitary operations to the state .
numerically , we keep some large but finite cutoff dimension for the svd step , so this step is approximate . on a hexagonal lattice ,
we do f - move on the chosen neighboring pairs of sites ( dash - circled in fig .
[ fig : rg_hex ] ) , so that the tensor network is changed into a configuration shown by thick dark lines in fig .
[ fig : rg_hex ] . physical indices are omitted from this figure .
now by grouping together the three tensors that meet at a triangle , we can map the tensor network back into a hexagonal lattice , with @xmath417 the number of sites in the original lattice .
this is achieved by the p - move introduced in the next section . to form a new tensor @xmath388 on one site of the renormalized hexagonal lattice .
( 2)constructing the double tensor @xmath418 from @xmath388 so that we can start to do f - moves again.,width=336 ] now we contract the three tensors that meet at a triangle together to form a new tensor in the renormalized lattice as shown in the first step in fig .
[ fig : p - move ] @xmath419 where @xmath420 is the physical index of the new tensor which includes all the physical indices of @xmath421 : @xmath422 .
note that in the contraction , only inner indices are contracted and the physical indices are simply group together .
constructing the double tensor @xmath394 from @xmath395 , we get the renormalized double tensor on the new hexagonal lattice which is in the same form as @xmath423,@xmath399 and we can go back again and do the f - move .
one problem with the above renormalization algorithm is that , instead of having one isolated fixed - point tensor for each phase , the algorithm has a continuous family of fixed points which all correspond to the same phase .
consider a tensor with structure shown in fig .
[ fig : cdl ] . are entangled within each group but not between the groups.,width=115 ] the tensor is a tensor product of three parts which include indices @xmath424 respectively .
it can be shown that this structure remains invariant under the renormalization flow .
therefore , any tensor of this structure is a fixed point of our renormalization flow .
however , it is easy to see that the state it represents is a tensor product of loops around each plaquette , which can be disentangled locally into a trivial product state
. therefore , the states all have only short - range entanglement and correspond to the topologically trivial phase .
the trivial phase has then a continuous family of fixed - point tensors .
this situation is very similar to that discussed in .
we will keep the terminology and call such a tensor a corner double line tensor .
not only does corner double line tensor complicate the situation in the trivial phase , it leads to a continuous family of fixed points in every phase .
it can be checked that the tensor product of a corner double line with any other fixed - point tensor is still a fixed - point tensor .
the states they correspond to differ only by small loops around each plaquette and represent the same topological order .
therefore any single fixed - point tensor gets complicated into a continuous class of fixed - point tensors . in practical application of the renormalization algorithm , in order to identify the topological order of the fixed - point tensor , we need to get rid of such corner double line structures . due to their simple structure , this
can always be done , as discussed in the next section .
now we present some examples where our algorithm is used to determine the phase of a tensor product state .
the algorithm can be applied both to symmetry breaking phases and topological ordered phases . in the study of symmetry breaking / topological ordered phases , suppose that we have obtained some tensor product description of the ground state of the system hamiltonian .
we can then apply our algorithm to the tensors , flow them to the fixed point , and see whether they represent a state in the symmetry breaking phase / topological ordered phase or a trivial phase . for system with symmetry / topological order related to gauge symmetry
, it is very important to keep the symmetry / gauge symmetry in the variational approach to ground state and search within the set of tensors that have this symmetry / gauge symmetry@xcite .
the resulting tensor will be invariant under such symmetries / gauge symmetries , but the state they correspond to may have different orders . in the symmetry breaking case , the state could have this symmetry or could spontaneous break it . in the topological ordered phase , the state could have nontrivial topological order or be just trivial .
our algorithm can then be applied to decide which is the case . in order to correctly determine the phase for such symmetric tensors
, it is crucial that we maintain the symmetry / gauge symmetry of the tensor throughout our renormalization process .
we will discuss in detail two cases : the ising symmetry breaking phase and the @xmath2 topological ordered phase .
for simplicity of discussion and to demonstrate the generality of our renormalization scheme , we will first introduce the square lattice version of the algorithm .
all subsequent applications are carried out on square lattice .
( algorithm on a hexagonal lattice would give qualitatively similar result , though quantitatively they might differ , e.g. on the position of critical point . ) tensor product states on a square lattice are represented with one tensor @xmath425 on each vertex , where @xmath115 is the physical index and @xmath426 are the four inner indices in the up , down , left , right direction respectively .
we will assume translational invariance and require the tensor to be the same on every vertex .
the renormalization procedure is be a local unitary transformation on the state which flows the form of the tensor until it reaches the fixed point .
it is implemented in the following steps .
first , we form the double tensor @xmath394 from tensor @xmath395 @xmath427 into tensor @xmath428 ( 2 ) svd decomposition of @xmath428 in two different directions , resulting in tensors @xmath401 , @xmath402 and @xmath0 , @xmath429 respectively.,width=240 ] then do the spectral decomposition of positive operator @xmath394 into @xmath430 and form a new tensor @xmath431 @xmath432 @xmath85,@xmath152,@xmath433,@xmath434 are physical indices in the up , down , left , right directions respectively .
this is illustrated in step 1 of fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_1 ] .
this step is very similar to the second step in the f - move on hexagonal lattice .
next we do svd decomposition of tensor @xmath428 . for vertices in sublattice @xmath98
we decompose between the up - right and down - left direction as shown in step 2 of fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_1 ] . for vertices in sublattice @xmath21 we decompose between the up - left and down - right direction as shown in step 3 of fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_1 ] . @xmath435 has been applied .
physical indices of the tensors are not drawn here.,width=115 ] after the decomposition , the original lattice ( gray lines in fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_2 ] ) is transformed into the configuration shown by thick dark lines in fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_2 ] . physical indices are omitted from this figure .
if we now shrink the small squares , we get a tensor product state on a renormalized square lattice . fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_3 ] shows how this is done . in step 1 , we contract the four tensors that meet at a small square @xmath436 where @xmath420 stands for the combination of all physical indices @xmath437 , @xmath438 . in step 2 ,
we construct a double tensor @xmath394 form tensor @xmath395 and completes one round of renormalization .
now we can go back to step 1 in fig .
[ fig : rg_sq_1 ] and flow the tensor further .
now we are ready to discuss two particular examples , the ising symmetry breaking phase and the @xmath2 topological ordered phase , to demonstrate how our algorithm can be used to determine the phase of a tensor product state .
a typical example for symmetry breaking phase transition is the transverse field ising model .
consider a square lattice with one spin @xmath439 on each site .
the transverse field ising model is @xmath440 where @xmath441 are nearest neighbor sites .
the hamiltonian is invariant under spin flip transformation @xmath442 for any @xmath443 .
when @xmath444 , the ground state spontaneously breaks this symmetry into either the all spin up state @xmath445 or the all spin down state @xmath446 . in this case any global superposition @xmath447 , the ground state has all spin polarized in the @xmath448 direction ( @xmath449 ) and does not break this symmetry . in the variational study of this system
, we can require that the variational ground state always have this symmetry , regardless if the system is in the symmetry breaking phase or not .
then we will find for @xmath444 the ground state to be @xmath450 .
such a global superposition represents the spontaneous symmetry breaking . for @xmath451
, we will find the ground state to be @xmath449 and does not break the symmetry . for @xmath452 , we will need to decide which of the previous two cases it belongs to .
we can first find a tensor product representation of an approximate ground state which is symmetric under the spin flip transformation , then apply the renormalization algorithm to find the fixed point and decide which phase the state belongs to .
below we will assume a simple form of tensor and demonstrate how the algorithm works .
suppose that the tensors obtained from the variational study @xmath425 , where @xmath115,@xmath453,@xmath454,@xmath455,@xmath456 can be @xmath78 or @xmath43 , takes the following form @xmath457 @xmath458 is a parameter between @xmath78 and @xmath43 . under an @xmath448 operation to the physical index , the tensor is changed to @xmath400 @xmath459 @xmath400 can be mapped back to @xmath395 by switching the @xmath78,@xmath43 label for the four inner indices @xmath426 .
such a change of basis for the inner indices does not change the contraction result of the tensor and hence the state that is represented .
therefore , the state is invariant under the spin flip transformation @xmath460 and we will say that the tensor has this symmetry also . when @xmath461 , the tensor represents state @xmath450 , which corresponds to the spontaneous symmetry breaking phase .
we note that the @xmath461 tensor is a direct sum of dimension-1 tensors .
such a direct - sum structure corresponds to spontaneous symmetry breaking , as discussed in detail in . when @xmath462 , the tensor represents state @xmath449 which corresponds to the symmetric phase . when @xmath463 , there must be a phase transition between the two phases
however , as @xmath458 goes from @xmath78 to @xmath43 , the tensor varies smoothly with well defined symmetry .
it is hard to identify the phase transition point .
now we can apply our algorithm to the tensor .
first , we notice that at @xmath461 or @xmath43 , the tensor is a fixed point for our algorithm .
next , we find that for @xmath464 , the tensor flows to the form with @xmath461 , while for @xmath465 , it flows to the form with @xmath462 .
therefore , we can clearly identify the phase a state belongs to using this algorithm and find the phase transition point .
note that in our algorithm , we explicitly keep the spin flip symmetry in the tensor .
that is , after each renormalization step , we make sure that the renormalized tensor is invariant under spin flip operations up to change of basis for the inner indices
. if the symmetry is not carefully preserved , we will not be able to tell the two phases apart .
obtained by taking the ratio of the contraction value of the double tensor in two different ways .
@xmath466 is invariant under change of scale , basis transformation and corner double line structures of the double tensor and can be used to distinguish different fixed point tensors . for clarity , only one layer of the double tensor is shown .
the other layer connects in exactly the same way.,width=240 ] we also need to mention that for arbitrary @xmath458 , the fixed point that the tensor flows to can be different from the tensor at @xmath461 or @xmath43 by a corner double line structure .
we need to get rid of the corner double line structure in the result to identify the real fixed point .
this is possible by carefully examining the fixed point structure .
another way to distinguish the different fixed points without worrying about corner double lines is to calculate some quantities from the fixed - point tensors that are invariant with the addition of corner double lines .
we also want the quantity to be invariant under some trivial changes to the fixed point , such as a change in scale @xmath467 or the change of basis for physical and inner indices .
one such quantity is given by the ratio of @xmath468 and @xmath469 defined as @xmath470 , and @xmath471 .
[ fig : x2x1 ] gives a graphical representation of these two quantities . in this figure
, only one layer of the double tensor is shown .
the other layer connects in the exactly the same way .
it is easy to verify that @xmath466 is invariant under the change of scale , basis transformation and corner double lines . for tensors under the renormalization flow .
as the number of rg steps increases , the transition in @xmath466 becomes sharper and finally approaches a step function at fixed point .
the critical point is at @xmath472.,width=355 ] we calculate @xmath466 along the renormalization flow .
the result is shown in fig .
[ fig : x1_ising ] . at the @xmath461 fixed point ,
@xmath473 while at @xmath462 , @xmath474 .
as we increase the number of renormalization steps , the transition between the two fixed points becomes sharper and finally approaches a step function with critical point at @xmath472 .
tensors with @xmath475 belongs to the symmetry breaking phase while tensors with @xmath476 belongs to the symmetric phase .
the algorithm can also be used to study topological order of quantum states . in this section , we will demonstrate how the algorithm works with @xmath2 topological order .
consider again a square lattice but now with one spin @xmath439 per each link .
a simple hamiltonian on this lattice with @xmath2 topological order can be defined as @xmath477 where @xmath213 means plaquettes and @xmath478 is all the spin @xmath439s around the plaquette and @xmath479 means vertices and @xmath480 is all the spin @xmath439s connected to the vertex .
the ground state wave function of this hamiltonian is a fixed - point wave function and corresponds to the @xmath294 loop state with @xmath320 as discussed in the previous section .
the ground state wave function has a simple tensor product representation .
for simplicity of discussion we split every spin @xmath439 into two and associate every vertex with four spins .
the tensor @xmath481 has four physical indices @xmath482 and three inner indices @xmath483 .
@xmath484 it can be checked that @xmath485 is a fixed - point tensor of our algorithm .
this tensor has a @xmath2 gauge symmetry .
if we apply @xmath486 operation to all the inner indices , where @xmath486 maps @xmath78 to @xmath78 and @xmath43 to @xmath370 , the tensor remains invariant as only even configurations of the inner indices are nonzero in the tensor .
consider then the following set of tensor parameterized by @xmath31 @xmath487 at @xmath488 , this is exactly @xmath485 and the corresponding state has topological order . at @xmath42 ,
the tensor represents a product state of all @xmath78 and we denote the tensor as @xmath489 . at some critical point in @xmath31 , the state must go through a phase transition .
this set of tensors are all invariant under gauge transformation @xmath490 on their inner indices and the tensor seems to vary smoothly with @xmath31 .
one way to detect the phase transition is to apply our algorithm .
we find that , at @xmath491 , the tensors flow to @xmath485 , while at @xmath492 , the tensors flow to @xmath489 .
we determine @xmath35 to be between @xmath493 . as this model
is mathematically equivalent to two dimensional classical ising model where the transition point is known to great accuracy , we compare our result to that result and find our result to be within @xmath494 accuracy ( @xmath495 ) . again in the renormalization algorithm , we need to carefully preserve the @xmath2 gauge symmetry of the tensor so that we can correctly determine the phase of the states .
the fixed - point tensor structure might also be complicated by corner double line structures , but it is always possible to identify and get rid of them .
similarly , we can calculate the invariance quantity @xmath466 to distinguish the two fixed points .
@xmath474 for @xmath485 while @xmath473 for @xmath489 .
the result is plotted in fig .
[ fig : x1_z2 ] and we can see that the transition in @xmath466 approaches a step function after a large number of steps of rg , i.e. at the fixed point .
the critical point is at @xmath496 . for @xmath492
, the tensor belongs to the trivial phase , while for @xmath491 , the tensor belongs to the @xmath2 topological ordered phase . for tensors under the renormalization flow .
as the number of rg steps increases , the transition in @xmath466 becomes sharper and finally approaches a step function at fixed point .
the critical point is at @xmath496.,width=355 ] our algorithm can also be used to demonstrate the stability of topological order against local perturbation . as is shown in ref .
, local perturbations to the @xmath2 hamiltonian correspond to variations in tensor that do not break the @xmath2 gauge symmetry .
we picked tensors in the neighborhood of @xmath485 which preserve this gauge symmetry randomly and applied our renormalization algorithm ( gauge symmetry is kept throughout the renormalization process ) .
we find that as long as the variation is small enough , the tensor flows back to @xmath485 , up to a corner double line structure .
this result shows that the @xmath2 topological ordered phase is stable against local perturbations .
in this paper , we discuss a defining relation between local unitary transformation and quantum phases .
we argue that two gapped states are related by a local unitary transformation if and only if the two states belong to the same quantum phase .
we can use the equivalent classes of local unitary transformations to define `` patterns of long range entanglement '' .
so the patterns of long range entanglement correspond to universality classes of quantum phases , and are the essence of topological orders.@xcite as an application of this point of view of quantum phases and topological order , we use the generalized local unitary transformations to generate a wave function renormalization , where the wave functions flow within the same universality class of a quantum phase ( or the same equivalent class of the local unitary transformations ) .
in other words , the renormalization flow of a wave function does not change its topological order .
such a wave function renormalization allows us to classify topological orders , by classifying the fixed - point wave functions and the associated fixed - point local unitary transformations .
first , we find that the fixed - point local unitary transformations are described by the data @xmath497 that satisfy @xmath498 @xmath499 @xmath500 [ see eqns .
( [ nnnn ] , [ di ] , [ nnstar ] [ 2ffstar ] , [ 1fstarf ] , [ penid ] , [ pffp ] , [ pfp ] ) ] . from the data
@xmath501 we can further find out the fixed - point wave function by solving the following equations for @xmath502 : @xmath503 [ see eqns .
( [ anonz ] , [ aiaistar ] , [ papa ] , [ phipa ] , [ phiikj ] , [ phinonz ] ) ] . the combined data @xmath504 that satisfy the conditions , , and classify a large class of topological orders .
we see that the problem of classifying a large class of topological orders becomes the problem of solving a set of non - linear algebraic equations , , , and . the combined data @xmath504 that satisfy the conditions , , , and also classify a large class of time reversal invariant topological orders , if we restrict ourselves to real solutions .
the solutions related by local orthogonal transformations all belong to the same phase , since the local orthogonal transformations always connect to identity if we enlarge the hilbert space .
we like to point out that we can not claim that the solutions @xmath505 classify all topological orders since we have assumed that the fixed - point local unitary transformations are described by tensors of finite dimensions .
it appears that chiral topological orders , such as quantum hall states , are described by tensors of infinite dimensions .
we note that the data @xmath504 just characterize different fixed - point wave functions .
it is not guaranteed that the different data will represent different topological orders . however , for the simple solutions discussed in this paper , they all coincide with string - net states , where the topological properties , such as the ground state degeneracy , number of quasiparticle types , the quasiparticle statistics _ etc _ , were calculated from the data . from those topological properties , we know that those different simple solutions represent different topological orders .
also @xmath506 are real for the simple solutions discussed here .
thus they also represent topological orders with time reversal symmetry .
( certainly , at the same time , they represent stable topological orders even without time reversal symmetry . )
we also like to point out that our description of fixed - point local unitary transformations is very similar to the description of string - net states . however , the conditions , , , and on the data appear to be weaker than ( or equivalent to ) those@xcite on the string - net data .
so the fixed - point wave functions discussed in this paper may include all the string - net states ( in 2d ) .
last , we present a wave function renormalization scheme , based on the glu transformations for generic tps .
such a wave function renormalization always flows within the same phase ( or within the same equivalence class of lu transformations ) .
it allows us to determine which phase a generic tps belongs to by studying the resulting fixed - point wave functions .
we demonstrated the effectiveness of our method for both symmetry breaking phases and topological ordered phases .
we find that we can even use tensors that do not break symmetry to describe spontaneous symmetry breaking states : if a state described by a symmetric tensor has a spontaneous symmetry breaking , the symmetric tensor will flow to a fixed - point tensor that has a form of direct sum .
we would like to thank i. chuang , m. hastings , m. levin , f. verstraete , z .- h . wang , y .- s .
wu , s. bravyi for some very helpful discussions .
xgw is supported by nsf grant no .
zcg is supported in part by the nsf grant no .
nsfphy05 - 51164 .
in section [ qphucl ] and section [ tolren ] , we argued about the equivalence relation between gapped quantum ground states in the same phase .
we concluded that two states are in the same phase if and only if they can be connected by local unitary evolution or constant depth quantum circuit : @xmath507 |\phi(0)\>\\ |\phi(1)\ > \sim |\phi(0)\ > & \text{\ iff\ } & |\phi(1)\ > = u^m_{circ } |\phi(0)\>\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we want to make these arguments more rigorous , by stating clearly what is proved and what is conjectured , and by giving precise definition of two states being the same , the locality of operators , etc .
we will show the equivalence in the following steps : ( all these discussions can be generalized to the case where the system has certain symmetries . @xmath51 and @xmath508 used in the equivalence relation
will then have the same symmetry as the system hamiltonian @xmath62 . )
first , according to the definition in section [ qphucl ] , two states @xmath36 and @xmath38 are in the same phase if we can find a family of local hamiltonians @xmath32 , @xmath509 $ ] with @xmath41 being its ground state such that the ground state average of any local operator @xmath33 , @xmath510 changes smoothly from @xmath42 to @xmath488 . here
we allow a more general notion of locality for the hamiltonian @xcite and require @xmath32 to be a sum of local operators @xmath511 : @xmath512 where @xmath511 is a hermitian operator defined on a compact region @xmath486 . @xmath513
sums over a set @xmath514 of regions .
the set @xmath514 contains regions that differ by translations .
the set @xmath514 also contains regions with different sizes .
however , @xmath511 approaches zero exponentially as the size of the region @xmath486 approaches infinity . or more precisely , for all sites @xmath515 in the lattice @xmath516 for some positive constant @xmath517 . here
sums over all regions in the set @xmath514 that cover the site @xmath515 , @xmath519 denotes operator norm , @xmath520 is the cardinality of @xmath486 , and @xmath521 is the diameter of @xmath486 .
therefore , instead of being exactly zero outside of a finite region , the interaction terms can have an exponentially decaying tail .
if @xmath36 and @xmath38 are gapped ground states of @xmath37 and @xmath39 , then we assume that for all @xmath510 to be smooth , @xmath32 must remain gapped for all @xmath31 .
if @xmath32 closes gap for some @xmath35 , then there must exist a local operator @xmath33 such that @xmath510 has a singularity at @xmath35 .
we call the gapped @xmath32 an adiabatic connection between two states in the same phase .
let @xmath32 be a differentiable family of local hamiltonians and @xmath41 be its ground state .
if the excitation gap above @xmath41 is larger than some finite value @xmath522 for all @xmath31 , then we can define @xmath523 , such that @xmath524 |\phi(0)\>$ ] . where @xmath525 is a function which has the following properties : 1 .
the fourier transform of @xmath525 , @xmath526 is equal to @xmath527 for @xmath528 .
@xmath529 is infinitely differentiable .
3 . @xmath530 . under this definition , @xmath51 is local ( almost ) and satisfies @xmath531 \right \| \leq h'(\text{dist}(z , b ) ) \left | z
\right \vert \left \vert \t h_z(g ) \right \| \left \vert o_b \right \| \label{local_th}\ ] ] where @xmath532 is any operator supported on site @xmath21 , @xmath533 is the smallest distance between @xmath21 and any site in @xmath486 , and @xmath534 is a function which decays faster than any negative power of @xmath85 . @xmath535 $ ] denotes commutator of two operators .
this is called the quasi - adiabatic continuation of states .
therefore , we can show that if @xmath36 and @xmath38 are in the same phase , then we can find a local ( as defined in ) hamiltonian @xmath536 such that @xmath524 |\phi(0)\>$ ] .
in other words , states in the same phase are equivalent under local unitary evolution .
note that here we map @xmath36 exactly to @xmath38 .
there is another version of quasi - adiabatic continuation @xcite , where the mapping is approximate . in that case
, @xmath536 can be defined to have only exponentially small tail outside of a finite region instead of a tail which decays faster than any negative power .
@xmath537 |\phi(0)\>$ ] will not be exactly the same as @xmath38 , but any local measurement on them will give approximately the same result .
next we want to show that the reverse is also true .
suppose that @xmath36 is the gapped ground state of a local hamiltonian @xmath37 , @xmath538 and each @xmath539 is supported on a finite region @xmath486 .
apply a local unitary evolution generated by @xmath540 to @xmath36 and take it to @xmath41 , @xmath541 , @xmath542 , where @xmath543 $ ] .
@xmath41 is then ground state of @xmath544 . under unitary transformation
@xmath545 the spectrum of @xmath37 does nt change , therefore @xmath32 remains gapped . to show that @xmath32 also remains local , we use
the lieb - robinson bound derived in , which gives @xmath546 \right \| & = & \left \vert \left[u_gh_z(0)u_g^{\dagger } , o_b\right ] \right \|\\ & \leq & h(\text{dist}(z , b ) ) \left |z\right \vert \left \vert h_z(0 ) \right \|
\left \vert o_b \right \|\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath547 decays faster than any negative power of @xmath85 . therefore , @xmath511 remains local up to a tail which decays faster than any negative power .
@xmath32 then forms a local gapped adiabatic connection between @xmath36 and @xmath38 . to detect for phase transition , we must check whether the ground state average value of any local operator @xmath33 , @xmath510 , has a singularity or not . @xmath548 . using the lieb - robinson bound given in , we find @xmath549 remains local ( in the sense of ) and evolves smoothly with @xmath31 . therefore , @xmath510 changes smoothly . in fact
, because @xmath32 is differentiable , the derivative of @xmath510 to any order always exists .
therefore , there is no singularity in the ground state average value of any local operator @xmath33 and @xmath36 and @xmath38 are in the same phase .
we have hence shown that states connected with local unitary evolution are in the same phase .
this completes the equivalence relation stated in .
the definition of locality is slightly different in different cases , so there is still some gap in the equivalence relation .
however , we believe that the equivalence relation should be valid with a slight generalization of the definition of locality .
lastly , we want to show that the equivalence relation is still valid if we use constant depth quantum circuit instead of local unitary evolution .
this is true because we can always simulate a local unitary evolution using a constant depth quantum circuit and vice - verse . to simulate a local unitary evolution of the form @xmath537 $ ] , first divide the total time into small segments @xmath550 such that @xmath551 \simeq e^{-i\delta t h(m\delta t)}$ ] .
the set of local operators @xmath553 can always be divided into a finite number of subsets @xmath554 , @xmath555 ... such that elements in the same subset commute with each other .
then we can do trotter expansion and approximate @xmath556 as @xmath557 , where @xmath558 , @xmath559 ... each term in @xmath560 , @xmath561 commute , therefore they can be implement as a piece - wise local unitary operator . putting these piece - wise local unitary operators together
, we have a quantum circuit which simulates the local unitary evolution .
the depth of circuit is proportional to @xmath562 .
it can be shown that to achieve a simulation with constant error , a constant depth circuit would suffice@xcite . on the other hand , to simulate a constant depth quantum circuit @xmath563 , where @xmath564 with a local unitary evolution
, we can define the time dependent hamiltonian as @xmath565 , such that for @xmath566 , @xmath567 .
it is easy to check that @xmath568=u_{circ}$ ] .
the simulation time needed is @xmath569 .
we can always choose a finite @xmath550 such that @xmath570 is finite and the evolution time is finite . | two gapped quantum ground states in the same phase are connected by an adiabatic evolution which gives rise to a local unitary transformation that maps between the states . on the other hand ,
gapped ground states remain within the same phase under local unitary transformations .
therefore , local unitary transformations define an equivalence relation and the equivalence classes are the universality classes that define the different phases for gapped quantum systems .
since local unitary transformations can remove local entanglement , the above equivalence / universality classes correspond to pattern of long range entanglement , which is the essence of topological order .
the local unitary transformation also allows us to define a wave function renormalization scheme , under which a wave function can flow to a simpler one within the same equivalence / universality class . using such a setup , we find conditions on the possible fixed - point wave functions where the local unitary transformations have _ finite _ dimensions .
the solutions of the conditions allow us to classify this type of topological orders , which generalize the string - net classification of topological orders .
we also describe an algorithm of wave function renormalization induced by local unitary transformations .
the algorithm allows us to calculate the flow of tensor - product wave functions which are not at the fixed points .
this will allow us to calculate topological orders as well as symmetry breaking orders in a generic tensor - product state . |
all known normal nuclei are made of the two nucleons , the proton and the neutron .
besides those two lightest baryons there exist still a couple of other stable ( but weakly decaying ) baryons , the hyperons . up to now the inclusion of multiple units of strangeness in nuclei
remains experimentally as theoretically rather largely unexplored .
this lack of investigation reflects the experimental task in producing nuclei containing ( weakly decaying ) strange baryons , which is conventionally limited by replacing one neutron ( or at maximum two ) by a strange @xmath0-particle in scattering experiments with pions or kaons .
there exists nowadays a broad knowledge about single hypernuclei , i.e. nuclei , where one nucleon is substituted by a @xmath1 ( or @xmath2 ) by means of the exchange reaction @xmath3 . over the last two decades
a rich phenomology has resulted for such hypernuclei . however , there exist more or less no experimental insight how more than one hyperon behave inside a nuclei .
the technical problem is to create within a tiny moment , smaller than the decay time of a hyperon , enough hyperons and then to bring them together with nucleons to form any potential multihypernucleus . by employing a relativistic shell model calculation , which gives a rather excellent description of normal nuclei and single @xmath1-hypernuclei
, it was found that such configurations might exist as ( small ) bound multihypernuclei ( memo - metastable exotic multihypernuclear object ) @xcite .
strange matter could also be realized in a completely different picture .
indeed , this second and much more speculative possibility was raised by physicists much earlier .
the fundamental theory of strong interactions , quantum chromodynamics , does not forbid the principle existence of ` larger ' hadronic particles , so called multiquark states .
today only the mesons and baryons are known in nature .
however , there could exist states with more than three quarks .
going further with this speculation one comes to the conclusion that only multiquark states with nearly the same number of up , down and strange quarks might exist as ( meta-)stable configurations @xcite .
such a very speculative form of strange matter is called strange quark matter .
( ultra-)relativistic heavy ion collisions provide the only ( earth based ) source for the formation of either strangelets ( small lumps of strange quark matter ) or multi - hypernuclear objects , consisting of nucleons , @xmath1 s and @xmath4 s , as dozens of hyperons are produced in a single central event . in principle
, strangelets can be produced via two different scenarios : by a condensation out of a quark - gluon plasma or by a coalescence of hyperons out of the created hot and dense fireball .
for the former scenario it is essential that within the phase transition of the deconfined matter to hadronic particles the _ net _ strangeness ( counting a surplus of strange over antistrange quarks ) is getting enriched in the plasma phase .
this distillation ( or separation ) of strangeness , i.e. the possible conglomeration of net strangeness , has been predicted to occur for a first order phase transition of a baryonrich qgp @xcite . in particular , if the strangelet does exist in principle , it has to be regarded as a cold , stable and bound manifestation of that phase being a remnant or ` ash ' of the originally hot qgp - state . on the other hand a further necessary request for the possible condensation
is that the initially hot plasma phase has to cool down considerably during the ongoing phase transition . within our present knowledge of the phase transition such a behaviour
can neither be unambiqously shown to happen nor be excluded . in section 2
we briefly summarize the reasons for the ( possible ) existence of this novel and exotic states . in section 3
the mechanism of strangeness distillation and the possible production of small strange matter states are reviewed .
we conclude this section by discussing the detection possibilities of small and finite strangelets with respect to their lifetimes against strong or weak hadronic decays . in section 4
we finally sketch on how the physics of strange matter can affect the physical picture of dense neutron stars and the issue of baryonic dark matter .
the first speculation about the possible existence of collapsed nuclei was given by bodmer @xcite .
he argued that another form of baryonic matter might be more stable than ordinary nuclei .
indeed it was speculated there both on the possible existence of hyperonic matter with baryons as colorless constituents or strange quark matter with quarks as major constituents .
the paper , however , lacked detailed calculation as the mit bag model or walecka model were only available a few years later .
let us now briefly summarize how a stable or metastable strangelet might look like @xcite : think of bulk objects , containing a large number of quarks @xmath5 , so - called multiquark droplets .
multiquark states consisting only of u- and d - quarks must have a mass larger than ordinary nuclei , otherwise normal nuclei would be unstable .
however , the situation is different for droplets of sqm , which would contain approximately the same amount of u- , d- and s - quarks .
speculations on the stability of strangelets are based on the following observations : ( 1 ) the ( weak ) decay of a s - quark into a d - quark could be suppressed or forbidden because the lowest single particle states are occupied .
( 2 ) the strange quark mass can be lower than the fermi energy of the u- or d - quark in such a dense quark droplet .
opening a new flavour degree of freedom therefore tends to lower the fermi energy and hence also the mass per baryon of the strangelet .
sqm may then appear as a nearly neutral state
. if the mass of a strangelet is smaller than the mass of the corresponding ordinary nucleus with the same baryon number , the strangelet would be absolutely stable and thus be the true groundstate of nuclear matter @xcite . within the mit bag model very low phenomenological bag parameters @xmath6
mev have to be employed for modeling such a possibility . on the other hand
, it is also conceivable that the mass per baryon of a strange droplet is lower than the mass of the strange @xmath1- baryon , but larger than the nucleon mass ( see fig .
the droplet is then in a metastable state , it can not decay spontanously into @xmath1 s . for bag parameters
b@xmath7 lower than 190 mev strange quark droplets can only decay via weak interactions . for larger b - values strangelets
are instable .
due to the strong finite size effects @xcite and the wider range of the employed model parameters , smaller strangelets are much more likely to be metastable than being absolutely stable .
also the possible influence of color magnetic and color electric potentials has been necglected in these calculations due to their complicated group structure . for very light strangelets with
baryon number @xmath8 it turns out @xcite that such contributions are in fact repulsive , making the possible candidates less stable ( with the well - known exception of the h dibaryon ) .
a classification scheme for metastable combinations of nucleons and hyperons exhibits that combinations of nucleons , @xmath0 s and @xmath9 s are favoured compared to combinations with @xmath10 s due to their q - values in vacuum @xcite .
an example is shown in fig .
2 , where the single particle levels of a strange nucleus consisting of two of each proton , neutron , @xmath0 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 are plotted . note that each baryon sits in the 1s - state .
the reaction @xmath13 can not induce a strong decay because the two @xmath0 s sitting in the 1s - level cause the produced @xmath0 s to escape in vacuum .
but this is energetically unfavoured resulting in an overall metastable compound system .
the calculation was carried out in a relativistic mean field model taking care of the nucleon - nucleon and nucleon - hyperon interaction .
an extension of this model also implements the scarce information about the hyperon - hyperon interaction .
this is done by introducing two new meson fields into the theory , @xmath14 and @xmath15 , which couple to strange baryons only @xcite .
the binding energy for memos will be moderately enhanced ( on a scale of nuclear binding energies ) due to this additional interactions .
indeed , binding energies of @xmath16 mev and more have been found with a net strangeness fraction of @xmath17 .
even negatively charged strange nuclear systems are possible without loosing stability .
the lightest stable object of this type is likely to be @xmath18 .
the global properties of a strangelet or a memo are likely to be identical : a similar small charge @xmath19 and nearly the same average baryon density @xmath20 . in turn
, this would suggest that a nearly neutral and heavy candiate could not unambiguosly be considered as a strangelet . in principle , to distinguish experimentally between both one has in addition to resolve the mass @xmath21 very accurately .
a memo is only bound in the order of @xmath22 mev whereas the strangelet may be bound from @xmath23 mev ( which is , of course , speculation ) .
the resembling microscopic structure gives raise to the speculation that both states might have a strong overlap and correlation .
the memo would decay into a strangelet , if the latter is energetically more favourable .
multiple collisions in the reaction of two bombarding nuclei ensure that the interacting system starts to equilibrate which might be suited to search for the most interesting collective effects .
in particular all exotic objects need for their formation _ large strange particle numbers , high degree of equilibration _ and _ large densities . _ in order to get this kind of states one should therefore use high energies to produce enough strangeness and energy density , and heavy nuclei to gain as much equilibration as possible .
this situation is now achieved at brookhaven ags using au+au and at cern sps using pb+pb .
it may then be possible to produce some of the lightest multistrange objects in the laboratory . in the following we want to sketch why the production of sqm clusters , if they do exist in principle , is likely , if a baryon rich and hot deconfined qgp is created in such collisions .
the net strangeness of the qgp is zero from the onset , although an equal , however large , number of strange and antistrange quarks has been produced .
however , there is a physical mechanism which separates the strange quarks from their antiparticles @xcite ( see fig .
it is ` simple ' for the antistrange quarks to materialize in kaons k(@xmath24 ) because of the lots of light quarks as compared to the s - quarks which could only move into the suppressed antikaons ( @xmath25 ) or the heavy hyperons .
hence , during a near equilibrium phase transition a large antistrangeness builds up in the hadron matter while the qgp retains a large net strangeness excess . for modeling the evolution of an initially hot fireball a two phase equilibrium description between the hadron gas and the qgp
was combined with nonequilibrium radiation by incorporating the rapid freeze - out of hadrons from the hadron phase surrounding the qgp droplet during a first order phase transition ( last reference of @xcite ) .
two scenarios may describe the evolution to the final state : the quark droplet may remain unstable until the strange quarks have clustered into @xmath1-particles and other strange hadrons to carry away the strangeness and the plasma has completely vanished into standard particles . this scenario is customarily accepted
. however , if sqm exists at low temperatures in configurations having a mass per baryon lower than the mass of the @xmath1-particle , the hot sqm droplet would remain at the phase transition boundary much longer . as shown in @xcite , producing strange baryons like @xmath0 particles is energetically more expensive and therefore less likely than producing sqm like strangelets . towards the end of the evolution
only baryons are allowed to escape from the droplet , since at this point all of the antiquarks are gone .
the baryons will be mostly nucleons , since the hyperons are heavier and require more energy for formation .
these nucleons remove energy but they do not carry away any strange quarks , so the ratio of strange to nonstrange quarks increases further , refining the distillation of strangeness .
the hot strange matter in fact might cool down to cold lumps of size @xmath26 , depending on the original baryon content of the plasma .
3b gives an impression how the hadronisation proceeds for a large bag constant ( @xmath27 mev no strangelet in the groundstate ) and a small bag constant ( @xmath28 mev ) .
for the large bag constant the system hadronizes completely in @xmath29 8 @xmath30 , which is customarily expected and thus not too surprising . yet , a strong increase of the net strangeness of the system is found in both situations , and the plasma drop reaches a strangeness fraction of @xmath31 when the volume becomes small .
indeed , for the small bag constant , however , a _ cold _ strangelet emerges from the expansion and evaporation process with an approximate baryon number of @xmath32 17 , a radius of @xmath33 , and a net strangeness fraction of @xmath34 , i.e. a charge to baryon ratio @xmath35 !
if a baryon rich qgp is temporarily created it will assemble the strange quarks during the ongoing evolution and expansion .
it might either lead to the formation of a strangelet , or it will decay mainly into hyperons in its late stage . the strangelet would be a remnant or ` ash ' of the deconfined quark matter phase and thus would provide a signal for the formation of a qgp @xcite .
as emphasized already in the introduction , for the possible condensation of small pieces of strange quark matter out of an initially hot qgp with no net strangeness two mechanisms have to be realized by nature : ( 1 ) strangeness distillation and ( 2 ) ongoing cooling ( e.g. by pion evaporation ) during the phase transition resulting in a loss of internal heat .
the strangeness distillation during the hadronization of a baryonrich qgp is a very intuitive process .
it works for all model parameters like e.g. also much higher bag constants @xcite . in a recent study
the above described model including particle evaporation from the outer surface has been combined within 1-dimensional longitudinal hydrodynamical expansion @xcite with initial conditions expected at cern - sps energies and future rhic energies .
again , a strong accumulation of net strangeness in the plasma phase has been found during the ongoing phase transition . still , the mechanism by which a qgp state is converted into hadrons is a major uncertainty in the different descriptions
. the hadronisation transition has often been described by geometric and statistical models , where the matter is assumed to be in partial or complete equilibrium during the whole expansion phase .
a fully microscopic and numerical model of the hadronization of confined and color - neutral hadrons out of a deconfined plasma has very recently been realized within the friedberg - lee model by traxler et al .
exploratory studies of a baryonrich system within this model have shown in fact that the strangeness distillation is a genuine feature of the hadronisation .
it might , however , be very difficult to experimentally verify that this distillation indeed happens during the transition .
we remark that the separation mechanism might be probed by density interferometry with hyperons or kaons @xcite . the hadrons with negative strangeness , the @xmath1 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 ,
are expected to be produced mainly at the last stage of the phase transition when the size of the quark phase volume has become quite small .
the realization of the second mechanism by nature , i.e. the necessary ongoing cooling for final possible strangelet condensation , is not as obvious .
it was pointed out already in the second ref . of @xcite
that the strangelet formation can only go hand in hand with strong cooling rather than reheating . besides the expansion of the system additional pion and nucleon evaporation should help to allow for a possible , yet necessary cooling . on
the other hand one realizes from fig . 3b
that depending on the bag parameter employed there might be ( moderate to strong ) cooling in the one and reheating in the other case .
in all the numerous and recent studies within thermal hadronic models one tries to find common parameters of the fireball by trying to fit the ratios of measured hadronic abundancies within a few parameters . within the above model of a rapidly disintegrating qgp we had repeated these kind of analysis @xcite and were forced to assume a high bag constant of @xmath38 mev in order to find a similar good agreement like earlier investigations .
then , according to the model , no real cooling would emerge during the phase transition and thus also no strangelet may condense
. the temperature will drop , if the specific entropy per baryon in the hadron phase exceeds that in the quark phase , @xmath39 , otherwise the temperature has to slightly increase during the transition @xcite .
the first is the case ( within the model ) when the bag constant @xmath40 is small or moderate and allows for the existence of ( meta-)stable strange quark matter states .
although this intimate connection between cooling of the plasma phase and the existence of strange quark matter is intriguing , it might be valid only within the simple parametrisation of the quark gluon plasma phase within a bag model description .
ultimately , whether @xmath41 is larger or smaller than @xmath42 at finite , nonvanishing chemical potentials might theoretically only be proven rigorously by lattice gauge calculations in the future , as also the principle existence of ( meta-)stable strange quark matter .
more conservative estimates of production of small multistrange objects ( either strangelets or memos ) without the need of a temporarily present intermediate qgp phase are based on coalescence models being put forward by dover and coworkers @xcite .
such estimates yield very small production rates , for instance @xmath43 events per central au+au collisions at 11.7 agev for the lightest bound @xmath9 system @xmath44he .
very simple coalescence estimates give production probabilities of strange clusters of the order of @xmath45 , where @xmath46 denotes the strangeness and @xmath47 the baryon number of the cluster . for a maximum sensitivity of @xmath48 only strangelets or memos with baryon numbers of @xmath49 are expected to be seen . as has been seen recently by the e864-collaboration @xcite the penalty factor @xmath50 for an additional unit of baryon number at ags energies in central collisions
is in fact very small , @xmath51 , implying that the formation of exotic objects by coalescence is even less favorable .
4 shows calculated thermal multiplicities of various hypermatter clusters for central pb+pb collisions at sps energies @xcite . these numbers should serve as an upper limit for the production via coalescence .
the ( thermal ) penalty factor suppresses the abundances of heavy clusters : metastable hypermatter can only be produced with a probability @xmath52 for @xmath53 ( e.g. a \{@xmath54 } object ) .
hence , only exotic objects with very low mass number are expected to be ( possibly ) seen at the ags or at cern .
it is important to note that these objects are a new form of matter , not a specific new particle .
the strange droplets produced in these reactions do not come in the form of a single type of particle .
many different sizes of droplets may be produced , spanning a range in mass , charge , and strangeness content .
the experimental task of finding the new form of matter is therefore challenging . here
any detected particle having an unusual charge to mass ratio is a potential strange matter candidate . employing tof - techniques in present settings to reveal the velocity and thus the charge to mass ratio
, the experimental setup sets a natural time scale of @xmath55 ns @xcite .
so , an important question we finally have to adress are the lifetimes of these objects . the lifetime of a memo should be similar to the @xmath1 s lifetime , i.e. @xmath56 sec . however , all the present experiments are unable to observe metastable hyperclusters due to the required lifetimes @xmath57s . on the other hand ,
if a produced strangelet is absolutely stable , the only energetically possible decay mode is the rather slow weak leptonic decay ( @xmath58 , @xmath59 ) , which will turn the strangelet to its minimum value in energy .
it is much more likely , if at all , however , that a small strangelet is a weakly decaying metastable state .
the situation turns out to be even more complicated : strangelets will not be in their ground state when being produced in a heavy ion collision .
suppose a strangelet is created out of the hot and dense matter with some arbitrary strangeness , charge and baryon number .
strong interactions and the distillation process will alter the composition of a strangelet by particle evaporation on a timescale of a few hundred fm / c after the collision .
the strangelet , if surviving this , will cool down until it reaches the domain of weak interactions . weak hadronic decay by hadron emission takes place on a timescale being estimated between @xmath60 s. as a conservative quideline one might even also consider the life - time of the @xmath1-particle .
strangelets stable against further strong decay channels but decaying by the weak hadronic decay will be dubbed as short - lived candidates .
strangelets stable against weak hadronic decay will then still be subject to the weak leptonic decay occuring on a timescale of @xmath61 s. they are dubbed as long - lived candidates .
obviously , the present experiments are probably only capable to look for the long - lived candidates . following the qualitative and old ideas of chin and kerman @xcite , we had carried out a detailed analysis for small short - lived and long - lived strangelet candidates @xcite , where shell effects are quite pronounced and immportant .
one qualitative outcome is that all candiates are likely to be negative , especially the long - lived candiadates . at first sight
this might appear counter - intuitive .
a closer inspection reveals that strong nucleon decay will drive a strangelet to a higher net strangeness content @xmath62 and carries away positive charge .
consider a system of bulk sqm in the ground - state with a finite total strangeness of e.g. @xmath63 ( compare fig . 1
, @xmath64 mev ) . one
would now naively argue that strange quark matter with @xmath65=0.4 is the ground - state of the system , because the energy per baryon of this state is lower than that of the hyperonic state .
however , the total energy per baryon can be lowered by additional @xmath6650 mev by assembling the non - strange quarks into pure nucleonic degrees of freedom ( i.e. ` @xmath67-particle or nucleon emission ' ) , leaving the strange quarks in a strange matter droplet , its strangeness fraction enriched to @xmath68 slightly _ above _ its minimum value .
this strong nucleon decay will stop to happen for energetical reasons at the so called tangent point ( compare fig.1 ) .
finite size corrections , i.e. strong shell effects , on the other side , of course , will change this picture quantitatively .
a similar reasoning shows that the weak nucleon decay again will change the candidates to become even more negative .
5 shows the result of this investigation for long - lived candidates which are stable against weak hadronic decay modes @xcite .
different bag parameters have been chosen in order to get some feeling for the different possibilities . besides the _
neutral _ so called quark - alpha state @xcite with @xmath69 ( @xmath70 ) a valley of stability appears at @xmath71 for long - lived , negative candidates . for bag parameters of @xmath72 mev
no long - lived candidates have been found at all .
still there exist a much richer spectrum of shortlived strangelets or memos with a lifetime of the order of the @xmath1 or somewhat below @xcite .
it might well be that only metastable strange clusters with @xmath66 cm flight path seem to have a chance of being created .
future experiments geared to proof the ( non)existence of strangelets therefore should clearly cover such short lifetimes .
an open geometry detectional device will be needed , which clearly is a challenging task due to the large background of charged hadrons at the target in violent events with high multiplicities .
originally ( strange ) quark matter in bulk was thought to exist only in the interiour of neutron stars where the pressure is high enough that the neutron matter melts into its quark substructure @xcite . at least in the cores of neutron stars ( where the density rises up to the order of @xmath73 times normal nuclear density )
it is not very likely that matter consists of individual hadrons .
on the other hand it is also known that the pure ` neutron ' matter is not really a nuclear matter state made solely out of neutrons , but at least at higher densities consists also of a considerable amount of protons as well as hyperons .
indeed , it was shown by glendenning that hyperons @xcite appear at a moderate density of about @xmath74 times normal nuclear matter density .
these new species influence the properties of the equation of state of matter and the global properties of neutron stars
. there may be so many hyperons in the neutron star that the whole object is more appropriately dubbed a giant hypernucleus .
the gross structure of a neutron star like its mass m and radius r is influenced by the composition of its stellar material .
this holds especially in the case of the existence of strangeness bearing `` exotic '' components like hyperons or strange quark matter which may significantly change the characteristic mass - radius ( mr ) relation of the star . for example
hyperons considerably soften the eos and reduce the maximum mass of a neutron star .
@xmath75 besides the speculative possibility of nearly pure sqm stars , which would be the case , if sqm is absolutely stable in bulk , it is more likely that in the interiour of the star a phase transition to hadronic matter will take place .
the ` neutron ' star would then have the form of a so called hybrid star , i.e. a star which is made of baryonic matter in the outer region , but with a quark matter core in the deep interiour .
the deconfinement phase transition from hadronic matter to the sqm phase is constructed according to the requirement of global charge neutrality between both phases @xcite .
the pressure of both phases spans up a two dimensional surface over the plane of the relevant chemical potentials of the baryons ( @xmath76 ) and the electrons ( @xmath77 ) .
this situation is depicted in fig .
one finds that the pressure varies smoothly and continuously with the proportion of both phases in equilibrium , which , in turn will lead to a mixed phase of finite radial extent ( of several kilometers ) inside the star @xcite .
7 shows the resulting mr relations for various situations and qcd coupling constants @xmath78 employed within the effective mass bag model discussed in @xcite .
the left hand side ( @xmath79 ) shows the pure sqm star results , which turn out to be rather compact objects .
the situation changes completely for the hybrid stars , depicted on the right hand side of fig.[rm1 ] ( @xmath80 ) .
their mr relation approaches the curve of the pure hadron star ( denoted by h ) if the phase transition occurs deep insight the star .
accordingly it will be difficult to judge from measured properties of pulsars to really disentangle the possible interiour structure of neutron stars. for possible consequences which might be observable , like e.g. timing structure of pulsar spin - down , higher spin rates , or stronger cooling rates , especially relevant for young neutron stars , we want to refer to @xcite .
witten raised the intriguing possibility that strange quark matter might in principle also be absolutely stable and may also provide an explanation for cold ( baryonic ) dark matter in the universe @xcite .
if being stable and nearly neutral , it could exist at all possible sizes @xcite , as the small coulomb energy is not sufficient for a break up into smaller pieces @xcite .
it might thus span as a charge neutral state the empty ` nuclear desert ' @xcite within the range from @xmath81 up to sizes of neutron stars @xmath82 . in witten s prospective scenario
hot strange quark matter nuggets could have condensed out of the deconfined phase during the phase transition in the expanding and cooling early universe @xcite .
these would carry most of the tiny surplus in baryon number of the whole universe . the baryon number would remain inside if the heat and entropy of the nugetts is carried away mainly by neutrino emission instead of mesons and especially baryons .
if an absolutely stable groundstate would exist the hot nuggets would further cool and instead of suffering a complete hadronisation they might settle into these new states and hence could resolve the dark matter problem .
since then the idea of absolute stability has stimulated a lot of work on potential consequences in astrophysics @xcite .
today it is fair to say that there is still no real evidence for absolutely stable sqm to be a possible dark matter candiate .
there had been early conjectures @xcite that escpecially smaller glumps of sqm could not have survived the ongoing and still hot epoch of the cosmological evolution , but would have in fact been completely evaporated into single hadrons .
hence , particle physicists were led to look for other possible ( and maybe even more exotic ) explanations on the issue of dark matter . on the other side , in a very recent ( and speculative ) study @xcite
the issue of stable quark matter was taken up again .
there it is speculated that a ( stable ) pre quark - matter phase might in fact also explain the formation of galaxies clusters , the formation of massive black holes in the galactic centres , and also might be a source of the @xmath83-ray bursts .
we refer the interested reader to @xcite . +
* acknowledgements : * thanks go to c. dover , a. dumitru , a. gal , l. gerland , p. koch - steinheimer , d. rischke , j. schaffner - bielich , k. schertler , c. spieles , h. stcker , m. thoma and c. traxler for their help and collaboration .
99 for a general review see : c. greiner and j. schaffner , _ int . j. mod . phys._*e5 * ( 1996 ) 239 ; c. greiner and j. schaffner , physics of strange matter , nucl - th/9801062 ; + for an introduction see : h. crawford and c. greiner , ` the search for strange matter ' , _ scientific american _ , vol .
1 , january 1994 , p. 58
j. schaffner , c. greiner and h. stcker , _ phys .
c _ * 46 * , 322 ( 1992 ) e. witten , _ phys .
d _ * 30 * , 272 ( 1984 ) ; e. farhi and r. l. jaffe , _ phys .
d _ * 30 * , 2379 ( 1984 ) c. greiner , p. koch and h. stcker , _ phys .
lett . _ * 58 * , 1825 ( 1987 ) ; c. greiner , d.h .
rischke , h. stcker and p. koch , _ phys .
d _ * 38 * , 2797 ( 1988 ) ; c. greiner and h. stcker , _ phys .
d _ * 44 * , 3517 ( 1991 ) a. r. bodmer , _ phys . rev .
d _ * 4 * , 1601 ( 1971 ) j. schaffner , c. b. dover , a. gal , c. greiner and h. stcker , _ phys .
lett . _ * 71 * , 1328 ( 1993 ) ; j. schaffner , c. dover , a. gal , c. greiner , d. millener and h. stcker , _ ann . phys . _ * 235 * , 35 ( 1994 ) c. spieles , c. greiner and h. stcker , _ eur .
j. _ * c 2 * , 351 ( 1998 ) a. dumitru , c. spieles , h. stcker and c. greiner , _ phys .
rev . _ * c 56 * , 2202 ( 1997 ) c. traxler , t.s .
biro and u. mosel , hadronization of a quark - gluon plasma in the chromodielectric model , hep - ph/9808298 ; c. traxler and c. greiner , in preparation c. greiner and b. mller , _ phys .
lett . _ * b219 * , 199 ( 1989 ) ; m. gyulassy , _ phys .
lett . _ * b286 * , 211 ( 1992 ) ; a. jacholkowski , contribution to these proceedings a.j .
baltz , c.b .
dover , s.h .
kahana , y. pang , t.j .
schlagel , e. schnedermann , _ phys .
lett . _ * b325 * , 7 ( 1994 ) j. sandweiss , contribution to these proceedings ; z. xu , contribution to these proceedings ; g. van buren , contribution to these proceedings ; m. munoz , contribution to these proceedings j. sandweiss , _ nucl .
b _ ( proc . suppl . ) * 24b * , 234 ( 1991 ) ; + f.s .
rotondo , proc .
quark matter ` 96 , _ nucl .
a _ * 610 * , 297c ( 1996 ) h.j .
crawford et al . , _ nucl .
b _ ( proc .
* 24b * , 251 ( 1991 ) f. dittus , proc .
quark matter ` 95 , _ nucl .
phys . a _ * 590 * , 347c ( 1995 ) ; r. klingenberg , proc .
quark matter ` 96 , _ nucl .
phys . a _ * 610 * , 306c ( 1996 ) s. a. chin and a. k. kerman , _ phys
lett . _ * 43 * , 1292 ( 1979 ) j. schaffner , c. greiner , a. diener and h. stcker , _ phys .
* c 55 * , 3038 ( 1997 ) ; j. schaffner , strangelets and strange quark matter ' , nucl - th/971104 f. c. michel , _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 60 * , 677 ( 1988 ) for a detailed survey on the astrophysical implications see : ` strange quark matter in physics and astrophysics ' , edited by j. madsen and p. haensel , _ nucl . phys .
b _ ( proc . suppl . ) * 24b * n.k . glendenning , _ astrophys . j._*293 * , 151 ( 1985 ) ; f. weber and n.k . glendenning , _ astrophys . j. _ * 390 * , 541 ( 1992 ) ; j. schaffner and i. mishustin , _ phys . rev .
c _ * 53 * , 1416 ( 1996 ) k. schertler , c. greiner and m.h .
thoma , _ nucl .
a _ * 616 * , 659 ( 1997 ) ; k. schertler , c. greiner , p. sahu and m.h .
thoma , the influence of medium effects in the gross structure of hybrid stars ' , astro - ph/9712165 , to appear in _ nucl .
a _ n. glendenning , s. pei and f. weber , _ phys .
lett . _ * 79 * , 1603 ( 1997 ) ; n. glendenning , _ j. phys .
g _ : nucl . part .
* 23 * , 2013 ( 1997 ) ; t. lu , observational effects of strange stars ' , astro - ph/9807052 ; j. madsen , how to identify a strange star , astro - ph/9806032 a. de rujula and s.l .
glashow , _ nature _ * 312 * , 734 ( 1984 ) ; a. de rujula , _ nucl .
a_*434 * , 605c ( 1985 ) d. enstrm , s. fredriksson , j. hanson , a. nicolaidis and s. ekelin , a quark - matter dominated universe , astro - ph/9802236 | relativistic heavy ion collisions offer the possibility to produce exotic metastable states of nuclear matter containing ( roughly ) equal number of strangeness compared to the content in baryon number .
the reasoning of both their stability and existence , the possible distillation of strangeness necessary for their formation and the chances for their detection are reviewed . in the later respect
emphasize is put on the properties of small lumps of strange quark matter with respect to their stability against strong or weak hadronic decays .
in addition , implications in astrophysics like the properties of neutron stars and the issue of baryonic dark matter will be discussed . |
type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) have been the tool that made possible the discovery of the acceleration of the expansion of the universe ( riess et al .
1998 ; perlmutter et al . 1999 ) , and they are now providing new insights on the cosmic component , dubbed `` dark energy '' , thus revealed .
however , in contrast with their key role as cosmological probes , and after more than 50 years of supernova research , the nature of their progenitors remains elusive . as far back as 1960 , it was established that type i supernovae ( in fact , the now denominated sne ia , or thermonuclear supernovae ) should result from the ignition of degenerate nuclear fuel in stellar material ( hoyle & fowler 1960 ) .
the absence of hydrogen in the spectra of the sne ia almost immediately suggested that they were due to thermonuclear explosions of white dwarfs ( wds ) .
isolated white dwarfs were once thought to be possible progenitors ( finzi & wolf 1967 ) , but soon discarded due to incompatibility with basic results from stellar evolution .
instead , accretion of matter from a close companion star in a binary system , by a previously formed c+o white dwarf with a mass close to the chandrasekhar mass , provides a viable mechanism to induce the explosion ( wheeler & hansen 1971 ) . two main competing production channels are still under discussion nowadays .
one possible path is the so called single degenerate ( sd ) channel , where a c+o white dwarf grows in mass by accretion from a non degenerate stellar companion : a main sequence star , a subgiant , a helium star , a red giant , or an agb star ( whelan & iben 1973 ; nomoto 1982 ) .
another possible path is the double degenerate ( dd ) channel ( webbink 1984 ; iben & tutukov 1984 ) , where two wds merge due to the loss of angular momentum by gravitational radiation .
the merging could produce the collapse of the white dwarf ( saio & nomoto 1985 ) , or it can produce a larger c+o white dwarf configuration that then explodes ( pakmor et al .
2012 ) . in the decade of the 90 s , the variety amongst sne ia was discovered , ranging from events such as sn 1991bg to those as sn 1991 t , through normal sne ia ( see filippenko 1997a , b ; branch et al .
2007 ; leibundgut 2011 ) .
such diversity was made amenable for cosmology when the correlation of the luminosity at the maximum of the light curve of each sn ia with its rate of decline was parameterized ( phillips 1993 , 1999 ; riess , press & kirshner 1995 ; perlmutter et al .
it became clear , then , that sne ia could be used as distance indicators in cosmology , and that led to the aforementioned discovery .
yet , the first decade of the new century has brought new surprises : super chandrasekhar supernovae , as well as extremly faint ones ( see below ) .
neither of them are useful for cosmology , although they are not a severe nuisance there , since they can be easily identified , and eliminated from the large samples of sne ia collected for cosmological probes .
also , various teams have started to measure supernova rates at a wide variety of redshifts .
the idea of using sne ia rates to discover the nature of the progenitor systems has now become an active line of research .
finally , high resolution spectroscopic observations of sn have yielded the surprising result of time
varying absorptions , which indicate the existence of outflows in the circumstellar medium surrounding some sn , and points to possible nova activity previous to the explosion .
an intriguing c ii feature has been identifieed , close to the si ii line typical of sne ia , and that has led to thinking in two different directions : either the thermonuclear flame does not burn the outermost layers of the white dwarf , or maybe c is a signature of the merged white dwarf companion of the sn .
there are also better estimates of the maximum h mass that could be present in the envelopes of the pre
sne , if the explosions were triggered by accretion from a non degenerate companion .
there is continued failure to detect h from the radio emission of the sne ia , and there could be constraints from the x ray emission as well .
the task of searching for the companion star in galactic supernovae has already given some definite results , and there are , now , simulations of the impact of the sn ejecta on the companion star that can be compared with the observations . in the following sections , we present and
discuss those new results . in section 2 we briefly review the different models proposed to explain the sn ia phenomenon .
section 3 examines how the delay time distribution ( dtd ) constrains the possible sn ia progenitors . in section 4
we discuss the carbon and oxygen absorption features seen , in recent years , in the spectra of sn ia at early times , while section 5 deals with the emission features at late times .
section 6 discusses the variable blueshifted sodium feature seen in some sne ia .
the x ray constraints are presented in section 7 , and the radio constraints in section 8 . in section 9
we report the limits on the luminosities of the companions of sne ia obtained from pre explosion images .
section 10 deals with the detection of companions throught the early light curves of sne ia .
section 11 reviews the direct searches for surviving companions , in the galaxy and in the large magellanic cloud .
section 12 deals with the identification of possible candidates to sne ia through reconstruction of the orbital evolution of diverse close binary systems containing white dwarfs .
section 13 addresses the important problem of the outliers from the peak brightness
decline rate of the light curve relationship used to make these sne calibrated candles for cosmology .
section 14 deals with the bulk of sne ia used for cosmology .
we summarize the current state of affairs in the last section .
an ideally complete model of a type ia supernova should start from the formation and subsequent evolution of the binary system assumed to originate it , include possible common envelope episodes , mass tranfer stages ( generally nonconservative ) , especially those immediately leading to the explosion , rotational states of the two stars involved , and finally the ignition process and its development into a full thermonuclear explosion ( hydrodynamics and nucleosynthesis ) . from that
, light curves and spectra of the emitted light should be computed , for the different stages of the outburst ( extending until the nebular phase ) .
the characteristics of the resulting remnants should be predicted as well .
in addition , the frequency of the explosions corresponding to the model has to be estimated , for different galactic environments .
the whole programme involves very diverse domains of expertise , so the progress has been disperse .
those models were first proposed by webbink ( 1984 ) and by iben & tutukov ( 1984 ) .
the most favored scenario , in the latter work , started from binaries with component masses in the range 59 @xmath0 .
they experienced two common envelope stages and ended as a pair of c+o white dwarfs , with masses in the range 0.71 @xmath0 , separated by distances 0.20.35 @xmath1 and orbiting each other with periods @xmath2 between 12 min and 14 hrs .
the system then losses angular momentum by emission of gravitational waves and the two white dwarfs merge on a time scale ranging from 10@xmath3 to 10@xmath4 yr ( merging of binaries due to the emission of gravitational radiation had already been considered by tutukov & yungelson 1979 )
. the merging would occur through disruption of the less massive component of the system .
that component fills its roche lobe first ( larger radius and smaller roche lobe ) . the mass transfer , then , should have a runaway character , since the more mass the white dwarf losses , the larger its radius becomes ( and the smaller its roche lobe ) .
the material of the disrupted white dwarf would form a thick disk around the more massive one , which would accrete mass from it until reaching the chandrasekhar limit and explosively ignite c at its centre . with the caveat that the effects on the orbit of the two common envelope phases could only be roughly approximated , iben & tutukov ( 1984 ) found that the rate of such mergings might , alone , account for the galactic sn ia rate . in the preceding scenario
, it was assumed that the only effect of the accretion of matter by the more massive white dwarf , from the debris of its companion , should be growth up to the chandrasekhar mass .
that was soon challenged by saio & nomoto ( 1985 ) , who argued that a very fast mass transfer ( @xmath5 ) would produce an off centre c flash .
a c burning front would then propagate ( nonexplosively ) down to the centre of the white dwarf , changing the chemical composition from c+o to o+ne+mg along the way .
electron captures on mg and ne would subsequently make the chandrasekhar mass smaller than the white dwarf mass , and gravitational collapse would ensue .
the outcome should thus be the formation of a neutron star , rather than a sn ia explosion .
nomoto & iben ( 1985 ) further concluded that the off
centre c ignition would always occur unless the mass accretion rate were less than one fifth of the eddington limit for an isolated white dwarf . later hydrodynamic simulations ( benz et al . 1990 ; guerrero et al .
2004 ) have confirmed that a heavy accretion disk is formed around the most massive white dwarf . whether a sn ia ensues would depend on the mass accretion rate of the white dwarf from the disk , that being determined by the viscosity of the latter :
a sufficiently low viscosity would allow the white dwarf to grow while avoiding the off centre , non explosive ignition of c ( mochkovich , guerrero & segretain 1997 ) .
the issue remains open .
another effect of mass acccretion from a massive disk should be the gain of angular momentum by the white dwarf .
its consequences have been studied by piersanti et al .
( 2003a , b ) and tornamb & piersanti ( 2013 ) .
they find that rotation can stabilize the white dwarf against contraction , even when its mass becomes larger than the chandrasekhar mass .
later , loss of angular momentum by emission of gravitational waves allows contraction , until the conditions for explosive c ignition are reached at the centre .
recently , lebanon , soker & garcia berro ( 2014 ) find constraints on the classical dd type of progenitor from the disk originated matter around the exploding wd , as this matter will be shocked by the sn ejecta and end up in a radiation implying a larger progenitor radius than observed .
a different approach is based on the violent merging of a pair of white dwarfs ( pakmor et al .
another possibility is the direct collision of a pair of white dwarfs .
such collisions could take place in environments of high star number density , like globular clusters or the galactic centre ( benz et al . 1989 ) , and also in triple star systems where a close pair of white dwarfs have their orbits perturbed by the third , more distant star ( thompson 2011 ; katz & dong 2012 ; kushnir et al .
2013 ; dong et al .
2014 ) . in the hydrodynamic simulations of pakmor
et al . ( 2010 ) , the merging of two equal mass ( @xmath6 ) white dwarfs produced a subluminous sn ia .
further modeling ( pakmor et al .
2011 ) has shown that violent mergings where the primary mass is @xmath6 can give rise to subluminous sne ia for unequal masses too , provided that the mass ratio is more than about 0.8 .
later on , pakmor et al .
( 2012 ) have found that the violent merging of two c+o white dwarfs , with masses 0.9 m@xmath7 and 1.1 m@xmath7 ( assumed to induce the detonation of the c+o mixture ) can account for normal sne ia as well .
that has been very recently confirmed by garca
senz et al . (
2013 ) , who find that the amount of @xmath8ni produced in the collisions ranges from 0.1 m@xmath7 to 1.1 m@xmath7 , thus covering from subluminous through normal up to overluminous sne ia .
they argue , however , that given the distribution of white dwarf masses , mostly subluminous events should arise . on the other hand , ruiter et al .
( 2013 ) find that the brightness distribution of the explosions produced by violent mergers matches the shape of that observed for sne ia ( although the issue depends on the occurrence of a particular phase of mass accretion during binary evolution ) . very recently , kromer et al .
( 2013a ) have successfully explained the narrow emission lines of [ o i ] in the late time spectra of sn 2010lp ( a subluminous sn ia ) by the violent merger of two c+o white dwarfs , with masses of 0.9 and 0.76 m@xmath7 .
even more recently , moll et al . (
2013 ) have found that prompt detonations following the merging of two white dwarfs can not only reproduce both common and overluminous sne ia , but also the width
luminosity relation on which the use of these supernovae as cosmological distance indicators is based .
a key point , though , is whether there are or not enough close binary white dwarf binaries to account for the rate of occurrence of sne ia .
one approach to this problem is to look for such systems in the galaxy .
napiwotzki et al .
( 2007 ) have reported the results of a systematic radial velocity survey for double degenerate binaries as potential progenitors of type ia supernovae .
more than 1000 wds and pre white dwarfs were observed with the vlt .
the frequency of he wds is much higher than that of c+o wds , and they regard he wd donors as a possible important channel for sne ia .
recently , badenes & maoz ( 2012 ) , using multi epoch spectroscopy of @xmath9 4000 white dwarfs from the sloan digital sky survey , have determined the white dwarf merger rate per unit stellar mass in our galaxy .
they find that the total rate might well account for the sn ia rate in the milky way and galaxies of the same type , but that the rate of merging of pairs of white dwarfs with a total mass above the chandrasekhar mass is only @xmath91/14 of the total rate .
so , unless sub chandrasekhar mergers can produce sne ia , the double degenerate channel should be , at most , a minor contributor to the sn ia phenomenon .
sn ia models based on the non violent merging of two white dwarfs , with a total mass below the chandrasekhar mass , involve a c+o plus a he white dwarf .
the he accreted by the more massive ( c+o ) white dwarf detonates and the shock wave thus generated can either induce the detonation of the c+o layers immediately below or converge near the centre and produce a c+o detonation there ( sim et .
al . 2012 ) .
these authors find that the light curves and spectra of such explosions do match those observed in sne ia .
besides , ruiter et al .
( 2011 ) had calculated that if those double detonation models were able to produce explosions similar to sne ia , then the sub
chandrasekhar explosions would account for a substantial fraction , at least , of the observed sn ia rate .
they also found that the double white dwarf channel involving a c+o plus a he white dwarf should have a distribution of delay times ( between formation of the binary and the sn explosion ) spanning from 800 myr up to the hubble time .
the channel leading to a sn ia explosion via mass accretion , by a c+o white dwarf , from a non degenerate binary companion , was first modelled by whelan & iben ( 1973 ) , although the idea , as we have seen , already appears in wheeler & hansen ( 1971 ) : a primary with a mass of 1.83 @xmath0 , plus a secondary with @xmath10 , initially form a system with an orbital period between 5 and 9 years .
the primary then evolves and becomes a c+o white dwarf , with a mass close to the chandrasekhar mass .
the secondary , after @xmath9 10@xmath4 yr , becomes an agb star , fills its roche lobe , and transfers mass to the white dwarf , which then reaches the chandrasekhar mass and explodes . in this first model
, the mass of the secondary was chosen to explain the occurrence of sne ia in elliptical galaxies , long after star formation has stopped .
subsequently , a variety of initial binary systems , in which mass accretion by the white dwarf can take place at different evolutionary stages of its companion ( main sequence , subgiant , red giant , agb ) , and either from roche lobe overflow or from a stellar wind , have been proposed .
also , mass loss by the two components of the binary can take place more than once , as well as mass transfer ( either conservative or non conservative ) .
the possibility that the companion might have lost its hydrogen rich envelope and become a helium star , at the time of mass tranfer to the white dwarf , has also been considered .
a problem common to both the single degenerate models and to the double degenerate models , in which the conditions for explosive c ignition , close to the centre of the c+o white dwarf , are reached when the white dwarf mass has grown to the chandrasekhar mass ( or when rotational support has been lost , for masses above such limit ) , is that thermonuclear burning propagation should be subsonic at first ( deflagration ) and , at some point , become supersonic ( detonation ) .
if only deflagrations were involved , the explosions could just produce a subclass of subluminous sne ia ( fink et al .
on the other hand , pure detonations of chandrasekhar mass white dwarfs would burn the c+o mixture to fe
peak elements entirely , in stark contrast with the observations , that show intermediate mass elements at and around maximum light .
a self consistent modeling of the deflagration / detonation transition still remains elusive , although steady progress is being made ( woosley 2007 ; aspden , bell & woosley 2010 ; schmidt et al . 2010 ; woosley , kerstein & aspden 2011 ) .
there is another problem that only concerns single
degenerate models of sne ia : the possible explosive ignition of the material ( hydrogen or helium ) accumulated on the surface of the accreting c+o white dwarf , before the latter reaches the chandrasekhar mass . also , in the case of hydrogen , a high rate of accretion may not lead to explosion but to the formation of an extended envelope , which would be ejected by interaction with the mass donor star , that terminating the accretion process .
accumulation of hydrogen on the surface of a white dwarf at a low rate should produce nova like explosions , in which all the accreted material ( and maybe even more ) would be expelled ( nomoto 1982 ; livio & truran 1992 ) .
the lower limit on the mass accretion rate , to avoid explosions and strong flashes , is uncertain and depends on the mass of the white dwarf , but a value @xmath11 is often given , although kercek , hillebrandt & truran ( 1999 ) , in 3d simulations , obtained steady hydrogen burning for rates as low as @xmath12 ( see discussion in hillebrandt & niemeyer 2000 ) .
even if hydrogen is burned steadily or in weak flashes , the resulting helium layer should explosively burn , in a detonation , if the rate of accumulation of helium were @xmath13 ( although this is only true for white dwarf masses @xmath14 ) .
the same applies to the direct accretion of helium .
lower rates would thus be excluded from the production of chandrasekhar mass explosions , but they could lead to sub
chandrasekhar , edge lit explosions , instead .
the explosion of helium shells in accreting white dwarfs as a type ia sn mechanism was first proposed by taam ( 1980 ) and nomoto ( 1982a ) ( the `` double detonation '' model ) , and numerically studied , in one dimensional ( 1d ) numerical simulations , by woosley , taam & weaver ( 1986 ) , and by livne ( 1990 ) .
the earliest 2d simulations were made by livne & glasner ( 1991 ) .
such explosions were further investigated by woosley & weaver ( 1994 ) , and by livne & arnett ( 1995 ) .
the `` robustness '' of the double detonation model has been recently checked in 2d and 3d simulations by moll & woosley ( 2013 ) , whilst the conditions for producing helium detonations have been examined by woosley & kasen ( 2011 ) .
the first evidence of a sub chandrasekhar explosion was found by ruiz
lapuente et al . (
1993 ) ( later confirmed by mazzali et al . 1997 ) , from modeling the spectra of sn 1991bg . whether double detonation models produce explosions characteristically similar to those of sne ia
remains an open question , but ruiter et al .
( 2011 ) find that the helium star channel would have delay times @xmath15 500 myr ( `` prompt explosions '' ) , while the double white dwarf channel ( c+o plus he white dwarf ) would have longer delay times , as mentioned above .
successful accretion of hydrogen , leading to growth of a c+o white dwarf up to the chandrasekhar mass through steady shell hydrogen and helium burning , thus requires high accretion rates .
that can be achieved for binary stellar companions at different stages ot their evolution , but if hydrogen accumulates faster than it can be burned , a red giant like structure should form , soon engulfing the companion and leading to a common envelope stage . a solution to this problem
was found by hachisu , kato & nomoto ( 1996 ) : when the mass accretion rate exceeds the maximum rate at which hydrogen can be burned , there is no static envelope solution , and the excess material is blown off in a wind .
the optically thick wind solution had been previously found to explain the light curves of nova outbursts by kato & hachisu ( 1994 ) .
white dwarfs accreting mass at high rates should emit large amounts of radiation in the x ray band , and they should appear as luminous supersoft x ray sources ( van den heuvel et al . 1992 ; di stefano & nelson 1996 ; yungelson et al . 1996 ; kahabka & van den heuvel 1997 ; li & van den heuvel 1997 ; orio 2006 ) .
however , as we will see in section 7 , that might be in conflict with the observed x
ray emission of elliptical galaxies and galaxy bulges .
another possible channel involving a c+o white dwarf plus a non degenerate companion star is the core
degenerate scenario recently advocated by soker ( 2013 ) : a chandrasekhar or super chandrasekhar white dwarf is formed from the merging of a white dwarf with the hot , more massive core of an agb star . the initial white dwarf is disrupted and its material accreted by the agb core , that leading to the formation of a rapidly spinning , more massive white dwarf .
the delay time till explosion would then be given by the spin
down time of the new white dwarf .
mergings of a white dwarf with the core of an agb star , following a common envelope episode , had also been considered as a production mechanism of sne ia by sparks & stecher ( 1974 ) and by livio & riess ( 2003 ) .
soker et al .
( 2013 , 2014 ) have proposed the core degenerate scenario to explain the characteristics of two very different sne : ptf11kx and sn 2011fe .
in the preceding , we have not dealt with the especifics of the hydrodynamic modeling of the different types of explosions surveyed , which has reached unprecedented standards of realism ( see hillebrandt et al .
they are being matched by 3d models of the spectra that should arise from the explosions ( baron , hauschildt & chen 2009 ) .
the delay time distribution ( dtd ) is given by the time evolution of the sn rate that would follow an instantaneous burst of star formation .
it is related to the observed rate @xmath16 by : @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the dtd , @xmath19 is the star formation rate , and @xmath20 and @xmath21 are in the sn rest frame ( see , for instance , ruiz lapuente & canal 1998 )
. early research on sne ia rates and dtds indicated the need of a two component model at least : one that could be fitted with a short dtd population ( @xmath22 yr ) and another one with a long dtd population ( 34 gyr ) ( scannapieco & bildsten 2005 ; mannucci et al .
2006 ; brandt et al .
recent studies ( maoz & mannucci 2012 ) suggest that the dtd peaks at the shortest times , as a function @xmath23 ( see also mannucci et al . 2005 , and oemler & tinsley 1979 ) .
such a function characterizes the dominance of double degenerate mergings . as already mentioned in the previous section , badenes & maoz ( 2012 )
find that the total merger rate of white dwarf pairs ( for sub chandrasekhar wds ) is similar to the observed sne ia rate ( see also ruiter et al .
2011 ) . the sne ia searches in clusters of galaxies at high redshifts ( barbary et al .
2012 ) have indicated a @xmath24 behavior of the rates , with @xmath25 @xmath26 -1.41@xmath27 , which also favors the wd merging channel .
such best fit value is consistent with measurements of the late dtd in field galaxies ( totani et al .
most predictions for the sd scenario show a steeper late time dtd ( greggio 2005 ; ruiter et al .
2009 ; mennekens et al .
2010 ) , whith @xmath25 ranging from @xmath25 @xmath26 -1.6 ( greggio 2005 ) to @xmath25 @xmath15 -3 ( mennekens et al .
2010 ) , depending on the details of the scenario and on how the binary evolution is calculated ( see , however , hachisu et al .
2008 , and pritchet et al .
recently , bonaparte et al .
( 2013 ) have computed the cosmic sn ia rate , for several cosmic star formation rates and progenitor models , and compared it with the observational data .
no firm conclusions can be derived , concerning the sn ia progenitors , but the existence of prompt sne ia , exploding within the first @xmath28 yr after the corresponding systems are formed , is required , althought their fraction should not exceed 1520% of the total , to be consistent with the chemical evolution of the galaxies ( see , for an updated view of this subject , the review by maoz , mannucci & nelemans 2014 ) .
also , from the analysis of the environments of 90 hubble flow sne ia discovered by the _
nearby supernova factory _ , rigault et al .
( 2013 ) find evidence of two distinct populations with different ages : one associated with current star formation and another one corresponding to passively evolving environments .
if the sne ia explosions would come from white dwarf mergings , one would expect to see carbon and oxygen in the early time spectra , coming from the surrounding clumps of this material , originated by the merging . with the access to large numbers of sne ia
, the _ sn factory _ has found c ii absorption lines in the spectra of several of them ( thomas et al .
these authors estimate that 22@xmath29 @xmath30 of sne ia exhibit c ii signatures as late as 5 days before maximum light . in some cases one can treat them as spherically symmetric absorptions , in others as `` carbon blobs '' . in the context of explosions from the merging of two c+o white dwarfs ,
the presence of this photospheric carbon at high velocities seems justified .
parrent et al .
( 2011 ) have studied both the spherically symmetric c ii absorption and the non spherically symmetric cases .
altavilla et al .
( 2007 ) found evidence of a c blob in the normal sn ia sn 2004dt .
folatelli et al ( 2012 ) have also found evidence of unburnt carbon in sne ia from the _ carnegie supernova project _ , in 30@xmath30 of the objects ( see figure 1 ) . in the case of the normal sn 2011fe , in the m101 galaxy
, the availability of early spectra has allowed to see both c ii and o i emissions ( parrent et al .
2012 ; nugent et al .
the absorption of o i appears at higher velocities , which suggests that sn 2011fe may have had an appreciable amount of unburned oxygen within the outer layers of the ejecta .
mazzali et al .
( 2014 ) , from modeling of the spectral evolution , find that the high velocity tail of the ejecta differs from the predictions of both deflagration and delayed detonation models of the explosion .
6580 and @xmath317234 lines , and a matching synthetic spectrum from a model with carbon ( dashed line ) .
a synthetic spectrum from a model without carbon is shown in dotted lines .
( see folatelli et al .
( courtesy of gaston folatelli .
aas . reproduced with permission ) . ] nomoto , kamiya & nakasato ( 2013 ) suggest that unburnt c inside the ejecta might just come from asymmetric sne ia explosions , in a single degenerate model , for instance , if off center ignitions take place ( maeda et al .
however , it is also possible that unburnt c would be left inside the ejecta in explosions coming from mergings of c+o wds , even from violent ones .
such carbon would not have been ignited by the detonation that takes place in such mergings ( hicken et al .
2007 ; pakmor et al .
2010 ; hillebrandt et al .
2013 ) . in that case
, we would have a minimum of @xmath930 @xmath30 of sne ia coming from double degenerate systems .
it is important to study through spectropolarimetry ( wang and wheeler 2008 ; hflich 1991 ; jeffery 1989 , 1990 ) the asymmetry of the c ii and o i features .
thus far , line asymmetries have been seen in some sne ia , such as sn 2004dt ( wang and wheeler 2008 ) .
the merging models of c+o wds need testing in the nebular phase .
as discussed in rpke et al ( 2012 ) , several properties of the merging models could be observable in that phase . in general , the model of ( initial )
deflagration of a wd when reaching the chandrasekhar mass leads to a high degree of neutronization , since burning occurs at densities higher than @xmath32 .
such neutronization can be seen , for instance , from the nebular emission of ni ii ( coming from the stable isotope @xmath33ni ) . in the violent
merging of two white dwarfs , instead , the burning occurs at peak densities below @xmath32 ( rpke et al .
2012 ) , and nebular emission of stable ni should not be so prominent .
in fact , the nebular emission of the decay products of @xmath8ni is expected to be asymmetric , both in the single degenerate model and in the non violent merging of two c+o wds , the asymmetry arising from the material produced by a deflagration initiated off
centre , when the wd reaches the chandrasekhar mass .
the ni produced later , in the detonation phase , would be more symmetrically distributed , instead .
those asymmetries of the nebular emission by the products of @xmath8ni decay have already been seen , according to maeda et al .
( 2010a , b ) .
maeda et al . ( 2010a ) assert that the nebular spectra do reveal ignitions offset from the centre of the wd , and that this is a generic feature of sne ia .
a point made by rpke et al .
( 2012 ) is that , in the violent merging of c+o wds , the detonation of the secondary wd , at low densities , should introduce copious amounts of oxygen in the innermost ejecta . that could give rise to visible [ o i ] @xmath34 6300 , 6364 .
this has been seen in sn 2010lp ( kromer et al . 2013a ; taubenberger et al .
2013a ) , and it gives strong support to that scenario .
a different question ( ruiz - lapuente 1996 ) is that , at lower densities , the [ fe ii ] and [ fe iii ] lines are less collisionally excited and become weaker than what is seen in the data .
this was shown for the sub
chandrasekhar edge lit detonations of livne & arnett ( 1995 ) which gave a very poor fit to the observations , while chandraskehar models with 0.6 m@xmath35 of @xmath8ni fit very well the data of normal sne ia .
the fit to the nebular data for the new class of sub chandrasekhar explosion models remains to be tested , since the result just mentioned came from the models of he detonations in sub
chandrasekhar wds available in the 90 s ( ruiz lapuente 1996 , hereafter r96 ; see figure 2 ) . on the other hand , in the models based on chandrasekhar mass wds resulting from accretion of h from a non degenerate star
, one would expect to see emission of h at @xmath316563 .
such emission is not seen in normal sne ia ( leonard 2007 ) .
hydrodynamic simulations indicate that seeing the h@xmath25 emission is related to the mixing of h with other elements . in a hydrodynamic simulation for a main sequence companion to the sn ( liu et al .
2012 ) , up to 19@xmath30 of the total mass of the companion star is stripped by the impact of the sn ejecta , and those debris should mix with the most slowly moving layers of the ejecta .
there have been a few sne ia with h@xmath25 in emission
. such are , for instance , the cases of sn 2002ic ( hamuy et al .
2003 ) , of sn 2005gj ( aldering et al .
2006 ) , and of ptf11kx ( dilday et al . 2012 ) .
we will address this point in section 13.2 .
as first seen by patat et al .
( 2007 ) , some sne ia have variable na i d absorption lines , significantly blueshifted with respect to the absorption features of other elements .
this result has been confirmed by simon et al .
( 2009 ) , sternberg et al .
( 2011 ) , and foley et al .
( 2012 ) ( see figure 3 ) .
the general interpretation is that a significant fraction of sne ia progenitor systems have outflows of material previous to the explosion .
the na i d lines arise from the ionized circumstellar medium ( csm ) .
foley et al .
( 2012 ) find a correlation with higher velocity ejecta in the sne ia that show blueshifted na i d line profiles .
they suggest the possibility that progenitor systems with strong outflows tend to have more kinetic energy per unit mass than those with weak or no outflows .
patat et al .
( 2013 ) have shown that the sn 2011fe was surrounded by a `` clean '' environment , and there is a lack of time variable blueshifted absorption features .
they found sn 2011fe consistent with the progenitor being a binary system with a main sequence or even a degenerate star .
nugent et al .
( 2011 ) found that the exploding star was likely a c+o wd and , from the lack of an early shock , that the companion was most likely a main sequence star or there is no surviving companion .
( 2011 ) , from pre explosion images , also exclude companions more evolved that subgiants ( see section 9 ) .
bloom et al .
( 2012 ) also find that only degeneracy supported compact objects wds and neutron stars are viable as the primary star . with few caveats
, they also restrict the companion ( secondary ) star radius to @xmath36 , that excluding roche
lobe overflowing red giant and main sequence companions to high significance .
it would be interesting to see if , within the sample of sne ia showing c ii and o i absorptions , there are cases of outflows .
it is tempting to think that the supernovae with variable na i d features are connected to nova precursors and the ones showing c and o in the outermost layers are connected with mergings of wds , instead .
recently , sternberg et al .
( 2013 ) have found that 18% of the sne ia events show time
variable na i d features associated with circumstellar material .
one might tentatively associate them with recurrent novae .
recurrent novae are binaries harboring a wd close to the chandrasekhar mass .
classical novae are the outcome of unstable thermonuclear burning in accreting white dwarfs .
those white dwarfs have typical masses @xmath37 .
if the accretion rate and white dwarf mass are high , the time between flashes can become short enough that the recurrence can be observed . due to the large accretion rate and insignificant mass loss by ejection
, it has been proposed that in recurrent novae ( rne ) the white dwarfs may grow to the chandrasekhar mass and give rise to sne ia ( starrfield et al .
1988 ; schaefer 2010 ) .
indeed , rne can be the progenitors of a part of the sne ia that show variable circumstellar na absorptions .
amongst recurrent novae , there are those of the u sco type , where the donor is a main sequence or subgiant star , and those of the rs oph type , where the donor is a red giant .
the supernova ptf11kx , classified as a sn ia
csm for its interaction with the circumstellar medium , is believed to have a symbiotic recurrent nova as its progenitor system ( dilday et al .
2012 ) , although it has also been attributed to a violent prompt merger of a white dwarf with the core of a massive agb star by soker et al .
( 2013 ) , who also argue that the mass of the shell surrounding ptf11kx is too high to have been produced by a recurrent nova .
they estimate the hydrogen mass in the shell to be @xmath38 .
also , l , yungelson & han ( 2006 ) have shown that symbiotic novae are unlikely sne ia progenitors , due to their low efficiency in hydrogen accumulation . sahman et al .
( 2013 ) suggest that the recurrent nova cl aql will become a sn ia within 10 myr .
they find that the mass of the white dwarf is 1.00 @xmath39 0.14 m@xmath7 , and the mass of the companion is 2.32 @xmath39 0.19 m@xmath7 .
the radius of the latter is 2.07@xmath39 0.06 r@xmath7 .
they estimate that the secondary is a slightly evolved a type star , and suggest that the system is rapidly evolving into a supersoft x ray source .
patat ( 2011 ) sees , in the variable sodium lines of some sne ia , a possible connection with recurrent novae .
recently , soraisam & gilfanov ( 2014 ) have compared the nova statistics for m31 with the sne ia rates .
they find that significant mass accumulation , in the unstable burning regime , is only possible for wds with masses below 1.25 @xmath0 .
more massive wds do not significantly accumulate mass .
thus , the final stage of mass growth can not occur at low mass accretion rates , when the burning is unstable .
therefore , to be sne ia progenitor candidates , the systems should go into the stable burning regime in the final phases .
systems consisting of a mass accreting white dwarf and a roche lobe filling , more massive , slightly evolved main sequence or subgiant star , steadily burning h , should appear as luminous supersoft x ray sources ( see section 2 ) . with varying mass accretion rates , however , they can also burn h unstably , at times , and then appear as recurrent novae of the u sco type .
nomoto et al . ( 2002 ) ( see also hachisu et al .
1999 ) propose an scenario in which a c+o white dwarf is formed from a red giant star with a helium core of @xmath40 .
following a first common
envelope episode , a helium star results and then evolves to form a c+o white dwarf of @xmath41 .
a part of the helium envelope would have been transferred to the main sequence companion .
the white dwarf would thus accrete and burn a mixture of h and helium . depending on the mass accretion rate ,
a wind might be blown from the surface of the white dwarf .
it should not be optically thick enough to absorb all the x ray emission , but it could , however , absorb a part of the soft x rays ( hachisu , kato & nomoto 2010 ; see next section ) .
it will be intersting to see whether variable circumstellar material would be observed in this scenario .
the two different channels to sn ia explosions , the single degenerate path and the double degenerate one , lead to very different predictions for the x ray emission ( gilfanov & bogdn 2010 ) . whereas no strong x ray emission is expected , prior to explosion , in the merger scenario , in the single degenerate scenario the white dwarf that accretes mass from a non degenerate companion becomes a source of x
rays for about 10@xmath42 yr before the explosion .
if the growth in mass of the white dwarf is due to accretion of hydrogen , followed by steady burning of hydrogen into helium , one expects a thermonuclear luminosity @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the energy per unit mass released by hydrogen burning , @xmath45 is the hydrogen mass fraction in the accreted material , and @xmath46 is the mass accretion rate . for standard values .
@xmath47 erg s@xmath48 , which is more than one order of magnitude larger than the gravitational energy released by accretion , @xmath49 ( @xmath50 and @xmath51 being the mass and radius of the white dwarf ) . that sustains a surface temperature of the white dwarf : @xmath52 such sources are observed in the milky way and nearby galaxies , and they are known ( see section 2.2 ) as supersoft sources ( van den heuvel et al .
1992 ; kahabka & van den heuvel 1997 ) .
gilfanov & bogdn ( 2010 ) report that the observed x ray flux from six nearby elliptical galaxies and galaxy bulges is a factor @xmath93050 less than predicted by the accretion scenario , based upon an estimate of the supernova rate .
they conclude that no more than @xmath9 5% of type ia supernovae in early type galaxies can be produced by white dwarfs accreting hydrogen in binary systems .
hachisu , kato & nomoto ( 2010 ) , however , suggest that there is , in fact , no inconsistency , since symbiotic supersoft sources have fluxes @xmath53 erg s@xmath48 in the 0.30.7 kev range .
there is also uncertainty in theoretically deriving the x ray luminosity of the supersoft sources , due to the still rough atmosphere models of mass accreting wds and to the neglect of absorption of the soft x
rays by the cool wind material from the companion star . on the other hand ,
x ray emission can inform us about the circumstellar medium around the sne ia ( badenes et al .
2007 ) . in that work ,
the authors disfavor optically thick accretion winds from the wd surface .
such winds would produce large cavities in the interstellar medium ( ism ) .
the fundamental properties of the seven supernova remnants ( snrs ) of type ia of their sample ( sn 1885 , kepler , tycho , sn 1006 , 0509 - 67.5 , 0519 - 69.0 , and n103b ) are incompatible with snr models expanding inside such cavities . in general , the search for x ray emission at the time of the supernova outburst has also provided probes of the circumstellar medium , which so far is considered to be of low density ( hughes et al .
recently , rusell & immler ( 2012 ) have examined 53 sne ia observed with the _ swift _ x ray telescope , and their upper limit to the x - ray emission gives further evidence that the companion stars in sne ia are neither massive nor evolved ( post main sequence ) , due to the corresponding limit on wind mass loss rate inferred .
they can not rule out , instead , main sequence star companions , with mass loss rates @xmath54 .
a double white dwarf system is also permitted , due to the lack of circumstellar interaction and hence lack of x
rays there .
the tightest constraint on the progenitor of a sn ia , coming from x ray emission , is that for sn 2011fe ( horesh et al .
2012 ; margutti et al . 2012 ) .
the x ray observations yield an upper limit 2@xmath5510@xmath56 m@xmath7 yr@xmath48 to the mass outflow ( assuming a wind velocity @xmath57 = 100 km s@xmath48 ) . as we have seen in section 2 , accretion at a rate @xmath9 10@xmath58 m@xmath7 yr@xmath48
is thought to be necessary for stable accretion and nuclear burning on the surface of a white dwarf ( nomoto 1982 ) .
supersoft sources can achieve those rates ( kahabka & van den heuvel 1997 ) , although the rates can also be either lower or higher , in these sources .
horesh et al .
( 2012 ) analyse the models of interaction of the wind with the circumstellar material and conclude that the data from sn 2011fe can rule out a symbiotic system , but not a main sequence or subgiant mass donor .
the same conclusion is reached from their analysis of the radio emission ( see next section ) .
margutti et al .
( 2012 ) also discard symbiotic systems , as well as roche lobe overflowing subgiants and main sequence secondary stars if @xmath59 1% of the transferred mass is lost at the lagrangian points .
the nearby sn 2014j has provided a new opportunity to test the presence of x - ray emission from the pre explosion x ray images ( nielsen et al .
according to these authors , the upper limits from the _ chandra _ x ray observatory do exclude a classical super soft source as the progenitor . near the chandrasekhar mass , the effective temperature corresponding to the stable nuclear burning on the wd surface exceeds 100 ev .
for this temperature , the 3@xmath60 upper limit on the bolometric luminosity is @xmath61 , assuming a column density of hydrogen @xmath62 and a black body spectrum . that confidently excludes a classical super soft source during the final stages of the mass accumulation by the progenitor . due to the large absorption ,
the _ chandra _ upper limits are less constraining at lower temperatures .
they do not exclude , therefore , less conventional progenitors , e.g. a wd enshrouded in an optically thick envelope or wind .
deep x ray observations of the post explosion environment ( margutti et al .
2014 ) now rule out single degenerate progenitors with steady mass loss until the time of the explosion ( the maximum mass spilled by the system should be @xmath63 1% ) , and do only allow recurrent novae with a recurrence time @xmath15 300 yrs , stars where the mass loss ceases before the explosion , or double wd systems . from a different angle ,
there have been , from the start , great expectations to detect hard x ray and @xmath64ray photons from sn 2014j ( isern et al .
2013 ; the & burrows 2014 ) , since the supernova was close enough to be detected by _
integral _ and _ nustar_. it has , indeed , been detected by _ integral _ ( churazov et al .
the line flux suggests that 0.62 @xmath39 0.13 @xmath0 of radioactive @xmath8ni have been synthesized in the core .
the mass of the ejecta ( from the continuum emission ) would be @xmath9 1.4 @xmath0 and composed of roughly equal fractions of iron group and intermediate mass elements .
there is thus agreement with the model of the explosion of a chandrasekhar mass wd .
diehl et al . ( 2014 ) find that about 0.06 m@xmath7 of @xmath8ni should be at the outskirts of the ejecta .
this has suggested that he accreted by the white dwarf could have exploded in the external layers and triggered the central ignition .
the lack of radio emission from type ia supernovae has been useful in discarding one type of single degenerate path as a major contributor : sne ia from symbiotic systems . in symbiotic systems , the white dwarf accretes mass from the wind of a giant or agb companion .
the wind accretion should produce radio emission when the sn ejecta interact with the circumstellar environment created by such systems .
panagia et al .
( 2006 ) set upper limits on mass loss rates of @xmath9 10@xmath58 m@xmath7 yr@xmath48 .
hancock et al ( 2011 ) suggest upper limits , to the average mass loss rate of the companion by stellar wind , of @xmath65 .
these authors say that such limit is inconsistent with sne ia in which the accretion comes from intermediate or high mass companions . instead
, a main sequence star having fast winds ( @xmath66 10 km @xmath48 ) could remain undetected , even with much higher mass loss rates .
the nearby supernova sn 2011fe has made possible the most sensitive radio study of a sn ia made up to now ( chomiuk et al .
the data set direct constraints to the density of the surrounding medium at radii @xmath67 cm , that implying an upper limit on the mass loss rate from the progenitor system of @xmath68 ( assuming a wind speed of 100 km s@xmath48 ) , or expansion inside a uniform csm with density @xmath69 6 @xmath70 .
drawing from the observed properties of non conservative mass transfer in accreting white dwarfs , they use the limits on the density of the circumstellar environment to exclude a good fraction of the parameter space of possible progenitor systems of sn 2011fe .
a symbiotic progenitor system can be ruled out , as well as any other system characterized by a high mass transfer rate onto the white dwarf which could give rise to optically thick accretion winds . assuming that a small fraction , @xmath9 1% of the mass transferred , is lost from the progenitor system
, they can also eliminate much of the parameter space occupied by potential progenitors such as recurrent novae or , alternatively , progenitors undergoing stable nuclear burning .
they eliminate , therefore , for sn 2011fe , a large fraction of the parameter space associated with popular single degenerate progenitor models , leaving only a limited region , mostly inhabited by some double degenerate systems , as well as by exotic single degenerates in which a sufficient time delay takes place between mass accretion and sn explosion .
the even closer sn 2014j has also been observed in radio with the vla , without any detection ( chandler & marvil 2014 ) .
this points out to a surrounding medium of low density as well .
it has been possible to put constraints on the progenitors from pre explosion images in other galaxies .
this endeavour has been of particular interest for sn 2011fe , since it exploded in the galaxy m101 , at 6.4 mpc only .
another nine sne ia with preexisting _ hst _ data on their host galaxies have also been close enough ( within 25 mpc ) to search for the progenitors .
it has only been possible to set upper limits which rule out normal stars with initial masses larger than 6 m@xmath7 at the tip of the agb branch , young post agb stars with initial masses larger than 4 m@xmath7 , and post red giant stars with initial masses above 9 m@xmath7 ( li et al .
2011a ) .
the case of sn 2011fe arose great expectations , since the sn was much closer than in previous occasions .
there was , however , no object seen at the location of the supernova in pre explosion images , down to magnitude 27.4 ( in the acs / f435w band ) ( li et al .
the conclusion of the analysis is that , for sn 2011fe , the red giant progenitor is excluded , while a subgiant or a main sequence companion star still are possible progenitors , from the imaging approach .
very recently , the nearby supernova sn 2014j in m82 has been tested in the same way .
this supernova is only at 3.5 mpc .
rosa , greggio & botticella ( 2014 ) have analyzed deep archival _
wfc3/ir images of m82 in the f110w and f160w filters , taken in jan .
2010 , and used them in an attempt to identify a progenitor for the sn , by registering the _ hst _ images with images of the sn taken on jan .
as in the sn 2011fe case , they can again exclude a red giant companion .
the limits are consistent with the companion being ( if not another wd ) a subgiant or a main sequence star .
goobar et al ( 2014 ) have also explored the _ hst _ images of the explosion region .
the observational limits , however are not as constraining here as in the case of sn 2011fe .
cm ( green lines ) ; a 6 m@xmath7 ms companion at @xmath71 cm ( blue lines ) ; a 2 m@xmath7 ms companion at @xmath72 cm ( red lines ) , and the lack of companion ( black lines ) . ( courtesy of dan kasen . aas . reproduced with permission ) . ]
according to kasen ( 2010 ) , the impact of the supernova debris on the companion produces a bright x ray ( 0.12 kev ) burst lasting from minutes to hours .
the diffusion of this x ray emission gives rise to a longer lasting optical / uv emisson which exceeds the radioactively powered emission from the supernova for the first few days after the explosion .
this effect can be seen in figure 4 .
the signatures are prominent for viewing angles looking down upon the shocked region , which should be about a 10% of the times .
kasen ( 2010 ) concludes that the current optical and uv data do effectively constrain the red giant companion channel , disfavoring it .
zheng et al . ( 2014 ) ( see their figure 3 ) , have presented very early light
curve data from sn 2014j . when comparing them with the predictions of kasen ( 2010 ) , the non companion case appears favored .
high z searches might provide the tightest constraint on the sn progenitors .
goldhaber et al . ( 2001 ) show , in their figure 1 , the light curves of 35 high z sne ia found by the _
supernova cosmology project ( scp)_. these data , as well as more recent ones ( conley et al . 2006 ; hayden et al .
2010 ; bianco et al .
2012 ) do not show any evidence for a companion in the early light curves of high z sne ia samples .
hayden et al .
( 2010 ) , from a simulation of the shock interaction with a companion , rule stars with masses larger that 6 m@xmath7 and also disfavour red giant companions .
another method to identify the progenitors of the sne ia was proposed by ruiz lapuente ( 1997 ) : to inspect the stars within the innermost regions of the galactic sne ia remnants in search of the mass donor star ( to either find it or to show its absence ) , in the area where it should still remain after the explosion , moving with a peculiar velocity gained from the orbital velocity in the binary system before the explosion .
a given star , to be candidate to donor in a sn ia explosion , should be at the distance of the remnant , moving with enhanced velocity , and maybe also show signs of contamination by the iron peak rich part of the supernova ejecta .
a subgiant named tycho g was found to be a likely candidate companion for sn 1572 ( ruiz lapuente et al .
2004 ) , since it is close to centre of the snr , at a distance compatible with that of the remnant , and it is in a region where stars follow the rotational pattern of the galaxy , but it has a radial velocity well above the 20 to 40 km s@xmath48 , typical at the distance of sn 1572
. it also has a high proper motion . a chemical analysis of the star showed enhancement of ni in the surface ( gonzlez hernndez et al .
2009 ) , suggesting contamination by the supernova ejecta . that was disputed by kerzendorf et al .
( 2009 , 2013 ) , who argued that all those characteristics might just correspond to a chance interloper .
based on greatly improved proper motion measurements and a more refined chemical analysis , bedin et al .
( 2014 ) , however , have shown that the probability of having found such an interloper at random is extremely low .
schaefer & pagnotta ( 2012 ) have looked as well for a companion star in a snr of the lmc ( snr 050967.5 ) and found no star that could have been the mass donor in the progenitor system .
their result points to the supernova having resulted from merging of two white dwarfs .
in addition , edwards , pagnotta & schaefer ( 2012 ) have examined the innermost area of the remnant snr 051969.0 , also in the lmc , and eliminated red giants , subgiants , and he stars as possible companions of the sn .
gonzlez hernndez et al . ( 2012 ) ( see also kerzendorf et al .
2012 ) have inspected the remnant of the galactic sn 1006 , determining distances and chemical abundances for all candidate stars within the innermost 27% of the area of the remnant .
the lack of detection of any viable candidate star rules out red giant and subgiant stars , as well as any star brighter than m@xmath73 @xmath9 + 4.9 ( approximately equal , or slightly less than the solar luminosity ) .
the key point , from the theoretical point of view , is that all groups that have simulated the impact of the ejecta of a supernova on its companion star ( marietta , burrows & fryxell 2000 ; pakmor et al .
2008 ; pan , ricker & taam 2012a ; liu et al .
2012 , 2013 ) consistently find that the companion survives the explosion .
this important conclusion is the basis for the observational searches .
there has been debate on whether the surviving companion of a wd plus main sequence system , or a wd plus subgiant system , would show rapid rotation after the explosion ( gonzlez hernndez et al .
2009 ; kerzendorf et al .
2009 , 2013 ; bedin et al .
hydrodynamic simulations by pan , ricker & taam ( 2012a ) , for main sequence companions , show that they would lose about half of their initial angular momentum , their rotational velocity dropping to a quarter of the original rotational velocity . the simulations by liu et al .
( 2012 ) , also for a companion on the main sequence , equally show that its rotational velocity can be significantly reduced by the effects of the impact of the sn ejecta , falling to a 32%14% of its pre explosion value , due to remotion of 55%89% of the initial angular momentum , taken away by the material stripped during the interaction with the supernova ejecta .
it is easy to see ( fig . 1 of marietta , burrows & fryxell 2000 , for instance )
that , in the case of a 1.1 m@xmath7 subgiant , remotion of @xmath74 by the impact of the ejecta means reducing the radius of the star , immediately after the impact , to about 1/3 of its previous value only ( in front of about 1/2 in the main sequence case ) , so the drop in rotational veocity must be correspondly larger .
in their simulations , pan , ricker & taam ( 2012a ) find that the contamination with ni in the companion star , from the passage of the sn ejecta , is of @xmath75 , for a main sequence star , and of @xmath76 for a red giant .
another point concerns the luminosity to be expected , for the surviving companions of recent sne ia .
podsiadlowski ( 2003 ) found that , in the case of a subgiant , the star , 10@xmath7710@xmath78 yr after the explosion , might be either significantly overluminous or underluminous , that depending on the amount of heating and the amount of mass stripped , as well as on the previous binary mass transfer .
more recently , shappee , kochanek & stanek ( 2013 ) have claimed that , in the case of a main sequence companion ( and maximizing the heating ) , the object should remain significantly overluminous for the above time lapse , but the more realistic simulations of pan , ricker & taam ( 2012b ) , also for a main sequence star , predict luminosities much closer to that of tycho g , @xmath79 yr after the explosion . in the case of a subgiant , a larger fraction of the material
should be directly stripped by the shock wave generated by the impact of the sn ejecta , and there should be less heating of the fraction of the envelope that remains bound . in all the preceding considerations , it has been implicitly assumed that there is no significant delay between the accretion phase that brings the white dwarf to the chandrasekhar mass and the sn explosion .
that has been questioned by di stefano , voss & claeys ( 2011 ) , who propose a model in which the c+o white dwarf , spun up by accretion of matter and angular momentum , is able to sustain a mass above the chandrasekhar mass , and only reaches the conditions for explosive c burning when it has lost enough angular momentum , on a time scale that may be long enough to allow the companion star to evolve to the white dwarf stage . also , overcoming the chandrasekhar
mass limit would allow exhaustion of the envelope of the companion star , only its compact core remaining at the end of the mass transfer phase . based on that
, di stefano & kilic ( 2012 ) argue that the lack of evidence of ex companion star in the above mentioned snr 050967.5 does not mean that such companion does not exist , since it could have become a c+o or a he white dwarf by the time of the explosion .
the problem of the time scale of spin down of the primary white dwarf has been very recently addressed by meng & podsiadlowski ( 2013 ) , who obtain an upper limit of a few 10@xmath42 yr .
such times would still allow a companion star to become dimmer than the upper limit set by schaefer & pagnotta ( 2012 ) , according to di stefano and kilic ( 2012 ) .
another remnant being now studied is the kepler snr ( sn 1604 ) . from the lack of bright stars in the field , kerzendorf et al .
( 2014 ) have ruled out red giants as possible companions of sn 1604 .
vlt observations with flames of the stars in more than 20% of the inner core of the snr have now been granted ( ruiz lapuente et al .
. it will be very interesting to see what high resolution spectra reveal .
other fairly symmetrical galactic snr are planned to undergo a similar scrutiny
another approach to dilucidate the progenitors of sne ia is to reconstruct the orbit of systems containing a wd . along these lines ,
the tight binary system cd30@xmath80 11223 has been found to consist of a c+o white dwarf plus a hot helium star ( geier et al .
the system turns out to be a progenitor candidate for the double detonation sn ia scenario ( see section 2.2 ) .
wang & han ( 2012 ) have studied this kind of possible progenitor system ( see also wang et al .
a c+o white dwarf is first formed , from the initially more massive star , and the system then is in a close orbit .
the mass donor later reaches roche lobe overflow and becomes a he star , but evolves , after exhaustion of the central he , to the red giant stage .
the system thus becomes a c+o wd plus a he red giant .
the mechanism can also work with the he star still staying in the main sequence phase .
fink , hillebrandt & rpke ( 2007 ) reproduce , in a 3d simulation of a double detonation , these explosions .
they find that the he detonation in a shell succesfully gives rise to a second detonation in the c+o core . in the outcome ,
@xmath8ni masses about 0.400.45 m@xmath7 are produced , with rapidly expanding @xmath8ni in the outer layers .
they note , however , the lack of observations of this type of explosion ( sn 1991 t could resemble it , but the core contained 0.8 m@xmath7 of @xmath8ni ) . a c+o wd plus a he donor could , instead , be the progenitor of the so called `` type .ia '' supernovae .
we do not include these in our physical diagram for sne ia , however , since their likely he features at maximum ( kasiwal et al .
2010 , and references therein ) rule them out as possible sne ia ( we only consider , in this paper , the types of explosions , either total or partial , that by their features at maximum can be regarded to be such ) .
from the many systematic searches made at various redshifts , it has been possible to identify sne ia that fall well away from the phillips ( 1993 , 1999 ) relationship between the peak luminosiy and the rate of decline of the light curve .
such relationship was traditionally related to the amount of @xmath8ni synthesized in chandrasekhar
mass models , since its variation not only correlated with that of the maximum luminosity , but it also produced opacity variation in the envelope of the sn , which resulted in slower decline rates of the light curve for larger ni masses .
in such view ( hflich & khokhlov 1996 ; pinto & eastman 2000 ; bravo et al .
2009 ) , only variations among chandrasekhar
mass wd explosions were the cause of the relationship .
a new proposal , which completely changes the explanation , is to assume that the phillips relationship results from variation in the viewing angle of the family of detonations of merging sub chandrasekhar explosions ( moll et al . 2013 ) . that marks a new turn in the search for the physical basis of a relationship that is crucial for cosmology , and it thus calls for further investigation . since this is relevant for cosmology , we mention that the method of determination of h@xmath81 using nebular spectra of sne ia ( ruiz lapuente 1996 ) favored a value of 68 km @xmath39 7 ( stat ) @xmath39 1 ( updated systematic error ) km s@xmath48 mpc@xmath48 , in good agreement with the latest results from the _ planck _ satellite ( ade et al . 2013 ) . the light curves of sne ia ( hflich & khokhlov 1996 ) favored 67 @xmath39 9 km s@xmath48 mpc@xmath48 ( also in agreement with _ planck _ ) .
riess et al . ( 2011 ) , within the _
program , had found @xmath82 km s@xmath48 mpc@xmath48 , in tension with the _ planck _ result ( but see , more recently , riees 2014 ) .
a few discoveries of highly luminous ( @xmath83 -20.4 ) sne ia suggest the existence of super chandrasekhar mass explosions ( howell et al .
these supernovae show very slowly evolving si ii @xmath31 6355 absorption velocity , and they can also show a plateau in their blue light curve ( scalzo et .
al . 2012 ) . the very large mass of @xmath8ni needed to explain those events can plausibly be produced by the collision of two white dwarfs ( raskin et al . 2010 ) or by accretion on a rapidly rotating c+o wd . the _ sn factory _ has tried to evaluate the percentage of super chandrasekhar sne ia , and they suggest about 2% ( aldering 2011 ) .
a super chandraskhar wd can be formed if it is supported by rapid rotation ( hachisu 1986 ; see also section 10 ) , and the rotating wd is more massive than a non rotating wd with the same central density ( yoon & langer 2005 ) . for a given central density ,
the density profile is shallower for those more massive wds , and therefore the mass contained within the density range for @xmath8ni production is larger .
also , for the same central density , a flame produces more @xmath8ni due to less pre expansion ahead of the propagating flame . in the case of merging
, one can have tamped detonations ( howell et al .
those tamped detonations in rapidly rotating wds can synthesize amounts of @xmath8ni as high as 1.62 m@xmath7 .
taubenberger et al .
( 2011 ) have estimated that the total mass of the wd , in the case of sn 2009dc , was @xmath84 , and the ejected @xmath8ni mass was @xmath85 .
the fact that some of those events show c ii absorption features in their spectra reinforces the hypothesis that they come from mergings of two wds . on the other hand , from modeling ( hillebrandt et al .
2013 ) of the violent wd merger scenario ( pakmor et al .
2010 ) , it seems unlikely that these supernovae would come from violent double degenerate mergers .
the @xmath8ni mass produced only depends on the mass of the primary wd , there . since exploding c+o wds , in the violent merger model , usually have masses well below 1.3 m@xmath7 ( ruiter et al .
2013 ) , that limits the amount of @xmath8ni produced in the explosion to @xmath86 only .
however , recent analyses of the nebular spectra of super chandrasekhar events ( taubenberger et al .
2013a ) , the case of sn 2009dc in particular , indicate that those outbursts can be explained by a merger of two massive c+o white dwarfs , producing @xmath9 1 m@xmath7 of @xmath8ni and @xmath9 2 m@xmath7 of ejecta .
that would come from the explosion of a chandrasekhar mass white dwarf , enshrouded by 0.60.7 m@xmath7 of c+o rich material .
6355 feature typical of the sne ia class , as well as prominent fe iii absorption features at @xmath34 4200 and 4900 . in panel b , a comparison of the spectrum of sn 2002ic at the epoch + 6 days from maximum with a spectrum of sn 1991 t , obtained at the + 4 days epoch , shows similarity , except for the h@xmath25 emission , which is not present in sn 1991 t .
( courtesy of mario hamuy .
nature publishing group . reproduced with permission ) . ]
there is a fraction of supernovae which show narrow hydrogen emission lines .
they were first noticed by hamuy et al .
( 2003 ) , in sn 2002ic ( see figure 3 ) .
such sn have been labelled in various ways , until recently being dubbed sne ia
cms ( silverman et al . 2013 ) .
the existence of the sn ia
csm class of objects seems to indicate that at least some sne ia do arise from the sd channel , since a h rich csm can form during the evolution of sd systems .
hamuy et al .
( 2003 ) suggest that sn 2002ic could have arised from a binary system containing a c+o white dwarf plus a massive ( 37 @xmath0 ) agb star , where the total mass loss in h can reach a few solar masses , since their analysis of the narrow component of h@xmath25 implies a high mass loss rate of @xmath87 ( see figure 5 ) .
the accreted mass would come from the wind of the agb star , partially captured by the wd . despite the mass loss rate being so high ,
however , the supernova has not been detected in radio .
dilday et al ( 2012 ) find that the supernova ptf11kx is of type ia , and suggest a symbiotic nova progenitor ( see , however , soker et al .
its late time spectrum confirms that it is , indeed , a sn ia .
a time series of high resolution spectra of this supernova reveals a complex circumstellar environment , with multiple shells similar to those ejected by nova rs ophiuchi .
dilday et al .
( 2012 ) found , from the _ palomar transient factory ( ptf ) _ , that the sn ia
csm are about 0.11% of all sne ia .
this is more or less consistent with the theoretical expectations for the fraction of sne ia from the symbiotic progenitor channel : between 1 and 30% ( han et al .
2004 ; l et al . 2009 ) . concerning other typical characteristics , sne ia
csm have peak absolute magnitudes in the range 21.3 @xmath88 19 mag , with relatively long rise times of @xmath8940 days .
they do not emit neither in radio nor at x
ray wavelengths .
sn 1991bg came as a suprise , being a subluminous sn ia , one order of magnitude fainter than normal sne ia ( filippenko et al . 1992 ; leibundgut et al . 1993 ; ruiz lapuente et al .
the amount of @xmath8ni synthesized was only about 0.07 @xmath0 ( ruiz lapuente et al . 1993 ) .
it is clearly out of the phillips relation .
later , there were many more discoveries of this type , and one could start to think of a sn 1991bg class .
li et al . ( 2011b ) quantify this class as 15% of all sne ia .
pakmor et al .
( 2011 ) suggest that violent mergers of wds with a primary of 0.9 m@xmath7 reproduce very well the 1991bg like sn .
indeed , the simulated optical light curves fit well the data ( hillebrandt et al . 2013 ) .
very recently , the presence of [ o i ] @xmath346300 , 6364 emission in the nebular spectrum of sn 2010lp , suggesting that oxygen is distributed in a non spherical region close to the centre of the sn ejecta , has also been interpreted as the result of a violent merger ( taubenberger et al .
2013b ) .
these events do exhibit unusually strong ca features at nebular phases , while they look as spectroscopically normal sne ia at maximum .
their distribution within their host galaxies shows great similarity with that of the sne ia and indicate old progenitor systems ( lyman et al .
according to these authors , they are consistent with helium shell detonations on low
mass c+o white dwarfs . the objects display
low peak luminosities , fast photometric evolution , high ejecta velocities , strong ca emission lines , and they are located in the extreme outskirts of their host galaxies ( kasliwal et al .
; see figure 6 ) . foley et al .
( 2013 ) identify a new subclass of supernovae called type iax .
they have low maximum velocities ( 2000 @xmath90 8000 km @xmath48 ) , and typically low peak magnitudes ( 14.2 @xmath91 18.9 mag ) . in fact , this is the same family of sne ia identified by li et al . (
2003 ) and dubbed sn 2002cx like sne ia .
foley et al .
( 2013 ) find that this subclass comprises 31@xmath92% . of all sne ia .
white et al ( 2014 ) , however , reduce it to 5.6@xmath93 .
given the large uncertainty , in figure 9 we have plotted an average of the two estimates .
those sn2002cx ( or sn iax ) events exhibit iron rich spectra at early phases , like sn 1991 t ( see ruiz lapuente et al .
1991 for the iron rich spectra of sn 1991 t ) , a luminosity as low as events like sn 1991bg ( i.e. 2 mag below normal type ia ) , and expansion velocities roughly half those of normal sne ia .
this subclass has a small @xmath8ni production , as seen at late phases .
they move fast into the nebular phase , that giving evidence of the small total mass ejected .
a survey of the models able to produce such kind of explosions suggests objects made of a 0.6 m@xmath7 c+o wd , with a layer of @xmath94 of he on top , which undergo a he detonation ( li et al .
2003 ; wang , justham & han 2013 ) .
the origin of the subclass is still under debate , however , because it is quite inhomogeneous ( narayan et al .
white et al . ( 2014 ) divide it in two subclasses : the `` sn 2002cx like '' and the `` sn 2002 es like '' sne ia .
the former tend to appear in later type or more irregular hosts , have more varied and generically dimmer luminosities , longer rise times , and they lack a ti ii through in their spectra , when compared to the latter .
the frequency of sn 2002cx events , as compared with normal and sn 1991bg like events , has also been estimated by perets et al .
variants of sn 2002cx events are seen in faint supernovae such as sn 2008 ha ( foley et al . 2009 , 2010 ) .
this last supernova is the faintest member of its subclass . its late
time photometry is consistent with the production of just a few times 10@xmath95 m@xmath7 of @xmath8ni , similar to the estimates from the early light curve ( foley et al .
the small ejecta and @xmath8ni masses are consistent with a failed deflagration of a wd , that did not disrupt the progenitor ( jordan et al . 2012 ; kromer et al .
there is still another model , proposed earlier , for this particular type iax supernova : it is the fallback of a core
collapse supernova ( moriya et al . 2010 ) .
this model , then , does not treat sn 2008 ha as a thermonuclear supernova , but as the collapse of a c+o star of 13m@xmath7 ( model 13co2 in their paper ) . the boundary between the fallback region and the ejecta is determined by whether the velocity of the region exceeds the escape velocity or not .
lyman et al . ( 2013 ) , argue that the host environments and morphologies point to a generally younger population for this subclass .
a model which synthesizes 0.003 m@xmath96 of @xmath8ni and ejects 0.074 m@xmath7 of material seems to reproduce the spectra and light curve of sn 2008 ha .
foley et al .
( 2013 ) find the environment of some of these type iax sn to be typical of old progenitor systems .
they discuss that the most significant reason for their classification of sn 2008 ha as a sn ia is the presence of signatures of the products of thermonuclear processing of c+o , in particular that of sulfur lines , with an intensity that is only typical of sne ia ( foley et al .
2009 ) . very recently ,
foley et al .
( 2014 ) report the possible detection of the stellar donor of sn 2008 ha in images from the _
different possibilities for the progenitor remain open , though the age is constrained to be @xmath15 80 myr .
thus , while type iax sne , fall well below the phillips relation , some of these events should be regarded as subluminous sne ia , which might be linked either to he detonations in a shell or to failed deflagrations
. others might originate in core
the diversity of the events ( see figures 7 , 8) suggests that several mechanisms take place within the sample of sne iax , explaining the properties of the different observed events .
@xmath97 @xmath98 diagram using the cfa3 sample of 185 sne ia ( hicken et al .
the solid line is the phillips et al .
( 1999 ) relation .
the fundamental relation developed by phillips ( 1993 ) was modified in phillips et al .
the figure is adapted from hillebrandt et al .
( 2013 ) , and we use the same sources for superluminous and 91bg - like subluminous events . the diversity of type iax is taken from narayan et al .
the area of the ca rich transients is marked on the diagram , following kasliwal et al .
the data on the luminous fast evolving sne ia come from perets et al .
the proportion in nature of the different events is tentatively given in figure 9 . ]
perets et al .
( 2010 , 2011a , b ; poznanski et al .
2010 ) have identified a new subclass of sne ia : rapidly declining sne , such as sn 1885a , 1939c , and 2002bj , that , unlike the iax subtype , are not faint .
sn 2002bj had a short rise time ( @xmath15 7 days ) and @xmath99 , which is a post maximum decline much faster than that of the bulk of sne ia ( @xmath100 ) , and even faster than that of sn 1991bg like events ( @xmath101 ) .
however , it reached a peak magnitude @xmath102 , which is not faint .
sn 1885a and 1939c arose in old environments , which points to also old wds as their progenitors .
in the case of sn 2002bj , the ejected mass appears to be low ( @xmath103 ) , that being consistent with the estimated mass of the sn 1885a remnant .
perets et al .
( 2011b ) evaluate the frequency of the sne in this subclass as being at least 12% of the global sne ia rate .
shell detonations have been suggested as the explosion mechanism ( perets et al .
2010 , 2011a ; poznanski et al .
2010 ) , but its consistency with the observations still remains an open question .
it has been presented in section 6 that a significant fraction ( 18% ) of the population of sne ia show time
variable na i d features , other features being variable as well .
those supernovae are normal sne ia , as the ones that we use for cosmology .
their characteristics point to recurrent novae ( patat 2011 ) or to systems with significant outflows prior to explosion , as progenitors .
another chunk of the normal ( cosmological ) sne ia likely comes from double degenerate systems ( @xmath9 30% ) , as suggested by the unburnt c and o in the outermost layers ( see section 4 ) .
one might ask : how can cosmological sne ia have two different origins ?
the reason is that in both cases the whole c+o wd is burnt , giving rise to the light curve whose variation in peak magnitude is due to the amount of @xmath8ni synthesized in the explosion , and the line opacity of those events modulates their rate of decline to give @xmath104 - 0.663[\delta m_{\rm 15}(b ) -1.1]^{2}$ ] , where @xmath105 is the absolute blue magnitude , at maximum , of a sn ia with @xmath106 ( phillips et al .
this relation extends the possibility of using sne ia with @xmath107 high , since they are seen to make a continuum with the slower ones .
scalzo et al .
( 2014 ) derive , from the bolometric light curves of a sample of sne ia obtained by the _ snfactory _ , a range of both ejected masses and @xmath8ni masses .
ejected masses would range , for normal sne ia , from 0.9 m@xmath7 for the fastest decliners to 1.4 m@xmath7 for the slowest ones .
the 91t like sne ia eject masses in excess of 1.4 m@xmath7 and produce @xmath8ni masses around 0.81.0 m@xmath7 .
the middle part of the sample is occupied by sne ia with chandrasekhar mass ejecta and producing 0.6 m@xmath7 of @xmath8ni ( as derived from the nebular spectra of sne ia in r96 ) .
it has been argued ( domnguez et al .
2001 ) that evolutionary effects in the maximum
rate of decline relation could make difficult the use of sn ia at very high @xmath108 .
branch et al .
( 2001 ) propose an strategy to test evolutionary effects , in the prospect of a space mission devoted to the study of dark energy by means of high@xmath108 sne ia .
their proposed plan , now completed for large samples of nearby sne ia , is to study all possible evolutionary effects in sne ia samples at low z. such effects have now been evaluated from big samples , and it has been shown that they do not to interfere with our understanding of dark energy ( ruiz lapuente 2007 ) .
the sne ia at @xmath108 = 1.914 ( jones et al .
2013 ) , at @xmath108 = 1.71 ( rubin et al . 2013 ) , and at @xmath108= 1.55 ( rodney et al . 2012 ) look normal and show no evolutionary effects .
concerning cosmology , it has been seen that these highest - z observations do suppport the @xmath109 model of our universe ( see also conley et al .
2011 ; sullivan et al .
2011 ) .
we have learned a lot about normal ( cosmological ) sne ia from the two recent nearby sne ia : sn 2011fe and sn 2014j . for the first one , the _ hst _ deep images have allowed to discard many single degenerate scenarios ( li et al .
2011a , b ) .
sn 2011fe showed unburnt c and o in the very early spectra .
one possible explanation is that it came from a double degenerate progenitor ( see nomoto , kamiya & nakasato 2013 for an alternative explanation of the unburnt c and o material ) . for sn 2014j ,
it has been possible to rule out red giants as the companions of the c+o wd that exploded .
it continues to be safe to exclude sn 1991bg events , sne iax , sne ia - csm and super chandrasekhar sne ia ( ca rich transients as well ) from the cosmological samples , as they lay outside the brightness
decline rate relation used in cosmology .
they might have been responsible ( in particular sne iax and sn 1991bg events ) for some outliers present in the early samples ( such as the first _
_ sne ia ) , for which we lacked explanation at those epochs of the cosmologically motivated sne ia searches .
dust absorption in the host galaxy is an important source of systematic error in sn cosmology .
a way to minimize its effect on distance determinations is to measure the properties of the sn in the rest frame infrared .
it has been demonstrated ( wood vasey et al .
2008 ; kirshner 2010 ; barone nugent et al .
2012 ) that sne ia are better standard candles in the infrared than in the optical wavelengths .
the infrared sample of nearby sne ia is steadily growing , now ( friedman et al . 2014 ) .
as we have seen , the last decade has brought considerable progress in the still far from closed search for the progenitor systems of the sne ia .
a new picture has emerged , where single degenerate progenitors would now make a much narrower channel than it was thought to be in the 90 s .
the highlight , here , is that the companions to sne ia , at the time of explosion , are very unlikely to be red giants or supergiants , as well as massive main sequence or subgiant stars .
this result comes from searches for companion stars in sne ia remnants , in our galaxy and in the lmc ; by looking at pre explosion images of nearby sne ia , like sn 2011fe ; from x ray surveys of sne ia made with _ swift _ ; from radio observations of nearby sne ia , and from confrontation of the early light curves of sne ia with theoretical predictions . on the other hand ,
the much expanded surveys for transients , at different wavelengths , have found from very dim explosions to overluminous outbursts .
multidimensional modeling of different types of thermonuclear explosions has reached a new level of realism , and they are confronted with observations uncovering the different layers of the exploding objects with unprecedented detail .
we still lack , however , the identification of a sne ia with the dismissal of some previously observed object . two different channels ( sd and dd ) leading to sn ia explosions still appear to be required , although the balance has now shifted towards the double degenerate channel , where violent mergings or violent collisions of white dwarfs appear as a promising mechanism .
the initial conditions leading to such collisions are still unclear , however . for subluminous sne ia of the sne iax type , or ca rich transients , edge
lit he detonations that might not disrupt the underlying c+o wd , or failed deflagrations in the outer shells , seem able to account for the observations and for the rates of the explosions .
from all the preceding , we can reach some tentative conclusions about the fraction of supernovae arising from different kinds of progenitor systems and their explosion mechanisms ( see figure 9 ) .
@xmath110 the supernovae that show unburnt carbon make 30% of the sne ia class . if we add to that the super chandrasekhar explosions ( 2@xmath30 ) , we can infer that around 32% of thermonuclear supernovae should arise from the merging of two white dwarfs . tamped detonations in rapidly rotating white dwarfs
may be the explosion mechanism , in the super chandrasekhar case , although mergings of massive white dwarfs could also account for these events .
@xmath110 between 31@xmath92 @xmath30 and 5.6@xmath93 of all sne ia do belong to the iax subtype , likely arising either from failed deflagrations or from surface detonations of low mass white dwarfs .
the large error bars come from the uncertainty on the selection effects that work against detection of subluminous events .
there are indications that this subclass of sne ia with low ejection velocities do , in fact , split into two subclasses .
further research in this are is needed .
@xmath110 there is a 15@xmath30 of sne ia of the 91bg type , which are tentatively associated with violent mergings of white dwarfs where the primary is of about 0.9 m@xmath7 .
detonation of the c+o mixture should then occur .
@xmath110 the fraction of explosions resulting from the accretion of hydrogen from a red giant star seems to be very low , as metioned before .
the sne coming from a symbiotic progenitor should only make 0.11@xmath30 of all sne ia .
@xmath110 about 12% of events have luminosities falling well in the middle of the bulk of sne ia , but they rise fast and do decline very fast after maximum ( the fraction migh be larger , due to selection effects ) .
their origin remains unclear .
@xmath110 the remaining fraction of sne ia , a 21 @xmath30 , could come from systems made of a c+o white dwarf plus a main sequence or subgiant star , and they could appear , before the explosion , as supersoft x ray sources or / and recurrent novae . in the sn of this and the former group ( as well as in those coming from non violent dd mergings ) ,
the explosion should start as a ( generally off centre ) deflagration , to become a detonation in reaching lower
density layers .
given the large sample of peculiar sne ia , it is worth obtaining spectral sequences , when using sn for cosmology .
such project would be made possible by dedicated space missions and by ground
based programs ( wood vasey 2010 ) .
i would like to thank gaston folatelli , mario hamuy , dan kasen , mansi kasliwal , gautham narayan , and josh simon , for their kind permissions to use their figures .
my thanks also go to hagai perets , lev yungelson , zhengwei liu , alexander tutukov , thomas tauris , enrique garca
berro , joe lyman , raffaella margutti , todd thompson , mickael rigault , markus kromer , dan kasen , boaz katz , mario hamuy , michael wood vasey , and marat gilfanov , for valuable comments , suggestions and criticisms to the first draft of this paper . the useful input from an anonymous referee
is also acknowledged .
this work has been supported by grant aya201236353 , from the ministerio de economa y competitividad of spain .
napiwotzki , r. , karl , c.a . , nelemans , g. , et al .
2007 , in _
european workshop on white dwarfs _ ,
asp conference series , 372 , ed .
r. napiwotzki & m.r .
burleigh ( astron
pacific , san francisco ) , p. 387
nomoto , k. , uenishi , t. , kobayashi , c. , umeda , h. , ohkubo , t. , hachisu , i. , & kato , m. 2002 , in _ from twilight to highlight : the physics of supernovae _
w. hillebrandt & b. leibundgut ( springer , berlin ) , p. 115 | although type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) are a major tool in cosmology and play a key role in the chemical evolution of galaxies , the nature of their progenitor systems ( apart from the fact that they must content at least one white dwarf , that explodes ) remains largely unknown . in the last decade ,
considerable efforts have been made , both observationally and theoretically , to solve this problem .
observations have , however , revealed a previously ususpected variety of events , ranging from very underluminous outbursts to clearly overluminous ones , and spanning a range well outside the peak luminosity decline rate of the light curve relationship , used to make calibrated candles of the sne ia . on the theoretical side ,
new explosion scenarios , such as violent mergings of pairs of white dwarfs , have been explored .
we review those recent developments , emphasizing the new observational findings , but also trying to tie them to the different scenarios and explosion mechanisms proposed thus far . |
the tangent space to an integral projective variety @xmath0 of dimension @xmath1 in a smooth point @xmath2 , named @xmath3 , is always of dimension @xmath1 .
it is no longer true for the osculating spaces .
for instance , as it was pointed out by togliatti in @xcite , the osculating space @xmath4 , in a general point @xmath2 , of the rational surface @xmath5 defined by @xmath6 is of projective dimension @xmath7 instead of @xmath8 .
indeed there is a non trivial linear relation between the partial derivatives of order @xmath9 of @xmath10 at @xmath2 that define @xmath4 .
this relation is usually called a _ laplace equation _ of order @xmath9 .
more generally , we will say that @xmath5 satisfies a laplace equation of order @xmath11 when its @xmath11-th osculating space @xmath12 in a general point @xmath13 is of dimension less than the expected one , that is @xmath14 .
the study of the surfaces satisfying a laplace equation was developed in the last century by togliatti @xcite and terracini @xcite .
togliatti @xcite gave a complete classification of the rational surfaces embedded by linear systems of plane cubics and satisfying a laplace equation of order two .
in the paper @xcite , perkinson gives a complete classification of smooth toric surfaces ( theorem 3.2 ) and threefolds ( theorem 3.5 ) embedded by a monomial linear system and satisfying a laplace equation of any order .
very recently miro - roig , mezzetti and ottaviani @xcite have established a nice link between rational varieties ( i.e. projections of veronese varieties ) satisfying a laplace equation and artinian graded rings @xmath15 such that the multiplication by a general linear form has not maximal rank in a degree @xmath16 . on the contrary , when the rank of the multiplication map is maximal in any degree , the ring is said to have the _ weak lefschetz property _
( briefly wlp ) .
the same type of problems arises when we consider the multiplication by powers @xmath17 ( @xmath18 ) of a general linear form @xmath19 .
indeed , if the rank of the multiplication map by @xmath17 is maximal for any @xmath20 and any degree , the ring is said to have the _ strong lefschetz property _ ( briefly slp ) .
+ these properties are so called after stanley s seminal work : the hard lefschetz theorem is used to prove that the ring @xmath21}{(x_0^{d_0},\ldots , x_n^{d_n})}$ ] has the slp ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.4 ) . from this example
one can ask if the artinian complete intersection rings have the wlp .
actually @xmath22}{(f_0,f_1,f_2)}$ ] has the wlp ( first proved in @xcite and then also in @xcite ) but it is still not known for more than three variables .
many other questions derive from this first example .
+ for more details about known results and some open problems we refer to @xcite .
let @xmath23 be an artinian ideal generated by the @xmath24 forms @xmath25 , all of the same degree @xmath26 , and @xmath27 be the _ syzygy bundle _ associated to @xmath28 and defined in the following way : @xmath29 for shortness we will denote @xmath30 and , forgetting the twist by @xmath26 , in all the rest of this text we call it the syzygy bundle . as in @xcite , many papers about the lefschetz properties involve the _ syzygy bundle_. indeed , in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.1 ) , brenner and kaid prove that the graded piece of degree @xmath31 of the artinian ring @xmath32}{(f_0,\ldots , f_r)}$ ] is @xmath33 . in [ @xcite , thm .
3.2 ] the authors characterize the failure of the wlp ( in degree @xmath34 , i.e. for the map @xmath35 ) when @xmath36 by the non injectivity of the restricted map @xmath37 on a general hyperplane @xmath19 .
let us say , in few words , what we are doing in this paper and how it is organized .
first of all we recall some definitions , basic facts and we propose a conjecture ( section [ s1 ] ) . in section [ s2 ] we extend to the slp the characterization of failure of the wlp given in @xcite
. then we translate the failure of the wlp and slp in terms of existence of special singular hypersurfaces ( section [ s3 ] ) .
it allows us to give an answer to three unsolved questions in @xcite . in section [ s4 ]
we construct examples of artinian rings failing the wlp and the slp by producing the appropriate singular hypersurfaces . in the last section
we relate the problem of slp at the range 2 to the topic of line arrangements ( section [ s5 ] ) .
let us now give more details about the different sections of this paper . in section [ s2 ] ,
more precisely in theorem [ p1 ] , we characterize the failure of the slp by the non maximality of the induced map on sections @xmath38 the geometric consequences of this link are explained in section [ s3 ] ( see theorem [ th1bis ] ) .
the non injectivity is translated in terms of the number of laplace equations and the non surjectivity is related , via apolarity , to the existence of special singular hypersurfaces
. then we give propositions [ pr54 - 1 ] , [ pr54 - 2 ] and [ pr54 - 3 ] that solve three problems posed in ( * ? ? ?
* problem 5.4 and conjecture 5.13 ) . in section [ s4 ]
we produce many examples of ideals ( monomial and non monomial ) that fail the wlp and the slp .
the failure of the wlp is studied for monomial ideals generated in degree @xmath7 on @xmath39 ( theorem [ th3 ] ) , in degree @xmath8 on @xmath39 ( proposition [ th4 ] ) , in degree @xmath7 on @xmath40 ( proposition [ d4 m ] ) ; the failure of the slp is studied for monomial ideals generated in degree @xmath7 ( proposition [ d4mslp ] ) ; finally , we propose a method to produce non monomial ideals that fail the slp at any range ( proposition [ nmslp ] ) . in the last section lefschetz properties and line arrangements
are linked .
the theory of line arrangements , more generally of hyperplane arrangements , is an old and deep subject that concerns combinatorics , topology and algebraic geometry .
one can say that it began with jakob steiner ( in the first volume of crelles s journal , 1826 ) who determined in how many regions a real plane is divided by a finite number of lines .
it is relevant also with sylvester - gallai s amazing problem .
hyperplane arrangements come back in a modern presentation in arnold s fundamental work @xcite on the cohomology ring of @xmath41 ( where @xmath42 is the union of the hyperplanes of the arrangement ) . for a large part of mathematicians working on arrangements
, it culminates today with the terao conjecture ( see the last section of this paper or directly @xcite ) .
this conjecture concerns particularly the derivation sheaf ( also called logarithmic sheaf ) associated to the arrangement . in this paper
we recall the conjecture . in proposition [ th5 ]
we prove that the failure of the slp at the range 2 of some ideals is equivalent to the unstability of the associated derivation sheaves .
thanks to the important literature on arrangements , we find artinian ideals that fail the slp .
for instance the coxeter arrangement , called b3 , gives an original ideal that fails the slp at the range 2 in a non trivial way ( see proposition [ b3 ] ) .
we finish by a reformulation of terao s conjecture in terms of slp .
the ground field is @xmath43 . + the dual @xmath44 of a vector space @xmath45 is denoted by @xmath46 . + the dimension of the vector space @xmath47 is denoted by @xmath48 where @xmath1 is clearly known in the context .
+ the vector space generated by the set @xmath49 is @xmath50 . + the join variety of @xmath11 projective varieties @xmath51 is denoted by @xmath52 ( see @xcite for the definition of join variety ) .
+ the fundamental points @xmath53 in @xmath54 are denoted by @xmath55 .
+ we often write in the same way a projective hyperplane and the linear form defining it ; we use in general the notation @xmath56 on @xmath54 and the notation @xmath57 on @xmath39 for hyperplanes .
+ the ideal sheaf of a point @xmath2 is @xmath58 .
let @xmath59=\bigoplus r_t$ ] be the graded polynomial ring in @xmath60 variables over @xmath43 .
the dimension of the vector space @xmath61 is @xmath48 .
+ let @xmath62 be a graded artinian algebra , defined by the ideal @xmath28 . note that @xmath63 is finite dimensional over @xmath43
. the artinian algebra @xmath63 ( or the artinian ideal @xmath28 ) has the weak lefschetz property ( wlp ) if there exists a linear form @xmath19 such that the homomorphism induced by the multiplication by @xmath19 , @xmath64 has maximal rank ( i.e. is injective or surjective ) for all @xmath16 .
the artinian algebra @xmath63 ( or the artinian ideal @xmath28 ) has the strong lefschetz property ( slp ) if there exists a linear form @xmath19 such that @xmath65 has maximal rank ( i.e. is injective or surjective ) for all @xmath16 and @xmath20 .
* it is clear that the slp for @xmath66 corresponds to the wlp .
* actually , it can be proved that if a lefschetz element exists , then there is an open set of such elements , so that one can call general linear form such an element .
* we will often be interested in artinian rings @xmath63 that fail the slp ( or wlp ) , i.e. when for any linear form @xmath19 there exist @xmath16 and @xmath20 such that the multiplication map @xmath65 has not maximal rank . in that case
we will say that @xmath63 ( or @xmath28 ) fails the slp at range @xmath20 and degree @xmath16 .
when @xmath66 we will say simply that @xmath63 fails the wlp in degree @xmath16 .
one of the main examples comes from togliatti s result ( see for instance @xcite , example 3.1 ) : the ideal @xmath67 fails the wlp in degree @xmath9 .
there are many ways to prove it .
one of them comes from the polarity on the rational normal cubic curve .
it leads to a generalization that gives one of the few known non toric examples .
( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.1 ) ) let @xmath68 be an integer and @xmath69 be non concurrent linear forms on @xmath39
. then the ideal @xmath70 fails the wlp in degree @xmath71 .
indeed on the general line @xmath72 the @xmath73 forms of degree @xmath74 become dependent thanks to the polarity on the rational normal curve of degree @xmath74 .
we propose the following conjecture .
for @xmath75 it is again togliatti s result .
let @xmath76 be non concurrent linear forms on @xmath39 and @xmath77 be a form of degree @xmath74 on @xmath39 .
then the ideal @xmath78 fails the wlp in degree @xmath71 if and only if @xmath79
in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.3 ) , the failure of the wlp in degree @xmath34 is related to the restriction of the syzygy bundle to a general hyperplane . here
we extend this relationship to the slp situation at any range and in many degrees , by using the syzygy bundle method originated in @xcite .
[ p1 ] let @xmath80 be an artinian ideal generated by homogeneous forms of degree @xmath26 and @xmath81 the syzygy bundle defined by the exact sequence @xmath82 where @xmath83 let @xmath16 be a non - negative integer such that @xmath84 and @xmath20 be an integer such that @xmath18 .
then @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath85 if and only if the induced homomorphism on sections ( denoted by @xmath86 ) @xmath87 has not maximal rank for a general linear form @xmath19 .
the theorem is not true if @xmath88 i.e. if there exists a syzygy of degree @xmath16 among @xmath89 . in @xcite
the authors consider the injectivity of the map @xmath86 for @xmath90 and for @xmath91 . in that case , since the forms @xmath92 are the generators of @xmath28 , we have of course @xmath93 . in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.1 ) the authors proved that @xmath94 for any @xmath95 .
let us consider the canonical exact sequence @xmath96 we obtain a long exact sequence of cohomology @xmath97 let us assume first that @xmath98 .
then we have always @xmath99 and it gives a shorter exact sequence : @xmath100 moreover , since @xmath101 , we have also @xmath102 .
then by tensoring the exact sequence defining the bundle @xmath81 by @xmath103 and taking the long cohomology exact sequence , we find : @xmath104 since the kernel and cokernel of both maps , @xmath105 and @xmath106 are the same , the theorem is proved for @xmath101 .
if @xmath107 , let us introduce the number @xmath108 .
this number is equal to @xmath109 and we have a long exact sequence : @xmath110 let us consider now the long exact sequence : @xmath111 since @xmath112 ( and @xmath113 ) , it remains a shorter exact sequence @xmath114 as before , since the kernel and cokernel of both maps are the same , the theorem is proved .
let us introduce the numbers @xmath115 , @xmath116 the following corollary is a didactic reformulation of the theorem above .
assume that there is no syzygy of degree @xmath16 among the @xmath92 s .
then @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath117 if and only if one of the two following equivalent conditions occurs : * @xmath118 , * @xmath119 . in the next section
we translate this corollary in geometric terms .
we recall that the @xmath11-th osculating space @xmath120 to a @xmath1-dimensional complex projective variety @xmath121 at @xmath2 is the subspace of @xmath122 spanned by @xmath2 and by all the derivative points of degree less than or equal to @xmath11 of a local parametrization of @xmath5 , evaluated at @xmath2 .
of course , for @xmath123 we get the tangent space @xmath124 . a @xmath1-dimensional variety @xmath121 whose @xmath11-th osculating space at a general point has dimension @xmath125 is said to satisfy @xmath126 independent laplace equations of order @xmath11 .
we will say , for shortness , that the _ number _ of laplace equations is @xmath126 . if @xmath127 , then there are always @xmath128 linear relations between the partial derivatives .
these relations are trivial laplace equations of order s. we will not consider them in the following , so when we write there is a laplace equation of order @xmath11 we understand a non - trivial laplace equation of order @xmath11 .
let us briefly explain now the link with projections of @xmath129 .
let @xmath130 be a complex vector space of linear forms of dimension @xmath60 such that @xmath131 .
we consider the veronese embedding : @xmath132 & \mapsto & [ l^{t } ] .
\end{array}\ ] ] the image @xmath129 is called the veronese @xmath1-fold of order @xmath133 . at the point
@xmath134\in v_t({\mathbb p}^n)$ ] , the @xmath11-th osculating space , @xmath135 , is the space of degree @xmath26 forms possessing a factorization @xmath136 where @xmath137 is a form of degree @xmath11 ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.3 ) .
it is identified with @xmath138 .
let us think about the projective duality in terms of derivations ( it is in fact the so - called apolarity , see @xcite ) . a canonical basis of @xmath139 is given by the @xmath140 derivations : @xmath141 let @xmath142 an ideal generated by @xmath24 forms of degree @xmath26 .
note that @xmath89 are points in @xmath143 .
we denote by @xmath144 the vector subspace of @xmath145 generated by the @xmath89 and by @xmath146 , for any @xmath147 .
let us introduce the orthogonal vector space to @xmath148 @xmath149 it gives an exact sequence of vector spaces @xmath150 and the corresponding projection map @xmath151 of course one can identify @xmath152 and write the decomposition @xmath153 in the following two situations , the vector space @xmath154 is easy to describe : 1 .
when @xmath144 is generated by @xmath24 monomials of degree @xmath26 , @xmath155 is generated by the remaining @xmath156 monomials .
2 . when @xmath157 where @xmath158\in { \mathbb p}(r_{1}^*)$ ] , @xmath155 is generated by degree @xmath26 polynomials that vanish at the points @xmath159\in { \mathbb p}(r_{1}).$ ] it is well known that the tangent spaces to the veronese varieties can be interpreted as singular hypersurfaces .
more precisely a hyperplane containing the tangent space @xmath160}v_t({\mathbb p}^n)$ ] corresponds in the dual space @xmath161 to a hypersurface of degree @xmath133 that is singular at the point @xmath162 $ ] .
more generally a hyperplane containing the @xmath11-th ( @xmath163 ) osculating space @xmath160}^{s}v_t({\mathbb p}^n)$ ] corresponds to a hypersurface of degree @xmath133 and multiplicity @xmath164 at the point @xmath162 $ ] ( see for instance @xcite ) .
thus the dual variety of @xmath129 is the discriminant variety that parametrizes the singular hypersurfaces of degree @xmath133 when the @xmath11-th osculating variety of @xmath129 parametrizes the hypersurfaces of degree @xmath133 with a point of multiplicity @xmath165 .
we propose now an extended version of the `` main '' theorem of @xcite ( to be precise theorem 3.2 ) .
[ th1bis ] let @xmath80 be an artinian ideal generated by @xmath24 homogeneous polynomials of degree @xmath26 .
let @xmath166 be integers such that @xmath167 , @xmath18 .
assume that there is no syzygy of degree @xmath16 among the @xmath92 s .
the following conditions are equivalent : 1 .
the ideal @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath85 .
2 . there exist @xmath168 , with @xmath169 , independent vectors @xmath170 and @xmath171 forms @xmath172 such that @xmath173 for a general linear form @xmath19 of @xmath54 .
the @xmath1-dimensional variety @xmath174 satisfies @xmath169 laplace equations of order @xmath117 .
[ item_iv_thm ] for any @xmath175 , @xmath176 , with @xmath177 .
the equivalence @xmath178 is proved in theorem [ p1 ] .
since @xmath28 is generated in degree @xmath26 , the map @xmath179 is surjective and the relation @xmath180 is equivalent to @xmath181}^{d+i - k}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n)\neq \emptyset$ ] .
more generally the number of independent relations @xmath173 is the dimension of the kernel of the map @xmath86 i.e. the dimension of @xmath182 ; this number of independent relations , written in a geometric way , is @xmath183}^{d+i - k}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n)]+1,\,\,\ , ( \delta \ge 0)\ ] ] where the projective dimension is @xmath184 if the intersection is empty .
the number is the number of ( non trivial ) laplace equations .
indeed , the dimension of the @xmath185-th osculating space to @xmath174 is @xmath186 since the @xmath185-th osculating space to @xmath187 meets the center of projection along a @xmath188 .
in other words , the @xmath1-dimensional variety @xmath174 satisfies @xmath126 laplace equations and @xmath189 is equivalent to @xmath190 .
the image by @xmath191 of the @xmath185-th osculating space to the veronese @xmath187 in a general point has codimension @xmath192 in @xmath193 .
the codimension corresponds to the number of hyperplanes in @xmath193 containing the osculating space to @xmath174 .
these hyperplanes are images by @xmath191 of hyperplanes in @xmath194 containing @xmath195 and the @xmath185-th osculating plane to @xmath187 at the point @xmath196 $ ] . in the dual
setting it means that these hyperplanes are forms of degree @xmath31 in @xmath197 with multiplicity @xmath198 at @xmath162 $ ] .
it proves that @xmath189 is equivalent to @xmath199 . to summarize , the number of laplace equations is @xmath200 and @xmath201 1 .
[ cor_cones ] let us explain the geometric meaning of theorem [ th1bis ] [ item_iv_thm ] in a simple case : if @xmath202 , then [ item_iv_thm ] means that @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath117 if and only if there exists at any point @xmath203 a hypersurface of degree @xmath31 with multiplicity @xmath204 at @xmath205 given by a form in @xmath206 .
2 . let @xmath207 where @xmath208 are general linear forms .
the vector space @xmath197 , where @xmath209 is the vector space of the forms of degree @xmath31 vanishing in @xmath24 points @xmath210 $ ] with multiplicity @xmath211 .
in other words @xmath212 ) ( see ( * ? ? ? * corollary 3 ) ) .
geometrically it can be described as @xmath213}^{i}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n ) , \cdots , t_{[l_r^{d+i}]}^{i}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n)).$ ] 3 . by the theorem above , when @xmath214 , the ideal @xmath207 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath215 if and only if the following intersection is not empty : @xmath216 } v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n ) , \cdots , t^i_{[l_r^{d+i}]}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n ) ) \cap \ , t^{d+i - k}_{[l^{d+i}]}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n).\ ] ] 4 .
here we focus the attention also on the number @xmath126 of laplace equations satisfied by @xmath217 .
the geometric meaning of this number was highlighted by terracini @xcite for laplace equations of order @xmath9 and recently for any order by @xcite , where a classification of varieties satisfying many laplace equations is given .
the characterization of the failure of the slp by the existence of ad - hoc singular hypersurfaces allows us to answer , in the three following propositions , some questions posed by migliore and nagel .
let us recall their questions : ( * ? ? ?
* problem 5.4 ) let @xmath218 for a general linear form @xmath19 .
@xmath219 fails the wlp , for @xmath220 .
there are some natural questions arising from this example : 1 . [ problem1 ]
prove the failure of the wlp in previous example for all @xmath221 .
2 . what happens for mixed powers ? 3 .
[ problem3 ] what happens for almost complete intersections , that is , for @xmath222 powers of general linear forms in @xmath24 variables when @xmath223 ? ( * ? ? ? * conjecture 5.13 ) let @xmath224 be general linear forms and @xmath225 1 .
[ conj1 ] if @xmath226 and@xmath227 then @xmath219 fails the wlp .
2 . if @xmath228 then @xmath219 fails the wlp if and only if @xmath229 .
we prove [ problem1 ] of ( * ? ? ?
* problem 5.4 ) in proposition [ pr54 - 1 ] , [ problem3 ] of ( * ? ? ?
* problem 5.4 ) , for @xmath230 and @xmath231 , in proposition [ pr54 - 2 ] and [ conj1 ] of ( * ? ? ?
* conjecture 5.13 ) in proposition [ pr54 - 3 ] .
since all these results concern powers of linear forms , let us first verify that the hypothesis on the global syzygy in theorem [ th1bis ] is not restrictive .
[ lem - syz ] let @xmath28 be the ideal @xmath232 where the @xmath233 are linear forms and @xmath234 .
let @xmath81 be its syzygy bundle .
then @xmath235 one direction is obvious .
let us assume that @xmath236 and that there exists a relation @xmath237 with @xmath238 forms of @xmath239 .
both hypotheses imply that the projective space @xmath240}^{i}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n ) , \cdots , t_{[l_r^{d+i}]}^{i}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n))$ ] has dimension strictly less than the expected one .
since the linear forms are general , it implies that the algebraic closure of @xmath241}^{i}v_{d+i}({\mathbb p}^n)$ ] has not the expected dimension .
it contradicts the lemma 3.3 in @xcite .
proposition [ pr54 - 2 ] is already proved in ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 4.8 ) and also in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.2 ( ii ) ) .
we propose here a new proof based on the existence of a singular hypersurface characterizing the failure of the slp .
let us mention that , on @xmath39 a hypersurface of degree @xmath31 with a point of multiplicity @xmath31 is simply an union of lines ( as , for instance , in theorem [ th3 ] and proposition [ th4 ] ) , but on @xmath54 , with @xmath101 , a hypersurface of degree @xmath31 with a point of multiplicity @xmath31 is more generally a cone over a hypersurface in the hyperplane at infinity .
this is the key argument in the proofs of the three following propositions .
[ pr54 - 1 ] let @xmath242 be an integer such that @xmath243 .
then the ideal @xmath244 fails the wlp in degree @xmath245 .
of course it is equivalent to say that @xmath246 fails the wlp in degree @xmath245 for @xmath247 general linear forms .
let us consider the syzygy bundle associated to the linear system @xmath248 since @xmath249 lemma [ lem - syz ] implies @xmath250 let @xmath19 be a linear form .
when @xmath243 we have @xmath251 . according to theorem [ th1bis ] the failure of the wlp in degree
@xmath245 is equivalent to the existence of a surface with multiplicity @xmath252 in the points @xmath253 and @xmath254 and multiplicity @xmath255 at a moving point @xmath205 .
the five concurrent lines in @xmath205 passing through @xmath256 belong to a quadric cone with equation @xmath257 ( the cone over the conic at infinity through the five points ) .
since @xmath258 the hypersurface @xmath259 has the desired properties . in @xmath54 there is always a quadric through @xmath260 points in general position . then given any general point @xmath261
, there is a quadratic cone with a vertex at @xmath205 and passing through @xmath260 fixed points in general position .
then we prove , [ pr54 - 2 ] in the following cases the ideal @xmath262 fails the wlp in degree @xmath245 : * @xmath263 and @xmath264 , * @xmath231 and @xmath265 , * @xmath266 and @xmath267 .
let us consider the syzygy bundle associated to the linear system @xmath268 let @xmath19 a linear form .
then the inequality @xmath269 is true if and only if @xmath242 and @xmath1 are one of the possibilities stated in the theorem . in all these cases we have @xmath270 , and by lemma [ lem - syz ] , @xmath271 .
according to theorem [ th1bis ] the failure of the wlp is equivalent to the existence of a hypersurface with multiplicity @xmath252 in the points @xmath159 $ ] and multiplicity @xmath255 at the moving point @xmath205 .
the lines through @xmath205 and @xmath159 $ ] belong to a quadratic cone with equation @xmath257 ( the cone over the quadric at infinity through the points ) . since @xmath258 the hypersurface @xmath259 has the desired properties .
[ pr54 - 3 ] the ideal @xmath272 fails the wlp in degree @xmath273 where @xmath274 be general linear forms on @xmath275 .
since @xmath276 lemma [ lem - syz ] implies @xmath277 we have to prove that , on a general hyperplane @xmath19 , the cokernel of @xmath278 has dimension strictly greater than @xmath279 the dimension of this cokernel is the dimension of the quartics with a quadruple point @xmath162 $ ] and @xmath280 double points .
we consider on the hyperplane at infinity the vector space @xmath45 of quadrics through the images of the @xmath280 points @xmath281 , \ldots , [ l_8^{\vee}]$ ] .
it has dimension @xmath282 .
let @xmath283 be a basis of this space of quadrics .
then the vector space @xmath284 of quartics generated by the products @xmath285 has dimension @xmath286 and all these quartics are singular in the @xmath280 points . in @xmath275
the independent quartic cones over these quartics belong to the cokernel . in the next section ,
we propose many examples of ideals failing the wlp or the slp by producing ad - hoc singular hypersurfaces .
in their nice paper about osculating spaces of veronese surfaces , lanteri and mallavibarena remark that the equation of the curve given by three concurrent lines depends only on six monomials instead of seven .
more precisely let us consider a cubic with a triple point at @xmath287 passing through @xmath288 , @xmath289 and @xmath290 .
its equation is @xmath291 and it depends only on the monomials @xmath292 .
so there is a non zero form in @xmath293 that is triple at a general point . in this way
they explain the togliatti surprising phenomena ( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.1 ) , @xcite and @xcite ) .
we apply this idea in our context . recall that in the monomial case being artinian to the ideal @xmath28 means that it contains the forms @xmath294 .
let us consider the @xmath295 fundamental points @xmath55 and let us assume that the number @xmath24 of monomials generating @xmath28 is chosen such that @xmath296 for @xmath297 fixed integers .
then , as it is noted in item [ cor_cones ] of remarks after theorem [ th1bis ] , the ideal @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath117 if and only if there exists at any point @xmath205 a hypersurface of degree @xmath31 with multiplicity @xmath298 at @xmath205 given by a form in @xmath206 .
we have to write this equation with a number of monomials as small as possible .
then the orthogonal space becomes bigger and we will cover all the possible choices .
first of all we describe exhaustively the monomial ideals @xmath299 $ ] of degree @xmath7 that do not verify the wlp .
[ th3 ] up to permutation of variables the monomial ideals generated by five quartic forms in @xmath300 $ ] that fail the wlp in degree @xmath273 are the following * @xmath301 , * @xmath302 .
geometrically it is evident that the first ideal @xmath303 fails the wlp . indeed under the veronese map , a linear form @xmath19 becomes a rational normal curve of degree four that defines a projective space @xmath304 and , modulo @xmath19 , the restricted monomials @xmath305 can be interpreted as points of this @xmath304 .
then the tangent line to the rational quartic curve at the point @xmath306 $ ] contains the two points @xmath307 $ ] and @xmath308 $ ] .
this line meets the plane @xmath309 in one point ; it implies that @xmath310 for the second ideal , it is not evident to see that the line @xmath311 always ( for any restriction ) meets the plane @xmath309 .
let us consider the points @xmath288 , @xmath289 and @xmath290 and the degree @xmath7 curves with a quadruple point in @xmath287 passing through these three points .
these curves are product of four lines : @xmath312 expanding @xmath77 explicitly in the coordinates @xmath313 , we see that the forms @xmath314 are missing and that twelve monomials appear to write its equation .
since we want only ten monomials , we have to remove two .
the following possibilities occur : * @xmath315 ( or equivalently by permutation of variables @xmath316 $ ] or @xmath317 , @xmath318 and @xmath319 $ ] ) then the remaining linear system is @xmath320 it corresponds to the first case i.e. to the ideal @xmath321 . *
@xmath322 and @xmath318 but @xmath323 ( or equivalentely by permutation of variables @xmath324 $ ] or @xmath325 $ ] ) then the remaining linear system is @xmath326 it corresponds to the second case i.e. to the ideal @xmath327 .
the quartic curve with multiplicity four in @xmath287 consists , in the first case , of two lines and a double line that are concurrent ; in the second case of four concurrent lines in harmonic division .
we do not apply the same technique to describe exhaustively the monomial ideals @xmath328 $ ] of degree @xmath8 that do not verify the wlp because the computations become too tricky .
but we can give some cases by geometric arguments .
[ th4 ] the following monomial ideals * @xmath329 , * @xmath330 , where @xmath331 is any monomial , * @xmath332 , fail the @xmath333 in degree @xmath7 . under the veronese map ,
a linear form @xmath19 becomes a rational normal curve of degree five that defines a projective space @xmath334 and , modulo @xmath19 , the restricted monomials @xmath305 can be interpreted as points of this @xmath334 .
then the tangent line to the rational quintic curve at the point @xmath335 $ ] contains the two points @xmath336 $ ] and @xmath337 $ ] .
this line meets the plane @xmath338 in one point ; it implies that @xmath339 in the same way the osculating plane at @xmath335 $ ] i.e. @xmath340 meets the plane @xmath338 in one point . in the last case ,
the geometric argument is not so evident
. let us set @xmath341 and @xmath342 .
then the equation of the product of the five concurrent lines is @xmath343 for any point @xmath344 we choose @xmath345 such that @xmath346 and @xmath347 .
then the equation depends only on @xmath348 monomials and the remaining monomials are @xmath349 we describe now some monomial ideals in @xmath350 $ ] , generated in degree @xmath273 , that do not verify the wlp .
[ th3 - 1 ] the monomial ideals @xmath351 where the forms @xmath352 are chosen among one of the following sets of monomials : * @xmath353 ( case ( a1 ) ) * @xmath354 ( case ( a2 ) ) * @xmath355 ( case ( a3 ) ) * @xmath356 ( case ( a4 ) ) * @xmath357 ( case ( b1 ) ) fail the wlp in degree @xmath9 .
we do not know if under permutation of variables the description above is exhaustive or not .
the singular cubic that we are considering here are union of concurrent planes and not all the cubic cones .
we look for a surface of degree @xmath273 with multiplicity @xmath273 at a general point @xmath344 that passes through the points @xmath358 such that its equation depends only on the remaining monomials in @xmath359 .
such a cubic surface is a cone over a cubic curve . here , instead of a general cubic cone
we consider only three concurrent planes .
since these @xmath273 planes have to pass through @xmath360 and @xmath361 it remains only , after a simple verification , the following cases : 0.3 0.3 + 0.3 0.3 + 0.3 * ( a1 ) the equation of the cubic is @xmath362 * ( a2 ) the equation of the cubic is @xmath363 * ( a3 ) the equation of the cubic is @xmath364 where at any point @xmath365 the function @xmath366 verifies @xmath367 . * ( a4 ) the equation of the cubic is @xmath368 .
* ( b1 ) the equation of the cubic is @xmath369 if we want @xmath370 to be of dimension @xmath371 ( for instance @xmath372 ) we need @xmath373 independent cubics with a triple point .
so , to get the failure of the wlp , we need @xmath373 independent cubics with a triple point .
let us recover with our method two linear systems of eight cubic forms ( the complete classification is already done in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.10 ) ) that fail the wlp in degree @xmath9 .
the following monomial ideals * @xmath374 * @xmath375 fail the @xmath333 in degree @xmath9 . the ideals @xmath28 and @xmath376 correspond respectively to the cases @xmath189 and @xmath377 in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.10 ) .
let us consider the following three forms defining singular cubics passing through the fundamental points and a general point @xmath365 : @xmath378 they are particular cases of type @xmath379 in the proof of proposition [ th3 - 1 ] .
they are linearly independent and can be written with twelve monomials .
then it remains only @xmath280 forms for @xmath370 : @xmath380 let us consider the following three forms defining singular cubics passing through the basis points and the general point @xmath365 : @xmath381 they are cases of type @xmath382 in the proof of proposition [ th3 - 1 ] .
they are linearly independent and can be written with twelve monomials : @xmath383 it remains only @xmath384 of course the same argument ( concurrent planes or hyperplanes ) can be used in degree or dimension bigger than @xmath273 . for instance
let us give a set of monomial ideals in @xmath350 $ ] , generated in degree @xmath7 that fail the wlp .
[ d4 m ] let @xmath385 be eleven monomials chosen among @xmath386 then the ideal @xmath387 fails the wlp in degree @xmath273 . at any point
@xmath388 an equation of a surface of degree @xmath7 with multiplicity @xmath7 at @xmath205 that passes through the points @xmath389 is given by @xmath390 we conclude this section with an example that fails the slp at the range @xmath9 . [ d4mslp ] the ideal @xmath391 $ ] fails the slp at the range @xmath9 in degree @xmath9 .
let @xmath288 , @xmath289 , @xmath290 and @xmath392 be four points .
we consider the quartic curve consisting of the union of the four lines @xmath393 and @xmath394 .
it is a quartic passing through @xmath395 and triple at @xmath392 .
it depends on the six monomials @xmath396 then it remains @xmath397 monomials @xmath398 the associated syzygy bundle @xmath81 verifies @xmath399 for a general linear form @xmath19 .
it proves that @xmath400 fails the slp at the range @xmath9 in degree @xmath9 .
let us study now the interesting case @xmath401 where @xmath402 is a finite set of distinct points in @xmath403 of length @xmath404 and @xmath405 its ideal sheaf
. the set @xmath402 corresponds by projective duality to a set of @xmath404 distinct lines in @xmath39 defined by linear forms @xmath406 .
we will now consider the ideal @xmath407 generated by @xmath408 .
we have @xmath409 . [ nmslp ]
let @xmath18 , @xmath410 and @xmath411 a finite set of @xmath24 distinct points in @xmath403 where @xmath57 are linear forms on @xmath39 .
assume that there exists a subset @xmath412 , of length @xmath413 , contained in a curve @xmath414 of degree @xmath415 .
then the ideal @xmath416 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath417 .
the union of @xmath414 and @xmath418 concurrent lines at a point @xmath2 passing through the remaining points @xmath419 , is a non zero section of @xmath420 . by theorem [ th1bis ]
it proves that @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath20 in degree @xmath417 . with this method
it is always possible to find systems of any degree that fail the slp by exhibiting a curve of degree @xmath26 with multiplicity @xmath421 at a general point @xmath2 .
but one can find some set of points for which these special curves do not split as product of lines ( see proposition [ b3 ] in the next section ) .
a line arrangement is a collection of distinct lines in the projective plane .
arrangement of lines or more generally arrangement of hyperplanes is a famous and classical topic that has been studied by many authors for a very long time ( see @xcite or @xcite for a good introduction ) .
let us denote by @xmath422 the equation of the union of lines of the considered arrangement .
another classical object associated to the arrangement is the vector bundle @xmath423 defined as the kernel of the jacobian map : @xmath424 the bundle @xmath425 is called _ derivation bundle _
( sometimes logarithmic bundle ) of the line arrangement ( see @xcite and @xcite for an introduction to derivation bundles ) .
the splitting of @xmath427 over a line @xmath430 is related to the existence of curves ( with a given degree @xmath431 ) passing through @xmath402 that are multiple ( with multiplicity @xmath432 ) at @xmath433 .
more precisely , in our context it implies the following characterization of unstability .
we recall that a rank two vector bundle @xmath440 on @xmath441 is _ unstable _ if and only if its splitting @xmath442 on a general line @xmath72 verifies @xmath443 .
this characterization is a consequence of the grauert - mlich theorem , see @xcite .
[ th5 ] let @xmath444 $ ] be an artinian ideal generated by @xmath445 polynomials @xmath446 where @xmath57 are distinct linear forms in @xmath39 .
let @xmath447 be the corresponding set of points in @xmath403 .
then the following conditions are equivalent : the failure of the slp at the range @xmath9 in degree @xmath449 is equivalent to the existence at a general point @xmath450 of a curve of degree @xmath26 with multiplicity @xmath34 at @xmath450 belonging to @xmath451 . by the lemma [ linksd ] it is equivalent to the following splitting @xmath452 on a general line @xmath72 . in other words
the failure of the slp is equivalent to have a non balanced decomposition and according to grauert - mlich theorem it is equivalent to unstability .
let us give now an ideal generated by non monomials quartic forms that fails the slp at the range @xmath9 .
it comes from a line arrangement , called b3 arrangement ( see ( * ? ? ?
* pages 13 , 25 and 287 ) ) , such that the associated derivation bundle is unstable ( in fact even decomposed ) .
the existence of a quartic curve with a general triple point is the key argument .
but contrary to the previous examples , this quartic is irreducible and consequently not obtainable by proposition [ nmslp ] .
consider the set @xmath402 of the nine dual points of the linear forms @xmath454 .
let @xmath28 be the artinian ideal @xmath455 and @xmath81 its syzygy bundle .
the derivation bundle of the arrangement is @xmath456 ( it is free with exponents @xmath457 ; see @xcite for a proof ) .
then , according to the lemma [ linksd ] there is at any point @xmath2 a degree @xmath7 curve with multiplicity @xmath273 at @xmath2 passing through @xmath402 . in other words , by theorem [ th1bis ] , @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath9 .
if @xmath461 is odd we can add to @xmath402 one point @xmath2 in general position with respect to @xmath402 and we can prove in the same way that @xmath464 fails the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath465 .
let us denote by @xmath466 the dual set of points of @xmath467 .
since there exists at any general point @xmath450 a curve of degree @xmath431 passing through @xmath468 , the lemma [ linksd ] implies that @xmath427 is unstable and proposition [ th5 ] implies that @xmath28 fails the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath463 .
one of the main conjecture about hyperplane arrangements ( still open also for line arrangements ) is terao s conjecture .
it concerns the free arrangements .
the conjecture says that freeness depends only on the combinatorics of the arrangement .
let us recall that the combinatorics of the arrangement @xmath469 is determined by an incidence graph .
its vertices are the lines @xmath470 and the points @xmath471 .
its edges are joining @xmath470 to @xmath472 when @xmath473 .
we refer again to @xcite for a good introduction to the subject .
terao s conjecture is valid not only for line arrangement but more generally for hyperplane arrangements .
let us consider a free arrangement @xmath474 with exponents @xmath428 ( @xmath475 ) and let us denote by @xmath476 its dual set of points .
we assume that terao s conjecture is not true i.e , that there exists a non free arrangement @xmath469 with the same combinatorics of @xmath477 .
let us add @xmath478 points @xmath479 in general position to @xmath476 in order to form @xmath480 and to th dual set @xmath402 of@xmath467 to form @xmath481 .
then the length of both sets of points is @xmath482 . on the general line @xmath72 we have @xmath483 when ,
since @xmath402 is not free , we have a less balanced decomposition for @xmath427 ( this affirmation is proved in @xcite ) : @xmath484 it implies that @xmath485 then adding @xmath478 lines passing through @xmath450 and the @xmath478 added points we obtain @xmath486 , @xmath487 and @xmath488 the bundle @xmath489 is balanced with splitting @xmath490 and @xmath491 then @xmath489 is semistable and @xmath492 is unstable .
in other words the ideal @xmath493 fails the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath494 when @xmath495 has the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath494 .
let @xmath496 a set of points of length @xmath482 in @xmath403 such that the ideal @xmath497 has the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath494 .
assume that @xmath498 has the same combinatorics of @xmath476 .
then @xmath499 has the slp at the range @xmath9 and degree @xmath494 . , the cohomology ring of colored braid group .
zametki _ , 5(2 ) : 227231 , 1969 . , osculating varieties of veronese varieties and their higher secant varieties .
_ canad . j. math .
_ 59 , no .
3 , 488502 ( 2007 ) . , syzygy bundles on @xmath39 and the weak lefschetz property . _ illinois j. math .
_ , 51:12991308 , 2007 . , les arrangements dhyperplans : un chapitre de gomtrie combinatoire
bourbaki seminar , vol .
1980/81 , p. 122
, lecture notes in math . , 901 , springer , berlin - new york , 1981 . , on varieties with higher osculating defect , _
arxiv:1204.4399_. to appear on revista matemtica iberoamericana , 29 ( 4 ) 2013 . , _ classical algebraic geometry : a modern view_. to be published by cambridge univ . press . , bounding cohomology groups of vector bundles on @xmath500 , _ math .
_ , 246(3):251270 , 1979/80 .
, inverse system of a symbolic power , i , _ j. of algebra _ 174:10801090 , 1995 .
, on a theorem of togliatti .
j. _ 2(4):379397 , 2002 .
, hyperplane arrangements of torelli type .
_ arxiv:1011.4611 _ , november 2010 . to appear on compositio math . ,
_ algebraic geometry , a first course_. volume 133 of _ graduate texts in math .
_ springer verlag , 1992 . , the weak and strong lefschetz properties for artinian k - algebras .
_ j. algebra _ , 262:99126 , 2003 . , inverse systems , gelfand - tsetlin patterns and the weak lefschetz property
_ journal of the london mathematical society _ 84:712730 , 2011 .
, togliatti systems .
_ osaka j. math .
_ , 43(1):112 , 2006 .
, osculatory behavior and second dual varieties of del pezzo surfaces . _ adv . in geom .
_ , 2(4):345363 , 2002 . , on the weak lefschetz property for powers of linear forms .
_ algebra and number theory _ , 4:487526 , 2012 .
, laplace equations and the weak lefschetz property , canad . j. math .
65(2013 ) , 634 - 654 . , a tour of the weak and strong lefschetz properties . _
arxiv:1109.5718 _ ,
september 2011 . to appear on journal of commutative algebra . , _
vector bundles on complex projective spaces_. progress in mathematics , vol .
3 , birkhuser , boston , mass . , 1980 . , _ arrangement of hyperplanes _
, volume 300 of _ grundlerhen der mathematischen wissenschaften [ fundamental principles of mathematical sciences ] . _ springer - verlag , berlin , 1992 . ,
inflections of toric varieties .
, 48:483516 , 2000 . ,
theory of logarithmic differential forms and logarithmic vector fields . _ j. fac .
tokyo sect .
_ , 27(2):265291 , 1980 . , elementary modifications and line configurations in @xmath39 .
_ comment .
_ 78(3):447462 , 2003 . , weyl groups , the hard lefschetz theorem , and the sperner property .
_ siam j. alg . disc . meth .
_ 1(2):168184 , 1980 .
, sulle @xmath501 che rappresentano pi di @xmath502 equazioni di laplace linearmente indipendenti .
, 33:176186 , 1912 . , alcune osservazioni sulle superficie razionali che rappresentano equazioni di laplace .
_ ann . mat .
pura appl .
_ 25(4):325339 , 1946 .
, varits de type togliatti .
_ c.r.a.s .
_ 343(6):411414 , 2006 .
, fibrs logarithmiques sur le plan projectif .
toulouse math .
_ 16(2):385395 , 2007 . | in a recent paper @xcite miro - roig , mezzetti and ottaviani highlight the link between rational varieties satisfying a laplace equation and artinian ideals failing the weak lefschetz property . continuing their work
we extend this link to the more general situation of artinian ideals failing the strong lefschetz property .
we characterize the failure of the slp ( which includes wlp ) by the existence of special singular hypersurfaces ( cones for wlp ) .
this characterization allows us to solve three problems posed in @xcite and to give new examples of ideals failing the slp .
finally , line arrangements are related to artinian ideals and the unstability of the associated derivation bundle is linked to the failure of the slp .
moreover we reformulate the so - called terao s conjecture for free line arrangements in terms of artinian ideals failing the slp . |
observations by the infrared astronomy satellite ( @xmath0 ) led to the discovery of a class of galaxies with enormous far - ir luminosities .
subsequent observations over a large range of wavelengths have shown that these objects , called ulig for ultraluminous infrared galaxies , have 1 ) bolometric luminosities and space densities comparable to those of optical quasars ( sanders et al . 1988 ) ; 2 ) a broad range in host galaxy spectral type , including starburst galaxies , seyfert i and ii , radio galaxies , and quasars ; 3 ) morphologies often suggestive of recent interactions or merging ( carico et al . 1990 ; leech et al.1994 ; rigopoulou et al .
1999 ) ; and 4 ) large amounts of molecular gas concentrated in small ( @xmath91 kpc ) central regions ( e.g. scoville et al . 1989 ; solomon et al . 1997 ) . understanding the nature of the prime energy source in ulig
has proven difficult ( e.g. smith , lonsdale , & lonsdale 1998 ) .
many of the observed characteristics indicate that very strong starbursts could be the culprit .
alternatively , an active galactic nucleus ( agn ) may power the ulig ( e.g. lonsdale , smith , & lonsdale 1993 ) .
the very high luminosities suggest an evolutionary connection between ulig and quasars , wherein a dust - enshrouded central massive black hole is gradually revealed as the appearance of the object changes from ulig to quasar ( sanders et al .
1988 ) .
much effort has been expended in trying to determine the primary source of energy
starbursts or agn driving the large fir luminosities .
the recent studies using iso indicate that the vast majority of the power comes from starbursts in @xmath10 of the observed systems ( genzel et al .
1998 ; lutz et al . 1998 ) .
rigopoulou et al .
( 1999 ) present the results of an expanded version of the mid - ir spectroscopic survey first reported by genzel et al .
using iso to observe 62 ulig at @xmath11 , they measured the line to continuum ratio of the 7.7 @xmath1 m polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ( pah ) feature to differentiate between starburst and agn as the dominant source of the large fir luminosity .
pah features have been shown to be strong in starburst galaxies and weak in agn ( moorwood 1986 ; roche et al .
rigopoulou et al .
confirmed the results of genzel et al .
( 1998 ) , and also found , based on near - ir imaging , that approximately 2/3 of their sample have double nuclei and nearly all the objects show signs of interactions .
for a recent review of ulig see sanders & mirabel ( 1996 ) .
ulig are also of great interest for studies of early star formation in the building of galaxies .
recent sub - mm observations suggest that objects similar to ulig may contain a significant fraction of the star formation at high redshifts ( e.g. lilly et al .
but so far most studies have found ulig only in the nearby universe .
sanders et al .
( 1988 ) initially studied a group of 10 objects at @xmath12 .
previously published systematic surveys have found objects mostly at @xmath13 ( leech et al .
1994 ; clements et al .
1996a , 1996b ) .
a few high redshifts objects have been found , all of which turn out to contain hidden agn .
these include fsc 15307 + 3252 at @xmath14 ( cutri et al .
1994 ) and fsc 10214 + 4724 at @xmath15 ( rowan - robinson et al.1991 ) .
the former object was found to exhibit a highly polarized continuum , indicating the presence of a buried quasar ( hines et al.1995 ) while the latter was found to be lensed ( eisenhardt et al.1996 ) and also shows signs of containing a hidden agn ( lawrence et al .
1993 ; elston et al . 1994
; goodrich et al . 1996 ) .
further progress in this field has been hampered by the lack of identified ulig at moderately high redshifts .
no new deep far - ir survey will become available prior to the launch of _ sirtf _ , which will be capable of studying ulig in detail at high redshifts .
so , the @xmath0 database remains the primary source of targets for finding high redshift ulig .
radio observations provide a relatively unbiased method for extracting fir galaxies from the @xmath0 faint source catalog ( fsc ; moshir et al .
1992 ) because radio continuum emission is relatively unaffected by extinction in dense gas and dust .
such fir / radio samples are ideal for detailed investigations of the complex relationships between the interstellar media , starbursts , and possible agn in ulig . for example , a sample of radio - loud objects was constructed by cross - correlating the @xmath0 fsc with the texas 365 mhz radio catalog ( txfs ; dey & van breugel 1990 ) .
subsequent optical identifications and spectroscopy showed that the txfs objects tend to be distant agn .
so a radio - quiet sample , extracted from the fsc , should be an excellent means of finding ulig without agn i.e .
powered by starbursts at interesting cosmological distances . in this paper
, we report on such a sample : we describe the sample selection process and discuss the near - ir imaging .
we defer a detailed analysis of the radio properties and optical spectroscopy to future papers .
we have used two large area surveys in the radio and far - ir , which we briefly describe here , to select ulig candidates . in the radio , we have used the first ( faint images of the radio sky at twenty cm ; becker , white , & helfand 1995 ) . using the vla , this project is surveying @xmath16 steradians down to a 5@xmath17 limit of 1 mjy with 5 arcsec resolution and subarcsec positional accuracy .
one of the problems with finding distant ulig using @xmath0 is that there are many faint galaxies visible in a deep optical image within the relatively large error ellipse of an fir source .
the high resolution and good positional information of first offer an excellent means of choosing the best of the many optical candidates on which to spend valuable large telescope time getting redshifts .
we used the second version of the catalog ( released 1995 october 16 ) , which samples 2925 degrees@xmath18 in two regions of sky in the north ( @xmath19 ra(j2000 ) @xmath20 , @xmath21 dec(j2000 ) @xmath22 ) and south ( @xmath23 ra(j2000 ) @xmath24 , @xmath25 dec(j2000 ) @xmath26 ) galactic caps . in the far - ir
we have used the @xmath0 fsc ( moshir et al .
1992 ) which resulted from the faint source survey ( fss ) .
relative to the @xmath0 point source catalog , the fss achieved better sensitivity by point - source filtering the detector data streams and then coadding those data before finding sources . at 60
( the band used for defining our candidates ) , the fsc covers the sky at @xmath27 and has a reliability ( integrated over all signal - to - noise ratios ) of @xmath28 .
the limiting 60 @xmath1 m flux density of the fsc is approximately 0.2 jy , where the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) is @xmath75 .
the fss also resulted in the faint source reject file which contains extracted sources not in the fsc with an snr above 3.0 .
we used the fsr , in addition to the fsc , with part of first to increase the number of targets in the fall sky .
the @xmath0 fsc was positionally cross - correlated with the second version of the first catalog , with the requirements that an fsc source must have a real 60 @xmath1 m detection ( @xmath29 ) and that it be within 60 arcsec of the first source .
the 60 @xmath1 m band was chosen because it is more reliable than the 100 @xmath1 m band and samples close to the wavelength peak of the ulig power . the resulting first - fsc ( ff ) catalog contains 2328 matches .
to increase the available objects in the fall sky , we also performed a positional match of the fsr with the south galactic cap portion of first , which yielded an additional 176 matches .
the 20 cm and 60 @xmath1 m flux densities for this sample of 2504 sources are plotted in figure [ f20v60 ] .
the majority of the ff sources fall along the well - known radio - fir correlation ( condon et al .
1991 ) , extending from nearby starburst galaxies to much fainter fir / radio flux levels .
the surface density of such objects is approximately 1 degree@xmath30 down to the @xmath31 limits of 1 mjy at 20 cm and @xmath70.2 jy at 60 @xmath1 m .
we generated optical finding charts using the digitized sky surveys , available from the space telescope science institute , for all 2504 matches .
the radio source position and the fsc error ellipse were overlaid on these charts .
visual inspection of these finding charts was carried out to select optically faint targets for further study , with the expectation that such targets would be distant ulig .
approximately 150 targets , which will carry the designation ff along with the usual coordinate naming scheme , were selected in this manner . a strict cutoff in optical magnitude
was not employed , and we make no attempt to construct a sample which has a well - defined limiting magnitude in the optical . in practice ,
the magnitude of the targets selected for optical imaging and spectroscopy depended on the observing conditions , i.e. some targets which are not visually faint on the dss image were observed during cloudy conditions . while the first and fsc catalogs do have well - defined flux limits , our sample was not constructed in order to be complete to a chosen flux level in either the radio nor the far - ir bands . the main goal of the survey is simply to find high - redshift ulig .
it is worth noting that our target list would include objects with observed characteristics in the radio , optical , and far - ir similar to those of fsc10214 + 4724 ( which itself lies outside of the first area that we used and so can not fall into our catalog ) .
we have not found any ulig at redshifts as great as that of fsc10214 + 4724 in the @xmath73000 degree@xmath18 surveyed .
during several runs from march 1996 to april 1999 , the kast spectrograph ( miller & stone 1994 ) at the shane 3 m telescope of lick observatory was used to obtain optical images and spectroscopy of the candidate ulig from our ff catalog .
the observing procedure typically consisted of taking two 300 s images in the @xmath32 band , identifying the optical counterpart of the ff source in these data , and immediately following up with slit spectroscopy of the optical object .
because the resolution and positional accuracy of first are high , it was usually clear which optical object coincided with the radio source .
the fwhm of the seeing in the images was usually in the range 1.52.0 arcsec .
standard stars were observed in imaging mode when conditions were photometric . however , because much of the data were obtained during non - photometric conditions , @xmath32 magnitudes will not be presented here for the sample . unless the source morphology demanded a particular value , the position angle of the slit was set to the parallactic angle .
the object was dithered along the slit by @xmath33 arcsec between two exposures to aid in fringe subtraction .
optical spectra of 1200 - 6000s duration were obtained of the optical source using the 300 line mm@xmath34 grating in the red - side spectrograph , which provides @xmath74.6 pixel@xmath34 resolution from 507010590 , and a 452/3306 grism in the blue - side spectrograph which provides @xmath72.5 pixel@xmath34 resolution from 30005900 .
the slit width was set at 2 arcsec .
the images and spectra were reduced using standard techniques . near - infrared images
were obtained of the targets for which redshifts had been determined in order to better ascertain the morphologies of the galaxies .
@xmath35 images were obtained for nearly all identified targets with nsfcam at the irtf 3 m telescope in 1998 august and 1999 february .
additional observations of 3 targets were obtained in service mode in september 1999 .
nsfcam was used in its 0.3 arcsec pixel@xmath34 mode which provides a 77@xmath3677 arcsec field .
typical total exposure times per object were 960s ; more distant objects were observed for twice this period .
conditions were photometric with seeing averaging 0.9 arcsec .
observations of standard stars from the persson et al .
( 1998 ) list were obtained and used to calibrate the images onto the california institute of technology ( cit ) system , which is defined in elias et al .
the data were reduced using standard techniques .
five targets were observed in the @xmath5 band using gemini ( mclean et al .
1993 ) at the shane 3 m telescope on 1998 october 7 .
gemini has 0.68 arcsec pixels which give it a 174 arcsec field .
objects were observed for 1080 s each in photometric conditions with seeing of @xmath71.2 arcsec .
the data were reduced using standard techniques and calibrated onto the cit system using observations of ukirt faint source standards ( casali & hawarden 1992 ) .
two distant targets were imaged at the keck i telescope with nirc ( matthews & soifer 1994 ) in 1998 april .
ff1106 + 3201 was observed in the @xmath5 band for 16 minutes and ff1614 + 3234 was observed for 32 minutes in the @xmath37 band .
both objects were observed in clear conditions with @xmath70.5 arcsec seeing .
these data were reduced using standard techniques and calibrated onto the cit system using observations of ukirt faint source standards ( casali & hawarden 1992 ) .
we attempted spectroscopic observations of approximately 150 iras / first candidates , of which 116 yielded redshift information .
the 108 with infrared imaging are listed in table 1 ; the 8 sources with redshifts but lacking infrared images are not considered further .
the sources which did not provide useful spectra were usually observed in poor conditions ; the reasons for their lack of redshifts were not because of having intrinsically challenging spectra .
the object names in table 1 are based on the first radio position .
the source in the first catalog would have the name given by the object s coordinates shown in our table 1 , in the format first j_hhmmss.s+ddmmss _ where the coordinates are truncated , not rounded . in the @xmath0 fsc , the fir source name is different from that implied by our ff name , so we have included the fsc source name as a column in table 1 .
the z designation in the fsc name means that the fir source is from the fsr catalog . the typical resolution of the spectroscopy was @xmath38 ( fwhm ) at @xmath39 , implying typical uncertainties of @xmath40 in redshift .
redshifts were determined from the spectra after identifying probable emission lines and continuum features . in practice the features most often used were the [ o ii]@xmath413727 , [ o iii]@xmath414959,5007 , and h@xmath42 lines , and the d4000 break .
the vast majority of the spectra have the emission lines characteristic of star formation ; very few show any signs , such as high ionization lines , of an agn .
four sample spectra , covering a range in redshift , signal to noise , and spectral type , are shown in figure [ spex ] . a more detailed analysis of the optical spectra
is deferred to a later paper .
the @xmath35 images are displayed for each object , along with the optical finding chart from the dss , in figure [ optir ] .
photometry of the ff objects was obtained from the @xmath35 images . in table 1 ,
the @xmath5 magnitudes within 3 arcsec diameter apertures , centered on the peak of the near - ir emission , are given for each object .
the 5 @xmath17 detection limit in most of the images is @xmath43 so the limiting factor in the uncertainty of the photometry is not the signal to noise , since most objects have magnitudes some 34 magnitudes brighter than the detection limit , but rather systematics in the zeropoint .
we estimate that the uncertainty in the zeropoint is @xmath44 mag . for most objects the 3 arcsec diameter aperture contains @xmath45 of the total light .
the morphologies of the objects tend to show signs of galaxy interactions , including tidal tails , multiple nuclei , and disturbed outer envelopes .
approximately 2/3 of the sample show such features , while 1/3 of the sample appear to be normal galaxies . a brief description of the near - ir morphology for each ff is included in table 1 .
one of the major advantages of using first in our survey is the high accuracy of its positional information .
the coordinates listed in table 1 are those of the radio source as given by the first catalog , which has an absolute astrometric uncertainty of @xmath71 arcsec .
the 20 cm vla images of all objects listed in table 1 were extracted from the first database .
the radio morphologies were classified by visual inspection of these cutout images , and by consulting the deconvolved sizes listed in the first catalog .
the 20 cm morphological information is given for each ff source in table 1 .
the 20 cm flux densities listed in table 1 have typical uncertainties of 10% at the 2 mjy level . improved @xmath0 flux densities were obtained for all objects in table 1 with the addscan utility at ipac .
in addition to the 60 @xmath1 m band used to construct our ff catalog , data at 12 @xmath1 m , 25 @xmath1 m , and 100 @xmath1 m was searched for detections .
almost none of the objects in table 1 were detected at either of the shorter two wavelengths , so no information is included from these wavebands in table 1 .
many detections were obtained in the 100 @xmath1 m data ; these are included where available in table 1 , and one @xmath17 upper limits are indicated in parentheses .
the uncertainty in the typical 60 @xmath1 m measurement in the sample is @xmath46 , and @xmath47 in the 100 @xmath1 m band where detected .
the 60 @xmath1 m and 100 @xmath1 m flux densities were used to calculate the far - infrared luminosity , as defined by sanders & mirabel ( 1996 ) : l(40500 @xmath1 m ) @xmath48 $ ] , where @xmath49 is the luminosity distance in mpc , @xmath50 $ ] , and @xmath51 . throughout this paper
we use h@xmath52 km s@xmath34 mpc@xmath34 and @xmath53 with @xmath54 .
when 100 @xmath1 m detections could not be obtained with addscan , the 1@xmath17 limiting flux densities were used in the calculation of the l@xmath55 .
the l@xmath55 are given in table 1 , and are plotted in figure [ p20vlfir ] .
the uncertainty in the l@xmath55 is dominated by a combination of the typical @xmath56 flux measurement errors and the @xmath47 uncertainty in the scaling factor c which accounts for the extrapolated flux longward of the 100 @xmath1 m band .
the reliability of the optical identification with the radio source for the objects in table 1 is very high .
the optical / radio source association with the fsc far - infrared source is less certain , because of the relatively large positional uncertainty of the @xmath0 detections .
but there are at least four reasons to believe that the identified optical / radio sources are indeed the fsc sources as well . first , in all cases , the first position is within twice the 1 @xmath17 error ellipse of the fsc source .
second , the optical spectra show emission lines typical of star - forming galaxies , as expected for most far - ir luminous objects .
third , in the cases where both 60 and 100 @xmath1 m detections were obtained , the @xmath0 flux ratios are typical of fir luminous galaxies ( soifer et al . 1987 ) .
finally , in nearly all cases the fir / radio flux ratio lies on the well - established correlation as seen in figure [ f20v60 ] .
there are at least two possible ways that the wrong association is being made .
first , a galaxy optically brighter than the identified ff source could lie just outside the @xmath0 error ellipse and still be the source of the iras detection .
but in our sample there are no such galaxies which are also detected by first , as would be expected if such objects were the true source of the fir emission .
second , a faint radio source could be missed by the first survey that would coincide with the @xmath57 source . using the rms given in the first catalog for each object ,
lower limits to the resulting @xmath58 ratios for objects beneath the @xmath59 detection limits are found to be @xmath7500 - 700 , far greater than the standard ratio for star - forming galaxies .
finally its worth noting that on average one expects to find only 0.035 first sources within the typical iras error ellipse area , so the probability of a random radio source being associated with an fsc source is low . in our sample of 108
identified ff objects , approximately 4 could be due to radio sources unassociated with the far - ir source .
although we defer the scientific analysis of the new sample to future contributions , we will briefly compare some basic global properties of our ff sample to those of other similarly large samples of high redshift ulig which have been previously published , e.g. leech et al .
( 1994 ) and clements et al .
our new sample has ulig at higher average redshift ( @xmath60 ) than that of leech et al .
( @xmath61 ) and that of clements et al .
( @xmath62 ) . as for the interaction rate ,
on which there has been some disagreement in the literature ( sanders & mirabel 1996 ) , our result that 2/3 of the sample shows signs of galaxy interactions is in agreement with leech et al .
but not clements et al . , who found that @xmath63 of their sample were interacting systems . finally , the rate of agn - type optical spectra in our sample , which is only @xmath64 , is somewhat less than the @xmath65 found by clements et al .
we do see a higher incidence of agn - type spectra at the highest l@xmath55 as has been noted previously by several studies ; for a review of this topic see sanders & mirabel ( 1996 ) .
we have constructed a new survey of ulig using a match of the @xmath0 fsc with the second version of the first catalog , which covered nearly 3000 degrees@xmath18 . by choosing for further study only optically faint matches from the dss which also fall on the radio - fir flux correlation
, we have attempted to find high redshift ulig which are powered primarily by starbursts .
optical images and spectra were obtained of 108 such targets , which were found to lie in the redshift range @xmath66 ; a redshift histogram is shown in figure [ zhist ] .
nearly all of these targets have @xmath67 greater than @xmath68 , and have a higher average redshift of @xmath69 than in other recent ulig surveys .
near - ir imaging shows that while more than the majority of objects show clear signs of galaxy interactions , nearly 1/3 appear to be normal at arcsec resolution in the @xmath5 band . with this sample ,
we intend to examine the nature of ulig evolution in future contributions .
the authors thank the staff of lick observatory for their help in obtaining the optical data , and bill vacca and dave griep at the irtf for their assistance in obtaining the near - ir data , and for conducting servicing observing for three of the sample objects .
we have made use of the online facilities provided by ipac .
we also thank bob becker for providing us with the first catalog and for help in using its contents . finally we thank rob kennicutt for a speedy referee report .
the digitized sky surveys were produced at the space telescope science institute under u.s .
government grant nag - w-2166 .
the images of these surveys are based on photographic data obtained using the oschin schmidt telescope on palomar mountain and the uk schmidt telescope .
the plates were processed into the compressed digital form with permission of these institutions .
the work by sas , wvb , and cdb at igpp / llnl was performed under the auspices of the u.s .
department of energy under contract w-7405-eng-48 to the university of california .
the work by ds was supported by igpp grants 98-ap017 and 99-ap026 . | we present a new sample of distant ultraluminous infrared galaxies .
the sample was selected from a positional cross
correlation of the @xmath0 faint source catalog with the first database .
objects from this set were selected for spectroscopy by virtue of following the well - known star - forming galaxy correlation between 1.4 ghz and 60 @xmath1 m flux , and by being optically faint on the poss . optical identification and spectroscopy
were obtained for 108 targets at the lick observatory 3 m telescope .
most objects show spectra typical of starburst galaxies , and do not show the high ionization lines of active galactic nuclei .
the redshift distribution covers @xmath2 , with 13 objects at @xmath3 and an average redshift of @xmath4 .
@xmath5-band images were obtained at the irtf , lick , and keck observatories in sub - arcsec seeing of all optically identified targets .
about 2/3 of the objects appear to be interacting galaxies , while the other 1/3 appear to be normal .
nearly all the identified objects have far - ir luminosities greater than @xmath6 , and @xmath725 % have @xmath8 . |
we consider a particular class of exact solutions of einstein s equations which describe impulsive gravitational or matter waves in a de sitter or an anti - de sitter background .
one class of such solutions has recently been derived by hotta and tanaka @xcite and analysed in more detail elsewhere @xcite .
this was initially obtained by boosting the source of the schwarzschild(anti-)de sitter solution in the limit in which its speed approaches that of light while its mass is reduced to zero in an appropriate way . in a de sitter background ,
the resulting solution describes a spherical impulsive gravitational wave generated by two null particles propagating in opposite directions . in an anti - de sitter background which contains closed timelike lines ,
the impulsive wave is located on a hyperboloidal surface at any time and the source is a single null particle with propagates from one side of the universe to the other and then returns in an endless cycle . in this paper
we investigate a more general class of such solutions .
the global structure of the space - times and the shape of the impulsive wave surfaces are exactly as summarised above and described in detail in @xcite . here
we consider a wider range of possible sources .
we present an interesting class of impulsive gravitational waves that are also generated by null particles , but these particles in general can have an arbitrary multipole structure .
the space - times are conformal to the impulsive limit of a family of type n solutions of kundt s class @xcite .
when the cosmological constant is negative , the solutions given here can be related to the impulsive limit of a class of solutions previously given by siklos @xcite .
it may be noted that a family of impulsive spherical gravitational waves have also been obtained by hogan @xcite .
these are particular ( impulsive ) cases of the robinson trautman family of solutions with a cosmological constant .
they will be discussed further elsewhere and are not related to the solutions given here .
as is well known , the de sitter and anti - de sitter space - times can naturally be represented as four - dimensional hyperboloids embedded in five - dimensional minkowski spaces .
impulsive waves can easily be introduced into these space - times using this formalism .
this is done is section 2 in which the form of the solution is constructed explicitly and the nature of its source is described .
appropriate coordinate systems for the separate cases of de sitter and anti - de sitter backgrounds are described respectively in sections 3 and 4 together with a discussion of the geometrical properties of the waves .
their relation to previously known solutions is indicated in section 5 .
we wish to consider impulsive waves in a de sitter or an anti - de sitter background . in these cases ,
the background can be represented as a four - dimensional hyperboloid @xmath0 embedded in a five - dimensional minkowski space - time @xmath1 where @xmath2 for a cosmological constant @xmath3 , @xmath4 for a de sitter background ( @xmath5 ) , and @xmath6 for an anti - de sitter background ( @xmath7 ) in which there are two timelike coordinates @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
let us now consider a plane impulsive wave in this 5-dimensional minkowski background .
without loss of generality , we may consider this to be located on the null hypersurface given by @xmath10 so that the surface has constant curvature . for @xmath4 ,
the impulsive wave is a 2-sphere in the 5-dimensional minkowski space at any time @xmath8 .
alternatively , for @xmath6 , it is a 2-dimensional hyperboloid .
the geometry of these surfaces has been described in detail elsewhere @xcite using various natural coordinate systems . in this five - dimensional notation
, we consider the class of complete space - times that contain an impulsive wave on this background and that can be represented in the form @xmath11 where @xmath12 is determined on the wave surface ( [ e2.5 ] ) .
thus , @xmath13 must be a function of two parameters which span the surface .
an appropriate parameterisation of this surface is given by @xmath14 where @xmath15 when @xmath4 and @xmath16 when @xmath6 .
in terms of these parameters , it can be shown that the function @xmath17 must satisfy the linear partial differential equation @xmath18 where @xmath19 represents the source of the wave .
it is a remarkable fact that this equation arises in such a similar form for both de sitter and anti - de sitter backgrounds .
this equation will be derived separately for both cases in the following sections . it may immediately be observed that a solution of ( [ e2.8 ] ) of the form @xmath20 const . represents a uniform distribution of null matter over the impulsive surface .
this may always be added to any other non - trivial solution . however , from now on we will only consider solutions which are vacuum everywhere except for some possible isolated sources .
let us now consider solutions that can be separated in the form @xmath21 where @xmath22 is a real constant . since @xmath23 is a periodic coordinate it follows that , for continuous solutions ( except possibly at the poles @xmath24 ) , @xmath22 must be a non - negative integer . for a vacuum solution with this condition , ( [ e2.8 ] )
reduces to an associated legendre equation @xmath25 this has the general solution @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are associated legendre functions of the first and second kind of degree 1 , and @xmath29 and @xmath30 are arbitrary constants .
the only possible nonsingular solutions involve the associated legendre functions of the first kind .
these are nonzero here only for @xmath31 , and the solutions are given by @xmath32 or any linear combination of them .
it may then be observed that the second of the above expressions can be obtained from the first by a simple `` rotation '' of the coordinates on the wave surface ( [ e2.5 ] ) , so that they are essentially the same solution .
we can thus restrict attention to the space - time ( [ e2.6 ] ) with @xmath33 .
it can then be shown that this case is conformally flat . the impulsive component in ( [ e2.6 ] )
can be removed by the discontinuous linear transformation @xmath34 where @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 is the heaviside step function .
( this does not introduce impulsive components into the weyl tensor . ) thus , these nonsingular solutions represent only the de sitter or anti - de sitter backgrounds in different coordinates . in these backgrounds , there is no equivalent to the plane impulsive gravitational wave ( for @xmath38 ) for which the weyl tensor has constant components over the wave surface .
it now follows that the only nontrivial solution of ( [ e2.9 ] ) involves the legendre functions of the second kind .
these necessarily have singularities at @xmath24 which may correspond to poles at which the sources of the impulsive wave may be located .
summing over all possible modes , a general real solution is obtained in the form @xmath39 \label{e2.10}\ ] ] where @xmath30 and @xmath40 are real constants representing the arbitrary amplitude and phase of each component .
it may be recalled that the associated legendre functions of the second kind are generated by the relation @xmath41 where @xmath42 .
the first few of these functions are given by @xmath43 which have been expressed in forms that are applicable for real @xmath44 for both @xmath45 and @xmath46 .
the first of these terms ( @xmath47 ) gives the simplest ( axially symmetric ) solution @xmath48 .
% \label{e2.12}\ ] ] in fact this is exactly the solution found by hotta and tanaka @xcite ( with @xmath49 ) which was obtained by boosting the source of the schwarzschild(anti-)de sitter space - time to the ultrarelativistic limit . in this case , the singularities correspond to sources represented by two delta functions @xmath50.\ ] ] let us now consider the further terms for arbitrary @xmath22 . from the definition of @xmath51 given in ( [ e2.10 ] ) and the identity ( [ ea.7 ] ) from the appendix , it can be shown that @xmath52\cos[m(\phi-\phi_m ) ] \nonumber % \label{e2.17 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath53 is the @xmath54 derivative of the delta function .
comparing this with ( [ e2.8 ] ) , it can be seen that each of the components @xmath55 corresponds to sources at @xmath24 given by @xmath56\cos[m(\phi-\phi_m ) ] .
\label{e2.18}\ ] ] these components describe point sources with an @xmath22-pole structure .
they have the appropriate dependence on @xmath44 as the @xmath54 derivative of the delta function , together with the appropriate periodic dependence on @xmath23 .
the multipole character of first three of these modes is clearly illustrated in fig . 1 .
( it may be noted that similar multipole sources can generate impulsive _
pp_-waves in space - times with @xmath38 @xcite . ) , @xmath57 and @xmath58 near the singular point representing one of the sources of the impulsive waves . ]
finally we observe that the solution ( [ e2.10 ] ) represents a general solution containing point sources which are arbitrary combinations of @xmath22-poles @xmath59 the constants @xmath30 represent the strength of each @xmath22-pole and @xmath40 its orientation .
when the cosmological constant is positive , it is most convenient to work with the global coordinate system given by @xmath60 in which @xmath61 $ ] , @xmath62 $ ] . in these
coordinates it can be seen that the impulsive wave is localised on the surface given by @xmath63 .
thus , on the impulsive null hypersurface @xmath64 the coordinates ( [ e3.1 ] ) are identical to those of ( [ e2.7 ] ) with the identity @xmath65 . in this case the line element ( [ e2.6 ] ) with the solution ( [ e2.10 ] ) takes the form @xmath66 now , in order to justify the equation ( [ e2.8 ] ) , we may adapt the approach of dray and t hooft @xcite . in deriving an exact solution for a spherical impulsive wave in a schwarzschild space - time , they have given field equations for such a wave in a more general class of backgrounds .
these also apply in a space - time with a positive cosmological constant . using a line element of the form @xmath67
-g(u , v)(\d\theta^2+\sin^2\theta\d\phi^2 ) \label{e3.3}\ ] ] and requiring that @xmath68 and @xmath69 on the null hypersurface @xmath70 , the field equations given in @xcite and @xcite reduce to the single equation on the impulse @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the laplacian on the sphere and the source of the wave is given by @xmath73 . now , putting @xmath74 and @xmath75 $ ] , the line element ( [ e3.2 ] ) can be transformed to the form ( [ e3.3 ] ) where @xmath76 and @xmath77 are given by @xmath78 with these , ( [ e3.4 ] ) takes the explicit form @xmath79 making the substitution @xmath80 , the laplacian on a sphere becomes @xmath81 + ( 1-z^2)^{-1}\partial_\phi\partial_\phi\ ] ] with which ( [ e3.5 ] ) takes the form ( [ e2.8 ] ) which is thus established for this case .
we now consider the explicit solutions ( [ e2.10 ] ) given by @xmath82 .
\label{e3.6}\ ] ] the simplest case in which @xmath83 for @xmath84 , is exactly the solution @xmath85 obtained by hotta and tanaka @xcite as described elsewhere @xcite .
it represents a spherical impulsive wave in a de sitter background generated by two null particles moving in opposite directions .
the particles are situated at the poles @xmath86 and @xmath87 . using these global coordinates
, it can be seen that the impulsive wave is located on the cosmological horizon of a de sitter space - time .
( this is analogous to the solution given in @xcite in which the impulsive wave is located on the horizon of a schwarzschild space - time . )
moreover , since @xmath64 on the wave , it can be seen from ( [ e3.2 ] ) that at any time the area of the spherical wavefront spanned by @xmath88 and @xmath23 is a constant equal to @xmath89 .
in fact it describes a spherical impulsive wave propagating from the north pole to the south pole in a closed form of the de sitter universe which contracts to a minimum size and then re - expands as described in @xcite and @xcite .
the general solution ( [ e3.6 ] ) of the space - time ( [ e3.2 ] ) can be seen to represent a similar wave generated by two null particles with arbitrary multipole structure .
the first few higher multipole terms are given simply by @xmath90 \cos(\phi-\phi_1 ) \nonumber \\
h_2&=&{2\over\sin^2\theta}\cos[2(\phi-\phi_2 ) ] \nonumber \\
h_3&=&-8{\cos\theta\over\sin^3\theta}\cos[3(\phi-\phi_3 ) ] . \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] it has been argued above that the area of the spherical wavefront spanned by @xmath88 and @xmath23 is a constant .
therefore this particular wave is non - expanding ( with the background either expanding or contracting through it ) . in view of this property
, we would expect that this solution can be related to a particular ( impulsive ) case of the generalised class of kundt waves with non - vanishing cosmological constant @xmath91 presented by garca daz and plebaski @xcite .
this has also been described by ozsvth , robinson and rzga @xcite as their class @xmath92 . adapting the coordinate system of @xcite , the line element for this class of solutions
can be given in the form @xmath93\d\tilde
u^2 \label{e22}\ ] ] where @xmath94 and @xmath95 is required to satisfy the equation @xmath96 it may be observed that this class is conformal to kundt s class of type n vacuum solutions with vanishing cosmological constant @xcite .
in fact it can be shown @xcite that this is the only class of vacuum solutions that are conformal to kundt s class of type n with @xmath3 zero .
since this is just the de sitter space - time when @xmath97 and @xmath5 , we can concentrate here on the case of an impulsive wave in which @xmath98 . now performing the transformation @xmath99 where @xmath100 in this case , the line element ( [ e22 ] ) becomes @xmath101
this can be seen to be exactly the solution ( [ e2.6 ] ) in which the de sitter background in the five - dimensional form ( [ e2.1 ] ) is parameterised by @xmath102 where , for consistency with ( [ e2.7 ] ) we only need to consider the impulsive wave located on @xmath103 .
in addition , the field equation ( [ e23 ] ) is identical to ( [ e2.8 ] ) .
finally , we may note that the left hand side of equation ( [ e3.5 ] ) or ( [ e23 ] ) is just the laplacian over the sphere plus two operating on a function .
it follows that the solutions described above can be rotated arbitrarily over the sphere . since the equation is linear , solutions
can therefore be constructed which contain an arbitrary number of pairs of arbitrary multipole particles distributed arbitrarily over the impulsive spherical wave .
however , the impulsive wave is unique it is a sphere of constant surface area equal to @xmath89 .
when the cosmological constant is negative , it is most convenient to introduce the global coordinate system given by @xmath104 in which @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
although this coordinate system is unconventional , it is particularly convenient for our purposes here . in these coordinates it can be seen that the impulsive wave is localised on the surface given by @xmath108 .
thus , on the impulsive null hypersurface @xmath109 , the coordinates ( [ e4.1 ] ) are identical to those of ( [ e2.7 ] ) with the identity @xmath110 . in this case the general line element ( [ e2.6 ] ) for an impulsive wave in an anti - de sitter background takes the form @xmath111 it may immediately be observed that these coordinates are naturally adapted such that the impulsive wave is given by @xmath109 , and that the wave surface of a constant negative curvature which is spanned by the parameters @xmath112 and @xmath23 do not vary with time .
the geometrical properties of these waves have been described elsewhere @xcite using different coordinate systems . basically , the impulsive wave is hyperboloidal and is generated by a single null particle moving in an anti - de sitter background which contains closed timelike geodesics .
the particle propagates from one side of the universe to the other and then returns in an endless cycle . the wave propagating in one direction
is obtained by the parameterisation @xmath113 as above , while propagation in the opposite direction can be parameterised by changing the signs of @xmath114 , @xmath115 and @xmath9 in ( [ e4.1 ] ) which is equivalent to putting @xmath116 .
it is also convenient to reparameterise the wave surfaces by introducing an alternative global coordinate system in which @xmath117 then , also putting @xmath118 and @xmath119 , ( [ e4.2 ] ) becomes @xmath120 in these coordinates , the parameterisation of ( [ e2.1 ] ) with @xmath6 is given by @xmath121 it may immediately be observed that ( [ e4.4 ] ) is conformal to an impulsive _ pp_-wave .
in fact it is the impulsive member of a family of solutions described by siklos @xcite which include the only vacuum space - times that are conformal to _ pp_-waves . in this work
, siklos found a specific family of exact type n solutions ( including possible pure radiation ) with a negative cosmological constant given by @xmath122 provided @xmath123 satisfies the equation @xmath124 where @xmath125 .
since the left hand side does not depend on @xmath126 explicitly , an arbitrary wave profile may be assumed and the solutions considered here simply correspond to the impulsive case in which @xmath127 . putting @xmath128 equation ( [ e4.6 ] ) can be written as @xmath129 which , using the coordinates @xmath113 and @xmath23 given by ( [ e4.3 ] ) , may be confirmed to be exactly of the form ( [ e2.8 ] ) .
equation ( [ e2.8 ] ) is thus justified also for the case of a negative cosmological constant .
having established the equation ( [ e2.8 ] ) in this case , we now express the explicit solutions ( [ e2.10 ] ) in the form @xmath130 . \label{e4.8}\ ] ] this now clearly represents an impulsive gravitational wave on a null hyperboloidal surface generated by a single null particle of arbitrary multipole structure located at the point @xmath131 on the surface . as in the previous section
, we may finally note that the field equation is linear and includes the laplacian over a hyperboloidal surface of constant negative curvature .
it therefore again follows that solutions can be constructed which contain an arbitrary number of arbitrary multipole particles distributed arbitrarily over the impulsive wave surface .
in his paper @xcite , siklos has also shown that , for the vacuum case ( except for some possible point sources ) , the general solutions of ( [ e4.6 ] ) for @xmath123 is of the form @xmath132 where @xmath133 is an arbitrary function of @xmath134 and @xmath125 ( holomorphic in @xmath135 ) . for space - times that are conformal to kundt waves for both positive and negative cosmological constant , ozsvth , robinson and rzga @xcite have presented the equivalent explicit vacuum solution to their equation ( [ e23 ] ) which also involves an arbitrary function which is holomorphic in @xmath136 which is related to @xmath135 by @xmath137 using ( [ e5.1 ] ) and also ( [ e4.3 ] ) with @xmath113 , a general vacuum solution of ( [ e2.8 ] ) can be written as @xmath138 where @xmath139 . in terms of the coordinates @xmath44 and @xmath23 , @xmath135
is given by @xmath140 the explicit solutions described in the current paper may easily be represented in this form . for these cases
, the siklos function @xmath123 may be expressed as @xmath141 , where @xmath142 corresponds to the distinct @xmath22-pole modes @xmath55 . for completeness
, we may now identify the expressions corresponding to the first few modes described above . for @xmath47 , the monopole solution for @xmath143
is equivalent to @xmath144\ ] ] which corresponds to @xmath145 when @xmath146 , the dipole solution for @xmath57 is equivalent to @xmath147[(x - a)^2+y^2]}\right ] \nonumber \\ & & \hskip13pc \times \big[(a^2-x^2-y^2)\cos\phi_1 + 2ay\sin\phi_1\big ] \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to @xmath148 \log{\zeta+a\over\zeta - a}.\ ] ] when @xmath149 , the quadrupole solution for @xmath58 is equivalent to @xmath150\cos2\phi_2 + 4ay(a^2-x^2-y^2)\sin2\phi_2 \over[(x+a)^2+y^2]^2[(x - a)^2+y^2]^2}\ ] ] which corresponds to @xmath151.\ ] ]
jp was supported by a visiting fellowship from the royal society and , in part , by the grant gacr-202/96/0206 of the czech republic and the grant gauk-230/96 of the charles university . 99 hotta m and tanaka m 1993 _ class .
quantum grav . _ * 10 * , 307 .
podolsk j and griffiths j b 1997 _ phys .
d _ * 56 * to appear in oct .
kramer d , stephani h , maccallum m a h and herlt e 1980 _ exact solutions of einstein s field equations _ , cambridge university press , chapter 27 . siklos s t c 1985 _ galaxies , axisymmetric systems and relativity _
m a h maccallum , cambridge university press , 247 .
hogan p a 1992 _ phys .
lett . a _ * 171 * , 21
. griffiths j b and podolsk j 1997 _ phys .
lett . a _ to appear .
dray t and t hooft g 1985 _ nucl .
b _ * 253 * , 173 .
garca daz a and plebaski j f 1981 _ j. math .
* 22 * 2655 .
ozsvth i , robinson i and rzga k 1985 _ j. math .
* 26 * 1755 . podolsk j 1993 _ phd thesis _
, charles university , prague .
it is well known that , at least in the range @xmath152 $ ] , any function can be expressed as a sum of legendre polynomials . in particular , using the identity @xmath153 , it can be shown that @xmath154 .
\label{ea.1}\ ] ] it also follows immediately from the closure property of the set of legendre polynomials that @xmath155 the associated legendre functions are generated by the relations @xmath156 by differentiating ( [ ea.1 ] ) @xmath22 times and multiplying by @xmath157 , it can be shown that @xmath158 .
\label{ea.4}\ ] ] now , let us introduce the operator @xmath159 .
then , applying the identity @xmath160p_j^m(z)=0 $ ] to ( [ ea.4 ] ) , it can immediately be seen that @xmath161 .
% \label{ea.5}\ ] ] using the definition of @xmath162 in ( [ ea.3 ] ) , this becomes @xmath163 % \label{ea.6}\ ] ] and , from ( [ ea.2 ] ) , we finally obtain that @xmath164 \label{ea.7}\ ] ] where @xmath53 is the @xmath54 derivative of the delta function . | we describe a class of impulsive gravitational waves which propagate either in a de sitter or an anti - de sitter background .
they are conformal to impulsive waves of kundt s class . in a background with positive cosmological constant they are spherical ( but non - expanding ) waves generated by pairs of particles with arbitrary multipole structure propagating in opposite directions .
when the cosmological constant is negative , they are hyperboloidal waves generated by a null particle of the same type . in this case
, they are included in the impulsive limit of a class of solutions described by siklos that are conformal to _ pp_-waves .
pacs class 04.20.jb , 04.30.nk running title : _ impulsive waves in ( anti-)de sitter space - time _ |
type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) serve as distance indicators used to measure the expansion history of the universe . although supernovae are not perfect standard candles , the peak absolute magnitude of an individual event can be inferred from observed multi - band light curves and a redshift using trained empirical relations .
sn ia optical light curves have homogeneous time evolution , which allowed them to be described by a template .
the relationship between light - curve decline rates and their correlation with absolute magnitude was noted by @xcite and further developed by @xcite , and was confirmed with the supernovae observed by the calan / tololo survey @xcite .
an observed - color parameter was added to the modeling of multi - band light curves .
today there is a suite of models that parameterize supernova light - curve shapes and colors , which are used to standardize absolute magnitudes to within a seemingly random @xmath7@xmath8 mag dispersion .
the host galaxy conveys information about the supernova progenitor environment .
although they do not describe an individual star , the host mass , specific star formation rate , and metallicity provide an expectation of the progenitor initial conditions that can be related to peak absolute magnitude .
dependence of light - curve parameters and hubble residuals ( inferred magnitudes from light curves minus those expected from the cosmological distance - redshift relation , or hubble law ) on global host - galaxy properties has been sought .
@xcite showed and @xcite confirmed that the light - curve shape parameter is correlated with host - galaxy morphology .
@xcite find that hubble residuals depend on host mass .
@xcite find a similar dependence on metallicity while @xcite find a dependence on both metallicity and specific star formation rate ( ssfr ) .
* hereafter c13b ) perform such an analysis on the supernovae of the nearby supernova factory ( snfactory , * ? ? ?
supernova distances are derived using linear magnitude corrections based on light - curve shape and color parameters from salt2 fits to snfactory synthetic photometry , using the procedure described in ; in this article these linearly - corrected distances are referred to as `` salt2 '' distances .
host mass , ssfr , and metallicity are derived from photometric and spectroscopic observations of the associated galaxies ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter c13a ) .
their findings are consistent with previous studies ; when splitting the sn ia sample by host mass , ssfr , and metallicity at @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 respectively , they find that sne ia in high - mass ( low - ssfr , high - metallicity ) hosts are on average @xmath12 mag ( @xmath13 mag , @xmath14 mag ) brighter than those in low - mass ( high - ssfr , low - metallicity ) hosts after brightness corrections based on the salt2 light - curve shape and color brightness corrections .
the hubble residuals depend on the model used to determine absolute magnitude .
although there is the expectation that the progenitor variability tracked by host - galaxy parameters must also be directly manifest within the supernova signal itself , it appears not to be captured by the light - curve models used and the associated standardization in the cited work .
the sdss - ii supernova survey , using samples divided by passive and star - forming hosts , finds hubble residual biases between both salt2- and mlcs2k2-determined distances @xcite : indication that the bias from the two light - curve fitters share a common source .
the two parameters of one model are highly correlated with the two parameters of the other @xcite , which brings to question whether a third light - curve parameter associated with host properties is not being captured by salt2 or mlcs2k2 .
although there are searches for such a third light - curve parameter associated with hubble residual bias ( e.g.@xcite who test whether heterogeneity in light - curve rise times can account for the sdss - ii result ) , as of yet no such parameter has been found .
* hereafter k13 ) expand the optical light - curve parameterization by characterizing light curves through the probability distribution function of a gaussian process for the regressed values at phases @xmath15 to 35 in one - day intervals relative to peak , rather than the parameters of a best - fit model .
the relationship between the k13 light - curve parameters and light - curve shapes can be seen in figure 4 of k13 , and are described briefly here .
the effect of the @xmath16 parameter on the light curve is relatively phase - independent and is increasingly stronger in bluer bands , very similar to the behavior of host - galaxy dust and the color parameters of other fitters .
the @xmath4 parameter affects the light - curve width and color around peak , similar to the stretch ( @xmath17 ) and @xmath18 parameters of salt2 and mlcs .
the @xmath5 parameter affects peak colors in a fashion inconsistent with dust ( @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 are positively correlated ) , controls the near - uv light curve width , and influences the light - curve decline 20 to 30-days after peak brightness .
the @xmath22 parameter most notably affects peak color and the light - curve shape through all phases of the @xmath23 band .
the k13 light curve parameters capture light - curve diversity distinct from those of salt2 ; figure 10 shows plots of salt2 versus k13 light - curve parameters .
the absolute magnitude at peak @xmath24-band brightness is taken to be an unknown function of a set of 15 light - curve parameters ; after modeling the function as a gaussian process and training , the absolute magnitude can be determined to a dispersion as low as 0.09 mag .
the larger number of light - curve parameters ( and their principal component compression ) that reduce the dispersion may be sensitive to the pertinent information encoded in the host - galaxy parameters . in this article
we look for dependence of the k13 light - curve parameters and hubble residuals on host - galaxy parameters .
k13 use a supernova dataset analyzed in c13b , so the absence of correlations between hubble residuals and host - galaxy parameters could provide positive evidence for the improved performance of the k13 method with respect to supernova environmental biases .
our sample starts with the 119 sne ia from k13 .
these objects have spectrophotometric data sets obtained by the snfactory with the supernova integral field spectrograph ( snifs , * ? ? ?
* ) that had been fully processed as of early 2011 .
the instrument has a fully filled @xmath25 spectroscopic field of view subdivided into a grid of @xmath26 spatial elements and a dual - channel spectrograph covering 32005200 and 510010000 .
the median signal - to - noise within 2.5-days of peak brightness is 10.2 per 2.4 bin .
the observing strategy provides observations of each supernova every 2 to 4 days up to @xmath27 days after maximum light . the spatial information provided by snifs enables photometric flux extraction for each spectral resolution element , making the reduced data spectrophotometric .
flux - calibrated multi - band light curves are composed of synthetic photometry calculated by integrating spectra over the transmission function of observer optical @xmath28 bands .
we are interested in the light - curve parameters and hubble residuals of the supernovae analyzed in k13 ( the same studied by c13b ) .
the objective of k13 was to calibrate absolute magnitudes at peak brightness based on light - curve shapes and colors .
the goal of this article is to examine possible biases in hubble residuals , not to minimize the dispersion as in k13 ; we therefore use a different sample selection increasing the number of supernovae used in this analysis to improve the statistics .
the supernova subsamples considered in our analysis are summarized in table [ samples : tab ] .
our * full * sample requires @xmath29 points over all bands with @xmath30 : this ensures temporal coverage to inform the regression of the multi - band light curves from roughly ten days before to forty days after @xmath24 maximum light .
a @xmath31 requirement reduces sensitivity of hubble residuals on the cosmological parameters @xmath32 and @xmath33 . in k13 ,
sn # 13 was identified as having one spectrum produce synthetic photometry discrepant with the rest of the light curve ( see their figure 3 for the effect ) . for consistency with the k13 we take the very conservative step of rejecting any supernova with
at least one synthetic photometry point @xmath34 away from the mean regressed light curve predicted by the gaussian process , even though such spectra already had been internally flagged as having processing errors .
only six objects ( each with one outlying point ) , sne # 8 , # 14 , # 85 , # 98 , # 99 , and # 111 are thus culled .
clc initial & snfactory data fully processed by early 2011 & 119 + full & @xmath35 photometric points with @xmath36 & + & @xmath37 & + & removal of sn # 13 identified in k13 as having spurious photometry & + & no photometry @xmath34 from regressed mean & 103 + early & in full sample & + & photometry at least 2 days before @xmath24 maximum & 64 + the above requirements leave a full sample of 103 supernovae . to ensure that biases are not introduced through extrapolation in the gaussian process regression
, we define the * early * sample as the subset of 64 supernovae from the full sample with data at least two days before maximum brightness . in k13 ,
the calibration of absolute magnitudes is trained for the specific restframe wavelengths probed by the observation , and several filter sets were considered .
the dispersion in hubble residuals of the validation sample of 43 sne was smallest for the absolute - magnitude calibration for the @xmath38-band of the blueshifted dark energy survey @xmath28 filter set , i.e. the rest - frame bands of a supernova at redshift @xmath39 covered by standard @xmath28 , which amount to supernova - frame effective wavelengths of 378 , 497 , 602 , and 708 nm .
these filters are annotated with a superscript @xmath40 . as our objective is to see how well sn ia distances
could be calibrated without restricting ourselves to a specific observer filter system , we use this particular training to look for the dependence of light - curve parameters and hubble residuals on host - galaxy properties .
the hubble residuals are calculated as the difference between the true and inferred peak magnitudes of the gaussian - process model from table 5 in k13 ; the true magnitude being that regressed by the light - curve model , the inferred being that regressed from light - curve shape and color parameters . they perform four distinct analyses with different training and validation sets such that each supernova was in a validation set once and only once .
for each supernova , the tabulated absolute magnitude is the one inferred while it was part of the validation set ; in this work the hubble residuals of all supernovae are treated collectively even though they were not analyzed with the same trained model .
the statistics of interest in this article can not benefit and in fact suffer from the overtraining of light - curve and absolute - magnitude models that can occur in the training process of k13 .
not all supernovae were used in the trainings of the k13 model ; `` training '' subsets were used to specify the supernova model , which in turn were used to predict absolute magnitudes of independent `` validation '' subsets . each absolute magnitude used in the current article
was determined while the supernova was in the validation set , i.e. the training did not include the supernova itself .
any overtraining of the training set thus appears as an added source of error in the absolute magnitudes .
in the present article , the signals of interest are deviations of hubble residuals that are correlated with host - galaxy properties ; no host - galaxy property information was used in the determination of the absolute magnitudes .
the early sample is a fair sample with which to examine the k13 analysis and training : supernovae lacking rise - time data extends the gaussian process regression outside of its expected range of applicability as peak magnitudes would then be extrapolated rather than interpolated .
the light curves in extrapolated regions revert toward the mean function ( the updated template of @xcite in the analysis of k13 ) , and have uncertainties bounded by the gaussian process kernel model rather than data . for this reason ,
the k13 training sample was restricted to supernovae with data earlier than 2 days before maximum .
we look for a correlation between light - curve parameters and the global host - galaxy properties of c13a in the early sample .
note that each property has a different galaxy subset for which there is a measurement ; the metallicity measurement in particular requires emission lines and no contamination from agn emission .
figure [ hosts : fig ] shows scatter plots from one of the light - curve trainings .
the @xmath16 light curve parameter is associated with color and exhibits similar trends as the salt2 @xmath41 parameter shown in c13b ; larger ( redder ) values trending with higher mass and metallicity hosts as could be explained by host - galaxy dust absorption or a color - metallicity dependence .
the @xmath4 parameter is correlated with salt2 @xmath17 and a smaller range of @xmath4 values in low - mass and low - metallicity hosts is apparent .
the @xmath5 parameter has a larger color shift compared to @xmath4 , broadens the post - maximum light curve , and shifts the height and phase of the secondary maximum in @xmath42 and @xmath43 .
there are no low @xmath5 values in low - metallicity hosts .
the @xmath22 parameter is anti - correlated with @xmath17 , and is associated with variability in uv light - curve brightness and shape as well as the red secondary maximum .
the set of extreme positive @xmath22 values are associated with high - mass galaxies .
we use the results of c13 who apply a salt2 fit and make magnitude corrections on synthetic photometry using observer - frame non - overlapping boxcar filter functions whose wavelength ranges correspond to johnson - cousins @xmath24 , @xmath44 , and @xmath45 .
the k13 hubble residuals are plotted against the salt2 residuals in figure [ resres : fig ] , with the early sample distinguished with filled symbols .
qualitatively , most of the solid points with salt2 hubble residual less than @xmath46 have k13 residuals that are closer to zero ( they lie above the @xmath47 curve ; also compare the skewness from the negative sides of the histograms in figure [ resres : fig ] . )
the positive correlation between the residuals shows that the two methods are subject to shared `` intrinsic dispersion '' that is irreducible for both . over the entire early sample
there is no significant bias between the supernova distances determined by k13 and salt2 : the distribution of the difference between their hubble residuals has mean @xmath48 mag .
however , biases do appear when the early sample is divided by global host - galaxy property .
for each host parameter , the population is split into two samples at boundaries established by previous studies : at @xmath49 for host - galaxy mass , @xmath50 for specific star formation rate , and @xmath51 for metallicity .
not all hosts have measurements of these properties ; for the early sample the number of supernovae in the low- and high - bin subsets are @xmath52 for mass , @xmath53 for ssfr , and @xmath54 for metallicity . for the full sample
the numbers are @xmath55 for mass , @xmath56 for ssfr , and @xmath57 for metallicity .
the k13 minus salt2 hubble residuals in subsets defined by these splits are given in table [ k13_salt_offsets : tab ] .
the significance of the differences are at @xmath58 , and @xmath59 for mass , specific star formation rate , and metallicity respectively .
ccccccc @xmath60 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 + @xmath67 & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & @xmath73 + the biases in k13 and salt2 hubble residuals imply that they should produce different hubble residual steps .
the mean hubble residual and intrinsic magnitude dispersion are fit for each subset defined by host - galaxy parameters and any significant signal in the mean of the less - than sample minus the greater - than sample ( i.e. the hubble residual step ) is an indicator of population dependence . a non - zero slope of a linear fit to the data also indicates dependence .
ccccccc @xmath40 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 + @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 + salt2 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 + @xmath40 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 + salt2 & @xmath106 & @xmath95 & @xmath107 & @xmath97 & @xmath108 & @xmath99 + salt2 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath114 + for the k13 4-band regressed approach , the hubble residuals and slopes are shown as a function of host galaxy mass , specific star formation rate , and metallicity in figure [ corr : fig ] . the hubble residual steps and slopes are listed in the early/@xmath40 row of table [ offsets : tab ] .
the signals for step or slope have significance @xmath115 for all cases except for the slope in ssfr that has a @xmath116 significance .
we test for the presence of significant residual correlated structure that may be not be captured in the simple step and slope statistics by assuming an underlying covariance in the hubble residuals described as @xmath117 and fitting for @xmath118 and @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is a normalization parameter , @xmath119 the correlation length , @xmath121 is the matrn function , and @xmath118 is the separation in the log galaxy parameter .
probability distribution functions of the covariance parameters are built from the best fits of multiple realizations of sets of points generated based on the data and their uncertainties . in all cases , @xmath122 falls within less than 1 standard deviation of the mean ; the data are consistent with having no correlation . to examine the influence of wavelength coverage ,
the light - curve to absolute - magnitude relation is retrained as in k13 using the same filter set but omitting the extreme bands , i.e. for @xmath80-data and @xmath87-data only .
the steps and slopes are listed as `` early/@xmath80 '' and `` early/@xmath87 '' in table [ offsets : tab ] : no significant steps are seen in either of these trainings but non - zero slopes ( at @xmath123 ) are found with ssfr for both . for the @xmath87 set in particular , the significance and size of the slope exceeds that of salt2 .
the salt2 ( v2.2.0 ) hubble residual steps and slopes are listed as the `` early / salt2 '' entry in table [ offsets : tab ] .
the significance of the mass step is reduced to @xmath124 .
splits in the other host - galaxy properties show similar weakening of the significance of the step in the two samples .
differences in the hubble residual steps from different samples or light - curve analyses are listed for select pairs in table [ offsets2:tab ] .
the steps of the various filter sets are calculated using the same supernovae and data , so their differences and uncertainties are not taken directly from table [ offsets : tab ] but are recalculated independently .
a relevant case is the effect of excluding the blueshifted @xmath125-band at 378 nm ; as noted above the @xmath87 fit has a comparatively larger and significant slope with ssfr than those of other runs .
cccc @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 + @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 + @xmath40-salt2 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 + @xmath40-salt2 & @xmath141 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 + the host - galaxy - property values used to separate the sample come from published work that searched for systematic biases .
the objective of this article is to use k13 hubble residuals to probe existing positive detections of bias residuals , not to again mine for systematics .
nevertheless , we check whether a different bias is evident in our sample .
figure [ bound : fig ] shows hubble - residual steps for a range of parameter boundaries ; there are no @xmath144 steps .
neither the k13- nor salt2-determined distances of the early sample show significant @xmath123 hubble residual steps with respect to host - galaxy properties .
we now consider how this subset behaves relative to larger subsets with relaxed criteria for the first phase of snifs data .
this bridges the results of the early sample with c13b , who use the same data and salt2 fits from the same parent supernova set to find a step at @xmath123 with host mass , consistent with previous studies @xcite .
our recalculation of salt2 hubble residual steps for the c13b sample are given in table [ offsets : tab ] as `` c13b / salt2 '' ; the results are consistent with c13b to 0.003 mag , the slight differences being due to our fitting of separate ( rather than joint ) intrinsic dispersions for each population .
the principal feature that distinguishes the early sample is the requirement for data at least @xmath145 days before peak .
we here examine the effect of changing the earliest phase required in the light curves .
while the k13 analysis is expected to be biased with underestimated uncertainties for supernovae without data coverage at peak , this does provide useful insight when bridging salt2 results of the early sample with that of the full sample . figure [ firstdate : fig ] shows the hubble residual steps with respect to host mass as a function of the required phase of first observation , and the number of low - mass and high - mass that enter each calculation .
we first consider the asymptotic limit where the first phase must be @xmath146 days after peak : this unconstraining requirement accommodates all 103 supernovae in the full sample .
table [ k13_salt_offsets : tab ] shows that like the early sample , biases between k13 and salt2 hubble residuals in the full sample only appear after spliting by host - galaxy property . k13 and salt2
hubble residual steps for the full sample are given in the `` full '' rows of table [ offsets : tab ] .
this larger set does have a positive salt2 mass - step detection at @xmath147 ; the k13 result has a less significant step detection at @xmath148 .
the steps calculated from median hubble residuals are 0.061 mag and @xmath149 mag for salt2 and k13 respectively , within @xmath150 of the weighted - mean results .
similar trends are seen with ssfr and metallicity .
note that the full sample , with a slightly smaller sample , gives results similar to c13b .
the results of the early sample are ( marginally at @xmath151 ) consistent with those of the full sample .
the complement @xmath152 sample has a step of @xmath153 , so the difference in the steps of the two samples is @xmath154 mag .
the step of the early sample is within @xmath155 of the full sample using salt2 .
the null hubble - residual step evolves into a positive signal with a slight increase in signal and slight decrease of noise .
a bias in the salt2 determination of corrected peak brightness between the early and full samples could be introduced when including or omitting rise - time data .
the reapplication of salt2 on artificial supernovae in the early sample created by removal of early data shifts magnitudes by @xmath156 mag and @xmath157 for low- and high - mass hosts respectively and a new mass step of @xmath158 ; this does not account for the 0.048 mag difference between the early and full samples .
samples defined by a more stringent first - phase requirement than the early sample have a small number and a fraction lower than the asymptotic limit of high - mass hosted supernovae .
we have performed an extensive search for physical sources of bias between observing start and host - mass : none have been found .
statistics examined include the first - phase versus local surface brightness , supernova magnitude and color at first observation , the salt2 @xmath17 light - curve shape parameter , and source of supernova discovery . for k13
, the step in the early sample is within @xmath159 of that from the full sample .
the k13 median steps are consistent with zero over all first - phase requirements .
the criterion for data at least @xmath145 days before peak for the early sample is based on the selection of k13 , fixed before any association with host - galaxy properties was made .
figure [ firstdate : fig ] shows that relaxing the criterion to include additional supernovae with coverage before peak does not affect the hubble residual step .
three supernovae with k13 hubble residuals @xmath160 mag from high - mass hosts with first data phases between maximum and 3-days after maximum , are responsible for the disparity between mean and median and the increase in hubble residual step for both k13 and salt2 .
the differences between the k13 and salt2 mass steps are calculated and shown in table [ offsets2:tab ] for the early and full samples .
the correlation between k13 and salt2 hubble residuals discussed in [ analysis : sec ] must be accounted for : the quadratic sum of the two step uncertainties and the simple by - eye comparison of the error bars in figure [ resres : fig ] overestimate uncertainty .
the difference in the k13 and salt2 mass steps for the early sample is at @xmath148 and for the late sample @xmath161 , suggesting that the lower mass step of k13 is significant .
the probabilities that the magnitude of the mass step is less for the k13 distances compared to salt2 distances are 0.954 and 0.998 for the early and full samples respectively .
the differing salt2 hubble residual steps of the early and late samples may be more efficiently attributed to some underlying light - curve parameter that is not captured by salt2 and that is not uniformly represented in the two samples ; candidate parameters include those identified in the gaussian process analysis . in a manner similar to the splitting of samples based on host - galaxy parameters ,
we now calculate salt2 hubble residual steps dividing the full sample by each of the first four k13 parameters ; results are given in table [ offsetsk13:tab ] for samples split by @xmath16 through @xmath22 in turn .
the hubble residual steps are significant ( @xmath144 ) in samples divided by @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
hubble residuals as a function of these parameters are shown in figure [ saltpca : fig ] , which also shows as a point of reference and contrast k13 hubble residuals as a function of these parameters .
the most significant step in k13 hubble residuals for the same four parameters is @xmath162 .
recall that as noted in
[ analysis : sec ] and seen in figures 69 of k13 , the k13 parameters do capture diversity in the uv and the secondary maximum at redder wavelengths that are not captured in the magnitude corrections using the salt2 parameters @xmath41 and @xmath17 .
cccc @xmath163 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 & @xmath166
absolute magnitudes for a subset of nearby supernova factory objects determined using a novel regression method and tabulated in k13 are used to measure the dependence of hubble residuals on global host - galaxy properties .
hubble residual steps with host mass , specific star formation rate , and metallicity are @xmath0 , @xmath167 , and @xmath168 mag respectively : all consistent with zero step . the salt2 hubble residual step for the same subset is @xmath94 mag , consistent with a null step at @xmath159 . as a point of comparison with a previous positive detection , @xcite
use an independent supernova sample and color stretch magnitude corrections to measure a mass step of 0.11 mag at @xmath169 .
this article s and their measurements are consistent at the @xmath170 level using k13 , and at @xmath150 using salt2 hubble residuals .
for an expanded sample of supernovae with light curves unlike those in the k13 training , the hubble residual step with mass is @xmath100 mag , which is consistent with a null step at the 8% level .
in contrast the color
stretch corrected magnitude step is @xmath106 mag , consistent with the null step at only 0.15% .
the difference between the k13 and salt2 mass steps for the full sample has an almost @xmath171 significance .
the analysis in this article differs with c13b in sample selection .
expansion of the sample to include supernovae with later first data asymptotically gives significant @xmath172 ) salt2 hubble residual steps with host - mass but not for k13 hubble residuals . to examine the difference between the early and full samples , we calculate the difference between the salt2 mass steps of the early and @xmath152 samples to be @xmath173 , a difference this large has a 4.2% chance of random occurrence .
the early and late samples do have different populations of objects , for example the early sample has a higher ratio of low - mass hosts ; however , the difference in relative fraction of high- to low - mass hosts is not statistically significant .
we conclude that there is an evolution from null to positive - signal salt2 hubble residual steps going from early to full samples , but that more statistics is required to determine whether the samples are inherently drawn from different parent distributions .
k13 hubble residual steps also evolve with sample , but asymptote at @xmath151 for the full sample .
the analysis in this article also differs with c13b in the inference of supernova absolute magnitude .
there is salt2 hubble residual dependence on both the k13 @xmath4 and @xmath5 parameters at the @xmath144 level though not meeting the @xmath171 standard for a positive detection ) that does not appear in k13 hubble residuals .
we conclude that multi - band light curves do convey information about supernova absolute magnitude that is not captured in salt v.2.2.0 .
the sample of supernova used to train salt2 may have a different supernova population than that of the snfactory data , and its performance on the results of the ensemble average is expected to improve with retraining using a subset of the snfactory sample .
the gp analysis has an advantage in that it nulls out population effects by having training and validation sets drawn from a common sample .
nevertheless , if salt2 did capture the diversity of light curves no bias would arise due to differing training and validation populations assuming that systematic changes in absolute magnitude are accompanied with changes in the time - evolving sed .
the continued study of correlations between host - galaxy properties and hubble residuals is of importance even as tools that measure distances improve .
correlations serve as important diagnostics of potential biases related to progenitor population that are not captured by light - curve parameters or absolute magnitude inference .
better accuracy can be achieved from local host - galaxy properties extracted from the region around the supernova @xcite , which can give a more accurate view of the progenitor environment compared to global properties .
physically , there is the expectation that multi - band light curves with broad wavelength coverage transmit information about the progenitor system . due to limitations in current light - curve fitters ,
some of this information has only been noted indirectly through host - galaxy properties .
this article shows that the novel light - curve analysis of k13 may be capturing more aspects of sn ia diversity .
application of the method to more supernovae will provide better statistics to test this hypothesis .
we thank dan birchall for observing assistance , the technical and scientific staffs of the palomar observatory , the high performance wireless radio network ( hpwren ) , the national energy research scientific computing center ( nersc ) , and the university of hawaii 2.2 m telescope .
we wish to recognize and acknowledge the significant cultural role and reverence that the summit of mauna kea has always had within the indigenous hawaiian community .
we are most fortunate to have the opportunity to conduct observations from this mountain .
nc acknowledges support from the lyon institute of origins under grant anr-10-labx-66 .
this work was supported by the director , office of science , office of high energy physics , of the u.s .
department of energy under contract no .
de - ac02 - 05ch11231 ; by a grant from the gordon & betty moore foundation ; in france by support from cnrs / in2p3 , cnrs / insu , and pnc , and by french state funds managed by the anr within the investissements davenir program under reference anr11idex000402 ; and in germany by the dfg through trr33 `` the dark universe . ''
nersc is supported by the director , office of science , office of advanced scientific computing research , of the u.s .
department of energy under contract no .
de - ac02 - 05ch11231 .
hpwren is funded by national science foundation grant number ani-0087344 , and the university of california , san diego . | @xcite [ k13 ] introduced a new methodology for determining peak - brightness absolute magnitudes of type ia supernovae from multi - band light curves .
we examine the relation between their parameterization of light curves and hubble residuals , based on photometry synthesized from the nearby supernova factory spectrophotometric time series , with global host - galaxy properties .
the k13 hubble residual step with host mass is @xmath0 mag for a supernova subsample with data coverage corresponding to the k13 training ; at @xmath1 , the step is not significant and lower than previous measurements .
relaxing the data coverage requirement the hubble residual step with host mass is @xmath2 mag for the larger sample ; a calculation using the modes of the distributions , less sensitive to outliers , yields a step of 0.019 mag .
the analysis of this article uses k13 inferred luminosities , as distinguished from previous works that use magnitude corrections as a function of salt2 color and stretch parameters : steps at @xmath3 significance are found in salt2 hubble residuals in samples split by the values of their k13 @xmath4 and @xmath5 light - curve parameters .
@xmath4 affects the light - curve width and color around peak ( similar to the @xmath6 and stretch parameters ) , and @xmath5 affects colors , the near - uv light - curve width , and the light - curve decline 20 to 30 days after peak brightness
. the novel light - curve analysis , increased parameter set , and magnitude corrections of k13 may be capturing features of sn ia diversity arising from progenitor stellar evolution . |
supergiant fast x ray transients ( sfxts ) are a new class of high mass x
ray binaries ( hmxbs ) discovered by ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) that are associated with ob supergiant stars via optical spectroscopy . in the x
rays they display outbursts significantly shorter than those of typical be / x ray binaries characterized by bright flares with peak luminosities of 10@xmath510@xmath6 erg s@xmath7 which last a few hours ( as observed by ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
as their quiescence is characterized by a luminosity of @xmath8 erg s@xmath7 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , their dynamic range is of 35 orders of magnitude . while in outburst
, their hard x ray spectra resemble those of hmxbs hosting accreting neutron stars , with hard power laws below 10kev combined with high energy cut - offs at @xmath930 kev , sometimes strongly absorbed at soft energies @xcite .
so , even if pulse periods have only been measured for a few sfxts , it is tempting to assume that all sfxts might host a neutron star .
the mechanism producing the outbursts is still being debated , and it is probably related to either the properties of the wind from the supergiant companion @xcite or to the presence of a centrifugal or magnetic barrier @xcite . was discovered during _ asca _
observations of the scutum arm region performed on 1994 april 12 , and 1999 october 34 as a flaring source which exhibited flux increases by a factor of 10 ( up to @xmath10 erg @xmath3 s@xmath7 ) with rising times on the order of 1hr @xcite , a strong absorption @xmath11 @xmath3 , and coherent pulsations with a period of @xmath12s . a _
chandra _ observation on 2004 may 12 , which provided the coordinates refined to arcsecond accuracy [ ra(j2000@xmath13 , dec(j2000@xmath14 @xmath15 , @xcite ] , found the source at a much fainter level ( @xmath16 erg @xmath3 s@xmath7 ) , and with a spectrum that was fit with an absorbed power - law model [ @xmath17 , @xmath18 @xmath3 ] . a newly discovered source , igr j18410@xmath00535 , was observed to flare by on 2004 october 8 @xcite , as it reached @xmath20mcrab in the 2060kev energy range ( integrated over 1700s ) and 20 mcrab in the 60200kev range .
the source was also detected in the 2060kev energy range in subsequent observations , at a flux roughly half that of the initial peak .
@xcite identified igr j18410@xmath00535 as .
@xcite established that the ir counterpart was 2mass 18410043@xmath00535465 , a reddened star with a weak double - peaked h@xmath21 emission line , initially classified as a be star , which @xcite later reclassified as b1 ib type star ; this corroborated the evidence that is a member of the sfxt class , as proposed by @xcite .
@xcite presented the first broad - band spectrum of this source , obtained with ( ibis@xmath22jem - x ) , that they fit with an absorbed power - law with @xmath23 , @xmath24 @xmath3 . in 2007
@xmath25 @xcite observed the outburst of the periodic sfxt igr j11215@xmath05952 @xcite , which allowed us to discover that the accretion phase during the bright outbursts lasts much longer than a few hours , as seen by lower - sensitivity instruments .
this is contrary to what was initially thought at the time of the discovery of this new class of sources . between 2007
october 26 and 2008 november 15 , was observed by @xmath25 as part of a sample of 4 sfxts which included igr j16479@xmath04514 , xte j1739302 , and .
the main aims were to characterize their long - term behavior , to determine the properties of their quiescent state , to monitor the onset of the outbursts and to measure the outburst recurrence period and duration @xcite .
approximately two observations per week were collected with the x ray telescope ( xrt , * ? ? ? * ) and the uv / optical telescope ( uvot , * ? ? ? * ) . during such an intense and sensitive monitoring , was the only sfxt that did not go through a bright outburst , although several on - board burst alert telescope ( bat , * ? ? ? * ) detections have been recorded @xcite . in this paper
we report on the observations of the first outburst of observed by @xmath25 on 2010 june 5 and we compare its properties with those of the prototype of the sfxt class , , which went into a bright outburst on 2010 march 04 . and count s@xmath7 detector@xmath7 , respectively .
the empty circles correspond to bat in event mode ( s / n@xmath26 ) , filled circles to bat survey mode data .
, width=321 ]
ax j1841.0@xmath00536 triggered the @xmath25/bat on 2010 june 5 at 17:23:30 ut ( trigger 423958 , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this is the first outburst of ax j1841.0@xmath00536 detected by the bat for which @xmath25 performed a slew , thus allowing broad - band data collection .
the source was detected in a 1344s bat image trigger , during a pre - planned observation , and there is an indication that the source was already in outburst before this observation began and well after it ended .
the xrt began observing the field rather late , at 17:51:50 ut ( @xmath27s ) , after the very long bat image trigger .
the automated target ( at , sequences 00423958000 - 001 ) observations lasted for several orbits , until @xmath28ks after the trigger ) .
follow - up target of opportunity ( too ) observations for a total of 10.8ks were obtained ( sequences 00030988093101 ) .
the data cover the first 11d after the beginning of the outburst .
the sfxt prototype triggered the bat on 2010 march 04 at 23:13:54 ut ( trigger 414875 , * ? ? ?
@xmath25 executed an immediate slew , so that the narrow - field instruments ( nfi ) started observing it about 395s after the trigger .
the at ran for @xmath29ks and was followed by one too observation ( 00035056149 ) for @xmath30ks until the source went into moon constraint . for the 2010 march 4 outburst of .
, width=321 ] the xrt data were processed with standard procedures ( xrtpipeline v0.12.4 ) , filtering and screening criteria by using ftools in the heasoft package ( v.6.9 ) , as fully described in e.g. @xcite .
we used the latest spectral redistribution matrices ( 20100930 ) .
the bat data were analysed using the standard bat analysis software within ftools .
mask - tagged bat light curves were created in several energy bands ( see * ? ? ? * for further details ) .
survey data products , in the form of detector plane histograms ( dph ) , are available , and were also analysed with the standard batsurvey software .
all quoted uncertainties are given at 90% confidence level for one interesting parameter unless otherwise stated .
[ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,>,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] @xmath31 is absorbing column density ( @xmath32 @xmath3 ) ; @xmath33 is 210kev observed flux ( @xmath34 erg @xmath3 s@xmath7 ) ; @xmath35 is 210kev luminosity ( @xmath36 erg s@xmath7 ) .
pow : absorbed powerlaw .
cpl : cutoff powerlaw , energy cutoff e@xmath37 ( kev ) .
hct : absorbed powerlaw , high energy cutoff e@xmath37 ( kev ) , e - folding energy e@xmath38 ( kev ) .
figure [ axj1841fig : lcv_campaign ] ( left ) shows the _
swift_/xrt 0.210kev light curve of throughout our 2008 monitoring program @xcite background - subtracted and corrected for pile - up , psf losses , and vignetting .
all data in one observation ( 12ks , typically ) were generally grouped as one point , except for the june 5 outburst , which shows up as a vertical line on the adopted scale [ fig .
[ axj1841fig : lcv_campaign ] ( right ) ] .
the observed dynamical range of this source in the xrt band is @xmath39 , considering as the lowest point a 3@xmath40 upper limit obtained on mjd 54420 at @xmath41 counts s@xmath7 , and the highest point the peak of the june 5 outburst .
[ axj1841fig : lcv_allbands ] shows the detailed light curves during the brightest part ( first orbit ) of the outburst in several energy bands .
the bat light curve is rather flat and weak , but significant signal is found at the lower energies ( 1550kev ) . for the timing analysis we converted the event arrival times to the solar system barycentre with the task barycorr and the _ chandra _ position @xcite .
we note that the xrt pc - mode readout frequency slightly undersamples the source period of @xmath424.7 s @xcite with respect to its nyquist frequency , which would guarantee an unambiguous reconstruction of the signal .
timing searches were conducted in various time intervals and energy ranges around @xmath424.7s , employing two methods : a fast - folding algorithm and an unbinned @xmath43 test @xcite . in both cases
the searches were inconclusive and we could not set meaningful upper limits on the pulsed fraction , because of the red noise and the scalloping due to the poor sampling . for the 2010 june 5 outburst of , we extracted the mean spectrum of the brightest x - ray emission ( obs .
00423958000 , @xmath441708 to 2390s ) and performed a fit in the 0.310kev band of the data , which were rebinned with a minimum of 20 counts bin@xmath7 to allow @xmath45 fitting .
an absorbed power - law model yielded a column of @xmath46 @xmath3 , a photon index @xmath47 ( @xmath48 , 17 degrees of freedom , dof ) , and a 210kev unabsorbed flux of @xmath49 erg @xmath3 s@xmath7 .
as there is no strict overlap between the bat event data and the xrt data ( see fig .
[ axj1841fig : lcv_allbands ] ) , we extracted one spectrum from the bat event file of the whole observation 00423958000 ( ` event ' ) , and one from the xrt event file in the same observation .
there are , however , bat survey data available in the interval @xmath50@xmath51s , and we extracted one ( ` survey ' ) spectrum in this restricted interval .
we performed joint fits in the 0.310kev and 14100kev energy bands for xrt and bat , respectively .
a factor was included to allow for normalization uncertainties between the two spectra .
the broad - band fits performed with the bat ` survey ' spectrum yield consistent results with the ones performed with the bat ` event ' spectrum , albeit with more unconstrained parameters due to the much more limited statistics .
therefore in table [ axj1841:tab : broadspec ] we report the fits performed with the bat ` event ' spectrum .
a simple absorbed power - law model is clearly an inadequate representation of the broad band spectrum ( @xmath52 for 29 dof ) , so we also considered other models typically used to describe the x ray emission from accreting pulsars in hmxbs , such as an absorbed power - law model with an exponential cutoff ( cutoffpl in xspec ) and an absorbed power - law model with a high energy cut - off ( highecut ) .
the latter models provide a significantly more satisfactory fit of the broad - band emission , resulting in a hard powerlaw - like spectrum below 10kev , with a roll over of the higher energies when simultaneous xrt and bat data fits are performed .
figure [ axj1841:fig : meanspec ] shows the fits for the highecut model .
table [ axj1841:tab : broadspec ] reports the average 210kev luminosities .
two estimates of the distance are available , from ( * ? ? ?
* @xmath53kpc ) and ( * ? ? ?
* @xmath54kpc ) , so we assumed 5 kpc , which is consistent with both .
figure [ axj1841fig:17544lcv_allbands ] shows the first orbit of the xrt and bat light curves of the 2010 march 04 outburst of .
the xrt count rate reaches a peak exceeding 25 counts s@xmath7 , then decreases to about 0.5 counts s@xmath7 and increases again up to about 20 counts s@xmath7 at the end of the first orbit of observations . the xrt / wt spectrum ( @xmath55@xmath56s ) , extracted with a grade 0 selection to mitigate residual calibration uncertainties at low energies , was fit with an absorbed power law resulting in @xmath57 , @xmath58 @xmath3 ( @xmath59 for 125 dof ) , and @xmath60 erg @xmath3 s@xmath7 ( unabsorbed )
. the xrt / pc spectrum ( @xmath61 to @xmath62s ) yields @xmath63 @xmath3 , @xmath64 ( @xmath65 , 17 dof ) and @xmath66 erg @xmath3 s@xmath7 ( unabsorbed ) .
we extracted a bat spectrum strictly simultaneous with the xrt one and fitted them ( 0.310kev , 1450kev ) with the same models as adopted for .
the results are in table [ axj1841:tab : broadspec ] , while figure [ axj1841:fig:17544meanspec ] shows the fits for the highecut model . for the luminosity calculation we adopted a distance of 3.6 kpc @xcite . for the 2010 march 4 outburst of .
, width=283 ]
in this paper we report our analysis of the 2010 june 5 outburst of and the 2010 march 04 outburst of the sfxt prototype . while in the first case
, the image trigger was a very long one and nfi data could be collected only @xmath67s after the trigger , when the source was relatively dim , in the second case , the slew occurred immediately after the trigger , while was still very bright . figure [ axj1841fig : best_sfxts ] ( panels e and g ) shows the full light curves of the outbursts of and as they were observed by @xmath25 for 11 and 2 days after the trigger , respectively .
the xrt light curve shows a decreasing trend from the initial bright flare from a maximum of @xmath68 counts s@xmath7 down to @xmath69 counts s@xmath7 during the first day , with several flares superimposed , hence yielding a dynamic range of approximately 900 during this outburst .
then , after three days , the source count rate rose again and reached @xmath70 counts s@xmath7 .
we estimate that the observed dynamical range of this source in the xrt band , considering the historical data we collected during our monitoring campaign ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* see fig .
[ axj1841fig : lcv_campaign ] ) is @xmath39 , hence placing it well in the customary range for sfxts .
the outburst of has similar characteristics to the one observed on 2008 march 31 , as the xrt light curve shows a peak at about 25 counts s@xmath7 , decreases to about 0.5 counts s@xmath7 and then increases again up to about 20 counts s@xmath7 at the end of the first orbit ( fig . [ axj1841fig:17544lcv_allbands ] ) .
this behaviour was previously observed in and , most notably , in igr j08408@xmath04503 @xcite and sax j1818.6@xmath01703 @xcite , so that this multiple - peak structure of the light curve could be considered a defining characteristic of the sfxt class and it is likely due to inhomogeneities within the accretion flow ( e.g. * ? ? ?
figure [ axj1841fig : best_sfxts ] compares the light curves of and with the outbursts of sfxts as observed during our monitoring campaigns with @xmath25 .
the most complete set of x ray observations of an outburst of a sfxt is the one of the periodic sfxt igr j11215@xmath05952 @xcite , which was surprisingly long .
we now know that such a length of the outburst ( hence the length of the accetion phase ) is a common characteristic of the whole sample of sfxts followed by @xmath25 , and in this respect fits right in , as its outburst lasted several days .
5952 did not trigger the bat , so it is referred to mjd 54139.94 ) .
points denote detections , triangles 3@xmath40 upper limits .
red data points ( panels e , g ) refer to observations presented here for the first time , while grey points to data presented elsewhere . where no data are plotted , no @xmath25 data were collected .
vertical dashed lines mark time intervals equal to 1 day , up to a week .
references : igr j084084503 ( 2008 - 07 - 05 , * ? ? ?
* panel a ) ; igr j11215@xmath05952 ( 2007 - 02 - 09 , * ? ? ?
* panel b ) ; igr j16479@xmath04514 ( 2005 - 08 - 30 , * ? ? ?
* panel c ) ; xte j1739@xmath0302 ( 2008 - 08 - 13 , * ? ? ?
* panel d ) ; sax j1818.6@xmath01703 ( 2009 - 05 - 06 , * ? ? ?
* panel f ) .
panels e and g report the 2010 - 03 - 04 outburst of igr j17544@xmath02619 and the 2010 - 06 - 05 outburst of ax j1841.0@xmath00536 , respectively ( this work ) .
, width=321 ] we have presented the broad - band ( 0.3100kev ) simultaneous spectroscopy of .
this allows us to make a comparison with the findings on the other sfxts that were observed in the same fashion .
the soft x
ray spectral properties observed during this flare are generally consistent with those observed with _ asca _ during the 1999 flare ( * ? ? ? * @xmath11 @xmath3 , @xmath71 ) .
as was observed relatively late after the trigger , no meaningful information can be derived on variability of the soft spectral parameters during the outburst , such as the absorbing column density .
however , we note that the value of @xmath72 in outburst follows the same trend of ` harder when brighter ' as reported in table 4 of @xcite , which was based on out - of - outburst emission . for the joint bat@xmath22xrt spectrum during the 2010 june 5 outburst ,
an absorbed power - law model is an inadequate description , and more curvy models are required .
we considered an absorbed power - law model with an exponential cutoff and an absorbed power - law model with a high energy cut - off , models typically used to describe the x ray emission from accreting neutron stars in hmxbs .
we obtained a good fit of the 0.3100kev spectrum , characterized by high absorption @xmath73 @xmath3 , a hard power law below 10kev , and a high energy cutoff .
these properties of are reminiscent of those of the prototypes of the sfxt class , [ whose data we have presented here and in @xcite ] , and xte j1739@xmath0302 ( @xcite ) .
although no statistically significant pulsations were found in the present data , is one of the 4 sfxts with known pulse period @xcite , @xmath74s , the others being igr j11215@xmath05952 ( [email protected] , * ? ? ?
* ) , igr j16465@xmath04507 ( 228@xmath756s , * ? ? ?
* ) , and igr j18483@xmath00311 ( [email protected] , * ? ? ?
* ) . while lacking the detection of cyclotron lines , which would yield a direct measurement of the magnetic field @xmath76 of the neutron star , an indirect estimate can be obtained by considering the highecut fit to the broad - band spectrum of in outburst . our value of the high energy cutoff @xmath77kev , although loosely constrained , yields a @xmath7810@xmath79 g @xcite
this value for @xmath76 , which is indeed similar to the one derived for the prototype of the sfxt class , is inconsistent with a magnetar nature of . in conclusion ,
we have shown how ax j1841.0@xmath00536 nicely fits in the sfxt class , based on the observed properties of during the 2010 june 5 outburst : a large dynamical range in x ray luminosity , the similarity of the light curve length and shape to those of the prototype of the class , and the x ray broad - band spectrum , which we show here for the first time down to 0.3kev , thus constraining both the absorption and the cutoff energy .
we thank the @xmath25 team duty scientists and science planners and the remainder of the @xmath25 xrt and bat teams , s. barthelmy in particular , for their invaluable help and support . this work was supported in italy by contract
asi - inaf i/009/10/0 , at psu by nasa contract nas5 - 00136 .
pe acknowledges financial support from the autonomous region of sardinia through a research grant under the program po sardegna fse 20072013 , l.r .
7/2007 `` promoting scientific research and innovation technology in sardinia '' .
lllllll source & sequence & obs / mode & start time ( ut ) & end time ( ut ) & exposure & time since trigger + & & & ( yyyy - mm - dd hh : mm : ss ) & ( yyyy - mm - dd hh : mm : ss ) & ( s ) & ( s ) + ax j1841.0@xmath00536 & 00423958000 & bat / evt & 2010 - 06 - 05 17:15:13 & 2010 - 06 - 05 19:01:13 & 1515 & -502 + & 00423958000 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 05 17:52:02 & 2010 - 06 - 05 18:03:24 & 682 & 1708 + & 00423958001 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 05 19:02:59 & 2010 - 06 - 06 09:46:49 & 6111 & 5965 + & 00030988093 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 07 21:07:22 & 2010 - 06 - 07 21:23:58 & 969 & 186228 + & 00030988094 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 08 14:49:26 & 2010 - 06 - 08 15:05:56 & 977 & 249952 + & 00030988095 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 09 16:18:40 & 2010 - 06 - 09 16:38:56 & 1212 & 341705 + & 00030988096 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 10 19:47:57 & 2010 - 06 - 10 21:33:56 & 1414 & 440663 + & 00030988097 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 11 13:10:31 & 2010 - 06 - 11 13:35:56 & 1503 & 503217 + & 00030988098 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 13 13:41:14 & 2010 - 06 - 13 15:23:58 & 848 & 677859 + & 00030988099 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 14 04:09:44 & 2010 - 06 - 14 05:58:57 & 1554 & 729969 + & 00030988100 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 15 02:39:58 & 2010 - 06 - 15 04:22:57 & 1184 & 810983 + & 00030988101 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 06 - 16 03:55:52 & 2010 - 06 - 16 04:14:58 & 1110 & 901937 + igr j17544@xmath02619 & 00414875000 & bat / evt & 2010 - 03 - 04 23:10:00 & 2010 - 03 - 04 23:30:02 & 1202 & -239 + & 00414875000 & xrt / wt & 2010 - 03 - 04 23:20:40 & 2010 - 03 - 05 00:47:11 & 421 & 401 + & 00414875000 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 03 - 04 23:27:59 & 2010 - 03 - 05 00:49:12 & 1520 & 840 + & 00414875001 & xrt / wt & 2010 - 03 - 05 01:21:58 & 2010 - 03 - 05 08:48:39 & 783 & 7679 + & 00414875001 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 03 - 05 01:22:03 & 2010 - 03 - 05 09:02:56 & 2502 & 7684 + & 00035056149 & xrt / pc & 2010 - 03 - 06 00:59:19 & 2010 - 03 - 06 01:33:50 & 801 & 92721 + | _ swift _ observed an outburst from the supergiant fast x ray transient ( sfxt ) ax j1841.0@xmath00536 on 2010 june 5 , and followed it with xrt for 11 days .
the x ray light curve shows an initial flare followed by a decay and subsequent increase , as often seen in other sfxts , and a dynamical range of @xmath1 .
our observations allow us to analyse the simultaneous broad - band ( 0.3100kev ) spectrum of this source , for the first time down to 0.3kev , which can be fitted well with models usually adopted to describe the emission from accreting neutron stars in high - mass x
ray binaries , and is characterized by a high absorption ( @xmath2 @xmath3 ) , a flat power law ( @xmath4 ) , and a high energy cutoff .
all of these properties resemble those of the prototype of the class , igr j17544@xmath02619 , which underwent an outburst on 2010 march 4 , whose observations we also discuss .
we show how well ax j1841.0@xmath00536 fits in the sfxt class , based on its observed properties during the 2010 outburst , its large dynamical range in x ray luminosity , the similarity of the light curve ( length and shape ) to those of the other sfxts observed by _
swift _ , and the x ray broad - band spectral properties . [ firstpage ] x - rays : binaries - x - rays : individual : ax j1841.0@xmath00536 - x - rays : individual : igr j17544@xmath02619 facility : _ swift _ |
a submanifold @xmath0 in some symplectic manifold @xmath1 is called lagrangian if @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
a simple example is given by the zero section @xmath4 in the cotangent bundle of a smooth manifold @xmath5 , and this is universal in the sense that a neighborhood of any lagrangian embedding of a closed @xmath5 into some symplectic manifold is symplectomorphic to a neighborhood of @xmath6 .
lagrangian submanifolds play a fundamental role in symplectic geometry and topology , as many constructions and objects can be recast in this form .
in fact , already in a 1980 lecture ( cf .
@xcite ) , a. weinstein formulated the `` symplectic creed '' : _ everything is a lagrangian submanifold .
_ today , lagrangian submanifolds ( sometimes decorated with additional structures ) are for example studied as objects of the _ fukaya category _ , which plays a fundamental role in kontsevich s formulation of homological mirror symmetry . rather than delving into such general theories ,
i want to concentrate here on a quite simple , and in fact basic , question : _ which closed , oriented @xmath7-manifolds admit a lagrangian embedding into the standard symplectic space @xmath8 , with @xmath9 ? _ an excellent introduction to this question , containing a discussion of some of the relevant classical algebraic topology , as well as early results obtained by holomorphic curve methods , is @xcite , which i will quote freely . for @xmath10
there is not much to say , since @xmath11 is the only connected closed 1-manifold , and the lagrangian condition @xmath12 is trivial in this case . in general , a necessary condition for an oriented closed manifold @xmath13 to admit a lagrangian embedding into @xmath14 is that its euler characteristic @xmath15 should vanish .
this is because the self - intersection number of any submanifold of @xmath14 is clearly zero , but it is also equal to the euler characteristic of the normal bundle , which for lagrangian submanifolds is isomorphic to the cotangent bundle .
so for @xmath16 , the only orientable closed manifold that could have a lagrangian embedding into @xmath17 is @xmath18 , and it embeds e.g. as the product of one circle in each @xmath19-factor . for non - orientable
closed surfaces @xmath20 , classical algebraic topology implies that a necessary condition for the existence of a lagrangian embedding is that @xmath21 is divisible by 4 , and a beautiful construction by givental @xcite shows that for strictly negative euler characteristic this is also sufficient .
the embedding question was only recently completely answered , when shevchishin showed that the klein bottle does not have a lagrangian embedding into @xmath17 ( @xcite , see also @xcite for an alternative argument by nemirovski ) . already for
@xmath22 , elementary algebraic topology does not tell us much .
it was one of the many important results in gromov s landmark paper @xcite to show that there are no exact lagrangian embeddings into @xmath23 , in the sense that any global primitive @xmath24 of the symplectic form @xmath25 has to restrict to a non - exact closed 1-form on the lagrangian submanifold @xmath26 .
this in particular rules out @xmath27 , but of course there are plenty of closed orientable 3-manifolds with @xmath28 . all of this and more is discussed in @xcite .
the goal of this chapter is to show how knowledge about string topology can be applied to give a far - reaching refinement of gromov s result .
in particular , i aim to present the overall strategy for proving the following result : ( fukaya)[thm : fukayamain ] let @xmath5 be a compact , orientable , aspherical spin manifold of dimension @xmath7 which admits an embedding as a lagrangian submanifold of @xmath14 . then a finite covering space @xmath29 of @xmath5 is homotopy equivalent to a product @xmath30 for some closed @xmath31-manifold @xmath32 .
moreover , @xmath33 is the centralizer of some element @xmath34 which has maslov class equal to 2 and positive symplectic area .
the assertion about the maslov class is known as _ audin s conjecture _ , and was originally asked for tori in @xmath14 , see @xcite .
the spin condition is a technical assumption ( it is needed to make the relevant moduli spaces of holomorphic disks orientable ) , and i expect that it can be removed by reformulating the argument somewhat . the asphericity assumption ( meaning that all higher homotopy groups of @xmath5 vanish ) enters the proof in a fairly transparent way , and one can imagine various replacements . as a corollary , we obtain the following more precise statement in dimension 3 .
( fukaya)[cor : fukaya1 ] if the closed , orientable , prime 3-manifold @xmath5 admits a lagrangian embedding into @xmath35 , then @xmath5 is diffeomorphic to a product @xmath36 of the circle with a closed , orientable surface .
the fact that the product @xmath36 does embed as a lagrangian submanifold into @xmath35 follows from an elementary construction , see e.g. @xcite . basically , one starts from an isotropic embedding of @xmath20 into @xmath35 , e.g. by embedding it into the lagrangian subspace @xmath37 .
then one uses the fact that a small neighborhood necessarily is symplectomorphic to a neighborhood of the zero section in @xmath38 , the direct sum of the cotangent bundle with a trivial symplectic vector bundle of rank 2 , to embed the product @xmath36 by taking the product of the zero section in @xmath39 with a standard small @xmath40 .
the above statements are special cases of a more general result discovered by kenji fukaya , and first described in @xcite , see also @xcite . as with most results involving @xmath41-holomorphic curves , the underlying idea can be traced back to misha gromov s foundational paper @xcite .
his proof of the fact that there are no exact compact lagrangian submanifolds of @xmath14 contains an important seed for fukaya s arguments . therefore , after discussing some aspects of moduli spaces of holomorphic disks in the next section , i begin section [ sec : main ] by sketching gromov s argument , followed by the discussion of an instructive example and the statement of fukaya s refinement ( theorem [ thm : blackbox ] ) . in a nutshell , fukaya s important observation was that the compactification of the moduli spaces of holomorphic disks with boundary on a lagrangian submanifold @xmath42 can be expressed in terms of string topology operations , in particular the loop bracket ( and possibly also its higher analogues at the chain level ) . after an interlude section on basic properties of l@xmath43 algebras ,
i describe how theorem [ thm : fukayamain ] is a fairly straightforward consequence of theorem [ thm : blackbox ] .
corollary [ cor : fukaya1 ] will follow by using specific facts from 3-dimensional topology . before finishing with a guide to the literature ,
i discuss a few further small observations . at the moment of this writing , full proofs of
the above theorems are not available yet .
one would like to construct a chain model @xmath44 for the free loop space of the manifold @xmath5 with the loop bracket operation @xmath45 ( and higher operations as necessary ) , such that @xmath46 is an l@xmath43-algebra .
moreover when this model is considered with coefficients in a suitable novikov ring , the compactified moduli spaces of holomorphic disks should give rise to an element in this chain complex satisfying the maurer - cartan equation in this l@xmath43-algebra .
so the principal problem is that the apparent freedom one has in building the chain model is severely constrained by the need to make it fit with the analysis of holomorphic disks , which in particular involves delicate transversality and gluing issues . in this text
, i will largely ignore the technical difficulties , by stating the key results as black boxes .
the main tool in our study of lagrangian embeddings @xmath47 will be moduli spaces of holomorphic disks with boundary on @xmath5 . before introducing the relevant spaces
, i will briefly review some standard notions .
the first of these is the _ maslov index _ of a loop of lagrangian subspaces in @xmath14 .
the lagrangian grassmannian @xmath48 is defined as the space of all lagrangian subspaces of @xmath49 .
standard symplectic linear algebra shows that a real @xmath7-dimensional subspace @xmath50 is lagrangian if and only if it is orthogonal with respect to the standard euclidean inner product to @xmath51 , its rotation by @xmath52 .
moreover , any orthonormal basis of a lagrangian subspace is a unitary basis of @xmath14 , and conversely the real linear span of a unitary frame is a lagrangian subspace .
since @xmath53 acts transitively on the unitary frames generating the same lagrangian subspace , one concludes that @xmath48 can be identified with @xmath54 .
the map @xmath55 which associates to a unitary matrix the square of its determinant induces a well - defined map @xmath56 , and for any loop @xmath57 we define _ its maslov index _ as @xmath58 clearly @xmath59 so defined is an invariant of the free homotopy class of @xmath60 . moreover , one can check that @xmath61 induces an isomorphism @xmath62 . now given a lagrangian immersion @xmath63 , any loop @xmath64 determines a loop in @xmath48 , simply by taking the loop of tangent spaces of @xmath5 at the image points of @xmath60 . in this way , we get a maslov index @xmath65 discussions of the maslov index can be found in various texts , see e.g. @xcite , @xcite or @xcite . in particular , it is easy to see that for a lagrangian immersion of an oriented manifold @xmath5 , the maslov index takes values in @xmath66 .
another useful notion is the _ area _ or _ energy _ of a disk @xmath67 with boundary on a lagrangian submanifold @xmath68 .
it is defined as @xmath69 and one easily checks that it only depends on the free relative homotopy class of @xmath70 .
indeed , just observe that given a homotopy @xmath71 \times d , [ 0,1 ] \times { { \partial}}d ) \to ( { { \mathbb{c}}}^n , l)$ ] with @xmath72 and @xmath73 , we have @xmath74 \times { { \partial}}d } h^*\omega = 0\ ] ] by the assumption that @xmath5 is a lagrangian submanifold . in particular , @xmath75 descends to a homomorphism @xmath76 .
finally , in order to discuss holomorphic curves , we introduce the relevant spaces of almost complex structures .
generally , an _ almost complex structure _
@xmath41 on some manifold @xmath77 is an automorphism of the tangent bundle @xmath78 with @xmath79 .
if @xmath77 carries a symplectic form @xmath80 , then an almost complex structure @xmath41 on @xmath77 is said to be _ tamed by _
@xmath80 , if @xmath81 for all nonzero tangent vectors @xmath82 .
in other words , @xmath80 is a positive area form on each 1-dimensional @xmath41-complex subspace of each tangent space .
it is a standard result that these @xmath80-tamed almost complex structures form a contractible ( in particular non - empty ) space .
given such a tamed @xmath41 , one can define a riemannian metric on @xmath77 by setting @xmath83 one can also define the notion of a @xmath41-holomorphic map @xmath84 from some riemann surface @xmath85 to @xmath77 , simply by asking that it satisfy the usual cauchy - riemann equations with respect to the given @xmath41 : @xmath86 in local conformal coordinates @xmath87 on the riemann surface this can be written equivalently as @xmath88 in riemannian geometry , the @xmath89-energy of a map @xmath90 is defined as @xmath91 where @xmath61 is any volume form on @xmath20 and @xmath92 denotes the operator norm of @xmath93 with respect to the metric @xmath94 on @xmath20 and the metric @xmath95 on @xmath77 .
the integrand turns out to be independent of the choice of @xmath61 , as any scaling factor also appears in the operator norm with opposite exponent .
now the importance of the taming condition stems from the following crucial fact : suppose @xmath96 is @xmath41-holomorphic , and we have chosen local conformal coordinates @xmath97 on @xmath20 . then at @xmath98 we have @xmath99 so that @xmath100 in particular , for @xmath41-holomorphic disks
@xmath101 , the energy as defined above , which was a purely topological quantity , is the same as the usual @xmath89-energy of the map @xmath70 .
choose an almost complex structure @xmath41 tamed by the standard symplectic structure @xmath25 on @xmath14 . given a relative homotopy class @xmath102
, we consider the set @xmath103 = a \in \pi_2({{\mathbb{c}}}^n , l)\}.\ ] ] the real 2-dimensional group @xmath104 of biholomorphisms of the disk fixing @xmath105 acts on @xmath106 by precomposition , and the quotient @xmath107 is called the moduli space of holomorphic disks in the class @xmath108 . the reader should take note that in the literature moduli spaces of holomorphic curves are almost universally denoted by @xmath109 , usually with some decoration , and the precise meaning of the symbol should very carefully be checked in each case .
the equation defining @xmath106 is elliptic , and so the linearization is a fredholm operator . the index theorem for holomorphic curves , as discussed for example in ( * ? ? ?
* appendix c ) , implies that the index of this operator , and hence the expected dimension of the moduli space @xmath106 , is @xmath110 .
the assignment @xmath111 can be viewed as a section of a suitable banach space bundle . under favourable circumstances this section
can be arranged to be transverse to the zero section , in which case its zero set @xmath112 is a manifold of the expected dimension . in general
, this is a serious technical difficulty beyond the scope of the present discussion , and resolving it requires substantial work .
note that , for @xmath113 , the action of @xmath114 on @xmath106 is free .
so , assuming that we can arrange transversality , we conclude that @xmath115 is a smooth manifold of dimension @xmath116 as shown by examples in @xcite , one generally needs the spin condition on @xmath5 to be able to orient the moduli spaces @xmath115 . for several reasons the individual spaces @xmath115 tend to not be very useful for proving anything interesting about @xmath5 ( with the notable exception of theorem [ thm : gromov - notexact ] ) .
the first is that these spaces strongly depend on @xmath41 , as simple examples show .
[ ex : nosol ] consider @xmath117 and the relative homotopy class @xmath118 which has degree 1 in the first factor and degree 0 in the second .
given any real number @xmath119 , consider the almost complex structure @xmath120 on @xmath17 given by the matrix @xmath121 if @xmath122 ranges in some interval @xmath123 , then all the @xmath120 are tamed by the symplectic form @xmath124 on @xmath125 . now for the standard split complex structure @xmath126 on @xmath17 , the moduli space @xmath127 is clearly non - empty , since for any @xmath128 the map @xmath129 defines an element in it . in general
, given any @xmath120-holomorphic map @xmath70 in the class @xmath108 , note that the projection @xmath130 onto the first @xmath19-factor is holomorphic in the usual sense , and since it has degree 1 it will be a biholomorphism .
so , precomposing with a suitable element of @xmath114 , we may assume that this projection @xmath130 is just a rotation by @xmath131 .
a short computation shows that in this case for @xmath70 to be @xmath120-holomorphic , it is necessary and sufficient that @xmath132 now if @xmath133 is a solution of this equation , then @xmath134
so for @xmath135 the moduli space @xmath136 is empty .
the phenomenon discussed in this example is a crucial ingredient in the proof below of gromov s theorem [ thm : gromov - notexact ] . a second , related complication is the failure of compactness , a simple instance of which is described in example [ ex : noncompact ] below
. both of these apparent problems can be overcome by considering the collection of all @xmath137 at once . in the next subsection
, i briefly discuss the compactness issue .
gromov s compactness theorem , in its modern formulation , asserts that every sequence of holomorphic curves of fixed topology and uniformly bounded energy , whose images lie within a compact subset of the target , has a subsequence converging in a suitable sense to a limiting `` stable curve '' .
a proof in text book form for holomorphic spheres was given by mcduff and salamon @xcite , and an exposition of gromov s proof for the higher genus case was written up by hummel @xcite .
the case of curves with boundary is for example discussed by liu as part of her ph.d .
thesis @xcite . for holomorphic disks with lagrangian boundary conditions the precise statement and proof
were worked out in u. frauenfelder s diploma thesis , published as @xcite . here
, i will describe the statement under the simplifying assumption that the target symplectic manifold @xmath1 is exact , i.e. @xmath138 , as in the case of my main example @xmath139 .
this assumption in particular implies that there are no non - constant holomorphic spheres in @xmath140 , and so the possible limiting configurations are much more restricted than in the general case .
basically , all the stable curves arising as gromov limits will be stable trees of disks , as explained presently .
recall that a _ tree _ is a ( finite ) set @xmath141 together with an edge relation @xmath142 satisfying the following conditions : * ( symmetric ) * if @xmath143 then @xmath144 . *
( antireflexive ) * if @xmath143 then @xmath145 . *
( connected ) * for all @xmath146 with @xmath147 there exist @xmath148 with @xmath149 , @xmath150 and such that @xmath151 for all @xmath152 . *
( no cycles ) * if @xmath153 satisfy @xmath151 and @xmath154 for all @xmath155 then @xmath156 .
one usually draws trees by drawing the corresponding 1-dimensional cw - complexes , which have one vertex for each @xmath157 and one ( unoriented ) 1-cell connecting @xmath122 and @xmath158 whenever @xmath143 ( and @xmath144 ) .
it follows from these axioms that the cw - complex corresponding to a tree in this way is connected and contractible .
moreover , deleting an edge connecting two vertices @xmath146 splits the cw - complex into two connected components , and we denote the subset of vertices in the component of @xmath158 by @xmath159 .
@xmath122 [ br ] at 32 45 @xmath158 [ l ] at 86 39 @xmath159 [ tl ] at 133 19 and @xmath158 , and the corresponding subtree @xmath159.,title="fig : " ] a map @xmath160 is called a _ tree homomorphism _
if for each @xmath161 the preimage @xmath162 is a tree , and moreover @xmath143 implies that either @xmath163 or @xmath164 .
a bijective tree homomorphism is called _ tree isomorphism_.
@xmath122 [ l ] at 480 311 @xmath158 [ l ] at 560 284 @xmath60 [ l ] at 639 269 @xmath165 [ l ] at 565 127 @xmath166 [ l ] at 76 347 @xmath167 [ l ] at 297 270 @xmath168 [ l ] at 303 182 @xmath169 [ l ] at 327 82 next we fix an exact symplectic manifold @xmath1 with a compact lagrangian submanifold @xmath170 and an almost complex structure @xmath41 tamed by @xmath80 . given this data ,
we define a _ stable tree of holomorphic disks with one boundary marked point _ to be a tuple @xmath171 modelled over a tree @xmath172 , consisting of a collection of holomorphic maps @xmath173 indexed by @xmath174 , a collection of nodal points @xmath175 indexed by directed edges @xmath143 , and a marked point @xmath176 labelled by @xmath177 , subject to the following conditions : 1 . if @xmath143 then @xmath178 .
2 . for each @xmath157 ,
the _ special boundary points associated with the vertex @xmath122 _ , namely the points @xmath179 for different @xmath180 with @xmath143 , together with @xmath181 for @xmath182 , are all pairwise distinct .
3 . if @xmath183 is constant , then the cardinality of the set @xmath184 of all special points is at least 3 . as usual , two such stable trees of disks @xmath185 and @xmath186 modelled on trees @xmath141 and @xmath187 , respectively ,
are called _ equivalent _ if there exist a tree isomorphism @xmath188 and a collection of mbius transformations @xmath189 such that @xmath190 for all @xmath191 with @xmath143 .
define the _ energy _ of a stable tree of holomorphic disks as the sum @xmath192 now we can give the relevant notion of convergence .
let @xmath1 be an exact symplectic manifold , let @xmath170 be a compact lagrangian submanifold , and let @xmath41 be an @xmath80-tame almost complex structure on @xmath140 .
a sequence @xmath193 of holomorphic disks with one boundary marked point @xmath194 is said to _ gromov converge _ to a stable tree of disks @xmath195 with one boundary marked point if there exist sequences of elements @xmath196 indexed by @xmath157 such that the following statements hold : 1 .
the sequence @xmath197 converges to @xmath181 .
2 . for every @xmath157 , the sequence of maps @xmath198 converges to @xmath183 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath199 .
if @xmath143 then @xmath200 converges to @xmath179 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath201 .
4 . if @xmath143 then @xmath202 intuitively , one can imagine the mbius transformations @xmath203 as microscopes , focusing on subregions in the domain to detect some piece of the limiting map . item ( 3 ) in the definition then says that different microscopes really capture different phenomena
. item ( 4 ) is a way of phrasing that the limit captures all the essential pieces . in particular , together with ( 2 )
it implies that @xmath204 now gromov s compactness theorem for disks can be stated as follows .
let @xmath1 be an exact symplectic manifold , let @xmath170 be a compact lagrangian submanifold , and let @xmath41 be an @xmath80-tame almost complex structure on @xmath140 .
suppose @xmath193 is a sequence of holomorphic disks with bounded energy such that all images are contained in some compact subset of @xmath140 .
then @xmath205 has a gromov convergent subsequence .
moreover , for a convergent sequence @xmath205 the limit is unique up to equivalence .
a careful exposition of the proof of this theorem , without the simplifying assumption that @xmath140 is exact , can be found in @xcite . rather than going into details here
, i will illustrate the phenomenon by considering a specific example .
[ ex : noncompact ] the situation is interesting already for holomorphic disks with boundary on @xmath40 with respect to the standard complex structure @xmath126 . by the maximum principle ,
these are necessarily maps @xmath206 .
they exist for all non - negative degrees , and the degree @xmath207 of the map equals the degree of its restriction to the boundary circle .
it turns out that the maslov index of the class @xmath208 is @xmath209 .
applying the general index formula , one finds that @xmath210 for @xmath211 , this index equals 1 .
indeed , the group of holomorphic degree 1 maps , i.e. holomorphic automorphisms of @xmath212 is 3-dimensional ( it can be identified with @xmath213 ) . in fact , any element of this group can be written uniquely as a composition @xmath214 , where @xmath215 is a rotation given by @xmath216 and @xmath217 is a map fixing @xmath218 . since we only consider the moduli space of maps up to the equivalence relation of precomposing with an element of @xmath114 , the moduli space can be identified with @xmath11 by recording the image of @xmath105 under any map in the equivalence class . in particular , the moduli space @xmath219 is compact .
next consider a map of higher degree @xmath220 .
again any such map can be written as a composition @xmath214 , where @xmath221 is a product ( not composition ! ) of @xmath207 maps of degree @xmath222 , each fixing @xmath223 , and @xmath215 is a rotation .
the map @xmath221 is characterized completely in terms of its zeros , counted with multiplicities .
in fact , if these zeros are @xmath224 ,
, @xmath225 , then we have @xmath226 by precomposing with an appropriate @xmath227 , we may always arrange that one of the zeros , say @xmath225 , equals 0 .
the coordinates of the other zeros give @xmath228 free local parameters for @xmath221 , and together with the rotation parameter for @xmath215 we get @xmath229 as predicted by the dimension formula above .
the moduli space @xmath230 of degree @xmath220 self - maps of the disk @xmath212 is noncompact .
in fact , consider representative maps @xmath231 of a sequence of points in the moduli space and orderings of the zeros @xmath232 of @xmath231 such that @xmath233 ( as above , this can be arranged by precomposing a given representative with some element of @xmath114 , which does not change the equivalence class ) .
after passing to a subsequence , we get convergence of the @xmath234 to some limiting @xmath235 for each @xmath236 .
the formula above still makes sense in the limit , but the `` zeros '' @xmath237 which lie on the circle @xmath11 contribute a trivial factor of @xmath222 to the product .
so if there are @xmath238 of these `` phantom '' zeros , the naive limiting map @xmath239 will have degree @xmath240 and so it is not an element of @xmath241 .
notice that in the above discussion , we made two arbitrary choices : a choice of ordering @xmath234 of the zeros of @xmath231 , and the choice to always reparametrize so that @xmath233 .
suppose for definiteness that with these choices we have @xmath242
. then there are unique maps @xmath243 such that @xmath244 , and so we get a different sequence of representatives @xmath245 of the same divergent sequence of points in the moduli space @xmath241 . just as above we get a , generally different , limiting map @xmath246 for a suitable subsequence .
note that in this reparametrization , we will have @xmath247 , and so @xmath246 has degree @xmath248 .
if we would analyse the situation fully , we would recover , for a suitable subsequence , the existence of finitely many sequences of mbius transformations @xmath249 , such that the reparametrized maps @xmath250 converge to some limiting map @xmath251 of degree @xmath252 in such a way that @xmath253 .
in addition , these maps fit together and form a disk tree as described in the compactness theorem above .
very roughly , the compactness theorem asserts that one can compactify a given space @xmath115 by adding pieces built out of moduli spaces @xmath254 with @xmath255 .
this compactification is often denoted by @xmath256 .
it admits an obvious stratification , where the stratum of codimension @xmath257 corresponds to stable trees of disks modelled on trees with exactly @xmath257 ( unoriented ) edges .
indeed , the heuristic dimension count proceeds as follows .
denote by @xmath258 the number of special points on the disk associated to @xmath157 and by @xmath259 its relative homotopy class .
note that @xmath260 , where @xmath257 is the number of edges of the tree , since we had one marked point to start with and each edge gives rise to two nodal points .
the formal dimension of the moduli space of disks associated to the vertex @xmath261 is @xmath262 requiring that the nodal points corresponding to an edge in @xmath141 are mapped to the same point in @xmath5 gives @xmath263 constraints . putting these together , we find that the formal total dimension equals @xmath264 _ if _
, for a given @xmath41 , all the moduli spaces appearing in the compactification @xmath256 were transversely cut out , one could hope to prove a _ gluing theorem _ , asserting that in fact the compactified moduli space is a manifold with boundary and corners .
this is generally too much to ask . in @xcite , fukaya , oh
, ohta and ono describe a procedure to put a so - called _ kuranishi structure _ on the compactified moduli spaces . without going into details , this
roughly means that these spaces admit fundamental chains _ that make them function as if they were manifolds with corners_. theorem [ thm : blackbox ] below should be understood in this sense .
presumably , the ongoing polyfold project of hofer , wysocki and zehnder ( cf .
@xcite ) will eventually lead to an alternative approach to the problem of putting enough structure on the compactified moduli space to prove a statement like theorem [ thm : blackbox ] .
as already mentioned , it is instructive to review the proof for the following well - known theorem of gromov .
[ thm : gromov - notexact ] if a compact manifold @xmath5 admits a lagrangian embedding into @xmath14 , then @xmath265 .
( sketch ) i sketch the proof of this theorem given in ( * ? ? ?
* section 9.2 ) , slightly rephrasing the end of the argument in order to make the relation to the following discussion even more apparent .
fix a lagrangian embedding @xmath47 , and choose a vector @xmath266 with @xmath267 .
consider the set @xmath268 \times d \times { { \mathbb{c}}}^n)$ ] of hamiltonian functions such that @xmath269 the idea is to consider , for a fixed @xmath270 , the moduli space @xmath271 of maps @xmath272 satisfying the following conditions : * @xmath273 for some @xmath274 $ ] , and * the relative homotopy class @xmath275 \in \pi_2({{\mathbb{c}}}^n , l)$ ] vanishes .
so for @xmath276 , we are considering holomorphic disks with boundary on the lagrangian @xmath5 , and since the relative homotopy class vanishes , these are precisely the constant maps
. note that we do not divide out any automorphisms here , since for positive @xmath24 these have no reason to preserve the solution space to the equation .
one can prove that for fixed small @xmath277 , there is still a compact @xmath7-dimensional family of solutions .
in fact , for generic choice of the hamiltonian @xmath278 , standard transversality techniques show that @xmath271 is a smooth @xmath279-dimensional manifold , whose boundary consists of those elements with @xmath280 .
on the other hand , a straightforward computation as in example [ ex : nosol ] shows that , for our choice of @xmath108 , there are no solutions to the equation with @xmath281 .
so if @xmath271 was compact , it would give a smooth cobordism from @xmath5 to the empty set .
now consider the evaluation map @xmath282 from what we said above , the boundary of this @xmath283-chain in the free loop space of @xmath5 is the cycle of constant loops
@xmath284 \in c_n(\lambda l)$ ] .
since this cycle is nontrivial in homology , @xmath271 can not be compact .
it follows from elliptic regularity theory ( cf .
* theorem 4.1.1 ) ) that if compactness fails , there is a sequence @xmath285 such that @xmath286 as @xmath287 .
appropriately rescaling such a sequence and applying removal of singularities as in @xcite , one finds either a nonconstant holomorphic sphere or a nonconstant holomorphic disk with boundary on @xmath5 .
since @xmath14 does not contain nonconstant holomorphic spheres ( such spheres would be contractible and have positive energy , contradicting stokes theorem ) , the only possibility is the existence of some nonconstant holomorphic disk @xmath288 .
now the standard symplectic form @xmath289 is positive on all complex lines in @xmath14 , and hence on all the tangent planes to the image of @xmath82 , so we have @xmath290 moreover , @xmath291 , where e.g. @xmath292 , and so stokes theorem implies that @xmath293 on the other hand , the lagrangian condition states that @xmath294 vanishes pointwise when restricted to @xmath5 . combining these observations , it follows that @xmath295 is a closed 1-form representing a nonzero class in @xmath296 , and this proves the theorem .
what was the essence of the proof of gromov s theorem ?
basically , the point is that the space @xmath271 has a single boundary component , corresponding to the space of constant disks , and hence for topological reasons it can not be compact .
analysing the breakdown of compactness , we found holomorphic disks .
the elements of @xmath271 do not appear to be holomorphic curves , due to the nonzero right hand side @xmath297 of the equation .
however , they can in fact be viewed as holomorphic maps into @xmath298 with respect to a family of almost complex structures which have an off - diagonal term built out of this right hand side , projecting holomorphically and with degree 1 to the disk .
this basic phenomenon was already present in example [ ex : nosol ] .
the stable map compactification in this particular case is given by bubble trees of disks with exactly one main component , satisfying the original equation , and all other bubbles being strictly holomorphic ( in the graph picture just mentioned , each of these has constant projection to the disk ) .
fukaya s insight was to see that the new boundary can be described in terms of string topology operations .
namely , for each @xmath102 , consider the compactified moduli space @xmath299 of holomorphic disks in the relative homotopy class @xmath108 .
similarly , denote by @xmath300 the space of solutions @xmath301 to the equation @xmath302\ ] ] in the relative homotopy class @xmath102 .
pretending as always that transversality holds , this space is a manifold of dimension @xmath303 and we denote its compactification by @xmath304 . assuming the analysis can be made to work ,
both @xmath305 and @xmath304 can be thought of as chains on @xmath306 , simply by associating to each map of the disk its restriction to the boundary circle .
in fact , for @xmath307 there is a slight ambiguity , since its elements are only well - defined up to precomposition by @xmath308 .
but one can easily get around this point , for example by replacing the actual map by a parametrization proportional to arc length . to arrive at a clean statement , i will introduce some further notation .
suppose we are given a suitable model @xmath44 for the chains on the free loop space of @xmath5 with coefficients in @xmath309 , such that for each @xmath310 the compactified spaces @xmath305 and @xmath304 , with their respective evaluation maps to @xmath306 , define elements in it .
note that @xmath306 is a disjoint union over its connected components @xmath311 , which can be identified with conjugacy classes @xmath60 of elements of @xmath312 .
it is convenient to introduce a new complex @xmath313 whose underlying vector space is @xmath44 , but with grading shifted according to the maslov index , i.e. an element in @xmath314 will have degree @xmath315 in @xmath313 .
the complex @xmath313 comes with a filtration by the symplectic area as follows .
it is shown in ( * ? ? ?
4.1.4 ) that the infimum @xmath316 of the symplectic energy is strictly positive .
since each loop on @xmath5 bounds a disk in @xmath14 , we can view the energy as a map @xmath317 .
the energy of @xmath318 is now defined as @xmath319 , where @xmath320 is the energy of the free homotopy class of the loops parametrized by the chain @xmath321 ( assumed to have connected domain of definition ) .
then the filtration @xmath322 on @xmath313 is given by @xmath323 now consider the completion @xmath324 of @xmath313 with respect to this filtration .
this means that an element in @xmath324 will be a possibly infinite sum @xmath325 of chains @xmath326 , provided that for each @xmath327 there are only a finite number of summands satisfying @xmath328 . with this definition , gromov compactness and our grading convention
imply that @xmath329 is a well - defined element of @xmath324 of degree @xmath330 .
in fact , it is contained in the submodule @xmath331 of chains with strictly positive area .
similarly , @xmath332 is an element of @xmath324 of degree @xmath279 , as follows by applying the analogue of to the graph of elements of @xmath300 in @xmath333 .
as explained at the end of section 2 , the compactification of @xmath305 is obtained by adding lower dimensional strata built as fiber products of other such moduli spaces along evaluation maps . in particular , the codimension 1 pieces @xmath334 are build from configurations of two holomorphic disks for which suitable boundary points are mapped to the same point in @xmath5 .
a more careful analysis reveals that , on the level of boundary values of the holomorphic maps , these configurations correspond to loop brackets @xmath335 with @xmath336 . [ ex:2torus ]
the mechanism just described can be seen in example [ ex : noncompact ] , but maybe it is slightly easier to visualize for the standard lagrangian torus @xmath337 .
any class @xmath338 is characterized by two integers @xmath339 giving the degrees of the projections to the two coordinate disks . for a moduli space @xmath340 with respect to the standard complex structure @xmath126 on @xmath17 to be nontrivial
we need @xmath341 . leaving aside the constant maps , the simplest moduli spaces @xmath342 and @xmath343 are compact , and in fact one can identify both with @xmath344 .
indeed , the equivalence classes of the maps @xmath345 given by @xmath346 for @xmath347 represent all elements in @xmath342 , and similarly the maps @xmath348 represent all elements in @xmath343 . note that because of the symmetries in the problem , in this particularly simple example the evaluation maps at @xmath222 are submersions , so that the geometric definition of the loop bracket @xmath349 can be used . to illustrate the discussion above , we want to argue that @xmath350.\end{aligned}\ ] ] every element of the space @xmath351 is a map @xmath352 of the form @xmath353 with @xmath354 and @xmath355 .
the space @xmath356 is obtained as the quotient by the diagonal action of @xmath114 , so the equivalence class of @xmath70 as above is alternatively represented by both @xmath357 or @xmath358 , where @xmath359 is uniquely associated with the equivalence class of @xmath70 .
now consider a sequence @xmath360 with @xmath224 and @xmath361 fixed but @xmath362 and @xmath363 varying .
assume that the projection of the sequence to @xmath356 leaves every compact subset , meaning that the corresponding sequence @xmath364 in the above notation does the same .
elementary considerations now show that for a suitable subsequence @xmath365 there will be a point @xmath366 such that 1 .
@xmath367 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath368 and @xmath369 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath370 , or 2 .
@xmath371 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath370 and @xmath372 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath368 . in both cases ,
the corresponding subsequences @xmath373 and @xmath374 converge to elements @xmath375 and @xmath376 , respectively , and the pair @xmath377 represents a boundary point of @xmath378 .
one checks that as @xmath224 and @xmath361 and the sequence @xmath365 vary , one obtains all boundary points from this construction . in case ( i ) ,
@xmath379 and @xmath380 , which is the unique intersection point of @xmath381 and @xmath382 , and in case ( ii ) the roles are reversed . in particular , the boundary loops of the two limit disks concatenate to represent points in the loop bracket @xmath383 .
we now return to the general discussion . similarly to the case of @xmath307 , the codimension 1 stratum for @xmath304 corresponds to stable maps consisting of one component satisfying the perturbed equation and one holomorphic disk , and so it is described by the loop brackets of the form @xmath384 . depending on the precise technical implementation
, the gluing along lower dimensional boundary strata might actually introduce more terms , corresponding to higher operations .
the main technical assertions which should come out of such an implementation can be formulated as the following theorem .
to get a cleaner statement , i have chosen to state it in slightly stronger form than is strictly necessary .
the concept of a filtered l@xmath43 algebra which appears in the statement is discussed in detail in the following section , where i also give some algebraic perspective on the equations and .
[ thm : blackbox ] let @xmath47 be a closed , oriented , spin lagrangian submanifold
. then on the filtered , degree - shifted chain complex @xmath324 associated to a suitable chain model @xmath44 for the free loop space @xmath306 there exists a filtered l@xmath43-algebra structure @xmath385 of degree @xmath386 , whose bracket on homology coincides with the loop bracket of string topology , and such that 1 .
the union of moduli spaces @xmath307 gives rise to an element @xmath387 of degree @xmath330 satisfying @xmath388 2 .
the union of moduli spaces @xmath389 gives rise to an element @xmath390 of degree @xmath279 satisfying @xmath391,\ ] ] where @xmath284\in c_n(\lambda l , { { \mathbb{q}}})$ ] denotes the chain of constant loops .
i will treat this theorem as a black box , and deduce the main results in the introduction from it by using abstract algebraic arguments and some 3-manifold topology .
for a graded vector space @xmath392 we denote by @xmath393 $ ] the vector space with grading shifted by @xmath7 , i.e. @xmath393_d = c_{d+n}$ ] . on the @xmath257-fold tensor product @xmath394 , we consider two actions of the permutation group @xmath395 . in the first one ,
a permutation @xmath396 acts on some tensor product of elements @xmath397 of pure degrees @xmath398 via @xmath399 with @xmath400 .
the quotient is the @xmath257th symmetric power @xmath401 of @xmath402 , whose decomposable elements we write as @xmath403 .
the second action is the first one twisted by the sign representation , @xmath404 the quotient is the @xmath257th exterior power @xmath405 of @xmath402 , whose elements are usually denoted by @xmath406 . with these definitions , for an element @xmath407 of odd degree we have @xmath408 , but @xmath409 .
an l@xmath43 algebra of degree 0 consists of a graded vector space @xmath402 and a sequence of multilinear operations @xmath410 of degree @xmath411 satisfying the sequence of quadratic relations @xmath412 for each @xmath413 .
( the signs are made explicit below . )
more generally , an l@xmath43 algebra structure of degree @xmath207 on @xmath402 is defined to be an l@xmath43 structure of degree @xmath414 on @xmath415 $ ] .
if the vector space @xmath402 of an l@xmath43 algebra of degree 0 is concentrated in degree 0 , then for degree reasons the only possibly nontrivial operation is @xmath45 , and the relation for @xmath416 turns out to be the jacobi identity for @xmath45 , so we recover lie algebras as a special case . if @xmath417 for @xmath418 , then we recover the definition of a dg lie algebra .
indeed , the first relation reads @xmath419 .
the second relation shows that @xmath420 is a derivation of @xmath45 , and the third relation is again the jacobi identity . in general ,
the jacobi identity holds `` up to homotopy '' given by @xmath421 , so it always holds for the induced bracket on @xmath422 . to make the signs in the quadratic relations as well as other signs below explicit , it is useful to give an alternative description .
first observe the graded linear isomorphism @xmath423 & \to s^k(c[-1])\\ c_1 \wedge \dots \wedge c_k & \mapsto ( -1)^{\sum ( k - i)|c_i| } c_1 \cdots c_k,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath398 denotes the degree in @xmath402 .
next introduce operations @xmath424)\to c[-1]$ ] as @xmath425 and note that with this degree shift these are all of degree @xmath426 .
set @xmath427):= \oplus_{k\geq 1 } s^k(c[-1])$ ] and observe that each of these operations can be extended to a map @xmath428 ) \to s(c[-1])$ ] defined as @xmath429 where @xmath430 is the sign introduced above finally , one defines @xmath431 ) \to s(c[-1])$ ] .
then the quadratic relations ( with the correct signs ) are equivalent to the single equation @xmath432 the above passage from the operations @xmath433 on @xmath402 to the operation @xmath434 on @xmath427)$ ] is called the _ bar construction_. conceptually , one views @xmath427)$ ] as a coalgebra via the comultiplication @xmath435 ) \to s(c[-1 ] ) \otimes s(c[-1])$ ] given by @xmath436 this map has the coassociativity property @xmath437 and it also turns out to be cocommutative in the sense that @xmath438 , where @xmath439)\otimes s(c[-1 ] ) \to s(c[-1 ] ) \otimes s(c[-1])$ ] is the signed permutation of the two factors . then @xmath440 is the unique way to extend @xmath441 as a coderivation , i.e. as a map satisfying the co - leibniz rule @xmath442 conversely , one can prove that any coderivation @xmath443 ) \to s(c[-1])$ ] is completely determined by its _ linear part _ @xmath444 ) \to c[-1]$ ] .
so @xmath434 is the unique coderivation of degree @xmath426 on @xmath427)$ ] such that the restriction of its linear part to @xmath445)$ ] equals @xmath441 .
it is also easy to see that the commutator @xmath446:= d_1 \circ d_2 - ( -1)^{|d_1||d_2| } d_2 \circ d_1 $ ] of two homogeneous coderivations is a coderivation , and so in our example above @xmath447 $ ] has this property .
these remarks explain why the relation is equivalent to the sequence of relations , since this sequence is obtained by restricting the linear part of @xmath448 to @xmath445)$ ] for each @xmath449 ( and precomposing with @xmath450 ) .
so in summary , an l@xmath43 structure on a graded vector space @xmath402 is the same as a coderivation of square zero on the symmetric tensor coalgebra @xmath427)$ ] .
i have adopted homological conventions here , whereas often in the literature one finds cohomological conventions , where the @xmath433 have degrees @xmath451 , and in the bar construction one shifts degrees by @xmath222 instead of @xmath426 .
given two l@xmath43 algebras @xmath452 and @xmath453 , a morphism from @xmath313 to @xmath454 consists of a sequence of maps @xmath455 of degrees @xmath456 satisfying the sequence of relations @xmath457 for @xmath413 . again , to state the signs correctly , it is useful to pass to the associated maps @xmath458 ) \to c'[-1]$ ] of degree @xmath414 given by @xmath459 .
any such collection of linear maps determines a unique morphism of coalgebras @xmath460 ) \to s(c'[-1])$ ] , given by @xmath461 the fact that @xmath462 is a morphism of l@xmath43 algebras can now be stated equivalently ( including the correct signs ) as @xmath463 the first important result about l@xmath43 algebras asserts that the structure of an l@xmath43 algebra can be transferred from a complex @xmath402 to its homology with respect to @xmath420 , without the loss of any essential information .
more precisely , it is formulated as follows .
[ thm : hpt ] suppose @xmath452 is an l@xmath43 algebra over a field of characterstic 0
. then there exists an l@xmath43 algebra structure @xmath464 on the homology which is homotopy equivalent to @xmath313 . here
a _ homotopy equivalence _ between l@xmath43 algebras is the essentially obvious generalization of the classical notion . in particular
, it is an l@xmath43 morphism which induces an isomorphism in the homology of the underlying complexes .
it is a theorem that every such map admits a homotopy inverse . for detailed definitions and a proof of these assertions , including the theorem ,
see e.g. @xcite .
the construction of the homotopy equivalence starts with a linear homotopy equivalence @xmath465 given by choosing a cycle in each homology class , which has a homotopy inverse @xmath466 given by projection along a complement of the image of @xmath467 .
one sets @xmath468 and @xmath469 , and constructs the higher maps @xmath470 and operations @xmath471 , @xmath472 simultaneously by induction .
the fact that the homologies of the two complexes agree is used to prove that all relevant obstructions vanish .
now let @xmath452 be an l@xmath43 algebra .
suppose that @xmath402 is the completion of some complex @xmath473 with respect to a doubly infinite filtration @xmath474 with @xmath475 , so that elements of @xmath402 are ( possibly infinite ) sums of elements of @xmath473 of the form @xmath476 denote the induced filtration on @xmath402 by @xmath477 .
the l@xmath43 structure on @xmath402 is called _ filtered _ if @xmath478 in the following discussion , it is convenient to denote by @xmath479 the image of an element under the identity map @xmath480 $ ] of degree @xmath481 .
an element @xmath482 of degree @xmath426 satisfying the equation @xmath483\ ] ] is called a _
maurer - cartan element of @xmath313_. since @xmath484 , the left hand side of this equation is indeed a well - defined element of @xmath313 .
note that is an instance of this equation . also , this equation is equivalent to @xmath485 moreover , an easy calculation yields if @xmath486 is a maurer - cartan element of @xmath313 and @xmath487 is arbitrary , then @xmath488 in particular , the map @xmath489 \to c[-1]$ ] given by @xmath490 is a differential .
finally , we describe what happens to equations and under morphisms .
[ prop : pushforward ] suppose @xmath491 is a morphism between l@xmath43 algebras @xmath313 and @xmath492 preserving filtrations as above . 1 .
if @xmath493 is a maurer - cartan element for @xmath313 , then @xmath494 with @xmath495 is a maurer - cartan element for @xmath492 .
2 . if @xmath493 is a maurer - cartan element and @xmath496 satisfy @xmath497 then the elements @xmath498 , @xmath499 and @xmath500 with @xmath501 satisfy @xmath502 to prove the first assertion , just observe that for a maurer - cartan element @xmath486 one has @xmath503 where the equality @xmath504 follows directly from the definitions . to prove the second assertion , one first checks that for any elements @xmath505 $ ] @xmath506 using this , we compute @xmath507 on the other hand , @xmath508
looking back at theorem [ thm : blackbox ] , we see that it asserts that the holomorphic disks with boundary on the lagrangian submanifold give rise to a maurer - cartan element @xmath122 in the l@xmath43 structure on @xmath324 such that with respect to the twisted differential the element @xmath284
\in \widehat{{\mathcal{c}}}$ ] becomes exact . since @xmath284 $ ] is never exact with respect to the ordinary boundary operator @xmath509 , this tells us that both the maurer - cartan element @xmath122 and at least one of the operations @xmath433 with @xmath510 must be nontrivial , since otherwise the twisted differential coincides with the untwisted boundary operator @xmath511 .
this observation lies at the core of fukaya s proof of theorem [ thm : fukayamain ] . before i discuss that , i will state two purely topological facts that will turn out to be useful . [
lem : top1 ] let @xmath64 be a loop , and denote by @xmath512 the centralizer of @xmath60 , i.e. the set of all elements commuting with @xmath60 .
let @xmath513 be a connected covering of @xmath5 associated to the subgroup @xmath514 , and let @xmath515 be a lift of @xmath60 .
then the projection @xmath516 induces a homeomorphism @xmath517 between the components of @xmath518 and @xmath60 in the respective free loop spaces .
since @xmath513 is a covering , any free homotopy @xmath519 \times s^1 \to l$ ] with @xmath520 admits a ( unique ) lift @xmath521 to @xmath29 with @xmath522 , and so in particular @xmath523 is the image of @xmath524 under the map @xmath525 induced by the projection .
this proves surjectivity of @xmath525 . to prove injectivity ,
assume that @xmath526 .
note that our two lifts @xmath527 and @xmath528 of @xmath165 are related by a deck transformation , i.e. by the action of some homeomorphism @xmath529 satisfying @xmath530 . if @xmath531 is a free homotopy from @xmath518 to @xmath532 , then @xmath533 is a homotopy from @xmath534 to @xmath528 . since by assumption @xmath535 is also freely homotopic to @xmath518 , we conclude that if @xmath525 is not injective , then @xmath60 has at least two preimages , namely @xmath518 and @xmath536 .
now suppose @xmath518 and @xmath536 are freely homotopic for some deck transformation @xmath537 , so that they are both preimages of @xmath60 under @xmath525 .
a free homotopy @xmath521 from @xmath518 to @xmath536 can be reinterpreted as a based homotopy from @xmath518 to @xmath538 , where @xmath539 \times \{1\}}$ ] is the path travelled by the base point under the homotopy .
note that @xmath540 projects to a closed loop in @xmath5 representing @xmath541 .
in particular , the projection of the homotopy @xmath521 yields that @xmath542 but @xmath543 was chosen to be the centralizer of @xmath60 in @xmath312 , so @xmath544 .
in other words , this implies that @xmath540 was a closed loop and so @xmath545 , i.e. any two preimages of @xmath60 coincide . together with the previous observation
this shows that @xmath525 is injective , completing the proof of the lemma .
[ lem : top2 ] in the situation of the previous lemma , assume moreover that @xmath5 ( and so @xmath29 as well ) is aspherical
. then evaluation at the base point @xmath546 is a homotopy equivalence .
the fiber of the map @xmath547 at @xmath548 is the space @xmath549 of loops which are based at @xmath548 and _ freely _ homotopic to @xmath515 . as in the previous proof , we observe that any free homotopy between @xmath550 and @xmath515 can be reinterpreted as a based homotopy between @xmath165 and @xmath551 . but
@xmath515 is central in @xmath552 , so that @xmath553 is _ based _ homotopic to @xmath518 .
so we conclude that in fact @xmath554 is the component of @xmath515 in the based loop space of @xmath29 , which is contractible since @xmath29 is aspherical .
so @xmath555 is a fibration with contractible fibers , and hence a homotopy equivalence .
[ cor : top3 ] if @xmath5 is an aspherical manifold , then every component of the free loop space @xmath306 has the homotopy type of a cw complex of dimension at most @xmath556 . @xmath557 after these preliminaries , i come to the proof of the main theorem .
( of theorem [ thm : fukayamain ] ) recall that the maurer - cartan element @xmath558 is built from the moduli spaces @xmath559 , which have geometric dimensions @xmath560 and the element @xmath561 is built from the spaces @xmath562 with geometric dimensions @xmath563 denote by @xmath564 the homology with respect to the usual boundary operator of @xmath324 .
recall that we denote by @xmath565 the image of @xmath566 under the degree shift @xmath567 $ ] . according to theorem [ thm : hpt ] ,
the l@xmath43 structure on @xmath324 pushes forward to an l@xmath43 structure on @xmath564 under a homomorphism @xmath568 , and by proposition [ prop : pushforward ] , this homomorphism maps the elements @xmath122 , @xmath158 and @xmath284 $ ] in @xmath324 to elements @xmath569 , @xmath570 and @xmath284 $ ] in @xmath564 satisfying the equation @xmath571}.\ ] ] writing @xmath572 the part of this equation corresponding to the trivial relative homotopy class can be written more explicitly as @xmath573}.\ ] ] since the homomorphism between the l@xmath43 structures preserves degrees , the geometric degrees of @xmath574 and @xmath575 are @xmath576 and @xmath577 , respectively . by the assumption that @xmath5 is aspherical , corollary [ cor : top3 ] implies that the homology @xmath564 is concentrated in geometric degrees @xmath578 . combining this observation with and the fact that the maslov index is even for orientable lagrangian submanifolds @xmath5 , we find that for the term @xmath579 to be nonzero we must have @xmath580 the first equation immediately implies that @xmath61 is not identically zero .
moreover , if @xmath581 for all @xmath582 , it follows that @xmath583 , again contradicting the first equation .
thus we conclude that some @xmath584 with @xmath585 must be nonzero , implying that the corresponding moduli space is nonempty .
so @xmath586 is represented by a holomorphic disk , and hence must have positive symplectic energy .
set @xmath587 and let @xmath588 denote the centralizer of @xmath60 .
notice that we have a short exact sequence @xmath589 in which the last map admits an inverse sending @xmath222 to @xmath60 .
it follows that the map @xmath590 , defined by @xmath591 , is an isomorphism ( @xmath592 is indeed a group homomorphism because @xmath60 commutes with all elements of @xmath402 ) . since @xmath5 is a @xmath593 , the covering space @xmath29 of @xmath5 with @xmath594 is a @xmath595 , so it is homotopy equivalent to @xmath30 for a @xmath596 space @xmath32 . to complete the proof of the theorem , it remains to show that @xmath32 is closed or , equivalently , that @xmath597 is a finite covering space .
note that the class @xmath586 with @xmath598 had the property that @xmath585 , and moreover @xmath574 is a nonzero element of geometric degree @xmath7 in @xmath564 .
so the homology in degree @xmath7 of @xmath599 must be nonzero . but combining lemma [ lem : top1 ] and lemma [ lem : top2 ] , we see that @xmath311 is homotopy equivalent to the @xmath7-manifold @xmath600 .
the nonvanishing of its top - dimensional homology now implies that @xmath29 is closed , which in turns means that @xmath597 is a finite covering space .
the more precise statement in dimension 3 can be proven with some specific results from 3-dimensional topology .
i wish to thank k. fukaya , k. honda and s. maillot for helpful correspondence , which lead to the following proof of corollary [ cor : fukaya1 ] .
( of corollary [ cor : fukaya1 ] ) let @xmath5 be a compact , orientable , prime 3-manifold .
it is well - known ( see e.g. @xcite ) that either @xmath601 or @xmath5 is irreducible , meaning that every embedded two - sphere in @xmath5 bounds a ball in @xmath5 .
if an irreducible 3-manifold @xmath5 admits a lagrangian embedding into @xmath35 , then by gromov s theorem [ thm : gromov - notexact ] it has infinite first homology , and hence infinite fundamental group , and so its universal cover @xmath29 is non - compact .
moreover , by the sphere theorem ( see @xcite ) , an irreducible 3-manifold has trivial second homotopy group .
it follows that @xmath602 for @xmath413 , and so by hurewicz s theorem @xmath603 for @xmath449 , implying that @xmath5 itself is aspherical .
now by theorem [ thm : fukayamain ] , a finite cover of @xmath5 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath36 for some closed oriented surface @xmath20 , and a result of waldhausen ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 6.5 ) implies that this homotopy equivalence can be improved to a homeomorphism .
recall from the proof above that the fundamental group @xmath402 of the cover arises as the centralizer of an element @xmath604 with @xmath605 .
now i will argue that in fact @xmath60 is central in @xmath312 , so that the covering projection is actually a homeomorphism .
indeed , consider the exact sequence @xmath606 where @xmath607 .
since the centralizer @xmath402 of @xmath60 is of finite index , @xmath608 is of finite index in @xmath609 . from the above proof of the theorem
, we see that @xmath610 is finitely generated ( it is the fundamental group of @xmath20 ) , so @xmath609 is also finitely generated .
then by stallings fibration theorem ( @xcite , see also ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 11.6 ) ) , we deduce that @xmath609 is the fundamental group of a compact surface @xmath611 , which under our current assumptions must be closed of genus at least 1 .
now the proof concludes with the following observation : any automorphism @xmath612 of the fundamental group @xmath609 of a closed oriented surface which is trivial on some finite index subgroup @xmath610 is trivial .
if the surface is a sphere there is nothing to prove , so we consider the case that the genus of the surface is at least 1 .
one knows that the fundamental group @xmath609 of a closed surface has no torsion .
let @xmath613 be given and consider the infinite cyclic subgroup @xmath614 generated by @xmath537 .
the subgroup @xmath615 contains the finite index subgroup @xmath616 , on which @xmath612 acts trivially . but any automorphism of an infinite cyclic group fixing some nontrivial subgroup must be the identity , so @xmath617 .
since this applies to any @xmath613 , the lemma is proven .
applying the lemma to the action of @xmath60 on @xmath609 by conjugation , which clearly fixes all elements of @xmath618 , we finally conclude that @xmath60 is central in @xmath312 , so that @xmath619 , which finishes the proof of the theorem .
above , i have presented fukaya s elegant arguments leading to some substantial new results about lagrangian submanifolds in @xmath14 . at first glance
, it seems that string topology is really essential to the approach .
however , on further inspection , one discovers that there may be a way to avoid it almost entirely .
the basic idea is the following . by viterbo s theorem ( see @xcite and chapter chap : viterbo ) , the homology of the free loop space can be described in symplectic terms as the symplectic homology of the cotangent bundle .
this theory can be defined in more general situations , for example for exact symplectic manifolds with contact - type boundary . moreover , for _ exact _ codimension 0 embeddings @xmath620 one has restriction maps @xmath621 .
it seems reasonable to expect ( and is the subject of current work ) that every algebraic structure that exists on the homology of the free loop space can also be defined on symplectic homology in general , even if the underlying domain is not a cotangent bundle . in the exact case
, the restriction homomorphism should respect all these structures .
but even more should be true . in the case of a non - exact embedding @xmath620
, there will be a maurer - cartan element in @xmath622 such that after twisting all the structures by this maurer - cartan element we get a morphism from @xmath623 to the twisted version @xmath624 .
this expectation is consistent with ( and gives one of several possible conceptual explanations for ) the results of fukaya for lagrangians in @xmath14 .
indeed , with @xmath625 being a small neighborhood of the zero section in the cotangent bundle of @xmath5 and @xmath626 , we are exactly in the situation just described .
what i have argued in earlier sections is that , after twisting by a maurer - cartan element coming from the embedding , the unit @xmath284 \in h_*(\lambda l)$ ] with respect to the loop product has become exact , which by a standard argument will force the twisted homology to vanish completely .
this is good news , because only in this case can we even expect to have a morphism from @xmath627 to this ring .
the prediction is that this morphism can indeed be defined in a suitable chain version of the theory .
once the above argument has been made to work , it extends the applicability of fukaya s approach in several directions .
notice that string topology only enters indirectly , via viterbo s isomorphism .
as long as the algebraic operations can be defined and the morphism associated to a codimension zero embedding respects them , one does not even need to know that the operations on symplectic homology are the same as those in string topology ( although this is of course expected to be true ) .
moreover , one can study non - exact codimension 0 embeddings of general exact symplectic manifolds with contact boundary by this method .
the basic source for this chapter are of course fukaya s papers @xcite
. versions of theorem [ thm : fukayamain ] under additional assumptions , like monotonicity of the lagrangian submanifold , are much easier to achieve , see e.g. @xcite and the references therein . for an introduction to symplectic topology
the book @xcite is recommended .
it covers a lot more than is necessary to understand the problem discussed here , and it gives some hints why lagrangian submanifolds are so central in symplectic topology . to learn something more specific about lagrangian embeddings and immersions , the excellent survey @xcite is still the best place to start .
recently , new results have appeared which suggest that the problem in higher dimensions is more flexible than previously expected @xcite .
a chain complex @xmath628 for the free loop space on which the loop bracket is fully defined , and which therefore might serve in the implementation of theorem [ thm : blackbox ] , has recently been proposed by irie @xcite .
finally , the reader who really wants to appreciate the discussion in this chapter needs to know quite a bit about holomorphic curves .
one good source which thoroughly covers a lot of the basics , including a version of gromov compactness and a complete proof of gromov s theorem [ thm : gromov - notexact ] , is @xcite .
many aspects of the theory are also covered in the earlier book @xcite . with these as a guide , the monumental @xcite will hopefully look less daunting .
k. fukaya , _ application of floer homology of langrangian submanifolds to symplectic topology _ , in : paul biran et al .
( eds . ) , morse theoretic methods in nonlinear analysis and in symplectic topology , springer , 2006 , 231-276 . c .- c .
m. liu , _ moduli of @xmath41-holomorphic curves with lagrangian boundary conditions and open gromov - witten invariants for an @xmath11-equivariant pair _ , ph.d .
thesis , harvard 2002 , arxiv : math.sg/0210257 d. mcduff and d. salamon , _ @xmath41-holomorphic curves and symplectic topology _ , american mathematical society colloquium publications , 52 .
american mathematical society , providence , ri , 2004 .
xii+669 pp .
isbn : 0 - 8218 - 3485 - 1 s. yu . nemirovski , _ homology class of a lagrangian klein bottle _ , isvestiya math .
73 , 2009 , no . 4 , 689698 .
v. v. shevchishin , _ lagrangian embeddings of the klein bottle and combinatorial properties of mapping class groups _ , isvestiya math .
73 , 2009 , no . 4 , 797859 | in this chapter i discuss some applications of string topology to the study of lagrangian embeddings into symplectic manifolds , as discovered by fukaya @xcite . |
first evidence of the violation of time reversal symmetry has been found in the kaon system @xcite . despite strong efforts no other signal of violation of time
reversal symmetry has been found to date .
however , by now , studying time reversal symmetry has become a corner stone of the search for physics beyond the standard model of elementary particles @xcite .
some alternatives or extensions of the standard model are due to dynamical symmetry breaking , multi higgs models , spontaneous symmetry breaking , grand unified theories ( e.g. so(10 ) ) , extended gauge groups ( leading e.g. to right - handed bosons @xmath3 in left - right symmetric models ) , super symmetric ( susy ) theories , etc .
, each implying specific ways of @xmath4 violation .
for a recent review of models relevant in the context of @xmath4 violation see e.g. @xcite , and refs . therein .
these theories `` beyond '' the standard model are formulated in terms of quarks and leptons whereas nuclear low energy tests of @xmath4 involve hadronic degrees of freedom ( mesons and nucleons ) @xcite . to extract hadronic degrees of freedom from observables one may introduce effective @xmath1odd nucleon nucleon potentials @xcite , or more specific @xmath1odd mesonic exchange potentials @xcite . as in the context of @xmath0-violation
see e.g. @xcite , these potentials have been proven quite useful to treat the nuclear structure part involved and to extract effective @xmath1odd hadronic coupling constants @xcite . in turn
they allow to compare the sensitivity of different experiments , which has been done recently in ref .
however , in order to compare upper bounds on a more fundamental level of @xmath1odd interactions , it is necessary to relate hadronic degrees of freedom to quark degrees of freedom in some way .
this step is hampered by the absence of a complete solution of quantum chromo dynamics ( qcd ) at the energies considered here . in many cases a rough estimate in the context of time
reversal violation may be sufficient , and , in the simplest case , factors arising from hadronic structure may be neglected . in the context of @xmath0odd time reversal violation
e.g. concepts such as pcac and current algebra @xcite have been utilized to improve the evaluation of hadronic structure effects . in the @xmath0even case , which is considered here ,
this approach is not applicable ( no goldstone bosons involved here ) .
however , it may be useful to utilize quark models specifically designed for and quite successful in describing the low energy sector .
in fact , experimental precision tests still continue to make progress and so theorists face a renewed challenge to translate these experimental constrains to a more fundamental interaction level .
the purpose of the present paper is to give estimates on hadronic matrix elements that arise when relating quark operators to the effective hadronic parameterizations of the @xmath0even @xmath1odd interaction .
these are the charge @xmath2 type exchange and the axial vector type exchange nucleon nucleon interaction @xcite
. they will shortly be outlined in the next section .
the ansatz to calculate @xmath5 matrix elements from the quark structure is described in section iii .
the last section gives the result for different types of quark models and a conclusion .
for completeness , note that in general also @xmath1-odd and @xmath0-odd interactions are possible , and in fact most of the simple extensions of the standard model mentioned above give rise to such type of @xmath1violation .
parameterized as one boson exchanges they lead e.g. to effective pion exchange potentials that are essentially long range , see @xcite .
limits on @xmath0odd @xmath1odd interactions are rather strongly bound by electric dipole moment measurements , in particular by that of the neutron @xcite .
in contrast bounds on @xmath0even @xmath1odd interactions are rather weak .
note , also that despite theoretical considerations @xcite new experiments testing generic @xmath1odd @xmath0even observables have been suggested ; for the present status see e.g. refs .
due to the moderate energies involved in nuclear physics tests of time reversal symmetry , hadronic degrees of freedom are useful and may be reasonable to analyze and to compare different types of experiments .
for a recent discussion see ref .
@xcite . in the following only @xmath1-odd and @xmath0-_even _ interactions will be considered .
they may be parameterized in terms of effective one boson exchange potentials . due to the behavior under @xmath6 ,
@xmath0 , and @xmath1 symmetry transformations , see e.g. @xcite , two basic contributions are possible then : a charged @xmath2 type exchange @xcite and an axial vector exchange @xcite .
the effective @xmath2 type @xmath1odd interaction is @xmath6odd due to the phase appearing in the isospin sector and is only possible for charged @xmath2 exchange .
it has been suggested by simonius and wyler , who used the tensor part to parameterize the interaction @xcite , @xmath7 there is some question of whether to choose an `` anomalous '' coupling @xcite , viz . @xmath8 .
the numerical value of @xmath9 is usually taken to be @xmath10 close to the strong interaction case @xcite .
we shall see in the following that it is not unreasonable to introduce such a factor since in may be related to `` nucleonic structure effects '' , which are not of @xmath1 violating origin ( similar to nuclear structure effects that are also treated separately ) . combining the @xmath1odd vertex with the appropriate @xmath1even vertex leads to the following effective @xmath1odd @xmath0even one boson exchange @xmath5 interaction , @xmath11 where @xmath12 , and
@xmath13 , and @xmath14 is the strong coupling constant , as e.g. provided by the bonn potential @xcite .
the axial vector type interaction has been suggested by @xcite . unlike the @xmath2type interaction the isospin dependence is not restricted and may be isoscalar , vector , and/or tensor type .
the effective lagrangian for the @xmath15 coupling for example is given by @xmath16 combined with the appropriate @xmath1even vertex this leads to an effective axial vector type exchange @xmath5 potential @xcite , @xmath17 the bounds on the @xmath1odd coupling strengths arising from various experiments have been discussed in ref .
a more recent bound not included there is from an improved analysis @xcite of the @xmath18fe @xmath19decay experiment @xcite .
bounds are in the order of 10% if derived from generic @xmath1odd @xmath0even observables and slightly more than an order of magnitude smaller , if related to the electric dipole moments @xcite . to complete this section , note
that although possible , two boson exchanges have not been considered up to now .
we now turn to effective @xmath1-odd @xmath0-even quark operators . the simplest operator that leads to an effective @xmath1odd @xmath0even vector type vertex @xmath20 analogous to the @xmath2type interaction eq .
( [ eqn : vnn ] ) is @xmath21 here @xmath22 , @xmath23 denote flavored quark fields .
again the flavor dependence is responsible for @xmath6 , viz .
@xmath1violation due to the phase dependence .
a tensor term has not been introduced for simplicity . on the basis of eq .
( [ quarkv ] ) such a term will arise in a natural way in the effective hadronic @xmath24 @xmath1-odd lagrangian through the quark structure effects as will be explained below .
the second generic quark operator utilizing axial vector bilinear operators is given by @xcite , @xmath25 with the on shell equivalent @xmath26 in order to recover eqs .
( [ eqn : vnn ] ) and ( [ eqn : ann ] ) we utilize the constituent quark model .
this model has been rather successful and valuable in reproducing gross features of low energy phenomenae , such as mass spectra , form factors , coupling constants , magnetic moments etc .
, see e.g. @xcite . to relate quark operators to effective hadronic operators we utilize the fock space representation of hadrons in terms of constituent quarks , viz .
@xmath27 since there is no low energy solution of qcd , the evaluation of the matrix elements of the l.h.s of eq .
( [ fock ] ) needs further consideration . in general
, the same problem arises in the context of strong interactions .
an extensive overview of the different approaches to tackle the problem in this case has been given by ref .
@xcite . here
we follow the ideas first formulated in ref .
@xcite , and extensively studied for different quark models in @xcite .
the resulting strong interaction potential is a generic hybrid model connecting quark degrees of freedom with effective meson nucleon degrees of freedom .
the basic idea is summarized in the following .
suppose the two nucleons overlap , and two quarks are sufficiently close together .
this situation is depicted in figure [ fig : qqnn]a ) .
then , to begin with , the matrix elements may be evaluated without introducing any mesonic fields . in terms of the constituent quark model @xmath28 excitations
are neglected ( or partially parameterized in the constituent quark mass ) . only at larger distances of the nucleons ,
mesons are essential and may appear as @xmath28 correlations on the nonperturbative qcd vacuum @xcite that might be the physical vacuum of the low energy regime @xcite .
however , the appearance of mesons is disconnected from the problem of @xmath1odd force .
therefore , in the following we assume that the hadronization mechanism is the _
same for both @xmath1odd and the usual @xmath1even strong interaction _ and investigate the relative strength of the @xmath1odd matrix elements to the @xmath1even matrix elements .
this is done in the framework of the virginia potential that assumes a quark pairing mechanism to generate effective meson nucleon coupling constants @xcite . to illustrate the quality of this ansatz table [ tab : virginia ]
shows the resulting coupling constants using different quark models compared to the values of a recent version of the bonn potential @xcite . in this framework
we utilize the factorization approximation to evaluate the matrix element of eq .
( [ fock ] ) , see figure [ fig : qqnn]b ) @xmath29 to demonstrate the calculation , we use the simple constituent quark model .
this model is supplemented by an explicit lower component , which already occurs implicitly in the dirac magnetic moments @xcite and in the two
body pair current through electromagnetic gauge invariance @xcite .
this way a treatment of relativistic effects has been introduced , see e.g. @xcite and ref . therein .
the integration of the internal degrees of freedom reads , @xmath30\ ] ] with @xmath31 the three quark wave internal function . in the rest system the space part of the wave function
is given by @xcite @xmath32\ ] ] where numerical values may be chosen as @xmath33 , and @xmath34 .
the coordinates are normalized lovelace coordinates , viz .
@xmath2 for the pair and @xmath35 for the odd quark .
integration is done in the breit system .
the symbol @xmath36 denotes either one of the vertices in ( [ quark ] ) .
evaluation for the different type of operators leads to the following expressions ( using the isospin formalism for @xmath37 quarks ) @xmath38 the factors arising are related to the quark structure of nucleons .
note , that in eq .
( [ axial ] ) one recognizes the well known coupling of the axial vector current ( for @xmath39 ) , viz .
@xmath40 of the nonrelativistic constituent quark model , besides factors arising from relativistic corrections due to the lower dirac component .
the latter reduce the value of @xmath41 close to the experimental one @xcite . in eq .
( [ tensor ] ) a tensor coupling appears , which belongs to the @xmath2 type @xmath1odd exchange . indeed due to the quark structure factors its relative strength is larger than the first term of the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ tensor ] ) , and therefore preferable in an ansatz of a @xmath2type @xmath1odd force as done by simonius and wyler @xcite .
the factor in front the tensor term may be interpreted as `` anomalous '' coupling .
it appears in analogy to the electromagnetic interaction , where the pauli term of the electromagnetic photon nucleon interaction can be recovered from a pure dirac coupling on quark level .
this has been explained and shown in ref .
the resulting relation between quark and hadronic @xmath1odd coupling strength on the basis of the constituent quark model is , for @xmath2 type exchange @xmath42 and for axial type of exchange @xmath43 here the expression for isoscalar and isovector are the same .
similar results may be obtained using different types of quark models . in the context of the virginia potential
those studied are the mit bag model and a relativistic model with linear confining potential , see ref .
these are used here in the same way as demonstrated for the constituent quark model in the previous section .
the values for the quark structure effects evaluated using typical quark model parameters of low energy phenomenology are given in table [ tab : values ] .
in fact , due to the symmetries inherent in the quark pairing mechanism ( viz .
the virginia potential ) it is possible to arrive at the following relations between the coupling constants , viz .
@xmath44 this equation shows that the factors appearing in the @xmath45 type exchange may be related to the anomalous coupling @xmath46 .
so , inclusion of @xmath9 might give a bound closer to the more basic quark degrees of freedom . in conclusion
, provided the hadronization process does not substantially differ for @xmath1odd and @xmath1even interactions , the factors arising reflect the _ nucleon _ structure effects .
the origin of the structure factors are due to the spin , isospin structure and the different mass scales ( i.e. @xmath47 vs. @xmath48 ) .
these have also been essential in deriving the relative strength of the strong coupling constants as given in table [ tab : virginia ] .
the author gratefully acknowledges support by the national institute for nuclear theory at the university of washington , seattle , during his stay on the int program `` physics beyond the standard model at low and intermediate energies '' . this work has been supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft
be 1092/4 - 1 .
p. herczeg , nucl . phys .
* 75 * ( 1966 ) 655 r. bryan , a. gersten , phys .
* 26 * ( 1971 ) 1000 , * 27 * ( 1971 ) 1102(e ) e.c.g .
sudarshan , proc .
a305 * , ( 1968 ) 319 m. simonius , phys .
lett . * 58b * ( 1975 ) 147 m. simonius , d. wyler , nucl
a286 * ( 1977 ) 182 w.c .
haxton , e.m .
henley , phys .
* 51 * ( 1983 ) 1937 p. herczeg , in _ tests of time reversal invariance in neutron physics
_ , eds , n.r .
roberson et al . , ( world scientific publishing , singapore , 1987 ) p. 24 .
e.g. adelberger , w.c .
haxton ann .
nucl . part .
* 35 * 501 ( 1985 ) .
i.s . towner and a.c .
hayes , phys . rev .
* c 49 * , 2391 ( 1994 ) .
gudkov , x .-
he , and b.h.j .
mckellar , phys .
* c47 * , 2365 ( 1993 ) .
m. beyer , nucl .
a493 * 335 ( 1989 ) .
m. beyer , phys .
* c48 * 906 ( 1993 ) .
w.c . haxton and a. hoering , nucl . phys . * a 560 * , 469 ( 1993 ) .
haxton , a. hring , m.j .
musolf , phys .
d50 3422 ( 1994 ) .
crewther , p. di vecchia , g. veneziano , e. witten , phys . lett .
* 88b * 123 ( 1979 ) .
altarev et al . , phys . lett . * b276 * 242 ( 1992 ) .
smith , phys .
b234 * 191 ( 1990 ) .
pendlebury , nucl . phys . *
a546 * 359c ( 1992 ) .
montanet et al .
( particle data group ) , phys.rev .
* d50 * 1173 ( 1994 ) .
p. herczeg , private communication : p. herzceg , j. kambor , m. simonius , and d. wyler to be published .
j. engel , p. frampton , and r. springer , preprint nucl - th/9505026 ( 1995 ) . c. itzykson and j .- b .
zuber , _ quantum field theory _
( mcgraw hill international , singapore , 1980 ) .
p. herczeg , private communication .
ressell , j. engel , p. vogel , preprint map-189 , nucl - th/9512013 ( 1995 ) .
cheung , h.e .
henrikson , f. boehm , phys .
rev . * c16 * , 2381 ( 1977 ) .
khriplovich , nucl . phys . *
b352 * 382 ( 1991 ) .
see e.g. f.e .
close , _ an introduction to quarks and partons _ ( academic press , 1979 ) ; a. le yaouanc , l. oliver , o. pene , j .- c .
raynal , _ hadron transitions in the quark model _
( gordon and breach , 1988 ) ; r.k .
bhaduri , _ models of the nucleon : from quarks to soliton _ ( addison - wesley , 1988 , lecture notes and supplements in physics , 22 ) .
f. myhrer , rev .
60 629 ( 1988 ) h.j .
weber , z. phys .
* a297 * ( 1980 ) 261 , * a301 * , 141 ( 1981 ) , phys . rev .
* c26 * , 2333 ( 1982 ) m. bozoian and h.j .
weber , phys .
* c28 * 811 ( 1983 ) m. beyer , h.j .
weber , phys .
* 146b * ( 1984 ) 383 ; phys . rev .
* c35 * ( 1987 ) 14 m.a .
shifman , a.i .
vainshtein , and v.i .
zakharov , nucl .
* b147 * , 385 and 448 ( 1980 ) for a recent discussion of constituent quarks see : d. diakonov , gatchina preprint , nucl - th/960323 .
r. machleidt , k. holinde and ch .
elster , phys . rep .
* 149 * , 1 ( 1987 ) n. isgur and g. karl , phys
* d18 * , 4187 ( 1978 ) ; * d 19 * , 2653 ( 1979 ) .
m. beyer , d. drechsel , and m.m .
giannini , phys .
122 b * , 1 ( 1983 ) h.j .
weber , m. weyrauch phys .
* c32 * , 1342 ( 1985 ) m. beyer and s.k .
singh , phys .
* b 160 * , 26 ( 1985 ) ; z. phys .
* c31 * , 421 ( 1986 ) @xmath49 & 3.8 & [ -0.5 ] & 9.85 & [ -0.49]&10.6 & [ 0.0]\\ \rho(763 ) & ( 1^{--},1 ^ -)&0.7 & [ 2.2 ] & 0.42&[3.2 ] & 1.10 & [ 1.53 ] & 0.41 & [ 6.1]\\ f_1(1285 ) & ( 1^{++},0^+)&0.5 & [ -1.5 ] & 0.22 & & 0.59 & [ 0 ] & & \\
a_1(119 ) & ( 1^{++},1 ^ -)&1.0 & [ -1.5 ] & 0.6 & & 1.64 & [ 0 ] & & \\
\hline\hline \end{array}\ ] ] | tests of time reversal symmetry at low and medium energies may be analyzed in the framework of effective hadronic interactions . here , we consider the quark structure of hadrons to make a connection to the more fundamental degrees of freedom .
it turns out that for @xmath0even @xmath1odd interactions hadronic matrix elements evaluated in terms of quark models give rise to factors of 2 to 5 . also , it is possible to relate the strength of the anomalous part of the effective @xmath2 type @xmath1odd @xmath0even tensor coupling to quark structure effects . |
in this work we consider the mechanical response of an amorphous solid quenched at zero temperature .
our formalism permits dealing explicitly with finite size systems : it rests on the idea that , during a quench at zero temperature , any finite size system relaxes toward one of many local minima in the potential energy landscape .
@xcite being at zero temperature , the system is then prescribed to lie at this minimum at all times .
small external perturbations are then expected to induce continuous changes in the local minimum .
large external perturbations may induce the vanishing of the local minimum occupied by the system : this vanishing occurs when the basin of attraction of this minimum reduces to a single point , that is when the minimum collides with at least one saddle point .
@xcite the difference between small , continuous changes of the local configuration and catastrophic events is exemplified figure [ fig : strain ] where the response of an amorphous system is shown as a function of shear .
the parameter @xmath0 measures the total shear deformation from a quenched state . in this picture ,
continuous segments are associated with shear - induced changes of local minima and discontinuities to their vanishing . after a minimum has disappeared , the system , coupled to a zero temperature thermal bath , relaxes in search of a new minimum in the potential energy landscape .
@xcite the separation of continuous changes of the local minimum and catastrophic events is , of course , not limited to shear deformation . in a more general context ,
suppose that we denote by @xmath0 the amplitude of any external drive applied to the system .
suppose that the system lies at a minimum which , for @xmath1 , is far from any catastrophe .
let us denote @xmath2 the amplitude of a perturbation of the external drive around @xmath3 .
if we were to slowly increase the amplitude of the perturbation from 0 , the system would smoothly follow a trajectory @xmath4 in configuration space for all amplitudes @xmath5 such that the basin of the local minimum remains non - vanishing .
if the hessian is non - degenerate , this trajectory @xmath6 is unique .
if we now stop the perturbation at some @xmath7 then revert the drive down to @xmath8 , the system would simply follow the trajectory @xmath4 from @xmath9 to @xmath3 , backward . in this sense
we will say that the continuous segments are microscopically reversible .
when the system is driven quasi - statically along these continuous segments , no energy is dissipated .
the reason is that at each point along these segments , the system is at mechanical equilibrium : the force applied to any particle is exactly zero and zero forces do no work .
the quasi - static response corresponds to the thermodynamically reversible , elastic , part of the mechanical response .
we will see , however , that energy is dissipated when the system is driven at finite deformation rates along these continuous segments .
this dissipation results from the fact that finite deformation rates induce non - zero forces which dissipate energy via the coupling with the zero temperature thermal bath
. we shall let underline and double - underlines respectively indicate vectors and tensors referred to a fixed cartesian system @xmath10 .
we shall also use the convention that greek indices refer to cartesian components of vectors or tensors , while roman indices refer to the particle numbers .
bold type denotes fields which are defined on every particle in the material : @xmath11 dots and double dots indicate matrix products and summation convention is always applied on repeated ( greek and latin ) indices . by convention , we also write : @xmath12 the superscript @xmath13 indicates the transpose of a matrix , @xmath14 its inverse , and @xmath15 the inverse of its transpose .
the identity matrix is denoted @xmath16 , and its components @xmath17 . in this work , utilizing the formalism underlying the andersen - parrinello - rahman theory @xcite we shall focus on the situation where a system of particles is contained in a periodic simulation cell .
the formalism we describe can easily be adapted to study the deformation of a material confined between walls : to do so , it is sufficient to embed the whole system confined particles plus walls in the cell and mandate that the particles constituting the walls affinely follow its deformation .
the shape of the simulation cell ( which is , by construction , a parallelepiped ) is represented by the set of @xmath18 or @xmath19 bravais vectors : @xmath20 or @xmath21 ; its volume is @xmath22 .
we consider a system of @xmath23 particles , with positions @xmath24 in real space .
the interaction potential @xmath25 depends on the positions of the particles but also on the shape of the simulation cell which enforces boundary conditions .
`` macroscopic '' deformations of the sample are performed by changing the bravais vectors .
since we are concerned with variations of the local minimum around some reference configuration , we will often use a _ reference _ configuration @xmath26 of the cell and compare it with a _ current _ value @xmath27 . following ray and rahman , @xcite
we introduce a transformation of particle coordinates which maps any vector @xmath28 onto a cubic reference cell : @xmath29 with @xmath30 $ ] .
if we change the cell coordinate from @xmath26 to @xmath27 and require that all particles affinely follow the deformation of the cell , any particle at point @xmath31 is mapped onto @xmath32 .
we denote @xmath33 which , in the usual language of elasticity , is the deformation gradient tensor .
@xcite once the reference frame @xmath26 is specified , any configuration @xmath34 of the system can be parameterized by a pair @xmath35 , with the convention that : @xmath36 . in this parameterization
, changes in @xmath37 correspond to affine transformations of all the particles following the cell shape , while changes in @xmath38 correspond to the non - affine part of the displacement of the particles . at zero temperature ,
an infinitesimal deformation of the system is often performed in two steps .
first , starting from a local minimum @xmath39 at @xmath26 , the particle coordinates affinely follow the change of the cell coordinate from @xmath26 to @xmath27 .
the @xmath39 remain constant .
the real - space position of particle @xmath40 is thus mapped from @xmath38 onto @xmath41 .
second , the particles are allowed to relax to the nearest equilibrium position , @xmath27 being fixed .
they reach new positions @xmath42 which differ in general from @xmath43 .
the non - affine part of the deformation is then characterized by the displacements as viewed in the reference frame , @xmath44 . for small displacements ,
the particles continuously follow changes of local minima .
the real space positions of the particles at equilibrium are thus a continuous function of @xmath27 ( on some interval of strains ) , and we could denote these equilibria as @xmath45 . likewise , the continuous changes of local minima are most readily studied by monitoring changes in the _ reference _ co - ordinates : @xmath46 . by definition ,
elastic constants are second order derivatives of the energy with respect to strain .
since strain is characterized by second order tensors , the elastic constants are fourth order tensors . before presenting the details of the tensorial formalism , however , it seemed pedagogically sounder to us to first consider the simple situation where the shape of the cell can be parameterized by a single degree of freedom .
suppose then that we prescribe the tensor @xmath47 as a function of a scalar parameter @xmath0 . for varying @xmath0 ,
so long as the local minimum does not vanish , the system follows a continuous trajectory in configuration space as illustrated on figure [ fig : strain ] . given a reference cell @xmath48 at @xmath3 , the energy functional
can be written either as a function of @xmath49 and @xmath0 : @xmath50 ; or as a function of @xmath51 and @xmath0 : @xmath52 .
we introduce the notation @xmath53 to emphasize that contrarily to @xmath54this function is defined after a choice of reference cell with bravais matrix @xmath26 .
changing @xmath0 for fixed @xmath39 corresponds to performing an affine strain of the whole system the particles and the boundary .
when particles are constrained to follow deformation - induced changes of a local minimum , their real - space positions @xmath55 and the corresponding non - affine displacements @xmath56 are now one - parameter functions of @xmath0 . an equation of motion for the non - affine displacement fields derives from a straightforward application of the implicit function theorem : the trajectory is specified by the condition that the system is always at mechanical equilibrium : @xmath57 note that the second equality is a property of the point derivatives of any observable of the form , @xmath58 : @xmath59 and is derived in appendix a. differentiating the condition @xmath60 once with respect to @xmath0 leads to : @xmath61 where the symbol @xmath62 is introduced to indicate derivatives which are taken under the constraints of mechanical equilibrium .
this equation is formally valid for all @xmath63 , even though it will primarily be used in the limit @xmath64 ( i.e. @xmath65 ) . using equation ( [ eqn : deriv : point ] )
, we see that in the limit @xmath64 , equation ( [ eqn : motion : gamma ] ) involves the hessian : @xmath66 and the field of virtual forces , @xmath67 in semi - condensed notation , equation ( [ eqn : motion : gamma ] ) reads : @xmath68 in order to solve equation ( [ eqn : motion : gamma:0 ] ) we need to take care to eliminate the zero modes of the hessian .
generically there are @xmath69 zero modes for a system in @xmath69 dimension : those correspond to translation invariance ; their existence indicates that a solution to equation ( [ eqn : motion : gamma:0 ] ) can only be defined up to global translations of the particles .
there are no zero modes associated with rotations because the geometry of the simulation cell ( a parallelepiped ) breaks the invariance of the problem under global rotations of the particles ( at fixed cell boundaries ) .
the zero modes can thus be eliminated in the standard way by subtracting off the projection onto uniform translations from any particular solution . up to this invariance
, the solution of ( [ eqn : motion : gamma:0 ] ) reads : @xmath70 the numerical practice which consist in , first affinely deforming the simulation cell , then letting the system relax toward the displaced minimum , provides a direct physical interpretation for this equation .
@xmath71 is the field of forces which would result from an elementary affine deformation of all the particles .
equation ( [ eqn : dr:0 ] ) shows that the non - affine displacements are just the linear response of the system to these extra forces .
examples for the fields @xmath71 and @xmath72 in simple ( left ) and @xmath73 ( right ) as defined in the text for a typical atomistic system .
the deformation mode is simple shear .
note the random character of @xmath74 and the strong correlations in @xmath73 , title="fig : " ] ( left ) and @xmath73 ( right ) as defined in the text for a typical atomistic system .
the deformation mode is simple shear .
note the random character of @xmath74 and the strong correlations in @xmath73 , title="fig : " ] shear and pure compression are shown figure [ fig : fields ] and [ fig : fields : c ] .
( the details of the numerical simulation will be given in section 1.5 . )
we observe that the short - range randomness of the vector @xmath75 contrasts with the large vortex - like structures displayed by the non - affine `` velocity '' fields @xmath76 .
we will later use the apparent disorder of the field @xmath77 to construct a statistical treatment of the contributions of these non - affine displacement to the elastic constants . for now , let us move on to study how these non - affine fields enter microscopic equations for the elastic constants .
( left ) and @xmath73 ( right ) in pure compression . ,
title="fig : " ] ( left ) and @xmath73 ( right ) in pure compression .
, title="fig : " ] upon deformation , the first and second derivative of the energy @xmath78 are related to the components of the stress and the elastic constant respectively .
we will later enter a full tensorial derivation of the equations to specify this relation .
for now , we can simply differentiate @xmath79 with respect to @xmath0 . at first order
, we obtain a projection of the stress : @xmath80 where the second equality holds because of mechanical equilibrium .
the partial derivative which appears at the rightmost side of these equalities corresponds to the projection of stress which would be inferred from the assumption that all the particles undergo affine displacements .
since the total derivative of the energy as a function of @xmath0 ( while enforcing the condition of mechanical equilibrium ) is identical to the partial derivative , it means that non - affine displacements do not contribute to the _ first _ derivative of energy with respect to @xmath0 , _
i.e. _ the projected stress .
the situation , however , is different when the second derivative of the energy is considered . indeed , we have : @xmath81 the first term in the right hand side of this equation , @xmath82 , corresponds to energy changes associated with strictly affine displacements of the particles .
it is the born approximation for the second derivative of the energy with respect to @xmath0 .
the last term introduces a correction to the born approximation which results from the existence of non - affine displacements .
since @xmath83 is positive definite , the corrective term is negative : non - affine displacements reduce the second order derivative of the energy from its born approximation .
this is another statement of the idea that non - affine displacement are associated with further minimization of the energy of the system from a tentative homogeneous deformation .
this property holds for any mode of deformation @xmath47 .
it means , for example , that the non - affine corrections to the shear and compression moduli must be negative . in the preceding section
, we considered the non - affine displacements in response to some prescribed mode of deformation parameterized by a scalar parameter , @xmath0 .
we now proceed to study the tensorial form of the above equations : derivatives of the energy functional with respect to the components of the strain tensor will provide analytical expressions for stress and elastic constants . the calculations can be simplified by noting that the number of independent components of the strain tensor is reduced by symmetry .
in particular , a useful symmetry property holds under the general assumption that @xcite the interaction potential can be written as a function of the full set of distances between pairs of interacting particles : @xmath84 , where the index @xmath85 runs overs all pairs of particles , and for each pair , @xmath86 modulo the periodic boundary conditions .
( note that for a periodic simulation cell , the distance between two points depends on their positions relative to the boundaries of the cell : the way distances are calculated thus depends on the shape of the cell , hence , on @xmath27 . )
we stress that the ability to write the energy functional in this way is not restricted to potentials involving only pair interactions : it also holds for _ e.g. _ three body interactions which depends on bond angles , as used for silicon @xcite , or embedded atom potentials @xcite , as used for metals .
this formalism does not apply , however , to situations when rotational degrees of freedom must be taken into account as , for instance , in cosserat approaches to granular materials @xcite or to model anisotropic objects like nematics . @xcite we expect a similar formal treatment to be possible in these situations , but it will require using a slightly more general formalism that we do not wish to address here . let us consider a reference configuration @xmath26 and a current configuration @xmath27 .
suppose that @xmath87 and @xmath31 are the difference between the positions of two particles in both these systems of coordinates .
they are related by @xmath88 , whence : @xmath89 with the green - saint venant strain tensor : @xcite @xmath90 we want to write the energy functional after the change of variable where any configuration @xmath34 of the system is mapped onto @xmath91 . under the general assumption that the potential energy can be written as a function of the distances @xmath92 only , equation ( [ eqn : stretch ] ) can be used to write : @xmath93 where it appears that the energy of the system is a function of @xmath94 and @xmath95 only .
@xcite the notation @xmath53 is introduced here to emphasize that this functional of @xmath94 and @xmath95 is defined after a choice of reference cell with bravais matrix @xmath26 ( whereas the functional @xmath25 does not depend on this choice ) .
a choice of @xmath26 being made , however , the energy functional depends on the current cell coordinates only _ via _ the symmetric tensor @xmath96 , but not _ via _ the whole tensor @xmath27 .
we recover the separation of coordinates : changing @xmath96 for fixed @xmath39 corresponds to performing an affine strain of the whole system the particles and the boundary ; changing @xmath39 in the reference cell corresponds to performing non - affine displacements of the particles .
we are now in a position to derive equations of motion for non - affine displacement fields in a fully tensorial form . in any configuration , the force acting on particle @xmath40 is : @xmath97 and mechanical equilibrium reads : @xmath98 the derivatives are taken here for fixed cell coordinates . the equation of motion for @xmath39 ,
is now obtained by differentiation of ( [ eqn : mechanical ] ) with respect to the components of @xmath96 : @xmath99 with the usual summation convention of repeated ( greek and latin ) indices .
as above , the symbol @xmath62 denotes partial derivatives with respect to some tensorial components while enforcing mechanical equilibrium ( [ eqn : mechanical ] ) . in the limit @xmath100 , equation ( [ eqn : motion ] ) involves the hessian : @xmath101 and the field of third order tensors , @xmath102 in semi - condensed notation ,
equation ( [ eqn : motion ] ) reads : @xmath103 provided standard caution in the inversion of the hessian , we then get , up to translation modes : @xmath104 which is the non - affine displacement field in response to elementary deformation along @xmath105 . to get further insight into the correction term in equation ( [ eqn : c : xi ] ) , and on the physical interpretation of @xmath77 , let us write
: @xmath106 this equality comes after differentiation of equation ( [ eqn : force ] ) with respect to @xmath96 and use of mechanical equilibrium ( equation ( [ eqn : mechanical ] ) ) . as in our pedagogical example of one - parameter strain , the field @xmath107 ,
can be interpreted as the forces which would result from an elementary affine displacement of all particles in the strain direction @xmath105 .
( more specifically , @xmath108 , with no summation on the greek indices , is the force resulting from a small affine transformation by @xmath109 ; @xmath107 is the tangent direction to the changes of forces upon affine transformations . )
we see that @xmath110 can be seen as the fluctuation of the force @xmath111 in response to an elementary strain .
this interpretation emphasizes the random character of field @xmath107 : local forces are , by definition zero at mechanical equilibrium ; however , their variation under an elementary strain depends on the configuration of the particles with which particle @xmath40 interacts ; in particular , @xmath110 should be zero if the conformation of particles surrounding @xmath40 is symmetric which is the case of a bravais crystal .
@xmath107 is thus a measure of the local asymmetry of particle configurations .
equation ( [ eqn : dr ] ) further states that the non - affine displacement is nothing but the linear response of the particles to these extra forces .
let us now derive microscopic equations for the stress and elastic constants . because the total potential energy is a function of @xmath96 and @xmath51 only it is sufficient to characterize the elastic response of a material using the derivatives of the potential energy with respect to the components of @xmath96 .
we note , however , that the usual definition of the cauchy stress and elastic stiffnesses involves derivatives with respect to the components of the deformation gradient tensor @xmath37 .
derivatives with respect to the components of @xmath96 provide the so - called thermodynamic tension and elastic constants ( or also thermodynamic stiffnesses ) .
the definitions of thermodynamic tension , cauchy stress , elastic constants , elastic stiffnesses and their relation are given in appendix a. by definition , the thermodynamic tension is the derivative of the energy functional with respect to the components of @xmath96 : @xmath112 since @xmath96 is a symmetric tensor , we can conclude without further examination that thermodynamic tension is also symmetric . using mechanical equilibrium
, we next have : @xmath113 as in our pedagogical example of one - parameter strain , we see here that the thermodynamic tension is equal to the partial derivative of @xmath53 ( here , with respect to @xmath96 ) .
this partial derivative corresponds to changes in energy during a strictly affine displacement of the particles : we see that the existence of non - affine displacement fields does not appear in the expression for the thermodynamic tension .
expression ( [ eqn : xi : tension ] ) is valid for any finite strain : this will allow us to later differentiate this expression a second time and obtain elastic constants .
often , though , we will use it in the limit @xmath100 .
note that this expression for the thermodynamic tension provides another interpretation of the field @xmath77 .
we can write : @xmath114 from the definitions of @xmath115 and @xmath77 .
this expression is to compare with equation ( [ eqn : xi : cauchy ] ) .
we see that @xmath110 can be seen as a fluctuation of stress ( or tension ) in response to an elementary displacement of particle @xmath40 .
this interpretation was noted in @xcite .
the elastic constants are second derivatives of the energy functional with respect to the green - saint venant strain tensor : @xmath116 the derivative is here `` total '' since this is the second derivative of the energy following deformation - induce changes of a minimum .
as we can permute the order of derivatives , elastic constants verify @xmath117 , and since @xmath118 is symmetric , @xmath119 . to obtain an analytical expression for the elastic constants , it suffices to differentiate expression ( [ eqn : xi : tension ] ) once and take the limit @xmath100 afterwards : @xmath120 using equation ( [ eqn : dr ] ) and the definition of @xmath121 , it then comes : @xmath122 we recognize the first term in equation ( [ eqn : c : xi ] ) as the born approximation @xmath123 .
the contraction of the inverse of the hessian on components of @xmath121 provides the correction terms . here
, we illustrate these ideas with numerical simulations of a two - dimensional bidisperse mixture of particles interacting through a shifted lennard - jones potential . @xcite particle sizes @xmath125 and a number ratio @xmath126 are used to prevent crystallization .
the system is prepared via an initial quench from an infinite temperature state .
further details regarding the numerical protocols will be found in our forthcoming dedicated numerical study @xcite .
the interaction potential is pair - wise additive : @xmath127 . in this case ,
formal expressions for the fields @xmath110 and the born approximation for the elastic constants can be related directly to the derivatives of @xmath128 .
these expressions ( ( [ eqn : xi : micro : pair ] ) and ( [ eqn : born : micro : pair ] ) ) are derived in appendix b. we just recall here equation ( [ eqn : born : micro : pair ] ) : @xmath129 where we have introduced the normalized vector between pairs of particles : @xmath130 , as well as the bond tensions and stiffnesses : @xmath131 the material is expected to be isotropic so that the elastic constants take only two independent values under permutations of indices : @xmath132 , which define the lam constants , @xmath133 and @xmath134 .
using equation ( [ eqn : born : micro : pair:0 ] ) we observe that the born term is identical for the two lam constants @xmath133 and @xmath134 .
introducing the notation @xmath135 , we find : @xmath136 to calculate the lam constants , it suffices to consider two modes of deformation and the associated non - affine fields .
we thus consider @xmath137 and @xmath138 which are associated with pure shear and pure compression respectively .
plots of @xmath139 and @xmath140 , and their corresponding displacement fields were given on figure [ fig : fields ] and [ fig : fields : c ] respectively .
pure shear grants access to the sum : @xmath141 .
pure compression grants access to the sum : @xmath142 , where @xmath143 is in two dimensions the compression modulus . with the fields @xmath139 and @xmath140 , we can directly construct the non - affine correction to @xmath134 : @xmath144 ; and to @xmath145 : @xmath146 .
we recall that since the hessian is positive definite , these corrections are necessarily negative .
we thus have in all generality that for an isotropic material , @xmath147 and @xmath148 .
using these fields , we find in this sample , for the shear and compression moduli : @xmath149 , @xmath150 , whence @xmath151 and @xmath152 , @xmath153 , whence @xmath154 .
all moduli are reported in dimensionless stress units .
these values compare to the highest density systems studied by tanguy et al @xcite .
we note that the correction term to the compression modulus appears to be small .
this can be understood to arise from a simple property .
let us consider the case when the potential is pairwise additive , and is homogeneous in the sense that the force between each pair of particles is a homogeneous function of their distance : @xmath155 .
a pure compression corresponds to a global scaling of all distances : if the forces are homogeneous , a global scaling of the distances preserves a state of mechanical equilibrium .
in other word , whenever the forces are homogeneous functions of the distances , the fluctuating force field associated with pure compression , @xmath156 , vanishes identically . hence , the correction to the born approximation vanishes for the compression modulus : @xmath157 . for a compressed lennard - jones system , if the total energy is dominated by the pairs of particles which are at close distance , the interaction is thus dominated by the repulsive power - law divergence of the potential .
since this power - law leads to forces which are homogeneous functions of the distances , this repulsive part of the lennard - jones potential leads to vanishing corrections to the born approximation . as a result
the overall amplitude of the field @xmath140 is small , hence the small correction to @xmath145 . in particular , this is consistent with the data from tanguy et al @xcite and explains why the corrections induce important changes in both @xmath133 and @xmath134 but smaller changes in their sum .
in expression ( [ eqn : c : xi ] ) , the correction to elastic constants involves a contraction of the hessian on the fields @xmath121 .
since the hessian is positive definite we are perturbing around a local minimum
it acts as a scalar product in expressions such as : @xmath158 .
this form of the corrections to elasticity suggests that further insight may be gained from a normal mode decomposition of the fields @xmath107 .
we denote the eigenvectors of the hessian by @xmath159 and the associated eigenvalues by @xmath160 .
we introduce a particle mass to correctly scale eigenvalues and eigenfrequencies and write @xmath161 .
( in our numerical simulations , the mass is taken to be unity . )
the vector @xmath107 is written as : @xmath162 with @xmath163 . using this decomposition and equation ( [ eqn : dr ] ) ,
the non - affine displacement fields read : @xmath164 the non - affine contribution to elasticity reads : @xmath165 as we saw from figures [ fig : fields ] and [ fig : fields : c ] , the fields @xmath77 display a very random character .
the randomness of the fields @xmath71 can be further assessed by studying fluctuations of the weights of their normal mode decomposition . to examine this question ,
we report , in figure [ fig : xiscatter ] , all values of @xmath166 , with @xmath167 corresponding to pure shear deformation and pure compression .
these quantities are obtained by calculating the fields @xmath168 and performing a full diagonalization of the hessian .
we see that within a frequency shell @xmath169 $ ] , the values of @xmath166 are scattered , so that they can indeed be interpreted as random variables . on the scatter plot , it is apparent that the distributions of @xmath166 are symmetric with respect to the horizontal axis , hence that the @xmath166 s have zero mean : this property is enforced by symmetry since each of the eigenvectors of the hessian is defined up to a sign convention .
the width of the distributions of @xmath166 seem to depend smoothly on @xmath170 and increase with @xmath170 for the most part . at high frequencies the scatter plots thin out because there are fewer and fewer eigenvectors to sample the density of states close to its upper cut - off .
on the basis of this observation , we make the assumption that the random fields , @xmath107 , and in particular their projections on normal modes , @xmath171 , are self - averaging quantities .
we thus introduce the correlators on frequency shells : @xmath172}\ ] ] in this definition , the average is performed for all the projections of @xmath121 and @xmath107 on eigenvectors with eigenfrequency @xmath169 $ ] . the assumption that @xmath171 are
self - averaging means that the quantities @xmath173 are expected to converge toward well - defined functions of @xmath170 in the thermodynamic limit : either when a large ensemble of systems of a given size is considered , or when one single system of a large size is considered . from their definition
, we observe that functions @xmath173 verify the same symmetries as the elastic constants , namely : @xmath174 in the thermodynamic limit , we can finally rewrite equation ( [ eqn : c : xi ] ) as : @xmath175 where @xmath176 is the density of states is , somewhat unconventionally , normalized to the number of degrees of freedom per unit volume . ] .
this equation is a sum rule : it relates elastic constants to the integral of a correlator between microscopic fields . versus the corresponding eigenfrequencies of the hessian ( with @xmath177 in shear ( top ) and @xmath178 in compression ( bottom ) ) .
@xmath166 is the projection of the field @xmath179 onto the eigenmode @xmath180 with frequency @xmath181 .
this set of data has been obtained using one typical system of size @xmath182 .
each point makes a contribution to the non - affine corrections to the elastic constants as described in the text . ] like the elastic constants , @xmath183 are tensorial quantities .
therefore , if the material is isotropic given the symmetry property ( [ eqn : gamma : sym]) these functions can take only two independent values corresponding to the two lam constants @xmath133 and @xmath134 : @xmath184 in this case , the two correlators , @xmath185 and @xmath186 provide a complete description of the non - affine corrections to the lam constants according to equation ( [ eqn : sum ] )
. to illustrate this discussion , we return to our two - dimensional numerical study of two modes of deformation , simple shear and pure compression .
this protocol suffices to measure the two lam constants of our system .
the vector fields @xmath139 and @xmath140 grant direct access to the quantities @xmath187 for @xmath167 . elementary algebra ,
similar to the calculations of section 1.5 , shows that these quantities also verify : @xmath188 and @xmath189 .
we report , in figure [ fig : dos ] , $ ] , as described in the text .
results were obtained as ensemble averages over 20 systems of sizes @xmath190 with @xmath191 : 20 circles ( black ) , 25 squares ( red ) , and 30 diamonds ( green ) .
convergence of the curves demonstrates that finite size effects are small .
( a ) density of states .
( b , c ) magnitude of `` noise '' field , @xmath192 , for simple shear ( b ) and compression ( c ) .
( d , e ) net contribution to elasticity , @xmath193 , of each frequency band for shear ( d ) and compression ( e ) .
, title="fig : " ] + $ ] , as described in the text .
results were obtained as ensemble averages over 20 systems of sizes @xmath190 with @xmath191 : 20 circles ( black ) , 25 squares ( red ) , and 30 diamonds ( green ) .
convergence of the curves demonstrates that finite size effects are small .
( a ) density of states .
( b , c ) magnitude of `` noise '' field , @xmath192 , for simple shear ( b ) and compression ( c ) .
( d , e ) net contribution to elasticity , @xmath193 , of each frequency band for shear ( d ) and compression ( e ) .
, title="fig : " ] $ ] , as described in the text .
results were obtained as ensemble averages over 20 systems of sizes @xmath190 with @xmath191 : 20 circles ( black ) , 25 squares ( red ) , and 30 diamonds ( green ) .
convergence of the curves demonstrates that finite size effects are small .
( a ) density of states .
( b , c ) magnitude of `` noise '' field , @xmath192 , for simple shear ( b ) and compression ( c ) .
( d , e ) net contribution to elasticity , @xmath193 , of each frequency band for shear ( d ) and compression ( e ) .
, title="fig : " ] $ ] , as described in the text .
results were obtained as ensemble averages over 20 systems of sizes @xmath190 with @xmath191 : 20 circles ( black ) , 25 squares ( red ) , and 30 diamonds ( green ) .
convergence of the curves demonstrates that finite size effects are small .
( a ) density of states .
( b , c ) magnitude of `` noise '' field , @xmath192 , for simple shear ( b ) and compression ( c ) .
( d , e ) net contribution to elasticity , @xmath193 , of each frequency band for shear ( d ) and compression ( e ) .
, title="fig : " ] $ ] , as described in the text .
results were obtained as ensemble averages over 20 systems of sizes @xmath190 with @xmath191 : 20 circles ( black ) , 25 squares ( red ) , and 30 diamonds ( green ) .
convergence of the curves demonstrates that finite size effects are small .
( a ) density of states .
( b , c ) magnitude of `` noise '' field , @xmath192 , for simple shear ( b ) and compression ( c ) .
( d , e ) net contribution to elasticity , @xmath193 , of each frequency band for shear ( d ) and compression ( e ) .
, title="fig : " ] the density of states @xmath194 , the correlators @xmath195 , @xmath196 , and the quantities @xmath197 ( with @xmath198 ) which measure the total contribution of the shell @xmath199 $ ] to the non - affine corrections .
three system sizes have been used in this plot : @xmath200 and @xmath201 , where @xmath191 is the length of the square simulation cell in dimensionless units . for each size ,
an ensemble of 20 system was used to provide statistical accuracy .
the functions @xmath202 and @xmath203 measure the variance of the distributions of @xmath204 and @xmath205 respectively , which appear on the scatter plot of figure [ fig : xiscatter ] .
we see that that these functions are roughly increasing as was suggested from the observation of the scatter plot .
important fluctuations of @xmath186 and @xmath206 at high frequencies result from the lack of statistical representation in the region where the density of states vanishes and where the scatter plots thin out . for their main part , however , the curves lie on top of one another for the three system sizes we have used : this is evidence that the continuous limit has already been reached .
this observation is consistent with the numerics of tanguy et al @xcite since the values of the elastic constants they measured did not vary much for the different sizes they studied , from @xmath207 to @xmath208 .
we believe that the good convergence of these measurements results from the decorrelation of the fluctuating forces @xmath209 at very short distances : because the correlation length is short , the finite sizes of the systems considered here provide enough sampling of the distribution of @xmath209 . the density of states , and the @xmath210 s exhibit rather complicated functional forms .
in contrast , it is striking to us that for simple shear and pure compression @xmath211 seems rather featureless ; particularly in comparison with both the density of states and the functions @xmath212 .
we have observed this for different numerical models and different densities .
@xcite the monotonous decay of @xmath213 and @xmath214 seems to indicate that a simple physical mechanism like a transfer of elasticity from low to high frequency phonons governs the non - affine corrections .
this reminds us of an analysis by radjai and roux of quasi - static deformation of granular materials @xcite in which the authors suggested that the non - affine velocity field could exhibit statistical properties similar to turbulence .
this sound like an appealing suggestion , although , at present , we have no evidence to further test the existence of turbulent - like energy transfers from large to small scales .
in the above formalism , we assumed that deformation was very slowly forced upon a piece of material , so that the relaxation of the system toward an inherent structure was always faster than the changes induced by the external drive .
this guaranteed that the system followed an energy minimum in configuration space .
our analysis , however , is essentially based on a second order expansion of the energy functional : it assumes small displacements , but may , in principle , apply to situations when the timescale of the external drive becomes relevant .
we consider here oscillatory perturbations of small amplitude , and assume that the system remains in the linear response regime around some energy minimum , far away from any catastrophic event .
we expect this situation to be of relevance to questions such as _ e.g. _ acoustic damping in granular materials @xcite or viscoelasticity in dense emulsions and foams @xcite . near a minimum , but not exactly _ at _ mechanical equilibrium , the particles are subjected to non - zero forces : an oscillatory external forcing at finite rate thus works on the system of particles .
energy is injected into the system and is lost in dissipative mechanisms at the microscopic scale ( friction between grains or viscous dissipation between bubbles ) .
we will follow the usual practice of characterizing energy transfers in the linear response regime using the components of the complex stress response , that is the storage and loss moduli , @xmath215 and @xmath216 .
@xcite we insist that we focus here on features of @xmath215 and @xmath216 that arise merely from the existence of non - affine displacement fields _ around a single minimum_. in an experiment
think , for example , of a foam it is unclear whether sufficiently small strain amplitudes can be achieved so as to stay within the basin of attraction of a single equilibrium configuration .
thus measured values of @xmath215 and @xmath216 would also receive contributions from plasticity in addition to the microscopic visco - elasticity studied here : transitions between distinct inherent structures would become a relevant mechanism of energy dissipation @xcite .
it s only after a careful study of the contribution of linear response that we will be in a position to characterize the relative importance of these various dissipative mechanisms .
the present work is a preliminary step in this direction . in order to work at finite strain rates ,
we need to use newton s equations coupled with the deformation of our simulation cell . in order to prevent the system from heating up
, a microscopic mechanism must be specified for energy dissipation .
dissipative mechanisms vary from system to system . in granular packings ,
dissipation involves the deformation of asperities at contact between grains . in foams ,
dissipation involves fluid flow inside a liquid phase : it is modeled by durian @xcite by viscous terms involving velocity differences between neighboring bubbles . in numerical simulations of structural glasses and supercooled liquids , the coupling with an external bath is modeled either by a nos - hoover @xcite thermostat , by use of a lagrange multiplier @xcite , or by a berendsen thermostat @xcite .
it thus appears , after examination of these different systems , that energy dissipation often arises as some sort of viscous damping at the microscopic level .
we will thus limit our present discussion to the situation where dissipation enters via a viscous drag force applied on individual particles .
below , we give some rule - of - thumb estimates for what the value of this viscosity might be in the case of dense emulsions . in the sllod algorithm , the viscous term is generally taken to be proportional to the peculiar velocity , @xcite that is the velocity @xmath217 of the particle minus its velocity corresponding to the affine flow @xmath218 .
similarly , in foams or granular materials , the viscous damping does not depend on the velocity in real space but on the difference between the particles velocity and their surrounding environment .
we thus first write the equations of motion as : @xmath219 in term of @xmath39 , it follows that : @xmath220 we see here that a term @xmath221 arises which depends on the position of the particle in the simulation cell .
another term of similar flavor would be @xmath222 : it does not appear in equation ( [ eqn : motion : r00 ] ) because it has already been eliminated by the above assumption that the viscous dissipation applies to the _ peculiar _ velocities .
such terms introduce a spatially dependent coupling between particular motion and the cell coordinates : they can not be allowed to enter the equations of motion if we want to enforce translation invariance .
this was originally noted by andersen @xcite and later by ray and rahman @xcite . within the formalism of souza and martins @xcite , an equation of motion with no spatially dependent terms
can be derived systematically from a lagrangian .
it relies on the idea that the distance traveled by a particle should be calculated while removing a component of rigid rotation .
we do not wish to detail this formalism here , but simply recall that adding appropriate terms in the lagrangian of the system ( particles plus simulation cell ) permits eliminating space - dependent terms from equation ( [ eqn : motion : r00 ] ) .
following these authors , we eliminate the term @xmath221 and focus on translation invariant equations of motion for an athermal system in sllod dynamics .
these equations read : @xmath223 we want to account for the dynamics of the system when it is submitted to small amounts of strain @xmath224 .
to do so , we write a perturbative expansion of equation ( [ eqn : motion : r0 ] ) around a known equilibrium state @xmath39 .
this expansion is written in terms of the displacements @xmath225 , which are also of order @xmath226 . at first order in @xmath226 ,
the perturbed equations of motion read : @xmath227 using the definition of @xmath228 and @xmath229 ( equations ( [ eqn : h:2 ] ) and ( [ eqn : xi:2 ] ) ) it follows that : @xmath230 this equation governs the linear response of our system around a single minimum . starting from this equation ,
various limits allow us to recover more usual expressions .
for example , taking @xmath231 and canceling the term on the right hand side yields the equation governing the vibration modes of the system ; canceling @xmath232 and @xmath233 yields the equations which governs quasi - static response and defines the non - affine displacement fields . to solve equation ( [ eqn : lin ] ) , we perform two transformations : a fourier transform of the time domain , and a normal mode decomposition of the displacement field .
the fourier components @xmath234 are the responses to perturbations of the form @xmath235 .
they are further decomposed onto normal modes as : @xmath236 and @xmath237 . with these notations ,
we find : @xmath238 which is solved by : @xmath239 the perturbed stress is then obtained by writing at first order in @xmath226 : @xmath240 using ( [ eqn : x : sol ] ) , the complex stress response in the frequency domain thus reads : @xmath241 it can thus be recast in the form : @xmath242 with : @xmath243 taking the thermodynamic limit , we can furthermore introduce the functions @xmath173 defined in equation ( [ eqn : gamma ] ) . equation ( [ eqn : g ] ) can then be written as an integral in frequency domain : @xmath244 it is then an easy task to extract the real and imaginary part of the stress response .
observe that we recover the born approximation and the true elastic constants in the high and low frequency limits respectively .
the response moduli are often studied in the overdamped limit , when the kinetic energy remains small compared to the elastic energy .
@xcite in this case , the term @xmath245 is negligible before @xmath246 and equation ( [ eqn : moduli ] ) can be given a simpler form .
to do so , we introduce the timescales : @xmath247 and write equation ( [ eqn : moduli ] ) as : @xmath248 where @xmath249 the complex modulus @xmath250 is thus naturally written as a sum of maxwell elements . by definition ,
@xcite the function @xmath251 is the relaxation spectrum of the system .
it is the product of the density of states with the correlator @xmath183 .
the specific forms of this relation associated with a given experimental geometry pure shear or pure compression derive trivially from these tensorial expressions . :
20 circles ( black ) , 25 squares ( red ) , and 30 diamonds ( green ) . ] we plot the shear relaxation spectrum for our model system in figure [ fig : relaxationspectrum ] , again for each of the three ensembles of systems with lengths 20,25 , and 30 , demonstrating the system size independence of the results .
since the true microscopic mechanisms of dissipation in real structural glasses remain somewhat poorly understood , we focus here on the case of a dense emulsion or foam , where the system is overdamped by construction . to make a semi - quantitative comparison with experiments on such systems , we need to give a rough estimate for the values of the coefficient of viscosity , @xmath233 , and the overall stiffness scale , @xmath252 , in our model .
a truly quantitative connection with experiment is somewhat beyond the scope of the present work and will be explored in our dedicated numerical study @xcite .
we should also remind the reader that the data presented in this work for illustrative purposes is taken from a compressed system with lennard - jones interactions ... clearly not sufficient for a fully quantitative comparison .
however , the hope is that there is a good deal of qualitative similarity in the structure of the hessian matrix for these various classes of disordered systems , and we proceed to dimensionalize @xmath252 and @xmath233 in order to make a semi - quantitative comparison with experiments on packings of emulsified droplets . a series of experiments , simulations , and theoretical works on such a system was carried out by mason and coworkers @xcite .
the surface tension of the droplets was found to be about @xmath253 , which , for well - compressed systems , should set the average scale of the interparticle stiffnesses . for crystalline systems ,
the scale of interparticle stiffness is characterized by the maximum eigenvalue of the system ( corresponding to eigenvectors which are plane waves with periodicity equal to one reciprocal lattice vector ) , thus we scale the eigenvalues of the hessian matrix of our system such that the maximum eigenvalues are roughly @xmath254 .
those maximum eigenvalues of the hessian matrix , as can be read off from the density of states , are about 5000 in our dimensionless units of stiffness , so we must have @xmath255}{[l]}=\frac{10}{5000}=2.10^{-3}{\text{dyne}/\text{cm}}$ ] .
this sets the scales of the second derivatives of the potential .
the order of magnitude of elastic constants then comes out by dividing @xmath256 by the average interparticule distance , that is by the diameter of droplets in the case of an emulsion .
taking a droplet radius of a micron , this sets the scale of elastic constants as @xmath257=10~\text{dyne}/\text{cm}^2 $ ] .
our measurement of elastic constants in the range of 100 , thus corresponds to values of order @xmath258 .
following durian @xcite , we ought to choose a value for @xmath233 such that the drag force , @xmath259 , between two droplets sliding past each other with relative velocity @xmath260 generates a stress in the film which is equal to the strain rate in the film times the effective viscosity , so we must have : @xmath261 where @xmath262 is the typical lateral extent of the film ( which , following durian , we take to be of the order of the droplet radius itself ) , and @xmath263 is the width of the film gap .
we can now dimensionalize our units of time , @xmath264=\nu/\bar{\lambda}$ ] , using the estimate of liu _ et .
al . _ for the effective viscosity in the film at the droplet interface of @xmath265cp , a droplet radius of a micron , and a film thickness of a nanometer , yielding : @xmath264=5\text{s}$ ] .
from the plot of the relaxation spectrum in figure [ fig : relaxationspectrum ] , we expect the viscoelastic effects and the crossover to affine deformation to appear in the range of frequencies from around 1hz up to about 1khz in these systems .
in this article , we have studied molecular displacements associated with deformation - induced , continuous changes of a minimum in the potential energy landscape of an amorphous solid . for small amounts of deformation ,
the trajectory followed by the particles is smooth , and the tangent displacements analogous to a velocity , with strain playing the role of an effective time involve affine and non - affine fields .
both fields enter at first order in the equation of motion of the particles during quasi - static deformation .
the non - affine fields can be calculated by inverting the hessian on a fluctuating force field @xmath266 , which is formally a third order tensor . for every component @xmath267 of the deformation , @xmath121 is the field of forces resulting on every particle from the _ affine _ motion of its neighborhood .
the non - affine displacement fields and the corrections they induce on elastic constants , can be expressed solely in terms of the hessian and of various tensorial components of the field @xmath121 .
we next observe that the field @xmath121 is weakly correlated in space , so that it can essentially be considered as a random vector field .
this randomness is confirmed by the scattered values for the projections of @xmath121 on the eigenmodes of the hessian . the normal - mode analysis of the field @xmath121 grants access to the contribution of each frequency shell to non - affine corrections to elasticity .
our numerical calculations indicate that the correlation function @xmath268}$ ] converges toward a smooth function in the thermodynamic limit : this means that the contribution of each frequency shell to non - affine corrections to elasticity is self - averaging . in our view , the existence of a well - defined limit for the elastic properties of amorphous structures , as observed by tanguy _
et al _ , rest on this self - averaging property .
we moreover observed that the contribution of frequency shells seems to be a rather simple function of the frequency , as opposed to both @xmath173 and the density of states .
this simple form of corrections to elasticity suggests that an elementary mechanism of transfer of energy between frequency shells may be at work and determines corrections to elastic constants .
this is reminiscent of the observation by radjai and roux of turbulent like features of non - affine displacement fields , @xcite although we have not determined whether turbulent - like scalings arise in our non - affine fields .
a better understanding of the mechanism underlying this transfer through frequency shells should in principle permit construction of approximations for the elastic constants of amorphous materials . after studying elastic properties of an amorphous solid in response to quasi - static deformation , we considered the case when the deformation rate is finite .
this required us to introduce both a molecular mass and a damping term to provide equations of motions which correspond to a molecular system in contact with a bath at low or zero temperature .
we have shown that the visco - elastic response of the solid can be written in the form of a sum of elementary damped oscillators . the frequency spectrum that is the distribution of timescales of elementary vibration modes is directly related to the function @xmath173 .
it thus appears , that a broad spectrum of timescales arise at linear order solely from the structure of any particular energy minimum in a high dimensional configuration space .
the system remains solid since it resides in the neighborhood of a local minimum in configuration space at all times : this is different from the usual idea that visco - elastic response is associated with transitions between minima in the energy landscape @xcite . in a real system , this type of dissipation may occur simultaneously with other mechanisms : energy transport via phonons , dissipation resulting from anharmonic terms , or transitions between various energy minima ( _ i.e. _ true plasticity ) .
the estimation of these various contributions and their interplay seem to us an exciting direction for future research
. it will require the construction of models , close to the experiments , where various dissipative mechanisms can be estimated quantitatively .
finally , we stress that the corrections to elastic constants involve @xmath269 factors as in equation ( [ eqn : sum ] ) : the convergence of the integral in equation ( [ eqn : sum ] ) thus depends on the low frequency behavior of the functions @xmath183 and of the density of states .
this becomes a problem when the system develops low frequency eigenmodes which have a non - zero scalar product with the field @xmath266 : a quick inspection of equation ( [ eqn : munormal ] ) indeed shows that such localized low frequency phonons would lead to diverging terms in the non - affine corrections to the born approximation .
we can identify two situations when this occurs : ( i ) a localized eigenvector with a vanishing frequency is involved whenever the local minimum occupied by the system reaches a catastrophe .
@xcite this property enabled us to obtain universal scalings for the elastic moduli close to a shear induced catastrophe , @xcite and observe the divergence of the non - affine corrections at these points .
( ii ) eigenmodes seem to drift toward the low frequency part of the spectrum when the system approaches the unjamming point of liu and nagel .
@xcite a divergence of the non - affine corrections to elasticity could thus arise around this point . in this case
, we expect the divergence of the non - affine corrections to elasticity to control the unjamming transition around the @xmath270 point .
al received support from the william .
m. keck foundation , the mrsec program of the nsf under award no .
dmr00 - 80034 , the james . s. mcdonnell foundation , nsf grant no .
dmr-9813752 , the lucile packard foundation , the mitsubishi corporation , and the national science foundation under grant no .
phy99 - 07949 .
cm was supported under the auspices of the u.s .
department of energy by the university of california , lawrence livermore national laboratory under contract no .
w-7405-eng-48 and would like to acknowledge the guidance and support of v. v. bulatov and j. s. langer and the hospitality of the llnl university relations program .
stresses are first derivatives of an energy functional with respect to strains .
@xcite since there are different definitions of the strain tensors ( @xmath96 or @xmath37 or @xmath271 or @xmath272 ) , there are different ways to take this derivative . moreover , this derivative can be lagrangian or eulerian .
we thus have various choices , which leads to a number of possible definitions .
two definitions of the stress are most important : the thermodynamic tension is the lagrangian derivative with respect to @xmath96 ; the true stress is the eulerian derivative with respect to the deformation gradient tensor @xmath37 .
let us consider some energy functional , parameterized by the cell coordinates : @xmath273 .
this functional can represent different objects : for example , it can be the energy @xmath274 for fixed @xmath39 : its strain derivatives were denoted as partial derivatives in the previous discussion ; it can also be the energy @xmath275 , provided constraints which enforce a relation @xmath276 .
the formalism developed here does not depend on any specific definition of this energy functional but only on the existence of some function @xmath273 .
the value of @xmath277 in a given reference configuration is denoted @xmath278 .
we saw the important role played by the green - saint venant strain tensor @xmath96 : it accounts for the mapping of distances after an affine transformation ( see equation ( [ eqn : stretch ] ) ) .
this property permits writing the strain - dependence of the energy functional _ via _ @xmath96 only , whenever the energy is a function of the set of distances @xmath92 between the particles .
@xcite by definition , the thermodynamic tension @xcite is conjugate to the green - saint venant strain tensor : @xmath279 where @xmath280 is the volume of the reference cell .
the thermodynamic tension @xmath281 is defined after a choice of a reference configuration : it is a lagrangian derivative .
it identifies , in the continuum limit , with the second piola - kirchhoff stress tensor .
@xcite this object is known , in general , not to have a simple mechanical interpretation : it can not be interpreted as the tensor generating forces on surface elements .
the cauchy stress corresponds to the usual definition of a stress : it gives surface forces when contracted on a vector normal to a surface which is prescribed in the physical space .
it can be shown that the cauchy stress can be written as a derivative of the energy with respect to the deformation gradient tensor : @xmath282 unlike the second piola - kirchoff stress ( i.e. the thermodynamic tension ) the cauchy stress does not depend on the choice of a reference state .
this equality holds in the limit @xmath283 : in this sense it is an eulerian derivative of the energy .
as we will show below , the second piola - kirchoff stress becomes identical to the cauchy stress in the limit where the current and reference configuration are identified . in order to relate these two definitions of the stress tensor
, we need to be able to switch between @xmath96- and @xmath37-derivatives . from the definition ( [ eqn : epsilon ] ) of the green - saint venant strain tensor , infinitesimal displacements read : @xmath284 since @xmath118 is symmetric , in a @xmath69-dimensional problem , it has only @xmath285 independent components , while @xmath37 has @xmath286 .
the rotational degrees of freedom are taken into account by considering the antisymmetric infinitesimal displacements : @xcite @xmath287 which is the generator of infinitesimal rotations , and has @xmath288 independent components . from equations ( [ eqn : depsilon ] ) and ( [ eqn : domega ] ) , it comes : @xmath289 using this relation , the differential form of an arbitrary function of @xmath37 , @xmath290 , reads :
@xmath291 using the property that the contraction of a symmetric with an antisymmetric tensor vanishes and the fact that @xmath96 is symmetric , we see that the derivative of a function @xmath292 with respect to @xmath96 is : @xmath293\ ] ] incidentally , we also find from the preceding calculation that iff @xmath292 only depends on @xmath96 , hence does not vary under infinitesimal rotations , it verifies : @xmath294 with these formulae in hand , let us come back to the definition ( [ eqn : cauchy : def ] ) of the cauchy stress . taking the limit @xmath283 ( or @xmath100 ) , in equation ( [ eqn : deriv : sym ] ) and
looking at equation ( [ eqn : cauchy : def ] ) we see that @xmath295 is symmetric .
using equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta ] ) , it appears that it equals the thermodynamic tension _ in this limit _ , yet in this limit only .
we emphasize here that the symmetry of the stress tensor results directly from the invariance of the interaction potential under elementary rotations : the energy functional is expected to be a function of @xmath296 and @xmath96 only : its derivatives with respect to the components of @xmath297 vanish .
this is not , however , equivalent to the energy functional being invariant under global rotations ( the bravais cell being a parallelepiped is not ) .
we note , however , that in general @xmath298 ( evaluated off the reference configuration ) need not be symmetric : this may explain the observation of non - symmetric stresses in @xcite .
barron and klein @xcite provide the following relation between the cauchy stress and the thermodynamic tension : @xmath299 this relation holds for finite deformations .
it can be obtained , following these authors , after a taylor expansion of the energy versus the different strain tensors .
we provide here a different derivation which relies on an interesting property concerning the transport of derivatives . as usual , a reference configuration @xmath26 is given and the system is strained to a current configuration @xmath27 . in order to define the cauchy stress around the configuration @xmath27 , we will need to consider @xmath27 as a new reference configuration @xmath300 and also consider a new current configuration @xmath301 .
we thus have three different sets of cell coordinates : @xmath26 , @xmath302 and @xmath301 .
we need to define strain tensors between each pair of these configuration : the deformation gradient tensors are denoted @xmath303 , @xmath304 and @xmath305 .
these transformations are illustrated schematically in figure [ fig : framescartoon ] .
likewise , the green - saint venant tensors are denoted : @xmath306 , @xmath307 and @xmath96 .
we have the property : @xmath308 . for any arbitrary function @xmath290 , and for
@xmath37 , we can write : @xmath309 whence , @xmath310 using this and equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta ] ) it is then an easy check that : @xmath311 this relation simply means that the tensorial derivative with respect to @xmath96 transforms as a tensor under a change of reference configuration .
we just saw in equation ( [ eqn : deriv : f ] ) that this is not true of the derivative with respect to @xmath37 .
going back to the definition of the cauchy stress ( equation ( [ eqn : cauchy : def ] ) ) and taking the limit @xmath312 , we have @xmath313 and using equation ( [ eqn : deriv : transport ] ) in the limit @xmath314 ( or @xmath315 ) , we recover equation ( [ eqn : cauchy ] ) .
it is useful to `` specialize '' the previous expressions for the situations when the energy , or any observable can be parameterized as @xmath316 .
we first have : @xmath317 the factor 1/2 results from the fact that each pair is counted twice with the convention of implicit summation over repeated indices .
plugging equation ( [ eqn : deriv : f : micro ] ) ( and its transpose ) into equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta ] ) we immediately obtain , @xmath318 we see from equation ( [ eqn : deriv : transport ] ) that this expression consist of a reference - independent formula , which is transported backward in the reference configuration as in equation ( [ eqn : deriv : transport ] ) . specializing the functional @xmath292 to @xmath319
, we can now provide an expression for the cauchy stress tensor , using either equation ( [ eqn : cauchy ] ) and ( [ eqn : deriv : eta : micro ] ) or alternatively ( [ eqn : cauchy : def ] ) and ( [ eqn : deriv : f : micro ] ) .
it reads : @xmath320 this is a generalization of the kirkwood formula to the case of an arbitrary n - body interaction potential .
note that specialization to systems with pairwise interactions immediately yields the standard expression . specializing the function @xmath292 to @xmath321
, we can furthermore obtain a useful formula .
indeed , in the limit @xmath283 , equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta : micro ] ) reduces to : @xmath322 by definition , elastic _
constants _ are second derivatives of the energy functional with respect to the green - saint venant strain tensor : @xmath323 in this expression , the energy functional @xmath277 can be any given function of the tensor , @xmath118 .
for example , it can be the energy functional of an atomistic system @xmath324 for fixed positions of the particles in a reference configuration .
derivatives of such a functional were denoted as partial derivatives of @xmath53 throughout the text .
but @xmath277 could also be defined as the energy of an atomistic system following deformation induced changes of a given minimum . in this case
the partial derivatives of @xmath277 would correspond to total derivatives for the energy functional @xmath53 .
the algebra presented here does not depend on these considerations but only on the existence of a function @xmath325 . since we can commute the order of the derivatives , the elastic constants verify @xmath117 , and since @xmath118 is symmetric , @xmath119 .
the second order expansion of the energy with respect to the components of @xmath96 thus reads : @xmath326 where @xmath327 is the stress in the reference configuration . using ( [ eqn : tension ] ) and ( [ eqn : second ] ) , we find for the thermodynamic tension : @xmath328 the elastic constant should not be confounded with the quantities which enter the stress - strain relations hence , the wave equation .
these are the elastic stiffnesses , @xmath329 , and appear in the expansion of the energy with respect to tensor @xmath330 : @xcite @xmath331 the relation of the elastic stiffnesses to the elastic constants is obtained by replacing the definition ( [ eqn : epsilon ] ) of @xmath96 in equation ( [ eqn : second ] ) and expanding in terms of @xmath332 : @xcite @xmath333 note that this expression indicates that elastic stiffnesses do not enjoy the full symmetry of the elastic constants . instead , they verify : @xcite @xmath334 the cauchy stress can now be obtained from ( [ eqn : tension : exp ] ) by use of equations ( [ eqn : cauchy ] ) and ( [ eqn : stiffness ] ) : @xcite @xmath335 before proceeding to the derivation of an expression for the born term , let us derive a general formula for second derivatives with respect to the components of @xmath96 .
we first write equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta ] ) with indices explicitly expressed : @xmath336\ ] ] the derivative of this expression with respect to @xmath267 reads : @xmath337\ ] ] we then use the property that in the limit @xmath100 , @xmath338 by definition , whence we see that @xmath339 after application of equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta ] ) . in the limit @xmath100 , we thus have for the second derivatives , after a further application of equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta ] ) : @xmath340\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can now provide microscopic expressions for the born approximation to elastic constants .
we take the energy functional @xmath277 to be the energy @xmath53 for some fixed positions of the particles in a reference frame . using equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta : micro ] ) and ( [ eqn : deriv : f : micro ] )
it is an easy task to write the born term as : @xmath341 in order to obtain a similar expression for @xmath110 , it is convenient to write : @xmath342 with @xmath343 the pair contributions @xmath344 are then easily expressed in terms of pair contributions to the hessian : @xmath345 then , either using equation ( [ eqn : deriv : rij ] ) or applying equation ( [ eqn : deriv : eta : micro ] ) on @xmath111 , we find for @xmath344 an expression which is analogous to kirkwood s formula for the stress : @xmath346 this general formula permits relating @xmath110 to elementary contributions @xmath347 of pairs to the hessian .
we furthermore notice the similarity between equation ( [ eqn : xi : micro ] ) and equation ( [ eqn : born : micro ] ) .
it allows writing the following expression for the born term : @xmath348
we provide here specific expressions for the case when the interaction potential can be written as : @xmath349 in this case , the force on individual bonds reads : @xmath350 with , @xmath351 introducing the bond tensions and stiffnesses , @xmath352 the components of the hessian @xmath353 can be expressed in terms of : @xmath354 the elements of the hessian are then , @xmath355 for the off - diagonal terms and @xmath356 for the diagonal terms . to obtain an expression for the field @xmath107 , we write : @xmath357 with ( no implicit sum on @xmath40 and @xmath358 ) : @xmath359 whence , @xmath360 inserting this expression in the sum ( [ eqn : xii : xiij ] ) , the second term disappears because the system is at mechanical equilibrium .
this yields : @xmath361 | we study exact results concerning the non - affine displacement fields observed by tanguy _ et al _ [ europhys .
lett . * 57 * , 423 ( 2002 ) , phys .
rev .
b * 66 * , 174205 ( 2002 ) ] and their contributions to elasticity . a normal mode analysis permits us to estimate the dominant contributions to the non - affine corrections to elasticity and relate these corrections to the correlator of a fluctuating force field .
we extend this analysis to the visco - elastic dynamical response of the system .
+ keywords : amorphous solids , born - huang approximation , visco - elasticity , non - affine a straightforward estimate of the elastic constants of simple crystals can be performed in the ( classical ) zero temperature limit : the relative initial positions of atoms are known ; elementary deformations are homogeneous even at the microscopic level .
it is thus a simple task to add up all contributing interactions .
these assumptions zero temperature and homogeneous displacement of the particles constitute the basis of the born - huang theory .
@xcite these assumptions can also be used to estimate the elastic constants of a disordered structure : they provide approximate expressions involving integrals over the pair correlation ; in liquid theory , these expressions correspond to the infinite frequency moduli .
@xcite of course , the two assumptions of zero temperature and homogeneous displacement are not valid in general and corrections to the born - huang approximation are expected to arise from the failure of either .
early studies by squire , holt and hoover , @xcite focused on thermal contributions to elasticity in crystals .
more recently , a surge of interest for athermal materials , like granular materials or foams , attracted some attention to corrections to the born - huang approximation which arise solely from the non - trivial structure of the potential energy landscape .
@xcite namely , in disordered solids at zero temperature , the assumption that particles follow homogeneous ( affine ) displacement fields is incorrect : when a material is strained even by vanishingly small amounts of deformation particles minimize the potential energy of the system by following non - affine displacements .
this idea was recently recognized in numerical simulations of compressed emulsions @xcite and lennard - jones glasses .
@xcite in particular , tanguy _ et al _
@xcite have clearly shown that non - affine corrections to the born - huang approximation hold in the continuum limit and amount to an important fraction of the born - huang term itself .
it is thus essential to understand these corrections well if we ever want to be able to construct approximations to the elastic constants of amorphous materials .
formal expressions for the non - affine ( or `` inhomogeneous '' , in the language of wallace @xcite ) corrections to the born - huang approximation were written early on @xcite .
these formal expressions have been used almost exclusively as a tool to calculate elastic constants in computer simulations , but were given little attention in light of their basic importance .
we believe that this arose from two limitations : ( i ) prior works remained at an essentially technical level , aiming merely to provide tools for numerical simulations ( ii ) the derivations of formal analytical expressions for elastic constants have always relied on simplifying assumptions either dealing with an infinite system or valid at zero stress .
these simplifications make it difficult to ascertain the domain of validity of various formulae or symmetries . in response to these issues , we wish to attack this problem from two opposite angles : provide an even more systematic and general treatment than before , yet relate this formalism to numerical observations similar to tanguy _
et al_. @xcite we thus hope that our treatment could serve , at least , as an introduction to the subject . from the formalism , we wish to extract information about the contribution of various scales to the non - affine corrections to elasticity : the question we have at heart is whether these corrections originate from small or large scales , or involve a broad distribution of scales as suggested by the observation of vortex - like patterns .
@xcite this question is directly related to the existence of a continuous limit for elastic properties of amorphous structures .
@xcite to address these questions , we perform a normal mode decomposition of the non - affine displacement field : it permits quantifying the contribution of every frequency shell to the non - affine corrections to elastic constants . in the large size limit
, these contributions seem to be self - averaging quantities ( in the sense that an ensemble average over subsystems will produce results which are equivalent to a single large system ) . the existence of this self - averaging property leads to an expression for the elastic constants in the continuum limit which resembles the sum rules of liquid theory .
finally , our attention was attracted by several related issues in the recent literature .
studies of sound propagation and attenuation in granular materials @xcite or of the visco - elastic response of dense emulsions and foams , @xcite emphasize the need for a deep theoretical understanding of the visco - elastic response of disordered solids .
related experiments by mckenna and coworkers indicated that features of the visco - elastic response of amorphous materials are related to measurable changes in their elastic constants .
@xcite we thus complement the study of static response by a study of dynamical response , and derive a formal expression for the visco - elastic moduli .
we shall establish that the relaxation spectrum is directly and simply related to a correlator emerging from the normal mode analysis .
the present work is meant to present the general framework of our analysis , which will be the basis of future numerical studies .
although , here , we will use numerical simulations to illustrate analytical developments , the main core of our numerical study will be presented in a dedicated article . |
a frequently used method for edge - preserving image denoising is the variational approach which minimizes the rudin - osher - fatemi ( rof ) functional @xcite . in a discrete ( penalized )
form the rof functional can be written as @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the given corrupted image and @xmath4 denotes the discrete gradient operator which contains usually first order forward differences in vertical and horizontal directions .
the regularizing term @xmath5 can be considered as discrete version of the total variation ( tv ) functional .
since the gradient does not penalize constant areas the minimizer of the rof functional tends to have such regions , an effect known as staircasing .
an approach to avoid this effect consists in the employment of higher order differences / derivatives .
since the pioneering work @xcite which couples the tv term with higher order terms by infimal convolution various techniques with higher order differences / derivatives were proposed in the literature , among them @xcite . in various applications in image processing and computer vision the functions of interest
take values on the circle @xmath0 or another manifold .
processing manifold - valued data has gained a lot of interest in recent years .
examples are wavelet - type multiscale transforms for manifold data @xcite and manifold - valued partial differential equations @xcite .
finally we like to mention statistical issues on riemannian manifolds @xcite and in particular the statistics of circular data @xcite .
the tv notation for functions with values on a manifold has been studied in @xcite using the theory of cartesian currents .
these papers were an extension of the previous work @xcite were the authors focus on @xmath0-valued functions and show in particular the existence of minimizers of certain energies in the space of functions with bounded total cyclic variation .
the first work which applies a cyclic tv approach among other models for imaging tasks was recently published by cremers and strekalovskiy in @xcite .
the authors unwrapped the function values to the real axis and proposed an algorithmic solution to account for the periodicity .
an algorithm which solves tv regularized minimization problems on riemannian manifolds was proposed by lellmann et al . in
they reformulate the problem as a multilabel optimization problem with an infinite number of labels and approximate the resulting hard optimization problem using convex relaxation techniques .
the algorithm was applied for chromaticity - brightness denoising , denoising of rotation data and processing of normal fields for visualization .
another approach to tv minimization for manifold - valued data via cyclic and parallel proximal point algorithms was proposed by one of the authors and his colleagues in @xcite .
it does not require any labeling or relaxation techniques .
the authors apply their algorithm in particular for diffusion tensor imaging and interferometric sar imaging . for cartan - hadamard manifolds convergence of the algorithm
was shown based on a recent result of bak @xcite .
unfortunately , one of the simplest manifolds that is not of cartan - hadamard type is the circle @xmath0 . in this paper
we deal with the incorporation of higher order differences into the energy functionals to improve denoising results for @xmath0-valued data .
note that the ( second - order ) total generalized variation was generalized for tensor fields in @xcite .
however , to the best of our knowledge this is the first paper which defines second order differences of cyclic data and uses them in regularization terms of energy functionals for image restoration .
we focus on a discrete setting .
first we provide a meaningful definition of higher order differences for cyclic data which we call _ absolute cyclic differences_. in particular our absolute cyclic first order differences resemble the geodesic distance ( arc length distance ) on the circle .
as the geodesics the absolute cyclic second order differences take only values in @xmath1 $ ] .
this is not necessary the case for differences of order larger than two .
following the idea in @xcite we suggest a cyclic proximal point algorithm to minimize the resulting functionals .
this algorithm requires the evaluation of certain proximal mappings .
we provide analytical expression for these mappings .
further , we suggest an appropriate choice of the cycles such that the whole algorithm becomes very efficient .
we apply our algorithm to artificial data as well as to real - world interferometric sar data .
the paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : diff ] we propose a definition of differences on @xmath0 .
then , in section [ sec : prox ] , we provide analytical expressions for the proximal mappings required in our cyclic proximal point algorithm .
the approach is based on unwrapping the circle to @xmath6 and considering the corresponding proximal mappings on the euclidean space .
the cyclic proximal point algorithm is presented in section [ sec : cpp ] . in particular
we describe a vectorization strategy which makes the matlab implementation efficient and provides parallelizability , and prove its convergence under certain assumptions .
section [ sec : numerics ] demonstrates the advantageous performance of our algorithm by numerical examples .
finally , conclusions and directions of future work are given in section [ sec : conclusions ] .
let @xmath0 be the unit circle in the plane @xmath7 endowed with the _ geodesic distance _
( arc length distance ) @xmath8 given a base point @xmath9 , the _ exponential map _
@xmath10 from the tangent space @xmath11 of @xmath0 at @xmath12 onto @xmath0 is defined by @xmath13 this map is @xmath14-periodic , i.e. , @xmath15 for any @xmath16 , where @xmath17 denotes the unique point in @xmath18 such that @xmath19 , @xmath20 .
some useful properties of the mapping @xmath21 ( which can also be considered as mapping from @xmath6 onto @xmath22 ) are collected in the following remark .
[ lem : mod_pi ] the following relations hold true : 1 .
@xmath23 for all @xmath24 .
2 . if @xmath25 then @xmath26 for all @xmath27 .
while i ) follows by straightforward computation relation ii ) can be seen as follows : for @xmath28 there exists @xmath29 such that @xmath30 hence it follows @xmath31 and since @xmath32 further @xmath33 to guarantee the injectivity of the exponential map , we restrict its domain of definition from @xmath6 to @xmath18 . thus , for @xmath34 , there is now a unique @xmath35 satisfying @xmath36 .
in particular we have @xmath37 .
given such representation system @xmath38 of @xmath39 , @xmath40 centered at an arbitrary point @xmath12 on @xmath0 the geodesic distance becomes @xmath41 actually we need only @xmath42 in the minimum .
clearly , this definition does not depend on the chosen center point @xmath12 .
we want to determine general finite differences of @xmath0-valued data .
let @xmath43 with @xmath44 where @xmath45 denotes the vector with @xmath46 components one .
we define the _ finite difference operator _ @xmath47 by @xmath48 by , we see that @xmath49 vanishes for constant vectors and is therefore translation invariant , i.e. , @xmath50 [ diff_n ] for the binomial coefficients with alternating signs @xmath51 we obtain the ( forward ) differences of order @xmath46 : @xmath52 note that @xmath53 does not only fulfill , but vanishes exactly for all ` discrete polynomials of order @xmath54 ' , i.e. , for all vectors from @xmath55 . here
we are interested in first and second order differences @xmath56 moreover , we will apply the ` mixed second order ' difference with @xmath57 and use the notation @xmath58 we want to define differences for points @xmath59 using their representation @xmath60 with respect to an arbitrary fixed center point . as the geodesic distance
these differences should be independent of the choice of the center point .
this can be achieved if and only if the differences are shift invariant modulo @xmath14 .
let @xmath61 .
we define the _ absolute cyclic difference _ of @xmath62 ( resp .
@xmath63 ) with respect to @xmath64 by @xmath65_{2 \pi } ; w \big ) \bigr\rvert = \min_{j \in { \mathbb{i}}_d } \bigl\lvert \delta \big ( [ x - ( x_j+\pi ) 1_d]_{2 \pi } ; w \big ) \bigr\rvert,\ ] ] where @xmath66_{2\pi}$ ] denotes the component - by - component application of @xmath67 if @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70_{2\pi } = \pm \pi$ ] , @xmath69 .
the definition allows that points having the same value are treated separately , cf .
figure [ fig : choosing_sides ] .
this ensures that @xmath71 is a continuous map .
for example we have @xmath72 . figures [ fig : def - d ] and [ fig : choosing_sides ] illustrate definition . for the absolute cyclic differences related to the differences in example [ diff_n ] we will use the simpler notation @xmath73 .8 , @xmath74 , on the circle ( blue ) and their inverse exponential maps at @xmath75 , @xmath74 , ( dark blue ) , where @xmath75 denotes the antipodal point of @xmath76 . in other words
, we cut the circle at the point @xmath76 and unwind it with respect to the tangent line at the antipodal point @xmath75 .
the absolute cyclic differences take the three pairwise different positions of the points @xmath77 , @xmath74 to each other into account .
these are shown in with respect to the representation system from the arbitrary point @xmath12 in.,title="fig : " ] .8 , @xmath74 , on the circle ( blue ) and their inverse exponential maps at @xmath75 , @xmath74 , ( dark blue ) , where @xmath75 denotes the antipodal point of @xmath76 .
in other words , we cut the circle at the point @xmath76 and unwind it with respect to the tangent line at the antipodal point @xmath75 .
the absolute cyclic differences take the three pairwise different positions of the points @xmath77 , @xmath74 to each other into account .
these are shown in with respect to the representation system from the arbitrary point @xmath12 in.,title="fig : " ] .8 , @xmath74 , on the circle ( blue ) and their inverse exponential maps at @xmath75 , @xmath74 , ( dark blue ) , where @xmath75 denotes the antipodal point of @xmath76 .
in other words , we cut the circle at the point @xmath76 and unwind it with respect to the tangent line at the antipodal point @xmath75 .
the absolute cyclic differences take the three pairwise different positions of the points @xmath77 , @xmath74 to each other into account .
these are shown in with respect to the representation system from the arbitrary point @xmath12 in.,title="fig : " ] , @xmath74 on the circle , where @xmath78 and @xmath79 , @xmath80 .
though @xmath81 denote the same point on the circle they are treated separately in the definition of the absolute cyclic differences . ]
the following equivalent definition of absolute cyclic differences appears to be useful .
[ cyc_diff_perm ] let @xmath62 be sorted in ascending order as @xmath82 and set @xmath83 .
let @xmath84 denote the corresponding permutation matrix , i.e. , @xmath85 and @xmath86 consider the @xmath14 shifted versions of @xmath87 given by @xmath88 where @xmath89 denotes the @xmath90-th unit vector .
then it holds @xmath91 the first equality in follows directly by definition . to see the second one ,
note that by linearity of the inner product we have @xmath92 for the geodesic distance we obtain by that @xmath93 .
in general the relation @xmath94 does not hold true as the following example shows .
[ conterex ] in general the @xmath46-th order absolute cyclic difference can not be written as @xmath95 consider for example the absolute cyclic third order difference for @xmath96 given by as @xmath97 we obtain @xmath98 so that @xmath99 . for @xmath100 relation holds true by the next lemma .
[ diff_sec ] for @xmath100 the following relation holds true : @xmath101 note that we need only the minimum over @xmath102 in proposition [ diff_sec ] and more precisely @xmath103 , \\
\lvert\delta(x;w ) - 2\pi \sigma\rvert = 2\pi - \lvert\delta(x;w)\rvert & \mbox{if } \ ; \;\lvert\delta(x;w)\rvert \in ( \pi,2 \pi],\\ \lvert\delta(x;w)\rvert - 2\pi & \mbox{if } \lvert\delta(x;w)\rvert \in ( 2\pi,3 \pi],\\ \lvert\delta(x;w ) - 4\pi \sigma\rvert = 4\pi - \lvert\delta(x;w)\rvert&\mbox{if } \ ; \ ; \lvert\delta(x;w)\rvert \in ( 3\pi,4 \pi ) , \end{cases}\ ] ] where @xmath104 and @xmath105 since @xmath106 for @xmath107 , we see that @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
first we consider @xmath110 . by lemma [ cyc_diff_perm ]
we obtain @xmath111 where we can assume by the cyclic shift invariance of @xmath110 that @xmath112 .
if @xmath113 , then the corresponding permutation matrix @xmath84 in lemma [ cyc_diff_perm ] is the identity matrix .
further we obtain that @xmath114 and by we get @xmath115 if @xmath116 , then @xmath117 and @xmath118 $ ] . in this case
we get @xmath119 this proves the first assertion .
for @xmath120 we can again assume that @xmath112 .
exploiting that @xmath121 we have to consider the following three cases : if @xmath122 , then @xmath84 is the identity matrix , @xmath123 and @xmath124 if @xmath125 , then @xmath126 and @xmath127 . by
we have @xmath128 if @xmath129 , then @xmath130 and @xmath131 . here
we obtain @xmath132 this finishes the proof .
for a proper , closed , convex function @xmath133 $ ] and @xmath134 the _ proximal mapping _
@xmath135 is defined by @xmath136 see @xcite .
the above minimizer exits and is uniquely determined .
many algorithms which were recently used in variational image processing reduce to the iterative computation of values of proximal mappings .
an overview of applications of proximal mappings is given in @xcite .
in this section , we are interested in proximal mappings of absolute cyclic differences @xmath137 , i.e. , @xmath138 for @xmath139 . more precisely , we will determine for @xmath140-valued vectors represented by @xmath141 the values @xmath142 for @xmath143 and first and second order absolute cyclic differences @xmath144 , @xmath145 . here
@xmath146 means that we are looking for the representative of @xmath147 in @xmath148 .
in particular , we will see that these proximal mapping are single - valued for @xmath141 with @xmath149 and have two values for @xmath150 .
we start by considering the proximal mappings of the appropriate differences in @xmath151 .
then we use the results to find the proximal functions of the absolute cyclic differences .
first we give analytical expressions for @xmath152 , where @xmath153 and @xmath154 , @xmath155 .
since we could not find a corresponding reference in the literature , the computation of the minimizer of @xmath156 is described in the following lemmas .
we start with @xmath157 .
[ lem : proxy_r ] for given @xmath158 and @xmath159 , @xmath155 set @xmath160 then the minimizer @xmath161 of @xmath162 is given by @xmath163 and the minimum by @xmath164 since @xmath165 , there exists a component @xmath166 and we rewrite @xmath167 substituting @xmath168 , @xmath169 and @xmath170 , @xmath171 we see that @xmath172 , where @xmath173 is the minimizer of @xmath174 the ( fenchel ) dual problem of @xmath175 reads @xmath176 and the relation between the minimizers of the primal and dual problems is given by @xmath177 rewriting we see that @xmath178 is the minimizer of @xmath179 where @xmath180 .
hence we obtain @xmath181 and by further @xmath182 substituting back results in and plugging @xmath161 into @xmath183 we get .
[ ex1 ] let @xmath157 , @xmath184 , and @xmath185 . 1 . for @xmath186 and @xmath187
we get @xmath188 and @xmath189 so that the minimizer of @xmath190 follows by _ soft shrinkage _ of @xmath191 with threshold @xmath192 : @xmath193 2 . for @xmath194 and @xmath195
we obtain @xmath196 and @xmath197 .
consequently , the minimizer of @xmath198 is given by @xmath199 3 .
for @xmath200 and @xmath201 we obtain @xmath202 and @xmath203 , so that the minimizer of @xmath204 is given by @xmath205 we will apply the following corollary .
[ diff_data ] let @xmath159 .
further , let @xmath206 and @xmath207 be given such that @xmath208 .
then @xmath209 set @xmath210 and @xmath211 . by assumption @xmath212 and
according to we have to consider three cases . 1
. let @xmath213 .
then by assumption also @xmath214 and we conclude by that @xmath215 2 .
let @xmath216 and @xmath217
. by this implies @xmath218 since @xmath219 and @xmath217 we obtain @xmath220 .
3 . let @xmath216 and @xmath221 .
by this implies @xmath222 and we are done .
next we consider the case @xmath223 .
[ lem : e_quad ] let @xmath224 . 1 .
then , for @xmath225 and @xmath226 , the minimizer @xmath227 of @xmath228 is given by @xmath229 and the minimum by @xmath230 2 . if @xmath231 for some @xmath232 and @xmath233 , then @xmath234 1 . setting the gradient of to zero results in @xmath235 using the sherman - morrison formula @xcite it follows @xmath236 for the corresponding energy we obtain by straightforward computation @xmath237^{2}\\ & = \frac{\lambda } { 1+\lambda { \left\lvert w \right\rvert_{2}}^{2}}\bigl(\langle f , w \rangle -a\bigr)^{2 } \text{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . follows directly from .
now we turn to @xmath0-valued data represented by @xmath141 .
we are interested in the minimizers of @xmath238 on @xmath239 for @xmath153 and @xmath240 .
we start with the case @xmath157 .
[ lem : proxy_b1 ] for @xmath145 set @xmath241 .
let @xmath157 and @xmath141 , where @xmath242 is adapted to the respective length of @xmath64 . 1 . if @xmath149 , then the unique minimizer of @xmath243 is given by @xmath244 2 .
[ proxy - casepi ] if @xmath150 , then @xmath243 has the two minimizers @xmath245 note that for @xmath246 case [ proxy - casepi ] ) appears exactly if @xmath247 and @xmath248 are antipodal points . by and
lemma [ diff_sec ] we can rewrite @xmath249 in as @xmath250 where @xmath251 . let @xmath252 we are looking for @xmath253^d } e_{k,\sigma}(x),\ ] ] where the last equality can be seen by the following argument : if for some @xmath254 the minimizer @xmath255^d } e_{k,\sigma}(x)$ ] has components @xmath256 for @xmath257 , then we get using @xmath258 , that @xmath259 by lemma [ lem : proxy_r ] the minimizers over @xmath151 of @xmath260 are given by @xmath261 where @xmath262 by corollary [ diff_data ] the minimum of @xmath263 is determined by @xmath264 .
note that @xmath265 for @xmath246 and @xmath266 for @xmath267 .
we distinguish two cases . 1 .
if @xmath268 , @xmath269 then @xmath270 attains its smallest value exactly for @xmath271 and @xmath272 by we obtain @xmath273 with @xmath274 as in .
corollary [ diff_data ] implies that @xmath275^d } e_{k,\sigma } ( x)\qquad \forall \sigma \in { \mathbb{z}}\backslash \{r - \langle k , w \rangle \}.\ ] ] finally , there exists exactly one @xmath276 such that @xmath277 and by we conclude that @xmath278 is the unique minimizer of @xmath243 over @xmath239 .
2 . if @xmath279 , @xmath269 , then @xmath270 attains its smallest value exactly for @xmath280 and by corollary [ diff_data ] the minimum of the corresponding functions @xmath263 is smaller than those of the other functions in .
we obtain @xmath281 and @xmath282 as in part 1 of the proof we conclude that @xmath283 are the minimizers of @xmath243 over @xmath239 .
this finishes the proof .
next we focus on @xmath284 .
[ thm : p2 ] let @xmath223 in , @xmath145 and @xmath141 , where @xmath242 is adapted to the respective length of @xmath64 . 1 .
if @xmath149 , then the unique minimizer of @xmath243 is given by @xmath285 2 .
if @xmath150 , then @xmath243 has the two minimizers @xmath286 the proof follows the lines of the proof of theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ] using lemma [ lem : e_quad ] . finally , we need the proximal mapping @xmath287 for given @xmath288 .
the proximal mapping of the ( squared ) cyclic distance function was also computed ( for more general manifolds ) in @xcite . here
we give an explicit expression for spherical data .
[ theo : prox_quad ] for @xmath289 let @xmath290 then the minimizer(s ) of @xmath291 are given by @xmath292 where @xmath293 is defined by @xmath294 and the minimum is @xmath295 obviously , the minimization of @xmath249 can be done component wise so that we can restrict our attention to @xmath296 . 1
. first we look at the minimization problem over @xmath6 which reads @xmath297 and has the following minimizer and minimum : @xmath298 2 . for the original problem @xmath299
we consider the related energy functionals on @xmath6 , namely @xmath300 by part 1 of the proof these functions have the minimizers @xmath301 and @xmath302 we distinguish three cases : 1 .
if @xmath303 , then the minimum in occurs exactly for @xmath304 and it holds @xmath305 for @xmath306 we see that @xmath307 and @xmath308 2 . if @xmath309 , then has its minimum exactly for @xmath310 and @xmath311 which is in @xmath18 for @xmath306 or @xmath312 and @xmath313 3 . in the case
@xmath314 the minimum in is attained for @xmath315 so that we have both solutions from i ) and ii ) .
this completes the proof .
the proximal point algorithm ( ppa ) on the euclidean space goes back to @xcite . recently
this algorithm was extended to riemannian manifolds of non - positive sectional curvature @xcite and also to hadamard spaces @xcite .
a cyclic version of the proximal point algorithm ( cppa ) on the euclidean space was given in @xcite , see also the survey @xcite .
a cppa for hadamard spaces can be found in @xcite . in the cppa
the original function @xmath316 is split into a sum @xmath317 and , iteratively , the proximal mappings of the functions @xmath318 are applied in a cyclic way .
the great advantage of this method is that often the proximal mappings of the summands @xmath318 are much easier to compute or can even be given in a closed form . in the following
we develop a cppa for functionals of @xmath0-valued signals and images containing absolute cyclic first and second order differences .
first we have a look at the one - dimensional case , i.e. , at signals . for given @xmath0-valued signals represented by @xmath319 , @xmath320 , and regularization parameters @xmath321 , @xmath322
, we are interested in @xmath323 where @xmath324 to apply a cppa we set @xmath325 , split @xmath326 into an even and an odd part @xmath327 and @xmath328 into three sums @xmath329 then the objective function decomposes as @xmath330 we compute in the @xmath331-th cycle of the cppa the signal @xmath332 the different proximal values can be obtained as follows : 1 . by proposition [ theo : prox_quad ] with @xmath333 playing the role of @xmath334 we get @xmath335 2 . for @xmath336 , we obtain the vectors @xmath337 by applying theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ] with @xmath246 independently for the pairs @xmath338 , @xmath339 .
3 . for @xmath340
, we compute @xmath341 by applying theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ] with @xmath342 independently for the vectors @xmath343 , @xmath344 .
the parameter sequence @xmath345 of the algorithm should fulfill @xmath346 this property is also essential for proving the convergence of the cppa for real - valued data and data on a hadamard manifold , see @xcite . in our numerical experiments
we choose @xmath347 with some initial parameter @xmath348 which clearly fulfill .
the whole procedure is summarized in algorithm [ alg : cppa ] .
* input * @xmath349 fulfilling and @xmath350 , @xmath351 or @xmath352 , @xmath353 , @xmath354 data @xmath355 or @xmath356 + initialize @xmath357 , @xmath306 initialize the cycle length as @xmath358 ( 1d ) or @xmath359 ( 2d ) @xmath360 @xmath361 a convergence criterion are reached @xmath362 next we consider two - dimensional data , i.e. , images of the form @xmath363 , @xmath364 . our functional includes _
_ h__orizontal and _ _ v__ertical cyclic first and second order differences @xmath365 and @xmath110 and _ _ d__iagonal ( mixed ) differences @xmath120 .
for non - negative regularization parameters @xmath366 , @xmath367 and @xmath354 not all equal to zero we are looking for @xmath368 where @xmath369 here the objective function splits as @xmath370 with the following summands : again we set @xmath371 and compute the proximal value of @xmath372 by proposition [ theo : prox_quad ] .
each of the sums in @xmath373 and @xmath374 can be split analogously as in the one - dimensional case , where we have to consider row and column vectors now .
this results in @xmath375 functions @xmath376 whose proximal values can be computed by theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ] .
finally , we split @xmath377 . into the four sums @xmath378 and
denote the inner sums by @xmath379 .
clearly , the proximal values of the functions @xmath380 , @xmath381 can be computed separately for the vectors @xmath382 by theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ] with @xmath383 . in summary
, the computation can be done by algorithm [ alg : cppa ] .
note that the presented approach immediately generalizes to arbitrary dimensions .
since @xmath0 is not a hadamard space , the convergence analysis of the cppa in @xcite can not be applied .
we show the convergence of the cppa for the 2d @xmath0-valued function under certain conditions .
the 1d setting in can then be considered as a special case . in the following ,
let @xmath384 .
our first condition is that the data @xmath385 is dense enough , this means that the distance between neighboring pixels @xmath386 is sufficiently small .
similar conditions also appear in the convergence analysis of nonlinear subdivision schemes for manifold - valued data in @xcite . in the context of nonlinear subdivision schemes , even more severe restrictions such as
` almost equally spaced data ' are frequently required @xcite .
this imposes additional conditions on the second order differences to make the data almost lie on a ` line ' .
our analysis requires only bounds on the first , but not on the second order differences .
our next requirement is that the regularization parameters @xmath387 in are sufficiently small . for large parameters any solution tends to become almost constant . in this case , if the data is for example equidistantly distributed on the circle , e.g. , @xmath388 in 1d , any @xmath389 shift is again a solution . in this situation
the model loses its interpretation which is an inherent problem due to the cyclic structure of the data . finally , the parameter sequence @xmath345 of the cppa has to fulfill with a small @xmath390 norm .
the later can be achieved by rescaling .
our convergence analysis is based on a convergence result in @xcite and an unwrapping procedure .
we start by reformulating the convergence result for the cppa of real - valued data , which is a special case of @xcite and can also be derived from @xcite .
[ thm : bacak ] let @xmath391 , where @xmath392 , @xmath393 , are proper , closed , convex functionals on @xmath394 .
let @xmath183 have a global minimizer .
assume that there exists @xmath395 such that the iterates @xmath396 of the cppa ( see algorithm [ alg : cppa ] ) satisfy @xmath397 for all @xmath398 .
then the sequence @xmath399 converges to a minimizer of @xmath183 .
moreover the iterates fulfill @xmath400 + 2 \lambda_k^2 l^2 c(c+1 ) \quad \mbox{for all } \ ; x \in \mathbb r^{n \times m}.\label{noch_1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the next lemma states a discrete analogue of a well - known result on unwrapping or lifting from algebraic topology .
we supply a short proof since we did not found it in the literature .
[ lem : discretecovering ] let @xmath401 with @xmath402 .
for @xmath9 not antipodal to @xmath403 fix an @xmath404 such that @xmath405 . then there exists a unique @xmath406 such that for all @xmath407 the following relations are fulfilled : 1 .
@xmath408 2 .
@xmath409 .
we call @xmath410 the lifted or unwrapped image of @xmath411 ( w.r.t . a fixed @xmath412 ) .
for @xmath413 , @xmath414 , it holds by assumption on @xmath415 that @xmath416 .
hence we have @xmath417 , where with an abuse of notation @xmath413 stands for an arbitrary representative in @xmath418 of @xmath413
. then obviously @xmath419 , @xmath420 are the unique values satisfying i ) and ii ) . for @xmath421 consider @xmath422 by assumption on @xmath415 we see that @xmath423 so that @xmath424 .
thus @xmath425 is the unique value with properties i ) and ii ) .
proceeding this scheme successively , we obtain the whole unique image @xmath426 fulfilling i ) and ii ) . for @xmath427
we define @xmath428 where @xmath429 to measure how ` near ' the images @xmath191 and @xmath411 are to each other .
[ lem : convlem2 ] let @xmath430 with @xmath431 and @xmath9 be not antipodal to @xmath432 .
fix @xmath433 with @xmath434 and let @xmath435 be the corresponding lifting of @xmath191 .
let @xmath436 $ ] . 1
. then every @xmath437 has a unique lifting @xmath410 w.r.t .
to the base point @xmath12 with @xmath438 .
2 . for @xmath439 defined by ,
let @xmath440 denote its analog for real - valued data , i.e. , @xmath441 where the cyclic distances in @xmath442 and in the @xmath443 terms are replaced by absolute differences in @xmath444 and @xmath445 .
then it holds @xmath446 by definition of @xmath447 and assumption on @xmath191 we have for any @xmath437 that @xmath448 and hence @xmath449 .
further it holds @xmath450 .
consequently , every @xmath437 has a unique lifting @xmath410 by lemma [ lem : discretecovering ] w.r.t . to the base point @xmath12 fulfilling @xmath438 . to see we show the equality for the involved summands in @xmath316 and @xmath440 separately .
first we consider @xmath373 . by properties of the lifting in lemma [ lem : discretecovering ] we have @xmath451 and @xmath452 . by the definition of @xmath373 and @xmath453
, this implies @xmath454 .
next we consider @xmath455 .
the corresponding second order differences are given by the expressions @xmath456 and @xmath457 , respectively .
we exemplarily consider the first term .
since @xmath458 the distance between any two members of the triple is smaller than @xmath459 . due to the properties of the lifting @xmath426 this implies @xmath460
. then we conclude by proposition [ diff_sec ] that @xmath461 .
similarly it follows that @xmath462 . concerning the data term @xmath463 we consider @xmath464 and @xmath465 .
by definition of @xmath447 we have @xmath466 and by construction of @xmath435 and @xmath426 that @xmath467 , @xmath468 and @xmath469 .
furthermore it holds @xmath470 . if @xmath471 , then there exists @xmath472 such that @xmath473 which is a contradiction .
thus @xmath474 .
similarly we conclude @xmath475 .
in summary we obtain @xmath476 for all @xmath477 which implies @xmath478 .
this finishes the proof .
[ rem : conv ] the set @xmath447 is a convex subset of @xmath479 which means that for @xmath480 and @xmath481 $ ] we have @xmath482_t \in { \mathcal s}(f,\delta)$ ] . here @xmath482_t$ ] denotes the point reached after time t on the unit speed geodesic starting at @xmath411 in direction of @xmath483 .
recall that a function @xmath484 is convex on @xmath447 if for all @xmath480 and all @xmath485 $ ] the relation @xmath486_t ) \le t\varphi(x ) +
( 1-t ) \varphi(y)$ ] holds true .
let @xmath430 with @xmath431 and @xmath436 $ ] .
then we conclude by lemma [ lem : convlem2 ] , since @xmath440 is convex , that @xmath439 is convex on @xmath487 .
[ lem : convlem1 ] let @xmath488 and @xmath489 .
let @xmath490 such that @xmath491 then any minimizer @xmath492 of @xmath316 in fulfills @xmath493 any minimizer @xmath494 of satisfies @xmath495 as a consequence we obtain @xmath496 [ rem : tildej ] lemma [ lem : convlem1 ] holds also true for real - valued data and @xmath440 in .
now we combine lemma [ lem : convlem1 ] and [ lem : convlem2 ] to locate the minimizers of @xmath316 and @xmath440 .
[ lem : convlem3 ] let @xmath497 with @xmath498 and @xmath499 be given .
choose the parameters @xmath500 of @xmath316 in such that with @xmath501 holds true .
then any minimizer @xmath492 of @xmath316 lies in @xmath487 .
furthermore , if @xmath502 is the unique lifting of @xmath191 w.r.t .
a base point @xmath12 and fixed @xmath503 with @xmath504 , then each minimizer @xmath505 of @xmath506 defines a minimizer @xmath507 of @xmath316 .
conversely , the uniquely defined lifting @xmath508 of a minimizer @xmath492 of @xmath316 is a minimizer of @xmath506 . by lemma [ lem : convlem1 ]
we obtain @xmath509 so that @xmath510 . in order to show the second statement note that the mapping @xmath511 is a bijection from @xmath487 to the set @xmath512 defined by @xmath513.\ ] ] if @xmath505 minimizes @xmath506 , then it lies in @xmath514 which follows by remark [ rem : tildej ] . by and
the minimizing property of @xmath505 we obtain for any @xmath437 that @xmath515 as a consequence , @xmath516 is a minimizer of @xmath316 on @xmath447 . by lemma [ lem : convlem1 ]
all the minimizers of @xmath316 are contained in @xmath447 so that @xmath516 is a minimizer of @xmath316 on @xmath479 .
we proceed with the last statement .
let @xmath492 be a minimizer of @xmath316 with lifting @xmath508 .
then we get for any @xmath517 that @xmath518 this shows that @xmath508 is a minimizer of @xmath506 on @xmath514 .
since by remark [ rem : tildej ] all minimizers of @xmath506 lie in @xmath514 , the last assertion follows .
next we locate the iterates of the cppa for real - valued data on a ball whose radius can be controlled .
[ lem : convlem4 ] for @xmath519 and @xmath520 with property , let @xmath521 be the sequence produced by algorithm [ alg : cppa ] for @xmath506 .
assume that @xmath522 .
let @xmath523 be the minimizer of @xmath506 .
then , for @xmath524 and @xmath525 , it holds @xmath526 where @xmath359 denotes the number of inner iterations and @xmath527 .
the assumption on the distances @xmath528 , @xmath407 , to be smaller than @xmath529 is automatically fulfilled for any unwrapping of @xmath0-valued data . by theorem [ thm : bacak ]
we know that @xmath530 + 2 \lambda_k^2 l^2 c(c+1).\ ] ] as a constant @xmath531 we can choose the maximum of the lipschitz constants of the involved summands . for @xmath453 , @xmath532 and @xmath533 the lipschitz constants are @xmath534 , @xmath535 , and @xmath535 , respectively . for the quadratic data term we have @xmath536 therefore , we can set @xmath537 . plugging in the minimizer @xmath538 into and using @xmath357 yields @xmath539 by theorem [ thm : bacak ] it holds @xmath540 using the triangle inequality we obtain @xmath541 which implies the assertion by and .
now we compare the proximal mappings acting on data with values in @xmath542 and @xmath543 [ lem : convlem5 ] for @xmath544 with @xmath498 , let @xmath316 be defined by with the splitting .
let @xmath502 be the unique lifting of @xmath191 w.r.t .
a base point @xmath12 not antipodal to @xmath432 and fixed @xmath503 with @xmath504 .
further , denote by @xmath440 the functional corresponding to @xmath316 . then , for any @xmath545 , @xmath546 $ ] and its lifting @xmath426 w.r.t .
@xmath12 , we have @xmath547 i.e. , the canonical projection @xmath548 commutes with the proximal mappings .
the function @xmath549 is based on the distance to the data @xmath191 .
since @xmath545 , we have @xmath550 for all @xmath407 .
the components of the proximal mapping @xmath551 are given by proposition [ theo : prox_quad ] from which we conclude for @xmath552 the proximal mappings of @xmath318 , @xmath553 , are given via proximal mappings of the first and second order cyclic differences .
we consider the first order difference @xmath554 . by the triangle inequality
, we have @xmath555 as well as @xmath556 . by the explicit form of the proximal mapping in theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ]
we obtain for @xmath318 , @xmath557 .
next we consider the horizontal and vertical second order differences @xmath456 and @xmath457 .
we have that @xmath558 , @xmath559 as well as @xmath560 .
hence all contributing values of @xmath411 lie on a quarter of the circle . applying the proximal mapping in theorem [ lem : proxy_b1 ] the resulting data lie on one half of the circle .
an analogous statement holds true for the horizontal part .
hence the proximal mappings of the ordinary second differences agree with the cyclic version ( under identification via @xmath548 ) .
this implies for @xmath318 , @xmath561 .
finally , we consider the mixed second order differences @xmath562 .
as above , we have for neighboring data items that the distance is smaller than @xmath563 . for all four contributing values of @xmath411
we have that the pairwise distance is smaller by @xmath459 .
thus again they lie on a quarter of the circle .
hence , the proximal mapping for the ordinary mixed second differences agree with the cyclic version ( under identification via @xmath548 ) .
this implies for @xmath318 , @xmath381 .
we note that lemma [ lem : convlem5 ] does not guarantee that @xmath564 remains in @xmath565 .
therefore it does not allow for an iterated application . in the following main theorem
we combine the preceding lemmas to establish this property .
[ thm : convergence ] let @xmath544 with @xmath566 .
let @xmath520 fulfill property and @xmath567 for some @xmath490 , where @xmath568 and @xmath527 .
further , assume that the parameters @xmath500 of the functional @xmath316 in and @xmath501 satisfy .
then the sequence @xmath399 generated by the cppa in algorithm [ alg : cppa ] converges to a global minimizer of @xmath316 .
let @xmath502 be the lifting of of @xmath191 with respect to a base point @xmath12 not antipodal to @xmath432 and fixed @xmath433 with @xmath504 .
further , let @xmath440 denote the real analog of @xmath316 . by lemma [ lem : convlem2 ] we have @xmath569 and @xmath570 for @xmath571 such that is also fulfilled for
the real - valued setting
. then we can apply remark [ lem : convlem1 ] and conclude that the minimizer @xmath505 of @xmath506 fulfills @xmath572 . by
we obtain @xmath573 by lemma [ lem : convlem4 ] the iterates @xmath574 of the real - valued cppa fulfill @xmath575 hence @xmath576 which means that all iterates @xmath574 stay within @xmath577 .
next , we consider the sequence @xmath578 of the cppa for the @xmath0-valued data @xmath191 .
we use induction to verify @xmath579 . by definition
we have @xmath580 .
assume that @xmath581 .
by bijectivity of the lifting , cf .
lemma [ lem : convlem2 ] , and since @xmath582 , we conclude @xmath583 . by lemma [ lem : convlem5 ]
we obtain @xmath584 by the same argument as above we have again @xmath585 .
finally , we know by theorem [ thm : bacak ] that @xmath586 and by lemma [ lem : convlem3 ] that @xmath587 is a global minimizer of @xmath316 .
this completes the proof .
for the numerical computations of the following examples , the algorithms presented in section [ sec : cpp ] were implemented in matlab .
the computations were performed on a macbook pro with an intel core i5 , 2.6ghz and 8 gb of ram using matlab 2013 , version 2013a ( 8.1.0.604 ) on mac os 10.9.2 .
.48 ( dashed red ) and disturbed signal by wrapped gaussian noise @xmath588 ( solid black ) .
reconstructed signals @xmath589 using only the @xmath590 regularizer ( @xmath591 ) , only the @xmath592 regularizer ( @xmath593 ) , and both of them ( @xmath594 , @xmath595 ) . while suffers from the staircasing effect , shows weak results at constant areas .
the combination of both regularizers in yields the best image.,title="fig : " ] .48 ( dashed red ) and disturbed signal by wrapped gaussian noise @xmath588 ( solid black ) .
reconstructed signals @xmath589 using only the @xmath590 regularizer ( @xmath591 ) , only the @xmath592 regularizer ( @xmath593 ) , and both of them ( @xmath594 , @xmath595 ) .
while suffers from the staircasing effect , shows weak results at constant areas . the combination of both regularizers in yields the best image.,title="fig : " ] .48 ( dashed red ) and disturbed signal by wrapped gaussian noise @xmath588 ( solid black ) .
reconstructed signals @xmath589 using only the @xmath590 regularizer ( @xmath591 ) , only the @xmath592 regularizer ( @xmath593 ) , and both of them ( @xmath594 , @xmath595 ) . while suffers from the staircasing effect , shows weak results at constant areas . the combination of both regularizers in yields the best image.,title="fig : " ]
.48 ( dashed red ) and disturbed signal by wrapped gaussian noise @xmath588 ( solid black ) .
reconstructed signals @xmath589 using only the @xmath590 regularizer ( @xmath591 ) , only the @xmath592 regularizer ( @xmath593 ) , and both of them ( @xmath594 , @xmath595 ) .
while suffers from the staircasing effect , shows weak results at constant areas . the combination of both regularizers in yields the best image.,title="fig : " ] the first example of an artificial one - dimensional signal demonstrates the effect of different models containing absolute cyclic first order differences , second order differences or both combined .
the function @xmath596 \to [ -\pi,\pi)$ ] given by @xmath597 is sampled equidistantly to obtain the original signal @xmath598 at @xmath599 samples .
this function is distorted by wrapped gaussian noise @xmath600 of standard deviation @xmath601 to get @xmath602 , see also remark [ lem : mod_pi ] .
the functions @xmath603 and @xmath588 are depicted in figure [ subfig : noisy ] .
note the following effects due to the cyclic data representation on @xmath18 : the linear increase on @xmath604 $ ] of @xmath191 is continuous and the change from @xmath529 to @xmath605 at @xmath606 is just due to the chosen representation system .
similarly the two constant parts with the values @xmath605 and @xmath607 differ only by a jump size of @xmath608 .
for the noise around these two areas , we have the same situation .
we apply algorithm [ alg : cppa ] with different model parameters @xmath350 and @xmath351 to @xmath588 which yields the restored signals @xmath589 .
the restoration error is measured by the ` cyclic ' mean squared error ( cmse ) with respect to the arc length distance @xmath609 we use @xmath610 and @xmath611 iterations as stopping criterion . for any choice of parameters
@xmath612 the computation time is about @xmath613 seconds .
the result @xmath589 in figure [ subfig : tv ] is obtained using only the @xmath590 regularization ( @xmath614 ) .
the restoration of constant areas is favored by this regularization term , but linear , quadratic and exponential parts suffer from the well - known ` staircasing ' effect . utilizing only the @xmath592 regularization ( @xmath615 ) , cf .
figure [ subfig : tv2 ] , the restored function becomes worse in flat areas , but shows a better quality in the linear parts . by combining the regularization terms ( @xmath616 , @xmath617 )
as illustrated in figure [ subfig : tv12 ] both the linear and the constant parts are reconstructed quite well and the cmse is smaller than for the other choices of parameters .
note that @xmath350 and @xmath351 were chosen in @xmath618 with respect to an optimal cmse .
the complex - valued synthetic aperture radar ( sar ) data is obtained emitting specific radar signals at equidistant points and measuring the amplitude and phase of their reflections by the earth s surface .
the amplitude provides information about the reflectivity of the surface .
the phase encodes both the change of the elevation of the surface s elements within the measured area and their reflection properties and is therefore rather arbitrary . when taking two sar images of the target area at the same time but from different angles or locations .
the phase difference of these images encodes the elevation , but it is restricted to one wavelength and also includes noise .
the result is the so called interferometric synthetic aperture radar ( insar ) data and consists of the ` wrapped phase ' or the ` principal phase ' , a value in @xmath18 representing the surface elevation . for more details
see , e.g. , @xcite . after a suitable preregistration
the same approach can be applied to two images from the same area taken at different points in time to measure surface displacements , e.g. , before and after an earthquake or the movement of glaciers .
the main challenge in order to unwrap the phase is the presence of noise .
ideally , if the surface would be smooth enough and no noise would be present , unwrapping is uniquely determined , i.e. , differences between two pixels larger than @xmath529 are regarded as a wrapping result and hence become unwrapped .
there are several algorithms to unwrap , even combining the denoising and the unwrapping , see for example @xcite . for denoising , deledalle et al .
@xcite use both sar images and apply a non - local means algorithm jointly to their reflection , the interferometric phase and the coherence .
.48 using only the @xmath373 regularizer ( @xmath619 ) , only the @xmath620 regularizer ( @xmath621 , @xmath622 ) , and both of them ( @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath625 ) . ,
title="fig : " ] .48 using only the @xmath373 regularizer ( @xmath619 ) , only the @xmath620 regularizer ( @xmath621 , @xmath622 ) , and both of them ( @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath625 ) . , title="fig : " ] .48 using only the @xmath373 regularizer ( @xmath619 ) , only the @xmath620 regularizer ( @xmath621 , @xmath622 ) , and both of them ( @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath625 ) .
, title="fig : " ] .48 using only the @xmath373 regularizer ( @xmath619 ) , only the @xmath620 regularizer ( @xmath621 , @xmath622 ) , and both of them ( @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath625 ) . , title="fig : " ] .48 using only the @xmath373 regularizer ( @xmath619 ) , only the @xmath620 regularizer ( @xmath621 , @xmath622 ) , and both of them ( @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath625 ) . , title="fig : " ] .48 using only the @xmath373 regularizer ( @xmath619 ) , only the @xmath620 regularizer ( @xmath621 , @xmath622 ) , and both of them ( @xmath623 , @xmath624 , @xmath625 ) .
, title="fig : " ] [ [ application - to - synthetic - data . ] ] application to synthetic data .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in order to get a better understanding in the two - dimensional case , let us first take a look at a synthetic surface given on @xmath626 ^ 2 $ ] with the profile shown in figure [ subfig:2dorig ] .
this surface consists of two plates of height @xmath627 divided at the diagonal , a set of stairs in the upper left corner in direction @xmath628 , a linear increasing area connecting both plateaus having the shape of an ellipse with major axis at the angle @xmath629 , and a half ellipsoid forming a dent in the lower right of the image with circular diameter of size @xmath630 and depth @xmath631 .
the initial data is given by sampling the described surface at @xmath632 sampling points .
the usual insar measurement would ideally result in data as given in figure [ subfig:2dwrapped ] , i.e. , the data is wrapped with respect to @xmath14 . in the figure
the resulting ideal phase is represented using the hue component of the hsv color space .
again , the data is perturbed by wrapped gaussian noise , standard deviation @xmath633 , see figure [ subfig:2dnoisy ] . for an application of algorithm [ alg : cppa ] to the minimization problem , we have to fix five parameters @xmath634 which were chosen on @xmath635 such that they minimize the cmse .
using only the cyclic first order differences with @xmath636 , see figure [ subfig:2dtv1 ] , the reconstructed image @xmath637 reproduces the piecewise constant parts of the stairs in the upper left part and the background , but introduces a staircasing in both linear increasing areas inside the ellipse and in the half ellipsoid .
this is highlighted in the three magnifications in figure [ subfig:2dtv1 ] .
applying only cyclic second order differences with @xmath638 manages to reconstruct the linear increasing part and the circular structure of the ellipsoid , but compared to the first case it even increases the cmse due to the approximation of the stairs and the background , see especially the magnification of the stairs in figure [ subfig:2dtv2 ] . combining first and second order cyclic differences by setting @xmath639 and @xmath640 , @xmath625 ,
these disadvantages can be reduced , cf .
figure [ subfig:2dtv12 ] .
note especially the three magnified regions and the cmse . .48 , @xmath641 and @xmath642).,title="fig : " ] .48 , @xmath641 and @xmath642).,title="fig : " ] [ [ application - to - real - world - data . ] ] application to real - world data .
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + next we examine a real - world example .
the data from @xcite is a set of insar data recorded in 1991 by the ers-1 satellite capturing topographical information from the mount vesuvius .
the data is available online and a part of it was also used as an example in @xcite for tv based denoising of manifold - valued data . in figure
[ fig : vesuvius ] the phase is represented by the hue component of the hsv color space .
we apply algorithm [ alg : cppa ] to the image of size @xmath643 , cf .
figure [ subfig : vesuv - orig ] , with @xmath644 and @xmath645 .
this reduces the noise while keeping all significant plateaus , ascents and descents , cf .
figure [ subfig : vesuv - denoised ] .
the left zoom illustrates how the plateau in the bottom left of the data is smoothened but kept in its main elevation shown in blue . in the zoom on the right
all major parts except the noise are kept .
we notice just a little smoothening due to the linearization introduced by @xmath646 . in the bottom left of this detail
some of the fringes are eliminated , and a small plateau is build instead , shown in cyan .
the computation time for the whole image using @xmath647 iterations as stopping criterion was 86.6 sec and 11.1 sec for each of the details of size @xmath648 .
in this paper we considered functionals having regularizers with second order absolute cyclic differences for @xmath0-valued data .
their definition required a proper notion of higher order differences of cyclic data generalizing the corresponding concept in euclidian spaces .
we derived a cppa for the minimization of our functionals and gave the explicit expressions for the appearing proximal mappings .
we proved convergence of the cppa under certain conditions . to the best of our knowledge
this is the first algorithm dealing with higher order tv - type minimization for @xmath0-valued data .
we demonstrated the denoising capabilities of our model on synthetic as well as on real - world data .
future work includes the application of our higher order methods for cyclic data to other imaging tasks such as segmentation , inpainting or deblurring . for deblurring
, the usually underlying linear convolution kernel has to be replaced by a nonlinear construction based on intrinsic ( also called karcher ) means .
this leads to the task of solving the new associated inverse problem .
further , we intend to investigate other couplings of first and second order derivatives similar to infimal convolutions or gtv for euclidean data .
finally , we want to set up higher order tv - like methods for more general manifolds , e.g. higher dimensional spheres . here
, we do not believe that it is possible to derive explicit expressions for the involved proximal mappings at least not for riemannian manifolds of nonzero sectional curvature .
instead , we plan to resort to iterative techniques .
d. p. bertsekas .
incremental gradient , subgradient , and proximal methods for convex optimization : a survey .
technical report lids - p-2848 , laboratory for information and decision systems , mit , cambridge , ma , 2010 .
p. grohs , h. hardering , and o. sander .
optimal a priori discretization error bounds for geodesic finite elements . technical report 2013 - 16 , seminar for applied mathematics , eth zrich , switzerland , 2013 . | in many image and signal processing applications , as interferometric synthetic aperture radar ( sar ) or color image restoration in hsv or lch spaces the data has its range on the one - dimensional sphere @xmath0 .
although the minimization of total variation ( tv ) regularized functionals is among the most popular methods for edge - preserving image restoration such methods were only very recently applied to cyclic structures . however , as for euclidean data , tv regularized variational methods suffer from the so called staircasing effect .
this effect can be avoided by involving higher order derivatives into the functional .
this is the first paper which uses higher order differences of cyclic data in regularization terms of energy functionals for image restoration .
we introduce absolute higher order differences for @xmath0-valued data in a sound way which is independent of the chosen representation system on the circle .
our absolute cyclic first order difference is just the geodesic distance between points .
similar to the geodesic distances the absolute cyclic second order differences have only values in @xmath1 $ ] .
we update the cyclic variational tv approach by our new cyclic second order differences . to minimize the corresponding functional
we apply a cyclic proximal point method which was recently successfully proposed for hadamard manifolds . choosing appropriate cycles
this algorithm can be implemented in an efficient way .
the main steps require the evaluation of proximal mappings of our cyclic differences for which we provide analytical expressions . under certain conditions
we prove the convergence of our algorithm .
various numerical examples with artificial as well as real - world data demonstrate the advantageous performance of our algorithm . |
due to the growing demand in data traffic , large improvements in the spectral efficiency are required @xcite .
network densification has been identified as a possible way to achieve the desired spectral efficiency gains @xcite .
this approach consists of deploying a large number of low powered base stations ( bss ) known as small cells . with the addition of small cell bss ,
the overall system is known as a heterogeneous cellular network ( hetnet ) .
co - channel deployment of small cell bss results in high intercell interference if their operation is not coordinated @xcite .
interference coordination techniques such as intercell interference coordination ( icic ) has been extensively studied for multi - tier hetnet scenarios @xcite .
icic relies on orthogonalizing time and frequency resources allocated to the macrocell and the small cell users .
orthogonalization in time is achieved by switching off the relevant subframes belonging to the macrocell thereby reducing inter - tier interference to the small cell bss @xcite .
orthogonalization in frequency can be achieved with fractional frequency reuse where the users in the inner part of the cells are scheduled on the same frequency resources in contrast to the users at the cell edge whom are scheduled on available orthogonal resources . distributed and
joint power control strategies for dominant interference supression in hetnets is discussed in @xcite .
the performance of multiple antenna ( i.e. , mimo ) hetnets using the above mentioned techniques is analyzed in @xcite and @xcite .
the effects of random orthogonal beamforming with maximum rate scheduling for mimo hetnets is studied in @xcite .
the effects of imperfect channel state information ( csi ) with limited feedback mimo is investigated in @xcite for a two - tier hetnet .
in addition to orthogonalization , interference coordination can also be achieved by means of transmit beamforming at the bss
. however , there seems to be limited literature on transmit beamforming techniques to coordinate interference in hetnets @xcite .
transmit beamforming techniques have been well explored in the multiuser ( mu ) mimo literature to mitigate or reduce the effects of intracell interference @xcite .
performance superiority at low signal - to - noise - ratio ( snr ) of the leakage based beamforming technique compared to zero - forcing beamforming ( zfbf ) is shown in @xcite .
with zfbf , complete mu intracell interference cancellation takes place if perfect csi is present at the bs and the number of transmit antennas exceeds the total number of receive antennas . however , leakage based beamforming focuses on maximizing the desired signal - to - leakage - noise - ratio ( slnr ) without any restrictions on the number of transmit antennas .
the focus of this paper is on the performance gains of a two - tier hetnet with active interference coordination .
intracell and intercell interference is coordinated by deploying leakage based beamformers at the macrocell and microcell bss .
we summarize the contributions of this paper as follows : * we evaluate the performance gains of full coordination and macro - only coordination techniques relative to no coordination for two - tier hetnets .
the impact of imperfect csi on the performance of these coordination techniques is also investigated .
* we demonstrate the effect of network densification with varying degrees of bs coordination on the mean per - user signal - to - interference - plus - noise - ratio ( sinr ) and compare the simulated mean per - user sinr results with the analytical approximations over a wide range of snr . the mean per - user sinr decreases with an increasing microcell count .
however , we show that coordination substantially reduces the rate of sinr decrease . *
we show that in the absence of coordination , network densification does not provide any gain in the sum rate , whereas with coordination , a linear increase in the sum rate is observed . _
notation : _ we use the symbols @xmath0 and @xmath1 to denote a matrix and a vector , respectively .
@xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , denote the conjugate transpose , the inverse and the trace of the matrix @xmath0 , respectively . @xmath5 and @xmath6 stand for the vector and scalar norms , respectively .
@xmath7 $ ] denotes the statistical expectation .
in the macrocell coverage area . ] we consider downlink transmission in a two - tier hetnet comprising of a single macrocell bs and multiple microcell bss , as shown in fig .
we consider a typical scenario where the mobile users in the coverage area of a particular cell are served by the corresponding bs .
we assume that lossless and delayless backhaul links are present between each bs to exchange csi , if desired .
we denote the total number of cells ( including the macrocell and all microcells ) as @xmath8 .
we denote the number of transmit antennas on bs @xmath9 as @xmath10 and the total number of single antenna users in cell @xmath9 as @xmath11 .
the received signal at mobile user @xmath12 in cell @xmath9 is given by [ rs ] & y_n , k = + & _ + _ + _ + _ . here
, @xmath13 denotes the @xmath14 complex gaussian independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) channel vector from the bs @xmath9 to user @xmath12 .
that is , @xmath15 , where @xmath16 denotes the received power from bs @xmath9 to user @xmath12 .
@xmath17 is the @xmath18 normalized beamforming vector from bs @xmath9 to user @xmath12 .
@xmath19 is the desired transmitted data symbol by bs @xmath9 to user @xmath12 .
the transmitted data symbols are normalized such that @xmath20=1 $ ] .
@xmath21 denotes the @xmath22 complex gaussian i.i.d .
intercell interfering channel vector from bs @xmath23 to user @xmath12 located in cell @xmath9 .
that is , @xmath24 . and @xmath25 are used to denote the desired and intercell interfering channels , respectively , regardless of the originating bs type ; i.e. , @xmath25 can represent the intercell interfering link from the macrocell bs for a particular user placed in a microcell.]@xmath26 from @xmath21 to simplify the notation .
] @xmath27 is the additive white gaussian noise at receiver @xmath12 having an independent complex gaussian distribution with variance @xmath28 .
finally , @xmath16 is defined as @xmath29here , @xmath30 refers to the total effective radiated transmit power ( erp ) from bs @xmath9 .
naturally , the erp of the macrocell bs is higher than the microcell bss .
@xmath31 is a reference distance of @xmath32 meter ( m ) for far field transmit antennas , @xmath33 is the distance to mobile user @xmath12 from the bs @xmath9 , @xmath34 is the pathloss exponent for urban macro ( uma ) or urban micro ( umi ) depending on the transmitting bs and @xmath35 is the correlated shadow fading value with a standard deviation @xmath36 , obtained from the gudmundson model @xcite with a decorrelation distance of @xmath37 m. snr with respect to bs @xmath9 and user @xmath12 is defined as @xmath38 , where @xmath28 is the receiver noise variance at user @xmath12 . from ( [ rs ] ) ,
the sinr at user @xmath12 being served by bs @xmath9 can be expressed as @xmath39 the leakage based technique to generate beamforming vectors is as described in @xcite , where the main idea is to maximize the desired signal power relative to the noise and total interference powers caused to other users ( leakage power ) .
the slnr for user @xmath12 served by the bs @xmath9 is defined as @xmath40 for single - stream transmission ( where each user is equipped with a single receive antenna ) , the leakage based beamforming vector desired for user @xmath12 being served by bs @xmath9 is given by the normalized version of the @xmath41 such that @xmath42 .
the structure of ( [ slnr - bf ] ) remains unchanged regardless of the coordination strategy .
however , the composition of @xmath43 depends on the coordination strategy considered , as described in section iii . for the simple case of no coordination @xmath44\ ] ] is the concatenated channel of all users being served by bs @xmath9 apart from user @xmath12 . assuming the distribution of intracell and intercell interference terms in ( [ sinr ] ) is identical to the distribution of noise
, the mean sum rate for cell @xmath9 can be expressed as @xmath45=\mathbb{e}\bigg[\sum\limits_{k=1}^{k_{n}}\log_{2}(1+\gamma_{n , k})\bigg].\ ] ] the mean sum rate over @xmath8 cells can then be expressed as @xmath46=\mathbb{e}\bigg[\sum\limits_{\substack{j=1}}^{n}\sum\limits_{k=1}^{k_{j}}\log_{2}(1+\gamma_{j , k})\bigg].\ ] ] from ( [ sinr ] ) , the mean per - user sinr can be expressed as @xmath47 $ ]
. exact evaluation of @xmath47 $ ] is extremely cumbersome .
instead , we consider an approximation motivated by the work in @xcite , which allows us to express the mean per - user sinr as [ msinr ] & [ _ n , k ] + & . the statistical expectations in both the numerator and the denominator of ( [ msinr ] )
can be evaluated further .
an approach to derive the closed - form approximation of ( [ msinr ] ) is presented in the appendix . on the other hand , ( [ msinr ] )
can be rewritten in its equivalent trace form as [ msinr2 ] & [ _ n , k ] + & , where @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the expression in ( [ msinr2 ] )
is used to approximate the mean per - cell sum rate over a wide range of snr and the mean per - user sinr over a large number of channel realizations as specified in section iv .
it is idealistic to assume perfect csi at all times to generate the leakage based beamforming vectors .
thus , we consider channel imperfections via channel estimation errors as mentioned in @xcite .
the imperfect channel at bs @xmath9 of user @xmath12 after introducing channel estimation errors is given by @xmath50 here , @xmath51 controls the level of csi imperfection .
@xmath52 results in perfect csi and @xmath53 models complete uncertainty .
@xmath54 is a @xmath14 complex gaussian error vector with a statistically identical structure to @xmath13 .
it is shown in @xcite that @xmath55 can be used to determine the impact of several factors on imperfect csi and can be a function of the length of the estimation pilot sequence , doppler frequency and snr .
the concatenated channel and the leakage based beamforming vector for user @xmath12 in cell @xmath9 can be expressed as ( [ slnr - bf ] ) and ( [ concchannel ] ) when replacing @xmath43 with @xmath56 and @xmath13 with @xmath57 , respectively .
the sinr with imperfect csi can be expressed as in ( [ sinr ] ) when replacing @xmath17 with @xmath58 , @xmath59 with @xmath60 and @xmath61 with @xmath62 , respectively . as the leakage based beamforming vectors
are designed with imperfect csi , the sinr expressed in ( [ sinr ] ) will contain channel estimation errors .
[ tab : tab1 ] in this section , we describe the bs coordination strategies considered .
* _ no coordination _ in this case , each bs coordinates the desired and intracell interfering links locally .
that is , the bss only consider maximizing the slnr of users belonging to its own coverage area .
the concatenated channel used to compute the leakage based beamforming vector weights for user @xmath12 in cell @xmath9 is given in ( [ concchannel ] ) .
we treat this strategy as the baseline case . *
_ full coordination _ in this case , we assume that each bs has knowledge of its own users desired channels and all intracell and intercell interfering channels
. the channel information may be exchanged by exploiting the intercell orthogonal reference signals via the backhaul interface @xcite . with the use of the fully acquired csi for each desired and interfering link ,
downlink leakage based beamformers can be designed to minimize the leakage power within the cell as well as to the other cells .
the concatenated channel used to compute the leakage based beamforming vector weights for user @xmath12 in cell @xmath9 can be expressed as + [ fcconc ] _
n , k=[_n,1, ,_n , k-1,_n , k+1,
,_n , k_n , + _ n,1, ,_n , n ] .
+ here @xmath63 denotes the concatenated intercell interfering channels transmitted from bs @xmath9 to all users in cell @xmath64 , given by + [ iciconc ] _
n , m=[_m,1,_m,2,_m,3
,_m , k_m ] . * _ macro - only coordination _ in this case , we assume that the macrocell bs has knowledge of the intercell interfering channels from itself to all microcell users .
the macrocell bs uses this information to coordinate transmission to its own users , as well as to the users located in each microcell , respectively .
the concatenated channel used to compute the leakage based beamforming weight vectors for user @xmath12 in cell @xmath9 can be expressed as ( [ fcconc ] ) and ( [ concchannel ] ) if @xmath9 is the macrocell and microcell bs , respectively . * _ no inter - tier interference _
this is an ideal case , where we assume that no cross - tier interference exists .
this means that users in a particular tier only experience intra - tier interference .
coordination is however present within each cell regardless of the tier . in computing the leakage based beamforming weight vector for user @xmath12 in cell @xmath9
, the concatenated channel will be given by ( [ concchannel ] ) if bs @xmath9 is the macrocell bs .
otherwise , for a microcell bs it is given as + [ niticonc ] _
n , k=[_n,1, ,_n , k-1,_n , k+1,
,_n , k_n , + _ n,1, ,_n , n-1 ] , + where @xmath65 refer to microcell bs indices .
table [ tab : tab1 ] summarizes the different bs coordination strategies with the respective structures for @xmath43 .
we consider a two - tier hetnet system comprising of a single macrocell and two microcells ( unless otherwise stated ) .
we carry out monte - carlo simulations to evaluate the system performance over @xmath66 channel realizations .
the location of the macrocell bs was fixed at the origin of the circular coverage area with radius @xmath67 .
the locations of the microcell bss inside the macrocell coverage area were uniformly generated subject to a spacing constraint .
the minimum distance between two microcells was fixed to twice the radius of the microcell , i.e. , @xmath68 , such that there is no overlap between successive microcells . in table
[ tab : tab2 ] , we specify the remainder of the simulation parameters and their corresponding values . .simulation parameters and values [ cols="^,^ " , ] [ tab : tab2 ] from ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr [ db ] for perfect and imperfect csi where @xmath69 .
the squares denote the approximated mean per - cell sum rates computed with ( [ msinr2 ] ) . ] from ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr [ db ] for perfect and imperfect csi where @xmath69 .
the squares denote the approximated mean per - cell sum rates computed with ( [ msinr2 ] ) . ] from ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr [ db ] for perfect and imperfect csi where @xmath69 .
the squares denote the approximated mean per - cell sum rates computed with ( [ msinr2 ] ) . ] from ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr [ db ] for perfect and imperfect csi where @xmath69 .
the squares denote the approximated mean per - cell sum rates computed with ( [ msinr2 ] ) . ]
performance vs. number of microcells at snr=10 db with perfect csi for full , no and macro only coordination strategies .
the approximated mean per - user sinrs are computed with ( [ msinr2 ] ) . ] performance from ( [ sr2 ] ) vs. number of microcells at snr=10 db with perfect csi for full , no and macro only coordination strategies . ] per macrocell from ( [ sr2 ] ) vs. number of microcells at snr=10 db with perfect csi for full , no and macro only coordination strategies . ]
[ nc ] shows the mean per - cell sum rate performance given by ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr with no coordination in the hetnet .
we consider perfect and imperfect csi at the bss . in the high snr regime
, inter - tier interference causes the mean sum rates to saturate for macrocell and microcells , respectively .
the dominant factor contributing to the poor mean sum rate performance of microcell users is the large inter - tier interference from the macro bs resulting from its high transmit power .
this behaviour is a result of the uncoordinated nature of the hetnet . with imperfect csi
, we again consider the mean sum rate performance with @xmath69 , where further degradation in the macrocell and microcell rates can be observed . the approximated mean per -
cell sum rates based on ( [ msinr2 ] ) are shown to closely match the simulated responses .
the variation between the simulated and analytical sinr responses can be justified from the fact that the approximation in ( [ msinr2 ] ) becomes less tight with increasing snr .
the uncoordinated network performance can be compared to the case where the hetnet is fully coordinated .
[ fc ] demonstrates the mean per - cell sum rate performance given by ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr for perfect and imperfect csi .
two major trends can be observed from the result .
first is the near @xmath70 increase in the microcell rates over the entire snr range relative to the baseline case ( fig .
secondly , microcell to microcell interference has a marginal impact on the macrocell user rates due to their low transmit powers .
this is demonstrated by comparing fig .
[ fc ] to fig .
[ nc ] .
as the macrocell bs is the dominant source of interference to the microcell users , we consider the case where coordination takes place at the macrocell bs only .
[ moc ] demonstrates the mean per - cell sum rate given by ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr performance of the macro only coordination strategy .
both the macro and microcell rates are found to be approximately equivalent to the full coordination case , observed by comparing fig .
[ fc ] and fig .
this suggests that if we can coordinate the transmission to minimize the most dominant source of interference , we are able to achieve near full coordination performance . moreover , this strategy significantly reduces the backhaul overheads by eliminating the need to equip the microcell bss with out - of - cell csi .
[ niti ] depicts the mean per - cell sum rate performance given by ( [ sr1 ] ) vs. macrocell snr of the no inter - tier interference coordination strategy .
due to zero cross - tier interference , this strategy results in superior mean per - cell sum rate performance in comparison with the other coordination strategies .
it is worth comparing fig .
[ niti ] to fig .
[ fc ] , and noting that the mean sum rate performance of full coordination approaches the performance of no inter - tier interference .
this demonstrates the value of bs coordination in a hetnet . the effect of increasing the microcell density is shown in fig .
[ mpusinr ] , where we plot the mean per - user sinr as a function of the number of microcells .
we observe that the mean per - user sinr decreases linearly with increasing number of microcells .
when the number of microcells is less than 5 , there is a marginal difference between macro only coordination and full coordination mean per - user sinr .
this suggests that at low microcell density , it is advantageous to avoid paying the high price of backhaul overheads for full coordination performance .
when there are more than 5 microcells , the gap between full coordination and macro - only coordination techniques starts to increase . approximately , a @xmath71 db difference in the mean per - user sinr is seen with @xmath37 microcells in the system .
the difference in the slopes of the various strategies demonstrates the impact of bs coordination in a hetnet with network densification .
thus , coordination arrests the rate of decay of the mean per - user sinr in a hetnet .
in addition to the above , the result demonstrates the validity of the approximated mean per - user sinr in ( [ msinr2 ] ) .
these are shown to closely match the simulated mean per - user sinr performance for all the coordination techniques .
[ mrp ] shows the microcell sum rate performance as defined in ( [ sr2 ] ) at the mean , @xmath37th and @xmath72th percentiles with respect to number of microcells at a snr of @xmath37 db . with full coordination ,
the microcell sum rate increases linearly with the number of microcells , as majority of the interference is being suppressed by the leakage based beamformers .
a similar trend can be observed for the macro only coordination case , however the microcell sum rate performance gains are lower compared to the full coordination case as the number of microcells increases .
the no coordination case suffers from strong macro and other microcell interference resulting in a saturated sum rate at higher number of microcells .
we now study the effect of deploying multiple macrocell bss on the microcell sum rate performance . for comparison purposes , we consider scenarios with both single and three overlapping macrocells with inter - site distances of @xmath32 km . in both cases ,
a maximum of @xmath37 microcell bss are randomly dropped at the edge of the macrocell at a radius of @xmath73 , such that the minimum distance between successive microcell bss is @xmath68 .
[ mrp2 ] shows the mean microcell sum rate as a function of the number of microcells for both the single and three macrocell bss cases at a snr of 10db .
it is seen that the sum rate of the single macrocell bs case is significantly higher than the three overlapping macrocell bs case .
this is due to higher aggregate intercell interference resulting from other macrocells and microcells located within these macrocells .
compared to fig .
[ mrp ] where the microcells are randomly placed anywhere within the macrocell coverage area , the no coordination performance benefits the most from the microcells being deployed at the edge of the macrocell .
this can be seen from the mean sum rate , as it shows a linear growth up to 7 microcells in comparison with 3 microcells .
we also observe that the improvement in mean sum rate with cell edge deployment of microcells is higher for the no coordination strategy . at 10 microcells ,
the increase in the mean sum rate for the full coordination strategy is approximately 3.6 bps / hz , while the increase with no coordination is about 10 bps / hz .
in this paper , we demonstrate the rate gains provided by bs coordination in hetnets . with bs coordination , the sum rate is seen to increase linearly and the mean per - user sinr decreases linearly with the number of microcells .
however , the rate of mean per - user sinr degradation is reduced significantly with increased degrees coordination at the bss in the hetnet . at a low density of microcells , macro - only
coordination performs close to full coordination .
however , this is not the case with a higher density of microcells where increasing amounts of interference from the microcells is being added .
in addition to the above , the impact of multiple macrocells is also investigated . here ,
degradation in the mean microcell sum rate is observed for all the respective coordination strategies in comparison to the case where only one macrocell is present .
using an eigenvalue decomposition , ( [ app1 ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath74=\mathbb{e}\bigg[\big|\mathbf{h}_{n , k}(\mathbf{x\lambda{}x}^{*}+\sigma_{k}^{2}\mathbf{i})^{-1}\mathbf{h}_{n , k}^{*}\big|^{2}\bigg]\\ & \hspace{68pt}=\mathbb{e}\bigg[\big|\boldsymbol{\delta}_{n , k}(\mathbf{\lambda}+\sigma_{k}^{2}\mathbf{i})^{-1}\boldsymbol{\delta}_{n , k}^{*}\big|^{2}\bigg],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath75 has the same statistics as @xmath13 as @xmath76 is a unitary matrix .
hence , @xmath77=\mathbb{e}\bigg[\big|\sum\limits_{i=1}^{z_{n}}(\mathbf{\lambda}_{ii}+\sigma_{k}^{2})^{-1}|\boldsymbol{\delta}_{n , k , i}|^{2}\big|^{2}\bigg],\ ] ] where @xmath78 is the @xmath79th element of @xmath80 .
since @xmath78 is a zero mean complex gaussian random variable with variance @xmath16 , it follows that @xmath81 is an exponential random variable with mean @xmath16 . using the standard properties of the exponential random variable ,
can be expressed as @xmath82.\ ] ] a similar approach can be taken to evaluate the mean per - user intracell and intercell interference powers . further averaging over the eigenvalues ,
@xmath83 in ( [ app4 ] ) is possible as the density of eigenvalues is known .
however , due to space limitations we leave this approach for future work .
1 cisco , cisco visual networking index : global mobile data traffic forcast update , 20112016 " , white paper , feb .
a. ghosh , n. mangalvedhe , r. ratasuk , b. mondal , m. cudak , e. vistosky , t.a .
thomas , j.g .
andrews , p. xia , h.s .
jo , h.s .
dhillon and t.d .
novlan , heterogeneous cellular networks : from theory to practice " , _ ieee commun . mag .
50 , no . 6 , pp .
5464 , jun . 2012 .
a. alexiou , wireless world 2020 " , _ ieee veh .
technol . mag .
_ , vol . 9 , no . 1 , pp .
46 - 53 , mar .
2014 . c. kosta , b. hunt , a.u .
quddus and r. tafazolli , on interference avoidance through inter - cell interference coordination ( icic ) based on ofdma mobile systems " , _ ieee commun .
surveys tuts .
3 , pp . 973995 , aug . 2012 .
d. lopez - perez , i. guvenc , g.d.l .
roche , m. kountouris , t. quek and j. zhang , enhanced intercell interference coordination challenges in heterogeneous networks " , _ ieee commun . mag .
2230 , jun . 2011 .
g. boudreau , j. panicker , n. guo , r. chang , n. wang and s. vrzic , interference coordination and cancellation for 4 g networks " , _ ieee commun . mag .
4 , pp . 7481 , apr . 2009 . e. hossain , m. rasti , h. tabassum and a. abdelnasser , evolution toward 5 g multi - tier cellular wireless networks : an interference management perspective " , _ ieee wireless commun .
3 , pp . 118127 , jun . 2014 .
dhillon , m. kountouris and j.g .
andrews , downlink mimo hetnets : modelling , ordering results and performance analysis " , _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
10 , pp . 52085222 , oct .
dhillon , m. kountouris and j.g .
andrews , downlink coverage probability in mimo hetnets " , _ in proc .
ieee 46th conference on signals , systems and computers ( asilomar ) _ , pp .
683687 , nov .
s. park , w. seo , y. kim , s. lim and d. hong , beam subset selection strategy for interference reduction in two - tier femtocell networks " , _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
_ , vol . 9 , no . 11 , pp . 34403449 , oct
s. akoum , m. kountouris and r.w .
heath , on imperfect csi for the downlink of a two - tier network " , _ ieee intern .
symp . on info .
theory ( isit ) _ , pp .
553337 , july 2011 .
w. liu , s. han and c. yang ,
hybrid cooperative transmission in heterogeneous networks " , _ in proc .
ieee 23rd conference on personal , indoor and mobile radio communications ( pimrc ) _ , pp .
921925 , sep .
m. hong , r - y .
sun , h. baligh and z - q .
luo , joint base station clustering and beamformer design for partial coordinated transmission in heterogeneous networks " , _ submitted to ieee j. on sel .
areas commun .
_ , nov . 2012 .
available online : arxiv.org/pdf/1203.6390 .
t. yoo and a. goldsmith , on the optimality of multiantenna broadcast scheduling using zero - forcing beamforming " , _ ieee j. sel .
areas in commun .
3 , pp . 528541 , mar .
peel , b.m hochwald and a.l .
swindlehurst , a vector perturbation technique for near capacity multiantenna multiuser communication - part i : channel inversion and regularization " , _ ieee trans .
53 , no.1 , pp . 195202 , jan .
m. sadek , a. tarighat and a. sayed , a leakage - based precoding scheme for downlink multi - user mimo channels " , _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
_ , vol . 6 , no .
5 , pp . 17111721 , may 2007 . m. gudmundson ,
correlation model for shadow fading in mobile radio systems " , _ electronics letters _
23 , pp . 21452146 , nov .
l. yu , w. liu and r. langley , sinr analysis of the subtraction - based smi beamformer " , _ ieee trans . signal process .
_ , vol.58 , no.11 , pp .
59265932 , nov .
h. suraweera , p.j .
smith and m. shafi , capacity limits and performance analysis of cognitive radio with imperfect channel knowledge " , _ ieee trans .
technol . _ ,
4 , pp . 18111822 , may 2010 .
a. ahn , r.w .
heath , performance analysis of maximum ratio combining with imperfect channel estimation in presence of cochannel interferences " , _ ieee trans .
wireless commun .
_ , vol . 8 , no .
3 , pp . 10801085 , mar .
n. lee and w. shin , adaptive feedback scheme on k - cell miso interfering broadcast channel with limited feedback " , _ ieee trans . wireless .
2 , pp . 401406 , feb . 2011 . | in this paper we demonstrate the rate gains achieved by two - tier heterogeneous cellular networks ( hetnets ) with varying degrees of coordination between macrocell and microcell base stations ( bss ) .
we show that without the presence of coordination , network densification does not provide any gain in the sum rate and rapidly decreases the mean per - user signal - to - interference - plus - noise - ratio ( sinr ) .
our results show that coordination reduces the rate of sinr decay with increasing numbers of microcell bss in the system .
validity of the analytically approximated mean per - user sinr over a wide range of signal - to - noise - ratio ( snr ) is demonstrated via comparison with the simulated results . |
let @xmath0 be a set of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 , where @xmath7 is a small constant .
let @xmath13 be a family of geometric `` regions , '' called _ ranges _ , in @xmath2 , each of which can be described algebraically by some fixed number of real parameters ( a more precise definition is given below ) .
for example , @xmath13 can be the set of all axis - parallel boxes , balls , simplices , or cylinders , or the set of all intersections of pairs of ellipsoids . in the _
@xmath13-range searching _ problem , we want to preprocess @xmath0 into a data structure so that the number of points of @xmath0 lying in a query range @xmath14 can be counted efficiently .
similar to many previous papers , we actually consider a more general setting , the so - called _ semigroup model _
, where we are given a weight function on the points in @xmath0 and we ask for the cumulative weight of the points in @xmath15 .
the weights are assumed to belong to a semigroup , i.e. , subtractions are not allowed .
we assume that the semigroup operation can be executed in constant time .
in this paper we consider the case in which @xmath13 is a set of constant - complexity semialgebraic sets .
we recall that a _ semialgebraic set _ is a subset of @xmath2 obtained from a finite number of sets of the form @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is a @xmath7-variate polynomial with integer coefficients , by boolean operations ( unions , intersections , and complementations ) .
specifically , let @xmath18 denote the family of all semialgebraic sets in @xmath2 defined by at most @xmath19 polynomial inequalities of degree at most @xmath20 each .
if @xmath21 are all regarded as constants , we refer to the sets in @xmath18 as _ constant - complexity semialgebraic sets _
( such sets are sometimes also called _ tarski cells _ ) . by _ semialgebraic range searching _
we mean @xmath18-range searching for some parameters @xmath21 ; in most applications the actual collection @xmath13 of ranges is only a restricted subset of some @xmath18 . besides being interesting in its own right
, semialgebraic range searching also arises in several geometric searching problems , such as searching for a point nearest to a query geometric object , counting the number of input objects intersecting a query object , and many others .
this paper focuses on the _ low storage _ version of range searching with constant - complexity semialgebraic sets the data structure is allowed to use only linear or near - linear storage , and the goal is to make the query time as small as possible . at the other end of the spectrum we have the _ fast query _ version , where we want queries to be answered in polylogarithmic time using as little storage as possible .
this variant is discussed briefly in section [ sec : concl ] . as is typical in computational geometry
, we will use the _ real ram _ model of computation , where we can compute exactly with arbitrary real numbers and each arithmetic operation is executed in constant time .
motivated by a wide range of applications , several variants of range searching have been studied in computational geometry and database systems at least since the 1980s .
see @xcite for comprehensive surveys of this topic .
the early work focused on the so - called _ orthogonal range searching _ , where ranges are axis - parallel boxes .
after three decades of extensive work on this particular case , some basic questions still remain open .
however , geometry plays little role in the known data structures for orthogonal range searching .
the most basic and most studied truly geometric instance of range searching is with _ halfspaces _ , or more generally _
simplices _ , as ranges .
studies in the early 1990s have essentially determined the optimal trade - off between the worst - case query time and the storage ( and preprocessing time ) required by any data structure for simplex range searching .
is assumed to be _ fixed _ and the implicit constants in the asymptotic notation may depend on @xmath7 .
this is the setting in all the previous papers , including the present one .
of course , in practical applications , this assumption may be unrealistic unless the dimension is really small .
however , the known lower bounds imply that if the dimension is large , no efficient solutions to simplex range searching exist , at least in the worst - case setting . ]
simplex range searching .
lower bounds for this trade - off have been given by chazelle @xcite under the semigroup model of computation , where subtraction of the point weights is not allowed .
it is possible that , say , the counting version of the simplex range searching problem , where we ask just for the number of points in the query simplex , might admit better solutions using subtractions , but no such solutions are known .
moreover , there are recent lower - bound results when subtractions are also allowed ; see @xcite and references therein .
we also refer to @xcite and references therein for recent lower bounds for the case where subtractions are also allowed .
the data structures proposed for simplex range searching over the last two decades @xcite match the known lower bounds within polylogarithmic factors .
the state - of - the - art upper bounds are by ( i ) chan @xcite , who , building on many earlier results , provides a linear - size data structure with @xmath22 expected preprocessing time and @xmath3 query time , and ( ii ) matouek @xcite , who provides a data structure with @xmath23 storage , @xmath24 query time , and @xmath25 preprocessing time .
denotes an arbitrarily small positive constant .
the implicit constants in the asymptotic notation may depend on it , generally tending to infinity as @xmath26 decreases to @xmath27 . ] a trade - off between space and query time can be obtained by combining these two data structures @xcite .
yao and yao @xcite were perhaps the first to consider range searching in which ranges were delimited by graphs of polynomial functions .
agarwal and matouek @xcite have introduced a systematic study of semialgebraic range searching .
building on the techniques developed for simplex range searching , they presented a linear - size data structure with @xmath28 query time , where @xmath29 . for @xmath30 ,
this almost matches the performance for the simplex range searching , but for @xmath31 there is a gap in the exponents of the corresponding bounds .
also see @xcite for related recent developments .
the bottleneck in the performance of the just mentioned range - searching data structure of @xcite is a combinatorial geometry problem , known as the _ decomposition of arrangements into constant - complexity cells_. here , we are given a set @xmath32 of @xmath33 algebraic surfaces in @xmath2 ( i.e. , zero sets of @xmath7-variate polynomials ) , with degrees bounded by a constant @xmath34 , and we want to decompose each cell of the arrangement @xmath35 ( see section [ sec : cross ] for details ) into subcells that are constant - complexity semialgebraic sets , i.e. , belong to @xmath18 for some constants @xmath20 ( bound on degrees ) and @xmath19 ( number of defining polynomials ) , which may depend on @xmath7 and @xmath34 , but not on @xmath33 .
the crucial quantity is the total number of the resulting subcells over all cells of @xmath35 ; namely , if one can construct such a decomposition with @xmath36 subcells , with some constant @xmath37 , for every @xmath33 and @xmath32 , then the method of @xcite yields query time @xmath28 ( with linear storage ) .
the only known general - purpose technique for producing such a decomposition is the so - called _ vertical decomposition _
@xcite , which decomposes @xmath35 into roughly @xmath38 constant - complexity subcells , for @xmath39 @xcite .
an alternative approach , based on _ linearization _ , was also proposed in @xcite .
it maps the semialgebraic ranges in @xmath2 to simplices in some higher - dimensional space and uses simplex range searching there . however , its performance depends on the specific form of the polynomials defining the ranges . in some special cases ( e.g. ,
when ranges are balls in @xmath2 ) , linearization yields better query time than the decomposition - based technique mentioned above , but for general constant - complexity semialgebraic ranges , linearization has worse performance . in a recent breakthrough , guth and katz @xcite have presented a new space decomposition technique , called polynomial partitioning .
for a set @xmath40 of @xmath1 points and a real parameter @xmath5 , @xmath41 , an _ @xmath5-partitioning polynomial _ for @xmath0 is a nonzero @xmath7-variate polynomial @xmath8 such that each connected component of @xmath42 contains at most @xmath11 points of @xmath0 , where @xmath43 denotes the zero set of @xmath8 . the decomposition of @xmath2 into @xmath12 and the connected components of @xmath10
is called a _ polynomial partition _ ( induced by @xmath8 ) . guth and
katz show that an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial of degree @xmath9 always exists , but their argument does not lead to an efficient algorithm for constructing such a polynomial , mainly because it relies on ham - sandwich cuts in high - dimensional spaces , for which no efficient construction is known .
our first result is an efficient randomized algorithm for computing an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial .
[ thm : partition - algo ] given a set @xmath0 of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 , for some fixed @xmath7 , and a parameter @xmath44 , an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial for @xmath0 of degree @xmath9 can be computed in randomized expected time @xmath45 .
next , we use this algorithm to bypass the arrangement - decomposition problem mentioned above .
namely , based on polynomial partitions , we construct _ partition trees _ @xcite that answer range queries with constant - complexity semialgebraic sets in near - optimal time , using linear storage .
an essential ingredient in the performance analysis of these partition trees is a recent combinatorial result of barone and basu @xcite , originally conjectured by the second author , which deals with the complexity of certain kinds of arrangements of zero sets of polynomials ( see theorem [ t : basu ] ) . while there have already been several combinatorial applications of the guth - katz technique ( the most impressive being the original one in @xcite , which solves the famous erds s distinct distances problem , and some of the others presented in @xcite ) , ours seems to be the first _ algorithmic _ application .
we establish two range - searching results , both based on polynomial partitions . for the first result , we need to introduce the notion of _ @xmath46-general position _ , for an integer @xmath47 .
we say that a set @xmath40 is in @xmath46-general position if no @xmath48 points of @xmath0 are contained in the zero set of a nonzero @xmath7-variate polynomial of degree at most @xmath46 , where @xmath49 .
this is the number one expects for a `` generic '' point set .- variate polynomials of degree at most @xmath46 have at most @xmath50 distinct nonconstant monomials .
the veronese map ( e.g. , see @xcite ) maps @xmath2 to @xmath51 , and hyperplanes in @xmath51 correspond bijectively to @xmath48-variate polynomials of degree at most @xmath46 .
it follows that any set of @xmath50 points in @xmath2 is contained in the zero set of a @xmath7-variate polynomial of degree at most @xmath46 , corresponding to the hyperplane in @xmath51 passing through the veronese images of these points .
similarly , @xmath48 points in general position are not expected to have this property , because one does not expect their images to lie in a common hyperplane .
see @xcite for more details . ]
[ t : const - r ] let @xmath21 and @xmath52 be constants .
let @xmath40 be an @xmath1-point set in @xmath53-general position , where @xmath53 is a suitable constant depending on @xmath54 , and @xmath26 .
then the @xmath18-range searching problem for @xmath0 can be solved with @xmath55 storage , @xmath22 expected preprocessing time , and @xmath56 query time .
we note that both here and in the next theorem , while the preprocessing algorithm is randomized , the queries are answered deterministically , and the query time bound is worst - case . of course
, we would like to handle arbitrary point sets , not only those in @xmath53-general position .
this can be achieved by an infinitesimal perturbation of the points of @xmath0 . a general technique known as `` simulation of simplicity '' ( in the version considered by yap @xcite )
ensures that the perturbed set @xmath57 is in @xmath53-general position .
if a point @xmath58 lies in the interior of a query range @xmath59 , then so does the corresponding perturbed point @xmath60 , and similarly for @xmath61 in the interior of @xmath62 .
however , for @xmath61 on the boundary of @xmath59 , we can not be sure if @xmath63 ends up inside or outside @xmath59 .
let us say that a _ boundary - fuzzy _ solution to the @xmath18-range searching problem is a data structure that , given a query @xmath64 , returns an answer in which all points of @xmath0 in the interior of @xmath59 are counted and none in the interior of @xmath62 is counted , while each point @xmath58 on the boundary of @xmath59 may or may not be counted . in some applications , we can think of the points of @xmath0 being imprecise anyway ( e.g. , their coordinates come from some imprecise measurement ) , and then boundary - fuzzy range searching may be adequate . [
c : fuzzy ] let @xmath21 , and @xmath52 be constants . then for every @xmath1-point set in @xmath2 , there is a boundary - fuzzy @xmath18-range searching data structure with @xmath55 storage , @xmath22 expected preprocessing time , and @xmath56 query time . actually , previous results on range searching that use simulation of simplicity to avoid degenerate cases also solve only the boundary - fuzzy variant ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
however , the previous techniques , even if presented only for point sets in general position , can usually be adapted to handle degenerate cases as well , perhaps with some effort , which is nevertheless routine . for our technique
, degeneracy appears to be a more substantial problem because it is possible that a large subset of @xmath0 ( maybe even all of @xmath0 ) is contained in the zero set of the partitioning polynomial @xmath8 , and the recursive divide - and - conquer mechanism yielded by the partition of @xmath8 does not apply to this subset . partially in response to this issue , we we next present a different data structure that , at a somewhat higher preprocessing cost , not only gets rid of the boundary - fuzziness condition but also has a slightly improved query time ( in terms of @xmath1 ) .
the main idea is that we build an auxiliary recursive data structure to handle the potentially large subset of points that lie in the zero set of the partitioning polynomial .
[ t : large - r ] let @xmath21 , and @xmath52 be constants . then the @xmath18-range searching problem for an arbitrary @xmath1-point set in @xmath2 can be solved with @xmath55 storage , @xmath65 expected preprocessing time , and @xmath66 query time , where @xmath67 is a constant depending on @xmath21 and @xmath26 .
we remark that the dependence of @xmath67 on @xmath20 , @xmath19 , and @xmath26 is reasonable , but its dependence on @xmath7 is superexponential .
our algorithms work for the semigroup model described earlier . assuming that a semigroup operation can be executed in constant time
, the query time remains the same as for the counting query .
a reporting query report the points of @xmath0 lying in a query range also fits in the semigroup model , except one can not assume that a semigroup operation in this case takes constant time .
the time taken by a reporting query is proportional to the cost of a counting query plus the number of reported points .
our algorithm is based on the polynomial partitioning technique by guth and katz , and we begin by briefly reviewing it in section [ sec : gk ] .
next , in section [ sec : algo ] , we describe the randomized algorithm for constructing such a partitioning polynomial .
section [ sec : cross ] presents an algorithm for computing the cells of a polynomial partition that are crossed by a semialgebraic range , and discusses several related topics .
section [ sec : range1 ] presents our first data structure , which is as in theorem [ t : const - r ] .
section [ s : cad ] describes the method for handling points lying on the zero set of the partitioning polynomial , and section [ sec : range2 ] presents our second data structure .
we conclude in section [ sec : concl ] by mentioning a few open problems .
in this section we briefly review the guth - katz technique for later use .
we begin by stating their result .
[ t : gk ] given a set @xmath0 of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 and a parameter @xmath44 , there exists an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial for @xmath0 of degree at most @xmath9 ( for @xmath7 fixed ) .
the degree in the theorem is asymptotically optimal in the worst case because the number of connected components of @xmath10 is @xmath68 for every polynomial @xmath8 ( see , e.g. , warren ( * ? ? ? * theorem 2 ) ) .
the guth - katz proof uses the _
polynomial ham sandwich _ theorem of stone and tukey @xcite , which we state here in a version for finite point sets : _
if @xmath69 are finite sets in @xmath2 and @xmath46 is an integer satisfying @xmath70 , then there exists a nonzero polynomial @xmath8 of degree at most @xmath46 that simultaneously bisects all the sets @xmath71 .
_ here `` @xmath8 bisects @xmath71 '' means that @xmath72 in at most @xmath73 points of @xmath71 and @xmath74 in at most @xmath73 points of @xmath71 ; @xmath8 might vanish at any number of the points of @xmath71 , possibly even at all of them .
guth and katz inductively construct collections @xmath75 of subsets of @xmath0 . for @xmath76 , @xmath77 consists of at most @xmath78 pairwise - disjoint subsets of @xmath0 , each of size at most @xmath79 ; the union of these sets does not have to contain all points of @xmath0 .
initially , we have @xmath80 .
the algorithm stops as soon as each subset in @xmath81 has at most @xmath11 points .
this implies that @xmath82 .
having constructed @xmath83 , we use the polynomial ham - sandwich theorem to construct a polynomial @xmath84 that bisects each set of @xmath83 , with @xmath85 ( this is indeed an asymptotic upper bound for the smallest @xmath46 satisfying @xmath86 , assuming @xmath7 to be a constant ) . for every subset @xmath87 ,
let @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
we set @xmath90 ; empty subsets are not included in @xmath77 .
the desired @xmath5-partitioning polynomial for @xmath0 is then the product @xmath91 .
we have @xmath92 by construction , the points of @xmath0 lying in a single connected component of @xmath10 belong to a single member of @xmath81 , which implies that each connected component contains at most @xmath11 points of @xmath0 .
we begin by observing that @xmath93 is the number of all nonconstant monomials of degree at most @xmath46 in @xmath7 variables .
thus , we fix a collection @xmath94 of @xmath95 such monomials .
let @xmath96 be the corresponding _ veronese map _ , which maps a point @xmath97 to the @xmath48-tuple of the values at @xmath98 of the monomials from @xmath94 .
for example , for @xmath99 , @xmath100 , and @xmath101 , we may use @xmath102 , where @xmath94 is the set of the eight monomials appearing as components of @xmath103 .
let @xmath104 be the image of the given @xmath71 under this veronese map , for , @xmath105 . by the standard _ ham - sandwich theorem _
( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , there exists a hyperplane @xmath106 in @xmath107 that simultaneously bisects all the @xmath108 s , in the sense that each open halfspace bounded by @xmath106 contains at most half of the points of each of the sets @xmath108 . in a more algebraic language
, there is a nonzero @xmath48-variate linear polynomial , which we also call @xmath106 , that bisects all the @xmath108 s , in the sense of being positive on at most half of the points of each @xmath108 , and being negative on at most half of the points of each @xmath108
. then @xmath109 is the desired @xmath7-variate polynomial of degree at most @xmath46 bisecting all the @xmath71 s .
in this section we present an efficient randomized algorithm that , given a point set @xmath0 and a parameter @xmath110 , constructs an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial . the main difficulty in converting the above proof of the guth - katz partitioning theorem into an efficient algorithm is the use of the ham - sandwich theorem in the possibly high - dimensional space @xmath107 .
a straightforward algorithm for computing ham - sandwich cuts in @xmath107 inspects all possible ways of splitting the input point sets by a hyperplane , and has running time about @xmath111 .
compared to this easy upper bound , the best known ham - sandwich algorithms can save a factor of about @xmath1 @xcite , but this is insignificant in higher dimensions .
a recent result of knauer , tiwari , and werner @xcite shows that a certain incremental variant of computing a ham - sandwich cut is @xmath112$]-hard ( where the parameter is the dimension ) , and thus one perhaps should not expect much better exact algorithms . we observe that the exact bisection of each @xmath71 is not needed in the guth - katz construction
it is sufficient to replace the stone tukey polynomial ham - sandwich theorem by a weaker result , as described below .
we say that a polynomial @xmath8 is _ well - dissecting _ for a point set @xmath113 if @xmath72 on at most @xmath114 points of @xmath113 and @xmath74 on at most @xmath114 points of @xmath113 .
given point sets @xmath69 in @xmath2 with @xmath1 points in total , we present a las - vegas algorithm for constructing a polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath115 that is well - dissecting for at least @xmath116 of the @xmath71 s . as in the above proof of the stone
tukey polynomial ham - sandwich theorem , let @xmath46 be the smallest integer satisfying @xmath70 .
we fix a collection @xmath94 of @xmath48 distinct nonconstant monomials of degree at most @xmath46 , and let @xmath103 be the corresponding veronese map . for each @xmath117
, we pick a point @xmath118 uniformly at random and compute @xmath119 .
let @xmath106 be a hyperplane in @xmath107 passing through @xmath120 , which can be found by solving a system of linear equations , in @xmath121 time .
if the points @xmath120 are not affinely independent , then @xmath106 is not determined uniquely ( this is a technical nuisance , which the reader may want to ignore on first reading ) . in order to handle this case , we prepare in advance , before picking the @xmath122 s , _ auxiliary _ affinely independent points @xmath123 in @xmath107 , which are in general position with respect to @xmath124 ; here we mean the `` ordinary '' general position , i.e. , no unnecessary affine dependences , that involve some of the @xmath125 s and the other points , arise .
the points @xmath125 can be chosen at random , say , uniformly in the unit cube ; with high probability , they have the desired general position property .
( if we do not want to assume the capability of choosing a random real number , we can pick the @xmath125 s uniformly at random from a sufficiently large discrete set . )
if the dimension of the affine hull of @xmath120 is @xmath126 , we choose the hyperplane @xmath106 through @xmath120 and @xmath127 . if @xmath106 is not unique , i.e. , @xmath128 are not affinely independent with respect to @xmath129 , which we can detect while solving the linear system , we restart the algorithm by choosing @xmath123 anew and then picking new @xmath130 . in this way , after a constant expected number of iterations , we obtain the uniquely determined hyperplane @xmath106 through @xmath120 and @xmath127 as above , and we let @xmath131 denote the corresponding @xmath7-variate polynomial .
we refer to these steps as one _ trial _ of the algorithm . for each @xmath71
, we check whether @xmath8 is well - dissecting for @xmath71 .
if @xmath8 is well - dissecting for only fewer than @xmath132 sets , then we discard @xmath8 and perform another trial .
we now analyze the expected running time of the algorithm .
the intuition is that @xmath8 is expected to well - dissect a significant fraction , say at least half , of the sets @xmath71 .
this intuition is reflected in the next lemma .
let @xmath133 be the indicator variable of the event : _
@xmath71 is * not * well - dissected by @xmath8_. [ l : exi ] for every @xmath134 , @xmath135 \le 1/4 $ ] .
let us fix @xmath136 and the choices of @xmath137 ( and thus of @xmath138 ) for all @xmath139 .
let @xmath140 be the dimension of @xmath141 , the affine hull of @xmath142 .
then the resulting hyperplane @xmath106 passes through the @xmath143-flat @xmath144 spanned by @xmath141 and @xmath145 , irrespective of which point of @xmath71 is chosen .
if @xmath122 , the point chosen from @xmath71 , is such that @xmath146 lies on @xmath141 , then @xmath106 also passes through @xmath147 .
put @xmath148 , and let us project the configuration orthogonally to a 2-dimensional plane @xmath149 orthogonal to @xmath144 .
then @xmath144 appears as a point @xmath150 , and @xmath108 projects to a ( multi)set @xmath151 in @xmath149 .
the random hyperplane @xmath106 projects to a random line @xmath152 in @xmath149 , whose choice can be interpreted as follows : pick @xmath153 uniformly at random ; if @xmath154 , then @xmath152 is the unique line through @xmath155 and @xmath156 ; otherwise , when @xmath157 , @xmath152 is the unique line through @xmath156 and @xmath158 ; by construction , @xmath159 . the indicator variable @xmath133 is @xmath160 if and only if the resulting @xmath152 has more than @xmath161 points of @xmath151 , counted with multiplicity , ( strictly ) on one side .
the special role of @xmath158 can be eliminated if we first move the points of @xmath151 coinciding with @xmath156 to the point @xmath158 , and then slightly perturb the points so as to ensure that all points of @xmath151 are distinct and lie at distinct directions from @xmath156 ; it is easy to see that these transformations can not decrease the probability of @xmath162 .
finally , we note that the side of @xmath152 containing a point @xmath163 only depends on the direction of the vector @xmath164 , so we can also assume the points of @xmath151 to lie on the unit circle around @xmath156 . using ( a simple instance of ) the standard planar ham - sandwich theorem , we partition @xmath151 into two subsets @xmath165 and @xmath166 of equal size by a line through the center @xmath156
. then we bisect @xmath165 by a ray from @xmath156 , and we do the same for @xmath166 .
it is easily checked ( see figure [ f : semi2-quarters ] ) that there always exist two of the resulting quarters , one of @xmath165 and one of @xmath166 ( the ones whose union forms an angle @xmath167 between the two bisecting rays ) , such that every line connecting @xmath156 with a point in either quarter contains at least @xmath168 points of @xmath151 on each side . referring to these quarters as `` good '' , we now take one of the bisecting rays , say that of @xmath165 , and rotate it about @xmath156 away from the good quarter of @xmath165 .
each of the first @xmath169 points that the ray encounters has the property that the line supporting the ray has at least @xmath169 points of @xmath151 on each side .
this implies that , for at least half of the points in each of the two remaining quarters , the line connecting @xmath156 to such a point has at least @xmath169 points of @xmath151 on each side .
hence at most @xmath170 points of @xmath108 can lead to a cut that is not well - dissecting for @xmath108 .
we conclude that , still conditioned on the choices of @xmath137 , @xmath139 , the event @xmath162 has probability at most @xmath171 .
since this holds for every choice of the @xmath137 , @xmath139 , the unconditional probability of @xmath162 is also at most @xmath171 , and thus @xmath135\le 1/4 $ ] as claimed .
hence , the expected number of sets @xmath71 that are not well - dissected by @xmath8 is @xmath172 = \sum_{i=1}^k \ex [ x_i ] \le k/4.\ ] ] by markov s inequality , with probability at least @xmath173 , at least half of the @xmath71 s are well - dissected by @xmath8 .
we thus obtain a polynomial that is well - dissecting for at least half of the @xmath71 s after an expected constant number of trials .
it remains to estimate the running time of each trial .
the points @xmath174 can be chosen in @xmath55 time .
computing @xmath106 involves solving a @xmath175 linear system , which can be done in @xmath121 time using gaussian elimination .
note that we do _ not _ actually compute the entire sets @xmath176 .
no computation is needed for passing from @xmath106 to @xmath8we just re - interpret the coefficients . to check which of @xmath177 are well - dissected by @xmath8
, we evaluate @xmath8 at each point of @xmath178 .
first we evaluate each of the @xmath48 monomials in @xmath94 at each point of @xmath113 .
if we proceed incrementally , from lower degrees to higher ones , this can be done with @xmath179 operations per monomial and point of @xmath113 , in @xmath180 time in total .
then , in additional @xmath180 time , we compute the values of @xmath181 , for all @xmath182 , from the values of the monomials . putting everything together we obtain the following lemma .
[ l : dissect ] given point sets @xmath69 in @xmath2 ( for fixed @xmath7 ) with @xmath1 points in total , a polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath115 that is well - dissecting for at least @xmath116 of the @xmath71 s can be constructed in @xmath183 randomized expected time .
we now describe the algorithm for computing an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial @xmath8 .
we essentially imitate the guth katz construction , with lemma [ l : dissect ] replacing the polynomial ham - sandwich theorem , but with an additional twist .
the algorithm works in phases . at the end of the @xmath184-th phase , for @xmath185
, we have a family @xmath186 of @xmath184 polynomials and a family @xmath77 of at most @xmath78 pairwise - disjoint subsets of @xmath0 , each of size at most @xmath187 .
similar to the guth
katz construction , @xmath77 is not necessarily a partition of @xmath0 , since the points of @xmath188 do not belong to @xmath189 .
initially , @xmath190 .
the algorithm stops when each set in @xmath77 has at most @xmath11 points . in the @xmath184-th phase ,
the algorithm constructs @xmath84 and @xmath77 from @xmath191 and @xmath83 , as follows . at the beginning of the @xmath184-th phase ,
let @xmath192 be the family of the `` large '' sets in @xmath193 , and set @xmath194 .
we also initialize the collection @xmath195 to @xmath196 , the family of `` small '' sets in @xmath193
. then we perform at most @xmath197 dissecting steps , as follows : after @xmath19 steps , we have a family @xmath198 of polynomials , the current set @xmath195 , and a subfamily @xmath199 of size at most @xmath200 , consisting of the members of @xmath201 that were not well - dissected by any of @xmath198 . if @xmath202 we choose , using lemma [ l : dissect ] , a polynomial @xmath203 of degree at most @xmath204 ( with a suitable constant @xmath205 that depends only on @xmath7 ) that well - dissects at least half of the members of @xmath206 . for each @xmath207 , let @xmath208 and @xmath209 .
if @xmath210 is well - dissected , i.e. , @xmath211 , then we add @xmath212 to @xmath195 , and otherwise , we add @xmath210 to @xmath213 .
note that in the former case the points @xmath214 satisfying @xmath215 are `` lost '' and do not participate in the subsequent dissections . by lemma [ l : dissect ] , @xmath216 .
the @xmath184-th phase is completed when @xmath217 , in which case we set is not necessarily well - dissecting , because it does not control the sizes of subsets with positive or with negative signs . ]
@xmath218 . by construction ,
each point set in @xmath195 has at most @xmath187 points , and the points of @xmath0 not belonging to any set of @xmath195 lie in @xmath219 .
furthermore , @xmath220 where again the constant of proportionality depends only on @xmath7 .
since every set in @xmath83 is split into at most two sets before being added to @xmath77 , @xmath221 .
if @xmath77 contains subsets with more than @xmath11 points , we begin the @xmath222-st phase with the current @xmath195 ; otherwise the algorithm stops and returns @xmath223 .
this completes the description of the algorithm .
clearly , @xmath224 , the number of phases of the algorithm , is at most @xmath225 .
following the same argument as in @xcite , and as briefly sketched in section [ sec : gk ] , it can be shown that all points lying in a single connected component of @xmath10 belong to a single member of @xmath226 , and thus each connected component contains at most @xmath11 points of @xmath0 . since the degree of @xmath84 is @xmath227 , @xmath228 , and @xmath229 ,
we conclude that @xmath230 as for the expected running time of the algorithm , the @xmath19-th step of the @xmath184-th phase takes @xmath231 expected time , so the @xmath184-th phase takes a total of @xmath232 expected time . substituting @xmath228 in the above bound and summing over all @xmath184 , the overall expected
running time of the algorithm is @xmath45 .
this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : partition - algo ] .
theorem [ thm : partition - algo ] is employed for the preprocessing in our range - searching algorithms in theorems [ t : const - r ] and [ t : large - r ] . in theorem [ t : const - r ]
we take @xmath5 to be a large constant , and the expected running time in theorem [ thm : partition - algo ] is @xmath55 .
however , in theorem [ t : large - r ] , we require @xmath5 to be a small fractional power of @xmath1 , say @xmath233 .
it is a challenging open problem to improve the expected running time in theorem [ thm : partition - algo ] to @xmath234 when @xmath5 is such a small fractional power of @xmath1 .
the bottleneck in the current algorithm is the subproblem of evaluating a given @xmath7-variate polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath235 at @xmath1 given points ; everything else can be performed in @xmath236 expected time .
finding the signs of @xmath8 at those points would actually suffice , but this probably does not make the problem any simpler .
this problem of _ multi - evaluation _ of multivariate real polynomials has been considered in the literature , and there is a nontrivial improvement over the straightforward @xmath237 algorithm , due to nsken and ziegler @xcite . concretely , in the bivariate case ( @xmath99 ) , their algorithm can evaluate a bivariate polynomial of degree @xmath238 at @xmath1 given points using @xmath239 arithmetic operations .
it is based on fast matrix multiplication , and even under the most optimistic possible assumption on the speed of matrix multiplication , it can not get below @xmath240 .
although this is significantly faster than our naive @xmath237-time algorithm , which is @xmath241 in this bivariate case , it is still a far cry from what we are aiming at . however , its running time is still a far cry from what we are aiming at .
let us remark that in a different setting , for polynomials over finite fields ( and over certain more general finite rings ) , there is a remarkable method for multi - evaluation by kedlaya and umans @xcite achieving @xmath242 running time , where @xmath243 is the cardinality of the field .
in this section we define the crossing number of a polynomial partition and describe an algorithm for computing the cells of a polynomial partition that are crossed by a semialgebraic range , both of which will be crucial for our range - searching data structures .
we begin by recalling a few results on arrangements of algebraic surfaces .
we refer the reader to @xcite for a comprehensive review of such arrangements .
let @xmath32 be a finite set of algebraic surfaces in @xmath2 .
the _ arrangement _ of @xmath32 , denoted by @xmath35 , is the partition of @xmath2 into maximal relatively open connected subsets , called _ cells _ , such that all points within each cell lie in the same subset of surfaces of @xmath32 ( and in no other surface ) .
if @xmath244 is a set of @xmath7-variate polynomials , then with a slight abuse of notation , we use @xmath245 to denote the arrangement @xmath246 of their zero sets .
we need the following result on arrangements , which follows from proposition 7.33 and theorem 16.18 in @xcite .
[ t : make - arrg ] let @xmath247 be a set of @xmath19 real @xmath7-variate polynomials , each of degree at most @xmath20 .
then the arrangement @xmath245 in @xmath2 has at most @xmath248 cells , and it can be computed in time at most @xmath249 . each cell is described as a semialgebraic set using at most @xmath250 polynomials of degree bounded by @xmath251 .
moreover , the algorithm supplies an explicitly computed point in each cell . a key ingredient for the analysis of our range - searching data structure is the following recent result of barone and basu @xcite , which is a refinement of a series of previous studies ; e.g. , see @xcite : see @xcite : [ t : basu ] let @xmath252 be a @xmath48-dimensional algebraic variety in @xmath2 defined by a finite set @xmath253 of @xmath7-variate polynomials , each of degree at most @xmath20 , and let @xmath244 be a set of @xmath19 polynomials of degree at most @xmath254 .
then the number of cells of @xmath255 ( of all dimensions ) that are contained in @xmath252 is bounded by @xmath256 .
let @xmath0 be a set of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 , and let @xmath8 be an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial for @xmath0 .
recall that the _ polynomial partition _
@xmath257 induced by @xmath8 is the partition of @xmath2 into the zero set @xmath12 and the connected components @xmath258 of @xmath10 .
as already noted , warren s theorem @xcite implies that @xmath259 .
we call @xmath260 the _ cells _ of @xmath261 ( although they need not be cells in the sense typical , e.g. , in topology ; they need not even be simply connected ) .
@xmath261 also induces a partition @xmath262 of @xmath0 , where @xmath263 is the _ exceptional part _ , and @xmath264 , for @xmath265 , are the _ regular parts_. by construction , @xmath266 for every @xmath267 , but we have no control over the size of @xmath268this will be the source of most of our technical difficulties . next , let @xmath59 be a range in @xmath269 .
we say that @xmath59 _ crosses _ a cell @xmath270 if neither @xmath271 nor @xmath272 .
the _ crossing number _ of @xmath59 is the number of cells of @xmath261 crossed by @xmath59 , and the _ crossing number _ of @xmath261 ( with respect to @xmath269 ) is the maximum of the crossing numbers of all @xmath273 .
similar to many previous range - searching algorithms @xcite , the crossing number of @xmath274 will determine the query time of our range - searching algorithms described in sections [ sec : range1 ] and [ sec : range2 ] .
[ l : cr ] if @xmath261 is a polynomial partition induced by an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial of degree at most @xmath46 , then the crossing number of @xmath261 with respect to @xmath269 , with @xmath275 , is at most @xmath276 , where @xmath277 is a suitable constant depending only on @xmath7 .
let @xmath273 ; then @xmath59 is a boolean combination of up to @xmath19 sets of the form @xmath278 , where @xmath279 are polynomials of degree at most @xmath20 .
if @xmath59 crosses a cell @xmath270 , then at least one of the ranges @xmath280 also crosses @xmath270 , and thus it suffices to establish that the crossing number of any range @xmath59 , defined by a single @xmath7-variate polynomial inequality @xmath281 of degree at most @xmath20 , is at most @xmath282 .
we apply theorem [ t : basu ] with @xmath283 , which is an algebraic variety of dimension @xmath284 , and with @xmath285 and @xmath286 , where @xmath8 is the @xmath5-partitioning polynomial . then , for each cell @xmath270 crossed by @xmath59
, @xmath287 is a nonempty union of some of the cells in @xmath288 that lie in @xmath252 .
thus , the crossing number of @xmath59 is at most @xmath289 .
we need to perform the following algorithmic primitives ( for @xmath7 _ fixed _ as usual ) for the range - searching algorithms that we will later present : * given an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath235 , compute ( a suitable representation of ) the partition @xmath261 and the induced partition of @xmath0 into @xmath290 .
+ by computing @xmath291 , using theorem [ t : make - arrg ] , and then testing the membership of each point @xmath58 in each cell @xmath270 in time polynomial in @xmath5 , the above operation can be performed in @xmath292 time , this would be the second step , together with an improved construction of an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial @xmath8 ( concretely , an improved multi - point evaluation procedure for @xmath8 ) as discussed at the end of section [ sec : algo ] , needed to improve the preprocessing time in theorem [ t : large - r ] . ]
where @xmath293 .
* given ( a suitable representation of ) @xmath261 as in ( a1 ) and a query range @xmath294 , i.e. , a range defined by a single @xmath7-variate polynomial @xmath17 of degree @xmath275 , compute which of the cells of @xmath261 are crossed by @xmath59 and which are completely contained in @xmath59 .
+ we already have the arrangement @xmath291 , and we compute @xmath295 .
for each cell of @xmath295 contained in @xmath296 , we locate its representative point in @xmath291 , and this gives us the cells crossed by @xmath59 .
for the remaining cells , we want to know whether they are inside @xmath59 or outside , and for that , it suffices to determine the sign of @xmath17 at the representative points . using theorem [ t : make - arrg ]
, the above task can thus be accomplished in time @xmath297 , with @xmath293 .
we are now ready to describe our first data structure for @xmath269-range searching , which is a constant fan - out ( branching degree ) partition tree , and which works for points in general position .
let @xmath0 be a set of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 , and let @xmath298 be constants .
we choose @xmath5 as a ( large ) constant depending on @xmath21 , and the prespecified parameter @xmath26 .
we assume @xmath0 to be in @xmath53-general position for some sufficiently large constant @xmath299 .
we construct a partition tree @xmath300 of fan - out @xmath301 as follows .
we first construct an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial @xmath8 for @xmath0 using theorem [ thm : partition - algo ] , and compute the partition @xmath261 of @xmath2 induced by @xmath8 , as well as the corresponding partition @xmath302 of @xmath0 , where @xmath259 . since @xmath5 is a constant , the ( a1 ) operation , discussed in section [ sec : cross ] , performs this computation in @xmath55 time .
we choose @xmath53 so as to ensure that it is at least @xmath303 , and then our assumption that @xmath0 is in @xmath53-general position implies that the size of @xmath304 is bounded by @xmath53 .
we set up the root of @xmath300 , where we store 1 .
the partitioning polynomial @xmath8 , and a suitable representation of the partition @xmath261 ; 2 . a list of the points of the exceptional part @xmath268 ; and 3 .
@xmath305 , the sum of the weights of the points of the regular part @xmath306 , for each @xmath267 .
the partition polynomial @xmath8 , a suitable representation of the partition @xmath261 , a list of the points of the exceptional part @xmath268 , and @xmath305 , the sum of weights of all points of @xmath306 , for each @xmath267 .
the regular parts @xmath306 are not stored explicitly at the root . instead ,
for each @xmath306 we recursively build a subtree representing it .
the recursion terminates , at leaves of @xmath300 , as soon as we reach point sets of size smaller than a suitable constant @xmath307 .
the points of each such set are stored explicitly at the corresponding leaf of @xmath300 . since each node of @xmath300 requires only a constant amount of storage and each point of @xmath0
is stored at only one node of @xmath300 , the total size of @xmath300 is @xmath55 .
the preprocessing time is @xmath22 since @xmath300 has depth @xmath308 and each level is processed in @xmath55 time . to process a query range @xmath273 , we start at the root of @xmath300 and maintain a global counter which is initially set to @xmath27 . among the cells @xmath260 of the partition @xmath261 stored at the root , we find , using the ( a2 ) operation , those completely contained in @xmath59 , and those crossed by @xmath59 . actually , we compute a superset of the cells that @xmath59 crosses , namely , the cells crossed by the zero set of at least one of the ( at most @xmath19 ) polynomials defining @xmath59 .
for each cell @xmath271 , we add the weight @xmath305 to the global counter .
we also add to the global counter the weights of the points in @xmath309 , which we find by testing each point of @xmath268 separately .
then we recurse in each subtree corresponding to a cell @xmath270 crossed by @xmath59 ( in the above weaker sense ) .
the leaves , with point sets of size @xmath179 , are processed by inspecting their points individually . by lemma [ l :
cr ] , the number of cells crossed by any of the polynomials defining @xmath59 at any interior node of @xmath300 is at most @xmath310 , where @xmath311 is a constant independent of @xmath5 . the query time @xmath312 obeys the following recurrence : @xmath313 o(n ) & \mbox{for $ n \le n_0 $ , } \end{array } \right .\ ] ] it is well known ( e.g. , see @xcite ) , and easy to check , that the recurrence solves to @xmath314 , for every fixed @xmath52 , with an appropriate sufficiently large choice of @xmath5 as a function of @xmath315 and @xmath26 , and with an appropriate choice of @xmath307 .
this concludes the proof of theorem [ t : const - r ] .
now we consider the case where the points of @xmath0 are not necessarily in @xmath53-general position .
as was mentioned in the introduction , we apply a general perturbation scheme of yap @xcite to the previous range - searching algorithm .
yap s scheme is applicable to an algorithm whose input is a sequence of real numbers ( in our case , the @xmath316 point coordinates plus the coefficients in the polynomials specifying the query range ) .
it is assumed that the algorithm makes decision steps by way of evaluating polynomials with rational coefficients taken from a finite set @xmath317 , where the input parameters are substituted for the variables .
the algorithm makes a 3-way branching depending on the sign of the evaluation .
the set @xmath317 does not depend on the input .
the input is considered degenerate if one of the signs in the tests is 0 .
yap s scheme provides a black box for evaluating the polynomials from @xmath317 that , whenever the actual value is @xmath27 , also supplies a nonzero sign , @xmath318 or @xmath319 , which the algorithm may use for the branching , instead of the zero sign .
thus , the algorithm never `` sees '' any degeneracy .
yap s method guarantees that these signs are consistent , i.e. , for every input , the branching done in this way corresponds to some infinitesimal perturbation of the input sequence , and so does the output of the algorithm ( in our case , the answer to a range - searching query ) . for us
, it is important that if the degrees of the polynomials in @xmath317 are bounded by a constant , the black box also operates in time bounded by a constant ( which is apparent from the explicit specification in @xcite ) .
thus , applying the perturbation scheme influences the running time only by a multiplicative constant .
it can be checked the range - searching algorithm presented above is of the required kind , with all branching steps based on the sign of suitable polynomials in the coordinates of the input points and in the coefficients of the polynomials in the query range , and the degrees of these polynomials are bounded by a constant . for producing the partitioning polynomial @xmath8 , we solve systems of linear equations , and thus the coefficients of @xmath8 are given by certain determinants obtained from cramer s rule . the computation of the polynomial partition and locating points in it is also based on the signs of suitable bounded - degree polynomials , as can be checked by inspecting the relevant algoritms , and similarly for intersecting a polynomial partition with the query range .
the key fact is that all computations in the algorithm are of constant - bounded depth each of the values ever computed is obtained from the input parameters by a constant number of arithmetic operations .
we also observe that when yap s scheme is applied , the algorithm never finds more than @xmath53 points in the exceptional set @xmath268 ( in any of the nodes of the partition tree ) . indeed ,
if @xmath320 input points lie in the zero set of a polynomial @xmath8 as in the algorithm , then a certain polynomial in the coordinates of these @xmath320 points vanishes ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 6.3 ) ) .
thus , assuming that the algorithm found @xmath320 points on @xmath12 , it could test the sign of this polynomial at such points , and the black box would return a nonzero sign , which would contradict the consistency of yap s scheme . after applying yap s scheme ,
the preprocessing cost , storage , and query time remain asymptotically the same as in theorem [ t : const - r ] ( but with larger constants of proportionality ) .
since the output of the algorithm corresponds to some infinitesimally perturbed version of the input ( point set and query range ) , we obtain a boundary - fuzzy answer for the original point set .
if the points of @xmath0 are not in @xmath53-general position , we perturb them infinitesimally using the general perturbation scheme of yap @xcite , so that the perturbed set is in @xmath53-general position
. then we construct the above data structure on the perturbed point set . by answering the query for this perturbed set
, we obtain a boundary - fuzzy answer for the original point set .
the preprocessing cost , storage , and query time remain asymptotically the same as in theorem [ t : const - r ] .
this concludes the proof of corollary [ c : fuzzy ] .
as mentioned in the introduction , if we construct an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial @xmath8 for an arbitrary point set @xmath0 , the exceptional set @xmath263 may be large , as is schematically indicated in fig .
[ f : semi2-patches ] ( left ) .
since @xmath268 is not partitioned by @xmath8 in any reasonable sense , it must be handled differently , as described below .
following the terminology in @xcite , we call a direction @xmath321 _ good _ for @xmath8 if , for every @xmath322 , the polynomial @xmath323 does not vanish identically ; that is , any line in direction @xmath324 intersects @xmath12 at finitely many points . as argued in ( * ? ? ? * and pp .
314315 ) , a random direction is good for @xmath8 with probability 1 . by choosing a good direction and rotating the coordinate system ,
we assume that the @xmath325-direction , referred to as the _ vertical _ direction , is good for @xmath8 . in order to deal with @xmath268 , we partition @xmath12 into finitely many pieces , called _ patches _ , in such a way that each of the patches is _ monotone _ in the vertical direction , meaning that every line parallel to the @xmath325-axis intersects it at most once .
this is illustrated , in the somewhat trivial 2-dimensional setting , in fig .
[ f : semi2-patches ] ( right ) : ( middle ) , there are five one - dimensional patches @xmath326 , plus four 0-dimensional patches .
then we treat each patch @xmath149 separately : we project the point set @xmath327 orthogonally to the coordinate hyperplane @xmath328 , and we preprocess the projected set , denoted @xmath329 , for range searching with suitable ranges .
these ranges are projections of ranges of the form @xmath330 , where @xmath331 is one of the original ranges . in fig .
[ f : semi2-patches ] ( right ) , ( middle ) , the patch @xmath332 is drawn thick , a range @xmath59 is depicted as a gray disk , and the projection @xmath333 of @xmath334 is shown as a thick segment in @xmath335 .
the projected range @xmath336 is typically more complicated than the original range @xmath59 ( it involves more polynomials of larger degrees ) , but , crucially , it is only @xmath337-dimensional , and @xmath337-dimensional queries can be processed somewhat more efficiently than @xmath7-dimensional ones , which makes the whole scheme work .
we will discuss this in more detail in section [ sec : range2 ] below , but first we recall the notion of _ cylindrical algebraic decomposition _ ( cad , or also _ collins decomposition _ ) , which is a tool that allows us to decompose @xmath12 into monotone patches , and also to compute the projected ranges @xmath336 . given a finite set @xmath247 of @xmath7-variate polynomials , a _
cylindrical algebraic decomposition adapted to @xmath244 _ is a way of decomposing @xmath2 into a finite collection of relatively open _ cells _ , which have a simple shape ( in a suitable sense ) , and which refine the arrangement @xmath245 .
we refer , e.g. , to ( * ? ? ?
* chap . 5.12 ) for the definition and construction of the `` standard '' cad . here
we will use a simplified variant , which can be regarded as the `` first stage '' of the standard cad , and which is captured by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 5.14 , algorithm 12.1 ) .
we also refer to ( * ? ? ?
* appendix a ) for a concise treatment , which is perhaps more accessible at first encounter . let @xmath244 be as above . to obtain the first - stage cad for @xmath8 ,
one constructs a suitable collection @xmath338 of polynomials in the variables @xmath339 ( denoted by @xmath340 in @xcite ) . roughly speaking ,
the zero sets of the polynomials in @xmath341 , viewed as subsets of the coordinate hyperplane @xmath335 ( which is identified with @xmath342 ) , contain the projection onto @xmath335 of all intersections @xmath343 , @xmath344 , as well as the projection of the loci in @xmath345 where @xmath345 has a vertical tangent hyperplane , or a singularity of some kind .
the actual construction of @xmath341 is somewhat more complicated , and we refer to the aforementioned references for more details . having constructed @xmath341 , the first - stage cad is obtained as the arrangement @xmath346 in @xmath2 , where the polynomials in @xmath341 are now considered as @xmath7-variate polynomials ( in which the variable @xmath325 is not present ) . in geometric terms , we erect a `` vertical wall '' in @xmath2 over each zero set within @xmath335 of a @xmath337-variate polynomial from @xmath341 , and the cad is the arrangement of these vertical walls plus the zero sets of @xmath347 .
the first - stage cad is illustrated in fig .
[ f : semi2-cad ] , for the same ( single ) polynomial as in fig .
[ f : semi2-patches ] ( left ) . in our algorithm
, we are interested in the cells of the cad that are contained in some of the sero sets @xmath345 ; these are going to be the monotone patches alluded to above .
we note that using the first - stage cad for the purpose of decomposing @xmath12 into monotone patches seems somewhat wasteful .
for example , the number of patches in fig .
[ f : semi2-patches ] is considerably smaller than the number of patches in the cad in fig .
[ f : semi2-cad ] .
but the cad is simple and well known , and ( as will follow from the analysis in section [ sec : range2 ] ) possible improvements in the number of patches ( e.g. using the vertical - decomposition technique @xcite ) do not seem to influence our asymptotic bounds on the performance of the resulting range - searching data structure .
the following lemma summarizes the properties of the first - stage cad that we will need ; we refer to ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 5.14 , algorithm 12.1 ) for a proof .
[ l : cad ] given a set @xmath348 $ ] of polynomials , each of degree at most @xmath46 , there is a set @xmath338 of @xmath349 polynomials in @xmath350 $ ] , each of degree @xmath351 , which can be computed in time @xmath352 , such that the first - stage cad defined by these polynomials , i.e. , the arrangement @xmath346 in @xmath2 , has the following properties : 1 .
( `` cylindrical '' cells ) for each cell @xmath353 of @xmath346 , there exists a unique cell @xmath354 of the @xmath337-dimensional arrangement @xmath355 in @xmath335 , such that one of the following possibilities occur : 1 .
@xmath356 , where @xmath357 is a continuous semialgebraic function ( that is , @xmath353 is the graph of @xmath358 over @xmath354 ) .
@xmath359 , where each @xmath360 , @xmath361 , is either a continuous semialgebraic real - valued function on @xmath354 , or the constant function @xmath362 , or the constant function @xmath363 , and @xmath364 for all @xmath365 ( that is , @xmath353 is a portion of the `` cylinder '' @xmath366 between two consecutive graphs ) .
2 . ( refinement property ) if @xmath367 , then @xmath368 , and thus each cell of @xmath346 is fully contained in some cell of @xmath369 . returning to the problem of decomposing the zero set of the partitioning polynomial @xmath8 into monotone patches ,
we construct the first - stage cad for @xmath286 , and the patches are the cells of @xmath346 contained in @xmath12 .
if the @xmath325-direction is good for @xmath8 , then every cell of @xmath346 lying in @xmath12 is of type ( a ) , and so if any cell of type ( b ) lies in @xmath12 , we choose another random direction and construct the first - stage cad in that direction . putting everything together and using theorem [ t : make - arrg ] to bound the complexity of @xmath346 , we obtain the following lemma . [
l : patches ] let @xmath8 be a @xmath7-variate polynomial of degree @xmath46 , and let us assume that the @xmath325-direction is good for @xmath8 .
then @xmath12 can be decomposed , in @xmath370 time , into @xmath371 monotone patches , and each patch can be represented semialgebraically by @xmath370 polynomials of degree @xmath372 .
the first - stage cad can also be used to compute the projection of the intersection of a range in @xmath18 with a monotone patch of @xmath8 .
essentially , this is done by forming the arrangement of @xmath8 and the polynomials defining @xmath59 , and by collecting the monotone patches in this arrangement that are contained in @xmath12 ; see the full version @xcite for more details .
[ l : project ] let @xmath373 be the decomposition of the zero set of a @xmath7-variate polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath46 into monotone patches , as described in lemma [ l : patches ] , and let @xmath59 be a semialgebraic set in @xmath18 , with @xmath374 . for every patch @xmath375 , the projection of @xmath376 in the @xmath325-direction can be represented as a member of @xmath377 , i.e. , by a boolean combination of at most @xmath378 polynomial inequalities in @xmath337 variables , each of degree at most @xmath379 , where @xmath380 and @xmath381 .
the representation can be computed in @xmath382 time .
the task of computing @xmath336 , the projection of @xmath330 , is similar to the operation ( a2 ) discussed in section [ sec : cross ] . in more abstract terms
, it can also be viewed as a quantifier elimination task : we can represent @xmath383 by a quantifier - free formula @xmath384 ( a boolean combination of polynomial inequalities ) ; then @xmath336 is represented by @xmath385 , and by eliminating @xmath386 we obtain a quantifier - free formula describing @xmath336 .
more concretely , we use a procedure based on the first - stage cad ( lemma [ l : cad ] ) and the arrangement construction ( theorem [ t : make - arrg ] ) . by definition
, @xmath59 is a boolean combination of inequalities of the form @xmath387 , where @xmath279 are @xmath7-variate polynomials , each of degree at most @xmath275 .
we set @xmath388 , we compute the set @xmath389 of @xmath337-variate polynomials as in lemma [ l : cad ] , and the first - stage cad is then computed as the @xmath7-dimensional arrangement @xmath390 according to theorem [ t : make - arrg ] .
since by lemma [ l : cad](ii ) , @xmath390 refines @xmath391 ( the first - stage cad from the preprocessing phase ) , each patch @xmath392 is decomposed into subpatches .
since the sign of each @xmath393 is constant on each cell of @xmath394 , and thus on each cell of @xmath390 , @xmath330 is a disjoint union of subpatches .
the projections of these subpatches into @xmath335 are cells of @xmath395 , and thus we obtain , in time @xmath382 , a representation of @xmath336 as a member of @xmath377 by theorem [ t : make - arrg ] , where @xmath380 and @xmath396 .
[ sec : range2 ] we now describe our second data structure for @xmath269-range searching . compared to the first data structure from section [ sec : range1 ] , this one works on arbitrary point sets , without the @xmath53-general position assumption , or , alternatively , without the fuzzy boundary constraint on the output , and has slightly better performance bounds .
the data structure is built recursively , and this time the recursion involves both @xmath1 and @xmath7 .
let @xmath0 be a set of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 , and let @xmath20 and @xmath19 be parameters ( not assumed to be constant ) .
the data structure for @xmath18-range searching on @xmath0 is obtained by constructing a partition tree @xmath300 on @xmath0 recursively , as above , except that now the fan - out of each node is larger ( and non - constant ) , and each node also stores an auxiliary data structure for handling the respective exceptional part . we need to set two parameters : @xmath397 and @xmath398 .
neither of them is a constant in general ; in particular , @xmath5 is typically going to be a tiny power of @xmath1 .
the specific values of these parameters will be specified later , when we analyze the query time .
we also note that there is yet another parameter in theorem [ t : large - r ] , namely , the arbitrarily small constant @xmath52 entering the preprocessing time bound .
however , @xmath26 enters the construction solely by the requirement that @xmath5 should be chosen smaller than @xmath399 , for a sufficiently large constant @xmath205 .
it will become apparent later in the analysis that @xmath400 can be assumed , provided that some other parameters are taken sufficiently large ; we will point this out at suitable moments . when constructing the partition tree @xmath300 on an @xmath1-point set @xmath0 , we distinguish two cases . for @xmath401 ,
@xmath300 consists of a single leaf storing all points of @xmath0 . for @xmath402
, we construct an @xmath5-partitioning polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath235 , the partition @xmath261 of @xmath2 induced by @xmath8 , and the partition of @xmath0 into the exceptional part @xmath268 and regular parts @xmath403 , where @xmath259 . set @xmath404 and @xmath405 , for @xmath265 . the root of @xmath300 stores @xmath8 , @xmath261 , and the total weight @xmath305 of each regular part @xmath306 of @xmath0 , as before . still in the same way as before , we recursively preprocess each regular part @xmath306 for @xmath18-range searching ( or stop if @xmath406 ) , and attach the resulting data structure to the root as a respective subtree .
a new feature of the second data structure is that we also preprocess the exceptional set @xmath268 into an auxiliary data structure , which is stored at the root .
here we recurse on the dimension , exploiting the fact that @xmath268 lies on the algebraic variety @xmath12 of dimension at most @xmath407 .
we choose a random direction @xmath324 and rotate the coordinate system so that @xmath324 becomes the direction of the @xmath325-axis .
we construct the first - stage cad adapted to @xmath408 , according to lemma [ l : cad ] and theorem [ t : make - arrg ] .
we check whether all the patches are @xmath325-monotone , i.e. , of type ( a ) in lemma
[ l : cad](i ) ; if it is not the case , we discard the cad and repeat the construction , with a different random direction .
this yields a decomposition of @xmath12 into a set @xmath409 of @xmath371 monotone patches , and the running time is @xmath370 with high probability .
next , we distribute the points of @xmath268 among the patches : for each patch @xmath392 , let @xmath329 denote the projection of @xmath410 onto the coordinate hyperplane @xmath411 .
we preprocess each set @xmath329 for @xmath377-range searching . here
@xmath381 is the number of polynomials defining a range and @xmath412 is their maximum degree ; the constants hidden in the @xmath413 notation are the same as in lemma [
l : project ] . for simplicity
, we treat all patches as being @xmath337-dimensional ( although some may be of lower dimension ) ; this does not influence the worst - case performance analysis .
the preprocessing of the sets @xmath329 is done recursively , using an @xmath414-partitioning polynomial in @xmath342 , for a suitable value of @xmath414 .
the exceptional set at each node of the resulting `` @xmath337-dimensional '' tree is handled in a similar manner , constructing an auxiliary data structure in @xmath415 dimensions , based on a first - stage cad , and storing it at the corresponding node .
the recursion on @xmath7 bottoms out at dimension @xmath160 , where the structure is simply a standard binary search tree over the resulting set of points on the @xmath416-axis .
we remark that the treatment of the top level of recursion on the dimension will be somewhat different from that of deeper levels , in terms of both the choice of parameters and the analysis ; see below for details .
this completes the description of the data structure , except for the choice of @xmath5 and @xmath307 , which will be provided later as we analyze the performance of the algorithm .
let us assume that , for a given @xmath0 , the data structure for @xmath269-range searching , as described above , has been constructed , and consider a query range @xmath417 .
the query is answered in the same way as before , by visiting the nodes of the partition tree @xmath300 in a top - down manner , except that , at each node that we visit , we also query with @xmath59 the auxiliary data structure constructed on the exceptional set @xmath268 for that node .
specifically , for each patch @xmath149 of the corresponding collection @xmath409 , we compute @xmath418 , the weight of @xmath419 . if @xmath420 then @xmath421 , and if @xmath422 then @xmath418 is the total weight of @xmath327 .
otherwise , i.e. , if @xmath59 crosses @xmath149 , then @xmath418 is the same as the weight of @xmath423 , where @xmath336 is the @xmath325-projection of @xmath330 , because @xmath149 is @xmath325-monotone . by lemma [
l : project ] , @xmath424 and can be constructed in @xmath382 time .
we can find the weight of @xmath425 by querying the auxiliary data structure for @xmath329 with @xmath336 .
we then add @xmath418 to the global count maintained by the query procedure .
this completes the description of the query procedure .
the analysis of the storage requirement and preprocessing time is straightforward , and will be provided later .
we begin with the more intricate analysis of the query time .
for now we assume that @xmath307 and @xmath5 have been fixed ; the analysis will later specify their values .
a straightforward analysis shows that the size of the data structure is linear and that it can be constructed in time @xmath65 , for any constant @xmath426 , by choosing @xmath5 sufficiently large , so we focus on analyzing the query time .
let @xmath427 denote the maximum overall query time for @xmath269-range searching on a set of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 .
for @xmath428 and @xmath429 , @xmath430 . for @xmath431 and @xmath432 , @xmath433 because any range in @xmath434 is the union of at most @xmath435 intervals .
finally , for @xmath436 and @xmath432 , an analysis similar to the one in section [ sec : range1 ] gives the following recurrence for @xmath427 : @xmath437 @xmath438 where @xmath293 , @xmath277 is a constant depending on @xmath7 , @xmath439 , and both @xmath440 and @xmath441 are bounded by @xmath442 with @xmath235 and @xmath443 .
( these are rather crude estimates , but we prefer simplicity . ) the leading term of the recurrence relies on the crossing - number bound given in lemma [ l : cr ] . in order to apply that lemma , we need that @xmath444 , which will be ensured by the choice of @xmath5 given below .
the second term corresponds to querying the auxiliary data structures for the exceptional set @xmath268 .
the last term covers the time spent in computing the cells of the polynomial partition crossed by the query range @xmath59 and for computing the projections @xmath336 for every @xmath445 ; here we assume that the choice of @xmath5 will be such that @xmath446 .
ultimately , we want to derive that if @xmath298 are constants , the recurrence ( [ eq : qtime ] ) implies , with a suitable choice of @xmath5 and @xmath307 at each stage , @xmath447 where @xmath448 is a constant depending on @xmath449 , and @xmath19 . however , as was already mentioned , even if @xmath298 are constants initially , later in the recursion they are chosen as tiny powers of @xmath1 , and this makes it hard to obtain a direct inductive proof of ( [ qt : good ] ) .
instead , we proceed in two stages .
first , in lemma [ l : weakerq ] below we derive , without assuming @xmath298 to be constants , a weaker bound for @xmath427 , for which the induction is easier .
then we obtain the stronger bound ( [ qt : good ] ) for constant values of @xmath298 by using the weaker bound for the @xmath337-dimensional queries on the exceptional parts , i.e. , for the second term in the recurrence ( [ eq : qtime ] ) .
[ l : weakerq ] for every @xmath450 there exists @xmath451 such that , with a suitable choice of @xmath5 and @xmath307 , @xmath452 for all @xmath453 ( with @xmath454 , say ) .
\(i ) this lemma may look similar to our first result on @xmath18-range searching , theorem [ t : const - r ] , but there are two key differences the lemma works for arbitrary point sets , with no general position assumption , and @xmath20 and @xmath19 are not assumed to be constants .
\(ii ) since query time @xmath55 is trivial to achieve , we may assume @xmath455 , for otherwise , the bound ( [ qt : bad ] ) in the lemma exceeds @xmath1 .
the case @xmath431 is trivial because @xmath456 clearly implies ( [ qt : bad ] ) , assuming that @xmath457 and that @xmath1 is sufficiently large so that @xmath458 .
we assume that ( [ qt : bad ] ) holds up to dimension @xmath407 ( for all @xmath450 , @xmath20 , @xmath19 , and @xmath1 ) , and we establish it for dimension @xmath7 by induction on @xmath1 .
we consider @xmath451 yet unspecified but sufficiently large ; from the proof below one can obtain an explicit lower bound that @xmath451 should satisfy .
we set @xmath459 this value of @xmath307 is roughly the threshold where the bound ( [ qt : bad ] ) becomes smaller than @xmath1 .
since we assume @xmath460 , our choice of @xmath5 satisfies the assumptions @xmath444 and @xmath446 , as needed in ( [ eq : qtime ] ) . in the inductive step , for @xmath428 ,
@xmath461 so we assume that @xmath432 and that the bound ( [ qt : bad ] ) holds for all @xmath462 . using the induction hypothesis , i.e. , plugging ( [ qt : bad ] ) into the recurrence ( [ eq : qtime ] ) , we obtain @xmath463 by the choice of @xmath5 , the first term of the right - hand side of ( [ eq : induct ] ) can be bounded by @xmath464 which is half of the bound we are aiming for .
next , we bound the second term .
we use the estimates @xmath465 , @xmath466 , and @xmath467 .
then @xmath468 we choose @xmath469 where @xmath470 ; i.e. , we choose @xmath471 . since @xmath472 and @xmath473 , the fraction in ( [ eq : q - aux ] ) can be bounded by @xmath474 because @xmath454 . finally , recall that @xmath293 , so our choice of @xmath451 ( again , choosing @xmath475 sufficiently large ) ensures that @xmath476 .
hence , the right hand side in ( [ eq : induct ] ) is bounded by @xmath477 as desired .
this establishes the induction step and thereby completes the proof of the lemma .
now we want to obtain the improved bound ( [ qt : good ] ) , i.e. , @xmath478 , with @xmath479 , assuming that @xmath298 are constants and @xmath480 . to this end , in the top - level ( @xmath7-dimensional ) partition tree , we set @xmath481 , where @xmath482 is a suitable small constant to be specified later
. then we use the result of lemma [ l : weakerq ] with @xmath483 for processing the @xmath337-dimensional queries on the sets @xmath329 .
thus , in the forthcoming proof , we do induction only on @xmath1 , while @xmath7 is fixed throughout .
we choose @xmath397 sufficiently large ( we will specify this more precisely later on ) , and we assume that @xmath402 and that the desired bound ( [ qt : good ] ) holds for all @xmath462 . in the inductive step we estimate , using the recurrence ( [ eq : qtime ] ) , the induction hypothesis , and the bound in ( [ qt : bad ] ) , @xmath484 the first term simplifies to @xmath485 .
thus , if we choose @xmath67 depending on @xmath486 ( which is a small positive constant still to be determined ) so that @xmath487 , then the first term will be at most half of the target value @xmath488 . thus , it suffices to set @xmath486 so that the remaining two terms are negligible compared to this value . for the @xmath489 term , any @xmath490 will do .
the second term can be bounded , as in the proof of lemma [ l : weakerq ] , by @xmath491 thus , with @xmath492 , the term is at most @xmath493 . again
, this establishes the induction step and concludes the proof of the final bound for the query time .
we remark that our choice of @xmath486 requires us to choose @xmath494 making its dependence on @xmath7 super - exponential .
first we derive a weaker bound for @xmath427 without assuming @xmath298 to be constants .
namely , we prove that for every constant @xmath450 there exists a constant @xmath451 such that , with a suitable choice of @xmath5 and @xmath307 , @xmath452 for all @xmath453 ( with @xmath454 , say ) .
we can assume that @xmath495 because otherwise the query time is trivially @xmath55 .
we choose @xmath473 , which ensures that @xmath496 .
next , we derive the stronger bound ( [ qt : good ] ) for constant values of @xmath298 by using this weaker bound for the @xmath337-dimensional queries on the projected exceptional parts , i.e. , for the second term in the recurrence ( [ eq : qtime ] ) . in this stage , we choose @xmath497 for a sufficiently small constant @xmath498 .
our choice of @xmath486 and @xmath451 implies that @xmath499 .
additional details can be found in the full version @xcite .
let @xmath500 denote the size of the data structure on @xmath1 points in @xmath2 for @xmath269-range searching , with the settings of @xmath5 and @xmath307 as described above .
for @xmath501 we have @xmath502 . for larger values of @xmath1 ,
the space occupied by the root of the partition tree , not counting the auxiliary data structure for the exceptional part @xmath268 , is bounded by @xmath489 , where @xmath293 .
furthermore , since @xmath500 is at least linear in @xmath1 , the total size of the auxiliary data structure constructed on @xmath268 is @xmath503 , where @xmath404 .
we thus obtain the following recurrence for @xmath500 : @xmath504 for @xmath505 , and @xmath502 for @xmath401 . using @xmath506 , @xmath507 , and @xmath508 , for both types of choices of @xmath5
, the recurrence easily leads to @xmath509 where the constant of proportionality depends on @xmath7 .
it remains to estimate the preprocessing time ; here , finally , the parameter @xmath52 in theorem [ t : large - r ] comes into play .
let @xmath510 be a constant such that @xmath511 ( at all stages of the algorithm ) .
as was remarked in the preceding analysis of the query time , we can make @xmath510 arbitrarily small , by adjusting various constants ( and , generally speaking and as already remarked above , the smaller @xmath510 , the worse constant @xmath448 we obtain in the query time bound ) .
let @xmath512 denote the maximum preprocessing time of our data structure for @xmath18-range searching on @xmath1 points , with @xmath513 a constant as above . using the operation ( a1 ) of section [ sec : cross ]
, we spend @xmath292 time to compute @xmath514 and the partition of @xmath0 into the exceptional part and the regular parts , and we spend additional @xmath292 time to compute @xmath409 and @xmath329 for every @xmath515 , where @xmath293 . the total time spent in constructing the secondary data structures for all patches of @xmath409
is bounded by @xmath516 .
hence , we obtain the recurrence @xmath517 for @xmath402 , and @xmath518 for @xmath401 . using the properties @xmath506 and @xmath507
, a straightforward calculation shows that @xmath519 where the constant of proportionality depends on @xmath7 .
hence , by choosing @xmath520 , the preprocessing time is @xmath65 .
this concludes the proof of theorem [ t : large - r ] .
this concludes the proof of theorem [ t : large - r ] .
we conclude this paper by mentioning a few open problems .
\(i ) a very interesting and challenging problem is , in our opinion , the fast - query case of range searching with constant - complexity semialgebraic sets , where the goal is to answer a query in @xmath521 time using roughly @xmath522 space .
there are actually two , apparently distinct , issues .
the standard approach to fast - query searching is to parameterize the ranges in @xmath13 by points in a space of a suitable dimension , say @xmath33 ; then the @xmath1 points of @xmath0 correspond to @xmath1 algebraic surfaces in this @xmath33-dimensional `` parameter space '' , and a query is answered by locating the point corresponding to the query range in the arrangement of these surfaces .
first , the arrangement has @xmath523 combinatorial complexity , and one would expect to be able to locate points in it in polylogarithmic time with storage about @xmath524 .
however , such a method is known only up to dimension @xmath525 , and in higher dimension , one again gets stuck at the arrangement decomposition problem , which was the bottleneck in the previously known solution of @xcite for the low - storage variant , as was mentioned in the introduction .
it would be nice to use polynomial partitions to obtain a better point location data structure for such arrangements , but unfortunately , so far all of our attempts in this direction have failed .
the second issue is , whether the point location approach just sketched is actually optimal .
this question is exhibited nicely already in the simple instance of range searching with disks in the plane .
the best known solution that guarantees logarithmic query time uses point location in @xmath526 and requires storage roughly @xmath527 , but it is conceivable that roughly quadratic storage might suffice .
\(ii ) our range - searching data structure for arbitrary point sets the one with large fan - out is so complex and has a rather high exponent in the polylogarithmic factor , because we have difficulty with handling highly degenerate point sets , where many points lie on low - degree algebraic surfaces .
this issue appears even more strongly in combinatorial applications , and in that setting it has been dealt with only in rather specific cases ( e.g. , in dimension 3 ) ; see @xcite for initial studies .
it would be nice to find a construction of suitable `` multilevel polynomial partitions '' that would cater to such highly degenerate input sets , as touched upon in @xcite .
\(iii ) another open problem , related to the construction of polynomial partitions , is the fast evaluation of a multivariate polynomial at many points , as briefly discussed at the end of section [ sec : algo ] .
p. k. agarwal and j. erickson , geometric range searching and its relatives , in : _ advances in discrete and computational geometry _ ( b. chazelle , j. e. goodman and r. pollack , eds . ) , ams press , providence , ri , 1998 , pp .
156 . p.
k. agarwal , j. matouek , m. sharir , on range searching with semialgebraic sets ii , in arxiv .
s. barone and s. basu , refined bounds on the number of connected components of sign conditions on a variety , _ discrete comput .
_ 47 ( 2012 ) , 577597 .
s. basu , r. pollack , and m .- f .
roy , on the number of cells defined by a family of polynomials on a variety , _ mathematika _ 43 ( 1996 ) , 120126 .
b. chazelle , h. edelsbrunner , l. j. guibas , and m. sharir , a singly exponential stratification scheme for real semi - algebraic varieties and its applications , _ theoret .
_ , 84 ( 1991 ) , 77105 . also in _ proc
16th int . colloq . on automata ,
languages and programming _ ( 1989 ) , pp .
179193 .
elekes , h. kaplan and m. sharir , on lines , joints , and incidences in three dimensions , _ j. combinat .
theory , ser .
a _ 118 ( 2011 ) , 962977 .
l. guth and n. h. katz , algebraic methods in discrete analogs of the kakeya problem , _ advances math . _
225 ( 2010 ) , 28282839 .
l. guth and n. h. katz , on the erds distinct distances problem in the plane , in arxiv:1011.4105 .
h. kaplan , j. matouek and m. sharir , simple proofs of classical theorems in discrete geometry via the guth
katz polynomial partitioning technique , _ discrete comput .
geom . _ 48 ( 2012 ) , 499517 .
h. kaplan , j. matouek , z. safernov and m. sharir , unit distances in three dimensions , _ combinat .
_ 21 ( 2012 ) , 597610
. k. kedlaya and ch .
umans , fast modular composition in any characteristic , _ proc .
49th annu .
ieee sympos .
sci . _ ( 2008 ) , 146155 .
knauer , h. r. tiwari and d. werner , on the computational complexity of ham - sandwich cuts , helly sets , and related problems , _ proc .
28th annu .
aspects comput .
( 2011 ) , 649660 .
m. sharir and h. shaul , semi - algebraic range reporting and emptiness searching with applications , _ siam j. comput .
_ 40 ( 2011 ) , 10451074
. j. solymosi and t. tao , an incidence theorem in higher dimensions , _ discrete comput .
_ 48 ( 2012 ) , 255280 .
a. h. stone and j. w. tukey , generalized sandwich theorems , _ duke math
. j. _ 9 ( 1942 ) , 356359 . | let @xmath0 be a set of @xmath1 points in @xmath2 .
we present a linear - size data structure for answering range queries on @xmath0 with constant - complexity semialgebraic sets as ranges , in time close to @xmath3 .
it essentially matches the performance of similar structures for simplex range searching , and , for @xmath4 , significantly improves earlier solutions by the first two authors obtained in 1994 .
this almost settles a long - standing open problem in range searching .
the data structure is based on the polynomial - partitioning technique of guth and katz [ arxiv:1011.4105 ] , which shows that for a parameter @xmath5 , @xmath6 , there exists a @xmath7-variate polynomial @xmath8 of degree @xmath9 such that each connected component of @xmath10 contains at most @xmath11 points of @xmath0 , where @xmath12 is the zero set of @xmath8 .
we present an efficient randomized algorithm for computing such a polynomial partition , which is of independent interest and is likely to have additional applications . |
type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) , characterized by no @xmath1 but strong si lines in the spectra at the maximum brightness , are brighter than most of sne classified into the other types and exhibit uniform light curves .
thus they are used as a standard candle to measure distances to remote galaxies .
a plausible explosion model for sne ia is the accreting white dwarf ( wd ) model , in which a white dwarf in a binary system accretes material from the companion star , increases its mass , usually up to the chandrasekhar mass limit ( @xmath2 ) , and then explodes ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
. there have been significant progresses in the accreting wd model since @xcite introduced the stellar wind from the wd while it accretes materials from the companion .
their model succeeded in sustaining a stable mass transfer in the progenitor systems of sne ia . according to their model
, there are two main evolutionary paths leading to sne ia , the super soft x - ray source ( sss ) channel and the symbiotic channel @xcite .
accordingly their model predicts which companion stars lead to sne ia . the above evolutionary scenario for sne ia has not been confirmed by observations , which will require the identification of the companion star that should remain in the vicinity of the explosion site .
@xcite argued that their group identified a g2iv star as the companion of tycho brahe s supernova remnant ( snr ) by measuring the velocities and distances of stars in the vicinity of the center of the snr .
they concluded that this g2iv star was moving much faster than the other neighbor stars and that the distance to this star seemed consistent with the distance to tycho s snr .
although @xcite has argued that the observed velocity of tycho g might correspond to the velocity of stars belonging to the thick disk population , the expected stellar mass in thick disk stars within the cone with 2.87 arcsec radius ( which corresponds to the angular distance from the center of tycho s snr to the tycho g star ) , at 3 kpc from earth , is only 2 @xmath3 , which makes the thick disk star alternative very unlikely . for this estimate
we use the density in the vicinity of tycho s snr @xcite . although the coincidence of the kinematic characteristics of tycho g with its being at the position and distance of the snr appears significant , confirmation by other means would nonetheless be very useful . in this paper
we propose a direct method to prove that the companion star is located inside the sn ejecta .
a hint was dropped by observations for a star called s - m star discovered by @xcite near a type ia snr 1006 .
@xcite proved that the s - m star was not the companion of this supernova by investigating features of fe ii absorption lines in the ultraviolet ( uv ) spectrum .
very broad wings were observed in both blue and red sides of the absorption lines .
the line width was a few thousand km / s much larger than the thermal velocity of stellar atmosphere , which is thought to be @xmath410 km / s .
the broad wings are likely to be formed by fe ii in the ejecta of snr 1006 ; photons in the blue wing are absorbed by the matter ejected toward us , and those in the red wing away from us .
thus it was proved that the s - m star is located behind the snr 1006 ejecta . when a star is inside the ejecta of sne ia , photons emitted from the star are absorbed only by the ejecta moving toward us .
hence the broad wing must be present only in the blue side .
the absorption line with only blue wing enables us to identify companion stars of sne ia .
@xcite used the uv range to observe the s - m star with the faint object spectrograph on the hubble space telescope .
however , in addition to difficulties in uv observations from the ground , companion stars on the evolutionary paths suggested by the above mentioned scenario @xcite may not be bright in the uv range
. then we will focus on absorption lines in the visible range .
furthermore the corresponding transitions need to be from the ground state because most fe ions in the ejecta are expected to be in the ground state .
thus only fe i can produce such absorption lines in sne ia ejecta . in this paper , we estimate the amount of fe i in the ejecta of tycho s snr by taking account of collisional processes in non - equilibrium and ionizations by photons emitted from the shocked ejecta , and calculate spectra of a star located at the center of a snr and discuss whether we can identify the feature of fe i absorption lines in the spectrum of the companion star .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ tbl : ew ] even when we find a star that exhibits the absorption feature discussed in this paper , there is a chance that a star other than the companion star happens to be inside the ejecta .
a star existing in the vicinity of a sn ia gets a fraction of the explosion energy and is accelerated .
if the companion star similar to tycho g star with the mass of @xmath5 1.2 @xmath6 and the radius of @xmath7 2 @xmath8 is located at the distance of @xmath9 5.5 @xmath8 from the progenitor , the size of the roche lobe is comparable to the size of the companion .
thus the star in this situation will get the maximum velocity after the explosion .
then the orbital velocity before the explosion is @xmath10 km / s . in a 3-d hydrodynamical simulation of sne ia by @xcite
, they obtain a plausible kick velocity @xmath11 km / s . therefore , including the orbital velocity , the velocity of the companion star becomes @xmath12 km / s . if the companion star has been moving away from the explosion site at that speed , the companion star is now at the distance of @xmath130.08 pc from the center .
the stellar mass density in the neighborhood of tycho s snr estimated from a model of the galaxy @xcite is less than 0.03 @xmath14 .
thus the expected stellar mass inside this volume is only @xmath15 .
therefore if we find a star showing absorption lines with broad blue wings in the spectrum , it is likely that the star is the companion star .
as a consequence , we have demonstrated that there exhibit very deep absorption lines with unique shapes in the spectrum of the companion star located at the center of a young snr such as tycho s snr .
there are , however , a few factors that might reduce or even erase these distinct absorption features . first , the number of fe i in the freely expanding ejecta is very sensitive to the number of ionizing photons emitted from the shocked ejecta .
an increase in the number of ionizing photons by a few factors might decrease the number of fe i by a few orders of magnitude or more .
since the main source of ionizing photons is o in the outer ejecta , the distributions of o and density in the outer ejecta need to be known precisely .
unfortunately , these regions in w7 have some problems to reproduce the observed optical spectra ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) . due to this uncertainty in the explosion model ,
it is not conclusive if the companion star of tycho s sn will exhibit unique fe i absorption features discussed in this paper .
nevertheless , it is true that every sn ia has a period during which the companion star has the distinct absorption features discussed above because the ejecta become cool enough to have plenty of fe i for a time after the optical brightening .
second , it is assumed in our calculations that ions in the shocked region are ionized to fe@xmath16 , si@xmath17 , o@xmath18 , c@xmath19 immediately after the shock passes following the procedure taken by @xcite .
since ions in lower ionization stages are a strong source of ionizing photons , ionization may be more advanced in real young snrs .
arnaud , m. rothenflug , r. 1985 , a&as , 60 , 425 branch , d. 1998 , , 36 , 17 colella , p. , woodward , p. 1984 , jcoph , 54 , 174 decourchelle , a. , et al .
2001 , a&as , 365 , l218 dehnen , w. , binney , j. , 1998 , mnras , 294 , 429 engstrom , l. , et al .
1992 , jphb , 25 , 2459 fuhrmann , k. 2005 , mnras , 359 , l35 hachisu , i. , kato , m. , nomoto , k. 1996 , apj , 470 , l97 hachisu , i. , kato , m. , nomoto , k. , umeda , h. 1999 , apj , 519 , 314 hachisu , i. , kato , m. , nomoto , k. 1999 , apj , 522 , 487 hamilton , a. , sarazin , c. 1984 , apj , 287 , 282 hamilton , a. , fesen , r. 1988 , apj , 327 , 178 itoh , h. , masai , k. , nomoto , k. 1988 , apj , 334 , 279 kato , t. 1976 , apjs , 30 , 397 reinecke , m. , hillebrandt , w. , & niemeyer , j. c. 2002 , , 391 , 1167 lotz , w. 1967 , apjs , 14 , 207l marietta , e. , burrows , a. , fryxell , b. 2000 , apjs , 128 , 615 mihalas , d. , 1978 , stellar atmospheres .
nomoto , k. 1982 , , 253 , 798 nomoto , k , thielemann , f. , yokoi , k. 1984 , apj , 286 , 644 ruiz - lapuente , p. , et al .
2004 , nature , 431 , 1069 schweizer , f. middleditch , j. 1980 , apj , 241 , 1039 sorokina , e. i. , et al .
2004 , astl , 30 , 737 spitzer , l. 1978 , physical processes in the interstellar medium .
tunklev , m. , et al .
1997 , phys , 55 , 707 verner , d. , et al .
1996 , apj , 465 , 487 vink , j. , et al .
2003 , apjl , 587 , l31 wang , l. , baade , d. , hflich , p. , wheeler , j. c. , kawabata , k. , & nomoto , k. 2004 , , 604 , l53 woosley , s. e. , & weaver , t. a. 1986 , lecture notes in physics , berlin springer verlag , 255 , 91 wu , c. , et al .
1993 , apj , 416 , 247 | we propose a method to identify the companion stars of type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) in young supernova remnants ( snrs ) by recognizing distinct features of absorption lines due to fe i appearing in the spectrum .
if a sufficient amount of fe i remains in the ejecta , fe i atoms moving toward us absorb photons by transitions from the ground state to imprint broad absorption lines exclusively with the blue - shifted components in the spectrum of the companion star . to investigate the time evolution of column depth of fe i in the ejecta
, we have performed hydrodynamical calculations for snrs expanding into the uniform ambient media , taking into account collisional ionizations , excitations , and photo - ionizations of heavy elements . as a result
, it is found that the companion star in tycho s snr will exhibit observable features in absorption lines due to fe i at @xmath0 nm and 385.9911 nm if a carbon deflagration sn model @xcite is taken .
however , these features may disappear by taking another model that emits a few times more intense ionizing photons from the shocked outer layers . to further explore the ionization states in the freely expanding ejecta
, we need a reliable model to describe the structure of the outer layers . |
group field theories ( gfts ) @xcite are quantum field theories on group manifolds , with the group chosen to be the local gauge group of spacetime in d dimensions , i.e. the lorentz group , or a suitable extension of it , for models aiming at a quantization of d - dimensional gravity .
they are characterized by a non - local pairing of field arguments in the interaction term , designed in such a way as to produce , in perturbative expansion , feynman diagrams with a combinatorial structure that are in 1 - 1 correspondence with d - dimensional simplicial complexes .
because of these basic properties , gfts can be understood as a generalization of matrix models @xcite for 2-dimensional quantum gravity , obtained in two steps : 1 ) by passing to generic tensors , instead of matrices , as fundamental variables , thus obtaining a generating functional for the sum over 3d simplicial complexes that was the essence of the dynamical triangulations approach to 3d quantum gravity@xcite ; 2 ) adding group structure defining extra geometric degrees of freedom .
the last step is what turns a generic tensor model into a proper field theory .
in fact , the first example of a gft was the group - theoretic generalization of 3d tensor models proposed by boulatov @xcite .
it was already at this initial stage , that group field theories allowed a direct contact between simplicial quantum gravity and what we now call spin foam models @xcite .
in fact the boulatov model , sharing the same combinatorics of tensor models and thus reproducing a 3d sum over triangulations , in perturbative expansion , produces weights for these triangulations given by the so - called ponzano - regge spin foam model , thanks to the additional su(2 ) group structure .
we now know that this is just one example of a very general result @xcite : any group field theory produces feynman amplitudes that can be re - expressed as spin foam models , and , conversely , any spin foam model for fixed 2-complex can be understood as the feynman amplitude for a given feynman diagram of a corresponding gft . in turn
, spin foam models @xcite have been a very active ( and growing ) area of quantum gravity research in the past ten years , for two main ( and related ) reasons .
first , one obtains a spin foam model when considering , once more , a discretization of continuum 1st order gravity , formulated as a constrained bf theory , on a simplicial complex , and quantizes it via path integral methods .
second , spin foams as 2-complexes with faces labelled by group representations arise naturally when considering the dynamics of the kinematical quantum states of geometry as identified by canonical loop quantum gravity @xcite ; indeed , from the lqg perspective , spin foams represents the histories of spin networks and are thus the crucial ingredient of any path integral or covariant formulation of the quantum gravity dynamics in lqg . from both the simplicial and canonical perspective ,
a sum over spin foams , weighted by appropriate amplitudes , is necessary to define in full the dynamics of the gravitational field : in simplicial quantum gravity because only such sum ( lacking a suitably defined refinement procedure ) can compensate the truncation of geometric degrees of freedom that the restriction to a given lattice imposes ; in lqg , because a complete path integral formulation of the dynamics needs , in general , i.e. except in the purely topological case or for very special choices of observables , a sum over all the histories between given spin network states . at present , group field theories are the only known tool to define uniquely such sum over spin foams , i.e. with fully specified weights , in a perturbative expansion of the gft partition function . in this property , lies the main reason of interest in gfts , from the lqg perspective . and indeed , up to now , group field theories have been mainly considered and used just as such : as a _
tool _ to define a sum over spin foams with prescribed weights , i.e. as an auxiliary formalism to define / construct spin foam models .
a different perspective is however possible , even if only tentatively or as a working hypothesis , at present , given the very limited understanding and control we have of the whole group field theory formalism .
this perspective has been advocated and described in more detail in @xcite , to which we refer .
+ group field theories can be understood as a 2nd quantized formulation of both loop quantum gravity and simplicial gravity , in which wave functions over the space of geometries are turned into classical fields first and then into operators .
in fact , the quanta of the gft field correspond to d - valent spin network vertices @xcite and , at the same time , to ( d-1)-simplices . since both loop quantum gravity and simplicial quantum gravity ( in its quantum regge calculus as well as in its dynamical triangulations formulation ) are meant to be themselves a quantization of what is already a classical field theory , i.e. general relativity , a 2nd quantization of the same provides a formalism very similar in spirit to what was ( somewhat improperly ) dubbed third quantizationof gravity @xcite .
this was a formal quantum field theory on superspace ( the space of all 3-geometries on , say , @xmath0 ) which would have canonical quantum gr corresponding to its quantum 1-particle sector , and would produce a sum over topologies in perturbative feynman expansion , obtained as interaction processes of quantum universes ( the particlesof this formalism ) .
clearly , the mathematical difficulties as well as those regarding the physical interpretation of the whole formalism are formidable , and consequently they prevented any substantial development . +
the group field theory formalism @xcite greatly improves the situation , both at the mathematical and physical level , by turning to a discrete and local picture of superspace , in which what is propagated , created and annihilated are local chunks of a ( d-1)-dimensional quantum space ( again , spin network vertices or ( d-1)-simplices ) .
one feature of 3rd quantization is retained , and even generalized , however : on the one hand these fundamental building blocks of quantum space can be combined at the kinematical level to represent , in principle , any spatial geometry and topology , and on the other hand their interactions still produce , in perturbative feynman expansion , quantum spacetimes of any topology . +
this step from a continuum to a discrete setting has another important consequence .
if the quantum gravity feynman diagrams in the 3rd quantized formalism were smooth manifolds , and the continuum path integral for quantum gravity on the given manifold represented , by construction , the feynman amplitude for each of them , in the discrete version of 3rd quantization provided by group field theories the feynman diagrams are given by combinatorial and un - embedded 2-complexes or , dually , by simplicial complexes , and the feynman amplitudes have the interpretation of discrete path integrals ( sum over discrete geometries ) over each simplicial complex .
+ this feature allows not only a better mathematical control on the quantities involved , but it also makes group field theories , at least in principle , a common framework for several approaches to quantum gravity , providing the basis for potential cross - fertilization and mutual enrichment . + as mentioned , each group field theory , in fact completely defines a possible dynamics for loop quantum gravity spin network states , thus proposing an explicit solution ( even if yet to be put to test ) for one outstanding challenge of the lqg programme . at the same time
, it does so by defining a sum over histories that includes the crucial ingredients of both main simplicial quantum gravity approaches . as in quantum regge calculus @xcite
, it defines the dynamics of a quantum and classical simplicial geometry in terms of a sum over discrete geometric data ( edge lengths , areas , etc , according to dimension ) for a given base simplicial complex .
in addition to this , it provides a possible way to encode all the continuum geometric degrees of freedom by a covariant procedure that is alternative to the infinite refinement procedure for fixed incidence matrix , that has proven to be problematic at the quantum level , in quantum regge calculus : a sum over inequivalent triangulations . in this
it obviously agrees with the dynamical triangulations ( dt ) approach @xcite ; in fact , freezing the discrete geometric data attached to each complex ( this can be done in various ways ) turns the perturbative expansion of gfts into a form very similar to the sum over triangulations weighted by a purely combinatorial factor that characterizes the dt approach ; such formulation , in its _ causal _ restriction ( corresponding to summing over a certain restricted class of lorentzian triangulations ) @xcite , has recently proven to be much more successful in recovering a continuum spacetime from the quantum theory . as a bonus , with respect to the dynamical triangulations approach ,
the gft approach permits a better control over the classical and quantum _ simplicial _ dynamics of geometry , which is here akin to the few - particlephysics in the usual qfts .
this stems from the possibility of a finer control over simplicial geometric variables , that puts gfts and their spin foam amplitudes in closer relation with lqg , regge calculus and other formulations of classical simplicial gravity .
this seems also to be confirmed by recent results on the spin foam / lqg lattice graviton , which match at least partially the results of simplicial gravity , in the regime where a connection between the two approaches can be made precise @xcite .
the links between group field theories and other approaches to quantum gravity are detailed in @xcite , to which we refer .
+ it should be clear , however , that much more remains to be understood about these links and that only further work can confirm or refute the idea that group field theories really represent in concrete terms a unifying framework for all of them , as we have been suggesting . as for the relationship with lqg , the open issues concern both the exact correspondence between gft boundary states and their hilbert space , in specific models , and that of usual su(2 ) lqg spin networks , as well as the relation between the gft transition amplitudes and the canonical lqg hamiltonian constraint , defining the quantum dynamics .
these issues will not concern us here .
the focus of our present work is instead on the relation between gfts and simplicial quantum gravity , and the aim is to make the correspondence between the two framework detailed and clear , with a precise matching between gft feynman amplitudes and simplicial quantum gravity sum over histories . in order to achieve this ,
we introduce and analyze in the present paper a new class of group field theories , characterized by feynman amplitudes which have , in any dimension and in any signature , _ exactly _ the form of a simplicial gravity path integral .
its amplitudes , that is , are expressed as a ( real ) measure part times a phase factor , with phase clearly identified with a simplicial gravity action . in 3 dimensions , this will mean obtaining a path integral for 3-dimensional simplicial gravity in first order formalism , corresponding to a 1st order regge calculus action plus higher order ( @xmath1-like ) corrections . in higher dimensions , we will obtain instead a path integral , augmented by a sum over triangulations of any topology , for what can be interpreted as topological bf theory with an additional orientation dependence , and , again , higher order ( quantum ) corrections to the action .
this work can be understood as the further development of the line of research on the issue of causality in spin foam quantum gravity and gft , and on the construction of a unified gft framework for loop quantum gravity , spin foam models , quantum regge calculus and dynamical triangulations , that started from an analysis of the issue of causality in spin foam models @xcite , continued with the development of a refined technique for the construction of causal spin foam models , based on the particle analogy which implicitly introduced additional variables into the usual spin foam formalism , in @xcite , with the explicit construction of causal spin foam models for pure gravity and gravity coupled to matter in 3d @xcite , and with the construction of a generalized gft formalism @xcite based on the techniques and variables introduced in @xcite .
the present gft construction is indeed , in a sense , a much improved and further developed version of the one in @xcite , in a sense to be detailed in the following . + we will detail both the motivation , the basic ideas and the results of our work in the next section . in section
iii we present the general definition of the new class of gfts , and the general structure of its feynman amplitudes .
section iv and v report instead the detailed form of the amplitudes of these models in 3 and 4 dimensions , in both riemannian and lorentzian cases , and a discussion of their properties .
we conclude with a summary of our results and an outlook on their relevance for further developments in this area .
we assume now that the above perspective on group field theory as a discrete quantum field theory ( 3rd quantized ) of spin networks or of simplicial geometry , and as a potential common unifying framework for different approaches to quantum gravity , is agreed upon , if tentatively only .
let us now focus on the following questions : what types of amplitudes we then expect or want the gft feynman diagrams to be assigned ?
that is , what properties and main features our spin foam amplitudes should have ?
how should they look like , if they are indeed feynman amplitudes for a field theory on a simplicial superspace ? from a path integral for a field theory on superspace , continuum or discrete , we expect to obtain a definition of causal transition amplitudes between quantum gravity states , i.e. the quantum gravity analogue of what , in ordinary field theory , is represented by expectation values in the vacuum state of time - ordered products of field operators . however , no time coordinate is allowed , in a fully background independent and diffeomorphism invariant theory of quantum gravity , to enter the definition of transition amplitudes , as it does through the minkowskian time when we define time - ordered 2-point functions in the usual qft . therefore , in quantum gravity , the difference between the various possible 2-point functionscan be characterized purely in terms of symmetry properties and of other formal features of them , independent of any spacetime coordinates .
let us look at some of these features .
for further discussion on this , see @xcite , and for a classic treatment of the issue of causality and different transition amplitudes in quantum gravity , within the covariant path integral approach , see @xcite
. consider the simplest case of a 4d spacetime of topology @xmath2 , with compact @xmath3 .
this spacetime has two boundaries , call them @xmath4 and @xmath5 , to which we associate a 3d spatial geometry @xmath6 and @xmath7 , respectively .
assume now that we can uniquely associate ( within a canonical quantum theory ) a state @xmath8 to the geometry @xmath6 , and @xmath9 to the geometry @xmath7 .
the basic idea underlying the time - lesscharacterization of the causal quantum gravity transition amplitudes @xmath10 is that , even if these can not correspond to any time - ordering , they do implement a time - less orderingor , better , a _ causal ordering_. this consists in the requirement that @xmath7 lies in the causal future of @xmath6 , which in turn can be formulated , when a canonical decomposition of the gravity variables is possible , as the requirement that the lapse function ( which in a suitable gauge is equivalent to a proper time ) between the two boundaries can only take positive values @xcite .
note that the formulation of this criterion does not require any use of coordinates .
notice also that the above has a direct analogue in the definition of different green functions for a relativistic particle @xcite , where it defines indeed the feynman propagator .
moreover , this criterion can be generalized to the situation in which no canonical decomposition is available , for example , keeping the same boundaries and boundary states , for spacetimes of non - trivial topology . in such cases
it can be formulated as the requirement that the amplitude is _ orientation dependent _ , i.e. that it turns into its complex conjugate if the spacetime orientation is reversed .
if the dynamics is defined by a quantum gravity path integral , in metric variables , all these requirements are automatically encoded in the definition of the configuration space as the space of all metrics up to diffeomorphisms and of the quantum amplitude as the exponential of @xmath11 times the einstein - hilbert action ( or some higher - derivatives extension ) , times a diffeo - invariant real measure : h_2h_1=_g h_1,h_2ge^is_eh(g ) .
[ pathintegral]indeed , this corresponds , in a canonical formulation to : h_2h_1= nn^i , [ pathintegralcan]with the integration range @xmath12 over the lapse function @xmath13 @xcite .
the above amplitude is _ complex _ , _ causal _
( @xmath7 is in the causal future of @xmath6 ) and _ orientation dependent _ ( it turns into its own complex conjugate under switch of spacetime orientation , as @xmath14 under this transformation , equivalent to switching positive to negative lapse ) .
moreover , it defines , at least formally , a _ green function _ of the hamiltonian constraint operator , the dynamical equation of motion of pure gravity , for trivial spacetime topology , not a solution of it , i.e. it satisfies : @xmath15 .
notice that the same definition for the quantum gravity path integral results in an orientation dependent transition amplitude also in the case of riemannian quantum gravity , i.e. the quantization of riemannian geometry , even though then the causality interpretation is not applicable to the same restriction on the lapse function . + a quick comparison with the usual ( say , free ) quantum field theory case , or , for that matter , with the relativistic particle case
, shows that these same properties are shared by the time - ordered product of field operators and by the usual feynman propagator . actually , in these simplified contexts , the above properties _ select uniquely _ the feynman propagator or time - ordered n - point function among the various qft n - point functions or particle propagators . in the formal 3rd quantized framework , as in usual qft , the path integral of the field theory itself provides , after field insertions , a definition of the causal transition amplitudes .
how this is realized in the 3rd quantized formalism is only apparent in perturbative expansion , and , once more , at a rather formal level , given the poor understanding of the formalism itself .
however , also in the gft case , we are at present lacking control of the theory beyond the perturbative regime .
therefore it is instructive to recall how the causal transition amplitudes are characterized in usual qft perturbative expansion . consider
then some time ordered product of field operators in the vacuum state ; one inserts the appropriate combination of fields in the path integral expression for the partition function of the field theory , and expands in powers of the coupling constant , obtaining the usual sum over feynman diagrams weighted by amplitudes obtained by gluing propagators with interaction vertices .
the choice of field insertion characterizes the boundary states and the original time ordering is reflected in the presence of the feynman propagator in each individual particle line of a feynman diagram .
this propagator , in position variables , can be expressed as a sum over histories for the single particle it refers to , i.e. by a path integral weighted by the usual relativistic particle action @xcite .
if one does the same for all the particles involved in a given feynman diagram , the whole feynman amplitude can be put in the form of a path integral for a discrete system of particles , weighted by the exponential of the classical action , and with a constraint on their histories in position space , representing the particle interactions .
the causality restriction enters , as we said , in the use of the feynman propagator , which results from restricting the proper time ( or lapse in canonical variables ) along each particle history to be positive , in turn giving a complex amplitude given by the exponential of @xmath11 times the particle action @xcite .
the restriction to positive proper times or lapses is also equivalent to a dependence of the amplitude on the orientation of the particle trajectories .
+ the same happens in the formal 3rd quantization setting for gravity @xcite : each feynman diagram , a discrete history of universe interactions , is weighted by an amplitude given by the path integral ( [ pathintegral ] ) , the exponential of the gravity action , i.e. the geometric action for the particle - universe for each line of propagation , plus appropriate joining conditions representing the interactions .
as we have discussed above , such path integral for gravity is a green function of the dynamical constraint equations ( as the feynman propagator for the klein - gordon equation ) , and it is causal and orientation dependent in the sense specified @xcite .
note also that the end result of combining the path integrals for gravity on trivial topology with the joining conditions for interactions is again a path integral for gravity with the same type of amplitude on a spacetime with non - trivial topology .
the analogy with particle dynamics and usual qfts is even clearer if one recalls @xcite that the einstein s equations define indeed the dynamics of a free particle moving in superspace . in a gft , in light of its proposed physical interpretation , we would expect a similar structure for the feynman amplitudes .
the discrete histories of possible interactions for the gft quanta are , as discussed , combinatorial 2-complexes dual to simplicial complexes , because the quanta themselves are identified with spin network vertices or ( d-1)-simplices , as said .
therefore , if the gft degrees of freedom and dynamics are to represent a quantum geometry and its evolution , we would expect the amplitudes associated to its discrete ( virtual ) histories , the gft feynman amplitudes , to have the form of a path integral for discrete gravity , i.e. an exponential of some classical discrete gravity action .
this way , they would have the sought for properties of causality / orientation dependence and complexity on top of making the relation with classical and quantum discrete gravity manifest . once more
, it is the _ complex nature _ of the feynman amplitudes and their having the form of an _ exponential of some simplicial gravity action _ , that would permit the interpretation of gfts as 3rd quantized theories of simplicial geometry and as providing a definition of discrete quantum gravity transition amplitudes . +
this expected and , we argue , _ needed _ general feature of gft models does not , by itself , select the _ specific form of the simplicial action _ that has to appear in the gft feynman amplitudes . on the contrary , because gfts are supposed to describe quantum gravity _ at all scales _
( unless the future development of the formalism will turn out to show some unavoidable breakdown or incompleteness of the same , beyond some energy or distance scale ) , one should , a priori , expect a very general formulation of classical simplicial gravity to describe the classical dynamics of the gft quanta .
this may correspond , for example , to some generalized action for regge calculus , with higher - order terms , e.g. higher powers of the curvature , appearing as the phase of our complex gft feynman amplitudes .
indeed , we will see how our new proposed gfts produce very general types of simplicial actions inside their _ complex _ feynman amplitudes , the regge action being just one contribution , although the dominant one in physically interesting limits .
this is _ not _ what happens in current gft models .
the feynman amplitudes / spin foam models of _ all _ current gfts are instead : real , a - causal and orientation independent , so that they do not reflect the orientation of the underlying simplicial complex nor allow for the identification of any ordering between the boundary states . in this sense
they define a - causal transition amplitudes .
this structure is due to an underlying @xmath16 symmetry of the spin foam amplitudes , first identified and interpreted in @xcite , which erases the orientation dependence of the same amplitudes at the level of each dual 2-cell or ( d-2)-simplex . still in @xcite , and in @xcite , it was shown how breaking this symmetry and restoring the orientation dependence would lead to feynman amplitudes with a much more direct relation with 1st order discrete gravity and with the expected exponential form .
+ usual spin foam models correspond , then , to a sort of symmetrized discrete path integralsfor gravity in 1st order form .
the continuum ( and 2nd order ) counterpart of such symmetrized discrete gravity path integral is given , formally , by the same formula ( [ pathintegralcan ] ) , but with the range of integration over the lapse function extended to the full real interval @xmath17 .
this formula gives a covariant definition of the physical inner product between canonical quantum gravity states and thus of the projector operator onto solutions of the hamiltonian constraint operator .
in fact the resulting quantity , morally a definition of @xmath18is a _ solution _ of the hamiltonian constraint equation in both its arguments @xcite , and it is a real quantity , as expected from a canonical inner product , as well as a - causal in that nothing constraints one boundary geometry to lie in the causal future of the other .
this is not so surprising , and maybe not even un - welcome , given that spin foam models have been introduced exactly in order to define in a covariant way the canonical physical inner product @xcite .
however , @xmath19 _ does not _ correspond to the lagrangian path integral ( [ pathintegral ] ) , and thus it is _ not _ what we would expect to obtain , in perturbative expansion , in a properly defined field theory on superspace .
the difference lies in the requirement of an additional symmetry on top of the lagrangian 4-diffeos @xcite : positive and negative lapses correspond in fact to the _ same _ class of 4-geometries , and the difference between the two half - ranges @xmath12 and @xmath20 is only that they correspond to _ opposite spacetime orientations_. in other words , the above quantity in lagrangian formulation is given by a different _ symmetric _ choice of quantum amplitude , but for the same space of 4d geometries : h^2 h^1 _ h = g ( e^is(g ) + e^-is(g ) ) .
[ pathintegralsym ] another insightful way of looking at the difference between the two ranges of lapse integration , or between ( [ pathintegral ] ) and ( [ pathintegralsym ] ) , is by recalling the difference between lagrangian and hamiltonian symmetries , the first being the 4d spacetime diffeomorphisms and the second being the transformations generated by the canonical operators @xmath21 and @xmath22 @xcite . the second set of symmetries is actually _ larger _ than the first , and the two coincide only after imposition of ( some ) equations of motion @xcite .
the range @xmath23 is symmetric under transformations of the lapse corresponding to 4d spacetime diffeos , while it is not under canonical symmetries that can connect positive and negative lapses , thus requiring a symmetric range @xmath24 @xcite .
therefore , the lagrangian path integral needs a further symmetrization ( [ pathintegralsym ] ) to satisfy the wheeler - dewitt equation . in a formulation of quantum gravity as a quantum field theory on superspace ,
then , one would expect the symmetrized amplitudes ( [ pathintegralsym ] ) to arise as feynman amplitudes only from a _ restriction _ or in a special _ subsector _ of a more general field theory producing instead ( [ pathintegral ] ) as the typical feynman amplitude .
+ once more , all this has a very precise analogue in the sum - over - histories formulation of the dynamics of a relativistic particle , with the symmetrized path integral corresponding to the hadamard propagator , given in momentum space by @xmath25 , thus imposing the hamiltonian constraint equation @xmath26 , instead of the feynman propagator , given in momentum space by @xmath27 , thus relaxing the same hamiltonian constraint at the quantum level .
some confusion may arise from the fact that usual spin foam model _ do _ indeed come from a path integral quantization of a discrete action , at least in 3d .
this is , however , bf theory which , although closely related to gravity , does not coincide with it .
the difference between 3d bf theory and 3d gravity in 1st order form is that the triad field in a gravity path integral is summed over those configurations corresponding to positive volume element only , while the b field in 3d bf theory is summed over both positive and negative volumes ; this has been emphasized in @xcite .
this again is the first order counterpart of the symmetrization ( [ pathintegralsym ] ) , and corresponds to a larger set of symmetries at the quantum level in bf theory with respect to 1st order gravity .
a similar mismatch between constrained bf - like theories and 1st order gravity arises in higher dimensions as well @xcite .
such mismatch also explains @xcite why , in the semiclassical , large representation limit , and thus after suppression of quantum interference between configurations associated to opposite orientations at the level of each dual face , the spin foam vertex amplitude of all known models still gives the cosine of the discrete gravity action for a single simplex , as opposed to the exponential of it @xcite .
moreover , we note here that the large-@xmath28 semiclassical limit can be understood as suppressing , together with interference between quantum configurations , also all quantum corrections to the regge action somehow hidden in usual spin foam models , leaving only the dominant regge term , even though still within a sum over opposite orientations producing the mentioned cosine factor .
this second suppression mechanism , in a slightly different form , will be shown at work also in our new gft models , where it will indeed reduce the gft feynman amplitudes to the form of a simple exponential of the regge action for simplicial gravity , with its quantum ( higher order ) corrections being negligible in the limit .
this being the situation , we would then like to identify the true gft analogue of the quantum gravity causal transition amplitudes , or , more precisely , we would like to construct group field theories for which , as in ordinary qft , the feynman expansion of n - point functions produces feynman amplitudes given by the exponential of a discrete gravity action ,
i.e. with the causality restrictions implicitly , automatically , but also clearly implemented .
this , for us , would be a clear sign that we are capturing the causal dynamics of discrete gravity correctly .
+ a subsequent analysis of how the usual spin foam models arise from a suitable restriction of these generalized amplitudes , or as a special limit of this new class of gfts would then shed some additional light on the exact relation between bf theories and gravity as well as on the role of the canonical physical inner product between quantum gravity states within a covariant field theory on superspace , in the more rigorous setting of both loop quantum gravity and group field theories .
an additional motivation for constructing this new class of gfts is that they would bring simplicial quantum gravity approaches in much closer contact with the spin foam formalism for discrete gravity path integrals , and , via spin foams , with loop quantum gravity . actually , there is hope that this new class of gfts may represent _ the _ common unified framework in which both simplicial quantum gravity approaches , quantum regge calculus and dynamical triangulations , as well as loop quantum gravity / spin foam one can be subsumed , for mutual benefit and further development of each .
the general idea of gfts as a common framework has been explained in the introduction , and it remains an interesting and intriguing perspective , in our opinion , regardless of our present results .
however , one crucial step is needed in order to make such perspective a concrete reality , and provide a solid basis for understanding the _ exact _ links between gfts , loop quantum gravity and simplicial quantum gravity .
this step has the same goal as the motivations we already gave above arising from a purely 3rd quantization perspective : this goal is to construct gft models with feynman amplitudes given _
exactly _ by the exponential of a simplicial gravity action , times some appropriate measure .
this is the step we take with the present work .
in fact , both quantum regge calculus and dynamical triangulations , although differing in the choice of variables used to encode the geometry of gravity at a simplicial level ( geometric data / edge lengths in the first case , combinatorics of simplicial complexes in the second ) , identify the quantum amplitude to be associated to each spacetime geometry with the exponential of the regge action for simplicial gravity , indeed a beautiful coordinate - free description of classical simplicial geometry @xcite .
a gft _ with the same type of quantum amplitudes _ for its feynman diagrams and with a sum over both geometric data and triangulations would represent a unification and a generalization of both approaches in a very literal , transparent sense .
+ an interesting difference , as for the classical simplicial action used , between usual simplicial quantum gravity and gfts , can be already envisaged .
gfts are based on a 1st order formulation of gravity and a group theoretic description of geometry . in other words
they refer to a palatini - like or bf - like formulation of gravity in terms of a d - bein field and a connection field .
we would then expect that the sought for generalized gfts would produce amplitudes given by exponentials of a simplicial gravity action in 1st order variables as well , i.e. with a double set of geometric variables : one corresponding to d - beins , and thus assigning volume information to the simplicial complex , and the other corresponding to a connection , and thus defining a group - theoretic notion of curvature , in terms of holonomies . in pure bf theory ,
in fact , the b field is just a lagrange multiplier and one can achieve a formulation of the quantum amplitudes using only the connection variables , and basically imposing the flatness condition everywhere . in gravity , however , one relaxes this condition and the d - bein is a true dynamical field , that we would expect to find as a dynamical variable in the path integral as well as a configuration / momentum variable in the definition of a field theory on superspace , alongside the connection field .
+ in a simplicial setting , therefore , we would expect to obtain a formulation of gravity in terms of some 1st order version of the regge action , with variables being a discretized d - bein @xmath29 , associated to each link of the simplicial complex , or a discretized bivector field @xmath30 , associated to each ( d-2)-face of the complex , in a bf - like formulation of gravity , plus a discretized connection variable , represented for example in terms of discrete parallel transports ( group elements ) of the same along dual links @xmath31 of the simplicial complex , as in all current spin foam models @xcite .
this action would have a general form of the type : s = _
f v_f(e , b ) _ f ( g_e * ) + ( higher order ) , [ discreteaction]with @xmath32 being the volume associated to the ( d-2)-face @xmath33 , which is a function of either @xmath34 variable or @xmath35 variables , and @xmath36 being the corresponding deficit angle , i.e. the discretized curvature .
similar 1st order formulations of discrete gravity have been proposed and studied , e.g. , in @xcite .
+ in dimension @xmath37 , one would have to add to ( [ discreteaction ] ) suitable ( non - local ) constraints on the discrete b variables , if a bf - like formulation is the one sought for , ensuring their geometric interpretation . in absence of such constraints , in fact , we would just have a discrete version of classical bf theory , as it clear from the fact that the variation of the action with respect to @xmath35 would produce the flatness condition @xmath38 for any face of the complex . in 4 spacetime dimensions , the issue of discrete bf constraints is also related to the issue of the constraints on area variables in the so - called area regge calculus @xcite .
we will discuss these issues in slightly more detail later in this article .
+ with the aim of reproducing the above type of classical action , plus the hope that this will lead to a more straightforward way of imposing the above constraint than in the usual spin foam procedure , and the main motivation of imposing the causality / orientation dependence condition , which is in fact a restriction on the integration range over the b field , we are thus led to introduce additional variables , directly identifiable with the b field of bf theory , into the usual gft formalism , which is based on the connection variables only ( group elements ) .
we will indeed obtain , from our new gfts , a 3rd quantized version of discrete bf theory in any dimension and any signature , _ with an additional restriction on orientation _ automatically imposed , as well as incorporating what can be interpreted as quantum corrections to the above classical action ( akin to higher derivative corrections to the einstein - hilbert action in effective approaches to continuum gravity ) .
this means that we will obtain a 3rd quantization of discrete 1st order gravity in 3d , and of an orientation - restricted bf theory in higher dimension . in 4d the corresponding gft model
would represent , we believe , the most suitable framework in which to implement the classical constraints on the b field that reduce bf theory to gravity , that have been extensively studied in the construction of spin foam models for 4d gravity ( see e.g. the recent @xcite ) , because it may make the identification and implementation of the geometric constraints at the simplicial level more straightforward , and in a context in which the needed orientation dependence / causality restriction is already implemented . before proceeding to the discussion of our results and of the new gft formalism ,
let us conclude by anticipating motivation , interpretation and advantages of the specific way we have chosen of introducing the additional variables corresponding to the continuum b field .
+ in the usual spin foam models , such as the ponzano - regge model for bf theory , as well as in the gft models that generate them , such as the boulatov model , the variable that is interpreted as the discrete counterpart of the b field of the original continuum bf theory is the representation label j associated to each ( d-2)-face of the simplicial complex .
this is first of all justified by the way it enters the expression for the spin foam amplitudes , after peter - weyl decomposition of the same . in the riemannian 3d case , for example , one indeed gets , for each dual face @xcite : d^3 b_f = ( g_f ) = _
j_f d_j_f ^j_f(g_f ) .
[ facebf ] @xmath30 is the original discretized b field , given by an @xmath39 lie algebra element , with which one starts from when deriving the spin foam amplitudes from a discrete lagrangian path integral , but that does not appear in the corresponding gft derivation , from which one just obtains the result of the @xmath30 integral above , i.e. the delta function over the group , forcing the flatness condition on the su(2 ) holonomy @xmath40 . starting from this delta function , by harmonic analysis on su(2 )
one gets the last expression in ( [ facebf ] ) , which indeed resembles the starting expression but with a discrete replacement for the @xmath30 variables : the representation labels @xmath41 . the same happens in the usual gfts .
apart from the formal similarities , one physical rationale for the identification of the @xmath41 with a discretized b field is the fact that it is conjugate to the connection variables , i.e. to the group elements @xmath42 , in the sense of fourier transforms , just as the b field is canonically conjugate to the a field in the hamiltonian formulation of classical bf theory .
this reasoning is of course sensible , and it is indeed supported by the respective role group representations and group elements play in loop quantum gravity , again following canonical analysis in the continuum , but it is also not fully conclusive .
there are a few reasons for being dissatisfied with this interpretation , even if they are , admittedly , not at all conclusive either .
one is that the @xmath41 corresponds more precisely to just _ one _ component of the original b field , its ( discretized ) absolute value , with the other components still missing any identification within the formalism .
the situation , in this respect , has been ameliorated somewhat by the recent development of new spin foam models for bf theory and gravity @xcite based on coherent states . here , the additional parameters labelling a coherent state basis of vectors in each representation space @xmath41 are interpreted as the spin foam analogue of the missing components of the b field with modulus @xmath41 .
this is justified by the fact that the _ expectation value _ of a lie algebra generator in a coherent state is given by a ( bi-)vector with modulus @xmath41 and components proportional to the coherent state parameters .
however , there are still several questions unanswered about the relation between a generic b field and the lie algebra generators , the exact physical role played by coherent states , apart from their mathematical convenience , etc . moreover , since the above is a relation that concerns the expectation values of quantum operators , one may suspect that it should be understood as a semi - classical one , holding only in some approximation of the dynamics of the quantum theory . as we will discuss later on , we feel that our approach of introducing additional independent variables playing in a straightforward sense the role of the discrete b field , and whose relation with lie algebra generators for the group considered is governed by the _ dynamics _ of the theory , may help to clarify , with further work , the role that coherent states play at the level of spin foam amplitudes .
+ our main concern with the identification of representation labels , and , before that , of the generators of the lie algebra , acting on connection group elements , with the discrete b field comes from looking at the issue from a more general lagrangian , rather than canonical perspective ( which is available only for trivial topology ) .
namely , we are looking for a group field theory discrete realization of the path integral for a _ gravity _ theory in 1st order form , which , as we have discussed , is likely to imply a restriction on the configurations of the b field summed over , that would give a different result for the face amplitudes with respect to ( [ facebf ] ) , as it happens , for example , in the model of @xcite .
in such a path integral two sets of variables are present , the geometric b field and the connection , and the relation between the two is _ one of the equations of motion _ of the theory ( the one imposing metricity of the connection ) and thus should be imposed only by the dynamics of the theory , and not imposed already at the kinematical level at the level of each history being summed over in the path integral , as it appears to be done in current gft models .
we feel that imposing such condition already at the kinematical level results , in the usual spin foam models , in freezing a part of the degrees of freedom of the theory .
in particular it may be this restriction is what is responsible for turning what should have been causal transition amplitudes into rather awkward , from the gft and 3rd quantization perspective , a - causal transition amplitudes , which correspond , as said , to a sort of symmetrized path integral , imposing the canonical dynamical constraints even in situations , e.g. non - trivial spacetime topologies , where a canonical interpretation is problematic and certainly not expected .
+ this feeling , admittedly not much more than this , in absence of more rigorous arguments , is however confirmed by the way the new variables we introduce should be restricted in order to reduce our new gft models to the usual ones , at the level of their feynman amplitudes , i.e. spin foam models . + in any case , we would like to have at our disposal a more general framework , that reproduces the full bf or 1st order gravity path integral , in which the mutual relations between the discrete counterparts of the continuum variables mimic more closely the continuum classical and quantum dynamics . in this way
, we may both confirm that we are indeed reproducing at the discrete level the features of the continuum dynamics and also , hopefully , shed some light on the usual spin foam models and procedures .
as was explained in the previous section , the new models should be thought of as the causal analogues of the usual gfts associated with bf theory .
+ bf theory in d dimensions for a group g with a lie algebra @xmath43 is a topological field theory defined by the following action [ eq : bfaction ] s = _ m tr ( b f(a ) ) where m is a d - dimensional manifold , b can be thought of locally as a @xmath43-valued ( d-2)-form and f is the curvature of the g - connection a , so it can also be thought of locally as a @xmath43-valued 2-form .
+ let us now describe our main strategy and its rationale , illustrating it for simplicity in the d=3 case .
the extension to different dimensions is straightforward and follows the same type of arguments .
it will be discussed in detail in the following .
* we would like to introduce additional variables , corresponding to a discrete b field associated to each 1-simplex in the simplicial complex , in the gft perturbative expansion .
this means that there should be one such variable for each argument of the gft field .
* we would like the new variables to be identified with the generators of the lie algebra of the relevant group .
this implies that they must have the same number of components .
the field should then be a complex function @xmath44 in this 3d example .
the complexity of the field , together with symmetry under _ even _ permutation of the arguments , is needed to ensure orientability of the simplicial complexes arising in perturbative expansion .
* the identification should follow from some equation of motion of the theory , so to be part of the dynamics ; at the same time , it should belong to the _ kinematical _ sector of the gft , because we would like boundary states to satisfy it , at least partially , so to have a similar structure to that of loop quantum gravity spin network states
. this condition would then follow from some sort of _ asymptotic condition _ on boundary states in computing gft transition amplitudes ( notice however that a gft equivalent of the cluster decomposition principle of ordinary qft or of the ordinary s - matrix theory has not yet been developed in full detail ) . * such equation of motion should then be of the type @xmath45 , where the indices @xmath46 label the arguments of the field , while the indices @xmath11 are vector indices in @xmath47 , and @xmath48 are the generators of the @xmath49 or @xmath50 lie algebra . however , the above equation is not invariant under group transformations , so we turn it into a covariant form , obtaining : @xmath51 , for each argument of the field . * the field being a function on the group , the generators of the corresponding lie algebra act on the group arguments of the field as derivative operators , so that the above equation is actually implemented , in configuration space ( with respect to @xmath52 ) as : @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the laplace - beltrami operator acting on the group manifold .
* after harmonic analysis , the @xmath55 is turned into the invariant casimir of the group @xmath52 , in a given representation @xmath56 , acting as a multiplicative operator on the field now function on the same representation parameters @xmath56 . * @xmath57 act here as multiplicative operators ; however , we can independently perform fourier analysis on the @xmath35 variables as well , going to conjugate variables @xmath58 , also in @xmath47 , and turn the quantity @xmath59 into a differential operator , a new laplace - beltrami operator acting on @xmath47 . * by means of this extension of the group field theory formalism , we want also to reproduce proper simplicial gravity path integrals in perturbative expansion . considering that , in the regge formalism for discrete gravity , d
- simplices are assumed to be flat and the whole dynamics of geometry comes from the boundary terms @xcite , we obtain a further motivation for restricting the modification of the gft dynamics with respect to usual models to be confined to only the kinematical term in the gft action . *
the interaction term is only modified by the extension in the number of variables as well as in a peculiar orientation dependence , in the variables @xmath60 , fourier conjugate to @xmath35 , that is necessary to ensure the proper matching of @xmath35 variables across simplices , and encoded in the dependence on the complex structure of the field @xmath61 , as we will see . as for the dependence on the group @xmath52 , it maintains the same structure of the usual models describing bf theory . in this way
we obtain a new kinetic term given by a differential operator acting on the field , very similar to the usual klein - gordon operator of scalar field theory , but with a product structure coming from the independent action of one operator of the above type acting on each argument of the field : @xmath62 .
+ notice that there is almost nothing in the above choices that can select any specific dynamics of the geometric data ( @xmath35 variables and group elements , say ) at the level of the individual feynman diagram .
the only dynamical ingredient above is the choice of a certain _ relation _ between them , but nothing seems to dictate , at the level of the gft action , the _ individual dynamics _ of each set of variables .
what we put in is then only a ) some _ complex structure _ resulting from the propagator representing the inverse of the chosen kinetic term , due to its singular nature as a differential operator , b ) the mentioned mutual relation between @xmath35 s and @xmath63 s , and c ) the combinatorics of the feynman diagrams ( dictated by the combinatorics of the variables in the action ) .
it is only to be expected , then , that the simplicial action describing their dynamics at the level of each feynman diagram , and appearing in the exponent of the phase part of the feynman amplitudes ( simplicial gravity path integral ) will be pretty generic .
the non trivial tests will be to show : 1 ) that this phase can be interpreted at all as a simplicial gravity action , because of the way the gft variables will enter in it ; 2 ) that this generalized action will reduce to the usual regge action ( in 1st order form ) in appropriate , clearly identified and physically meaningful limits .
our proposed formalism passes these tests .
the strongest support for the mentioned choices , and for the resulting form of the gft action for the new models , is , therefore , simply the resulting expression for the feynman amplitudes of the corresponding gft , which indeed fulfill _ all _ the expectations and goals we have stated above .
some additional nice features of the resulting model can be already underlined at this point .
as we mentioned , the kinetic operator above is a singular differential operator , which implies that its inverse has to be defined in the complex domain , just as it happens in the usual klein - gordon case .
on the one hand , this complexification is responsible for the complexity of the resulting feynman amplitudes , and ultimately , as we shall see , for the wanted exponential form of the same amplitudes ; on the other hand , the differential form introduces the dynamical correlations between simplices that we would expect in a discrete theory of quantum geometry .
also , the propagator corresponding to the kinetic operator will introduce quantum corrections , virtual degrees of freedom , not captured by the on - shell condition @xmath64 , thus relaxing it at the quantum level , again matching our expectations .
finally let us mention that the presence of derivatives in the gft kinetic terms allows for the identification of a non - trivial symplectic structure on the space of fields , and makes a canonical analysis _ of the gft itself _ possible .
this nice feature is shared also by the generalized models introduced in @xcite , of which the new ones represent a sort of relativistic extension(fixing some pathologies of the same arising in perturbative expansion ) , as we will discuss , and it is at the basis of the canonical analysis performed in @xcite .
we now give the definition of the action for the new class of gft models , for general dimension d and general gauge group g. + let g be a semi - simple group ( we will deal with the double covers of the rotation and the lorentz groups in d dimensions ) and let x be a space isomorphic , as a metric vector space , to the lie algebra @xmath43 of g. the basic variable of the theory is a complex - valued field @xmath61
@xmath65 where d is the dimension of the model , which is the dimension of the generated simplicial complexes ( we will concentrate on the 3 and 4 dimensional cases ) .
+ the field is interpreted as a ( d-1)-simplex , with the group and lie algebra variables corresponding to its geometry .
the group elements represent discrete parallel transports of a connection ( the discrete analogue of the @xmath66 of bf theory ) from the centre of the simplex to the boundaries , while the @xmath60 variables allow us the reconstruction of the volumes of the boundary ( d-2)-simplices , and are thus related to the b field of bf theory . + the field is assumed to be invariant under _ even _ permutation of the labelling of its ( pairs of ) arguments @xmath67 ) , and to turn into its own complex conjugate under change of this labelling by an _ odd _ permutation . in this way , the orientation of the corresponding ( d-1)-simplex is encoded in the complex structure of the field@xcite .
+ as in usual gft models , geometric closure of the ( d-2)-simplices which form this ( d-1)-simplex translates into invariance of the field under the global symmetry @xmath68 @xcite .
we will impose this symmetry in the usual way by taking the field to be arbitrary and then projecting it onto the diagonal subspace , i.e. the field @xmath69 is given by @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is now arbitrary .
below , to reduce clutter , we will write the actions in terms of the @xmath61 s instead o the @xmath72 s . + also , we will denote both the field and its complex conjugate by @xmath73 , with @xmath74 and @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
+ the model is defined by the following action @xmath77}_{\textrm{kinetic operator } } \phi(g_i ; x_i ) + { } \nonumber \\ & & { } + \frac{\lambda}{(d+1 ) ! } \sum_{\nu_1 , \ldots , \nu_{d+1 } } \int_{g^{d(d+1 ) } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{d+1 } \ , dg_{ij}\bigg ) \ , \int_{x^{d(d+1)}}\bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j}^{d+1 } dx_{ij } \bigg ) \ , \ , \,\underbrace { \bigg [ \prod_{i < j } \delta(g_{ij } g_{ji}^{-1 } ) \delta(\nu_i x_{ij } + \nu_j x_{ji } ) \bigg ] } _ { \textrm{vertex } } \ , \ , \ , \times { } \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : actiongx } & & { } \times \phi^{\nu_1}(g_{1j } ; x_{1j } ) \ldots \phi^{\nu_{d+1}}(g_{d+1 j } ; x_{d+1 j}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath78 and @xmath79 are the laplace - beltrami operators on x and on g respectively , corresponding to the killing form , is obtained by extending , using e.g. left - invariance , the _ negative _ of the metric used to define @xmath78 .
the reason for this choice of conventions comes from the fact that if one uses the same sign for the @xmath78 as the one used in the mathematical literature @xcite for the @xmath79 , then one gets a negative - definite operator in the case g is compact .
so , for example , if g is su(2 ) , then the corresponding @xmath78 would have been given ( in the appropriate coordinates ) by @xmath80 .
on the other hand , with our conventions it is just the usual laplacian on flat space . ] and the cartan - killing metric , and d is the dimension of g and @xmath81 . + as in usual gfts , the combinatorics of arguments in the action is designed in such a way as to mimic the combinatorics of the ( d-2)-faces of a d - simplex in the interaction term , and the gluing of two d - simplices across their common boundary in the kinetic term .
the sum over @xmath82 in the second term makes the action real . interpreting the @xmath61 as representing ( d-1)-simplices which are incomingor in the past boundary , and the @xmath83
as representing ( d-1)-simplices which are outgoingor in the future boundarywith respect to the d - simplex corresponding to the gft interaction vertex , we see that there are d+2 possible vertices , corresponding to the cases in which ( d+1)-n initial(d-1)-simplices interact to give rise to n final(d-1)-simplices after the interaction has taken place . in turn
these various terms correspond to the well - known ( d-1)-dimensional pachner moves .
as noticed above , the orientation of the ( d-1)-simplices , inducing a _ pre - order _ @xcite also on the set of d - simplices , and turning the resulting feynman diagrams into _ directed graphs _ is encoded in the complex structure of the fields . for simplicity of presentation ,
we have chosen the weight the various interaction terms corresponding to different choices of @xmath82 s with the same coupling constant @xmath84 ; it is straightforward to relax this assumption defining coupling constants @xmath85 , with @xmath86 in order to ensure reality of the action , as it was done also in @xcite .
+ let us remark that it is possible to choose a different vertex from the one above .
one in which there is no dependence on the @xmath87 , in the x variables , and this dependence is instead shifted to the p variables : @xmath88\ ] ] below , we will call the model given by ( [ eqnarray : actiongx ] ) model a , while the one with this new vertex model b. + note also that the the kinetic operator is just a product of d copies of the klein - gordon one for a massive scalar field living in @xmath89 , one for each pair of arguments of the field .
+ let us write the above action in momentum space with respect to the x variables .
we will denote the space dual to x as p. thus ( [ eqnarray : actiongx ] ) is equal to ] where the vectors denote the coordinates in which the appropriate killing form has a canonical form ( diagonal matrix with @xmath901 along the diagonal . ] @xmath91}_{\textrm{kinetic operator } } \phi(g_i ; p_i ) + { } \nonumber \\ & & { } + \frac{\lambda}{(2\pi)^{dd(d+1 ) } ( d+1 ) ! } \sum_{\nu_1
\ldots \nu_{d+1 } } \int_{g^{d(d+1 ) } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{d+1 } \ , dg_{ij } \bigg ) \ , \int_{p^{d(d+1 ) } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{d+1 } dp_{ij } \bigg ) \ , \ , \,\underbrace { \bigg [ \prod_{i < j } \delta(g_{ij } g_{ji}^{-1 } ) \delta(p_{ij } - p_{ji } ) \bigg ] } _ { \textrm{vertex } } \times { } \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : actiongp } & & { } \times \phi^{\nu_1}(g_{1j } ; p_{1j } ) \ldots \phi^{\nu_{d+1}}(g_{d+1 j } ; p_{d+1 j}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath92 is the magnitude of p with respect to the killing form . the kinetic term can be interpreted as the product of d klein - gordon operators on the group g , and for a particle / field of ( variable ) mass square @xmath93 .
+ the written action is the one associated with model a ( i.e. equation ( [ eqnarray : actiongx ] ) ) . notice that the orientation dependence , i.e. the dependence of the vertex term on the @xmath82 s , is apparently lost in going to the @xmath94 variables ( of course , the vertex has this form in the p variables exactly because of the @xmath95-dependence in the x variables , thus this dependence is retained ) . in model b , instead , the vertex in the ( g , p ) variables becomes @xmath96\ ] ] so the vertex of model b depends explicitly on the @xmath95 s in the ( g , p ) variables , and not in the x variables .
we will see that the feynman amplitudes , when we use the p variables , thus in both the ( g , p ) and ( j , p ) representations , are the same for both models .
the difference between them is apparent only when the x variables are invoked .
since , as we shall see later on , it is the p variables that have clear physical significance , and we are going to deal extensively only with the ( g , p ) and ( j , p ) representations , we shall not draw the distinction between the two versions of the model in what follows , apart when we briefly report the feynman amplitudes in the ( j , x ) variables at the end of this section .
+ we can also perform the fourier transform with respect to the group variables . expanding the field harmonically on the group and using its invariance under the global right shifts @xcite , we get @xmath97 the j s label the representations of the group g. the index j can go over both discrete and continuous values in general as is the case for the lorentz group .
the d s are the representation functions ( the components of the representation matrices ) .
@xmath98 is an appropriate normalized intertwiner ( between the representations labelled by @xmath99 ) , and @xmath100 labels the different basis elements of the space of normalized intertwiners . +
a very important property of the laplace operator is that it is multiplicative on the representation functions ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
more precisely , @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the appropriate casimir operator and the minus sign is used for compact groups while the plus sign for the noncompact ones . which is minus the usual one .
the space of casimirs of the rotation and the lorentz groups in 3 dimensions is one dimensional , while in 4 dimensions it is 2 dimensional . in 4 dimensions ,
the casimir that corresponds to the laplace - beltrami operator in the riemannian case , where the representations of spin(4 ) are labelled by a pair of spins @xmath103 , is proportional to @xmath104 , while for the lorentzian case , where representations of @xmath105 are labelled by an integer @xmath106 and a real number @xmath107 , it is proportional ( in our normalizations ) to @xmath108 . ] inserting the above into ( [ eqnarray : actiongp ] ) we get @xmath109}_{\textrm{kinetic operator } } \phi_{\alpha_i}^{j_i \lambda}(p_i ) + { } \nonumber \\ & & { } + \frac{\lambda}{(2\pi)^{dd(d+1 ) } ( d+1 ) ! } \sum_{j_{ij } , \alpha_{ij } , \lambda_i , \nu_i ; i \neq j = 1 , \ldots , d+1 } \int_{p^{d(d+1 ) } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{d+1 } dp_{ij } \bigg ) \phi_{\alpha_{1j}}^{\nu_1 j_{1j } \lambda_1}(p_{1j } ) \ldots { } \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : actionjp } & & { } \ldots \phi_{\alpha_{(d+1 ) j}}^{\nu_{d+1 } j_{(d+1 ) j } \lambda_{(d+1 ) j}}(p_{(d+1 ) j } ) \underbrace{\bigg [ \big \ { j - \textrm{symbol}\big \}(j_{ij } ; \lambda_i ) \big ( \prod_{i < j}^{d+1 } \delta(p_{ij } - p_{ji } ) \ , \delta_{\alpha_{ij } \alpha_{ji } } \big ) \bigg ] } _ { \textrm{vertex}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the interaction term is essentially the standard one , which is a product of fields whose arguments are contracted in the pattern of a d - simplex multiplied by the appropriate j - symbol , always obtained by the contraction ( along pairwise identified tensor indices , following the combinatorics of faces of a d - simplex ) of d+1 d - valent intertwiners of the group g. the only difference being that now it is not only the alphas and the j s that are contracted but also the p s as well .
+ for completeness we also list the action in the x , j variables , which is easily obtained by taking the fourier transform of ( [ eqnarray : actionjp ] ) with respect to the p variables .
note that the kinetic term is just the product of d copies of the klein - gordon one on flat @xmath110 , with the metric whose signature is decided by the appropriate killing form , and with ( variable ) mass square @xmath111 .
+ it is given by : @xmath112}_{\textrm{kinetic operator } } \phi_{\alpha_i}^{j_i \lambda}(x_i ) + { } \nonumber \\ & & { } + \frac{\lambda } { ( d+1 ) ! } \sum_{j_{ij } , \alpha_{ij } , \lambda_i , \nu_i ; i \neq j = 1 , \ldots , d+1 } \int_{x^{d(d+1 ) } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{d+1 } dx_{ij } \bigg ) \phi_{\alpha_{1j}}^{\nu_1 j_{1j } \lambda_1}(x_{1j } ) \ldots \phi_{\alpha_{(d+1 ) j}}^{\nu_{d+1 } j_{(d+1 ) j } \lambda_{(d+1 ) j}}(x_{(d+1 ) j } ) \times { } \nonumber \\ \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : actionjx } & & { } \times \underbrace{\bigg [ \big \ { j - \textrm{symbol}\big \}(j_{ij } ; \lambda_i ) \big ( \prod_{i < j}^{d+1 } \delta(\nu_i x_{ij } + \nu_j x_{ji } ) \
, \delta_{\alpha_{ij } \alpha_{ji } } \big ) \bigg ] } _ { \textrm{vertex}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to see that the new models we are presenting are essentially a sort of relativistic extensionof the generalized group field theories ( gfts ) introduced in @xcite . in fact , the new models encode the orientation of the feynman diagrams / triangulations resulting from the perturbative expansion of the partition function , that we are going to discuss in the following , in the action and in the quantum feynman amplitudes in almost the same way as the models in @xcite ( see also the discussion of these models in @xcite ) . the difference from the models outlined
there is the fact that the field is now a function of more variables , passing , in momentum space , from a variable mass - energy @xmath113 valued on the real line to the set of momentum variables @xmath114 .
consequently , the kinetic operator in each argument of the field turns from a schroedinger - type one into a klein - gordon one .
while this could be considered a somewhat minor modification at the level of the action alone , the step from a non - relativistic type of dynamics to a relativistic one has huge consequences at the level of the feynman amplitudes and for the whole quantum dynamics of the corresponding models .
we quantize the theory now via the path - integral method .
the partition function is given by @xmath115}.\ ] ] in lack of a better understanding of the quantum theory and of more powerful tools , we study the quantum dynamics of the theory in perturbative expansion around the vacuum , expanding the partition function in feynman diagrams @xmath116 in the usual way .
we get @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the number of vertices in the feynman diagram @xmath116 , sym(@xmath116 ) is the symmetry factor of the diagram ( order of automorphisms of the diagram / complex ) , and @xmath119 is the feynman amplitude for the graph @xmath116 obtained as is customary by taking the product of vertex functions and feynman propagators , obtained by inverting the kinetic operator in the action .
+ we then set out to extract vertex and propagator from our classical action .
let us begin with the vertex contribution .
it is clear that the interaction term in the ( g , p ) variables ( equation ( [ eqnarray : actiongp ] ) ) is exactly like the interaction terms in the usual gfts for bf theory with the sole difference being the extra variables ( which are contracted in exactly the same way as the group variables ) .
the vertex amplitude is then just the usual one , which is nothing but a product of delta functions connecting the group arguments in the d - simplex pattern , with the addition of extra delta functions connecting the p variables paralleling the group ones . in other words ,
if we represent the vertex in the standard way @xcite we see that it consists of ( d+1 ) bundles , of d - strands each , joined together in a pattern of a d - simplex ( in the shaded area of the picture ) .
each strand represents a product of a delta function on the group with a delta function on the lie algebra .
the dark dots represent the arguments of the delta functions .
since we never have a situation when several strands meet at a point , it is obvious that there is no real interaction enforced by this vertex , at least not in usual local qft sense , just a rerouting of the strands .
it is in this sense that gfts are sometimes referred to as combinatorially non - local field theories + we now move on to the propagator .
the easiest way to get it is to use the action written in terms of the ( j , p ) variables , and the expansion of a delta function on a group in terms of the characters . we wo nt really need the explicit form of the character functions nor the precise values of the coefficients ,
rather just the fact that such an expansion is possible .
for all the groups that we will consider in this work this is indeed the case .
we will use the following notation for this expansion [ eq : delta ] ( g ) = _ j _ j _
j(g ) , where @xmath120 is the character of the representation labelled by j , and as before the index j can go over both discrete and continuous values ( the sum standing for the usual sum or for the integral , respectively ) .
+ from this expansion and from the expression of the kinetic operator in ( [ eqnarray : actionjp ] ) we can immediately read off the expression of the feynman propagator [ eq : propagatorjp ] d_f [ g_i , h_i ; p_i , q_i ] = _ g dh _ i=1^d ( _ j_i _ j(g_i h h_i^-1 ) ( p_i - q_i ) ) . the above expression ,
indeed , satisfies [ eq : propagator equation ] _ i=1^d ( p_i^2 + _ g_i - m^2 ) d_f [ g_i , h_i ; p_i , q_i ] = i _ g dh _ i=1^d ( ( g_i h h_i^-1 ) ( p_i - q_i ) ) . the fact that it is the feynman propagator , as opposed to some other green s function , follows as usual from the i@xmath121 prescription used in ( [ eq : propagatorjp ] ) , as it is clear by recalling that the kinetic operator in ( [ eqnarray : actionjp ] ) , as noticed above , is essentially the klein - gordon operator in momentum variables . + note that by taking the fourier transform with respect to the p variables we can obtain the expression for the same propagator in the ( j , x ) variables . instead of computing it this way , which in fact does not easily lead to an explicit expression , we note that the kinetic term is perfectly symmetric in the way it treats the group manifold @xmath52 and the space @xmath60 . because of this symmetry , we can just reproduce the very same steps that will lead us to the propagator in the ( p , g ) variables , to obtain instead the same propagator in the ( x , j ) variables .
clearly this will be just the product of klein - gordon propagators for a scalar massive ( of mass@xmath122 = @xmath123 ) field in the flat space x. + to sum the series and obtain the propagator in the ( g , p ) variables as opposed to the ( j , p ) above , take advantage of the fact that , once more , the kinetic term in the ( g , p ) variables in ( [ eqnarray : actiongp ] ) is just the product of klein - gordon ones on the group g with the mass given by @xmath124 , and use the feynman - schwinger - dewitt parametrization of the propagator@xcite .
this parametrization relates the klein - gordon propagator of a massive scalar field on a space to the schroedinger evolution kernel on that space , in a fictitious proper time parameter @xmath125 . to see this connection between the propagator and the kernel recall the schroedinger equation on the group , which is given by [ eq : schrodinger ] i + _ g ( g , t ) = 0 .
the general solution to this equation is given by the aforementioned schroedinger evolution kernel @xmath126 $ ] which gives the solution @xmath127 at time @xmath128 given the solution at time @xmath129 .
@xmath130 \ , \psi(g_0 , t_0),\ ] ] where @xmath131 is the heaviside step function .
many properties of @xmath132 immediately follow from this equation and the fact that ( [ eq : schrodinger ] ) is invariant under left and right shifts , notably symmetry , composition and green function property . + by the symmetry property of the kernel , we mean the fact that it is invariant under shifting both arguments on the group on one hand and that it is a central function on the other .
this latter fact means that the kernel is expandable in characters , a feature we will use shortly . in formulae
the kernel satisfies [ eq : central ] k[g , h , t ] = k[g h^-1 , t ] k[g , t ] = k[h g h^-1 , t ] .
the composition property of the kernel is the standard one : [ eq : composition ] _
g dg_2 k [ g_1 , g_2 , t ] k [ g_2 , g_3 , s ] = k [ g_1 , g_3 , t+s ]
. this equation will be useful when we will compute the feynman amplitudes of our model .
+ finally and most importantly the kernel satisfies the following two equations @xmath133}{\pp t } + \box_g \ , k [ g , h , t ] = 0 \ ; \ ; \textrm{and } \ ; \ ; i \frac{\pp \big ( \theta(t ) \ , k[g , h , t ] \big ) } { \pp t } + \box_g \ , \big ( \theta(t ) \ ,
k [ g , h , t ] \big ) = i \ , \delta(t ) \ , \delta(g h^{-1}).\ ] ] these coupled with the boundary condition @xmath134 = \delta(g h^{-1})$ ] mean that @xmath135 \big ) $ ] is the retarded propagator for the schroedinger equation .
it is this last feature that links the schroedinger kernel with the feynman propagator .
+ to see this link take the fourier transform of the inhomogeneous equation with respect to t , going to the conjugate variable @xmath136 , which is the mass ( square ) of the particle in the proper time parametrization of the klein - gordon propagator @xcite , or the energy of the same in the usual schroedinger equation if we denote by @xmath137 $ ] the fourier transform of @xmath138 \big ) $ ] then it follows that @xmath139 = i \delta(g h^{-1}).\ ] ] comparing this to ( [ eq : propagator equation ] ) we see immediately that k satisfies essentially the same equation as @xmath140 . from this
we can easily deduce that [ eq : propagatoriskernel ] d_f [ g_i , h_i ; p_i , q_i ] = _ g dh _ i=1^d ( k ( p_i - q_i ) ) . alternatively , we could use the known character expansion of the @xmath141 $ ] , which is given by @xcite @xmath142 = \sum_j \delta_j \ , \chi_j(g ) \
, e^{\mp i c_j t}.\ ] ] if we fourier transform this ( multiplied by the step function ) with respect to @xmath125 we get [ eq : kernelexpansion ] k [ g , ] = _ j _ j _
j(g ) . comparing this with the character expansion of the @xmath143 $ ] given in ( [ eq : propagatorjp ] ) we re - obtain ( [ eq : propagatoriskernel ] ) .
+ as was mentioned above , the feynman propagator for our theory in the ( g , p ) variables is just ( a product of d copies of ) the klein - gordon propagator , here written in terms of the schroedinger evolution kernel , for a free particle on the group , with the mass equal to @xmath144 as anticipated , the above procedure can be reproduced in order to obtain the propagator in the ( j , x ) variables , which is a product of propagators ( one for each argument of the field ) for a scalar field with mass@xmath122 = @xmath123 on the ( flat ) space x. which means that the propagator in these variables is given by s labelling different field components in ( [ eqnarray : actionjx ] ) , however they just contribute trivial kronecker deltas , and since it is customary in the literature to not write them explicitly we do the same here .
their effect on the feynman amplitude is just to contribute a factor @xmath145 to the weight of every dual face . ]
[ eq : propagatorjx ] d_f [ x_i , y_i ; j_1 , i , j_2,i ] = _ i=1^d ( _ j_1,i j_2,i k ) . the only difference with the ( g , p ) expression , that results , as we will see , in a very different form for the full feynman amplitudes in the two representations , is the absence of the analogue of the additional integration over h @xmath146 g , coming from the gauge invariance requirement on the gft field , and which breaks the symmetry between the x and g spaces in the gft action .
+ analogously to the vertex above we represent the propagator by a bundle of d strands as in the picture .
+ each strand represents a multiplicand from the right hand side of equation ( [ eq : propagatoriskernel ] ) , i.e. the i - th strand is @xmath147 \ , \delta(p_i - q_i).\ ] ] the box across all the strands represents the common integral over the h. the dark dots at the ends of the strands represent the remaining arguments of the propagator ( ( @xmath148 ) on one side and ( @xmath149 ) on the other ) .
+ the reason why we have drawn the strands in the propagator differently from those in the vertex is that in distinction to the situation in the usual models where the strands represent the same thing ( simple delta functions ) , this is not the case here , as a true propagation of degrees of freedom takes place between simplices , even though only a re - routing of the same occurs within each simplex .
+ since we have now both the necessary ingredients , the vertex and the propagator , we proceed now to construct explicitly the feynman amplitudes .
a feynman diagram @xmath116 is obtained by gluing several vertices together using the propagators .
if we pick one of the strands and follow it around the diagram , in absence of external legs , as in the diagrams merging from the perturbative expansion of the partition function , the strand closes back on itself .
we can think of this loop as the boundary of a 2-dimensional surface which we assume has the topology of a disk .
the combinatorics of the vertex is such that if we take all these disks together they form the dual 2-complex @xmath150 of a simplicial d - complex @xmath151 , the original disks being the 2-cells topologically dual to the ( d-2)-dimensional subsimplices in the simplicial complex ( for details consult @xcite ) . in the ( g , p ) variables the feynman graph amplitude factorizes per dual face ( or , equivalently , per edge of the triangulation ) ,
i.e. the amplitude for a graph @xmath116 is a product of dual face amplitudes : @xmath152 where , @xmath153 is the number of the dual edges in @xmath154 and @xmath155 is the number of the dual faces , and @xmath156 is the amplitude assigned to each dual face @xmath157 .
this amplitude depends on the group elements @xmath158 that are assigned to the dual edges @xmath31 on the boundary of the dual face @xmath157 , and that result from the gauge symmetry of the field @xmath61 under @xmath52 ( see @xcite ) , and on a single p variable associated to the whole dual face @xmath157 left after doing all the delta functions over intermediate momenta .
more precisely , this amplitude is just a product of kernels with delta functions , integrated over the common group and momentum @xmath94 variables , and for a dual face with n vertices ( and thus n links ) it is given by [ eq : ampl ] a [ h_1 , , h_n ; p ] = _ g^2n ( _ i=1^n dg_i dg_i ) ( _ i=1^n k ) ( _ i=1^n ( g_i-1 g_i^-1 ) ) , where @xmath159 . the first multiplicand is just the the propagators which are sitting on the dual edges , while the second multiplicand is the delta functions coming from the vertices which is a consequence of the translational symmetry in the p variables , leaving the detailed treatment of this symmetry for future work . ] . + ) in the amplitude for a dual face .
the black boxes represent the integrals over the hs._,scaledwidth=70.0% ] we can use the delta functions coming from the vertices to do the integrals over the @xmath160 s obtaining : @xmath161 = \int_{g^n } \bigg ( \prod_{i=1}^n dg_i \bigg ) \bigg ( \prod_{i=1}^n k\bigg [ g_{i-1 } h_i g_i^{-1 } , \big ( p^2 - \frac{d}{24 } \ ,
m^2 \big ) \bigg ] \bigg ) .\ ] ] we would like to do the integrals over the remaining g s and obtain something which depends only on the holonomy around the dual face , computed through the @xmath162 variables only , as in usual spin foam models and gfts .
however , the schroedinger kernels in the mass representation in the g - variables do not compose in any simple way . to bypass this difficulty we use again the feynman - schwinger - dewitt representation for the kernels in the previous equation @xmath161 = \int_{g^n } \bigg ( \prod_{i=1}^n dg_i \bigg ) \int_{\mathbb{r}^n } \bigg ( \prod_{i=1}^n
dt_i \bigg ) \bigg ( \prod_{i=1}^n e^{i t_i ( p^2 - \frac{d}{24 } \ , m^2 ) } \ , \theta(t_i ) \ , k\bigg [ g_i h_i g_{i+1}^{-1 } , t_i \bigg ] \bigg ) .\ ] ] now , since the kernels in the proper time representation do satisfy the composition identity ( [ eq : composition ] ) we can ( after interchanging the order of integration ) perform the group integrals obtaining @xmath161 = \int_{\mathbb{r}^n } dt_1 \dots dt_n \
, e^{i ( p^2 - \frac{d}{24 } \ , m^2 ) ( t_1 + \dots + t_n ) } \ , \theta(t_1 ) \dots \theta(t_n ) \ , k \bigg [ h_1 \dots h_n \ , , \ , t_1 + \dots + t_n \bigg ] .\ ] ] the product of the group elements in the kernel is exactly the holonomy around the dual face which we will denote by h. thus @xmath163 = a_n [ h ; p ] $ ] .
+ to do the integrals over the proper times we change variables @xmath164 = \int_{\mathbb{r}^n } dt \
, dt_2 \dots dt_n \ , e^{i ( p^2 - \frac{d}{24 } \ , m^2 ) \ , t } \ , \theta(t - t_2 - \dots - t_n ) \ , \theta(t_2 )
\dots \theta(t_n ) \ , k \big [ h \ , , \ , t \big ] .\ ] ] the integrals over @xmath165 can now be performed as these variables appear only in the step functions giving [ eq : amplitudegp ] a_n [ h ; p ] = _ dt e^i ( p^2 - m^2 ) t ( t ) t^n-1 k .
what we have shown above is that the dual face amplitude in the ( g , p ) variables is the value at @xmath166 of the fourier transform of a monomial multiplied by the retarded schroedinger kernel in the ( proper ) time @xmath151 .
we will use this equation repeatedly in what follows . from the case
there is a problem with this approach however due to the fact that the integral above does not converge for @xmath168 _ unless _ some of the parameters of the kernel are complexified ; and while it is possible to find the complexification needed by a careful analysis using distribution theory , it is much simpler to simply do the integral above explicitly , since then the required complexification is then easy to see . ]
the explicit form of this object depends on the details of the group under consideration @xcite
. we will give the explicit formulae for the rotation and lorentz groups in three and four dimensions in the next sections .
+ the above discussion gives the feynman amplitude @xmath169 in terms of the ( g , p ) variables . to make connection with the usual spinfoam we want to write this amplitude in terms of the ( j , p ) variables as well .
this is done by returning to the general expression of the face amplitude ( [ eq : ampl ] ) , inserting the character expansion of the propagator ( [ eq : propagatorjp ] ) and using the fact that the characters satisfy is the kronecker delta in the discrete case and the dirac delta in the continuous .
the easiest way to see that this equation is true comes from seeing that it follows from the fact that the delta functions on the groups compose , i.e. that @xmath170 . ] @xmath171 it is then easy to see that the dual face amplitude is given by ) as if we take the given character expansion of the kernel , plug it into the right hand side of ( [ eq : amplitudegp ] ) and evaluate the integral over t , we obtain exactly the answer given in ( [ eq : amplitudejp ] ) . ] : [ eq : amplitudejp ] a_n [ h ; p ] = _ j _ j(h ) , where n is again the number of dual edges ( vertices ) in the dual face @xmath157 .
going through the standard computations @xcite of group integrals , we can obtain from this formula the spin foam picture of our model .
the amplitude of the dual 2-complex ( the feynman amplitude ) obtained from our model is given by [ eq : spinfoamjp ] z_t^ * = ( _ f^*t^ * _ j_f^ * _ p dp_f^ * ) ( _ f^ * t^ * _ v^ * t^ * \ { } ) .
the sum goes over all labellings of the dual 2-complex by representations of g , and j - symbol stands for the appropriate symbol coming from the representation theory of g ( it is the 6-j symbol in 3 dimensions and 15-j symbol in 4 dimensions ) .
note that the feynman amplitude in these variables is now factorized differently , as it is no longer just a product of amplitudes assigned to dual faces , but , as a result of the group integrations , there are contributions coming from the dual vertices .
+ it is easy to see that , in the spin foam representation , i.e. in momentum space , from the gft perspective , the difference between the new models and the usual ones lies in the amplitudes assigned to the dual faces .
these amplitudes are just just products of the coefficients of the character expansion of the propagators above . however , albeit limited , this difference is crucial and has many consequences : 1 ) it makes the feynman amplitudes complex ; 2 ) it produces truly dynamical propagating quantum degrees of freedom , as the usual feynman propagator of qft does ; 3 ) it selects as dominant contributions to the amplitudes the solutions of the kinematical qft equations of motion , i.e. those for which @xmath172 , which , up to a constant @xmath173 , implies the identification of the @xmath114 s with the lie algebra generators for the group @xmath52 , which , as explained in the previous section , is what we want to mimic the structure of a bf path integral , given the identification ( that we will confirm in detail in presenting the 3d and 4d models ) of the p variables with the discrete analogue of the b field of bf theory .
we report here for completeness also the expression for the feynman amplitudes in the ( j , x ) representation : the propagator was already given above ( [ eq : propagatorjx ] ) .
the vertex is completely analogous to the one we gave in the ( g , p ) variables ( under the substitutions g @xmath174 x and p @xmath174 j ) , with the sole difference that the whole expression is now multiplied by the appropriate @xmath175 .
now , however , there is a difference between models a and b mentioned at the beginning of this section , as the delta functions on the x variables are different .
+ @xmath176 = \prod_{i=1}^d \bigg ( \delta_{j_{1,i } j_{2,i } } \ , k \bigg [ x_i - y_i , \pm c_j + \frac{d}{24 } m^2 \bigg ] \bigg ) , \ ] ] where k is the schroedinger kernel in the mass representation . note that this expression is basically the same as the propagator in the ( g , p ) variables ( [ eq : propagatoriskernel ] ) , showing that the formulations of the theory in the ( g , p ) variables and in the ( j , x ) ones are dual to each other .
there is an important difference however , which spoils this duality which is the extra symmetry the field satisfies in the g variables ( shift invariance ) which has no analogue in the x ones .
this is the reason there is no integral in the above expression over the space x analogous to the integral over h in ( [ eq : propagatoriskernel ] ) .
+ the vertex is completely analogous to the one we gave in the ( g , p ) variables ( under the substitutions g @xmath174 x and p @xmath174 j ) , with the sole difference that the whole expression is now multiplied by the appropriate @xmath175 .
+ if we use now these ingredients to calculate the feynman amplitudes @xmath177 , we get the following @xmath178 with the dual face amplitude @xmath179 being given by either arising from contracting all the representation kronecker deltas around a dual face . ]
@xmath180,\ ] ] or @xmath181,\ ] ] where , as mentioned above , k is just the schroedinger kernel on x. @xmath182 is a function , with value either @xmath183 or @xmath184 , of the combinatorics of the triangulation and the assignment of the orientation data ( the @xmath95 s ) to the triangulation whose exact form is not important here , as we are not going to use or discuss this particular representation of the feynman amplitudes .
+ notice the marked difference with the same quantity in the ( g , p ) representation ( which is especially clear in model b where the above amplitudes are completely independent of the x variables ) .
this is due to the absence of the analogue of the shifting gauge integrals .
let us summarize what we have discussed so far .
we have defined a new class of generalized gft models in ( [ eqnarray : actiongx ] , [ eqnarray : actiongp ] , [ eqnarray : actionjp ] , [ eqnarray : actionjx ] ) .
we then analyzed the feynman rules of the theory .
the vertex is easily seen to be almost the standard one .
the propagator for the theory ( which in a sense encodes most of the new features of the model ) is obtained using the schwinger - dewitt parametrization .
we have then constructed the feynman amplitudes of the model in both the ( g , p ) , ( j , p ) and ( j , x ) variables .
some general features of the new models are already apparent at this stage , such as the complexity of the amplitudes , the presence of propagating degrees of freedom at the quantum level , the relaxation at the quantum level of the relation between ( the discrete analogue of ) the b field and the generators of the lie algebra of the group g. we will now move on , and present in detail the model one obtains from this general definition in the 3d and 4d cases , in both riemannian and lorentzian settings . in doing so , the above features will become even clearer , as in particular it will become clearer the geometric interpretation of both the p and the g variables .
moreover , we will see that the feynman amplitudes of the new models , in the ( g , p ) variables , have indeed the form of path integrals for simplicial quantum gravity of the form of a bf theory restricted to positive orientation .
this extra condition is what makes the feynman amplitudes we get not triangulation independent . here
we discuss the relation between the new and the usual models .
there are two ways in which one re - obtains the more traditional gfts and spin foam models for bf theory , as an appropriate restriction , from these generalized ones ( the same was true for the models proposed in @xcite ) . *
the conventional gfts are obtained when we take the static - ultra - local limit @xcite of the action ( [ eqnarray : actiongx ] ) , and for a specific choice of the mass parameter @xmath185 ( which however does not play any role in the resulting amplitudes ) . in this limit
one gets rid of the propagation in the theory by replacing the derivatives in the kinetic term with delta functions : + @xmath186\;\;\rightarrow\;\ ; \bigg [ \prod_{i=1}^d\,\delta(g_i , g_i')\delta(\nu_i x_i + \nu_i ' x_i ' ) \bigg ] .\ ] ] + if we do this in ( [ eqnarray : actiongx ] ) we will obtain essentially the usual gft model but with the sole difference of having extra arguments which the field depends on .
+ how are the feynman amplitudes affected by these extra variables ? since there is no coupling between the group and the x ( or p ) variables , they are just propagated in parallel around the feynman graph .
the upshot of this is that the extra variables x ( or p ) contribute just an overall ( infinite ) constant and thus do not affect the amplitudes , that reduce then to the usual spin foam models . + * another way of looking at the relation between the new model and the conventional , which clarifies the fact the new model is the causal analogue of the usual ones , comes from considering the theory in the ( j , p ) variables . + take a single propagator and look at its character expansion ( [ eq : propagatorjp ] ) . as is clear from this equation that the coefficients of the characters are just the usual klein - gordon propagators on a flat space x , whose dimensions is equal to the dimension of the group g and which has a metric which is the killing form .
also , it is clear that it is from here that the complexity ( thus the causal nature , as we discussed ) of the amplitudes comes . using sohozki s formula @xmath187 and the reality of characters ) ( from which the propagator is derived ) in a symmetric way , such that the coefficients of characters which are complex conjugates of each other are real and equal . ]
, it follows that the real part of the propagator is given by + [ eq : onshell ] d_f [ g_i , h_i ; p_i , q_i ] = _ i=1^d ( ( p_i - q_i ) _ g dh ) . notice that taking the real part of the propagator is the same as going on - shell with respect to the corresponding equation of motion , which is the classical relation between the p variables and the lie algebra generators of the group g , or , as we will confirm in the next sections and we have discussed in the previous , between the b and the a field of bf theory ( metricity of the connection ) .
if we do now the integrals over the p variables it is immediate that we just get the propagator and thus the whole spin foam amplitudes of the usual gfts , as the delta functions integrate to one .
let us stress once more that the causalnature of the new models , i.e. the fact that their amplitudes are complex functions of the geometric data , interpretable , as we will confirm in the next sections , as discrete gravity path integrals , results exactly from the lifting of a classical equation of motion ( a discrete analogue , we argue , of the relation between b and a in bf theory ) to allow for off - shell propagation .
one could go further and argue that it is this quantum lifting of a classical condition that allows us to go beyond usual bf theory , where it is only the classically allowed flat configurations that have non - zero amplitude in the path integral .
+ notice also that the situation here is entirely analogous to what happens in the case of a free relativistic quantum particle .
the real part of the propagator @xmath188 is simply the on - shell condition @xmath189 .
it is crucial to allow the momentum to go over the classically disallowed value in order to have genuine quantum behaviour of the system .
this is also what characterizes time - ordered products of field operators with respect to other 2-point functions in scalar field theory + however , even though the above interpretation is intriguing and in line with what our initial motivations were and our results of the next sections will show , we feel that there is much more left to understand about the physics behind the above outlined relation between the new models and the traditional bf ones , as well as about the relation between the two ways , discussed here , in which one can re - obtain the traditional models from these new ones .
we leave this for future work .
we now specialize the class of models considered above to the case d=3 and g = su(2 ) .
the usual models ( with the trivial kinetic term ) , for this choice of dimension and group , give euclidean 3-d bf theory , augmented by a sum over topologies , in perturbative expansion .
+ the action ( [ eqnarray : actiongp ] ) becomes @xmath190 \phi(g_i ; p_i ) + { } \\ & & { } + \frac{\lambda}{(2\pi)^{36 } 4 ! } \sum_{\nu_1 \ldots \nu_4 } \int_{g^{12 } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{4 } \ , dg_{ij }
\bigg ) \ , \int_{p^{12 } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{4 } dp_{ij } \bigg ) \ , \ , \ , \bigg [ \prod_{i < j } \delta(g_{ij } g_{ji}^{-1 } ) \delta(p_{ij } - p_{ji } ) \bigg ] \times { } \\ & & { } \times \phi^{\nu_1}(g_{1j } ; p_{1j } ) \ldots \phi^{\nu_4}(g_{4 j } ; p_{4 j}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] su(2 ) is a compact group of rank one , hence the kernel depends on a single periodic parameter .
it is convenient to choose this parameter to be the angle of rotation in the usual representation of su(2 ) .
more precisely , if h @xmath146 g then @xmath191 where @xmath192 is the angle of rotation , @xmath193 is the axis of rotation and @xmath194 are the pauli matrices .
the angle @xmath192 is a _ multivalued _ function of the group element .
this should be clear as @xmath192 and @xmath195 for @xmath196 correspond to the same group element .
in other words , any choice of @xmath106 in the expression @xmath197 provides a possible definition of the angle characterizing the holonomy @xmath198 .
what this means is that from a geometrical point of view , the angle of rotation , is intrinsically an equivalence class of real numbers modulo addition of @xmath199 .
we will denote this equivalence class by @xmath200 = \theta(h ) \
, \textrm{mod } \ , 4 \pi$ ] , and identify @xmath201 $ ] , i.e. @xmath197 for any choice of @xmath106 , with the holonomy angle .
however , since the equivalence class is not a number , to write any formula involving the angle of rotation , one should pick a representative of the equivalence class ( i.e. choose a specific @xmath106 , for example @xmath202 thus restricting oneself to the @xmath203 $ ] range ) .
this random choice , does not matter if the function is automatically periodic when @xmath204 ( e.g. the character function ) .
however , when the functional expression one is dealing with is not periodic ( the evolution kernel below ) , one needs to sum over all the equivalence classes ( all possible @xmath106 to obtain a function with the correct boundary conditions , i.e. a function on the group .
+ the explicit form of the evolution kernel on su(2 ) in ( proper ) time @xmath151 is given @xcite by the following formula [ eq : su2kernel ] k [ h , t ] = _
n=- ^ ( exp ) .
note the sum enforcing periodicity in @xmath205 . to avoid writing the sums which enforce periodicity in what follows
, we adopt the following notation : whenever we have a sum which enforces periodicity of a certain function , i.e. whenever have an expression of the form @xmath206 , we will just write @xmath207)$ ] . the sum , which is required to convert an expression involving @xmath208 $ ] to a legitimate one involving just real numbers , will be kept implicit .
this is perfectly reasonable from the geometric point of view as well , as it is exactly the entire equivalence class that has the meaning of an angle of rotation .
this sum has also the meaning of a sum over all geodesics over the group ( i.e. @xmath0 ) connecting the same two points @xcite .
+ once more , we define the partition function of the model as a perturbative expansion in feynman diagrams : @xmath117 and , again , the feynman amplitudes factorize per dual face : @xmath209 according to ( [ eq : amplitudegp ] ) , to get the amplitude @xmath156 for a dual face with n vertices in the ( g , p ) variables , we should multiply the expression for the evolution kernel by @xmath210 and then take the fourier transform of the result , with respect to @xmath151 , at the value @xmath211 , where @xmath212 is the 3x3 identity matrix . as a consequence , since the metric on the dual to x is given in terms of the inverse of this killing form , @xmath213 . ] .
+ thus [ eq : su2amplitude ] a_n = _
n=- ^ ( _ 0^ dt t^n - exp ) the integral can be evaluated explicitly @xcite using the formula [ eq : hankel ] _ 0^ dt t^-1 exp = i^+1 q^ h_^(1)(q p ) , where @xmath214 is a hankel function of the first kind of order @xmath95 .
the two coefficients p and q are complex numbers in general , but what is very important is that they should satisfy ( im@xmath215 and im@xmath216 )
. it should be obvious that this should be the case as the integrals will simply not converge otherwise .
note that while the left hand side has @xmath217 in it , the right hand side has @xmath218 .
the fact that we have to take a square root will be very important in the lorentzian case .
+ for us [ eq : pq ]
= n - , p = ^2 - q^2 = .
it is clear that @xmath219 and @xmath220 ) imply that both the @xmath221 and the @xmath192 should be complexified and given small positive imaginary parts .
this complexification is nothing but the usual feynman @xmath222 prescription .
the root of @xmath217 is defined in the usual way , by taking a cut along the negative real axis , letting @xmath223 and extending by continuity . as
both the numerator and denominator have small phases ( both are positive ) , their ratio also has a small phase .
thus the square root of @xmath217 is very close to the real axis and is very nearly equal to @xmath224 |}{|\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4}|}$ ] .
+ plugging ( [ eq : hankel ] ) into ( [ eq : su2amplitude ] ) we get @xmath225 = \frac{i^{n-2}}{16 \sqrt{\pi } ( n-1 ) ! } \bigg [ \ , \ , \frac { [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] } { \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) } \bigg ( \frac{| \ , [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] \ , |}{\sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4 } } } \bigg ) ^{n- \frac{3}{2 } } \bigg ] \ , h^{(1)}_{n-\frac{3}{2 } } \big ( \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4 } } \ , | \ , \ , \ , [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] \ , | \big ) .\ ] ] the hankel function of half - integer order can be given explicitly in terms of elementary functions via [ eq : polynomial ] h_n - ^(1)(z ) = i^- ( n-1 ) \ { _ k=0^n-2 ( -1)^k } e^iz . using this expression
we get that the dual face amplitude has the form [ eq : ramplitudemeasure ] a_n = ( [ ( h ) ] , || , n ) e^i | [ ( h ) ] | , with @xmath136 being given by @xmath226 \ , , \ , ( n-1 ) ! } \bigg [ \frac{1}{\textrm{sin } ( [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] ) } \bigg ( \frac{| [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] |}{\sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4}}}\bigg ) ^{n-1 } \bigg ] \times { } \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : measure } & & { } \times \bigg \ { \sum_{k=0}^{n-2 } \big ( -1 \big ) ^k \frac{(n + k -2)!}{k ! ( n - k-2 ) ! } \frac{1}{\big ( 2 i \sqrt{\vec{p } - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4 } } \ , \ , | [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] | \big ) ^k } \bigg \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] above , we have given the amplitude for just one dual face , or recalling that in 3d a dual face is dual to an edge of the triangulation , it is the amplitude for a single edge . however , as was mentioned in the previous section , the amplitude of the dual complex in the ( g , p ) variables is just the product of the dual - face amplitudes , or in the 3d context the product of edge amplitudes .
thus , we can easily write the amplitude for the whole triangulation ( feynman graph ) @xmath227 . it is [ eq : partition ] z_t = _ g^e^ * ( _ e^ * t^ * dg_e^ * ) _ p^e ( _ e t d_e ) ( g_e^ * , ^2_e , n_e ) e^i _ e | [ _ e ] | , where the products go over all edges in the triangulation @xmath228 and all dual edges in the dual 2-complex @xmath229 , and the factor @xmath230 is a product of all the @xmath136 s coming from each dual face i.e. @xmath231 with @xmath232 given by ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) .
+ now , consider the exponent in the above expression .
we see immediately that it is just the regge action for euclidean 3d gravity @xmath233 in 1st order form , after identification of @xmath234 with @xmath235 . here
the sum goes over all edges of the triangulation .
@xmath235 stands for the length of the edge e and @xmath236 for the deficit angle , i.e. the discretized curvature , around the dual edge , which coincides with the angle of rotation @xmath237 $ ] that characterizes our holonomies @xmath238 ( again , equivalent to @xmath197 for any choice of @xmath106 ) . + this reconfirms and makes precise the interpretation for the new variables , the @xmath94 s , which was proposed in the introduction , as that they give the length of the edges to which they are associated , and thus as representing the discretized triad ( b field ) associated with these edges , while the group elements are confirmed as a discretization of the lorentz connection field @xmath66 .
indeed , we obtain an expression for the simplicial gravity action of the same type as the ones in @xcite , and , as there , with the edge lengths ( hinge volumes ) restricted to have a positive orientation .
note that this identification of the length with the variable p becomes especially nice if we set @xmath239 , as then it is the length of @xmath240 directly , @xmath241 , which coincides with the length of the edge @xmath235 .
for this reason , as well as to simplify the formulae , we will adopt this choice for @xmath242 in the following discussion of the amplitude in the ( g , p ) variables .
+ it is clear that the variation of the above action with respect to the edge lengths , or the variables @xmath240 , gives the classical equation @xmath243 , i.e. imposes flatness of the discrete geometry as the only _ classically _ allowed configuration , as we expect from 3d gravity .
the variation with respect to the connection variables is more involved , and we would expect it to provide a discrete analogue of the continuum conditions enforcing metricity of the connection .
we leave its analysis for future work @xcite .
+ the amplitude for the triangulation @xmath227 is then just the partition function for discrete 3d euclidean gravity , in 1st order form , with a measure factor @xmath244 , as desired .
let us now consider the measure factor @xmath245 , in more detail .
this factor is a complex number in general as should be evident from ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) .
thus if we write @xmath246 with s_c ( g_e^ * , ^2_e , n_e ) = _ e [ sc ] , we see that the full feynman amplitude for the whole triangulation has the form @xmath247 } .\ ] ] the modulus of the quantum measure @xmath248 , i.e. @xmath249 is then what should be considered as a proper quantum measure factor in our path integral , while the phase @xmath250 gives what can be interpreted as quantum corrections to the regge action ( hence the subscript ) .
we thus see that the amplitudes of our model , more precisely , have the form of a path integral ( with an explicitly defined measure ) of an extended 1st order regge calculus , in which the regge action is extended by ( also explicitly computable ) quantum corrections .
+ let us then study in more detail these quantum corrections , in order to confirm their geometric meaning and thus their proposed interpretation .
we then study the explicit formula ( [ sc ] ) for @xmath251 as well as the expression ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) .
also , we focus on the dependence on the geometric data @xmath94 and @xmath252 , neglecting constant factors , which give a constant contribution to the phase at every edge ( equal to @xmath253 ) . + one of the most important properties of this part of expression ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) is that it depends on @xmath254 $ ] and @xmath240 solely through the combination ( @xmath255 |$ ] ) , weighted by factors that will necessarily be purely combinatorial , i.e. dependent on @xmath256 only .
+ under the interpretation discussed above for the p variables and for the @xmath252 , a first possible interpretation of the powers of the expression ( @xmath257 ) is that they represent the discrete analogues of higher order corrections to the einstein - hilbert action , given by powers of the ricci scalar @xcite .
one could then expect the correspondence @xmath258
| \big ) ^k \sim \ , \,\int r^k(g ) \ , \ , \textrm{vol } , \ ] ] where @xmath259 is the mentioned combinatorial factor , vol is the volume form and the aforementioned correspondence holds in the continuum approximation ( in the sense of measures ) @xcite .
+ however , the simplicial geometry of such higher powers of the regge term is subtle ( see again @xcite for an extensive and detailed analysis ) . in particular , for the square power of the above expression , another plausible interpretation is provided by the square of the riemann tensor , giving : @xmath260 | \big ) ^2 \sim \ , \,\int r_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}(g ) r^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}(g ) \ , \
, \textrm{vol } .\ ] ] in general , in fact , higher order curvature terms , as traditionally defined in simplicial gravity , involve an additional geometric ingredient , a normalization of the hinge volumes , that gives them the correct dimensionless character .
this is taken to be the contribution of the d - simplex volume associated to the specific hinge considered , @xmath261 , giving a complete quadratic term of the form @xmath262 arguments , to be most likely irrelevant for the continuum correspondence , but of course this is not at all obvious . with this choice of normalizing factor , one can indeed show that ( the discrete analogue of ) both @xmath263 and @xmath264 agree when restricted to a single hinge .
therefore the difference between the two types of higher order terms depends exclusively on how different hinges are coupled , each being weighted individually by the quadratic expression above .
the simplest choice of coupling @xmath265 to the square of the riemann tensor .
other constructions are however possible for both the riemann tensor itself and the quadratic terms that can be constructed from it @xcite .
also , we are not aware of similar detailed analyzes for higher powers , thus for curvature invariants beyond the quadratic order . + in our model , the normalizing volume factor can be interpreted as being given by the planck length to the appropriate power and multiplied by our purely combinatorial factor @xmath259 , a function of @xmath256 .
therefore a more complete interpretation scheme for the higher order corrections to the regge action provided by our gfts does involve a careful analysis of these combinatorial factors and in particular of the way they couple different hinges in the same d - simplex and beyond .
this analysis will be performed and reported elsewhere @xcite .
+ from a more general perspective , however , these corrections to the regge action , predicted by our model(s ) share two main features : 1 ) they involve , as mentioned , both positive and negative powers of the curvature invariants , and 2 ) they depend on two independent sets of geometric variables , the ( discrete analogues of ) the d - bein and the connection fields .
this implies , therefore , that the corrections to the bare regge action produced by the model are of the general f(r ) type in the metric affine formalism @xcite .
+ we would like to emphasize once more that these corrections are not arbitrary , rather their form , including relative coefficients weighting them , and their behaviour in the various regimes of the theory are fully determined by the our choice of the original gft action .
this also means of course that one can modify the exact dependence on them of the simplicial action appearing in our feynman amplitudes , by modifying the same gft action , thus constructing different specific models within the general class of gfts we have defined .
+ let us analyze further the physics behind the corrections @xmath251 .
we are most interested in two approximations , both of which can be given a clear physical interpretation .
+ the first regime is when the lengths becomes large , i.e. when @xmath266 ( remember that we are working in planck units ) .
equivalently , this is the regime of large actions , in units of the planck s constant , due to the way in which the edge lengths enter the discrete regge action .
this approximation can thus be considered as a semiclassical approximation as it corresponds to the case where the relative size of the quantum fluctuations of the action ( and of the edge lengths ) is small .
this is the analogue , for our models , of the asymptotics usually considered in the standard spin foams ( the large j asymptotic ) .
+ the second regime is approached when the edge lengths and discrete curvatures become small , and the triangulation becomes finer and finer , i.e. when @xmath267 | ) \rightarrow 0 $ ] and @xmath268 .
this can be thought of as the continuum approximation .
+ let us first look at the behaviour of the measure and thus of the quantum corrections @xmath251 at the heuristic level .
consider then the explicit expression for the ( complex ) measure in ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) , and in particular to the part of it within curly brackets .
+ in the first case ( large lengths @xmath241 ) it is the first term in the sum in ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) that dominates , and since this term is real , it means the regge action remains the dominant contribution to the phase of the path integral amplitude .
we expect then the phase , including corrections , to be of the general form @xmath269 , thus with inverse powers of the curvature to play the role of quantum corrections to the regge action , and the full feynman amplitude ( discrete gravity path integral ) to be approximated by @xmath270 \bigg [ \frac{[\theta_e]^{2(n_e-1)}}{\textrm{sin } ( [ \ , \theta_e \ , ] ) } \bigg ( \frac{1}{|\vec{p}_e| [ \theta_e]}\bigg ) ^{n_e-1 } \bigg ] \times { } \\ & & { } \times \bigg [ 1 + o \bigg ( \frac{1}{|\vec{p}_e| [ \theta_e ] } \bigg ) \bigg ] \bigg \ } \ , \ , e^{i \big [ s_{regge } ( g_{e^ * } , |\vec{p}_e| ) + o ( 1 / |\vec{p}_e| [ \theta_e ] ) \big ] } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the second case ( small edge lengths and very fine triangulation , i.e. high @xmath256 ) it is the last term in the sum in ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) that dominates .
this term also contributes just a constant to @xmath251 ( equal to @xmath271 ) .
we expect then the phase , including corrections , to be of the general form @xmath272 , thus with positive powers of the curvature to play the role of quantum corrections to the regge action , and the full feynman amplitude ( discrete gravity path integral ) to be dominated by a term like : @xmath273)^{2(n_e-1)}}{\textrm{sin } ( [ \ , \theta_e \ , ] ) } \bigg ( \frac{1}{|\vec{p}_e| [ \theta_e]}\bigg ) ^{2n_e-3 } \bigg ] \bigg \ } \ , \ , e^{i \big [ s_{regge } ( g_{e^ * } , \vec{p}^2_e ) \ , + \ , o(\sum_e ( | \vec{p}_e| \theta_e)^2 ) \big ] } .\ ] ] we would like now to go beyond the naive heuristic considerations and analyze the form of the quantum measure , and of @xmath251 in particular , in more detail .
+ this can be done with full confidence for the semiclassical approximation .
the reason for this is that ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) , and thus the full feynman amplitude , is regular at the limiting point @xmath274 ( it goes simply to zero ) , for a generic triangulation .
also , the proper analysis involves the asymptotic expansion of the hankel function for large values of the argument , but , for half - integer order , this _ coincides _ with the expression ( [ eq : polynomial ] ) that we have used .
this allows us to obtain full understanding of the way the phase behaves in the large length limit .
we can then use directly the expression ( [ sc ] ) and , expanding the arctangent in powers of @xmath275 , we get that @xmath276.\ ] ] of course , all the coefficients in the expansion can , in principle be computed within our model .
as said , we can think of @xmath277 as the inverse of the scalar curvature .
thus @xmath278 \textrm{vol}$ ] .
since the corrections are inverse in the curvature , they are of the infrared type , as it is intuitively to be expected as we are doing a large scale approximation to out model . thus we see that the new model predicts long - distance effects , at the simplicial level , of the same type as those predicted by effective @xmath1-extended gravity models , and that have been found relevant in cosmological applications ( most notably for modelling dark energy effects ) @xcite .
+ the other case of interest ( the continuum limit ) is much more involved to analyze , and the purely heuristic argument can be trusted as a limited indication of the relevant physics ( it is intuitively obvious that in the small distance regime one gets quantum corrections of the ultraviolet type @xmath279 ) , but one that can not be easily confirmed by a detailed analysis , at this point . +
the reason for this is that , as is not difficult to see from ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) , the feynman amplitude has a badly singular point in ( @xmath280 ) : 1 ) it diverges in the limit like @xmath281 ; 2 ) the hankel function has a branch point at 0 , which poses extra problems one needs to deal with due to the stokes phenomenon , whose main consequence is , in this context , that the expression for the amplitude around this point depends heavily on how exactly the limit is taken , i.e. which path one takes in the complex domain to approach the singular point . finally , the limit @xmath267 | ) \rightarrow 0 $ ] by itself is not very physically meaningful .
it acquires its importance when combined with the limit @xmath268 .
however , it is not difficult to see that the way the amplitude behaves is sensitive to the way these two limits are combined . due to the above reasons we defer the detailed treatment of this regime of the model , as well as of the corresponding formulation of simplicial geometry for future work @xcite .
+ finally , let us note that the fact that the amplitude diverges as @xmath281 is very appealing intuitively , as it implies that for larger triangulations it is the small values of @xmath282 that are the most relevant ones and that they become more and more dominant as we take larger and larger triangulations ( this is because the higher powers are more divergent ) .
+ since we have interpreted the p variables as giving the lengths of the edges of the triangulation , this looks exactly like the behaviour one would want in order to recover a good continuum limit : for a triangulation consisting of a large number of tetrahedra , the dominant histories are those for which the basic simplices are small , corresponding moreover to a singularity in the quantum amplitudes . + the new model is a causal one in the sense of @xcite and it shares many features of the 3d model presented in @xcite . let us briefly recall the model proposed there .
the action used in @xcite is a discretized version of ( [ eq : bfaction ] ) .
the b field is replaced with a lie algebra element @xmath283 associated to every edge of the triangulation , and the connection a is substituted by its holonomy around the dual face @xmath284 .
the discrete action is then given by @xmath285 the model is quantized via the path integral method in the usual way the only crucial difference being that the product @xmath286 is restricted to be nonnegative .
this is because , as was argued in @xcite , this corresponds to restricting the discretzied volume to be positive , and thus it represents the wanted implementation of the causalityrestriction in quantum gravity transition amplitudes .
thus the partition function is given by which is the deficit angle around the edge with the heaviside step function @xmath287 . ]
[ eq : causalpartition ] z = _
g^e^ * ( _ e^ * t^ * dg_e^ * ) _ p^e ( _ e t d _ e ) ( _ e _ e ) e^i _ e _ e ( _ e ) . the new model , which generates amplitudes given by ( [ eq : partition ] ) , is causal in the same sense as ( [ eq : causalpartition ] ) due to the simple fact that the @xmath241 is always positive .
thus , keeping the interpretation of the p s in mind , in our gft model the integral over the discretized field is also restricted to be such that the hinge volumes are positive .
this restriction results @xcite in the causal analogues of usual spin foams in both the free and matter coupled cases .
+ there are several differences , however , between the model proposed here and the one proposed in @xcite , i.e. between ( [ eq : partition ] ) and ( [ eq : causalpartition ] ) . * first
, the discretizations used in the two cases are somewhat different .
although , both use the holonomies to represent the curvature and both average the b field over an edge ( and get a vector ) , the way these two objects enter into the discrete action is slightly different .
notably , the two variables are totally independent in the new model and interact simply through multiplicative coupling , at least before one uses the equations of motion resulting from the variation of the simplicial action . in the old model however , the variables mix more substantially : a ) there is extra coupling introduced by the dot product @xmath288 ( @xmath289 is completely absent from the action in ( [ eq : partition ] ) ) ; and b ) the domains of integration of the two variables are interdependent , due to the step function . with regards to both these points
the new model is _ simpler _ than the old one .
it is well possible , however , that one can get a 3d model , in the same new class of gfts we are proposing , that is closer to the one in @xcite by imposing additional ( symmetry ) conditions on the variables appearing in the gft action . *
the measure factor @xmath290 present in ( [ eq : partition ] ) is absent from ( [ eq : causalpartition ] ) .
these are , as discussed above , corrections to the bare regge action ( and thus to the 3d bf action ) that have been here deduced from first principles and not added in an ad hoc way ( which of course could be done with ( [ eq : causalpartition ] ) ) .
thus the new model is significantly richer than the old one . also with respect to this point ,
we notice that there is still freedom left in choosing specific gft actions within the general class of gfts we introduced , and thus obtaining models with modified ( and possibly simpler ) path integral measures in the perturbative expansion . * due to the fact that the factor @xmath290 depends on @xmath256 , it should be clear that if we perform the integrals over the p s in ( [ eq : partition ] ) we will get dual face amplitudes which depend on the number of vertices in each dual face , i.e. each dual face amplitude is a function of @xmath256 .
this however is not the case in the old model where the dual face amplitudes , which were computed explicitly in @xcite were independent of this factor .
the reason for this can be traced to the following fact . at the spin foam level , and in the construction of @xcite , the basic building block of the model was considered to be the dual face . at the gft level , it is necessarily the wedge ( i.e. the portion of the dual face contained within a d - simplex ) from which everything else is constructed @xcite .
the causal restriction advocated for in @xcite was a dual - face one , and this is the reason for the independence of the resulting amplitudes from the number of wedges ( vertices ) making the dual face .
one would expect that if the construction in @xcite is repeated but with the causality restriction being imposed at the level of each wedge , one would obtain a model which is closer to the one reproduced here .
* finally , in @xcite the causal restriction , although shown plausible , was implemented essentially by hand simply by inserting the step function into the partition function ( [ eq : causalpartition ] ) ; therefore one could be left wondering about the possibility of different ways of implementing the same type of causal restriction . in the new model(s ) we are proposing such freedom is absent , at least for given choice of gft action : the amplitudes are built , in a _
unique _ manner , from the same building block , the propagator , and it is exactly the propagator that has the information about causality , orientation dependence and the propagation of quantum degrees of freedom .
consider now the model in the ( j , p ) variables ( i.e. equation ( [ eq : amplitudejp ] ) specified for @xmath291 and g= su(2 ) ) [ eq : rspinfoamjp ] z_=(_f*t^*_j_f^ * _ p d^3 _ f^ * ) _ f^ * t^ * _ v^ * t^ * \ { 6-j } , where of course now the representations are labelled by half - integers @xmath292 . since it is the p s that give the lengths , the interpretation of the j variables is not as straightforward as it is in the usual models .
looking at the expression above we can see that the j s label the different poles of the dual face amplitude . since the expression for the dual face amplitude is essentially a product of feynman propagators we can think of the j variables as labelling the different semi - classical , on - shell values of @xmath241 .
the poles are @xmath293 if we make the same choice for @xmath242 as before , i.e. if we set @xmath294 , then we see that @xmath295 .
+ notice that if we plug this back into the path integral .
we can heuristically interpret this restriction as imposing the connection metricity equation of motion ( i.e. the equation obtained by varying the connection ) into the path integral .
] into ( [ eq : partition ] ) we see that it becomes @xmath296 from which we see that the exponent is just the regge action with the edge length restricted to be @xmath297 .
this matches nicely with the expression obtained in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) for the eigenvalues of the length operator in 3d canonical quantum gravity .
+ of course , this does not really mean that the lengths are quantized in our model .
this is because the length information is given by @xmath241 s and these are unconstrained , in general . just like in the feynman propagator for a scalar particle
the momentum is not constrained , in the quantum theory , to the mass shell .
+ we can now obtain a pure spin foam expression for the feynman amplitudes of our model , i.e. one involving only the representation variables .
it is not difficult to perform the integrations over @xmath298 s in ( [ eq : rspinfoamjp ] ) .
the easiest way to do this is by using cauchy s formula to @xmath299 and then closing the contour in the complex plane . by jordan
s lemma , since @xmath300 , the integral of the expression we have along a semicircle centered at the origin of radius r , goes to zero as r @xmath301 .
this allows us to add this bit to the integral closing the contour . ] .
the result of these integrations is given by @xmath302 where the dual face amplitude is given by [ eq : rspinfoamj ] a_f^ * ( j_f^ * , n_f^ * ) = 4 ^2 ^n_f^*-1 .
let us now try to extract some physical information on the model , and in particular how it depends on the combinatorics of the underlying triangulation , starting from this expression for the amplitudes .
+ consider the regime of large @xmath303 , i.e. consider the triangulations which are composed of many tetrahedra , which we have argued is one ingredient for approximating continuum physics in this setting
. this should be combined with a small @xmath282 approximation ; however , having integrated out the p s , we can only expect to read out from the amplitudes what are the dominant configurations in the @xmath304 variables .
using stirling s formula @xmath305 we can easily see that the second multiplicand in ( [ eq : rspinfoamj ] ) is asymptotic to @xmath306 .
thus for large @xmath307 s [ eq : asymptotic ] a_f^ * ( j_f^ * , n_f^ * ) ~ ^n_f^*-1 , where f is a function of polynomial growth . + we conclude that the amplitude consisting of a large number of tetrahedra is dominated ( as this is when @xmath308 ) by the two lowest values of j s , @xmath309 , which can be thought of as the vacuum configuration , and @xmath310 , which is some sort of lowest excited state .
so , if we interpret the values of @xmath304 as edge lengths , as in usual spin foam models , it is the shortest values that are the dominant ones for fine triangulations , as we would expect . in the limit of finer and finer triangulations ( which , again , we would expect to lead to a continuum approximation of the discrete path integral , then , the partition function can be reasonably well approximated by a purely combinatorial sum , with amplitudes given by the above quantities evaluated at @xmath311 , i.e. for purely equilateral triangulation with edge lengths @xmath312 .
in other word , in this regime , the model would effectively , and _ dynamically _ , reduce to a pure dynamical triangulations model @xcite .
+ consider the regime of large @xmath292 s .
again , having integrated out the trueedge length variables @xmath94 , we can heuristically interpret this regime as a large distance approximation .
looking again at the same expression ( [ eq : rspinfoamj ] ) , it is clear that it is the lowest values of @xmath307 s that are most relevant in the limit .
what this means is that if we look at the large length limit the most important feynman diagrams are represented by the simplest triangulations , more precisely those with least number of vertices for each dual face . in other words ,
_ if one is interested only in large distance and semi - classical physics _
, then considering simple triangulations would suffice , as the gft partition function , in perturbative expansion , is anyway dominated by such configurations .
this leads further support to the nice results obtained in the calculation of the lattice graviton propagator in @xcite , working indeed in the context of the large - j limit of spin foam models , and using semi - classical boundary states based on simple boundary triangulations , as well as very simple bulk triangulations ( low order in the gft coupling constant @xmath84 ) .
+ these considerations should however be taken with care , since the @xmath313 are not , strictly speaking edge lengths , as we have stressed above , this role being in fact played by the @xmath94 variables .
we hope that the above results underlie the fertility and potential usefulness of the proposed model in understanding quantum geometry .
we now move on to the case when d=3 and g = sl(2,@xmath314 ) @xmath315 su(1,1 ) , i.e. g is the double cover of the lorentz group in three dimensions .
thus , this model corresponds to the lorentzian gravity in 3d .
+ su(1,1 ) has two nonconjugate cartan subgroups .
this is easy to see as @xmath316 can be obtained by complexifying two of the generators of @xmath39 .
thus we would obtain a generator of rotation and two generators of boosts .
the cartan subgroups are thus the two subgroups generated by these different elements .
one cartan subgroup is just u(1 ) generated by the uncomplexified element , we will denote its conjugacy class by r ( for rotation ) .
the other cartan subgroup is generated by one of the complexified elements and it is a noncompact group ( isomorphic to @xmath314 ) whose conjugacy class we will denote by b ( for boost ) .
+ the fact that they are cartan subgroups means that any element of su(1,1 ) is conjugate to either an element of r or of b apart from a set of elements of measure zero in the haar measure .
su(1,1 ) . if @xmath317 then g @xmath146 b. if @xmath318 then g @xmath146 r. the set of elements which satisfy @xmath319 is a set of measure zero . ] the conjugacy classes of the elements of r will be parametrized by a periodic parameter @xmath252 ( angle ) for which we choose a normalization such that its period is @xmath320 . while the conjugacy classes of the elements of b will be parametrized by a real number @xmath127 ( the boost parameter , rapidity ) .
+ the explicit formula for the evolution kernel in proper time is given by the following formula @xcite @xmath321 & = & \frac{1}{(4 \pi i t ) ^{\frac{3}{2 } } } \frac { [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] } { 2 sin\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big)}\ , \ , \ , \ , exp \bigg [ \frac{i}{2 t } [ \ , \theta(h ) \,]^2 + \frac{i t}{8 } \bigg ] \qquad \qquad \qquad \textrm{when } h \in r \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : su11kernel } & & \\ & = & \frac{1}{(4 \pi i t ) ^{\frac{3}{2 } } } \frac{\psi(h ) } { 2 sinh\big(\frac{\psi(h)}{2 } \big)}\ , \ , \ , \ , exp \bigg [ - \frac{i}{2 t } \psi^2 + \frac{i t}{8 } \bigg ] \qquad \qquad \qquad \quad \ ,
\textrm{when } h \in b \nonumber , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the same notation for the periodic parameter @xmath252 as in the previous subsection . + note that when the holonomy group element is a rotation then the su(1,1 ) evolution kernel has exactly the same form as the su(2 ) one ( [ eq : su2kernel ] ) .
the crucial difference between the rotation and the boost cases is the different sign sitting in front of the parameters in the two cases ; plus in the rotation case and minus in the boost case .
+ once more we are interested in the partition function of the theory , expanded perturbatively in feynman diagrams @xmath117 and , again , the feynman amplitudes factorize per dual face @xmath322 according to the general formula ( [ eq : amplitudegp ] ) we get the dual face amplitude @xmath156 by multiplying the above expression for the kernel ( [ eqnarray : su11kernel ] ) by @xmath323 and evaluating its fourier transform at @xmath211 .
note that the killing form ( which enters into the definition of @xmath92 ) has now signature @xmath324 .
thus there is one timelike direction ( the generator of the compact subgroup ) and two spacelike ones . using the same normalizations as in the case of su(2 )
, we get @xmath325 .
so , the amplitude for a dual face with n vertices is given by @xmath326 = \frac{1}{(n-1 ) ! } \int_0^{\infty } dt \ ,
t^{n-1 } \ , e^{i t \ , ( p^2 - \frac{m^2}{8 } ) } \ , k[h \ , , \ , t].\ ] ] now , consider the case when h is a rotation ( h @xmath146 r ) . then since the formula for the kernel ( [ eqnarray : su11kernel ] ) is exactly the same as the one we used in the su(2 ) calculation ( [ eq : su2kernel ] ) we can just write down the answer . thus @xmath327 & = & \mu_r \big ( [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] \ , , \ , \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 } \
n \big ) \ , e^{i \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4 } } \ , | \ , [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] \ , |}\\ \mu_r \big ( [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] \ , , \ , \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 } \ , , \
, n \big ) & = & \frac{- i \sqrt{2}}{16 \pi ( n-1 ) ! } \bigg [ \frac{1}{\textrm{sin } ( [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] ) } \bigg ( \frac{| [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] |}{\sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4}}}\bigg ) ^{n-1 } \bigg ] \times { } \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : rsu11amplitudegp } & & { } \times \bigg \ { \sum_{k=0}^{n-2 } \big ( -1 \big ) ^k \frac{(n + k -2)!}{k ! ( n - k-2 ) ! } \frac{1}{\big ( 2 i \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 - 1}{4 } } \ , | [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] | \big ) ^k } \bigg \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these are exactly the same formulae as before ( [ eq : ramplitudemeasure ] ) , ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) , with the difference being that @xmath221 is calculated with the minkowski metric and not the euclidean one , and that this formula is not valid for arbitrary su(1,1 ) element h , rather only when h is a rotation ( h @xmath146 r ) .
note the exponential factor in the amplitude . restricting for the moment to the case when @xmath328
, it should be clear that if we interpret , analogously to the riemannian case , @xmath329 to be the square of the minkowski length of the edge dual to the dual face under consideration , then the above exponent gives exactly the expected contribution to the regge action coming from the edge under consideration . in order to simplify the following formulae and discussion we will set @xmath239 .
this of course also has the effect of making the length of @xmath221 to be directly the square of the edge length .
+ now , the crucial difference between the riemannian and the lorentzian cases lies in the fact that @xmath221 can now go over both positive and negative values . as mentioned above the case when @xmath330 one just gets the exponent in the amplitude above becomes @xmath331 | } $ ] .
a simple oscillating phase .
+ when @xmath221 goes negative , clearly latexmath:[$\sqrt{\vec{p}^2 } = \pm i previous section we know that @xmath221 should have a small positive imaginary part .
this means that when @xmath221 goes from positive to negative values it does so above the origin in the complex .
this means that @xmath221 has values above the cut we used to define the square root in the previous section .
thus we have to choose the positive square root , i.e. @xmath333 ( see the picture ) . plugging this into our exponent we see that it is equal to latexmath:[$e^{- keeping in mind the interpretation of the p variables as that @xmath221 is the length of the corresponding edge of the triangulation
, we see a very interesting phenomenon happening .
the exponent as we said earlier coming from an edge contributes a summand towards the regge action of the triangulation , with @xmath335 $ ] being the deficit angle and @xmath282 being the length of the relevant edge .
now , as long as the length is positive , i.e. @xmath240 is timelike we get an oscillating phase in the partition function . on the other hand
when the @xmath240 goes spacelike making the length negative , we get an exponential suppression of the amplitude . + classically , in the regge action when the edge of the triangulation is timelike , the curvature defect around it has to be a rotation ( think of a massive point particle ) .
we see that quantum mechanically this is not true
. the edge corresponding to a rotational defect can be both timelike and spacelike , however the spacelike case is suppressed exponentially in the path integral .
this is similar to the behaviour exhibited by the feynman propagator of the relativistic point particle ( which is not surprising as we have essentially the same mathematics here ) .
the probability for the particle to propagate inside the lightcone is given by an oscillating phase .
the particle can also leak outside the light cone ( despite being relativistic ) .
but , the probability of doing so is exponentially suppressed . +
this of course is an intuitively satisfying feature of the model .
however , the discussion above was limited to the case when the holonomy h around the dual face is a rotation ( lies in r ) .
+ when h is a boost we can of course repeat the same calculation as before ) gives a hankel function of the second kind . ] .
however , there is no real need to do this .
look at the two expressions in ( [ eqnarray : su11kernel ] ) . note that apart from the factor in front and a phase factor ( @xmath336 ) , the case when g @xmath146 b is just the complex conjugate of the case when g @xmath146 r , due to the difference in the sign in front of the @xmath252 and @xmath127 .
as , from the mathematical point of view , in order to get the dual face amplitude we are taking a fourier transform , we can apply the general theorem that relates the fourier transform of a function to the fourier transform of its conjugate .
namely , if we denote the fourier transform of a function f by @xmath337 $ ] , then @xmath338 = \big ( \mathcal{f}(f)[-k ] \big ) ^*$ ] .
the fourier transform of a complex conjugate of a function is the complex conjugate of the fourier transform evaluated at the negative of the argument . using this we can immediately write down the dual face amplitude in the case when g @xmath146 b. it is given by @xmath327 & = & \mu_b \big ( \psi(h ) \ , , \ ,
\sqrt { \vec{p}^2 } \ , , \ , n \big ) \ , e^{- i \sqrt { - \vec{p}^2 } \ , | \ , \psi(h ) } \\
\mu_b \big ( \psi(h ) \ , , \ , \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 } \ , , \ , n \big ) & = & \frac { \sqrt{2}}{16 \pi ( n-1 ) ! } \bigg [ \frac{1}{\textrm{sinh } ( \psi(h ) ) } \bigg ( \frac { \psi(h ) } { \sqrt{- \vec{p}^2}}\bigg ) ^{n-1 } \bigg ] \times { } \\ & & { } \times \bigg \ { \sum_{k=0}^{n-2 }
\big ( -1 \big ) ^k \frac{(n + k -2)!}{k ! ( n - k-2 ) ! }
\frac{1}{\big ( - 2 i \sqrt{- \vec{p}^2 } \ , | \psi(h ) | \big ) ^k } \bigg \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the formula for @xmath339 is obtained from @xmath340 by letting @xmath341 , replacing @xmath342 $ ] with @xmath343 , switching the trigonometric sine for the hyperbolic one and finally taking the complex conjugate .
of course , by doing the whole calculation from scratch along the same lines as in the riemannian case , one gets the same result .
+ now we can easily see that the behaviour of the amplitude when h is a boost with respect to the different two possibilities of the sign of the @xmath221 is opposite of that when h is a rotation , due to the minus sign in front of @xmath221 in the formula above .
in other words , when @xmath221 is positive , i.e. @xmath344 is a spacelike vector , then we just have an oscillating phase . on the other hand
when @xmath221 goes negative , or equivalently , when @xmath344 becomes timelike , amplitude becomes a decaying exponent . has to have a small positive imaginary part , @xmath221 has a small negative imaginary part .
thus when we go from the positive values to the negative ones , we are doing so under the cut , thus choosing the negative square root @xmath345 . ] again , this is in full agreement with expectations as classically the curvature defect around a spacelike edge is a boost .
+ summarizing , if we put together all the dual face amplitudes and form the amplitude for the whole triangulation then what we get is [ eq : lamplitude ] z_t = _ g^e^ * ( _ e^ * t^ * dg_e^ * ) _ p^e ( _ e t d_e ) ( g^*_e^ * , _ e^2 ,
n_e ) e^i s_regge where as before @xmath136 is the quantum measure factor , being a product of @xmath340 s and @xmath339 s as appropriate , and @xmath346 is given by @xmath347 here @xmath235 stands for the absolute value of the length of the edge e ( @xmath241 ) and @xmath348 stands for the deficit parameter sitting at the edge e ( an angle or a boost ) .
note that they are varied independently of each other showing that we have is 1st order theory .
@xmath349 is a function of both @xmath235 and @xmath348 and is given by the following table [ eq : table ] c|c|c & rotation & boost + timelike & + 1 & + i + spacelike & + i & - 1 thus as we ve said above when the variables are such that one is off - diagonal in this table ( rotation - spacelike or boost - timelike ) one gets exponential suppression of the amplitude .
while when one is on the diagonal then one gets an oscillating phase .
this means that the configurations that do not allow for a simultaneous classical geometric interpretation for both the discrete b field and the discrete connection , i.e. those configurations that would be classically disallowed , are not forbidden but still exponentially suppressed .
we would like to stress the fact that this causal behaviour is not put into the model by hand , but rather emerges naturally from its very definition as there were no arbitrary choices made anywhere in the construction ( once the gft action has been chosen ) .
+ since the formulas in the lorentzian case are so close to those in the riemannian one we can easily carry over all the results from there .
so , it is not difficult to see that ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) carries over without much change .
in fact , there is no change when h is a rotation apart from the definition of p. when h is a boost the angle becomes a boost parameter , the trig sine goes to a hyperbolic one as well as a few sporadic minus signs .
the conclusions deduced from the measure factor carry through without any change in the case in which we have an oscillatory contribution to the partition function ( i.e. a complex exponential ) . the only difference being that when h is a boost , all the phases go to their conjugates , which of course does not affect the qualitative behaviour .
+ when we are off - diagonal in the table , and we have then an exponential suppression , the integrand is , apart from an overall factor ( a power of i ) , real .
this is easiest to see from the fact that , as is evident from ( [ eq : polynomial ] ) , the hankel function for purely imaginary arguments is a ( multiple of ) real function .
thus strictly speaking one just has the measure factor in the path integral and no complex exponential ( whose phase is to be interpreted to be the action ) .
however , we find it far more clear , intuitively , and more insightful from the physical perspective to split again the integrand into a measure factor and an exponent as we did above .
applying this philosophy to @xmath350 , we get corrections to the action @xmath351 of the form @xmath352 , exactly in accordance with expectations , and in complete similarity with the results obtained in the other cases . + as before , in the large minkowski length limit the quantum corrections @xmath251 coming from the phase of the factor @xmath136 are of the inverse scalar curvature type ( @xmath353 ) , indicating the infrared corrections to the bare regge action in the semiclassical limit .
+ moreover , in all cases , we still get an amplitude that diverges like @xmath281 as @xmath354 , which means that when the number of tetrahedra in the triangulation increases , the shorter lengths become more and more dominant ones , which is what one would expect if the model is to have a good continuum limit .
the point @xmath355 is a branch point of the amplitude which diverges there , thus requiring a much more detailed treatment deferred for future work @xcite .
let us now move on to the lorentzian analogue of the ( j , p ) representation ( [ eq : rspinfoamjp ] ) for the quantum amplitudes . to do this note
that su(1,1 ) has two types of representations @xcite : * discrete ones labelled by a positive half integer j. the casimir @xmath102 for these representations is negative and is equal to ) .
this duplicity of representations is responsible for the factor of 2 in front of the sum over the discrete representations . ]
the constant @xmath145 appearing in the character expansion of the delta function is @xmath357 . * continuous ones labelled by a positive real number @xmath107 .
the casimir for these representations is positive and is equal to @xmath358 .
the constant @xmath359 is just @xmath360 if we plug these expressions into ( [ eq : spinfoamjp ] ) ( note that we have to pick the positive sign in front of the casimir as su(1,1 ) is noncompact ) we get [ eq : lspinfoamjp ] z_=(_f*t^ * _ p d^3 _ f^ * ) _ f^ * t^ * a_f^*(j_f^*/ _ f^ * , p_f^ * , n_f^ * ) _ v^ * t^ * \ { 6-j } , where now we get two types of the dual face amplitude in the ( j , p ) variables @xmath361 = \frac{i^{n_{f^ * } } ( 2j_{f^*}+1)}{\big ( \frac{\vec{p}_{f^*}^2}{2 } - \frac{m^2}{8 } - \frac{j_{f^*}(j_{f^*}+1)}{2 } + i \epsilon \big ) ^{n_{f^*}}},\ ] ] when the representation is of discrete type , and @xmath362 = \frac{i^{n_{f^ * } } ( 2 \rho_{f^ * } ) } { \big ( \frac{\vec{p}_{f^*}^2}{2 } - \frac{m^2}{8 } + \frac{\rho_{f^*}^2}{2 } + \frac{1}{8 } + i \epsilon \big ) ^{n_{f^*}}},\ ] ] when it is of the continuous type . + it is obvious from these two expressions that we get poles of two types , timelike and spacelike .
what we mean by this is that there are two sets of poles , one when @xmath221 is positive , i.e. when @xmath344 is timelike ; and one when it is negative , i.e. @xmath344 is spacelike .
the first type of poles occurs when the representation labelling the dual face is of discrete type , as then we have in the denominator of ( [ eq : lspinfoamjp ] ) the following expression @xmath363 , which vanishes when @xmath364 which , if we set @xmath239 , gives @xmath365 as in the riemannian case .
+ the other type of poles occurs when the relevant representation is of a continuous type as then we have in the denominator of the same equation the expression @xmath366 . which vanishes when @xmath367 which , on setting @xmath185 , gives @xmath368 .
+ if we interpret these formulae as giving the semiclassical values of the length , we arrive at the intriguing fact that there are no preferred spacelike lengths as @xmath107 is continuous and thus the poles at the @xmath359 s fill the line .
in contrast , there are preferred timelike lengths , which are the discretely spaced @xmath145 s .
+ finally , by doing a wick rotation@xmath369 , we can perform the integrals over the @xmath298 s along the lines this was done in the riemannian case . the asymptotic formula ( [ eq : asymptotic ] )
goes through essentially unchanged , and we get @xmath370^{n_{f^*}-1 } \quad \textrm{or } \quad a_{f^ * } ( j_{f^ * } , n_{f^ * } ) \sim \frac{1}{f(n_{f^ * } ) } \ , \ , \ , \bigg [ \frac{8 } { \delta_{\rho_{f^*}}^2 } \bigg ] ^{n_{f^*}-1}\ ] ] the only relevant difference being that the factor second factor ( which dictates the behaviour of the asymptotic ) is now either @xmath371^{n-1}$ ] ( as before ) or alternatively equal to @xmath372^{n-1}$ ] .
the conclusion is the same as before : for large @xmath373 s it is only the lowest @xmath304 s and @xmath107 s that contribute ( @xmath374 and @xmath375 ) . ) .
however , the exact form of f is of no importance for us here as long as it is still a function of polynomial growth
. we will continue to use this notation for this prefactor in 4d as well . ]
+ note that we could have performed the mentioned wick rotationanywhere in the above discussion .
most importantly , we could have done it in the triangulation amplitude ( [ eq : lamplitude ] ) .
since , this amplitude is just a partition function for gravity , we thus see that there is a straightforward way of performing the wick rotationin the gravity partition function coming from the new model which does not rely on the existence of any particular time slicing .
we would like to point out however , that this wick rotation(although very similar to the rotation in the squares of the edge lengths performed in causal dynamical triangulations @xcite ) is not the complete story , in the sense that it does not turn the action for lorentzian gravity into one for riemannian gravity , nor it turns complex exponentials into real ones ( thus quantum mechanical amplitudes into statistical weights ) .
this is due to the fact that we have a first order theory with the b and a fields being totally independent .
thus , while we wick rotate the b field to a euclidean one , we do not touch the connection . in this sense ,
the label wick rotation is a slight abuse of language , as it really corresponds to some sort of partial or half - performed wick rotation , from a geometric perspective , hence the quotation marks .
however , we find it very intriguing that even this partial transformation can be performed in such a natural way , and believe it can be a good starting point for a similarly natural , but this time complete definition of a geometric wick rotation in simplicial quantum gravity .
+ summarizing , we see that the lorentzian case is not particularly different from the riemannian one . there is essentially only one major , qualitative difference , which stems from the fact that the lorentzian geometry is richer than the euclidean one . due to the first order nature of the theory , in the lorentzian setting one gets additional , classically forbidden , histories , which have mismatching b and a fields .
these histories are , as is customary in quantum mechanics , exponentially suppressed . as for the rest
the same simplicial gravity path integral interpretation for the feynman amplitudes of our gft applies , and similar types of quantum corrections to the 1st order regge action are identified .
we now come to deal with the four dimensional case ( d=4 ) . our discussion in this subsection and the next will be rather brief as , if we stick to ( causally restricted ) bf theory ( as opposed to gravity , in higher dimensions ) , there is little difference between the 3d and 4d cases .
our main aim in the present section is indeed to show explicitly that there are no qualitative new features added to the model by going to the fourth dimension , in neither the riemannian nor the lorentzian signatures , which shows how our proposed new class of gfts behaves similarly in any dimension . as we shall see below , the four dimensional models are essentially carbon copies of the three dimensional ones .
+ the only _ absolutely crucial _ difference between 3 and 4 dimensions appears , of course , when one tries to convert bf theory into a gravitational one . at the continuum level , this is done by imposing the so - called simplicity constraints on the b field , in a plebanski - like formulation of gravity .
since we re interpreting the p variables as a discretized b field , the difference between having bf and gravity lies in these variables , and indeed we expect the discrete analogue of the plebanski constraints to be imposed on them , when passing to gravity @xcite , as they indeed have the needed component structure ( see the discussion in the third subsection below ) . in this work
, however , we will treat the p s as being just elements of a metric vector space isomorphic to the lie algebra of g , neglecting any further constraint .
thus our discussion will be rather and will amount to little more than a presentation of the results .
+ the action becomes @xmath376 \phi(g_i ; p_i ) + { } \\ & & { } + \frac{\lambda}{(2\pi)^{120 } 5 ! } \sum_{\nu_1 \ldots \nu_5 } \int_{g^{20 } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^5 \ , dg_{ij } \bigg ) \ , \int_{p^{20 } } \bigg ( \prod_{i \neq j = 1}^{5 } dp_{ij } \bigg ) \ , \ , \bigg [ \prod_{i < j } \delta(g_{ij } g_{ji}^{-1 } ) \delta(p_{ij } - p_{ji } ) \bigg ] \times { } \\ & & { } \times \phi^{\nu_1}(g_{1j } ; p_{1j } ) \ldots \phi^{\nu_5}(g_{5 j } ; p_{5 j}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the group that we are using for the riemannian version of the 4d theory is the double cover of the rotation group in 4 dimensions so(4 ) , which is just spin(4 ) @xmath377 su(2)xsu(2 ) .
the fact that the group is a direct product of two copies of the group we used for the 3d riemannian case allows us to carry over easily essentially all the results we discussed in that case to the 4d setting .
the reason for this is the fact that the schroedinger kernel on @xmath378 is just the product of the kernels on @xmath379 and @xmath380 .
this in turn follows from the fact that the laplacian on the direct product of two groups is just the sum of the two laplacians @xmath381 .
this allows us to write down the kernel on su(2)xsu(2 ) right away , essentially by squaring the expression given in ( [ eq : su2kernel ] ) [ eq : so4kernel ] k [ h , t ] = .
we are of course using the same notation as before with respect to the periodic parameters @xmath382 and @xmath383 .
as before , we want to calculate the feynman graph / triangulation amplitude @xmath177 .
since this amplitude when written in terms of the ( g , p ) variables factorizes per dual face , we concentrate on the amplitude for a single dual face . to get the dual face amplitude for a face with n vertices @xmath384 $ ]
, we multiply the expression of the kernel by @xmath323 and take the fourier transform evaluated at @xmath385 , i.e. @xmath386 = \frac{1}{(n-1 ) ! } \int_0^{\infty } dt \ , e^{i ( p^2 - \frac{m^2}{4 } ) t } \ , t^{n-1 } \ , k [ h \ , , \ , t].\ ] ] since the group is compact , its killing form , in our conventions , is positive definite .
also , since the space p is isometric to the ( dual of ) @xmath387 we have @xmath388 , with @xmath389 .
thus , ( with our normalizations ) @xmath390 . also , below we will denote the combination @xmath391 ^ 2 + [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] ^2}$ ] as @xmath392 $ ] .
as in the 3d case , this ( equivalence class of ) parameter(s ) has the geometric interpretation as the square distance between the origin and the point on the group manifold corresponding to the holonomy @xmath198 , measured along a geodesic .
+ using the formula ( [ eq : hankel ] ) , we get @xmath225 = \frac{i^{n-1}}{(16 \pi)^2 ( n-1 ) ! } \ , \ , \frac { [ \ , \theta_1(h ) \ , ] [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] } { \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta_1(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) } \ , \ , \bigg [ \frac{[\theta(h)]}{\sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2}{4 } } } \bigg ] ^{n-3 } \ , \ , h^{(1)}_{n-3 } \big ( \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 -1 } { 2 } } \ , [ \theta(h ) ] \big ) , \ ] ] with the same analytic continuation in the variables as in the 3d case . the hankel function of integer order does not have an expression in terms of elementary functions analogous to ( [ eq : polynomial ] ) .
instead it is given in terms of the following non - elementary integral .
however , there is a very simple relation between a hankel function of a negative order with the one of a positive one , which is @xmath393 .
this means that all we need to do when n=2 ( this is the only allowed value for n which is less than 3 , since any dual face has at least two vertices ) is multiply the given formula by a sign . ]
@xmath394 as we see , the formula above still furnishes a natural split of the amplitude into an exponential piece and a measure piece .
thus the dual face amplitude is equal to @xmath225 = \mu ( [ \theta(h ) ] , \vec{p } , n ) \ , e^{i \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 -1}{2 } } | [ \theta(h ) ] |},\ ] ] with @xmath136 given by @xmath395 , \vec{p } , n ) & = & - \frac{i^n 2^{n-10}}{\pi^{\frac{5}{2 } } ( n-1 ) !
\gamma(n - \frac{5}{2 } ) } \ , \frac { [ \ , \theta_1(h ) \ , ] [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] } { \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta_1(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) } \ , \big [ \theta(h ) \big ] ^{2(n-3 ) } \ , \times { } \nonumber \\ \label{eqnarray : rmeasure } & & { } \times \bigg \ { \int_0^{\frac{\pi}{2}}ds \frac{\textrm{cos}^{n-\frac{5}{2}}(s ) \ , \ , e^{- i
( n - \frac{7}{2 } ) \ , s } } { \textrm{sin}^{2n - 5}(s ) } \ , \textrm{exp } \big [ -2 \ , \textrm{cot}(s ) \ , \big ( \theta(h ) \sqrt{\vec{p}^2 - \frac{m^2 -1 } { 2 } } \big ] \bigg \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as before , we multiply together all the dual face amplitudes and obtain the amplitude for the feynman diagram / triangulation @xmath396 the products go over all the dual edges @xmath31 of the dual complex @xmath154 and over all the triangles @xmath125 in the triangulation @xmath151 , the @xmath136 is the product of all the @xmath136 s coming from all the edges .
the expression @xmath397 in the exponent is @xmath398 |\ ] ] thus the feynman amplitudes of the model are partition functions for an action of discretized bf theory type .
classically , the theory given by the action @xmath397 coincides with the one given by the usual bf action , as the equations of motion that they produce are the same ( zero curvature ) .
however , quantum mechanically , there is a significant difference between the two theories . the difference being that for the usual bf theory the integral over the b field is unrestricted , with the integration producing the usual a - causal , real partition function .
for the model given by @xmath397 the fact that the variable p , which represents the discretized b field , enters only through its length ( which is always positive ) , means that what we have is the causal analogue of the usual bf theory ( hence the subscript ) .
+ it is tempting to call @xmath399 the area of the triangle t of the triangulation .
however , this is untenable as the variable p , being generic and non - simple ( i.e. not itself a wedge product of 4-vectors ) , does not have an interpretation of defining the geometry of the triangle to which is associated , as one needs a simple bivector to do this .
as before , the identification is cleanest if we set @xmath239 which we do in what follows to simplify the discussion and formulae .
it is clear , however , that we are setting the stage for obtaining a proper causal spin foam model for 4d gravity , to be defined from the above by imposition of suitable simplicity constraints on the p variables .
as before we write the @xmath136 in terms of magnitude and phase @xmath400 again , we interpret the @xmath401 as a quantum measure factor , while the phase @xmath402 gives quantum corrections to the pure bf action @xmath397 .
+ it is straightforward to extract the explicit expression for the phase from ( [ eqnarray : rmeasure ] ) .
it is given by , @xmath403.\ ] ] although this expression looks totally different from the one we had in 3d ( [ eqnarray : measure ] ) many of the features of the three dimensional model carry through without any change .
most importantly , it still depends on the @xmath404 and @xmath405 solely through the combination @xmath406 , which , at least when @xmath407 is simple , can be interpreted to be the discrete analogue of the ricci scalar r. which means that the quantum corrections arising from the measure @xmath136 are of the general form f(r ) , just like in 3d .
+ it is possible to analyze asymptotically the expression for the phase above , along the lines done in 3d , and compute the _
exact _ coefficients and combinatorial factors weighting the corrections to the regge action . ) , which , in the half - integer - order case , terminates and provides an explicit expression . ] in the large area asymptotic ( @xmath408 ) .
the result is the same as before .
one gets inverse scalar curvature corrections ( @xmath409 \ , \textrm{vol}$ ] ) to the bare bf action , i.e. one gets infrared terms arising from the factor @xmath136 in the large distance and semiclassical regime . + also , just as is the case in three dimensions , it is possible to see that the dual face amplitude goes like @xmath410 when @xmath354 . when z is close to zero . ] as before , we would like to draw the reader s attention to the fact that this type of behaviour is at least consistent with , if not suggestive of , the existence of the continuum limit .
+ let us move on to the j variables .
since our group is a product of two copies of su(2 ) , its representation theory follows from that of the su(2 ) .
more precisely , each irrep of su(2 ) @xmath411 su(2 ) , is characterized by a pair of half - integers ( @xmath412 ) .
the dimension of such an irrep is @xmath413 , finally the casimir that concerns us is just the sum of the two casimirs coming from the two su(2 ) factors @xmath414 . +
the 4d case corresponding to equation ( [ eq : spinfoamjp ] ) is : @xmath415 \prod_{v^ * \in t^ * } \left\ { 15-j \right\ } \bigg ) , \ ] ] from which we immediately the semiclassical values of @xmath282 .
they are @xmath416 which as before have the nicest form when @xmath417 .
+ finally , it is not difficult to perform the integrals over the p variables , and obtain the analogue of equation ( [ eq : asymptotic ] ) .
the result is @xmath418^{n_{f^*}-1}.\ ] ] as we see it is entirely analogous to the one before , with the crucial factor @xmath419^{n-1}$ ] , which determines the asymptotic being replaced by @xmath420^{n-1}$ ] .
the dominant contributions come from the representations for which @xmath421 .
this is satisfied only when , neither j exceeds @xmath422 . in other words , the two allowed values are those corresponding to the vacuumand to the lowest excited state .
also , note that if we impose , by hand , the simplicity constraint at this level , in the way it is imposed in usual spin foam models , i.e. if we set @xmath423 then there are exactly two dominant contributions : the vacuum @xmath424 , once more , and the configuration with @xmath425 .
once again , one can think of this as an indication of a dynamical reduction of the model to a purely combinatorial one of the dynamical triangulations - type .
finally , let us consider the case when d=4 and g = sl(2,@xmath426 ) .
the technical difference between the ( double cover of the ) lorentz group in 4 dimension and the one in 3 is that in 4d the group sl(2,@xmath426 ) has just one cartan subalgebra .
thus , apart from a set of measure zero , all elements in the group are conjugate to the elements of the cartan subgroup , which is the image of the cartan subalgebra under the exponential map .
as @xmath427 is spanned by three rotations and three boosts one can take the cartan subalgebra spanned by a rotation and a boost along the same direction , i.e. one compact and one noncompact element .
thus the schroedinger kernel will be parametrized by one periodic parameter @xmath61 ( with period @xmath320 ) and one non - periodic one @xmath127 .
one can think of them as giving the angle of rotation and the boost parameter of the given group element .
intuitively , since @xmath428 can be thought of to be a complexification of @xmath429 @xcite , we will see that what happens in the lorentzian domain can be guessed by complexifying the results obtained in the riemannian one .
for example , the formula for the kernel on sl(2,@xmath426 ) is effectively a complexification of that on su(2 ) @xmath411 su(2 ) given in ( [ eq : so4kernel ] ) @xmath430 = \frac{1}{(4 \pi i t ) ^3 } \frac { [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] \psi(h)}{4 \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) \textrm{sinh}\big(\frac{\psi(h)}{2}\big)}\ , \ , \ , \
, \textrm{exp } \bigg [ \frac{i}{2t}\bigg ( [ \ , \theta(h ) \ , ] ^2 -\psi^2(h ) \bigg ) + \frac{i t}{4 } \bigg ] .\ ] ] as should be easy to see , the above expression is obtained by picking one of the @xmath252 s in ( [ eq : so4kernel ] ) and analytically continuing it to @xmath431 .
+ again , we want to compute the feynman graph amplitude @xmath432 in the ( g , p ) variables .
since in these variables the total amplitude is just a product of dual face amplitudes it is sufficient to calculate a generic amplitude @xmath433 $ ] of a dual face with n vertices .
according to what should be the standard procedure by now , to get @xmath433 $ ] we multiply the kernel by @xmath434 and take the fourier transform at @xmath435 , where we have set @xmath436 as this simplifies the formulae on one hand , and gives the cleanest interpretation of the variable p on the other .
@xmath386 = \frac{1}{(n-1 ) ! } \int_0^{\infty } dt \
, e^{i ( p^2 - \frac{1}{4 } ) t } \
, t^{n-1 } \ , k [ h \ , , \ , t].\ ] ] the killing form on @xmath437 has signature @xmath438 , thus in our normalization @xmath439 now , there are two ways to do the needed integral .
either we use the hankel function ( [ eq : hankel ] ) formula and plow ahead with the algebra , paying attention to how we approach the cut when we take the square root . or we use similar arguments to what we used when we discussed the lorentzian case in 3 dimensions , using the fact that mathematically we are just performing a 1-d fourier transform , which allows us to rely on the relation between the fourier transforms of the function and its complex conjugate .
either way , the dual face amplitude is given by @xmath225 = \mu ( [ \theta(h ) ] , \vec{p } , n ) \
, e^{i \ , \alpha ( [ \theta(h ) ] , \vec{p}^2 ) \ , \ , |\vec{p}^2| \ , \ , | [ \theta(h ) ] |},\ ] ] where @xmath440 ^ 2 $ ] is equal to @xmath441 ^ 2 - \psi^2(h)$ ] which is just the ( square of the ) length of the cartan subalgebra element parametrizing the conjugacy classes , or equivalently it is the length of a geodesic on the group manifold joining the point given by the element h to the identity .
the @xmath442 is given by the following table , which is a carbon copy of the one in 3d ( [ eq : table ] ) @xmath443 the columns are labelled by the two possible cases of the @xmath444 .
the rotation is when @xmath444 is positive , as it is easy to see that the h is then conjugate to a rotation ; while the boost is when @xmath444 is negative as this is when h is conjugate to a boost .
+ the rows , on the other hand , are labelled by the two possible cases of @xmath221 .
timelike is when this vector has positive length and spacelike when this vector has negative length .
+ finally , the @xmath136 is , apart from sporadic signs and factors of i , just the the analytic continuation ( @xmath445 ) of the measure in the riemannian case ( [ eqnarray : rmeasure ] ) . for completenss
we give the exact formula here + @xmath395 , \vec{p } , n ) & = & \frac { \mp i^{\pm n } 2^{n-10 } \alpha^{n-3 } ( [ \theta(h ) ] , \vec{p}^2)}{\pi^{\frac{5}{2 } } ( n-1 ) !
\gamma(n - \frac{5}{2 } ) } \ , \frac { [ \ , \theta_1(h ) \ , ] [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] } { \textrm{sin}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta_1(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) \textrm{sinh}\big(\frac { [ \ , \theta_2(h ) \ , ] } { 2}\big ) } \ , \big [ \theta(h ) \big ] ^{2(n-3 ) } \ , \times { } \nonumber \\ & & { } \times \bigg \ { \int_0^{\frac{\pi}{2}}ds \frac{\textrm{cos}^{n-\frac{5}{2}}(s ) \ , \ , e^ { \mp i ( n - \frac{7}{2 } ) \ , s } } { \textrm{sin}^{2n - 5}(s ) } \ , \textrm{exp } \big [ -2 \ , \textrm{cot}(s ) \ , \alpha ( [ \theta(h ) ] , \vec{p}^2 ) \ , | \vec{p } | \theta(h ) \big ] \bigg \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is straightforward to compute the feynman graph amplitude @xmath446 now .
it is @xmath447 where as before @xmath136 is a product of all the @xmath136 s coming from each dual face and @xmath397 is given by @xmath448 where @xmath442 is given in the table above .
once again , we get a causal bf action in our partition function , i.e. we get a theory whose classical equations of motion are just like those of the standard bf , while there are profound differences at the quantum level . + as was the case in 3d we get exponential suppression of the wrong type of correlation between the variables .
more precisely , had it not been for the fact that the variables p are in general not simple , we could have said that in the situation when the triangle corresponding to a holonomy given by a rotation is timelike or alternatively when it is spacelike when the holonomy is a boost , then this triangle contributes a phase to the partition function .
on the other hand , if there is a mismatch between the @xmath36 and @xmath344 ( rotation - spacelike or boost - timelike ) , this triangle contributes an exponential suppression factor to the partition function .
the behaviour of the model in the lorentzian case is unaffected by dimension .
+ also , since the measure factor is effectively the same as in the riemannian case , its phase depends on the deficit parameter @xmath36 and on the area @xmath282 in the same way as the bare bf action does , i.e. the phase of @xmath136 is a function of @xmath449 ( as well as the @xmath450 s characterizing the triangulation ) .
this fact is interpreted as before to mean that there are quantum corrections arising from the factor @xmath136 of the general f(r ) type .
+ the semiclassical analysis is exactly the same as in the riemannian case and one sees that in the limit of large areas , we get inverse scalar curvature corrections to the bare bf action as before . finally , the amplitude is as divergent as before in the neighborhood of the @xmath355 . as in the previous section , we consider this fact to be a necessary condition for the existence of the continuum limit .
+ it is not difficult to write down the full feynman amplitude in the ( j , p ) variables .
the relevant representations of @xmath451 are labelled by two parameters . a half integer j and a real positive parameter @xmath107 .
the relevant casimir and normalizations is equal to @xmath452 .
the analogue of ( [ eq : spinfoamjp ] ) is now [ eqnarray : lspinfoamjp ] z_=(_f*t^ * _ p d^3 _ f^ * ) _ f^ * t^ * _ v^ * t^ * \ { 15-j } , the poles in the expression ( [ eq : spinfoamjp ] ) are obviously located at @xmath453 so these particular values are the preferred semiclassical areas. + finally , as in 3d there exists a simple way of performing a ( partial , as explained ) wick rotation in this model , by analytically continuing ( some components of ) the p variables .
this shows that also the existence of a good wick rotation in our model is independent of the dimension .
we can use this wick rotation to perform the integrals over the p s in the amplitude in the ( j , p ) variables ( equation ( [ eq : spinfoamjp ] ) ) and obtain the 4d lorentzian analogue of ( [ eq : asymptotic ] ) , which is given by @xmath454^{n_{f^*}-1}.\ ] ] the relevant difference from the riemannian case is that the factor @xmath455^{n-1}$ ] , which controls the way the asymptotic behaves , gets replaced with @xmath456^{n-1}$ ] .
this means that the most dominant contributions are those which satisfy @xmath457 .
this does not of course force the j and the @xmath107 to each be small ( as was the case in 3d ) .
however , it does force the minkowski length ( or more appropriately area ) to be small .
note however , that if we restrict -by hand- to representations which are simple ( i.e. those for which either j or @xmath107 is zero ) , the expression above _ does _ force each of the parameters to be small , hinting again at a dynamical reduction to a dynamical triangulations - like sector .
we have presented above a new gft model for a bf - type formulation of quantum simplicial gravity , in 4 dimensions , in the spin foam formalism .
the spin foam amplitudes ( gft feynman amplitudes ) have the form , modulo a quantum measure , of the exponential of a classical 1st order action based on two types of variables : a set of bivectors associated to 2-simplices of the simplicial complex and a set of lorentz group elements representing parallel transports of a lorentz connection .
the action has a regge calculus expression , augmented by higher order terms that can be interpreted as quantum corrections , that become negligible in the semi - classical limit . in this generalized simplicial gravity action , the areas as area of the corresponding triangle
is , strictly speaking , not applicable until the ( discrete ) bivector is constrained to be a quadratic function of a ( discrete ) tetrad vector , as noted earlier .
] of the triangles are functions of the bivectors and the deficit angle associated , again , to each triangle obtained from the holonomy of the same lorentz connection , and thus a function of the corresponding group elements .
the equations of motion following variation of the dominant contribution to the action , in the semiclassical ( large distance ) limit , restrict the holonomies to be flat , just as in ordinary bf theory , but the integration over the bivectors in the path integral does not treat on equal footing positive and negative orientations for the triangles , as bf theories do . the result is a complex amplitude , as said , and not a delta function over flat connections as in bf theory . + the above model seems to us to be a very promising starting point for the construction of a gft for quantum gravity in 4 dimensions , both riemannian and lorentzian , based on the idea of gravity as a constrained bf theory @xcite .
this type of formulation has been central to the construction of all spin foam models in 4d , and lots is known already about the constraints that the bivectors have to satisfy in order to admit a true geometric interpretation , i.e. to be interpretable as coming from a discretized tetrad field , as it should be in a palatini - like formulation of gravity .
+ most of the model building on gfts and spin foam models from constrained bf theory have used a well - motivated but rather indirect procedure , we feel , based on the kinematical identification of bivectors with lie algebra generators , and thus translating them in constraints on the lorentz group representations and on the intertwiners appearing in the spin foam representation of the feynman amplitudes @xcite .
this however , as we discussed , resulted in amplitudes with a less than straightforward relation with discrete gravity actions , and with a symmetrization over opposite orientations that is not what we should expect , we have argued , from a 3rd quantized gravity perspective .
moreover , from the point of view of a path integral quantization of bf theory , the identification of bivectors with lie algebra generators acting on representation spaces remains a bit obscure , given that this holds at a quantum level while in a path integral one integrates over classical variables only ( although not solutions to the classical equations of motion ) and does not refer to quantum states if not at the boundary .
a similar doubt concerns the more recent construction of spin foam models @xcite and related gfts @xcite , based on coherent states . here
the geometric picture behind the chosen implementation of the constraints is much clearer , but again is justified at the quantum level in terms of the coherent states basis in each representation space . on the one hand
this suggests a semiclassical validity only of the identification ; on the other hand , it results in quantum amplitudes with a less than straightforward relation with classical gravity actions , and with the same symmetrization over opposite orientations as in usual models . in the end ,
the procedure adopted may well result to be correct and our doubts unfounded or settled , but we feel that further work is needed to clarify the situation , and we see our new models as a useful framework in which to do so .
+ in fact , the new 4d bf - like model , thanks to the explicit presence of bivector variables and to their role in the discrete path integral clearly analogous to that played by the b field in continuum formulations , suggests that a much more straightforward way of implementing the simplicity constraints is possible .
this is simply to constrain directly the integration over the bivector variables of our 4d model .
the simplest way of doing so is to insert appropriate delta functions imposing the simplicity conditions on bivectors , and one has just to make sure that this is done consistently and as geometrically expected at the level of each feynman diagram . alternatively , and preferably
, one should implement the constraints directly at the level of the new gft action , and for doing so one has to identify clearly which constraints are needed in each 4-simplex ( interaction term ) and which refer to the gluing of 4-simplices ( kinetic term ) , or whether one should instead constrain directly the field in both terms , as it is done for the other spin foam models @xcite .
work on this is in progress @xcite .
the expected result of this new way of implementing the simplicity constraints , starting from our 4d model , is to obtain a constrained gft whose feynman amplitude are given by a path integral for an action that could be directly interpreted as the discretization of the plebanski action for classical gravity , i.e. of the form : @xmath458 , where @xmath459 are lagrange multipliers imposing the constraints @xmath460 on the bivector variables @xmath461 associated to each dual face ( triangle ) @xmath33 incident to each dual vertex ( 4-simplex ) @xmath462 ( we have neglected here the quantum corrections to the 1st order regge action coming from the measure ) .
+ let us stress that a result of this type would be of interest , we believe , also from a purely simplicial gravity perspective .
in fact , recent progress in spin foam models has motivated work on so - called area regge calculus@xcite , i.e. a formulation of classical and quantum simplicial gravity in which the fundamental geometric variables were the areas of the triangles of the simplicial complex as opposed to the edge lengths as in traditional regge calculus .
in fact , spin foam models based on constrained bf theory ended up associating , as basic geometric variables , representation labels to triangles , with the interpretation of areas of the same .
it was noted @xcite , however , that , while the correspondence areas - edges works ( almost ) fine for a single 4-simplex , constraints on the areas variables are needed in order to capture correctly the simplicial geometry as soon as more than one 4-simplex is considered .
the identification of these area constraints have proven to be very difficult .
our model would suggest that a better formulation of classical and quantum simplicial gravity , directly following the continuum picture of gravity as a constrained bf theory , would use our bivector variables to determine the areas of triangles , and that the needed constraints needed in order to encode the geometry are constraints on these bivector variables , and not directly on the areas .
more precisely , the simplicity constraints will restrict the components of the bivectors other than their modulus ( area ) , and their re - phasing in terms of constraints on areas is , if possible , certainly not straightforward . in any case
, the description of simplicial geometry implicit in our models in both 3 and 4 dimensions deserves to be studied in more detail .
we leave this for future work .
+ the above 4d model , as well as its 3d version , in both lorentzian and riemannian versions , would also be the natural starting point for understanding in a more clear way the role that coherent states for the lorentz group play in spin foam models , and , in 4d , for understanding better the justification for the procedure used in the recently proposed spin foam models in order to impose the simplicity constraints .
what we would expect is that the parameters labelling coherent states for the lorentz group in both 3d and 4d models will be directly related , if not identified , with the new ( bi-)vector variables we introduce _ in the approximation in which our free field classical equations of motions are satisfied _ , i.e. in the approximation in which one substitutes , in the amplitudes for our 3d and 4d models , the generators of the lorentz lie algebra for the ( bi-)vector variables , which indeed represents a dominant ( semiclassical ) contribution to our amplitudes , as it is clear from the structure of our propagators .
however , further work is needed to confirm or refute this expectation .
this work is currently in progress @xcite .
we have presented a new class of gft models for the dynamics of quantum geometry , in any spacetime dimension and signature .
the construction was based on the extension of the gft formalism to include additional variables with the interpretation of a discrete counterpart of the continuum b field in bf - like formulations of gravity .
the feynman amplitudes for the new gfts , i.e. the corresponding spin foam models , have exactly the form of true simplicial gravity path integrals , with a clear - cut relation with discrete gravity actions , as opposed to other known models in which the connection arises only in some asymptotic limit . in 3d
the new models are seen to provide a quantization of discrete quantum gravity in 1st order ( palatini ) form , in a local and discrete 3rd quantized framework in which topology is allowed to fluctuate . in 4d and higher ,
the new models have the form of a 3rd quantized framework for bf theory , but with an additional dependence of the amplitudes on the orientation of the simplicial complex , of the type on would expect in a path integral quantization of 1st order gravity .
+ the lorentzian models also present a very nice interplay between the two sets of discrete variables ( b field and connection ) which leads automatically to a suppression of all the configurations which do not match the simultaneous geometric interpretation of both of them .
+ the gft provides also a precise prescription for the quantum correction to the classical regge - like action ( in 1st order form ) that have to be included in the corresponding path integral , in absence of further restrictions to the models .
these additional terms in the action become negligible in both the continuum limit ( large number of simplices of small size ) and in the semi - classical limit ( arbitrary number of simplices but large size of simplices , thus large associated action ) , leaving only the regge action to contribute to the path integral , as one would expect . in the general case , and as soon as one goes beyond these limiting regimes , the simplicial action provided by our gft models turns into a generic @xmath1 extended action for gravity .
we feel that this has several interesting implications at the simplicial gravity level as well as from a more phenomenological perspective , that deserve to be studied in more detail .
+ the way the large - p limit affects the amplitudes of the new models sheds new light , we feel , on the usual large - j limit that brings usual spin foam models in closer relation with simplicial gravity path integrals , by allowing an approximation of the vertex amplitudes with the cosine of the regge action .
indeed , our models suggest that this limit is a large distance limit which is equivalent , at the discrete level , to a large action and thus semi - classical limit ( because of the way the regge action , and its higher order corrections , depends on the hinge volumes ) . as such
, it has two effects : it kills any quantum interference between opposite orientations for the hinges , in the usual models only , in which such opposite orientations are treated on equal footing ; it kills any short - distance effect such as @xmath463 corrections to the action , leaving only the regge term as the leading contribution to the quantum amplitudes , with next to leading order contributions being represented by inverse curvature terms @xmath464 which indeed modify the ir physics of the corresponding classical discrete gravity theory .
+ let us also mention that the explicit presence of a discrete analogue of the b field in our amplitudes allows a rather transparent definition of a wick rotation in simplicial quantum gravity our results , as we have discussed , support the view of gfts as local and discrete 3rd quantizations of gravity , providing a nice field theoretic description of the quantum dynamics of the fundamental building blocks of quantum space @xcite . also , the new models seem to implement nicely the ideas , discussed at length as a motivation for the work we have presented in this paper , as well as in @xcite , on the notion of causality and orientation dependence in quantum gravity , and to provide a definition of _ causal transition amplitudes _ for quantum gravity states , with all the expected properties .
+ at a more practical level , the new 4d models represent , in our opinion , a very convenient starting point for the construction of a gft ( and spin foam , and simplicial quantum gravity ) formulation of quantum gravity as a constrained bf theory , based on a more straightforward and geometrically clean procedure of implementing the so - called simplicity constraints that reduce bf theory to gravity , than in other spin foam formulations , as we have discussed above .
also , they offer a new context in which to study the low energy physics of gfts and loop quantum gravity , e.g. graviton propagator calculations @xcite .
+ even more importantly , maybe , the new models , and possible modifications of the same , seem to provide the long sought for _ explicit _ unifying framework for spin foam / loop quantum gravity and simplicial quantum gravity approaches ( quantum regge calculus and dynamical triangulations ) .
looking at these different approaches from the proposed common gft framework can offer , we hope , new possibilities for mutual enrichment and cross - fertilization between the various lines of research that are currently pursued as separate avenues toward a common goal , in particular regarding the outstanding issue of the continuum and semiclassical approximation of the discrete picture of quantum geometry they all seem to be based on @xcite .
here we collect a few basic facts about groups @xcite used in the discussion in the main text . +
a cartan subalgebra is a maximal abelian subalgebra of the lie algebra @xmath43 .
the image of the cartan subalgebra under the exponential map is called a cartan subgroup .
it is possible to show that all cartan subalgebras ( subgroups ) have the same dimension r , which is called the rank of the group .
+ in a compact group all its cartan subgroups are conjugate to each other and any element of the group is conjugate to an element of some fixed cartan subgroup .
this means that we can parametrize the conjugacy classes of the group by the elements of the cartan subalgebra .
+ in a noncompact group the situation can be more complicated as on one hand not all cartan subgroups are conjugate . and the other , even if we do select a representative from each conjugacy class of cartan subgroups it is not true in general that each element of the group is conjugate to an element of one of the selected subgroups .
fortunately , however , these exceptional elements form a set of measure zero in the haar measure in the cases that we are interested in . at the practical level
, what follows from the above is that on a noncompact group there is no global spherical coordinate system @xcite , i.e. it is impossible to parametrize all the elements of the group by r parameters ( elements of a fixed cartan subalgebra ) like in the compact case .
rather , there will be several different domains in general with all elements in each domain being conjugate to a cartan subgroup of a specific topology , with the elements which do nt lie in any domain forming a set of measure zero .
the elements in each domain are parametrizable by a set of r parameters , which are just the elements of the corresponding cartan subalgebras .
+ intuitively , if one uses a cartan decomposition of @xmath43 , i.e. if one writes @xmath465 , with the killing form being negative definite on the elements of @xmath466 ( the compact part as the 1-parameter subgroup generated by any element in @xmath466 is just a circle @xmath467 ) and positive definite on the elements of @xmath468 ( the noncompact part , the 1-parameter subgroup generated by any element is diffeomorphic to the real line ) ; and if one obtains a cartan subalgebra by taking e.g. k generators from @xmath466 and p ones from @xmath468 ( with k + p = r of course ) .
then the cartan subgroup corresponding to this subalgebra is not conjugate to the cartan subgroup corresponding to a subalgebra formed from a different relative proportion of compact and noncompact elements .
if we call the elements generated by @xmath466 rotations and the ones generated by @xmath468 boosts , then the different cartan subgroups correspond to different relative number of rotations to boosts .
the r parameters which parametrize the elements in each domain are split into two classes , periodic and aperiodic .
the number of periodic parameters is equal to the number of rotations while the number of the aperiodic ones is equal to the number of boosts .
j. ambjorn , b. durhuus , t. jonsson , three - dimensional simplicial quantum gravity and generalized matrix models , mod.phys.lett.*a6 * , 1133 - 1146 , ( 1991 ) ; n. sasakura , tensor model for gravity and orientability of manifold , mod.phys.lett.*a6 * , 2613 - 2624 , ( 1991 ) ; m. gross , tensor models and simplicial quantum gravity in @xmath469 2-d , nucl.phys.proc.suppl.*25a * , 144 - 149 , ( 1992 ) j.c .
baez an introduction to spin foam models of quantum gravity and bf theory , lect.notes phys . * 543 * , ( 2000 ) , 25 - 94 , [ arxiv : gr - qc/9905087 ] ; d. oriti , space - time geometry from algebra : spin foam models for nonperturbative quantum gravity , rept .
. phys . * 64 * , 1489 , ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/0106091 ] ; a. perez , spin foam models for quantum gravity , class .
. grav . * 20 * , r43 , ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/0301113 ] d. oriti , _ a new perspective on the continuum in quantum gravity : group field theories as the microscopic description of the quantum spacetime fluid _ , in the proceedings of the workshop from quantum to emergent gravity : theory and experiments , trieste , pos , to appear s. b. giddings , a. strominger , baby universes , third quantization and the cosmological constant , nucl .
b * 321 * , 481 , ( 1989 ) ; s. coleman , why there is nothing rather than something : a theory of the cosmological constant , nucl .
b * 310 * , 643 , ( 1988 ) ; m. mcguigan , third quantization and the wheeler - dewitt equation , phys . rev .
d * 38 * , 3031 , ( 1988 ) ; t. banks , prolegomena to a theory of bifurcating universes : a nonlocal solution to the cosmological constant problem or little lambda goes back to the future , nucl .
b * 309 * , 493 , ( 1988 ) j. ambjorn , j. jurkiewicz , r. loll , reconstructing the universe , phys.rev.d * 72 * , 064014 , ( 2005 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0505154 ] ; j. ambjorn , j. jurkiewicz , r. loll the universe from scratch , contemp.phys . *
47 * , 103 - 117 , ( 2006 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0509010 ] c. rovelli , graviton propagator from background - independent quantum gravity , phys.rev.lett . *
97 * , 151301 , ( 2006 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/0508124 ] ; e. bianchi , l. modesto , c. rovelli , s. speziale , graviton propagator in loop quantum gravity , class .
quant . grav . *
23 * , 6989 - 7028 , ( 2006 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/ 0604044 ] ; e. bianchi , l. modesto , the perturbative regge - calculus regime of loop quantum gravity , [ arxiv : 0709.2051 ] a. carlini , j. greensite , the mass shell of the universe , phys.rev.d * 55 * , 3514 - 3524 ( 1997 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/9610020 ] ; j. greensite , field theory as free fall , class.quant.grav . * 13 * , 1339 - 1352 ( 1996 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/9508033 ] l. freidel , d. louapre , asymptotics of 6j and 10j symbols , class.quant.grav . * 20 * , 1267 - 1294 , ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0209134 ] ; j.w .
barrett , c. m. steele , asymptotics of relativistic spin networks , class.quant.grav . * 20 * , 1341 ( 2003 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/0209023 ] m. caselle , a. dadda , l. magnea , regge calculus as a local theory of the poincare group , phys.lett.b * 232 * , 4 , 457 ( 1989 ) ; j. w. barrett , first order regge calculus , class.quant.grav . * 11 * , 2723 - 2730 ( 1994 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/9404124 ] h.w .
hamber , r.m .
williams , higher derivative quantum gravity on a simplicial lattice , nucl.phys.b * 248 * , 392 , ( 1984 ) ; erratum : ibid.b * 260 * , 747 , ( 1985 ) ; h.w .
hamber , r.m .
williams , simplicial quantum gravity with higher derivative terms : formalism and numerical results in four - dimensions , nucl.phys.b * 269 * , 712 , ( 1986 ) j. makela , r.m .
williams , constraints on area variables in regge calculus , class .
* 18 * , l43 ( 2001 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/0011006 ] ; j.w .
barrett , m. rocek , r.m .
williams , a note on area variables in regge calculus , class.quant.grav . *
16 * , 1373 - 1376 , ( 1999 ) , [ arxiv : gr - qc/9710056 ] | group field theories , a generalization of matrix models for 2d gravity , represent a 2nd quantization of both loop quantum gravity and simplicial quantum gravity . in this paper , we construct a new class of group field theory models , for any choice of spacetime dimension and signature , whose feynman amplitudes are given by path integrals for clearly identified discrete gravity actions , in 1st order variables .
in the 3-dimensional case , the corresponding discrete action is that of 1st order regge calculus for gravity ( generalized to include higher order corrections ) , while in higher dimensions , they correspond to a discrete bf theory ( again , generalized to higher order ) with an imposed orientation restriction on hinge volumes , similar to that characterizing discrete gravity .
the new models shed also light on the large distance or semi - classical approximation of spin foam models .
this new class of group field theories may represent a concrete unifying framework for loop quantum gravity and simplicial quantum gravity approaches . |
throughout this paper , we consider a unique server addressing two parallel queues numbered @xmath51 and @xmath52 , respectively .
incoming jobs enter either queue and require random service times ; the server then processes jobs according to the so - called shortest queue first ( sqf ) policy
. specifically , let @xmath6 ( resp .
@xmath7 ) denote the workload in queue @xmath51 ( resp .
queue @xmath52 ) at a given time , including the remaining amount of work of the job possibly in service ; the server then proceeds as follows : * queue @xmath51 ( resp .
queue @xmath52 ) is served if @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 ( resp . if @xmath11 and @xmath12 ) ; * if only one of the queues is empty , the non empty queue is served ;
* if both queues are empty , the server remains idle until the next job arrival .
in contrast to fixed priority disciplines where the server favors queues in some predefined order remaining unchanged in time ( e.g. , classical preemptive or non - preemptive head - of - line priority schemes ) , the sqf policy enables the server to dynamically serve queues according to their current state .
the performance analysis of such a queueing discipline is motivated by the so - called sqf packet scheduling policy recently proposed to improve the quality of internet access on high speed communication links . as discussed in @xcite
, sqf policy is designed to serve the shortest queue , i.e. , the queue with the least number of waiting packets ; in case of buffer overflow , packets are dropped from the longest queue .
thanks to this simple policy , the scheduler consequently prioritizes constant bit rate flows associated with delay - sensitive applications such as voice and audio / video streaming with intrinsic rate constraints ; priority is thus implicitly given to smooth flows over data traffic associated with bulk transfers that sense network bandwidth by filling buffers and sending packets in bursts .
in this paper , we consider the fluid version of the sqf discipline . instead of packets ( i.e. , individual jobs )
, we deal with the workload ( i.e. , the amount of fluid in each queue ) . since the fluid sqf policy considers the shortest queue in volume , that is , in terms of workload , its performance is quantitatively described by the variations of variables @xmath6 and @xmath7 . to simplify the analysis
, we here suppose that the buffer capacity for both queues @xmath51 and @xmath52 is infinite .
moreover , we assume that incoming jobs enter either queue according to a poisson process ; in view of the above application context , one can argue that such poisson arrivals can model traffic where sources have peak rates significantly higher than that of the output link ; such processes can hardly represent , however , the traffic variations of locally constant bit rate flows .
this poisson assumption , although limited in this respect , is nevertheless envisaged here in view of its mathematical tractability and as a first step towards the consideration of more complicated arrival patterns .
the above framework enables us to define the pair @xmath13 representing the workloads in the stationary regime in each queue as a continuous - state markov process in @xmath14 . in the following , we determine the probability distribution of the couple @xmath13 by studying its laplace transform .
the problem can then essentially be formulated as follows .
[ prob1 ] given the domain @xmath15 and analytic functions @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 in @xmath21 , determine two bivariate laplace transforms @xmath22 , @xmath23 and two univariate laplace transforms @xmath24 , @xmath25 , analytic in @xmath21 and such that equations @xmath26 for some analytic function @xmath27 , together hold for in @xmath28 .
note that each condition @xmath29 or @xmath30 with @xmath31 brings the latter equations respectively to @xmath32 to the best knowledge of the authors , the mathematical analysis of the sqf policy has not been addressed in the queueing literature .
some comparable queueing disciplines have nevertheless been studied : * the _ longest queue first _ ( lqf )
symmetric policy is considered in @xcite , where the author studies the stationary distribution of the number of waiting jobs @xmath33 , @xmath34 in each queue ; reducing the analysis to a boundary value problem on the unit circle , an integral formula is provided for the generating function of the pair @xmath35 ; * the _ join the shortest 2-server queue _ ( jsq ) , where an arriving customer joins the shortest queue if the number of waiting jobs in queues are unequal , is analyzed in @xcite .
the bivariate generating function for the number of waiting jobs is then determined as a meromorphic function in the whole complex plane , whose associated poles and residues are calculated recursively .
while the above quoted studies address the stationary distribution of the number of jobs in each queue , we here consider the real - valued process @xmath13 of workload components whose stationary analysis requires the definition of its infinitesimal generator on the relevant functional space .
besides , the laplace transform of the distribution of @xmath13 proves to be meromorphic not on the entire complex plane , but on the plane cut along some algebraic singularities ( while the solution for jsq exhibits polar singularities only ) ; as a both quantitative and qualitative consequence , the decay rate of the stationary distribution at infinity for sqf may change according to the system load from that defined by the smallest polar singularity to that defined by the smallest algebraic singularity .
the organization of the paper is as follows . in section
[ ma ] , a markovian analysis provides the basic equations for the stationary distribution of the coupled queues ; the functional equations verified by the relevant laplace transforms are further derived in section [ ltd ] . in section [ expi ] , we specialize the discussion to the so - called symmetric exponential case where arrival rates are identical , and where service distribution are both exponential with identical mean ; the functional equations are then specified and shown to involve a key cubic equation . specifically ,
* problem [ prob1 ] * for the symmetric case is shown to reduce to the following .
[ prob2 ] solve the functional equation @xmath36 for function @xmath1 , where given functions @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 are related to one branch of a key cubic polynomial equation @xmath37 .
for real @xmath38 , the solution @xmath39 is written in terms of a series involving all iterates @xmath40 for @xmath41 .
the analytic extension of solution @xmath42 to some domain of the complex plane is further studied in section [ sqfqueue ] ; this enables us to derive the empty queue probability along with the tail behavior of the workload distribution in each queue for the symmetric case .
the latter is then compared to that of the associated preemptive head of line ( hol ) policy .
concluding remarks are finally presented in section [ cl ] .
the proofs for basic functional equations as well as some technical results are deferred to the appendix for better readability .
as described in the introduction , we assume that incoming jobs consecutively enter queue @xmath43 ( resp .
queue @xmath44 ) according to a poisson process with mean arrival rate @xmath45 ( resp .
@xmath46 ) .
their respective service times are independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) with probability distribution @xmath47 , @xmath48 ( resp .
@xmath49 , @xmath50 ) and mean @xmath51 ( resp . mean @xmath52 ) .
let @xmath53 ( resp .
@xmath54 ) denote the mean load of queue @xmath43 ( resp .
queue @xmath44 ) and @xmath55 denote the total load of the system . since the system is work conserving , its stability condition is @xmath56 and we assume it to hold in the rest of this paper . in this section ,
we first specify the evolution equations for the system and further derive its infinitesimal generator .
first consider the total workload @xmath57 of the union of queues @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
for any work - conserving service discipline ( such as sqf ) , the distribution of @xmath58 is independent of that discipline and equals that of the global single @xmath59 queue .
the aggregate arrival process is poisson with rate @xmath60 and the i.i.d .
service times have the averaged distribution @xmath61 with mean @xmath62 .
the stationary probability for the server to be in idle state , in particular , equals @xmath63 let @xmath64 ( resp .
@xmath65 ) be the number of job arrivals within time interval @xmath66 at queue @xmath51 ( resp .
queue @xmath52 ) ; if @xmath67 ( resp .
@xmath68 ) is the service time of the @xmath69-th job arriving at queue @xmath51 ( resp .
@xmath52 ) , the total work brought within @xmath66 into queue @xmath51 ( resp .
@xmath44 ) equals @xmath70 ( resp .
@xmath71 . denoting by @xmath72 ( resp .
@xmath73 ) the workload in queue @xmath43 ( resp .
@xmath44 ) at time @xmath74 , define indicator functions @xmath75 and @xmath76 by @xmath77 respectively . with the above notation
, the sqf policy governs workloads @xmath72 and @xmath73 according to the evolution equations @xmath78 for @xmath79 and some initial conditions @xmath80 , @xmath81 .
this defines the pair @xmath82 , @xmath83 , as a markov process with state space @xmath84 ( see figure [ fig1 ] for sample paths of process @xmath82 ) . as a first result , integrating each equation ( [ path ] ) over interval @xmath85 $ ] , dividing each side by @xmath74 and letting @xmath86 implies @xmath87 and @xmath88 almost surely ( along with similar limits for integrals related to @xmath7 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 ) , and equating these limits readily provides identites @xmath91 for the stationary probability that the server treats queue @xmath51 and @xmath52 , respectively ; equivalently , the latter identities read @xmath92 in the symmetric case when arrival rates are equal and service times have identical distribution , i.e. , @xmath93 and @xmath94 , the above relations give @xmath95 the discrepancy in inequalities @xmath96 and @xmath97 defining the service policy ( when both queues are non empty ) does not favor queue @xmath43 with respect to queue @xmath44 , since event @xmath98 has probability 0 ; in fact , assuming for instance @xmath99 at some time @xmath74 , we have @xmath100 if a job arrival occurs with service time of amount exactly @xmath101 , which has probability 0 for any service time distribution .
the distribution of process @xmath102 does not give a positive probability to the diagonal @xmath103 in state space @xmath104 .
we now address the determination of the stationary distribution function @xmath105 , @xmath106 , of the bivariate workload process @xmath102 . in order to define the class of stationary distribution @xmath107
, we further assume that * distribution @xmath108 has a regular density @xmath109 ( resp .
@xmath110 ) at any point @xmath111 such that @xmath112 ( resp .
@xmath113 ) ; * distribution @xmath107 has a regular density @xmath114 ( resp .
@xmath115 ) at any point @xmath116 ( resp .
@xmath117 ) on the boundary @xmath118 ( resp . on the boundary @xmath119 ) .
( a real - valued function is here said to be regular if it is continuous and bounded over its definition domain . ) in the rest of this paper , assumptions * a.1 * -*a.2 * for the existence of regular densities will be confirmed by exhibiting their laplace transforms ; the uniqueness of the stationary distribution then _ a posteriori _ justifies such assumptions .
an _ a priori _ justification for the existence of densities would otherwise imply the use of malliavin calculus @xcite on the poisson space .
using , we have @xmath120 in the stationary regime ; following assumptions * a.1 * -*a.2 * above , we can then write @xmath121 for all @xmath122 , where @xmath123 ( resp .
@xmath124 ) is the dirac distribution at point @xmath125 ( resp . at point @xmath126 ) .
+ let us now characterize the stationary distribution of process @xmath127 by means of its infinitesimal generator @xmath128 defined by @xmath129\ ] ] where the limit is uniform with respect to @xmath130 ( see @xcite or ( * ? ? ?
* , p. 377 ) ) ; the symbol @xmath131 denotes any function for which the latter limit exists . in the following ,
we denote by @xmath132 the set of functions @xmath133 everywhere bounded , twice differentiable with bounded first and second derivatives in @xmath134 .
further , introduce positive cones @xmath135 along with boundaries ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) @xmath136 we can then state the following . with the notation ( [ cones12])-([axes12 ] ) , the infinitesimal generator @xmath128 of process @xmath127 is given by @xmath137+\lambda_2 \mathbb{e}[\theta(\mathbf{u}+\mathcal{t}_2\mathbf{e}_2)-\theta(\mathbf{u } ) ] \label{gen1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath130 and any test function @xmath138 , where @xmath139 ( resp .
@xmath140 ) denotes the generic service time of jobs arriving at queue @xmath51 ( resp .
queue @xmath52 ) and with vectors @xmath141 , @xmath142 .
[ generator ] using evolution equations ( [ path ] ) and given @xmath143 , expression ( [ gen1 ] ) is easily derived from uniform estimates ( with respect to @xmath130 ) for the distribution of the number of jumps of process @xmath144 on any interval @xmath145 $ ] ( all intervening poisson processes have rates lower than @xmath60 ) and for drift rates ( when non zero , the service rate is the constant @xmath146 ) .
once generator @xmath128 is determined , the stationary distribution @xmath107 of @xmath147 is known ( see @xcite or @xcite ) to satisfy @xmath148
following the prerequisites of section [ ma ] , we now study integral equation .
since the problem is linear in unknown distribution @xmath107 , it is tractable through laplace transform techniques .
let @xmath15 and its closure @xmath149 .
assumptions @xmath150 in section [ ig ] , for the existence of regular densities @xmath151 and @xmath152 with respective support @xmath153 and @xmath154 ( see equations ( [ cones12])-([axes12 ] ) ) enable us to define their laplace transforms @xmath22 , @xmath24 by @xmath155 for @xmath156 , where @xmath157 ; using the expectation operator , definitions ( [ ff ] ) equivalently read @xmath158 , \ ; \ ; g_1(s_1 ) = \e\big[e^{-s_1u_1}\ind_{\{0=u_2<u_1\}}\big].\ ] ] the laplace transforms @xmath23 and @xmath25 of regular densities @xmath159 and @xmath160 with respective support @xmath161 and @xmath162 ( see equations ( [ cones12])-([axes12 ] ) ) are similarly defined by @xmath163 for @xmath156 ; equivalent definitions can be similarly written in terms of the expectation operator . expression ( [ dphi ] ) for distribution @xmath164 and the above definitions then enable to define the laplace transform @xmath165 of the pair @xmath13 by @xmath166 for @xmath167 .
finally , let @xmath168 ( resp .
@xmath169 ) denote the laplace transform of service time @xmath139 ( resp .
@xmath140 ) at queue @xmath43 ( resp .
queue @xmath44 ) for @xmath170 ( resp .
@xmath171 ) ; set in addition @xmath172 and @xmath173 * a ) * transforms @xmath22 , @xmath24 and @xmath23 , @xmath25 together satisfy @xmath174 for @xmath175 , where @xmath176 and @xmath177 . *
b ) * transforms @xmath22 and @xmath25 ( resp .
@xmath23 , @xmath24 ) satisfy @xmath178 for @xmath175 , with @xmath179 \\ - \lambda_2\mathbb{e } \left [ e^{-s_1u_1-s_2u_2}\ind_{\{0 \leq u_2 < u_1\}}e^{-s_2\mathcal{t}_2}\ind_{\{\mathcal{t}_2 > u_1-u_2\ } } \right ] .
\label{h}\end{gathered}\ ] ] * c ) * constants @xmath180 and @xmath181 satisfy relation @xmath182 .
[ resol ] * a ) * fix @xmath183 .
the test function @xmath184 , @xmath185 , belongs to @xmath132 and has derivatives @xmath186 , @xmath187 . besides
, we have @xmath188 hence @xmath189 = ( b_1(s_1)-1)\theta(\mathbf{u})$ ] , and similarly @xmath190 = ( b_2(s_2)-1)\theta(\mathbf{u})$ ] .
applying proposition [ generator ] , formula ( [ gen1 ] ) for @xmath191 then yields @xmath192 with @xmath193 defined in ( [ ker ] ) . integrating that expression of @xmath191 over closed quarter plane @xmath134 with respect to distribution @xmath164 and using assumptions *
a.1 * -*a.2 * , relation then gives @xmath194 with @xmath176 and @xmath177 ; using ( [ ldef ] ) finally provides ( [ fonct ] ) .
* b ) * as detailed in appendix [ a2 ] , there exists a family of functions @xmath195 with @xmath196 , such that @xmath197 , @xmath198 _ and _ @xmath199 . for given @xmath200 , @xmath201 ,
the function @xmath202 defined by @xmath203 , @xmath130 , therefore belongs to @xmath132 and satisfies @xmath204 pointwise in @xmath134 with @xmath205 ( note that @xmath206 ) .
apply then formula ( [ gen1 ] ) to regularized test function @xmath202 and integrate this expression over @xmath134 against distribution @xmath164 to define @xmath207 in view of ( [ stationary ] ) , we have @xmath208 and , provided that @xmath209 has a finite limit @xmath210 as @xmath211 , we must have @xmath212 .
the detailed calculation of that limit @xmath210 ( depending on the pair @xmath213 ) is performed in appendix [ a2 ] and condition @xmath212 is shown to reduce to first equation ( [ fonctcomp ] ) . exchanging indices 1 and 2 provides second equation ( [ fonctcomp ] ) , after noting that @xmath214 changes into @xmath215 .
* c ) * adding equations ( [ fonctcomp ] ) gives ( [ fonct ] ) if and only if @xmath182 holds .
computing @xmath216 by letting @xmath217 in ( [ fonct ] ) readily gives @xmath218 with @xmath219 .
identity ( [ pk ] ) is obviously pollaczek - khintchin formula for the transform @xmath220 of the total workload @xmath57 in the global @xmath59 queue , with i.i.d .
service times having distribution @xmath221 defined by ( [ db ] ) . [ coroltech ] let @xmath27 be defined by ( [ h ] ) .
transform @xmath24 satisfies @xmath222 for @xmath183 such that @xmath30 .
similarly , transform @xmath25 satisfies @xmath223 for @xmath183 such that @xmath29 .
[ c.2 ] function @xmath224 is finite for any given @xmath183 ; if @xmath30 , the product @xmath225 is therefore zero . as @xmath226 second equation ( [ fonctcomp ] ) then implies ( [ fonctg1 ] ) .
relation ( [ fonctg2 ] ) is similarly derived . in this section ,
we first compare the sqf system with the hol queue , where one queue has head of line ( hol ) priority over the other ; such a comparison then enables us to extend the analyticity domain of laplace transforms @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 , @xmath25 .
+ let @xmath227 , @xmath228 , denote the workload in queue @xmath229 when the other queue has hol priority ; similarly , let @xmath230 denote the workload in queue @xmath229 when this queue has hol priority over the other . finally , given two real random variables @xmath231 and @xmath232 , @xmath232
is said to dominate @xmath231 in the strong order sense ( for short , @xmath233 ) if and only if @xmath234 for any positive non - decreasing measurable function @xmath235 .
workload @xmath236 verifies @xmath237 for all @xmath83 .
[ domstoch ] we clearly have @xmath238 almost surely for all @xmath83 , where @xmath75 is defined by .
equation ( [ path ] ) consequently entails that @xmath239 pathwise , which implies the strong stochastic domination .
similarly , we have @xmath240 almost surely for all @xmath83 and ( [ path ] ) entails @xmath241 pathwise , hence the strong stochastic domination .
assume that random variable @xmath242 has an analytic laplace transform @xmath243 in the domain @xmath244 for some real @xmath245 .
laplace transform @xmath22 can be analytically extended to domain @xmath246 and transform @xmath25 can be analytically extended to @xmath247 .
similarly , transform @xmath23 can be analytically extended to @xmath248 and @xmath24 can be analytically extended to @xmath249 .
[ extensions ] assume first that @xmath250 and @xmath251 are real with @xmath252 ; given @xmath253 , we have @xmath254 ; using the domination property @xmath255 of proposition [ domstoch ] and the previous inequality , definition ( [ ff ] ) of @xmath22 on @xmath149 entails @xmath158 \leq \mathbb{e}\big[e^{-(s_1+s_2)\overline{u}_2}\big];\ ] ] we then deduce that @xmath22 can be analytically continued to any point @xmath213 verifying @xmath256 and @xmath257 . assuming now that @xmath258 and @xmath259 , domination property @xmath260 yields @xmath261 and definition ( [ ff ] ) of @xmath22 on @xmath149 entails in turn @xmath158 \leq \mathbb{e}\big[e^{- s_2 \overline{u}_2}\big];\ ] ] @xmath22 can therefore be analytically continued to any point @xmath213 verifying @xmath262 and @xmath263 . we conclude that @xmath22 can be analytically continued to domain @xmath264 , as claimed .
writing definition ( [ ffb ] ) of @xmath25 as @xmath265 $ ] for @xmath171 , the same type of arguments as above enables us to analytically continue function @xmath25 to any point verifying @xmath266 .
domains @xmath264 and @xmath267 are illustrated in figure [ fig3 ] ( assuming @xmath268 for instance ) . following proposition [ resol ] and corollary [ coroltech ] , the determination of laplace transforms @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25
critically depends on both the determination of auxiliary bivariate function @xmath27 generally defined in ( [ h ] ) and the solutions to equations @xmath269 and @xmath270 .
the latter , however , may be very intricate to compute for general service time distributions . to make the resolution more tractable
, we will now introduce some specific assumptions .
first , service times are assumed to be exponentially distributed ; this readily provides a more explicit expression for function @xmath27 . in the case of exponentially distributed service times
, we have @xmath271 where @xmath272 are analytically defined for @xmath273 . [ hexp ] the proof of proposition [ hexp ] is deferred to appendix [ a3 ] . expression ( [ hbis ] ) consequently reduces the determination of function @xmath27 to that of two univariate functions @xmath274 and @xmath275 . in the rest of this paper
, we further assume that the poisson arrival rates and service time distributions in each queue are equal , the so - called `` symmetric ( exponential ) case '' .
because of its technical complexity , the asymmetric case will be treated in a forthcoming paper @xcite .
as previously motivated , we assume from now on that * poisson arrival rates are equal , namely @xmath93 ; * service times in both queues are exponentially distributed with identical parameter @xmath276 , i.e. , @xmath277 ; the laplace transform of the service time distribution is then @xmath278 . by the latter symmetry assumption ,
queues @xmath43 and @xmath44 are now interchangeable in terms of probability distribution .
definition ( [ ff ] ) of @xmath22 or @xmath23 then entails that @xmath279 for @xmath31 and we denote by @xmath280 the latter quantity ; using similar arguments , we have @xmath281 . by proposition [ resol].c ,
we further have @xmath282 and function @xmath283 introduced in ( [ j1j2 ] ) is simply given by @xmath284 relations then specialize to the unique equation @xmath285 where general expression for @xmath27 now simply reduces to @xmath286 where @xmath287 ( note the symmetry between transforms @xmath22 and @xmath23 mentioned above implies that @xmath288 ) .
once function @xmath27 is expressed by ( [ hsym ] ) in terms of auxiliary function @xmath1 , functional equation ( [ kernelsym ] ) gives @xmath289 in terms of both @xmath290 and @xmath1 .
as univariate transform @xmath290 will be later shown to depend on function @xmath1 only , our remaining task is therefore to derive the latter function .
let us first assert some extension properties for analytic functions of interest .
recall from ( * ? ? ?
* 3.3 ) that the laplace transform of the workload @xmath291 in queue @xmath43 when queue @xmath44 has hol priority is given by @xmath292 = \frac{2(1-\rho)s\xi^+(s)}{\lambda(1-b(s))(s-\xi^+(s))}\ ] ] for @xmath293 , where @xmath294 is the unique root of equation @xmath295 which is positive for @xmath296 .
specializing definition ( [ ker ] ) for @xmath297 to the present symmetric case , equation @xmath298 readily reduces to @xmath299 its roots @xmath294 and @xmath300 are therefore given by @xmath301 where discriminant @xmath302 is positive for @xmath303\zeta^-,\zeta^+[$ ] and non positive for @xmath304 $ ] , with @xmath305 functions @xmath306 are defined for real @xmath307 $ ] . with the convention @xmath308
, we can define analytic or meromorphic extensions of these functions in the complex plane as follows .
function @xmath309 ( resp .
@xmath310 ) can be analytically ( resp .
meromorphically ) extended to the cut plane @xmath311 $ ] .
[ extendxi ] function @xmath312 is well - defined for @xmath313\zeta^-,\zeta^+[$ ] , whereas function @xmath314 is well - defined for @xmath315\zeta^-,\zeta^+[$ ] and @xmath316 , with @xmath317 .
it is easily checked that for @xmath318 belonging to the vertical line @xmath319 , we have @xmath320 and @xmath321 ( note this vertical line and the real line are the only subsets of the complex plane on which @xmath320 ) .
the schwarz s reflection principle applied to function @xmath322 with respect to the vertical line @xmath323 then ensures that the function @xmath324 defined by @xmath325 for @xmath326 and @xmath327 for @xmath328 is globally analytic on the cut plane @xmath329 $ ] .
let us then define functions @xmath330 and @xmath331 by @xmath332 respectively . by construction ,
function @xmath330 is a meromorphic extension of @xmath310 in @xmath333 $ ] with a pole at point @xmath334 , while function @xmath331 is an analytic extension of @xmath309 in @xmath335 $ ] .
+ for notation simplicity , we will still denote by @xmath310 and @xmath309 their respective analytic continuation @xmath330 and @xmath331 defined above . consider now equation @xmath336 , whose unique non - zero solution is @xmath337 . as @xmath338 , it is easily verified that solution @xmath337 is associated with branch @xmath310 if @xmath339 and with branch @xmath309 if @xmath340 .
define then @xmath341 ( note that @xmath342 for all @xmath343 $ ] , as easily verified from the defining expression of polynomial @xmath344 in ( [ xi+- ] ) ) . with the above notation , laplace transform @xmath290 can be analytically extended to the half - plane @xmath345 ; function @xmath346 can be analytically extended to @xmath347 .
[ extendgf0 ] by ( [ uhol ] ) and lemma [ extendxi ] , transform @xmath348 is analytic for @xmath349 .
this transform may have a pole only at any point @xmath318 such that @xmath350 . by the above discussion
, we actually have a pole at @xmath351 when @xmath352 ; it is not a pole when @xmath353 but the algebraic singularity at point @xmath354 instead occurs . applying then corollary [ extensions ] with @xmath355 , the extended analyticity domains for @xmath290 and @xmath346 follow .
following definition ( [ msym ] ) and lemma [ extendgf0 ] , function @xmath1 is consequently analytic on the half - plane @xmath356 .
as detailed in section [ sqfqueue ] , the final determination of function @xmath1 relies on the algebraic and analytic properties for the branches of a cubic polynomial equation . *
a ) * for given @xmath38 and @xmath357 , relations @xmath358 can be inverted in variable @xmath318 as @xmath359 respectively , where @xmath360 and @xmath361 are the two non positive roots of cubic equation @xmath37 in variable @xmath362 , with @xmath363 for @xmath38 , @xmath300 and @xmath294 are given by @xmath364 and @xmath365 . *
b ) * for @xmath366 , cubic polynomial @xmath367 has three distinct real roots @xmath360 , @xmath361 and @xmath368 such that @xmath369 and @xmath370 .
[ roots - r ] * a ) * eliminating @xmath300 between first relation ( [ z - s ] ) and polynomial equation ( [ eqxi ] ) satisfied by @xmath300 , we can write @xmath371 where @xmath372 , cubic polynomial @xmath367 being defined as in ( [ cubiceq ] ) . similarly , eliminating @xmath294 between second relation ( [ z - s ] ) and equation ( [ eqxi ] ) enables us to write @xmath373 where @xmath374 with identical polynomial @xmath367 .
we readily deduce , in particular , that @xmath375 , and similarly @xmath376 .
* b ) * for @xmath38 , we have @xmath377 and @xmath378 since @xmath379 by the stability condition . further accounting for its values at infinity , we deduce that cubic polynomial @xmath367 has three real roots for @xmath366 ; denoting them by @xmath360 , @xmath361 and @xmath368 , the latter discussion implies the claimed inequalities .
we finally verify that roots @xmath360 and @xmath361 previously characterised either in * a ) * or * b ) * actually coincide .
in fact , let @xmath380 so that @xmath381 ; given the variations of the function @xmath314 for @xmath382 , @xmath318 has to be sufficiently large for @xmath381 to be positive ; this implies that we necessarily have @xmath383 where @xmath360 is the smallest root of polynomial @xmath367 .
we can similarly prove that if @xmath384 , then @xmath385 where @xmath386 is the second smallest root of @xmath367 .
as solutions to a polynomial equation , algebraic functions @xmath387 , @xmath388 and @xmath389 can be analytically defined in @xmath390 cut along some slits . specifically , writing @xmath391 as @xmath392 with coefficients @xmath393 , @xmath394 and @xmath395 defined by ( [ cubiceq ] ) and introducing @xmath396 any solution @xmath397 to @xmath37 can be expressed by cardano s formula @xcite as @xmath398{\frac{1}{2 } \left ( - \widetilde{q}+ \sqrt{- \frac{\delta}{27 } } \right ) } + j^n \sqrt[3]{\frac{1}{2 } \left ( - \widetilde{q } - \sqrt{- \frac{\delta}{27 } } \right ) } , \ ] ] where @xmath399 , the pair @xmath400 can take either value @xmath125 , @xmath401 or @xmath402 , and with discriminant @xmath403 defined by @xmath404 .
some algebra shows that discriminant @xmath405 factorizes as @xmath406 with @xmath407 the respective analyticity domains of functions @xmath408 , @xmath409 and @xmath410 are related to the roots of discriminant @xmath405 , these roots defining the so - called ramification points for such algebraic functions . * a ) * discriminant @xmath405 has four distinct roots , namely two real roots @xmath411-\mu,0[$ ] and @xmath412 and two complex conjugate roots @xmath413 and @xmath414 .
+ * b ) * algebraic functions @xmath408 , @xmath409 and @xmath410 are analytic on the cut plane @xmath415 $ ] , @xmath416\cup[\eta_3,\eta_4])$ ] and @xmath417 $ ] , respectively . [ discriminant ] * a ) * the point @xmath418 is clearly a root of @xmath419 and it is simple since @xmath420 in view of expression ( [ smalldelta ] ) . moreover , as the coefficient of the leading term of the cubic polynomial @xmath421 is positive , as @xmath422 and @xmath423 , discriminant @xmath405 has at least another negative real root @xmath424 between @xmath334 and 0 .
besides , the discriminant of @xmath421 is easily calculated as @xmath425 with @xmath426 ; as @xmath427 for @xmath428 , we have @xmath429
. it then follows from ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.3.1 ) that cubic polynomial @xmath421 with real coefficients has only one real root , namely @xmath424 , the two others @xmath413 and @xmath414 being complex conjugates .
* b ) * by considering the analytic continuation of function @xmath430 such that @xmath431 in @xmath416\cup[\eta_3,\eta_4])$ ] , formulas ( [ cardan ] ) enable us to analytically continue function @xmath408 to the cut plane @xmath415 $ ] , function @xmath409 to the cut plane @xmath416\cup[\eta_3,\eta_4])$ ] and function @xmath410 to the cut plane @xmath417 $ ] , respectively . the graphs of functions @xmath432 and @xmath433 are illustrated in fig .
[ courbexi ] on interval @xmath434 $ ] .
function @xmath435 is increasing while function @xmath436 reaches its minimum at some point @xmath437 ; @xmath436 is decreasing on interval @xmath438\zeta^+,s^*[$ ] and increasing on interval @xmath438s^*,0[$ ] .
recall from proposition [ roots - r ] that @xmath383 entails @xmath439 ; conversely , we have @xmath439 for @xmath440 . function @xmath387 is thus defined and regular for @xmath441\eta_1,+\infty[$ ] where @xmath442 . using similar arguments , @xmath388 is shown to be regular for @xmath443 .
on the basis of the preliminary results obtained in section [ expi ] , we are now ready to provide a final solution for auxiliary function @xmath1 ( section [ rse ] ) and determine an extended analyticity domain ( section [ ss ] ) , from which all relevant probabilistic properties for the symmetric queue can be derived ( sections [ eqp ] and [ lqa ] ) .
we first provide a series expansion for laplace transform @xmath290 on some real interval of its definition domain . the proposition below states the core functional equation verified by function @xmath1 .
function @xmath1 defined by ( [ msym ] ) verifies the functional equation @xmath444 for @xmath38 , with @xmath445 where @xmath371 is the unique solution to equation @xmath446 .
[ c1 ] applying equation successively to points @xmath447 and @xmath448 with identical ordinate @xmath318 , we obtain @xmath449 after using expression ( [ jj ] ) for @xmath450 and formula ( [ hsym ] ) for @xmath214 ; equations ( [ msymequ ] ) hold for sufficiently large @xmath318 so that @xmath451 is positive . using the fact that @xmath371 . equating the common value of @xmath452 from ( [ msymequ ] ) and using the fact that @xmath453 gives functional equation ( [ fonctmsym ] ) . by proposition [ roots - r].a , @xmath454 depends on the branch @xmath360 only . as @xmath455 in view of defining equation ( [ eqxi ] ) , definition
( [ defqlh ] ) for @xmath456 further gives @xmath457 , \label{hz}\ ] ] and a similar rational expression is derived from ( [ defqlh ] ) for @xmath458 in terms of @xmath360 . as a consequence , given functions @xmath2
, @xmath3 , and @xmath4 depend only on the branch @xmath408 of cubic equation @xmath37 .
note also that by the notation introduced in inversion relations ( [ z - s])-([z - sinvert ] ) , @xmath456 just coincides with @xmath459 ; the mapping @xmath460 is now introduced in view of its iterated composition , as will be shown in the central result below .
the laplace transform @xmath290 can be expressed as @xmath461 \label{gsym}\ ] ] for sufficiently large real @xmath318 so that @xmath462 and where @xmath463 is given by the series expansion @xmath464 with functions @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 defined by , and @xmath465 denoting the @xmath466-th iterate of function @xmath4 .
[ resolsym ] iterating functional equation ( [ fonctmsym ] ) for @xmath380 yields @xmath467 ( the product being equal to 1 for @xmath468 ) , with remainder @xmath469 to show that @xmath470 as @xmath471 , let us fix some @xmath380 . we first prove that the sequence @xmath472 , @xmath473 , is strictly increasing and tends to @xmath474 when @xmath475 .
in fact , as @xmath476 for @xmath380 by proposition [ roots - r].b , we deduce from expression ( [ hz ] ) that @xmath477 for @xmath38 and the sequence @xmath478 , @xmath473 , is thus strictly increasing .
moreover , if that sequence were upper bounded , it would tend to a finite limit @xmath479 such that @xmath480 and the number @xmath481 is positive ; but using expression ( [ hz ] ) for @xmath456 , equality @xmath480 reduces to @xmath482,\ ] ] or equivalently @xmath483 and the latter would define a simultaneously positive and negative quantity , a contradiction .
we thus conclude that @xmath484 when @xmath475 . besides
, we derive from definition ( [ defqlh ] ) for @xmath2 that @xmath485 , where @xmath486 by definition ( [ msym ] ) of function @xmath1 , the sequence @xmath487 , @xmath473 , is bounded since both @xmath290 and @xmath346 vanish at infinity as laplace transforms of regular densities .
it follows that remainder @xmath488 is @xmath489 = o(r^k)$ ] and therefore tends to 0 as @xmath471 .
the finite sum in ( [ quotientbis ] ) thus converges as @xmath471 .
formula ( [ gsym ] ) for @xmath452 eventually follows from the latter expansion inserted into second equation ( [ msymequ ] ) .
we now specify the smallest singularity of laplace transform @xmath290 ; to this end , we first deal with the analyticity domain of auxiliary function @xmath1 .
recall by definition ( [ msym ] ) that @xmath1 is known to be analytic at least in the half - plane @xmath356 , where @xmath490 is defined by .
function @xmath1 can be analytically continued to the half - plane @xmath491 ( with @xmath492 ) defined by * @xmath493 in case @xmath494 , where we set @xmath495 ; * @xmath496 in case @xmath340 , where @xmath497 is the largest real root of discriminant @xmath405 .
[ extendm ] the proof of proposition [ extendm ] is detailed in appendix [ a4 ] .
we now turn to transform @xmath290 and determine its singularities with smallest module .
recall by corollary [ extensions ] that @xmath290 has no singularity in @xmath498 .
[ domaing ] the singularity with smallest module of transform @xmath290 is * for @xmath494 , a simple pole at @xmath499 with leading term @xmath500 with @xmath501 ; * for @xmath502 , an algebraic singularity at @xmath503 with leading term @xmath504 at first order in @xmath505 , where factor @xmath506 is given by @xmath507\ ] ] with constants @xmath508 , @xmath509 and where @xmath510 , @xmath511 are given in ( [ zeta1 + - ] ) . [ gsing ]
consider again the two following cases : + * a ) * if @xmath494 , write the 1st equation ( [ msymequ ] ) as @xmath512 ; \label{gsymbis}\ ] ] as @xmath513 , we have @xmath514 while @xmath515 .
proposition [ extendm ] then ensures that @xmath516 is analytic at @xmath517 since @xmath518 for @xmath494 .
as @xmath452 has no singularity for @xmath519 , we conclude from expression ( [ gsymbis ] ) that @xmath290 has a simple pole at @xmath520 with residue @xmath521\ ] ] where @xmath495 .
differentiating formula for @xmath294 at @xmath520 , we further calculate @xmath522 ; residue @xmath523 in leading term ( [ resgsym1 ] ) then follows ; + * b ) * if @xmath502 , let @xmath513 so that @xmath524 and @xmath525 where @xmath526 .
proposition [ extendm ] then ensures that @xmath1 is analytic at @xmath527 since @xmath528 .
we conclude from expression ( [ gsymbis ] ) and the latter discussion that @xmath529 is not a singularity of @xmath290 .
+ by definition of @xmath294 , where @xmath344 is factorized as @xmath530 with @xmath531 , we obtain @xmath532 where @xmath508 and with constant @xmath533 . by expression ( [ gsymbis ] ) for @xmath452 , we then obtain @xmath534 \nonumber \\ & = g(\zeta^+ ) + r^+(s-\zeta^+)^{1/2 } + ... \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath535 with @xmath536 defined in ( [ resgsym2 ] ) . expansion ( [ resgsym2 ] ) then follows with associated factor @xmath506 ; we conclude that the singularity with smallest module of @xmath290 is @xmath510 , an algebraic singularity with order 1 .
the results obtained in the previous section enable us to give a closed - form expression for the empty queue probability in terms of auxiliary function @xmath1 only .
probability @xmath537 is given by @xmath538 with @xmath1 given by series expansion ( [ mseries ] ) .
[ g0sym ] apply relation ( [ gsymbis ] ) for @xmath452 with @xmath539 ; as @xmath540 , we then derive that @xmath541 hence @xmath542 ; \label{g(0)bis}\ ] ] differentiating formula for @xmath294 at @xmath539 gives @xmath543 so that the first term inside brackets in ( [ g(0)bis ] ) reduces to @xmath544 .
now , applying ( [ fonctmsym ] ) to value @xmath539 ( with corresponding pair @xmath545 and @xmath546 ) shows that the right - hand side of ( [ g(0)bis ] ) also equals @xmath547 , as claimed . by ( [ p0 ] ) and ( [ g(0 ) ] )
, we derive the probability @xmath548 that either queue @xmath43 or @xmath44 is empty .
we depict in figure [ figg0 ] the variations of @xmath549 in terms of load @xmath550 when fixing @xmath551 ( for comparison , the black dashed line represents the empty queue probability @xmath552 for the unique queue aggregating all jobs from either class @xmath43 or @xmath44 ) .
the numerical results show that @xmath549 decreases to a positive limit , approximately @xmath553 , when @xmath554 tends to 1 ; this can be interpreted by saying that , while the global system is unstable and sees excursions of either variable @xmath6 or @xmath7 to large values , one of the queues remains less than the other for a large period of time and has therefore a positive probability to be emptied by the server .
furthermore , the red dashed line depicts the empty queue probability @xmath555 if the server were to apply a preemptive hol policy with highest priority given to queue @xmath43 ; following lower bound ( [ stochlowup ] ) , we have @xmath556 .
we further notice that for @xmath557 , the positive limit of @xmath549 derived above for sqf is close enough to the maximal limit @xmath558 of @xmath559 .
the above observations consequently show that the sqf policy compares favorably to the optimal hol policy by guaranteeing a non vanishing empty queue probability for each traffic class at high load .
we finally derive asymptotics for the distribution of workload @xmath6 or @xmath7 in either queue , i.e. , the estimates of tail probabilities @xmath560 for large queue content @xmath561 .
we shall invoke the following tauberian theorem relating the singularities of a laplace transform to the asymptotic behavior of its inverse ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 25.2 , p.237 ) .
let @xmath165 be a laplace transform and @xmath562 be its singularity with smallest module , with @xmath563 as @xmath564 for @xmath565 and @xmath566 ( replace @xmath165 by @xmath567 if @xmath568 is finite ) .
the laplace inverse @xmath235 of @xmath165 is then estimated by @xmath569 for @xmath570 , where @xmath571 denotes euler s @xmath571 function .
[ tauberian ] note that the fact that @xmath568 is finite or not does not change the estimate of inverse @xmath235 at infinity . before using that theorem for the tail behavior of either @xmath6 or @xmath7
, we first state some simple bounds for their distribution tail . the global workload @xmath57 is identical to that in an @xmath572 queue with arrival rate @xmath573 and service rate @xmath276 .
the complementary distribution function of @xmath58 is therefore given by @xmath574 for all @xmath575 , with @xmath495 ; the distribution tail of workload @xmath6 or @xmath7 therefore decreases at least exponentially fast at infinity .
following upper bound ( [ stochlowup ] ) relating @xmath6 to variable @xmath291 corresponding to a hol service policy with highest priority given to queue @xmath44 , we further have @xmath576 for all @xmath577 .
the laplace transform of @xmath291 is given by equation and is meromorphic in the cut plane @xmath311 $ ] , with a possible pole at @xmath578 .
specifically , the application of theorem [ tauberian ] shows that the tail behavior of @xmath291 is given by @xmath579 for large @xmath561 .
the tail behavior of @xmath291 , and therefore @xmath6 , may therefore be either exponential or subexponential according to system parameters .
we precisely have the following result .
the workload in queue @xmath43 is such that @xmath580 for large @xmath561 , with constants @xmath495 and @xmath581 where @xmath582 is given by ( [ zeta1 + - ] ) and @xmath506 by ( [ resgsym2 ] ) .
[ asymptoticssym ] applying equation ( [ ldef ] ) to @xmath583 gives the laplace transform of @xmath6 as @xmath584 with @xmath585 by using and ( [ hsym ] ) .
we now follow the results of theorem [ gsing ] on the smallest singularity of @xmath290 in order to derive the smallest singularity of transform @xmath586 expressed above .
@xmath587 assume first @xmath494 .
by proposition [ extendm ] , function @xmath588 is analytic for @xmath589 .
it then follows from ( [ laplu1 ] ) that the singularity with smallest module of @xmath590 is at @xmath591 with leading term @xmath592 since @xmath593 and the root @xmath594 of @xmath595 is a removable singularity since @xmath596 has to be analytic for @xmath597 . by estimate ( [ resgsym1 ] ) for @xmath598 near @xmath591 , ( [ leadterm0 ] ) yields @xmath599 as @xmath600
; smallest singularity @xmath591 is thus a simple pole for laplace transform @xmath586 . applying then theorem [ tauberian ] with @xmath601 and @xmath602
, we derive that @xmath603 for large @xmath561 with prefactor @xmath604 as claimed .
@xmath587 assume now that @xmath502 .
by formula ( [ laplu1 ] ) and proposition [ extendm ] , function @xmath588 is analytic for @xmath605 .
it then follows from ( [ laplu1 ] ) that the singularity with smallest module of @xmath590 is at @xmath606 with leading term again specified by ( [ leadterm0 ] ) so that @xmath607 \label{smallestpolegter}\ ] ] near @xmath606 . by estimate ( [ resgsym2 ] ) , ( [ smallestpolegter ] ) yields @xmath608 as @xmath609 where @xmath610 smallest singularity @xmath606 is thus an algebraic singularity for laplace transform @xmath586 , with order @xmath611 .
applying theorem [ tauberian ] with @xmath612 , @xmath613 and @xmath614 , we derive that @xmath615 for large @xmath561 with prefactor @xmath616 .
@xmath587 finally , assume that @xmath617 ; the polar singularity @xmath618 and the algebraic singularity @xmath619 for @xmath290 coincide in this case . recall from proposition [ extendm].b that function @xmath620 is analytic for @xmath621 whenever @xmath340 ; @xmath424 is the only real zero @xmath622 of discriminant @xmath406 and expression ( [ smalldelta ] ) of @xmath421 gives @xmath623 , hence @xmath624 ; @xmath516 is therefore analytic at @xmath625 . near @xmath626 , formula ( [ xi+- ] )
easily gives @xmath627 expression ( [ gsymbis ] ) for @xmath598 and the discussion above then imply that @xmath628 in the neighborhood of @xmath626 .
the leading term ( [ leadterm0 ] ) for @xmath590 is consequently given by @xmath629 smallest singularity @xmath626 is thus an algebraic singularity for laplace transform @xmath586 , with order @xmath630 . applying then theorem [ tauberian ] with @xmath631 , @xmath632 and @xmath633
, we derive that @xmath634 for large @xmath561 with prefactor @xmath635 . for any given load @xmath6360,1[$ ] , theorem [ asymptoticssym ] consequently provides the same exponential trend as that of upper bound ( [ asympthol ] ) for hol ; as a matter of fact , a large value of @xmath6 entails that queue @xmath43 behaves as if queue @xmath44 , with smaller workload , had a hol priority .
the stationary analysis of two coupled queues addressed by a unique server running the sqf discipline has been generally considered for poisson arrival processes and general service time distributions ; required functional equations for the derivation of the stationary distribution for the coupled workload process have been derived .
specializing the resolution of such equations to both exponentially distributed service times and the so - called `` symmetric case '' , all quantities of interest have been obtained by solving a single functional equation . the solution @xmath1 for that equation has been given , in particular , as a series expansion involving all consecutive iterates of an algebraic function @xmath4 related to a branch of some cubic equation @xmath37 .
it must be noted that the curve represented by that cubic equation in the @xmath637 plane is singular ; in fact , whereas `` most '' cubic curves are regular ( i.e. , without multiple points ) , it can be easily checked that cubic @xmath638 has a double point at infinity . in
equivalent geometric terms , cubic @xmath638 can be identified with a sphere when seen as a surface in @xmath639 , whereas most cubic curves are identified with a torus .
this fact can be considered as an essential underlying feature characterizing the complexity of the present problem ; such geometric statements will be enlightened for solving the general asymmetric case in @xcite .
an extended analyticity domain for solution @xmath1 has been determined as the half - plane @xmath640 , thus enabling to determine the singularity of laplace transform @xmath290 with smallest module .
it could be also of interest to compare such extended domain @xmath640 to the maximal convergence domain of series expansion ( [ mseries ] ) ( recall the convergence of that series has been stated in theorem [ resolsym ] for real @xmath38 only ) ; in fact , the analyticity domain @xmath640 may not coincide with the validity domain for such a series representation .
the discrete holomorphic dynamical system defined by the iterates @xmath641 , @xmath642 , definitely plays a central role for such a comparison . as an alternative approach to that of section [ sqfqueue ] , function @xmath1 may also be derived through a riemann - hilbert boundary value problem ; hints for such an approach can be summarized as follows .
we successively note that * there exists @xmath643\zeta^-,\zeta^+[$ ] such that for @xmath644 , @xmath645 belongs to the analyticity domain @xmath640 determined by proposition [ extendm ] ; * denoting by @xmath646 the image by functions @xmath647 of the open interval @xmath438s_0,\zeta^+[$ ] , we note that @xmath648 for @xmath649 with @xmath650 .
equations then enable us to deduce the condition @xmath651 the above riemann - hilbert problem for function @xmath1 is , however , valid on open path
@xmath646 only and not on the whole closed contour @xmath652 , defined as the image by functions @xmath653 of closed segment @xmath654 $ ] . the well - posed problem , nevertheless , formulates as follows .
[ rhpglob ] determine a function @xmath107 which is analytic in @xmath655 , where @xmath656 is the domain delineated by the closed contour @xmath652 , tends to 0 at infinity and such that boundary condition ( [ bv0 ] ) holds on @xmath652 ( and not only on @xmath646 ) .
if the solution @xmath107 to * problem 3 * can be shown to exist and to be analytic on @xmath656 , then functions @xmath1 and @xmath107 coincide .
proving the latter statement and deriving an alternative representation of solution @xmath1 ( namely , as a path integral on closed contour @xmath652 ) is an object of further study . on the application side
, the performance of the sqf discipline has been characterized , both in terms of empty queue probability and distribution tail at infinity .
the results show that sqf compares quite favorably with respect to the `` optimal '' priority discipline , namely hol .
such performance properties will be generalized to the asymmetric case where flow patterns are allowed to be heterogeneous .
before proving equations ( [ fonctcomp ] ) , we state preliminary expressions of @xmath24 and @xmath25
. given @xmath657 univariate transforms @xmath24 and @xmath25 satisfy @xmath658 [ g1g2prov ] as transforms of regular densities , we have @xmath659 , @xmath660 when @xmath661 for fixed @xmath250 with @xmath200 . besides , we have @xmath662 , @xmath663 when @xmath661 with fixed @xmath664 , where @xmath665 is the laplace transform of the restriction of density @xmath159 on the boundary @xmath154 and @xmath181 is the value at @xmath666 of density @xmath160 on boundary @xmath162 ; as a consequence , @xmath667 for fixed @xmath664 .
now , letting @xmath251 tend to @xmath474 in each side of ( [ fonct ] ) , the above limit results entail @xmath668 with @xmath669 , which provides identity ( [ g1g2comp ] ) for @xmath670 .
identity ( [ g1g2comp ] ) for @xmath671 is symmetrically deduced by letting @xmath250 tend to @xmath474 in ( [ fonctcomp ] ) with fixed @xmath672 .
we now address the derivation of equations ( [ fonctcomp ] ) .
recall that subsets @xmath153 , @xmath154 , etc . of state space
@xmath134 are defined in ( [ cones12])-([axes12 ] ) .
given @xmath196 , define the function @xmath673 by @xmath674 ; @xmath673 is twice continuously differentiable over @xmath675 , @xmath676 for each @xmath677 and @xmath678 ( the dirac mass at @xmath679 ) for the weak convergence of distributions .
for given @xmath200 , @xmath201 , let then be the test function @xmath203 , @xmath130 , with @xmath680 function @xmath202 belongs to @xmath681 and is 0 on the outside of @xmath153 ; moreover , we have @xmath198 so that @xmath204 pointwise in @xmath134 , with limit function @xmath131 defined by @xmath682 , @xmath130 . by direct differentiation
, we further calculate @xmath683 for @xmath130 , with @xmath684 after ( [ iepsilon ] ) ; note that derivative @xmath685 tends to @xmath686 for the weak convergence of distributions as @xmath211 .
+ let us now calculate the limit @xmath687 with @xmath209 introduced in ( [ mepsilon ] ) ; to this end , we address successive terms of @xmath688 according to definition ( [ gen1 ] ) .
integrating first @xmath689 over @xmath690 against @xmath164 reduces to @xmath691 \varphi_1(\mathbf{u})\mathrm{d}\mathbf{u}\ ] ] since @xmath689 vanishes on the outside of @xmath153 ; on account of the above mentioned weak convergence properties , we then obtain @xmath692 with @xmath693 defined as in lemma [ g1g2prov ] and where @xmath694 defines the laplace transform of density @xmath151 restricted to the positive diagonal @xmath695 ( function @xmath696 is determined below ) . besides , the integral of @xmath697 over @xmath698 equals 0 as this function vanishes on the outside of @xmath153 .
further , we have @xmath699 for given @xmath130 and @xmath700 , therefore @xmath701 by the dominated convergence theorem ; hence @xmath702 where random variable @xmath127 has distribution @xmath107 . for given @xmath130 ,
we similarly have @xmath703 and therefore @xmath704 finally , noting that @xmath705 and adding limit terms ( [ lim1 ] ) , ( [ lim3 ] ) , ( [ lim4 ] ) according to ( [ gen1 ] ) gives limit @xmath706 the final expression @xmath707 \\ & + \lambda_1 \left [ b_1(s_1)g_2(s_2 ) - \int_0^{+\infty } e^{-s_2u_2}\mathbb{e } \left ( e^{-s_1\mathcal{t}_1 } \ind_{\{\mathcal{t}_1 > u_2\ } } \right ) \psi_2(u_2)\mathrm{d}u_2 \right ] \\ & + \lambda_2 b_2(s_2 ) f_1(s_1,s_2 ) + \lambda_2 \ ; \bigg [ \int_{\gamma_2 } e^{-\mathbf{s } \cdot \mathbf{u } } \mathbb{e } \left ( e^{-s_2\mathcal{t}_2 } \ind_{\{\mathcal{t}_2 > u_1 - u_2\ } } \right ) \varphi_2(\mathbf{u } ) \mathrm{d}\mathbf{u } \\ & + \int_0^{+\infty } e^{-s_1u_1}\mathbb{e } \left ( e^{-s_2\mathcal{t}_2 } \ind_{\{\mathcal{t}_2 > u_1\ } } \right ) \psi_1(u_1)\mathrm{d}u_1 \bigg ] - \lambda f_1(s_1,s_2 ) = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] defining @xmath214 as in ( [ h ] ) to gather all remaining integrals , the latter identity reads @xmath708 with @xmath709 , @xmath693 being defined by ( [ defe21e12 ] ) and where @xmath696 defines the laplace transform of density @xmath151 restricted to the diagonal . changing index 1 into 2 , and noting that @xmath214 changes into @xmath710 , symmetrically yields second equation @xmath711 with @xmath712 , @xmath713 defined by and where @xmath714 defines the laplace transform of density @xmath159 restricted to the diagonal . to conclude the proof , we prove the following technical lemma . functions @xmath696 and @xmath714 are identically zero .
[ w1w2 ] adding equations ( [ fonctcomp1 ] ) and ( [ fonctcomp2 ] ) ( and omitting arguments for the sake of simplicity ) yields @xmath715 .
on the other hand , equation ( [ fonct ] ) gives @xmath716 ; equating right hand sides of the latter equations then provides the identity @xmath717 using expressions ( [ g1g2comp ] ) for @xmath670 and @xmath671 , the latter identity simply reduces to @xmath718 , showing that function @xmath719 is constant . as both @xmath696 and @xmath714 vanish at @xmath474 , this constant
is 0 and since these functions are non negative by definition , this entails that @xmath720 . after using equations ( [ g1g2comp ] ) to express @xmath693 and @xmath713 in terms of @xmath671 and
@xmath670 , respectively , lemma [ w1w2 ] finally enables us to reduce ( [ fonctcomp1 ] ) and ( [ fonctcomp2 ] ) to equations ( [ fonctcomp ] ) .
this concludes the proof of proposition [ resol ] .
for an exponentially distributed service time @xmath139 with parameter @xmath721 , the factor of @xmath45 in definition ( [ h ] ) of @xmath214 reads @xmath722 = \\
\int_0^{+\infty } \int_0^{+\infty } \left [ \int_{u_2-u_1}^{+\infty } e^{-s_1x_1 } \mu_1 e^{-\mu_1x_1 } \mathrm{d}x_1 \right ] e^{-s_1u_1-s_2u_2}\ind_{\{0 \leq u_1 < u_2\}}\mathrm{d}\phi(u_1,u_2),\end{gathered}\ ] ] for @xmath723 and @xmath724 . by definition ( [ dphi ] ) ,
the latter term is equal to @xmath725 \\ = \frac{\mu_1}{\mu_1+s_1 } \big [ g_2(s_1+s_2+\mu_1 ) + f_1(-\mu_1,s_1+s_2+\mu_1 ) \big ] \end{gathered}\ ] ] where , by corollary [ extensions ] , each term inside brackets is analytically defined for @xmath213 such that @xmath726 and @xmath727 , respectively , that is at least for @xmath728 .
similarly , for an exponentially distributed service time @xmath140 with parameter @xmath729 , the factor of @xmath46 in definition ( [ h ] ) of @xmath214 reads @xmath730 = \\ - \frac{\mu_2}{\mu_2+s_2}\left [ g_1(s_1+s_2+\mu_2 ) + f_2(s_1+s_2+\mu_2,-\mu_2)\right ] \end{gathered}\ ] ] where , by corollary [ extensions ] , each term inside brackets is analytically defined for @xmath213 such that @xmath731 and @xmath732 , respectively , hence for @xmath733 .
adding up the two above expressions , we obtain claimed expressions .
* by lemma [ discriminant ] , function @xmath387 is analytic on the cut plane @xmath736 $ ] , where ramification points @xmath737 , @xmath424 are determined as the real negative roots of discriminant @xmath405 . as @xmath738 ,
function @xmath387 is , in particular , analytic in the half - plane @xmath739 ; * by definition ( [ cubiceq ] ) , we may have @xmath740 only if @xmath741 , that is , @xmath742 or @xmath743 or @xmath744 ; in the case @xmath745 , we have @xmath746 and in the case @xmath747 , @xmath748 we conclude that we can not have @xmath749 if @xmath750 ; * by corollary [ extensions ] , transform @xmath290 is analytic on @xmath751 where @xmath752 if @xmath494 and @xmath354 if @xmath502 .
* a ) * assume first that @xmath352 . in the @xmath756 plane , the diagonal @xmath757 intersects the curve @xmath758 at @xmath759 ( see fig . [ courbexi1 ] ) .
further , we easily verify that @xmath760 for @xmath761 and condition ( [ conditionaa ] ) is therefore fulfilled in this first case .
we then conclude that function @xmath1 is analytic for @xmath762 , and thus for @xmath763 ( recall by definition ( [ msym ] ) that @xmath1 is the sum of two non - negative laplace transforms ) .
* b ) * assume now that @xmath340 ( see fig . [ courbexi2 ] ) .
we have shown above that we can not have @xmath764 , which would otherwise imply @xmath765 .
we thus necessarily have @xmath766 , which entails that @xmath767 for @xmath768 and condition ( [ conditionaa ] ) is therefore fulfilled in this second case .
we then conclude that function @xmath1 is analytic for @xmath768 , hence for @xmath621 . | we analyze the so - called shortest queue first ( sqf ) queueing discipline whereby a unique server addresses queues in parallel by serving at any time that queue with the smallest workload . considering a stationary system composed of two parallel queues and assuming poisson arrivals and general service time distributions , we first establish the functional equations satisfied by the laplace transforms of the workloads in each queue .
we further specialize these equations to the so - called `` symmetric case '' , with same arrival rates and identical exponential service time distributions at each queue ; we then obtain a functional equation @xmath0 for unknown function @xmath1 , where given functions @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 are related to one branch of a cubic polynomial equation .
we study the analyticity domain of function @xmath1 and express it by a series expansion involving all iterates of function @xmath4 .
this allows us to determine empty queue probabilities along with the tail of the workload distribution in each queue .
this tail appears to be identical to that of the head - of - line preemptive priority system , which is the key feature desired for the sqf discipline . |
it is well known that the current through a voltage - biased superconducting quantum point contact ( sqpc ) is carried by localized states .
these states , called andreev states , are confined to the normal region of the contact .
the energy of the states the andreev levels exist in pairs , ( one above and one under the fermi level ) , and lie within the energy gap of the superconductor , with positions which depend on the change @xmath0 in the phase of the superconductors across the junction .
the applied bias affects this phase difference through the josephson relation , @xmath1 . with a constant applied bias @xmath2 much smaller than the gap energy @xmath3
, @xmath0 will increase linearly in time , and the andreev levels will move adiabatically within the gap .
this motion is a periodic oscillation in @xmath0 , indicating that no energy is transfered to the sqpc and a pure ac current will flow through the contact .
this is actually the ac josephson effect .
we wish to study this system in a non - equilibrium situation , one way to accomplish this is by introducing microwave radiation with a frequency @xmath4 , which will couple the andreev levels to each other .
the radiation will represent a non - adiabatic perturbation of the sqpc system .
however , if the amplitude of the electromagnetic field is sufficiently small , the field will not affect the adiabatic dynamics of the system much unless the condition for resonant optical interlevel transitions is fulfilled .
such resonances will only occur at certain moments determined by the time evolution of the andreev level spacing .
the resonances will provide a mechanism for energy transfer to the system to be nonzero when averaged over time and hence for a finite dc current through the junction .
the rate of energy transfer is in an essential way determined by the interference between different scattering events @xcite , and therefore it is not surprising that oscillatory features appear in the ( dc ) current - voltage characteristics of an irradiated sqpc .
dephasing and relaxation will affect the interference pattern and may even conspire to produce a dc current flowing in the reverse direction with respect to the applied voltage bias .
the mechanism behind this negative resistance is very similar to the one responsible for the `` somersault effect '' discussed by gorelik et al .
@xcite .
a peculiar feature of the andreev bound states , in comparison with normal bound states , is that they can carry current .
this is why microwave - induced transitions between andreev levels can be detected by means of transport measurements .
in fact , it is possible to do andreev energy - level spectroscopy in the sense that the andreev level spectrum at least in principle can be reconstructed from a measurement of the microwave - induced subgap current .
such microwave spectroscopy of andreev states in mesoscopic superconductors is the topic addressed in this work .
for an unbiased , mesoscopic sqpc which by construction has a normal region @xmath5 which is much shorter than the coherence length @xmath6 the andreev spectrum of each transport mode has the form @xmath7^{1/2}.\ ] ] here @xmath8 is the transparency of the mode and the energy is measured from the fermi energy @xcite . with a small bias voltage applied , the levels move along the adiabatic trajectories @xmath9 in energy - time space , oscillating with a period of @xmath10 , as shown in fig . [ fig : junction ] . in equilibrium
the lower andreev level will obviously be occupied , while the upper level will be empty . in the discussion below we consider a single - mode sqpc , although we note that the theory also applies for the case of a single dominant mode in a multi - mode junction .
the transparency @xmath8 of the mode is taken to be arbitrary but energy - independent , @xmath11 .
a high frequency electromagnetic field is applied to the gate situated near the contact , see inset in fig .
[ fig : junction ] . the time - dependent electric field induced by the gate
is concentrated within the non - superconducting region of the junction , and hence the charge carriers will couple to the electromagnetic field only there . when the criterion @xmath12 for adiabaticity is obeyed , the rate of interlevel transitions is exponentially small keeping the level populations constant in time @xcite .
the presence of a weak electromagnetic field [ on the scale of @xmath13 does not affect the adiabatic level trajectories except for short times close to the resonances at @xmath14 , when @xmath15 . here
the dynamics of the system is strongly non - adiabatic with a resonant coupling which effectively mixes the adiabatic levels .
this is an analog of the well known landau - zener transition , which describes interlevel scattering as a resonance point is passed . in our case these transitions give rise to a splitting of the quasiparticle trajectory at the points @xmath16 into two paths ; @xmath17 and @xmath18 , forming a loop in @xmath19 space ( see fig .
[ fig : junction ] ) .
the resonant scattering opens a channel for energy absorption by the system ; a populated upper level when approaching the edge of the energy gap ( at point @xmath20 in fig .
[ fig : junction ] ) creates real excitations in the continuum spectrum , which carry away the accumulated energy from the contact . as a result ,
the net rate of energy transfer to the system is finite ; it consists of energy absorbed both from the electromagnetic field and from the voltage source .
the confluence of the two adiabatic trajectories at @xmath21 gives rise to a strong interference pattern in the probability for real excitations at the band edge , point @xmath20 .
the interference effect is controlled by the difference of the phases acquired by the system during propagation along the paths @xmath17 and @xmath18 . in order to describe the time evolution of the andreev states in more detail we use the time - dependent bogoliubov - de gennes , ( bdg ) , equation @xcite for the quasiclassical envelopes @xmath22 of the two - component wave function @xmath23 , @xmath24 { \bf u } \ , .
\label{bdg}\ ] ] in this equation @xmath25 is a four - component vector , while @xmath26 is the hamiltonian of the electrons in the electrodes of the point contact , @xmath27 , \ ] ] where @xmath28 and @xmath29 denote pauli matrices in electron - hole space and in @xmath30 space respectively . for a mesoscopic junction the gap function @xmath31
need not be calculated self - consistently , which is why in eq .
( [ h0 ] ) it is assumed to have the constant value @xmath32 in the superconducting reservoir on one side of the sqpc and the different constant value @xmath33 in the reservoir on the other side .
the gate potential @xmath34 in eq .
( [ bdg ] ) oscillates rapidly in time and the amplitude is assumed to be small compared to the andreev level spacing , @xmath35 .
the function @xmath36 , which is smooth on the scale of the fermi wavelength , has a discontinuity at @xmath37 , i.e. at the point contact , whose spatial extension can be neglected .
the discontinuity translates to a boundary condition for @xmath36 , @xmath38 which can be found @xcite by matching at the point @xmath37 two scattering state solutions to the bdg equation approaching from left and right . under the assumption that @xmath39 the system of andreev levels experiences an adiabatic evolution in time
this is true at all times except close to the resonances ( points @xmath40 and @xmath41 in fig .
[ fig : junction ] ) and at point c , which will be discussed later . for a resonant transition to occur , the deviation of the interlevel spacing from the resonance value @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the duration of the resonance , has to be less than the quantum mechanical resolution of the energy levels @xmath44 . using this criterion
we can estimate the duration @xmath43 of the non - adiabatic evolution as @xmath45^{1/2}$ ] , which implies that @xmath43 is much shorter than the period @xmath10 of josephson oscillations if @xmath46 .
hence , if this inequality is obeyed we may consider the non - adiabatic dynamics as temporally localized scattering events .
we shall use this later to derive an analytical result for the induced dc current . for the time
being , however , we will keep the discussion a little more general .
we therefore introduce an ansatz for the wave function * u * in the normal region of the junction in terms of a linear combination of the eigenstates @xmath47 corresponding to the adiabatic andreev levels @xmath48 .
the rapidly oscillating terms are explicitly introduced in this so called resonance approximation , @xmath49 following ref @xcite we insert the ansatz ( [ b ] ) into the bdg equation ( [ bdg ] ) to find , using the notation @xmath50 , an equation for the coefficients @xmath51 , @xmath52 \vec{b}(t ) .
\label{eq.coupled}\ ] ] here @xmath53/2\hbar$ ] is a measure of the deviation from resonance .
this equation describes the time evolution of the coefficients @xmath54 and @xmath55 , which embody the dynamics of the population of the andreev states under irradiation .
we recall that the coupling to the time - dependent field is finite only in the normal region , which explains why @xmath56 in ( [ eq.coupled ] ) obtains as the matrix element of @xmath57 between the andreev states @xmath47 ; @xmath58 , where @xmath59 denotes a scalar product in 4-dimensional space . for the case of a double barrier sqpc structure @xmath56
was calculated in ref . @xcite . for a single barrier junction
an analogous calculation gives us , @xmath60 , where the constant @xmath61 is determined by the position of the barrier .
we note , that this matrix element is proportional to the _ reflectivity _ of the junction ; reflection mixes electron states with @xmath62 and @xmath63 allowing optical transitions between the andreev levels . in a perfectly transparent sqpc ( @xmath64 ) ,
the upper and lower andreev levels correspond to opposite electron momenta the two levels can not be coupled by radiation since momentum can not be conserved and the effect under consideration does not exist , cf . refs .
@xcite .
before we proceed to calculate the current through the irradiated sqpc we need to discuss the boundary condition at @xmath65 ( @xmath66 is an integer ) . in the vicinity of these points , the andreev levels approach the continuum and
the adiabatic approximation is unsatisfactory , even at small applied voltages and weak electromagnetic fields .
the duration @xmath43 of the non - adiabatic interaction between the andreev level and the continuum states can be estimated using the same argument as for the microwave - induced landau - zener scattering .
one finds that , @xmath67 . if we evaluate the condition , @xmath68 , we find that we would require that @xmath69 .
this means that we can safely treat the non - adiabatic region as short . to derive the boundary condition , for example , at point @xmath20 in fig .
[ fig : junction ] , one needs to calculate the transition amplitude connecting the states @xmath70 at time @xmath71 and @xmath72 at time @xmath73 : @xmath74 . here
@xmath75 is the exact propagator corresponding to the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ bdg ] ) .
we will now proceed with symmetry arguments to show that this amplitude is exactly zero .
it can be shown that both the hamiltonian ( [ h0 ] ) and the boundary condition for @xmath36 at @xmath37 ( [ bc ] ) are invariant under the simultaneous charge- and parity inversion described by the unitary operator @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the parity operator in @xmath78-space .
this implies that at any time any non - degenerate eigenstate of the hamiltonian is an eigenstate of the symmetry operator @xmath79 with eigenvalue @xmath80 or @xmath81 and that this property persists during the time evolution of the state .
specifically , if we take a state on each side of @xmath82 , @xmath83 next we insert @xmath84 , where the operator @xmath85 changes the sign of the phase @xmath0 , into eq .
( [ sym2 ] ) and apply @xmath86 from the left and arrive at , @xmath87 which shows that @xmath88 .
this means that the two states , @xmath89 and @xmath90 are orthogonal .
this is consistent with the results of shumeiko et.al .
@xcite , who have shown that the andreev state wave functions are @xmath91-periodic whereas the energy levels and the current are @xmath92-periodic .
since the state evolving from the adiabatic state @xmath70 is orthogonal to the adiabatic state @xmath93 , the probability for an adiabatic andreev state to be scattered " into a localized state after passing the non - adiabatic region is identically zero . in reality , the andreev state as it approaches the continuum band edge decays into the states of the continuum .
such a decay corresponds to a delocalization in real space and is the mechanism for transferring energy to the reservoir @xcite . the orthogonality property shown above guarantees that the coherent evolution of our system persists during only one period of the josephson oscillation and that the equilibrium population of the andreev levels is reset at each point @xmath65 @xcite .
this imposes the boundary condition @xmath94 at the beginning of each period .
the quasiclassical equation for the total time dependent current at the junction ( @xmath37 ) reads @xmath95 . by manipulating the bdg equation
as given by ( [ bdg ] ) and ( [ h0 ] ) and omitting oscillating terms which will not contribute to the dc current the quantity of interest one may turn this expression into the following form , @xmath96 .
\label{j}\ ] ] in the static limit , @xmath97 and @xmath98 , this result is clearly equivalent to the standard expression @xmath99 for the andreev level current . in the general nonstationary case
@xmath36 is a linear combination of @xmath47 according to eq .
( [ b ] ) and we can calculate the current averaged over the period @xmath100 .
this is done through eq .
( [ j ] ) with help of eq .
( [ eq.coupled ] ) and the normalization condition @xmath101 , leading to @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the population of the upper level at the end of the period and @xmath104 at the beginning of the period .
the result simplifies further since according to eq .
( [ bcphi ] ) @xmath105 .
the direct current through the contact can be viewed as resulting from photon - assisted pair tunneling or equivalently as being due to the distortion of the ac pair current due to the induced interlevel transitions . to facilitate an understanding of the current expression in another way ,
let us study energy conservation .
we have two sources of energy , the applied field and the applied bias . if we consider a single josephson period @xmath100 , the energy absorbed by the system from the voltage source is @xmath106 , and from the applied field it is @xmath107 ( assuming for simplicity that @xmath105 ) .
energy conservation for the period can be stated as , @xmath108 , with the energy leaving the system stated as @xmath109 or , inserting the value of @xmath100 , @xmath110 this is exactly the same result as obtained by the more tedious method used above .
this discussion allows us to interpret the current as voltage - bias mediated , photon assisted tunneling .
generally the current is given by eq .
( [ idc ] ) with the boundary condition eq .
( [ bcphi ] ) inserted .
the actual calculation of the current has to be done numerically in most cases .
however , in the limit of a weak applied external field and when the frequency of the applied field is such that we have two ( in time ) well separated resonances , we can treat the resonances as temporally localized scattering events .
this approach can be quite rewarding as will become clear below .
formally , we can describe the system s evolution through a resonance by letting a scattering matrix @xmath111 connect the coefficients @xmath51 before and after the splitting points @xmath40 and @xmath41 . approximating the time dependence of the andreev levels to be linear , a standard analysis of the landau - zener interlevel transitions
( see e.g. @xcite ) gives the scattering matrix elements at the points @xmath40 and @xmath41 as , @xmath112 , \hat{s}_b= \left [ \begin{array}{cc}r & d e^{i \theta } \\ -d e^{-i
\theta } & r \end{array } \right ] , \label{sc_mat}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath113 is the probability of the landau - zener interlevel transition . here @xmath114 where @xmath56 is once again the matrix element for the interlevel transitions . by introducing the matrix @xmath115 , @xmath116 which describes the ballistic " dynamics of the system between the landau - zener scattering events , we connect the coefficients @xmath51 at the end of the period of the josephson oscillation , @xmath82 , with the coefficients @xmath117 at the beginning of the period , @xmath118 , @xmath119 the time - averaged current through the junction can be directly expressed through these coefficients . combining the boundary condition ( [ bcphi ] ) with eqs . ( [ idc ] ) and ( [ bb0 ] ) , one finds @xmath120 where @xmath121 is the phase of the probability amplitude for the landau - zener transition , which only weakly depends on @xmath2 . in fig .
[ fig : compare ] the current is calculated both numerically and with the expression above , eq .
( [ i ] ) .
the current is plotted as a function of inverse voltage in order to show a periodicity in @xmath122 .
the close fit in fig .
[ fig : compare ] ensures us that the scattering approach works well for the situation when the resonances are well separated and the applied field is weak .
equation ( [ i ] ) is the basis for presenting the biased sqpc as a quantum interferometer .
there is a clear analogy between the sqpc interferometer and a standard squid in that they both rely on the presence of trajectories that form a closed loop . in a squid , which is used to measure magnetic fields ,
the loop is determined by the device geometry ; in the sqpc the voltage ( analog of the magnetic field ) is well defined while the geometry " of the loop in @xmath19 space can be measured .
this loop is determined by the andreev - level trajectories in @xmath19 space and is controlled by the frequency of the external field .
this gives us an immediate possibility to reconstruct the phase dependence of the andreev levels from the frequency dependence of the period @xmath123 of oscillations of the current versus inverse voltage , see fig .
, it follows from eq .
( [ phi ] ) , that @xmath124 this shows that the position of the andreev energy levels can be reconstructed from measurements of microwave - induced subgap currents through the sqpc .
in order to be able to do interferometry it is necessary to keep phase coherence during at least one period of the josephson oscillation .
there are three dephasing mechanisms that impose limitations in practice : ( i ) deviations from an ideal voltage bias , ( ii ) microscopic interactions , and ( iii ) radiation induced transitions to continuum states .
the main source of fluctuations of the applied voltage is the ac josephson effect . according to the rsj model , a fixed voltage across the junction
can only be maintained if the ratio between the intrinsic resistance @xmath125 of the voltage source and the normal junction resistance @xmath126 is small . if @xmath127 the amplitude of the voltage fluctuations @xmath128 is estimated as @xmath129 .
effects of voltage fluctuations on the accumulated phase @xmath130 can be neglected if @xmath131 , i.e. if @xmath132 , which corresponds to a lower limit for the bias voltage @xcite .
the dephasing time due to microscopic interactions is comparable to the corresponding relaxation time @xcite .
this mechanism of dephasing can be neglected as soon as the relaxation time exceeds the josephson oscillation period , @xmath133 .
taking electron - phonon interaction as the leading mechanism of inelastic relaxation , we estimate @xmath29 to be of the order of the electron - phonon mean free time at the critical temperature , @xmath134 , since the large deviations from equilibrium in our case occur in the energy interval @xmath135 .
this gives @xcite another limitation on how small the applied voltage can be , @xmath136 .
the third mechanism of dephasing becomes important when the andreev levels are closer than @xmath137 to the continuum band edge .
one can estimate the corresponding relaxation time as @xmath138 . for small radiation amplitudes @xmath139 exceeds @xmath140 , while for optimal amplitudes they are about equal .
the effect of the level - continuum transitions on the interference oscillations depends on the frequency . if @xmath141 the loop region " [ @xmath142 is optically disconnected from the continuum , and transitions can not destroy interference .
possible level - continuum transitions at times outside the loop will only decrease the amplitude of the effect by a factor @xmath143 , where @xmath144 is the relative fraction of the period @xmath140 during which transitions to the continuum are possible .
accordingly , this factor is of the order of unity for the voltages that correspond to the maximum amplitude of oscillations .
if @xmath145 , the interference is impeded by the optical transitions into the continuum , and the current oscillations decrease .
still , a nonzero average current through the junction will persist . in any real system
, both relaxation and dephasing will be present as discussed above .
therefore , to complete our analysis we will simulate these effects on our system .
if we assume that the relaxation and dephasing times , @xmath146 are long compared to the duration of the non - adiabatic resonances , @xmath43 , we can use a technique @xcite , where dissipation is modelled by adding a term to the time evolution equation of the density matrix for the two - level andreev system .
the equations are , where relaxation enters in the diagonal terms and dephasing through the off - diagonal terms , @xmath147_{nn}- \frac{\rho_{nn}-\rho_{nn}^{eq}}{\tau } , \label{eq.d1 } \\ & & \dot \rho_{nn'}(t)=-\frac{i}{\hbar}[h_0(t),\rho(t)]_{nn'}- \frac{\rho_{nn'}}{\tau_{\phi } } , \ ; \mbox{n$\neq$n'}. \label{eq.d2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath148 as the characteristic time for relaxation of the system to the equilibrium population , @xmath149 and @xmath150 as the characteristic time for dephasing .
these equations describe the `` ballistic '' dynamics of the dissipative system , replacing eq .
( [ phi ] ) .
the exact form of the density matrix for the system considered here will be a @xmath151 matrix for the discrete two level space of the andreev states .
( to avoid confusion we will use @xmath152 to denote the pauli matrices in this discrete space . ) the hamiltonian for the density matrix is found in eq .
( [ eq.coupled ] ) , and the diagonal elements @xmath153 and @xmath154 will represent the population of the upper and lower andreev levels .
the resonant events which are unaffected by the dissipation can still be modeled with the scattering matrices introduced earlier , eq .
( [ sc_mat ] ) , @xmath155 to calculate the effect of relaxation and dephasing on the current we will use the standard expression , @xmath156 , for the current carried by a populated andreev state and average over one josephson period .
the result is , as a function of the upper levels population , @xmath157dt , \label{eq.dispcurr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the josephson relation @xmath1 and the conservation of probability , @xmath158 . by solving the time evolution equations of the density matrix for the whole josephson period and imposing the boundary condition @xmath159 , we arrive at the following result , @xmath160 where @xmath161.\end{aligned}\ ] ] inserting these expressions into eq .
( [ eq.dispcurr ] ) we find , @xmath162.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first important property of this expression is that for @xmath163 and @xmath164 it reduces to the previous current expression that we derived , eq .
( [ i ] ) . one obvious effect on the current is that the oscillations of the current decrease when the dephasing time , @xmath150 , becomes small .
another is that when the relaxation time , @xmath148 , is decreased , the current diminishes , see fig .
[ diss_plot ] .
we note that the number of parameters has become quite large .
it is now possible to calculate the current for different combinations of @xmath165 and the transmission coefficient @xmath8 .
a curious effect occurs when the relaxation time is such that the upper level , after being populated at point a , is fully depopulated at @xmath166 , the middle of the josephson period .
what we find is a negative dc current for a positive bias , a regime where our system shows a _ negative conductance _ , see fig .
[ diss_plot ] , plots a and d. the relaxation time is such that the upper level is mainly populated when it s derivative is negative ( it carries a negative current ) and then the lower level is highly populated for the part of the period when it s derivative is negative .
this effect will be most pronounced when the energy of the applied field , @xmath137 , approaches the energy of the gap , @xmath167 , as in fig .
[ diss_plot]d .
actually , the physical mechanism which is behind the appearance of this negative resistance is similar to the one responsible for the somersault effect " effect discussed in ref .
@xcite . in that case
the method for periodically bringing a pair of andreev levels in a superconducting quantum point contact in resonance with a microwave field was different .
rather than applying a voltage bias , the time - dependence of the gate potential was assumed to have two components ; one slow component which shifts the andreev levels through its effect on the transparency @xmath168 and one fast ( microwave ) component for coupling the two levels .
we have shown that irradiation of a voltage - biased superconducting quantum point contact at frequencies @xmath169 can remove the suppression of subgap dc transport through andreev levels . quantum interference among resonant scattering events
can be used for microwave spectroscopy of the andreev levels .
the same interference effect can also be applied for detecting weak electromagnetic signals up to the gap frequency . due to the resonant character of the phenomenon ,
the current response is proportional to the ratio between the amplitude of the applied field and the applied voltage , @xmath170 . at the same time , for common sis detectors a non - resonant current response is proportional to the ratio between the amplitude and the frequency of the applied radiation @xcite ) , @xmath171 , i.e. it depends entirely on the parameters of the external signal and can not be improved .
finally , we note that the classic double - slit interference experiment , where two spatially separated trajectories combine to form an interference pattern , clearly demonstrates the wave - like nature of electron propagation . for a 0-dimensional system , with no spatial structure
, we have shown that a completely analogous interference phenomenon may occur between two distinct trajectories in the _ temporal _ evolution of a quantum system .
* acknowledgment . *
support from the swedish kva , ssf , materials consortia 9 & 11 , nfr and from the national science foundation under grant no .
phy94 - 07194 is gratefully acknowledged .
nil and mj are grateful for the hospitality of the institute for theoretical physics , uc santa barbara , where part of this work was done .
the role of photoinduced interference effects in a normal junction was discussed by l. y. gorelik , a. grincwajg , v. kleiner , r. i. shekhter , and m. jonson , phys .
lett . * 73 * , 2260 ( 1994 ) ; l. y. gorelik , f. maa , r. i. shekhter , and m. jonson , phys . rev . lett . *
78 * , 3169 ( 1997 ) .
this result is obvious for a pure sns contact ( @xmath64 ) since the two andreev states involved in the transition at the band edge have momenta @xmath172 and @xmath63 pointing in opposite directions .
see also @xcite . | we show that irradiation of a voltage - biased superconducting quantum point contact at frequencies of the order of the gap energy can remove the suppression of subgap dc transport through andreev levels .
quantum interference among resonant scattering events involving photon absorption is furthermore shown to make microwave spectroscopy of the andreev levels feasible .
we also discuss how the same interference effect can be applied for detecting weak electromagnetic signals up to the gap frequency , and how it is affected by dephasing and relaxation . |
the generation of the mass of hadrons composed of light quarks is a central problem in quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) , the theory of the strong interaction . unlike any other composite system ,
hadrons are built out of constituents with masses which are negligible compared to their total mass which is generated by dynamical effects .
a central role is played by the spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry , a fundamental symmetry of qcd . without this symmetry breaking
, hadrons would appear as mass degenerate parity doublets .
however , in the spectrum of free particles large mass splitting is observed between chiral partners , for baryons and for mesons .
the order parameter of the symmetry breaking , the quark condensate , is expected to be density and temperature dependent so that the symmetry could be at least partially restored for hadrons embedded in nuclear matter . already in 1991
brown and rho @xcite suggested scaling laws for hadron in - medium masses ; and shortly after , lutz , klimt , and weise @xcite discussed in - medium properties of mesons in the framework of the nambu - jona - lasinio ( njl ) model .
a recent overview of theory and experiment is given in @xcite ; results from photon - induced reactions are summarized in @xcite . although originally in - medium effects were mainly discussed in connection with heavy ion collisions , they should be also observable at normal nuclear density @xcite in systems that can be more easily interpreted than the strongly time - dependent density and temperature variations in heavy ion collisions . among such effects
is the mass - shift of the @xmath9-meson in normal dense nuclear matter .
this scalar @xmath10 , isoscalar @xmath11 state is mostly regarded as the chiral partner of the @xmath12 pion @xcite .
however , due to its unconventionally large width ( mass between 400 - 550 mev , width 400 - 700 mev @xcite ) , in some models it is treated as a correlated state of two pions ( respectively four quarks ) rather than a quark - antiquark state @xcite .
the mass split between the @xmath9 and the pion in vacuum is large .
however , predictions from different models @xcite indicated that already at normal nuclear matter density @xmath13 the mass of the @xmath9 should drop by @xmath14 200 mev @xcite , while the pion , which is protected by its goldstone boson nature , should almost be unaffected .
the strong coupling of the @xmath9 to scalar , isoscalar pion pairs should lead to a modification of the invariant - mass distribution of such pairs in nuclear matter .
this effect is predicted by different model studies independent of the assumed nature of the @xmath9 @xcite . in models ,
in which the @xmath9 is not treated as a quark - antiquark state , the corresponding effect comes from an in - medium modification of pion - pion final state interaction for scalar , isoscalar pion pairs .
this effect must not be confused with the final state interaction of individual pions with nuclear matter by re - absorption and re - emission processes .
this prediction has been experimentally tested with pion- and photon - induced reactions .
pion induced reactions were studied by the chaos collaboration @xcite , which observed a mass shift for isoscalar @xmath15 pairs in heavy nuclei but no effect for the like - sign @xmath16 pairs where the @xmath9 can not contribute .
the experiment had only a limited detector acceptance , which complicated the interpretation of the results .
a similar effect was observed for the @xmath17 reaction by the crystal ball collaboration at bnl @xcite which , however , could not measure an isovector channel for comparison .
pion - induced reactions have the disadvantage that due to the large absorption cross section only the nuclear surface is probed . photons can probe the entire volume of nuclei .
although also in this case final - state interaction ( fsi ) effects can not be avoided , they can be studied in a systematic way because they depend strongly on the kinetic energy of the produced pions @xcite .
nuclei are almost transparent for low - energy pions , which means that invariant - mass distributions of pion pairs produced close to the production threshold are much less affected by fsi than at higher energies .
photon induced production of pion pairs off nuclei has been previously measured with the taps detector at mami @xcite .
these experiments found for heavy nuclei a systematic shift of the invariant mass of @xmath18 pairs towards small values while the distributions for mixed - charge pairs @xmath19 were much less effected .
however , as discussed in @xcite the spectra were reproduced by the results from calculations with the boltzmann - uehling - uhlenbeck ( buu ) transport model @xcite .
this model treated the pion - nucleus fsi effects in great detail , but did not include any explicit in - medium modification of @xmath18 pairs .
however , the model results had also non - negligible systematic uncertainties , mainly from the input for the elementary reaction cross sections .
a more systematic study was limited by the statistical quality of the data and the range of nuclear masses investigated . as discussed above ,
fsi effects are minimized close to the production threshold ; but the production cross sections are small . the lightest nucleus included in the previous study was @xmath4c .
invariant - mass distributions for the elementary processes off the ( quasi)-free nucleon ( see @xcite for an overview ) have been studied previously for the @xmath20 @xcite , the @xmath21 @xcite , and @xmath22 @xcite final states .
data for @xmath23 had low statistical quality in the threshold region @xcite and no data were available for @xmath24 .
the present experiment therefore aimed at a precise measurement of pion - pion invariant - mass distributions for the @xmath18 and @xmath19 final states at low incident photon energies over a large range of nuclear masses , including @xmath25h , @xmath3li , @xmath4c , @xmath5ca , and @xmath6pb targets .
such data are needed to separate the fsi effects from non - trivial in - medium modifications of the double pion channels .
the experimental setup is described in @xcite where the data from the @xmath26li target have been analyzed for other meson production reactions .
the measurement was performed at the tagged photon beam of the mainz mami accelerator @xcite . the primary electron beam of 883 mev produced bremsstrahlung in a copper radiator of 10@xmath27 m thickness .
the photons were tagged with the glasgow magnetic spectrometer @xcite .
four solid - state targets ( thicknesses 5.4 cm ( li ) , 1.5 cm ( c ) , 1 cm ( ca ) , 0.05 cm ( pb ) ) and a liquid - deuterium target ( thickness 4.8 cm , 0.6% of radiation length ) were used .
the thickness of the solid - state targets was chosen such that they were comparable in units of the radiation lengths of the materials ( from 3.5% for lithium to 9% for lead ) .
for the measurement with the lead target a lower beam energy was used ( 645 mev ) in order to enhance the statistical quality of the data in the threshold region . in this letter , we therefore summarize only the results for incident photon energies below 600 mev .
the reaction products were detected with an almost @xmath28-covering electromagnetic calorimeter assembled from the crystal ball ( cb ) @xcite and taps @xcite detectors .
the targets were mounted in the center of the crystal ball .
a particle identification detector ( pid ) @xcite was mounted around the targets in cylindrical geometry for identification of charged particles .
for the same purpose the taps detector was equipped with individual plastic detectors in front of each baf@xmath29 module .
the trigger conditions were chosen relatively open in order to minimize systematic uncertainties .
the crystal ball and taps were subdivided into logical sectors , taps into 8@xmath3064 modules arranged in a pizza - like geometry and the crystal ball into 45 rectangles .
events were accepted when at least two sectors of the calorimeter were hit and the total analog sum energy in the crystal ball was above 50 mev .
the charged pion was not used in the trigger .
events where the decay photons of the neutral pions had not satisfied the trigger condition were removed in the off - line analysis because of the systematic uncertainties in the simulation of the trigger efficiency for charged pions .
the analysis of data measured with the above setup is discussed for different final states in @xcite .
the specific analysis steps for @xmath18 and @xmath19 production off nuclear targets are described in detail for the previous measurements with the taps detector @xcite .
the main improvements of the present experiment compared to the previous measurements @xcite are the almost @xmath28 coverage of the solid angle and the use of the pid for the identification of charged pions via the @xmath31 method .
the first step of the analysis was the assignment of hits to photons , charged pions , protons , and neutrons .
the identification of hits in taps ( see @xcite for details ) used the information from the plastic scintillators in front of the taps crystals and a pulse - shape analysis ( psa ) , using the narrow- and wide - gate energy integration of the baf@xmath29 signals for the separation of photons from nucleons . a time - of - flight ( tof ) versus energy analysis showed the characteristic bands for photons , charged pions , and nucleons .
as discussed in @xcite , at forward angles the charged - pion band in taps is contaminated with protons .
therefore , charged pions were not accepted in taps ( this excluded charged pions with polar angles @xmath32 from the analysis ) . in the crystal ball @xcite ,
charged hadrons were identified via their @xmath31 spectra constructed from the energy loss @xmath33 in the pid and the energy deposition in the crystal ball .
this analysis also used the correlation between the azimuthal angles of the hits in the pid and the cb . a typical @xmath31 spectrum shown in fig .
[ fig : banana ] , left hand side , demonstrates the separation of charged pions from protons . in the cb
, neutrons can not be distinguished from photons , as opposed to in taps .
therefore , neutral hits in the cb were accepted as candidates for photons and for neutrons , while neutral hits in taps were separated at this stage into disjunct samples of photons and neutrons through psa and tof - versus - energy .
events were then assigned to the @xmath18 and @xmath19 final states .
accepted were events with four photons ( for the @xmath34 final state ) and events with two photons and one charged pion ( for the @xmath19 final state ) .
detection of recoil nucleons was allowed but not required and after identification , recoil nucleons were ignored in the further analysis .
consequently , three different sub - classes of events were accepted for both reactions .
for the double neutral channel , these were : events with exactly four photon candidates ( 50% ) ; events with four photons and one proton ( 32% ) ; and events with four photons and one neutron candidate ( 18% ) .
similarly , for @xmath19 pairs , events with : exactly two photon candidates and exactly one candidate for a charged pion in the crystal ball ( 59% ) ; events with an additional proton ( 28% ) ; and events with an additional candidate for a neutron ( 22% ) were accepted . in the next step the invariant mass of the pairs of photon candidates
was constructed . for events with a neutron candidate in the crystal ball ( which is indistinguishable from a photon ) ,
all possible pion combinations of neutral hits were tested and the ` best ' combination was selected using a @xmath35-test minimizing @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the nominal pion mass , and @xmath38 , @xmath39 are invariant mass and uncertainty of all possible combinations of ` photon ' pairs .
the unpaired neutral hit , not assigned to be a pion decay photon , was then taken as neutron and thereafter disregarded .
the resulting two - dimensional spectrum of pion - invariant masses for double @xmath8 production is shown in fig .
[ fig : banana ] , right hand side .
events with both invariant masses in the range 110 - 160 mev were selected for further analysis .
the small combinatorial background underneath the peak , was extrapolated in a side - bin analysis and subtracted .
subsequently , the nominal mass of the pion @xmath37 was used to improve the resolution as in @xcite by replacing the measured photon energies @xmath40 by @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the invariant mass corresponding to the measured photon four vectors .
this data sample was tested for residual background with missing mass spectra ( the recoil nucleon was treated as a missing particle even if it was detected ) : @xmath43 where @xmath44 and @xmath45 are the four momenta of the incident photon and nucleon ( the latter assumed at rest ) and @xmath46 , @xmath47 the four momenta of the two pions . the corresponding spectra
are shown in fig .
[ fig : mismas ] , bottom row .
they demonstrate the cleanness of the signal and the excellent agreement between measured data and monte carlo simulations . for the mixed - charge channel , the invariant - mass spectra
were fitted with the simulated line - shape of the pion peak and a polynomial background ( second degree polynomial ) .
some background arises from the quasi - free @xmath48 reaction from protons which contaminate the pion band in the @xmath31 spectra .
the fraction of protons that intrude is small , but the cross section for single @xmath8 production can be larger than for @xmath19 production by more than two orders of magnitude . the most efficient way to remove this background uses the missing mass calculated for the hypothesis of the @xmath48 reaction ( see @xcite for details ) ,
i.e. it is assumed that the ` charged pion ' is a misidentified proton : @xmath49 with the same notation as in eq .
( [ eq : misma_1 ] ) .
typical spectra are shown in fig .
[ fig : mismas ] . for the deuteron target background peak and double pion production
are separated , for the heavier nuclei , due to the larger momenta of the bound nucleons and fsi , the background is only visible as a shoulder on the tail of the signal peak .
only events with @xmath50 140 mev have been accepted .
the center row of fig .
[ fig : mismas ] shows the missing mass @xmath51 ( see eq .
( [ eq : misma_1 ] ) ) calculated under the assumption of quasi - free @xmath19 production . the ( blue ) triangles represent the raw spectra and the ( black ) dots the events that passed the above @xmath52 cut .
the latter agree well with the simulated line - shape ( ( red ) lines ) .
residual background was removed with the condition @xmath53 mev .
charged pions may deposit more than their kinetic energy in the detector .
when they are stopped , they may interact with nuclei or decay and deposit some fraction of their rest mass as energy ( see @xcite for details ) .
the additional energy deposition was taken into account by a correction derived from the comparison of kinetic and deposited energies of charged pions in the monte carlo simulations .
the charged pion reconstruction was tested as in @xcite with an analysis of the position and shape of the invariant mass peak from the @xmath54 decay .
the results for data and monte carlo simulation were in good agreement , and the peak position agreed with the nominal mass of the @xmath55-meson .
since charged pion detection enters twice in this analysis , this test is very sensitive .
total cross sections were extracted from the measured yields , the target surface densities , the photon flux , and the simulated detection efficiencies .
systematic uncertainties from the targets were in the range from 1% to 3% .
the photon flux was determined from the counting of the deflected electrons in the tagger focal plane and the tagging efficiency , i.e. the fraction of correlated photons passing the collimator ( typically @xmath14 50% ) .
the systematic uncertainty was estimated at the 5% level .
systematic uncertainties from the cuts applied for reaction identification and possible residual backgrounds were estimated at @xmath14 3% for @xmath18 and @xmath14 5%
( for @xmath56 500 mev ) to 10% ( for @xmath56 400 mev ) for @xmath19 .
the detection efficiency was simulated with the geant4 program package @xcite .
the simulations were based on the event generator used for the previous experiments @xcite , which incorporates fermi - smearing and fsi processes in a glauber - type approximation .
the efficiency corrections were applied to the data as a function of incident photon energy and invariant mass of the pion pairs . in this way , the influence of the properties of the event generator on the results is minimized . depending on incident photon energy , pion - pion invariant mass , and target , typical values of the detection efficiency were in the range 30% - 70% for @xmath18 pairs and between 5% - 40% for the @xmath19 channel .
total cross sections were extracted by integration of the invariant mass distributions .
we estimate a systematic uncertainty of the detection efficiency of @xmath14 10% for neutral pairs and @xmath14 20% for the mixed charge pairs .
it is larger for the latter because their detection efficiency depends strongly on the kinetic energy of the charged pions ( see @xcite for details ) .
the total systematic uncertainties are indicated in fig .
[ fig : invdiff ] as shaded bands ( error bars in all figures represent statistical uncertainties ) .
one should , however , keep in mind that for the comparisons of reaction channels and the results for different nuclei , systematic uncertainties cancel to a large extent .
invariant - mass distributions of the pion pairs for incident photon energies between 400 mev - 460 mev are summarized in fig . [
fig : invdiff ] .
the distributions measured for pion pairs produced off quasi - free nucleons from the deuteron differ in shape and magnitude from those measured off free protons ( fig .
[ fig : invdiff ] , top row ) . this may be partly attributed to fermi - smearing , but includes also differences in the elementary cross sections for protons and neutrons .
this is important for comparisons of the nuclear data to model results , which have to rely on experimental input for the elementary cross sections . the data for carbon and lead from messchendorp et al .
@xcite are in reasonable agreement with the present results for the neutral pairs ; but not for the mixed - charge channel .
agreement between the @xmath19 data for calcium from bloch et al . @xcite and
the present results is much better ( see fig . [
fig : invdiff2 ] ) .
it had already been noticed that the @xmath19 data from references @xcite are probably in conflict because the mass dependence for the chain carbon - calcium - lead would have been very unnatural ( the magnitude of the calcium cross section normalized by mass number had been larger than both the carbon and lead data , but one would have expected it in between of them ) .
the present measurement favors the previous results from bloch et al .
@xcite with which they agree within systematic uncertainties .
comparison of the invariant - mass distributions in fig .
[ fig : invdiff ] shows , that for the @xmath18 and the @xmath19 pairs , strength shifts to small invariant masses for increasing mass of the nucleus .
this general trend is certainly not related to properties of the @xmath9 meson , which does not couple to the mixed - charge channel .
the effect can be studied in more detail with the help of the composite ratios defined by @xmath57 where @xmath58 are the invariant mass distributions and @xmath59 the total production cross sections for two nuclei with mass numbers @xmath60 and @xmath61 . results for incident - photon energies from 400 mev - 460 mev are summarized in fig . [
fig : ratio ] .
they demonstrate that , at least in this energy range , the behavior of the invariant - mass distributions is almost identical for both isospin states , so that the dominant effect is most likely due to fsi of the pions with the nucleus .
previous results @xcite for the composite ratio of carbon and lead indicated a stronger enhancement at low invariant masses for neutral pion pairs than for the mixed - charge pairs .
however , comparison to the present invariant - mass distributions ( see fig . [
fig : invdiff ] ) suggests that this was due to statistical fluctuations , in particular in the lead data .
using the lighter nuclei ( deuteron and @xmath26li ) as reference , the low - mass enhancement becomes larger , but in the same way for neutral and mixed - charge pairs .
an estimate of how important fsi effects are for the pions can be deduced from the scaling of the cross sections with nuclear mass number @xmath62 .
total cross sections as a function of incident photon energy , scaled by the mass number @xmath62 , are shown for both isospin states in the inserts of fig .
[ fig : alpha ] . the scaling changes from threshold to higher incident photon energies .
this behavior can be parameterized with the scaling coefficient @xmath63 from @xmath64 which is shown in fig .
[ fig : alpha ] .
their interpretation is straightforward . at incident
photon energies close to the production threshold @xmath63 is close to unity , which means that the cross sections scale with the number of nucleons ( or the nuclear volume ) , indicating negligible losses due to pion absorption .
the coefficient then drops as a function of @xmath65 and approaches 2/3 for beam energies between 500 mev and 600 mev , indicating a scaling proportional to the surface of the nuclei , which means strong absorption .
this is expected from the absorption properties of nuclear matter for pions @xcite .
nuclei are transparent for pions with kinetic energies below @xmath14 40 mev and ` black ' for pions with energies above @xmath14 100 mev , which may excite the @xmath66-resonance . in quasi - free kinematics , pions from pion pairs produced with incident photon energies around 500 mev ( 600 mev ) have kinetic energies around 50 mev ( 75 mev ) when the energy is symmetrically shared by the two pions ( up to 138 ( 150 ) mev for pions from extremely asymmetric energy distribution ) .
the scaling behavior is similar for both isospin channels , so that comparable fsi effects are to be expected .
the shapes of pion - pion invariant - mass distributions for different ranges of incident photon energies are compared in fig .
[ fig : compinv ] . for both isospin channels , at the lowest incident photon energies , the distributions are similar for all nuclei .
they basically agree with a fermi - smeared version of the elementary cross section average of proton and neutron cross sections , represented by the deuteron data . at higher incident photon energies
they start to differ , and for fixed photon energy , the heaviest nuclei have the softest distributions .
this general trend can be related to the increase of fsi with rising beam energy and rising mass .
it can be easily understood that fsi tends to soften the distributions .
two effects are important .
inelastic scattering tends to decrease the kinetic energy of the pions and their mean - free path increases with decreasing energy .
any effects due to in - medium modification of the @xmath9-meson can only be studied on top of the fsi effects , which requires detailed model descriptions of fsi . an efficient way to treat these ` trivial ' nuclear effects are transport - theoretical approaches @xcite .
we compare typical invariant - mass distributions to the results of the giessen boltzmann - uehling - uhlenbeck ( gibuu ) model @xcite in figs .
[ fig : invdiff ] and [ fig : invdiff2 ] . on an absolute scale ,
the production cross section for the neutral pairs is underestimated by the model at very low incident photon energies and agrees better at higher energies , while for the mixed - charge pairs agreement is good at low energies and becomes worse for the highest energies .
these discrepancies are at least partly related to the uncertainty in the elementary input to the model ( the production cross sections off neutrons are not well known for most isospin channels ) . in order to facilitate the comparison of the shapes ,
rescaled versions of the model results are shown .
the shapes of the invariant - mass distributions of the mixed - charge pairs agree for all discussed ranges of incident photon energy almost perfectly with the data .
this demonstrates that for @xmath19 the observed evolution of the distributions with photon energy and atomic mass can be indeed explained by fsi .
agreement is not as good for the neutral pairs where , at least for low incident photon energies , the measured distributions tend to be softer than the predicted ones , exhibiting additional strength at low invariant masses .
however , this effect is not large and part of it is probably also related to the model input .
the shape of the distribution measured for the deuteron target is softer than for the proton ( see fig . [
fig : invdiff ] ) and this effect is not included in the model .
precise results have been obtained for the invariant - mass distributions of @xmath18 and @xmath19 pairs produced from deuterium , li , c , ca , and pb targets from production threshold up to incident photon energies of 600 mev .
a pronounced shift of strength towards small invariant masses as a function of the nuclear mass number is observed for _ both _ final states .
this effect increases with increasing beam energy and can be related to re - absorption and re - emission processes of the pions in the nuclei .
an analysis of the scaling behavior of the total cross sections demonstrates that fsi are negligible close to production threshold and saturate at energies above 500 mev .
the general trend of the shape change of the invariant - mass distributions correlates with the energy dependence of the fsi effects .
consequently , the dominant effect on the invariant - mass distributions comes from fsi . as a consequence of these results , possible in - medium modifications of the @xmath9 meson (
respectively pion - pion interaction in the scalar , isoscalar state ) can not be easily tested with an analysis of the shape change of the pion - pion invariant - mass distributions as a function of mass number and/or beam energy as attempted in many recent works .
predictions of the invariant - mass distributions in the framework of the gibuu transport model reproduce their shapes for the mixed - charge pairs excellently , demonstrating that the nuclear effects for this channel are understood .
small shape discrepancies for the neutral pairs require further investigation , in particular more precise input for the elementary reactions into models . in view of these uncertainties , no clear evidence for a contribution of @xmath9 in - medium
modification can be deduced , although the observed shapes of the low - energy invariant - mass distributions of @xmath18 pairs suggest that a small effect might exists .
we wish to acknowledge the outstanding support of the accelerator group and operators of mami .
we thank o. buss and u. mosel for interesting discussions and the provision of the gibuu model predictions .
this work was supported by schweizerischer nationalfonds , deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( sfb 443 ) , uk science and technology facilities council , stfc , european community - research infrastructure activity ( fp6 ) , the us doe , us nsf , and nserc ( canada ) .
brown and manque rho , phys .
66 ( 1991 ) 2720 .
m. lutz , s. klimt , and w. weise , nucl .
phys . a 542 ( 1992 ) 521 .
s. leupold , v. metag , u. mosel , int . j. of mod .
e 19 ( 2010 ) 147 .
b. krusche et al . , eur .
j. special topics 198 ( 2011 ) 199 v. bernard , u .- g .
meissner , i. zahed , phys .
59 ( 1987 ) 966 . t. hatsuda , t. kunihiro , h. shimizu , phys . rev .
82 ( 1999 ) 2840 .
z. aouissat et al . , phys .
c 61 ( 1999 ) 012202 .
j. beringer et al .
d 86 ( 2012 ) 010001 . h.c .
chiang , e. oset , m.j .
vicente vacas , nucl .
a 644 ( 1998 ) 77 .
l. roca , e. oset , m.j .
vicente vacas , phys .
b 541 ( 2002 ) 77 .
g. chanfray et al . , eur .
j. a 27 ( 2006 ) 191 .
m. abaladejo and j.a .
oller phys .
d 86 ( 2012 ) 034003 .
r. rapp et al .
c 59 ( 1999 ) r1237 .
f. bonutti et al . , phys .
77 ( 1996 ) 603
. f. bonutti et al . , phys .
c 60 ( 1999 ) 018201 .
f. bonutti et al . , nucl .
phys . a 677 ( 2000 ) 213 .
p. camerini et al . , nucl .
phys . a 735 ( 2004 ) 89 .
n. grion et al .
phys . a 763 ( 2005 ) 80 .
a. starostin et al , phys
. rev . lett .
85 ( 2000 ) 5539 .
b. krusche et al .
j. a 22 ( 2004 ) 277 .
messchendorp et al , phys .
( 2002 ) 222302 .
f. bloch et al , eur .
j. a 32 ( 2007 ) 219 .
o. buss et al . , eur .
j. a 29 ( 2006 ) 189 .
b. krusche and s. schadmand , prog .
51 ( 2003 ) 399 . f. hrter et al .
b 401 ( 1997 ) 229 .
m. wolf et al .
j. a 9 ( 2000 ) 5 .
sarantsev et al . , phys .
b 659 ( 2008 ) 94 .
w. langgrtner et al .
87 ( 2001 ) 052001 .
a. zabrodin et al . , phys .
c 60 ( 1999 ) 055201 . v. kleber et al . , eur .
j. a 9 ( 2000 ) 1 .
y. maghrbi et al . , eur .
j. a 49 ( 2013 ) 38 .
h. herminghaus et al . , ieee trans . on nucl .
science . 30
( 1983 ) 3274 . th .
walcher , prog .
( 1990 ) 189 .
mcgeorge et al . , eur .
j. a 37 ( 2008 ) 129 .
a. starostin et al . , phys .
c 64 ( 2001 ) 055205 .
gabler et al . , nucl .
. meth . a 346 ( 1994 )
d. watts , in _ calorimetry in particle physics , proceedings of the 11th internatinal conference , perugia , italy 2004 _ , edited by c. cecchi , p. cenci , p. lubrano , and m. pepe ( world scientific , singapore , 2005 , p. 560 ) .
s. schumann et al . , eur .
j. a 43 ( 2010 ) 269 .
f. zehr et al . , eur .
j. a 48 ( 2012 ) 98 .
s. agostinelli et al . ,
instr . meth . a 506 ( 2003 ) 250 .
o. buss et al . , phys .
( 2012 ) 1 . | photoproduction of @xmath0 and @xmath1 pairs from nuclei has been measured over a wide mass range ( @xmath2h , @xmath3li , @xmath4c , @xmath5ca , and @xmath6pb ) for photon energies from threshold to 600 mev .
the experiments were performed at the mami accelerator in mainz , using the glasgow photon tagging spectrometer and a 4@xmath7 electromagnetic calorimeter consisting of the crystal ball and taps detectors . a shift of the pion - pion invariant mass spectra for heavy nuclei to small invariant masses has been observed for @xmath8 pairs but also for the mixed - charge pairs .
the precise results allow for the first time a model - independent analysis of the influence of pion final - state interactions .
the corresponding effects are found to be large and must be carefully considered in the search for possible in - medium modifications of the @xmath9-meson .
results from a transport model calculation reproduce the shape of the invariant - mass distributions for the mixed - charge pairs better than for the neutral pairs , but also for the latter differences between model results and experiment are not large , leaving not much room for @xmath9-in - medium modification . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
after the formidable achievement of bose - einstein condensation in spin - polarized alkali gases @xcite , the next challenge that experimentalists have already set themselves is to realize quantum degenerate conditions also in fermionic alkali vapors .
one particular motivation in this respect is the prediction that a gas of spin - polarized atomic @xmath0li becomes superfluid at densities and temperatures comparable with those at which the bose - einstein experiments are performed @xcite . as a result of this experimental interest ,
the first theoretical studies of an ideal fermi gas trapped in a harmonic external potential have recently appeared @xcite .
moreover , the effects of an interatomic interaction have also been considered @xcite .
it is interesting to note that oliva s calculations for atomic deuterium were already performed a decade ago , even though magnetically trapped deuterium had not been observed at that time .
in fact , it has still not been observed , because the loading of the trap can not be accomplished in the same way as for atomic hydrogen @xcite .
this is presumably caused by the fact that deuterium binds more strongly to a superfluid helium film , that the surface recombination rate is much larger , and that the sample is contaminated with atomic hydrogen @xcite .
fortunately , such problems do not arise for experiments with alkali gases and both @xmath0li and @xmath1k have indeed been trapped already @xcite .
the most important qualitative feature of a trapped fermi gas is that its density profile ` freezes ' at low temperatures .
this is a result of the pauli exclusion principle and can be easily understood by considering an ideal gas in the trapping potential @xmath2 . in general the extent of the gas cloud
is determined by the classical turning point of the most energetic particles .
if the gas is fully classical , i.e. , it obeys maxwell - boltzmann statistics , these particles have an energy of a few @xmath3 and the size of the cloud @xmath4 follows from @xmath5 , implying that @xmath6 .
we see that , as we lower the temperature , the size of the cloud shrinks .
moreover , if we keep the number of particles @xmath7 fixed , the density increases .
this process gradually continues until we reach zero temperature and the density profile becomes equal to @xmath8 . if the gas obeys fermi - dirac statistics , however , the most energetic particles have in the degenerate ( nonclassical ) regime an energy that is equal to the fermi energy @xmath9 and the size of the gas cloud is always given by @xmath10 for temperatures @xmath11 . comparing this also with the density profile for an ideal bose gas , which in the degenerate regime consists of a large and narrow condensate peak with a width of about @xmath12 on top of a broad thermal background of size @xmath13 ,
we conclude that the density profile of a degenerate fermi gas is indeed ` frozen ' .
in contrast to the ideal bose gas , the ideal fermi gas also does not have a phase transition . from a point of view of condensed matter physics
, an atomic fermi gas thus appears much less interesting than a bose gas .
the main objective of this contribution is to argue that this is no longer true if there are interactions between the atoms .
for atomic alkali gases the most important interatomic interaction is the so - called central interaction @xmath14 , which consists of a sum of the usual singlet and triplet interactions .
more precisely , we have that @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 denote the projection operators on the subspace of singlet and triplet states , respectively . besides this interaction that is the net result of the coulomb attractions and repulsions between the electrons and nuclei of the atoms , we also have to consider the weak magnetic dipole - dipole interactions . of these ,
the electron - electron magnetic dipole interaction is most important and obeys @xcite @xmath18 here @xmath19 is the electron magnetic moment and the tensor operator @xmath20 is obtained from coupling the pauli spin matrices @xmath21@xmath22 and @xmath21@xmath23 of the two valence electrons to a tensor of rank 2 . it should be noted that both these interactions do not commute with the electron spin operators @xmath24@xmath21@xmath25 and therefore also do not commute with the atomic hamiltonian , which in a magnetic field contains both a hyperfine and a zeeman term . as a consequence
the central and dipole - dipole interactions are not fully diagonal in the basis in which the atoms are in definite hyperfine states .
this is important in principle , because it implies that two atoms can also collide inelastically , i.e. , their hyperfine states can change during the collision . together with three - body recombination events , these inelastic collisions in fact
always seriously limit the lifetime of a trapped alkali gas .
nevertheless , we will in the following mostly neglect the nondiagonal parts of the interatomic interaction by restricting ourselves to ( doubly ) spin - polarized gases for which the ` good ' elastic collisions dominate the ` bad ' inelastic ones .
clearly such a restriction is a minimum requirement for our discussion to be also of some experimental interest .
as we will see in detail below , the most common phase transition in a weakly - interacting fermi gas is due to the formation of so - called cooper pairs .
the main idea behind the famous bardeen - cooper - schrieffer theory for this phenomenon is in fact a bose - einstein condensation of these pairs @xcite . to see how we can arrive at a mean - field theory for this phase transition ,
let us first recapitulate the mean - field ( hartree ) theory for bose - einstein condensation in an atomic bose gas .
at zero temperature we can then use a variational many - body wave function in which all the atoms are in the same one - particle state @xmath26 , so @xmath27 in the language of second quantization this essentially reads @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the creation operator for an atom at postion @xmath30 and @xmath31 is the ` vacuum ' state in which there are no atoms present in the trap . calculating the average of the hamiltonian @xmath32 in this variational wave function and minimizing with respect to @xmath26 leads of course to the gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite if @xmath33 .
the above variational wave function has a definite number of particles . for practical calculations ,
in particular if we want to consider also nonzero temperatures or corrections to the mean - field theory , it is much more convenient to consider a variational wave function in which not the number of particles @xmath7 , but instead the phase @xmath34 is fixed .
this state is given by @xmath35 as can be seen from the fact that now the matrix element @xmath36 has a definite phase in contrast to the matrix element @xmath37 .
it is not difficult to show that by minimizing the average energy in the state @xmath38 we again recover the gross - pitaevskii equation .
more important for our purposes is that we can easily show by fourier analysis that @xmath39 which shows that the number of particles @xmath7 and the phase @xmath34 are conjugate variables and obey the commutation relation @xmath40 = i$ ] .
the heisenberg equation of motion for the average phase thus becomes @xmath41 \right\rangle = -i \left\langle \frac{\partial
h}{\partial n } \right\rangle \equiv -i \mu~,\ ] ] with @xmath42 the chemical potential of the gas .
we therefore recover the important josephson relation @xmath43 which is also well known from the hydrodynamic formulation of the gross - pitaevskii equation @xcite . indeed , taking the gradient of this equation and using the definition of the superfluid velocity ,
i.e. , @xmath44 , we obtain the desired result that @xmath45 let us now return to cooper - pair formation in degenerate fermi gases .
in analogy with bose - einstein condensation we can now use at zero temperature the variational wave function @xmath46 a few remarks are in order .
first , we have denoted the various hyperfine states of the atoms by @xmath47 . in our previous discussion of bose - einstein condensation we should in principle
also have indicated the hyperfine state of the atoms and used @xmath48 instead of @xmath29 in the variational wave function .
however , as long as all the atoms are in the same hyperfine state , the precise atomic state which is trapped is unimportant from a theoretical point of view and only influences the interatomic interaction , i.e. , the particular value of the scattering length , that should be used in the gross - pitaevskii equation . for clarity we therefore suppressed the spin degrees of freedom in that case .
second , the fermionic creation operators anticommute . as a result
the cooper - pair wave function must obey @xmath49 , reflecting the pauli exclusion principle .
there are essentially two ways to fulfill this antisymmetrization requirement .
if all the atoms are in the same hyperfine state we have @xmath50 and the orbital part of the cooper - pair wave function is antisymmetric with respect to an exchange of the atoms
. the relative angular momentum of the pairs must therefore be odd .
in particular , we can have @xmath51-wave pairing .
this situation occurs in doubly spin - polarized fermi gases and also in liquid @xmath52he @xcite .
if we have an equal number of atoms in two hyperfine states , which is implicitly assumed in the above variational wave function , the spin part of the cooper - pair wave function can already be antisymmetric and the relative angular momentum of the pairs must then be even .
we now can have @xmath53-wave pairing as in ordinary superconductors . in principle , we can of course also have @xmath54-wave pairing as in the high - temperature superconductors , but this turns out to be extremely unlikely for dilute gases .
third , in actual applications it is again more convenient to use a variational wave function with a well defined phase . in this case
it is obtained by multiplying the cooper - pair wave function in the right - hand side of eq .
( [ fixedn ] ) with @xmath55 and summing over all even values of @xmath7 .
we then find @xmath56 and exactly the same relation between the states @xmath57 and @xmath38 as for a condensate of single atoms .
the josephson relation given in eq .
( [ jr ] ) is therefore also valid in this case .
moreover , in the state @xmath38 we have a nonvanishing expectation value @xmath58 which suggest that @xmath59 is the appropriate order parameter for the bardeen - cooper - schrieffer transition , just like @xmath60 is the order parameter for bose - einstein condensation .
although this identification of the order parameter is correct , it turns out that it is more convenient in practice to work with the so - called bcs gap parameter @xmath61 where @xmath62 is a shorthand notation for the elastic part of the interatomic interaction , and @xmath63 and @xmath64 are the relative and center - of - mass coordinates of the cooper pair , respectively . knowing the order parameter of the phase transition of interest
, it is straightforward to obtain the corresponding mean - field theory .
the main idea is first to write in the interaction part of the hamiltonian @xmath65 the operators @xmath66 and @xmath67 as a sum of a mean value and fluctuations , and then to neglect terms that are quadratic in the fluctuations . in this manner
we arrive at the mean - field hamiltonian @xmath68 where the renormalized chemical potentials are in a good approximation ( but see below ) given by @xmath69 and the density profile of atoms in spin state @xmath47 obeys @xmath70 .
it is important to note that in trapped alkali gases it is indeed appropriate to have a chemical potential for each spin state , because the time scale for relaxation towards equilibrium in spin space is always much larger than the equilibration time for the spatial degrees of freedom .
this is for example quite dramatically demonstrated by the two overlapping condensate experiments by myatt @xcite . to complete the mean - field theory
we should now calculate the mean values of the operators @xmath66 and @xmath67 in a thermal ensemble with the hamiltonian @xmath71 .
this clearly makes the theory selfconsistent . to perform the calculation we write the annihilation operators at the positions @xmath30 and @xmath72 as @xmath73 respectively . substituting this in the mean - field hamiltonian and neglecting gradients in the center - of - mass coordinate @xmath74
, we find that @xmath75 diagonalizing the above hamiltonian by means of a bogoliubov transformation , the spin - density profiles can then be calculated from @xmath76 and , most importantly , the bcs gap parameter from @xmath77 notice that the averages in the right - hand side of eqs .
( [ spin ] ) and ( [ gap ] ) depend on the position @xmath74 , since the mean - field hamiltonian @xmath71 depends parametrically on this position .
to arrive at such a simplyfied ( thomas - fermi ) description of the inhomogeneity of the gas we have to be able to neglect gradients of the densities @xmath78 and the bcs gap parameter @xmath79 .
this is indeed true for present experiments with fermionic alkali gases , because the number of trapped atoms is so large that both the correlation length and the size of the cooper pairs are small compared the typical length scale on which the trapping potential varies @xcite .
we refer for the details of the diagonalization to our previous work @xcite . for our present purposes
it is however important to mention that in the optimal case of equal spin densities , the final result of eq .
( [ gap ] ) is the famous bcs gap equation @xcite @xmath80 where the so - called bogliubov dispersion @xmath81 obeys @xmath82 in principle , one can solve the bcs equation for any interatomic potential @xmath83 .
however , for alkali gases the complete central interaction is usually not very well known and we have only information on the two - body scattering length @xmath84 .
we therefore would like to reformulate the gap equation in such a way that only this scattering length enters .
this is achieved by noting that the gap equation is very similar to the lippmann - schwinger equation for the two - body t(ransition ) matrix .
indeed the latter reads @xcite @xmath85 using the lippman - schwinger equation with @xmath86 , we can after some algebraic manipulation show that the gap equation is equivalent to @xmath87 this result serves our purposes since the two - body t matrix is directly related to the two - body scattering length as we will see next .
in doubly spin - polarized fermi gases all the atoms are in the same hyperfine state . although it is straightforward to generalize the following to an arbitrary state @xmath47 ,
we will in first instance restrict ourselves to the fully stretched state @xmath88 in which both the electron as well as the nuclear spin have a maximal projection on the magnetic field axis .
the relevant interaction matrix element is then equal to @xmath89 with @xmath90 the angle between the interatomic separation @xmath91 and the magnetic field @xmath92 . for this potential
we have to calculate the two - body t matrix . treating the weak electron - electron magnetic dipole interaction in born approximation @xcite and making use of the fact that for the central interaction only @xmath51-waves contribute at low momenta , we find @xmath93 here @xmath84 is the triplet @xmath51-wave scattering length and @xmath94 denotes the angle between the momentum transfer @xmath95 and the magnetic field axis .
we now have two cases to consider .
generically we expect the @xmath51-wave scattering length to be of the order of the range of the triplet potential and therefore @xmath96 to be much smaller than one . in that case
the contribution of the triplet potential to the two - body t matrix is negligible and the effective interaction between the atoms is dominated by the long - range dipole - dipole interaction . due to the complicated angular dependence of this interaction
it is not possible to solve the bcs gap equation analytically .
however , we can nevertheless make progress by noting that the magnetic dipole - dipole interaction is most attractive when @xmath91 is directed along the magnetic field .
we thus expect that if cooper pairs are formed their wavefunction @xmath97 is most likely proportional to @xmath98 , which implies that @xmath99 .
since this gap is anisotropic in the relative wave vector @xmath100 , the gas is below the critical temperature an anisotropic superfluid , just like @xmath52he in the so - called a phases @xcite . to obtain an estimate for the critical temperature we explicitly consider only the @xmath51-wave part of the dipole - dipole interaction , which results in the approximation @xmath101 this explicitly confirms that the dipole - dipole interaction is only attractive in the channel @xmath102 . substituting the above two - body t matrix into the bcs gap equation and linearizing with respect to @xmath103 to obtain an equation for the critical temperature , we find @xmath104 here we used the notations @xmath105 for the cauchy principle value part of the integral and @xmath106 for the fermi distribution function @xmath107 evaluated at @xmath108 .
note that we have also used that the bcs gap equation will have a nontrivial solution in the center of the trap first , since the density of the gas is highest there . introducing a ` scattering length ' @xmath109 for the electron - electron magnetic dipole interaction by means of @xmath110 ,
i.e. , @xmath111 a@xmath112 with @xmath113 the mass of a hydrogen atom and a@xmath112 its bohr radius , the equation for the critical temperature becomes identical to the linearized bcs gap equation that has been studied previously in the context of @xmath53-wave superconductors by s de melo @xcite . using their result
, we have for the critical temperature @xmath114 with @xmath115 euler s constant .
unfortunately , the bcs transition to an anisotropic superfluid thus occurs at extremely low temperatures in this case and appears to be out of reach experimentally .
for example for @xmath0li at a density of @xmath116 @xmath117 , we have @xmath118 nk and @xmath119 . the second case to consider appears to be more promising .
as mentioned before , the triplet @xmath51-wave scattering length is in general too small to be able to dominate over the dipole - diple interaction .
for @xmath0li it is only @xmath120 a@xmath112 , for instance .
however , we can imagine that it is possible , in the same way as in the recent experiment by inouye @xcite , to ( optically ) trap a hyperfine state that has a @xmath51-wave feshbach resonance @xcite and tune the external bias magnetic field such that the @xmath51-wave scattering length becomes large and negative .
the two - body t matrix is then well approximated by @xmath121 substituting this into the bcs gap equation , it is not difficult to show that it is solved by the _ ansatz _
@xmath122 where @xmath123 are the spherical components of a vector @xmath124 that is normalized as @xmath125 . furthermore ,
linearizing the bcs gap equation with respect to @xmath103 , we find that the critical temperature is now determined by @xmath126 the solution can be obtained by the same methods as before and reads @xmath127 it is important to realize that up to this point the direction of the vector @xmath124 is arbitrary .
this reflects the rotational symmetry of the problem .
however , as we have seen , the magnetic dipole - dipole interaction breaks this symmetry and will cause * d * to lie either parallel or perpendicular to the magnetic field , depending on precisely which hyperfine state @xmath47 is trapped . because we are dealing with an attractive interaction we also have to make sure that the gas is mechanically stable .
this leads to the restriction that @xmath128 , or equivalently @xmath129 .
unfortunately , the latter again severely limits the feasibility of experimentally observing the in principle interesting possibility of a transition to an anisotropic superfluid .
we now turn our attention to the case of fermionic gases that are a mixture of two hyperfine states . in such a gas
we can have @xmath53-wave collisions between atoms in different hyperfine states , which has as an advantage that interacting effects are expected to be much more important .
moreover , it has an additional advantage that it is now in principle possible to use evaporative cooling to cool the gas to low temperatures .
a fermionic gas consisting of three hyperfine states has recently been considered as well @xcite , but since it does not lead to any qualitative different physics we restrict ourselves here to mixtures of only two spin states .
we denote the two hypefine states involved from now on by @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
experimentally , there are two ways to realize such a system
. we can either magnetically trap two low - field seeking states , or use an optical trap . in the latter case
it is presumably necessary to load the trap by precooling the gas in a magnetic trap using sympathetic cooling . if the @xmath53-wave scattering length @xmath84 between two atoms in different spin states is positive , a first many - body effect that we have to consider is the phase separation of the gas into two phases with opposite ` magnetization ' . roughly speaking
, this implies that instead of having overlapping spin densities @xmath132 and @xmath133 , the gas prefers to separate into two phases in which ( almost ) all the atoms are either in the state @xmath130 or in the state @xmath131 .
the driving force behind this instability is that although the phase separation increases the kinetic energy of the gas , this increase is more than compensated by the decrease in interaction energy .
more precisely , the gas is stable if the free - energy surface @xmath134 $ ] has a positive curvature in all directions . using that @xmath135 the free energy in the degenerate regime is given by @xmath136 = \int d{\bf r}~ \left\ { ( 6\pi^2)^{2/3 } \frac{3\hbar^2}{10 m } \left ( n_{\uparrow}^{5/3}({\bf r } ) + n_{\downarrow}^{5/3}({\bf r } )
\right ) + \frac{4\pi a \hbar^2}{m } n_{\uparrow}({\bf r } ) n_{\downarrow}({\bf r } ) \right\}\ ] ] and stability of the gas requires that the spin densities obey @xmath137 . in the particular case of equal spin densities
this reduces to the condition that @xmath138 .
note that above we have used the t - matrix approximation to evaluate the average interaction energy .
because the chemical potential @xmath139 is equal to the derivative @xmath140 , we must for consistency use the same approximation to determine the renormalized chemical potentials @xmath141 .
therefore , we use in the following always that @xmath142 instead of the less accurate ( only born approximation ) relation given in eq .
( [ chem ] ) .
even though the interaction between the atoms is effectively repulsive , there can nevertheless occur a bcs pairing transition to a superfluid state due to the so - called luttinger - kohn instability @xcite .
physically , the instability is a result of the fact that two atoms in the same hyperfine state can exchange a fluctuation ( phonon ) in the density of the other hyperfine state , leading to an effectively attractive interaction between the atoms involved .
the @xmath51-wave transition associated with the luttinger - kohn effect has been studied by baranov @xcite .
these authors obtain for the critical temperature the estimate @xmath143 where notably @xmath84 is the @xmath53-wave scattering length .
it should , however , be kept in mind that to be able to observe the transition we must require that the gas is mechanically stable and does not phase separate . as we have already seen , this implies for equal spin densities that @xmath138 .
moreover , for generic values of the scattering length we will even have that @xmath144 at the low densities of interest .
it therefore seem once again practically impossible to observe the above transition in a real atomic gas .
our last chance of achieving a superfluid phase in a fermionic gas thus appears to be a spin - polarized gas with a large and negative @xmath53-wave scattering length . besides the possibility of using a feshbach resonance to tailor the scattering length ,
we can also directly make use of the anomalously large @xmath0li triplet scattering length of @xmath145 a@xmath112 by trapping a spin - polarized @xmath0li gas in a bias magnetic field of at least @xmath146 t @xcite .
substituting eq .
( [ t2b ] ) into the bcs gap equation we see that the solution @xmath79 is now independent of the wave vector @xmath100 and therefore equal to @xmath147 .
furthermore , a linearization in @xmath147 gives @xmath148 which results in the critical temperature @xmath149 since the mechanical stability of the gas requires also for a negative scattering length only that @xmath150 , this expression shows that the prospects of observing a bcs transition in this case are indeed most favorable . in view of this encouraging situation
we have studied in more detail the behavior of the spin density profile @xmath78 and the bcs gap parameter @xmath147 for a spin - polarized @xmath0li gas in the same magnetic trap that has been used for the bose - einstein condensation experiments with @xmath151li @xcite .
the results for equal spin densities are shown in fig .
[ profiles ] and lead to three important conclusions .
first , we see explicitly that the density profile of a degenerate fermi gas is indeed completely ` frozen ' .
clearly , even the bcs transition to a superfluid has essentially no effect on the density profile . from an experimental point of view
this is somewhat unfortunate , because it implies that the appearance of a condensate of cooper pairs can not be observed by the same methods that have been so successful in the bose - einstein condensation experiments .
we come back to this problem shortly .
second , for a total density of @xmath152 @xmath117 the critical temperature is about @xmath153 nk . in view of the achievements with bosonic alkali gases
, this appears to be a density - temperature combination which is certainly within reach experimentally .
finally , we have also compared the density profile of @xmath0li with that of a noninteracting fermi gas with the same number of particles .
the strong attractive interaction between the @xmath0li atoms evidently results in a substantial increase of the density in the center of the trap .
experimentally , this is a favorable effect because for a fixed number of atoms in the trap it enhances the critical temperature as is shown quantitatively in fig .
[ tc ] . for future convenience
we mention that in a good approximation the critical temperature obeys @xmath154 with @xmath155 the thermal de broglie wavelength and @xmath156 the size of the harmonic oscillator ground state .
it must be kept in mind that the latter formula can only be used for values of @xmath157 that are less then about @xmath158 , since for larger values the gas is mechanically unstable and undergoes a spinodal decomposition first .
we have argued that for condensed matter physics in trapped atomic fermi gases , a spin - polarized gas with a large and negative @xmath53-wave scattering length between the atoms in the two different hyperfine states appears to be most promising . in view of the large uncertainties in the interatomic interaction potential of @xmath1k , the most likely candidate for the achievement of a gaseous bcs superfluid
is at present @xmath0li .
however , before successful experiments with atomic @xmath0li can be performed , some experimental problems need to be resolved .
one problem is that in spin - polarized atomic @xmath0li not only the @xmath53-wave scattering length but also the exchange and dipolar decay rates are anomalously large . as a result
the gas has usually a very short lifetime . to enhance the lifetime to about @xmath159 s at the densities of interest
, we can either apply a bias magnetic field of about @xmath160 t or use optical methods to trap two high - field seeking states .
the latter solution seems to be most practical and is actively being persued at the moment . assuming that we are able to achieve the necessary conditions for the bcs transition , the next problem that arises is the detection of the cooper pair condensate .
as we have seen , the density profile shows essentially no sign of the phase transition .
time - of - flight measurements , that were the ` smoking gun ' for the bose - einstein condensation experiments , are therefore not appropriate here . another possible signature that comes to mind are the frequencies of the collective modes . because of the large @xmath53-wave scattering length required for relatively high critical temperatures , the collective modes are always in the hydrodynamical regime .
they are therefore described by the ( local ) conservation laws and the josephson relation . in the case of equal spin densities
we thus obtain the following set of equations . the continuity equation for a superfluid
is @xmath161 with the total density @xmath162 and the total current density @xmath163 consisting of a normal and superfluid contribution .
in addition , newton s law gives @xmath164 where @xmath51 denotes the pressure in the gas .
finally , we have also the josephson relation , which leads to ( cf .
( [ vs ] ) ) @xmath165 in principle , we must also take into account the conservation of energy .
however , for a degenerate fermi gas the specific heats at constant pressure and volume are almost equal and the continuity equation for the total energy density essentially decouples from the previous ones .
this has important consequences , because for density fluctuations the josephson relation just copies newton s law and we must conclude that the first sound modes are not affected by the bcs transition . of course , a measurement of second sound modes would be a clear signature of the transition , but this is presumably quite hard experimentally because second sound is primarily a temperature wave due to the fact that the energy fluctuations are almost decoupled . in analogy with sound attenuation in superconductors ,
it has been suggested by fetter @xcite that the damping of the first sound modes might be strongly influenced by the appearance of a cooper pair condensate , but more work is needed to make sure whether this interesting suggestion would work .
a property of the gas that is certainly influenced by the bcs transition is the decay of the gas .
qualitatively this can be easily understood from the correlator method devised by kagan @xcite . in this approach
we can relate the decay rate constant @xmath166 for two - body decay to the rate constant in the normal phase @xmath167 by @xmath168 hence , the cooper pair condensate enhances the decay of the gas . a quantitative estimate of the effect is somewhat complicated by the fact that we can not use a pseudopotential to calculate the cooper pair wavefunction @xmath169 from our knowledge of the gap parameter @xmath147 . in any case ,
the increase in the two - body decay rate of the gas can only be used as a detection method if the gas is trapped in a magnetic trap , since in an optical trap the two - body decay will essentially be eliminated and the lifetime of the gas is determined by the rate at which photons scatter off the atoms in the gas . because this is a one - atom problem , it is also not affected by the bcs transition .
a final detection method that we would like to mention is the scattering of a beam of @xmath0li atoms from the gas cloud .
since such an experiment is quite similar to a tunneling experiment , it is directly sensitive to the existence of the gap parameter @xmath147 . therefore , a measurement of the angular distribution of the scattered atoms appears to be a promising way to get detailed information about the condensate of cooper pairs .
of course , to be most sensitive we need a very cold beam .
however , this is clearly not an impossible requirement , because the first results of such experiments with a condensate of @xmath170rb atoms have recently been reported @xcite . from a theoretical point of view
, we are at present performing a study of the above scattering process to see how large the effects of the bcs transition are .
it is interesting to note that it is also possible to detect vortices in this manner , because the atomic beam ( in contrast to a laser beam ) does not only see the core of the vortex but its complete velocity profile .
this is in fact also true for a bose condensate .
an experiment of this sort may therefore also be of interest in the context of ongoing research on the properties of trapped atomic bose gases .
most of the work presented here has been performed in close collaboration with ian mcalexander , cass sackett , and randy hulet .
we are very grateful for their continued encouragement and crucial contributions .
we also thank yvan castin , eric cornell , jean dalibard , allan griffin , massimo inguscio , tony leggett , andrei ruckenstein , guglielmo tino and peter zoller for helpful discussions .
we acknowledge support from the stichting fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom ) , which is financially supported by the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) .
( to be published , cond - mat/9807027 ) . .
private communication . . . . . and . .
( to be published , cond - mat/9712262 ) . .
private communication . .
private communication . | we present an overview of the various phase transitions that we anticipate to occur in trapped fermionic alkali gases .
we also discuss the prospects of observing these transitions in ( doubly ) spin - polarized @xmath0li and @xmath1k gases , which are now actively being studied by various experimental groups around the world . |
the inner region of disk accretion onto neutron stars may be characterized by two unique radii : ( i ) the marginally stable orbit due to general gravity ( gr ) . for nonrotating neutron stars this
is located at r_gr=6gmc^2=12.4m_1.4 km , where @xmath11 is the neutron star mass , and @xmath12 . for finite rotation rates ,
@xmath13 is somewhat smaller .
the flow behavior near @xmath13 has been subjected to numerous studies , especially in the context of black hole accretion disks ( e.g. , muchotrzeb & paczyski 1982 ; matsumoto et al .
1984 ; abramowicz et al . 1988
; narayan et al . 1997 ; chen et al .
1997 ) : close to @xmath13 the inward radial velocity of the accreting gas increases steeply with decreasing radius and becomes supersonic .
the existence of such marginally stable orbit for neutron star is predicated on the fact that neutron star models constructed using different nuclear equations of state generally give a stellar radius less than @xmath13 ( arnett & bowers 1977 ; kluniak & wagoner 1985 ) .
( ii ) the magnetospheric radius , @xmath14 , below which magnetic stress dominates disk plasma stress . while the precise value of @xmath14 depends on the ( rather uncertain ) details of the magnetic field disk interactions , it is estimated to close to or slightly less than ( by a factor of a few ) the spherical alfven radius , i.e. , r_mr_ar(b_0 ^ 2r^3m)^2/7 = 18 r_10 ^ 12/7m_1.4 ^ -1/7b_8 ^ 4/7m_17
^ -2/7 ( km ) , [ alfven]with @xmath15 ( e.g. , pringle & rees 1972 ; lamb , pethick & pines 1973 ; ghosh & lamb 1979 ; arons 1987 ) , where we have scaled various quantities to values appropriate for neutron stars in low - mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) : @xmath16 km is the neutron star radius , @xmath17 g is the dipolar surface field strength , and @xmath18 is the mass accretion rate ( the eddington accretion rate is about @xmath19 g s@xmath20 ) . for highly magnetized neutron stars ( such as x - ray pulsars , typically having @xmath21 g ) , @xmath14 is much greater than @xmath13 and the stellar radius , the disk is therefore truncated near @xmath14 , within which the disk plasma becomes tied to the closed field lines and is funneled onto the magnetic poles of the star , although some plasma may continue to fall in the equatorial plane as a result of interchange instabilities ( spruit & taam 1990 ; see also arons & lea 1980 ) . for weakly magnetized neutron stars , such as those expected in lmxbs , @xmath14 and @xmath13
are comparable , and the plasma may not climb onto the field lines before reaching the stellar surface .
a question therefore arises as to how the magnetic field affects the the dynamics of the inner disk and changes the sonic point . in this paper
, we present an unified ( albeit phenomenological ) treatment of neutron star accretion disks under the combined influences of magnetic fields and strong gravity .
our study is motivated by the recent observations using the rossi x - ray timing explorer ( rxte ) ( bradt , rothschild & swank 1993 ) which revealed kilo - hertz quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) in the x - ray fluxes of at least thirteen lmxbs ( see van der klis 1997 for a review ) .
these khz qpos are characterized by their high levels of coherence ( with @xmath22 up to @xmath23 ) , large rms amplitudes ( up to @xmath24 ) , and wide span of frequencies ( @xmath25 hz ) which , in most cases , are strongly correlated with the x - ray fluxes . in several sources ,
the x - ray power spectra show twin khz peaks moving up and down in frequency together , with the separation frequency roughly constant .
moreover , in five atoll sources single qpos ( with a much higher level of coherence ) have been seen during one or more x - ray bursts , with frequencies equal to the frequency differences between the two peaks or twice that .
this is a strong indication of beat phenomena ( strohmayer et al .
while the origin of these qpos is uncertain , it is clear that the action must take place close to the neutron star , either in the accreting atmosphere ( klein et al .
1996 ) or in the inner disk ( strohmayer et al . 1996
; miller , lamb and psaltis 1996 ) .
a generic beat - frequency model assumes that the qpo with the higher frequency is associated with the kepler motion at some preferred orbital radius around the neutron star , while the lower - frequency qpo results from the beat between the kepler frequency and the neutron star spin frequency .
it has been suggested that this preferred radius is the magnetosphere radius ( strohmayer et al .
1996 ) or the sonic radius of the disk accretion flow ( miller et al .
1996 ) . in this paper ,
we are not concerned with the actual mechanisms by which khz qpos in the x - ray fluxes of lmxbs may be produced ( see miller et al .
1996 and van der klis 1997 for extensive discussion on various possibilities ) .
rather , our main purpose is to understand what physical effects determine the characteristics of the inner accretion disks in lmxbs . in the sonic - point model ,
miller et al . ( 1996 ) suggest that some accreting gas can penetrate inside the magnetosphere , whose boundary is located at a larger radius than the sonic radius . for unknown reasons
, they assume that these gases are unaffected by the magnetic field once they are inside the magnetosphere and remains in a keplerian disk .
they further suggest that the variation of qpo frequency results from the change in radiative forces on the accretion disk .
we note , however , that the effect of radiative forces on the disk fluid ( rather than test particle orbiting the central star ) , is far from clear .
calculating particle trajectories without solving for the global disk structure ( m. c. miller 1997 , private communication ) is inadequate for determining the magnitude of the radiative forces .
while the radiative forces may be important for high - luminosity z - sources , their effects on the disk dynamics are expected to be be small for low - luminosity systems ( @xmath26 less than @xmath27 of @xmath28 ) . on the other hand , it is well known that millisecond pulsars have magnetic fields in the range of @xmath29 g , and one expect that neutron stars in lmxbs to have the similar range of field strengths .
while the magnetic field may not be strong enough to induce a corotating magnetosphere outside the neutron star , it can nevertheless influence the dynamics of the inner disk flow by transporting away angular momentum from the disk .
ideally , to properly assess the dynamical effect of magnetic fields on the accretion disks , one needs to solve for both the fluids and the fields self - consistently .
this is a difficult task if not impossible . despite many decades of theoretical studies ( e.g. , pringle & rees 1972 ; lamb et al .
1973 ; ghosh & lamb 1979 ; aly 1985 , 1991 ; arons 1987 ; spruit & taam 1990 ; sturrock 1991 ; shu et al . 1994
; lovelace et al .
1987 , 1995 ; stone & norman 1994 ; miller & stone 1997 ) , there remain considerable uncertainties on the nature of the stellar magnetic field
disk interactions . particularly outstanding are the issues related to the efficiency of magnetic field dissipation in and outside the disk and whether the stellar field threads the disk in a closed configuration or it becomes open due to differential shearing between the star and the disk .
it seems unlikely that some of these issues can be resolved on purely theoretical grounds . in this paper
, we shall not attempt a self - consistent magnetohydrodynamics ( mhd ) calculations .
rather , _ we shall adopt a phenomenological approach _ and consider rather general field configurations .
we believe that such an approach is useful in bridging the gap between full mhd theories and observations .
indeed , as we show in this paper , if the observed khz qpos are associated with the sonic point kepler frequency , then various systematics of khz qpos should provide useful constraints on the nature of magnetic field
disk interactions as well as on the magnetic field structure in lmxbs . in 2 we introduce a model of magnetic slim accretion disk .
numerical solutions are presented in 3 .
because of various uncertainties in disk parameters , we shall focus on the simplest models , leaving more complete exploration to future studies . however ,
in 4 we introduce the notion of `` generalized marginally stable orbit '' including both the gr and magnetic effects .
we derive an analytical expression for the sonic radius , which shows that the sonic point depends mainly on two parameters characterizing the disk magnetic field ( in addition to the neutron star mass ) .
we show how different modes of magnetic field disk interactions can lead to different sonic - point orbital frequencies and their scalings with the field strength and mass accretion rate .
section 5 concerns the equilibrium spin periods of neutron stars in our slim magnetic disk model .
some applications to khz qpos in lmxbs are discussed in 6 , where we show that our phenomenological approach can be used to learn about the physics of magnetic field disk interactions .
unless otherwise noted , we use geometrized units in which the speed of light and newton s gravitation constant are unity .
we now consider geometrically thin axisymmetric accretion disk in steady state , taking into account of the transonic nature of the flow , and the deviation from keplerian motion in the inner region of the disk .
our models generalize the usual `` slim disks '' around black holes ( e.g. , muchotrzeb & paczyski 1982 ; matsumoto et al . 1984 ; abramowicz et al . 1988 ;
narayan et al . 1997 ; chen et al .
1997 ) by including the effect of magnetic fields .
gr effects are included in our purely newtonian treatment by using the pseudo - newtonian potential introduced by paczyski & wiita ( 1980 ) = -mr-2 m .
this potential correctly reproduces the marginally stable orbit ( where @xmath30 is the spin angular momentum ) , we have @xmath31 , and @xmath32 . for a spin frequency of @xmath33 hz ( strohmayer et al .
1996 ) , this amounts to a correction of @xmath34 to @xmath13 and @xmath27 to @xmath35 .
these corrections are neglected in this paper . ]
located at @xmath36 , and is adequate for this initial exploration , considering the much greater uncertainties in the magnetic field disk interactions .
the self - gravity of the disk is neglected .
we assume that the accreting material is confined to a thin disk , and we do not formally introduce a magnetosphere in our model . as discussed in 1 ,
when the field strength is sufficiently high ( as in x - ray pulsars , which typically have @xmath21 g ) , there is no question that a corotating magnetosphere exists outside the neutron star surface , located near @xmath37 ( see eq . [ [ alfven ] ] ; note that , theoretically , the magnetosphere radius is not known to within a factor of two , nor is it clear what the width of the transition zone is ) . in such a high - field regime , we shall find that the sonic point as obtained from our model is approximately equal to the usual alfven radius .
although in our model the flow continues to be confined in the disk plane even inside the magnetosphere , in reality it may well behave differently ( e.g. , the plasma may `` jump '' onto the field lines and get funneled onto the magnetic poles ) .
thus for high magnetic systems , the supersonic portion of our flow ( inside the sonic point ) may not be realistic .
however , for low magnetic systems ( such as lmxbs ) , which is the main focus of this paper , there needs not be a genuine magnetosphere to truncate the disk flow , but the magnetic forces can still shift the sonic point to a radius larger than @xmath38 . in such low - field regimes ,
we expect our global flow solutions to have a wider validity .
the mass continuity equation takes the form m=-2ru , [ mdot]where @xmath39 is the radial velocity of the flow ( @xmath40 for accretion ) , and @xmath41 is the surface density of the disk .
the disk half - thickness since only height - integrated equations are used . ]
is given by @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the isothermal sound speed , and @xmath35 is the keplerian angular velocity ( for the pseudo - newtonian potential ) : _ k=(mr^3)^1/2rr-2 m . [ omegak]the radial momentum equation reads ududr=-1dpdr+(^2-_k^2)r + b_zb_r2|_z = h , [ uup ] where @xmath44 is the integrated disk pressure , @xmath45 is the angular velocity .
the last term in eq .
( [ uup ] ) represents the dominant radial magnetic force , obtained by integrating over height the force per unit volume @xmath46 and dividing by @xmath47 .
note that in eq .
( [ uup ] ) , @xmath48 is evaluated at the upper disk plane , and @xmath49 . in deriving the magnetic force ,
we have also neglected the @xmath50-component of the magnetic stress .
the angular momentum equation reads u dldr = r , [ dl]where the second term on the right - hand - side is the magnetic torque per unit mass , obtained by integrating over height the torque per unit volume @xmath51 and dividing by @xmath47 .
equation ( [ dl ] ) can be integrated in @xmath52 to give the conservation equation for angular momentum : m l_0=m l+2r^3 + m n_b(r ) , [ l0 ] where @xmath53 is the integration constant , and m n_b(r)=-_r^drr^2 b_zb_|_z = h .
[ n_b]the three terms on the right - hand - side of eq .
( [ l0 ] ) correspond to advective angular momentum transport , viscous torque , and magnetic torque due the threading field lines from @xmath52 to @xmath54 , respectively .
the constant @xmath53 is the eigenvalue of the problem ; it should be determined by requiring the flow to be regular at the sonic point .
we shall adopt the standard @xmath55prescription for the disk kinematic viscosity , i.e. , @xmath56 ( shakura & sunyaev 1973 ) .
the energy equation describing the thermal state of the flow can be written in the form : t u d sdr = e_visc+e_joule -2f_z . here
@xmath57 is the specific entropy ( per unit mass ) , @xmath58 is the viscous heating rate per unit area . with the @xmath59-prescription for the disk viscosity
, we have e_visc=2h1(rddr)^2 = ( rddr)^2 .
the vertical ( optically thick ) radiative transport flux is f_z =- c3ddz(at^4 ) , where @xmath60 is the opacity and @xmath61 is the radiation energy density . the joule heating rate @xmath62 depends on the field dissipation in the disk , and its specific form depends on our ansatz for the magnetic field ( 2.2 ) .
finally we need equations of state .
for the inner disk region of interest in this paper , radiation pressure dominates over gas pressure .
thus we have @xmath63 and @xmath64 . also , the opacity is dominated by thomson scattering , @xmath65 @xmath66 g .
the equations above can be applied to general axisymmetric magnetic field
disk configurations , as long as mass loss from possible disk wind is negligible , and the accreting material is confined to a thin disk plane .
we now specify our ansatz for the magnetic fields . the vertical field component is assumed to take the form b_z = b_0(rr)^n .
[ bz]we shall mostly focus on the @xmath67 case , corresponding to a central stellar dipole field threading the disk ( e.g. , ghosh & lamb 1979 ; knigl 1991 ; yi 1995 ; wang 1995 ) , although we will also consider more general values of @xmath68 , as in the cases when high - order multipoles are important ( arons 1993 ) or when field lines become open due differential shearing between the disk and the star ( aly 1985 , 1991 ; sturrock 1991 ; newman et al . 1992 ; lynden - bell & boily 1994 ; lovelace et al .
in reality , the power - law relation in eq .
( [ bz ] ) is most likely to be valid only for a small range of @xmath52 , but as we shall see in 4 , the sonic point is mainly determined by the local behavior of the magnetic field . for the azimuthal component of the magnetic field , we consider two possibilities : \(i ) if the stellar magnetic field threads the accretion disk in a closed configurations ( e.g. , ghosh & lamb 1979 ) , then @xmath69 is governed by @xmath70 ( where @xmath71 is the field dissipation time ) . in steady - state
, this gives @xmath72 , where @xmath73 is the rotation frequency of the star .
we define a dimensionless parameter @xmath74 such that b_|_z = h=(_s-_k)b_z , [ bphi]where @xmath35 is the kepler frequency and @xmath75 is the disk orbital frequency .
various ( uncertain ) estimates for the field dissipation timescale in the magnetically threaded disk configurations have been summarized in wang ( 1995 ) .
\(ii ) if the magnetic field becomes open ( e.g. , lovelace et al .
1995 ) , we assume b_|_z = h =- b_z , where @xmath76 specifies the maximum twist angle of any field line connecting the star and the disk . clearly , eq . ( [ bphi ] ) encompasses the second possibility if we set @xmath77 .
however , we note that the physical meaning of @xmath53 in these two cases are rather different : for closed field configurations ( i ) , @xmath78 measures the total torque on the star , while for the ( partially ) open field configurations ( ii ) , @xmath78 also include the angular momentum carried away from the disk by the magnetic fields of disk outflow . in both cases
, @xmath78 is the total angular momentum transported away from the disk per unit time .
similar to eq .
( [ bphi ] ) , our ansatz for the radial component @xmath79 of the disk magnetic field is b_r|_z = h=_r(-u_k r)b_z . we expect @xmath80 to be of the same order of magnitude as @xmath74 . with the particular ansatz for the magnetic fields given by eq .
( [ bphi ] ) , the joule heating rate @xmath62 can be calculated as e_joule = dz14b_zb_(r ) = 12r b_z^2(_s-)^2_k .
the dissipation due to the current associated with @xmath79 is much smaller and has been neglected .
it is useful to define dimensionless field strengths @xmath81 and @xmath82 via @xmath83 where @xmath84 . roughly speaking
, @xmath6 is the ratio of the total magnetic torque and the characteristic accretion torque on the neutron star . comparing with eq .
( [ alfven ] ) we see that for dipole magnetic fields , @xmath85 . in all our calculations ,
we choose @xmath86 ; the flow structure and the sonic radius are rather insensitive to the value of @xmath82 .
the radial force equation and the continuity equation can be cast in the form which reveals the existence of a sonic point : ( dudr)=a_s^2r+l^2r^3-_k^2 r + b_r^2u^2l_rr^3_k(rr)^2n-3 , [ up]where @xmath87 .
the sonic point ( where @xmath88 ) is a critical point of the differential equation .
the other equations can also be rewritten in the forms convenient for numerical integration .
the angular momentum equation is l_0=l - r^2 c_s^2u_kddr + n_b , [ l0_2]with = -b^2l_rr(rr)^2n-3 -_s_k .
[ dnb]the energy equation is = -c_s^2r 2u_k(ddr)^2 + 12b^2l_rr^2_k ( rr)^3(_s-)^2 -3c c_s_km .
[ energy_2 ] the eigenvalue @xmath53 is adjusted so that the solution is regular at the sonic point .
equations ( [ up])-([energy_2 ] ) are integrated inward from an outer radius ( far from the sonic point ) where the disk is approximately keplerian .
note that in this outer keplerian region , eq .
( [ dnb ] ) can be integrated to give n_b(r)=b^2l_r2n-3(rr)^2n-3\
{ 1-(4n-6)_s(4n-9)(m / r^3)^1/2 } , [ nbb]and the angular momentum equation yields u(r)=-3r c_s^22(l_k - l_0+n_b ) ( 1 - 2m/3r1 - 2m / r ) , where @xmath89 .
the sound speed @xmath90 can be obtained from the energy equation ( [ energy_2 ] ) . since the radial velocity is small at large radius
, the entropy advection term can be neglected . substituting @xmath91 from eq .
( [ l0_2 ] ) into eq .
( [ energy_2 ] ) , we find c_s(r)=m_k4c .
[ cs ] equations ( [ up])-([energy_2 ] ) turn out to be a rather stiff set of equations .
we have opted to adopt a further simplification by assuming the disk is isothermal .
we estimate the range of @xmath90 using the thin disk expression ( [ cs ] ) evaluated near the sonic radius .
the physical rationale behind this approximation is that the transition from keplerian disk to supersonic flow is very sharp , and we do not expect the sound speed to change significantly in this transition region ( near the sonic point ) .
as we shall see in 4 , the sonic radius is insensitive to the thermal state of the disk when the sound speed is small .
we have not studied the general dependence of the sonic radius on the thermal state of the disk . however , considering the very large uncertainties in the disk magnetic fields , the isothermal approximation should be adequate for use in the first step in our investigation .
figure 1 depicts two examples of transonic accretion flows , with closed dipolar stellar fields threading the disks ( @xmath67 ) .
we choose a standard set of parameters : @xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 ( a typical value for a @xmath95 , @xmath96 km neutron star ) , and @xmath97 ( corresponding to stellar spin frequency of @xmath98 hz ) . as expected , the magnetic fields slow down the tangential flow velocity , and , together with the strong relativistic gravity , make the radial velocity supersonic at small radii . for small @xmath6 ,
the deviation of @xmath45 from @xmath35 is small ; for larger @xmath6 , the sonic radius @xmath99 larger , and @xmath45 gradually approaches @xmath73 inside the sonic point . in these examples ,
the sonic points are located at @xmath100 ( for @xmath101 ) and @xmath102 ( for @xmath103 ) , the corresponding eigenvalues ( @xmath53 ) are @xmath104 and @xmath105 , respectively . in figure 2
we show the sonic radius @xmath99 and the corresponding specific angular momentum @xmath53 as a function of @xmath6 for several different values of @xmath59 and @xmath90 .
we assume @xmath94 and @xmath106 for these models .
the following trends have been found : for a given @xmath6 , a larger @xmath59 tends to make @xmath99 larger ( i.e. , viscosity tends to `` destablize '' the disk ) , while a larger @xmath90 tends to make @xmath99 smaller ( i.e. , pressure `` stablizes '' the disk ) . however , we emphasize that dependences of @xmath99 on these disk parameters ( @xmath107 ) are rather weak . moreover
, as @xmath90 decreases , the sonic @xmath99 converges to a value independent of @xmath59 and @xmath90 the reason for this convergence will become clear in 4 .
as our numerical results in 3 indicate , in the limit of small disk pressure and viscosity , the sonic radius approaches a value independent of the disk parameters ( @xmath108 and the equation of state ) .
asymptotic sonic radius _ can be derived analytically using a simple mechanical model : consider the equation of motion of a test mass around a neutron star = l^2r^3-_k^2 r , l_0=l+n_b(r ) .
[ testeq]imagine that the test mass is `` attached '' to a magnetic field line so that its orbital angular momentum @xmath109 is not conserved by itself .
the conserved angular momentum @xmath53 includes the contributions from both the orbital motion and the angular momentum @xmath110 [ cf .
( [ n_b ] ) ] carried by the threading magnetic field . equation ( [ testeq ] ) can be obtained by setting the pressure and viscosity to zero in our general slim disk equations ( 2.1 ) .
the radial component of the magnetic force has been neglected .
an equilibrium orbit is determined by the condition l_0-n_b=_k^2 r = l_k(r ) .
deviation @xmath111 from the equilibrium is governed by the perturbation equation of the form + _ eff^2r=0 , where the the effective epicyclic frequency @xmath112 is given by _
eff^2=2_krddr(l_k+n_b)= m(r-6m)r(r-2m)^3 - 2b^2l_r_kr^2 ( rr)^2n-3(1-_s_k ) , [ kappa2](recall that @xmath113 and @xmath114 is the neutron star radius ) . setting @xmath115
, we obtain a critical orbit , which we dub the _ `` generalized marginal stable orbit '' _ , located at @xmath116 . clearly , @xmath117 depends only on the gravitational potential and the local magnetic torque @xmath118 .
the magnetic field enters only through the dimensionless ratio @xmath81 .
the corresponding constant eigenvalue @xmath119 , however , depends on the global field structure . in figure 2
we plot @xmath117 and @xmath53 against @xmath6 for @xmath106 ( corresponding to spin frequency of @xmath98 hz ) and @xmath94 .
we see that @xmath117 is the upper limit to the numerically determined @xmath99 , i.e. , _
@xmath117 is the asymptotic sonic radius as the disk viscosity and pressure diminish_. it is of interest to consider two limiting cases : ( i ) in the newtonian limit ( neglecting the gr effect ) , or equivalently when @xmath6 is large ( so that @xmath120 ) , we have = ^2/(4n-5 ) . [ largeb]for @xmath67 , this is the standard result for the inner radius of the keplerian disk , as determined by @xmath121 ( e.g. , arons 1993 ; wang 1995 ) ; ( ii ) in the limit of small @xmath6 ( so that @xmath117 is close to @xmath38 ) , we find = 6 + 16b^23(rm)^(4n-5)/2 .
[ smallb]this gives the correction to the standard general - relativity - induced mso located at @xmath36 .
the consideration of the limiting cases clearly indicates the sonic point ( or the generalized mso ) constructed in our slim disk model includes the essential physics embodied in the determination of the usual magnetosphere radius . as we argued at the beginning of 2 , for high magnetic systems ,
a genuine magnetosphere should certainly exist outside the neutron star . for low magnetic systems , however
, the accretion flow may well be confined in the disk , and the distinction between the sonic point and the magnetosphere boundary may not exist .
we emphasize that our analysis given here is phenomenological .
it only takes account of the dynamics of disk under a fixed magnetic field configuration , while a full mhd treatment should include perturbations of both disk fluid and magnetic fields .
the usefulness of our analytical result lies in the fact that @xmath117 provides a good approximation to the sonic radius ; and the sonic point is induced by both the gr effect and the magnetic effect .
we note that in the presence of disk viscosity and magnetic fields , a fluid element continuously falls inward by the viscous stress and the magnetic stress , and therefore the concept of `` marginally stable orbit '' does not strictly apply .
nevertheless , we use the term `` generalized mso '' to refer to the asymptotic sonic radius as determined by our analytical expressions .
figure 3 depicts the orbital frequency , rather than the approximate pseudo - newtonian eq .
( [ omegak ] ) .
] at the generalized mso ( approximately the sonic radius ) as a function of the mass accretion rate @xmath3 for several different combinations of model parameters ( @xmath68 and @xmath73 ) .
note that once we specify @xmath68 and @xmath73 in units of @xmath122 , the numerical value of @xmath123 depends on the other parameters only through the combination @xmath124 ( see eqs . [ [ kappa2]]-[[smallb ] ] ) .
we have therefore used x = m_1.4 ^ 2n-2r_10 ^ -2nm_17b_7 ^ 2 = 0.07317b^2(m_1.4r_10)^(4n-5)/2 [ xlabel]as the @xmath125-variable in fig . 3 ( where @xmath126 is the surface field @xmath2 in units of @xmath127 g ) . for large @xmath128 ( or small @xmath6 ) , @xmath117 approaches @xmath36 and @xmath129 approaches @xmath130 khz .
the scaling of @xmath131 with @xmath3 depends mainly on @xmath68 , the index which specifies the shape of the magnetic field lines ( see eq . [ [ bz ] ] ) .
note that the sonic point converges to the mso only in the limit of small @xmath90 .
thus in reality , the dependence of the sonic - point kepler frequency @xmath132 on @xmath3 may be different if @xmath90 is not small .
for example , @xmath133 for radiation - dominated optically - thick disk , and therefore the dependence of @xmath132 on @xmath3 is slightly steeper than what is shown in fig . 3 .
we shall discuss some of the applications of fig . 3 to qpos in lmxbs in 6 .
as discussed before ( 2.2 ) , for closed field configurations , the quantity @xmath78 measures the total torque on the neutron star due to the accreting matter and the threading magnetic fields .
it is of interest to consider how the equilibrium stellar rotation rate @xmath134 , at which @xmath135 , is determined in the slim disk model .
we shall restrict to the dipole fields ( @xmath67 ) in this section .
first consider the result when the gr effect is neglected . in this case
the keplerian disk boundary @xmath37 is determined by the condition @xmath136 , or @xmath137 , where @xmath138 .
we find = ^2/7 , [ ghosh](cf .
[ [ largeb ] ] ) .
the total torque on the star is given by n_tot = m l_0=m l_k(r_m)76 .
[ torquen]equilibrium is obtained for @xmath139 .
using eq .
( [ ghosh ] ) we then find @xmath140 and @xmath141 , which gives _ s , eq=3.44m_1.4 ^ 1/2r_10 ^ -3/2b^-6/7(khz ) = 1.467m_1.4 ^ 5/7r_10 ^ -18/7m_17 ^ 3/7 ( b_8 ^ 2)^-3/7(khz ) .
[ omegeq]this is the standard result that the equilibrium spin frequency is equal to the keplerian frequency at the alfven radius .
this result is plotted in fig .
4 . in the slim magnetic disk model ,
the total torque on the neutron star @xmath78 is obtained from the eigenvalue @xmath53 . in the asymptotic regime
discussed in 4 , @xmath53 can be determined from the analytical expressions : @xmath99 is obtained from the condition @xmath142 in eq .
( [ kappa2 ] ) , and then @xmath143 with @xmath110 given by eq .
( [ nbb ] ) ( specialized to @xmath67 ) .
it is straightforward to show that in the limit of @xmath144 , we recover the results given in eqs .
( [ ghosh]-[omegeq ] ) .
the equilibrium @xmath134 is obtained by requiring @xmath135 . in fig .
4 we plot the equilibrium spin frequency @xmath145 as a function of @xmath6 . clearly , for large @xmath6 , our calculation agrees with the usual nonrelativistic result .
relativistic corrections are significant only when @xmath6 is small , for which the sonic point lies close to the neutron star .
we note that the discussion in this section is valid only if the magnetic fields are closed throughout the disk . only in these cases
does @xmath53 measure the net torque on the neutron star .
thus our results in this section are much more restrictive compared to the location of the sonic point ( which depends only on the local field structure ) discussed in 3 - 4 .
we have presented in 2 - 4 an unified treatment of the inner region of accretion flow under the combined influences of general relativistic gravity and stellar magnetic fields in lmxbs .
we have shown that even relatively weak magnetic fields ( @xmath0 g ) can slow down the orbital motion in the inner disk by taking away angular momentum from the disk , thereby changing the position of the sonic point significantly ( cf .
figs . 2 - 3 ) . while the mechanisms responsible for the khz qpos in lmxbs are still uncertain , it is tempting to associate them with orbital motions at a certain preferred radius .
if this is the case , then the keplerian frequency at inner radius of the disk , or more precisely the sonic radius is certainly a natural choice ( see paczyski 1987 for an earlier suggestion on the importance of the disk sonic point ) .
one can envisage a number of different mechanisms that will lead to qpos at @xmath146 and the beat frequency with the stellar spin ( miller et al .
1996 ; van der klis 1997 ) .
the following discussion is based on the hypothesis that the khz qpo frequency corresponds to @xmath131 or the sonic - point kepler frequency .
we note that although our treatment of the magnetic field effects in 2 - 4 is rather general ( albeit based on a phenomenological prescription ) , other physical effects might be at work ( such as radiation forces for high - luminosity systems ; see 1 ) . as a result ,
some of our conclusions below should be considered tentative .
\(a ) _ range of qpo frequencies and constraint on the magnetic field strength _ : as emphasized by van der klis ( 1997 ) , similar qpo frequencies ( @xmath25 hz ) have been observed in sources with widely different average luminosities @xmath147 ( from a few times @xmath148 to near @xmath28 , corresponding to @xmath149 between a few times @xmath150 g s@xmath20 to @xmath19 g s@xmath20 ) , while for an individual source @xmath151 often correlates strongly with the x - ray flux .
this peculiar lack of correlation between the qpo frequency and @xmath147 can be explained in our model , as long as the star s magnetic field strength correlates with its @xmath149 in such a way as to leave @xmath152 in a certain range ( see fig .
3 ) . for example , if we use the model with @xmath67 ( dipole field ) and @xmath153 hz , then to produce @xmath154 in the range of @xmath25 hz would require @xmath155 ; on the other hand , if we use the model with @xmath156 and @xmath157 ( open field configuration ) , we would require @xmath158 ( we have adopted @xmath159 in these examples ) . indeed , such correlation between the magnetic field strength and the mean mass accretion rate among lmxbs has been suggested independently on the basis of z and atoll source phenomenology ( hasinger & van der klis 1989 ) , although the origin for this correlation is still unclear .
we note , however , that the correlation needs not be very strong , considering the wide range of other controlling parameters such as @xmath68 ( the shape of the magnetic field ) and @xmath160 ( stellar rotation ) ( see fig . 3 ) .
while there is a natural upper limit to @xmath131 ( corresponding to @xmath161 ; but see ( c ) below ) , the existence of a ( source - dependent ) lower limit to the observed qpo frequency needs an explanation .
if we rely on inner disk accretion to explain these qpos ( e.g. , van der klis 1997 ) , then one possibility is that for large @xmath117 ( small @xmath131 ) , the accreting gas can be channeled out of the disk plane by the magnetic field this must happen for sufficiently small @xmath3 ( or sufficiently large @xmath162 , as in the case of accreting x - ray pulsars ) .
the precise location where the plasma leaves the disk depends on the near - zone field structure , and is clearly source - dependent .
the observed qpo frequencies may already be used to probe the magnetic fields in lmxbs and the nature of the magnetic field disk interactions . as an example , consider the atoll source 4u 0614 + 091 which has extremely small luminosity ( see ford et al .
1997 and references therein ) : to obtain @xmath163 hz requires @xmath164 ( this constraint depends somewhat on the field structure and @xmath160 ; see fig . 3 ) .
at @xmath165 , this translates to @xmath166 a stronger magnetic field would push the sonic point ( or the generalized mso ) to a larger radius .
we are left with two possibilities : ( i ) if @xmath167 , we would require @xmath168 , i.e. , the dissipation of toroidal fields near the disk must be very efficient ; ( ii ) if @xmath76 ( as expected for open field configurations ) , then we would require @xmath169 . indeed , if the khz qpo sources represent a fair sample of lmxbs , then we might conclude that the magnetic fields in lmxbs are systematically weaker than those in millisecond pulsars .
this may indicate that the magnetic field of a neutron star is `` buried '' during the lmxb phase ( e.g. , romani 1990 ; urpin & geppert 1995 ; konar & bhattacharya 1997 ; brown & bildsten 1998 ) , and later regenerates or re - emerges as accretion stops .
\(b ) _ scaling of @xmath151 with @xmath3 _ : for most sources , it was found that the khz qpo frequency strongly correlates with the xte count rate ( @xmath170 kev ) , with power - law index greater than unity .
however , the scaling relation between the count rate and @xmath3 is not well established , and it has been suggested the flux of the black - body component is a better indicator of qpo frequency ( ford et al .
as discussed in 3 , @xmath131 depends primarily on the magnetic field structure near the sonic point , particularly on the `` field shape '' index @xmath68 . if the scaling of @xmath151 with @xmath3 can be established observationally , it may be possible to distinguish a closed field configuration from an open one .
for example , if we believe the scaling @xmath171 with @xmath172 , then we may conclude that @xmath173 ( see eq .
[ [ largeb ] ] and the discussion following eq . [ [ xlabel ] ] ) , which indicates that magnetic fields in lmxbs do not have dipolar shape , but rather have complex topology ( see arons 1993 for discussion on related issues ) .
\(c ) _ the maximum value of @xmath151 _ : it has been suggested ( zhang et al .
1997 ) based on the narrow range of the maximal qpo frequencies ( @xmath174 hz ) in at least six sources that these maximum frequencies correspond to the kepler frequency at @xmath36 , which then implies that the neutron star masses are near @xmath175 ( see also kaaret et al .
while we agree that this conclusion seems most natural , we nevertheless add the following cautionary notes : ( i ) the inferred large stellar masses may be problematic : all neutron stars with well - determined masses ( including a few that certainly had accreted mass , although not necessarily in the same accretion mode as in lmxbs ) have masses consistent with being @xmath176 ( e.g. , van kerkwijk et al .
in particular , the @xmath177 ms recycled pulsar b1855 + 09 , which is thought to have gone through a lmxb phase ( phinney & kulkarni 1994 ) , has a mass @xmath178 ( kaspi et al .
. moreover , accretion of @xmath179 might have spun up the neutron stars to near break - up ( see cook et al .
1994 for calculations of spin - up tracks in the nonmagnetic case ) , in contrary to the observed spin rates ( @xmath180 hz ) .
( ii ) if the maximum @xmath151 is indeed @xmath181 , then the correlation between @xmath151 and @xmath3 should weaken as @xmath3 increases , and eventually @xmath151 should approaches a constant independent of @xmath3 ( see fig . 3 ) . this has not been observed .
therefore in our opinion it is premature to identify the maximal @xmath151 with the kepler frequency at @xmath38 .
an alternative is that as @xmath151 approaches @xmath174 hz , the rms qpo amplitude decreases as the observations have indicated , making it difficult to detect higher qpo frequencies .
\(d ) _ horizontal - branch oscillations ( hbos ) in z - sources _ : in several z - sources ( e.g. , sco x-1 , gx 5 - 1 and gx 17 + 2 ) , hbos with frequencies @xmath182 hz have been detected _ simultaneously _ with the khz qpos ( see van der klis 1997 ) .
one standard interpretation of hbos is that they are associated with the beat between the kepler frequency at the magnetosphere boundary and the neutron star spin ( alpar & shaham 1985 ) .
since the spin frequencies @xmath160 of these sources ( as determined from the difference in the twin khz qpo frequencies ) lie around @xmath33 hz ( see white & zhang 1997 ) , the putative magnetosphere boundary must be located at a large radius where @xmath183 hz . as we have shown in this paper , such a strong magnetic field must necessarily push the ( generalized ) disk sonic point to a large radius where the kepler frequency drops below the kilo - hertz range .
( recall that for low field systems such as lmxbs , the distinction between the sonic point and the magnetosphere boundary probably does not exist , and the two separate radii are replaced by a single generalized sonic point [ see 3 - 4 ] . )
therefore if the khz qpos are associated with the sonic - point kepler frequency , then the magnetospheric beat frequency model for hbos can not work , and the origin of hbos must lie elsewhere .
alternative models for hbos have been discussed by biehle & blandford ( 1993 ) and stella & vietri ( 1997 ) .
the author thanks zhiyun li , rob nelson and brian vaughan for valuable discussions and lars bildsten for comment .
he also thanks the referee for constructive comments which improved the presentation of the paper .
this research is supported by a richard chace tolman fellowship at caltech , nasa grant nag 5 - 2756 , and nsf grant ast-9417371 . | the inner regions of accretion disks of weakly magnetized neutron stars are affected by general relativistic gravity and stellar magnetic fields . even for field strengths
sufficiently small so that there is no well - defined magnetosphere surrounding the neutron star , there is still a region in the disk where magnetic field stress plays an important dynamical role .
we construct magnetic slim disk models appropriate for neutron stars in low - mass x - ray binaries ( lmxbs ) which incorporate the effects of both magnetic fields and general relativity ( gr ) . the magnetic field
disk interaction is treated in a phenomenological manner , allowing for both closed and open field configurations .
we show that even for surface magnetic fields as weak as @xmath0 g , the sonic point of the accretion flow can be significantly modified from the pure gr value ( near @xmath1 for slowly - rotating neutron stars ) .
we derive an analytical expression for the sonic radius in the limit of small disk viscosity and pressure .
we show that the sonic radius mainly depends on the stellar surface field strength @xmath2 and mass accretion rate @xmath3 through the ratio @xmath4 , where @xmath5 measures the azimuthal pitch angle of the magnetic field threading the disk .
the sonic radius thus obtained approaches the usual alfven radius for high @xmath6 ( for which a genuine magnetosphere is expected to form ) , and asymptotes to @xmath7 as @xmath8 .
we therefore suggest that for neutron stars in lmxbs , the distinction between the disk sonic radius and the magnetosphere radius may not exist ; there is only one `` generalized '' sonic radius which is determined by both the gr effect and the magnetic effect .
we apply our theoretical results to the khz quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) observed in the x - ray fluxes of lmxbs .
if these qpos are associated with the orbital frequency at the inner radius of the disk , then the qpo frequencies and their correlation with mass accretion rate can provide useful diagnostics on the ( highly uncertain ) nature of the magnetic field
disk interactions .
in particular , a tight upper limit to the surface magnetic field @xmath2 can be obtained , i.e. , @xmath9 g , where @xmath10 , in order to produce khz orbital frequency at the sonic radius .
current observational data may suggest that the magnetic fields in lmxbs have complex topology . |
for a long time , the phenomenological approach dominated in description of multiplicity distributions in multiparticle production . the very first attempts to apply qcd formalism to the problem failed because in the simplest double - logarithmic approximation it predicts an extremely wide shape of the distribution that contradicts to experimental data .
only recently it became possible to get exact solutions of qcd equations which revealed much narrower shapes and such a novel feature of cumulant moments as their oscillations at higher ranks .
these moments are extremely sensitive to the tiny details of the distribution .
surprisingly enough , those qcd predictions for parton distributions have been supported by experimental data for hadrons .
qcd is also successful in qualitative description of evolution of these distributions with decreasing phase space bins which gives rise to notions of intermittency and fractality .
however , there are some new problems with locations of the minimum of cumulants at small bins .
the experimentally defined truncated generating functions possess an intriguing pattern of zeros in the complex plane of an auxiliary variable .
it recalls the pattern of lee - yang zeros of the grand canonical partition function in the complex fugacity plane related to phase transition . before demonstrating all these peculiarities
let us define the multiplicity distribution @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the cross section of @xmath3-particle production processes , and the generating function @xmath4 the ( normalized ) factorial and cumulant moments of the @xmath5 distribution are @xmath6 @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the average multiplicity .
they describe full and genuine @xmath9-particle correlations , correspondingly .
let us point out here that the moments are defined by the derivatives at the origin and are very sensitive to any nearby singularity of the generating function . in practice ,
one deals with distribution truncated due to finiteness of the available phase space and the summation in all formulae above is cut off at some finite value of @xmath10 which depends on the phase space region chosen , and increases with its increase .
it is a polynomial of the power @xmath11 and has @xmath11 zeros in the complex @xmath12-plane . to shorten the presentation ,
i omit here all the details of calculations and references to original papers .
the reader can find them in my review paper in physics - uspekhi * 37 * ( 1994 ) 715 .
main qualitative results are described and demonstrated in figures in the subsequent three sections .
their physics implications are discussed in the last section .
first , let us consider qcd without quarks , i.e. gluodynamics
. the generating function of the gluon multiplicity distribution in the full phase - space volume satisfies the equation @xmath13 .
\label{8}\ ] ] here @xmath14 is the initial momentum , @xmath15 is the angular width of the gluon jet considered , @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the jet virtuality , @xmath18const , @xmath19 @xmath20 is the running coupling constant , and the kernel of the equation is @xmath21 .
\label{10}\ ] ] it is the non - linear integro - differential equation with shifted arguments in the non - linear part which take into account the conservation laws , and with the initial condition @xmath22 and the normalization @xmath23 the condition ( [ 12 ] ) normalizes the total probability to 1 , and the condition ( [ 11 ] ) declares that there is a single particle at the very initial stage .
after taylor series expansion at large enough @xmath24 and differentiation in eq .
( [ 8 ] ) , one gets the differential equation @xmath25 , \label{14}\ ] ] where @xmath26 , and higher order terms have been omitted . leaving two terms on the right - hand side ,
one gets the well - known equation of the double - logarithmic approximation which takes into account the most singular components .
the next term , with @xmath27 , corresponds to the modified leading - logarithm approximation , and the term with @xmath28 deals with next - to - leading corrections .
the straightforward solution of this equation looks very problematic .
however , it is very simple for the moments of the distribution because @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the generating functions of @xmath31 and @xmath32 , correspondingly , according to ( [ 3 ] ) , ( [ 4 ] ) .
using this fact , one gets the solution which looks like @xmath33}{q^2 \gamma ^2 + q\gamma ^{\prime } } , \label{13}\ ] ] where the anomalous dimension @xmath34 is related to @xmath35 by @xmath36 the formula ( [ 13 ] ) shows how the ratio @xmath37 behaves in different approximations . in double - log approximation when @xmath38 , it monotonously decreases as @xmath39 that corresponds to the negative binomial law with its parameter @xmath40 i.e. to very wide distribution . in modified - log approximation ( @xmath41 )
it acquires a negative minimum at @xmath42 and approaches asymptotically at large ranks @xmath9 the abscissa axis from below . in the next approximation given by ( [ 13 ] ) it preserves the minimum location but approaches a positive constant crossing the abscissa axis . in ever higher orders it reveals the quasi - oscillatory behavior about this axis .
this prediction of the minimum at @xmath43 and subsequent specific oscillations is the main theoretical outcome .
it is interesting to note that the equation ( [ 8 ] ) can be solved exactly in the case of fixed coupling constant .
all the above qualitative features are noticeable here as well . while the above results are valid for gluon distributions in gluon jets ( and pertain to qcd with quarks taken into account )
, the similar qualitative features characterize the multiplicity distributions of hadrons in high energy reactions initiated by various particles . as an example , i show in fig.1 the ratio @xmath37 as a function of @xmath9 in the @xmath44 data of delphi collaboration at 91 gev , where the oscillations and the location of minima are of a special interest .
the multiplicity distributions can be measured not only in the total phase space ( as has been discussed above for very large phase - space volumes ) but in any part of it . for the homogeneous distribution of particles within the volume ,
the average multiplicity is proportional to the volume and decreases for small volumes but the fluctuations increase .
the most interesting problem here is the law governing the growth of fluctuations and its possible departure from a purely statistical behavior related to the decrease of the average multiplicity .
such a variation has to be connected with the dynamics of the interactions .
in particular , it has been proposed to look for the power - law behavior of the factorial moments for small rapidity intervals @xmath45 @xmath46 inspired by the idea of intermittency in turbulence . in the case of statistical fluctuations with purely poissonian behavior ,
the intermittency indices @xmath47 are identically equal to zero . experimental data on various processes in a wide energy range support
this idea ( e.g. , see fig.2 ) , and qcd provides a good basis for its explanation as a result of parton showers .
the generating function technique is not applicable here , and one should consider the feynman graphs of evolution of a jet with its subjet hitting the phase - space window under consideration ( see the abovementioned review ) . at moderately small rapidity windows , one can get in the double - log approximation the power - law behavior with @xmath48 the running property of qcd coupling constant is not important in that region .
this property becomes noticeable at ever smaller windows when ( e.g. , at @xmath9=2 ) @xmath49 , and leads to smaller numerical values of @xmath50 compared to ( [ 16 ] ) .
the general trends in this region decline somewhat from the simple power law ( [ 15 ] ) due to logarithmic corrections .
qualitatively , these predictions correspond to experimental findings at relatively small ranks @xmath9 where the steep increase in the region of @xmath51 on the log - log plot of the dependence ( [ 15 ] ) is replaced by slower one at smaller intervals @xmath45 ( see fig.2 ) .
the transition point between the two regimes depends on the rank in qualitative agreement with qcd predictions also .
namely , the transition happens at smaller bins for higher ranks .
these findings can be interpreted as an indication on fractal structure of particle distributions within the available phase space . when interpreted in terms of fluctuations ,
they show that the fluctuations become stronger in small phase - space regions in a definite power - like manner and , surely , exceed trivial statistical fluctuations .
let us turn now to the @xmath9-behavior of moments at small bins .
the phenomenon of the oscillations of cumulants discussed above reveals itself here as well if one goes beyond the double - log approximation of ( [ 16 ] ) . in terms of factorial moments ,
it means the non - monotonous behavior of the intermittency indices as functions of @xmath9 .
( compare it to the steady increase with @xmath9 at @xmath52 given by ( [ 16 ] ) . )
it gives rise to the negative values of @xmath32 and @xmath37 .
the fate of the first minimum can be easily guessed from the formula ( [ q ] ) . for large enough virtualities ( i.e. small @xmath53 ) , the minimum location moves to higher values of rank @xmath9 for jets with larger virtuality @xmath17 since the qcd coupling constant is running as @xmath54 .
therefore , the predicted shift of the minimum is @xmath55 it follows that @xmath56 moves to higher ranks at higher energies because more massive jets become available .
another corollary is that it should shift to smaller values of @xmath9 for smaller bins at fixed energy .
while former statement finds some support in experiment , the second one does not look to be true as shown in fig.3 . on the contrary
, the minimum appears at higher ranks for smaller bins .
there is no solution of this problem yet but it should be ascribed to the higher - order effects .
actually , one can guess that the higher order terms shown as @xmath57 in ( [ q ] ) become so important at small bins that they overpower the weak @xmath17-dependence of @xmath58 in the first term of ( [ q ] ) .
it is important to stress here that at large rapidity intervals the modified leading - log term with @xmath28 does not influence the value of @xmath56 , and only increases the value of @xmath37 by @xmath59 .
thus , the next- to - leading corrections should be in charge of the additional shift of @xmath56 , and , therefore , small bins help us look into higher orders of qcd .
there is another fascinating feature of multiplicity distributions
it happens that zeros of the truncated generating function form a spectacular pattern in the complex plane of the variable @xmath12 .
namely , they seem to lie close to a single circle . at enlarged values of @xmath11
they move closer to the real axis pinching it at some positive value of @xmath12 .
it is demonstrated in fig.4 for ua5 data on @xmath60 interactions at 200 and 900 gev for various rapidity windows .
no qcd interpretation of the fact exists because it is hard to exploit the finite cut - off in analytic calculations .
the interest to it stems from the analogy to the locations of zeros of the grand canonical partition function as described by lee and yang who related them to possible phase transitions in statistical mechanics . in that case ,
@xmath12 variable plays the role of fugacity , and pinching of the real axis implies existence of two phases in the system considered . in particle physics
, it shows up the location of the singularity of the generating function i.e. the number of zeros of truncated generating functions increases and they tend to move to the singularity point when @xmath61 .
since it happens to lie close to the origin , it drastically influences the behavior of moments ( see ( [ 3 ] ) , ( [ 4 ] ) ) , and , therefore , determines the shape of the distribution .
the study of the singularities is at the very early stage now , and one can only say that the singularity is positioned closer to the origin in nucleus - nucleus collisions and it is farthest in @xmath44 that appeals to our intuitive guess .
let us discuss the implications of the above findings .
the qcd prediction of quasioscillating behavior of cumulant moments of the multiplicity distributions reveals the tiny features which were overlooked by simpleminded fits of the negative binomial distribution .
the truncated negative binomial distribution has the oscillating cumulants as well but the oscillations should die out asymptotically while they persist in qcd .
it demonstrates that the qcd distribution belongs to the class of non - infinitely - divisible ones and shows that the poissonian cluster models are ruled out by qcd since they lead to positive values of cumulants and can not reproduce their oscillations at asymptotically high energies . moreover , this prediction is closely related to the existence of a new expansion parameter in describing multiparticle production in qcd . in terms of moments , this parameter is equal to the product of the moment s rank to the anomalous dimension of qcd @xmath62 .
let us recall that the similar parameter appears when calculating the feynman tree graphs and looks like a product of the number of final particles to qcd coupling constant @xmath63 .
both parameters become large if large number of particles is involved .
the invalidity of simple perturbative approach in multiple production processes would ask for more convenient basis ( compared to particle number representation ) to be used . as one of possible examples of effectiveness of such an approach , we would mention lasers where coherent state basis is more suitable .
that is why studies of coherent and squeezed states as well as statistical approach and search for collective effects , in general , are welcome .
the recent findings of zeros of the truncated generating functions point out in that direction , and provoke speculations to their possible relation to the problem of phase transition in hadronic matter .
the success of qcd in predicting the qualitative features of moments of multiplicity distributions both for large phase - space regions ( oscillation of cumulants ) and for small bins ( intermittency indices , fractality ) seems even more surprising if one recognizes that they are derived for parton distributions while hadrons are observed in experiment .
nevertheless , these qualitative features reveal themselves in hadron distributions as well .
why such a local parton - hadron duality persists even at higher moments is an open question .
another problem appears in such a tiny property as the evolution of the minimum location at smaller bins .
its solution can show a way to take into account higher order effects of qcd more properly . to conclude
, we would like to stress that recent theoretical studies of qcd multiplicity distributions predict rather exotic features of the moments of the distributions which find some support in experiment and , at the same time , provoke new problems to be solved .
fig.1 the ratio of cumulant to factorial moments @xmath37 as the function of the rank @xmath9 .
the delphi - data on @xmath44 at 91 gev in the total phase space are shown by dots .
the dashed line shows the fit by the negative binomial distribution with the parameters given by delphi .
the solid line is drawn just to guide the eye .
fig.3 behavior of the ratio of cumulant to factorial moments @xmath37 as a function of the rank @xmath9 for some single hemisphere multiplicity distributions from the delphi collaboration : ( a ) full hemisphere ; ( b ) rapidity window @xmath66 ; ( c ) rapidity window @xmath67 . the minimum shifts to higher @xmath9 for smaller bins
. fig.4 the locations of zeros of the truncated generating function for ua5-data on @xmath60 interactions at 200 and 900 gev ( c.m.s . ) in various rapidity windows .
the upper halfplane of @xmath68 is shown only because of the up - down symmetry .
( for further experimental information see the talk of g. gianini at multiparticle dynamics-95 ) . | the solution of qcd equations for generating functions of multiplicity distributions reveals new peculiar features of cumulant moments oscillating as functions of their rank .
this prediction is supported by experimental data on @xmath0 collisions .
evolution of the moments at smaller phase space bins leads to intermittency and fractality .
the experimentally defined truncated generating functions possess zeros in the complex plane of an auxiliary variable recalling lee - yang zeros in statistical mechanics . * novel features of multiplicity distributions in qcd and experiment * i.m.dremin lebedev physical institute , moscow 117924 , russia contents + \1 .
introduction + 2 .
_ oscillations _ of cumulants of multiplicity distributions in qcd + 3 .
_ evolution _ of distributions with decreasing phase space volume + intermittency and fractality + 4 .
_ zeros _ of truncated generating functions + 5 .
discussion and conclusions + |
we note that linear stability analysis can not be used to probe the stability of the synchronization , as we can not perform a valid taylor expansion when @xmath81 , where @xmath82 . for equal driving force profiles that we linearize , @xmath182 , @xmath183 ,
if we were to taylor expand , then the linearized expression for @xmath184 would be @xmath185 which has a singularity at @xmath81 .
the apparent singularity actually occurs at @xmath186 and at @xmath187 in the full expression , but the choice of constraining force ensures this zero in the denominator is canceled by the numerator . however , when we expand in @xmath37 and shift the singularity so that it occurs at @xmath81 , then the numerator is no longer zero at this point .
the reason we have this zero in the denominator is the following : the torque free condition ( [ eq : forcetorquefree ] ) is @xmath188 along with equations ( [ eq : rl]-[eq : rb],[eq : rld]-[eq : rbd ] ) , we use ( [ eq : torquefree ] ) to solve for the constraining forces @xmath189 , @xmath24 .
however , at @xmath190 , @xmath189 is multiplied by a term which vanishes , so the torque free condition can be satisfied without specifying @xmath189 .
we over - constrain the system when we divide by zero and specify @xmath189 at @xmath190 .
geometrically , @xmath191 corresponds to the phase where @xmath192 is parallel to @xmath193 .
our numerical analysis of the full expression avoids this singularity . | the green alga _ chlamydomonas _ swims with synchronized beating of its two flagella , and is experimentally observed to exhibit run - and - tumble behaviour similar to bacteria .
recently we studied a simple hydrodynamic three - sphere model of _ chlamydomonas _ with a phase dependent driving force which can produce run - and - tumble behaviour when intrinsic noise is added , due to the non - linear mechanics of the system . here
, we consider the noiseless case and explore numerically the parameter space in the driving force profiles , which determine whether or not the synchronized state evolves from a given initial condition , as well as the stability of the synchronized state .
we find that phase dependent forcing , or a beat pattern , is necessary for stable synchronization in the geometry we work with .
introduction microorganisms swim in the low reynolds number regime where viscous forces dominate , inertia is negligible and the familiar propulsion methods of larger organisms become ineffective @xcite .
fluid flow is governed by the stokes equation , which is time reversible . a necessary condition on a periodic swimming stroke in order to achieve net propulsion is that it is non - time reversible @xcite .
inspired by sperm cells , which achieve propulsion by propagation of bending waves through their flagellum , taylor demonstrated that propulsion is possible in a viscous environment by studying the propagation of waves on an infinite sheet @xcite .
purcell showed that a swimmer needs at least two compact degrees of freedom to break the time reversal symmetry and achieve net propulsion @xcite .
many microorganisms swim using flagella @xcite ; there are two fundamentally different types of flagella : bacterial flagella and eukaryotic flagella ( or cilia ) .
eukaryotic flagella form bends when microtubules on one side of the flagella ` walk ' or ` slide ' along the microtubules on the other side @xcite .
the propagation of bends allows the flagella to form beat patterns that can break the time reversal symmetry .
for example , the first half of an individual cilium s beat cycle , called the _ power stroke _
, has the cilium sticking out and pushing the fluid , while the second half , called the _ recovery stroke _ , has the cilium bent as it returns to its original position @xcite .
our understanding of propulsion at low reynolds number has been developed by theoretical model microswimmers .
lighthill demonstrated a model that can achieve net propulsion by studying periodic shape deformations of a nearly spherical swimmer , showing that the swimming velocity is at most of the order of the square of the amplitude of the deformations @xcite .
purcell s three - link swimmer was studied by becker _
et al . _ , who determined the swimming direction and velocity for different angle amplitudes and relative link lengths @xcite .
a useful one - dimensional model is the linear three - sphere swimmer , where three beads are connected by two rods that change length with a non - reciprocal pattern @xcite .
dreyfus _
et al . _
studied a rotational analogue of the three - sphere swimmer @xcite .
avron _
et al . _
presented a more efficient swimmer consisting of a pair of bladders which exchange their volume and vary the distance between them @xcite . there have been several experimental realisations of artificial low reynolds number swimmers @xcite .
when two sperms swim close to each other , their tails beat in synchrony @xcite and taylor studied this using his waving sheet model with hydrodynamic interactions @xcite .
coordinated beating of flagella or cilia is important for a range of processes including motility , efficient pumping of fluid and symmetry breaking in developing embryos @xcite .
theoretical and experimental models have been studied to show that synchronization can occur through hydrodynamic interaction and that it is relevant to bacterial swimming and pumping by arrays @xcite .
flagellar synchronization is observed in _ chlamydomonas _
, a unicellular green alga that swims using two flagella that beat with a breaststroke pattern @xcite .
the cell has diameter @xmath0 and swims with velocity @xmath1 so the reynolds number is @xmath2 and inertia is negligible . during normal swimming ,
the flagella beat in synchrony .
these periods of synchrony are interrupted by periods of asynchronous beating and during these asynchronies , there is a large change in the cell s orientation @xcite .
this is analogous to run - and - tumble behaviour observed in bacteria .
simple models have helped us understand better the intricacies of low reynolds number swimming and hydrodynamic synchronization , and a recent development has been to combine these two effects in the context of a simple three - sphere model for the swimming of _ chlamydomonas _ @xcite .
this simple model captures some of the important features of _ chlamydomonas _ , namely , the ability to swim , the exact role of hydrodynamic interactions @xcite , the existence of stable synchronized states and an emergent run - and - tumble behaviour which is observed when we add white noise to the driving force @xcite . here , we consider the model without added noise and explore its phase diagram and full parameter space to see when the model evolves into the synchronized state .
we also investigate the stability of the synchronized state under various conditions , and the different types of behaviour that can be obtained form the model .
these studies have revealed a number of intriguing features .
the model we arrange three beads in the @xmath3 plane , each of radius @xmath4 , on a frictionless scaffold , as shown in figure [ fig : model ] . in a lab frame , but it does not interact with the fluid . the green underlay is a schematic of a _ chlamydomonas _ cell . ]
we refer to the left , right and back beads with the subscripts ` @xmath5 ' , ` @xmath6 ' and ` @xmath7 ' , respectively .
let @xmath8 be the origin of the cell reference frame with respect to a lab frame .
the cell axes @xmath9 make an angle @xmath10 with the lab axes @xmath11 .
the left and right beads model the flagella and move on circular trajectories in the cell frame of radius @xmath7 in opposite directions and with phases @xmath12 and @xmath13 ; the back bead models the cell body and is fixed with respect to the cell frame .
the positions and velocities of the beads are @xmath14 where the unit vectors @xmath15 and @xmath16 are in the normal and tangent directions of the circular trajectory of @xmath17 .
the left and right beads are driven by tangential forces @xmath18 and @xmath19 respectively .
normal forces @xmath20 and @xmath21 are exerted by the beads in order to be constrained to the circular trajectories .
the force on the back bead is such that the swimmer is force free and torque free : @xmath22 where @xmath23 for @xmath24 and @xmath25 for @xmath26 .
the forces and velocities are related through hydrodynamic interactions between the beads : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the friction coefficient of each bead ( @xmath29 is viscosity of the ambient fluid ) . in the limit when @xmath4 is small
compared with all other length scales , the hydrodynamic interaction is described by the oseen tensor @xmath30 with @xmath31 @xcite .
the phase difference @xmath32 evolves according to @xmath33 , \label{eq : deltadot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
\label{eq : thetadot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we solve equation [ eq : deltadot ] numerically for a choice of stroke pattern ( driving forces ) @xmath36 , @xmath24 .
the long term behaviour of @xmath37 depends on the stroke pattern and in many cases the initial condition .
we compute @xmath38 and @xmath39 to leading order in @xmath40 , since we do not require hydrodynamic interactions for synchronization @xcite , but we include the next order hydrodynamic term when computing the velocities , since we need this second order affect to achieve a net swimming velocity . swimming velocity in the synchronized state
first we consider the synchronized state where @xmath41 and @xmath42 , so that @xmath43 .
we do not worry about the stability of the synchronized state , which we consider in the next section , and assume that the swimmer stays in this state .
since the reynolds number is low , we need to ask ` does the model achieve net propulsion ? '
if hydrodynamic interactions are not included , then the cell just moves forwards and backwards and there is no net motion .
however , if we include hydrodynamic interactions , which vary in strength around the cycle , then the symmetry in the swimming stroke is broken and net propulsion is achieved .
the magnitude and direction of the net swimming velocity depends on the ratios @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
figure [ fig : hlvel ] shows the net swimming velocity in the @xmath46 direction for a range of @xmath47 and constant driving force @xmath48 . for @xmath49 , swimming is in the positive direction , otherwise the cell swims in the negative direction .
polotzek and friedrich in reference @xcite give the following explanation of why the cell may swim in either direction .
the instantaneous velocity @xmath50 is the ratio of the force @xmath51 , which has to be applied to the back bead to prevent it from moving , and the friction coefficient @xmath52 associated with towing the swimmer in the @xmath46 direction . the force @xmath53 oscillates during a stroke cycle and the hydrodynamic interactions , which reduce the magnitude of @xmath53 , are strongest when the beads are closest together . on the other hand ,
the friction coefficient is largest when the beads are furthest apart and smallest when the beads are close together .
the geometry of the swimmer determines which effect dominates and therefore whether the net swimming is in the positive or negative direction . .
the zero contour lies approximately on the line @xmath54 for sufficiently large @xmath44 . ]
( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 327,13 ) ( 88,246 ) ( 142,180 ) ( 312,180 ) ( 218,174 ) ( 218,96 ) ( 117,115 ) ( 314,115 ) ( 117,85 ) ( 314,85 ) ( 117,62 ) ( 314,62 ) herein we fix the values @xmath55 and @xmath56 , which results in forwards swimming for @xmath57 . the the net velocity is also affected by the force profile and we consider driving forces @xmath58 such that @xmath59 , where @xmath60 is a fixed average force . the net velocity @xmath61 can be written as @xmath62 , where @xmath63 , @xmath64 is the period , and we can write @xmath65 . in the synchronized state the force dependence cancels in the ratio @xmath66 , so the force only enters the net velocity expression through the @xmath67 term . in order to maximise the net velocity , we must minimise the period @xmath68 , where we can write @xmath69 .
minimising @xmath70 with the constraint @xmath59 tells us that a constant force profile @xmath71 maximises the net velocity .
clearly , increasing @xmath60 increases the net velocity .
however as we shall see in the next section , the synchronized state is not stable when we choose a constant force profile .
friedrich _
et al .
_ showed that a constant driving force can give a stable synchronized state if we change the direction of rotation of the beads , so @xmath72 @xcite , which is equivalent to changing the sign of @xmath73 , but here we choose to work with @xmath57 and @xmath74 .
synchronization and stability we consider force profiles of the forms @xmath75 and @xmath76 , where @xmath77 and @xmath24 .
the definition of the synchronized state that we use here is zero ( or integer multiple of @xmath78 ) phase difference between the two flagella , i.e. when @xmath79 , @xmath80 .
initially we tried to analyst the the synchronization stability by linear stability analysis , but we are unable to do this because we can not perform a valid taylor expansion when @xmath81 , where @xmath82 .
we work numerically to avoid this taylor expansion ; for further details see the appendix .
we identify five main types of stability of the synchronized state by looking at the evolution of @xmath37 from different initial conditions @xmath83 for a number of @xmath84 equally spaced in the range @xmath85 : ( i ) all the initial conditions @xmath83 evolve into the synchronized state for all @xmath84 ( the synchronized state is stable ) .
( ii ) some choices of @xmath84 evolve into the synchronized state and others choices evolve into an oscillating state , but there is a larger number of @xmath84 that lead to synchronization than the number of @xmath84 that leads to oscillations .
( iii ) some choices of @xmath84 evolve into the synchronized state and others choices evolve into an oscillating state ; the numbers of @xmath84 that lead to each type of behaviour are similar .
( iv ) some choices of @xmath84 evolve into the synchronized state and others choices evolve into an oscillating state , but there is a larger number of @xmath84 that lead to oscillations than the number of @xmath84 that leads to synchronization .
( v ) all choices of @xmath84 evolve into the oscillating state , ( the synchronized state is unstable ) .
although the choice of initial condition @xmath86 is arbitrary , we want to know how likely it is that a small perturbation from the synchronized state will decay back to synchronization , or whether it is likely to evolve into an oscillating state .
this choice of @xmath87 is suitable for this purpose . for type ( v )
stability , if we start in the synchronized state , then it is likely that some numerical noise will kick @xmath37 into an oscillating state .
it is possible for a small amount of noise to kick the synchronized state into an oscillating state for types ( ii ) , ( iii ) , ( iv ) , with low probability for type ( ii ) , then increasing probability for type ( iii ) and then type ( iv ) .
first we consider the case where @xmath88 . for each choice of coefficient and initial condition
, @xmath37 evolves either to an integer multiple of @xmath78 and remains at this value ( synchronization ) ; or it reaches a state where it oscillates about @xmath89 sinusoidally ; or it reaches a periodic state near zero , but never reaching zero .
figure [ fig : devolutions1 ] shows examples of these three cases and the corresponding orientation @xmath90 . for driving force @xmath91 and initial condition @xmath92 with ( a ) @xmath93 , ( b ) @xmath94 , ( c ) @xmath95 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail .
the bottom axis @xmath96 shows the number of cycles which increases monotonically with time .
bottom row : corresponding @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] for driving force @xmath91 and initial condition @xmath92 with ( a ) @xmath93 , ( b ) @xmath94 , ( c ) @xmath95 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail .
the bottom axis @xmath96 shows the number of cycles which increases monotonically with time .
bottom row : corresponding @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] for driving force @xmath91 and initial condition @xmath92 with ( a ) @xmath93 , ( b ) @xmath94 , ( c ) @xmath95 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail .
the bottom axis @xmath96 shows the number of cycles which increases monotonically with time .
bottom row : corresponding @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] + for driving force @xmath91 and initial condition @xmath92 with ( a ) @xmath93 , ( b ) @xmath94 , ( c ) @xmath95 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail .
the bottom axis @xmath96 shows the number of cycles which increases monotonically with time .
bottom row : corresponding @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] for driving force @xmath91 and initial condition @xmath92 with ( a ) @xmath93 , ( b ) @xmath94 , ( c ) @xmath95 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail .
the bottom axis @xmath96 shows the number of cycles which increases monotonically with time .
bottom row : corresponding @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] for driving force @xmath91 and initial condition @xmath92 with ( a ) @xmath93 , ( b ) @xmath94 , ( c ) @xmath95 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail .
the bottom axis @xmath96 shows the number of cycles which increases monotonically with time .
bottom row : corresponding @xmath97.,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 145,127 ) ( 290,126 ) ( 434,126 ) ( 8,192 ) ( 154,192 ) ( 300,192 ) ( 14,88 ) ( 147,93 ) ( 159,79 ) ( 289,82 ) ( 306,99 ) ( 435,59 ) ( 80,110 ) ( 80,10 ) ( 225,110 ) ( 225,10 ) ( 370,110 ) ( 370,10 ) when @xmath37 oscillates about @xmath89 , then the orientation oscillates about some fixed value .
the cycle averaged motion is in a straight line , but the cell jiggles from side to side as well as backwards and forwards as it moves along .
when @xmath94 and the oscillations are near zero , there is a net drift in the orientation so the net motion of the cell is along a curved trajectory . for many choices of @xmath58
, the initial condition determines whether @xmath37 evolves into the synchronized state or the oscillating state .
figure [ fig : icphasediagram ] shows the the dependence of @xmath37 evolution on initial condition for @xmath98 .
a 63 @xmath99 69 grid is shown where each square represents an initial condition @xmath100 .
a black square represents an initial condition for which @xmath101 after a sufficiently long time ; a white square represents an initial condition for which @xmath37 continues to oscillate periodically as @xmath102
. evolves for different initial conditions for @xmath103 with ( a ) @xmath104 , ( b ) @xmath105 , ( c ) @xmath106 .
black squares represent initial conditions which lead to the synchronized state and white squares represent initial conditions which lead to a periodic oscillating state .
the stability of the synchronized state is : ( a ) type ( v ) unstable ; ( b ) type ( i ) stable ; ( c ) type ( ii).,title="fig : " ] evolves for different initial conditions for @xmath103 with ( a ) @xmath104 , ( b ) @xmath105 , ( c ) @xmath106 .
black squares represent initial conditions which lead to the synchronized state and white squares represent initial conditions which lead to a periodic oscillating state .
the stability of the synchronized state is : ( a ) type ( v ) unstable ; ( b ) type ( i ) stable ; ( c ) type ( ii).,title="fig : " ] evolves for different initial conditions for @xmath103 with ( a ) @xmath104 , ( b ) @xmath105 , ( c ) @xmath106 .
black squares represent initial conditions which lead to the synchronized state and white squares represent initial conditions which lead to a periodic oscillating state .
the stability of the synchronized state is : ( a ) type ( v ) unstable ; ( b ) type ( i ) stable ; ( c ) type ( ii).,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 120,10 ) ( 0,130 ) ( 268,10 ) ( 147,130 ) ( 418,10 ) ( 298,130 ) ( 70,4 ) ( 218,4 ) ( 369,4 ) for @xmath104 , all initial conditions lead to an oscillating state and the synchronized state is unstable ( type ( v ) ) .
the black squares in figure [ fig : icphasediagram ] are initially in the synchronized state .
many squares along the line @xmath42 are white because a small amount of numerical noise drives the system away from the synchronized state . for @xmath105 ,
initial conditions close to @xmath42 lead to the synchronized state , but initial conditions far from @xmath42 lead to an oscillating state .
the synchronized state is stable ( type ( i ) ) . for @xmath106 , most initial conditions close to @xmath42 lead to the synchronized state , but a few initial conditions close to @xmath42 lead to an oscillating state and we have type ( ii ) stability ;
if @xmath37 starts close to the synchronized state , it is likely to evolve into the synchronized state and it will stay in the synchronized state if there is no noise , but it is also possible for the cell to start close to the synchronized state and move away into an oscillating state . in an oscillating state
the cell can still swim , but there will be more side to side movement .
there appear to be a few white squares on the line @xmath107 , however this is because the grid does not lie exactly on the @xmath78 line , the grid contains points @xmath108 and @xmath109 and this small deviation from the synchronized state @xmath110 is enough for evolution into an oscillating state for a few choices of @xmath84 .
similar behaviour is observed for other harmonics , but with different ranges of coefficients giving the different stability types for the synchronized state .
for example , figure [ fig : harm4 ] shows the 4th harmonic for three different coefficients of cosine and initial condition @xmath111 .
figure [ fig : harm4](a ) shows that @xmath37 oscillate about @xmath89 for @xmath112 , oscillations are close to zero for @xmath113 ( it is interesting to note the 4 peaks in every cycle ) , and @xmath37 evolves into the synchronized state for @xmath114 . for the 4th harmonic with initial condition @xmath111 and coefficient ( a ) @xmath112 , ( b ) @xmath113 , ( c ) @xmath114 . (
a ) , ( b ) @xmath37 evolves into different oscillating states .
( c ) @xmath37 evolves into the synchronized state .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] for the 4th harmonic with initial condition @xmath111 and coefficient ( a ) @xmath112 , ( b ) @xmath113 , ( c ) @xmath114 .
( a ) , ( b ) @xmath37 evolves into different oscillating states .
( c ) @xmath37 evolves into the synchronized state .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] for the 4th harmonic with initial condition @xmath111 and coefficient ( a ) @xmath112 , ( b ) @xmath113 , ( c ) @xmath114 .
( a ) , ( b ) @xmath37 evolves into different oscillating states .
( c ) @xmath37 evolves into the synchronized state .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 81,7 ) ( 222,7 ) ( 370,7 ) ( 10,88 ) ( 144,26 ) ( 151,88 ) ( 286,26 ) ( 291,86 ) ( 424,28 ) figure [ fig : harmstab ] shows the stability of the synchronized state for the first 10 harmonics for a discrete range of coefficients when we choose the cosine term , i.e. @xmath115 . .
orange blocks represent stability ( i ) ; dark blue blocks represent stability ( ii ) ; pale blue blocks represent stability ( iii ) ; pale green blocks represent stability ( iv ) ; and bright green blocks represent stability ( v ) . ]
( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 96,147 ) ( 225,12 ) we see that there are more type ( i ) and ( ii ) force profiles for negative coefficients than for positive , showing that we are more likely to end up in the synchronized state when the coefficient is negative than when the coefficient is positive , for an arbitrary choice of harmonic .
we see that for @xmath116 there is no type ( i ) behaviour , so we can not guarantee that we will reach the synchronized states for these higher harmonics .
the unstable type ( v ) band around @xmath117 gets narrower as @xmath118 increases , so we only need weak phase dependence to reach a synchronized state for higher harmonics , but the region of initial conditions which does lead to the synchronized state is very small . even after reaching the synchronized state ,
it is likely that noise will drive @xmath37 away from the synchronized state .
usually the stability moves towards the lower types of stability ( more stable types ) as @xmath119 increases for each harmonic , although there are some exceptions . for example , when @xmath120 we can start in a type ( i ) region , then as @xmath121 increases we move into a type ( ii ) region .
we also see a type ( iii ) region surrounded by type ( iv ) regions on both sides for @xmath122 and @xmath123 . for each type of stability shown in figure
[ fig : harmstab ] , we select an arbitrary force profile and show the full initial condition phase diagram in figure [ fig : icselection ] . in the type ( i )
stable case , we see that oscillating states can still evolve ( see also figure [ fig : icphasediagram ] ) , but the initial conditions for an oscillating state are not close to the synchronized case . in a few cases when we replace the cosine with sine , all initial conditions lead to the synchronized state , for example , the force profile @xmath124 for @xmath125 , except for a very thin dotted white curve through the middle of the phase diagram indicating an unstable oscillating state .
however , if we look at this oscillating state for long enough , after some time the numerical noise causes it to move into the synchronized state . .
( a ) type ( i ) stable diagrams for @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
( b ) type ( ii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
( c ) type ( iii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath130 .
( d ) type ( iv ) stability for @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
( e ) type ( v ) stability for @xmath133 and @xmath134.,title="fig : " ] .
( a ) type ( i ) stable diagrams for @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
( b ) type ( ii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
( c ) type ( iii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath130 .
( d ) type ( iv ) stability for @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
( e ) type ( v ) stability for @xmath133 and @xmath134.,title="fig : " ] .
( a ) type ( i ) stable diagrams for @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
( b ) type ( ii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
( c ) type ( iii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath130 .
( d ) type ( iv ) stability for @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
( e ) type ( v ) stability for @xmath133 and @xmath134.,title="fig : " ] + .
( a ) type ( i ) stable diagrams for @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
( b ) type ( ii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
( c ) type ( iii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath130 .
( d ) type ( iv ) stability for @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
( e ) type ( v ) stability for @xmath133 and @xmath134.,title="fig : " ] .
( a ) type ( i ) stable diagrams for @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
( b ) type ( ii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
( c ) type ( iii ) stability for @xmath128 and @xmath130 .
( d ) type ( iv ) stability for @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
( e ) type ( v ) stability for @xmath133 and @xmath134.,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 73,161 ) ( 219,161 ) ( 367,161 ) ( 143,2 ) ( 297,2 ) ( 0,288 ) ( 122,169 ) ( 148,288 ) ( 269,169 ) ( 295,288 ) ( 416,169 ) ( 71,134 ) ( 192,12 ) ( 225,134 ) ( 345,12 ) we see from the bright green band down the center of figure [ fig : harmstab ] that we need some form of phase dependence in order to achieve synchronization . if we choose a constant driving force then @xmath37 evolves into an oscillating state for all initial conditions .
the synchronized state is unstable , so even if we start in the synchronized state , a small amount of numerical noise can drive the system into the oscillating state .
friedrich _
et al .
_ showed that synchronization can occur with constant forcing when the direction of rotation of the beads is reversed ( equivalent to @xmath135 and reversing swimming direction ) but here we focus on the case @xmath136 and @xmath74 .
the inspiration for our run - and - tumble model in reference @xcite came from the initial condition phase diagrams . to see run - and - tumble we want to start in a stable synchronized state , then allow noise to move us temporarily into a white region of the phase diagram , before moving back into a black region . in reference @xcite , we allowed noise to vary the coefficients @xmath137 , so that a black square in the noiseless phase diagram can change to a white square when the instantaneous effect of the noise changes the value of @xmath137 , then changes back to a black square when the instantaneous effect of the noise is smaller .
this allows us to start in the synchronized state ( with fluctuations due to the noise ) , then move away from the synchronized state when the instantaneous noise is large and we are at a suitable point in the phase diagram , then move back into the fluctuating synchronized state when the instantaneous noise is small . in reference
@xcite , we chose to work with the first harmonic and use @xmath138 , where @xmath139 is the noise term .
we chose the value 0.7 because it is in the stability type ( i ) region , but lies close to the type ( ii ) region .
in the fluctuating synchronized state , when we move through the values of @xmath140 which are surrounded by white squares in the type ( ii ) phase diagram , there is the possibility to move into an oscillating state , but there are still plenty of black squares surrounding the line @xmath42 , so we can have long periods in the _ run _ phase .
the noise causes fluctuations of the position in the phase diagram , and this could also be a cause of run - and - tumble behaviour .
for example , consider the phase diagram in figure [ fig : icselection](a ) .
if we are in the synchronized state and noise is small enough such that fluctuations in @xmath37 are within the black region , then tumbles will not occur .
if the noise is larger , so @xmath37 fluctuations move into the white region , then the cell could begin to move into the oscillating state , and after a few oscillations noise could kick the oscillations into the black region and the cell would move back towards a synchronized state .
elsewhere , we will consider the effects of adding noise to @xmath39 and @xmath141 , without any noise in the coefficient , to see if we obtain run - and - tumble behaviour this way and compare the statistics to the run - and - tumble obtained when noise is added to the coefficient .
if we start in the synchronized state , then @xmath142 which is non - zero for @xmath143 , so the system does not stay in the synchronized state .
we focus on the first harmonic and consider the case @xmath144 and @xmath145 where @xmath146 ( and we have dropped the upper index on the coefficient ) .
when @xmath147 and @xmath148 , synchronization is frustrated and @xmath37 oscillates about @xmath149 , @xmath80 , shown in figure [ fig : mc](a ) for @xmath150 .
the orientation of the cell drifts , shown in figure [ fig : mc](b ) so the cell swims along a curved trajectory . for @xmath151 ,
the centre of @xmath37 oscillations drifts away from the synchronized state , but remains close to @xmath152 .
swapping the signs of the coefficients swaps the direction of the orientation drift .
when the coefficients have the same sign but different magnitudes , @xmath37 oscillates about @xmath153 and the orientation oscillates about some fixed value .
figure [ fig : mc](c ) shows the evolution of @xmath37 for @xmath154 .
this type of behaviour is also seen for some choices of equal coefficients , for example , in figure [ fig : devolutions1](e ) , ( f ) where @xmath155 .
choices of coefficients which give this type of behaviour can be used to model a mutant of _ chlamydomonas _ which swims with antiphase synchrony @xcite . when the model swims with antiphase beating , the beat frequency is higher than when it swims with in phase beating , which has been observed in real _ chlamydomonas _ cells @xcite . and ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) corresponding orientation @xmath90 for force profiles @xmath156 and initial conditions @xmath157 , @xmath158 and with ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath150 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath154 ; ( e ) , ( f ) @xmath159 . each inset shows a small part of the main plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] and ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) corresponding orientation @xmath90 for force profiles @xmath156 and initial conditions @xmath157 , @xmath158 and with ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath150 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath154 ; ( e ) , ( f ) @xmath159 .
each inset shows a small part of the main plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] and ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) corresponding orientation @xmath90 for force profiles @xmath156 and initial conditions @xmath157 , @xmath158 and with ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath150 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath154 ; ( e ) , ( f ) @xmath159 .
each inset shows a small part of the main plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] + and ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) corresponding orientation @xmath90 for force profiles @xmath156 and initial conditions @xmath157 , @xmath158 and with ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath150 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath154 ; ( e ) , ( f ) @xmath159 .
each inset shows a small part of the main plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] and ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) corresponding orientation @xmath90 for force profiles @xmath156 and initial conditions @xmath157 , @xmath158 and with ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath150 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath154 ; ( e ) , ( f ) @xmath159 .
each inset shows a small part of the main plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] and ( b ) , ( d ) , ( f ) corresponding orientation @xmath90 for force profiles @xmath156 and initial conditions @xmath157 , @xmath158 and with ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath150 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath154 ; ( e ) , ( f ) @xmath159 .
each inset shows a small part of the main plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 83,107 ) ( 83,9 ) ( 226,107 ) ( 226,9 ) ( 368,107 ) ( 368,9 ) ( 12,188 ) ( 148,125 ) ( 16,84 ) ( 149,80 ) ( 155,188 ) ( 288,125 ) ( 165,94 ) ( 290,41 ) ( 295,182 ) ( 430,159 ) ( 304,85 ) ( 431,78 ) when the coefficients have opposite signs and different magnitudes , there are two main types of behaviour that occur . for @xmath160 and @xmath161 or @xmath162 and @xmath163 ,
then @xmath37 oscillates periodically and the corresponding orientation drifts in the negative direction in the former case and in the positive direction in the latter case .
this is shown in figure [ fig : mc](e ) , ( f ) for @xmath159 . for @xmath160 and @xmath164 or @xmath162 and @xmath165 ,
then oscillations in phase difference , @xmath37 , drift in the negative ( positive ) direction and the orientation drifts in the positive ( negative ) direction in the former ( latter ) case . figure [ fig : deldrift ] shows examples of this this case where one bead completes more cycles than the other bead .
there is a difference in the mean angular velocity of the two beads without choosing a different @xmath60 for each bead . and corresponding orientation for ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath166 and @xmath167 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] and corresponding orientation for ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath166 and @xmath167 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] + and corresponding orientation for ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath166 and @xmath167 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] and corresponding orientation for ( a ) , ( b ) @xmath166 and @xmath167 ; ( c ) , ( d ) @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
the insets show a small part of the plot in more detail.,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 128,136 ) ( 128,6 ) ( 325,136 ) ( 325,6 ) ( 40,234 ) ( 207,236 ) ( 32,108 ) ( 209,65 ) ( 239,239 ) ( 406,154 ) ( 228,109 ) ( 408,80 ) so far we have considered force profiles with only one harmonic term .
now we consider driving forces with contributions from two harmonics . for simplicity
we choose equal profiles for the left and right beads , @xmath170 , and of the form @xmath171 , @xmath172 and with the @xmath173 s chosen such that @xmath174 for all real @xmath140 .
figure [ fig : harm12 ] shows the stability of the synchronized state for @xmath175 and @xmath176 .
each grid square represents a choice of driving force with coefficients @xmath177 , @xmath178 and the colour represents the stability of the synchronized state for that particular driving force . ,
( b ) @xmath179 .
the colour of each square represents the following stability : orange represents type ( i ) ; dark blue represents type ( ii ) ; pale blue represents type ( iii ) ; pale green represents type ( iv ) ; bright green represents type ( v).,title="fig : " ] , ( b ) @xmath179 .
the colour of each square represents the following stability : orange represents type ( i ) ; dark blue represents type ( ii ) ; pale blue represents type ( iii ) ; pale green represents type ( iv ) ; bright green represents type ( v).,title="fig : " ] ( 10,10)(0,0 ) ( 125,4 ) ( 322,4 ) ( 193,16 ) ( 392,16 ) ( 34,170 ) ( 232,170 ) we see that there are large regions for which the synchronized state is type ( i ) stable .
conclusion this simple mechanical model is able to evolve into a stable synchronized state for certain choices of parameters in the driving force when the initial condition is within some region of the synchronized state .
we do not need hydrodynamic interactions to achieve stable synchronization ; we include hydrodynamic friction on each bead , with force free and torque free conditions and a phase dependent driving force , which can be constructed with a suitable combination of harmonic terms . for many choices of force profile ,
some initial conditions allow the model to evolve into the synchronized state , while other initial conditions that are very close to the synchronized state lead to an oscillating state .
there are some force profiles , including constant forcing , where there are no initial conditions that evolve into the synchronized state , and if the system starts in the synchronized state when the driving forces are equal , even a small amount of numerical noise can drive the system into an oscillating state .
there are different types of periodic behaviour for different choices of parameters in the driving force ; often the phase difference oscillates about @xmath89 , but sometimes the oscillations can occur close to zero with multiple peaks per cycle . when the parameter in the driving force is different for the left and right beads , we can get periodic oscillating states about a range of values , or we can get a drifting oscillating state , where one bead has a higher average angular velocity than the other . when the coefficients have equal magnitude and opposite sign , this can lead to oscillations about the synchronized state .
this frustrated synchronization is interesting when we add intrinsic noise to the driving force , because then the behaviour of @xmath37 is very similar for both opposite coefficients and equal coefficients , although the behaviour in the orientation is different in the two cases .
the nonlinear mechanics of the system make it difficult to study analytically and it is not easy to predict the parameter ranges which give stable synchronization .
our numerical results have highlighted some of the main types of behaviour of the model .
an important feature is that it is necessary to have some sort of phase dependent driving force in order to have a stable type ( i ) or type ( ii ) synchronized state .
when the phase dependence is only weak , then the synchronized state is unstable , which we see from figure [ fig : harmstab ] when the coefficient is small .
the value of the coefficient at which the phase dependence becomes strong enough to give synchronization depends on the harmonic , whether we choose a positive or negative coefficient , and whether we choose sine or cosine .
these latter choices are equivalent to adding a constant phase @xmath180 , @xmath89 or @xmath181 in the harmonic term .
this simple mechanical model shows a wide range of behaviour when we vary the parameter in the driving forces .
the variety of stabilities suggests possibilities for developing run - and - tumble models , where noise can be used to to jump between regions of a phase diagram that lead to synchronization or oscillations , or jump between phase diagrams as we did in reference @xcite .
we would like to thank nariya uchida for fruitful discussions and the epsrc for financial support . |
the emergence of non trivial collective behaviour in multidimensional systems has been analized in the last years by many authors @xcite @xcite @xcite .
those important class of systems are the ones that present global interactions .
a basic model extensively analized by kaneko is an unidimensional array of @xmath0 elements : @xmath1 where @xmath2 , is an index identifying the elements of the array , @xmath3 a temporal discret variable , @xmath4 is the coupling parameter and @xmath5 describes the local dynamic and taken as the logistic map . in this work ,
we consider @xmath5 as a cubic map given by : @xmath6 where @xmath7 $ ] is a control parameter and @xmath8 $ ] .
the map dynamic has been extensively studied by testa et.al.@xcite , and many applications come up from artificial neural networks where the cubic map , as local dynamic , is taken into account for modelizing an associative memory system .
@xcite proposed a gcm model to modelize this system optimazing the hopfield s model .
the subarmonic cascade , showed on fig-[fig:2 ] prove the coexistence of two equal volume stable attractors .
the later is verified even as the gcm given by eq.[eq : sist ] has @xmath9 .
janosi et .
@xcite studied a globally coupled multiattractor quartic map with different volume basin attractors , which is as simple second iterate of the map proposed by kaneko , emphazasing their analysis on the control parameter of the local dynamic .
they showed that for these systems the mean field dynamic is controlled by the number of elements in the initial partition of each basin of attraction .
this behaviour is also present in the map used in this work . in order to study the coherent - ordered phase transition of the kaneko s gcm model , cerdeira et .
@xcite analized the mechanism of the on - off intermitency appearing in the onset of this transition .
since the cubic map is characterized by a dynamic with multiple attractors , the first step to determine the differences with the well known cuadratic map given by kaneko is to obtain the phase diagram of eq.[eq : sist ] and to study the the coherent - ordered dynamical transition for a fixed value of the control parameter @xmath10 .
the later is done near an internal crisis of the cubic map , as a function of the number of elements @xmath11 with initial conditions in one basin and the values of the coupling parameter @xmath4 , setting @xmath0 equal to 256 . after that
, the existence of an inverse period doubling bifurcation as function of @xmath4 and @xmath11 is analized .
the dynamical analysis process breaks the phase space in sets formed by synchronized elements which are called clusters .
this is so , even when , there are identical interactions between identical elements .
the system is labeled as _
1-cluster _ , _ 2-cluster _ , etc .
state if the @xmath12 values fall into one , two or more sets of synchronized elements of the phase space .
two different elements @xmath13 and @xmath14 belong to the same cluster within a precision @xmath15 ( we consider @xmath16 ) only if @xmath17 thus the system of eq.[eq : sist ] , shows the existence of different phases with clustering ( coherent , ordered , partially ordered , turbulent ) .
this phenomena appearing in gcm was studied by kaneko for logistic coupled maps when the control and coupling parameters vary . a rough phase diagram for an array of 256 elements
is determined for the number of clusters calculated from 500 randomly sets of initial conditions within the precision specified above .
this diagram displayed in fig-[fig:1 ] , was obtained following the criteria established by this author .
therefore , the @xmath18 number of clusters and the number of elements that build them are relevant magnitudes to characterize the system behaviour .
in order to study phase transition , the two greatest lyapunov exponents are shown in fig-[fig:4 ] and fig-[fig:5 ] .
they are depicted for a=3.34 as a function of @xmath4 and for three different values of initial elements @xmath11 . in the coherent phase , as soon as @xmath4 decrease , the maximum lyapunov exponent changes steeply from a positive to a negative value when the two cluster state is reached .
a sudden change in the attractor phase space occurs for a critical value of the coupling parameter @xmath19 in the analysis of the transition from two to one cluster state . besides that
, in the same transition for the same @xmath19 , a metastable transient state of two cluster to one cluster chaotic state is observed , due to the existence of an unstable orbit inside of the chaotic basin of attraction , as is shown in fig-[fig:3 ] the characteristic time @xmath20 in which the system is entertained in the metastable transient is depicted in fig-[fig:6 ] , for values of @xmath4 near and above @xmath19 . for
a given set of initial conditions , it is possible to fit this transient as : @xmath21 this fitting exponent @xmath22 , depends upon the number of elements with initial conditions in each basin as is shown in the next table for three @xmath11 values and setting @xmath23 . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] it is worth noting from the table that @xmath22 increases with @xmath11 up to @xmath24 , and for @xmath11 due to the basins symmetry .
in order to analize the existence of period doubling bifurcations , the maxima lyapunov exponent @xmath25 is calculated as function of @xmath11 and @xmath4 . for each @xmath11 ,
critical values of the coupling parameter , called @xmath26 , are observed when a negative @xmath25 reaches a zero value without changing sign .
this behaviour is related to inverse period doubling bifurcations of the gcm .
fitting all these critical pair of values @xmath27 , a rough @xmath11 vs @xmath26 graph is shown in fig-[fig:7 ] , and different curves appears as boundary regions of the parameter space where the system displays @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) periods states .
this is obtained without taking into accout the number of final clusters .
it is clear that greater values of @xmath11 , correspond to smaller @xmath26 for the occurrence of the bifurcation .
evidence of period 16 appears for values of @xmath30 smaller than 30 . in fig-[fig:7 ] t=2(symmetric ) means period two orbit , with clusters oscillating with equal amplitud around zero , t=2(asymmetric ) means period two orbit , with clusters oscillating with different amplitud .
the study of systems with coexistence of multiple attractors gives a much richer dynamics and a new control parameter must necessarily be added .
although the dimensionality in the parameter space is increased by one , the dynamics is rather simple to characterize .
some of the relevant aspects of this kind of systems are shown in this work .
the phase diagram that was obtained shows the existence of similar phases to those using the cuadratic and quartic map , this behaviour suggests some kind of universality in the dynamics of the gcm .
another interesting issue found , concerns the metastable transition between two to one cluster state , along with a sudden jump in the maximum lyapunov exponent , as it was displayed in fig.[fig:7 ] . the characteristic time given by eq.[eq:1 ]
also correspond to the above transition where the critical exponent @xmath31 and the critical coupling parameter @xmath32 shows a strong dependence on the number of initial elements in each basin .
an inverse bifurcation cascade appears when the system is in two or more clusters state where @xmath32 and @xmath30 are the critical parameters of the bifurcation , which means the maximum lyapunov exponent is equal to zero .
this work is partially supported by conicet ( grant pip 4210 ) .
mfc and lr also express their acknowledgment to the ictp where the initial discussion of the work was performed . | a system of n unidimensional global coupled maps ( gcm ) , which support multiattractors is studied .
we analize the phase diagram and some special features of the transitions ( volumen ratios and characteristic exponents ) , by controlling the number of elements of the initial partition that are in each basin of attraction .
it was found important differences with widely known coupled systems with a single attractor . |
stars during their early stage of evolution experience a phase of mass loss driven by strong stellar winds @xcite .
the stellar winds can entrain and accelerate ambient gas and inject momentum and energy into the surrounding environment , thereby significantly affect the dynamics and structure of their parent molecular clouds @xcite .
both outflows and bubbles are manifestations of strong stellar winds dispersing the surrounding gas . in general , collimated jet - like winds from young embedded protostars usually drive powerful collimated outflows , while wide - angle or spherical winds from the pre - main - sequence stars are more likely to drive less - collimated outflows or bubbles @xcite .
a bubble is a partially or fully enclosed three - dimensional structure whose projection is a partial or full ring @xcite .
the kinetic energy of an outflow is very large ( @xmath10-@xmath11 erg ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , implying a substantial input of mechanical energy into its parent molecular cloud @xcite .
feedback from young stars has been proposed as a significant aspect of self - regulation of star formation @xcite .
feedback may maintain the observed turbulence in molecular clouds and it may also be responsible for stabilizing the clouds against gravitational collapse @xcite .
the impact of outflows on surrounding gas has been studied primarily in small regions such as orion kl @xcite , l1551 @xcite and gl 490 @xcite on scales less than 10@xmath12 .
recently there have been a few studies related to outflow feedback in nearby clouds .
@xcite undertook a complete survey of outflows in perseus and found that outflows have an important impact on the environment immediately surrounding localized regions of active star formation , but that outflows have insufficient energy to feed the observed turbulence in the entire perseus complex . @xcite and @xcite studied the outflows in the @xmath13 ophiuchi main cloud and serpens south , respectively .
both studies concluded that outflows can power the supersonic turbulence in their parent molecular cloud but do not have enough momentum to support the entire cloud against the global gravitational contraction .
@xcite identified 20 outflows in the taurus region and concluded that outflows can not sustain the observed turbulence seen in the entire cloud . in this paper , we report a systematic and detailed search for outflows around sources from the spitzer space telescope ( hereinafter referred to as spitzer ) young stellar object ( yso ) catalog and then estimated their impact on the entire taurus molecular cloud .
similar to outflows , bubbles are important morphological features in star formation process , which can give information about spherical stellar winds and physical properties of their surrounding environments @xcite .
parsec - scale bubbles are usually found in massive star - forming regions @xcite .
the conventional thought has been that high - mass stars can drive spherical winds and easily create the observed bubbles , while the spherical winds from low- and intermediate - mass stars are too weak to produce bubbles . however , @xcite studied shells ( bubbles ) in perseus , a nearby low - mass star - forming molecular cloud , and concluded that the total energy input from outflows and shells is sufficient to maintain the turbulence .
the taurus molecular cloud is at a distance of 140 pc @xcite .
it covers an area of more than 100 deg@xmath1 @xcite . using the j=2 - 1 line of @xmath2co ,
13 outflows have been found around low - mass embedded ysos in taurus @xcite .
there are 13 high velocity molecular outflows in taurus included in the catalog of @xcite . using jcmt - harp @xmath2co j=3 - 2 observations , 16 outflows have been found in l1495 , a ` bowl - shaped ' region in the nw corner of taurus @xcite .
recently , 20 outflows have been identified , 8 of which were new detections with the five college radio astronomy observatory ( fcrao ) @xmath2co j=1 - 0 and @xmath3co j=1 - 0 data cubes covering the entire taurus molecular cloud @xcite .
the up - to - date catalog of ysos @xcite from the spitzer provides an opportunity to search for outflows and bubbles in a more comprehensive manner . here
we present a systematic and detailed search for outflows and bubbles in the vicinity of young stellar objects and estimate their impact on the overall taurus molecular cloud .
the paper is organized as follows . in [ data ]
we describe the data used in the study .
the details including searching methods , morphology and physical parameters of outflows and bubbles are presented in [ outflows ] and [ bubbles ] , respectively .
the driving sources of outflows and bubbles , their energy feedback to the parent cloud and the related comparison between taurus and perseus are discussed [ discussion ] . in [ conclusions ] we summarize the main results .
in our study we used the @xmath2co(1 - 0 ) and @xmath3co(1 - 0 ) data observed with 13.7 m fcrao telescope @xcite .
we also adopted the up - to - date catalog of spitzer ysos , where 215 ysos and 140 new yso candidates in taurus are reported @xcite .
the fcrao co survey was taken between 2003 and 2005 .
the @xmath2co and @xmath3co maps are centered at @xmath14=@xmath15 , @xmath16=@xmath17 ( j2000 ) covering an area of approximately 100 @xmath18 .
the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) beam width is @xmath19 for @xmath2co and is @xmath20 for @xmath3co .
the pixel size of the resampled data is @xmath21 , which corresponds to 0.014 pc at a distance of 140 pc .
there are 80 channels for @xmath2co and 76 channels for @xmath3co , covering approximately @xmath225 to @xmath2314.9 km s@xmath8 .
the width of a velocity channel is 0.254 km s@xmath8 for @xmath2co and 0.266 km s@xmath8 for @xmath3co @xcite .
the mips ( multi - band imaging photometer for spitzer ; * ? ? ?
* ) maps were created as part of the final products from the spitzer legacy taurus i and ii surveys @xcite .
the data were obtained in fast scan mode in three bands : 24 , 70 , and 160 @xmath24 m , over an area of 44 @xmath18 .
the observations were performed in three epochs between 2005 and 2007 , with an integration time of 30 s ( 24 @xmath24 m ) and 15 s ( 70 & 160 @xmath24 m ) .
the maps were created using the basic calibrated data ( bcds ) and coadded using the spitzer software package mopex ( mosaicking and point source extractor ; * ? ? ? * ) . despite the fact that the data were taken with interleaved scan legs to provide optimal coverage at 70 and 160 @xmath24 m
, some small gaps remained , in particular at 160 @xmath24 m .
to mitigate this effect , the 160 @xmath24 m final mosaic was created using 32 arcsec pixels , instead of the native 16 arcsec / pixel scale .
this pixel scale matches quite well with the @xmath2540 arcsec beam at 160 @xmath24 m wavelength .
the 24 and 70 @xmath24 m maps adopted the standand 2.5 and 4 arcsec / pixel scale , respectively , to properly sample their respective 6 and 18 arcsec beams .
the maps were used successfully for photometric purposes to identify new sources in the taurus molecular cloud @xcite .
we identified 55 outflows around the spitzer ysos in the 44 deg@xmath1 area of taurus . in total 31 of the detected outflows were previously unknown . in the following subsections ,
we describe the searching procedure of outflows , the morphology , physical properties , and the comparison between our findings and the known ones . instead of a blind search , we focused on seeking outflows around ysos .
the search procedure was performed with an interactive data language ( idl ) pipeline .
we plotted spectra , position velocity diagrams ( hereafter p - v diagrams ) and integrated intensity maps to identify the outflows around the 355 ysos which spitzer identified in taurus .
detailed steps of the search are the following .
\(1 ) we plotted @xmath2co contours ( hereafter contour map ) overlaid on a @xmath3co grey - scale image around a yso . according to the scale and velocity range of previously - detected outflows in taurus , we chose two sizes ( @xmath26 and @xmath27 ) and three sets of velocity intervals ( -1 to 3.5 km s@xmath8 , -1 to 4.5 km s@xmath8 and -1 to 5.5 km s@xmath8 for blue ; 7.5 to 13 km s@xmath8 , 8.5 to 13 km s@xmath8 and 9.5 to 13 km s@xmath8 for red ) to plot the contour maps .
we plotted the maps with 3 sets of velocity intervals and two scales around the 355 ysos automatically . in total , 2130 maps were obtained .
we inspected these maps to identify outflow candidates according to the morphology of the blue and red lobes . in the end
, 74 candidates were selected .
\(2 ) we plotted @xmath2co p - v diagrams along four directions ( at position angles of @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 ) on three scales ( 20@xmath12 , 40@xmath12 and 60@xmath12 ) around the 74 candidates .
the size and high - velocity range of outflow candidates were determined roughly by checking the p - v diagrams .
when the velocity bulge appears along the direction away from the central velocity , we marked it as the start of the high - velocity wing . and along the above direction , the maximum velocity corresponding to the outermost contour is the end of this high - velocity wing .
we further confirmed each of the diagrams individually by visual inspection .
the position range of the entire high - velocity bulge along the position axis was considered to be the rough size of the outflow .
if more than one central velocity is found in the p - v diagram , it likely has multiple velocity components @xcite and thus will be excluded from the list of outflow candidates .
therefore , 19 candidates with multiple velocity components were eliminated and the remaining 55 outflow candidates were considered to be possible outflows .
\(3 ) using the rough sizes and velocity ranges obtained in step ( 2 ) , we plotted contour maps for the remaining 55 outflows .
p - v diagrams were plotted through the midpoint of the blue and red peaks ( bipolar outflow ) or through the peak of the lobe in the case of monopolar outflow , at position angles spaced by @xmath32 .
we chose the angle with the most prominent bulge along the velocity axis to determine the velocity interval of the outflows .
then we plotted the contour map again with this velocity interval .
\(4 ) finally we plotted the average spectra of the blue and red lobes . according to the morphology of p - v diagrams and contour maps , we divided the outflows into five classes .
the higher is the ranking , the more likely it is that we have identified an outflow .
we define a typical p - v diagram ( tpv ) and a representative contour map ( rcm ) as follows .
if there is obvious high velocity gas which can be seen by the protuberance along the velocity axis on the p - v diagram and the high velocity range is not less than 1 km s@xmath8 , then we regard the p - v diagram as a tpv .
if the outermost contour of the lobe is closed and we can see a clear and unbroken lobe on the contour map , then we regard the contour map as a rcm .
table [ outflowclass ] shows our criteria for outflow classification with an `` @xmath33 '' meaning that it satisfies a certain condition . having both @xmath2co tpv and @xmath2co rcm
is required for high ranking ( class a@xmath34 ) , but having @xmath3co tpv or @xmath3co rcm gives a lower ranking ( class a@xmath35 and class b@xmath35 ) because @xmath3co is generally optically thin in outflows and we usually found lobes of outflows with @xmath2co not @xmath3co .
having only @xmath2co rcm was divided into the lowest ranking ( class c@xmath34 ) because the high velocity gas in p - v diagram is not obvious .
the primary condition to identify an outflow is having high velocity gas which can be seen from the protuberance along the velocity axis on the p - v diagram .
lccccrr class & @xmath2co & @xmath2co & @xmath3co & @xmath3co & outflow & percentage + & tpv & rcm & tpv & rcm & numbers & + a@xmath34 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & & & 24 & 43.6% + a@xmath35 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & 18 & 32.7% + b@xmath34 & @xmath33 & & & & 4 & 7.3% + b@xmath35 & @xmath33 & & @xmath33 & & 1 & 1.8% + c@xmath34 & & @xmath33 & & & 8 & 14.5% + following the steps in [ outflowstep ] we found 55 outflows in the 44 deg@xmath1 area of taurus molecular cloud .
all the outflows we detected were listed in table [ outflowlist ] .
each outflow is referred as a taurus molecular outflow " ( tmo ) .
we present the locations , polarities and scales of the outflows overlaid on the spitzer mips image in fig .
[ bigmap ] .
there are 31 new ones among all the detected outflows .
we have thus increased the total number of known outflows by a factor of 1.3 .
lccllclcl tmo_01 & 04 11 59.7 & 29 42 36 & - & iii & a@xmath34 & mr & n & 1 + tmo_02 & 04 14 12.2 & 28 08 37 & iras 04113 + 2758 ( l1495 ) & i & a@xmath34 & bi & n & 1 , 2 , 3 + tmo_03 & 04 14 14.5 & 28 27 58 & - & ii & a@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_04 & 04 18 32.0 & 28 31 15 & - & flat & a@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_05 & 04 19 41.4 & 27 16 07 & iras 04166 + 2706 & i & a@xmath34 & mb & n & 1 , 2 , 5 , 6 , 7 + tmo_06 & 04 19 58.4 & 27 09 57 & iras 04169 + 2702 & i & a@xmath34 & bi & n & 1 , 2 , 3 , 7 + tmo_07 & 04 21 07.9 & 27 02 20 & iras
04181 + 2655 & i & a@xmath34 & bi & n & 2 , 3 , 6 , 7 + tmo_08 & 04 22 15.6 & 26 57 06 & fs tau b & i & a@xmath34 & bi & n & 1 , 2 + tmo_09 & 04 23 25.9 & 25 03 54 & - & ii & a@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_10 & 04 24 20.9 & 26 30 51 & - & ii & a@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_11 & 04 24 45.0 & 27 01 44 & - & iii & a@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_12 & 04 29 30.0 & 24 39 55 & haro 6 - 10 & i & a@xmath34 & mr & n & 1 , 6 , 8 + tmo_13 & 04 31 10.4 & 25 41 29 & - & - & a@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_14 & 04 31 58.4 & 25 43 29 & - & iii & a@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_15 & 04 32 14.6 & 22 37 42 & - & flat & a@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_16 & 04 32 31.7 & 24 20 02 & l1529 & ii & a@xmath34 & bi & n & 1 , 6 , 9 , 10 + tmo_17 & 04 32 32.0 & 22 57 26 & iras 04295 + 2251 ( l1536 ) & i & a@xmath34 & mr & n & 3 , 7 + tmo_18 &
04 32 43.0 & 25 52 31 & - & ii & a@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_19 & 04 34 15.2 & 22 50 30 & - & ii & a@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_20 & 04 37 24.8 & 27 09 19 & - & iii & a@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_21 & 04 39 53.9 & 26
03 09 & l1527 & i & a@xmath34 & bi & n & 1 , 3 , 6 , 7 , 11 , 12 , 13 + tmo_22 & 04 41 08.2 & 25 56 07 & iras 04381 + 2540 ( tmc-1 ) & flat & a@xmath34 & mb & n & 1 , 6 , 7 , 14 + tmo_23 & 04 41 12.6 & 25 46 35 & iras 04381 + 2540 ( tmc-1 ) & i & a@xmath34 & mr & n & 1 , 6 , 7 , 14 + tmo_24 & 04 42 07.7 & 25 23 11 & iras 04390 + 2517 ( lkh@xmath14 332 ) & ii & a@xmath34 & mr & n & 3 + tmo_25 & 04 18 58.1 & 28 12 23 & iras 04158 + 2805 ( l1495 ) & flat & a@xmath35 & mb & y & 4 , 7 + tmo_26 & 04 23 18.2 & 26 41 15 & - & ii & a@xmath35 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_27 & 04 26 56.2 & 24 43 35 & iras 04239 + 2436 ( hh 300 ) & i & a@xmath35 & mr & n & 1 , 3 , 6 , 15 + tmo_28 & 04 27 02.6 & 26 05 30 & iras
04240 + 2559 ( dg tau ) & i & a@xmath35 & bi & n & 1 , 16 + tmo_29 & 04 27 02.8 & 25 42 22 & - & ii & a@xmath35 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_30 & 04 27 57.3 & 26 19 18 & iras 04248 + 2612 & flat & a@xmath35 & mr & n & 1 , 3 + tmo_31 & 04 28 10.4 & 24 35 53 & - & flat & a@xmath35 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_32 & 04 30 51.7 & 24 41 47 & iras 04278 + 2435 ( zz tau irs ) & flat & a@xmath35 & mr & n & 1 , 6 , 17 + tmo_33 & 04 32 15.4 & 24 28 59 & iras 04292 + 2422 ( haro 6 - 13 ) & flat & a@xmath35 & bi & n & 1 , 3 + tmo_34 & 04 33 07.8 & 26 16 06 & - & iii & a@xmath35 & mb & y & 4 + tmo_35 & 04 33 10.0 & 24 33 43 & - &
iii & a@xmath35 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_36 & 04 33 16.5 & 22 53 20 & iras
04302 + 2247 & i & a@xmath35 & bi & n & 1 , 3 , 7 + tmo_37 & 04 33 34.0 & 24 21 17 & - & ii & a@xmath35 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_38 & 04 33 36.7 & 26 09 49 & - & ii & a@xmath35 & mb & y & 4 + tmo_39 & 04 35 57.6 & 22 53 57 & iras 04328 + 2248 ( hp tau ) & ii & a@xmath35 & bi & n & 3 + tmo_40 & 04 39 11.2 & 25 27 10 & hh706 & - & a@xmath35 & mr & n & 1 + tmo_41 & 04 39 13.8 & 25 53 20 & iras 04361 + 2547 ( tmr-1 ) & i & a@xmath35 & bi & n & 1 , 3 , 6 , 7 , 18 + tmo_42 & 04 48 02.3 & 25 33 59 & tau a 8 & iii & a@xmath35 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_43 & 04 18 51.4 & 28 20 26 & hh156 & i & b@xmath34 & mb & y & 2 + tmo_44 & 04 20 21.4 & 28 13 49 & - & flat & b@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_45 & 04 26 53.3 & 25 58 58 & - & i & b@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_46 & 04 39 56.1 & 26 28 02 & - & - & b@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_47 & 04 35 35.3 & 24 08 19 & iras 04325 + 2402 ( l1535 ) & i & b@xmath35 & bi & n & 1 , 3 , 6 , 17 , 19 , 20 + tmo_48 & 04 15 35.6 & 28 47 41 & - & i & c@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_49 & 04 17 33.7 & 28 20 46 & - & ii & c@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_50 & 04 18 10.5 & 28 44 47 & - & i & c@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_51 & 04 18 31.1 & 28 16 29 & - & ii & c@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_52 & 04 18 31.2 & 28 26 17 & - & i & c@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_53 & 04 18 41.3 & 28 27 25 & - & flat & c@xmath34 & mr & y & 4 + tmo_54 & 04 21 54.5 & 26 52 31 & - & ii & c@xmath34 & bi & y & 4 + tmo_55 & 04 29 04.9 & 26 49 07 &
iras 04260 + 2642 & i & c@xmath34 & mr & n & 4 + table [ outflowclass ] lists the numbers and percentages in the five classes of outflows .
we can see class a@xmath34 and class a@xmath35 account for 76.3% of all the detected outflows .
these two types can be considered as the most probable " outflows in our study .
table [ outflowclassnum ] lists the numbers of previously known and newly detected outflows in different classes .
we found more new outflows of class a@xmath34 and class a@xmath35 , which account for 64.5% of all the newly detected outflows .
that is , most of the new outflows we found are likely true outflows .
lcc type & previously & newly + & known & detected + a@xmath34 & 13 & 11 + a@xmath35 & 9 & 9 + b@xmath34 & 0 & 4 + b@xmath35 & 1 & 0 + c@xmath34 & 1 & 7 + table [ outflownumyso ] lists the outflow numbers and percentages according to the types of their driving sources .
class i accounts for 36.4% , which is the largest proportion of all the ysos driving outflow .
the outflows driven by the class i ysos are closer to the ysos and have more collimated bi - polar morphology .
compared with the class i , class iii ysos drive a small proportion ( 12.7% ) of outflows , which tend to be farther from the ysos .
this indicates that the outflows from class iii ysos are more evolved than those from class i ysos .
we also found three outflows ( tmo_13 , tmo_40 , tmo_46 ) without ysos , indicating that they are possibly class 0 objects . among the three outflows , tmo_13 and tmo_40
are newly found in our study , while tmo_46 has been reported in @xcite .
lrr yso & number of & percentage + type & outflows & + i & 20 & 36.4% + flat & 10 & 18.2% + ii & 15 & 27.3% + iii & 7 & 12.7% + no yso & 3 & 5.4% + we found 25 bipolar , 22 monopolar redshifted and 6 monopolar blueshifted outflows .
bipolar and redshifted outflows account for the vast majority of outflows in the taurus molecular cloud .
this is consistent with the results of @xcite .
[ sample - figure01 ] - fig .
[ sample - figure55 ] show the @xmath36 integrated intensity map , @xmath36 p - v diagram and average spectrum for each outflow . for class a@xmath35 and b@xmath35 outflows
, we also plotted the @xmath37 integrated intensity maps and @xmath37 p - v diagrams . using the fcrao large - scale survey data @xcite and the latest yso catalog from @xcite we were able to identify the previously known outflows , obtain more complete morphology , and find additional new outflows .
the yso catalog is also convenient for identifying the driving sources of the outflows . comparing with the previous works
, we confirmed more driving sources of outflows .
l1527 ( tmo_21 ) is a typical outflow in taurus @xcite .
the p - v diagram and contour map in our work are very similar to those in @xcite and @xcite .
tmo_08 ( sst 042215.6 + 265706 ) and fs tau b in @xcite are the same outflow with the same location .
they have the same structure , which can be seen in our fig .
[ sample - figure08 ] and figure 15 in @xcite .
in addition , tmo_30 ( sst 042757.3 + 261918 ) , tmo_32 ( sst 043051.7 + 244147 ) , tmo_33 ( sst 043215.4 + 242859 ) and tmo_41 ( sst 043913.8 + 255320 ) also have the same morphology as iras 04248 + 2612 , zz tau irs , iras 04292 + 2422 and iras 04361 + 2547 in @xcite , respectively .
these confirm the general consistency between the two works in terms of strong and extended outflows . for tmo_02 ( sst 041412.2 + 280837 ) , we obtained a good bipolar structure shown in the upper left panel of fig .
[ sample - figure01 ] , while @xcite considered this outflow ( iras 04113 + 2758 ) to be redshifted only .
@xcite did not identify the driving source of this outflow ( named by w - co - flow1 ) , while we determined that the yso sst 041412.2 + 280837 is driving the outflow . @xcite only presented the central spectrum of iras 04390 + 2517 and iras 04328 + 2248 , while we illustrated the two outflows ( tmo_24 and tmo_39 ) more clearly through contour maps and p - v diagrams .
the morphology of tmo_07 ( sst 042107.9 + 270220 ) shown in fig .
[ sample - figure07 ] is similar to that of j04210795 + 2702204 in @xcite .
this outflow was also reported by @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
however , @xcite did not find it with the same fcrao survey data .
@xcite reported that iras 04240 + 2559 was a monopolar redshifted outflow with @xmath2co ( 3 - 2 ) line .
but at this location we found the well - defined bipolar outflow as shown in fig .
[ sample - figure28 ] . as for l1529 , @xcite presented high - velocity @xmath2co wings observed by antenna no . 2 of the caltech 10.4 m array , but @xcite did not find any high - velocity gas in observations at fcrao .
we identified a bipolar outflow named tmo_16 ( sst 043231.7 + 242002 ) and demonstrated the result of @xcite with the fcrao data . at the position of iras 04295
+ 2251 @xcite showed line wings while @xcite found no outflow .
we found a red monopolar outflow as shown in fig .
[ sample - figure17 ] .
we have found 31 new outflows which are labeled y " in the eighth column of table [ outflowlist ] .
two of these new outflows were not identified as outflows in the literature .
@xcite considered iras 04158 + 2805 ( l1495 ) but did not find any sign of outflow activity in the @xmath2co ( 2 - 1 ) transition at the location of tmo_025 ( sst 041858.1 + 281223 ) .
@xcite had some doubt about co flow of coku tau-1 when analyzing the @xmath2co ( 3 - 2 ) emission , while we found tmo_043 ( sst 041851.4 + 282026 ) at this site .
the rest of the new outflows have not been reported in the literature and are identified as outflows for the first time .
all of the new outflows are of small angular extent , less than 10@xmath12 .
they were missed in previous searches perhaps because of their small sizes . to study the effects of outflows on their environment we calculated their masses , momenta , kinetic energy and energy deposition rates .
the total column density of the outflowing gas is @xmath38 where @xmath39 , @xmath40 erg s , @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 is the observed source antenna temperature with proper correction for antenna efficiency .
we assumed an excitation temperature of 25 k. the excitation temperature assumed in the literature @xcite ranges from 11 k to 50 k. the lowest temperature will decrease the mass estimate by a factor of 3 and the highest temperature will increase the mass estimate by a factor of 2.2 .
the detailed derivations regarding the physical parameters of the outflows are given in appendix a. @xcite described three major issues that can cause uncertainties in the calculation of an outflow s parameters , namely , the inclination , opacity , and blending .
our prescriptions are the following .
( 1 ) we defined the inclination angle of the outflow as the angle between the long axis of the outflow and the line of sight . since the outflows with *
small * inclination angle ( especially when * the outflow is perpendicular to the plane of the sky * ) are hard to detect , our outflow searching is biased to those with * large * inclination angle . if the inclination angle @xmath44 is randomly distributed , the average value is given by @xmath45 from the above formula we got the average inclination angle of * 57.3@xmath46 * , which differs from the usually used median value of 45@xmath46 .
then the velocity and the dynamic age , @xmath47 , should be scaled up by a factor of * 1.9 * and * 0.64 * , respectively .
( 2 ) using the @xmath36 and @xmath37 data we can correct for the opacity in the @xmath2co line when @xmath36 emission of an outflow is optically thick .
the algorithm for the opacity correction is described in appendix a. ( 3 ) we probably missed some low - velocity outflowing gas , which blended into the ambient gas , when we conservatively determined the emission only from outflows .
previous studies @xcite showed that neglecting this gas results in the underestimate of the outflow mass almost by a factor of 2 .
table [ outflowparameters ] gives the length , mass , momentum , kinetic energy , dynamical timescale and the luminosity of the outflows in taurus .
llcccccccc tmo_01 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.5 & 11 @xmath33 25 & 1.11 & 0.083 & 0.205 & 0.51 & 4.4 & 0.37 + tmo_02 & blueshifted & 3.4 & 8 @xmath33 12 & 0.58 & 0.168 & 0.570 & 1.92 & 1.7 & 3.63 + & redshifted & 3.6 & 6 @xmath33 5 & 0.31 & 0.061 & 0.220 & 0.79 & 0.8 & 2.97 + tmo_03 & blueshifted & 3.1 & 6 @xmath33 9 & 0.41 & 0.050 & 0.156 & 0.49 & 1.3 & 1.19 + & redshifted & 2.4 & 11 @xmath33 2 & 0.46 & 0.013 & 0.030 & 0.07 & 1.9 & 0.12 + tmo_04 & blueshifted & 2.6 & 6 @xmath33 8 & 0.41 & 0.026 & 0.069 & 0.18 & 1.5 & 0.36 + & redshifted & 2.5 & 3 @xmath33 8 & 0.33 & 0.005 & 0.013 & 0.03 & 1.3 & 0.08 + tmo_05 & blueshifted & 4.6 & 9 @xmath33 18 & 0.83 & 0.078 & 0.355 & 1.61 & 1.8 & 2.89 + & redshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + tmo_06 & blueshifted & 2.8 & 5 @xmath33 5 & 0.29 & 0.038 & 0.109 & 0.31 & 1.0 & 0.96 + & redshifted & 3.9 & 3 @xmath33 5 & 0.21 & 0.010 & 0.038 & 0.15 & 0.5 & 0.88 + tmo_07 & blueshifted & 2.1 & 7 @xmath33 7 & 0.38 & 0.012 & 0.025 & 0.05 & 1.8 & 0.09 + & redshifted & 2.7 & 2 @xmath33 2 & 0.13 & 0.002 & 0.005 & 0.01 & 0.5 & 0.08 + tmo_08 & blueshifted & 3.1 & 5 @xmath33 4 & 0.26 & 0.013 & 0.039 & 0.12 & 0.8 & 0.48 + & redshifted & 2.8 & 2 @xmath33 2 & 0.12 & 0.001 & 0.003 & 0.01 & 0.4 & 0.07 + tmo_09 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 1.8 & 17 @xmath33 18 & 1.01 & 0.311 & 0.565 & 1.02 & 5.5 & 0.59 + tmo_10 & blueshifted & 2.3 & 3 @xmath33 7 & 0.29 & 0.010 & 0.023 & 0.05 & 1.3 & 0.13 + & redshifted & 2.9 & 7 @xmath33 3 & 0.30 & 0.016 & 0.047 & 0.14 & 1.0 & 0.43 + tmo_11 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.6 & 7 @xmath33 7 & 0.40 & 0.020 & 0.052 & 0.14 & 1.5 & 0.29 + tmo_12 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.5 & 4 @xmath33 3 & 0.22 & 0.014 & 0.036 & 0.09 & 0.8 & 0.33 + tmo_13 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.2 & 7 @xmath33 4 & 0.34 & 0.053 & 0.115 & 0.25 & 1.5 & 0.51 + tmo_14 & blueshifted & 2.6 & 5 @xmath33 5 & 0.29 & 0.019 & 0.050 & 0.13 & 1.1 & 0.38 + & redshifted & 3.2 & 7 @xmath33 4 & 0.31 & 0.031 & 0.099 & 0.32 & 0.9 & 1.05 + tmo_15 & blueshifted & 1.9 & 3 @xmath33 3 & 0.18 & 0.013 & 0.024 & 0.05 & 0.9 & 0.16 + & redshifted & 1.5 & 3 @xmath33 4 & 0.20 & 0.010 & 0.016 & 0.02 & 1.3 & 0.06 + tmo_16 & blueshifted & 2.3 & 2 @xmath33 2 & 0.11 & 0.005 & 0.012 & 0.03 & 0.4 & 0.21 + & redshifted & 2.0 & 4 @xmath33 4 & 0.23 & 0.023 & 0.046 & 0.09 & 1.1 & 0.25 + tmo_17 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 1.7 & 5 @xmath33 14 & 0.60 & 0.042 & 0.072 & 0.12 & 3.5 & 0.11 + tmo_18 & blueshifted & 2.0 & 10 @xmath33 3 & 0.42 & 0.012 & 0.024 & 0.05 & 2.1 & 0.07 + & redshifted & 1.9 & 3 @xmath33 4 & 0.20 & 0.007 & 0.013 & 0.02 & 1.0 & 0.08 + tmo_19 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.2 & 4 @xmath33 4 & 0.23 & 0.008 & 0.017 & 0.04 & 1.0 & 0.11
+ tmo_20 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 4.0 & 7 @xmath33 3 & 0.31 & 0.017 & 0.067 & 0.26 & 0.8 & 1.08 + tmo_21 & blueshifted & 3.1 & 4 @xmath33 2 & 0.17 & 0.004 & 0.012 & 0.04 & 0.5 & 0.22 + & redshifted & 2.9 & 5 @xmath33 3 & 0.22 & 0.011 & 0.032 & 0.09 & 0.7 & 0.40 + tmo_22 & blueshifted & 1.6 & 10 @xmath33 22 & 0.97 & 0.226 & 0.351 & 0.54 & 6.1 & 0.28 + & redshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + tmo_23 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 3.7 & 3 @xmath33 6 & 0.27 & 0.019 & 0.072 & 0.26 & 0.7 & 1.18 + tmo_24 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 3.2 & 4 @xmath33 6 & 0.29 & 0.015 & 0.047 & 0.15 & 0.9 & 0.52 + tmo_25 & blueshifted & 2.4 & 5 @xmath33 5 & 0.31 & 0.267 & 0.640 & 1.52 & 1.2 & 3.87 + & redshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + tmo_26 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.4 & 13 @xmath33 8 & 0.60 & 0.369 & 0.880 & 2.09 & 2.5 & 2.68 + tmo_27 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.4 & 6 @xmath33 7 & 0.37 & 0.074 & 0.174 & 0.41 & 1.5 & 0.86 + tmo_28 & blueshifted & 2.2 & 4 @xmath33 6 & 0.30 & 0.170 & 0.371 & 0.80 & 1.3 & 1.91 + & redshifted & 3.9 & 3 @xmath33 2 & 0.15 & 0.031 & 0.122 & 0.47 & 0.4 & 3.80 + tmo_29 & blueshifted & 1.9 & 9 @xmath33 4 & 0.40 & 0.264 & 0.492 & 0.91 & 2.1 & 1.37 + & redshifted & 2.1 & 6 @xmath33 5 & 0.32 & 0.076 & 0.161 & 0.34 & 1.5 & 0.74 + tmo_30 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.4 & 9 @xmath33 9 & 0.49 & 0.286 & 0.673 & 1.57 & 2.1 & 2.43 + tmo_31 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.1 & 5 @xmath33 14 & 0.62 & 0.277 & 0.587 & 1.24 & 2.9 & 1.37 + tmo_32 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 3.3 & 9 @xmath33 6 & 0.42 & 0.131 & 0.429 & 1.39 & 1.2 & 3.53 + tmo_33 & blueshifted & 2.1 & 8 @xmath33 5 & 0.38 & 0.120 & 0.249 & 0.51 & 1.8 & 0.90 + & redshifted & 3.7 & 11 @xmath33 13 & 0.68 & 0.896 & 3.299 & 12.08 & 1.8 & 1.174 + tmo_34 & blueshifted & 3.2 & 5 @xmath33 3 & 0.23 & 0.061 & 0.198 & 0.63 & 0.7 & 2.86 + & redshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + tmo_35 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 3.2 & 6 @xmath33 4 & 0.28 & 0.049 & 0.156 & 0.49 & 0.9 & 1.79 + tmo_36 & blueshifted & 2.6 & 9 @xmath33 14 & 0.65 & 0.484 & 1.241 & 3.17 & 2.5 & 4.03 + & redshifted & 1.9 & 8 @xmath33 6 & 0.42 & 0.092 & 0.177 & 0.34 & 2.1 & 0.51 + tmo_37 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.1 & 15 @xmath33 19 & 0.99 & 0.348 & 0.737 & 1.55 & 4.6 & 1.08 + tmo_38 & blueshifted & 2.3 & 13 @xmath33 8 & 0.61 & 0.377 & 0.860 & 1.95 & 2.6 & 2.35 + & redshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + tmo_39 & blueshifted & 2.3 & 7 @xmath33 5 & 0.35 & 0.136 & 0.313 & 0.72 & 1.5 & 1.51 + & redshifted & 2.2 & 6 @xmath33 5 & 0.32 & 0.076 & 0.167 & 0.37 & 1.4 & 0.81 + tmo_40 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 4.7 & 4 @xmath33 4 & 0.25 & 0.129 & 0.607 & 2.84 & 0.5 & 7.683 + tmo_41 & blueshifted & 3.8 & 3 @xmath33 4 & 0.23 & 0.028 & 0.104 & 0.39 & 0.6 & 2.09 + & redshifted & 3.9 & 5 @xmath33 15 & 0.63 & 0.317 & 1.226 & 4.72 & 1.6 & 9.401 + tmo_42 & blueshifted & 3.2 & 5 @xmath33 15 & 0.65 & 0.105 & 0.338 & 1.08 & 2.0 & 1.72 + & redshifted & 2.3 & 3 @xmath33 3 & 0.17 & 0.004 & 0.010 & 0.02 & 0.7 & 0.10 + tmo_43 & blueshifted & 2.7 & 9 @xmath33 9 & 0.51 & 0.034 & 0.092 & 0.24 & 1.9 & 0.41 + & redshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + tmo_44 & blueshifted & 2.4 & 15 @xmath33 14 & 0.84 & 0.148 & 0.359 & 0.87 & 3.4 & 0.81 + & redshifted & 1.4 & 9 @xmath33 13 & 0.63 & 0.070 & 0.097 & 0.13 & 4.4 & 0.10 + tmo_45 & blueshifted & 2.9 & 2 @xmath33 4 & 0.19 & 0.013 & 0.037 & 0.11 & 0.6 & 0.53 + & redshifted & 2.1 & 3 @xmath33 2 & 0.14 & 0.006 & 0.013 & 0.03 & 0.6 & 0.14 + tmo_46 & blueshifted & 2.8 & 6 @xmath33 13 & 0.58 & 0.050 & 0.141 & 0.39 & 2.0 & 0.61 + & redshifted & 2.9 & 5 @xmath33 18 & 0.76 & 0.123 & 0.362 & 1.06 & 2.5 & 1.34 + tmo_47 & blueshifted & 1.5 & 8 @xmath33 3 & 0.36 & 0.193 & 0.282 & 0.41 & 2.4 & 0.53 + & redshifted & 1.9 & 5 @xmath33 10 & 0.45 & 0.304 & 0.583 & 1.11 & 2.3 & 1.53 + tmo_48 & blueshifted & 5.2 & 2 @xmath33 3 & 0.15 & 0.002 & 0.012 & 0.06 & 0.3 & 0.71 + & redshifted & 3.4 & 2 @xmath33 2 & 0.11 & 0.001 & 0.004 & 0.02 & 0.3 & 0.16 + tmo_49 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 4.4 & 7 @xmath33 17 & 0.76 & 0.042 & 0.182 & 0.79 & 1.7 & 1.47 + tmo_50 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.2 & 4 @xmath33 13 & 0.55 & 0.020 & 0.044 & 0.10 & 2.4 & 0.12 + tmo_51 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.9 & 2 @xmath33 2 & 0.10 & 0.001 & 0.003 & 0.01 & 0.4 & 0.08 + tmo_52 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.3 & 2 @xmath33 3 & 0.16 & 0.002 & 0.004 & 0.01 & 0.7 & 0.04 + tmo_53 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.4 & 2 @xmath33 10 & 0.41 & 0.005 & 0.011 & 0.03 & 1.7 & 0.05 + tmo_54 & blueshifted & 1.9 & 5 @xmath33 5 & 0.30 & 0.013 & 0.025 & 0.05 & 1.5 & 0.10 + & redshifted & 1.8 & 8 @xmath33 5 & 0.38 & 0.034 & 0.061 & 0.11 & 2.1 & 0.17 + tmo_55 & blueshifted & - & - & - & - & - & - & - & - + & redshifted & 2.0 & 4 @xmath33 11 & 0.49 & 0.011 & 0.023 & 0.05 & 2.4 & 0.06 + the distributions of length , mass , energy and dynamical timescale of outflows are shown in fig . [ outflow - histogram ] .
the extents of outflows are in the range of 0.1 - 1.11 pc .
79% of outflows are smaller than 0.6 pc .
the mass of 54% of outflows is between @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the outflows with mass lower than @xmath48 and higher than @xmath49
account for 17% and 29% of the total , respectively .
the energy of 48% of outflows is in the range @xmath50 - @xmath51 erg . the outflows with energy lower than @xmath50 erg and higher than @xmath51 erg account for 31% and 21% , respectively .
the dynamical timescales of outflows are between @xmath52 yr and @xmath53 yr . 85% of outflows have dynamical timescale shorter than @xmath54 yr . the mass , momentum , energy and luminosity in table [ outflowparameters ] are only lower limits because we did not take into account the inclination and blending correction in the calculation
. the mass should be multiplied by a factor of 2 due to blending . assuming the average inclination angle of outflows is * 57.3@xmath46 * , the velocity and the dynamic age should be scaled up by a factor of * 1.9 * and * 0.64 * , respectively . combining the correction factors due to blending and inclination , the momentum ,
the kinetic energy and luminosity of outflows should be multiplied by a factor of * 3.8 , 6.8 and 11 * , respectively . after correction ,
the total mass , momentum , energy , and luminosity of all outflows found in taurus are approximately @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 * erg * , and @xmath58 , respectively .
the totals of the previously known outflows are about @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 * erg * , and @xmath62 , respectively .
we found 1.8 times more outflowing mass , * 1.6 * times more momentum and 1.5 times more energy from outflows injecting into the taurus molecular cloud than previously study .
a high spatial dynamic range and systematic spectral line survey with good angular resolution is clearly necessary for obtaining a more complete picture of the influence of outflows on their parent cloud .
following the method of identifying bubbles in @xcite we have identified 37 bubbles in the @xmath0 deg@xmath1 region of taurus .
the procedures for bubble searching , the morphology and physical parameters of bubbles are described in the following sections .
we undertook a blind search for bubbles using the fcrao @xmath63co data cube .
the integrated intensity map , p - v diagram and channel maps of each bubble were examined .
the detailed steps of the search were as follows .
\(1 ) we first searched for circular or arc - like ( hereafter bubble - like ) structures in @xmath63co data cube channel by channel through visual inspection .
if there is a bubble - like structure in at least three contiguous channels , we considered it as a bubble candidate .
the approximate central position and radius of each candidate were recorded for further analysis .
we also marked the channels where the bubble - like structure appears . with the marked channels we obtained the expanding velocity interval of a bubble .
\(2 ) we plotted @xmath63co contour maps around the central position of the bubble candidates with the expanding velocity intervals .
\(3 ) we plotted p - v diagrams in @xmath63co through the central position of each candidate of every @xmath32 in position angle .
we chose the one with the most obvious circular or v " structure to show in the figures .
the circular or
v " structure in the p - v diagram is described in the expanding bubble model @xcite .
\(4 ) we plotted the @xmath63co channel maps of each candidate to look over the variation of radius with velocity .
\(5 ) finally , we fitted a gaussian profile to the azimuthally averaged profile of @xmath63co intensity of each candidate in the channel where the bubble morphology is most like a ring or arc .
the radius of a bubble was obtained from the peak position of the fitted profile . the contour map , p - v diagram , channel maps and gaussian fitted curves helped us not only to analyze the morphology but also to determine the confidence level of a bubble .
the bubble candidates were classified into 6 categories according to the characteristic of the above four types of plots .
the criteria for bubble classification , as well as the numbers and ratios of bubbles in different classes are illustrated in table [ bubbleclass ] . in this table
@xmath33 " means that it meets a certain condition . for each type of plot
the condition is as follows .
\(a ) there is an obvious bubble - like structure in the contour map .
\(b ) the p - v diagram has an obvious circular or v " structure .
\(c ) there is an obvious bubble - like structure in the channel map and the radius of bubble is increasing or decreasing with channel .
\(d ) the average intensity distribution can be fitted with a gaussian profile .
meeting all the above four items is required for a high ranking ( class a ) .
if the plots only meet ( b ) and ( c ) , we then divided the bubbles into the lower ranking ( class b1 ) because only the expanding velocity is detected but there is no obvious bubble - like structure and good gaussian fitted profile .
then b2 , b3 and b4 are in descending order of ranking . a candidate bubble only meeting ( a )
is assigned the lowest ranking ( class c ) because the gas with expanding velocity is not obvious .
lccccrr a & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & 13 & 35.2% + b1 & & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & & 6 & 16.2% + b2 & @xmath33 & & @xmath33 & & 4 & 10.8% + b3 & @xmath33 & @xmath33 & & & 4 & 10.8% + b4 & & & @xmath33 & & 4 & 10.8% + c & @xmath33 & & & & 6 & 16.2% + following the above procedures we found 37 bubbles in the entire 100 deg@xmath1 area of taurus molecular cloud .
each bubble is referred as a `` taurus molecular bubble '' ( tmb ) .
the positions and classifications are listed in table [ bubble ] .
the numbers and percentage of each class are illustrated in table [ bubbleclass ] .
the @xmath63co integrated intensity maps , p - v diagrams , gaussian fitting profiles and channel maps for the bubbles are presented in fig .
[ bubble_fig1 . ] - fig .
[ bubble_fig37 . ] .
if the morphology of a contour map is a closed ring , we then considered it to be an expanding bubble .
if the ring on the contour map is incomplete , we then called it a broken bubble .
there are 3 expanding bubbles ( tmb_07 , tmb_10 and tmb_24 ) and 34 broken bubbles among all the bubbles in taurus . to examine the impact of bubbles on the host cloud we calculated the mass , momentum , kinetic energy , dynamical timescale and energy deposition rate of the bubbles .
assuming the @xmath3co(1 - 0 ) emission of the bubble is optically thin , the total column density is derived as follows : @xmath64 where @xmath39 , @xmath40 erg s , @xmath41 and @xmath65 .
the excitation temperature , @xmath66 is assumed to be 25 k. @xmath43 is the observed source antenna temperature with proper correction for antenna efficiency .
the optical depth correction factor , @xmath67 , is estimated from the following formulae @xcite .
@xmath68 dv } , \label{equ : ftau}\ ] ] where @xmath69 is the opacity of the @xmath3co transition . assuming equal excitation temperatures for @xmath3co and @xmath2co
, we can get @xmath70 where @xmath71 and @xmath72 are the brightness temperature of @xmath2co and @xmath3co , respectively .
@xmath73 is the opacity of the @xmath2co transition . assuming the @xmath2co emission from the bubbles is optically thick ( @xmath74 )
, the opacity of @xmath3co can be obtained from @xmath75 with the column density and area we can obtain the bubble mass . using the bubble mass and expansion velocity we can then get the momentum and kinetic energy of the bubble using @xmath76 and @xmath77 , respectively .
the kinetic timescale of bubble can be calculated as @xmath78 , where @xmath79 is the radius and @xmath80 is the expansion velocity of the bubble .
the bubble energy injection rate , @xmath81 , can be estimated as @xmath82 .
the physical parameters of all bubbles are listed in table [ bubble ] .
the momentum and kinetic energy are lower limits mainly because of the underestimate of the minimum expansion velocity .
the total mass , momentum , energy and energy injection rate of all detected bubbles in taurus molecular cloud are about @xmath83 , @xmath84 , @xmath85 erg and @xmath86 , respectively .
cccccccrrrccr tmb_01 & 04 12 08 & 24 53 33 & a & n & 0.98 & 1.3 & 25 & 31 & 0.39 & 0.8 & 0.17 & 15.5 + tmb_02 & 04 14 28 & 27 45 53 & b1 & y & 0.60 & 1.3 & 6 & 7 & 0.09 & 0.5 & 0.06 & 3.5 + tmb_03 & 04 16 20 & 28 28 53 & a & y & 0.76 & 1.8 & 10 & 18 & 0.33 & 0.4 & 0.25 & 9.0 + tmb_04 & 04 19 05 & 27 33 33 & a & y & 0.62 & 1.3 & 7 & 9 & 0.12 & 0.5 & 0.08 & 4.5 + tmb_05 & 04 21 12 & 26 55 33 & b3 & y & 0.56 & 1.8 & 4 & 8 & 0.14 & 0.3 & 0.14 & 4.0 + tmb_06 & 04 25 17 & 25 32 13 & b1 & n & 0.77 & 1.3 & 10 & 12 & 0.16 & 0.6 & 0.08 & 6.0 + tmb_07 & 04 25 29 & 26 10 13 & b1 & n & 1.12 & 2.3 & 102 & 234 & 5.31 & 0.5 & 3.51 & 117.0 + tmb_08 & 04 27 07 & 24 20 13 & a & n & 0.70 & 2.3 & 18 & 42 & 0.95 & 0.3 & 1.00 & 21.0 + tmb_09 & 04 27 31 & 26 16 53 & b4 & n & 0.49 & 1.0 & 4 & 4 & 0.04 & 0.5 & 0.03 & 2.0 + tmb_10 & 04 28 52 & 24 14 33 & a & y & 1.58 & 1.5 & 213 & 325 & 4.92 & 1.0 & 1.53 & 162.5 + tmb_11 & 04 29 32 & 26 32 33 & a & y & 0.84 & 2.0 & 41 & 83 & 1.68 & 0.4 & 1.31 & 41.5 + tmb_12 & 04 29 44 & 26 32 53 & b4 & y & 0.70 & 2.5 & 23 & 58 & 1.47 & 0.3 & 1.72 & 29.0 + tmb_13 & 04 30 31 & 24 26 13 & a & y & 0.73 & 2.3 & 18 & 41 & 0.93 & 0.3 & 0.94 & 20.5 + tmb_14 & 04 31 14 & 29 25 53 & b2 & y & 0.84 & 2.0 & 10 & 20 & 0.40 & 0.4 & 0.31 & 10.0 + tmb_15 & 04 31 30 & 24 14 33 & a & y & 0.84 & 1.3 & 34 & 43 & 0.54 & 0.6 & 0.27 & 21.5 + tmb_16 & 04 31 32 & 24 09 53 & b3 & n & 0.70 & 1.8 & 22 & 39 & 0.69 & 0.4 & 0.57 & 19.5 + tmb_17 & 04 31 35 & 23 35 13 & b4 & n & 0.42 & 1.0 & 2 & 2 & 0.02 & 0.4 & 0.02 & 1.0 + tmb_18 & 04 31 50 & 24 22 13 & c & n & 0.56 & 2.0 & 14 & 29 & 0.59 & 0.3 & 0.69 & 14.5 + tmb_19 & 04 31 59 & 25 43 13 & b1 & y & 0.70 & 2.0 & 16 & 32 & 0.64 & 0.3 & 0.60 & 16.0 + tmb_20 & 04 32 03 & 25 36 53 & b2 & n & 0.42 & 1.3 & 4 & 5 & 0.07 & 0.3 & 0.07 & 2.5 + tmb_21 & 04 32 37 & 29 29 13 & a & n & 0.62 & 2.3 & 6 & 14 & 0.31 & 0.3 & 0.37 & 7.0 + tmb_22 & 04 32 39 & 24 46 13 & a & y & 1.06 & 1.3 & 28 & 36 & 0.45 & 0.8 & 0.17 & 18.0 + tmb_23 & 04 33 10 & 26 08 53 & b4 & n & 0.28 & 1.3 & 2 & 2 & 0.03 & 0.2 & 0.04 & 1.0 + tmb_24 & 04 33 13 & 25 24 53 & c & n & 0.49 & 1.3 & 5 & 7 & 0.09 & 0.4 & 0.07 & 3.5 + tmb_25 & 04 33 34 & 24 20 53 & a & y & 0.28 & 3.0 & 5 & 15 & 0.46 & 0.1 & 1.61 & 7.5 + tmb_26 & 04 34 47 & 29 37 13 & b3 & n & 0.46 & 2.3 & 3 & 6 & 0.14 & 0.2 & 0.23 & 3.0 + tmb_27 & 04 36 02 & 28 23 13 & c & y & 1.40 & 2.5 & 64 & 161 & 4.08 & 0.5 & 2.39 & 80.5 + tmb_28 & 04 36 23 & 25 36 33 & b2 & y & 1.40 & 3.3 & 386 & 1275 & 41.84 & 0.4 & 31.93 & 637.5 + tmb_29 & 04
37 04 & 25 46 33 & c & y & 0.84 & 1.5 & 20 & 30 & 0.46 & 0.5 & 0.27 & 15.0 + tmb_30 & 04 38 11 & 26 05 53 & b3 & y & 1.90 & 1.8 & 340 & 604 & 10.68 & 1.0 & 3.23 & 302.0 + tmb_31 & 04 39 11 & 29 05 13 & b2 & n & 1.26 & 1.5 & 74 & 113 & 1.71 & 0.8 & 0.67 & 56.5 + tmb_32 & 04 39 48 & 28 35 33 & c & n & 0.70 & 2.0 & 7 & 14 & 0.27 & 0.3 & 0.26 & 7.0 + tmb_33 & 04 41 10 & 25 31 13 & c & n & 0.70 & 1.0 & 10 & 10 & 0.10 & 0.7 & 0.05 & 5.0 + tmb_34 & 04 44 20 & 28 36 53 & b1 & n & 1.26 & 2.8 & 143 & 399 & 11.08 & 0.4 & 7.95 & 199.5 + tmb_35 & 04 46 12 & 25 07 33 & a & n & 0.62 & 1.5 & 8 & 13 & 0.19 & 0.4 & 0.15 & 6.5 + tmb_36 & 04 46 43 & 24 59 13 & b1 & y & 0.56 & 1.8 & 12 & 21 & 0.38 & 0.3 & 0.39 & 10.5 + tmb_37 & 04 48 12 & 24 50 33 & a & n & 0.63 & 2.3 & 8 & 18 & 0.41 & 0.3 & 0.48 & 9.0 + the distribution of radius , mass , energy and dynamical timescale of bubbles are shown in fig .
[ bubble - histogram ] .
the radius of bubbles is in the range 0.28 - 1.9 pc .
78% of the bubbles are smaller than 1 pc .
the mass of 65% of the bubbles is between @xmath87 and @xmath88 . the bubbles with mass lower than @xmath87 and higher than @xmath88 account for 16% and 19% , respectively .
the highest bubble mass is @xmath89 .
the energy of 60% of bubbles is in the range @xmath90 - @xmath91 erg . the bubbles with energy lower than @xmath90 erg and higher than @xmath91 erg account for 16% and 24% , respectively .
the dynamical timescales of bubbles are between @xmath92 yr and @xmath93 yr . almost 95% of bubbles are younger than @xmath93 yr . compared to the outflows , the bubbles have about * 110 * times larger mass and * 24 * times higher energy .
the extents of bubbles are larger than outflows , which can be seen from fig .
[ yso - distribute ] .
the dynamical timescales of bubbles are longer than that of outflows .
among the 55 outflows we found that bipolar , monopolar redshifted and monopolar blueshifted outflows account for 45% , 44% and 11% , respectively . there are more red lobes than blue ones , which can be seen from the histograms in fig .
[ outflow - histogram ] .
the occurrence of more red lobes may result from the fact that taurus is thin @xcite .
red lobes tend to be smaller and younger .
the total mass and energy of red lobes is similar to blue lobes on average , which can be seen from the upper right panel and lower left panel of fig .
[ outflow - histogram ] .
the outflows are driven by four types of ysos . from table
[ outflownumyso ] we can see class i , flat , class ii and class iii account for 36.4% , 18.2% , 27.3% and 12.7% of all the driving sources , respectively .
[ yso - distribute ] shows the distribution of different classes of ysos driving outflows ( hereafter outflow - driving yso ) and ysos inside the bubbles ( hereafter bubble - driving yso ) .
the rough dividing line shows that there are more outflow - driving ysos in class i , flat and class ii while few outflow - driving ysos in class iii , which indicates that outflows are more likely appear in the earlier stage ( class i ) than in the later phase ( class iii ) of star formation .
there are more bubble - driving ysos of class ii and class iii while there are few bubble - driving ysos of class i and flat , implying that the bubble structures are more likely to occur in the later stage of star formation . from the size of the symbols we can see that the larger outflows and bubbles are , the higher energy they have . with the complete sample of outflows and bubbles we can estimate the overall impact of dynamical structures on the taurus molecular cloud .
we investigated whether the outflows and bubbles have enough energy to potentially unbind the entire taurus molecular cloud or drive the turbulence in the cloud . using a total mass of @xmath94 @xcite and an effective radius of 13.8 pc @xcite for the 100 deg@xmath1 region of taurus ,
we calculated the magnitude of the gravitational binding energy @xmath95 to be @xmath9 * erg*. the total kinetic energy of outflows from the 44 deg@xmath1 region of taurus is @xmath57 erg , much less than the gravitational binding energy . given that we searched for outflows around ysos only in the spitzer 44 deg@xmath1 survey region not the overall area of taurus , we may well have missed some outflows .
most of the gas of taurus is centered on the spitzer 44 deg@xmath1 survey region , which can be seen from fig . 2 of @xcite .
there are not many ysos outside the spitzer coverage in taurus and those ysos are generally clustered , which can be seen from figure 1 of @xcite .
so there should be few outflows outside the spitzer coverage in taurus and the outflows we found around ysos in the 44 deg@xmath1 area account for the majority of outflows in taurus .
similarly , the total kinetic energy of the detected bubbles in the 100 deg@xmath1 taurus region is @xmath96 erg , which also can not balance the gravitational potential energy of the entire cloud . *
the turbulent energy of the taurus molecular cloud is given approximately by * @xmath97 * where @xmath98 is the three dimensional turbulent velocity dispersion , which can be calculated by * @xmath99 * here @xmath100 = 2 km s@xmath101 is the one dimensional fwhm velocity dispersion based on typical @xmath102co spectra in taurus @xcite .
then we get @xmath103 km s@xmath101 .
the total mass of the 100 deg@xmath104 region of taurus is @xmath105 @xcite . using eq .
( [ equ : energyturb ] ) we obtain the turbulent energy of the taurus to be @xmath106 erg . *
the energy of all detected outflows ( * @xmath107 erg * ) is about two orders of magnitude less than the turbulent energy of the cloud .
the lower limit of the total energy of the bubbles ( @xmath96 erg ) is 29% of the turbulent energy .
* we conclude that the total energy of outflows and bubbles can not balance the turbulence in taurus .
* we also estimated the total outflow energy rate ( outflow luminosity , @xmath108 ) and the total bubble energy rate ( bubble luminosity , @xmath109 ) with the energy rate needed to maintain the turbulence ( turbulent energy dissipation , @xmath110 ) . *
the luminosity of outflows is @xmath111 erg s@xmath101 after inclination and blending correction .
summing up the luminosity in table [ outflowparameters ] we get the energy injection rate of bubbles to be @xmath112 erg s@xmath101 .
* * the turbulent dissipation rate can be calculated as * @xmath113 * where @xmath114 is the turbulent dissipation time .
we estimate the turbulent dissipation time through two methods based on numerical simulations .
* * first , the turbulent dissipation time of the cloud is given by @xcite * @xmath115 * where @xmath116 pc is the cloud diameter and @xmath117 is the one dimensional turbulent velocity dispersion along the line of sight , * @xmath118 * here @xmath100 = 2 km s@xmath101 is the same as that in [ turbulentenergy ] .
then we get @xmath119 km s@xmath8 . combining eq .
( [ equ : t_diss_mckee ] ) and eq .
( [ equ : sigma_1d ] ) we obtain the turbulent dissipation time , @xmath120 yr , which is about 6 times larger than the result ( @xmath121 yr ) in @xcite .
then using eq .
( [ equ : l_turb ] ) we get the turbulent dissipation rate to be @xmath122 erg s@xmath101 , which is 51% of the luminosity of outflows and only 10% of the energy injection rate of bubbles .
* * second , we follow @xcite to calculate the dissipation time of the cloud by * @xmath123 * where @xmath124 is the free - fall timescale , @xmath125 is the mach number of the turbulence , and @xmath126 is the ratio of the driving length to the jean s length of the cloud , * @xmath127 * using our extensive data sets we get @xmath128 0.53 pc , which is the average size of outflows and bubbles we found in taurus . the jean s length is defined as * @xmath129 * where @xmath130 is the sound speed @xcite . for an ideal gas * @xmath131 * where @xmath132 is the boltzmann s constant , @xmath133 = 10
k is the temperature of the taurus molecular cloud , and @xmath134 = 2.72 is the mean molecular weight @xcite .
then we get the sound speed , @xmath135 = 0.3 km @xmath136 .
@xmath137 is the representative volume density of the region where dissipation takes place .
we estimate the volume density to be @xmath138 1500 @xmath139 . using eq .
( [ equ : lambda_j ] ) we obtain the jean s length of the region , @xmath140 pc , which is about 4 times larger than that ( @xmath141 pc ) in perseus @xcite . and then using eq .
( [ equ : kappa ] ) we obtain @xmath142 , which is different from the assumption ( @xmath143 1 ) by @xcite and @xcite . * * the mach number of the turbulence can be calculated by @xcite * @xmath144 * using eq .
( [ equ : sigma3d ] ) , eq .
( [ equ : c_s ] ) and eq .
( [ equ : m_rms ] ) we get the mach number , @xmath125 = 5 , which is different from the assumption ( @xmath145 10 ) by @xcite and @xcite . * * the free - fall timescale of the cloud , * @xmath146 * where * @xmath147 * is the average volume density of the cloud .
then we get the free - fall timescale , @xmath148 yr . * * using the formulas from eq .
( [ equ : t_diss ] ) to eq .
( [ equ : rho_cloud ] ) we obtain the turbulent dissipation time to be @xmath149 yr
. then we get the turbulent dissipation rate to be @xmath150 erg s@xmath101 , which is about 2.4 times larger than the luminosity of outflows but 48% of the energy injection rate of bubbles .
the turbulent dissipation rate we obtained is close to that ( @xmath151 erg s@xmath101 ) of @xcite . in table
[ dissipationrate ] we list the parameters related to the dissipation rate we get from the above two methods and compare them with the results of @xcite . * lcccc method & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 & @xmath110 + & & & ( @xmath93 yr ) & ( @xmath155 erg s@xmath8 ) + mo07 & - & - & @xmath156 & @xmath157 + ml99 & 0.64 & 5 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 + na12 & 1 & 10 & @xmath160 & @xmath161 + * both methods invoke numerical simulations to calibrate the numerical factors in addition to essentially dimensional arguments .
the main difference of the two methods is the scale of the region where dissipation takes place . @xcite adopted the dimension of the entire cloud , while when we use the method given by @xcite the scale is the average size of outflows and bubbles .
none of the simulations so far implements the physics ( excitation , radiative transfer , etc . ) necessary for actually modeling dissipation .
thus we should treat the calculations above with caution and take them as dimensional and order - of magnitude estimates . *
* comparing the energy injection rate of outflows and bubble with the turbulent dissipation rate , we conclude that in the current episode of star formation in taurus , both outflows and bubbles can sustain the currently observed turbulence in taurus .
* protostellar winds will inject energy into the cloud and may help sustain turbulence @xcite .
the winds can clear the gas surrounding the young star and form a bubble structure @xcite . to assess whether the winds can drive bubbles in taurus we compared the wind energy injection rate into the cloud ( @xmath162 ) with the total energy injection rate from bubbles of the cloud .
following @xcite , we estimated the wind energy injection rate using equation 3.7 from @xcite : @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the wind velocity , which is generally assumed to be close to the star escape velocity .
for the low- and intermediate - mass stars the escape velocity is about @xmath165 km s@xmath8 @xcite .
similar to @xcite we assumed @xmath166 km s@xmath8 .
the total mass loss rate from the protostellar winds is given by @xmath167 , which can be estimated by the sum of the wind mass loss rate for each bubble ( @xmath168 ) .
the wind mass loss rate required to produce the bubbles is roughly estimated by equation ( 2 ) from @xcite : @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the total momentum of bubbles .
the wind velocity , @xmath164 , is the same as that in eq .
( [ equ : windenergyinjection ] ) .
@xmath171 is the wind timescale , which is assumed @xmath172 myr @xcite .
( [ equ : windmassloss ] ) we obtained the wind mass loss rates of each bubble ( @xmath168 ) , which are listed in table [ bubble ] .
summing @xmath168 of all bubbles we find @xmath167 to be @xmath173 m@xmath174 yr@xmath8 . using eq .
( [ equ : windenergyinjection ] ) we obtained the wind energy injection rate ( @xmath162 ) to be @xmath175 * * erg s**@xmath101 , 31% of the total energy injection rate from bubbles in taurus , which is comparable to the turbulent dissipation rate in taurus .
therefore , the protostellar winds can drive bubbles to sustain turbulence in taurus .
* the origin of turbulence in the molecular cloud has been intensely debated over the past three decades ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
@xcite suggests that for a large fraction of clouds the turbulent driving is external .
numerical simulations shows that the external sources of turbulence are likely to be large - scale hi streams @xcite , shocks @xcite , alfv@xmath176n waves @xcite , supernovae explosion and galactic differential rotation @xcite .
it is unclear which one is the source of turbulence in taurus . *
we have studied the dynamic structures including outflows and bubbles within the taurus molecular cloud using the 100 deg@xmath1 fcrao large - scale @xmath2co(1 - 0 ) and @xmath3co(1 - 0 ) maps and the spitzer protostellar catalog . the high sensitivity and large spatial dynamic range of the maps provide us an excellent opportunity to undertake an unbiased search for outflows and bubbles in this region .
we also analyzed the energy injection of these dynamic structures into the entire cloud .
our conclusions regarding the dynamic structures in taurus and their properties are as follows .
we identified 55 outflows around the spitzer ysos in the main 44 deg@xmath1 area of taurus . in total ,
31 of the detected outflows were previously unknown , increasing the number of outflows by a factor of 1.3 .
we classified the outflows into 5 categories according to the morphology of contour maps and p - v diagrams .
the classifications indicate the confidence level of the outflows .
76.3% of the outflows are in the `` most probable '' category in our study .
most of the outflows are driven by class i , flat and class ii ysos while few outflows were found around class iii ysos , which indicates that the outflow activity likely occurred in the earlier stage rather than the late phase of the star formation .
more bipolar and monopolar redshifted outflows were identified while few monopolar blueshifted ones were detected in our study .
we detected 37 bubbles in the 100 deg@xmath1 region of taurus .
all the bubbles were previously unknown .
the bubbles were identified by the integrated intensity maps , p - v diagrams , gaussian fitting profiles and channel maps .
the gravitational binding energy of the taurus molecular cloud is @xmath9 * erg*. the total kinetic energy of outflows and bubbles in taurus are @xmath4 erg and @xmath5 erg , respectively .
neither outflows nor bubbles can balance the overall gravitational binding energy of taurus . \7 . the turbulent energy of the taurus molecular cloud is @xmath177 erg . the energy of all detected outflows and bubbles can not have generated the observed turbulence in taurus .
the rate of turbulent dissipation in taurus is * between @xmath178 to @xmath179 erg s@xmath8*. the energy injection rates of outflows and bubbles are @xmath180 erg s@xmath8 and @xmath7 erg s@xmath8 , respectively . * both outflows and bubbles can sustain the turbulence in taurus at the current epoch . *
the stellar winds can drive bubbles to sustain turbulence in the taurus molecular cloud .
[ summary ]
we are grateful to dr .
yue , dr . z.y .
zhang , dr .
t. liu , dr .
x.y . gao and dr .
z.y . ren for their kind and valuable advice and support .
we would like to thank the anonymous referee for the careful inspection of the manuscript and constructive comments particularly the important suggestions to examine the turbulent dissipation issue to improve the quality of this study .
we also thank prof .
w. butler burton for help in the review process .
this work is partly supported by the china ministry of science and technology under state key development program for basic research ( 2012cb821802 ) , and the national natural science foundation of china ( 11373038 , 11373045 ) , the hundred talents program of the chinese academy of sciences and the young researcher grant of national astronomical observatories , chinese academy of sciences .
to calculate molecular outflow parameters we need first to obtain the column density first . a simple solution of the equation of radiative transfer is @xmath181(1-e^{-\tau_\nu } ) , \label{equ : radiativetransfer}\ ] ] where @xmath43 is the source temperature , @xmath66 is the excitation temperature and @xmath182 is the background temperature , and @xmath183 is the frequency of the transition . the modified planck function @xmath184 is defined as @xmath185 where @xmath186 is boltzmann s constant and @xmath187 is planck s constant .
the definition of optical depth in terms of upper level column density is expressed as @xcite @xmath188 assuming @xmath189 @xmath190 1 , @xmath191 @xmath190 @xmath66 and @xmath182 @xmath190 @xmath66 , we get the column density of the rotational upper level of the transition in the outflow by combining eq .
( [ equ : radiativetransfer ] ) with eq .
( [ equ : opticaldepth ] ) .
@xmath192 where @xmath43 is the observed source antenna temperature with proper correction for antenna efficiency , @xmath193 is the speed of light , and @xmath194 is the spontaneous transition rate from the upper level(@xmath195 ) to the lower level(@xmath184 ) , which can be expressed as @xmath196 where @xmath197 is the permanent electric dipole moment of a molecule and @xmath184 = 0 .
+ the total column density of the outflow is @xmath198 where @xmath199 is the fraction of the @xmath36 in the upper level of the transition . under local thermal equilibrium(lte ) conditions , @xmath200 is given by @xmath201 where the statistical weight of the upper level @xmath202 , the lte partition function ( for @xmath203 @xmath204 @xmath205 ) @xmath206 and the rotational constant @xmath207 $ ] for the @xmath208 transition @xcite .
then we can derive the total column density of outflow from eq .
( [ equ : columndensityupperlevel ] ) , eq .
( [ equ : aul ] ) , eq .
( [ equ : columndensitytotal ] ) and eq .
( [ equ : correctionfactor ] ) , @xmath209 if there is a high velocity wing in @xmath36 but not in @xmath37 profile , we assume @xmath36 is optically thin
. then we can calculate the column density of outflow from eq .
( [ equ : derivedtotalcolumndensity ] ) .
if there is high velocity wing both in @xmath36 and @xmath37 profile , we can correct the optical depth of @xmath36 using the following equation @xmath210 here @xmath211 and @xmath212 are the antenna temperatures of @xmath213 and @xmath214 ( with proper correction for antenna efficiency ) , respectively . @xmath73 and @xmath69 are the optical depths of @xmath36 and @xmath37 , respectively .
we assume the abundance ratio of @xmath36 to @xmath37 is 65 @xcite .
the correction factor for opacity is defined as @xmath215 then we get the corrected total column density of outflow as @xmath216 after obtaining the column density we can calculate other parameters of outflow .
the mass of outflow can be calculated from @xmath217\mu_{\rm g}m({\rm h})s , \label{equ : outflowmass}\ ] ] where @xmath218=2.72 is the mean molecular weight @xcite , @xmath219=@xmath220 g is the mass of a hydrogen atom , and @xmath221/[\rm{co}]$ ] is assumed to be @xmath222 , and @xmath223 is the area of the outflow .
+ the momentum ( @xmath224 ) and energy ( @xmath225 ) of the outflow can be calculated from @xmath226 @xmath227 where @xmath228 is the average velocity of the outflow relative to the cloud systemic velocity and @xmath229 is obtained from eq.([equ : outflowmass ] ) .
+ the dynamical timescale @xmath47 can be estimated from @xmath230 where @xmath231 is the typical linear scale of the outflow lobe .
the outflow luminosity , @xmath108 , can be estimated by dividing the kinetic energy by the dynamical timescale .
it can be expressed as @xmath232 | we have identified outflows and bubbles in the taurus molecular cloud based on the @xmath0 deg@xmath1 five college radio astronomy observatory @xmath2co(1 - 0 ) and @xmath3co(1 - 0 ) maps and the spitzer young stellar object catalogs . in the main 44 deg@xmath1 area of taurus we found 55 outflows , of which 31 were previously unknown .
we also found 37 bubbles in the entire 100 deg@xmath1 area of taurus , all of which had not been found before .
the total kinetic energy of the identified outflows is estimated to be @xmath4 erg , which is * 1% * of the cloud turbulent energy .
the total kinetic energy of the detected bubbles is estimated to be @xmath5 erg , which is 29% of the turbulent energy of taurus .
the energy injection rate from outflows is @xmath6 , * 0.4 - 2 times * the dissipation rate of the cloud turbulence .
the energy injection rate from bubbles is @xmath7 erg s@xmath8 , * 2 - 10 times * the turbulent dissipation rate of the cloud .
the gravitational binding energy of the cloud is @xmath9 * erg * , * 385 * and 16 times the energy of outflows and bubbles , respectively .
we conclude that neither outflows nor bubbles can * provide enough energy to balance the overall gravitational binding energy and the turbulent energy of taurus .
however , * in the current epoch , stellar feedback is sufficient to maintain the observed turbulence in taurus .
= 5000 = 1000 |
superconducting mgb@xmath1 exhibits a number of rather peculiar properties , originating from the involvement of two sets of bands of different anisotropy and different coupling to the most relevant phonon mode @xcite . among them
are pronounced deviations of the upper critical field , @xmath0 , from predictions of the widely used anisotropic ginzburg - landau theory ( aglt ) .
apart from two - band superconductivity , mgb@xmath1 provides a link between low and high @xmath8 superconductors on a phenomenological level , particularly concerning vortex physics . in both high and low @xmath8 superconductors , for example , a phase transition of vortex matter out of a quasi - ordered `` bragg glass ''
have been identified , with rather different positions in the @xmath5-@xmath6 plane .
studying the intermediate mgb@xmath1 may help establishing a `` universal vortex matter phase diagram '' . here
, we present a torque magnetometry study of the anisotropic upper critical field , equilibrium magnetization , and the vortex matter phase diagram of single crystalline mgb@xmath1 @xcite
. we will show direct evidence of a temperature dependence of the @xmath0 anisotropy , discuss strong indications of a difference between the anisotropies of the penetration depth and @xmath0 , and present the @xmath5-@xmath6 phase diagram for @xmath7 .
single crystals were grown with a cubic anvil high pressure technique , described in this issue @xcite .
three crystals were used in this study , labeled a , b , and c. sharp transitions to the superconducting state indicate a high quality of the crystals .
an @xmath9 curve of crystal b with @xmath10 can be found in ref.@xcite .
the torque @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the magnetic moment of the sample , was recorded as a function of the angle @xmath13 between the applied field @xmath14 and the @xmath15axis of the crystal in various fixed fields @xcite . for measurements close to @xmath8 , in fields up to @xmath16 , a non - commercial magnetometer with very high sensitivity
was used @xcite . for part of these measurements ,
a vortex - shaking process was employed to speed up the relaxation of the vortex lattice @xcite .
crystal a was measured in this system .
crystals b and c were measured in a wider range of temperatures down to @xmath17 , in a quantum design ppms with torque option and a maximum field of @xmath18 . for crystals b and c , @xmath19 measurements at fixed angles were performed in addition to @xmath20 measurements in fixed @xmath5 .
early measurements on polycrystalline or thin film mgb@xmath1 samples with various methods and single crystals by electrical transport yielded values of the anisotropy parameter of the upper critical field @xmath21 in a wide range of values of @xmath22 @xcite .
more recently , several papers reported a temperature dependence of the @xmath0 anisotropy , ranging between about @xmath23 at @xmath24 and @xmath25 close to @xmath8 @xcite . in this section ,
we present direct evidence of a temperature dependence of the @xmath0 anisotropy @xmath2 and discuss details of it s behaviour , comparing the torque data with numerical calculations @xcite .
four angular torque dependences are shown in fig.[mgb2hc2raw ] .
panels a ) and b ) correspond to measurements at @xmath26 .
for fields nearly parallel to the @xmath27-axis , both curves are flat , apart from a small background visible in panel b ) .
only when @xmath5 is nearly parallel to the @xmath28plane there is an appreciable torque signal . the curve can be interpreted in a straight - forward way : for @xmath5 parallel to the @xmath15axis the sample is in the normal state , while for @xmath5 parallel to the @xmath28plane it is in the superconducting state .
the crossover angle @xmath29 between the normal and the superconducting state is the angle for which the fixed applied field is the upper critical field . from the existence of both superconducting and normal angular regions
follows immediately that @xmath30 and @xmath31 . in panel c ) , on the other hand , the crystal is seen to be in the superconducting state for all values of the angle @xmath13 , and therefore @xmath32 .
finally , the data in panel d ) show only a small background contribution @xmath33 form and angular regime of the deviation from a straight line are incompatible with a superconducting signal .
therefore , the crystal is here in the normal state for any @xmath13 , and we have @xmath34 . from figure [ mgb2hc2raw ] we therefore have two limitations for the upper critical field anisotropy , hereafter called @xmath2 , without any detailed @xmath0 criterion , and without any model fits : @xmath35 these relations show that _ the upper critical field anisotropy @xmath2 of mgb@xmath1 can not be temperature independent_. as an immediate implication , the _ anisotropic ginzburg - landau theory _ ( aglt ) in it s standard form _ does not hold for mgb@xmath1_. the deviation is strong , within a change of temperature of about @xmath36 , @xmath2 changes , _ at least _
, by a fifth of it s value .
although it is clear that aglt with it s effective mass anisotropy model can not describe the data measured at _ different _ temperatures consistently , the detail analysis of the @xmath13 dependence of @xmath0 we used is based on aglt .
we will show that as long as we stay at a _ fixed _ temperature , aglt is able to describe @xmath37 remarkably well @xcite .
although the location of @xmath29 , for example in fig .
[ mgb2hc2raw]a ) , seems clear at first sight , this clarity disappears , when examining the transition region in a scale necessary for the precise determination of @xmath29 ( see fig . 1 in ref .
@xcite ) . for an strict analysis ,
it is necessary to take into account that the transtion at @xmath0 is rounded off by fluctuations . in sufficiently high fields , @xmath38 , the so - called `` lowest landau level '' ( lll ) approximation
was used successfully to describe the effects of fluctuations around @xmath0 @xcite . in the case of the cuprates ,
the value of @xmath39 , and thus of the regime of applicability of the lll approximation , is a controversial issue ( see , e.g. , ref.@xcite for a theoretical discussion of the limits of the lll approximation ) .
however , in the case of mgb@xmath1 , even using the theoretical criterion of ref .
@xcite , which led to the high estimation @xmath40 in the case of yba@xmath1cu@xmath41o@xmath42 , we obtain an upper limit of @xmath43 .
we therefore used a lll scaling analysis for the determination of @xmath44 or @xmath37 @xcite . from the resulting @xmath37 curve , the anisotropy parameter @xmath2
is then extracted by an analysis with aglt , which predicts the angular dependence of the upper critical field to be @xcite @xmath45 we note that in the rescaling of the torque according to the lll fluctuations theory , the target parameter @xmath2 is used , which is obtained only later with eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) . therefore , scaling analysis and determination of @xmath2 with eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) had to be performed iteratively in order to self consistently find @xmath2 .
however , the @xmath44 and @xmath37 points obtained with the scaling analysis depend not very strongly on the value of @xmath2 used in the scaling and the procedure converges rather fast .
figure [ hc2crystc ] shows the angular dependence of @xmath0 of crystal b and c. the curves shown in the figure are fits of eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) to the data , showing that the angular dependence of @xmath0 is well described by aglt at both temperatures . on the other hand , the anisotropy parameter @xmath2 needed to describe the data with eq.([hc2_theta ] )
is temperature dependent , as is best seen in the inset .
dependence of crystals b and c , at @xmath46 and @xmath47 . shown
are results obtained both from @xmath20 measurements in fixed @xmath5 [ b at @xmath26 ( @xmath48 ) and at @xmath47 ( @xmath49 ) , c at @xmath26 ( @xmath50 ) and at @xmath47 ( @xmath51 ) ] and from @xmath19 measurements at fixed @xmath13 [ b at @xmath26 ( @xmath52 ) ] .
inset : calculated curves from the main panel , scaled to the fitted value of @xmath53 . ] vs.temperature @xmath6 .
open symbols correspond to @xmath54 , full symbols to @xmath55 , from fits of eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) to the @xmath37 data .
up triangles are from measurements on sample a ( with @xmath29 determined with a simple `` straight line crossing '' criterion ) and squares are from measurements on sample b , using a fluctuation analysis ( see text ) .
full lines are theoretical calculated curves @xcite .
b ) temperature dependence of the upper critical field anisotropy @xmath21 , determined from fits of eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) to @xmath37 .
the full line is again from the theoretical calculation of ref .
@xcite . ]
the irreversible properties of the two crystals ( b and c ) are different in a pronounced way ( see secs .
[ lockin ] and [ pesec ] ) , showing that they have a rather different defect structure .
the good agreement both in value and angular dependence of @xmath0 of crystals b and c that is observable in fig .
[ hc2crystc ] indicates that such differences in the defect structure do not influence the upper critical field much , at least in the region between @xmath46 and @xmath47 , and therefore can not influence our conclusion of a @xmath6 dependent @xmath0 anisotropy .
small , but systematic , deviations from the angular dependence of @xmath0 according to eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) were observed only at temperatures close to @xmath8 .
it may indicate that we are approaching @xmath39 in this region and the values of @xmath44 and @xmath37 obtained from the lll scaling analysis ( see above ) start to deviate from the mean field values .
the good general approximation of @xmath37 by eq.([hc2_theta ] ) is in agreement with recent calculations @xcite .
however , the calculations predict small deviations at low temperatures @xcite , rather than close to @xmath8 .
our experimental limitation of fields up to @xmath56 may prevent the observation of deviations from eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) at low temperatures . the upper critical fields parallel and perpendicular to the layers obtained with the scaling analysis and eq . ( [ hc2_theta ] ) are shown in fig . [ hc2mgb2sumup]a ) .
results obtained for two crystals measured in two magnetometers are depicted as different symbols .
the @xmath57dependence of @xmath53 is in agreement with ( isotropic ) calculations by helfand _
@xcite , with @xmath58 . on the other hand
, @xmath59 exhibits a slight positive curvature near @xmath8 .
these features are common to highly anisotropic ( layered ) superconductors .
although mgb@xmath1 as a whole is rather isotropic , superconductivity is dominant on the quasi-2d bands , which may well account for the different @xmath6 dependence of @xmath53 and @xmath60
. this may also be the origin of the positive curvature of @xmath0 observed in other measurements of bulk , thin film and single crystal mgb@xmath1 @xcite . due to the lack of low @xmath6 data and the @xmath61 dependence , only an estimation @xmath62 can be given .
the anisotropy data [ fig .
[ hc2mgb2sumup]b ) ] show that @xmath2 _ systematically _ _ decreases _ with increasing temperature , from @xmath63 at @xmath64 to @xmath65 at @xmath66 . from the experimental data shown in fig .
[ hc2mgb2sumup ] we estimate @xmath67 , while at zero temperature , @xmath2 may become as large as @xmath68 .
comparing our data with the data reported by other authors @xcite , we note that electrical transport measurements @xcite yield too high values of @xmath53 @xcite .
all bulk measurements ( torque @xcite , magnetization @xcite , thermal conductivity @xcite , and specific heat @xcite ) agree well on the @xmath69 dependence and value . concerning @xmath59 , and consequently @xmath61 , however , reported values differ from each other .
exchanging the samples between different groups could help clarifying , whether the discrepancies of @xmath59 values are mainly due to sample differences or due to differences in the experimental methods employed .
very recently , @xmath59 , @xmath69 , and @xmath61 , have been calculated for mgb@xmath1 @xcite .
the fermi surface was modeled as consisting of two separate sheets , approximated as simple spheroids , but with average characteristics taken from first principles calculations .
the result of these calculations are compared with our experimental data in fig.[hc2mgb2sumup ] .
very good agreement is seen for the upper critical field perpendicular to the layers ( @xmath70 ) .
qualitatively , calculations and experiment also agree well for the upper critical field parallel to the layers ( @xmath71 ) .
this shows that the essential source of the deviations of the upper critical field from aglt predictions is captured with a simple effective two band model , while further details of the fermi surface and superconducting gap are negligible . in fig .
[ hc2mgb2sumup ] , we see good quantitative agreement between experimental data and the theoretical curve between @xmath72 and @xmath73 . the deviations at lower @xmath6 may , on the one hand , be due to a decreased the accuracy of our analysis because the field limitation of @xmath56 restricts the angular range where @xmath0 data could be obtained .
this can lead to deviations larger than the estimated error bars , especially since the theoretical calculations indicate deviations of the @xmath74 dependence from the prediction of eq.([hc2_theta ] ) at low @xmath6 @xcite . on the other hand , @xmath0 at low temperatures
depends on the shape of the fermi surface in rather subtle manner , and the model fermi surface used for the calculations @xcite may be too simple for a quantitatively correct description at low @xmath6 .
the deviations at higher @xmath6 may be due to the limitations of the lll scaling approach in low fields , and or due to the influence of disorder , which is not accounted for in the calculations .
close to @xmath8 , non - locality is not important , and consequently , aglt is expected to hold even if this is not the case at lower @xmath6 . despite of this , fig .
[ hc2mgb2sumup ] clearly indicates that the variation of @xmath2 with temperature is the strongest close to @xmath8 .
therefore , in mgb@xmath1 , aglt seems to have a very limited range of applicability indeed .
an alternative method to obtain the anisotropy parameter @xmath75 of a superconductor , used often and with success in the case of cuprates @xcite , consists of measuring the torque , as a function of angle , well below @xmath0 , and analyzing the data with a formula developed by kogan @xcite : @xmath76 where @xmath77 , @xmath78 is the effective mass anisotropy , @xmath79 is the in - plane penetration depth , @xmath80 is the volume of the crystal , @xmath81 is the flux quantum , and @xmath82 is a constant of the order of unity depending on the vortex lattice structure . equation ( [ tau_rev ] ) is valid in the limits of fields @xmath83 and not too close to @xmath8 .
a further restriction is that eq .
( [ tau_rev ] ) describes the reversible torque only . to obtain the true reversible torque , we employed a vortex - shaking process @xcite . in the investigated field and temperature region ,
the shaked torque was found to be well reversible . in @xmath84 [ a ) ] and
@xmath85 [ b ) ] . shown together with the measured values ( open circles )
are best fits of eq .
( [ tau_rev ] ) ( full curves ) . ] in fig .
[ mgb2taurev ] , normalized torque @xmath86 vs angle @xmath13 curves , measured in different fields at @xmath47 , are compared .
increasing @xmath5 from @xmath87 [ panel a ) ] to @xmath85 [ panel b ) ] leads to an unexpectedly large shift of the maximum torque towards @xmath88 , which may indicate an increase of the anisotropy @xmath3 with increasing @xmath5 .
this is confirmed by the analysis of the data with eq .
( [ tau_rev ] ) .
the best agreements of the equation with the data are obtained for @xmath89 in @xmath84 and @xmath90 in @xmath85 ( full curves in fig .
[ mgb2taurev ] ) .
although descriptions with @xmath90 in @xmath84 or @xmath89 in @xmath85 are also possible without obvious discrepancies to the data , the corresponding qualities of the fit as expressed by the parameter @xmath91 are worse by more than an order of magnitude in both cases . from the analysis of reversible torque data for crystal
a measured in the range of fields and temperatures from @xmath92 to @xmath93 and from @xmath94 to @xmath95 @xcite , a few points are worth to be emphasized : 1 . )
@xmath3 is field dependent , increasing nearly linearly from @xmath87 in zero field to @xmath96 in @xmath93 .
no clear @xmath6 dependence is visible between @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
3 . ) the effective anisotropy @xmath3 , as obtained from the analysis with eq.([tau_rev ] ) is different from the @xmath0 anisotropy @xmath2 . especially concerning point 3 . ) , it is important to recognize that , also theoretically , the anisotropy @xmath3 is not necessarily the same as the @xmath0 anisotropy @xmath2 .
when aglt is not applicable , the anisotropies of the penetration depth , @xmath97 , and of the upper critical field , @xmath2 , differ in general .
calculations of @xmath97 of mgb@xmath1 @xcite indeed found values much lower than the upper critical field anisotropy values .
there is also experimental support for a low @xmath97 @xcite . in eq .
( [ tau_rev ] ) , @xmath3 appears twice , and in a first approximation @xcite , the appearance outside of the logarithm can be thought of as due to the @xmath98 anisotropy , while the appearance in the logarithm is linked to the @xmath0 anisotropy . a corresponding calculation with different ( fixed ) @xmath97 and @xmath2 yields @xcite a field dependent ( common ) effective anisotropy @xmath3 similar to the experimental observations .
field dependent point - contact spectroscopy @xcite and specific heat @xcite measurements indicate that the small gap disappears in fields of the order of @xmath99 , i.e. , superconductivity in the ( 3d ) @xmath100 fermi sheets is rapidly suppressed by even low fields , whereas it persists in the ( 2d ) @xmath101 sheets up to much higher fields .
this should result in an increase of the effective ( bulk ) anisotropy with increasing @xmath5 .
further studies are needed for a complete understanding of the detailed interplay of the effects described above . in the `` unshaked '' torque data of crystals a and b , a pronounced peak in the irreversible torque for field alignments close to @xmath102 , was observed ( see , e.g. , upper inset of fig . 5 of ref.@xcite ) .
it is tempting to ascribe this feature , also observed by other authors @xcite , to `` intrinsic pinning '' , in analogy to observations on strongly anisotropic cuprate superconductors .
however , the observation of such `` intrinsic pinning '' in mgb@xmath1 is rather counter - intuitive , since the `` intrinsic pinning '' is mostly determined by the ratio of the @xmath27-axis coherence length to the separation of the superconducting layers , which is much larger in mgb@xmath1 than in the case of cuprates in the region where `` intrinsic pinning '' is commonly observed by torque magnetometry ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
the apparent paradox is resolved by further measurements : torque measurements on crystal c with the same conditions show no sign of `` intrinsic '' pinning for @xmath102 @xcite , indicating the _ extrinsic _ origin of the feature .
the most likely cause of the peak in the irreversible torque for @xmath102 is a small amount of stacking faults
. it may indicate the presence of some stacking faults in crystals a and b , while they would seem to be absent in crystal c @xcite .
in low @xmath8 superconductors , such as nbse@xmath1 , the order - disorder transition is signified experimentally by a peak effect ( pe ) in the critical current density @xcite .
we observed such a pe by torque measurements on mgb@xmath1 single crystals b and c , both in @xmath20 and @xmath19 measurements , as can be seen in fig.[peakmgb2 ] . in sec .
[ lockin ] , we have noticed that crystals b and c behave quite differently for @xmath102 , which may be due to the presence of a small number of stacking faults in the former one .
the presence of the pe in two crystals with such pronounced differences strongly indicates that the pe , or rather it s underlying mechanism , is an intrinsic feature of mgb@xmath1 . a study with a `` minor hysteresis loop '' technique on crystal b @xcite revealed a history dependent critical current density in the pe region , compatible with and expected for the behaviour at the order - disorder transition . , vs field , at @xmath103 . shown are representative curves , measured at angles ( from left to right ) @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , @xmath108 , @xmath109 , @xmath110 , and @xmath111 .
horizontal lines indicate zero and the criterion of @xmath112 chosen for the determination of the irreversibility line . for the curve measured at @xmath113 , peak maximum and onset
are indicated ( see text ) . ]
figure [ perawtheta ] shows the irreversible part @xmath114 of the torque , scaled by @xmath115 , vs field , at @xmath103 for various angles .
the scaling was chosen to minimize the angle and field dependence intrinsic to the torque .
since the peak is not visible at all temperatures and angles as well as in fig.[peakmgb2 ] , onsets and maxima were determined from irreversible torque curves as those shown in fig.[perawtheta ] .
@xmath116 was defined as the field , where the irreversible torque starts to deviate from a straight line behaviour , as indicated in the figure for the curve measured at @xmath117 .
@xmath116 , defined in this way , is close to @xmath118 as indicated in fig.[peakmgb2]b ) .
however , we note that with the determination of onsets and maxima from the irreversible torque , the fine details of the differences in the field increasing and decreasing branch of the hysteresis loops are lost . .
a ) torque @xmath119 vs @xmath5 , measured at an angle of @xmath120 between the @xmath27-axis of the sample and the applied field . due to the anisotropy
, the location in fields of the pe is much higher than for @xmath7 , but the angular scaling is straight forward @xcite .
b ) magnetization @xmath121 vs @xmath5 , for @xmath7 , determined by squid magnetometry .
c ) absolute magnetic susceptibility @xmath122 vs @xmath123 , measured with an ac amplitude @xmath124 and a frequency of @xmath125 .
the pe visible in panels a ) and c ) is indicated by arrows . ]
it can be seen in fig .
[ perawtheta ] that the height of the peaks varies in a pronounced way with the angle @xmath13 .
one possible explanation for this behaviour is an interaction of the peak effect with stacking faults @xcite .
although the presence and the location of the peak effect are not affected by stacking faults , the extent of hysteresis may be .
the difference of how pronounced the peaks of crystals b and c are [ see fig .
[ peakmgb2]b ) ] supports such a scenario .
the location in higher fields of the peak effect in crystal c indicates that there is less point - like disorder present in this crystal than in crystal b. however , the smaller ratio @xmath126 in crystal c , compared to crystal b , is difficult to explain with only one sort of disorder .
individual strong pinning , e.g. , by sparse stacking faults , should be much more efficient in the disordered phase than in the bragg glass with it s nearly perfect ordered lattice @xcite .
if the peak height observed in crystal b is affected by stacking faults , a more pronounced pe close to @xmath102 is natural , since the pinning efficiency of stacking faults , similar to twin boundary pinning , is strongly direction - dependent @xcite . on the other hand ,
the peak height can be influenced by the natural angle dependence of the torque , despite the scaling made .
this is because the @xmath127 is only an approximation , which is not appropriate for all angles @xmath13 , in a superconductor with pronounced anisotropy ( see also ref .
@xcite ) .
the angular dependence of the _ onsets and maxima _ of the pe tracks the one of @xmath0 , i.e. , it follows eq.([hc2_theta ] ) @xcite .
this indicates that the pe ( or rather it s underlying mechanism ) is a feature for all directions of the applied field , and not just of the angular region where it is readily discernible .
to directly check the situation for @xmath7 and @xmath102 , where torque measurements are not possible , squid and ac susceptibility @xcite measurements were performed .
( crystal b ) for @xmath7 .
data points shown are from the projection of the torque vs field data presented in ref .
@xcite and the projection of additional @xmath20 measurements in fixed @xmath5 .
the dashed line is a calculation @xcite of the @xmath128 dependence ( cf .
[ hc2mgb2sumup ] ) , the dotted lines are guides for the eye . the different phases of vortex matter are labeled ( see text ) . ] in fig . [ pedifftech ] , we compare measurement curves obtained on crystal b at @xmath129 , using different experimental techniques .
torque measurements performed at an angle of @xmath120 show [ fig .
[ pedifftech]a ) ] a clearly discernible pe located in a field of about @xmath130 . scaled with eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) to @xmath7 , this corresponds to @xmath131 to @xmath132 . as can be seen in fig.[pedifftech]b ) , there is no sign of a pe observable in squid data in this field region .
generally , no sign of a peak effect was observed by squid magnetometry at any temperature , for both field directions .
this is likely due to insufficient sensitivity of the squid . in ac susceptibility data [ fig .
[ pedifftech]c ) ] , on the other hand , a pe _ is _
visible for @xmath7 in the appropriate field region .
a report of the ac susceptibility results will be published elsewhere @xcite .
a pe in mgb@xmath1 was also reported recently by other authors , in the case of @xmath7 from transport data @xcite and ac susceptibility with a local hall probe @xcite , in the case of @xmath102 from transport data @xcite .
the phase diagram for @xmath7 obtained from torque magnetometry , based on both @xmath20 and @xmath19 measurements and the angular scaling of eq .
( [ hc2_theta ] ) is presented in fig.[mgb2phdhc ] .
the magnitude of the peaks is reduced quickly by increasing the temperature , and above @xmath133 , the pe is no longer discernible in the torque data .
this is due to the decreased sensitivity of the torque magnetometer in lower fields and due to thermal smearing of the effective pinning potential . in a recent report of low frequency
ac susceptibility measurements @xcite , the peak effect was observed for @xmath7 at temperatures up to about @xmath73 , and interpreted in terms of the order - disorder transition as well . in ref.@xcite , the transformation of the pe into a `` step - like '' ac susceptibility
is reported for the temperature interval between @xmath134 and @xmath135 , and interpreted as a signature of thermal melting . in our case , no step - like feature in the reversible torque was observed in the continuation of the pe .
it should be emphasized , that thermal melting so far below @xmath0 would be at odds @xcite with theoretical expectations @xcite .
the equilibrium order - disorder transition , which corresponds to @xmath136 @xcite , is located in fields of about @xmath4 in crystal b and in about @xmath137 in crystal c. the peak effect observed in other crystals by transport was reported to be located even closer to @xmath0 @xcite .
these differences are natural for a disorder - induced phase transition in crystals with varying degrees of disorder .
form and location of the pe observed in mgb@xmath1 resembles results obtained on nbse@xmath1 single crystals with varying degrees of disorder @xcite , but are rather different from the order - disorder transition in cuprate superconductors @xcite .
in summary , studying the anisotropic superconducting state properties of mgb@xmath1 revealed a strong temperature dependence of the upper critical field anisotropy @xmath2 , and indicated a difference of the anisotropies of the penetration depth and the upper critical field .
these findings , which imply a breakdown of the standard form of the widely used anisotropic ginzburg - landau theory in mgb@xmath1 , can be explained by superconductivity in this compound involving two band systems of different dimensionality , in accordance with microscopic studies .
a pronounced peak effect in the magnetic hysteresis is a signature of an `` order - disorder '' transition of vortex matter , similar to transitions in both high @xmath8 cuprate and low @xmath8 superconductors . despite the intermediate importance of thermal fluctuations in mgb@xmath1
, the phase diagram resembles quite closely the one of the low @xmath8 superconductor nbse@xmath1 . on the other hand , chances of a proper identification of mainly
thermally induced melting at higher temperatures are better in mgb@xmath1 , due to the increased thermal fluctuations .
we thank v. g. kogan and b. batlogg for enlightening and stimulating discussions . this work was supported by the swiss national science foundation , by the european community ( contract ica1-ct-2000 - 70018 ) , by the polish state committee for scientific research ( 5 p03b 12421 ) , and by the swiss
federal office bbw ( 02.0362 ) .
note that there are two torque conventions used in the literature , leading to opposite signs of the torque shown , but to the same physical consequences .
the convention used here ( and in refs.@xcite ) is that the diamagnetism is expressed by a negative value of the magnetic moment .
the other convention , used in refs.@xcite , is that the diamagnetism is expressed solely by the direction of the ( positive ) magnetic moment vector .
l. lyard , p. samuely , p. szabo , c. marcenat , t. klein , k. h. p. kim , c. u. jung , h .- s .
lee , b. kang , s. choi , s .-
lee , l. paulius , j. marcus , s. blanchard , a. g. m. jansen , u. welp , and w. k. kwok , cond - mat/0206231 .
this justifies our aglt based analysis _
a posteriori_. an only small deviation of the @xmath138dependence of @xmath139 from aglt predictions ( with a @xmath6 dependent anisotropy ) was also found in numerical calculations @xcite . in a very recent study , kogan [ v.
g. kogan , cond - mat/0207688 ] performed detailed calculations of the torque density from the free energy of the london model with different anisotropies @xmath2 and @xmath97 .
the obtained result is more complicated than the first approximation used in ref .
@xcite .
x ray investigations of crystals b and c are in progress .
stacking faults have been observed in other samples of mgb@xmath1 , see , e.g. , y. zhu , l. wu , v. volkov , q. li , g. gu , a. r. moodenbaugh , m. malac , m. suenaga , and j. tranquada , physica c * 356 * , 239 ( 2001 ) .
see , e.g. , s. s. banerjee , n. g. patil , s. ramakrishnan , a. k. grover , s. bhattacharya , p. k. mishra , g. ravikumar , t. v. c. rao , v. c. sahni , m. j. higgins , c. v. tomy , g. balakrishnan , and d. m. paul , phys .
b * 59 * , 6043 ( 1999 ) . in the bragg glass ,
the strong elastic forces disfavour non - collective pinning .
similar ideas were discussed in the context of cuprate superconductors with twin boundaries .
see a. i. larkin , m. c. marchetti , and v. m. vinokur , phys .
. lett . * 75 * , 2992 ( 1995 ) .
similar observations were made on a yba@xmath1cu@xmath41o@xmath42 crystal containing two twin boundaries .
see w. k. kwok , j. a. fendrich , c. j. v. der beek , and g. w. crabtree , phys .
lett . * 73 * , 2614 ( 1994 ) . | the angular and temperature dependence of the upper critical field @xmath0 in mgb@xmath1 was determined from torque magnetometry measurements on single crystals .
the @xmath0 anisotropy @xmath2 was found to decrease with increasing temperature , in disagreement with the anisotropic ginzburg - landau theory , which predicts that the @xmath2 is temperature independent .
this behaviour can be explained by the two band nature of superconductivity in mgb@xmath1 .
an analysis of measurements of the reversible torque in the mixed state yields a field dependent effective anisotropy @xmath3 , which can be at least partially explained by different anisotropies of the penetration depth and the upper critical field .
it is shown that a peak effect in fields of about @xmath4 is a manifestation of an _ order - disorder _ phase transition of vortex matter .
the @xmath5-@xmath6 phase diagram of mgb@xmath1 for @xmath7 correlates with the intermediate strength of thermal fluctuations in mgb@xmath1 , as compared to those in high and low @xmath8 superconductors . |
it is believed that a neutron star begins its life as a proto - neutron star ( pns ) in the aftermath of a supernova explosion .
the evolution of the pns depends upon the star s mass , composition , and equation of state ( eos ) , as well as the opacity of neutrinos in dense matter .
previous studies @xcite have shown that the pns may become unstable as it emits neutrinos and deleptonizes , so that it collapses into a black hole .
the instability occurs if the maximum mass that the equation of state ( eos ) of lepton - rich , hot matter can support is greater than that of cold , deleptonized matter , and if the pns mass lies in between these two values .
the condition for metastability is satisfied if `` exotic '' matter , manifested in the form of a bose condensate ( of negatively charged pions or kaons ) or negatively charged particles with strangeness content ( hyperons or quarks ) , appears during the evolution of the pns .
even if collapse to a black hole does not occur , the appearance of exotic matter might lead to a distinguishable feature in the pns s neutrino signature ( _ i.e. _ , its neutrino light curve and neutrino energy spectrum ) that is observable from current and planned terrestrial detectors .
this was investigated recently by pons _
@xcite who studied the evolution of a pns in the case where hyperons appeared in the star during the latter stages of deleptonization .
although the possibility of black hole formation was first discovered in the context of kaon condensation in neutron star matter @xcite , a full dynamical calculation of a pns evolution with consistent eos and neutrino opacities in kaon condensed matter has not been performed so far .
one of the objectives of this paper is to investigate @xmath1 condensation in finite temperature matter , including the situation of trapped neutrinos in more detail .
an impetus for this study is the recent suggestion that a mixed phase of kaon - condensed and normal matter might exist which could greatly affect the structure @xcite and its neutrino opacity @xcite .
another objective of our study is to identify differences in thermodynamic quantities such as the pressure , entropy or specific heat that might produce discriminating features in the star s neutrino emission . in separate works
, we will examine neutrino interactions in kaon - condensed matter and neutrino signals from pns evolution calculations in a consistent fashion . since we wish to isolate the aforementioned effects due to kaons in this paper , we deliberately exclude consideration of hyperons .
hyperons and kaons were considered together in refs . @xcite and @xcite .
hyperons tend to delay the appearence of kaons in matter , especially if the @xmath2 appears first
. however , the @xmath2 couplings are not as well determined as those of the @xmath3 and even in this case the data are restricted to nuclear or subnuclear densities . relatively small variations in the coupling constants can lead to a situation where the threshold density for the appearance of @xmath2 particles is larger than that for kaons .
these uncertainties remain unresolved ; further hyper - nuclear experiments are needed to pin down their couplings .
the original investigations of kaon condensation in neutron star matter ( _ e.g. _ refs . @xcite and its astrophysical conseqences @xcite ) employed a chiral @xmath4 model in which the kaon - nucleon interaction occurs directly via four point vertices .
however , one can also employ an indirect , finite - range interaction which arises from the exchange of mesons .
several studies have been performed along these lines @xcite .
@xcite found that the chiral and meson exchange approaches give similar results provided that the kaon - nucleon couplings are chosen to yield similar optical potentials in nuclear matter . allowing kaons to interact via the exchange of mesons
has the advantage that it is more consistent with the walecka - type effective field - theoretical models usually used to describe nuclear matter @xcite . in most studies of kaon condensation it has been found that the transition to a phase in which kaons condense is second order for modest values of the kaon optical potential , @xmath5 , of order -100 mev . for magnitudes of @xmath5 well in excess of 100 mev , however , the phase transition becomes first order in character .
even when the transition is first order , it is not always possible to satisfy gibbs criteria for thermal , chemical and mechanical equilibrium , so a maxwell construction , which satisfies only thermal and mechanical equilibrium , was sometimes employed to construct the pressure - density relation .
recently , glendenning and schaffner - bielich ( gs ) @xcite modified the meson exchange lagrangian in such a way that the gibbs criteria for thermal , chemical and mechanical equilibrium in a first order phase transition was possible . the extended mixed phase of kaon - condensed and normal matter which results produces a qualitative difference for the structure of a neutron star , since the eos is softened over a wider region than in the case in which there is no mixed phase .
this has implications for the mass - radius relation and the maximum mass , among other properties of the star . in this paper , we investigate the phase transition involving kaon - condensed matter and its influence upon the equation of state .
we find that the precise form assumed for the scalar interactions ( particularly , their density dependence ) , both for baryon - baryon and kaon - baryon interactions , determines whether or not the transition is first or second order , and , in the case of a first order phase transition , establishes whether or not a gibbs construction is possible .
since the form of the scalar interactions is not experimentally well constrained at present , we have explored several different models in this study of the effects of kaon condensation on the eos and the structure of a pns . for each model
, we have performed a detailed study of the thermal properties which are summarized in terms of phase diagrams in the density - lepton content and density - temperature planes . in sec .
ii we present the various lagrangians and derive exressions for the thermodynamic properties of each .
we also develop the theoretical formalism necessary to describe baryons and kaon condensed matter in both the pure and mixed phases .
this is followed by a discussion of the determination of the various coupling constants .
section iii contains a comparison of the results for the eos and for the structure of neutron stars for typical values of entropy and lepton content in a proto - neutron star as it evolves .
our conclusions and outlook for evolution of a proto - neutron simulation are presented in sec .
iv . in appendix
a , the extent of the correspondence between a meson exchange formalism and a chiral model to describe kaon condensation in matter is examined .
the role of higher order kaon self - interactions in determining the order of the phase transition to a kaon condensed state is studied in appendix b.
we begin with the well - known relativistic field theory model of walecka @xcite supplemented by nonlinear scalar self - interactions @xcite . here
nucleons ( @xmath6 ) interact via the exchange of @xmath7- , @xmath8- , and @xmath9-mesons .
explicitly , the lagrangian is @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the nucleon field , the @xmath9-meson field is denoted by @xmath12 and the quantity @xmath13 is the isospin operator which acts on the nucleons .
scalar self - couplings @xcite , which improve the descripton of nuclear matter at the equilibrium density , are included in the potential @xmath14 , with @xmath15 denoting the vacuum nucleon mass .
the field strength tensors for the vector mesons are given by the expressions @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
in the standard walecka model the nucleon effective mass m^*_gm = m - g_(the label gm refers to the glendenning - moszkowski parameters @xcite that we will use with this expression ) .
we shall also study an alternative form due to zimanyi and moszkowski ( labelled by zm ) @xcite : @xmath18 by redefining the nucleon field , @xmath19 , the lagrangian can be written exactly in the form eq .
( [ hyp1 ] ) , but the nucleon effective mass becomes m^*_zm = m(1+g_/m)^-1 . for small values of @xmath7
this is equivalent to the walecka form .
however the zm effective mass has the property that , in the limit of large @xmath7 , @xmath20 remains positive whereas @xmath21 can become negative @xcite , which is unphysical . in the mean field approximation
the thermodynamic potential per unit volume for both lagrangians is @xmath22 here the inverse temperature is denoted by @xmath23 , @xmath24 and the subscripts @xmath25 or @xmath26 have been suppressed .
the chemical potentials are given by @xmath27 note that in a rotationally invariant system only the time components of the vector fields contribute to eq .
( [ hyp2 ] ) and for the isovector field only the @xmath28 component contributes .
the contribution of antinucleons is not significant for the thermodynamics of interest for a pns and is ignored . using @xmath29 ,
the thermodynamic quantities can be obtained in the standard way .
the nucleon pressure is @xmath30 , and the number density @xmath31 and the energy density @xmath32 are given by @xmath33 where the fermi distribution function @xmath34 . the entropy density is then given by @xmath35 .
the contribution from the leptons and antileptons is adequately given by its non - interacting form , since their interactions give negligible contributions @xcite .
thus the thermodynamic potential per unit volume of the leptons and antileptons is : @xmath36\ , , \label{zlept}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 and @xmath38 denote the degeneracy and the chemical potential , respectively , of leptons of species @xmath39 .
the degeneracy @xmath37 is 2 for electrons and muons and it is 1 for neutrinos of a given species . since the star is in chemical equilibrium with respect to the weak processes @xmath40 , where the lepton @xmath39 is either an electron or a muon , the chemical potentials obey @xmath41 . if there are no neutrinos trapped in the star the neutrino chemical potentials @xmath42 are zero or , equivalently , the total neutrino concentration @xmath43 , where we define the concentration for particle @xmath44 to be @xmath45 .
the pressure , density and energy density of the leptons are obtained from eq .
( [ zlept ] ) in standard fashion .
the two kaon lagrangians of the meson - exchange type which have been previously suggested ( in refs . @xcite and @xcite , respectively ) ,
can both be written in the form @xmath46 where @xmath47 denote the charged kaon fields and we have defined the combined vector field @xmath48 with @xmath49 and @xmath50 denoting @xmath8 and the @xmath28 fields , respectively ; @xmath51 and @xmath52 are coupling constants . since only the time components of the vector fields
survive , in practice only @xmath53 is non - zero .
the two lagrangians differ in the forms chosen for the quantity @xmath54 .
both have the standard vacuum mass term , but the interaction terms differ .
specifically , knorren , prakash and ellis ( kpe ) @xcite take @xmath55 with @xmath56 denoting the vacuum kaon mass , while glendenning and schaffner - bielich ( gs ) @xcite choose @xmath57 note that the coupling constant @xmath58 is defined here to be twice that defined in gs .
a similar remark applies to the @xmath59 coupling constant @xmath60 .
it is remarkable , as pointed out in appendix a , that to leading order in the kaon condensate intensity , the equations obtained with the chiral kaplan - nelson @xcite lagrangian at zero temperature agree precisely with those from the kpe lagrangian . to see the significance of the term involving the vector fields in eq .
( [ algs ] ) , consider the invariance of the lagrangian under the transformation @xmath61 .
this allows the conserved kaon current density to be identified as @xmath62 now for the combined gs lagrangian , @xmath63 , the equation of motion for the omega field is @xmath64 since the nucleon current @xmath65 is conserved , as is the kaon current @xmath66 , taking the divergence of eq .
( [ veceom ] ) immediately yields @xmath67 ( and similarly for the @xmath9 field ) .
this is the required condition for a vector field @xcite so as to reduce the number of components from four to three . on the other hand
, @xmath68 does not contain an @xmath69 term , so that the kaon current does not appear on the right hand side of eq .
( [ veceom ] ) . at the mean field level , however , where the vector fields are constants , any derivative is necessarily zero so that the divergence condition is automatically satisfied . for the coupling of the kaon fields to the scalar @xmath7 field , kpe use a linear coupling , whereas gs have an additional quadratic term
there is little guidance on the form that should be used to generate the kaon effective mass so the choice is somewhat arbitrary , although , as we shall see , it can significantly affect the thermodynamics .
both the kpe and gs choices lead to problems for sufficiently large values of the @xmath7 field ; in one case the effective mass becomes imaginary , in the other it becomes negative .
we are therefore led to consider a third form in the spirit of the zm model for nucleons .
for specificity we start with the gs lagrangian which can be written @xmath70 in terms of a covariant derivative @xmath71 , and replace it by @xmath72 we observe that the form of @xmath73 above is one of many possibilities . making the transformation @xmath74 and noting that @xmath7 is a constant mean field , the kaon lagrangian can be put in the form of eq .
( [ kaonlag ] ) with @xmath75 the label @xmath76 denotes this work " . while eqs .
( [ alkpe ] ) , ( [ algs ] ) and ( [ altw ] ) all give @xmath77 for small @xmath7 , they differ at order @xmath78 and beyond , _
i.e. _ , for large values of @xmath7
. the kaon partition function at finite temperature can be obtained for a lagrangian of the form ( [ kaonlag ] ) by generalizing the procedure outlined in kapusta @xcite .
first , we transform to real fields @xmath79 and @xmath80 , @xmath81 and determine the conjugate momenta @xmath82 the hamiltonian density is @xmath83 , and the partition function of the grand canonical ensemble can then be written as the functional integral @xmath84[d\pi_2]\int_{periodic}[d\phi_1][d\phi_2 ] \exp\left\{\int\limits_0^{\beta}d\tau\int d^3x\left ( i\pi_1\frac{\partial\phi_1}{\partial\tau}+ i\pi_2\frac{\partial\phi_2}{\partial\tau}-{\cal h}_k(\pi_i,\phi_i ) + \mu j_0(\pi_i,\phi_i)\right)\right\}\;.\label{zint}\ ] ] here the fields obey periodic boundary conditions in the imaginary time @xmath85 , namely @xmath86 , where @xmath87 .
the chemical potential associated with the conserved kaon charge density is denoted by @xmath88 and chemical equilibrium in the reaction @xmath89 requires that @xmath90 .
the gaussian integral over momenta in eq .
( [ zint ] ) is easily performed .
next the fields are fourier decomposed according to @xmath91 where the first term describes the condensate , so that in the second term @xmath92 .
the pion decay constant @xmath93 has been inserted so that the condensate angle @xmath94 is dimensionless .
the matsubara frequency @xmath95 . the partition function
can then be written @xmath96[d\phi_{2,n}({\mbox{\bfp } } ) ] e^s\;,\qquad{\rm where}\nonumber\\ s&=&\thalf \beta v(f\theta)^2(\mu^2 + 2\mu x_0-\alpha ) -\thalf\sum_{n,{\mbox{\scriptsize{\bfp}}}}\bigl(\phi_{1,-n}(-{\mbox{\bfp}}),\phi_{2,-n}(-{\mbox{\bfp}})\bigr ) { \mbox{\bfd}}\left(\matrix{\phi_{1,n}({\mbox{\bfp}})\cr\phi_{2,n}({\mbox{\bfp}})\cr}\right ) \;,\nonumber\\ { \mbox{\bfd}}&=&\beta^2\left(\matrix{\omega_n^2+p^2+\alpha-2\mu x_0-\mu^2 & 2(\mu+x_0)\omega_n\cr-2(\mu+x_0)\omega_n & \omega_n^2+p^2+\alpha-2\mu x_0-\mu^2\cr}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath11 is a normalization constant .
we define the @xmath47 energies according to @xmath97 so that the three approaches give @xmath98 using the definition ( [ defom ] ) and suppressing the explicit dependence of @xmath99 on @xmath100 , the determinant of @xmath101 is @xmath102 \left[\omega_n^2+(\omega^++\mu)^2\right]\;,\ ] ] giving @xmath103 where the normalization constant @xmath11 has been dropped since it is irrelevant to the thermodynamics .
performing the sum over @xmath104 and neglecting the zero - point contribution , which contributes only beyond the mean field approach and in any case is small @xcite , we obtain the grand potential for the kaon sector : @xmath105\;.\label{zkexch}\ ] ] the kaon pressure , @xmath106 , and the kaon number density is easily found to be @xmath107\;,\ ] ] and the bose occupation probability @xmath108 .
the kaon energy density is @xmath109\;,\ ] ] and the kaon entropy density is @xmath110 .
it is useful first to define the quantity @xmath111\;.\ ] ] then the mean @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath7 fields , as well as the condensate amplitude @xmath94 , determined by extremizing the total grand potential @xmath112 , can be written @xmath113 \frac{\partial\alpha}{\partial x_0}\right\}\nonumber\\ & & m_{\rho}^2b_0 = \thalf g_{\rho}(n_p - n_n)-g_{\rho k } \left\{\mu(f\theta)^2+n_k^{th}-x_0a_k^{th}-\thalf[(f\theta)^2+a_k^{th } ] \frac{\partial\alpha}{\partial x_0}\right\}\nonumber\\ & & m_{\sigma}^2\sigma = -\frac{du(\sigma)}{d\sigma } -2\frac{\partial m^*}{\partial\sigma}\sum_{n , p } \int\frac{d^3k}{(2\pi)^3 } \frac{m^*}{e^*}f_f(e^*-\nu_{n , p } ) -\thalf\left[(f\theta)^2+a_k^{th}\right]\frac{\partial\alpha } { \partial\sigma}\nonumber\\ & & \theta(\mu^2 + 2\mu x_0-\alpha)= \theta[\mu-\omega^-(0)][\mu+\omega^+(0 ) ] = 0\;. \label{hhyp5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the derivative @xmath114 is zero for the kpe case and @xmath115 for the gs and tw cases .
the derivatives with respect to the @xmath7 field are @xmath116 note that the last of eqs .
( [ hhyp5 ] ) yields either @xmath117 ( no condensate ) or the condition for a condensate to exist .
since @xmath88 is positive here , we only have the possibility of a @xmath1 condensate with @xmath118 .
note also that the contribution of the condensate to the kaon pressure @xmath119 vanishes , as it should .
the remaining condition to be imposed is that neutron star matter must be charge neutral . for a single phase this implies @xmath120 where @xmath121 and @xmath122 are the net negative lepton number densities .
the mixed phase thermodynamics is discussed below .
the sum of the nucleon and kaon energy densities can be simplified somewhat by using the equations of motion .
this gives @xmath123\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the theory discussed above there are two independent chemical potentials , which we can take to be @xmath124 and @xmath88 , each connected with a conserved charge , the baryon number and charge of the system , respectively .
glendenning @xcite pointed out that in the presence of a first order phase transition , conservation laws must be globally , not locally , imposed , if possible , in the mixed phase region .
a maxwell construction would have been appropriate had there been just a single conserved charge .
however , relaxing the condition of local charge neutrality does not guarantee that the model lagrangian , solved in the mean field approximation , will provide a description of the mixed phase , which is only possible if the gibbs criteria can be satisifed . a simple ,
yet general , procedure to check if the gibbs criteria can be fulfilled by a specific model is discussed in appendix b. denoting the phase containing a condensate with a subscript @xmath94 , and the phase without a condensate with @xmath117 , the total pressures in the two phases must be equal @xmath125 each of the chemical potentials is the same in the two phases . if the volume fraction of the non - condensed phase is @xmath126 , then global conservation of charge requires @xmath127_{\theta=0}+(1-\chi)[n_p - n_k - n_e - n_\mu]_{\theta}=0 \ , .
\label{g2}\ ] ] the densities of the individual species in the mixed phase are evident here .
the total energy density is the weighted sum of the two phases @xmath128 the total entropy density is obtained through a similar equation . in the effective lagrangian approach adopted here , knowledge of two distinct sets of coupling constants , one parametrizing the nucleon - nucleon interactions , and
one parametrizing the kaon - nucleon interactions , are required for numerical computations .
these are associated with the exchange of @xmath129 and @xmath9 mesons .
we consider each of these in turn .
the nucleon - meson coupling constants are determined by adjusting them to reproduce the properties of equilibrium nuclear matter at @xmath130 .
the properties used are the saturation density , @xmath131 , the binding energy / particle , @xmath132 , the symmetry energy coefficient , @xmath133 , the compression modulus , @xmath134 , and the dirac effective mass at saturation , @xmath135 .
not all of these quantities are precisely known and the values we choose are listed in table i. for completeness , we list the equations needed to obtain the coupling constants , assuming that the scalar self coupling has the form @xmath136 , where @xmath137 . from the equation of motion for the @xmath138 field and the fact that the pressure is zero at saturation density in nuclear matter
, the value of @xmath139 is given by @xmath140 where @xmath141 and @xmath142 .
the @xmath9 meson coupling constant can be determined for a given symmetry energy through the relation @xmath143 an expression involving the compression modulus can be deduced by differentiating the @xmath7 equation of motion : @xmath144
^ 2 \left\ { \frac{9n_0m^{*2 } } { e_f^{*2}[k+9(e_a+e_f^*-m)]-3k_f^2e_f^ * } -3 \left ( \frac{n_0}{e_f^*}-\frac{n_s}{m^ * } \right ) \right\ } + n_s \frac{df}{d\phi_0 } - \frac{d^2u(\phi_0)}{d\phi_0 ^ 2 } \;.
\label{comp}\ ] ] here @xmath145 , the value of @xmath146 at saturation density , is obtained directly from the dirac effective mass .
the function @xmath147 depends on the particular expression used for the effective mass . the scalar density @xmath148 \}$ ] .
the @xmath7 equation of motion at saturation can be written in the form @xmath149\;,\ ] ] which together with eq .
( [ comp ] ) allows the @xmath7 coupling to be obtained .
finally the constants appearing in the scalar self - coupling @xmath150 are determined from : @xmath151 \nonumber \\ b & = & \frac{1}{2 m \phi_0 } \left[\frac{d^2u(\phi_0)}{d\phi_0 ^ 2 } - 3 c \phi_0 ^ 2 \right ] \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constants determined in this way are given in table i. note that in principle the potential should be bounded from below for large values of the @xmath7 field requiring @xmath152 to be positive ; this is the case for the zm model . in order to investigate the effect of a kaon condensate on the eos in high - density matter
, the kaon - meson coupling constants have to be specified .
empirically known quantities can be used to determine these constants , but it should be borne in mind that laboratory experiments give information only about kaon - nucleon interaction in free space or in nearly isospin symmetric nuclear matter . on the other hand ,
the physical setting in this work is matter in the dense interiors of neutron stars which has a different composition and spans a wide range of densities ( up to @xmath153 ) .
therefore , kaon - meson couplings as determined from experiments might not be appropriate to describe the kaon - nucleon interaction in neutron star matter , and the particular choices of coupling constants should be regarded as parameters that have a range of uncertainty . with the above caveats in mind
, we now examine the relationship between the optical potential of a single kaon in infinite nuclear matter and the kaon - meson couplings in our lagrangian .
lagrange s equation for an @xmath154-wave @xmath1 with a time dependence @xmath155 , where @xmath156 is the asymptotic energy , defines the optical potential @xcite for our lagrangian ( [ kaonlag ] ) according to @xmath157~k^-({\bf x } ) & = & [ -2x_0e + \alpha - m_k^2]~k^-({\bf x } ) \nonumber\\ & \equiv & 2~m_k~u_k~k^-({\bf x})\;. \end{aligned}\ ] ] in nuclear matter , @xmath158 , so for a kaon with zero momentum ( @xmath159 ) the optical potential is @xmath160 utilizing the functional forms for @xmath54 in eqs .
( [ alkpe ] ) , ( [ algs ] ) , and ( [ altw ] ) , the optical potentials for the kpe , gs and tw models are easily obtained . for the kpe case
this may be written exactly as @xmath161 whereas for the gs and tw cases there are higher order corrections in addition to the terms linear in the fields .
we choose @xmath51 to be @xmath162 and @xmath52 to be @xmath163 on the basis of simple quark and isospin counting arguments .
note that this value for @xmath51 is also suggested by comparison to the chiral approach ( see ref .
@xcite and appendix a ) and it leads to a @xmath164 mev contribution to the optical potential .
the total optical potential is shown in table ii for various choices of the @xmath7 coupling .
the linear form eq .
( [ linear ] ) , exact for kpe , is an accurate fit to the the gs and tw cases for moderate values of the optical potential . for orientation ,
chiral models suggest that the magnitude of the optical potential is at most 120 mev @xcite , while fits to kaonic atom data have been reported with values in the range 50200 mev @xcite .
we note that glendenning and schaffner - bielich @xcite label their results according to values of the optical potential obtained in the linear approximation ( henceforth , @xmath165 ) . in order to make an apposite comparison with their results
, we will parametrize the kaon coupling for each model simply by specifying the value of @xmath166 .
the effects of kaon condensation on the eos are more pronounced at zero temperature than at finite temperature , since the fraction of thermally excited kaons increases with temperature relative to the fraction of kaons residing in the condensate .
we therefore begin by examining results for the zero temperature case .
we have considered two different nucleon lagrangians , gm and zm , and three different kaon lagrangians , kpe , gs and tw . below densities of about @xmath167 ,
matter is composed of neutron - rich nuclei immersed in a neutron sea .
for this regime , we use the potential model results of negele and vautherin @xcite in the range @xmath168 and those of baym , bethe , and pethick @xcite for @xmath169 . for cold stars ,
the eos in this regime has little effect on maximum masses or stellar radii .
furthermore , since the entropy in the stellar mantle @xmath170 is quickly radiated away in neutrinos , the eos in this regime does not substantially affect the results of this paper . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we compare the pressures for the different nucleon and kaon lagrangians as a function of baryon density , @xmath171 .
the solid lines show results for both the pure nucleon and kaon condensed phases with no attempt to enforce the gibbs conditions of chemical and mechanical equilibrium . in all cases ,
a first order phase transition is found to occur , as long as the magnitude of the optical potential @xmath172 is in excess of 100 mev . where possible , the pressure in the mixed phase obtained by imposing gibbs criteria for mechanical and chemical equilibrium is shown as a dashed line . for the gm+kpe ,
zm+kpe and zm+gs models it was not possible to satisfy gibb s criteria , despite the occurrence of a first order phase transition for large enough @xmath173 .
the reason for this is connected with the form of the kaon lagrangian , as discussed below .
we also point out in appendix b that non - linear kaon self - interactions lead to a second order , rather than a first order , transition . the qualitative similarity of the results shown in fig . [ fig1 ] for the different nuclear lagrangians enables us to simplify our analysis by allowing us to focus on three , rather than six , possible lagrangian combinations .
for a given kaon lagrangian , fairly similar results can be obtained with different nuclear lagrangians by making relatively small shifts in the kaon optical potential @xmath165 .
the following discussion will therefore focus on the three cases gm+kpe , gm+gs and zm+tw . the case gm+kpe is chosen to compare with the results of kpe , the case gm+gs is chosen to compare with the results of gs , and the case zm+tw demonstrates the usefulness of lagrangians in which anomalous values of effective masses are implicitly eliminated . the results for the model gm+gs shown here and elsewehere in this paper are identical to those found by gs for the same interactions .
note that in all models considered , the phase transition is second order in nature for moderately low values of the optical potential . in figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] , the density dependence of the scalar , vector , and iso - vector fields , the electron chemical potential @xmath174 , the condensate amplitude @xmath94 , and the nucleon and kaon effective masses are displayed in the pure nucleon and kaon condensed phases , ignoring any possible mixed phase for the present . for the optical potential chosen , @xmath175 mev , a first order phase transition occurs in all three cases . after the onset of condensation a rapid change in the behavior of the electron chemical potential and some of the field strengths
is seen to occur .
the differences in the variation of the scalar ( @xmath176 ) and isovector ( @xmath177 fields between the models are particularly illuminating . for gm+kpe ,
the scalar field exhibits a relatively rapid increase with density after the onset of condensation .
this in turn causes both the nucleon and kaon effective masses to drop rapidly with density .
in fact , for sufficiently large density , the gm+kpe kaon effective mass vanishes ( see fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
the variations of the effective masses in the models gm+gs and zm+tw are more moderate .
the variation of the isovector field with density , which in large part controls the variation of the electron chemical potential @xmath88 and hence the electron concentration , is also more dramatic in the case of gm+kpe than in the gm+gs and zm+tw models . notice that in the kpe model it goes to zero for asymptotic densities ( this follows from eq .
( [ hhyp5 ] ) ) , so that the proton and neutron abundances become equal .
this does not occur for the other two cases considered here .
finally , it is worth noting that in all three models the condensate amplitude rises rapidly once the threshold density is reached .
we turn now to a discussion of the results obtained by imposing gibbs criteria for mechanical and chemical equilibrium at zero temperature . in fig .
[ fig3a ] , we show the chemical potentials associated with the two conserved charges , charge and baryon number , as functions of each other , for the model gm+gs for a kaon optical potential of @xmath178 mev .
quantities associated with the pure nucleon phase , phase i , are shown as solid lines here and in subsequent figures .
phase ii refers to the high - density phase in which nucleons and the kaon condensate are in equilibrium , and quantities associated with it are shown as dashed lines .
both phases , i and ii , coexist in the mixed - phase region which is displayed as a dotted line . this figure illustrates the way a mixed phase is built from the two pure phases . for electron chemical potentials below the solid curve , matter is positively charged in phase i. a similar interpretation of positive or negative charge for @xmath88 below or above the dashed curve is not possible , since two different types of particles , kaons and leptons , can furnish charge . in other words , a decrease in @xmath88 , or , equivalently , the number of electrons , does not necessarily lead to a positive net charge in phase ii . for @xmath179 mev , only phase i with nucleons and leptons are present . for @xmath180 mev , a mixed phase of positively charged phase i and negatively charged phase ii obeying the gibbs conditions ( [ g1 ] ) is favored .
qualitatively , a similar situation is encountered in the construction of the mixed phase for the zm+tw model , but the mixed phase region is quite small . as noted earlier , however , it was not possible to satisfy gibbs criteria for models with the kaon lagrangian kpe . in fig .
[ fig3b ] we show the individual charge densities of phase i and ii in the mixed phase , as a function of baryon density .
the dotted curve in this figure shows the volume fraction of phase i. the results are for the gm+gs model with @xmath181 mev ( upper panel ) and for the zm+tw model with @xmath182 mev ( lower panel ) . near the lower threshold ,
matter in phase i is very slightly positively charged and occupies most of the volume . as the density increases , the volume fraction of phase i , @xmath126 , decreases and its charge density increases .
note that the negative charge density of matter in phase ii at the lower transition point , @xmath183 @xmath184 , and the positive charge density of matter in phase i at the higher transition point , @xmath185 @xmath184 , are rather large in the case of gm+gs compared to the case zm+tw .
this is due to the stronger density dependence of the scalar and isovector densities in the former case .
note also that a first order transition allows for the existence of a very dense and nearly isospin symmetric matter in the mixed phase . in figs .
[ fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] , we show the magnitudes of the various fields , the electron chemical potential , the nucleon and kaon effective masses , and the condensate amplitude for the gm+gs and zm+tw models , respectively .
both models show the same qualitative behavior . at the lower phase boundary ,
in which phase ii just begins to appear , the scalar field in phase ii is much larger than in phase i and the condensate amplitude @xmath94 in phase ii takes a large value which decreases with increasing @xmath186 through the mixed - phase region .
thus , the effective masses of both kaons and nucleons in phase ii are much smaller than in phase i. the densities demarking the mixed phase region and its overall extent are dependent upon the interaction models , and upon the assumed values of the kaon optical potentials , here taken to be @xmath187 mev in the case of gm+gs and @xmath188 mev in the case of zm+tw .
the region in density over which the mixed phase extends is much smaller in the latter case , chiefly due to the more moderate behavior of the scalar interaction with density variations in this case .
it is instructive to compare the behavior of the two models at the threshold of the mixed phase region .
phase i will have a net small positive charge and a volume proportion @xmath126 close to 1 ( see fig . [ fig3b ] ) .
this has to be counterbalanced by a large net negative charge in phase ii since it is weighted by the small proportion @xmath189 . focusing on phase ii , the condensate condition for the models gm+gs and zm+tw from the last of eqs .
( [ hhyp5 ] ) is @xmath190 and the kaon number density , which has to be large , is @xmath191 in order to ensure that @xmath192 , the quantity @xmath193 , and hence @xmath194 , has to be positive definite . in the zm+tw model the kaon effective mass is relatively large so that @xmath53 is positive and therefore @xmath94 is relatively small . on the other hand in the gm+gs model @xmath194
is quite small so that @xmath53 is negative and @xmath94 has to be large .
the negative value of @xmath195 implies a large negative value of @xmath196 which is clearly sensitive to the value of @xmath52 .
in fact , if this coupling is reduced by more than about 15% from our chosen value it is no longer possible to satisfy the gibbs criteria . by comparing the pure phase results in figs . [ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] with the mixed phase results of figs .
[ fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] , it is clear that substantial modifications of the various fields are required to satisfy gibbs criteria .
we examine now the kpe model for which it was not possible to satifsfy the gibbs criteria . in this case , eq . ( [ alkpe ] ) and the last of eqs .
( [ hhyp5 ] ) leads to the condensate condition @xmath197 whereas the functional form of the number density of kaons is identical to that in eq .
( [ kden ] ) .
( [ culprit ] ) differs in important ways from eq .
( [ lucky ] ) . for the kpe model ,
even if @xmath198 is positive , @xmath88 has the proclivity to turn negative for large @xmath124 ( or equivalently , for large baryon densities ) , leading to @xmath199 or imaginary values of the kaon effective mass @xmath194 .
this may be seen in fig .
[ fig5a ] where we show the electron chemical potential @xmath88 as a function of the ( negative ) charge density in pure phase ii for a typical value of the neutron chemical potential @xmath200 mev .
it is now possible to understand qualitatively why a mixed phase can not occur in the case of the kaon lagrangian kpe . in comparison with the gm+gs and zm+tw models ,
a distinctive feature of the kpe model is that @xmath88 decreases rapidly with the ( negative ) charge density . in constructing a mixed phase
, we are attempting to balance the positive charge in phase i with the negative charge in the dense phase ii in which the electron chemical potential , and hence the charge content in leptons , is rapidly decreasing towards zero .
the balance never occurs , hence the failure to meet the gibbs criteria . in terms of compositions ,
the gs or tw lagrangians introduce negative charges in matter by increasing the number density of kaons , while keeping the electron density nearly constant or even slightly increasing with the charge density .
the kpe lagrangian , however , rapidly substitutes electrons by kaons , which is detrimental to meeting the gibbs criteria . for these reasons
, we will concentrate on results with the other two kaon lagrangians in the remainder of this paper .
the influence of the condensate on neutron star structure ( at zero temperature ) is shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] in which the gravitational mass is displayed as a function of the star s central baryon number density ( left panel ) and its radius ( right panel ) . for the models shown , the transition is first order and gibbs equations for mechanical and chemical equilibrium are utilized .
for all cases shown the central densities of the maximum mass stars lie in the mixed phase .
the effects of the condensate are more evident in the case of the gm+gs model in which the mixed phase occurs over a wider region of density than in the zm+tw model .
when the effects of the softening induced by the occurrence of the condensate are large , the limiting mass and the radius at the limiting mass are reduced significantly from their values when the condensate is absent .
note , however , that the softening effects are limited by the constraint that the maximum mass must exceed that of the binary pulsar psr 1913 + 16 , 1.442 m@xmath201 . in the case of gm+gs
, this constraint limits @xmath202 to be smaller than about 125 mev .
in such a case , the minimum radius achieved is not as small as in the case @xmath203 mev , as shown in fig .
the radii of stars with masses less than 1.2 m@xmath201 are not affected by the choice of the kaon lagrangian or the kaon optical potential , since the condensation threshold is not reached in these cases . the density dependence of @xmath204 , @xmath205 and @xmath206 have been investigated in other works @xcite , but for the most part either in isospin symmetric nuclear matter or pure neutron matter .
in general , our results for @xmath204 with @xmath207 mev are consistent with those of refs .
@xcite ( for an appropriate comparison , our results are to be compared with results obtained without in - medium pion contributions in ref .
@xcite ) and those of ref .
@xcite for nuclear matter at both @xmath208 and 3 .
there is a relatively small change produced in going from nuclear matter to beta - equilibrated neutron star matter to pure neutron matter for the quantities @xmath204 and @xmath205 .
note that a direct comparison of the real parts of the optical potentials between different calculations must also account for the fact that in obtaining fits to data , the imaginary parts are often found to be as large as the real parts , which indicates fragmentation of strength in the quasi - particle spectral function .
relatively larger variations are found in the kaon energies in matter with varying amounts of isospin as can be seen from fig .
[ newfig ] . in this figure ,
the top panel provides a comparison of results for beta - equilibrated neutron - star matter for the gm+kpe , gm+gs , and zm+tw models , respectively , for values of @xmath209 at the extreme ends considered here , namely , 80 and 120 mev .
the bottom panel shows results for the zm+tw model for @xmath210 mev , for pure neutron matter , neutron - star matter , and isospin symmetric nuclear matter , respectively . at nuclear density where the models are calibrated
, @xmath8 decreases by about a few mev in going from pure neutron matter to neutron star matter and by about a few tens of mev in going from neutron star matter to nuclear matter . with increasing density , these differences become progressively larger .
this trend is chiefly due to the behavior of the vector fields in matter with different amounts of isospin . at this time
, our results for the density dependence of @xmath8 can be compared with those of the potential models in refs .
@xcite . for values of @xmath209 near the lower end of the range we explored , in the neighborhood of 80 mev , the behavior of @xmath8 , for example , is quite similar to the potential model results . as the authors in refs .
@xcite indicated , kaon condensation may be unlikely in this case .
however , the relevant comparision must also include the electron chemical potential @xmath211 , since the density where @xmath212 determines the onset of kaon condensation . as demonstrated in ref .
@xcite , the behavior of @xmath211 for neutron star matter at high densities is determined by the density dependence of the nuclear symmetry energy ( see also a similar discussion in ref .
potential model calculations ( see , for example ref .
@xcite ) tend to have a relatively weak density dependence of the symmetry energy , which generally results in an onset of kaon condensation that is at a rather large density . in field - theoretical and dirac - brueckner - hartree - fock @xcite models , however , the symmetry energy varies relatively rapidly with density .
these lead to smaller densities where kaon condensation occurs , for a given behavior of the kaon energy @xmath8 .
furthermore , the calculations of ref . @xcite have been performed only for pure neutron matter which further enhaces the values of @xmath8 and discourages kaon condensation .
in addition , as @xmath213 is increased in magnitude in field - theoretical models , the role of kaons increases and @xmath8 becomes progressively smaller as a function of density .
nevertheless , the lack of effective constraints at high density preclude choosing any model over another at this time . in summary , choosing values of @xmath209 near the lower end of the range we explored either lead to a second order phase transition or no transition at all in a neutron star , in which case the gross properties of the star are relatively unaffected from the case without kaons . on the other hand , values near the higher end of this range lead to a first order phase transition at a relatively low density , depending on the form of the interaction chosen , and a more pronounced effect on the star .
our aim has been to provide benchmark calculations in which both possibilities are entertained in order to consider their impact on thermodynamics and their astrophysical implications .
we now investigate results at finite temperature and values of the lepton content characteristic of those likely to be encountered in the evolution of a pns .
we choose three representative sets of pns conditions which correspond to : the initial conditions within a pns ( entropy / baryon @xmath214 , trapped neutrinos with a lepton fraction @xmath215 ) , a time after several seconds when the interior is maximally heated ( @xmath216 , no trapped neutrinos so @xmath43 ) , and a very late time when the pns has cooled ( @xmath217 identical to the zero temperature case discussed above ) . for a detailed explanation of the evolution of a cooling pns see pons _
_ @xcite .
the contribution of the nucleons to the entropy per baryon @xmath218 , with @xmath171 denoting the total nucleon density , in degenerate situations ( @xmath219 ) can be written @xmath220 where @xmath135 and @xmath221 are the effective mass and the fermi momentum of species @xmath44 , respectively .
for the temperatures of interest here , and particularly with increasing density , the above relation provides an accurate representation of the exact results for entropies per baryon even up to @xmath222 . the behavior with density of both the fermi momenta and the effective mass controls the temperatures for a fixed @xmath223 . for kaons
it is straightforward to show that the contribution to the entropy from @xmath224 mesons can be ignored since it is exponentially suppressed in comparison to the @xmath1 contribution .
for the latter , keeping the leading temperature dependence of the simplest approximation scheme for bosons given in ref .
@xcite , the kaon entropy per baryon is @xmath225 \frac{n_k^{th}}{n_b}\quad{\rm where } \quad \psi t=\mu+x_0-\sqrt{\alpha+x_0 ^ 2}\;,\ ] ] and @xmath226 is determined from @xmath227 by solving the equation @xmath228 below the kaon condensation threshold as the temperature becomes very small @xmath229 so @xmath230 . above the kaon condensation threshold the last of eqs .
( [ hhyp5 ] ) implies that @xmath231 in which case @xmath232 .
this simple approximation provides quite an accurate account of the kaon entropy per baryon which is fairly small for the scenarios examined here since it involves just the thermal contribution and the condensate plays no role .
the total entropy per baryon @xmath233 also includes the lepton contributions ; @xmath234 is dominated , however , by @xmath223 . in figs .
[ fig7 ] and [ fig8 ] , the relative concentrations of various particles are displayed versus baryon number density for our three pns conditions in the cases gm+gs and zm+tw , respectively .
the cases shown allow the gibbs equations to be solved , and the boundaries of the mixed phase regions are indicated by vertical lines .
the effect of finite temperature is to allow the existence of @xmath235 and @xmath1 particles at all densities , although kaons become relatively abundant only within the mixed phase region . in the third set of diagrams ,
trapped neutrinos are present at all densities and the appearance and abundances of the negatively charged particles @xmath235 and @xmath1 are suppressed .
furthermore , the critical density for kaon condensation is shifted to higher density . in fig .
[ fig9 ] the pressure is displayed as a function of baryon number density for these two lagrangians and the three pns conditions .
two choices for the kaon optical potential are shown to highlight differences between cases in which kaons condense in second or first order phase transitions .
the reduction of the pressure when kaons condense is obvious . for conditions
in which the phase transition is first order , the result of applying the gibbs conditions and the result of assuming pure phases ( thin line ) are both shown .
the application of the gibbs conditions leads to further softening of the pressure over a wider density range . in the case of model zm+tw ,
a first order phase transition occurs only for very low temperatures and low neutrino concentrations . in fig .
[ fig10 ] we show the matter temperature as a function of the baryon density for these two lagrangians for the two pns conditions with @xmath236 ( the kaon optical potentials are as in the previous figure ) .
the appearance of the kaon condensate generally leads to a reduction in specific heat which is indicated by the abrupt temperature increase which persists to high densities . in the case of first order transitions
, applying the gibbs conditions leads to a further enhancement of the temperature in the mixed phase regime .
this behavior is in marked contrast to the case in which additional fermionic degrees of freedom , such as hyperons or quarks , are excited @xcite causing the temperature to drop and the specific heat of the matter to be increased .
the latter follows from eq .
( [ nucentropy ] ) where , in the absence of any variation of @xmath135 , a system with more components at a given baryon density has a smaller temperature than a system with fewer components ( recall that @xmath237 ) . in the present case
the dropping of the effective mass is the dominant effect and this leads to larger temperatures .
figure [ fig11 ] shows the phase diagram of kaon condensed matter , for the case gm+gs with @xmath178 mev .
the left panel displays results for zero temperature in the density lepton concentration plane .
the dashed lines show the minimum lepton concentration allowed at zero temperature ( with @xmath43 ) for each density .
note that the minimum lepton concentration increases with density until the phase transition begins ; above this density , the minimum lepton concentration decreases with increasing density .
also note that the phase transition to a kaon - condensed phase is pushed to higher densities when trapped neutrinos are present .
this implies that in the initial pns core material , in which @xmath238 and the central density is less than 3.5 times the nuclear saturation density , a kaon condensate phase likely does not exist .
however , as neutrinos leak from the star the transition density decreases and a kaon condensate eventually forms .
the right panel displays results in the density versus temperature plane , assuming no trapped neutrinos ( @xmath43 ) .
the phase diagram for kaon condensed matter for the case zm+tw with @xmath182 mev is shown in fig . [ fig12 ] ; the results are qualitatively similar to the gm+gs case in which @xmath239 mev in fig .
[ fig11 ] .
this is understandable from the perspective that the actual optical potential for these two models are nearly the same .
the boundary between phases i and the mixed - phase region are nearly the same for the two cases .
the major difference is the much smaller extent of the mixed - phase region for the case zm+tw .
note that for both cases the density at which the phase transition begins is relatively independent of temperature , so that the heating which initially occurs in the pns has little effect on the eventual appearance of a kaon condensate .
also note that the density range of the mixed phase decreases with increasing temperature , and the mixed phase persists to high temperatures .
it appears that the mixed phase exists up to temperatures exceeding 60 mev , for the case gm+gs and @xmath178 mev , or 30 mev for the case zm+tw with @xmath182 mev .
it becomes increasingly difficult to determine the properties of a mixed phase near the temperature at which it disappears . in fig .
[ fig13 ] the gravitational mass is plotted as a function of central baryon number density for these models .
results are shown for our three pns conditions which correspond to snapshots of the pns evolution . the initial configuration ( dotted curves )
has the largest maximum mass .
the progression to the dashed and solid curves indicates the evolution with time and we see that the maximum masses decrease .
the effect of temperature upon the structure of the pns is significant .
thermal kaons play a significant role here , since the net negative charge they contribute to the system partially inhibits the appearance of the condensate which allows hot neutrino free stars to reach higher masses than cold stars .
the net decrease in maximum mass during the evolution for either case is seen to be of order 0.20.3 m@xmath201 .
thus there is an appreciable range of masses for the pns which will result in metastability with the star ultimately collapsing to a black hole .
the central density of the maximum mass , zero temperature star is smaller for the gm+gs case than for the zm+tw case .
this is in spite of the apparently softer " gm+gs equation of state in which the kaon condensed mixed - phase region extends over a wider density range .
ultimately , the smaller maximum mass of the gm+gs eos leads to a smaller central density at the maximum mass .
in this work , we have studied the equation of state of matter , incorporating the possible presence of a kaon condensate , and including the effects of trapped neutrinos and finite temperatures .
the calculation of the neutrino spectra of different flavors emitted from a proto - neutron star as it evolves from a hot , lepton - rich state to a cold , neutrino - poor state requires the knowledge of the equation of state of matter at temperatures up to about 5060 mev and lepton fraction up to about 0.4 . since the nucleon - nucleon and kaon - nucleon interactions at high density are relatively poorly understood , we explored several possible field - theoretical models in both sectors .
these models are distinguished by the form of the assumed scalar ( and in some cases vector ) interactions which chiefly determine the density dependences of the nucleon and kaon effective masses .
these models produce significantly different high density behavior of the eos , even though the kaon - meson couplings in these models are calibrated to give the same the kaon - nucleus optical potential in nuclear matter .
the principal findings of our studies at zero temperature were : 1 .
the order of the phase transition between pure nucleonic matter and a phase containing a kaon condensate depends sensitively on the choice of the kaon - nucleon interaction .
2 . in one case we studied ( kpe ) , although a first - order phase transition resulted , it was not possible to satisfy gibbs rules for phase equilibrium which would have produced a mixed phase .
we performed a detailed analysis of this situation and found that scalar , and to a lesser extent the isovector , interactions that vary rapidly with density were chiefly responsible for this failure .
this was confirmed by developing a new kaon - nucleon interaction ( tw ) with more moderate variations in the scalar density and the kaon effective mass in which the gibbs criteria in a first order phase transition would be satisfied . the extent of the mixed phase region was thereby reduced .
the significance of the new kaon - nucleon interaction ( tw ) we developed is that it avoids the anomalous behavior for the kaon effective mass that occurs in previous models ( kpe , gs ) at very high density .
near the low - density boundary of a mixed phase region , the kaon condensed phase appears with large density , too large for the kpe interaction to produce physically acceptable effective masses .
we also made detailed comparisons with earlier work which used the gs form for the scalar interactions .
3 . in all models considered ( kpe , gs and tw )
, a first - order phase transition occurs only for large values of the kaon - nucleus optical potential ; moderate values generally produce a second order phase transition . in the meson exchange models studied here ,
only linear kaon self - interactions were considered . in the case of a first order phase transition , the condensate amplitude was found to be rather large at the low - density boundary of the mixed phase .
we therefore explored the effect of non - linear kaon self - interactions guided by the chiral model in appendix b. we found that introducing higher order interactions , using the lowest order chiral lagrangian , results in a second order , rather than a first order , phase transition . whether this behavior persists
when more general higher order operators in the chiral expansion are considered remains an open question . at finite temperatures
, we find the effects of condensation , in general , are less pronounced than at zero temperature . for moderate values of the optical potential ,
when the phase transition is first order at zero temperature , kaon condensation eventually becomes a second order phase transition at high enough temperatures , whether or not neutrino trapping is considered .
the temperature at which this occurs is in the range of 3060 mev , depending upon interactions . for the cases at finite temperatures in which the transition is first order , its thermodynamics ( such as the pressure - density relation ) becomes effectively similar to that of a second order phase transition
this is because of the existence of thermal kaons and because of nucleonic thermal effects .
the condensate is suppressed , and moved to higher densities , both by the existence of trapped neutrinos and by finite temperatures .
compared to earlier works , the new aspects of our work are : 1 . the delineation of the phase boundaries in the baryon density versus lepton number and baryon density versus temperature planes .
this is helpful to anticipating the possible outcome in a full pns simulation .
in particular , the critical temperatures above which the mixed phase disappears are above 30 and 60 mev , depending upon the interaction .
this has implications for the temperature dependence of the surface energies , and for the melting temperatures , of the droplets in the mixed phase .
the finding that thermal effects on the maximum gravitational mass of neutron stars are comparable to the effects induced by the trapped neutrino content .
this is in stark contrast to previously studied cases in which nucleons - only matter , or matter containing hyperons , were considered .
furthermore , compared to equations of state previously studied that allow metastable protoneutron stars , those containing hyperons or quark matter , the maximum mass does not significantly decrease during the deleptonization of the protoneutron star because of these thermal effects .
only after the temperature in the protoneutron star significantly decreases does the maximum mass appreciably fall .
this implies that the possible collapse of a metastable protoneutron star to a black hole occurs during the late stages of cooling , after several tens of seconds , rather than during the late stages of deleptonization , which is somewhat earlier .
the support of the u.s .
department of energy under contract numbers doe / de - fg02 - 87er-40317 ( jap and jml ) , doe / de - fg06 - 90er40561 ( sr ) , doe / de - fg02 - 88er-40328 ( pje ) , and doe / de - fg02 - 88er-40388 ( mp ) is acknowledged .
j. pons also gratefully acknowledges research support from the spanish dgcyt grant pb97 - 1432 , and thanks j.a .
miralles for useful discussions .
in this appendix , we examine the conditions under which there exists a close correspondence between a meson exchange model and the chiral @xmath240 approach of kaplan and nelson @xcite . such a correspondence is most easily established for the zero temperature case by setting the scalar self - coupling terms , _
i.e. , _ @xmath241 . specializing to the case where the only baryons are nucleons and using the walecka lagrangian for the nucleons ,
it was shown in ref .
@xcite that the chiral thermodynamic potential per unit volume can be written @xmath242 where the primes on the meson fields distinguish them from those used previously and @xmath243 is the heaviside step function .
the nucleon effective masses are @xmath244 we employ the values suggested by politzer and weise @xcite , namely @xmath245 mev ( @xmath246 is the strange quark mass ) and @xmath247 mev .
@xmath248 is usually taken to lie in the range @xmath249 to @xmath250 mev .
if we ignore the fairly small effect of @xmath251 here and in the kaon - nucleon sigma term , @xmath252 , we can write @xmath253 as well as redefining the scalar field , we can redefine the chiral vector fields entering the chemical potentials : @xmath254 substituting in eq .
( [ omkap ] ) we find @xmath255 if we expand this in powers of @xmath94 and retain only the lowest order @xmath256 term , the last term in eq .
( [ omchmes ] ) does not contribute and our thermodynamic potential is exactly of the form given by eqs .
( [ hyp2 ] ) and ( [ zkexch ] ) for the meson exchange model provided that the @xmath68 expression is used . in order for the correspondence to be exact ,
the parameters for the @xmath7 and @xmath8 meson need to obey @xmath257 these are precisely the conditions found in ref .
@xcite for the optical potentials of the chiral and meson exchange models to be the same in nuclear matter .
the relation involving the @xmath8 meson couplings is quite well obeyed with our parameters .
in addition , for the @xmath9 meson , @xmath258 this indicates that @xmath259 , a condition which is not well obeyed by the parameters used here or in other works .
given that the chiral and meson exchange thermodynamic potentials can be put into precise correspondence to lowest order in @xmath256 , it follows that the equations of motion and the thermodynamics will be identical to this order .
if scalar self - coupling terms are included , @xmath260 , then the transition from the chiral to the meson exchange approach will couple higher powers of the @xmath7 field to the kaon condensate ( in the braces in eq .
( [ omchmes ] ) ) .
it will also introduce higher order terms .
these additional contributions may not be negligible so the correspondence between the two approaches becomes less precise .
our findings in appendix a naturally raise the question of whether it is sufficient to work at order @xmath256 , involving only linear kaon self - interactions , in the meson exchange models .
it clearly will be sufficient at the low - density onset of a second order phase transition where @xmath94 is small .
on the other hand , for a first order phase transition , the value of @xmath94 is large at the low - density onset of the mixed phase , particularly for the gs model .
it is therefore interesting to explore the effect of non - linear kaon self - interactions guided by the chiral model .
the order of the phase transition ( in the mean field approximation ) is determined by the behavior of the thermodynamic potential , @xmath261 , at fixed chemical potentials .
a first order transition , with a mixed phase , is possible only if there exists some value of @xmath124 for which @xmath261 exhibits two degenerate minima . at the critical density corresponding to the low - density onset of the mixed phase ,
the @xmath117 phase should be a local minimum which is degenerate with a minimum at some finite @xmath262 . in the vicinity of the critical density ,
the @xmath117 phase is nearly charge neutral ( with an infinitesimal excess of positive charge and a volume fraction close to 1 which balances the negative charge in the kaon phase which has an infinitesimal volume fraction ) .
this requirement enables us to determine the electron chemical potential at the critical density by charge neutrality .
we focus on the gm+gs model for which the thermodynamic potential of nucleons and kaons was given in eqs .
( [ hyp2 ] ) and ( [ zkexch ] ) ; the contribution due to leptons is ignored since it does not contain any @xmath94 dependence at fixed @xmath88 . at zero temperature with a kaon optical potential @xmath175 mev
, this model predicts a first order phase transition in the vicinity of @xmath263 mev , as can be deduced from fig .
[ fig14 ] where @xmath264 is plotted as a function of @xmath94 . the thermodynamic potential for the model gm+gs is shown as the solid curve labelled @xmath265 .
it clearly shows two minima , one at @xmath117 and the other at @xmath266 .
the latter corresponds to a kaon number density @xmath267 @xmath184 which is larger than the baryon density .
for such a dense condensate one would suspect that non - linear kaon self - interactions might be important .
the order @xmath268 corrections to the thermodynamic potential are easily found from eq .
( [ omchmes ] ) : @xmath269 the result of adding this correction to @xmath265 is shown as the dashed curve in fig .
[ fig14 ] .
it greatly alters the behavior of @xmath261 for @xmath270 .
the exsistence of a second minimum suggests that a first order phase transition is still possible , but at larger @xmath124 .
however , we find that this is not the case and a second - order transition occurs at @xmath271 mev .
it is possible to incorporate all powers of @xmath94 arising from self - interactions in the chiral model . in this case
the correction to the grand potential is @xmath272 the result of including this correction is shown as the dot - dashed curve in fig .
[ fig14 ] . in this case
no first order phase transition is possible in the vicinity of @xmath273 .
instead a second order phase transition occurs once again at @xmath271 mev ; this is because kaon self interactions play no role when @xmath94 is small . despite our findings here
, it is not clear if kaon self - interactions will generically disfavor a first order transition .
this is because we have ignored higher order operators in the chiral expansion which will become important with increasing @xmath94 .
the indication from phenomenological chiral perturbation theory @xcite is that such effects can be significant when @xmath274 .
the robust finding here is that the higher order kaon self - interactions predicted by the lowest order chiral lagrangian lead to a second order , rather than a first order , phase transition
. 99 bigus m. prakash , i. bombaci , m. prakash , p.j .
ellis , j.m .
lattimer and r. knorren , phys .
rep . * 280 * , 1 ( 1997 ) .
tpl v. thorsson , m. prakash and j.m .
lattimer , nucl .
phys . a * 572 * , 693 ( 1994 ) .
kj w. keil and h.t .
janka , astron . and astrophys .
* 296 * , 145 ( 1994 ) .
pons , s. reddy , m. prakash , j.m .
lattimer and j.a .
miralles , astrophys .
j. * 513 * , 780 ( 1999 ) .
glendenning and j. schaffner - bielich , phys .
c * 60 * , 025803 ( 1999 ) .
rbp s. reddy , g. bertsch and m. prakash , phys .
b 475 , 1 ( 2000 ) .
kpe r. knorren , m. prakash and p.j .
ellis , phys .
c * 52 * , 3470 ( 1995 ) .
schaffner j. schaffner and i.n .
mishustin , phys .
c * 53 * , 1416 ( 1996 ) .
kapnel d. b. kaplan and a. e. nelson , phys .
b * 175 * , 57 ( 1986 ) ; * 179 * , 409 ( 1986 ) ( e ) .
politzer and m.b .
wise , phys .
b * 273 * , 156 ( 1991 ) .
brown , k. kubodera , m. rho and v. thorsson , phys .
b * 291 * , 355 ( 1992 ) .
mfmt t. maruyama , h. fujii , t. muto and t. tatsumi , phys .
b * 337 * , 19 ( 1994 ) .
mti t. muto , t. tatsumi and n. iwamoto , phys .
d * 61 * , 083002 ( 2000 ) ; _ ibid_. d * 61 * , 063001 ( 2000 ) . ty t. tatsumi and m. yasuhira , nucl .
a * 670 * , 218 ( 2000 ) .
sew b. d. serot and j. d. walecka , advances in nuclear physics * 19 * ed .
negele and e. vogt ( plenum , ny , 1986 ) ; b. d. serot , rep .
phys . * 55 * , 1855 ( 1992 ) .
bb j. boguta and a. bodmer , nucl
* a292 * , 413 ( 1977 ) .
gm n.k . glendenning and s.a
moszkowski , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 2414 ( 1991 ) .
zm j. zimanyi and s.a .
moszkowski , phys .
c * 42 * , 1416 ( 1990 ) . lrp c .- h .
lee , s. reddy and m. prakash , proc . of int .
workshop xxvi on gross properties of nuclei and nuclear excitations , ed .
m. buballa , w. nrenberg , j. wambach and a. wirzba ( hirschegg , austria , 1998 ) p. 86 .
ogievetskij and i.v .
polubarinov , ann .
( ny ) * 25 * , 358 ( 1963 ) .
kapusta j. i. kapusta , _ finite temperature field theory _ , cambridge university press , 1985 .
kloop v. thorsson and p.j .
ellis , phys .
d * 55 * , 5177 ( 1997 ) ; t.tatsumi and m. yasuhira , phys .
b * 441 * , 9 ( 1998 ) and nucl .
a * 653 * , 133 ( 1999 ) .
glendenning , nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . ) * 24b * , 110 ( 1991 ) ; phys . rev .
d * 46 * , 1274 ( 1992 ) .
eric t.e.o . ericson and f. scheck , nucl .
* b19 * , 450 ( 1970 ) .
katom e. friedman , a. gal and c.j .
batty , nucl .
a * 579 * , 578 ( 1994 ) ; e. friedman , a. gal , j. mare and a. ciepl , phys .
c * 60 * , 024314 ( 1999 ) .
waas and w. weise , nucl .
phys . a * 625 * , 287 ( 1997 ) .
ro a. ramos and e. oset , nucl .
a * 671 * , 481 ( 2000 ) .
bgn a. baca , c. garca - recio , and j. nieves , nucl - th/0001060 .
nv j. w. negele and d. vautherin , nucl .
a * 207 * , 298 ( 1974 ) .
bbp g. baym , c. j. pethick and j. sutherland , astrophys .
j. * 170 * , 299 ( 1971 ) .
pandharipande , c.j .
pethick , and v. thorsson , phys . rev .
lett . * 75 * , 4567 ( 1995 ) .
chp j. carlson , h. heiselberg , and v.r .
pandharipande , nucl - th/9912043 .
lattimer , c.j .
pethick , m. prakash , and p. haensel , phys .
* 66 * , 66 ( 1991 ) .
apr a. akmal , v.r .
pandharipande , and d. g. ravenhall , phys .
c * 58 * , 1804 ( 1998 ) . eng l. engvik , m. hjorth - jensen , e. osnes , g. bao , and e. stgaard , phys .
lett . * 73 * , 2650 ( 1994 ) ; astrophys .
jl . * 469 * , 794 ( 1996 ) .
johns , p.j .
ellis and j.m .
lattimer , astrophys .
j. * 473 * , 1020 ( 1996 ) .
gl j. gasser and h. leutwyler , nucl .
b250 * , 465 ( 1985 ) .
.meson - nucleon coupling constants fitted to a binding energy / particle of 16.3 mev at an equilibrium density of @xmath275 in nuclear matter with a compression modulus @xmath276 mev and effective mass @xmath277 .
the symmetry energy coefficient @xmath133 is 32.5 mev . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
fig . [ fig1 ] : pressure versus baryon number density for the six choices of the nucleon and kaon lagrangians considered in this paper . the temperature @xmath130 and there are no trapped neutrinos ( @xmath43 ) . selected values for the kaon optical potential @xmath278 are indicated .
the solid lines show the pressure in the pure phases i ( nucleons only ) and ii ( the high - density nucleon - kaon condensed phase ) .
the dashed lines show the pressures obtained by imposing gibbs criteria for phase equilibrium in a mixed - phase region for the case of first order transitions . for the kpe choice of the kaon lagrangian
, gibbs criteria could not be satisfied despite the occurence of first order phase transitions in some cases . fig .
[ fig2 ] : the density dependences of the scalar , vector , and iso - vector fields for different choices of the nucleon and kaon lagrangians ( @xmath279 ) .
the solid curves show the chemical potential @xmath280 . in this figure ,
results are shown only for the pure phases i and ii ; the mixed phase produced by satisfying gibbs criteria is ignored .
[ fig3a ] : the electron chemical potential @xmath88 versus the neutron chemical potential @xmath124 in pure phases i and ii , and in the mixed phase . the pure phase i ( solid curve ) consists of nucleons and leptons .
the pure phase ii ( dashed curve ) is comprised of a kaon condensate coexisting with nucleons and leptons .
the mixed phase ( dots ) is constructed by satisfying gibbs rules for phase equilibrium .
[ fig3b ] : individual charge densities of pure phases i and ii and the volume fraction @xmath126 of phase i in the mixed phase as a function of baryon density .
results are for the gm+gs model with @xmath181 mev and for zm+tw model with @xmath281 mev . fig .
[ fig4 ] : the density dependences of the scalar , vector , and iso - vector fields for two choices of the nucleon and kaon lagrangians ( @xmath279 ) .
phase i is the pure nucleon phase and phase ii is the high - density nucleon - kaon condensed phase .
the vertical lines demark the mixed phase region .
[ fig5a ] : the electron chemical potential @xmath88 in phase ii matter versus charge density for different models at a fixed neutron chemical potential of @xmath283 mev . in all cases , the optical potential @xmath178 mev .
[ fig6 ] : left panel : the gravitational mass as a function of the central baryon number density for the cases gm+gs and zm+tw ( @xmath279 ) .
curves are labelled by the values of @xmath278 and the eos includes a mixed phase region .
right panel : the gravitational mass as a function of the stellar radius .
fig [ newfig ] : the density dependences of the kaon energy @xmath8 in matter with different isospin content .
the top panel compares results of gm+kpe , gm+gs and zm+tw models for beta stable neutron star matter for @xmath284 and -120 mev , respectively .
the bottom panel shows results for the zm+tw model with @xmath284 mev in pure neutron matter , beta stable neutron star matter and nuclear matter .
fig [ fig7 ] : the relative concentrations of hadrons and leptons as functions of baryon number density for three representative snapshots during the evolution of a pns .
the results shown are for the model gm+gs . to the left of the vertical line
there is no kaon condensate , to the right a mixed phase is present .
fig [ fig9 ] : the pressure versus baryon number density for three representative snapshots during the evolution of a pns .
the cases shown in the upper panels produce only second order phase transitions . for the cases in the lower panels the transitions
are first order , except for zm+tw with @xmath236 . in the lower panels ,
heavy curves include a mixed phase region and light curves ignore a mixed phase region .
fig [ fig11 ] : the phase diagram of kaon condensed matter for the case gm+gs and @xmath175 mev .
the left panel shows results at zero temperature in the density versus lepton concentration plane .
the dashed curve shows the minimum lepton concentration for each density , which occurs for trapped neutrino concentration @xmath43 .
the right panel shows results in the density versus temperature plane for neutrino free matter ( @xmath43 ) .
fig [ fig14 ] .
the thermodynamic potential as a function of the condensate order parameter @xmath94 .
results are shown for the gm+gs model near the critical density ( @xmath286 mev and @xmath287 mev ) with optical potential @xmath175 mev . | we study the equation of state of kaon - condensed matter including the effects of temperature and trapped neutrinos .
several different field - theoretical models for the nucleon - nucleon and kaon - nucleon interactions are considered .
it is found that the order of the phase transition to a kaon - condensed phase , and whether or not gibbs rules for phase equilibrium can be satisfied in the case of a first order transition , depend sensitively on the choice of the kaon - nucleon interaction . to avoid the anomalous high - density behavior of previous models for the kaon - nucleon interaction , a new functional form is developed .
for all interactions considered , a first order phase transition is possible only for magnitudes of the kaon - nucleus optical potential @xmath0 mev .
the main effect of finite temperature , for any value of the lepton fraction , is to mute the effects of a first order transition , so that the thermodynamics becomes similar to that of a second order transition . above a critical temperature , found to be at least 3060 mev depending upon the interaction , the first order transition disappears .
the phase boundaries in baryon density versus lepton number and baryon density versus temperature planes are delineated , which are useful in understanding the outcomes of protoneutron star simulations .
we find that the thermal effects on the maximum gravitational mass of neutron stars are as important as the effects of trapped neutrinos , in contrast to previously studied cases in which the matter contained only nucleons or in which hyperons and/or quark matter were considered .
kaon - condensed equations of state permit the existence of metastable neutron stars , because the maximum mass of an initially hot , lepton - rich protoneutron star is greater than that of a cold , deleptonized neutron star .
the large thermal effects imply that a metastable protoneutron star s collapse to a black hole could occur much later than in previously studied cases that allow metastable configurations . #
10= -.025em0 - 0 .05em0 - 0 -.025em.0433em0 |
most people have heard of the black hole information paradox @xcite . but the full strength of this paradox is not always appreciated .
if we make two reasonable sounding assumptions \(a ) all quantum gravity effects die off rapidly at distances beyond some fixed length scale ( e.g. planck length @xmath0 or string length @xmath1 ) \(b ) the vacuum of the theory is unique then we _ will _ have ` information loss ' when a black hole forms and evaporates , and quantum unitarity will be violated .
( the hawking ` theorem ' can be exhibited in this form @xcite , and it can be seen from the derivation how conditions ( a),(b ) above can be made more precise and the ` theorem ' made as rigorous as we wish . ) in this article we will see that string theory gives us a way out of the information paradox , by violating assumption ( a ) .
how can this happen ?
one usually thinks that the natural length scale for quantum gravity effects is @xmath0 , since this is the only length scale that we can make from the fundamental constants @xmath2 . but
a black hole is a large object , made by putting together some large number @xmath3 of fundamental quanta .
thus we need to ask whether non - classical effects extend over distances @xmath0 or over distances @xmath4 for some constant @xmath5 .
one finds that the latter is true , and that the emerging length scale for quantum corrections is order horizon radius .
the information of the hole is distributed throughout a horizon sized ` fuzzball ' .
hawking radiation is thus not emitted from a region which is an ` information free vacuum ' , and the information paradox is resolved . to see how the information paradox arises
, we must first see how hawking radiation is produced in the traditional picture of the black hole .
consider the semiclassical approximation , where we have a quantum field living on a classical spacetime geometry .
if the metric of this spacetime is time dependent , then the quantum field will not in general sit in a given vacuum state , and pairs of particles will be produced .
the schwarzschild black hole has a metric ds^2=-(1 - 2mr ) dt^2+dr^21 - 2mr+r^2d_2 ^ 2 this metric looks time independent , but that is an illusion ; these schwarzschild coordinates cover only the exterior of the hole , and if we look at the full geometry of the spacetime then we can not obtain a time independent slicing of the geometry .
we schematically sketch some spacelike slices for the schwarzschild geometry in fig.[matfthree ] .
( this figure is not a penrose diagram ; it is just a formal depiction of the exterior and interior regions of the hole , and if we try to put any time independent coordinates on this space they will degenerate at the horizon @xmath6 . ) outside the horizon ( @xmath7 ) we can take the spacelike slice to be @xmath8 ; this part is called @xmath9 in the figure . inside the horizon
@xmath10 the constant @xmath11 surface is _
timelike_. we get a spacelike surface by taking @xmath12 instead ; this part is termed @xmath13 .
we can join these two parts of the spacelike surface by a ` connector region ' @xmath14 , so that we construct a spacelike surface covering regions both outside and inside the horizon .
the details of such a construction can be found in the reference listed above @xcite , and we will summarize the discussion given there .
we have the part @xmath9 as a @xmath15 slice .
the ` connector ' part @xmath14 is almost the same on all slices , and has a smooth intrinsic metric as the surface crosses the horizon .
the inner part of the slice @xmath13 is a @xmath16 surface , with the value of @xmath17 kept away from the singularity at @xmath18 .
the coordinate @xmath19 is only schematic ; it will degenerate at the horizon . ]
how do we make a ` later ' spacelike slice ? outside the horizon we can take the surface @xmath20 . inside the horizon
we must now continue our constant @xmath17 surface for a little longer before joining it to the constant @xmath11 part .
thus the later surface is not identical in its intrinsic geometry to the earlier one .
we have a time dependent slicing , and there will be particle production in the region where the surface is being ` stretched ' . to see this particle production consider the evolution of wavemodes in the geometry . to leading order we can evolve the wavemode by letting the surfaces of constant phase lie along the null geodesics of the geometry .
[ matffourtp ] shows a wavemode being stretched and deformed , so that even though the wavemode was not populated by particles at the start of the evolution , we have some amplitude to get particles @xmath21 and @xmath22 at the end of the stretching . the crucial point here is the state of these created quanta .
this state has the form @xmath23 , where @xmath24 creates quanta on the part of the slice outside the horizon and @xmath25 creates quanta on the part of the slice inside the horizon .
this state can thus be expanded in a series of terms that have @xmath26 particle pairs . to understand the essentials of the paradox we can replace the state by a simpler one with just two terms quanta outside
the horizon ( the @xmath27 quanta ) is ` entangled ' with the state of the quanta inside the horizon ( the @xmath28 quanta ) . .
the mode with shorter wavelength evolves for some more time before suffering the same distortion , and then it creates entangled pairs @xmath29 . ]
it is important to see how the next pair of quanta are created ( fig.[matftthree ] ) .
the spacelike slice stretches , moving the locations of the @xmath30 quanta further apart . in the new region that is created ,
an entangled pair @xmath29 is created out of the vacuum .
thus the overall state can be written schematically in the form |=_k 1 [ |0_b_k|0_c_k+ |1_b_k|1_c_k ] [ one ] to see how the above state leads to the information paradox , let us make some basic observations .
\(i ) the state @xmath31 is ` highly entangled ' between the @xmath32 pairs .
we can compute the entropy of this entanglement by tracing over the @xmath28 quanta , obtaining the density matrix @xmath33 describing the @xmath27 quanta , and computing the entropy @xmath34 $ ] of this density matrix .
this entropy is of order the bekenstein entropy @xcite of the hole .
if the hole evaporates away completely then we are left with the @xmath27 quanta in their highly entangled state but we can not see anything that they are entangled _
thus an initial pure state which formed the hole has evolved to a mixed state , and we have lost unitarity .
\(ii ) a common misconception is that ` subtle quantum gravity effects ' can change the state of the emitted radiation and resolve this problem .
this is incorrect .
suppose we change the state of each entangled pair in ( [ one ] ) a little , |=_k 1[(1+_k ) |0_b_k|0_c_k+ ( 1-_k)|1_b_k|1_c_k ] [ onep ] where @xmath35 .
then the state is still highly entangled ; the entropy of entanglement has changed by a very small fraction . a pure state for
the @xmath27 quanta would be a state like |=_k [ 1 ( |0_b_k+|1_b_k ) ] [ oneq ] but such a state is nowhere ` close ' to the state ( [ one ] ) ; we need an _ order unity _ change in the state of each pair @xmath36 . and the entangled pairs @xmath37 shown on the spacelike slices in the penrose diagram . ]
\(iii ) if we somehow obtained a state like ( [ oneq ] ) then the emitted radiation would be in a pure state , but this would still not help ; the state of the radiation would have no dependence on the initial matter making the hole .
fig.[matfseventq ] shows a penrose diagram of the hole . on any spatial slice
there are three kinds of matter that we must consider . on the extreme
left we have the infalling matter @xmath38 that made the hole .
next we have the ` negative energy quanta ' @xmath39 and finally near spatial infinity we have the quanta @xmath40 .
what we need is for the @xmath40 to form a pure state ( entangled with nothing else ) , but carrying the information of the initial matter @xmath38 .
\(iv ) so what prevents the information of @xmath38 from reaching the quanta @xmath40 ? when we burn a piece of coal , the emitted radiation does manage to carry all the information of the coal .
the first quantum emitted from the coal may well be in a mixed state with the part of the coal left behind ; for example the emitted quantum may be a photon , and its spin may be entangled with the spin of the emitting atom which stays behind in the coal |=1 [ |_photon|_atom+|_photon|_atom ] the next quantum emitted from the coal may also be in a mixed state with the coal , but note that the emission process will be influenced in principle by the spin of the atom left behind after the first emission . in this way
the spin of later emitted quanta get related to the spins of earlier emitted quanta , and if the coal finally burns away to nothing then the emitted radiation survives in a pure state , with all the information of the initial piece of coal .
we can now see the difference between this process and the evaporation of the hole .
the radiation quanta @xmath36 are pairs created from the _ vacuum_. the matter @xmath38 is far away ( several miles for a typical astrophysical hole ) from the place where the spacelike slice is stretching and producing quanta , so its information does not influence the state of the created pairs .
further , later pairs @xmath36 are produced in a way that does not depend on the state of earlier produced pairs . as we had seen from fig.[matftthree ] , after the quanta @xmath30 are created , the part of the spacelike slice carrying these quanta stretches in such a way that these quanta are moved away from the region near the horizon where the production of the next pair @xmath29 will occur . thus unlike the case of the coal , here
the the state of later pairs does not depend on the state of earlier pairs .
\(v ) we can now summarize the essential strength of the information paradox .
the region near the horizon has a curvature length scale @xmath41 , which we can take to be of order several miles .
consider the evolution of modes of a quantum field in this region .
follow the evolution of a field mode from the time its wavelength is say @xmath42 to the time it stretches to a wavelength @xmath41 ; this evolution takes a ` time ' @xmath41 . with all length and time scales being classical , and the evolution taking place far away from the matter @xmath38 and any region of high curvature
, the evolution of the mode will lead to a state like ( [ two ] ) . but to solve the information problem _ we need the actual evolution of the field mode in this situation to differ by order unity from the expected evolution_.
the fuzzball program solves the paradox by showing that assumption ( a ) in the above section is incorrect ; quantum effects change the black hole interior in a way that distributes the information of the hole throughout a horizon sized region .
schematically , the picture of the hole is changed from that in fig.[inter](a ) to that in fig.[inter](b ) , where the latter picture shows a ` quantum fuzz ' filling a horizon sized region .
the modification of the black hole interior allows the emitted quanta to carry the information of the state of the hole .
= 2.5 in while astrophysical holes are typically charge neutral , in string theory it is easier to start with supersymmetric holes which have a charge equal to their mass .
thus they are ` extremal black holes ' in general relativity , and give supersymmetric solutions in string theory . the traditional picture of the extremal hole
is shown schematically in fig.[firstp](a ) .
we have flat space at infinity , then a ` neck ' leading to an infinite ` throat ' .
there is a horizon at the end of the throat , through which a quantum can fall in finite _ proper _ time .
there is a region inside the horizon , which contains a timelike singularity .
the region around the horizon is a low curvature region .
the important point is that if we draw a ball shaped region around the horizon then the state in this region is the _ vacuum _ state @xmath43 .
thus there is no information about the hole in the vicinity of this horizon .
we will term a horizon like this with no information in its vicinity an ` information free horizon ' .
fig.[firstp](b ) depicts the extremal hole given by the fuzzball proposal .
we have flat space at infinity , the neck and the throat .
but while the throat is long , it is not infinite .
the throat ends in a quantum fuzzy ` cap ' , where the precise details of the cap contain the information of the state of the hole .
the fuzzball program is primarily a _ construction .
_ we take a specific black hole in string theory , with some mass and charges .
this hole should have @xmath44 microstates , where @xmath45 is the bekenstein entropy of the hole .
we try to construct these microstates and see what they look like .
all cases worked out so far have given microstates that are ` fuzzballs ' ; there is no horizon , and the details of the microstates are explicitly manifested by the gravity solution . in particular , all extremal black hole states that have been constructed have the form fig.[firstp](b ) , and not the form fig.[firstp](a ) .
note that if fig.[inter](b ) or fig.[firstp](b ) was the true picture of all black hole microstates then there would be no information paradox .
an infalling quantum would not encounter a vacuum all the way to a singularity , but instead would interact with the degrees of freedom of the hole , just like what happens when a photon falls on a piece of coal .
so far we have a good understanding of all states for the 2-charge extremal hole ( the so called ` small black hole ' ) , and we also understand large sets of microstates for the 3-charge and 4-charge extremal holes .
one family of states for the non - extremal hole has also been constructed ; moreover , these nonextremal states are found to emit radiation at exactly the rate that would be expected for the ` hawking emission ' from these special microstates .
( for some reviews on the fuzzball program , see @xcite . ) the fuzzball ` conjecture ' says that all microstates of all black holes will behave like the ones that have been constructed .
let us see in more detail what this means .
the essential property of the microstates found in the fuzzball program is that there is no ` information free horizon ' .
consider first the extremal hole . in the traditional picture fig.[firstp](a ) we can mark a ball shaped region around the horizon where all quantum fields are in the _ vacuum _ state @xmath43 ; i.e. , we just have the expected vacuum of quantum fields on gently curved spacetime . with the fuzzball conjecture
_ it is not possible to find such a ball shaped region around a horizon_. while the redshift may be large near the fuzzy region drawn in fig.[firstp](b ) , there is no region that we can mark out that will look like a piece of the traditional extremal penrose diagram straddling the horizon .
any ball shaped region we draw near the fuzzball boundary will have a state @xmath31 that is _ not _ near the vacuum state @xmath43 .
rather , we will have 0 | 0 for mm_plso that the state @xmath31 would be nearly orthogonal to the vacuum @xmath43 for holes with large mass @xmath46 .
this absence of a traditional horizon distinguishes the fuzzball proposal from many other attempts to understand the information problem .
let us list some of these alternative proposals .
first , we have hawking s original proposal which says that information is indeed lost , and we should build our quantum theory without requiring a unitary s - matrix .
another proposal is that the information moves into baby universes forming inside the horizon region .
another recent proposal is that we should impose a ` final state boundary condition ' at the black hole singularity @xcite , so that information is forced to emerge in the hawking radiation .
by contrast , the fuzzball proposal does not require ` new physics ' .
instead the proposal says that when we actually construct the microstates of a black hole in the full theory of quantum gravity then we find the state to be a ` puffed up fuzzball ' , and so radiation from the microstate is no different from radiation from a piece of coal . before proceeding to see in more detail what kind of microstates we find for black holes , let us note some common misconceptions about the information puzzle and the fuzzball proposal .
\(a ) ads / cft duality is one of the most remarkable results to emerge from string theory @xcite .
it is sometimes believed that we can resolve the information paradox by using this duality .
this is incorrect , since such an argument would be circular . as we discussed in the last section ,
if we are given assumptions ( a),(b ) about quantum gravity then we _ will _ have a breakdown of quantum unitarity .
in this situation we will also lose the ads / cft correspondence , since this duality assumes that both sides of the duality are good unitary quantum theories . thus
to save quantum theory ( and ads / cft in particular ) we have to show that at least one of the traditional assumptions ( a),(b ) breaks down in our full theory of quantum gravity .
we have to resolve the problem in the _ gravity _ description of the state ; it is a circular argument to say that information will come out because there is a dual field theory that is unitary .
this said , it will turn out that the ads / cft correspondence will be a very important tool in helping us understand the general set of microstates .
it is easier to count and classify states in the cft , so while we must construct our microstates in the gravity picture to resolve the information paradox , we can use the cft analysis to know when we have constructed all the states ( or enough that the general state can be understood as an extrapolation of those that have been made ) .
\(b ) a common question about fuzzballs is : does an infalling observer feel something very different when falling into a fuzzball than into a traditional black hole ? this is a dynamical question , and we will try to use our knowledge of the time independent fuzzball states to conjecture an answer in section [ dynamical ] . the key point will be that there are different energy and time scales for different processes . for _ heavy _ observers ( mass much larger than the hawking temperature ) and over short times ( order the infall time ) the behavior of the typical fuzzball may be no different from the behavior of the traditional black hole geometry . but
over _ long _ times ( order the hawking evaporation time ) the fuzzball behaves differently from the traditional black hole , and returns information to infinity in the hawking radiation while the traditional black hole geometry leads to information loss .
there are a couple of things that we need to be careful about when addressing such issues .
first , it is sometimes believed that if the fuzzball state is ` too complicated ' then it is ` essentially ' the vacuum , and should be replaced by @xmath43 .
this is incorrect .
the generic fuzzball state is indeed very ` complicated ' , but it is important that it is close to being _
orthogonal _ to the vacuum .
all we can say is that for some _ particular _ process the fuzzball state behaves almost like the vacuum state .
secondly , it is sometimes believed that the fuzzball state will have a ` fine structure ' that will affect only motion over planck distances ; evolution of ordinary quanta will be just the same as in the traditional black hole geometry .
this is incorrect ; in fact as noted in section [ introduction ] ( and shown in detail in the reference mentioned above @xcite ) we need the evolution of hawking wavelength quanta to change _ by order unity _ at the horizon .
we will note below that for the one family of non - extremal microstates that are known , the low energy emitted quanta indeed see the detailed structure of the ` ergoregion ' of the geometry , while high energy quanta are not sensitive to the location of the ergoregion . before moving to a detailed study of fuzzballs ,
let us ask what would constitute a ` disproof ' of the fuzzball conjecture . to disprove the conjecture we would have to show that generic states of the hole _ do _ have an ` information free horizon ' .
for extremal holes , this would need us to argue that there are two kinds of microstates : the ones that are like the ` fuzzballs ' that have so far been found , and the remainder that are _ not _ like fuzzballs . with all we know now this looks hard to do , since in the dual cft description there seems to be no sharp boundary between different classes of microstates , and for the simple case of the 2-charge extremal hole _
all _ states have been found to be fuzzballs .
the remarkable thing about string theory is that it admits no free parameters
it is a unique theory with all brane tensions and couplings fixed .
there is of course a large freedom in which solution of the theory we choose to look at ; this freedom allows us for example to choose any value for the dilaton field which sets the local value of the string coupling @xmath47 . since we can not add anything to the theory
, we must make our black hole from objects _ in _ the theory .
the theory contains gravitons , as any theory of quantum gravity would , and a collection of extended objects - strings and branes - of different dimensionalities .
one knows that all different versions of string theory are related by exact dualities , so we can use any one ; we will take type iib string theory for concreteness .
one makes black holes by taking branes in the theory and wrapping them on compact directions ; from the viewpoint of the noncompact directions this places a given mass at a point in space , and with a suitable choice of wrapped objects we can create a black hole . among the objects in iib
string theory we have 5-dimensional branes , which we will use .
thus we compactify five directions as follows m_9,1m_4,1s^1t^4 [ sfour ] where we have singled out one @xmath48 for later use .
the @xmath48 has length @xmath49 and the @xmath50 has volume @xmath51 .
we can wrap a large number @xmath52 of strings on the @xmath48 , and this does give a large mass at one point in the noncompact space .
but the strings carry charge as well , and also create distortions of the moduli the sizes of the compact directions .
when all these effects are taken into account one finds that one does not get a horizon , and there is no black hole . from a statistical entropy perspective
this is good , since the degeneracy of the string bound state does not grow with @xmath52 ; the strings bind together by just making one ` multiwound string ' which loops @xmath52 times around the @xmath48 before closing on itself .
thus the statistical entropy vanishes , in agreement with the vanishing of the bekenstein entropy .
we can do better by adding @xmath53 units of momentum along @xmath48 to the string .
the strings are called the ` ns1-brane ' in string theory , and momentum is usually denoted ` p ' , so this system would be called the ns1-p system . from the viewpoint of the noncompact directions , the momentum carries kaluza - klein charge under the gauge field arising from reduction along @xmath48
, so we have two kinds of charges in the state and this is called the 2-charge system
. the extremal states of this system are those that have the minimum charge for given mass , and these turn out to be supersymmetric .
what is remarkable is that these lowest mass states are very numerous .
as we had seen , the strings join up into one long string , and the momentum will bind to this string by creating travelling waves along the string .
the total momentum can be partitioned among different harmonics in many ways , and each such state has the same energy .
the number of states is @xcite ~e^2 so that the microscopic entropy is s_micro=2 [ entropy ] terms from string theory ; there is an infinite throat , ending in a horizon with a singularity inside ( c ) the actual geometries of the ns1-p system ; the throat ends in ` caps ' , with different caps for different microstates .
the boundary of the ` cap ' region shown by the dotted circle has area satisfying @xmath54 . ]
what about the metric that this ns1-p system will generate ?
let us discuss this in three steps : \(1 ) at first it may seem reasonable to assume that all the strings and momentum charges sit at one location @xmath18 in the noncompact space ; after all we had made a bound state of these objects and so all charges should be concentrated at a given location .
this gives what we will call the ` naive ' geometry of the 2-charge extremal system ds^2&=&11+q_1r^2[-dt^2+dy^2+q_pr^2(dt+dy)^2 ] & + & _
i=1 ^ 4 dx_idx_i+_a=1 ^ 4 dz_adz_a [ three ] here @xmath55 is along @xmath48 , @xmath56 are coordinates for @xmath50 and in the 4-d noncompact space @xmath57 we write @xmath58 .
this metric has a singularity at @xmath18 but no horizon .
this metric is sketched in fig.[geometries](a ) .
\(2 ) we note that near @xmath18 the curvature of ( [ three ] ) diverges , so if there are higher derivative @xmath59 terms in the gravity lagrangian then they can be important . in string theory
there is indeed a whole series of such higher derivative terms in the effective action @xcite , and it is unclear how to compute the net effect from all these terms .
dabholkar @xcite considered the 2-charge system was taken with a slightly different compactification ( the @xmath50 in ( [ sfour ] ) was replaced by another 4-manifold called k3 ) .
only the first of the higher derivative corrections was considered , and it was found that the naive geometry changed to one of the kind expected for an extremal hole : there is an infinite throat ending in a horizon ( fig.[geometries](b ) ) . in the presence of higher derivative terms the bekenstein entropy
gets replaced @xcite by its generalization , the bekenstein - wald entropy @xmath60 , and it was found that s_bw = s_micro an order of magnitude agreement between these entropies had been earlier conjectured in @xcite . thus we see that while there are still open questions about the gravity solution of the 2-charge hole , it does seem plausible that this is a simple example of an extremal black hole . the strongest argument for thinking of the 2-charge system as a good black hole comes from the form of the microscopic entropy .
we have @xmath61 for two charges , @xmath62 for three charges , and @xmath63 for four charges ; further the entropy arises in each case as a partition of momentum of a string or ` effective string ' .
thus let us investigate further this 2-charge system and see how fuzzballs arise .
\(3 ) let us now ask if ( [ three ] ) is indeed the correct metric for the system .
we have seen that different microstates arise from different ways of carrying the momentum on the string .
the first point to note is that the fundamental string has no longitudinal vibrations , so to describe the momentum carrying wave we have to specify both the harmonic order along the string as well as the transverse direction chosen for vibration . to picture the vibrations of the string
let us open it up to its full length @xmath64 ; i.e. go to the @xmath52 fold cover of the @xmath48 .
let us start by putting all the momentum in the lowest allowed harmonic , and choose the polarization of the vibration such that the string in the covering space executes one turn of a uniform helix ; the helix will project to a circle @xmath65 in the noncompact space .
thus the string looks like a ` slinky ' , winding around the @xmath48 direction as it wanders around in the @xmath66 plane .
the important part here is that the string is not sitting at @xmath18 in the noncompact space ; instead it is spread out over a sizable region ( the size of this region scales with the charges as @xmath67 ) . as a result
the metric produced by this vibrating string will differ from the naive expectation ( [ three ] ) .
this metric can be written down in a straightforward way @xcite ( it was earlier found in a dual form in related contexts @xcite ) .
the metric has no horizon , and we have pictured the string and its metric in fig.[strings](a ) .
what do we make of this metric ?
this way of choosing the momentum harmonics is certainly one of the microstates that we were counting in the entropy ( [ entropy ] ) .
but the geometry does not agree with ( [ three ] ) , and even if we apply the higher derivative corrections , we do not get the infinite throat of fig.[geometries](b ) .
one might think that the departure from ( [ three ] ) arises because this particular state of the string has a large rotation ; by choosing the string to swing in a helical fashion we gave the state its maximal possible angular momentum . to address this issue ,
let us look at a microstate that has _ no _ angular momentum . since we know how to make all microstates , this is easy to do . again consider our vibrating string , but let the first half of the string describe a clockwise helix , and the other half an anticlockwise helix ( fig.[strings](b ) ) .
the net angular momentum will be zero .
naively , one might have thought that now we should get back the solution ( [ three ] ) ; after all the state we are making has the same mass , charges and angular momentum as the metric ( [ three ] ) .
but we see immediately that we will _ not _ get the metric ( [ three ] ) ; the string has again spread over a region whose radius scales as @xmath68 .
so we see that the actual microstates of our system do not give the ` naive ' metric ( [ three ] ) .
further the region over which the metric departs from the naive metric is so large for these states that the higher derivative corrections turn out to have no significant effect on the geometry ; in particular it does not change the microstate geometry to one with an infinite throat . let us now consider the general state of this system .
each harmonic of vibration of the string behaves like a harmonic oscillator , and strictly speaking we should specify the state of the string by giving the excitation number for each oscillator .
thus an energy eigenstate would be written like |=(a^ i_1_k_1)^m_1 ( a^i_2_k_2)^m_2 (a^i_s_k_s)^m_s|0[sstate ] where @xmath43 is the state of the string with no vibrations , and the creation operator @xmath69 creates an excitation in the harmonic @xmath70 with vibration direction @xmath71 .
a generic state will have @xmath72 , and so we should really write down the quantum wavefunction of the appropriate eigenstate for each harmonic oscillator .
but it is easier to start with the case where the energy of the state is placed in relatively few harmonics , so that @xmath73 . in this case
we have large occupation numbers for the excited oscillators , and we can replace the energy eigenstates by coherent states without losing the essential physics of the state .
now we can describe the string by a classical vibration profile f(t - y ) where the vector @xmath74 is transverse to the direction @xmath55 , and is a function of only @xmath75 because the momentum moves purely upwards along the string in the extremal state ( if we had vibrations going in both directions on the string then we would have more energy than needed to give the net momentum charge of the state ) .
let the string vibrations be in the noncompact directions .
the metric of the string carrying such a vibration profile is given by @xcite ds^2_string&=&h[-dudv+kdv^2 + 2a_i dx_i dv ] & & + _
i=1 ^ 4 dx_idx_i+_a=1 ^ 4 dz_adz_ab_uv&=&-12[h-1 ] , b_vi = ha_ie^2&=&h [ ttsix ] where h^-1&=&1+q_1l_t_0^l_t + k&=&q_1l_t_0^l_t + a_i&=&-q_1l_t_0^l_t [ functionsq ] where we have written @xmath76 to denote the fact that this metric is in the ` string frame ' of string theory , and we have given the metric , gauge field @xmath77 and dilaton field @xmath78 which are the nonzero fields in this solution . in fig.[geometries](c )
we depict these solutions schematically .
there is no horizon ; instead the throat ends in a cap whose structure depends on the choice of profile function @xmath74 .
( the same geometries can also be obtained in the language of ` supertubes ' , where the charges are dualized to ns1-d0 @xcite . ) for string vibrations in the @xmath50 directions the metrics can be found in a similar way @xcite , and fermionic excitations can be added @xcite to make general extremal solutions .
the extremal and near - extremal behavior of 2-charge solutions have been studied in many different ways @xcite .
it is now interesting to look at a generic state from the set of allowed states , and note at what radius @xmath79 this departure from the naive geometry becomes significant .
suppose we compute the area @xmath80 of this surface @xmath12 in the naive geometry ( [ three ] ) ; since the naive geometry and the actual geometries pretty much agree at this location what we are computing is the area of the boundary of the ` fuzzball region ' in a typical microstate .
interestingly , one finds that @xcite ~~s_micro [ ssize ] so we see that even though there is no horizon for any microstate , the boundary area of the typical microstate satisfies a bekenstein like relation with the entropy of the system .
in the above section we looked at extremal holes made with two charges ns1 and p. in string theory we have s and t dualities , which can change one set of charges into another .
these are exact symmetries of the theory , so the physics in the two descriptions will be equivalent .
but it can be more convenient to describe the physics in one duality frame than in another . to see the structure of the 2-charge system it is useful to start with the ns1-p frame , as we did .
this is because the bound states of this system are just states of a fundamental string carrying momentum , and it is possible to construct the metric produced by such a string .
it is not obvious how to construct the metrics of the 2-charge extremal states if we start in any other duality frame .
but once we have the metrics in the ns1-p frame , we can of course apply the s , t dualities to get the metrics in any other duality frame
. why should we be interested in other duality frames ?
we have two goals : \(1 ) first , we would like to study small excitations around the extremal states that we have constructed .
the extremal states themselves are supersymmetric ground states of system for its given charge , and they have no dynamics . if we excite the system with extra energy , then the state will become non - supersymmetric and time - dependent , and we will be able to observe the dynamical behavior of excitations around our microstate .
\(2 ) second , we would like to construct extremal states of the extremal black hole with _ three _ charges .
the 3-charge hole has a larger entropy , and therefore a larger horizon , than the 2-charge hole .
the higher derivative corrections are thus small at the horizon of the 3-charge hole , so this hole looks closer to the black holes that we are familiar with
. we will find it easier to do both these things if we first take our 2-charge system to another duality frame . under the dualities the following will happen :
\(1 ) the @xmath52 ns1 strings will be transformed to @xmath81 d5 branes . in the compactification ( [ sfour ] ) these d5 branes
are wrapped on @xmath82 .
\(2 ) the @xmath53 units of momentum will be transformed into @xmath83 d1 branes wrapped on @xmath48 .
the system obtained after these dualities will be called the d1d5 system . as in the case of the ns1-p system ,
what we want here is the bound state of the d1 branes and the d5 branes .
naively , we might think that when we bind all these branes together then we will get a pointlike mass which we can take to be sitting at the origin @xmath18 of the noncompact space @xmath84 .
but our experience with the ns1-p system shows that this might not be right . in the ns1-p case
the system had acquired a nontrivial transverse size due to the vibration of the ns1 in the process of carrying the momentum p. an s duality will not change the transverse size of any system , when we measure this size in the einstein metric ; this is because the einstein metric is left unchanged by an s duality .
t dualities are carried out only in the compact directions , and do not change the transverse size of the system when this size is measured in the _ string _ metric .
thus when we are done with our dualities from ns1-p to d1d5 , we will find that the d1-d5 microstate will also have a nontrivial transverse size .
the metric ( [ ttsix ] ) for the ns1-p system gives , after duality transformations , the following d1-d5 metric @xcite ( the subscript ` string ' means that the metric is written in the string frame ) ds^2_string&=&[-(dt - a_i dx^i)^2+(dy+b_i dx^i)^2]&+&dx_idx_i+dz_adz_a [ qsix ] where the harmonic functions are h^-1&=&1+^2q_1l_t_0^l_t dv|x - f(v)|^2k&=&^2q_1l_t_0^l_t dv ( ^2 f(v))^2|x - f(v)|^2 , + a_i&=&-^2q_1l_t_0^l_t dv f_i(v)|x - f(v)|^2 [ functionsqq ] here @xmath85 is given by db=-*_4da [ vone ] and @xmath86 is the duality operation in the 4-d transverse space @xmath87 using the flat metric @xmath88 .
by contrast the ` naive ' geometry which one would write for d1-d5 is & & ds^2_naive=1[-dt^2+dy^2 ] & & dx_idx_i+dz_adz_a[d1d5naive ] suppose that in ( [ qsix ] ) we look at a region |f|r [ slimit ] then we see that the metric simplifies to the form ds^2_string&=&r^2[-dt^2+dy^2]+dr^2&+&d_3 ^ 2 + dz_adz_a this metric has the form ads_3s^3t^4 thus we have an asymptotically @xmath89 space if we restrict to the region @xmath90 , and we can apply the ideas of ads / cft duality . to be able to take the limit ( [ slimit ] ) we need that @xmath91 , and it turns out that this is possible if we take the radius @xmath92 of the @xmath48 to be large @xcite 1 taking this limit , we expect by maldacena s ads / cft correspondence that there will be a cft description that is dual to the gravity description .
let us see what this cft is .
recall that we have wrapped @xmath93 d5 branes on @xmath82 and @xmath94 d1 branes on @xmath48 .
the d1 branes are bound to the d5 branes , so as a first approximation we can say that the d1 branes vibrate inside the plane of the d5 branes . but now note how the corresponding charges behaved in the ns1-p duality frame .
suppose we had a ns1 that was wound @xmath52 times around the @xmath48 , which has length @xmath95 .
let us add one unit of momentum p. then we have p=2l=2n_1n_1 l=2n_1l_t thus even though we added only one unit of momentum p to the ns1 , this unit of momentum looks like @xmath52 units of the basic vibration mode allowed on the full length of the ` multiwound ns1 '
. let us call this phenomenon ` _ fractionation _ ' @xcite .
after duality to the d1d5 frame , we get the following picture .
suppose we have @xmath93 d5 branes in a bound state .
we bind one d1 brane to these d5 branes .
then this d1 brane will appear as a ` fractional d1 brane ' in the bound state ; it will behave as if there were @xmath93 ` fractional d1 branes inside the d5 branes ' , with the tension of each fractional d1 brane being @xmath96 times the tension of an isolated d1 brane @xcite .
if we had @xmath94 units of d1 charge , then there will be nn_5n_1 units of ` fractional d1 charge ' inside the d5 branes .
this corresponds to the @xmath97 units of ` fractional momentum ' that we would find in the ns1-p duality frame .
the d1 and d5 branes each stretch like a ` string ' along the direction @xmath48 . now note that these two kinds of branes can be interchanged by a set of t dualities .
indeed , if we perform a t duality in each of the four directions of the @xmath50 , the d5 branes become d1 branes and the d1 branes become d5 branes . thus our final model for the d1d5 bound state should be symmetric under the interchange of these two kinds of branes . thus rather than
think of having @xmath98 units of fractional d1 branes inside the d5 branes , we should think of just having @xmath99 units of an ` effective string ' @xcite that winds around the @xmath48 .
one can advance more rigorous arguments for such a model , but the above crude picture should suffice for our present discussion .
let us now see what we can do with this effective string : \(1 ) _ count of ground states:_first , let us look at all the ground states of this d1d5 cft .
the effective string has total winding number nn_1n_5 around the @xmath48 .
we can have many different configurations with this same total winding .
all strands of this effective string could be separate closed loops , as in fig.[eff](a ) .
or we could join them all into one long string , as in fig.[eff](b ) .
more generally , we would get @xmath100 strands with winding number @xmath101 , with _
k k m_k = n [ ssum ] counting all these different possibilities gives @xmath102 states , with s=2 this agrees with ( [ entropy ] ) , as it should , since the d1d5 system is the same as the ns1-p system under s , t dualities .
identifying cft states with gravity solutions:_we have made d1d5 gravity solutions in ( [ qsix ] ) , and sketched the cft states in fig.[eff ] .
but which cft state corresponds to which gravity solution ?
the link is made by going through the solutions in the ns1-p language .
start with the d1d5 cft state , and look at a loop with winding number @xmath101 .
each separate such loop is called a ` component string ' . in the ns1-p picture
the string state ( [ sstate ] ) was described by oscillators acting on the vacuum state .
the oscillator @xmath103 maps to a component string with winding number @xmath101 . the polarization @xmath104 of the vibration gives a ` spin ' for the component string , which we have drawn with arrows in fig.[eff ] . thus start with a cft state , find the corresponding ns1-p state from ( [ sstate ] ) and find the profile function @xmath74 for these vibrations of the string . putting this @xmath74 in ( [ ttsix ] )
gives the metric of this ns1-p state , and performing s , t dualities gives the metric ( [ qsix ] ) in the d1d5 duality frame .
this then is the metric dual to the cft state that we started with . as mentioned above , to get a well defined profile function @xmath74 we need large occupation numbers @xmath100 for each @xmath101 in ( [ ssum ] ) .
if this is not the case , we get quantum fluctuations and the system is not well described by a classical geometry ; this gives the general ` fuzzball ' configuration .
( the reader can consult the references @xcite for details on the approximations needed to get a classical geometry and for more details of the cft - gravity map @xcite . ) the essential point property of fuzzballs is their size and not how ` quantum ' the solution is .
as noted in ( [ ssize ] ) the _ size _ of the generic state is order horizon size ; how ` quantum ' this state is depends on whether the excitations of the ns1 are concentrated into a few harmonics or spread over many harmonics .
\(3 ) _ energy gaps:_so
far we have looked at ground states of the d1d5 cft .
let us now add some extra energy to one of these ground states , making a non - extremal state .
the dynamics of the effective string is very simple if we are at ` weak coupling ' : we just get massless bosonic and fermionic modes travelling up and down the effective string ( these are called left and right moving modes respectively ) . while the cft should actually be at strong coupling to reflect the gravity solution , we will use it at weak coupling where we can actually compute , and hope that the corrections are not large since we are ` close ' to supersymmetric configurations . in fig.[effex](a )
we take the state where all component strings are singly wound , and add an excitation on one component string ; let this excitation be in the lowest harmonic allowed on the component string .
this is the lowest energy excitation of this cft state , and has an energy @xmath105 . in the gravity
dual , we see that we can place a quantum in a wavefunction at the bottom of the throat .
let the lowest allowed energy for such a quantum be @xmath106 .
one finds ( e)_cft=(e)_gravity [ sagree ] in fig.[effex](b ) we take the cft state with winding number @xmath107 for each component string .
the lowest allowed excitation energy is now _ half _ the value in fig.[effex](a ) .
but the corresponding gravity dual has a deeper throat ; this makes the quantum in the geometry suffer a larger redshift , and we again get ( [ sagree ] ) .
we see from this analysis that we _ must _ have ` caps ' for the geometries dual to the d1d5 cft states . if we had the naive geometry of fig.[geometries ] ( a ) or ( b ) , then we would not get agreement of energy gaps between the cft and gravity pictures .
3-charge geometries:_if we add excitations carrying momentum p _ up _ the component strings , but not _ down _ , then the state get a net momentum charge p which equals the energy added .
we then get states of the 3-charge extremal hole @xcite .
the generic cft state of this hole is pictured in fig.[threec](a ) .
we do not yet know how to make the dual of a generic 3-charge cft state .
but let us look at the simple 3-charge state depicted in fig.[threec](b ) ; because all the component strings have equal length and spins , the geometry has axial symmetry , and we _ are _ able to construct the gravity dual .
this dual is given by the metric @xcite & & ds^2 = - ( dt^2-dy^2 ) + ( dt - dy)^2 & & + hf ( + d^2 ) + & & + h ( r_n^2 - n a^2 + ) ^2d^2 + & & + h ( r_n^2 + ( n+1 ) a^2 - ) & & ^2d^2 + & & + ( ^2d+ ^2d)^2 + & & + ( dt - dy ) + & & - dy & & + _
i=1 ^ 4 dz_i^2 [ em ] where & & q_1 q_5q_1 q_5 + q_1 q_p
+ q_5 q_pf & = & r_n^2 - a^2n ^2 + a^2 ( n+1 ) ^2 + h & = & , h_1 = 1 + , h_5 = 1 + [ deffh ] again one finds that there is no horizon , and the geometry ends in a smooth ` cap ' ( fig.[threec](c ) ) .
the energy gaps for the 3-charge cft states agree exactly with the energy of quanta placed in the geometry fig.[threec](c ) .
these facts suggest very strongly that all we have learnt for 2-charge extremal holes ( where we can understand all states ) will also hold for 3-charge extremal holes .
\(5 ) _ non - extremal holes : _ we have seen in ( 2 ) above that we get non - extremal states if we have excitations running both up and down the string . in the case
( 2 ) we added only one excitation to one component string , so in the gravity dual we had just one quantum sitting in the geometry .
we could ignore the backreaction of this single quantum , and so solved the free wave - equation on the extremal background .
let us now consider the general non - extremal state , where we have an arbitrary number of left and right excitations on the component strings .
we depict the general state of the non - extremal system in fig.[nonex](a ) .
if we could understand the gravity dual of such cft states , we would have understood the non - extremal black hole .
we can not construct the gravity duals of the generic states fig.[nonex](a ) , but we _ do _ know how to make duals of special states like the one in fig.[nonex](b ) .
all the component strings have been chosen to have the same length and spins ; further , the left and right excitations are all fermionic and chosen so that they occupy the lowest allowed levels for these fermions . in this case the gravity dual is found to have the structure @xcite @xmath108 where c_i = _ i , s_i=_i @xmath109 the geometry again has no horizon , and is sketched schematically in fig.[nonex](c ) .
it is exciting that we have been able to make non - extremal states and found them to also be ` fuzzballs ' rather than ` metrics with horizon ' . but
more is true .
we can also study hawking radiation from these non - extremal states .
first consider the generic cft state in fig.[nonex](a ) .
the left and right moving excitations can collide and leave the cft bound state as radiation .
the rate of this process is given by an emission vertex @xmath110 times the occupation probabilities for the left and right colliding modes .
symbolically , = v_l_r if we put thermal distributions for @xmath111 , then @xmath112 agrees exactly with the hawking emission from the near - extremal black hole @xcite = _ hawking of course here we have agreement only of the radiation _ rate _ , not the details of emission .
the cft emission @xmath112 is a unitary process in a normal thermodynamic system , while @xmath113 is the semiclassical computation in the black hole geometry which leads to information loss .
let us see if we can do better with our understanding of fuzzballs .
we can not yet make the gravity dual of the general state fig.[nonex](a ) , but let us see if we can understand emission from the special states fig.[nonex](b ) that we _ can _ make . in the cft description
we get the emission by replacing the occupation numbers @xmath114 with the ones appropriate to this special microstate _ cft = v|_l|_r on the gravity side , we find that the geometry ( [ 2charge ] ) is _ unstable _ , and radiates energy out to infinity @xcite
. the rate of this radiation is found to exactly agree with the rate of emission from the cft @xcite _
gravity=_cft with such an explicit description of the emission from the gravity state , we can ask how and where the radiation arises .
the geometry of the microstate has no horizon , but it does have an ergoregion .
thus we get the process of ergoregion emission , whereby particle pairs are produced near the ergoregion ; one member of the pair falls into the ergoregion while the other escapes to infinity as radiation .
but the member that falls in is not ` lost ' as would be the case for traditional hawking radiation ; instead it influences the production of further quanta from the ergoregion .
this happens because of a ` bose enhancement ' process ; after @xmath115 quanta have collected in the ergoregion the probability to create the next quantum is proportional to @xmath116 .
the emission thus increases exponentially , and is characterized by a set of complex frequencies ^(i)gravity=^(i)gravity_r+i^(i)gravity_i in the dual cft state fig.[nonex](b ) we also find emission peaked at certain discrete frequencies since we have taken all component strings to be excited in the same way .
we again find an exponential growth of emission , with complex frequencies in exact agreement with the gravity emission @xcite ^(i)cft=^(i)gravity the emission from our special microstates is peaked at special frequencies like a laser instead of being the planckian emission spectrum expected from warm bodies .
but this is of course expected ; each microstate emits somewhat differently , and if we start with a very special microstate where all excitations are at a given energy then we will get a peculiar emission behavior .
the important point is that we get exact agreement between the cft computation and a gravity calculation which this time _ gives the same emission by a unitary process with no information loss_. in particular , we see that the quanta that fall into the ergoregion influence the production of the next quantum through bose enhancement .
this should be compared to the discussion of section [ introduction ] where we noted that radiation from a piece of coal can carry out information because radiated quanta can ` see ' the effects of earlier radiated quanta , while in the traditional computation of hawking radiation the newly produced pairs do not see the state of earlier produced pairs .
the 2-charge extremal hole requires @xmath117 corrections at its horizon to get the exact bekenstein - wald entropy . thus while we can understand all states of the 2-charge hole
, we would like to study 3-charge and 4-charge extremal holes , which have a larger horizon and do not require such corrections . for 3-charge and 4-charge extremal holes we do not yet have a systematic way of constructing all states in the gravity description .
but for all those states which have been constructed , we find that we get ` fuzzballs ' : the throats are finite and capped , not infinite and ending in a horizon .
the simplest 3-charge extremal states are those with @xmath118 axial symmetry ; these states were constructed some years ago @xcite .
how do we make more general 3-charge solutions ? it can be shown that any supersymmetric solution for n=1 supergravity in 6-d can be written as a 2-d fiber over a hyperkahler base @xcite .
the @xmath118 extremal solutions @xcite can be dimensionally reduced on the @xmath50 to give solutions in 6-d , and we can then ask what this base - fiber split looks like . interestingly , the base turns out to be ` pseudo - hyperkahler ' : the signature of the base jumps from being @xmath119 to @xmath120 across a hypersurface in the base @xcite .
the fiber degenerates at this hypersurface too , in such a way so that the overall 6-d metric remains smooth .
thus the lesson is that while local supergravity equations tell us that the solution will have a hyperkahler base and a 2-d fiber , in the actual solutions corresponding to d1-d5-p extremal states this split can not be performed globally ; it degenerates along certain surfaces . in a very interesting series of papers @xcite ,
bena and warner took this story to a new level .
they started from the equations of 11-d m - theory , and obtained a more detailed version of this base - fiber split . specializing the hyperkahler base to gibbons - hawking spaces ( which have an extra u(1 ) symmetry )
, they managed to get a complete solution of the supergravity field equations .
the fact that the space was pseudo - hyperkahler ( rather than hyperkahler ) could be easily built into their formalism : the solutions were written in terms of harmonic functions on the base , and the sign of the sources in these harmonic functions determined the local signature of the base . with this formalism , it became possible to write down explicitly large families of supersymmetric solutions to string theory , all having the mass and charges of the 3-charge black hole .
none of the solutions had a horizon or ` black hole singularity ' .
the sources of the harmonic functions are held apart at fixed distances by fluxed running on spheres joining them ; these constraints are given by ` bubble equations ' , which contain the essence of the supergravity equations in the present ansatz .
the above mentioned solutions had one @xmath121 symmetry the one needed to make the pseudo - hyperkahler base a gibbons - hawking space .
the solutions have 4 + 1 noncompact dimensions
. we can do a dimensional reduction along the circle corresponding to the remaining @xmath121 symmetry , thus getting solutions in 3 + 1 noncompact dimensions . the way to do
this compactification is to make the circle the fiber of a kaluza - klein monopole .
the solutions acquire a fourth charge , that of the kk monopole , and we get 4-charge solutions in 3 + 1 noncompact dimensions .
( note that if we want to make an extremal black hole with classical horizon size in 3 + 1 dimensions , then we have to use four charges . )
such solutions have recently been constructed @xcite .
the bubble equation in this 3 + 1 dimensional setting become similar to equations studied earlier by denef @xcite .
in fact denef had developed an elegant general formalism for making supersymmetric solutions out of more fundamental constituents .
these fundamental constituents could be individual branes ( having no entropy ) or extremal black holes ( having a nonzero entropy ) .
the fuzzball proposal would say that all states of the system can be written in terms of constituents _ without _ entropy .
it is not clear if the elementary constituents used in the references above @xcite are ` complete ' ; it is likely that there are more complicated constructions that need to be taken into account before we have all 4-charge extremal states .
a general philosophy that emerges from all these constructions is the importance of ` dipole charges ' .
the supersymmetric solutions have some charges that we measure from infinity ; let us call these the ` true charges ' of the solutions .
when we look at the actual microstate solutions , we find that we have flat space at infinity , then for some distance we have the uniform throat expected of the traditional black hole , and then a ` cap ' region . in this cap
we find , besides the ` true ' charges , a set of charges that are not measured as charges at infinity .
these are ` dipole charges ' and their net value adds up to zero . but their locations can be varied , and this gives us different solutions corresponding to the same total mass and ` true ' charges .
exploring the space of such allowed solutions is therefore relevant to exploring the structure of general black hole microstates .
( one can think of these dipole systems as supertubes with more than two charges ; for some generalization of supertubes to three or more charges , see @xcite . ) with this wealth of available tools , a large variety of supersymmetric solutions have been made for the 3-charge and 4-charge cases . one can make structures that look like microstates of holes , or rings , or a collection of holes and rings .
some choices of fluxes lead to ` deep throat ' solutions , which may account for a large fraction of the microstates of the hole .
solutions depending on a continuous parameter were recently found @xcite by putting a supertube inside a deep throat .
with such a construction it may be possible to get enough solutions that their number will go like @xmath122 $ ] for charges @xmath123 ; in that case one would have an entropy from these solutions that would account for the black hole entropy , and we would be in a situation similar to the one that we had for the 2-charge case .
several other studies have been done with extremal solutions .
steps have been taken to quantize the moduli space of these solutions @xcite , to study the mathematical properties of the family of such solutions @xcite , and to coarse grain over the solutions to get an ` entropy ' @xcite .
while we could make the gravity states of the 2-charge extremal system with comparative ease , we have seen that it is hard to make the gravity duals for general states of the three and four charge extremal holes .
one approach in this situation has been to treat some of the charges ` exactly ' , finding their exact gravity description , while letting the other charges be placed as a small perturbation in the background produced by the first set of charges . with such an approach
we may be better able to think of the complete ensemble of all states , though we will lose some understanding of the full gravity description of the state since some of the charges have not been handled with full backreaction .
let us see how some of these approaches proceed .
since the entropy of a black hole is given by its surface area , it has always been tempting to find some degrees of freedom that live at the horizon and whose count gives the entropy of the hole .
the problem with this of course is that we can not place something at the horizon and expect it to stay there ; any excitation at the horizon either falls into the hole or escapes to infinity , leaving no degrees of freedom at the horizon .
this is just the standard ` no hair ' phenomenon found for traditional black hole geometries , and has been a long standing problem in understanding the entropy of black holes .
but now we have learnt that at least for simple cases of extremal black hole states , we do not have a horizon but instead a geometry that ` caps off ' before a horizon is reached . in the simplest case of the 2-charge extremal d1d5 solution , the profile function @xmath74 is the helix sketched in fig.[strings](a ) . in this case
the cap region has the geometry of global @xmath124 .
thus let two of the charges making the hole be d1 and d5 , and let these charges be in a state which generates this particular 2-charge geometry .
now let us add other excitations as perturbations , creating new excitations that we can count but for which we will not take the gravitational backreaction into account .
what excitations should we take ?
it has been noted @xcite that we can put ` giant gravitons ' @xcite in @xmath89 type geometries .
these giant gravitons are branes which wrap spheres in the @xmath89 space or the sphere , and are preventing from collapsing to a point because they move through the gauge field flux which exists in the background geometry . counting these giant gravitons
one finds enough states to account for the entropy of a 3-charge hole .
note however that since we have not considered the gravitational backreaction of these giant gravitons we can not say that we understand the full gravity description in this picture . a counting has been suggested @xcite for ` brane states wrapping a black hole horizon ' .
the count gives a number that agrees with the entropy of the corresponding hole .
for the reasons mentioned above , it is completely clear where and how such brane states would be located in the presence of the horizon .
tro see if this count could be put on a firmer footing , an attempt was made @xcite to understand such a counting of branes by replacing the effect of some of the charges by the capped geometry they would produce ; the other branes were then put as test charges in the capped geometry .
there is no horizon now , but the branes wrapped a sphere which is analogous to the spherical horizon in the naive black hole geometry . with this construction
the branes did not fall through a horizon , and thus could be localized and counted . but a different problem emerged .
the branes wrapping the sphere turn out to act like ` domain walls ' , so that the value of the flux they produced jumps from one side of the wrapped brane to the other .
regularity in the cap required no field on the ` inner ' side of the brane , so one gets a nonzero field on the ` outer ' side which extends all the way to infinity . thus wrapping a brane in this fashion on a sphere produces a nonzero gauge field strength over an infinite volume , making the state have infinite energy .
perhaps some other method of wrapping branes may be more appropriate to counting the degrees of freedom of the system .
the 4-charge hole has been studied similarly @xcite by letting some charges form a ` capped ' background , and letting the other charges be added as test branes .
interactions between these test charges were also considered , and it seemed possible that d0 branes placed in the background geometry could swell up to d2 branes wrapping spheres by the myers mechanism @xcite .
the construction has been extended to black rings @xcite .
it should be checked though if in all these cases one can avoid the above mentioned problem of infinite flux energies .
the fuzzball program constructs the states of the black hole , in the gravity description . these states can be thought of as energy eigenstates of the system .
thus they do not individually describe time dependent processes like the formation of a black hole by collapse of a shell .
but once we understand the energy eigenstates of a system , we can reconstruct its dynamics by superpositions of these eigenstates . while we do not have a comprehensive picture of all
non - extremal microstates , in this section we will try to conjecture some aspects of the dynamics that should result if all black hole microstates were indeed fuzzballs .
the main dynamical questions of interest are of the following type . what happens to an observer as he approaches the horizon ?
how should we understand his evolution inside the hole ?
how does his information come out in the hawking radiation ?
if we start with a collapsing shell , how does it evolve into a fuzzball ?
let us consider what we have learnt about black hole microstates and see if we can postulate how some of these questions might be answered .
a common first question about fuzzballs is the following . in the traditional picture of the hole we have vacuum at the horizon ,
so an infalling observer feels nothing as he crosses the horizon . in the fuzzball
the information of the hole is distributed throughout a horizon sized ball .
so will the observer feel something drastically different as he approaches the place where he expected a horizon ? to understand this and similar issues , it is important to note that there are two different time scales of interest in the black hole problem .
one is the ` crossing time scale ' @xmath125 over which an infalling quantum travels from the horizon to the singularity .
the other is the much longer hawking evaporation timescale @xmath126 , which for a 3 + 1 dimensional schwarzschild hole is @xmath127 times @xmath125 .
thus we can say that @xmath126 is larger than @xmath125 by a power of @xmath128 .
now consider a quantum falling into the hole .
the density of the ` fuzz ' for a generic state of the hole was computed @xcite , and found to be low at the horizon .
thus there need not be a sharp interaction of the infalling quantum with the degrees of freedom of the hole ; in fact there is no contradiction in assuming that the motion of the quantum over the time @xmath125 resembles the free fall in the traditional black hole geometry . what we _ need
_ to solve the information problem is that the interaction of the infalling quantum with the degrees of freedom of the hole happen in a time smaller than @xmath126 , so that the information of the quantum can indeed come out in the hawking radiation . since @xmath129 , there is no contradiction in assuming very different evolutions on these two different time scales .
the existence of these two different scales makes it possible to preserve some part of our classical intuition about black holes while resolving the information puzzle .
this could be part of a more general principle .
in the extremal hole , we see two different _ length _ scales . in the traditional extremal geometry
the throat has an infinite length . in the fuzzball picture ,
the length of the throat for a generic 3-charge geometry has been estimated @xcite .
suppose the diameter of the throat is @xmath130 .
the length of the throat is then a power of the charges @xmath131 times @xmath130 . from a macroscopic perspective
, we can say that the depth of the throat is a power of @xmath128 times its diameter .
thus if we look only a down the throat only upto a fixed multiple of @xmath130 then for @xmath132 we will see just the classical throat geometry and not the quantum fuzz at the end of the throat .
these computations suggest a ` classical correspondence principle ' , which would say that to leading classical order the fuzzball states behave in a way expected from the traditional hole .
we do not yet have a clear formulation of such a principle , but let us note some other computations which might help formulate such a principle .
consider the 2-charge extremal geometries . if we take a simple geometry like the one pictured in fig.[strings](a ) , then an infalling quantum bounces off the end and returns back in a small time . now consider the geometry for a generic state ( fig.[geometries](c ) ) .
this geometry is very complicated in the cap region , and an infalling quantum will be trapped in that region for a long time .
was estimated the time of return from a generic 2-charge geometry was found @xcite to be a power of @xmath133 times the crossing time across the fuzzball ; this long time results from the many deflections a geodesic suffers before it can exit the cap region .
again , we can think of this return time as a power of @xmath128 times the crossing time .
for an observer who looks at the system only for a fixed multiple @xmath134 times the crossing time , the infalling quantum would appear to be lost for ever when we take the charges to infinity .
thus for such an observer we can replace the boundary of the fuzzball by a traditional horizon , and obtain essentially the same effect : now the infalling quantum would never return .
it is in this sense that we should understand the emergence of a horizon in the fuzzball picture .
the ` horizon ' is only an effective concept describing the evolution over the short timescale @xmath125 , while the actual details of the quantum fuzz lead to the eventual leakage of information from the fuzzball , something that can not happen if we _ really _ had the traditional black hole horizon . just as we differentiated between two different time scales and length scales , we should also separate two different _ energy _ scales .
the typical hawking radiation quantum has an energy @xmath135 of order the temperature @xmath136 of the hole .
when we think of an infalling observer , we should ask if the energy of this observer is @xmath137 , or if @xmath138 . from our analysis of the information paradox
we know that the evolution of hawking radiation quanta with @xmath137 _ must _ be modified by order unity by the detailed information in the fuzzball state ; otherwise information will not come out in the radiation . on the other hand ,
it is not necessary that the evolution of modes with @xmath138 be affected to leading order by the fuzzball structure , at least for time scales @xmath139 . as an explicit example of this , consider the nonextremal geometry that we considered in the last section .
the hawking emission happens because of the negative effective potential in the ergoregion , and this emission does not happen from the part of the geometry which is not in the ergoregion .
but the negative potential is quite small , and the emitted quanta have a low energy .
if we send a high energy quantum into the geometry , it does not notice the ergoregion potential in any significant way , and its evolution does not depend sensitively on whether or not it passes through the ergoregion .
thus here we have a simple example where the evolution of the hawking radiation quanta depends on sensitive details of the geometry while the evolution of a ` heavy ' infalling observer is not sensitive to the same details .
if the energy eigenstates of the black hole are horizon sized fuzzballs , then any infalling shell should eventually be best described by a linear combination of these fuzzball geometries . but how will this happen ?
a classical shell seems to feel no large quantum effects as it crosses the horizon , so one would think that the result should be the traditional black hole with the ` information free horizon ' . in this section
we will make some simple observations which indicate why black holes may not be as classical as they at first appear .
consider any state of matter which has mass @xmath46 , and which is localized in a region @xmath140 which is order the black hole radius for mass @xmath46 .
a collapsing shell would be such a state as it crosses its horizon .
now consider any other state which has the same mass and which is localized in the same region , for example a fuzzball state .
let us ask if there is any significant amplitude for ` tunneling ' between such states , postponing for the moment the details of what this tunneling process is .
( we will see below that we are looking for ` spreading of a wavefunction ' rather than tunneling , but it is more helpful to think of a tunneling process on a first pass at the issues . ) normally the tunneling amplitude would be small , since the states have large mass and size .
we will estimate the action for a tunneling process by writing s_tunnel~1
g r d^4x~1 g 1(gm)^2(gm)^4~gm^2 [ saction ] where we have assumed a length scale @xmath141 for the curvature and a volume @xmath142 over which the process takes place . thus the amplitude for tunneling from the shell to a fuzzball state ~e^-s_tunnel is very small .
but now note that there are a very large number of fuzzball states that we can tunnel to .
this number is given by ~e^s_bek~e^gm^2 we see that something curious happens for black holes .
these objects have such a large entropy that the very small probability for tunneling between classical configurations can be compensated for by the very large number of states that we can tunnel to @xcite .
this would make a black hole an essentially quantum object .
note that if we took a star instead , then the action ( [ saction ] ) is larger ( the size of the object is bigger ) while the entropy is much lower , and there is no such quantum behavior .
the above was just a crude order of magnitude estimate , but now let us see if we can say something more about the actual dynamical process of shell collapse .
the crucial point will be the fact that there is a large number of possible states states of the hole
the @xmath143 fuzzballs . in the classical picture of collapse
we do not see these states which are supposed to give the entropy of the hole .
we will see that it may not be correct to ignore the large phase space which these microstates represent , and when we do take all these solutions into account the quantum evolution of a collapsing shell can be very different from its classical approximation .
let us proceed in three steps .
\(1 ) first let us take a 2-charge extremal geometry , and throw into the throat a quantum of a scalar field @xmath78 with energy @xmath144 .
we choose @xmath144 to be small , so the backreaction of the quantum on the geometry can be ignored .
the quantum will fall down the throat , reach the cap , and eventually reflect back up the throat .
how do we describe this evolution in terms of the energy eigenstates of the system ?
we can find the energy eigenstates of the quantum by solving the wave - equation @xmath145 .
( for the simple geometries of fig.[effex ] the wavefunctions have been explicitly computed @xcite . )
we get a set of energy eigenfunctions .
the lowest energy state is localized in the cap ( as shown in fig.[effex ] ) , the next one extends a little further out , the next one still further , etc .
the infalling quantum starts high up the throat , so we must superpose these energy eigenfunctions with suitable coefficients to obtain this initial wavepacket |=_k
c_k |e_k[sum ] where @xmath146 is the eigenfunction with energy @xmath147 .
this is all just standard quantum mechanics , and we would do a similar computation for describing a localized quantum moving in the potential of a harmonic oscillator .
the evolution of the wavepacket down the throat is obtained by evolving the energy eigenfunctions ; since these eigenfunctions have slightly different energies , the relative phases between their coefficients change with time and cause the wavepacket to move downwards towards the cap . the essential point in the above discussion
is that even though the quantum is localized quite high up the throat up the start , if we want to express its wavefunction in terms of the stationary states of the system then we have to construct the detailed energy eigenfunctions @xmath146 in the entire geometry , and these will depend sensitively on the structure of the cap .
\(2 ) now let us imagine that the energy of the infalling quantum is a bit higher .
we would therefore like to take into account the small backreaction that the infalling quantum would create on the geometry .
how should we do this ?
we still have to follow the same basic scheme : we have to find the energy eigenstates of the system and superpose them with appropriate coefficients . the evolution
will then be given by the changing phases of the coefficients .
but what are the energy eigenstates this time ?
clearly , we should find solutions to the full system of gravity plus scalar field @xmath78 , with the backreaction of the @xmath78 excitation included , and arrive at some eigenstates @xmath148 $ ] which are functionals of both the metric @xmath47 and the scalar field @xmath78 .
note in particular that the energy @xmath147 of this state will reflect the energy of the background extremal 2-charge geometry as well as the energy of the quantum .
so we are making energy eigenstates around an energy e_total = e_extremal+e_quantum [ stotal ] the number of states of the system increase with the energy , and we observe here that the set of eigenstates that will be involved in a sum like ( [ sum ] ) will be the number at energy @xmath149 , and not at the base energy @xmath150 .
\(3 ) now let us imagine increasing the energy of the infalling quantum still further , so that a classical analysis would indicate the formation of a horizon at some point in the throat , much before the cap is reached .
this is of course the case that we are really interested in understanding .
the basic scheme will remain the same as in the above two cases , but now we have to find all energy eigenstates of the system with an energy @xmath149 where the contribution @xmath151 is not small . according to our postulate , these energy eigenstates are horizon sized fuzzballs , pictured in fig.[geometries](c ) . thus the initial infalling quantum has to be written in the form ( [ sum ] ) as a set of very quantum fuzzball states ; these states are very numerous and have a nontrivial structure all the way upto the horizon .
now suppose we did not know that there were all these fuzzball states , and we wrote the sum ( [ sum ] ) with only the states that we see in the traditional picture of the black hole .
then we would be using a much smaller number of states .
for example if we took the infalling quantum to have spherical symmetry , then we might ( erroneously ) assume that the black hole background should be a classical spherically symmetric state .
but from what we have seen of fuzzball states , they are in general _ not _ spherically symmetric .
spherical symmetry of the overall state is obtained by superposing with equal coefficient a _ non - spherical _ geometry with all of its rotates . thus if we write the initial shell as a superposition of spherically symmetric fuzzball states , then these states will have large _ fluctuations _ @xmath152 . in short , the fuzzball picture would give a much larger sum of states in ( [ sum ] ) as compared to a traditional picture which does not explicitly recognize the degrees of freedom corresponding to the bekenstein entropy .
as the phases of the coefficients @xmath39 evolve , the initial state with the quantum will change to a general linear superposition of fuzzball states , something we can not see in the traditional classical infall .
it is interesting to note the phase evolution of the @xmath39 becomes important in a time that is shorter than the hawking evaporation time .
suppose we have a shell of mass @xmath46 that collapses to form a black hole .
let the schwarzschild radius of the hole be denoted by @xmath92 . to make the shell collapse we must localize the matter in the shell so that it fits in a radius @xmath153 .
this needs a momentum spread for the shell p for a nonrelativistic shell , the energy of the shell is @xmath154 , and the uncertainty in @xmath144 will ; be e~ppm the different fuzzball states @xmath146 making up the shell wavefunction @xmath31 will go ` out of phase ' over a time @xmath155 so that the state will look like a linear combination of generic fuzzball states rather than a well defined shell .
we have t_dephase~1emr^2 but the hawking evaporation time for a schwarzschild hole ( in all dimensions ) is t_evap~ mr^2 thus we find that the time over which the the wavefunction ` dephases to fuzzballs ' is shorter than the hawking evaporation time t_dephase t_evap this is important , since this ` dephasing ' would not be of interest if it took _ longer _ than the hawking evaporation time .
( note that if we take a relativistic shell with @xmath156 instead of @xmath154 then we get an even shorter time @xmath155 .
now we would have e~p this gives t_dephaser mr^2 where we recall that we are measuring all quantities in planck units , and @xmath157 . )
having obtained a rough picture of how black hole infall may be studied using fuzzball states , let us consider a toy model which illustrates in more detail how wavefunctions ` spread ' during evolution . in fig.[potential ]
we sketch a system where a quantum can move along the @xmath17 direction , from @xmath158 to @xmath18
. if we have only this direction @xmath17 to move in , the motion of a quantum would be straightforward .
but now let us assume that there is another direction @xmath55 in our space .
let there be a potential v = k(r ) y^2 let @xmath159 vanish at large and small @xmath17 and be high in - between , with the peak at @xmath12 . towards @xmath18 .
the lines of constant potential are sketched ; they allow the wavepacket to spread as it reaches @xmath160 . ] now let us see what this toy model represents .
if @xmath159 vanishes near @xmath18 , then the wavefunction can easily spread over a large range of values of @xmath55 once the quantum gets close to @xmath18 .
this represents the fact that there is a large phase space of fuzzball states ( given by the bekenstein entropy ) which can be accessed once an infalling shell comes close enough to the origin . for larger @xmath17
there are much fewer states for the given energy , while at infinity there are again many states possible because of the large volume of space available .
first consider a classical particle moving in this @xmath161 space .
we can assume @xmath162 consistently , and the particle just reaches the point @xmath163 at the end of its motion .
now consider the quantum problem , and start with a wavepacket @xmath164 at large @xmath17 .
if @xmath5 is large enough , the wavepacket will manage to pass through the location of steep potential at @xmath12 , and emerge into the region at small @xmath17 .
but in this region there is no potential limiting the wavefunction in the @xmath55 direction , so it can spread over the region @xmath165 .
thus while the classical solution suggested that the endpoint of the motion is at @xmath163 , the actual wavefunction can spread over all @xmath55 on reaching @xmath18 .
this effect becomes more pronounced if we have a large number of transverse directions like @xmath55 . in our actual problem
the wavefunction of a collapsing shell can spread over the very large of @xmath44 fuzzball states after the shell becomes smaller than a certain size .
it is possible that the consequent spreading of the wavefunction invalidates a classical analysis of the motion of the shell .
let us summarize the above discussion on the possible dynamics of fuzzballs .
a principal feature characterizing black holes is their large entropy .
the traditional picture of the hole does not exhibit the microstates required to explain this entropy .
if we take the presence of the large number of microstates into account , then the wavefunction of a collapsing shell might spread to a nontrivial extent over this vast phase space of allowed solutions .
the resulting dynamics would not correspond to a given quantum moving on a given black hole geometry , but rather lead to a wavefunctional @xmath166 $ ] that is spread over all possible geometries .
if this happens then we can not argue that the light cones of the traditional black hole geometry trap the information of the shell forever and lead to information loss .
so what is the fuzzball proposal and what does it say about the information problem ?
suppose we go to a condensed matter physicist , and tell him about the information paradox .
we show him the principles ( a ) , ( b ) listed in section [ introduction ] , and tell him that they are reasonable conditions to assume for quantum gravity .
we then prove to him that given these conditions , there will _ have _ to be a violation of quantum unitarity .
since the condensed matter person uses quantum theory , he would be very concerned that quantum theory needs a fundamental modification , even though the violation may not be significant in his systems of interest .
indeed , he would probably agree that resolving this paradox should be an important goal of theoretical physics .
now let us see how the results of the fuzzball program change the situation .
the fuzzball proposal does not require new physics , or try to develop abstract principles about what happens in black holes .
it simply takes a fully consistent theory of quantum gravity string theory and explicitly makes examples of microstates of black holes .
all states made so far turn out to be different from the traditional geometry of a black hole : the microstates do not have an ` information free horizon ' . thus condition ( a ) of the hawking ` theorem ' breaks down .
the fuzzball ` conjecture ' just says that the microstates not yet constructed would continue to have this feature ; thus there should not be two sharply different classes of microstates , one with ` information free horizons ' and one without .
given the results of the fuzzball program , what would the condensed matter physicist say ?
he can not agree that there is any information _ paradox_. a paradox is a sharp contradiction that we can not find a way around .
if we can find a way around the paradox for some black hole states , then we can not argue that there is any sharp contradiction with black holes , even though we have not yet constructed all possible states for all holes .
thus the condensed matter person will simply tell us to go and make other fuzzball states , and come back only if we can show that there are states of black holes that are _ not _ fuzzballs . to summarize ,
now the ` boot is on the other leg ' ; with the results from the fuzzball program we do not have an information ` paradox ' unless we can show that the behavior of microstates found so far does not continue in natural way to the class of all microstates .
but it is important to note that this does not mean that we understand all there is to know about black holes . for one thing , we still have a lot to learn about the dynamics of black holes .
we have conjectured some aspects of dynamics above , and it would be good to check these ideas in concrete detail and to understand what role is played by the large phase space of fuzzball solutions . in the early days of of the fuzzball program
there were some concerns that quantum corrections may destroy the fuzzball nature of 2-charge solutions , and that 3-charge microstates may not be fuzzballs like the 2-charge ones .
possible quantum corrections were investigated @xcite and no evidence was found that they would be a problem ; the magnitude of these corrections was shown to be bounded because of the geometric structure of the fuzzball solution .
large numbers of 3-charge and 4-charge solutions have been made , and now there are also families of nonextremal solutions .
for these reasons , perhaps at this point we should accept the hypothesis that the @xmath44 states of the hole are fuzzballs , and see what this hypothesis tells us about the physics of black holes .
one thing we can do with the fuzzball picture is ask if we can find evidence for various ideas that have been suggested in the past : \(a ) it has been suggested @xcite that the observations made by an infalling observer are given by a description that is ` complementary ' to the observations made by an observer at infinity .
let us see if we can say anything about this suggestion from our microstate constructions . in @xcite the infall of a test quantum into the extremal 2-charge system
was studied in the cft picture .
it was found that there were _ three _ different logical ways to define time evolution for the quantum : one suited to an infalling quantum , one to an emerging quantum , and one symmetrical between these two , which may be appropriate for an observer at infinity .
simple states in one description look very complicated in the other , with the ` complication ' determined by the entropy of the state .
note that we do not have different hilbert spaces for different observers .
nevertheless , it would be good to see if there is a relation between such effects and notion of complementarity .
\(b ) recently it has been suggested @xcite that there is a ` future boundary condition ' that must be imposed at the black hole singularity .
this makes the state at the singularity unique , and forces information to come out in the hawking radiation . with fuzzballs , we find that states of the hole ` swell up ' and become big because we need an adequate phase space to hold @xmath44 states @xcite .
thus with fuzzballs there is a sense in which data can not be ` focused ' to a singularity .
perhaps this effect can be interpreted as some kind of a boundary condition at a singularity , and thus a relation found with the idea of a boundary condition at the singularity @xcite .
\(c ) in one of the earliest attempts at resolving the information paradox @xcite it was argued that when considering virtual quanta , we should take into account their gravitational backreaction ; thus the creation operator for a scalar quantum should be ` dressed ' with gravity excitations .
for black holes , it was argued that this would lead to large gravitational backreaction from the hawking radiation quanta , destroying the traditional picture of semiclassical particle production at a low curvature horizon .
this proposal has a standard counter - argument : the gravitational effects of the _ pair _ of produced quanta should cancel out at the horizon , so that the hawking derivation is not really invalidated .
let us now recall our discussion of section [ spread ] , where we have seen that to follow the effect of an infalling shell we must expand its wavefunction in eigenstates of the _ total _ system ( matter+gravity ) , with energy ( [ stotal ] ) .
so while the argument of @xcite may not work for the hawking quanta of a scalar field on a spherically symmetric background , with the full set of nonperturbative black hole microstates we do find support for the idea that matter states should be studied only with their full gravitational backreaction included .
\(d ) there have been studies @xcite of geodesics in the traditional black hole geometry , where it was found that complex geodesics gave a dominant saddle point describing the correlation of operators in the dual cft ; these correlations were then used as a way of characterization of the singularity .
fuzzballs states are not expected to have such a singularity individually ( though the quantum fuzz does get more dense towards the center for a typical state ) .
but when we take an average over fuzzball states , the traditional black hole geometry can appear as a saddle point of the entire sum @xcite , and it would be interesting to see if the complex geodesics emerge naturally to describe expectation values of correlation functions in the ensemble of fuzzball states . a crucial question now is to extract the essential lessons of the fuzzball program , and see what it tells us about the structure of quantum gravity when we have large amounts of matter crushed at high densities .
clearly , one feature that we have seen is that quantum gravity effects do not extend over a fixed distance like @xmath0 ; instead this distance increases with the number of quanta involved in the black hole bound state .
what does this tell us about cosmology , where we also have large amounts of matter at high densities ?
in @xcite the state of the early universe was modeled after the states that give the entropy of black holes , and the resulting evolution was studied .
the universe did not inflate .
but the nonlocal correlations in the quantum bound state extended right across the universe .
so we might have a different possible resolution of the ` horizon problem ' : the universe is homogeneous because of quantum nonlocal effects at very early times .
there are many other questions that we need to answer however before we can get a proper understanding of the early universe .
what determines the initial state ? if this state to be determined from first principles , or to be randomly chosen from a given set ?
we do not know how to address such questions yet , but knowing the nature of black hole microstates should be a start in understanding the dense matter that must almost certainly be a feature of the far past .
i would like to thank steve avery , borun chowdhury , sumit das , stefano giusto and oleg lunin for many helpful comments .
this work was supported in part by doe grant de - fg02 - 91er-40690 .
10 s. w. hawking , commun .
phys . * 43 * , 199 ( 1975 ) .
s. d. mathur , arxiv:0803.2030 [ hep - th ] .
j. d. bekenstein , phys .
d * 7 * , 2333 ( 1973 ) . s. d. mathur , fortsch .
phys . * 53 * , 793 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0502050 ] .
s. d. mathur , class .
* 23 * , r115 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0510180 ] .
i. bena and n. p. warner , arxiv : hep - th/0701216 ; n. p. warner , arxiv:0810.2596 [ hep - th ] .
k. skenderis and m. taylor , phys .
* 467 * , 117 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0804.0552 [ hep - th ] ] . g. t. horowitz and j. m. maldacena , jhep * 0402 * , 008 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0310281 ] .
g. lopes cardoso , b. de wit and t. mohaupt , class .
. grav .
* 17 * , 1007 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9910179 ] ; g. lopes cardoso , b. de wit , j. kappeli and t. mohaupt , jhep * 0012 * , 019 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0009234 ] .
l. susskind , arxiv : hep - th/9309145 ; j. g. russo and l. susskind , nucl .
b * 437 * , 611 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9405117 ] .
a. sen , nucl .
b * 440 * , 421 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9411187 ] ; a. sen , mod .
a * 10 * , 2081 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9504147 ] .
m. cvetic and d. youm , nucl
. phys .
b * 476 * , 118 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9603100 ] ; d. youm , phys .
rept . * 316 * , 1 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9710046 ] .
v. balasubramanian , j. de boer , e. keski - vakkuri and s. f. ross , phys .
d * 64 * , 064011 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0011217 . j. m. maldacena and l. maoz , jhep * 0212 * , 055 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0012025 ]
. o. lunin and s. d. mathur , nucl .
b * 610 * , 49 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0105136 .
d. mateos and p. k. townsend , phys .
* 87 * , 011602 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0103030 ] ; r. emparan , d. mateos and p. k. townsend , jhep * 0107 * , 011 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0106012 ] ; b. c. palmer and d. marolf , jhep * 0406 * , 028 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0403025 ] ; s. d. mathur , nucl .
b * 529 * , 295 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9706151 ] .
o. lunin , j. maldacena and l. maoz , arxiv : hep - th/0212210 .
m. taylor , jhep * 0603 * , 009 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0507223 ] .
s. giusto , s. d. mathur and y. k. srivastava , nucl .
b * 754 * , 233 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0510235 ] .
o. lunin and s. d. mathur , nucl .
b * 623 * , 342 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0109154 ] .
o. lunin and s. d. mathur , phys .
lett . *
88 * , 211303 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0202072 ] .
o. lunin , s. d. mathur and a. saxena , nucl . phys .
b * 655 * , 185 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0211292 ] .
s. r. das and s. d. mathur , phys .
b * 375 * , 103 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9601152 ] .
j. m. maldacena and l. susskind , nucl .
b * 475 * , 679 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9604042 ] .
i. kanitscheider , k. skenderis and m. taylor , jhep * 0704 * , 023 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0611171 ] ; i. kanitscheider , k. skenderis and m. taylor , jhep * 0706 * , 056 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0704.0690 [ hep - th ] ] ; k. skenderis and m. taylor , phys .
* 98 * , 071601 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0609154 ] . v. jejjala , o. madden , s. f. ross and g. titchener , phys .
d * 71 * , 124030 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0504181 ] .
n. seiberg and e. witten , jhep * 9904 * , 017 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9903224 ] ; f. larsen and e. j. martinec , jhep * 9906 * , 019 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9905064 ] ; j. de boer , nucl .
b * 548 * , 139 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9806104 ] .
a. strominger and c. vafa , phys .
b * 379 * , 99 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9601029 ] .
v. cardoso , o. j. c. dias , j. l. hovdebo and r. c. myers , phys .
d * 73 * , 064031 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0512277 ] .
b. d. chowdhury and s. d. mathur , class .
grav . * 25 * , 135005 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0711.4817 [ hep - th ] ] ; b. d. chowdhury and s. d. mathur , arxiv:0806.2309 [ hep - th ] ; b. d. chowdhury and s. d. mathur , arxiv:0810.2951 [ hep - th ] . c. g. callan and j. m. maldacena , nucl .
b * 472 * , 591 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9602043 ] ; a. dhar , g. mandal and s. r. wadia , phys .
b * 388 * , 51 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9605234 ] ; s. r. das and s. d. mathur , nucl . phys .
b * 478 * , 561 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9606185 ] ; s. r. das and s. d. mathur , nucl .
b * 482 * , 153 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9607149 ] ; j. m. maldacena and a. strominger , phys .
d * 55 * , 861 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9609026 ] .
s. giusto , s. d. mathur and a. saxena , nucl .
b * 701 * , 357 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0405017 ] . s. giusto , s. d. mathur and a. saxena , arxiv : hep - th/0406103 .
o. lunin , jhep * 0404 * , 054 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0404006 ] .
j. b. gutowski , d. martelli and h. s. reall , class .
grav . *
20 * , 5049 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0306235 ] . s. giusto and s. d. mathur , arxiv : hep - th/0409067 . i. bena and n. p. warner , adv .
* 9 * , 667 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0408106 ] ; i. bena and n. p. warner , phys .
d * 74 * , 066001 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0505166 ] ; i. bena , c. w. wang and n. p. warner , phys .
d * 75 * , 124026 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0604110 ] ; i. bena , c. w. wang and n. p. warner , jhep * 0611 * , 042 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0608217 ] ; i. bena , n. bobev and n. p. warner , jhep * 0708 * , 004 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0705.3641 [ hep - th ] ] ; i. bena , c. w. wang and n. p. warner , jhep * 0807 * , 019 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0706.3786 [ hep - th ] ] .
p. berglund , e. g. gimon and t. s. levi , jhep * 0606 * , 007 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0505167 ] ; v. balasubramanian , e. g. gimon and t. s. levi , jhep * 0801 * , 056 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0606118 ] ; e. g. gimon and t. s. levi , jhep * 0804 * , 098 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0706.3394 [ hep - th ] ] .
a. saxena , g. potvin , s. giusto and a. w. peet , jhep * 0604 * , 010 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0509214 ] ; j. ford , s. giusto and a. saxena , nucl .
b * 790 * , 258 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0612227 ] ; s. giusto and a. saxena , class .
* 24 * , 4269 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0705.4484 [ hep - th ] ] ; j. ford , s. giusto , a. peet and a. saxena , class .
grav . * 25 * , 075014 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0708.3823 [ hep - th ] ] ; s. giusto , s. f. ross and a. saxena , jhep * 0712 * , 065 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0708.3845 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. denef , jhep * 0210 * , 023 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0206072 ] .
i. bena and p. kraus , phys .
d * 70 * , 046003 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0402144 ] ; i. bena , phys .
d * 70 * , 105018 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0404073 ] .
e. g. gimon and p. horava , arxiv : hep - th/0405019 ; d. bak , y. hyakutake and n. ohta , nucl .
b * 696 * , 251 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0404104 ] ; d. bak , y. hyakutake , s. kim and n. ohta , arxiv : hep - th/0407253 .
i. bena , n. bobev , c. ruef and n. p. warner , arxiv:0804.4487 [ hep - th ] .
v. s. rychkov , jhep * 0601 * , 063 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0512053 ] ; j. de boer , s. el - showk , i. messamah and d. v. d. bleeken , arxiv:0807.4556 [ hep - th ] . j. de boer , j. manschot , k. papadodimas and e. verlinde , arxiv:0809.0507 [ hep - th ] ; j. de boer , f. denef , s. el - showk , i. messamah and d. van den bleeken , arxiv:0802.2257 [ hep - th ] ; j. raeymaekers , w. van herck , b. vercnocke and t. wyder , jhep * 0810 * , 039 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0805.3506 [ hep - th ] ] ; m. c. n. cheng , jhep * 0703 * , 070 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0611156 ]
. v. balasubramanian , j. de boer , v. jejjala and j. simon , jhep * 0512 * , 006 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0508023 ] ; l. f. alday , j. de boer and i. messamah , jhep * 0612 * , 063 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0607222 ] ; m. boni and p. j. silva , jhep * 0510 * , 070 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0506085 ] ; v. balasubramanian , b. czech , v. e. hubeny , k. larjo , m. rangamani and j. simon , gen . rel .
* 40 * , 1863 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0701122 ] ; k. papadodimas , h. h. shieh and m. van raamsdonk , jhep * 0704 * , 069 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0612066 ] ; n. ogawa and s. terashima , arxiv:0805.1405 [ hep - th ] ; s. bellucci and b. n. tiwari , arxiv:0808.3921 [ hep - th ] . j. mcgreevy , l. susskind and n. toumbas , jhep * 0006 * , 008 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0003075 ] .
d. gaiotto , a. simons , a. strominger and x. yin , arxiv : hep - th/0412179 ; d. gaiotto , a. strominger and x. yin , jhep * 0511 * , 017 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0412322 ] .
s. r. das , s. giusto , s. d. mathur , y. srivastava , x. wu and c. zhou , nucl .
b * 733 * , 297 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0507080 ] .
f. denef , d. gaiotto , a. strominger , d. van den bleeken and x. yin , arxiv : hep - th/0703252 .
r. c. myers , jhep * 9912 * , 022 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9910053 ] .
e. g. gimon and t. s. levi , jhep * 0804 * , 098 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0706.3394 [ hep - th ] ] .
g. mandal , s. raju and m. smedback , phys .
d * 77 * , 046011 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0709.1168 [ hep - th ] ] ; d. martelli and j. sparks , nucl .
b * 759 * , 292 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0608060 ] ; a. basu and g. mandal , jhep * 0707 * , 014 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0608093 ] ; g. mandal and n. v. suryanarayana , jhep * 0703 * , 031 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0606088 ] ; i. biswas , d. gaiotto , s. lahiri and s. minwalla , jhep * 0712 * , 006 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0606087 ] . s. giusto and s. d. mathur , nucl .
b * 738 * , 48 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0412133 ] .
s. d. mathur , arxiv:0805.3716 [ hep - th ] .
l. susskind , l. thorlacius and j. uglum , phys .
d * 48 * , 3743 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9306069 ] ; l. susskind , phys . rev .
lett . * 71 * , 2367 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9307168 ] ; d. a. lowe , j. polchinski , l. susskind , l. thorlacius and j. uglum , phys .
d * 52 * , 6997 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9506138 ] .
g. t hooft , nucl .
b * 335 * , 138 ( 1990 ) ; k. schoutens , h. l. verlinde and e. p. verlinde , phys .
d * 48 * , 2670 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9304128 ] ; y. kiem , h. l. verlinde and e. p. verlinde , phys .
d * 52 * , 7053 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9502074 ] .
s. d. mathur , int .
j. mod .
d * 17 * , 583 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0705.3828 [ hep - th ] ] .
p. kraus , h. ooguri and s. shenker , phys .
d * 67 * , 124022 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0212277 ] ; l. fidkowski , v. hubeny , m. kleban and s. shenker , jhep * 0402 * , 014 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0306170 ] .
b. d. chowdhury and s. d. mathur , class .
* 24 * ( 2007 ) 2689 [ arxiv : hep - th/0611330 ] ; s. d. mathur , arxiv:0803.3727 [ hep - th ] ; s. kalyana rama , gen .
grav . * 39 * , 1773 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0702202 ] . | the black hole information paradox is one of the most important issues in theoretical physics .
we review some recent progress using string theory in understanding the nature of black hole microstates . for all cases where
these microstates have been constructed , one finds that they are horizon sized ` fuzzballs ' .
most computations are for extremal states , but recently one has been able to study a special family of non - extremal microstates , and see ` information carrying radiation ' emerge from these gravity solutions .
we discuss how the fuzzball picture can resolve the information paradox .
we use the nature of fuzzball states to make some conjectures on the dynamical aspects of black holes , observing that the large phase space of fuzzball solutions can make the black hole more ` quantum ' than assumed in traditional treatments .
_ black holes , string theory _ : |
quantum entanglement is a feature of quantum mechanics that has captured much recent interest due to its essential role in quantum information processing @xcite . it may be characterized and manipulated independently of its physical realization , and it obeys a set of conservation laws ;
as such , it is regarded and treated much like a physical resource .
it proves useful in making quantitative predictions to quantify entanglement.when one has complete information about a bipartite system
subsystems @xmath0 and @xmath1the state of the system is pure and there exists a well established measure of entanglement the _ entropy of entanglement _ , evaluated as the von neumann entropy of the reduced density matrix , @xmath2 with @xmath3 .
this measure is unity for the bell states and is conserved under local operations and classical communication .
unfortunately , however , quantum systems in nature interact with their environment ; states of practical concern are therefore mixed , in which case the quantification of entanglement becomes less clear .
given an ensemble of pure states , @xmath4 with probabilities @xmath5 , a natural generalization of @xmath6 is its weighted average @xmath7 .
a difficulty arises , though , when one considers that a given density operator may be decomposed in infinitely many ways , leading to infinitely many values for this average entanglement .
the density operator for an equal mixture of bell states @xmath8 , for example , is identical to that for a mixture of @xmath9 and @xmath10 , yet by the above measure the two decompositions have entanglement one and zero , respectively .
various measures have been proposed to circumvent this problem , most of which evaluate a lower bound .
one such measure , the _ entanglement of formation _ , @xmath11 @xcite , is defined as the minimal amount of entanglement required to form the density operator @xmath12 , while the _ entanglement of distillation _ , @xmath13 @xcite , is the guaranteed amount of entanglement that can be extracted from @xmath12 .
these measures satisfy the requirements for a physical entanglement measure set out by horodecki _
et al_. @xcite .
they give the value zero for @xmath14 , which might be thought somewhat counterintuitive , since this state can be viewed as representing a sequence of random `` choices '' between two bell states , both of which are maximally entangled .
this is unavoidable , however , because assigning @xmath15 a non - zero value of entanglement would imply that entanglement can be generated by local operations .
the problem is fundamental , steming from the inherent uncertainty surrounding a mixed state : the state provides an incomplete description of the physical system , and in view of the lack of knowledge a definitive measure of entanglement can not be given .
an interacting system and environment inevitably become entangled .
the problem of bipartite entanglement for an open system is therefore one of tripartite entanglement for the system and environment .
complicating the situation , the state of the environment is complex and unknown .
conventionally , the partial trace with respect to the environment is taken , yielding a mixed state for the bipartite system .
if one wishes for a more complete characterization of the entanglement than provided by the above measures , somehow the inherent uncertainty of the mixed state description must be removed . to this end , nha and carmichael @xcite recently introduced a measure of entanglement for open systems based upon quantum trajectory unravelings of the open system dynamics @xcite .
central to their approach is a consideration of the way in which information about the system is read , by making measurements , from the environment .
the evolution of the system conditioned on the measurement record is followed , and the entanglement measure is then contextual dependent upon the kind of measurements made .
suppose , for example , that at some time @xmath16 the system and environment are in the entangled state @xmath17 a partial trace with respect to @xmath18 yields a mixed state for @xmath19 .
if , on the other hand , an observer makes a measurement on the environment with respect to the basis @xmath20 , obtaining the `` result '' @xmath21 , the reduced state of the system and environment is @xmath22 with conditional system state @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the probability of the particular measurement result .
thus , the system and environment are disentangled , so the system state is pure and its bipartite entanglement is defined by the von neumann entropy , eq .
( [ eq : von - neumann ] ) .
nha and carmichael @xcite apply this idea to the continuous measurement limit , where @xmath25 executes a conditional evolution over time .
in this paper we follow the lead of nha and carmichael , also carvalho _ et al . _
@xcite , not to compute their entanglement measure _ per se _ , but to examine the entanglement _ dynamics _ of a cascaded qubit system coupled through the oneway exchange of photons .
the system considered has been shown to produce unconditional entangled states generally a superposition of bell states as the steady - state solution to a master equation @xcite .
for a special choice of parameters ( resonance ) , a maximally entangled bell state is achieved @xmath26 except that the approach to the steady state takes place over an infinite amount of time . here
we analyze the conditional evolution of the qubit system to illuminate the dynamical creation of entanglement in the general case , and to explain , in particular , the infinitely slow approach to steady - state in the special case .
we demonstrate that in the special case the conditional dynamics exhibit a distinct bimodality , where the approach to the bell state is only one of two possibilities for the asymptotic evolution : the second we call an _ entangled - state cycle _ , where the qubits execute a sustained stochastic switching between two bell states . though involving just two qubits and elementary quantum transitions , the situation is similar to that of a bimodal system in classical statistical physics in the limit of a vanishing transition rate between attractors . the physical model of the cascaded qubit system
is presented in sec .
[ subsec2_1 ] and the quantum trajectory unraveling of its conditional dynamics in sec .
[ subsec3_1 ] . in sec .
[ subsec4_1 ] we analyze the quantum trajectory equations to demonstrate bimodality and the existence of entangled - state cycles .
finally , a discussion and conclusions are presented in sec .
[ subsec5_1 ] .
in this section we briefly outline the physical model for the cascaded qubit system to be analyzed . a more detailed description , together with the techniques and assumptions used to derive the model master equation presented here , is available in @xcite .
the system considered consists of two high - finesse optical cavities , each containing a single tightly - confined atom , the cavities arranged in a cascaded configuration with unidirectional coupling from cavity 1 to cavity 2 ( fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] ) . for simplicity
, we consider the cavity modes to be identical , with resonance frequency @xmath27 and field decay rate @xmath28 .
inefficiencies and losses in the coupling between the cavities are modeled by a real parameter @xmath29 , @xmath30 , with perfect coupling corresponding to @xmath31 .
the atoms are assumed to have five relevant electronic levels , of which two ground states , @xmath32 and @xmath33 , represent an effective two - state system , or qubit . and
@xmath33 , to three excited states , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and @xmath36.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] for each atom , the cavity field in combination with auxiliary laser fields ( incident from the side of the cavity ) drives two separate resonant raman transitions between states @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
an additional laser field coupled to the @xmath37 transition provides a tunable light shift of the energy of state @xmath32 .
all fields are assumed far detuned from the atomic excited states , so these states may be adiabatically eliminated and atomic spontaneous emission ignored . under the further assumption that the cavity field decay rate is much larger than the transition rates between @xmath32 and @xmath33 , the cavity fields may also be adiabatically eliminated to yield a master equation for the reduced two - atom density matrix @xmath12 , @xmath38}+{\left[\hat r_2,\rho\hat r_1^\dag\right]}\right)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath39 where @xmath40 , and @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the rates of @xmath43 and @xmath44 transitions , respectively . by virtue of the cavity output ,
the system is an open system and solutions to master equation ( [ eq : me ] ) generally describe mixed states . under appropriate conditions
, however , the system evolves to a pure and entangled steady state .
if the coupling between cavities is perfect ( @xmath31 ) and the parameters of the subsystems are the same ( @xmath45 , @xmath46 ) then the steady state is the pure state @xmath47 where we use the abbreviated notation @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
then when @xmath50 , which we shall refer to as the _ resonance _ condition , the steady state is a maximally - entangled bell state .
this may seem to be ideal , but a problem arises when we consider the eigenvalues of the operator @xmath51 . specifically , the characteristic time for the system to reach steady state , @xmath52 , where @xmath53 denotes the eigenvalue of @xmath51 with smallest ( in magnitude ) non - zero real part , approaches infinity as the resonance condition is approached .
this is shown by the plot in fig .
[ fig : fig2 ] .
thus the master equation itself , in particular its steady state , offers limited insight into the behavior of the system at resonance .
we wish to learn more about this special case ; in particular , how does the entanglement develop dynamically .
also , if additional information is factored into the description , by making measurements on the environment , can we better characterize the long term behavior , or possibly find perfect entanglement after a finite time ?
we demonstrate that quantum trajectory theory can provide answers to these questions . the relaxation time @xmath54 plotted as a function of @xmath55 .
note the singularity at resonance , @xmath56.,scaledwidth=40.0% ]
as with any open system , the first step in unraveling the master equation is to identify the points of coupling to the environment .
the first is obvious the output from cavity 2 . to measure this output ,
let us assume the existence of an ideal photon detector in the path of the output from cavity 2 ; we call it _ detector 1_. the second point of coupling to the environment is more subtle
. our model does not assume the inter - cavity coupling to be perfect ; only a fraction @xmath29 of the output photon flux from cavity 1 makes it into cavity 2 .
physically , this loss may be caused , for example , by non - ideal transmissivity of the faraday isolators or by absorption in the cavity mirrors .
these imperfections cause photons to be scattered into the environment in some uncontrollable fashion .
formally , though , this is equivalent to assuming that the apparatus is ideal , except that there exists a beamsplitter between the cavities , as drawn schematically in fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] .
we therefore further assume the existence of a second photon detector to collect photons reflected by this beamsplitter ; we call it
_ detector 2_. we now proceed to develop the quantum trajectory formalism for the cascaded qubit system . in this approach the system is described by a pure state which is dependent on ( conditioned on ) the counting histories , or records , of detectors 1 and 2 .
firstly , we rewrite the master equation in a form suitable for translation into the quantum trajectory language .
we reexpress eq .
( [ eq : me ] ) in the form @xmath57 with @xmath58-\frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1,2 }
\left(\hat c_i^{\dag}\hat c_i \rho+\rho\hat c_i^{\dag}\hat c_i\right),\\ \mathcal{s}\rho&=\sum_{i=1,2}\hat c_i \rho\hat c_i^{\dag},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath59 then , within quantum trajectory theory , the evolution of the system is described by a pure state @xmath60 which evolves under the non - hermitian effective hamiltonian @xmath61 the continuous evolution interrupted at random times by quantum jumps , @xmath62 , where the jumps occur with probability @xmath63 in time interval @xmath64 .
physically , the jump operators @xmath65 and @xmath66 account for the reduction of the state of the system , given a photon count is recorded by detector 1 or detector 2 , respectively .
thus , within the quantum trajectory description of the coupled cavity system , we consider an experiment in which ideal detectors are employed , such that every scattered photon is detected and recorded . given the history of detector ` clicks ' , one has complete information about the system state , in the sense that that state is always pure ; hence , although the solution to the master equation is generally mixed , one is able to characterize the entanglement in an unambiguous ( conditional ) fashion @xcite .
consider the special case where the coupling between the cavities is optimal ( @xmath31 ) . in this case
there is only one output from the system , that from cavity 2 , recorded by detector 1 .
standard numerical algorithms @xcite have been used to simulate typical quantum trajectories for various values of @xmath55 .
specifically , we consider the evolution of the conditional expectation of the operator product @xmath67 , where @xmath68 is the pauli operator diagonal in the @xmath69representation , @xmath70 this expectation has a number of convenient properties ; for example , the steady - state value @xmath71 regardless of the value of @xmath55 , which makes it easy to compare rates of convergence to the steady state for different system parameters . -0.5
cm figure [ fig : fig4 ] contrasts the solution to the master equation and a single quantum trajectory .
the solution to the master equation exhibits a completely smooth evolution that tends asymptotically towards the steady state .
the quantum trajectory , on the other hand , undergoes a sequence of switches between two extreme values of @xmath72 , which occur at each photon detection . provided the parameters
are chosen away from resonance , the photon detections eventually stop and the trajectory settles into the steady state ( [ eq : ss ] ) , with @xmath73 ; the steady state is clearly a dark state . at resonance , however , the photon detections may continue indefinitely .
physically , this seems plausible , since it simply implies that the atoms continue to switch between states @xmath32 and @xmath33 , scattering one photon with each transition . at resonance , apparently
, a unique equilibrium dark state can not be established .
the cyclic behavior that replaces it is completely invisible if we consider only the ensemble average a vivid demonstration of how single quantum trajectories can provide additional insight into the evolution of an open quantum system .
the oscillatory behavior featured in fig .
[ fig : fig4 ] hints at a simple cyclic process .
in fact , it is simple enough that we can understand why it occurs without resorting to numerics . in this section
we formulate a graphical description of individual trajectories .
figure [ fig : fig4 ] demonstrates that the conditional expectation @xmath72 is conserved during the periods of evolution between quantum jumps .
the positively and negatively correlated subspaces @xmath74 are coupled only through quantum jumps .
noting that @xmath75 are each @xmath76-dimensional ( assuming real amplitudes without loss of generality ) , we manage to break up a @xmath77-dimensional space into two @xmath76-dimensional planes , linked to one another by the quantum jumps .
we refer to this representation as the _ cascaded system phase space_. trajectories within it can be viewed as lines moving continuosly within either plane and jumping discontinuously between the planes .
we use phase space portraits within @xmath78 and @xmath79 to characterize the behavior of the system , where for the sake of simplicity , and without loss of generality , we are assuming @xmath80 and @xmath81 to be real .
we define @xmath82 and scale time by setting @xmath83 .
the master equation then takes the form ( @xmath31 ) @xmath84 where @xmath85 the resonance condition is now @xmath86 .
it is useful to convert to a matrix notation , such that a pure state @xmath60 of the system is represented by a @xmath77-vector , @xmath87 and system operators are written as @xmath88 matrices , e.g. , @xmath89 and @xmath90 the evolution of @xmath60under @xmath91 is written as a linear differential equation in four variables , @xmath92\ ! { |\phi\rangle}\nonumber\\ & = \left(\begin{array}{cccc } -2&0&0&2r\\ 0&-(1+r^2)&2r^2&0\\ 0&2&-(1+r^2)&0\\ 2r&0&0&-2r^2\\\end{array}\right ) \label{eqn : basicde}\!{|\phi\rangle}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as noted above , this evolution is constrained within either @xmath78 or @xmath79 .
thus we can write @xmath60 as a vector sum of two orthogonal components @xmath93 and @xmath94 , @xmath95 , to obtain the decoupled dynamics @xmath96 eigenvectors of the two dynamical matrices correspond to states of the system that are preserved under the evolution between quantum jumps .
note , however , that it does not necessarily follow that such a state is a steady state of the quantum trajectory evolution as a whole ; it must eventually experience a quantum jump if its norm decays i.e .
, the corresponding eigenvalue is not zero .
recall from quantum trajectory theory that the probability for a state not to jump prior to time @xmath16 is given by its norm @xcite .
for the systems of equations given above we find the following ( unnormalised ) eigenstates and eigenvalues : 1 .
@xmath97 , @xmath98 ; this is the steady state of the system for @xmath99 .
2 . @xmath100 , @xmath101 ; this state in @xmath78 is orthogonal to @xmath102 and must eventually jump to a state in @xmath79 .
3 . @xmath103 , @xmath104 ; this state in @xmath79 must eventually jump to a state in @xmath78 unless @xmath86 ; in the latter case it plays no role once an entangled - state cycle is initiated ( see below ) .
4 . @xmath105 , @xmath106 ; this state in @xmath79 must eventually jump to a state in @xmath78 . in the special case of resonance , @xmath86 ,
there are two independent steady states , @xmath102 and @xmath107 , which helps to explain the failure of the master equation evolution to approach a unique steady state .
it also suggests a fundamental feature of the indefinite switching , the cyclic behavior , revealed by individual quantum trajectories : during such an _ entangled - state cycle _ , the system state must remain orthogonal to @xmath102 and @xmath107 .
we verify this shortly , after examining the trajectory evolution away from resonance , where the steady state @xmath102 is always reached for perfect inter - cavity coupling .
typical quantum trajectories for @xmath108 are shown in figs .
[ fig : fig5 ] and [ fig : fig6 ] , where the @xmath78 and @xmath79 subspaces are drawn as circular planes .
normalized states are located on the circumferences of the circles .
the bell states @xmath109 lie at intersections of the circumference with the dotted lines as shown . between quantum jumps , under the influence of the non - hermitian hamiltonian @xmath91
, the norm of the state decays and the point representing it within the phase space moves to the interior of one of the circles .
quantum jumps cause a switch from @xmath78 to @xmath79 or vice - versa .
they are represented by the lines connecting the two planes , where for illustrative purposes , the system state is renormalized after each quantum jump ; thus jumps terminate at points on the circumference of the circles .
we restrict ourselves to separable initial states located in one or other of the two subspaces ; for example , the states @xmath110 and @xmath111 , respectively , are considered in figs .
[ fig : fig5 ] and [ fig : fig6 ] .
the action of the jump operator @xmath65 on states located in @xmath78 ( with renormalization ) is @xmath112 while the action of @xmath65 on states in @xmath79 is @xmath113 thus , when a quantum jump occurs , any state within @xmath78 collapses onto the bell state @xmath114 in @xmath79 , while any state within @xmath79 collapses onto the state @xmath115 in @xmath78 .
consider an initial normalized state in @xmath78 , @xmath116 , for some ( real ) @xmath117 .
given that @xmath102 is a steady state of the evolution between quantum jumps , the probability of an eventual quantum jump to @xmath79 is @xmath118 while with probability @xmath119 the system evolves to the steady state @xmath102 without any photon emissions .
if a jump from @xmath79 to @xmath120 has just occurred , then by the same argument one shows that the probability of a future quantum jump to @xmath79 is @xmath121 , or , alternatively , the probability of reaching the steady state after such a jump is @xmath122 ^ 2 $ ] .
consider now an initial state in @xmath79 , @xmath123 , for some ( real ) @xmath124 .
owing to the instability of both @xmath107 and @xmath125 for @xmath99 , an eventual quantum jump is guaranteed ; thus , @xmath126 armed with this information , we move to an explanation of the quantum trajectories displayed in figs .
[ fig : fig5 ] and [ fig : fig6 ] . in fig .
[ fig : fig5 ] we plot three typical phase - space trajectories for @xmath108 and @xmath127 .
[ fig : fig5](a ) illustrates the case where the system evolves directly to the steady state @xmath102 .
the probability of this event is @xmath128 , so it is the most likely occurrence for the chosen parameters .
if a first quantum jump does occur , then typical trajectories are shown in figs .
[ fig : fig5](b ) and ( c ) . following the jump to @xmath129 in @xmath79 , a second jump returning the state to @xmath78 is guaranteed . for @xmath108 ,
this leaves the system in the state @xmath130 , from which the probability of a further cycle of jumps is @xmath131 .
thus , after a first quantum jump cycle , it is most likely that further cycles will follow , as seen in figs .
[ fig : fig5](b ) and ( c ) , where in both cases a total of five cycles ( ten photon detections ) occur before the system finally reaches the steady state . in fig .
[ fig : fig6 ] we plot three typical phase - space trajectories for @xmath108 and @xmath132 . in this case , at least one quantum jump is certain to occur , following which the probability of further jumps is @xmath131 , as above .
so for this initial condition , the most likely outcome is a sequence of quantum jump cycles following a first guaranteed photon detection . in fig .
[ fig : fig6 ] ( a ) only the first detection occurs , while in figs .
[ fig : fig6](b ) and ( c ) this detection is followed by a sequence of cycles before the steady state is eventually achieved .
the case @xmath86 is of particular interest .
the normalized eigenstates of the evolution between quantum jumps are the bell states @xmath133 , @xmath134 , @xmath135 , and @xmath136 .
the eigenvalues are @xmath137 and @xmath138 .
the action of the jump operator @xmath65 on states within @xmath78 simplifies to @xmath139 and its action on states within @xmath79 to @xmath140 for @xmath86 , photon detections , if they occur , are associated with collapses onto one of two maximally - entangled bell states . for initial states @xmath141 and @xmath142 in @xmath78 and @xmath79 , respectively ,
the system evolves continuously , without the emission of any photons , to @xmath133 and @xmath143 , with probabilities @xmath144 and @xmath145 in @xmath79 or @xmath146 in @xmath78 . in this case , as both terminal states are unstable under the between - jump evolution , a second detection and quantum jump must follow . according to eqs .
( [ eq : plusjump ] ) and ( [ eq : minusjump ] ) this simply exchanges @xmath147 for @xmath146 and vice - versa .
hence , a perpetual switching between bell states @xmath147 and @xmath146 occurs .
we designate this behavior an _ entangled - state cycle_. thus , at resonance we find a distinctly bimodal behavior .
the system either evolves into a maximally - entangled bell state without emitting photons , or an entangled - state cycle is initiated under which the system switches indefinitely between orthogonal bell states while emitting a continual stream of photons . as an aside , such behavior can be regarded as a quantum measurement that distinguishes the bell states @xmath148 from @xmath149 .
the two alternative outcomes of the quantum trajectory evolution are illustrated in figs .
[ fig : fig7 ] and [ fig : fig8 ] for the initial states @xmath150 in @xmath78 and @xmath132 in @xmath79 , respectively . with this choice of initial states
there are equal probabilities for reaching the steady states , @xmath151 [ fig .
[ fig : fig7](a ) ] and @xmath152 [ fig . [ fig : fig8](a ) ] , and for commencing an entangled - state cycle [ figs .
[ fig : fig7](b ) and [ fig : fig8](b ) ] . note that once an entangled - state cycle is initiated , the trajectory remains in a plane orthogonal to the lines defining @xmath151 and @xmath152 ; the cycle continues indefinitely our original model allowed for the possibility of imperfect intercavity coupling , through the parameter @xmath29 and the jump operator @xmath66 which describe the effects of photon loss in propagation between the two cavities .
focusing on the resonant case ( @xmath86 ) , we now consider the situation in which @xmath153 .
typical trajectories for @xmath154 are shown in figs .
[ fig : fig9](a ) and [ fig : fig10](a ) , with the two photon count records shown in frames ( b ) and ( c ) of the figures .
remarkably , entangled - state cycles persist , but now the system settles into one or other of two distinct cycles , involving either the symmetric or antisymmetric bell states . to understand the behavior , consider the forms of the operators involved ; in particular , for @xmath86 , we have effective hamiltonian @xmath155 and jump operators @xmath156 and @xmath157 significantly , these operators commute with one another , @xmath158=[\hat
c_1,\hat h_{\rm eff}]=[\hat c_2,\hat h_{\rm eff}]=0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] their operation upon the bell states is given by @xmath159 and @xmath160 thus , the bell states are eigenstates of @xmath91 , and the jump operators interchange bell states in @xmath78 and @xmath79 : each jump operator converts the symmetric ( antisymmetric ) bell state in @xmath78 to the symmetric ( antisymmetric ) bell state in @xmath79 and vice - versa .
now , let us consider a particular quantum trajectory for which a total of @xmath161 jumps occur , separated by the time intervals @xmath162 .
for an initial state @xmath163 , the ( unnormalized ) state at the conclusion of the @xmath161 jumps is written as @xmath164 where each @xmath165 is either @xmath65 or @xmath66 .
since all operators in the string acting on @xmath166 commute , this expression can be rewritten in a variety of forms , two of which prove to be especially useful in explaining the distinct behaviors illustrated by figs .
[ fig : fig9 ] and [ fig : fig10 ] .
in the first case , we may write @xmath167 passing all @xmath168 ocurrences of @xmath65 to the right and all @xmath169 occurrences of @xmath66 to the left ( @xmath170 ) ; in the second we write @xmath171 where all jump operators are passed to the left . the arbitrary ( pure ) initial state can be expressed as a superposition of bell states , @xmath172 where @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 , and @xmath176 are expansion coefficients , generally complex . substituting this expansion into eqs .
( [ phit1 ] ) and ( [ phit2 ] ) , and using eqs .
( [ heff1])([c2psi])assuming for simplicity that @xmath168 and @xmath169 are even the two forms for the state @xmath177 are @xmath178 where @xmath179 observe now that the ratio of the eigenvalues satisfies @xmath180 it follows that @xmath181 and @xmath182 allow us to predict quite distinct asymptotic behaviors for the system state . for sufficiently large @xmath168 , the contribution to @xmath181 from the symmetric bell states is negligible compared with the contribution from the antisymmetric bell states , in which case , using eqs .
( [ eq : cycle1 ] ) and ( [ eq : cycle1prime ] ) , @xmath183 the system is locked into a cycle between the two antisymmetric bell states , the situation illustrated in fig . [
fig : fig9 ] ( for @xmath184 , @xmath185 ) .
in contrast , for sufficiently large @xmath16 , the contribution to @xmath182 from the antisymmetric bell states is negligible compared with that from the symmetric bell states , and using eqs .
( [ eq : cycle2 ] ) and ( [ eq : cycle2prime ] ) , @xmath186 the system is locked into a cycle between the two symmetric bell states , as shown in fig .
[ fig : fig10 ] . which of the two cycles is chosen in a particular realization of the photon counting record is random , as is the time taken to settle into the cycle .
effectively , the decision is the outcome of a competition between the periods of evolution between quantum jumps and the jumps themselves specifically , those associated with photon counts at detector 1 . considering eqs .
( [ eq : cycle1prime ] ) and ( [ eq : ratio ] ) , we see that every count at detector 1 results in an increased probability to find the system in one of the antisymmetric bell states . on the other hand , from eqs .
( [ eq : cycle2prime ] ) and ( [ eq : ratio ] ) , the periods of evolution between counts have the reverse effect
they increase the probability for the system to be found in a symmetric bell state .
the critical factor that decides which tendency wins is the number of photon counts occuring at detector 1 over a given ( substantial ) interval of time .
if there are many , as in fig .
[ fig : fig9](b ) , the entangled - state cycle between antisymmetric bell states wins out ; if there are few , fig .
[ fig : fig10](b ) , the cycle between symmetric bell states occurs .
the same decision mechanism is observed in other examples @xcite .
note that counts at detector 2 are not involved not directly at least .
they do figure indirectly as a mechanism reducing the average number of counts at detector 1 ; indeed , they are the ultimate source of the asymmetry reflected in the ratio @xmath187 . as the system approaches a particular cycle the quantum trajectory evolution tends to reinforce the establishment of the cycle .
close to the antisymmetric cycle , the evolution between jumps is dominantly governed by @xmath188 and is therefore relatively fast .
this leads to frequent photon counts at detector 1 [ fig .
[ fig : fig9](b ) ] .
close to the symmetric cycle , the between - jump evolution is dominantly governed by @xmath189 , hence is relatively slow .
photon counts at detector 1 become much less frequent [ fig .
[ fig : fig10](b ) ] . from the dramatic difference in count rates at detector 1 for the two cycles ,
it is clear that one can determine which entanglement cycle the system evolves to for a particular realization .
however , without knowledge of the record of photon counts at detector 2 , which by definition we do not have , one can not know where on the cycle the system is , i.e. , whether the state is in @xmath78 or @xmath79 .
thus , the ensemble average state of the system is mixed , described by one of the density operators @xmath190
consider a thought experiment where the cascaded qubit system , set to resonance , evolves freely and its entire output is collected and stored inside a black box . at some time the lasers driving the raman transitions are turned off , so the evolution ceases .
the box and qubits are separated and moved to causally disconnected regions of space time .
let alice and bob be standard observers of the qubits , and give eve jurisdiction over the box .
we can now ask , how much entanglement exists between the qubits of alice and bob ? while this is simply a roundabout way of asking how entanglement evolves , it helps elucidate some of the key concepts behind the quantum trajectory measure of entanglement .
conventional entanglement measures are based upon an analysis of the density matrix at this time .
they throw away the box and look at the system of qubits alone they disregard eve and view the system from the perspective of alice and bob . yet in general
every interaction between two objects entangles them , and as the qubit system and box interacted in the past , their states are intertwined . neither
possess an independent reality , and neither , considered alone , can be completely described .
eve s box contains information , which , if discarded , adds entropy to the qubit system of alice and bob .
this entropy is the source of ambiguity in the quantification of entanglement . from this point of view , as noted in the introduction , the problem of bi - partite entanglement in an open system relates to that of tri - partite entanglement in a closed one . to completely characterize the entanglement of the present example , in addition to the entanglement between alice and bob
, we must consider their entanglement with eve .
a quantum description of the box is impractical , but it is feasible to extract classical information about what it contains , through measurement .
quantum trajectories facilitate this , and allow us not to discard the box completely . in turn
, the system state retains its purity , conditional on the classical information extracted from the box . with this extra information
, we can extract more entanglement from the cascaded qubit system .
working from the master equation for the cascaded system @xcite , previously it was assumed that the system evolved gradually into a pure state , whereby entanglement was generated .
the behaviour at resonance , however , was unclear , since there the master equation had two zero eigenvalues and no well - defined steady state . by considering the conditional evolution we have shown that , at resonance , asymptotically the system is either in the bell state @xmath151 or oscillating ( stochastically switching ) between two bell states , @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
from the density matrix point of view , the latter is an equal mixture of bell states and would yield no entanglement under any mixed state measure ; physically , alice and bob , without collaboration from eve , can not extract any entanglement from their qubits .
suppose , however , that eve opens her box to count the number of photons inside .
seeing whether the count is even or odd , she is able to deduce exactly which bell state alice and bob s system is in .
thus , her measurement unravels the density operator , creating entanglement , despite the fact that the measurement is not causally connected to alice and bob s qubits .
it is tempting to say that the entanglement was always there , as a matter of fact , until one realizes that there are many other ways in which eve could choose to measure her state , each producing a different unravelling of the qubit system and yielding a different value of entanglement .
the entanglement facilitated by eve s measurements is _ contextual _ in this sense .
this thought experiment demonstrates why any attempt to quantify the entanglement of an open system from the density operator alone can not be considered complete .
the density operator should not be treated as a fundamental object , as it does not provide a complete description of the physical state .
we have presented a simple example where oscillations between maximally entangled states are hidden within a separable density operator . the fact that the density operator contains entropy , implies that information about its entanglement with an external system was discarded at some time . in studying such a mixed state , there is benefit from considering , not only the mixed state itself , but the process through which it was generated , and the access this potentially gives to a conditional dynamics .
the results of this paper could be extended by employing quantum trajectories in a broader sense . in cases where the results of environmental interactions can not be measured , such as coupling loss , wiseman and vaccaro @xcite
have shown that only certain unravelings can be physically realized . a conceivable measure of entanglement would take the minimum of all physically realizable unravelings .
alternatively , one might take the maximum of all physically realizable unravellings , which would measure the maximum distillable entanglement when local measurements on the environment are taken into account .
h. j. carmichael , p. kochan , and l. tian , `` coherent states and open quantum systems : a comment on the stern - gerlach experiment and schrdinger cats , '' in _ coherent states : past , present , and future _ , eds .
d. h. feng , j. r. klauder , and m. r. strayer ( world scientific , singapore , 1994 ) , pp . 75 - 91 . | a system of cascaded qubits interacting via the oneway exchange of photons is studied . while for general operating conditions the system evolves to a superposition of bell states ( a dark state ) in the long - time limit , under a particular _ resonance _ condition no steady state is reached within a finite time .
we analyze the conditional quantum evolution ( quantum trajectories ) to characterize the asymptotic behavior under this resonance condition .
a distinct bimodality is observed : for perfect qubit coupling , the system either evolves to a maximally entangled bell state without emitting photons ( the dark state ) , or executes a sustained entangled - state cycle random switching between a pair of bell states while emitting a continuous photon stream ; for imperfect coupling , two entangled - state cycles coexist , between which a random selection is made from one quantum trajectory to another . |
one of the most important events in modern physics is that our universe is expanding accelerated @xcite .
however , a plausible explanation for this is commonly done using the model of a very exotic fluid called dark energy , which has negative pressure .
another well - known possibility is to modify einstein s general relativity ( gr ) @xcite , making the action of the theory depend on a function of the curvature scalar @xmath3 , but at a certain limit of parameters the theory falls on gr .
this way to explain the accelerated expansion of our universe is known as modified gravity or generalized .
considering that the gravitational interaction is described only by the curvature of space - time , we can generalize the einstein - hilbert action through analytic function of scalars of the theory , as for example the gravities @xmath0 @xcite , with @xmath4 being the ricci scalar or curvature scalar , @xmath5 @xcite , with @xmath6 being the trace of energy - momentum tensor , or yet @xmath7 @xcite , @xmath8 @xcite and @xmath9 @xcite , with @xmath10 being the energy - momentum tensor .
an alternative to consistently describe the gravitational interaction is one which only considers the torsion of space - time , thus cancelling out any effect of the curvature .
this approach is known as teleparallel theory ( tt ) @xcite , which is demonstrably equivalent to gr . in order to describe not only the gravitational interaction , but also the accelerated expansion of our universe , ferraro and fiorini @xcite proposed a possible generalization of the tt , which became known as @xmath1 gravity @xcite , in which up to now has provided good results in both cosmology as local phenomena of gravitation .
a key problem in @xmath1 gravity is that it breaks the invariance under local lorentz transformations complicating the interpretation of the relationship between all inertial frames of the tangent space to the differentiable manifold ( space - time ) @xcite .
this problem may lead to the emergence of new degrees of freedom spurious who are responsible for the breakdown of the local lorentz symmetry @xcite .
a consequence of the formulated theory using a scalar which is not invariant by local lorentz transformations , the torsion scalar @xmath11 in this case , is that instead of the theory presenting differential equations of motion of fourth order , as in the case of the @xmath0 gravity , it has second - order differential equations .
that seems like a benefit but is a consequence of this fact on the local lorentz symmetry .
we still have which this generalization of the tt is not equivalent to generalization @xmath0 for rg .
this is the main reason that will address the construction of a theory that generalize the tt , but which still keep the local lorentz symmetry on a particular case .
therefore , it is clear that we must build the function of action with dependence on a scalar that at some limit is invariant under local lorentz transformations .
it will be shown soon forward .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec2 ]
we do a review of @xmath1 gravity , introducing the functional variation method used in this work , obtaining the equations of motion of this theory , noting a poorly treated point at the limit to gr . in section [ sec3 ]
we propose the action of generalized teleparallel theory , we obtain the equations of motion through functional variation of the same and compared with @xmath1 gravity .
we show the equivalence of our theory with @xmath0 gravity , in the case of cosmology for the line element of flat flrw metric in subsection [ subsec4.1 ] , and also in the case of a spherically symmetric line element in subsection [ subsec4.2 ] .
we show still the equivalence of our theory with a particular case of @xmath12 gravity in section [ sec5 ] . in section [ sec6 ]
we make four applications , one where we reconstructed the action of our theory for the universe of the model of de sitter , another where we obtain a static type - de sitter solution ; we analyse teh evolution for the state parameter to dark energy and the thermodynamics for a cosmological model .
we make our final considerations in section [ sec7 ] .
the geometry of a space - time can be characterized by the curvature and torsion . in the particular case
in which we only consider the curvature and torsion being zero , we have defined , together with the metricity condition @xmath13 where @xmath14 are the components of the metric tensor , a riemannian geometry where the connection @xmath15 is symmetric in the last two indices . already in the particular case that we consider only torsion ( riemann tensor identically zero , case without curvature ) in the space - time , we can then work with objects that depend solely on the so - called tetrads matrices and its derivatives as dynamic fields . in the space - time having only torsion , the line element can be represented through two standard forms @xmath16 where we have the following relationships @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 e @xmath21 , with @xmath22 being the tetrads matrices and @xmath23 its inverse , and @xmath24=diag[1,-1,-1,-1]$ ] the minkowski metric .
we adopt the latin indices for the tangent space and the greeks into space - time .
we will first establish the equations of motion for the theory @xmath1 , thus showing that the functional variation method adopted here is consistent .
we restrict the geometry to of weitzenbock where we have the following connection @xmath25 all riemann tensor components are identically zero for the connection ( [ wc ] ) .
we can then define the components of the tensor of torsion and contortion as @xmath26 we can also define a new tensor , so we write a more elegant way the equations of motion , through the components of the tensor torsion and contortion , as @xmath27 we define the torsion scalar as @xmath28 some observations are important here .
the first is that there is a direct analogy to a space only with torsion and another considering only curvature in that the connections are related by @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the levi - civita connection , which is symmetric in the last two indices .
the second observation is that the torsion scalar @xmath11 is not a lorentz scalar ( in the tangent space ) , being only a scalar in the tensorial indices ( space - time ) @xcite .
this is precisely the cause for that theory built starting this scalar breaks down the invariance by local lorentz transformations .
we can in reality build the curvature scalar analog , through of the torsion scalar , to relation @xcite @xmath31 where @xmath32=\sqrt{-g}$ ] , with @xmath33 $ ] .
the curvature scalar @xmath4 in ( [ r ] ) is a lorentz scalar as well as a scalar on tensorial indices .
that is why the @xmath34 gravity is a theory that is invariant under local lorentz transformations and general coordinates transformations ( tensorial ) .
is then possible to construct a generalization of the teleparallel theory ( tt ) using the following action of the @xmath1 gravity , @xmath35\,\label{ftaction}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 , @xmath1 is a function of the torsion scalar and @xmath37 is the lagrangian density of the material content .
we call attention to the true sign @xmath38 in the front of the matter term .
this so far has not been explicitly addressed in the literature of this theory , because we still have few models that couple content materials that need to be obtained through functional variation in principle .
this signal is essential if the theory is equivalent to gr at some limit
. it will soon be clear forward . making the functional variation of the action ( [ ftaction ] ) we have @xmath39\,,\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{2\kappa^2}\int d^4x\left[f\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^{a}_{\;\;\sigma}}\delta e^{a}_{\;\;\sigma}+e\frac{df}{dt}\delta t\right ] -\int d^4x \delta\mathcal{l}_{matter}\,,\nonumber\\ & = & \delta s_t-\delta s_{matter}\label{dels1}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath40 .
now let s do first the functional variation of the matter term , @xmath41\nonumber\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] that making the integration by part of the latter term , considering @xmath42 , we have @xmath43\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{2\kappa^2}\int d^4x\;2\kappa^2 e\theta_a^{\;\;\sigma}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\,,\label{delsm1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath44 , and we define @xmath45 as being the energy - momentum tensor .
we have now the functional variation of geometric part , @xmath46\right\ } \nonumber\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] doing integration by parts the last term , considering @xmath42 , we obtain @xmath47\right\}\delta e^{a}_{\;\;\sigma } \label{delst1}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath48 . taking ( [ delsm1 ] ) and ( [ delst1 ] ) and replacing in ( [ dels1 ] ) , and imposing the principle of least action
@xmath49 and multiplying by @xmath50 , we have the following equation of motion @xmath51- \kappa^2 \theta_{\nu}^{\;\;\sigma}=0\label{eqm0}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting the derivatives @xcite @xmath52 in ( [ eqm0 ] ) we finally have the equations of motion of the @xmath1 gravity @xmath53-\kappa^2\theta_{\nu}^{\;\;\sigma}=0\label{eqmft}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we make use of identity @xcite @xmath54=-\frac{1}{2}\left[g_{\nu}^{\;\;\sigma}-\frac{1}{2}\delta^{\sigma}_{\nu}t\right]\,,\label{id}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath55 being the mixed components of the einstein tensor , for rewrite ( [ eqmft ] ) as @xmath56=\kappa^2 \theta_{\nu}^{\;\;\sigma}\label{eqmft2}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this theory falls on einstein s general relativity with a cosmological constant , when we make @xmath57 .
here it becomes clear that if we do not consider the sign @xmath38 in front of the matter term in action ( [ ftaction ] ) in the theory , we do not return to gr for a linear @xmath1 function , reaching a opposite signal to einstein s equation .
this fact will be crucial to show later that an invariant theory by local lorentz transformations , as the @xmath0 gravity , can not fall in @xmath1 gravity , since these have opposite coupling signs to the matter term .
sotiriou et al @xcite have shown that @xmath1 gravity does not preserve its equations of motion invariant by local lorentz transformations .
it is in relation to this problem that we then construct a generalization of the teleparallel theory that preserves the invariant of the equations of motion for a local lorentz transformation .
this will be addressed in the next section .
an important identity is given by @xmath58 , where @xmath4 is the curvature scalar associated with a riemann tensor defining solely by levi - civita connection @xmath30 , where the indices @xmath59 are symmetric , and the covariant derivative @xmath60 is defined by this connection .
the curvature scalar is by definition invariant through a local lorentz transformation , but it is also invariant through a general coordinate transformation .
so it would be interesting to develop a theory that generalize the tt but that the functional action depends on an invariant under local lorentz transformations .
this is not the case on @xmath1 gravity .
we propose the following action @xmath61\,,\label{sgtt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we define @xmath62 this action generalizes tt and falls on a modified @xmath1 gravity as well as @xmath0 gravity .
we can show this by making the limit @xmath63 , where we have @xmath64 , ergo @xmath65 , @xmath66 and the theory must be equivalent to a modified @xmath1 ( we ll see this later ) .
moreover , we can regain @xmath0 gravity , making the limit @xmath67 , where we have @xmath68 , then the theory must be equivalent to @xmath0 .
we show this explicitly through the equations of motion later on . by performing the functional variation of the action ( [ sgtt ] )
we obtain : @xmath69\,.\label{sgtt2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath70 $ ] , in which @xmath71 are the matter fields , doing , @xmath72 with @xmath40 in the same manner as in @xmath1 gravity .
the functional variation of the matters term ( [ sgtt3 ] ) is exactly the same as given in ( [ delsm1 ] ) .
the geometric part is @xmath73\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{2\kappa^2}\int d^4x \left[f\;\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}+e\;f_{\mathcal{t}}\delta{\mathcal{t}}\right]\,,\label{dels3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we use @xmath74 . the first term in ( [ dels3 ] ) is already known
, we will pay attention to the second term . performing the functional variation to @xmath75 in ( [ tc ] )
we obtain @xmath76\nonumber\\ & = & -\delta t-2a_1\left[-e^{-2}\partial_\mu\left(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\alpha_{\;\;\beta\alpha}\right)\delta e+e^{-1}\delta\partial_\mu\left(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\alpha_{\;\;\beta\alpha}\right)\right]\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] replacing in ( [ dels3 ] ) taking into account the functional variation of @xmath11 and @xmath77 we have , @xmath78\nonumber\\ & & + 2a_1\left[e^{-1}f_{\mathcal{t}}\partial_\mu(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\alpha_{\;\;\beta\alpha})\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}-f_{\mathcal{t}}\delta\partial_\mu(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu})\right]\bigg{\rbrace}\,.\label{delstc1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we do the integration by part in the terms containing @xmath79 and @xmath80 . the first integration by parts is given by @xmath81+\frac{1}{2\kappa^2}\int d^4x\partial_\alpha\left[ef_{\mathcal{t}}\frac{\partial t}{\partial(\partial_\alpha e^a_{\;\;\sigma})}\right]\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\,,\nonumber\\\label{int1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the first term is zero because it is a surface term , which we consider @xmath42 .
the second integration by parts is given by @xmath82+\frac{2a_1}{2\kappa^2}\int d^4x(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\,\delta(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu})\,,\label{sterm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the first term is null for being a surface term .
then we have @xmath83\;.\label{int2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] making use of the following relationship @xmath84 and replacing ( [ int1 ] ) and ( [ int2 ] ) in ( [ delstc1 ] ) , developing the terms of @xmath85 we have @xmath86\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\nonumber\\ & & + 2a_1\bigg[e^{-1}f_{\mathcal{t}}\partial_{\mu}(e\,g^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\beta\nu})\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}+(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\bigg[g^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\nonumber\\ & & -et^{\nu}_{\;\;\beta\nu}\left(g^{\beta\sigma } e_a^{\;\;\mu}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}+g^{\mu\sigma}e_a^{\;\;\beta}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\right)+e\,g^{\mu\beta}\frac{\partial t^{\nu}_{\;\;\beta\nu}}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}+e\,g^{\mu\beta}\frac{\partial t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}}{\partial(\partial_\alpha e^a_{\;\;\sigma})}\delta(\partial_\alpha e^a_{\;\;\sigma})\bigg]\bigg]\bigg{\rbrace}\,.\label{delstc2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] at this point we see that we still have to do an integration by parts in the last term , ie , @xmath87\nonumber\\ & & -\frac{2a_1}{2\kappa^2}\int d^4x\partial_\alpha\left[(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\,e\,g^{\mu\beta}\frac{\partial t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}}{\partial(\partial_\alpha e^a_{\;\;\sigma})}\right]\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\,,\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where once again the first term vanishes due to be a surface term . replacing this result in ( [ delstc2 ] )
we obtain @xmath88 + 2a_1\bigg[e^{-1}f_{\mathcal{t}}\partial_{\mu}(e\,g^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\beta\nu})\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\nonumber\\ & & + ( \partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\bigg[g^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}\frac{\partial e}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}-et^{\nu}_{\;\;\beta\nu}\left(g^{\beta\sigma } e_a^{\;\;\mu}+g^{\mu\sigma}e_a^{\;\;\beta}\right)+e\,g^{\mu\beta}\frac{\partial t^{\nu}_{\;\;\beta\nu}}{\partial e^a_{\;\;\sigma}}\bigg]-\partial_\alpha\left[(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\,e\,g^{\mu\beta}\frac{\partial t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}}{\partial(\partial_\alpha e^a_{\;\;\sigma})}\right]\bigg]\bigg{\rbrace}\delta e^a_{\;\;\sigma}\,.\label{delstc3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we must replace those derived from @xmath11 , @xmath77 and @xmath89 in relation tetrads and its derivatives . taking into account the results of @xmath90 , we have the following derivative , @xmath91 substituting the above derivatives in ( [ delstc3 ] ) , making @xmath92 in ( [ sgtt3 ] ) and multiplying by @xmath93 we have the following equation of motion for the generalized teleparallel theory @xmath94+a_1\bigg{\lbrace}e^{-1}f_{\mathcal{t}}\delta^\sigma_\omega \partial_\mu(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu})+(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\big[\delta^\sigma_\omega g^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}\nonumber\\ & & -\left(\delta^\mu_\omega g^{\beta\sigma}t^{\nu}_{\;\;\beta\nu}+g^{\mu\sigma}t^\nu_{\;\;\omega\nu}\right)-g^{\mu\beta}t^{\sigma}_{\;\;\beta\omega}\big]-e^{-1}e^a_{\;\;\omega}\partial_\alpha\big[e(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})(g^{\mu\alpha}e_a^{\;\;\sigma}-g^{\mu\sigma}e_a^{\;\;\alpha})\big]\bigg{\rbrace}+\kappa^2\theta_{\omega}^{\;\;\sigma}=0\,.\label{eqmgtt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the limit in which @xmath63 ( @xmath95 ) , making @xmath96 the equation of motion ( [ eqmgtt ] ) does not fall exactly on the equation of motion of the @xmath1 gravity in ( [ eqmft ] ) .
this happens to the fact that the relationship between the curvature scalar and the torsion scalar are through a minus sign , which prevents a theory as @xmath0 gravity , in which the coupling signal with matter is positive , fall in a theory like @xmath1 gravity , in which the coupling signal with the matter should be negative so that it falls within the gr . in the next section
we ll show the equivalence between the gtt and @xmath0 gravity .
let s start this section showing the equivalence of gtt with @xmath0 gravity in the limit @xmath67 , to general tetrads .
let us first establish some necessary identities , as arising from the condition of metricity @xmath97 with it the identity @xmath98 becomes @xmath99 now we can divide the equation of motion in terms such as @xmath100+a_1e^{-1}f_{\mathcal{t}}\delta^\sigma_\omega \partial_\mu(eg^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu})\,,\label{t1}\\ & & t^{(2)}=a_1(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})\big[\delta^\sigma_\omega g^{\mu\beta}t^\nu_{\;\;\beta\nu}-\delta^\mu_\omega g^{\beta\sigma}t^{\nu}_{\;\;\beta\nu}-g^{\mu\sigma}t^\nu_{\;\;\omega\nu}-g^{\mu\beta}t^{\sigma}_{\;\;\beta\omega}\big]\,,\label{t2}\\ & & t^{(3)}=-a_1e^{-1}e^a_{\;\;\omega}\partial_\alpha\big[e(\partial_\mu f_{\mathcal{t}})(g^{\mu\alpha}e_a^{\;\;\sigma}-g^{\mu\sigma}e_a^{\;\;\alpha})\big]\,.\label{t3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] developing the last term we have @xmath101\,.\label{t31}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using , , , , and in and we have the sum of terms @xmath102 and @xmath103 results in @xmath104 now we use the identity in , then we can rewrite the equation of motion , using , as follows @xmath105f_{\mathcal{t}}+\frac{1}{2}\left[-\mathcal{t}f_{\mathcal{t}}+f\right]\delta^{\mu}_{\nu}+2s_{\nu}^{\;\;\alpha\mu}\partial_{\alpha}f_{\mathcal{t}}+\kappa^2\theta^{\mu}_{\;\;\nu}=0\label{gtt1}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] considering @xmath106 , with @xmath107 , we have to gtt will only be equivalent to @xmath0 gravity in the limit @xmath67 , so @xmath108 and the term @xmath109 must be identically zero , as shown in section iii subsection c to @xcite . when this term vanishes , we have exactly one theory invariant by local lorentz transformations , which occurs only when @xmath67 and thus the equation becomes identical to the @xmath0 gravity , which is covariant and independent of the chosen of set of tetrads . in the next section we will specify a set of tetrads that explicitly show the equivalence between the two theories to the limit referred to above . in this section we explicitly show that the gtt equations of motion in ( [ eqmgtt ] ) , are exactly the same as @xmath0 gravity for the particular limit in which @xmath67
. we can then begin comparing the equations of motion for a easier symmetry of the metric , as the maximum symmetry for the cosmological friedmann - lemaitre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) flat metric @xmath110 considering now the case of cosmology , with line element flrw flat ( [ eleflrw ] ) , for a diagonal tetrad @xmath111=diag[1,a(t),a(t),a(t)]$ ] , we have that the equations ( [ eqmgtt ] ) become @xmath112f_{\mathcal{t}}-fa^2\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{eqmgttflrw00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath113f_{\mathcal{t}}-fa^2\bigg{\rbrace } \;,\label{eqmgttflrw11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
we can now compare these equations with those obtained from the @xmath0 gravity , whose equations of motion are @xcite @xmath116 considering the flat flrw metric ( [ eleflrw ] ) , the equations ( [ eqmfr ] ) provide us @xmath117\ ; , \label{eqmfrflrw00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath118\;.\label{eqmfrflrw11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] subtracting ( [ eqmgttflrw00 ] ) from ( [ eqmfrflrw00 ] ) we have @xmath119\right\}\;.\label{sub1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] subtravting ( [ eqmgttflrw11 ] ) from ( [ eqmfrflrw11 ] ) we obtain @xmath120+\dot{a}^2[(4 - 6a_1)f_{\mathcal{t}}+2f_{\bar{r}}]\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{a^2}{2}\left[f(\bar{r})-f(\mathcal{t})\right]\big\}\;.\label{sub2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we see clearly that to the limit at which @xmath67 , we have @xmath121 , then ( [ sub1 ] ) and ( [ sub2 ] ) are identically null , showing the equivalence of equations of motion between gtt and @xmath0 for this limit .
the conclusion is that the gtt is only invariant under local lorentz transformations and at the same time invariant by general coordinates transformations to the limit at which @xmath67 .
we have demonstrated in general that the gtt is equivalent to gravity @xmath122 , but in addition to explain this through a metric with specific symmetry , we want to leave the equations of motion open for further analysis of this theory .
let us now consider the case of a spherically symmetric and static line element @xmath123 we can choose the following diagonal tetrad @xmath111=diag[e^{a(r)/2},e^{b(r)/2},r , r\sin\theta]$ ] , which taking into account ( [ eqmgtt ] ) , provides us the following equations of motion @xmath124f_{\mathcal{t}}+2\,f\,r^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\ ; , \label{diag00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath125f_{\mathcal{t}}+2\,f\,r^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{diag11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath126 @xmath127f_{\mathcal{t}}+2\,f\,r^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{diag22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath128 denotes derivation in relation to radial coordinate @xmath129 .
taking the metric ( [ eles ] ) to the equations of the @xmath0 gravity in ( [ eqmfr ] ) , we obtain @xmath130f_{\bar{r}}+2fre^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{frs00}\\ \kappa^2\theta_1^{\;\;1}&=&\frac{e^{-b}}{4r}\bigg{\lbrace}(2ra'+8)\frac{d}{dr}f_{\bar{r}}+\left[(ra'+4)b'-2ra''-r(a')^2\right]f_{\bar{r}}+2fre^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{frs11}\\ \kappa^2\theta_2^{\;\;2}&=&\kappa^2\theta_3^{\;\;3}=\frac{e^{-b}}{2r^2}\bigg{\lbrace}2r^2\frac{d^2}{dr^2}f_{\bar{r}}-r(rb'-ra'-2)\frac{d}{dr}f_{\bar{r}}+(rb'+2e^b - ra'-2)f_{\bar{r}}+fr^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;.\label{frs22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here first we noticed that if @xmath131 , exists an equation ( [ diag21 ] ) outside the diagonal for gtt , resulting in the restriction of functional form @xmath132 , com @xmath133 .
then we have the same constraint to @xmath1 gravity in this case @xcite .
we also see that to the limit at which @xmath67 , @xmath121 , all equations ( [ diag00])-([diag22 ] ) for gtt are identical to @xmath0 given in ( [ frs00])-([frs22 ] ) . now choose a set of non - diagonal tetrads @xmath134\;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equations to gtt in ( [ eqmgtt ] ) provide us @xmath135f_{\mathcal{t}}+2\,f\,r^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ndiag00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath136e^b\nonumber\\ & & -\left(a_1r^2\left(2a''+(a')^2\right)-8(1-a_1)ra'-8(1-a_1)\right)e^{b/2}\bigg]f_{\mathcal{t}}+2\,f\,r^2e^{3b/2}\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ndiag11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath137f_{\mathcal{t}}+2\,f\,r^2 e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;.\label{ndiag22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can then see that in this case the equations of motion are diagonals .
but equivalence of the gtt with the @xmath0 gravity only gives to the limit @xmath67 , when the equations ( [ frs00])-([frs22 ] ) and ( [ ndiag00])-([ndiag22 ] ) are identical .
in this section we make an important observation . when we were finishing the calculation of the non - diagonal tetrads case of the previous subsection , we note that a group have submitted exactly the same idea of our work here .
the so - call @xmath12 gravity @xcite , with @xmath138 , is a more general theory that presented here , where the algebraic function contained in action , may be any analytic function of the variables @xmath11 and @xmath139 .
we noted then that the equivalence of this theory with the @xmath0 gravity is given only for the specific functional form @xmath140 . compared to our theory
, we have the gtt is a particular case of @xmath12 gravity , when @xmath141 .
we can show this again explicitly using equations of motion .
the equation of motion for @xmath12 gravity is given by @xmath142 the first observation here is that this theory does not fall in @xmath1 gravity on general , as well as our gtt , as mentioned at the end of the section [ sec3 ] .
making @xmath143 , ergo @xmath144 , the equation of motion ( [ ftb ] ) , using the identity ( [ i d ] ) , becomes @xmath145 this equation is not equal to ( [ eqmft2 ] ) for @xmath1 gravity , and can not fall on gr when @xmath146 , due to sign .
this shows that the @xmath12 gravity also not returns on @xmath1 gravity on general .
now we can show that the particular case @xmath147 this theory falls in our gtt .
we take the flrw metric ( [ eleflrw ] ) with diagonal tetrads @xmath148=diag[1,a , a , a]$ ] , the equations of motion ( [ ftb ] ) provides us with @xmath149f_b+fa^2\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ftbflrw00}\\ & & \kappa^2\theta_1^{\;\;1}=\kappa^2\theta_2^{\;\;2}=\kappa^2\theta_3^{\;\;3}=\frac{1}{2a^2}\bigg{\lbrace}4a(\dot{a})\left(\frac{d}{dt}f_t\right)+\left[4a\ddot{a}+8(\dot{a})^2\right]f_t-2a^2\left(\frac{d^2}{dt^2}f_b\right)\nonumber\\ & & + \left[6a\ddot{a}+12(\dot{a})^2\right]f_b+fa^2\bigg{\rbrace}\;.\label{ftbflrw11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now identifing @xmath150 , recall that @xmath75 is given in ( [ tc ] ) , then @xmath151 we have that the equations ( [ ftbflrw00 ] ) and ( [ ftbflrw11 ] ) are identical from the gtt ( [ eqmgttflrw00 ] ) and ( [ eqmgttflrw11 ] ) , thus showing the equivalence between the theories
. we can also confirm this by choosing the spherical symmetry for the metric ( [ eles ] ) , first for diagonal tetrads @xmath148=diag[e^{a/2},e^{b/2},r , r\sin\theta]$ ] , ergo , the equations ( [ ftb ] ) provide us @xmath152f_t-2r^2\left[2\frac{d}{dr}-b'\right]\frac{d}{dr}f_b\nonumber\\ & & + \left[-r(ra'+4)b'-4e^b+r\left(2ra''+r(a')^2 + 8a'\right)+8\right]f_b-2fr^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ftbdiag00 } \\ & & \kappa^2\theta_1^{\;\;1}=\frac{e^{-b}}{4r^2}\bigg{\lbrace}2\left[2e^b-4ra'-4\right]f_t+2r\left[ra'+4\right]\frac{d}{dr}f_b\nonumber\\ & & + \left[r\left(ra'+4\right)b'+4e^b - r\left(2ra''-r(a')^2 - 8a'\right)-8\right]f_b+2r^2fe^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ftbdiag11 } \\ & & \kappa^2\theta_2^{\;\;1}=-\frac{1}{r^2\sin\theta}\left[\cos\theta\frac{d}{dr}f_t+\cos\theta\frac{d}{dr}f_b\right]=0\;,\label{ftbdiag21 } \\ & & \kappa^2\theta_2^{\;\;2}=\kappa^2\theta_3^{\;\;3}=\frac{e^{-b}}{4r^2}\bigg{\lbrace}2r(ra'+2)\frac{d}{dr}f_t+\left[-r\left(ra'+2\right)b'+r^2\left(2a''+(a')^2\right)+6ra'+4\right]f_t\nonumber\\ & & -2r^2\left[2\frac{d}{dr}-b'\right]\frac{d}{dr}f_b+\left[-r(ra'-4)b'-4e^b+r^2\left(2a''+(a')^2\right)+8ra'+8\right]f_b-2fr^2e^b\bigg{\rbrace}\;.\label{ftbdiag22}\end{aligned}\ ] ] again we have the equivalence of the equations of motion ( [ ftbdiag00])-([ftbdiag22 ] ) with ( [ diag00])-([diag22 ] ) , for the identifications @xmath153 and ( [ id2 ] ) . by taking the choice of non - diagonal tetrads([ndtetrad ] ) , the equations of motion from the @xmath154 gravity ( [ ftb ] ) provide us @xmath155\frac{d}{dr}f_t+\left[4re^{3b/2}b'+2(2ra'+4)e^{2b}-4(ra'+2)e^{3b/2}\right]f_t\nonumber\\ & & + \left[4r^2e^{3b/2}\frac{d}{dr}+\left(8re^{2b}-2r^2e^{3b/2}\right)\right]\frac{d}{dr}f_b\nonumber\\ & & + \left[r\left(ra'+4\right)e^{3b/2}b'+4\left(ra'+2\right)e^{2b}-\left(2r^2a''+r(a')^2 + 8ra'+8\right)e^{3b/2}\right]f_b+2fr^2e^{5b/2}\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ftbndiag00}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath156f_t+2r(ra'+4)e^{3b/2}\frac{d}{dr}f_b\nonumber\\ & & + \left[r(ra'+4)e^{3b/2}b'+4(ra'+2)e^{2b}-(2r^2a''+r^2(a')^2 + 8ra'+8)e^{3b/2}\right]f_b+2fr^2e^{5b/2}\bigg{\rbrace}\;,\label{ftbndiag11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath157\frac{d}{dr}f_t\nonumber\\ & & + \left[r(ra'+2)e^{3b/2}b'-4e^{5b/2}+4(ra'+2)e^{2b}-\left(2r^2a''+r^2(a')^2 + 6ra'+4\right)e^{3b/2}\right]f_t\nonumber\\ & & + \left[4r^2e^{3b/2}\frac{d}{dr}+4re^{2b}-2r^2e^{3b/2}b'\right]\frac{d}{dr}f_b\nonumber\\ & & + \left[r(ra'+4)e^{3b/2}b'+4(ra'+2)e^{2b}-\left(2r^2a''+r^2(a')^2 + 8ra'+8\right)e^{3b/2}\right]f_b+2fr^2e^{5b/2}\bigg{\rbrace}\;.\label{ftbndiag22}\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] just as before , making identifications @xmath153 and ( [ id2 ] ) , the equations ( [ ftbndiag00])-([ftbndiag22 ] ) are identical from the gtt in ( [ ndiag00])-([ndiag22 ] ) , confirming again the equivalence of these theories .
a method to obtain the functional form of the algebraic function @xmath158 is the so - called reconstruction .
this method is to specify a model that fix the material content of the theory in terms of scalar @xmath75 , allowing to reconstruct the functional form of @xmath158 through of the equations of motion of the theory .
we will choose the particular case of flat flrw metric in which @xmath159 , a_0,h_0,t_0\in\re_{+}$ ] , it provides us with the model of de sitter universe , where @xmath160 . in this case , using ( [ tc ] ) , we have that @xmath161}$ ] , @xmath162 and @xmath163 . knowing that @xmath164 , the equation ( [ eqmgttflrw00 ] ) provide us
@xmath165 ^ 2=3[h_0(\mathcal{t})]^2(2 - 3a_1)f_{\mathcal{t}}(\mathcal{t})-\frac{1}{2}f(\mathcal{t})\label{eqr1}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] integrating with respect to that @xmath75 results in @xmath166^{(1 - 3a_1)/(2 - 3a_1)}c_1\;,\;c_1\in\re\,.\label{ftc1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we take here the limit at which @xmath63 in ( [ eqmgtt ] ) , that after use the identity ( [ i d ] ) and the consideration @xmath64 , results in @xmath167=-\kappa^2\theta_{\omega}^{\;\;\sigma}\label{gttft}\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as in @xmath0 gravity @xcite , we can consider a very specific case where @xmath168 , with @xmath169 and @xmath170 is defined by ( [ tc ] ) . in the case of a perfect fluid @xmath171 $ ] , and @xmath172 , which results in the equations @xmath173\;,\label{gttdesitter}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which taking the trace results in @xmath174 considering now the line element ( [ eles ] ) , for @xmath175 and @xmath176 ( type - dark energy ) , we can integrate the equations of motion ( [ gttdesitter ] ) , where we get the following solution @xmath177\;.\label{ssol}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is a static type - de sitter solution where we can identify effective cosmological constant @xmath178/[6f_{t_0}(-t_0)]$ ] .
a solution type - de sitter was also previously obtained in @xmath0 gravity for @xmath179 and @xmath180 @xcite .
* we emphasize here that this solution it comes to different theory to @xmath1 gravity , because the gtt does not fall in @xmath1 gravity for @xmath63 , except for the special case where @xmath1 is a odd analytic function , that is @xmath181 . *
a good test for our theory is the evolution of a model of the universe .
this can discard or keep a theory depending on whether it is in agreement with the observational data .
let s follow the procedure found in @xcite to determine the state parameter @xmath2 .
for a universe permeated by a perfect fluid , of which equation of state is governed by @xmath182 , we can rewrite the equations of motion and as @xmath183\label{h2}\,,\\ & & \dot{h}=-\frac{\kappa^2}{2}g_{eff}\left(p_{m}+p_{de}+\rho_{m}+\rho_{de}\right)\,,\,p_{de}=\frac{1}{\kappa^2}\left[a_1\ddot{f}_{\mathcal{t}}+h\dot{f}_{\mathcal{t}}-\frac{1}{2}f\right]\label{hdot}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we can defining the state parameter of dark energy by @xmath184 we now assume an exponential model , as well as @xcite , defined by @xmath185\right)\label{exp}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we will now test for a solution of the type power law @xmath186 * we can show that is a solution of the equations of motion and if the material part is given by the expressions @xmath187}{\mathcal{t}_st^2}}\left[\mathcal{t}_s^2t^4 + 6\alpha\mathcal{t}_st^2(a_1+\alpha(3a_1 - 2))+72a_1\alpha^2(a_1(2\alpha-1)-\alpha)\right]\beta\nonumber\\ & & + \mathcal{t}_st^2\left[-6\alpha^2 + 6\alpha a_1(2+\alpha)-\beta\mathcal{t}_st^2\right]\bigg\}\\ & & p_{mt}=\frac{1}{2\mathcal{t}_s^2\kappa^2 t^6}\bigg\{e^{\frac{6\alpha[a_1+\alpha(1 - 2a_1)]}{\mathcal{t}_st^2}}\big[-\mathcal{t}_s^3t^6 + 2\mathcal{t}_s^2\alpha t^4(-4 + 3a_1(2 - 3\alpha)+6\alpha)+288a_1\alpha^2(a_1+\alpha(1 - 2a_1))^2\nonumber\\ & & -24\mathcal{t}_st^2\alpha(3a_1-\alpha)(-\alpha+a_1(2\alpha-1))\big]\beta+\mathcal{t}_s^2t^4\left[2\alpha(-4 - 3a_1(\alpha-1)+3\alpha)+\beta\mathcal{t}_s t^2\right]\bigg\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] * the figure [ fig1 ] is the temporal evolution of the state parameter @xmath2 of the dark energy .
the red curve is obtained with constant given by @xmath188 , where we can see that the fluid is always phantom @xmath189 .
the blue curve is obtained with constant given by @xmath190 , where we can see that the fluid is always phantom @xmath189 , but it fluctuates approximately between the values @xmath191 and @xmath192 .
the most interesting case is the green curve obtained for the constants @xmath193 . in this case
we see that the fluid begins in a rather phantom phase , going through another phase type quintessence , heading toward a behavior of baryonic matter ( @xmath194 ) and finally returning the phantom phase .
the result is that the current accelerated expansion of the universe and the crossing of the phantom divide from the phantom phase to the non - phantom ( quintessence ) one can be realized , as well as in @xcite .
[ cols= " > , < " , ] a further application is for thermodynamics of the apparent horizon in cosmology flrw metric . we can follow the formulation given in @xcite . we can establish a similar equation of continuity , deriving over time and using @xmath195 whereas the baryonic matter is conserved ( @xmath196 ) , we can see that dark energy is not conserved , yielding the interpretation that it is a system out of equilibrium with entropy production ( non - equilibrium thermodynamics ) .
following exactly the same steps in @xcite , we can establish the first law of thermodynamics @xmath197 at where @xmath198 the temperature of the apparent horizon , @xmath199 is the entropy of the apparent horizon , @xmath200 is the produced entropy , @xmath201 is the misner - sharp energy , @xmath202 the work and @xmath203 the volume element of the apparent horizon . here
it is clearly seen that the first law of thermodynamics is consistent for entropy production associated with an effective newton constant @xmath204 , given in , which for the linear case of @xmath158 the entropy production vanishes and the system back to equilibrium . *
if we take the same model of the previous section , i.e. and , we can explicitly show the time dependence of effective newton constant in @xmath205}{\mathcal{t}_st^2}}\right\}^{-1}\label{geff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here are two important observations .
the first is that it becomes explicit dependence of the first law of thermodynamics to the specific choice of the value on @xmath206 in .
the second is that by taking the particular value @xmath207 in , clearly we have @xmath208 , which again shows the dependence of the theory in relation to the specific value of @xmath206 , and from , and we return to linear theory , where there is no entropy production . *
we construct a theory that describes the gravitational interaction through effects of torsion of space - time .
this theory generalizes the teleparallel theory keeping the invariance by both local lorentz transformations as general coordinates transformations for a particular case .
the action of our theory is described by a general algebraic function that depends on a tensorial scalar @xmath75 which is classified by a real parameter @xmath206 .
our theory falls exactly in @xmath0 gravity when we take the limit in which @xmath67 .
this is shown from the equations of motion of the two theories .
we make two small applications of our theory , reconstructing the action for the particular case of de sitter universe for the flat flrw metric , with a set of diagonal tetrads , and for obtain a static type - de sitter solution .
we also analyse the evolution of the state parameter of the dark energy and the first thermodynamics law for the apparent horizon .
our theory is a good scenery to an attempt to explain the accelerated expansion of our universe , by modifying the teleparallel usual gravitation , or analogous to einstein gravity .
the real parameter @xmath206 which classifies which theory the gtt describes , it is crucial to any consideration of cosmological phenomena .
we also expect new solutions of black holes arise through our theory , in which may also suggest some light on the so - called dark matter explanation on local effects of gravitation . 99 a. riess et al , _
observational evidence from supernovae for an accelerating universe and a cosmological constant _ , astron .
j. * 116 * , 1009 ( 1998 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9805201[astro-ph/9805201 ] ] ; s. perlmutter et al , _ measurements of and from 42 high - redshift supernovae _ , astrophys.j . * 517 * , 565 ( 1999 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9812133[astro-ph/9812133 ] ] ; j. tonry et al , _ cosmological results from high - z supernovae _
, astrophys.j . * 594 * , 1 ( 2003 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0305008[astro-ph/0305008 ] ] .
j. plebanski and a. krasinski , _ an introduction to general relativity and cosmology _ , cambridge university press , new york ( 2006 ) .
s. nojiri , s.d .
odintsov , _ introduction to modified gravity and gravitational alternative for dark energy _ , econf c0602061 , * 06 * , ( 2006 ) ; int .
j. geom . meth . mod.phys .
4,115 - 146,2007 [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0601213[hep-th/0601213 ] ] ; thomas p.
sotiriou , valerio faraoni , _
f(r ) theories of gravity _ , rev .
phys . * 82 * 451 - 497 ( 2010 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0805.1726[arxiv:0805.1726 ] ] ; antonio de felice , shinji tsujikawa , _
f(r ) theories _ , living rev
* 13 * 3 , ( 2010 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1002.4928[arxiv:1002.4928 ] ] ; timothy clifton , pedro g. ferreira , antonio padilla , constantinos skordis , _ modified gravity and cosmology _ , physics reports * 513 * , 1 ( 2012 ) , 1 - 189 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1106.2476[arxiv:1106.2476 ] ] .
tiberiu harko , francisco s.n .
lobo , shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , _
f(r , t ) gravity _ , phys.rev.d * 84 * 024020 , ( 2011 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1104.2669[arxiv:1104.2669 ] ] ; mubasher jamil , d. momeni , muhammad raza , ratbay myrzakulov , _ reconstruction of some cosmological models in f(r , t ) gravity _ , eur .
j. c * 72 * 1999 ( 2012 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1107.5807[arxiv:1107.5807 ] ] ; f. g. alvarenga , a. de la cruz - dombriz , m. j. s. houndjo , m. e. rodrigues and d. sez - gmez , _ reconstruction of some cosmological models in f(r , t ) gravity _ , phys.rev .
d * 87 * ( 2013 ) 10 , 103526 , phys.rev .
d * 87 * ( 2013 ) 12 , 129905 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1302.1866[arxiv:1302.1866 ] ] .
kazuharu bamba , chao - qiang geng , shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , _ equivalence of modified gravity equation to the clausius relation _ ,
* 89 * ( 2010 ) 50003 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0909.4397[arxiv:0909.4397 ] ] ; m. j. s. houndjo , m. e. rodrigues , d. momeni , r. myrzakulov , _ exploring cylindrical solutions in modified f(g ) gravity _ , canadian journal of physics , 2014 , * 92*(12 ) 1528 - 1540 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1301.4642[arxiv:1301.4642 ] ] ; m. e. rodrigues , m. j. s. houndjo , d. momeni , r. myrzakulov , _ a type of levi - civita s solution in modified gauss - bonnet gravity _ , canadian journal of physics , 2014 , * 92*(2 ) : 173 - 176 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1212.4488[arxiv:1212.4488 ] ] ; kazuharu bamba , sergei d. odintsov , lorenzo sebastiani , sergio zerbini , _ finite - time future singularities in modified gauss - bonnet and f(r , g ) gravity and singularity avoidance _ ,
eur.phys.j.c*67 * 295 - 310 , ( 2010 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0911.4390[arxiv:0911.4390 ] ] ; shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , alexey toporensky , petr tretyakov , _ reconstruction and deceleration - acceleration transitions in modified gravity _ ,
gen.rel.grav.*42 * 1997 - 2008 , ( 2010 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0912.2488[arxiv:0912.2488 ] ] .
guido cognola , emilio elizalde , shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , sergio zerbini , _ dark energy in modified gauss - bonnet gravity : late - time acceleration and the hierarchy problem _ , phys.rev.d*73 * : 084007 , ( 2006 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0601008[hep-th/0601008 ] ] ; emilio elizalde , ratbay myrzakulov , valery v. obukhov , diego sez - gmez , _ lambdacdm epoch reconstruction from f(r , g ) and modified gauss - bonnet gravities _ , class .
grav . * 27*:095007 , ( 2010 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1001.3636[arxiv:1001.3636 ] ] ; antonio de felice , teruaki suyama , _ vacuum structure for scalar cosmological perturbations in modified gravity models _ , jcap * 0906 * : 034 , ( 2009 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0904.2092[arxiv:0904.2092 ] ] ; antonio de felice , shinji tsujikawa , _ construction of cosmologically viable f(g ) gravity models _ ,
phys.lett.b * 675 * 1 - 8 , ( 2009 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0810.5712[arxiv:0810.5712 ] ] ; shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , _ modified gauss - bonnet theory as gravitational alternative for dark energy _ , phys.lett.b * 631*:1 - 6 , ( 2005 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0508049[hep-th/0508049 ] ] ; shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , _ modified gravity with negative and positive powers of the curvature : unification of the inflation and of the cosmic acceleration _ , phys.rev.d * 68*:123512 , ( 2003 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0307288[hep-th/0307288 ] ] . sergei d. odintsov and diego saez - gomez , _ @xmath210 gravity phenomenology and @xmath211cdm universe
_ , phys.lett .
b * 725 * ( 2013 ) 437 - 444 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1304.5411[arxiv:1304.5411 [ gr - qc ] ] ] .
r. aldrovandi and j. g. pereira , _ an introduction to teleparallel gravity _ , instituto de fisica teorica , unsep , sao paulo , [ link : www.ift.unesp.br / users / jpereira / tele.pdf[www.ift.unesp.br / users / jpereira / tele.pdf ] ] ; r. aldrovandi ; j. g. pereira ; k. h. vu , _ selected topics in teleparallel gravity _ ,
vol.*34 * no.4a so paulo dec .
2004 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0312008[gr-qc/0312008 ] ] ; j.w .
maluf , _ the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity _ , annalen phys . * 525 * ( 2013 ) 339 - 357 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1303.3897[arxiv:1303.3897 ] ] ; f. w. hehl , j. d. mccrea , e. w. mielke , and y. neeman , _ metric - affine gauge theory of gravity : field equations , noether identities , world spinors , and breaking of dilation invariance _ , phys . rep .
* 258 * , 1 - 171 ( 1995 ) , [ http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/037015739400111f[doi:10.1016/0370-1573(94)00111-f ] ] .
rafael ferraro and franco fiorini , _ modified teleparallel gravity : inflation without inflaton _ , phys.rev .
d * 75 * ( 2007 ) 084031 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0610067[gr-qc/0610067 ] ] .
tiberiu harko , francisco s. n. lobo , g. otalora , emmanuel n. saridakis , _ nonminimal torsion - matter coupling extension of f(t ) gravity _ ,
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 124036 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1404.6212[arxiv:1404.6212 ] ] ; s. basilakos , s. capozziello , m. de laurentis , a. paliathanasis , m. tsamparlis , _ noether symmetries and analytical solutions in f(t)-cosmology : a complete study _
, phys.rev .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 103526 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1311.2173[arxiv:1311.2173 ] ] ; kazuharu bamba , sergei d. odintsov , diego sez - gmez , _ conformal symmetry and accelerating cosmology in teleparallel gravity _ , phys.rev .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 084042 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1308.5789[arxiv:1308.5789 ] ] ; h. mohseni sadjadi , _ generalized noether symmetry in f(t ) gravity _ , phys.lett .
b * 718 * ( 2012 ) 270 - 275 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1210.0937[arxiv:1210.0937 ] ] ; m.e . rodrigues , m.j.s .
houndjo , d. saez - gomez , f. rahaman , _ anisotropic universe models in f(t ) gravity _ ,
d * 86 * ( 2012 ) 104059 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1209.4859[arxiv:1209.4859 ] ] ; vincenzo f. cardone , ninfa radicella , stefano camera , _ accelerating f(t ) gravity models constrained by recent cosmological data _
, phys.rev .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 124007 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1204.5294[arxiv:1204.5294 ] ] ; kazuharu bamba , ratbay myrzakulov , shinichi nojiri , sergei d. odintsov , _ reconstruction of f(t ) gravity : rip cosmology , finite - time future singularities and thermodynamics _ , phys.rev .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 104036 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1202.4057[arxiv:1202.4057 ] ] ; chen xu , emmanuel n. saridakis , genly leon , _ phase - space analysis of teleparallel dark energy _ , jcap * 1207 * ( 2012 ) 005 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1202.3781[arxiv:1202.3781 ] ] ; k. karami , a. abdolmaleki , _ generalized second law of thermodynamics in f(t)-gravity _ , jcap * 1204 * ( 2012 ) 007 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1201.2511[arxiv:1201.2511 ] ] ; hao wei , xiao - jiao guo , long - fei wang , _ noether symmetry in f(t ) theory _ , phys.lett . b707 ( 2012 ) 298 - 304 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1112.2270[arxiv:1112.2270 ] ] ; christian g. boehmer , tiberiu harko , francisco s.n .
lobo , _ wormhole geometries in modified teleparralel gravity and the energy conditions _ ,
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 044033 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1110.5756[arxiv:1110.5756 ] ] ; yi - peng wu , chao - qiang geng , _ primordial fluctuations within teleparallelism _ ,
d * 86 * ( 2012 ) 104058 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1110.3099[arxiv:1110.3099 ] ] ; s. capozziello , v.f .
cardone , h. farajollahi , a. ravanpak , _ cosmography in f(t)-gravity _ , phys.rev .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 043527 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1108.2789[arxiv:1108.2789 ] ] ; christian g. boehmer , atifah mussa , nicola tamanini , _ existence of relativistic stars in f(t ) gravity _ , class.quant.grav . * 28 * ( 2011 ) 245020 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1107.4455[arxiv:1107.4455 ] ] ; rong - xin miao , miao li , yan - gang miao , _ violation of the first law of black hole thermodynamics in f(t ) gravity _ , jcap * 1111 * ( 2011 ) 033 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1107.0515[arxiv:1107.0515 ] ] ; xin - he meng , ying - bin wang , _ birkhoff s theorem in the f(t ) gravity _ ,
c * 71 * ( 2011 ) 1755 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1107.0629[arxiv:1107.0629 ] ] ; hao wei , xiao - peng ma , hao - yu qi , _
f(t ) theories and varying fine structure constant _ , phys.lett .
b * 703 * ( 2011 ) 74 - 80 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1106.0102[arxiv:1106.0102 ] ] ; rafael ferraro , franco fiorini , _ non trivial frames for f(t ) theories of gravity and beyond _ , phys.lett .
b * 702 * ( 2011 ) 75 - 80 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1103.0824[arxiv:1103.0824 ] ] ; yi zhang , hui li , yungui gong , zong - hong zhu , _ notes on f(t ) theories _ , jcap * 1107 * ( 2011 ) 015 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1103.0719[arxiv:1103.0719 ] ] ; tower wang , _ static solutions with spherical symmetry in f(t ) theories _ , phys.rev .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 024042 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1102.4410[arxiv:1102.4410 ] ] ; kazuharu bamba , chao - qiang geng , chung - chi lee , ling - wei luo , _ equation of state for dark energy in f(t ) gravity _ , jcap * 1101 * ( 2011 ) 021 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1011.0508[arxiv:1011.0508 ] ] ; rui zheng , qing - guo huang , _ growth factor in f(t ) gravity _ , jcap * 1103 * ( 2011 ) 002 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1010.3512[arxiv:1010.3512 ] ] ; james b. dent , sourish dutta , emmanuel n. saridakis , _
f(t ) gravity mimicking dynamical dark energy . background and perturbation
, jcap * 1101 * ( 2011 ) 009 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1010.2215[arxiv:1010.2215 ] ] ; rong - jia yang , _ conformal transformation in f(t ) theories _ , europhys.lett .
* 93 * ( 2011 ) 60001 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1010.1376[arxiv:1010.1376 ] ] ; k. karami , a. abdolmaleki , _
f(t ) modified teleparallel gravity models as an alternative for holographic and new agegraphic dark energy models _ , res.astron.astrophys .
* 13 * ( 2013 ) 757 - 771 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1009.2459[arxiv:1009.2459 ] ] ; puxun wu , hong wei yu , _
f(t ) models with phantom divide line crossing _ , eur.phys.j .
c * 71 * ( 2011 ) 1552 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1008.3669[arxiv:1008.3669 ] ] ; gabriel r. bengochea , _ observational information for f(t ) theories and dark torsion _ , phys.lett .
b * 695 * ( 2011 ) 405 - 411 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1008.3188[arxiv:1008.3188 ] ] ; shih - hung chen , james b. dent , sourish dutta , emmanuel n. saridakis , _ cosmological perturbations in f(t ) gravity _ , phys.rev .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 023508 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1008.1250[arxiv:1008.1250 ] ] ; rong - jia yang , _ new types of f(t ) gravity _ , eur.phys.j .
c * 71 * ( 2011 ) 179 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1007.3571[arxiv:1007.3571 ] ] ; puxun wu , hong wei yu , _ the dynamical behavior of f(t ) theory _
, phys.lett .
b * 692 * ( 2010 ) 176 - 179 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1007.2348[arxiv:1007.2348 ] ] ; ratbay myrzakulov , _ accelerating universe from f(t ) gravity _
, eur.phys.j .
c * 71 * ( 2011 ) 1752 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1006.1120[arxiv:1006.1120 ] ] ; g.g.l .
nashed and w. el hanafy , _ a built - in inflation in the f(t)-cosmology _ , eur.phys.j .
c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 10 , 3099 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1403.0913[arxiv:1403.0913 ] ] .
thomas p. sotiriou , baojiu li , john d. barrow , _ generalizations of teleparallel gravity and local lorentz symmetry _ , phys.rev .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 104030 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1012.4039[arxiv:1012.4039 ] ] ; baojiu li , thomas p. sotiriou , john d. barrow , _
f(t ) gravity and local lorentz invariance _ ,
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 064035 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1010.1041[arxiv:1010.1041 ] ] .
miao li , rong - xin miao , yan - gang miao , _ degrees of freedom of f(t ) gravity _ , jhep * 1107 * ( 2011 ) 108 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1105.5934[arxiv:1105.5934 ] ] .
ruben aldrovandi and jose geraldo pereira , _ teleparallel gravity , an introduction _ , springer , new york ( 2013 ) .
m. hamani daouda , manuel e. rodrigues and m.j.s .
houndjo , _
static anisotropic solutions in f(t ) theory _
, eur.phys.j .
c * 72 * ( 2012 ) 1890 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1109.0528[arxiv:1109.0528 [ physics.gen-ph ] ] ] .
sebastian bahamonde , christian g. boehmer and matthew wright , _ modified teleparallel theories of gravity _ , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1508.05120[arxiv:1508.05120 [ gr - qc ] ] ] . s. capozziello , a. stabile and a. troisi , _ spherical symmetry in @xmath0-gravity _ , class.quant.grav .
* 25 * ( 2008 ) 085004 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:0709.0891[arxiv:0709.0891 [ gr - qc ] ] ] .
kazuharu bamba , chao - qiang geng and chung - chi lee , _ cosmological evolution in exponential gravity _
, jcap * 08 * ( 2010 ) 021 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1005.4574v3[arxiv:1005.4574 [ astro-ph.co ] ] ] .
ednaldo l. b. junior , manuel e. rodrigues , ines g. salako and mahouton j. s. houndjo , _ reconstruction , thermodynamics and stability of cdm model in f(t , t ) gravity _ , accepted for publication in class . and quantum gravity , [ https://arxiv.org/abs/1501.00621[arxiv:1501.00621 [ gr - qc ] ] ] . | we construct a theory in which the gravitational interaction is described only by torsion , but that generalizes the teleparallel theory still keeping the invariance of local lorentz transformations in one particular case .
we show that our theory falls , to a certain limit of a real parameter , in the @xmath0 gravity or , to another limit of the same real parameter , in a modified @xmath1 gravity , interpolating between these two theories and still can fall on several other theories .
we explicitly show the equivalence with @xmath0 gravity for cases of friedmann - lemaitre - robertson - walker flat metric for diagonal tetrads , and a metric with spherical symmetry for diagonal and non - diagonal tetrads .
we do still four applications , one in the reconstruction of the de sitter universe cosmological model , for obtaining a static spherically symmetric solution type - de sitter for a perfect fluid , for evolution of the state parameter @xmath2 and for the thermodynamics to the apparent horizon . |
it is an extrapolation of 18 orders of magnitude from the neutron radius of a heavy nucleus such as @xmath1pb with a neutron radius of @xmath2 fm to the approximately 10 km radius of a neutron star . yet
both radii depend on our incomplete knowledge of the equation of state of neutron - rich matter . that strong correlations arise among objects of such disparate sizes
is not difficult to understand .
heavy nuclei develop a neutron - rich skin as a result of its large neutron excess ( _ e.g. , _ @xmath3 in @xmath1pb ) and because the large coulomb barrier reduces the proton density at the surface of the nucleus .
thus the thickness of the neutron skin depends on the pressure that pushes neutrons out against surface tension . as a result , the greater the pressure , the thicker the neutron skin @xcite .
yet it is this same pressure that supports a neutron star against gravitational collapse @xcite .
thus models with thicker neutron skins often produce neutron stars with larger radii @xcite .
the above discussion suggests that an accurate and model - independent measurement of the neutron skin of even a single heavy nucleus may have important implications for neutron - star properties .
attempts at mapping the neutron distribution have traditionally relied on strongly - interacting probes . while highly mature and successful , it is unlikely that the hadronic program will ever attain the precision status that the electroweak program enjoys .
this is due to the large and controversial uncertainties in the reaction mechanism @xcite .
the mismatch in our knowledge of the proton radius in @xmath0pb relative to that of the neutron radius provides a striking example of the current situation : while the charge radius of @xmath0pb is known to better than 0.001 fm @xcite , realistic estimates place the uncertainty in the neutron radius at about 0.2 fm @xcite .
the enormously successful parity - violating program at the jefferson laboratory @xcite provides an attractive electroweak alternative to the hadronic program .
indeed , the parity radius experiment ( prex ) at the jefferson laboratory aims to measure the neutron radius of @xmath1pb accurately ( to within @xmath4 fm ) and model independently via parity - violating electron scattering @xcite .
parity violation at low momentum transfers is particularly sensitive to the neutron density because the @xmath5 boson couples primarily to neutrons .
moreover , the parity - violating asymmetry , while small , can be interpreted with as much confidence as conventional electromagnetic scattering experiments .
prex will provide a unique observational constraint on the thickness of the neutron skin of a heavy nucleus .
we note that since first proposed in 1999 , many of the technical difficulties intrinsic to such a challenging experiment have been met .
for example , during the recent activity at the hall a proton parity experiment ( happex ) , significant progress was made in controlling helicity correlated errors @xcite .
other technical problems are currently being solved such as the designed of a new septum magnet and a specific timeline has been provided to solve all remaining problems within the next two years @xcite . our aim in this contribution is to report on some of our recent results that examine the correlation between the neutron skin of @xmath0pb and various neutron - star properties @xcite .
in particular , we examine the consequences of a `` softer '' equation of state that is based on a new accurately calibrated relativistic parameter set that has been constrained by both the ground state properties of finite nuclei and their linear response .
further , results obtained with this new parameter set dubbed `` fsugold '' @xcite will be compared against the nl3 parameter set of lalazissis , konig , and ring @xcite that , while highly successful , predicts a significantly stiffer equation of state .
the starting point for the calculation of the properties of finite nuclei and neutron stars is an effective field - theory model based on the following lagrangian density : @xmath6\psi \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{\kappa}{3 ! } ( g_{\rm s}\phi)^3 \!-\ ! \frac{\lambda}{4!}(g_{\rm
s}\phi)^4 \!+\ ! \frac{\zeta}{4 ! } \big(g_{\rm v}^2 v_{\mu}v^\mu\big)^2 \!+\ ! \lambda_{\rm v } \big(g_{\rho}^{2}\,{\bf b}_{\mu}\cdot{\bf b}^{\mu}\big ) \big(g_{\rm v}^2v_{\mu}v^\mu\big ) \;.
\label{lagrangian}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the lagrangian density includes an isodoublet nucleon field ( @xmath7 ) interacting via the exchange of two isoscalar mesons a scalar ( @xmath8 ) and a vector ( @xmath9 ) one isovector meson ( @xmath10 ) , and the photon ( @xmath11 ) @xcite .
in addition to meson - nucleon interactions , the lagrangian density is supplemented by four nonlinear meson interactions , with coupling constants denoted by @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 .
the first three of these terms are responsible for a softening of the equation of state of symmetric nuclear matter at both normal and high densities @xcite .
in particular , the cubic ( @xmath12 ) and quartic ( @xmath13 ) scalar self - energy terms are needed to reduce the compression modulus of symmetric nuclear matter , in accordance to measurements of the giant monopole resonance in medium to heavy nuclei @xcite . in turn ,
@xmath16-meson self - interactions ( @xmath14 ) are instrumental for the softening of the equation of state at high density thereby affecting primarily the limiting masses of neutron stars @xcite .
finally , the last of the coupling constants ( @xmath15 ) induces isoscalar - isovector mixing and has been added to tune the poorly - known density dependence of the symmetry energy @xcite . as a result of the strong correlation between the neutron radius of heavy nuclei and the pressure of neutron - rich matter @xcite ,
the neutron skin of a heavy nucleus is highly sensitive to changes in @xmath15 .
[ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
in conclusion , a new accurately calibrated relativistic model ( `` fsugold '' ) has been fitted to the binding energies and charge radii of a variety of magic nuclei . in this regard ,
the new parametrization is as successful as the nl3 set which has been used here as a useful paradigm . in particular ,
symmetric nuclear matter saturates at a fermi momentum of @xmath17 ( corresponding to a baryon density of @xmath18 ) with a binding energy per nucleon of @xmath19 mev .
further , by constraining the fsugold parameter set by a few nuclear collective modes , we obtain a nuclear - matter incompressibility of @xmath20 mev and a neutron skin thickness in @xmath0pb of @xmath21 fm .
while the description of the various collective modes imposes additional constraints on the eos at densities around saturation density , the high - density component of the eos remains largely unconstrained .
thus , we made no attempts at constraining the eos at the supranuclear densities of relevance to neutron - star physics .
rather , we simply explored the consequences of the new parametrization on a variety of neutron star observables and eagerly await high - quality data that will constrain the high - density component of the eos .
in particular , we found a limiting neutron - star mass of @xmath22 , a radius of @xmath23 km for a @xmath24 neutron star , and no direct urca cooling in neutron stars with masses below @xmath25 .
it is interesting to note that recent observations of pulsar - white dwarf binaries at the arecibo observatory suggest a pulsar mass for psrj0751 + 1807 of @xmath26 at a 95% confidence level @xcite .
if this observation could be refined , not only would it redefine the high - density behavior of this ( and many other ) eos , but it could provide us with a precious boost in our quest for the equation of state . | the nucleus of @xmath0pb a system that is 18 order of magnitudes smaller and 55 orders of magnitude lighter than a neutron star may be used as a miniature surrogate to establish important correlations between its neutron skin and several neutron - star properties .
indeed , a nearly model - independent correlation develops between the neutron skin of @xmath1pb and the liquid - to - solid transition density in a neutron star .
further , we illustrate how a measurement of the neutron skin in @xmath0pb may be used to place important constraints on the cooling mechanism operating in neutron stars and may help elucidate the existence of quarks stars . |
Subsets and Splits