article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
recent advances in observational cosmology @xcite have revived interest in alternative theories of gravity in which the gravitational interaction is modified in the infrared domain and which could potentially explain the accelerated expansion of the universe without introducing the dark energy and matter components .
theoretical consistency and existing experimental data impose severe constraints on such models .
different approaches to the problem have been discussed in the literature ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite , and refs .
@xcite for reviews ) .
one of them employs spontaneous breaking of lorentz symmetry by space - time dependent condensates of scalar fields @xcite coupled to gravity in a covariant way via a derivative coupling .
the resulting theory may have a non - pathological perturbative behavior about the broken vacuum @xcite and exhibit modifications of gravitational interactions at large scales ( see sect . [
sc : intro - model ] for more details ) .
in particular , graviton may acquire a non - zero mass , which is the reason to call these models massive gravity models .
existing experimental data constrain the mass of the graviton and other parameters of massive gravity models .
absence of lorentz invariance makes the constraints weaker than one would expect in a lorentz - invariant theory : the newton s potential remains unmodified in the linear approximation despite non - zero graviton mass @xcite , so that solar system constraints are satisfied for rather large masses .
the constraint on the mass of the graviton comes from the emission of gravitational waves by binary pulsars which is responsible for their spin - down @xcite .
consistency of observations with gr requires the graviton mass to be smaller than the inverse period of orbital motion of the binary system , that is @xcite @xmath2 standard cosmological solutions may be reproduced in massive gravity @xcite .
further constraints on the parameters of the model are imposed by the growth of perturbations and structure formation in the post - inflationary epoch @xcite . in general relativity ( gr ) , a crucial role is played by the spherically symmetric vacuum solution to the einstein equations the schwarzschild solution .
this role is twofold : first , this solution describes the metric outside of spherical non - rotating bodies and gives rise , in the weak field limit , to the newtonian gravity .
it provides therefore a useful approximation in many astrophysical situations .
second , the schwarzschild solution describes the result of a gravitational collapse , the black hole .
although the existence of black holes has not yet been directly confirmed , there exists an indirect evidence that some of binary stellar systems contain black holes as one of the companion @xcite , and that many galaxies , including the milky way , harbor super - massive black holes in their centers @xcite .
it is conceivable that black holes will be directly observed in the near future , and that their properties , including the metric configuration near the horizon , will be quantitatively tested @xcite , thus providing a probe of gr in a fully non - linear regime .
the schwarzschild metric , together with properly arranged scalar fields is a solution to einstein equations in massive gravity as well @xcite .
however , the properties of black holes are , in general , expected to be different . in particular , rotating black holes are certainly modified , and , more generally , black holes are expected to have hair @xcite .
the possible existence of black hole hair in massive gravity models suggests that there might exist spherically symmetric solutions other than the schwarzschild one . in this paper
we construct explicit examples of such solutions .
we found a new class of vacuum spherically - symmetric solutions in massive gravity which depend , in addition to the mass @xmath0 ( equivalently , the schwarzschild radius ) , on one more parameter which we call the `` scalar charge '' @xmath1 . at zero value of this parameter
the standard schwarzschild solution is recovered , while at non - zero values of @xmath1 the schwarzschild metric gets modified .
the modified solution is non - linear at all distances ; it can not be obtained in the linear approximation .
similar phenomenon has been previously found in the context of bi - gravity models @xcite .
the new solutions may have event horizons and are , therefore , candidates for modified black holes .
we found both analytical and numerical examples of such modified black holes .
the analytical solutions found in a particular massive gravity model show a variety of different behaviors . depending on the parameters of the model , the deviation of the metric from the minkowski one may decay at infinity as @xmath3 or slower .
the solutions thus may have finite or infinite adm @xcite mass , respectively . in the case of a finite mass
, this mass may be positive or negative depending on the sign of @xmath0 . in either case
the singularity at the origin may be hidden by the horizon . the solutions with negative mass exhibit an anti - gravitating behavior at large distances from the center .
the modified gravitational potential may decay slower than @xmath3 in a certain distance range .
such a behavior would mimic the effect of the dark matter .
interestingly , the modification depends not only on the parameters of the model , but also on the scalar charge and the mass of the solution .
thus , the apparent amount of the `` dark matter '' may be different for objects of the same mass , in contrast with other models of modified gravity .
this paper is organized as follows . in sect . [
sc : intro - model ] we briefly review the massive gravity model and summarize previous results about the newtonian potential in this model . in sect .
[ sc : ansatz ] we present the spherically symmetric ansatz and reduce the einstein equations to four ordinary differential equations . in sect .
[ sc : xw ] we choose a particular model and find analytical solutions to the einstein equations in this model . in sect .
[ sc : z ] we demonstrate , by numerical computation , that modified black hole solutions exist in more realistic massive gravity models which are attractors of the cosmological evolution .
finally , sect .
[ sc : concl ] contains the summary and discussion of our results .
in this paper we consider the massive gravity model described by the following action @xcite , @xmath4 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first two terms are the curvature and the lagrangian of the minimally coupled ordinary matter ; they comprise the standard gr action .
the third term describes four scalar fields @xmath5 , @xmath6 whose space - time dependent vacuum expectation values break spontaneously the lorentz symmetry .
these fields are minimally coupled to gravity through a derivative coupling ; they will be referred to as the goldstone fields .
we consider the functions @xmath7 which depend on two particular combinations of the derivatives of the goldstone fields , @xmath8 , where @xmath9 the constant @xmath10 has the dimension of mass .
the model is understood as the low - energy effective theory valid below the scale @xmath10 .
the vacuum configuration has the form @xmath11 where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are two constants determined by the requirement that the energy - momentum tensor associated with the four scalar fields vanishes in the minkowski background .
the configuration ( [ eq : vacuum ] ) is , therefore , a solution to the einstein equations .
the constants @xmath12 and @xmath13 may be set to one by the redefinition of fields , which we assume to be the case in what follows . for functions @xmath14 which are invariant under rotations of the goldstone fields @xmath6 in the internal space ( i.e. , those depending on @xmath15 through three combinations @xmath16 , @xmath17 ) , the background ( [ eq : vacuum ] ) preserves the rotational symmetry .
the lorentz symmetry is , in general , broken .
the action of the goldstone fields with functions @xmath14 depending only on @xmath18 and @xmath15 is invariant under the following symmetry , @xmath19 where @xmath20 are arbitrary functions of @xmath21 . because of this symmetry , the behavior of perturbations about the vacuum ( [ eq : vacuum ] ) is non - pathological , i.e. there are neither ghost nor rapid instabilities @xcite .
the spectrum consist of two tensor modes ( graviton polarizations ) only , which are , in general , massive .
the graviton mass scale is @xmath22 . during the cosmological evolution , the universe described by the action ( [ eq : action ] )
is driven to an
attractor point @xcite
@xmath23 @xmath24 being a constant . at the attractor point
the theory possesses an additional symmetry , @xmath25 models described by the action ( [ eq : action ] ) with the function @xmath26 have been studied more intensively @xcite . in particular , it has been shown that for @xmath27 and for @xmath28 the cosmological perturbations in these models behave identically to those in gr @xcite .
for other values of @xmath24 the behavior of the perturbations may or may not reproduce that of gr depending on the initial conditions .
another reason to study models characterized by the function @xmath26 comes from the analysis of newtonian approximation .
the gravitational potential of a static source in the model ( [ eq : action ] ) , in the linear approximation , has the form @xcite @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the newton s constant and @xmath31 is a constant of order of the graviton mass whose value depends on the particular form of the function @xmath7 .
this constant vanishes at the point where the symmetry ( [ eq : symmetry2 ] ) holds , that is , where @xmath32 .
thus , at the point of the attractor the newtonian potential remains unmodified .
it has been shown that the standard schwarzschild metric is a solution to the einstein equations in massive gravity models possessing the symmetry ( [ eq : symmetry2 ] ) @xcite , with the scalar fields given by @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the schwarzschild radius of the black hole .
on the other hand , the metric of a rotating black hole is necessarily modified @xcite from its standard gr ( kerr ) form .
a static spherically symmetric configuration in the massive gravity model ( [ eq : action ] ) can be written in the following form , @xmath35 , \nonumber \\ \phi^i & = & \phi \left ( r \right ) \dfrac{\lambda^2 x^i}{r } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this field configuration is invariant under two residual coordinate transformations .
the first one is an arbitrary change of the radial coordinate @xmath36 , which allows to set either @xmath37 or @xmath38 .
the second one consist in redefining the time variable @xmath39 .
this last transformation allows to cancel either @xmath40 or @xmath41 .
we choose the conditions @xmath37 and @xmath42 .
thus , we get the following ansatz , @xmath43 , \nonumber \\ \phi^i & = & \phi \left ( r \right ) \dfrac{\lambda^2 x^i}{r } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] as compared to gr , this configuration contains two additional radial functions @xmath44 and @xmath45 . as has been pointed out in sect .
[ sc : intro - model ] , the rotational invariance of the vacuum ( and likewise , of the ansatz ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) ) requires that the function @xmath7 depends on @xmath15 through three combinations @xmath46 .
these combinations are expressed in terms of the radial functions and their derivatives as follows , @xmath47 where the two functions @xmath48 and @xmath49 are @xmath50 and @xmath51 in these expressions and in what follows , the prime denotes the derivative with respect to the radial coordinate @xmath52 . after fixing the ansatz ( [ eq : ansatz ] )
, the einstein equations reduce to the following four equations : @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the einstein tensor and @xmath55 is the energy - momentum tensor of the four goldstone fields .
the other six equations are identically satisfied .
the explicit expressions for the components of @xmath56 and @xmath57 are given in the appendix .
consider first the equation @xmath58 .
assuming @xmath59 , this equation gives @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 .
furthermore , the time and radial components of the energy - momentum tensor differ by the quantity proportional to eq .
( [ eq : t_0r=0 ] ) . therefore , when this equation holds one has @xmath63 .
this implies that @xmath64 or , equivalently , @xmath65 in full analogy with the schwarzschild solution in gr .
hence , the einstein equations reduce to the following four equations , @xmath66 , \label{eq : equat3 } \\ 0 & = & x \mathcal{f}_x + f_{1 } \left ( \mathcal{f}_1 - 2 f_1 \mathcal{f}_2 + 3 f_{1}^2 \mathcal{f}_3 \right ) , \label{eq : equat4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath67 . for a generic function @xmath14
, this system of equations is well defined . indeed ,
since the function @xmath44 enters the equations ( [ eq : equat1][eq : equat4 ] ) only through the variable @xmath18 , one may consider @xmath18 as an independent variable instead of @xmath44 .
then the fourth equation allows to find @xmath68 in terms of @xmath18 , while the first equation gives @xmath69 in terms of @xmath70 .
the second equation then gives @xmath18 in terms of @xmath70 and the third equation allows to determine @xmath70 as a function of @xmath52 .
finding analytical solutions of the non - linear system of equations like ( [ eq : equat1][eq : equat4 ] ) is impossible for a generic function @xmath7 .
so , in order to get some insight into the behavior of the solutions , let us choose the function @xmath14 in such a way that the resulting equations are solvable analytically . consider the function @xmath14 of the following form , @xmath71 where @xmath72 is an arbitrary dimensionless constant and @xmath73 ( the numerical value of @xmath74 can be absorbed into the constant @xmath10 ) .
the coefficients inside the parentheses are chosen in such a way that the vacuum ( [ eq : vacuum ] ) is the solution to the einstein equations at @xmath75 .
our example contains , therefore , a single continuous free parameter @xmath72 .
two additional constraints should be imposed on @xmath72 .
the first one comes from the requirement that the graviton is non - tachyonic .
this translates into the inequality @xmath76 the second condition is necessary to ensure that scalar modes with pathological behavior do not reappear upon addition of higher - derivative terms ( recall that the model ( [ eq : action ] ) is understood as the low - energy effective theory , so such terms are generically present ) .
this imposes certain constraint on the function @xmath7 and its derivatives ( cf .
( 70 ) of ref.@xcite ) , which in the case at hand implies @xmath77 we should stress that the choice of the functional form of @xmath14 is by no means unique . the particular form ( [ eq : fct - xw ] ) has been chosen in order to simplify the solution of the field equations , as will become clear below .
let us start with eq .
( [ eq : equat4 ] ) which takes the form @xmath78 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] because of our choice of the function @xmath14 , this equation contains the variable @xmath18 as an overall factor only .
hence , it reduces to a closed differential equation for @xmath68 .
the solution to this equation is @xmath79 where the constant @xmath13 satisfies the equation @xmath80 we are interested in real positive values of @xmath13 ( the case @xmath81 can be reduced to @xmath82 by the inversion of coordinates ) .
if @xmath83 there is only one such solution , @xmath84 if @xmath85 there exists another one , @xmath86 thus , at negative @xmath87 we have two different branches of solutions . the remaining equations ( [ eq : equat2 ] ) and ( [ eq : equat3 ] ) can be written as follows , @xmath88 where @xmath89 recall that , according to our normalization , the constant @xmath74 only takes two values , @xmath73 .
( [ eq : alpha(r ) ] ) is a linear inhomogeneous equation for @xmath70 .
its general solution can be found analytically .
making use of this solution and integrating the remaining equations one finally obtains : @xmath90^{1/2 } , \nonumber \\
\phi \left ( r \right ) & = & b r. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath91 and @xmath1 are two integration constants : @xmath91 is the schwarzschild radius , while @xmath1 is a scalar charge whose presence reflects the modification of the gravitational interaction as compared to gr . at @xmath92 the solution ( [ eq : sol - xw ] )
reduces to the conventional schwarzschild solution describing a black hole of the mass @xmath93 .
the behavior of the metric at @xmath94 depends on the constants @xmath72 and @xmath73 . if @xmath95 , we must also take @xmath96 , and the only solution of eq .
( [ eq : a ] ) in this case is @xmath97 .
hence , we have @xmath98 , @xmath99 , and the metric is growing at infinity as @xmath100 .
such solutions do not describe asymptotically flat space . if @xmath101 , we must take @xmath102 in order to satisfy eqs .
( [ eq : positive - mass ] ) and ( [ eq : no - tachyons ] ) . in this case @xmath103
. two branches of solutions exist , one with zero , and one with non - zero cosmological constant , which can be positive or negative depending on the numerical value of @xmath72 . in what follows we consider the branch with @xmath98 ( @xmath97 ) .
the behavior of the solutions is determined by the two integration constants @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and the value of the parameter @xmath104 . if @xmath105 , the third term on the r.h.s . of eq .
( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) dominates at large distances .
the adm mass of these solutions is infinite .
we do not discuss them further here . if @xmath106 , the standard schwarzschild term dominates at infinity .
the adm mass of such solutions is equal to @xmath0 . the solutions with positive ( negative )
@xmath0 have attractive ( repulsive ) behavior at infinity . at the origin @xmath107
both terms proportional to @xmath0 and @xmath1 are singular , so the metric always possesses a singularity unless @xmath108 .
this singularity may or may not be hidden by the horizon depending on the signs and values of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
the solutions possessing the horizon are candidates for modified black holes .
the horizon is always present if both @xmath0 and @xmath1 are positive .
such black holes have attractive gravitational potential at all distances , which is stronger than for a conventional black hole of the mass @xmath0 .
the horizon size of the modified black hole is larger than @xmath109 . if @xmath110 and @xmath111 , the presence of the horizon depends on the relative values of @xmath1 and @xmath0 .
it exists for sufficiently small @xmath1 . defining , on dimensional grounds , the mass parameter @xmath112 associated with @xmath1 by the relation @xmath113
, the existence of horizon requires that @xmath114 the newtonian potentials for solutions satisfying and not satisfying the condition ( [ eq : horizon ] ) are shown in fig .
[ fig:1](a ) and ( b ) , respectively .
when the horizon exists , the gravitational field is attractive all the way to the horizon .
the attraction is weaker than in the case of the usual schwarzschild black hole of mass @xmath0 , and the horizon size is smaller .
the behavior of the gravitational force with distance mimics that of the smaller - mass black hole plus a continuous distribution of `` dark matter '' , with the total mass enclosed within the radius @xmath52 approaching @xmath0 as @xmath94 .
finally , at @xmath115 and @xmath116 the modified black hole anti - gravitates at large distances and gravitates close to the horizon .
the attraction changes to repulsion at @xmath117 the corresponding newtonian potential is shown in fig .
[ fig:1](c ) .
a remark is in order at this point . in the conventional general relativity
the constant @xmath34 or equivalently , the black hole mass @xmath0 , is also a free parameter which can , in principle , be positive or negative . in gr , however , only positive values make sense for the following reasons .
first , negative - mass schwarzschild solutions possess naked singularity at the origin , which is physically unacceptable .
second , the conventional matter satisfies the null energy condition which ensures that any compact spherically - symmetric matter distribution has a positive mass @xcite .
none of these arguments go through in the case of massive gravity . fig .
[ fig:1](c ) gives an example of solution with repulsive behavior at large distances and without naked singularity : as for a conventional black hole , the singularity of this solution is hidden behind the horizon .
the positivity of energy is also not expected in massive gravity .
this is related to the fact that the background ( [ eq : vacuum ] ) breaks time translations , and only the combination of the time translations with the shifts of @xmath5 by a constant remains unbroken . in this respect
the massive gravity model is exactly analogous to the ghost condensate model @xcite , where the negative - energy states have been constructed explicitely @xcite .
the solutions found in the previous section have the asymptotic behavior different from that obtained in the linear perturbation theory in ref . @xcite . in order to compare our results with those of ref .
@xcite , let us discuss them in the gauge where @xmath118 , @xmath119 ( cf .
[ sc : ansatz ] ) . in this gauge
the perturbation theory of ref .
@xcite corresponds to assuming that the variations of all the metric components are of the same order . in other words , they are formally assigned a small parameter @xmath120 to the first power .
the solutions described in ref .
@xcite satisfy the einstein equations expanded to the linear order in @xmath120 .
the solution ( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) is not of this type . transforming it into the gauge
@xmath118 one finds that @xmath121 does not decay as fast as the perturbations of other components , for instance , as @xmath122 .
in fact , in the equations expanded in powers of perturbations the terms of order @xmath123 balance those linear in @xmath122 .
in other words , in the formal expansion of the solution of sect . [ sc : xw ] in powers of the small parameter @xmath120
the perturbation @xmath124 should be assigned the order @xmath125 rather than @xmath120 .
hence , the solution ( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) is non - linear even at large distances from the center .
a similar phenomenon has been observed in the context of bi - gravity models in ref .
@xcite .
another difference between the solution ( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) and the solution to the linearized equations of ref .
@xcite is that the former is static , while in the latter only metric components are static ( in the gauge @xmath126 ) .
the scalar fields have time dependence which may be viewed as an accretion of a fluid with zero energy - momentum tensor . in general relativity
, one may relate the mass of a star to an integration constant of the vacuum solution in the exterior space by matching the interior and exterior solutions at the star surface ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . in massive gravity
, one may try to use the same approach to determine the scalar charge of an ordinary star .
the analytical solution in the interior region is required for the matching procedure .
the star is described , to a good approximation , by a diagonal energy - momentum tensor @xmath127 , where @xmath128 and @xmath129 are the energy density and pressure inside the star , respectively .
this energy - momentum tensor is assumed to be responsible for the external gravitational field described by eq .
( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) .
since there is no direct coupling between the ordinary matter and the goldstone fields , @xmath130 must be conserved separately , @xmath131 .
for simplicity , we take the energy density to be constant at @xmath132 , where @xmath133 is the surface of the star , and zero outside . the pressure @xmath129 can not be chosen independently ; it is determined by the conservation of @xmath130 . because of the spherical symmetry , the ansatz ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) holds .
the einstein equations in the interior of the star are obtained from eqs .
( [ eq : equat1][eq : equat3 ] ) by adding the contributions of the energy - momentum of the star , while eq .
( [ eq : equat4 ] ) remains unchanged .
the resulting set of equations can be solved analytically .
the solution reads @xmath134^{-1 } , \nonumber \\
h \left ( r \right ) & = & \pm \int \dfrac{{\textrm{d}}r}{\alpha } \left [ 1 - \alpha \left ( \dfrac{s_{2}}{c_{0 } m^2 } \dfrac{\lambda-1}{r^{\lambda+2 } } + 1 \right)^{-1 } \right]^{1/2 } , \nonumber \\
\phi \left ( r \right ) & = & b r. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for simplicity , we have expanded the first equation in powers of @xmath128 , while the other relations are exact . since the geometry inside the star is regular , the integration constants @xmath135 and @xmath136 must be set to zero .
the interior solution has to be matched with the solution ( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) at @xmath133 .
it is convenient to match the variable @xmath18 which equals 1 in the interior region . in the gauge
@xmath118 this variable is nothing but the @xmath137 component of the metric .
hence , it must be continuous .
making use of eqs .
( [ eq : sol - xw ] ) one can see that the continuity of @xmath18 at @xmath133 requires that @xmath92 .
therefore , the scalar charge of an ordinary star is zero .
it remains an open question how objects ( e.g. , black holes ) with @xmath138 can be created . the argument given above
does not apply to time - dependent configurations , so it is possible that a non - zero scalar charge may be acquired during the gravitational collapse .
as mentioned earlier , models characterized by the function @xmath7 of a single variable @xmath139 are of a particular interest .
we discuss in this section the exact static spherically symmetric solutions in these models .
our goal is to demonstrate that the solutions found earlier are not specific to the particular form of the action ( [ eq : fct - xw ] ) and exist also in the models obeying the symmetry ( [ eq : symmetry2 ] ) . in sect .
[ sc : xw ] the analytical solutions of eqs .
( [ eq : equat1][eq : equat4 ] ) were obtained by choosing the function @xmath7 in such a way that the dependence on @xmath18 factors out in eq .
( [ eq : equat4 ] ) .
since now @xmath14 has only one argument , the derivatives of @xmath14 with respect to @xmath18 and @xmath15 are no more independent . for this reason we did not succeed in constructing non - trivial examples where the einstein equations are solvable analytically .
hence , to demonstrate the existence of solutions we have to use numerical methods .
consider the following function @xmath14 , @xmath140 were @xmath141 are tree independent scalars made out of @xmath142 , @xmath143 .
the coefficients in front of individual terms have been adjusted so that the flat metric and the scalar fields given by eq .
( [ eq : vacuum ] ) solve the field equations at @xmath75 . for the vacuum configuration ( [ eq : vacuum ] ) one has @xmath144 .
we are interested in solutions to the field equations that asymptote to this vacuum state .
in addition to the adjustments already made , the following inequality should be imposed on the coefficients @xmath72 and @xmath74 to ensure that the graviton is non - tachyonic , @xmath145 this guarantees that the square of the graviton mass is non - negative . moreover ,
this inequality is sufficient for the absence of pathological scalar modes which may appear upon addition of higher - derivative terms . as in the previous example
, the overall scale of the coefficients @xmath72 and @xmath74 can be absorbed in the parameter @xmath10 , so without loss of generality we may set @xmath146 . for this class of models , the field equations ( [ eq : equat1][eq : equat4 ] ) may be viewed as equations for @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 and @xmath150
. then eq .
( [ eq : equat1 ] ) gives @xmath69 in terms of @xmath70 , while eq .
( [ eq : equat4 ] ) enables to express @xmath151 in terms of @xmath152 .
the two remaining equations form a coupled set of non - linear equations for @xmath70 and @xmath152 ; they have to be solved numerically .
the numerical solutions are shown in fig .
[ fg : alpha ] for different value of the parameters @xmath153 and @xmath154 .
for all these graphs , we have assumed that the external horizon is located at @xmath155 and that @xmath156 at the horizon .
the large value of @xmath152 is chosen in order to make the difference between the modified solution and the schwarzschild solution visible on the plot ( large values of @xmath152 correspond to large scalar charge @xmath1 of the previous section ) . from one for three different cases : the usual schwarzschild solution ( solid line ) and two solutions corresponding to different values of the parameters of the function ( [ eq : functz ] ) ( long - dashed and short - dashed lines ) .
the integration constants of these solutions have been chosen such that the external horizon is located at @xmath155 .
, width=302 ] the plots show the behavior qualitatively similar to that discussed in section [ sc : xw ] .
in particular : * if @xmath157 , the newtonian potential @xmath158 is attractive at short distances and becomes repulsive at larger distances ; * if @xmath159 and @xmath160 , the newtonian potential is attractive outside of the horizon , and becomes repulsive close to the singularity .
the deviations from the schwarzschild metric are larger for larger values of the `` scalar charge '' ( parameterized by the value of @xmath152 at the horizon ) .
the schwarzschild solution is recovered at @xmath161 .
to summarize , there exist spherically symmetric vacuum solutions in massive gravity models which depend on two integration constants , the mass @xmath0 and an extra parameter @xmath1 which can be called the `` scalar charge '' . at zero value of the scalar charge
the standard schwarzschild solution is recovered , while at non - zero @xmath1 the metric is modified with respect to the schwarzschild case .
the solutions having non - zero scalar charge exhibit much reacher behavior than the schwarzschild solution in gr . as can be seen from the explicit example of sect .
[ sc : xw ] , both the short and long distance behavior may be modified depending on the parameters of the model . unlike in general relativity , the solutions may have a _ negative _ adm mass .
such solutions have repulsive gravitational interaction at large distances . at short distances
the repulsion may change to attraction and give rise to the horizon , hiding the singularity at the origin .
such solutions represent anti - gravitating black holes . in the case of a positive adm mass
, the @xmath1-dependent contributions may make the gravitational attraction weaker at short distances ( cf .
[ fig:1]-(a ) ) . in this case
the gravitational force decays with distance slower than @xmath162 , thus mimicking the presence of dark matter .
interestingly , solutions with the same value of @xmath0 but different scalar charge @xmath1 have different behavior , which corresponds to different amount of the apparent `` dark matter '' .
this is in contrast with other models possessing modifications of the gravitational potential @xcite , where the modification of the gravitational force is determined by the parameters of the model .
it is currently an open question how objects with non - zero scalar charge may be created . as has been argued in sect .
[ sec : grav - field - star ] , the absence of direct coupling between the goldstone fields and ordinary matter results in zero scalar charges of static matter distributions .
thus , the gravitational field of ordinary stars is described by the @xmath92 solutions , i.e. , by the standard schwarzschild metric .
this may be not the case for black holes , especially the super - massive black holes in the centers of galaxies , which may be of primordial origin @xcite . in any case
, this question requires further investigation .
another open question is the stability of the modified black hole solutions .
several kinds of instabilities may be present . among perturbations of the solutions there may exist unstable modes with the characteristic time scale of order of the horizon size ; in this case the interpretation in terms of black holes is not possible .
second potential source of problems is generic presence of the higher - derivative terms not included in the action ( [ eq : action ] ) .
one has to check that the 2-parameter family of modified black holes survives their inclusion . by analogy with the ghost condensate case
, one may expect that these terms produce at least a slow jeans - type instability @xcite , which is not , however , dangerous for the black hole interpretation .
finally , the presence of negative mass solutions may lead to instabilities of the quantum - mechanical nature similar to those found in ref.@xcite . to conclude this list ,
let us mention also the solutions satisfying @xmath163 which were not considered in this paper .
in this case the ten einstein equations reduce to three equations for @xmath70 , @xmath69 and @xmath68 which form a ( generically ) well - defined system .
it remains to be seen whether this system has asymptotically flat solutions . in any case
, the schwarzschild solution does not belong to this class which is characterized by @xmath164 .
we are grateful to s. dubovsky for valuable discussions and comments on the manuscript .
the work of m.b . is supported by the belgian _ fond pour la formation la recherche dans lindustrie et dans lagriculture ( fria)_. the work of p.t . is supported by iisn , belgian science policy ( under contract iap v/27 ) .
for the ansatz ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) discussed in section [ sc : ansatz ] , the non - zero components of the einstein tensor are given by the following relations @xmath165 , \\
\mathcal{g}_{r}^{r } & = & \dfrac{1}{r^2 } \left ( 1 - \dfrac{\alpha + r \alpha^{\prime}}{\alpha \beta } \right ) , \\ \mathcal{g}_{\theta}^{\theta } & = & \mathcal{g}_{\varphi}^{\varphi } = - \dfrac{1}{4 r } \left [ \dfrac{\alpha^{\prime } + r \alpha^{\prime\prime}}{\alpha \beta } + \left ( \dfrac{2 \alpha + r \alpha^{\prime}}{\alpha \beta } \right)^{\prime } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the energy - momentum tensor of the goldstone fields is expressed through @xmath166,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath167 and @xmath168 for functions @xmath14 which are invariant under rotations of the goldstone fields @xmath6 internal space , the derivatives of @xmath14 with respect to @xmath15 are given by @xmath169 where @xmath170 .
therefore , the components of the energy - momentum tensor which are not identically zero are given by @xmath171 , \\ & & \\
\mathcal{t}_{r}^{r } & = & \lambda^{4 } \left [ - \dfrac{1}{2 } \mathcal{f } - \left ( \mathcal{f}_{x } + \dfrac{\partial \mathcal{f}}{\partial w^{ij } } \dfrac{v^{i } v^{j}}{x^{2 } } \right ) \dfrac{h^{\prime2}}{\beta } \right ] \\ & & + \dfrac{1}{\beta } \dfrac{\partial \mathcal{f}}{\partial w^{ij } } \left ( - \partial_r \phi^i \partial_r \phi^j + \dfrac{2 v^{j}}{x } \partial_r \phi^i \partial_r \phi^0 \right ) , \\ \mathcal{t}_{\theta}^{\theta } & = & \mathcal{t}_{\varphi}^{\varphi } = - \dfrac{1}{2 } \lambda^{4 } \mathcal{f } + \dfrac{\partial \mathcal{f}}{\partial w^{ij } } \partial^\theta \phi^i \partial_\theta \phi^j , \\ \mathcal{t}_{0}^{r } & = & - \dfrac{\lambda^{4 } h^{\prime}}{\beta } \left [ \mathcal{f}_{x } + \dfrac{\partial \mathcal{f}}{\partial w^{ij } } \left ( \dfrac{v^{i } v^{j}}{x^{2 } } + \dfrac{\partial_r \phi^i \partial_r \phi^{j}}{\beta \lambda^{4 } x } \right ) \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] | the static vacuum spherically symmetric solutions in massive gravity are obtained both analytically and numerically . the solutions depend on two parameters ( integration constants ) : the mass @xmath0 ( or , equivalently , the schwarzschild radius ) , and an additional parameter , the `` scalar charge '' @xmath1 . at zero value of @xmath1 and positive
mass the standard schwarzschild black hole solutions are recovered .
depending on the parameters of the model and the signs of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , the solutions may or may not have horizon .
those with the horizon describe modified black holes provided they are stable against small perturbations . in the analytically solvable example , the modified black hole solutions may have both attractive and repulsive ( anti - gravitating ) behavior at large distances . at intermediate distances
the gravitational potential of a modified black hole may mimics the presence of dark matter .
modified black hole solutions are also found numerically in more realistic massive gravity models which are attractors of the cosmological evolution .
massive gravity , spherically symmetric solutions , black holes .
ulb - th/09 - 05 |
the nonlinear schrdinger equation is a powerful tool for describing bose einstein condensates at zero temperature .
double well potentials are an important class of configurations to which this tool can be applied . for square wells ,
exact solutions are known to exist @xcite . in zi _
@xcite , we outlined a method for obtaining such exact solutions for a symmetric double square well situation with attractive interaction .
we found an exact criterion to determine the bifurcation point .
here we perform similar calculations for the repulsive case and extend our treatment , including wells of different depth but also a stability analysis .
the repulsive case is perhaps more interesting in view of the fact that , for this interaction , situations such that most of the condensate was contained in one of the wells have been seen experimentally @xcite .
we also present some dynamic calculations not included in @xcite for both kinds of interaction .
these lean somewhat on a generalized josephson junction model @xcite .
we note in passing that a josephson junction for a bose - einstein condensate was first obtained by inguscio s group @xcite , see also @xcite .
symmetry breaking solutions that are known to exist for positive nonlinearity ( repulsive interaction in the case of bec , dark solitons in nonlinear optical media ) often tend to localize the wave function in one of the wells .
this happens for the nonlinearity exceeding a critical value at which the asymmetric solutions branch off from the symmetry preserving ones in the parameter space .
therefore , we can talk about bifurcation at this critical value of nonlinearity .
the existence of such solutions of the nonlinear schrdinger equation was first pointed out in the context of molecular states for repulsive interaction @xcite , as will be treated here .
importantly , the effect of this spontaneous symmetry breaking has been observed in photonic lattices @xcite .
it should be stressed that the nature of bifurcation depends on the symmetry of the problem and is of the pitchfork variety for even wells and saddle point for uneven wells @xcite . in this paper
we will consider a double square well potential , first symmetric and then asymmetric .
the asymmetric potential leads to more complicated profiles .
as far as we know , these square well configurations are the only ones for which exact solutions exist
. these solutions are all in the form of jacobi elliptic functions .
one of the problems considered here , extending @xcite to repulsive interaction , is how to proceed from easily obtainable symmetric double well solutions of the linear schrdinger equation to the fully nonlinear case , and from so obtained symmetric solutions on to the bifurcated , asymmetric ones .
when the _ potential _ is asymmetric both bifurcation of the static solutions and the dynamics of oscillating solutions will be seen to become very different from those for the symmetric potential .
the manuscript is composed as follows : in section [ sec1 ] we derive symmetry preserving states starting from the linear limit and then gradually increasing the nonlinear interaction . in section
iii we investigate the symmetry breaking states that branch off from the symmetry preserving ones in the parameter space .
we give a simple exact formula for the bifurcation point .
section iv treats asymmetric potentials .
section v is devoted to dynamics treated by the josephson model , particularly useful at the bifurcation point , and then numerically .
results are consistent by all three methods ( sections iii , iv and v ) .
some concluding remarks wind up the text ( section vi ) .
heavier calculations have been relegated to the appendix .
this paper can be read independently of reference @xcite .
we start from the nonlinear schrdinger equation @xmath0 f(x)=\mu f(x)\ ] ] here the potential is of the form @xmath1 see fig .
solutions in the three regions will be written as @xmath2 the solutions vanish on and outside the outer boundaries @xmath3 .
we assume continuity of @xmath4 and its derivative at @xmath5 and normalization to @xmath6 . the symmetric solutions are @xmath7 and the antisymmetric solutions , which will be of particular interest here , are @xmath8 here @xmath9 and @xmath10
have been chosen to be zero at the ends , and also so as to preserve even and odd parity respectively for the two cases .
the parameters of the symmetric solutions are found from eq .
( [ nls ] ) to satisfy ( @xmath11 ) @xmath12 and for the antisymmetric solutions we have @xmath13 positive roots for all the a s are taken throughout .
we choose @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 to generate all the other constants .
these three parameters will determine the solution completely . ,
@xmath17 and @xmath18.,width=321 ] we now concentrate on the antisymmetric case , as we have checked that bifurcation only occurs for this case in the lowest mode as suggested by fig .
[ rys3 ] ( and also by fig . 3 of ref .
we have two continuity conditions at @xmath19 @xmath20 here @xmath21 . the normalization of the wave function , @xmath22 yields @xmath23 the above normalization condition works out as : @xmath24 + { 4k}\left [ k\omega - e(k \omega |m ) \right ] = { \eta},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath25 is the elliptic function of the second kind @xcite . we now have three equations for @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath14 as required . here
@xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 are fixed and describe one specific experimental setup . up to now
, the shooting method was used to find solutions @xcite . to systematically solve our equations we first turn to the linear limit @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 .
the functions are now easy to calculate @xmath33 the two continuity conditions are : @xmath34 this last equation will give us linear @xmath14 in terms of fixed parameters .
the normalization condition is @xmath35 giving a value for @xmath36 , and @xmath37 follows from continuity .
we are now ready to tie this solution up to the small @xmath29 limit in a perturbative manner .
we notice that @xmath38 obtained in the linear approach become a zero order approximation in an @xmath29 expansion
. the parameters @xmath15 and @xmath39 are both of order @xmath29 and follow from equations ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ wargranlin ] ) @xmath40 linear @xmath14 , denoted by @xmath41 , is found as the lowest root of @xmath42 there will also be a small @xmath29 correction @xmath43 such that @xmath44 .
this will complete the calculation of the three unknowns @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 in the small @xmath29 limit ( appendix ) .
now that we have a starting point , we can generate all symmetric solutions by gradually increasing @xmath29 .
we introduce the notation @xmath45 , and @xmath16 .
we write the conditions ( [ 8 ] ) and ( [ 9 ] ) in the symbolic functional form @xmath46 here we used eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) to express the amplitudes @xmath36 and @xmath37 in terms of the @xmath47 and the wavevectors @xmath48 and @xmath49 , which in turn can be expressed in terms of the @xmath47 .
the left hand side of equation ( [ warnorm ] ) defines @xmath50 , which is evidently free of @xmath29 . upon defining @xmath51
we write all three conditions ( [ 8 ] ) , ( [ 9 ] ) and ( [ warnorm ] ) simply as @xmath52 in all three equations ( [ eqh ] ) functions @xmath53 on the left , remain free of @xmath29 .
hence if we increase @xmath29 by a small increment @xmath54 the parameters @xmath47 will increase by @xmath55 governed by @xmath56 where @xmath57 . assuming the matrix @xmath58 to be nonsingular we can now generate increments in @xmath47 by gradually increasing the control parameter @xmath29 .
inverting eq .
( [ increment ] ) we find @xmath59
even when the double well is symmetric , the nonlinear schrdinger equation is known to admit symmetry breaking states .
this is in contradistinction to the linear version , admitting only symmetric and antisymmetric states as treated in section ( [ sec1 ] ) .
these symmetry breaking states are possible above a critical value of @xmath29 .
they are of considerable physical interest , as they include situations such as the location of most of the wavefunction in one half of the double well . more generally , there is the possibility of very different profiles in the two halves .
the solutions corresponding to symmetry breaking are known to bifurcate from the antisymmetric ones . here
we will give a condition defining the bifurcation points in parameter space and investigate how this bifurcation can be interpreted .
we will give diagrams to illustrate this .
similar diagrams for a quartic potential can be found in @xcite , however they do not correspond to any analytic solutions known to us .
solutions generalizing the symmetric case are : @xmath60 and the generalization for the antisymmetric case is : @xmath61 when @xmath62 , @xmath63 the solutions ( [ symetric ] ) and ( [ antisymetric ] ) are recovered .
once again we concentrate on a generalization of the antisymmetric case , as the only one branching off from a basic mode .
we now have five conditions for @xmath64 , which we will denote @xmath65 @xmath66 and in place of equation ( [ eqh ] ) we have @xmath67 , see the appendix .
one solution is @xmath68 , as we know , and conditions ( [ 8 ] ) , ( [ 9 ] ) and ( [ warnorm ] ) are recovered .
however , as we will see , above a certain threshold in @xmath29 a second solution appears .
the value of @xmath29 at which this bifurcation occurs will be denoted by @xmath69 .
the second solution branches off the antisymmetric one at this point . to find it
we note that at such a point the antisymmetric solution is continuous with respect to @xmath29 , whereas the asymmetric one is not .
therefore we expect the @xmath70 matrix @xmath58 to be nonsingular , whereas the @xmath71 matrix @xmath72 will be singular at this point .
simple algebra shows that the determinant of the @xmath71 matrix can be factorized at the bifurcation point for which @xmath73 and @xmath62 . @xmath74 and @xmath75
is found to be given by : @xmath76_{m_1=m_3 , d=0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in view of the above , @xmath77 .
this condition can be expressed in terms of variables _ characterizing the antisymmetric solution_. if we write conditions ( [ newcondit1 ] ) , ( [ newcondit2 ] ) as @xmath78 and @xmath79 we obtain a simple condition for the bifurcation point : @xmath80 this further simplifies to : @xmath81 = 0.\label{nieglupi}\ ] ] .,width=321 ] thus we can find the bifurcation point on the antisymmetric branch in terms of just two of the antisymmetric variables . having that point we can move out onto the asymmetric branch using : @xmath82 this equation can be used everywhere except at the branch point , where second derivatives must come in .
we have checked numerically that condition ( [ nieglupi ] ) is always satisfied at the bifurcation point . for an illustration of a bifurcated asymmetric solution paired with the corresponding symmetry preserving one far from bifurcation ,
see fig .
[ rysstany ] .
suppose now that the right hand well is somewhat shallower that on the left ( @xmath83 ) .
otherwise we keep the notation of fig .
( [ eq1 ] ) is now replaced by @xmath84 equation ( [ eq2 ] ) is similarly modified .
when this is done all formulas for the symmetry breaking case formally carry through , with the understanding that @xmath85 is now @xmath86 .
interchanging @xmath87 and @xmath88 no longer gives a trivial alteration .
solutions with most of the condensate on the left or on the right are no longer mirror images . also , the linear limit is altered , relevant equations becoming @xmath89 even in this limit , we now have five equations for five unknowns : @xmath87 , @xmath16 , @xmath88 , @xmath14 and @xmath90 .
this limit is thus nolonger much simpler than the fully nonlinear case .
however this is not worth pursuing , as the interesting bifurcation does not now occur from the `` linear '' branch .
illustrations of how phase diagrams are modified as compared to the symmetric potential case are given in fig .
[ rys2 ] , e and f. as we increase @xmath29 from zero , a new double fixed point suddenly appears and bifurcates as we increase @xmath29 ( see the next section ) .
thus we have two new fixed points ( nolonger a pitchfork bifurcation ) .
now allow @xmath91 to be time dependent and satisfy the one dimensional equation @xmath92 f(x , t),\ ] ] with potential @xmath93 in the form of a double well , which is not necessarily symmetric . to establish a link between the above equation and the josephson model , we first focus on the energy spectrum of the system in the linear limit ( @xmath94 ) .
it consists of pairs of energy levels separated by a gap that is proportional to the height of the barrier ; for a sufficiently high barrier the spacing between the pairs is larger than the spacing within the first pair . in this case
we can construct a variational analysis based on the lowest pair of levels , @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
we assume that @xmath97 is normalized to unity and approximate it by @xmath98 , where @xmath99 are defined as @xmath100 the eigenstates @xmath101 and @xmath102 are orthonormal .
amplitudes @xmath103 must satisfy @xmath104 and their time derivatives are approximately given by @xmath105 where @xmath106 w_{l , r}(x ) , \,\,\ , k = - \int w_l^*(x ) \left[-\frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^2 } + v(x ) \right ] w_r(x ) \
, \mbox{d}x,\,\,\ , u_{l , r } = \eta \int two expressions ( for @xmath107 and @xmath108 ) .
the josephson equations , @xmath109 will follow upon defining @xmath110 and rescaling the time @xmath111 . here
@xmath112 is the ratio of nonlinear coupling to tunneling and @xmath113 is the difference in the depth of the wells . with our simplifications and substitutions the suitably normalized hamiltonian of the system
can be obtained in the form ( see also @xcite ) @xmath114 the parameter @xmath112 is positive for repulsive interaction ( @xmath115 ) and negative for attractive interaction ( @xmath116 ) .
note the two symmetries : @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
the first of these symmetries implies that completely solving for @xmath119 gives the solution for @xmath120 .
these equations differ from those governing josephsonian oscillations in superconducting junctions by two additional terms : one proportional to @xmath112 which derives from the nonlinear interaction ( it has the same sign as @xmath29 ) and the constant @xmath113 , owing its existence to the asymmetry of the potential .
consider the stationary solutions of the josephson equations . from eq .
( [ jos1 ] ) we see that @xmath121 . in fig .
[ rysnowy ] we see how to find them graphically . for @xmath122
there are always two solutions with @xmath123 .
the other two solutions appear for nonzero @xmath124 when @xmath125 ( or @xmath126 ) . in the case of nonzero @xmath113
there are also always at least two solutions .
the other two appear above @xmath112 equal @xmath127 . having the stationary solutions we can draw the energy dependence on @xmath112 , shown in fig .
the two lowest eigenvectors of the nonlinear schrdinger equation ( solid lines ) are compared with those resulting from the josephson junction approach ( dashed lines ) for the case of equally deep wells .
notice the good agreement . ) with the dashed ones ( @xmath128 for @xmath129 - symmetric potential case ) and dashed dotted line ( @xmath130 for @xmath131 and @xmath132- asymmetric potential case).,width=321 ] now consider the dynamics of the @xmath133 case .
constant energy contours in @xmath124 , @xmath134 phase space followed by the system for positive @xmath112 are shown in fig .
[ rys2 ] , ( a - d ) , one each for @xmath135 , @xmath136 and two for @xmath137 , each of which is generic . the difference between the second and third case concerns the possibility of self trapping solutions oscillating about an average @xmath124 such that @xmath134 covers all possible values in the third case . however , the fixed point dynamics is common to the latter three cases .
fixed points are at : ( 1 ) @xmath123 , @xmath138 ; ( 2 ) @xmath123 , @xmath139 ; ( 3 ) @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 . the latter pair bifurcate from the second point as we increase @xmath112 through @xmath143 ,
see fig . 3 for an illustration of how this happens .
we will now look at the stability of the three classes of fixed points .
assume perturbations such that @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
simple calculations give values of @xmath146 for the three categories : + ( 1 ) @xmath147 ( phase point in the ( @xmath134,@xmath124 ) plane moves on an ellipse like trajectory around ( @xmath148,@xmath148 ) ) + ( 2 ) @xmath149 ( fixed point stable when @xmath135 , but when @xmath125 , any perturbation moves out along an arm of the separatrix emerging from ( @xmath150,@xmath148 ) ) + ( 3 ) @xmath151 ( phase point moves on an ellipse like trajectory around one of ( @xmath150,@xmath152 ) ) + thus , according to this criterion the first fixed point is always stable for @xmath153 .
the antisymmetric solution ( 2 ) is stable for @xmath154 and unstable for @xmath155 .
the bifurcated pair ( 3 ) is always stable and we have a typical pitchfork bifurcation at @xmath143 .
these results are in full agreement with a numerical stability analysis based on the nonlinear schrdinger equation ( see fig .
. we might add that they contradict some statements in the literature , e.g. @xcite and @xcite . ) .
note the differences in the trajectories between the cases b and e , especially in the `` waves '' that cover the entire @xmath134-range .
the fixed points are still present in the corners of the fourth frame ( d ) but do not turn up on this scale.,width=321 ] for the antisymmetric states , @xmath156 : a ) @xmath157 , @xmath158 ; b ) @xmath159 , @xmath160 ; c ) @xmath161 , @xmath162 ; d ) @xmath163 , @xmath164 . as we see in the case of a ) , b ) and c ) the solution is stable .
the periods of oscillations match the formulas derived from the values of @xmath146 given in section 3 , @xmath165 . in case
d ) the solution is unstable .
the stability of the asymmetric bifurcated branch has also been confirmed.,width=321 ] one might wonder how the josephson bifurcation picture ties up with the exact solutions considered earlier .
suppose we have an analytic solution given by @xmath87 , @xmath16 , @xmath88 , @xmath14 and @xmath90 .
as @xmath139 in our considerations , this solution clearly corresponds to one of the bifurcated fixed points in the josephson model . how can we determine the corresponding value of @xmath112 so that @xmath124 takes the proper value ?
a good approximation to @xmath124 when @xmath90 is small , is ( appendix ) : @xmath166}{\left[(k_1 ^ 2+k_3 ^ 2)\omega - k_1 e(k_1\omega |m_1 ) - k_3 e(k_3\omega |m_3)\right]}\ ] ] and @xmath167 .
the apparent independence of @xmath90 is deceptive , as @xmath90 will determine @xmath87 and @xmath88 , above . in particular
when @xmath62 , @xmath168 , @xmath169 and @xmath123 as expected .
the antisymmetric solution is recovered .
when @xmath170 , the fixed points are still located at @xmath171 .
the stationary values of @xmath124 are now roots of the quartic @xmath172 and are shifted down as compared to the case of @xmath133 .
illustrations of how phase diagrams are modified as compared to the symmetric potential case are given in fig .
[ rys2 ] , e and f. now phase curves covering all possible @xmath134 values and such that @xmath124 changes sign are possible . as we increase @xmath112 from zero , a new double fixed point suddenly appears at a critical value of @xmath112 equal @xmath127 , and bifurcates as we increase @xmath112 .
thus for @xmath173 we have two new fixed points .
a stability analysis yields results similar to the above , for @xmath133 , but values of @xmath174 are now given in terms of roots of the quartic @xmath175 .
in this paper we have thoroughly investigated the behavior of bose - einstein condensates in double square well potentials , both symmetric and asymmetric .
a simple method for obtaining exact solutions for repulsive interaction was outlined ( similarly as in @xcite for attractive interaction ) .
we treat the system both exactly and by a josephson junction model .
we have checked the josephson model results , both static and dynamic , against exact calculations .
agreement is suprisingly good .
some controversies about the stability , to be found in the literature , have been resolved .
the authors would like to acknowledge support from kbn grant 2p03 b4325 ( e.i . ) , kbn grant 1p03b14629 ( p.z . ) and the polish ministry of scientific research and information technology under grant pbz - min-008/p03/2003 ( m.t . ) .
consultations with professor george rowlands were very helpful .
to find the @xmath43 correction we eliminate @xmath36 and @xmath37 from equations ( [ 8 ] ) and ( [ 9 ] ) @xmath176 and calculate the perfect differential of @xmath177 for small @xmath29 .
as the first two differentials follow from eqs .
( [ eq6 ] ) @xmath43 can be so obtained .
this calculation is somewhat less straightforward .
it completes the calculation of @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath14 in the small @xmath29 limit , our starting point . in the limit @xmath15 and @xmath39 tending to zero eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) is recovered from ( [ rf ] ) .
the general equation for small increments of @xmath178 and @xmath14 is @xmath179 and so @xmath180 where in the perturbation limit @xmath15 and @xmath39 are proportional to @xmath29 and are given by equation ( [ eq6 ] ) .
we find after some calculations using known identities @xcite @xmath181 and @xmath182 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are taken in the linear limit .
we obtain @xmath183 the continuity conditions at @xmath5 are now generalized to : @xmath184 and the normalization condition is now : @xmath185 \\ \nonumber & & - { 2k_2 } \left [ e(k_2 ( b+d)|m_2 ) + e(k_2 ( b - d)|m_2)\right ] \\
\nonumber & & + { 2k_1}\left [ k_1\omega - e(k_1 \omega |m_1)\right ] + { 2k_3}\left [ k_3\omega - e(k_3 \omega
|m_3 ) \right ] = { \eta}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we can assume @xmath186 much smaller than one , eqs .
( [ eq8 ] ) and ( [ g4row ] ) up to second order simplify to : @xmath187 + 4k_2 \left[\mbox{sn}(k_2b|m_2)\mbox{dc}(k_2b|m_2)-e(k_2b|m_2 ) \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where : @xmath188^{3/2 } \sqrt{1-m_2 } \ \ \ \ k^2 = \frac{\mu}{1+m } \ \ \
k_2 ^ 2 = \frac{v_0-\mu}{2-m_2 } \\
\nonumber \phi(m ) & = & 2k \left [ k\omega - e(k\omega |m ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath189 / \left [ \phi(m_1 ) + \phi(m_3 ) \right]$ ] . by comparing @xmath90 determined by the first and third equations we can reduce the system to just four equations for four unknowns , @xmath87 , @xmath16 , @xmath88 and @xmath14 .
e. sakellari , n.p .
proukakis , m. leadbeater and c.s .
adams , new journal of physics * 6 * , 42 ( 2004 ) .
elena a. ostrovskaya , _ et .
al _ , phys .
a * 61 * , 031601(r ) ( 2000 ) .
s. giovanazzi , a. smerzi and s. fantoni , phys . rev
. lett . * 84 * , 4521 ( 2000 ) .
et al _ , phys .
* 79 * , 4950 ( 1997 ) .
j. p. g. kevrekidis , zhigang chen , b. a. malomed , d. j. frantzeskakis and m. i. weinstein , physics letters a * 340 * , 275 ( 2005 ) .
g. ioos , d.d .
joseph , _ elementary stability and bifurcation theory _ , springer , new york 1980 . | in this paper we treat the behavior of bose einstein condensates in double square well potentials , both of equal and different depths . for even depth , symmetry preserving solutions to the relevant nonlinear schrdinger equation is known , just as in the linear limit . when the nonlinearity is strong enough
, symmetry breaking solutions also exist , side by side with the symmetric one .
interestingly , solutions almost entirely localized in one of the wells are known as an extreme case . here
we outline a method for obtaining all these solutions for repulsive interactions . the bifurcation point at which , for critical nonlinearity
, the asymmetric solutions branch off from the symmetry preserving ones is found analytically .
we also find this bifurcation point and treat the solutions generally via a josephson junction model .
when the confining potential is in the form of two wells of different depth , interesting new phenomena appear .
this is true of both the occurrence of the bifurcation point for the static solutions , and also of the dynamics of phase and amplitude varying solutions . again
a generalization of the josephson model proves useful .
the stability of solutions is treated briefly . |
massive black holes weighing from a million to a billion suns have long been suspected to be the powerhouse of energetic phenomena taking place in distant galaxies .
energy in the form of radiation , high velocity plasma outflows , and ultra relativistic jets , is extracted efficiently from the gravitational field of the black hole when gas is accreting from the parsec scale of a galactic nucleus down to the scale of the horizon . since the early discovery of quasars , the accretion paradigm has been at the heart of the interpretation of massive black holes as being `` real '' sources in the universe .
it was also recognized in the late 60 s that the luminous quasars and the active galactic nuclei ( agns ) were undergoing strong cosmic evolution : nuclear activity was common in the past and declined with cosmic time .
no bright quasar lives in our local universe , but a few agns are present with very modest activity , representing the fading tail of the population . from simple considerations on the life - cycle of quasars ,
there has been always the suspicion that at high redshifts accretion was ignited in many if not all galaxies , leading to the commonly held premise that most galaxies we see in our local universe should host in their nucleus a massive black hole , relic of an earlier active phase . for long times , black hole masses in agns and quasars
have been inferred only indirectly using as chief argument the concept of eddington limited accretion . but
today , due largely to the impact of ground - based telescopes and of the hubble space telescope , the mass of quiescent black holes inside the cores of nearby galaxies including our own milky way , has been measured using stars and/or gas clouds as dynamical probes .
now there is indeed strong circumstantial evidence that massive black holes are ubiquitous in ellipticals and in the bulges of disk galaxies .
astronomers discovered in addition , and most importantly , the existence of tight correlations between the black hole mass and the large scale properties of the underlying host@xmath2 .
it is currently believed that during the formation of galaxies , a universal mechanism was at play able to deposit , in the nuclear regions , large amounts of gas to fuel the black hole to such an extent that its feedback , i.e. its large - scale energy / momentum injection , had blown the gas out , thus sterilizing the galaxy against further star formation@xmath3 .
major galaxy mergers could be at the heart of this symbiotic relationship as they may explain both the ignition of a powerful agn and the formation of a violently perturbed galaxy remnant dominated by stellar dispersion@xmath4 .
galaxy formation is a genuine cosmological problem : the cooling and collapse of baryons in dark matter halos , clustering hierarchically , is the prime element for understanding galaxy evolution .
the time of first appearance of black holes in mini - halos is largely unknown : whether they formed at redshift @xmath5 as relic of the first metal free stars@xmath6 , or later in more massive virialized haloes from unstable gaseous disks or dense young star clusters , is unknown@xmath7 .
what is currently known is that black holes mainly grow from gas accretion@xmath8 , and that bright quasars , hosting a billion solar mass black hole , are already in place out to redshift @xmath9 when the universe was @xmath10 years old@xmath11 .
the new paradigm of the concordant evolution of black holes and galaxies imposes a new perspective : black holes previously believed to play a passive role are now in `` action '' shaping their cosmic environment@xmath12 .
the coevolution of black hole and galaxies embraces a variety of astrophysical phenomena that are now becoming of major scientific interest .
they go from the formation of black hole seeds in the first pre - galactic structures clustering hierarchically at very high redshifts , to black hole growth and feedback in major gas - rich mergers .
but not only .
a new and critical aspect of this concordant evolution is the presence of _ black hole pairs _ in galaxies that form during the violence of a merger .
_ there is growing evidence that nature provides through mergers the privileged habitat where massive binary black holes can form and evolve . _ but why are _ binary black holes _ important ?
the answer is manyfold and is the focus of this writing .
the review is organized as follows . in section 1.2
we introduce key physical scales of black hole binaries on their path to coalescence under the emission of gravitational waves . in section 1.3
we summarize current evidence of dual and binary black holes in the realm of observations .
section 1.4 reports on the quest for the presence of massive black hole binaries in bright elliptical galaxies .
section 2 describes the basic physics of black hole inspiral both in gas - poor and gas - rich environments also with use of numerical simulations .
section 3 summarizes selected results attained over the last years in the study of black hole hardening in pure stellar / collisionless backgrounds .
section 4 shows key results on the formation of black hole pairs / binaries during gas - rich major as well as minor mergers , simulated with unprecedented accuracy starting from cosmologically motivated initial conditions . in section 5 we address a number of issues related to the dynamics of binary black holes in massive gaseous disks : orbital decay , eccentricity evolution , accretion on flight and migration in a circum - binary disk .
section 6 explores the delicate and important issue on the electromagnetic counterparts of gravitational wave coalescence events .
section 7 contains our conclusions and future perspectives .
einstein s theory of space - time and gravity , general relativity , predicts that motions of masses produce propagating waves that travel through space - time at the speed of light @xmath13 .
two masses ( of total mass @xmath14 ) in a binary emit gravitational waves that in the far field zone , i.e. much farther away from the source , perturb space - time with a dimensionless metric - strain amplitude @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the distance and @xmath17 the orbital velocity ( in geometric units ) .
this indicates that the strongest sources of gravitational waves are the most massive bodies that move close to the speed of light , i.e. the most massive black holes ( @xmath18 ) that move in a binary , with @xmath19 at the moment of their coalescence .
therefore , binary black holes `` created '' in merging galaxies offer one of the most promising venues of producing the loudest gravitational waves in the universe that the _ laser interferometer space antenna _ ( _ lisa _ ) or / and the pulsar timing array ( pta ) experiment are expected to detect @xmath20 . during late inspiral and final plung - in ,
the black holes become genuine dynamical entities , creating rich space - time structure that remains imprinted in the strain amplitude signal .
the detection of this signal gives unique probe of the existence of the horizon which clothes the interior singularity of the black hole . according to the _ no - hair _
theorem , a black hole is similar to an elementary particle specified uniquely by its mass @xmath21 and angular momentum @xmath22 ( dimensionless spin @xmath23 ) .
the size of the horizon that varies from @xmath24 for @xmath25 to @xmath26 for @xmath27 ( for a maximally rotating kerr hole ) is very tiny compared to the galactic scale : for @xmath25 , the horizon is @xmath28 , i.e. only @xmath29 ( considering that one pc is the mean distance between the stars in the solar neighborhood ) .
thus only through the detection of the waveforms emitted from `` coalescing '' and `` vibrating '' black holes we may hope to unravel their true nature@xmath30 . with _
lisa _ , black hole masses and spins will be measured with astonishing accuracy@xmath31 , and this claim suffices to explain why binary black holes are becoming now so important not only for exploiting the black hole demography in a cosmological context , but gravity in the strong field regime .
as two black holes of mass @xmath32 and @xmath33 coalesce , a new black hole forms with mass less than the sum @xmath34 according to the area theorem . gravitational waves carry away mass - energy and angular momentum , and depending on the spin , they carry away also linear momentum as the resulting radiation pattern is anisotropic .
the binary center of mass thus recoils back and the relic black hole acquires a kick@xmath35 .
while for slowly spinning black holes and for spins ( anti-)aligned with the orbital axis , recoil velocities are @xmath36 there are spin configurations for which the recoil can be as large as 4000 @xmath37 , i.e in excess of the escape velocity from the largest galaxies : this occurs when the black holes have comparable masses , and the spin vectors have opposite directions and lie in the orbital plane .
_ coalescence _ and _ recoil _ are the final step of a long process of _ slow inspiral_. according to the quadrupole formula , a binary of total mass @xmath14 , mass ratio @xmath38 semi - major axis @xmath39 and eccentricity @xmath40 is expected to coalesce , i.e. to reduce its axis @xmath41 virtually to zero , after a time span@xmath42 @xmath43 where @xmath44(1-e^2)^{-7/2}$ ] . for two black holes of @xmath45 released during a galaxy merger on a circular orbit at a distance @xmath46 pc , this time far exceeds the age of the universe ( @xmath47 yr ) .
it is thus clear that coalescing binary black holes are interesting astrophysical sources only if nature provides a dissipative mechanism that guides the inspiral from the scale of a merger , of @xmath48 kpc , to the scale @xmath49 below which gravitational waves are conducive to coalescence on a timescale @xmath50 yr : eq .
( 1 ) yields @xmath51 corresponding to @xmath52 schwarzschild radii for a black hole of mass @xmath45 . at @xmath49 , the orbital period ( for @xmath53 and @xmath54 ) is of only @xmath55 and the relative circular velocity @xmath56 is far in excess of the dispersion velocity of the ambient stars in a typical galaxy ( @xmath57 ) .
the dynamic range for describing the hole s inspiral is so overwhelmingly large and extreme , going from the kpc scale down to @xmath49 , that a variety of processes may conspire to bring ( or halt ) the black holes down to ( or away from ) coalescence .
thus , the main focus of this review is to highlight the _
physical _ and _ dynamical _ processes that guide the sinking of massive black holes during binary mergers down to @xmath49 .
[ fig:3c75 ] [ fig : ngc6240 ] mergers occur either in gas - poor environments where collisionless / stellar processes are at play , or / and in gas - rich environments where gas - dynamical processes assist the black hole inspiral .
observations seem to reflect this dichotomy : accreting black hole pairs are seen in elliptical galaxies devoid of cold gas , as well as in ultra luminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ) , prototypes of gas - rich mergers between spirals .
if accretion is triggered along the course of the merger , black holes can give origin to a rich phenomenology , that goes from dual to binary agn activity , in the radio - loud or radio - quite mode , according to their dynamics , habitat and merger type . with _ dual _ agns we will indicate , in the following , dual black holes that are simultaneously active during a galaxy - galaxy encounter , but are still at large relative separations . in this case they are not physically bound in a binary and so , their dynamics is determined by the gravitational potential of the interacting system . with _ binary _
agns we will indicate active black holes that are at close enough distances that they form a keplerian system in a merger remnant . _ recoiling _ agns have been also hypothesized following the recognition that asymmetric gravitational wave emission leads to large recoil velocities : they should appear as off - center agns accreting from a small punctured disk@xmath58 . in our local universe ,
3c 75 is a well studied double radio source at the center of the galaxy cluster abell 400@xmath59 .
figure 1 shows the radio and x - ray images of the composite source , and of the host galaxies in the optical .
evidence for interaction between the radio jets suggests that the sources are members of a system undergoing a large scale merger .
_ chandra _ observations have confirmed the presence of two x - ray nuclei 7 kpc apart , and of diffuse thermal emission along the radio streams , indicating that their proximity is not an artifact of a projection effect .
3c 75 is not the only case known of a dual agn : pks 2149 - 158 a and pks 2149 - 158 b in abell 2382 is a dumbbell system@xmath60 hosting two radio cores with extended twin - jets , observed at a projected distance of 16 kpc .
the jets emanate from two ellipticals of comparable luminosity and show signs of interaction with the intra cluster medium . only through dedicated optical and x - ray follow - up observations it will be possible to prove that the underlying galaxies are in close physical interaction .
dual agns have been recently discovered inside the dusty , obscured environment of at least two ulirgs whose infrared emission is powered by an intense star - burst .
the most compelling is the case of ngc 6240@xmath61 , an on - going gas - rich merger between two spirals , shown in figure 2 : _ chandra _ images have revealed that presence of two bright nuclear x - ray sources whose spectral energy distribution is consistent with being two accreting massive black holes ( of @xmath62 and @xmath63@xmath64 ) , seen at a projected distance of 700 pc@xmath65 .
each nucleus is at the center of a stellar disk in rotation whose dynamics implies the presence of more than @xmath66 of stars@xmath67 .
kinematic evidence exists that the two nuclei are not physically bound yet , and that the system is caught in the immediate proximity of its first close passage .
a massive rotating disk of cold gas together with gas filaments fill the space in between the two active nuclei@xmath67 .
mrk 463 is the second case@xmath68 : this ulirg shows clear morphological signs of an interaction between two gas - rich galaxies , and two luminous obscured x - ray nuclei are observed at a projected distance of 3.8 kpc .
the interacting star - burst system arp 299 is a potential third candidate of a dual agn@xmath69 , due to the presence of a highly obscured x - ray nucleus ( in the galaxy member ngc 3690 ) and possibly of a second less luminous one ( in ic 694 ) , at a projected distance of 4.6 kpc .
dynamical mass estimates indicate that the black holes in arp 299 are nested in massive ( @xmath70 ) nuclear gaseous disks of @xmath71 pc in size .
[ fig : ngc3341 ] while the above cases refer to dual agns in galaxies of comparable mass ( i.e. major mergers ) , dual agns in minor merger are still difficult to observe . despite this , a system of two offset nuclei has been discovered in the disturbed disk galaxy ngc 3341 .
the two offset nuclei have projected distances of 5.1 and 8.4 kpc from the primary center@xmath72 .
one of the two offset nuclei ( object b ) shows a seyfert 2 spectrum , typical of an accreting black hole . this unusual system , shown in figure 3 , can be viewed as a minor merger in action with two dwarf galaxy satellites falling onto the more massive primary .
as the primary nucleus indicates a possible low - level of agn activity typical of a liner , ngc 3341 may be the first candidate dual agn system in a composite , triple minor merger .
the existence of binary agns is still debatable at observational level , and four cases deserve attention .
the first refers to the elliptical galaxy 0402 + 379@xmath73 .
vlbi ( high spatial resolution ) observations have offered the view of two compact flat - spectrum radio sources c1 and c2 at a projected separation of only 7 pc@xmath74 .
two jets depart from c1 , while c2 ( initially interpreted as a bright knot along one jet ) shows signs of variability that are a distinguishing feature of an active black hole .
thus , two massive black holes are powering the radio - emission , and are likely to form a real _ binary _ in a passively evolving elliptical .
the second is the case of oj 287 , a bl lac object present on photographic plates since 1891 .
its complex optical light curve shows a periodic variation of @xmath75 yr suggesting that the engine is a massive binary black hole with the smaller ( secondary ) orbiting the larger hole with an observed @xmath76 yr orbital period@xmath77 .
maximum brightness is obtained when the secondary black hole , moving on an inclined orbit , plunges into the accretion disk that surrounds the primary ; a second enhancement in brightness is detected a year later , interpreted as perturbed gas falling onto the primary . for oj 287 , the primary ( secondary ) black hole has an estimated mass of @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) implying an orbital decay timescale via emission of gravitational radiation of only @xmath80 yr . the third candidate is the quasar sdss 092712.65 + 294344@xmath81 .
no periodicities in the light curve are observed in this source , but a systematic shift of 2650 @xmath37 in its composite set of emission lines .
sdss 092712.65 + 294344 has been presented in literature as first case of recoiling black hole@xmath82 : in this interpretation , the set of very narrow emission lines at the redshift of the galaxy host result from illumination of central gas by the active black hole . moving with line - of - sight speed of 2650 @xmath37 away from the galaxy core ,
the black hole that drags its own accretion disk is responsible of the blue - shifted broad line emission resulting from gas clouds bound to the black hole itself .
this picture is challenged by the presence , in the optical spectrum , of a third set of narrow lines at the same redshift of the broad line system which do not find a clear - cut interpretation . in the recoiling hypothesis ,
tenuous gas moving with the black hole is responsible to the emission .
however , to a closer scrutiny , this quasar offers at least two alternative interpretations . sdss 092712.65 + 294344
may host a binary whereby a secondary ( lighter ) black hole , orbiting around a more massive primary , is fed by matter flowing from a circum - binary disk in close tidal contact@xmath83 . in this picture , the narrow lines that define the rest frame galaxy would still result from the central illumination offered by the binary , the broad line blue - shifted set from gas clouds bound to the orbiting secondary , and the narrow blue - shifted lines from rarefied gas around the secondary black hole that has excavated a gap in the surrounding disk ( as described in section 5.4 ) . under this hypothesis , the mass of the primary has been estimated @xmath84 , the mass ratio between the two black holes @xmath85 , and an orbital semi - major axis @xmath86 pc , corresponding to an orbital period of 340 yr and @xmath87 yr . the binary hypothesis is preferred over the recoiling hypothesis being one hundred times more probable than the ejection hypothesis@xmath88 .
furthermore , it can be directly tested by searching for systemic doppler changes in the velocity due to orbital motion@xmath89 .
a third alternative is that sdss 092712.65 + 294344 is the composite system of two active agns co - present inside two galaxies that are in the verge of colliding at high relative speed in a galaxy cluster@xmath90 .
the four and last candidate is the quasar sdss j153636.22 + 044127.0@xmath91 discovered recently in a systematic search of quasars with anomalous spectra , among 17.500 sources with redshift @xmath92 in the sdss dr7 release .
the quasar shows two clear broad line emission systems separated in velocity by 3500 @xmath37 , plus a third unresolved absorption line system at an intermediate velocity ( interpreted as emission from intervening material along the line of sight ) .
boronson & lauer@xmath91 interpreted this object as a binary system of two black holes with their own emission line system .
elliptical galaxies are believed to be the end product of multiple mergers@xmath93 , though the exact sequence of events that shape ellipticals as they appear today is still uncertain .
ellipticals show remarkable regularities in their smooth stellar light profile : their outer surface brightness @xmath94 follows a srsic profile @xmath95 over a wide mass - dynamical range .
the fit is so remarkable that departures from this regularity has been recently used as diagnostic tool for tracing back their formation history@xmath96 .
ellipticals appear to come in two distinct varieties@xmath97 : bright ( giant ) ellipticals have srsic index @xmath98 and show cores , i.e. _ missing - light _ inside a radius marking the dividing line between a flatter inner surface brightness profile and the srsic profile at outer radii ; the less bright , less massive ( normal ) ellipticals have instead @xmath99 , and show _ extra - light _ at their center relative to the inner extrapolation of the outer srsic profile . missing or extra light are features that underscore a dichotomy that involves not only the central kpc of the galaxy but many global structural and physical properties@xmath100 . core ( i.e. missing - light )
giant ellipticals are essentially non - rotating , anisotropic and modestly triaxial ; stars are very old and if gas is present , it is _ hot _ and x - ray emitting .
often giant ellipticals host strong radio sources .
by contrast , core - less ( i.e. extra - light ) ellipticals are rotationally supported and have disky - distorted isophotes
. rarely contain hot x - ray emitting gas and a radio source .
both local and global features thus appear to record memory of a different merger history .
a number of authors@xmath101 has suggested recently that missing - light ( giant ) ellipticals are shaped by ( re-)mergers of _ gas - poor _ galaxies , while extra - light ellipticals are the result of a _ gas - rich _ merger producing an extra stellar component in the central regions of the galaxy @xmath102 .
extra - light in normal ellipticals is suggestive that _ cold _ gas has played a critical role in the build up of the galaxy : gas can radiate and fall in the central regions of the merger remnant converting a sizable fraction of its mass into stars , in violation of liouville s theorem .
missing light@xmath103 instead does not find an easy explanation : collisionless mergers preserve the density profile of the progenitor galaxies and do not enhance significantly the velocity dispersion , according to liouville s theorem .
thus , the presence of missing - light requires extra physics .
core ( missing - light ) galaxies and core - less ( extra - light ) ellipticals generally host a massive black hole in their nucleus , and an interesting hypothesis has been advanced .
that in a gas - poor environment , missing - light results from a dynamical process involving a _ binary _ black hole .
a first possibility is that a stellar core forms in response to repeated three - body interactions between the binary and a star passing by@xmath104 : impinging on the binary from low angular momentum orbits stars are scattered back with very high velocities and leave the nucleus .
the binary that decays excavates with time the central region of the galaxy producing a stellar core , emptied of light .
the missing light correlates with the black hole mass closely@xmath105and with the number of successive mergers necessary to explain the stellar mass deficit@xmath106 . a second possibility that may operate in succession is core formation due to the recoiling black hole born after binary coalescence .
gravitational radiation not only carries away energy and angular momentum : depending on the black hole spin direction relative to the orbital plane , radiation transports away linear momentum , as waves are emitted anisotropically .
the relic black hole , as already mentioned in section 1.2 , receives a recoil velocity that can be as large as 4000 @xmath37 .
the instantaneous removal of the black hole via radiation recoil generally results in the rapid formation of a stellar core that expands due to the sudden change in the gravitational potential , now lacking of a massive central body , and to the subsequent deposition of kinetic energy as the black hole returns toward the center of the galaxy@xmath107 ( the effect being the largest when the hole is ejected on a return orbit with a velocity just below escape ) .
these ideas radical and ad hoc have become nowadays two mainstream possibilities .
but , how can core excavation be prevented in core - less ellipticals ?
a possibility is that gas has played a critical role not only in creating new additional light but in accelerating binary decay ( if a binary is present ) under the action of gas - dynamical torques .
the working hypothesis is that fast orbital decay controlled by gas prevents core formation ; spin - orbit alignment which is favored in a gas rich environment@xmath108 , brings the two holes in a configuration , prior to coalescence , of minimum recoil , thus preventing expansion of the stellar core at the time of formation of the new , relic hole .
> from the above considerations , black hole binaries seem to be linked in fundamental ways to the dynamics of the stellar and gas components of galaxies , and this motivates strongly the interest on binary black holes not only as sources of gravitational waves , but as key systems in the context of galaxy formation .
mergers occur mainly in two varieties : they may involve nearly equal mass galaxies , and these are referred to as _ major _ mergers , or unequal mass galaxies , i.e. _ minor _ mergers .
both may involve either gas - rich or gas - poor galaxies so that black hole dynamics has no unique outcome but differs in relation to the merger type and environment .
exploring these diversities in a self - consistent cosmological scenario is currently a challenge , and thanks to recent advances in numerical simulations , it is now possible to address a number of compelling issues .
galaxy mergers cover cosmological volumes ( @xmath109 kpc aside ) , whereas black hole coalescences probe exceedingly small volumes from @xmath110 pc down to @xmath111 pc and to the horizon scale ( @xmath112 pc , for @xmath113 ) .
thus , tracing the black hole inspiral in a merger requires simulations with gravitational / hydrodynamical force resolution covering more than ten orders of magnitude in length , and a variety of different physical processes , often not scale free . following a merger , how can black holes reach the gravitational wave inspiral regime ?
the overall scenario has first been outlined in a seminal study by begelman , blandford & rees @xmath114 , in the context of stellar systems .
four main phases characterize the dynamical evolution of the black holes : ( i ) the pairing phase p in which dynamical friction against the stellar / dark matter background is acting on each black hole causing their sinking ; ( ii ) phase b when the holes dynamically couple to form a _ binary _ and continue to sink due to the large scale drag of dynamical friction ; ( iii ) phase h in which the binary hardens via 3-body scatterings off single stars ;
( iv ) phase gw , the last , when gravitational wave back - reaction becomes important to drive the inspiral down to coalescence .
early studies explored the phase of pairing p , simulating the collisionless merger of spherical halos @xmath115 .
governato , colpi & maraschi@xmath116 in particular first noticed that when two equal mass halos merge , the twin black holes nested inside the more massive nuclei are dragged rapidly toward the center of the remnant and form a close pair .
the drag , initially , is not acting on the individual holes but on the massive stellar - cusp in which they are hosted .
only when the merger is in its advanced stage , the black holes behave as independent point masses and continue to lose orbital angular momentum under the action of dynamical friction .
they further noticed that the situation reverses in unequal mass ( minor ) mergers , where the less massive halo , tidally disrupted along the course of the encounter , leaves its _ naked _ black hole wandering in the outskirts of the main halo .
thus , depending on the halo mass ratio and internal structure of the interacting galaxies , the transition from phase p @xmath117 b can be at some point prematurely aborted or severely delayed .
similarly , the transit from phase b @xmath117 h @xmath117 gw is not always secured even in major mergers ( where also the black holes are expected to have comparable masses ) , as the stellar content in the immediate vicinity of the black holes may not suffice to harden the binary down to a separation where gravitational wave driven inspiral sets in@xmath118 .
all these issues will be discussed critically below .
n - body and monte carlo merger trees simulations@xmath119 describing the assembly of galaxies show that unequal mass mergers are common along cosmic history . as black hole masses , in the local universe ,
correlate tightly with the mass of the host@xmath120 ( @xmath121 ) , this implies a black hole mass spectrum ranging from @xmath122 up to @xmath66 and mass ratios @xmath123 in literature , these intervals have not been explored systematically and main emphasis has been given to equal - mass mergers , given the heavy computational demand , and the impossibility , in gas - rich mergers , of using self - similar solutions , owing to the presence of dissipative components .
while black hole masses in the interval @xmath124 are of interest for _ lisa _ astrophysics , black holes with @xmath125 are of key importance for the pulsar timing array experiment ( pta ) , due to their different frequency of operation . while the `` light '' _ lisa _ black holes carry information on how / where they formed along the course of galaxy assembly @xmath126(up to @xmath5 ) , the `` heavy '' pta black holes@xmath127 trace mergers among very massive galaxies present in the already evolved universe , at redshift @xmath128 .
dynamical friction is the main cause of braking of the black hole orbits during the process of pairing , and acts individually on each hole .
this drag arises in response to the gravitational perturbation excited by the black hole on the background of dark matter and/or stars . in the original formulation of chandrasekhar@xmath129 ,
the drag is the collective result of momentum exchange between the massive perturber @xmath21 ( the black hole in our case ) and every single particle of the background . in a collisionless system of uniform mass density @xmath130 and isotropic velocity distribution , the force on @xmath21 ,
acting against its velocity vector @xmath131 is @xmath132 { { \bf v}\over v^3}.\ ] ] the gravitational drag that involves only those particles moving more slowly than @xmath133 ( the term in squared brackets ) , is maximum when the velocity @xmath133 of the perturber nears the 1d velocity dispersion @xmath134 , as the force declines linearly with @xmath133 , and as @xmath135 , in the low ( @xmath136 ) and high ( @xmath137 ) speed limit , respectively .
the coulomb logarithm @xmath138 in equation ( 5 ) expresses the non - locality of the drag as it comprises the whole range of impact parameters relevant for the exchange of momentum in the interaction of the stars with @xmath139 since gravity is a long - range force , @xmath140 is close to the size @xmath141 of the collissionless background , while @xmath142 is the impact parameter for a large - scattering angle gravitational interaction .
dynamical friction expresses the tendency of gravitating systems to reach energy equipartition , so that any excess of kinetic energy ( that carried by the hole ) is distributed among all particles .
restricted to a static , infinite , isotropic and homogeneous collisionless medium , chandrasekhar s formula assumes that the stars / dark - matter particles move along unperturbed trajectories that are straight lines , thus neglecting the self - gravity present in real backgrounds . despite this limitation
, the formula has been often used to estimate sinking times also in inhomogeneous self - gravitating backgrounds evaluating @xmath130 and @xmath134 at the current , i.e. local position of the perturber , treating @xmath143 as adjustable parameter .
many approaches has been developed to overcome the limits of the local approximation , including the theory of linear response tlr@xmath144 . in tlr
, dynamical friction is viewed as a direct manifestation of the fluctuation - dissipation theorem@xmath145 . in this interpretation ,
the fluctuations of the two - body force between the massive perturber @xmath21 and any particle @xmath146 add collectively to give a non - vanishing drag . in a medium characterized by a distribution function @xmath147
, the components of the force can be expressed as the sum over time and phase - space ( * r*,*p * ) @xmath148 of a suitable self - correlation tensor @xmath149 correlating the two - body gravitational force between the black hole ( in @xmath150 ) and any individual star ( in @xmath151 ) at time @xmath152 with that at the earlier time @xmath153 .
this formula captures the complexity of the physics leading to the orbital decay of a mass @xmath21 in a generic self - gravitating background .
the drag force at time @xmath152 keeps _ memory _ of the previous history of the composite system , as its strength depends on the dynamics of the perturber and of the particles at earlier times as determined by the unperturbed hamiltonian . applied to selected spherical environments@xmath154
, tlr has been powerful to prove that the stellar response embodied in @xmath155 remains correlated with the perturbation for a time shorter than the typical orbital time of stars and that the force arises preferentially from those stars closer to the perturber , due to the inhomogeneity of the background ( distant lower density regions contribute less to the drag ) .
tested against high resolution numerical simulations@xmath154 , tlr has been useful also in showing that in the interplay between loss of energy and angular momentum , eccentric orbits do not circularize under the action of the drag force , but remain eccentric along the course of the decay implying shorter sinking times . in a singular isothermal sphere with 1d velocity dispersion @xmath134 and density profile @xmath156,$ ] tlr
predicts a sinking time , expressed in terms of the circularity @xmath157 ( defined as the ratio between the angular momentum of the current orbit relative to that of a circular orbit of equal energy ) @xmath158 where @xmath159 and @xmath17 are the initial radius and velocity of the circular orbit with the same energy of the actual orbit , and @xmath160 is the mass of the dark matter and stars within @xmath161 equation ( 8) indicates that a massive black hole can sink at the center of the sphere within a time @xmath162 yr , if released during the merger at a distance of @xmath48 pc : @xmath163}\right ) \left ( { r_{\rm cir}\over 300 { \rm pc}}\right ) ^2 \left({v_{\rm cir}\over \sqrt{2 } \times 100 \,\kms}\right ) \left({10 ^ 6\,\msun\over m_\bh}\right)\epsilon^{0.4}\,\rm yr.\ ] ] dynamical friction acts also in collisional fluids and arises again from the gravitational pull between the perturber and its density wake excited in the ambient medium . in the steady - state limit and for _ supersonic _ motion , the drag on a massive perturber moving with velocity @xmath131 across a homogeneous fluid with density @xmath164 and sound speed @xmath165 reads @xmath166 g^2\,m_\bh^2\rho_{\rm gas } { { \bf v}\over v^3 } , \,\,\,\,\,\,\,{\rm for}\,\,\,\,\,\,\,{\cal m}>1\ ] ] where @xmath167 is the mach number .
the deceleration results , in this regime , by the enhanced density wake that lags behind the perturber and that is confined in the narrow cone , the mach cone , whose surfaces of constant density are hyperboloids@xmath168 .
the main result is that the gaseous drag is enhanced for supersonic motion ( with @xmath169 ) compared to chandrasekhar s formula ( for @xmath170 ) by a factor @xmath171 hinting for shorter timescales when dynamical friction occurs in gaseous backgrounds@xmath168 .
a black hole can also accrete while sinking and a drag , comparable in strength to the large - scale force @xmath172 arises due to accretion : @xmath173 where @xmath174 is the bondi - hoyle - littleton accretion rate so that @xmath175 ( with @xmath176 ) , valid for any @xmath177 the _ subsonic _ case is instead more elusive , because sound waves can propagate both down - wind and up - wind so that the drag , in this low speed limit , can be much weaker than in the collisionless case .
the drag is exactly zero in a homogeneous infinite medium due to the front - back symmetry of the perturbed density distribution present in any stationary solution .
however this result does not rigorously hold if one performs a finite time analysis@xmath168 .
if the perturber triggers the disturbance at time @xmath178 and moves subsonically along a straight line , the symmetry is broken as long as @xmath179 is smaller than the size of the medium , resulting in a finite drag @xmath180 for @xmath181 equations ( 5 - 11 ) set the guidelines for our understanding of dynamical friction . as the drag @xmath182 is proportional either to @xmath130 or @xmath183 black holes find their preferred way toward coalescence in backgrounds as those created in dissipative mergers .
gas can play an important role there : subject to instabilities and shocks , it can cool and control preferentially the inspiral creating conditions were @xmath184 .
@xmath182 is also a sensitive function of @xmath185 or @xmath167 and is large when @xmath185 and/or @xmath186 .
nevertheless , this basic formulation can not capture important details of the process . in a real merger : @xmath187 the underlying gravitational field is fluctuating violently ; @xmath187 prior to the encounter , the black holes are often inside massive power - law stellar cusps and thus have effective mass @xmath188 larger than their own mass : @xmath187 tides strip stars in the cusp and @xmath188 changes long the course of the merger , as @xmath189 ; @xmath187 stars and gas are co - present , but often have different geometries and so , they respond differently to the perturbation induced by the black hole : in rotating backgrounds the gravitational pull of @xmath21 creates spiral patterns that can not simply be described by a back - stream density wake ; @xmath187 the density wakes excited by the two black holes may start to self - interact and overlap as the hole s separation decreases .
@xmath187 when the process of pairing under dynamical friction is sufficiently advanced , the black holes form a binary , and at this stage the interaction changes character . in presence of a collisionless ( stellar ) background , it is the interaction of individual stars that drives binary evolution , while in a collisional fluid , gravitational and viscous torques play a key role .
@xmath187 the black holes may start to inject energy and momentum in the medium modifying the underlying density , and in turn the back - reaction force on their orbit .
if , in the simplest approximation , the collisionless background is described as a singular isothermal sphere , two black holes form a binary when their separation @xmath41 falls below the distance @xmath190 at which the mass in stars / dark matter enclosed within their relative orbit is equal to the total mass @xmath14 of the binary : @xmath191 at @xmath192 , the hole s relative circular velocity equals the circular velocity of the stars , @xmath193 dynamical friction continues to drive the inspiral , but as soon as @xmath17 increases above @xmath194 the interaction between the binary and the stars from collective becomes individual , and the drag no longer shows the clear dependence on @xmath14 . _ scattering off the binary _ by _ single stars _ becomes the main process for extracting binding energy and angular momentum from the orbit .
when a star is impinging on the binary , it is shot out at an average velocity comparable to the binary s orbital velocity @xmath17 ( eq .
if @xmath17 exceeds the 3d velocity dispersion @xmath195 , stars are ejected away from the galaxy nuclues with very high speeds , and this occurs as soon as the binary reaches the hardening radius@xmath196 , defined as the binary separation at which the binding energy per unit mass exceeds @xmath197 : @xmath198 below @xmath199 stars leave the galaxy s core carrying away a tiny fraction of the binary energy , approximately @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the reduced mass of the binary@xmath196 .
this corresponds to an increase of the binary s binding energy @xmath202 and thus a decrease in the semi - major axis per scattering of the order of @xmath203 according to this loss , the binary continues to harden transiting from b @xmath117 h , and from h @xmath117 gw , and to accomplish this , it needs to eject a mass in stars @xmath204 for a typical galaxy s nucleus@xmath205 . whether the binary will eject this mass , and complete the inspiral down to the gravitational wave domain
will be discussed in section 3 .
if the black holes move inside the gaseous background of a nuclear disk that forms in a merger , we can introduce the scale below which they bind @xmath206 to this purpose , we consider as reference model a mestel disk , i.e. a rotationally supported , self - gravitating disk characterized by a surface mass density profile @xmath207 where @xmath208 is the projected radial distance and @xmath209 the density at the scale radius @xmath210 the disk , in differential rotation @xmath211 with constant @xmath212 , has a total mass @xmath213 .
the black holes form a binary whenever the disk mass enclosed within @xmath41 equals @xmath14 : @xmath214 in a fluid , the binary does not interact with an isolated parcel of gas since any perturbation is transmitted to the fluid either via shocks or through acoustic waves . thus
, below @xmath215 the interaction remains collective .
in the transit from b @xmath117 h @xmath117 gw , the binary continues to exchange angular momentum with the gas and to deposit energy that can be radiated away , in a manner that will be described in section 5 .
a key radius that can be introduced to describe the coupling of the black hole with its environment , is the gravitational influence or bondi - hoyle - littleton radius @xmath216 ( where @xmath217 is the velocity of the black hole relative to the medium ) that indicates the size of the region of dynamical influence of each black hole on fluid particles .
thus , as soon as the binary separation drops below @xmath218 , the gravitational field of both holes is expected to affect the geometry , dynamics and thermal state of the gas , and key physical processes for black hole inspiral will be described in section 5 . [
fig : merritt ] figure 4 shows the result of a study by milosavljevic & merritt@xmath219 who simulated the idealized merger of two identical spherical galaxies with twin black holes , combining the tree code gadget@xmath220 , used as integrator to trace the early stages of the merger when the black holes are subject to dynamical friction in the pure stellar background , to the code nbody6++@xmath221 , a direct - summation n - body code that follows the dynamics of the black holes scattering off individual stars , in the advanced stages of the merger .
[ fig : escala ] as illustrated in figure 4 ( upper panel , first row ) the black holes initially remain closely associated with their stellar cusp . in this phase black hole pairing
is controlled by dynamical friction which is acting not only on the individual black holes but on the black hole+star s cusp system .
as time proceeds , the two cusps merge into a regenerated cusp with density comparable to the initial , and the black holes form a binary ( second row ) . in the last two rows ,
the interaction of the binary with the stars is no longer collective and is followed with the direct - summation n - body code .
dynamical friction plays no role , and three - body scattering becomes the main process of binary hardening that continues at a different peace .
meantime , stars are ejected and core scouring starts .
this is illustrated again in figure 4 ( last two rows ) where the density of the newly - formed cusp continues to drop as the black hole binary transfers energy to the stars .
the code nbody6++ can not follow however the _ long - term _ evolution of the binary as a variety of spurious collisional effects , associated to the small number of particles @xmath222 used , leads to an unphysical , rapid decay of the binary .
because of the numerical discreteness effects associated with approximating a galaxy nucleus with @xmath223 stars by a model consisting at best of @xmath224 particles , direct n - body simulations appear to be limited to the early stages of phase h. for this reason the subsequent evolution will be described in section 3 .
as far as gas - drag is concerned , figure 5 shows a case - study by escala et al.@xmath225 who simulated using gadget in its sph implementation , the sinking of two black holes in a spherical isothermal gas cloud .
the black holes , initially unbound , excite two prominent density wakes along their mildly transonic orbit and sink toward the center where they form a binary .
when the large - scale drag by gas - dynamical friction is no longer effective since @xmath41 has decayed below @xmath226 the system develops an ellipsoidal deformation resulting from the superposition of the heads of the wakes .
the asymmetry present in the wakes combines to make the ellipsoidal gaseous envelope misaligned with the binary axis , and this is the cause of further decay .
there are , at present , no simulations of _ gas - free _ mergers between galaxies with composite structure ( i.e. with a dark matter halo , a stellar disk , a bulge and a central black hole ) that follow in realism the dynamics of the black holes during phase p @xmath227 b. most of the studies start already with a close black hole pair moving inside the gravitational potential of a stellar equilibrium model , and follow in great detail the phase of binary hardening by three - body interactions ( phase h ) , using direct summation codes . these studies have revealed that the rate at which the binary hardens depends sensitively on the properties of the underlying gravitational potential and on the degree of two - body relaxation present in the galaxy s model@xmath228 . as the fractional energy exchange per scattering , in three - body encounters , is @xmath229 the rate at which the binary decays is @xmath230 , assuming a constant flux of stars ( @xmath231 ) and a binary cross section @xmath232 corrected for gravitational focusing .
this defines a hardening timescale @xmath196 @xmath233 which expresses the time it takes the binary to reach the separation @xmath41 , from large initial distances , inside a fixed stellar homogeneous background . in galactic nuclei
, @xmath234 determines the initial rate at which the binary hardens .
only stars on near radial orbits with specific angular momentum @xmath235 less than @xmath236 experience the field of the individual binary components : this condition defines a selected domain in phase - space , called _ loss cone_. as the stellar mass contained in the loss cone of a typical galaxy is less than @xmath237 , the black hole orbit decays at a much lower rate once the loss cone is emptied@xmath238 .
whether the black holes can continue to exchange energy and momentum with stars then depends on the efficiency with which stars are re - supplied to the loss cone .
the depletion of the orbital population inside the loss cone may thus lead to a _ stalling _ in the decay rate .
[ fig : berczik ] stars are expected to diffuse across the loss cone boundary through stellar two - body relaxation processes .
a small angular momentum perturbation , excited by a star passing by or by the fluctuating component of the gravitational potential , can deflect a star with @xmath239 into the loss cone @xmath240 , and this occurs on the two - body relaxation time @xmath241 ( where @xmath242 is the crossing through the galaxy of a typical star ) . since @xmath243 is often longer than the lifetime of the galaxy s nucleus , stellar dynamical processes are unable to conduct the binary to coalescence , and this theoretical difficulty has been called the _ final parsec problem_@xmath205 .
this problem has been investigated in depth@xmath244 , and the picture that is emerging goes in the direction of reducing the bridge separating phase h to phase gw , because of the presence of additional mechanisms@xmath238 . in the collisionless background of a massive elliptical where two - body relaxation is unimportant , binary evolution can continue if stars ejected by the black holes remain , after the encounter , inside the loss cone : moving on returning orbits , these stars interact again with the binary for a few times before they are lost@xmath238 , alleviating the demand on @xmath237 . if re - ejection happens to be only marginally important , most relevant is the geometry of the galactic potential .
in triaxial nuclei where angular momentum is not a conserved quantity , there exists a potentially larger population of orbits that can encounter the black hole binary@xmath245 .
the non - axisymmetric / rotating case in particular allows for the growth of stellar bars@xmath246 .
torques from bar - like potentials then create a population of centro - philic orbits that pass near the center of the galaxy once per crossing time , and that promptly interact with the binary .
figure 6 shows , via a sequence of snapshots , how black holes sink inward along the bar , inside an unstable strongly rotating stellar spheroids@xmath246 .
a further mechanism for refilling the loss cone is dynamical relaxation induced by a population of massive perturbers , such as giant molecular clouds or star clusters , that scatter efficiently field stars across the loss cone boundary , leading to rapid coalescence of the binary@xmath247 . in galaxies where none of these mechanisms is present and the binary stalls , infall of a `` third '' massive black hole , during a repeated merger ,
can accelerate the decay@xmath248 .
a hierarchical triplet may form , with the third black hole strongly perturbing the hard inner binary through the exchange of energy and angular momentum as in a three - body encounter . if the orbit of the third black hole is inclined relative to the orbital plane of the inner binary , a kozai resonance lead the eccentricity of the inner binary to such an high value that the two black holes coalesce promptly@xmath249 . in the dense nuclei of the less massive ellipticals ,
two - body relaxation may lead to the repopulation of the loss cone .
stars diffuse across the loss cone boundary so that the binary decays on a time @xmath250 .
this regime is opposite to the collisionless case , and often ellipticals fall in between , having relaxation times comparable to their age . in this case ,
gravitational encounters contribute to the refilling of the loss cone but the phase - space distribution does not reach steady state .
steep angular momentum gradients at the loss cone boundary are produced after the sudden draining of stars , following the formation of the hard binary . since the collisional transport rate in phase - space is proportional to these gradients ,
steep gradients imply an increased flux of stars .
this transitory enhancement becomes even most important when the galaxy s nucleus experience repeated mergers or infall . in this case the loss cone returns to an unrelaxed , non - equilibrium state with a large angular momentum gradient@xmath238 .
> from the above considerations , refilling of the loss cone either through non - equilibrium relaxation or dynamical relaxation implies a depletion of stars _ outside _ the loss cone .
this process destroys the nuclear stellar cusp producing `` missing light '' .
this is at the hart of core scouring by the black hole binary .
since @xmath237 gives the stellar mass removed by the binary , and since @xmath237 correlates with the binary mass , theory of binary decays finds its most outstanding test in bright ellipticals built from repeated mergers ( as mass depletion requires at least @xmath251 with @xmath252 mergers ) where black hole dynamics is dominated by the stellar component of the interacting systems@xmath253 real binaries likely evolve through a combination of different mechanisms where gas plays also a role .
there is a close parallelism between the final parsec problem and the problem of quasar fueling : both requires that a mass in gas and/or star comparable to @xmath14 or even larger be supplied to the _ inner parsec _ of the galaxy host within a timescale @xmath254 yr , much shorter than the age of the universe .
observations of powerful agns and quasars indicates that nature accomplishes this probably through inflows triggered by torques from stellar bars@xmath255 and/or unstable , massive gas disks@xmath256 .
there is the suspicion that the same inflow of gas that can contribute to the fueling could contribute to the orbital decay of the black hole binary in a number of ways : through viscous torques in self - regulated accretion disks that extract angular momentum from the orbit or through renewed star formation .
the study of black hole dynamics from the state of pairing p down to the gw domain in _ gas - rich mergers _ is a field in rapid progress .
the heavy computational demand and the rich physics involved require to proceed through well defined steps and simplifications in order to have full control of the basic physics and a strategy to attack the complexity which is present when treating with star formation and gas - dynamics .
the importance of black hole binary evolution in gaseous background is not only limited to their dynamics .
it also involves the physics of accretion that determines the black hole mass growth and spin evolution , and the interaction of the black holes with the environment through their energy and momentum deposition in the interstellar medium@xmath257 .
these processes are inter - related and touch many aspect of galaxy and agn evolution . in describing the first key results
, it will become clear that the body of data from simulations is still inhomogeneous , and many question remain unanswered . while black hole dynamics in collisionless systems has been explored mainly in the hardening phase h where the numerical challenge is the highest , black hole dynamics in dissipative / collisional systems has been mainly studied from the onset of pairing , in gas - rich galaxies simulated with some realism , down to the onset of the hardening phase h that occurs , when / if present , inside a massive nuclear disk , immersed in a massive bulge .
trial runs with galaxies either gas - free or with a hot - virialized gas component , have been carried out to test the sensitive dependence of black hole pairing@xmath258 on the background models .
these trials reveal that we are still far from having a unified view of the fate of black holes , and in the incoming paragraphs we will summarize key findings and open problems .
galaxies , as observed in our low - redshift universe , are multi - component systems of collisionless dark matter and stars that coexist in equilibrium with either a hot or cold multi - phase gaseous component : a central massive black hole is also part of this landscape . simulating a collision between two galaxies thus requires the versatile tool of hydrodynamical simulations .
the merger of two spiral galaxies similar to the milky way represents the prototype of a galaxy collision , and it has been studied in the literature typically with force resolution of @xmath259 pc@xmath260 .
the merger of two spirals with black holes complements these studies , representing a real numerical challenge as in the simulation there is the need to reach / maintain a force resolution on a scale as small as @xmath261 pc in order to accurately trace the hole s dynamics down to @xmath262 .
this is the `` minimal '' request that can be attained with gradual resizing of the computational volume via splitting techniques .
figure 7 shows the outcome of a merger , selected among a suite of simulations with different encounter geometries and disk orientations by mayer et al.@xmath263 . here , twin milky way like galaxies approach each other on a parabolic prograde coplanar orbit with pericentric distance equal to @xmath264 of the galaxy s virial radius , typical of cosmological mergers .
each galaxy model comprises a central black hole of @xmath265 lying on the observed @xmath21 versus @xmath134 relation , a stellar bulge ( modeled as an hernquist sphere of mass @xmath266 ) , an exponential disk of stars and gas ( with total mass @xmath267 and gas fraction @xmath268 ) , and a massive ( @xmath269 ) extended dark matter halo with nfw density profile@xmath270 .
simulations are performed using the n - body / sph code gasoline@xmath271 .
gas thermo - dynamics includes a recipe of star formation and radiative cooling down to a relatively high floor temperature of 20,000 k to account for turbulent heating , non - thermal pressure forces and the presence of a warm interstellar medium .
the galaxies first experience a few close fly - by ( upper six panels of figure 7 ) during which tidal forces start to tear the galactic disks apart , generating tidal tails and plumes .
the steep potentials at the center of both galaxies allow the survival of their baryonic cusps that sink under the action of dynamical friction against the dark matter background , dragging together the two black holes . during the last close passage , prior merger , strong spiral patterns appear in both the stellar and gaseous disks : non axisymmetric torques redistribute angular momentum so that as much as 60@xmath272 of the gas originally present in each disk of the parent galaxy is funneled inside the inner few hundred parsecs of the individual galaxy cores .
this is illustrated in the middle panel of the last row .
the black holes , still in the pairing phase p , are found to be surrounded by a rotating stellar and gaseous disk of mass @xmath273 and size of a few hundred parsecs .
the two black holes with their own disks are just 6 kpc far apart and accretion ( not resolved on this scale ) is expected to light up the two black holes as in the case of ngc 6240 . in the meantime a star - burst of 30 @xmath274 yr@xmath275 has invested the central region of the on - going merger .
it is worth noting that already at this stage the dissipative role of gas changes the black hole environment . while in the collisionless case ( as depicted in figure 4 ) the black holes pair inside their stellar cusps that preserve their density , in the dissipative case they pair inside a denser background resulting from gas - dynamical instabilities that have funneled additional mass in the hole s surroundings .
[ fig : ngc3341 ] at this stage of the simulation , a computational volume of 30 kpc in size is refined in order to achieve a force resolution of @xmath276 pc and continue the study of the black hole s dynamics .
the fine - grained region selected is large enough to guarantee that stars and dark matter particles essentially provide a smooth background , while the computation focuses on the gas component which dominates by mass in the region .
the short dynamical timescale involved in this phase ( @xmath277 myr ) compared to the star - burst duration ( @xmath48 myr ) suggests to model the thermodynamics and radiation physics simply via an effective equation of state .
calculations that include radiative transfer show that the thermodynamic state of a metal rich gas heated by a star - burst , comprising stellar feed - back , can be approximated by an equation of state of the form @xmath278 with @xmath279 where the specific internal energy @xmath280 evolves with time as a result of @xmath281 work and shock heating@xmath282 . with time , the two baryonic disks eventually merge in _ a single massive self - gravitating , rotationally supported nuclear disc _ of @xmath109 pc in size , now weighing @xmath283 .
this _ grand disk _ is more massive than the sum of the two nuclear disks formed earlier because radial gas inflows occur in the last stage of the galaxy collision .
a strong spiral pattern in the disk produces remarkable radial velocities whose amplitude declines as the spiral arms weaken over time . just after the merger ,
radial motions reach amplitudes of @xmath284 , and possibly feed the black holes on flight .
the nuclear disk is surrounded by a more diffuse , rotationally - supported envelope extending out to more than a @xmath285 kpc from the center and by a background of dark matter and stars distributed in a spheroid .
this grand disk is rotationally supported ( @xmath286 km s@xmath275 ) and also highly turbulent , having a typical velocity @xmath287 km s@xmath275 .
multiple shocks generated as the galaxy cores merge are the main source of this turbulence .
the disk is composed by a very dense , compact region of size about 25 pc which contains half of its mass ( the mean density inside this region is @xmath288 atoms @xmath289 ) .
the outer region instead , from 25 to 75 - 80 pc , has a density 10 - 100 times lower .
the disk scale height also increases from inside out , ranging from 20 pc to nearly 40 pc .
the volume - weighted density within 100 pc is in the range @xmath290 atoms @xmath289 compatible to the observed nuclear disks@xmath291 .
this suggests that the degree of dissipation implied by the effective equation of state gives a reasonable description of reality despite the simplicity of the thermodynamical scheme adopted . after 5.12 gyr from the onset of the collision , the black holes , dragged toward the dynamical center of the merger remnant , move inside the grand disk spiraling inward under the action of gas - dynamical friction . in less than @xmath110 myr , a timescale much shorter than the duration of the star - burst , the relative black hole orbit decay from @xmath48 pc to @xmath292 pc where they form a _
binary _ , as mass of gas enclosed within their separation is less than the mass of the binary .
it is the gas that controls the orbital decay , not the stars .
the transition between state p to b is now completed as illustrated in figure 8 : a mildly eccentric binary ( @xmath293 ) has formed with orbital period of @xmath294 yr .
this short sinking timescale comes from the combination of two facts : that gas densities are higher than stellar densities in the center due to the dissipative nature of the interaction , and that the black holes move relative to the background with mildly supersonic velocities where the drag is the highest@xmath263 .
but , how sensitive are the results on the input physics ?
mayer et al.@xmath263 have decreased the degree of dissipation by increasing @xmath295 to @xmath296 , to mimic the presence of a heat source .
is is found that in this warmer environment , a turbulent , pressure supported cloud of a few hundred parsecs forms rather than a rotationally supported cold disk .
the mass of gas is lower within 100 pc relative to the @xmath279 case because of adiabatic expansion following the final shocks , at the time of merging of the two cores .
the nuclear region is still gas dominated , but the stars / gas ratio is @xmath297 in the inner @xmath298 pc .
the black holes in this hotter environment follow a `` retarded '' dynamics : the transit from p @xmath117 b is not any longer seen , over a time span of @xmath299 myr .
the black holes remain at a distance of 50 - 150 pc , as shown in figure 8 , and a bound system is expected to form , according to eq .
9 , on a time scale @xmath300 yr , under the joint control of stars and of the lower density gas .
[ fig : pairing ] the radiative injection of energy from the black holes accreting on flight might be a candidate for a heating source , and for increasing the turbulence in the gas by injecting kinetic energy@xmath301 in the surrounding medium , possibly creating outflows .
a rough estimate for the energy released in the accretion process is @xmath302 ( with @xmath303 the eddington luminosity , @xmath304 , and @xmath305 the fractional energy deposited by the accreting black hole in the surrounding gas ) .
this energy is @xmath306 , for a black hole mass of @xmath307 accreting at the eddington limit for a time @xmath308 yr , and @xmath309 .
this energy appears to be larger than the energy dissipated by the binary in its inspiral down to @xmath49 , @xmath310 .
energy released on flight by the black holes can influence the thermal state of the grand disk which is supposed to convert a sizable fraction of its gas into stars .
this environmental change is expected to affect the dynamics and the fueling of black holes ( even after black hole coalescence ) with consequences that have not been exploited yet , given the computational challenge that these processes pose .
increasing the resolution will be the next priority . at higher spatial resolutions ( @xmath311 pc ) ,
the grand disk is expected to reveal a much richer structure with spiral patterns and bars , considered as possible candidates for triggering small scale inflows around the black holes .
regions that appear featureless in low resolution runs should instead reveal the true nature of the gas .
wada & norman@xmath312 showed that when the main radiative processes and the feedback from supernovae are directly incorporated in simulations of rotating gaseous disks , a multi - phase turbulent interstellar medium arises naturally due to the interplay between gravitational / thermal instabilities and energy injection by supernovae .
the resulting structure is clumpy at all scales .
this is a clear example that there is still some _ missing _ physics that needs to be incorporated , beyond polytropes .
pairing seems inescapable in major , equal - mass mergers : the violence of the collision affecting both galaxies in a nearly symmetric fashion ( regardless the geometry of the encounter ) brings the two black holes in the central region of the remnant .
there , in presence of a cold nuclear disk , a binary forms rapidly within a myr after the merger is completed .
but , what about pairing in minor merger ?
minor , i.e. unequal - mass mergers differ profoundly from major mergers .
encounters are uneven , resembling more an `` accretion '' process than a merger as the less massive galaxy is dramatically damaged during its sinking into the primary by tidal and ram pressure forces .
simulations by boylan - kolchin@xmath313 of collisionless spherical halos shows how details on the encounter geometry , satellite - to - host mass ratio , internal structure ( dark matter plus bulge ) , and on presence ( absence ) of a central black hole in the main host affect the degree of damage of the satellite resulting in a broad variety of outcomes .
satellites on less - bound , eccentric orbits are more easily destroyed than those on more - bound or more - circular orbits as a result of an increased number of pericentric passages and greater cumulative effects of gravitational shocking and tidal stripping .
in addition , satellites with densities typical of faint elliptical galaxies are disrupted relatively easily , while denser satellites can survive much better in the tidal field of the host . also satellites merging on to a host with a central black hole are more strongly disrupted than those merging on to hosts without the black hole .
thus , it is not surprising that also black hole pairing is affected in major ways by these details .
it is clear that investigating the necessary conditions for pair formation in minor mergers with gas is of primary importance , both in a broad cosmological context , and for the impact on the _ lisa _ data stream .
callegari et al.@xmath314 find different outcomes , in their systematic study of 4:1 ( i.e. mass ratio @xmath315 ) and 10:1 ( i.e. @xmath316 ) collisionless and gas - dynamical mergers , performed with gasoline at various cosmic epochs .
specifically , the 4:1 mergers are studied in the local universe ( @xmath317 ) , while the 10:1 mergers at @xmath318 , assuming a constant @xmath319 relation in between these cosmic epochs@xmath320 , and rescaled models , replica of the milky way , for the galaxies . in
the @xmath318 runs , the black hole masses are thus @xmath321 and @xmath322 , so that their expected inspiral and coalescence signal falls nicely in the _ lisa _ sensitivity window@xmath323 . .
in the upper row , the hole s distance refers to two selected 4:1 mergers ( for galaxy models at @xmath317 ) ; the thin and thick lines correspond to simulations with no - gas ( dry ) and with gas ( @xmath324 ) , respectively . in the lower row
, the hole s distance refers to 10:1 mergers ( for galaxy models at @xmath318 ) ; the thin and thick lines correspond to simulations with no - gas ( dry ) and with gas ( @xmath325 ) , respectively .
the insets show the color - coded density maps of stars ( left ) and gas ( right ) , on a box of 4 kpc on a side .
the large dot on each curve indicates the time at which the two snapshots are recorded .
colors code the range @xmath326 m@xmath327 pc@xmath328 for stars , and @xmath329 m@xmath327 pc@xmath328 for the gas .
these snapshots are representative of the average behavior of the satellites during the first two orbits .
note the formation of a strong bar for the 4:1 minor merger , which is absent for the 10:1 case , and the truncation of the gaseous disk in the 10:1 satellite caused by ram pressure stripping.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] all collisionless cases , regardless the value of @xmath330 , do not lead to the formation of a close black hole pair : tidal shocks progressively lower the density in the satellite until it dissolves , leaving a wandering black hole in the remnant . only with the inclusion of a gaseous disk component , inclusive of radiative cooling , star formation , and supernova feedback ,
the merger changes significantly .
figure 9 depicts the star - forming gaseous component of the satellite , to show its profound structural damage ( the primary is not shown ) . for mass ratios 4:1 at @xmath317 , bar instabilities excited at pericentric passages
funnel gas ( present in a fraction @xmath331 of the total disk mass ) to the center of the satellite , steepening its potential well and allowing its survival against tidal disruption down to the center of the merger remnant . therefore in this case , the presence of a dissipative component is necessary and sufficient to pair the black holes down to the force resolution limit of @xmath332 pc scales , and to create conditions favorable to the formation of a binary . instead
, the smaller satellites ( in the 10:1 mergers at @xmath318 ) are more strongly affected by both internal star formation and the gas - dynamical interaction between their interstellar medium and that of the primary galaxy .
torques in the early stages of the merger are not acting to concentrate gas to the center , due to the absence of a stellar bar and the stabilizing effect of turbulence . as a result
, ram pressure strips all of the interstellar medium of the satellite .
still , gas - rich satellites ( with @xmath325 ) undergo a central burst of star formation during the first orbits which increases their central stellar density , thus allowing their survival and ensuring the pairing of the two black holes via dynamical friction in a few @xmath333 yr after the disruption of the satellite .
by contrast , in a satellite with lower gas content ( @xmath324 ) star formation is not effective in enhancing its concentration : as a consequence , even its central region is disrupted at a few hundred parsecs from the center of the primary , and the pairing between the two black holes is delayed by a few billion years .
the sensitive dependence of pairing in minor mergers suggests that there exist a _ minimum _
mass ratio for the interacting galaxies below which phase b is unattended .
these simulations@xmath314 suggest that a 10:1 merger is nearing this limit , depending sensitively on the fraction of gas present in both galaxies .
as shown in section 4.1 , major mergers between multi - component galaxies lead to the pairing of black holes inside the turbulent , gaseous disk that forms in the aftermath of the collision .
ideally , a large set of simulations should be carried on to explore how black holes transit from p@xmath117b@xmath117h , under a variety of initial conditions . to encompass the enormous computational effort , a number of authors explored ( using gadget ) black hole sinking in a two - composite system , i.e. an equilibrium circum - nuclear disk embedded in a stellar bulge@xmath334 , viewed as relics of the merger . in all these studies ,
the equilibrium disk is modeled as a self - gravitating mestel disk of size ( @xmath335 pc ) , mass ( @xmath336 ) and vertical scale height ( @xmath337 pc ) , as close as indicated by observations of massive nuclear disks in seyfert and ulirgs@xmath338 .
stars follow a plummer profile and their mass within the spherical volume of radius @xmath339 is five times the disk mass , as suggested by observations@xmath340 . in modeling the gas disk ,
thermodynamics plays a critical role . in real astrophysical disks ,
massive gas clouds coexist with warmer phases and a simple isothermal equation of state would provide an unrealistic averaged representation of the real thermodynamical state .
cold self - gravitating disk are unstable to fragmentation and find their stability as soon as stars , resulting from the collapse and/or collision of clouds , inject energy in the form of winds and supernova blast waves , feeding back energy into the disk now composed of stars and a multiphase gas . due to the complexity of implementing in a code this rich physics at the required level of accuracy ,
a simple polytropic equation of state of the form @xmath341 is introduced to capture the basic thermodynamical behavior of the gas .
@xmath342 is a free parameter corresponding to the entropy of the gas and @xmath295 , varying between @xmath343 and @xmath296 , is a parameter that can be tuned to represent either a pure adiabatic response ( @xmath344 ) or a response that mimics cooling , star formation and feedback ( @xmath279 ) as in mayer et al.@xmath263 .
escala et al.@xmath246 consider cases where @xmath342 varies to reproduce different degree of clumpiness , keeping @xmath295 fixed to 5/3 , while dotti et al.@xmath345 explore , in a complementary fashion , cases with @xmath344 and 7/5 , and fixed @xmath342 .
escala et al.@xmath346 assume equal mass black holes moving on circular orbits , varying the black hole mass to disk ratio , and the angle between the orbital plane of the pair and the circum - nuclear disk .
dotti et al.@xmath347 explore the dynamics of both equal and unequal mass black holes starting from eccentric , prograde or retrograde orbits that may arise from arbitrary encounter geometries and minor merger events .
the main results of all these works can be summarized as follows : ( i ) the black holes always reach separations of a few parsecs in @xmath348 myr , and form a keplerian binary ; ( ii ) the pairing process is faster in colder disks and for black holes orbiting in the disk plane ; ( iii ) black holes on initially eccentric prograde orbits lose memory of their initial eccentricity and form binaries consistent with @xmath349 ; ( iv ) retrograde eccentric orbits turn into prograde near - circular orbits before the black holes form a bound system ; ( v ) very massive binaries perturb the disk globally and excavate transitory gaps in the circum - binary environment . [
fig : miewakes ] in the rotating background of a mestel disk , the black holes on circular orbits excite prominent wakes both in front of and behind their path , but the wake that forms behind is the most effective in exchanging angular momentum given the rotation pattern and surface density profile of the disk@xmath350 .
this causes a net braking and the black holes end forming a binary in less than 10 myr .
braking by gas - dynamical friction depends also on the level of disk clumpiness that introduces a noise element on the black hole dynamics : clumps perturb the black hole orbits more strongly and at random phases so that their inspiral is more rapid and chaotic . in smoother background
the perturbation instead takes the form of a spiral wave .
figure 10 depicts snapshots of the face - on density distribution of the gas disk and current black hole position , obtained for four different runs with increasing @xmath342 , and computed at the same time , from escala et al .
@xmath346 . in the cold clumpy disk ,
black holes have decreased their separation by more than a factor 10 reaching , the numerical resolution length .
the sensitivity to clumpiness suggests a parallelism with stellar systems : as large clumps ( likely in the form of dense molecular clouds ) accelerate binary hardening in gaseous disks , the same holds true in stellar backgrounds where molecular clouds accelerate loss cone refilling and so black hole inspiral .
circularization in a smooth ( high @xmath342 ) rotating disk is also a clear prediction of these studies@xmath351 .
when the black holes move on eccentric orbits , circularization takes place well before the black holes form a binary and this is a feature peculiar to dynamical friction in a rotating background . on an initially eccentric orbit
, the black hole has , near periapsis , a velocity larger than the local rotational velocity , so that dynamical friction causes a reduction of its velocity : the wake of fluid particles lags behind the black hole trail .
by contrast , near apoapsis , the black hole velocity is lower than the disk rotational velocity , and in this case , the wake is dragged _ in front _ of the black hole s trail , causing a positive tangential acceleration .
the composite effect is a decrease of @xmath352 . in spherical backgrounds
, dynamical friction tends to increase / maintain the eccentricity , both in collisionless@xmath353 and in gaseous@xmath354 environments .
this is suggestive that the presence of a rotating gaseous background can be inferred from the smallness of the binary eccentricity on scales of a few parsecs .
a further recently discovered signature of a rotating background is the angular momentum flip of initially counter - rotating orbits@xmath355 .
this has been highlighted when considering the inspiral of a black hole ( called secondary ) moving in a mestel disk with @xmath279 and hosting at the center a primary black hole .
the initially negative angular momentum of the moving black hole grows very fast during the first million year .
the black hole - disk interaction brakes the hole at all orbital phases , because the hole s velocity and disk flow pattern are anti - aligned and the density wake lags alway behind the hole .
the increase of the orbital angular momentum is further facilitated by the fact that , while the orbit decays , the black hole interacts with progressively denser regions of the disk .
the orbit is nearly radial at the time the orbital angular momentum changes sign and this occurs before the secondary binds to the central black hole .
when co - rotation establishes , the orbital momentum increases under the circularizing action of dynamical friction in its co - rotating mode .
this orbital _ flip _ has been visible thanks to the high numerical resolution adopted ( 0.1 pc through the entire simulation ) that allows to trace the gas - black hole interaction with unprecedented accuracy . in conclusion ,
a further prediction of black hole inspiral in rotating disks in that gas - dynamical friction conspires to drive counter - rotating orbits in co - rotation before the time of formation of a keplerian binary .
accretion can be studied only if the resolution length - scale of the code is smaller than the bondi - hoyle - littleton radius of the moving black hole . if this resolution is achieved , as in a recent series of simulations@xmath355 , its is possible to follow the fueling of the black hole _ on flight _
, i.e along its motion , and also to include the contribution of the drag force @xmath356 due to accretion from the numerical self - consistent measure of @xmath357 while in previous studies , each black hole was treated as a collisionless particle , now the hole is a _ sinking _ particle , ready to capture gas within @xmath218 while orbiting inside the disk . in a recent study@xmath355 , accretion onto the secondary , moving black hole has been traced starting either from a prograde or a retrograde eccentric orbit relative to the disk s rotation .
it is found that as long as the orbit of the moving black hole remains eccentric , accretion occurs at a low rate , with an eddington factor @xmath358 ( defined as the mass accretion rate @xmath359 in units of the eddington rate ) close to 0.1 , due to the large relative velocity between the black hole and the fluid , and is highly variable owing to the presence of inhomogeneities in the gas in the vicinity @xmath218 . only when the orbit has circularized ( and flipped for the retrograde case ) , the moving black hole accretes at high rate with @xmath360 and in a less variable fashion .
thus , two accretion phases are present for the moving black hole : the first is the low / variable state that occurs before circularization ( and/or angular momentum flip ) and the second is the high / constant state after circularization in the co - rotating mode . by contrast
, the central black hole undergoes accretion at an almost constant rate @xmath361 , in the absence of a substantial motion .
what is the fate of gas inside the black hole sphere of influence @xmath218 ? in the simulations , it is possible to keep record of the specific energy and angular momentum of every accreted fluid particle as a function of time . as the gas density in the black hole vicinity ( near @xmath218 ) can be as high as @xmath362 @xmath289 , it is conceivable that dissipative / radiative processes operate to reduce the gas internal energy below the values adopted in the simulations . in these circumstances
, we expect that the fluid particles bound to each black hole form a geometrically thin , accretion disk in keplerian rotation .
since every gas particles is found to carry a net angular momentum in the direction parallel to that of the grand nuclear disk , the size of the coplanar accretion disk can be computed according to angular momentum conservation : @xmath363 , where @xmath364 is the vertical component of the specific angular momentum of the particles bound , relative to each hole .
after circularization , @xmath365 can be as small as @xmath366 pc for the very bound particles , strongly suggesting that both black holes are fed through a thin , cold accretion disk along the course of the inspiral@xmath351 .
viscosity ( of magneto - rotational origin ) is expected to self - regulate the transport of angular momentum in the small keplerian disks , so that gas flows onto each black hole at the rate determined by the physical conditions of the gas at the outer boundary .
[ fig : highres ] with increased _ spatial _ and _ mass _ numerical resolution , binary hardening has now being explored down to separations close to @xmath218 .
figure 11 illustrates the outcome of the high resolution simulation by dotti et al .
describing the hardening process through phases p @xmath117 b @xmath117 h , for a prograde and retrograde initially eccentric orbit .
orbital decay , guided by gas - dynamical friction , continues from the @xmath367 pc scale down to @xmath368 pc , maintaining the same derivative across this domain . when the black hole separation is @xmath369 pc the derivative steepens indicating that the nature of the black hole - disk interaction has changed .
as first indicated by escala et al.@xmath225 , torques resulting from the ellipsoidal deformation , arising from the superposition of the interacting wakes , accelerates the orbital decay . only when the black hole separation reaches the resolution limits of the gravitational and hydrodynamical forces the binary stalls , as artifact of the numerical resolution .
the rapid decay is a feature present in the @xmath279 runs , i.e. when the thermodynamical treatment allows from some degree of dissipation .
equivalent runs for @xmath344 show evidence of stalling suggesting that dissipative processes play a critical role in determining the black hole dynamics and fate below @xmath370 pc .
reaching the scale @xmath49 is still a numerical challenge because not only it requires an increasingly high resolution , but new input physics .
the physics that is described in the next section will relay on the assumption that the gaseous nuclear disk remains on all scales gaseous , i.e. immune by episodes of star formation and feed - back , and that in the near vicinity of the black hole binary the gas has cooled down to form a _
circum - binary _ disk .
the black holes them - selves carry their own small , tidally truncated accretion disks ( confined within their roche lobes ) .
these disks can be either consumed or replenished , but their presence will be ignored in the next section as they play a marginal role in the hole s dynamics . only in section 6 , these disks will be considered as they play a major role in determining the electro - magnetic signature of binary black holes during their inspiral down to coalescence , and after their merger .
consider the case of two equal - mass black holes surrounded by a circum - binary disk .
what is the physical state of this disk ? at the radii of greatest interest , typically of @xmath371 pc , the circum - binary disk is expected to be _ self - gravitating _ as it likely carries a mass @xmath372 in excess of @xmath373 : self - gravity controls the gas dynamics so that the circum - binary disk differs from a canonical , geometrically thin accretion disk@xmath374 . in this _ hybrid _ configuration ,
the rotation curve is not fully keplerian ( with @xmath375 ) , the surface mass - density @xmath376 still declines as in a mestel disk ( @xmath377 ) , and the vertical scale height , which for a keplerian disk is @xmath378 , takes instead the expression @xmath379 . the stability of self - gravitating accretion disks around _ single _
black holes has been investigated extensively in recent years@xmath380 . in these disks , large scale disturbances excited by self - gravity
can not always be stabilized nor by pressure gradients ( at short wavelengths ) nor by rotation ( at longer wavelengths ) .
when the non - linear outcome of the instability is particularly violent , fragmentation of the disk into gravitationally bound clumps occurs , turning gas into stars .
but there are regimes of interest here , where self - gravity affects the disk structure by exciting non - axisymmetric instabilities that redistribute the angular momentum across the disk without major damage . crudely , the dividing line from these two different behaviors is set by the toomre parameter @xmath381 varying with distance @xmath208 across the disk : disks are unstable to fragmentation in regions where @xmath382 those with higher sound or turbulence speeds and lower surface densities tend instead to be stable and have @xmath383 at all radii .
astrophysical disks may form initially with @xmath384 , but radiative losses are expected to cool the disks down , until eventually @xmath385 numerical simulations show that at this stage , any perturbed disk develops a gravitational instability in the form of a spiral pattern .
compression and shocks induced by the instability lead to a net energy redistribution / deposition and the disk heats up .
the instability thus self - regulates its growth in a way that the disk is kept close to marginal stability .
thus astrophysical disks are expected to evolve into a quasi - stable stationary state down to @xmath386 , and to sustain an _ accretion _
flow with outward angular momentum transport through spiral waves@xmath387 .
circum - binary disks around massive black hole binaries are poorly known theoretically .
we do not know how they are fed from the outer massive nuclear disk present on the @xmath48 pc scale , and how they evolve . when a black hole binary is at the center of a self - regulated disk , its time - varying gravitational field is expected to perturbe the disk , and in particular its inner rim .
the binary , acting as a source of angular momentum , exerts a tidal torque that inhibits the gas from drifting inside its orbit .
this creates a hollow density region , called _
gap_@xmath388 , that surrounds the binary .
further interaction between the binary and the disk depends on the way the excess of orbital angular momentum of the binary , transmitted to the disk , is redistributed through viscous torques and/or spiral patterns in the fluid , on the way the disk is fed and on its stability against fragmentation .
gap formation can be understood , in these disks , using dynamical friction as key concept .
consider , for simplicity , the only presence of an inviscid ring of gas skimming the black holes on a circular orbit at a radius @xmath208 slightly larger than the binary separation @xmath41 ( @xmath389 ) , and focus on the fate of a fluid parcel .
as the fluid parcel moves more slowly than the black holes , it is exerting a drag that tends to decelerate the black holes .
the fluid element , accelerated tangentially by the gravitational pull of the black hole closest to it , reacts drifting back with an excess of orbital angular momentum . as a result
the entre ring will eventually drift away increasing its distance from the binary : the annular region that was filling the space near @xmath41 moves away increasing the gap size . if a viscous ( continually fed ) accretion disk is present outside the binary in place of the annular ring , the response of the disk is determined by the competition between the tidal torque exerted by the binary and the pressure and/or viscous torques present inside the disk that , in opposition to the tide , tend to refill the emptied region and keep the gap closed .
a hollow , low density region ( the gap ) of size @xmath390 surrounding the binary , forms as long as @xmath391 is larger than the roche lobe radii , i.e. the radii of the two equipotential surfaces connecting the two black holes ( @xmath392 ) , and the disk scale height @xmath393 .
the gap is maintained when the gap - closing time @xmath394 , comparable in magnitude to the viscous / turbulence time at the inner edge of the disk @xmath395 ( where @xmath396 is the radial drift / turbulent velocity of the disk near @xmath41 ) is longer than the gap - opening time @xmath397 , where @xmath398 is the angular momentum that must be added to the gas to open a gap of size @xmath391 , and @xmath399 is the tidal torque by dynamical friction that can be estimated as @xmath400 ( from eq . 10 ) .
the condition @xmath401 is fulfilled in presence of a massive binary , i.e. whenever the gas mass enclosed within @xmath402 ( estimated before gap opening ) @xmath403 , as demonstrated in numerical simulations@xmath346 .
figure 12 shows the outcome of an sph simulation ( performed using gadget-2@xmath404 ) designed by cuadra et al.@xmath405 to follow the early dynamical evolution of a black hole binary inside a circum - binary ring in keplerian rotation and with initial profile @xmath406 .
the gap , already present as initial condition , is maintained for the entire duration of the simulation ( @xmath407 dynamical times @xmath408 ) as gas piles up near @xmath409 in response to the joint action of the tidal torque offered by the binary and of the torques in the fluid .
the binary soon starts to decay and to increase its eccentricity . with time however , as illustrated in figure 12 , the ring , allowed to cool on a few dynamical times , becomes unstable to non - axisymmetric perturbations that are transmitted through the entire structure .
the ring thus spreads over a larger volume . at this point
the action of viscous torques becomes progressively ineffective and the binary stalls .
whether the binary continues to decay on a much longer timescale is still matter of a debate , the process being reminiscent to that of planet _ migration _ in circum - stellar disks@xmath388 .
[ fig : cuadra ] analytical and numerical studies of black hole migration in standard keplerian accretion disks @xmath410 have indicated that migration is a slow process occurring on a timescale longer than the viscous time @xmath411 at the inner edge of the disk where the gap is located ( @xmath412 ) .
if @xmath413 is the unperturbed surface density of a reference keplerian disk at @xmath414 and @xmath415 the mass enclosed , the resulting migration time is crudely , @xmath416 cuadra et al.@xmath405 computed the migration time @xmath417 in a self - regulated ( @xmath418 ) circum - binary disk , starting from an estimate of @xmath419 based on a viscosity prescription that originates from self - gravity , and from an appropriate estimate of the cooling time and of the opacity law of the gas in the disk . since @xmath417 is found to be proportional to @xmath420 ( with @xmath421 ) , the maximum rate of orbital decay can be inferred considering the highest @xmath422 consistent with a toomre parameter @xmath418 .
( denser disks would likely fragment into stars rather than remaining gaseous and this would destroy the hydrodynamical interaction that leads to black hole binary migration . ) following cuadra et al .
, binaries with mass @xmath423 , i.e. binaries in the frequency interval of _ lisa _ operation , are found to have migration times @xmath424 yr , while heavier binaries would instead stall , and/or decay via three - body encounters off stars@xmath425 if migration , as described in@xmath426 , continues down to smallest scales , the circum - binary disk is no longer dominated by self - gravity and takes the form of a keplerian accretion disk . in this regime ,
the binary - disk interaction is better described in terms of a sequence of _ resonances_@xmath427 .
azimuthal and longitudinal modes at the outer lindblad resonance are excited that promote the orbital decay of the binary . whether black hole migration is conducive to the domain in which gravitational waves take over and guide
the inspiral is still uncertain .
should this occur , then below @xmath49 the circum - binary disk would become no longer dynamically important .
only gravitational waves are expected to influence the orbital elements : waves circularize the orbit and if @xmath428 is large at the end of black hole migration , the two black holes may coalesce with still a residual eccentricity which is imprinted in the gravitational wave pattern@xmath429 .
the presence of the circum - binary accretion disk and of circum - stellar disks around each black hole , unimportant at dynamical level during the gw phase , can play a key role in determining whether the gravitational wave signal from the binary is accompanied by a bright electromagnetic counterpart .
this will be the subject of next section .
consider a black hole binary crossing the h @xmath227 gw boundary . after a time @xmath430
it will then coalesce becoming one of the loudest sources of gravitational waves observable in the whole sky with _
lisa _ will operate as an all sky monitor , detecting at the same time galactic and cosmological sources .
given the difficulty to disentangle the different signals , and the large number of noise sources , the accuracy in determining a single source position is still matter of debate .
a distinctive electromagnetic counterpart to a _
detection of a black hole coalescence would have different payoffs , allowing to identify the galaxy host , and to observe directly the redshift of the source . as a consequence
, the simultaneous detection of a gravitational wave and an electromagnetic signal could be used to estimate fundamental cosmological parameters as coalescing binaries are standard _
detection of an electromagnetic counterpart would also improve our understanding of the accretion physics of massive black holes , by comparing directly the luminosity with the black hole s masses and spins obtained directly from the gravitational wave signal .
a large number of possible electromagnetic counterparts have been proposed in the last few years ( see , e.g. , kocsis & loeb@xmath432 and references therein ) . in this review
we will discuss only few selected candidates , in relation to the dynamical evolution of the black holes during ( the preglows ) and after ( the afterglows ) coalescence .
as already discussed , the dynamical effect of a massive black hole binary is to open a gap in its circum - binary accretion disk . as the binary semi - major axis decays due to the interaction with the disk itself
, viscous dissipation maintains the outer edges of the gap at @xmath433 . only during the last phases of binary evolution , when the semi - major axis decays due to gravitational wave emission , the outer disk and binary evolution decouples .
the distance between the black holes and the inner rim of the circum - binary disk ( still moving toward the center on the viscous timescale ) increases .
if an accretion disk is present , in addition , around the primary black hole ( of an unequal mass binary ) , the secondary creates the conditions for excavating an _ annular _ gap , i.e. a hollow region between the circum - stellar disk around the primary and the outer circum - binary disk . as a consequence ,
the gas orbiting at radii smaller than the outer edge of the inner circum - stellar disk is driven inward under the action of gravitational torques by the inspiraling secondary black hole .
armitage & natarajan@xmath434 showed that this effect amplifies the accretion rate onto the primary that can largely exceed the eddington limit just prior coalescence .
they suggested that a large fraction of the energy associated with this extreme pre coalescence accretion event is converted in thermal energy of the gas accreting onto the primary .
the increased temperature triggers large outflows of gas , with velocities comparable to the the orbital velocity of @xmath435 km s@xmath275 .
the authors suggest that such strong high velocity outflows can be viewed as clear signal of coalescing or recently coalesced black hole binaries .
armitage & natarajan@xmath434 showed that the evolution of the inner edge of the gap causes a possibly observable preglow just before coalescence . in this section
we discuss the consequences of the evolution of the outer edge of the gap , resulting in an afterglow observable years after coalescence . when the black holes reach coalescence , the circum - binary disk is free from gravitational torques and starts to spread inwards viscously refilling the gap .
milosavljevic & phinney@xmath436 estimated that the timescale before complete refilling of the gap and the turn on of observable accretion activity is @xmath437 yr .
they also constrained the luminosity and spectrum of the turning on agn associated to the binary coalescence event : @xmath438 erg s@xmath275 are emitted between 0.52 kev in the rest frame of the source and for hole s masses in the _ lisa _ band . based on models of the black hole assembly@xmath439 ,
dotti et al.@xmath440 estimated that next generation x ray missions ( such as _ xeus _ or _ constellation x _ ) will be able to detect an x ray afterglow for a large fraction of the total coalescences detectable by _ lisa _ in three years of operation ( @xmath441 9 , 21 , and 28 after 1 , 5 , and 20 yr from the gw detection , respectively ) .
black hole binaries recoil , at the time of their coalescence , due to anisotropic emission of gravitational waves .
the possibility that recoiling black holes can produce an observable electromagnetic signature of a recent coalescence , already suggested by milosavljevic & phinney@xmath436 , has been subject of a detailed discussion only recently .
lippai , frei & haiman@xmath442 simulated the response of a thin disk , initially orbiting around a @xmath443 black hole , to kicks that eject the black hole from the center .
in particular they explored the range @xmath444 , where @xmath445 is the kick velocity of the black hole recoiling either in the disk plane or perpendicular to the disk .
the perturbation in the potential well exerted by the black hole recoiling in the disk plane alters the orbits of the particles forming the disk , resulting in the formation of over - density regions distributed over a tightly wound spiral caustic , as shown in the left panel of figure 13 . the density enhancement within weeks after the ejection , can be more than 10 times larger than the unperturbed disk , and moves outward at the speed @xmath446 .
density enhancements are observed also for black holes recoiling perpendicularly to the disk plane ( see figure 13 , right panel ) , but are much weaker ( @xmath447 of the unperturbed value ) , and develops in caustic only after @xmath448 yr .
assuming that the gas forming the density enhancement is shocked heated , the authors estimated a prompt increase in the emitted luminosity up to @xmath449 , 70 days ( @xmath171 yr ) after the coalescence .
lippai et al .
found also that the converging velocity ( @xmath450 ) of the shocking regions is an increasing function of the radius , so that the spectrum of the afterglow peaks at a characteristic photon energy @xmath451 ev 50 days after coalescence , and grows up to @xmath452 ev @xmath453 yr after .
[ fig : lippai ] schnittman & krolik@xmath454 noticed that the disk considered in lippai et al.@xmath442 is optically thick , and as a consequence the radiation is absorbed and re emitted with a thermal spectrum in the infrared .
they also applied their results to cosmological models of structure formation , finding that @xmath455 of these afterglows should be detectable in the _
spitzer , xmm - newton _ , and _
chandra _ surveys . the presence of a recoiling black hole ejected from its nucleus can be observed in galaxy merger remnants up to @xmath333 yr after the binary coalescence .
different electromagnetic signatures have been proposed : the recoiling black hole can be observed as an off - center qso , if the hole itself is able to retain a punctured disk at the coalescence@xmath456 .
volonteri & madau@xmath457 studied this process in a statistical context , finding that tens of off - centered agns should be discovered by the future _ james webb space telescope ( jwst)_. episodic accretion flares can be produced from the tidal disruption of stars during the lifetime of the recoiling black hole@xmath458 .
[ fig : berni ] a recoiling massive black hole can also retain a `` hyper - compact stellar system '' ( hcss ) detectable in the optical as a luminous cluster@xmath459 .
the structural properties of hcsss are defined by the stellar distribution function of stars near the black holes prior coalescence , and by the recoil velocity of the black hole remnant@xmath460 .
the authors estimate that the size and luminosity of hcsss is similar to that of a globular cluster , but can reach values typical of ultra compact dwarf galaxies if the host galaxies are very massive and the kick velocities sufficiently small .
hcsss are distinguishable from globular clusters and dwarf galaxies because of the peculiar velocity distribution of their stars : the internal velocities in a hcss are comparable to the recoil velocity , allowing for velocity dispersions much larger than the ones observed in canonical globular clusters .
the authors use cosmological models to constrain the number of hcsss observable in the local universe , finding that up to 100 hcsss should be present in the virgo cluster , even if only a few could be bright enough to be confirmed as hcsss by spectroscopical follow - ups . a different signature of a recoiling black hole has been discussed in devecchi et al.@xmath461 . the authors perform n - body / sph simulations of black holes recoiling in massive elliptical galaxies , hosting a hot , x ray emitting , gas component . they discover that the gravitational interaction between the moving black hole and the hot medium excites a density perturbation in the gas , observable as enhancement in the x ray emission . if the black hole is moving with a subsonic speed , a nearly spherical distribution of hot particles forms around : this feature can live up to @xmath462 yr .
if the black hole is moving supersonically , it triggers an over - density in the form of a mach cone , as illustrated in figure 14 , observable for few tens of myr .
the possibility to observe these features ( the spherical or conical x ray enhancement ) depends strongly on the angular resolution of the x ray detector .
thanks to the high spatial resolution , _ chandra _ can detect recoiling black holes out to the distance of virgo .
the problem of formation and coalescence of dual black holes in merging galaxies goes back to the influential paper of begelman , blandford & rees@xmath114 .
since then , our view on the formation of cosmic structures and of their embedded black holes has improved dramatically .
we are now aware of the fact that dual , binary and recoiling quasars are exclusive signposts of the process of galaxy assembly . their search in survey covering the entire electromagnetic spectrum
has then become compelling , as compelling is a deep understanding of the dynamics of their formation , at theoretical level .
this review has touched key aspects of the long journey traveled by the black holes on their path to coalescence , highlighting its complexity .
the processes that are conducive , in merging galaxies , to black hole coalescence are heterogeneous as the physical / dynamical range that needs to be covered is enormous , going from the scale of a cosmic merger ( @xmath48 kpc ) down to the tiny volume of a galaxy s nuclear region of @xmath463 pc . only below this small scale ,
gravitational waves alone drive the black hole to coalescence . given the complexity of the problem , a step ahead has been carried out in recent years thanks to major advances in numerical simulations . despite this effort there is no simulation at present that is capable of following the pairing process in full realism , either in pure stellar / gas - poor as well as in gas - rich environments , from self - consistent cosmological conditions . in stellar backgrounds
there is still the need to explore in greater detail loss cone refilling in the time - varying non - axisymmetric gravitational potentials that form in the aftermath of a merger , and the role of instabilities and of massive perturbers created in situ . on a smaller scale ,
when few body interactions become important , there is also the need to include post - newtonian black hole dynamics , as indicated in in a recent study@xmath464 . in gas - rich backgrounds
, dissipation is known to play a key role in speeding black hole inspiral , but often the thermodynamical description of the gas has been treated in simple , idealized terms : the gas is multi - phase and star formation , together with stellar / agn feedback may play a critical role in affecting the actual dynamics of the black holes .
the inclusion of these composite effects is a must for the future , and we are working on these lines .
low mass black holes at high redshifts are likely to pair in gas - rich halos , while high mass black holes at lower redshifts likely pair in gas - poor stellar backgrounds . thus exploring the dynamics in different habitat
is of major importance . the search of dual
, binary and recoiling black holes , fed through accretion , will continue : imaging of galaxies in close interaction may unveil the presence of pairing black holes on kpc scales .
spectroscopically , the presence of large doppler displacements in the emission line systems of quasars and agns@xmath465 may reveal the presence of black holes in close orbital motion on scales close to a parsec .
a major advance will come from _ lisa _ in space and the pulsar timing array experiment on earth .
pulsar timing array will detect the emission of very massive black holes many year before coalescence ( @xmath466 yr ) , while lisa will detect the last year of inspiral and the final rapid coalescence .
thus , we have tools to trace the entire dynamical evolution of black holes using both the electromagnetic and gravitational wave windows .
we thank all the people that have had a long term collaboration with the authors and contributed to many of the results discussed in this review ; simone callegari , roberto decarli , bernadetta devecchi , fabio governato , francesco haardt , stelios kazantzidis , george lake , piero madau , lucio mayer , carmen montuori , ben moore , tom quinn , alberto sesana , joachim stadel , marta volonteri , and james wadsley .
f. pretorius , lecture note in _ physics of relativistic objects in compact binaries : from birth to coalescence _ , edited by m. colpi , p. casella , v. gorini , u. moschella and a. possenti .
, astrophysics and space science library , vol .
berlin : springer * ( 2009 ) * ( arxiv0710.1338p ) p. f. hopkins , j. t. cox , thomas , s. n. dutta , l. hernquist , j. kormendy , and t. r. lauer , apjs 181 , 135 * ( 2009 ) * p. f. hopkins , t. r. lauer , t. j. cox , l. hernquist , and j. kormendy , apj in press ( arxiv:0806.2325 ) * ( 2009 ) * m. milosavljevi , m. and d. merritt , d. apj 563 , 34 * ( 2001 ) * | _ binary _ black holes occupy a special place in our quest for understanding the evolution of galaxies along cosmic history .
if massive black holes grow at the center of ( pre-)galactic structures that experience a sequence of merger episodes , then dual black holes form as inescapable outcome of galaxy assembly , and can in principle be detected as powerful dual quasars .
but , if the black holes reach _ coalescence _ , during their inspiral inside the galaxy remnant , then they become the loudest sources of gravitational waves ever in the universe .
the _ laser interferometer space antenna _ is being developed to reveal these waves that carry information on the mass and spin of these binary black holes out to very large look - back times .
nature seems to provide a pathway for the formation of these exotic binaries , and a number of key questions need to be addressed : how do massive black holes pair in a merger ? depending on the properties of the underlying galaxies , do black holes always form a close keplerian binary ?
if a binary forms , does hardening proceed down to the domain controlled by gravitational wave back reaction ? what is the role played by gas and/or stars in braking the black holes , and on which timescale does coalescence occur
? can the black holes accrete on flight and shine during their pathway to coalescence ?
after outlining key observational facts on dual / binary black holes , we review the progress made in tracing their dynamics in the habitat of a gas - rich merger down to the smallest scales ever probed with the help of powerful numerical simulations .
n - body / hydrodynamical codes have proven to be vital tools for studying their evolution , and progress in this field is expected to grow rapidly in the effort to describe , in full realism , the physics of stars and gas around the black holes , starting from the cosmological large scale of a merger .
if detected in the new window provided by the upcoming gravitational wave experiments , binary black holes will provide a deep view into the process of hierarchical clustering which is at the heart of the current paradigm of galaxy formation .
they will also be exquisite probes for testing general relativity , as the theory of gravity .
the waveforms emitted during the inspiral , coalescence and ring - down phase carry in their shape the sign of a dynamically evolving space - time and the proof of the existence of an horizon . 3 pc^-3 -1.5truecm monica colpi@xmath0 & massimo dotti @xmath1 + 0.3truecm 1-department of physics g. occhialini , university of milano - bicocca , piazza della scienza 3 , 20126 milano , italy , [email protected] + 2-department of astronomy , university of michigan , ann arbor , mi , 48109 , usa , [email protected] + keywords : black hole physics - stellar and fluid dynamics - galaxies : evolution - galaxies : nuclei - galaxies : cosmology |
the realization of bcs bose - einstein condentate ( bec ) evolution with two - component atomic fermi gases has received tremendous attention in the last decade @xcite . in these experiments
, the tuning of attractive interactions permits the ground state of the system to evolve from a weak fermion attraction bcs limit of loosely bound and largely overlapping cooper pairs to a strong fermion attraction limit of tightly bound small bosonic molecules which undergo bec .
the main difference between the bcs - bec evolution problem and the simple bcs theory is that the cooper pairing is not allowed only for fermions with energies close to the fermi energy but is also allowed for all momenta .
all of the early theoretical works were concentrated on the balanced fermi gases , i.e. both components have the same number and mass , suggesting that the evolution is not a phase transition but a smooth crossover , and hence the name _ bcs - bec crossover_. this prediction was then found to be in very good agreement with all of the observations @xcite .
motivated by the experimental success with balanced fermi gases , many of the recent theoretical works were concentrated on imbalanced ( population , mass and/or dimension ) fermi gases , suggesting various phases and phase transitions between them .
some of these predictions were also confirmed by the following experiments @xcite , opening the door for new studies on more complicated systems with the hope of finding exotic phases of matter .
arguably , one of the very promising new systems to investigate is the spin - orbit coupled ( soc ) atomic fermi gases @xcite .
this is mainly motivated by the very recent success in realizing soc atomic bec @xcite , and by a practical proposal for generating a soc fermi gas with @xmath0k atoms @xcite .
some of the very recent results on these systems can be summarized as follows .
for the two - body problem , it has been found that a two - body bound state exists for some types of soc , e.g. rashba or dresselhaus types , even on the bcs side ( @xmath1 ) of a resonance @xcite with arbitrarily small @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the @xmath4-wave scattering length .
for the many - body problem , it has been found for balanced fermi gases that the soc increases the single - particle density of states , which in return favors the cooper pairing so significantly that increasing the soc , while @xmath3 is held fixed , eventually induces a bcs - bec evolution even for a weakly - interacting system when @xmath2 @xcite .
similar to what happens in the usual bcs - bec crossover picture of a balanced fermi gas with increasing @xmath5 , the bcs - bec evolution with increasing soc turns out to be a smooth crossover but not a phase transition .
therefore , the ground state of balanced fermi gases with or without the soc is a topologically trivial gapped superfluid .
however , the bcs - bec evolution with rashba - type soc is found to become a phase transition for population- @xcite and/or mass - imbalanced @xcite fermi gases .
it has been found that the soc counteracts the population imbalance , and that this competition tends to stabilize the uniform topologically nontrivial gapless superfluid phases against the phase separation .
in addition , topological phase transitions associated with the appearance of momentum space regions with zero quasiparticle / quasihole energies have been found , the signatures of which could be observed in the momentum distribution or the single - particle spectral function @xcite .
the anisotropic ( in momentum space ) nature of the soc is also found to stabilize exotic superfluid phases .
for instance , in sharp contrast to the no - soc case where only the gapless superfluid phase supports population imbalance , both the gapless and gapped superfluid phases are found to support population imbalance in the presence of a rashba - type soc @xcite .
similarly , again in sharp contrast to the no - soc case where only the gapped superfluid phase supports population balance , both the gapped and gapless superfluid phases are found to support population balance in mass - imbalanced soc fermi gases when the mass difference becomes large enough @xcite . in this paper ,
we extend our recent works @xcite , and study the effects of anisotropic soc on the phase diagrams of both balanced and imbalanced fermi gases throughout the entire bcs - bec evolution .
we analyze both zero and finite temperature phase diagrams , and the paper is organized as follows .
first , we review the noninteracting and interacting two - body problem in sec .
[ sec : tbp ] , and calculate the binding energy of the two - body bound - state in vacuum .
second , we study the many - body problem in sec . [
sec : mbp ] , where we derive the mean - field theory at zero temperature , and use it to analyze the ground - state phase diagrams of imbalanced fermi gases .
then , we investigate the gaussian fluctuations in sec .
[ sec : fluct ] near the critical temperature , and calculate the effective mass of the cooper pairs and their critical condensation temperature in the molecular bec limit .
last , our conclusions are briefly summarized in sec .
[ sec : conc ] .
before presenting our new results for the many - body problem , let us first introduce the model hamiltonian and review some of the recent results for the noninteracting and interacting two - body problem . for the noninteracting soc fermions , the two - body hamiltonian ( in units of @xmath6 ) can be written as @xmath7 where @xmath8 $ ] with @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) creates ( annihilates ) a spin-@xmath11 fermion with momentum @xmath12 , @xmath13 is the kinetic energy , and @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the spin - orbit fields with @xmath16 .
the eigenvalues of this hamiltonian matrix are @xmath17 where @xmath18 labels the helicity bands , and @xmath19 are the kinetic energy average and half of the kinetic energy difference of @xmath20 and @xmath21 fermions .
the corresponding eigenfunctions @xmath22 are given by @xmath23 .
$ ] throughout this paper , we mainly consider four analytically tractable spin - orbit fields : ( i ) @xmath24 and @xmath25 corresponding to an equal mixture of rashba- @xcite and dresselhaus - type @xcite soc ( erd ) , ( ii ) @xmath26 and @xmath27 corresponding to a fully aligned soc ( fa ) , ( iii ) @xmath28 and @xmath29 corresponding to a purely rashba- or dresselhaus - type soc ( prd ) , and ( iv ) @xmath30 corresponding to a fully spherical soc ( fs ) . we note that erd- and fa - type soc are essentially the same for balanced fermi gases , but these cases differ substantially for imbalanced fermi gases as we discuss below in sec .
[ sec : mbp ] . for the interacting soc fermions
, it has recently been shown that the strength of the attractive particle - particle interaction @xmath31 is related to the two - body binding energy @xmath32 in vacuum via , @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the energy threshold for the two - body bound state .
as usually done , the theoretical parameter @xmath35 can be eliminated in favor of the experimentally relevant @xmath4-wave scattering length @xmath3 via the relation , @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the volume .
[ htb ] the bound - state equation is analytically tractable for the four cases mentioned above . for the simplest erd- and fa - type soc , a two - body bound state with energy @xmath38 exists only when @xmath39 , showing that the erd- and fa - type soc do not have any observable effect on the two - body problem . on the other hand ,
in the case of prd - type soc , a two - body bound state exists even for @xmath1 @xcite , and its energy is determined by @xcite @xmath40 in the weak soc limit , when @xmath41 , this expression gives @xmath42 up to the leading order in @xmath43 , and it recovers the usual result in the @xmath44 limit . however , in the strong soc limit , when @xmath45 , eq .
( [ eqn : ebprd ] ) gives @xmath46 which is exponentially small as shown in fig .
[ fig : eb ] .
we also obtain @xmath47 at unitarity @xcite .
similarly , in the fs - type soc , an even deeper two - body bound state exists for @xmath1 , and its energy is given by @xmath48 where @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) sign is valid for @xmath1 ( @xmath39 ) .
this expression reduces to @xmath51 in the weak- and @xmath52 in the strong soc limits , and to @xmath53 at unitarity . having shown that different types of soc give rise to significant differences with regards to the existence of the two - body bound state and its binding energy , next we analyze the many - body problem where these differences also play an important role
let us first consider noninteracting ( @xmath54 or @xmath2 ) balanced ( @xmath55 or @xmath56 ) fermi gases at zero temperature .
for this purpose , and throughout this paper , we conveniently choose the energy ( length ) scale as the fermi energy @xmath57 ( fermi momentum @xmath58 ) of @xmath59 fermions such that @xmath60 .
it has been shown that increasing the soc for a noninteracting fermi gas leads to a change in the fermi surface topology , when the number of fermions in the @xmath49-helicity band ( @xmath61 ) vanishes @xcite , where @xmath62 this occurs when the chemical potential @xmath63 goes below the bottom of the energy band , i.e. when @xmath64 , or when @xmath43 increases beyond a critical value ( @xmath65 ) . in some ways , this is similar to the usual bcs - bec crossover problem , where the quasiparticle / quasihole excitation spectrum changes behavior as a function of increasing the scattering parameter @xmath66 at @xmath64 , i.e. its minimum is located at a finite ( zero ) momenta when @xmath67 ( @xmath68 ) .
for the erd- and fa - type soc , we obtain @xmath69 , and thus setting @xmath64 gives @xmath70 . for the prd - type soc
, we obtain @xmath71 for @xmath72 leading to @xmath73 in the weak soc limit when @xmath74 , and also obtain @xmath75 for @xmath76 .
thus , setting @xmath64 gives @xmath77^{1/3 } k_f / m \approx 0.75 k_f / m .
$ ] lastly , for the fs - type soc , we obtain @xmath78 leading to @xmath79^{1/3 } + ( m^6 \alpha^6 + k_f^6/2 + k_f^3\sqrt{4m^6\alpha^6 + k_f^6}/2)^{1/3}/(2 m ) .
$ ] thus , again setting @xmath64 gives @xmath80 we emphasize that the aforementioned change in fermi surface topology for the noninteracting balanced fermi gases is not a quantum phase transition but a smooth crossover @xcite .
adding the interactions does not effect this picture much @xcite , and the crossover in the fermi surface topology again occurs at @xmath64 .
however , this is no longer the case for the interacting imbalanced fermi gases @xcite , and next we show how this crossover picture becomes a quantum phase transition in the presence of a population imbalance within the self - consistent mean - field theory . in the absence of a soc and at low temperatures , it is well - established that the mean - field theory is sufficient to describe the fermi gases both in the bcs and the bec limits , and that this theory also captures qualitatively the correct physics in the entire bcs - bec evolution @xcite .
hoping that the mean - field formalism remains sufficient in the presence of a soc , here we analyze the resultant ground - state phase diagrams . for this purpose
, we use the mean - field hamiltonian @xmath81 where @xmath82 $ ] denotes the fermionic operators collectively , @xmath83 and @xmath84 is the mean - field order parameter where @xmath85 is the thermal average .
the mean - field thermodynamic potential can be written as @xcite @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the temperature , @xmath88 labels the quasiparticle / quasihole excitation energies @xmath89 , @xmath90 , $ ] and @xmath91 where @xmath92 . here , the quasiparticle / quasihole excitation energies @xmath89 are determined by the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian matrix given in eq .
( [ eqn : ham ] ) . following the usual procedure , i.e. @xmath93 for the order parameter and @xmath94 for the number equations ,
we obtain the self - consistency equations @xmath95.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these equations are the generalization of the mean - field order parameter and number equations to the case of an anisotropic soc , and they are consistent with the known results in the appropriate limits @xcite ( see sec .
[ sec : qpe ] ) . as usual , we checked the stability of the mean - field solutions for the uniform superfluid phase using the curvature criterion @xcite , which says that the curvature of @xmath96 with respect to @xmath97 , i.e. @xmath98,\end{aligned}\ ] ] needs to be positive , where @xmath99 .
$ ] when the curvature @xmath100 is negative , the uniform mean - field solution does not correspond to a minimum of @xmath96 , and a nonuniform superfluid phase , e.g. a phase separation , is favored .
it is known that the curvature criterion correctly discards the unstable solutions , but metastable solutions may still survive .
this may cause minor quantitative changes in the first order phase transition boundaries @xcite . while the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian matrix given in eq .
( [ eqn : ham ] ) do not acquire a simple analytic form for a general soc , next we discuss three limits where the quasiparticle / quasihole excitation energies simplify considerably , allowing for further analytical investigation .
first of all , for balanced ( @xmath103 ) fermi gases , we obtain @xcite @xmath104 where @xmath105 and @xmath106 , and @xmath107 , i.e. @xmath108 and @xmath109 . since all @xmath89 have no zeros and are always gapped for all parameters in @xmath110 space
, we expect the bcs - bec evolution to be a smooth crossover for balanced fermi gases even in the presence of a soc @xcite .
this is similar to what happens in the usual bcs - bec crossover picture of a fermi gas with no soc , where the quasiparticle / quasihole excitation energies are also gapped .
therefore , the ground state of balanced fermi gases with soc is a topologically trivial superfluid @xcite . in this case
, the order parameter equation reduces to @xmath111 and the number equation reduces to @xmath112 , $ ] where @xmath113 @xcite .
these equations are analytically tractable in the strong - coupling limit when @xmath68 and @xmath114 , for which they are approximately given by @xmath115 $ ] and @xmath116 , $ ] respectively , where @xmath117 is given in eq .
( [ eqn : ehel ] ) . comparing the order parameter equation with
the bound - state one immediately leads to @xmath118 for all four types of soc , but the number equation leads to @xmath119 for the erd- and fa- , @xmath119 for the prd- , and @xmath119 for the fs - type soc .
we note that @xmath97 is independent of @xmath43 only in the erd- and fa - type soc , which is consistent with the recent numerical findings @xcite .
this is not surprising since the soc term can be eliminated by a momentum shift in the @xmath120 and @xmath121 directions , respectively , in the erd- and fa - type soc , which also leads to a shift in the chemical potential @xmath122 since eq .
( [ eqn : ekbal ] ) depends only on the total magnitude of the soc , i.e. @xmath123 , the erd- , fa- , prd- and fs - type soc differ in their jacobians of the @xmath110-space integrals .
when @xmath124 and @xmath102 , i.e. the fa - type soc , we obtain @xmath125 which again can be gapless in some @xmath110 space regions .
the zeros of @xmath89 can be found by imposing the condition @xmath126 indicating that the zeros occur at real @xmath127 momenta such that @xmath128 since @xmath129 , setting @xmath130 above leads to @xmath131 provided that @xmath132 and @xmath119 this analysis shows that the conditions @xmath133 and @xmath134 determine the phase boundaries between the sf , gsf(i ) and gsf(ii ) regions ( see sec .
[ sec : phase ] ) , and that these three phases meet at a tri - critical point determined by @xmath135 . in this case , the derivatives of the quasiparticle / quasihole energies are given by @xmath136 for the order parameter , @xmath137 for the average chemical potential , and @xmath138 for the half of the chemical potential difference . here , @xmath139 .
we again note for this case that the order parameter equation reduces to @xmath140 and the number equations reduce to @xmath141 .
$ ] similar to the balanced case discussed in sec .
[ sec : bal ] , we note that fa - type soc term again can be eliminated for the population - imbalanced fermi gases , by a momentum shift in the @xmath121 direction @xcite .
this also leads to a shift in the chemical potentials , i.e. @xmath142 therefore , fa - type soc does not have any observable effect on the phase diagrams , which is in sharp contrast with the erd - type soc as discussed next . on the other hand , when @xmath143 and @xmath101 , it is straightforward to show that @xcite @xmath144 where @xmath145 note in this case that @xmath89 can be gapless at some points / lines in @xmath110 space .
the zeros of @xmath89 can be found by imposing the condition @xmath146 indicating that both @xmath147 and @xmath148 needs to be satisfied .
therefore , in the prd - type soc , the zeros occur when @xcite @xmath149 and at real @xmath150 momenta , @xmath151 provided that @xmath152 for @xmath153 , and @xmath154 for @xmath155 .
similarly , in the erd - type soc , the zeros occur when @xmath156 and at real @xmath157 momenta , @xmath158 provided with the same conditions as above .
this analysis shows for both prd- and erd - type soc that the conditions @xmath133 and @xmath159 determine the phase boundaries between the sf , gsf(i ) and gsf(ii ) regions ( see sec .
[ sec : phase ] ) , such that these three phases meet at a tri - critical point determined by @xmath160 @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : ek ] , typical excitation spectra @xmath161 of the prd - type soc are shown for the sf , gsf(i ) and gsf(ii ) phases , illustrating the @xmath110-space topology of their gapped / gapless excitations as discussed in sec .
[ sec : phase ] in great detail .
[ htb ] in this case , the derivatives of the quasiparticle / quasihole energies are given by @xmath162 for the order parameter , @xmath163 \xi_{\mathbf{k},- } / e_{\mathbf{k},\lambda } $ ] for the average chemical potential , and @xmath164 \xi_{\mathbf{k},- } / e_{\mathbf{k},\lambda } $ ] for the half of the chemical potential difference . therefore , the order parameter equation reduces to @xmath165 and the number equations reduce to @xmath166 , $ ] where @xmath113 @xcite .
[ tab : top ] .the topological classification of uniform superfluid phases are summarized , depending on the number of zero energy quasiparticle / quasihole excitation energy surfaces , rings or points in @xmath110-space . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] there are three phases in the phase diagrams @xcite . while the normal ( n ) phase is characterized by @xmath167 , the uniform superfluid and nonuniform superfluid , e.g. phase separation ( ps ) , are characterized by @xmath168 and @xmath169 , respectively , when @xmath170 .
furthermore , in addition to the topologically trivial gapped superfluid ( sf ) phase , the gapless superfluid ( gsf ) phase can also be distinguished by the momentum - space topology of its excitations .
depending on the number of zeros of @xmath89 ( zero energy regions in @xmath110 space ) , there are two topologically distinct gapless phases . for the erd - type soc , we have gsf(i ) where @xmath89 has one , and gsf(ii ) where @xmath89 has two zero energy rings in @xmath110 space .
similarly , for the prd - type soc , we have gsf(i ) where @xmath89 has two , and gsf(ii ) where @xmath89 has four zero energy points in @xmath110 space .
the topological classification of uniform superfluid phases are summarized in table i. in fig .
[ fig : ek ] , we show the excitation spectra @xmath161 of the prd - type soc for the sf phase in [ fig : ek](a ) , gsf(ii ) phase in [ fig : ek](b ) , and gsf(i ) phase in [ fig : ek](c ) , illustrating @xmath110-space topology of their gapped / gapless excitations .
these data correspond to the points indicated by the red cross marks in fig .
[ fig : ai](b ) .
[ htb ] in fig .
[ fig : alpha ] , we show the ground - state phase diagrams of ( a ) erd- and ( b ) prd - type soc fermi gases as a function of the population imbalance @xmath171 and the scattering parameter @xmath66 . here
, the dashed blue and dotted green lines correspond to @xmath159 and @xmath133 , respectively , and they mark the sf , gsf(i ) and gsf(ii ) phase boundaries .
we note that the regions bounded by the solid black lines show instability toward a non - uniform superfluid phase ( ps ) .
since our classification of distinct topological phases applies only to the uniform superfluid region , the dashed and dotted lines shown within these regions are solely for illustration purposes .
we find that while the erd - type soc does not have any observable effect on the balanced fermi gases ( see sec .
[ sec : bal ] ) , it gives rise to a phase diagram with very similar topological structure as that of the prd - type soc .
this is not very surprising since the main difference between the erd- and prd - type soc is the jacobians involved in the @xmath110-space integrals .
this must be contrasted with the fa - type soc , which does not have any observable effect on the system even in the presence of a population imbalance ( see sec . [
sec : sz ] ) , and therefore , its phase diagram is exactly the same as that of the usual population - imbalanced fermi gases without the soc .
since this problem is well - studied in the literature @xcite , we do not discuss it any further .
comparing fig .
[ fig : alpha ] with the @xmath44 limit @xcite , it is clearly seen that both the erd- and prd - type soc are counteracting the population imbalance .
on one hand , this competition always tends to stabilize the gsf phase against the ps , and therefore , at any given @xmath172 , the system eventually transitions to a stable sf or gsf by increasing @xmath43 , no matter how small @xmath66 is .
this is best seen in fig .
[ fig : ai ] , where the phase diagrams are shown as a function of @xmath172 and @xmath43 at unitarity when @xmath173 . on the other hand , we find that while both the erd- and prd - type soc stabilize the gsf phase against the n phase for low @xmath172 due to increased density of states
@xcite , they destabilize the gsf phase against the n phase for high @xmath172 .
[ htb ] in sharp contrast to the @xmath174 case where only the gapless gsf phase can support population imbalance , one of the intriguing effects of the erd- and prd - type soc is that both the gapless gsf and gapped sf phases can support population imbalance when @xmath175 .
this is possible due to the anisotropic nature of the soc fermi gases in @xmath110 space .
in fact , it has recently been shown for the mass - imbalanced fermi gases that both the gapped sf and gapless gsf phases can support population balance when @xmath175 @xcite .
this is again in sharp contrast to the @xmath174 case where only the gapped sf phase can support population balance , and it is possible solely due to the anisotropic nature of the soc fermi gases in @xmath110 space . the transition from gsf(ii ) to gsf(i ) leads to a change in topology in the lowest quasiparticle band , similar to the lifshitz transition in ordinary metals and nodal ( non-@xmath4-wave ) superfluids .
however , the topological transition discussed here is unique , because it involves an @xmath4-wave superfluid , and could be potentially observed for the first time through the measurement of the momentum distributions of @xmath20 and @xmath21 fermions @xcite .
the momentum distributions are readily available from eq .
( [ eqn : ntot ] ) , and we illustrate the typical @xmath176 distributions of the sf , gsf(i ) , and gsf(ii ) phases in fig . [
fig : nk ] .
the distributions are anisotropic in @xmath110 space , which follows from the anisotropic structure of @xmath89 . in addition , while the distributions of sf phase do not show sharp features , those of gsf(i ) and gsf(ii ) phases are exactly @xmath177 and @xmath178 for @xmath110-space regions where @xmath179 and @xmath180 .
therefore , a major redistribution occurs for the minority component ( @xmath181 ) at the topological phase transition boundaries .
for instance , at the gfs(ii ) to gsf(i ) transition boundary , the sharp peak that is present near the origin vanishes abruptly .
although this topological transition is quantum in its nature , signatures of it should still be observed at finite @xmath87 , where the observables are smeared out due to thermal effects .
while the primary signature of this topological transition is seen in the momentum distribution , single - particle spectral function @xcite as well as some thermodynamic quantities such as the atomic compressibility would also show an anomaly at the transition boundary .
[ htb ] all of these results are obtained within the self - consistent mean - field approximation , which is known to be reliable for the entire bcs - bec evolution only near @xmath176 . since the fluctuations dominate the physics at finite @xmath87 towards the molecular bec limit @xcite , to emphasize further the effects of finite @xmath87 , next we discuss the gaussian fluctuations near the critical temperature @xmath182 , i.e. the temperature at which the mean - field order parameter @xmath183 vanishes .
one way to go beyond the mean - field ( or saddle - point ) approximation and study the gaussian fluctuations is to use the imaginary - time functional integral approach @xcite .
using this approach and expanding the order parameter field around @xmath167 , one obtains the fluctuation action @xmath184 where @xmath185 is the inverse fluctuation propagator , @xmath186 is the fluctuation field , and @xmath187 is the bosonic matsubara frequency . it is a straightforward task to calculate the propagator @xmath188,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath189 and @xmath190 sums over odd and even @xmath191 values , respectively , @xmath192 is the hermitian conjugate , @xmath193 and @xmath194 are the quasiparticle / quasihole excitation energies .
the calculation of the fourth order fluctuations is lengthy and straightforward , but the results are not particularly illuminating .
next we use the fluctuation action to study the time - dependent ginzburg - landau functional near @xmath182 .
the ginzburg - landau theory is used to study the low - frequency and long - wavelength behavior of the order parameter near @xmath182 . for this purpose
, first we consider the static part of the propagator and expand @xmath195 in powers of @xmath196 , and then expand @xmath197 in powers of @xmath198 after the analytic continuation @xmath199 .
this calculation leads to the time - dependent ginzburg - landau equation in @xmath110 space @xcite , i.e. @xmath200 here , the zeroth order coefficient @xmath201 is given by @xmath202.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the condition @xmath203 is the thouless criterion , and it leads to an equation for @xmath182 .
we checked for all four types of soc that this criterion is in agreement with the order parameter equation after setting @xmath204 in the latter .
the coefficient of the time - dependent term @xmath205 \nonumber \\ & \times \left [ \frac{1}{(e_{\mathbf{k } , \lambda_o } - e_{\mathbf{k } , \lambda_e})^2 } + \frac{i \delta(e_{\mathbf{k } , \lambda_o } - e_{\mathbf{k } , \lambda_e } - \omega)}{\omega } \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] is a complex number . for balanced fermi gases
, while its imaginary part reflects the decay of cooper pairs into the two - particle continuum for @xmath67 , the imaginary part vanishes for @xmath68 and the behavior of the fluctuation field is propagating , reflecting the presence of stable bound states ( molecular bosons ) @xcite .
the second - order coefficient @xmath206 evaluated at @xmath207 is not illuminating for imbalanced fermi gases .
however , for balanced fermi gases with prd - type soc , where @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 , the coefficients are given by @xmath211 \nonumber \\ & + \frac{x_{\mathbf{k } , s}}{e_{\mathbf{k , s}}^2 } \left [ \delta_{ij } + s\frac{m\alpha}{k_\perp } \left(\delta_{ij } - \frac{k_i k_j}{k_\perp^2 } \right ) \right ] \big\rbrace \nonumber \\ & + \frac{1}{8 } \sum_{\mathbf{k},s , s ' } \frac{x_{\mathbf{k } , s } + x_{\mathbf{k } , s ' } } { e_{\mathbf{k } , s } + e_{\mathbf{k } , s ' } } \frac{s s'}{k_\perp^2 } \left ( \delta_{ij } - \frac{k_i k_j}{k_\perp^2 } \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath212 .
one needs to set the explicit @xmath43 terms and the last @xmath213 term to zero to extract @xmath214 from this expression . for balanced fermi gases with fs - type soc , where @xmath215 and @xmath210 , one simply needs to replace @xmath216 with @xmath217 to extract @xmath218 .
similarly , in the case of erd - type soc , where @xmath219 and @xmath210 , one needs to replace @xmath216 with @xmath220 to extract @xmath221 , and set the explicit @xmath43 terms and the last @xmath213 term to zero to extract @xmath222 .
finally , in the case of fa - type soc , where @xmath223 and @xmath210 , one needs to replace @xmath216 with @xmath150 to extract @xmath224 , and set the explicit @xmath43 terms and the last @xmath213 term to zero to extract @xmath225 . in general , the coefficients @xmath226 , @xmath227 and @xmath228
need to be calculated numerically together with the order parameter and number equations .
however , it can be analytically shown that their asymptotic forms recover the usual ginzburg - landau equation for bcs superfluids in weak coupling and the gross - pitaevskii equation for a weakly interacting dilute bose gas in strong coupling @xcite .
next we use the latter correspondence to extract the effective mass of the cooper pairs ( molecular bosons ) and their critical condensation temperature in the molecular bec limit . for illustration purposes , here we consider only balanced fermi gases . in the molecular bec limit , when @xmath68 and @xmath229 so that @xmath230 , we may set @xmath231 and @xmath232 . therefore , in this limit , the time - dependent coefficient simplifies to @xmath233 for all types of soc .
the second - order coefficients simplify to @xmath234 / ( 16 m e_{\mathbf{k},s}^2 ) + \sum_{\mathbf{k},s , s ' } s s'/ [ 8k_\perp^2(e_{\mathbf{k } , s } + e_{\mathbf{k } , s ' } ) ] $ ] along the @xmath235 directions and to @xmath236 along the @xmath121 direction for the prd - type soc , and similarly to @xmath237 / ( 16 m e_{\mathbf{k},s}^2 ) + \sum_{\mathbf{k},s , s ' } s s'/ [ 6k^2(e_{\mathbf{k } , s } + e_{\mathbf{k } , s ' } ) ] $ ] along all @xmath238 directions for the fs - type soc . in the case of erd- and fa - type soc
, we note that since @xmath239 for @xmath240 and @xmath241 for @xmath242 , respectively , the diagonal coefficients all become equal in the molecular limit , i.e. @xmath243 , and it is @xmath244 these @xmath110-space sums are analytically tractable for all four types of soc that we consider in this paper .
for instance , for the erd- or fa type soc , we obtain @xmath245 however , for the prd - type soc , we obtain @xmath246 $ ] for the time - dependent , and @xmath247 -\sqrt{2m}/[64\pi \sqrt{|\mu| } ] \ln[(2|\mu| - m\alpha^2)/(2|\mu| ) ] $ ] along the @xmath235 directions and @xmath248 $ ] along the @xmath121 direction for the second - order coefficients .
similarly , for the fs - type soc , we obtain @xmath249 $ ] for the time - dependent and @xmath250 -\sqrt{m}/(12\pi\sqrt{2|\mu| } ) $ ] for the second - order coefficients .
next we extract the effective gross - pitaevskii parameters using the asymptotic forms of the ginzburg - landau coefficients given above .
we recall that , since the ginzburg - landau theory derived above reduces to the gross - pitaevskii theory of a weakly - interacting molecular bose gas after the rescaling @xmath251 the effective mass of the cooper pairs ( molecular bosons ) along the @xmath252th direction is simply given by @xmath253 @xcite . in the absence of a soc , this gives @xmath254 for all @xmath238 directions .
[ htb ] using the asymptotic forms of @xmath227 and @xmath218 , and setting @xmath255 , we find that the mass of the molecular bosons is @xmath256 for the erd- and fa - type soc .
however , using the asymptotic forms of @xmath227 , @xmath257 and @xmath214 , and setting @xmath255 , we find that the mass of the molecular bosons @xmath258 is @xmath259 and @xmath260 along the @xmath121 direction for the prd - type soc .
this expression is in complete agreement with the recent findings @xcite , showing that @xmath261 decreases monotonically with increasing @xmath262 as plotted in fig .
[ fig : mb ] .
equation ( [ eqn : mbperp ] ) gives @xmath263 when @xmath264 , @xmath254 when @xmath265 , and @xmath266 at unitarity when @xmath267 . on the other hand
, we find that the mass of the molecular bosons @xmath268 is @xmath269 for the fs - type soc , which is also a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath262 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : mb ] .
equation ( [ eqn : mb ] ) gives @xmath270 when @xmath264 , @xmath254 when @xmath265 , and @xmath271 at unitarity .
having calculated the effective mass of the cooper pairs , we are ready to calculate their critical bec temperature .
the @xmath43 dependence of the cooper pair mass in the molecular bec limit has a dramatic effect on the finite @xmath87 phase diagram of the system . for atomic bose gases ,
@xmath272 is determined from the number equation , @xmath273 where @xmath274 is the number and @xmath275 is the kinetic energy of atomic bosons , with @xmath276 their effective mass along the @xmath252th direction .
this leads to @xmath277^{2/3 } $ ] in three dimensions , where @xmath278 is the density of bosons and @xmath279 is the riemann zeta function with @xmath280 . setting @xmath281 , where @xmath282 is the total density of fermions , we obtain @xmath283 in three dimensions , where @xmath284 is the fermi energy and @xmath276 is the mass of the molecular bosons along the @xmath252th direction . in the absence of a soc , this gives @xmath285 @xcite .
[ htb ] since we expect the cooper pairs to progressively become weakly - repulsive in the molecular bec limit , and using the effective mass of the cooper pairs found in sec .
[ sec : mb ] , we find @xmath286 for the erd- and fa - type soc , @xmath287 for the prd- , and @xmath288 for the fs - type soc . in fig . [
fig : tbec ] , we show @xmath272 as a function @xmath262 . while @xmath272 is independent of @xmath43 for the erd- and fa - type soc , we find that @xmath272 increases monotonically with increasing @xmath262 for the prd- and fs - type soc . for the prd - type soc
, we find @xmath289 when @xmath264 , @xmath285 when @xmath265 , and @xmath290 at unitarity @xcite . similarly , for the fs - type soc
, we find @xmath291 when @xmath264 , @xmath285 when @xmath265 , and @xmath292 at unitarity .
to conclude , we extended our recent works @xcite , and investigated the effects of an anisotropic soc on the phase diagrams of both balanced and imbalanced fermi gases throughout the entire bcs - bec evolution .
we analyzed both zero and finite temperature phase diagrams , and our main results can be summarized as follows .
in the first part , we derived the self - consistent mean - field theory at zero temperature , and used it to investigate the effects of soc on the ground - state phase diagrams .
we showed that while both the erd- and fa - type soc do not have any observable effect on the balanced fermi gases , only the fa - type soc does not have any effect on the population - imbalanced gases . on the other hand
, in the case of erd- and prd - type soc , we found that the competition between the population imbalance and the soc gives rise to very rich phase diagrams , involving normal , superfluid and phase separated regions , and quantum phase transitions between the topologically trivial gapped superfluid and the nontrivial gapless superfluid phases .
for instance , one of the intriguing effects of the soc is that , in sharp contrast to the no - soc case where only the gapless superfluid phase supports population imbalance , both the gapless and gapped superfluid phases can support population imbalance in the presence of a soc .
we also showed that the topological structure of the ground - state phase diagrams is quite robust against the effects of anisotropy , i.e. they are very similar for erd- and prd - type soc .
in the second part , we went beyond the mean - field description , and investigated the effects of gaussian fluctuations near the critical temperature .
this allowed us to derive the time - dependent ginzburg - landau theory , from which we extracted the effective mass of the cooper pairs and their critical condensation temperature @xmath272 in the molecular bec limit .
we showed that while the effective mass ( @xmath272 ) of the bosons does not depend on @xmath43 for the erd- and fa - type soc , it decreases ( increases ) monotonically as a function of increasing @xmath262 for the prd- and fs - type soc .
we found @xmath293 for the prd- and @xmath294 for the fs - type soc in the weakly - interacting @xmath2 limit , and @xmath295 for both types at unitarity when @xmath296 .
this shows that the presence of either a prd- or fs - type soc increases @xmath182 considerably especially in the bcs limit , which is in sharp contrast to erd- or fa - type soc where the soc does not have any effect on @xmath182 throughout the bcs - bec evolution .
this work is supported by the marie curie international reintegration ( grant no .
fp7-people - irg-2010 - 268239 ) , scientific and technological research council of turkey ( career grant no .
tb@xmath297tak-3501 - 110t839 ) , and the turkish academy of sciences ( tba - geb@xmath297p ) .
computing resources used in this work were provided by the istanbul technical university , informatics institute , high performance computing laboratory ( hpcl grant no .
1005201003 ) .
m. inguscio , w. ketterle , and c. salomon , _ ultra - cold fermi gases _ , proceedings of the international school of physics enrico fermi , course clxiv , varenna , ( ios , amsterdam , 2008 ) .
s. giorgini , l. p. pitaevskii , and s. stringari , rev .
phys . * 80 * , 1215 ( 2008 ) .
m. w. zwierlein , a. schirotzek , c. h. schunck , and w. ketterle , science * 311 * , 492 ( 2006 ) .
g. b. partridge , w. li , r. i. kamar , y. liao , and r. g. hulet , science * 311 * , 503 ( 2006 ) . y. shin , c. h. schunck , a. schirotzek , and w. ketterle , nature * 451 * , 689 ( 2008 ) .
n. navon , s. nascimbne , f. chevy , and c. salomon , science * 328 * , 729 ( 2010 ) .
lin , r. l. compton , a. r. perry , w. d. phillips , j. v. porto , and i. b. spielman , phys .
* 102 * , 130401 ( 2009 ) .
lin , y .- j .
lin , k. jimnez - garca , and i. b. spielman , nature ( london ) * 471 * , 83 ( 2011 ) .
j. p. vyasanakere and v. b. shenoy , phys .
b * 83 * , 094515 ( 2011 ) .
j. p. vyasanakere , s. zhang , and v. b. shenoy , phys .
b * 84 * , 014512 ( 2011 ) .
yu and h. zhai , arxiv:1105.2250 ( 2011 ) .
hui hu , l. jiang , x .-
liu , and han pu , arxiv:1105.2488 ( 2011 ) .
li han and c. a. r. s de melo , arxiv:1106.3613 ( 2011 ) .
g. chen , m. gong , and c. zhang , arxiv:1107.2627 ( 2011 ) .
m. gong , s. tewari , and c. zhang , arxiv:1105.1796 ( 2011 ) .
m. iskin and a. l. subai , phys .
* 107 * , 050402 ( 2011 ) .
w. yi and g .- c .
guo , arxiv:1106.5667 ( 2011 ) .
m. iskin and a. l. subai , arxiv:1107.2376 ( 2011 ) .
l. p. gorkov and e. i. rashba , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 037004 ( 2001 ) .
g. dresselhaus , phys . rev .
* 100 * , 580 ( 1955 ) .
note that the fa - type soc may not be eliminated by a momentum shift for mass - imbalanced fermi gases .
c. a. r. s de melo , m. randeira , and j. r. engelbrecht , phys .
lett . * 71 * , 3202 ( 1993 ) .
m. iskin and c. a. r. s de melo , phys .
a * 74 * , 013608 ( 2006 ) .
j. p. gaebler , j. t. stewart , t. e. drake , d. s. jin , a. perali , p. pieri , and g. c. strinati , nature phys . * 6 * , 569 ( 2010 ) . | we consider a general anisotropic spin - orbit coupling ( soc ) and analyze the phase diagrams of both balanced and imbalanced fermi gases for the entire bcs
bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) evolution . in the first part
, we use the self - consistent mean - field theory at zero temperature , and show that the topological structure of the ground - state phase diagrams is quite robust against the effects of anisotropy . in the second part , we go beyond the mean - field description , and investigate the effects of gaussian fluctuations near the critical temperature . this allows us to derive the time - dependent ginzburg - landau theory , from which we extract the effective mass of the cooper pairs and their critical condensation temperature in the molecular bec limit . |
the entropy production of the surrounding medium of a system driven out of equilibrium is arguably the most convenient tool for quantifying the irreversiblity . in the long time limit when the steady state value of the entropy production arising due to the boundary contributions could be neglected ,
the probability distribution function @xmath1 for the change in the medium entropy @xmath2 at time @xmath3 , is known to satisfy certain symmetry relation , generally known as the fluctuation theorem @xcite : @xmath4 this symmetry relation implies that the probability of observing the entropy annihilation over a long time interval becomes negligibly small and can be viewed as the nonequilibrium generalization of the second law of thermodynamics .
the derivation of the distribution function in the asymptotic time limit is often performed by finding out the corresponding large deviation function(ldf ) @xmath5 which is related to the distribution function as , @xmath6 the ldf plays the role of the free energy functions in equilibrium systems @xcite and in the case of nonequilibrium systems , its symmetry property , @xmath7 , validates the fluctuation theorem or the gallavotti - cohen symmetry @xcite .
for a system described by the continuous time markov dynamics , a microscopic transition from its configuration @xmath8 to @xmath9 with a transition rate , @xmath10 , causes the entropy of the surrounding medium to change @xcite by the amount @xmath11 , where @xmath12 , the boltzmann constant , is assumed to be unity .
of the many studies on the entropy production of the medium for systems with microscopic reversibility @xcite , some recent works on the properties of the ldf and its symmetry relation can be found in @xcite where the authors studied the asymptotic distributions of the entropy production by finding out the ldf using a generating function based approach . in reference
@xcite , the authors obtained the ldf for partially asymmetric simple exclusion processes and reaction - diffusion processes with microscopic reversibility .
the emergence of a kink - like feature in the ldf at zero entropy production was argued to be generic for such processes .
this kink could be characterized by the average value of the medium entropy production rate , making the entropy production rate a good candidate for quantifying the irreversibility in nonequilibrium systems .
while there is a wide applicability of the above formula for finding the medium entropy production for nonequilibrium systems having bi - directional transitions between its various states , this formula can not be applied directly when we encounter a system with irreversible microscopic transitions between its states @xcite .
totally asymmetric simple exclusion processes(tasep ) where particles move in only one direction respecting the exclusion principle is one such example of systems with irreversible microscopic transition .
other examples include enzymatic reaction networks modeled by michaelis - menten scheme , directed percolation etc . in these systems
when some of the transition rates @xmath10 become zero , this formula predicts an infinite entropy production which have not been observed in realistic situations @xcite . to address this shortcoming , ben - avraham _ et _ _ al . _
@xcite proposed a regularization scheme by sampling the states of the system at small time interval and obtained the modified transition probabilities . using those transition probabilities , they computed the medium entropy production rate and its ldf for a three - state irreversible loop . in reference
@xcite , the authors used a slightly different method by introducing small backward transitions and determined the lower bound for the average rate of medium entropy production originating from the predominant irreversible transitions . in this paper , we obtain the effective time - dependent transition rates for systems with irreversible transitions by allowing the systems to undergo all possible allowed transitions over small time interval @xmath0 and , then , deriving the probabilities of transition between any two states at the end of the time interval , @xmath0 .
the new transition rates are identical to the original transition rates for small @xmath0 .
these transition rates allow us to extend straightforwardly the generating function based approach used earlier @xcite to find out the ldf for the mean entropy production for irreversible systems . for a two - site tasep and a three - state irreversible system , we first obtain the transition probabilities between any two arbitrary states by solving the governing master equations .
the transition rates are obtained after keeping the leading order terms in @xmath0 in the taylor expansion of the time - dependent probabilities and then differentiating with respect to @xmath0 .
these new rates are used to obtain the average rate of medium entropy production and further to obtain the ldf for the entropy production through a saddle point approximation . at zero entropy production ,
the ldfs for both the models show a kink which can be characterized by the average entropy production rate @xcite .
finally , the ldf is used to find the distribution of the entropy production in the long time limit . in the case of a two - site tasep ,
the average rate of medium entropy production monotonically increases with the particle injection and withdrawal rates @xmath13 . for large values of the medium entropy production rate ,
the distribution function for the entropy production appears like a gaussian distribution .
for low entropy production rates , the distribution function turns out to be a non - gaussian one .
the features of the ldf that are responsible for producing the non - gaussian shape of the entropy distribution function are strongly ( exponentially ) suppressed in the case of large entropy production rates .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec:2 ]
, we introduce the entropy production formalisms for markov jump processes and a practical way to apply those for systems having unidirectional transitions . in section [ sec:3 ] , we first compute the rate of medium entropy production in the nonequilibrium steady state for two - site tasep with equal injection and withdrawal rates denoted by @xmath13 .
next , we obtain the ldf as well as the distribution function for the medium entropy production for different values of @xmath13 . in section [ sec:4 ] , using the same lines of approach , we obtain the analytical form of the ldf for entropy production for a three - state irreversible loop .
the results are summarized in section [ sec:5 ] .
in this section , we first present a brief overview of these relations @xcite valid for stochastic dynamics modeled as continuous time markovian dynamics with finite , discrete configuration space .
next , we elucidate the feasibility of using the known entropy production formulae for a system having one or more microscopically irreversible transitions between its finite number of discrete states . due to the microscopic irreversibility inherent in the system ,
some of the transition rates involved in the entropy production formulations are zero . here , without introducing negligibly small backward transition rates as was done in @xcite , we obtain the new set of transition rates by sampling the states of the system at a small time interval @xmath0 . in the limit @xmath14 , these new transition rates approach their original values , thus making the computations of entropy production rate and its ldf more accurate .
we consider a continuous - time markov jump process , for the time interval @xmath15 , with finite number of states .
the dynamical evolution of the probability @xmath16 , that the system is found in state @xmath8 , is described by the master equation @xmath17 where @xmath18 and @xmath10 are the transition rates for the jump from state @xmath9 to @xmath8 and from state @xmath8 to @xmath9 , respectively .
equation([1 ] ) can be written in matrix form as , @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the column matrix and the @xmath21th element of the transition matrix @xmath22 are @xmath23 in order to obtain the expression for the entropy production due to a transition from one state to another , we begin by defining the average gibbs entropy of the system as @xmath24 the expression for the time evolution of the system entropy has the form @xcite @xmath25 where the overdot implies a derivative with respect to time . the first term on the right hand side of the above relation is always positive and is identified as the total entropy production rate due to stochastic transitions .
the second term is the medium entropy production rate or the entropy flow into the medium due to these transitions .
the total rate of the entropy production is now expressed as @xmath26 with @xmath27 in order to calculate the medium entropy production rate , we first briefly describe the strategy to compute the transition rates employing a matrix - based approach . to begin with ,
we consider a markov process in which transitions between the discrete states @xmath28 are measured in discrete time steps , @xmath29 , where @xmath30 .
the solution of equation([matrix_form ] ) is determined by diagonalizing the matrix @xmath22 as @xmath31 , where matrix @xmath32 is formed of the eigenvectors of @xmath22 arranged column - wise , and @xmath33 is the inverse of @xmath32 .
the diagonal matrix @xmath34 has the eigenvalues of @xmath22 as its diagonal elements .
the solution of equation([matrix_form ] ) then reads @xmath35 the elements of the @xmath36 matrix are the transition probabilities .
for instance , the element @xmath37 , in conventional notation , implies @xmath38 , i.e. , the probability of finding the system at @xmath8-th state at time @xmath3 , provided it was at @xmath9-th state at the initial time .
these transition probabilities allow us to obtain the time - dependent transition rates @xcite if the states of the system are sampled at small time interval @xmath39 . to be more specific , let us consider the probability @xmath40 at time @xmath41 of finding the system at state @xmath8 . in the limit @xmath42
, we have , @xmath43 this relation defines @xmath44 which denotes the transition rate from state @xmath9 to @xmath8 . in the subsequent sections ,
these transition rates are used in relation ( [ medium_entropy ] ) to calculate the average rate of entropy production of the medium , its ldf and the distribution function in the asymptotic time limit .
we consider two - site tasep with equal particle injection and withdrawal rates @xmath13 as our first model of a system with irreversible transitions between its four states as shown in figure [ fig : samplefig1 ] .
let us consider the time evolution of the probability densities @xmath45 , where the element @xmath46 of the column matrix denotes the probability of finding the system in state @xmath8 .
the governing master equation can be written as , @xmath47 where @xmath22 is the @xmath48 matrix having the following form , @xmath49 the eigenvalues of @xmath22 are @xmath50,\ \lambda_4=\frac{1}{2}[-1 - 3\alpha+\sqrt{1 - 6\alpha+\alpha^2}]$ ] with the corresponding eigenvectors @xmath51,-\frac{1}{2\alpha}[1+\alpha + \sqrt{1 - 6\alpha + \alpha^2}],1\right)^t;\\ e_4=\left(1,\frac{1}{2\alpha}[1 - 3\alpha -\sqrt{1 - 6\alpha + \alpha^2}],-\frac{1}{2\alpha}[1+\alpha-\sqrt{1 - 6\alpha+\alpha^2}],1\right)^t.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath33 has the form @xmath52 with @xmath53 . substituting @xmath32 , @xmath54 and @xmath33 in equation([soln1 ] ) , each element of the column vector @xmath55 is expressed as @xmath56 which can be written in the compact form as @xmath57 in the above equation , the conditional probability @xmath37 implies the probability of finding the system at @xmath8-th state at time @xmath3 , provided it was at @xmath9-th state at initial time .
@xmath58 term corresponds to the null transition .
if we consider the time interval , @xmath59 , to be small such that the sampling time becomes , @xmath60 , it is then ensured that the transition matrix @xmath61 becomes closer to the original transition matrix ( [ tasep_trmatrix ] ) . in this limit
, the matrix @xmath36 has the form , = ( cccc 1-+ & & - & + - & 1-+ & ^2 ^ 2 & - + & -(+ ) ^2 & 1 - 2 + 2 ^ 2 ^ 2 & + & & - & 1-+ + ) .
the corresponding transition matrix @xmath61 as defined in ( [ wmatrix ] ) is = ( cccc ^2- & & -3 ^ 2 & + -(1 + ) & -1 & 2 ^ 2 & -(1 + ) + & 1 - 2(+ ) & 4 ^ 2 - 2 & + & & -3 ^ 2 & ^2- + ) . having obtained the time - dependent transition rates in the previous subsection , we now evaluate the average rate of medium entropy production in the nonequilibrium steady state as defined in equation([medium_entropy ] ) .
we define the transition rate for a transition from state @xmath9 to @xmath8 as @xmath62 which is related to the corresponding element of the transition matrix as , @xmath63 .
the steady state probability densities for the two - site model are obtained as , @xmath64 in the small time limit , the ratio of the forward and the reverse transition rates are approximated as , @xmath65 the average rate of entropy production of the medium is thus obtained as , @xmath66.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the entropy production rate is plotted in the figure [ fig : entropy_prodiction_eigenvalues](a ) with @xmath13 .
the positivity of the entropy production suggests that the medium entropy increases as the system undergoes transition from one state to another . with the definition of the transition matrix @xmath61 in the previous section ,
we calculate the ldf for entropy production@xcite .
let @xmath67 be the probability that the system is in the @xmath8-th state at time @xmath3 while the change in the medium entropy is @xmath2 .
the probability of finding the system at time @xmath68 after a small time interval @xmath0 , during which the entropy exchange with the medium is @xmath69 due to the jump of the system from state @xmath9 to @xmath8 , is expressed as @xcite , @xmath70.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit @xmath14 , we have , @xmath71.\end{aligned}\ ] ] introducing the generating function @xmath72 we write the time evolution of the generating function as , @xmath73 the above equation can be written in a matrix form as , @xmath74 where & = ( llll -(+^2(-2)/2 ) & ( ) ^1- ( -(1+))^ & ( -3 ^ 2)^1-()^ & + ( -(1+))^1-()^ & -1 & ( 2 ^ 2)^1- [ 1 - 2(+0.5)]^ & ( -(1+))^1-()^ + ( ) ^1-(-3 ^ 2)^ & ( 1 - 2(+0.5))^1-(2 ^ 2)^ & ( 4 ^ 2 - 2 ) & ( ) ^1-(-3
^ 2)^ + & ( ) ^1-(-(1+))^ & ( -3 ^ 2)^1-()^ & -(+^2(-2)/2 ) + ) , & and @xmath75 .
\(a ) ( b ) \(a ) ( b ) in order to find the total probability distribution @xmath76 , we need to introduce the total generating function @xmath77 . in the large time limit , the total generating function can be approximated as , @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the smallest of all the eigenvalues defined through the following equation @xmath80 we evaluate the smallest eigenvalue numerically and it is plotted in figure [ fig : entropy_prodiction_eigenvalues](b ) with @xmath81 . the symmetry of the smallest eigenvalue about @xmath82 validates the fluctuation theorem @xmath83 @xcite .
the average rate of entropy production of the medium @xmath84 is related to the smallest eigenvalue as , @xmath85 in order to obtain the probability distribution @xmath67 , one has to invert the relation in equation ( [ genfn ] ) .
the final integration is done using a saddle point approximation scheme .
the ldf or the rate function @xmath86 with @xmath87 as the normalised rate of entropy production , can be expressed as the legendre transform of @xmath79 @xmath88 here @xmath89 is the saddle point defined through the equation @xmath90 . from figure [ fig : entropy_prodiction_eigenvalues](a ) , it is evident that the average entropy production rate is always positive and it increases as we increase the value of @xmath13 . at zero entropy production ,
the ldf shows a kink which becomes prominent for larger values of @xmath13 ( see figure [ fig : largedeviation](a ) ) . the symmetry property displayed by the ldf , @xmath91 , as shown in figure [ fig : largedeviation](b ) , is attributed to the symmetry property of the distribution function of entropy production quantified through the fluctuation theorem . .
from the left to right panel , the three figures correspond to the rates @xmath92 , @xmath93 and @xmath94 , respectively .
for the small values of the entry and exit rates , the distribution is non - gaussian .
the distribution tends to be gaussian for larger values of entry and exit rates.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] for @xmath94 . for this value of @xmath13 , @xmath95 .
the solid black curve corresponds to the @xmath96 and the red dashed curve is obtained using equation([gaussian_approx ] ) . ] using the expression for the ldf , one may find out the probability distribution function of the normalized entropy production rate @xmath97 in the asymptotic time limit as @xmath98 the ldf provides the detailed information about the distribution function , which is non - gaussian in nature in our case , for large fluctuations .
however , for larger values of @xmath13 when the value of the average entropy production rate is also large , the central part of the distribution tends to be gaussian , while for smaller values of @xmath13 it has a non - gaussian form . intuitively , for small @xmath13 , the number of transitions are also small and over the time interval @xmath99 , the smaller number of events cause the distribution function to have a poisson distribution - like form .
the distribution functions @xmath97 for three different values of @xmath13 are plotted in figure [ fig : entropy_prodiction_dist ] . to have a qualitative understanding of the distribution function for larger values of @xmath84 , it should be noted from figure [ fig : largedeviation](a ) that the values of the ldf from its minimum are larger if the rate of medium entropy production is increased .
these large fluctuations are strongly suppressed in the exponential form of the distribution function .
thus , if we perform a taylor expansion of the ldf about its minimum at @xmath100 , we have @xmath101 we determine the second derivative numerically and for @xmath102 , its value is , @xmath103 . taking the form of @xmath86 as in the equation([gaussian_approx ] ) , we obtain the distribution function for large values of medium entropy production ( see figure [ fig : gaussian_approx ] ) .
the matching between the original distribution and the approximated one is remarkable and thus , the distribution can be approximated as gaussian for large @xmath84 .
however , similar approximation can not be made for smaller values of @xmath84 since in this case , the fluctuations away from the center are not so large .
this explains why the distribution function in this case becomes non - gaussian .
here we apply the present method to a three - state irreversible loop @xcite where the transitions between the three states denoted as @xmath104 happen in a cyclic way as @xmath105 with rate @xmath106 . in the small time interval @xmath0 ,
the transition rates @xmath107s have the form , @xmath108 as before , the time evolution of the generating function @xmath109 @xmath110 , as defined in equation([genfn ] ) , is governed by , @xmath111 where @xmath112 and @xmath113 has the form , @xmath114 the smallest eigenvalue of @xmath115 dominates the large time behavior of the total generating function @xmath116 . in this case ,
the smallest eigenvalue is @xmath117 the rate of medium entropy production is found as , @xmath118.\label{med_entropy_pleimling}\ ] ] \(a ) ( b ) the ldf for the normalized entropy production @xmath119 has the form @xmath120 where the saddle point @xmath89 is defined implicitly as @xmath121 expressing equation ( [ implicit_eq ] ) in terms of @xmath122 , where @xmath123 , we find @xmath124 the saddle point @xmath89 is related to @xmath122 as @xmath125 substituting equation([smallesteigenv ] ) , ( [ med_entropy_pleimling ] ) and ( [ saddle_lambda ] ) into ( [ largedev_2 ] ) , we have @xmath126 the symmetry property of the ldf , @xmath127 , implies that the fluctuation relation for the entropy production in the medium holds for the system in the long time limit .
the plot of the ldf for the entropy production ( see figure [ fig : largedeviation_pleimling](a ) ) shows a kink at zero entropy production as a consequence of the fluctuation theorem @xcite . the distribution function for the entropy production , as shown in [ fig : largedeviation_pleimling](b ) , is obtained directly from equation ( [ ld_pleimling ] ) .
in summary , we have obtained the ldf and the probability distribution function for the medium entropy production for a two - site tasep and a three - state cyclic process .
both tasep and the three - state process involve irreversible transitions due to the hopping of particles in a specific direction and the unicyclic nature of the three - state process . in order to apply the general results of entropy production for stochastic jump processes
, we obtained first the time - dependent transition rates by sampling the states of the systems over a short time interval .
these new transition rates are incorporated in the subsequent derivations of the ldf for the entropy production which satisfies gallavotti - cohen symmetry .
for the two - site tasep , the value of the ldf for large fluctuations becomes higher as the average entropy production rate is increased . as a consequence of this , the distribution function tends to be gaussian . for smaller values of particle injection and withdrawal rates , which in turn makes the average entropy production rate smaller ,
the distribution function becomes non - gaussian and it resembles poisson distribution because of lesser number of events over the time interval . for the three - state irreversible loop , we have found the analytical forms of the smallest eigenvalue and the ldf . for both the processes , the smallest eigenvalue and the ldf
are derived keeping the first order terms in @xmath0 in the new transition rates .
the smallest eigenvalue and the ldf for the medium entropy production satisfy the fluctuation theorem .
our results for the three - state process differ slightly from the previous study @xcite since we incorporate here the conventional definition of the transition rates in the subsequent derivations of the smallest eigenvalue and the ldf . in reference
@xcite , applying bayes theorem to the posterior probabilities , it has been shown that the microscopic reversibility condition is not a necessity to propose a generalize fluctuation theorem for total entropy production . since
using time coarse - graining procedure , we obtain nonzero reverse transition probabilities even for processes involving irreversible transitions , it is expected that this procedure leads to holding symmetry relations of certain kinds for the probability distribution of entropy production . using similar coarsening theorem ,
the authors in reference @xcite have shown the validity of integral fluctuation theorem and crooks relation for hatano - sasa entropy of many - state irreversible processes .
finally , the present methodology based on derivation of the time - dependent transition rates seems to be useful for studying a broad range of models relevant to physical and biophysical processes including complex networks involving multiple degrees of freedom @xcite .
99 evans d j , cohen e g d and morriss g p , 1993 _ phys .
lett . _ * 71 * 2401 gallavotti g and cohen e g d , 1995 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 74 * 2694 gallavotti g and cohen e g d , 1995 _ j. stat .
phys . _ * 80 * 931 kurchan j , 1998 _ j. phys .
a _ * 31 * 3719 lebowitz j l and spohn h , 1999 _ j. stat .
phys . _ * 95 * 333 harris r j and schtz g m , 2007 _ j. stat .
_ p07020 ellis r s , 1985 entropy , large deviations , and statistical mechanics ( berlin : springer ) touchette h , 2009 _ physics reports _ * 478 * 1 schnakenberg j , 1976 _ rev .
phys . _ * 48 * 571 andrieux d and gaspard p , 2004 _ j. chem
. phys . _ * 121 * 6167 seifert u , 2005 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 95 * 040602 seifert u , 2008 _ eur
j. b _ * 64 * 423 tom t and de oliveira m j 2012 _ phys .
* 108 * 020601 zia r k p and schmittmann b ,
2007 _ j. stat . mech .
_ p07012 barato a c , chetrite r , hinrichsen h and mukamel d , 2010 _ j. stat . mech .
_ p10008 imparato a and peliti l , 2007 _ j. stat .
l02001 dorosz s and pleimling m , 2011 _ phys .
e _ * 83 * 031107 de oliveira rodrigues j e and dickman r , 2010 _ phys .
e _ * 81 * 061108 takeuchi k a , kuroda m , chat h and sano m , 2007 _ phys .
* 234503 ben - avraham d , dorosz s and pleimling m , 2011 _ phys . rev .
* 84 * 011115 zeraati s , jafarpour f h and hinrichsen h , 2012 _ j. stat . mech .
_ l12001 mehl j , speck t and seifert u , 2008 _ phys .
e _ * 78 * 011123 speck t , engel a and seifert u , 2012 _ j. stat .
_ p12001 reichl l e , 1980 a modern course in statistical physics ( weinheim : wiley - vch ) ohkubo j , 2009 _ j. phys .
* 78 * 123001 ben - avraham d , dorosz s and pleimling m , 2011 _ phys .
e _ * 83 * 041129 gernert r , emary c and klapp s h l , 2014 _ phys .
e _ * 90 * 062115 | we obtain the large deviation function for entropy production of the medium and its distribution function for two - site totally asymmetric simple exclusion process ( tasep ) and three - state unicyclic network .
since such systems are described through microscopic irreversible transitions , we obtain time - dependent transition rates by sampling the states of these systems at a regular short time interval @xmath0 .
these transition rates are used to derive the large deviation function for the entropy production in the nonequilibrium steady state and its asymptotic distribution function .
the shapes of the large deviation function and the distribution function depend on the value of the mean entropy production rate which has a non - trivial dependence on the particle injection and withdrawal rates in case of tasep .
further , it is argued that in case of a tasep , the distribution function tends to be like a poisson distribution for smaller values of particle injection and withdrawal rates . |
many observational programs over the past few years have led to the proposition that all galaxies with a substantial spheroid component contain supermassive black holes , irrespective of the presence or absence of nuclear activity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
since black holes grow via the accretion of matter and this accretion leads to detectable nuclear activity , these results imply that all galaxies must go through an accretion phase , yet the mechanism which triggers nuclear activity in `` currently '' active galaxies remains unknown . in order to fuel active galactic nuclei ( agn ) ,
essentially all of the angular momentum must be removed from some fraction of the host galaxy s interstellar medium ( ism ) .
low - luminosity agn , which dominate the local population , require accretion rates of @xmath1 yr@xmath2 , assuming typical radiative efficiencies .
studies of agn and inactive control samples have investigated the frequency of several mechanisms for angular momentum transport to determine their viability .
interactions between galaxies is one good candidate @xcite as theoretical simulations of mergers show significant accretion into the central regions of the merger remnant ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
interactions may be responsible for triggering agn activity in the more luminous quasars @xcite , yet detailed studies of interacting pairs have not found a statistically significant excess of the lower - luminosity seyfert galaxies in interacting systems @xcite .
large - scale bars have also been proposed as a mechanism to fuel nuclear activity @xcite .
the nonaxisymmetric potential due to a large - scale bar leads to the formation of a shock front along the bar s leading edges @xcite and material has been observed flowing into the central regions of several barred galaxies @xcite .
however , detailed near - infrared ( nir ) studies of large samples of active and inactive galaxies have shown either no , or at most a marginal ( @xmath3 ) , excess of large - scale bars in active samples @xcite .
these studies of interacting and barred galaxies pushed the effective spatial resolution limit of ground - based observations for large samples of agn , yet the typical spatial resolution of these investigations remain many hundreds of parsecs .
hst_programs over the past few years have targeted the circumnuclear morphology of large active galaxy samples to search for signatures of agn fueling ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
one of the main goals of these programs was to investigate the fraction of seyferts with nuclear bars ( bars with semimajor axis lengths typically less than a kiloparsec ) , which could be comprised of gas or stars @xcite and cause the transport of matter from approximately a kiloparsec to tens of parsecs .
however , these studies have found nuclear bars in only @xmath4% of all seyferts
@xcite and studies of seyfert and control samples have found similar fractions of double bars in samples of active and inactive galaxies with large - scale bars @xcite .
the comparable fractions of nuclear bars in active and inactive galaxies , combined with the apparent absence of them in the majority of all active galaxies , suggests that some other mechanism is needed to fuel nuclear activity in many active galaxies .
one new candidate that arose from the _ hst_studies is nuclear dust spirals @xcite . visible
nir color maps of the majority of the active galaxies in these surveys showed nuclear spirals , with a wide range of coherence , that extend from approximately a kiloparsec down to tens of parsecs ( the limiting spatial resolution of the nearest subsample ) .
these nuclear spirals are distinct from the spiral arms in the main disks of these galaxies as they appear to have density contrasts of only a factor of a few above the ambient ism and no associated star formation .
nuclear spirals are a promising fueling mechanism not only by virtue of their frequency , but also because they may mark the location of shock fronts or turbulence in the central , circumnuclear gaseous disks and therefore trace the sites of angular momentum dissipation .
the possibility of shock - driven inflow , as traced by nuclear spiral structure , has been the subject of a number of recent theoretical studies @xcite . while most of the observational programs to date have targeted the circumnuclear region of active galaxies , nuclear dust spirals
have also been observed in a small number of inactive galaxies with single - bandpass observations @xcite . in _
9 we began a program ( sn8597 , pi regan ) to obtain wfpc2 images of galaxies with prior nicmos observations ( from sn7330 , pi mulchaey and go7867 , pi pogge ) in order to quantify the frequency of nuclear spiral structure in inactive galaxies .
we present the observations of our final sample of 123 galaxies , along with a description of the sample , survey design , and classification system for circumnuclear dust structure , in ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter paper i ) .
our nuclear dust classification has six types , including four for nuclear dust spirals : grand design , tightly wound , loosely wound , and chaotic spirals .
we placed galaxies with dust structures but without evidence for nuclear spirals in a fifth , `` chaotic '' class , and galaxies with no detected circumnuclear dust structure into a sixth , `` no structure '' class .
the final dataset presented in paper i , in spite of the initial effort to create a well - match active and control sample , is relatively heterogeneous due to both the vagarious _ hst_snapshot scheduling and our attempt to augment the sample with additional nearby galaxies of interest . in the present paper we create well - matched subsamples of the full dataset presented in paper i in order to measure the relative frequency of nuclear dust spirals in active and inactive galaxies .
this sample creation , described in the next section , draws unique pairs of active / inactive or barred / unbarred galaxies that otherwise have all of the same host galaxy properties and are at the same distance , while also maximizing the total size of the subsample drawn from the full dataset . in [ sec : active ] and [ sec : all ] we describe the trends for circumnuclear dust morphology for the active / inactive and barred / unbarred samples , respectively .
the implications of these results for the fueling of nuclear activity are described in [ sec : discuss ] and our results are summarized in [ sec : conc ] .
to construct the best - matched sample given the available observations , we have developed an algorithm to identify a unique inactive , control galaxy for each active galaxy and maximize the number of pairs of active and inactive galaxies .
the host galaxy properties used to identify possible control galaxies for each active galaxy were the four properties used to define the original rsa control sample : hubble type ( @xmath5 ) , blue luminosity ( @xmath6 ) , heliocentric velocity ( @xmath7 ) , and inclination ( @xmath8 ) , along with a fifth property : the angular size of the host .
this fifth property is expressed as the fraction ( @xmath9 ) of the angular extent ( @xmath10 ) of the host galaxy within the @xmath11 field of view of the color maps shown in figure 1 of paper i. the constraints on these parameters are : @xmath12 , @xmath13 mag , @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 .
these constraints were applied to the subsample of 86 ( out of 123 ) galaxies with @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
these two cuts were chosen to avoid distant galaxies , where the _
hst_spatial resolution is comparable to ground - based observations of nearby galaxies , and highly inclined systems , where we found our morphological classifications were less reliable ( see paper i ) .
the algorithm first identifies all possible control galaxies for each active galaxy through measurement of the absolute difference between each of the host galaxy parameters .
as there are more active than inactive galaxies in the final dataset , the number of inactive galaxies is the main constraint on the final number of matched pairs .
the first step in the algorithm is therefore to identify each inactive galaxy that has only one active galaxy match .
these unique galaxy pairs are placed into the output catalog and the active galaxies in these pairs are then removed from the list of possible matches for the remaining inactive galaxies .
this procedure is then repeated until no potential matched pairs remain .
for the case where there are no inactive galaxies with a unique active galaxy match , the control galaxy with the fewest number of active galaxy matches was picked and matched with the active galaxy with the smallest number of other control galaxy matches .
this method successfully found a unique active galaxy match for each inactive galaxy with @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and at least one possible pair : the best possible outcome .
for other parameter constraints described below it was either equally successful or at worst would fail to match only one or two control galaxies .
this process yielded a final , matched sample of 28 active galaxies and 28 inactive galaxies .
the distribution of nuclear classifications and host galaxy properties for this sample is shown in figure [ fig : matchagn ] .
the galaxies in this active and inactive sample are listed in table [ tbl : matchagn ] and their host galaxy properties are provided in paper i. the mean ( and rms ) differences between the pairs for each of these properties are : @xmath19 mag , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 .
if we increased the size of the constraints , such as from 0.5 to 1 mag in @xmath6 , the sample size would only increase by three pairs , which we decided did not justify the chance this would increase systematic biases .
the top left panel of the figure shows the relative distribution of active and inactive galaxies in each of the six nuclear classes .
the remaining panels show the distribution of host galaxy properties .
we did not include the presence or absence of a large - scale bar in this sample selection , as this additional constraint would have further reduced the sample size .
the sample listed in table [ tbl : matchagn ] has more unbarred inactive galaxies ( ten ) than unbarred active galaxies ( four ) . as we show next , nuclear spiral structure appears to be present in barred and unbarred galaxies with equal frequency , so this should not affect our results , although the distribution of barred and unbarred galaxies into the nuclear spiral classes is different .
we created matched samples of barred and unbarred galaxies in the same manner as for the active and inactive galaxies .
the goal of this investigation was to measure the frequency of nuclear spiral structure in barred and unbarred galaxies , as well as to verify the two results noted in paper i : the existence of grand design nuclear spirals only in barred galaxies and the strong tendency for tightly wound nuclear spirals to avoid barred galaxies .
due to the small number of unbarred galaxies ( 25 or 86 ) in this sample , only 19 pairs of barred and unbarred galaxies were identified .
these galaxies are listed in table [ tbl : matchbar ] .
figure [ fig : matchbar ] shows the distribution of these galaxies in each of the morphological classes for circumnuclear dust , along with the distributions of their host galaxy properties .
the mean differences between the pairs of barred and unbarred galaxies in each of the parameters are : @xmath24 mag , @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 .
the barred and unbarred pairs were not required to have the same nuclear activity , although as eleven of 19 barred galaxies and eight of 19 unbarred galaxies were active , the comparison below should not be biased by any differences between active and inactive galaxies .
the main result of figure [ fig : matchagn ] is that nuclear spiral structure is found with comparable frequency in active and inactive galaxies for a sample well - matched by host galaxy properties .
when all four nuclear spiral classes are summed together , 21 of the 28 active galaxies ( 75% ) have nuclear dust spirals compared to 17 of the 28 ( 61% ) inactive galaxies .
the significance of this result can be estimated with a binomial distribution as each galaxiy either has a nuclear spiral or does not , these outcomes are statistically independent , and each galaxy has the same probability of having a nuclear spiral .
the variances of the active and inactive samples are @xmath29 and @xmath30 , respectively , and the variance of the difference is @xmath31 .
thus , the observed spiral frequencies formally differ by only @xmath32 , which is not statistically significant .
of the four types of nuclear spirals , there are approximately equal numbers of active and inactive galaxies in the grand design , tightly wound , and chaotic spiral classes .
the active galaxies with loosely wound nuclear spirals outnumber inactive galaxies with similar circumnuclear morphologies by a factor of three to one , although this excess has less than @xmath33 significance .
the main result from this figure is that nuclear spirals are found with comparable frequency in active and inactive galaxies .
another interesting result from figure [ fig : matchagn ] is that 25% ( seven ) of the inactive galaxies have no obvious circumnuclear dust structure at all , whereas all of the active galaxies have some structure in their circumnuclear dust distribution .
these galaxies must either have no circumnuclear dust , or this dust must be smoothly distributed .
employment of the binomial distribution estimate shows that this difference has a formal significance of @xmath34 .
these galaxies include four s0s , an sa , an sab , and an sbc , and therefore it is not hubble type alone which drives the absence of circumnuclear dust structure .
spatial resolution is important to identify dust structures in the centers of galaxies , as color maps are most sensitive to dust structure with an angular size comparable to the psf .
we are therefore progressively less sensitive to small - scale dust structure in the more distant galaxies . however , as we have an equal number of active and inactive galaxies at each distance , there is no bias against the detection of dust structures in one sample relative to the other . therefore spatial resolution will not effect the relative frequency of dust structure in active and inactive galaxies , although it may effect the number of galaxies with detected dust structure , the full sample from paper i includes these same seven inactive galaxies with no circumnuclear dust structure : ngc357 , ngc628 , ngc1398 , ngc1638 , ngc3300 , ngc3458 , and ngc7096 , along with one active galaxy : ngc3362 .
this agn was excluded from the discussion in the present paper because it has a heliocentric velocity greater than @xmath35 ( @xmath36 ) .
the lack of circumnuclear dust structure in this agn may be due to poor spatial resolution , or contamination by light from the central point source .
the presence of some emission line gas in the central region of ngc3362 indicates that it does have some circumnuclear gas , even though no dust structure is apparent in the colormap .
the fact that the only agn in this class in the full sample is at a large distance , and in any case shows emission line structure in the circumnuclear region , further supports our result that inactive galaxies have a strong tendency to lack circumnuclear dust structure relative to active galaxies .
the upper left panel of figure [ fig : matchbar ] shows the distribution of the barred and unbarred galaxies into each nuclear class .
while the sample is smaller than shown in figure [ fig : matchagn ] , the differences appear more striking . the first column confirms the result from paper i that grand design nuclear spiral structure is only found in galaxies with large - scale bars .
seven grand design nuclear spirals are found in barred galaxies , whereas none are found in unbarred galaxies .
this result has @xmath34 formal significance . in paper
i we found 19 barred galaxies with grand design structure and no unbarred galaxies in this class .
grand design nuclear spiral structure is therefore only found in galaxies with large - scale bars .
furthermore , these grand design nuclear dust spirals always appear to connect with dust lanes along the leading edges of the large - scale bar
. if the barred galaxies in this sample and in the full sample discussed in paper i are representative of the population of barred galaxies , grand design nuclear spirals are present in approximately a third of all barred galaxies ( 27% of the full sample from paper i , 37% of the present , smaller sample ) .
these grand design nuclear spirals are therefore more common than inner rings , which were only found in a small minority of barred galaxies in paper i. only three of the 19 barred galaxies listed in table 2 show evidence for inner rings in the _ hst_observations presented in paper i. the morphology of these dust lanes is in good agreement with the predictions of hydrodynamic simulations of gas morphology in the circumnuclear regions of barred galaxies @xcite .
the observations clearly show the shock fronts in large - scale bars continues into the circumnuclear region to the limit of our angular resolution , which corresponds to tens of parsecs from the nucleus .
the inflow of matter due to large - scale bars can lead to the secular evolution of galaxies , fuel circumnuclear star formation , accretion , and may eventually lead to the dissolution of the large - scale bar @xcite .
the fact that inner rings are only found in a small minority of barred galaxies , and are less common than grand design spirals , shows that the `` pile up '' of bar - driven inflow into a ring is a rare occurence . in the full sample described in paper i
there were three barred galaxies ( out of 70 ) with tightly wound nuclear dust spirals compared with eight ( of 31 ) unbarred galaxies .
two of those barred galaxies with tightly wound nuclear dust spirals were excluded from this analysis because of distance or because there was not an unbarred galaxy with comparable host galaxy properties .
the matched sample shown in figure [ fig : matchbar ] has seven unbarred galaxies with tightly wound nuclear spirals and only one barred galaxy with a tightly wound nuclear spiral .
this difference has a formal significance of @xmath3 and therefore may represent a second real difference in the circumnuclear structure of barred galaxies .
as there are a small number of barred galaxies with tightly wound nuclear dust spirals , the connection between tightly wound nuclear spirals and the absence of a large - scale bar is not as strong as the connection between grand design nuclear spirals and large - scale bars .
nevertheless , given the fact that barred galaxies far outnumber unbarred galaxies in the full sample , and there is an even stronger trend in the full sample , there may be a physical connection between the absence of a large - scale bar and the presence of a tightly wound nuclear dust spiral .
the tendency for tightly wound nuclear spirals to be present in unbarred galaxies could be confirmed ( improved to @xmath34 significance ) with an additional sample of on order ten unbarred galaxies that are well - matched to our existing barred galaxy sample . to investigate any additional correlations between host galaxy properties and circumnuclear dust structure , we have examined the mean host galaxy properties of all of the galaxies in paper i with @xmath18 and @xmath17 .
the mean hubble type of this sample is only slightly later than sab .
this is also the case for all of the individual nuclear classes except for the loosely wound spiral class , which has an earlier mean hubble type between s0/a and sa .
the similar mean hubble types for each nuclear class suggests that there is not a strong relationship between galaxy type and the morphology of the circumnuclear dust .
the fact that the loosely wound spirals are more common in galaxies whose large - scale spiral arms are more tightly wound may be due to the relative importance of the bulge and disk in the circumnuclear and large - scale morphology .
however , @xcite showed that the rotation curves of galaxies are more dependent on luminosity than on hubble type . a difference in luminosity , parametrized here as @xmath6 ,
could therefore explain the variations in circumnuclear dust structure if the amount of differential rotation is the primary factor in the pitch angle of the nuclear spirals .
in general , there are no large differences in the average @xmath6 from class to class .
the mean @xmath6 for the entire sample is -20.3 mag and the mean value for each class deviates at most by little over half a magnitude from this value .
the deviation is largest between the tightly wound nuclear spirals , which have @xmath37 mag and the loosely wound nuclear spirals , which have @xmath38 mag .
therefore it appears that the tightly wound nuclear spirals are found in more luminous galaxies .
as @xcite found that more luminous galaxies have larger central velocity gradients , tightly wound nuclear spirals may therefore be found in more luminous galaxies if these galaxies also deviate more strongly from solid - body rotation .
an alternate explanation is that the tightly wound spirals have been undisturbed for a longer period of time and have had more time to wind .
kinematic observations are necessary to determine if the circumnuclear rotation curve is the primary driver of nuclear spiral pitch angle .
two additional parameters that describe the morphology of these galaxies , but are not included in our paired sample matching , are the presence of a ring or pseudo ring and whether or not a galaxy is classified as peculiar .
we have used the rc3 classifications listed in table 3 of paper i to compute the relative frequency of ringlike and peculiar morphology as a function of nuclear classification and found that the relative frequencies of these classifications are consistent with each other across the six circumnuclear dust classes .
this consistency is not very significant , however , as the quality of the rc3 classifications is difficult to quantify for the full sample . a larger number of well - matched galaxy pairs would provide an improved basis for investigation of correlations between circumnuclear morphology and host galaxy properties .
all of the mechanisms proposed to fuel nuclear activity in galaxies are also methods that can trigger circumnuclear star formation and may lead to secular evolution .
recent work on a direct connection between seyferts and starbursts by @xcite has investigated connections between the circumnuclear dust morphology and star formation .
these authors studied the relationship between the @xcite `` inner hubble type '' classification and the presence of circumnuclear star formation and found that most seyferts with circumnuclear star formation were classified as late - type inner spirals , or loosely wound spirals in our classification system .
if there is more star formation in galaxies with high pitch angle nuclear spirals , this could help to explain the slightly brighter @xmath6 of the loosely wound nuclear spirals relative to the other three nuclear spiral classes .
inspection of the images and colormaps shown in figure 1 of paper i shows some observational support for the results of @xcite , namely the star formation in ngc1672 , ngc4314 , ngc5427 , and ngc6951 .
we note , however , that our sample was not designed to carry out a well - defined study of star formation .
although our analysis based on matched pairs of either active / inactive or barred / unbarred galaxies minimizes sample biases , there are nevertheless several to consider .
the first is that the bar and active galaxy classifications are nonuniform .
as described in paper i , several of the allegedly inactive galaxies designated as controls for the rsa seyfert sample were later reclassified as active galaxies by the palomar survey @xcite . while many of the inactive galaxies in this sample were part of the palomar survey ,
the other galaxies were observed as part of less sensitive surveys that may be biased against the detection of very low - luminosity agn .
this reflects a problem inherent in the view of galaxies as either active or inactive , when in reality the intensity of nuclear activity varies along a continuum over many orders of magnitude .
proper inclusion of , for example , bins of @xmath39 or accretion rate , would require considerably larger samples .
for the current investigation it is very nevertheless unlikely that at least any bright seyfert 1 galaxies were included in our inactive sample due to the fact that there are no bright , unresolved point sources at the centers of their visible or near - infrared _ hst_images .
several quite faint active galaxies from the palomar survey do not have distinct nuclei , so the possibility remains that there are very low - luminosity active galaxies in the inactive sample .
the vast majority of these misclassified active galaxies would have to be in the dust - free or chaotic classes to significantly change our results on active galaxies .
a second potential selection effect is that the brightness of the nuclear point source in the active galaxies may increase the @xmath6 used to match the active and inactive samples .
while this is a concern for comparisons of luminous agn , it is unlikely to affect this study because most of the bona fide agn are still relatively low luminosity nuclei and only make a minor contribution to the total galaxy@xmath40agn luminosity . to test this
we have artificially decreased the @xmath6 value by half a magnitude and rematched the pairs of active and control samples .
there was no significant difference in either the frequency of nuclear spiral structure or the result that the total absence of circumnuclear dust was only found in the inactive galaxies .
a related uncertainty to the first point above is that the sample matching process is only as reliable as the host galaxy properties that are used to create the samples .
fortunately , all of the host galaxy properties were obtained from the rc3 catalog @xcite and therefore were extracted from a homogeneous dataset .
while it is more difficult to obtain accurate galaxy classifications for more distant or less luminous galaxies , the fact that the galaxy samples were matched based on both of these properties simultaneously should account for distance- and brightness - dependent errors in the measurement of the host galaxy properties .
a more serious problem is the bar classifications .
while all of these galaxies have bar classifications in the rc3 catalog , it is now well known that nir observations often identify bars in galaxies considered unbarred at visible wavelengths ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and several of the unbarred galaxies lack nir data . if some of the unbarred galaxies were later found to be barred based on nir observations , that would not change our result that grand design nuclear spirals are only found in galaxies with large - scale bars , although this could effect the result that small pitch angle nuclear spirals ( the tw class ) are preferentially found in unbarred galaxies .
a final uncertainty is the quality of our own nuclear classifications .
as discussed in paper i , the classifications for many galaxies were initially disputed .
however , most of these disputes were between the different nuclear spiral classes and would not affect our result on the relative frequency of nuclear spirals in active and inactive galaxies .
the main uncertainty that could affect this result is the misclassification between the chaotic spiral and chaotic dust classes .
however , half ( three ) of the active galaxies classified as chaotic would have to have spiral structure and half ( also three ) of the inactive galaxies classified as chaotic spirals would have to lack spiral structure in order produce a @xmath34 difference between active and inactive galaxies .
the probability of both circumstances is quite low .
approximately a third of the barred galaxies in this sample show curved dust lanes which start at the leading edges of their large - scale bars , have a grand design morphology in the circumnuclear region and then extend into the unresolved nuclear region .
the apparent extension of the shock fronts in these galaxies into the circumnuclear region presents a strong case for the bar - driven inflow of matter to the nucleus in at least some barred galaxies .
while single color maps do not provide a direct measure of the matter surface density in these dust lanes due to uncertainties caused by the unknown dust geometry and optical depth effects , a lower limit of a few @xmath41 pc@xmath42 is reasonable @xcite . in simulations of dust lanes in barred galaxies the maximal inflow rates are as high as @xmath43 @xcite , similar to measurements of the maximum gas velocity parallel to the dust lanes for several galaxies @xcite .
the mean inflow in the simulations is a few @xmath44 .
@xcite derive a lower limit of @xmath45 m@xmath46 yr@xmath2 for the accretion rate into the central kiloparsec of barred galaxies from their co data .
this amount of matter inflow from bars is sufficient to explain the enhanced molecular gas content at the centers of barred galaxies @xcite and trigger circumnuclear star formation .
there may also be sufficient matter inflow to fuel low - luminosity nuclear activity .
however , this material must still travel from tens of parsecs , the best spatial resolution of these observations , to scales of less than a parsec in order to come within range of the central black hole s gravitational potential .
the presence of grand design spiral shocks demonstrates the presence of a mechanism for matter inflow to the centers of barred galaxies , yet this symmetric spiral structure is only found in a minority of active and inactive galaxies .
the majority of nuclear dust spirals take less symmetric forms with a range in pitch angle , or even have a chaotic appearance that may just exhibit some shear due to differential rotation
. these forms of nuclear spiral structure are probably not formed by large - scale forces in the host galaxy , such as a bar , and instead are probably created _ in situ_. turbulence , either due to pressure or gravitational forces , may create structures that are then sheared into a spiral form due to differential rotation @xcite . the characteristics of density contrasts formed by acoustic turbulence include low density enhancements over the ambient ism , a lack of associated star formation due to their low density , an increase in contrast at smaller radii , and that they should completely fill the circumnuclear disks in which they propagate @xcite . as the turbulence which leads to these spirals produces
shocks in the ism , and shocks dissipate energy and angular momentum , these spirals trace the sites of angular momentum transfer that can lead to the fueling of nuclear activity . in a test of this scenario by @xcite , analysis of nuclear dust spirals in the liners
ngc4450 and ngc4736 show that the azimuthal fourier power spectrum of these spirals has a slope of @xmath47 , indicative of turbulence .
the tightly wound , loosely wound , and chaotic nuclear spirals have similar morphologies to the nuclear spirals studied by @xcite and @xcite , which suggests that most nuclear spirals are caused by a turbulent process .
while morphological arguments suggests that nuclear spirals are formed by turbulence and shocks , the question remains : does sufficient angular momentum transfer occur to fuel nuclear accretion ?
the presence of an insignificant excess of nuclear spirals in active galaxies over inactive galaxies does not support this scenario .
this is not to say that matter inflow is ruled out , only that it stops short of the central black hole .
kinematic evidence for inflow associated with these spirals , as well as emission - line signatures of shocks , would provide more compelling evidence that nuclear spiral structure can produce the accretion rates required to fuel low - luminosity agn .
bars and interactions are mechanisms that can remove angular momentum and fuel nuclear activity .
nuclear spirals could be another possibility , provided that they trace sufficiently strong shocks in the circumnuclear ism .
however , all three of these proposed fueling mechanisms are found with approximately equal frequency in both active and inactive galaxies .
this naturally prompts the question : if these mechanisms are responsible for fueling agn , why are agn not found in the otherwise indistinguishable inactive galaxies ? these observations of nuclear dust spirals , as well as previous work on other similarities in the host galaxies of low - luminosity agn on larger scales , show that there are not clear differences between active and inactive galaxies on any scales greater than approximately a hundred parsecs , the smallest scales probed by the present work .
the absence of clear differences between active and inactive galaxies to within approximately 100 pc radius of their galactic nuclei , combined with the presumption that all of these galaxies possess supermassive black holes , suggests that the characteristic inflow timescale from this radius is an upper limit on the lifetime of nuclear activity .
a plausible estimate of this inflow timescale is the dynamical timescale . at a hundred parsecs ,
the dynamical timescale is several million years in a typical galaxy .
if the structures responsible for agn fueling exist at hundreds of parsec scales , but they are equally common in inactive galaxies , this suggests that the lifetime for an individual episode of nuclear activity is less than several million years . in our proposed scenario , where the structures responsible for agn fueling are present in essentially all galaxies , all galaxies periodically go through a short - lived agn phase
the cold ism in the circumnuclear region of nearly all spiral galaxies exhibits a wealth of structure .
this structure often takes the form of nuclear dust spirals , which demonstrates that some differential rotation is present in the circumnuclear region of most spiral galaxies .
a comparison of a well - matched sample of 19 barred and 19 unbarred galaxies has confirmed our previous result ( paper i ) that grand design nuclear dust spirals are only found in galaxies with large - scale bars .
grand design spirals are present in approximately a third of all barred galaxies and these circumnuclear spirals connect to the relatively straight dust lanes associated with the large - scale bar .
the dust lanes therefore form essentially contiguous structures from many kiloparsec scales to within tens of parsecs of galactic centers .
these nuclear spirals are also more common than inner rings , which are found in only a minority of all barred galaxies .
the fact that most barred galaxies do not have rings inside the bar suggests that bar - driven inflow does not commonly stall in a circumnuclear ring .
our comparison of barred and unbarred galaxies also shows that there is a marginally significant tendency for tightly wound nuclear dust spirals to be found in galaxies that lack large - scale bars .
the low pitch angle of these spirals may be due to an increased time for winding or greater differential rotation . to test for differences in the circumnuclear dust distribution in active and inactive galaxies ,
we have created a well - matched sample of 28 active and 28 inactive galaxies by identifying pairs with all of the same host galaxy properties .
this analysis finds only a statistically insignificant excess of nuclear spirals in active galaxies over the inactive control sample and that nuclear spiral structure is present in the majority of both types .
a perhaps more surprising result was that although all of the active galaxies have some discernible dust structure , seven of the 28 inactive galaxies have no circumnuclear dust structure .
these galaxies either have an extremely smooth dust distribution or no cold component to their ism in the circumnuclear region .
the comparable frequency of nuclear dust spirals in a well - matched sample of active and inactive galaxies , when combined with similar results for the frequency of bars or interactions from previous work , suggests that there is no universal fueling mechanism for low - luminosity agn at scales greater than 100 pc from galactic nuclei .
we have shown that the circumnuclear dust morphologies of most active and inactive galaxies are indistinguishable .
all of these galaxies are assumed to contain supermassive black holes and therefore the main difference between them is whether or not that central black hole is currently fueled .
if the structures responsible for fueling nuclear activity are not present on the hundreds of parsec scales probed by these observations , or are present with equal frequency in active and inactive galaxies , then the timescale for nuclear activity must be less than the timescale for matter inflow from these spatial scales .
if the dynamical timescale on these spatial scales is an approximate measure of the characteristic inflow time , this suggests an upper limit to the lifetime of an individual episode of nuclear activity is several million years .
support for this work was provided by nasa through grant numbers go-7330 , go-7867 , and go-08597 from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
pm was supported by a carnegie starr fellowship .
we would like to thank andy gould , witold maciejewski , keiichi wada , and the referee for helpful suggestions and comments .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
cc ic2560 & ngc7392 + mrk1066 & ngc3300 + ngc1068 & ngc1398 + ngc1667 & ngc0214 + ngc1672 & ngc5383 + ngc2273 & ngc5691 + ngc2336 & ngc1530 + ngc3227 & ic5267 + ngc3486 & ngc1300 + ngc3516 & ngc1638 + ngc3786 & ngc2179 + ngc4143 & ngc3458 + ngc4151 & ngc2146 + ngc4303 & ngc4254 + ngc4725 & ngc2985 + ngc4939 & ngc3145 + ngc5273 & ngc3032 + ngc5347 & ngc7096 + ngc5427 & ngc2276 + ngc5643 & ngc4030 + ngc5953 & ngc2460 + ngc6300 & ngc3368 + ngc6744 & ngc5054 + ngc6814 & ngc0628 + ngc6951 & ngc5970 + ngc7469 & ngc5614 + ngc7496 & ngc7716 + ngc7743 & ngc0357 + cc mark1066 & ic5063 + ngc1530 & ngc5054 + ngc2273 & ic5267 + ngc2276 & ngc5427 + ngc2460 & ngc5953 + ngc3032 & ngc5273 + ngc3145 & ngc4939 + ngc3351 & ngc4380 + ngc3516 & ngc1638 + ngc4253 & mark1210 + ngc4303 & ngc4254 + ngc4725 & ngc2985 + ngc5135 & ngc5614 + ngc5347 & ngc7096 + ngc5643 & ngc4030 + ngc5691 & ngc2179 + ngc6412 & ngc0628 + ngc7130 & ngc0788 + ngc7469 & ngc5548 + | we present a detailed study of the relation between circumnuclear dust morphology , host galaxy properties , and nuclear activity in nearby galaxies .
we use our sample of 123 nearby galaxies with visible near - infrared colormaps from the _ hubble space telescope _ to create well - matched , `` paired '' samples of 28 active and 28 inactive galaxies , as well as 19 barred and 19 unbarred galaxies , that have the same host galaxy properties .
comparison of the barred and unbarred galaxies shows that grand design nuclear dust spirals are only found in galaxies with a large - scale bar .
these nuclear dust spirals , which are present in approximately a third of all barred galaxies , also appear to be connected to the dust lanes along the leading edges of the large - scale bars .
grand design nuclear spirals are more common than inner rings , which are present in only a small minority of the barred galaxies .
tightly wound nuclear dust spirals , in contrast , show a strong tendency to avoid galaxies with large - scale bars .
comparison of the agn and inactive samples shows that nuclear dust spirals , which may trace shocks and angular momentum dissipation in the ism , occur with comparable frequency in both active and inactive galaxies .
the only difference between the active and inactive galaxies is that several inactive galaxies appear to completely lack dust structure in their circumnuclear region , while none of the agn lack this structure .
the comparable frequency of nuclear spirals in active and inactive galaxies , combined with previous work that finds no significant differences in the frequency of bars or interactions between well - matched active and inactive galaxies , suggests that no _ universal _ fueling mechanism for low - luminosity agn operates at spatial scales greater than @xmath0 pc radius from the galactic nuclei .
the similarities of the circumnuclear environments of active and inactive galaxies suggests that the lifetime of nuclear activity is less than the characteristic inflow time from these spatial scales .
an order - of - magnitude estimate of this inflow time is the dynamical timescale .
this sets an upper limit of several million years to the lifetime of an individual episode of nuclear activity . |
in the first place , we note that all the time - evolution free - propagators in eq.(2 ) are retarded , @xmath130 with @xmath131 .
this is so because the time - order prescription on the time integrals implies @xmath132 , hence @xmath133 holds in all the @xmath130 oparators of eq.(2 ) .
it is the time - ordering together with the heaviside function @xmath134 in the integrand of eq.([laeq ] ) that guarantee causality . substituting in eq.([laeq ] ) the expressions of the operators @xmath135 as sums over normal modes , and making use of the identities @xcite @xmath136 and @xmath137,\label{sm1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] that we will denote by @xmath138 , we can write eq.([laeq ] ) as @xmath139,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the integrand of the time - ordered integrals is the product of the retarded time - evolution free - propagators , @xmath140 is the fine - structure constant and @xmath141 is the electron charge .
next , integrating in time we end up with @xmath142}}{(k - k_{a})(k - k_{b})(k'-k)}\nonumber\\&+&\frac{\cos{[(\omega'-\omega_{a})t]}}{(k'-k_{a})(k'-k_{b})(k'-k)}\bigr],\label{sm3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where straightforward application of perturbation theory enforces to taking the principal value ( p.v . ) of the integral in eq.([sm3 ] ) , as intermediate states with energies equal to that of the initial state must be removed from the sums ( integrals in the continuum ) in order to avoid zeros in the denominators , @xmath143 having impossed causality by time - ordering the integrals of eq.([sm2 ] ) and multiplying the integrand by @xmath134 , there is no need to add arbitrarily small imaginary parts @xmath144 to the real poles of the integrand in eq.([sm3 ] ) in order to ensure that the propagators are retarded .
also , we have argued in the letter that spontaneous emission enters at higher order , hence it can not provide imaginary shifts @xmath145 to the real poles of eq.([sm3 ] ) either , in contrast to refs.@xcite .
lastly , the contours of integration for each of the terms of the frequency integrals in the complex plane is univocally determined by the condition @xmath58 .
each term contains complex exponential factors of @xmath93 and @xmath94 of the form @xmath146 , with @xmath147 being generic linear functions of @xmath148 and @xmath13 .
that implies that the integration contours must be closed by infinitely large semi - circles either in the upper half plane for @xmath149 , or in the lower half plane for @xmath150 , which is ultimately determined by the condition @xmath58 .
it is worth mentioning that the integrand of eq.([sm3 ] ) is invariant under the exchange @xmath151 , which implies that the total integral is independent of the order of integration , as expected . and @xmath94 .
] thus , @xmath54 is unambiguously given by eq.([sm3 ] ) .
the final result is given in the eq.(4 ) of the letter .
finally , the causal - adiabatic approximation referred to in the conclusions of the letter corresponds to adding up a factor @xmath152 to the integrand of eq.([sm2 ] ) , with @xmath90 , and to extending the lower limits of the time integrals to @xmath111 . after performing the time
integrals one obtains the @xmath13-independent terms of eq.([sm3 ] ) ( excluding the heaviside function ) with a small imaginary part @xmath153 added to both real poles , @xmath154 we also note that eq.(6 ) in the letter corresponds to the @xmath13-independent terms of eq.([sm3 ] ) of which only the terms proportional to @xmath155 and @xmath156 have been retained in the @xmath157-functions , and in which small imaginary parts @xmath158 have been added to each real pole respectively .
milonni , _ the quantum vacuum _ , academic press , san diego ( 1994 ) . c. cohen - tannoudji , j. dupont - roc and g. grynberg , _ photons and atoms .
introduction to quantum electrodynamics _ , wiley - vch verlag gmbh @xmath159 co. kgaa , weinheim ( 2004 )
. t. juffmann _
et al . _ , nat
. nanotechnol .
* 7 * , 297 ( 2012 ) .
m. saffman , t.g .
walker and k. mlmer , _ rev .
phys . _ * 82 * , 2313 ( 2010 ) .
j. israelachvili , _ intermolecular and surface forces _ , academic press ( 1992 ) .
d.p . craig and t. thirunamachandran , _ molecular quantum electrodynamics _ , dover ed .
, new york ( 1998 ) .
f. london , _ z. phys . _ * 63 * , 245 ( 1930 ) .
casimir and d. polder , _ phys .
_ * 73 * , 360 ( 1948 ) .
h. safari , s.y .
buhmann , d .-
welsch and h. trung - dung , _ _
rev . a__**74 * * , 042101 ( 2006 ) .
wylie and j.e .
sipe , _ _ phys
. rev . a__**30 * * , 1185 ( 1984 ) ; _ _ phys .
rev . a__**32 * * , 2030 ( 1985 ) .
s. scheel and s.y .
buhmann , _ acta phys .
slov . _ * 58 * 675 ( 2004 ) .
gorza and m. ducloy , _ _ eur .
j. d__**40 * * ( 2006 ) 343 .
m. donaire , _ _ phys
. rev . a__**83 * * , 022502 ( 2011 ) ; _ _ phys .
rev . a__**85 * * , 052518 ( 2012 ) .
e.a . power and t.
thirunamachandran , _ _ phys
. rev . a__**51 * * , 3660 ( 1995 ) .
mclone and e.a .
power , _ _ proc .
r. soc . a__**286 * * , 573 ( 1965 ) .
l. gomberoff , r.r .
mclone and e.a .
_ * 44 * , 4148 ( 1966 ) .
y. sherkunov , _ _ phys
. rev . a__**72 * * , 052703 ( 2005 ) .
haakh , j. schiefele and c. henkel , _ int . j. mod
: conf . ser . _
* 14 * , 347 ( 2012 ) .
h. safari and m.r .
karimpour , _ phys .
* 114 * , 013201 ( 2015 ) .
l. rizzuto , r. passante and f. persico , _
rev . a__**70 * * , 012107 ( 2004 ) .
berman , _ _ phys .
rev . a__**91 * * , 042127 ( 2015 ) .
some of the diagrams of fig.([fig1 ] ) discarded provide also terms with poles in both @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
however , after integrated in frequencies , they yield contributions of the order of @xmath160 times smaller than the ones found here , and hence they are negligible . for instance , in diagram @xmath161 this is due to its lack of resonance with the transition of atom @xmath4 , since both photons are simply resonant .
sakurai , _ advanced quantum mechanics _
, additon - wesley ( 1994 ) .
berman and b. dubetsky , _ _ phys .
rev . a__**55 * * , 4060 ( 1997 ) .
_ , _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 91 * , 213602 ( 2003 ) .
_ , _ phys .
lett . _ * 92 * , 223602 ( 2004 ) . | we present a time - dependent quantum calculation of the van der waals interaction between a pair of dissimilar atoms , one of which is initially excited while the other one is in its ground state . for small detuning ,
the interaction is predominantly mediated at all distances by the exchange of doubly resonant photons between the two atoms .
we find that it presents both temporal and spatial oscillations .
spatially oscillating terms depend on the resonant frequencies of both atoms , while the frequency of the time oscillations is given by their detuning .
we analyse the physical content of our findings and discuss to what extent previous conflicting stationary approaches provide compatible results .
a proper account of causality is found essential in order to obtain the correct result .
dispersion forces between neutral atoms are often interpreted as a result of the quantum fluctuation of both the electromagnetic ( em ) field and the atomic charges @xcite .
a prominent example of those are van der waals ( vdw ) forces acting between neutral atoms and molecules , which are important in atomic and molecular interferometry where they influence the measured interference pattern @xcite . in quantum information ,
vdw forces between rydberg atoms produce a rydberg blockade which may be exploited to realize quantum gates @xcite . in biophysical and chemical processes
vdw forces are known to play a crucial role for the stability and assembling of molecules @xcite .
+ at zero temperature , two atoms in their ground states undergo a series of virtual transitions to upper levels .
it is the coupling of the charges of each atom to the quantum em field that induces the correlation between their transient dipole moments , giving rise to a non - vanishing vdw interaction .
the lifetime of the virtual atomic transitions is very short in comparison to ordinary observation times and thus , the use of stationary quantum perturbation theory is well justified for the calculation of this interaction @xcite . for short interatomic distances
@xmath0 in comparison to the relevant transition wavelengths ( non - retarded regime ) the interaction scales as @xmath1 , while for large distances ( retarded regime ) it goes like @xmath2 @xcite .
+ the situation is different for excited atoms .
first , excited states are unstable and present finite lifetimes .
this implies that , generically , the interaction between excited atoms must depend on time .
second , if any of the transitions from the excited to lower atomic levels is relevant to the interaction , the exchange of resonant photons between the atoms must be considered .
the energy of the interaction mediated by resonant photons is usually referred to as _ resonant van der waals potential _ in the literature @xcite . in the retarded regime
the resonant potential overtakes by far the non - resonant one .
it is in this regime that different approaches yield conflicting results concerning the spatial oscillations of the interaction @xcite .
this long - standing problem is the main motivation of the present letter . in the following ,
we address the time - dependent quantum computation of the interaction between two dissimilar atomic dipoles , one of which is excited .
the excited atom is taken of type @xmath3 while the atom in its ground state is considered of a different type @xmath4 . without loss of generality
we approximate the atoms by two - level systems of resonant frequencies @xmath5 and @xmath6 respectively , with respective linewidths @xmath7 and @xmath8 .
further , in order to ensure the perturbative nature of the calculation and to avoid resonant energy transfer we set the detuning @xmath9 such that @xmath10 and @xmath11 , with @xmath12 being the interaction hamiltonian at the time of observation , @xmath13 . since the observation is made for atom @xmath3 excited , we must have @xmath14 .
lastly , we assume without much loss of generality @xmath15 , which is easily met by pairs of alkali atoms
. we will refer to this condition as _ quasi - resonant_. we will see that it allows for a great reduction in the number of calculations and makes the resonant potential dominant at all distances .
we will show that the interaction energy oscillates both in time and in space .
it contains time - independent terms which oscillate in space with frequency @xmath16 , and time - dependent terms which oscillate in time with frequency @xmath17 and in space with frequency @xmath18 .
we compare our results to previous conflicting approaches and discuss in detail to which extent they provide compatible results .
we aim at computing the em energy of atom @xmath3 due to the presence of atom @xmath4 . to this end
we apply standard time - dependent quantum perturbative techniques in the electric dipole approximation @xcite . at
any given time @xmath13 the state of the two - atom - vacuum system can be written as @xmath19 , where the state of the system at time 0 is @xmath20 . in this expression
@xmath21 label the upper / lower internal states of the atoms @xmath3 and @xmath4 respectively and @xmath22 is the em vacuum state .
@xmath23 denotes the time evolution operator in the schrdinger representation , @xmath24\bigr\}.\nonumber\ ] ] in this equation @xmath25 is the free hamiltonian of the internal atomic states , @xmath26 , while the hamiltonian of the free em field is @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the photon frequency , and the operators @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the creation and annihilation operators of photons with momentum @xmath31 and polarization @xmath32 respectively .
finally , the interaction hamiltonian reads @xmath33 , with @xmath34 . in this expression @xmath35
are the electric dipole operators of each atom and @xmath36 is the electric field operator evaluated at the position of each atom , which can be written in the usual manner as a sum over normal modes as @xcite @xmath37,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath38 is a generic volume and @xmath39 denote the annihilation / creation electric field operators of photons of momentum @xmath31 , respectively .
while the internal atomic and em degrees of freedom are quantum variables , the position vectors @xmath40 are classical variables .
we emphasize here that we do not make further simplifications to these potentials . in particular , we do not replace the em response of any of the atoms by its ordinary polarizability , as it is the case in ref.@xcite .
next , considering @xmath41 as a perturbation to the free hamiltonians , the unperturbed time - evolution operator for atom and free photon states is @xmath42}$ ] . in order to make contact with a realistic setup
, we imagine that atom @xmath3 starts being excited at time @xmath43 by a laser pulse of duration @xmath44 .
this fixes our temporal resolution and implies that at time @xmath45 the initial state @xmath46 is well - defined within a time interval of the order of @xmath47 .
we are now ready to compute the em energy of atom @xmath3 due to the presence of atom @xmath4 at any time @xmath13 such that @xmath48,@xmath49 the above expression admits an expansion in powers of @xmath41 which can be developed out of the time - ordered exponential equation for @xmath23 , @xmath50 . at leading order , eq.([force ] ) contains a series of terms of fourth order in @xmath41 where an electric field operator creates / annihilates a photon at time @xmath13 at the position of atom @xmath3 .
they correspond to the twelve well - known time - ordered diagrams of fig.[fig1 ] @xcite . in the time - dependent approach
, each diagram contributes to @xmath51 with two terms in which @xmath52 is flanked by two @xmath53-matrices which make the system evolve , in opposite time directions , from the initial state to two different states at time @xmath13 , which differ from one another in the state of atom @xmath3 and in the number of photons by one unit . at the lowest order in @xmath41 . the time variable runs along the vertical.,width=336,height=128 ] in quasi - resonant conditions , the greatest contribution to @xmath54 comes from diagram @xmath55 , in which two doubly resonant photons are exchanged one after the other .
doubly resonant photons are those emitted by one of the atoms in its upper level and absorbed by the other atom in its lower level , while for non - resonant photons the emission / absorpsion processes are inverted .
lastly , simply resonant photons are those emitted and absorbed by both atoms in either their upper or lower levels .
in addition , the diagrams @xmath56 of fig.[fig1 ] , which contain both doubly resonant and non - resonant photons , provide terms which make it possible to extend the frequency integrals of diagram @xmath55 into the negative domain .
their contribution is indeed essential for establishing causality ( cf .
ref.@xcite ) .
all the other contributions from these and from the rest of diagrams are at the most of the order of @xmath57 times smaller and hence negligible .
putting everything together , transforming the sums over photon momenta into continuum integrals and imposing the causality condition @xmath58 with @xmath59 , we find at leading order , @xmath60+[k\leftrightarrow k']^{\dagger}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the time integrals of the time - evolution operators in eq.([laeq ] ) yield a series of terms with poles along the real axis , @xmath61}}{(k - k_{a})(k - k_{b})(k'-k)}+\frac{\cos{[(\omega'-\omega_{a})t]}}{(k'-k_{a})(k'-k_{b})(k'-k)}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] further , the development of this expression contains terms in which both photons resonate either with the transition of atom @xmath3 or with the transition of atom @xmath4 only .
this is a direct consequence of energy conservation . upon integration in frequencies ,
the former terms are time - independent while the latter oscillate in time as @xmath62 .
important is the fact that only the first term in eq.([poles ] ) arises in the stationary approach @xcite .
however , the integration in frequencies of the third and fourth terms provides additional time - independent contributions which are missing in the stationary approach .
lastly , replacing the time integrals in eq.([laeq ] ) with the result ( [ poles ] ) and integrating in orientations and frequencies , we obtain see appendix , @xmath63\cos{(2k_{a}r)}+\frac{2\mathcal{u}_{ijpq}}{r^{5}}k_{a}[\beta^{ij}\beta^{pq}\nonumber\\ & -k_{a}^{2}r^{2}\alpha^{ij}\beta^{pq}]\sin{(2k_{a}r)}\label{tdep}\\ & -\frac{\mathcal{u}_{ijpq}}{r^{6}}[\beta^{ij}\beta^{pq}-k_{b}^{2}r^{2}(\beta^{ij}\beta^{pq}+2\alpha^{ij}\beta^{pq})\nonumber\\ & + k_{b}^{4}r^{4}\alpha^{ij}\alpha^{pq}]\cos{(2k_{b}r+\delta_{ab}t ) } -\frac{2\mathcal{u}_{ijpq}}{r^{5}}k_{b}\nonumber\\ & \times[\beta^{ij}\beta^{pq}-k_{b}^{2}r^{2}\alpha^{ij}\beta^{pq}]\sin{(2k_{b}r+\delta_{ab}t)}\nonumber\\ & + \frac{\mathcal{u}_{ijpq}}{r^{6}}[1+ ... +(k_{a , b}r)^{4}]\mathcal{o}(\delta_{ab}/\omega_{a , b})+ ... ,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath64 $ ] , @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 , @xmath68 .
it is worth stressing that the heaviside function in eq.([laeq ] ) together with the time - order prescription do not only guarantee causality , but also determine univocally the contours of integration over frequencies in the complex plane when taking the principal value ( see appendix ) .
the last term in eq.([tdep ] ) indicates the order of the leading corrections to the dominant doubly resonant photon exchange terms of eq.([laeq ] ) @xcite . as anticipated , the time - independent terms of eq.([tdep ] )
oscillate only in space with frequency @xmath69 .
on the contrary , the time - dependent terms oscillate in time with frequency @xmath17 and in space with frequency @xmath70 . only for large integration times , @xmath71 , their time average vanishes . in the short time
limit , @xmath72 , @xmath54 vanishes identically at our order of approximation .
this is a consequence of the fact that , in order to establish the interaction , it is necessary that the excitation be transferred actually to atom @xmath4 . for @xmath73 , the probability of excitation of atom @xmath4 oscillates in time as @xmath74/2]}$ ] , being maximum for the first time at @xmath75 .
correspondingly , @xmath54 becomes maximum for the first time at @xmath76 .
the lapse @xmath77 between these two times is the time for a photon to travel back from @xmath78 to @xmath79 after the excitation of atom @xmath4 .
a long - standing debate exists in the literature concerning the spatial oscillations of the two - atom interaction in the retarded regime when one of the atoms is excited @xcite .
the existence of spatial oscillations is indeed supported by experiments @xcite . according to our findings , for @xmath80 and @xmath58 , the interaction oscillates both in time and in space as @xmath81\nonumber\\ & \simeq\frac{-2\mathcal{u}_{ijpq}}{r^{2}}\alpha^{ij}\alpha^{pq}k_{a}^{4}\sin{[\delta_{ab}(r / c - t/2)]}\nonumber\\ & \times\sin{[k_{a}(r+ct/2)+k_{b}(r - ct/2)]}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the last expression we read that , at fixed time
, the interaction is modulated by long - range oscillations of frequency @xmath82 , while short - range oscillations take place at frequency @xmath83 . also as a function of time
the interaction is modulated by oscillations of frequency @xmath17 . in fig.[fig3 ] we plot the energy of the interaction between two alkali atoms , one of @xmath84rb which is excited to the state @xmath85 and another one of @xmath86k which is in its ground state , in the retarded regime .
in contrast to our result , the stationary approach of power and thirunamachandran in ref.@xcite predicts no oscillations for @xmath87 in the far field .
the key point in their calculation is the addition of small imaginary parts to the resonant frequency of atom @xmath3 in such a way that poles get shifted off the real axis .
they used the prescription that a positive / negative imaginary part must be added for emitted / absorbed photons in order to account for the finite linewidth of the excited atom .
in particular , for @xmath88 the dominant term in their stationary calculation is the first one in eq.([poles ] ) , but with the real poles shifted as @xmath89^{-1}$ ] , @xmath90 . after integrating in orientations an analogous equation to eq.([laeq ] ) @xcite , they must have obtained for the energy in the far field limit , @xmath91 , @xmath92 with @xmath90 . since the pole in @xmath93 lies on the upper half of the complex plane and the pole in @xmath94 lies on the lower half , the only nonvanishing contribution to the above integral comes from the term proportional to @xmath95 . as the real part of the poles is in both cases @xmath96 , taking the limit @xmath90 the exponent vanishes after evaluating the residues and the integral yields the non - oscillating result @xmath97 .
rb atom in state @xmath85 @xmath98@xmath99 and a @xmath86k atom in its ground state , for @xmath91
. the black line corresponds to a snapshot of the interaction at time @xmath100s , where the contributions of the d1 and d2 transition lines of the @xmath86k atom ( @xmath101@xmath102 and @xmath103@xmath102 respectively ) add up approximately in - phase .
a long - range period @xmath104 , with @xmath105 , is identified .
the red line corresponds to the time - independent result of the causal - adiabatic approximation .
average over dipole orientations has been taken.,width=291,height=158 ] in the previous stationary calculation of mclone and power @xcite and gomberoff _ et al .
_ @xcite the poles in eq.([wad ] ) were not shifted . as a result ,
when taking the principal value of the integrals in eq.([wad ] ) with @xmath106 , the four exponentials in the numerator contribute as @xmath107 after adding up the residues , yielding the oscillating result @xmath108 . as mentioned after eq.([poles ] ) , some time - independent terms are missing in the stationary calculation , which explains the discrepancy of this result with the time - independent component of ours in eq.([ff ] ) .
in fact , the correct time - independent result can be obtained by switching on adibatically the interaction potential , @xmath41 , within the time - dependent causal approach .
that is , by replacing @xmath109 in eq.([laeq ] ) with @xmath110 , @xmath90 , and extending the lower limit of the time integrals to @xmath111see appendix .
this results in an equation analogous to eq.([wad ] ) but with both poles shifted along the imaginary axis in the same direction an amount @xmath112 , which yields @xmath113 for @xmath91 .
recently , safari and karimpour have published a letter @xcite where they claim to obtain for @xmath91 the same oscillating behaviour as gomberoff _
et al .
_ @xcite . however , a straightforward comparison of eq.(19 ) of ref.@xcite and eqs.(14,26 ) of ref .
@xcite reveals that this is indeed not the case . whereas the result of the latter is the one outlined above , @xmath114 , the authors of the former have found @xmath115 , despite the fact that both approaches are based on fourth order stationary perturbation theory .
the origin of the discrepancy is in the algebraic manipulation inherited by the authors of ref.@xcite from ref.@xcite . in the appendix b of ref.@xcite
the authors have tried to express the total contribution of the twelve diagrams of fig.[fig1 ] as a single frequency integral whose integrand is a function of the ordinary polarizabilities of the two atoms . in doing so by means of eq.(b2 ) of ref.@xcite ,
the authors have replaced effectively the denominator of eq.([wad ] ) , which is a symmetric and separable function of @xmath93 and @xmath116 for @xmath106 , by the expression @xmath117^{-1}[1/(k'-k)+1/(k'+k)]$ ] , which is neither symmetric nor separable . as a consequence , that replacement makes the frequency integrals depend arbitrarily on the order of integration .
next , integrating in @xmath94 first and in @xmath93 later , one obtains @xmath113 , which agrees with eq.(19 ) of ref.@xcite for @xmath91 , @xmath88 , upon averaging in atomic orientations .
interestingly , this result equals the time - independent term of eq.([ff ] ) .
however , this coincidence can only be accidental , since the above replacement and the subsequent prescription on the order of integration are neither connected to the time - dependent terms of eq.([poles ] ) which cause the actual discrepancy with respect to the result of refs.@xcite nor to the causal - adiabatic approximation .
it is worth noting that while we have invoked the existence of finite lifetimes @xmath118 in order to impose physical constraints on the detuning @xmath17 and on the observation time @xmath13 , no explicit reference to these quantities appear in our expression for @xmath54 . as a matter of fact
, only the emission through the exchange of resonant photons between the two atoms has been implicitly accounted for in our calculation of @xmath54 .
however , our calculation lacks the inclusion of the spontaneous emission of each atom into free space , whose rates are @xmath119 , respectively .
the processes corresponding to the latter phenomenon are generally unimportant in comparison to those depicted in fig.[fig1 ] since their leading contribution to @xmath54 is of order @xmath120 @xmath121 see fig.[fig2 ]
. they might only be relevant for the case that the lifetimes are of the order of the temporal frequency of the interaction , @xmath122 , but they can not affect in any case the oscillatory behaviour found here for the terms of order @xmath123 .
this argument opposes to the reasons given in ref.@xcite to add imaginary shifts to the real poles at @xmath124 .
we finalize by mentioning that berman has shown in a recent publication @xcite how to introuduce spontaneous emission in a consistent manner in an adiabatic approximation . assuming that atom @xmath3 is excited adiabatically with @xmath125 , he has obtained the correct time - independent result .
in this letter we have shown that the van der waals interaction between two dissimilar atoms , one of which is initially prepared in an excited state , presents generically oscillations both in time and in space . in quasi - resonant conditions
the interaction is dominated at all distances by the exchange of doubly resonant photons between the two atoms .
it is modulated in space by long - range oscillations of frequency @xmath82 , while short - range oscillations take place at frequency @xmath83 .
the time frequency is @xmath17 , which determines the rate at which the excitation is transferred to atom @xmath4 . in the retarded regime
the interaction takes the form of eq.([ff ] ) . only for large integration times , @xmath71 ,
that expression reduces to a time - independent term which oscillates in space with frequency @xmath69 .
the latter is also equivalent to the result of the causal - adiabatic approximations ( see appendix and ref.@xcite ) .
it does not agree , however , with the result of stationary perturbation theory @xcite . which incorporate in the calculation of @xmath54 the effect of photon emission into free space .
in @xmath126 and @xmath127 the photon @xmath128 is emitted into free space from atom @xmath3 , whereas in @xmath129 it is emitted from atom @xmath4.,width=309,height=83 ] we thank paul berman and marie - pascale gorza for fruitful discussions . financial support from anr-10-idex-0001 - 02-psl and anr-13-bs040003 - 02 is gratefully acknowledged . |
the evolving populations in galaxy clusters offer a unique opportunity to directly observe galaxy evolution , and particularly the effects of environment on star forming galaxies .
present - day rich clusters have strikingly different populations from galaxies in poorer environments , suggesting that some mechanism is at work on the cluster population which is absent in the lives of normal field galaxies .
the first clues towards understanding the evolution of the cluster population came more than 20 years ago , with the discovery that higher redshift clusters have a larger fraction of blue galaxies than those at the present epoch : the butcher - oemler effect ( butcher & oemler 1978 , 1984 ) .
these purely photometric results were confirmed spectroscopically ( e.g. , dressler & gunn 1982 , 1992 ; lavery & henry 1986 ; fabricant , mcclintock & bautz 1991 ) and populations of both star forming and recently post - star formation galaxies in moderate redshift clusters have been identified ( i.e. , the balmer - strong h-@xmath5 or k@xmath6a galaxies ; dressler & gunn 1982 ; couch & sharples 1987 ; poggianti 1999 ) .
many subsequent investigations have focused on the details of how these galaxies are transformed into the population seen in clusters today ( couch & sharples 1987 ; barger 1996 ; poggianti 1999 ; balogh 1999 , b99 hereafter ) .
the emerging picture is that there may be a population of galaxies which were formed very early in the cluster s history , corresponding to the ellipticals often seen in cluster cores ( e.g. , bower , lucey & ellis 1992 ; ellis 1997 ; gladders et al .
1998 ; kelson 2000 ; van dokkum 1998 ) .
subsequent generations of infalling field galaxies have had their star formation disrupted , possibly with an associated starburst . as this transformation progresses ,
these galaxies might be identified with normal - looking spirals , then galaxies with strong balmer absorption spectra , and finally s0 galaxies which have retained some of their disk structure but have ceased active star formation ( dressler 1997 ) . despite these advances ,
a number of questions remain about the evolution of cluster galaxies and the butcher - oemler phenomenon .
recently , there have been several challenges to the existence of the butcher - oemler effect as a universal pattern which equally affects all classes of clusters ( andreon 1998 ; andreon & ettori 1999 ; smail 1998 ; jones , smail & couch 2000 ) .
the original distant cluster samples which were investigated are a heterogeneous mixture of clusters found by optical signatures or by their association with a strong active galactic nucleus . in many cases , cluster masses or richnesses
are still not well determined due to the difficulty of obtaining robust velocity dispersions , and there is a possibility of significant substructure in some objects .
more recently , x - ray selected clusters , which in part overlap with optically - selected clusters but on average may be more massive or more relaxed , have been investigated . in several cases ( smail 1998 ; b99 ) , the incidence of blue or post - star forming galaxies has been found to be significantly less than that of previous samples .
thus , a worrisome question remains as to how the observed galaxy populations relate to the more global properties of the clusters , such as mass and dynamical state , as well as the cluster sample selection method .
even if clusters do contain a higher fraction of star forming galaxies at higher redshifts , a second fundamental question is whether this blue population represents a true increase in the average star formation in these galaxies over the properties of galaxies in the coeval field
. a significant fraction of galaxies in some spectroscopic surveys have been found to be starbursts or have balmer lines strong enough to signify a previous starburst encompassing 10 - 30% of the galaxy mass ( lavery & henry 1988 ; barger 1996 ; poggianti 1999 ) .
this suggests that temporary episodes of excess star formation are associated with a galaxy s tenure in the cluster . however , balogh ( 1997 , b99 ) found no evidence for excess star formation in a sample of luminous x - ray selected clusters , as the generally smaller numbers of starburst and post - starburst galaxies could be explained by galaxies infalling from the field .
thus , they conclude that the cluster environment works only in the direction of suppressing star formation .
the differences in these results may be partially ascribed to differences in the selection technique for the galaxies observed and identified in both cluster and field ; but some of the discrepancy may come from true differences in the cluster samples . here
we describe an investigation of the relationship between galaxy evolution and cluster structure , based on a well - defined and homogeneous sample of clusters at @xmath7 and coeval field galaxy measurements .
photometry and spectroscopy from the canadian network for observational cosmology cluster redshift survey ( cnoc1 ; yee , ellingson & carlberg 1996 ) were used to construct a sample of cluster galaxies and the properties of their stellar population .
field galaxy measurements from the cnoc2 field galaxy survey ( yee 2000 ) were used to accurately determine the properties of field galaxies at these redshifts .
we present both a classical measure of the cluster blue fraction determined from spectroscopically confirmed cluster members and a spectral principal component analysis ( pca ) which delineates the relative fractions of starlight from different stellar populations . in an approach complementary to that of looking at individual galaxy properties in detail , we focus on building smooth composite spatial distributions of the various stellar populations . with these distributions
, it is possible to explore the relationship between the evolution of galaxy populations and the growth and evolution of the cluster .
in 2 of this paper we present the data and in 3 we discuss the blue fraction measurements .
we describe the principal component analysis method and tests of its accuracy from galaxies of known spectral type in 4 . in 5 we present the results based on composite radial distributions of the average pca components .
we discuss the results and their implications for scenarios of galaxy population evolution in rich clusters in 6 .
our conclusions are summarized in 7 . throughout this paper @xmath8=0.1 and @xmath9=100 km
s@xmath10 mpc@xmath10 are used .
the cnoc1 cluster redshift survey targeted 16 rich x - ray luminous galaxy clusters with @xmath11 .
the clusters range in velocity dispersion from about 600 to 1200 km s@xmath10 , with @xmath12 erg s@xmath10 .
deep gunn @xmath13 and @xmath14 imaging and multi - slit spectroscopic observations from the canada - france - hawaii 3.6 m telescope were used to map the cluster sample to radii of 13 @xmath15 mpc from the cluster cores .
wavelength coverage was @xmath16 in the rest frame of each cluster , with a resolution of about 15 .
this wavelength range samples the important features of [ oii ] emission , the 4000 break , ca[ii ] h and k and the balmer lines h@xmath17 and higher .
a total of @xmath18 1200 cluster galaxies were spectroscopically identified . the cnoc1 cluster ms0906 + 11
was omitted from this analysis because it shows strong binary substructure in both x - ray and velocity data , and robust values for dynamical parameters were not possible .
particular care was taken to quantify selection effects and the completeness of the sample as a function of galaxy magnitude , color , redshift and position .
for each galaxy , a completeness measure was empirically calculated for its apparent magnitude , position within the cluster and @xmath19 color ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 ; see yee 1996 for details ) .
these values reflect our selection criteria for spectroscopy , as well as empirical success rates , and their inverses are used as weighting functions to build a representative sample of cluster properties .
the largest factor in these weights is due to apparent magnitude , and the color selection effect is very small .
the wide field coverage and careful attention to the empirical selection functions are crucial for building an accurate portrait of cluster structure .
we note that cnoc1 chose a relatively simple selection criterion based only upon galaxy apparent magnitude and position ; for comparison , the morphs clusters observed by dressler ( 1999 ) were chosen by a combination of magnitude , position and morphology / color in order to concentrate observations on the non - passive population . as a result ,
the overlap between the several clusters the cnoc and morphs samples have in common is actually minimal
ms 0016 + 16 has an overlap of only 7 cluster galaxies ( ellingson 1998 ) .
dynamical and spatial analyses of the clusters ( carlberg 1996 ; carlberg , yee & ellingson 1997 , cye hereafter ; carlberg 1997a , b ) yielded cluster masses , mass - to - light ratios and density profiles . in particular , we adopt their dynamically - determined values for @xmath1 , the radius within which the average cluster density is 200 times the critical density .
this radius averages 1.17 @xmath15 mpc for the sample ; virial radii are 1.52 @xmath1 .
lewis ( 1999 ) presented the x - ray gas profiles from rosat hri and pspc observations of much of the sample , finding that dynamical and x - ray measurements of the cluster masses are in excellent agreement .
balogh ( 1997 , b99 ) analyzed spectral line indices for cluster galaxies in a classical approach to galaxy evolution which is complementary to the approach used here .
whereas line indices give detailed information about star formation histories in individual galaxies , here we use a pca decomposition as a broader measure of galaxy properties to create smooth distributions of starlight in populations at several different ages .
these measurements are then combined with the dynamical and x - ray properties of the clusters to address the issue of galaxy evolution in terms of the spatial distribution of different populations .
the first indication of evolution in cluster populations came from purely photometric measurements of the fraction of blue galaxies , , in the clusters ( butcher & oemler 1978 ) .
the original definition of was based on the fraction of galaxies in a cluster which are more than 0.2 mag bluer in @xmath22 than the early - type galaxies .
the galaxies are counted to an absolute magnitude of @xmath23 within the radius @xmath24 , which encompasses 30% of the cluster galaxies . while the butcher - oemler effect is clearly seen in many clusters , this purely photometric measure can be affected by the significant fraction of field galaxies found within the counting radius .
the cnoc1 survey provides a dataset from which one can derive for a substantial sample of spectroscopically - confirmed cluster members , without having to perform background corrections .
here we use similar but not identical definitions to compute for the cnoc1 clusters , using the spectroscopically confirmed cluster galaxies only , and for a range of absolute magnitude and radius parameters .
we define the dividing line between blue and red galaxies relative to the observed color of the cluster red sequence .
this guards against possible systematic errors in our color measurements .
on the @xmath19 vs @xmath14 diagram we fit the color magnitude relation for the early - type galaxies using a least absolute deviation ( lad ) algorithm ( press 1992 ) with iterative rejection .
the fit is performed using galaxies inside 1/2 @xmath1 to maximize the prominence of the red - sequence .
since the lad algorithm can be unstable , the fit is examined by eye to ensure a good fit . in a few instances where there are either too few galaxies defining the red - sequence or the red - sequence has too wide a dispersion compared to its magnitude range
, an eye - fitted cmr is used .
blue galaxies are defined as galaxies bluer than half the @xmath19 color difference ( in the observed bands ) between the e / s0 and sbc sed , where the seds are computed from the templates of coleman , wu & weedman ( 1980 ) ; i.e. , the dividing line between blue and red galaxies is half way between the colors of an e / s0 and sbc galaxy .
this corresponds to @xmath25 of 0.21 to 0.28 mag , depending on the cluster redshift .
the original criterion of @xmath26 mag ( corrected to z=0 ) is similar , in that it corresponds to @xmath18 2/3 of the difference between the colors of an e / s0 and sbc galaxy .
it should be noted that is strictly computed based on the photometric properties of the galaxies , regardless of the spectroscopic classification .
the only spectroscopic information that is used is the redshift , which defines a galaxy as a cluster member . for the primary values , we count galaxies within the redshift limits defined for each cluster as presented in table 1 of carlberg ( 1996 ) to a k- and evolution - corrected absolute magnitude of @xmath27 , or the spectroscopic magnitude limit ( cye ) , whichever is brighter .
k - corrections are calculated from coleman ( 1980 ) and the evolution assumed is @xmath28 .
all but three clusters out of 15 ( ms0015 + 16 , ms0451 - 03 , and ms1006 + 12 ) have spectroscopic limits which are within 0.5 mag of 19.0 mag .
the counting radius is @xmath1 .
the galaxies are weighted as described in 2 above , and error bars are computed using simple root @xmath29 statistics . as a comparison to the original definition of , the @xmath27 limit is slightly brighter ( equivalent to @xmath30 ) , and the average radius of 1.17 h@xmath10 mpc for @xmath1 , is typically a factor of 2 or more larger than @xmath24 .
the results are plotted in three panels in figure 1 as vs @xmath31 .
figure 1a shows the strong correlation of vs redshift , with a range of between 0.1 to 0.4 , similar to that obtained by butcher & oemler ( 1984 ) .
the dashed line represents the best fit to the data , with a slope of 0.62 @xmath32 0.14 . to test the effects of the galaxy sample selection limits
, we also computed values using the criteria of a sampling radius of @xmath1 and @xmath33 , as well as 0.5@xmath1 and @xmath34 ( figures 1b and 1c ) .
the former test is important to verify that the somewhat uneven absolute magnitude limits of the primary sample do not have a significant influence on the values , as typically the higher the redshift of the cluster , the higher the probability that it is not sampled to 19.0 mag .
figure 1b indicates that and the butcher - oemler effect do not depend critically on on the luminosity of the galaxies .
sampling to a limit one magnitude brighter produces mostly additional scatter in the results the average value for is essentially identical with an average ratio of 1 .
sampling to a smaller radius ( figure 1c ) , however , appears to produce a significant effect .
when sampling only to a radius of 1/2 r@xmath35 , the blue fraction drops by an average of 20% ( a 2@xmath36 result ) , and the butcher - oemler effect appears to be mostly obliterated , in that most clusters ( with the exception of ms045103 ) have very similar values , regardless of their redshift .
it appears that the cores of clusters do not evolve significantly in their populations , and that the butcher - oemler effect is caused by changes in populations at radii well outside of the cluster cores .
this result immediately hints at the possibility of strong and evolving population gradients in galaxy clusters , and also explains some of the discrepant results from estimates of which have relied on data from only the cluster cores ( e.g. , smail 1998 ) .
principal component analysis ( pca ) provides a sensitive method for measuring the strengths of different stellar populations from spectroscopic data .
this technique has been used by various groups ( e.g. , connolly 1995 ; zaritsky , zabludoff & willick 1995 ; bromley 1998 ; folkes 1999 ) to determine galaxy populations .
it is especially applicable to the faint , high redshift galaxies observed in the cnoc1 survey , because the entire spectrum , rather than a narrowly defined range of line indices , contributes to the measurement .
we use the relatively high signal - to - noise galaxy spectra taken from the las campanas redshift survey ( lcrs ; shectman 1996 ) to derive our pca basis vectors .
the method employed is the same as that described in detail by bromley ( 1998 ) in their lcrs spectral classification analysis ; here we give only a very brief summary .
the lcrs spectra are first renormalized , de - redshifted to the rest - frame wavelength range 3500 - 5500 , and then effectively continuum subtracted by high - pass filtering .
the resulting catalog of spectra is then put into matrix form , upon which we apply singular value decomposition ( svd ; see e.g. , press 1992 ) in order to derive the set of orthonormal vectors , here galaxy spectra , which will then form the basis in our principal component analysis .
the original lcrs analysis finds four significant pca basis vectors , which correspond roughly to an `` elliptical '' component showing the standard old - population features , two `` emission '' components exhibiting [ oii ] @xmath373727 and [ oiii ] @xmath384959,5007 emission lines typical of star formation , and a `` balmer '' component featuring strong balmer absorption lines indicative of intermediate age stars . in this paper
we combine the two original emission components into a single vector because our cnoc1 spectra generally do not extend to the h@xmath39/[oiii ] region .
we plot in figure 2 the resulting three orthonormal pca basis vectors used in the analysis of our cnoc spectra .
we use a standard linear least - squares technique to decompose each spectrum into the best - fit linear combination of the three orthonormal pca basis vectors . at the same time
, we also fit a 7th - order legendre polynomial to each spectrum in order to account for the continuum , as the pca basis was derived originally from continuum - subtracted data .
the fits are done in observed - frame wavelengths , and we use simple linear interpolation to compute flux values for the basis vectors at the appropriate redshifted wavelengths . in effect , we are writing each continuum - subtracted spectrum , @xmath40 , as a linear combination of the three pca basis vectors @xmath41 , @xmath42 , \ ] ] where @xmath37 is the wavelength , @xmath31 is the galaxy redshift , and the @xmath43 are the best - fit pca coefficients .
we further renormalize the @xmath43 according to @xmath44 so that the @xmath45 form a measure of the fractional luminosity - weighted contribution of each pca basis vector to the galaxy spectrum in question .
the set of @xmath45 thus provides a measurement of the stellar population for each galaxy , and we will typically refer to the @xmath45 as the pca components .
the combination of these three pca components is adequate to separate most types of normal galaxies .
figure 3 shows pca components for galaxies in the kennicutt spectrophotometric atlas of low - redshift galaxies ( kennicutt 1992 ) .
normal elliptical and spiral galaxies are well separated on this plot .
our chosen normalization requires that the data points lie within the lower left triangle of the plot : a pure elliptical " spectrum will be located at the origin .
note that the kennicutt atlas does not populate the region of the plot with large balmer values and low emission - line values . in this region
we plot high signal - to - noise examples of k@xmath6a ( post - star formation ) galaxies from the cnoc1 clusters as identified by standard line indices ( e.g. , barger 1996 ; poggianti 1999 ; b99 ) to illustrate the properties of these important cluster galaxies .
we estimate uncertainties in the pca components , @xmath45 , as follows .
we start with the formal uncertainties in the @xmath45 returned by the linear least - squares fit , and check these error estimates using the 1164 cnoc2 ( yee 2000 ) galaxies for which we have two independent spectra available for pca fits .
we compare the actual differences in the @xmath45 to their formal errors , and we find that the main effect is that the formal errors are underestimates at @xmath46 , but overestimates at larger @xmath45 .
we thus empirically rescale the formal uncertainties in order to match the observed @xmath45 differences , and as we have a large set of redundant spectral observations , we can readily do this rescaling as a function of @xmath45 for each of the three pca components .
the typical correction factors to the original formal errors are @xmath47 for @xmath46 , and @xmath48 at larger @xmath45 . for our data ,
negative values are allowed for any of the components , in order to retain statistical robustness and to provide an additional check on uncertainties .
our average spectra have uncertainties on the order of 0.010.15 in each component .
large negative values are absent , with the exception of a small number of galaxies with negative `` emission '' components .
these stem from large noise spikes at the blue end of some of the lower redshift galaxies being mistaken for ( negative ) [ oii ] emission , and are usually accompanied by large estimated uncertainties .
we note that these galaxies also have large negative [ oii ] equivalent widths and large uncertainties as reported by b99 .
the `` emission '' component is most sensitive to this type of error because we typically sample only one strong emission feature in our spectral range ; as such , it is most closely analogous to a single line index measurement
. unfortunately , such errors , when combined with our normalization scheme , can also strongly affect the other components .
because of this , galaxies with values less than @xmath49 in any component are individually examined , and if a single noise feature is implicated in a negative emission component , the emission component is set to zero and the other components renormalized accordingly .
comparison of galaxy colors and line indices versus pca components , for galaxies which have undergone this correction versus those which have cleaner blue spectral regions , show no systematic effects .
pca values were also checked against the classical line indices from b99 ( figure 4 ) . the expected correlations between emission " and [ oii ] and between balmer " and h@xmath5 are seen , with variations within the uncertainties .
note that the correlations are not required to pass through the origin , as the pca components are based on relative powers of many lines .
the pca analysis was able to extract usable values for about 15% more galaxies than the line indices , and , in general , uncertainties were slightly smaller relative to the range of values observed ( i.e. , 2 uncertainty was typical for h-@xmath5 , which has about a 10 true range in the sample ; the pca component has a median uncertainty of 0.08 for measurements with a range of 00.8 ) .
thus , the pca components can produce a somewhat clearer delineation between objects with differing stellar populations .
one feature of note is that the `` emission '' component saturates at unity as the [ oii ] line strength increases .
that is , our pca technique is not usable as a linear measure of emission line luminosity in individual galaxies beyond sc , as a scd and a starburst galaxy may both have values close to unity .
thus , a detailed analysis of starburst galaxies is better done directly with emission line indices , rather than with these pca components , though measurements of star formation rates for less active types are still accurate . for cluster populations ,
the fraction of very strong star forming galaxies is very small , so this slight nonlinearity is unlikely to significantly affect average population measures .
a composite average population gradient from 913 galaxies in 15 clusters was constructed from galaxies with k@xmath6 -evolution corrected @xmath50 . in constructing composite pca values for subsamples of the data ,
individual galaxy pca values were weighted according to each cluster s selection function for apparent magnitude , position within the cluster , and @xmath19 color ( see 2 ) .
more than 50% of galaxies within these magnitude limits are sampled in each cluster , with the success rate of identifying objects observed spectroscopically greater than @xmath51% .
about 3% of the galaxies with redshifts showed catastrophic problems in a part of the spectrum which made accurate pca estimates impossible .
these objects were excluded from the sample and galaxy weights for the remaining objects were recalculated accordingly . creating a fair composite sample of the galaxies as a function of cluster - centric radius also requires correcting for the fact that the individual clusters can have varying observational coverage . to account for the fact that some clusters were not observed to the maximum radius
, weights for galaxies at large radii were increased by the inverse of the fraction of the clusters which were observed to that radius . for this analysis ,
the brightest cluster galaxy was omitted for each cluster , since these galaxies ( which are often cd galaxies ) may have a very different star formation history from the rest of the cluster .
finally , galaxies were also weighted by the inverse of the cluster richness , as measured by the galaxy - cluster spatial covariance amplitude b@xmath52 ( e.g. , yee & lpez - cruz 1999 ) .
this photometric measure of the galaxy overdensity within 0.25 @xmath15 mpc of the cluster core is well correlated with velocity dispersion and x - ray temperature ( yee 2000 ) . correcting for cluster richness
ensures that the results are not dominated by the few richest clusters , and that composite luminosity densities for high and low redshift subsamples are properly normalized , even if there is a difference in mean richness between them .
together , this weighting scheme allows us to create a fair sample of cluster properties , corrected for observational selection effects and the gross effects of richness .
galaxy positions were scaled by @xmath1 ( cye ) , which corrects for differing cluster richness by scaling each galaxy position to a fixed cosmological overdensity .
these dynamical parameters are well determined for these clusters by 30 - 200 cluster members each , and have been found to yield results in excellent agreement with x - ray determinations of the cluster masses ( lewis 1999 ) .
figure 5a shows the average pca components for a composite of the 15 clusters , as a function of cluster - centric radius .
a clear spatial gradient is seen , with the older population declining from the cluster core towards the outer parts of the cluster , and an accompanying increase in the emission line component .
there are between 107 and 294 galaxies in each bin except for the outermost , which has only 17 .
uncertainties were estimated via bootstrap techniques . also plotted
are the average pca values for galaxies at @xmath53 taken from the cnoc2 field galaxy spectroscopic sample .
it is clear that the pca component curves are approaching these values with increasing radius , and also that at no point is there an excess of emission line activity in the cluster , relative to the field , confirming the results from balogh ( 1997 ) , who used line indices from the same spectral database .
morphological and spectral gradients similar to this are seen in low - z clusters ( e.g. , oemler 1974 ; dressler 1980 ; whitmore 1993 ) .
similar gradients , seen in galaxy color , morphology , or emission line strengths , have also been noted in clusters at higher redshifts by a number of investigators ( e.g. , abraham 1996 ; smail 1998 ; morris 1998 ; couch 1998 ; balogh 1997 and dressler 1997 ) .
such gradients are consistent with the infall of field galaxies in hierarchical clustering models of cluster growth ( e.g. , gunn & gott 1972 ; kauffmann 1995 ; balogh , navarro & morris 2000 ) and suggest that galaxies which have more recently fallen into the cluster potential preferentially inhabit its outskirts .
a related phenomenon is the spatial / velocity segregation of red and blue galaxies in clusters .
blue galaxies are generally found to have higher velocities and more extended spatial distributions than red galaxies , which has led to some confusion as to the accuracy of virial mass estimates .
carlberg ( 1997 ) , however , showed that for the cnoc1 sample , a separate dynamical analysis of red and blue subsamples produced the same mass .
thus , we expect these gradients in our data , and note that galaxies throughout the clusters appear to be at least in quasi - equilibrium with the cluster potential .
the principal component analysis allows the construction of a smooth model cluster in the three separate components , and hence allows a self - consistent correction for spatial projection effects . a deprojected version of the component fractions is shown in figure 5b .
here an overall average galaxy density profile , @xmath54(r ) , was adopted from cye and is of the form : @xmath55 where @xmath14 is the true , deprojected radius .
for each ring in projected radial coordinates , we determine the fractional contribution from galaxies in shells at greater true radius , @xmath14 .
the projected pca components are then corrected for contamination from the projection of these galaxies .
the outermost bin is the first to be corrected .
pca components for regions outside of the surveyed area .
the values for @xmath56 are assumed to be the cnoc2 field values and the average of the outermost data point and the field values is assumed for @xmath57 @xmath58 .
the spatial deprojection is then propagated inwards , using the new components for the outer bins to correct the inner ones .
the spatial deprojection tends to steepen the gradient but the effect is relatively small ; the most significant difference is that the innermost points for the elliptical population are raised by about 10% . while deprojected profiles are appealing , this process introduces substantial random and systematic uncertainties from the assumed profile , and errors in the outer bins propagate inwards note , for example , how the slight departure from absolute smoothness in the projected profile at @xmath59 is amplified in the bin at @xmath60 .
thus , while we provide deprojected versions of several of our results based on the whole cluster sample , results which further split the data into smaller subsamples are shown only in projected spatial coordinates .
the three original pca axes are strikingly similar to recognizable stellar population types , but do not actually correspond exactly to distinct real galaxy types .
however , these pca components can be linearly transformed to measure a galaxy s match to any template stellar population . in figure 6a
we plot a weighted composite for the sample , where the three components have been linearly transformed to a new pca coordinate system with axes named old population " , field - like " , and post - star formation ( psf ) " .
these new pca coordinates were defined in order to divide the stellar light from each galaxy into components representing empirically - determined stellar populations of different ages : a natural " pca coordinate system for cluster populations .
table i lists the axes of the redefined pca coordinate system in terms of the original components . old population " values were chosen to match ellipticals in the kennicutt spectrophotometric atlas of galaxies ( 1992 ) , and agree with the reddest galaxies in these clusters .
a decomposition of spectral synthesis models ( from bruzual & charlot 1993 ) indicates that any population more than about 3 gyr old will yield similar pca values .
the new field - like " vector is calculated separately for each cluster , based on the average for cnoc2 field galaxies at these same redshifts and magnitudes . on average , values are similar to a present - day sbc , but with additional power in balmer absorption lines .
there is a mild increase in the emission " fraction between @xmath61 and @xmath62 and thus the field - like " component is defined as a function of cluster redshift .
post - star - formation " values are determined from a spectral synthesis model of a galaxy whose star formation is constant for 4 gyr and then is abruptly stopped .
the new vector corresponds to the time of the maximum balmer component , about 1 gyr after the truncation .
this rather extreme spectral type is found to be in general agreement with the observed pca values from the strongest k@xmath6a spectra of galaxies seen in the clusters .
note that these components are not strictly orthonormal , though they are normalized to a sum of unity , as before .
thus , the equivalent of total flux is conserved , but the final component values are dependent on the choice of all three axes . while the old population " and field - like " components are robustly determined empirically , the psf " component is somewhat more arbitrarily defined . choosing a slightly different recipe for this component will raise or lower all three values .
for example , changing the psf " component to a somewhat less strong balmer component , more indicative of average k@xmath6a galaxies ( elliptical= 0.15 , emission=0.15 , balmer=0.70 ; see e.g. , figure 3 ) will raise the
psf " component for an average cluster galaxy by about 0.02 , and lower each of the old population " and field - like " components by about 0.01 to compensate .
thus , in addition to the random uncertainties in our pca values , there is an additional systematic uncertainty of a few percent in their interpretation as real stellar populations . despite this slight degeneracy , the overall cluster structure
is well illustrated by this transformation . old population
" galaxies preferentially occupy the cluster interior , and a smooth gradient towards younger populations is seen until the properties of cluster galaxies approach those of the coeval field population asymptotically at 25 @xmath1 , well outside of the virial radius .
figure 6b shows the same results deprojected in the same manner as figure 5b .
the profiles are qualitatively the same as for the projected spatial coordinates , but are steeper in the core region . note especially that the data are quite consistent with zero field - like " or
psf " component in the cluster core , and then a fairly steep rise within about 0.5@xmath1 .
the post - star formation component appears relatively flat in projected spatial coordinates , and flat with a central dip in deprojected spatial coordinates with a component fraction of about 10% .
again , there is a possibility of a few percent systematic uncertainty in the absolute values , though the overall shape remains the same for different choices of pca coordinates .
this is larger than the @xmath63 fraction of identifiable k@xmath6a galaxies seen in the same dataset by b99 , who further conclude that there is no excess of such galaxies over the field .
however , the pca technique is sensitive to smaller fractions of galaxy light in the post - star formation state ( i.e. , there is no discrete cutoff in line strength , as there is in identifying individual k@xmath6a galaxies ) , so higher fractions are expected than for studies which count only galaxies with extreme signatures .
we confirm the result that there is only a few percent of very strong balmer - line galaxies in the clusters , but note that there are many galaxies with slightly weaker balmer lines still in excess of what is expected for normal field or elliptical galaxies .
these galaxies overlap the observational scatter from the substantial passive / elliptical galaxy population and so individual identification of their populations is impossible .
thus , the comparison with b99 appears reasonable , and this analysis of the data suggests that there is a small excess of light from intermediate age stars over the field population . comparison with the k@xmath6a fraction in the morphs sample of clusters at similar redshifts ( dressler 1999 ; poggianti 1999 ) is slightly more troubling , as they find closer to 20% of the galaxies have strong post - starburst signatures .
this may signify true differences in cluster populations for x - ray selected clusters such as the emss sample , versus the optically - selected morphs clusters ( see 6 ) .
the intermediate shape of the psf " profile , neither rising nor falling as steeply as the other components , indicates that the psf " components do indeed trace a population which is intermediate in dynamical state as well as stellar age .
interestingly , because the populations must approach a pure field - like " component outside of the cluster , we expect that the psf " component will approach zero at large radii .
however , our data do not show an obvious decline even in the outermost data point . in figure 7
we examine the trend in population gradients in clusters over our redshift range of 0.18 to 0.55 .
plotted are the
old population " components versus radius for subsamples at @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
the pca values , weights and uncertainties are calculated as before . while the cluster cores appear to be similarly dominated by old populations , a significant change in the fractional population gradient is seen between the two redshift bins . at lower redshift
, the old population appears to dominate to larger radii , whereas at higher redshifts , the field - like galaxies are more noticeable in the inner portions of the cluster , though they still avoid the central core .
this steepening of the population gradient can be thought of as a more detailed restatement of the butcher - oemler effect .
note that redefining the butcher - oemler effect in terms of gradients immediately explains the changes in the apparent blue fraction measures shown in figures 1a and 1c , where the counting radius was changed .
it also explains why some studies which have focused on the cluster cores have found very little evidence for population evolution .
a rough comparison of these results with those from previous measures of galaxy cluster populations can be made by equating our old population " with the summed fractions of e and s0 galaxies from morphological studies and assuming that @xmath66 @xmath15 mpc for clusters in other surveys .
values inferred from figure 7 of dressler ( 1997 ) for the subset of regular " clusters from the morphs sample are plotted with a dashed line on figure 7 , and suggest that the pca population gradient in the higher redshift bin are generally in agreement with other clusters at similar redshifts .
interestingly , our lower redshift bin , with a mean redshift of @xmath67 , appears to be very close to the values inferred by the @xmath68 morphological gradients derived by whitmore , gilmore & jones ( 1993 ) .
the dotted line on figure 7 shows an estimate of the population gradients from their low redshift sample .
while care must be taken in comparing spectral and morphological quantities , it appears that the pca gradients are generally in agreement with other measures of galaxy type , and also suggest that the evolution in the gradients tapers off at @xmath69 .
luminosity surface density profiles for each pca component were constructed from the total galaxy luminosity surface density distribution and the pca fractional gradients shown in figure 6a .
figure 8 shows the profiles for the transformed pca coordinates described above .
the fractional gradients seen in figure 6 are shown here as relative light distributions which increase in spatial extent from older to younger stellar populations .
this is quite consistent with what is expected from the accretion of field galaxies into the cluster , where galaxies which fell into the cluster at earlier times and whose stellar populations have longest felt the effects of the cluster environment will have a more concentrated spatial distribution than those that are only now entering the cluster for the first time .
we note that the field - like " and psf " populations are most similar in shape , suggesting that much of the older population significantly predates the introduction of these younger galaxies to the cluster . in figure 9
we illustrate a possible explanation for the evolution in cluster populations and population gradients in clusters by constructing luminosity profiles as a function of cluster redshift .
figure 9a shows the relative luminosity surface density for the old population " component for @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
the two curves are nearly identical in both shape and normalization .
note that the normalization for all curves in figures 8 , 9a and 9b is identical since the weights for each galaxy are normalized by the cluster richness , as measured by b@xmath52 , the possible observational selection effect that the higher redshift bins contain somewhat richer clusters on average is removed .
plotting the distributions as a function of @xmath70 rather than a fixed metric radius normalizes each galaxy position in terms of cosmological overdensity at the cluster redshift .
it appears that the old population , which presumably includes both galaxies which were formed early in the cluster s history , as well as galaxies which have been spectroscopically transformed after falling into the cluster environment , has not changed in shape significantly relative to @xmath1 over this timescale , this is in agreement with the idea that these galaxies have resided in the cluster for several billion years and are in a stable dynamical equilibrium .
figure 9b shows the sum of the field - like " and post - star - formation " light profiles , representing galaxies which are newer introductions to the cluster potential .
the two components were summed in part to slightly increase the signal - to - noise ratio and also to represent more closely the light from butcher - oemler " galaxies , which are often taken as the mixture of both star forming and k@xmath6a galaxies .
summing two of the three components also minimizes possible complications from the pca coordinate transformations , since the cluster populations are now divided into two nearly - normal components , with a systematic uncertainty from pca coordinate definitions of only about 1% .
these curves are normalized identically to those in figure 9a ; note that the core densities are lower by about a factor of 8 and the curves are more extended , relative to the old population . " also , unlike the old population " , the young stellar populations show significant evolution over the redshifts observed .
qualitatively , the two curves appear to have similar shapes outside of the cluster core , but the lower redshift curve has an amplitude about a factor of three lower than the higher redshift curve .
thus the butcher - oemler effect appears to be caused by a decrease in the density of a young stellar population which has the same overall spatial extent relative to @xmath70 at these redshifts .
the results from composite radial distributions of galaxy populations are consistent with a simple model of cluster formation and evolution .
it appears that the cluster can be modeled as the sum of two components : a virilized component of older galaxies , and a younger component which , while it is probably in quasi - equilibrium with the cluster potential ( carlberg 1997a ) , has fallen in more recently and which may eventually be expected to transform both spectrally and dynamically to blend with the older population .
galaxies in the midst of this transformation ( e.g. , k@xmath6a galaxies , or the psf " pca component ) appear to inhabit an intermediate spatial distribution .
the origin of the young and intermediate - age components identified with the butcher - oemler galaxies " may be constrained by tracing their spatial luminosity distribution as a function of redshift . over the redshift range sampled here
, we find that outside the core region ( @xmath71 0.25 @xmath1 ) the shape of the young population luminosity distribution appears to be unchanging .
this strongly suggests that dynamical state of galaxies ( i.e. , time since entry to the cluster potential ) and age of their stellar populations are fundamentally linked .
this is a reasonable assumption if the mechanism which transformed the population is due to the cluster environment .
the main difference in these curves is then a simple vertical shift , and these results can thus be interpreted as a straightforward decline in the infall rate of new galaxies into the cluster . in this scenario ,
galaxy population changes can be used as a direct measure of cluster growth rates .
this explanation for galaxy population evolution was also suggested by kauffmann ( 1995 ) , who modeled cluster populations according to a recipe for hierarchical clusters in a cdm universe , and abraham ( 1996 ) , who modeled the morphological gradients in the cnoc1 cluster abell 2390 as a function of cluster infall .
the young , field - like component comprises about 15% of the galaxy light within @xmath1 for our higher redshift subsample . the difference in mass - to - light ratios between the field - like " and old population "
stars can be estimated from the relative flux at @xmath72 in population synthesis models for a galaxy with ongoing star formation versus a passively evolving population ( e.g. , charlot & bruzual 1993 ) .
the mass - to - light ratio of the old population " should be about 2.5 times that of the field - like " population , implying that about 6% of the stellar mass in the cluster has recently fallen into the cluster at an observed epoch of @xmath73 .
thus , the butcher - oemler effect illustrates the sensitivity of galaxy populations in tracing even a very small fraction of infall into the cluster .
figure 9 further suggests that the infall rate has declined further by a factor of @xmath2 by @xmath74 .
however , calibrating this result to absolute infall rates and linking it to cosmological models remain uncertain because of the unknown timescales of both virialization and population evolution in these environments .
for example , the mechanism which affects ongoing star formation in clusters might operate quite gradually , as may be indicated by the relatively weak balmer line strengths .
if this is the case , the field - like " galaxies we see in the cluster may have been introduced to the cluster a billion or more years earlier than the observed epoch . that the blue galaxies are seen to be in equilibrium with the same mass potential as the red galaxies ( carlberg 1997a ) also suggests that they may remain in the cluster for several crossing times before undergoing a significant spectral transformation .
in addition , the spectral transformation can be expected to take 13 billion years , even if star formation is terminated abruptly . the ratio of the field - like " to psf " components in figure 8 places rough limits on the maximum length of the delay between galaxy infall and the cessation of star formation .
the observed ratio in the light densities of about 4 implies a ratio of 23 in the mass densities , since the mass - to - light ratio of the field - like " population will be less than that of the more evolved psf " population .
psf " population is relatively short lived , with a duration of about 1 gyr .
thus , in the case of a constant infall rate , the field - like " population can endure the cluster environment for 2 - 3 gyr . for a declining infall rate ,
this value is an upper limit .
estimates of this timescale were also found to be on the order of a few gyr by poggianti ( 1999 ) and balogh ( 2000 ) .
the observed epochs of our redshift subsamples are at @xmath75 and @xmath76 ; a conservative estimate of a 1.5 billion year delay between infall and the post - star formation phase of the spectral transformation would place the epoch of infall corresponding to the observations at @xmath77 and @xmath78 , for the lower and higher redshift bins , respectively ( @xmath9= 75 km s@xmath10 mpc@xmath10 , @xmath79=0.5 ) .
note that this assumes that star formation is terminated almost instantaneously upon a galaxy s entry into the cluster . a larger delay of 3 gyr places the infall for our larger observed redshift bin at @xmath80 .
the _ very _ tentative agreement between our @xmath81 spectroscopic gradient and the morphological gradients from @xmath82 ( whitmore 1993 ) also suggest that cluster infall is very rapidly decreasing during intermediate redshifts and perhaps is coming to a steady state by our lower redshift bin , corresponding to @xmath77 .
this is qualitatively in agreement with evidence that the cluster x - ray luminosity function has not evolved strongly since @xmath83 ( e.g. , henry 992 ; rosati 1998 ; vikhlinin 1998 ) , and low - density cosmological models which place most of cluster formation at @xmath84 .
expanding the study of population gradients to both higher and lower redshifts , and combining the results with analytic and n - body results for cluster growth will be a topic of further investigation .
an alternate viewpoint to a declining infall rate is that some physical property of the cluster environs has evolved over these timescales , driving the observed evolution in the populations .
possibilities include differing rates or efficiencies of galaxy - galaxy interactions , evolving gas densities in the cluster , which would affect the efficiency of ram - pressure stripping of gas from infalling galaxies , and the evolution of the infalling field population ( lavery & henry 1988 ; dressler & gunn 1993 ; moore et al . 1996 ; fujita 1998 ) .
we have already removed the primary effect of field galaxy evolution by constructing vector components which are based on the observed field population at the same magnitudes and redshifts as the clusters .
global evolution in the hot intra - cluster medium is also probably not a strong driving force in the observed evolution .
all of the clusters in our sample are luminous x - ray clusters , and there does not appear to be a strong correlation between the x - ray gas density and the galaxy populations .
figure 10 shows the old population " component for 8 clusters versus azimuthally averaged x - ray gas density , each measured at 0.5 @xmath1 from the cluster core .
the gas density measurements are based on the rosat / asca observations from lewis ( 1999 ) . while there is some variation in each parameter , they do not appear positively correlated , as would be expected if gas density evolution were driving the overall population changes .
( note that gas stripping may still be responsible for the transformation of individual galaxies , while an independent , cosmologically changing condition drives the population evolution . )
the baryon fractions in these clusters also do not show a strong correlation with redshift ( lewis 1999 ) , further suggesting that the butcher - oemler effect is not directly linked to an evolving intra - cluster medium .
changing rates of efficiencies of galaxy - galaxy interactions remain a possible mechanism for galaxy evolution in clusters , although morphological evidence for this remains mixed ( e.g. , oemler 1997 ) .
since the effects of cluster richness and dynamics are normalized in this analysis , any evolutionary effect must come from either a cosmological change in the clustering of galaxies as they fall into the cluster ( i.e. , a declining rate of infalling pairs or small groups which might inhabit the regions near clusters ) or in the ability of galaxies to continue to form stars in the wake of a collision .
a more detailed analysis of statistical interaction rates in these clusters is underway .
a common property of these scenarios is that either more favorable environmental conditions or a higher resiliency of the infalling field galaxies result in star formation in infalling galaxies persisting for a longer time within the high redshift cluster environment .
this general scenario of a longer interval before a galaxy completes its spectral transformation can be contrasted against the alternative scenario of changing infall rates , and the observed trend in the fractional population gradients can be used to constrain them . as discussed above ,
the observed gradients are qualitatively in agreement with the scenario that changing infall rates drive the observed evolution .
a key feature of the infall model is that most of the additional blue galaxies seen at higher redshift are linked with a newly infalling population with an extended spatial distribution .
thus the butcher - oemler effect is greater when a larger counting radius is used and the cluster core is changing relatively slowly . in the changing - timescale scenario ,
the excess blue galaxies seen at higher redshift are galaxies which are persisting in their star formation despite the fact that they fell into the cluster long ago .
thus we would expect to see that the major evidence for evolution would be that the field - like " population would have a more concentrated spatial distribution relative to @xmath70 ( i.e. , more like the old population " ) at higher redshifts . in terms of population gradients
, this will tend to create gradients which manifest the butcher - oemler effect via additional blue galaxies in the inner parts of the clusters .
thus , the gradients would tend to become flatter at higher redshift , with the strongest evolution in the core region due to the dynamically old but spectroscopically unevolved population .
figures 7 and 9 can not definitively rule out this possibility , as the strength of such an effect is based on the details of both cluster and galaxy formation , as well as the exact mechanism that truncates star formation in the cluster environment . however , the data appear to be more consistent with a simple infall model rather than with a simple model of increasing the length of time galaxies can persist in forming stars in the cluster environment . while some of the discrepancies in measurements of the butcher - oemler effect can be explained by differing observational and analysis techniques , there appear to be significant differences in the average properties of different cluster samples . in particular ,
the cnoc1 x - ray selected sample appears to have a significantly lower fraction of both star forming and post - star forming galaxies than the optically - selected morphs sample ( b99 ; this work ) .
this difference most likely springs from the two different ways in which the samples were collected .
the morphs sample for many years comprised the only sample of rich clusters at @xmath85 and is a heterogeneous collection of optically and agn - selected clusters .
they span a fairly wide range of richnesses , and in some cases the richness or cluster mass is still not well - determined ; overestimating the mass because of velocity structures in a merging cluster may be a concern .
morphologically they also span a range of types , including both centrally concentrated and diffuse clusters and it is not clear how well they represent the cluster population as a whole .
the cnoc1 cluster samples were chosen primarily from the einstein medium deep survey ( emss ; gioia 1990 , gioia & luppino 1994 ) x - ray sample , with the addition of the rich cluster abell 2390 .
both optical and x - ray morphologies show that these clusters are on average very smooth and regular .
this is not surprising , as the x - ray selection technique is most sensitive to the high gas densities in the cores of centrally concentrated clusters . in addition
, the central luminosity peaks from cooling flows can make less - massive high redshift clusters much more visible to x - ray surveys : nearly half of the cnoc1 clusters are cooling flow clusters . as cooling flows
may be associated with clusters which have _ not _ had a major merging event in the recent past ( e.g. , allen 1998 ) , this may strengthen the tendency towards regular clusters .
hence , selection technique may predispose the cnoc1 sample , and very luminous x - ray clusters in general , to appear to be more quiescent than other samples , and our implied infall rates may actually be lower limits to the actual growth of cluster structures
. these systematic differences in the cluster samples may be responsible for the differing fraction of post - starburst galaxies seen in the morphs and cnoc1 samples , if the starburst phenomenon is associated with the infall of small groups into the cluster potential .
starbursts may be commonly induced by galaxy interactions , which in turn are more frequently found in the low velocity dispersion environments of small groups . if the luminous x - ray clusters which dominate the cnoc / emss sample have not absorbed a significant subclump of galaxies within the previous 1.5 or more gyr , they are not likely to contain a significant fraction of galaxies with post - starburst spectra .
a number of new surveys for high redshift clusters are amassing large numbers of both fainter x - ray clusters and optically - selected clusters ( e.g. , zaritsky 1997 ; holden 1999 ; scharf 1996 ; rosati 1998 ; kim 1999 ; lewis , stocke & ellingson 1999 ; gladders & yee 2000 ) .
these should soon allow galaxy population studies for complete samples of clusters which are truly representative of the cluster population at a chosen redshift , and provide enough variation in cluster type to investigate the dependence of population on the clusters recent merging histories .
we have investigated the butcher - oemler effect in a sample of 15 rich galaxy clusters at @xmath0 from the cnoc1 cluster survey . a classical measurement of the cluster blue fraction , based on spectroscopically confirmed cluster members , shows a significant butcher - oemler effect , in that high redshift clusters have a larger fraction of star forming galaxies .
these galaxies are found primarily outside of the cluster cores , and the butcher - oemler effect virtually disappears when a counting radius of only 0.5@xmath1 is used .
we have developed an alternative method of measuring stellar populations in galaxies via a principal component analysis ( pca ) of galaxy spectra .
basis vectors defined from the low - redshift lcrs spectral database were used to decompose cluster galaxy spectra into three components , corresponding to an old , passively evolving population , a young population matched to the coeval field , and a population of intermediate age , matched to a 0.5 gyr post - star formation population .
these components are shown to be robust measurements of stellar populations by comparison with low redshift galaxy spectra and classical line indices . however , unlike line indices , pca components directly measure the fraction of light emitted by a given population , allowing for straightforward construction of population fractions and spatial distributions .
composite population gradients show a smooth transition from the infalling field galaxy population to the older populations seen in the inner regions .
the gradients are corrected for the evolution of the field population and cluster richness and show no evidence for an excess of star formation in the cluster ; the cluster environment therefore appears to have the monotonic effect of decreasing star formation in infalling galaxies .
however , there is evidence for a small excess of intermediate age stars , mostly located in galaxies with mixed stellar populations .
this suggests that star formation in these galaxies has been truncated gradually , without an accompanying strong starburst .
evolution in the cluster galaxy population between @xmath86 and 0.2 is manifest in a flattening of the fractional population gradient at later epochs , while the cluster cores remain dominated by an old , red population .
luminosity surface brightness distributions indicate that the old stellar population has a centrally concentrated , unchanging spatial extent as a function of @xmath70 .
younger galaxy populations have a more extended distribution that also retains its general shape but appears to be decreasing by about a factor of three in amplitude between @xmath86 and @xmath61 .
this phenomenon is most consistent with scenarios where the mechanism which truncates star formation in individual galaxies remains constant , but the cluster population evolution is driven by a declining rate of infall into the clusters .
depending on the length of time that star formation in galaxies can survive the cluster environment , this may indicate a change in the infall rates into clusters between @xmath3 and @xmath4 ; if galaxies reside in the cluster for a significant interval before ceasing star formation , the evolution will correspond to even earlier epochs .
we note that the stellar mass fraction of young populations in these clusters is on the order of a only few percent , despite the fact that it requires several gyr to transform stellar populations from young to old populations .
this also suggests that the butcher - oemler effect as seen at intermediate redshifts is a lingering echo of more rapid cluster formation which occurred much earlier , in qualitative agreement with low - density cosmological models .
additional n - body and analytical modeling is necessary to firmly link the observed evolution in population gradients to models of cluster formation and growth .
these results indicate that galaxy populations provide a very sensitive probe of cluster growth , and that the construction of spatial distributions for different galaxy populations may illuminate both cluster and galaxy evolution . extending similar studies to both higher and lower
redshifts is critical towards building a consistent picture of cluster evolution .
however , the best studied samples at intermediate and high redshifts may not be representative of the cluster population , as both x - ray and optically selected samples may introduce systematic biases in the dynamical state and formation history of the clusters .
as the populations seen in individual clusters may be strongly affected by the recent merging history of the cluster , it is important that a wide variety of cluster types be sampled in order to build a truly representative sample .
a new generation of high redshift cluster samples based on algorithms which are sensitive to low surface brightness and newly merging cluster structures is necessary to expand and clarify our picture of the formation of galaxy clusters and the effects of environment on galaxy evolution .
ee acknowledges support provided by the national science foundation grant ast 9617145 .
hl acknowledges support provided by nasa through hubble fellowship grant # hf-01110.01 - 98a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa under contract nas 5 - 26555 .
the cnoc surveys are supported by operating and collaborative grants from nserc to hy and rc .
lcccc new component axis & & elliptical & emission & balmer + old population & & 0.77 & 0.03 & 0.20 + field - like & @xmath31=0.25 & 0.32 & 0.39 & 0.29 + & @xmath870.35 & 0.28 & 0.46 & 0.26 + & @xmath870.45 & 0.22 & 0.51 & 0.26 + & @xmath870.55 & 0.22 & 0.52 & 0.26 + post star formation ( psf ) & & 0.10 & 0.05 & 0.85 + | we present photometric and spectroscopic measurements of the galaxy populations in clusters from the cnoc1 sample of rich , x - ray luminous clusters at @xmath0 .
a classical measure of the galaxy blue fraction for spectroscopically confirmed cluster members shows a significant butcher - oemler effect for the sample , but only when radii larger than 0.5@xmath1 are considered .
we perform a principal component analysis of galaxy spectra to divide the total cluster light into contributions from stellar populations of different ages .
composite radial distributions of different stellar populations show strong gradients as a function of cluster - centric radius . the composite population is dominated by evolved populations in the core , and gradually changes at radii greater than the virial radius to one which is similar to coeval field galaxies .
we do not see evidence at any radius within the clusters for an excess of star formation over that seen in the coeval field . within this redshift range , significant evolution in the fractional population gradient
is seen .
both low and high redshift clusters have similar populations in the cluster cores , but higher redshift clusters have steeper gradients and more star forming galaxies at radii outside of the core region in effect , a restatement of the butcher - oemler effect .
luminosity density profiles are consistent with a scenario where this phenomenon is due to a decline over time in the infall rate of field galaxies into clusters . depending on how long galaxies reside in clusters before their star formation rates
are diminished , this suggests a decrease in the infall into clusters of a factor of @xmath2 between @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
we also discuss alternative scenarios for the evolution of cluster populations . |
many cardiovascular diseases such as due to the arterial occlusion is one of the leading cause of death world wide .
the partial occlusion of the arteries due to stenotic obstruction not only restrict the regular blood flow but also characterizes the hardening and thickening of the arterial wall .
however , the main cause of the formation of stenosis is still unknown but it is well established that the fluid dynamical factors play an important role as to further development of stenosis . therefore ,
during the past few decay several studies were conducted by young @xcite , young and tsai @xcite to understand the effects of stenosis on blood flow through arteries . [ cols= " < , < " , ] tu and deville @xcite investigated pulsatile flow of blood in stenosed arteries .
misra and shit @xcite studied in two different situations on the blood flow through arterial stenosis by treating blood as a non - newtonian ( herschel - bulkley ) fluid model .
it is generally well known that blood , being a suspension of red cells in plasma , behaves like a non - newtonian fluid at low shear rates @xcite .
however , misra and chakravarty @xcite and shit and roy @xcite put forwarded a mathematical analysis for the unsteady flow of blood through arteries having stenosis , in which blood was treated as a newtonian viscous incompressible fluid .
the hemodynamics associated with a single stenotic lesion are significantly affected by the presence of a second lesion . in many situations
there are evidences of the occurrence of the multiple or overlapping stenosis such as the patients of angiograms .
misra et al .
@xcite conducted a theoretical study for the effects of multiple stenosis .
an experimental study of blood flow through an arterial segment having multiple stenoses were made by talukder et al . @xcite .
the effects of overlapping stenosis through an arterial stenosis have been successfully carried out analytically as well as numerically by chakravarty and mandal @xcite and layek et al .
@xcite respectively . however , all these studies are restricted in the consideration of magnetic field and the porous medium .
since blood is electrically conducting fluid , its flow characteristics is influenced by the application of magnetic field .
if a magnetic field is applied to a moving and electrically conducting fluid , it will induce electric as well as magnetic fields .
the interaction of these fields produces a body force per unit volume known as lorentz force , which has significant impact on the flow characteristics of blood .
such an analysis may be useful for the reduction of blood flow during surgery and magnetic resonance imaging ( mri ) .
the effect of magnetic field on blood flow has been analyzed theoretically and experimentally by many investigators @xcite - @xcite under different situations .
shit and his co - investigators @xcite - @xcite explored variety of flow behaviour of blood in arteries by treating newtonian/ non - newtonian model in the presence of a uniform magnetic field . very recently , the studies of blood flow through porous medium has gained considerable attention to the medical practitioners/ clinicians because of its enormous changes in the flow characteristics .
the capillary endothelium is , in turn , covered by a thin layer lining the alveoli , which has been treated as a porous medium .
dash et al .
@xcite considered the brinkman equation to model the blood flow when there is an accumulation of fatty plaques in the lumen of an arterial segment and artery - clogging takes place by blood clots .
they considered the clogged region as a porous medium .
bhargava et al .
@xcite studied the transport of pharmaceutical species in laminar , homogeneous , incompressible , magneto - hydrodynamic , pulsating flow through two - dimensional channel with porous walls containing non - darcian porous materials .
misra et al .
@xcite presented a mathematical model as well as numerical model for studying blood flow through a porous vessel under the action of magnetic field , in which the viscosity varies in the radial direction .
hematocrit is the most important determinant of whole blood viscosity .
therefore , blood viscosity and vascular resistance ( due to the presence of stenosis ) affect total peripheral resistance to blood flow , which is abnormally high in the primary stage of hypertension .
again hematocrit is a blood test that measures the percentage of red blood cells present in the whole blood of the body .
the percentage of red cells in adult human body is approximately 40 - 45 % @xcite .
red cells may affect the viscosity of whole blood and thus the velocity distribution depends on the hematocrit .
so blood can not be considered as homogeneous fluid @xcite . due to the high shear rate near the arterial wall ,
the viscosity of blood is low and the concentration of cells is high in the central core region .
therefore , blood may be treated as newtonian fluid with variable viscosity particularly in the case of large blood vessels .
the present study is motivated towards a theoretical investigation of blood flow through a tapered and overlapping stenosed artery in the presence of magnetic field .
the study pertains to a situation in which the variable viscosity of blood depending upon hematocrit is taken into consideration .
the present model is designed in such a way that it could be applicable to both converging/ diverging artery depending on the choice of tapering angle @xmath0 .
thus , the study will answers the question of mechanism of further deposition of plaque under various aspects .
we consider the laminar , incompressible and newtonian flow of blood through axisymmetric two - dimensional tapered and overlapping stenosed artery .
any material point in the fluid is representing by the cylindrical polar coordinate @xmath1 , where @xmath2 measures along the axis of the artery and that of @xmath3 and @xmath4 measure along the radial and circumferential directions respectively .
the mathematical expression that corresponds to the geometry of the present problem is given by where the onset of the stenosis is located at a distance @xmath6 from the inlet , @xmath7 the length of the overlapping stenosis and @xmath8 representing the distance between two critical height of the stenoses .
the expression for @xmath9 is responsible for the artery to be converging or diverging depending on tapering angle @xmath0 has the form @xmath10 + fig
. 1 schematic diagram of the model geometry .
+ + we assumed that blood is incompressible , suspension of erythrocytes in plasma and has uniform dense throughout but the viscosity @xmath11 varies in the radial direction . according to einstein s formula for the variable viscosity of blood taken to be @xmath12,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the coefficient of viscosity of plasma , @xmath14 is a constant ( whose value for blood is equal to 2.5 ) and @xmath15 stands for the hematocrit . the analysis will be carried out by using the following empirical formula for hematocrit given by in lih @xcite @xmath16,\ ] ] + in which @xmath17 represents the radius of a normal arterial segment , @xmath18 is the maximum hematocrit at the center of the artery and @xmath19 a parameter that determines the exact shape of the velocity profile for blood .
the shape of the profile given by eq.(4 ) is valid only for very dilute suspensions of erythrocytes , which are considered to be of spherical shape . according to our considerations , the equation that governs the flow of blood under the action of an external magnetic field through porous medium
may be put as @xmath20 + where @xmath21 denotes the ( axial ) velocity component of blood , @xmath22 the blood pressure , @xmath23 the electrical conductivity , @xmath24 the permeability of the porous medium and @xmath25 is the applied magnetic field strength . to solve our problem , we use no - slip boundary condition at the arterial wall , that is , @xmath26 further we consider axi - symmetric boundary condition of axial velocity at the mid line of the artery as @xmath27
in order to simplify our problem , let us introduce the following transformation @xmath28 with the use of the transform defined in ( 8) and the equations ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) , the governing equation ( 5 ) reduces to @xmath29-m^2u-\frac{1}{k}(a_1-a_2\xi^m)u=\frac{r_0 ^ 2}{\mu_0}\frac{\partial p}{\partial z}\ ] ] with @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
+ similarly the boundary conditions transformed into @xmath34 @xmath35 the equation ( 9 ) can be solved subjected to the boundary conditions ( 10 ) and ( 11 ) using frobenius method .
for this , of course , @xmath21 has to be bounded at @xmath36 .
then only admissible series solution of the equation ( 9 ) will exists and can put in the form @xmath37 where @xmath38 , @xmath39 and @xmath40 are arbitrary constants . + to find the arbitrary constant @xmath38 , we use the no - slip boundary condition ( 10 ) and obtained as @xmath41 substituting the value of @xmath21 from equation ( 12 ) into equation ( 9 ) and we get @xmath42+\frac{r_{0}^{2}\frac{dp}{dz}}{4a_{1}\mu_{0}}\big[\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}(i+1)(i+2)(a_{1}-a_{2}\xi^{m})b_{i}\xi^{i}+\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}(i+2)(a_{1}-(m-1)a_{2}\xi^{m})b_{i}\xi^{i}\nonumber\\ -(m^{2}+\frac{a_{1}}{k})\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}b_{i}\xi^{i+2}+\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\frac{a_{2}}{k}b_{i}\xi^{i+m+2}\big]=\frac{r_{0}^{2}\frac{dp}{dz}}{4a_{1}\mu_{0}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equating the coefficients of @xmath38 and other part in equation ( 14 ) we have , @xmath43 and @xmath44 hence the constants @xmath39 and @xmath40 are obtained by equating the coefficients of @xmath45 and @xmath46 from both side of equations ( 15 ) and ( 16 ) respectively and can be put in the form @xmath47 @xmath48 with @xmath49 substituting the expression for @xmath38 in the equation ( 12 ) , we have @xmath50}{\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}}\ ] ] the average velocity @xmath51 has the form @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the pressure gradient of the flow field in the normal artery in the absence of magnetic field . the non - dimensional expression for @xmath21 is given by @xmath54}{\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}}\ ] ] the volumetric flow rate across the arterial segment is given by @xmath55 substituting @xmath21 from eq.(20 ) into eq.(23 ) and then integrating with respect to @xmath56 , we obtain @xmath57}{\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}}\ ] ] if @xmath58 be the volumetric flow rate in the normal portion of the artery , in the absence of magnetic field and porosity effect , then @xmath59 therefore , the non - dimensional volumetric flow rate has the following form @xmath60}{\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}}\ ] ] if the flow is steady and no outward / inward flow takes place through the arterial segment , then the mass flux is constant and hence @xmath61 .
the expression for pressure gradient from ( 26 ) can be put as @xmath62}\ ] ] the wall shear stress on the endothelial surface is given by @xmath63_{r = r(z)}\ ] ] substituting @xmath21 from eq.(20 ) into eq.(28 ) , we obtain @xmath64}{4a_1}\frac{\bigg [ { \sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty } { b_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i+2}}\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{ia_i { ( \frac{r}{r_0})}^{i-1}}}- \sum \limits_{i=0}^{\infty } { ( i+2)b_i { ( \frac{r}{r_0})}^{i+1}}\sum \limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}\bigg]}{\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}}\ ] ] if @xmath65 be the shear stress at the normal portion of the arterial wall , in the absence of magnetic field , the non - dimensional form of the wall shear stress is given by @xmath66\frac{\frac{dp}{dz}}{\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i } } } \bigg [ { \sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty } { b_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i+2}}\sum\limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{ia_i { ( \frac{r}{r_0})}^{i-1}}}\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{1.0 cm}-\sum \limits_{i=0}^{\infty } { ( i+2)b_i { ( \frac{r}{r_0})}^{i+1}}\sum \limits_{i=0}^{\infty}{a_i(\frac{r}{r_0})^{i}}\bigg].\end{aligned}\ ] ]
in the previous section we have obtained analytical expressions for different flow characteristics of blood through porous medium under the action of an external magnetic field . in this section
we are to discuss the flow characteristics graphically with the use of following valid numerical data which is applicable to blood . to continue this section we have use the following standard values of physical parameter : @xmath67 fig .
2 indicates the different locations of the stenosis in the axial direction . in fig .
2 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 correspond to the onset and outset of the stenosis and @xmath70 and @xmath71 represent the throat of the primary stenosis and secondary stenosis respectively .
it is interesting to note from this figure that @xmath72 is the location where further deposition takes place and hence it is known as overlapping stenosis .
locations of the points z=0.5 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 , 3.5 .
+ the variation of axial velocity at different axial position along the radial direction are shown in fig .
we observe from this figure that the velocity is maximum at the central line of the vessel for all position of @xmath2 . among all these positions ,
the velocity is high at the throat of the primary stenosis and low at the onset of the overlapping stenosis .
however , the central line velocity at the throat of secondary stenosis is about 30 % less than the primary stenosis .
but the central line velocity at @xmath72 ( between the throat of two stenosis ) suddenly falls about 55 % than that of secondary one .
this observation may leads to the flow circulation zone and may causes further deposition of plaque .
4 depicts the variation of axial velocity for different length between the throat of two stenoses .
it has been observed that the velocity at the throat of the stenoses significantly increases with the increase of @xmath8 .
thus , the effect of the shape of stenosis has important role on the flow characteristics .
similar is the observation from fig .
5 that the axial velocity decreases as the tapering angle @xmath0 increases . fig .
6 illustrates the variation of axial velocity at the throat of the secondary stenosis for different values of the hartmann number @xmath73 .
we observe that the axial velocity significantly decreases at the central line of the artery with the increase of the magnetic field strength . while the velocity in the vicinity of the arterial wall increases with the increasing values of @xmath73 in order to maintain constant volumetric flow rate .
it is also well known that when a magnetic field is applied in an electrically conducting fluid ( here for blood ) there arises lorentz force , which has a tendency to slow down the motion of the fluid .
it has been observed from fig . 7
that the axial velocity near the central line of the channel increases with the increase of the permeability parameter @xmath74 , while the trend is reversed in the vicinity of the arterial wall .
this phenomena is noticed because of the permeability parameter @xmath74 is depend as the reciprocal of the permeability of the porous medium .
8 gives the distribution of axial velocity for different values of the hematocrit @xmath18 .
we note from fig . 8 that the axial velocity decreases at the core region of the artery with the increase of hematocrit level @xmath18 , whereas the opposite trend is observed in the peripheral region .
this fact lies with in the hematocrit as the blood viscosity is high in the core region due to the aggregation of blood cells rather than low viscosity in the plasma near the arterial wall .
9 - 12 illustrate the variation of pressure gradient @xmath75 along the length of the stenosis for different values of the physical parameters of interest . fig .
9 shows that the axial pressure gradient increases with the increase of magnetic field strength . we have already observed that the lorentz force has reducing effect of blood velocity , so as more pressure is needed to pass the same amount of fluid under the action of an external magnetic field .
however , the opposite trend is observed in the case of porous permeability parameter @xmath74 as shown in fig .
it has been seen from fig . 11 that the pressure gradient increases with the increase of the hematocrit @xmath18 .
it indicates from this figure that when the aggregation of blood cells increase at the core region that is hematocrit @xmath18 is high , more pressure gradient is needed to pass the same amount of the fluid through the stenotic region .
it is interesting to note from these three figures that the magnitude of the pressure gradient is high enough at the throat of the primary stenosis than that of the secondary one .
but from fig .
12 , we observed that at the throat of secondary stenosis , the pressure gradient is high in comparison to the throat of the primary stenosis .
this happens due to the increasing of the tapering angle @xmath0 .
therefore , in the case of diverging artery more pressure is needed as the flow advances in the downstream direction .
figs . 13 and 14
give the distribution of the wall shear stress for different values of the hematocrit @xmath18 and tapering angle @xmath0 .
we observe from fig .
13 that the wall shear stress increases as the hematocrit @xmath18 increases .
one can note from this figure that the wall shear stress is low at the throat of the secondary stenosis as well as at the downstream of the artery .
it is generally well known that at the low shear stress region mass transportation takes place and thereby occurs further deposition .
however , it is interesting to note from fig .
14 that the wall shear stress decreases significantly with the increasing values of the tapering angle @xmath0 .
moreover , the magnitude of the wall shear stress is same at both the throat of the stenosis in the absence of tapering angle @xmath0 .
therefore , we may conclude that there is a chance of further deposition at the downstream of the diverging artery .
a theoretical study of blood flow through overlapping stenosis in the presence of magnetic field has been carried out . in this study the variable viscosity of blood depending on hematocrit and the has been treated as the porous medium .
the problem is solved analytically by using frobenius method .
the effects of various key parameters including the tapering angle @xmath0 , percentage of hematocrit @xmath18 , the magnetic field and permeability parameter @xmath74 are examined .
the main findings of the present study may be listed as follows : + * the effect of primary stenosis on the secondary one is significant in case of diverging artery @xmath76 * the flow velocity at the central region decreases gradually with the increase of magnetic field strength . *
the permeability parameter @xmath74 has an enhancing effect on the flow characteristics of blood .
* at the core region , the axial velocity decreases with the increase of the percentage of hematocrit @xmath18 . *
the hematocrit and the blood pressure has a linear relationship as reported in @xcite .
* the lower range of hematocrit may leads to the further deposition of cholesterol at the endothelium of the vascular wall .
finally we can conclude that further potential improvement of the model are anticipated .
since the hematocrit positively affects blood pressure , further study should examine the other factors such as diet , tobacco , smoking , overweight etc . from a cardiovascular point of view .
more over on the basis of the present results , it can be concluded that the flow of blood and pressure can be controlled by the application of an external magnetic field .
99 young df , fluid mechanics of arterial stenosis , _ j. biomech .
* 101 * ( 1979 ) , 157 - 175 .
young df and tsi fy , flow characteristic in models of arterial stenosis - i , ssteady flow , _
j. biomech . ,
_ * 6 * , ( 1973 ) 395 - 410 .
misra jc , sinha a and shit gc , mathematical modelling of blood flow in a porous vessel having double stenoses in the presence of an external magnetic field , _ int .
j. biomath .
_ , * 4 ( 2 ) * ( 2011 ) , 207 - 225 .
misra jc , shit gc , chandra s and kundu pk , hydromagnetic flow and heat transfer of a second grade viscoelastic fluid in a channel with oscillatory stretching walls : application to the dynamics of blood flow , _
j. eng . math .
_ , * 69 * ( 2011 ) , 91 - 100 .
+ fig . 3 velocity distribution in the radial direction at different axial position @xmath2 ,
when @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
+ + fig .
4 variation of axial velocity along axial direction for different values of @xmath8 , when @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
+ + fig .
5 variation of axial velocity at @xmath82 for different values of @xmath0 , when @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath81 .
+ + fig .
6 velocity distribution at @xmath82 for different values of @xmath73 , when @xmath77 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
+ + fig .
7 variation of axial velocity for different values of the permeability parameter @xmath74 at @xmath82 , when @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
+ + fig.8 variation of axial velocity in the radial direction for different values of @xmath18 @xmath82 , when @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 . + + fig .
9 variation of pressure gradient ( @xmath83 ) for different values of @xmath73 when @xmath77 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
+ + fig .
10 variation of pressure gradient ( @xmath83 ) with @xmath2 for different values of @xmath74 when @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , when @xmath80 .
+ + fig .
11 variation of pressure gradient ( @xmath83 ) for different values of @xmath18 when @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
+ + fig .
12 variation of pressure gradient ( @xmath83 ) with @xmath2 for different values of @xmath0 when @xmath77 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath81 .
+ + fig . 13 distribution of wall shear stress @xmath84 along with @xmath2 for different values of @xmath18 when @xmath81 , @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath80 + + fig .
14 distribution of wall shear stress @xmath84 along with @xmath2 for different values of @xmath0 when @xmath77 , @xmath79 , @xmath78 and @xmath81 . | this paper presents a theoretical study of blood flow through a tapered and overlapping stenosed artery under the action of an externally applied magnetic field .
the fluid ( blood ) medium is assumed to be porous in nature .
the variable viscosity of blood depending on hematocrit ( percentage volume of erythrocytes ) is taken into account in order to improve resemblance to the real situation . the governing equation for laminar , incompressible and newtonian fluid subject to the boundary conditions
is solved by using a well known frobenius method .
the analytical expressions for velocity component , volumetric flow rate , wall shear stress and pressure gradient are obtained .
the numerical values are extracted from these analytical expressions and are presented graphically .
it is observed that the influence of hematocrit , magnetic field and the shape of artery have important impact on the velocity profile , pressure gradient and wall shear stress .
moreover , the effect of primary stenosis on the secondary one has been significantly observed .
* keywords : * _ overlapping stenoses , tapered artery , mhd flow , porous vessel , hematocrit , frobenius method _ 0.8 cm -.1 in -.1 in 0.0 cm [ section ] [ theorem]definition [ theorem]observation [ theorem ] [ theorem]proposition [ theorem]rule 23.0 cm = currsize |
recently , many efforts have been devoted to the entanglement in strongly correlated systems@xcite , in the hope that its non - trivial behavior in these systems may shed new lights on the understanding of physical phenomena of condensed matter physics .
a typical case is the relation of entanglement to quantum phase transition@xcite .
for example , osterloh _ el al.,_@xcite reported that the entanglement shows scaling behavior in the vicinity of quantum phase transition point of the transverse - field ising model .
most of previous works are for spin 1/2 systems , where the degrees of freedom at each site ( or qubit ) is 2 . for these systems ,
the entanglement of formation , i.e. , the concurrence@xcite , is often used as a measure of pairwise entanglement between two qubits .
such measure is only valid for @xmath2 systems .
if the degrees of freedom at each qubit is larger than 2 ( for example , the spin 1 system or systems consisting of fermions with spin ) , how to quantity the entanglement of arbitrary entangled state is a challenging issue .
several studies @xcite were devoted to this issue . for example , mintert _ et al .
_ obtained a lower bound for the concurrence of mixed bipartite quantum states in arbitrary dimensions .
nevertheless , it is still very difficult to provide a reliable measure for the pairwise entanglement of systems with the number of local states larger than 2 . to the best of our knowledge , none of previous work investigated the pairwise entanglement for systems consisting of electrons with spin , such as the hubbard model ,
although there were a few works studied the local entanglement of fermionic models @xcite . in this paper , we introduce and study the fermionic concurrence by using the extended hubbard dimer as an example .
besides its importance in exploring many - body correlation in condensed matter physics , a dimer system also has potential utility in the design of quantum device@xcite . by considering the pauli s principle ,
we first illustrate how to quantify the fermionic concurrence in the hubbard model and formulate it in terms of fermion occupation and correlation so one can easily calculate it . then based on the exact solution of the hubbard dimer
, we obtain the result at the ground state and show that the fermionic concurrence could be used to distinguish state exhibiting charge - density correlation from state exhibiting spin - density correlation .
we also study its behavior at finite temperatures @xcite , and find that it is a decreasing function of temperature .
moreover , we investigate the behavior of the concurrence under a nonuniform local potential and magnetic field @xcite .
we find that the concurrence could be modulated by these local fields .
our work therefore not only provides a possible way to investigate the pairwise entanglement in the electronic system , but also enriches our physical intuition on the systems with both charge and spin degree of freedom .
some results are instructive for future experiments .
the hamiltonian of the one - dimensional extended hubbard model reads @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 create and annihilate an electron of spin @xmath7 at site @xmath8 , respectively , and the hoping amplitude @xmath9 is set to unit .
at each site , there are four possible states , @xmath10-site system is of @xmath11 dimension , and @xmath12 are its natural bases .
therefore any state in such a system can be expressed as a superposition of the above bases .
we consider reduced density matrix @xmath13 of site @xmath8 and @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the thermal density matrix of the system , and @xmath16 stands for tracing over all sites except the freedom of @xmath8th and @xmath14th site .
thus @xmath17 defines the quantum correlation between site @xmath8 and site @xmath14 .
however , since there does not exist a well - defined entanglement measurement for a mixed state of @xmath18 bipartite systems , it is impossible to study the entanglement between two sites exactly .
fortunately , the hilbert space of site @xmath8 and @xmath14 can be expressed in a direct - product form of electrons with spin up and spin down , that is , for site @xmath8 and @xmath14 , we have two subspaces , one with the bases @xmath19 , and the other one with @xmath20 symmetry
. the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) possesses u(1)@xmath21su(2 ) symmetry , i.e. , it is invariant under the gauge transformation @xmath22 and spin rotation @xmath23 , which manifest the charge and spin conservation .
the latter implies the absence of coherent superposition between configurations with different eigenvalues of @xmath24 .
thus the reduced density of electrons with spin - up on two sites has the form @xmath25 in the standard bases latexmath:[$|0 , 0\rangle , |0 , \uparrow\rangle , density matrix @xmath17 are related to single occupation and correlations between the two sites , @xmath27 where @xmath28 denotes the expectation value of the corresponding operator .
we use the concurrence as a measure of entanglement for such two - qubit system .
it is defined in terms of the spectrum of the matrix @xmath29@xcite where @xmath30 .
precisely , if @xmath31s are eigenvalues of @xmath29 and @xmath32 , the concurrence can then be calculated as @xmath33.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since there exists a monotonous relation between the concurrence and the entanglement of formation @xmath34 , @xmath35 , where @xmath36 @xcite , we will hereafter use the concurrence instead of entanglement of formation in our study . from eq .
( [ eq : reducemat ] ) , the fermionic concurrence can be calculated as @xmath37
in this section , we consider a model which consists of two sites and two electrons , because not only can it be exactly solved , but also it gives us a clear physical picture .
the hamiltonian for the dimer reads @xmath38 in the standard bases @xmath39 of the reduced subspace with zero magnetization : @xmath40 , @xmath41 is a @xmath42 matrix @xmath43 and we can easily obtain its eigenfunction @xmath44 + \frac{\cos\theta}{\sqrt{2}}\left[|\uparrow , \downarrow\rangle + & & \psi_2=\frac{\cos\theta}{\sqrt{2}}\left[|\uparrow\downarrow , 0 \rangle + |0 , \uparrow\downarrow\rangle\right ] - \frac{\sin\theta}{\sqrt{2}}\left[|\uparrow , \downarrow\rangle + & & \psi_3=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[|\uparrow\downarrow , 0 \rangle - & & \psi_4=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left[|\uparrow , \downarrow\rangle - @xmath45 is defined as @xmath46 the corresponding eigenvalues are @xmath47 > from the ground - state wavefunction , we have @xmath48 thus , the fermionic concurrence takes the form of @xmath49 and @xmath1 .
the curves in the @xmath50 plane constitutes a contour map , and the thick line denotes the local extremum .
[ figure_vuc ] , width=321 ] ) as a function of @xmath0 and @xmath51 .
[ figure_ve0 ] , width=321 ] of the fermionic concurrence as a function of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
[ figure_tth ] , width=321 ] clearly , the ground - state wavefunction simultaneously comprises the states of the double occupied state @xmath52 and the single occupied state @xmath53 .
the magnitude of @xmath45 determines which of them dominates in the ground state . from its definition , it is easy to learn that the line @xmath54 , i.e. @xmath55 , separates the two regions .
one region dominated by @xmath56 corresponds to the charge - density - wave state for a large system , and the other one dominated by @xmath57 , and shows the mirror symmetry along the line @xmath58 ( see figure [ figure_vuc ] ) . at finite temperatures , the expectation value of a given operator @xmath59 is @xmath60 , where @xmath61 , @xmath62 is the partition function , and @xmath63 denotes the energy spectra . for the present model , we should also take into account states in the subspace with @xmath64 besides that of @xmath40 .
then we have two additional states @xmath65 with the same eigenvalue @xmath66 .
thus the fermionic concurrence of the hubbard dimer takes the form , @xmath67 .
\label{eq : contemp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is not difficult to prove that the above expression is a decreasing function of @xmath51 , as shown in figure [ figure_ve0 ] for a specific value of @xmath68 . in the high temperature limit , @xmath69 ,
the boltzmann weight of each eigenstate becomes almost equal , so the first term in the square brackets of eq .
( [ eq : contemp ] ) becomes negative and we have a vanishing fermionic concurrence .
hence we expect that there exists a threshold temperature @xmath70 at which the concurrence becomes zero .
precisely , it is determined by @xmath71 clearly , the hoping - correlation @xmath72 arises from the state of @xmath73 and @xmath74 , and charge correlation @xmath75 from @xmath76 .
since the boltzmann weight @xmath77 of @xmath73 is always larger than @xmath78 , the term of absolute value is then positive for finite @xmath51 .
however , the term @xmath79 in the expression of boltzmann wight breaks the mirror symmetry of the fermionic concurrence at the ground - state along the line @xmath54 .
for example , the concurrence in the fourth quadrant of the @xmath80 plane is more susceptive to thermal fluctuation and might be easily suppressed to zero than other quadrants .
therefore , in different quadrants , the effect of thermal fluctuation is quite different . then from eq .
( [ eq : tccond ] ) , we obtain a slope - like threshold temperature for the concurrence ( see figure [ figure_tth ] ) .
( @xmath81 instead of @xmath82 as an indictor for axes ) and v at the ground - state . here , @xmath83 .
[ figure_vu00 ] , width=321 ]
in this section , we would like to consider the behavior of the concurrence under an external field . in general , a uniform external field , like the local potential or the magnetic field , suppresses the concurrence since it frustrates the hoping process .
thus we are only interested in the case with a nonuniform field . moreover , differing from the previous investigation where calculations were done for canonical ensembles , we perform calculation for grand canonical ensembles .
the first case we consider is to add site energy term to the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltoina_twosite ] ) @xmath84 for simplicity , we set @xmath85 , since the main physics is not changed under this condition .
( @xmath81 instead of @xmath82 as an indictor for axes ) and v at @xmath86 . here
[ figure_vu01 ] , width=321 ] and v at the ground - state . here
[ figure_vb00 ] , width=321 ] and v at @xmath86 . here
[ figure_vb01 ] , width=321 ] we show the fermionic concurrence as a function of @xmath82 and @xmath1 as well as its corresponding contour map in the ground - state for a specific value of @xmath83 in fig .
[ figure_vu00 ] .
clearly the ground - state phase diagram can be obtained from the contour map .
the area outside the arc is the spin singlet state described in eq .
( [ eq : gsss ] ) , while the inside area is one - particle state .
thus the arc in the contour - map is just the level crossing point for different states
. the level - crossing also leads to a jump on the surface of the concurrence in the @xmath87 plane . since the experiments are always done at finite temperatures , it is useful to investigate the effect of thermal fluctuation .
we show the dependence of the fermionic concurrence on @xmath82 and @xmath1 at @xmath86 in fig .
[ figure_vu01 ] where we observe that the jump at the level - crossing point in fig .
[ figure_vu00 ] is eliminated by the thermal fluctuation .
we find , at some points , eg . , @xmath83 and @xmath88 , the concurrence is small when @xmath89 .
if we change the value of @xmath82 the thermal concurrence can be increased substantially .
such a role played by the local potential is important , because the change of @xmath82 in principle can be realized by the electric field so it provides a possible way to control the magnitude of the concurrence .
the second case we consider is to add a zeeman - like term to the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltoina_twosite ] ) @xmath90 for simplicity , we again set @xmath91 .
we show the concurrence as a function of @xmath92 and @xmath1 for a specific value of @xmath83 in the ground state in fig .
[ figure_vb00 ] , and at @xmath86 in fig .
[ figure_vb01 ] , respectively .
similar to the first case , the magnetic field may also induce the level - crossing in the ground - state , which may lead to a quantum phase transition .
the induced level - crossing results in a jump on the surface of the concurrence in the @xmath93 plane .
such a jump is blurred by the thermal fluctuation , as shown in fig .
[ figure_vb01 ] .
here we have an interesting phenomena : although the fermionic concurrence is defined in a single sector , such as for spin - up electrons only , it can still be modulated by the other sector ( spin - down electron ) through magnetic field .
for the present case , the magnetic field does not always decrease the concurrence , it may actually increase the concurrence in some regions .
therefore , a nonuniform magnetic field can be in favor of the entanglement of formation between two qubits .
in summary , we first presented a possible way to study the concurrence as a measure of pairwise entanglement for fermionic systems .
then we studied its behavior in the hubbard dimer both at zero and finite temperatures .
it was interesting to observe that the classification of two different regions , one dominated by the charge - density correlation @xmath94 $ ] while the other one dominated by the spin - density correlation @xmath95 for general @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and found that it is a decreasing function of the temperature , which leads to a condition of the threshold temperature where the concurrence vanishes .
we then obtained the threshold temperature as a function of @xmath0 and @xmath1 numerically .
our method , as we pointed out in the introduction , could be easily extended to other electronic systems .
results obtained in this paper help us gain more insight into physical properties of strongly correlated systems . moreover , we studied the role of nonuniform local potential as well as magnetic field for the extended hubbard dimer .
we found that both of them can be used to modulate the concurrence .
though our analysis is based on a specific value of @xmath83 , the main physics is the same for other positive @xmath0 .
finally , we want to point out that although results obtained in this paper are for a 2-site ( dimer ) system , their qualitative features should be the same for big size system . | in this paper , we introduce and study the fermionic concurrence in a two - site extended hubbard model .
its behaviors both at the ground state and finite temperatures as function of coulomb interaction @xmath0 ( on - site ) and @xmath1 ( nearest - neighbor ) are obtained analytically and numerically .
we also investigate the change of the concurrence under a nonuniform field , including local potential and magnetic field , and find that the concurrence can be modulated by these fields .
# 1#1 # 1#1 |
the surface brightness fluctuations ( sbf ) method measures the intrinsic pixel - to - pixel intensity variance in a galaxy image resulting from statistical fluctuations in the numbers and luminosities of the stars within individual pixels . since the sbf signal is convolved with the point spread function , one measures the fourier space amplitude of the power spectrum on the scale of the psf in the galaxy - subtracted .
the ratio of sbf variance to galaxy surface brightness has units of flux and scales inversely with the square of the galaxy distance .
this ratio is usually converted to a magnitude called @xmath4 .
the distance can be determined if the absolute @xmath0 , which depends on both the photometric bandpass and the stellar population , is known from empirical or theoretical calibration .
sbf measurements in multiple bands can provide useful distance - independent information on the stellar content of a galaxy . the sbf method was first quantified by tonry & schneider ( 1988 ) .
the cefal stellar populations workshop where this contribution was presented marked an interesting anniversary , being twenty years to the month since the publication of that seminal work .
the first major application of the sbf method was by tonry et al .
( 1990 ) for a sample of virgo galaxies in the @xmath5 bandpasses .
they also made a first attempt to predict the behavior of @xmath0 as a function of galaxy color .
soon afterward , tonry ( 1991 ) presented the first fully empirical sbf calibration , giving @xmath6 as a function of @xmath7 .
following these early efforts , a large ground - based sbf survey ( tonry et al .
1997 , 2001 ) presented a redetermination of the empirical @xmath8-band sbf calibration and measured distances for 300 early - type galaxies and spiral bulges within about 40 mpc . for a comprehensive review of the first decade of sbf studies , see blakeslee , ajhar , & tonry ( 1999 ) .
although the major part of sbf research has been concerned with the measurement of extragalactic distances , peculiar velocities , and three - dimensional structure in the local universe , recently there has been renewed interest in sbf as a stellar population indicator .
this is because sbf is sensitive to the properties of the brightest stars in a galaxy in a given bandpass , and the detailed evolution of these brightest stars is usually not well constrained , especially for old , metal - rich stellar populations .
there are few if any galactic or magellanic star clusters where such models can be tested directly against resolved stellar systems .
there have been several recent theoretical efforts to predict sbf magnitudes for various bandpasses and stellar populations ( liu et al . 2000 ;
blakeslee et al .
2001 ; mei et al . 2001 ; cantiello et al .
2003 ; mouhcine et al .
2005 ; raimondo et al . 2005
; marin - franch & aparicio 2006 ; lee et al .
cervio et al .
( 2008 ) have recently made a rigorous study of the theoretical underpinnings of the sbf method .
optical and near - ir sbf measurements for magellanic cloud star clusters of varying ages also provide important tests for stellar population models ( gonzlez et al .
2004 ; gonzlez - lpezlira et al.2005 ; raimondo et al .
although there is broad agreement in the predictions for the most common sbf bandpasses ( especially @xmath8 band ) , the agreement among different models , and between models and observations , worsens in the near - ir and uv / blue
. we can not be comprehensive in the limited space of this review , and we refer the interested reader to the original works for details .
see also the contributions by m. cantiello , r. gonzalez - lopezlira , and g. raimondo in this volume .
here we simply highlight a few results from recent sbf work related to stellar population issues .
in order to work as a distance indicator , the stellar population dependence of the sbf magnitude must be well calibrated .
this has worked best in the @xmath8 and @xmath2 bands , where the relation between @xmath4 and galaxy color has the smallest scatter ( e.g. , blakeslee et al .
2001 ; c^ ot ' e et al .
we now discuss the most recent calibrations of the sbf method and the difficulties ( and opportunities ) in modeling the stellar population effects on sbf magnitudes at various wavelengths . _
2.1 sbf as a distance indicator : some recent work _ most of the recent work on sbf distances has focused either on dwarf galaxies in southern groups and clusters observed with large aperture ground - based telescopes ( e.g. , jerjen et al . 2004 ; mieske et al . 2006 ; dunn & jerjen 2006 ) or on early - type galaxies observed with the _ hst _
advanced camera for surveys wide field channel ( acs / wfc ) .
sbf studies with acs / wfc f814w bandpass ( similar to @xmath8 ) include the first optical sbf distances out to @xmath9100 mpc or beyond ( biscardi et al . 2008 ; blakeslee et al . , in preparation ) , a measurement of the distance of the peculiar gas - rich lenticular galaxy ngc1533 in the dorado group ( barber degraaff et al . 2007 ) , and studies of sbf gradients in galaxies ( cantiello et al.2005 , 2007b ; discussed below ) . the most extensive sbf work with the acs to date has been in the f850lp band ( z_850@xmath10 ) as part of the acs virgo and fornax cluster surveys ( c^ ot ' e et al.2004 ; jordn et al .
mei et al .
( 2005 , 2007 ) present the sbf analysis , calibration , distance measurements for 90 early - type galaxies in the acs virgo survey , and blakeslee et al .
( 2009 ) present the same for 43 galaxies in the acs fornax survey .
the latter study also presents a recalibration based on the combined virgo and fornax samples . vs @xmath11 color calibration for our acs virgo and fornax cluster survey galaxies ( from blakeslee et al .
sbf magnitudes for the fornax galaxies are shifted brighter by the best - fit relative distance modulus of @xmath12 mag .
the curve represents the best - fit cubic polynomial calibration for the dependence of @xmath13 on @xmath11 .
[ fig : finalcal ] ] figure [ fig : finalcal ] shows the resulting z_850@xmath10-band sbf calibration from blakeslee et al .
the dependence of @xmath13 on @xmath11is nonlinear and can be well described by a cubic polynomial .
the fit yields a highly precise relative distance modulus of @xmath12 mag ( including systematic uncertainties ) for fornax with respect to virgo .
the intrinsic scatter in the method is estimated empirically to be just 0.06 mag for galaxies with @xmath14 , but increases at bluer colors ( the compactness of fornax makes it possible to measure this small intrinsic scatter ) .
mei et al .
( 2005 ) showed that the general behavior ( with a zero - point shift ) of sbf in z_850@xmath10 was reasonably approximated by predictions from bruzual & charlot ( 2003 ) simple stellar population ( ssp ) models of varying age and metallicity .
however , it is not possible to predict the scatter in the sbf relations from ssp models .
chemo - evolutionary or semi - analytic models are required for this , although some estimates can be made from simple monte carlo simulations ( blakeslee et al .
2001 ) . a fully successful model should predict the very tight @xmath13 vs @xmath11 relation with increased scatter at the blue end . at present ,
significant uncertainties remain in sbf model predictions even in well - studied bandpasses .
for instance , figure [ fig : padteri ] compares sbf predictions in the @xmath8 band from padova and teramo / basti ssp models ( see lee et al .
2009 for full details ) .
the predictions are given both with and without the contributions from the thermally pulsing agb ( tp - agb ) stage .
two things are worth noting : there are large differences between the two sets of model predictions ( left panel ) , and the highly uncertain tp - agb stage has a very large effect ( compare left and right panels ) .
the agreement between the sets of models is better when this stage is omitted , but of course it is needed to match the observations ( represented by the thick lines )
. band , with ( left ) and without ( right ) the thermally pulsing agb ( tp - agb ) stage , adapted from lee et al .
( 2009 ) . at each of four different ages , models with five different metallicities
are connected by the thin lines . for reference ,
the large solid squares mark the solar metallicity models of varying age .
the empirical @xmath8-band sbf relations are shown by the bent thick lines ( see lee et al .
2009 for details ) .
[ fig : padteri ] ] _ 2.2 multi - band sbf : hot horizontal branches , tp - agb , post - agb , etc .
_ worthey ( 1993b ) showed theoretically that sbf measurements in the uv could provide quantitative information on the presence of extended hot horizontal branch stars in elliptical galaxies and other unresolved stellar systems . according to the models used by worthey
, the presence of a hot horizontal branch could make the @xmath15-band sbf magnitude brighter by 3 mag in a metal - rich early - type galaxy .
the effect at shorter wavelengths , such as the f284w band of _
hst_/wfpc2 , was even larger .
however , the sbf signal is very faint at these wavelengths , and to date there have been no practical demonstrations of the usefulness of @xmath15-band sbf for this purpose . with the coming of large ground - based telescopes equipped with blue sensitive detectors ( and hopefully the uvis channel of wfc3 )
this may soon change .
although the acs / wfc has no sensitivity shortward of 4000 , this instrument ( before its sad demise ) afforded the first samples of reliable @xmath16-band ( f435w ) sbf measurements beyond the local group ( cantiello et al.2007b ) , which have proven to have interesting implications for stellar population synthesis .
cantiello et al .
( 2007b ) demonstrated the sensitivity of sbf @xmath17@xmath18@xmath19 colors to the rate of post - agb evolution .
the observational data disagreed with standard model predictions , but cantiello et al . showed that the models could be brought into agreement with the data by adjusting the post - agb evolution to agree with that inferred for resolved stars in m32 .
the hot post - agb stars have a proportionately larger effect on @xmath17 than on @xmath19 . however , this solution was not unique , since an unmodeled hot horizontal branch or other missing components could also cause the observed discrepancy .
additional sbf measurements in the uv ( to constrain further the properties of the hot component ) and near - ir ( sensitive to the post - agb star progenitors ) could fully resolve this issue .
multi - band optical / ir sbf data are thus relevant to such problems as agb evolution and the uv excess in elliptical galaxies ( e.g. , buzzoni & gonzalez - lopezlira 2008 ) . , but here shown for the _ hst _ nicmos f160w band .
the empirical relation from jensen et al .
( 2003 ) is shown as a thick solid line .
the importance of the tp - agb phase is considerably greater in the near - ir .
the effect of these stars in fact reverses the sense of the dependence of the sbf magnitude on color , so that the near - ir sbf brightens as observed at bluer colors , instead of becoming fainter as it would without the tp - agb .
see lee et al .
( 2009 ) for details .
[ fig : padter160 ] ] blakeslee et al .
( 2001 ) found that the treatment of the agb phase was responsible for some large discrepancies in the near - ir sbf predictions of different models ; see also the discussion by liu et al .
figure [ fig : padter160 ] , adapted from lee et al .
( 2009 ) shows a dramatic demonstration of the effects of the tp - agb phase on near - ir sbf ( in the _
hst_f160w bandpass ) .
for both the padova and teramo / basti sets of models , the inclusion of the tp - agb phase actually reverses the sense of the dependence of the sbf magnitude on integrated color ( at least for age @xmath20 gyr ) .
the original expectations from models were that near - ir sbf magnitudes would brighten at redder colors ( e.g. , worthey 1993a ) .
it was a surprise when the reverse was found observationally ( jensen et al .
1998 , 2003 ) .
the modeling of the agb phase was likely much of the reason for the erroneous prediction .
for the most part , the inclusion of the agb in population synthesis relies on imperfectly constrained empirical prescriptions , rather than true evolutionary models .
it is evident from the figures and comparisons with observations that nature has ordained a better behaved agb phase than those included in the population models .
the relations between sbf magnitude and integrated color are tighter than might be expected from current models .
sbf data can provide powerful constraints to aid in the development of true agb evolutionary codes for inclusion in the next generation of stellar population models .
until now we have discussed mean colors and sbf magnitudes , but these quantities vary within galaxies , most notably because of radial gradients in stellar population properties .
sbf gradients were known from ground - based data for a few galaxies ( tonry 1991 ; sodemann & thomsen 1995 , 1996 ; tonry et al .
2001 ) , but until recently there were no systematic studies .
ngc205 was the first galaxy where an sbf gradient was noted .
it is unusual in that its center is blue and it becomes redder outward , the reverse of typical gradients .
this is because the gradient is due to relatively recent central star formation , and therefore an age effect .
the slope of the dependence of _
i@xmath21 on @xmath7 is also shallower than that of the mean dependence for galaxies .
colors and @xmath8-band sbf measurements in a series of concentric annuli are shown for seven early - type galaxies studied by cantiello et al.(2005 ) with the acs / wfc . in all of these galaxies ,
the color gets bluer and _
i@xmath21 brighter with increasing radial distance from the galaxy center .
the vertical shifts are due to the different galaxy distances ( see cantiello et al . 2005 , 2007a for details ) .
[ fig : gradients ] ] cantiello et al .
( 2005 , 2007a ) have used the acs / wfc to make the first studies of sbf gradients in significant samples of galaxies ( see figure [ fig : gradients ] ) .
they show that the size of the internal sbf vs color slope for multiple annuli within a galaxy can reveal whether the gradients are due to age or metallicity . in most cases , they are metallicity gradients , but in some cases an age gradient appears equally or more important .
the galaxies with age gradients tend to be bluer and show some evidence for past mergers ( e.g. , ngc1344 ) . at these optical wavelengths ,
age and metallicity variations cause qualitatively similar sbf vs color relations , though with different slopes .
it would be extremely interesting to study internal sbf gradients in the near - ir where pure age or metallicity variations would translate to very different dependences of sbf magnitude on color . with improvements in near - ir instruments , this is now becoming possible .
color is plotted as a function of the `` fluctuation count '' @xmath22 , the difference between sbf magnitude @xmath13 and total @xmath2 magnitude of the galaxy , for galaxies in virgo ( open circles ) fornax ( filled circles ) .
note that @xmath23 , like @xmath11 , is distance - independent and can therefore be used for an alternative calibration of the sbf method ( see blakeslee et al .
2009 ) . unlike color
, @xmath24 is also independent of galactic extinction .
the dashed and solid lines show the best - fit linear and quadratic relations , respectively .
@xmath24 is closely related to the stellar mass of the galaxy , and the correlation with color results from the mass - metallicity scaling relation ; the scatter increases at blue colors and low luminosities . [ fig : gznbar ] ]
the distance - independent `` fluctuation count '' @xmath24 is defined as @xmath25 $ ] ( tonry et al .
2001 ) , where @xmath26 is the galaxy total luminosity and @xmath27 is the mean `` fluctuation luminosity '' corresponding to magnitude @xmath0 , which depends on the stellar population .
the ratio @xmath28 is a distance - independent galaxy luminosity in units of @xmath27 and scales with the number of stars in the galaxy ( and thus with stellar mass ) .
figure [ fig : gznbar ] shows the correlation of @xmath24 with color from blakeslee et al .
( 2009 ) , a consequence of the mass - metallicity relation . @xmath24 also shows a good correlation with velocity dispersion @xmath29 , tighter than even the mg@xmath30-@xmath29 relation ( blakeslee et al .
2002 ) .
the correlation with color means that @xmath24 can also be used to calibrate sbf distances . depending on the color baseline and properties of the data sample , the sbf calibration based on @xmath24 may show less scatter than that from color ( blakeslee et al . 2002 , 2009 ) .
however , the calibration is then no longer based purely on stellar population properties , but involves a galaxy mass scaling relation .
thus , luminous blue galaxies and small red galaxies deviate from the calibration , and there may be systematic environmental effects similar those of the fundamental plane . for these reasons ,
the preferred calibration uses galaxy color , but the behavior of @xmath24 itself would be interesting to examine with semi - analytic galaxy modeling .
multi - band sbf studies are a unique and quite promising way of constraining stellar population properties , especially when combined with additional information .
sbf data could help enormously in understanding tp - agb evolution and hot stellar components in elliptical galaxies .
although there has been much theoretical modeling in this regard , the observational studies to date have been limited .
the current lack of an efficient large - format space - based camera is a big blow , but currently available large - format near - ir imagers and the coming generation of multi - band digital sky surveys provide interesting prospects for new sbf studies .
we have only scratched the surface of this field .
i wish to thank the conference organizers for inviting me to talk on this subject .
i am indebted to my collaborators on the acs virgo and fornax cluster surveys for their many contributions to this work , my colleagues at teramo observatory for their hospitality following the conference , and hyun - chul lee for providing figures prior to publication .
barber degraaff , r. , blakeslee , j. p. , meurer , g. r. , & putman , m. e. 2007 , , 671 , 1624 biscardi , i. , raimondo , g. , cantiello , m. , & brocato , e. 2008 , , 678 , 168 blakeslee , j. p. , ajhar , e. a. , & tonry , j. l. 1999 , post - hipparcos cosmic candles , 237 , 181 blakeslee , j. p. , vazdekis , a. , & ajhar , e. a. 2001 , , 320 , 193 blakeslee , j. p. et al .
2002 , , 330 , 443 blakeslee , j. p. , et al . 2009 , , 694 , 556 bruzual , g. , & charlot , s. 2003 , , 344 , 1000 buzzoni , a. , & gonzlez - lpezlira , r. a. 2008 , , 686 , 1007 cantiello , m. , blakeslee , j.p . , raimondo , g. , mei , s. , brocato , e. , capaccioli , m. 2005 , , 634 , 239 cantiello , m. , blakeslee , j.p . , raimondo , g. , brocato , e. , capaccioli , m. 2007a , , 668 , 130 cantiello , m. , raimondo , g. , blakeslee , j. p. , brocato , e. , & capaccioli , m. 2007b , , 662 , 940 cantiello , m. , raimondo , g. , brocato , e. , & capaccioli , m. 2003 , , 125 , 2783 cervio , m. , luridiana , v. , & jamet , l. 2008 , , 491 , 693 c^ ot ' e , p. et al .
2004 , , 153 , 223 dunn , l. p. , & jerjen , h. 2006 , , 132 , 1384 gonzlez , r. a. , liu , m. c. , & bruzual a. , g. 2004 , , 611 , 270 gonzlez - lpezlira , r. a. et al .
2005 , , 363 , 1279 jensen , j. b. , tonry , j. l. , & luppino , g. a. 1998 , , 505 , 111 jensen , j. b. et al .
2003 , , 583 , 712 jerjen , h. , binggeli , b. , & barazza , f. d. 2004 , , 127 , 771 jordn , a. et al .
2007 , , 169 , 213 lee , h .- c . , worthey , g. , & blakeslee , j. p. 2009
, , submitted ( arxiv:0902.1177 ) liu , m. c. , charlot , s. , & graham , j. r. 2000 , , 543 , 644 marn - franch , a. , & aparicio , a. 2006 , , 450 , 979 mei , s. , quinn , p. j. , & silva , d. r. 2001 , , 371 , 779 mei , s. et al .
2005 , , 625 , 121 mei , s. et al .
2007 , , 655 , 144 mieske , s. , hilker , m. , & infante , l. 2006 , , 458 , 1013 mouhcine , m. , gonzlez , r. a. , & liu , m. c. 2005 , , 362 , 1208 raimondo , g. , brocato , e. , cantiello , m. , & capaccioli , m. 2005 , , 130 , 2625 sodemann , m. , & thomsen , b. 1995 , , 110 , 179 sodemann , m. , & thomsen , b. 1996 , , 111 , 208 tonry , j. l. , & schneider , d.p .
1988 , , 96 , 807 tonry , j. l. , ajhar , e. a. , & luppino , g.a . 1990 , , 100 , 1416 tonry , j. l. 1991 , , 373 , l1 tonry , j. l. , blakeslee , j. p. , ajhar , e. a. , & dressler , a. , 1997 , , 475 , 399 tonry , j. l. , dressler , a. , blakeslee , j. p. , ajhar , e. a. , et al . 2001 , , 546 , 681 worthey , g. 1993a , apj , 409 , 530 worthey , g. 1993b , apj , 415 , l91 | surface brightness fluctuations ( sbf ) can provide useful information about the unresolved stellar content of early - type galaxies and spiral bulges .
the absolute sbf magnitude @xmath0 in a given passband depends on the properties of the stellar population and can be predicted by population synthesis models .
sbf measurements in different bandpasses are sensitive to different evolutionary stages within the galaxy stellar population .
near - ir sbf magnitudes are sensitive to the evolution of stars within the agb phase , especially the thermally pulsing agb , while sbf in the blue and uv are sensitive to the hot horizontal branch and post - agb stages .
thus , multi - band sbf studies can constrain important evolutionary parameters .
empirically , sbf data at the red end of the optical spectrum ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and potentially @xmath3 ) remain excellent distance indicators .
i briefly review some recent work on stellar populations using sbf , primarily from an observational point of view .
address = herzberg institute of astrophysics , national research council of canada , victoria , b.c .
v9e 2e7 |
the standard @xmath0 gauge theory of the electroweak interactions is in good agreement with all current experimental data . nonetheless , there is no evidence to show which mechanism is responsible for the breakdown of this symmetry to the @xmath1 of electromagnetism .
it is usually assumed that electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) is due to the vacuum expectation value of one or more fundamental scalars which are doublets of @xmath2 .
this explanation is unsatisfactory for a number of reasons : @xmath3 in all such theories there must be at least one physical degree of freedom remaining from the fundamental scalar doublet(s ) , the higgs boson .
as yet , there is no direct evidence for the existence of such a state .
@xmath3 these models do not give a dynamical explanation of electroweak symmetry breaking . instead
, the potential must be adjusted to produce the desired result .
@xmath3 when embedded in theories with additional dynamics at higher energy scales , these theories are technically unnatural @xcite .
for example , in the context of grand unified theories ( guts ) radiative corrections to the higgs boson mass(es ) give contributions proportional to large ( gut - scale ) masses .
the higgs mass must be `` fine tuned '' to be of order the weak scale .
@xmath3 theories of fundamental scalars are thought to be `` trivial '' @xcite , _ i.e. _ it is not possible to construct an interacting theory of scalars ( in four dimensions ) which is valid to arbitrarily short distance scales .
rather , a theory of scalars must be viewed as a low - energy effective theory .
new physics must enter below the energy scale of the `` landau - pole '' of the scalar theory .
this last consideration implies that , whether or not a higgs boson exists , there must be new physics beyond the standard one - higgs doublet model at some ( possibly exponentially high ) energy scale . in this sense ,
theories with a weakly coupled higgs , including the ever - popular minimal supersymmetric standard model , simply allow one to postpone answering the question of what is responsible for electroweak symmetry breaking ( and other related questions such as the origin of fermion masses ) up to very high energies . in theories of dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking , such as technicolor @xcite
, ewsb is due to chiral symmetry breaking in an asymptotically - free , strongly - interacting , gauge theory with massless fermions . unlike theories with fundamental scalars , theories of dynamical ewsb are natural . like the qcd scale , @xmath4
, the weak scale arises by dimensional transmutation and can be exponentially smaller than , say , the gut or planck scales .
furthermore , non - abelian gauge theories may make sense as fundamental theories . in the simplest technicolor theory one introduces a left - handed weak - doublet of `` technifermions '' , and the corresponding right - handed weak - singlets ; both transform as @xmath5 s of a strong @xmath6 technicolor gauge group .
the global chiral symmetry respected by the strong technicolor interactions is @xmath7 .
when the technicolor interactions become strong , the chiral symmetry is broken to the diagonal subgroup , @xmath8 , producing three nambu - goldstone bosons which become , via the higgs mechanism , the longitudinal degrees of freedom of the @xmath9 and @xmath10 . because the left - handed and right - handed techni - fermions carry different electroweak quantum numbers , the electroweak interactions break down to electromagnetism .
if the @xmath11-constant of the theory , the analog of @xmath12 in qcd , is chosen to be 246 gev , then the @xmath9 mass has its observed value .
furthermore , since the symmetry structure of the theory is _ precisely _ the same as that of the standard one higgs - doublet model , the remaining @xmath8 `` custodial '' symmetry insures that @xmath13 .
in addition to the `` eaten '' nambu - goldstone bosons , such a theory will give rise to various resonances , the analogs of the @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and possibly the @xmath16 , in qcd .
the phenomenology of an @xmath17 model in general , and of resonances of this sort in particular , are discussed in ref . .
however , the symmetry breaking sector must also couple to the ordinary fermions , allowing them to acquire mass . in models of a strong electroweak symmetry breaking sector there must either be additional flavor - dependent gauge interactions @xcite , the so - called `` extended '' technicolor ( etc ) interactions , or yukawa couplings to scalars @xcite ( as in the standard model ) which communicate the breaking of the chiral symmetry of the technifermions to the ordinary fermions . the most popular type of strong ewsb model which attempts to explain the masses of all observed fermions contains an entire family of technifermions with standard model gauge couplings .
such models are referred to as one - family models . while this is a reasonable starting point for model building , given the family structure of the observed fermions , a variety of other possibilities
have been explored .
models containing more than one doublet of technifermions have a global symmetry group larger than @xmath18 .
therefore chiral symmetry breaking produces additional ( pseudo-)nambu - goldstone bosons ( pngbs ) , other than those required to provide the longitudinal degrees of freedom of the @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
furthermore , the models typically possess a larger variety of resonances than the one - doublet model .
the phenomenology of arbitrary color - neutral pngbs and resonances is similar to that discussed in ref . or , in the case of color - neutral charged pngbs , to that of the extra scalars in `` two - higgs '' models .
therefore , in this work , we will largely be concerned with the properties of colored resonances and pngbs .
these models have a possibly unique signature : resonances associated with the _ electroweak _ symmetry breaking sector which are _ strongly produced_. hadron colliders will be especially important for searching for signatures of such colored particles associated with ewsb .
in this section we survey models with a dynamical ewsb sector , and summarize some of the novel physics that may be necessary in a model consistent with present data .
we do not consider any of the models discussed in this section to be a complete theory of ewsb in fact most of these models are ruled out by one or more of the problems listed below .
their main value lies in illustrating some of the possible physics which may appear in a complete dynamical theory of ewsb .
models incorporating etc interactions ran into trouble with flavor changing neutral currents ( fcncs ) @xcite in the early 1980 s .
for example , models with flavor dependent etc gauge couplings generically produce four - fermion interactions like : @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the cosine and sine of a model - dependent mixing angle ; and @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the etc gauge boson mass and coupling respectively .
the interaction in equation ( [ 4f ] ) contributes to the @xmath24 mass splitting , and in order that this contribution be smaller than the short - distance , standard model contribution , we must have ( taking the mixing angle to be equal to the cabibbo angle ) : @xmath25 on the other hand , the mass of an ordinary fermion is expected to be given by @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the technifermion field @xcite .
if we assume that the tc dynamics is qcd - like , we can estimate the technifermion condensate by scaling from qcd @xcite : @xmath28 given that @xmath11 can not be larger , reduces the value of @xmath11 needed to generate the correct @xmath9 mass . ]
than 246 gev , it is impossible to generate a large enough mass for the @xmath29 quark ( much less the @xmath30 quark ) using the above relations .
two possible solutions to the conflict between large fermion masses and small fcncs were proposed in the mid and late 1980 s .
the first solution was to make the tc gauge coupling run slower than in qcd ( this behavior was dubbed walking ) @xcite .
this has the effect of making the technifermion condensate much larger than scaling from qcd suggests , so that for a fixed quark or lepton mass , the necessary mass scale for etc gauge bosons is increased , thus suppressing fcncs .
the second solution was to build a glashow - illiopoulos - maiani ( gim ) @xcite symmetry into the etc theory ( this is sometimes called technigim ) @xcite .
this mechanism allows for etc scales as low as 1 tev .
a further problem is how to produce a large isospin splitting for the @xmath31 and @xmath32 quark masses without producing large isospin splitting in the @xmath9 and @xmath10 masses @xcite .
isospin splitting in the gauge sector is described by the radiative correction parameter @xmath33 ( a.k.a .
@xmath34 ) , which is tightly constrained by experimental data . a completely different alternative for model building is to include a scalar that couples to both fermions and technifermions in the model @xcite .
this has the advantage that it allows for a standard gim symmetry , and can produce acceptable isospin splitting .
the scalar may be kept light by supersymmetry @xcite , or it may be a composite , formed by some strong ( fine - tuned ) four - fermion interaction , for example @xcite .
the latter possibility arises in models with strong etc interactions @xcite , which can be a natural result of walking , since walking implies that the tc coupling remains large out to the scale where tc is embedded in etc .
scalars or strong etc interactions are also helpful in producing large top quark masses .
a further twist on the tc scenario goes under the rubric of multiscale models @xcite .
the original idea was that technifermions in different representations of the tc gauge group should condense at different scales , thus producing more than one scale of ewsb .
( higher dimension tc representations may be useful for producing walking couplings . )
multiple ewsb scales can also be produced in other ways .
for example in walking and/or strong etc models , the effects of qcd interactions can produce a large splitting between techniquarks and technileptons @xcite .
an additional challenge for tc models was noticed more recently @xcite : models with qcd - like dynamics tend to produce large positive contributions to the electroweak radiative correction parameter @xmath35 which grow with the number of technicolors and the number of technidoublets , while experiments tend to prefer small values for @xmath35 .
there are several possibilities for evading this problem .
there may simply be very few technifermions which contribute to ewsb , so that the contribution to @xmath35 is small .
alternatively , mechanisms can be invented which produce a negative contribution to @xmath35 : the technifermions may have exotic electroweak quantum numbers @xcite , or the tc dynamics can be sufficiently unlike qcd so as to invalidate the naive scaling - up of qcd phenomenology @xcite .
both of these alternatives usually also rely on some form of isospin breaking .
this makes multiscale models potentially very useful since the bulk of the isospin breaking necessary to produce a negative contribution to @xmath35 can occur in the lowest ewsb scale @xcite , whereas the @xmath33 parameter is sensitive to isospin breaking at the highest ewsb scale .
the most recent problem for etc models arises from the measurement of the @xmath36 partial width at lep @xcite .
the experiments find a partial width which is slightly larger than the standard model prediction , while almost all the etc models that have been constructed so far produce a correction which further reduces this width .
the sign of the correction is a consequence of the almost universal assumption that @xmath2 commutes with the etc gauge group .
the alternative , where @xmath2 is embedded in the etc gauge group , may be interesting , since this reverses the sign of the correction @xcite .
( models with scalars and/or strong etc , can make the etc correction unobservably small @xcite . ) = .5pc
.field guide to models summary table .
the abbreviated headings are : the number of technicolors ( @xmath37 ) , the dimension of the representation which condenses to break the electroweak gauge symmetry ( @xmath38 ) , the number of doublets ( @xmath39 ) , the pattern of electroweak symmetry breaking [ 48 ] , the presence of a walking technicolor coupling , scalars and/or strong etc ( setc ) , multiscale ( ms ) , gim suppression of flavor changing neutral currents , or non - commuting ( nc ) etc and weak gauge groups . [
cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] @xmath40 decay mode @xmath41 , similar to a light neutral higgs @xcite .
+ @xmath42 decay mode @xmath43 , assuming a one - family model , with @xmath44 and @xmath45 respectively ; no reach for @xmath46 ; for larger @xmath47 couplings , the discovery reach extends to @xmath48 gev @xcite .
+ @xmath49 no reach for one - family model ; possibility of reach for the lane - ramana @xcite multiscale model in the processes @xmath50 @xcite .
the discovery reach could be greatly improved if the tlc operates in a @xmath51 mode .
+ @xmath52 estimated from work on charged higgs detection ( via @xmath53 ) for @xmath54 , @xmath55 gev , @xmath56 integrated luminosity and assuming a @xmath32-tagging efficiency @xmath57 @xcite .
+ @xmath58 current opal limit @xcite .
the kinematic limit is @xmath59 .
+ @xmath60 kinematical limits for lep200 and a @xmath61 tev @xmath62 collider ( tlc ) @xcite .
+ @xmath63 contribution to the @xmath64 cross section in multiscale models @xcite .
+ @xmath65 qcd pair production of colored pngbs with decay into @xmath66 jets @xcite .
+ @xmath67 qcd pair production of colored pngbs , each decaying to @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 or @xmath71 should allow higher reach in mass .
this has yet to be studied .
we would like to thank nick evans , howard haber , bob holdom , dimitris kominis , vassillis koulovassilopoulos , ken lane , and michael peskin for discussions and for comments on the manuscript .
r.s.c . acknowledges the support of an alfred p. sloan foundation fellowship , an nsf presidential young investigator award , and a doe outstanding junior investigator award . e.h.s .
acknowledges the support of an aauw american fellowship . this work was supported in part under nsf contract phy-9057173 and doe contract de - fg02 - 91er40676 .
k. lane , boson u. preprint buhep-94 - 2 , to appear in _ 1993 tasi lectures _
( world scientific , singapore ) ; s. king , southampton preprint shep 93/94 - 2 , hep - ph/9406401 ; m. einhorn _
perspectives on higgs physics _ , g. kane ed .
( world scientific , singapore 1993 ) 429 .
report of the strongly coupled electroweak symmetry breaking : model independent results " subgroup of the electroweak symmetry breaking and beyond the standard model " working group of the dpf long range planning study .
t. han , m. golden and g. valencia , convenors .
b. holdom , _ phys . rev _ * d24 * ( 1981 ) 1441 ; b. holdom , _ phys
. lett . _ * b150 * ( 1985 ) 301 ; k. yamawaki , m. bando , and k. matumoto , _ phys . rev .
* 56 * ( 1986 ) 1335 ; t. appelquist , d. karabali , and l.c.r .
wijewardhana , _ phys .
_ _ 57 _ ( 1986 ) 957 ; t. appelquist and l.c.r .
wijewardhana , _ phys . rev _ * d35 * ( 1987 ) 774 ; t. appelquist and l.c.r .
wijewardhana , _ phys . rev _ * d36 * ( 1987 ) 568 .
p. sikivie _ et al .
_ , _ nucl .
_ * b173 * ( 1980 ) 189 ; r. renkin and m. peskin _ nucl .
phys . _ * b211 * ( 1983 ) 93 ; t. appelquist _
_ , _ phys .
rev . _ * d31 * ( 1985 ) 1676 ; r. s. chivukula , _ phys rev . lett . _ * 61 * ( 1988 ) 2657 ; b. holdom _ phys . lett . _ * b226 * ( 1989 ) 137 ; t. appelquist _
_ , _ phys .
_ * b232 * ( 1989 ) 211 ; h. goldberg _ phys .
* 58 * ( 1987 ) 633 .
t. appelquist , m. einhorn , t. takeuchi , and l.c.r .
wijewardhana , _ phys .
lett . _ * 220b * , 223 ( 1989 ) ; v.a .
miransky and k. yamawaki , _ mod .
lett . _ * a4 * ( 1989 ) 129 ; k. matumoto _ prog .
* 81 * ( 1989 ) 277 .
b. lynn , m. peskin , and r. stuart , in _ physics at lep _ , j. ellis and r. peccei eds .
cern preprint * 86 - 02 * ( 1986 ) .
m. golden and l. randall , _ nucl .
_ * b361 * , 3 ( 1991 ) ; b. holdom and j. terning , _ phys . lett _ * b247 * , 88 ( 1990 ) ; m. peskin and t. takeuchi , _ phys . rev . lett . _ * 65 * , 964 ( 1990 ) ; a. dobado , d. espriu , and m. herrero , _ phys .
lett . _ * b253 * , 161 ( 1991 ) ; m. peskin and t. takeuchi _ phys .
_ * d46 * 381 ( 1992 ) .
b. holdom _ phys .
_ * b259 * ( 1991 ) 329 ; e. gates and j. terning _ phys .
* 67 * ( 1991 ) 1840 ; t. appelquist and g. triantaphyllou , _ phys . lett .
_ * b278 * ( 1992 ) 345 ; r. sundrum and s. hsu , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b391 * ( 1993 ) 127 ; n. evans and d. ross , _ nucl . phys . _ * b417 * ( 1994 ) 151 .
r. s. chivukula , s. b. selipsky , and e. h. simmons , _ phys .
_ * 69 * ( 1992 ) 575 ; e h. simmons , r s. chivukula and s b. selipsky , in proceedings of _ beyond the standard model iii _ , s. godfrey and p. kalyniak , eds . , ( world scientific , singapore , 1993 ) ; n. kitazawa _ phys .
lett . _ * b313 * ( 1993 ) 395 ; r. s. chivukula , e. gates , e. h. simmons , and j. terning , _ phys . lett . _ * b311 * ( 1993 ) 157 .
r. s. chivukula , h. georgi , and l. randall , _ nucl .
* b292 * ( 1987 ) 93 ; r. s. chivukula and h. georgi , _ phys .
_ * d36 * ( 1987 ) 2102 ; v. bhansali and h. georgi , _ phys .
lett . _ * b197 * ( 1987 ) 553 ; a. nelson _ phys .
* d38 * ( 1988 ) 2875 .
b. holdom , _ phys .
_ * b143 * ( 1984 ) 227 ; _ phys .
* 57 * ( 1986 ) 2496 ; _ phys .
* 58 * ( 1987 ) 177(e ) ; _ phys .
lett . _ * b246 * ( 1990 ) 169 ; _ proc .
dynamical symmetry breaking , nagoya 1991 _ ( world scientific , singapore , 1991 ) 275 .
e. eichten , i. hinchliffe , k. lane and c. quigg , ; e. eichten , i. hinchliffe , k. lane and c. quigg , . for an alternative formulation , see r. casalbuoni , s. de curtis , d. dominici and r. gatto , ; .
report of the exotica " subgroup of the electroweak symmetry breaking and beyond the standard model " working group of the dpf long range planning study .
a. djouadi , j. ng and t. rizzo , convenors .
t. das , _ et al .
_ , _ phys rev .
_ * 18 * ( 1967 ) 759 .
m. peskin , _ nucl .
_ * b175 * ( 1980 ) 197 ; j. preskill , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b177 * ( 1981 ) 21 .
r. dashen , _ phys .
* 183 * ( 1969 ) 1245 .
s. dimopoulos , ; j. ellis _ et al .
_ in ref .
; s. dimopoulos , s. raby and g. l. kane , ; f. hayot and o. napoli , .
see , e.g. , r. s. chivukula and m. golden , .
see , e.g. , j. ellis _ et al .
_ in ref . .
r. m. harris , talk given at dpf-94 , albuquerque , august 2 - 6 , 1994 .
j. bagger , s. dawson , and g. valencia , _ phys .
_ * 67*(1991 ) , 2256 .
r. s. chivukula , m. golden , and m. v. ramana , _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 68 * ( 1992 ) , 2883 .
m. soldate and r. sundrum , _ nucl . phys . _
* b340 * 1 ( 1990 ) ; r. s. chivukula , m. dugan , and m. golden , _ phys .
_ * d47 * ( 1993 ) , 2930 .
miransky , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , _ phys .
_ * b221 * ( 1989 ) 177 ; v.a .
miransky , m. tanabashi , and k. yamawaki , _ mod .
lett . _ * a4 * ( 1989 ) 1043 ; y. nambu , efi-89 - 08 ( 1989 ) unpublished ; w.j .
* 62 * ( 1989 ) 2793 ; w.a .
bardeen , c.t .
hill and m. lindner , ; c.t .
hill , .
report of the top quark as a window on electroweak symmetry breaking " subgroup of the electroweak symmetry breaking and beyond the standard model " working group of the dpf long range planning study . m. peskin and s. parke , convenors .
v. lubicz , private communication .
f. iddir , a. le yaouanc , l. olivier , o. pene and j. c. raynal , ; contributions by m. e. peskin , t. barklow and k. hikasa in _ physics and experiments with @xmath72 linear colliders _ , saariselka , finland , 1991 ; r. orava , p. eerola and m. nordberg eds . ,
world scientific , singapore 1992 .
t. barklow , talk given at dpf-94 , albuquerque , august 2 - 6 , 1994 .
p. arnold and c. wendt , _ phys .
_ * d33 * , ( 1986 ) 1873 . gem technical design report , * sscl - sr-1219 * , 1993 .
v. barger , r. j. n. phillips and d. p. roy , _ phys .
* b324 * ( 1994 ) 236 , hep - ph/9311372 ; j. f. gunion,_phys .
* b322 * ( 1994 ) 125 , hep - ph/9312201 .
this is only an estimate , since the cross section falls as @xmath73 near the threshold .
see , e.g. , p. m. zerwas , talk at lc92 , _ workshop on @xmath62 linear colliders _ , garmisch - partenkirchen ( frg ) , 1992 . | we discuss the phenomenology of models of dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking which attempt to generate the observed fermion mass spectrum .
after briefly describing the variety of and constraints on proposed models , we concentrate on the signatures of colored pseudo - nambu - goldstone bosons and resonances at existing and proposed colliders .
these particles provide a possibly unique signature : _ strongly produced _ resonances associated with _ electroweak _ symmetry breaking .
= 11 # 1cite##1##2##1 = 12 .4 in .4 in -2pc -.15 cm = # 1#2#3_nucl .
phys . _
* b#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys .
lett . _ * b#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys .
lett . _ * # 1b * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys .
rev .
_ * d#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys .
rev .
lett .
_ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys .
rep . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_ann .
rev .
astron .
astrophys . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_rev .
mod .
phys . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_ann .
rev .
nucl . part .
sci . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_mod .
phys .
lett . _ * a#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_zeit .
fr physik _
* c#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_ap .
j. _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_int .
j. mod .
phys .
_ * a#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_nuovo cim .
_ * a#1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 # 1#2#3_phys .
rev . _ * # 1 * ( 19#2 ) # 3 psfig.sty ( 0,0)(0,0 ) ( 333,330)buhep-95 - 7 ( 333,315)hep - ph/9503202 subgroup report for the electroweak symmetry breaking and beyond the standard model " working group of the dpf long range planning study .
this report will appear as a chapter in _ electroweak symmetry breaking and beyond the standard model _ , edited by t. barklow , s. dawson , h.e .
haber , and j. siegrist , to be published by world scientific . |
the recent isolation of graphene layers a single atom thick@xcite has lead to a great deal of activity , because of their novel electronic properties and potential applications .
the lattice structure of graphene is determined by the @xmath4 coordination between neighboring carbon atoms .
each carbon atom has three nearest neighbors , leading to planar honeycomb lattice . with small modifications ,
the same structure describes other carbon allotropes , such as the fullerenes and the carbon nanotubes .
in this paper we study the simplest systems which combine two of these allotropes : the junctions between a single graphene layer and carbon nanotubes .
a regular array of closely spaced armchair nanotubes attached to a graphene layer has already been studied@xcite , and related systems are being considered for their potential applications@xcite .
we undertake here the investigation of junctions made of nanotubes with different chiralities , which have in common a transition from the planar to the tubular geometry mediated by the presence of six heptagonal carbon rings .
these induce the negative curvature needed to bend the honeycomb carbon lattice at the junction , playing a kind of dual role to that of the pentagonal carbon rings in the fullerene cages@xcite .
we analyze first the electronic properties of a single junction between a carbon nanotube and a graphene layer .
we discuss the possible structures of this type , concentrating on geometries where the heptagonal rings are evenly spaced around the junction .
the nanotubes can be then either armchair @xmath0 or zig - zag with @xmath5 geometry ( that is , with @xmath6 hexagonal rings around the tube ) .
we calculate their electronic structure , using the tight - binding model based on the @xmath7 orbitals of the carbon atoms widely applied to carbon allotropes with @xmath4 coordination . paying attention to the local density of states , we find that the junctions fall into two different classes , depending on the behavior in the low - energy regime .
one of the classes , comprising the junctions made of armchair and @xmath5 nanotubes when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 , is characterized by the presence of a peak in the density of states close to the fermi level .
the peak is absent in the other class , formed by the junctions made with the rest of zig - zag geometries . in general
, the density of states tends to be depleted in the junction at low energies , with peaks above and below the fermi level marking the threshold for the propagation of new states across the junction .
we present next a continuum description , based on the formulation of dirac fermion fields in the curved geometry , which allows us to characterize the general properties of the junction , and which is consistent with the previous discrete analysis .
thus , we see that the peak at the fermi level in the local density of states is in general a reflection of the existence of quasi - bound states ( zero modes ) for the dirac equation in the curved space of the junction . it is known that the topological defects of the honeycomb lattice ( pentagonal and heptagonal rings ) induce an effective gauge field in the space of the two dirac points of the planar graphene lattice@xcite .
it turns out that the effective magnetic flux is enough to localize two states at the junctions made of armchair or @xmath5 nanotubes when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 . at low energies ,
however , the generic behavior is given by evanescent states , which arise from the matching of modes with nonvanishing angular momentum and have exponential decay in the nanotube .
we finally apply our computational framework to the analysis of the band structure of the arrays of nanotube - graphene junctions . considering the behavior of the low - energy bands close to the fermi level , we find that the arrays also fall into two different classes .
the arrays made of armchair nanotubes or @xmath5 nanotubes with @xmath2 equal to a multiple of 3 tend to have a series of flat bands close to the fermi level , while the arrays made with the rest of zig - zag nanotubes have all the bands dispersing at low energies .
such a different behavior has its origin in the existence of states confined in the nanotube side of the junction .
we find that this feature can also be explained in the context of the continuum model .
the armchair and the @xmath5 geometries with @xmath2 equal to a multiple of 3 allow for the formation of standing waves between the junction and the other end of the tube .
this is the mechanism responsible for the confinement of the states in the nanotubes and the consequent development of the flat bands , whose number grows at low energies with the length of the nanotube , in agreement with the predictions of the continuum theory .
our first aim is to analyze the density of states of a semi - infinite nanotube attached to a graphene layer in the tight - binding approximation .
the possible setups that we will consider , keeping the threefold coordination of the carbon atoms , are sketched in fig .
the structures can be wrapped by the graphene hexagonal lattice , with the exception of the six points where the sides of the hexagonal prism ( which describes the nanotube ) intersect the plane .
the threefold coordination of the carbon atoms requires the existence of sevenfold rings at those positions . + ( a ) ( b ) ( c ) we describe the electronic states in the structures shown in fig .
[ one ] by means of a nearest - neighbor tight - binding model . in general the relaxation of elastic energy will modify the bond lengths at the junction , depending on the nanotube radius .
we will assume that this relaxation does not change significantly the electronic behavior . in this respect ,
a tight - binding model based on the @xmath8 carbon orbitals is well - suited for the purpose of discerning the extended or localized character of the different electronic states .
our main achievement will be to assign the different features in the local density of states to the behavior of the electronic states near the nanotube - graphene junctions .
to this aim , we have actually checked that slight modulations of the transfer integral @xmath9 near the junctions do not produce significant changes in the results shown in what follows .
we concentrate on the analysis of geometries where the six heptagonal carbon rings are evenly spaced around the junction as in fig .
this constrains the possible chiralities of the nanotubes , that can be then either armchair @xmath0 or zig - zag @xmath1 , with the number @xmath2 running over all the integers .
nanotubes in which the carbon sheet is wrapped with helicity can be also attached at the expense of introducing an irregular distribution of the heptagonal rings .
anyhow , we expect that the rules explaining the different features in the density of states are universal enough to hold even in these more general cases
. we have obtained the spectra of different types of hybrid structures by diagonalization of the tight - binding hamiltonian for very large lattices , with up to @xmath10 carbon atoms in the graphene part and @xmath11 in the nanotube side .
given that the whole geometry has @xmath3 symmetry , we have classified the energy eigenstates into six groups according to the eigenvalue @xmath12 under a rotation of @xmath13 . the nature of each electronic state is given in general by its behavior at the nanotube - graphene junction .
for this reason , we have characterized the hybrid structures in terms of the local density of states averaged over a circular ring of atoms at the end of the nanotube close to the junction .
our computations have covered a number of structures including armchair and zig - zag nanotubes with different radii .
after inspection of all the spectra , it becomes clear that there are several generic features in the density of states .
we have represented in fig . [
two ] the behavior near the junction between a graphene layer and a ( 54,0 ) zig
- zag nanotube .
we observe that , apart from the peak close to zero energy in the sectors corresponding to @xmath14 , for @xmath15 there is always a depletion in the density of states at low energies , delimited by two abrupt upturns .
it is remarkable that the pattern in the sectors corresponding to @xmath16 reproduces the same observed for @xmath14 , but with a scale that is approximately twice larger .
the density of states in the sector with @xmath17 displays in turn a wider depletion , with the position of the peaks scaled by an approximate factor of 3 with respect to those in the @xmath14 sectors .
+ ( a ) ( b ) + + + ( c ) ( d ) in the above behavior of the density of states , the appearance of the peak close to zero in the sectors with @xmath14 is the only feature not generic for all kinds of nanotubes . in the junctions made with zig - zag nanotubes , the peak actually appears for nanotube geometries of the type @xmath5 when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 .
in this series of hybrid structures , the patterns in the density of states for each value of @xmath12 are quite similar , with the position of the corresponding peaks scaled in proportion to the radius of the nanotube . on the other hand ,
the rest of junctions , for which @xmath2 is not a multiple of 3 , display a different behavior .
we have represented in fig .
[ three ] the local density of states averaged over a ring of atoms at the end of a @xmath18 nanotube close to the junction .
it can be observed the depletion of the density of states at low energies in all but one of the @xmath12-sectors , and the absence of a peak at zero energy in any of the sectors .
the local density of states of the @xmath18 nanotube is dominated at the junction by contributions from states with @xmath16 , and this has to do with the fact that the lowest - energy subbands of a @xmath5 zig - zag nanotube have a nonvanishing angular momentum equal to @xmath19 for the motion around the tubule .
this corresponds to a quantum number @xmath20 in the case of the @xmath18 nanotube , while the low - energy states have @xmath21 in the @xmath22 nanotube .
the present picture becomes then consistent with the fact that states in higher subbands may propagate across the junction only above ( or below ) some threshold energy .
this feature will be established more precisely in the continuum approach derived below in terms of the dirac equation . + ( a ) ( b ) + + + ( c ) ( d ) at this point , the hybrid structures can be classified into two different groups , depending on whether there is a peak or not close to zero energy in the local density of states around the nanotube - graphene junction .
the peak comes actually from the contribution of a doubly degenerated level with states having @xmath14 , and whose probability distribution decays exponentially in the nanotube .
the character of these states will be established in the next section , after developing the continuum limit in terms of dirac fermion fields .
the evidence for the two different classes of hybrid structures is reinforced by the fact that the junctions made with armchair nanotubes behave in a quite similar way to that shown by the @xmath5 nanotubes when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 .
the local density of states averaged over a circular ring of atoms around the junction between a @xmath23 nanotube and a graphene layer has been represented in fig . [
we observe the presence of the peak close to zero energy in the sectors with @xmath14 .
there is a clear depletion in the local density of states at low energies except in the sector with @xmath21 , which is consistent with the fact that the lowest - energy subbands in the armchair nanotube correspond to zero angular momentum around the tubule .
+ ( a ) ( b ) + + + ( c ) ( d ) the existence of the two different classes of nanotube - graphene junctions is illustrated in fig .
[ five ] , which shows the results for the local density of states around the junction ( after summing over the sectors with different values of @xmath12 ) for the different types of nanotube considered above .
it is remarkable the similarity between the density of states for the @xmath24 and @xmath23 nanotube geometries , which have a very close value of the radius .
this suggests that there must be a universal way of understanding the low - energy electronic properties of the two different classes of junctions , independent of the details of the lattice building the junction within each class .
+ ( a ) ( b ) + + + ( c ) ( d )
we observe that the density of states summed over all values of @xmath12 tends to have an approximate linear behavior away from the very low energy regime .
this motivates the analysis of the junction in terms of the dirac equation in the hybrid geometry , as the dirac fermions provide an appropriate description of the electronic properties in the 1d carbon nanotube as well as in the 2d graphene layer .
we will then assume that the radius @xmath25 of the nanotube is much larger than the graphene lattice constant , in order to obtain the continuum limit of the tight - binding model .
within this approximation , the analysis of the electronic structure is reduced to the study of the dirac equation in a space with an abrupt change from a planar to a cylindrical structure . the transition from a geometry to the other takes place due to the presence of the six heptagonal rings at the junction .
these defects are the source of negative curvature , playing a role opposite to that of the pentagonal rings in a fullerene cage@xcite .
the heptagons , as well as the pentagons , also induce frustration in the honeycomb lattice , and lead to the exchange of the two dirac valleys of the planar geometry@xcite .
this latter effect has to be accounted for by means of an effective non - abelian gauge field operating in the space of the two independent dirac points of graphene .
it can be shown that the effective flux associated to an individual heptagonal ring is equal to @xmath26 @xcite ( in units such that @xmath27 ) .
the flux provided by the six heptagons at the junction can reach therefore a maximum of 3/2 times the flux quantum .
in general , however , the count of the total flux may not follow an additive rule , so that it can be lower than the maximum value , depending on the relative position of the heptagonal rings@xcite .
we will see that this is actually the origin of the two different classes of junctions .
note that the angular momentum around the axis of the nanotube is conserved and quantized in integer units , in a continuum description of the geometry analyzed here . on the other hand ,
the angular momentum in the plane is quantized and shifted by @xmath28 plus the number of flux quanta of the effective gauge field induced by the heptagonal rings .
the existence of topological defects which induce an effective flux at the junction allows us to match wavefunctions with different angular momenta at either side of the junction , provided that the effective flux corresponds to a half - integer number of quanta . by looking at the effect of pairs of heptagonal rings ,
the non - abelian gauge field operating in the space of the two dirac points becomes anyhow proportional to a sigma matrix @xmath29 .
we may consider then that the effect of the six heptagonal rings at the junction is described by an effective abelian field , standing for either of the eigenvalues of @xmath29 @xcite .
we end up therefore with two different dirac equations , with effective magnetic fluxes of opposite sign .
we will denote the dirac spinors satisfying the two dirac equations as @xmath30 and @xmath31 , respectively .
given that the region of the space away from the junction has no curvature , we can use radial coordinates @xmath32 to write the set of two dirac equations in the plane for @xmath33 : @xmath34 @xmath35 is the fermi velocity and the components @xmath36 and @xmath37 denote the respective amplitudes of the electron in the two sublattices of the graphene lattice .
the parameter @xmath38 corresponds to the quanta of effective flux felt by the electrons when making a complete tour around the junction . in the nanotube side ,
we use cylindrical coordinates @xmath39 , with @xmath40 .
the dirac equation for the nanotube is @xmath41 we note that ( [ dp1])-([dp2 ] ) as well as ( [ dn1])-([dn2 ] ) are expressions of the dirac equation in flat space .
this is consistent with the fact that , in the continuum limit , the curvature is localized at the circle connecting graphene and the nanotube . as an alternative to the coordinate @xmath42
, we could make for instance the change of variables @xmath43 , allowing us to map the nanotube into the region of the plane with @xmath44 .
using a common radial coordinate @xmath45 to describe both graphene and the nanotube , the metric of the space turns out to be multiplied by the conformal factor @xmath46 .
the first derivative of the metric becomes then discontinuous and the curvature scalar , computed in terms of second derivatives of the metric , is @xmath47 .
the integral of this expression corresponds actually to the total curvature provided by the heptagonal rings .
this makes clear that the effects of the curvature are implicit in the operation of matching the solutions of ( [ dp1])-([dp2 ] ) and ( [ dn1])-([dn2 ] ) at the circle @xmath48 . the solutions of the eqs .
( [ dp1])-([dp2 ] ) are of the form @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are constants , and @xmath52 and @xmath53 are bessel functions .
the energy is @xmath54 . on the other hand , the resolution of eqs .
( [ dn1])-([dn2 ] ) shows that there are propagating and evanescent waves in the nanotube , which can be written as : @xmath55 where @xmath56 and @xmath57 are constants , the energy @xmath58 is given by : @xmath59 and the phase factor in eq .
( [ pe ] ) is : @xmath60 we note that the evanescent states with longitudinal decay @xmath61 arise for nonvanishing angular momentum @xmath2 .
then there is an energy threshold @xmath62 for the appearance of propagating states in the nanotube .
this is perfectly consistent with the behavior of the local density of states obtained for the different values of @xmath12 in the tight - binding approach .
the depletion found in different @xmath12-sectors for the local density of states at the end of the nanotube ( close to the junction ) corresponds actually to the range of evanescent states given by ( [ e ] ) .
as already mentioned , the position of the peaks delimiting the depletion in the tight - binding approach scales in proportion to the value of the angular momentum , which corresponds in the lattice to the different values of @xmath12 .
moreover , we have also seen that such a position is inversely proportional to the nanotube radius @xmath25 , with values in the plots that can be approximately matched with the estimate @xmath63 ( after using the expression of the fermi velocity @xmath64 , in terms of the transfer integral @xmath9 and the c - c distance @xmath65 ) .
we find therefore that the generic features found for the local density of states in the tight - binding approach are well captured by the continuum limit based on the dirac equation .
the presence of a peak in the local density of states close to zero energy ( in the sectors @xmath66 ) is the only feature not generic for all types of nanotubes , and that can be also explained within our continuum approach .
the rotation caused by each heptagonal ring in the space of the two dirac points corresponds to an effective magnetic flux of @xmath26 @xcite , but the way this flux is combined in the case of pairs of heptagons depends on their relative position .
this has been studied in the case of pentagon pairs in ref .
, arriving at a conclusion that can be readily generalized to the case of heptagonal defects .
the result is that , when the distance between the heptagons is given by a vector @xmath67 ( using the same notation to classify the nanotubes ) such that @xmath68 is not a multiple of 3 , the effective flux of a pair of heptagons does not add to @xmath8 , but to the lower amount @xmath13 .
the number @xmath68 for the distance between heptagons is a multiple of 3 only in the case of junctions with armchair nanotubes , or with @xmath1 nanotubes when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 . in these instances ,
the total flux felt around the junction is equal to the sum of the fluxes provided by the individual heptagons , giving a value of @xmath69 . in the rest of the cases
, the total flux corresponds instead to @xmath70 .
the number @xmath38 of flux quanta has a direct correspondence with the number of zero modes of the dirac equation .
their existence rests on the possibility of having localized states at the junction , with suitable decay in both the graphene part and the nanotube side .
if we take for instance the maximum effective flux and @xmath69 , we have an equation for a zero - energy eigenstate in the region @xmath71
@xmath72 for a wavefunction with angular momentum @xmath2 , we obtain the behavior @xmath73 this gives rise to modes decaying from the junction for values @xmath74 .
the wavefunction has to be matched at @xmath48 with the appropriate dependence in the nanotube , that is @xmath75 recalling that @xmath40 , we see that only the value @xmath76 provides a localized state at the junction . on the graphene side ,
the state is not strictly normalizable , in a similar way to other half - bound states induced by defects@xcite .
anyhow , such a localized state has a reflection in the peak observed close to zero energy in the @xmath14 sectors of the tight - binding density of states . by inverting the direction of the flux and taking @xmath77
, it can be seen that the solutions have then a nonvanishing component @xmath78 similar to ( [ zm ] ) , but with angular momentum @xmath79 instead of @xmath2 .
another localized state is found therefore with opposite chirality and @xmath80 . in the case of the junctions with @xmath1 nanotubes such that @xmath2 is not a multiple of 3 ,
the flux corresponding to @xmath70 is not enough to localize states at the junction .
it can be seen that there are no zero - energy solutions of the dirac equation decaying simultaneously in the graphene plane and in the nanotube .
this explains why in this type of junctions there is no low - energy peak within the depleted region of the local density of states .
we complete in this way the correspondence between the tight - binding approach and the continuum limit based on the dirac equation , accounting for the main electronic features and unveiling also the origin of the different low - energy behavior in the two classes of junctions .
( [ e0 ] ) and ( [ pe ] ) allow us to analyze the scattering of a wave in the plane off the nanotube .
the coefficients @xmath81 and @xmath82 define the transmission and reflection by the nanotube . for a wave coming from the plane ,
the coefficient @xmath82 is zero , and @xmath83 is proportional to the transmission coefficient . using the theory of scattering of two dimensional dirac electrons by an impurity@xcite
, the transmission coefficient is given by : @xmath84 at high energies , @xmath85 or , alternatively , @xmath86 , we can use the asymptotic expansion : @xmath87 and @xmath88 . from these expansions ,
we obtain : @xmath89 so that @xmath90 .
this estimate is valid for angular momenta @xmath2 such that @xmath91 .
we can also obtain the reflection coefficient in this limit , @xmath92 , which is also independent of @xmath2 for @xmath91 .
the angular dependence of the scattering cross section @xmath93 is : @xmath94 ^ 2\ ] ] and the total cross section , @xmath95 , is proportional to @xmath96 .
the total flux of particles propagating inside the nanotube , normalized to the total incoming flux , is also proportional to @xmath96 . in the low energy limit , @xmath97
, we obtain : @xmath98 in this limit , most of the electrons reaching the junction are scattered back into the plane .
we can make use of the continuum equations to analyze systems of very large sizes .
we calculate the electronic green s functions numerically . the dirac equation in the plane , in radial coordinates , can be discretized@xcite
. each radial equation can be approximated by a nearest neighbor tight binding model with two inequivalent hoppings : @xmath99 where @xmath100 and @xmath101 give the values of @xmath102 and @xmath103 at position @xmath104 , @xmath65 being a length scale which defines the discretization .
( [ discrete ] ) also include an energy scale , @xmath9 , which plays the role of an upper cutoff .
the fermi velocity is equal to @xmath105 .
the dirac equation is obtained for @xmath106 .
we can write eqs .
( [ discrete ] ) in a more compact form using a single index , @xmath107 , such that @xmath108 and @xmath109 , so that : @xmath110 where , using as new length scale @xmath111 , we have : @xmath112\ ] ] where we start at position @xmath113 .
the diagonal green s function at site @xmath114 can be written as : @xmath115 and : @xmath116 with boundary conditions at @xmath117 and @xmath118 : @xmath119 and : @xmath120 and : @xmath121 where the radius of the nanotube is @xmath122 .
the boundary conditions in eq .
( [ bc ] ) describe a semi - infinite nanotube attached at position @xmath113 , and also approximate the boundary of a plane at position @xmath123 .
the green s function deep inside the nanotube can be calculated analytically : @xmath124 the density of states in the plane has been calculated numerically , with @xmath125 and summing angular momenta from @xmath126 to @xmath127 .
the calculation is equivalent to analyzing a cluster with @xmath128 sites .
results for the green s function in the nanotube , and at the position @xmath129 , are shown in fig .
[ dos_0 ] .
the energy scale is set by @xmath130 . .
the density of states is shown at position @xmath131 from the junction ( red , diamonds ) , and @xmath127 ( blue , hexagons).,width=302 ] the green s function for the system built up by the nanotube and the graphene sheet is shown in fig .
the parameters are the same as the ones used for the calculation shown in fig .
[ dos_0 ] , and the radius of the nanotube is @xmath132 .
the density of states at distances from the nanotube @xmath133 are similar to those in the unperturbed sheet . near the juncture with the nanotube
, there is a depletion of states at low energies , compensated by the existence of a localized state at @xmath134 .
we have not analyzed so far the effect on the electronic structure of strains which may be induced near the junction .
these strains deform the bonds , and induce an additional , intravalley gauge field acting on the electrons@xcite .
the large in - plane stiffness of graphene implies that the bonds will tend to their equilibrium lengths throughout the system .
the bending at the junction will be localized within a length scale @xmath135 , where @xmath136 ev is the bending rigidity of graphene , and @xmath137 ev @xmath138 is an average of the lam coefficients of graphene .
this length is comparable to the lattice spacing .
the mismatch between the diameter of the nanotube and the lattice constant of the graphene layer induces additional strains , with a long range decay into the bulk of the graphene plane and the nanotube , which can be calculated using the continuum theory of elasticity@xcite .
we expect , however , the interatomic distance in graphene to be very close to the distance between carbon atoms along the radial direction of the nanotube , so that the strains induced by this effect will be small . the strains will decay as @xmath139 or @xmath140 as function of the distance to the junction . using dimensional analysis , the strain near the junction is of order @xmath141 , where @xmath142 is the change in the equilibrium radius of the nanotube induced by the plane or , alternatively , of order @xmath143 , where @xmath65 is the interatomic distance .
we expect the value of @xmath143 to be similar on the plane side of the junction .
the associated gauge field is @xmath144 , where @xmath145 gives the change of the tight - binding hopping @xmath9 with @xmath65 .
thus , we expect that the elastic strains will induce changes on the electronic structure on energy scales of order @xmath146 near the junction .
our computational framework allows us also to address the electronic properties of arrays of nanotube - graphene junctions .
we consider the case in which the unit cell of the array has a hexagonal shape in the base , of the type shown in fig .
the periodic arrangement of junctions is formed then by translating the unit cell by two independent vectors of the triangular array , in such a way that the 2d base is fully covered with the hexagonal patches .
the brillouin zone of the superlattice is a hexagon , and the main electronic properties are encoded in the form of the bands from the center to the @xmath147 and @xmath148 points at the boundary of the zone .
as long as the states in momentum space have well - defined transformation properties under translations by the lattice vectors of the triangular array , we can obtain the bands of the array of junctions by solving a tight - binding model in the unit cell , with appropriate momentum - dependent boundary conditions between opposite sides of its hexagonal base .
the band structure of the array of junctions depends on the geometry of the nanotubes , as well as on their length and the distance between them . for simplicity
, we are going to consider arrays where all the nanotubes have the same chirality .
then , it can be checked that the arrays fall into two main classes , regarding the behavior of the bands close to the fermi level .
the distinctive feature of one class with respect to the other is the presence of flat bands in the low - energy part of the spectrum .
the arrays of junctions made of armchair nanotubes , for instance , always have a number of these flat bands , as illustrated by the representative in fig .
[ eight](a ) .
the appearance of flat bands in a particular array of junctions was noticed in ref . .
we have found that the flat bands are actually generic in arrays made of armchair nanotubes , which display a series of them as one moves from the fermi level to higher ( or lower ) energies .
the spacing in energy between the flat bands becomes inversely proportional to the length of the nanotubes .
the bands dispersing at low energies in fig . [ eight](a ) are not affected however by variations of that variable , while they move instead closer to the fermi level as the distance between the nanotubes in the array is increased . + ( a ) ( b ) + + + ( c ) ( d ) on the other hand , the presence of flat bands at low energies is not generic in arrays made of zig - zag nanotubes . in general
, we may expect a number of bands dispersing above and below the fermi level , as shown in figs . [
eight](b ) and ( d ) , which represent the low - energy bands of arrays made respectively of @xmath149 and @xmath150 nanotubes . in the case of the zig - zag nanotubes ,
flat bands only appear close to the fermi level when the junctions are formed with @xmath1 geometries such that @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 .
this distinctive behavior can be appreciated in fig .
[ eight](c ) , which displays the low - energy bands in the case of an array made of @xmath24 nanotubes .
the shape of the bands resembles there the typical appearance of the spectra of arrays made of armchair nanotubes , as shown in fig . [
eight](a ) .
the mentioned flat bands have their origin in the existence of localized states in the arrays of junctions .
we have checked that the junctions made of armchair nanotubes and @xmath1 nanotubes with @xmath2 equal to a multiple of 3 have in common the formation of electron states confined mostly in the nanotube side .
these are the states responsible for the development of the flat bands shown in fig .
[ eight ] , as the wave functions with most of their weight in the nanotubes show little overlap in the graphene part of the lattice .
this also explains in a natural way the proliferation of flat bands at low energies as the nanotube length is increased , by thinking of the confined modes as standing waves in the tube . on the other hand ,
the states that are preferentially localized at the junctions ( corresponding to the quasi - bound states of the dirac equation ) may be identified here as the pairs of branches degenerated at the @xmath151 point .
these states may have in general a significant overlap between nearest junctions , which is reflected in the appreciable dispersion of the corresponding bands .
we can reach in the continuum limit a qualitative understanding of the similar behavior of the arrays made of armchair and @xmath1 nanotubes when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 , by noticing that these are the only geometries that support low - energy standing waves between the junction and the other end of the tube .
this requires the superposition of two modes with opposite momenta along the tube , which is possible at low energies in the armchair nanotubes as the modes at opposite dirac points have then vanishing angular momentum . in general
, this is not the case for the @xmath1 geometries , since in the zig - zag nanotubes the dirac points correspond to large momenta in the transverse direction . yet
the formation of standing waves is possible when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 , as the low - energy states about the two dirac points fall then in the same sector with quantum number @xmath21 regarding the @xmath3 symmetry .
thus , it is possible to form a state confined in the nanotube by superposition of two modes with opposite longitudinal momenta and the same quantum number @xmath12 .
this is consistent with the fact that the confined states are actually found in the @xmath152 sector in the diagonalization of very large lattices of individual nanotube - graphene junctions . in the real lattice of the array ,
the confinement of the electrons in the nanotubes is only approximate , but the decay of the wave functions in the graphene part away from the junctions is strong enough to account for the development of the flat bands shown above .
in this paper we have studied the electronic structure of the hybrid material made of carbon nanotubes attached to a graphene sheet . by analyzing individual nanotube - graphene junctions ,
we have found the following features : \i ) low - energy electrons in the graphene layer , with @xmath153 , are scattered by the nanotube , and the probability of propagating into the tube is small .
\ii ) high - energy electrons reaching the nanotube junction , with @xmath154 , are mostly transmitted into the nanotube .
\iii ) at low energies , @xmath153 , and in the vicinity of the junction , @xmath155 , there is in general a depletion of the density of states .
\iv ) in certain nanotube geometries ( armchair and @xmath1 with @xmath2 equal to a multiple of 3 ) , there are quasi - bound states near @xmath156 , partially localized at the junction .
we have shown that these features can be accounted for in a continuum model of the hybrid geometry .
this is based on the dirac fermion fields describing the electronic excitations , interacting with the curvature and the effective gauge field arising from the six heptagonal carbon rings at the junction .
thus , properties i ) , ii ) and iii ) are intrinsic to the continuum dirac equation and universal for all nanotube geometries , while iv ) depends on the relative position of the six heptagonal rings and the consequent effective magnetic flux at the junction . while we have focused on the case of armchair and zig - zag nanotubes , it becomes clear that the continuum theory may account as well for the properties of junctions with other geometries . in this respect , it is likely that , by allowing for less regular distributions of the heptagonal rings , nanotubes with nontrivial helicity can also be attached to the graphene sheet . in a more general theoretical perspective , it may be interesting to analyze other discrete realizations of the 2d dirac equation , like the geometry of a square lattice with one half magnetic flux per plaquette .
we have also shown that the arrays of nanotube - graphene junctions fall into two main classes , depending on whether their spectra exhibit or not flat bands close to the fermi level .
the flat bands only appear in arrays made of armchair nanotubes or @xmath1 nanotubes when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 . on the other hand
, the semiconducting behavior seems to be a constant in the class characterized by the presence of the flat bands , as no dispersive bands cross then the fermi level .
metallic behavior of the array of junctions is possible in the other class , as shown in fig .
[ eight](b ) , though that behavior does not appear to be a generic trend , as illustrated by the absence of low - energy bands crossing the fermi level in the other representative of the class shown in fig .
[ eight](d ) . in real experimental samples
, it is quite likely that the arrays may be formed by junctions with nanotubes of different helicities . in this case
, we can expect that the electronic structure of these arrays will be a mixture of the features already present in figs . [
eight](a)-(d ) .
in particular , part of the electronic states will be still confined in some of the nanotubes , and other states will be partially localized at some of the junctions .
the feasibility of using the arrays of nanotube - graphene junctions may depend on the possibility to tailor these hybrid structures to get specific functions . at this point ,
more input from experimental measurements on these arrays would be required , while the remarkable behavior predicted for these systems ( localization and confinement of states , flat bands ) opens good perspectives in the investigation of novel electronic devices .
we acknowledge many helpful discussions with a. h. castro neto , who also mentioned to us the existence of ref .
we acknowledge financial support from mec ( spain ) through grants fis2005 - 05478-c02 - 01 , fis2005 - 05478-c02 - 02 and consolider csd2007 - 00010 , by the comunidad de madrid , through citecnomik , cm2006-s-0505-esp-0337 .
s. v. morozov , k. s. novoselov , m. i. katsnelson , f. schedin , l. a. ponomarenko , d. jiang and a. k. geim , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 016801 ( 2006 ) .
j. l. maes , phys . rev .
b * 76 * , 045430 ( 2007 ) .
f. guinea , m. i. katsnelson , and m. a. h. vozmediano , phys . rev .
b * 77 * , 075422 ( 2008 ) . f. guinea , b. horowitz , and p. le doussal , phys . rev .
b * 77 * , 205421 ( 2008 ) .
l. d. landau and e. m. lifschitz , _ theory of elasticity _ , pergamon press , oxford ( 1959 ) . | we study the electronic structure of the junctions between a single graphene layer and carbon nanotubes , using a tight - binding model and the continuum theory based on dirac fermion fields .
the latter provides a unified description of different lattice structures with curvature , which is always localized at six heptagonal carbon rings around each junction .
when these are evenly spaced , we find that it is possible to curve the planar lattice into armchair @xmath0 as well as zig - zag @xmath1 nanotubes . we show that the junctions fall into two different classes , regarding the low - energy electronic behavior .
one of them , constituted by the junctions made of the armchair nanotubes and the zig - zag @xmath1 geometries when @xmath2 is a multiple of 3 , is characterized by the presence of two quasi - bound states at the fermi level , which are absent for the rest of the zig - zag nanotubes .
these states , localized at the junction , are shown to arise from the effective gauge flux induced by the heptagonal carbon rings , which has a direct reflection in the local density of states around the junction .
furthermore , we also analyze the band structure of the arrays of junctions , finding out that they can also be classified into two different groups according to the low - energy behavior . in this regard ,
the arrays made of armchair and @xmath1 nanotubes with @xmath2 equal to a multiple of 3 are characterized by the presence of a series of flat bands , whose number grows with the length of the nanotubes .
we show that such flat bands have their origin in the formation of states confined to the nanotubes , with little overlap in the region between the junctions .
this is explained in the continuum theory from the possibility of forming standing waves in the mentioned nanotube geometries , as a superposition of modes with opposite momenta and the same quantum numbers under the @xmath3 symmetry of the junction . |
the paradigm that ultraluminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ) could evolve into qsos was proposed by pioneering studies by sanders et al .
( 1988 ) and norman & scovill ( 1988 ) . by recent observations ,
the x - ray emission ( brandt et a. 1997 ) or pa@xmath0 lines ( veilleux , sanders , & kim 1999 ) intrinsic for active galactic nuclei ( agns ) have been detected in more than one third of ulirgs .
on the other hand , recent high - resolution observations of galactic centers have revealed that the estimated mass of a central `` massive dark object''(mdo ) , which is the nomenclature for a supermassive bh candidate , does correlate with the mass of a galactic bulge ; the mass ratio of the bh to the bulge is 0.002 as a median value ( e.g. , marconi & hunt 2003 ) .
in addition , it has been found that qso host galaxies are mostly luminous and well - evolved early - type galaxies ( e.g. , mclure , dunlope , & kukula 2000 ) .
comprehensively judging from all these findings , it is likely that ulirgs , qsos , bulges , and smbhs are physically related to each other .
a radiation drag model for the formation of smbhs is recently proposed by umemura ( 2001 ) . here
, we suppose a simple two - component system that consists of a spheroidal stellar bulge and inhomogeneous optically - thick interstellar medium ( ism ) within it . in this model
, radiation drag extracts the angular momentum from inhomogeneous optically - thick ism and allow it to accrete onto the center .
then , the mass of an mdo , @xmath1 , which is the total mass of dusty ism assembled to the central massive object , is given by @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the bulge luminosity , @xmath4 is a galactic wind timescale , and @xmath5 is a time before which the optical depth is less than unity . here , @xmath6 is found to be maximally 0.34 in the optically thick limit based on the numerical simulation by kawakatu & umemura ( 2002 ) . in this paper , we should distinguish bh mass from the mass of an mdo although the mass of an mdo is often regarded as bh mass from an observational point of view .
supposing the mass accretion driven by the viscosity on to the bh horizon is limited by an order of eddington rate , the bh mass grows according to @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the ratio of bh accretion rate to the eddington rate , and @xmath9 is the eddington timescale , @xmath10 . here
@xmath11 is the mass of a seed bh , which could be a massive bh with @xmath12 formed by the collapse of a rotating supermassive star ( shibata & shapiro 2002 ) . .
@xmath13 is the time when @xmath14 . here
, we assume that @xmath15 is the eddington luminosity .
the phase at @xmath16 is a bright and optically thick phase , which may correspond to a ultraluminous infrared galaxy ( ulirg ) phase .
after the agn luminosity ( @xmath15 ) exhibits a peak at @xmath17 , it fades out abruptly .
the later fading nucleus could be a low luminosity agn ( llagn ) .
the optically - thin , bright agn phase ( _ gray area _ ) can be divided into two phases ; one is the host - dominant phase ( proto - qso ) , which is the dark gray area ( @xmath18 ) and the other is the agn - dominant phase ( qso ) , which is the light gray area ( @xmath19 ) . the lifetime of both phases are comparable , @xmath20yr .
, height=264 ]
here , we construct a scenario of the coevolution of smbh and bulge based on the radiation drag model for smbh formation . in order to treat the realistic chemical evolution of host galaxy
, we use an evolutionary spectral synthesis code pegase(fioc & rocca - volmerange 1997 ) . also , we employ a galactic wind model with the wind epoch of @xmath21yr because it can reproduce a present - day color - magnitude relation . in this model ,
the system is assumed to change from optically - thick to optically - thin phase at @xmath22 .
also , we assume the star formation rate is in proportion to gas fraction and initial gas mass is @xmath23 .
thereby , we can estimate the evolution of the physical properties of qso host , such as mass , luminosity , color and metallicity .
based on the present coevolution model , the mass accretion proportional to the bulge luminosity leads to the growth of an mdo , which is likely to form a massive dusty disk in the nucleus .
however , the matter in the mdo does not promptly fall into the bh , because the bh accretion is limited by equation ( [ eq2 ] ) .
the bh mass reaches @xmath1 at a time @xmath24 because almost all of the mdo matter has fallen onto the central bh .
the resultant bh fraction becomes @xmath25 , which is just comparable to the observed ratio .
the evolution of bulge luminosity ( @xmath3 ) and agn luminosity ( @xmath15 ) are shown in figure [ fig:1 ] , assuming the constant eddington ratio ( @xmath26 ) .
even after the galactic wind ( @xmath27 ) , @xmath28 continues to grow until @xmath17 and therefore the agn brightens with time .
after @xmath15 exhibits a peak at @xmath17 , it fades out abruptly to exhaust the fuel .
the fading nucleus could be a low luminosity agn ( llagn ) . ) and the lower panel shows the bh - to - bulge mass ratio ( @xmath29 ) against the bulge fraction ( @xmath30 ) .
the hatched area is the prediction of the present analysis .
the observational data are plotted by symbols .
the data points are categorized into four types .
_ crosses _ disk galaxies which do not possess agns , _ open circles _ seyfert 1 galaxies ( sy1s ) , _ filled triangles _
narrow line seyfert 1 galaxies ( nlsy1s ) , and _ filled circles _ seyfert 2 galaxies ( sy2s ) .
seyfert galaxies accompanied by starburst activities are specified like sy1/starburst or sy2/starburst .
, height=302 ] it is found that the area of @xmath31 can be divided into two phases with a transition time @xmath13 when @xmath14 ; the earlier phase is the host luminosity - dominant phase , and the later phase is the agn luminosity - dominant phase .
also , lifetimes of both phases are comparable to each other , which is about @xmath32yr .
the agn - dominant phase is likely to correspond to ordinary qsos , but host - dominant phase is obviously different from observed qsos so far .
we define this phase as `` a proto - qso '' ( kawakatu , umemura , & mori 2003 ) .
we have predicted the observable properties of proto - qsos as follows : ( 1 ) the broad emission lines are narrower , which is less than @xmath33km / s .
thus , proto - qso can be regarded as a `` narrow line type i qso ( nlqso ) '' ( 2 ) a massive dusty disk ( @xmath34 ) surrounds a massive bh , and it may obscure the nucleus in the edge - on view to form a type 2 nucleus .
( 3 ) the bh - to - bulge mass ratio , @xmath35 , rapidly increases from @xmath36 to @xmath37 in @xmath38yr .
( 4 ) the colors of @xmath39 at observed bands are about 0.5 magnitude bluer than those of qsos .
the predicted properties of proto - qsos are similar to those of high redshift radio galaxies .
the proto - qso phase is preceded by an optically thick phase before the galactic wind , which may correspond to ulirgs .
the present model predicts that the bh fraction is anticipated to be much less than 0.002 and grows with metallicity in the ulirg phase .
we have hitherto applied the radiation drag model to elliptical galaxies , but it could been also applied to disk galaxies .
thus , we recently elucidate the efficiency of the radiation drag in disk galaxies ( kawakatu & umemura 2004 ) . as seen in figure
[ fig:2 ] , it is found that the smbh should be smaller in a disk galaxy , but correlate with the bulge component in a similar way to an elliptical galaxy .
in addition , the observational trends in disk galaxies are broadly consistent with the theoretical prediction .
hence , by analogy to proto - qsos , a growing bh phase in a disk galaxy ( e.g. , nls1 ) possibly have a massive dusty disk within a younger bulge .
based on the radiation drag model for the bh growth , incorporating the chemical evolution of the early - type host galaxy , we have built up the coevolution model for a qso bh and the host galaxy . as a consequence
, we have shown the possibility of the proto - qso phase , which is optically thin and host luminosity - dominant , and has the lifetime comparable to the qso phase timescale of a few @xmath32 yr .
also , by considering theoretical predictions for the observable properties in proto - qso phase , we conclude that radio galaxies at high redshifts are a possible candidate for proto - qsos .
the proto - qso phase is preceded by an optically - thick ultraluminous infrared galaxy ( ulirg ) phase .
furthermore , the present model could be applied to disk galaxies .
we found that the mass of a smbh correlates with that of a bulge even in disk galaxies .
thus , by analogy to proto - qsos , a growing bh phase in a disk galaxy ( e.g. , nls1 ) may have a massive dusty disk within a younger bulge . in summary ,
the present model could be a physical picture of evolution of ulirgs ( lirgs ) to qsos ( sy1s ) . | the formation and growth of supermassive black holes ( smbhs ) physically linked with bulges are considered .
we focus on the radiation hydrodynamic process for the growth of smbh in the optically thick starburst phase , where radiation from bulge stars drives the mass accretion on to a galactic center through radiation drag effect . in the present scenario , the agn luminosity - dominant phase ( qso phase )
is preceded by the host luminosity - dominat phase , which is called `` proto - qso phase '' . in this phase
, there exists the massive dusty disks within younger bulges .
also , the proto - qso phase is anticipated by an optically - thick ultraluminous infrared galaxy ( ulirg ) phase .
furthermore , such radiation hydrodynamic model has been also applied to disk galaxies .
it turns out that the mass of a smbh primarily correlates with a bulge component even in a disk galaxy .
thus , by analogy to proto - qsos , the bh growing phase in disk galaxies may have massive dusty disks within younger bulges . |
anticipating the discovery of cholesteric liquid crystals by about two decades @xcite , reusch proposed in 1869 that a periodically nonhomogeneous multilayered material reflects normally incident circularly polarized light of one handedness , but not of the opposite handedness , provided that all layers are made of the same homogeneous , uniaxial dielectric material such that the optic axis in each layer is rotated about the thickness direction with respect to the optic axis in the adjacent layer by a fixed angle @xcite .
such a periodically nonhomogeneous dielectric material is nowadays called a _
reusch pile_. extensive theoretical and experimental work by joly and colleagues @xcite showed that circular - polarization - selective reflection of normally incident light by a reusch pile may occur in several spectral regimes .
this selective reflection of circularly polarized light of one handedness , but very little of the other , in a given spectral regime is commonly called circular bragg phenomenon @xcite . according to a classification scheme developed by hodgkinson
_ et al . _
@xcite , if the number of layers in each period @xmath0 , the reusch pile can be called an equichiral material ; if @xmath1 , but not very large , it can be called an ambichiral material ; and if @xmath2 , it is a finely chiral material .
equichiral materials do not exhibit the circular bragg phenomenon .
ambichiral materials may exhibit the circular bragg phenomenon in several spectral regimes , depending on the variations of their constitutive parameters with frequency .
therefore , a cholesteric liquid crystal @xcite can be considered as a finely chiral reusch pile made of uniaxial dielectric layers .
reusch piles can also be made of biaxial dielectric material such as columnar thin films ( ctfs ) @xcite .
a chiral sculptured thin film ( stf ) @xcite can be considered a finely chiral reusch pile comprising biaxial ctfs .
chiral stfs were first fabricated by young and kowal @xcite in 1959 and were rediscovered in the 1990s @xcite .
they have been extensively studied since then for optical applications exploiting the circular bragg phenomenon @xcite .
the effect of the number of layers @xmath3 on the circular bragg phenomenon has been studied @xcite . both @xmath3 and the total number of periods
have to be substantially large for the circular bragg phenomenon to fully develop @xcite . what is the effect of @xmath3 on the surface - wave propagation guided by the interface of a homogeneous isotropic material and an ambichiral dielectric material ?
the results reported in this letter are due to the investigations conducted to answer that question .
the planar interface of an isotropic homogeneous metal and an ambichiral dielectric material can guide surface - plasmon - polariton waves .
the planar interface of an isotropic , homogeneous dielectric material and an ambichiral dielectric material can guide dyakonov
tamm waves . for surface waves of both types , we examined the evolution of the solution(s ) of the dispersion equation with @xmath3 .
for this purpose , we considered the canonical boundary - value problem of surface - wave propagation , shown schematically in fig .
[ canonical ] .
the half space @xmath4 is occupied by isotropic and homogeneous material with relative permittivity @xmath5 .
the half space @xmath6 is occupied by an ambichiral dielectric material comprising homogeneous layers each of thickness @xmath7 , the @xmath8th layer occupying the region @xmath9 , @xmath10 .
the relative permittivity dyadic is given as @xmath11 where the reference permittivity dyadic @xmath12 contains the eigenvalues @xmath13 of @xmath14 , the dyadic @xmath15 depends on the tilt angle @xmath16 $ ] woth respect to the @xmath17 plane , the dyadic @xmath18 represents a rotation about the @xmath19 axis by an angle @xmath20 , @xmath21 with @xmath22 being the number of layers in each period @xmath23 , right - handed rotation is represented by @xmath24 and left - handed rotation by @xmath25 , and @xmath26 is an angular offset with respect to the @xmath27 axis . without any loss of generality ,
let us suppose that the surface wave propagates parallel to the @xmath27 axis guided by the interface plane @xmath28 .
the associated electromagnetic fields depend on @xmath27 as @xmath29 , have no dependence on @xmath30 , and their dependences on @xmath19 in both half spaces indicate decay as @xmath31 .
the wavenumber @xmath32 is complex valued in general . the complete formulation of the canonical boundary - value problem to obtain a dispersion equation for @xmath32 being available elsewhere @xcite ,
we proceed directly to the presentation of numerical results .
the dispersion equation was solved using the newton raphson method @xcite , with the free - space wavelength @xmath33 fixed at @xmath34 nm . for all numerical results presented here , the ambichiral dielectric material was taken to comprise ctfs made by evaporating patinal titanium oxide @xcite by directing a collimated evaporant flux in a low - pressure chamber at a fixed angle @xmath35 $ ] with respect to the planar substrate .
for the chosen ctf , @xmath36 ^ 2\\[5pt ] \epsb=\left[1.6765 + 1.5649 \left(\frac{2\chiv}{\pi}\right)-0.7825 \left(\frac{2\chiv}{\pi}\right)\right]^2\\[5pt ] \epsc=\left[1.3586 + 2.1109 \left(\frac{2\chiv}{\pi}\right)-1.0554 \left(\frac{2\chiv}{\pi}\right)^2\right]^2\\[5pt ] \chi=\tan^{-1}\left(2.8818\tan\chiv\right ) \end{array}\right\}\ , \label{cstf_per}\ ] ] according to hodgkinson and co - workers @xcite .
we fixed @xmath37 nm , while varying @xmath38 $ ] ( so that @xmath39 was simultaneously varied ) and @xmath40 .
calculated as solutions of the surface - wave dispersion equation as a function of @xmath38 $ ] and @xmath40 for spp waves guided by the interface of aluminum ( @xmath41 ) and an ambichiral dielectric material characterized by eqs .
( [ cstf_per ] ) with @xmath42 . for these calculations
, we fixed @xmath43 nm and @xmath37 nm .
top : first solution .
bottom : second solution.,width=528 ] let the isotropic homogeneous partnering material be thin - film aluminum with @xmath41 @xcite at @xmath43 nm .
all solutions of the surface - wave dispersion equation depicted as functions of @xmath3 in fig .
[ spp1 ] represent surface - plasmon - polariton ( spp ) waves @xcite .
these solutions are complex valued , as necessitated by @xmath44 being complex valued .
only one solution of the dispersion equation exists when the anisotropic partner is homogeneous ( @xmath45 ) @xcite .
however , two solutions exist when that partner is periodically nonhomogeneous ( @xmath46 ) when @xmath47 and @xmath48 . for @xmath49 ,
only one solution was found .
the most notable feature of the solutions presented in fig . [ spp1 ] is their evolution as @xmath3 increases .
specifically , the solutions @xmath32 in fig . [ spp1](top ) converge to within @xmath50 of the corresponding solutions for the metal / chiral - stf interface @xcite when @xmath51 , and the solutions in fig .
[ spp1](bottom ) converge to within @xmath50 when @xmath52 .
also , @xmath53 converges faster than @xmath54 .
next , let the isotropic homogeneous partnering material be magnesium fluoride a dielectric material with @xmath55 at @xmath43 nm .
all solutions of the surface - wave dispersion equation depicted as functions of @xmath3 in fig . [ dt ] represent dyakonov
tamm waves @xcite .
all the solutions @xmath32 are real valued , because dissipation is negligibly small in both partnering materials . for @xmath45 ,
the anistropic partner is homogeneous and the solution @xmath32 when @xmath47 represents a dyakonov wave @xcite . for @xmath46 ,
the solutions @xmath32 represent dyakonov tamm waves .
figure [ dt ] indicates the typical difference between dyakonov and dyakonov
tamm waves : the range of @xmath26 is much larger for surface waves of the latter type than for the surface waves of the former type . calculated as solutions of the surface - wave dispersion equation as a function of
@xmath38 $ ] and @xmath40 for dyakonov
tamm waves guided by the interface of magnesium fluoride ( @xmath55 ) and an ambichiral dielectric material characterized by eqs .
( [ cstf_per ] ) with @xmath42 . for these calculations
, we fixed @xmath43 nm and @xmath37 nm .
, width=288 ] just like the solutions presented in fig .
[ spp1 ] for spp waves , those presented in fig .
[ dt ] for dyakonov
tamm waves also evolve as @xmath3 increases .
specifically , the solutions for dyakonov tamm waves in fig . [ dt ] converge to within @xmath56 of the corresponding solution for the isotropic - dielectric / chiral - stf interface @xcite when @xmath57 .
the canonical boundary - value problem of surface - wave propagation guided by the planar of an isotropic homogeneous material and an ambichiral material was set up and solved .
both dyakonov tamm and spp waves were investigated .
as the number @xmath3 of ctfs per period in the ambichiral partnering material increased , the solutions of the surface - wave dispersion equation were found to converge to those for the ambichiral material replaced by the corresponding finely chiral material .
the convergence was faster when the isotropic homogeneous partner was a dielectric material than when it was a metal . for spp waves ,
the real part of the surface wavenumber @xmath32 converge faster than the imaginary part .
the solutions converge faster for the surface waves with smaller phase speeds than for the surface waves with larger phase speeds , irrespective of the fact that isotropic homogeneous partner is a metal or a dielectric material .
mf and al are grateful for partial support from grant no .
dmr-1125591 of the us national science foundation .
al is also grateful to the charles godfrey binder endowment at the pennsylvania state university for partial support of this work .
g. joly and j. billard , quelques champs lectromagntiques dans les piles de reusch i. les vibrations propres dune pile de deux lames a birfringence rectiligne ne sont pas orthogonales , " _ j. opt . (
paris ) _ * 12*(5 ) , 323329 ( 1981 ) .
g. joly and j. billard , quelques champs lectromagntiques dans les piles de reusch ii .
piles claires sous lincidence normale par des ondes monochromatiques planes et uniformes , " _ j. opt .
( paris ) _ * 13*(4 ) , 227238 ( 1982 ) .
g. joly and n. isaert , quelques champs lectromagntiques dans les piles de reusch iii .
birfringence elliptique des vibrations itratives ; activit optique de piles hlicodales dextension finie , " j. opt .
( paris ) * 16*(5 ) , 203213 ( 1985 ) .
a. lakhtakia and j. a. polo jr .
, `` dyakonov tamm wave at the planar interface of a chiral sculptured thin film and an isotropic dielectric material , ''
soc.rapid publ .
_ * 2*(1 ) , 07021 ( 2007 ) . i. j. hodgkinson , q. h. wu , and j. hazel , `` empirical equations for the principal refractive indices and column angle of obliquely - deposited films of tantalum oxide , titanium oxide and zirconium oxide , '' _ appl .
opt . _ * 37*(13 ) , 26532659 ( 1998 ) .
a. lakhtakia , y .- j .
jen , and c .- f .
lin , multiple trains of same - color surface plasmon - polaritons guided by the planar interface of a metal and a sculptured nematic thin film .
part iii : experimental evidence , " _ j. nanophoton . _ * 3 * , 033506 ( 2009 ) . | the planar interface of an isotropic homogeneous metal and an ambichiral dielectric material can guide surface - plasmon - polariton waves .
the planar interface of an isotropic , homogeneous dielectric material and an ambichiral dielectric material can guide dyakonov
tamm waves . in either instance
, we found that , as the ambichiral partnering material evolves into a finely chiral material , the solutions of the dispersion equation for surface - wave propagation evince convergence . the convergence is faster for the surface waves with larger phase speeds than for the surface waves with smaller phase speeds .
* keywords * : ambichiral material ; dyakonov tamm wave ; finely chiral material , surface plasmon - polariton wave * evolution of surface - plasmon - polariton and dyakonov tamm waves with the ambichirality of a partnering dielectric material * + muhammad faryad and akhlesh lakhtakia + pennsylvania state university , department of engineering science and mechanics , nanoengineered metamaterials group ( nanomm ) , university park , pa 168026812 , usa + |
on 9th october 2006 , @xcite reported k. itagaki s discovery of a possible supernova ( sn ) in ugc 4904 .
although the sn was discovered after the peak , an upper limit of the @xmath6 magnitude ( @xmath7 ) was obtained at @xmath820 days before the discovery @xcite .
interestingly , @xcite also reported that an optical transient had appeared in 2004 close to the position of sn 2006jc .
the transient was as faint as @xmath9 and its duration was as short as @xmath10 days . since the event was faint and short - lived , they speculated that the transient was a luminous blue variable ( lbv)-like event .
the spatial coincidence between the lbv - like event and sn 2006jc is confirmed by @xcite . because of such an intriguing association with the lbv - like event , many groups performed follow - up observations of sn 2006jc in various wavebands : x - ray , ultra violet ( uv ) , optical , infrared ( ir ) , and radio .
spectroscopic observations showed many broad features and strong narrow emission lines . according to the he detection , sn 2006jc
was classified as type ib @xcite . however ,
strange spectral features and their evolutions were reported .
a bright blue continuum was prominent in the optical spectrum at early epochs @xcite .
such a bright blue continuum had also been observed in type ii sn 1988z @xcite , but the origin of this feature is still unclear .
as the blue continuum declined , the red wing brightened and the optical spectra showed `` u''-like shapes @xcite .
this is a distinguishing feature of sn 2006jc in contrast to the spectra of usual sne that have a peak in optical bands .
photometric observations in optical and ir bands were performed continuously .
the optical light curve ( lc ) showed a rapid decline from 50 days after the discovery , as in the case of sn 1999cq @xcite . at the same epoch , near infrared ( nir ) emissions brightened @xcite .
the nir brightness increased from @xmath11 days to @xmath12 days after the discovery and then declined @xcite .
the epoch of the nir brightening corresponds to that of the development of the red wing in the optical spectra @xcite .
the nir brightening , as well as the fact that the redder side of the he emission profile declined faster than the bluer side , has been interpreted as an evidence of an ongoing dust formation @xcite . additionally , on 29th april 2007 ( 200 days after the discovery ) , the _ akari _ satellite performed nir and mid - infrared ( mir ) photometric and spectroscopic observations @xcite and the _ magnum _ telescope obtained the nir photometries @xcite .
they report the formation of amorphous carbon dust : another piece of evidences of the dust formation .
x - ray and uv emissions have also been observed by the _ swift _ and _ chandra _ satellites @xcite .
x - ray observations were performed at seven epochs and showed a brightening from @xmath13 days to @xmath14 days after the discovery @xcite .
the x - ray detection suggests an interaction between the sn ejecta and the circumstellar matter ( csm ) . on the contrary
, the radio emission was not detected by very large array ( vla ) @xcite .
we present a sn explosion model of a wolf - rayet star that explains the bolometric and x - ray lcs .
hydrodynamics , nucleosynthesis , and lc synthesis calculations are performed assuming the spherical symmetry . in this study
, we assume the explosion date of sn 2006jc to be 15 days before the discovery ( @xmath15 ) and the energy source of the light to be the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay .
the paper is organized as follows : in [ sec : bol ] , we describe how we derive the bolometric lc from observations in the various wavebands , in [ sec : presn ] , we briefly discuss the presupernova evolutionary properties of the progenitor star ; in [ sec : hyd ] , hydrodynamical and nucleosynthesis calculations are described ; in [ sec : lc ] , lc synthesis calculations are presented ; in [ sec : csm ] , we calculate the x - ray emission due to the ejecta - csm interaction ; in [ sec : conclude ] and [ sec : discuss ] , conclusions and discussion are presented .
cc 20 & 370 + 21 & 340 + 24 & 250 + 27 & 180 + 28 & 170 + 33 & 110 + 36 & 87 + 38 & 75 + 39 & 70 + 40 & 66 + 42 & 58 + 44 & 53 + 47 & 44 + 49 & 40 + 53 & 36 + 58 & 28 + 60 & 27 + 62 & 25 + 64 & 23 + 65 & 22 + 70 & 15 + 77 & 6.3 + 79 & 4.8 + 81 & 4.0 + 89 & 2.2 + 92 & 2.1 + 103 & 1.0 + 119 & 0.36 + 138 & 0.23 + 195 & 0.15 the bolometric luminosities of sne are usually estimated from the integration over the optical and nir emission because the usual sne radiate dominantly in the optical and nir bands ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , the spectra of sn 2006jc show the bright red and blue wings @xcite , which implies that the emissions in uv and ir bands considerably contribute to the bolometric luminosity .
we construct the bolometric luminosity with the integration of the uv , optical , and ir photometries that are obtained with the _ hct _
@xcite , _ azt-24 _
@xcite , _ magnum _
@xcite , and _ subaru _ telescopes @xcite and the _ swift _ @xcite and _ akari _ satellites @xcite . since the uv fluxes are available only at @xmath16 days @xcite , the uv luminosity is estimated from the optical luminosity at the other epoch .
available observations are shown in figure [ fig : lcobsall ] .
details of optical observations will be presented in the forthcoming papers ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
we adopt a distance of 25.8mpc corresponding to a distance modulus of 32.05 @xcite and a reddening of @xmath17 @xcite .
the optical lcs were obtained with the _ hct _ and _ subaru _ telescopes @xcite .
we integrate the optical fluxes with a cubic spline interpolation from @xmath18 hz to @xmath19 hz .
the optical luminosities ( @xmath20 ) are summarized in table [ tab : uvopt ] and the lc is shown in figure [ fig : lcobs ] . the optical lc declines
monotonically after the discovery .
the decline suddenly becomes rapid at @xmath21 days and the optical luminosity finally goes down to @xmath22ergs s@xmath23 at @xmath24 days .
the x - ray lc obtained with the _ swift _ and _ chandra _ satellites @xcite shows that the x - ray luminosities , @xmath25 , are much fainter than the optical luminosities @xcite .
thus , the x - ray contribution to the bolometric luminosities is negligible .
however , the uv luminosity , @xmath26 , is comparable to the optical luminosity at @xmath16 days ( @xmath27ergs s@xmath23 as estimated from the uvot observations , @xcite ) .
the uv luminosity is @xmath28 of the optical luminosity , i.e. , the total flux is @xmath29 times brighter than the optical flux ( fig .
[ fig : lcobs ] ) .
since the uv flux declined as the optical flux @xcite , we assume that @xmath30 at every epoch . although the blue wing declines with time and @xmath26 might be over - estimated at @xmath31 days @xcite , the bolometric luminosity ( @xmath32 ) should be reliable because the ir contribution dominates in the bolometric luminosity at such late epochs ( [ sec : irest ] ) .
ccccc 49 & 3.9 & 1580 & 2.9 & 9.0 + 57 & 12 & 1330 & 5.1 & 12 + 67 & 16 & 1340 & 6.6 & 15 + 70 & 19 & 1330 & 7.8 & 17 + 72 & 23 & 1300 & 8.9 & 19 + 77 & 27 & 1310 & 11 & 23 + 79 & 18 & 1400 & 9.1 & 21 + 127 & 46 & 1050 & 7.6 & 12 + 132 & 52 & 1010 & 7.2 & 11 + 154 & 17 & 1150 & 4.2 & 7.0 + 157 & 32 & 1010 & 4.5 & 6.6 + 159 & 75 & 900 & 6.7 & 8.7 + 160 & 26 & 1050 & 4.4 & 6.8 + 167 & 35 & 990 & 4.5 & 6.4 + 168 & 54 & 940 & 5.5 & 7.5 + 169 & 99 & 880 & 7.6 & 9.7 + 170 & 48 & 930 & 4.8 & 6.3 + 171 & 45 & 950 & 4.9 & 6.7 + 172 & 44 & 940 & 4.6 & 6.3 + 192 & 48 & 900 & 4.0 & 5.3 + 195 & 45 & 870 & 3.3 & 4.2 + 197 & 56 & 860 & 3.8 & 4.8 + 202 & 5.6 & 1190 & 1.5 & 2.7 + 215 & 28 & 870 & 2.1 & 2.7 the ir spectroscopy and photometries are obtained with the _ azt-24 _ and _ magnum _ telescopes ( nir photometries , @xcite ) and the _ akari _ satellite ( nir spectroscopy and mir photometries , @xcite ) . as indicated by the red wing in the optical spectra
, the ir emission considerably contributes to the bolometric luminosity of sn 2006jc .
the mir observation is available at @xmath33 days @xcite .
the ir luminosity integrated over @xmath34 hz is estimated from the nir and mir observations as @xmath35 ergs s@xmath23 .
@xcite concluded that the ir emission is originated from amorphous carbon grains with two temperatures of @xmath36k and 320k .
the large difference between the two temperatures would imply that the origin of the hot carbon dust with @xmath36k is different from that of the warm carbon dust with @xmath37k .
the hot carbon dust is suggested to be newly formed in the sn ejecta and heated by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay by a dust formation calculation @xcite . on the other hand , the origin of the emission from the warm carbon dust
is suggested to be a sn light echo of the csm carbon dust ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) .
therefore , we assume that the optical emission from sn 2006jc is absorbed and simultaneously re - emitted by the hot carbon dust and thus the luminosity emitted from the hot carbon dust should be included in the bolometric luminosity of sn 2006jc . according to the estimated temperatures and masses of the hot and warm carbon grains @xcite , the luminosities contributed by the hot and warm carbon grains are @xmath38 ergs s@xmath23 and @xmath39 ergs s@xmath23 , respectively . and
@xmath40 stems from that the h - band luminosity is slightly brighter than the luminosity emitted from the hot carbon dust @xcite . ] for the epochs when the ir photometries at @xmath41 are unavailable , we estimate the contribution of the ir emission by fitting the jhk - band photometries with amorphous carbon emission . from the kirchhoff s law , the thermal radiation from a spherical dust grain x with a uniform radius @xmath42 and temperature @xmath43 is given by @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is the absorption efficiency of the grain .
for the optically thin case , the observed emission from dust grains @xmath46 is written as @xmath47 where @xmath48 and @xmath6 denote the total number of the dust particles and the distance from the observer , respectively @xcite . in the followings ,
we convolve the @xmath49-independent coefficients as an emission coefficient @xmath50 . applying the absorption efficiency for the amorphous carbon grain with @xmath51
, we derive the temperature of the hot carbon dust , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 to reproduce the jhk - band photometries . to justify the above estimate
, we compare the estimate with the actual mir observation at @xmath33 days @xcite .
the fitting gives the temperature @xmath54 k and the emission coefficient @xmath55 for the hk - band photometries at @xmath33 days .
the luminosity integrated over @xmath56 is @xmath57 ergs s@xmath23 .
the temperature and luminosity are roughly consistent with those of the hot carbon dust .
the agreement indicates that the fitting gives a good estimate of the ir emission due to the hot carbon dust .
we note that the estimate can not account for the emission from the warm carbon dust .
table [ tab : nirbb ] summarizes the emission coefficient , temperature , estimated luminosity at @xmath58 hz , and luminosity emitted below @xmath59 hz .
the dust temperature roughly declines from @xmath60k at @xmath61 days to @xmath62k at @xmath33 days .
this is consistent with a picture that the hot carbon dust was formed in the sn ejecta and cooled down gradually @xcite .
the ir lc is shown in figure [ fig : lcobs ] .
the estimated luminosity at @xmath58 hz evolves as the jhk lcs , and thus the ir lc brightens at @xmath63 days and declines at @xmath64 days .
since there is no nir data at @xmath65 days , the bolometric lc can not be estimated at this epoch .
the bolometric luminosity is derived from the summation of @xmath26 , @xmath20 , and @xmath66 and summarized in table [ tab : bol ] , where @xmath67 is applied .
cc 49 & 81 + 51 & 81 + 53 & 75 + 58 & 64 + 60 & 61 + 62 & 59 + 65 & 55 + 66 & 54 + 70 & 45 + 77 & 33 + 79 & 29 + 119 & 14 + 138 & 10 + 195 & 4.7
the presupernova model has been extracted from a set of models already presented by @xcite and computed with the latest release of the stellar evolutionary code franec ( 5.050218 ) . since all the features of this code
have been already presented , we will address here only the main points .
the interaction between convection and local nuclear burning has been taken into account by coupling together and solving simultaneously the set of equations governing the chemical evolution due to the nuclear reactions and those describing the convective mixing .
more specifically , the convective mixing has been treated by means of a diffusion equation where the diffusion coefficient is computed by the use of the mixing - length theory .
the nuclear network is the same as that adopted in @xcite , but the nuclear cross sections have been updated whenever possible ( see table 1 in @xcite ) .
a moderate amount of overshooting of 0.2 @xmath68 has been included into the calculation only on the top of the convective core during core h burning .
mass loss has been taken into account following the prescriptions of @xcite for the blue supergiant phase ( @xmath69k ) , @xcite for the red supergiant phase ( @xmath70k ) , @xcite for the wnl wolf - rayet phase and @xcite during the wne / wco wolf - rayet phases .
we adopt the following correspondence of the models to the various wr phases according to the surface abundances , as suggested by @xcite : wnl ( @xmath71 ) , wne ( @xmath72 and @xmath73 ) , wnc ( @xmath74 ) and wco ( @xmath75 ) .
( hereafter , c / n and c / o denote the number ratios . ) the x - ray emission , as well as the early bright blue continuum and the narrow lines , clearly indicates an interaction between the sn ejecta and the csm , i.e. , the existence of a dense csm .
furthermore , the ir spectral energy distribution may be explained by the formation of amorphous carbon grains in the sn ejecta and the csm ( @xcite , see also @xcite ) . since the c - rich environment ( i.e. , @xmath76 ) is required to form carbon dust ( e.g. , @xcite )
, the ir observations suggest that the sn ejecta and csm contain a c - rich layer .
this suggests that the progenitor star of sn 2006jc is a wco wolf - rayet star with a c - rich envelope and csm ( figs .
[ fig : modpresn]a-[fig : modpresn]d ) .
lr + @xmath77 [ myr ] & 4.64 + @xmath78 [ @xmath79 & 25.80 + @xmath80 [ @xmath79 & 35.40 + @xmath81 [ myr ] & 4.16 + @xmath82 [ @xmath79 & 10.01 + + @xmath83 [ myr ] & 0.46 + @xmath84 [ @xmath79 & 12.56 + @xmath80 [ @xmath79 & 7.04 + @xmath85 [ @xmath79 & 18.80 + @xmath86 & 0.28 + @xmath87 [ myr ] & 0.07 + @xmath88 [ myr ] ( @xmath89 ) & 0.11 ( 0.77 ) + @xmath90 [ myr ] ( @xmath89 ) & 0.054 ( 0.44 ) + @xmath91 [ myr ] ( @xmath89 ) & 0.21 ( 0.31 ) + + @xmath92 [ yr ] & 1.25(+4 ) + @xmath93 [ @xmath79 & 16.52 + @xmath94 [ @xmath79 & 4.83 + @xmath95 [ @xmath79 & 1.50 + @xmath96 [ @xmath79 & 6.88 + @xmath97 [ cm ] & 3.08(+10 ) + @xmath98 ( int .- ext . )
[ @xmath79 & 5.262 - 6.648 + @xmath99 ( int .- ext . )
[ @xmath79 & 2.736 - 4.097 + @xmath100 [ yr ] & 1.10(+5 ) + @xmath101 [ yr ] & 5.43(+4 ) + @xmath102 [ yr ] & 2.21(+5 ) + @xmath103 [ yr ] & 3.86(+5 ) inspection of all the presupernova models available in @xcite indicates that only massive models , i.e. , @xmath104 , fulfill the requirements from the ir observation and become wco stars . moreover , these are the only stars in which the chemical compositions of the mantle and csm are dominated mainly by c with a smaller amount of o ( fig . [
fig : modpresn]cd ) . in stars with initial masses smaller than @xmath105 ,
the mass of the he convective core increases or remains constant during the core he burning phase . at core he exhaustion , a sharp discontinuity of he abundance is produced at the outer edge of the co core .
then , the co core begins to contract to ignite the next nuclear fuel while he burning shifts to a shell inducing a formation of a convective zone .
the he convective shell forms beyond the he discontinuity at the outer edge of the co core .
hence its chemical composition is dominated by he [ @xmath46(he)@xmath106 . because of the short lifetime of the advanced burning stages , only a small amount of he is burned inside the shell before the presupernova stage ( figs .
[ fig : modpresn]ab ) .
such a behavior is typical for stars in which the he core mass remains roughly constant during core he burning ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in stars with initial masses greater than @xmath105 , on the contrary ,
the mass loss is efficient enough ( @xmath107 ) to uncover the he core and they reduce progressively their mass during the core he burning phase .
the star enters the wne wolf - rayet stage and its subsequent evolution is governed by the actual size of the he core .
in particular , as the he core progressively reduces due to the mass loss , the star tends to behave as an initially - lower mass star , i.e. , essentially reduces its central temperature .
this induces the he convective core to shrink progressively in mass as well , leaving a layer with a variable chemical composition that reflects the central abundances at various stages during core he burning .
when the stellar mass is reduced below the maximum extension of the he convective core , the products of core he burning appear on the surface and the star becomes a wco wolf - rayet star .
at core he exhaustion , he burning shifts to a shell inducing the formation of the convective shell .
the convective shell forms in the region with variable chemical composition . as a consequence , at variance with what happens in stars with @xmath108 , in these stars
, the chemical composition of the convective shell becomes a mixture of the central he burning products .
hence it is mainly composed of c , o and he ( figs .
[ fig : modpresn]cd ) . since all the models above @xmath109 have a similar presupernova structure , we selected a @xmath109 star as representative of a typical star becoming a wco wolf - rayet star
. the mass at the presupernova stage ( @xmath96 ) is @xmath110 because of the strong mass loss .
we underline that the @xmath111-@xmath96 relation is highly uncertain because it strongly depends on many details of the stellar evolution ( e.g. , the mass loss , overshooting , rotation , and metallicity , see @xcite ) .
for this reason , for the purpose of this study , we mainly focus on a wco progenitor with @xmath112 @xmath113 , without paying much emphasis on @xmath111 .
a detailed discussion of the presupernova evolution during all the nuclear burning stages is beyond the purpose of this paper .
hence we report here in table [ tab : presn ] some key properties during the h , he , and advanced burning stages .
in particular , for the h burning stage we report the following quantities : the h burning lifetime ( @xmath77 ) , the maximum extension of the convective core ( @xmath78 ) , the total mass ( @xmath80 ) at core h exhaustion , the time spent as an o - type star ( @xmath81 ) and the he core mass ( @xmath82 ) at h exhaustion . here
, we assume that the temperature of the o - type stars is @xmath114 .
for the he burning phase we report the following quantities : the he burning lifetime ( @xmath83 ) , the maximum size of the he convective core ( @xmath84 ) , @xmath80 at core he exhaustion , the maximum depth of the convective envelope ( @xmath85 ) , the central @xmath115 mass fraction at core he exhaustion [ @xmath86 ] , the time spent at the red side ( @xmath117 ) of the hr diagram ( @xmath87 ) , and the wnl , wne , and wco lifetimes ( @xmath88 , @xmath90 , and @xmath91 , respectively ) - in parenthesis the central he mass fraction [ @xmath89 ] when the star enters the wnl , wne and wco phases . for the advanced burning stage we report the following key quantities : the time until the explosion ( @xmath92 ) , the maximum size of the he core [ @xmath93 ] , the maximum size of the co core [ @xmath94 ] , the masses of the iron core ( @xmath95 ) and the star ( @xmath96 ) and the radius of the star ( @xmath97 ) at the presupernova stage , the final extension in mass of the he convective shell [ @xmath121 and of the convective c shell [ @xmath122 , and the total lifetimes during the wnl [ @xmath100 ] , wne [ @xmath101 ] , wco [ @xmath102 ] , and wr [ @xmath103 , where @xmath126 phases .
figures [ fig : hr40 ] and [ fig:40pre2 ] show the evolutionary path in the hr diagram and the temperature and density profiles at the presupernova stage .
the sn explosion and explosive nucleosynthesis are calculated for the progenitor star with @xmath110 .
we apply various explosion energies ( @xmath127 ) for the sn explosion calculations ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the hydrodynamical calculation is performed by means of a spherical lagrangian hydrodynamics code with a piecewise parabolic method ( ppm , @xcite ) including nuclear energy production from the @xmath128-network .
the equation of state takes account of the gas , radiation , @xmath129-@xmath130 pair @xcite , coulomb interactions between ions and electrons , and phase transition @xcite .
after the hydrodynamical calculations , nucleosynthesis is calculated as a post - processing with a reaction network that includes 280 isotopes up to @xmath131br ( see table 1 in @xcite ) .
since the explosion mechanism of a core - collapse sn for a massive star with an iron core is still an unsolved problem ( e.g. , @xcite ) , we initiate the sn explosion as a thermal bomb .
although there are various ways to simulate the explosion ( e.g. , a kinetic piston , @xcite ) , it is suggested that the explosive nucleosynthesis does not depend sensitively on the way how the explosion energy is deposited @xcite .
we set an inner reflective boundary at @xmath132 and @xmath133 km within the iron core and elevate temperatures at the inner boundary . in the spherical symmetry case , for any given progenitor model ,
hydrodynamics and nucleosynthesis are determined by the explosion energy . during the sn explosion , a shock propagates outward inducing local compression and heating , triggering explosive nucleosynthesis . behind the shock front
the matter is accelerated and starts moving outward . however ,
if the progenitor has a deep gravitational potential and the explosion energy is low , the inner layers begin to fall back due to the gravitational attraction . a more compact star and a lower explosion energy leads a larger amount of fallback .
the fallback has a deep implication on the sn nucleosynthesis because it decreases the matter ejection , especially , of the inner core ( e.g. , @xmath4ni ) .
figure [ fig : vrho ] shows density structures at 100 s after the explosions when homologously expanding structures are reached ( @xmath134 ) .
we find that the fallback takes place for the model with @xmath135 but not for the models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 .
figure [ fig : escape ] shows a comparison between the escape velocity and the ejecta velocity for the model with @xmath135 and demonstrates that the matter below @xmath137 will fall back . on the other hand , in the models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 , the matter above the inner boundary will be ejected .
the abundance distributions after the explosions are shown in figures [ fig : abn]a-[fig : abn]d . in every model , @xmath138ni
is synthesized in the innermost layer ( @xmath139 ) due to the low electron fraction .
thus , we can estimate the maximum amounts of synthesized @xmath4ni for given energies .
the @xmath4ni - rich layer extending to @xmath140 [ where @xmath141 and @xmath142si - rich layer extending to @xmath143 [ where @xmath144 expand farther in the models with higher @xmath145 because the temperature achieved is higher in the outer layer for higher @xmath145 . @xmath146 and @xmath147 for each model are summarized in table [ tab : abn ] .
ccccc 1 & 1.8 & 2.1 & & + 5 & 2.1 & 2.5 & 0.5 & 1.8 + 10 & 2.3 & 2.7 & 0.6 & 2.0 + 20 & 2.5 & 3.0 & 0.7 & 2.3 @xmath4ni is synthesized at @xmath148 . since @xmath149 in the model with @xmath135 ,
the model is likely not to eject @xmath4ni . on the other hand , the models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20
can eject all synthesized @xmath4ni because the fallback does not occur .
the total amounts of synthesized @xmath4ni for the models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 are summarized in table [ tab : abn ] .
the energy source of the lc of sn 2006jc is still under debate .
the possible sources include the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay like type i sne and the ejecta - csm interaction like type iin sne . however , both scenarios have the following problems . in the case of the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay ,
the @xmath150-ray photon and positron emitted from the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay are absorbed by the sn ejecta and the absorbed energy is thermalized .
thus , the spectra would show a blackbody - like continuum as normal type i sne do . however
, the spectra of sn 2006jc do not resemble those of normal type i sne but show a bright blue continuum in early epochs @xcite . in the case of the ejecta - csm interaction , the kinetic energy
is transformed to an x - ray emission via bremsstrahlung radiation , and then converted to uv , optical , and ir emissions .
thus , it is difficult to explain that the x - ray luminosity is much fainter than the optical luminosity unless the optical depth for the x - ray emission is much higher than that for the optical emission .
another problem with the ejecta - csm interaction model is that the x - ray lc is not synchronized with the bolometric lc .
in addition , the lc powered by the ejecta - csm interaction usually has a long - term plateau ( e.g. , sn 1997cy , @xcite ) .
thus , we assume that the lc is powered by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay .
the bolometric lc of sn 2006jc is constructed from the uv , optical , and ir observations as described in
[ sec : bol ] .
the estimated peak bolometric magnitude of sn 2006jc is @xmath151 , being as bright as sn 2006aj ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
thus , it is speculated that the ejected amount of @xmath4ni [ @xmath152 is similar to sn 2006aj , i.e. , @xmath153 @xcite . according to [ sec : hyd ] ,
the models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 can eject a large enough amount of @xmath4ni , while the @xmath4ni production of the model with @xmath135 is too small . the spherical explosion models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 yield too much @xmath154 because of no fallback . however , no fallback is a consequence of the assumption of the spherical symmetry .
the fallback takes place in an aspherical explosion even with a high explosion energy and thus the aspherical explosion may well decrease @xmath154 and increase the central remnant mass @xmath155 ( @xcite ) . therefore , assuming that aspherical fallback takes place in the high - energy models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 , we estimate the amount of fallback to yield @xmath153 and then the ejected masses for the models as @xmath156 . as a result
, the sets of @xmath155 , @xmath157 and @xmath145 are derived to be ( @xmath158 , @xmath159 , @xmath160 ) @xmath161 ( 1.8 , 5.1 , 5 ) , ( 2.0 , 4.9 , 10 ) , and ( 2.3 , 4.6 , 20 ) . applying the homologous density structures of the models ( fig .
[ fig : vrho ] ) , we synthesize bolometric lcs for the models with @xmath136 , 10 , and 20 using the lte radiation hydrodynamics code and the gray @xmath150-ray transfer code @xcite . in the radiative transfer calculation ,
the electron scattering is calculated for the ionization states solved by the saha equation and the rosseland mean opacity is approximated with an empirical relation to the electron - scattering opacity @xcite .
the peak width ( @xmath162 ) of the sn lc depends on the ejected mass @xmath157 , explosion energy @xmath145 , opacity @xmath163 , density structure , and @xmath4nidistribution , as @xmath164 @xcite , where @xmath165 represents the effects of the density structure and the @xmath4ni distribution . here , we assume for sake of simplicity a uniform mixing of @xmath4ni in the sn ejecta .
also , the density structures after the sn explosions with various @xmath145 are analogous .
thus , the dependence on @xmath165 is negligible and we investigate the lc properties depending on @xmath163 , @xmath157 and @xmath145 .
the synthetic lcs obtained for the models with ( @xmath159 , @xmath160 ) @xmath161 ( 5.1 , 5 ) , ( 4.9 , 10 ) , and ( 4.6 , 20 ) are shown in figure [ fig : lc ] .
figure [ fig : lc ] also shows the multicolor and bolometric lcs of sn 2006jc .
the period of sn 2006jc is divided into four epochs depending on the available observations : ( 1 ) uv and optical photometries at @xmath166 days , ( 2 ) optical and nir photometries at @xmath63 days , ( 3 ) optical photometry at @xmath65 days , and ( 4 ) optical , nir , and mir photometries and nir spectroscopy at @xmath64 days .
\(1 ) at @xmath166 days , the ir contributions to the bolometric luminosity may well be small because the ir contribution is only @xmath167 at @xmath168 days . thus , the peak bolometric luminosity derived from the uv and optical fluxes is reliable ( [ sec : optest ] ) .
if the bolometric lc peaked at the discovery , the peak luminosity is reproduced by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay of @xmath169 . the rapid decline
after the peak prefers such high - energy models as ( @xmath159 , @xmath160 ) = ( 4.9 , 10 ) and ( 4.6 , 20 ) .
\(2 ) at @xmath63 days , the ir contribution to the bolometric luminosity increases from @xmath167 at @xmath61 days to @xmath170 at @xmath171 days .
the contribution of @xmath172 to @xmath173 changes from @xmath174 at @xmath61 days to @xmath175 at @xmath171 days . at this epoch ,
the optical and ir emissions contribute to the bolometric luminosities . combining the ir brightening and the optical decline , the bolometric lc including @xmath26 ( @xmath176 ) declines slowly .
such a slow decline is consistent with the models of ( @xmath159 , @xmath160 ) = ( 4.9 , 10 ) and ( 4.6 , 20 ) .
\(3 ) at @xmath65 days , nir photometries are not available .
the decline of the optical luminosity at this epoch is more rapid than at @xmath177 days .
such a rapid decline of the optical lc can not be reproduced by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay .
however , the bolometric lc may well decline more slowly than the optical lc because the ir emission dominates in the bolometric luminosity .
\(4 ) at @xmath64 days , nir photometries are available continuously and optical photometries are available at @xmath178 days @xcite .
the contribution of the optical emission to the bolometric luminosities is negligible ( @xmath179 at @xmath178 days ) . at this epoch ,
the contribution of @xmath172 to the total luminosity increases from @xmath180 at @xmath181 days to @xmath28 at @xmath33 days .
the estimated ir luminosity is consistent with the luminosity emitted from the hot carbon dust at @xmath33 days ( [ sec : irest ] ) .
since the dust temperature decreases with time , the ratio of the mir luminosities to the nir luminosities becomes larger with time .
therefore , the amorphous carbon emission model reasonably estimates the ir luminosity due to the hot carbon dust at @xmath182 days .
the model with @xmath183 , @xmath184 , and @xmath169 reproduces well the lc decline at @xmath64 days and the ir luminosities due to the hot carbon dust at @xmath33 days days was presented by @xcite .
they estimated the total luminosity and the dust temperature as @xmath185ergs s@xmath23 and @xmath186 k , respectively .
our model with @xmath183 , @xmath184 , and @xmath169 predicted the luminosity of @xmath187ergs s@xmath23and the dust temperature of @xmath188 k @xcite at @xmath189 days , which are lower than the observations .
this suggests that the observed ir emissions at @xmath190 days may originate not only from the newly - formed dust in the sn ejecta heated by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay but also from the light echo of the csm dust . ] .
therefore , we conclude that the hypernova - like sn explosion model with @xmath183 , @xmath184 , and @xmath169 is the most preferable model among the exploded models of a wco wolf - rayet star with @xmath110 .
x - rays from sn 2006jc were detected by the _ swift _ and _ chandra _ satellites @xcite .
the x - ray detection indicates that the expanding sn ejecta collides with the csm .
we calculate x - ray emission from the ejecta - csm interaction for the sn model with ( @xmath159 , @xmath160 ) @xmath161 ( 4.9 , 10 ) , and estimate the csm density structure on the basis of a comparison with the observed x - ray lc ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the observed x - ray luminosities estimated with the distance of @xmath191 mpc in @xcite are scaled using @xmath192 mpc .
we adopt a csm density profile characterized by a power - law of @xmath193 and assume that the interaction starts at a distance @xmath194 cm .
the parameters @xmath195 , @xmath196 , and @xmath197 are determined so that the ejecta - csm interaction reproduces the observed x - ray lc .
the interaction generates reverse and forward shock waves in the sn ejecta and csm , respectively .
both regions are heated by the shock waves and emit x - rays .
in such a compact star , because the density in the shocked sn ejecta is higher than that in the shocked csm , the emitted x - rays from the shocked sn ejecta are more luminous than those from the shocked csm ( fig .
[ fig : lx ] ) .
figure [ fig : lx ] shows the synthesized x - ray lc for @xmath198 g @xmath199 and @xmath200 for @xmath201 cm and @xmath202 for @xmath203 cm , i.e. , for a flat ( inside ) and steep ( outside ) csm density profile of @xmath204 g @xmath199 for @xmath201 cm and @xmath205 g @xmath199 for @xmath203 cm .
the total mass of the csm is @xmath206 to reproduce the peak of the observed x - ray lc and the subsequent decline .
the density , velocity , and temperature structures and their evolutions are shown in figures [ fig : csm]abc .
the velocity of the reverse shock is @xmath207 km s@xmath23 .
the reverse shock reaches @xmath208 from the outer edge of the sn ejecta at @xmath209 days and heats up the swept - up sn ejecta .
the temperature behind the reverse shock is higher than @xmath210 k where dust can not newly form and the dust formed in the sn ejecta is destroyed @xcite .
our calculation does not show the formation of a cooling shell .
this is because the csm interaction is so weak to emit x - ray of @xmath211 ergs s@xmath23 .
if the bolometric luminosity is powered by the csm interaction , i.e. , if the csm interaction emits as high luminosity as @xmath212 ergs s@xmath23 , the cooling shell might form and thus the dust formation might be possible .
further detailed studies , however , are required to confirm the dust formation behind the reverse shock .
such a flat density profile of the inner csm implies that the stellar wind was not steady because the steady wind should form the csm of @xmath213 .
this circumstellar environment might have been formed by a variable mass - loss rate @xmath214 and/or a variable wind velocity @xmath215 .
for example , assuming that the stellar wind blew with a constant @xmath216 km s@xmath23 for two years before the explosion , the mass - loss rate must have changed from @xmath217 to @xmath218 @xmath219 yr@xmath23 in two years .
such a drastic change of the mass - loss rate and/or the wind velocity is consistent with the fact that the progenitor of sn 2006jc was surrounded by the matter ejected by the lbv - like event two years before the explosion .
we present a theoretical model for sn 2006jc whose properties are summarized as follows .
\(1 ) * wco progenitor and dust formation * : the progenitor is a wco wolf - rayet star whose total mass has been reduced from @xmath220 to as small as @xmath110 .
the wco star model has a thick c - rich envelope and csm .
this is consistent with the formation of amorphous carbon grains in the sn ejecta and the csm suggested by _ akari _
observations @xcite .
@xcite have calculated dust formation in the wco star explosion model and shown that carbon dust is formed in the c - rich layer at @xmath168 days .
this is much earlier than the dust formation after @xmath221 yr in type ii sne ( sne ii ) , because of the much smaller @xmath157 in the wco star than sne ii . according to the models in @xcite ,
the stars with @xmath104 typically become wco stars to form a thick c - rich layer and csm . this limiting mass , however , is still uncertain and strongly depends on many details of the stellar evolution .
the early dust formation in the sn ejecta and the csm suggests that the progenitor of sn 2006jc is a massive star becoming a wco wolf - rayet star .
\(2 ) * explosion and bolometric light curve * : the multicolor lcs of sn 2006jc show peculiar evolutions , e.g. , a rapid decline of the optical lc and brightening of the ir lc .
these can be interpreted as an ongoing dust formation . assuming the absorbed optical light is re - emitted in the ir band , the bolometric lc is constructed as a summation of @xmath26 ( @xmath176 ) , @xmath20 , and @xmath66 .
by calculating the hydrodynamics , nucleosynthesis , and the bolometric lc for the sn explosion with the various explosion energies , @xmath135 , 5 , 10 , and 20 , we find that the hypernova - like sn explosion model with @xmath183 , @xmath184 , and @xmath169 best reproduces the bolometric lc of sn 2006jc with the radioactive decays .
also , the temperature evolution of the carbon dust heated by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay reasonably well explains the ir observations for @xmath222 days @xcite .
\(3 ) * csm interaction and x - ray light curve * : applying the model with @xmath183 and @xmath184 , we calculate the ejecta - csm interaction and the resultant x - ray lc .
we derive the csm density structure to reproduce the x - ray lc of sn 2006jc as @xmath204 g @xmath199 for @xmath201 cm and @xmath205 g @xmath199 for @xmath203 cm .
the flat density distribution in the inner csm indicates a drastic change of the mass - loss rate and/or the wind velocity that is consistent with the lbv - like event two years before the explosion .
* lbv connection * : our model does not take into account the lbv - like event that occurred two years before the explosion .
the first reason is that the mechanism of the outburst is still unclear .
the second reason is that , at least in the framework of the current understanding of standard stellar evolution , the envelope of a massive star practically freezes out after core he exhaustion ( i.e. , about 10000 years before the explosion ) due to the more rapid evolution of the core than the envelope .
in addition , it is interesting to note that , and this is a confirmation of the theoretical expectation , there is no observational evidence that any wolf - rayet star has ever undergone such a luminous outburst @xcite .
hence , there is no specific reason to associate the occurrence of a lbv - like outburst to the presupernova evolution .
future studies on the mechanism of the outburst are required to firmly conclude the origin of the lbv - like outburst .
it would be possible that a possible binary companion star could undergo the lbv - like outburst .
* fallback * : according to our hydrodynamics and nucleosynthesis calculations , in the spherically symmetric models with @xmath223 , the fallback does not take place and thus the amount of synthesized @xmath4ni is much larger than @xmath169 which is required to power the lc of sn 2006jc ( [ sec:56ni ] ) . in the aspherical explosions
, however , the fallback takes place even for @xmath223 . in this paper
, we assume the fallback even for the models with @xmath223 and derive the amount of fallback to yield the appropriate amount of @xmath4ni . to justify the above assumption
, we calculate an aspherical explosion induced by a jet with an opening angle of @xmath224 and an energy deposition rate of @xmath225 @xcite .
the jet - induced model realizes an explosion with @xmath226 , @xmath227 , and @xmath228 that is consistent with the adopted model .
we note that an aspherical radiative transfer calculation is required to confirm that the jet - induced explosion model can reproduce the lc of sn 2006jc . * light curve models * : the model with @xmath183 , @xmath184 , and @xmath169 is not an unique model to reproduce the bolometric lc of sn 2006jc . in the case of usual sne
, the velocities of the absorption lines can disentangle the degeneracy of @xmath157 and @xmath145 by means of the comparison with the photospheric velocities ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , the spectra of sn 2006jc are dominated by he emission lines and the nature is unclear .
thus we can not fully resolve the degeneracy . since the lc shape is proportional to @xmath229 , the model with a larger @xmath157 requires a higher @xmath145 .
an explosion of the progenitor star with a larger @xmath96 reproduces the lc of sn 2006jc with a higher @xmath145 and the x - ray lc with a lower csm density . on the other hand , an explosion of the progenitor star with a smaller @xmath96 reproduces the lc with a lower @xmath145 , e.g. ,
an explosion with @xmath230 and @xmath135 can explain the lc shape of sn 2006jc .
however , such low @xmath145 explosions suppress explosive nucleosynthesis and enhance the fallback . as a result
, the @xmath4niproduction is reduced for a small @xmath96 .
if the lc of sn 2006jc is powered by the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay , the bright peak indicates a larger amount of @xmath4ni production ( @xmath231 ) than a normal sn [ @xmath232 , e.g. , sn 1987a , @xcite ] .
therefore , sn 2006jc is likely a more energetic explosion than a normal sn with @xmath233 .
* dust formation * : we assume that the energy source of the lc of sn 2006jc is the @xmath4ni-@xmath4co decay . this consistently explains the formation of carbon dust at the early epoch ( @xmath168days ) and the dust temperature at @xmath24days @xcite . in this scenario , however , the origin of the bright blue continuum remains an unsolved problem ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
such a spectrum might be explained by the ejecta - csm interaction . in this scenario ,
however , the fine tunings are required to reproduce the bolometric lc ; most of the x - rays are absorbed and converted to the optical luminosity , which only a small fraction of the x - rays are emitted with changing the fraction from @xmath234 at @xmath235 days to @xmath236 at @xmath237 days . moreover ,
the formation of carbon dust with two temperatures would not be explained .
since both scenarios are inconclusive so far , further investigations may give important implications on the emission mechanism of sn 2006jc .
we would like to thank a. arkharov , n. efimova , a. di paola , c. corsi , e. di carlo , and m. dolci for providing us the data of the jhk - band photometries .
we also would like to thank s. immler for the preprint on the swift observations .
thanks the support from the 21st century coe program ( quest ) of jsps ( japan society for the promotion of science ) for his stay in the university of tokyo and the hospitality of the department of astronomy .
, d.k.s . , and t.p.p .
are supported by the jsps - insa ( indian national science academy ) exchange programme .
m.t . are supported through the jsps research fellowship for young scientists .
this work has been supported in part by world premier international research center initiative ( wpi initiative ) , mext , japan , and by the grant - in - aid for scientific research of the jsps ( 10041110 , 10304014 , 11740120 , 12640233 , 14047206 , 14253001 , 14540223 , 16740106 , 18104003 , 18540231 , 20540226 ) and mext ( 19047004 , 20040004 , 20041005 , 07ce2002 ) .
holland , s. , et al .
2007 , `` supernova 1987a : 20 years after : supernovae and gamma - ray bursters '' , ed .
s. immler , k.w .
weiler , and r. mccray ( aip : new york ) , in press .
the poster paper is available at http://astrophysics.gsfc.nasa.gov/conferences/supernova1987a/holland_poster.pdf . | we present a theoretical model for type ib supernova ( sn ) 2006jc .
we calculate the evolution of the progenitor star , hydrodynamics and nucleosynthesis of the sn explosion , and the sn bolometric light curve ( lc ) .
the synthetic bolometric lc is compared with the observed bolometric lc constructed by integrating the uv , optical , near - infrared ( nir ) , and mid - infrared ( mir ) fluxes .
the progenitor is assumed to be as massive as @xmath0 on the zero - age main - sequence .
the star undergoes extensive mass loss to reduce its mass down to as small as @xmath1 , thus becoming a wco wolf - rayet star .
the wco star model has a thick carbon - rich layer , in which amorphous carbon grains can be formed .
this could explain the nir brightening and the dust feature seen in the mir spectrum .
we suggest that the progenitor of sn 2006jc is a wco wolf - rayet star having undergone strong mass loss and such massive stars are the important sites of dust formation .
we derive the parameters of the explosion model in order to reproduce the bolometric lc of sn 2006jc by the radioactive decays : the ejecta mass @xmath2 , hypernova - like explosion energy @xmath3 ergs , and ejected @xmath4ni mass @xmath5 .
we also calculate the circumstellar interaction and find that a csm with a flat density structure is required to reproduce the x - ray lc of sn 2006jc .
this suggests a drastic change of the mass - loss rate and/or the wind velocity that is consistent with the past luminous blue variable ( lbv)-like event . |
the method of cosmic crystallography was developed by lehoucq , lachize - rey , and luminet @xcite , and consists of plotting the distances between cosmic images of clusters of galaxies . in euclidean spaces ,
we take the square of the distance between all pairs of images on a catalogue versus the frequency of occurence of each of these distances . in universes with euclidean multiply connected spatial sections
, we have sharp peaks in a plot of distance distributions .
it is usual to consider the friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) cosmological models of constant curvature @xmath0 with simply connected spatial sections .
however , models with these spacetime metrics also admit , compact , orientable , multiply connected spatial sections , which are represented by quotient manifolds @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is @xmath3 , @xmath4 or @xmath5 and @xmath6 is a discrete group of isometries ( or rigid motions ) acting freely and properly discontinously on @xmath7 .
the manifold @xmath8 is described by a fundamental polyhedron ( fp ) in @xmath7 , with faces pairwise identified through the action of the elements of @xmath6 .
so @xmath7 is the universal covering space of @xmath8 and is the union of all cells @xmath9fp@xmath10 , @xmath11 @xmath6 .
the repeated images of a cosmic source is the basis of the cosmic cristallography method .
the images in a multiply connected universe are connected by the elements @xmath12 of @xmath6 .
the distances between images carry information about these isometries .
these distances are of two types @xcite : type i pairs are of the form @xmath13 where @xmath14=distance[x , y],\ ] ] for all points @xmath15 and all elements @xmath11 @xmath6 ; type ii pairs of the form @xmath16 if @xmath17=distance[y , g(y ) ] , \label{clifford}\ ] ] for at least some points @xmath15 and some elements @xmath12 of @xmath6 .
the cosmic cristallography method puts in evidence type ii pairs .
these distances are due to clifford translations , which are elements @xmath18 such that eq .
( [ clifford ] ) holds for _ any _ two points @xmath19 type ii pairs give sharp peaks in distance distributions in euclidean @xcite and spherical spaces @xcite , but they do not appear in hyperbolic space .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ wt ] for an flrw model with total energy density @xmath20 and having as spatial sections the weeks manifold - coded @xmath21 in @xcite and in table i below - which is the closed , orientable hyperbolic manifold with the smallest volume ( normalized to minus one curvature ) known . the bernui - teixeira ( b - t ) function @xcite is an analytical expression for a uniform density distribution in an open hyperbolic model .
, width=302 ] in hyperbolic spaces , the identity ( or trivial motion ) is the only clifford translation . in this case , the cosmic cristallography method by itself can not help us to detect the global topology of the universe .
several works have tried to identify multiply connected , or closed , hyperbolic universes by applying variants of the cosmic cristallographical method @xcite , most of which now rely on type i , in the absence of type ii , isometries .
it is these variants that we call _ cosmic crystallography of the second degree_. one of these @xcite , proposed by us , consisted of subtracting , from the distribution of distances between images in closed hyperbolic universes , the similar distribution for the open model .
it did not pretend to be useful for the determination of a specific topology , but it might reinforce other studies that look for nontrivial topologies .
uzan , lehoucq , and luminet @xcite invented the _ collect correlated pairs _ method , that collect type i pairs and plot them so as to produce one peak in function of the density parameters , @xmath22 for matter and @xmath23 for dark energy .
gomero et al .
@xcite obtained _ topological signatures , _ by taking averages of distance distributions for a large number of simulated catalogues and subtracting from them averages of simulations for trivial topology . here
we introduce still another second order crystallographic method , in the absence of clifford translations and sharp peaks .
we look for signals of nontrivial topology in statistical parameters of their distance distributions . as commented above on ref .
@xcite , these methods are not as powerful as the original clifford crystallography , but will certainly be useful as added tools to help looking for the global shape of the universe .
let the metric of the friedmann s open model be written as @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the expansion factor or curvature radius , and @xmath26 is the standard metric of hyperbolic space @xmath27 .
we assume a null cosmological quantity , hence the expressions for @xmath25 and other quantities are as in friedmann s open model - see , for example , landau and lifshitz @xcite . to simulate our catalogues we assume for the cosmological density parameter the values @xmath20 and @xmath28 with hubble s constant @xmath29kms@xmath30mpc@xmath30 .
the present value of the curvature radius is @xmath31 mpc for @xmath20 and @xmath32mpc for @xmath33 . to generate pseudorandom source distributions in the fp , we first change the coordinates to get a uniform density in coordinate space : @xmath34 with @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
our sources are then generated with equal probabilities in @xmath37 space , and their large scale distributions are spatially homogeneous .
+ + & + name & volume & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath20 & @xmath40 + & 0.94 & 0.52 & 0.75 & 747 & 379 + & 0.98 & 0.54 & 0.75 & 729 & 357 + & 1.89 & 0.64 & 0.85 & 463 & 247 + & 2.83 & 0.74 & 0.94 & 403 & 199 + & 3.75 & 0.77 & 1.16 & 451 & 237 + & 4.69 & 0.87 & 1.38 & 653 & 273 + & 4.69 & 0.87 & 1.38 & 653 & 273 + & 4.69 & 0.87 & 1.38 & 653 & 273 + we did the simulations for eight spatially compact , hyperbolic models .
their space sections are the manifolds listed in table i , which gives their names , volumes , and the circumscribing and inscribing radii ( @xmath39 and @xmath38 ) of their fp s .
these and other data on the manifolds were obtained from the snappea program @xcite . in the last two columns , we list the number of cells ( replicas of fp ) needed to assure a complete cover of @xmath27 up to a radius @xmath41 for @xmath20 and @xmath42 for @xmath33 .
this corresponds to the redshift ( @xmath43 ) of the last scattering surface .
aproximately @xmath44 images were created in each simulated catalogue .
manifolds with different volumes will have different numbers of sources in their fp s . in this and remaining figures , a dashed line marks the value of the plotted parameter for the open model , and a solid line marks the bernui - teixeira value .
, width=302 ] .,width=302 ] _ for the simulations with @xmath45,title="fig:",width=302 ] _ _ , title="fig:",width=302 ] _ _ .,title="fig:",width=302 ] _ _ .,title="fig:",width=302 ] _ _ , title="fig:",width=302 ] _ _ , title="fig:",width=302 ] _ ten different pseudorandom distributions of sources for each manifold were simulated . from the result of each simulation we calculated the distance distribution and then the latter s mean value @xmath46,$ ] standard deviation @xmath47 skewness @xmath48 and peakedness @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the distance variable ,
@xmath51 is the expected value operator , and @xmath52 $ ] is the @xmath53-moment about the mean value - cf .
@xcite , for example . for each of our chosen eight compact manifolds
, we took the averages of these statistical parameters for ten simulations ( obtained by varying the computer pseudorandom seed ) , to get their tendency in comparison with those for the simply connected case .
we proceeded in two ways to obtain a distribution in the open model , for comparison with the compact cases .
in one of them , a simulated catalogue ( real ones are not yet deep enough for use in cosmic crystallography ) was obtained , with the same cosmological parameters and a pseudorandom distribution of sources inside the observable universe ( redshift @xmath54 ) . in the other , the analytical bernui - teixeira function for a uniform distribution in simply connected universes @xcite was used .
we compare the results for eight compact manifolds with those for the simulated simply connected case , and with the b - t function .
figures 2 - 9 show these results for @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 , plotted vs. the manifold volumes , with the density parameters @xmath20 and @xmath33 .
it is of course premature to think of a functional dependence on volume ( except for the obvious fact that , if the volume is so large as to enclose the observable universe , then the distribution of sources is indistinguishable from that for an open universe - see fagundes @xcite , for example ) .
but we note a tendency of @xmath55 , @xmath56 , and @xmath58 in compact universes to have values below those of the corresponding b - t function , and for @xmath57 to lie above that function .
this could give us a signal of nontrivial topology in a future , realistic situation .
we expect that the presence of type i pairs of distances is more evident for manifolds with smaller normalized volumes , or for models with smaller @xmath59 .
in fact our results are better for @xmath55 and @xmath56 with @xmath20 , where the observable universe is bigger than for @xmath40 .
this implies more copies of the fp , and hence more topological effects .
the set of these statistical parameters may eventually provide a complementary indication as for the multiply connectedness of a possibly negatively curved cosmos .
e. g. is grateful to fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado de so paulo ( fapesp process 01/10328 - 6 ) for a post - doctoral scholarship
. h. v. f. thanks conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ( cnpq process 300415/84 - 2 ) for partial financial support . | the cosmic crystallography method of lehoucq et al . @xcite produces sharp peaks in the distribution of distances between the images of cosmic sources .
but the method can not be applied to universes with compact spatial sections of negative curvature .
we apply to the these a second order crystallographic effect , as evidenced by statistical parameters .
pacs number : 98.80.jk keywords : cosmology , large scale structure |
the field of single - molecule electronics has been expanding rapidly during recent years , as techniques to electrically contact and control single molecules in a transport junction have improved @xcite . by studying the electric current through the molecule as function of the applied voltage - bias , spectroscopic information can be extracted @xcite . in setups with a gate - electrode , which can be used to control the electrostatic potential on the molecule , a detailed spectroscopy can be performed @xcite . by applying a temperature - bias and measuring the induced electric current or voltage , additional information can be extracted , such as the type of carriers ( holes / electrons ) dominating transport @xcite .
this emerging field of molecular thermoelectrics @xcite is also interesting for applications .
molecules have been predicted to be particularly efficient for conversion of heat into electric energy @xcite ( or analogously for cooling , using electric energy to pump heat ) , the reason being their very sharp electronic resonances when weakly coupled to electrodes @xcite .
this is similar to the large thermoelectric efficiency of e.g. , semi - conducting nanowires with highly peaked densities of states @xcite .
most theoretical works on meso- and nano - scale thermoelectrics have focused on the _ linear , equilibrium _ regime , where one operates close to the small voltage @xmath0 which exactly cancels the current induced by the small thermal bias @xmath1 . here the thermopower ( or seebeck coefficient ) @xmath2 is the decisive quantity , where ( @xmath3 ) @xmath4 is the ( thermal ) conductance . a large efficiency @xmath5 of the device operated as a heat to electric energy converter is then related to a large dimensionless thermoelectric figure of merit @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the operating temperature and @xmath8 the thermal conductance . in bulk systems
, @xmath9 is normally limited by the wiedemann - franz law , stating that @xmath10 is a system independent constant . however , the wiedemann - franz law is a result of fermi - liquid theory and breaks down in mesoscopic and nanoscopic systems , e.g. , due to large coulomb interaction , as has been demonstrated for quantum dots @xcite and metallic islands @xcite , allowing much larger values of @xmath9 to be reached .
as @xmath11 , the efficiency approaches the ideal carnot value @xmath12 @xcite .
however , in the linear regime , @xmath13 , the efficiency stays low even if @xmath9 can be made very large : @xmath14 .
the _ non - linear _ thermoelectric properties of molecular junctions are therefore of great interest .
recent experiments @xcite probing the thermopower of thiol end - capped organic molecules showed non - linearities in the measured @xmath15 already at @xmath16 .
earlier measurements of thermopower in metallic island single - electron transistors even displayed a change of the sign of the thermopower for very large @xmath1 @xcite . in the interesting regime of sharp electronic resonances ,
the electron tunnel coupling @xmath17 is small and the main factor limiting the efficiency of molecular energy converters is expected to be the heat current from phonon exchange with rate @xmath18 @xcite . nonetheless , to our knowledge
, its effect has this far not been systematically investigated . only by making the tunnel coupling larger , @xmath19
, the phonon contribution to the heat current becomes negligible . in this case , however , the efficiency becomes instead limited by the large electronic life - time broadening of the molecular resonances .
the thermoelectric efficiency in this limit of coherent transport was studied very recently in the non - linear regime @xcite using both a many - body transport approach and a ( non - interacting ) approach based on hckel theory . except for the latter work and a few others @xcite , most theoretical studies of molecular thermoelectrics have focused on non - interacting models , using a landauer type approach . however , in the regime of weak tunnel coupling between molecule and electrodes , intra - molecular interactions typically constitute the largest energy scales of the problem . in this paper , we calculate the thermoelectric efficiency and converted electric power of a molecular device , including a single dominant molecular orbital , strong coulomb interaction and coupling to a discrete vibrational mode , as well as coupling to lead phonons and lead electrons .
importantly , we include on equal footing the phonon and electron contributions to the heat current , both of which contribute in establishing the stationary occupation of the molecular vibrational mode .
the coulomb repulsion and electron - vibration coupling on the molecule are treated non - perturbatively in the limit of weak electron and phonon exchange in which thermoelectric efficiency is high .
a central finding is that optimal thermoelectric operation typically is achieved in the _ non - linear , non - equilibrium _ regime .
here concepts of figure of merit and thermopower are no longer meaningful and the molecular occupancies , efficiency and output power must be explicitly calculated .
the paper is organized as follows : sect .
[ sec : model ] introduces the dissipative anderson - holstein model and the thermoelectric transport equations . in sect .
[ sec : transport ] we present results for the efficiency and output power as function of the applied bias voltage and energy of the molecular orbital dominating transport .
the heating of the molecule is analyzed in sect .
[ sec : heat ] and the optimal choice of molecule and junction parameters is discussed in sect .
[ sec : optimal ] .
section [ sec : conclusions ] summarizes and provides an outlook . throughout the paper we set @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is planck s constant , @xmath22 the boltzmann constant and @xmath23 the electron charge .
despite polarization and screening effects in molecular junctions @xcite , the electronic level - spacing in molecular devices is typically large compared to applied voltage- and temperature - bias .
we therefore restrict our attention to a single molecular orbital dominating transport .
in fact , the thermoelectric properties have also been predicted to be optimal in this case @xcite .
however , the quantized vibrational modes , which couple to the charge localized on a molecular device , can not be neglected @xcite .
the vibrations additionally couple to bulk phonon modes of the electrodes @xcite .
the goal of this paper is to clarify the importance of these excitations , characteristic of a molecular device , for the thermoelectric properties .
we consider a thermoelectric junction as sketched in fig .
[ fig:1 ] .
its basic physics is captured by the following _ dissipative _ anderson - holstein model hamiltonian @xmath24 , where @xmath25 the molecular hamiltonian , @xmath26 , describes a spin - degenerate orbital level ( operator @xmath27 for spin - projection @xmath28 ) with energy @xmath29 and coulomb repulsion @xmath30 . the electron number @xmath31 , with @xmath32 , is linearly coupled to the vibrational coordinate of the harmonic mode of frequency @xmath33 ( operator @xmath34 ) .
the dimensionless electron - vibration coupling @xmath35 is the shift of the vibrational potential as the molecule is charged , measured in units of the vibrational zero - point amplitude .
the reservoir hamiltonian , @xmath36 , describes the combined electron and phonon degrees of freedom in the two reservoirs , conveniently referred to as the hot ( @xmath37 ) and cold ( @xmath38 ) electrodes .
non - interacting reservoir electrons with energy @xmath39 are created ( annihilated ) by @xmath40 ( @xmath41 ) ; @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) are the corresponding phonon operators for an electrode phonon mode with frequency @xmath44 . in each electrode electrons and phonons
are assumed to be in equilibrium with temperatures @xmath45 and @xmath46 respectively .
the coupling between the reservoirs and the molecule is described by the hamiltonian @xmath47 , where the first term describes tunneling of electrons with amplitude @xmath48 and the second term couples the molecular and electrode vibrational coordinates with ( in general energy - dependent ) amplitude @xmath49 . in view of the thermoelectric efficiency we consider the case where both couplings are weak , i.e.
, we want a small tunnel broadening and a small heat current carried by the phonons .
therefore , @xmath47 can be treated perturbatively below . the electron - electron interaction and electron - vibration coupling on the molecule
are however allowed to take arbitrary values , which is a crucial aspect for addressing the important regime @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
( color online ) .
( a ) : sketch of a thermoelectric junction with a single molecule , drawn by way of illustration as c@xmath52 . operated as a thermal- to electric power converter
, a temperature - bias is applied across the device . for an energy level above the electrochemical potentials , @xmath53
, this can drive a net flow of _ electrons _ from the hot ( h ) to the cold ( c ) electrode by tunneling through the junctions .
in addition , combined electron and phonon heat currents @xmath54 and @xmath55 are driven through the molecule .
( b ) : the thermoelectric circuit is loaded by a resistor @xmath56 , and as a result a voltage bias is applied to the cold electrode , partially opposing the thermally induced electron flow .
the voltage thus ranges from @xmath57 ( corresponding to @xmath58 ) to the value where @xmath59 ( corresponding to @xmath60 ) . in the rest of the paper we will however consider a test device as drawn in ( a ) , where @xmath61 , rather than @xmath56 , is the free parameter .
we investigate how to adjust @xmath61 and the other parameters to obtain a maximal efficiency @xmath5 and output power @xmath62 . ]
we consider the thermoelectric junction in fig .
[ fig:1](a ) operated as a heat to electric power converter .
one electrode is heated ( referred to as hot ( h ) ) with the other electrode ( referred to as cold ( c ) ) kept at the ambient temperature .
the hot electrode is grounded ( chemical potential @xmath63 measured relative to the electrode fermi levels at zero bias ) and a ( negative ) voltage @xmath64 is applied to the cold electrode ( @xmath65 ) . for simplicity
we assume the capacitances associated with the tunnel junctions to both electrodes to be equal , resulting in a voltage - dependence of the molecular orbital , @xmath66 .
we note that in an actual device which also makes use of the converted power , the voltage is not applied , but rather controlled by the temperature - bias and the resistance of the external circuit , see fig .
[ fig:1](b ) . to formulate the transport equations ,
the linear coupling term in ( [ eq:3_h ] ) is first eliminated by a standard transformation @xcite , which leads to a renormalization of the onsite and charging energies : @xmath67 , @xmath68 . after this transformation the eigenstates of @xmath26 are easily found to be given by @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is the electronic state and @xmath71 denotes the vibrational excitation number .
the corresponding eigenenergies are @xmath72 with @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
furthermore , the electron tunnel amplitude is renormalized to @xmath76 $ ] , thereby incorporating the franck - condon factors for electron tunneling .
the resulting transport characteristics under an applied voltage - bias have been analyzed in many works , see e.g. , @xcite .
we note that in principle the additional coupling to reservoir phonon modes requires a more involved transformation , leading to more complicated expressions for the renormalized parameters @xcite .
these corrections can be neglected in the regime considered here , where the coupling between the reservoir phonons and the molecular vibrational mode is weak . as mentioned above
, the maximum efficiency of energy conversion is expected in the limit of weak electron tunneling @xcite and weak coupling between molecular- and electrode vibrations : @xmath77 . here
the rate for electron tunneling involving electrode @xmath78 is @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is the density of states , which is assumed energy independent ( wide band limit ) .
the relevant rate for phonon exchange with electrode @xmath78 is @xmath81 , with @xmath82 defined by @xmath83 . here
the phonon density of states , @xmath84 , and the coupling strength , @xmath49 , are in general energy - dependent . however , in the weak coupling limit only their value at @xmath83 enters into the problem due to the selection rule @xmath85 in lowest order perturbation theory in the coupling to electrode phonons ( see the expression ( [ eq : phonon_rate ] ) for the rate matrix below ) . in the regime of non - linear temperature- and/or voltage - bias
addressed in this paper , the molecular density matrix is not known a priori and needs to be calculated . for the weak coupling considered here
this can be done using a standard master equation approach .
we can neglect contributions from non - diagonal elements of the density matrix , since the molecular states in our model are non - degenerate on the scale set by the rates ( @xmath86 ) and spin - degeneracy does not lead to off - diagonal contributions .
we note that this holds only in the weak coupling limit where the transport rates are evaluated to lowest order perturbation theory in @xmath87 and @xmath88 @xcite .
the transition rates for electron tunneling ( @xmath89 ) and phonon exchange ( @xmath90 ) can then be calculated from fermi s golden rule @xcite : @xmath91 \right\ } , \\
\label{eq : phonon_rate } w_{am , a'm'}^{(p ) } & = & \sum_{r } \gamma_r \delta_{a a ' } \left\ { \delta_{m , m'+1 } m b_r(\omega ) + \delta_{m , m'-1 } m ' \left [ b_r(\omega ) + 1 \right ] \right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath92 is a franck - condon factor @xcite , @xmath93 the spin - projection onto the @xmath94-axis of state @xmath95 , which has electron number @xmath96 , and @xmath97 + 1\}$ ] and @xmath98 - 1\}$ ] are respectively the fermi- and bose distribution functions of lead @xmath78 with electro - chemical potential @xmath99 .
the stationary state master equation to be solved for the occupations @xmath100 then reads @xmath101 where eq .
( [ eq : prob_norm ] ) expresses probability normalization . at this point
, we note that the interplay of charge and phonon tunneling is still non - trivial , as they do `` interact '' via the vibrational occupation number . a finite electric current tends to highly excite the vibrational mode , leading to high effective molecular temperatures
( see also fig .
[ fig:3](c ) ) and even clear deviations from an equilibrium ( boltzmann ) shape of the distribution .
this effect is particularly pronounced when the electron - vibration coupling is not too large , @xmath102 .
the phonon current , on the other hand , tends to thermalize the vibration towards a temperature , that depends only on the temperatures of the hot ( @xmath103 ) and cold ( @xmath104 ) lead and the relative size of the couplings @xmath105 and @xmath106 .
however , through the excitations created by the electric current , the phonon current acquires an indirect dependence on both voltage and level position
. therefore accurate calculation of the non - equilibrium molecular state accounting for both electron and phonon effects is crucial .
the electric current , @xmath107 , and heat current , @xmath108 , going out of lead @xmath78 , are given by @xmath109 p_{a ' m ' } , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath110 and @xmath111 .
the electron current matrix @xmath112 is similar to ( [ eq : electronic_rate ] ) , but includes only processes involving reservoir @xmath78 and a plus / minus sign for processes adding electrons to the molecules ( first term in ( [ eq : electronic_rate ] ) ) / removing electrons from the molecules ( second term in ( [ eq : electronic_rate ] ) ) .
analogously , the heat current matrices , @xmath113 and @xmath114 , are similar to ( [ eq : electronic_rate ] ) and ( [ eq : phonon_rate ] ) , respectively , but including only processes involving reservoir @xmath78 and with the rate multiplied by the energy of the tunneling electron ( measured relative to @xmath99 ) or phonon .
we note that there is in general some ambiguity associated with the definition of the heat current , see @xcite , which however does not matter in the weak coupling limit discussed here . beyond the linear regime , thermopower and figure of merit
are no longer suitable quantities and we instead directly calculate the efficiency of the energy converter as follows . driven by the thermal bias , electrons can gain potential energy by tunneling from the hot to the cold electrode via the molecule .
the resulting electric output power is @xmath115 , where @xmath116 .
the input heat power , required to maintain the temperature bias , is equal to the heat current , @xmath54 , flowing out of the hot electrode .
the efficiency is thus given by @xmath117 note that there is no conservation of the stationary heat current , as there is for the electric current , @xmath118 .
instead the first law of thermodynamics guarantees that @xmath119 .
we start by studying the efficiency and output power at fixed thermal bias , here chosen to be @xmath120 , as function of applied voltage - bias @xmath61 and level position @xmath121 .
the efficiency of a single level quantum dot ( spin - less electrons and no vibrational mode ) was studied in @xcite , where it was shown that the ideal carnot efficiency is reached in the equilibrium limit of vanishing current , requiring the fermi functions to be equal , @xmath122 , defining a line in the @xmath123 plane : @xmath124 . in fig .
[ fig:2 ] this equilibrium line corresponds to the boundary of the white areas .
however , along this line also the output power vanishes ( corresponding to reversible , infinitely slow operation without entropy loss ) . for vanishing couplings to the phonon mode , @xmath125 and @xmath126
, we recover this result in the non - interacting limit , @xmath127 , as well as for very strong interactions , @xmath128 . in the intermediate regime ,
the efficiency is slightly reduced .
switching on the electron - vibration coupling , but keeping @xmath129 , the efficiency is decreased and never reaches the ideal value ( @xmath130 for @xmath120 ) , see fig .
[ fig:2](a ) .
in fact , @xmath5 vanishes close to the zero electric current line ( boundary of the white area ) , the reason being that , in contrast to the single - level discussed above , the heat current does not vanish completely when the charge current does . inside the white area the current has been reversed by a too large voltage - bias and flows from high- to low - biased electrode and therefore does not accomplish any useful electric work ( note that this regime can not be reached in the thermoelectric circuit of fig .
[ fig:1](b ) ) .
( color online ) .
( a)(c ) : efficiency @xmath5 at thermal bias @xmath120 , as function of voltage - bias @xmath61 and level position @xmath121 for increasing coupling to substrate phonons , @xmath131 ( a ) , @xmath132 ( b ) , @xmath133 ( c ) . in all plots @xmath134 , @xmath135 , @xmath136 and the couplings
are symmetric , @xmath137 , @xmath138 .
( d ) : output power @xmath62 as function of @xmath61 and @xmath121 for the parameters used in ( b ) ( the power depends only weakly on @xmath18 ) . ]
the maximal efficiency is reached in the non - linear regime when the level is far above the fermi edges of both leads . in this case
electron transport involves very few thermally excited states in the heated electrode ( tail of the fermi function ) and electron - induced vibrational excitations are exponentially suppressed , minimizing electronic heat loss .
however , in this regime the current is highly suppressed , leading to a very small output power , see fig .
[ fig:2](d ) . additionally , even a small coupling to the substrate phonons , @xmath132 in fig .
[ fig:2](b ) , drastically decreases the efficiency in this low - current regime , while having a much smaller effect in the regime where the current is larger ( @xmath121 is smaller ) .
thus , already a weak coupling to substrate phonon modes , @xmath139 , drastically changes the ideal operating conditions for maximum efficiency by introducing a heat loss which depends only weakly on @xmath121 and @xmath61 ( the dependence is indirect , through the vibrational occupations ) . when the coupling to the substrate phonons becomes comparable to the tunnel coupling , @xmath140 in fig .
[ fig:2](c ) , the efficiency is significantly decreased also in the high current regime .
the output power , shown in fig .
[ fig:2](d ) for the parameters used in ( b ) , depends only weakly on @xmath18 and is maximal for @xmath141 and @xmath142 .
next we fix the level position to a value with both large power and efficiency , @xmath143 , and vary instead @xmath61 and @xmath1 . the resulting efficiency and output power
is shown in fig .
[ fig:3](a ) and ( b ) respectively , for the same parameters as in fig . [ fig:2](b ) .
( color online ) .
efficiency @xmath5 ( a ) , output power @xmath62 ( b ) , and molecular temperature @xmath144 ( c ) , as function of @xmath61 and @xmath1 , with @xmath143 and other parameters as in fig .
[ fig:2](b ) . along the edge of the white areas in ( a ) and
( b ) @xmath59 , and this edge therefore defines the non - linear thermopower @xmath145 at @xmath59 .
the standard linear response thermopower , @xmath146 , is thus given by the slope close to zero , indicated by the green dashed line in ( a ) .
note that @xmath144 in ( c ) is plotted also in the regime where the current has been reversed , even though the device would normally not be operated under such conditions .
( d ) : @xmath5 ( thick lines ) and @xmath144 ( thin lines , normalized by @xmath147 ) as function of @xmath1 at @xmath148 for @xmath149 ( red solid lines ) , @xmath150 ( green dashed lines ) , and @xmath151 ( blue dotted lines ) . ] as above , a too large voltage - bias compared to the temperature - bias reverses the current and no useful electric work is accomplished ( white areas ) .
the non - linear thermopower can be defined through @xmath152 at @xmath59 , i.e. , @xmath61 is the finite voltage needed to compensate the temperature - bias and give zero electric current .
thus , @xmath153 is given by the slope of the line which passes through zero voltage at zero temperature - bias and hits the edge of the white areas at @xmath1 in fig .
[ fig:3](a ) and ( b ) . for large temperature - bias
there are clear deviations from the linear response thermopower , @xmath146 , given by the slope of the green dashed line in fig .
[ fig:3](a ) .
as expected , the efficiency and ( even more so ) the power is increased by an increased temperature - bias .
figure [ fig:3](a)(b ) shows the dependence on the temperature - bias over a wide range , all the way up to @xmath154 .
such large temperature - bias could be obtained if the device is operated at low temperatures . in applications
, however , @xmath7 is most likely room temperature and junction stability limits operation to lower relative temperature - bias ( e.g. , @xmath155 would mean @xmath156 k , which is a realistic value ) .
however , it is actually possible to keep the ( non - equilibrium ) molecular temperature , @xmath144 , much lower than the average electrode temperature , @xmath157 , allowing operation at higher temperature - bias . to calculate @xmath144 we use an idea suggested in @xcite and couple an additional phonon bath ( `` thermometer '' ) very weakly to the molecule
the temperature of the thermometer bath is varied and @xmath144 is defined as the bath temperature where the heat current between this bath and the molecule vanishes .
figure [ fig:3](c ) shows @xmath144 as function of @xmath61 and @xmath1 , where it is seen that for small voltages @xmath144 exceeds the average electrode temperature @xmath158 .
a larger voltage - bias , however , reduces the non - equilibrium electron current and @xmath144 approaches @xmath159 .
still , it is desirable to reduce @xmath144 further , thereby allowing operation at higher @xmath1 without breaking the molecule . in designing molecular thermoelectric junctions
it is therefore important to choose the electrode material and molecular anchoring groups such that the molecular vibration couples more strongly to the substrate phonons of the colder electrode ( @xmath160 ) .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig:3](d ) , where @xmath161 ( red solid lines ) , @xmath162 ( green dashed lines ) and @xmath163 ( blue dotted lines ) .
the asymmetric phonon coupling significantly reduces @xmath144 ( thin lines ) by preventing phonons from accumulating on the molecule : they enter slowly ( @xmath105 ) and exit quickly ( @xmath106 ) . however , the asymmetry has a rather small effect on the efficiency ( thick lines ) since heat is still prevented from `` leaking '' through the molecule via the phonons as long as @xmath105 stays small compared to @xmath17 .
in contrast , with also @xmath105 large the efficiency goes down much more , and @xmath144 goes up ( the red solid and blue dotted lines for @xmath144 still show a very small difference : the electron tunneling and substrate phonon couplings drive the system toward slightly different molecular temperatures , causing @xmath144 to depend on the ratio @xmath164 ) . in realizing the mechanical coupling asymmetry @xmath160 , it is important keep the electronic tunnel coupling symmetric .
introducing an asymmetry in the electron tunnel couplings , @xmath165 , while keeping @xmath166 fixed , reduces the efficiency since the current level is set by the smallest coupling , while the phonon leakage current depends only weakly on @xmath167 and @xmath168 ( only indirectly through the vibrational occupations ) .
comparing fig . [ fig:3](a ) and ( b ) , we reach an important result for optimizing molecular thermoelectric junctions , namely that for a given temperature - bias , maximum efficiency and maximum output power is achieved at almost the same voltage - bias .
this is also seen in fig .
[ fig:4 ] , where ( a ) shows the maximum efficiency , @xmath169 , and ( b ) the efficiency @xmath5 at maximum power @xmath170 , both obtained by adjusting the voltage at given thermal bias @xmath1 .
( color online ) .
( a ) : maximum efficiency , @xmath169 , as function of @xmath1 , i.e. , the maximum obtained from vertical cuts in a plot such as fig .
[ fig:3](a ) .
parameters as in fig .
[ fig:3](a)(c ) , but the strength of the coupling to substrate phonons is varied . here
@xmath171 and @xmath172 .
( b ) : same as ( a ) , but instead showing efficiency at maximum output power @xmath173 , i.e. , @xmath5 taken at the maximum @xmath62 obtained from vertical cuts in a plot such as fig .
[ fig:3](b ) . ] for non - zero coupling @xmath18 to substrate phonons the maximum efficiency and the efficiency at maximum output power are very close .
the reason is seen from the relation @xmath174 , where @xmath175 ( @xmath176 ) is the electron ( phonon ) contribution to the heat current . since @xmath176 only has a weak ( indirect ) dependence on the voltage - bias , @xmath5 and @xmath62 can be simultaneously maximized by adjusting the bias when the phonon heat loss dominates ( @xmath177 ) . as fig .
[ fig:3 ] and fig .
[ fig:4 ] shows , this holds approximately also when @xmath178 .
when the electron - vibration coupling becomes strong , @xmath179 , the tunnel amplitudes involving the vibrational ground state become suppressed ( franck - condon blockade @xcite ) .
this reduces both the efficiency and output power since the current is decreased .
additionally , heat dissipation is increased since transport through excited vibrational states is favored , the typical energy transferred to the vibrational mode by a tunneling electron being given by the classical displacement energy , @xmath180 .
this is shown in fig . [ fig:5](a ) and ( b ) , where @xmath181 ( cf . , fig . [ fig:3](a ) and
( b ) ) .
( color online ) .
dependence on the molecular vibration frequency @xmath33 and its coupling to the electron charge @xmath35 , all other parameters fixed to those of fig .
[ fig:3](a)(c ) .
( a)(b ) : efficiency @xmath5 ( a ) and power @xmath62 ( b ) , as function of @xmath61 and @xmath1 for @xmath181 and @xmath182 .
( c)(d ) : efficiency @xmath5 as function of @xmath61 and @xmath1 for @xmath183 and @xmath182 ( c ) and @xmath134 and @xmath184 ( d ) . ]
similarly , a smaller electron - vibration coupling enhances the efficiency , see fig .
[ fig:5](c ) , where @xmath183 . in choosing @xmath135 ( @xmath185 mev assuming room temperature ) we have investigated the influence of a rather high energy vibrational mode .
molecules often also have vibrational modes with much lower frequency , down to a few mev , especially when contacted to electrodes by linker wires @xcite .
however , as is shown in fig . [ fig:5](d ) , where @xmath184 , a low - energy vibrational mode leads to a much smaller decrease of @xmath5 compared to the ideal case of no vibrational mode , as long as @xmath35 is not too large .
the reason is simply that a low frequency mode essentially can be seen as a broadening of the electronic resonance of width @xmath186 , setting the scale for additional heat loss from electron tunneling compared to the case of no vibrational mode .
almost all decrease in efficiency in this case comes from the coupling to substrate phonon modes .
in contrast , a vibrational mode with a frequency much larger than the involved temperature- and voltage - bias , does not contribute at all to electron or heat transport ( other than through the trivial shift of the electronic parameters @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath187 through the electron - vibration coupling ) .
finally , we mention that in the simple model analyzed here , the strength of the coulomb interaction does not play a crucial role . in the presence of a coupling to substrate phonons , reducing
@xmath188 leads to a somewhat larger efficiency ( and output power ) as the electric current is increased by the presence of another `` transport channel '' .
we have analyzed the efficiency and output power of a non - linear molecular thermoelectric device operated as a power converter .
accounting for the molecular vibration and its coupling to substrate phonons turned out to be crucial in comparison with results for quantum dot models without these , as it qualitatively changes the operating conditions for optimal efficiency away from the equilibrium regime . by investigating a generic model system we can now identify some basic criteria for efficient molecular energy converters : _ ( i ) _
the coupling between substrate phonon modes and molecular vibrations should be asymmetric and minimal .
coupling more strongly to the colder lead reduces the molecular temperature and allows operation at higher temperature - bias , improving efficiency and output power . _
( ii ) _ the electron tunnel couplings should be symmetric , @xmath189 .
furthermore , they should be small as to minimize the life - time broadening , but still larger than the phonon coupling , @xmath190 . _
( iii ) _ the local electron - vibration coupling energy should be small compared to the zero - point energy of the vibrational mode ( @xmath191 ) .
this is most crucial for vibrational modes with frequencies around the operating temperatures and voltages .
modes with much higher frequencies do not contribute at all , and those with much lower frequencies only contribute to the heat loss through the coupling to substrate phonons . _
( iv ) _ ideal operating conditions for high efficiency and power is achieved when the conducting orbital energy is at a few @xmath192 from the fermi edges of the electrodes ( @xmath193 mev at room temperature ) .
control of the thermopower by adding electron donating or withdrawing groups to benzenedithiol molecules , thereby shifting the position of the homo and lumo , was recently demonstrated @xcite .
the temperature - bias should be chosen as high as is allowed by molecular stability and the heat source .
the ideal voltage - bias depends on the other parameters , but is nearly the same when optimizing output power as when optimizing efficiency .
additionally , the efficiency at maximum power is very close to the maximum efficiency .
the general insights obtained in this exhaustive study of the most basic molecular thermoelectric model can serve as a guide for more complex molecular modeling , incorporating multiple vibrational modes , multiple electronic states , breakdown of the born - oppenheimer picture ( pseudo jahn - teller mixing @xcite ) , etc .
in general , one expects deviations from a single - orbital model to give a less efficient energy - converter , as additional heat is lost by population of excited states .
it might however be possible to find special circumstances under which excited states can instead be desirable , e.g. , by effectively cooling the vibrational mode .
atomistic studies of specific configurations of molecules , anchoring groups and electrodes may identify suitable systems which satisfy the above criteria and thereby further assist in advancing the chemical engineering of molecular thermoelectric junctions . for device applications , engineering of molecular monolayer devices , rather than ones based on a single molecule ,
presents a challenge to supramolecular chemistry , nanodevice fabrication and surface science .
we acknowledge financial support from the dfg under contract no . spp-1243 ( m. l. , m. w ) and the european union under the fp7 strep program single ( m. l. , k. f. ) .
this work was carried out partly in the danish - chinese centre for molecular nano - electronics supported by the danish national research foundation . | we present a detailed study of the _ non - linear _ thermoelectric properties of a molecular junction , represented by a dissipative anderson - holstein model .
a single orbital level with strong coulomb interaction is coupled to a localized vibrational mode and we account for both electron and phonon exchange with both electrodes , investigating how these contribute to the heat and charge transport .
we calculate the efficiency and power output of the device operated as a heat to electric power converter and identify the optimal operating conditions , which are found to be qualitatively changed by the presence of the vibrational mode . based on this study of a generic model system
, we discuss the desirable properties of molecular junctions for thermoelectric applications . |
understanding the behavior of interacting dynamical systems is a long standing problem .
main efforts focused on dynamical systems interacting in a lattice , and with a mean field coupling @xcite .
typical attempts establish the existence of an absolutely continuous invariant measure , see for example @xcite .
more recently , the attention has shifted towards more general and irregular networks of coupled maps @xcite .
the last decade has witnessed a rapidly growing interest in dynamics on spaces with complex topology .
this interest is partly motivated by results showing that the structure of a network can dramatically influence the dynamical properties of the system , but also because many , disparate , real - world networks share a common feature heterogeneity in the interaction structure @xcite .
this suggests a network structure in which most nodes have degree close to the minimum , while some high - degree nodes , termed _ hubs _ , are present and have greater impact upon the network functioning .
recent work has suggested the ability of networks with a heterogeneous degree distribution to present degree dependent collective behavior @xcite .
hubs may undergo a transition to coherence whereas the remaining nodes behave incoherently .
the dynamical properties among the hubs play a central role in many realistic networks .
there is evidence that the dynamics of hub neurons coordinate and shape the network in a developing hippocampal network @xcite , and play a major role in epileptic seizures @xcite .
recent efforts to understand the dynamics of the hubs concentrated mainly on numerical investigations @xcite .
the description of the dynamical properties of the hubs remains elusive .
it remains unknown how hub dynamics depends on various network parameters such as the dynamics of the isolated nodes , and the structure of the network .
revealing the dynamics of the hubs in relation to the graph structure is an important step toward understanding complex behavior and unveiling the topological implications on the network functioning . in this paper
, we study the dynamics of coupled expanding circle maps on a heterogeneous random network .
we provide a probabilistic approach to describe effective dynamics of the massively connected nodes in a weak interaction limit .
we show that for almost every random network and almost all initial conditions the high dimensional network problem governing the dynamics of the massively connected nodes can be reduced to a few macroscopic equations .
such reduction is intimately related to the ergodic properties of the expanding maps .
this reduction allows one to explore the coherent properties of the network .
our analysis reveals that the intrinsic properties of the node dynamics also play a major role and may hinder or enhance coherence .
our main object of study is the network dynamics of coupled maps . _
a network of coupled dynamical systems _ is defined to be a triple @xmath0 where : * @xmath1 is a labelled graph of @xmath2 nodes , termed network ; see section [ nets ] for details .
* @xmath3 is the local dynamics at each node in the network @xmath1 , see section [ dyn ] .
* @xmath4 described the coupling scheme , see section [ int ] .
abstractly , the network dynamics is defined by the iteration @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the product space and @xmath7 , where @xmath8 , and @xmath9 defines the spacial interaction @xmath1 and type of coupling interaction scheme @xmath4 . in section [ netdyn ] we shall present the above network equation from the single node perspective . in what follows we define our local dynamics and the network class we are working with .
finally , we define the class of coupling functions of interest . for simplicity
we introduce the following * notation : * given functions @xmath10 ( or sequences @xmath11 ) , we write @xmath12 ( resp .
@xmath13 ) if there exists a universal constant @xmath14 so that @xmath15 ( resp .
@xmath16 ) . likewise , denote @xmath17 if @xmath18 . for simplicity , otherwise unless stated , we understand the sums running over @xmath19 to @xmath2 . throughout we denote by @xmath20 the @xmath21-norm of a function @xmath22 .
we concentrate our attention on networks of @xmath2 nodes described by labelled graphs .
our terminology is that of refs .
we regard such graphs as networks of size @xmath2 .
we use a random network model @xmath23 which is an extension of the erds - rnyi model for random graphs with a general degree distribution , see for example ref .
here @xmath24 , @xmath25 will describe the expected degree of each node ; for convenience we order @xmath26 , and denote @xmath27 . in this model @xmath23
consists of the space of all graphs of size @xmath2 , where each potential edge between @xmath28 and @xmath29 is chosen with probability @xmath30 and where @xmath31 to ensure that @xmath32 it assumed that @xmath33 is chosen so that @xmath34 note that the model @xmath35 is actually a probability space , where the sample space is the finite set of networks of size @xmath2 endowed with the power set @xmath36-algebra .
moreover , the probability measure @xmath37 on the sample space is generated by @xmath38 . throughout the paper
, we will take expectation with respect to measures associated with the node dynamics .
therefore , if for clarity we need to emphasize that the probability and expectation are taken in @xmath23 , we write for a given @xmath39 and for a random variable @xmath40 , @xmath41 * network property : * we call a subset @xmath42 a property of networks of order @xmath2 if transitivity holds : if @xmath1 belongs to @xmath43 and @xmath44 is isomorphic to @xmath1 ( this means that the graphs are the same up to relabelling of the nodes ) then @xmath44 belongs to @xmath43 as well
. we shall say that _ almost every _
network @xmath1 in @xmath45 has a certain property @xmath43 if @xmath46 as @xmath47 .
the assertion _ almost every _ @xmath48 has property @xmath43 is the same as the proportion of all labelled graphs of order @xmath2 that satisfy @xmath43 tends to 1 as @xmath47 .
these networks may be described in terms of its _ adjacency matrix _ @xmath49 , defined as @xmath50 in the model @xmath51 each element of the adjacency @xmath52 s is an independent bernoulli ( random ) variable , taking value @xmath19 with success probability @xmath38 .
the _ degree _ @xmath53 of the @xmath28th node is the number of connections it receives .
@xmath53 is a random variable , which in terms of the adjacency matrix reads @xmath54 .
note that as the network is oriented the number of connections @xmath55 the @xmath28th node makes with its neighbors need not to be @xmath53 .
notice that @xmath56 .
an interesting property of this model is that under this construction @xmath57 is the expected value of @xmath53 , that is , @xmath58 while also @xmath59 .
we are interested in the large size behavior of heterogeneous networks . here
we say that a network is _ heterogeneous _ when there is a considerable disparity between the node s degree .
real world networks are typically heterogeneous a small fraction of nodes is massively connected whereas the remaining nodes are only poorly connected . to be precise , we study the following class [ h1 ] we say that the model @xmath60 is strongly heterogeneous if the following hypotheses are satisfied : n1 _ massively connected hubs : _ there is @xmath61 such that for every @xmath62 if we write @xmath63 then @xmath64 as @xmath47 and @xmath65 $ ] ( and @xmath66 ) .
we regard @xmath67 as the normalized degrees .
n2 _ slow growing low degrees : _ for @xmath68 @xmath69 where @xmath70 control the scale separation between low degree nodes and the hub nodes .
n3 _ cardinality of the hubs : _ the number of hubs @xmath71 satisfies @xmath72 for some small @xmath73 .
[ ws ] we will often suppress the @xmath2 dependence in the notation so write @xmath74 instead of @xmath75 and we also often write @xmath76 and @xmath77 instead of @xmath78 and @xmath79 . the hypothesis that the number of highly connected nodes is significantly smaller than the system size , @xmath80 , implies that the network is heterogeneous .
the @xmath81 high - degree nodes are termed _ hubs _ , and the remaining nodes are called _ low degree nodes_. these assumptions on heterogeneity mimic conditions observed in a large class of realistic networks including neuronal networks , social interaction , internet , among others @xcite .
typically , the number of hubs in the network is much smaller than the system size ( and the degrees of the hubs ) .
we wish to treat the large networks , so we assume that @xmath2 is large .
that is , the networks we consider have finite but large number of nodes .
ordered according to their magnitudes .
whilst the hubs increase proportionally to @xmath82 the remaining nodes increase in another scale .
, width=384 ] an interesting property of such random graphs is that under the condition n2 the degrees have good concentration properties , as the next result shows let @xmath23 satisfy the strong heterogeneity condition .
then almost every random network @xmath48 has every vertex satisfying @xmath83 for any @xmath84 .
( this statement should be understood in the sense of ( [ aenetwork ] ) . )
we obtain this result via a chebyshev inequality .
the expected value of @xmath54 is given by @xmath85 . to estimate the variance of var@xmath86 notice that @xmath87 and that @xmath88 .
if @xmath89 then @xmath52 and @xmath90 are independent , otherwise notice that @xmath91 .
this remark leads to @xmath92 combining ( [ ek2 ] ) and ( [ e2k ] ) we obtain @xmath93 this implies @xmath94 .
( in fact , the previous equation gives @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the probability to connect node @xmath28 to the main hub node @xmath19 since @xmath97 gives @xmath98 and therefore @xmath99 . )
hence the chebyshev inequality yields @xmath100 and condition n2 implies that this probability tends to zero as @xmath2 increases .
therefore , we obtain that @xmath101 for almost every network , which concludes the proof .
[ ndelta ] this model imposes minimum and maximum growth conditions for @xmath78 in terms of the network size @xmath2 . indeed
( n2 ) implies @xmath102 moreover , ( [ deltarho ] ) leads to an upper estimate for the growth of the maximum expected degree @xmath78 , namely @xmath103 for some @xmath104 small enough .
the next example provides an illustration of a degree sequence satisfying the strong heterogeneity condition
. we shall construct networks from this illustration for numerical simulations later on in the paper .
* example 1 : * an example of a degree sequence satisfying the strong heterogeneity condition is @xmath105 with @xmath106 , so that @xmath107 where @xmath108 .
condition ( [ deltarho ] ) imposes a growth condition on the expected degree with scaling coefficient @xmath109 it easy to modify this example so that the expected degree sequence exhibits a power law behavior in the distribution of the expected degrees , and other non trivial distributions .
we choose the dynamics on each node of the network to be identical @xmath110 .
in fact , it turns out that under our hypothesis if the dynamics on each node is slightly different our claims still hold true .
we consider expanding maps on the circle @xmath111 as a model of the isolated dynamics of the nodes .
we will use that @xmath112 is compact and the addition structure coming from @xmath113 , see ref .
@xcite for details .
[ h2 ] let @xmath114 be a @xmath115 hlder continuous expanding map , for some @xmath116 $ ] .
that is , we assume that there exists @xmath117 such that @xmath118 for all @xmath119 and @xmath120 , for some riemannian metric @xmath121 , and @xmath122 is hlder continuous with exponent @xmath123 .
the differentiability condition , that is , @xmath124 , plays an important role in our analysis .
it is well known that if @xmath125 , then @xmath126 may admit invariant measures which are singular with respect to lebesgue measure . moreover , if @xmath127 the system is structurally stable .
our aim in this subsection is to introduce the interaction structure we will use in the network dynamics ( [ md1 ] ) .
we consider pairwise interaction @xmath128 for simplicity we assume @xmath4 satisfies the following representation @xmath129 where @xmath130 is an integer , and @xmath131 are @xmath132 functions ( i.e. for each @xmath133 and @xmath134 one has @xmath135 and @xmath136 ) .
notice that @xmath4 is well - defined .
of particular interest in applications is the interactions akin to diffusion , @xmath137 with this interaction function we are ready to introduce the network dynamics . given an integer @xmath2 and a @xmath138 interaction matrix @xmath49 , we consider the dynamics of a network of @xmath2 coupled maps is described by @xmath139 is defined by @xmath140 here @xmath141 is the lift of @xmath142 ( note that @xmath111 ) .
the right hand side in ( [ md1 ] ) is well - defined because @xmath112 has an addition structure , @xmath143 is well - defined and for each choice of lift @xmath142 to a map @xmath141 the expression in ( [ md1 ] ) gives the same result .
by abuse of notation we will denote the lift @xmath144 also by @xmath126 . here
@xmath52 is chosen as in section [ nets ] , @xmath145 describes the state of the @xmath28-th node at time ( which has degree @xmath146 ) and @xmath147 is the largest expected degree .
moreover , @xmath148 is a free parameter which describes the normalized overall coupling strength .
we shall also denote the state @xmath149 as @xmath150 whenever convenient if there is no risk of confusion .
we are interested in the weak coupling limit as @xmath151 , that is , when @xmath148 is independent of @xmath76 and @xmath2 .
our main goal is to obtain a low dimensional equation to describe the highly connected nodes .
our strategy is to prove the following reduction by means of an effective dynamics . for simplicity
we choose the initial conditions on @xmath152 to be independent and identically distributed .
more precisely _ choice of initial conditions : _ let @xmath153 be a measure supported on @xmath112 with density @xmath154 .
moreover , let @xmath155 be @xmath156hlder where @xmath157 $ ] ( this notion is defined in section [ ison ] ) .
consider the global phase space of the coupled maps @xmath152 , and a product measure @xmath158 $ ] be given such that @xmath159 we have @xmath160 .
this choice of initial conditions is natural in numerical experiments .
we shall use this choice to state our main result [ thm : main ] let @xmath23 be strongly heterogeneous and consider the coupled map network ( [ md1 ] ) on @xmath23 .
assume that the network structural parameters satisfy @xmath161 and let all initial conditions on @xmath152 be given according to a product measure @xmath162 .
then there exists a positive number @xmath163 such that for almost every network in @xmath23 and for @xmath164almost every initial condition the dynamics of the hubs @xmath165 is reduced to @xmath166 where @xmath167 is the normalized degree , and @xmath168 where @xmath169 is the invariant measure of @xmath126 .
moreover , @xmath170 satisfies @xmath171 for any @xmath104 ( where @xmath172 is the @xmath21-norm of @xmath173 ) .
[ mfr ] if @xmath174 is not satisfied the function @xmath22 stills converges to zero as @xmath175 .
the speed of convergence will then depend on the parameters of the network , see proposition [ emf ] .
our result has a mean field flavor . loosely speaking ,
the hubs interact with their local mean field .
as the network is random the local mean field perceived by the hubs is a fraction of the total mean field with weights given by the normalized degrees @xmath167 . on the other hand , the mean field
is determined by the invariant measure @xmath169 of the isolated dynamics .
the function @xmath176 describes the noise - like disturbance on the motion of the hubs . _
@xmath164almost every initial condition : _ the claim concerning the reduction holds almost surely with respect to @xmath153 .
indeed , we could arrange the initial conditions into fixed points of the coupled maps and consider the particular case that @xmath177 and @xmath178
. then the reduction obviously fails in the realization where @xmath179 . in this situation
the dynamics of the hubs are given by isolated dynamics , and not by our reduction .
this example shows that one needs to remove a zero measure set of initial conditions _ almost surely every graph : _ the assertion that the theorem holds for almost every graph is more subtle .
we control the concentration inequalities of relevant quantities associated with our results .
but with small probability close to zero some pathological networks may appear .
in such exceptional networks the mean field reduction may not hold .
we now discuss a particular example of such a pathology .
recall that the networks we consider are oriented .
however , @xmath180 , which implies that statistically for a given node the number of incoming and outgoing are the same .
let us consider a situation @xmath181 and @xmath182 .
we present a pictorial representation of such network in fig .
[ orientedstar ] .
clearly the dynamics of this hub will not be described by our reduction theorem , as it does not receive input from its neighbors and therefore acts as an isolated node .
notice that @xmath183 together with @xmath184 , which implies that @xmath185 this shows that the probability to find such networks converges to zero as @xmath76 grows .
more generically , due to the concentration inequality described in proposition [ conin ] the degrees only differ from @xmath57 by a amount proportional to @xmath57 in a set of networks of small measure .
we simulate the scenario from the main theorem using the network model in example 1 from section [ nets ] , with @xmath186 , @xmath187 and @xmath188 and @xmath189 .
we take @xmath190 for @xmath191 . moreover , we consider @xmath192
. this network can be thought of as composed of a erds - rnyi layer corresponding to @xmath193 and another layer of highly connected nodes .
a pictorial representation of such network with @xmath194 and @xmath195 can be seen in fig .
[ illustration ] and @xmath195 , width=192 ] we take the bernoulli map @xmath196 to model the isolated dynamics . this model corresponds to a case with hlder exponent @xmath197 .
the lebesgue measure @xmath198 is invariant for the localized system .
this means that @xmath199 .
another interesting property of the system is stochastic stability , which means that adding a @xmath200-small uncorrelated noise in the evolution the dynamics can still be described by an invariant measure @xmath201 .
moreover , @xmath201 is uniformly close to @xmath198 .
it is easy to see that all our results still remain true if this small noise is included . hence , to avoid round - off numerical problems associated with the map @xmath202
, we introduce a small additive noise @xmath203 with uniformly distributed with support @xmath204 $ ] .
hence , the isolated dynamics under the influence of this small noise is given by @xmath205 we wish to explore two coupling functions and their consequences for the hub dynamics , focusing in particular on the collective properties of the hubs .
to this end , we introduce the following coherence measure . given points @xmath206 , with @xmath207 , we define the _ coherence _
@xmath208 between the hubs by @xmath209 consider the coupling function @xmath210 our reduction technique renders the following interaction function for the hubs @xmath211 according to the main theorem , the coupling equation ( [ eq : sin ] ) gives the reduced equations @xmath212 and where @xmath173 is the noise term .
hence , the hubs effectively decouple from the network , as there is no interaction with the hubs with the mean field .
the only effect of the network on the hubs is a noise - like term @xmath173 and the parameter @xmath148 only appears in the noise term .
the stochastic stability of the bernoulli family implies that for @xmath213 large enough @xmath214 .
first , for a fixed @xmath215 and @xmath216 we compute @xmath208 as a function of @xmath148 . in the computation of the coherence measure @xmath208
we discard the first @xmath217 iterates and consider @xmath218 .
as predicted no coherence is attained , and the behavior of @xmath208 as a function of @xmath148 is flat .
the results are presented in fig .
[ alpha0]a ) . in fig .
[ alpha0]b ) the time series of @xmath219 are shown . as a function of alpha . in b )
the time series of @xmath219 .
, width=480 ] we now perform a set of simulations to study the scaling relations between @xmath22 and @xmath76 .
notice that in the model of example 1 we take @xmath220 , hence our theorem predicts a scaling as @xmath221 . in this set of experiments we vary @xmath76 ,
recall that @xmath186 and the low degrees @xmath222 for @xmath223 are fixed .
we also fix @xmath224 , and consider only the fluctuations @xmath225 on the main hub @xmath226 . for simplicity of notation
we shall write @xmath227 . for each experiment
we compute the quantity @xmath228 where @xmath229 .
this mean value of the modulus of the fluctuations @xmath22 must have the same scaling relation @xmath230 .
for each @xmath76 we construct the corresponding network only once and measure @xmath231 .
this implies that we do not average @xmath231 over the network ensemble , as the networks have good concentration properties .
the simulation results are presented in fig .
[ zetadelta ] and are in agreement with the predictions and the expected degree @xmath76 .
the simulation results are shown in black full points and a curve with scaling @xmath232 is shown in red ( full bold line ) .
our theorem predicts a scaling relation @xmath230 , which is in agreement with the simulation results .
, width=211 ] as before @xmath2 and the @xmath57 s for the low degree nodes are fixed .
now we also fix @xmath234 and vary @xmath235 to study the scaling relations between @xmath22 and @xmath233 . our theorem predicts a scaling as @xmath236 .
we then compute the mean value of the modulus of the fluctuations @xmath237 . in this subsection , for simplicity of notation we shall write @xmath238 and @xmath239 . again , for each @xmath233 we construct the corresponding network only once and measure @xmath231 .
the simulation results are presented in fig .
[ zetakappa ] and is in agreement with the predictions and normalized degree @xmath233 .
the simulation results are shown in black full points and a curve with scaling @xmath240 is shown in red ( full bold line ) . for fixed network parameters @xmath241 our theorem predicts a scaling relation @xmath242 , which is in agreement with the simulation results .
, width=240 ] the reduction reveals that coherent dynamics can be caused by cancellations due to the nature of the coupling functions and the dynamics of the isolated dynamics ( in terms of the invariant measure ) .
depending on the coupling function the hubs may exhibit a coherent behavior for a range of coupling strengths @xmath148 . here , we illustrate such scenario .
again , we consider the network from example 1 , with @xmath243 , @xmath190 for @xmath244 .
we fix @xmath234 , with @xmath245 an @xmath246 .
then we construct one realization of such a network . the coupling function
@xmath247 we performed extensive numerical simulations to compute the coherence measure for the two hubs @xmath248 and @xmath249 as a function of the coupling strength @xmath148 .
the result can be seen in fig .
the parameter @xmath208 , see ( [ r ] ) has an intricate dependence on @xmath148 .
such behavior can be uncovered by our reduction techniques . versus the coupling strength @xmath148 .
the high values of @xmath208 corresponds to regimes where the dynamical of the hubs @xmath226 and @xmath249 are correlated .
the onset of coherent regimes can be predicted by the reduction techniques , e.g. , the large coherent plateau is given by ( [ alphab ] ) .
[ fig : r],width=240 ] applying the main theorem with the coupling ( [ eq : sinsin ] ) yields the following effective equations for the hubs dynamics @xmath250 let us neglect the finite size fluctuations for a moment .
then the dynamics of the hubs are described by the following equation @xmath251 and so the parameter @xmath148 determines the dynamics significantly .
indeed ( [ esz ] ) has a trivial fixed point @xmath252 ( identified with @xmath19 ) for all @xmath148 , but this fixed point is only stable for @xmath253 in this range if the initial conditions for the hubs start in a vicinity of @xmath254 then they will remain there for all future times .
this will correspond to a trivial coherent behavior .
hence , while the low degree behaves in an erratic fashion the hubs , although isolated chaotically , will stay in a steady state .
this regime corresponds to large values of the coherence measure @xmath208 . on the other hands , when @xmath255 this fixed point becomes repelling and indeed the second plateau in fig .
[ fig : r ] corresponds to a stable periodic orbit of period two .
examples of such dynamics can be observed in fig .
[ alphag ] we depict the trajectories of the hubs @xmath226 ( solid circles ) and @xmath249 ( solid squares ) along with the trajectories of the low degree node @xmath256 ( diamonds ) .
the trajectories are shown in the circle .
the trajectories of the hubs stay close to an equilibrium point , whereas the trajectories of the low degree nodes spread over the whole circle . for @xmath257
we depict the trajectories of the hubs in the circle .
they display a coherent periodic motion of period two.,width=384 ]
the proof of the main theorem is based on the ergodic properties of @xmath126 and is derived from the properties of the peron - frobenius operator ( acting on some convenient banach space ) . to prove that this operator has fixed points , we use standard technique based on the notion of the projective metric associated with a convex cone in a vector space . we follow closely the exposition in ref .
we use the distance @xmath258 induced by the riemannian metric . given a measure @xmath153 absolutely continuous with respect to the lebesgue measure @xmath198 , that is , given @xmath275 one has @xmath276 , for an integrable function @xmath154
, then the pushforward of @xmath153 under @xmath126 has the duality property @xmath277 the fixed points @xmath278 of the linear operator @xmath272 are @xmath126-_invariant _ absolutely continuous probabilities measures .
conversely , if a @xmath126-invariant probability @xmath169 is absolutely continuous with respect to @xmath198 then there exists the radon - nikodym derivative @xmath279 and @xmath280 .
the domain of @xmath272 plays a vital role .
another important point is that the metric space @xmath281 is not complete .
nonetheless , @xmath272 acting on @xmath282 is a contraction with a unique fixed point .
we study the dynamics of the low degree nodes as perturbations of the isolated dynamics , and then obtain the statistical properties of the low degree in terms of perturbation results of the transfer operator . to this end , we show that for almost every network , low degree nodes can be viewed as a perturbation .
notice that @xmath286 can be rewritten as @xmath287 where the coupling term taking into account ( [ h ] ) is represented as @xmath288 with @xmath289 [ rdelta ] let @xmath23 be strongly heterogeneous . then the coupling term @xmath290 viewed as a mapping @xmath291 is @xmath292 , and for every low degree node @xmath68 the coupling term satisfies @xmath293 for almost every network in @xmath23 .
the claim on the regularity of @xmath290 is trivial .
the second claim follows from the concentration properties . since the manifold is compact , we obtain for every @xmath119 @xmath294 and @xmath295 now we wish to show concentration properties for @xmath296 .
hence , for a given fixed @xmath297 for simplicity we denote @xmath298 and estimate @xmath299 leading to @xmath300 to obtain our claim we also estimate the variance @xmath301 hence , we need to estimate @xmath302 but @xmath303 , hence , @xmath304 recall that by property n2 of the strong heterogeneity @xmath310 , and note that @xmath311 which leads to the following estimate @xmath312 this leads to @xmath313 hence , for every @xmath314 we obtain @xmath315 implying that for almost every network in the model @xmath23 , @xmath316 by the triangle inequality @xmath317 together with ( [ ey ] ) and taking @xmath318 small enough we obtain that @xmath319 now recall that the function @xmath320 are uniformly bounded over @xmath112 yielding @xmath321 for almost every network as @xmath322 has the derived concentration properties .
this result reveals that for almost every network @xmath23 the network effect on low degree nodes is a perturbation in the limit of large @xmath76 .
we use this remark to treat the mean field reduction in terms of the ergodic properties of the perturbed maps .
next we consider the index @xmath28 fixed on a low degree node .
the following argument will hold for any low degree node .
we can view the perturbed map @xmath323 as a random - like perturbation of the map @xmath126 by writing @xmath324 where @xmath208 is small by proposition [ rdelta ] .
note that the maps @xmath325 are uniformly close in the @xmath326 topology to @xmath126 .
we view @xmath325 as parametrized families @xmath327 of @xmath132-hlder continuous maps .
so at each time step in its evolution , we pick a map @xmath325 in an open neighborhood of @xmath126 .
denote @xmath328 and define @xmath329 hence , the equation may be recast as @xmath330 for that map we introduce perturbed versions of the linear operator @xmath272 @xmath331 we now claim the following note that the main difference here to the stochastic stability analysis performed in @xcite is that the maps @xmath333 are not chosen independently , which may lead to the non - existence of stationary measures . since @xmath126 is a local diffeomorphism , all the points @xmath334 have a same number @xmath335 of preimages , namely the degree of @xmath126 .
( in our case @xmath336 . ) moreover , given any preimage @xmath337 of @xmath338 , there exists a neighbourhood @xmath339 of @xmath338 and an inverse branch @xmath340 such that @xmath341 and @xmath342 .
a local inverse branch @xmath343 must be contracting @xmath344 for every @xmath345 in @xmath339 .
moreover , by compactness of @xmath112 , there exists @xmath264 such that given @xmath346 , @xmath347 with @xmath348 ,
one may write @xmath349 for @xmath350 with @xmath351 for each @xmath352 . obviously @xmath353 with these remarks , we can write the transfer operators as @xmath354 to obtain bounds on the jacobian we first note that @xmath359 we estimate the first difference in the right hand side of ( [ df_dif ] ) as follows .
since @xmath323 is a uniformly @xmath357 close to @xmath126 .
moreover , @xmath360 \right| \nonumber \\ & = & |\mbox{det } df(x_i)| \left| 1 - \mbox{det } \left [ \mbox{i } + dr(x_i ) df^{-1}(x_i ) \right ] \right| , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath361 = 1 + \mbox{tr } d r(x_i ) df^{-1}(x_i).\ ] ] noting that expansivity implies that the derivative @xmath122 is an isomorphism at the every point , and in view of proposition [ rdelta ] we obtain @xmath362 \right| \lesssim \delta^{-\gamma},\ ] ] and therefore @xmath363 ) we note that @xmath364 is @xmath156hlder continuous implying that the determinant is @xmath365hlder continuous @xmath366 yielding in view of ( [ xit ] ) @xmath367 ) and ( [ d2 ] ) for the right hand side terms of ( [ df_dif ] ) yield the following estimate latexmath:[\[\label{df } to obtain the result , it remains to control the test functions @xmath154 . note that since @xmath155 is @xmath263-hlder continuous we have @xmath369 and since the manifold is compact @xmath154 will attain its maximum on @xmath112 .
hence , @xmath370 , once , @xmath371 as @xmath76 is large .
altogether the estimates ( [ df ] ) and ( [ difva ] ) imply that for all @xmath372 @xmath373 concluding the result .
the above proposition reveals that at each step the transfer operator of the low degree nodes is uniformly close to the unperturbed operator .
the natural question concerns the behavior of compositions of the transfer operators , corresponding to the time evolution .
hence , we introduce the transfer operator @xmath374 [ near ] let @xmath376 then there exists @xmath377 such that almost every network @xmath378 for all @xmath379 where @xmath380 is the fixed point of the unperturbed operator @xmath272 and @xmath381 , @xmath382 satisfy @xmath383 before we prove this proposition , we need the following auxiliary result concerning the behavior of a family of operators near a contraction . given a metric space @xmath384 , we denote the open ball @xmath385 our claim is as follows [ contrf ] let @xmath384 be a metric space and transformation @xmath386 with lipschitz constant @xmath387 and a unique fixed point @xmath388 .
let @xmath213 be a metric space and consider a family of transformations @xmath389 , with @xmath390 , and introduce the composition @xmath391 suppose that the transformations satisfy @xmath392 now , consider a ball @xmath403 .
we claim that if @xmath404 then @xmath405 .
indeed , consider the action of a generic element @xmath1 @xmath406 but since @xmath407 we have the following bound @xmath408 , and by induction the claim follows .
hence , @xmath410 where @xmath411 .
this concludes the second part .
if @xmath337 is contained in a compact subset @xmath14 of @xmath40 containing @xmath399 then the claim on @xmath412 can be made uniform on @xmath337 follows from compactness arguments .
recall the discussion in sec .
[ ison ] : the convex cone @xmath282 is endowed with the metric @xmath413 where @xmath414 and @xmath318 is given by a similar expression with @xmath415 replaced by @xmath416 .
therefore , we obtain @xmath425 as @xmath426 .
proposition [ lfp ] guarantees that the transfer operator @xmath272 is a contraction in the metric space @xmath281 .
moreover , @xmath272 and @xmath355 are uniformly close .
hence , applying lemma [ contrf ] in the metric space @xmath281 we conclude proposition [ near ] . * the expectation operator : * as before we consider an absolutely continuous measure @xmath153 with density @xmath154 .
moreover , we assume @xmath155 is @xmath156hlder continuous . let @xmath158 $ ] be a product measure , that is , given @xmath159 we have @xmath160 .
we define the expectation operator with respect to the measure @xmath153 @xmath427 the intuitive idea here is that the initial conditions of the low degree nodes are distributed according to this product measure .
so at the initial time the systems are independent .
then with the evolution of the initial conditions , since the systems are interacting , the pushforward of this measure under the dynamics no longer has the product structure .
however , since the interaction is mild a mean field reduction can be obtained .
let @xmath436 be a projector to the @xmath28th component , denoting @xmath437 then @xmath438 .
now the following argument holds for any @xmath68 , hence , for sake of simplicity we drop the @xmath28 dependence .
given @xmath439 , take @xmath440 note that @xmath441 and notice that @xmath442 . since @xmath443 we may write @xmath444 by proposition [ near ] we obtain @xmath445 where @xmath446 . defining @xmath447
the claim in the first part follows ( for every low degree node ) . to prove the second part we proceed in the same manner and obtain the desired estimates for the covariance .
note that @xmath448 \nonumber \\ & = & \mathbb{e}_{\mu } \left [ \langle \psi ( x_i^k ) , \sigma ( x_j^k ) \rangle \right ] - \langle \mathbb{e}_{\mu } ( \psi(x_i^k ) ) , \mathbb{e}_{\mu } ( \sigma ( x_j^k ) ) \rangle .
\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] now we wish to estimate the @xmath449 . to this end
we fix @xmath28 and @xmath29 with @xmath450 , and introduce @xmath451 defined as @xmath452 for the corresponding sequences @xmath453 and @xmath454 , along with @xmath455 .
consider the projector @xmath456 defined as @xmath457 . with this notation we may write @xmath458 where @xmath459 . now
since @xmath162 has a product structure and @xmath460 is a natural projector @xmath461 has density @xmath462 .
note that @xmath4 is in a neighborhood of a product map , and all the estimates hold uniformly , we obtain @xmath463 where again @xmath464 satisfies @xmath465 and the result follows . before , proving the homogeneity of the mean field we need to control certain concentration properties of the graphs .
the first is the concentration of the degrees @xmath54 , which is given by proposition [ conin ] .
the second is related to @xmath466 next we show that this quantity is heavily concentrated at @xmath467 . for this
we have the following proposition we obtain this claim by a chebyshev inequality . for @xmath468 , for @xmath52 and @xmath90 are independent for @xmath471 and note @xmath303 .
therefore , we need to estimate the expectation and variance of @xmath472 : @xmath473 note that @xmath474 along with @xmath475 , where in first inequality we used property n2 of the strong heterogeneity and in the last inequality we used the graphical condition ( [ deltarho ] ) .
moreover , @xmath476 , and denote @xmath477 , clearly @xmath478 $ ] . thus , @xmath479 using this together with @xmath480 and assumption n3 of the strong heterogeneity implies @xmath481 leading to @xmath482 and we obtain @xmath483 applying the chebyshev inequality we obtain that @xmath487 this implies that for almost every graph @xmath488 now using the triangle inequality and the bound [ ye ] we obtain @xmath489 and we obtain the result .
let the initial conditions of the low degree nodes be chosen independently and according to a measure @xmath162 as before .
let @xmath490 , then there exists @xmath491 such that given @xmath492 small enough for almost every network in @xmath23 and @xmath164almost every initial condition for all @xmath62 @xmath493 where @xmath494 is determined by the network structure and the dynamics : indeed , we wish to use a chebyshev bound .
hence , we start estimating the mean and the variance . for a fixed @xmath28 in the set of hubs , we need to estimate the expectation and the variance of the coupling term @xmath501 .
the first follows easily @xmath502 but from proposition [ meancovar ] , we have @xmath503 .
also , in view of the concentration inequality proposition [ conin ] for _ almost every _ network @xmath504 hence , @xmath505 for almost every network . to estimate the variance we note that @xmath506 \nonumber .\end{aligned}\ ] ] now for the low degree indexes @xmath508 , we have in view of proposition [ meancovar ] @xmath510 and hence , @xmath511 \right | \lesssim \delta^{-\gamma \nu } y_i.\ ] ] now , we claim good concentration properties for @xmath472 so that we can change its value by its expected value @xmath467 .
hence , combining ( [ hb ] ) and ( [ dy ] ) for _ almost every _ graph we obtain @xmath512 therefore , the variance depends on a competition between the network structure parameters .
we obtain the following cases : applying chebyshev inequality @xmath515 therefore , we obtain that for almost every network in @xmath23 and @xmath516almost every initial condition we have @xmath517 but in view of the triangle inequality we obtain @xmath518 however , by ( [ emuv ] ) we obtain @xmath519 notice that as @xmath520 $ ] we have @xmath521 .
now clearly , @xmath522 as @xmath116 $ ] and @xmath523
. moreover , the competition with the term @xmath524 can be absorbed in @xmath318 .
combining the two upper bounds estimates we obtain @xmath525 and our first claim follows .
_ case ii ) @xmath526_. we obtain @xmath527 applying the chebyshev inequality we obtain an inequality similar to ( [ ev ] ) with the right hand side replaced by @xmath528 .
hence , we obtain @xmath529 as the condition @xmath530 implies @xmath531 .
here we distinguish two cases : consider the dynamics of the high degree nodes @xmath536 where the coupling term @xmath290 reads @xmath537 with @xmath538 as before . by proposition [ emf ] on the homogeneity of the mean field
, we obtain @xmath539 for almost all networks in @xmath23 , with @xmath540 and @xmath541 using ( [ rhub ] ) and ( [ eq : ymean ] ) we obtain @xmath542 where @xmath543 and @xmath544 . since the functions @xmath545 is continuous and the manifold is compact and because of ( [ eq : errorest ] ) it follows that @xmath546 has the properties claimed in the main theorem . * acknowledgments : * this work was partially supported by fp7 iif research fellowship
project number 303180 , eu marie - curie irses brazilian - european partnership in dynamical systems ( fp7-people-2012-irses 318999 breuds ) , and the brazilian agency fapesp . | we study expanding circle maps interacting in a heterogeneous random network .
heterogeneity means that some nodes in the network are massively connected , while the remaining nodes are only poorly connected .
we provide a probabilistic approach which enables us to describe the effective dynamics of the massively connected nodes when taking a weak interaction limit .
more precisely , we show that for almost every random network and almost all initial conditions the high dimensional network governing the dynamics of the massively connected nodes can be reduced to a few macroscopic equations .
such reduction is intimately related to the ergodic properties of the expanding maps .
this reduction allows one to explore the coherent properties of the network . |
the micro - quasar grs 1915 + 105 is an enigmatic black hole binary ( bhb ) exhibiting enormous variability which have been classified in more than 14 different variability classes @xcite .
it is believed that the extreme variability and rapid state changes observed in grs 1915 + 105 are due to a very high accretion rate , which is close to , or at times higher than , the eddington accretion rate @xcite .
it is also known for exhibiting large superluminal radio flares and steady radio emission which are always associated with specific x - ray variability classes @xcite .
such an extreme and correlated multi - wavelength variability makes grs 1915 + 105 a unique bhb . in this context , igr j170913624 ,
a new x - ray transient source believed to be a bhb , generated considerable interest recently .
it was detected by integral / ibis in 2003 @xcite .
it has exhibited repeated outbursts with periods of two to four years in 1994 , 1996 , 2001 , 2003 , 2007 , and 2011 @xcite .
the recent 2011 outburst of igr j170913624 was unusually long and the source was found to be active even after one year @xcite . during this outburst ,
igr j170913624 revealed its highly variable nature and showed variability patterns so far observed only in grs 1915 + 105 .
the most prominent of these patterns was the ` heartbeat ' pattern , similar to the @xmath0-class in grs 1915 + 105 .
@xcite documented the first six months of rxte observations and showed that not only @xmath0-class but many other variability patterns similar to @xmath1- , @xmath5- , @xmath6- , @xmath7- , @xmath8- , and @xmath9- classes have been observed during this outburst of igr j170913624 .
@xcite also detected a high frequency quasi - periodic oscillation ( hfqpo ) in this source with a frequency of 66 hz , which is almost identical to the frequency of hfqpo in grs 1915 + 105 . despite striking morphological similarities ,
the most perplexing difference between the two sources lies in their observed intensities .
while grs 1915 + 105 is one of the brightest x - ray sources with a typical brightness of @xmath100.5 2 crab , igr j170913624 is about 20 times fainter . in the present scenario ,
mass , distance , and inclination for this source are rather poorly constrained , with reports so far suggesting a mass range of <3 m@xmath4 @xcite to @xmath1015 m@xmath4 @xcite and a distance range of @xmath1011 kpc @xcite to @xmath1020 kpc @xcite . nevertheless , the apparent faintness of igr j170913624 is difficult to explain even after assuming the smallest possible mass of 3 @xmath11 for a black hole @xcite and the largest possible distance of @xmath1025 kpc for a galactic source .
here , we attempt to investigate the possible reasons for this apparent faintness of igr j170913624 by simultaneously fitting spectra at different phases .
the main idea is that the system parameters can not change over the phase of the oscillations .
therefore , a simultaneous fitting of spectra at different phases , with system parameters tied across phases , may put a better constraint on them .
this , along with a proposal that the ` heartbeats ' can be used as a ` standard candle ' , leads to a primary conclusion that the faintness of igr j170913624 is due to its low or negative spin .
we have used data from long simultaneous observations of igr j170913624 made on 2011 march 27 with rxte ( obsid : 96420 - 01 - 05 - 000 , total exposure @xmath1021 ks ) and xmm - newton ( obsid : 0677980201 , total exposure @xmath1039 ks ) with net simultaneous exposure of @xmath1015 ks .
the data reduction for the rxte / pca observation was carried out with heasoft version 6.8 following standard analysis procedure for good xenon data .
we extracted 1 s light curve from pcu2 data .
it showed the typical @xmath1-class oscillations with periods ranging from 30 to 50 s ( figure 1 ) .
it contained a total of 385 bursts .
we carried out ` phase - resolved ' spectroscopy for these bursts in the energy range of 3.035.0 kev for rxte / pca and 0.712.0 kev for xmm / pn data as described below .
the peak time for each burst was identified in a semiautomatic manner using an idl script and the peak - to - peak interval between consecutive bursts was divided into 64 phases of equal length .
the start and stop times of each phase , recorded in rxte mission time for 385 bursts , were used for extracting spectra for each phase .
total counts for all 64 spectra and their corresponding exposure times were then used to generate the ` phase - folded ' light curve ( figure 2 ) .
the 64 phase bins were grouped into five phases as shown in figure 2 and the spectra extracted for these five phases were used for simultaneous spectral fitting .
the grouping was carried out mainly by the visual inspection of the folded rxte / pca lightcurve .
the xmm observation was carried out in the _ fast timing _
mode of epic - mos and the _ burst _ mode of epic - pn and we followed the standard analysis procedures for these modes using _
sas v11.0.0 _ and the latest calibration files .
we used data from xmm - pn only because mos2 data could not be checked for possible pileup ( generation of pattern plot always resulted in error ) whereas mos1 data are not useful in timing mode because of a dead pixel in the ccd . for pn data ,
the observed and the expected pattern behavior differed below 0.7 kev and hence the energy range for rest of the analysis was restricted to 0.712.0 kev .
start and stop times of the 64 phases of all bursts from rxte mission were converted into xmm mission time using the _ xtime _ tool , available at heasarc , which were used to build gti files using sas task _
gtibuild_. these gti files were used for extracting the 64 phase spectra using the task _ evselect_. the ` phase - folded ' light curve was generated using the total counts and the exposure times , as described earlier .
the subtle features were averaged out as a consequence of the quasi - periodicity and co - adding , but the overall profile of the ` phase - folded ' light curve followed a typical burst cycle .
further , it was seen that the oscillations were more pronounced in the xmm light curve indicating that the accretion disk radiation was primarily participating in the oscillations and not the comptonized emission from the corona which dominates at higher energies .
source spectra from the five grouped phases were extracted using rawx columns between 32 and 42 for single and double pixel events ( pattern @xmath124 ) .
sas tools _ rmfgen _ and _ arfgen _ were used to generate redistribution matrices and ancillary files , respectively , and the same files were used for the spectra of all phases .
the background spectrum was extracted from rawx columns between 5 and 7 after confirming that the region was not contaminated significantly with source photons in the selected energy range .
a single background spectrum was used for the five phases .
all spectra were rebinned using sastask _
specgroup _ to have a minimum of 25 counts per channel .
once we extracted the spectra for the five phases for both pca and pn , the 10 spectra were fitted simultaneously with various parameters tied as follows .
the 10 spectra were loaded into xspec as 10 data groups . for a given phase , all parameters for pca and pn
spectra were tied together except the normalization constant which was frozen at 1.0 for pn whereas for pca it was kept free but tied across the five phases . for a particular spectral model , we tied all parameters representing system property , such as mass , distance , inclination , spin or combination of these , across the five phases .
the parameters describing the accretion process such as inner disk temperature or accretion rate , inner disk radius , were fitted independently for each phase .
wide - band x - ray spectrum of a black hole binary generally consists of two dominant components : a multi - color disk and a high - energy tail arising from compton scattering in an optically thin region surrounding the disk .
we used diskpn @xcite as a simplified disk model , primarily because its parameters are cleanly separated in accretion - process - dependent parameters ( disk temperature and inner disk radius ) and system parameters ( normalization ) . for a general relativistic description of the multi - temperature disk spectrum , we used kerrbb @xcite , which is widely used for its accurate modeling of disk spectrum and to investigate black hole spin
the high - energy tail of the spectrum is typically modeled as powerlaw to approximate the comptonized component .
however , @xcite proposed a more physical model simpl to empirically describe the comptonized component . here ,
we have used simpl along with one of the two disk models ( diskpn and kerrbb ) to fit the spectra in the five phases simultaneously , as described below . for the first part of the analysis
, we fitted rxte - pca and xmm - pn spectra for the five phases simultaneously with const*phabs*(simpl@xmath13diskpn ) .
the parameter const was used to account for possible calibration uncertainties between the two instruments .
normalizations of diskpn were tied across the five phases , whereas rest of the parameters were allowed to vary independently .
though the interstellar absorption can be considered as a part of system parameters , we allowed it to vary to account for any phase - dependent absorption intrinsic to the source .
we , however , found that the n@xmath14 values for the five phases were not significantly different and the fitted values of n@xmath14 were in agreement with the values reported by @xcite and @xcite .
table 1 provides the results of spectral fits .
it can be seen that the inner disk temperature is highest for phase 1 corresponding to the peak of the bursts , implying higher accretion rate as expected .
we verified that neither the fe - line nor the reflection component was required to fit the data .
a best fit was obtained with @xmath15 value of 1709.0 for 1030 degrees of freedom . however , for the present work , more important is the best - fit value of diskpn normalization , @xmath16 , as it can provide some constraints on mass ( @xmath17 ) , distance ( @xmath18 ) , and inclination ( @xmath2 ) .
the best fit value of diskpn normalization was found to be @xmath19 . assuming a minimum mass of @xmath103 m@xmath4 and a maximum distance of @xmath1025 kpc for a galactic black hole candidate along with a standard value for color correction factor , @xmath20
, the best - fit value of @xmath21 resulted in a lower limit on inclination angle of 76@xmath3 .
considering the 90% upper confidence limit of @xmath22 for the normalization , the lowest possible inclination angle was @xmath1053@xmath3 .
this lower limit comes only from simultaneous spectral fitting and it is not dependent on any additional information , and hence it can be considered as fairly robust . since spectral fitting could not constrain lower limit of n@xmath23 , it was not possible to obtain an upper limit on @xmath2 with spectral fitting .
however , simultaneous spectral analysis with diskpn to model accretion disk spectra suggests that igr j170913624 is a high inclination binary .
this is consistent with the finding of @xcite and @xcite . , scattering fraction ( f@xmath24 ) , n@xmath14 , and @xmath25 for all combinations of @xmath18 , @xmath17 , @xmath2 and @xmath26 .
the parameters are more or less similar for any combination of system parameters and hence distinction between them is not made .
error bars ( 90% confidence ) are shown with gray and only a subset of data are shown here.,width=453,height=453 ] in the second part , we fitted the spectra using the model cons*phabs*(simpl@xmath13kerrbb ) . apart from mass , distance , inclination , and spin as independent fit parameters , kerrbb has parameters governing the second - order effects such as ` spectral hardening factor ' , ` returning radiation ' and ` limb darkening ' .
we , however , froze these parameters to their default values .
typically kerrbb is used for disk - dominated spectra with luminosity < 0.3 @xmath27 , however , @xcite have shown that simpl@xmath13kerrbb can be used to accurately describe spectra with higher luminosities as well . in this case , we tied all kerrbb parameters except n@xmath14 and mass accretion rate across the five phases .
further , the normalization was frozen to 1.0 .
since all system parameters can not be fitted simultaneously , we selected specific values for mass , inclination , and spin and fitted for mass accretion rate and distance . in order to systematically investigate the parameter space
, we varied the black hole mass from 3 @xmath11 to 20 @xmath11 , inclination angle from @xmath28 to @xmath29 , and spin from 0 to 0.9 .
results of this analysis have been shown in figures 3 and 4 .
figure 3 shows variation of interstellar absorption , n@xmath14 , two parameters of simpl power - law index , @xmath30 and the scattering fraction , @xmath31 , and fit statistic , @xmath32 for the five phases .
since these parameters are more or less the same for any combination of system parameters ( mass , distance , inclination , and spin ) , these are shown without any distinction .
again it was found that neither the fe - line nor the reflection component is required for fitting data with the f - test chance improvement probability being > 88% for all combinations of mass , distance , and inclination . for a combination of mass @xmath17 , inclination @xmath2 ( > 50@xmath3 ) , and spin @xmath26 ,
the fitted values of distance @xmath18 ( top panel ) and mass accretion rate @xmath33 ( bottom panel ) have been shown in figure [ mdplot ] .
only maximum ( phase 1 ) and minimum ( phase 3 ) mass accretion rates have been shown in figure [ mdplot ] for the sake of clarity .
error bars ( 90% confidence limit ) are smaller than the symbols for most of the points in plot .
this indicates that the distance and the accretion rate are very well constrained for a given combination of system parameters .
figure [ mdplot ] can be used to put some significant limits on the spin of the black hole with some independent constraints on either black hole mass or distance .
one such independent constraint comes from the total luminosity argument during ` heartbeat ' oscillations .
@xcite studied such oscillations in grs 1915 + 105 and suggested that the radiation pressure instability augmented by the local eddington limit within inner accretion disk as the origin of such variability pattern .
however , this mechanism requires high accretion rate .
@xcite showed that during the peak of ` heartbeat ' , the bolometric disk luminosity is typically as high as 80%90 % of the eddington luminosity . given the similarity between the variability patterns in grs 1915 + 105 and igr j170913624 , it is natural to assume a similar mechanism operating in both the sources . in this way
, the observed flux during the peak of the ` heartbeat ' oscillations can be used to estimate the distance for a given mass or in other words ` heartbeat ' can be used as a standard candle in order to constrain the parameters .
we found the best - fit value of the peak bolometric flux as 4.10 @xmath34 erg s@xmath35@xmath36 .
figure 1 shows that the peak flux in individual bursts is not the same and there is a burst - to - burst variation in the peak flux values .
therefore , we have assumed the range of peak flux to be ( 3.0 5.0 ) @xmath34 erg s@xmath35 @xmath36 and a more conservative range of peak luminosity to be 60%-90% of eddington luminosity .
thus the obtained possible @xmath37 range is shown as a gray area in the top left corner of figure [ mdplot ] .
it can be seen that the points within this region correspond to inclination angle < 60@xmath3 and spin < 0.2 .
however , the lower limit on inclination was found to be @xmath1076@xmath3 from diskpn normalization .
this presents a tantalizing possibility of black hole spin to be retrograde indicating a black hole spin in opposite direction to the accretion disk .
further , we have found a lower limit of @xmath1053@xmath3 on inclination angle from 90% upper confidence limit of diskpn normalization .
the points corresponding to @xmath3850@xmath3 require spin to be < 0.2 .
thus we exclude the possibility of high spin and it appears that the main reason for the observed faintness of igr j170913624 is very low ( or even negative ) spin of the black hole , in contrast to grs 1915 + 105 , which is known to have a very high spin @xcite .
it can be seen that even for the exotic type of black hole with mass <3 @xmath11 @xcite , this inference on black hole spin remains valid .
further , in order to verify the effect of other frozen parameters of kerrbb , such as returning radiation , limb darkening , and inner boundary stress , we have also enabled all of them ( one by one as well as all together ) and found that the lines corresponding to a particular combination of spin and inclination angle move away from the shaded region .
we verified that the same is valid when powerlaw is used instead of simpl .
thus for any combination of these parameters or model for the high - energy tail , the black hole spin is required to be either very low or negative .
the 66 hz hfqpo of igr j170913624 detected by @xcite may also be considered as an independent constraint on black hole mass , if it is assumed to be related to mass . in this case ,
the black hole mass in igr j170913624 has to be @xmath39 .
for such a high black hole mass , figure 4(a ) does not provide any constraint on the distance , however , both the inclination angle and the spin are required to be > 70@xmath3 and > 0.7 , respectively . for these high values of inclination angle and spin , figure 4(b ) shows that the required accretion rate is only a small fraction of the eddington accretion rate .
thus , if we assume that the 66 hz qpo is related to the black hole mass , the basic accretion process giving rise to the apparent similar variability of grs 1915 + 105 and igr j170913624 has to be different .
however , it is more likely , as also suggested by @xcite , that the 66 hz hfqpo is not directly related to the black hole mass . in that case , the previous argument for a low black hole mass based on the apparent flux and similar accretion process between igr j170913624 and grs 1915 + 105 holds , and the inference of low or negative spin remains valid .
overall this work indicates that the black hole spin may not play a significant role in generating the observed extreme variability and such a behavior is generated mainly by a high accretion rate .
p3.5 cm c c c c c & phase 1 & phase 2 & phase 3 & phase 4 & phase 5 + @xmath40 ( @xmath4110@xmath42@xmath36 ) & 0.93@xmath43 & 0.84@xmath44 & 0.81@xmath45 & 0.81@xmath46 & 0.88@xmath46 + t@xmath47 ( kev ) & 1.24@xmath48 & 1.11@xmath46 & 1.02@xmath46 & 1.05@xmath46 & 1.11@xmath46 + r@xmath49 ( r@xmath50 ) & 24.8@xmath51 & 24.9@xmath52 & 28.2@xmath53 & 26.3@xmath54 & 27.3@xmath55 + @xmath30 & 3.57@xmath56 & 2.66@xmath57 & 2.56@xmath58 & 2.52@xmath59 & 2.70@xmath58 + scattered fraction & 0.47@xmath60 & 0.27@xmath44 & 0.36@xmath44 & 0.37@xmath46 & 0.35@xmath44 + disk flux@xmath61 & 2.10 & 1.23 & 1.01 & 1.06 & 1.47 + total flux@xmath61 & 2.54 & 1.53 & 1.42 & 1.49 & 1.92 + @xmath62 norm@xmath63 & + + + + + +
grs 1915 + 105 was so far the only bhb exhibiting extreme variability and spectral changes over timescales as short as a few tens of seconds .
observations of similar variability in another bhb igr j170913624 establishes that such extreme variability of grs 1915 + 105 is not due to some specific coincidences unique to one particular bhb , but is a more generic phenomenon . here , we presented results of simultaneous fitting of 0.735.0 kev spectra during different phases of the ` heartbeat ' oscillations in igr j170913624 , which indicate that the most likely difference between grs 1915 + 105 and igr j170913624 is in the spins of the respective black holes .
while the black hole in grs 1915 + 105 is known to be rotating with high spin , the black hole in igr j170913624 is found to have a very low spin .
in fact , for inclination @xmath1070@xmath3 , which is favored by the data , the black hole could very well have a retrograde spin . in this case
, igr j170913624 would be the first known astrophysical source having a retrograde spin .
even though theoretically possible , such a scenario would be very challenging to explain from the point of view of evolution of such a system .
this research has made use of data obtained from high energy astrophysics science archive research center ( heasarc ) , provided by nasa s goddard space flight center .
we thank a. r. rao for useful discussions .
we also thank the anonymous referee for very useful comments . | igr j170913624 is a transient x - ray source and is believed to be a galactic black hole candidate .
recently , it has received a considerable attention due to the detection of peculiar variability patterns known as ` heartbeats ' , which are quasi - periodic mini - outbursts repeated over timescales ranging between 5 and 70 s. so far , such variability patterns have been observed only in grs 1915 + 105 and these are classified as @xmath0- and @xmath1-variability classes . here , we present the results of ` phase - resolved ' spectroscopy of the ` heartbeat ' oscillations of igr j170913624 using data from simultaneous observations made by rxte and xmm - newton .
we find that the 0.735 kev spectra can be fitted with a ` canonical ' model for black hole sources consisting of only two components a multi - temperature disk black body and a power law ( or its equivalent ) .
we attempt to constrain the system parameters of the source by simultaneously fitting spectra during different phases of the burst profile while tying the system parameters across the phases .
the results indicate that the source is a high inclination binary ( @xmath2>53@xmath3 ) .
further , the observed low flux from the source can be explained only if the black hole spin is very low , along with constraints on the black hole mass ( < 5 m@xmath4 ) and the distance ( > 20 kpc ) . for higher inclination angles , which is favored by the data ,
the black hole spin is required to be negative . thus low or retrograde
spin could be the reason for the low luminosity of the source . |
at distances in the range of about @xmath17 to @xmath18 , the sculptor group is among the nearest galaxy groups beyond the local group @xcite .
it forms an elongated filament of galaxies and comprises a number of separate subgroups at different distances along the line of sight . at a distance of about @xmath19 ,
the nearest of these subgroups consists of ngc 55 , ngc 300 , and possibly two or more known dwarf spheroidal companions ( @xcite ; koribalski et al .
, in prep . ) .
ngc 55 and ngc 300 are medium - sized spiral galaxies of type sb(s)m and sa(s)d , respectively @xcite .
their proximity makes them preferential targets for deep observations with high spatial resolution and mass sensitivity .
some of the basic properties and physical parameters of ngc 300 , including the results of this work , are listed in table [ tab_ngc300 ] .
the distance towards ngc 300 has been measured with great accuracy and through different methods .
@xcite used the tip of the red giant branch to determine distance moduli of @xmath20 and @xmath21 through two different statistical methods as part of the araucaria project @xcite .
their results are consistent with the distance moduli of @xmath22 and @xmath23 derived from cepheid variables by @xcite and @xcite , respectively . based on these measurements
we therefore adopt a distance of @xmath6 for ngc 300 throughout this paper .
early imaging of ngc 300 was carried out by @xcite using the 64-m parkes radio telescope .
they determined an mass of @xmath24 and a total mass of @xmath25 from the rotation curve under the assumption of a distance of @xmath6 .
they also noticed that the velocity field of ngc 300 appears strongly distorted which they attributed to the gravitational influence of a large cloud to the south - east of the galaxy .
this cloud , however , was later found to be most likely part of the magellanic stream @xcite .
lrll parameter & value & unit & ref .
+ type & sa(s)d & & [ 1 ] + @xmath26 ( j2000 ) & @xmath27 & & + @xmath28 ( j2000 ) & @xmath29 & & + distance & @xmath30 & @xmath31 & [ 2 ] [ 3 ] + @xmath32 & @xmath33 & & [ 4 ] + radial velocity & & & + barycentric & @xmath34 & @xmath35 & + lsr & @xmath36 & @xmath35 & + position angle@xmath37 & & & + inner disc & @xmath38 & & + outer disc & @xmath39 & & + inclination & @xmath40 & & + max .
velocity & @xmath41 & @xmath35 & + integrated flux & @xmath42 & @xmath43 & + mass & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & + inner disc & @xmath46 & @xmath45 & + outer disc & @xmath47 & @xmath45 & + gas mass@xmath48 & @xmath49 & @xmath45 & + stellar mass@xmath48 & @xmath50 & @xmath45 & + total mass@xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath45 & + + + a larger area around ngc 300 was mapped in by @xcite with the 64-m parkes radio telescope . within their brightness temperature sensitivity of @xmath53 over @xmath54 and across the @xmath55 parkes beam they detected several extended gas clouds with velocities comparable to those found across ngc 300 , including a long ` tail ' extending about @xmath56 to the southeast of the galaxy .
while @xcite assumed that these clouds were associated with ngc 300 , there has been a long debate over the past decades whether they might instead be fragments of the magellanic stream that runs across the same part of the sky ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
a more detailed image of ngc 300 was obtained by @xcite with the twin - element interferometer of the owens valley radio observatory . at a much higher angular resolution of @xmath57 half - power beam width
they were able to derive a detailed radial velocity map of the inner part of the galaxy . by fitting a tilted ring model to the velocity field
they were able to describe the distorted velocity contours of ngc 300 as a result of varying inclination and position angle across the disc .
the rotation curve obtained by @xcite from the tilted ring model is basically flat beyond a radius of about @xmath58 with a turnover velocity of @xmath59 at @xmath60 radius .
they suggest that the warping of the disc of ngc 300 could have been caused by a close encounter with another galaxy or massive cloud within the past @xmath61 years .
similar synthesis observations of ngc 300 with somewhat higher angular resolution ( @xmath62 half - power beam width ) were obtained by @xcite who employed a mosaic of five pointings with the very large array ( vla ) .
unfortunately , the synthesis images obtained by @xcite and @xcite did not reveal the extent and structure of the outer disc of ngc 300 due to insufficient field of view and lack of sensitivity .
we therefore decided to obtain deep observations of a large field of @xmath0 around ngc 300 in a mosaic of 32 pointings with the australia telescope compact array ( atca ) .
the aim of these observations was to map the entire extent of the disc of ngc 300 , determine its structure , and dynamics , and search for extra - planar gas in the vicinity of the galaxy .
the observations and results of this project are described in this paper .
similar observations of the sculptor group galaxy ngc 55 will be presented in a separate paper .
this paper is organized as follows : section [ sect_observations ] describes our observations and data reduction procedure . in section [ sect_results ]
we discuss our results , including the general physical parameters of ngc 300 and the results of the rotation curve analysis . in section [ sect_massmodels ]
we describe the fitting of mass models , with and without dark matter , to the observed rotation curve . in section [ sect_discussion ]
we discuss the possible origin of the extended outer gas disc of ngc 300 and present evidence of the distortion of the gas disc by ram pressure .
finally , section [ sect_summary ] gives a summary of our results and conclusions .
the observations of ngc 300 were carried out in late 2007 and 2008 with the six 22-m antennas of the australia telescope compact array .
five of the antennas are moveable along an east - west track with a total length of @xmath63 , whereas the sixth antenna is fixed and separated by another @xmath63 from the western end of the track .
the total observing time of @xmath64 was equally divided among the ew352 and ew367 array configurations to improve baseline coverage . because of the large spatial separation between antenna 6 and all other antennas in these configurations we only used data from antennas 1 to 5 in our analysis .
the resulting minimum and maximum baselines were @xmath65 and @xmath66 , respectively .
ngc 300 was simultaneously observed in the 21-cm line emission of neutral hydrogen @xcite and in 21-cm radio continuum emission , using the two independent frequency chains of the atca . for the observations we used a bandwidth of @xmath67
centred at a frequency of @xmath68 .
the resulting velocity coverage is about @xmath69 with a channel separation of @xmath70 and an effective velocity resolution of about @xmath71 .
the radio continuum data were obtained over a bandwidth of @xmath72 centred at @xmath73 .
only the data will be discussed in this paper . in order to map a large field of about @xmath0 ( corresponding to a projected size of about @xmath74 ) we covered ngc 300 with a large mosaic of 32 separate pointings .
adjacent pointings were separated by @xmath75 which corresponds to approximately half the half - power beam width of the atca antennas at a wavelength of @xmath76 .
the geometry of the entire mosaic is outlined in fig .
[ fig_mosaic ] .
the integration time per pointing in each array configuration was @xmath77 .
the resulting spectral rms noise level at @xmath70 channel separation is about @xmath78 per beam which is equal to the theoretical noise level . at the beginning of each observing run
we spent about 15 to 20 minutes on the atca s standard flux calibration source , pks 1934@xmath79638 , which was used for bandpass and flux calibration of the data .
every 45 minutes during our observing runs we integrated for 5 minutes on our gain amplitude and phase calibrator , pks 0008@xmath79421 , which has a @xmath80 flux of about @xmath81 and a separation from ngc 300 of about @xmath82 .
pks 0008@xmath79421 was used to calibrate gain amplitudes and phases as a function of time . of the atca antennas at @xmath76 .
the black cross marks the central position of the entire mosaic ( and of ngc 300 ) at @xmath83 and @xmath84 in j2000 equatorial coordinates .
the grey ellipse outlines the approximate size and orientation of the optical disc of ngc 300 . ]
the data were reduced and analysed with the astronomical image processing system ( aips ; @xcite ) , the multichannel image reconstruction , image analysis and display ( miriad ) software package @xcite , and the groningen image processing system ( gipsy ; @xcite ) in a combined approach .
we first used the task atlod to read the raw data into aips for the purpose of flagging bad pixels in the time - baseline domain using the interactive task spflg .
next , we imported the flagged data into miriad .
the flagging table produced by aips was then applied via the miriad task fgflag before proceeding with some additional flagging of shadowed antennas , absorption in the primary calibrator , pks 1934@xmath79638 , and otherwise corrupted visibilities .
we then carried out the standard data reduction procedure , making use of miriad s dedicated mosaicking capabilities which include automatic corrections for primary beam attenuation . for the image cube and beam we applied a robust weighting of visibilities with a robustness parameter of zero .
the resulting synthesised beam is elliptical with a full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of @xmath4 and a position angle of @xmath85 with respect to north .
furthermore , we employed a pixel size of @xmath86 in the image domain and a resolution and channel separation of @xmath3 through hanning smoothing in the spectral domain .
the resulting spectral rms noise level is @xmath87 per beam , corresponding to a @xmath1 column density sensitivity of @xmath88 per spectral channel .
this translates into a @xmath1 mass sensitivity of @xmath5 at a distance of @xmath6 . to reduce the impact of beam sidelobes caused by our incomplete aperture synthesis we subsequently deconvolved the image data cube using the clean algorithm originally developed by @xcite .
we actually applied the steer clean algorithm @xcite implemented in the miriad task mossdi with a flux density cutoff of @xmath89 per beam equivalent to about three times the rms noise level at @xmath3 channel width .
individual channel maps of the final data cube are shown in fig .
[ fig_chanmaps ] .
the zeroth , first , and second moment maps of ngc 300 were calculated using the aips task momnt . for this purpose , we first multiplied the data cube with the theoretical gain across the mosaic to obtain a data cube with a constant noise level at all positions and frequencies .
next , we created a mask from the data cube by hanning - smoothing the frequency axis over three channels , convolving the spatial dimension with a gaussian of 5 pixels fwhm , and then masking all pixels in the smoothed cube that had a flux density value of less than @xmath90 per beam . in momnt ,
only those pixels of the original data cube that had not been masked in the smoothed cube were used in calculating the moment maps .
finally , the moment maps were divided again by the gain model to recover the original gain levels across the mosaic .
there are several ways of determining the mean radial velocity of an line , including the calculation of the first moment of the spectrum , the fitting of one or more gaussian functions to the spectral line , or simply by using the velocity of the peak of the line .
the impact of these and other methods on the outcome of rotation curve fits was studied in detail by @xcite based on a sample of galaxies observed as part of the nearby galaxy survey ( things ; @xcite ) .
they found the most suitable method to be the fitting of gauss hermite polynomials @xcite with an additional skewness parameter , @xmath91 , to the spectral lines .
the fitting function used by @xcite and implemented in the gipsy task xgaufit is a modified gauss
hermite polynomial including only the zeroth- and third - order terms , namely @xmath92 with the substitution @xmath93 .
the free parameters of the fit are @xmath94 , @xmath95 , @xmath96 , and the aforementioned skewness parameter , @xmath91 . the advantage of using gauss
hermite polynomials instead of pure gaussian functions is that the former will account for asymmetries in the line profile that can be characterised by @xmath91 . in our analysis
we used the position of the maximum of @xmath97 to derive the radial velocity field .
the total column density map of ngc 300 , derived from the zeroth moment of the data cube , is shown in fig . [ fig_coldens ] .
the disc appears to be significantly more extended than the optical disc and shows a clear separation into an inner and outer disc .
the inner disc is characterised by high column densities of @xmath98 and appears to be aligned with the stellar disc .
in contrast , the outer disc has lower column densities of typically @xmath99 and is spatially much more extended .
furthermore , the transition between the inner and outer disc seems to go along with a systematic twist resulting in very different orientation angles of the two discs .
this twist is also evident in the radial velocity map in fig .
[ fig_coldens ] and the position - velocity diagrams in fig .
[ fig_posivelo ] . owing to our large mapping area and sufficiently high sensitivity ,
this is the first time that the entire extent ( down to a column density level of about @xmath2 ) of the disc of ngc 300 has been revealed in such detail . within the @xmath2 column density level
, the major axis of the disc of ngc 300 spans slightly more than @xmath9 on the sky which is equivalent to a linear diameter of about @xmath10 .
earlier observations of ngc 300 with the vla by @xcite revealed only a small part of the outer disc , mainly due to the insufficient size of their mosaic of only five pointings . the integrated spectrum of ngc 300 is shown in fig .
[ fig_intspec ] . the total flux derived from our atca data is @xmath100 .
the corresponding total mass of ngc 300 amounts to @xmath101 under the assumption that the gas is optically thin .
since this will not be the case in the dense inner regions of the disc , the derived mass must be considered a lower limit .
in addition , some of the diffuse flux of ngc 300 will not have been picked up by the atca due to the lack of sufficiently short telescope baselines .
the effect of missing short spacings and the inability of clean to recover all the flux is visible in the channel maps of fig .
[ fig_chanmaps ] , with the emission sitting in a slightly negative bowl .
the mass determined from the parkes all - sky survey ( hipass ; @xcite ) is slightly larger with @xmath102 ( * ? ? ?
* scaled to a distance of @xmath6 ) .
this indicates that some flux is missing in our atca observations , although not much . on the other hand
, hipass suffers from inaccurate bandpass calibration resulting in serious artefacts near bright and extended sources , and the true mass of ngc 300 could even be somewhat higher than the one determined by @xcite .
the total mass of @xmath103 determined by @xcite from their vla observations ( again scaled to a distance of @xmath6 ) is significantly smaller , mainly reflecting the limited size of their mosaic on the sky and possibly the lack of short telescope baselines .
we can also try to assess how the mass is distributed between the inner and outer disc of ngc 300 . by simply defining a column density boundary of @xmath104 between the two disc components we obtain masses of @xmath46 and @xmath105 for the inner and outer disc , respectively .
hence , a significant fraction of the mass is within the extended outer disc .
a closer inspection of the column density distribution reveals a certain degree of asymmetry in the disc .
the south - eastern edge of the disc is rather clean and sharp , whereas the north - western edge looks more frayed and less well defined .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ fig_nhiprofile ] showing the column density profile across ngc 300 as a function of declination offset ( i.e. along a line of constant right ascension passing through the centre of the galaxy ) .
there is a distinctive plateau in the southern part of ngc 300 followed by a sudden and steep drop in column density towards the southern edge of the disc . in the northern part ,
in contrast , we observe a steady exponential decline without any obvious plateau or drop .
the velocity dispersion map of ngc 300 , derived from the fitting of gauss hermite polynomials to the spectra , is shown in the lower - right panel of fig . [ fig_coldens ] .
velocity dispersions across the inner disc are variable and somewhat higher than in the outer disc with typical values in the range of about @xmath106 to @xmath107 .
in contrast , the outer disc appears homogeneous with dispersions of just under @xmath108 in most areas ( equivalent to just over @xmath109 fwhm for gaussian line profiles ) .
these values are not atypical for the warm neutral medium of the milky way @xcite and indicate an upper limit on the order of @xmath110 for the gas temperature
. the true gas temperature may be well below this upper limit , as effects such as turbulent motion and beam smearing will contribute to the observed line width .
are due to galactic foreground emission that was not deconvolved .
the vertical dotted line indicates the systemic velocity of ngc 300 of @xmath111 ( equivalent to @xmath112 in the barycentric reference frame ) . ]
[ fig_dispersion ] reveals regions of increased velocity dispersion near the boundary between the inner and outer disc , in particular on the north - eastern side of the galaxy .
the highest dispersions of about @xmath109 are found along a filament in the eastern part of ngc 300 .
such high values can no longer be explained by thermal line broadening alone , as in that case gas temperatures of about @xmath113 would be required .
instead , the high velocity dispersion suggests the presence of different gas components along the line of sight as supported by the spectra shown on the right - hand side of fig .
[ fig_dispersion ] .
the spectra were extracted from the locations of highest dispersion marked with a and b in the map and reveal a clear double line profile at the boundary between the inner and outer disc .
apparently , each disc component produces a separate line component in the spectrum , and the transition between the inner and outer disc is not gradual but abrupt within the size of our synthesized beam .
this is also suggested by the radial velocity field as indicated by the white contours in fig .
[ fig_dispersion ] . in the transition region between the inner and outer disc
we observe a strong discontinuity in the velocity field .
the resulting kinks in the velocity contours coincide precisely with the regions of increased velocity dispersion in the map , thus confirming our impression of an abrupt transition between the inner and outer disc of ngc 300
. column density sensitivity of about @xmath2 . ]
interestingly , the transition from the inner disc to the outer disc is less sharp on the south - western side of ngc 300 where the velocity contour lines are much smoother , and despite a slightly increased velocity dispersion the spectra do not exhibit a double - peak profile .
instead , there is a gradual transition from the inner to the outer disc component in the spectrum across several beam widths . in order to determine the rotation curve , @xmath114 , of ngc 300 we must assume a model for the three - dimensional kinematics of the galaxy .
one of the simplest and most commonly applied models is to assume that the gas particles move in circular orbits along tilted rings with varying position angle , @xmath115 , and inclination , @xmath116 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
in addition , each ring is assigned a position , @xmath117 , and systemic velocity , @xmath118 , both of which can also be allowed to vary .
we used the gipsy task rotcur to fit a tilted ring model to the radial velocity field of ngc 300 as derived from the fitting of gauss hermite polynomials to the spectral lines .
we fitted 20 rings with radii ranging from @xmath119 to @xmath120 ( @xmath121 to @xmath13 ) in steps of @xmath122 .
each ring was chosen to be @xmath122 wide to match the angular resolution of our data .
data within an angle of @xmath123 around the minor axis of ngc 300 were excluded from the fit , and all data were weighted with the cosine of the position angle , @xmath124 .
we first derived the position of the centre of ngc 300 from an optical @xmath125-band image taken with the mpg / eso 2.2-m telescope at la silla @xcite .
ngc 300 has a very distinct , point - like core that is thought to be associated with either a nuclear stellar cluster or even a central black hole @xcite and should therefore provide us with an accurate position of the dynamical centre .
a gaussian fit to the optical core revealed a central position of @xmath126 and @xmath127 in the j2000.0 coordinate system .
next , we ran rotcur with the optically derived central position fixed and the gas expansion velocity also fixed to a value of @xmath128 .
all other parameters ( systemic velocity , rotation velocity , position angle , and inclination angle ) were still left as free parameters .
after the first run of rotcur we determined the systemic velocity by averaging over the fitted systemic velocities of all rings .
the resulting value of @xmath129 in the lsr frame , corresponding to @xmath130 in the barycentric reference frame , was then used and kept fixed in all subsequent runs .
this result is consistent with the barycentric velocity of @xmath131 found by @xcite based on hipass .
next , we ran rotcur again with only the rotation velocity , position angle , and inclination angle left as free parameters .
we followed the approach described by @xcite and first fixed the radial position angle profile .
to reduce the initial bumpiness of the position angle profile we smoothed it by applying a boxcar filter with a width of @xmath132 ( equal to three radial bins ) to the position angle solution .
after the next run of rotcur we also smoothed and fixed the inclination angle profile using the same boxcar filter as for the position angle . with all other parameters fixed , we then ran rotcur for the last time to obtain the final solution for the rotation curve . our final rotation curve of ngc 300
is shown in fig .
[ fig_rotcur]a and table [ tab_parameters ] . a comparison between the observed and modelled velocity fields is presented in fig . [ fig_velofield ] .
due to the combination of a large field of view with a fairly compact array configuration we are able to determine the rotation curve out to an angular radius of @xmath120 equivalent to a physical radius of @xmath13 . this is a significant improvement compared to the previous measurement with the very large array ( vla ) by @xcite which covered a radius of only @xmath133 .
the rotation curve derived by @xcite is also plotted in fig .
[ fig_rotcur]a for comparison . within their uncertainties
both rotation curves agree quite well , although a direct comparison is difficult due to the different resolutions of the vla observations and the atca observations presented here . at a higher resolution of @xmath134 fwhm
, the rotation curve of @xcite shows small - scale variations not present in our atca rotation curve . in addition
, there is some discrepancy in the very inner region of @xmath135 which is most likely caused by different degrees of beam smearing in combination with a rapid change in rotation velocity in the inner part of the galaxy .
hence , our atca observations in particular are not capable of reliably defining the rotation curve of ngc 300 across the inner @xmath136 .
the derived rotation curve of ngc 300 rises out to a radius of about @xmath137 to @xmath138 ( equivalent to @xmath139 to @xmath133 ) where we observe a maximum rotation velocity of @xmath140 at @xmath141 ( @xmath142 ) .
this value is consistent with the results of @xcite who found a maximum velocity of @xmath143 at a radius of @xmath144 ( @xmath145 ) .
@xcite derived similar values in the range of @xmath146 to @xmath147 at a radius of @xmath60 ( @xmath148 ) .
beyond about @xmath15 the rotation velocity gradually decreases to below @xmath149 .
this decrease was not seen in the previous vla data of @xcite due to insufficient radial extent of their map .
a particular problem of rotation curve fits in general is the determination of uncertainties .
the statistical errors of the fit , as provided by rotcur , are usually much smaller than the actual uncertainties of the solution which are dominated by systematic errors such as non - circular motion of the observed gas , insufficient spatial resolution of the observations , effects of varying optical depth , etc .
there are two possible ways to obtain more reliable estimates of the uncertainties .
one possibility is to determine the standard deviation of velocities along each tilted ring from the mean value of the rotation velocity for that ring .
this provides us with a more realistic assessment of the true deviations of the observed velocities from the model .
the error bars of our final rotation curve presented in fig . [ fig_rotcur]a have been determined by this method .
another possibility is to derive the rotation curve for the approaching and receding side of the galaxy separately and assess the differences between the two curves .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig_rotcur]b where the approaching and receding curves are compared to the overall rotation curve .
the fits for the approaching and receding sides are independent from the overall rotation curve fit , as we derived separate solutions for the position angle and inclination .
the two rotation curves both show a clear maximum and then decrease again at larger radii .
the position of the maximum as well as the overall shape of the rotation curve , however , differ substantially between the approaching and receding side .
these discrepancies indicate systematic uncertainties of up to @xmath150 for the overall rotation curve of ngc 300 .
the rotation curve of the receding side continually decreases after reaching a maximum at @xmath151 , whereas the curve derived from the approaching side also decreases but then flattens out at larger radii .
in addition , the approaching side has its rotation curve maximum significantly further inward at @xmath152 .
these differences indicate a high degree of asymmetry in the kinematics of the gas disc of ngc 300 , some of which is immediately evident from the velocity map in the left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig_velofield ] .
the results indicate that the finding of a decreasing rotation curve in the outer disc should be approached with caution because non - circular motions and asymmetries in the disc could have contributed significantly to the observed velocity field of ngc 300 .
[ fig_rotcur]c and [ fig_rotcur]d show the position angle , @xmath153 , and inclination , @xmath154 , used in the final rotation curve fit with rotcur . for comparison
we also show the originally fitted values before applying the boxcar filter for smoothing and the separate solutions for the approaching and receding side of the galaxy .
the position angle is constant over the entire inner disc of ngc 300 with @xmath155 for @xmath156 . beyond the edge of the inner disc the position angle of the gas disc gradually changes by about @xmath157 only to become constant again in the very outer disc with @xmath158 for @xmath159 .
this behaviour of @xmath153 reflects the visual impression of a twist in the disc of ngc 300 and suggests the presence of two distinct gas discs , each with its own spatial orientation .
the variation in inclination , @xmath154 , with radius appears less regular .
the inclination of the gas disc increases from about @xmath157 to just over @xmath160 within the inner @xmath55 ( @xmath161 ) and then gently decreases again to @xmath162 in the outermost regions of the disc . the observed decrease in rotation velocity
is strongly coupled with the characteristics of the inclination angle in the outer parts of the disc .
a smaller inclination angle would result in a higher rotation velocity . in order to obtain a flat rotation curve ,
the inclination angle of the outermost tilted ring would need to be about @xmath163 .
this is significantly smaller than the inclination angle of about @xmath164 resulting from the tilted ring model . at the same time
, we estimate a geometric inclination angle of about @xmath165 by comparing the major and minor axis of the @xmath166 column density contour level under the assumption of perfect circular symmetry of the disc .
this is consistent with the kinematic inclination from the tilted ring model .
it is interesting to note in this context that the maximum rotation velocity occurs near the transition radius between the inner and outer disc .
a closer inspection of the rotation curves derived for the approaching and receding sides of ngc 300 ( fig . [ fig_rotcur ] ) reveals that the position of maximum rotation velocity is closely linked to strong variations in inclination angle at that particular radius .
it is possible that part of this variation in inclination is an artefact caused by the failure of the tilted ring model to cope with the sudden transition between the inner and outer disc .
consequently , the decrease in rotation velocity across the outer disc of ngc 300 could be less pronounced than indicated by the tilted ring model .
after having determined the overall rotation curve , we can now try to derive mass models of ngc 300 using the gipsy task rotmas .
this will allow us to study the radial distribution of the different visible and dark matter components in ngc 300 and assess how much dark matter is required to explain the rotation curve .
for this purpose , we assume the presence of three mass components , namely a gaseous disc , a stellar disc , and a dark matter halo .
rotmas will attempt to fit the velocity curves of these three components to the total rotation curve : @xmath167 the factors @xmath168 and @xmath169 are mass scaling factors for the stellar and gaseous disc , respectively .
rotmas determines the velocity curve , @xmath170 , of a mass component from its mass surface density , @xmath171 . in the following sections [ sect_gasmass ] and [ sect_starmass ] we will derive the required mass surface densities of the gaseous and stellar disc . in section [ sect_darkmass ] we will introduce the different dark matter models used in the mass modelling of ngc 300
finally , section [ sect_massmodelling ] will discuss the outcome of the mass modelling .
[ cols= " > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] for all three halo models we carried out fits for fixed , partly fixed ( gas only ) , and variable stellar and gaseous mass components .
the resulting mass model fits are shown in table [ tab_massmodels ] and fig .
[ fig_massmodels ] .
all three dark matter halo models result in reasonably good fits .
the goodness of fit of the pseudo - isothermal halo model is somewhat lower compared to the burkert and nfw halo models .
the lower performance of the pseudo - isothermal halo is mainly due to its @xmath172 density profile at large radii . as a consequence
, the velocity curve will continue to increase and eventually converge to a parameter - dependent constant , @xmath173 .
therefore , the pseudo - isothermal halo model can not explain the decreasing rotation curve of ngc 300 , whereas the burkert and nfw halo models ( both with an @xmath174 behaviour ) are doing better .
of course , all three halo models produce a lower reduced @xmath175 in the case of free stellar and gas mass scaling factors .
whereas for the pseudo - isothermal and nfw haloes the improvement is significant , the burkert halo is the only model to produce a good fit with fixed mass scaling factors . in the case of free mass scaling factors we obtain values in the range of @xmath176 and @xmath177 .
fixing the gas mass scaling factor to @xmath178 yields somewhat smaller stellar mass scaling factors of @xmath179 . as the stellar mass scaling factor
strongly depends on the assumptions made about the stellar mass - to - light ratio of ngc 300 , a higher value of @xmath168 can arise from differences in star formation history or metallicity compared to the standard spiral galaxy model found by @xcite . in comparison ,
the best mass model fit for ngc 300 found by @xcite yields @xmath180 ( relative to our stellar disc mass of @xmath181 ) , and his maximum - disc model has @xmath182 .
@xcite derive somewhat larger values of @xmath183 and @xmath184 for their best - fitting and maximum - disc models , respectively .
these numbers are all in general agreement , but they also expose the uncertainties in the determination of the stellar mass - to - light ratio and the total stellar disc mass of ngc 300 .
the free mass scaling factors for the gaseous component are somewhat higher than expected . a factor of 2 can still be explained by optical depth effects in the inner regions of the gas disc , significant amounts of ionised gas throughout the disc , or missing flux in our map due to lack of short interferometer spacings .
gas mass scaling factors of 4 or 5 , however , seem unreasonably large and not realistic . note that in the very inner region of ngc 300 the value of the rotation velocity of the gas disc is negative ( see fig . [ fig_massmodels ] ) .
this does not imply counter - rotation of the gas or the presence of negative mass , but simply reflects a net outward force on test particles due to the central depression of the gas disc .
this net outward force results in a negative value of @xmath185 and therefore an imaginary velocity in the mathematical description of mass models that is usually expressed by negative values of @xmath186 .
in addition to the dark matter models discussed above we also fitted two models without any dark matter component at all , using newtonian dynamics and ( non - relativistic ) modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ; @xcite ) , respectively . in both cases ,
only the stellar and gas mass scaling factors were left as free parameters of the fitting procedure . for the mond model we assumed a constant @xmath187 @xcite . and fixed mass scaling factors resulted in very similar values of @xmath188 . ] the resulting mass models are shown in table [ tab_massmodels2 ] and fig . [ fig_massmodels2 ] .
neither of the two models produces meaningful results .
the best fit in the mond scenario ( @xmath189 ) yields mass scaling factors of @xmath190 and @xmath191 for the stellar and gaseous disc , respectively .
apart from the significantly larger @xmath192 compared to all of the dark matter models with free mass scaling factors , the mond model results in a considerable downscaling of the gas disc mass .
this is an implausible result because the derived gas mass surface density was directly derived from the observed column densities and must therefore be a lower limit .
fixing the mass scaling factor for the gas disc to a value of @xmath178 slightly reduces the stellar mass scaling factor to @xmath193 , the goodness - of - fit parameter , however , significantly deteriorates to @xmath194 .
the reason for the inferior performance of mond is the decrease in rotation velocity at larger radii .
mond has been designed to explain the flat rotation curves originally observed in many galaxies .
therefore , the model will fail in cases of decreasing rotation curve .
consequently , deep observations with the aim to detect the faint , outer gas discs of galaxies have the potential to challenge mond through the detection of decreasing rotation curves in the outer regions of many more galaxies .
it should be noted , though , that as discussed earlier the observed decrease in the rotation velocity of ngc 300 is uncertain due to the possibility of non - circular motions and asymmetries in the disc .
deep studies of a much larger sample of spiral galaxies will be required to investigate the frequency of occurrence of decreasing rotation curves in these galaxies .
the newtonian scenario without dark matter also fails to produce meaningful results .
the best fit again has a large @xmath195 .
in addition , both the stellar and gaseous disc masses would have to be scaled up significantly by scaling factors of @xmath196 and @xmath197 , respectively . such large scaling factors , in particular for the gas disc , are highly implausible .
of course , fixing the gas mass scaling factor to @xmath178 does not produce any meaningful result at all , because the remaining free stellar mass component dramatically fails to reproduce the overall shape of the rotation curve , resulting in a @xmath192 of @xmath198 . in summary
, we obtain the best mass model fits under the assumption of a burkert or nfw dark matter halo .
both dark matter models can cope with the decreasing rotation curve of ngc 300 at larger radii .
the burkert halo provides the best fit with fixed mass scaling factors , but both halo models produce similarly good fits with variable mass scaling factors , although the gas mass scaling factor is slightly larger and less realistic for the nfw halo .
the resulting total mass of ngc 300 within @xmath13 amounts to @xmath199 . for fixed mass scaling factors
almost 90 per cent of the mass is contributed by dark matter . in the case of variable mass scaling factors
we obtain 68 per cent dark matter for both the burkert and nfw halo models ( but only 57 per cent for the pseudo - isothermal halo model ) .
however , all these results should be approached with great caution .
first of all , none of the dark matter models discussed above is physically motivated . instead , these are heuristic models based mainly on the results of numerical computer simulations .
secondly , the lower @xmath192 values of the models with dark matter compared to those without dark matter may simply reflect the larger number of free fitting parameters in the former case .
any increase in the number of mass components or free parameters may naturally improve the goodness of fit , no matter what dark matter model one assumes .
a conspicuous feature of ngc 300 is its extended outer disc spanning more than @xmath9 ( equivalent to about @xmath10 ) across the sky .
although the outer disc was partly mapped by previous observations ( e.g. , @xcite ) , this is the first time that its extent has been imaged out to the @xmath2 column density level with moderately high spatial resolution of approximately @xmath7 .
the results of our tilted ring model suggest that there is a substantial change in position angle between the inner and outer disc , resulting in a twisted appearance of ngc 300 which is particularly obvious in the velocity field .
one possible scenario for this twist is that the distortion and warping of the outer disc of ngc 300 was caused by tidal forces during a recent encounter with another galaxy .
a potential candidate for a close encounter could be ngc 55 .
both galaxies are separated by about @xmath200 on the sky , corresponding to a projected separation of about @xmath201 . under the assumption that both galaxies move away from each other at a relative velocity of @xmath202 ,
there would have been a close encounter between ngc 55 and ngc 300 about @xmath203 ago .
this time scale is comparable to the @xmath204 that have passed since the previous perigalactic passage of the magellanic clouds on their orbit about the milky way and the resulting creation of the magellanic stream as predicted by numerical simulations ( @xcite ; however see @xcite ) .
alternatively , the distortion of the disc of ngc 300 could have been caused by a recent encounter with a smaller companion galaxy .
the nearest currently known companion is the dwarf - spheroidal galaxy eso 294@xmath79g010 .
its distance of about @xmath6 @xcite is the same as that of ngc 55 and ngc 300 , and its angular separation from ngc 300 is @xmath205 , equivalent to a physical separation of about @xmath206 .
its small size @xcite and relatively large separation from ngc 300 , however , suggest that eso 294@xmath79g010 has never had any significant gravitational influence on ngc 300 . at the same time , eso 294@xmath79g010 is much closer to ngc 55 with an angular separation of only @xmath207 equivalent to about @xmath208 .
deep optical observations of two fields in the outer part of ngc 300 with the gemini south 8-m telescope by @xcite revealed an extended stellar disc reaching out to a radius of at least @xmath209 ( equivalent to about @xmath210 or 10 optical scale lengths ) .
surprisingly , the luminosity of the stellar disc of ngc 300 shows a simple exponential profile over its entire radial extent ( except for the nuclear region ) without any indication of a deviation or break .
this seems to contradict our observation of a strongly warped disc with a rather discontinuous transition between the inner and outer disc .
if this warp were the result of tidal interaction , the stellar disc should have been affected in the same way .
it is important to note that @xcite did not map the entire two - dimensional distribution of the outer disc on the sky , but observed only two fields in the south - eastern quadrant of ngc 300 .
any warp in the stellar disc would therefore have to affect the stars at this particular azimuthal angle to be discernible , and further optical imaging at different azimuthal angles would be required to firmly exclude the presence of a warp in the outer stellar disc .
@xcite discuss some of the implications of this discrepancy and speculate about the origin of the extended stellar disc , including the possibility of stars being scattered from the inner disc .
another possibility is that gas accreted by ngc 300 through hot or cold accretion modes could have fuelled low levels of star formation in the outer disc . in this case , however , there should be a break in the radial stellar surface brightness profile .
alternatively , stars could have formed in the outer disc as a result of instabilities such as spiral density waves . in order to test this hypothesis ,
@xcite calculated the toomre @xmath211 parameter , @xmath212 @xcite , based on the data of @xcite . here
, @xmath213 is the velocity dispersion of the gas disc , @xmath214 is the epicyclic frequency of the rotating disc defined by @xmath215 and @xmath216 denotes the gas mass surface density , all three of which are a function of galactocentric radius , @xmath217 .
@xcite found values in excess of @xmath218 for the disc beyond a radius of @xmath58 ( equivalent to about @xmath219 ) , suggesting that the outer disc of ngc 300 is stable with respect to axisymmetric instabilities .
recalculation of @xmath211 based on our observations with the atca , however , suggests somewhat smaller @xmath211 parameters over much of the disc of ngc 300 . using eq .
[ eqn_toomreq ] and assuming the same constant gas velocity dispersion of @xmath220 as @xcite yields typical values of @xmath221 between @xmath17 and @xmath222 radius ( fig .
[ fig_toomreq ] ) , suggesting that the gas disc may be susceptible to axisymmetric instabilities .
however , a slightly higher and more realistic velocity dispersion of @xmath108 @xcite would result in the disc being toomre stable at most radii .
furthermore , recent studies suggest that the star formation efficiency in disc galaxies is regulated by other effects , such as the physics of the ism on small scales @xcite or the gas pressure in the disc @xcite , and that the toomre @xmath211 parameter does not necessarily provide an accurate description of the ability of the disc to form stars .
parameter of the gas disc of ngc 300 as a function of galactocentric radius . ] obviously , the next logical step in our attempt to understand the evolutionary history of ngc 300 would be a more detailed study of the outer stellar disc to determine the age and chemical composition of the stars .
this was recently achieved by @xcite through @xmath223 and @xmath224 photometry of three fields in the outskirts of ngc 300 with the gemini south telescope .
the observations confirmed that the stellar population in the outer disc is predominantly old . at the same time
, there appears to be a radial gradient in metallicity with a sudden break at a radius of about @xmath15 .
while the inner disc shows a radially decreasing metallicity , this trend surprisingly reverses in the outer disc .
interestingly , the break occurs near the boundary between the inner and outer disc of ngc 300 , although it is not clear at this point whether this is just a coincidence or whether there is a physical connection between the two phenomena .
@xcite propose two possible scenarios for the observed break in the metallicity gradient .
either there could have been some kind of radial mixing of stars in the disc , or star formation could have slowly progressed outward during the evolution of ngc 300 , resulting in a moderate metallicity gradient in the inner disc , but an almost flat and pristine metallicity distribution across the outer disc . in both cases , the gas in the outer disc would not play any significant role in the recent star formation activity of ngc 300 , which is consistent with the generally old age ( @xmath225 ) of the stellar population in the outer disc and the presence of only a small fraction of younger ( a few hundred million years ) main sequence stars .
the aforementioned strong asymmetries found in the outer disc of ngc 300 are suggestive of ram pressure interaction with the surrounding intergalactic medium ( igm ) of the sculptor group .
as ngc 300 is moving through the igm , gas at the leading edge of the disc would be compressed , whereas gas at the trailing edge of the disc would be dragged and stripped by ram pressure forces ( see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) .
the influence of ram pressure has been mainly observed in the dense intergalactic medium of massive galaxy clusters ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , in particular the nearby virgo cluster @xcite , where ram pressure is believed to be responsible for the stripping and removal of gas from galaxies @xcite .
in contrast , only very few cases of ram pressure stripping in galaxy groups have been reported so far ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . to assess whether ram pressure could have caused the observed asymmetries in the gas disc of ngc 300 we can compare the expected ram pressure forces with the gravitational forces stabilising the disc .
the pressure imposed on the gas disc by a galaxy s own gravitational potential can be expressed as @xmath226 @xcite . here , @xmath216 is the gas mass surface density of the disc as a function of radius , and @xmath227 denotes the gravitational potential of the galaxy . the term on the right - hand side of eq .
[ eqn_gravity ] determines the maximum of the absolute value of the gravitational acceleration perpendicular to the disc , with @xmath228 being the height above the disc .
the gas disc will be subject to ram pressure stripping if the pressure exerted by the igm exceeds the stabilising gravitational pressure as determined by eq .
[ eqn_gravity ] .
the ram pressure of the igm is determined by the density of the igm , @xmath229 , and the relative velocity of the galaxy with respect to the surrounding medium , @xmath230 , thus @xmath231 ram - pressure stripping of gas in the disc will occur whenever the instability condition @xmath232 is fulfilled . as the gravitational pressure will be a strong function of galactocentric radius
, one can also define a truncation radius at which ram pressure forces start to dominate over gravity .
the simple analytic approach described above assumes that the galaxy is moving face - on through the igm , however , hydrodynamical simulations have demonstrated that even for larger inclination angles of the disc of up to about @xmath233 with respect to the direction of motion the analytic approach produces meaningful results @xcite . in order to assess the stability of the gas disc of ngc 300 against ram pressure stripping we have calculated the instability condition for different scenarios .
we assumed the gravitational potential of the galaxy to be dominated by its dark matter halo and neglected the potential of the stellar disc and gas disc .
this assumption will be met at greater heights , @xmath228 , above the disc plane in the outermost regions of the disc where we expect the gas to be particularly vulnerable to ram pressure stripping .
furthermore , we assumed the dark matter halo to have an nfw profile with the parameters ( for the model with fixed stellar and gaseous mass scaling factors ) derived in section [ sect_massmodelling ] and listed in table [ tab_massmodels ] .
the gravitational potential of the nfw halo reads @xmath234}\ ] ] @xcite where @xmath235 , @xmath236 , and @xmath96 are parameters of the nfw profile as discussed in section [ sect_nfw ] . solving eq .
[ eqn_gravity ] for the nfw potential and combining it with eq .
[ eqn_rampressure ] allows us to investigate the instability condition for different values of the igm density and relative velocity of ngc 300 .
the results are presented in fig .
[ fig_rampressure ] . the left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig_rampressure ] shows the situation for a constant velocity of @xmath237 of ngc 300 with respect to the igm but for five different igm densities .
the right - hand panel of fig .
[ fig_rampressure ] shows the situation for a constant igm density of @xmath238 but for five different velocities .
as we would expect , most of the gas disc of ngc 300 is many orders of magnitude above the instability condition of @xmath239 represented by the horizontal black line .
however , under certain conditions the outermost part of the gas disc beyond a radius of about @xmath240 will get near or just below the instability line , in particular for igm densities in excess of about a few times @xmath16 and sufficiently high relative velocities of @xmath241 .
the density values assumed here are consistent with constraints on the density of the local group medium by various studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it is interesting to note that the outer edge of the disc of ngc 300 appears to be close to balance between gravitational and ram pressure forces over a range of reasonable values for density and velocity .
this could indicate that the edge of the disc is defined by the aforementioned truncation radius at which ram pressure forces start to dominate over gravity .
a stable disc configuration beyond that radius would be impossible , suggesting that under certain conditions ram pressure could in general be responsible for establishing the outer edge of discs of galaxies in group environments .
furthermore , ram pressure could also result in a significant vertical displacement of disc gas and thereby contribute to the warping observed in the outer disc of many spiral galaxies .
this situation is shown schematically in the left - hand panel of fig .
[ fig_rampressure2 ] where the gravitational acceleration , @xmath242 , of the nfw halo perpendicular to the gas disc is shown as a function of height , @xmath228 , above the disc plane . under the assumption of a face - on wind caused by the surrounding igm , there will be for each galactocentric radius an equilibrium height , @xmath243 , at which the gravitational pressure in the disc will be in balance with the ram pressure of the wind .
of course , there will be no such equilibrium for radii greater than the truncation radius beyond which the ram pressure always exceeds the gravitational pressure at any height above the disc .
the right - hand panel of fig .
[ fig_rampressure2 ] shows the expected value of @xmath243 as a function of galactocentric radius in ngc 300 for two different igm densities of @xmath244 and @xmath245 and under the assumption of a constant relative velocity of @xmath246 . over much of the disc of ngc 300
the expected equilibrium height , and thus vertical displacement , of the gas is very small . towards the outer disc
the equilibrium height exceeds @xmath7 with a maximum value of @xmath247 in the outermost radial bin under the assumption of @xmath248 .
if we increase the igm density by a factor of ten to @xmath245 the equilibrium height increases to almost @xmath15 at @xmath249 , and beyond that radius there is no solution at all because we would exceed the truncation radius .
these estimates illustrate that ram pressure may have an impact on the vertical structure of the of ngc 300 depending on the properties of the surrounding igm .
we can also rule out higher igm densities of well above @xmath16 as they would result in a destruction of the outer parts of the observed disc .
please note that in all our calculations we neglected the gravitational potential of the stellar and gaseous discs , hence underestimating the restoring force
. this will particularly be the case for the inner disc of ngc 300 and locations close to the disc plane , where the ratio between gravitational pressure and ram pressure will be significantly higher than indicated in fig .
[ fig_rampressure ] . near the outer edge of the disc , however , the contribution from stars and gas to the gravitational potential is much smaller compared to the dark matter component . while the stellar mass surface density across the outer disc is immeasurably small , the contribution of the gas disc to the gravitational potential is comparable to that of the dark matter halo within a few hundred @xmath250 of the disc plane and negligible for @xmath251 .
therefore , our general conclusions about the stability of the outer disc are not affected by the additional contribution from the gas , and our numerical results near the outer edge of the disc are accurate within a factor of about @xmath17 to @xmath252 .
our results suggest that the edge of the gas disc of ngc 300 may indeed be subject to ram pressure stripping , although the effect will likely be subtle .
this result is consistent with our observations which show notable asymmetries between the north - western and south - eastern part of ngc 300 and signs of distortion along the north - western edge of the disc . in this scenario
the proper motion of ngc 300 on the sky would be in the south - eastern direction , pointing away from ngc 55 .
the ram - pressure scenario is also consistent with the offsets between the gas and the stellar distribution found in several dwarf galaxies of the sculptor group by @xcite .
although these effects are by far not as strong as in massive galaxy clusters , our results suggest that even in modest - sized galaxy groups ram pressure interaction does play a role in shaping the faint , outer gas discs of spiral galaxies in a density regime often not exposed by shallow observations .
this finding highlights once more the need for deep and large - scale imaging of galaxies in the 21-cm line of in order to understand the role of interaction and feedback between galaxies and the igm .
alternatively , some of the observed asymmetries in the disc of ngc 300 could be the result of cold - mode accretion flows of primordial gas .
lopsidedness of the stellar and gaseous discs of galaxies is a well - known and common phenomenon ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . among other processes
@xcite , cold - mode accretion flows of primordial gas have been discussed as the potential origin of the observed asymmetries @xcite .
hydrodynamical simulations by @xcite have shown that there are two distinct modes of gas accretion on to galaxies : hot - mode accretion of shock - heated gas at temperatures in excess of the virial temperature of the dark matter halo , @xmath253 to @xmath254 , and cold - mode accretion of gas at lower temperatures of @xmath255 .
while in their simulations the cold mode dominates accretion at higher redshifts , the hot mode becomes increasingly more important at lower redshifts , as many dark matter haloes exceed a critical virial mass of about @xmath256 above which accreted gas becomes predominantly shock - heated @xcite .
furthermore , cold - mode accretion is geometrically different from hot - mode accretion in that it occurs along filaments and therefore is not radially symmetric .
asymmetric cold - mode accretion could have resulted in asymmetries in the outer gas disc of ngc 300 , because the accreted gas would end up in non - circular orbits with substantial orbital time - scales in excess of about @xmath257 near the outer edge of the gas disc .
this scenario is supported by numerical simulations of @xcite who conclude that accretion along filaments of the cosmic web with accretion rates of a few @xmath258 is likely to be responsible for the ubiquity of lopsidedness observed in the stellar and gaseous discs of galaxies .
we conclude that sensitive observations of a large sample of galaxies would provide the opportunity to systematically study the kinematics of gas in the outer disc to determine the contribution of external processes such as ram pressure or gas accretion .
we have used the australia telescope compact array to map a large area of about @xmath0 ( corresponding to a projected size of about @xmath74 ) around the sculptor group galaxy ngc 300 in the 21-cm line of .
we achieved a @xmath1 column density sensitivity of @xmath259 over @xmath3 for emission filling the synthesised beam of @xmath4 fwhm .
the corresponding @xmath1 mass sensitivity is @xmath5 under the assumption of a distance of @xmath6 for ngc 300 .
the major results and conclusions from our analysis of the emission in ngc 300 are : * ngc 300 is characterised by a dense inner disc with column densities in excess of about @xmath260 and an extended outer disc with column densities of typically less than @xmath261 .
the inner disc has an orientation angle of @xmath8 and is perfectly aligned with the optical ( stellar ) disc .
the outer disc has a totally different orientation angle of @xmath11 , and its major axis spans more than @xmath9 on the sky equivalent to a linear diameter of about @xmath10 within the @xmath2 column density contour .
* under the assumption that the gas is optically thin we derive a total mass for ngc 300 of @xmath12 .
this is only slightly short of the single - dish value of @xmath262 found by @xcite , indicating that the atca recovered about 90 per cent of the total flux . of the total mass of ngc 300 , about @xmath263 ( or 57 per cent )
is contributed by the inner disc and @xmath105 ( or 43 per cent ) by the outer disc .
* we fitted a tilted ring model to the velocity field of ngc 300 to determine the rotation curve out to a radius of @xmath13 .
the derived rotation curve rises out to a radius of approximately @xmath15 where we observe a maximum velocity of about @xmath14 .
further out the rotation curve slowly decreases to about @xmath264 in the outermost ring at @xmath13 radius .
* we constructed different mass models of ngc 300 involving a stellar disc , a gas disc , and a dark matter halo .
we obtain good fits for both the burkert and nfw dark matter halo models , both of which successfully cope with the decreasing rotation velocity in the outer parts of the galaxy . fits with either newtonian dynamics or modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ) and no dark matter halo at all result in much higher @xmath265 values and unrealistic mass scaling factors for the gaseous disc . *
the twisted structure of the disc of ngc 300 suggests distortion by tidal interaction , but no nearby companion galaxy is currently known that could have exerted strong tidal forces on the disc . at the same time , optical studies by @xcite provide evidence against tidal interaction by demonstrating that the stellar disc of ngc 300 has a simple exponential radial profile out to the largest detected radii without any sign of distortion . *
optical observations by @xcite have shown that the stellar population in the outer disc is predominantly old ( @xmath225 ) and that therefore the outer gas disc does not currently play a significant role in the star formation activity of ngc 300 .
* asymmetries in the outer disc suggest that ngc 300 is affected by ram pressure interaction while moving through the intergalactic medium of the sculptor group , with its proper motion on the sky directed approximately to the south - east .
estimates show that , under reasonable assumptions on the igm density and relative velocity , the outer edge of the disc of ngc 300 may be significantly distorted by ram pressure . from our analysis
we conclude that the density of the igm in the sculptor group must be lower than about @xmath16 as otherwise the outer parts of the disc of ngc 300 could not have survived .
we thank s .- h .
oh for helpful discussions on the calculation of stellar mass - to - light ratios for the _ spitzer _ irac bands and w. j. g. de blok for valuable comments that helped to improve the manuscript .
the australia telescope compact array is part of the australia telescope which is funded by the commonwealth of australia for operation as a national facility managed by csiro .
this work is based in part on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa .
99 allen r. j. , ekers r. d. , terlouw , j. p. , 1985
, in di ges v. , scarsi l. , crane p. , friedman j. h. , levialdi s. , eds , data analysis in astronomy , plenum press , new york , usa , p. 271
baldwin j. e. , lynden - bell d. , sancisi r. , 1980 , mnras , 193 , 313 barnes d. g. , staveley - smith l. , de blok w. j. g. , oosterloo t. , stewart i. m. , wright a. e. , banks g. d. , bhathal r. , boyce p. j. , calabretta m. r. , et al . , 2001 ,
mnras , 322 , 486 begeman k. g. , broeils a. h. , sanders r. h. , 1991 , mnras , 249 , 523 bell e. f. , de jong r. s. , 2001 , apj , 550 , 212 bland - hawthorn j. , vlaji m. , freeman k. c. , draine b. t. , 2005 , apj , 629 , 239 blitz l. , rosolowsky e. , 2006 , apj , 650 , 933 bouchard a. , jerjen h. , da costa g. s. , ott j. , 2005 , aj , 130 , 2058 bouchard a. , jerjen h. , da costa g. s. , ott j. , 2007 , aj , 133 , 261 bournaud f. , combes f. , jog c. j. , puerari i. , 2005 , a&a , 438 , 507 burkert a. , 1995 , apj , 447 , l25 capozziello s. , cardone v. f. , troisi a. , 2007 , mnras , 375 , 1423 carignan c. , 1985 , apjs , 58 , 107 de blok w. j. g. , walter f. , brinks e. , trachternach c. , oh s .- h . , kennicutt r. c. , 2008 , aj , 136 , 2648 de grijs r. , peletier r. f. , 1997 , a&a , 320 , l21 dekel a. , birnboim y. , 2006 , mnras , 368 , 2 de vaucouleurs g. , de vaucouleurs a. , corwin h. g. , buta r. j. , paturel g. , fouque p. , 1991
, third reference catalogue of bright galaxies .
springer - verlag , berlin , heidelberg , new york fazio g. g. , hora j. l. , allen l. e. , ashby m. l. n. , barmby p. , deutsch l. k. , huang j .- s . , kleiner s. , marengo m. , megeath s. t. , melnick g. j. , et al .
, 2004 , apjs , 154 , 10 gardiner l. t. , noguchi m. , 1996 , mnras , 278 , 191 gieren w. , pietrzyski g. , walker a. , bresolin f. , minniti d. , kudritzki r .-
p . , udalski a. , soszyski i. , fouqu p. , storm j. , bono g. , 2004 , aj , 128 , 1167 gieren w. , pietrzyski g. , soszyski i. , bresolin f. , kudritzki r .-
, minniti d. , storm j. , 2005a , apj , 628 , 695 gieren w. , pietrzyski g. , bresolin f. , kudritzki r
, minniti d. , urbaneja m. , soszyski i. , storm j. , fouqu p. , bono g. , walker a. , garcia j. , 2005b , eso messenger , 121 , 23 giovanelli r. , haynes m. p. , 1983
, aj , 88 , 881 greisen e. w. , 1990 , in longo g. , sedmak , g. , eds , acquisition , processing and archiving of astronomical images , naples , italy , p. 125
gunn j. e. , gott j. r. , 1972 , apj , 176 , 1 hayashi e. , navarro j. f. , springel v. , 2007 , mnras , 377 , 50 haynes m. p. , roberts m. s. , 1979 , apj , 227 , 767 haynes m. p. , van zee l. , hogg d. e. , roberts m. s. , maddalena r. j. , 1998 , aj , 115 , 62 helou g. , roussel h. , appleton p. , frayer d. , stolovy s. , storrie - lombardi l. , hurt r. , lowrance p. , makovoz d. , masci f. , et al . , 2004 , apjs , 154 , 253 hinshaw g. , weiland j. l. , hill r. s. , odegard n. , larson d. , bennett c. l. , dunkley j. , gold b. , greason m. r. , jarosik n. , komatsu e. , nolta m. r. , page l. , spergel d. n. , et al . , 2009 , apjs , 180 , 225 hgbom j. a. , 1974 , a&as , 15 , 417 jarrett t. h. , chester t. , cutri r. , schneider s. e. , huchra j. p. , 2003
, aj , 125 , 525 jerjen h. , freeman k. c. , binggeli b. , 1998 , aj , 116 , 2873 jog c. j. , combes f. , 2009 , phr , 471 , 75 kalberla p. m. w. , dedes l. , kerp j. , haud u. , 2007 , a&a , 469 , 511 kalberla p. m. w. , kerp j. , 2009 , ara&a , 47 , 27 kantharia n. g. , ananthakrishnan s. , nityananda r. , hota a. , 2005 , a&a , 435 , 483 karachentsev i. d. , grebel e. k. , sharina m. e. , dolphin a. e. , geisler d. , guhathakurta p. , hodge p. w. , karachentseva v. e. , sarajedini a. , seitzer p. , 2003 ,
a&a , 404 , 93 kent s. m. , 1986 , aj , 91 , 1301 kent s. m. , 1987 , aj , 93 , 816 kere d. , katz n. , weinberg d. h. , dav r. , 2005 , mnras , 363 , 2 kere d. , katz n. , fardal m. , dav r. , weinberg d. h. , 2009 , mnras , 395 , 160 kim s. c. , sung h. , park h. s. , sung e .-
, 2004 , chinese journal of astronomy and astrophysics , 4 , 299 koribalski b. s. , staveley - smith l. , kilborn v. a. , ryder s. d. , kraan - korteweg r. c. , ryan - weber e. v. , ekers r. d. , jerjen h. , henning p. a. , putman m. e. , et al .
, 2004 , aj , 128 , 16 leroy a. k. , walter f. , brinks e. , bigiel f. , de blok w. j. g. , madore b. , thornley m. d. , 2008 , aj , 136 , 2782 mcconnachie a. w. , venn k. a. , irwin m. j. , young l. m. , geehan j. j. , 2007 , apj , 671 , l33 mastropietro c. , 2009 , iau symposium , 256 , 117 mathewson d. s. , cleary m. n. , murray j. d. , 1975 , apj , 195 , 97 milgrom m. , 1983 , apj , 270 , 365 navarro j. f. , frenk c. s. , white s. d. m. , 1995 , mnras , 275 , 56 navarro j. f. , frenk c. s. , white s. d. m. , 1996 , apj , 462 , 563 navarro j. f. , frenk c. s. , white s. d. m. , 1997 , apj , 490 , 493 oh s .- h . , de blok w. j. g. , walter f. , brinks e. , kennicutt r. c. , 2008 , aj , 136 , 2761 pietrzyski g. , gieren w. , fouqu p. , pont f. , 2002 , aj , 123 , 789 pietrzyski g. , gieren w. , soszyski i. , udalski a. , bresolin f. , kudritzki r .-
, mennickent r. , walker a. , garcia a. , szewczyk o. , szymaski m. , kubiak m. , wyrzykowski . , 2006 , aj , 132 , 2556 puche d. , carignan c. , bosma a. , 1990 , aj , 100 , 1468 putman m. e. , staveley - smith l. , freeman k. c. , gibson b. k. , barnes d. g. , 2003 , apj , 586 , 170 rasmussen j. , pedersen k. , 2001 , apj , 559 , 892 reach w. t. , megeath s. t. , cohen m. , hora j. , carey s. , surace j. , willner s. p. , barmby p. , wilson g. , glaccum w. , lowrance p. , marengo m. , fazio g. g. , 2005 , pasp , 117 , 978 richter o .- g . , sancisi r. , 1994 , a&a , 290 , l9 rix h .- w . , zaritsky d. , 1995 , apj , 447 , 82 rizzi l. , bresolin f. , kudritzki r .-
, gieren w. , pietrzyski g. , 2006 , apj , 638 , 766 roediger e. , hensler g. , 2005 , a&a , 433 , 875 roediger e. , brggen m. , 2006 , mnras , 369 , 567 rogstad d. h. , lockhart i. a. , wright m. c. h. , 1974 , apj , 193 , 309 rogstad d. h. , chu k. , crutcher r. m. , 1979 , apj , 229 , 509 salpeter e. e. , 1955 , apj , 121 , 161 salucci p. , burkert a. , 2000 , apj , 537 , l9 sancisi r. , fraternali f. , oosterloo t. , van der hulst j. m. , 2008 , a&arv , 15 , 189 sanders r. h. , noordermeer e. , 2007 , mnras , 379 , 702 sault r. j. , teuben p. j. , wright m. c. h. , 1995 , asp conf .
, 77 , 433 sembach k. r. , wakker b. p. , savage b. d. , richter p. , meade m. , shull j. m. , jenkins e. b. , sonneborn g. , moos h. w. , 2003 , apjs , 146 , 165 shobbrook r. r. , robinson b. j. , 1967 , aujph , 20 , 131 soffner t. , mendez r. h. , jacoby g. h. , ciardullo r. , roth m. m. , kudritzki r. p. , 1996
, a&a , 306 , 9 steer d. g. , dewdney p. e. , ito m. r. , 1984 , a&a , 137 , 159 tamburro d. , rix h .- w .
, leroy a. k. , mac low m .- m . , walter f. , kennicutt r. c. , brinks e. , de blok w. j. g. , 2009 , aj , 137 , 4424 toomre a. , 1964 , apj , 139 , 1217 van der hulst j. m. , terlouw j. p. , begeman k. g. , zwitser w. , roelfsema p. r. , 1992 , asp conf .
ser . , 25 , 131 van der kruit p. c. , searle l. , 1981a , a&a , 95 , 105 van der kruit p. c. , searle l. , 1981b , a&a , 95 , 116 van der marel r. p. , franx m. , 1993 , apj , 407 , 525 vlaji m. , bland - hawthorn j. , freeman k. c. , 2009 , apj , 697 , 361 vollmer b. , cayatte v. , balkowski c. , duschl w. j. , 2001 , apj , 561 , 708 vollmer b. , beck r. , kenney j. d. p. , van gorkom j. h. , 2004 , aj , 127 , 3375 vollmer b. , 2009 , a&a , 502 , 427 walter f. , brinks e. , de blok w. j. g. , bigiel f. , kennicutt r. c. , thornley m. d. , leroy a. , 2008 , aj , 136 , 2563 white d. a. , fabian a. c. , forman w. , jones c. , stern c. , 1991 , apj , 375 , 35 wild j. p. , 1952 ,
apj , 115 , 206 williams r. j. , mathur s. , nicastro f. , elvis m. , drake j. j. , fang t. , fiore f. , krongold y. , wang q. d. , yao y. , 2005 , apj , 631 , 856 yoshizawa a. m. , noguchi m. , 2003 , mnras , 339 , 1135 | we used the australia telescope compact array to map a large field of approximately @xmath0 around the sculptor group galaxy ngc 300 in the 21-cm line emission of neutral hydrogen .
we achieved a @xmath1 column density sensitivity of @xmath2 over a spectral channel width of @xmath3 for emission filling the @xmath4 synthesised beam .
the corresponding mass sensitivity is @xmath5 , assuming a distance of @xmath6 .
for the first time , the vast disc of ngc 300 has been mapped over its entire extent at a moderately high spatial resolution of about @xmath7 .
ngc 300 is characterised by a dense inner disc , well aligned with the optical disc of @xmath8 orientation angle , and an extended outer disc with a major axis of more than @xmath9 on the sky ( equivalent to a diameter of about @xmath10 ) and a different orientation angle of @xmath11 . a significant fraction ( about 43 per cent ) of the total detected mass of @xmath12 resides within the extended outer disc .
we fitted a tilted ring model to the velocity field of ngc 300 to derive the rotation curve out to a radius of @xmath13 , almost twice the range of previous rotation curve studies .
the rotation curve rises to a maximum velocity of almost @xmath14 and then gently decreases again in the outer disc beyond a radius of about @xmath15 .
mass models fitted to the derived rotation curve yield good fits for burkert and nfw dark matter halo models , whereas pseudo - isothermal halo models and mond - based models both struggle to cope with the declining rotation curve .
we also observe significant asymmetries in the outer disc of ngc 300 , in particular near the edge of the disc , which are possibly due to ram pressure stripping of gas by the intergalactic medium ( igm ) of the sculptor group .
our estimates show that ram pressure stripping can occur under reasonable assumptions on the density of the igm and the relative velocity of ngc 300 .
the asymmetries in the gas disc suggest a proper motion of ngc 300 toward the south - east . at the same time , our data exclude igm densities of significantly higher than @xmath16 in the vicinity of ngc 300 , as otherwise the outer gas disc would have been stripped .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : individual : ngc 300 galaxies : kinematics and dynamics galaxies : structure radio lines : galaxies . |
the particle - hole state densities are basic quantities for the description of preequilibrium emission ( pe ) in semiclassical models as well as quantum - statistical theories ( e.g. , @xcite ) involving a series of particle - hole excitations caused by two - body interactions . the nuclear excitation in the equilibrium processes concerns the single - particle levels ( s.p.l . ) within an energy range of the order of the nuclear temperature around the fermi level .
this explains the basic role of the s.p.l
. equidistant spacing model ( esm ) @xcite in the analysis of the equilibrium emission ( see also @xcite )
. however , much higher and lower single - particle energies are involved in pe reactions so that one should consider the reduced suitability of the esm partial - state density ( psd ) formula of williams @xcite . moreover , the inconsistency between the phenomenological s.p.l .
density @xmath0 mev@xmath1 and the number _ a _ of nucleons in the nucleus has come under increasing criticism @xcite . on the other hand , combinatorial calculations performed in the space of realistic shell model s.p.l .
@xcite have other inherent shortcomings ( e.g. , the strong dependence on the basic set of s.p.l . ) @xcite .
this accounts for the continued use of the williams - type formula with various corrections @xcite or exact calculation @xcite for additional pauli blocking and the pairing interaction .
in fact , there have been early attempts at considering the single - particle energy dependence of the s.p.l .
density @xmath2 within pe formalisms @xcite .
next , kalbach @xcite discussed different forms of this dependence and found it tied to pe surface effects due to the interdependence of the respective assumptions .
@xcite obtained an indication for the energy dependence nearly as that given by the fermi - gas model ( fgm ) below the fermi energy @xmath3 , but linear above @xmath3 .
chadwick and reffo @xcite found the use of either the fgm prescription or the equidistant parametrization @xmath4=@xmath5 more accurate than the phenomenological one .
the fgm s.p.l .
density has also been involved in the development of the partial level densities with linear momentum @xcite . at the same time
, the esm accuracy has been discussed in connection with the non - uniform s.p.l .
density effect @xcite provided by the harmonic oscillator model . the analysis of the energy - dependent s.p.l .
density in the vicinity of the fermi energy @xcite provided a more general form and a good approximation of the effect for low energies , where the influence of the finite depth of the potential well can be neglected .
various @xmath2 have been obtained within both the semiclassical thomas - fermi approximation @xcite and the exact quantum mechanical calculations @xcite which are also applicable at the high excitations located in the continuum region . the psd including distinct energy - dependences for the excited - particle and hole level densities has recently been used in semiclassical @xcite or quantum - statistical @xcite cross - section calculations . the valid use of energy - dependent s.p.l .
densities within the esm particle - hole state density formula , even when corrected for the finite depth of the real nuclear potential well @xcite , has not yet been proved .
proving it is one aim of this work .
first , the particle - hole state density is obtained in sec .
ii by means of recursive relations particularly using the fgm s.p.l . density .
next , these are compared in sec .
iii with the results of the esm formula modified by using s.p.l .
densities different for excited particles and holes , obtained from the fgm at the respective average - excitation energies @xcite ( the average energy - dependent esm formalism ) .
the analysis is also carried out for the density of particle - hole bound states , with single - particle excitations not exceeding the nucleon binding energy @xcite .
the advanced pairing correction @xcite is taken into account while the comparison of various effects includes the exact correction for the pauli exclusion principle @xcite .
the importance of distinct corrections in the average energy - dependent esm formalism is further discussed in sec .
iv . at the same time the subtraction of the free - gas contribution @xcite
is analysed within this formalism , thus making no use of arbitrary truncation @xcite .
the respective results are compared with the semiclassical and quantum - mechanical calculations of the continuum effect .
since the actual quantum - statistical analyses of the multistep reactions still involve the rough esm , the respective results could be altered following consideration of the effective @xmath6-interaction strength as the only free parameter .
the conclusions are drawn in sec .
densities of the excited particles and holes with distinct energy dependences or even different values at the fermi energy @xmath3 were considered by gadioli and co - workers @xcite , btk and dobe @xcite , and herman _ et al .
the subsequent study @xcite of unperturbed shell - model hamiltonian spacings indicated a linear energy dependence for excited particles , as well as different corresponding values at the fermi level . on the other hand , schmidt _
_ @xcite found that the smooth s.p.l .
density in a woods - saxon potential lies between the density corresponding to an infinite box and the one for an harmonic oscillator , and approximately follows @xmath8 .
moreover , this energy dependence has already been used within an improved abrasion model for heavy - ion collisions @xcite .
given the need for an analytical pld expression , we have followed the method of bogila _ et al . _
@xcite while the finite depth of the nuclear potential well and the case of particle - hole bound states have also been considered .
actually , the particle - hole bound state formula turns into the common form in the limit of large values of the nucleon binding energy @xmath9 .
the following discussion will concern the general form of @xmath2 , with the @xmath10 value at the fermi level .
however , the usual fgm energy dependence @xmath11 is particularly taken into account ( see also the appendix ) .
this can be expressed in terms of the single - particle excitation energies @xmath12 for particles , and @xmath13 for holes .
next , similarly to bogila _ et al .
_ we have retained the first three terms of its expansion in powers of @xmath14 around the value at zero excitation energy .
the general forms of the excitation - energy dependence then become @xmath15 and @xmath16 where the theta functions are unity if their argument is greater than zero , and zero otherwise .
the fgm values of the coefficients are @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 , where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the values at the fermi level of the respective derivatives .
various energy dependences of the s.p.l .
density can obviously be involved within this framework , by using the appropriate values for the coefficients in eqs .
( [ eq:2]-[eq:3 ] ) .
the bound - state density @xmath22 for @xmath23 excited particles above the fermi level and @xmath24 holes below it ( @xmath25 ) , at the total excitation energy @xmath26 , can be obtained by convolution of the single - particle and hole level densities with an excitation - energy conserving delta function @xcite @xmath27 @xmath28 where the pauli principle is not yet taken into account .
one way to proceed @xcite is to replace the @xmath29 function by its integral representation @xmath30dk \ : , \ ] ] so that @xmath31 by using the s.p.l .
densities given by eqs .
( [ eq:2]-[eq:3 ] ) , evaluation of the integrals , and expansion of the respective results , it results @xmath32 } \over { ( ik)^{n}}}dk\right ) \ : , \ ] ] where , by replacing @xmath33 by @xmath34 , [ eq:8 ] @xmath35 @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 is the integral which forms the functional argument in eq .
( [ eq:7 ] ) , and @xmath39 finally , by using the cauchy residue theorem we have obtained the expression @xmath40 @xmath41 the @xmath42 factorial and power have additionally been included in order to obtain a form similar to those obtained by obloinsk ' y @xcite in the frame of the esm , and bogila _ et al . _
@xcite within the fgm with no constraints for particles or holes .
thus , in the limiting case of large @xmath9 and @xmath3 in the above expression , the @xmath34 and @xmath43 indices become zero so that the last four sums in @xmath44 disappear and the formula of bogila _ et al . _
is obtained @xmath45 @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the well - known ericson formula @xcite for the esm case .
we underline that a definite single - particle ground state should be marked out by the finite value of @xmath3 within a consistent energy - dependent s.p.l . density .
therefore , the finite depth of the nuclear - potential well should be explicitly present in the particle - hole state density formulas exceeding the esm framework .
the usual formula for the density of the particle - hole bound states within the esm approximation results immediately from eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) by noting the unity values of all functionals @xmath44 for a constant s.p.l .
the only difference with respect to the formula of obloinsk @xcite concerns the pauli - blocking factor @xmath48 and the corresponding minimum energy @xmath49 for a @xmath23-@xmath24 state , which have not yet been included here .
on the other hand , the temporary omission of the pauli - principle correction can be used to estimate the energy - dependence effect better .
thus , the ratio between the results of eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) and obloinsk formula without the pauli correction is shown in fig . 1 for a few simple @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations .
here the bound - state condition is released , @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 , and @xmath3=38 mev .
these particle - hole states are actually the most important ones for the pe description , and are least affected by the pauli - principle oversight . also shown
is the ratio of the psds given by eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) and the ericson formula , in agreement with the trend of the bogila _
_ results ( fig . 1 of ref .
@xcite ) if one takes into account the different @xmath3 values used in these analyses .
while the former ratio describes the energy - dependence effect versus an esm formula including the potential finite - depth , the latter has the same role versus the simplest esm expression of ericson .
first , the case of the @xmath50 configuration , fig .
1(a ) , shows that the deviation of @xmath51 from @xmath10 is not really compensated by the corresponding deviation of @xmath52 , within the s.p.l .
density convolution .
thus , the obloinsk ' y and ericson formulas provide the same psd at excitation energies below @xmath3 , which are higher than the results of eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) .
second , a consideration of the potential finite depth decreases the obloinsk ' y psd values versus the ericson formula . at the same time , the results of eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) decrease less significantly above @xmath26=@xmath3 because of the deviation of @xmath52 from @xmath10 .
moreover , the case of the @xmath53 configuration shows the increased importance of the energy dependence versus the obloinsk ' y formula , with the deviation from unity of the respective ratio becoming relevant at excitations higher than @xmath3 .
smaller deviations have been obtained @xcite as compared with the ericson expression . following the related forms of the recursive psd expression ( [ eq:9 ] ) and obloinsk formula @xcite
, the correction for the pauli blocking and pairing effects can be implemented within the former by inclusion of ( i ) a @xmath23-@xmath24 configuration - dependent threshold energy in the theta function , and ( ii ) the pauli - blocking and pairing - correction term of the excitation energy , within the kalbach formulation @xcite @xmath54 where the threshold energy @xmath55^{1/2}\ ] ] is determined by the ground and excited - state gaps @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the ground - state gap is related to the condensation energy @xmath58 which can be given by the constant - pairing correction @xmath59 @xcite , based on the odd - even mass differences ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
@xmath60 is obtained by using the parametrization @xcite @xmath61 \ : \theta ( e - e_{phase } ) \ : , \ ] ] where @xmath62 is the critical number of excitons , and @xmath63 is the energy of the pairing phase transition given by @xmath64 \ :
\theta ( n / n_c - 0.446 ) \ : .\ ] ] actually , the latter theta function has been introduced by kalbach @xcite in order to explicitly take into account the lack of a phase transition for small @xmath65 .
the inclusion of @xmath66=@xmath67 and the form of the second term in the kalbach correction ( [ eq:12 ] ) have been adopted for a pauli - correction function symmetric in particles and holes , including the effects of passive holes .
next , the third term in eq .
( [ eq:12 ] ) has been added in order to force the psd to have the values of @xmath10 and @xmath68 for @xmath69 and @xmath70 , respectively .
the function @xmath71/p_m\ ] ] restricts the action of this third term to just around @xmath72 .
consequently , the psd recursive formula ( [ eq:9 ] ) , now including the pauli and pairing corrections , becomes @xmath73^{n-1 } \nonumber \\ & \times & \theta(e - e_{\mbox{th}}-ib - jf ) \ : r_{ij}\left([e - a_k(p , h)-ib - jf]^{n - n } { { ( n-1)!}\over { ( n-1)!}}\right ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the completeness of the eqs .
( [ eq:9 ] ) or ( [ eq:17 ] ) has the drawback of making them difficult to use in reaction calculations , due to the intricate form ( [ eq:8a ] ) of the functionals @xmath44 .
since approximate but simpler solutions are still of real interest , we will discuss below the kalbach @xcite attempt to use the energy - dependent s.p.l .
density within the esm formula .
in fact , we will be checking its correctness against the exact expression ( [ eq:17 ] ) .
it seems important to note that the kalbach approach involves distinct but average s.p.l .
densities for the holes and excited particles , respectively , at average excitation energies .
the general form of the esm density of particle - hole bound states corrected for ( i ) the pauli exclusion principle @xcite , ( ii ) pairing interactions @xcite , and ( iii ) the finite depth of the nuclear potential well @xcite can be written , similarly to kalbach @xcite , @xmath74 where @xmath75^{n-1}\ ] ] @xmath76 is a function including the finite - depth , pauli - blocking and pairing corrections , as well as the bound - state condition .
the original correction function @xcite was used to modify the psd formula for the infinite potential well , with the pauli correction terms @xmath77 neglected in all terms except the leading one . however , by means of eq .
( [ eq:18 ] ) the function @xmath78 can now be regarded as the ratio between the actual psd formula and the ericson expression .
the index @xmath79 is related to the inclusion of the advanced pairing correction of kalbach @xcite , i.e. , of the terms @xmath80 and @xmath81 . the importance of the pauli - blocking and pairing correction term @xmath80 is shown in fig . 2 for simple @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations .
first , omission of this correction provides the unit value of the function @xmath82 in the case of the @xmath83 configurations at excitation energies lower than @xmath3 .
second , there is a rather similar case ( or even identical for the state @xmath50 ) if the pauli correction @xmath48 and the corresponding minimum energy @xmath49 @xcite are taken into account but not the pairing corrections .
a small threshold behavior becomes apparent in this case .
third , the inclusion of the advanced pairing correction yields a strong reduction at lower excitation energies .
finally , the bound - state condition obviously provides a different function , mainly determined by the number of holes . in order to take into account the long - range deviations from esm , kalbach @xcite proposed the use of average values for the fgm s.p.l .
density ( [ eq:1 ] ) corresponding to average excitation energies for either particles or holes . as a first approximation
, these energies were estimated in the esm frame .
we follow the same method below but also include the case of the bound states .
the probability for the occurrence of a @xmath23-@xmath24 state with the excitation energy @xmath26 and an excited particle between @xmath14 and @xmath14+@xmath84 is given by @xmath85 .
consequently , the average excitation energy per excited particle is given by @xmath86 where @xmath87 . assuming a slow energy dependence of the correction term @xmath88 , the average excitation energies for either particles or holes become [ eq:21 ] @xmath89 @xmath90 where @xmath91^n \nonumber \\ & \times & \left[1+{{n}\over{p } } { { ib}\over { e - a_k(p , h)-ib - jf}}\right ] \theta(e - e_{\mbox{th}}-ib - jf)\end{aligned}\ ] ] returns to @xmath92 for large @xmath9 @xcite .
the shapes of the two functions @xmath78 and @xmath93 , and the average excitation energies for simple @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations are shown , bound - state case included , in fig .
3 . the above - mentioned similarity between the functions @xmath93 and @xmath92 can be observed , in the general case , for the @xmath50 and @xmath94-states in figs .
3(a ) and 3(b ) .
it is worth noting the results of eqs .
( [ eq:21 ] ) for the bound - plus - continuum states shown in fig .
3(e ) , and the bound states only as displayed in fig .
the distinct trends are due to the separate constraints on hole excitation up to a value of @xmath3 in the former circumstance , and a particle excitation limited by the @xmath9 value in the latter .
first , @xmath95 and @xmath96 increase nearly as @xmath97 at the lowest excitations , the slightly larger values for holes arising from the fact that @xmath93 is smaller than @xmath78 .
next , the constrained average excitation energy of either holes ( in the general case ) or particles ( for bound states ) becomes rather saturated at energies @xmath26 above the values of @xmath3 and @xmath9 , respectively .
the esm basis of eqs .
( [ eq:21 ] ) determines the saturation values around @xmath98 for @xmath96 in the former case , and around @xmath99 for @xmath95 in the latter .
moreover , in the limit of the @xmath50 configuration a quite sudden change can be observed at total excitation energies around the values of @xmath3 and @xmath9 , respectively .
there is also a small change in the trend of @xmath96 and @xmath95 just below the maximum excitation energy @xmath26 for a given @xmath23-@xmath24 bound - state configuration , due to the final occupation of the highest allowed single - particle levels . to underscore the correlation between the specific shapes of the correction functions @xmath82 , average excitation energies @xmath95 and @xmath96 , and corresponding average values of the s.p.l
. densities [ eq:23 ] @xmath100 @xmath101 these quantities are shown together in fig . 4 for the configuration @xmath53 .
first , the effect of the pauli and pairing correction is rather small .
the saturations of @xmath95 and @xmath96 are distinctly caused by the bound - state condition , fig .
4(c ) , and finite - depth correction , fig .
4(d ) , respectively .
this is why the energy dependence of @xmath102 , fig .
4(e ) , is distinct from the one of @xmath103 , fig .
4(f ) , either in the general case ( solid curves ) or for the particle - hole bound states ( dotted - dashed curves ) .
the average energy - dependent formula was finally obtained by using the average s.p.l
. densities ( [ eq:23 ] ) within the psd formula ( [ eq:18 ] ) which becomes @xmath104^p[g_h(p , h)]^he^{n-1 } } \over{p!h!(n-1)!}}f_k(p , h , e , f ) \ : .\ ] ] it approximately takes into account the energy dependence of the s.p.l . density , even though the simple esm form is still in use .
however , there is no basic argument why this procedure should be used so that its accuracy needs further study .
the method adopted in this respect consists in a comparison of the results obtained by means of the approximate formula and the recursive eq .
( [ eq:17 ] ) .
the corresponding predictions and their ratio are shown in fig . 5 for the same simple @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations .
the global values @xmath3=38 mev , @xmath9=10 mev , @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 , and @xmath56=1 mev were used .
first of all , in the general case of the particle - hole state densities ( i.e. , for @xmath105 ) there is only a small difference between the two psd formulas even at medium energies .
the agreement improves for more complex configurations , where the average of the single - particle excitation energies becomes really meaningful .
similar agreement is seen when the respective densities for the particle - hole bound states are compared within the first half of the energy range for each @xmath23-@xmath24 configuration . however , the difference becomes significant near the maximum energy for a given particle - hole state , and increases as the psd values drop back to zero .
nevertheless , the disagreement of these bound - state density formulas at the high - energy extremity should have little or no effect on the reaction cross - section calculations .
therefore we may conclude that the results obtained by using the average energy - dependent s.p.l .
densities within the esm formula are rather close to the exact convolution of the energy - dependent s.p.l . density .
the next question concerns the need for this average energy - dependent approach .
the answer can be obtained by comparing the average energy - dependent esm results with the psds given by the widely used esm formula @xcite .
this is shown in fig .
6 , where the above global parameters were used .
the pairing effect is apparent within this latter comparison , especially at lower energies . besides this aspect ,
the behavior shown at medium energy is similar to the comparison of the recursive and obloinsk formulas in fig .
the overall difference obviously exceeds the variation between the predictions of the psd recursive formula and the average energy - dependent esm formalism .
it is rather small for the general case of the particle - hole states , figs .
6(a ) and 6(c ) , but larger for the bound states , figs .
6(b ) and 6(d ) .
this strong effect following the consideration of the energy - dependent s.p.l .
density is particularly caused by the constant increase in hole excitation for larger @xmath26 , and the related significant decrease of the hole - state density as shown in fig .
4(f ) .
the pauli - exclusion effect on particle - hole state densities has already been subject to additional investigation by zhang and yang @xcite who used an exact method .
kalbach established later @xcite that no conflict exists between their results and the frequently used williams formulas if the energy - dependent pauli term included pairing and passive - hole effects .
the esm derivation of psd formulas without any approximation in the pauli correction term was performed by baguer _
_ @xcite and mao ming de and guo hua @xcite .
the latter extended the method to the case of the finite - depth potential and bound states , and included the kalbach @xcite pairing correction .
the effect of the alternative use of the approximate and exact pauli - correction , and the one caused by the average energy - dependent esm formula are compared below .
the results that were obtained by means of eq .
( [ eq:18 ] ) and according to the exact pauli - correction formalism @xcite are shown together in fig .
7 , for the most sensitive low - energy region .
the analysis was first carried out without pairing correction , i.e. , for @xmath56=0 as shown in figs .
7(a ) and 7(c ) .
the global value @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 adopted by fu and kalbach @xcite was used .
then , the psd calculation with pairing correction corresponding to the value @xmath56=1 mev , figs .
7(b ) and 7(d ) , completed the analysis of these effects under any circumstances .
the ratio of the psd obtained by using the two formalisms , figs .
7(c ) and 7(d ) , shows more exactly that a close agreement even within 1 % is established just above the threshold for each @xmath23-@xmath24 configuration .
minor deviations exist only for larger number of excitons , of less interest for multistep reaction calculations which include them in the so - called @xmath106-stage @xcite .
therefore , the results of the exact pauli - blocking effect calculations are closely related to those obtained by using the approximate pauli correction @xcite
. the inclusion of a suitable pairing correction seems more significant with the following additional remark .
the psd for the very - few - exciton configurations become rather saturated within a short energy range above the threshold . on the other hand ,
these configurations have the main role in the description of multistep reactions .
thus , the adequate account of the pairing effect may be found unessential for some analyses .
the analysis of the high - energy limit of the particle - emission spectra , however , is quite sensitive to both pairing and nuclear - shell effects ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
finally , the comparative analysis of the effects illustrated in figs . 6 and 7 shows , on a common basis , the higher importance of the s.p.l .- density energy dependence versus the exact calculation of the pauli correction .
the importance of the various approximations involved in the derivation of the psd formulas should be well known in order to avoid useless effort or deficient results .
first , one might want to know the consequences of the present analysis on the total state densities obtained as the sum of all psd for allowed particle - hole numbers @xmath23=@xmath24 .
next , one might question the usefulness of the psd formulas discussed above , while quantum - mechanical calculations concentrating on the continuum region are being developed @xcite . average s.p .
excitation energies are shown in fig . 8 for representative @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations of the psds sum defining the total state density @xmath107 .
the same global values @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 , @xmath3=38 mev and @xmath56=1 mev were used as above .
thus , it becomes apparent that all significant terms of this sum are characterized by rather equal @xmath95 and @xmath96 increasing nearly as @xmath97 .
the saturated average excitation energy of the holes plays a major role in the case of the few - exciton states which are vital for pe description , but not for configurations around the most probable exciton number @xmath108 @xcite .
the latter class of configurations mainly determine the total state density value , so that the corresponding esm predictions are meaningful in this respect .
nevertheless , the average energy - dependent approach should be considered for the calculation of the psd involved in the first stages of the multistep processes .
shlomo @xcite performed an exact quantum mechanical calculation of the s.p.l .
density as the sum of the bound and continuum contributions in the case of finite potential wells .
a distinct point of this approach has been the consideration of the free - gas states counted by the s.p.l .
density for a finite potential well .
the density of these states was calculated and subtracted by using green s functions associated with the respective single - particle hamiltonians .
then , the commonly used semiclassical approximations for the s.p.l .
density were similarly considered for some widely used mean - field potentials .
thus , shlomo found by means of both classes of methods that , for a realistic finite depth well , the s.p.l .
density decreases with energy in the continuum region _ ( the continuum effect)_. this effect may have a twofold meaning for the multistep reaction calculations .
first , the continuum s.p.l . density following the subtraction of the free - gas contribution should be added to the particle - hole bound state density .
the latter quantity has been used for the description of the multistep compound ( msc ) processes @xcite .
it has been assumed to be zero outside the nuclear well , which is now considered less appropriate @xcite .
second , in the opinion of bogila _ et al .
_ @xcite the subtraction of the free gas spectrum should be involved in all psd for pe calculations .
this point could be most important in accounting for the multistep direct ( msd ) processes @xcite which currently take into account all particle - hole states .
thus a correct yet simple method to estimate the s.p.l .
density including the continuum effect is needed .
the continuum effect can be taken into account within the average energy - dependent esm formula ( [ eq:24 ] ) by using a form similar to eq .
( 30 ) of ref .
@xcite ( see the appendix ) for the excited - particle level density .
according to eq .
( [ eq:23a ] ) it becomes @xmath109 \ : .\ ] ] to emphasize the origin of the particular behaviour of @xmath102 , this is shown at the same time as the corresponding @xmath95 for the basic @xmath53 configuration in figs .
9(b ) and 9(d ) .
it is obvious that the average excitation energy is unchanged ( see fig .
4 ) so that the continuum effect fully determines the corrected s.p.l .
density for excited particles .
the comparison with the similar quantities @xmath96 and @xmath103 ( the same as in fig .
4 ) demonstrates the importance of this effect , the average s.p.l .
density becoming even lower for excited particles than for holes . on the other hand
, it seems worth comparing the specific average excitation energies and s.p.l .
densities which determine the psds including the continuum effect [ figs .
9(b ) and 9(d ) ] , with the related quantities for the particle - hole bound states [ figs .
9(a ) and 9(c ) ] . the reasons for deviations from the psd general trend , for the two main additional classes of particle - hole state densities with variant characteristics are outlined in this way .
thus , the average excitation energies , limited by the value @xmath9 for the excited particles , entirely determine the s.p.l .
densities for the particle - hole bound state densities .
actually one may note that @xmath110 has a rather constant value in this case .
the value of @xmath111 is similarly constant but obviously lower in the latter case , i.e. of the bound and continuum state density including the continuum effect .
however , the above - discussed aspect of @xmath110 is the key quantity for the second class of modified psds .
moreover , these two classes of psds with various restrictions [ figs . 10(a ) and 10(b ) ] are at the same time compared with the predictions of eqs .
( [ eq:23 ] ) and ( [ eq:24 ] ) including only the finite - depth correction , also shown in fig .
a few configurations significant in pe calculations are used in this respect . the ratios of each of the two variant psds to the general psd values given in fig .
10(b ) are further shown in figs .
10(c ) and 10(d ) .
it follows that at medium energies the size of the continuum effect on the psd values , which is given by the latter class of ratios , is rather similar to that for the bound - state condition .
therefore , a possible replacement within msc calculations of the particle - hole bound state density by the psd corrected for the continuum effect @xcite would not be trivial .
a similar point may concern the use within the msd calculations of the psd either including the continuum effect @xcite or taking into account the free - gas single particle levels as well .
the relation between the results of eq . ( [ eq:25 ] ) and the quantum - mechanical ( qm ) calculations should be also considered before further use of the former in reaction calculations .
hence , following shlomo _
@xcite , the s.p.l .
density was calculated @xcite by using the respective relation with green s function . as an alternative to the smearing procedure
, the imaginary part of green s function has been calculated separately for the discrete and continuous states .
the regular and jost solutions of the radial schrdinger equation are used in the continuum . the smooth part of the rapidly fluctuating s.p.l .
density is calculated by means of the strutinski smoothing procedure @xcite .
the woods - saxon ( ws ) potential @xcite was considered in this frame as well as in the semiclassical thomas - fermi ( tf ) formula , with the similar results shown in fig .
the familiar fgm shape is given by the tf formula with an infinite square - well ( sq ) potential , while the corresponding finite well ( fsq ) illustrates the continuum effect in fig .
it should be noted that the continuum component of the s.p.l .
density is nearly the same within either exact quantum - mechanical calculations with the ws potential , or tf approximation with either the ws or the fsq potential wells , provided that the free - gas contribution is subtracted .
moreover , a similar trend is obtained by means of the simple fgm formula ( [ eq:25 ] ) taking into account the continuum effect .
nevertheless , the quantum - mechanical s.p.l . density can be related to this formula only for a reduced fermi energy , e.g. @xmath112 mev @xcite .
this value has been obtained as an average value along the trajectory of the incident projectile with respect to the both nuclear density and first nucleon - nucleon collision probability .
the usual value @xmath3=38 mev causes lower @xmath113 values , that are not consistent with the phenomenological data . therefore one may use the simple fgm energy dependence , within an appropriate form which matches the quantum - mechanical s.p.l .
density including the continuum effect , in the average energy - dependent esm formalism .
this unsophisticated yet improved method could provide the correct psds for msd / msc calculations , in agreement with the consideration that the highly - excited single - particle states are not strongly coupled to compound nuclear states @xcite or partially relaxed states of composite nuclei formed in nuclear reactions at intermediate energies @xcite . the question is additionally made intricate by the recent proof of a much shorter time scale required to reach thermal equilibration in intermediate - energy nucleon - induced reactions , found to be of the order of @xmath11410@xmath115 sec @xcite .
further experimental - data analyses should thus consider a combination of reaction models and related psd formalisms as well .
the particle - hole state density has been obtained by means of recursive relations , for the bound as well as bound - plus - continuum states .
the corresponding expressions , i.e. , eqs .
( [ eq:9 ] ) and ( [ eq:17 ] ) , can be used for various energy dependences of the excited - particle and hole state densities while the particular case of the fgm is discussed .
we have underlined that consideration of the finite depth of the nuclear - potential well should be explicitly present in the particle - hole state density formulas exceeding the esm framework . next , the results of the recursive formula are compared with the kalbach @xcite approximation still within the esm formula but using distinct average s.p.l
. densities for the holes and excited particles respectively , at their average excitation energies . at the same time
the kalbach formalism is extended to the case of the bound states , while the pairing and pauli - blocking effects have been included in all terms of the esm correction function .
the correctness of the average energy - dependent esm approach is established by reference to the rigorous convolution ( [ eq:9 ] ) of the energy - dependent s.p.l .
densities for the case of the fgm dependence .
the difference between the predictions of the two methods is compared with the similar variation between average energy - dependent form and the standard formula @xcite , the former being much lower especially in the bound - state case .
the exact calculation of the pauli - blocking effect , which is close to the well - known approximate pauli correction @xcite , is also discussed .
thus it is shown on a common basis the higher importance of the s.p.l .- density energy dependence versus the exact calculation of the pauli correction .
the significant role of the pairing correction is pointed out , while comments are made on the circumstances under which the adequate account of the pairing effects could indeed appear less than essential @xcite .
the continuum effect has been considered for the case of a fgm energy dependence in the average energy - dependent esm approach .
the continuum component of the s.p.l .
density is found rather similar using either exact quantum - mechanical calculations with the woods - saxon potential , or thomas - fermi approximation with ws as well as finite - square potential wells , provided that the free - gas contribution is subtracted .
a similar trend is obtained by means of the simple fgm formula for the s.p.l .
density if the continuum effect is taken into account .
it should be noted that no arbitrary truncation , e.g. in the range 15 - 25 mev @xcite , is thus necessary in order to take care for the continuum effect within the s.p.l .
density account . on the other hand ,
since the actual quantum - statistical analyses of the multistep reactions use the rough esm , the results following consideration of the effective @xmath6-interaction strength as the only free parameter could be altered .
this point is the subject of current work along with systematic calculations of the s.p.l .
density in the continuum and the correlation with pe surface effects @xcite .
the authors are grateful to marshall blann , emil betak , zhang jingshang , and shalom shlomo for valuable discussions .
thanks are also due to the referees of this work for helpful critiquing .
assistance of ms .
vivien prager with improving the manuscript is acknowledged .
this work has been carried out under the romanian ministry of research and technology contract no .
4/a13 and the research contract no .
8886/r1 of the international atomic energy agency ( vienna ) .
the s.p.l . density associated with a local mean field @xmath116 has the following expression in the thomas - fermi approximation , by taking into account the spin degeneracy and neglecting the spin - orbit interactions @xcite the single - particle energy @xmath118 is measured relative to the top of the nuclear well , in order to make a clear distinction between the bound states at @xmath1190 and unbound continuum states at @xmath1200 . for the finite well potentials
, the nucleus can be imagined inside a spherical box of radius @xmath121 larger than the range of @xmath122 ( see fig . 1 of @xcite ) . in the case of a square potential
well of radius @xmath123 and depth @xmath1240 , we have from eq .
( [ eq : a1 ] ) where @xmath126=4@xmath127 and @xmath128=4@xmath129 . since the properties of the nucleus itself do not depend on @xmath121 @xcite , in the case of the finite square well one has to subtract the contribution of free fermi gas when @xmath130 @xcite has the well - known fgm form except the continuum correction term . in terms of the single - particle energy @xmath133=@xmath118-@xmath134 which is measured relative to the bottom of the nuclear well
, it becomes where @xmath10=@xmath136=@xmath137 with reference to both notations used for the s.p.l .
energy . actually , the derivation of eq .
( [ eq : a4 ] ) shows that the radius @xmath121 is indeed taken into account but @xmath138 does not depend on it .
therefore , the final expression is apparently only a difference of terms calculated for the sq potential well and the free - particle case , respectively , within an infinite spherical box with the radius @xmath123 . 99 e. gadioli and p.e .
hodgson , _ pre - equilibrium nuclear reactions _ ( oxford university press , oxford , 1992 )
. h. feshbach , _ theoretical nuclear physics : nuclear reactions _ ( wiley , new york , 1992 ) .
t. ericson , adv . in phys .
* 9 * , 425 ( 1960 ) .
a. bohr and b.r .
mottelson , _ nuclear structure _
benjamin , inc .
, advanced book program , reading , 1969 ) , p. 153 .
williams , nucl .
a166 * , 231 ( 1971 ) .
m. herman , g. reffo , m. rosetti , g. giardina , and a. italiano , phys .
c * 40 * , 2870 ( 1989 ) .
m.b . chadwick and g. reffo ,
c * 44 * , 919 ( 1991 ) ; m.b .
chadwick , p. obloinsk , p.e .
hodgson , and g. reffo , _ ibid .
_ * 44 * , 814 ( 1991 ) .
williams , jr . , a. mignerey , and m. blann , nucl .
a207 * , 619 ( 1973 ) ; k. albrecht and m. blann , phys .
c * 8 * , 1481 ( 1973 ) ; w. scobel _
_ , _ ibid .
_ * 30 * , 1480 ( 1984 ) .
m. blann and g. reffo , in international atomic energy agency report no .
indc(nds ) - 214/lj , vienna , 1989 , p. 75 . g. reffo and m. herman , in _ proceedings of the international conference on nuclear data for science and technology , gatlinburg , tennessee , 1994 _ , edited by j.k . dickens ( american nuclear society , 1994 ) , p. 473 ; m. herman , g. reffo , h. lenske , and h. wolter , _ ibid .
_ , p. 466 .
fu , nucl .
. eng . * 86 * , 344 ( 1984 ) . c. kalbach , nucl .
eng . * 95 * , 70 ( 1987 ) ; z. phys .
a * 332 * , 157 ( 1989 ) .
mao ming de and guo hua , j. phys .
g * 19 * , 421 ( 1993 ) .
m. blann , phys .
* 28 * , 757 ( 1972 ) ; nucl . phys .
* a213 * , 570 ( 1973 ) ; in _ proceedings of the international school of nuclear physics , predeal , romania , 1974 _ , edited by a. ciocanel ( editura academiei , bucharest , 1974 ) , p. 249 ; see also phys .
c * 54 * , 1341 ( 1996 ) .
e. gadioli , e. gadioli erba , and p.g .
sona , nucl .
* a217 * , 589 ( 1973 ) .
e. gadioli , e. gadioli erba , and j.j .
hogan , phys .
c * 16 * , 1404 ( 1977 ) . c. kalbach , phys .
c * 23 * , 124 ( 1981 ) . c. kalbach , phys .
c * 32 * , 1157 ( 1985 ) .
m.b . chadwick and p. obloinsk ,
c * 44 * , r1740 ( 1991 ) ; * 46 * , 2028 ( 1992 ) .
j.s . zhang and s.g .
wu , chinese j. nucl .
* 14 * , 121 ( 1992 ) .
bogila , v.m .
kolomietz , and a.i .
sanzhur , z. phys .
a * 341 * , 373 ( 1992 ) .
g. ghosh , r.w .
hasse , p. schuck , and j. winter , phys .
lett . * 50 * , 1250 ( 1983 ) .
blin , b. hiller , r.w .
hasse , and p. schuck , j. de phys .
* 45 * , c6 - 231 ( 1984 ) .
hasse and p. schuck , nucl .
a445 * , 205 ( 1985 ) .
p. schuck , r.w .
hasse , j. jaenicke , c. grigoire , b. remaud , f. sebille , and e. suraud , in _ progress in particle and nuclear physics _ ( pergamon press , oxford , 1989 ) , vol .
22 , p. 181 .
k. sato and s. yoshida , phys .
c * 49 * , 1099 ( 1994 ) ; m. abe , s. yoshida , and k. sato , phys .
c * 52 * , 837 ( 1995 ) .
s. shlomo , ye.a .
bogila , v.m .
kolomietz , and a.i .
sanzhur , z. phys .
a * 353 * , 27 ( 1995 ) .
bogila , v.m .
kolomietz , a.i .
sanzhur , and s. shlomo , phys .
c * 53 * , 855 ( 1996 ) .
d.r . dean and u. mosel , z. phys .
a * 322 * , 647 ( 1985 ) .
s. shlomo , nucl . phys . *
a539 * , 17 ( 1992 ) .
s. shlomo , v.m .
kolomietz , and h. dejbakhsh , phys .
c * 55 * , 1972 ( 1997 ) .
m. avrigeanu and v. avrigeanu , j. phys .
g * 20 * , 613 ( 1994 ) .
m. avrigeanu , a. harangozo , and v. avrigeanu , in _ proc . of the 7th int .
conf . on nuclear reaction mechanisms , varenna , 1994 _ , edited by e. gadioli ( ricerca scientifica ed educazione permanente , milano , 1994 ) , p. 165 .
m. avrigeanu , a. harangozo , and v. avrigeanu , ipne - bucharest report np-85 - 1995 ; rom .
* 41 * , 77 ( 1996 ) .
e. btk and j. dobe , z. phys .
a * 279 * , 319 ( 1976 ) .
p. obloinsk , nucl .
a453 * , 127 ( 1986 ) .
tubbs and s.e .
koonin , astrophys .
j. * 232 * , l59 ( 1979 ) .
mazurek , j.m .
lattimer , and g.e .
brown , astrophys .
j. * 229 * , 713 ( 1979 ) .
m. herman , g. reffo , and c. costa , phys .
c * 39 * , 1269 ( 1989 ) .
k .- h . schmidt , h. delagrange , j.p .
dufour , n. c^ arjan , and a. fleury , z. phys .
a * 308 * , 215 ( 1982 ) .
gaimard and k .- h .
schmidt , nucl .
a531 * , 709 ( 1991 ) .
w. dilg , w. schantl , h. vonach , and m. uhl , nucl . phys .
* a217 * , 269 ( 1973 ) .
j.s . zhang and x.l .
yang , z. phys .
a * 329 * , 69 ( 1988 ) .
n. baguer , r. capote , and r. pedrosa , z. phys .
a * 334 * , 397 ( 1989 ) .
y. watanabe , a. aoto , h. kashimoto , s. chiba , t. fukahori , k. hasegawa , m. mizumoto , s. meigo , m. sugimoto , y. yamanouti , n. koori , m.b .
chadwick , and p.e .
hodgson , phys .
c * 51 * , 1891 ( 1995 ) .
fu , nucl .
* 92 * , 440 ( 1986 ) .
h. feshbach , a. kerman , and s. koonin , ann .
( n.y . ) * 125 * , 429 ( 1980 ) .
i. tecu , report nucl - th/9711007 ; rom .
( in press ) .
ross and r.k .
bhaduri , nucl . phys .
* a188 * , 566 ( 1972 ) . m. avrigeanu , a. harangozo , v. avrigeanu , and a.n .
antonov , phys .
c * 54 * , 2538 ( 1996 ) .
grimes , phys .
c * 42 * , 2744 ( 1990 ) .
weidenm " uller , phys .
lett . * 10 * , 331 ( 1964 ) .
mustafa , m. blann , a.v .
ignatyuk , and s.m .
grimes , phys .
c * 45 * , 1078 ( 1992 ) ; m.g .
mustafa , m. blann , and a.v .
ignatyuk , _ ibid .
_ * 48 * , 588 ( 1993 ) .
s. chiba , k. niita , and o. iwamoto , phys .
c * 54 * , 3302 ( 1996 ) .
p. ring and p. schuck , _ the nuclear many - body problem _ ( spriger , berlin , 1980 ) , ch . 13 . * the convolution state density given by eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) , divided by the obloinsk formula without pauli correction ( solid curves ) , as well as by the ericson formula ( dashed curves ) , for the given @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations . in eq .
( [ eq:9 ] ) and the obloinsk formula , @xmath3=38 mev and the limit of large @xmath9 is considered . for all calculations @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 . * the correction function for the pauli blocking , nuclear - potential finite depth and pairing - correlation effects , of the esm particle - hole state density for given @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations .
the calculations use the finite - depth correction alone with @xmath3=38 mev ( dotted curves ) , the pauli correction without ( dashed curves ) and with the pairing effects included ( solid curves ) , and also the bound - state condition with @xmath9=10 mev ( dash - dotted curves ) . * ( a),(b ) the @xmath93 and ( c),(d ) the @xmath78 correction functions to the esm formula for the pauli blocking , potential finite - depth and pairing - correlation effects , as well as ( e),(f ) the average excitation energies for particles and holes within the given @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations , for ( a),(c),(e ) the particle - hole bound plus continuum states , and ( b),(d),(f ) the bound states only . for all calculations
@xmath3=38 mev , and @xmath9=10 mev is considered for the bound states . *
\(a ) the @xmath93 and ( b ) @xmath78 correction functions to the esm formula for the pauli blocking , potential finite - depth and pairing - correlation effects , ( c),(d ) the average excitation energies for particles and holes , and ( e),(f ) the average energy - dependent s.p.l .
densities for excited particles and holes , for the @xmath53 configuration .
the meaning of the curves is the same as in fig .
2 except that the dotted line in ( e ) and ( f ) gives the value of @xmath10 . for all calculations @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 and @xmath3=38 mev , while @xmath9=10 mev is considered for the bound states .
* the particle - hole state densities for the given @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations , obtained with the average energy - dependent esm formalism ( solid curves ) and the psd recursive formula ( dashed curves ) , and their ratio , for ( a),(c ) bound - plus - continuum states , and ( b),(d ) bound states only .
the same global values are used as in fig .
4 . * the same as fig . 5 except
the latter psd formula considered in the comparison is the esm formula @xcite ( dash - dotted curves ) . * ( a),(b ) the particle - hole state densities for given @xmath65-exciton configurations with @xmath23=@xmath24 , obtained with the esm formulas including the advanced pairing correction @xcite and either the exact correction for the pauli exclusion principle @xcite ( solid curves ) or the respective approximate form @xcite ( dashed curves ) , and ( c),(d ) their ratios .
for all calculations @xmath10=14 mev@xmath1 , while @xmath56=1 mev is considered for the pairing correction account in ( c ) and ( d ) .
* average excitation energies of the excited particles ( dotted curves ) and holes ( dashed curves ) for given @xmath65-exciton configurations with @xmath23=@xmath24 , as function of the total excitation energy .
the same global values are used as in fig .
4 , while @xmath56=1 mev is considered for the pairing correction account . *
( a),(b ) the average excitation energies and ( c),(d ) the related s.p.l . densities for ( a),(c ) the particle - hole bound states , and ( b),(d ) the general case including ( solid curves ) or not ( dotted curve ) the continuum effect , for the @xmath53 configuration . the same global values are used as in fig .
* the particle - hole state densities for the given @xmath23-@xmath24 configurations , obtained within the average energy - dependent esm formalism for ( a ) the bound states and ( b ) the bound - plus - continuum states including the continuum effect ( solid curves ) or taking into account also the free - gas single particle levels as given by eqs .
( [ eq:23 ] ) and ( [ eq:24 ] ) in the limit of large @xmath9 and with only the finite - depth correction ( dotted curves ) , and ( c),(d ) the ratios of each of the two kinds of variant psds to the third one .
the same global values are used as in fig .
the comparison of the smoothed quantum - mechanical s.p.l .
density for the neutrons of the nucleus @xmath139fe ( solid curve ) and the results of the tf approximation using ( a ) the same woods - saxon potential well as within the qm calculation , and ( b ) the infinite ( sq ) and finite square potential wells ( fsq ) ( dashed curves ) , and the fgm formula with the fermi - energy values of @xmath3=38 mev ( dotted curve ) and @xmath140=20 mev ( dot - dashed curve ) . for parameters of the potential wells see refs . | the correct use of energy - dependent single - particle level ( s.p.l . ) densities within particle - hole state densities based on the equidistant spacing model ( esm ) is analysed .
first , an analytical expression is obtained following the convolution of energy - dependent excited - particle and hole densities .
next , a comparison is made with results of the esm formula using average s.p.l .
densities for the excited particles and holes , respectively . the fermi - gas model ( fgm ) s.p.l .
densities calculated at the corresponding average excitation energies are used in both cases .
the analysis concerns also the density of particle - hole bound states .
the pairing correlations are taken into account while the comparison of various effects includes the exact correction for the pauli exclusion principle .
quantum - mechanical s.p.l .
densities and the _ continuum effect _ can also match a corresponding fgm formula , suitable for use within the average energy - dependent partial state density in multistep reaction models . |
advances of the past decades in nonlinear optics , bose einstein condensates , propagation of soliton waves in plasma physics and in other fields of nonlinear science have involved a detailed study of nonlinear schrdinger equations ( see , for example , @xcite , bruga : sci10 , @xcite , @xcite , zakh : shab71 and references therein ) . in the theory of bose
einstein condensation @xcite , @xcite , from a general point of view , the dynamics of gases of cooled atoms in a magnetic trap at very low temperatures can be described by an effective equation for the condensate wave function known as the gross pitaevskii ( or nonlinear schrdinger ) equation @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
experimental observations of dark and bright solitons @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , khayketal02 and bright soliton trains @xcite , strecker : etal02 , @xcite in the presence of harmonic confinement have generated considerable research interest in this area bongssengs04 , @xcite .
the propagation of an optical pulse in a real fiber is also well described by a nonlinear schrdinger equation for the envelope of wave functions travelling inside the fiber @xcite , @xcite , bruga : sci10 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
a class of self - similar solutions that exists for physically realistic dispersion and nonlinearity profiles in a fiber with anomalous group velocity dispersion is discussed in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , serkin : hasrgawa00 , @xcite , which suggests , among other things , a method of pulse compression and a model of steady - state asynchronous laser mode locking @xcite .
solutions of a nonhomogeneous schrdinger equation are also known for propagation of soliton waves in plasma physics @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
integration techniques of the nonlinear schrdinger equation include painlev analysis @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , heetal09 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , hirota method @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , lax method @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , zakh : shab71 , miura transformation @xcite , @xcite , inverse scattering transform and hamiltonian approach @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , gardneretal67 , @xcite among others @xcite , degasres , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
although the classical soliton concept was developed for nonlinear autonomous dispersive systems with time being an independent variable only , not appearing in the nonlinear evolution equations ( see @xcite , @xcite for highlighting this point ) , connections between autonomous and nonautonomous schrdinger equations have been discussed in @xcite , ablowprintrub04 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , per - gtorrkonot06 , @xcite and @xcite ( see remark 2 for an explicit transformation ) .
the formation of matter wave solitons in bose
einstein condensation by magnetically tuning the interatomic interaction near the feshbach resonance provides an example of nonautonomous systems that are currently under investigation @xcite , frantz10 , @xcite .
we elaborate on results of recent papers @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , liangzhangliu05 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , kruglovetal03 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , serkinetal04 , @xcite , @xcite , strecker : etal02 , @xcite , zyan03a , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite on construction of exact solutions of the nonlinear schrdinger equation with variable quadratic hamiltonians ( see also @xcite and zakh : shab71 , @xcite , @xcite ) . in this paper , a unified form of these soliton - like ( self - similar ) solutions
is presented , thus combining progress of the soliton theory with a complete integrability of generalized harmonic oscillators .
we show , in general , that the soliton evolution in external fields described by variable quadratic potentials is totally determined by the linear problem , similar to the motion of a classical particle with acceleration , while the original soliton shape is due to a delicate balance between the linear hamiltonian ( dispersion and potential ) and nonlinearity in the schrdinger equation according to basic principles of the soliton theory .
examples include bright and dark solitons , and jacobi elliptic and painlev ii transcendental solutions for solitary wave profiles , which are important in nonlinear optics ablowprintrub04 , @xcite , @xcite , kruglovetal03 , @xcite , @xcite , serkin : hasrgawa00 , @xcite , @xcite and bose
einstein condensation @xcite , @xcite , serkinetal10 , @xcite , @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows .
we present a unified form of one soliton solutions with integrability conditions , and sketch the proof in the next two sections , respectively . in section 4 , more details are provided and some simple examples are discussed .
section 5 deals with a feshbach resonance management of matter wave solitons . in the last section , an extension of our method
is given and a classical example of accelerating soliton in a linearly inhomogeneous plasma @xcite , @xcite is revisited from a new perspective .
an attempt to collect most relevant bibliography is made but in view of a rich history and the very high publication rate in these research areas we must apologize in advance if some important papers are missing .
the nonlinear schrdinger equation@xmath0where the variable hamiltonian @xmath1 is a quadratic form of operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 namely,@xmath4(@xmath5 @xmath6 @xmath7 @xmath8 are suitable real - valued functions of time only ) has the following soliton - like solutions@xmath9(@xmath10 is a real constant , @xmath11 is a parameter and @xmath12 @xmath13 @xmath14 @xmath15 are real - valued functions of time only given by equations ( [ mkernel])([c0 ] ) below ) , provided that@xmath16(@xmath17 and @xmath18 are constants and @xmath19 as we shall see in the next section , these ( integrability ) conditions control the balance between the linear hamiltonian ( dispersion and potential ) and nonlinearity in the schrdinger equation ( [ s2 ] ) thus making possible an existence of the soliton - like solution ( with damping or amplification ) in the presence of variable quadratic potentials ( see also @xcite , @xcite , serkinetal07 , @xcite and @xcite for discussion of important special cases ; remark 2 provides an important interpretation of relations ( [ s4 ] ) as a complete integrability condition for the nonautonomous nonlinear schrdinger equation ( [ s1 ] ) when @xmath20 here , the soliton profile function @xmath21 of a single travelling wave - type argument @xmath22 @xmath23 satisfies the ordinary nonlinear differential equation of the form@xmath24if @xmath25 with the help of an integrating factor,@xmath26which can be solved in terms of jacobian elliptic functions akhiezerelliptic , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
when @xmath27 equation ( [ s5 ] ) leads to painlev ii transcendents ablo : seg81 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , kudryashovbook10 .
the variable phase is given in terms of solutions of the following system of ordinary differential equations:@xmath28@xmath29@xmath30(see ref .
@xcite and the next section for more details ) , where the standard substitution@xmath31reduces the riccati equation ( [ s6 ] ) to the second order linear equation@xmath32with@xmath33(relations with the corresponding ehrenfest theorem for the linear hamiltonian are discussed in ref . @xcite . )
it is worth noting that in the soliton - like solution under consideration ( [ s3 ] ) linear and nonlinear factors are essentially separated , namely , the nonlinear part is represented only by the profile function @xmath34 of a single travelling wave variable @xmath35 as solution of the nonlinear equation ( [ s5 ] ) . letting @xmath36constant , one obtains@xmath37and@xmath38for the soliton velocity and acceleration with the aid of ( [ s8 ] ) .
then , by ( [ s6])([s7]):@xmath39that is similar to equation of motion of a classical particle ( damped parametric oscillations ) . the initial value problem for the system ( [ s6])([s8 ] ) , which corresponds to the linear schrdinger equation with a variable quadratic hamiltonian ( generalized harmonic oscillators @xcite , dod : mal : man75 , @xcite , @xcite , yeon : lee : um : george : pandey93 ) , can be explicitly solved in terms of solutions of our characteristic equation ( [ s10 ] ) as follows cor - sot : lop : sua : sus , @xcite , @xcite , suslov10:@xmath40where@xmath41provided that @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the standard solutions of equation ( [ s10 ] ) corresponding to the following initial conditions @xmath44 @xmath45 and @xmath46 @xmath47 ( formulas ( [ a0])([c0 ] ) correspond to green s function of generalized harmonic oscillators ; see , for example , cor - sot : lop : sua : sus , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein for more details . )
the continuity with respect to initial data,@xmath48has been established in @xcite for suitable smooth coefficients of the linear schrdinger equation .
thus the soliton - like solution ( [ s3 ] ) evolves to the future @xmath49 starting from the following initial data:@xmath50where @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 @xmath55 and @xmath11 are arbitrary real parameters ( see also ( [ ap12h ] ) for a more general solution of this form ) .
when @xmath25 the gauge transformation @xmath56 $ ] changes the original equation ( [ s2 ] ) into@xmath57where @xmath5 @xmath6 @xmath7 @xmath8 are suitable real - valued functions of time @xmath58 only and@xmath59which is more common in practice . once again
, classical solution of the linear equation ( [ s10 ] ) , namely , our characteristic function @xmath60 completely controls the specific form of the nonlinearity factor @xmath61 required for creation of the soliton ( an extension is given in section 6 ; see also refs .
@xcite , serkinetal07 and @xcite for important special cases ) . a simple change of variables,@xmath62transforms the nonautonomous equation ( [ s2 ] ) with conditions ( [ s4 ] ) , when @xmath25 into a standard autonomous nonlinear schrdinger equation with respect to the new variables @xmath63 and @xmath64@xmath65which is completely integrable by advanced methods of the soliton theory @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , zakh : shab71 ( see also @xcite and references cited in the introduction ) .
this observation provides an alternative approach to derivation of our equations ( [ s6])([s9 ] ) .
an extension of the transformation ( [ s2c ] ) is given in @xcite .
following @xcite ( see also @xcite , merz and @xcite ) , we are looking for exact solutions of the form@xmath66(@xmath11 is a parameter ) .
substituting into ( [ s2 ] ) and taking the imaginary part,@xmath67for the real part , equating coefficients of all admissible powers of @xmath68 with @xmath69 one gets our system of ordinary differential equations ( [ s6])([s8 ] ) of the corresponding linear schrdinger equation with the unique solution ( [ mkernel])([c0 ] ) already obtained in refs .
@xcite , @xcite , suslov10 and/or elsewhere .
in addition , an auxiliary nonlinear equation of the form@xmath70appears as a contribution from the last two terms . with the help of ( [ s7 ] ) and ( [ s9 ] ) our equation ( [ p2 ] ) can be rewritten as@xmath71looking for a travelling wave solution with damping or amplification : @xmath72one gets@xmath73with @xmath74 and @xmath75 ( or @xmath76 then equation ( [ p3 ] ) takes the form@xmath77which must have all coefficients depending on @xmath78 only in order to preserve a self - similar profile of the travelling wave with damping or amplification .
this results in the required equation ( [ s5 ] ) under the balancing conditions ( [ s4 ] ) and our proof is complete .
( an extension is given in section 6 . ) assuming in ( [ p4 ] ) that@xmath79 where @xmath63 and @xmath80 implies @xmath81 with a general solution @xmath82
a brief description of the method under consideration is as follows . in order to obtain soliton - like solutions ( [ s3 ] ) explicitly , say in terms of elementary and/or transcendental functions , one has to solve , in general , the nonlinear equation ( [ s5 ] ) for the profile function @xmath83 in terms of jacobian elliptic functions @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ( some elementary solutions are also available ) , when @xmath25 or in terms of painlev ii transcendents , when @xmath84 ( it is known that if @xmath85 this equation does not have the painlev property @xcite , @xcite ) . in addition , one has to solve the linear characteristic equation ( [ s10 ] ) , which has a variety of solutions in terms of elementary and special ( hypergeometric , bessel ) functions @xcite , @xcite , ni : uv , @xcite , @xcite .
many elementary solutions of the corresponding linear schrdinger equation for generalized harmonic oscillators are known explicitly ( see , for example , cor - sot : lop : sua : sus , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein ) .
then , the linear part allows determination of the travelling wave argument @xmath35 and the damping ( or amplifying ) factor @xmath86 of the soliton - like solution ( [ s3 ] ) .
our balancing conditions ( [ s4 ] ) control dispersion , potential and nonlinearity in the original nonlinear schrdinger equation ( [ s2 ] ) , which is crucial for the soliton existence .
( an extension is discussed in section 6 . ) when @xmath25 equation ( [ s5 ] ) is integrated to the first order equation ( [ s5a ] ) and ( the corresponding initial value problem ) can be solved by the reduction of elliptic integrals in terms of jacobian or weierstrass ( doubly ) periodic elliptic functions @xcite , @xcite , krugloveta05 , @xcite .
we are interested in real - valued solutions .
some of the classical nonlinear wave configurations are given by@xmath87if
@xmath88 and@xmath89if @xmath90 here , cn@xmath91 and sn@xmath91 are the jacobi elliptic functions @xcite , @xcite , whi : wat .
familiar special cases include the _ bright _
soliton:@xmath92with @xmath93 in ( [ cn ] ) and the _ dark _
soliton:@xmath94with @xmath95 in ( [ sn ] ) , when cn@xmath96 and sn@xmath97 respectively ( the real period tends to infinity ) .
more details can be found in refs .
akhiezerelliptic , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and/or elsewhere .
if @xmath27 the substitution @xmath98 and @xmath99 transforms ( [ s5 ] ) into the second painlev equation,@xmath100 in the limit @xmath101 this equation reduces to the airy equation and its solution may be thought of as a nonlinear generalization of an airy function @xcite .
there is a one - parameter family of real solutions @xmath102 that are bounded for all real @xmath103 with the following asymptotic properties:@xmath104here , ai@xmath105 is the airy function , @xmath106 provided @xmath107 @xmath108@xmath109and@xmath110these asymptotics were found in @xcite , @xcite and , eventually , had been proven rigorously in @xcite , deiftzhou95 ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein for study of this nonlinear airy function ; graphs of these functions are presented in @xcite , see figure 1 for an example : @xmath111 an application to a soliton moving with a constant velocity in linearly inhomogeneous plasma is discussed in section 6 .
generalized harmonic oscillators @xcite , @xcite , hannay85 , @xcite , @xcite , which correspond to the schrdinger equation with variable quadratic hamiltonians , are well studied in quantum mechanics ( see also cor - sot : lop : sua : sus , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein for a general approach and known elementary and transcendental solutions ) .
a few examples include the caldirola kanai hamiltonian of the quantum damped oscillator @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and some of its natural modifications ; a modified oscillator considered by meiler , cordero - soto and suslov @xcite , @xcite , and the degenerate parametric oscillator cor - sot : susdpo ; the quantum damped oscillator of chruciski and jurkowski @xcite , and a quantum - modified parametric oscillator among others .
green s functions are derived in a united way in ref .
cor - sot : sua : susinv .
combination of linear and nonlinear parts by our formula ( [ s3 ] ) results in numerous explicit soliton - like solutions for corresponding nonlinear schrdinger equations .
it is worth noting that in this approach most linear and some nonlinear classical special functions of mathematical physics are linked together through these solutions . in the simplest form,@xmath112one
gets @xcite , @xcite , @xcite@xmath113(@xmath114 @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117 are constants ) and@xmath118(traditionally , @xmath119 and @xmath120 with @xmath121 @xcite , @xcite . the case @xmath84 is discussed in section 6 . )
the case @xmath122@xmath123is of interest in fiber optics ( see , for example , @xcite , @xcite , hasegawa , @xcite , @xcite , krugloveta05 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , rajuetal05 , @xcite , @xcite , serkinetal07 , @xcite and references therein ) . here , all parameters @xmath124 @xmath125 and @xmath61 are functions of the propagation distance @xmath126 and this equation describes the amplification or attenuation ( if @xmath8 is positive ) of pulses propagating nonlinearly in a single - mode optical fiber , where @xmath127 is the complex envelope of the electrical field in a comoving frame , @xmath128 is the retarded time , @xmath129 is the group velocity dispersion parameter , @xmath125 is the dispersion gain or loss function , and @xmath61 is the nonlinearity parameter @xcite , krugloveta05 .
the substitution @xmath130 @xmath131 results in@xmath132which , of course , can be solved by the method under consideration , but a standard change of the time variable,@xmath133transforms this equation into the previous one .
just replace @xmath134 ( see also @xcite , @xcite , serkin : hasrgawa00 , @xcite and @xcite , where this simple observation has been omitted ) .
more general transformations are discussed in refs .
@xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite . in a similar fashion
, one can show that the nonlinear schrdinger equation of the form@xmath135has the following explicit solution:@xmath136where@xmath137and@xmath138provided@xmath139(@xmath25 @xmath140 @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath141 @xmath142 @xmath18 and @xmath11 are arbitrary real constants ) .
the reader may choose the profile function @xmath143 say in one of the forms ( [ cn])(tanh ) .
if @xmath27 the schrdinger equation,@xmath144has a solution - like solution of the form ( [ ex8b ] ) ( last term in ( ex8d ) should be omitted ) provided that@xmath145which solution is given in terms of the nonlinear airy function @xmath146 further details are left to the reader ( see also section 6 ) .
discovery of bose einstein condensates in ultra - cold gases of weakly interacting alkali - metal atoms has stimulated intensive studies of nonlinear matter waves on a macroscopic scale ( see , for example , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , srteckeretal03 ) .
the gross pitaevskii equation for a zero - temperature condensate of atoms , confined in a cylindrical trap @xmath147 and a time - dependent harmonic confinement , which can be either attractive or expulsive , along the @xmath78 direction , @xmath148 is given by @xcite , dal : giorg : pitaevski : str99 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite:@xmath149where @xmath150 @xmath151 is the @xmath152-wave scattering length , @xmath153 is the mass of the atom , @xmath154 and the condensate interaction with the normal atomic cloud through three - body interaction is phenomenologically incorporated by a gain or loss term @xmath155 if the interaction energy of atoms is much less that the kinetic energy in the transverse direction , then the substitution @xmath156allows one to reduce the three - dimensional gross
pitaevskii equation ( gpeq ) to the following one - dimensional nonlinear schrdinger equation in new dimensionless units @xmath157 and @xmath158@xmath159here,@xmath160and @xmath161 is the bohr radius ( see refs .
@xcite , kivsh : alex : tur01 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite for more details ) .
letting@xmath162with the function @xmath163 given by ( [ gg ] ) below , equation ( [ ex10 ] ) can be transformed into ( [ s2 ] ) , where@xmath164then our characteristic equation ( [ s10 ] ) take the form@xmath165which describes the motion of a classical oscillator with variable frequency @xcite .
( this equation coincides also with the ehrenfest theorem for the corresponding linear hamiltonian @xcite . )
choosing the standard solutions @xmath166 and @xmath167 with @xmath168 @xmath169 and @xmath46 @xmath170 one can use formulas ( [ mkernel])([c0 ] ) with @xmath171 in order to solve the linear problem in quadratures .
this gives the soliton travelling wave variable @xmath35 and the following balancing conditions:@xmath172when
@xmath173 the properties of bose einstein condensed gases can be strongly altered by tuning the external magnetic field . a feshbach resonance management for bose
einstein condensates has been discussed from experimental and theoretical perspectives by many authors ( see , for example , abdullaevetal03 , @xcite , @xcite , cornishetal00 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , kevreketal03 , @xcite , @xcite , moerverhaxels95 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , stengetal99 , @xcite , @xcite , timmetalphysrep99 , @xcite , @xcite and references therein ) .
the feshbach resonance is a scattering resonance in which pairs of free atoms are tuned via zeeman effect into resonance with vibrational state of the diatomic molecule @xcite , @xcite , tiesverhst93 .
( they are known as feshbach resonance because of their similarity to scattering resonances described by herman feshbach in nuclear collisions . )
the strength of the nonlinearity @xmath174 is defined in terms of @xmath152-wave scattering length @xmath175 namely,@xmath176and dependence of atomic collision cross section due to existence of the metastable state @xcite , @xcite , kagansurshlyap97prl , @xcite enables @xmath151 to be continuously tuned from positive to negative values .
( the scattering length also determines the formation rate , the spectrum of collective excitations , the evolution of the condensate phase , the coupling with the noncondensed atoms , and other important properties @xcite , @xcite . ) as follows from the experiments , the @xmath152-wave scattering length is the following function of the applied magnetic field @xcite:@xmath177(the feshbach resonance provides , so to speak , a continuous knob to adjust the atom - atom interaction from repulsive to attractive , and from weak to strong @xcite .
thus it is possible to study strongly interacting , weakly or noninteracting , or collapsing condensates kagansurshlyap97prl , all with the same alkali species and experimental setup .
when the nonlinearity @xmath178 one deals with linear modes of a macroscopic harmonic oscillator @xcite ; see , for example , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein for a detailed treatment of the corresponding quantum oscillator with variable frequency . ) in the empirically established expression ( [ feshres ] ) , @xmath179 is the resonant value of the magnetic field , @xmath180 is the off - resonance scattering length and parameter @xmath181 represents the resonance width in units of the bohr radius @xmath161 ( see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein for more details ) .
feshbach resonances have been observed in @xmath182 at @xmath183 @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , in @xmath184 at @xmath185 and @xmath186 @xcite and have also been identified in @xmath187 @xcite , @xcite , strecker : etal02 , @xcite .
the feshbach resonance provides an effective practical tool for experimental study of the matter wave solitons .
indeed , for creation of a certain soliton configuration one needs to satisfy the following condition : @xmath188 in order to synchronize the feshbach resonance and harmonic trap .
( here , both sides have the same simple pole structure , which can be used in experimental setting . )
this equation allows determination of the classical law of motion ( kinematics in @xmath78 direction ) of the expectation value @xmath189 with respect to the linear part of gross
pitaevskii hamiltonian ( [ gpeq ] ) , when @xmath190 in terms of a suitable applied magnetic field @xmath191 near the feshbach resonance .
( the synchronized harmonic trap oscillation frequency should be found from the classical equation of motion ( [ classosc ] ) as @xmath192 vice versa , the required tuning magnetic field is given by@xmath193if a particular law of motion @xmath194 is obtain by integration ( dynamics ) of the classical equation ( [ classosc ] ) .
our criteria of the wave matter soliton management are consistent with ones obtained in refs .
atre : pani : aga06 , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite and @xcite , if the classical equation of motion ( [ classosc ] ) is taken into account ( this point seems not emphasized in these papers ) . harmonic matter wave solitons , which correspond to @xmath195constant in the nonlinear schrdinger equation ( [ ex10 ] ) , namely,@xmath196can be produced in bose
einstein condensates by tuning the external magnetic field near the feshbach resonance as follows@xmath197letting @xmath198 one gets@xmath199when @xmath200 ( a similar case has been recently discussed in refs .
@xcite and @xcite ; it is of interest to analyze possible experimental setup ; see also @xcite ) .
the reader may find more details on the synchronization of feshbach resonance and harmonic trap , explicit soliton configurations , and available numerical and experimental results in recent papers @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ( see also @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , eba : khal , @xcite , @xcite , trall - gin : drake : lop - rich : trall - herr : bir , @xcite , zakh : shab71 and references therein ) .
if an arbitrary linear combination of operators @xmath2 and @xmath201 is added to the quadratic hamiltonian in equation ( [ s2 ] ) , namely,@xmath202one can look for exact solutions in a more general form@xmath203(@xmath11 is a parameter , we are separating contributions from linear @xmath204 and nonlinear @xmath205 parts in the constant term ) .
the linear part has been already solved in @xcite and @xcite .
one has additional equations@xmath206@xmath207@xmath208to the system ( [ s6])([s8 ] ) , whose solutions are given by@xmath209here,@xmath210
\frac{ds}{\lambda \left ( s\right ) } , \label{ap9}\]]@xmath211@xmath212with @xmath213 and @xmath214 ( see refs . @xcite and @xcite for more details ) . our equation ( [ p2 ] ) takes the form@xmath215and the nonlinear equation ( [ p3 ] ) becomes@xmath216once again , with the help of ( [ s7 ] ) , ( [ s9 ] ) and ( [ ap4 ] ) , equation ( [ ap12 ] ) can be rewritten as@xmath217and looking for a travelling wave solution of the form@xmath218one gets@xmath219with @xmath220 and @xmath221 ( or @xmath222 then@xmath223and our balancing conditions are given by@xmath224with @xmath225 according to ( [ s8 ] ) . for the soliton velocity,@xmath226thus extending ( [ s11a ] ) .
equation of motion is given by@xmath227as a nonhomogeneous generalization of ( [ s11c ] ) ( forced damped parametric oscillators ) .
as a final result , our solitary wave solution has the form@xmath228where the elliptic function @xmath34 satisfies the nonlinear equation ( [ s5 ] ) with @xmath120 and @xmath51 @xmath229 @xmath17 and @xmath18 are real parameters .
time - dependent functions @xmath230 @xmath231 @xmath232 @xmath233 @xmath234 and @xmath235 are given by our equations ( [ mkernel])([c0 ] ) and ( [ ap6])([ap11 ] ) ( as in the corresponding solution of the linear schrdinger equation @xcite , suaz : sus ) . _
example 1_. a soliton motion with acceleration in linearly inhomogeneous plasma was discovered in refs .
@xcite and chenhh : liucs78 ( see also @xcite , @xcite ) . for a modified equation,@xmath236where @xmath237 @xmath238 @xmath115 @xmath239 and @xmath42
are constants , we get @xmath240 and@xmath241with@xmath242 in our particular solution ( [ ap12h ] ) .
the classical case chenhh : liucs76 , @xcite corresponds to @xmath119 and @xmath243 ( with @xmath244 the reader may choose the profile @xmath34 in one of the forms ( [ cn])([tanh ] ) . _
example 2_. a similar case occur , if one takes @xmath84 in ( [ ex4 ] ) .
the corresponding schrdinger equation is given by@xmath245where@xmath246with the help of the gauge transformation,@xmath247one gets@xmath248and@xmath249here,@xmath250and the soliton profile is defined ( as a solution of the second painlev equation ) in terms of the nonlinear airy function @xmath251 with asymptotics given by ( [ aspii])([aspiiph ] ) .
( graph of one of these functions , @xmath252 is presented on figure 1 from clark10 . )
it is worth noting that , in a contrast to the previous case , our @xmath253-soliton moves with a constant velocity when @xmath254 further details are left to the reader .
* acknowledgements .
* we thank andrew bremner , carlos castillo - chvez , elliott h. lieb , vladimir i. manko and svetlana roudenko for support , valuable discussions and encouragement . one of us ( sks ) is grateful to his students in a mathematics of quantum mechanics course at arizona state university for a detailed discussion of several aspects of this work .
999 f. kh .
abdullaev , a. m. kamchatov , v. v. konotop and v. a. brazhnyi , _ adiabatic dynamics of periodic waves in bose einstein condensates with time dependent atomic scattering length _
lett . * 90 * ( 2003 ) # 23 , 230402 ( 4 pages ) .
u. al khawaja , _ a comparative analysis of painlev , lax pair , and similarity transformation methods in obtaining the integrability conditions of nonlinear schrdinger equations _ , j. math .
* 51 * ( 2010 ) , 053506 ( 11 pages ) .
r. conte , _ the painlev approach to nonlinear ordinary differential equations _
, in : _ the painlev property , one century later _ , crm series in mathematical physics ( r. conte , ed . ) , springer
verlag , new york , 1991 .
77180 .
r. cordero - soto , r. m. lopez , e. suazo and s. k. suslov , _ propagator of a charged particle with a spin in uniform magnetic and perpendicular electric fields _ , lett .
* 84 * ( 2008 ) # 23 , 159178 .
r. cordero - soto , e. suazo and s. k. suslov , _ quantum integrals of motion for variable quadratic hamiltonians _
, annals of physics * 325 * ( 2010 ) # 10 , 18841912 ; see also arxiv:0912.4900v9 [ math - ph ] 19 mar 2010 .
s. l. cornish , n. r. claussen , j. l. roberts , e. a. cornell and c. e. wieman , _ stable _ @xmath182 _ bose einstein condensates with widely tunable interactions _ ,
* 85 * ( 2000 ) # 9 , 17951798 .
v. v. dodonov and v. i. manko , _ invariants and correlated states of nonstationary quantum systems _ , in : _ invariants and the evolution of nonstationary quantum systems _ , proceedings of lebedev physics institute , vol .
71 - 181 , nauka , moscow , 1987 [ in russian ] ; english translation published by nova science , commack , new york , 1989 , pp .
103 - 261 .
b. a. dubrovin , v. b. matveev and s. p. novikov , _ non - linear equations of korteweg de vries type , finite - zone linear operators and abelian varieties _
, in : _ integrable system : selected papers _ , london math .
lecture note series , vol .
53 - 140 .
a. ebaid and s. m. khaled , _ new types of exact solutions for nonlinear schrdinger equation with cubic nonlinearity _ , journal of computational and applied mathematics ( 2010 ) , doi:10.1016/j.cam.2010.09.024 .
o. fedichev , yu . kagan , g. v. shlyapnikov and j. t. m. walraven , _ influence of nearly resonant light on the scattering length in low - temperature atomic gases _
* 77 * ( 1996 ) # 14 , 29132916 .
y. i. kruglov , a. c. peacock and j. d. harvey , _
exact self - similar solutions of the generalized nonlinear schrdinger equation with distributed coefficients _
lett . * 90 * ( 2003 ) # 11 , 113902 ( 4 pages ) .
z. x. liang , z. d. zhang and w. m. liu , _ dynamics of a bright solutions in bose
einstein condensates with time - dependent atomic scattering length in an expulsive parabolic potential _ , phys .
* 94 * ( 2005 ) # 5 , 050402 ( 4 pages ) .
m. meiler , r. cordero - soto and s. k. suslov , _ solution of the cauchy problem for a time - dependent schrdinger equation _ , j. math
* 49 * ( 2008 ) # 7 , 072102 ( 27 pages ) ; see also arxiv : 0711.0559v4 [ math - ph ] 5 dec 2007 .
j. l. roberts , n. r. claussen , j. p. burke , jr . , c. h. greene , e. a. cornell and c. e. wieman , _ resonant magetic field control of elastic scattering in cold _ @xmath182 _ _ _ _ , phys .
81 * ( 1998 ) # 23 , 51095112 . v. n. serkin , a. hasegawa and t. l. belyeva , _ comment on exact self - similar solutions of the generalized nonlinear schrdinger equation with distributed coefficients _ ,
* 92 * ( 2004 ) # 19 , 199401 ( 1 page ) .
j. stenger , s. inouye , m. r. andrews , h .- j .
miester , d. m. stamper - kurn and w. ketterle , _ strongly inelastic collisions in bose - einstein condensate near feshbach resonances _ , phys .
lett . * 82 * ( 1999 ) # 12 , 24222425 .
w. c. stwalley , _ stability of spin - alligned hydrogen at low temperatures and high magnetic fields : new field - dependent scattering resonances and predissociations _ ,
* 37 * ( 1976 ) # 24 , 16281631 . c. trallero - giner , j. drake , v. lopez - richard ,
c. trallero - herrero and j. l. birman , _ bose einstein condensates : analytical methods for the gross pitaevskii equation _ , phys .
a * 354 * ( 2006 ) , 115118 . v. e. zakharov and a. b. shabat , _ exact theory of two - dimensional self - focusing and one - dimensional self - modulation of waves in nonlinear media _ , zh .
* 61 * ( 1971 ) , 118134 [ sov .
jetp * 34 * ( 1972 ) , 6269 . ] v. e. zakharov and a. b. shabat , _ a scheme for integrating the nonlinear equations of mathematical physics by the method of the inverse scattering problem .
, functional analysis and its applications * 8 * ( 1974 ) # 3 , 226235
. x .- f .
zhang , q. yang , j .- f .
zhang , x. z. chen and w. m. liu , _ controlling soliton interactions in bose
einstein condensates by synchronizing the feshbach resonance and harmonic trap _ , phys .
a * 77 * ( 2008 ) , 023613 ( 7 pages ) . | we construct one soliton solutions for the nonlinear schrdinger equation with variable quadratic hamiltonians in a unified form by taking advantage of a complete ( super ) integrability of generalized harmonic oscillators .
the soliton wave evolution in external fields with variable quadratic potentials is totally determined by the linear problem , like motion of a classical particle with acceleration , and the ( self - similar ) soliton shape is due to a subtle balance between the linear hamiltonian ( dispersion and potential ) and nonlinearity in the schrdinger equation by the standards of soliton theory .
most linear ( hypergeometric , bessel ) and a few nonlinear ( jacobian elliptic , second painlev transcendental ) classical special functions of mathematical physics are linked together through these solutions , thus providing a variety of nonlinear integrable cases .
examples include bright and dark solitons , and jacobi elliptic and second painlev transcendental solutions for several variable hamiltonians that are important for current research in nonlinear optics and bose einstein condensation .
the feshbach resonance matter wave soliton management is briefly discussed from this new perspective . |
numerical simulations were performed with the open - source qiwib implementation of mctdhb @xcite , using standard runge kutta time evolution and representing spatial derivatives with five point stencil finite differences . for the @xmath65 ground - state results in figs .
( 3 ) and ( 4 ) , we have performed simulations on a 1400 point equidistant grid with different values of the coupling constant @xmath77 using @xmath78 as the computational box length for @xmath79 and @xmath80 for stronger interactions . while for @xmath67
, we have used a 2000 point equidistant grid with @xmath78 for @xmath81 and @xmath82 for stronger interactions . for the time - evolution of the com variance
, we have used 600 point equidistant grid with @xmath83 for both @xmath55 and @xmath40 simulations .
we have assured ourselves that the results are converged with respect to changes in these parameters and those of time and space discretization .
in addition , we have compared the qiwib results against an independent implementation of mctdhb @xcite , which produced identical results at the reported accuracy .
the simulations of the quench dynamics are performed in two steps : ( 1 ) relaxation to the ground state of the harmonic trap and ( 2 ) time propagation after turning off the trap .
it follows from very general principles that observables linked only to the com wave function are independent of the interaction strength for at most harmonic potentials or constant gauge fields .
here we demonstrate this explicitly for the com variance and a many particle system governed by the hamiltonian of eq .
( 1 ) . for this purpose
we write an arbitrary initial quantum state as @xmath84 where @xmath85 is a complete basis set which depends only on the com and @xmath86 is a complete basis set which depends on the @xmath13 relative motion degrees - of - freedom .
we further write the time evolution of the many - body wavefunction as ( @xmath87 ) @xmath88 in eq . , the total hamiltonian was written as @xmath89 , where @xmath90 is the com hamiltonian and the remaining terms , including the interaction - dependent operators , form @xmath91 .
then we can explicitly write @xmath92 the dynamics of the second moment of the com wave function is obtained as @xmath93 from the last line of eq .
it can be seen that the result is independent of the interaction strength during the time evolution .
the time evolution of the com variance thus depends only on the initial state ( through the expansion coefficients @xmath94 ) and the external potential through the com hamiltonian @xmath90 .
this fact can be used as a sanity check for mctdhb simulations , which , if fully converged , should produce the same time evolution for the com variance for different values of the interaction strength .
the ground state of @xmath65 particles in a time - independent harmonic trap with frequency @xmath38 is described by a product of the center - of - mass ( com ) and relative motion wave functions : @xmath95 .
the analytical form of the com wave function is @xmath96 where @xmath97 . on the other hand ,
the relative motion wave function with the normalization constant @xmath98 and harmonic oscillator length scale , @xmath99 , can be obtained as @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the relative coordinate , @xmath102 is the confluent hypergeometric function of the second kind and @xmath103 comes from the discontinuity in the first derivative due to the delta interaction @xcite .
explicitly , @xmath103 is calculated by solving the transcendental equation @xmath104 the ground - state energy is given by @xmath105 and the exact results for the natural occupancy are obtained by numerically diagonalizing of the single particle density matrix @xmath106 after turning off the trap , the gaussian com wave function expands .
in particular , the time evolution of the com wave function represents the textbook example of gaussian wave propagation @xcite @xmath107 } \biggr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the com wave function spreads leading to a variance increasing quadratically in time @xmath108.\ ] ] the relative motion after trap release , on the other hand , is dominated by the bound state of the attractive @xmath109 interactions . indeed
, since the @xmath109 function has exactly one bound state , near the origin the relative motion wave function will approach this bound state in the long time - limit and possible other contributions from scattering state will disperse . the initial relative motion wave function can be expressed in terms of the bound state and scattering states : @xmath110 , where the bound state is @xmath111 .
then , the expected variance of the relative motion wave function in the long time limit must be @xmath112 .
in the main text we have demonstrated the ambiguity of the studying the eigenvalues of the single - particle density matrix , the natural occupations , for a specific mctdhb simulation . for @xmath65 particles we are able to vary the number of modes @xmath0 over a good range , which permits a conventional study of convergence with respect to mode number .
it is further possible to analyse the shape of the two - particle wave function in the mctdhb approximation , which sheds some light on the unphysical coupling of relative and com motion in the truncated multi - mode expansion .
we test the convergence by checking whether relevant quantities , e.g. the variational ground - state energy , remain unchanged as the number of modes @xmath0 is increased .
the results in table [ tab1 ] are still varying at the level of several percent between @xmath113 and @xmath40 and thus indicate , correctly , that the mctdhb expansion converges very slowly and is not yet fully converged with 10 modes . while this way of testing convergence is reliable and has produced the correct answer , varying @xmath0 from one to ten modes is a luxury that can only be afforded for small particle numbers @xmath5 . in simulations with hundreds to thousands of particles ( e.g. @xcite ) , the options for choosing @xmath0 are severely limited due to the unfavorable scaling of numerical effort when both @xmath5 and @xmath0 are large .
c | c | c | c | c | c | c | & & + & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & & @xmath115 & @xmath116 + & -0.5787 & 1 & 0 & & 1 & 0 + & -1.1451 & 0.9342 & 0.0536 & & 0.9613 & 0.0316 + & -1.3817 & 0.9062 & 0.0701 & & 0.9483 & 0.0392 + & -1.5546 & 0.8846 & 0.0825 & & 0.9387 & 0.0451 + & -1.6213 & 0.8761 & 0.0872 & & 0.9355 & 0.0470 + & -1.9527 & 0.8251 & 0.1142 & & 0.9202 & 0.0563 + we have also considered how the dependence of the com variance of the trapped ground state on the interaction strength @xmath117 changes for different numbers of modes @xmath0 . for brevity , we introduce the dimensionless interaction parameter where @xmath118 . for @xmath65 , this coupling constant is related to the ratio between relevant length scales via @xmath119 , where the prefactor changes with @xmath5
. figure [ fig : r2r2 ] compares the com variance from mctdhb calculations with the exact result @xmath120 from eq .
( 2 ) of the main text .
it is apparent that the mctdhb results deviate severely from the exact values for strongly attractive interaction , and that convergence of the mctdhb expansion with increasing the number of modes @xmath0 is exceedingly slow .
( symbols ) .
the solid horizontal line denotes the exact ground - state com variance @xmath120 . for comparison
, the dash - dotted line shows the exact relative - coordinate variance @xmath121 of the two - particle bound state . ] in fig .
[ fig : m5m10gspop ] , we present the dependence of the natural occupation on the interaction parameter .
a couple of remarks pointing to the ambiguity of this convergence indicator are in order .
first , by looking at the results for @xmath40 and @xmath122 one is tempted to conclude that mctdhb has already converged since three orbitals are below @xmath123 .
but , we know from fig . [ fig : r2r2 ] that for the same interaction strength the mctdhb com variance is still far from the exact value .
second , it can be seen that all the natural occupations , except for the highest one , are shifted up as the number of single - particle modes @xmath0 is increased .
this further exemplifies the failure of the convergence requirement based on the lowest occupancy .
for example , the 5th lowest natural occupation at @xmath124 is below @xmath125 for @xmath126 , while this is not true for @xmath40 , where the 5th single - particle mode is now above the cut - off value . for ( a ) @xmath126 and ( b ) @xmath40 .
the dashed horizontal line denotes the convergence criterion of @xmath127 . ]
lastly , we look at the rate of convergence for observables , in particular the ground state energy and the single - particle density variance , as depicted in fig . [ fig : convm ] .
we find that the mctdhb results approach the exact values with a slow power law as a function of the number of single - particle modes @xmath0 , i.e. @xmath128 .
the empirical exponent @xmath103 lies between @xmath129 and @xmath130 , which indicates slightly faster convergence than the @xmath130 leading exponent of the full - ci expansion of two 1d bosons with point interaction in a fixed harmonic oscillator basis @xcite .
we note that this power - law behavior only sets in for mode numbers larger than @xmath131 in this case and the convergence rate is significantly slower for smaller @xmath0 .
this may be because the variational optimisation of the modes is particularly effective for small @xmath0 .
it also means , however , that in the pre - power - law regime of @xmath132 increasing the number of modes brings even less effect than the empirical power law would suggest that governs larger regimes of @xmath0 .
unfortunately , for particle numbers in the hundreds or larger , the scaling of computational resources practically limits the application of mctdhb exactly to the small @xmath0 regime . for @xmath124 : ( a ) ground - state energy and ( b ) single - particle density variance . dashed horizontal lines correspond to the exact values .
symbols denote the mctdhb results for different @xmath0 .
the exponent of the power law fit , @xmath103 , is also shown .
( inset ) log - log plot of the absolute difference between the exact and mctdhb results . ] in order to understand how mctdhb deals with the competing length scales and why it violates the separation of com and relative motion , it is instructive to plot the two particle density , as shown in fig .
[ fig:2body ] for @xmath65 .
in these plots , the diagonal ( @xmath133 ) represents the com coordinate @xmath134 and the antidiagonal ( @xmath135 ) the relative motion coordinate @xmath136 .
while the left hand panels relate to the ground state of @xmath137 , the right hand panels relate to a later time @xmath138 after trap release . here
the com wave function has expanded significantly according to eq .
, whereas the relative - motion bound state is hardly changed .
the upper two panels show the exact result and panel ( b ) clearly demonstrates the diverging length scales .
note the changing spatial scale between panels ( a ) and ( b ) .
the middle panels ( c ) and ( d ) present the @xmath1 ( gross - pitaevskii ) result . at this level ,
the com and relative motion length scales are identical because the product form of the state with a single mode function @xmath139 together with the inversion symmetry of the problem forces a four - fold symmetry and leaves no option to distinguish the two diagonal directions . for long times
, the wave function expands in both directions and the com and relative motion length scales are identical .
the lower panels ( e ) and ( f ) report an mctdhb simulation with @xmath126 modes .
the trapped ground state in [ fig:2body](e ) is approximated better than with @xmath1 , although some more detailed features are missing . the long - time profile in fig .
[ fig:2body](f ) shows five separated peaks with each one exhibiting a four - fold symmetry and resembling the @xmath1 result , albeit on a different scale . as the mctdhb expansion is a sum over symmetrized product states , different numbers of modes @xmath0 will produce up to @xmath0 peaks with diagonal off diagonal symmetry .
thus for given @xmath0 , the com and relative motion are strongly coupled and expansion dynamics , where the com length scale grows over time , will not be captured correctly . furthermore , this discretised behavior due to finite @xmath0 leads to an impractical number of @xmath0 needed to correctly model the limit of a delocalised com but localised relative motion . for @xmath137 at different times : left [ ( a),(c),(e ) ] @xmath140 and right [ ( b),(d),(f ) ] @xmath141 .
comparison between [ ( a),(b ) ] exact , [ ( c),(d ) ] gross - pitaevskii ( @xmath1 ) , and [ ( e),(f ) ] @xmath126.,title="fig : " ] for @xmath137 at different times : left [ ( a),(c),(e ) ] @xmath140 and right [ ( b),(d),(f ) ] @xmath141 .
comparison between [ ( a),(b ) ] exact , [ ( c),(d ) ] gross - pitaevskii ( @xmath1 ) , and [ ( e),(f ) ] @xmath126.,title="fig : " ]
in this section , we are going to prove the bounds for the variance of the exact single - particle density manifested in the shaded region in fig . 4 of the main text .
for systems with a hamiltonian that is separable in the com and relative motion coordinate , we can conveniently introduce the following change - of - variables for the com coordinate @xmath134 : @xmath142 and for the relative motion coordinate with @xmath143 @xcite : @xmath144 this means that the many - body wave function is given by @xmath145 this allows us to write the single - particle density profile as @xmath146 where , @xmath147 and @xmath148 note that we can express @xmath149 as : @xmath150 then we can transform the integration from @xmath151 , where @xmath152 is the corresponding jacobian .
the single - particle density becomes @xmath153 the @xmath154 integrations over @xmath155 can now be done separately and be used to define a new function @xmath156 which allows us to write the single - particle density as @xmath157 one can see that indeed the single - particle density profile is just a convolution between the @xmath158 and another function @xmath159 that is associated with the relative - motion wave function .
the function @xmath160 can be further interpreted as the mean - density for a fixed com position .
this can be justified by following ref .
we write the single - particle density in this case as @xmath161 the integration over @xmath162 can be easily done due to the presence of the @xmath109-function leading to @xmath163 again we transform the integration variables using eq . such that @xmath164 , where we define @xmath165 this yields @xmath166
lastly , we integrate over the @xmath167 to find that indeed @xmath160 is equal to @xmath168 , @xmath169 it is straightforward to show that the variances add in a convolution provided that at least one of the functions is centered at the origin ( in our case the com wave function ) : @xmath170 where @xmath171 , @xmath172 and the functions @xmath173 and @xmath160 are normalized to unity . from eq . , it can be deduced that the width of the exact single - particle density will always be greater than the width of the com wave function , @xmath174 and the equality is satisfied in the limit of large interaction coupling @xmath175 ( @xmath176 ) .
moreover , the variance of the relative motion density for an untrapped state is smaller than the untrapped case , i.e. , @xmath177 , where @xmath178 is an excellent approximation of the untrapped relative motion variance that becomes exact for large @xmath5 @xcite .
this means that the bounds for the exact single - particle density must be @xmath179 9ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop ( ) @noop `` , '' ( ) \doibase 10.1023/a:1018705520999 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _
( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.130401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.240401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.88.043601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/17/11/115001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.023619 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.11.265 [ * * , ( ) ] | multi - mode expansions in computational quantum dynamics promise convergence toward exact results upon increasing the number of modes .
convergence is difficult to ascertain in practice due to the unfavourable scaling of required resources for many - particle problems and therefore a simplified criterion based on a threshold value for the least occupied mode function is often used .
here we show how the separable quantum motion of the center of mass can be used to sensitively detect unconverged numerical multi - particle dynamics in harmonic potentials . based on an experimentally relevant example of attractively interacting bosons in one dimension
, we demonstrate that the simplified convergence criterion fails to assure qualitatively correct results .
furthermore , the numerical evidence for the creation of two - hump fragmented bright soliton - like states presented by streltsov _
et al . _ [ prl 100 , 130401 ( 2008 ) ] is shown to be inconsistent with exact results .
implications for our understanding of dynamical fragmentation in attractive boson systems are briefly discussed .
recent advances in the field of ultracold atoms have made it possible to observe the quantum dynamics of few to many particles under unitary time evolution @xcite .
the opportunity to explain and predict novel effects motivates computational approaches , which face the challenge of vast complexity @xcite .
variational multi - mode dynamics seeks to reduce the computational complexity by expanding the wave function with a small number @xmath0 of optimised mode functions @xcite .
specifically adapted for bosonic particles is the multi - configurational time - dependent hartree method for bosons ( mctdhb ) @xcite .
it provides a hierarchy of approxmations beyond the hartree or gross - pitaevskii mean - field theory @xcite , to which it reduces for @xmath1 .
the ability to represent fragmented bose - einstein condensates and correlated wave functions for @xmath2 is the defining feature of the approach .
while the limit of large @xmath0 formally recovers the multi - particle schrdinger equation , it is often impossible to verify convergence through increasing @xmath0 due to prohibitive computational requirements .
this motivates the search for independent convergence checks .
here we test the convergence of mctdhb simulations by exploiting the artificial coupling of the center - of - mass ( com ) and relative motion in the truncated multi - mode expansion . in harmonic external potentials and homogeneous gauge fields ,
the com dynamics of a many - particle system is independent of the particle interactions by the generalised kohn s theorem @xcite . including time - dependent , anisotropic , rotating , or absent trapping potentials of any number of spatial dimensions , this result covers a wide range of experimentally relevant scenarios , where the exact quantum mechanical time evolution of the com can be easily obtained . since a convergent simulation
is typically required to reproduce the exact com dynamics , a comparison between both results serves as a sensitive convergence test . an interesting scenario for quantum dynamics with ultra - cold atoms
is provided by attractive bosons in narrowly confining elongated traps , where bright matter - wave solitons of @xmath3 to @xmath4 atoms have been observed @xcite .
fragmentation of the bose - einstein condensate can be anticipated from theoretical arguments @xcite , even though experiments have been largely consistent with gross - pitaevskii ( @xmath1 ) theory .
the tendency to form many - particle bound states @xcite , which are themselves well approximated by the hartree approximation @xcite , further motivates the use of multi - mode expansions , and several mctdhb - based studies have been published @xcite . in this work
we find a pathologically slow convergence of the mctdhb expansion for untrapped or weakly - trapped attractive bosons where the com length scale becomes of the same order or larger than the typical length scale of relative motion . specifically , we find that predictions for the dynamical creation of the two - humped , two - fold fragmented states of attractive bosons named `` fragmentons '' in ref .
@xcite were based on unconverged mctdhb simulations and are inconsistent with the exact com dynamics .
we further find that previously proposed internal convergence checks of mctdhb fail to reliably detect unconverged results , including the popular strategy of setting a threshold for the smallest eigenvalue of the single - particle density matrix to estimate the relevance of the least important mode @xcite . for definiteness
, we consider the dynamics of @xmath5 bosons of mass @xmath6 in one dimension with the hamiltonian @xmath7 where @xmath8 , and @xmath9 is the coupling parameter of attractive interactions @xcite . due to the harmonic trapping potential
the problem is separable and the com hamiltonian @xmath10 formally defines a single - particle problem in the com coordinate @xmath11 .
the hamiltonian of relative motion @xmath12 depends only on the @xmath13 distances between particles and commutes with @xmath14 .
thus the time evolution of any observables that are purely related to the com coordinate is completely independent of the interaction strength .
this is very useful for checking the convergence of multi - mode simulations .
_ multi - mode quantum dynamics _ the mctdhb method is based on the variational ansatz for the quantum state @xmath15^{n_k}|\mathrm{vac}\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath16 particles .
both the expansion coefficients and the single - particle functions @xmath17 are time dependent and their evolution equations follow from a variational principle ( for details see ref .
@xcite ) .
the main parameter determining the accuracy and computational effort of mctdhb simulations is the number of single - particle modes @xmath0 .
the com variance @xmath18 can be obtained from through the two - body density matrix @xmath19 as @xcite , @xmath20 since the expansion refers to single - particle quantities rather than the separated com and relative coordinates , it does not trivially respect the separability .
the simulated time evolution of the com variance will thus be exact in two limits : when the expansion is fully converged , or when particle interactions vanish ( @xmath21 ) . in the latter case the mctdhb time evolution reduces to uncoupled single - particle schrdinger equations , which can be solved accurately within the chosen discretisation scheme @xcite .
a simple convergence test is thus obtained by re - running a given simulation with @xmath21 . if the interacting simulation is fully converged , the resulting time evolution of the com must agree in both cases . is independent of interactions @xcite ] _ dynamical fragmentation _ as an example we consider the quantum time evolution of a bright soliton state following ref .
@xcite .
the initial state is prepared as a simple product state ( @xmath1 ) of @xmath22 bosons with @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is a unit length scale , and the time evolution is simulated with mctdhb in the absence of a trap [ i.e. @xmath25 in eq . ] and with @xmath26 .
the time evolution diagrams of the single - particle density with @xmath1 and @xmath27 shown in panels ( a ) and ( b ) of fig .
[ fig : fragmenton ] are consistent with the previously published results ( see fig . 1 case iii in ref .
@xcite ) . the com variance shown in fig .
[ fig : fragmenton](d ) deviates strongly from the exact time evolution and demonstrates that the mctdhb results are unconverged .
attractive bosons prepared in a product initial state corresponding to a mean - field soliton following ref . @xcite .
( a ) ( c ) the time evolution of the single - particle density @xmath28 from mctdhb simulations for different mode numbers . the @xmath27 simulation ( b ) was used in ref .
@xcite as evidence for the dynamical formation of two - humped fragented quantum states called `` fragmentons '' .
( d ) the time evolution of the com variance is compared to the exact result ( thick line ) from a @xmath21 simulation .
, title="fig : " ] + attractive bosons prepared in a product initial state corresponding to a mean - field soliton following ref . @xcite .
( a ) ( c ) the time evolution of the single - particle density @xmath28 from mctdhb simulations for different mode numbers . the @xmath27 simulation ( b ) was used in ref .
@xcite as evidence for the dynamical formation of two - humped fragented quantum states called `` fragmentons '' .
( d ) the time evolution of the com variance is compared to the exact result ( thick line ) from a @xmath21 simulation .
, title="fig : " ] streltsov _ et al . _
@xcite used the simulation result of fig .
[ fig : fragmenton](b ) as evidence for the dynamical formation of two - hump fragmented states .
they argued that the simulation corresponds to an interaction quench where the initial state , which is a gross - pitaevskii - level approximation to a bright matter wave soliton , is suddently subjected to increased interactions . while a splitting into two equal - sized fragments or solitons is energetically not possible in the gross - pitaevskii equation ( @xmath1 ) , a fragmented fock state of the form @xmath29 with overlapping two - hump functions @xmath30
is energetically allowed and can be described within the expansion with @xmath27 modes @xcite .
this argument is consistent with the splitting of the single - particle density into two rapidly parting fragments seen in fig .
[ fig : fragmenton](b ) , but the exact time evolution of the com variance is not . the outward motion of the fragments starting shortly after @xmath31 goes in hand with a rapid increase of the com variance as seen by the thin ( red ) line in [ fig : fragmenton](d ) , growing to almost two orders of magnitude larger than the exact dynamics of @xmath32 at @xmath33 .
this leads us to the conclusion that dynamical fragmentation can not happen in just the way that was described in ref .
@xcite , but it leaves open the question whether other dynamical processes might favour the formation of `` fragmentons '' .
the @xmath34 simulation [ fig .
[ fig : fragmenton](c ) , ( d ) ] , which was not available at the time of publication of @xcite , shows significant changes compared to the @xmath27 case and further demonstrates that two modes are not sufficient to describe the exact quantum dynamics .
careful examination of the early - time dynamics of the com variance in fig .
[ fig : fragmenton](d ) reveals an interesting observation : mctdhb consistently ( for @xmath35 ) predicts an initial decrease of the com variance while the exact @xmath32 increases monotonically .
this illustrates the artificial coupling of the com with the contracting relative coordinates in mctdhb .
however , importantly , the graphs for @xmath27 and @xmath36 are on top of each other until @xmath37 . without the knowledge of the exact com dynamics , judging from the observed succession of mctdhb results under the assumption that the expansion is convergent , one would come to the erroneous conclusion that the observed contraction of the com variance at early times was a reliable and converged result .
the obvious discrepancy with the exact result implies that a conventional convergence check based on observing the absence of change while increasing the mode number @xmath0 fails in this example .
many more modes would be required to converge the expansion , which is unfeasible .
for this reason it is particularly important to be able to solve the com dynamics exactly in order to detect these artefacts of the simulation . in order to better understand the convergence properties of mctdhb for attractive bosons we consider a closely related , exactly solvable , and experimentally realisable scenario where two bosons are initially prepared in the ground state of a harmonic trap with frequency @xmath38 and released from the trap at @xmath39 . simulating the dynamics with up to @xmath40 modes provides a wealth of internal information that can be used to asses the convergence properties of mctdhb .
figure [ fig : comdifg ] shows the results of an unconverged mctdhb simulation with @xmath40 modes .
particles after sudden release from a harmonic trap ; @xmath41 .
( a ) center - of - mass variance exact time evolution @xmath42 $ ] ( full line ) and mctdhb simulation with @xmath40 modes ( broken line ) showing unphysical breathing oscillations . left inset : com wave function before ( @xmath39 , broken line ) and after trap release ( @xmath43 , full line ) .
( b ) eigenvalues of the single - particle density matrix for the mctdhb simulation .
right inset : semi - logarithmic scale showing that the lowest occupancy is below the threshold value @xmath44 for all times.,title="fig : " ] particles after sudden release from a harmonic trap ; @xmath41 .
( a ) center - of - mass variance exact time evolution @xmath42 $ ] ( full line ) and mctdhb simulation with @xmath40 modes ( broken line ) showing unphysical breathing oscillations .
left inset : com wave function before ( @xmath39 , broken line ) and after trap release ( @xmath43 , full line ) .
( b ) eigenvalues of the single - particle density matrix for the mctdhb simulation .
right inset : semi - logarithmic scale showing that the lowest occupancy is below the threshold value @xmath44 for all times.,title="fig : " ] _ natural occupancy criterion _ the relevance of mode functions in the mctdhb expansion is assessed by examining the eigenvalues @xmath45 of the single - particle density matrix , also known as natural occupancies , from @xmath46 , where @xmath47 and eigenvalues are ordered by size @xmath48 .
a rapidly decreasing sequence of eigenvalues in the exact single - particle density matrix is expected to signal convergence of the multi - mode expansion @xcite . since exact results are usually not available , instead it has become popular to draw conclusions from the natural populations obtained from the variational mctdhb simulation .
a commonly used criterion assumes that the simulation is converged if the smallest relative population lies below a threshold valuein fact , near zero eigenvalues are not desirable and may create numerical instabilities , since the mctdhb algorithm relies on inverting the single - particle density matrix @xcite ] and recently @xmath49 has been used for ultra - cold atom experiments @xcite ( @xmath50 in ref .
@xcite ) .
the results shown in fig . [ fig : comdifg ] provide an example where the threshold criterion fails , while comparison of the com dynamics with exact results clearly shows that the simulation is not converged . beyond the possibility that simply a smaller threshold value may need to be set ,
we argue that the logic behind the threshold criterion is flawed because it ignores the possibility that ( a ) a large number of natural orbitals with very small occupancies can still have an important sum contribution to the density matrix , ( b ) the natural occupancy of the @xmath0-th mode may be underestimated by the variational approach , and ( c ) the nonlinear evolution equations of mctdhb may amplify small inaccuracies in the fractional occupancies into large deviations of observables at later times . while good - natured examples were reported in the literature @xcite where these problems do not arise , all three possibilities play a role in the breakdown of the criterion for attractive bosons . specifically , the variational mctdhb calculation of the trapped ground state ( initial state in fig .
[ fig : comdifg ] ) yields a smallest natural occupancy of @xmath51 ( @xmath40 ) compared to the almost four times larger exact value of @xmath52 ( exact ) , supporting concern ( b ) .
it validates point ( a ) that the cumulative contribution of natural orbitals beyond the 10 highest occupied , @xmath53 ( exact ) , is an order of magnitude larger than the mctdhb value for the @xmath54 natural occupancy , confirming that the latter is a poor estimate for the former .
even though these numbers are several orders of magnitudes smaller than unity and a reasonably faithful representation of the true quantum state might be expected , a 23% deviation of the com variance from the exact value indicates a poorly converged result instead . finally re - running the mctdhb simulation with a slightly modified initial state ( optimised to @xmath55 modes ) we indeed find a sensitive dependence on initial conditions as anticipated in point ( c ) where a change in the breathing frequency and amplitude will lead to completely different values of @xmath32 after a few periods .
particles as a function of the length - scale ratio @xmath56 .
the top panel shows the com variance @xmath32 and the variance of the single - particle density @xmath57 from exact and simulated mctdhb results . for comparison also the soliton variance @xmath58
is shown .
this relative motion length scale is clearly seen to influence the variational @xmath34 result in the limit of weak trapping potential . ]
_ role of the particle number _ it is instructive to consider the convergence properties of mctdhb in dependence of the available parameters .
in contrast to the repulsive bose gas , which has a dimensionless interaction parameter @xcite , the interaction strength scales out for untrapped attractive bosons and the only remaining dimensionless parameter is the particle number @xmath5 @xcite .
a second dimensionless parameter is available in a harmonic trap by comparing relevant length scales .
the ratio @xmath56 allows for a meaningful comparison of results between varying particle number and is thus used for comparing ground state calculations of attractive bosons in figs .
[ fig : r2r2n2 ] and [ fig : r2r2n2right ] . here
, @xmath59 is the ground state com variance in the harmonic trap and @xmath60 $ ] is the variance of the soliton particle density @xmath61)$ ] obtained for the untrapped ground state with @xmath1 @xcite , a characteristic length scale determined by particle interactions .
the mctdhb results for the variance of the single - particle density @xmath57 and com variance @xmath32 of figs .
[ fig : r2r2n2 ] and [ fig : r2r2n2right ] show good agreement with exact results only for @xmath62 , which is a weakly - interacting or strong - trap limit where the harmonic potential dominates all length scales of the quantum state .
as soon as the interacting length scale @xmath63 becomes comparable to or smaller than the com length scale , significant deviations from exact results occur for the numerically obtained @xmath57 and @xmath32 . in the weak - trap regime @xmath64 ,
the deviation can become arbitrarily large .
so could the failure of the mctdhb approximation be detected by internal criteria , i.e. without comparing to exact results ?
this appears possible for @xmath65 particles , where the threshold of @xmath44 for the lowest occupancy would signal un - converged results for @xmath66 . inspecting
the sequence of numerical results with increasing @xmath0 further indicates that convergence is very slow @xcite .
the situation is far worse with @xmath67 particles , where increasing @xmath0 further may not be an option due to limited computational resources . , which changes scaling from @xmath68 for @xmath27 to @xmath69 for @xmath70 , where @xmath71 depends weakly on @xmath5 with @xmath72 .
] analysis of the natural occpancies provides the consistent picture of an almost pure bose - einstein condensate , with the least occupancy well below the threshold .
further , the main observable @xmath57 displays little variation between @xmath1 and @xmath34 on the scale of fig . [ fig : r2r2n2right ] and clearly shows the same trend as function of @xmath56 .
we are thus led to the conclusion that the detection of spurious results from mctdhb is much more difficult and may even be impossible without exact results to compare with , for particle numbers of the order of 100 or larger .
why is mctdhb unable to capture the physics of the weak trap regime while the hartree approximation ( @xmath1 ) is known to reproduce the exact , untrapped ground state energy to leading order for large @xmath5 @xcite , and previous work has found mctdhb to converge nicely at large @xmath5 @xcite ?
the hartree approximation fails to describe the delocalisation of the com in the untrapped limit @xcite because the variational principle , conditioned to minimise the total energy , finds the best compromise in localising the single available mode function @xmath73 . when a finite number @xmath2 is used in the multi - mode expansion
, it is still energetically advantageous to localise the mode functions .
indeed , an infinite number of mode functions is needed to represent a state with delocalised com but bound relative motion @xcite . with @xmath67 bosons .
the shaded region depicts the known limits for @xmath57 : @xmath74 @xcite . ] in conclusion , we have demonstrated how easily obtainable , accurate results for the com variance were useful in detecting unconverged results and in demonstrating the failure of several popular internal convergence checks of mctdhb .
the possible dynamical creation of `` fragmentons '' is re - opened for discussion as numerical evidence in ref .
@xcite turned out spurious .
our findings call for a systematic re - evaluation of the available convergence criteria for numerical quantum dynamics and what is required to claim `` numerically exact '' results @xcite
. the comparison of com dynamics with independent , exact results may be useful for other numerical methods of quantum dynamics and is available in any spatial dimensions and for any particle statistics as long as external potentials are at most harmonic .
the data presented in this paper will be available online @xcite .
we thank l.d .
carr , b. gertjerenken , m.f .
andersen and w.p .
reinhardt for discussions .
this work has been supported by the marsden fund of new zealand ( contract number uoo1320 ) and the uk engineering and physical sciences research council ( grant no .
ep / l010844/1 ) .
47ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.80.885 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s11467 - 011 - 0232-x [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1742-5468/2004/i=04/a=p04005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0009 - 2614(90)87014-i [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s0370 - 1573(99)00047 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.71.012712 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.240404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.77.033613 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _
( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.123.1242 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.aop.2011.03.003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1126/science.1071021 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nature747 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.112.060401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.113.013002 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/nphys3135 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.93.021604 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s1296 - 2147(01)01183 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1704156 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.11.265 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.130401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.80.043616 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.240401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4821350 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.81.938 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.91.063613 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.89.023602 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.92.043627 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.91.033611 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1367 - 2630/17/8/083024 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.463007 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.86.063606 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 4075/42/4/044018 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.103.220601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1073/pnas.1201345109 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) , @noop ( ) @noop `` , '' ( ) \doibase 10.1023/a:1018705520999 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.88.043601 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.82.023619 [ * * , ( ) ] * supplemental materials : center - of - mass motion as a sensitive convergence test for variational multi - mode quantum dynamics * jayson g. cosme@xmath75 , christoph weiss@xmath76 , and joachim brand@xmath75 + @xmath75_new zealand institute for advanced study , dodd - walls centre for photonics and quantum technology , centre for theoretical chemistry and physics , massey university , private bag 102904 , north shore , auckland 0745 , new zealand _ @xmath76_joint quantum centre ( jqc ) durham newcastle , department of physics , durham university , durham dh1 3le , united kingdom _ |
a _ partition _ of a number @xmath4 is a sequence @xmath5 such that @xmath6 and @xmath7 . to indicate that @xmath8 is a partition of @xmath2 we write @xmath9 .
let @xmath1 be the number of partitions of @xmath2 . by our definition
, @xmath10 is the unique partition of @xmath11 .
the problem of finding asymptotic estimates for @xmath1 was introduced , and one might reasonably say , solved , by the famous paper of hardy
ramanujan @xcite . as well as
their exact formula for @xmath1 , proved as the original application of the circle - method , their paper also contains several weaker results proved using less sophisticated analytic methods ; for example , that @xmath12 where @xmath13 .
the only time they refer to using combinatorial arguments to obtain lower and upper bounds for @xmath1 is in a footnote in 2.1 , which suggests the strongest such bounds they could prove were of the form @xmath14 our first aim is this paper is to improve on this . in 2 we introduce g. d. james abacus notation for partitions and use it to establish an important bijection on partitions ( see 2.2 ) . in
3 we use this bijection to show that for every @xmath15 there exists a constant @xmath16 such that @xmath17 despite the appearance of an ` @xmath18 ' in this inequality , the proof of is almost entirely combinatorial .
the closest competing result in the literature is due to erds , who gives at the start of @xcite a short elementary proof that @xmath19 where , as before , @xmath13 .
erds result is of course significantly sharper than , but this improvement comes at the cost of a greater contribution from analysis . for instance , the reader may already have correctly guessed that the identity @xmath20 is needed . in this context
, we mention that peter neumann ( oxford algebra kinderseminar , january 2003 ) has asked whether there is a combinatorial proof that there exists a constant @xmath21 such that @xmath22 for all @xmath23 . while comes tantalisingly close , the ideas behind it do not appear quite powerful enough to solve his problem .
our second aim is to show that the partition bijection given in 2.2 may be used to solve several other problems in the enumeration of partitions . in our first application
we give a very short proof of an identity originally due to gauss ( see ( * ? ? ?
* end of 3 ) ) : @xmath24 our main application concerns a result of erds . in the main part of @xcite , erds uses the same underlying idea as he used to prove , and some more lengthy ( but still elementary ) analysis , to prove that there exists a constant @xmath25 such that @xmath26 it was already known from the work of hardy and ramanujan @xcite that , but erds methods were not sufficiently powerful to prove this .
later however , newman @xcite gave an elementary proof that if holds for _ some _ constant @xmath27 , then necessarily @xmath28 . in
4 we use our bijection to give an alternative proof of this result . in length it is comparable with newman s , but it requires considerably less knowledge of analysis , and the motivation is perhaps more apparent . in 5
we conclude by showing how the abacus may be applied to give exact asymptotic estimates for two other classes of partitions , namely self - conjugate partitions , and partitions with distinct parts .
let @xmath8 be a partition of @xmath2 . a @xmath29-_hook _ in @xmath8 consists of two adjacent nodes in the young diagram of @xmath8 whose removal leaves the diagram of a partition of @xmath30 .
by repeatedly removing @xmath29-hooks from @xmath8 one obtains the _ @xmath29-core _ of @xmath8 . for example , the @xmath29-core of @xmath31 is @xmath32 , obtained after removing the five @xmath29-hooks indicated in the diagram below .
[ 0.5]-core of @xmath31.,title="fig : " ] in this diagram , two of the three @xmath29-hooks of the original partition are shown by bold lines .
the remaining lines are @xmath29-hooks of partitions obtained _ en route _ to the @xmath29-core .
it is not obvious that the @xmath29-core of a partition is independent of the manner in which one removes its @xmath29-hooks .
this , and much else besides , can be seen very clearly if we represent partitions using g. d. james abacus ( see ( * ? ? ? * ch . 2 , 2627 ) ) . to make this
article self - contained we briefly recall how to operate this piece of apparatus .
( we describe only the ` binary ' @xmath29-runner abacus . )
[ [ section ] ] let @xmath8 be a partition of @xmath2 . starting in the southwest corner of the young diagram of @xmath8 walk along its rim , heading towards the northeast corner . for each step
right , put a space , indicated @xmath33 , and for each step up , put a bead , indicated @xmath34 .
for example , the partition @xmath31 shown above has the sequence @xmath33@xmath34@xmath33@xmath33@xmath34@xmath34@xmath33@xmath33@xmath33@xmath34 .
it will be seen shortly that it is useful to allow such a sequence to begin with any number of beads , and to finish with any number of spaces these must be stripped off before the partition is recovered .
one then arranges the sequence in two columns , known as the _ runners _ of the abacus . for instance @xmath31
is represented by @xmath35 we call this an _ abacus _ display for the partition @xmath8 .
one sees that @xmath29-hooks in @xmath8 correspond to beads with a space above them , and that an abacus display for the partition obtained by removing a given @xmath29-hook is obtained by sliding the corresponding bead one space up its runner .
( it is at this point that our convention about initial beads and final spaces is needed . )
the @xmath29-core of @xmath8 is obtained by pushing all the beads up as far as they will go . to reconstruct the partition @xmath8 from an abacus display for its @xmath29-core we need to know the number of positions down each bead
must be moved .
for example , given the abacus display @xmath36 for the @xmath29-core of @xmath31 , we recover the original partition by moving the bead on the first runner down by @xmath29 positions , and on the second runner moving the lowest bead down by @xmath29 positions and the next lowest down by @xmath37 position .
we record this information in a pair of partitions , @xmath38 , known as the @xmath29-_quotient _ of @xmath8 ; here @xmath39 has @xmath29-quotient @xmath40 .
note that the total number of nodes in @xmath41 and @xmath42 is equal to the total number of @xmath29-hooks removed , so @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the @xmath29-core of @xmath8 .
[ [ section-1 ] ] given a partition @xmath8 we may , by adding a bead at the start if necessary , choose an abacus display for @xmath8 so that the @xmath29-core of @xmath8 has at least as many beads on the second runner as the first . with this convention to fix the order of the partitions in the @xmath29-quotient of @xmath8
, the correspondence just described between partitions and pairs @xmath45 of @xmath29-cores and @xmath29-quotients is bijective .
moreover , it is easy to see that any @xmath29-core is of the form @xmath46 for some @xmath47 .
therefore we have shown that , if @xmath48 is the number of pairs @xmath38 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are partitions with @xmath49 , then @xmath50 where the sum is over all the non - negative integers @xmath51 such that @xmath52 is a non - negative even integer .
for example , @xmath53 as it is easy to calculate @xmath48 given @xmath54 for @xmath55 using the formula @xmath56 , gives us a recurrence relation for the values of the partition function .
we exploit this recurrence in 3 and 4 below .
[ [ section-2 ] ] we now prove gauss identity .
let @xmath57 be the ordinary generating function for @xmath58 , @xmath59 since each node in the @xmath29-quotient of a partition contributes two nodes to the original partition , our bijection shows that @xmath60 by , this is equivalent to gauss identity .
it should be said that this is not the first combinatorial proof of gauss identity . in @xcite
, andrews gives a bijective proof ( in the style of franklin s proof of euler s pentagonal number theorem ) that : @xmath61 replacing @xmath62 with @xmath63 gives .
another strategy is to first give a combinatorial proof of jacobi s triple product identity , as done for example in ; from jacobi s identity , it only takes a simple specialisation to get .
[ [ section-3 ] ] we conclude this section by remarking that the bijection we have described may be thought as being between the set of all partitions , and the set of all oriented binary trees with vertices labelled by members of @xmath64 , with the property that if two leaves are connected to the same node , they are not both labelled by 0 . for example , the @xmath29-core and @xmath29-quotient of @xmath31 may be represented by the diagram below . here
the upper ` @xmath29 ' records the number of rows ( or columns ) in the @xmath29-core of @xmath31 . iterating the process , we find that @xmath31 is represented by the oriented binary tree shown below .
the corresponding formulation of gauss identity is the attractive @xmath65
by counting only partitions of @xmath66 with @xmath29-core @xmath10 and @xmath29-quotient @xmath67 where both @xmath41 and @xmath42 are partitions of @xmath68 , we obtain the inequality @xmath69 .
an immediate consequence is that @xmath70 given @xmath71 , we may choose a power of @xmath72 , say @xmath73 , such that @xmath74 . since @xmath58 is an increasing function , @xmath75 , and
so @xmath76 it seems striking that such a simple argument gives a lower bound which , while far from optimal , is still of the right asymptotic form .
marti ( see ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 3.1 ) ) has shown that , with a little more analysis , and the use of a computer to check small cases , one can obtain the significantly stronger lower bound @xmath77 the next lemma shows how our bijection may be applied to give an upper bound .
[ lemma : fbound ] suppose that @xmath78 is an increasing function such that @xmath79 and @xmath80 then @xmath81 for all @xmath82 .
we work by induction on @xmath2 .
using we have @xmath83 where we adopt the convention that @xmath84 , and similarly for @xmath85 .
hence @xmath86 which completes the inductive step .
the reader will see that we have been very crude in taking @xmath2 as an upper bound for the number of summands in there appears to be no advantage in being any more precise at this point
. given any @xmath15 there is a constant @xmath16 depending only on @xmath18 such that @xmath87 without loss of generality , assume that @xmath88 .
let @xmath89 .
we shall prove that when @xmath90 is large enough , @xmath91 satisfies the conditions of lemma [ lemma : fbound ] .
setting @xmath92 , we have @xmath93 where we used the inequality @xmath94 which is valid for @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
therefore the only condition we must satisfy is that @xmath97 or , equivalently , that @xmath98 clearly this will hold provided @xmath90 is sufficient large .
in this section we assume erds result that @xmath99 for some constant @xmath25 , and prove that @xmath100 . we shall also need erds upper bound that @xmath101 for all @xmath82 .
( here , as always , @xmath102 . )
recall that @xmath48 denotes the number of pairs @xmath38 of partitions such that @xmath103 .
we first show that it follows from erds result that @xmath104 we then use the bijection described in 2.2 to deduce that @xmath105 comparing this with @xmath106 shows that @xmath100 .
( the only reason for taking @xmath107 rather than a general @xmath2 in is that this choice lead to some simplifications in the expressions we encounter ; there is of course no need to prove anything stronger . )
[ [ section-4 ] ] all the results in this section and 5 are proved using the following simple lemma , whose proof requires only the basic integral @xmath108 [ lemma : gen ] if @xmath109 then @xmath110 let @xmath111 stand for the sum on the left - hand - side . since @xmath112 it is sufficient to prove that @xmath113 this is not hard . on the one hand , @xmath114 and on the other ,
@xmath115 which tends to @xmath11 as @xmath116 .
hence @xmath117 has the claimed limit .
[ [ section-5 ] ] we start by proving . if holds when @xmath2 is even then , by a simple sandwiching argument , it must hold for all @xmath2 .
we may therefore assume that @xmath118 , in which case becomes @xmath119 let @xmath15 be given .
choose @xmath120 so that @xmath121 we first obtain an upper estimate for @xmath122
. for @xmath123 set @xmath124 so we have @xmath125 .
we shall see that as @xmath68 tends to infinity , the contribution of @xmath126 to @xmath122 dominates , no matter what the choice of @xmath127 .
in fact , it follows from erds bound and the inequality @xmath128 that @xmath129 and so @xmath130 we now look at the main contribution .
provided @xmath131 and @xmath132 , the smallest @xmath2 for which @xmath1 appears in @xmath126 is at least @xmath120 . hence if these conditions hold , @xmath133 it now follows from lemma [ lemma : gen ] , applied with @xmath134 , @xmath135 , that @xmath136 finally , let @xmath137 to get @xmath138 we now obtain a lower estimate for @xmath122 . by taking @xmath127 sufficiently small
we may ensure that @xmath139 for this choice of @xmath127 we have , by the same manipulations as before , @xmath140 the second term on the left - hand - side compensates for the double counting of the contribution of @xmath141 to @xmath122 ; as @xmath142 for @xmath143 , this term vanishes in the limit .
as before , it follows from lemma [ lemma : gen ] that @xmath144 now let @xmath145 .
this completes the proof of .
[ [ section-6 ] ] it follows from that @xmath146 where the sum is over all non - negative integers @xmath51 such that @xmath147 is a non - negative even number .
we may estimate this sum using the same ideas as 4.2 .
we start with a lower estimate .
the contribution from those @xmath148 mod @xmath72 is at least the contribution from those @xmath149 mod @xmath72 , so we have @xmath150 for any @xmath127 such that @xmath123 .
let @xmath15 be given .
by we may choose @xmath120 so that @xmath151 take @xmath143 .
choose @xmath127 sufficiently small that @xmath152 for this choice of @xmath127 we have @xmath153 it now follows from lemma [ lemma : gen ] , applied with @xmath154 , @xmath135 , that @xmath155 now let @xmath145 . to complete the proof of we must also show that @xmath156 in order to apply the method used in 4.2 we need a uniform upper bound for @xmath48 ; the relatively crude estimate @xmath157 given by is sufficient for this purpose .
as no other new ideas are needed we shall omit the remaining details of the proof .
in this final section we give asymptotic formulae for the number of self - conjugate partitions , and for the number of partitions with distinct parts . as corollaries ,
we get precise estimates for the proportions of such partitions .
we omit the details of the analytic arguments required , as they are of the same nature as those already seen in 4 . recall
that if @xmath158 is a partition of @xmath2 then the conjugate partition @xmath159 is defined by @xmath160 ; the diagram of @xmath159 is obtained from that of @xmath8 by reflecting it in its leading diagonal .
let @xmath161 be the number of self - conjugate partitions of @xmath2 .
given an abacus display for a partition @xmath8 , one obtains a display for the conjugate partition @xmath159 by reading the sequence of beads and spaces from right to left , and then replacing @xmath34 with @xmath33 and _ vice versa_. for example , @xmath31 and @xmath162 have the abacus displays : @xmath163 respectively .
if @xmath8 is self - conjugate then the sequence of spaces and beads corresponding to @xmath8 has an even number of entries .
it follows that if @xmath8 has @xmath29-quotient @xmath38 then @xmath164 .
this gives us a bijection between self - conjugate partitions of @xmath2 and pairs @xmath165 where @xmath44 is a @xmath29-core ( and so of a known shape ) and @xmath41 is a partition of @xmath166 .
( this bijection is well known , see for instance ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6.2.2 ) . we leave it to the reader to work out the connection with the labelled binary trees of 2.4 . )
the corresponding numerical result is @xmath167 where the sum is over all the non - negative integers @xmath51 such that @xmath52 is a non - negative integer divisible by @xmath72 . by the same techniques used in 4.3
, one finds that @xmath168 it follows that the proportion of self - conjugate partitions satisfies @xmath169 thus of the @xmath1 partitions of @xmath2 , approximately @xmath170 are self - conjugate .
let @xmath171 be the number of partitions of @xmath2 with distinct parts . here
the numerical result we require is @xmath172 where the sum is over all the non - negative integers @xmath51 such that @xmath52 is a non - negative even integer . for a combinatorial proof of this result ,
see proposition 5.2 in @xcite . as an alternative ,
note that the generating function for @xmath171 is @xmath173 hence by , @xmath174 comparing coefficients of @xmath175 gives the required result . by the same techniques used in 4.3
, one finds that @xmath176 it follows that the proportion of partitions with distinct parts satisfies @xmath177 | in 2003 , marti showed that one could use the machinery of @xmath0-cores and @xmath0-quotients of partitions to establish lower bounds for @xmath1 , the number of partitions of @xmath2 . in this paper
we explore these ideas in the case @xmath3 , using them to give a largely combinatorial proof of an effective upper bound on @xmath1 , and to prove asymptotic formulae for the number of self - conjugate partitions , and the number of partitions with distinct parts . in a further application
we give a combinatorial proof of an identity originally due to gauss . |
dark matter remains one of the most important unsolved problems in contemporary physics .
astronomical observations indicate that the energy density of dark matter exceeds that of ordinary matter by a factor of five @xcite .
extensive laboratory searches for weakly interacting massive particle ( wimp ) dark matter through scattering - off - nuclei experiments have failed to produce a strong positive result to date , see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite , which has spurred significant interest of late in searching for alternate well - motivated forms of dark matter , such as ultralight ( sub - ev mass ) spin-0 particles that form either an oscillating classical field or topological defects , see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite .
the idea that the fundamental constants of nature might vary with time can be traced as far back as the large numbers hypothesis of dirac , who hypothesised that the gravitational constant @xmath1 might be proportional to the reciprocal of the age of the universe @xcite .
more contemporary theories , which predict a variation of the fundamental constants on cosmological timescales , typically invoke a ( nearly ) massless underlying dark energy - type field , see , e.g. , the review @xcite and the references therein .
most recently , a new model for the cosmological evolution of the fundamental constants of nature has been proposed in ref .
@xcite , in which the interaction of an oscillating classical scalar dark matter field with ordinary matter via quadratic interactions produces both ` slow ' linear - in - time drifts and oscillating - in - time variations of the fundamental constants @xcite .
topological defects , which are stable , extended - in - space forms of dark matter that consist of light scalar dark matter fields stabilised by a self - interaction potential @xcite and which interact with ordinary matter , produce transient - in - time variations of the fundamental constants @xcite . the oscillating - in - time and transient - in - time variations of the fundamental constants produced by scalar dark matter can be sought for in the laboratory using high - precision measurements , which include atomic clocks @xcite , highly - charged ions @xcite , molecules @xcite and nuclear clocks @xcite , in which two transition frequencies are compared over time . instead of comparing two transition frequencies over time , we may instead compare a photon wavelength with an interferometer arm length , in order to search for variations of the fundamental constants @xcite ( see also @xcite for some other applications ) . in the present work ,
we outline new laser interferometer measurements to search for variation of the electromagnetic fine - structure constant and particle masses ( including a non - zero photon mass ) .
we propose a strontium optical lattice clock
silicon single - crystal cavity interferometer as a novel small - scale platform for these new measurements .
the small - scale hydrogen maser cryogenic sapphire oscillator system @xcite and large - scale gravitational - wave detectors , such as ligo - virgo @xcite , geo600 @xcite , tama300 @xcite , elisa @xcite or the fermilab holometer @xcite , can also be used as platforms for some of our newly proposed measurements .
unless explicitly indicated otherwise , we employ the natural units @xmath2 in the present work .
alterations in the electromagnetic fine - structure constant @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the electron charge , @xmath5 is the reduced planck constant and @xmath6 is the photon speed , or particle masses ( including a non - zero photon mass @xmath7 ) produce alterations in the accumulated phase of the light beam inside an interferometer @xmath8 , since an atomic transition frequency @xmath9 and length of a solid @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the number of atoms and @xmath12 is the bohr radius ( @xmath13 is the electron mass ) , both depend on the fundamental constants and particle masses .
alterations in the accumulated phase can be expressed in terms of the sensitivity coefficients @xmath14 , which are defined by : @xmath15 where the sum runs over all relevant fundamental constants @xmath16 ( except photon mass ) .
the sensitivity coefficients depend on the specific measurement that is performed . in order to define the variation of dimensionful parameters , such as @xmath13
, we assume that such variations are due to the interactions of dark matter with ordinary matter , see , e.g. , ref . @xcite .
the sensitivity coefficients , which we derive below in sections [ sec:3 ] and [ sec:4 ] , are for single - arm interferometers , but are readily carried over to the case of two - arm michelson - type interferometers , for which the observable quantity is the phase difference @xmath17 between the two arms , as we illustrate with a couple of examples in section [ sec:5 ] .
one intuitively expects that multiple reflections should enhance observable effects due to variation of the fundamental constants by the effective mean number of passages @xmath18 .
this can be readily verified by the following simple derivation . for multiple reflections of a continuous light source that forms a standing wave ( in the absence of variation of the fundamental constants ) , we sum over all possible number of reflections @xmath19 : @xmath20 = \frac{1}{\exp \left ( \kappa - i \phi \right ) - 1 } , \ ] ] where @xmath21 is the attenuation factor that accounts for the loss of light amplitude after a single to - and - back passage along the length of the arm , and @xmath22 ( @xmath23 is an integer ) is the phase accumulated by the light beam in a single to - and - back passage along the length of the arm . for a large effective mean number of passages , @xmath24 , and for sufficiently small deviations in the accumulated phase , @xmath25 , the sum in eq .
( [ app - a_derivation1 ] ) can be written as : @xmath26 & \simeq n_{\textrm{eff } } \exp \left(i n_{\textrm{eff } } \cdot \delta \phi \right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] from which it is evident that the effects of small variations in the accumulated phase are enhanced by the factor @xmath18 .
variation of @xmath0 and particle masses alters the accumulated phase through alteration of @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
there are four main classes of experimental configurations to consider , depending on whether the frequency of light inside an interferometer is determined by a specific atomic transition ( i.e. , when the high - finesse cavity length is stabilised to an atomic transition ) or by the length of a resonator ( i.e. , when the laser is stabilised to a high - finesse cavity ) , and whether the interferometer arm length is allowed to vary freely ( i.e. , allowed to depend on the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) or its fluctuations are deliberately shielded ( i.e. , the arm length is made independent of the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors , e.g. , through the use of a multiple - pendulum mirror system ) .
we consider each of these configurations in turn .
the simplest case is when the frequency of light inside an interferometer is determined by an optical atomic transition frequency and the interferometer arm length is allowed to vary freely ( i.e. , allowed to depend on the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) . a strontium clock
silicon cavity interferometer in its standard mode of operation falls into this category . in this case , the atomic transition wavelength and arm length are compared directly : @xmath27 where the optical atomic transition frequency @xmath9 is proportional to the atomic unit of frequency @xmath28 .
variation of @xmath0 thus gives rise to the following phase shift : @xmath29 we note that the effect of variation of @xmath0 already appears at the non - relativistic level in eq .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_1 ] ) , with the corresponding sensitivity coefficient @xmath30 . for systems consisting of light elements ,
the relativistic corrections to this sensitivity coefficient are small and can be neglected .
this is in stark contrast to optical clock comparison experiments , for which @xmath31 in the non - relativistic approximation and the contributions to @xmath32 arise solely from relativistic corrections @xcite . for a strontium clock
silicon cavity interferometer , which operates on the @xmath33sr @xmath34 @xmath35 @xmath36 transition ( @xmath37 nm ) and for which the cavity length is @xmath38 m @xcite , the phase shift in eq .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_1 ] ) for a single to - and - back passage of the light beam is : @xmath39 for comparison , in a large - scale gravitational - wave detector of length @xmath40 km and operating on a typical atomic optical transition frequency , the phase shift for a single to - and - back passage of the light beam is : @xmath41 as noted in section [ sec : theory ] , multiple reflections enhance the coefficients in eqs .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_1a ] ) and ( [ sensitivity_coefficient_1b ] ) by the effective mean number of passages @xmath18 , which depends on the reflectivity properties of the mirrors used . for large - scale interferometers ,
this enhancement factor is @xmath42 . for small - scale interferometers with highly - reflective mirrors
, this enhancement factor can be considerably larger : @xmath43 .
another possible system in this category is the hydrogen maser cryogenic sapphire oscillator system , which operates on the @xmath44h ground state hyperfine transition : @xmath45 \left [ \mu_p \frac{m_e}{m_p } \right ] , \ ] ] where @xmath46 is the relativistic casimir factor and @xmath47 is the dimensionless magnetic dipole moment of the proton in units of the nuclear magneton . in this case , changes in the measured phase have the following dependence on changes in the fundamental constants : @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the averaged light quark mass , and where we have used the calculated values @xmath50 @xcite and @xmath51 @xcite .
if one performs two simultaneous interferometry experiments with two different transition lines , using the same set of mirrors , then one may search for variations of the fundamental constants associated with changes in the atomic transition frequencies : @xmath52 in particular , note that shifts in the arm lengths ( due to variation of the fundamental constants or undesired effects , such as seismic noise or tidal effects ) cancel in eq .
( [ seismic_shield ] )
. we also note that atomic clock transition frequencies may also be compared by locking lasers to the atomic transitions and using phase coherent optical mixing and frequency comb techniques to measure the laser frequency difference / ratio .
if fluctuations in the arm length are deliberately shielded ( i.e. , the arm length is made independent of the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors , e.g. , through the use of a multiple - pendulum mirror system ) , but @xmath9 is still determined by an atomic transition frequency , then changes in the measured phase @xmath53 have the following dependence on changes in the fundamental constants : @xmath54 when a laser is locked to a resonator mode determined by the length of the resonator , @xmath9 is determined by the length of the resonator , which changes if the fundamental constants change . in the non - relativistic limit ,
the wavelength and arm length ( as well as the size of earth ) have the same dependence on the bohr radius , and so there are no observable effects if changes of the fundamental constants are slow ( adiabatic ) and if the interferometer arm length is allowed to vary freely ( i.e. , allowed to depend on the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) .
indeed , this may be viewed as a simple change in the measurement units .
transient effects due to the passage of topological defects may still produce effects , since changes in @xmath9 and @xmath55 may occur at different times .
the sensitivity of laser interferometry to non - transient effects is determined by relativistic corrections , which we estimate as follows .
the size of an atom @xmath56 is determined by the classical turning point of an external atomic electron .
assuming that the centrifugal term @xmath57 is small at large distances , we obtain @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is the energy of the external electron and @xmath60 is the net charge of the atomic species ( for a neutral atom , @xmath61 ) .
this gives the relation : @xmath62 .
the single - particle relativistic correction to the energy in a many - electron atomic species is given by @xcite : @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the energy of the external atomic electron , @xmath65 is its angular momentum , @xmath66 is the nuclear charge , and @xmath67 is the effective principal quantum number .
variation of @xmath0 thus gives rise to the following phase shift : @xmath68 \frac{\delta \alpha}{\alpha } .\ ] ] here @xmath69 is the atomic number of the atoms that make up the solid spacer between the mirrors of the resonator , while @xmath70 is the atomic number of the atoms that make up the arm .
note that the sensitivity coefficient depends particularly strongly on the factor @xmath71 .
@xmath72 for light atoms and may be of the order of unity in heavy atoms . if fluctuations in the arm length are deliberately shielded ( i.e. , the arm length is made independent of the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) and @xmath9 is determined by the length of the resonator , then changes in the measured phase @xmath73 have the following dependence on changes in the fundamental constants : @xmath74 a large - scale gravitational - wave detector ( such as ligo , virgo , geo600 or tama300 ) in its standard mode of operation falls into this category .
a non - zero photon mass alters the accumulated phase through alteration of @xmath9 , @xmath75 ( where @xmath56 is the atomic radius ) and @xmath6 . in particular ,
if a non - zero photon mass is generated due to the interaction of photons with slowly moving dark matter ( @xmath76 ) , then the energy and momentum of the photons are approximately conserved and the photon speed changes according to : @xmath77 the effects of a non - zero photon mass in atoms are more subtle . the potential of an atomic electron changes from coulomb to yukawa - type : @xmath78 where the sum runs over all remaining atomic electrons . for @xmath79 , the leading term of the corresponding perturbation reads ( we omit the constant terms , which do not alter the atomic transition frequencies and wavefunctions ) : @xmath80 , \ ] ] which for a neutral atom takes the asymptotic forms : @xmath81 in the semiclassical approximation , it is straightforward to confirm that the dominant contribution to the expectation value of the operator ( [ yukawa_perturbation ] ) comes from large distances , @xmath82 , where the external electron sees an effective charge of @xmath83 .
therefore , the shift in an atomic energy level @xmath84 is simply : @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the expectation value of the radius operator for state @xmath84 .
typically , @xmath87 . assuming that the perturbation ( [ yukawa_perturbation ] ) is adiabatic and that the the dominant contribution to the matrix elements @xmath88 comes from large distances , application of time - independent perturbation theory gives the following shift in the size of the atomic orbit for state @xmath84 : @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the static dipole polarisability of state @xmath84 .
static dipole polarisabilities for the electronic ground states of neutral atoms range from @xmath91 @xmath92 in hydrogen to @xmath93 @xmath92 in caesium @xcite .
if @xmath9 is determined by an atomic transition frequency and the interferometer arm length is allowed to vary freely ( i.e. , allowed to depend on the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) , then a non - zero photon mass produces the following changes in the measured phase @xmath94 : @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the difference in the orbital size between the final and initial states involved in the radiative atomic transition , and @xmath97 is the static dipole polarisability of the atoms that make up the arm .
the three separate contributions in eq .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_1b ] ) scale roughly in the ratio @xmath98 , respectively , meaning that the contribution from the change in the photon speed dominates .
if fluctuations in the arm length are deliberately shielded ( i.e. , the arm length is made independent of the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) , but @xmath9 is still determined by an atomic transition frequency , then a non - zero photon mass produces the following changes in the measured phase @xmath99 : @xmath100 where we again note that the contribution from the change in the photon speed dominates . if @xmath9 is determined by the length of the resonator and the interferometer arm length is allowed to vary freely ( i.e. , allowed to depend on the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) , then a non - zero photon mass produces the following changes in the measured phase @xmath101 : @xmath102 here @xmath103 is the static dipole polarisability of the atoms that make up the solid spacer between the mirrors of the resonator . the phase shift in eq .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_2b ] ) is suppressed by the factor @xmath104 in the static limit ( compare with eqs .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_1b ] ) and ( [ sensitivity_coefficient_4b ] ) above ) . however , for time - dependent effects , the phase shift can be significantly larger ( see the examples in section [ sec:5 ] ) .
if fluctuations in the arm length are deliberately shielded ( i.e. , the arm length is made independent of the length of the solid spacer between the mirrors ) and @xmath9 is determined by the length of the resonator , then a non - zero photon mass produces the following changes in the measured phase @xmath105 : @xmath106 similarly to eq .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_2b ] ) , the phase shift in eq .
( [ sensitivity_coefficient_3b ] ) is also suppressed by the factor @xmath104 in the static limit .
however , we again note that the phase shift can be significantly larger for time - dependent effects ( see section [ sec:5 ] ) .
oscillating classical dark matter exhibits not only temporal coherence @xcite , but also spatial coherence , with a coherence length given by : @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is the dark matter particle mass , and a virial ( root - mean - square ) speed of @xmath109 is typical in our local galactic neighbourhood .
our solar system travels through the milky way ( and hence relative to galactic dark matter ) at a comparable speed @xmath110 .
an oscillating scalar dark matter field takes the form : @xmath111 meaning that measurements performed on length scales @xmath112 are sensitive to dark matter - induced effects that arise from differences in the spatial phase term @xmath113 at two or more points . ) .
, width=226 ] as a specific example , we consider measurements performed using a large - scale gravitational - wave detector with equal arm lengths that are deliberately shielded from fluctuations , @xmath114 , and with the emitted photon wavelength determined by the length of the resonator . since we are considering slowly moving dark matter ( @xmath76 ) , changes in the wavelength of the travelling photon are related to changes in @xmath6 by : @xmath115 ^ 2 / 2 \omega^2 $ ] , where the interaction between the photon field and @xmath116 may be interpreted as the varying photon mass : @xmath117 ^ 2 = ( m_\gamma)_{\textrm{max}}^2 { \cos^2 \left ( m_\phi t - m_\phi \left<{\boldsymbol{v}}\right > \cdot { \boldsymbol{r } } \right ) } $ ] . for the simplest case when the dark matter is incident directly onto one of the detector arms as shown in fig . [
fig : interferometer_spatial_coherence ] , the shift in the accumulated phase difference between the two arms is given by : @xmath118 dz , \ ] ] and to leading order we find : @xmath119 the shift in the accumulated phase difference between the two arms in eq .
( [ ligo_example_b ] ) is suppressed by the factor @xmath120 .
topological defect dark matter is intrinsically coherent , both temporally and spatially . as a specific example
, we again consider measurements performed using a large - scale gravitational - wave detector with equal arm lengths that are deliberately shielded from fluctuations and with the emitted photon wavelength determined by the length of the resonator .
for the case of a 2d domain wall with a gaussian cross - sectional profile of root - mean - square width @xmath121 and which travels slowly ( @xmath122 ) in the geometry shown in fig .
[ fig : interferometer_spatial_coherence ] , the interaction between the photon field and @xmath116 may be interpreted as the varying photon mass : @xmath123 ^ 2 = ( m_\gamma)_{\textrm{max}}^2 { \exp[-(z + vt)^2 / d^2 ] } $ ] .
calculating the shift in the accumulated phase difference between the two arms , eq .
( [ ligo_example_a ] ) , we find to leading order : @xmath124 \right .
\notag \\
& - \left .
\frac{\sqrt{\pi}d}{2l } \left[\textrm{erf } \left ( \frac{l + tv + z_0 } { d } \right ) - \textrm{erf } \left ( \frac{tv + z_0 } { d } \right ) \right ] \right\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where erf is the standard error function , defined as @xmath125 .
the shift in the accumulated phase difference between the two arms in eq .
( [ ligo_example_c ] ) is largest for @xmath126 . for @xmath127 ,
the phase shift in ( [ ligo_example_c ] ) is suppressed by the factor @xmath128 . in the case
when @xmath129 , the phase shift in ( [ ligo_example_c ] ) is suppressed by the factor @xmath130 when the topological defect envelops arm 2 but remains far away from arm 1 ; however , at the times when the topological defect envelops arm 1 , there is no such suppression .
we have outlined new laser interferometer measurements to search for variation of the electromagnetic fine - structure constant @xmath0 and particle masses ( including a non - zero photon mass ) .
we have proposed a strontium optical lattice clock
silicon single - crystal cavity interferometer as a novel small - scale platform for these new measurements .
our proposed laser interferometer measurements , which may also be performed with large - scale gravitational - wave detectors , such as ligo , virgo , geo600 or tama300 , may be implemented as an extremely precise tool in the direct detection of scalar dark matter . for oscillating classical scalar dark matter ,
a single interferometer is sufficient in principle , while for topological defects , a global network of interferometers is required .
the possible range of frequencies for oscillating classical dark matter is @xmath131 ( corresponding to the dark matter particle mass range @xmath132 ) , while the timescale of passage of topological defects through a global network of detectors is @xmath133 s for a typical defect speed of @xmath134 km / s .
the current best sensitivities to length fluctuations are at the fractional level @xmath135 in the frequency range @xmath136 hz for a large - scale gravitational - wave detector @xcite and at the fractional level @xmath137 in the frequency range @xmath138 hz for a silicon - based cavity @xcite .
we are very grateful to jun ye and fritz riehle for suggesting the strontium clock
silicon cavity interferometer as a suitable small - scale platform for our newly proposed measurements , and for important discussions .
we are also grateful to an anonymous referee for suggesting the use of phase coherent optical mixing and frequency comb techniques , further to our proposal centred around eq .
( [ seismic_shield ] ) .
we would like to thank bruce allen , dmitry budker , federico ferrini , hartmut grote , sergey klimenko , giovanni losurdo , guenakh mitselmakher and surjeet rajendran for helpful discussions .
this work was supported by the australian research council . v. v.
f. is grateful to the mainz institute for theoretical physics ( mitp ) for its hospitality and support .
b. m. roberts , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , m. pospelov , y. v. stadnik , dark matter scattering on electrons : accurate calculations of atomic excitations and implications for the dama signal . arxiv:1604.04559 . o. k. baker , m. betz , f. caspers , j. jaeckel , a. lindner , a. ringwald , y. semertzidis , p. sikivie , k. zioutas , prospects for searching axionlike particle dark matter with dipole , toroidal , and wiggler magnets . _ phys . rev .
d _ * 85 * , 035018 ( 2012 ) .
m. pospelov , s. pustelny , m. p. ledbetter , d. f. j. kimball , w. gawlik , d. budker , detecting domain walls of axionlike models using terrestrial experiments .
_ _ phys .
lett . _ _ * * 110 * * , 021803 ( 2013 ) . y. v. stadnik , v. v. flambaum , axion - induced effects in atoms , molecules , and nuclei : parity nonconservation , anapole moments , electric dipole moments , and spin - gravity and spin - axion momentum couplings . _
d _ * 89 * , 043522 ( 2014 ) . b. m. roberts , y. v. stadnik , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , n. leefer , d. budker . limiting p - odd interactions of cosmic fields with electrons , protons , and neutrons . _
_ * 113 * , 081601 ( 2014 ) .
b. m. roberts , y. v. stadnik , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , n. leefer , d. budker .
parity - violating interactions of cosmic fields with atoms , molecules , and nuclei : concepts and calculations for laboratory searches and extracting limits .
d _ * 90 * , 096005 ( 2014 ) .
oscillating classical spin-0 dark matter can be readily produced in the early universe through non - thermal production mechanisms ( e.g. , through vacuum decay @xcite ) . during galactic structure formation ,
gravitational interactions between dark matter and ordinary matter result in the virialisation of the dark matter particles , which gives the finite coherence time : @xmath139 ( i.e. , @xmath140 ) , where @xmath108 is the dark matter particle mass , and a virial ( root - mean - square ) speed of @xmath141 is typical in our local galactic neighbourhood .
e. j. angstmann , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , relativistic effects in two valence electron atoms and ions and the search for variation of the fine structure constant .
a _ * 70 * , 014102 ( 2004 ) . v. v. flambaum , a. f. tedesco , dependence of nuclear magnetic moments on quark masses and limits on temporal variation of fundamental constants from atomic clock experiments .
c _ * 73 * , 055501 ( 2006 ) .
r. m. godun _ et al .
_ , frequency ratio of two optical clock transitions in @xmath144yb@xmath143 and constraints on the time variation of fundamental constants . _ _ phys .
_ _ * * 113 * * , 210801 ( 2014 ) .
n. huntemann , b. lipphardt , c. tamm , v. gerginov , s. weyers , e. peik , improved limit on a temporal variation of @xmath145 from comparisons of yb@xmath143 and cs atomic clocks .
_ _ phys .
_ _ * * 113 * * , 210802 ( 2014 ) . j. c. berengut , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , a. ong , electron - hole transitions in multiply charged ions for precision laser spectroscopy and searching for variations in @xmath0 .
_ phys . rev .
_ * 106 * , 210802 ( 2011 ) .
j. c. berengut , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , a. ong , optical transitions in highly charged californium ions with high sensitivity to variation of the fine - structure constant .
_ * 109 * , 070802 ( 2012 ) .
m. s. safronova , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , u. i. safronova , s. g. porsev , m. g. kozlov , highly charged ions for atomic clocks , quantum information , and search for @xmath0 variation .
lett . _ * 113 * , 030801 ( 2014 ) .
a. windberger _
et al . _ ,
identification of the predicted @xmath146 level crossing optical lines with applications to metrology and searches for the variation of fundamental constants .
_ * 114 * , 150801 ( 2015 ) .
j. c. berengut , v. a. dzuba , v. v. flambaum , s. g. porsev , proposed experimental method to determine @xmath0 sensitivity of splitting between ground and 7.6 ev isomeric states in @xmath148th .
lett . _ * 102 * , 210801 ( 2009 ) .
w. g. rellergert , d. demille , r. r. greco , m. p. hehlen , j. r. torgerson , e. r. hudson , constraining the evolution of the fundamental constants with a solid - state optical frequency reference based on the @xmath148th nucleus .
_ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 104 * , 200802 ( 2010 ) .
j. p. turneaure , s. r. stein , an experimental limit on the time variation of the fine structure constant , in _ atomic masses and fundamental constants 5 _ [ editors : j. h. sanders , a. h. wapstra ] , @xmath149 ( 1976 ) .
m. e. tobar , p. wolf , s. bize , g. santarelli , v. flambaum , testing local lorentz and position invariance and variation of fundamental constants by searching the derivative of the comparison frequency between a cryogenic sapphire oscillator and hydrogen maser .
d _ * 81 * , 022003 ( 2010 ) .
s. schiller , c. laemmerzahl , h. mueller , c. braxmaier , s. herrmann , a. peters , experimental limits for low - frequency space - time fluctuations from ultrastable optical resonators .
_ phys . rev .
d _ * 69 * , 027504 ( 2004 ) .
v. v. flambaum , d. b. leinweber , a. w. thomas , r. d. young , limits on the temporal variation of the fine structure constant , quark masses and strong interaction from quasar absorption spectra and atomic clock experiments .
d _ * 69 * , 115006 ( 2004 ) .
p. schwerdtfeger , table of experimental and calculated static dipole polarizabilities for the electronic ground states of the neutral elements ( in atomic units ) , last updated 2014 , ctcp.massey.ac.nz/tablepol2014.pdf | we outline new laser interferometer measurements to search for variation of the electromagnetic fine - structure constant @xmath0 and particle masses ( including a non - zero photon mass ) .
we propose a strontium optical lattice clock
silicon single - crystal cavity interferometer as a novel small - scale platform for these new measurements .
our proposed laser interferometer measurements , which may also be performed with large - scale gravitational - wave detectors , such as ligo , virgo , geo600 or tama300 , may be implemented as an extremely precise tool in the direct detection of scalar dark matter that forms an oscillating classical field or topological defects . |
activated processes are responsible for large qualitative changes in broad classes of systems .
a well - known example is escape from a potential well , in which fluctuations carry the system over a potential barrier .
activated escape underlies diffusion in crystals , protein folding , and provides a paradigm for activated chemical reactions .
another example is nucleation in phase transitions
. it would be advantageous to control the probabilities of activated processes by applying a comparatively weak external force .
the idea is that the force need not be solely responsible for driving the system over the barrier ; it only must appropriately influence fluctuations .
a familiar phenomenon which has elements of control of activated processes is stochastic resonance ( sr)@xcite . in sr , an adiabatic modulation of the system parameters by a slowly varying field is usually assumed .
the strong effect of the field can be readily understood in this case , if one notices that the probability of a thermally activated process is @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the activation energy ( the barrier height for escape from a potential well ) .
even a comparatively small field - induced modulation @xmath2 of the activation energy , @xmath3 , greatly affects @xmath4 provided @xmath5 , with @xmath6 being linear in the modulation amplitude .
in contrast , one might expect that a high - frequency field would just `` heat up '' the system by changing its effective temperature . the rate @xmath4 would then be incremented by a term proportional to the field intensity @xmath7 rather than the amplitude @xmath8 .
this is indeed the case in the weak - field limit @xcite . however
, one may ask what happens if the appropriately weighted field amplitude is not small compared to the fluctuation intensity ( temperature ) .
recent results @xcite show that , counter - intuitively , for high - frequency driving the change of @xmath6 is linear in @xmath9 , over a broad range of @xmath9 .
the exponential effect of nonadiabatic driving leads to a number of new phenomena not encountered in sr , including resonant ( in the field frequency ) rate enhancement .
this provides the basis for much of the selectivity and flexibility in controlling fluctuations , as we now outline .
one can effectively control activated processes because , although they happen at random , the trajectories of the system in an activated process are close to a specific trajectory . the latter is called the optimal path for the corresponding process @xcite . the effect of the driving field accumulates along the optimal path , giving rise to a linear - in - the - field correction to the activation energy @xmath1 .
it can be calculated if the fluctuational dynamics of the system is known .
alternatively , response to the driving can be found experimentally , and in fact used to investigate the system dynamics away from the metastable state . a fairly general case in which the field effect can be evaluated and insight gained into the underlying mechanism is a dynamical system driven by a stationary colored gaussian noise @xmath10 with a power spectrum @xmath11 of arbitrary shape @xcite .
the langevin equation of motion is of the form : @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the period of the driving force @xmath14 . for small characteristic noise intensity @xmath15 ,
the system mainly performs small fluctuations about its periodic metastable state @xmath16 .
large fluctuations , like those leading to escape from the basin of attraction to @xmath17 , require large bursts of @xmath10 which would overcome the restoring force @xmath18 .
the probability densities of large bursts of @xmath10 are exponentially small , @xmath19 $ ] , and exponentially different depending on the form of @xmath10 [ @xmath20 is given by the fourier transform of @xmath21 .
therefore for any state @xmath22 into which the system is brought by the noise at time @xmath23 , there exists a realization @xmath24 which is exponentially more probable than the others . this optimal realization and the corresponding optimal path of the system
@xmath25 provide the minimum to the functional @xmath26 = { 1\over 2}\int\!\!\intdt\,dt'\,f(t)\hat { \cal f}(t - t')f(t ' ) + \intdt\ , \lambda(t ) \left[\dot q - k(q;t)-f(t)\right ] \label{varfunct}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( the integrals are taken from @xmath27 to @xmath28 ) .
the lagrange multiplier @xmath29 relates @xmath30 and @xmath25 to each other [ cf .
( [ langevin ] ) ; @xmath31 for @xmath32 .
the activation rate has the form @xmath33 , \ ; r = \min{\cal r}.\ ] ] the exponent @xmath1 can be obtained for an arbitrary noise spectrum and an arbitrary periodic driving by solving the variational problem ( [ varfunct ] ) numerically , with appropriate boundary conditions @xcite .
we now turn to the case where the driving force @xmath14 is comparatively weak , so that the field - induced correction @xmath34 . nonetheless , @xmath35 may exceed @xmath36 and thus strongly change the rate @xmath4 ( [ escape_rate ] ) . to first order
, @xmath2 can be obtained by evaluating the term @xmath37 in ( [ varfunct ] ) along the path @xmath38 , @xmath39 calculated for @xmath40 .
special care has to be taken when activated escape and nucleation are analyzed .
here in the absence of driving , the optimal path is an instanton , the optimal fluctuation may occur at any time @xmath41 .
the field @xmath14 lifts the time degeneracy of escape paths .
it synchronizes optimal escape trajectories , selecting one per period , so as to minimize the activation energy of escape @xmath1 @xcite .
the correction @xmath2 should be evaluated along the appropriate trajectory , @xmath42 eq .
( [ escape_chi ] ) provides a closed - form expression for the change of the time - averaged activation rate @xmath43 , for an arbitrary spectrum of the driving field @xmath14 .
clearly @xmath44 is linear in @xmath45 , and the corresponding coefficient @xmath46 is therefore called the logarithmic susceptibility ( ls ) @xcite . because of minimization over @xmath41 , the change of @xmath44 is nonanalytic in @xmath14 , which leads to a number of observable consequences .
the ls has been evaluated for overdamped and underdamped white - noise driven systems@xcite .
extensive numerical and analog simulations of the escape rate in driven systems @xcite are in excellent qualitative and quantitative agreement with the theory , including the prefactor , over a broad range of field amplitudes .
a simple physical system which embodies a number of activated phenomena is a mesoscopic dielectric brownian particle trapped by a strongly focused laser beam creating an optical gradient trap , i.e. `` optical tweezers '' @xcite .
techniques based on optical tweezers have found broad applications in contactless manipulation of objects such as atoms , colloidal particles , and biological materials . activated
escape can be studied using a dual optical trap generated by two closely spaced parallel light beams .
this was used initially to investigate the synchronization of interwell transitions by low - frequency ( adiabatic ) sinusoidal forcing @xcite
. quantitative characterization of activated processes requires that the double - well confining potential of a dual trap @xmath47 be adequately determined .
the corresponding measurement , for a transparent spherical silica particle of diameter @xmath48 m optically trapped in water , was reported recently @xcite . in the experiment @xcite ,
all three coordinates of the particle are determined simultaneously .
the double - well potential @xmath47 is found directly from the measured stationary distribution @xmath49 $ ] . from the kramers theory @xcite ,
it is possible then to calculate the rates @xmath50 ( @xmath51 ) of activated transitions between the minima of @xmath47 . for the range of @xmath47 in which @xmath50 vary by nearly 3 orders of magnitude , the calculated values of @xmath50 are in excellent quantitative agreement with the results of direct measurements
this provides a direct model - free test of the multidimensional kramers rate theory , with no adjustable parameters .
the double - beam trap can also be used to investigate the effect of ac - modulation on transition rates .
an interesting application of this effect is to direct the diffusion of a particle in a spatially periodic potential @xcite . for a generic periodic potential ,
the ac - induced change of the activation barrier differs depending on the direction in which the particle moves ( right or left , for example ) .
this makes the probabilities of transitions to the right and to the left exponentially different and results in diffusion in the direction of more frequent transitions .
an effect closely related to directed diffusion , but more amenable to testing using optical trapping , is ac - field induced localization in one of the wells of a symmetric double - well potential .
both effects should occur if the field breaks the spatio - temporal symmetry of the system .
the ratio of the period - averaged stationary populations @xmath52 of the wells is determined by the ratio of the period - averaged transition rates @xmath53 , @xmath54/k_bt ) , \label{population_ratio}\ ] ] where @xmath55 are the field - induced corrections ( [ escape_chi ] ) to the activation energies of escape from wells 1,2 .
= 3.0 in figure 1 .
the least - squares fits to the experimentally determined instantaneous time - dependent switching probabilities @xmath56 for a particle in the adiabatically modulated double - beam trap , over a cycle @xmath57 of the modulating waveform .
the phase angle between the first and second harmonics is @xmath58 .
when the phase angle is incremented by @xmath59 , the escape rates from the left and right wells interchange .
the inset shows the instantaneous difference between the heights of the potential barriers in the two wells .
the experimental data @xcite on effective localization due to the field - induced symmetry breaking are shown in fig . 1 .
the experiment is conducted with a symmetric double - well potential and barrier height @xmath60 .
the intensity of the laser beams is then modulated so that the well depths are changed by @xmath61 $ ] .
the modulation amplitude is @xmath62 .
the frequency @xmath63 varies between 1 and 100 hz , which covers the range from adiabatically slow to nonadiabatic modulation . over this range
, field - induced re - population occurs between the wells for a nonsinusoidal modulation waveform , so that @xmath64 .
it is the breaking of the spatio - temporal symmetry @xmath65 that leads to the escape rate from one of the wells being on average much bigger than from the other , as seen from fig . 1 .
in turn , this leads to a higher population in one of the wells .
not only is it observed under slow modulation , as evidenced by fig . 1 , but a population difference of @xmath66 is also observed far into the nonadiabatic regime .
this is sufficient to create significant directional diffusion , and demonstrates the onset of _ dynamical _ symmetry breaking .
the effect would not arise if nonadiabatic driving led just to `` heating '' of the particle .
investigation of methods to control activated processes is currently at a very exciting stage .
the importance of the problem and its relevance to many areas , from condensed - matter physics to biophysics , is becoming increasingly appreciated .
the results outlined here show that there is a fairly general approach to controlling fluctuations , and the first experiments on overdamped systems show that such control can indeed be exercised .
a broad range of problems remains unexplored .
they include such issues as a microscopic theory of driven many - body systems and experimental exploration of underdamped driven systems .
we also envision practical applications of these results , starting with the development of new highly selective colloidal separation as well as crystal growth techniques .
we are grateful to lowell mccann and vadim smelyanskiy with whom many of the results discussed above were obtained .
this research was supported by the nsf through grants dmr-9971537 and phy-0071059 .
10 for reviews on stochastic resonance see m.i .
dykman , d.g .
luchinsky , r. mannella , p.v.e .
mcclintock , n.d .
stein , and n.g .
stocks , _ stochastic resonance in perspective _ , nuov .
d * 17 * , pp .
661 - 83 ( 1995 ) ; l. gammaitoni , p.h .
hnggi , p. jung , and f. marchesoni , _ stochastic resonance _ , rev .
phys . * 70 * , pp .
223 - 88 ( 1998 ) ; r.d .
astumian and f. moss , _ overview : the constructive role of noise in fluctuation driven transport and stochastic resonance _ , chaos * 8 * , pp .
533 - 8 ( 1998 ) ; k. wiesenfeld and f. jaramillo , _ minireview of stochastic resonance _ , chaos * 8 * , pp .
539 - 48 ( 1998 ) .
larkin and yu.n .
ovchinnikov , _ resonance reduction of the lifetime of the metastable state of tunnel junctions _ , j. low temp . phys . * 63 * , 317 - 29 ( 1986 ) ; b.i .
ivlev and v.i .
melnikov , _ effect of resonant pumping on activated decay - rates _ , phys .
a * 116 * , 427 - 8 ( 1986 ) ; s. linkwitz and h. grabert , _ enhancement of the decay rate of a metastable state by an external driving force _ , phys .
b * 44 * 11901 - 10 ( 1991 ) . m.h .
devoret , d. esteve , j.m .
martinis , a. cleland , and j. clarke , _ resonant activation of a brownian particle out of a potential well : microwave - enhanced escape from the zero - voltage state of a josephson junction _ , phys .
b * 36 * , 58 - 73 ( 1987 ) .
dykman , h. rabitz , v.n .
smelyanskiy , and b.e .
vugmeister , _ resonant directed diffusion in nonadiabatically driven systems _ ,
lett . * 79 * , 117881 ( 1997 ) ; v.n .
smelyanskiy , m.i .
dykman , h. rabitz , and b.e .
vugmeister , _ fluctuations , escape , and nucleation in driven systems : logarithmic susceptibility _ , phys .
lett . * 79 * , 311316 ( 1997 ) .
luchinsky , r. mannella , p.v.e .
mcclintock , m.i .
dykman , and v.n .
smelyanskiy , _ thermally activated escape of driven systems : the activation energy " _
, j. phys .
a * 32 * , l371 - 7 ( 1999 ) ; m.i .
dykman , b. golding , l.i .
mccann , v.n .
smelyanskiy , d.g .
luchinsky , r. mannella , and p.v.e .
mcclintock , _ activated escape of periodically driven systems _ , to be published .
h. kramers , _ brownian motion in a field of force and the diffusion model of chemical reactions _ , physica ( utrecht ) * 7 * , 284304 ( 1940 ) ; r. landauer and j.a .
swanson , _ frequency factors in the thermally activated process _ , phys .
* 121 * , 16681674 ( 1961 ) .
m. magnasco , _ forced thermal ratchets _ , phys .
lett . * 71 * , 147780 ( 1993 ) ; for a review see f. julicher , a. ajdari , and j. prost , _ modeling molecular motors _ , rev .
mod . phys . * 69 * , 1269 - 1281 , ( 1997 ) . | the rates of activated processes , such as escape from a metastable state and nucleation , are exponentially sensitive to an externally applied field .
we describe how this applies to modulation by high - frequency fields and illustrate it with experimental observations .
the results may lead to selective control of diffusion in periodic potentials , novel control mechanisms for crystal growth , and new separation techniques . |
the question about how a piece of information ( a virus , a rumor , an opinion , etc .
, ) is globally spread over a network , and which ingredients are necessary to achieve such a success , has motivated much research recently .
the reason behind this interest is that identifying key aspects of spreading phenomena facilitates the prevention ( e.g. , minimizing the impact of a disease ) or the optimization ( e.g. the enhancement of viral marketing ) of diffusion processes that can reach system wide scales . in the context of political protest or social movements
, information diffusion plays a key role to coordinate action and to keep adherents informed and motivated @xcite .
understanding the dynamics of such diffusion is important to locate who has the capability to transform the emission of a single message into a global information cascade , affecting the whole system .
these are the so - called `` privileged or influential spreaders '' . beyond purely sociological aspects
, some valuable lessons might be extracted from the study of this problem .
for instance , current viral marketing techniques ( which capitalizes on online social networks ) could be improved by encouraging customers to share product information with their acquaintances .
since people tend to pay more attention to friends than to advertisers , targeting privileged spreaders at the right time may enhance the efficiency of a given campaign .
the prominence ( importance , popularity , authority ) of a node has however many facets . from a static point of view
, an authority may be characterized by the number of connections it holds , or the place it occupies in a network .
this is the idea put forward in @xcite , where the authors seek the design of efficient algorithms to detect particular ( sub)graph structures : hierarchies and tree - like structures . turning to dynamics
, a node may become popular because of the attention it receives in short intervals of time @xcite but that is a rather volatile way of being important , because it depends on activity patterns that change in the scale of hours or even minutes .
a more lasting concept of influence comprises both a topological enduring ingredient and the dynamics it supports ; this is the case of centola s `` reinforcing signals '' @xcite or the @xmath0-core @xcite , which we follow here . in this paper
, we approach the problem of influential spreaders taking into consideration data from the spanish `` 15 m movement '' @xcite .
this pacific civil movement is an example of the social mobilizations from the `` arab spring '' to the `` occupy wall - street '' movement that have characterized 2011 .
although whether osns have been fundamental instruments for the successful organization and evolution of political movements is not firmly established , it is increasingly evident @xcite that at least they have been nurtured mainly in osns ( facebook , twitter , etc . ) before reaching classic mass media .
data from these grassroots movements but also from less conflictive phenomena in the web 2.0 provide a unique opportunity to observe system - wide information cascades .
in particular , paying attention to the network structure allows for the characterization of which users have outstanding roles for the success of cascades of information .
our results complement some previous findings regarding dynamical influence both at the theoretical @xcite and the empirical @xcite levels .
besides , our analysis of activity cascades reveals distinctive traits in different phases of the protests , which provides important hints for future modeling efforts .
the `` 15 m movement '' is a still ongoing civic initiative with no party or union affiliation that emerged as a reaction to perceived political alienation and to demand better channels for democratic representation .
the first mass demonstration , held on sunday may 15 ( @xmath1 from now on ) , was conceived as a protest against the management of the economy in the aftermath of the financial crisis .
after the demonstrations on day @xmath1 , hundreds of participants decided to continue the protests camping in the main squares of several cities ( puerta del sol in madrid , plaa de catalunya in barcelona ) until may 22 , the following sunday and the date for regional and local elections . from a dynamical point of view , the data used in this study are a set of messages ( tweets ) that were publicly exchanged through _ www . twitter.com_. the whole time - stamped data collected comprises a period of one month ( between april 25th , 2011 at 00:03:26 and may 26th , 2011 at 23:59:55 ) and it was archived by _ cierzo development ltd .
_ , a start - up company . to filter out the whole sample and choose only those messages related to the protests , 70 keywords ( _ hashtags _ ) were selected , those which were systematically used by the adherents to the demonstrations and camps .
the final sample consists of 535,192 tweets . on its turn ,
these tweets were generated by 85,851 unique users ( out of a total of 87,569 users of which 1,718 do not show outgoing activity , i.e. , they are only receivers ) .
see @xcite for more details .
twitter is most frequently used as a broadcasting platform .
users subscribe to what other users say building a `` who - listens - to - whom '' network , i.e. , that made up of followers and followings in twitter .
this means that any emitted message from a node will be immediately available to anyone following him , which is of utmost importance to understand the concept of activity cascade in the next sections .
such relationships offer an almost - static view of the relationships between users , the `` follower network '' for short . to build it , data for all the involved users
were scrapped directly from _ www.twitter.com_. the scrap was successful for the 87,569 identified users , for whom we also obtained their official list of followers restricted to those who had some participation in the protests .
the resulting structure is a directed network , direction indicates who follows who in the online social platform . in practice , we take this underlying structure as completely static ( does not change through time ) because its time scale is much slower , i.e. , changes occur probably in the scale of weeks and months . in - degree
@xmath2 expresses the amount of users a node is following ; whereas out - degree represents the amount of users who follow a node .
this network exhibits a high level of reciprocity : a typical user holds many reciprocal relationships ( with other users who the node probably knows personally ) , plus a few unreciprocated nodes which typically point at hubs . .
in yellow , the cumulative proportion of emitted messages as a function of time .
note that the two lines evolve in almost the same way . according to this evolution ,
we have distinguished two sub - periods : one of them characterized as `` slow growth '' due to the low activity level and the other one tagged as `` explosive '' or `` bursty '' due to the intense information traffic within it . ]
the main topological features of the follower network fit well in the concept of `` small - world '' @xcite , i.e. , low average shortest path length and high clustering coefficient . furthermore ,
both in- and out - degree distribute as a power - law , indicating that connectivity is extremely heterogenous .
thus , the network supporting users interactions is scale - free with some rare nodes that act as hubs @xcite .
an activity cascade or simply `` cascade '' , for short , starting at a _ seed _ , occurs whenever a piece of information or replies to it are ( more or less unchanged ) repeatedly forwarded towards other users .
if one of those who `` hear '' the piece of information decides to reply to it , he becomes a _ spreader _ , otherwise he remains as a mere _ listener_. the cascade becomes global if the final number of affected users @xmath3 ( including the set of spreaders and listeners , plus the seed ) is comparable to the size of the whole system @xmath4 .
intuitively , the success of an activity cascade greatly depends on whether spreaders have a large set of followers or not ( figure [ example ] ) ; remarkably , the seed is not necessarily very well connected .
this fact highlights the entanglement between dynamics and the underlying ( static ) structure .
note that the previous definition is too general to attain an _ operative _ notion of cascade .
one possibility is to leave time aside , and consider only identical pieces of information traveling across the topology ( a _ retweet _ , in the twitter jargon ) .
this may lead to inconsistencies , such as the fact that a node decides to forward a piece of information long after receiving it ( perhaps days or weeks ) .
it is impossible to know whether his action is motivated by the original sender , or by some exogenous reason , i.e. , invisible to us .
one may , alternatively , take into consideration time , thus considering that , regardless of the exact content of a message , two nodes belong to the same cascade as consecutive spreaders if they are connected ( the latter follows the former ) and they show activity within a certain ( short ) time interval , @xmath5 . the probability that exogenous factors are leading activation is in this way minimized . also , this concept of cascade is more inclusive , regarding dialogue - like messages ( which , we emphasize , are typically produced in short time spans ) .
this scheme exploits the concept of spike train from neuroscience , i.e. , a series of discrete action potentials from a neuron taken as a time series . at a larger scale ,
two brain regions are identified as functionally related if their activation happens in the same time window .
consequently , message chains are reconstructed assuming that activity is contagious if it takes place in short time windows .
we apply the latter definition to explore the occurrence of information cascades in the data . in practice , we take a seed message posted by @xmath6 at time @xmath7 and mark all of @xmath6 s followers as listeners .
we then check whether any of these listeners showed some activity at time @xmath8 .
this is done recursively until no other follower shows activity , see figure [ example ] . in our scheme
, a node can only belong to one cascade ; this constraint introduces a bias in the measurements , namely , two nodes sharing a follower may show activity at the same time , so their follower may be counted in one or another cascade ( with possible important consequences regarding average cascades size and penetration in time ) . to minimize this degeneration
, we perform calculations for many possible cascade configurations , randomizing the way we process data .
we distinguish information cascades ( or just cascades , for short ) from spreader - cascades . in information cascades
we count any affected user ( listeners and spreaders ) , whereas in spreader - cascades only spreaders are taken into account .
we measure cascades and spreader - cascades size distributions for three different scenarios : one in which the information intensity is low ( slow growth phase , from @xmath9 to @xmath10 ) , one in which activity is bursty ( explosive phase , @xmath11 to @xmath12 ) and one that considers all available data ( which spans a whole month , and includes the two previous scenarios plus the time in - between , @xmath9 to @xmath13 ) .
figure [ growth ] illustrates these different periods .
the green line represents the cumulative proportion of nodes in the network that had shown some activity , i.e. , had sent at least one message , measured by the hour .
we tag the first 10 days of study as `` slow growth '' because , for that period , the amount of active people grew less than 5% of the total of users , indicating that recruitment for the protests was slow at that time .
the opposite arguments apply in the case of the bursty or `` explosive '' phase : in only 8 days the amount of active users grew from less than 10% up to over an 80% .
the same can be said about global activity ( in terms of the total number of emitted directed messages the activity network ) , which shows an almost exact growth pattern .
besides , within the different time periods slow growth , explosive and total , different time windows have been set to assess the robustness of our results .
our proposed scheme relies on the contagious effect of activity , thus large time windows , i.e. , @xmath14 hours , are not considered .
the @xmath0-core decomposition of a network consists of identifying particular subsets of the network , called @xmath0-cores , each obtained by recursively removing all the vertices of degree less than @xmath0 , where @xmath15 indicates the total number of in- and out - going links of a node , until all vertices in the remaining graph have degree at least @xmath0 . in the end , each node is assigned a natural number ( its coreness ) , the higher the coreness the closer a node is to the nucleus or core of the network .
the main advantage of this centrality measure is , in front of other quantities , its low computational cost that scales as @xmath16 , where @xmath4 is the number of vertices of the graph and @xmath17 is the number of links it contains @xcite .
this decomposition has been successfully applied in the analysis of the internet and the autonomous systems structure @xcite . in the following section
, we will use the @xmath0-core decomposition as a means to identify influence in social media .
in particular , we discuss which , degree or coreness , is a better predictor of the extent of an information cascade .
the upper panels ( @xmath18 ) of figure [ fig3 ] reflect that a cascade of a size @xmath19 can be reached at any activity level ( slow growth , explosive or both ) . as expected , these large cascades occur rarely as the power - law probability distributions evidence .
this result is robust to different temporal windows up to 24h .
in contrast , lower ( @xmath20 ) panels show significant differences between periods .
specifically , the distribution of involved spreaders in the different scenarios changes radically from the `` slow growth '' phase ( figure [ fig3]d ) to the `` explosive '' period ( figure [ fig3]f ) ; the distribution that considers the whole period of study just reflects that the bursty period ( in which most of the activity takes place ) dominates the statistics .
the importance of this difference is that one may conclude that , to attain similar results a proportionally much smaller amount of spreaders is needed in the slow growth period .
going to the detail , however , it seems clear ( and coherent with the temporal evolution of the protests , fig .
[ growth ] ) that although cascades in the slow period ( panel a ) affect as much as @xmath21 of the population , the system is in a different dynamical regime than in the explosive one : indeed , distributions suggest that there has been a shift from a subcritical to a supercritical phase .
the previous conclusions raise further questions : is there a way to identify `` privileged spreaders '' ?
are they placed randomly throughout the network s topology ? or do they occupy key spots in the structure ? and , will these influential users be more easily detected in a bursty period ( where large cascades occur more often ) ? in
what context will influential spreaders single out ? to answer these questions , we capitalize on previous work suggesting that centrality ( measured as the @xmath0-core ) enhances the capacity of a node to be key in disease spreading processes @xcite .
the authors in @xcite discussed whether the degree of a node ( its total number of neighbors , @xmath0 ) or its @xmath0-core ( a centrality measure ) can better predict the spreading capabilities of such node .
note that the @xmath0-shell decomposition splits a network in a few levels ( over a hundred ) , while node degrees can range from one or two up to several thousands .
we have explored the same idea , but in relation to activity cascades which are the object of interest here .
the upper left panel of fig .
[ coredegree ] shows the spreading capabilities as a function of classes of @xmath0-cores .
specifically , we take the seed of each particular cascade and save its coreness and the final size of the cascade it triggers .
having done so for each cascade , we can average the success of cascades for a given core number .
remarkably , for every scenario under consideration ( slow , explosive , whole ) , a higher core number yields larger cascades .
this result supports the ideas developed in @xcite , but it is at odds with those reported in @xcite , which shows that the @xmath0-core of a node is not relevant in rumor dynamics .
exactly the same conclusion ( and even more pronounced ) can be drawn when considering degree ( lower left panel ) , which appears to be in contradiction with the mentioned previous evidence @xcite . at a first sight ,
our findings seem to point out that if privileged spreaders are to be found , one should simply identify the individuals who are highly connected
. however , this procedure might not be the best choice .
the right panels in figure [ coredegree ] show the @xmath0-core ( upper ) and degree ( lower ) distributions , indicating the number of nodes which are seeds at one time or another , classified in terms of their coreness or degree .
unsurprisingly , many nodes belong to low cores and have low degrees .
the interest of these histograms lies however in the tails of the distributions , where one can see that , while there are a few hundred nodes in the high cores ( and even over a thousand in the last core ) , highest degrees account only for a few dozen of nodes . in practice
, this means that by looking at the degree of the nodes , we will be able to identify quite a few influential spreaders ( the ones that produce the largest cascades ) .
however , the number of such influential individuals are far more than a few . as a matter of fact
, high cascading capabilities are distributed over a wider range of cores , which in turn contain a significant number of nodes .
focusing on fig .
[ coredegree ] , note that triggering cascades affecting over @xmath22 of the network s population demands nodes with @xmath23 . checking the distribution of degrees ( right - hand side )
, it is easy to see that an insignificant amount of nodes display such degree range . in the same line
, we may wonder what it takes to trigger cascades affecting over @xmath22 of the network s population , from the @xmath0-core point of view . in this case , nodes with @xmath0-core around 125 show such capability .
a quick look at the core distribution yields that over 1500 nodes accomplish these conditions , i.e. , they belong to the 125th @xmath0-shell or higher .
we may now distinguish between scenarios in figure [ coredegree ] .
while any of the analyzed periods shows a growing tendency , i.e. , cascades are larger the larger is the considered descriptor , we highlight that it is in the slow growth period ( black circles ) where the tendency is more clear , i.e. , results are less noisy . between the other two periods , the explosive one ( red squares )
is distinctly the less robust , in the sense that cascade sizes oscillate very much across @xmath0-cores , and the final plot shows a smaller slope than the other two .
this subtle fact is again of great importance : it means that during `` information storms '' a large cascade can be triggered from anywhere in the network ( and , conversely , small cascades may have begun in important nodes ) .
the reason for this is that in periods where bursty activity dominates the system suffers `` information overflow '' , the amount of noise flattens the differences between nodes . for instance , in these periods a node from the periphery ( low coreness ) may balance his unprivileged situation by emitting messages very frequently .
this behavior yields a situation in which , from a dynamical point of view , nodes become increasingly indistinguishable .
the plot corresponding to the whole period analyzed ( green triangles ) lies consistently between the other two scenarios , but closer to the relaxed period .
this is perfectly coherent , the study spans for 30 days and the explosive period represents only 25% of it , whereas the relaxed period stands for over 33% .
furthermore , those days between @xmath10 and @xmath11 , and beyond @xmath12 , resemble the relaxed period as far as the flow of information is concerned .
online social networks are called to play an ever increasing role in shaping many of our habits ( be them commercial or cultural ) as well as in our position in front of political , economical or social issues not only at a local , country - wide level , but also at the global scale .
it is thus of utmost importance to uncover as many aspects as possible about topological and dynamical features of these networks .
one particular aspect is whether or not one can identify , in a network of individuals with common interests , those that are influentials to the rest .
our results show that the degree of the nodes seems to be the best topological descriptor to locate such influential individuals .
however , there is an important caveat : the number of such privileged seeds is very low as there are quite a few of these highly connected subjects . on the contrary , by ranking the nodes according to their @xmath0-core index , which can be done at a low computational cost , one can safely locate the ( more abundant in number ) individuals that are likely to generate large ( near to ) system - wide cascades .
the results here presented also lead to a surprising conclusion : periods characterized by explosive activity are not convenient for the spreading of information throughout the system using influential individuals as seeds .
this is because in such periods , the high level of activity mainly coming from users which are badly located in the network introduces noise in the system .
consequently , influential individuals lose their unique status as generators of system wide cascades and therefore their messages are diluted . on more general grounds ,
our analysis of real data remarks the importance of empirical results to validate theoretical contributions .
in particular , fig .
[ coredegree ] , together with the observations in @xcite , raises some doubts about rumor dynamics as a good proxy to real information diffusion .
we hypothesize that such models approach information diffusion phenomena in a too simplistic way , thus failing to comprise relevant mechanisms such as complex activity patterns @xcite . finally , although the underlying topology may be regarded as constant , any modeling effort should also contemplate the time evolution of the dynamics . indeed , fig .
[ fig3 ] suggests that the system is in a sub - critical phase when activity level is low , and critical or supercritical during the explosive period .
this is related to the rate at which users are increasingly being recruited as active agents , i.e. the speed at which listeners become spreaders .
this work has been partially supported by micinn through grants fis2008 - 01240 and fis2011 - 25167 , and by comunidad de aragn ( spain ) through a grant to the group fenol . | social media have provided plentiful evidence of their capacity for information diffusion .
fads and rumors , but also social unrest and riots travel fast and affect large fractions of the population participating in online social networks ( osns ) .
this has spurred much research regarding the mechanisms that underlie social contagion , and also who ( if any ) can unleash system - wide information dissemination .
access to real data , both regarding topology the network of friendships and dynamics the actual way in which osns users interact , is crucial to decipher how the former facilitates the latter s success , understood as efficiency in information spreading . with the quantitative analysis that stems from complex network theory ,
we discuss who ( and why ) has privileged spreading capabilities when it comes to information diffusion .
this is done considering the evolution of an episode of political protest which took place in spain , spanning one month in 2011 . |
the @xmath0 meson discovered by the cdf collaboration @xcite in @xmath4 collisions at @xmath5 tev completes the family of mixed flavor mesons .
the @xmath0 meson has a @xmath6 anti - quark and a @xmath7 quark .
current and future experiments at the tevatron and lhc are expected to provide large samples of the excited states of the @xmath0 mesons @xcite .
this will make possible the study of the spectroscopy and the decays of the @xmath0 mesons .
the @xmath0 meson family lies intermediate in mass and size between the @xmath8 @xmath9 and the @xmath10 ( @xmath11 ) families where the heavy quark interactions are believed to be understood rather well .
comparison between experimental measurement and theoretical results will improve our understanding of these interactions and guide us in the search for multiquark and molecular exotics such as the recently claimed ( discovered ) @xmath12 @xcite and @xmath13 @xcite .
different models @xcite including various versions of potential models and qcd sum rules have been used to evaluate the @xmath0 spectrum yielding results consistent with the experimentally measured ground state mass and lifetime .
the @xmath0 mesons have non - vanishing flavor quantum numbers which are conserved in strong and electromagnetic interactions . therefore , the @xmath0 states , below the open flavor @xmath1 threshold , can only decay weakly or radiatively .
these states are expected to be relatively long - lived and easier to be observed experimentally . from the theoretical side , weak and radiative decays are free from uncertainties encountered in strong decays which makes the decays of these states theoretically more tractable . in a previous paper @xcite ,
we have evaluated a limited set of the @xmath0 spectrum using a model based on reductions of the bethe - salpeter equation ( bse ) .
we have used a set of parameters fixed from previous investigations of other meson spectra .
our results agreed very well with the experimentally measured ground state mass and lifetime .
we also evaluated the @xmath0 decay constant , the @xmath6 antiquark and the @xmath7 quark inclusive decay widths and the weak annihilation width .
we also evaluated the exclusive semileptonic ( @xmath14 ) and two - body nonleptonic ( @xmath15 ) decay widths @xcite , where p ( v ) denotes a pseudoscalar ( vector ) meson .
we used the bse amplitudes to evaluate the semileptonic form factors and used factorization to obtain the nonleptonic decay widths in terms of the semileptonic form factors and the weak decay constants . in the present paper , we evaluate the complete @xmath0 spectrum below the open flavor @xmath1 threshold and consider the radiative @xmath16 and @xmath17 electromagnetic transitions .
this complements our picture @xcite of the @xmath0 mesons .
radiative decays are the dominant decay modes of the @xmath0 excited states having widths of about a fraction of mev , much greater than the weak widths at the order of mev . therefore , accurate determination of the masses and the radiative decay widths will be extremely important for understanding the @xmath0 spectrum and distinguishing exotic states . the paper is organized as follows . in the next section
we briefly outline our model and compare our spectrum with those of other models .
we then evaluate the @xmath16 and @xmath17 radiative decays .
finally we discuss our results .
we applied a relativistic model based on reductions of the bse to evaluate the @xmath0 spectrum .
the bse is a suitable starting point for treating hadrons as relativistic bound states of quarks and antiquarks , just as the dirac equation provides a relativistic description of a fermion in an external field .
the bse for a bound state may be written in momentum space in the form @xcite @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the four - momentum of the bound state , @xmath20 is the relative four - momentum of the constituents .
the bse has three elements , the two particle propagator ( @xmath21 ) and the interaction kernel ( @xmath22 ) which we provide as input , and the amplitude ( @xmath23 ) obtained by solving the equation .
we also solve for the energy , which is contained in the propagator .
we used a reduction of the bse where the two particle propagator is modified in a way that keeps covariance and reduces the four - dimensional bse into a three - dimensional equation @xcite .
we considered an interactional kernel that consists of two terms , one for the short range one gluon exchange @xmath24 and the other for the long range phenomenological confinement interaction @xmath25 @xcite .
@xmath26 here , @xmath27 is the strong coupling , which is weighted by the meson color factor of @xmath28 , and the string tension @xmath29 is the strength of the confining part of the interaction . while the one gluon exchange @xmath24 has the vector nature , we adopt a scalar lorentz structure for @xmath25 as discussed in @xcite .
we solve for the energies and the amplitudes in momentum space and transform these amplitudes into coordinate space .
we have included seven parameters in our model , four masses ( @xmath30 ) , two parameters to fix the strong coupling @xmath27 and control its running with the meson mass , and the last parameter is the string tension @xmath29 of the confining interaction .
we fixed the parameters of our model by fitting the spectra of other mesons as described in @xcite .
we obtained a good fit for a wide range of meson masses with root mean square deviation from experimental masses of about 50 mev .
table [ parameters ] compares the parameters relevant to the @xmath0 mesons of our model with those of different models in the literature . in table
[ parameters ] , @xmath31 and @xmath32 are the masses of the @xmath7 and @xmath33 quark respectively , while @xmath27 is the strong coupling of the one gluon exchange and @xmath29 is the string tension of the confining interaction . in many models , including ours , @xmath27 runs with the meson mass , thus table [ parameters ] gives @xmath27 at the scale of the ground state mass of the @xmath0 mesons .
the model used in @xcite employs the martin potential @xcite which is not linear but varies with powers of the quark antiquark distance .
we notice that our @xmath31 and @xmath32 values are smaller that those of other models , while our string tension @xmath29 is larger .
the values of the strong coupling @xmath27 are consistent around 0.36 except in @xcite where @xmath27 is 0.265 and in @xcite where @xmath27 is 0.21 .
.[parameters]the parameters of different models relevant to the @xmath0 mesons . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] + table [ m1 ] shows differences between the transition energies ( spin - spin splittings ) , while the transition matrix elements are comparable .
it also shows that hindered transitions have widths at the same level as the allowed ones .
we have evaluated the @xmath0 spectrum below the @xmath1 threshold using a reduction of the bse . we have made predictions for the transition rates of the @xmath16 and @xmath17 radiative decays .
we compared our results with the results of other models in the literature .
experimental results will help clarify the spin - spin and spin - orbit splittings of different models and consequently improve our knowledge of physical quantities such as the quark masses and the strong coupling @xmath27 at the scale of @xmath34 .
measurements of radiative transitions and comparison with such results may indicate the existence of exotic multiquark or molecular exotics .
gershtein , v.v .
kiselev , a.k .
likhoded , a.v .
tkabladze , phys .
usp . * 38 * , 1 ( 1995 ) ; v.v .
kiselev , a.k .
likhoded , a.v .
tkabladze , phys . rev . *
d51 * , 3613 ( 1995 ) ; s.s .
gershtein , v.v .
kiselev , a.k .
likhoded , a.v .
tkabladze , a.v .
berezhnoi , a.i .
onishchenko , hep - ph/9803433 .
a. abd el - hady , j. h. muoz , and j.p .
vary , phys . rev . *
d62 * , 014019 ( 2000 ) . c. itzykson , and j.b .
zuber , quantum field theory .
mcgraw - hill , new york ( 1980 ) ( chapter 10 gives a review of bethe - salpeter equation ) . | we evaluate the complete spectrum of the @xmath0 mesons , below the open flavor @xmath1 threshold , in a bethe - salpeter model .
we make predictions for the radiative decay widths of the @xmath0 excited states .
we compare our results with those of other models .
epsf -0.5 in 6.5 in 8.5 in -.375 in * radiative decays of @xmath0 mesons in a bethe - salpeter model + * @xmath2 _ physics department , king khalid university , abha 9004 , saudi arabia
_ + @xmath3 _ department of physics and astronomy , iowa state university , ames , iowa 50011 , usa _
+ .5 in |
the extinction curve describes how the extinction changes with the wavelength .
extinction is due to the presence of dust grains in the interstellar medium and its characteristics are different in a diffuse interstellar medium as compared to a dense interstellar medium .
thus , the knowledge of extinction curve is necessary to deredden magnitudes and colors of astronomical objects and to understand the physical properties of dust grains .
* hereafter ccm ) derived a mean extinction law ( for @xmath2 ) that depends on only one parameter @xmath3 .
they considered the sample used in the ultraviolet ( uv ) extinction study of @xcite based on _ international ultraviolet explorer _ extinction curves of 45 reddened milky way ob stars .
ccm searched for the corresponding optical and near - infrared ( ubvrijhkl ) photometry from the literature .
finally they used the intrinsic colors of @xcite for the appropriate spectral types to determine the extinction .
they obtained the following one - parameter family of curves that represents the uv to infrared ( ir ) extinction law in terms of @xmath0 : @xmath4 where @xmath5 , and @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the wavelength - dependent coefficients .
equation ( [ ccmlaw ] ) is very powerful because it allows one to determine the extinction in some spectral region based on the extinction in a different spectral region , given that one knows @xmath0 .
the @xmath0 parameter ranges from about 2.0 to about 5.5 ( with a typical value of 3.1 ) when one goes from diffuse to dense interstellar medium . in this formalism
@xmath0 therefore characterizes the dust properties in the region that produces the extinction .
many authors used this parameter to study extinction , e.g. : @xcite searched for a relation between @xmath0 and other parameters that characterize the extinction curves ; @xcite studied the role of @xmath0 as the main regulatory agent of the penetration of radiation inside dark clouds ; @xcite discussed different methods to deredden the data and obtained a new estimate of the extinction law in terms of @xmath0 .
* hereafter gs ) applied a @xmath8 minimization to compute the @xmath0 values for a sample of stars with uv extinction data using the linear relation ( [ ccmlaw ] ) . a similar method with weights
was used by @xcite to determine @xmath0 and @xmath1 toward a sample of stars with known color excesses in ubvrijhkl . here
we extend the method used by gs in order to obtain improved @xmath0 values for the lines of sight toward a sample of stars with known extinction data in the uv .
the structure of this paper is the following . in [ th.cons .
] we discuss the theoretical basis of our @xmath0 derivation . in [ data ]
we describe our data sources .
we present the results and assess the consistency between different samples and theoretical approaches in [ results ] . finally in [ conclusion ]
we discuss our results and comment on the future work .
the interstellar dust grains span a wide range of sizes from a few angstroms to a few micrometers . in general
, they reduce the intensity of the transmitted beam by two physical processes : absorption and scattering .
the extinction is the result of these two processes .
+ the apparent magnitude @xmath9 of each star as a function of wavelength may be written as @xmath10 @xmath11 where @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 represent absolute magnitude , distance and total extinction , respectively , and subscripts `` red '' and `` comp '' denote reddened and comparison stars , respectively .
the extinction as a function of @xmath15 may be obtained by comparing corresponding stars paired according to spectral properties . in principle , the comparison star should be of the same spectral classification as the reddened star , but with a negligible extinction .
if the reddened star and the comparison star have the same spectral classification it also means that they have very similar intrinsic spectral energy distributions .
thus we have @xmath16 .
we also assume that @xmath17 .
the magnitude difference obtained from equation ( [ mred ] ) and ( [ mcomp ] ) is therefore : @xmath18 the quantity @xmath19 is a constant term and may be eliminated by normalizing with respect to extinction difference in two standard wavelengths @xmath20 and @xmath21 : @xmath22 generally , the extinction curves are normalized with respect to the b and v passbands in the @xcite system : @xmath23 where @xmath24 , @xmath25 is the observed color and @xmath26 is the intrinsic color ( by construction equal to the color of the comparison star ) .
it is possible to obtain the absolute extinction by using the total to selective extinction ratio : @xmath27 then : @xmath28 ccm , for computational reasons , divided the complete extinction curve ( equation [ ccmlaw ] ) into three wavelengths regions and fitted the extinction law as a function of @xmath29 : + infrared ( @xmath30 ) , + optical / nir ( @xmath31 ) , + ultraviolet and far - ultraviolet ( @xmath32 ) .
+ for every wavelength , the coefficients @xmath6 and @xmath7 from equation ( [ ccmlaw ] ) are fixed and given by an appropriate expression .
observations from _ international ultraviolet explorer _ cover a range from @xmath33 ( @xmath15[@xmath34 = 1549 , 1799 , 2200 , 2493 , and 3294 ) , so we use the equations for the coefficients for the last two regions listed above .
for @xmath31 and @xmath35 we have : @xmath36 for @xmath37 : @xmath38+f_a(x);\\ & b(x)&=-3.090 + 1.825x+1.206/[(x-4.62)^2 + 0.263]+f_b(x).\end{aligned}\ ] ] where : @xmath39 @xmath40 @xcite compute @xmath0 values using equations ( [ ccmlaw ] ) and ( [ eps ] ) and by minimizing the quantity : @xmath41\}^2 \label{chi}\ ] ] the right side of equation ( [ chi ] ) is a second order polynomial ( parabola ) of @xmath0 with the minimum : @xmath42\right\}}{\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands}}(a(x_i)-1)^2 } \label{rvgs}\ ] ] + this formula is right when the errors in @xmath43 are identical for all bands .
our data ( see [ data ] ) have errors that differ from band to band , so we use an improved @xmath8 , weighted by the observational errors .
ducati et al .
( 2003 ) suggested the following @xmath8 for independent minimization with respect to @xmath0 and @xmath1 : @xmath44 ^ 2\ ] ] where @xmath45 are the weights associated with each band .
we use a related but different approach which stems from the fact that in addition to uv bands we also use @xmath46 as our input data .
we normalize our color excesses with @xmath46 to form @xmath47 . since @xmath48 , we minimize the following @xmath8 with respect to @xmath0 only : @xmath49 \ } ^2 ~e^2(b - v ) \label{chiweighted}\ ] ] setting @xmath50 and minimizing equation ( [ chiweighted ] ) with respect to @xmath0 we find : @xmath51/ \sigma_i^2 \}}{\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } \ { ( a(x_i)-1)^2/ \sigma_i^2 \ } } \label{rvweighted}\ ] ] where : @xmath52 \equiv \left(\frac{\partial \epsilon(\lambda_i - v)}{\partial e(\lambda_i - v ) } \sigma[e(\lambda_i - v)]\right)^2 + \left ( \frac{\partial \epsilon(\lambda_i - v)}{\partial e(b - v ) } \sigma[e(b - v)]\right)^2 \nonumber\\ & = & \left(\frac{e(\lambda_i - v)}{e(b - v ) } \right)^2 \left [ \left ( \frac{\sigma[e(\lambda_i - v)]}{e(\lambda_i - v)}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{\sigma[e(b - v)]}{e(b - v ) } \right)^2 \right ] \label{sigma}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath53 & \equiv & \sigma^2[(m_{\lambda_i}-m_v ) - ( m_{\lambda_i}-m_v)_0 ] \nonumber\\ & = & \sigma^2[m_{\lambda_i}]+\sigma^2[m_v]+\sigma^2_{i,{\rm mismatch } } \label{sigmae}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the error terms on the right side of equation ( [ sigmae ] ) are described in table [ table1 ] . in equation ( [ sigma ] )
we assumed for simplicity that the errors in @xmath54 and @xmath46 are independent .
however , the values of @xmath47 and their errors for different bands are not independent . to get a good idea about the errors in @xmath0 we compute them in two ways .
first , we calculate the maximum error in @xmath0 , which is the straight sum of errors coming from different sources : @xmath55 then we obtain the error in quadrature which would properly describe total uncertainty if the errors from different sources were uncorrelated : @xmath56 } \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } [ ( a(x_i)-1)^2/\sigma_i^2 ] } \cdot \sqrt { \sum_{j=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } \left ( \frac{a(x_j)-1}{\sigma_j } \right)^2 } \label{quaerr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] neither description ( [ errabs ] ) nor ( [ quaerr ] ) is strictly correct : the real error in @xmath0 lies likely between these two estimates . by definition : @xmath57 where the second equality is a consequence of equation ( [ rvweighted ] ) .
therefore the maximum error in @xmath1 is given by } \frac{1}{\sigma_i^2 } = c$ ] , where @xmath58 is a constant .
from equation ( [ sigma ] ) we conclude that this condition is in conflict with @xmath59=\sigma [ e(b - v)]$ ] assumed by gs .
if we ignore this conflict and force both conditions , then : @xmath60 \cdot \sigma [ e(b - v)]\ ] ] the results reported in table 1 of gs suggest that they used the above formula rather than their equation ( 8) . ] : @xmath61 + \left | \frac{\partial a_v } { \partial e(b - v ) } \right| \sigma [ e(b - v ) ] \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } ( a(x_i)-1)^2/\sigma_i^2 } \left [ \sum_{j=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } \left | \frac{(a(x_j)-1)}{\sigma_j^2}\right| \sigma[e(\lambda_j - v ) ] \right . \nonumber\\ & + & \left .
\left| \sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands}}\frac{(a(x_i)-1)(-b(x_i))}{\sigma_i^2 } \right| \sigma[e(b - v ) ] \right ] \label{averrmax}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the error in quadrature is given by : @xmath62 + \left ( \frac{\partial a_v}{\partial e(b - v ) } \right ) ^2 \sigma^2[e(b - v ) ] } \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } ( a(x_i)-1)^2/\sigma_i^2 } \left[\left(\sum_{j=1}^{n_{\rm bands } } \frac{(a(x_j)-1)}{\sigma_j^2 } \right)^2\sigma^2[e(\lambda_j - v)]\right .
\nonumber\\ & + & \left.\left(\sum_{i=1}^{n_{\rm bands}}\frac{(a(x_i)-1)(-b(x_i))}{\sigma_i^2 } \right)^2\sigma^2[e(b - v ) ] \right]^{1/2 } \label{sigmaquadav}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
we use the data taken from the @xcite catalog of ultraviolet color excesses @xmath63 for stars of spectral types b7 and earlier .
the uv measurements are taken from _ astronomical netherlands satellite _ ( ans ) data @xcite and consist of observations in five uv channels with central wavelengths : @xmath64 1549 , 1799 , 2200 , 2493 , and 3294@xmath65 .
the sources of the data used to obtain @xmath66 as given by equation ( [ extinction ] ) and their errors are listed in table [ table1 ] .
we also consider another type of error : a ` mismatch error ' , which is caused by the fact that the reddened star and the comparison star may have slightly different colors .
@xcite give in their section 2c , table 1b ultraviolet color excess errors which include errors associated with spectral type misclassification ( mismatch error ) and errors in the intrinsic colors .
we adopt their values for this total additional source of error , and we record them under the name of mismatch error .
figure [ figure1 ] shows the histograms of the @xmath54 errors for the five ultraviolet bands which we obtain using equation ( [ sigmae ] ) .
the errors are completely dominated by the mismatch errors which results in a few spikes observed in each panel .
the errors adopted by gs and marked by vertical lines are shown for comparison . from the @xcite catalog
we exclude some lines of sight using the same method of selection as gs .
it means that we exclude the lines of sight that have @xmath67 , and the ones with @xmath68 .
this selection results in 923 lines of sight considered previously by gs .
in addition , we also exclude those stars that do not have spectral type classification , because for them we are not able to assign the mismatch errors .
this last cut reduces the number of lines of sight we consider to 782 .
figure [ figure2 ] shows the sky positions of the stars in our sample .
the sample contains stars of spectral type b7 and earlier and this is the reason for which almost all the stars lie in the galactic plane at low latitudes .
by using the method described in [ th.cons . ]
we compute for our sample the @xmath0 and @xmath1 values listed in table [ table2 ] . here
we present only the first 20 objects from our sample .
the complete table is available in electronic form and on the world wide web . in the first column we list the names of stars , in the second and third
the galactic coordinates , then the @xmath46 values taken from @xcite catalog ; in the remaining columns we list the @xmath0 and @xmath1 values with their errors obtained using formulae ( [ rvweighted])([sigmaquadav ] ) . + our determination of @xmath0 values with their errors is made using the gs method improved through the consistent treatment of observational errors .
figure [ figure3 ] shows the good agreement between the @xmath0 values obtained with gs unweighted method and the weighted method applied here . in our case ,
the @xmath0 values are not so different between the two methods because our adopted errors in @xmath69 are of the same order in the five uv wavelengths .
however , it s important to notice that typical errors in @xmath0 are very different between the two methods ( mostly due to the mismatch errors considered here )
. + figure [ figure4 ] shows the same points as in figure [ figure2 ] , but now different colors mark different values of @xmath0 with @xmath0 increasing from red to blue . as expected most lines of sight
have @xmath0 of about 3.1 .
this may be also seen in figure [ figure5 ] which shows @xmath0 values as a function of galactic coordinates .
the circular red points are the mean values of @xmath0 for the data binned every @xmath70 and every @xmath71 for the galactic longitude and latitude , respectively .
these mean values do not differ a lot one from another but some sky anisotropy is also quite apparent .
figure [ figure6 ] shows the histogram of the @xmath0 values derived here .
the weighted mean of @xmath0 values is @xmath72 .
we consider systematic errors in extinction curve determination that can result from using biased @xmath46 values . to this aim
we use the wegner s ( 2002 ) calibration of @xmath46 to estimate the effect of the calibration change on the value of @xmath0 .
usually , the extinction curve is expressed in terms of a color excesses to @xmath46 ratio .
since @xmath0 value depends on this ratio ( see equation [ eps ] or [ rvweighted ] ) , the adopted @xmath46 calibration will influence it . since we do not know which set of @xmath46 values is more appropriate [ @xcite or @xcite ] , the difference in obtained @xmath0 values will be a good indicator of a possible systematic error in @xmath0 .
@xcite made a catalog of interstellar extinction curves of ob stars .
he used the uv data from @xcite , but differently from @xcite who used the data sources described in table [ table1 ] , he took the visual magnitudes and spectral classification of o and b stars from the simbad database .
the maximum error in @xmath46 adopted by @xcite is 0.04 mag ; the error in @xmath73 and @xmath74 is 0.01 , and he obtains the intrinsic colors using the ` artificial ' standard method by @xcite , who found a linear relation between @xmath75 and @xmath76 and used the coefficients of this relation also to compute the linear relation between the intrinsic colors .
this method improves the accuracy of the intrinsic colors based on ans photometry .
there are 190 stars that @xcite has in common with our sample . for these stars
we compute the @xmath0 values using formula ( [ rvweighted ] ) weighted by the observational errors given by @xcite .
figure [ figure7 ] shows the difference in the @xmath0 values given by different calibrations values is : @xmath77 . ] .
the main effect on @xmath0 comes from the fact that the @xmath46 values from two calibrations differs on average by [email protected] in the sense that @xcite color excesses are smaller than the ones used in our primary determination .
+ table [ table3 ] reports results for the lines of sight in common between wegner s ( 2002 ) sample and our sample .
the complete table is given in the electronic form on the world wide web .
the first column lists stellar designations , the second and third report the galactic coordinates ; in the fourth column we list the @xmath46 values taken by @xcite ; the fifth column gives our @xmath0 values and the sixth their maximum errors ; the seventh contains the @xmath46 values used by @xcite , the eighth provides the @xmath0 values and the ninth their errors computed with our method and using the wegner s ( 2002 ) ultraviolet data .
using ultraviolet color excesses we find @xmath0 and @xmath1 values and their errors for a sample of 782 lines of sight .
we extend the analysis of @xcite by considering various sources of statistical and systematic errors . in a treatment related to the one by ducati et al .
( 2003 ) , we introduce the weights associated with the errors in each uv band to our @xmath8 minimization procedure .
we explicitly give all the formulae we use to compute the @xmath0 and @xmath1 values and their errors .
we compute the maximum errors and the errors in quadrature for @xmath0 and @xmath1 taking into account mismatch errors that affect the color excesses to the largest extent .
we present the sky distribution of @xmath0 values and show their behavior as a function of galactic coordinates . finally , we emphasize how @xmath0 values change with different calibrations of @xmath46 .
since @xmath0 value may characterize entire extinction curves , extending our study into wavelength regions beyond ultraviolet will provide a check on the universality of ccm law in various parts of the spectrum .
we discuss this issue in the forthcoming paper .
we are grateful to gregory rudnick for his very careful reading of the original version of this manuscript and a number of helpful suggestions .
we thank paola mazzei and guido barbaro for their comments .
ag acknowledges the financial support from earastargal fellowship at max - planck - institute for astrophysics , where this work has been completed .
99 cardelli , j. a. , clayton , g. c. , & mathis j. s. 1989 , , 345 , 245 cecchi - pestellini , c. , cervetto , c. , aiello , s. , & barsella , b. 1995 , , 43 , 1319 2003 , , 588 , 344 , m. p. 1970 , a&a , 4 , 234 , e. l. & massa , d. 1990 , , 72 , 163 , e. l. 1999 , , 111 , 63 gnaciski , p. & sikorski , j. 1999 , , 49 , 577 , p. & greenberg , j. m. 1993 , a&a , 274 , 439 johnson , h.l .
1966 , , 4 , 193 , d. m. & savage , b. d. 1981 , , 248 , 545 , b. 1978 , a&as , 34 , 1 , j. , krelowski , j. , & wegner , w. 1993 , , 273 , 575 , b. d. , massa , d. , meade , m. , & wesselius , p. r. 1985 , , 59 , 397 , w. 2002 , balta , 11 , 1 , p. r. , van duinen , r. j. , de jonge , a. r. w. , aalders , j. w. g. , luinge , w. , & wildeman , k. j. 1982 , a&as , 49 , 427 , c .- c . ,
gallagher , j. s. , peck , m. , faber , s. m. , & tinsley , b. m. 1980 , , 237 , 290 values as a function of galactic coordinates .
the circular red points represent the unweighted mean values of @xmath0 in different coordinate bins with the rms error bars represented by the vertical lines . the galactic longitudes and latitudes are binned every @xmath79 and @xmath80 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=302 ] values as a function of galactic coordinates .
the circular red points represent the unweighted mean values of @xmath0 in different coordinate bins with the rms error bars represented by the vertical lines .
the galactic longitudes and latitudes are binned every @xmath79 and @xmath80 , respectively.,title="fig:",width=302 ] values obtained from equation ( [ rvweighted ] ) using the wegner s ( 2002 ) uv data versus the @xmath0 values computed with the same formula , but using our primary data .
the line shows a 1-to-1 relationship .
the right panel shows the comparison between two different calibrations of @xmath46 .
the line marks the average difference level.,title="fig:",width=302 ] values obtained from equation ( [ rvweighted ] ) using the wegner s ( 2002 ) uv data versus the @xmath0 values computed with the same formula , but using our primary data .
the line shows a 1-to-1 relationship .
the right panel shows the comparison between two different calibrations of @xmath46 .
the line marks the average difference level.,title="fig:",width=302 ] clcp6.5 cm @xmath74 & @xcite & [email protected] & + @xmath76 & @xcite & [email protected] & we adopt the same conservative errors estimate for all stars .
+ @xmath81 & @xcite & [email protected] & + @xmath73 & @xcite & [email protected] - [email protected] & + @xmath82 & @xcite & @xmath83 & + @xmath84 & @xcite & [email protected] - [email protected] & [ table1 ] lccccccccc bd-84617 & 37.0 & 8.4 & 1.22 & 3.23 & 0.24 & 0.12 & 3.94 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd-84634 & 38.0 & 7.4 & 1.22 & 2.92 & 0.25 & 0.12 & 3.56 & 0.48 & 0.34 + bd-11471 & 213.4 & 1.4 & 0.74 & 2.87 & 0.44 & 0.21 & 2.13 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+233762 & 60.3 & @xmath850.3 & 1.05 & 3.30 & 0.30 & 0.15 & 3.47 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+23771 & 37.2 & @xmath851.4 & 0.93 & 2.65 & 0.35 & 0.17 & 2.46 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+243893 & 61.3 & @xmath850.5 & 0.65 & 3.32 & 0.45 & 0.22 & 2.16 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+341054 & 173.4 & @xmath850.2 & 0.49 & 3.78 & 0.59 & 0.28 & 1.85 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+341059 & 173.0 & 0.2 & 0.49 & 3.75 & 0.59 & 0.29 & 1.84 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+341150 & 175.1 & 2.4 & 0.44 & 2.58 & 0.69 & 0.33 & 1.13 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+341162 & 175.5 & 2.6 & 0.36 & 2.81 & 0.84 & 0.40 & 1.01 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+343631 & 69.2 & 6.9 & 0.13 & 4.62 & 2.20 & 1.05 & 0.60 & 0.48 & 0.34 + bd+354258 & 77.2 & @xmath854.7 & 0.29 & 2.39 & 1.07 & 0.51 & 0.69 & 0.48 & 0.34 + bd+361261 & 174.1 & 4.3 & 0.52 & 2.75 & 0.62 & 0.30 & 1.43 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+363882 & 73.5 & 2.2 & 0.64 & 3.43 & 0.50 & 0.24 & 2.19 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+364145 & 77.5 & @xmath852.0 & 0.96 & 2.79 & 0.31 & 0.15 & 2.68 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+373945 & 77.3 & @xmath850.2 & 1.07 & 3.24 & 0.30 & 0.14 & 3.46 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+374092 & 80.2 & @xmath854.2 & 0.55 & 2.90 & 0.59 & 0.28 & 1.60 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+391328 & 169.1 & 3.6 & 0.88 & 2.62 & 0.37 & 0.18 & 2.30 & 0.50 & 0.36 + bd+404179 & 79.0 & 1.2 & 0.88 & 3.27 & 0.34 & 0.16 & 2.87 & 0.47 & 0.34 + bd+421286 & 166.1 & 4.3 & 0.56 & 3.12 & 0.53 & 0.26 & 1.75 & 0.47 & 0.34 [ table2 ] l c c c c c c c c c c hd1544 & 119.3 & @xmath850.6 & 0.44 & 3.19 & 0.73 & 0.35 & 0.37 & 2.79 & 0.67 & 0.31 + hd2083 & 120.9 & 9.0 & 0.29 & 3.69 & 1.01 & 0.48 & 0.26 & 3.99 & 0.70 & 0.33 + hd2905 & 120.8 & 0.1 & 0.33 & 3.24 & 1.20 & 0.57 & 0.30 & 0.82 & 1.05 & 0.49 + hd7252 & 125.7 & @xmath851.9 & 0.35 & 3.01 & 0.86 & 0.41 & 0.32 & 3.17 & 0.68 & 0.32 + hd12867 & 133.0 & @xmath853.7 & 0.41 & 2.72 & 0.74 & 0.35 & 0.38 & 2.84 & 0.63 & 0.30 + hd13969 & 134.5 & @xmath853.8 & 0.56 & 2.73 & 0.54 & 0.26 & 0.54 & 2.88 & 0.46 & 0.21 + hd14092 & 134.7 & @xmath854.1 & 0.49 & 2.52 & 0.62 & 0.30 & 0.46 & 2.61 & 0.55 & 0.26 + hd14250 & 134.8 & @xmath853.7 & 0.58 & 2.60 & 0.52 & 0.25 & 0.55 & 2.59 & 0.49 & 0.23 + hd14357 & 135.0 & @xmath853.9 & 0.56 & 3.90 & 0.56 & 0.27 & 0.49 & 3.28 & 0.54 & 0.25 + hd14818 & 135.6 & @xmath853.9 & 0.48 & 2.63 & 0.84 & 0.40 & 0.46 & 2.17 & 0.68 & 0.31 + hd14947 & 135.0 & @xmath851.8 & 0.77 & 2.96 & 0.39 & 0.19 & 0.76 & 2.50 & 0.37 & 0.17 + hd14956 & 135.4 & @xmath852.9 & 0.89 & 2.54 & 0.45 & 0.22 & 0.88 & 2.44 & 0.36 & 0.17 + hd16429 & 135.7 & 1.1 & 0.92 & 3.12 & 0.35 & 0.17 & 0.86 & 2.72 & 0.33 & 0.16 + hd17114 & 137.3 & @xmath850.3 & 0.76 & 2.85 & 0.40 & 0.19 & 0.73 & 2.92 & 0.35 & 0.16 + hd17603 & 138.8 & @xmath852.1 & 0.92 & 2.71 & 0.44 & 0.21 & 0.92 & 2.66 & 0.31 & 0.15 + hd18352 & 137.7 & 2.1 & 0.48 & 2.91 & 0.63 & 0.30 & 0.45 & 3.07 & 0.52 & 0.24 + hd24431 & 148.8 & @xmath850.7 & 0.69 & 2.79 & 0.44 & 0.21 & 0.65 & 2.64 & 0.41 & 0.19 + hd24912 & 160.4 & @xmath8513.1 & 0.29 & 3.45 & 1.36 & 0.65 & 0.26 & 3.78 & 0.75 & 0.36 + hd30614 & 144.1 & 14.0 & 0.30 & 3.01 & 1.33 & 0.63 & 0.34 & 3.07 & 0.74 & 0.35 + hd34078 & 172.1 & @xmath852.3 & 0.52 & 3.44 & 0.57 & 0.27 & 0.49 & 3.20 & 0.49 & 0.23 [ table3 ] | we present determinations of the total to selective extinction ratio @xmath0 and visual extinction @xmath1 values for milky way stars using ultraviolet color excesses .
we extend the analysis of @xcite by using non - equal weights derived from observational errors .
we present a detailed discussion of various statistical errors .
in addition , we estimate the level of systematic errors by considering different normalization of the extinction curve adopted by @xcite .
our catalog of 782 @xmath0 and @xmath1 values and their errors is available in the electronic form on the world wide web .
* key words : * catalogs dust , extinction galaxy : general ism : structure techniques : photometric |
in the last fifteen years , deep vla surveys have allowed to extend direct determinations of radio source counts down to @xmath2jy levels at 1.41 , 4.86 and 8.44 ghz . at these frequencies
, counts now cover about 7 orders of magnitude in flux and reach areal densities of several sources arcmin@xmath3 . at bright fluxes ,
the radio source population is dominated by classical , strongly evolving , powerful radio galaxies ( fanaroff - riley classes i and ii ) and quasars , whose counts begin to converge below @xmath4mjy .
the vla surveys , however , have revealed a flattening in differential source counts ( normalized to euclidean ones ) below a few mjy at 1.41 ghz ( condon & mitchell 1984 ) , at 4.86 ghz ( donnelly et al .
1987 ; fomalont et al .
1991 ) , and , most recently , also at 8.44 ghz ( windhorst et al . 1993 , 1995 ; partridge et al . 1997 ; kellermann et al .
1999 ; richards et al . 1998 ) .
several scenarios have been developed to interpret this `` excess '' in the number counts of faint radio sources : a non - evolving population of local ( @xmath5 ) low - luminosity galaxies ( wall et al .
1986 ) ; strongly evolving normal spirals ( condon 1984 , 1989 ) ; and actively star - forming galaxies ( windhorst et al .
1985 , 1987 ; danese et al . 1987
; rowan robinson et al . 1993 ) .
thus , the currently available deep source counts are more than sensitive enough to include any radio source of the familiar steep and `` flat''-spectrum classes contributing to fluctuations detectable by any of the forthcoming space borne cmb anisotropy experiments ( see toffolatti et al . ,
1998 ; de zotti & toffolatti , 1998 ) . extrapolations in flux density are not required : the real issue is the _ spectral behaviour _ of sources , since existing surveys extend only up to 8.4 ghz and hence a substantial extrapolation in frequency is necessary to reach the frequency bands of the map and planck surveyor missions .
the point has to be carefully discussed , since important spectral features , carrying information on physical conditions of sources , are expected at cm to mm wavelengths .
these include the transition from optically thick to thin synchrotron emission for `` flat''-spectrum sources , the steepening of the synchrotron spectrum due to radiation energy losses by the relativistic electrons , and the mm - wave excesses due to cold dust emission
. on the other hand , future space missions will also provide complete samples of the extremely interesting classes of extragalactic radio sources characterized by inverted spectra ( i.e. flux density increasing with frequency ) , which are very difficult to detect in radio frequency surveys .
strongly inverted spectra up to tens of ghz can be produced in very compact , high electron density regions , by synchrotron or free - free absorption .
this is the case for ghz peaked spectrum radio sources ( gps ) , which are currently receiving an increasing amount of interest . also of great interest
are advection dominated sources ( ads ) , which turn out to have a particularly hard radio emission spectrum . in
@xmath6 we briefly discuss the spectral properties , at mm and sub - mm wavelengths , of the different classes of sources mentioned above . in
@xmath7 we deal with number counts while , in
@xmath8 , we present estimates of the angular power spectrum of intensity and polarization fluctuations due to discrete extragalactic sources and discuss the effect of clustering . in @xmath9 we summarize our main conclusions .
the observed spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of `` flat-''spectrum radio sources ( compact radio galaxies , radio loud qsos , bl lacs ) generally have a gap at mm / sub - mm wavelengths ( see figure [ figsed ] ) .
those sources which have data in this interval frequently show a dip in the mm region , indicative of a cross - over of two components .
the spectral shape carries a good deal of extremely interesting information on the physical properties of sources . for example , in flow models of compact radio sources the spectrum steepens at the frequency at which the radiative cooling time equals the outflow time ( cf .
begelman et al . 1984 )
; for `` hot spots '' , this typically lies in the millimeter or far - ir part of the spectrum , while , in cocoons or extended regions of lower surface brightness , the break moves down to lower frequencies . according to the basic model of blandford & rees ( 1974 ) and scheuer ( 1974 ) , which is supported by a large body of observational evidence , the spectral break frequency , @xmath10 , at which the synchrotron spectrum steepens , is related to the magnetic field @xmath11 and to the `` synchrotron age '' @xmath12 ( in myr ) by @xmath13ghz .
thus , the systematic multifrequency study at the planck and map frequencies will provide a statistical estimate of the radio source ages and of the evolution of the spectrum with cosmic time : both are pieces of information of great physical importance .
various evolutionary models of the radio emission spectrum have been proposed based on different assumptions ( `` one - shot '' or continuous injection of relativistic electrons , complete or no isotropization of the pitch - angle distribution ; see myers & spangler 1985 for a summary ) .
these models strongly differ in the form of the falloff above @xmath10 ; hence measurements at mm and sub - mm wavelengths will provide crucial information on the physical effects operating in radio sources . also , many compact `` flat''-spectrum sources are observed to become optically thin at high radio frequencies .
correspondingly , their spectral index steepens to values ( @xmath14 ) typical of extended , optically thin sources . in the case of blazars ( brown et al .
1989 ) the component dominating at cm wavelengths is rather `` quiescent '' ( variations normally occur on timescales of years ) and has a spectral turnover at @xmath155 cm , where the transition between optically thick and optically thin synchrotron emission occurs . at higher frequencies
the emission is dominated by a violently variable `` flaring '' component , which rises and decays on timescales of days to weeks , and has a spectral turnover at mm / sub - mm wavelengths .
the `` quiescent '' emission may be identified with emission from the bulk of a relativistic jet aligned close to the line of sight , while the flaring component may arise in smaller regions of enhanced emission within the jet , where emitting electrons are injected or reaccelerated .
the study of the flaring component is clearly central to understanding the mechanisms reponsible for variability in radio loud active nuclei ; the mm / sub - mm region is crucial in this respect , since it is in this region that the flare spectra become self absorbed .
it is known from vlbi studies that the apparently smooth `` flat '' spectra of compact radio sources are in fact the combination of emissions from a number of components with varying synchrotron self absorption turnover frequencies which are higher for the denser knots . it may be argued ( lawrence 1997 ) that the mm / sub - mm region measures sub - parsec scale , unresolved regions , including the radio core .
excess far - ir / sub - mm emission , possibly due to dust , is often observed from radio galaxies ( knapp & patten 1991 ) .
planck data will allow to assess whether this is a general property of these sources ; this would have interesting implications for the presence of interstellar matter in the host galaxies , generally identified with giant ellipticals , which are usually thought to be devoid of interstellar matter
. observations of large mm fluxes attributed to dust emissions have been reported for several distant radio galaxies ( see mazzei & de zotti , 1996 and references therein ) .
the inferred dust masses are 12 orders of magnitude higher than found for nearby radio galaxies .
the two components ( synchrotron and dust emission ) may well have different evolution properties .
current predictions on number counts do not explicitly include sources with strongly inverted spectra , peaking at mm wavelengths , that would be either missing from , or strongly underepresented in low frequency surveys and may be difficult to distinguish spectrally from fluctuations in the cmb ( crawford et al .
1996 ) .
the recent study of ghz peaked spectrum radio sources ( gps ) by odea and baum ( 1997 ) has revealed a fairly flat distribution of peak frequencies extending out to 15 ghz in the rest frame , suggesting the existence of an hitherto unknown population of sources peaking at high frequency ( see also lasenby 1996 ) .
the host galaxies appear to be a homogeneus class of giant ellipticals with old stellar populations whereas gps quasars present a different redshift distribution and have radio morphologies quite unlike those of gps galaxies ( snellen et al .
1998a , b , c ) .
it is very hard to guess how common such sources may be .
snellen ( 1997 ) exploited the sample of de vries et al .
( 1997 ) to estimate a count of @xmath16 for sources having peak frequencies between 1 and 8 ghz and peak flux densities between 2 and 6 jy .
he also found that counts of gps sources are only slowly decreasing with increasing peak frequency in that range .
if indeed the distribution of peak frequencies extends up to several tens ghz keeping relatively flat , it is conceivable that from several tens to hundreds of gps sources will be detected by planck , whereas map could detect only a few of them .
therefore , although these rare source will not be a threat for studies of cmb anisotropies , we may expect that planck surveys will provide crucial information about their properties .
gps sources are important because they may be the younger stages of radio source evolution ( fanti et al .
1995 ; readhead et al .
1996 ) and may thus provide insight into the genesis and evolution of radio sources ; alternatively , they may be sources which are kept very compact by unusual conditions ( high density and/or turbulence ) in the interstellar medium of the host galaxy ( van breugel et al .
1984 ) .
another very interesting class of inverted spectrum radio sources , is that characterized by advection - dominated emission ( narayan & yi 1995 ; fabian & rees 1995 ; di matteo & fabian 1997 ) .
convincing observational evidence for the presence of super - massive black - holes ( bh ) in many nearby galaxies have been accumulating in recent years ( kormendy & richstone 1995 ; magorrian et al .
1998 ; ho 1999 ) .
these data seem to imply that an important , possibly dominant , fraction of all massive galaxies with appreciable spheroidal component ( hence the e / s0 galaxies in particular , but also early - type spirals ) host a black - hole with a mass roughly proportional to that of the hosting spheroid .
franceschini et al .
( 1998 ) have found a tight relationship between the bh mass and both the nuclear and total radio flux at centimetric wavelengths .
the radio flux turns out to be proportional to @xmath17 .
this is consistent with the radio centimetric flux being contributed by cyclo - synchrotron emission in an advection - dominated accretion flow .
the latter should correspond to a situation in which the accretion rate is low , as typically expected for the low - density ism in local early type galaxies .
a property that distinguishes this emission is an inverted spectrum with spectral index @xmath18 up to a frequency of 100200 ghz , followed by fast convergence ( far - ir and optical emission is expected to be very weak ) .
based on the analysis by franceschini et al .
( 1998 ) , we would expect that some sources of this kind may detected by planck at 70 and 100 ghz .
this assumes that the advection flows evolves in redshift @xmath19 , as suggested by analyses of faint radio - optical samples of e / s0 s . in spite of the limited statistics
, this would be a way to test for the presence of massive bh s and of the evolution of the ism in galaxies up to moderate redshifts .
high frequency free - free cutoffs may be present in agn spectra
. ionized gas in the nuclear region absorbs radio photons up to a frequency : @xmath20 free - free absorption cutoffs at frequencies @xmath21ghz may indeed be expected , in the framework of the standard torus scenario for type 1 and type 2 agn , for radio cores seen edge on , and may have been observed in some cases ( barvainis & lonsdale , 1998 ) .
they provide constraints on physical conditions in the parsec scale accretion disk or infall region for the nearest sources of this kind .
source counts are presently available only at cm wavelengths . in carrying out extrapolations to mm wavelengths ,
several effects need to be taken into account .
on one side , the majority of sources with flat or inverted spectra at 5 ghz have spectral turnovers below 90 ghz ( kellermann & pauliny - toth 1971 ; owen & mufson 1977 ) .
this is not surprising since , as noted above , astrophysical processes work to steepen the high frequency source spectra . on the other side
, high frequency surveys preferentially select sources with harder spectra . for power law differential source counts , @xmath22 , and a gaussian spectral index distribution with mean @xmath23 and dispersion @xmath24 , the counts at a frequency @xmath25 are given by @xmath26 with ( kellermann 1964 ; condon 1984 ) : @xmath27 .
estimates neglecting the dispersion of spectral indices underestimate the counts by a factor @xmath28 $ ] . the spectral index distribution between 5 and 90 ghz determined by holdaway et al .
( 1994 ) has @xmath29 ; for euclidean counts , @xmath30 , the correction then amounts to about a factor of 3 .
a good fraction of the observed spread of spectral indices is due to variability whose rms amplitude , in the case of blazars , increases with frequency , reaching a factor of about 1.5 at a few hundred ghz ( impey & neugebauer 1988 ) . in some cases , variations by a factor of 2 to 3 , or more , have been observed ( e.g. 3c345 : stevens et al .
1996 ; pks@xmath31 : zhang et al . 1994 ; @xmath32 and 3c279 : reich et al .
the highest frequency outbursts are expected to be associated to the earliest phases of the flare evolution . since the rise of the flare is often rather abrupt ( timescale of weeks ) ,
they were probably frequently missed . in view of the uncertainties on the spectra of radio selected agns , and the poor knowledge on number counts and spectral properties of inverted spectrum sources discussed in
2 , an accurate modelling of radio source counts at @xmath33 ghz is currently impossible .
however , the simple model adopted by toffolatti et al .
( 1998 ) appears to be remarkably successful .
these authors adopted the luminosity evolution scheme of danese et al .
( 1987 ) , who considered three classes of sources : powerful radio galaxies and radio loud quasars ( distinguishing between extended , steep spectrum , and compact , flat `` '' spectrum sources ) , and evolving starburst / interacting galaxies . the average spectral index , @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) , of `` flat spectrum '' sources was taken to be @xmath36 for @xmath37 ghz , with a steepening to @xmath38 at higher frequencies . as for `` steep''spectrum sources ( elliptical , s0 and starburst galaxies ) , whose contribution to source counts is actually minor in the whole frequency range of interest in connection with the map and planck missions , the radio power
spectral index relation determined by peacock and gull ( 1981 ) was adopted .
this simple recipe has allowed to reproduce , without any adjustment of the parameters , the deep counts at 8.44 ghz ( windhorst et al .
1993 ; partridge et al .
1997 ) , which were produced several years after the model ( see figure 2 ) .
this scenario , implying a substantial contribution of active star - forming galaxies to sub - mjy counts at cm wavelengths , is consistent with the results by kron et al .
( 1985 ) and thuan & condon ( 1987 ) indicating that the optical counterparts of sub - mjy sources are mainly faint blue galaxies , often showing peculiar optical morphologies indicative of high star formation activity and of interaction and merging phenomena . moreover , the spectra are similar to those of the star forming galaxies detected by iras ( franceschini et al .
1988 ; benn et al . 1993 ) . on the other hand
, a recent work by gruppioni , mignoli & zamorani ( 1999 ) , reaching a fainter magnitude limit in the spectroscopic identifications of sources selected at 1.4 ghz with a flux limit of 0.2 mjy , finds that the majority of their radio sources are likely to be early type galaxies .
optical identifications of sources at @xmath2jy flux levels ( hammer et al . 1995 ; windhorst et al .
, 1995 ; richards et al . , 1998 ) show that they are made mainly of star - forming galaxies , with a smaller fraction of ellipticals , late - type galaxies with nuclear activity and local spiral galaxies .
it may be noted that the counts predicted by toffolatti et al .
( 1998 ) at frequencies above 100 ghz may be somewhat depressed by the assumption of a spectral break at 200 ghz for all `` flat''-spectrum sources while examples are known of sources with a flat or inverted spectrum up to 1000 ghz .
in view of this , we updated the the baseline model of toffolatti et al . by assuming that the steepening of the spectral indices to @xmath38 occurs at @xmath39 ghz .
sokasian et al .
( 1999 ) have produced skymaps of bright radio sources at frequencies up to 300 ghz by means of detailed individual fits of the spectra of a large number of sources compiled from several catalogs , including the all sky sample of sources with @xmath40jy ( khr et al .
their estimated number of sources brighter than @xmath41jy is about a factor of two below that predicted by toffolatti et al .
a very similar result was obtained by holdaway et al .
( 1994 ) based on the observed distribution of 8.4@xmath42ghz spectral indices . on the other hand ,
these empirical estimates yield , strictly speaking , lower limits , since sources with inverted spectra may be under - represented in the primary sample .
furthermore , in the presence of substantial variability , estimates using mean fluxes underpredict actual counts of bright sources . a comparison of the @xmath43@xmath44 of radio sources with the predicted ones for dusty galaxies ( even allowing for very different evolutionary scenarios : de zotti et al . 1999 , their figure 1 ) shows an abrupt change in the populations of bright sources observed in channels above and below @xmath45 mm : radio sources dominate at the longer wavelengths and dusty galaxies at the shorter ones .
this is due to the steep increase with frequency of the dust emission spectrum in the mm / sub - mm region ( typically @xmath46 ) , which makes the crossover between radio and dust emission components only weakly dependent on their relative intensities ; moreover , dust temperatures tend to be higher for distant high luminosity sources , partially compensating for the effect of redshift . at , say , @xmath47300 ghz dusty galaxies
dominate the number counts of extragalactic sources .
we only briefly remind the point in the next subsection and defer to the comprehensive reviews of guiderdoni et al .
( 1999 ) and of mann et al .
( 1999 ) for a thorough discussion .
although the situation is rapidly improving , thanks to the deep iso counts at @xmath48 m ( kawara et al . 1997 ; puget et al .
1999 ) , to the preliminary counts at @xmath49 m with scuba on jcmt ( see mann et al . 1999 , for a review on the subject ) and to the important constraints from measurements of the far - ir to mm extragalactic background ( schlegel et al . 1998 ; hauser et al . 1998
; fixsen et al .
1998 ) , first detected by puget et al . ( 1996 ) , current estimates are affected by bigger uncertainties than in the case of radio sources . in fact ,
predicted counts have a higher responsiveness to the poorly known evolutionary properties , because of the boosting effect of the strongly negative k corrections .
the most extensive surveys , carried out by iras at @xmath50 m , cover a limited range in flux and are rather uncertain at the faint end ( hacking & houck 1987 ; gregorich et al .
1995 ; bertin et al .
it is then not surprising that predictions of recent models differ by substantial factors .
again , substantial extrapolations in frequency are required , and have to deal with the poor knowledge of the spectrum of galaxies in the mm / sub - mm region ; the @xmath51mm/@xmath50 m flux ratios of galaxies are observed to span about a factor of 10 ( chini et al .
1995 ; franceschini & andreani 1995 ) .
the effect of radio sources as a limiting factor for the detection of primordial cmb anisotropies has been extensively analyzed by many authors ( see , e.g. , franceschini et al .
1989 ; blain & longair 1993 ; danese et al .
1996 ; gawiser & smoot 1997 ) .
more recently , detailed analyses of the problem have been worked out by toffolatti et al .
( 1998 ) for the planck surveyor mission , and by refregier , spergel & herbig ( 1999 ) for the map mission .
the relevant formalism is readily available in the literature ( see , e.g. , de zotti et al . 1996 ; tegmark & efstathiou 1996 ; toffolatti et al .
1998 ; scott & white 1999 ) and we skip it here .
a poisson distribution of extragalactic point sources produces a simple white - noise power spectrum , with the same power in all multipoles , so that their contribution to fluctuations in a unit logarithmic multipole interval increases with @xmath52 as @xmath53 ( for large values of @xmath52 ) , while , at least for the standard inflationary models , which are consistent with the available anisotropy detections , the function @xmath54 yielded by primordial cmb fluctuations is approximately constant for @xmath55 , then oscillates and finally decreases quasi exponentially for @xmath56 ( @xmath57 ) .
hence confusion noise due to discrete sources will dominate at small enough angular scales .
figure 3 shows the expected angular power spectra of the extragalactic foregrounds components at 30 , 100 and 217 ghz , corresponding to the central frequencies of three planck channels ; also , map has channels centered at 30 and 94 ghz .
the two lines for each population ( radio sources and far - ir sources ) are obtained assuming that sources can be identified and removed down to fluxes of 1 or 0.1 jy .
radio sources give the most relevant contribution to cmb fluctuations up to , say , @xmath58 ghz , whereas dusty galaxies dominate at higher frequencies . at 217 ghz , the poisson fluctuation level due to far - ir selected sources predicted by the model of guiderdoni et al .
( 1998 ) is higher than that of radio selected sources , whereas it falls below the radio component if we adopt the toffolatti et al . model . as discussed by de zotti et al .
( 1999 ) , the latter model falls somewhat short of the best current estimate of the far - ir to mm extragalactic background ( fixsen et al .
1998 ) , while model e by guiderdoni et al . tends to exceed it .
figure 3 also indicates that source removal is much more effective in reducing the poisson fluctuation level at @xmath59 mm .
in fact , in this wavelength range fluctuations are dominated by the brightest sources below the detection limit , while at shorter wavelengths the dominant population are evolving dusty galaxies whose counts are so steep that a major contribution to fluctuations comes from fainter fluxes . -10pt
-20pt fluctuations in the galactic emissions at @xmath60 are also plotted in figure 3 , for comparison .
they are represented by long@xmath61short dashes ( dust ) , dots@xmath61short dashes ( free - free ) , and dots@xmath61long dashes [ synchrotron : we have plotted both the power spectrum derived by tegmark & efstathiou ( 1996 ) , @xmath62 , and that observed in the tenerife patch , @xmath63 ( lasenby 1996 ) ; the latter is significantly lower than the former in the range of scales where it has actually been measured , but has a flatter slope so that it may become relatively more important on small scales ] .
the heavy dashed line flattening at large @xmath52 shows the power spectrum of anisotropies due to the sunyaev - zeldovich effect computed by atrio - barandela & mcket ( 1998 ) adopting a lower limit of @xmath64 for cluster masses , a present ratio @xmath65 , and @xmath66 . for @xmath67 ,
corresponding to angular scales @xmath68 [ @xmath69 , diffuse galactic emissions dominate total foreground fluctuations even at high galactic latitudes .
these are minimum at @xmath70ghz ( kogut 1996 ) . for larger values of @xmath52
the dominant contribution is from extragalactic sources ; their minimum contribution to the anisotropy signal occurs around 150 - 200@xmath71ghz .
therefore , the minimum in the global power spectrum of foreground fluctuations moves , at high galactic latitudes , from about 70 ghz for @xmath67 , to 150 - 200@xmath71ghz at higher values of @xmath52 .
the detailed spectral and evolutionary behaviour of sources determines the exact value of the frequency of the minimum foreground fluctuations ; such frequency decreases with decreasing galactic latitude ( de zotti et al .
1999 ) . on the other hand , in the frequency range 50200 ghz , a higher contamination level due to source confusion could be produced by a still undetected population of sources whose emission peaks at @xmath72 ghz ( gawiser , jaffe & silk , 1999 ) .
anyway , the discussion in 1 and 2 indicates that _ unknown _ source populations are unlikely to give a fluctuation level much higher than the presently estimated one .
toffolatti et al . (
1998 ) found that clustering contribution to fluctuations due to extragalactic sources is generally small in comparison with the poisson contribution .
however , the latter , in the case of radio sources , comes mostly from the brightest sources below the detection limit , while the clustering term is dominated by fainter sources .
therefore , an efficient subtraction of radio sources decreases the poisson term much more effectively than the clustering term , which therefore becomes relatively more and more important . in the case of a power law
angular correlation function ( @xmath73 ) , the power spectrum of intensity fluctuations is @xmath74 ( peebles 1980 ; eq .
if this behaviour extends to large enough angular scales , i.e. to small enough values of @xmath52 , the clustering signal , for a power law index not much steeper than the canonical value @xmath75 , will ultimately become larger than the poisson anisotropy . on the other hand , for large values of @xmath76
, @xmath77 is expected to drop below the above power law approximation , and @xmath78 will correspondingly break down . the preliminary estimates ( toffolatti et al .
, in preparation ) reported in figure 4 are based on the correlation functions of radio sources derived by loan et al .
( 1997 ) and by magliocchetti et al .
the different slopes at large values of @xmath52 reflect different values of @xmath79 : the upper curve correspond to the larger value ( @xmath80 ) obtained by magliocchetti et al .
( 1999 ) .
scott & white ( 1999 ) have recently shown that if dusty galaxies cluster like the @xmath81 lyman break galaxies ( giavalisco et al .
1998 ) , at frequencies @xmath82ghz the anisotropies due to clustering may exceed the poisson ones on all scales accessible to planck ; in the 353@xmath71ghz ( @xmath49 m ) channel the clustering signal may exceed the primordial cmb anisotropies on scales smaller than about @xmath83
. it should be noted , however , that current models ( toffolatti et al .
1998 ; guiderdoni et al .
1998 ) strongly suggest a broad redshift distribution of sources contributing to the autocorrelation function of the intensity fluctuations , implying a strong dilution of the clustering signal .
a further substantial overestimate of the effect of clustering may follow from the extrapolation to degree scales , with constant slope , of the angular correlation function determined on scales of up to a few arcmin . our preliminary estimate shown in figure 4 ,
has been obtained by assuming that the angular correlation function of lyman break galaxies substantially steepens at @xmath84 , consistent with the data of giavalisco et al .
( 1998 ) .
the polarized spectra have not been studied as extensively as the intensity spectra . for a power law electron energy spectrum @xmath85 , the polarization level , @xmath86 , yielded by a uniform magnetic field is @xmath87 ( leroux 1961 ) . for a typical high frequency value of @xmath88 , @xmath89 .
non - uniformities of the magnetic fields and differential faraday rotation decrease the polarization level .
however , the faraday rotation optical depth is proportional to @xmath90 so that faraday depolarization is negligible at the high frequencies relevant for planck and map .
bouchet et al .
( 1998 ) have analized the possibility of extracting the power spectrum of cmb polarization fluctuations in the presence of polarized galactic foregrounds using a multifrequency wiener filtering of the data .
they concluded that the power spectrum of e - mode polarization of the cmb can be extracted from planck data with fractional errors @xmath9130% for @xmath92 .
the b - mode cmb polarization , whose detection would unambiguously establish the presence of tensor perturbations ( primordial gravitational waves ) , can be detected by planck with signal - to - noise @xmath934 for @xmath94 by averaging over a 20% logarithmic range in multipoles .
polarization of extragalactic radio sources , not considered by bouchet et al .
( 1998 ) , is an important issue as well .
flat spectrum radio sources are typically 4 - 7% polarized at cm and mm wavelengths ( nartallo et al .
1998 ; aller et al . 1999 ) . for random orientations of the magnetic fields of sources along the field of view ,
the rms polarization fluctuations are approximately equal to intensity fluctuations times the mean polarization degree ( de zotti et al .
, in preparation ) .
our preliminary estimate of figure 5 assumes a mean polarization of radio sources of 5% , close to the main peak of the percentage polarization distribution of the sample studied by nartallo et al .
( 1998 ) .
measurements of polarized thermal emission from dust are only available for interstellar clouds in our own galaxy .
the distribution of observed polarization degrees of dense clouds at 100@xmath95 m shows a peak at @xmath96 ( hildebrand 1996 ) .
we have adopted this value for mean polarization of dusty galaxies at mm / sub - mm wavelengths ; this is likely to be an upper limit since the global percentage polarization from a galaxy is the average of contributions from regions with different polarizing efficiencies and different orientations of the magnetic field with respect to the plane of the sky ; all this works to decrease the polarization level in comparison with the mean of individual clouds . at 217 ghz the power spectrum obtained on the basis of the source counts of guiderdoni et al .
( model e ) is also shown ( upper thin dashed line ) .
note that , since the emission of radio sources appears to be more polarized than that of dusty galaxies , radio sources give the dominant contribution to extragalactic polarization fluctuations up to 217 ghz .
anyway , figure 5 shows that the main limitations to cmb polarization measurements come from galactic emissions , not from extragalactic sources .
a brief summary on polarization fluctuations of galactic emissions can be found in de zotti et al .
the power spectrum of the polarized component of galactic synchrotron emission , shown in fig .
5 , has been obtained from the corresponding temperature fluctuation power spectrum ( as estimated by tegmark & efstathiou 1996 ) assuming the signal to be 40% polarized . as for dust emission ,
we have taken up the estimates by prunet et al .
( 1998 ) for the e - mode ; the extrapolations to to 100 and 30 ghz are made adopting their dust emission spectrum .
free - free emission is not polarized .
however , thompson scattering by electrons in the hii regions where it is produced , may polarize it tangentially to the edges of the electron cloud ( keating et al .
the polarization level is expected to be small , with an upper limit of approximately 10% for an optically thick cloud .
the very deep vla surveys have allowed to extend radio source counts down to @xmath2jy levels at @xmath97 cm ; the bulk of radio sources in the universe have probably been detected ( haarsma & partridge 1998 ) .
on the other hand , estimates of the counts and of fluctuations due to extragalactic sources at mm / sub - mm wavelengths are made uncertain by the poor knowledge of their spectral properties in this spectral region as well as by the possibility that source populations with strongly inverted spectra may show up . however , as mentioned in 3 , estimates based on very different approaches agree to within a factor of 2 up to @xmath98ghz .
conservative estimates indicate that , in the frequency range 50200 ghz , extragalactic foreground fluctuations are well below the expected amplitude of cmb fluctuations on all angular scales covered by the planck and map missions .
current data on the angular correlation function of radio sources imply that fluctuations due to clustering are generally small in comparison with poisson fluctuations ; however , the relative importance of the former increases if sources are subtracted from the sky maps down to faint flux levels .
the polarized emission of extragalactic sources will not be a threat for measurements of the polarized component of primordial cmb anisotropies ; much stronger limitations come from galactic synchrotron and dust emissions .
moreover , future space mission like planck ( and , to a lesser extent , map ) will not only provide all sky maps of the primordial cmb anisotropies but also unique information on the physics of compact radio sources and in particular on the physical conditions in the most compact components ( transition from optically thick to optically thin synchrotron emission , ageing of relativistic electrons , high frequency flares ) and on their relationship with emissions at higher energies ( ssc versus ec models ) .
they will also allow us to study the population properties of inverted spectrum sources like gps , sources with high frequency free - free self absorption , ads , etc .. lt thanks the organizing committee and the sloan foundation for their warm hospitality .
we thank b. guiderdoni for kindly providing us with the source counts predicted by his model e. the angular power spectrum of cmb anisotropies has been calculated by cmbfast 2.4.1 ( seljak u. , & zaldarriaga m. , 1996 ) .
we gratefully acknowledge the long - standing , very fruitful collaboration on extragalactic foregrounds with l. danese , a. franceschini and p. mazzei .
we thank n. mandolesi for useful discussions on the capabilities of the planck surveyor mission and g.l .
granato for kindly providing us with figure 1 .
lt also thanks f. bouchet , r.d .
davies , e. gawiser , e. guerra , b. partridge , a. refregier and d. scott for helpful discussions and comments during his stay in princeton .
this research has been supported in part by grants from asi and cnr .
lt acknowledges partial financial support from the spanish dges , project pb951132c0202 , and spanish cicyt accin especial n. esp98 - 1545-e . | confusion noise due to extragalactic sources is a fundamental astrophysical limitation for experiments aimed at accurately determining the power spectrum of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) down to arcmin angular scales and with a sensitivity @xmath0 . at frequencies
@xmath1 ghz , the most relevant extragalactic foreground hampering the detection of intrinsic cmb anisotropies is constituted by radio loud active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , including `` flat spectrum '' radiogalaxies , quasars , bl - lacs and blazars .
we review our present understanding of astrophysical properties , spectra , and number counts of the above classes of sources .
we also study the angular power spectrum of fluctuations due both to poisson distributed and clustered radio sources and give preliminary predictions on the power spectrum of their polarized components .
furthermore , we discuss the capabilities of future space missions ( nasa s map , bennett et al . 1995 ; esa s planck surveyor , bersanelli et al .
1996 ) in studying bright radio sources over an almost unexplored frequency interval where spectral signatures , essential for the understanding of the physical processes , show up . |
the photo- and electro - production of kaons on the proton in the resonance region have been studied both experimentally and theoretically since the 1960s .
many data were collected on the kaon photo - production ( cornell , cal tech , bonn , tokyo , desy , and orsay , see @xcite ) but only a few experiments were carried - out on the electro - production ( harvard - cornell , desy , and cambridge , see @xcite and references therein ) . simulated by the availability of new facilities with higher current or / and high duty factor and polarization capability ( jlab , bonn , grenoble ) , more precise data on both reactions have been accumulated starting in the late of 1990s which renewed interest in the subject .
now various response functions are accessible and measured with a good level of precision .
the latest experimental data , especially those from jlab @xcite on the separated cross sections in the electro - production in the kinematic region where scarce data were formerly available , allow to perform more rigorous tests of theoretical models and in this way improve our understanding of the elementary process .
numerous theoretical attempts have been made to describe the electro - magnetic production of kaons with @xmath2 in the final state . in the kinematic region , @xmath3 gev ,
the isobaric models @xcite are of particular interest . in these models
the amplitude is derived from an effective hadronic lagrangian using the feynman diagram technique in the tree level approximation .
however , it has been shown that the new data on @xmath4 @xcite can be equally well described by the regge model @xcite which is based on the idea of exchanges of families of the particles with particular quantum numbers in the t - channel .
the regge model was aimed mainly for higher energies ( @xmath5 gev ) and small angles .
however , the model was successfully applied to description of the electro - production data at the centre of mass energy @xmath6 gev @xcite . in the isobaric models the invariant amplitude gains contributions from the extended born diagrams , in which the proton , @xmath2 , @xmath7 , and kaon are exchanged in the intermediate state , and the resonant diagrams which include exchanges of moderate mass ( less than 2 gev ) nucleon , hyperon , and kaon resonances .
unfortunately , due to absence of a dominant exchanged baryon resonance in the process @xcite , in contrast with the pion and eta production , many of exchanged resonances have to be _ a priori _ assumed to contribute @xcite introducing a rather large number of free parameters in calculations , the appropriate coupling constants .
the free parameters are determined by fitting the cross sections and polarizations to the experimental data which , however , provides a copious number of possible sets of parameters @xcite .
this large number of models which describe the data equally well can be reduced implementing duality hypothesis , crossing symmetry , and su(3 ) symmetry constrains .
according to duality principle most of the nucleon resonances exchanged in the s - channel , especially those with a high spin , can be mimic by the lowest - mass kaon poles k@xmath8 and k@xmath9 in the t - channel @xcite .
the crossing symmetry constraint requires that a realistic model must yield simultaneously a reasonable description of the radiative capture of k@xmath10 on the proton with the lambda in the final state , which is related to the @xmath11 via the crossing symmetry @xcite .
the flavor su(3 ) symmetry allows to relate the main coupling constants @xmath12 and @xmath13 to the better established one , @xmath14 . for the 20% breaking of the su(3 ) symmetry the following limits can be obtained : @xmath15 and @xmath16 @xcite .
analysis of data performed under different assumptions about duality , crossing and su(3 ) symmetry @xcite showed that a moderate number of resonances is sufficient to get a reasonable agreement with the experimental data .
the models discussed above assume point - like particles in the hadron vertexes to ensure the gauge invariance principle .
recently haberzettl _ et al . _
@xcite introduced hadron form factors in the gauge - invariant way in an isobaric model which required addition of a contact term to compensate the gauge - violating part of the amplitude .
the method was worked out recently by davidson and workman @xcite and further used by janssen _
taking into account the hadron form factors led to reducing of divergences at higher energies inherent to most of isobaric models and also to more realistic predictions for the isospin - symmetry related @xmath17 channel @xcite .
another simplification assumed by the models is neglecting a meson - baryon re - scattering in the final state which obviously leads to violation of unitarity .
interaction of hadrons in the final state was taking into account for the photo - production reaction by feuster and mosel @xcite employing the k - matrix approximation . enforcing unitarity dynamically
was performed by chiang _
_ @xcite who utilised the coupled - channel approach . in their analysis
they concluded that inclusion of the @xmath18n system in the intermediate state is needed for a proper description of the @xmath11 reaction .
more elementary approaches to study the reaction mechanism of @xmath11 was performed in terms of quark degrees of freedom in refs .
these models being in a closer connection with qcd than those based on the hadron degrees of freedom , need a smaller number of parameters to describe the data . moreover
, the quark models assume explicitly an extended structure of the hadrons which was found to be important for a reasonable description of the photo - production data @xcite . other approach to the @xmath11 reaction based on the chiral perturbation theory @xcite
is applicable to the threshold region only .
this paper is aimed to discuss existing isobaric and regge models for the electro - magnetic production of k@xmath19 off the proton particularly in view of the new experimental data @xcite .
we intend to pick up among the models those reliable in the kinematic region of the e98 - 108 experiment @xcite for further comparison with the coming data .
the experiment e98 - 108 which was carried out in hall a at jefferson lab in 2001 and 2002 extends the present data on the separated cross sections of the @xmath4 reaction to higher energies and larger @xmath20 ( @xmath21 ) providing very good quality data and consequently it can set stringent constraints on the models . in the next section we briefly outline the models . in the section 3
we discuss predictions of the models in comparison with the new data .
in comparison performed here we adopted a set of isobaric models , which are sufficiently well described in literature to enable performing calculations , and the regge model .
we also adopted results of the model by bennhold _
_ utilising the `` new isobar model ( dec 2000 ) '' interactive code at the kaon - maid web - page @xcite .
those , trivial , isobaric models which assume only the born terms ( ab1 @xcite and aw1 @xcite ) were omitted from the analysis .
the isobaric models selected for the comparison can be grouped according to the reaction they were determined for : + 1 .
photo - production only : ab2 @xcite , aw2 @xcite , as1 , as2 @xcite , w1 and w2 @xcite .
electro - production only : aw3 @xcite .
photo- and electro - production : aw4 @xcite , c3 @xcite , c4(wjc ) @xcite , sl @xcite and sla @xcite .
the models in the first group have to be extended for @xmath4 assuming a particular prescription for the electro - magnetic form factors of the mesons and baryons .
results of these models for the electro - production , therefore , depends to some extent on an ansatz we made for the electro - magnetic form factors and in this limited sense the models are predictive . in this analysis we used phenomenological prescriptions @xcite fixed by the electron scattering .
the meson form factors were supposed to be of the monopole form with @xmath22 gev for all mesons whereas the dipole form , with @xmath23 and @xmath24 gev , was used for all baryons .
unfortunately , there are several models , aw3 , aw4 , c3 , and c4 , which were not sufficiently well commented in the original paper and for which either a definition or a form of the electro - magnetic form factors is not clear . in that cases we tried several possibilities to introduce the form factors .
finally we have chosen those which provide the best agreement with original results .
that is why in the case of aw3 and aw4 models we employ the phenomenological prescriptions as used in ref .
@xcite and discussed above . in the case of the williams - ji - cotanch models , c3 and c4 ( wjc ) , we find it interesting to compare the original prescription in which the electric ( @xmath25 ) and magnetic ( @xmath26 ) form factors are used in the electro - magnetic vertexes , we denote it as c3_4 and c4_4 hereafter , with the definition commonly used @xcite in which dirac ( @xmath27 ) and pauli ( @xmath28 ) form factors are substituted in a gauge - invariant way @xcite , we denote it as c3_2 and c4_2 . in both cases
the gari and krumpelmann prescription , the extended vector meson dominance model @xcite , was utilised for the baryon form factors and the vector meson dominance model as discussed by williams _
@xcite was used for mesons . in tables 1 and 2
coupling constants are listed for the isobaric models adopted here .
the effective parameters @xmath29 , e.g. @xmath30 for the baryon exchanges and @xmath31 for the meson ones , are shown except for the main coupling constants for which @xmath32 and @xmath33 are stated .
values of the parameters can be directly compared since they are properly normalised according to definition of vertexes and units used here .
since the observable quantities are bilinear forms of the cgln amplitudes which are linear in the strong coupling constants in the tree level approximation the whole set of the constants may be multiplied by an arbitrary global phase , e.g. -1 . in this way
we can arrive with the same sign for the main coupling constant @xmath34 which then makes a comparison more transparent .
.coupling constants of the isobaric models for the photo - production of kaons .
some of the sets of the coupling constants were multiplied by -1 . to get the negative sign at @xmath34 . [ cols="<,>,>,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] to reveal behaviour of the models in the kinematic region relevant for the e98 - 108 experiment , @xmath35 gev and @xmath36 gev@xmath37 , in figs .
[ r6b ] and [ r6c ] we compare predictions of the models for the unpolarised cross section @xmath38 with old data by bebek _
@xcite , brown _ et al . _
@xcite , and brauel _ et al .
_ @xcite . in figure [ r6c ] the data point at @xmath39 gev@xmath37 @xcite is out of the physical region , for @xmath40 gev starting at @xmath41 gev@xmath37 , which is probably due to scaling the data from larger energies ( @xmath42 gev@xmath37 for @xmath43 gev ) . in figure [ r6b ] calculations
were performed at @xmath44 gev , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 deg .
only the best predictions are shown in the both figures .
the models aw3 , aw4 , sla , maid , and regge can provide very good results for the @xmath20-dependence , fig . [ r6b ] . results of the models differ mainly at small @xmath20 again where more precise data would be useful . here
the maid model displays a pronounced bump structure similar to that for the separated cross sections ( fig .
[ r1c ] ) but here it predicts very small , in comparison with the other models , photo - production cross section : @xmath47 nb / sr ( fig . [ r6b ] ) .
the models fail in describing the t - dependence of @xmath38 the best results being achieved for @xmath48 ( zero kaon angle ) , fig .
the only regge and maid models provide a reasonable behaviour but they fail in normalisation of @xmath38 .
predictions of the model c4 are out of the data in both figures [ r6b ] and [ r6c ] ( excluding at @xmath48 in fig .
[ r6c ] ) .
the model possesses a wrong t - dependence in addition and its results differ distinctly from predictions of the other models at forward kaon angles ( fig .
[ r6c ] ) . in this subsection
we discuss only the isobaric models because the energies assumed here are not high enough to be reasonable to apply the regge model .
the regge model systematically over - predicts the photo - production data at photon energies less than 2 gev as was shown in fig .
[ r1c ] and ref .
@xcite . in figures [ r2a]-[r2c ]
we compare predictions of the models for the total cross section in the photo - production with saphir data @xcite .
relative errors of the data amount approximately to 8% excluding in the threshold region where it is around 15% and for energies higher than 1.5 gev where it amounts up to 40% ( see figures [ r2a]-[r2c ] ) .
these data are therefore less restrictive than the unseparated electro - production cross sections for which the relative errors are less than 5% .
predictions of the older models as1 , as2 , aw2 , and aw4 are consistent with the data only up to @xmath49 gev ( figs .
[ r2a ] and [ r2b ] ) and those of w1 , w2 , ab2 , and c4 up to @xmath50 gev ( figs .
[ r2b ] and [ r2c ] ) .
apart from the c4 model the agreement with the data is within the expected range of validity of the models .
the sl , sla , and c3 models provide a satisfactory description of @xmath51 for the photon energy ranging up to 2 gev ( fig .
[ r2c ] ) .
predictions of the sl and sla models are very close each other .
better results are provided by the `` off - shell extended '' versions b and c of the saclay - lyon model ( see ref .
@xcite ( fig .
the maid model is in an excellent agreement with the data in the whole range of energies describing also their dip - bump structure ( fig .
[ r2c ] ) .
this success is due to presence of the hadron form factors in the model as well as to the fit of the model parameters to the described data .
the model attempted to explain the bump structure of the data around @xmath1 gev by addition the `` missing '' resonance @xmath52 to the model .
inclusion of this resonance also improved behaviour of model predictions at higher energies @xcite .
values of the @xmath53 , calculated in analogy with eq.(1 ) but for the total cross section and normalised to the number of the data points , are 2.47 and 5.17 for c3 and sla models , respectively . larger value for the sla model
is due to worse predictions of the model for @xmath51 near the threshold and for @xmath54 gev than those of the c3 model .
the model ab2 gives a very good agreement with data up to 1.6 gev ( fig .
[ r2a ] ) , resulting in @xmath55 which is better than that for sla . however , prediction of the ab2 is worse for @xmath54 gev ( figs .
[ r2a ] and [ r2c ] ) than that of sla .
the best value , @xmath56 , was achieved by the maid model whereas for c4 it amounts 11.6 .
the saphir data on the differential cross sections and polarizations @xcite suffer from still larger error bars than those for @xmath51 .
another disadvantage of the data is their averaging over bins of the photon energy and kaon angle . at this point
one should also mention an apparent discrepancy of these sphir data with the older ones @xcite , especially at small kaon scattering angles @xcite .
however , we show a comparison of model predictions with the latest data here . in figs .
[ r3a]-[r3c ] we display the differential cross section as a function of the photon lab energy for three values of the kaon c.m . angle .
the older models as1 , as2 , w1 , w2 , aw2 , aw4 , and ab2 can describe the data satisfactorily only up to 1.4 gev , even if the ab2 , w1 and w2 models at 154 deg ( fig .
[ r3c ] ) and the aw4 model at 25.8 deg ( fig .
[ r3a ] ) can provide good results for energies up to 2 gev .
the models c3 and aw4 give very good results at small angles ( fig . [ r3a ] ) and
high energies but they fail for larger angles and @xmath57 gev ( aw4 ) or @xmath58 gev ( c3 ) ( figs .
[ r3b ] and [ r3c ] ) .
the model c4 systematically over - predicts the differential cross sections in most of the kinematic region discussed here , especially at forward angles which was already observed in fig .
the sl and sla models over - predict data at small angles especially near the threshold region .
they provide very good description at intermediate angles but fail again at backward angles and @xmath59 gev ( fig . [ r3c ] ) where results of the two models differ noticeably too .
evidently , the best result here is provided by the maid model which can reproduce even the data structure .
the model being regularised by the hadron form factors agree with the data for all angles even for @xmath60 gev .
situation with data accuracy is still worse for the lambda polarization asymmetry ( @xmath61 ) .
that is why in figs .
[ r3d ] and [ r3e ] we show the energy bins over which data were averaged . at @xmath62 deg ( fig .
[ r3d ] ) the models except for maid have a problem to describe the data points for @xmath63 gev . the best result ( in terms of @xmath53 )
was achieved by the maid and ab2 models . at @xmath64 deg ( fig .
[ r3e ] ) the maid , saclay - lyon , and as2 ( for @xmath65 gev only ) models give reasonable predictions .
there is no need to say that more and better quality data are desirable here .
among the tested models only the saclay - lyon a ( sla ) and maid can describe more or less all the discussed data .
the regge model is successful in predicting the electro - production cross sections but it can not provide good results for the photo - production at energy less than 3 - 4 gev .
the williams - ji - cotanch model c4 fails to describe the total cross section for the photo - production whereas c3 version can not describe the new electro - production data . however
, uncertainty in prescription for the electro - magnetic form factors does play a significant role for predictions of these models for the separated cross sections in the electro - production .
the older models , adelseck - saghai ( as1 , as2 ) , workman ( w1 , w2 ) , and adelseck - bennhold ( ab2 ) are excluded by the new photo - production data , except for some cases where the models provide a reasonable results .
these models , extended for the electro - production , can not also predict the new data satisfactory .
the analysis depends , however , to some extent on the prescription used for the electro - magnetic form factors .
large differences of the model predictions for the separated cross sections at small @xmath20 call for other high accuracy electro - production data in that region . in the kinematic region of the e98 - 108 experiment , @xmath35 gev and @xmath66 gev@xmath37 ,
the sla , adelseck - wright ( aw4 ) , regge and maid models are expected to provide reasonable results for the separated and unseparated cross sections whereas the unseparated cross sections merely can be predicted by the aw3 and c4 models in addition , where in the model c4 the electric ( @xmath25 ) and magnetic ( @xmath26 ) form factors are substituted in the electro - magnetic vertex @xcite .
financial support from ga cr 202/02/0930 is gratefully acknowledged .
two of us ( p.b . and m.s . )
thank the infn , gruppo sanit in rome sincerely for its hospitality during completing this work .
adelseck and b. saghai , phys .
c * 42 * , 108 ( 1990 ) . c.j .
bebek , c.n .
brown , p. bucksbaum , m. herzlinger , s.d .
holmes , c.a .
lichtenstein , f.m .
pipkin , s.w .
raither , and l.k .
sisterson , phys .
d * 15 * , 594 ( 1977 ) .
g. niculescu _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 81 * , 1805 ( 1998 ) .
et al . _ ,
accepted to phys .
c ; nucl - ex/0211005 .
p. markowitz , m. iodice , s. frullani , c.g .
chang , and o.k .
baker , `` electroproduction of kaons up to q@xmath37 = 3 ( gev / c)@xmath37 '' , jefferson lab experimental proposal e98 - 108 approved for hall a ( 1998 ) ; p. markowitz , in _ proc .
9th int . conf . on the structure of baryons _ , newport news , virginia , u.s.a . , 3 - 8 mar . , 2002 ;
m. iodice , in _ proc .
electron - nucleus scattering vii _ , elba ,
italy , 24 - 28 june , 2002 , eur .
a ( in press ) .
adelseck , c. bennhold , and l.e .
wright , phys .
c * 32 * , 1681 ( 1985 ) .
adelseck and l.e .
wright , phys .
c * 38 * , 1965 ( 1988 ) .
workman , phys .
c * 44 * , 552 ( 1991 ) . r.a .
williams , chueng - ryong ji , and s.r .
cotanch , phys . rev .
c * 43 * , 452 ( 1991 ) .
williams , chueng - ryong .
ji , and s.r .
cotanch , phys .
c * 46 * , 1617 ( 1992 ) .
david , c. fayard , g .- h .
lamot , and b. saghai , phys .
c * 53 * , 2613 ( 1996 ) .
t. mizutani , c. fayard , g .- h .
lamot , and b. saghai , phys .
c * 58 * , 75 ( 1998 ) . m. guidal , j .-
m . laget , and m. vanderhaeghen , nucl .
a * 627 * , 645 ( 1997 ) ; phys .
c * 61 * , 025204 ( 2000 ) .
h. thom , phys .
151 * , 1322 ( 1966 ) .
h. haberzettl , c. bennhold , t. mart , and t. feuster , phys .
c * 58 * , r40 ( 1998 ) ; f.x .
lee , t. mart , c. bennhold , h. haberzettl , l.e .
wright , nucl .
a * 695 * , 237 ( 2001 ) . c. bennhold , h. haberzettl , and t. mart , nucl - th/9909022 ; http://www.kph.uni-mainz.de/maid/maid.html .
r.m . davidson and r. workman , phys .
c * 63 * , 025210 ( 2001 ) .
s. janssen , j. ryckebusch , d. debruyne , and t. van cauteren , phys .
c * 65 * , 015201 ( 2001 ) . t. feuster and u. mosel , phys .
c * 58 * , 457 ( 1998 ) .
wen - tai chiang , f. tabakin , t .- s.h .
lee , and b. saghai , phys .
b * 517 * , 101 ( 2001 ) .
zhenping li , phys .
c * 52 * , 1648 ( 1995 ) .
d. lu , r.h .
landau , and s.c .
phatak , phys .
c * 52 * , 1662 ( 1995 ) .
farrar , k. huleihel , and h. zhang , nucl .
b * 349 * , 655 ( 1991 ) .
s. steininger and u .- g .
meissner , phys .
b * 391 * , 446 ( 1997 ) .
( saphir collaboration ) , phys .
b * 445 * , 20 ( 1998 ) .
gari and w. krmpelmann , phys .
rev d * 45 * , 1817 ( 1992 ) .
m. sotona and s. frullani , prog .
phys . * 117 * , 151 ( 1994 ) .
s. capstick and w. roberts , rhys .
d * 49 * , 4570 ( 1994 ) ; _ ibid . _ * 58 * , 074011 ( 1998 ) .
b. saghai , in _ proc .
workshop on hypernuclear physics with electromagnetic probes _ , hampton uni . ,
virginia , u.s.a .
, 2 - 4 dec .
, 1999 , ( eds .
l. tang and o. hashimoto ) , p. 24 .
p. bydovsk , m. sotona , o. hashimoto , k. itonaga , and t. motoba , in _ proc .
workshop on physics with gev electrons and gamma - rays _ , sendai , japan , 13 - 15 feb .
, 2001 , ( eds .
t. tamae , j. kasagi , t. terasawa , and h. yamazaki ) .
acad . press ,
, 2001 , tokyo , p.101 .
a. bleckmann , s. herda , u. opara , w. schulz , w.j .
schwille , and h. urbahn , z. phys . * 239 * , 1 ( 1970 ) .
et al . _ ,
* 28 * , 1086 ( 1972 ) .
p. brauel , t. canzler , d. cords , r. felst , g. grindhammer , m. helm , w .- d .
kollmann , h. krehbiel , and m. schdlich , z. phys .
c * 3 * , 101 ( 1979 ) .
m. bockhorst _
( saphir collaboration ) , z. phys .
c * 63 * , 37 ( 1994 ) . | predictions of isobaric and regge models are compared with the latest experimental data ( bonn , jlab ) to select among the models those providing a satisfactory description of the data .
only the saclay - lyon ( sla ) and maid models are in a reasonable agreement with both photo- and electro - production data ranging up to about @xmath0 gev . in this energy region
the regge model is suitable only for description of the electro - production data and the older models adelseck - saghai ( as1 , as2 ) , workman ( w1,w2 ) , and adelseck - bennhold ( ab2 ) can reliably predict only the photo - production cross sections up to @xmath1 gev . in the kinematic region of the e98 - 108 experiment on the electro - production , sla , adelseck - wright ( aw4 ) , regge and maid models
are expected to provide an appropriate description of the separated cross sections whereas the unseparated cross sections can be reasonably well predicted also by the aw3 and williams - ji - cotanch ( c4 ) models .
= 15.5 cm |
asteroid families form as a result of collisions between asteroids .
these events can either lead to a formation of a large crater on the parent body , from which fragments are ejected , or catastrophically disrupt it .
more than 120 families are currently known in the main belt ( nesvorn et al .
2015 ) and the number of their members ranges from several thousands to just a few dozens , for the smaller and compact families .
a lot of progress has been made in the last decades in developing sophisticated impact hydrocodes able to reproduce the main properties of families , mainly accounting for their size distribution , and , in a few cases ( the karin and veritas clusters ) the ejection velocities of their members ( michel et al .
however , while the sizes of asteroids can be either measured directly through radar observations or occultations of stars , or inferred if the geometric albedo of the asteroid is known , correctly assessing ejection velocities is a more demanding task .
the orbital element distribution of family members can , at least in principle , be converted into ejection velocities from gauss equations ( zappal et al .
1996 ) , provided that both the true anomaly and the argument of perihelion of the family parent body are known ( or assumed ) .
orbital elements of family members , however , are not fixed in time , but can be changed by gravitational and non - gravitational effects , such as resonant dynamics ( morbidelli and nesvorn 1999 ) , close encounters with massive asteroids ( carruba et al .
2003 ) , and yarkovsky ( bottke et al . 2001 ) effects , etc . separating which part of the current distribution in proper elements may be caused by the initial velocity field and which is the consequence of later evolution is a quite complex problem .
interested readers are referred to vokrouhlick et al .
( 2006a , b , c ) for a discussion of monte carlo methods applied to the distribution of asteroid families proper semi - major axis .
yet , insights into the distribution of the ejection velocities are valuable for better understanding of the physics of large - scale collisions ( nesvorn et al .
2006 , michel et al .
they may help to calibrate impact hydrocodes , and improve models of the internal structure of asteroids .
here we analyze the inclination distribution of asteroid families .
the proper inclination is the the proper element least affected by dynamical evolution , and it could still bear signs of the original ejection velocity field . we find that a family formed in an event in which the ejection velocities were not much larger than the escape velocity from the parent body should be characterized by a peaked ( leptokurtic ) initial distribution ( relative to a gaussian ) , while families formed in hyper - velocity impacts , such as the case of the eos family ( vokrouhlick et al .
2006a ) , should have either a normal or less peaked ( platykurtic ) distribution .
the subsequent dynamical evolution should then act to bring this initial distribution to appear more gaussian ( or mesokurtic ) .
the relative importance of the subsequent evolution depends on which specific proper element is considered , and on how active the local dynamics is . using the proper inclination we attempt to identify cases where the local dynamics either did not have time or was not effective in erasing the initial , presumably leptokurtic , distributions .
these cases can be used to better understand the conditions immediately after a parent body disruption .
this paper is divided as follows . in sect .
[ sec : gauss_eq ] , we model the distribution of ejection velocities after a family - forming event .
we explain how a peakedness of an expected distribution can be measured by the pearson kurtosis .
[ sec : kurt_dyn ] shows how dynamics can modify the initial distribution by creating a new distribution that is more gaussian in shape . in sect .
[ sec : kurt_families ] , we survey the known asteroid families , to understand in which cases the traces of the initially leptokurtic distribution can be found .
[ sec : conc ] presents our conclusions .
proper orbital elements can be related to the components of the velocity in infinity , @xmath1 , along the direction of the orbital motion ( @xmath2 ) , in the radial direction ( @xmath3 ) , and perpendicular to the orbital plane ( @xmath0 ) through the gauss equations ( murray and dermott 1999 ) : @xmath4 , \label{eq : gauss_1}\ ] ] @xmath5 , \label{eq : gauss_2}\ ] ] @xmath6 where @xmath7 , and @xmath8 define a reference orbit ( usually the center of an asteroid family , defined in our work as the center of mass in a 3d proper element orbital space , and @xmath9 and @xmath10 are the ( generally unknown ) true anomaly and perihelion argument of the disrupted body at the time of impact . from the initial distribution @xmath11
, it should therefore be possible to estimate the three velocity components , assuming one knows the values of @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
this can be accomplished by inverting eqs .
[ eq : gauss_1 ] , [ eq : gauss_2 ] , [ eq : gauss_3 ] . with the exception of extremely young asteroid families ( e.g. , the karin cluster , nesvorn et al .
2002 , 2006 ) , this approach is not viable in most cases . apart from the obvious limitation that we do not generally know the values of @xmath9 and @xmath10 , a more fundamental difficulty is that several gravitational ( e.g. , mean - motion and secular resonances , close encounters with massive asteroids ) and non - gravitational ( e.g. , yarkovsky and yorp ) effects act to change the proper elements on long timescales .
the gauss equations thus can not be directly applied in most cases to obtain information about the original ejection velocities . in this work
we propose a new method to circumvent this difficulty .
of the three proper elements , the proper inclination is the one that is the least affected by dynamics .
for example , unlike the proper semi - major axis , the proper inclination is not directly effected by the diurnal version of the yarkovsky effect ( it is affected by the seasonal version , but this is usually a much weaker effect , whose strength is of the order of 10% of that of the diurnal version , for typical values of asteroid spin obliquities and rotation periods ( vokrouhlick and farinella 1999 ) ) . also , unlike the proper eccentricity , which is affected by chaotic diffusion in mean - motion resonances , the proper inclination is more stable .
in addition , the inclination is related to a single component of the ejection velocities , @xmath0 , via eq .
[ eq : gauss_3 ] .
this equation can be , at least in principle , inverted to provide information about @xmath12 .
what kind of a probability distribution function ( @xmath13 ) is to be expected for the original values of @xmath14 ?
velocities at infinity @xmath15 are obtained from the ejection velocities @xmath16 through the relationship : @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the escape velocity from the parent body . following vokrouhlick et al .
( 2006a , b , c ) , we assume that the ejection velocity field follows a gaussian distribution of zero mean and standard deviation given by : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the body diameter in km , and @xmath21 is a parameter describing the width of the velocity field . only objects with @xmath22 succeed in escaping from the parent body . as a result , the initial distribution of @xmath15 should generally be more peaked than a gaussian one .
[ fig : beta_fam_real ] , panel a , displays the frequency distribution function @xmath23 for 1031 objects with @xmath24 km computed for a parent body with an escape velocity of 130 m / s and @xmath25 .
we assumed that @xmath26 and @xmath27 . since @xmath9 and @xmath28 appear only as multiplying factors in the expression for @xmath0 , different choices of these parameters do not affect the shape of the distribution .
one can notice how the @xmath0 distribution is indeed more peaked than that of the gaussian distribution with the same standard deviation ( shown in red in fig .
[ fig : beta_fam_real ] ) .
a useful parameter to understand if a given distribution is ( or is not ) normally distributed is the kurtosis ( carruba et al .
pearson kurtosis ( pearson 1929 ) , defined as @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the fourth moment about the mean and @xmath31 is the standard deviation , gives a measure of the `` peakedness '' of the distribution . the gaussian distribution has @xmath32 and is the
most commonly known example of a mesokurtic distribution .
larger values of @xmath33 are associated with leptokurtic distributions , which have longer tails and more acute central peaks . the opposite case , with @xmath34 ,
is known as platykurtic .
we generated values of @xmath0 for various values of @xmath21 for ten thousand 5-km bodies originating from a parent body with @xmath35 m s@xmath36 ( results can be re - scaled for any other body size using eq .
[ eq : std_vej ] , and a different value of @xmath20 ) . fig .
[ fig : beta_vej ] shows how the kurtosis value of the @xmath0 distribution changes as a function of @xmath37 .
as expected , for smaller values of @xmath37 the @xmath0 distribution is more peaked , and the kurtosis values are larger . for @xmath38 ,
the kurtosis value approaches 0 , because the influence of parent body s gravity diminishes .
most families for which an estimate of @xmath21 is available ( see nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) , sect . 5 and references within )
have estimated values of @xmath37 in the range from 0.4 to 1.2 , and should therefore have been significantly leptokurtic when they formed .
what typical values of @xmath33 one would expect for a real asteroid family , where different sizes of fragments are considered together ? as the large objects typically have lower values of @xmath0 , this implies that they would contribute to the peak of the distribution , and when considered with smaller fragments , the whole distribution should correspond to a larger value of @xmath33 . to illustrate this effect , we simulated a family using a size distribution @xmath39 with @xmath40 , and @xmath41 .
the computed value of @xmath33 for bodies in the size range from 2 to 8 km was found to be 0.96 ( see fig . [
fig : beta_fam_real ] , panels b ) , while the one for a restricted range @xmath24 km was 0.21 ( fig . [
fig : beta_fam_real ] , panel a ) .
this shows that one must be careful when interpreting the real families , where the escape velocity and size distribution effects can combine together to produce larger values of @xmath33 . to isolate the escape velocity effect
, it is best to use a restricted range of sizes . of the @xmath0 distribution on @xmath37 ( solid blue line ) .
the scaling of the tick marks on the x - axis are proportional to the @xmath42 .
the blue dashed line is the second order polynomial that best - fitted the data .
the red line is @xmath32 , corresponding to a mesokurtic distribution.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] finally , we compare our simple model for the @xmath0 distribution with the results of impact simulations .
we have taken these results from nesvorn et al .
( 2006 ) , where a smooth particle hydrodynamic ( sph ) code was used to model the formation of the karin family . in this case
, the parent body was assumed to have @xmath43 km , which gives @xmath44 m s@xmath36 .
different impact conditions ( impact speed , impact angle , projectile size , etc . ) were studied in this work .
the dynamical evolution of fragments and their re - accretion following the initial impact was followed by the pkdgrav code .
using these simulations , we extracted the values of @xmath0 for the escaping fragments and estimated the value of @xmath21 from eq .
[ eq : vel_inf ] . in a specific case that produced the best fit to the observed size distribution of the karin family
, we obtained @xmath45 for fragments with @xmath46 km .
finally , we found that the @xmath0 distribution has @xmath47 , and is therefore significantly peaked .
this is in very good agreement with results from our simple method to generate fragments ( see above ) , which for the same size range and @xmath37 gives @xmath48 .
this suggests , again , that the initial @xmath0 distribution of asteroid families should be leptokurtic .
now that we have some expectations for the @xmath33 values just after a family formation , we turn our attention to @xmath33 for real asteroid families , where the inferred @xmath0 values may have been affected by the long - term dynamics .
we use the koronis family to illustrate this effect .
the koronis family is located at low eccentricities and low inclinations , in a region that is relatively dynamically quiet ( at least in what concerns the proper inclination ; bottke et al .
2001 ) . of the @xmath0 component and @xmath49 km bodies ( black line ) .
the blue line shows the mean value over the 450-myr integration span , and the red lines are one standard deviation from the mean.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] bottke et al .
( 2001 ) simulated the long - term dynamical evolution of the koronis family .
their simulation included the gravitational effects of four outer planets and the yarkovsky effect .
different sizes of simulated family members were considered .
we opted to illustrate here the case with @xmath49 km , for which bottke et al .
( 2001 ) numerically integrated the orbits of 210 bodies over 450 myr .
the initial distribution of family members in bottke et al .
( 2001 ) was obtained using the same method as described in sect .
[ sec : gauss_eq ] .
we computed the values of @xmath14 by inverting eq .
[ eq : gauss_3 ] .
since pearson s kurtosis is dependent on the presence of outliers , we eliminated from our distributions objects with values more than @xmath50 away from the mean .
this allowed us to avoid possible distortions in the computed @xmath33 values caused by a few distant objects .
[ fig : kurtosis_vw ] shows that the initially leptokurtic distribution tends to become more mesokurtic with time .
this can be understood as follows . in statistics ,
the central limit theorem states that the averages of random variables drawn from uncorrelated distributions are normally distributed .
if the dynamical effects produce changes of @xmath51 compatible with the central limit theorem , one would expect that , with time , the distributions of @xmath14 should indeed become more and more mesokurtic , as the contribution from dynamics increases . to illustrate things in the case of the ( real ) koronis family , we computed the value of @xmath33 for all its 5118 members taken from nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) , and for members with @xmath52 km .
we obtained @xmath53 and @xmath54 , respectively . since both these values are considerably leptokurtic , we believe that the dynamical evolution of the koronis family did not had enough time to alter the initial distribution of inclinations .
therefore , in the specific case of the koronis family , we may still be observing traces of the primordial distribution of @xmath0 .
we selected the families identified in nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) that : ( i ) have at least 100 members with @xmath55 km , and ( ii ) have a reasonably well defined age estimate proper element domain .
this method may not identify peripheral regions of some large families , the so - called _ halo _ of bro and morbidelli ( 2013 ) , as belonging to the dynamical group .
for families such as the eos and koronis groups , results from nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) should be considered as conservative estimates . ] .
the first selection criterion is required to have a reasonable statistics for the @xmath56 computation .
if we assume that the error is proportional to the square root of the number of objects , a sample of 100 objects would give us an uncertainty in @xmath56 of 10% .
we use a restricted size range , @xmath55 km , to avoid the influence of the size - dependent velocity effects on the kurtosis .
the age estimate is useful to have some input for a physical interpretation of our results .
also , since @xmath56 is sensitive to the presence of outliers in the distribution , we use the jarque - bera statistical test ( jbtest hereafter ) to confirm that the @xmath0 distribution differs ( or not ) from a gaussian one .
we choose to work with this specific test , instead of others , because the jbtest is particularly sensitive to whether sample data have the skewness and kurtosis matching a normal distribution ( jarque & bera 1987 ) .
the test , implemented on matlab , provides a @xmath57 parameter stating the probability that a given @xmath0 distribution follows ( or not ) the gaussian @xmath13 .
the null hypothesis level is usually set at 5% .
finally , we also checked that the @xmath0 distribution was not too asymmetrical , and verified that its skewness , the parameter that measures a possible asymmetry , was in the range between -0.25 and 0.25 .
a skewness value outside this range would indicate an asymmetric ejection velocity field , or some dynamical effects that are beyond the scope of this study . of the 122 families listed in nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) , 48 cases satisfied these requirements . at this stage of our analysis
we do not eliminate interlopers and do not consider in detail the local dynamics .
also , families with halos may have a further spread out distribution in inclination than what accounted for by hcm , and therefore larger values of @xmath56 .
for these families , our results should be considered as conservative .
values of @xmath56 may be affected by these factors , but first we would like to see what families may be more interesting in terms of a simple first - order criteria .
table [ table : families_kurt ] reports the values of @xmath56 for the whole family ( 3rd column ) , for @xmath58 km ( @xmath59 ) members ( 4rd column ) , and the @xmath60 coefficient of the jbtest for the @xmath59 population .
note that the maximum value of @xmath60 is 50.0% .
following the notation of nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) , the first two columns in table [ table : families_kurt ] report the family identification number ( fin ) and the family name .
finally , the sixth column displays the family age estimate , with its error .
the age estimate was obtained using eq . 1 in nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) , and values of the @xmath61 parameter , its error ( also estimated from eq . 1 and the value of @xmath62 from nesvorn et al .
2015 ) , and geometric albedos from table 2 of that paper .
densities were taken from carry ( 2012 ) for the namesake body of each family , when available . if not , a standard value of 1.2 g @xmath63 for c - complex families and 2.5 g @xmath63 for the s - complex families was used . in a few cases , for which a better age estimate was available in the literature
, we used these latter values .
this includes the following cases ( labeled by @xmath64 in table 1 ) : karin ( nesvorn et al . 2002 ) , eos ( vokrouhlick et al .
2006b ) , hygiea ( carruba et al .
2013b ) , and koronis , themis , meliboea , and ursula ( carruba et al . 2015 ) .
moreover , the families with values of skewness not in the range from -0.25 to 0.25 are identified by a `` ( s ) '' after family s name in table 1 .
to select families whose @xmath0 component may have not changed significantly with time , we adopted the following criteria : @xmath56 for the @xmath59 population has to be larger than 0.25 , the estimated error on values of @xmath56 , skewness in the range from -0.25 and 0.25 , and @xmath60 has to be lower than 5% .
after this pre - selection was carried out , we were left with a sample of 9 candidates this is much higher than the 2 families one would expect to randomly fulfill this criteria , based on the number of families in our sample , and this suggests that a real effect might actually be observed in our data
. ordered by a decreasing value of @xmath65 , these 8 candidates are the gallia , hoffmeister , barcelona , hansa , massalia , koronis , rafita , hygiea and dora families .
we discarded the case of the hoffmeister family , since this family is significantly affected by the @xmath66 resonance with ceres ( novakovi et al .
2015 ) .
[ fig : vw_famiies ] shows the distributions ( blue line ) of the @xmath0 values for @xmath59 members of the gallia , barcelona , massalia , and koronis families , four of our selected families with leptokurtic distributions of @xmath0 .
as can be observed from this figure , these families have @xmath0 more peaked than a gaussian , and this is particularly evident for the case of the gallia family .
[ fig : age_gamma ] displays values of @xmath65 versus the estimated ages of the eight families satisfying our selection criteria .
one can notice that there is not a clear correlation between family age and @xmath65 .
while there are 4 families younger than 700 myr , three families ( hansa , hygiea , and rafita ) are estimated to be older than 2 gyr .
what these eight families have in common is that they are located in orbital regions not very affected by dynamical mechanisms capable of changing proper @xmath67 .
gallia , barcelona , and hansa are families in stable islands at high inclinations , all in regions with not many mean - motion resonances ( carruba 2010 ) .
as previously discussed , koronis is located in a region at low inclination relatively quiet in terms of dynamics , and the same can be said for hygiea ( carruba et al .
2013b ) , and , possibly , for the rafita and massalia families ( the latter also a relatively young family , vokrouhlick et al .
2006b ) . versus the estimated age of eight families satisfying our selection criteria .
the horizontal blue lines display the estimated error on the ages , while the vertical ones show the nominal errors on @xmath65 , assumed equal to 0.1.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] finally , among the families with large values of both skewness and kurtosis , the cases of the karin and astrid families are of a particular interest to us .
karin is a very young family , already identified as such in nesvorn et al .
( 2002 , 2006 ) , while astrid is a family located in a dynamically quiet region .
nesvorn et al .
( 2006 ) showed that the velocity field of karin was probably asymmetrical , so the relatively high value of the skewness that we found for the karin cluster ( -0.60 ) should not be surprising .
astrid has the highest observed value of @xmath65 .
this family , however , also interacts with a secular resonance that produces a large dispersion of the inclination distribution .
if the resonant population of objects is removed , the value of @xmath65 drops to 0.3 , with a skewness within the acceptable range .
the still large value of @xmath65 of this revised astrid group makes it a very good candidate for a family with a partially pristine @xmath0 velocity field .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
the main results of this work can be summarized as follows : * we developed a model for how the original field of velocities at infinity should appear for newly created families .
families with a low @xmath68 ratio , where @xmath69 is a parameter describing the standard deviation of ejection velocity field , assumed normal ( eq . [ eq : std_vej ] ) , and @xmath70 is the escape velocity from the parent body , should have values of velocities at infinity following a peaked distribution . this distribution is characterized by positive values of kurtosis @xmath33 ( leptokurtic distribution ) .
this is confirmed by sph simulations for the karin cluster , that show a leptokurtic distribution of @xmath0 values , the component of the velocity of infinity perpendicular to the orbital plane .
since the proper inclination is less affected by dynamical evolution than proper semi - major axis and eccentricity , and since @xmath0 can be obtained from the distribution in proper @xmath67 ( eq . [ eq : gauss_3 ] ) , we decided to concentrate our analysis on the distribution of @xmath0 values .
we studied the influence that dynamics has on the distribution of @xmath0 values .
an initially peaked @xmath0 distributions tend to become more normal with time .
* we computed values of @xmath65 , the kurtosis of the distribution of @xmath0 values for objects with @xmath55 ( @xmath59 ) , for all families listed in nesvorn et al .
( 2015 ) that i ) have an age estimate , ii ) have a @xmath59 population of at least 100 objects , and iii ) are not following a gaussian distribution , according to the jarque - bera test .
we also required the families to have values of skewness , the parameter identifying possible asymmetries in the @xmath0 distribution , between -0.25 and 0.25 .
eight families , the gallia , barcelona , hansa , massalia , koronis , rafita , hygiea and dora families , satisfied these criteria and have values of @xmath65 larger than 0.25 , which suggests that they could still bear traces of the original values of @xmath0 .
four of these families are younger than 700 myr .
all of these groups appear to be located in regions not strongly affected by dynamical mechanisms able to modify proper inclination . among asymmetrical families ,
the karin and astrid groups stand out as interesting cases .
overall , while a more in depth study of the families selected in this work , accounting for a better analysis of local dynamics and of the role of possible interlopers , should be performed , our analysis already allowed us to select several asteroid families that could still bear traces of the original distribution of velocities at infinity . while to select families that could still bear traces of the original values of @xmath0 we concentrated on the shape of the @xmath0 distribution , obtaining better estimates of the _ magnitude _ of @xmath0 for these selected families could much improve our knowledge of the physical mechanisms at work in the family - forming event , and serve as an useful constraints for simulations describing cratering and catastrophic destruction events , other than the observed size frequency distribution ( durda et al .
we thank an anonymous reviewer for comments and suggestions that significantly improved the quality of this paper .
this paper was written while the first author was a visiting scientist at the southwest research institute ( swri ) in boulder , co , usa .
we would like to thank the so paulo state science foundation ( fapesp ) that supported this work via the grant 14/24071 - 7 , the brazilian national research council ( cnpq , grant 305453/2011 - 4 ) , and the national science foundation ( nsf ) .
the authors are grateful to w. f. bottke for allowing them to use the results of the koronis family simulations , to s. aljbaae for revising earlier version of this manuscript , and to d. durda for comments and suggestions that improved the quality of this work .
michel , p. , richardson , d. c. , durda , d. d. , jutzi , m. , asphaug , e. 2015 , collisional formation and modeling of asteroid families , in asteroid iv , ( p. michel , f. e. demeo , w. bottke eds . ) , univ .
arizona press and lpi , 341 . | asteroid families form as a result of large - scale collisions among main belt asteroids .
the orbital distribution of fragments after a family - forming impact could inform us about their ejection velocities .
unfortunately , however , orbits dynamically evolve by a number of effects , including the yarkovsky drift , chaotic diffusion , and gravitational encounters with massive asteroids , such that it is difficult to infer the ejection velocities eons after each family s formation . here
we analyze the _ inclination _ distribution of asteroid families , because proper inclination can remain constant over long time intervals , and could help us to understand the distribution of the component of the ejection velocity that is perpendicular to the orbital plane ( @xmath0 ) . from modeling the initial breakup
, we find that the distribution of @xmath0 of the fragments , which manage to escape the parent body s gravity , should be more peaked than a gaussian distribution ( i.e. , be leptokurtic ) even if the initial distribution was gaussian .
we surveyed known asteroid families for signs of a peaked distribution of @xmath0 using a statistical measure of the distribution peakedness or flatness known as kurtosis .
we identified eight families whose @xmath0 distribution is significantly leptokurtic .
these cases ( e.g. the koronis family ) are located in dynamically quiet regions of the main belt , where , presumably , the initial distribution of @xmath0 was not modified by subsequent orbital evolution .
we suggest that , in these cases , the inclination distribution can be used to obtain interesting information about the original ejection velocity field .
[ firstpage ] minor planets , asteroids : general celestial mechanics . |
pablo picasso `` i paint objects as i think them , not as i see them '' recently , generative adversarial networks ( gans ) @xcite have shown significant promise in synthetically generate natural images using the mnist @xcite , cifar-10 @xcite , cub-200 @xcite and lfw datasets @xcite . however
, we could notice that all these datasets have some common characteristics : i ) most of the background / foreground are clearly distinguishable ; ii ) most of the images contain only one object per image and finally iii ) most of the objects have fairly structured shape such as numeric , vehicles , birds , face etc . in this paper
, we would like to investigate if machine can create ( more challenging ) images that do not exhibit any of the above characteristics , such as the artwork depicted in fig .
[ fig : clscom ] .
artwork is a mode of creative expression , coming in different kind of forms , including drawing , naturalistic , abstraction , etc .
for instance , artwork can be non - figurative nor representable , e.g _ abstract _ paintings .
therefore , it is very hard to understand the background / foreground in the artwork .
in addition , some artwork do not follow natural shapes , e.g _ cubism _ paintings . in the philosophy of art , aesthetic judgement
is always applied to artwork based on one s sentiment and taste , which shows one s appreciation of beauty .
an artist teacher wrote an online article @xcite and pointed out that an effective learning in art domain requires one to focus on a particular type of skills ( e.g practice to draw a particular object or one kind of movement ) at a time .
meanwhile , the learning in gans only involves unlabeled data that does nt necessarily reflect on a particular subject . in order to imitate such learning pattern ,
we propose to train gans focuses on a particular subject by inputting some additional information to it .
a similar approach is the conditional gans ( condgan ) @xcite .
the work feed a vector @xmath0 into @xmath1 and @xmath2 as an additional input layer . however , there is no feedback from @xmath0 to the intermediate layers .
a natural extension is to train @xmath1 as a classifier with respect to @xmath0 alike to the categorical gans ( catgan ) @xcite and salimans et al . @xcite . in the former , the work extended @xmath1 in gans to @xmath3 classes , instead of a binary output .
then , they trained the catgan by either minimize or maximize the shannon entropy to control the uncertainty of @xmath1 . in the latter ,
the work proposed a semi - supervised learning framework and used @xmath4 classes with an additional fake class .
an advantage of such design is that it can be extended to include more ( adversarial ) classes , e.g introspective adversarial networks ( ian ) @xcite used a ternary adversarial loss that forces @xmath1 to label a sample as reconstructed in addition to real or fake .
however , such work do not use the information from the labels to train @xmath2 . to this end
, we propose a novel adversarial networks namely as agan that is close to condgan @xcite but it differs in such a way that we feed @xmath0 to @xmath2 only and back - propagate errors to @xmath2 .
this allows @xmath2 to learn better by using the feedback information from the labels .
at the same time , agan outputs @xmath4 classes in @xmath1 as to the @xcite but again we differ in two ways : first , we set a label to each generated images in @xmath1 based on @xmath0 .
secondly , we use sigmoid function instead of softmax function in @xmath1 .
this generalizes the agan architecture so that it can be extended to other works , e.g multi - labels problem @xcite , open set recognition problem @xcite , etc .
inspired by larsen et al .
@xcite , we also added the l2 pixel - wise reconstruction loss along with the adversarial loss to train @xmath2 in order to improve the quality of the generated images .
empirically , we show qualitatively that our model is capable to synthesize descent quality artwork that exhibit for instance famous artist styles such as vincent van vogh ( fig .
[ vangogh2 ] ) . at the same time ,
our model also able to create samples on cifar-10 that look more natural and contain clear object structures in them , compared to dcgan @xcite ( fig .
[ fig : cifar ] ) .
in this section , we present a novel framework built on gans @xcite . we begin with a brief concept of the gans framework .
then , we introduce the agan .
the gans framework @xcite was established with two competitors , the generator @xmath2 and discriminator @xmath1 .
the task of @xmath1 is to distinguish the samples from @xmath2 and training data . while , @xmath2 is to confuse @xmath1 by generating samples with distribution close to the training data distribution .
the gans objective function is given by : @xmath5 ) \label{eq : gan}\ ] ] where @xmath1 is trained by maximizing the probability of the training data ( first term ) , while minimizing the probability of the samples from @xmath2 ( second term ) .
the basic structure of agan is similar to gans : it consists of a discriminator and a generator that are simultaneously trained using the minmax formulation of gans , as described in eq .
[ eq : gan ] .
the key innovation of our work is to allow feedback from the labels given to each generated image through the loss function in @xmath1 to @xmath2 .
that is , we feed additional ( label ) information @xmath6 to the gans network to imitate how human learn to draw .
this is almost similar to the condgan @xcite which is an extension of the gans in which both @xmath1 and @xmath2 receive an additional vector of information @xmath6 as input .
that is , @xmath6 encodes the information of either the attributes or classes of the data to control the modes of the data to be generated .
however , it has one limitation as the information of @xmath6 is not fully utilized through the back - propagation process to improve the quality of the generated images .
therefore , a natural refinement is to train @xmath1 as a classifier with respect to @xmath6 . to this end
, we modify @xmath1 to output probability distribution of the labels , as to catgan @xcite except that we set a label to each generated images in @xmath1 based on @xmath6 and use cross entropy to back - propagate the error to @xmath2 .
this allows @xmath2 to learn better by using the feedback information from the labels .
conceptually , this step not only help in speeding up the training process , but also assists the agan to grasp more abstract concepts , such as artistic styles which are crucial when generating fine art paintings .
also , we use sigmoid function instead of softmax function in @xmath1 , and employ an additional l2 pixel - wise reconstruction loss as to larsen et al .
@xcite along with adversarial loss to improve the training stability .
contrast to larsen et al .
@xcite , in agan architecture , the decoder @xmath1 shares the same network with encoder @xmath7 only . fig .
[ fig : ccgan ] depicts the overall architecture of the proposed agan .
formally , @xmath1 maps an input image @xmath8 to a probability distribution @xmath9 , @xmath10 .
generally , @xmath1 can be separated into two parts : an encoder @xmath7 that produces a latent feature @xmath11 followed by a classifier @xmath12 .
similarly , @xmath2 is fed with a random vector @xmath13 concatenated with the label information @xmath14 and outputs a generated image @xmath15 , such that @xmath16\rightarrow \hat{\mathbf{x}}$ ] .
@xmath2 composes of a @xmath17 that transforms the input to a latent space , followed by a decoder @xmath18 . in this context
, @xmath19 is a normal - distributed random number generator with mean @xmath20 and standard standard deviation of @xmath21 , and @xmath22 is the number of elements in @xmath23 . given @xmath3 labels and @xmath4 representing the fake class , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are denoted as one - hot vectors , such that @xmath26 $ ] and @xmath27 $ ] , where @xmath28 and @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 when @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the true classes of the real and generated images , respectively .
then , the data draw from the real distribution is denoted @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is the label of @xmath36 .
meanwhile , @xmath37 is the noise distribution for @xmath23 . for simplicity
, we use @xmath38 to express the output of @xmath2 , such that @xmath33 is randomly chosen .
hence , we can minimize the loss function , @xmath39 w.r.t parameters @xmath40 in @xmath1 to update @xmath1 : @xmath41 \nonumber \\ & - \mathbb{e}_{\hat{\mathbf{z}}\sim p_{noise } , \hat{k}\sim \mathbf{k}}\big[\log ( 1-p(y_i|g(\hat{\mathbf{z}},\hat{\mathbf{y}}_{\hat{k } } ) , i < k+1 ) ) \nonumber \\ & + \log p(y_i|g(\hat{\mathbf{z}},\hat{\mathbf{y}}_{\hat{k}}),i = k+1)\big ] \label{eqld}\end{aligned}\ ] ] meanwhile , we maximize @xmath39 to update parameters @xmath42 in @xmath2 in order to compete with @xmath1 .
hence , we can reformulate eq .
[ eqld ] as a minimization problem @xmath43 : @xmath44 \label{eqla}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to to improve the training stability in the agan , we added the l2 pixel - wise reconstruction loss @xmath45 along with @xmath43 .
given the latent feature @xmath11 output from @xmath7 using @xmath36 as input , @xmath11 is fed into @xmath18 to reconstruct the image @xmath46 .
hence , @xmath45 is defined as : @xmath47\ ] ] where @xmath48 is the second - ordered norm .
it should be noted that in the original vae @xcite , @xmath45 is used to update both the @xmath7 and @xmath18 .
conversely , we found that @xmath45 degrades the quality of the generated images when it is used to update @xmath7 .
hence , we only use @xmath45 when updating @xmath42 .
the final form of the loss function for @xmath2 is @xmath49 .
algorithm [ pseu ] illustrates the training process in our agan model .
minibatch size , @xmath50 and learning rate , @xmath51 randomly initialize @xmath52 and @xmath42 denote parameters of @xmath18 , @xmath53 sample @xmath54\sim\mathcal{n}(0,1)^{n\times d}$ ] randomly set @xmath55 , \hat{k}_i\in\mathbf{k}$ ] sample minibatch @xmath56 $ ] and @xmath57 $ ] @xmath58 @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath61 , @xmath62 @xmath63 @xmath64 @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67
in this work , we used the publicly available wikiart dataset @xcite for our experiments .
wikiart is the largest public available dataset that contains around 80,000 annotated artwork in terms of genre , artist and style class .
however , not all the artwork are annotated in the 3 respective classes . to be specific ,
all artwork are annotated for the _ style _ class .
but , there are only 60,000 artwork annotated for the _ genre _ class , and only around 20,000 artwork are annotated for the _ artist _ class .
we split the dataset into two parts : @xmath68 for testing and the rest for training . in terms of the agan architectures , we used @xmath69 for all leaky relu . on the other hand , @xmath18 shares the layers deconv3 to deconv6 in @xmath2 ; and
@xmath7 shares the layers conv1 to conv4 in @xmath1 .
we trained the proposed agan and other models in the experiments for @xmath70 epochs with minibatch size of 128 . for stability
, we used the adaptive learning method rmsprop @xcite for optimization .
we set the decay rate to @xmath71 and initial learning rate to @xmath72 .
we found out that reducing the learning rate during the training process will help in improving the image quality .
hence , the learning rate is reduced by a factor of @xmath73 at epoch @xmath74 .
0.1 [ dore1 ] 0.36 [ dore2 ] 0.1 0.36 0.1 0.36 * genre : * we compare the quality of the generated artwork trained based on the _ genre_. fig .
[ fig : clscom ] shows sample of the artwork synthetically generated by our proposed agan , dcgan @xcite and gan / vae , respectively .
we can visually notice that the generated artwork from the dcgan is relatively poor , with a lot of noises ( artefacts ) in it . in gan / vae
, we could notice that the generated artwork are less noisy and look slightly more natural .
however , we can observe that they are not as compelling .
in contrast , the generated artwork from the proposed agan are a lot more natural visually in overall
. + * artist : * fig . [ gogh ] illustrates artwork created by agan based on _ artist _ and interestingly , the agan is able to recognize the artist s preferences .
for instance , most of the _ gustave dore s _ masterpieces are completed using engraving , which are usually dull in color as in fig .
[ vangogh1]-top .
such pattern was captured and led the agan to draw greyish images as depicted in figure [ vangogh2]-(top ) .
similarly , most of the vincent van gogh s masterpieces in the wikiart dataset are annotated as _ sketch and study _ genre as illustrated in fig .
[ vangogh1]-bottom . in this genre , van gogh s palette consisted mainly of sombre earth tones , particularly dark brown , and showed no sign of the vivid colours that distinguish his later work , e.g the famous _ * the starry night * _ masterpiece . this explains why the artwork synthetically generated by agan is colourless ( fig .
[ vangogh2]-bottom ) . + * style : * fig .
[ ukiyo ] presents the artwork synthetically generated by agan based on _
style_. one interesting observation can be seen on the _ ukiyo - e _ style paintings .
generally , this painting style is produced using the woodblock printing for mass production and a large portion of these paintings appear to be yellowish as shown in figure [ unreal11 ] due to the paper material .
such characteristic can be seen in the generated _ ukiyo - e _ style paintings .
although the subjects in the paintings are hardly recognizable , it is noticeable that agan is trying to mimic the pattern of the subjects .
.comparison between different gan models using log - likehood measured by parzen - window estimate .
[ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] we trained both the dcgan @xcite and agan to generate natural images using the cifar-10 dataset .
the generated samples on cifar-10 are presented in fig .
[ fig : cifar ] . as aforementioned ,
the dcgan is able to generate much recognizable images , contrast to its failure in generating artwork .
this implies our earlier statements that the objects in cifar-10 have a fairly structured shape , and so it is much easier to learn compared to the artwork that are abstract .
even so , we could still notice some of the generated shapes are not as compelling due to cifar-10 exhibits huge variability in shapes compared to cub-200 dataset of birds and lfw dataset of face .
meanwhile , we can observed that the proposed agan is able to generate much better images .
for instance , we can see the auto - mobile and horse with clear shape . by using the gan models trained previously
, we measure the log - likelihood of the generated artwork .
following goodfellow et al .
@xcite , we measure the log - likehood using the parzen - window estimate . the results are reported in table [ parzen ] and show that the proposed agan performs the best among the compared models .
however , we should note that these measurements might be misleading @xcite .
in addition , we also find the nearest training examples of the generated artwork by using exhaustive search on l2 norm in the pixel space .
the comparisons are visualized in fig .
[ fig : nearest ] and it shows that the proposed agan does not simply memorize the training set .
in this work , we proposed a novel agan to synthesize much challenging and complex images . in the empirical experiments , we showed that the feedback from the label information during the back - propagation step improves the quality of the generated artwork . a natural extension to this work
is to use a deeper agan to encode more detail concepts .
furthermore , we are also interested in jointly learn these modes , so that agan can create artwork based on the combination of several modes .
in figure [ genccgan]-[fig : artist ] , we show more results on the _ genre _ and _ artist _ class . for instance , _ nicholas roerich _ had travelled to many asia countries and finally settled in the indian kullu valley in the himalayan foothills . hence , he has many paintings that are related to mountain using * symbolism * style .
this can be seen in the generated paintings ( figure [ fig : artist ] , no . 8 from left ) which look like mountain even - though unrealistic . on another example
, agan also shows that _ ivan shishkin _
s persistent in drawing forest landscape paintings ( figure [ fig : artist ] , no .
6 from left ) .
_ ivan shishkin _ is one of the most prominent russian landscape painters . by his contemporaries
, shishkin was given the nicknames titan of the russian forest " , forest tsar " , old pine tree " and lonely oak " as there was no one at that time who depicted trees more realistically , honestly and with greater love .
in this section , we report more results on the cifar-10 dataset .
figure [ cifar10 ] shows the generated images in each of the class . even though the objects in cifar-10 exhibit huge variability in shapes
, we can see that agan is still able to generate object - specific appearances and shapes . | this paper proposes an extension to the generative adversarial networks ( gans ) , namely as agan to synthetically generate more challenging and complex images such as artwork that have abstract characteristics .
this is in contrast to most of the current solutions that focused on generating natural images such as room interiors , birds , flowers and faces .
the key innovation of our work is to allow back - propagation of the loss function w.r.t .
the labels ( randomly assigned to each generated images ) to the generator from the discriminator . with the feedback from the label information , the generator is able to learn faster and achieve better generated image quality . empirically , we show that the proposed agan is capable to create realistic artwork , as well as generate compelling real world images that globally look natural with clear shape on cifar-10 .
oldmaketitlemaketitle image synthesis , generative adversarial networks , deep learning |
numerical simulations of lattice field theories are usually performed in the lagrangian formulation .
nonetheless , we think there are very good reasons to develop numerical simulation techniques for the hamiltonian approach @xcite : powerful many - body techniques are available @xcite , which allow the direct computation of the vacuum wave function properties ; fermions are implemented directly and need not be integrated out ; properties like the mass spectrum are more immediate .
finally , universality checks between the lagrangian and the hamiltonian formalism are very welcome .
we study the hamiltonian lattice version of the two - dimensional wess - zumino model described in refs .
@xcite ; we only wish to highlight here the main features of the formulation . in the hamiltonian formalism ,
since @xmath0 is conserved , it is possible to preserve exactly a 1-dimensional subalgebra of the original supersymmetry algebra , i.e. , we can write @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is a fermionic charge . this subalgebra is enough to guarantee some of the most important property of supersymmetry , including a non - negative spectrum , and pairing of fermionic and bosonic states of nonzero energy ; spontaneous breaking of supersymmetry is equivalent to a strictly positive ground - state energy @xmath3 ; the full supersymmetry algebra is recovered in the continuum limit together with lorentz invariance . in order to obtain a hamiltonian free of fermion sign problems , and therefore amenable to quantum monte carlo methods
, we adopt free boundary conditions , with lattice size @xmath4 .
the model is parametrized by a _
@xmath5 , an arbitrary polynomial in the bosonic field .
the two - dimensional wess - zumino model is superrenormalizable ; fields do not renormalize , and only @xmath5 needs to be normal ordered . in strong coupling at leading order
, the model reduces to independent copies of supersymmetric quantum mechanics , one for each site ; supersymmetry is broken if and only if the degree of the prepotential @xmath6 is even @xcite . in weak coupling , on the other hand
, supersymmetry is broken at tree level if and only if @xmath6 has no zeroes .
the predictions of strong coupling and weak coupling are quite different , and it is interesting to study the crossover from strong to weak coupling .
we perform our simulations using the green function monte carlo ( gfmc ) algorithm @xcite .
a discussion of gfmc in the context of the present problem can be found in ref .
@xcite ; we only wish to remark the main features of the algorithm : the aim is to generate a stochastic representation of the ground - state wavefunction , which is then used to compute expectation values of observables .
statistical fluctuations are reduced with the help of a guiding wavefunction , whose free parameters are determined dynamically during the simulation . in order to keep the variance of observables finite as the simulation proceeds ,
it is necessary to simulate a population of @xmath7 _ walkers _ ( field configurations at fixed time ) , and extrapolate the results to @xmath8 .
we focus on the case @xmath9 ; strong coupling always predicts supersymmetry breaking ; weak coupling predicts unbroken supersymmetry for @xmath10 ; according to ref .
@xcite , unbroken supersymmetry should be accompanied by a nonzero @xmath11 ( parity breaking ) .
perturbative computations show that @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the adimensional lattice bare coupling , @xmath14 is the renormalized ( continuum ) coupling , with dimension of @xmath15 , defined at the mass scale @xmath16 , and @xmath17 is the lattice spacing .
we study , as @xmath18 , the trajectory @xmath19 corresponding to a perturbative rg trajectory ( [ eq : evol2_l ] ) ; the effect of @xmath20 is small in the range we considered , therefore we expect eq .
( [ eq : trajectory ] ) to be a reasonable approximation to a true rg trajectory .
we estimate the correlation length from the exponential decay of the connected correlation function @xmath21 averaged over all @xmath22 pairs with @xmath23 , excluding pairs for which @xmath24 or @xmath25 is closer to the border than ( typically ) 8 . in our formulation , fermions are staggered and even / odd @xmath26 correspond to different channels .
we begin with the discussion of the case @xmath27 , for which we have obtained the statistics of @xmath28 gfmc iterations .
the even-@xmath26 channel is plotted in fig . [
fig : xieven , l2=0.35 ] ; it is very difficult to extract a correlation length , presumably because @xmath29 has a very small overlap with the lightest state of the channel , and the value of @xmath30 quoted in fig .
[ fig : xieven , l2=0.35 ] should be considered tentative .
the odd-@xmath26 channel , plotted in fig .
[ fig : xiodd , l2=0.35 ] , is much cleaner , and it is possible to estimate @xmath30 with a good precision . for the other values of @xmath31 , the situation is similar but with larger errors ; we have a statistics of at least @xmath32 iterations , which we are increasing to @xmath28 .
the values of @xmath33 follow nicely the expected behavior @xmath34 as shown in fig .
[ fig : xioddlog ] : the entire range @xmath35 seem to be in the scaling region , with @xmath36 a borderline case .
the values of @xmath37 have very large errors , and it is hard to draw any conclusion from them .
we measure the ground state energy @xmath3 along the trajectory ( [ eq : trajectory ] ) ; the measurements have a very small statistical error , ranging from 1% for @xmath38 ( where @xmath39 ) to 0.1% for @xmath36 .
we extrapolate to @xmath40 and @xmath8 fitting @xmath41 to the form @xmath42
@xmath41 is plotted in fig .
[ fig : e0log ] : it seems to behave @xmath43 , while nave scaling would predict @xmath44 .
the value of @xmath41 ( disregarding this puzzling exponent ) and the lack of any signal for a breakdown of parity ( like a double - peaked distribution of @xmath29 ) strongly hint that the trajectory ( [ eq : trajectory ] ) belongs to the phase with broken supersymmetry and zero @xmath11 .
we are repeating the computation for trajectories with smaller @xmath20 .
j. kogut , l. i. susskind , phys .
d11 ( 1975 ) 395 ; j. kogut , rev .
phys . 51 ( 1979 ) 659 .
w. von der linden , phys .
rept . 220 ( 1992 ) 53 .
m. beccaria , m. campostrini , a. feo , nucl . phys .
b ( proc . suppl . ) 106 - 107 ( 2002 ) 944 .
m. beccaria , m. campostrini , a. feo , hep - lat/0109005 .
e. witten , nucl .
b188 ( 1981 ) 513 .
e. witten , nucl .
b202 ( 1982 ) 253 . | we investigate a hamiltonian lattice version of the two - dimensional wess - zumino model by quantum monte carlo simulations . in order to study the pattern of supersymmetry breaking
, we measure the ground state energy and the correlation length along a trajectory approaching the continuum limit .
the algorithm is very effective in measuring the ground state energy , and adequate for the correlation length . |
that the global properties of an extended system may be mapped to the boundaries is an idea that has found success in holographic theories of general relativistic systems @xcite , and in magnetically confined plasmas @xcite .
we report on a similar behavior observed in incompressible hydrodynamic flows in a taylor - couette apparatus where it is observed that certain characteristics of the global flow are largely dictated by the boundaries .
this finding is particularly relevant for experiments that examine quasi - keplerian ( qk ) flows , that is , rotation satisfying @xmath0 where @xmath1 , @xmath2 is the fluid angular velocity and @xmath3 is the radial coordinate , as models of astrophysical systems , namely accretion disks .
numerous recent studies have commented on the hydrodynamic stability of such systems @xcite , with extensions to magnetohydrodynamics in electrically conducting fluids @xcite .
while there is some disagreement between studies as to whether hydrodynamic turbulence can be induced in qk flows , the balance seems to lean toward the negative , at least insofar as incompressible turbulence is considered , and points to the important role of magnetohydrodynamic effects in astrophysical systems .
however , while it is known that qk flows are linearly stable it remains unknown whether there exists a nonlinear transition to turbulence , even for incompressible hydrodynamic systems .
some experiments @xcite and simulations @xcite indicate that such a transition is not likely , while others present evidence that suggests that a subcritical transition may exist @xcite and some simulations find significant transient growth of perturbations that may allow for nonlinear effects to enter @xcite .
fluid experiments in other regimes of operation that are not astrophysically- elevant have observed bi - stability @xcite , suggesting that should a similar mechanism exist for qk systems then a subcritical pathway to turbulence may explain angular momentum transport in accretion disks @xcite .
we show in this work that the influence of the boundaries is intimately connected to the global structure of flows in taylor- ouette experiments and , by extension , is also related to the tendency of these systems to generate and sustain turbulence .
one of the long - standing challenges of taylor - couette experiments in the quest to understand angular momentum transport in astrophysically - relevant flows has been the parasitic presence of ekman circulation ( secondary circulation ) induced by the mismatch between the fluid velocity and the solid body rotation of the axial boundaries .
a significant reduction in ekman circulation has been realized in experiment by using axial boundaries that are split into multiple rings capable of differential rotation .
under particular boundary conditions , azimuthal velocity profiles of the fluid can be generated that very nearly match that of ideal couette rotation @xcite , the rotation profile that is expected in the absence of axial influences for a constant radial flux of angular momentum , and has been observed to hold over a wide range of reynolds numbers @xcite .
in contrast , studies in the `` classical '' configuration where the axial boundaries rotate with the outer cylinder have shown performance that further deviates from ideal couette as the reynolds number is increased @xcite .
such trends are revealing of whether these systems are dominated by boundary interactions or internal dynamics , a distinction with important consequences for the applicability of such experiments to interpretation of astrophysical systems , especially at large reynolds numbers .
first , through the experiments reported here we identify two necessary criteria that define constraints on the boundary configurations that allow near - ideal flows to develop .
we then discuss the competing roles of radial ( stewartson ) boundary layers and axial ( ekman ) boundary layers , from which we develop a model that describes the quantitative departure of the rotation profiles from ideal couette flow as a function of the angular momentum fluxes through the boundaries .
a taylor - couette ( tc ) device is a system of coaxial cylinders that rotate independently of each other with the experimental fluid region between .
the tc apparatus used in these studies , called the hydrodynamic turbulence experiment ( htx ) , is a modified version of the classical device in that the axial boundaries in htx are segmented to allow differential rotation across the boundaries @xcite .
the inner cylinder radius is @xmath4 cm and the outer cylinder radius is @xmath5 cm .
the inner radius and outer radius of the independent rings are defined by the parameters @xmath6 and @xmath7 , respectively .
the axial length of the experimental volume is @xmath8 cm , giving an aspect ratio of @xmath9 ( see fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
corresponding components on the top and bottom are driven by the same motor so that the system is up - down symmetric .
the angular velocities of the inner cylinder , outer cylinder and rings are identified by @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively .
rotary encoders report the speed of the motors to the control system .
a laser doppler velocimeter ( ldv ) diagnostic system is used to measure the local , azimuthal velocity ( @xmath13 ) , which in the experiments reported here were measured at the midplane of the device .
the ldv system is calibrated by measuring fluid flow in solid body for which , after spin - up , the only velocity component is @xmath13 , which is a unique function of the motor speeds . for these studies
we define the global shear reynolds number as @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the geometric- ean radius , @xmath16 and @xmath17 is the kinematic viscosity , approximately @xmath18 m@xmath19/s for water .
( color online ) illustration of the htx device at pppl showing the segmented axial boundaries ( yellow , blue and green segments ) , the inner cylinder in black , the outer cylinder in green and the working fluid in dark blue.,width=377 ]
the core observation of this work is summarized in fig .
[ fig2 ] , presenting flows under two different values of normalized shear ( @xmath20 and @xmath21 ) and three different boundary conditions : ` split ` , ` optimized ` , and ` ekman ` . for the @xmath20 cases these configuration speeds , reported as @xmath10-@xmath12-@xmath11 ,
are multiples of 350 - 350 - 50 rpm ( ` split ` ) , 350 - 185 - 50 rpm ( ` optimized ` ) , and 350 - 50 - 50 rpm ( ` ekman ` ) . for the @xmath21
these are 250 - 250 - 50 rpm ( ` split ` ) , 250 - 140 - 50 rpm ( ` optimized ` ) , and 250 - 50 - 50 rpm ( ` ekman ` ) . the reference profile for these studies
is described by ideal couette rotation , defined in terms of angular velocity as @xmath22 , where @xmath23 , @xmath24 . as a function of azimuthal velocity
the couette solution is @xmath25 .
it is interesting that while the ` ekman ` and ` split ` configurations exhibit progressive departure from ideal couette as the reynolds number is increased , the shape of the ` optimized ` cases is nearly invariant with respect to scaling of the reynolds number .
( color online ) scaled measurements of @xmath13 at various @xmath26 for ( a ) @xmath20 and ( b ) @xmath21.,width=377 ] recognizing that the axial boundaries in the ` split ` cases will tend to increase the angular momentum flux to the bulk , and conversely for the ` ekman ` cases , we begin by considering the ansatz that the balance of angular momentum fluxes across the axial boundaries determines the deviation from ideal couette . a continuous variation of @xmath12 from @xmath11 to @xmath10 would then suggest that there is some intermediate state for which the profile must pass close to ideal couette rotation .
we now address whether there is a method for predicting this optimal value of @xmath12 . the transition between the bulk flow and the walls of the tc device , which may move at very different speeds , occurs over thin boundary layers .
the structure of these boundary layers depends on whether we are considering the balance of forces in the axial or radial directions .
the bulk flow transitions to the axial boundary speeds over ekman boundary layers whose thickness scales like @xmath27 , and in the ideal model of radial boundaries , over stewartson boundary layers that scale like @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is a local reynolds number particular to the boundary location @xmath3 with boundary speed @xmath30 @xcite .
the fluxes of angular momentum across these boundary layers , being inversely proportional to the boundary layer thickness , do not scale proportionally , and hence we anticipate that self - similarity of the global properties need not be preserved as the reynolds number is scaled .
thus , while the observed variation in the shape of the ` ekman ` and ` split ` profiles is expected , it comes as some surprise that the ` optimized ` profiles are effectively independent of the reynolds number .
the experiments reported here showed no significant temporal variation in the mean values , hence , it can be stated that in steady - state the net flux of angular momentum into these flows must sum to zero , that is , @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the fluxes integrated over the inner and outer cylinders , respectively , and @xmath34 is the axial flux integrated over each axial boundary ( with inward towards the fluid defined as a positive flux ) .
the ideal couette profile is the response to a constant radial flux of angular momentum , implying that @xmath35 and that the axial fluxes of angular momentum are everywhere zero .
such a state can be imagined in a tc system with free - slip conditions on the axial boundaries , or with a continuously variable boundary that can perfectly match the ideal couette profile , conditions that will result in vanishing stress at the axial boundaries .
the radial flux of angular momentum under these conditions ( which we call @xmath36 , the couette flux ) has a magnitude equal to @xmath37 where @xmath38 . as an aside
, it is interesting to note that @xmath39 when the radius ratio ( @xmath40 ) is equal to the golden ratio .
even though there is , in general , a large mismatch between fluid and axial boundary speeds , we find that the flows under the ` optimized ` boundary conditions very closely approximate the ideal couette profile , and therefore have a nearly constant radial flux of angular momentum . we now show that rather than satisfying the condition that the axial flux of angular momentum everywhere vanishes , these flows satisfy a much weaker constraint : it is the surface integral of the axial angular momentum flux that vanishes , that is , @xmath41 . to calculate the axial flux of angular momentum ,
being proportional to @xmath42 , we make the assumption that @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the difference of the boundary angular velocity ( @xmath30 ) and the fluid angular velocity just inside the ekman boundary layer ( @xmath2 ) , and that @xmath45 represents the thickness of an ekman boundary layer with an unknown numerical constant @xmath46 .
defining the normalized quantities @xmath47 ( recalling , @xmath16 ) , @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 , we have @xmath51 that the radial flux of angular momentum under ideal couette rotation [ eq . [ phic ] ]
scales like @xmath26 , whereas @xmath34 scales like @xmath52 means that unless steps are taken to force the integral in eq .
[ phiz ] to zero , there will always exist a reynolds number beyond which the axial flux will overwhelm the couette flux and cause the flow to depart from ideal rotation , regardless of aspect ratio . from eq .
[ phiz ] we can immediately conclude that tc devices of the `` classical '' geometry with the axial boundaries co - rotating with either the inner cylinder or outer cylinder will always have non - zero @xmath34 and can therefore never be a good model for astrophysical systems at sufficiently high reynolds numbers to be of interest . in looking for the conditions under which ideal couette flow may be generated , we set @xmath53 and search for the boundary conditions ( the @xmath54 ) that cause the integral of eq . [ phiz ] to vanish .
( color online ) experiments conducted in @xmath20 flows showing @xmath13 as a function of @xmath12 for the ( a ) ` htx ` and ( b ) ` wide - ring ` geometries , progressing from low ring speeds ( bottom curves ) to higher ring speeds ( upper curves ) . in panels ( c ) and ( d ) the experimental @xmath55 ( dashed green ) , for the measured profiles relative to the ideal coutte profile for these boundary conditions , is plotted against the calculated axial flux of angular momentum from eq . [ phiz ] ( red , increasing function ) and the pressure differential from eq .
[ dp ] ( blue , decreasing function ) for the ` htx ` and ` wide - ring ` geometries , respectively .
@xmath34 is normalized by @xmath56 and @xmath57 is normalized by the kinetic energy density for ideal couette flow .
the vertical dotted lines indicate the zeros of @xmath57 and @xmath34.,width=529 ] figure [ fig3 ] summarizes fluid velocity measurements over a scan of @xmath12 for @xmath20 flows for two axial boundary configurations : the ` htx ` configuration with @xmath58 cm and @xmath59 cm , and a ` wide - ring ` configuration with rings that span the entire radial gap .
these experiments show that the ` htx ` configuration produces an exceptional match to the ideal couette profile for a narrow range of ring speeds centered about @xmath60 rpm , with very low fluctuation levels spanning the entire gap @xcite .
importantly , the boundary conditions that generate near - ideal flows for the ` htx ` configuration include the zero crossing of @xmath34 [ fig .
[ fig3](c ) ] .
however , the ` wide - ring ` case also has a zero in @xmath34 , near @xmath61 rpm [ fig . [ fig3](d ) ] , yet its flows never resemble ideal couette , indicating that the vanishing of @xmath34 is a necessary but not sufficient condition for achieving near - ideal flows .
( color online ) same as fig .
[ fig3 ] except for @xmath21.,width=529 ] the role of the axial boundaries in dictating global performance has also been interpreted through the competition of pressures from the bulk flow and from the boundary flow that is viscously coupled to the axial boundaries @xcite .
the tendency to drive secondary flows was shown to be consistent with whether the bulk pressure is larger than ( ekman circulation ) or smaller than ( anti - ekman circulation ) the boundary pressure . following the intuition motivated by these simulations , we define a function @xmath57 that characterizes the average pressure difference between ideal couette rotation and boundary rotation , @xmath62 for the ` wide - ring ` configuration the zeros of @xmath57 and @xmath34 are widely separated , meaning that no circumstance exists where pressure balance and zero net axial flux can be simultaneously satisfied .
in contrast , the ` htx ` configuration has zeros of these functions that are nearly coincident and fall within the operating range in which small fluctuations were observed in ref .
other boundary configurations with @xmath21 also have nearly coincident zeros of @xmath34 and @xmath57 , in remarkably good agreement with experiments ; see fig .
note that the requirement of coincident or nearly - coincident zeros represents an effective third constraint .
these studies suggest that the requirements of having nearly coincident zeros of @xmath34 and @xmath57 for the generation of ideal flows may represent necessary and sufficient conditions .
additional research conducted over a wider range of geometries and shear conditions will provide a stronger test of this hypothesis .
while the coincident vanishing of @xmath34 and @xmath57 define what may be necessary and sufficient conditions for ideal flows to develop , they do not reveal how qk systems should behave under non - optimized conditions .
a general model of the fluid response to forcing by the boundaries must account for the fluxes across both axial and radial boundary layers . as there
does not exist a theory of stewartson boundary layers under the conditions of qk rotation at large reynolds numbers , we can not rely on results derived from a linear analysis of perturbative differences in rotational speeds @xcite , especially for experimental conditions where the stewartson boundary layers are turbulent @xcite .
instead , we assume a generalized scaling of the stewartson boundary layer thickness of the form @xmath63 , taking the exponent of the reynolds number ( @xmath64 ) as a free - parameter to be determined from the observed scalings in fig .
[ fig2 ] . while the numerical factors @xmath65 and @xmath66 are introduced through the definitions of the boundary layer thicknesses we can not measure the boundary layers directly , and therefore we must interpret their meaning as a measure of the effectiveness of angular momentum flux .
we begin this analysis by considering the ` ekman ` configurations from fig .
[ fig2 ] where we note that @xmath13 transitions to solid body rotation at @xmath11 near the outer cylinder , implying that @xmath67 . with a jump in azimuthal velocity ( a negative @xmath68 ) occurring over a stewartson layer at the inner cylinder ,
the appropriate form for @xmath32 is @xmath69 where @xmath70 is a result of converting from a representation of the boundary layer thickness that depends on the local @xmath71 to a global @xmath26 .
we approximate these flows with a piecewise function of the form @xmath72 and @xmath73 , where @xmath74 is the transition radius , similar to the identification of separate flow regions in the recent work of nordsiek _ et al .
_ @xcite . substituting this rotation profile into eq .
[ phiz ] ( using @xmath75 ) and using eq .
[ phi1 ] for the radial flux at @xmath76 , we solve the global balance of angular momentum , @xmath77 , for the dimensionless @xmath78 as a function of @xmath26 .
noting that @xmath34 has two parts given this representation , our solution has three terms and is of the form @xmath79 where @xmath80 , and the integral expressions @xmath81 and @xmath82 are defined as @xmath83 @xmath84 ( color online ) scaling of the velocity differential @xmath85 for the three groups of boundary conditions from fig .
[ fig2 ] for ( a ) @xmath20 and ( b ) @xmath21 .
the dashed lines in the figure are the solutions to eqs .
[ dv1 ] and [ dv2 ] with @xmath86 and @xmath87.,width=377 ] equation [ dv1 ] is a transcendental expression in @xmath68 since the limits of the integrals in @xmath81 and @xmath82 are functions of @xmath74 which itself depends on @xmath68 .
equation [ dv1 ] has only two free parameters : @xmath64 and @xmath88 .
comparison of eq .
[ dv1 ] with experimental measurements of @xmath68 is presented in fig .
[ fig5 ] for the @xmath20 and @xmath21 cases , where values of @xmath89 and @xmath90 provide the best fit to the experimental measurements .
this analysis can be extended to the case of the ` split ` configuration with positive @xmath68 by accounting for the different boundary conditions and a slightly more complex flow structure .
the most important feature of the positive @xmath68 cases is that there is a nearly linear decrease in @xmath68 across the gap , where @xmath68 at @xmath91 is defined to be equal to @xmath92 . in the @xmath20 cases @xmath68 decreases by about @xmath93 across the gap ( @xmath94 ) , and by @xmath95 for @xmath21 ( @xmath96 ) ,
nearly independent of reynolds number .
the radial flux at @xmath91 in terms of the @xmath97 reduced @xmath68 is @xmath98 where @xmath99 .
the solution for positive , normalized @xmath68 is @xmath100 where , similar to eq .
[ dv1 ] , we have @xmath101 @xmath102 \omega_b^{1/2 } s^2 ds . \label{f4}\ ] ] for the ` split ` cases , the term @xmath103 defines the transition point from increasing to decreasing @xmath68 , and the terms in square brackets in eq.[f4 ] derive from the variation of @xmath68 with radius ( note that if @xmath68 were constant across the gap then @xmath104 and the term in brackets reduces to unity , recovering eq .
equation [ dv2 ] is compared against the measured @xmath105 in fig .
[ fig5 ] and is also found also to be in good agreement with experiment when using the same values of @xmath106 and @xmath64 derived from the analysis of the ` ekman ` cases .
the success of this model in reproducing the general features of the departures from ideal couette is remarkable given that it represents a simple accounting of the angular momentum fluxes across the boundaries , ignoring completely the complex internal dynamics of these flows , especially at large reynolds number where a substantial fraction of the volume exhibits turbulent fluctuations @xcite .
what disagreement exists between experiment and theory should not overshadow the success of this model in reproducing the general trend of the velocity deviations , the relative amplitude of the positive and negative @xmath68 cases , and the change in the amplitude of the positive @xmath68 cases between @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
while the model presented here uses a single set of parameters for both values of @xmath107 , better fits to the data can be found if we let these parameters depend on @xmath107 .
it is also possible the these parameters may depend on geometry and reynolds number in a way that is not captured by the power - law scaling used here .
studies of the measured fluctuation levels arising from the stewartson boundary layers in ref .
@xcite found that the transition to turbulent stewartson boundary layers was consistent with the taylor model of low reynolds number centrifugal instability .
so while can not offer a precise explanation for why @xmath64 should take a value close to @xmath108 , we reiterate that the inferred scaling applies to the angular momentum flux which is a combination of variations in the boundary layer thickness and an effective viscosity within these layers that is modified by turbulent fluctuations .
it is beyond the scope and ability of these experiments to identify the separate scalings of the turbulent viscosity and the thickness of the stewartson boundary layers , though perhaps future experiments will be able to provide greater insight into this problem .
we conclude with an outlook to future physical and numerical experiments .
the ratio of @xmath34 and @xmath36 explored earlier can be recast as a constraint on the aspect ratio @xmath109 as a function of the reynolds number .
the relative contribution of @xmath34 can be made arbitrarily small by increasing the axial size of the system , so that to make @xmath110 for an ` ekman ` configuration , for example , one would need an aspect ratio of order @xmath111 at a reynolds number of @xmath112 . outside of using very large aspect ratios
, one can employ mechanical advantages as we have done in htx , such as extensions of the inner and outer cylinder or independent rings . despite the desire to simplify the mechanical design of such modified tc devices
, further analysis shows that the only way to achieve simultaneous zeros in @xmath34 and @xmath57 is through a design with at least one independent ring .
greater insight into the balance of forces in quasi- eplerian flows could be explored in future experiments in modified taylor couette devices like htx .
in particular , further exploration of the reynolds number dependence on these deviations , the dependence of the model parameters on @xmath107 , and the structure of the ekman cells would tell us much more about the influence of the boundaries on global behavior .
we have shown that nearly ideal flows exhibit profile shape invariance under scaling of the reynolds number , an effect we interpret through the dual conditions of vanishing axial angular momentum flux and vanishing pressure differential that are nearly simultaneously satisfied , offering predictive capability for selecting optimized boundary conditions and in experimental design . the strongest piece of evidence in support of this model is the prediction of self - similarity of the profiles with respect to scaling of the reynolds number only for cases in which the axial flux of angular momentum and the pressure differential vanish nearly coincidentally , a prediction in excellent agreement with the observations presented in fig .
it should be reiterated that while the experiments for ` optimized ` flows show very small departures from ideal couette , and whose interpretation is congruent with the coincident zeros in @xmath57 and @xmath34 , this does not strictly prove that these criteria represent true sufficient conditions . an interesting problem for
future studies would be to measure how the departures from ideal couette depend on the `` distance '' between these zeros .
it is interesting to note that in all cases presented here the local axial fluxes of angular momentum may be quite large given the substantial difference in speed between the bulk fluid and the axial boundaries , and that it is only on summation over the axial boundaries that zero net axial flux is realized for the ` optimized ` cases . recalling that multiple experiments @xcite and simulations @xcite have observed a nearly uniform axial structure through the bulk of the fluid volume
, the existence of the large axial fluxes naturally raises the question : what allows the bulk flows to depart from the solid body rotation forced by the boundaries ?
intuition based on the taylor - proudman theorem for rayleigh - stable flows , that is @xmath113 , would suggest that the bulk should tend to follow the boundary .
however , it should be recalled that the ekman boundary layers do not need to satisfy the taylor- roudman theorem because the axial gradient of @xmath13 is balanced with a viscous diffusion of vorticity over the scale of the boundary layer thickness .
thus , the nearly uniform axial structure suggests that the large fluxes of angular momentum that must be present due to the existence of the the ekman boundary layers are redistributed locally , perhaps by small ekman cells that do not extend far into the bulk of the fluid or even in the boundary layers themselves . as has been shown in prior studies , the free - shear layer that develops at the interface between the differentially rotating rings on the axial boundaries
is expected to be centrifugally unstable and may help to enhance the redistribution of angular momentum locally @xcite . another problem for future experiments , both physical and numerical , will be to explore in greater detail how the very large , local fluxes of angular momentum are redistributed near the axial boundaries with only minor effect on the bulk flow in the ` optimized ` configurations . non - optimized boundaries , like the ` split ` and ` ekman ` configurations , show progressive departure from the ideal couette flow as the reynolds number is increased , in agreement with the expectations of a dominant axial flux of angular momentum .
a good test for numerical experiments will be to accurately model the global behavior of the mean flows in tc experiments by properly accounting for the angular momentum fluxes from the boundaries .
we believe that the boundary layer scalings presented here may enable simulations to bootstrap to larger effective reynolds numbers by using specified boundary flux models , thus bypassing the need for very fine grids to resolve the boundary layer structure directly . with the combination of recent simulations of qk flows that can attain reynolds numbers of the order of @xmath114 @xcite , though with axially - periodic boundary conditions , a specified - flux boundary model may allow simulations to reach something resembling experimental conditions of large reynolds number tc flows .
we thank j. goodman for sharing his thoughts on angular momentum transport and boundary layers in our studies , and e. schartman , e. gilson , and p. sloboda in helping to keep the experiments running smoothly .
this work was supported by the u.s .
department of energy , fusion energy sciences under contract de - ac02 - 09ch11466 through the center for momentum transport & flow organization in plasmas and magentofluids ( cmtfo ) .
j. e. rice , j. w. hughes , p. h. diamond , y. kosuga , y. a. podpaly , m. l. reinke , m. j. greenwald , . d. grcan , t. s. hahm , a. e. hubbard , e. s. marmar , c. j. mcdevitt , and d. g. whyte .
edge temperature gradient as intrinsic rotation drive in alcator @xmath116-mod tokamak plasmas .
, 106:215001 , 2011 .
m. seilmeyer , v. galindo , g. gerbeth , t. gundrum , f. stefani , m. gellert , g. rudiger , m. schultz , and r. hollerbach . experimental evidence for magnetorotational instability in a taylor - couette flow under the influence of a helical magnetic field . , 113:024505 , 2014s .
f. stefani , t. gundrum , g. gerbeth , g. rdiger , m. schultz , j. szklarski , and r. hollerbach .
experimental evidence for magnetorotational instability in a taylor - couette flow under the influence of a helical magnetic field .
, 97:184502 , 2006 .
d. r. sisan , n. mujica , w. a. tillotson , y. huang , w. dorland , a. b. hassam , t. m. antonsen , and d. p. lathrop . experimental observation and characterization of the magnetorotational instability .
, 93:114502 , 2004 . | we present measurements of quasi - keplerian flows in a taylor - couette device that identify the boundary conditions required to generate near - ideal flows that exhibit self - similarity under scaling of the reynolds number .
these experiments are contrasted with alternate boundary configurations that result in flows that progressively deviate from ideal couette rotation as the reynolds number is increased .
these behaviors are quantitatively explained in terms of the tendency to generate global ekman circulation and the balance of angular momentum fluxes through the axial and radial boundary layers .
+ eric m. edlund * and hantao ji + princeton plasma physics laboratory
+ september 1 , 2015 |
we introduced the notion of minor - embedding in adiabatic quantum optimization in @xcite . in particular
, we showed that the np - hard quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem on a graph @xmath0 can be solved in an adiabatic quantum computer that implements the spin-1/2 ising hamiltonian , by reduction through minor - embedding of @xmath0 in the quantum hardware graph @xmath2 .
we proved the correctness of the minor - embedding reduction and solved a related parameter setting problem in @xcite . in this paper
, we discuss the intertwined adiabatic quantum architecture design problem , which is to construct a hardware graph @xmath2 that satisfies all known physical constraints and , at the same time , permits an efficient minor - embedding algorithm .
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : aqc ] , we review adiabatic quantum computation , and describe an adiabatic quantum architecture that is implemented with superconducting devices and the imposing physical constraints . in section [ sec : minor - embed ] , we recall the minor - embedding in aqc . in section
[ sec : triad ] , we describe an optimal complete - graph minor hardware graph . in section [ sec : sparse ] , we discuss the open problem for designing sparse - graph minor universal hardware graphs and the related work in literature .
adiabatic quantum computation ( aqc ) was proposed by farhi et al .
@xcite in 2000 as an alternative quantum paradigm to solve np - hard optimization problems , which are believed to be classically intractable .
later , it was shown by aharonov et al .
@xcite that aqc is not just limited to optimization problems , and is polynomially equivalent to conventional quantum computation ( quantum circuit model ) . in this paper , we will focus on _ quantum adiabatic optimization _ ,
in which the final hamiltonian is a diagonal matrix in the computational basis . in particular , we restrict to a subclass of hamiltonians , known as _ ising hamiltonians _ : @xmath6 where @xmath7 ( @xmath8 resp . ) is the vertex set ( edge set resp . ) of @xmath0 , @xmath9 , and @xmath10 ( the pauli matrix @xmath11 is in the @xmath12th position ) , similarly for @xmath13 . the eigenvalues and the corresponding eigenstates of @xmath14 are encoded in the following energy function : @xmath15 where @xmath16 , called a _
spin_. in particular , the smallest eigenvalue of @xmath14 corresponding to the minimum of @xmath17 , and @xmath18 corresponds to its eigenvector ( called _ ground state _ ) of @xmath14 .
hereafter , we refer the problem of finding the minimum energy of the ising model or equivalently the ground state of ising hamiltonian as the _ ising problem_. an adiabatic quantum algorithm is described by a system hamiltonian @xmath19 for @xmath20 $ ] , @xmath21 , @xmath22 .
there are three ingredients of @xmath23 : ( 1 ) initial hamiltonian : @xmath24 ; ( 2 ) final hamiltonian : @xmath25 ; and ( 3 ) evolution path : @xmath26 \longrightarrow [ 0,1]$ ] , e.g. , @xmath27 .
@xmath23 is an adiabatic algorithm for an optimization problem if we encode the problem into the final hamiltonian @xmath28 such that the ground state of @xmath28 corresponds to the answer to the problem .
the initial hamiltonian @xmath29 is chosen to be non - commutative with @xmath28 and its ground state must be known and experimentally constructable , e.g. , @xmath30 . here @xmath31 is the running time of the algorithm . according to the adiabatic theorem , if @xmath32 evolves `` slowly '' enough , or equivalently , if @xmath31 is large enough , which is determined by the minimum spectral gap ( the difference between the two lowest energy levels ) of the system hamiltonian , the system remains at the ground state of @xmath32 , and consequently , ground state of @xmath25 gives the solution to the problem .
therefore , if we set @xmath28 to be @xmath14 , @xmath23 is an adiabatic algorithm for the ising problem . in physics , @xmath33 is known as the _ ising model in a transverse field_. a scalable superconducting architecture for adiabatic quantum computation that implements the hamiltonian of ising model in a transverse field was initially proposed by kaminsky et al .
d - wave systems inc .
@xcite is building such a superconducting quantum processor .
in particular , the quantum architecture is based on superconducting flux qubits connected via tunable coupling devices .
see figure [ fig : physical - qubit]@xmath34 for the schematic of physical qubit - coupler - qubit , and @xcite for its design and experimental results .
@xmath35{physical - qubit - coupler.png } & \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth , angle=90]{label - d3-k7.png}\\ ( a ) & ( b ) \end{array}\ ] ] [ fig : d3-triad ] topologically , an adiabatic quantum hardware architecture can be viewed as an undirected graph @xmath1 with weighted vertices and weighted edges .
see figure [ fig : d3-triad]@xmath36 for an example .
let @xmath1 denote the quantum hardware graph .
each vertex @xmath37 corresponds to a qubit , and each edge @xmath38 corresponds to a coupler between qubit @xmath12 and qubit @xmath39 . in the following
, we will use qubit and vertex , and coupler and edge interchangeably when there is no confusion .
there are two weights , @xmath40 ( called the qubit _ bias _ ) and @xmath41 ( called the _ tunneling amplitude _ ) , associated with each qubit @xmath12 .
there is a weight @xmath42 ( called the coupler _ strength _ ) associated with each coupler @xmath43 . in general , these weights are functions of time , i.e. , they vary over time , e.g. , @xmath44 .
there are some known physical constraints on the quantum hardware graph ( superconductor based design ) . in particular , there is a _ degree - constraint _ in that each qubit can have at most a constant number of couplers .
the coupler ( or edge ) length can not be `` too long ''
( that is , all neighbor qubits are within a bounded distance ) .
note that the wire of a qubit can be `` stretched '' .
the shape of each qubit does not need to be a small circle .
in other words , an adiabatic quantum hardware graph is a bounded - degree , edge - length bounded _ geometric graph _ ( or known as _ layout _ ) .
notice that crossing is allowed ( i.e. , it can be a non - planar graph ) .
given an adiabatic quantum computer that implements the ising hamiltonian , one can thus solve an ising problem on a graph @xmath0 , if @xmath0 can be embedded as a subgraph of the quantum hardware graph @xmath1 . as mentioned above , there are physical constraints on the hardware graph @xmath1 .
in particular , the _ degree - constraint _ of a qubit implies that the graphs that can be solved on a given hardware graph @xmath1 through subgraph embedding must also be degree - bounded .
so what to do if @xmath0 is not a subgraph of the hardware graph @xmath1 ?
kaminsky et al .
@xcite observed and proposed that one can embed @xmath0 in @xmath2 through ferromagnetic coupling to solve maximum independent set ( mis ) problem ( which is a special case of the ising problem ) of planar cubic graphs ( regular graphs of degree-3 ) on an adiabatic quantum computer .
in particular , they proposed an @xmath45 square lattice as a scalable hardware architecture on which all @xmath46-vertex planar cubic graphs are embeddable .
the notion of embedding here follows naturally from physicists intuition that each _ logical qubit _ ( corresponding to a vertex in the input graph )
is mapped to a subtree of _ physical qubits _ ( corresponding to vertices in the hardware graph ) that are ferromagnetically coupled such that each subtree of physical qubits acts like a single logical qubit .
for example , in figure [ fig : example - embedding ] , the logical qubit @xmath47 ( in orange color ) of the graph @xmath0 is mapped to a subtree of physical qubits ( labeled @xmath47 ) of the square lattice . informally , a minor - embedding @xmath48 of a graph @xmath0 in the hardware graph @xmath1 is a subgraph of @xmath1 such that @xmath48 is an `` expansion '' of @xmath0 by replacing each vertex of @xmath0 with a ( connected ) subtree of @xmath1 , or equivalently , @xmath0 can be obtained from @xmath48 by contracting edges ( same color in figure [ fig : example - embedding ] ) . in graph theory
, @xmath0 is called a ( graph ) _ minor _ of @xmath1 .
( see for example @xcite ) .
we now formally define minor - embedding .
let @xmath1 be a fixed hardware graph .
given @xmath0 , the _ minor - embedding _ of @xmath0 is defined by @xmath49 such that * each vertex in @xmath7 is mapped to a connected subtree @xmath50 of @xmath1 ; * there exists a map @xmath51 such that for each @xmath52 , there are corresponding @xmath53 and @xmath54 with @xmath55 . given @xmath0 ,
if @xmath56 exists , we say that @xmath0 is _ embeddable _ in @xmath1 .
when @xmath56 is clear from the context , we denote the minor - embedding @xmath57 of @xmath0 by @xmath48 is also referred as @xmath0-minor . ] .
see figure [ fig : example - embedding ] for an example .
in particular , there are two special cases of minor - embedding : * _ subgraph - embedding : _ each @xmath50 consists of a single vertex in @xmath1 .
that is , @xmath0 is isomorphic to @xmath48 ( a subgraph of @xmath1 ) . * _ topological - minor - embedding : _ each @xmath50 is a chain ( or path ) of vertices in @xmath1 .
remark : the embedding in @xcite is the _ topological - minor _ embedding . in @xcite , we have shown that the np - hard quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem @xcite ( which is equivalent to the ising problem ) on a graph @xmath0 can be solved in an adiabatic quantum computer that implements the spin-1/2 ising hamiltonian , by reduction through minor - embedding of @xmath0 in the quantum hardware graph @xmath2 . by _ reduction through minor - embedding _ ,
we mean that one can reduce the original ising hamiltonian on the input graph @xmath0 to the embedded ising hamiltonian @xmath58 on its minor - embedding @xmath48 , i.e. , the solution to the embedded ising hamiltonian gives rise to the solution to the original ising hamiltonian .
we proved the correctness of the minor - embedding reduction .
there are two components to the reduction : _ embedding _ and _ parameter setting_. the embedding problem is to find a minor - embedding @xmath48 of a graph @xmath0 in @xmath1 .
the parameter setting problem is to set the corresponding parameters , qubit bias and coupler strengths , of the embedded ising hamiltonian . in @xcite
, we solved the parameter setting problem .
the embedding problem , though , is dependent on the hardware graph design problem discussed in the following sections .
in this section , we describe a @xmath59-minor hardware graph , where @xmath59 is a complete graph of @xmath60 vertices .
a triangular layout of a @xmath59-minor graph @xcite , called triad , is shown in figure [ fig : triad ] .
@xmath61{complete8.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=0.3\textwidth , angle=90]{triad - k8.pdf } \end{array}\ ] ] the idea behind the construction of triad is to map each vertex of @xmath59 to a chain of @xmath62 `` virtual '' vertices .
the inductive construction is illustrated in figure [ fig : construction ] .
@xmath63{complete3.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{complete4.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth]{complete5.pdf } \\
\includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth , angle=90]{triad - k3.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth , angle=90]{triad - k4.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=0.15\textwidth , angle=90]{triad - k5.pdf } \end{array}\ ] ] suppose the available degree ( the number of allowed couplers ) of a physical qubit is @xmath64 . the idea is to chop the @xmath62 virtual vertices into @xmath65 physical qubits .
for example , suppose @xmath66 and @xmath67 , then it will require two physical qubits : we `` chop '' the chain of @xmath68 virtual vertices into two physical qubits : one consists of 3 virtual vertices and the other consists of 4 virtual vertices .
see figure [ fig : decomp]@xmath34 for the illustration .
@xmath69{decomp1.pdf } & \includegraphics[width=0.45\textwidth]{figuredecompose2.pdf}\\ ( a ) & ( b ) \end{array}\ ] ] [ fig : decomp2 ] the result of such a chopping is a decomposition of @xmath59 .
alternatively , we can view a complete graph @xmath59 as a combination ( disjoint union ) of two complete subgraphs of @xmath70 and a complete bipartite graph of @xmath71 .
inductively , a complete graph @xmath59 ( assume @xmath72 ) can be represented as a partition of complete graph @xmath73 s and complete bipartite graph @xmath74 s , as illustrated in figure [ fig : decomp2]@xmath36 .
notice that @xmath75 is a minor of @xmath74 .
for example , if @xmath67 , one can thus use @xmath76 as the basic unit for building triad . by construction , it is easy to see that triad is optimized for embedding a complete graph @xmath59 .
each logical qubit ( vertex ) of @xmath59 requires at least @xmath77 physical qubits .
that is , the hardware graph needs to have @xmath78 physical qubits . in short , triad satisfies all known physical constraints and admits a simple and efficient embedding ( as illustrated in figure [ fig : triad ] ) of @xmath59 , which thus allows for embedding any graph of @xmath60 vertices efficiently .
since qubits and couplers are scarce , we are interested in designing a sparse - graph - minor hardware graph .
first , we introduce the terminology of minor - universal graph .
let @xmath4 consist of a set of sparse graphs ( e.g. , bounded degree graphs ) .
it is also desirable that these sparse graphs are the underlying graphs of some classically hard instances .
we are interested in designing a @xmath4-minor - universal graph _
@xmath5 _ that is as small as possible ( in terms of number of qubits and number of couplers ) subject to both physical constraints and embedding constraint .
that is , it satisfies all known physical constraints and , at the same time , a minor - embedding can be efficiently computed .
the name `` minor - universal '' was naturally adopted from the `` universal graph '' .
there are many studies on the construction of an universal graph ( which is a special case of a minor - universal graph ) , see @xcite and references therein .
many of these work are based on the expanders which seem to have the desired properties sparse and yet highly connected .
however , to the best of our knowledge , all the current known explicitly constructable expanders are _ topological _ graphs and require long edge lengths , while what we need is a _ geometric _ expander .
minors are well - studied in graph theory , see for example @xcite . given a _ fixed _
graph @xmath0 , there are algorithms that find a minor - embedding of @xmath0 in @xmath1 in polynomial time of size of @xmath1 , from the pioneering @xmath80 time algorithm by robertson and seymour @xcite to the recent nearly linear time algorithm of b. reed .
however , it is worthwhile to reiterate that these algorithms are for _ fixed _
@xmath0 , and their running times are _ exponential _ in the size of @xmath0 . here
the minor - embedding problem is to find a minor - embedding of @xmath0 ( for any given @xmath0 ) while fixing @xmath1 . to the best of our knowledge ,
the only known work related to our minor - embedding problem was by kleinberg and rubinfeld @xcite , in which they showed that there is a randomized polynomial algorithm , based on a random walk , to find a minor - embedding in a given degree - bounded expander .
however , as discussed above , the known expanders do not satisfy the physical constraints required .
our embedding problem might appear similar to the embedding problem from parallel architecture studies .
however , besides the different physical constraints for the design of architectures , the requirements are very different .
in particular , in our embedding problem , we do not allow for _ load _ @xmath81 , which is the maximum number of logical qubits mapped to a single physical qubit .
also , we require _ dilation _ , which is the maximum number of stretched edges ( through other qubits ) , to be exactly 1
. however , all of the existing research on embedding problems for parallel processors @xcite , at least one of the conditions is violated ( namely either load @xmath81 or dilation @xmath81 ) .
we remark that the _ treewidth _ of @xmath5 needs to necessarily large ( @xmath82 ) for otherwise the dynamic programming over the tree - decomposition of @xmath5 would be able to solve the problem in @xmath83 time ( while polynomial in the size of the input size ) @xcite , once the embedding is given . for the quantum circuit model ,
it was shown by markov & shi @xcite that a quantum circuit with @xmath60 gates whose underlying graph has treewidth @xmath84 can be simulated in @xmath85 time .
how does a minor - embedding affect the efficiency of an adiabatic algorithm ? and how do we measure the goodness of an embedding ?
these problems in turn relate to the running time or complexity of quantum adiabatic algorithms . recall that
according to the adiabatic theorem , the running time of an adiabatic algorithm depends on the minimum spectral gap of the system hamiltonian , which however is in general difficult to compute analytically . in order to address the time complexity of an adiabatic algorithm ,
one will also need to specify the initial hamiltonian .
the effect of the embedding and its consequential initial hamiltonian on the complexity of an adiabatic algorithm remains to be investigated .
most of this work was done while the author was working at d - wave systems inc .
i would like to thank my colleagues from whom i learn to derive this work .
thanks also go to david kirkpatrick for the encouragement , advice and discussion , and bill kaminsky for the comments . | in @xcite , we introduced the notion of minor - embedding in adiabatic quantum optimization . a minor - embedding of a graph @xmath0 in a quantum hardware graph @xmath1 is a subgraph of @xmath2 such that @xmath0 can be obtained from it by contracting edges .
in this paper , we describe the intertwined adiabatic quantum architecture design problem , which is to construct a hardware graph @xmath2 that satisfies all known physical constraints and , at the same time , permits an efficient minor - embedding algorithm .
we illustrate an optimal complete - graph - minor hardware graph . given a family @xmath3 of graphs , a ( host ) graph @xmath1 is called @xmath3-minor - universal if for each graph @xmath0 in @xmath3 , @xmath1 contains a minor - embedding of @xmath0 .
the problem for designing a @xmath4-minor - universal hardware graph @xmath5 in which @xmath4 consists of a family of sparse graphs ( e.g. , bounded degree graphs ) is open . |
in recent years there have been significant advances in the tomographic characterization of materials . as a result , it is now possible to carry out detailed investigations of the 3d grain structures of polycrystalline materials ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
a fundamental ingredient in any such investigation is a suitable quantitative description of the grain morphology .
such a description contains the key features of the structure , ideally free from noise and imaging artifacts .
a good description usually results in significant data compression , describing large 3d voxel data sets using only a small number of parameters .
data compression is necessary , for example , when carrying out analysis of sequences of tomographic data sets ( e.g. , the high time resolution in - situ synchrotron images considered in @xcite ) .
in addition , the description of tomographic data via tessellations provides a basis for the statistical analysis of grain structures and , in some cases , can be used to develop stochastic models of material microstructures ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
the most commonly used quantitative descriptions of space - filling grain ensembles are based on tessellations , which divide the space into disjoint regions called _ cells_. the cells represent the individual grains .
the most widely used tessellation model is the _ voronoi tessellation _ ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , which takes , as parameters , a set of generating points .
the space is then divided into convex cells by assigning each point to its nearest generator .
laguerre tessellation _
( see , e.g. , @xcite ) is a generalization of the voronoi tessellation that also partitions the space into convex cells .
like the voronoi tessellation , the laguerre tessellation is generated by a set of points ; however , unlike the voronoi tessellation , these points are weighted , with the weights influencing the size of the cells .
consequently , the laguerre tessellation is able to describe a wider range of structures than the voronoi tessellation .
for this reason , the laguerre tessellation is a popular choice for modeling polycrystalline grain structures @xcite and other materials , such as foams @xcite . in order to describe a tessellation by a set of generating points
, it is necessary to solve an inverse problem : that is , a set of generating points that produce the observed cells must be found . the _ voronoi inverse problem _ ( vip ) is well - studied ; see , for example , @xcite . recently , duan et al .
@xcite proposed an algorithm that finds solutions to the _ laguerre inverse problem _
although the examples considered in @xcite are restricted to 2d , the methodology is easily applied in higher dimensions .
the solutions to the vip and the lip assume that the empirical data constitute perfect descriptions of the observed cells .
however , this is not true when working with tomographic data , which is distorted by noise and also contains imprecision arising from discretization during the imaging process .
it is also worth noting that real - world materials are not perfectly described by laguerre tessellations ( though the descriptions can be quite good ) .
these limitations mean that methods that attempt to invert a tessellation extracted from the tomographic data do not , in general , result in good fits .
the lip is solved by iteratively finding the generating points of the given tessellations . when applied to imperfect data
, this iterative procedure propagates errors , resulting in tessellations that have little correspondence to the tomographic data .
thus , when dealing with empirical data , it is not appropriate to attempt to solve the lip . instead , the generating points of a laguerre tessellation that is a good approximation of the material must be found .
this is , at its core , an optimization problem .
we call this problem the _ laguerre approximation problem _ ( lap ) .
the corresponding voronoi approximation problem has been considered in the literature , beginning with @xcite .
a simple heuristic approach for solving the lap was proposed in @xcite .
more sophisticated approaches , which formulate and solve an optimization problem , are described in @xcite .
although these techniques provide good fits in certain settings , they are either limited to small sample sizes or require the considered tessellations to be sufficiently regular . in this paper
, we present a fast and robust algorithm for fitting laguerre approximations to large data sets .
more precisely , we formulate an optimization problem where we minimize the discrepancy between the grain boundaries observed in the image data and the grain boundaries produced by our laguerre approximation .
the cost function is chosen so that it can be evaluated very efficiently and that all necessary information can be easily obtained from image data .
we then solve the optimization problem using the cross - entropy ( ce ) method @xcite , a stochastic optimization algorithm that is able to escape local minima .
we carry out experiments on both real and artificially - generated image data that show our approach is able to produce very good fits .
this paper is structured as follows . in section
[ sec : laguerre ] , we review some key properties of laguerre tessellations . in section [ sec : optimization ] , we give a more complete description of the lap and formulate our optimization problem .
then , in section [ sec : ce - method ] , we introduce the ce method as a robust tool for solving this optimization problem .
section [ sec : results ] gives results for both artificial and experimental data that demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach .
finally , section [ sec : conclusions ] summarizes our results and suggests directions for further research .
in the following section , we define voronoi and laguerre tessellations and give a number of properties that we will use to solve the lap . for notational convenience ,
we only consider tessellations in @xmath0 .
however , our methods are easily applied in other dimensions .
the voronoi tessellation is defined by a locally finite set of generating points , @xmath1 , where @xmath2 denotes the index set consisting of natural numbers .
the cell corresponding to the @xmath3th generating point , @xmath4 , is given by @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the euclidean norm on @xmath0 .
in the case of the laguerre tessellation , the generating points , @xmath7 , are weighted , where we assume that @xmath8 .
the cells of the laguerre tessellation , @xmath9 , are then defined by @xmath10 for all @xmath11 , where the euclidean norm used in is replaced by the so - called power distance @xmath12 given the generator points , the faces of the cells can be computed efficiently ; see , e.g. , @xcite . as we take the weights @xmath13 to be positive real numbers , the generating points have a geometric interpretation as spheres .
that is , we can represent a generating point , @xmath14 , as a sphere with center @xmath15 and radius @xmath13 .
the flexibility of the laguerre tessellation comes at a cost .
for example , while each cell of a voronoi tessellation contains its generating point , the generating points of a laguerre tessellation may not be contained in their corresponding cells . in some cases , a generating point of a laguerre tessellation may not even produce a cell .
that is , it is possible that there exists a point , @xmath14 , such that @xmath16 ; see , for example , @xcite .
in addition , while the cells of a voronoi tessellation uniquely determine its generating points , there are uncountably many sets of generating points that can generate a given laguerre tessellation ; see , @xcite .
thus , while the vip has a unique solution , the lip has uncountably many solutions . under mild conditions
, however , it can be shown that the generating points of a laguerre tessellation are uniquely determined given one generating point and the weight ( or one coordinate ) of a generating point in an adjacent cell ; see @xcite .
we will often find it convenient to consider planes that are equidistant from two generating points ( under their respective power distances ) .
that is , given two generating points , @xmath14 and @xmath17 , we consider the separating plane given by @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the unit normal vector of @xmath20 and @xmath21 is the shortest distance from the origin to the plane ; see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.1 ) for more details .
the plane @xmath20 defines a half - space @xmath22 which covers the cell @xmath23 .
note that the intersection of all such half - spaces , @xmath24 , defines the cell @xmath23 . because the normal vectors are taken to be unit vectors , the distance from an arbitrary point , @xmath25 , to the plane @xmath20 is given by @xmath26
given an exact description of a laguerre tessellation ( e.g. , in terms of the half - spaces defined above ) , it is not too difficult to solve the lip .
that is , it is straightforward to find a set of weighted points that is able to generate the given tessellation . furthermore , these points can be chosen to satisfy certain constraints ; see @xcite .
when dealing with tomographic data , however , the description of the tessellation is not exact .
this is because , even if the material itself can be perfectly described by a laguerre tessellation , the noise and discretization errors inherent in the imaging process mean that the cell boundaries extracted from the data are subject to error .
the lip can be solved as described in @xcite .
however , the iterative computation of generators is sensitive to imperfect data and errors propagate quickly . as a result
, the ensuing tessellations often do not correspond well to the tomographic data . therefore , solving the lip for empirical data is generally ill advised .
instead , we wish to find generating points that produce a laguerre tessellation that is as close as possible to the tomographic data ( with respect to some metric ) .
this is , at its core , an optimization problem . in order to properly formulate this optimization problem
, a discrepancy measure needs to be defined .
we then choose the generating points of the approximating tessellation in order to minimize this discrepancy .
the choice of discrepancy measure depends on the nature of empirical data . in this paper
, we work with tomographic data .
we assume that the tomographic image data constitutes a collection of voxels in a convex window .
furthermore , we assume that the image has already been segmented e.g. , by the watershed transform ; see @xcite and that the voxels have been labeled by their corresponding grains .
thus , the data is of the form @xmath27 , where @xmath28 denotes the number of grains and @xmath29 is a grid of voxel coordinates .
the @xmath3th grain region , @xmath30 , is then given by @xmath31 .
note that @xmath32 does not correspond to an actual grain , but is either the empty set or a collection of one voxel thick layers that separate grains .
such thin layers often arise in segmentation procedures such as the watershed transformation .
a grain region @xmath30 may correspond to the grain itself or a region that contains the grain ( if the space is not completely filled with grains ) , cf .
figure [ fig : labeled - image ] .
we assume that the grain regions are roughly convex and that the segmentation is of a high quality . the most direct way to measure the discrepancy between 3d image data and a laguerre tessellation generated by the points @xmath7 is by counting the number of incorrectly assigned voxels .
that is , we calculate @xmath33 where @xmath34 is a discretized version of the tessellation generated by @xmath35 and @xmath36 denotes the number of elements in some set @xmath37 .
many other discrepancy measures considered in the literature are of a similar form . for example , in @xcite , the difference between a cell in the approximating tessellation and its equivalent in the empirical data is measured by the intersection of the approximating cell with the corresponding adjacent cells in the empirical data .
minimizing the total overlap of the approximating cells is equivalent to minimizing the number of incorrectly assigned voxels .
we call discrepancy measures that aim to minimize the volume of the difference between the empirical and approximating tessellations _ volume - based _ measures .
although minimizing a volume - based measure gives a very good fit to the data , such measures are poorly suited to most numerical optimization methods .
this is because evaluating such a discrepancy measure is computationally expensive .
for example , when considering the number of incorrectly assigned voxels , a discretized version of the approximating tessellation needs to be generated . in practice , this limits the number of times such a discrepancy measure can be evaluated . as a result , approaches that aim to minimize volume - based discrepancies are restricted to small data sets with small numbers of grains ( e.g. , 109 grains in @xcite ) or are forced to use non - optimal optimization techniques , such as gradient - descent , which do not require too many evaluations of the discrepancy and , as such , limit the time taken by the fitting procedure ( ideally to substantially less than 24 hours ) .
as we propose to use stochastic optimization techniques to solve this problem , we need a discrepancy measure that is significantly faster to evaluate .
we can achieve this by considering an _ interface - based _ discrepancy measure a measure that considers only the boundaries between cells instead of a volume - based one .
if an approximating tessellation can accurately reproduce these interfaces , it will be a good approximation of the data .
the primary advantage of interface - based discrepancy measures is that they can be calculated from the generating points of the approximating tessellation without the need to generate the tessellation itself . in order to define such a discrepancy measure
, we consider the sets of voxels that separate adjacent cells .
we define the interface between two grains , @xmath3 and @xmath38 , in the empirical data by @xmath39 where @xmath40 denotes the 26-neighborhood of @xmath41 i.e. , the voxels @xmath42 that have a distance less than or equal to @xmath43 from @xmath41 .
this set contains all voxels that touch both grains .
note that @xmath44 if the grains are not adjacent . if the tessellation generated by @xmath7 is a good approximation to the empirical data , then the plane separating the generating points of adjacent cells @xmath3 and @xmath38 ( which defines the boundary of the two cells ) should be close to @xmath45 .
thus , we measure the distance between @xmath45 and @xmath20 , the plane separating cells @xmath3 and @xmath38 in the approximating tessellation .
the discrepancy between the approximating tessellation and the empirical data is then given by the sum of squares of these distances .
that is , we define @xmath46 where @xmath47 is given in and @xmath48 is the set of separating planes determined by the generating points @xmath49 .
note that this discrepancy measure can be calculated without generating the approximating tessellation .
a separating plane can be computed for all pairs of generators ( or generator candidates , when performing the optimization ) even if their cells are empty or not adjacent in the laguerre tessellation .
therefore , such ` degenerate ' cases are not a problem for our approach . by matching all separating planes to the corresponding test points at once
, laguerre cells computed based on ` good ' configurations of generators will match the desired cell configuration well enough .
when aiming to minimize a volume - based discrepancy , the lap reduces to the optimization problem of finding @xmath50 there are a number of significant difficulties which must be overcome in solving . in particular , a. the optimization problem is high - dimensional , b. the optimization problem has many local minima , c. the discrepancy is expensive to evaluate .
the approach developed in @xcite avoids problems ( ii ) and ( iii ) by finding the exact solution of a linear program ( an optimization problem where a linear cost function is minimized subject to linear constraints ) .
however , when the lap is transformed into a linear program , the size of the resulting problem grows very quickly in both the number of voxels and the number of grains .
this means that the linear programming approach can not be applied to large 3d data sets containing many grains . in @xcite ,
gradient - descent methods are used to obtain laguerre approximations ( with a relatively low number of evaluations of the discrepancy ) .
unlike the linear programming approach , the dimensionality of the optimization problem grows only linearly in the number of grains ( and does not depend on the number of voxels ) .
thus , @xcite avoids problem ( iii ) and , to a lesser extent , problem ( i ) .
however , the gradient - descent methods used there become stuck in local minima .
thus , the approach considered in @xcite is reliant on the ability to find initial conditions that are close to global optima . although it is often possible to find good initial conditions
e.g. , when fitting tessellations to foams with regular structures this is not always the case , as will be seen in section [ sec : results ] .
in addition , even when good initial conditions can be found , the quality of the approximating tessellation can usually be significantly improved when the optimization algorithm is able to escape local minima .
stochastic optimization methods are widely used tools for solving high - dimensional optimization problems with many local minima ; see @xcite for an overview .
such methods have been used to solve problems related to the lap . in @xcite ,
the ce method is used to find a solution to the lip and , in @xcite , simulated annealing is used to fit 3d laguerre tessellations to 2d image data .
however , no stochastic approach has yet been proposed in order to solve the lap for large , noisy 3d data sets . in our approach to solving the lap for large tomographic data sets , we use the ce method to minimize an interface - based discrepancy measure .
the ce method has been widely applied to high - dimensional multi - extremal optimization problems ; see , @xcite .
it has a number of advantages over other stochastic optimization methods .
for example , simulated annealing ( described in @xcite ) can not be easily applied to the lap , as it is very difficult to find an appropriate cooling schedule .
in addition , the ce method can be easily parallelized . by using the ce method to minimize an interface - based discrepancy measure
, we have a method that can escape local minima and solves a problem whose dimensionality grows linearly in the number of grains .
although the discrepancy is expensive to evaluate , we reduce this cost significantly by minimizing an interface - based measure .
in addition , we further reduce the cost of calculating the discrepancy by replacing @xmath51 defined in with an approximation , @xmath52 . the interface - based discrepancy , @xmath51 , measures the distance between voxels on the boundaries between cells in the empirical data and the planes separating the generating points in the approximating tessellation . in order to calculate this discrepancy , every voxel in each grain boundary
is considered .
although this is much faster to calculate than a volume - based discrepancy , it is still computationally expensive .
however , very good approximations of @xmath51 can be obtained by instead considering sets of _ test points _ that describe the interfaces between the grains .
we find that test points obtained by fitting approximating planes to the interfaces , using the orthogonal regression approach introduced in @xcite , work very well . in order to calculate the test points , we consider only the points separating the two cells being considered ( i.e. , we ignore points of contact between three or more grains ) .
thus , instead of @xmath45 , we consider @xmath53 this avoids some numerical issues that could arise when using orthogonal regression .
we then approximate the boundary between the @xmath3th and @xmath38th grain using the plane that minimizes the total squared distance to all points in @xmath54 . determining this plane is a least - squares problem , which we solve using singular value decomposition .
the approximating plane passes through the centroid , @xmath55 , of the set @xmath56 .
we obtain a normal vector , @xmath57 , to the plane by taking the right - singular vector corresponding to the smallest singular value of the matrix containing the voxel coordinates in @xmath56 shifted by @xmath58 . for more details on the singular value decomposition approach ,
see @xcite .
the test points , @xmath59 are chosen to lie on this approximating plane . more precisely , we put a circle with radius @xmath60 around the centroid @xmath61 with the same orientation as the plane .
we then place @xmath62 test points equidistantly on this circle .
an illustration is given in figure [ fig : test_points_on_plane ] . in cases where the estimation of the plane is not ` stable ' ( i.e.
, the number of voxels in @xmath56 is too low to determine the location and orientation ) , we simply use the centroid @xmath61 for all 10 test points . the criterion for ` stable ' is simple : the smallest singular value must be smaller than half the second largest one . this way we can be confident that the third and shortest axis ( which is perpendicular to the plane )
is correctly identified .
given the test points for the boundary between adjacent grains @xmath3 and @xmath38 , we define the approximate discrepancy at the boundary by @xmath63 where @xmath47 is given in and @xmath20 is the plane separating the generating points @xmath14 and @xmath17 .
the total approximate discrepancy is then given by @xmath64 note that , here , we normalize the discrepancy .
this is done in order to make the cost function easier to interpret : it can be thought of as the average squared distance of test points from their corresponding separating plane .
the cross - entropy ( ce ) method is a stochastic optimization method that is able to solve many difficult optimization problems , including combinatorial optimization problems and continuous optimization problems with many local minima ; see @xcite .
the fundamental idea of the method is to describe the location of the global minimum of an @xmath65-dimensional cost function , @xmath66 , in terms of a degenerate @xmath65-dimensional probability distribution .
that is , a random variable with this distribution takes only a single value , namely @xmath67 .
if there is more than one global minimum , each minimum will have a corresponding degenerate distribution .
the ce method works by ` learning ' one of these distributions . in the continuous
setting , this is done as follows . a parametric density , @xmath68 , is used to describe the possible locations of a global minimum .
a sample of size @xmath69 is drawn from this density and ordered by the corresponding values of @xmath70 . the @xmath71 ( where @xmath72 is the ceiling function ) members of the sample with the lowest values of @xmath70
are identified as the ` elite ' sample , where @xmath73 .
the elite sample is then used to update the parameter vector , @xmath74 .
the updating is done by choosing @xmath74 to minimize the cross - entropy distance ( also called the kullback - leibler divergence ) between @xmath68 and the targeted degenerate probability distribution .
the process is continued until a stopping condition is met , e.g. , the probability distribution is nearly degenerate .
thus , the ce method uses information about good choices of arguments to find better choices . the ce method and its convergence properties
are discussed extensively in @xcite .
usually , the parametric density , @xmath75 , is chosen to be a product of normal densities .
that is , we choose @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the density of a normal distribution with mean @xmath78 and standard deviation @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
thus , each component of the argument of @xmath66 is drawn independently from a normal distribution .
there are two main reasons for using normal distributions .
first , as the standard deviation of a normal distribution goes to zero , the distribution converges to a degenerate distribution .
the second reason is that the parameter vector , @xmath81 , which minimizes the cross - entropy distance , is simply given by the maximum - likelihood estimates obtained from the elite sample . in other words
, we update the parameters by setting the means equal to the sample means of the elite sample and the standard deviations equal to the sample standard deviations of the elite sample . using this approach
, we have the following general algorithm for estimating @xmath82
. 1 . * initialization . *
identify an initial parameter vector , @xmath83 and set @xmath84 .
2 . * sampling . *
draw an independent sample @xmath85 from @xmath86 and sort it so that @xmath87 .
we denote the @xmath38th component of @xmath88 by @xmath89 .
* updating . *
calculate the sample means and standard deviations of the elite sample .
that is , calculate @xmath90 and @xmath91 set @xmath92 and @xmath93 .
set @xmath94 .
* iteration . *
if a predetermined stopping condition is met , terminate .
otherwise , set @xmath95 and repeat from step @xmath96 .
the parameters of the ce algorithm help to improve the speed of convergence and quality of solutions .
for example , a good choice of @xmath97 improves the convergence properties of the algorithm .
the means , @xmath98 , should be chosen as close as possible to the optimal solution .
the initial standard deviations , @xmath99 , should be chosen large enough that the algorithm is able to escape local minima but not so large that good configurations are quickly abandoned .
ideally , the size of the sample in each step , @xmath69 , should be quite large . however , there are often memory and performance constraints that limit this size .
the parameter @xmath100 , which controls the size of the elite sample , should be chosen large enough that a representative sample of good solutions are included in the elite sample . however ,
if @xmath100 is chosen too large , the algorithm will take too long to converge .
in general , the bigger @xmath69 is , the smaller @xmath100 should be .
a standard stopping condition for the algorithm is that it terminates when the cost function does not decrease significantly for a given number of steps .
when using the ce approach outlined above , the standard deviations of the normal densities may shrink too quickly .
in this case , the ce algorithm can converge to a sub - optimal solution . in order to guard against this
, we use variance injection .
the basic idea is to occasionally increase the variances of the distributions so that the algorithm can easily escape local minima .
usually , variance is injected when the cost function does not decrease significantly enough over a given number of iterations .
the magnitude of this increase can depend on the current value of the cost function .
if variance injection is used a number of times without a significant decrease in the cost function , then the algorithm is terminated .
an alternative to variance injection is to use smoothing when updating @xmath74 .
the updating step for the means at the @xmath101th iteration is then of the form @xmath102 and the updating step for the standard deviations is given by @xmath103 where @xmath104 $ ] ( typically @xmath105 $ ] ) .
it is also possible to carry out dynamic smoothing , with both @xmath106 and @xmath107 taken to be functions of the number of steps . in our experience
, variance injection is more effective than smoothing . for a detailed discussion of both variance injection and dynamic smoothing ,
see @xcite .
we solve the lap by minimizing the approximate discrepancy described in section [ sec : approx ] .
that is , we solve @xmath108 where @xmath52 is given in . putting this in the terminology of section [ sec : ce_description ] , we find the arguments that minimize the cost function @xmath109 , namely the @xmath110 generating points , each of which is described by three coordinates and an associated radius .
we associate a normal distribution with each of the @xmath111 values that need to be determined .
thus , for @xmath112 , the coordinates and radius of the @xmath3th generating point , @xmath113 , are each described by a normal density .
we denote the initial means and standard deviations by @xmath114 and @xmath115 . in order to ensure that the radii are positive , we truncate the corresponding normal densities to the positive real line ( this is possible without changing the updating rules ,
see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
we apply variance injection when the cost function does not decrease significantly over a period of @xmath116 iterations .
more precisely , at each iteration of the algorithm , we record @xmath117 , the minimal value of the approximate discrepancies calculated from the sample in that step .
if , at the @xmath101th step , @xmath118 we perform variance injection .
because many generating points may already be close to their optimal positions and sizes , variance injection is carried out locally with a magnitude controlled by a parameter @xmath119 .
this is done by calculating the local cost of each cell and increasing the variance of the associated densities accordingly .
we calculate the average cost of the @xmath3th cell by @xmath120 the local cost of a cell , @xmath121 , is defined to be the maximum of its own average cost and the average cost of its adjacent cells .
that is , @xmath122 the variance injection is performed by setting @xmath123 for @xmath112 .
if , at any stage , the benefit of variance injection becomes negligible , we stop performing it . more precisely , if the current minimum cost , @xmath124 divided by the minimum cost immediately prior to the last variance injection is larger than @xmath125 , we no longer carry out variance injection .
the algorithm is terminated when @xmath126 where @xmath127 .
reasonably good initial tessellations can be obtained directly from the tomographic data @xcite .
the centroids and equivalent radii of the grains in the tomographic data are used for the coordinates and radii of the generating points .
the centroids , @xmath128 , are given by @xmath129 for @xmath130 .
the equivalent radii are given by @xmath131{\frac{3}{4\pi } \
# r_i}\ ] ] for @xmath130 .
the initial means of the densities are then given by @xmath132 , @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 for @xmath112 .
the initial standard deviations are chosen proportional to the local cost of the cells in this approximation .
the local costs are calculated as in section [ sec : vi_details ] .
thus , @xmath136 for @xmath112 .
our investigations showed that a parameter choice of @xmath137 , @xmath138 , @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 and @xmath143 works well for a large number of different data sets .
the elite set then consists of @xmath144 samples , which results in a sufficiently large sample of good solutions .
note that other parameter values may improve the speed of convergence ( or , in the case of the parameters controlling variance injection and termination , improve the quality of the approximation ) . however , the basic performance of the ce algorithm is relatively robust to parameter choice .
that is , the convergence behavior and quality of approximations are good for a wide range of parameters .
the approximations obtained using the ce algorithm have unbounded cells at the edge of the observation window .
this is because the corresponding grains in the tomographic data are not delimited by other grains .
the unbounded cells are then intersected with the observation window , @xmath145 .
note that , in most cases , edge grains are of little scientific interest and are not considered when analyzing the data . in practice , edge grains may be only partially observed or may not be representative ( e.g. , when stuying the dynamics of grains undergoing grain coarsening ) . in this paper , we explicitly ignore grains and their approximating cells if they lie at the edge of the observation window .
in this section , we present the results of a number of numerical experiments which we carried out in order to demonstrate the effectiveness of the ce approach .
we consider three distinct data sets .
two of these data sets are produced using stochastic models .
these ` artificial ' data sets allow us to investigate how well our method is able to reconstruct tessellations when we are certain the underlying tessellation is , indeed , laguerre .
the first artificial data set is produced using a stochastic model that describes a polycrystalline material undergoing grain coarsening .
the second artificial data set is , by design , much more pathological .
it exhibits large variation in the size and shape of its grains , as well as the number of neighbors each grain has .
this data set allows us to explore the effectiveness of our approach in an extreme setting .
in particular , it provides an example of a setting in which the standard choice of initial conditions is far from optimal .
finally , we consider an empirical data set : tomographic data obtained from a sample of al-5 wt% cu .
we demonstrate that our method is able to produce an excellent approximation to this data set using a laguerre tessellation .
the artificial data sets are produced using two distinct stochastic models .
the polycrystalline model ( pcm ) , developed in @xcite , describes a polycrystalline material undergoing grain coarsening .
the second data set is produced using a randomly marked poisson process ; see @xcite .
the resulting tessellation is known as a poisson - laguerre tessellation ( plt ) ; see @xcite . in the first case
, there is a strong correlation between the relative positions of the generating points and their weights . in the second example , the weights are independent of the positions of the generating points . as a result , the second data set is much less regular than the first data set .
figure [ fig : artificial : cross - sections ] shows 2d cross sections of the data sets , together with their generating points . in the pcm model , a random laguerre tessellation is produced using a set of spheres that may overlap slightly .
the centers of the spheres give the locations of the generating points and the radii define the weights .
the spheres have hard - cores which may not overlap .
this was shown to be a suitable model for polycrystalline materials in @xcite . both the density of the sphere packing and the radii of the spheres influence the sizes and shapes of the cells in the resulting tessellation .
in particular , when highly dense packings are used , very `` spherical '' cells are generated with a narrow coordination number distribution .
we generated a sample from this model in a bounded window , @xmath146 ^ 3 $ ] using parameters that were fitted to a sample of al-5 wt% cu annealed for 200 minutes .
the fitting procedure is described in @xcite .
note that the parameters we use were obtained by fitting the model to the empirical data described in section [ sec : results : experimental ] .
having produced a sample , we removed cells that would correspond to a very small number of voxels after discretization ( i.e. , cells having a smaller volume than a ball with radius of 4 voxels ) . the final result is a tessellation consisting of roughly 2500 grains ( approximately the same number as in the experimental data ) .
the plt model is generated by simulating a homogeneous poisson process with some intensity @xmath147 in a bounded window @xmath145 .
the points are independently marked by gamma - distributed random variables with some shape parameter @xmath106 and rate parameter @xmath107 .
note that , unlike the pcm model , it is possible that some generating points will not produce cells in the plt model .
we generated a sample from this model in @xmath148 ^ 3 $ ] with intensity @xmath149 ( so that the expected number of points is roughly 2500 ) , where we used parameters @xmath150 and @xmath151 for the mark distribution .
the realizations of the pcm and plt models were both discretized on a voxel grid , resulting in two @xmath152 images .
these images are of the form described in section [ sec : data ] .
the ce method was then used to solve the lap .
the results are illustrated in figure [ fig : artificial : cross - sections - overlay ] , where 2d cross - sections of the original tessellations are shown with the approximating tessellations superimposed .
using multi - threading on a standard quad - core processor ( intel core i5 - 3570k ) , the computing time was roughly 3 hours for the pcm data and 4 hours for the plt data . for smaller test sets , with 500 grains each ,
the time required was roughly 20 to 30 minutes .
the memory requirements when fitting the full data sets were minimal ( especially in comparison to approaches where it is necessary to store the complete voxelized data ) . basically , it is necessary to store the test points and all the generators from one iteration of the ce method .
the cost of storing additional variables , such as the means and standard deviations of the densities describing the generators and the cost values of the test points are negligible . for the pcm data , the number of test points used was approximately 140000 .
approximately 160000 points were used for the plt data .
together with @xmath153 generators in one iteration , this sums up to less than 200 mb of ram when using 32-bit floating point coordinates .
figure [ fig : artificial : convergence ] illustrates the convergence behavior of the ce algorithm .
when approximating the pcm data , roughly 650 iterations of the algorithm were required . in the plt case ,
about 900 iterations were required .
it is not surprising that the ce algorithm took longer to terminate in the plt case . as will be seen in section [ sec : results : artificial : evaluation ] the initial conditions in this setting are much further from the optimal solution . in order to evaluate the quality of our approximations
, we compare them to approximations obtained using the heuristic approach presented in @xcite and the orthogonal regression method proposed in @xcite .
note that , although the orthogonal regression approach is able to achieve quite good approximations of the cells , it does not result in a parametrized tessellation .
table [ tab : artificial : evaluation ] shows an evaluation of the approximations with respect to a volume - based discrepancy measure : the number of voxels that are correctly labeled . our method results in an almost perfect approximation of the pcm data .
the heuristic approach considered in @xcite also works very well .
however , it is not able to reproduce the neighbor structure as successfully as our approach , as evidenced by rows 2 through 5 of table [ tab : artificial : evaluation ] .
our method is slightly less successful at approximating the plt data but , in this case , considerably outperforms the heuristics of @xcite .
[ tab : artificial : evaluation ] the parameters used by the heuristic approach of @xcite are very close to the initial conditions of the ce algorithm . thus , from the difference in performance , it seems that the initial conditions are quite far from the optimal parameters . in order to find better configurations ,
the ce algorithm has to be able to escape local minima around these initial conditions .
this is made clear by the fact that increasing the number of times variance injection is used ( as well as the number of iterations ) , we are able to further improve the results for the ce algorithm .
namely , by manually increasing the number of variance injections to 20 ( instead of the 8 used in the standard approach ) , we obtained an approximation which correctly labeled 97.3% of the voxels ( instead of 96.2% ) .
this significant improvement indicates that local minima are present in which the ce algorithm is becoming trapped ( because variance injection works by helping the algorithm escape local minima ) .
this , in turn , implies that there are local minima near to the initial conditions of the ce algorithm that are sufficiently deep to trap it .
a direct implication of these results is that algorithms that converge to nearby local minima ( such as gradient - descent ) may not lead to good approximations when using a standard choice of initial conditions .
furthermore , it is not clear that it is always straightforward to find good initial conditions .
for example , the initial generating points are usually chosen to lie inside their cells .
but , using the methods presented in @xcite and the exact description of the plt tessellation , it was not possible to find a solution to the lip subject to the restriction that generating points were contained in their cells .
if a method such as gradient - descent starts with all of the points lying inside their cells , it is unclear that it will be able to obtain a solution where some generating points lie far outside their cells .
figure [ fig : artificial : cell - volumes ] shows scatter plots of the original cell sizes vs. the cell sizes in the ce approximations .
the quality of the ce approximation of the pcm data is immediately apparent .
it is also clear that the difficulties in fitting the plt data lie primarily in the small cells .
the experimental data we consider was used in @xcite to develop the pcm model discussed in section [ sec : results : artificial ] .
an al-5 wt% cu sample ( cylindrical with @xmath154 mm length and @xmath155 mm diameter ) was heated to the semisolid state at a temperature of @xmath156 , at which point coarsening processes were measured _ in situ _ using synchrotron x - ray tomographic imaging . for the present paper ,
we consider only data obtained after an annealing time of 200 minutes ( which corresponds to the first annealing step in @xcite ) .
it consists of approximately 2500 grains , which is quite a large data set .
a 2d cross - section of the data is shown in figure [ fig : experimental : cross - section ] .
the experimental data set was segmented using the watershed transformation , resulting in a labeled image of grain regions , which are separated by a watershed layer of one - voxel thickness .
further details regarding sample preparation , imaging and segmentation can be found in @xcite .
the ce method was applied to solve the lap for the experimental data set .
a cross - section of the resulting laguerre approximation is given in figure [ fig : experimental : cross - section - overlay ] .
0.5pt fitting the approximation took approximately 70 minutes on the same intel core i5 - 3570k quad - core processor used to fit the artificial data .
the number of test points extracted from the image data was roughly 150000 , which is almost the same as for the artificial data sets .
the convergence behavior of the ce method is illustrated in figure [ fig : experimental : convergence ] .
using the same parameters , only 283 iterations were necessary , which is substantially fewer than the number required for the artificial data .
this is mainly due to the fact that only one variance injection was required . as with the artificial data ,
we compare our results with the heuristic approach proposed in @xcite and the orthogonal regression approach introduced in @xcite .
as mentioned above , the orthogonal regression approach reconstructs the individual cells quite well but does not result in a tessellation . the results are summarized in table [ tab : experimental : evaluation ] .
the ce method correctly assigns @xmath157% of the voxels .
in contrast , the heuristic approach correctly assigns only @xmath158% of the voxels .
the orthogonal regression yields @xmath159% .
[ tab : experimental : evaluation ] note that the ce method significantly outperforms both the heuristic method and orthogonal regression when describing the neighborhood structure of the grains , although it does not seem possible for a tessellation containing only convex cells to accurately capture the full neighborhood structure .
this is at least partially due to segmentation issues and contacts in the image data with very small areas .
in contrast , the orthogonal regression approach performs surprisingly badly .
it seems that the geometric properties of normal laguerre tessellations ( e.g. , coinciding faces , edges and vertices ) favor realistic reconstructions .
we think this confirms that the laguerre tessellation is a good choice for representing polycrystalline microstructures .
it is possible , of course , that the quality of the fit could be improved using non - convex cells .
for example , in @xcite , the linear programming method was used to obtain a generalized power diagram approximation of similar data ( but with far fewer grains and voxels ) resulting in a fit that correctly assigned @xmath160% of the voxels with non - convex cells .
figure [ fig : experimental : cell - characteristics](a ) shows a scatter plot of the volumes of the original grains against the volumes of the laguerre cells ( with the volumes expressed as radii of volume - equivalent spheres ) .
the overall fit of the cell volumes is excellent .
figure [ fig : experimental : cell - characteristics](b ) shows that the locations of the grains are also quite accurate .
note that the main issue with fitting seems to be small cells .
this is not such a problem , however , as small cells ( with equivalent radii of up to 10 voxels ) are subject to image segmentation error and are , thus , not too reliable in the original data .
in this paper , we considered the problem of approximating tomographic data by a laguerre tessellation .
we expressed this problem as an optimization problem : the generating points of the approximating tessellation need to be chosen in order to minimize the discrepancy between the tessellation and the tomographic data .
we considered an interface - based discrepancy measure , instead of the volume - based discrepancies more commonly considered in the literature .
this allowed us to use the ce method , a stochastic optimization method that is able to escape local minima , to fit the approximating tessellation .
we then carried out numerical experiments on both artificially generated and experimentally obtained tomographic data that demonstrated the broad effectiveness of our approach .
our method is robust and easy to implement .
thus it can be applied to fit laguerre tessellations to almost any material with a granular or cellular structure .
an obvious next step is to extend our approach to tessellations that include non - convex cells . in particular , we believe the approach and philosophy outlined in this paper can be extended to fit generalized power diagrams ( see @xcite ) generalizations of laguerre tessellations that can include non - convex cells
. this will be the subject of a forthcoming research paper .
this work was partially supported by the australian research council under grant dp140101956 and by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft under grant kr 1658/4 - 1 .
a software package including java code and data sets can be downloaded from https://github.com/stochastics-ulm-university/laguerre-approximation .
n. limodin , l. salvo , m. sury , and m. dimichiel . in situ investigation by x - ray tomography of the overall and local microstructural changes occurring during partial remelting of an al15.8wt.% cu alloy . , 55:31773191 , 2007 .
w. ludwig , a. king , p. reischig , m. herbig , e.m .
lauridsen , s. schmidt , h. proudhon , s. forest , p. cloetens , s. rolland du roscoat , j.y .
buffire , t.j .
marrow , and h.f .
poulsen . .
, 524(12):6976 , 2009 . c. lautensack , h. ewe , p. klein , and t. sych .
in j. hirsch , b. skrotski , and g. gottstein , editors , _ aluminium alloys their physical and mechanical properties _ , pages 13681374 , weinheim , 2008 .
wiley - vch .
d. westhoff , j. j. van franeker , t. brereton , d. p. kroese , r. a. j. janssen , and v. schmidt .
stochastic modeling and predictive simulations for the microstructure of organic semiconductor films processed with different spin coating velocities .
, 23(4):045003 , 2015 .
botev , d.p .
kroese , r.y .
rubinstein , and p. lecuyer .
the cross - entropy method for optimization . in v.
govindaraju and c.r .
rao , editors , _ machine learning : theory and applications _ , pages 3559 .
north - holland , oxford , 2013 . | the analysis of polycrystalline materials benefits greatly from accurate quantitative descriptions of their grain structures .
laguerre tessellations approximate such grain structures very well .
however , it is a quite challenging problem to fit a laguerre tessellation to tomographic data , as a high - dimensional optimization problem with many local minima must be solved . in this paper
, we formulate a version of this optimization problem that can be solved quickly using the cross - entropy method , a robust stochastic optimization technique that can avoid becoming trapped in local minima .
we demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach by applying it to both artificially generated and experimentally produced tomographic data .
image processing ; microstructural characterization ; grain boundary structure ; polycrystalline ; power diagram ; inverse problem ; cross - entropy method |
in our current understanding of pulsar magnetospheres and radiation mechanisms , strongly magnetized rotating neutron stars play a central role .
the underlying plasma processes like particle acceleration , pair creation and pulsed emission profiles throughout the whole electromagnetic spectrum strongly depend on the peculiar magnetic field geometry and strength adopted or extracted from numerical simulations of the magnetosphere .
for instance radio emission is believed to emanate from the polar caps , therefore in regions of strong gravity where curvature and frame - dragging effects are considerable due to the high compacity of neutron stars @xmath4 for typical models with its mass @xmath5 , its radius @xmath6 and the schwarzschild radius given by @xmath1 , @xmath7 being the gravitational constant and @xmath8 the speed of light .
detailed quantitative analysis of radio pulse polarization and pair cascade dynamics could greatly benefit from a better quantitative description of the electromagnetic field around the polar caps .
although there exists an extensive literature about flat space - time electrodynamics , only little work has been done to include general - relativistic effects .
the first general solution for an oblique rotator in flat vacuum space - time was found by @xcite with closed analytical formulas .
this solution is often quoted to explain the magnetic dipole radiation losses . to be truly exact , we emphasize that the poynting flux @xmath9 derived from his solution does not strictly coincide with the point dipole losses @xmath10 but depends on the ratio @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the light cylinder radius and @xmath3 the rotation rate of the neutron star .
it is only equal to the textbook equation for dipole losses in the limit of vanishing radius @xmath13 .
the distinction is meaningful at least for checking results emanating from numerical computations . indeed , because of limited computer resources , we are often forced to take ratios @xmath14 not completely negligible compared to unity .
therefore the computed spin - down luminosity can significantly deviate from the point dipole losses .
moreover , @xcite showed in the case of an aligned rotator that the electric field induced by frame - dragging effects could be as high as the one induced by the stellar rotation itself .
these results were extended to an oblique rotator a few years later by thanks to a formalism developed earlier by @xcite .
it is therefore crucial to treat maxwell equations in the general - relativistic framework in order to analyse quantitatively acceleration and radiation in the vicinity of the neutron star .
this led @xcite to seek for an approximate solution of maxwell equations in a curved space - time either described by the schwarzschild metric or by the kerr metric , using a linearised approach employing the newman - penrose formalism .
he computed the structure of the electromagnetic waves propagating in vacuum and launched by a rotating dipole .
he also gave an expression for the poynting flux @xmath15 depending on the ratio @xmath11 .
the exact analytical solution for the static magnetic dipole in schwarzschild space - time was given by @xcite and extended to multipoles by .
@xcite also studied the influence of space - time curvature and frame dragging effects on the electric field around the polar caps of a pulsar and confirmed the earlier claims of an increase in its strength . @xcite
computed the electric field for an aligned rotator in vacuum in the schwarzschild metric .
the aligned rotator has also been investigated by @xcite with special emphasize to particle acceleration in vacuum . @xcite and @xcite took a similar approach to study the acceleration of particles around polar caps . @xcite computed the electromagnetic field in the exterior of a slowly rotating neutron star in the slow rotation metric as well as inside the star and investigated the impact of oscillations .
they gave approximate analytical expressions for the external electromagnetic field close to the neutron star .
@xcite extended the previous work by solving numerically the equations for the oblique rotator in vacuum in general relativity .
they retrieve @xcite results close to the surface and the deutsch solution for distances larger than the light cylinder @xmath16 .
it is the purpose of this paper to elucidate quantitatively and accurately some aspects of general - relativistic effects on the electrodynamics close to the neutron star .
our goal is to derive a general formalism to compute the solution of maxwell equations in curved space - time for any multipole component of the magnetic field .
consequently , we use a 3 + 1 formalism of electrodynamics in curved space - time as presented in [ sec : modele ] .
next we show how to solve for the electromagnetic field for an aligned rotator in [ sec : aligne ] .
this method is easily extended to a perpendicular rotator as explained in [ sec : orthogonal ] .
because maxwell equations in vacuum are linear , the most general solution for an oblique rotator will be a linear superposition of the weighted aligned and perpendicular rotator .
conclusions and future possible work are drawn in [ sec : conclusion ] .
the covariant form to describe the gravitational and electromagnetic field in general relativity is the natural way to write them down in a frame independent way . nevertheless , it is more intuitive to split space - time into an absolute space and a universal time , similar to our all day three dimensional space , rather than to use the full four dimensional formalism .
another important advantage of a 3 + 1 split is a straightforward transcription of flat space techniques for scalar , vector and tensor fields to curved spaces .
we start with a description of the special foliation used for the metric .
next we derive maxwell equations in this foliation and conclude on some words about force - free electrodynamics which will be treated in another work but for completeness we give the useful expressions already in this paper .
we therefore split the four dimensional space - time into a 3 + 1 foliation such that the metric @xmath17 can be expressed as @xmath18 where @xmath19 , @xmath20 is the time coordinate or universal time and @xmath21 some associated space coordinates .
we use the landau - lifschitz convention for the metric signature given by @xmath22 @xcite .
@xmath23 is the lapse function , @xmath24 the shift vector and @xmath25 the spatial metric of absolute space . by convention
, latin letters from @xmath26 to @xmath27 are used for the components of vectors in absolute space ( in the range @xmath28 ) whereas latin letters starting from @xmath29 are used for four dimensional vectors and tensors ( in the range @xmath30 ) .
our derivation of the 3 + 1 equations follow the method outlined by @xcite . a fiducial observer ( fido )
is defined by its 4-velocity @xmath31 such that @xmath32 this vector is orthogonal to the hyper - surface of constant time coordinate @xmath33 .
its proper time @xmath34 is measured according to @xmath35 the relation between the determinants of the space - time metric @xmath36 and the pure spatial metric @xmath37 is given by @xmath38 for a slowly rotating neutron star , the lapse function is @xmath39 and the shift vector @xmath40 we use spherical coordinates @xmath41 and an orthonormal spatial basis @xmath42 .
the spin @xmath26 is related to the angular momentum @xmath43 by @xmath44 .
it follows that @xmath26 has units of a length and should satisfy @xmath45 . introducing the moment of inertia @xmath46 , we also have @xmath47 . for the remainder of the paper
, it is also convenient to introduce the relative rotation of the neutron star according to @xmath48 in the special case of a homogeneous and uniform neutron star interior with spherical symmetry , the moment of inertia is @xmath49 thus the spin parameter can be expressed as @xmath50 we adopt this simplification for the neutron star interior in order to compute the spin parameter @xmath26 .
let @xmath51 and @xmath52 be the electromagnetic tensor and its dual respectively , see appendix [ app : metric ] .
it is useful to introduce the following spatial vectors @xmath53 such that [ eq : bdeh ] @xmath54 @xmath55 is the vacuum permittivity and @xmath56 the vacuum permeability .
@xmath57 is the fully antisymmetric spatial tensor and @xmath58 the three dimensional levi - civita symbol .
the contravariant analog is @xmath59 .
relations eq .
( [ eq : bdeh ] ) can be inverted such that @xmath60 these three dimensional vectors can be recast into @xmath61 these expressions are also easily inverted such that @xmath62 all these antisymmetric tensors are summarized in appendix [ app : metric ] . with these definitions of the spatial vectors ,
maxwell equations take a more traditional form in the curved three dimensional space .
the system reads @xmath63 the source terms @xmath64 are given by @xmath65 @xmath66 being the 4-current density .
the above differential operators should be understood as defined in a three dimensional curved space , the absolute space with associated spatial metric @xmath25 , such that @xmath67 the special case of a diagonal spatial metric is given in appendix [ app : operateur ] .
the three dimensional vector fields are not independent , they are related by two important constitutive relations , namely [ eq : constitutive ] @xmath68 the curvature of absolute space is taken into account by the lapse function factor @xmath23 in the first term on the right - hand side and the frame dragging effect is included in the second term , the cross - product between the shift vector @xmath69 and the fields .
we see that @xmath70 are the fundamental fields , actually those measured by a fido , see below .
the source terms have not yet been specified .
having in mind to apply the above equations to the pulsar magnetosphere , we give the expressions for the current in the limit of a force - free plasma , neglecting inertia and pressure .
the force - free condition in covariant form reads @xmath71 and in the 3 + 1 formalism it becomes @xmath72 which implies @xmath73 and therefore also @xmath74 . as in the special relativistic case ,
the current density is found to be , see the derivation for instance in @xcite @xmath75 because @xmath76 and @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 can be interpreted as the magnetic and electric field respectively as measured by the fido .
moreover @xmath80 thus @xmath81 is the electric charge density as measured by this same observer . using the projection tensor defined by @xmath82 its electric current density @xmath83
is given by @xmath84 maxwell equations ( [ eq : maxwell1])-([eq : maxwell4 ] ) , the constitutive relations ( [ eq : constitutivee]),([eq : constitutiveh ] ) and the prescription for the source terms set the background system to be solved for any prescribed metric .
in the next section , we show how to solve this system in a simple way by introducing a vector spherical harmonic basis in curved space as summarized in appendix [ app : hsv ] . for the remainder of this paper , we will only focus on the vacuum field solutions , leaving the force - free case for future work .
note that we choose to keep all physical constants in the formulas because this helps to check easier the consistency with dimensionality of the equations .
the system to be solved being linear , we treat separately the aligned and the perpendicular case , the general oblique configuration being a weighted linear superposition of both solutions .
we first address the simple static and rotating aligned dipole magnetic field before investigating the interesting perpendicular rotator as a special case of an oblique rotator .
we start with a non rotating neutron star , setting the spin to zero , @xmath85 , therefore @xmath86 , followed by a simplification of the constitutive relations .
the electric field vanishes , thus @xmath87 whereas @xmath88 . as a consequence
, the magnetic field satisfies the static ( @xmath89 ) maxwell equations given by @xmath90 far from the neutron star , we expect to retrieve the flat space - time expression for the dipole magnetic field with magnetic moment @xmath91 or , written explicitly , @xmath92 = - \frac{\mu_0\,\mu}{4\,\pi } \ , \sqrt{\frac{8\,\pi}{3 } } \ , \mathrm{re } \left [ { \mathbf{\nabla } \times}\frac{\mathbf \phi_{1,0}}{r^2}\right]\ ] ] in curved space - time , the meaning of a dipole field needs to be explicitly defined .
we take as a definition for the dipolar magnetic field the one which is expressed only with the first vector spherical harmonic @xmath93 corresponding to the mode @xmath94 according to its flat space - time expression eq .
( [ eq : bdipoleplat ] ) .
this is valid for a symmetry around the @xmath95-axis because @xmath96 . the perpendicular case or more generally the oblique rotator would include the mode @xmath97 for the dipolar field .
this will be done in section [ sec : orthogonal ] .
thus we expand the magnetic field according to the divergencelessness prescription and look for a separable solution with the prescription @xmath98\ ] ] with the boundary condition @xmath99 @xmath93 is a vector spherical harmonic , see for instance @xcite .
the vector spherical harmonics being proper functions of the curl linear differential operator insure that such separable solutions do indeed exist .
these linear algebra properties are absolutely fundamental and make vector spherical harmonics extremely useful to solve linear partial differential equations involving vector fields .
note that @xmath100 is the unique unknown in this simple problem and depends only on the radial coordinate @xmath101 .
( [ eq : static1 ] ) is automatically satisfied by construction whereas inserting the expansion eq .
( [ eq : bstatic1 ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : static2 ] ) following the property eq .
( [ eq : rotrotphi ] ) of appendix [ app : hsv ] ( for @xmath102 ) leads to a second order linear ordinary differential equation for the scalar function @xmath103 such that @xmath104 the exact solution to this boundary problem which asymptotes to the flat dipole at large distances as prescribed by eq .
( [ eq : bstatic2 ] ) is given by @xmath105\ ] ] which corresponds to the solution shown in @xcite .
the non vanishing magnetic field components are [ eq : magneticstatic ] @xmath106 \ , \frac{\mu\,\cos\vartheta}{r_s^3 } \\
\label{eq : magneticstatict } b^{\hat \vartheta } & = 3 \ , \frac{\mu_0}{4\,\pi } \ , \left [ 2 \ , \sqrt { 1 - \frac{r_s}{r } } \ , { \rm ln } \left ( 1 - \frac{r_s}{r } \right ) + \frac{r_s}{r } \ , \frac{2\,r - r_s}{\sqrt{r\,(r - r_s ) } } \right ] \ , \frac{\mu\,\sin\vartheta}{r_s^3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] corrections to first order compared to flat space - time are @xmath107 \\ b^{\hat \vartheta } & = \frac{\mu_0}{4\,\pi } \ , \frac{\mu\,\sin\vartheta}{r^3 } \ , \left [ 1 + \frac{r_s}{r } + o\left ( \frac{r_s}{r } \right ) \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] this first example shows how easy it is to compute the solution once the expansion onto vector spherical harmonics has been performed and knowing their properties and action on linear differential operators .
next we consider the more useful case of a rotating magnetic dipole with magnetic moment aligned to the rotation axis .
now the situation becomes much more involved .
first , rotation induces an electric field and secondly frame dragging effects mix electric and magnetic fields through the constitutive relations eq .
( [ eq : constitutive ] ) . to demonstrate how our formalism works , we decided to split the task in two steps .
first we neglect frame dragging effects and look solely for the induced electric field . in a second stage , we add frame dragging .
frame dragging effects could become important and should be included . nevertheless , before dealing with the most general expression including frame dragging , we think it is educational to introduce the reasoning by hand and work out a low order expansion explicitly without any frame dragging effect .
this would be acceptable for sufficiently low rotation and we can in the first stage neglect the shift vector setting @xmath108 as in the previous paragraph .
maxwell equations then become @xmath109 these equations are particularly straightforward to solve because it represents a decoupled system of two unknown vector fields , one for @xmath110 and one for @xmath78 . from the flat space - time solution , we know that the electric field will be quadrupolar which means only one mode is present namely @xmath111 for the axisymmetric case .
thus we expand both fields according to @xmath112 \\
\label{eq : tournantb1 } \mathbf b & = \mathrm{re } \left [ { \mathbf{\nabla } \times } ( f_{1,0}^b \ , \mathbf \phi_{1,0 } ) \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] this expansion insure automatically and analytically the divergencelessness nature of both @xmath110 and @xmath78 .
moreover , these expressions lead as in the previous static regime to a separable solution for both the electric and magnetic field .
straightforward calculations show that @xmath103 again satisfies eq .
( [ eq : laplacef10 ] ) whereas @xmath113 has to be solution of another second order linear differential equation given by @xmath114 it is obtained by inserting the expansion eq .
( [ eq : tournantd2 ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : tournant2 ] ) following the property eq .
( [ eq : rotrotphi ] ) of appendix [ app : hsv ] but now for @xmath115 . the exact solution of this homogeneous linear differential equation and vanishing at infinity reads @xmath116\ ] ] where @xmath117 is a constant to be determined from the boundary conditions at the surface of the neutron star .
we now discuss this inner boundary condition in more details . inside a perfectly conducting star ,
the rotation of the plasma induces an electric field @xmath118 which satisfies @xmath119 this implies an electric field as measured by a fido given by @xmath120 for this fido , the electromagnetic field symbolized by @xmath70 has to verify the jump conditions across an interface as in flat space - time . in other words , the magnetic field component normal to the surface and
the electric field components lying in the plane of the interface are continuous functions .
more explicitly , the normal component @xmath121 and the tangential components @xmath122 have to be continuous across the stellar surface . by construction
, it can be verified by projection of eq .
( [ eq : tournantd2 ] ) onto @xmath123 that the component @xmath124 remains zero in the exterior vacuum space , as it is inside the star . note that this remark is consistent with the projection of eq .
( [ eq : cld ] ) onto @xmath123 . for the other tangential component , by projection of eq .
( [ eq : cld ] ) onto @xmath125 we have to enforce the condition @xmath126 this has to be compared with the projection of eq .
( [ eq : tournantd2 ] ) onto @xmath125 and given by @xmath127 in order to deduce the constant of integration @xmath117 in eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf20 ] ) , eq .
( [ eq : limitefd20 ] ) and ( [ eq : limited20 ] ) should be compared at the stellar surface setting @xmath128 .
@xmath121 is known from the static dipole solution and given by eq .
( [ eq : magneticstaticr ] ) . by direct calculation from eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf20 ] ) we arrive at @xmath129\ ] ] the constant @xmath117 then follows immediately from the above condition .
we get @xmath130 where @xmath131^{-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the magnetic field remains the same as for the static dipole and the electric field yields @xmath132 \ , ( 3\,\cos^2\vartheta - 1 ) \\
d^{\hat \vartheta } & = 6 \ , \frac{\varepsilon_0 \ , \mu_0 \ , \mu}{4\,\pi } \ , \frac{r}{r_s^3 } \
, \frac{\tilde{\omega}_r}{\alpha_r^2 } \ , \alpha \ , c_1 \ , c_2 \ ,
\left [ \left ( 1 - 2\,\frac{r}{r_s } \right ) \ , \ln\alpha^2 - 2 - \frac{r_s^2}{6\,r^2\,\alpha^2 } \right ] \ , \cos\vartheta \ ,
\sin\vartheta \\ d^{\hat \varphi } & = 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] so far , we did not include any frame dragging effect symbolized by the cross product in the constitutive relations eq .
( [ eq : constitutivee ] ) and ( [ eq : constitutiveh ] ) .
now we proceed to the inclusion of the frame dragging effect to look for more accurate solutions taking explicitly into account the rotation of the neutron star .
because these constitutive relations and the vacuum maxwell equations are linear , we use a power series expansion of the unknown vector fields with respect to a small adimensionalized parameter @xmath133 which is related to the neutron star spin such that @xmath134 .
any vector field @xmath135 is expanded into @xmath136 @xmath137 is the static field for the non rotating star .
thus , to zero - th order , the electric field vanishes , @xmath138 .
they are at least first order in @xmath3 .
the shift vector is a quantity of first order so we write it as @xmath139 . from the constitutive relations , we get the @xmath140-th order of the auxiliary electric field for @xmath141 as @xmath142 and for the @xmath140-th order of the auxiliary magnetic field @xmath143 moreover , for any order , we have the constraints @xmath144 as a consequence , we obtain a hierarchical set of partial differential equations for the fields @xmath145 such that @xmath146 for @xmath141 .
the initialisation for @xmath147 corresponds to the static dipole with @xmath148 given by eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf20 ] ) , therefore @xmath138 as expected .
we immediately conclude that the first perturbation in magnetic field corresponds to a second order term symbolized by @xmath149 ( @xmath150 ) .
we look for the first order perturbation in electric field corresponding to an electric quadrupole with @xmath111 such that @xmath151 from now on , we suppress the real part symbol , it should be understood that the physical fields correspond to the real parts of the expressions derived below . inserting this expansion into eq .
( [ eq : hierarchy1 ] ) with @xmath152 , the function @xmath113 is solution of the following second order inhomogeneous linear ordinary differential equation @xmath153\ ] ] the right hand side is obtained from the property eq .
( [ eq : rotbetarotvhs ] ) .
to solve this equation , we use standard techniques .
first we look for the general solution to the homogeneous equation which is nothing else than eq .
( [ eq : laplacef20 ] ) with the subsequent solution eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf20 ] ) , which we write here as @xmath154 . next a peculiar solution of the inhomogeneous eq .
( [ eq : laplacesourcef20 ] ) and vanishing at infinity is given by @xmath155\ ] ] in order to satisfy the boundary condition on the star , we also need the following expression @xmath156 in order to compute @xmath157 in eq .
( [ eq : limited20 ] ) from @xmath158 .
the constant @xmath117 will be determined from the inner boundary condition , now taking the frame dragging effect into account because of the presence of the peculiar solution @xmath159 , it has to be set to @xmath160\ ] ] putting all pieces together , the full solution @xmath158 reads @xmath161 \\ - 2 \ , \frac{\varepsilon_0 \
, \mu_0 \ , \mu}{4\,\pi } \ , \sqrt{\frac{6\,\pi}{5 } } \ , \frac{a\,c}{r_s^2\,r } \ , \left [ \ln\alpha^2 + \frac{r_s}{r } \right]\end{gathered}\ ] ] taking the value of the constant @xmath117 into account , we finally get @xmath162 - 2 \ , \frac{\omega\,r^3}{r_s^3 } \ , \left ( \ln\alpha^2 + \frac{r_s}{r } \right ) \right\}\end{gathered}\ ] ] if we separate the frame dragging effect @xmath163 from the pure rotation @xmath3 , we get @xmath164 - \right .
\\ \left .
2 \ , \frac{\omega\,r^4}{r_s^5 } \ , \left ( \frac{r_s^2}{r^2 } \ , \left ( \ln\alpha^2 + \frac{r_s}{r } \right ) + \frac{c_2\,r_s^2}{3\,\alpha_r^2\,r^2 } \ , \left ( \ln\alpha_r^2 + \frac{r_s}{r } \right ) \ , \times \right . \right . \\
\left.\left.\left [ \left ( 3 - 4\,\frac{r}{r_s } \right ) \
, \ln\alpha^2 + \frac{r_s^2}{6\,r^2 } + \frac{r_s}{r } - 4 \right ] \right ) \right\}\end{gathered}\ ] ] the components of the electric field are then @xmath165 with the radial derivative given explicitly by @xmath166 \right . \\ & \left .
- \frac{\omega\,r^3}{r_s^5 } \left ( \frac{6\,c_2\,r_s^2}{\alpha_r^2\,r^2 } \ , \left ( \ln\alpha_r^2 + \frac{r_s}{r } \right ) \ , \left [ \left ( 1 - 2 \ , \frac{r}{r_s } \right ) \ , { \rm ln } \alpha^2 - 2 - \frac{r_s^2}{6\,\alpha^2\,r^2 } \right ] + 3 \ , \frac{r_s^4}{\alpha^2\,r^4 } \right ) \right\ } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] these expressions are the same as equations ( 124)-(125)-(126 ) in @xcite specialized to the aligned rotator . in the newtonian limit we find @xmath167 as it should be .
the properties of the vector spherical harmonics in curved space allow us to derive in a systematic way the relations between the expansion coefficients of @xmath145 . because of the axisymmetry of the problem , there are no toroidal components of neither the magnetic nor the electric part .
therefore , all coefficients with @xmath168 vanish .
thus we expand both fields according to @xmath169 the superscript @xmath170 denotes the order of the expansion in the spin parameter , related to the frame dragging effect . injecting those expressions into eqs .
( [ eq : hierarchy1 ] ) and ( [ eq : hierarchy2 ] ) , we get for @xmath171 according to eq .
( [ eq : rotbetarotvhs ] ) in appendix [ app : hsv ] @xmath172\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath173\end{gathered}\ ] ] it is understood that @xmath174 .
the very important fact about this hierarchical system of second order linear partial differential equations relating the @xmath175 to the @xmath175 is its _ uncoupled _ nature . indeed
the coefficients @xmath175 and @xmath176 are related to the immediately lowest order expansion coefficients @xmath177 and @xmath178 . consequently , we can find the solution to any order by simply computing more coefficients .
the recurrence starts with the static aligned magnetic dipole which is the zero - th order approximation of the solution , with subscript @xmath179 .
as already noted in the previous paragraph , the electric field is a first order effect at least . for concreteness ,
let us work out the approximate solution to third order , i.e. including to vector spherical harmonic functions in the expansion of both the electric and the magnetic field . at first glance
, this seems a rather high degree of accuracy for such solution in contrast to the first order expansion of the background metric .
nevertheless , we have in mind to use such results as a benchmark to test forthcoming general relativistic electromagnetic solvers in free space and in the force - free approximation in order to extend the code presented in @xcite .
this justifies our wish to reach a high degree of accuracy for the numerical solutions even if the metric is only first order accurate in the spin parameter @xmath26 .
the electric field is a consequence of the rotation of the star , thus to zero - th order , there is only a magnetic field , i.e. @xmath180 and @xmath181 , the dipole in schwarzschild space - time given by eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf10 ] ) , all other @xmath182 with @xmath183 being equal to zero .
the initialisation with @xmath180 implies that there are no first order corrections to the magnetic field because eq .
( [ eq : fl0bk ] ) has a vanishing right hand side .
it is a linear homogeneous second order partial differential equation with zero boundary conditions on the star and at infinity . therefore the solution vanishes identically leading to @xmath184 .
the first correction comes from the coefficients @xmath185 which have to satisfy eq .
( [ eq : fl0dk ] ) .
there is only one inhomogeneous equation corresponding to @xmath115 with the right hand side including @xmath186 .
if written explicitly , we retrieve eq .
( [ eq : laplacesourcef20 ] ) namely @xmath187 with its subsequent solution .
the next order includes a perturbation in the magnetic field .
indeed , the coefficients @xmath188 have to satisfy eq .
( [ eq : fl0bk ] ) with source terms emanating only from @xmath189 , supplemented with vanishing boundary conditions .
the two equations are inhomogeneous , namely @xmath190 finally , this perturbed magnetic field will feed back to the electric field to third order with the non - vanishing coefficients satisfying @xmath191 \\ \label{eq : f40d3 } \partial_r(\alpha^2\,\partial_r(r\,f_{4,0}^{d(3 ) } ) ) - \frac{20}{r } \ , f_{4,0}^{d(3 ) } & = 4 \ , \sqrt{\frac{15}{7 } } \ , \varepsilon_0 \
, \omega \ , f_{3,0}^{b(2)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] but with boundary conditions at the stellar surface according to eq .
( [ eq : cld ] ) .
equations ( [ eq : f10b2])-([eq : f20d3 ] ) show the hierarchical set we are led to in order to improve the solution step by step by including an increasing number of multipoles of order @xmath192 in accordance with the degree of approximation desired in the spin parameter . some of these equations can be solved analytically with source terms , but we were unable to write down simple expressions for the solution with appropriate boundary conditions except for the very few first coefficients . finding closed expression is a cumbersome task .
eventually , we decided to solve the above set of equations numerically by spectral methods .
we expand the solutions into rational chebyshev functions as defined in @xcite .
see below for the details .
our starting point is to use a finite number of multipolar coefficients in the expansion of both the fields , @xmath193 terms for @xmath194 and @xmath195 terms for @xmath196 , writing [ eq : dbdvlptalign ] @xmath197 the order in the spin parameter , previously labelled as @xmath170 , has disappeared in the numerical solution , we do not perturb anymore according to @xmath26 .
each of the coefficient @xmath198 and @xmath199 has to satisfy the differential equation which is given for the magnetic field by @xmath200\end{gathered}\ ] ] and for the electric field by @xmath201\end{gathered}\ ] ] the boundary conditions at infinity enforce vanishing coefficients whereas on the neutron star surface , we have to impose continuity of the tangential @xmath110 and normal @xmath78 components on the stellar surface . introducing the expansions eq .
( [ eq : dbdvlptalign ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : cld ] ) , then projecting along @xmath125 and using the useful identities for frame - dragging presented in appendix [ sec : framedragging ] we get the relation between the coefficients of @xmath110 and @xmath78 as @xmath202 = \\
\varepsilon_0 \ , r \ , \tilde{\omega } \ ,
\left [ \sqrt{l\,(l+1 ) } \ , ( 1 - j_{l,0}^2 - j_{l+1,0}^2 ) \ , f_{l,0}^{b } - \right .
\\ \left .
\sqrt{(l-2)\,(l-1 ) } \ , j_{l,0 } \ , j_{l-1,0 } \ , f_{l-2,0}^{b } - \sqrt{(l+2)\,(l+3 ) } \ , j_{l+1,0 } \ , j_{l+2,0 } \ , f_{l+2,0}^{b}\right ] \end{gathered}\ ] ] where quantities have to be evaluated on the neutron star surface , at @xmath128 .
some recurrence formulas are very useful to deal with spherical harmonics .
the three recurrences used to impose the boundary conditions are @xmath203 with the constants given by @xmath204 let us write down explicitly the equations for the three first coefficients in @xmath196 and @xmath194 .
the system of partial differential equations reads @xmath205 \\
\partial_r(\alpha^2\,\partial_r(r\,f_{5,0}^{b } ) ) - \frac{30}{r } \ , f_{5,0}^{b } & = \frac{2}{\sqrt{11 } } \ , \frac{\omega}{\varepsilon_0 \ , c^2 } \ , \left [ - 5 \ , \sqrt{6 } \ , f_{4,0}^{d } + 9 \ , \sqrt{\frac{35}{13 } } \ , f_{6,0}^{d } \right ] \\ \label{eq : f20d } \partial_r(\alpha^2\,\partial_r(r\,f_{2,0}^{d } ) ) - \frac{6}{r } \ , f_{2,0}^{d } & = \frac{6}{\sqrt{5 } } \ , \varepsilon_0 \ , \omega \ , \left [ f_{1,0}^{b } - 3 \sqrt{\frac{2}{7 } } \ , f_{3,0}^{b } \right ] \\ \label{eq : f40d } \partial_r(\alpha^2\,\partial_r(r\,f_{4,0}^{d } ) ) - \frac{20}{r } \ , f_{4,0}^{d } & = 2 \ , \sqrt{3 } \ , \varepsilon_0 \ , \omega \ , \left [ 2 \ , \sqrt{\frac{5}{7 } } \ , f_{3,0}^{b } - 5 \ , \sqrt{\frac{2}{11 } } \ , f_{5,0}^{b } \right ] \\
\partial_r(\alpha^2\,\partial_r(r\,f_{6,0}^{d } ) ) - \frac{42}{r } \ , f_{6,0}^{d } & = 18 \ , \sqrt{\frac{35}{143 } } \ , \varepsilon_0 \ , \omega \ , f_{5,0}^{b } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the associated boundary conditions are [ eq : clfd ] @xmath206 \\
\alpha^2 \ , \left [ \frac{2}{3}\,\sqrt{\frac{5}{7 } } \ , \partial_r(r\,f_{4,0}^{d } ) - \sqrt{\frac{6}{35 } } \ , \partial_r(r\,f_{2,0}^{d } ) \right ] & = \varepsilon_0 \ , r \ , \tilde{\omega } \ , \left [ \frac{44}{15\,\sqrt{3 } } \ , f_{3,0}^{b } - \frac{2}{5 } \ , \sqrt{\frac{6}{7 } } \ , f_{1,0}^{b } - \frac{20}{3}\,\sqrt{\frac{10}{231 } } \ , f_{5,0}^{b } \right ] \\
\alpha^2 \ , \left [ \sqrt{\frac{42}{143 } } \ , \partial_r(r\,f_{6,0}^{d } ) - \frac{2}{3}\,\sqrt{\frac{5}{11 } } \ , \partial_r(r\,f_{4,0}^{d } ) \right ] & = \varepsilon_0 \ , r \ , \tilde{\omega } \ , \left [ \frac{58}{39 } \ , \sqrt{\frac{10}{3 } } \ , f_{5,0}^{b } - \frac{40}{3\,\sqrt{231 } } \ , f_{3,0}^{b } \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] again where quantities have to be evaluated on the neutron star surface , at @xmath128 .
we emphasize that the magnetic field at the neutron star surface is exactly matched to the expression for the general - relativistic static dipole , eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf10 ] ) .
all other multipole fields @xmath199 with @xmath207 vanish at @xmath128 by our definition .
the computation of the electromagnetic field in vacuum has been reduced to a system of linear ordinary differential equations of second order .
moreover , it is a boundary value problem to be solved in a semi - infinite interval , from @xmath128 to @xmath208 .
several different techniques exist to treat such a system .
we choose to employ spectral methods , expanding the unknown functions onto special basis functions .
according to @xcite , dealing with rational chebyshev functions @xmath209 is a judicious choice for the interval @xmath210 .
these functions are defined by @xmath211 where @xmath212 are the chebyshev polynomials of order @xmath140 and @xmath213 .
@xmath214 is a scaling parameter which should reproduce the characteristic length of the problem .
we choose @xmath215 .
any radial function @xmath216 is therefore expanded into a finite number of @xmath217 terms such that @xmath218 the inner and outer boundary conditions for the magnetic field coefficients @xmath219 are expressed as @xmath220 actually , all the @xmath221 vanish except for the dipole @xmath222 , recall that we strictly impose a dipolar magnetic field on the neutron star surface .
the outer boundary conditions for the electric field coefficients @xmath223 are the same as eq .
( [ eq : clf1 ] ) .
the inner boundary conditions are different because we enforce conditions on the derivative , see eq .
( [ eq : clfd ] ) , but it remains a relation involving linear terms in the expansion coefficients .
we use what @xcite calls the boundary - bordering method leading to a linear algebra system to be solved . for more details on spectral and pseudo - spectral methods ,
see for instance also @xcite .
technically , we use mathematica 9 to compute the matrix coefficients and invert the system to find the expansion coefficients . for the subsequent numerical applications , we normalize the magnetic moment of the neutron star to unity , @xmath224 .
in order to demonstrate the accuracy of our spectral algorithm to solve the system of linear ordinary differential equations , we begin with the static aligned dipole . the neutron star radius is set to @xmath225 although it is irrelevant for the static dipole case because there is no rotation and no scaling with @xmath226 .
the schwarzschild radius is chosen with increasing value compared to the stellar radius , we take @xmath227 .
the absolute value of the expansion coefficients of the function @xmath228 are shown in fig . [ fig : fb10_align ] with a number of collocations points @xmath229 . for any value of the compactness parameter @xmath230
, we get the prescribed 15 digits of accuracy , although that for compactness close to unity , we need more coefficients .
indeed , for very low compactness @xmath231 , red curve with full circles , less than ten coefficients are required to get full accuracy .
the same remark holds for any @xmath232 . for the typical compactness of a neutron star , @xmath233 , magenta curve with full triangles
, we need almost 25 coefficients to achieve the required accuracy .
nevertheless , the spectral convergence of our computation is clearly identified by the exponential decrease of the magnitude of the highest - order coefficients within an accuracy of 15 digits .
the other question to address is the efficiency of our spectral algorithm to reproduce the exact solution depending on the strength of deviation from the flat space - time metric . in order to check the correctness of these coefficients
, we have to compare them with the expansion coefficients of the analytical solution given by eq .
( [ eq : dipoleschwarzf10 ] ) . for the static aligned dipole .
@xmath140 corresponds to the order of the k - th rational chebyshev function and the numbers in the legend depict the ratio @xmath234.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] to do this , we define the absolute error between the analytical @xmath235 and the numerical @xmath236 solution by @xmath237 this error is plotted in fig .
[ fig : fb10_align_erreur ] and shows a perfect match between both solutions , within the numerical accuracy .
we reach 15 digits of significance for the relevant coefficients , those which are not zero numerically .
this explains the decreasing number of significant digits when the coefficients are close to zero .
they are meaningless .
for the static aligned dipole .
@xmath140 corresponds to the order of the k - th rational chebyshev function and the numbers in the legend depict the ratio @xmath234.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] this first example demonstrates the very high accuracy obtainable by our spectral method .
next , we pursue with the rotating aligned dipole . rotation combined with frame
dragging effects will produce higher order multipole coefficients which to first order depend linearly on the spin parameter @xmath26 .
we already gave an approximate analytical solution to the lowest order , i.e. the induced electric field without taking into account the perturbation in the magnetic field .
nevertheless with our numerical integration procedure , we are able to give solutions to any order in the multipole moments @xmath192 .
we therefore proceed in an increasing order of complexity . starting with only the two functions @xmath228 and @xmath238 to the lowest approximation , corresponding to the magnetic dipole and to the electric quadrupole
, we then successively add the couple @xmath239 and conclude with two more functions @xmath240 .
consequently , we can quantitatively estimate the contribution to the electromagnetic field from higher multipoles other than dipole and quadrupole .
we performed different sets of calculation by combining slow and fast rotation @xmath241 with low and high compactness @xmath242 with normalized magnetic moment @xmath224 .
we start with a very slowly rotating dipole for which @xmath243 and a low compactness @xmath244 in order to look for small perturbations of the electric field induced by frame dragging effects .
we can therefore compare the approximate analytical expressions with the more accurate numerical one .
the absolute value of the rational chebyshev coefficients of the lowest order approximation are shown in fig . [
fig : f_align_rot_1_r1000_rs2000 ] for @xmath228 and @xmath238 .
spectral convergence is achieved as expected .
the discrepancy between the analytical solution and the numerical computation are small , less than @xmath245 , the absolute error between both sets of coefficients is close to zero as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : erreur_align_rot_1_r1000_rs2000 ] . in red circles and @xmath238 in blue squares , for the aligned rotating dipole .
the parameters are @xmath244 and @xmath243.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in red circles and for the electric field @xmath246 in blue squares .
the parameters are @xmath244 and @xmath243.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in a second set of calculations , we increased the frame - dragging effects by taking @xmath247 and @xmath244 . the absolute value of the rational chebyshev coefficients of the lowest order approximation are shown in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_1_r10_rs2000 ] for @xmath228 and @xmath238 .
spectral convergence is achieved as expected . here
also the absolute discrepancy between both sets of coefficients is close to zero as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : erreur_align_rot_1_r10_rs2000 ] . in red circles and @xmath238 in blue squares , for the aligned rotating dipole .
the parameters are @xmath244 and @xmath247.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in red circles and for the electric field @xmath246 in blue squares .
the parameters are @xmath244 and @xmath247.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in a third set of calculations , we increased the compactness by taking @xmath243 and @xmath248 .
these values are typical for radio pulsars . the absolute value of the rational chebyshev coefficients of the lowest order approximation are shown in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_1_r1000_rs2 ] for @xmath228 and @xmath238 .
spectral convergence is achieved as expected . here
also the absolute discrepancy between both sets of coefficients is close to zero as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : erreur_align_rot_1_r1000_rs2 ] . in red circles and @xmath238 in blue squares , for the aligned rotating dipole .
the parameters are @xmath248 and @xmath243.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in red circles and for the electric field @xmath246 in blue squares .
the parameters are @xmath248 and @xmath243.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in a last set of calculations , we increased the rotation frequency by taking @xmath247 and @xmath248 .
these values are typical for millisecond pulsars . the absolute value of the rational chebyshev coefficients of the lowest order approximation are shown in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_1_r10_rs2 ] for @xmath228 and @xmath238 .
spectral convergence is achieved as expected .
the absolute discrepancy is shown in fig .
[ fig : erreur_align_rot_1_r10_rs2 ] in red circles and @xmath238 in blue squares , for the aligned rotating dipole .
the parameters are @xmath248 and @xmath247.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in red circles and for the electric field @xmath246 in blue squares .
the parameters are @xmath248 and @xmath247.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] next , we go on in this section about the aligned rotator by computing higher order multipoles @xmath249 to demonstrate that they are several orders of magnetic less than the magnetic dipolar and electric quadrupolar moment .
results are shown in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_2_r1000_rs2000 ] for two more multipoles with a slowly rotating non compact star .
the same for a rapidly rotating neutron star is shown in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_2_r10_rs2 ] . and @xmath250 for the aligned rotating dipole .
the parameters are @xmath244 and @xmath243.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] and @xmath250 for the aligned rotating dipole .
the parameters are @xmath248 and @xmath247.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] we conclude this section by computing even higher order multipoles @xmath251 to demonstrate that they are also several orders of magnetic less than the lower multipolar moments . for a total of 6 multipoles
, we get the coefficients represented in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_3_r1000_rs2000 ] for the slowly rotating non compact star and for a rapidly rotating neutron star in fig .
[ fig : f_align_rot_3_r10_rs2 ]
. and @xmath252 for the aligned rotating dipole.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] and @xmath252 for the aligned rotating dipole.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] the dipolar magnetic field as well as the electric quadrupolar field are not significantly affected by the higher multipolar fields .
indeed , we show the discrepancy in the expansion coefficients in fig . [
fig : erreur_multipole_r10_rs2 ] .
we first compare the dipole magnetic field quadrupole electric field expansion versus a dipole plus octupole @xmath253 expansion of the magnetic field and a quadrupole plus @xmath254 electric fields , denoted by @xmath255 and @xmath256 .
the same can be performed with a threefold expansion for both fields and denoted by @xmath257 and @xmath258 .
higher order multipoles can also be compared by inspection of @xmath259 and @xmath260 .
comparison with the lowest order expansion is not possible because this approximate solution does not contain neither @xmath261 nor @xmath262 .
we conclude from the plots in fig .
[ fig : erreur_multipole_r10_rs2 ] that the discrepancy in the expansion coefficients is not relevant .
in other words , adding higher multipoles will not significantly perturb the lower expansion coefficients . for an almost non rotating and non compact star ,
the discrepancies are shown in fig .
[ fig : erreur_multipole_r1000_rs2000 ] .
they are weaker than in the previous case . [ cols="^,^ " , ]
in this paper , we showed how to look for a systematic solution to the stationary maxwell equations in the background space - time of a slowly rotating neutron star following the 3 + 1 foliation and an expansion of the unknown electromagnetic field onto vector spherical harmonics .
we obtained numerical solutions of high accuracy for the aligned rotator and less accurate for the orthogonal rotator .
we hope that these results will serve as a benchmark for general - relativistic codes solving the electromagnetic field in a static background metric like for instance pulsar and black hole magnetospheres .
the orthogonal rotator could still benefit from some improvements by replacing the asymptotic spherical hankel functions by more precise functions which take into account at least to first order the perturbation in the metric induced by the presence of the mass @xmath5 .
this would lead to more rapid convergence of the solution but those analytical solutions do not exist .
a next step would be to solve the time dependent maxwell equations instead of looking for solutions to the boundary value problem , especially difficult to handle with high accuracy for an orthogonal rotator .
this could improve the estimate of the magnetic dipole losses in a curved space - time .
a further step to this work will be to include a force - free plasma surrounding the neutron star in order to compute the pulsar force - free magnetosphere in the general - relativistic case .
the same technique could be useful for the black hole magnetosphere .
however , because of the non linearity implied by the force - free current , it is impossible to solve the system semi - analytically as we did here .
computing the force - free magnetosphere requires numerical simulations .
this is the subject of a forthcoming paper in which we will describe a time dependent pseudo - spectral code using the vector spherical harmonics expansion to solve maxwell equations in a curved vacuum space - time .
i would like to thank ric gourgoulhon and serguei komissarov for helpful discussions .
j. l. , cohen j. m. , 1970 , ap&ss , 9 , 146 j. p. , 2001 , chebyshev and fourier spectral methods .
springer - verlag c. , hussaini m. y. , quarteroni a. , zang t. a. , 2006 , spectral methods j. m. , kearney m. w. , 1980 , ap&ss , 70 , 295 j. m. , kegeles l. s. , 1974a , physical review d , 10 , 1070 j. m. , kegeles l. s. , 1974b , physics letters a , 47 , 261 j. m. , kegeles l. s. , 1975 , physics letters a , 54 , 5 j. m. , toton e. t. , 1974 , annals of physics , 87 , 244 a. j. , 1955 , annales dastrophysique , 18 , 1 v. l. , ozernoy l. m. , 1964 , zh .
teor . fiz . , 47 , 1030 y. , matsunaga n. , okita t. , 2004 , mnras , 348 , 1388 s. s. , 2011 , mnras , 418 , l94 k. , kojima y. , 2000 , progress of theoretical physics , 104 , 1117 l. , lifchitz e. , 1989 , _ thorie des champs_. editions mir moscou a. , harding a. k. , 1997 , apj , 485 , 735 a. g. , tsygan a. i. , 1992 , mnras , 255 , 61 j. , 2012 , mnras , 424 , 605 j. a. , 1974 , physical review d , 10 , 3166 j. , 1976 , general relativity and gravitation , 7 , 459 l. , ahmedov b. j. , miller j. c. , 2001 , mnras , 322 , 723 l. , j. ahmedov b. , 2004 , mnras , 352 , 1161 n. , shibata s. , 2003 , apj , 584 , 427 s. , 1995 , apj , 449 , 224 o. , rezzolla l. , 2002 , mnras , 331 , 376
we give the explicit expressions for the metric and the electromagnetic field tensor using the landau - lifschitz signature @xmath22 @xcite .
the metric decomposed into time and space components reads then @xmath263 where @xmath23 is the lapse function , @xmath24 the shift vector and @xmath264 .
the spatial metric is simply given by @xmath265 and the inverse metric by @xmath266 the contravariant components of the electromagnetic field tensor expressed with the fields @xmath267 are @xmath268 and its dual expressed with the fields @xmath269 are @xmath270 the covariant components of the electromagnetic field tensor expressed with the fields @xmath269 are @xmath271 and for its dual with respect to @xmath267 are @xmath272
the metric of a slowly rotating neutron star remains very close to the usual flat space , except for the radial direction .
indeed the spatial metric is diagonal such that @xmath273 for any scalar field @xmath274 , the gradient and laplacian are respectively @xmath275 the physical components of a vector are depicted by hatted indexes .
the differential vector operators are then for the divergence and the curl @xmath276 \\
( { \mathbf{\nabla } \times}\mathbf b)^{\hat \vartheta } & = \frac{1}{r\,\sin\vartheta } \ , \partial_\varphi\,b^{\hat r } - \frac{\alpha}{r } \ , \partial_r(r\,b^{\hat \varphi } ) \\ ( { \mathbf{\nabla } \times}\mathbf b)^{\hat \varphi } & = \frac{\alpha}{r } \ , \partial_r(r\,b^{\hat \vartheta } ) - \frac{1}{r } \ , \partial_\vartheta\,b^{\hat r } \end{aligned}\ ] ]
these expressions are very similar to their flat space equivalent , except for the replacement of the radial derivative @xmath277 by @xmath278 in each term .
the transverse part of the spatial metric @xmath25 with @xmath279 is exactly the same as for the flat space .
because the flat space vector spherical harmonics ( vsh ) lie only in this transverse sub - space , it is straightforward to extend these vsh to the special metric eq .
( [ eq : metric3d ] ) as shown in the next paragraph .
we generalize the vector spherical harmonics ( vsh ) introduced in @xcite to a three - dimensional curved space .
the three sets of vector spherical harmonics we use are defined by the vector spherical harmonics share some useful properties with respect to their spatial derivatives .
first , assume a 3d scalar field @xmath283 expanded onto the scalar spherical harmonics such that @xmath284 then , its gradient expanded onto the vsh becomes @xmath285 the action of the same gradient on the vsh gives the divergence of any vector field @xmath281 as @xmath286 and for the curl @xmath287\end{gathered}\ ] ] for each component taken individually , we find for the divergence finally , define the radial differential operator @xmath290 by @xmath291 = \frac{\alpha}{r } \ , \frac{d}{dr } \left ( \alpha \ , \frac{d}{dr } ( r\,f ) \right ) - \frac{l(l+1)}{r^2 } \ , f = \frac{\alpha}{r^2 } \ , \frac{d}{dr } \left ( \alpha \ , r^2 \ , \frac{df}{dr }
\right ) - \frac{l(l+1)}{r^2 } \ , f\ ] ] the vsh noted @xmath292 are eigenvectors in the linear algebra meaning , of the vector laplacian operator @xmath293 .
indeed , it is straightforward to show that @xmath294 = \mathcal{d}_l[f ] \ , \mathbf{\phi}_{l , m}\ ] ] it is thus an extension of the properties of the scalar spherical harmonics to the realm of 3d vectors .
another useful relation is @xmath295 \ , \mathbf{\phi}_{l , m}\ ] ] where we introduced the operator @xmath296 \equiv \left [ \frac{1}{r } \ , \frac{\partial}{\partial r } \left ( \alpha^2\,\frac{\partial}{\partial r}(r\,f ) \right ) - \frac{l(l+1)}{r^2 } \ , f \right]\ ] ] finding the components of @xmath281 is therefore equivalent to finding the expansion coefficients of three scalar fields onto the scalar spherical harmonics .
this procedure works for any vector field .
however , the magnetic field being divergencelessness , only two of the three components are independent .
it is therefore judicious to deal properly with those kind of fields by analytically enforcing the condition on the divergence as explained below .
any divergencelessness vector field is efficiently developed onto the vector spherical harmonic _ orthonormal basis_. this will be the case for the magnetic field and the electric field in our algorithm .
assume that the vector field @xmath135 is divergencelessness .
it is helpful to introduce two scalar functions @xmath300 and @xmath301 such that the decomposition immediately implies the property of divergencelessness field .
this is achieved by writing @xmath302
+ g_{l , m}(r , t ) \ , \mathbf{\phi}_{l , m } \right)\ ] ] this expression automatically and _ analytically _ enforces the condition @xmath303 .
let us quickly draw the way to compute these functions .
the transformation from the spherical components to the functions @xmath304 is given by in our 3 + 1 formulation of maxwell equations in curved space , the frame dragging effects are included in the constitutive relations eq .
( [ eq : constitutivee ] ) , ( [ eq : constitutiveh ] ) , i.e. the cross product of two divergencelessness vector fields @xmath308 and @xmath194 or @xmath308 and @xmath196 . from the definition of the vsh and the shift vector we get @xmath309 and therefore for the curl @xmath310 the second useful set of identities involves @xmath311\ ] ] applying straightforward algebra using the vsh definitions and the scalar harmonics eigenfunction properties , we get @xmath312\end{gathered}\ ] ] we give explicit expressions for the first few modes @xmath313 for the aligned rotator @xmath96 | pulsars are thought to be highly magnetized rotating neutron stars accelerating charged particles along magnetic field lines in their magnetosphere and visible as pulsed emission from the radio wavelength up to high energy x - rays and gamma - rays .
being highly compact objects with compactness close to @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the schwarzschild radius and @xmath2 the mass and radius of the neutron star , general - relativistic effects become important close to their surface .
this is especially true for the polar caps where radio emission is supposed to emanate from , leading to well defined signatures such as linear and circular polarization . in this paper
, we derive a general formalism to extend to general relativity the deutsch field solution valid in vacuum space .
thanks to a vector spherical harmonic expansion of the electromagnetic field , we are able to express the solution to any order in the spin parameter @xmath3 of the compact object .
we hope this analysis to serve as a benchmark to test numerical codes used to compute black hole and neutron star magnetospheres .
[ firstpage ] stars : neutron - stars : magnetic fields - general relativity - methods : analytical - methods : numerical |
an @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath1 is a @xmath4-module determined by an integral matrix @xmath0 and a complex parameter vector @xmath5 .
these systems are also known as _ gkz - systems _ , as they were introduced in the late 1980 s by gelfand , graev , kapranov , and zelevinsky @xcite .
their solutions occur naturally in mathematics and physics , including the study of roots of polynomials , picard
fuchs equations for the variation of hodge structure of calabi - yau toric hypersurfaces , and generating functions for intersection numbers on moduli spaces of curves , see @xcite .
the ( holonomic ) rank of @xmath1 coincides with the dimension of its solution space at a nonsingular point . in this article
, we provide a combinatorial formula for the rank of @xmath1 in terms of certain lattice translates determined by @xmath0 and @xmath6 . for a fixed matrix @xmath0 ,
this computation yields a geometric stratification of the parameter space @xmath7 that refines its stratification by the rank of @xmath1 .
let @xmath8 $ ] be an integer @xmath9-matrix with integral column span @xmath10 .
assume further that @xmath0 is _ pointed _ , meaning that the origin is the only linear subspace of the cone @xmath11 .
a subset @xmath12 of the column set of @xmath0 is called a _ face _ of @xmath0 , denoted @xmath13 , if @xmath14 is a face of the cone @xmath15 .
let @xmath16 be variables and @xmath17 their associated partial differentiation operators .
in the polynomial ring @xmath18 $ ] , let @xmath19 denote the toric ideal associated to @xmath0 , and let @xmath20 be its quotient ring .
note that @xmath21 is isomorphic to the semigroup ring of @xmath0 , which is @xmath22 : = \bigoplus_{a\in { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}a } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\cdot t^a \end{aligned}\ ] ] with multiplication given by semigroup addition of exponents .
the weyl algebra @xmath23=\delta_{ij } , [ x_i , x_j]=0=[\del_i,\del_j]\>\ ] ] is the ring of @xmath24-linear differential operators on @xmath25 $ ] .
[ def - gkz ] the _ @xmath0-hypergeometric system _ with parameter @xmath26 is the left @xmath4-module @xmath27 where @xmath28 are _ euler operators _ associated to @xmath0 .
the _ rank _ of a left @xmath4-module @xmath29 is @xmath30}m.\ ] ] the rank of a holonomic @xmath4-module is finite and equal to the dimension of its solution space of germs of holomorphic functions at a generic nonsingular point @xcite .
in @xcite , gelfand , kapranov , and zelevinsky showed that when @xmath21 is cohen macaulay and standard @xmath31-graded , the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath1 is holonomic of rank @xmath32 for all parameters @xmath6 , where @xmath32 is @xmath33 times the euclidean volume of the convex hull of @xmath0 and the origin .
adolphson established further that @xmath1 is holonomic for all choices of @xmath0 and @xmath6 and that the holonomic rank of @xmath1 is generically given by @xmath32 @xcite .
however , an example found by sturmfels and takayama showed that equality need not hold in general @xcite ( see also @xcite ) .
at the same time , cattani , dandrea , and dickenstein produced an infinite family of such examples through a complete investigation of the rank of @xmath1 when @xmath2 defines a projective monomial curve @xcite .
the relationship between @xmath32 and the rank of @xmath1 was made precise by matusevich , miller , and walther , who used euler
koszul homology to study the holonomic
_ generalized @xmath0-hypergeometric system _ @xmath34 associated to a toric module @xmath29 ( see definition [ def : toric ] ) .
the euler koszul homology @xmath35 of @xmath29 with respect to @xmath6 is the homology of a twisted koszul complex on @xmath36 given by the sequence @xmath37 .
this includes the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath38 as the special case that @xmath39 . as in this special case , and for the purposes of this article , suppose that the generic rank of @xmath40 is @xmath32 .
the matrix @xmath0 induces a natural @xmath41-grading on @xmath42 ; the _ quasidegree set _ of a finitely generated @xmath41-graded @xmath42-module @xmath43 is defined to be the zariski closure in @xmath7 of the set of vectors @xmath44 for which the graded piece @xmath45 is nonzero . in @xcite , an explicit description of the _ exceptional arrangement _
@xmath46 associated to @xmath29 is given in terms of the quasidegrees of certain @xmath47 modules involving @xmath29 ( see ) .
this description shows that @xmath48 is a subspace arrangement in @xmath7 given by translates of linear subspaces that are generated by the faces of the cone @xmath15 , and that @xmath48 is empty exactly when @xmath49 is a maximal cohen
macaulay @xmath21-module .
it is also shown in @xcite that the rank of @xmath35 is upper semi - continuous as a function of @xmath6 .
thus the exceptional arrangement @xmath48 is the nested union over @xmath50 of the zariski closed sets @xmath51 in particular , the rank of @xmath34 induces a stratification of @xmath48 , which we call its _
rank stratification_. the present article is a study of the rank stratification of @xmath48 when @xmath52 $ ] is @xmath41-graded such that the degree set @xmath53 of @xmath29 is a nontrivial @xmath54monoid . in particular , @xmath29 is weakly toric ( see definition [ def - wtoric ] ) .
if @xmath55 , then @xmath29 is the semigroup ring @xmath21 from and @xmath56 is the @xmath0-hypergeometric system at @xmath6 .
the module @xmath29 could also be a localization of @xmath21 along a subset of faces of @xmath0 . as @xmath29 will be fixed throughout this article
, we will often not indicate dependence on @xmath29 in the notation .
examination of the long exact sequence in euler koszul homology induced by the short exact sequence of weakly toric modules @xmath57 \rightarrow q \rightarrow 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] reveals that the _ rank jump _ of @xmath29 at @xmath6 , @xmath58 we define the _ ranking arrangement _ @xmath59 of @xmath29 to be the quasidegrees of @xmath60 .
vanishing properties of euler
koszul homology imply that the exceptional arrangement @xmath48 is contained in the ranking arrangement @xmath59 .
we show in theorem [ thm - str comparison ] that @xmath59 is the union of @xmath48 and an explicit collection of hyperplanes . for a fixed @xmath61 , we then proceed to compute @xmath62 . in section [ sec : r - t mods ] , we combinatorially construct a _ finitely generated _
@xmath41-graded _ ranking toric module _
@xmath63 with @xmath64 . since @xmath62 is determined by the euler
koszul homology of @xmath60 by , we see that @xmath63 contains the information essential to computing the rank jump @xmath62 . to outline the construction of the module @xmath63 ,
let @xmath65 be the polyhedral complex of faces of @xmath0 determined by the components of the ranking arrangement @xmath59 that contain @xmath6 .
we call the collection of integral points @xmath66 the _ ranking lattices _ @xmath67 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 .
this set is a union of translates of lattices generated by faces of @xmath0 , where the vectors in these lattice translates of @xmath68 in @xmath67 are precisely the degrees of @xmath60 which cause @xmath69 to lie in the ranking arrangement .
since it contains full lattice translates , @xmath67 can not be the degree set of a finitely generated @xmath21-module .
thus , to complete the construction of the degree set @xmath70 of @xmath63 , we intersect @xmath67 with an appropriate half space ( see definition [ def - cp ] ) . to give a flavor of our approach for @xmath71 , this is equivalent to intersecting @xmath72 with @xmath73 $ ] . by setting up the proper module structure , @xmath74 gives the @xmath41-graded degree set of the desired toric module @xmath63 with @xmath75 .
after translating the computation of the rank jump @xmath62 to @xmath63 , we obtain a generalization of the formula given by okuyama in the case @xmath76 @xcite .
[ thm - compute jump ] the rank jump @xmath62 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 can be computed from the combinatorics of the ranking lattices @xmath67 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 . in particular , the rank of the hypergeometric system is the same at parameters which share the same ranking lattices .
the proof of theorem [ thm - compute jump ] can be found in section [ subsec : rank jumps ] as a special case of our main result , theorem [ thm - main ] .
let @xmath77 and @xmath78 be subspace arrangements in @xmath7 .
we say that a stratification @xmath79 of @xmath77 _ respects _ @xmath78 if for each irreducible component @xmath80 of @xmath78 and each stratum @xmath81 , either @xmath82 or @xmath83 .
a _ ranking slab _ of @xmath29 is a stratum in the coarsest stratification of @xmath48 that respects the arrangements @xmath59 and the negatives of the quasidegrees of each of the @xmath47 modules that determine @xmath48 ( see definition [ def - ranking slab ] ) .
proposition [ prop - zc e ] states that the parameters @xmath84 belong to the same ranking slab of @xmath29 exactly when their ranking lattices coincide , that is , @xmath85 . combining this with theorem [ thm - compute jump ]
, we see that the rank of @xmath40 is constant on each ranking slab .
[ cor - strat vs equiv ] the function @xmath86 is constant on each ranking slab .
in particular , the stratification of the exceptional arrangement @xmath48 by ranking slabs refines its rank stratification .
hence , like @xmath48 , each set @xmath87 is a union of translated linear subspaces of @xmath7 which are generated by faces of @xmath15 . in order for the ranking slab stratification of @xmath48 to refine its rank stratification
, it must respect each of the arrangements appearing in its definition ; this can be seen from examples [ example - hidden ] , [ example - nonconstant slab ] , and [ plane - line-4diml ] . in particular , as @xmath88 , the exceptional arrangement @xmath48 does not generally contain enough information to determine its rank stratification .
when @xmath39 , the ranking lattices @xmath67 are directly related to the combinatorial sets @xmath89 defined by saito , which determine the isomorphism classes of @xmath1 . in @xcite , various @xmath90-functions arising from an analysis of the symmetry algebra of @xmath0-hypergeometric systems are used to link these isomorphism classes to the sets @xmath89 .
we conclude this paper with a shorter proof , replacing the use of @xmath90-functions with euler koszul homology .
the following is a brief outline of this article . in section [ sec : defns ] , we summarize definitions and results on weakly toric modules and euler koszul homology , following @xcite .
section [ sec : ekstr ] is a study of the structure of the euler
koszul complex of maximal cohen
macaulay toric face modules .
the relationship between the exceptional and ranking arrangements of @xmath29 is made precise in section [ sec : exceptional arrangement ] . in section [ sec : r - t mods ] , we define the class of ranking toric modules , which play a pivotal role in calculating the rank jump @xmath62 . section [ sec : comb of rank ] contains our main theorem , theorem [ thm - main ] , which results in the computation of @xmath62 for a fixed parameter @xmath6 .
we close with a discussion on the isomorphism classes of @xmath0-hypergeometric systems in section [ sec : isom classes ] .
i am grateful to my advisor uli walther for many inspiring conversations and thoughtful suggestions throughout the duration of this work .
i would also like to thank laura felicia matusevich for asking the question is rank constant on a slab ? " as well as helpful remarks on this text and conversations that led directly to the proof of theorem [ thm - isom classes ] .
finally , my thanks to ezra miller for many valuable comments for improving this paper , including the addition of definition [ def - cellular definition ] , and to the referee for detailed notes that clarified this article .
in this section , we summarize definitions found in the literature and set notation .
most important are the definitions of a weakly toric module @xcite and euler koszul homology @xcite .
let @xmath91 denote the columns of @xmath0 .
for a face @xmath13 , let @xmath92 denote the complement of a face @xmath12 in the column set of @xmath0 .
if @xmath12 is any subset of the columns of @xmath0 , the _ codimension _ of @xmath12 is @xmath93 , the codimension of the @xmath94-vector space generated by @xmath12 .
the _ dimension _ of @xmath12 is @xmath95 .
a face @xmath12 of @xmath0 is a _ facet _ of @xmath0 if @xmath96 .
recall that the _ primitive integral support function _ of a facet @xmath13 is the unique linear functional @xmath97 such that @xmath98 @xmath99 for all @xmath100 , and @xmath101 exactly when @xmath102 .
the _ volume _ of a face @xmath12 , denoted @xmath103 , is the integer @xmath104 times the euclidean volume in @xmath105 of the convex hull of @xmath12 and the origin .
[ def : semigroup ring d ] let @xmath106 be the semigroup generated by the face @xmath12 and , as in , @xmath107\ ] ] is the corresponding semigroup ring , called a _ face ring _ of @xmath0 .
let @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
define @xmath110\ ] ] to be the polynomial ring in @xmath111 and @xmath112 = \delta_{ij},[x_i , x_j ] = 0 = [ \del_i,\del_j]\>\ ] ] to be the _ weyl algebra _ associated to @xmath12 .
note that @xmath113 [ def : monoid ] let @xmath114 be variables . for a face @xmath13 , we say that a subset @xmath115 is an _ @xmath116module _ if @xmath117 .
further , we call an @xmath116module @xmath118 an _ @xmath116monoid _ if it is closed under addition , that is , for all @xmath119 , @xmath120 . given an @xmath116module @xmath118 ,
define the @xmath121-module @xmath122 as a @xmath24-vector space with @xmath121-action given by @xmath123 .
further , @xmath124 is equipped with a multiplicative structure given by @xmath125 for @xmath119 and extended @xmath24-linearly . by definition
, @xmath116 is an @xmath116monoid and @xmath126 as rings .
define a @xmath41-grading on @xmath127 by setting @xmath128 then @xmath124 is naturally a @xmath41-graded @xmath121-module by setting @xmath129 .
the _ saturation _ of @xmath12 in @xmath68 is the semigroup @xmath130 .
the _ saturation _ , or _ normalization _ , of @xmath121 is the semigroup ring of the saturation of @xmath12 in @xmath68 , which is given by @xmath131 as a @xmath41-graded @xmath121-module .
note that @xmath132 is a cohen
macaulay @xmath121-module @xcite .
if @xmath43 is a @xmath41-graded @xmath42-module and @xmath133 , the _ degree set _ of @xmath43 , denoted @xmath134 , is the set of all @xmath133 such that @xmath135 .
let @xmath136 denote the @xmath41-graded module with @xmath137-graded piece @xmath138 .
we now recall the definitions of toric and weakly toric modules and their quasidegree sets , which can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* definition 4.5 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) , respectively .
[ def : toric ] a @xmath41-graded @xmath42-module is _ toric _ if it has a filtration @xmath139 such that for each @xmath140 , @xmath141 is a @xmath41-graded translate of @xmath142 for some face @xmath143 .
notice that toric modules are necessarily finitely generated @xmath42-modules .
[ def - qdeg ] if @xmath43 is a finitely generated @xmath41-graded @xmath42-module , a vector @xmath144 is a _ quasidegree _ of @xmath43 , written @xmath145 , if @xmath146 lies in the zariski closure of @xmath134 under the natural embedding @xmath147 .
notice that if @xmath43 is toric , then @xmath148 is a finite subspace arrangement in @xmath7 , consisting of translated subspaces generated by faces of @xmath0 , see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2.5 ) . a partially ordered set @xmath149 is _ filtered _ if for each @xmath150 there exists @xmath151 with @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
[ def - wtoric ] we say that a @xmath41-graded @xmath42-module @xmath29 is _ weakly toric _ if there is a filtered partially ordered set @xmath149 and a @xmath41-graded direct limit @xmath154 where @xmath155 is a toric @xmath42-module for each @xmath151 .
we then define the _ quasidegree set _ of @xmath29 to be @xmath156 where each @xmath157 is defined by definition [ def - qdeg ] .
[ ex - m wt ] if @xmath158 is an @xmath54module , then @xmath159 is weakly toric because it is a direct limit over @xmath160 of @xmath161 under the natural @xmath0-homogeneous inclusion @xmath162\cong { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}^d]$ ] . consider the matrix @xmath163 $ ] with face @xmath164 $ ] .
the module @xmath165 $ ] is weakly toric with quasidegree set @xmath166\right ) = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f\ ] ] because it is a filtered direct limit over @xmath167 of @xmath168 .
similarly , the module @xmath169 $ ] is weakly toric with @xmath170\right ) = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}^2 $ ] .
the quotient @xmath169/s_a$ ] is also weakly toric .
its quasidegree set consists of the point @xmath171 $ ] and the union of lines in @xmath172 , where @xmath173 are the coordinates of @xmath174 .
we now recall the definition of the euler
koszul complex of a weakly toric module @xmath29 with respect to a parameter @xmath26 . for @xmath175 , each _ euler operator _
@xmath176 determines a @xmath41-graded @xmath4-linear endomorphism of @xmath36 , defined on a homogeneous @xmath177 by @xmath178 and extended @xmath24-linearly .
this sequence @xmath179 of commuting endomorphisms determines a koszul complex @xmath180 on the left @xmath4-module @xmath36 , called the _
euler koszul complex _ of @xmath29 with parameter @xmath6 .
@xmath181 euler
koszul homology module _ of @xmath29 is @xmath182 .
our object of study will be the _
generalized @xmath0-hypergeometric system _ @xmath34 associated to @xmath29 .
the euler
koszul complex defines an exact functor from the category of weakly toric modules with degree - preserving morphisms to the category of bounded complexes of @xmath41-graded left @xmath4-modules with degree - preserving morphisms , so short exact sequences of weakly toric modules yield long exact sequences of euler koszul homology .
notice also that euler
koszul homology behaves well under @xmath41-graded translations : for @xmath183 , @xmath184 we close this section by recording two important vanishing results for euler koszul homology .
[ prop - hh qis 0 ] for a weakly toric module @xmath29 , the following are equivalent : 1 .
@xmath185 for all @xmath186 , 2 .
@xmath187 , 3 .
@xmath188 see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 5.4 ) .
[ thm - cm hh rel ] let @xmath29 be a weakly toric module .
then @xmath185 for all @xmath189 and for all @xmath26 if and only if @xmath29 is a maximal cohen
macaulay @xmath21-module .
see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6.6 ) for the toric case .
the extension to the weakly toric case can be found in @xcite .
theorem [ thm - cm hh rel ] provides a criterion for higher vanishing of euler
koszul homology via maximal cohen macaulay @xmath21-modules . in this section ,
we provide a description of the euler koszul homology modules of maximal cohen macaulay @xmath121-modules for a face @xmath13 and
use it to understand the images of maps between such modules . throughout this section ,
@xmath43 is a toric @xmath121-module for a face @xmath13 .
recall the definitions of toric , @xmath121 , @xmath190 , and @xmath191 from definition [ def : semigroup ring d ] , and let @xmath192 [ not - hhf ] let @xmath193 be the lexicographically first subset of @xmath194 of cardinality @xmath195 such that @xmath196 is a set of linearly independent euler operators on @xmath197 .
the existence of @xmath193 follows from the fact that the matrix @xmath0 has full rank .
we use @xmath198 to denote the euler
koszul complex on @xmath199 given by the operators @xmath200 , and set @xmath201 using the standard basis of @xmath10 , let @xmath202 and let @xmath203 denote a complex with trivial differentials .
we show now that when @xmath204 , @xmath205 is quasi - isomorphic to a complex involving @xmath198 and @xmath203 .
[ prop - str cm ek complex ] let @xmath13 and @xmath43 be a toric @xmath121-module .
if @xmath206 , then there is a quasi - isomorphism of complexes @xmath207 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_\bullet^f(n,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , if @xmath43 is maximal cohen macaulay as an @xmath121-module , there is a decomposition @xmath208 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh_0^f(n,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] under the hypotheses of proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] , @xmath209 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh_0^f(n,\beta^f)^{\binom{\codim(f)}{i}},\ ] ] for @xmath189 , as shown in @xcite . in particular , @xmath210 we show in proposition [ prop - str / rk image ] that surjections of maximal cohen
macaulay toric modules for nested faces yield induced maps on euler koszul homology that respect the decompositions of .
the additional information stored in @xmath203 of shows how images of collections of such surjections overlap , which will be vital to our calculation of @xmath62 in section [ sec : comb of rank ] .
[ pf - gf ] fix a matrix @xmath211 such that the entries of each row of @xmath212 not corresponding to @xmath193 are zero and the rows of @xmath0 that do correspond to @xmath193 are identical in @xmath0 and @xmath213 . setting @xmath214 , @xmath21 and @xmath215
are isomorphic rings , and the matrix @xmath216 gives a bijection of their degree sets , sending @xmath54 to @xmath217 .
this identification makes @xmath43 a @xmath218-graded @xmath219-module , where @xmath220 , and there is a quasi - isomorphism of complexes @xmath221 let @xmath222 and @xmath223 , and recall that @xmath224 . by the definition of @xmath216 , @xmath225 for @xmath226 because @xmath227 .
let @xmath228 and @xmath229 denote the weyl algebra and the polynomial ring @xmath230 $ ] with an @xmath231-grading . since @xmath43 is an @xmath219-module , @xmath232 , and so there is an isomorphism @xmath233 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}d_{f ' } \otimes_{r_{f ' } } n$ ] .
hence the action of each element in @xmath234 on @xmath235 is 0 . if @xmath236 denotes the standard basis of @xmath237 , then the set @xmath238 generates @xmath239 by choice of @xmath216 . applying the isomorphism @xmath240 in the reverse direction , we obtain
finally , if @xmath43 is maximal cohen macaulay as an @xmath121-module , @xmath241 for all @xmath189 by theorem [ thm - cm hh rel ] .
[ remark - diffl in cm ek complex ] let @xmath242 and @xmath243 respectively denote the differentials of the euler koszul complexes @xmath244 and @xmath198 . under the hypotheses of proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] , if @xmath245 and @xmath246 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk^f_i(n,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^j{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot\right)$ ]
, then @xmath247 is an element of @xmath248 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk^f_{i-1}(n,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^j{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot\right ) \subseteq \kk^{a'}_{q-1}(n,\beta).$ ] [ example - ek cm comp ] consider the matrix @xmath249.\ ] ] set @xmath250 \in{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}^3 $ ] , and let @xmath251 denote the standard basis vectors in @xmath252 .
notice that every face ring of @xmath0 is cohen macaulay because the semigroup generated by each face of @xmath0 is saturated . for the face @xmath253
, we choose @xmath254 to be the identity matrix .
the proof of proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] shows that there is an isomorphism of complexes @xmath255\cdot e_i \ar[r]^{0\cdot } & { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]}\right),$ ] so the euler
koszul homology of @xmath256 at @xmath6 is @xmath257 \cdot e_i\right).\ ] ] for the face @xmath258 $ ] of @xmath0 , @xmath259 is again already in the desired form , so take @xmath216 to be the identity matrix and write @xmath25\<\del_1,\del_2\>$ ] in place of @xmath260 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}d_f \otimes_{r_f } s_f$ ]
. then proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] implies that @xmath261\<\del_1,\del_2\ > & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1,\del_2\>\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise . } \end{cases } \intertext{for $ g_1=[a_1]$ and $ g_{g_1}$ as the identity matrix , } \hh_q(s_{g_1},\beta ) & = \begin{cases } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1\ > & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1\>\cdot e_2 \oplus { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1\>\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1\>\cdot e_2\wedge e_3 & \text{if $ q=2$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise . } \end{cases } \intertext{for the face $ g_2 = [ a_2]$ , setting $ g_{g_2 } = \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1&\phantom{-}0&0\\ 1&-1&0\\ 0&\phantom{-}0&1 \end{smallmatrix}\right]$ yields the decomposition } \hh_q(s_{g_2},\beta ) & = \begin{cases } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_2\ > & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_2\>\cdot ( e_1-e_2 ) \oplus { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1\>\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_2\>\cdot ( e_1-e_2)\wedge e_3 & \text{if $ q=2$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise .
} \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ lemma - ek morph ] let @xmath262 be faces of @xmath0 , @xmath43 be a toric @xmath121-module , and @xmath263 be a toric @xmath264-module .
regard @xmath43 and @xmath263 as toric @xmath21-modules via the natural maps @xmath265 .
let @xmath266 be a morphism of @xmath21-modules .
then there is a commutative diagram @xmath267^{\kk_\bullet(\pi,\beta ) } \ar[d ] & \kk_\bullet(l,\beta ) \ar[d ] \\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{f^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk^{f}_\bullet(n,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot \right ) \ar[r ] & { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{g^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk^{g}_\bullet(l,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}g^\bot \right ) } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with vertical maps as in . by choice of @xmath193 and @xmath268 in notation
[ not - hhf ] and the corresponding @xmath216 and @xmath269 , the diagram @xmath270^{\kk_\bullet(\pi,\beta ) } \ar[d ] & & \kk_\bullet(l,\beta ) \ar[d ] \\
\kk^{g_f a}_\bullet(n,\beta ) \ar[r ] & \kk^{g_f a}_\bullet(l,\beta ) \ar[r ] & \kk^{g_g a}_\bullet(l,\beta ) } \ ] ] commutes .
hence the result follows from the proof of proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] .
[ prop - str / rk image ] let @xmath262 be faces of @xmath0 , @xmath43 be a maximal cohen macaulay toric @xmath121-module , and @xmath263 be a maximal cohen
macaulay toric @xmath264-module .
regard @xmath43 and @xmath263 as toric @xmath21-modules via the natural maps @xmath265 .
let @xmath271 be a surjection of @xmath21-modules .
if @xmath272 , then @xmath273 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh_0^g(l,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot\right)\ ] ] as a submodule of @xmath274 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh_0^g(l,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}g^\bot\right)$ ] .
( continuation of example [ example - ek cm comp ] ) [ example - ek cm comp i m ] the surjection of face rings given by @xmath275 induces the following image in euler
koszul homology : @xmath276\<\del_1\ > & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\<\del_1\>\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise . } \end{cases}\ ] ] with @xmath224 , the image of @xmath277 is isomorphic to the image of @xmath278 . by proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] ,
there are decompositions @xmath279 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh^f_0(n,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot \right ) \intertext{and } \hh^{a'}_\bullet(l,\beta ) & = { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{f^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh^f_\bullet(l,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] so it is enough to find the image of @xmath280 as a submodule of @xmath281 .
the result now follows because the sequence @xmath282^{\hh_0^f(\pi,\beta ) } & & \hh_0^f(l,\beta ) \ar[r ] & 0}\ ] ] is exact , @xmath283 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh^g_0(l,\beta)$ ] , and @xmath284 for @xmath189 .
( continuation of example [ example - ek cm comp i m ] ) [ example - ek cm comp i m intersect ] let @xmath285 for @xmath286 .
then @xmath287 & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot e_2 \oplus { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot e_2\wedge e_3 & \text{if $ q=2$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise , } \end{cases } \intertext{and } \image
\hh_q(\pi_2,\beta ) & = \begin{cases } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x ] & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot ( e_2-e_1 ) \oplus { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot ( e_2-e_1 ) \wedge e_3 & \text{if $ q=2$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise . } \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the intersection of the images of euler
koszul homology at @xmath6 applied to @xmath288 and @xmath289 is @xmath290\cap[\image \hh_q(\pi_2,\beta ) ] = \begin{cases } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x ] & \text{if $ q=0$,}\\ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x]\cdot e_3 & \text{if $ q=1$,}\\ 0 & \text{otherwise } \end{cases}\ ] ] because @xmath291 .
we close this section with an observation that is vital to our rank jumps computations . for faces
@xmath292 , set @xmath293 .
let @xmath294 be maximal cohen macaulay toric @xmath142-modules , @xmath263 be a maximal cohen
macaulay toric @xmath264-module , and @xmath295 be @xmath21-module surjections .
suppose that @xmath272 .
using the equality @xmath296^\bot$ ] , proposition [ prop - str / rk image ] implies that @xmath297 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh_0^g(l,\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^i { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}[f\cup g]^\bot\right ) , \end{array}\ ] ] which has rank @xmath298
let @xmath299 be a nonempty @xmath54monoid ( see definition [ def : monoid ] ) , so that the nontrivial module @xmath300 $ ] is weakly toric ( see example [ ex - m wt ] ) and @xmath301 since @xmath302 is an @xmath54-monoid , the generic rank of @xmath40 is @xmath32 .
rank jump _ of @xmath29 at @xmath6 is the nonnegative integer @xmath303 of parameters with nonzero rank jump .
by @xcite and @xcite , the exceptional arrangement can be described in terms of certain @xmath47 modules involving @xmath29 , namely @xmath304 where @xmath305 .
it follows that @xmath48 is a union of translates of linear subspaces spanned by the faces of @xmath0 , see ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 9.3 ) .
we begin our study of @xmath62 with the short exact sequence @xmath306 \rightarrow q \rightarrow 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] while @xmath60 is not a noetherian @xmath21-module , it is a filtered limit of noetherian @xmath41-graded @xmath21-modules and is therefore weakly toric ( see definition [ def - wtoric ] ) . thus the _ ranking arrangement _ of @xmath29 @xmath307 is an infinite union of translates of linear subspaces of @xmath7 spanned by proper faces of @xmath0 . since @xmath308 $ ] is a maximal cohen
macaulay @xmath21-module , theorem [ thm - cm hh rel ] implies that @xmath309,\beta)=0 $ ] for all @xmath189 .
moreover , by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.2 ) , @xmath310,\beta)=\vol(a)$ ] for all @xmath6 .
examination of the long exact sequence in euler koszul homology from reveals that @xmath311 this implies that for @xmath61 , @xmath312 is nonzero .
therefore there is an inclusion @xmath313 .
we make this relationship precise in theorem [ thm - str comparison ] .
[ lemma - finite inside ] let @xmath133 .
the number of irreducible components of @xmath314 which intersect @xmath315 is finite .
view @xmath21 and its shifted saturation @xmath316 as graded submodules of @xmath308 $ ] . to see that the intersection @xmath317 involves only a finite number of irreducible components of @xmath314 ,
it is enough to show that the arrangement given by the quasidegrees of the module @xmath318 has finitely many irreducible components .
this follows since @xmath316 is toric .
recall from that @xmath53 . for
@xmath183 and @xmath13 , let @xmath319 .
[ lemma - mm05 ] let @xmath52 $ ] be a weakly toric module , @xmath183 , @xmath13 be a face of codimension at least two , and @xmath320 be an interior vector of @xmath116 . if @xmath12 is maximal among faces of @xmath0 not in @xmath321 , then for all sufficiently large positive integers @xmath322 , the vector @xmath323 is an exceptional degree of @xmath29 .
this is ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 14 ) when @xmath324 and @xmath0 is homogeneous .
( the matrix @xmath0 is called _ homogeneous _ when the vector @xmath325 is in the @xmath326-row span of @xmath0 . ) the same argument yields this generalization by @xmath41-graded local duality , see ( * ? ? ?
* section 3.5 ) .
[ thm - str comparison ] let @xmath52 $ ] be a weakly toric module .
the ranking arrangement @xmath59 contains the exceptional arrangement @xmath48 and @xmath327 where @xmath328 is pure of codimension 1 .
we must show that @xmath48 contains all irreducible components of @xmath59 of codimension at least two . to this end , let @xmath329 be such that @xmath330 is an irreducible component with @xmath331 .
then there are submodules @xmath332 and @xmath333 such that @xmath334 and @xmath335 . in fact
, there is a @xmath336 with @xmath337 and @xmath338 .
we may further choose @xmath90 so that @xmath12 is maximal among faces of @xmath0 that are not in the set @xmath321 . to see this
, first note that @xmath339 for all @xmath340 . indeed , for
if @xmath341 , then there are @xmath342 and @xmath343 with @xmath344 , a contradiction .
since @xmath338 is an irreducible component of @xmath345 , it suffices to show that @xmath90 can be chosen so that each facet @xmath346 of @xmath0 is in @xmath321 .
first , if @xmath347 , then by lemma [ lemma - finite inside ] , there are at most a finite number of translates of @xmath348 that define components of @xmath345 and intersect @xmath349 ; write these as @xmath350 . if necessary , replace @xmath90 by a vector @xmath351 such that @xmath352 to assume that @xmath346 is in @xmath321 .
note that after such a replacement , it is still true that @xmath353 by the previous paragraph , so @xmath354 . next , suppose that @xmath355 .
if @xmath356 , then @xmath357 , an impossibility because @xmath358 defines an irreducible component of @xmath345 .
thus it must be that @xmath359 . in this case , @xmath360 , so @xmath346 is in @xmath321 .
hence every facet @xmath346 of @xmath0 is in @xmath321 , and the claim on the choice of @xmath90 is established .
let @xmath361 be an interior vector of @xmath116 .
lemma [ lemma - mm05 ] implies that for all sufficiently large integers @xmath322 , the vector @xmath362 .
therefore @xmath363 .
[ not - beta cmpt ] for @xmath26 , the _ @xmath6-components _ @xmath364 of the ranking arrangement of @xmath29 are the union of the irreducible components of @xmath59 which contain @xmath6 .
since @xmath0 has a finite number of faces , @xmath364 has finitely many irreducible components . by (
* porism 9.5 ) , the exceptional arrangement @xmath365 of the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath366 has codimension at least two . in the following example
we show that there may be components of @xmath365 which are embedded in codimension 1 components of the ranking arrangement @xmath314 .
in particular , the zariski closure of @xmath367 may not agree with @xmath365 .
[ example - hidden ] let @xmath368\ ] ] with @xmath369 , and label the faces @xmath370 $ ] and @xmath371 $ ] . with @xmath372 $ ] , the exceptional arrangement of @xmath324 is properly contained in a hyperplane component of the ranking arrangement : @xmath373 we will discuss the rank jumps of @xmath1 in examples [ example - hidden2 ] and [ example - hidden3 ] . one goal of section [ sec : comb of rank ] is to understand the structure of the sets @xmath374 .
we will achieve this by stratifying @xmath48 by ranking slabs ( see definition [ def - ranking slab ] ) .
another description of ranking slabs ( via translates of certain lattices contained in the @xmath6-components @xmath364 ) will be given in proposition [ prop - zc e ] .
let @xmath77 and @xmath78 be subspace arrangements in @xmath7 .
we say that a stratification @xmath79 of @xmath77 _ respects _ @xmath78 if for each irreducible component @xmath80 of @xmath78 and each stratum @xmath81 , either @xmath82 or @xmath83 .
[ def - ranking slab ] a _ ranking slab _ of @xmath29 is a stratum in the coarsest stratification of @xmath48 that respects each of the following arrangements : @xmath59 and @xmath375 for @xmath376 .
since each of the arrangements used in definition [ def - ranking slab ] is determined by the quasidegrees of a weakly toric module , the closure of each ranking slab of @xmath29 is the translate of a linear subspace of @xmath7 that is generated by a face of @xmath0 .
corollary [ cor - strat vs equiv ] states that @xmath86 is constant on each ranking slab , so each @xmath87 with @xmath186 is a union of translates of linear subspaces of @xmath7 that are spanned by faces of @xmath0 .
it then follows that the stratification of @xmath48 by ranking slabs refines its rank stratification . while this is generally a strict refinement , examples [ example - hidden3 ] and [ example-4diml hidden ]
show that the two stratifications may coincide for parameters close enough to the cone @xmath15 .
we wish to emphasize that the rank jump @xmath62 is not simply determined by holes within the semigroup @xmath54 , as can be seen in example [ ex - first example ] .
[ def : slab ] a _ slab _ is a set of parameters in @xmath7 that lie on a unique irreducible component of the exceptional arrangement @xmath48 @xcite .
we will show by example that rank need not be constant on a slab . in example [ example-4diml hidden ] , this failure results from embedded " components of @xmath48 , while in example [ example - nonconstant slab ] , it is due to the hyperplanes of @xmath59 that strictly refine the arrangement stratification of @xmath48 .
together with example [ plane - line-4diml ] , these examples show that each of the arrangements listed in definition [ def - ranking slab ] is necessary to determine such a geometric refinement of the rank stratification of @xmath48 .
as in section [ sec : exceptional arrangement ] , let @xmath299 be a nonempty @xmath54monoid ( see definition [ def : monoid ] ) , so that @xmath300 $ ] is a nontrivial weakly toric module ( see example [ ex - m wt ] ) . for a fixed @xmath61 ,
we know from that @xmath60 can be used to compute the rank jump @xmath62 . however
, this module contains a large amount of excess information that does not play a role in @xmath377 . to isolate the graded pieces of @xmath60 that impact @xmath62
, we will define weakly toric modules @xmath378 so that @xmath379{12 cm } \begin{enumerate } \item \label{prop1 } $ m \subseteq s^{\beta } \subseteq t^{\beta } \subseteq s_a[\del_a^{-1}],$ \item \label{prop2 }
$ \cr_a(m,\beta ) = \qdeg\left(\dfrac{t^{\beta}}{s^{\beta}}\right),$ \item \label{prop3 } $ \beta \notin \qdeg\left(\dfrac{s_a[\del_a^{-1}]}{t^{\beta}}\right)$ , \item \label{prop4 } $ \beta \notin \qdeg\left(\dfrac{s^{\beta}}{m}\right)$ , and \item \label{prop5 } $ \pp^{\beta } = \deg\left(\dfrac{t^{\beta}}{s^{\beta}}\right)$ is a union of translates of $ \wt{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f}$ for various $ f \preceq a$. \end{enumerate } \end{minipage}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in proposition [ prop - qis ] , we show that properties - of allow us to replace @xmath60 with @xmath380 when calculating @xmath62 . to use this module to actually compute @xmath62
, we will encounter other toric modules with structure similar to @xmath63 , which are called _ ranking toric modules_. property allows @xmath63 ( and similarly , any ranking toric module ) to be decomposed into _ simple ranking toric modules_. these modules are constructed so that their euler koszul homology modules have easily computable ranks . at the end of section [ subsec : simple rtm ] , we outline more specifically how simple ranking toric modules will play a role in our computation of @xmath62 .
we now construct the class of _ ranking toric modules _ , which includes the module @xmath63 coming from .
these modules will be constructed via their degree sets , which are unions of @xmath381modules for various @xmath13 .
we begin by isolating the translated lattices contained in @xmath382 that lie in the @xmath6-components @xmath383 of the ranking arrangement of @xmath29 ( see notation [ not - beta cmpt ] ) .
the union of these translated lattices will be denoted by @xmath67 .
[ def - ep ] 1 .
let @xmath65 be the set of faces of @xmath0 corresponding to the @xmath6-components @xmath364 of the ranking arrangement of @xmath29 .
this set @xmath384 is a polyhedral cell complex , and @xmath364 is the union @xmath385 2 . for each @xmath386
, let @xmath387 lemma [ lemma - mm05 ] and theorem [ thm - str comparison ] together imply that @xmath388 is nonempty exactly when there is a containment @xmath389 .
3 . since @xmath302 is an @xmath54monoid , @xmath390
is closed under addition , so @xmath388 is @xmath68-stable .
thus there is a finite set of @xmath68-orbit representatives @xmath391 such that @xmath392 is partitioned into @xmath68-orbits as a disjoint union over @xmath391 .
notice that @xmath393 $ ] .
the @xmath68-orbits @xmath394 in are the translated lattices that we will use to construct ranking toric modules .
each is determined by the pair @xmath395 .
we denote the collection of such pairs by @xmath396 5 . for a subset @xmath397 ,
let @xmath398 [ not - omitj ] many of the objects we define in this section are dependent upon a subset @xmath399 , and this dependence is indicated by the subscript @xmath400 .
whenever we omit this subscript , it is understood that @xmath401 . by the upcoming proposition [ prop - zc e ] , two parameters @xmath84 belong to the same ranking slab exactly when @xmath85 .
this is what will be used to show that the rank jump @xmath62 ) is constant on ranking slabs .
[ lemma - zc e addition ] the zariski closure of the ranking lattices @xmath67 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 coincides with the @xmath6-components @xmath364 of the ranking arrangement .
it is clear from the definitions that @xmath402 .
for the reverse containment , if @xmath403 , then there exists a vector @xmath404 such that @xmath405 .
this implies that @xmath406 is empty , so the claim now follows from the definition of quasidegree sets in definitions [ def - qdeg ] and [ def - wtoric ] .
[ prop - zc e ] the parameters @xmath84 belong to the same ranking slab if and only if the ranking lattices of @xmath29 at @xmath6 and @xmath407 coincide , that is , if @xmath408 this is a consequence of lemma [ lemma - zc e addition ] , lemma [ lemma - mm05 ] , and theorem [ thm - str comparison ] . in light of proposition [ prop - zc e ] ,
use equality of ranking lattices to extend the ranking slab stratification of @xmath48 to the parameter space @xmath7 .
one might try making the sets @xmath409 in definition [ def - ep ] the degree sets of ranking toric modules .
however , while the natural map @xmath410 given by faces @xmath262 induces a vector space map @xmath411 , this induced map is not a morphism of @xmath121-modules because it sends units to zero . to overcome this
, we introduce the lattice points in a certain polyhedron , denoted by @xmath412 , and intersect it with @xmath413 to produce the degree set of a ranking toric module .
[ def - cp ] 1 .
recall the primitive integral support functions @xmath414 from the beginning of section [ sec : defns ] . in order to construct a ranking toric module from @xmath409 , ( and achieve the various quasidegree sets proposed in ) , set @xmath415 for @xmath71 , notice that @xmath416 is simply the integral points in the cone @xmath417 after translation by @xmath6 .
2 . for a pair @xmath418 ,
let @xmath419 .
\nonumber \intertext{the degree sets of ranking toric modules are of the form } \label{17 } \pp_j^{\beta } & \phantom{:}= \bigcup_{(f , b)\in j } \pp_{f , b}^{\beta } \ = \ \cc_a(\beta ) \cap \bbe_j^{\beta } \intertext{for $ j\subseteq\cj(\beta)$. the largest of these is } \label{eqn - p } \pp^{\beta } \ & : = \ \pp_{\cj(\beta)}^{\beta } \ = \
\cc_a(\beta ) \cap \bbe^{\beta } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] the degree set appearing in .
( continuation of example [ example - hidden ] ) [ example - hidden2 ] with @xmath420 \in\ee_a(s_a)$ ] and @xmath421 $ ] , the sets of definitions [ def - ep ] and [ def - ts and r - t ] are @xmath422 \sqcup [ b + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}g ] , \\ \text{and } \phantom{xx } \pp^{\beta } & = & [ \beta + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f ] \sqcup [ b + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}g ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] having defined the degree sets of ranking toric modules in , we now construct the modules themselves . along the way
, we meet the modules that satisfy the requirements of .
[ def - ts and r - t ] 1 .
each ranking toric module will be a quotient of the module @xmath423 ( for some @xmath26 ) , where @xmath424 \phantom{xx } \text { and } \phantom{xx } t^{\beta}\ = \ { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\{\tt^{\beta}\}.\ ] ] notice that if @xmath425 , then @xmath426 .
the simplest case occurs when @xmath55 and @xmath427 , so that @xmath428 .
2 . for @xmath429 ,
let @xmath430 we show in proposition [ prop - basics r - toric ] that @xmath423 and @xmath431 are indeed weakly toric modules ( see definition [ def - wtoric ] ) .
when @xmath401 , these modules satisfy the properties . by notation [ not - omitj ] , @xmath432 .
3 . for a subset @xmath429 ,
the quotient @xmath433 has degree set @xmath434 , as recorded in proposition [ prop - basics r - toric ] . in proposition [ prop - qis ] , we show that @xmath60 in can be replaced by @xmath435 when computing @xmath62 .
if a toric module @xmath43 is isomorphic to @xmath436 for a pair @xmath437 and a subset @xmath429 , we say that @xmath43 is a _ ranking toric module _ determined by @xmath400 .
[ prop - basics r - toric ] let @xmath397 .
there are containments of weakly toric modules : @xmath438 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , @xmath439 is a ranking toric module with degree set @xmath440 . by construction , we have the containment @xmath441 . since the intersection of @xmath67 and @xmath302 is empty , @xmath442 is empty as well .
hence @xmath443 .
the other containments in are obvious .
it is clear from the definitions that the degree sets of all modules in question are closed under addition with elements of @xmath54 , so they are all weakly toric modules . for the second statement , since @xmath444 , @xmath436 is a finitely generated @xmath21-module and therefore @xmath436 is toric . by lemma [ lemma - zc e addition ] and the definition of @xmath445 ,
the arrangement @xmath446 coincides with the @xmath6-components @xmath364 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 .
further , the construction of @xmath63 in definition [ def - ts and r - t ] is such that @xmath63 can replace @xmath60 in when calculating @xmath62 .
[ prop - qis ] the euler koszul complexes @xmath447 and @xmath448 are quasi - isomorphic . in particular , @xmath449 consider the short exact sequences @xmath450}{m } \rightarrow \dfrac{s_a[\del_a^{-1}]}{t^{\beta } } \rightarrow 0 \quad \text{and } \quad 0 \rightarrow \dfrac{s^{\beta}}{m } \rightarrow \dfrac{t^{\beta}}{m } \rightarrow \dfrac{t^{\beta}}{s^{\beta } } \rightarrow 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the definition of @xmath412 ensures that @xmath6 is not a quasidegree of either @xmath451 or @xmath308/t^{\beta}$ ] .
thus we obtain the result from long exact sequences in euler koszul homology and proposition [ prop - hh qis 0 ] .
[ def - e k char ] the _ @xmath452 partial euler
koszul characteristic _ of a weakly toric module @xmath43 is the ( nonnegative ) integer @xmath453 the main result of this article , theorem [ thm - main ] , states that the partial euler koszul characteristics of ranking toric modules are determined by the combinatorics of the ranking lattices @xmath67 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 .
lemma [ lemma - chi p ] describes @xmath62 as the @xmath454 partial euler
koszul characteristic of @xmath63 , so our results regarding the combinatorics of rank jumps are a consequence of theorem [ thm - main ] .
[ lemma - chi p ] the @xmath455 partial euler koszul characteristic of every nontrivial ranking toric module for a pair @xmath437 is 0 .
in particular , @xmath456 .
this follows from ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.2 ) and .
the polyhedral structure of the degree sets of ranking toric modules plays an important role in our computation of their partial euler koszul characteristics .
we will use that each face @xmath457 determines an @xmath121-module that is the quotient of a ranking toric module .
modules of this type are called _ simple ranking toric modules_. [ def - rtoric simple ] 1 . for a subset @xmath429 , the ranking toric module
@xmath436 is _ simple _ if there is a unique @xmath458 such that all pairs in @xmath400 are of the form @xmath395 .
2 . for each @xmath459 and @xmath429 , denote by @xmath460 the simple ranking toric module determined by the set @xmath461 .
the degree set of this module is denoted by @xmath462 .
3 . call the parameter @xmath6 _ simple _ for @xmath29 if @xmath63 is a simple ranking toric module , or equivalently , if there is an @xmath459 such that @xmath463 ( see notation [ not - omitj ] ) .
we show in theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] that for @xmath13 , each simple ranking toric module @xmath460 is a maximal cohen
macaulay toric @xmath121-module .
thus the results of section [ sec : ekstr ] can be applied to compute the rank of their euler koszul homology modules .
notice that by setting @xmath464 it follows from definition [ def - rtoric simple ] that @xmath465 .
in particular , when @xmath401 , @xmath466 .
[ prop - simple r - t ] for @xmath459 and @xmath429 , the simple ranking toric module @xmath460 of definition [ def - rtoric simple ] admits an @xmath121-module structure that is compatible with its @xmath21-module structure . by construction , @xmath462 is closed under addition with elements of @xmath116 .
[ def - triangle ] we define a partial order @xmath467 on @xmath397 by @xmath468 if and only if @xmath469 for pairs @xmath470 . we let @xmath471 denote the subset of @xmath400 consisting of maximal elements with respect to @xmath467 . for @xmath429
, @xmath471 is the smallest subset of @xmath400 that determines a direct sum of simple ranking toric modules into which @xmath436 embeds .
the calculation of the partial euler koszul characteristics of a ranking toric module @xmath436 will be achieved by homologically replacing it by an acyclic complex @xmath472 composed of simple ranking toric modules .
we then examine the spectral sequences determined by the double complex @xmath473 to obtain a formula for the partial euler
koszul characteristics of @xmath436 .
we now define an equivalence relation on the union of the various @xmath68-orbit representatives of .
we show in proposition [ prop - p decomp ] that for @xmath429 , the ranking toric module @xmath436 splits as direct sum over the equivalence classes of this relation .
thus by additivity of rank , can be expressed as a sum involving simpler ranking toric modules .
[ def - tilde ] 1 .
let @xmath474 be the collection of all @xmath68-orbit representatives from .
let @xmath475 be the equivalence relation on the elements of @xmath476 that is generated by the relations @xmath477 if there exist @xmath478 such that @xmath479 3
. let @xmath480 denote the set of equivalence classes of @xmath475 .
4 . for @xmath481 and @xmath429 ,
let @xmath482 hence for @xmath429 , there is a partition of @xmath440 over @xmath480 : @xmath483 .
[ prop - p decomp ] for @xmath429 , there is a decomposition @xmath484 . for distinct @xmath485 , the sets @xmath486 and @xmath487 are disjoint by definition of @xmath475 .
thus there is a decomposition @xmath488 . as a special case of proposition [ prop - p decomp ]
, the simple ranking toric module @xmath489 can be expressed as the direct sum @xmath490 ( see ) . for @xmath401 ,
let the _ rank jump from @xmath491 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 _
be @xmath492 [ cor - j decomp ] the rank jump @xmath62 can be expressed as the sum @xmath493 .
this follows from , proposition [ prop - p decomp ] , and the additivity of @xmath62 . as stated in corollary [ cor - j decomp ] , computing @xmath62
is reduced to finding @xmath494 for each @xmath481 .
when working with examples , it is typically useful to consider each @xmath494 individually .
in contrast , as we continue with the theory , it is more efficient for our notation to study @xmath62 directly . in sections [ subsec : simple case ] and
[ subsec : non - simple case ] , replacing @xmath384 , @xmath63 , and @xmath62 by their corresponding @xmath491 counterparts calculates @xmath494 .
we retain the notation of section [ sec : r - t mods ] .
this section contains our main result , theorem [ thm - main ] , which states that for any subset @xmath429 , the partial euler koszul characteristics of the ranking toric module @xmath436 are determined by the combinatorics of @xmath409 ( refer to definitions [ def - e k char ] , [ def - ts and r - t ] , and [ def - ep ] ) . as a special case of this result , we will have computed @xmath456 in terms of the ranking lattices @xmath67 , resulting in a proof of theorem [ thm - compute jump ] .
we begin by examining the partial euler
koszul characteristics of simple ranking toric modules @xmath495 from definition [ def - rtoric simple ] .
we will compute the partial euler
koszul characteristics of a ranking toric module @xmath436 by homologically approximating it by a cellular resolution ( see definition [ def - cellular definition ] ) built from simple ranking toric modules .
the next theorem shows that simple ranking toric modules are maximal cohen macaulay toric face modules , which will be useful in the general case .
this allows us to compute the rank jump @xmath62 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 when @xmath6 is simple for @xmath29 , as in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.5 ) .
[ thm - rank simple r - toric ] fix @xmath26 , @xmath459 , and @xmath429 .
then the simple ranking toric module @xmath460 is a maximal cohen
macaulay toric @xmath121-module .
further , there is a decomposition @xmath496 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh^f_0(p_{f , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left(\textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and for all @xmath497 , @xmath498 fix a @xmath68-orbit representative @xmath499 , chosen so that @xmath500 .
this implies that @xmath501 is a short exact sequence of toric modules . since @xmath502 the definition of @xmath412 ensures that @xmath503 .
proposition [ prop - hh qis 0 ] and imply that induces the isomorphism @xmath504 .
as @xmath505 , proposition [ prop - str cm ek complex ] gives the decomposition , in light of proposition [ prop - p decomp ] . by (
* ; * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.3 ) , @xmath506 .
now the additivity of rank and combine to complete the claim .
[ cor - simple ] if @xmath61 is simple for @xmath29 , then the rank jump of @xmath29 at @xmath6 is @xmath507 \cdot \vol(f).\ ] ] since @xmath6 is simple for @xmath29 , @xmath463 for some @xmath13 .
hence apply theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] to corollary [ cor - j decomp ] , noting that @xmath508 .
( continuation of examples [ example - hidden ] and [ example - hidden2 ] ) [ example - hidden3 ] with @xmath509 $ ] , we have the set @xmath510 .
both @xmath511 and @xmath512 are simple ranking toric modules . by corollary [ cor - simple ] , @xmath513\cdot 1 \ =
\ 1 \quad \text{and } \quad j_{\widehat{b}}(\beta ) = 1\cdot [ 1 - 1]\cdot 1 \ = \ 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it now follows from proposition [ prop - p decomp ] that @xmath514 .
a similar calculation shows that @xmath515 for any @xmath516 .
[ example-4diml hidden ] let @xmath517\ ] ] with @xmath518 , and consider the faces @xmath370 $ ] and @xmath371 $ ] .
note that the semigroup @xmath54 of example [ example - hidden ] embeds into the @xmath54 here . with @xmath519 $ ] , the exceptional arrangement of @xmath21 is @xmath520 , where @xmath521 thus the ranking slab stratification of @xmath365 is strictly finer than its arrangement stratification .
further , this finer stratification coincides with the rank stratification of @xmath365 inside the cone @xmath15 . for @xmath522 , @xmath523 , while @xmath524 for @xmath525 $ ] .
calculations similar to those of example [ example - hidden3 ] show that @xmath526$. } \end{cases}\ ] ] in particular , the rank of the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath366 is not constant on the slab @xmath527\subseteq \ee_a(s_a)$ ] ( see definition [ def : slab ] ) .
[ example-2 lines c4 ] let @xmath528 for @xmath529\ ] ] and consider the saturated faces @xmath530 $ ] and @xmath531 $ ] .
here @xmath532 , @xmath533 , and @xmath534 .
computations in macaulay 2 @xcite with reveal that @xmath535\cup[\beta'+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f_2],\ ] ] where @xmath536 $ ] . with @xmath537 $ ] and @xmath538 , @xmath539\setminus\beta'$ , } \\
\beta+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f_2 & \text{if $ \beta\in[\beta'+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f_2]\setminus\beta'$ , } \end{cases}\ ] ] @xmath540\cup [ \beta+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f_1]\cup [ \beta+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f_2 ] & \text{if $ \beta=\beta'$}\\ [ \beta+b+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f_1]\cup \beta+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f_1 & \text{if $ \beta\in\wt{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}a}\cap[\beta'+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f_1]\setminus\beta'$ , } \\
\beta+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}f_2 & \text{if $ \beta\in\wt{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}a}\cap[\beta'+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f_2]\setminus\beta'$ , } \end{cases}\ ] ] and @xmath541\setminus\beta'$ , } \\ \
{ \widehat{\beta } \ } & \text{if $ \beta\in\wt{{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{n}}}}a}\cap[\beta'+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f_2]\setminus\beta'$. } \end{cases}\ ] ] by corollary [ cor - simple ] , for @xmath542\setminus\beta'$ ] , @xmath543\cdot\vol(f_2)\ = \ [ 3 - 1]\cdot 1\ = \ 2,\ ] ] while for @xmath544\setminus\beta'$ ] , @xmath545 , and @xmath546\cdot\vol(f_1)\ = \ 2 \cdot [ 3 - 1]\cdot 1\ = \
4.\ ] ] to compute the rank jump of @xmath21 at @xmath407 , we must move to the general case .
we will see in example [ example-2 lines c4 again ] that @xmath547 , which arises as the sum of the generic rank jumps along irreducible components of @xmath548 that is then corrected by error terms that arise from a spectral sequence calculation . we are now prepared to compute the partial euler
koszul characteristics of ranking toric modules .
the proof of our main theorem , theorem [ thm - main ] , will be given at the end of this section , after a sequence of lemmas .
the definitions of @xmath549 , @xmath409 , and @xmath436 can be found in definitions [ def - ep ] and [ def - ts and r - t ] , respectively .
[ thm - main ] for @xmath429 , the partial euler
koszul characteristics of the ranking toric module @xmath436 are determined by the combinatorics of @xmath409 .
we compute the partial euler
koszul characteristics of the ranking toric module @xmath436 will be achieved by homologically approximating @xmath436 by simple ranking toric modules ; note that the ranks of the euler
koszul homology modules of simple ranking toric modules have been computed in theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] .
[ def - cellular definition ] let @xmath550 be an oriented cell complex ( e.g. cw , simplicial , polyhedral ) .
then @xmath550 has the cochain complex @xmath551 where @xmath552 is multiplication by some integer coeff@xmath553 .
let @xmath554 be the category with the nonempty faces of @xmath550 as objects and morphisms @xmath555 fix an abelian category @xmath556 and suppose there is a covariant functor @xmath557 .
let @xmath558 for each @xmath559 .
a sequence of morphisms in @xmath556 @xmath560 is _ cellular _ and _ supported on _
@xmath550 if the @xmath561 component of @xmath562 is coeff@xmath553 @xmath563 .
since @xmath556 is abelian , a cellular sequence is necessarily a complex . in a manner analogous to definition [ def - cellular definition ] , a cellular complex supported on @xmath550 can also be obtained from the chain complex @xmath564 of @xmath550 and a contravariant functor @xmath565 .
further , we could replace @xmath564 in this construction with the _ reduced _ chain or cochain complexes of @xmath550 .
we say that a complex in @xmath556 is _ cellular _ if it can be constructed from the underlying topological data of a cell complex and a functor @xmath557 .
when @xmath550 is a simplicial or polyhedral cell complex , coeff@xmath553 of definition [ def - cellular definition ] is simply @xmath566 if the orientation of @xmath567 induces the orientation of @xmath568 and @xmath569 if it does not . the generality in which we define cellular complexes is alluded to in the introduction of @xcite and appears as ( *
* definition 3.2 ) .
an introduction to these complexes , in the polyhedral case , can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 4 ) .
recall from definition [ def - triangle ] that @xmath471 was defined so that it yields the smallest set of faces of @xmath0 that determines a direct sum of simple ranking toric modules into which @xmath436 embeds .
[ not - cpx i ] we wish to take intersections of faces in the set @xmath471 . in order to keep track of which
faces were involved in each intersection , set @xmath570 with @xmath571 , let @xmath572 be the standard @xmath573-simplex with vertices corresponding to the elements of @xmath574 . to the @xmath575-face of @xmath550 spanned by the vertices corresponding to the elements in @xmath576 ,
assign the ranking toric module @xmath577 .
choosing the natural maps @xmath578 for @xmath579 induces a cellular complex supported on @xmath550 , @xmath580 with @xmath581 [ lemma - i acyclic ] the cohomology of the cellular complex @xmath472 of is concentrated in cohomological degree 0 and is isomorphic to @xmath436 .
given @xmath582 , let @xmath583 be the faces @xmath584 such that @xmath585 .
the degree @xmath44 part of @xmath472 computes the cohomology of the @xmath586-subsimplex of @xmath550 given by the vertices with labels corresponding to @xmath583 ; in particular , it is acyclic with @xmath587-cohomology @xmath588 . by construction , @xmath436 is a @xmath41-graded monomial module over the saturated semigroup ring @xmath589 , and it can be translated by some @xmath361 so that @xmath590 .
after translation by @xmath44 , is similar to an _ irreducible resolution _
, as defined in ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* definition 2.1 ) .
we continue to view @xmath436 as an @xmath21-module , so we use maximal cohen macaulay toric face modules instead of irreducible quotients of @xmath589 .
consider the @xmath41-graded double complex @xmath591 with @xmath592 let @xmath593 and @xmath594 denote the horizontal and vertical differentials of @xmath591 , respectively . by the exactness of ,
taking homology of @xmath591 with respect to @xmath593 yields @xmath595 we now apply the decomposition of these homologies given in theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] to obtain a new description of the euler
koszul homology of the ranking toric module @xmath436 .
[ lemma - right ss ] the vertical spectral sequence obtained from the double complex @xmath596 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk^{f_s}_i(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^j { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( with differentials as in lemma [ lemma - ek morph ] ) has abutment @xmath597 by theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] and lemma [ lemma - ek morph ] , the vertical differentials @xmath594 of @xmath598 are compatible with the quasi - isomorphism @xmath599 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk^{f_s}_\bullet(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^\bullet { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath600 and @xmath601 converge to the same abutment , the result follows from .
note that the first page of the spectral sequence in lemma [ lemma - right ss ] is @xmath602 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh^{f_s}_0(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath603 , let @xmath604 denote the differential of @xmath605 , and let @xmath606 respectively denote the vertical and horizontal differentials of @xmath607 .
if @xmath245 with @xmath608 , then by remark [ remark - diffl in cm ek complex ] , the element @xmath609 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_i^{f_s}(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) \subseteq \ { ' e}_0^{p ,- q}\ ] ] has vertical differential @xmath610 we will use that is an element of @xmath611\otimes \kk_{i-1}^{f_s } ( p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^j { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) \subseteq { ' e}_0^{p ,- q+1}\ ] ] to show that @xmath612 degenerates quickly .
this is the main technical result of this article .
[ lemma - ss terminates ] the spectral sequence @xmath613 of lemma [ lemma - right ss ] degenerates at the second page . for @xmath614 ,
let @xmath615 denote the image of @xmath616 in @xmath617 , if it exists .
let @xmath618 denote the differential of @xmath619 , so @xmath620 . to see that @xmath621 , consider an element @xmath622 with @xmath623 .
then there is an element @xmath624 such that @xmath625 , which is used to define @xmath626 ( recall that is independent of the choice of @xmath627 . )
we write @xmath628 as an element of .
note that @xmath629 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_{i-1}^{f_s}(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^j { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) , \nonumber \intertext{so $ \alpha^s_{ij}$ is in the kernel of $ { } _ v\delta$ for all $ s , i , j$. by \eqref{eq : nice 1st page } , $ \alpha^{s}_{ij}$ is in the image of $ { } _ v\delta$ whenever $ i>0$. hence without changing $ \oalpha$ , we may assume that for all $ s\in\cg^p_j$ , $ \alpha^{s}_{ij}=0 $ when $ i>0 $ , so that } \alpha & \in \bigoplus_{s\in\cg^p_j } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{f_s^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_0^{f_s}(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) .
\nonumber \intertext{as the differential $ { } _ h\delta$ is induced by \eqref{9 } , } { } _ h\delta(\alpha ) & \in \bigoplus_{s\in\cg^{p+1}_j } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{f_s^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_0^{f_s}(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) .
\nonumber \intertext{by hypothesis on $ \alpha$ and \eqref{31 } , there is an element } \label{34 } \eta & \in \bigoplus_{s\in\cg^{p+1}_j } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{f_s^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_1^{f_s}(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) \intertext{such that $ { } _ v\delta(\eta)={}_h\delta(\alpha)$. set $ \zeta={}_h\delta(\eta)$ and note that $ \delta_2(\oalpha)=\ol{\zeta}$. using again that the differential $ { } _ h\delta$ is induced by \eqref{9 } , applied now to \eqref{34 } , we see that } \zeta & \in \bigoplus_{s\in\cg^{p+2}_j } { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[x_{f_s^c } ] \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\kk_1^{f_s}(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right ) .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath630 , @xmath631 is in the kernel of @xmath632 .
hence implies that @xmath633 vanishes .
[ lemma - formula ] for @xmath429 , the @xmath452 partial euler
koszul characteristic of the ranking toric module @xmath436 is given by @xmath634 for @xmath635 , let @xmath636 by lemma [ lemma - ss terminates ] , @xmath637 . from the abutment , we see that @xmath638 for @xmath639 .
since @xmath640 by lemma [ lemma - chi p ] , also @xmath641 .
thus the @xmath452 partial euler koszul characteristic of @xmath436 can be expressed as @xmath642 now follows from the definition of @xmath643 and the quasi - isomorphism , as the isomorphic first pages of the spectral sequences there are and .
we will compute the ranks of @xmath644 and the image of @xmath645 from in subsequent lemmas .
the first is an immediate consequence of theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] .
[ lemma - rank - hqip ] if @xmath646 , then @xmath647 by definition of @xmath648 and additivity of rank , @xmath649 . now apply theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] .
the rank of the image of @xmath645 is determined combinatorially because the spectral sequence rows @xmath650 are cellular complexes .
[ lemma-e cell rows ] the complexes @xmath650 are cellular with support @xmath651 of notation [ not - cpx i ] . in notation
[ not - cpx i ] , we constructed the cellular complex @xmath472 from a labeling of the simplex @xmath572 . if we assign in this construction @xmath652 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh_q^f(p_f^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f^\bot \right)\ ] ] in place of @xmath460 and use the induced maps , we obtain the cellular complex @xmath650 with differential @xmath653 , see .
the existence and compatibility of the differentials follows from lemma [ lemma - ek morph ] .
[ lemma - rank image ] the rank of the image of @xmath645 is determined by the combinatorics of @xmath409 . by lemma [ lemma-e cell rows ] ,
the image of @xmath645 is determined by the @xmath575-coboundaries of @xmath550 and the corresponding labels of @xmath550 , which come from @xmath409 .
if @xmath400 is simple for @xmath29 , the result follows from theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] , so suppose that @xmath436 is not simple for @xmath29 .
by lemma [ lemma - i acyclic ] , @xmath436 is the @xmath587-cohomology of the acyclic cellular complex @xmath472 .
thus the abutment of the spectral sequences arising from the double complex @xmath473 is @xmath654 . by lemma [ lemma - right ss ] ,
the vertical spectral sequence obtained from the double complex @xmath655 of has the same abutment .
since this spectral sequence degenerates on the second page by lemma [ lemma - ss terminates ] , lemma [ lemma - formula ] yields the formula , and by lemmas [ lemma - rank - hqip ] and [ lemma - rank image ] , the summands of are dependent only on the combinatorics of @xmath409 .
recall formula : @xmath656 lemma [ lemma - rank - hqip ] computes the first summand , but lemma [ lemma - rank image ] does not explicitly state the rank of the image of @xmath645 .
a method to do this is provided by proposition [ prop : alg ] .
[ def : circuit ] for @xmath657 , a subset @xmath658 corresponds to a subcomplex @xmath659 of the simplex @xmath660 , as described in notation [ not - cpx i ] .
if @xmath661 and there is a minimal generator of @xmath662 of the form @xmath663 $ ] , where all coefficients @xmath664 are nonzero , then we say that @xmath665 is a _ circuit _ for @xmath666 . for @xmath657 ,
let @xmath667 denote the set of circuits for @xmath666 , and set @xmath668 for @xmath669 , @xmath670 , and @xmath671 , set @xmath672 [ prop : alg ] let @xmath673 be the ranking toric module in .
the rank of the image of @xmath645 from is equal to @xmath674 further , can be computed by combining theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] and induction on the dimension of @xmath675 . before providing the proof of proposition [ prop : alg ] , we state two lemmas . [ lemma : easier comp ] for @xmath676 , @xmath677 where @xmath673 is the ranking toric module given by .
the rank of the image of @xmath678 is @xmath679 by proposition [ prop - str / rk image ] .
view the image of @xmath680 as a quotient of @xmath681 .
if @xmath44 is one of its nonzero multigraded components , then it also appears in the degree set of another summand of @xmath682 .
the collection of such degrees is exactly @xmath683 .
[ lemma : harder comp ] for @xmath657 , @xmath684.\end{aligned}\ ] ] to see this , notice first that for @xmath685 , @xmath686 is generated by the images coming from circuits for @xmath666 . by proposition [ prop - str / rk image ] ,
given a fixed circuit @xmath665 for @xmath666 , the rank of @xmath687 can be computed as the rank of @xmath688 times the @xmath31-rank of @xmath689 = \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f(\lambda)^\bot .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] by the same reasoning used to obtain , the rank of @xmath690 equals the rank of .
the @xmath31-rank of is a binomial coefficient in the codimension in @xmath7 of the span of the vectors in @xmath691 , so the rank of is @xmath692 further , for a collection of circuits @xmath671 , @xmath693 gives the rank of the intersection over @xmath694 of the images of type , so the inclusion - exclusion principle yields .
recall from that the domain of @xmath645 is the direct sum @xmath695 \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}\hh^{f_s}_0(p_{f_s , j}^{\beta},\beta ) \otimes_{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}\left ( \textstyle\bigwedge^q { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{z}}}}f_s^\bot \right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath696 , let @xmath697 denote the restriction of @xmath645 to the summands in @xmath698 .
order the elements of @xmath699 , so that @xmath700 .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] lemmas [ lemma : easier comp ] and [ lemma : harder comp ] respectively computed the summands of , resulting in .
thus it remains to show the second statement .
if a ranking toric module has dimension 0 , then it is necessarily a simple ranking toric module , so theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] computes the rank of its euler
koszul homology modules . thus by induction on dimension
, we can compute the summand in corresponding to @xmath669 if the dimension of @xmath701 is strictly less than the dimension of @xmath681 .
if it is the case that the dimension of @xmath701 equals the dimension of @xmath681 , notice first that each pair @xmath702 has @xmath703 .
this implies that @xmath701 is a direct sum ( as in proposition [ prop - p decomp ] ) of the simple ranking toric module @xmath704 and a lower - dimensional ranking toric module .
therefore induction together with theorem [ thm - rank simple r - toric ] still completes the computation .
finally , the same argument applies to computing the rank of @xmath705 for @xmath671 , since @xmath706 . by lemma [ lemma - chi p ] , our results on the partial euler
koszul characteristics of ranking toric modules reveal the combinatorial nature of rank jumps of the generalized @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath34 . by and
lemma [ lemma - chi p ] , @xmath456 , so the result is an immediate consequence of theorem [ thm - main ] and proposition [ prop : alg ] .
[ example-2 cmpts ] if @xmath26 is such that @xmath707 , the proof of theorem [ thm - main ] and section [ subsec : compute ] show that the rank jump of @xmath29 at @xmath6 is @xmath708 \cdot \vol(f_i ) \right ) + |b_g^{\beta}| \cdot c^{\beta } \cdot\vol(g),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath709 and the constant @xmath710 is given by @xmath711 ( continuation of example [ example-2 lines c4 ] ) [ example-2 lines c4 again ] with @xmath712 $ ] , the set @xmath713 , and @xmath714 by proposition [ prop - p decomp ] . by ,
@xmath715 \cdot \vol(f_i ) \right ) \ + \
|\widehat{\beta ' } \cap b_g^{\beta}| \cdot c^{\beta } \cdot\vol(g)\\ & = & 2 + 2 + 1\cdot(-2)\cdot 1 \ = \ 2 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath716 by corollary [ cor - simple ] .
thus proposition [ prop - p decomp ] implies that the rank jump of the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath717 is @xmath718 .
when @xmath76 and @xmath719 for some @xmath481 , ( * ? ?
* theorem 2.6 ) implies that the rank jump @xmath62 of @xmath29 at @xmath6 corresponds to the reduced homology of the lattice @xmath384 .
the formula given by okuyama involves this homology and the volumes of the 1-dimensional faces of @xmath0 in @xmath384 . for higher - dimensional cases ,
the cellular structure of the complex @xmath720 of notation [ not - cpx i ] shows that , in general , more information than the reduced homology of @xmath384 is needed to compute @xmath62 , or even a single @xmath494 .
recall from definition [ def - ranking slab ] that a ranking slab of @xmath29 is a stratum in the coarsest stratification of @xmath48 that respects a specified collection of subspace arrangements .
we are now prepared to prove corollary [ cor - strat vs equiv ] , which states that the ranking slab stratification of @xmath48 refines its rank stratification . from this
it follows that each @xmath374 is a union of ranking slabs , making each a union of translated linear subspaces of @xmath7 .
if @xmath84 belong to the same ranking slab , then the ranking lattices @xmath721 coincide by proposition [ prop - zc e ] . by theorem [ thm - compute jump ] ,
the rank jumps @xmath62 and @xmath722 coincide as well .
[ cor - eea union linear translates ] for all integers @xmath186 , @xmath87 is a union of translates of linear subspaces that are generated by faces of @xmath0 .
this is an immediate consequence of theorem [ thm - str comparison ] and corollary [ cor - strat vs equiv ] .
the following is the second example promised at the end of section [ sec : exceptional arrangement ] , showing that the rank of @xmath34 need not be constant on a slab ( see definition [ def : slab ] ) .
further , this example shows that neither the arrangement stratification of @xmath48 nor its refinement given by the @xmath47 modules in determine its rank stratification . [ example - nonconstant slab ] consider the matrix @xmath723\ ] ] with @xmath724 , and label the faces @xmath725,$ ] @xmath726 $ ] , and @xmath727 $ ] . with @xmath728 $ ] and @xmath729 , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 3 \\ 2 \\ 3 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 3 \\ 5 \\ 3 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 5 \\ 3 \\ 3 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 3 \\ 3 \\ 5 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 5 \\ 5 \\ 6 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] \right\}$ ] , the exceptional arrangement of @xmath21 is @xmath730 for @xmath731 , @xmath732\setminus
\beta'$,}\\ \bigcup_{i=1}^3 [ \beta ' + \cc f_i ] & \text{if $ \beta = \beta'$,}\\ \end{cases}\ ] ] so by the proof of theorem [ thm - main ] , the rank jump of @xmath29 at @xmath61 is @xmath733\setminus\beta'$,}\\ 2 & \text{otherwise . }
\end{cases}\ ] ] here the arrangement stratification of @xmath365 agrees with the one given by the @xmath47 modules that determine it , but @xmath86 is not constant on the slab @xmath734\subseteq\ee_a(s_a)$ ] . to show that all of the arrangements in the definition of ranking slabs ( definition [ def - ranking slab ] ) are necessary to obtain a refinement of the rank stratification of @xmath48
, we include the following example . here
, @xmath62 changes where components of @xmath365 that correspond to different @xmath47 modules intersect .
[ plane - line-4diml ] let @xmath735,\ ] ] @xmath736 $ ] , @xmath737 $ ] , and @xmath738 $ ] . here
@xmath739 , and the exceptional arrangement of @xmath21 is @xmath740 \cup [ \beta ' + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}g],\ ] ] where @xmath741 by corollary [ cor - simple ] and example [ example-2 cmpts ] , @xmath742\setminus\beta'$ , } \\ 4 & \text{if $ \beta\in[\beta'+{{\ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}g]\setminus\beta'$. } \end{cases}\ ] ] we include a final example to show that @xmath62 is not determined simply by @xmath743 , the holes in the semigroup @xmath54 .
[ ex - first example ] the matrix @xmath744\ ] ] has volume 16 .
the exceptional arrangement of @xmath324 is the union of four lines and a point : @xmath745 + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f \right ) \cup \left ( \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}g \right ) \cup \left ( \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1\\ 0\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[a_5 ] \right ) \cup \left ( \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 0\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[a_6 ] \right ) \cup \left\ { \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 2\\ 2\\ 1 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] \right\},\ ] ] where @xmath746 $ ] and @xmath747 $ ] .
the generic rank jumps along each component are as follows : @xmath748 + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}f \mapsto 3 , \quad \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1\\ 0\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[a_5 ] \mapsto 1 , \quad \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}g \mapsto 3 , \quad \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 0\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[a_6 ] \mapsto 1 , \quad \text{and } \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 2\\ 2\\ 1 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] \mapsto 2 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] these generic rank jumps are achieved everywhere except at the points @xmath749 , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1\\ 0\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 0\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] , \text { and } \left[\begin{smallmatrix } \phantom{-}0\\ \phantom{-}0\\ -1 \end{smallmatrix}\right].\ ] ] the point that may be unexpected in this collection is @xmath750 $ ] .
both of the components of @xmath365 that contain @xmath90 have generic rank jumps of 1 ; however , @xmath751 .
this is because the ranking arrangement of @xmath21 has three components that contain @xmath90 : @xmath752 \right ) \cup \left ( b + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[a_6 ] \right ) \cup \left ( b + { { \ensuremath{\mathbb{c}}}}[a_1\ a_2\ a_3\ a_4 ] \right ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the plane @xmath753)$ ] were not in @xmath754 , then the rank jump of @xmath21 at @xmath90 would only be 1 by .
thus the hyperplane in , although unrelated to the holes in @xmath54 , accounts for the higher value of @xmath755 .
the rank jumps at the other parameters are @xmath756 \right ) = j\left ( s_a , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 0\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] \right ) = 3 \quad \text { and } \quad j\left ( s_a , \left[\begin{smallmatrix } 1\\ 1\\ 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ] \right ) = 5.\ ] ] the algebraic upper semi - continuity of the rank of @xmath34 implies that most of the codimension 1 components of the ranking arrangement @xmath59 do not increase the rank of @xmath34 .
it would interesting to know if the set of such hyperplanes can be identified .
when @xmath324 , the results of section [ sec : comb of rank ] apply to the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath366 . for a face @xmath567 of @xmath0 , @xmath757 is a finite set .
it is shown in @xcite and @xcite that @xmath1 and @xmath758 are isomorphic as @xmath4-modules precisely when @xmath759 for all faces @xmath567 of @xmath0 .
we will now use euler koszul homology to give a simple proof of one direction of this equivalence ; first we exhibit a complementary relationship between @xmath89 and @xmath760 ( see ) .
[ obs - etau ] it is shown in theorem [ thm - compute jump ] that as @xmath567 runs through the faces of @xmath0 , the sets @xmath761 determine the rank jump of @xmath1 at @xmath6 .
notice that @xmath762 is the complement of @xmath89 in the group @xmath763 . if @xmath770 is not an isomorphism , then @xmath771 by lemma [ lemma - nisom ] . by the definition of quasidegrees
, there exist vectors @xmath772 and @xmath773 for some face @xmath567 such that @xmath774 , @xmath775 , and @xmath776 for all @xmath140 .
hence @xmath777 , so @xmath778 .
further , the condition @xmath779 for all @xmath140 implies that @xmath780 .
for the if " direction , suppose that @xmath783 for all faces @xmath567 of @xmath0 . as stated in (
* ; * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.2 ) , @xmath784 implies by definition that @xmath785 , so @xmath764 for some @xmath786 .
there are unique vectors @xmath787 with disjoint support such that @xmath788 . in light of lemma [ lemma - netau ]
, we may assume that both @xmath789 and @xmath790 are nonzero .
we claim that at least one of @xmath791 or @xmath792 defines an isomorphism from @xmath1 to @xmath758 .
if @xmath793 or @xmath794 defines an isomorphism , then the only - if " direction and lemma [ lemma - netau ] imply that @xmath791 or @xmath792 , respectively , give the desired isomorphism .
we are left to consider the case when @xmath795 does not define an isomorphism from either domain . by lemma [ lemma - nisom ] , this is equivalent to @xmath796 from the right side of , we see that the nonempty face @xmath797 is such that @xmath798 , so @xmath799 . however , the shift @xmath800 in the left side of implies that @xmath801 .
thus @xmath802 , which is a contradiction .
it is not yet understood how the holomorphic solution space of @xmath1 varies as a function of @xmath6 ; different functions of @xmath6 suggest alternative behaviors .
walther showed in @xcite that the reducibility of the monodromy of @xmath1 varies with @xmath6 in a lattice - like fashion . when the convex hull of @xmath0 and the origin is a simplex , saito used the sets @xmath89 to construct a basis of holomorphic solutions of @xmath1 with a common domain of convergence @xcite .
thus theorem [ thm - compute jump ] and the complementary relationship in observation [ obs - etau ] between the @xmath89 and the ranking lattices of @xmath21 at @xmath6 suggest that the ranking slabs give the coarsest stratification over which there could be a constructible sheaf of solutions for the hypergeometric system .
victor v. batyrev and duco van straten , _ generalized hypergeometric functions and rational curves on calabi yau complete intersections in toric varieties _ , ( english summary ) comm . math . phys .
* 168 * ( 1995 ) , no . 3 , 493533 . i. m. gelfand , a. v. zelevinski , and m. m. kapranov , _ hypergeometric functions and toric varieties _ , funktsional
i prilozhen .
* 23 * ( 1989 ) , no . 2 , 1226 .
correction in ibid , * 27 * ( 1993 ) , no . 4 , 91 . mutsumi saito and william n. traves , _ differential algebras on semigroup algebras _ , _ symbolic computation : solving equations in algebra , geometry , and engineering _ ( south hadley , ma , 2000 ) , 207226 , contemp . math
, * 286 * , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 2001 .
bernd sturmfels , _ solving algebraic equations in terms of @xmath0-hypergeometric series _ ( english summary ) , formal power series and algebraic combinatorics ( minneapolis , mn , 1996 ) , discrete math . * 210 * ( 2000 ) , no . 1 - 3 , 171181 .
bernd sturmfels and nobuki takayama , _ grbner bases and hypergeometric functions _ , grbner bases and applications ( linz , 1998 ) , 246258 , london math .
lecture note ser . , * 251 * , cambridge univ . press , cambridge , 1998 . | the holonomic rank of the @xmath0-hypergeometric system @xmath1 is the degree of the toric ideal @xmath2 for generic parameters ; in general , this is only a lower bound . to the semigroup ring of @xmath0
we attach the ranking arrangement and use this algebraic invariant and the exceptional arrangement of nongeneric parameters to construct a combinatorial formula for the rank jump of @xmath1 . as consequences , we obtain a refinement of the stratification of the exceptional arrangement by the rank of @xmath1 and show that the zariski closure of each of its strata is a union of translates of linear subspaces of the parameter space .
these results hold for generalized @xmath0-hypergeometric systems as well , where the semigroup ring of @xmath0 is replaced by a nontrivial weakly toric module @xmath3 $ ] .
we also provide a direct proof of the main result in @xcite regarding the isomorphism classes of @xmath1 . |
the discovery of a new class of superconductors based on iron pnictides has opened up the new prospects for the study of high - temperature superconductivity ( cf .
reviews @xcite ) .
the nature of superconductivity in these novel materials and other physical properties significantly differs from those of high @xmath7 cuprates , though they still have many common features , which gives hope for a better understanding of the problem of high - temperature superconductivity in general .
the discovery of superconductivity in iron pnictides was soon followed by its discovery in iron _ chalcogenide _ fese .
a lot of attention was attracted to this system because of its simplicity , though its superconducting characteristics ( under normal conditions ) were quite modest ( @xmath88k ) and its electronic structure was quite similar to that of iron pnictides ( cf . review in @xcite ) . the situation with iron chalcogenides fundamentally changed with the appearance of _ intercalated _ fese based systems with the value of @xmath830 - 40k , which immediately attracted attention due to their unusual electronic structure @xcite .
currently quite the number of such compounds is known .
the first systems of this kind were a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1 ( a = k , rb , cs ) with the value of @xmath8 30k @xcite .
it is generally believed that superconductivity in this system appears in an ideal 122-type structure .
however samples studied so far always have been multiphase , consisting of a mixture of mesoscopic superconducting and insulating ( antiferromagnetic ) structures such as k@xmath1fe@xmath10se@xmath11 , which complicates the studies of this system .
a substantial further increase of @xmath7 up to 45k has been achieved by intercalation of fese layers with rather large molecules in compounds such as li@xmath0(c@xmath1h@xmath12n@xmath1)fe@xmath9se@xmath1 @xcite and li@xmath0(nh@xmath1)@xmath13(nh@xmath4)@xmath14fe@xmath1se@xmath1 @xcite .
the growth of @xmath7 in these systems might be associated with increase of the distance between the fese layers from 5.5 to @xmath157 in a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1 and 8 - 11 in the large molecules intercalated systems ,
i.e. with the growth of the two - dimensional character of the materials
. most recently the active studies has started of [ li@xmath3fe@xmath0oh]fese system with the value of @xmath843k @xcite , where a good enough single phase samples and single crystals were obtained . a significant breakthrough in the study of iron based superconductors happened with the observation of a record high @xmath7 in epitaxial films of single fese monolayer on a substrate of srtio@xmath16(sto ) @xcite .
these films were grown as described in ref .
@xcite and most of the works to follow on the 001 plane of the sto .
the tunnel experiments reported in ref . @xcite produced the record values of the energy gap , while the resistivity measurements gave the temperature of the beginning of superconducting transition substantially higher than 50k .
it should be noted that the films under study are very unstable on the air .
thus in most works the resistive transitions were mainly studied on films covered with amorphous si or several fete layers .
it significantly reduces the observed values of @xmath7 .
unique measurements of fese films on sto , done in ref .
@xcite _ in situ _
, gave the record value of @xmath7>100k .
so far , these results have not been confirmed by the other authors .
however arpes measurements of the temperature dependence of the superconducting gap in such films , now confidently demonstrate value of @xmath7 in the range of 6575 k. films consisting of several fese layers produce the values of @xmath7 significantly lower than those for the single layer films @xcite .
recently monolayer fese film on 110 sto plane @xcite covered with several fete layers was grown .
resistivity measurements on these films ( including measurements of the upper critical magnetic field @xmath17 ) gave value of @xmath830k .
at the same time , the fese film , grown on batio@xmath4 ( bto ) substrate , doped with nb ( with even larger than in sto values of the lattice constant @xmath15 3.99 ) , showed in the arpes measurements the value of @xmath18 70k @xcite . in a recent paper @xcite it was reported the observation of quite high values of the superconducting gap in fese ( from tunnelling spectroscopy ) for fese monolayers grown on 001 plane of tio@xmath19 ( anatase ) , which in its turn was grown on the 001 plane of srtio@xmath4 .
the lattice constant of anatase is very close to the lattice constant of bulk fese , so fese film remains essentially unstretched .
single layer fese films were also grown on the graphene substrate , but the value of @xmath7 was of the order of 8 - 10k similar to bulk fese @xcite . that emphasizes the role of the unique properties of substrates such as sr(ba)tio@xmath4 , which can play determining role in the significant increase of @xmath7 . more information about the experiments on single
layer fese films can be found in the recently published review of ref .
below we shall concentrate on the present day understanding of the electronic structure of fese monolayer systems .
bulk fese system has the simplest crystal structure among other iron high - t@xmath20 superconductors .
a unit cell is a tetrahedron with fe ion in the center and se in its vertices .
the symmetry group is p4/nmm with lattice constants @xmath21 ( fe - fe distance ) and @xmath22 ( interlayer distance ) , with the height of the se ions over the fe planes @xmath23 @xcite .
figure [ strucfepn ] schematically shows a simple crystal structure of iron based superconductors @xcite .
the common element for all of them is the presence of the feas or fese plane ( layer ) , where fe ions form a simple square lattice .
the pnictogen ( pn - as ) or chalcogen ( ch - se ) ions are located at the centers of the squares above and below fe plane in a staggered order .
the 3d states of fe in fepn plane ( ch ) play a decisive role in the formation of the electronic properties of these systems , including superconductivity . in this sense , these layers are quite similar to the cuo@xmath1 planes in cuprates ( copper oxides ) . also these systems can be considered , to a first approximation , as a quasi - two dimensional .
note that all of the feas crystal structures shown in fig .
[ strucfepn ] are ion covalent crystals .
chemical formula , say for a typical system 122 , can be written for example as ba@xmath24(fe@xmath24)@xmath1(as@xmath25)@xmath1 .
charged feas layers are held by coulomb forces from the surrounding ions . in the bulk fese
electrically neutral fese layers are held by much weaker van der waals interactions .
this makes the system suitable for intercalation of various atoms and molecules that can be fairly easy introduced between the layers of fese .
chemistry of intercalation processes for iron chalcogenide superconductors is discussed in detail in a recent review ref .
the crystal structure of k@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 and [ li@xmath3f@xmath0oh]fese systems are shown in fig .
[ interfech](b ) .
= 1 ) crystal structure of 122-type of k@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 , ( b ) ideal ( @xmath26=0 ) crystal structure of [ li@xmath3f@xmath0oh]fese compound.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] = 1 ) crystal structure of 122-type of k@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 , ( b ) ideal ( @xmath26=0 ) crystal structure of [ li@xmath3f@xmath0oh]fese compound.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] the structure of the fese monolayer film on sto is shown in fig .
[ fesesto ] .
it can be seen that the fese layer is directly adjacent to the surface tio@xmath1 layer of sto .
note that the lattice constant within fese layer in a bulk samples is equal to 3.77 , while sto has substantially greater lattice constant equal to 3.905 .
thus the single
layer fese film should be noticeably stretched , compared with the bulk fese .
however this tension quickly disappears as the number of subsequent layers grows .
electronic spectrum of iron pnictides now is well understood , both by theoretical calculations based on the modern band structure theory and arpes experiments @xcite .
almost all physical effects of interest to superconductivity are determined by electronic states of feas plane ( layer ) , shown in fig .
[ strucfepn ] ( b ) .
the spectrum of carriers in the vicinity of the fermi level @xmath27 0.5 ev , where superconductivity is formed , practically have only fe-3@xmath28 character .
thus the fermi level is crossed by four or five bands ( two or three hole and two electronic ones ) , forming a typical semi metallic dispersions . in this rather narrow energy interval around the fermi level
the dispersions can be considered as parabolic @xcite .
lda+dmft calculations @xcite show that the role of electronic correlations in iron pnictides , unlike the cuprates , is relatively insignificant .
it is reduced to a noticeable renormalization of the effective masses of the electron and hole dispersions , as well as to general `` compression '' ( reduction ) of the bandwidth .
the presence of the electron and hole fermi surfaces of similar size , satisfying ( approximately ! ) the `` nesting '' condition plays a very important role in the theories of superconducting pairing in iron arsenides based on ( antiferromagnetic ) spin fluctuations @xcite
. we shall see below that the electronic spectrum and fermi surfaces in the fe chalcogenides are very different from this qualitative picture of fe pnictides .
it raises the new problems for the explanations of microscopic mechanism of superconductivity in fese systems .
lda calculations of electronic structure of the a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1 ( a = k , cs ) system were performed immediately after its experimental discovery @xcite .
surprisingly enough , this spectrum has appeared to be qualitatively different from that of the bulk fese and spectra of all known systems based on feas . in fig .
[ 122comp ] we compare energy bands of bafe@xmath1as@xmath19 ( ba122 ) @xcite ( the typical prototype of feas systems ) and a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1(a = k , cs ) @xcite .
one can see a significant difference in the spectra near the fermi level .
0 ) @xcite , ( b ) lda bands of k@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 ( black lines ) and cs@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 ( blue lines ) .
additional horizontal lines correspond to fermi levels of 20% and 60% hole doping @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] 0 ) @xcite , ( b ) lda bands of k@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 ( black lines ) and cs@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1 ( blue lines ) .
additional horizontal lines correspond to fermi levels of 20% and 60% hole doping @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] in fig .
[ fsafese ] we show the calculated fermi surfaces for two systems a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1 ( a = k , cs ) at various doping levels @xcite .
we see that they differ significantly from the fermi surfaces of feas systems fermi surfaces in the center of the brillouin zone , there are only small ( mainly electronic ! ) fermi sheets , while the electronic cylinders in the brillouin zone corners are substantially larger .
the shape of the fermi surface , typical for bulk fese and feas systems , can be reproduced only at a much larger ( experimentally inaccessible ) levels of the hole doping @xcite .
fe@xmath1se@xmath1 ( a = k , cs ) for the stoichiometric ( left ) and 20% ( right ) hole doping @xcite .
, scaledwidth=90.0% ] this shape of the fermi surfaces in a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1 systems was rather soon supported by arpes experiments . for example , in fig . [ fsfesearp ]
we show arpes data of ref .
@xcite , which obviously is in agreement with lda data of refs .
@xcite .
fe@xmath29se@xmath1 ( @xmath7=32k ) and tl@xmath30k@xmath31fe@xmath32se@xmath1 ( @xmath7=28k ) @xcite.,scaledwidth=75.0% ] one can clearly see that in this system it is impossible to speak of any , even approximate , `` nesting '' properties of electron and hole fermi surfaces .
lda+dmft calculations for k@xmath3fe@xmath9se@xmath1 system for various doping levels were done in refs .
@xcite . there , along with the standard lda+dmft approach , we also used our lda@xmath33+dmft @xcite approach , which allows , in our opinion , to solve the problem of `` double counting '' of coulomb interaction in the lda+dmft in a more consistent way . for dmft calculations coulomb and exchange interactions of the electrons in the fe-3d shell
we have chosen @xmath34 ev and @xmath35 ev and as an _ impurity solver _ hirsh fye quantum monte - carlo algorithm ( qmc ) was used .
the results of the lda calculations are useful to compare with the arpes data obtained in refs .
@xcite .
it is turned out that for k@xmath3fe@xmath9se@xmath1 correlation effects play quite an important role .
they lead to a noticeable change in lda energy dispersions .
in contrast to iron arsenides , where the quasiparticle bands near the fermi level are well defined , in the k@xmath3fe@xmath9se@xmath1 compounds in the vicinity of the fermi level there is a strong suppression of quasiparticle bands .
this reflects the fact that the correlation effects in this system are stronger than in iron arsenides .
the value of the quasiparticle renormalization ( correlation narrowing ) of the bands at the fermi level is 4 - 5 , whereas in iron arsenides this factor is only 2 - 3 for the same values of the interaction parameters .
the results of these calculations , in general , are in good qualitative agreement with the arpes data @xcite .
both demonstrate strong damping of quasiparticles in the immediate vicinity of the fermi level and a strong renormalization of the effective mass as compared to systems based on feas
. however , in our calculations formation of unusually `` shallow '' ( depth @xmath36 0.05 ev ) electron bands near the @xmath37-point in the brillouin zone , observed in arpes experiments , is not visible . in ref .
@xcite the authors reported systematic arpes study of the k@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath38s@xmath39 system at different doping levels .
it was shown that the sulfur doping level @xmath40 can control the depth of the `` shallow '' electron band near the @xmath37-point ( fig .
[ fig1 ] , @xmath41 band ) .
we tried to model this situation for different compositions of k@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath38s@xmath39 , taking into account the changes of lattice constant .
we considered three cases of k@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath42 , k@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath43s@xmath43 and k@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath44s@xmath45 .
the appropriate values of lattice constants used in our calculations are listed in table [ tab1 ] .
-@xmath37 direction in k@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath38s@xmath46 .
( b ) the bandwidth of @xmath41 and @xmath47 bands as a function of doping .
( c ) doping dependence of the effective mass ( @xmath48 ) and fermi velocity ( @xmath49 ) of the @xmath41 band @xcite . ] fe@xmath9se@xmath38s@xmath39 compounds . ] fe@xmath9se@xmath38s@xmath39 compounds . ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab1 ] the lda calculated density of states and band dispersions are presented in fig .
[ fig2 ] and fig .
[ fig3 ] correspondingly . upon
sulfur doping the bandwidth of fe-3d states increases , while the bottom of the @xmath41 band slightly goes down .
corresponding @xmath41 band bottom positions are 0.37 , 0.38 , 0.40 ev .
the se-4p states also go down in energy ( see table [ tab1 ] ) .
these results are in qualitative agreement with arpes experiments , though the unusually low values of band bottom energies ( `` shallow '' band formation ) of @xmath41 band remain a mystery .
we can also note , that according to table [ tab1 ] k@xmath1fe@xmath1se@xmath1 has the smallest ( lda ) bandwidth of 3d states and it grows with sulfur doping .
thus one can expect , that k@xmath1fe@xmath1se@xmath1 is the most correlated system in this series . in ref .
@xcite we presented the results of lda calculations for stoichiometric liohfese .
corresponding energy band dispersions are shown in fig .
[ liohfese_spectr_fs ] ( a ) . at first glance , the energy spectrum of this system is quite similar to the spectra of the most of feas based systems and bulk fese . in particular , the main contribution to the density of states in the wide energy range around the fermi level
is determined solely by fe-3@xmath28 .
the fermi surfaces are qualitatively similar to that of majority of fe based superconductors . however , this is somewhat misleading impression .
real [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese system , where superconductivity was discovered , the partial replacement of li by fe in lioh intercalation layers leads to noticeable lioh _ electron _
doping , so that the fermi energy moves upwards ( relative to the stoichiometric case ) by about 0.15 - 0.2 ev .
then , as can be seen from fig .
[ liohfese_spectr_fs ] ( a ) , the hole bands close to the @xmath5 point shifts below the fermi level and the hole cylinders of fermi surface almost disappear .
the general view of the lda calculated fermi surface for this level of electron doping is shown in fig .
[ liohfese_spectr_fs ] ( b ) .
it has an obvious similarity with the results for the a@xmath0fe@xmath9se@xmath1 system ( see fig .
[ fsafese ] ) .
these conclusions are directly confirmed by arpes experiments @xcite , with the results are shown in fig .
[ liohfese_spectr_fs ] ( c ) .
0 ) @xcite , ( b ) lda fermi surface liohfese , corresponding to electron doping of 0.3 electrons per unit cell , ( c ) experimental arpes fermi surfaces for [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite , ( d ) experimental arpes bands near the fermi level of [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] 0 ) @xcite , ( b ) lda fermi surface liohfese , corresponding to electron doping of 0.3 electrons per unit cell , ( c ) experimental arpes fermi surfaces for [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite , ( d ) experimental arpes bands near the fermi level of [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] 0 ) @xcite , ( b ) lda fermi surface liohfese , corresponding to electron doping of 0.3 electrons per unit cell , ( c ) experimental arpes fermi surfaces for [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite , ( d ) experimental arpes bands near the fermi level of [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] 0 ) @xcite , ( b ) lda fermi surface liohfese , corresponding to electron doping of 0.3 electrons per unit cell , ( c ) experimental arpes fermi surfaces for [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite , ( d ) experimental arpes bands near the fermi level of [ li@xmath50fe@xmath51oh]fese @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] from fig .
[ liohfese_spectr_fs ] one can see that the fermi surface consists mostly of electronic cylinders surrounding the @xmath6-points , while around the @xmath5 point the fermi surface is either absent or very small . in any case , for this system we can not speak of any `` nesting '' of electron and hole fermi surfaces in any sense .
electronic dispersions found in the arpes experiments are very similar to corresponding arpes dispersions reported in refs .
@xcite for k@xmath3fe@xmath9se@xmath1 system .
these are qualitatively similar to dispersions obtained in lda and lda+dmft calculations , including rather strong correlation bands narrowing ( by about several times with different compression factor for different bands ) @xcite ) .
however , the explanation of the formation of extremely `` shallow '' electron @xmath41 band with depth @xmath150.05 ev near the @xmath6-point remains unclear .
this requires an unusually strong correlation compression which hardly can be obtained from the lda+dmft calculations , while the diameter of electronic cylinders around @xmath6 points is nearly unchanged by correlations and almost coincides with the results of lda calculations .
an interesting debate flared up around the possible nature of magnetic ordering of fe ions , which replaces li ions within intercalation lioh layers . in ref .
@xcite it was stated that this ordering is just a canted antiferromagnet . however , in ref .
@xcite , on the basis of magnetic measurements , it was claimed that it is ferromagnetic , with curie temperature @xmath5210k , i.e. substantially below the superconducting transition temperature .
this conclusion was confirmed indirectly in ref .
@xcite by observing the scattering of neutrons on the lattice of abrikosov vortices , which might be induced in the fese layers by ferromagnetic ordering of fe spins in the li@xmath3fe@xmath0oh layers .
at the same time , in ref . @xcite it was argued that mssbauer measurements indicate the absence of any kind of magnetic ordering on fe ions in intercalation layers . in ref .
@xcite lsda calculations of the exchange integrals were performed for some typical magnetic configurations of fe ions , replacing li in lioh layers . for the most likely magnetic configuration , leading to magnetic ordering , we have obtained the positive ( ferromagnetic ) sign of the exchange interaction , and simple estimate of the curie temperature produced the value of curie temperature @xmath53 10k , which is in excellent agreement with the results of experiment of refs .
@xcite .
lda calculations of the spectrum of the isolated fese monolayer can be performed in a standard slab approach . to calculate electronic properties we used the _ quantum - espresso _
@xcite package .
the results of these calculations are shown in fig .
[ fese_lda_dmft_bands ] ( a ) .
it can be seen that the spectrum has the form typical for feas based systems and bulk fese discussed in detail above .
however arpes experiments @xcite convincingly show that this is not so . for fese monolayers on sto only electronic fermi surface sheets
are observed around the @xmath6 points of the brillouin zone , while hole sheets , centered around the @xmath5 point ( in the center of the zone ) , are simply absent .
an example of such data is shown in fig .
[ fese_arpes_bands ] ( a ) @xcite . similarly to intercalated fese systems there are no signs of `` nesting '' of fermi surface
there are just no surfaces to `` nest '' ! in an attempt to explain the contradiction between arpes experiments @xcite and band structure calculations reflected in the absence of hole cylinder in the @xmath5 point , one can suppose that this may be the consequence of fese / sto monolayer stretching due to mismatch of lattice constants of the bulk fese and sto .
we have studied this problem by varying the lattice parameter @xmath54 and se height @xmath55 in the range @xmath56 around the bulk fese parameters . before the electronic structure was calculated crystal structure was relaxed .
unfortunately , the conclusion was that the changes of lattice parameters do not lead to qualitative changes of fese fermi surfaces and the hole cylinders in the @xmath5 point always remain
. however , there is another rather simple qualitative explanation for the absence of hole cylinders and the observed fermi surfaces can be obtained by assuming that the system is just electronically doped .
the fermi level has to be moved upwards in energy by the value of @xmath36 0.2 - 0.25 ev , as shown by the solid ( red ) horizontal line in fig .
[ fese_lda_dmft_bands ] ( a ) , which corresponds to the doping level of 0.15 - 0.2 electron per fe ion . strictly speaking , the nature of this doping is not fully identified .
but there is a common belief that it is associated with the formation of oxygen vacancies in the srtio@xmath4 substrate ( within the topmost layer of tio@xmath1 ) , occurring during the various technological steps used during the film preparation , such as annealing , etching , etc .
it should be noted that the formation of the electron gas at the interface with the srtio@xmath4 is a widely known phenomenon , which was studied for a long time @xcite . at the same time , for fese / sto system this issue remains poorly understood ( see , however , refs .
@xcite .
electron correlations have relatively little influence on the spectrum of the fese monolayer .
[ fese_lda_dmft_bands ] ( b ) shows the results of lda+dmft calculations for estimated experimental value of electron doping .
dmft calculations were done for the values of the coulomb and exchange ( hund ) electron interactions in the fe-3d shell equal to @xmath57 ev and @xmath58 ev . as _ impurity solver _ we used the continuous time quantum monte
carlo algorithm ( ct - qmc ) .
the inverse dimensionless temperature was taken to be @xmath47 = 40 .
it can be seen that the spectrum is very weakly renormalized by correlations and preserves the general lda like shape , with a slight band compression factor of about @xmath36 1.3 .
red line shows approximate fermi level position to agree with arpes experimental data .
lda+dmft bands of isolated electronically doped fese monolayer near the doping shifted fermi level.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] 0 ) .
red line shows approximate fermi level position to agree with arpes experimental data .
lda+dmft bands of isolated electronically doped fese monolayer near the doping shifted fermi level.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] electronic dispersion in monolayer fese films was measured by arpes and reported in a number of papers @xcite .
the results of ref .
@xcite are shown in fig .
[ fese_arpes_bands ] ( b ) .
they are consistent with those of other studies and , in general , are similar to those obtained for the intercalated fese systems ( see e.g. fig .
[ liohfese_spectr_fs ] ( c ) ) .
overall , they are qualitatively similar to the results of lda+dmft but there is no quantitative agreement . in particular , in the arpes experiments
the presence of the unusual `` shallow '' electron band at @xmath6 point , with the band bottom at @xmath36 0.05 ev is clearly observed .
however , our calculated dispersions show a `` depth '' of almost an order of magnitude larger . it should also be noted that an additional `` shadow '' or `` replica '' electronic band near the @xmath6 point was observed in ref .
@xcite , which is @xmath15100 mev below the parent band `` shallow '' band , and is clearly visible in fig .
[ fese_arpes_bands ] ( b ) .
this `` shadow '' band is completely missed in the band structure calculations .
the possible nature of this band ( due to interaction with 100 mev sto optical phonons ) and its importance for mechanisms of @xmath59 enhancement in fese / sto films was discussed in ref .
@xcite .
now let us discuss the results of our lda calculations of electronic structure of the fese monolayer film on srtio@xmath4 substrate as shown in fig .
[ fesesto ] .
these calculations were again performed with _ quantum espresso _ @xcite . by looking on left panel of fig .
[ mlfese_sto ] one can immediately recognize that there appears an additional hole band near the @xmath6 point . to understand its origin we plotted on right panel of fig .
[ mlfese_sto ] o-2p states of topmost surface tio@xmath1 layer of sto substrate .
we can conclude , that the presence of sto interface leads to the appearance of this additional band of o-2p surface states near the fermi level with probable `` nesting '' with hole fe 3d band band with nesting vector @xmath60=0 .
also we observe rather small splitting of electron bands at @xmath6 point .
the relevance of these results to arpes experiments and their significance for enhanced superconductivity in fese / sto system are at present unclear .
however , the additional electron band splitting may have the relation to the observation of the `` replica '' band at @xmath6
point @xcite , providing the explanation of its appearance not related to interaction with optical phonons in sto .
we have presented a short review of calculations of electronic band structure of high @xmath7 systems based on fese monolayers , from intercalated compounds like a@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath38s@xmath46 ( a = k , cs , ... ) and [ li@xmath3fe@xmath0oh]fese to single fese layer films of srtio@xmath4 substrate .
our calculations show , that in all these systems the general structure of electronic spectrum is significantly different from the `` standard model '' typical for almost all feas based superconductors and bulk fese .
this structure is characterized by the practical absence of hole like fermi surface cylinders around the @xmath5 point at the center of the brillouin zone with only electron like cylinders present around the @xmath6 points in the corners of the brillouin zone .
these results are essentially confirmed by the available arpes experiments .
an apparent absence of obvious `` nesting '' properties between electron and hole fermi surface pockets cast serious doubts upon the most popular picture of cooper pairing , assumed to realize in feas systems , based on the exchange of antiferromagnetic fluctuations and leading to the picture of @xmath61 pairing @xcite .
the role of electronic correlations in fese monolayers remain rather controversial .
lda+dmft calculations for k@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath1s system show that here these correlations are more important than in typical feas systems , leading to stronger bandwidth compression ( different for different fe 3d bands ) and rather poorly defined quasiparticles close to the fermi level . in contrast to this , in isolated fese single
layer system the same calculations demonstrate rather weak influence of correlations with small bandwidth compression ( effective mass renormalization ) . the role of srtio@xmath4 substrate may also be important leading to the appearance of o-2p hole band of tio@xmath1 layer in the vicinity of the fermi level .
the serious problems for understanding of the observable electronic structure of fese monolayer systems remain to be solved .
in particular , at present there are no acceptable explanation of formation of unusually `` shallow '' electronic bands around the @xmath62 points , with fermi energies @xmath15 0.05 ev , observed in arpes experiments on all of these systems .
it can be guessed that this fact reflects our poor understanding of electron correlations and the question remains open .
note that the existence of such small fermi energies in conduction bands of the system under discussion signifies the serious problems related to the antiadiabatic regime of cooper pairing @xcite .
taking into account the typical values of the energy gap in fese monolayer superconductors @xmath63 0.015 - 0.02 ev @xcite we also obtain the anomalously low gap to the fermi energy ratios : @xmath640.25 - 0.5 , which indicate , that these superconductors belong to bcs
bec crossover region @xcite .
calculations of electronic structure of fese systems were performed under the faso state contract no . 0389 - 2014 - 0001 and partially supported by rfbr grant 14 - 02 - 00065 .
nsp and aas work was also supported by the president of russia grant for young scientists no .
mk-5957.2016.2 .
wang qing - yan , li zhi , zhang wen - hao , zhang zuo - cheng , zhang jin - song , li wei , ding hao , ou yun - bo , deng peng , ghang kai , wen jing , song can - li , he ke , jia jin - feng , ji shuai - hua , wang ya - yu , wang li - li , chan xi , ma xu - cun , xue qi - kun .
* 29 * 037402 ( 2012 ) zhao l , mou d , liu s , he j , peng y , yu l , liu x , liu g , he s , dong x , zhang j , he j b , wang d m , chen g f , guo j g , chen x l , wang x , peng q , wang z , zhang s , yang f , xu z , chen c , zhou x j. phys .
b * 83 * , 140508(r ) ( 2011 ) defa liu , wenhao zhang , daixiang mou , junfeng he , yun - bo ou , qing - yan wang , zhi li , lili wang , lin zhao , shaolong he , yingying peng , xu liu , chaoyu chen , li yu , guodong liu , xiaoli dong , jun zhang , chuangtian chen , zuyan xu , jiangping hu , xi chen , xucun ma , qikun xue , x. j. zhou .
nature communications * 3 * 931 ( 2012 ) lin zhao , aiji liang , dongna yuan , yong hu , defa liu , jianwei huang , shaolong he , bing shen , yu xu , xu liu , li yu , guodong liu , huaxue zhou , yulong huang , xiaoli dong , fang zhou , zhongxian zhao , chuangtian chen , zuyan xu , zhou x j. nature communications * 7 * 10608 ( 2016 ) | we review a variety of theoretical and experimental results concerning electronic band structure of superconducting materials based on fese monolayers .
three type of systems are analyzed : intercalated fese systems a@xmath0fe@xmath1se@xmath2s@xmath0 and [ li@xmath3fe@xmath0oh]fese as well as the single fese layer films on srtio@xmath4 substrate .
we present the results of detailed first principle electronic band structure calculations for these systems together with comparison with some experimental arpes data .
the electronic structure of these systems is rather different from that of typical feas superconductors , which is quite significant for possible microscopic mechanism of superconductivity .
this is reflected in the absence of hole pockets of the fermi surface at @xmath5-point in brillouin zone , so that there are no `` nesting '' properties of different fermi surface pockets .
lda+dmft calculations show that correlation effects on fe-3d states in the single fese layer are not that strong as in most of feas systems . as a result ,
at present there is no theoretical understanding of the formation of rather `` shallow '' electronic bands at @xmath6 points .
lda calculations show that the main difference in electronic structure of fese monolayer on srtio@xmath4 substrate from isolated fese layer is the presence of the band of o-2p surface states of tio@xmath1 layer on the fermi level together with fe-3d states , which may be important for understanding the enhanced @xmath7 values in this system .
we briefly discuss the implications of our results for microscopic models of superconductivity .
pacs : 74.20.-z , 74.20.rp , 74.25.jb , 74.70.-b |
when complex systems join to form even more complex systems , the interaction of the constituent subsystems is highly random @xcite .
the complex stochastic interactions among these subsystems are commonly quantified by calculating the cross - correlations . this method has been applied in systems ranging from nanodevices @xcite , atmospheric geophysics @xcite , and seismology @xcite , to finance @xcite . here
we propose a method of estimating the most significant component in explaining long - range cross - correlations . studying cross - correlations in these diverse physical systems
provides insight into the dynamics of natural systems and enables us to base our prediction of future outcomes on current information . in finance ,
we base our risk estimate on cross - correlation matrices derived from asset and investment portfolios @xcite . in seismology ,
cross - correlation levels are used to predict earthquake probability and intensity @xcite . in nanodevices used in quantum information processing ,
electronic entanglement necessitates the computation of noise cross - correlations in order to determine whether the sign of the signal will be reversed when compared to standard devices @xcite .
reference @xcite reports that cross - correlations for @xmath0 calculated between pairs of eeg time series are inversely related to dissociative symptoms ( psychometric measures ) in 58 patients with paranoid schizophrenia . in genomics data ,
@xcite reports spatial cross - correlations corresponding to a chromosomal distance of @xmath1 million base pairs . in physiology ,
@xcite reports a statistically significant difference between alcoholic and control subjects .
many methods have been used to investigate cross - correlations ( i ) between pairs of simultaneously recorded time series @xcite or ( ii ) among a large number of simultaneously - recorded time series @xcite .
reference @xcite uses a power mapping of the elements in the correlation matrix that suppresses noise .
reference @xcite proposes detrended cross - correlation analysis ( dcca ) , which is an extension of detrended fluctuation analysis ( dfa ) @xcite and is based on detrended covariance .
reference @xcite proposes a method for estimating the cross - correlation function @xmath2 of long - range correlated series @xmath3 and @xmath4 . for fractional brownian motions with hurst exponents @xmath5 and @xmath6 , the asymptotic expression for @xmath2 scales as a power of @xmath7 with exponents @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
univariate ( single ) financial time series modeling has long been a popular technique in science .
to model the auto - correlation of univariate time series , traditional time series models such as autoregressive moving average ( arma ) models have been proposed @xcite .
the arma model assumes variances are constant with time .
however , empirical studies accomplished on financial time series commonly show that variances change with time . to model time - varying variance , the autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity ( arch ) model
was proposed @xcite . since then , many extensions of arch has been proposed , including the generalized autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity ( garch ) model @xcite and the fractionally - integrated autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity ( fiarch ) model @xcite . in these models ,
long - range auto - correlations in magnitudes exist , so a large price change at one observation is expected to be followed by a large price change at the next observation .
long - range auto - correlations in magnitude of signals have been reported in finance @xcite , physiology @xcite , river flow data @xcite , and weather data @xcite . besides univariate time
series models , modeling correlations in multiple time series has been an important objective because of its practical importance in finance , especially in portfolio selection and risk management @xcite . in order to capture potential cross - correlations among different time series , models for coupled heteroskedastic time series
have been introduced @xcite . however , in practice , when those models are employed , the number of parameters to be estimated can be quite large .
a number of researchers have applied multiple time series analysis to world indices , mainly in order to analyze zero time - lag cross - correlations .
reference @xcite reported that for international stock return of nine highly - developed economies , the cross - correlations between each pair of stock returns fluctuate strongly with time , and increase in periods of high market volatility . by volatility
we mean time - dependent standard deviation of return .
the finding that there is a link between zero time lag cross - correlations and market volatility is `` bad news '' for global money managers who typically reduce their risk by diversifying stocks throughout the world . in order to determine whether financial crises are short - lived or long - lived , ref .
@xcite recently reported that , for six latin american markets , the effects of a financial crisis are short - range . between two and four months after each crisis ,
each latin american market returns to a low - volatility regime . in order to determine whether financial crisis are short - term or long - term at the world level , we study 48 world indices , one for each of 48 different countries . we analyze cross - correlations among returns and magnitudes , for zero and non - zero time lags .
we find that cross - correlations between magnitudes last substantially longer than between the returns , similar to the properties of auto - correlations in stock market returns @xcite .
we propose a general method in order to extract the most important factors controlling cross - correlations in time series . based on random matrix theory @xcite and principal component analysis @xcite
we propose how to estimate the global factor and the most significant principal components in explaining the cross - correlations .
this new method has a potential to be broadly applied in diverse phenomena where time series are measured , ranging from seismology to atmospheric geophysics .
this paper is organized as follows . in section
ii we introduce the data analyzed , and the definition of return and magnitude of return . in section iii
we introduce a new modified time lag random matrix theory ( tlrmt ) to show the time - lag cross - correlations between the returns and magnitudes of world indices .
empirical results show that the cross - correlations between magnitudes decays slower than that between returns . in section iv
we introduce a single global factor model to explain the short- or long - range correlations among returns or magnitudes .
the model relates the time - lag cross - correlations among individual indices with the auto - correlation function of the global factor . in section
v we estimate the global factor by minimizing the variance of residuals using principal component analysis ( pca ) , and we show that the global factor does in fact account for a large percentage of the total variance using rmt . in section
vi we show the applications of the global factor model , including risk forecasting of world economy , and finding countries who have most the independent economies .
in order to estimate the level of relationship between individual stock markets either long - range or short - range cross - correlations exist at the world level we analyze @xmath8 world - wide financial indices , @xmath9 , where @xmath10 denotes the financial index and @xmath11 denotes the time .
we analyze one index for each of 48 different countries : 25 european indices @xcite , 15 asian indices ( including australia and new zealand ) @xcite , 2 american indices @xcite , and 4 african indices @xcite . in studying 48 economies that include both developed and developing markets we significantly extend previous studies in which only developed economies were included e.g . , the seven economies analyzed in refs .
@xcite , and the 17 countries studied in ref .
we use daily stock - index data taken from _ bloomberg _ , as opposed to weekly @xcite or monthly data @xcite .
the data cover the period 4 jan 1999 through 10 july 2009 , 2745 trading days . for each index @xmath9
, we define the relative index change ( return ) as @xmath12 where @xmath11 denotes the time , in the unit of one day . by magnitude of return
we denote the absolute value of return after removing the mean @xmath13
in order to quantify the cross - correlations , random matrix theory ( rmt ) ( see refs . @xcite @xcite and references therein ) was proposed in order to analyze collective phenomena in nuclear physics .
@xcite extended rmt to cross - correlation matrices in order to find cross - correlations in collective behavior of financial time series .
the largest eigenvalue @xmath14 and smallest eigenvalue @xmath15 of the wishart matrix ( a correlation matrix of uncorrelated time series with finite length ) are @xmath16 where @xmath17 , and @xmath18 is the matrix dimension and @xmath19 the length of each time series .
the larger the discrepancy between ( a ) the correlation matrix between empirical time series and ( b ) the wishart matrix obtained between uncorrelated time series , the stronger are the cross - correlations in empirical data @xcite .
many rmt studies reported equal - time ( zero @xmath20 ) cross - correlations between different empirical time series @xcite . recently
time - lag generalizations of rmt have been proposed @xcite . in one of the generalizations of rmt , based on the eigenvalue spectrum called time - lag rmt ( tlrmt ) , ref .
@xcite found long - range cross - correlations in time series of price fluctuations in absolute values of 1340 members of the new york stock exchange composite , in both healthy and pathological physiological time series , and in the mouse genome .
we compute for varying time lags @xmath20 the largest singular values @xmath21 of the cross - correlation matrix of n - variable time series @xmath22 @xmath23 we also compute @xmath24 of a similar matrix @xmath25 , where @xmath22 are replaced by the magnitudes @xmath26 .
the squares of the non - zero singular values of are equal to the non - zero eigenvalues of @xmath27 or @xmath27 , where by @xmath27 we denote the transpose of . in a singular value decomposition ( svd )
@xcite @xmath28 the diagonal elements of are equal to singular values of , where the and correspond to the left and right singular vectors of the corresponding singular values .
we apply svd to the correlation matrix for each time lag and calculate the singular values , and the dependence of the largest singular value @xmath21 on @xmath20 serves to estimate the functional dependence of the collective behavior of @xmath29 on @xmath20 @xcite .
we make two modifications of correlation matrices in order to better describe correlations for both zero and non - zero time lags .
* the first modification is a correction for correlation between indices that are not frequently traded .
since different countries have different holidays , all indices contain a large number of zeros in their returns .
these zeros lead us to underestimate the magnitude of the correlations . to correct for this problem ,
we define a modified cross - correlation between those time series with extraneous zeros , @xmath30 here @xmath31 is the time period during which both @xmath22 and @xmath32 are non - zero . with this definition , the time periods during which @xmath22 or @xmath32 exhibit zero values have been removed from the calculation of cross - correlations .
the relationship between @xmath33 and @xmath34 is @xmath35 * the second modification corrects for auto - correlations .
the main diagonal elements in the correlation matrix are ones for zero - lag correlation matrices and auto - correlations for non - zero lag correlation matrices .
thus , time - lag correlation matrices allow us to study both auto - correlations and time - lag cross - correlations .
if we study the decay of the largest singular value , we see a long - range decay pattern if there are long - range auto - correlations for some indices but no cross - correlation between indices . to remove the influence of auto - correlations and isolate time - lag cross - correlations ,
we replace the main diagonals by unity , @xmath36 with this definition the influence of auto - correlations is removed , and the trace is kept the same as the zero time - lag correlation matrix . in fig .
1(a ) we show the distribution of cross - correlations between zero and non - zero lags . for @xmath37 the empirical pdf @xmath38 of the cross - correlation coefficients @xmath29 substantially deviates from the corresponding pdf @xmath39 of a wishart matrix , implying the existence of equal - time cross - correlations . in order to determine whether short - range or long - range cross - correlations accurately characterize world financial markets , we next analyze cross - correlations for @xmath40 . we find that with increasing @xmath20 the form of @xmath38 quickly approaches the pdf @xmath39 , which is normally distributed with zero mean and standard deviation @xmath41 @xcite . in fig .
1(b ) we also show the distribution of cross - correlations between _ magnitudes_. in financial data , returns @xmath42 are generally uncorrelated or short - range auto - correlated , whereas the magnitudes are generally long - range auto - correlated @xcite .
we thus examine the cross - correlations @xmath43 between @xmath44 for different @xmath20 . in fig .
1(b ) we find that with increasing @xmath20 , @xmath45 approaches the pdf of random matrix @xmath39 more slowly than @xmath46 , implying that cross - correlations between index magnitudes persist longer than cross - correlations between index returns . in order to demonstrate the decay of cross - correlations with time lags , we apply modified tlrmt . fig .
2 shows that with increasing @xmath20 the largest singular value calculated for @xmath47 decays more slowly than the largest singular value calculated for .
this result implies that among world indices , the cross - correlations between magnitudes last longer than cross - correlations between returns . in fig .
2 we find that @xmath48 vs. @xmath20 decays as a power law function with the scaling exponent equal to 0.25
. the faster decay of @xmath48 vs. @xmath20 for implies very weak ( or zero ) cross - correlations among world - index returns for larger @xmath20 , which agrees with the empirical finding that world indices are often uncorrelated in returns .
our findings of long - range cross - correlations in magnitudes among the world indices is , besides a finding in ref .
@xcite , another piece of `` bad news '' for international investment managers .
world market risk decays very slowly .
once the volatility ( risk ) is transmitted across the world , the risk lasts a long time .
the arbitrage pricing theory states that asset returns follow a linear combination of various factors @xcite .
we find that the factor structure can also model time lag pairwise cross - correlations between the returns and between magnitudes .
to simplify the structure , we model the time lag cross - correlations with the assumption that each individual index fluctuates in response to one common process , the `` global factor '' @xmath49 , @xmath50 here in the global factor model ( gfm ) , @xmath51 is the average return for index @xmath52 , @xmath49 is the global factor , and @xmath53 is the linear regression residual , which is independent of @xmath49 , with mean zero and standard deviation @xmath54 . here
@xmath55 indicates the covariance between @xmath42 and @xmath49 , @xmath56 .
this single factor model is similar to the sharpe market model @xcite , but instead of using a known financial index as the global factor @xmath49 , we use factor analysis to find @xmath49 , which we introduce in the next section .
we also choose @xmath49 as a zero - mean process , so the expected return @xmath57 , and the global factor @xmath49 is only related with market risk .
we define a zero - mean process @xmath58 as @xmath59 a second assumption is that the global factor can account for most of the correlations .
therefore we can assume that there are no correlations between the residuals of each index , @xmath60 .
then the covariance between @xmath42 and @xmath61 is @xmath62 the covariance between magnitudes of returns depends on the return distribution of @xmath49 and @xmath42 , but the covariance between squared magnitudes @xmath63 indicates the properties of the magnitude cross - correlations .
the covariance between @xmath64 and @xmath65 is @xmath66 the above results in eqs .
( [ cov1])-([cov2 ] ) show that the variance of the global factor and square of the global factor account for all the zero time lag covariance between returns and squared magnitudes . for time
lag covariance between @xmath58 , we find @xmath67 here @xmath68 is the autocovariance of @xmath49 .
similarly , we find @xmath69 here @xmath70 is the autocovariance of @xmath71 . in gfm ,
the time lag covariance between each pair of indices is proportional to the autocovariance of the global factor .
for example , if there is short - range autocovariance for @xmath49 and long - range autocovariance for @xmath71 , then for individual indices the cross - covariance between returns will be short - range and the cross - covariance between magnitudes will be long - range .
therefore , the properties of time - lag cross - correlation in multiple time series can be modeled with a single time series the global factor @xmath49 .
the relationship between time lag covariance among two index returns and autocovariance of the global factor also holds for the relationship between time lag cross - correlations among two index returns and auto - correlation function of the global factor , because it only need to normalize the original time series to mean zero and standard deviation one .
in contrast to domestic markets , where for a given country we can choose the stock index as an estimator of the `` global '' factor , when we study world markets the global factor is unobservable . at the world level when we study cross - correlations among world markets , we estimate the global factor using principal component analysis ( pca ) @xcite . in this section
we use bold font for n dimensional vectors or @xmath72 matrix , and underscore @xmath11 for time series .
suppose @xmath73 is the multiple time series , each row of which is an individual time series @xmath74 .
we standardize each time series to zero mean and standard deviation 1 as @xmath75 the correlation matrix can be calculated as @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the transpose of @xmath78 , and the @xmath19 in the denominator is the length of each time series .
then we diagonalize the @xmath79 correlation matrix @xmath80 @xmath81 here @xmath82 and @xmath83 are the eigenvalues in non - increasing order , @xmath84 is an orthonormal matrix , whose @xmath52-th column is the basis eigenvector @xmath85 of @xmath80 , and @xmath86 is the transpose of @xmath84 , which is equal to @xmath87 because of orthonormality . for each eigenvalue and the corresponding eigenvector ,
it holds @xmath88 according to pca , @xmath89 is defined as the @xmath52-th principal component ( @xmath90 ) , and the eigenvalue @xmath91 indicates the portion of total variance of @xmath78 contributed to @xmath92 , as shown in eq .
( [ pca_value ] ) .
since the total variance of @xmath78 is @xmath93 the expression @xmath94 indicates the percentage of the total variance of @xmath78 that can be explained by the @xmath92 .
according to pca ( a ) the principal components @xmath92 are uncorrelated with each other and ( b ) @xmath92 maximizes the variance of the linear combination of @xmath95 with the orthonormal restriction @xmath96 given the previous principal components @xcite . from the orthonormal property of @xmath84
we obtain @xmath97 where * i * is the identity matrix .
then the multiple time series @xmath78 can be represented as a linear combination of all the @xmath98 @xmath99 the total variance of all time series can be proved to be equal to the total variance of all principal components @xmath100 next we assume that @xmath101 is much larger than each of the rest of eigenvalues which means that the first @xmath98 , @xmath102 , accounts for most of the total variances of all the time series .
we express @xmath78 as the sum of the first part of eq .
( [ r2pc ] ) corresponding to @xmath103 and the error term combined from all other terms in eq .
( [ r2pc ] ) .
thus @xmath104 then @xmath103 is a good approximation of the global factor @xmath49 , because it is a linear combination of @xmath42 that accounts for the largest amount of the variance .
@xmath105 is a zero - mean process because it is a linear combination of @xmath106 which are also zero - mean processes ( see eq .
( [ z ] ) ) . comparing eqs .
( [ z ] ) and ( [ r2pc1 ] ) with @xmath107 we find the following estimates : @xmath108 using eq . ( [ pca_value ] )
we find that @xmath109 in the rest of this work , we apply the method of eq .
( [ duan ] ) to empirical data .
next we apply the method of eq .
( [ duan ] ) to estimate the global factor of 48 world index returns .
we calculate the auto - correlations of @xmath49 and @xmath110 , which are shown in figs . 3 and 4 .
precisely , for the world indices , fig .
3(a ) shows the time series of the global factor @xmath49 , and fig .
3(b ) shows the auto - correlations in @xmath49 .
we find only short - range auto - correlations because , after an interval @xmath111 , most auto - correlations in @xmath49 fall in the range of @xmath112 @xcite , which is the 95% confidence interval for zero auto - correlations , here @xmath113 .
for the 48 world index returns , fig .
4(a ) shows the time series of magnitudes @xmath110 , with few clusters related to market shocks during which the market becomes fluctuates more .
4(b ) shows that , in contrast to @xmath49 , the magnitudes @xmath110 exhibit long - range auto - correlations since the values @xmath110 are significant even after @xmath114 .
the auto - correlation properties of the global factor are the same as the auto - correlation properties of the individual indices , i.e. , there are short - range auto - correlations in @xmath49 and long - range power - law auto - correlations in @xmath110 @xcite .
these results are also in agreement with fig .
1(b ) where the largest singular value @xmath48 vs. @xmath20 calculated for @xmath47 decays more slowly than the largest singular value calculated for .
as found in ref .
@xcite for @xmath115 , @xmath21 approximately follows the same decay pattern as cross - correlation functions .
although a ljung - box test shows that the return auto - correlation is significant for a 95% confidence level @xcite , the return auto - correlation is only 0.132 for @xmath116 and becomes insignificant after @xmath111 .
therefore , for simplicity , we only consider magnitude cross - correlations in modeling the global factor .
we model the long - range market - factor returns * m * with a particular version of the garch process , the gjr garch process @xcite , because this garch version explains well the asymmetry in volatilities found in many world indices @xcite .
the gjr garch model can be written as @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the volatility and @xmath119 is a random process with a gaussian distribution with standard deviation 1 and mean 0 .
the coefficients @xmath120 and @xmath121 are determined by a maximum likelihood estimation ( mle ) and @xmath122 if @xmath123 , @xmath124 if @xmath125 .
we expect the parameter @xmath126 to be positive , implying that `` bad news '' ( negative increments ) increases volatility more than `` good news '' .
for the sake of simplicity , we follow the usual procedure of setting @xmath127 in all numerical simulations . in this case , the gjr - garch(1,1 ) model for the market factor can be written as @xmath128 we estimate the coefficients in the above equations using mle , where the estimated coefficients are shown in table . 1 .
next we test the hypothesis that a significant percentage of the world cross - correlations can be explained by the global factor . by using pca
we find that the global factor can account for 30.75% of the total variance .
note that , according to rmt , only the eigenvalues larger than the largest eigenvalue of a wishart matrix calculated by eq .
( [ rmt ] ) ( and the corresponding @xmath129s ) are significant . to calculate the percentage of variance the significant @xmath129s account for
, we employ the rmt approach proposed in ref .
the largest eigenvalue for a wishart matrix is @xmath130 for @xmath8 and @xmath113 we found in the empirical data .
from all the 48 eigenvalues , only the first three are significant : @xmath131 , @xmath132 , and @xmath133 .
this result implies that among the significant factors , the global factor accounts for @xmath134 of the variance , confirming our hypothesis that the global factor accounts for most variance of all individual index returns .
pca is defined to estimate the percentage of variance the global factor can account for zero time lag correlations .
next we study the time lag cross - correlations after removing the global trend , and apply the svd to the correlation matrix of regression residuals @xmath135 of each index [ see eq .
( [ duan1 ] ) ] .
our results show that for both returns and magnitudes , the remaining cross - correlations are very small for all time lags compared to cross - correlations obtained for the original time series .
this result additionally confirms that a large fraction of the world cross - correlations for both returns and magnitudes can be explained by the global factor .
the asymptotic ( unconditional ) variance for the gjr - garch model is @xmath136 @xcite . for the market factor
the conditional volatility @xmath118 can be estimated by recursion using the historical conditional volatilities and fitted coefficients in eq .
( [ pr2d ] ) .
for example , the largest cluster at the end of the graph shows the 2008 financial crisis . in fig .
5(a ) we show the time series of the conditional volatility of eq .
( [ pr2d ] ) of the global factor .
the clusters in the conditional volatilities may serve to predict market crashes . in each cluster ,
the height is a measure of the size of the market crash , and the width indicates its duration . in fig .
5(b ) we show the forecasting of the conditional volatility of the global factor , which asymptotically converges to the unconditional volatility .
next , in fig .
[ cormarind ] we show the cross - correlations between the global factor and each individual index using eq .
( [ pc12cor ] ) .
there are indices for which cross - correlations with the global factor are very small compared to the other indices ; 10 of 48 indices have cross - correlations coefficients with the global factor smaller than 0.1 .
these indices correspond to iceland , malta , nigeria , kenya , israel , oman , qatar , pakistan , sri lanka , and mongolia .
the financial market of each of these countries is weakly bond with financial markets of other countries .
this is useful information for investment managers because one can reduce the risk by investing in these countries during world market crashes which , seems , do not severely influence these countries .
we have developed a modified time lag random matrix theory ( tlrmt ) in order to quantify the time - lag cross - correlations among multiple time series . applying the modified tlrmt to the daily data for 48 world - wide financial indices , we find short - range cross - correlations between the returns , and long - range cross - correlations between their magnitudes .
the magnitude cross - correlations show a power law decay with time lag , and the scaling exponent is 0.25 . the result we obtain , that at the world level the cross - correlations between the magnitudes are long - range , is potentially significant because it implies that strong market crashes introduced at one place have an extended duration elsewhere which is `` bad news '' for international investment managers who imagine that diversification across countries reduces risk .
we model long - range world - index cross - correlations by introducing a global factor model in which the time lag cross - correlations between returns ( magnitudes ) can be explained by the auto - correlations of the returns ( magnitudes ) of the global factor .
we estimate the global factor as the first component by using principal component analysis . using random matrix theory , we find that only three principal components are significant in explaining the cross - correlations .
the global factor accounts for 30.75% of the total variance of all index returns , and 75.34% of the variance of the three significant principle components .
therefore , in most cases , a single global factor is sufficient .
we also show the applications of the gfm , including locating and forecasting world risk , and finding individual indices that are weakly correlated to the world economy . locating and forecasting world risk can be realized by fitting the global factor using a gjr - garch(1,1 ) model , which explains both the volatility correlations and the asymmetry in the volatility response to both `` good news '' and `` bad news . ''
the conditional volatilities calculated after fitting the gjr - garch(1,1 ) model indicates the global risk , and the risk can be forecasted by recursion using the historical conditional volatilities and the fitted coefficients . to find the indices that are weakly correlated to the world economy
, we calculate the correlation between the global factor and each individual index .
we find 10 indices which have a correlation smaller than 0.1 , while most indices are strongly correlated to the global factor with the correlations larger than 0.3 .
to reduce risk , investment managers can increase the proportion of investment in these countries during world market crashes , which do not severely influence these countries .
based on principal component analysis , we propose a general method which helps extract the most significant components in explaining long - range cross - correlations .
this makes the method suitable for broad range of phenomena where time series are measured , ranging from seismology and physiology to atmospheric geophysics .
we expect that the cross - correlations in eeg signals are dominated by the small number of most significant components controlling the cross - correlations .
we speculate that cross - correlations in earthquake data are also controlled by some major components .
thus the method may have significant predictive and diagnostic power that could prove useful in a wide range of scientific fields . c. k. peng _ et al _ phys .
e * 49 * , 1685 ( 1994 ) ; a. carbone , g. castelli , and h. e. stanley , physica a * 344 * , 267 ( 2004 ) ; l. xu _
et al _ , phys .
e * 71 * , 051101 ( 2005 ) ; a. carbone , g. castelli , and h. e. stanley , phys .
e * 69 * , 026105 ( 2004 ) .
ftse 100 , dax , cac 40 , ibex 35 , swiss market , ftse mib , psi 20 , irish overall , omx iceland 15 , aex , bel 20 , luxembourg luxx , omx copenhagen 20 , omx helsinki , obx stock , omx stockholm 30 , austrian traded atx , athex composite share price , wse wig , prague stock exch , budapest stock exch indx , bucharest bet index , sbi20 slovenian total mt , omx tallin omxt , malta stock exchange ind , ftse / jse africa top40 ix ise national 100 , tel aviv 25 , msm30 , dsm 20 , mauritius stock exchange , nikkei 225 , hang seng , shanghai se b share , all ordinaries , nzx all , karachi 100 , sri lanka colombo all sh , stock exch of thai , jakarta composite , ftse bursa malaysia klci , psei - philippine se , mse top 20 .gjr - garch(1,1 ) coefficients of the global factor . the p - values and t - values comfirms that all these parameters are significant at 95% confidence level .
the positive value of @xmath126 means bad news " has larger impact on the global market than good news " .
we find @xmath137 , which is very close to 1 , and so indicate long - range volatility auto - correlations . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] world financial index returns each of size @xmath113 ( a ) the empirical pdf of the coefficients of the cross - correlation matrix calculated between index returns with increasing @xmath20 quickly converges to the gaussian form .
the normal distribution is the distribution of the pairwise cross - correlations for finite length uncorrelated time series , which is a normal distribution with mean zero and standard deviation @xmath138 . between ( b ) the empirical pdf of the coefficients of the matrix @xmath139 calculated between index volatilities approaches the pdf of the random matrix more slowly than in ( a ) .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] + world financial index returns each of size @xmath113 ( a ) the empirical pdf of the coefficients of the cross - correlation matrix calculated between index returns with increasing @xmath20 quickly converges to the gaussian form .
the normal distribution is the distribution of the pairwise cross - correlations for finite length uncorrelated time series , which is a normal distribution with mean zero and standard deviation @xmath138 . between ( b ) the empirical pdf of the coefficients of the matrix @xmath139 calculated between index volatilities approaches the pdf of the random matrix more slowly than in ( a ) .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] + obtained from the spectrum of the matrices and @xmath140 versus time lag @xmath20 . with increasing @xmath20 , the largest singular values obtained for of returns decays more quickly than @xmath140 calculated for absolute values of returns .
the magnitude cross - correlations decay as a power law function with the scaling exponent of @xmath141.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] + , and become insignificant after time lag @xmath111 , with no more than one significant auto - correlation for every 20 time lags .
therefore , only short - range auto - correlations can be found in the global factor.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] + , and become insignificant after time lag @xmath111 , with no more than one significant auto - correlation for every 20 time lags .
therefore , only short - range auto - correlations can be found in the global factor.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] , and is still larger than 0.2 until @xmath142 . for every time lag ,
the autocorrelation is significant even after @xmath114 .
therefore long - range auto - correlations exist in the magnitudes of the global factor.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] + , and is still larger than 0.2 until @xmath142 . for every time lag ,
the autocorrelation is significant even after @xmath114 .
therefore long - range auto - correlations exist in the magnitudes of the global factor.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=60.0% ] and each individual index @xmath42 , @xmath143 .
the global factor has large correlation with most of the indices . however , there are indices that are not much correlated with the global factor .
10 of the 48 indices have a correlation smaller than 0.1 between the global factor , corresponding to the indices for iceland , malta , nigeria , kenya , israel , oman , qatar , pakistan , sri lanka , and mongolia .
hence , unlike most countries , the economies of these 10 countries are more independent of the world economy.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] | we propose a modified time lag random matrix theory in order to study time lag cross - correlations in multiple time series .
we apply the method to 48 world indices , one for each of 48 different countries .
we find long - range power - law cross - correlations in the absolute values of returns that quantify risk , and find that they decay much more slowly than cross - correlations between the returns .
the magnitude of the cross - correlations constitute `` bad news '' for international investment managers who may believe that risk is reduced by diversifying across countries .
we find that when a market shock is transmitted around the world , the risk decays very slowly .
we explain these time lag cross - correlations by introducing a global factor model ( gfm ) in which all index returns fluctuate in response to a single global factor . for each pair of individual time series of returns , the cross - correlations between returns ( or magnitudes )
can be modeled with the auto - correlations of the global factor returns ( or magnitudes ) .
we estimate the global factor using principal component analysis , which minimizes the variance of the residuals after removing the global trend . using random matrix theory ,
a significant fraction of the world index cross - correlations can be explained by the global factor , which supports the utility of the gfm .
we demonstrate applications of the gfm in forecasting risks at the world level , and in finding uncorrelated individual indices .
we find 10 indices are practically uncorrelated with the global factor and with the remainder of the world indices , which is relevant information for world managers in reducing their portfolio risk . finally , we argue that this general method can be applied to a wide range of phenomena in which time series are measured , ranging from seismology and physiology to atmospheric geophysics . |
the top - quark physics is one of the most important topics at a next generation linear collider . near and above the threshold of a top quark and anti - top quark ( @xmath11 )
, there will be about @xmath12 pairs produced per one @xmath13 of integrated luminosity .
thus a high luminosity linear collider may allow for a good determination @xcite of the top - quark mass ( @xmath14 ) , its total width , the strong coupling constant @xmath15 , and even new physics effects such as from a virtual higgs boson .
indeed , as the heaviest particle observed so far with a mass at the electroweak scale , the top quark may hold the key to new physics in the electroweak sector @xcite . without knowing the underlying dynamics beyond the standard model ( sm )
, it is appropriate to parameterize new physics effects at low energies by an effective lagrangian @xmath16 where @xmath17 is a cutoff scale above which new physics sets in , and @xmath18 is the sm lagrangian , @xmath19 the sm - gauge - invariant dimension - six operators . @xmath20
represent the coupling strengths of @xmath19 @xcite . in this paper
we study the possibility of probing for anomalous top - quark couplings @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath0 at next linear colliders . it has been shown in the literature that angular distribution in top - quark events at @xmath3 colliders bring useful information on the top - quark couplings , with which one can constrain its deviations from the sm @xcite . at @xmath3
colliders the top - quark pair is produced in a unique spin configuration , and the electroweak decay products of polarized top quark are strongly correlated to the spin axis .
parke and shadmi @xcite suggested several spin basis ( helicity , beamline and off - diagonal basis ) to discuss the @xmath11 spin correlation . on the other hand , deviations from the sm
may be observable via the top - quark spin correlations which depend sensitively on the couplings @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath0 .
the purpose of the current study is to explore which spin basis described in ref .
@xcite is more suitable for studying a given anomalous top - quark coupling than others .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2 ,
we briefly review on effective lagrangian and present explicitly the dimension-6 operators which describe the anomalous couplings @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath0 , then we examine the constraints on the coefficients of these operators . in section 3
, we present a detail calculation of the top - quark spin correlation , and finally section 4 is summary and conclusion .
in the linearly realized effective lagrangian @xcite , the anomalous top - quark couplings are described by higher dimensional operators .
recently the dimension - six operators involving the top quark and invariant under the sm gauge group were reclassified and some are analyzed in refs .
@xcite . here
we list all eleven dimension - six cp - even operators in refs .
@xcite which generate anomalous couplings of @xmath23 to the top quark beyond the sm interactions , [ operators ] o_q^(1 ) & = & i|q_l ^q_l , + o_q^(3)&=&i|q_l ^^i q_l , + o_db & = & ( |q_l d _
b_r ) d^ + ( d^)^(q_l ) , + o_bw & = & w^i _ , + o_qb & = & b _ , + o_qw & = & w^i _ , + o_t2 & = & i|t_r ^t_r , + o_dt & = & ( |q_l d _
t_r ) d^ + ( d^)^(q_l ) , + o_tb & = & b _ , + o_tw & = & w^i _ , + o_tb & = & b _ , where @xmath24 is the higgs doublet , @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 are pauli matrices . in eq.(2 ) , some of the operators induce energy - dependent couplings , some do not . if an anomalous coupling is function of energy , its effects on the physical quantity at different energy scale will be enhanced at high energy . in table
[ one ] we show explicitly the energy dependence of various couplings .
.the energy - dependence of dimension - six operators in eq .
( [ operators ] ) for couplings @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
an overall normalization @xmath32 has been factored out . [
cols="<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] now we present the experimental constraints on various operators .
the most direct bounds on these operators come from the measurement of the observables @xmath33 and @xmath34 at lep . updating the bounds in our previous paper ref .
@xcite and assuming no accidental cancellation happens between different operators , as is often assumed , we give the limits below on each of operators in eq .
( [ operators ] ) at the @xmath35 ( @xmath36 ) level as @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the vacuum expectation value of the higgs field .
one can see that the constraints on some of the operators listed in table [ one ] are relatively poor and there is room for possible new physics .
however if the operators are not independent for a given model , cancellations may happen among different contributions , therefore the bounds obtained from @xmath33 and @xmath34 may not be as restrictive @xcite .
operators @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 , are not constrained by @xmath33 at tree level . however , at one - loop level they contribute to gauge boson self - energies .
the authors of ref .
@xcite have considered these constraints and showed some rather loose bounds on them .
one can also put limits on various coefficients of the operators using the argument of partial wave unitarity .
the upper bounds are obtained for @xmath44 tev in ref .
@xcite @xmath45 and @xmath46 are very weak due to their small contributions to @xmath47 decay .
we study in this section the production and decay of top - quark pair in the presence of anomalous couplings and examine the different behavior of top - quark spin correlations in various spin bases .
we consider the top - quark pair production in @xmath3 collisions @xmath48 to make our discussion general we write the effective cp - even vertices of @xmath30 and @xmath31 as [ vtt ] _ vt^=ieq_tr^v^p_r + ieq_tl^v^p_l+ieq_t^v , where @xmath49 are the projection operators @xmath50 and @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the momenta of the outgoing top quark and top antiquark , respectively .
we have neglected the terms which contain @xmath53 by using the dirac equation for massless electrons . in terms of the gauge - invariant operators in eq .
( [ operators ] ) , the left(right)-handed couplings @xmath54 and the electroweak magnetic - moment couplings @xmath55 are [ ctt ] q_tr^&=&q_t ( 1- + ) , + q_tl^&=&q_t ( 1- + ) , + q_tr^z&=&q_t^r ( 1 + - + ) , + q_tl^z&=&q_t^l ( 1- - + & & + ) , + q_t^&=&- , + q_t^z&=&- + , where @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 , which are the sm couplings .
2 truein the discussion on the polarized top - quark production requires a definite spin basis . in the sm
, it is shown that the size of top - spin correlation for different spin bases are quite distinct @xcite . in the presence of anomalous couplings ,
we adopt the same notation of generic spin basis @xcite . a general spin axis @xmath62 for the top quark is defined by an angle @xmath63 ( clockwise ) in the @xmath64 rest - frame with respect to @xmath65 direction , as shown in fig . 1 .
the top antiquark spin axis can be defined with the same angle @xmath63 , but in the @xmath66 rest - frame with respect to @xmath67 direction .
for instance , a polarized state @xmath68 refers to a top quark with spin along @xmath69 and an anti - top quark with spin along @xmath70 . with this choice of spin basis ,
the tree level differential polarized cross sections are given in terms of the center - of - mass energy @xmath71 and top - quark speed @xmath72 as [ eett ] d(e_l^- e_r^+ t__)d & = & d(e_l^- e_r^+ t__)d + & = & ( ) |a_lr -b_lr-2f_t^l^2 |^2 , + d(e_l^- e_r^+ t__)d & = & d(e_l^- e_r^+ t__)d + & = & ( ) |a_lr + b_lrd_lr -2f_t^l^2 |^2 , where @xmath73 is the top scattering angle with respect to the @xmath74 beam and @xmath75 , and [ abd ] a_lr&=&[(f_ll+f_lr ) ] /2 , + b_lr&=&[f_ll(+ ) + f_lr(- ) ] /2 , + d_lr&=&[f_ll(1 + ) + f_lr(1-)]/2 , with [ ftt ] f_ij&=&q_e q_tj^+q_ei q_tj^z , i , j = r , l , + f_t^i&=&q_e q_t^+q_ei q_t^z , i = r , l .
similarly , one can obtain the differential cross sections for a different beam polarization @xmath76 by interchanging the labels @xmath77 and @xmath78 in eq .
( [ eett ] ) .
there are three typical bases charaterized by choosing a different angle @xmath63 as follows .
* helicity basis : for @xmath79 , the top - quark spin axis is against ( along ) its direction of motion .
* beamline basis : for @xmath80 , the top - quark spin is in the positron direction in the top rest - frame .
* off - diagonal basis : @xmath81 , where @xmath82 and @xmath83 represent the sm parts of @xmath84 and @xmath85 respectively in eq .
( [ abd ] ) .
although one can similarly define another off - diagonal basis for @xmath76 scattering , the considerably small difference between the two bases allows us to use the off - diagonal basis for @xmath86 even when discussing @xmath76 scattering @xcite . regarding the off - diagonal basis , parke and
collaborators have applied it to top - pair production at a linear and hadron colliders @xcite , and found many advantages in studying physics of the top quark .
it gives rise to substantial spin correlation than the helicity or beamline basis do @xcite .
for example , @xmath87 and @xmath88 are equal to zero for off - diagonal basis at the sm tree level and therefore all @xmath89 pairs are of opposite spins .
moreover , the dominant component up to 97% of the @xmath90 cross section is @xmath91 at the energy @xmath92 , much larger than 58% in the helicity basis @xcite .
furthermore , the top - pair production density matrix in the off - diagonal basis is greatly simplified due to many zero entries in the matrix @xcite . in the presence of anomalous couplings
, however , the situation may be different due to the very different helicity structures of the new operators .
thus we will consider all of the three bases in the following discussions in order to find out which basis is more sensitive to which class of operators .
of the eleven operators listed in eq .
( [ operators ] ) we will take two operators @xmath43 and @xmath93 for a detail study .
we choose these two operators for the following reasons .
first , they have distinctive energy - dependence as seen in table [ one ] , which characterizes a typical feature of anomalous couplings .
second , while the operator @xmath94 modifies @xmath95 and @xmath96 which affect the top - quark production , the operator @xmath93 modifies the top - quark decay as well .
in addition , these two operators have no direct effects on @xmath97 measurement , so their coefficients are not strongly constrained .
consequently , the top - quark production and decay would be the unique place to explore them if they generate sizeable effects at high energy experiments . numerically taking the conservative limits in eq .
( [ bound3 ] ) , we will adopt @xmath98 in our analysis .
[ c - s ] 6.2 truein we plot in fig . 2 the total cross section and various polarized cross sections of @xmath99 versus @xmath100 in the presence of operators @xmath43 and @xmath93 .
one can clearly see from the figure the effects of new physics .
however , the operator @xmath93 seems not to make any correction to @xmath101 .
this is due to the fact that the couplings of the right - handed electron with @xmath102 and @xmath103 are from @xmath104 gauge interaction , while @xmath93 are of purely @xmath105 interactions .
we have numerically verified the cancellation of @xmath93 between @xmath106 and @xmath107 contributions . in fig . 3 and fig . 4
, we plot the energy dependence of the fraction of top quark pair production in three different bases for @xmath43 and @xmath93 , respectively .
the fraction is defined by @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the polarized total cross section for the process @xmath110 including appropriate anomalous couplings . while the off - diagonal , beamline , and helicity bases present the most , medium , and least polarization of @xmath11 states , respectively , the percentage effects due to new operators are of reversed order , namely it is the most significant in the helicity basis instead .
the reason is as follows : the new physics effects come dominantly from the interference terms between the sm and anomalous couplings at the order of @xmath111 , and the pure contributions of the anomalous couplings set in at a higher order of @xmath112 .
since in the sm with the off - diagonal basis , the spin configuration is almost exclusively @xmath113 , the leading anomalous contribution coming from the interference is forced to be in the same unique configuration . on the other hand , the helicity basis presents a large partition between @xmath113 and @xmath114 , so that it allows a more significant effect in reshuffling these two configurations due to the existence of the anomalous operators , thus leading to possibly appreciable differences when comparing with the sm predictions .
we notice that because of the strong energy dependence of the couplings , the effects are generally larger at higher energies .
moreover , we also observed a particularly large deviation from the sm prediction for the operator @xmath43 in @xmath115 reaction near @xmath116 gev , see fig .
this is due to the corrections from the direct term which is proportion to @xmath117 . in the case
the interference term gives the negative contributions and the direct term gives the positive contributions , there should be a peak at some energy scale and this scale is decided by the size of @xmath118 and @xmath17 . for the parameter we selected i.e. @xmath119 , it appears at the energy of 850 gev . in fig . 5 and fig .
6 , we show the behavior of the fraction at @xmath120 as a function of the couplings @xmath43 and @xmath93 , respectively .
the sm prediction can be read off from the figures for the couplings to be zero .
the sign of the coupling @xmath43 may be inferred by different beam polarizaton choices .
for instance , consider a @xmath68 final state as in fig .
5 , a positive coupling gives significant enhancement to @xmath121 initial state and a negative coupling leads a reduction for @xmath115 initial state . given the discussion above , we conclude that the percentage corrections from anomalous couplings to the spin configuration in the off - diagonal basis are much smaller than that in the helicity basis for the polarized @xmath122 scattering .
the enhanced spin correlation in the sm is not necessarily beneficial in distinguishing contributions from anomalous couplings .
we now consider the process of top decay and examine the effects of anomalous couplings @xmath0 on the correlation coefficient .
in general the effective vertex of @xmath0 coupling can be written as [ coup ] _
twb^=i [ g_l^p_l + g_r^p_r + g_tb^l p_l + g_tb^r p_r ] , where @xmath51 and @xmath123 are the momenta of incoming top quark and outgoing bottom quark respectively and g_l&=&gv_tb-(2k^2 ) + + , + g_r&= & + , + g_tb^l&=&- - , + g_tb^r&=&- - .
note that the sm coupling is the first term in @xmath124 .
it is easy to see from eq .
( [ coup ] ) that the leading corrections to the top decay at order @xmath111 come from interference between the sm and terms in @xmath124 and terms in @xmath125 .
we will henceforth neglect effects from @xmath126 and @xmath127 which are suppressed by @xmath112 . using the narrow width approximation for the @xmath128 boson ( k^2-m^2 ) , we express the polarized differential top - decay width for @xmath129 as [ width ] = ( 1-|y)^2(1 + 2|y)(1 + ) ( 1_d ) +
+ o ( ) , where @xmath130 and @xmath131 is the angle between the momentum direction of the lepton or down - type light quark and the top - spin axis in the top - quark rest - frame . here
, we neglect all fermion mass except top quark . the polarized differential decay rate in the sm is conveniently parameterized as [ rate ] = where @xmath132 , @xmath133 ( lepton or down - type light quark ) or @xmath134 ( neutrino or up - type light quark ) .
the correlation coefficients @xmath135 are @xmath136 and @xmath137 for @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath138 , respectively @xcite . comparing eq .
( [ width ] ) with eq .
( [ rate ] ) , we find that the anomalous couplings do not give corrections to the correlation coefficient @xmath139 up to @xmath140 . since all spin bases are defined in the process of top production , the angular distributions of different decay products give same relationship of different spin bases .
therefore we select the angle distribution between the momentum direction of the lepton or down - type light quark and the top - spin axis at top rest frame , whose correlation coefficient @xmath139 is lagest
. we will show in the next subsection that this selection is advantageous for us to define observables with large value .
we have also recalculated the top - decay width in the presence of the anomalous coupling , which is shown in table [ two ] .
we find the corrections may be as large as @xmath141 .
it would be very interesting to determine the top width or individual branching fractions to this level of accuracy .
ll to1.88exto18.80ex & to1.88exto15.60ex@xmath142 [ gev ] + to1.88exto18.80exsm ( @xmath143 ) & to1.88exto15.60ex0.178 + to1.88exto18.80ex@xmath144 & to1.88exto15.60ex0.177 + to1.88exto18.80ex@xmath145 & to1.88exto15.60ex0.180 + to1.88exto18.80ex@xmath146 & to1.88exto15.60ex0.188 + to1.88exto18.80ex@xmath147 & to1.88exto15.60ex0.169 + to1.88exto18.80ex@xmath148 & to1.88exto15.60ex0.177 + to1.88exto18.80ex@xmath149 & to1.88exto15.60ex0.179 + since we need the construction of the full event kinematics for @xmath11 decays , the dileptonic decay mode would be difficult to make use of due to the two missing neutrinos . although the identification of six - jet events in the pure hardonic decay mode should be viable , it would be impossible to sort out quarks from anti - quarks in the four light jets .
the semileptonic mode becomes the unique channel for the study of top - spin correlations .
we consider the case where one lepton with positive charge comes from top - quark decay while two partons come from top antiquark decay . to obtain the differential cross section of @xmath150
, the production and decay spin density matrix are always used as the usual approach in the approximation of narrow widths for top quark and @xmath128 boson @xcite . after integrating over all azimuthal angles ,
one gets the double differential rate as = ( 1+s_t_|l_|l + s__d_d
+ s_t s__|l_d _ |l_d ) where @xmath151 ( @xmath133 ) is the decay product of top quark ( top antiquark ) and @xmath152 ( @xmath153 ) is the angle defined in eq ( [ width ] ) .
@xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath156 are @xmath64 , @xmath157 and @xmath89 correlation functions , respectively .
they can be expressed as s_t&= & _ i , j = l , r ( r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) + r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) -r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) -r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) ) , + s_&= & _ i , j = l , r ( r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) -r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) + r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) -r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) ) , + s_t s_&= & _ i , j = l , r ( r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) -r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) -r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) + r(e_i^- e_j^+ t _ _ ) ) .
r(e_i^- e_j^+ t_s_t _ s _ ) = , i , j = l , r and s_t , s_= ,
. here , @xmath158 are the polarized cross section in top - pair production which could be obtained by integrating over @xmath159 in eq .
( [ eett ] ) .
@xmath160 is the total cross section of @xmath161 . integrating over @xmath153 ,
one obtains = ( 1 + _
|l ) , where the effective correlation coefficient @xmath162 is given by [ ls ] _ |l^s = s_t_|l .
such effective spin correlation corresponds to the top - quark spin asymmetry which is some observable and can be derived as a_s= = .
similarly , we integrate over @xmath153 in the region of 0<_d<1 and obtain .
_ _ d>0 ( 1 + _ |l^ss _
|l ) , where [ lss ] _ |l^ss= _ |l .
this effective correlation coefficient corresponds to the spin - spin asymmetry which is defined as a_ss= = . even though distinction of the down - type quark and the up - type quark in the final decay state is impossible , we can at least hope to measure @xmath163 by a statistical method @xcite .
( [ ls ] ) and ( [ lss ] ) are generically valid for other decay product .
one can simply replace @xmath164 by @xmath165 , where @xmath166 denotes any decay product .
therefore , the observables @xmath167 and @xmath163 are proportional to the correlations coefficient @xmath165 and we choose the largest value @xmath168 .
the spin asymmetry @xmath167 and spin - spin asymmetry @xmath163 are shown versus @xmath71 for @xmath43 in the case of right - hand polarized electron beam in fig . 7 , and for @xmath93 in the case of left - hand polarized electron beam in fig . 8 .
with the analysis in the last two subsections , it is not surprising to see that the corrections to @xmath167 and @xmath163 are the most significant in the helicity basis for @xmath43 and @xmath93 . for the left - hand polarized electron beam
, the top quark with up - spin is the dominant configuration and for the right - hand polarized electron beam the dominant one is that with down - spin . due to the cancellation between different polarized beams
, there is no unique basis which is optimal for searching new physics . in fig . 9 and fig . 10
, we show the spin asymmetry @xmath167 and spin - spin asymmetry @xmath163 versus @xmath71 for @xmath43 and @xmath93 in the case of unpolarized beam .
the corrections to @xmath167 and @xmath163 are the most significant in the helicity basis for @xmath43 and in the off - diagonal basis for @xmath93 , related to the chirality structure of the operators .
we took an effective lagrangian approach to new physics in the top - quark sector and discussed the anomalous - coupling effects on the spin correlation in top - quark pair production and decay . in the framework of the generic spin basis proposed by parke and collaborators , we performed detail calculations of spin correlations , spin asymmetry and spin - spin asymmetry for three different bases .
we found that the helicity basis is the best for polarized beam , and for unpolarized beam the optimal choice of the spin basis depends on the specific form of the new physics .
specifically the helicity basis will be the best choice in probing for new physics associated with @xmath104 type operators such as @xmath43 , while the off - diagonal basis appears to be more suitable for @xmath105 type operators such as @xmath93 .
: we thank e.l .
berger , k. hagiwara , s. parke and j .- m .
yang for discussions .
t. huang , z .- h .
lin and x. zhang were supported in part by the nsf of china .
t. han was supported in part by a us doe grant no .
de - fg02 - 95er40896 and by wisconsin alumni research foundation . c. j. c. burgess and h. j. schnitzer , nucl
. phys . * b228 * , 454 ( 1983 ) ; c. n. leung , s. t. love and s. rao , z. phys .
* c31 * , 433 ( 1986 ) ; w. buchmuller and d. wyler , nucl . phys . *
b268 * , 621 ( 1986 ) ; k. hagiwara , s. ishihara , r. szalapski and d. zeppenfeld , phys . rev . *
d48 * , 2182 ( 1993 ) .
d. atwood and a. soni , phys . rev . * d45 * , 2405 ( 1992 ) ; d. atwood , a. aeppli and a. soni , phys . rev .
lett * 69 * , 2754 ( 1992 ) ; d. atwood , s. bar - shalom , g. eilam and a. soni , phys . rept . * 347 * , 1 ( 2001 ) ; b. holdom and t. torma , phys . rev .
* d60 * , 114010 ( 1999 ) ; t. torma , hep - ph/9912281 ; s.m .
lietti and h. murayama , phys .
* d62 * , 074003 ( 2000 ) ; e. boos , m. dubinin , m. sachwitz , h.j .
schreiber , eur .
j. * c16 * , 269 ( 2000 ) ; s.d .
rindani , hep - ph/0002006 ; b. grzadkowski and z. hioki , hep - ph/0003294 ; z. hioki , hep - ph/0104105 ; s.d .
rindani , hep - ph/0105318 . | we investigate the feasibility of probing anomalous top - quark couplings of @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 in terms of an effective lagrangian with dimension - six operators at future @xmath3 linear colliders with a c. m. energy @xmath4 gev .
we first examine the constraints on these anomalous couplings from the @xmath5 data at lep i and from unitarity considerations .
we then consider in detail the effects of anomalous couplings on @xmath6 spin correlations in the top - pair production and decay with three spin bases : the helicity , beamline and off - diagonal bases .
our results show that the polarized beams are more suitable for exploring the effects of different new operators . for polarized beams ,
the helicity basis yields the best sensitivity .
-0.5 in 6.5 in 8.50 in -0.5 in [ 1]0= 0=0
1= 1=1 0>1 # 1 / / # 1#20.7ex # 1@xmath7 # 1@xmath8 # 1 # 1 # 1[#1 ] [ appendixc ] [ subappendixc ] * top - quark spin correlation at linear colliders + with anomalous couplings * + .3 cm @xmath9institute of high energy physics , academia sinica , + beijing , 100039 , p. r. china , + @xmath10department of physics , university of wisconsin , madison , wi 53706 , usa + .3 in |
in strong gravitational lensing of quasars , the separations between multiple images , @xmath5 , is the most important observable linking observations to theory .
since the image separation is determined by the potential depth of the lens , the image separation distribution of lensed quasars offers a direct probe of the hierarchical structure of the universe .
for instance , normal galaxies can produce strongly lensed quasars with image separations of @xmath6 , while lenses with image separation @xmath7 can only be caused by clusters of galaxies .
about 70 of @xmath6 lenses are known to date , and there is one example of a lensed quasar system in which the lens potential is dominated by that of dark matter @xcite .
among gravitationally lensed quasars , those with intermediate image separations ( @xmath8 ) are of great interest because they represent a link between small- and large - separation lenses . in the standard modeling procedure used to predict the distribution of image separations , assuming isothermal profiles and an a priori velocity function of galaxies , lenses with image separations @xmath9 are very rare , because even the largest early type galaxies do not have einstein radii this large .
thus the probability for @xmath10 lensing is almost negligible .
however , while q0957 + 561 ( @xmath11 ; * ? ? ?
* ) is primarily lensed by a galaxy , the image separation is boosted by the cluster in which the lensing galaxy resides .
this example implies that the environment of the lens galaxy may significantly affect the distribution of image separations in the @xmath12 range @xcite .
in addition , a secondary mass along the line of sight could affect strong lensing @xcite , and this also may enhance the lensing probabilities in this image separation range .
finally , there is a predicted contribution in this range from clusters ; simple theoretical models that include transition of the property of lenses at @xmath13 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) predict that large - separation lenses due to clusters begin to dominate the total lensing probability .
therefore , the overall lensing probability distribution for @xmath14 is predicted to depend on the interplay of these two effects ; the environmental effects and the emergence of cluster lenses .
however , the overall lensing probability at @xmath14 is quite small , thus a large number of quasars is needed to investigate the lensing probability distribution . indeed ,
even the current largest homogeneous sample of lensed quasars @xcite contains only one lens in this image separation range . in this paper
, we present the discovery of two @xmath15 gravitationally lensed quasars , sdss j100128.61 + 502756.9 ( hereafter sdss j1001 + 5027 ) and sdss sdss j120629.65 + 433217.6 ( hereafter sdss j1206 + 4332 ) .
these gravitational lenses were identified from an ongoing lens search using the data of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . currently the sdss contains more than 50,000 spectroscopically classified quasars ; thus the sdss provides the opportunity to construct the largest homogeneous lens catalog in existence .
indeed , @xmath16 new gravitationally lensed quasars have been found by using the sdss ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . in this paper
, we describe photometric and spectroscopic observations of two new lens candidates and show that they are gravitational lenses .
we model the lens systems and discuss the environments of the lens galaxies .
we also compare the image separation distributions of lensed quasars in the sdss ( though still very preliminary because of the limited statistics ) with a simple theoretical model .
this paper is organized as follows . in [ sec : sdss ] , we briefly describe our method of searching for lens candidates from the sdss data .
section [ sec : obs ] presents the results of both photometric and spectroscopic follow - up observations , and [ sec : model ] shows the result of lens modeling .
section [ sec : env ] is devoted to a discussion of the environments of the lens galaxies .
we also discuss the lensing probability distribution , which is shown in
[ sec : stat ] .
we summarize our results in [ sec : sum ] .
all gravitational lenses presented in this paper were selected as lens candidates from the sdss , which is a survey to image @xmath17 of the sky .
the sdss also conducts spectroscopy of galaxies and quasars that are selected from the imaging data @xcite .
a dedicated 2.5-meter telescope at apache point observatory ( apo ) is equipped with a multi - ccd camera @xcite with five optical broad bands centered at @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 @xcite .
the imaging data are automatically reduced by the photometric pipeline @xcite .
the astrometric positions are accurate to about @xmath23 for sources brighter than @xmath24 @xcite , and the photometric errors are typically less than 0.03 magnitude @xcite .
the spectra cover @xmath25@xmath26 at a resolution of @xmath27@xmath28 .
we use spectroscopically classified quasars with @xmath29 to search for gravitational lens candidates .
sdss j1001 + 5027 and
sdss j1206 + 4332 are identified as lens candidates by our standard candidate selection algorithm ( n. inada et al .
, in preparation ) .
this algorithm is based on the idea that the image of a quasar pair with a small separation appears to be more extended than that of single quasar , and characterizes the extent by the following sdss image parameters : dev_l ( the likelihood that the image of the object is fit by a de vaucouleurs profile ) , exp_l ( the likelihood by an exponential disk ) , and star_l ( the likelihood by the point spread function ) .
this algorithm has already found six new sdss lenses @xcite as well as all previously known gravitational lenses in the sdss footprint .
however , the possible second lensed components of the candidates we study in this paper were also recognized as separate astronomical objects in the sdss imaging data because of the relatively large image separations @xcite .
figure [ fig : sdss ] shows the sdss @xmath30-band images of the candidates . in both images , the seeing was @xmath31 , better than the typical seeing of sdss images , @xmath32 @xcite .
the figure clearly shows two stellar components in each case ; we designate the brighter ones as component a and the fainter ones as component b. table [ table : sdss ] summarizes the result of the sdss photometry of the components . in each system
the components have colors similar to each other and the colors are consistent with that expected from quasars ; this makes them excellent lens candidates .
follow - up spectroscopic observations were conducted on 2003 november 20 and 2004 june 21 with the double imaging spectrograph ( dis ) on the astrophysical research consortium ( arc ) 3.5-m telescope at apo .
we used a @xmath33 slit in low ( blue ) or medium ( red ) resolution mode .
the resolution is about @xmath34 .
the final spectra cover the wavelength range of 3900 to 9400 .
we aligned the slit along the direction joining the two images ; since the separations between the images are large compared with the seeing size , extraction of the spectrum of each component was straightforward .
the data were reduced using standard iraf reduction procedures .
we also obtained deep images of the systems with the 8k mosaic ccd camera of the university of hawaii 2.2-meter telescope ( uh88 ) at mauna kea and with the seaver prototype imaging camera ( spicam ) of the arc 3.5-m telescope .
the uh88 imaging was conducted on 2004 may 23 and 25 .
we obtained @xmath35-band images in the photometric nights ; the exposure times were 360 seconds for each candidate and each band .
the image scale was @xmath36 @xmath37 .
we estimated the seeing as @xmath38 , better than the sdss seeing size of @xmath39 .
the arc @xmath40-band imaging was conducted on 2004 january 13 .
the exposure was 300 seconds , the seeing was @xmath41 , and the image scale was @xmath42 @xmath37 .
each frame was bias - subtracted and flat - field corrected .
the magnitudes in the uh88 images were calibrated by the standard star pg 1528 + 062 @xcite .
astrometry and photometry of the uh88 images are summarized in table [ table : uh88 ] .
spectra and images of this object are shown in figures [ fig : spec1001 ] and [ fig : uh_1001 ] , respectively . in figure
[ fig : spec1001 ] , both components show , , and emission lines redshifted by @xmath43 .
it is worth noting that the flux ratios ( b / a ) of the emission lines , particularly the emission lines , are larger than that of the continuum ; the equivalent widths of emission lines are 56 and 76 for a and b , respectively
. such difference can be caused by the difference of the emission regions of continuum and broad emission lines combined with microlensing by stars .
we find two extended objects near the quasar images ( see figure [ fig : uh_1001 ] ; the image separation is @xmath2 ) .
when subtracting a quasar component , we used a nearby star as a point - spread function ( psf ) template .
the objects , denoted by g1 and g2 , have colors consistent with those of early - type galaxies at @xmath44 @xcite .
since galaxy g1 is nearly colinear with the two quasar components , it is likely that g1 is the main contributor to the lens potential .
however , galaxy g2 is also quite close to the lens system , and could affect the lens potential significantly .
we note that component b could be reddened by the lens galaxy g1 .
the spectra of the two components shown in figure [ fig : spec1206 ] show , , , and emission lines at the same wavelengths , which supports the idea that this is a gravitationally lensed quasar at @xmath45 .
however , the flux ratios ( b / a ) of the emission lines are slightly smaller than that of the continuum ; the equivalent widths of emission lines are 69 and 53 for a and b , respectively .
the images in figure [ fig : uh_1206 ] clearly reveal the lensing galaxy g1 as well as two quasar components separated by @xmath3 , further supporting the lensing hypothesis . we also found other galaxies g2 and g3 near component b. these galaxies , particularly g2 , may contribute to the lens potential to some extent . indeed
, both g1 and g2 are quite red ( see table [ table : uh88 ] ) and are consistent with being high - redshift ( @xmath46 ) early - type galaxies @xcite , while g3 is blue and thus may be a chance superposition of a local galaxy .
there is strong absorption ( equivalent width @xmath47 ) at @xmath48 in the spectrum of component b. the redshift of the absorber is @xmath49 , consistent with the color of g1 .
therefore the absorber may be associated with the lensing galaxy g1 .
although the lens systems appear quite complex , we will first attempt to model the lens systems with simple models . specifically
, we try models that describe g1 by a singular isothermal ellipsoid ( sie ) , or singular isothermal sphere ( sis ) plus external shear .
even these simple models , however , have eight parameters ( the galaxy position @xmath50 and @xmath51 , the einstein ring radius @xmath52 , the ellipticity @xmath53 or shear @xmath54 , the position angle @xmath55 or @xmath56 , the source position @xmath57 and @xmath58 , and the flux of the quasar @xmath59 ) that is equal to the number of observational constraints from the uh88 imaging data ( the image positions , the galaxy position , and fluxes of the images ; see table [ table : uh88 ] ) .
thus there are no degrees of freedom and in usual cases we will be able to find models that perfectly reproduce the observables . to fit the models , we use standard lens modeling techniques as implemented in the _ lensmodel _ software @xcite . sdss j1001 + 5027
is well fitted by both the sis plus shear and sie models .
the resulting fitting parameters are shown in table [ table : model ] .
the ellipticity @xmath60 in the sie model is similar to that of the light , though the position angle @xmath61 ( measured east of north ) is quite different from that of the light ( @xmath62 ) measured from the uh88 image . in general the position angles of the light and lens models are aligned @xcite ; therefore this result suggests that the external field , rather than the galaxy g1 , is responsible for the quadrupole moment of the lens potential .
the position angles in the models are rather close to the direction to g2 .
since in general the position angle of external shear gives an idea of the direction to a main perturber , it seems that g2 significantly affects the lens models .
we also predict the time delay as @xmath63 ( a leads b ) , assuming a lens redshift of @xmath64 . fitting sdss j1206 + 4332 by either sis plus shear or sie failed ; the models yielded large chi - squares @xmath65 with no degrees of freedom , and the models required unnaturally large @xmath53 or @xmath54 .
we also tried a sie plus shear model , but the resulting fit was similarly poor .
this implies that the lens system is too complicated to be described by such simple models .
thus we add g2 , which is modeled by a sis , as well as galaxy g1 modeled by sie , in order to make the model more realistic .
we derive best - fit models by changing the value of the einstein radius of g2 , @xmath52(g2 ) .
we find that this `` sie@xmath66g2 '' model fits the data well when @xmath67 , although the maximum value is slightly smaller than that inferred from the faber - jackson relation ( @xmath68 from the @xmath69-band flux ratio , assuming g1 and g2 are at the same redshift ) . as a specific example
, we show the best fit parameters for @xmath70 in table [ table : model ] .
the position angle of galaxy g1 in the model ( @xmath71 ) is in good agreement with that observed .
the time delay is derived to be @xmath72 ( a leads b ) , assuming the strong absorption system at @xmath49 is associated with the lens galaxy . even if we decrease the value of @xmath52(g2 ) up to @xmath23 ,
the time delay is affected only moderately ; the time delay is predicted to be @xmath73 when @xmath74 . in summary
, lens modeling has revealed that neither system is simple . in particular , the secondary galaxies may play an important role in both lenses .
lens galaxies of lensed quasars , particularly in systems with relatively large image separations ( @xmath9 ) , commonly lie in groups or clusters @xcite .
such `` compound '' lens systems include q 0957 + 561 @xcite , pg 1115 + 080 @xcite , mg 2016 + 112 @xcite , rx j0911 + 0551 @xcite , mg 0751 + 2716 @xcite , sdss j0903 + 5028 @xcite , class b1608 + 656 @xcite , b2108 + 213 @xcite , and he
0435 - 1223 @xcite .
if dense environments of the lens galaxies are common , then they could affect strong lens studies in several ways @xcite .
on the theoretical side , estimation of environmental effects remains controversial : while @xcite and @xcite argued that the large fraction of lens systems should lie in dense environments and thus the environmental effects are significant , @xcite estimated using a halo occupation distribution that the typical values for the external convergence and shear are quite small .
although we have already seen in
[ sec : obs ] and [ sec : model ] that sdss j1001 + 5027 and sdss j1206 + 4332 have additional galaxies that likely affect the lens potential , it is important to check the larger field for hints of groups or clusters .
figure [ fig : fields ] shows the fields around the lens systems obtained at uh88 .
we find many galaxies around sdss j1001 + 5027 , indicating that there may be a group or cluster along the line of sight . for sdss j1206 + 4332
, we can not see any noticeable enhancement of the number of galaxies around the lens system , though there are several faint galaxies near the lens system . to explore the environments further , we derived the number densities of galaxies around each lens system using the uh88 images .
we perform object identifications using the source extractor algorithm ( sextractor ; * ? ? ?
we define galaxies as objects with sextractor parameter class_star smaller than 0.6 in the @xmath75 band image .
note that this star / galaxy separation criterion is successful only for objects with @xmath76 .
we derive the number densities of galaxies as a function of @xmath75-band magnitudes of the galaxies , which are shown in figure [ fig : count ] . in the figure
, we compare the galaxy number densities within @xmath77 of each lens system with those of the background , estimated from galaxies more than @xmath77 away in each image after excluding the region near bright stars .
the total areas of the backgrounds are thus 87.0 @xmath78 and 79.8 @xmath78 for sdss j1001 + 5027 and sdss j1206 + 4332 , respectively .
we find an enhancement of galaxy number densities for sdss j1001 + 5027 ; the number densities of three magnitude bins show excesses by more than @xmath79 . on the other hand , the galaxy number count around sdss j1226 + 4332 is consistent with that of the background .
figure [ fig : colmag ] shows a color - magnitude diagram of galaxies near sdss j1001 + 5027 to study the origin of the enhancement of galaxy number densities .
we find a weak ridge line at @xmath80 , suggesting the existence of a group or a cluster at @xmath81 , which is consistent with that of lens galaxies g1 and g2 estimated from their colors .
we also plot the distribution of galaxies at @xmath82 , by making color cuts ; @xmath83 , @xmath84 , and @xmath85 .
we find that the galaxies are clustered north and west of the lens system , rather than distributed homogeneously ( see also figure [ fig : fields ] ) .
thus the lens galaxy may lie in a group or a cluster that is located to the north - west of the lens ; spectroscopic identifications of these galaxies as well as the lens galaxy should be undertaken .
thus far , 13 gravitationally lensed quasars have been discovered using the sdss .
in addition , we have recovered several previously known lensed quasar systems . table [ table : lens ] summarizes the current status of our lens search in the sdss .
note that limitations of follow - up time have forced us to focus on the sdss spectroscopic sample of quasars .
thus the list does not contain lenses that do not have sdss spectra ( e.g. , apm 08279 + 5255 ; see * ? ? ?
. the table does not contain sdss j1402 + 6321 @xcite either , since the redshift ( @xmath86 ) is below our criterion for the quasar sample ( see discussion below ) . among gravitational lenses in the table , sdss j1004 + 4112 and q 0957 + 561 were selected by searching around each quasar for stellar objects that have similar colors as the quasar itself @xcite , and the rest were successfully selected by our standard candidate selection algorithm ( see [ sec : sdss ] ) though the first identifications of some of the candidates were made by different algorithms .
an exception is sdss j0903 + 5028 @xcite which was targeted as a luminous red galaxy @xcite because of the bright lens galaxy ; however , we include this system in the statistical analysis below , since the quasar would have been targeted as a high - redshift quasar if it had not been obscured by the foreground lens galaxy @xcite .
the table shows that we have discovered a relatively large number of @xmath15 lenses .
we note that our current lens sample shown in table [ table : lens ] is quite incomplete because of poor seeing in many follow - up observations .
this mostly explains the large discrepancy between theory and observation at the image separation range .
] , and that future follow - up observations would increase the number of lenses even in the current quasar sample . therefore we now calculate the expected lensing probability in the sdss quasar sample and compare it with the number of @xmath15 lenses in the sample .
in particular , we neglect the contribution of lens galaxy environments , as has normally been done , to see whether the assumption is still valid or not . in computing the lensing probability ,
we assume a spatially flat universe ( @xmath87 ) . we compute the lensing probability distribution along the lines described by @xcite .
the lens galaxies are modeled by sis @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the velocity dispersion of the lens galaxy .
we adopt the velocity function of early - type galaxies determined from @xmath90 sdss galaxies at @xmath91 @xcite , and neglect the redshift evolution ( i.e. , we assume that the velocity function is constant in comoving units ) .
the use of the velocity function of early - type galaxies is sufficient for our calculation because at @xmath14 lensing by early - type galaxies is dominant @xcite .
we need also to incorporate the selection function of the sdss lens search ; which we do in a preliminary way by making the following assumptions .
first , we use the magnification factor of the brighter image , @xmath92 , where @xmath93 is the einstein radius and @xmath94 is the position of the source relative to the lens galaxy , to compute the magnification bias , because at @xmath14 two lensed components are well separated in the sdss data .
although we may have an alternative choice of using the magnification factor of the fainter image , we adopt @xmath95 to calculate the upper limit of the lensing probability ; thus the actual lensing rate at @xmath14 might be smaller than our calculation ) our computation is expected to underestimate the lensing probability because at such small separations lensed components are not decomposed and thus the magnification factor of the two images @xmath96 is more appropriate . ] .
next , for the limiting bright - to - faint flux ratio we assume @xmath97 ; this is justified because all lenses in table [ table : lens ] satisfy this condition . lensing probabilities calculated with this selection function represent an upper limit at relatively large image separation @xmath98 . to calculate the expected number of lensed quasars in the current sdss quasar sample
, we need the luminosity function of quasars as well as the redshift and magnitude distributions of the quasar sample .
we adopt a sample of @xmath99 quasars at @xmath100 .
the sample is constructed in the same way as in @xcite .
we did not search for lensed quasars at @xmath101 as low - redshift quasars are intrinsically extended , and we do not use high - redshift quasar ( @xmath102 ) sample because it contains a significant fraction of objects whose spectra were misidentified by the sdss spectroscopic pipeline ( c.f . ,
discussion in * ? ? ?
the redshift distribution is similar to that shown in @xcite . for the luminosity function of quasars
, we use what is called lf1 in @xcite , which has a faint end slope of @xmath103 and a bright end slope of @xmath104 ( @xmath105 ) or @xmath106 ( @xmath107 ) .
the result is shown in figure [ fig : sepdist ] .
as seen , the number of @xmath15 lenses already exceeds the theoretical expectations , when we adopt the standard value of the cosmological constant , @xmath108 .
the situation is similar if we increase @xmath109 to @xmath110 . in terms of the constraint on the cosmological constant ,
the excess in the bin centered at @xmath111 is described as @xmath112 ( 68% confidence limit ) assuming a poisson distribution , which is highly inconsistent with recent measurements of the cosmological constant @xmath113 with errors of less than 10% ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
we emphasis that our current lens sample is quite incomplete ; indeed , currently we have several @xmath15 quasar pairs with the same redshifts which could also be gravitational lenses @xcite , which need deep imaging to find the putative lens galaxies .
thus observations of these quasar pairs as well as lens candidates should be conducted , which might make the discrepancy even larger .
such an excess may indicate that our simple treatment of lensing statistics is inaccurate and that we need to include other effects .
we report the discovery of two gravitationally lensed quasars , sdss j1001 + 5027 and sdss j1206 + 4332 .
the systems were identified as new lens candidates in the sdss , and confirmed as lenses by spectroscopic and imaging observations at the arc 3.5 m and the uh88 telescope .
sdss j1001 + 5027 is a lensed quasar at @xmath43 , and consists of two lensed images separated by @xmath2 .
sdss j1206 + 4332 is a lensed quasar at @xmath45 , and consists of two lensed images separated by @xmath3 . in each system
we have identified the galaxy responsible for the lensing .
we have found that the lens systems are complicated .
the imaging data clearly show other galaxies that are very close to the main lens galaxies . the lens modeling has shown that these galaxies affect the lens potentials significantly .
we have examined the wide field images , which show an enhancement of the galaxy number density within @xmath77 of sdss j1001 + 5027 .
spectroscopic follow - up observations are needed to see if the group / cluster ( @xmath81 ) is actually associated with the lens galaxy .
although the sdss lens survey is ongoing , we have made a preliminary comparison of theoretical lensing probability distributions with the observed distribution .
we have found that the number of lenses with @xmath98 already exceeds the theoretical expectations .
we still have many lens candidates with @xmath14 that remain to be observed @xcite ; if some of them turn out to be true gravitational lenses , the conflict will become even stronger .
this excess may be caused by external convergence and shear fields which we have not taken into account in our calculation .
basically , external shear broadens the distribution of image separations for a given mass of a lens object ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
this broadening is enough to enhance the lensing probability at @xmath14 because the lensing probability at the image separation region is a strong function of image separations .
more significant enhancement may be achieved by external convergence , since it increases both image separation and lensing probability .
indeed , among five intermediate - separation lenses in table [ table : lens ] , two lens systems ( rx j0911 + 0551 and q 0957 + 561 ) lie in clusters , and two other lens systems ( sdss j0903 + 5028 and sdss j1001 + 5027 ) also appear to lie in dense environments .
in addition , the two lens systems reported in this paper are complex in the sense that galaxies very close to the main lens galaxies affect the lens potentials .
other possible systematic effects include triaxiality of lenses @xcite and massive substructures @xcite . in either case ,
lens statistics at this image separation should be done with caution ; simple models that consider only isolated single lens objects can be misleading . we thank paul schechter for useful comments , and anonymous referee for many suggestions .
m. o. and n. i. are supported by jsps through jsps research fellowship for young scientists .
j. f. h is currently supported by nasa through hubble fellowship grant # 01172.01-a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 . funding for the creation and distribution of the sdss archive has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national aeronautics and space administration , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the japanese monbukagakusho , and the max planck society .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium ( arc ) for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the university of chicago , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , the johns hopkins university , the korean scientist group , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , university of pittsburgh , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington .
this work is based on observations obtained with the apache point observatory 3.5-meter telescope , which is owned and operated by the astrophysical research consortium , and with the university of hawaii 2.2-meter telescope .
= -1pt abazajian , k. , et al .
2003 , , 126 , 2081 abazajian , k. , et al .
2004 , , 128 , 502 abazajian , k. , et al .
2005 , , in press ( astro - ph/0410239 ) bade , n. , siebert , j. , lopez , s. , voges , w. , & reimers , d. 1997 , , 317 , l13 bernardi , m. , et al . 2005 , in preparation bertin , e. , & arnouts , s. 1996 , , 117 , 393 blanton , m. r. , lin , h. , lupton , r. h. , maley , f. m. , young , n. , zehavi , i. , & loveday , j. 2003 , , 125 , 2276 bolton , a. s. , burles , s. , koopmans , l. v. e. , treu , t. , & moustakas , l. a. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0410425 ) browne , i. w. a. , et al .
2003 , , 341 , 13 burles , s. , et al .
2005 , in preparation cohn , j. d. , & kochanek , c. s. 2004 , , 608 , 25 dalal , n. , & watson , c. r. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0409483 ) eisenstein , d. j. , et al .
2001 , , 122 , 2267 fassnacht , c. , et al .
2004 , in proceedings of iau symposium 225 `` impact of gravitational lensing on cosmology '' , eds .
y. mellier and g. meylan , in press ( astro - ph/0409086 ) faure , c. , alloin , d. , kneib , j .-
p . , & courbin , f. 2004 , astro - ph/0405521 fukugita , m. , ichikawa , t. , gunn , j. e. , doi , m. , shimasaku , k. , & schneider , d. p. 1996
, , 111 , 1748 fukugita , m. , shimasaku , k. , & ichikawa , t. 1995 , , 107 , 945 gunn , j. e. , et al .
1998 , , 116 , 3040 hennawi , j. f. , 2004 , phd thesis , princeton university hogg , d. w. , finkbeiner , d. p. , schlegel , d. j. , & gunn , j. e. 2001 , , 122 , 2129 holder , g. p. , & schechter , p. l. 2003 , , 589 , 688 huterer , d. , keeton , c. , & ma , c. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0405040 ) inada , n. , et al .
2003a , , 126 , 666 inada , n. , et al . 2003b , , 426 , 810 inada , n. , et al .
2005a , , submitted inada , n. , et al .
2005b , , submitted ivezi , .
, et al . 2004 , an , 325 , 583 johnston , d. e. , et al . 2003 ,
, 126 , 2281 keeton , c. r. 2001 , preprint ( astro - ph/0102340 ) keeton , c. r. , christlein , d. , & zabludoff , a. i. 2000 , , 545 , 129 keeton , c. r. , kochanek , c. s. , & falco , e. e. 1998 , , 509 , 561 keeton , c. r. , & zabludoff , a. i. 2004 , , 612 , 660 landolt , a. u. 1992 , , 104 , 340 lawrence , c. r. , schneider , d. p. , schmidt , m. , bennett , c. l. , hewitt , j. n. , burke , b. f. , turner , e. l. , & gunn , j. e. 1984 , science , 223 , 46 lupton , r. , gunn , j. e. , ivezi , z. , knapp , g. r. , kent , s. , & yasuda , n. 2001 , in asp conf .
238 , astronomical data analysis software and systems x , ed .
f. r. harnden , jr . , f. a. primini , and h. e. payne ( san
francisco : astr .
pac . ) , p. 269
( astro - ph/0101420 ) martel , h. , premadi , p. , & matzner , r. 2002 , , 570 , 17 mckean , j. p. , et al .
2005 , , in press ( astro - ph/0410554 ) mitchell , j. l. , keeton , c. r. , frieman , j. a , & sheth , r. k. 2005 , , in press ( astro - ph/0401138 ) morgan , n. d. , snyder , j. a. , & reens , l. h. 2003 , , 126 , 2145 morgan , n. d. , kochanek , c. s. , pevunova , o. , & schechter , p. l. 2005 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0410614 ) myers , s. t. , et al .
2003 , , 341 , 1 oguri , m. 2002 , , 580 , 2 oguri , m. , et al . 2004a , , 605 , 78 oguri , m. , et al .
2004b , , 56 , 399 oguri , m. , & keeton , c. r. 2004 , , 610 , 663 oscoz , a. , serra - ricart , m. , mediavilla , e. , buitrago , j. , & goicoechea , l. j. 1997 , , 491 , l7 pier , j. r. , munn , j. a. , hindsley , r. b. , hennessy , g. s. , kent , s. m. , lupton , r. h. , & ivezi ' c , .
2003 , , 125 , 1559 pindor , b. , turner , e. l. , lupton , r. h. , & brinkmann , j. 2003 , , 125 , 2325 pindor , b. , et al .
2004 , , 127 , 1318 pindor , b. , et al .
2005 , in preparation richards , g. t. , et al .
2002 , , 123 , 2945 richards , g. t. , et al . 2004 , , 155 , 257 schneider , d. p. , et al . 2003 , , 126 , 2579 sheth , r. k. , et al . 2003 , , 594
, 225 smith , j. a. , et al .
2002 , , 123 , 2121 stoughton , c. , et al .
2002 , , 123 , 485 strauss , m. a. , et al .
2002 , , 124 , 1810 surdej , j. , swings , j .-
p . , magain , p. , courvoisier , t.
, & borgeest , u. 1987 , , 695 , 696 tegmark , m. , et al . 2004 , , 69 , 103501 tonry , j. l. , & kochanek , c. s. 1999 , , 117 , 2034 turner , e. l. , ostriker , j. p. , & gott , j. r. 1984 , , 284 , 1 walsh , d. , carswell , r. f. , & weymann , r. j. 1979 , , 279 , 381 weymann , r. j. , et al .
1980 , , 285 , 641 york , d. g. , et al .
2000 , , 120 , 1579 wambsganss , j. , bode , p. , & ostriker , j. p. 2005
, , submitted ( astro - ph/0405147 ) cccccccc + + a & 10 01 28.61 & + 50 27 56.9 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 + b & 10 01 28.35 & + 50 27 58.5 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 + a & 12 06 29.65 & 43 32 17.6 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 + b & 12 06 29.65 & 43 32 20.6 & @xmath129 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + cccccc + + a & @xmath134 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 + b & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & @xmath142 + g1 & @xmath143 & @xmath144 & & @xmath145 & @xmath146 + g2 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 & & @xmath149 & @xmath150 + g1+g2 & & & @xmath151 & & + a & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 + b & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & @xmath160 & @xmath161 + g1 & @xmath162 & @xmath163 & & @xmath164 & @xmath165 + g2 & @xmath166 & @xmath167 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 + g3 & @xmath171 & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & @xmath175 + crcccr q 0142@xmath188100 & @xmath189 & @xmath190 & @xmath191 & previously known lens & 1 + sdss j0246@xmath1880825 & @xmath192 & @xmath193 & @xmath194 & & 2 + sdss j0903 + 5028 & @xmath195 & @xmath196 & @xmath197 & targeted as a galaxy & 3 + rx j0911 + 0551 & @xmath198 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & previously known lens & 4 + sbs 0909 + 523 & @xmath201 & @xmath180 & @xmath202 & previously known lens & 5 + sdss j0924 + 0219 & @xmath203 & @xmath204 & & & 6 + q 0957 + 561 & @xmath205 & @xmath206 & @xmath207 & previously known lens & 7 + sdss j1001 + 5027 & @xmath2 & @xmath208 & & & 8 + sdss j1004 + 4112 & @xmath209 & @xmath210 & @xmath211 & large - separation lens & 9 + sdss j1021 + 4913 & @xmath212 & @xmath213 & & & 10 + pg 1115 + 080 & @xmath214 & @xmath213 & @xmath185 & previously known lens & 11 + sdss j1138 + 0314 & @xmath215 & @xmath216 & & & 12 + sdss j1155 + 6346 & @xmath217 & @xmath218 & @xmath219 & & 13 + sdss j1206 + 4332 & @xmath3 & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & & 8 + sdss j1226@xmath1880006 & @xmath222 & @xmath223 & @xmath224 & & 14 + sdss j1335 + 0118 & @xmath225 & @xmath226 & & & 15 + sdss j1650 + 4251 & @xmath227 & @xmath228 & & & 16 + | we report the discovery of two doubly - imaged quasars , sdss j100128.61 + 502756.9 and sdss j120629.65 + 433217.6 , at redshifts of @xmath0 and @xmath1 and with image separations of @xmath2 and @xmath3 , respectively .
the objects were selected as lens candidates from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) . based on the identical nature of the spectra of the two quasars in each pair and the identification of the lens galaxies ,
we conclude that the objects are gravitational lenses .
the lenses are complicated ; in both systems there are several galaxies in the fields very close to the quasars , in addition to the lens galaxies themselves .
the lens modeling implies that these nearby galaxies contribute significantly to the lens potentials . on larger scales ,
we have detected an enhancement in the galaxy density near sdss j100128.61 + 502756.9 .
the number of lenses with image separation of @xmath4 in the sdss already exceeds the prediction of simple theoretical models based on the standard lambda - dominated cosmology and observed velocity function of galaxies . |
rules express general knowledge about actions or conclusions in given circumstances and also principles in given domains . in the if - then format , rules are an easy way to represent cognitive processes in psychology and a useful means to encode expert knowledge . in another perspective , rules are important because they can help scientists understand problems and engineers solve problems .
these observations would account for the fact that rule learning or discovery has become a major topic in both machine learning and data mining research .
the former discipline concerns the construction of computer programs which learn knowledge or skill while the latter is about the discovery of patterns or rules hidden in the data .
the fundamental concepts of rule learning are discussed in [ 16 ] .
methods for learning sets of rules include symbolic heuristic search [ 3 , 5 ] , decision trees [ 17 - 18 ] , inductive logic programming [ 13 ] , neural networks [ 2 , 7 , 20 ] , and genetic algorithms [ 10 ] . a methodology comparison can be found in our previous work [ 9 ] . despite the differences in their computational frameworks , these methods perform a certain kind of search in the rule space ( i.e. , the space of possible rules ) in conjunction with some optimization criterion .
complete search is difficult unless the domain is small , and a computer scientist is not interested in exhaustive search due to its exponential computational complexity .
it is clear that significant issues have limited the effectiveness of all the approaches described .
in particular , we should point out that all the algorithms except exhaustive search guarantee only local but not global optimization .
for example , a sequential covering algorithm such as cn2 [ 5 ] performs a greedy search for a single rule at each sequential stage without backtracking and could make a suboptimal choice at any stage ; a simultaneous covering algorithm such as id3 [ 18 ] learns the entire set of rules simultaneously but it searches incompletely through the hypothesis space because of attribute ordering ; a neural network algorithm which adopts gradient - descent search is prone to local minima . in this paper , we introduce a new machine learning theory based on multi - channel parallel adaptation that shows great promise in learning the target rules from data by parallel global convergence .
this theory is distinct from the familiar parallel - distributed adaptation theory of neural networks in terms of channel - based convergence to the target rules .
we describe a system named cfrule which implements this theory .
cfrule bases its computational characteristics on the certain factor ( cf ) model [ 4 , 22 ] it adopts .
the cf model is a calculus of uncertainty mangement and has been used to approximate standard probability theory [ 1 ] in artificial intelligence .
it has been found that certainty factors associated with rules can be revised by a neural network [ 6 , 12 , 15 ] .
our research has further indicated that the cf model used as the neuron activation function ( for combining inputs ) can improve the neural - network performance [ 8 ] .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows .
section [ sec : mcrlm ] describes the multi - channel rule learning model .
section [ sec : mrr ] examines the formal properties of rule encoding .
section [ sec : mac ] derives the model parameter adaptation rule , presents a novel optimization strategy to deal with the local minimum problem due to gradient descent , and proves a property related to asynchronous parallel convergence , which is a critical element of the main theory .
section [ sec : re ] formulates a rule extraction algorithm .
section [ sec : app ] demonstrates practical applications
. then we draw conclusions in the final section .
cfrule is a rule - learning system based on multi - level parameter optimization .
the kernel of cfrule is a multi - channel rule learning model .
cfrule can be embodied as an artificial neural network , but the neural network structure is not essential .
we start with formal definitions about the model .
[ def : mcrl ] the multi - channel rule learning model @xmath0 is defined by @xmath1 ( @xmath2 ) channels ( @xmath3 s ) , an input vector ( @xmath4 ) , and an output ( @xmath5 ) as follows : @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 such that @xmath9 is the input dimensionality and @xmath10 for all @xmath11 .
the model has only a single output because here we assume the problem is a single - class , multi - rule learning problem .
the framework can be easily extended to the multi - class case .
[ def : channel ] each channel ( @xmath12 ) is defined by an output weight ( @xmath13 ) , a set of input weights ( @xmath14 s ) , activation ( @xmath15 ) , and influence ( @xmath16 ) as follows : @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the bias , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 for all @xmath11 .
the input weight vector @xmath21 defines the channel s pattern .
[ def : chact ] each channel s activation is defined by @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the cf - combining function [ 4 , 22 ] , as defined below .
[ def : cf ] the cf - combining function is given by @xmath24 where @xmath25 @xmath26 @xmath27 s are nonnegative numbers and @xmath28 s are negative numbers .
as we will see , the cf - combining function contributes to several important computational properties instrumental to rule discovery .
[ def : chinf ] each channel s influence on the output is defined by @xmath29 [ def : output ] the model output @xmath5 is defined by
@xmath30 we call the class whose rules to be learned the _ target class _ , and define rules inferring ( or explaining ) that class to be the _ target rules_. for instance , if the disease diabetes is the target class , then the diagnostic rules for diabetes would be the target rules .
each target rule defines a condition under which the given class can be inferred .
note that we do not consider rules which deny the target class , though such rules can be defined by reversing the class concept .
the task of rule learning is to learn or discover a set of target rules from given instances called training instances ( data ) .
it is important that rules learned should be generally applicable to the entire domain , not just the training data .
how well the target rules learned from the training data can be applied to unseen data determines the generalization performance .
instances which belong to the target class are called positive instances , else , called negative instances .
ideally , a positive training instance should match at least one target rule learned and vice versa , whereas a negative training instance should match none .
so , if there is only a single target rule learned , then it must be matched by all ( or most ) positive training instances .
but if multiple target rules are learned , then each rule is matched by some ( rather than all ) positive training instances .
since the number of possible rule sets is far greater than the number of possible rules , the problem of learning multiple rules is naturally much more complex than that of learning single rules . in the multi - channel rule
learning theory , the model learns to sort out instances so that instances belonging to different rules flow through different channels , and at the same time , channels are adapted to accommodate their pertinent instances and learn corresponding rules .
notice that this is a mutual process and it can not occur all at once . in the beginning , the rules are not learned and the channels are not properly shaped , both information flow and adaptation are more or less random , but through self - adaptation , the cfrule model will gradually converge to the correct rules , each encoded by a channel .
the essence of this paper is to prove this property . in the model design ,
a legitimate question is what the optimal number of channels is .
this is just like the question raised for a neural network of how many hidden ( internal computing ) units should be used .
it is true that too many hidden units cause data overfitting and make generalization worse [ 7 ] .
thus , a general principle is to use a minimal number of hidden units .
the same principle can be equally well applied to the cfrule model . however , there is a difference . in ordinary neural networks ,
the number of hidden units is determined by the sample size , while in the cfrule model , the number of channels should match the number of rules embedded in the data . since , however , we do not know how many rules are present in the data , our strategy is to use a minimal number of channels that admits convergence on the training data .
the model s behavior is characterized by three aspects : * information processing : compute the model output for a given input vector .
* learning or training : adjust channels parameters ( output and input weights ) so that the input vector is mapped into the output for every instance in the training data . * rule extraction :
extract rules from a trained model .
the first aspect has been described already .
the if - then rule ( i.e. , if the premise , then the action ) is a major knowledge representation paradigm in artificial intelligence . here
we make analysis of how such rules can be represented with proper semantics in the cfrule model .
[ def : rule ] cfrule learns rules in the form of if @xmath31 , ... ,
@xmath32 , ... , @xmath33 , . .
, @xmath34 , . .
, then the target class with a certainty factor . where @xmath35 is a positive antecedent ( in the positive form ) , @xmath36 a negated antecedent ( in the negative form ) , and @xmath37 reads `` not . ''
each antecedent can be a discrete or discretized attribute ( feature ) , variable , or a logic proposition .
the if part must not be empty . the attached certainty factor in the then part , called the rule cf , is a positive real @xmath38 .
the rule s premise is restricted to a conjunction , and no disjunction is allowed .
the collection of rules for a certain class can be formulated as a dnf ( disjunctive normal form ) logic expression , namely , the disjunction of conjunctions , which implies the class .
however , rules defined here are not traditional logic rules because of the attached rule cfs meant to capture uncertainty .
we interpret a rule by saying when its premise holds ( that is , all positive antecedents mentioned are true and all negated antecedents mentioned are false ) , the target concept holds at the given confidence level .
cfrule can also learn rules with weighted antecedents ( a kind of fuzzy rules ) , but we will not consider this case here . there is increasing evidence to indicate that good rule encoding capability actually facilitates rule discovery in the data . in the theorems that follow ,
we show how the cfrule model can explicitly and precisely encode any given rule set .
we note that the ordinary sigmoid - function neural network can only implicitly and approximately does this . also , we note although the threshold function of the perceptron model enables it to learn conjunctions or disjunctions , the non - differentiability of this function prohibits the use of an adaptive procedure in a multilayer construct .
[ thm : rule - rep ] for any rule represented by definition [ def : rule ] , there exists a channel in the cfrule model to encode the rule so that if an instance matches the rule , the channel s activation is 1 , else 0 .
( proof ) : this can be proven by construction .
suppose we implement channel @xmath39 by setting the bias weight to 1 , the input weights associated with all positive attributes in the rule s premise to 1 , the input weights associated with all negated attributes in the rule s premise to @xmath40 , the rest of the input weights to 0 , and finally the output weight to the rule cf .
assume that each instance is encoded by a bipolar vector in which for each attribute , 1 means true and @xmath40 false .
when an instance matches the rule , the following conditions hold : @xmath41 if @xmath27 is part of the rule s premise , @xmath42 if @xmath43 is part of the rule s premise , and otherwise @xmath27 can be of any value .
for such an instance , given the above construction , it is true that @xmath44 1 or 0 for all @xmath11 .
thus , the channel s activation ( by definition [ def : chact ] ) , @xmath45 must be 1 according to @xmath46 .
on the other hand , if an instance does not match the rule , then there exists @xmath11 such that @xmath47 . since @xmath18 ( the bias weight ) = 1 ,
the channel s activation is 0 due to @xmath46 .
@xmath48 [ thm : ruleset - rep ] assume that rule cf s @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) .
for any set of rules represented by definition [ def : rule ] , there exists a cfrule model to encode the rule set so that if an instance matches any of the given rules , the model output is @xmath49 , else 0 .
( proof ) : suppose there are @xmath1 rules in the set . as suggested in the proof of theorem [ thm : rule - rep ] , we construct @xmath1 channels , each encoding a different rule in the given rule set so that if an instance matches , say rule @xmath39 , then the activation ( @xmath15 ) of channel @xmath39 is 1 . in this case , since the channel s influence @xmath16 is given by @xmath51 ( where @xmath13 is set to the rule cf ) and the rule cf @xmath49 , it follows that @xmath52 .
it is then clear that the model output must be @xmath49 since it combines influences from all channels that @xmath53 but at least one @xmath49 . on the other hand , if an instance fails to match any of the rules , all the channels activations are zero , so is the model output . @xmath48
in neural computing , the backpropagation algorithm [ 19 ] can be viewed as a multilayer , parallel optimization strategy that enables the network to converge to a local optimum solution .
the black - box nature of the neural network solution is reflected by the fact that the pattern ( the input weight vector ) learned by each neuron does not bear meaningful knowledge .
the cfrule model departs from traditional neural computing in that its internal knowledge is comprehensible .
furthermore , when the model converges upon training , each channel converges to a target rule .
how to achieve this objective and what is the mathematical theory are the main issues to be addressed .
the cfrule model learns to map a set of input vectors ( e.g. , extracted features ) into a set of outputs ( e.g. , class information ) by training .
an input vector along with its target output constitute a training instance .
the input vector is encoded as a @xmath54 bipolar vector .
the target output is 1 for a positive instance and 0 for a negative instance . starting with a random or estimated weight setting ,
the model is trained to adapt itself to the characteristics of the training instances by changing weights ( both output and input weights ) for every channel in the model .
typically , instances are presented to the model one at a time .
when all instances are examined ( called an epoch ) , the network will start over with the first instance and repeat .
iterations continue until the system performance has reached a satisfactory level .
the learning rule of the cfrule model is derived in the same way as the backpropagation algorithm [ 19 ] .
the training objective is to minimize the sum of squared errors in the data . in each learning cycle , a training instance is given and the weights of channel @xmath39 ( for all @xmath39 ) are updated by @xmath55 @xmath56 where @xmath13 : the output weight , @xmath14 : an input weight , the argument @xmath57 denotes iteration @xmath57 , and @xmath58 the adjustment .
the weight adjustment on the current instance is based on gradient descent .
consider channel @xmath39 .
for the output weight ( @xmath13 ) , @xmath59 ( @xmath60 : the learning rate ) where @xmath61 ( @xmath62 : the target output , @xmath5 : the model output ) .
let @xmath63 the partial derivative in eq .
( [ eq : gr - u ] ) can be rewritten with the calculus chain rule to yield @xmath64 then we apply this result to eq .
( [ eq : gr - u ] ) and obtain the following definition .
the learning rule for output weight @xmath13 of channel @xmath39 is given by @xmath65 for the input weights ( @xmath14 s ) , again based on gradient descent , @xmath66 the partial derivative in eq .
( [ eq : gr - w ] ) is equivalent to @xmath67 since @xmath15 is not directly related to @xmath68 , the first partial derivative on the right hand side of the above equation is expanded by the chain rule again to obtain @xmath69 substituting these results into eq .
( [ eq : gr - w ] ) leads to the following definition .
the learning rule for input weight @xmath14 of channel @xmath39 is given by @xmath70 where @xmath71 assume that @xmath72 suppose @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
the partial derivative @xmath75 can be computed as follows .
* case ( a ) if @xmath76 , @xmath77 * case ( b ) if @xmath78 , @xmath79 it is easy to show that if @xmath80 in case ( a ) or @xmath81 in case ( b ) , @xmath82 .
it is known that gradient descent can only find a local - minimum .
when the error surface is flat or very convoluted , such an algorithm often ends up with a bad local minimum .
moreover , the learning performance is measured by the error on unseen data independent of the training set .
such error is referred to as generalization error .
we note that minimization of the training error by the backpropagation algorithm does not guarantee simultaneous minimization of generalization error .
what is worse , generalization error may instead rise after some point along the training curve due to an undesired phenomenon known as overfitting [ 7 ] .
thus , global optimization techniques for network training ( e.g. , [ 21 ] ) do not necessarily offer help as far as generalization is concerned . to address this issue
, cfrule uses a novel optimization strategy called multi - channel regression - based optimization ( mcro ) . in definition [ def : cf ] ,
@xmath83 and @xmath84 can also be expressed as @xmath85 @xmath86 when the arguments ( @xmath27 s and @xmath87 s ) are small , the cf function behaves somewhat like a linear function .
it can be seen that if the magnitude of every argument is @xmath88 , the first order approximation of the cf function is within an error of 10% or so . since
when learning starts , all the weights take on small values , this analysis has motivated the mcro strategy for improving the gradient descent solution .
the basic idea behind mcro is to choose a starting point based on the linear regression analysis , in contrast to gradient descent which uses a random starting point .
if we can use regression analysis to estimate the initial influence of each input variable on the model output , how can we know how to distribute this estimate over multiple channels ?
in fact , this is the most intricate part of the whole idea since each channel s structure and parameters are yet to be learned .
the answer will soon be clear . in cfrule , each channel s activation is defined by @xmath89 suppose we separate the linear component from the nonlinear component ( @xmath90 ) in @xmath15 to obtain @xmath91 we apply the same treatment to the model output ( definition [ def : output ] ) @xmath92 so that @xmath93 then we substitute eq.([eq : phi - app ] ) into eq.([eq : sys - app ] ) to obtain @xmath94 in which the right hand side is equivalent to @xmath95 + r_{acc}\ ] ] note that @xmath96 suppose linear regression analysis produces the following estimation equation for the model output : @xmath97 ( all the input variables and the output transformed to the range from 0 to 1 ) .
the mcro strategy is defined by @xmath98 for each @xmath99 that is , at iteration @xmath100 when learning starts , the initial weights are randomized but subject to these @xmath101 constraints .
.the target rules in the simulation experiment . [ cols= " < , <
if global optimization is a main issue for automated rule discovery from data , then current machine learning theories do not seem adequate . for instance , the decision - tree and neural - network based algorithms , which dodge the complexity of exhaustive search , guarantee only local but not global optimization . in this paper
, we introduce a new machine learning theory based on multi - channel parallel adaptation that shows great promise in learning the target rules from data by parallel global convergence .
the basic idea is that when a model consisting of multiple parallel channels is optimized according to a certain global error criterion , each of its channels converges to a target rule .
while the theory sounds attractive , the main question is how to implement it . in this paper , we show how to realize this theory in a learning system named cfrule .
cfrule is a parallel weight - based model , which can be optimized by weight adaptation .
the parameter adaptation rule follows the gradient - descent idea which is generalized in a multi - level parallel context . however , the central idea of the multi - channel rule - learning theory is not about how the parameters are adapted but rather , how each channel can converge to a target rule .
we have noticed that cfrule exhibits the necessary conditions to ensure such convergence behavior .
we have further found that the cfrule s behavior can be attributed to the use of the cf ( certainty factor ) model for combining the inputs and the channels .
since the gradient descent technique seeks only a local minimum , the learning model may well be settled in a solution where each rule is optimal in a local sense . a strategy called multi - channel regression - based optimization ( mcro ) has been developed to address this issue .
this strategy has proven effective by statistical validation .
we have formally proven two important properties that account for the parallel rule - learning behavior of cfrule .
first , we show that any given rule set can be explicitly and precisely encoded by the cfrule model .
secondly , we show that once a channel is settled in a target rule , it barely moves .
these two conditions encourage the model to move toward the target rules .
an empirical weight convergence graph clearly showed how each channel converged to a target rule in an asynchronous manner .
notice , however , we have not been able to prove or demonstrate this rule - oriented convergence behavior in other neural networks .
we have then examined the application of this methodology to dna promoter recognition and hepatitis prognosis prediction . in both domains , cfrule is superior to c4.5 ( a rule - learning method based on the decision tree ) based on cross - validation .
rules learned are also consistent with knowledge in the literature . in conclusion , the multi - channel parallel adaptive rule - learning theory is not just theoretically sound and supported by computer simulation but also practically useful . in light of its significance , this theory would hopefully point out a new direction for machine learning and data mining .
this work is supported by national science foundation under the grant ecs-9615909 .
the author is deeply indebted to edward shortliffe who contributed his expertise and time in the discussion of this paper .
1 . j.b .
adams , `` probabilistic reasoning and certainty factors '' , in _ rule - based expert systems _ , addison - wesley , reading , ma , 1984 . 2 .
alexander and m.c .
mozer , `` template - based algorithms for connectionist rule extraction '' , in _ advances in neural information processing systems _ , mit press , cambridge , ma , 1995 . 3 .
b.g . buchanan and t.m .
mitchell , `` model - directed learning of production rules '' , in _ pattern - directed inference systems _ , academic press , new york , 1978 .
b.g . buchanan and e.h .
shortliffe ( eds . ) , _ rule - based expert systems _ , addison - wesley , reading , ma , 1984 . 5 .
p. clark and r. niblett , `` the cn2 induction algorithm '' , _ machine learning _ , 3 , pp .
261 - 284 , 1989 . 6 .
fu , `` knowledge - based connectionism for revising domain theories '' , _ ieee transactions on systems , man , and cybernetics _ , 23(1 ) , pp . 173182 , 1993 .
fu , _ neural networks in computer intelligence _ , mcgraw hill , inc . , new york , ny , 1994
fu , `` learning in certainty factor based multilayer neural networks for classification '' , _ ieee transactions on neural networks_. 9(1 ) , pp .
151 - 158 , 1998 . 9 .
fu and e.h .
shortliffe , `` the application of certainty factors to neural computing for rule discovery '' , _ ieee transactions on neural networks _ , 11(3 ) , pp .
647 - 657 , 2000 . 10 .
janikow , `` a knowledge - intensive genetic algorithm for supervised learning '' , _ machine learning _ , 13 , pp .
189 - 228 , 1993 . 11 .
koudelka , s.c .
harrison , and m. ptashne , `` effect of non - contacted bases on the affinity of 434 operator for 434 repressor and cro '' , _ nature _ , 326 , pp .
886 - 888 , 1987 . 12 .
lacher , s.i .
hruska , and d.c .
kuncicky , `` back - propagation learning in expert networks '' , _ ieee transactions on neural networks _ , 3(1 ) , pp . 6272 , 1992 .
n. lavrac and s. dzeroski , _ inductive logic programming : techniques and applications _ , ellis horwood , new york , 1994 .
lawrence , _ the gene _ , plenum press , new york , ny , 1987 . 15 .
mahoney and r. mooney , `` combining connectionist and symbolic learning to refine certainty - factor rule bases '' , _ connection science _
, 5 , pp . 339 - 364 , 1993 . 16 .
t. mitchell , _ machine learning _
, mcgraw hill , inc .
, new york , ny . , 1997 .
quinlan , `` rule induction with statistical data a comparison with multiple regression '' , _ journal of the operational research society _ , 38 , pp .
347 - 352 , 1987 . 18 .
quinlan , _
c4.5 : programs for machine learning _ ,
morgan kaufmann , san mateo , ca . , 1993 .
rumelhart , g.e .
hinton , and r.j .
williams , `` learning internal representation by error propagation '' , in _ parallel distributed processing : explorations in the microstructures of cognition _ , vol .
1 . mit press , cambridge , ma , 1986 . 20 .
r. setiono and h. liu , `` symbolic representation of neural networks '' , _ computer _ , 29(3 ) , pp .
71 - 77 , 1996 . 21 .
y. shang and b.w .
wah , `` global optimization for neural network training '' , _ computer _ , 29(3 ) , pp .
45 - 54 , 1996 . 22 .
shortliffe and b.g .
buchanan , `` a model of inexact reasoning in medicine '' , _ mathematical biosciences _
, 23 , pp .
351 - 379 , 1975 . 23 .
towell and j.w .
shavlik , `` knowledge - based artificial neural networks '' , _ artificial intelligence_. 70(1 - 2 ) , pp
. 119 - 165 , 1994 . | in this paper , we introduce a new machine learning theory based on multi - channel parallel adaptation for rule discovery .
this theory is distinguished from the familiar parallel - distributed adaptation theory of neural networks in terms of channel - based convergence to the target rules .
we show how to realize this theory in a learning system named cfrule .
cfrule is a parallel weight - based model , but it departs from traditional neural computing in that its internal knowledge is comprehensible .
furthermore , when the model converges upon training , each channel converges to a target rule .
the model adaptation rule is derived by multi - level parallel weight optimization based on gradient descent .
since , however , gradient descent only guarantees local optimization , a multi - channel regression - based optimization strategy is developed to effectively deal with this problem .
formally , we prove that the cfrule model can explicitly and precisely encode any given rule set . also , we prove a property related to asynchronous parallel convergence , which is a critical element of the multi - channel parallel adaptation theory for rule learning .
thanks to the quantizability nature of the cfrule model , rules can be extracted completely and soundly via a threshold - based mechanism . finally , the practical application of the theory is demonstrated in dna promoter recognition and hepatitis prognosis prediction .
[ section ] [ section ] [ section ] + + + * li min fu * + department of cise + university of florida + + corresponding author : + li min fu + department of computer and information sciences , 301 cse + p.o .
box 116120 + university of florida + gainesville , florida 32611 + + phone : ( 352)392 - 1485 + e - mail : [email protected] * multi - channel parallel adaptation theory + for rule discovery * + * li min fu * + * keywords : * rule discovery , adaptation , optimization , regression , certainty factor , neural network , machine learning , uncertainty management , artificial intelligence . |
galaxy morphology is studied for the purpose of classification and analysis of the physical structures exhibited by galaxies in wide redshift ranges in order to get a better understanding of the structure and development of galaxies . while significant research has been done to study the morphology of galaxies with spiral arms @xcite ,
research efforts have been focused also on the analysis of elliptical and s0 galaxies using photometric measurement of the electromagnetic radiation , ellipticity , position angle , shape , and colour @xcite .
these analyses were successful in acquiring information regarding the structure and development of some of these galaxies .
however , these studies have done little analysis of the spirality of galaxies that were classified as elliptical . studying the morphology of large datasets of galaxies
have attracted significant attention in the past decade @xcite , and was driven by the increasing availability of automatically acquired datasets such as the data releases of the sloan digital sky survey @xcite .
however , attempts to automatically classify faint galaxy images along the hubble sequence have been limited by the accuracy and capability of computer learning classification systems , and did not provide results that met the needs of practical research @xcite .
this contention led to the _ galaxy zoo _
@xcite project , which successfully used a web - based system to allow amateur astronomers to manually classify galaxies acquired by sdss @xcite , and was followed by other citizen science ventures based on the same platform such as _ galaxy zoo 2 _ @xcite , _ moon zoo _ @xcite , and _ galaxy zoo mergers _ @xcite .
while it has been shown that amateurs can classify galaxies to their basic morphological types with accuracy comparable to professional astronomers @xcite , manual classification may still be limited to what the human eye can sense and the human brain can perceive .
for instance , the human eye can sense only 15 to 25 different levels of gray , while machines can identify 256 gray levels in a simple image with eight bits of dynamic range .
the inability of the human eye to differentiate between gray levels can make it difficult to sense spirality in cases where the arms are just slightly brighter than their background , but not bright enough to allow detection by casual inspection of the galaxy image .
in fact , this limitation might affect professional astronomers as much as it affects citizen scientists . since the human eye can only sense the crude morphology of galaxies along the hubble sequence , and since the classification of galaxies is normally done manually , morphological classification schemes of galaxies are based on few basic morphological types
. however , as these schemes are merely an abstraction of galaxy morphology , some galaxies can be difficult to associate with one specific shape , and many in - between cases can exist . here
we use the ganalyzer method to transform the galaxy images into their radial intensity plots @xcite , and analyze the spirality of galaxies classified manually as elliptical and s0 by the _ galaxy zoo _ , rc3 , and na10 catalogues .
the method that was used to measure the spirality of the galaxies in the dataset is the ganalyzer method @xcite . unlike other methods that aim at classifying a galaxy into one of several classes of broad morphological types @xcite , ganalyzer measures the slopes of the arms to determine the spirality of a galaxy .
ganalyzer is a model - driven method that analyzes galaxy images by first separating the object pixels from the background pixels using the otsu graylevel threshold @xcite .
the centre coordinates of the object are determined by the largest median value of the 5@xmath15 shifted window with a distance less than @xmath2 from the mass centre , where s is the surface area @xcite .
this method allows the program to determine the maximum radial distance from the centre to the outermost point , as well as the major and minor axes by finding the longest distance between two points which pass through the centre for the major axis , and then assigning the perpendicular line as the minor axis @xcite .
the ellipticity is defined as the ratio of the lengths of the minor axis to the major axis @xcite .
comparison of the ellipticity of 1000 galaxies to the ellipticity computed by sdss ( using isoa and isob ) shows a high pearson correlation of @xmath30.93 between the two measurements .
after the centre coordinates of the galaxy @xmath4 and the radius @xmath5 are determined , the galaxy is transformed into its radial intensity plot such that the intensity value of the pixel @xmath6 in the radial intensity plot is the intensity of the pixel at coordinates @xmath7 in the original galaxy image , such that @xmath8 is a polar angel of [ 0,360 ] , and @xmath5 is the radial distance that ranges from 0.4 to 0.75 of the galaxy radius , producing an image of dimensionality of 360@xmath135 @xcite .
figure [ radial ] shows an example of two galaxies and their transformation such that the y axis is the pixel intensity and the x axis is the polar angle .
as the figure shows , in the case of the elliptical galaxy the peaks are aligned on the same vertical line , while in the case of the spiral galaxy the peaks shift .
the spirality is then measured by the slope of the groups peaks as described in @xcite , such that the peak in radial distance _
r _ is grouped with the peak in radial distance _
r_+1 if the difference between their polar angles is less than 5@xmath9 .
this transformation makes it easier for machines to detect and measure the spirality , but can also detect spirality in galaxies that might look to the human observer as elliptical since the human eye can only recognize 15 - 25 gray levels , making it difficult to notice subtle spirality when looking at a raw galaxy image .
for instance , tables 1 and 2 show several sdss galaxy images classified manually by _ galaxy zoo _ participants as elliptical , with their radial intensity plot transformation and their spirality as measured by ganalyzer . to test how the method analyzes tidally disrupted elliptical galaxies @xcite
, we used several tidally disrupted galaxies from the na10 catalogue , displayed in table 3 .
if the radial intensity plot does not feature peaks the galaxy is defined as pure elliptical .
elliptical and lenticular galaxies in some cases can also have peaks in their radial intensity plot due to the position angle , but in these cases all peaks will be aligned on the same vertical line so that the slope will be very close to zero , and therefore the galaxy will be identified as elliptical .
an exception can be in cases of s0 galaxies in which the position angle of the disk is different from the position angle of the galaxy , but the difference is not greater than 5@xmath9 . in that case
ganalyzer might consider the disk and the galaxy as the same arm , but the difference in the position angles will lead to a certain slope in that arm .
therefore , the arms of the galaxy will have a certain slope when measured using ganalyzer .
the radial intensity plot can allow the detection of subtle curves in the arms that might not be easily detected by manual observation of the raw galaxy image , but becomes noticeable in its radial intensity plot .
therefore , it is possible that many galaxies that were classified manually as elliptical might in fact feature a certain spirality @xcite .
as the table shows , while the galaxies seem elliptical to the unaided human eye , the radial intensity plot transformations of the galaxies show that the peaks of maximal intensity shift , meaning that these galaxies feature certain curves in the arms . by defining spirality and ellipticity thresholds ganalyzer
can also be used for classifying galaxies into their broad morphological types of elliptical , spiral and edge - on , and a thorough discussion and experimental results about galaxy classification with ganalyzer are described in @xcite . in previous experiments with ganalyzer @xcite thresholds were applied to the slopes in the radial intensity plots so that the decision whether a galaxy is spiral or not is in agreement with the perception of a person observing the raw galaxy image . however , as described above , in this study ganalyzer is not used as a classifier , but as a tool to measure and detect the existence of galaxy spirality . since the radial intensity plot provides a more sensitive view of galaxy spirality than the non - transformed raw image , no thresholds are used in this study in order to utilize the ability of the radial intensity plots to detect subtle slopes in the galaxy arms and to test whether galaxies that seem elliptical to the human eye are indeed ellipticals , or have a subtle spirality that is difficult to measure using the unaided eye .
that is , the purpose of the method described in this section is not to mimic the human eye , but test whether the human eye observing the raw galaxy image is indeed the most accurate tool to determine whether a galaxy is spiral or elliptical .
the data used in the experiment are galaxies acquired by sloan digital sky survey , and were classified manually by the participants of the galaxy zoo project @xcite .
all galaxies in the dataset have redshift , and the classification results were based on the corrected _ super clean _
dataset described in @xcite . for the study , only galaxies that were classified by galaxy zoo participants as ellipticals were used , and the dataset consisted of 60,518 galaxies .
the images were downloaded automatically by using the cas server .
the galaxies were also divided into six bins based on their redshift , ranges from 0 to 0.3 , such that each bin had a redshift range of 0.05 .
the number of galaxies in each redshift is specified in table 4 .
the efficiency of ganalyzer can be affected by two or more galaxies that appear very close to each other in the image , either due to merging or superpositioning . since
one galaxy can be segmented with part or all of the other galaxy , ganalyzer might detect the other galaxy as an arm . in most cases such arm "
is not expected to be mistakenly identified as sharp spirality because the angle of the brightest point compared to the center is not expected to shift , but it can lead to the false detection of mild spirality that is not based on the morphology of the target galaxy . to avoid analyzing overlapping galaxies each image
was scanned for psfs as done in @xcite , and when more than one psf is detected the image is ignored .
out of the galaxies classified by galaxy zoo as elliptical @xmath312.05% were detected as galaxies with more than one nucleus and were therefore rejected from the analysis .
other catalog that were used in this study were the rc3 catalog @xcite , of which 261 galaxies classified as ellipticals and 640 galaxies classified as s0 were used , and the na10 catalog @xcite , of which 2705 galaxies that were classified as ellipticals , and 1964 galaxies that were classified as s0 were used in the experiment .
additionally , 7638 galaxies of the na10 catalog classified as spirals were also used in the analysis .
figure [ spirality_distribution ] shows the distribution of the slopes of the arms of the galaxies classified manually as elliptical .
as the figure shows , @xmath324% of the galaxies exhibit nonzero signal for spirality , and @xmath310% of the galaxies had a slope of the arms greater than 0.4 , indicating that many of the _ galaxy zoo _ galaxies that were classified manually as ellipticals actually have some spirality .
expectedly , the fraction of galaxies that meet the spirality threshold decreases as the slope of the arms gets larger , and just less than 2% of the galaxies that were classified manually as ellipticals were detected to have a measured slope greater than 1 . as the graph shows , the measured slope of the arms of most galaxies is close to 0 .
60,000 galaxies classified as ellipticals ] figure [ redshift_0_015 ] shows the distribution of the slopes of the arms in a galaxy population of different redshifts . as can be learned from the figure , the slope of the arms increases with the redshift , showing that at higher redshifts human readers find it more difficult to detect spirality by eye and tend to classify more galaxies as ellipticals . correlating the apparent magnitude of these galaxies with the slope of the arms provided a weak pearson correlation value of -0.036 , showing that the analysis is merely weakly dependent on apparent magnitude in the redshift range used in this study .
while the experiments above show that human readers can in some cases fail to notice mild spirality , we also tested the error rate of human readers when they determine that the galaxy that they observe is spiral .
figure [ gz_spirals ] shows the distribution of the measured slope of the arms among galaxies that were classified by galaxy zoo participants as spiral .
as the figure shows , when the human eye is able to detect spirality , spirality does exist , and galaxies classified by human observers as spirals are rarely galaxies that do not have any spirality in them
. the reason could be the limited sensitivity of the human eye in detecting spirality , so that once spirality can be detected by the human eye it is above a certain spirality threshold that can be sensed by applying the analysis of the radial intensity plot of the galaxy as described in section [ methodology ] .
the results obtained with the _ galaxy zoo _ data were compared also to the analysis using data taken by the rc3 catalogue @xcite and the na10 catalogue @xcite . unlike _ galaxy zoo _ that was classified by amateurs , rc3 and na10 were both classified by professional astronomers .
figure [ rc3 ] shows the slopes of the arms of galaxies classified as ellipticals and s0 by rc3 . as the graph shows , galaxies classified as s0 have a higher arm slopes compared to galaxies classified as ellipticals .
the figure also shows that like the _ galaxy zoo _ catalog , the arms of many of the galaxies classified by professional astronomers as ellipticals also has a certain slope .
these results are in agreement with the observation of @xcite , according which professional astronomers do not outperform amateur astronomers in classification of galaxies into their broad morphological types .
figure [ na10 ] shows the slopes of the arms of galaxies classified as ellipticals and s0 in the na10 catalog .
these results are in agreement with the results of the rc3 catalog , showing higher arm slopes in galaxies classified manually as s0 .
the distribution of the slopes of the arms was also analyzed for different redshifts , as displayed by figure [ na10_redshift ] , showing galaxies classified as ellipticals .
as the figure shows , the fraction of galaxies with non - zero slope classified as ellipticals in the na10 catalog does not change significantly with the redshift in the tested redshift ranges .
in this study we used computer - aided analysis based on the radial intensity plots of sdss galaxy images to examine spirality in galaxies that were classified manually as elliptical . while the unaided human eye provides a limited tool for analyzing elliptical galaxy images due to the limited sensitivity of the human vision to different gray levels , transforming the images to their radial intensity plots allows much easier detection of the spirality .
the results suggest that more than a third of the galaxies that were classified manually by _ galaxy zoo _ participants as elliptical actually have a certain spirality .
although in most cases the spirality was low , 10% of the galaxies classified as elliptical had a slope greater than 0.5 , suggesting that computer - aided analysis can in some cases be more sensitive to galaxy spirality compared to the human eye .
these conclusions are also true for galaxies classified by professional astronomers , as was shown by using the rc3 and na10 catalogs
. the results also exhibit redshift bias .
this bias can be attributed to the quality of the images , as images of nearby galaxies provide higher image quality and therefore manual inspection of these images can be easier compared to images of galaxies with higher redshift , in which the ability of computer - aided analysis to detect subtle differences between gray levels can provide an advantage over the unaided human eye .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the us department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , university of cambridge , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max planck institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max planck institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory and the university of washington .
abraham , r. g. , merrifield , m. r. , ellis , r. s. , tanvir , n. r. , brinchmann , j. , 1999 .
the evolution of barred spiral galaxies in the hubble deep fields north and south .
mnras 308 , 569576 .
abraham , r. g. , van den bergh , s. , nair , p. , 2003 . a new approach to galaxy morphology .
i. analysis of the sloan digital sky survey early data release .
apj 588 , 218229 .
ball , n. m. , brunner , r. j. , myers , a. d. , strand , n. e. , alberts , s. l. , tcheng , d. , 2008 .
robust machine learning applied to astronomical data sets .
probabilistic photometric redshifts for galaxies and quasars in the sdss and galex .
apj , 683 , 1221 .
ball , n. m. , loveday , j. , brunner , r. j. , 2008 .
galaxy colour , morphology and environment in the sloan digital sky survey .
mnras 383 , 907922 .
banerji , m. , et al .
galaxy zoo : reproducing galaxy morphologies via machine learning .
mnras , 406 , 342353 .
conselice , c.j . , 2003 .
the relationship between stellar light distributions of galaxies and their formation histories .
apjs , 147 , 128 .
corwin , h. g. , jr .
, buta , r. j. , de vaucouleurs , g. , 1994 .
corrections and additions to the third reference catalogue of bright galaxies aj 108 , 21282144 .
djorgovski , s. g. , davis , m. , 1987 .
fundamental properties of elliptical galaxies .
apj 313 , 5968 .
dressler , a. , lynden - bell , d. , burstein , d. , davies , r. l. , faber , s. m. , terlevich , r. wegner , g. , 1987 .
spectroscopy and photometry pf elliptical galaxies .
i. a new distance estimator .
apj 313 , 42 .
huertas - company , m. , aguerri , j. a. l. , bernardi , m. , mei , s. , sanchez almeida , j. , 2011 .
sdss automated morphology classification .
a&a 525 , 157 joy , k. et al . , 2011 .
moon zoo : citizen science in lunar exploration .
astronomy & geophysics 52 , 1012 .
kormendy , j. , fisher , d. b. , cornell , m. e. , bender , r. , 2009.structure and formation of elliptical and spheroidal galaxies .
apjs 182 , 216309 .
kormendy , j. , bender , r. , 2012 . a revised parallel - sequence morphological classification of galaxies : structure and formation of s0 and spheroidal galaxies .
apjs 198 , 2 .
lintott , c. j. , et al .
galaxy zoo : morphologies derived from visual inspection of galaxies from the sloan digital sky survey .
mnras 389 , 11791189 .
lintott , c. j. , et al . 2011 .
galaxy zoo 1 : data release of morphological classifications for nearly 900,000 galaxies .
mnras 410 , 166178 .
loveday , j. , 1996 . the apm bright galaxy catalogue .
mnras 278 , 10251048 .
masters , k. l. , et al . 2011 .
galaxy zoo : bars in disk galaxies .
mnras 411 , 20262034 .
nair , p. , 2009
, phd dissertation , university of toronto nair , p. , abraham , r. , 2010 . on the fraction of barred spiral galaxies .
apj , 714 , l260 otsu , n. , 1979 . a threshold selection method from gray level histograms .
ieee trans .
sys . man .
9 , 6266 .
shamir , l. , nemiroff , r.j .
a lossy fits image compression algorithm that protects user - defined levels of photometric integrity .
aj 129 , 539546 .
shamir , l. , nemiroff , r.j .
, 2005b . a fuzzy logic based algorithm for finding astronomical objects in wide - angle frames .
pasa 22 , 111117 .
shamir , l. , 2009 .
automatic morphological classification of galaxy images .
mnras 399 , 13671372 .
shamir l. , 2011a .
ganalyzer : a tool for automatic galaxy image analysis .
apj 736 , 141 .
shamir l. , 2011b .
astrophysics source code library , ascl:1105.011 shamir l. , 2012 , handedness asymmetry of spiral galaxies with [email protected] shows cosmic parity violation and a dipole axis , physics letters b , 715 , 2529 .
scorza , c . ,
bender , r. , 1990 , a&a 235 , 49 .
thorsten , l. , 2008 . is the gini coefficient a stable measure of galaxy structure ?
apjs 179 , 319 tyson , j.a . , 2002 .
large synoptic survey telescope : overview .
proceedings of the spie , 4836 , 1020 .
wallin , j. , holincheck , a. , borne , k. , lintott , c. , smith , a. , bamford , s. , fortson , l. , 2010 .
tasking citizen scientists from galaxy zoo to model galaxy collisions .
asp conference series , 423 , 217222 .
van den bergh , s. , 2009 .
what are s0 galaxies ?
apj , 694 , l120l122 .
van den bergh , s. , 2009 .
lenticular galaxies and their environment .
apj 702 , 1502 van dokkum , p. g. 2005 . the recent and continuing assembly of field elliptical galaxies by red mergers .
aj 130 , 2647 - 2665 .
york , d.g .
et al . , 2000 .
the sloan digital sky survey quasar catalog .
ii . first data release .
aj , 120 , 25792593 . | we use an automated galaxy morphology analysis method to quantitatively measure the spirality of galaxies classified manually as elliptical . the data set used for the analysis
consists of 60,518 galaxy images with redshift obtained by the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) and classified manually by _ galaxy zoo _ , as well as the rc3 and na10 catalogues .
we measure the spirality of the galaxies by using the ganalyzer method , which transforms the galaxy image to its radial intensity plot to detect galaxy spirality that is in many cases difficult to notice by manual observation of the raw galaxy image .
experimental results using manually classified elliptical and s0 galaxies with redshift @xmath00.3 suggest that galaxies classified manually as elliptical and s0 exhibit a nonzero signal for the spirality .
these results suggest that the human eye observing the raw galaxy image might not always be the most effective way of detecting spirality and curves in the arms of galaxies .
* keywords * : galaxies : elliptical and lenticular techniques : image processing . |
langevin dynamics@xcite is a modeling technique , in which the motion of a set of massive bodies in the presence of a bath of smaller solvent particles is directly integrated , while the dynamics of the solvent are `` averaged out '' .
this approximation may lead to a dramatic reduction in computational cost compared to `` explicit solvent '' methods , since dynamics of the solvent particles no longer need to be fully resolved .
with langevin dynamics , the effect of the solvent is reduced to an instantaneous drag force and a random delta - correlated force felt by the massive bodies .
this framework has been applied in a variety of scenarios , including implicit solvents,@xcite brownian dynamics,@xcite dynamic thermostats,@xcite and the stabilization of time integrators.@xcite in spite of the numerous successes of conventional langevin dynamics it has long been recognized that there are physically compelling scenarios in which the underlying assumptions break down , necessitating a more general treatment.@xcite to this end , generalized langevin dynamics ( gld ) permits the modeling of systems in which the inertial gap separating the massive bodies from the smaller solvent particles is reduced . here
the assumptions of an instantaneous drag force and a delta - correlated random force become insufficient , leading to the introduction of a temporally non - local drag and a random force with non - trivial correlations .
gld has historically been applied to numerous problems over the years,@xcite with a number of new applications inspiring a resurgence of interest , including microrheology,@xcite biological systems,@xcite nuclear quantum effects,@xcite and other situations in which anomalous diffusion arises.@xcite to facilitate computational exploration of some of these applications , a number of authors have developed numerical integration schemes for the generalized langevin equation ( gle ) , either in isolation or in conjunction with extra terms accounting for external or pairwise forces as would be required in a molecular dynamics ( md ) simulation .
these schemes must deal with a number of complications if they are to remain computationally efficient and accurate .
* the retarded drag force takes the form of a convolution of the velocity with a memory kernel .
this requires the storage of the velocity history , and the numerical evaluation of a convolution at each time step , which can become computationally expensive .
* the generation of a random force with non - trivial correlations may also require the storage of a sequence of random numbers , and some additional computational expense incurred at each time step .
numerous methods exist that circumvent either one or both of these difficulties.@xcite each has a different computational cost , implementation complexity , order of convergence , and specific features , e.g. , some are restricted to single exponential memory kernels , require linear algebra , etc . to this end
, it is difficult to distinguish any individual method as being optimal , especially given the broad range of applications to which gld may be applied .
motivated by the aforementioned applications and previous work in numerical integrators , we have developed a new family of time integration schemes for the gle in the presence of conservative forces , and implemented it in a public domain md code , lammps.@xcite our primary impetus was to enable the development of reduced order models for nanocolloidal suspensions , among a variety of other applications outlined above .
previous computational studies of these systems using explicit solvents have demonstrated and resolved a number of associated computational challenges .
@xcite our method enables a complementary framework for the modeling of these types of systems using implicit solvents that can include memory effects . otherwise , to date the gle has only been solved in the presence of a number of canonically tractable external potentials and memory kernels.@xcite integration into the lammps framework , provides a number of capabilities .
lammps includes a broad array of external , bonded , and non - bonded potentials , yielding the possibility for the numerical exploration of more complex systems than have been previously studied .
finally , lammps provides a highly scalable parallel platform for studying n - body dynamics .
consequently , extremely large sample statistics are readily accessible even in the case of interacting particles , for which parallelism is an otherwise non - trivial problem . in this paper , details germane to both the development of our time integration scheme , as well as specifics of its implementation are presented .
the time integration scheme to be discussed is based upon a two - parameter family of methods specialized to an extended variable formulation of the gle .
some of the salient advantages of our formulation and the final time integration scheme are : * generalizability to a wide array of memory kernels representable by a positive prony series , such as power laws . * efficiency afforded by an extended variable formulation that obviates the explicit evaluation of time convolutions . * inexpensive treatment of correlated random forces , free of linear algebra , requiring only one random force evaluation per extended variable per timestep .
* exact conservation of the first and second moments of either the integrated velocity distribution or position distribution , for harmonically confined and free particles .
* numerically stable approach to the langevin limit of the gle .
* simplicity of implementation into an existing verlet md framework .
the specialization to prony - representable memory kernels is worth noting , as there is a growing body of literature concerning this form of the gle.@xcite a number of results have been presented that establish the mathematical well - posedness of this extended variable gle including a term accounting for smooth conservative forces , as may arise in md.@xcite these results include proofs of ergodicity and exponential convergence to a measure , as well as a discussion of the langevin limit of the gle in which the parameters of the extended system generate conventional langevin dynamics .
one somewhat unique feature of our framework is that we are analyzing the gle using methods from stochastic calculus . in particular , we focus on weak convergence in the construction our method , i.e. , error in representing the moments of the stationary distribution or the distribution itself .
the optimal parametrization of our two - parameter family of methods will be defined in terms of achieving accuracy with respect to this type of convergence . in particular , the optimal method that has been implemented achieves exactness in the first and second moments of the integrated velocity distribution for harmonically confined and free particles .
few authors have considered this type of analysis for even conventional langevin integrators , with a notable exception being wang and skeel,@xcite who have carried out weak error analysis for a number of integrators used in conventional langevin dynamics . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first time that such a weak analysis has been carried out for a gle integrator . we hope that these considerations will contribute to a better understanding of existing and future methods .
the remainder of this paper is structured as follows : * * section [ problem_statement ] * introduces the mathematical details of the gle . * * section [ extended_variable_formalism ] * presents the extended variable formulation and its benefits . *
* section [ numerical_integration_of_the_gle ] * develops the theory associated with integrating the extended variable gle in terms of a two - parameter family of methods . * * section [ error_analysis ] * provides details of the error analysis that establishes the ` optimal ' method among this family . * * section [ multistage_splitting ] * discusses the extension of our method to a multi - stage splitting framework .
* * section [ implementation_details ] * summarizes details of the implementation in lammps . * * section [ results ] * presents a number of results that establish accuracy in numerous limits / scenarios , including demonstration of utility in constructing reduced order models .
the gle for @xmath0 particles moving in @xmath1-dimensions can be written as [ cont_gle ] @xmath2 with initial conditions @xmath3 and @xmath4 . here
, @xmath5 is a conservative force , @xmath6 is a random force , @xmath7 is a diagonal mass matrix , and @xmath8 is a memory kernel .
the solution to this stochastic integro - differential equation is a trajectory , which describes the positions @xmath9 and velocities @xmath10 of the particles as a function of time , @xmath11 .
the second term on the right - hand side of equation [ vel_gle ] accounts for the temporally non - local drag force , and the third term accounts for the correlated random force .
the nature of both forces are characterized by the memory kernel , @xmath12 , consistent with the fluctuation - dissipation theorem ( fdt).@xcite the fdt states that equilibration to a temperature , @xmath13 , requires that the two - time correlation of @xmath14 and @xmath15 be related as follows : @xmath16 here , @xmath17 is the kronecker delta , and @xmath18 is boltzmann s constant . in the context of an md simulation ,
we are interested in solving equation [ cont_gle ] for both @xmath19 and @xmath20 at a set of @xmath21 uniformly spaced discrete points in time . to this end
, we seek to construct a solution scheme that is mindful of the following complications : * calculation of the temporally non - local drag force requires a convolution with @xmath15 , and thusly the storage of some subset of the time history of @xmath20 .
* numerical evaluation of @xmath14 requires the generation of a sequence of correlated random numbers , as specified in equation [ fdt ] . * as equation [ cont_gle ]
is a stochastic differential equation ( sde ) , we are not concerned with issues of local or global error , but rather that the integrated solution converges in distribution .
to circumvent the first two complications , we work with an extended variable formalism@xcite in which we assume that @xmath15 is representable as a prony series : @xmath22 , \quad t\geq 0.\ ] ] as will be demonstrated in section [ extended_variable_formalism ] , this form of the memory kernel will allow us to map the non - markovian form of the gle in equation [ cont_gle ] onto a higher - dimensional markovian problem with @xmath23 extended variables per particle .
the third complication is resolved in sections [ numerical_integration_of_the_gle ] and [ error_analysis ] , in which a family of integrators is derived , and then ` optimal ' parameters are selected based upon an error analysis of the moments of the integrated velocity .
we introduce the extended variable formalism in two stages .
first , we define a set of extended variables that allow for an effectively convolution - free reformulation of equation [ cont_gle ] .
then , we demonstrate that the non - trivial temporal correlations required of @xmath14 can be effected through coupling to an auxiliary set of ornstein - uhlenbeck ( ou ) processes .
we begin by defining the extended variable , @xmath24 , associated with the @xmath25th prony mode s action on the @xmath26th component of @xmath19 and @xmath20 : @xmath27 v_i(s ) ds\ ] ] component - wise , equation [ cont_gle ] can now be rewritten as : [ ext_gle_1 ] @xmath28 rather than relying upon the integral form of equation [ ext_var_def ] to update the value of @xmath24 , we consider the total differential of @xmath24 to generate an equation of motion that takes the form of a simple sde : @xmath29 now , the system of equations [ ext_gle_1 ] and [ ext_var_eom ] can be resolved for @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath24 without requiring the explicit evaluation of a convolution integral .
next , we seek a means of constructing random forces that obey the fdt , as in equation [ fdt ] . to this end , we consider the following sde : @xmath32 if @xmath33 is a standard wiener process , this sde defines an ornstein - uhlenbeck ( ou ) process , @xmath34 .
using established properties of the ou process,@xcite we can see that @xmath34 has mean zero and two - time correlation : @xmath35 , \quad s\geq 0\ ] ] it is then clear , that the random force in equation [ cont_gle ] can be rewritten as : @xmath36 here each individual contribution is generated by a standard ou process , the discrete - time version of which is the ar(1 ) process . while we are still essentially forced to generate a sequence of correlated random numbers , mapping onto a set of ar(1 ) processes has the advantage of requiring the retention of but a single prior value in generating each subsequent value .
further , standard gaussian random number generators can be employed . combining both results ,
the final extended variable gle can be expressed in terms of the composite variable , @xmath37 : [ ext_gle_2 ] @xmath38 it is for this system of equations that we will construct a numerical integration scheme in section [ numerical_integration_of_the_gle ] .
it is worth noting that other authors have rigorously shown that this extended variable form of the gle converges to the langevin equation in the limit of small @xmath39.@xcite informally , this can be seen by multplying the @xmath40 equation by @xmath39 , and taking the limit as @xmath39 goes to zero , which results in @xmath41 inserting this expression into the equation for @xmath42 , we obtain @xmath43 which is a conventional langevin equation .
we have been careful to preserve this limit in our numerical integration scheme , and will explicitly demonstrate this theoretically and numerically .
we consider a family of numerical integration schemes for the system in equation [ ext_gle_2 ] assuming a uniform timestep , @xmath44 .
notation is adopted such that @xmath45 for @xmath46 . given the values of @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49
, we update to the @xmath50th time step using the following splitting method : 1 .
_ advance @xmath42 by a half step : _
@xmath51 2 .
_ advance @xmath52 by a full step : _
. _ advance @xmath40 by a full step : _
@xmath54 4 .
_ advance @xmath42 by a half step : _
@xmath55 here , each @xmath56 is drawn from an independent gaussian distribution of mean zero and variance unity .
the real - valued @xmath57 and @xmath58 can be varied to obtain different methods .
for consistency , we require that @xmath59 for the remainder of this article , we restrict our attention three different methods , each of which corresponds to a different choice for @xmath57 and @xmath58 . *
* method 1 : * using the euler - maruyama scheme to update @xmath40 is equivalent to using @xmath60 * * method 2 : * if @xmath42 is held constant , the equation for @xmath40 can be solved exactly .
using this approach is equivalent to setting @xmath61 * * method 3 : * both methods 1 and 2 are unstable as @xmath39 goes to zero . to improve the stability when @xmath39 is small
, we consider the following modified version of method 2 : @xmath62 note that all three methods satisfy the consistency condition , and are equivalent to the strmer - verlet - leapfrog method@xcite when @xmath63 and @xmath64 . to help guide our choice of method , we compute the moments of the stationary distribution for a one - dimensional harmonic potential ( natural frequency @xmath65 ) and a single mode memory kernel ( weight @xmath66 and time scale @xmath67 ) .
a similar approach has been used for the classical langevin equation.@xcite the extended variable gle for this system converges to a distribution of the form @xmath68\ ] ] where @xmath69 is the usual normalization constant . from this
, we can derive the analytic first and second moments @xmath70
@xmath71 @xmath72 next , we consider the discrete - time process generated by our numerical integrators , and show that the moments of its stationary distribution converge to the analytic ones in @xmath44 . @xmath73
the stationary distribution of this process is defined by the time independence of its first moments @xmath74 enforcing these identities , it can be shown that @xmath75 hence , the first moments are correctly computed by the numerical method for any choice of @xmath76 and @xmath77 . computing the second moments , we obtain @xmath78 @xmath79 @xmath80 from this analysis
, we conclude that we obtain the correct second moment for @xmath81 for any method with @xmath82 .
now , applying the particular values of @xmath76 and @xmath77 , and expanding in powers of @xmath44 , we obtain the following . *
* method 1 : * @xmath83 @xmath84 * * method 2 : * @xmath85 @xmath86 * * method 3 : * @xmath83 @xmath87 for methods 1 and 3 , we obtain the exact variance for @xmath81 , independent of @xmath44 , since they both satisfy @xmath82 . for method 2 ,
the error in the variance of @xmath81 is second - order in @xmath44 .
all three methods overestimate the variance of @xmath88 , with an error which is second - order in @xmath44 .
the error in the variance of @xmath89 is first - order for method 1 , and second - order for methods 2 and 3 .
it is possible to choose @xmath76 and @xmath77 to obtain the exact variance for @xmath88 , but this would require using a different value for @xmath76 and @xmath77 for each value of @xmath65 .
this is not useful in our framework , since the method is applied to problems with general nonlinear interaction forces .
we would like our numerical method to be stable for a wide range of values for @xmath39 . as we mentioned in section [ extended_variable_formalism ]
, the gle converges to the conventional langevin equation as @xmath39 goes to zero , and we would like our numerical method to have a similar property . for fixed @xmath44 , both methods 1 and 2 are unstable ( @xmath90 is unbounded ) as @xmath39 goes to zero .
however , method 3 does not suffer from the same problem , with @xmath91 converging to zero and @xmath90 bounded .
from this analysis , we conclude that method 3 is the best choice for implementation .
prior to providing implementation details , however , we briefly consider a simple multistage extension that can capture the exact first and second moments of position and velocity simultaneously at the expense of introducing a numerical correlation between them . inspired by the work of leimkuhler and matthews,@xcite we consider a generalization of the splitting method considered in section [ numerical_integration_of_the_gle ] in which the position and velocity updates are further split , @xmath92 in the special case that @xmath93 , we have @xmath94 , the two updates of @xmath88 can be combined , and we recover our original splitting method . repeating the analysis in section [ error_analysis ] for the harmonic oscillator with a single memory term , we find @xmath95 @xmath96 @xmath97 @xmath98 in the special case that @xmath99 , we can simplify these expressions to obtain @xmath100 @xmath101 from this analysis , we conclude that we obtain the correct second moment for @xmath88 for any method with @xmath99 and @xmath82 .
to guarantee the correct second moment for @xmath81 , the choice of @xmath76 and @xmath77 becomes @xmath65 dependent . as was discussed in the previous section ,
the parameters prescribed by methods 1 and 3 using the original splitting have a similar behavior but with the roles of @xmath88 and @xmath81 reversed .
it is then tempting to formulate a method that exactly preserves the second moments of both @xmath88 and @xmath81 at the same time .
it turns out that this is possible by simply shifting where we observe @xmath81 , using either @xmath102 or @xmath103 in the multistage splitting method above .
for example , consider the following asymmetric method , with @xmath99 , @xmath104 for this method we obtain , @xmath105 @xmath106 if we use a method with @xmath82 , we find that we obtain the exact moments for @xmath88 and @xmath81 , but we have introduced an @xmath107 correlation between @xmath88 and @xmath81 .
this is in contrast to the symmetric methods where this correlation is identically zero .
method 3 , as detailed in section [ error_analysis ] has been implemented in the lammps software package .
it can be applied in conjunction with all conservative force fields supported by lammps .
there are a number of details of our implementation worth remarking on concerning random number generation , initial conditions on the extended variables , and the conservation of total linear momentum .
the numerical integration scheme requires the generation of gaussian random numbers , by way of @xmath108 in equation [ s_update ] . by default ,
all random numbers are drawn from a uniform distribution with the same mean and variance as the formally required gaussian distribution .
this distribution is chosen to avoid the generation of numbers that are arbitrarily large , or more accurately , arbitrarily close to the floating point limit .
the generation of such large numbers may lead to rare motions that result in the loss of atoms from a periodic simulation box , even at low temperatures .
atom loss occurs if , within a single time step , the change in one or more of an atom s position coordinates is updated to a value that results in it being placed outside of the simulation box after periodic boundary conditions are applied .
a uniform distribution can be used to guarantee that this will not happen for a given temperature and time step . however , for the sake of mathematical rigor , the option remains at compile - time to enable the use of the proper gaussian distribution with the caveat that such spurious motions may occur .
should the use of this random number generator produce a trajectory in which atom loss occurs , a simple practical correction may be to use a different seed and/or a different time step in a subsequent simulation .
it is worth noting that the choice of a uniform random number distribution has been rigorously justified by dnweg and paul@xcite for a number of canonical random processes , including one described by a conventional langevin equation .
we anticipate that a similar result may hold for the extended variable gle presented in this manuscript .
with respect to the initialization of the extended variables , it is frequently the case in md that initial conditions are drawn from the equilibrium distribution at some initial temperature .
details of the equilibrium distribution for the extended system are presented in section 2 of an article by ottobre and pavliotis.@xcite in our implementation , we provide the option to initialize the extended variables either based upon this distribution , or with zero initial conditions ( i.e. , the extended system at zero temperature ) . as it is typically more relevant for md simulations ,
the former is enabled by default and used in the generation of the results in this paper .
conservation of the total linear momentum of a system is frequently a desirable feature for md trajectories . for deterministic forces
, this can be guaranteed to high precision through the subtraction of the velocity of the center of mass from all particles at a single time step . in the presence of random forces such as those arising in gld
, a similar adjustment must be made at each time step to prevent the center of mass from undergoing a random acceleration . while it is not enabled by default
, our implementation provides such a mechanism that can be activated .
when active , the average of the forces acting on all extended variables is subtracted from each individual extended variable at each time step . while this is a computationally inexpensive adjustment , it may not be essential for all simulations .
throughout this section , results will be presented , primarily in terms of the integrated velocity autocorrelation function ( vaf ) .
this quantity is calculated using `` block averaging '' and `` subsampling '' of the integrated trajectories for computational convenience.@xcite error bars are derived from the standard deviation associated with a set of independently generated trajectories .
, @xmath113 ) , ii . ) critically damped ( @xmath114 , @xmath115 ) , and iii . ) overdamped limits ( @xmath116 , @xmath117 ) .
a time step of @xmath118 is used for all runs , and error bars are drawn based upon a sample of 10,000 walkers over 10 independent runs .
[ single_mode_fig],title="fig : " ] , @xmath113 ) , ii . ) critically damped ( @xmath114 , @xmath115 ) , and iii . ) overdamped limits ( @xmath116 , @xmath117 ) .
a time step of @xmath118 is used for all runs , and error bars are drawn based upon a sample of 10,000 walkers over 10 independent runs .
[ single_mode_fig],title="fig : " ] , @xmath113 ) , ii . ) critically damped ( @xmath114 , @xmath115 ) , and iii . ) overdamped limits ( @xmath116 , @xmath117 ) .
a time step of @xmath118 is used for all runs , and error bars are drawn based upon a sample of 10,000 walkers over 10 independent runs .
[ single_mode_fig],title="fig : " ] to validate our integration scheme in the presence of a conservative force , we next consider gld with an external potential .
the analytic solution of the gle with a power law memory kernel and a harmonic confining potential has been derived by other authors.@xcite in the cited work , the gle is solved in the laplace domain , yielding correlation functions given in terms of a series of mittag - leffler functions and their derivatives . here , we apply our integration scheme to a prony series fit of the power law kernel and demonstrate that our results are in good agreement with the exact result over a finite time interval .
the gle that we intend to model has the form : @xmath119 we begin by constructing a prony series representation of the memory kernel .
as it exhibits a power law decay in the laplace domain , as well , a prony series representation will have strong contributions from modes decaying over a continuum of time scales .
to this end , rather than relying on a non - linear fitting procedure to choose values for @xmath39 , we assume logarithmically spaced values from @xmath120 to @xmath121 . by assuming the form of each exponential , the prony series fit reduces to a simple linear least squares problem , that we solve using uniformly spaced data over an interval that is two decades longer than the actual simulation . in figure
[ kernel_fit_fig ] , the prony series fit of the memory kernel for @xmath122 is compared to its exact value . for @xmath123 , @xmath122 with an increasing number of modes.[kernel_fit_fig],title="fig : " ] here , the maximum relative error is @xmath124 , while it is @xmath125 for @xmath126 . in figure
[ harmonic_soln_fig ] , the normalized vaf computed via numerical integration of the extended gle with a variable number of modes is shown compared to the exact result for some of the parameters utilized in an article by despsito and viales.@xcite it seems evident that the accuracy of the integrated velocity distribution improves relative to the exact velocity distribution as the number of terms in the prony series fit increases .
this is quantified in figure [ harmonic_error_fig ] , in which the pointwise absolute error in the integrated vaf is illustrated . for @xmath123 , @xmath122 , and @xmath127 .
a time step of @xmath118 is used , and error bars are drawn based upon a sample of 10,000 walkers over 10 independent runs with @xmath118.[harmonic_soln_fig],title="fig : " ] for @xmath123 , @xmath122 , and @xmath127 .
a time step of @xmath118 is used , and error bars are drawn based upon a sample of 10,000 walkers over 10 independent runs with @xmath118.[harmonic_soln_fig],title="fig : " ] + for @xmath123 , @xmath122 , and @xmath127 .
a time step of @xmath118 is used , and error bars are drawn based upon a sample of 10,000 walkers over 10 independent runs with @xmath118.[harmonic_soln_fig],title="fig : " ] .
error is computed with respect to the mean of vafs computed from 10 independent runs.[harmonic_error_fig],title="fig : " ] next , we demonstrate that our implementation is robust in certain limits of the gle - particularly the langevin and zero coefficient limits . as our implementation is available in a public domain code with a large user base , developing a numerical method that is robust to a wide array of inputs is essential .
for the zero coefficient limit we consider a harmonically confined particle experiencing a single mode prony series memory kernel of the following form : @xmath128 the initial conditions on @xmath88 and @xmath81 are drawn from a thermal distribution at @xmath129 . in the limit that @xmath130 , we expect the integrated normalized vaf to approach that of a set of deterministic harmonic oscillators .
the initial conditions on @xmath88 and @xmath81 are drawn from a thermal distribution at @xmath129 , giving the integrated result some variance , even in the newtonian / deterministic limit . in figure [ zero_coeff_fig ] , that this limit is smoothly and stably approached is illustrated .
( newtonian ) limit from @xmath131 for a single prony mode with @xmath113 .
the particle is harmonically confined with @xmath132 , and the expected period of oscillation is restored for @xmath133 .
[ zero_coeff_fig],title="fig : " ] in the exact @xmath133 limit , oscillations in the vaf occur at the natural frequency of the confining potential , @xmath132 , whereas for non - zero @xmath66 , these oscillations are damped in proportion to @xmath66 , as one may expect on the basis of intuition .
the langevin limit is illustrated next . to this end
, we utilize the same single mode prony series memory kernel , but remove the confining potential ( i.e. , @xmath134 ) .
we have done so to ensure that the langevin limit yields an ornstein - uhlenbeck process . in figure
[ langevin_lim_fig ] , we illustrate that this limit is also smoothly and stably approached .
( langevin ) limit from @xmath113 for a single prony mode .
the particle is subject to no conservative forces , so the resultant dynamics correspond to an ornstein - uhlenbeck process .
the ` exact ' langevin limit was integrated using _
fix langevin _ in lammps .
[ langevin_lim_fig],title="fig : " ] the result for the langevin limit itself was integrated using the existing _ fix langevin _ command in lammps .
for @xmath135 , the gle yields results that differ from the langevin limit as one might expect on the basis of the previous results .
however , even for @xmath136 , the gle yields results that are close to that of the langevin limit , as the resultant numerical method retains some gle - like behavior .
however , for @xmath137 and @xmath118 , the parameter @xmath138 $ ] , is below machine epsilon . as mentioned in section [ error_analysis ] , this results in a method that is indistinguishable from conventional langevin dynamics , and consequently , the integrated dynamics are indistinguishable .
this result demonstrates that the method is robust , even if the user ` accidentally ' crosses into a langevin - like regime .
we again emphasize that methods 1 and 2 , considered earlier , will not stably approach this limit . to demonstrate capability in reduced order modeling , we next invert the vaf associated with a set of trajectories generated in the presence of a conservative force , to construct a memory kernel that will reproduce the same dynamics without such a force .
in other words , we seek an effective memory kernel , @xmath139 , such that a simplified gle of the form : @xmath140 reproduces the vaf of a gle of the more general form given in equation [ cont_gle ] . the starting point for this procedure
is the observation that for equation [ force_free_gle ] , the vaf and memory kernel have the following relationship in the laplace domain:@xcite @xmath141 here , tildes indicate that the associated time domain quantities have been laplace transformed , with transform domain variable @xmath142 .
given @xmath143 for some process whose vaf we wish to reproduce via integration of equation [ force_free_gle ] , @xmath144 can be resolved algebraically , and its time domain form can be found via an inverse laplace transform : @xmath145 this effective memory kernel can then be fit to a prony series , and equation [ force_free_gle ] can be integrated using the numerical method developed in this manuscript . in figure [ harmonic_kernel_fit ] , we demonstrate that we can use this inversion procedure to take the exact vaf generated by equation [ harmonic_gle ] , and compute a @xmath139 for equation [ force_free_gle ] that reproduces it : .
note that while the exact vaf evolves under the influence of a harmonic confining potential ( equation [ harmonic_gle ] ) , the integrated vaf is spawned by a gle free of any conservative forces ( equation [ force_free_gle ] ) .
the effect of the force is included in the construction of @xmath139 .
[ harmonic_kernel_fit],title="fig : " ] here , the parameters utilized in equation [ harmonic_gle ] were @xmath146 and @xmath147 , and the associated analytic vaf was fit to a three term prony series .
this initial fit was done to realize a simpler form of the laplace domain vaf , which was inserted into equation [ kernel_fit_eqn ] .
the resultant @xmath139 was also fit to a three term prony series .
it is interesting to note that one term of this fit reduced to a conventional langevin term ( i.e. , one that was proportional to @xmath148 rather than @xmath149 $ ] ) highlighting the utility of our method s reproduction of the langevin limit .
this prony series representation of @xmath139 was used in equation [ force_free_gle ] , which was numerically integrated to yield the integrated vaf result in figure [ harmonic_kernel_fit ] .
this result is especially interesting as it demonstrates capability for effecting a confining potential , on a finite timescale , exclusively through the gle drag / random forces .
this same fitting procedure could be used to remove inter - particle interactions , albeit with some loss of dynamical information , and will be discussed in more detail in future work .
it is important to note that while the dynamics of a confined particle are reproduced in the absence of an explicit confining force , this is only the case over the interval for which the memory kernel is reconstructed . outside of this interval , the asymptotic behavior of the prony series memory kernel will give rise to unbounded diffusive motion . while the expected discrepancies in the dynamics are difficult to notice in the vaf , as both the analytic and reconstructed quantities decay to zero , it is very evident in the mean - squared displacement ( msd ) . here
the asymptotic exponential behavior of the prony series memory kernel necessarily leads to asymptotic diffusive motion signaled by a linear msd .
in contrast , the analytic memory kernel with the confining force will generate an msd that remains bounded .
this is illustrated in figure [ harmonic_msd_comparison ] . here , the fit vaf is integrated to yield the msd for the prony series model , and compared with the exact msd over both the interval of the fit , and beyond .
this example illustrates the importance of choosing an appropriate interval for fitting memory kernels to achieve the appropriate limiting behavior in one s dynamics .
, title="fig : " ]
a family of numerical integration schemes for gld have been presented .
these schemes are based upon an extended variable formulation of the gle in which the memory kernel is rendered as a positive prony series . in certain limits
, it can be shown that a specific instance of this family of integrators exactly conserves the first and second moments of the integrated velocity distribution , and stably approaches the langevin limit . to this end
, we identify this parametrization as optimal , and have implemented it in the md code , lammps .
numerical experiments indicate that this implementation is robust for a number of canonical problems , as well as certain pathologies in the memory kernel .
an exemplary application to reduced order modeling illustrates potential uses of this module for md practitioners .
future work will further develop the vaf fitting procedure in the context of statistical inference methods , and present extensions of the numerical integrator to mixed sign and complex memory kernels .
the authors would like to acknowledge jason bernstein , paul crozier , john fricks , jeremy lechman , rich lehoucq , scott mckinley , and steve plimpton for numerous fruitful discussions and feedback .
sandia national laboratories is a multi - program laboratory managed and operated by sandia corporation , a wholly owned subsidiary of lockheed martin corporation , for the u.s .
department of energy s national nuclear security administration under contract de - ac04 - 94al85000 .
42ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _
_ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) | generalized langevin dynamics ( gld ) arise in the modeling of a number of systems , ranging from structured fluids that exhibit a viscoelastic mechanical response , to biological systems , and other media that exhibit anomalous diffusive phenomena .
molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations that include gld in conjunction with external and/or pairwise forces require the development of numerical integrators that are efficient , stable , and have known convergence properties . in this article
, we derive a family of extended variable integrators for the generalized langevin equation ( gle ) with a positive prony series memory kernel . using stability and error analysis
, we identify a superlative choice of parameters and implement the corresponding numerical algorithm in the lammps md software package .
salient features of the algorithm include exact conservation of the first and second moments of the equilibrium velocity distribution in some important cases , stable behavior in the limit of conventional langevin dynamics , and the use of a convolution - free formalism that obviates the need for explicit storage of the time history of particle velocities .
capability is demonstrated with respect to accuracy in numerous canonical examples , stability in certain limits , and an exemplary application in which the effect of a harmonic confining potential is mapped onto a memory kernel .
+ _ copyright 2013 american institute of physics .
this article may be downloaded for personal use only .
any other use requires prior permission of the author and the american institute of physics . _ |
galaxy biasing " clearly exists . the fact that galaxies of different types cluster differently (
, dressler 1980 ; lahav , nemiroff & piran 1990 , santiago & strauss 1992 ; loveday 1995 ; hermit 1996 ; guzzo 1997 ) implies that not all of them are exact tracers of the underlying mass distribution .
it is obvious from the emptiness of large voids ( , kirshner 1987 ) and the spikiness of the galaxy distribution with @xmath17 spacing ( , broadhurst 1992 ) , especially at high redshifts ( steidel 1996 ; 1998 ) , that if the structure has evolved by standard gravitational instability theory ( gi ) then the galaxy distribution must be biased .
arguments for different kinds of biasing schemes have been put forward and physical mechanisms for biasing have been proposed ( , kaiser 1984 ; davis 1985 ; bardeen 1996 ; dekel & silk 1986 ; dekel & rees 1987 ; braun , dekel & shapiro 1988 ; babul & white 1991 ; lahav & saslaw 1992 ) .
cosmological simulations of galaxy formation clearly indicate galaxy biasing , even at the level of galactic halos ( , cen & ostriker 1992 ; kauffmann , nusser & steinmetz 1997 ; blanton 1998 ; somerville 1998 ) . the biasing becomes stronger at higher redshifts ( , bagla 1998a , 1998b ; jing & suto 1998 ; wechsler 1998 ) .
the biasing scheme is interesting by itself as a constraint on the process of galaxy formation , but it is of even greater importance in many attempts to estimate the cosmological density parameter @xmath18 .
if one assumes a linear and deterministic biasing relation of the sort @xmath19 between the density fluctuations of galaxies and mass , and applies the linear approximation for gravitational instability , @xmath20 with @xmath21 ( peebles 1980 ) , then the observables @xmath22 and @xmath23 are related via the degenerate combination @xmath24 .
thus , one can not pretend to have determined @xmath18 by measuring @xmath13 without a detailed knowledge of the relevant biasing scheme .
it turns out that different methods lead to different estimates of @xmath13 , sometimes from the same data themselves ( for reviews see dekel 1994 , table 1 ; strauss & willick 1995 , table 3 ; dekel , burstein & white 1997 ; dekel 1998a ) .
most recent estimates for optical and iras galaxies lie in the range @xmath25 .
the methods include , for example : ( a ) comparisons of local moments of @xmath1 ( from redshift surveys ) and @xmath2 ( from peculiar velocities ) or the corresponding power spectra or correlation functions ; ( b ) linear regressions of the fields @xmath1 and @xmath2 or the corresponding velocity fields ; ( c ) analyses of redshift distortions in redshift surveys ; and ( d ) comparisons of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) dipole with the local - group velocity as predicted from the galaxy distribution . in order to sharpen our determination of @xmath18
it is important that we understand the sources for this scatter in the estimates of @xmath13 .
some of this scatter is due to the different types of galaxies involved , and some may be due to unaccounted - for effects of nonlinear gravity and perhaps other sources of systematic errors in the data or the methods . in this paper
we investigate the possible contribution to this scatter by nontrivial properties of the biasing scheme the deviations from linear biasing and the stochastic nature of the biasing scheme .
this is done using a simple and natural formalism for general galaxy biasing .
the biasing of density peaks in a gaussian random field is well formulated ( , kaiser 1984 ; bardeen 1986 ) and it provides a very crude theoretical framework for the origin of galaxy density biasing . in this scheme , the galaxy galaxy and mass mass correlation functions are related in the linear regime via ( r ) = b^2 ( r ) , [ eq : xi ] where the biasing parameter @xmath26 is a constant independent of scale @xmath27 . however , a much more specific linear biasing model is often assumed in common applications , in which the local density fluctuation fields of galaxies and mass are assumed to be deterministically related via the relation ( ) = b ( ) .
[ eq : linear ] note that follows from , but the reverse is not true .
the deterministic linear biasing model is not a viable model .
it is based on no theoretical motivation .
if @xmath28 , it must break down in deep voids because values of @xmath22 below @xmath29 are forbidden by definition . even in the simple case of no evolution in comoving galaxy number density , the linear biasing relation is not preserved during the course of fluctuation growth .
non - linear biasing , where @xmath26 varies with @xmath2 , is inevitable . indeed ,
the theoretical analysis of the biasing of collapsed halos versus the underlying mass ( mo & white 1996 ) , using the extended press - schechter approximation ( bond 1991 ) , predicts that the biasing is nonlinear and provides a useful approximation for its behavior as a function of scale , time and mass threshold .
@xmath30-body simulations provide a more accurate description of the nonlinearity of halo biasing ( see figure [ fig:1 ] ; somerville 1998 ) , and show that the model of mo & white is a good approximation . we provide more details about theoretical , numerical and observational constraints on the exact shape of nonlinear biasing in [ sec : constraints ] , where we estimate the magnitude of nonlinear biasing effects .
it is important to realize that once the biasing is nonlinear at one smoothing scale , the smoothing operation acting on the density fields guarantees that the biasing at any other smoothing scale obeys a different functional form of @xmath31 and is also non - deterministic .
thus , any deviation from the simplified linear biasing model must also involve both scale - dependence and scatter .
the focus of this paper is therefore on the consequences of the stochastic properties of the biasing process , which could either be related to the nonlinearity as mentioned above , or arise from other sources of scatter .
an obvious part of this stochasticity can be attributed to the discrete sampling of the density field by galaxies the shot noise .
in addition , a statistical , physical scatter in the efficiency of galaxy formation as a function of @xmath2 is inevitable in any realistic scenario .
it is hard to believe that the sole property affecting the efficiency of galaxy formation is the underlying mass density at a certain smoothing scale ( larger than the scale of galaxies ) .
for example , the random variations in the density on smaller scales is likely to be reflected in the efficiency of galaxy formation . as another example
, the local geometry of the background structure , via the deformation tensor , must play a role too . in this case , the three eigenvalues of the deformation tensor are relevant parameters .
such hidden variables would show up as physical scatter in the density - density relation .
a similar scatter is noticeable in the distribution of particular morphological types versus the underlying total galaxy distribution ( lahav & saslaw 1992 ) .
the hidden scatter is clearly seen for halos in simulations including gravity alone ( [ sec : constraints ] below and figure [ fig:1 ] based on somerville ( 1998 ) even before the more complex processes involving gas dynamics , star formation and feedback affect the biasing and in particular its scatter . in practice , there are two alternative options for dealing with the shot noise component of the scatter
. in some cases one can estimate the shot noise and try to remove it prior to the analysis of measuring @xmath13 .
this is sometimes difficult , , because of the finite extent of the galaxies which introduces anti - correlations on small scales .
the shot noise is especially large and hard to estimate in the case where the biasing refers to light density rather than number density .
the alternative is to treat the shot noise as an intrinsic part of the local stochasticity of the biasing relation without trying to separate it from the physical scatter .
the formalism developed below is valid in either case . in
[ sec : local ] we present the biasing formalism , separate the effects of nonlinear biasing and stochastic biasing , and apply the formalism to measurements involving local second - order moments of @xmath2 and @xmath22 . in [ sec : cor ] we derive relations for two - point correlation functions in the presence of local biasing scatter . in [ sec : dist ] we apply the formalism to the analysis of redshift distortions . in
[ sec : high ] we address methods involving third - order moments . in [ sec : constraints ] we discuss constraints on the nonlinearity and scatter in the biasing scheme based on simulations , simple models and observations . in
[ sec : conc ] we summarize our conclusions and discuss our results and future prospects .
let @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) be the field of mass - density fluctuations and @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) the corresponding field of galaxy - density fluctuations ( or , alternatively , the field of light - density fluctuations , whose time evolution is less sensitive to galaxy mergers ) .
the fields are both smoothed with a fixed smoothing window , which defines the term local " .
the concept of galaxy biasing is meaningful only for smoothing scales larger than the comoving scale of individual galaxies , namely a few mpc .
an example would thus be a top - hat window of radius @xmath36 , for which the rms fluctuations of optical galaxies is about unity .
our analysis is confined to a specific smoothing scale , at a specific time , and for a specific type of objects .
assume that both @xmath2 and @xmath1 are random fields , with one - point probability distribution functions ( pdf ) @xmath37 and @xmath38 , both of zero mean by definition and of standard deviations @xmath39 and @xmath40 . the key idea is to consider the local biasing relation between galaxies and mass to also be a _
process , specified by the _ biasing conditional distribution _
@xmath41 of @xmath1 at a given @xmath2 .
we shall use below in several different ways the following lemma relating joint averaging and conditional averaging for any functions @xmath42 and @xmath43 : = _ , [ eq : lemma ] where the inner average is over the conditional distribution of @xmath1 at a given @xmath2 and the outer average is over the distribution of @xmath2 .
this is true because = dgd p(g , ) ( g ) ( ) = d p ( ) ( ) dg p(g| ) ( g ) , in which the first equality is by definition , and where for the second equality @xmath44 has been replaced by @xmath45 and the double integration has become successive .
define the _
mean biasing function _ @xmath31 by the conditional mean , b ( ) = d g p ( ) g .
this function is plotted in figure [ fig:1 ] .
this is a natural generalization of the deterministic linear biasing relation , @xmath46 .
the function @xmath31 allows for any possible _ non - linear _ biasing and fully characterizes it ; it reduces to the special case of _ linear _ biasing when @xmath47 is a constant independent of @xmath2 . in the following treatment of second - order local moments
, we will find it natural to characterize the function @xmath31 by the moments @xmath6 and @xmath7 defined by /^2 ^2
/^2 . in the case of linear biasing
they both coincide with @xmath48 .
it will be shown that the parameter @xmath6 is the natural generalization of @xmath48 and that the ratio @xmath49 is the relevant measure of nonlinearity in the biasing relation ; it is unity for linear biasing , and is either larger or smaller than unity for nonlinear biasing .
as can be seen from the definitions of @xmath6 and @xmath7 , this measure is independent of the stochasticity of the biasing .
it thus allows one to maintain general nonlinearity while addressing stochasticity .
the local _ statistical _ character of the biasing relation can be expressed by the conditional moments of higher order about the mean at a given @xmath50 .
define the _ random biasing field _ @xmath51 by g - , [ eq : eps ] such that its local conditional mean vanishes by definition , @xmath52
. the local variance of @xmath51 at a given @xmath2 defines the _ biasing scatter function _ @xmath53 by ^2 ( ) /^2 .
[ eq : sbd ] the scaling by @xmath54 is for convenience .
the function @xmath55 is marked by error bars in figure [ fig:1 ] . by averaging over @xmath2 , and using , one obtains the constant of local _ biasing scatter _
[ eq : sb ] thus , to second order , the nonlinear and stochastic biasing relation is characterized locally by three basic parameters : @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath8 .
the parameters @xmath6 and @xmath49 refer to the mean biasing and its nonlinearity , while @xmath56 measures the scatter .
this parameterization separates in a natural way the properties of nonlinearity and stochasticity .
the formalism simply reduces to the case of linear biasing when @xmath57 and to deterministic biasing when @xmath58 .
if the biasing conditional distribution , @xmath59 , is a gaussian [ still allowing @xmath31 and @xmath5 to vary with @xmath2 ] , then the first- and second - order moments fully characterize the biasing relation .
in much of the following we will restrict ourselves to second moments , but we shall see in [ sec : high ] that a generalization to higher biasing moments , such as the skewness , is straightforward
. from the basic parameters defined above one can derive other useful biasing parameters .
a common one is the ratio of _ variances _ , sometimes referred to as the " biasing parameter , ^2 = ^2 + ^2 . [ eq : bv ] the second equality is an interesting result of .
it immediately shows that @xmath15 is sensitive both to nonlinearity and to stochasticity , and that always @xmath61 .
note the roles of @xmath62 and @xmath63 as the respective contributions of biasing nonlinearity and biasing scatter to the total scatter in @xmath1 .
this makes @xmath15 biased compared to @xmath6 , = ( ^2 ^ 2 + ^2 ^ 2 ) ^1/2 , [ eq : bv1 ] by the root of the sum in quadrature of the nonlinearity factor @xmath49 and the scatter factor @xmath56 . using
, the mean parameter @xmath6 is simply related to the _ covariance _ , ^2 = .
[ eq : gm ] thus , @xmath6 is the slope of the linear regression of @xmath1 on @xmath2 and it serves as the basic biasing parameter the natural generalization of the linear biasing parameter @xmath48 . unlike the variance @xmath64 in
, the covariance in has no additional contribution from the biasing scatter @xmath8 .
a complementary parameter to @xmath15 is the _ linear correlation coefficient _ , = = ( ^2 ^ 2 + ^2 ^ 2 ) ^-1/2 .
[ eq : r ] the equalities are based on and respectively .
the inverse " regression , of @xmath2 on @xmath1 , yields another biasing parameter : = = ^2 = ^2 =( ^2 ^ 2 + ^2 ^ 2 ) .
[ eq : binv ] the parameter @xmath65 is closer to what is measured in reality by two - dimensional linear regression ( , sigad 1998 ) , because the errors in @xmath2 are typically larger than in @xmath1 .
note that @xmath65 is biased compared to @xmath6 , with the ratio given by the sum in quadrature of the nonlinearity factor @xmath49 and the scatter factor @xmath56 .
it is worthwhile to summarize the relations between the parameters in the two degenerate cases . in the case of _ linear _ and stochastic biasing , the above parameters reduce to = = b_1,=b_1 ( 1+^2b_1 ^ 2 ) ^1/2 , = b_1 , = b_1 ( 1+^2b_1 ^ 2 ) .
[ eq : lin - sto ] thus , @xmath66 . in the case of nonlinear and _ deterministic _ biasing
they reduce instead to , = 0,=,=,=^2 .
[ eq : nl - det ] both @xmath65 and @xmath15 are biased with respect to @xmath6 , and the bias in @xmath65 is always larger .
whether they are biased high or low compared to @xmath6 depends on whether the nonlinearity factor @xmath49 is larger or smaller than unity , respectively .
we shall see in [ sec : constraints ] that although @xmath6 and @xmath7 could significantly differ from unity and from @xmath67 , the ratio @xmath49 , in realistic circumstances , typically obtains values in the range @xmath68 .
this means that the effects of nonlinearity are likely to be relatively small . in the fully degenerate case of linear and deterministic biasing ,
all the @xmath26 parameters are the same , and only then @xmath69 . note , again , that the parameters @xmath70 and @xmath71 nicely separate the properties of nonlinearity and stochasticity , while the parameters @xmath15 , @xmath27 and @xmath65 mix these properties . in actual applications ,
the above local biasing parameters are involved when the parameter
@xmath13 " is measured from observational data in several different ways . for linear and deterministic biasing this parameter
is defined unambiguously as @xmath72 . but
any deviation from this degenerate model causes us to actually measure different @xmath13 parameters by the different methods . for example , it is the parameter @xmath73 which is determined from measurements of @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
the former is typically determined from a redshift survey , and the latter either from an analysis of peculiar velocity data , or from the abundance of rich clusters ( with a slightly modified @xmath18 dependence ) , or by cobe normalization of a specific power - spectrum shape for mass density fluctuations . as noted in , in the case of stochastic biasing @xmath15
is always an overestimate of @xmath7 .
when the biasing is linear , , @xmath15 is an overestimate of @xmath48 .
the corresponding @xmath76 is thus underestimated accordingly .
a useful way of estimating @xmath13 ( , dekel 1993 ; hudson 1995 ; sigad 1998 ) is via the _ linear regression _ of the fields in our cosmological neighborhood , , @xmath77 on @xmath34 ( or , alternatively , via a regression of the corresponding velocities ) . in the mildly - nonlinear regime , @xmath77 is actually replaced by another function of the peculiar velocity field and its first spatial derivatives , which better approximates the scaled mass - density field @xmath78 ( , nusser 1991 ) .
the regression that is done , taking the errors on both sides into account , is effectively @xmath2 on @xmath22 , because the errors in @xmath23 ( or @xmath79 ) are typically more than twice as large as the errors in @xmath22 ( , sigad 1998 ) .
hence , the parameter that is being measured is close to @xmath80 . in the case of linear gravitational instability and linear deterministic biasing ,
the slope of this regression line is simply @xmath81 .
note in that in the case of linear and stochastic biasing @xmath65 is an overestimate of @xmath48 .
the corresponding @xmath13 is thus underestimated accordingly in this inverse - regression analysis .
for the purpose of redshift - distortion analysis we need to generalize our treatment of stochastic and nonlinear biasing to deal with spatial correlations . given the random biasing field @xmath51 , , we define the two - point biasing
matter cross - correlation function and the biasing auto - correlation function by ( r ) , ( r ) , [ eq : xibb ] where the averaging is over the ensembles at points 1 and 2 separated by @xmath27 .
( recall that throughout this paper the fields are assumed to be smoothed with a given window . ) by the definition of the random biasing field @xmath51 , and the local scatter , , at zero lag one has @xmath82 and @xmath83 .
we now define the biasing as _ local _ if ( r)=0 for any r , ( r)=0 for r > , where @xmath84 is typically on the order of the original smoothing scale .
( some implications of local biasing are discussed in scherrer & weinberg 1998 . ) a two - point equivalent lemma to implies that g_1 = g_1 | _ g| _ g_1 g_2 = g_1 g_2 | _ g| _ .
[ eq : lemma4 ] using these identities , one obtains analogous relations to and : ( r ) = + ( r ) , [ eq : xigm ] ( r ) = + ( r ) .
[ eq : xigg ] in the case of _ linear _ and _ local _ biasing , these become ( r)=b_1 ( r ) , [ eq : xigm_lin ] ( r ) = b_1 ^ 2 ( r ) + ( r ) , ( r)=0 for r>. [ eq : xigg_lin ] note that the biasing parameter that appears here is @xmath48 , not to be confused with @xmath15 when the biasing is stochastic . to see how the power spectra are affected by the biasing scatter , we assume , without limiting the generality of the analysis , that the local biasing can be approximated by a step function : ( r)= .
[ eq : xibb2 ] recalling that the power spectra are the fourier transforms of the corresponding correlation functions , p(k ) = 4_0^(r ) ( kr ) kr r^2 dr , [ eq : p - xi ] we get for @xmath85 , from and , ( k)= b_1 ( k ) , [ eq : pgm ] ( k)= b_1 ^ 2(k ) + ^2 ^ 2 v_b , [ eq : padd ] where @xmath86 is the volume associated with the original smoothing length , @xmath84 . we see that the _ local _ biasing scatter adds to @xmath87 an _ additive constant _ at all @xmath88 values . finally , one can address the effect of the scatter on moments of the fields smoothed at a general smoothing length @xmath89 .
each of these moments is related to the corresponding power spectrum via an integral of the form _
w^2(kr ) p(k ) , [ eq : smooth ] where @xmath90 is the fourier transform of the smoothing window of radius @xmath27 .
using one obtains for linear biasing ^2(r)=b_1 ^ 2 ^2(r ) + ^2 ^ 2 ( /r)^3 .
[ eq : sadd ] in the following section we will apply this formalism to the linear analysis of redshift distortions .
for the purpose of an analysis involving _ nonlinear _ biasing , note that two - point averages as in and are calculable once one knows the function @xmath31 and the one- and two - point distributions of the underlying density field @xmath2 .
it turns out that the relation for @xmath91 , , is in fact a simple extension of involving only the local moment @xmath6 : ( r)=(r ) .
[ eq : xigm_bh ] to prove this , we use @xmath92 to write = dp ( ) b ( ) dp(| ) , and use the fact that @xmath93 . to compute @xmath6
one needs to know only the function @xmath31 and the one - point distribution @xmath37 .
higher - order moments , like the one in , would , in general , involve the two - point pdf as well .
a very promising way of estimating @xmath13 is via redshift distortions in a redshift survey ( , kaiser 1987 , hamilton 1992 , 1993 , 1995 , 1997 ; fisher 1994 ; fisher , scharf & lahav 1994 ; heavens & taylor 1995 ; cole , fisher & weinberg 1995 ; fisher & nusser 1996 ; lahav 1996 ) .
peculiar - velocity gradients along the line of sight distort the comoving volume elements in redshift space compared to the corresponding volumes in real space . as a result ,
a large - scale isotropic distribution of galaxies in real space is observed as an anisotropic distribution in redshift space .
the relation between peculiar velocities and mass density depends on @xmath18 , and hence the distortions relative to the galaxy density depend both on @xmath18 and on the galaxy biasing relation . in the deterministic and linear biasing case ,
this relation involves a single @xmath13 parameter ( see hamilton 1997 ) .
however , in the general biasing case , the distortion analysis is in principle complicated by the fact that the galaxies play two different roles ; they serve both as luminous tracers of the mass distribution as well as test bodies for the peculiar - velocity field .
to first order , the local galaxy density fluctuations in redshift space ( @xmath94 ) and real space ( @xmath22 ) are related by @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is the radial component of the galaxy peculiar velocity @xmath97 .
assuming no velocity biasing , linear gi theory predicts @xmath98 , where @xmath99 is a geometrical factor depending on the angle between @xmath100 and @xmath101 .
thus , the basic linear relation for redshift distortions is g_s = g+f^2 .
[ eq : dist_basic ] a general _ local _ expression for redshift distortions is obtained by taking the mean square : = + 2(f^2 ) + ( f^2)^2 .
[ eq : dist_loc ] with our formalism for stochastic biasing , using and , it becomes ^2 = ^2 [ 1 + 2(f^2 ) ^-1 + ( f^2)^2 ^-2 ] .
[ eq : dist_loc_b ] this is similar to equation ( 7 ) of pen ( 1998 ) , in the sense that it involves both @xmath15 and @xmath10 in a non - trivial way and is thus directly affected by the stochasticity of the biasing scheme .
however , we shall see that this is true _ only _ for the _ local _ moments , at the original smoothing length for which @xmath15 and @xmath10 were defined .
when the biasing is stochastic , the situation at non - zero lag is very different .
the general linear analysis of redshift distortions involves non - local analysis . the general expression in terms of correlation functions
is obtained straightforwardly from by averaging @xmath102 over the distributions of @xmath2 at a pair of points separated by @xmath27 :
^s(r ) = ( r ) + 2(f^2 ) ( r ) + ( f^2)^2 ( r ) .
[ eq : dist_xi ] ( recall that our correlation functions and power spectra correspond to the smoothed fields . )
recalling that the power spectra are the fourier transforms of the corresponding correlation functions , , one can equivalently write ^s(k ) = ( k ) + 2(f^2 ) ( k ) + ( f^2)^2 ( k ) . [ eq : dist_p ] similarly , the spherical harmonic analysis for redshift distortions in linear theory for a flux - limited survey ( fisher , scharf & lahav 1994 , equation 11 ) can be extended to yield for the mean - square harmonics in redshift space : | a_lm^s |^2 = 2 dkk^2 [ | _ l ( k ) |^2 p_gg(k ) + 2 f | _ l ( k ) _
l^c(k ) | p_gm ( k ) + f^2 | _ l^c ( k ) |^2 p_mm(k ) ] , where @xmath103 is the real - space window function and @xmath104 is the redshift - correction window function , both depending on the selection function and the weighting function .
again , this expression mixes the three different power spectra such that the @xmath18 dependence , in general , may involve more than one unique @xmath13 .
the crucial question is how to relate the correlation functions , or power spectra , to the biasing scheme . in the case of linear and deterministic biasing ,
one simply has @xmath105 , so the distortion relation reduces to kaiser s formula , ^s=(1+^2_1)^2 , where @xmath72 ( and here @xmath106 ) . in order to obtain more specific distortion relations for the case of stochastic biasing
, we shall use the spatial correlations from [ sec : cor ] in the general distortion relations of the current section . at zero lag , by definition , @xmath83 . then , as in for the local moments , @xmath107 , and the general distortion relation for @xmath108 , , reduces to an equation similar to the local , in which the second and third terms involve different combinations of @xmath10 and @xmath15 and thus allow to determine them separately .
however , at large separations @xmath89 , where @xmath109 vanishes by the assumption of local biasing , one obtains instead , from and ^s(r ) = ( r ) [ 1 + 2(f^2 ) b_1 ^ -1 + ( f^2)^2 b_1 ^ -2 ] .
[ eq : dist_xi_lin ] this is the degenerate kaiser formula , which is very different from the expression for local moments , . in particular , it is independent of the biasing scatter !
it now involves only the mean biasing parameter @xmath48 ( a degenerate combination of @xmath10 and @xmath15 ) , but it contains no information on the stochasticity , @xmath8 . in terms of @xmath48 ,
the relation for @xmath108 is identical to the case of deterministic biasing .
thus , the distortion analysis at @xmath89 is indeed incapable of evaluating the stochasticity of the process .
this is a straightforward result of the assumed locality of the biasing scheme .
the biasing scatter at two distant points is uncorrelated and therefore its contribution to @xmath110 cancels out . on the other hand ,
the redshift distortion analysis is sensitive to the _ non - linear _ properties of the biasing relation .
a proper analysis would require a nonlinear treatment of the redshift distortions including a nonlinear generalization of the gi relation @xmath111 , because the nonlinear effects of biasing and gravity enter at the same order .
the result is more complicated than , but is calculable in principle once one knows the function @xmath31 and the one- and two - point probability distribution functions of @xmath2 .
the insensitivity to stochasticity remains valid in the case of nonlinear biasing .
back to the case of linear stochastic biasing .
the distortion relation for @xmath112 becomes more complicated because of the additive term in . for linear biasing ,
when substituting in , the terms analogous to the ones involving @xmath113 and @xmath114 in for @xmath108 are multiplied by @xmath115 $ ] , a function of @xmath88 . the distortion relation for @xmath112
is thus affected by the biasing scatter in a complicated way . however ,
if the scatter is small , there may be a @xmath88 range around the peak of @xmath112 where the additive scatter term in is small compared to the rest . in this range
the relation reduces to an expression similar to for the corresponding power spectra .
for example , if @xmath116 we have @xmath117 , while @xmath118 at the peak ( , kolatt & dekel 1997 ) , so a significant @xmath88 range of this sort is viable , especially if @xmath119 .
on the other hand , the scatter term always dominates at small and at large @xmath88 s .
if @xmath120 , then the scatter may dominate already not much below @xmath121 . in terms of moments of a general smoothing length @xmath89 ,
using in one obtains a complicated distortion relation again . for small scatter
there may be a limited range of scales for which the first term in dominates and then the distortions reduce to an equation similar to for moments of smoothed fields . at large enough scales , where @xmath122 is rising with @xmath88 and
thus @xmath54 is decreasing faster than @xmath123 , the scatter becomes dominant .
note that in order to obtain equation ( 7 ) of pen ( 1998 ) from the general linear distortion relation , , one has to define @xmath88-dependent biasing parameters by @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
( note that pen s @xmath13 refers to his @xmath48 , which is equivalent to our @xmath15 , except that he allows it to vary with @xmath88 ) .
in the case of local biasing , a comparison to our and yields @xmath126 and @xmath127 . in the @xmath88 range near the peak of @xmath128 where the constant term in may be negligible , one has @xmath129 and @xmath130 , and there is indeed no sign of the stochasticity in the distortion relation .
we now move to measures of biasing involving third - order moments .
given the biasing random fields @xmath51 , define the biasing skewness function @xmath131 , in analogy to @xmath53 of , by ( ) s , [ eq : skewb ] where @xmath132 .
after averaging over @xmath2 , the biasing skewness parameter is /s .
the biasing parameter that is defined by ratio of skewness moments is then , based on and after some algebra , b_3 ^ 3 = s + 3 ^ 2 s + . in the case of deterministic biasing ,
@xmath133 , one has b_3 ^ 3 = s , which differs from the parameters @xmath6 and @xmath7 of [ sec : local ] due to nonlinear effects . in the linear case where both @xmath31 and @xmath53 are constants , the expression for @xmath134 reduces to b_3 = b_1 ( 1 + b_1 ^ 3 ) ^1/3 . now ,
if @xmath135 , then @xmath136 independently of @xmath8 .
if , on the other hand , @xmath137 is positively skewed , then @xmath138 . an interesting quantity involving the skewness and variance of @xmath2
is @xmath139 . in the second - order approximation to gi with gaussian initial fluctuations
this quantity is constant in time . for top - hat smoothing and a given power spectrum of an effective power index @xmath140 at the smoothing scale ,
this constant is @xmath141 ( juszkiewicz 1993 ) .
the corresponding quantity involving the moments of @xmath22 , @xmath142 , provides an observational measure of biasing ( weinberg 1995 ) : b_s3 ^ -1 = b_3 ^ 3 ^4 = /s + 3 ^ 3 /s + [ /^2 + ^2]^2 . in the case of deterministic biasing ,
b_s3 = ^2 /^4 /s . in the case of linear biasing where @xmath31 and @xmath53 are constants
, this ratio reduces to b_s3 = b_1 ( 1+^2/b_1 ^ 2)^2 1+/b_1 ^ 3 .
the biasing parameter obtained this way thus depends both on @xmath8 and @xmath143 . if @xmath135 , as when @xmath137 is gaussian , then @xmath144 , and the deviation from @xmath48 is even larger than that of @xmath65 or @xmath15 , . for positive biasing skewness @xmath143 ,
the parameter @xmath145 may in fact become smaller than @xmath48 .
szapudi ( 1998 ) has shown that , under certain simplifying assumptions , the biasing parameters ( taken as two coefficients in a taylor expansion , ) can be determined using three - point statistics ( cumulant correlators ) .
the assumptions made are that the biasing is local , deterministic and scale independent , and that redshift distortions are negligible .
this approach should be generalized to the more realistic case of stochastic biasing and to allow other nontrivial features in the biasing scheme .
the cosmic energy equation ( ce ) ( peebles 1980 , 74 ; peebles 1993 , eq .
20.11 ; davis , miller & white 1997 ) can be used to determine @xmath18 by relating the observed dispersion of galaxy peculiar velocities to a spatial integral over the galaxy mass cross - correlation function , @xmath146 .
the observable is the galaxy galaxy auto - correlation function @xmath147 , so the corresponding biasing parameter is b_ce = / . at zero lag , @xmath148 of . at non - zero lag
, @xmath149 can be derived from and . for linear biasing , and , one obtains at non - zero lag @xmath150 , which is different from @xmath65 if the biasing is stochastic , .
the estimation of @xmath18 via the cosmic virial theorem ( cv ) , as applied to galaxy surveys ( peebles 1980 , 75 ; bartlett & blanchard 1996 ) , relates the observed dispersion of galaxy galaxy peculiar velocities to a spatial integral over the 3-point galaxy galaxy mass cross - correlation function , @xmath151 ( divided by @xmath152 ) .
the observable is the 3-point galaxy correlation function @xmath153 , so the corresponding biasing parameter is b_cv = / . at zero lag , using , b_cv = + 3 ^ 2 + s + ^2 . in the case of deterministic but nonlinear biasing ,
@xmath154 , which in general differs from any of the biasing parameters discussed so far .
if @xmath31 and @xmath53 are constants and the biasing is stochastic , then , at zero lag , @xmath155 .
if the analysis is done on scales smaller than the biasing coherence length @xmath84 , then the local expressions are relevant .
otherwise , one needs to appeal to three - point spatial correlations .
note that in the case of cv or ce ( which are valid on small scales ) the measured quantity may be @xmath156 or @xmath157 , depending on the application , rather than @xmath13 which is typical in applications based on the linear approximation to gravitational instability .
in the scheme outlined above , the local biasing process at given scale , time and galaxy type , is characterized by the conditional probability density function @xmath3 .
the conditional mean , or the function @xmath158 , contains the information about the mean biasing ( via the parameter @xmath6 ) and the nonlinear features ( , via @xmath70 ) .
the first additional quantity of interest in the case of non - negligible scatter in the biasing relation can be the conditional standard deviation , the function @xmath159 , and its variance over @xmath2 , @xmath63 . in order to evaluate the actual effects of nonlinear and stochastic biasing on the various measurements of @xmath13
, one should first try to constrain these functions or evaluate these parameters from simulations , theoretical approximations , and observations . in an ongoing study , somerville ( 1998 )
are investigating the biasing in high - resolution @xmath30-body simulations of several cosmological scenarios , both for galactic halos and for galaxies as identified using semi - analytic models .
earlier results from simulations were obtained , , by cen & ostriker ( 1992 ) and in more detail by mo & white ( 1996 ) .
we refer here to an example of the preliminary results of somerville , in the context of our biasing formalism . as our test case we use a representative cosmological model : @xmath160 with a @xmath161cdm power spectrum which roughly obeys the constraints from large - scale structure .
the simulation mass resolution is @xmath162 inside a box of comoving side @xmath163 .
the present epoch is identified with the time when the rms mass fluctuation in a top - hat sphere of radius @xmath36 is @xmath164 .
figure [ fig:1 ] is borrowed from somerville ( 1998 ) in order to demonstrate the qualitative features of the biasing scheme .
it shows the density fluctuation fields of galactic halos versus mass at the points of a uniform grid at two different times .
the halos are selected above a mass threshold of @xmath165 .
the fields are smoothed with a top - hat window of radius @xmath36 .
the conditional mean [ @xmath166 and the conditional scatter [ @xmath167 are marked .
the nonlinear behavior in the negative regime , @xmath168 , is characteristic of all masses , times , and smoothing scales : the function @xmath169 is flat near @xmath170 and it abruptly steepens towards @xmath171 . in the positive regime , @xmath172 ,
the behavior is less robust it strongly depends on the mass , time and smoothing scale .
the scatter in the figure includes both shot noise and physical scatter which are hard to separate properly .
the scatter function @xmath53 grows rapidly from zero at @xmath173 to a certain value near @xmath171 , and it continues to grow slowly for @xmath174 to an asymptotic value at large @xmath2 . in the case shown at @xmath175 ,
the nonlinear parameter is @xmath176 , and the scatter parameter is @xmath177 .
the effects of stochasticity and nonlinearity in this specific case thus lead to moderate differences in the various measures of @xmath13 , on the order of @xmath178 .
gas - dynamics and other non - gravitational processes may extend the range of estimates even further . a recent hint for the origin of physical scatter in the biasing scheme is provided by blanton ( 1998 ) .
they find , based on hydrodynamic cosmological simulations , that the local gas temperature , which is an important factor affecting the efficiency of galaxy formation , is not fully correlated with the other dominant factor the local mass density .
they therefore argue that this is a physical hidden variable that contributes to the stochasticity proposed in our current paper .
they also detect significant scale dependence in the biasing scheme , and identify its main source with the correlation of the temperature with the large scale gravitational potential . given the distribution @xmath37 of the matter fluctuations , the biasing function @xmath31 should obey by definition at least the following two constrains : * @xmath179 everywhere because the galaxy density @xmath180 can not be negative , and @xmath181 at @xmath173 because there are no galaxies where there is no matter . *
@xmath182 because @xmath1 describes fluctuations about the mean galaxy density .
an example for a simple functional form that obeys the constraint at @xmath183 and reduces to the linear relation near @xmath184 is ( , dekel 1993 ) = c ( 1+)^b -1 . [ eq : powerb ] the constraint @xmath182 is to be enforced by a specific choice of the factor @xmath185 as a function of the power @xmath26 . with @xmath28 , this functional form indeed provides a reasonable fit to the simulated halo biasing relation in the @xmath186 regime .
however , the same value of @xmath26 does not necessarily fit the biasing relation in the @xmath187 regime , which can require either @xmath188 or @xmath28 depending on halo mass , smoothing scale and redshift . a better approximation could thus be provided by a combination of two functions like with two different biasing parameters @xmath189 and @xmath190 in the regimes @xmath191 and @xmath174 respectively
. another useful version of such a combination is = , which provides an even better fit to the behavior in fig .
[ fig:1 ] . as mentioned above
, the parameter @xmath189 is always larger than unity while @xmath190 ranges from slightly below unity to much above unity .
the best fit to fig .
[ fig:1 ] at @xmath175 has @xmath192 and @xmath193 . at high redshift
both @xmath189 and @xmath190 become significantly larger .
the nonlinear biasing relation can alternatively be parameterized by a general power series : = _
[ eq : taylor ] since @xmath1 must average to zero , this power series can be written as = b_1 + 12b_2 ( ^2 -^2 ) + 16b_3 ( ^3 -s ) + ... , [ eq : taylor3 ] where @xmath39 , @xmath194 , etc .
this determines the constant term @xmath195 .
the constraint at @xmath29 provides another relation between the parameters .
therefore , the expansion to third order contains only two free parameters out of four . in order to evaluate the parameters @xmath6 and @xmath7 for these nonlinear toy models , we approximate the density pdf as a gaussian , or alternatively as log - normal in @xmath196 ( , coles & jones 1991 ; kofman 1994 ) : p()= 1 ^1/2 1 ( 1+)(-[(1+)-(1+^2)^-1/2]^2 2(1+^2 ) ) . [ eq : lognormal ] the only free parameter is @xmath197 .
the skewness , for example , is @xmath198 , etc . for nonlinear biasing that is described by taylor expansion to third order ( ) and a gaussian or log - normal density pdf , assuming @xmath199 and @xmath200 ,
one obtains 1 + 12 ( b_2 b_1)^2 ^2 .
this is always larger than unity , but the deviation is small .
alternatively , using the functional form of , with @xmath189 ranging from 1 to 5 , @xmath190 ranging from 0.5 to 3 , and a log - normal pdf of @xmath201 , we find numerically that @xmath49 is in the range 1.0 to 1.15 .
these two toy models , which approximate the nonlinear biasing behavior seen for halos in the @xmath30-body simulations , indicate that despite the obvious nonlinearity , especially in the negative regime , the nonlinear parameter @xmath49 is typically only slightly larger than unity .
this means that the effects of nonlinear biasing on measurements of @xmath13 are likely to be relatively small . a quick comment on gaussian " and bivariate gaussian " biasing , which has been used in the recent literature ( , pen 1998 ) .
a specific model for nonlinear and stochastic biasing is where the conditional distribution is a gaussian , but allowing @xmath31 and @xmath5 to vary with @xmath2 : p(g| ) .
based on the @xmath30-body simulations , this is a reasonable approximation for galactic halos .
however , the model of _ bivariate gaussian _ biasing , which might be tempting because it makes some of the computations easier , is much more restrictive ; it is in fact a special case of _ linear _ biasing .
this model assumes that the joint distribution of galaxies and mass is a two - dimensional gaussian , p ( , ) , where @xmath202 and @xmath203 , and with the local biasing correlation coefficient @xmath204const .
if @xmath37 is also a gaussian , @xmath205 $ ] , the conditional probability is p(|)=p ( , ) p ( ) .
[ eq : condg ] this is a one - dimensional gaussian for @xmath206 , with mean @xmath207 and variance @xmath208 . back to the quantities @xmath1 and @xmath2 , the conditional mean is @xmath209 , where @xmath210 as usual .
this is thus a special case of _ linear _ biasing , with a constant linear biasing parameter @xmath211 independent of @xmath2 , as in . from the conditional variance of the gaussian distribution in
, the biasing scatter is also a constant independent of @xmath2 , @xmath212 . based on @xmath30-body simulations
, linear biasing could be a poor approximation even for galactic halos .
the whole biasing scheme is characterized in this case by only two parameters , @xmath15 and @xmath27 , or alternatively @xmath48 and @xmath8 , independent of @xmath2 .
direct constraints on the local biasing field should , in principle , be provided by the data themselves , of galaxy density ( , from redshift surveys ) versus mass density ( , from peculiar velocity surveys , or gravitational lensing ) .
it is a bit early to deduce the nonlinear shape of @xmath31 from these data because of the large errors that they involve at present .
however , we note a qualitative example of scatter in the biasing relation in the fact that the smoothed density peaks of the great attractor ( ga ) and perseus pisces ( pp ) are of comparable height in the mass distribution as recovered by potent from observed velocities ( , dekel 1994 ; dacosta 1996 ; dekel 1998 ) , but pp is significantly higher than ga in the galaxy map ( , hudson 1995 ; sigad 1998 ) .
for example , a linear regression of the @xmath213-smoothed density fields of potent mass and optical galaxies in our cosmological neighborhood yields a @xmath214 per degree of freedom for the assumed errors in the data ( hudson 1995 ) . one way to obtain a @xmath215 , as desired ,
is to assume a biasing scatter of @xmath216 in the optical density ( while @xmath217 at that smoothing ) . with @xmath218 ,
one has @xmath219 .
this is only a very crude estimate , and there is yet much to be done along similar lines with future data .
a promising method has been worked out ( sigad & dekel 1998 ; see also dekel 1998b ) for recovering the mean biasing function @xmath158 and its associated parameters @xmath6 and @xmath7 from a measured pdf ( or counts in cells ) of galaxies in a redshift survey .
if @xmath220 were deterministic and monotonic , then it could be derived from the cumulative pdfs of galaxies and mass , @xmath221 and @xmath222 , via @xmath223 $ ] ( also narayanan & weinberg 1998 ) .
it is found for halos in @xmath30-body simulations that this is a good approximation for @xmath169 despite the scatter .
the other key point confirmed by a suite of simulations is that @xmath222 is relatively insensitive to the cosmological model or the fluctuation power spectrum , and can be approximated for our purpose by a log - normal distribution in @xmath224 ( , bernardeau 1994 ; bernardeau & kofman 1995 ) .
thus , @xmath31 can be evaluated from a measured @xmath221 and the rms @xmath225 of mass fluctuations on the same smoothing scale .
since redshift surveys are by far richer than peculiar - velocity samples , this method will allow a better handle on @xmath31 than the local comparison of density fields of galaxies and mass .
it can be applied to local redshift surveys as well as surveys of objects at high redshift .
constraints on the biasing scheme can also be obtained by comparing the clustering properties of galaxies of different types in a given redshift surveys ( , lahav & saslaw 1992 ) .
indeed , partly motivated by the ideas of our current paper , a clear confirmation for nontrivial biasing , non - linear and/or stochastic beyond shot noise , has recently been reported by tegmark & bromley ( 1998 ) based on the las campanas redshift survey .
we have introduced a straightforward formalism for describing the biasing relation between the density fluctuation fields of galaxies and mass , based on the conditional probability function @xmath3 .
the key feature of this formalism is the natural separation between nonlinear and stochastic effects in the biasing scheme .
the nonlinearity is expressed by the conditional mean via the function @xmath31 , and the statistical scatter is measured by the conditional standard deviation , @xmath53 , and higher moments if necessary . for analyses using local moments of second order ,
the biasing scheme is characterized by three parameters : @xmath6 measuring the mean biasing , @xmath49 measuring the effect of nonlinearity , and @xmath56 measuring the effect of stochasticity .
deviations from linear and deterministic biasing typically result in biased estimates of the biasing parameter , or the parameter @xmath13 ( @xmath226 ) , which depend on the actual method of measurement .
the nonlinearity and the scatter lead to differences of order @xmath11 and @xmath12 respectively in the different estimators of @xmath13 using second - order local moments .
they typically lead to an underestimate of @xmath13 with respect to @xmath227 . based on @xmath30-body simulations and toy models , the effects of nonlinear biasing are typically small , on the order of 20% or less , and the effects of scatter could be somewhat larger .
one expects the @xmath13 parameters from second - order local moments to be biased in the following order : @xmath228 .
the stochasticity affects the redshift - distortion analysis only by limiting the useful range of scales , especially in the analysis involving power spectra . in this range , for _ linear _ stochastic biasing
, the basic _ linear _ expression reduces to the simple kaiser formula for @xmath229 ( not @xmath15 ) , and it does not involve the scatter at all .
the distortion analysis is in principle sensitive to the nonlinear properties of biasing , but the nonlinear effects , especially at low redshifts , are expected to be weak , and on the same order as the effects of nonlinear gravitational instability .
this is good news for the prospects of measuring an unbiased @xmath13 from redshift distortions in the large redshift surveys of the near future ( 2df and sdss ) .
a detailed nonlinear analysis of redshift distortions with nonlinear biasing will be reported in a subsequent paper .
more detailed studies of simulations , including different recipes for galaxy formation , are required in order to constrain the parameters of the biasing formalism more accurately .
the analysis could also be extended to include non - local biasing , using the biasing correlations as defined here .
the study of stochastic and nonlinear biasing should be extended to address the time evolution of biasing because many relevant measurements of galaxy clustering are now being done at high redshifts . as seen in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , the biasing is clearly a function of cosmological epoch ( , rees , private communication ; dekel & rees 1987 ; mo & white 1996 ; steidel et al . 1996 ; 1998 ; bagla 1998a , 1998b ; matarrese 1997 ; wechsler 1998 ; peacock 1998 ) . in particular ,
if galaxy formation is limited to a given epoch and the biasing is linear , one can show ( , fry 1996 ) that the linear biasing factor @xmath48 would eventually approach unity as a simple result of the continuity equation .
tegmark & peebles ( 1998 ) have generalized the analytic study of time evolution to the case of stochastic but still linear biasing and showed how @xmath15 and @xmath27 approach unity in this case .
analytic attempts to study the evolution of mildly nonlinear stochastic biasing have been reported recently ( taruya , koyama & soda 1998 ; taruya & soda 1998 ; catelan 1998 ; catelan , matarrese & porciani 1998 ; sheth & lemson 1998 ) .
these studies can be extended to the general nonlinear case using our formalism .
the simulations of somerville ( 1998 ) are aimed at this goal .
more accurate measurements of peculiar velocities in our greater cosmological neighborhood , and careful comparisons to the galaxy distribution , promise to allow improved observational estimates of the biasing scatter in the future .
the reconstruction of the large - scale mass distribution based on weak gravitational lensing ( van waerbeke 1998 ; 1999 ; schneider 1998 ; kaiser 1998 ) is also becoming promising for this purpose . the main moral of this paper is that in order to put any measurement of @xmath13 in cosmological perspective , and in particular when trying to use it for an accurate measurement of the cosmological parameter @xmath18 , one should consider the effects of nonlinear and stochastic biasing and the associated complications of scale dependence , time dependence , and type dependence .
the current different estimates are expected to span a range of @xmath230 in @xmath13 due to stochastic and nonlinear biasing .
the analysis of redshift distortions seems to be most promising ; once it is limited to the appropriate range of scales , the analysis is independent of stochasticity and the nonlinear effects are expected to be relatively small .
babul , a. , & white , s. d. m. 1991 , , 253 , l31 bagla , j. s. 1998 , , 297 , 251 bagla , j. s. 1998 , , 299 , 417 bardeen , j. , bond , j. r. , kaiser , n. , & szalay , a. 1986 , , 304 , 15 bartlett , j.b . , & blanchard , a. 1996 , , 464 , 805 bernardeau , f. 1994 , , 291 , 697 bernardeau , f. , & kofman , l. 1995 , , 443 , 479 blanton , m. , cen , r. , ostriker , j. p. , & strauss , m. a. 1998 , submitted ( astro - ph/9807029 ) bond , j.r . , cole , s. , efstathiou , g. , & kaiser , n. 1991 , , 379 , 440 braun , e. , dekel , a. , & shapiro , p. 1988
, , 328 , 34 broadhurst , t. j. , ellis , r. s. , koo , d. c. , & szalay , a. s. , 1990 , nature , 343 , 726 catalan , p. , matarrese , s. , & porciani , c. 1998 , , in press ( astro - ph/9804250 ) catalan , p. , lucchin , f. , matarrese , s. , & porciani , c. 1998 , , 297 , 692 cen , r. , & ostriker , j. p. 1992 , apj , 399 , l113 cole , s. , fisher , k. b. , & weinberg , d. 1995 , , 275 , 515 coles , p. , & jones , b. 1991 , , 248 , 1 da costa , l. n. , freudling , w. , wegner , g. , giovanelli , r. , haynes , m. p. , & salzer , j. j. 1996 , , 468 , l5 davis , m. , efstathiou , g. , frenk , c. s. , & white , s. d. m. 1985 , , 292 , 371 davis , m. , miller , a. , & white , s. d. m. 1997 , , 460 , 63 dekel , a. 1994 , , 32 , 371 dekel , a. 1997 , in _ galaxy scaling relations : origins , evolution and applications _ ( eso workshop , november 1996 ) , ed . l. da costa ( springer ) in press ( astro - ph/9705033 ) dekel , a. 1998a , in press dekel , a. 1998b , in large - scale surveys ( iap symposium xiv ) eds . y. mellier & s. colombi ( gif - sur - yvette : editions frontires ) , in press ( astro - ph/9809291 ) dekel , a. , bertschinger , e. , yahil , a. , strauss , m. a. , davis , m. , & huchra j. p. 1993
, , 412 , 1 ( pi93 ) dekel , a. , burstein , d. , & white , s.d.m .
1997 , in _ critical dialogues in cosmology _ , ed .
n. turok ( singapore : world scientific ) , p. 175
( astro - ph/9611108 ) dekel , a. , eldar , a. , kolatt , t. , willick , j. a. , faber , s. m. , courteau , s. , & burstein , d. 1998 , in preparation dekel , a. , & rees , m. j. 1987 , , 326 , 455 dekel , a. , & silk , j. 1986 , , 303 , 39 dressler , a. 1980 , , 236 , 351 fisher , k. b. , davis , m. , strauss , m. a. , yahil , a. , & huchra , j. p. 1994
, , 267 , 927 fisher , k. b. , & nusser , a. 1996 , , 279 , l1 fisher , k. b. , scharf , c. a. , & lahav , o. 1994 , , 266 , 219 fry , j. n. 1996 , , 461 , l65 guzzo , l. , strauss , m. a. , fisher , k. b. , giovanelli , r. , & haynes , m. p. 1997
, , 489 , 37 hamilton , a. j. s. 1992 , , 385 , l5 hamilton , a. j. s. 1993 , , 406 , l47 hamilton , a. j. s. 1995 , in _ clustering in the universe _ , proc .
30@xmath231 rencontres de moriond , ed .
s. maurogordato , c. balkowski , c. tao , and j. trn thanh vn ( gif - sur - yvette : editions frontires ) , 143 hamilton , a. j. s. 1997 , , 289 , 285 heavens , a. f. , & taylor , a. n. 1995 , , 275 , 483 hermit , s. , santiago , b. x. , lahav , o. , strauss , m. a. , davis , m. , dressler , a. , & huchra , j. p. 1996
, , 283 , 709 hudson , m. j. , dekel , a. , courteau , s. , faber , s. m. , & willick , j. a. 1995 , , 274 , 305 jing , y. p. , & suto , y. 1998 , , 494 , l5 juszkiewicz , r. , bouchet , f. r. , & colombi , s. 1993 , , 412 l9 kaiser , n. 1984 , , 284 , l9 kaiser , n. 1987 , , 227 , 1 kaiser , n. , wilson , g. , luppino , g. , kofman , l. , gioia , i. , metzger , m. , & dahle , h. 1998 , ( astro - ph/9809268 ) kauffman , g. , nusser , a. , & steinmetz , m. 1997 , , 286 , 795 kirshner , r. p. , oemler , a. jr .
, schechter , p. l. , & shectman , s. a. 1987 , 314 , 493 [ ] kofman , l. , bertschinger , e. , gelb , j. , nusser , a. and dekel , a. 1994 , , 420 , 44 kolatt , t. , & dekel , a. 1997 , , 479 , 592 lahav , o. 1996 , helvetica physica acta , 96 , 388 lahav , o. , nemiroff , r. j. , & piran , t. 1990 , , 350 , 119 lahav , o. , & saslaw , w. 1992 , , 396 , 430 loveday 1995 , , 442 , 457 matarrese , s. , coles , p. , lucchin , f. , & moscardini , l. 1997 , , 286 , 115 mo , h. , & white , s.d.m .
1996 , , 282 , 347 narayanan , v. k. , & weinberg , d. h. 1998 , , in press ( astro - ph/9806238 ) nusser , a. , dekel , a. , bertschinger , e. , & blumenthal , g. r. 1991 , , 379 , 6 peacock , j. a. 1998 , phil .
a , submitted ( astro - ph/9805208 ) .
peebles , p. j. e. 1980 , large - scale structure in the universe ( princeton university press ) peebles , p. j. e. 1993 , principles of physical cosmology ( princeton university press ) pen , u .- l . 1998 , apj , 504 , 601 santiago , b. x. & strauss , m. a. 1992 , , 387 , 9 scherrer , r.j . & weinberg , d.h . 1998 , apj , 504 , 607 schneider , p. 1998 , apj , 498 , 43 sheth , r. k. , & lemson , g. 1998 , mnras , submitted ( astro - ph/9808138 ) sigad , y. , & dekel , a. 1998 , in preparation sigad , y. , eldar , a. , dekel , a. , strauss , m. a. , & yahil , a. 1998 , , 495 , 516 ( astro - ph/9708141 ) somerville , r. , sigad , y. , lemson , g. , dekel , a. , colberg , j. , kauffmann , g. , & white , s. d. m. 1998 , in preparation steidel , c. c. , adelberger , k. l. , dickinson , m. , giavalisco , m. , pettini , m. , & kellogg , m. 1998 , , 492 , 428 steidel , c. c. , giavalisco , m. , pettini , m. , dickinson , m. , & adelberger , k. l. 1996 , , 462 , l17 strauss , m. a. , & willick , j. a. 1995 , , 261 , 271 szapudi , i. 1998 , , submitted ( astro - ph/9805090 ) taruya , a. , koyama , k. , & soda , j. 1998 , submitted ( astro - ph/9807005 ) taruya , a. , & soda , j. 1998 , submitted ( astro - ph/9809204 ) tegmark , m. & bromley , b. c. 1998 , submitted ( astro - ph/9809324 ) tegmark , m. & peebles , p. j. e. 1998 , submitted ( astro - ph/9804067 ) van waerbeke , l. 1998 , a&a , 334 ,
1 van waerbeke , l. 1999 , ( astro - ph/9807041 ) wechsler , r. h. , gross , m. a. k. , primack , j. r. , blumenthal , g. r. , & dekel , a. 1998 , , 506 , 19 ( astro - ph/9712141 ) weinberg , d. h. 1995 , in wide - field spectroscopy and the distant universe , eds . s. j. maddox & a. aragon - salamanaca ( singapore : world scientific ) , 129 | we propose a general formalism for galaxy biasing and apply it to methods for measuring cosmological parameters , such as regression of light versus mass , the analysis of redshift distortions , measures involving skewness and the cosmic virial theorem . the common linear and deterministic relation @xmath0 between the density fluctuation fields of galaxies @xmath1 and mass @xmath2 is replaced by the conditional distribution @xmath3 of these random fields , smoothed at a given scale at a given time . the nonlinearity is characterized by the conditional mean @xmath4 , while the local scatter is represented by the conditional variance @xmath5 and higher moments .
the scatter arises from hidden factors affecting galaxy formation and from shot noise unless it has been properly removed . for applications involving second - order local moments ,
the biasing is defined by three natural parameters : the slope @xmath6 of the regression of @xmath1 on @xmath2 , a nonlinearity @xmath7 , and a scatter @xmath8 .
the ratio of variances @xmath9 and the correlation coefficient @xmath10 mix these parameters .
the nonlinearity and the scatter lead to underestimates of order @xmath11 and @xmath12 in the different estimators of @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) .
the nonlinear effects are typically smaller .
local stochasticity affects the redshift - distortion analysis only by limiting the useful range of scales , especially for power spectra . in this range , for linear stochastic biasing
, the analysis reduces to kaiser s formula for @xmath6 ( not @xmath15 ) , independent of the scatter .
the distortion analysis is affected by nonlinear properties of biasing but in a weak way .
estimates of the nontrivial features of the biasing scheme are made based on simulations and toy models , and strategies for measuring them are discussed .
they may partly explain the range of estimates for @xmath13 .
# 1equation ( [ eq:#1 ] ) # 1equations ( [ eq:#1 ] ) # 1([eq:#1 ] ) # 1equation ( [ eq:#1 ] ) # 1equations ( [ eq:#1 ] ) #
1#1@xmath16 # 10= -.025em0 - 0 .05em0 - 0 -.025em.0433em0 # 1#1 |
the loewner differential equation was introduced by karl lwner @xcite ( who later changed his name to charles loewner ) to study properties of univalent functions on the unit disk .
the differential equation is driven by a function that encodes in an ingeneous way continuous curves slitting the disk from the boundary .
a few years ago , oded schramm realized that by taking brownian motion as the driving function , the loewner equation generates families of random curves with a conformally invariant measure , that he called `` stochastic loewner evolutions '' ( sle s ) @xcite .
moreover , he showed that if the loop - erased random walk has a scaling limit , and if this scaling limit is conformally invariant , then it must be described by an sle , and he made similar conjectures about the scaling limits of uniform spanning trees and of critical percolation .
the existence of conformally invariant scaling limits and the connections with sle were established for the first two models by lawler , schramm and werner @xcite , and for critical site percolation on the triangular lattice by smirnov @xcite . over the past few years schramm s idea has been investigated further , mainly in a combined effort of lawler , schramm and werner @xcite , leading to new developments in the study of ( the scaling limit of ) discrete models . in sle
an ensemble of driving functions generates an ensemble of shapes .
it is a difficult task to understand fully the relation between these two ensembles .
for this reason we investigate here the simpler problem of the relation between a driving term in loewner s equation and the curve it generates , by explicit calculation .
in particular we study exact , deterministic solutions of loewner s equation in the upper half @xmath13 of the complex plane .
one of the purposes of this study is to present some explicit examples that may help to elucidate the behavior of the curves generated by loewner s equation .
for example , our solution for square - root forcing in section [ squarerootforcing ] shows a transition from a simple curve that stays above the real line to a curve intersecting the real line , which is similar to the transition occurring at @xmath14 in sle . to get us started , we need to understand how the loewner equation describes curves slitting the half - plane @xmath13 .
so suppose that @xmath15 , @xmath16 , is a simple curve in @xmath13 emanating from the real line .
then according to conformal mapping theory , there exists a unique conformal mapping of the form @xmath17 that takes the domain @xmath18 consisting of all points in @xmath13 minus those on the slit @xmath19 $ ] onto the upper half of the @xmath20-plane , in such a way that near infinity this map has the expansion @xmath21 see figure [ slitmap ] for a schematic picture of the mapping .
it is a theorem that the coefficient @xmath22 ( which is called the _ capacity _ ) is continuously increasing with @xmath6 .
therefore , the parameterization of the curve can be chosen such that @xmath23 , and henceforth we assume that this is the case . in the @xmath24-plane maps into a linear boundary in the @xmath20-plane .
notice that two neighbouring points in the @xmath24-plane have images which are far apart in the @xmath20-plane . ]
the conformal maps @xmath25 satisfy a surprisingly simple differential equation , which is the loewner equation [ le ] @xmath26 with the initial condition @xmath27 for all @xmath24 in @xmath13 . here
, the value of @xmath28 at time @xmath6 is just the image of the point @xmath15 under the map @xmath25 .
we call @xmath0 the driving function or forcing function of the loewner equation
. it is continuous and real - valued .
( for a text - book discussion of loewner s equation and proofs of the above statements when the domain is the unit disk , see @xcite and @xcite .
the half - plane case we are considering here is analogous and is discussed in @xcite and @xcite ) .
conversely , the loewner equation ( [ le ] ) has a solution for any given continuous real - valued function @xmath0 .
this generates the function @xmath29 . for each value of @xmath6
this function can be thought of as a mapping of the form @xmath17 which takes some connected subset of the upper - half @xmath24-plane , @xmath18 , into the entire region @xmath13 above the real axis of the @xmath20-plane .
correspondingly , there exists an inverse function @xmath30 , which obeys @xmath31 for all @xmath20 in the upper half - plane .
this function maps the region @xmath13 of the @xmath20-plane into the region @xmath18 of the @xmath24-plane .
it obeys the partial differential equation @xmath32 the loewner equation continually generates new singular points of @xmath25 that are mapped by @xmath25 onto the corresponding points @xmath0 in the @xmath20-plane .
thus , as time goes on , points are continually removed from @xmath18 .
if @xmath0 is sufficiently smooth @xcite , these singular points form a simple curve @xmath33 , where the points @xmath33 obey @xmath34 this curve is called the trace of the loewner evolution , but we also refer to it as the line of singularities .
( naturally , if we take @xmath0 to be the driving function corresponding to a given curve @xmath15 as described above , then @xmath33 will coincide with @xmath15 ) .
equations ( [ le ] ) have a simple scale invariance property under changing both the scale of space and of time .
any change of time of the form @xmath35 can be compensated by a change of scale . to do this , define a new @xmath36 and @xmath28 by @xmath37 this pair then satisfies equations ( [ le ] ) . note that by the schwarz reflection principle of complex analysis @xcite , the map @xmath25 extends to the lower half - plane and satisfies @xmath38 .
it follows from equation ( [ scale ] ) that flipping the sign of the forcing has the effect of reflecting the regions @xmath18 and @xmath13 ( and hence also the line of singularities @xmath33 ) in the imaginary axis .
likewise , a shift in the driving function @xmath0 can be compensated by a similar shift in @xmath25 , since the pair @xmath39 again solves equations ( [ le ] ) .
this shows that a shift in the driving function simply produces a shift of the same magnitude in the trace @xmath33 .
in this note we are interested in the question how the behavior of the trace is related to that of the driving function .
this question can be investigated both numerically and , in some cases , by exact methods . a simple numerical method to find the trace generated by a given driving function @xmath0 , is to numerically integrate loewner s equation backwards from the initial condition @xmath40 to obtain the value of @xmath41 . to deal with the singularity in loewner s equation
, we can use the first - order approximation @xmath42 substituting @xmath40 and solving this equation for @xmath43 gives an approximation for the value of @xmath36 at time @xmath44 , from where we then integrate backwards to obtain @xmath45 .
this method is good enough for the purpose of producing pictures .
the figures [ linear ] , [ spirals ] , [ intersections ] and [ doubletrace ] in this note were obtained in this way .
exact solutions of equations ( [ le ] ) can be found in a few cases .
the simplest are ones in which the forcing has one of the forms @xmath46 or @xmath47 for @xmath48 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 . for a driving function of the form of equation ( [ forceb ] )
, a rescaling according to ( [ scale ] ) gives the new forcing @xmath49 this result allows us to scale away the constant @xmath50 when @xmath51 .
for the special value @xmath52 the multiplicative constant can not be scaled away , and can be important in determining the form of the solution . in sections
[ constantforcing ] , [ linearforcing ] and [ squarerootforcing ] we shall derive the solutions respectively for the powers @xmath1 , @xmath3 , and @xmath2 . section [ halfcircle ] contains an explicit construction of the maps @xmath25 for a half - plane slit by an arc , and we point out that this is a special case of square - root forcing with a finite - time singularity . in section [ varyingforcing ]
we consider a more general version of loewner s equation , where the forcing is a superposition of the values @xmath12 and produces two lines of singularities .
here we look at the almost trivial situation in which @xmath48 and we can take @xmath53 this situation is well - known ( see for example @xcite and appendix a in @xcite ) , but for the sake of completeness we also treat it here .
we could of course shift @xmath54 away by using equation ( [ shift ] ) , but this case is so easy that shifting is hardly worth the effort . the equation for @xmath36 can be solved by inspection , giving @xmath55^{1/2}. \label{gc}\ ] ] the inverse map is of the same form as the direct one , namely @xmath56^{1/2}.\ ] ] at time @xmath6 , the function @xmath36 acquires a new singularity at the point @xmath57 which maps under @xmath25 to the point @xmath58 in the @xmath20-plane .
thus the singularities form a line segment parallel to the imaginary axis and the mapped region of the @xmath24-plane is the upper half - plane minus that line segment .
the mapping has a singular point at the place where the trace meets the real axis .
we can approach this point @xmath59 from two different directions , giving us two different images at the points @xmath60 figure [ constant ] gives an illustration of the mapping . because any smooth enough function @xmath0 looks locally
as if it were constant , we might expect that smooth @xmath0 s generate traces of singularities which look like simple curves coming up from the real axis .
in fact , one can prove that this statement is correct whenever @xmath0 is sufficiently smooth so that it is hlder continuous with exponent @xmath2 and sufficiently small norm , i.e. so that @xmath61 for all @xmath6 and some constant @xmath50 .
the tricky issue is , when can it be that the curve will touch itself or hit the real line .
condition ( [ cond ] ) is enough to ensure that this will not happen , as was shown by marshall and rohde @xcite , who did not give the value of the constant @xmath50 .
our solution in section [ squarerootforcing ] below gives a specific example of the transition occuring at @xmath62 . in a parallel and independent paper , lind
@xcite proves also generally that hlder-@xmath2 functions with coefficients @xmath63 generate slits .
the next case , not much harder , has the forcing increase linearly with time according to @xmath64 we do not need an additive or multiplicative constant in equation ( [ linear ] ) because these can be eliminated by equations ( [ scale ] ) and ( [ shift ] ) .
if we now redefine the independent variable to be @xmath65 , then @xmath66 obeys @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the function @xmath69 in terms of @xmath70 the solution is @xmath71 here , @xmath72 is a constant which must be set from the initial condition , @xmath73 , giving the solution @xmath74 or equivalently @xmath75 to find the trajectory of the singularity , use equations ( [ sing ] ) and ( [ csoln ] ) to get @xmath76 it is possible to find an explicit expression for this trajectory . to do so , substitute @xmath77 into the previous equation . then split the equation in its real and imaginary parts to obtain @xmath78 after substituting the second equation into the first
, it can be shown that @xmath79 increases monotonously in time from the value @xmath80 to @xmath81 . in terms of the parameter
@xmath79 , the line of singularities may be written explicitly as @xmath82 this shows that the line of singularities moves outward to infinity while remaining within a fixed distance of the real axis .
figure [ linear ] shows the first part of this trajectory .
-plane that arises from the forcing @xmath11 , up to time @xmath83 . ] for small and large values of @xmath6 we can also construct asymptotic forms of the solution ( [ csoln2 ] ) . as @xmath6 goes to zero , one can expand @xmath84 to third order in @xmath33 and find that , to this order , the result is @xmath85 for large @xmath6 , @xmath86 + 2\pi i + o(\ln t / t).\ ] ]
the next case , much more interesting , has the forcing be a square - root function of time .
this case has two subcases : one in which the forcing has a finite - time singularity based on the rule of equation ( [ forcea ] ) , i.e. @xmath87^{1/2 } , \qquad t\leq1 , \qquad \kappa\geq 0 .
\label{forceap}\ ] ] here , as we shall see , the result changes qualitatively as @xmath7 varies , with the critical case being @xmath14 where the singular curve intersects the real axis . in the other situation , the forcing has an infinite - time singularity with the rule @xmath88^{1/2 } , \qquad \kappa\geq 0 .
\label{forcebp}\ ] ] in this case @xmath33 is just a straight line , as is already clear from the scaling relation ( [ scale ] ) . to find the solution for the forcing ( [ forcebp ] ) ,
define the new variable @xmath89 and set @xmath90
. then @xmath91 satisfies @xmath92 where @xmath93 .
it follows that @xmath94 = \frac{1}{2}(y_+ - y_-).\ ] ] therefore , if we set @xmath95 then @xmath96 which integrates to @xmath97 the constant @xmath72 can be determined from the observation that in the limit when @xmath6 approaches @xmath1 , @xmath98 our solution ( [ forcebpsoln ] ) for general @xmath6 becomes simply @xmath99 since the line of singularities is determined by the condition that @xmath36 is equal to the forcing we get @xmath100.\ ] ] more explicitly the coefficient is @xmath101,\ ] ] so that the line of singularities is set at an angle to the real axis which is @xmath102 for @xmath103 the line is ( as we know ) perpendicular to the real axis while as @xmath104 the angle of intersection becomes smaller and smaller .
now we turn to the forcing ( [ forceap ] ) with a singularity after a finite time . in this case
, one can eliminate the time - dependence by using the new variable @xmath105 then @xmath91 obeys @xmath106 where @xmath107 .
once again the derivative becomes a simple function of the unknown , again appearing in the form of a ratio of polynomials , i.e. @xmath108 where this time the roots are @xmath109 .
notice that now the roots are real and positive when @xmath110 but that they are complex for @xmath8 .
thus we can expect a qualitative change in the solution at @xmath14 .
the integration of the equation proceeds exactly as in the previous case , giving the solution @xmath111 where @xmath112 has the same form as before , but with different @xmath113 : @xmath114 the initial condition then implies that @xmath115 and the equation for the line of singularities is then @xmath116 note that equation ( [ sqrtsoln ] ) for the line of singularities tells us that @xmath117 must approach @xmath118 when @xmath6 approaches @xmath3 . in the following subsections we shall consider the asymptotics of @xmath33 in this limit in more detail .
we separate the discussion into the two cases @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
then the section is completed with the derivation of the shape of the critical line of singularities at @xmath14 .
when @xmath8 , the real and imaginary parts of @xmath119 are @xmath120 from which it follows easily that @xmath121 is a positive real constant .
since the real part of @xmath117 must go to @xmath118 when @xmath6 approaches @xmath3 , we conclude that @xmath122 , since the other possible candidate for the limit , i.e. @xmath123 , is in the wrong half - plane .
it then follows from the observation that @xmath124 must vanish , that the trace must have wrapped around @xmath125 an infinite number of times .
hence the line of singularities is spiralling in towards the point @xmath125 , as is depicted in figure [ spirals ] . .
also shown is the limiting case @xmath14 where the trace starts to hit the real line .
all the curves have been translated to make them start in the origin at time @xmath126 . ] to find a more explicit expression for the asymptotics , notice that when @xmath33 is close to @xmath125 , we can make the approximations @xmath127 splitting equation ( [ sqrtsoln ] ) in its real and imaginary parts , and substituting the above approximate values then gives a system of two equations that we can solve for the unknows @xmath128 and @xmath129 .
this gives the result @xmath130 / 4 , \\ { \mathop{\rm arg\,}\nolimits}(z_c(t)-y_+ ) & \approx & \big [ b(\kappa ) - \kappa^{1/2}(4-\kappa)^{1/2}\ln(1-t ) \big ] / 4,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the constants are @xmath131 thus , the distance between @xmath33 and @xmath125 is decreasing like a power law in @xmath6 , whereas the winding number of @xmath33 around @xmath125 grows only logarithmically .
the line of singularities intersects the real line at an angle that varies with @xmath7 .
the curves were translated to make them start in the origin . ] for @xmath9 the real and imaginary parts of @xmath119 are @xmath132 and @xmath121 is again a positive real number .
this time , as @xmath6 approaches one , @xmath33 must approach the point @xmath123 on the real line , see figure [ intersections ] .
in fact , we can calculate the angle at which the line of singularities intersects the real line from the observation that @xmath124 must vanish . indeed ,
if we denote by @xmath79 the angle at which @xmath33 hits the real line ( measured from the real line in the positive direction ) , then we have that in the limit @xmath133 , @xmath134 whereas @xmath135 .
the condition @xmath136 then gives @xmath137 when @xmath6 goes to @xmath3 .
as we can see , we have a glancing incidence for @xmath14 and @xmath104 , while for @xmath10 the incidence is perpendicular .
in fact we can prove that for @xmath10 the line of singularities is a half - circle of radius @xmath138 .
we will do this in section [ halfcircle ] , where we give an explicit construction of the conformal maps @xmath25 when the half - plane is slit by a half - circle .
it is not difficult to find an explicit expression for the critical line of singularities at @xmath14 . in this case , the two roots in equation ( [ geqn ] ) are the same , @xmath139 , and the equation can be rewritten as @xmath140\frac{dg}{d\tau}=1.\ ] ] integration is straightforward and gives @xmath141 where we have determined the integration constant from the initial condition @xmath142 .
the line of singularities is determined by the condition that for @xmath143 , @xmath144 . substituting @xmath145 and splitting
the equation in real and imaginary parts leads to the expression @xmath146 for the critical curve in terms of the parameter @xmath79 .
this parameter @xmath79 increases monotonously with time from @xmath80 to @xmath147 .
taking @xmath13 minus the slit @xmath148 $ ] onto @xmath13 , in three steps .
the illustration also tracks the images of the upper half of the unit disk and of the four `` special '' points @xmath149 , @xmath1 , @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
the definitions of @xmath150 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 are in the text . ] in this section , we consider the situation where the upper half - plane @xmath13 is slit by the curve @xmath154 , @xmath155 .
the idea is to construct the conformal maps that map the half - plane minus the slit @xmath148 $ ] back to the half - plane and have the expansion of equation ( [ expansion ] ) .
after reparameterizing time one can then identify the driving function , and verify that the obtained maps @xmath25 satisfy loewner s equation .
the form of the normalized maps and of the driving function already appears in appendix a of @xcite , but for completeness we present a short account of the derivation of these results below .
a simple rescaling argument then allows us to make the connection with section [ squarerootforcing ] and prove that the square - root forcing we considered there generates a half - circle of radius @xmath138 when @xmath10 . to obtain the normalized conformal maps , we start by constructing the map @xmath156 of figure [ halfcircle ] as the composition of the three maps depicted there .
the explicit form of this map is @xmath157\ ] ] where @xmath158 and the function @xmath159 is given by @xmath160 with @xmath161 .
we can now expand @xmath156 for large @xmath24 , and identify the capacity @xmath162 .
a simple translation will then give us the map satisfying ( [ expansion ] ) .
expanding @xmath163 for large @xmath24 up to order @xmath164 gives @xmath165 therefore , the map @xmath166 has the expansion of equation ( [ expansion ] ) , with capacity @xmath167 .
the proper time reparameterization that makes the capacity equal to @xmath168 is given by @xmath169 which has the inverse @xmath170 the maps @xmath25 are then given by @xmath171 .
more explicitly , this can be written in the form @xmath172 we know from figure [ halfcircle ] that this map takes the point @xmath173 onto the image @xmath174 , which implies that the driving function must be @xmath175 indeed , one can check by differentiating ( [ circlemap ] ) with respect to time , that @xmath25 satisfies loewner s equation with this driving function . to make the connection with section [ squarerootforcing ] , we note that a rescaling of the form ( [ scale ] ) with @xmath176 turns the driving function into a function of the form of equation ( [ forceap ] ) with @xmath10 , up to a translation .
we conclude that this particular square - root forcing produces a line of singularities that is a half - circle of radius @xmath138 .
we conclude this section with a discussion of its relation to an old paper by kufarev @xcite .
kufarev considers the equivalent of loewner s equation ( [ le ] ) in the unit disk , and gives an explicit solution of this equation for negative times .
a half - plane version of kufarev s example is obtained as follows .
suppose that we set @xmath177 for @xmath178 .
then it can be verified that the solution of ( [ le ] ) at time @xmath179 is the normalized map that takes @xmath13 onto @xmath13 minus the half - disk of radius @xmath180 centered at @xmath181 .
observe that for @xmath182 , up to a translation , this solution is just the inverse of ( [ circlemap ] ) at time @xmath183 .
this is not a coincidence because generally , if one sets @xmath184 and solves loewner s equation for both @xmath185 and @xmath186 , the two results are related by @xmath187 .
in this section we look at a special case of the more general version of loewner s equation ( appearing for example in @xcite ) @xmath188 where @xmath189 is a measure on the real line that can be time - dependent . here
we will take @xmath189 to be time - independent and assigning a mass @xmath190 to the values @xmath191 such that @xmath192 .
then the equation for @xmath36 takes the form @xmath193 this can be seen as a case where the forcing @xmath0 is a superposition of values , and we also believe that this can be described as a case where the forcing @xmath0 makes rapid ( random ) jumps between the values @xmath191 . equations like ( [ jump ] ) are generally easily integrated .
take the specific case in which the possible values of @xmath28 are @xmath12 , which are taken on with equal probability .
then equation ( [ jump ] ) becomes @xmath194 which then integrates to give @xmath195 there are two traces , starting respectively from @xmath196 and then moving upward towards @xmath197 .
the traces are found , as before , by setting @xmath36 equal to the forcing .
thus the right - hand trace obeys @xmath198 again we can obtain an explicit expression for the trace , like we did for the case of linear forcing in section [ linearforcing ] , and for the critical curve in section [ squarerootforcing ] . after substituting @xmath200 and splitting the previous equation in real and imaginary parts , we obtain @xmath201 where @xmath79 increases with time from the value @xmath80 to @xmath202 .
note that we have filled in the results for both traces , using the fact that they must be symmetrically placed about the imaginary axis .
we can also compute the asymptotics . for small values of @xmath6
we obtain @xmath203 while for large values of @xmath6 the traces behave like @xmath204 we see that as the traces move upward , they also approach one another , as is shown in figure [ doubletrace ] .
one of us ( lpk ) would like to thank leiden university and professor wim van saarloos for their hospitality for a part of the period in which the work was performed .
we have had useful conversations about this research with paul wiegmann , ilya gruzberg , isabelle claus , marko kleine berkenbusch , and john cardy .
we thank steffen rohde and joan lind for sharing their recent work on loewner s equation with us .
lpk would like to acknowledge partial support from the us nsf s division of materials research .
wk is supported by the stichting fom ( fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ) in the netherlands .
10 l. v. ahlfors , _ complex analysis : an introduction to the theory of analytic functions of one complex variable_. mcgraw - hill , new york , second edition ( 1966 ) .
l. v. ahlfors , _ conformal invariants : topics in geometric function theory_. mcgraw - hill , new york ( 1973 ) .
m. bauer , d. bernard , _ conformal field theories of stochastic loewner evolutions_. commun .
239 , pp .
493 - 521 ( 2003 ) ; arxiv : hep - th/0210015 .
p. l. duren , _
univalent functions_. springer - verlag , new york , 1983 .
an overview of the literature on schramm s loewner evolutions ( sle ) is given in ilya a. gruzberg and leo p. kadanoff , _ the loewner equation : maps and shapes _ ; arxiv : cond - mat/0309292 .
kufarev , _ a remark on integrals of loewner s equation _ , doklady akad .
nauk sssr 57 , pp .
655656 ( 1947 ) , in russian . g. f. lawler , _ an introduction to the stochastic loewner evolution _
, available online at url + http://www.math.duke.edu/@xmath205jose/papers.html g. f. lawler , o. schramm , w. werner , _ values of brownian intersection exponents i : half - plane exponents_. acta math .
187 , 2 , pp . 237273 ( 2001 ) ; arxiv : math.pr/9911084
. g. f. lawler , o. schramm , w. werner , _ conformal invariance of planar loop - erased random walks and uniform spanning trees_. ann .
( to appear ) ; arxiv : math.pr/0112234 . j. r. lind , _ a sharp condition for the loewner equation to generate slits _ ; arxiv : math.cv/0311234 . k. lwner , _ untersuchungen ber schlichte konforme abbildungen des einheitskreises , i_. math . ann .
89 , pp . 103121
d. e. marshall and s. rohde , _ the loewner differential equation and slit mappings _ , available online at url + http://www.math.washington.edu/@xmath205rohde/ o. schramm , _ scaling limits of loop - erased random walks and uniform spanning trees_. israel j. math .
118 , pp .
221288 ( 2000 ) ; arxiv : math.pr/9904022
. s. smirnov , _ critical percolation in the plane : conformal invariance , cardy s formula , scaling limits_. c. r. acad .
. i. math .
333 , 3 , pp .
239244 ( 2001 ) .
a longer version is available online at url http://www.math.kth.se/@xmath205stas/papers/ | in this note , we solve the loewner equation in the upper half - plane with forcing function @xmath0 , for the cases in which @xmath0 has a power - law dependence on time with powers @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 . in the first case
the trace of singularities is a line perpendicular to the real axis . in the second case
the trace of singularities can do three things . if @xmath4 , the trace is a straight line set at an angle to the real axis . if @xmath5 , as pointed out by marshall and rohde @xcite , the behavior of the trace as @xmath6 approaches @xmath3 depends on the coefficient @xmath7 .
our calculations give an explicit solution in which for @xmath8 the trace spirals into a point in the upper half - plane , while for @xmath9 it intersects the real axis .
we also show that for @xmath10 the trace becomes a half - circle . the third case with forcing @xmath11
gives a trace that moves outward to infinity , but stays within fixed distance from the real axis .
we also solve explicitly a more general version of the evolution equation , in which @xmath0 is a superposition of the values @xmath12 .
[ [ key - words ] ] key words : + + + + + + + + + + conformal map , loewner equation , singularity , slit domain . |
core - collapse - supernovae ( cc - sne ) are believed to be the explosions that mark the end - point in the evolution of massive stars ( @xmath8 m@xmath9 ; see e.g. * ? ? ?
they are spectroscopically divided in different groups according mainly to the presence of the h and he lines in their optical spectra .
while type ii sne show prominent h features , type i do not , and can be further subdivided , according to the presence or absence of he , as types ib and ic respectively .
there are also hybrid objects which undergo a transition from being h dominated at early phases of their spectral evolution , to he dominated at later times .
these are termed type iib sne .
the first sn to have shown this spectral transition was sn 1987k , and its progenitor was proposed to be a star that had lost most of its hydrogen envelope before exploding @xcite .
the best studied type iib sn to date is sn 1993j ( e.g. @xcite ) , that is considered the prototype of the subclass .
its lc showed an early peak , followed by a rapid decline thought to be the consequence of the cooling of the progenitor s stellar envelope after shock breakout .
subsequently it presented a secondary maximum attributed to input from the radioactive decay of @xmath7ni .
the star that exploded as sn 1993j was detected in archival images @xcite , and its disappearance was confirmed by @xcite .
two mechanisms have been proposed by which type iib sn progenitors lose part of their h envelope before exploding , namely stripping by a close companion after roche lobe overflow , and wind - driven stellar mass loss in a single star .
the former scenario has gained strength over the past years , for example with the detection of signatures of the possible hot blue companion star of sn 1993j ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) , and the modelling of a progenitor binary system and likely detection of the stellar companion of sn 2011dh @xcite . moreover , although a wolf - rayet ( wr ) wind - like spectrum was obtained for the type iib sn 2013cu a few hours after explosion @xcite , recent work has shown that the progenitor star for sn 2013cu was unlikely a wr @xcite .
an important question is which of the observed properties of sne iib can be connected with the characteristics of their progenitor systems .
for example , @xcite proposed that bright early luminosity from the shock - heated progenitor stellar envelope , low radio shell velocities , and thermal x - ray emission were characteristic of extended progenitors with r @xmath10 r@xmath4 , while compact progenitors with r @xmath11 r@xmath4 have faint early optical lcs , have high radio shell velocities and non - thermal x - ray emission .
however , this link is not straightforward and needs to be revised since the type iib sne 2011dh and 2011hs present fast expanding radio shells but the hydrodynamical modelling of their lc @xcite , and in the case of sn 2011dh the detection of its progenitor in archival images @xcite and its disappearance @xcite , point to the explosion of extended stars . to further complicate the picture ,
sne iib show a variety of continuum flux excess in early uv spectra @xcite .
strong uv - excess suggest significant interaction between the sn ejecta and circumstellar material . to date ,
few type iib sne have been thoroughly studied since they are relatively rare events .
@xcite estimated the fraction of type iib over a volume limited sample of 81 type ii sne to be @xmath12 . in this paper
we present optical and near infrared ( nir ) data for the type iib sn 2011fu .
sn 2011fu , with coordinates @xmath13 and @xmath14 ( j2000 ) , was discovered in a spiral arm of the galaxy ugc 1626 by f. ciabattari and e. mazzoni of the italian supernovae search project ( issp ) , on 2011 september 21.04 ut and classified by @xcite as a young type ii sn 2011 september 23.84 ut .
a previous analysis of optical data of sn 2011fu was presented by @xcite , which confirmed it was a type iib sn . in this manuscript
we contribute with data probing the whole sn evolution . in section [ host ]
we discuss the distance , reddening , and explosion epoch of sn 2011fu . in section [ data ]
we summarize our observations and the reduction process of the data . in section [ phot ]
we present the optical and nir lcs of the object , while in section [ spec ] we present and discuss the spectral evolution . in section [ discussion ]
we discuss the results obtained from the hydrodynamical modelling of the pseduo - bolometric lc and we compare our nebular spectra with published models for late time type iib sn spectra .
finally , in section [ conclusion ] , we present the conclusions of our work .
the rise to a first maximum in the _ v _ and _ r _ lcs ( see the inset of figure [ fig : apparentlcs ] ) implies that sn 2011fu was discovered very soon after explosion .
in fact , models show that the evolution of the sn lc during this rise should be very fast , and lasts @xmath11 d for a number of configurations ( e.g. @xcite ) . by adopting @xmath15 as the explosion date of sn 2011fu
, we obtain the best fit of the early phase of the pseudo - bolometric lc with the hydrodynamical models presented in section [ lcmodelling ] . for this reason we have chosen @xmath15 as the explosion date of sn 2011fu , which is in agreement with the discovery epoch , the last non detection of the object which was 2011 august 10 ( @xmath16 ) , the pre - discovery image taken by xing gao 2011 september 20 ( @xmath17 ) , and the classification as a young object . note that this assumed explosion date also agrees , within the uncertainties , with the explosion epoch adopted by @xcite .
all phases in the rest of this manuscript are given with respect to @xmath15 .
ugc 1626 is a sab(rs)c type galaxy whose recessional velocity given by the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) is @xmath18 km s@xmath19 .
we have performed measurements of the sn redshift from the narrow h@xmath20 emissions in its spectra and have obtained the same redshift as for its host galaxy , which we adopt in the rest of this paper . the redshift derived distance
to ugc 1626 , also provided by ned assuming h@xmath21 km s@xmath19 mpc@xmath19 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and accounting for the virgo , great attractor and shapley infalls is @xmath24 mpc , i.e. @xmath25 mag , @xcite .
the reddening in the line of sight of ugc 1626 due to the milky way is @xmath26 mag @xcite .
we detect a narrow absorption likely due na i d @xmath27@xmath28 , @xmath29 at the host galaxy redshift .
the equivalent width of this line is @xmath30 that using the relations for unresolved na i d given by @xcite , provides an estimate of the reddening in the host galaxy as : @xmath31 mag .
in fact , a similar value of reddening due to the host galaxy is obtained using the relations of @xcite . in the rest of this manuscript
we adopt @xmath32 mag as the total reddening towards sn 2011fu .
we note that in @xcite the relations of @xcite were used to estimate the contribution to the reddening due to the host galaxy , and they obtained @xmath33 , which is consistent with the value we have adopted within the uncertainties .
the observational follow - up data of sn 2011fu presented in this paper covers the period between a few days post discovery , until the sn disappeared behind the sun ( end of february 2012 ) .
after that , one more spectrum and one epoch of _ gri _ photometric data were obtained well into the nebular phase of the sn , 2012 july 20 ut .
thanks to a large collaboration between many european institutions , optical photometry and spectroscopy , as well as some nir photometric data of sn 2011fu , have been collected at several sites .
some amateur data taken by f.ciabattari and e. mazzoni from italy , and xing gao from china were also included in our analysis .
a summary of the characteristics of the instruments used to acquire our photometric data can be seen in table [ photometric_log ] . the list with our spectroscopic observations and the instrumental configuration used to acquire the data is presented in table [ spectroscopic_log ] .
all the data were corrected for overscan , bias , and flat - field within the iraf environment , except for data obtained at the liverpool telscope ( lt ) which were automatically reduced with the instrument specific pipeline .
the instrumental magnitudes of the sn were derived via point spread function ( psf ) fitting which was done with snoopy @xcite . in the case of the _ u _ and _ u _ photometry ,
the measurements were done after performing template subtraction . for all other bands , psf photometry at late time
was verified by performing template subtractions and no major differences were found .
a set of fifteen local stars in the sn field ( figure [ fig:11fusequence ] ) were used to trace the photometric calibration .
the stellar sequence was calibrated with the zero points and colour terms derived for each site thanks to observations of landolt standards ( tables [ sequence_magsjc ] and [ sequence_magssloan ] ) and the sn magnitudes were calculated relative to these .
the errors of the magnitudes of the stellar sequence were obtained as the rms deviation with respect to their mean values .
given the fact that several instruments with different passbands were used to acquire our data , we performed s - corrections of our _ bvrrii _ photometry to the bessell system @xcite . in order to derive the s - correction terms we used our spectral sequence of the sn .
note that we were not able to perform s - corrections to the _ u _ , _ u _ , and _ z _ band photometry given the fact that our spectra do not cover completely these passbands .
the sn magnitudes together with their errors , calculated by adding in quadrature the uncertainties associated with the calibration and the psf fit , are reported in tables [ ubvri_phot ] , [ ugz_phot ] , and [ jhk_phot ] .
the unfiltered photometry provided by f. ciabattari was rescaled to the _ r _ band considering that the detector sensitivity peaks at this wavelength . with the same argument
the data provided by x. gao were rescaled to _
note that stars 2 , 6 , 9 , 12 , and 14 from our sequence coincide with stars 2 , 1 , 4 , 3 and 5 used for photometric calibration by @xcite .
the greatest difference between the two sequences is 0.1 mag found for star 2 in the _ u _ band . for the rest of the bands differences are found to be less than 0.1 mag .
the nir data was reduced within iraf with the help of caindr , a package developed by jos a. acosta pulido and rafael barrena for the instrument cain3 at the tcs .
the images of each specific filter were corrected for flat field , and bad pixel corrections were applied .
then background images were constructed and subtracted from the science frames , and finally the images were combined taking into account the dithering pattern . similarly to the optical data , we measured the instrumental sn magnitudes by psf fitting .
the sn calibration was done relative to 2-mass stars in the field ( @xcite ; see table [ sequence_magsjc ] ) .
the spectra were corrected for overscan , bias , and flat - field within iraf . next they were variance - weighted extracted and wavelength calibrated with the use of arc lamp spectra .
the wavelength calibration was cross - checked with respect to sky emission lines .
finally a flux calibration was applied using sensitivity functions obtained from the observation of spectrophotometric standards .
the flux calibration was cross - checked with the photometry of the sn at the nearest epoch .
telluric lines were corrected dividing the sn spectra by telluric line spectra obtained from the spectrophotometric standards .
the optical - nir lcs of sn 2011fu are presented in figure [ fig : apparentlcs ] .
in addition to the data presented in the figure we obtained two epochs of sloan _
g _ band data , which are listed in table [ ugz_phot ] . in the optical ,
the lcs clearly present two peaks in all bands , but not in the nir since the data do not cover the early phases .
the rise to primary peak in the _ v _ and _ r _ band can be seen thanks to the early time data provided by amateur astronomers ( see inset in the top - right of the figure ) . by making low order polynomial fits to the optical lcs we have estimated the phases and magnitudes at which the minima after first peak and secondary maxima take place .
the results are presented in table [ min_max_decay_rise ] .
note that we obtain different absolute magnitudes at secondary peak than @xcite due to the fact that we have adopted different distance and reddening towards the host , however , our values agree within the uncertainties .
we also fitted low order polynomials to the first peaks in the _ r _ and _ v _ lcs . in
the _ v _ band the first peak at 16.3 mag is reached @xmath34 d after explosion while in the _ r _ band the 16.0 mag first peak is obtained @xmath35 d post explosion .
we have also estimated the decline rates of the tails of the _ bvriz _ lcs ( table [ min_max_decay_rise ] ) .
these rates are quite similar to those estimated for sn 2013df by @xcite , and are steeper than expected from @xmath7co decay .
this is a common characteristic to stripped envelope sne ( e.g. , sn 2008ax , @xcite ) and is possibly due to increasing transparency for @xmath36 rays in their lower mass ejecta . | we present optical and near infrared observations of the type iib supernova ( sn ) 2011fu from a few days to @xmath0 d after explosion .
the sn presents a double - peaked light curve ( lc ) similar to that of sn 1993j , although more luminous and with a longer cooling phase after the primary peak .
the spectral evolution is also similar to sn 1993j s , with hydrogen dominating the spectra to @xmath1 d , then helium gaining strength , and nebular emission lines appearing from @xmath2 d post - explosion .
the velocities derived from the p - cygni absorptions are overall similar to those of other type iib sne .
we have found a strong similarity between the oxygen and magnesium line profiles at late times , which suggests that these lines are forming at the same location within the ejecta .
the hydrodynamical modelling of the pseudo - bolometric lc and the observed photospheric velocities suggest that sn 2011fu was the explosion of an extended star ( @xmath3 r@xmath4 ) , in which 1.3 @xmath5 erg of kinetic energy were released and 0.15 m@xmath6 of @xmath7ni were synthesised .
in addition , a better reproduction of the observed early pseudo - bolometric lc is achieved if a more massive h - rich - envelope than for other type iib sne is considered ( 0.3 m@xmath6 ) .
the hydrodynamical modelling of the lc and the comparison of our late - time spectra with nebular spectral models for type iib sne , point to a progenitor for sn 2011fu with a zams mass of 13 - 18 m@xmath6 .
[ firstpage ] supernovae : general , supernovae : individual : sn 2011fu . |
the nucleon electromagnetic form factors @xmath2 and @xmath3 are fundamental quantities in nuclear and elementary particle physics as they provide information on the spatial distributions of charge and magnetization within the nucleon .
they are a function of the four - momentum transfer squared of the virtual photon , @xmath4 . in the nonrelativistic limit
, they are the fourier transform of the charge and magnetization distributions . therefore
, isolating the up- and down - quark contributions to the nucleon form factors is essential to examine spatial asymmetries in the quark distributions .
there are primarily two methods used to extract the proton form factors .
the first is the rosenbluth or longitudinal - transverse ( lt ) separation method @xcite which uses measurements of unpolarized cross section , and the second is the polarization transfer / polarized target ( pt ) method @xcite which requires measurements of the spin - dependent cross section . in the one - photon exchange ( ope )
approximation or the born value , the unpolarized cross section is proportional to the `` reduced '' cross section , @xmath5 , where @xmath6 , @xmath7 is the nucleon mass , and @xmath8 is the virtual photon longitudinal polarization parameter defined as @xmath9 $ ] , where @xmath10 is the scattering angle of the electron . measuring @xmath11 at several @xmath8 points for a fixed @xmath4 value , one can separate @xmath12 and @xmath13 . however , for cases where @xmath14 is extremely small ( large ) , it is difficult to extract @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) with precision . on the other hand ,
the polarization measurements are sensitive only to the ratio @xmath15 .
therefore , by taking ratios of polarization components , many of the systematic uncertainties in the polarization measurements cancel , allowing for precise measurements of the ratio @xmath16 @xcite , where @xmath17 is the proton magnetic dipole moment .
the two methods yield strikingly different results for the ratio @xmath18 in the region @xmath19 ( gev / c)@xmath20 @xcite , where the rosenbluth extractions show approximate scaling , @xmath21 , while the recoil polarization data indicate a nearly linear decrease in @xmath18 with @xmath4 with some hint of flattening out above 5 ( gev / c)@xmath20 .
recent studies suggest that hard two - photon exchange ( tpe ) corrections to the unpolarized cross section may resolve the discrepancy @xcite .
recent precise measurements of the neutron s electric to magnetic form factor ratio @xmath22 up to 3.4 gev@xmath20 @xcite , combined with existing @xmath16 measurements in the same @xmath4 range allowed for a separation of the up- and down - quark contributions to the nucleon form factors at large @xmath4 @xcite .
this first analysis , referred to as `` cjrw '' in this work , examined the scaling behavior of the up- and down - quark contributions at large @xmath4 , supporting the idea that diquark correlations play an important role @xcite . recently , we extended the flavor separation analysis @xcite using combined cross section and polarization measurements of elastic electron - proton scattering with an emphasis on precise new data from ref .
@xcite covering the low - momentum region , which is sensitive to the large - scale structure of the nucleon . in our work
, we account for effects neglected in the original work where we apply tpe corrections in the extraction of the proton form factors based on the approach of ref .
the tpe correction applied in our work , based on the parametrization from ref .
@xcite , is linear in @xmath8 @xcite and vanishes in the limit @xmath23 1 @xcite .
we also compare our results to a parametrization of the proton form factors extracted @xcite after applying the hadronic calculation for tpe from ref .
we also include additional new @xmath24 data from clas @xcite and performed a new global fit to @xmath24 which we used , along with the parametrization of @xmath25 @xcite , to construct @xmath26 , as well as account for the uncertainties associated with all of the form factors measurements as the cjrw analysis accounted only for uncertainties on @xmath25 which was the dominant uncertainty for their flavor - separated results .
finally , we use our results of the flavor - separated form factors to construct the flavor - separated dirac , @xmath27 , and pauli , @xmath28 , form factors and their ratios .
in this section , we present our results of the flavor - separated form factors @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
we then compare our results to the cjrw extractions which allows for examination of the effect of the tpe corrections applied , additional uncertainties , as well as updated form factor data set used .
we also compare our results to the venkat _
et al . _
@xcite ( `` vamz '' ) , and arrington _ et al . _
@xcite ( `` amt '' ) extractions which use improved proton form factor parametrization obtained assuming different treatment of tpe corrections at lower @xmath4 values .
in addition , we used the venkat plus the @xmath24 and @xmath25 fits mentioned above , and looked at the impact of our updated @xmath24 fit by replacing this with the kelly @xcite fit for @xmath24 ( `` vamz - kelly '' ) .
finally , we compare the results to recent theoretical calculations and fits to the flavor - separated form factors : a dyson - schwinger equation ( `` dse '' ) calculation @xcite , a pion - cloud relativistic constituent quark model ( `` pc - rcqm '' ) @xcite , a relativistic constituent quark model whose hyperfine interaction is derived from goldstone - boson exchange ( `` gbe - rcqm '' ) @xcite , and a generalized parton distribution ( gpd ) calculations @xcite .
( top ) and @xmath28 ( bottom ) and their ratios from our analysis @xcite and the cjrw extractions @xcite .
also shown are the amt @xcite and vamz fits @xcite , and the values from the gbe - rcqm @xcite , pc - rcqm @xcite , the dse @xcite , and the gpd @xcite models.,title="fig:",width=199 ] ( top ) and @xmath28 ( bottom ) and their ratios from our analysis @xcite and the cjrw extractions @xcite . also shown are the amt @xcite and vamz fits @xcite , and the values from the gbe - rcqm @xcite , pc - rcqm @xcite , the dse @xcite , and the gpd @xcite models.,title="fig:",width=199 ] ( top ) and @xmath28 ( bottom ) and their ratios from our analysis @xcite and the cjrw extractions @xcite . also shown
are the amt @xcite and vamz fits @xcite , and the values from the gbe - rcqm @xcite , pc - rcqm @xcite , the dse @xcite , and the gpd @xcite models.,title="fig:",width=199 ] + ( top ) and @xmath28 ( bottom ) and their ratios from our analysis @xcite and the cjrw extractions @xcite . also shown are the amt @xcite and vamz fits @xcite , and the values from the gbe - rcqm @xcite , pc - rcqm @xcite , the dse @xcite , and the gpd @xcite models.,title="fig:",width=199 ] ( top ) and @xmath28 ( bottom ) and their ratios from our analysis @xcite and the cjrw extractions @xcite . also shown
are the amt @xcite and vamz fits @xcite , and the values from the gbe - rcqm @xcite , pc - rcqm @xcite , the dse @xcite , and the gpd @xcite models.,title="fig:",width=199 ] ( top ) and @xmath28 ( bottom ) and their ratios from our analysis @xcite and the cjrw extractions @xcite . also shown
are the amt @xcite and vamz fits @xcite , and the values from the gbe - rcqm @xcite , pc - rcqm @xcite , the dse @xcite , and the gpd @xcite models.,title="fig:",width=199 ] figure [ fig1 ] shows the flavor - separated contributions of @xmath29 and @xmath30 . it was reported in the cjrw analysis that while both the up - quark form factors , @xmath31 and @xmath32 , continued to rise compared to the down - quark , the down - quark contributions , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , strikingly exhibited @xmath35 scaling behavior above @xmath36 1.0 ( gev / c)@xmath20 in agreement with the moments of the generalized parton distributions predictions @xcite
. however , these predictions are based on fits which included nucleon form factors data , except for the most recent @xmath26 data .
our results for @xmath31 and @xmath32 suggest as well that both form factors continue to rise with increasing @xmath4 but with @xmath32 values somewhat higher than the cjrw extractions at low @xmath4 .
this can be seen clearly in the ratio @xmath37 . on the other hand ,
our results suggest that the down - quark contributions are falling more rapidly than the up - quark contributions at high @xmath4 with respect to the @xmath35 behavior which is more apparent for @xmath34 and the ratio @xmath37 in agreement with global parametrizations and theoretical calculations which predict faster falloff than the apparent @xmath35 scaling behavior . however , such behavior is sensitive to the parametrization of @xmath26 at @xmath38 2 ( gev / c)@xmath20 @xcite .
the difference in the results obtained are attributed mainly to the tpe corrections applied to the proton form factors and to lesser extent to the use of the updated @xmath24 parametrization .
in addition , while the @xmath26 uncertainties have the largest impact , the additional uncertainties from the proton and @xmath24 yield a non - negligible increase in the total uncertainties . and
points and curves as in fig .
[ fig1].,title="fig:",width=264 ] and @xmath39 .
points and curves as in fig .
[ fig1].,title="fig:",width=264 ] + figure [ fig2 ] shows the ratios @xmath40 and @xmath39 . here
@xmath41 are the @xmath36 0 limits of @xmath42 with @xmath43 1.67 and @xmath44 @xmath45 2.03 . the ratios are scaled by @xmath46 and normalized to @xmath47 yielding 0.5(1 ) for the up(down)-quark contribution . at low @xmath4
, the ratio @xmath48 falls rapidly up to @xmath49 ( gev / c)@xmath20 where it starts to decrease slowly . while our values are somewhat larger than those obtained in the cjrw extractions for @xmath50 1.5 ( gev / c)@xmath20 due to the difference in the @xmath32 values , they are in good qualitative agreement with form factor fits and calculations .
the ratio @xmath39 increases slowly at low @xmath4 and becomes almost constant for @xmath38 1 ( gev / c)@xmath51 .
our results are consistent with both the cjrw results and extractions based on form factors fits .
however , our results differ from all calculations as they predict a rapid falloff of @xmath33 at large @xmath4 compared to @xmath34 which clearly leads to a rapid rise in the ratio
. the high-@xmath4 measurements of @xmath26 planned at jefferson lab after the 12 gev upgrade @xcite are clearly critical to pin down the behavior of this ratio as well as to examine the theoretical calculations and models .
this work was supported by khalifa university of science , technology and research and by the u.s .
department of energy , office of nuclear physics , under contract de - ac02 - 06ch11357 .
30 rosenbluth m n 1950 _ phys .
rev . _ * 79 * 615 dombey n 1969 _ rev .
phys . _ * 41 * 236 punjabi v _ et al .
_ 2005 _ phys .
* c71 * 055202 ; puckett a j r _ et al .
_ 2012 _ phys .
rev . _ * c85 * 045203 ; puckett a j r _ et al .
_ 2010 _ phys .
lett . _ * 104 * 242301 ; zhan x _ et al .
_ 2011 _ phys .
lett . _ * b705 * 59 ; ron g _
_ 2011 _ phys .
rev . _ * c84
* 055204 ; arrington j , perdrisat c , and de jager c w 2011 _ j. phys . conf .
ser . _ * 299 * 012002 qattan i a _ et al .
_ 2005 _ phys .
lett . _ * 94 * 142301 ; arrington j 2003 _ phys .
* c68 * 034325 arrington j , melnitchouk w , and tjon j a 2007 _ phys .
rev . _ * c76 * 035205 carlson c e and vanderhaeghen m 2007 _ ann
nucl . part .
sci . _ * 57 * 171 arrington j , blunden p , and melnitchouk w 2011 _ prog .
phys . _ * 66 * 782 qattan i a and alsaad a 2011 _ phys
* c84 * 054317 [ erratum : 2011 _ phys .
* c84 * 029905 ] adikaram d _
( clas collaboration ) 2015 _ phys .
lett . _ * 114 * 062003 ; rachek i a _ et al .
_ 2015 _ phys .
_ * 114 * 062005 ; rimal d _ et al . _
( clas collaboration ) 2016 _ preprint
_ arxiv:1603.00315 [ nucl - ex ] blunden p g , melnitchouk w , and tjon j a 2005 _ phys .
* c72 * 034612 riordan s _ et al .
_ 2010 _ phys .
lett . _ * 105 * 262302 cates g , de jager c , riordan s , and wojtsekhowski b 2011 _ phys . rev
* 106 * 252003 cloet i _ et al .
_ 2009 _ few - body syst . _
* 1 qattan i a and arrington j 2012 _ phys . rev . _
* c86 * 065210 qattan i a and arrington j 2014 _ eur .
j. woc _ * 66 * 06020 qattan i a , arrington j , and alsaad a 2015 _ phys .
_ * c91 * 065203 bernauer j c _ et al . _
( a1 collaboration ) 2014 _ phys .
* c90 * 015206 qattan i a , alsaad a , and arrington j 2011 _ phys .
* c84 * 054317 borisyuk d and kobushkin a 2011 _ phys .
* d83 * 057501 tvaskis v _ et al .
_ 2006 _ phys .
_ * c73 * 025206 arrington j , blunden p g , and melnitchouk w 2011 _ prog .
phys . _ * 66 * 782 ; chen y -c , kao c -w , and yang s -n 2007 _ phys .
lett . _ * b652 * 269 arrington j 2004 _ phys .
rev . _ * c69 * 032201 lachniet j _ et al . _
( clas collaboration ) 2009 _ phys .
lett . _ * 102 * 192001 venkat s , arrington j , miller g a , and zhan x 2011 _ phys . rev .
_ * c83 * 015203 kelly j j 2004 _ phys
* c70 * 068202 cloet i c and miller g a 2012 _ phys . rev . _
* c86 * 015208 rohrmoser m , choi k -s , and plessas w 2011 _ preprint _ arxiv:1110.3665 [ hep - ph ] gonzalez - hernandez j o , liuti s , goldstein g r , and kathuria k 2013 _ phys
* c88 * 065206 diehl m , feldmann t , jakob r , and kroll p 2005 _ eur .
phys . j. _ * c39 * 1 dudek j _
_ 2012 _ eur .
phys . j. _
* a48 * 187 | the spatial distribution of charge and magnetization within the nucleon ( proton and neutron ) is encoded in the elastic electromagnetic form factors @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
these form factors have been precisely measured utilizing elastic electron scattering , and the combination of proton and neutron form factors allows for the separation of the up- and down - quark contributions to the nucleon form factors .
we expand on our original analyses and extract the up- and down - quark contributions to the nucleon electromagnetic form factors from worldwide data with an emphasis on precise new data covering the low - momentum region , which is sensitive to the large - scale structure of the nucleon . from these , we construct the flavor - separated dirac and pauli form factors and their ratios , and compare the results to recent extractions and theoretical calculations and models . |
a quantum computer will allow to perform some algorithms much faster than in classical computers e.g. shor algorithm for the factorization the numbers @xcite .
the basic elements in the quantum computation are qubits and quantum logical gates , which allow to construct any circuit to quantum algorithms .
the good candidates to realization of qubits are semiconductor quantum dots with controlled electron numbers .
the qubit state can be encoded using an electron charge or , which is also promising , an electron spin @xcite .
the spin qubits are characterized by longer decoherence times necessary in the quantum computation @xcite . however to prepare that qubit one needs to apply a magnetic field and removed the degeneracy between spin up and down .
the manipulation of the qubit can be done by electron spin resonance and the read - out via currents in spin - polarized leads @xcite . another concept to encode the qubit
is based on the singlet - triplet states in a double quantum dot ( dqd ) . in this case
the magnetic field is not necessary and the qubit preparation is performed by electrical control of the exchange interactions @xcite .
the qubit states can be controlled by e.g. an external magnetic field @xcite , spin - orbit @xcite or hyperfine interaction @xcite . for the read - out of the qubit state one can use current measurement and the effect of pauli spin blockade @xcite . in the pauli blockade regime
the current flows only for the singlet , which gives information about the qubit states .
divincenzo _ et al _ @xcite suggested to build the qubit in more complex system , namely in three coherently couplet quantum dots ( tqd ) .
the qubit states are encoded in the doublet subspace and can be controlled by exchange interactions .
this subspace was pointed as a decoherence - free subspace ( dfs ) @xcite , which is immune to decoherence processes .
another advantage of this proposal is the purely electrical control of the exchange interactions by gate potentials which act locally and provide much faster operations . in the tqd system , in the contrast to the dqd qubit , one can modify more than one exchange interaction between the spins and perform full unitary rotation of the qubit states @xcite .
the three spin qubit has also more complicated energy spectrum which provides operations on more states in contrast to the two spin system .
recently experimental efforts were undertaken @xcite to get coherent spin manipulations in a linear tqd system according to the scheme proposed by divincenzo _
et al _ @xcite .
the initialization , coherent exchange and decoherence of the qubit states were shown in the doublet @xcite and doublet - quadruple subspace @xcite .
the read - out of the qubit state was performed , like in dqd , by means of the pauli blockade @xcite .
_ @xcite observed a quadruplet blockade effect which is based on reducing leakage current from quadruplet to triplet states in the presence of magnetic field .
@xcite showed that divincenzo s proposal can be realized on double quantum dots with many levels and three spin system controlled by gate potentials . in this paper
we demonstrate that tqd in a triangular geometry can work as a qubit .
this kind of tqd was already fabricated experimentally by local anodic oxidation with the atomic force microscope @xcite and the electron - beam lithography @xcite . in the triangular tqd
qubit exchange interactions between all spins are always on and very important is symmetry of the system .
trif et al .
@xcite and tsukerblat @xcite studied an influence of the electric field on the symmetry of triangular molecular magnets and spin configurations in the presence of a spin - orbit interaction .
divincenzo s scheme to encode the qubit in triangular tqd was considered by hawrylak and korkusinski @xcite where one of the exchange coupling was modified by gate potential .
recently georgeot and mila @xcite suggested to build the qubit on two opposite chiral states generated by a magnetic flux penetrating the triangular tqd .
one can use also a special configuration of magnetic fields ( one in - plane and perpendicular to the tqd system ) to encode a qubit in chirality states @xcite .
recent progres in theory and experiment with tqd system was reported in @xcite .
our origin idea is to use the fully electrical control of the symmetry of tqd to encode and manipulate the qubit in the doublet subspace .
the doublets are vulnerable to change the symmetry of tqd , which will be use to prepare and manipulate the qubit ( sec .
[ preparation ] ) .
the crucial aspect in quantum computations is to read - out the qubit states .
here we propose a new detection method , namely , a doublet blockade effect which manifests itself in currents for a special configuration of the local potential gates .
we show ( sec . [ detection ] ) that the doublet blockade is related with an asymmetry of a tunnel rates from source and drain electrodes to tqd and the inter - channel coulomb blockade .
the method is fully compatible with purely electrical manipulations of the qubit .
next we present studies of dynamics of the qubit and demonstrate the coherent and rabi oscillations ( sec .
[ dynamics ] ) .
the studies take into account relaxation and decoherence processes due to coupling with the electrodes as well as leakage from the doublet subspace in the measurement of current flowing through the system .
we derive characteristic times which describe all relaxation processes .
our model is general and can be used for a qubits encoded also in the linear tqd , which is a one of the cases of broken symmetry in the triangular tqd .
our system is a triangular artificial molecule built of three coherently coupled quantum dots with a single electron spin on each dot ( see .
fig.[fig1 ] ) .
interactions between the spins are described by an effective heisenberg hamiltonian @xmath0 where the zeeman term is included to show splitting by an external magnetic field @xmath1 ( @xmath2 is the bohr magneton , _ g _ is the electron g - factor ) and @xmath3 is an exchange interaction between electrons on sites @xmath4 and @xmath5
. the exchange parameter can be calculated by heitler - london and hund - mulliken method . for a defined confinement potential
one can find the parameter as a function of the interdot distance , the potential barrier and the magnetic field @xcite . for the system with three spins
there are two subspaces , one of them is a quadruplet with the total spin @xmath6 and @xmath7 .
the quadruplet states are given by : @xmath8 .
the second subspace is formed by doublet states with @xmath9 and @xmath10 . the doublet state for @xmath11
can be expressed as : @xmath12 @xmath13 and @xmath14 denote a singlet and triplet state on the @xmath15 bond , respectively . here
we assume large coulomb intradot interactions and ignore double electron occupancy .
in the doublet subspace ( [ d1])-([d2 ] ) one can express the hamiltonian ( [ heisenberg ] ) as @xmath16 using the pauli matrix representation .
the parameters are given by @xmath17 the eigenvalues of ( [ matrix2 ] ) are : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the doublet splitting and @xmath20 describes the energy differences between the doublet and the quadruplet subspace .
two other parameters @xmath21 and @xmath22 can be interpreted as an effective magnetic field in the _ z _ and _ x _ direction , respectively @xcite . in gaas
/ algaas quantum dots the exchange interaction @xmath20 is estimated in the range @xmath23 mev @xcite and in a molecular magnet as @xmath24 mev @xcite . the doublet splitting for a linear tqd is the order @xmath25
@xmath26ev @xcite .
this parameter can be even larger @xmath27 @xmath26ev in si / sige quantum dots @xcite .
in this paper we assume that the exchange couplings @xmath3 can be manipulated by local potential gates @xmath28 , which change potential barriers and modify electron hopping as well as local covalency between the quantum dots .
the exchange coupling can be expressed in the linear approximation as @xmath29 , where @xmath30 describes sensitivity of the exchange coupling to the gate voltage . for our analysis of the symmetry breaking in tqd ,
it is more suitable to parameterize the gate potentials as @xmath31 $ ] with @xmath32 , some amplitude @xmath33 and angle @xmath34 .
this parametrization corresponds to influence of an effective electric field @xmath35 on the bond polarization and covalency . for a small value of * e *
the exchange couplings can be expressed as @xmath36,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 , @xmath38 is a parameter describing sensitivity of the exchange coupling to the electric field , @xmath39 - the elementary electron charge ,
@xmath40 - the vector showing the position of the @xmath4-th quantum dot , @xmath34 is the angle between @xmath35 and the axis @xmath41 ( see fig.[fig1 ] ) .
a similar relation was obtained for the triangular molecule in the electric field which changed chirality of the spin system @xcite .
let us stress that because the electric field is taken as the small parameter , single electron occupancy of each dot is conserved and the ground state is always the doublet . in the tqd system one can also consider superexchange processes through excited double occupied states . applying local potential gates to the quantum dots
one can shift their energy levels and modify the superexchange couplings @xcite . because a parameter of inter - dot electron hopping is relatively small with respect to a intra - dot coulomb interaction , the modifications of the superexchange couplings are very small and
will not be discussed in the paper .
let us consider how to encode the qubit in the doublet subspace with the spin @xmath11 , expressed by @xmath42 .
this state is isolated from the doublet @xmath43 and the quadruplets states for a moderate magnetic field , @xmath44 .
the encoded qubit states @xmath45 and @xmath46 correspond to the doublets @xmath47 and @xmath48 , eq.([d1 ] ) and ( [ d2 ] ) ( the spin index @xmath49 is omitted to simplify the notation ) . in the further considerations the hyperfine and spin - orbit interactions
are ignored .
the qubit is prepared by a proper orientation @xmath34 of the effective electric field @xmath50 which changes the symmetry of the system .
[ eigenvectors ] presents density matrix elements @xmath51 and @xmath52 as a function of @xmath34 .
one can see that the qubit is prepared in the state @xmath47 for @xmath53 ( the electric field is oriented from the quantum dot 1 ) . for this symmetry
the exchange parameters are @xmath54 and from eq .
( [ delta ] ) and ( [ gamma ] ) one gets @xmath55 and the mixing between the doublets @xmath56 . for @xmath57
the electric field points to the quantum dot 1 and @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath56 . in this case
the qubit is prepared in the state @xmath48 .
we would like to emphasize that in the triangular tqd the both qubit states are equivalent and can be easily achieved only by change the symmetry of the system .
this is the main advantage in comparison with the linear tqd where the qubit can be prepare usually only in one of the doublet state .
( solid black curve ) and @xmath52 ( dashed red curve ) vs @xmath34 for the ground state at a moderate value of the electric field @xmath60 .
the left and right inserts shows direction of the electric field when the qubit is prepared in the states @xmath48 and @xmath47 , respectively .
these two opposite directions of the electric field corresponds to a minimal ( thin line ) and maximal ( thick line ) bond polarization between the dots 2 and 3.,scaledwidth=30.0% ] now we show how one can perform one qubit operations by means of the electric field .
after preparation of the qubit in one of the states @xmath47 or @xmath48 we change rapidly the angle @xmath34 to perform a dynamic rotation of the qubit state .
the qubit dynamics is described by the time - dependent schrdinger equation with the hamiltonian ( [ matrix2 ] ) .
we can show two basic quantum gates .
for @xmath61 the pseudo - spin rotates around the x - axis on the bloch sphere , which is the pauli - x quantum gate and the solution of the schrdinger is given by @xmath62 $ ] is an unitary operator of rotation around the x - axis .
second quantum gate we get for @xmath56 with the solution given by ( [ h2 ] ) but now instead @xmath63 we have @xmath64 $ ] which is an unitary operator of rotation around the z - axis .
these two rotations can be use to get to any point on the bloch sphere .
it is clearly seen that by modification of the parameters @xmath22 and @xmath21 one can get full control of the qubit operations ( see also @xcite ) .
in the linear tqd the read - out of the qubit state is possible due to charge - spin conversion in the regime of the pauli spin blockade .
a detuning voltage is applied between two outermost dots , which drives the system from single occupied configuration ( 1,1,1 ) to double occupied e.g. ( 2,0,1 ) .
this transfer is possible for an electron with the opposite spin orientation and can be detected by a quantum point contact ( qpc ) @xcite . in this section
we would like to show a new method to read - out the qubit state which is based on a measurement of currents flowing through the system .
the detection is compatible with electrical control of qubit state and the charge - spin conversion is not necessary .
we assume that tqd is coupled by tunnel junctions to the electrodes , where the first and the second dot are connected to the left and right electrode , respectively .
application of this method in an experimental setup is a similar technical complexity as qpc .
the electron transport through the tunnel junctions is studied within the sequential tunneling regime .
transfer rates from the left ( l ) and the right ( r ) electrode to tqd are given by : @xmath65 here we assume that both tunnel barriers are characterized by the same parameter @xmath66 , the reduced planck constant is taken @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 denote the states with two and three electrons with the corresponding energies @xmath70 and @xmath71 , @xmath72 is an electron creation operator on the dot 1 ( 2 ) with spin @xmath73 . _
f _ denotes the fermi distribution function , the electrochemical potentials in the left and the right electrode are @xmath74 and @xmath75 , where @xmath76 is the fermi energy and @xmath77 is an applied bias voltage . by analogy
one can define transfer rates @xmath78 from tqd to the electrodes .
we confine our considerations to a voltage window with transitions between the states with three and two electrons , but a similar situation one can expect for transitions between three and four electron states .
two electron states @xmath68 can be either the singlet @xmath79 or triplet @xmath80 . for a high intra - dot coulomb interaction one can neglect double occupied states and confine considerations to the states with single electron occupancy only . the singlet can be then expressed as a linear superposition : @xmath81 , where @xmath82 denotes the singlet on the @xmath83 pair of dots .
calculating the elements of the transfer matrices one can find net transfer rates between the doublet @xmath84 , @xmath85 and the singlet @xmath79 : latexmath:[\ ] ] @xmath195 has a lorentzian dependence and reaches its maximum for a resonance condition @xmath196 . in this case the doublet blockade is removed and higher current flows through the system . at the resonance condition ( @xmath196 ) .
the notation and the parameters are the same as in fig .
[ singdynamic ] .
notice that the results are presented in the rotating frame , whereas fig .
[ singdynamic ] presents the evolution in the laboratory frame .
the relaxation rates are @xmath149 , and @xmath151 . ]
[ singdynamicrez ] shows the density matrix elements , the currents and the oscillations on the bloch sphere for the driven case in the resonance ( @xmath196 ) .
we take the same parameters as for fig .
[ singdynamic ] but now the results are presented in the rotating frame .
one can see the large rabi oscillations of @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the population of the states is changed alternately between @xmath47 and @xmath48 with the frequency @xmath197 .
it is also seen in fig .
[ singdynamicrez]c which presents the rotation of the pseudo - spin on the bloch sphere .
the rotation is in the @xmath198-@xmath199 plane on the spiral with periodic transfers between the states @xmath51 and @xmath52 . in the stationary limit one gets @xmath200 and @xmath201 , which is a higher value than in the non - driven case with @xmath202 ( see fig . [ singdynamic ] ) .
the relaxation times @xmath166 and @xmath167 are almost the same as for the time independent case due to their weak dependance on @xmath22 and @xmath21 .
the current plots in fig .
[ singdynamicrez]b ) present strong oscillations which corresponds to coherent switching between the doublet states ( rabi oscillations ) .
the leakage current flowing through the right junction @xmath203 also shows some oscillations . the stationary current ( dashed line ) is larger than for the non - driven case as one may expect when the doublet blockade is removed .
switched on at @xmath152 .
panel a ) presents the time evolution of the density matrix elements , while b ) presents the current flowing through the left ( blue curve ) and right junction ( black curve ) .
the black - dashed line corresponds to the current in the stationary limit .
panel c ) shows the evolution of the pseudo - spin on the bloch sphere .
the initial state is @xmath48 ( the black arrow ) , and the final state is represented by the green arrow .
the parameters taken in the calculations : @xmath204 , @xmath205 the other parameters are the same as in fig.[blockadet ] .
the relaxation rates for these parameters are @xmath206 , @xmath207 , @xmath208 , and @xmath209 .
notice that in the present case the currents are smaller than those ones in fig.[singdynamic]b because now the transfer rates are different . ]
one can expect similar dynamics when the two - electron ground state is triplet .
here we still confine ourselves to the doublets with @xmath11 and ignore spin - flip processes . now in the voltage window ( see the inset in fig.[trypdynamic ] ) we have the states @xmath210 , @xmath211 and @xmath212 whereas @xmath213 is below the chemical potential in the left electrode .
the master equation ( [ dme ] ) is rewritten in the form @xmath214 here the population of the states is built - up by the transfers @xmath215 , @xmath216 and @xmath217 from the right electrode .
electrons escape from the system to the left electrode which is described by @xmath218 and @xmath219 .
the currents flowing from the right and the left electrode are expressed as @xmath220 notice that now the role of the doublet states @xmath47 and @xmath48 is reversed , and current flows through @xmath48 while @xmath47 is the dark state and blocks electron transport - see eq.([dtot1 ] ) . in the bloch space we have : @xmath221 one can easily find the main contributions to the relaxation rates : @xmath222 , which is qualitatively similar to the previously considered case with the singlet state but now the transfer rates are different [ compare eq.([dtos])-([dtos2 ] ) with eq.([dtot1])-([dtot4 ] ) ] .
the leakage to the triplet state is given by @xmath223 which has an additional term @xmath224 describing transfer from the triplet to quadruplet state .
the last row in eq.([master - dt ] ) and ( [ bloch - trip ] ) describes another leakage process with the relaxation rate @xmath225 .
this process changes the population of the triplet and the quadruplet state and indirectly influences dynamics in the doublet subspace . solving these equations we determine the occupation probabilities and consequently the currents : @xmath183 and @xmath180 .
the results are presented in fig .
[ trypdynamic ] for the time independent mixing term , @xmath226 for @xmath154 and @xmath48 as the initial state . on the top panel
one can see coherent oscillations for @xmath51 and @xmath52 similar as for the case with the singlet state .
however , due to the quadruplet state the dynamic of the doublets and their final occupation is different than for the singlet case . in the short time
range the population @xmath227 and @xmath228 increases due to leakage from the doublet subspace with characteristics rates @xmath167 and @xmath229 .
in the longer time scale the population @xmath227 goes to @xmath228 ( in the stationary limit @xmath230 ) . the influence of these states on the doublet dynamics is clearly seen in the currents @xmath231 and @xmath203 presented in fig .
[ trypdynamic]b .
@xmath183 shows different behavior than in the singlet case , because the doublet blockade is modified by the quadruplet state which gives an additional contribution to the current .
the increase of the current @xmath180 at the short time scale is related with the leakage to the triplet state . for longer times
@xmath180 is diminished but the quadruplet contribution makes the drop less pronounced than in the singlet case . the bottom panel , fig .
[ trypdynamic]c , presents the doublet dynamics on the bloch sphere .
the behavior of the bloch vector is similar as in the singlet case with some quantitative differences .
the phase and the amplitude damping is smaller which is the result of the longer relaxation times in the considered case . in the considerations above
we have taken into account only charge fluctuations on the evolution of the qubit .
let us now extend the studies and include spin - flip processes .
a spin of an electron captured on a quantum dot can interact with nuclear spins of many atoms confined in the area of the quantum dot , which can lead to decoherence of the qubit states .
the decoherence processes due to hyperfine interaction in triangular spin clusters has been already investigated by troiani et al .
@xcite . here
we consider another decoherence process caused by the spin relaxation in the electrodes .
the electrodes connected to tqd are paramagnetic and electron can be injected with spin up to the state @xmath232 or with spin down to @xmath233 .
this stochastic process leads to mixing between two doublet subspaces .
the evolution of the qubit is studied in the absence of the magnetic field .
we assume that the qubit is prepared in the state @xmath210 with the spin @xmath141 and the singlet is the ground state for two electrons .
similarly as in in the previous cases the qubit dynamics is govern by the master equation ( [ dme ] ) , but now we take into account states with different spin orientation @xmath234 , @xmath235 and @xmath79 @xmath236 where the transfer rates are the same for both spin orientations : @xmath237 and @xmath238 .
one can see that the master equation ( [ master - spin - flip ] ) represents dynamics of two doublet subspaces with @xmath11 and @xmath239 .
the subspaces are mixed with each other by transfers to the singlet state [ see fourth equation in ( [ master - spin - flip ] ) ] .
these two subspaces correspond to two pseudo - spin vectors on two bloch spheres .
each of the subspace is described by the master equation eq .
( [ bloch - sing ] ) but the relaxation rates are now : @xmath240 and the leakage process @xmath241 , which is twice larger than in the case without spin - flip due states degeneracy .
we make the laplace transformation of the master equation ( [ master - spin - flip ] ) and find the relaxation rates from the poles of the polynomial @xmath242 . here
the polynomial @xmath243 is the same as for the previous case [ described by eq .
( [ bloch - sing ] ) ] with the transfer rates including degeneracy of the doublet states .
the second polynomial @xmath244 $ ] is related with the spin flip - processes which mix two doublet subspaces . from @xmath245 one
finds the spin - flip relaxation times @xmath246 in the limit of weak coupling with the electrodes .
the rate @xmath247 is the second largest rate , after leakage and describes a rapid relaxation process , which can be seen in the short time scale .
@xmath248 corresponds the longest relaxation process which leads to total mixing of two doublet subspaces in the stationary limit .
the dynamics in the doublet subspace including spin - flip processes is presented in fig .
[ spinflip]a .
the time evolution of @xmath249 is similar to the case without spin - flip ( compare with fig .
[ singdynamic ] ) , but now its reduction in the short time scale is faster due to @xmath250 .
at the same time the @xmath251 is built - up with the rate @xmath250 , and goes to the stationary limit @xmath252 with the rate @xmath253 .
the qubit dynamics can be also seen in the spin current flowing through the left @xmath254 and right junction @xmath255
see fig.[spinflip ] b. the shape of the total current @xmath256 is very similar as in the case without spin - flip . to get
more information one needs to measure the spin dependent currents @xmath257 .
the dashed and dotted blue curves in fig .
[ spinflip ] b show @xmath258 and @xmath259 with the characteristic times @xmath260 in the short and long time scale .
the fast increase of the total current in the right electrode @xmath180 for the very short time scale is related with @xmath178 which now is two times shorter .
( blue dotted curve ) , @xmath261 ( blue dashed curve ) and right junction with spin @xmath262 ( black dashed curve ) .
notice that @xmath263 .
the total currents @xmath264 are plotted as a solid lines .
the parameters taken in the calculations are the same as in fig .
[ singdynamic ] .
the relaxation rates are @xmath265 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath266 , and @xmath267 . ]
let us estimate the characteristic times calculated in the paper .
in the first order of approximation the relaxation times are proportional to @xmath268 defined in equation ( [ transferrates ] ) .
the tunnel rate @xmath66 in ( [ transferrates ] ) is the order of nev for sequential transport @xcite
. however it can be much larger in the coherent regime ,
@xmath269 @xmath26ev @xcite .
if we assume @xmath270 @xmath26ev for our system then the relaxation and decoherence time is @xmath271 ns and @xmath272 ns for the case with singlet .
for triplet we have @xmath273 ns and @xmath274
ns . the leakage to the singlet and triplet states are @xmath275 ns and @xmath276 ns respectively .
these relaxation times are the same order as the decoherence time @xmath277 ns due to hyperfine interaction in gaas - based quantum dots @xcite . for the spin - flip
processes the relaxation times are : @xmath278 ns and @xmath279 ns .
one can see that due to the long relaxation time @xmath280 the qubit conserves its spin coherence for a time needed for a read - out process .
summarizing we have proposed the qubit controlled by a symmetry breaking effect in a triangular tqd system .
the main result of the paper is the new method for read - out of the qubit state by the current measurement in the doublet blockade regime , and the analysis of the qubit dynamics in the presence of decoherence processes caused by interaction with the electrodes .
we assumed that each dot contains one spin and the qubit was encoded in the doublet subspace .
the qubit states has been controlled by the applied gate potentials which break the triangular symmetry .
the calculations have been performed in the the heisenberg model where the exchange couplings are modified by the orientation @xmath34 of the electric field with respect to the triangular axes . for a specific @xmath34 one of the doublets
is occupied and can be taken as an initial qubit state for further manipulations . by quick impulses of the electric field
one can perform the pauli x - gate and z - gate operations .
a composition of these two operations gives full unitary control of the single qubit .
moreover we have demonstrated the new method to read - out of the qubit states using the electric transport through tqd and the doublet blockade effect .
the method is compatible with pure electrical manipulations and the spin - to - charge conversion is not necessary . the doublet blockade effect is related with an asymmetry of tunnel rates between the doublet states and the electrodes . for some specific symmetry of tqd one of the doublet states is a dark one and the electron transport is blocked .
we have considered two cases with the singlet and the triplet as a ground state for two electrons . for the singlet case
the current is blocked due to the doublet @xmath48 , whereas for transport from the triplet the dark state is the doublet @xmath47 .
the doublet blockade can be also used to detect the qubit states in the linear tqd .
however to satisfy the blockade condition @xmath56 one of the electrodes must be connected to the central dot .
moreover the blockade can be applied to dynamical initialization of the qubit state as well as to perform landau - zener passages @xcite .
we have also considered the time dependent electron transport in the doublet blockade regime .
our research gives information about dynamics of the qubit , the coherent oscillations and the relaxation processes due to presence of the electrodes .
a role of the leakage processes from the doublet to two electron states has been studied as well . for the triplet case
the leakage is larger than for singlet due to activation of the quadruplet state .
we have also presented the driven case where the mixing parameter between the doublet state is time dependent @xmath281 . in the resonance condition
@xmath196 the doublet blockade is partially removed and one can observe strong rabi oscillations .
moreover we have investigated mixing of the doublet subspaces with @xmath11 and @xmath239 caused by the spin - flip processes in the electrodes .
the total mixing time @xmath280 is very long what is promising for manipulation and read - out of the qubit .
z. shi , c. b. simmons , d. r. ward , j. r. prance , r. t. mohr , t. s. koh , j. k. gamble , x. wu , d. e. savage , m. g. lagally , m. friesen , s. n. coppersmith , and m. a. eriksson , phys . rev .
b * 88 * , 075416 ( 2013 ) . | we present a model of a qubit built of a three coherently coupled quantum dots with three spins in a triangular geometry .
the qubit states are encoded in the doublet subspace and they are controlled by a gate voltage , which breaks the triangular symmetry of the system .
we show how to prepare the qubit and to perform one qubit operations .
a new type of the current blockade effect will be discussed .
the blockade is related with an asymmetry of transfer rates from the electrodes to different doublet states and is used to read - out of the dynamics of the qubit state .
our research also presents analysis of the rabi oscillations , decoherence and leakage processes in the doublets subspace . |
lattice computations of the potential of a pair of static - light mesons ( in the following also referred to as @xmath0 mesons ) are of interest , because they constitute first principles determinations of a hadronic force .
such potentials can e.g. be used as input for phenomenological calculations to determine , whether two @xmath0 mesons may form a bound tetraquark state . in the literature interactions between static - light mesons
have been studied in the quenched approximation @xcite and recently also with dynamical quarks @xcite . here
i report on the status of an investigation with two flavors of dynamical wilson twisted mass quarks .
forces are not only studied between the lightest static - light mesons ( denoted by @xmath1 ) , but for the first time also first excitations are taken into account ( denoted by @xmath2 ) .
quantum numbers of single static - light mesons as well as of pairs of static - light mesons ( @xmath3 systems ) have been discussed in detail in @xcite . in the following
i give a brief summary .
i consider static - light mesons made from a static antiquark @xmath4 and a light quark @xmath5 without non - trivial gluonic excitations .
they can be labeled by the @xmath6-component of isospin @xmath7 , the @xmath6-component of the light quark spin @xmath8 and parity @xmath9 .
the @xmath10 static - light meson ( denoted by @xmath1 , corresponding to @xmath0/@xmath11 in @xcite ) is the lightest static - light meson . it is lighter by around @xmath12 than its parity partner with @xmath13 ( denoted by @xmath2 , corresponding to @xmath14 and @xmath15 ) .
the corresponding static - light meson trial states are @xmath16 and + @xmath17 for @xmath1 mesons and @xmath18 and @xmath19 for @xmath2 mesons , respectively . for a more detailed discussion of static - light mesons
i refer to @xcite .
the aim of this work is to compute the potential of a pair of @xmath0 mesons as a function of their separation @xmath20 ( without loss of generality i choose the axis of separation to be the @xmath6 axis ) . to this end
one has to compute the energies of eigenstates of the qcd hamiltonian containing two static antiquarks @xmath21 and @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath24 , which define the positions of the two @xmath0 mesons , and which will be surrounded by light quarks and gluons .
these @xmath3 states are characterized by the following five quantum numbers : isospin @xmath25 , the @xmath6-component of isospin @xmath26 , the absolute value of the @xmath6-component of the light quark spin @xmath27 , parity @xmath9 and `` @xmath28-parity '' ( reflection along the @xmath28-axis ) @xmath29 .
i use @xmath3 trial states @xmath30 where the lower indices @xmath31 , @xmath0 and @xmath32 denote spinor indices , @xmath33 is the charge conjugation matrix and @xmath34 is a suitably chosen combination of @xmath35 matrices .
note that it is essential to couple the light degrees of freedom of both mesons in spinor space , because these degrees of freedom determine the quantum number @xmath36 .
proceeding in a naive way by coupling light and static degrees of freedom in both @xmath0 mesons separately will not result in a well defined angular momentum @xmath36 and , therefore , will mix different @xmath3 sectors . to obtain @xmath37 , the flavors of the light quarks have to be chosen according to @xmath38 , while for @xmath39 three possibilities exist , @xmath40 . for a list of @xmath3 trial states and their quantum numbers
i refer to @xcite , table 1 .
i use @xmath41 gauge field configurations generated by the european twisted mass collaboration ( etmc ) .
the fermion action is @xmath42 wilson twisted mass @xcite at maximal twist , where static - light mass differences are automatically @xmath43 improved @xcite .
the gauge action is tree - level symanzik improved @xcite .
i use gauge coupling @xmath44 and light quark mass @xmath45 corresponding to a lattice spacing @xmath46 and a pion mass @xmath47 @xcite . for details regarding these gauge field configurations
i refer to @xcite .
in twisted mass lattice qcd at finite lattice spacing su(2 ) isospin is explicitely broken to u(1 ) , i.e. @xmath48 is still a quantum number , but @xmath49 is not .
moreover , parity @xmath50 has to be replaced by twisted mass parity @xmath51 , which is parity combined with light flavor exchange .
the consequence is that there are only half as many @xmath3 sectors in twisted mass lattice qcd as there are in qcd , i.e. qcd @xmath3 sectors are pairwise combined .
nevertheless , it is possible to unambiguously interpret states obtained from twisted mass correlation functions in terms of qcd quantum numbers .
the method has successfully been applied in the context of static - light mesons @xcite and is explained in detail for kaons and @xmath52 mesons in @xcite . for a more elaborate discussion of twisted mass symmetries in the context of @xmath3 systems
i refer to an upcoming publication @xcite .
the potential of a pair of @xmath0 mesons is extracted from the exponential falloff of correlation functions of trial states ( [ eqn001 ] ) . as explained in subsection [ sec002 ]
the trial states differ by the spin coupling of the light quarks via the @xmath53 matrix @xmath34 ( @xmath54 possibilities ) and by their light quark flavor ( @xmath55 possibilities ) .
consequently , there are @xmath56 different correlation functions .
this number can also be understood from the point of view of individual @xmath0 mesons : since each of the two @xmath0 mesons has @xmath57 possibilities regarding quantum numbers ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 ) , there should be @xmath58 @xmath3 correlation functions .
as outlined in subsection [ sec002 ] the @xmath3 trial states ( [ eqn001 ] ) can be classified according to @xmath3 quantum numbers . however , to interpret the @xmath3 potential obtained from the correlation function of a specific trial state ( [ eqn001 ] ) , it is also useful to express this trial state in terms of individual @xmath0 mesons , e.g. + @xmath59 @xmath60 @xmath61 + @xmath62 @xmath60 @xmath63 , + where @xmath1 and @xmath64 denote creation operators for @xmath1 and @xmath2 mesons , respectively , and @xmath65 and @xmath66 indicate the orientation of the light quark spin .
after linearly combining the two trial states via @xmath67 to eliminate the @xmath68 contributions , one can extract an @xmath69 potential with quantum numbers @xmath70 .
similarly , one can estimate a @xmath68 potential with the same quantum numbers by choosing @xmath71 .
results are shown in figure [ fig001](a ) .
further examples are discussed in @xcite .
@xmath3 potentials as functions of the meson separation .
( a ) @xmath69 potential and @xmath68 potential both with quantum numbers @xmath70 .
( b ) , ( c ) , ( d ) attractive @xmath69 singlet , isospin triplet and isospin / spin sextet . ]
@xmath3 potentials mainly differ in their asymptotic value at large meson separations , which is approximately @xmath72 , @xmath73 or @xmath74 for @xmath69 , @xmath75 or @xmath68 combinations , respectively , and whether they are attractive or repulsive at small meson separations .
some of the potentials , even though they differ in their quantum numbers , are exactly degenerate due to isospin symmetry ( @xmath39 triplets ) or rotational symmetry around the @xmath6-axis ( @xmath76 doublets ) . in summary
the number of attractive and repulsive @xmath3 potentials for @xmath69 , @xmath75 and @xmath68 combinations and their degeneracies are as follows : + [ cols= " < , < , < , < " , ] + consequently , from the @xmath77 trial states ( [ eqn001 ] ) one can extract @xmath78 different potentials . of particular interest ,
when asking , whether two @xmath0 mesons may form a bound tetraquark state , are attractive @xmath69 potentials .
as stated above there are three different possibilities , a singlet , an isospin triplet and an isospin / spin sextet .
the three potentials are shown in figure [ fig001](b ) to [ fig001](d ) .
while the triplet and the sextet are rather similar , the singlet is significantly different : it is deeper and wider and , therefore , probably the best candidate to start investigations , whether there are bound @xmath3 tetraquark states .
such phenomenological investigations will be part of a subsequent publication .
i have presented selected results of a first principles lattice computation of @xmath3 potentials .
various channels characterized by the quantum numbers @xmath79 have been investigated . compared to existing publications the computations have been performed with rather light dynamical quark mass ( @xmath80 ) .
the results have been interpreted in terms of individual @xmath1 and @xmath2 mesons .
future plans include studying the light quark mass dependence , the continuum limit as well as finite volume effects . moreover , also @xmath81 and @xmath82 potentials could be computed . to treat the @xmath83 quark as a fully dynamical quark
, such computations should be performed on @xmath84 flavor gauge field configurations currently generated by etmc @xcite .
finally , one should use the obtained @xmath3 potentials as input for phenomenological considerations to answer e.g. the question , whether two @xmath0 mesons are able to form a bound tetraquark state .
i thank the organizers of `` excited qcd 2011 '' for the invitation to give this talk .
i acknowledge useful discussions with pedro bicudo , william detmold , rudolf faustov , roberto frezzotti , vladimir galkin , chris michael and attila nagy . this work has been supported in part by the dfg sonderforschungsbereich tr9 computergesttzte theoretische teilchenphysik . c. stewart and r. koniuk , phys .
d * 57 * , 5581 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/9803003 ] . c. michael and p. pennanen [ ukqcd collaboration ] , phys .
d * 60 * , 054012 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/9901007 ] .
m. s. cook and h. r. fiebig , arxiv : hep - lat/0210054 .
t. doi , t. t. takahashi and h. suganuma , aip conf .
proc . * 842 * , 246 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0601008 ] .
w. detmold , k. orginos and m. j. savage , phys .
d * 76 * , 114503 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0703009 ] . m. wagner [ etm collaboration ] , pos * lattice2010 * , 162 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1008.1538 [ hep - lat ] ] .
g. bali and m. hetzenegger , pos * lattice2010 * , 142 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1011.0571 [ hep - lat ] ] .
k. nakamura _ et al .
_ [ particle data group ] , j. phys .
g * 37 * , 075021 ( 2010 ) .
k. jansen , c. michael , a. shindler and m. wagner [ etm collaboration ] , jhep * 0812 * , 058 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0810.1843 [ hep - lat ] ] . c. michael , a. shindler and m. wagner [ etm collaboration ] , jhep * 1008 * , 009 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1004.4235 [ hep - lat ] ] .
r. frezzotti , p. a. grassi , s. sint and p. weisz [ alpha collaboration ] , jhep * 0108 * , 058 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0101001 ] .
r. frezzotti and g. c. rossi , jhep * 0408 * , 007 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0306014 ] .
p. weisz , nucl .
b * 212 * , 1 ( 1983 ) .
r. baron _ et al .
_ [ etm collaboration ] , arxiv:0911.5061 [ hep - lat ] .
boucaud _ et al . _
[ etm collaboration ] , phys .
b * 650 * , 304 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/0701012 ] .
p. boucaud _ et al .
_ [ etm collaboration ] , comput .
commun . * 179 * , 695 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0803.0224 [ hep - lat ] ] .
b. blossier , m. wagner and o. pene [ etm collaboration ] , jhep * 0906 * , 022 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0903.2298 [ hep - lat ] ] .
r. baron _ et al .
_ [ etm collaboration ] , comput .
commun . *
182 * , 299 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1005.2042 [ hep - lat ] ] .
m. wagner [ etm collaboration ] , to be published . | i report on a lattice computation of the energy of a system of two light quarks and two static antiquarks as a function of the separation of the static antiquarks . in terms of hadrons
such a system corresponds to a pair of @xmath0 mesons and its energy to the hadronic potential .
i present selected results for different isospin , spin and parity combinations of the individual @xmath0 mesons mainly focusing on those channels relevant to determine , whether two @xmath0 mesons may form a bound tetraquark state . |
most solid tumors eventually establish colonies in distant anatomical locations ; when these colonies become clinically detectable , they are called macrometastasis . while often there is a large burden from primary tumors , it is in fact metastatic disease that is responsible for most cancer fatalities @xcite .
the creation of macrometastasis requires the successful completion of a sequence of difficult steps .
first , cancer cells must gain access to the general circulation system via the process of intravasation .
next , the cells must survive in the inhospitable environment of the circulatory system . following this
, the tumor cells must exit the circulatory system ( extravasation ) at a distant site and initiate micrometastsis ( clinically undetectable population of tumor cells at a distant anatomical site ) .
lastly , the micrometastsis must develop the ability to successfully proliferate in the distant site and grow into clinically identifiable macrometastasis .
the completion of these steps is very difficult and only a small fraction of tumor cells are able to achieve this @xcite .
however , due to the vast number of cells in most primary tumors , metastasis commonly occurs in later stage solid tumors . there has been significant mathematical research in the design of optimal anti - cancer therapies .
this has included studies on optimal chemotherapy , radiotherapy , and more recently targeted therapies and immunotherapy ( @xcite ) .
since we are interested in radiotherapy we will focus on previous work in this field .
the vast majority of modeling of radiotherapy response is based on the linear - quadratic model ( lq ) which says that tissue response is governed by the parameters @xmath1 and @xmath2 ( see e.g. , @xcite ) . specifically , following a single exposure to @xmath3 gray of radiation , the surviving fraction of viable cells
is given by @xmath4 .
an important question in this field is to decide on the optimal temporal distribution of a given amount of radiation , i.e. , how to kill the most tumor cells while inflicting the least amount of normal tissue damage .
this is commonly referred to as the ` optimal fractionation problem . '
two possible solutions to this problem are hyper - fractionated and hypo - fractionated schedules . in hyper - fractionated schedules ,
small fraction sizes are delivered over a large number of treatment days , while in hypo - fractionated schedules , large fraction sizes are delivered over a small number of treatment days .
if we minimize primary tumor cell population at the conclusion of treatment , it has been seen ( @xcite and @xcite ) that whether hyper or hypo - fractionation is preferable depends on the radiation sensitivity parameters of the normal and cancerous tissue .
however we will observe in section 4 of this manuscript that when designing optimal treatments with the goal of minimizing metastatic production , hypo - fractionation is preferable for many parameter choices , and hyper - fractionation is only preferable sometimes when the @xmath0 value of the tumor is large .
there have been a substantial number of works looking at optimal fractionation . the work @xcite considers dynamic design of fractionation schedules with incomplete repair , repopulation and reoxygenation . a more recent work @xcite considers the optimization problem associated with finding fractionation schedules under an lq model with incomplete repair and exponential repopulation .
the authors theoretically establish the benefits of hypo - fractionation in the setting of a low @xmath0 value of the tumor . brenner and hall
@xcite utilized the lq model in combination with the lea - catcheside function ( a generalization of the lq model that is useful at higher doses or prolonged doses ) to conclude that due to its slow response to radiation , prostate cancer can be treated equally effectively by either uniform radiation scheduling or hypo - fractionation ( which has fewer side effects ) .
unkelbach et al .
@xcite studied the interdependence between optimal spatial dose distribution and creation of fractionation schedules .
another work @xcite utilized a dynamic programming approach to study the problem of optimal fractionation schedules in the presence of various repopulation curves .
an important property common to all of these works is that they utilize an objective function that seeks to minimize final primary tumor population size in some sense . while this can be an important objective , in most cancers , it is ultimately metastatic disease that proves fatal
. therefore , in this work , we study optimal fractionation schedules when using an objective function that seeks to minimize the total production of metastatic cells .
the understanding of the metastatic process and how to respond to it has been greatly aided by the mathematical modeling community ( for an overview of this contribution see the recent review paper @xcite ) . in an interesting work @xcite , iwata et al .
developed a set of differential equations governing the population dynamics of the metastatic population .
a compelling work is the paper by thames et al .
@xcite where they developed a mathematical model of the metastatic process to calculate risk from metastatic disease due to delay in surgery . hanin and korosteleva @xcite used a stochastic model to address questions such as : ( 1 ) how early do metastasis events occur , ( 2 ) how does extirpation of the primary affect evolution of the metastasis , and ( 3 ) how long are metastasis latent ?
haeno and michor @xcite developed a multitype branching process model to study metastasis and in particular the probability of metastasis being present at diagnosis . in a follow up work @xcite
, they used a mathematical model to study metastasis data in recently deceased pancreatic cancer patients . in a recent work @xcite , diego et al .
used an ode model to study the relationship between primary and metastatic cancer sites , and in particular , makes predictions about the clinical course of the disease based on the parameter space of their ode model .
the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : metsprod ] , we discuss a model for metastasis production and how it can be used to develop a function that reflects metastatic risk .
next , in section [ sec : opt ] , we describe the optimization model and solution approach .
finally , in section [ sec : num ] , we present numerical results in the setting of breast cancer .
we start by assuming that the total population of primary tumor cells at time @xmath5 is given by the function @xmath6 .
note we will assume throughout this work that the population of cells is large enough that we can treat the population as a deterministic function .
we then assume that each tumor cell initiates a successful macrometastasis at rate @xmath7 per unit of time .
this is similar to the modeling approach taken in @xcite where they were able to fit their model to metastasis data from patients .
if we are interested in the time horizon @xmath8 $ ] then our total rate of production of successful macrometastasis on that interval is @xmath9 in particular @xmath10 , the number of successful metastasis established in the time interval in @xmath8 $ ] , is a poisson random variable with mean @xmath11 and thus the probability of metastasis occurring is @xmath12 .
therefore , in order to minimize @xmath13 , it suffices to minimize @xmath11 . in the rate @xmath11 , we assume that every cell is capable of metastasis . in the geometry of the actual tumor , it might be the case that only those cells on the surface of the tumor are capable of metastasis , or only those cells in close proximity to a blood vessel are capable .
therefore , we consider the generalization @xmath14 for @xmath15 .
this is similar to the model of metastasis creation in @xcite ; there they refer to the parameter @xmath16 as the fractal dimension of the blood vessels infiltrating the tumor , if we assume that the tumor is three dimensional with a two dimensional surface and that all cells on the surface are equally capable of metastasis then we can take @xmath17 .
however if we assume that only a small fraction of cells on the surface are capable of metastasis we could take e.g. , @xmath18 .
notice that in order to minimize @xmath19 , we do not need to know the parameter @xmath20 , which is difficult to measure .
note that we are using a rather simplistic model for the metastasis production in that we assume at most only two rates of metastasis for the primary tumor cells . in reality , it is likely that the rate of metastasis for a given cell will be a complex function of its position , migratory potential , and its oxidative state .
however , given the lack of data available , we found it preferable to work with this relatively simplistic model that does not require the knowledge of any intricate parameters .
in addition , since the primary goal of this work is to introduce a novel objective function , we feel that adding further biological details can be saved for further exploration .
lastly and importantly , variants of this relatively simplistic model have been matched to clinical metastasis data @xcite .
our goal is to determine an optimal radiotherapy fractionation scheme that minimizes the probability that the primary tumor volume metastasizes . given the discussion from the previous section , this equates to minimizing @xmath19 ; however , for simplicity , we will use an approximate objective that uses a summation rather than an integral during therapy .
let the time horizon @xmath21 consists of treatment days and a potentially long period of no treatment at the end of which metastatic risk is evaluated .
suppose a radiation dose @xmath22 is delivered at time instant @xmath5 , for @xmath23 , then we choose to minimize @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the number of cells immediately before the delivery of dose @xmath26 .
during the course of the treatment , we assume exponential tumor growth with a time lag . beyond that
, we use the gomp - ex model for tumor growth because we are evaluating long - term metastatic risk and the exponential model will give unreasonably large values over such a long time period . the gomp - ex law of growth
assumes that the cellular population expands through the exponential law @xcite initially , when there is no competition for resources .
however , there is a critical size threshold @xmath27 such that for @xmath28 the growth follows the gompertz law .
thus , we have @xmath29 for @xmath30 and @xmath31 for @xmath32 $ ] where @xmath33 and @xmath34 are tumor tissue sensitivity parameters , @xmath35 is the tumor doubling time in units of days , @xmath36 is the tumor kick - off time , @xmath37 is the tumor size at the starting of treatment , @xmath38 is the carrying capacity and @xmath39 is a constant related to the proliferative ability of the cells .
the expression @xmath40 is defined as @xmath41 .
@xmath42 is the time when the tumor population reaches size @xmath27 and can be computed using following equation @xmath43 we also use the concept of biological effective dose ( bed ) to constrain the side - effects in the oar around the tumor .
we assume that a dose @xmath3 results in a homogeneous dose @xmath44 in the @xmath45th oar , where @xmath46 is the sparing factor ; for the heterogeneous case , it is possible to use the approach in @xcite .
the bed in the @xmath45th oar is defined by @xmath47_i } } \right),\ ] ] where @xmath48_i}$ ] is an oar tissue sensitivity parameter .
the bed can be derived from the lq model and is used to quantify fractionation effects in a clinical setting .
note that we can also have multiple bed constraints on a single oar , e.g. , to model early and late effects .
the optimization problem of interest is @xmath49 s.t .
@xmath50_i}}\right ) \leq c_i,\ \
i=1,\dots , m\ ] ] where @xmath51 is a constant that specifies an upper bound to the @xmath45th bed in the oar and @xmath52 is the total number of oars in the vicinity of tumor .
note that we do not work directly with the quantity @xmath53 during therapy but instead with its approximation @xmath54 .
here , @xmath55 is an upper bound for @xmath53 and is a good approximation for @xmath53 if the impact of the exponential growth term in ( [ eq : linearquadraticexp ] ) is relatively small compared to the dose fraction terms , which is typically the case for most disease sites .
formulation is a nonconvex quadratically constrained problem .
such problems are computationally difficult to solve in general . however
, we can use a dynamic programming ( dp ) approach with only two states to solve this deterministic problem , similar to the work in @xcite .
the states of the system are @xmath56 , the cumulative dose , and @xmath57 , the cumulative dose squared , delivered to the tumor immediately after time @xmath5 .
we have @xmath58 @xmath59 now we can write the dp algorithm ( forward recursion ) as @xmath60 , & t\le n_0 - 1\\ \min_{d_{t}\ge0}[x_0^\xi e^{-\xi\left ( \alpha_t ( u_{t-1}+d_{t } ) + \beta_t ( v_{t-1}+d_{t}^2)-\frac{\ln 2}{\tau_d}(t - t_k)^+\right)}+j_{t-1}(u_{t-1},v_{t-1})]+\int_{n_0}^{t}(x_t)^\xi , & t = n_0\end{cases}\ ] ] with @xmath61 , @xmath62 .
we set the function @xmath63 to be @xmath64 if @xmath65_i } } v_t > c_i\ ] ] for any @xmath66 .
since there are only two state variables , we can solve our optimization problem by discretizing the states and using this dp algorithm .
we solve the optimization problem based on the radiobiological parameters for breast cancer .
we consider two different normal tissues @xcite , heart and lung tissue . for each normal tissue , we define the maximal toxicity @xmath67_i}}\frac{d_i^2}{n_i}\ ] ] where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are tissue specific parameters and define the maximum total dose @xmath68 delivered in @xmath69 fractions for each oar .
a standard fractionated treatment is to deliver @xmath70 gy to the tumor with @xmath71 gy fractions @xcite .
the tolerance bed values ( @xmath51 ) for various normal tissues were computed based on the standard scheme . hence all bed in oar associated with optimal schedules obtained in this section
are less than or equal to their corresponding bed in standard schedule , i.e. @xmath72 gy and @xmath73 for @xmath74 .
all radiobiological parameter values used are listed in table [ tabledata ] along with their sources .
.breast tumor and normal tissues parameters [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ]
in this work , we have considered the classic problem of optimal fractionation schedules in the delivery of radiation .
we have however done this with the non - traditional goal of minimizing the production of metastasis .
this is motivated by the fact that the majority of cancer fatalities are driven by metastasis @xcite , and that this disseminated disease can be very difficult to treat .
we addressed this goal by considering the optimal fractionation problem with a novel objective function based on minimizing the total rate of metastasis production , which we argue is equivalent to minimizing the time integrated tumor cell population .
we were able to numerically solve this optimization problem with a dynamic programming approach .
we computed radiotherapy fractionation schedules that minimized metastatic risk for a variety of parameter settings .
the resulting optimal schedules had an interesting structure that was quite different from what is observed from the traditional optimal fractionation problem where one is interested in minimizing local tumor population at the end of treatment . in the traditional optimal fractionation problem
it was observed in @xcite that if @xmath48_t}\le\min_i\{{[\alpha/\beta]_i}/\gamma_i\}$ ] then a hypo - fractionated schedule is optimal and if @xmath48_t}>\min_i\{{[\alpha/\beta]_i}/\gamma_i\}$ ] then a hyper - fractionated schedule is optimal .
in contrast , in the current work we observed that if we are evaluating metastatic risk at the conclusion of therapy then independent of the relationship between @xmath48_t}$ ] and @xmath75_i}/\gamma_i\}$ ] , the resulting fractionation schedules for minimizing metastatic risk is a hypo - fractionated structure with large initial doses that taper off quickly .
this is due to the structure of the objective function . in order to minimize the time integrated tumor cell population immediately after treatment , it is necessary to quickly reduce the tumor cell population since this is the high point of the tumor cell population over the course of the treatment .
if we think of the tumor cell population as quite dangerous due to its metastasis potential , then it is natural to want to reduce their population as quickly as possible .
we observed that the structure of the optimal schedule depends on the length of time for which we evaluated metastatic risk .
in particular if we evaluate metastasis risk in a long time frame ( several years ) after therapy , and it holds that @xmath48_t}>\min_i\{{[\alpha/\beta]_i}/\gamma_i\}$ ] , then the optimal schedule will have either medium initial doses tapering off slowly ( that is , a schedule where @xmath76 ) or equal - dosage routine where we have @xmath77 .
this is in contrast to when we evaluate metastatic risk over the course of the treatment period , in which case a hypo - fractionated schedule is nearly always optimal .
note that if our evaluation time - frame of metastatic risk is several years after the conclusion of therapy , then we want to minimize the tumor cell population as soon as possible to reduce initial metastatic risk , but we also need to avoid a large tumor population in the long time period after the conclusion of treatment .
in many of our results , we observed the optimality of hypo - fractionated schedules .
interestingly , previous clinical trials , e.g. , the fast trial for breast cancer @xcite and the chhip trial for prostate cancer @xcite , show the benefit of hypo - fractionation . it should be noted that the motivation for these trials was the low @xmath48_t}$ ] value in prostate and breast tumors .
our results indicate even when the @xmath48_t}$ ] ratio of the tumor is very large , it may still better to deliver a hypo - fractionated schedule when taking metastatic risk into account .
the current work provides a possible new motivation for considering hypo - fractionated schedules , i.e. , metastasis risk reduction . in this paper
, we have assumed the delivery of single daily fractions and have not considered alternate fractionation schemes such as chart @xcite that deliver multiple fractions a day .
some of our results indicate optimal hypo - fractionation schedules ( as obtained for the t=0.07 case ) .
one way to deliver a large amount of dose in a very short period of time is to use such schemes like chart .
however , additional modeling is needed to incorporate incomplete sublethal damage repair due to short inter - fraction time periods .
another possible interpretation of this work is to view the output @xmath53 as the risk of the tumor developing resistance to a chemotherapeutic treatment .
this can be achieved by simply viewing the parameter @xmath20 as the rate at which tumor cells develop drug resistance . due to the severe consequences of drug resistance , this is also an interesting direction for further exploration .
we feel that this type of work minimizing metastatic production opens the potential for a new line of research in the radiation optimization community as well as cancer biology .
in particular , there are several important biological phenomena that we have not included .
this includes oxygenation status ( and history ) of cells as well as the vascular structure of the tumor of interest .
lastly , a potentially interesting extension of this work could be to validate our predictions in animal models of metastatic cancer .
t. bortfeld , j. ramakrishnan , j. n tsitsiklis , and j. unkelbach .
optimization of radiation therapy fractionation schedules in the presence of tumor repopulation .
forthcoming in informs journal on computing .
, 2013 .
m. mizuta , s. takao , h. date , n. kishimoto , k. sutherland , r. onimaru , and h. shirato . a mathematical study to select fractionation regimen based on physical dose distribution and the linear - quadratic model . , 84:829833 , 2012 .
g. tortorelli , et al .
standard or hypofractionated radiotherapy in the postoperative treatment of breast cancer : a retrospective analysis of acute skin toxicity and dose inhomogeneities . , 13(1):230 , 2013 .
j. owen , a. ashton , j. bliss , j. homewood and et al . .
effect of radiotherapy fraction size on tumour control in patients with early - stage breast cancer after local tumour excision : long - term results of a randomised trial .
, 7:467471 , 2006 .
d. dearnaley , i. syndikus , g. sumo , m. bidmead , d. bloomfield , c. clark , ... & e. hall .
conventional versus hypofractionated high - dose intensity - modulated radiotherapy for prostate cancer : preliminary safety results from the chhip randomised controlled trial .
, 13:4354 , 2012 . | metastasis is the process by which cells from a primary tumor disperse and form new tumors at distant anatomical locations .
the treatment and prevention of metastatic cancer remains an extremely challenging problem .
this work introduces a novel biologically motivated objective function to the radiation optimization community that takes into account metastatic risk instead of the status of the primary tumor . in this work
, we consider the problem of developing fractionated irradiation schedules that minimize production of metastatic cancer cells while keeping normal tissue damage below an acceptable level . a dynamic programming framework is utilized to determine the optimal fractionation scheme .
we evaluated our approach on a breast cancer case using the heart and the lung as organs - at - risk ( oar ) . for small tumor @xmath0 values ,
hypo - fractionated schedules were optimal , which is consistent with standard models .
however , for relatively larger @xmath0 values , we found the type of schedule depended on various parameters such as the time when metastatic risk was evaluated , the @xmath0 values of the oars , and the normal tissue sparing factors .
interestingly , in contrast to standard models , hypo - fractionated and semi - hypo - fractionated schedules ( large initial doses with doses tapering off with time ) were suggested even with large tumor @xmath1/@xmath2 values .
numerical results indicate potential for significant reduction in metastatic risk . |
since the discovery of the giant magnetoresistance effect,@xcite research in spintronics has been developing at a fast pace . an important requirement for practical applications of this novel technology is the generation , control and manipulation of spin - polarized currents preferably using electric fields only.@xcite spin - orbit interactions in semiconductor materials are promising tools to achieve that goal .
in particular , the rashba interaction,@xcite a type of spin - orbit coupling that originates from a lack of inversion symmetry in semiconductor heterostructures ( such as inas or gaas ) , has been experimentally shown to possess a high degree of tunability using gate contacts.@xcite since the spin - orbit interaction couples the electron momentum and its spin , the rashba field behaves as an effective magnetic field that is responsible for spin coherent oscillations , which can be exploited in spintronics .
based on this property , datta and das suggested a spin field - effect transistor.@xcite it consists of a one - dimensional ballistic channel sandwiched by two ferromagnetic contacts .
their proposal relies on the control of the current along the channel using the rashba interaction via a third terminal ( the gate ) and the relative orientation of the leads magnetizations .
the length of the channel and the intensity of the rashba strength determine the flow of the current .
realization of the spin transistor was hindered by some limitations , such as the mismatch problem ( which results in poor injection of spin - polarized current between a ferromagnet and a semiconductor)@xcite and the idealization of ballistic transport.@xcite however , recent experiments on quasi - two dimensional structures@xcite , already discussed in refs . , have overcome these obstacles and have obtained a behavior which looks similar to the spin transistor effect . in reality , strictly one - dimensional channels are hard to fabricate and one must deal mostly with _
quasi_-one dimensional systems containing many propagating channels .
confinement in the transversal direction is accomplished with potentials leading to subband spacings often smaller than a few mev , the order of magnitude of the fermi energy in low - dimensional systems . as a consequence ,
multiple subbands are populated and channel mixing effects become relevant in many situations .
in fact , the rashba interaction itself includes an intersubband mixing term which couples adjacent subbands with opposite spins .
this coupling has been recently demonstrated to give rise to strongly modulated conductance curves,@xcite especially close to the onset of higher - energy plateaus , due to fano interference@xcite between propagating waves and rashba induced localized levels.@xcite in the presence of in - plane magnetic fields , rashba coupling induced intersubband mixing effects are shown@xcite to reduce the visibility of anomalous conductance steps,@xcite and to produce transmission asymmetric lineshapes even in purely one - dimensional systems.@xcite in this paper , we analyze the role of intersubband coupling effects in multichannel quantum wires .
our model consists of a quantum wire with a localized rashba spin - orbit interaction coupled to ferromagnetic leads with magnetization perpendicular to the direction of the rashba field .
we find that the rashba intersubband coupling term modifies the spin precession effect in a dramatic way .
typically , one finds a few oscillation cycles in the conductance curves before arriving at a strongly irregular domain at high values of the rashba parameter in which case the intersubband coupling produces an effective randomization of the injected spins independent of the relative orientation of the leads magnetization .
therefore , our results point out a serious limitation of the spin transistor performance , even in the ideal cases of perfect spin injection and fully ballistic propagation . on the other hand ,
rashba interaction has lately deserved much attention as a generation procedure of spin - polarized currents .
several methods have been proposed in different setups ( see refs . , although the list is by no means exhaustive ) .
we here consider a simple system : a rashba quantum wire attached to two nonmagnetic leads .
we find that the rashba interaction can produce a highly polarized electric current and that the effect is purely due to interchannel coupling . for quantum waveguides supporting a single propagating mode , the polarization effect vanishes.@xcite
since the rashba interaction is localized , we calculate the generated polarization as a function of the interface smoothness and show that the highest values of the polarization are obtained when the transition between the regions with and without spin - orbit interaction is abrupt . in sec .
ii we discuss the physical system and establish the theoretical model to calculate the linear conductance .
section iii is devoted to the numerical results when the contacts are ferromagnetic .
the spin polarization effect in the case of normal contacts is analyzed in sec .
finally , sec .
v contains our conclusions .
we consider a quasi - one dimensional system ( a quantum wire ) with a localized rashba interaction ( the rashba dot ) coupled to semi - infinite leads .
figure [ fig1 ] shows a sketch of the physical system .
transport occurs along the @xmath0 direction .
we characterize the rashba dot as a small region of length @xmath1 with strong spin - orbit coupling with strength @xmath2 .
the spin polarization in the leads is described using the stoner model for itinerant ferromagnets . due to exchange interaction among the electrons ,
the electronic bands in the asymptotic regions become spin split with a splitting phenomenologically given by an effective field @xmath3 , which we take as a parameter .
this approximation is good at low temperatures ( lower than the curie temperature ) and for electron densities large enough so that strong correlations can be safely neglected.@xcite denoting the stoner field in left and right regions by @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively , the parallel configuration is described by @xmath6 while the antiparallel corresponds to @xmath7 .
in addition , we assume that a local gate potential @xmath8 is aligning the potential bottom of the successive regions . this way we remove unwanted conductance modifications due to the potential mismatches,@xcite thus focussing on the properties induced purely by the spin - orbit coupling
. the system hamiltonian reads @xmath9 the confinement along the direction @xmath10 , perpendicular to the current , is taken as parabolic with oscillator frequency @xmath11 , which defines the length @xmath12 .
the inhomogeneous rashba coupling @xmath13 is given by @xmath14 where , as usual , spin is represented by the vector of pauli matrices @xmath15 while @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the cartesian components of the electron s linear momentum .
the rashba intensity @xmath18 varies smoothly taking a constant value @xmath2 inside the rashba dot and vanishing elsewhere .
the term proportional to @xmath16 is responsible for spin precession of an injected electron.@xcite the intersubband coupling term proportional to @xmath17 couples adjacent subbands with opposite spins .
finally , the term with the derivative @xmath19 is added in eq .
( [ eqr ] ) to ensure the hermitian character of the hamiltonian . as mentioned above
, the stoner field @xmath20 is constant in the left and right asymptotic regions ( @xmath21 ) and it smoothly vanishes at distances @xmath22 towards the left and right of the rashba dot .
these are assumed large enough such that all evanescent states at the interface vanish before reaching the leads .
the gate potential aligning the band bottom of the different regions is taken as @xmath23 .
an equivalent choice but localized to the rashba dot would be @xmath24 .
all spatial transitions in @xmath18 and @xmath20 are described using fermi - like type functions characterized by a small diffusivity @xmath25.@xcite in general , @xmath25 is assumed to be small enough , although we shall also discuss below the dependence with this parameter in some cases . for a given energy @xmath26 the electron wave function fulfills schrdinger s equation @xmath27 with the appropriate boundary conditions .
our method of solution combines discretization of the longitudinal variable @xmath0 in a uniform grid with a basis expansion in transverse eigenfunctions @xmath28 and in eigenspinors @xmath29 along a direction given by a unitary vector @xmath30 , @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the spin quantum number while @xmath33 denotes the twofold spin discrete variable . in terms of the polar and azimuthal angles
@xmath34 corresponding to the spin quantization axis @xmath30 we can write @xmath35 the transverse eigenfunctions are the solutions of the harmonic 1d oscillator @xmath36 with @xmath37 projecting eq .
( [ eqs ] ) onto the basis we obtain the equations for the unknown _ channel amplitudes _ @xmath38 @xmath39 notice that the rashba interaction is the only source of interchannel coupling since , in general , the matrix element @xmath40 will be non diagonal . using the separation in two spin - orbit contributions introduced in eq .
( [ eqr ] ) we can write @xmath41 equations ( [ eq9 ] ) and ( [ eq10 ] ) clearly show that , in general , both @xmath42 and @xmath43 couple channels with opposite spins through the matrix elements @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
of course , if the spin quantization axis @xmath30 is chosen along the @xmath0 or @xmath10 axis then either @xmath44 or @xmath45 become diagonal .
regarding the coupling between transverse modes , we notice that @xmath43 is always diagonal ( @xmath46 ) while @xmath42 is connecting modes differing in one subband index ( @xmath47 ) through the oscillator matrix element @xmath48 .
if we neglect @xmath42 as in strict one - dimensional systems , eq .
( [ ccm ] ) involves a single mode @xmath49 .
if , in addition , the spin axis is chosen along @xmath10 then the two spin modes uncouple and no spin oscillation is allowed ; in other directions ( @xmath0 or @xmath50 ) a rigid spin precession should be expected if all the contribution between parenthesis in eq .
( [ eq10 ] ) is assumed constant .
this precession is the underlying working mechanism of the datta - das spin transistor.@xcite below we investigate the solution of eq .
( [ ccm ] ) in the general case in order to analyze the robustness of the _ spin precession _
scenario when @xmath42 is included and when space inhomogeneity in @xmath18 is also taken into account .
the appendix contains the details of the employed numerical method to compute the transmission @xmath51 , i.e. , the probability amplitude from a given left incident mode @xmath52 to the right mode @xmath53 .
then , using the scattering approach the linear - response conductance is given by , @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the conductance quantum .
for later discussion on the polarization of the transmitted current we also define the _ polarized _ conductance @xmath56 , @xmath57 and the relative polarization @xmath58 @xmath59 , @xmath60 we shall pay special attention to the multichannel case considering energies @xmath26 in eq .
( [ ccm ] ) such that up to 10 propagating modes are active in the leads .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the results for polarized leads oriented along @xmath0 .
when @xmath42 is neglected the conductance for 5 and 10 propagating modes displays an almost sinusoidal behavior with only minor distortions .
these deviations , which are enhanced in the single mode case , can be attributed to the quantum interference with the rashba dot.@xcite the present results confirm , therefore , the precession scenario mentioned above but only when the number of modes is large enough and interband coupling is neglected .
quite remarkably , however , this scenario is not robust with the inclusion of @xmath42 .
when the full rashba interaction is considered only for small values of @xmath2 the conductance behaves in a regular way .
very rapidly as @xmath2 increases @xmath61 fluctuates in a staggered way that resembles the conductance fluctuations of disordered systems .
the mean value , in units of @xmath62 , is @xmath63 , with @xmath64 the number of active channels , while the amplitude of the fluctuation decreases when @xmath64 increases .
the existence of the first conductance minimum has been clearly seen in the experiments of ref . .
our results are in agreement with this experiment , but they also predict that successive maxima and minima are heavily distorted or even fully washed out .
it is also worth noticing that the first conductance minimum for the black dots occurs at a slightly lower value of @xmath2 than that of the grey ( red color ) data , indicating that the minima @xmath65 are somewhat contracted with respect to the simple prediction from the rashba dot length : @xmath66 , with @xmath67 ( red symbols ) .
figure [ fig3 ] contains the results for polarized leads along @xmath0 but in antiparallel directions . in this case , when @xmath68 the conductance vanishes due to the spin valve effect .
as @xmath2 increases , however , the conductance rises and the spin valve effect is effectively destroyed by the presence of the rashba dot . for big enough values
the system behaves similarly to the case of parallel polarized leads ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) , displaying irregular oscillations around a mean value @xmath69 . for strong spin - orbit couplings and high number of modes
no clear distinction between parallel and antiparallel orientations is then to be expected .
this is a consequence of the strong subband mixing .
in fact , if @xmath42 is neglected ( red symbols ) there is a full correspondence between the conductance nodes of the parallel geometry with the maxima of the antiparallel one ; as could expected from the simplified rigid precession scenario .
the above results are not modified if other values of @xmath21 are used , provided they are large enough to ensure full polarization of the leads .
the same is true for distances @xmath22 .
they should be large enough to allow the decay of evanescent states at the interfaces with the rashba dot and at the points where stoner fields are switched on .
we consider next polarized leads along @xmath10 and @xmath50 ; that is , in directions that are perpendicular to the quantum wire . for @xmath50 polarizations the results are very similar to the @xmath0 ones already discussed and
thus will not be shown .
figures [ fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] contain the results for @xmath10-polarized parallel and antiparallel leads .
a first conspicuous difference with the results of figs.[fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] is that the grey symbols ( red color ) do not display wide sinusoidal oscillations .
the conductance when @xmath42 is neglected is actually maximal for the parallel case and stays rather constant with some small oscillations at large @xmath70 s that disappear when the number of channels increases . on the other hand , @xmath61 vanishes for the antiparallel orientation .
we understand this spin - valve behavior as a complete absence of spin precession , resulting from the fact that @xmath13 is spin diagonal in this approximation [ cf .
( [ eq10 ] ) ] . including @xmath42 in the @xmath10-polarized geometry again
yields qualitative modifications of the linear conductance ( black symbols in figs.[fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] ) . except for the antiparallel one - channel case
, @xmath61 shows staggering behavior at large @xmath2 s , quite similarly to the @xmath0-polarized results . on average , the conductance
is somewhat reduced from the maximal value in the parallel case ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) and , remarkably , takes a finite value in the antiparallel distribution ( fig .
[ fig5 ] ) . for @xmath71 the antiparallel conductance
has already reached a value close to @xmath72 and to the eventual saturation value .
the rashba coupling is thus quite effective in allowing transmission by flipping spins of the polarized incoming electrons towards the opposite spin orientation of the outgoing ones .
the single channel limit ( upper panel of fig .
[ fig5 ] ) is obviously an exception since even the black symbols vanish in this case .
this is easily understood noticing that the incident @xmath73 mode couples in the rashba dot with modes @xmath74 , but not with @xmath75 , which is the only propagating mode in the right lead .
therefore , no conduction is possible under this conditions .
experimentally , the absence of conductance oscillation in the parallel @xmath10-oriented configuration has been confirmed.@xcite our results reproduce that behavior ( fig . [ fig4 ] ) and they also suggest the antiparallel @xmath10 orientation ( fig .
[ fig5 ] ) as an interesting configuration for a spin - orbit - controlled device .
indeed , the initial rise of conductance in the multichannel case , interpreted above as a rashba - induced destruction of the spin valve , could be used as the conducting ( on ) state of the device .
one should check , however , that the evolution of @xmath76 from zero to the higher values remains smooth for increasing numbers of propagating channels .
the present results do not elucidate this point but they seem to indicate that for @xmath77 propagating modes the initial rise of @xmath76 occurs more rapidly than for @xmath78 . in a future work we shall treat the continuum case , having an infinite number of transverse states , using a different approach from the present one .
the results shown above are not much modified if the interfaces with the stoner fields at distaces @xmath79 and @xmath80 to the left and right of the rashba dot , respectively ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) , are smoothed by increasing the corresponding fermi - function parameter.@xcite this confirms that the conductance modifications are an effect of the rashba dot , and not of the stoner field interfaces .
indeed , the more diffuse the interface , the more reflectionless and thus more ideal is the description of the contact . in the next section
we shall discuss the case of nonpolarized leads ( @xmath81 ) , but we have also calculated some cases of partial polarization by decreasing @xmath3 when both @xmath82 and @xmath83 transverse states are active , although their number is not perfectly balanced .
we have found that the conductance is qualitatively similar to the fully polarized case , with irregular behaviour at large values of @xmath2 .
it has been recently pointed out@xcite that a rashba dot can act as a current polarizer in such a way that when a non polarized current enters the dot from the left , the transmitted current to the right may attain an important degree of spin polarization in @xmath10 direction . for this to occur
, it has been shown that at least two propagating modes of opposite spin must interfere.@xcite in wires with parabolic transverse confinement this means that the energy should at least exceed @xmath84 such that the four modes @xmath85 are active and the interference occurs in subsets @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
the resulting spin polarization is very sensitive to the energy ( see fig . 3 of ref . ) and a large enhancement of the polarization @xmath58 , eq .
( [ eqp ] ) is obtained when the energy is such that a fano - type resonance with a quasibound state from a higher evanescent band is formed .
this type of resonances which lead to the fano - rashba effect was investigated in ref . .
the polarization of the transmitted current is zero if , instead of @xmath10 , other direction for the quantization axis are chosen .
the preference for the transverse @xmath10 direction in polarization is an example of _ chirality _ induced by the rashba interaction .
this is possible even with a time - reversal invariant hamiltonian like eq .
( [ eqr ] ) because our boundary condition ( left incidence ) is not time reversal invariant .
indeed , if we consider the time reversed boundary condition , i.e. , incidence from the right , the current transmitted to the left is polarized in the opposite direction .
the superposition of both solutions completely restores the symmetry without any preferred spin direction .
the reversal of the polarization for the right - to - left transmission can be seen as a peculiar behavior of rashba polarizers that makes them _ fragile _ in the presence of magnetic barriers like those of sec .
indeed , one could naively think that when the rashba dot acts as a current polarizer the left - to - right transmission with @xmath10-magnetized leads should be very high in parallel configuration and very low in antiparallel configuration .
this is not the case , however , because of multiple backwards and forwards reflections with their associated inversions of @xmath58 ( see lower panels of figs .
[ fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] ) . in this section
we assume nonmagnetic leads by taking @xmath88 , i.e. , vanishing stoner fields in fig .
[ fig1 ] , and analyze the evolution of the polarization and the conductance when the number of active channels increases . as shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] upper panel , high polarizations @xmath58 are obtained for the minimal number of channels @xmath89 and strong spin - orbit intensities @xmath2 .
the clear correlation between @xmath61 and @xmath58 , conductance minima correspond to maxima in polarization , indicate that this is an effect connected with the formation of quasibound states that tend to block the current for a given spin direction . when the number of channels is increased ( lower panels of fig .
[ fig6 ] ) both @xmath61 and @xmath58 show reduced staggering oscillations with increasing @xmath70 , as in figs .
[ fig2]-[fig5 ] .
there is also an overall tendency to smoothly reduce @xmath61 and increase @xmath58 in a linear way with @xmath70 . with increasing number of channels the slopes of these straight lines
are reduced and for @xmath90 the polarization reaches the values @xmath91 and @xmath92 for 10 and 20 propagating channels , respectively . in almost all cases the polarization is positive , indicating that the transmitted current is preferentially polarized along @xmath93 . in this subsection
we discuss how the results are affected by the way in which the rashba field is switched on spatially .
for this , we vary the parameter @xmath25 in the fermi functions describing the transitions shown in fig .
[ fig1].@xcite for large values of @xmath25 the edges are quite smooth and correspond to an _
adiabatic _ turn - on or turn - of in space . on the contrary ,
abrupt changes are given by the limit @xmath94 .
our method is based on a grid discretization of the variable @xmath0 and its only requirement is that the grid should be fine enough to describe the spatial variations .
the results discussed above have been obtained using @xmath95 , a rather small value describing abrupt transitions in space .
we have checked that either using a smaller value @xmath96 or a larger value @xmath97 the behaviors of the conductance in the presence of polarized leads discussed in sec .
ii , namely the staggering for high values of @xmath2 and the modification due to intersubband coupling , are not qualitatively changed .
of course , it should be fulfilled that the rashba dot length @xmath1 is much greater than @xmath25 in order to still allow the transition to reach to the saturation value @xmath2 .
more delicate is the polarization @xmath58 discussed in the preceding subsection and fig [ fig6 ] . in fig [ fig7 ] we show the evolution with @xmath25 of @xmath61 and @xmath58 when @xmath78 channels are propagating in the wire .
the polarization vanishes when @xmath25 increases , indicating that smooth edges do not favor the appearance of polarized currents . in this diffuse - edge limit
the conductance takes the maximal value @xmath98 as in a purely ballistic wire without any rashba dot .
the evolution for @xmath99 ( upper panel ) is quite smooth but for @xmath100 ( lower panel ) superimposed to the overall behavior we find irregular maxima and minima as in previous results .
recent experiments have proved the feasibility of the spin transistor proposed by datta and das some years ago.@xcite this device , usually presented as a paradigm of spintronics , is expected to open new ways to overcome present limitations of electronics . in this paper
we have discussed some specific aspects related to the rashba interaction , including the so - called intersubband coupling , relevant for a better understanding of the physical mechanisms behind the spin transistors and spin polarizers .
taking the wire containing the rashba dot oriented along @xmath0 we have analyzed the transmission in the presence of polarized leads along @xmath0 , @xmath10 or @xmath50 , and with increasing number of propagating channels .
the cases of parallel and antiparallel polarized leads along @xmath0 and @xmath10 have been explicitly shown .
the evolution with rashba intensity shows dramatic modifications when the rashba intersubband coupling is included .
these modifications are specially relevant at strong values of @xmath2 , where staggering oscillations of @xmath61 have been found . in general ,
only a first smooth oscillation of @xmath76 remains when the full rashba interaction is considered , while successive ones are heavily distorted or even fully washed out .
the spin - valve behavior is effectively destroyed by the rashba dot and the conductance for both parallel and antiparallel leads is relatively high .
the role of rashba dots as spin polarizers has been discussed and explicitly calculated assuming the leads to be nonpolarized .
a smooth linear increase in @xmath58 with rashba intensity has been observed in the multichannel case . in the limit of adiabatic transitions the polarization vanishes .
these overall smooth behaviors are superimposed by irregular changes for high values of @xmath2 .
useful discussions with m .- s .
choi are gratefully acknowledged .
this work was supported by the micinn ( spain ) grant fis2008 - 00781 .
this appendix gives some details of the practical method to solve eq .
( [ ccm ] ) and the corresponding boundary conditions .
we use a method based on the quantum transmitting boundary algorithm.@xcite a fictitious partitioning of the system in central and asymptotic regions ( contacts ) is introduced .
the boundaries for the left and right contacts are at @xmath101 and @xmath102 , respectively . in the contacts the band amplitudes
take the form @xmath103 where @xmath104 is a label referring to left @xmath105 and right @xmath106 contacts , respectively , and we defined @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
the incident and reflected amplitudes for a given mode @xmath52 and contact @xmath109 are given by @xmath110 and @xmath111 , respectively .
this expression is for a propagating channel in contact @xmath109 , for which @xmath112 and its corresponding wavenumber @xmath113 is a real number .
equation ( [ eccm1 ] ) also applies to evanescent modes , @xmath114 , if we assume in this case @xmath115 and a purely imaginary wavenumber @xmath116 notice that the output amplitudes can be obtained from the wave function right at the interface , @xmath117 substituting eq .
( [ eqbcn ] ) in eq .
( [ eccm1 ] ) we obtain @xmath118 that is the quantum - transmitting - boundary equation for the contacts .
equations ( [ ccm ] ) and ( [ eccm2 ] ) , for the central and contact regions , respectively , form a closed set that does not invoke the wave function at any external point .
of course , this is not true for any of these two subsets separately , since central and contact regions are connected through the derivative in eq .
( [ ccm ] ) and of @xmath119 in eq .
( [ eccm2 ] ) . in practice
, we use a uniform grid in @xmath0 with @xmath49-point formulae for the derivatives ( @xmath120 ) and truncate the expansion in transverse bands , eq .
( [ exp ] ) , to include typically 30 - 60 terms .
the resulting sparse linear problem is then solved using routine ` me48`.@xcite 90 m. n. baibich , j. m. broto , a. fert , f. nguyen van dau , f. petroff , p. eitenne , g. greuzet , a. firederich , j. chazelas , phys .
* 61 * , 2472 ( 1988 ) .
g. binasch , p. grnberg , f. saurenbach , w. zinn , phys .
b * 39 * , 4828 ( 1989 ) .
j. fabian , a. matos - abiague , c. ertler , p. stano , and i. zutic , acta physica slovaca * 57 * , 565 ( 2007 ) .
e. i. rashba , fiz .
tverd , tela ( leningrad ) * 2 * , 1224 ( 1960 ) .
phys . solid state * 2 * , 1109 ( 1960 ) ] j. nitta , t. akazaki , h. takayanagi , and t. enoki , phys .
lett . * 78 * , 1335 ( 1997 ) .
s. datta and b. das , appl phys .
lett . * 56 * , 665 ( 1990 ) .
g. schmidt , d. ferrand , l. w. molenkamp , a. t. filip and b. j. van wees , phys .
b * 62 * , r4790 ( 2000 ) .
j. schliemann , j. c. egues , and d. loss , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 146801 ( 2003 ) .
h. c. koo , j. h. kwon , j. eom , j. chang , s. h. han , and m. johnson , science * 325 * , 1515 ( 2009 ) . a. n. m. zainuddin , s. hong , l. siddiqui , and s. datta , arxiv:1001.1523 ( unpublished , 2010 ) .
p. agnihotri and s. bandyopadhyay , arxiv:1001.2705 ( unpublished , 2010 ) .
i.a . shelykh and n.g .
galkin , phys .
b * 70 * , 205328 ( 2004 ) .
l. zhang , p. brusheim , and h.q .
xu , phys .
b * 72 * , 045347 ( 2005 ) .
d. snchez and ll .
serra , phys .
b * 74 * , 153313 ( 2006 ) .
r. lpez , d. snchez and ll .
serra , phys .
b * 76 * , 035307 ( 2007 ) .
u. fano , phys . rev . * 124 * , 1866 ( 1961 ) .
serra , d. snchez , and r. lopez , phys .
b * 72 * , 235309 ( 2005 ) .
v. pershin , j. a. nesteroff , and v. privman , phys .
b * 69 * , 121306(r ) ( 2004 ) .
d. snchez , ll .
serra , and m .- s .
choi , phys .
b * 77 * , 035315 ( 2008 ) .
a. a. kiselev and k. w. kim , appl .
78 , 775 ( 2001 ) .
m. governale , d. boese , u. zlicke , and c. schroll , phys .
b 65 , 140403(r ) ( 2002 ) .
r. ionicioiu and i. damico , phys . rev .
b 67 , 041307(r ) ( 2003 ) .
g. usaj and c. a. balseiro , phys . rev .
b 70 , 041301(r ) ( 2004 ) .
a. o. govorov , a. v. kalameitsev , and j. p. dulka , phys . rev .
b 70 , 245310 ( 2004 ) .
m. khodas , a. shekhter , and a. m. finkelstein , phys .
92 , 086602 ( 2004 ) .
m. yamamoto , t. ohtsuki , and b. kramer , phys .
b * 72 * , 115321 ( 2005 ) .
m. eto , t. hayashi , and y. kurotani , j. phys .
. jpn . * 74 * , 1934 ( 2005 ) .
ohe , m. yamamoto , t. ohtsuki , and j. nitta , phys .
b * 72 * , 041308(r ) ( 2005 ) .
g. silvestrov and e.g. mischenko , phys .
b * 74 * 165301 ( 2006 ) .
cummings , r. akis , and d.k .
ferry , appl .
phys . lett . *
89 * , 172115 ( 2006 ) .
f. zhai and h.q .
xu , phys .
b * 76 * , 035306 ( 2007 ) . c.a .
perroni , d. bercioux , v.m .
ramaglia , v. cataudella , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 19 * , 186227 ( 2007 ) .
f . liu , z .- c .
zhong , l. chen , d. p. li , c. zhang , and z. s. ma , phys . rev .
b * 76 * , 195304 ( 2007 ) .
f . l and y. guo , phys .
b * 76 * , 045120 ( 2007 ) ; appl . phys
* 91 * , 092128 ( 2007 ) .
m. scheid , a. pfund , d. bercioux , and k. richter , phys .
b * 76 * 195303 ( 2007 ) .
apel , p.a .
orellana , and m. pacheco , nanotechnology * 19 * , 355202 ( 2008 ) .
a. aharony , o. entin - wohlman , y. tokura , and s. katsumoto , phys .
b * 78 * , 125328 ( 2008 ) .
f. zhai , k. chang , and h.q .
xu , appl .
. lett . * 92 * , 102111 ( 2008 ) .
p. debray , j. wan , s. m. s. rahman , r. s. newrock , m. cahay , a. t. ngo , s. e. ulloa , s. t. herbert , m. muhammad , and m. johnson , nature nanotechnology * 4 * , 759 ( 2009 ) .
gelabert , d. snchez , r. lpez , and ll .
serra , phys .
status solidi c * 6 * , 2123 ( 2009 ) .
o. entin - wohlman , a. aharony , y. tokura , y. avishai , preprint ( arxiv:0911.1347 ) .
e. n. bulgakov and a. f. sadreev , phys .
b * 66 * , 075331 ( 2002 ) .
f. zhai and h.q .
xu , phys .
94 * , 246601 ( 2005 ) .
a.a . kiselev and k.w .
kim , phys .
b * 71 * , 153315 ( 2005 ) .
a. auerbach , _ interacting electrons and quantum magnetism _ , springer - verlag , new york , 1994 .
the inhomogeneous rahba intensity is given by @xmath121 $ ] where the fermi functions are @xmath122^{-1}$ ] and @xmath25 is a parameter modeling the diffusivity of the interface .
similar expressions for the gate potential @xmath8 and stoner field @xmath20 are used .
c.s . lent and d.j .
kirkner , j. appl . phys . * 67 * , 6353 ( 1990 ) . ll . serra and d. snchez ,
_ quantum - transmitting - boundary algorithm with local spin - orbit coupling _ , in _ progress in industrial mathematics 2006 _
bonilla , m. moscoso , g. platero and j.m .
vega , eds . ) , p. 449 , springer , berlin , 2008 .
hsl , a collection of fortran codes for large - scale scientific computation .
see http://www.hsl.rl.ac.uk , ( 2007 ) | we investigate intersubband mixing effects in multichannel quantum wires in the presence of rashba spin - orbit coupling and attached to two terminals .
when the contacts are ferromagnetic and their magnetization direction is perpendicular to the rashba field , the spin - transistor current is expected to depend in a oscillatory way on the rashba coupling strength due to spin coherent oscillations of the travelling electrons .
nevertheless , we find that the presence of many propagating modes strongly influences the spin precession effect , leading to ( i ) a quenching of the oscillations and ( ii ) strongly irregular curves for high values of the rashba coupling .
we also observe that in the case of leads magnetization parallel to the rashba field , the conductance departs from a uniform value as the rashba strength increases .
we also discuss the rashba interaction induced current polarization effects when the contacts are not magnetic and investigate how this mechanism is affected by the presence of several propagating channels . |
in spite of the growing recognition that physics skills
`` scholastic rigor , analytical thinking , quantitative assessment , and the analysis of complex systems '' @xcite are important for biology @xcite and pre - medical @xcite students , these students often arrive in physics classes skeptical about the relevance of physics to their academic and professional goals . to engage these students , in the 2010 - 2011 academic year ,
the yale physics department debuted a new introductory physics sequence , that , in addition to covering the basics
kinematics , force , energy , momentum , hooke s law , ohm s law , maxwell s equations _ etc . _
also covers a number of more biologically - relevant topics , including , in particular , probability , random walks , and the boltzmann factor .
the point of view of the class is that the essential aspect of physics is that it constitutes a mathematical description of the natural world , irrespective of whether the topic is planetary motion or cellular motion .
the enrollment in the new sequence was approximately 100 students .
the class is evenly split between sophomores and juniors with a few seniors .
the majority ( 80% ) are biology majors , with 80% identifying themselves as premedical students , and they possess considerable biological sophistication . in many cases ,
they are involved in biomedical research at yale or at the yale school of medicine . in many cases too , they are involved in medically - related volunteer work .
the major time commitment required to do justice to a rigorous physics class has to compete with these other obligations .
therefore , an important aspect of our teaching strategy is to convince these students that physics is indeed relevant to their goals . to this end
, we determined to cover a number of biologically - relevant topics , with which the majority of the students would have some familiarity from their earlier biology and chemistry classes .
this paper presents three such topics , that are interrelated and can be treated as random walks , in the hope that these may be useful to others .
first is dna melting @xcite , which we place in the context of polymerase chain reaction ( pcr ) .
this provides a way to illustrate the role of the boltzmann factor in a venue well - known to the students .
this treatment builds on earlier sections of the course , concerned with random walks and chemical reaction rates , which are not described here .
the second topic is the activity of helicase motor proteins in unzipping double - stranded nucleic acid ( dna or rna , although we will write in terms of dna ) .
our discussion is based on ref . .
helicase activity constitutes an elegant example of a brownian ratchet and builds on the earlier discussion of dna melting .
third , we present a discussion of force generation by actin polymerization , which provides the physical basis of cell motility in many cases , and which is another brownian ratchet . in this case , based on ref . , we can determine how the velocity of actin polymerization depends on actin concentration and on load .
in each of these examples , biology and pre - medical students in an introductory physics class see that a physics - based approach permits a new , deeper understanding of a familiar molecular - biological phenomenon .
`` the laws of thermodynamics may easily be obtained from the principles of statistical mechanics , of which they are an incomplete expression . ''
gibbs @xcite . instead of introducing thermal phenomena via thermodynamics and heat engines ,
as might occur in a traditional introductory sequence , following the suggestion of garcia _ et al . _
@xcite , we chose to assert the boltzmann factor as the fundamental axiom of thermal physics .
building upon earlier sections of the course on probability and random walks , this approach permits us to rapidly progress to physics - based treatments of dna melting , unzipping of double - stranded dna at the replication fork by helicase motor proteins , and force - generation by actin - polymerization . specifically , we assert that , for microstates @xmath0 and @xmath1 of a system , the probability ( @xmath2 ) of realizing a microstate @xmath0 and the probability ( @xmath3 ) of realizing a microstate @xmath1 are related via @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the energy of microstate @xmath0 , @xmath6 is the energy of microstate @xmath1 , @xmath7 jk@xmath8 is boltzmann s constant , and @xmath9 is the absolute temperature . `` this fundamental law is the summit of statistical mechanics , and the entire subject is either the slide - down from this summit , as the principle is applied to various cases , or the climb up to where the fundamental law is derived and the concepts of thermal equilibrium and temperature clarified .
'' r. p. feynman on the boltzmann factor @xcite . to illustrate the boltzmann factor in a simple example , we consider protein folding / unfolding .
protein / unfolding is an example of an isomerization reaction , in which one chemical species alternates between different molecular configurations . in this case , it is important to realize that the folded state corresponds to a single microstate , but that the unfolded state corresponds to @xmath10 microstates .
this is because there is just one molecular configuration associated with the folded state .
by contrast , the unfolded state can be viewed as a random walk in space , and therefore corresponds to @xmath10 different molecular configurations , one for each different random walk .
if there are a total of @xmath11 proteins , @xmath12 of which are unfolded , and if there are @xmath10 possible unfolded microstates , then the probability of realizing a particular unfolded microstate ( @xmath13 ) is equal to the probability that a protein molecule is unfolded multipled by the probability that an unfolded protein is in the particular unfolded microstate of interest , which is one of @xmath10 equally - likely microstates : @xmath14 there is a unique folded microstate , so in terms of @xmath11 and the number of folded proteins , @xmath15 , the probability of realizing the folded microstate is simply @xmath16 combining eq . [ bf ] , eq .
[ eq2 ] , and eq . [ eq3 ] , we find @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the energy of any of the unfolded states and @xmath19 is the energy of the folded state .
next , we examine dna melting , according to the model of ref . , in which dna melting is equivalent to dna unzipping .
we treat dna zipping and unzipping as a set of isomerization reactions . to this end , we consider a population of identical dna strands each of which contains a junction between dsdna and ssdna .
[ fig1 ] illustrates the reactions involving the dna strand with @xmath0 paired base pairs .
this is the chemical species in the center .
the species on the left and right are dna strands with @xmath20 and @xmath21 paired base pairs , respectively .
the relevant reaction rates are @xmath22 , which is the zipping rate , and @xmath23 , which is the unzipping rate .
when @xmath24 , the dna zips up .
when @xmath25 , the dna unzips . as suggested in fig .
[ fig1 ] , @xmath26 is the mean number of dna strands with @xmath0 paired base pairs , _ etc .
_ zipped base pairs are illustrated , either undergoing isomerization to a dna strand with @xmath27 base pairs or isomerization to a dna strand with @xmath28 base pairs.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] we have previously discussed in class that how the concentration of chemical species changes in time can be described by chemical rate equations . with the help of fig .
[ fig1 ] , we are thus lead to an equation for the rate of change of @xmath26 in terms of @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath26 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 : @xmath31 at equilibrium , at a temperature @xmath9 , on - average nothing changes as a function of time , so @xmath32 .
thus , @xmath33 the factor @xmath34 , which is the ratio of the mean number of dna strands with @xmath21 zipped base pairs to the mean number with @xmath0 zipped base pairs , is equal to the ratio of the probability that a particular dna strand has @xmath21 zipped base pairs to the probability that it has @xmath0 zipped base pairs .
thus , this factor is given by a boltzmann factor ( _ cf . _ eq .
[ xxx ] ) : @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the energy required to unzip one additional base pair ( so @xmath36 is positive ) and @xmath10 specifies that the two unzipped ssdna bases have a factor @xmath10 times as many microstates as the single dsdna base pair they replace .
the last equality in eq .
[ zip1 ] defines the free energy required to unzip one base pair : @xmath37 students are familar with @xmath38 from their chemistry classes .
similarly , we have @xmath39 substituting eq . [ zip1 ] and eq . [ zip2 ] into eq . [ steadystate2 ] , we have @xmath40 it follows from eq . [ steadystate3 ]
that @xmath41 eq . [ dg ] informs us that the dna unzips ,
_ i.e. _ @xmath42 , only if @xmath43 , _
i.e. _ only if @xmath44 .
in order for this condition ( @xmath44 ) to be satisfied , it is necessary that @xmath45 .
if we define the dna `` melting temperature '' to be @xmath46 , we see that the dna unzips for @xmath47 , while it zips up for @xmath48 .
this phenomenon is an essential ingredient in dna multiplication by polymerase chain reaction ( pcr ) , which is well - known to the students , and for which kary mullis won the 1993 nobel prize in chemistry @xcite .
the first step in pcr is to raise the temperature above @xmath49 , so that each dsdna strand unzips to become two ssdna strands .
when the temperature is subsequently reduced in the presence of oligonucleotide primers , nucleotides and dna polymerase , each previously - unzipped , ssdna strand templates its own conversion to dsdna .
this doubles the original number of dsdna strands because a new dsdna strand is created for each ssdna .
pcr involves repeating this temperature cycling process multiple ( @xmath50 ) times , with the result that the initial number of dsdna molecules is multiplied by a factor of @xmath51 .
thus , initially tiny quantities of dsdna can be hugely amplified , and subsequently sequenced .
it is also instructive to view dna zipping / unzipping as a biased random walk , which students have previously studied in the class . in this context , if we consider a dsdna - ssdna junction , the probability of zipping up one base pair in a time @xmath52 is @xmath53 , and the probability of unzipping one base pair in a time @xmath52 is @xmath54 . for small enough @xmath52 it is reasonable to assume that the only three possibilities are ( 1 ) to zip up one base pair or ( 2 ) to unzip one base pair or ( 3 ) to not do anything
therefore , since probabilities sum to unity , we must have that the probability to do nothing is @xmath55 .
given these probabilities , and the length of a base pair , @xmath56 , we may readily calculate the mean displacement of the ssdna - dsdna junction in a time @xmath52 : @xmath57 where zipping corresponds to a negative displacement of the ss - to - ds junction since the mean of the sum of @xmath11 identically - distributed , statistically - independent random variables is @xmath11 times the mean of one of them ( which students learned earlier in the course ) , then in a time @xmath58 the mean displacement of the ssdna - dsdna junction is @xmath59 the corresponding drift velocity of the ssdna - dsdna junction is @xmath60 this is the drift velocity of a dsdna - ssdna junction in terms of the zipping up rate ( @xmath22 ) and the unzipping rate ( @xmath23 ) , or the zipping rate ( @xmath22 ) and the unzipping free energy ( @xmath38 ) .
we will come back to this result below , but we note now that eq .
[ vj ] is appropriate only when the junction is far from a helicase . as defined in eq .
[ eq4 ] , @xmath38 is the change in free energy that occurs when one additional base pair is unzipped .
thus , as far as this expression for @xmath38 is concerned , the final , `` product '' state is the unzipped state , and the initial , `` reactant '' state is the zipped state .
thus , unzipping corresponds to the forward direction of the reaction .
we may make contact with what students have learned in chemistry classes , namely that a reaction proceeds forward if @xmath38 is negative , by pointing out that eq .
[ vj ] informs us that the unzipping reaction proceeds forwards ( _ i.e. _ that @xmath61 ) only for @xmath43 , exactly as we are told in chemistry classes . here
, though , this result is derived from a more basic principle , namely the boltzmann factor .
helicases @xcite are a class of motor proteins ( a.k.a . molecular motors ) , which perform myriad tasks in the cell by catalyzing atp - to - adp hydrolysis and using the free energy released in this reaction to do work .
the importance of helicases may be judged from the fact that 4% of the yeast genome codes for some kind of helicase .
one of their roles is to unzip dsdna and/or dsrna .
thus , helicases play an indispensible role in dna replication , for example . to engage students in this topic , we start by showing a number of online movies illustrating the dna - unzipping activity of helicase motor proteins at the replication fork @xcite
. these movies also present an opportunity for active learning in which we ask students to discuss with their neighbors what is misleading about the videos .
the essential point is that , wonderful as they are , the videos suggest that everything proceeds deterministically .
by contrast , as we will discuss , all of the processes depicted are actually random walks , but with a drift velocity that corresponds to their progress .
we also point out that , on the medical side , werner syndrome , which involves accelerated aging , is caused by a mutation in the _ wrn _ gene which codes for the helicase wrn @xcite .
one proposed mechanism for how helicase unzips dna is as follows .
the helicase steps unimpeded on ssdna towards a ss - to - ds junction , until it encounters the junction , which then blocks its further progress , because the helicase translocates only on ssdna . however , at the junction , there is a non - zero probability per unit time for the junction to thermally unzip one base pair , because of the boltzmann factor .
it is then possible for the helicase to step into the just - unzipped position .
if the helicase does this , the dna is prevented from subsequently zipping back up again . in this way ,
the junction is unzipped one step .
repeating this process many times leads to the complete unzipping of the dna . because this mechanism relies on random brownian motions to both unzip the dna and to move the helicase into the just - unzipped position ,
the helicase is said to be a brownian ratchet @xcite , analogous to feynman s thermal ratchet @xcite . just as the motion of the ss - to - ds junction may be conceived as a random walk , so may be the translocation of the helicase on ssdna . in this case , the probability of the helicase stepping one base pair towards the junction ( @xmath62 ) in a time @xmath52 is @xmath63 , and the probability stepping one base pair away from the junction ( @xmath64 ) in a time @xmath52 is @xmath65 , where @xmath66 and @xmath67 are the rate of stepping towards the junction and the rate of stepping away from the junction , respectively . since probabilities sum to unity , and we assume that the only three possibilities in a small time @xmath52 are to step towards the junction one base pair or to step away from the junction one base pair or to not do anything , we must have that the probability to do nothing is @xmath68 . given these probabilities , and the length of a base pair , @xmath56
, we may calculate the mean displacement of the helicase in a time @xmath52 : @xmath69 since the mean of the sum of @xmath11 identically - distributed , statistically - independent random variables is @xmath11 times the mean of one of them , then in a time @xmath58 the mean displacement of the helicase is @xmath70 the corresponding drift velocity of the helicase is @xmath71 this is the drift velocity of a helicase in terms of the stepping - towards - the - junction rate ( @xmath66 ) and the stepping - away - from - the - junction rate ( @xmath67 ) .
just like eq
. [ vj ] , eq .
[ vh ] is appropriate only when the helicase is far from the junction .
-direction to increase towards the right , so that @xmath22 and @xmath67 correspond to motion in the negative @xmath72-direction , and @xmath23 and @xmath66 correspond to motion in the positive @xmath72-direction.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] an important additional point , concerning helicase translocation on ssdna , is that , as we saw in eq .
[ dg ] , the ratio of forward and backward rates is given by a change in free energy .
thus , for helicase stepping we must expect , in analogy with eq .
[ dg ] , that the ratio of stepping rates is given by @xmath73 where @xmath74 is a free energy change .
but what free energy change ?
the answer can be gleaned from the observation that helicases , and motor proteins generally , can be thought of as enzymes , which catalyze atp - to - adp hydrolysis , which is coupled to the helicase s translocation .
it follows that @xmath74 in eq .
[ dgprime ] corresponds to the free energy difference between atp and adp .
( note that @xmath74 , as specified in eq .
[ dgprime ] , must be positive , in order to ensure that @xmath75 so that the helicase translocates on ssdna preferentially towards the ssdna - to - dsdna junction . )
so far , we have considered the situtation when the ds - to - ss junction and the helicase are far apart . to determine how helicase unzips dsdna , it is necessary to determine what happens when these two objects come into close proximity , given that they can not cross each other . to elucidate what happens in this case , we show to the class a simple mathematic demonstration that simulates these two non - crossing random walks @xcite .
the simulation treats both the location of the helicase and the location of the ds - to - ss junction as random walks . at each time step within the simulation ,
the helicase ordinarily steps in the positive @xmath72-direction , towards the junction , with probability @xmath63 and in the negative @xmath72-direction , away from the junction , with probability @xmath76 , while the junction ordinarily steps in the positive @xmath72-direction , zipping up one step , with probability @xmath53 and in the negative @xmath72-direction , unzipping one step , with probability @xmath54 .
however , in the simulation , if the helicase and the junction are neighbors , neither one is permitted to step to where it would overlap with the other .
thus , the helicase and the junction can not cross .
an example of the simulational results is shown in fig .
[ titans ] , where the orange trace represents helicase location as a function of time and the green trace represents the location of the ssdna - to - dsdna junction as a function of time . evidently , the helicase and the junction track together , implying that they have the same drift velocity . for the parameters of this simulation ,
the helicase translocates in the same direction as it would in the absence of the junction .
by contrast , the junction s direction is opposite its direction without the helicase . thus , for these parameters , the helicase indeed unzips dsdna . using sliders within the mathematica demonstration , which is readily accessed via any web browser
, students can explore for themselves the effects of varying @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 . and @xmath77 .
the green random walk represents the position of a ssdna - to - dsdna junction for @xmath78 and @xmath79 . in both cases , @xmath80 .
the blue line is eq .
the two random walks start at 0 in the case of the junction , and at -2 in the case of the helicase .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] to incorporate analytically the fact that the helicase and the junction can not cross , we introduce the probability , @xmath81 , that the helicase and the junction are not next to each other . the dsdna - to - ssdna junction can only zip up if the helicase and the junction are not next to each other .
therefore , we reason that eq . [ dxj ]
should be modified to read @xmath82 similarly , eq .
[ dxh ] should be modified to read @xmath83 it follows that the drift velocities are modified to read @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
however , from the simulation , it is also clear that , while the helicase is unzipping dna , the helicase and the junction must have the same drift velocity _ i.e. _ @xmath86 or @xmath87 we can solve this equation to determine @xmath81 : @xmath88 furthermore , we can use this expression for @xmath81 to determine the drift velocity at which the helicase unzips the dsdna by substituting into eq .
[ vh2 ] . setting @xmath89
, we find @xmath90 eq . [ vvv ] represents the velocity at which helicase unzips dsdna according to the brownian ratchet mechanism .
the numerator in eq .
[ vvv ] is the difference of two rate ratios .
it follows , using eq .
[ dg ] and eq .
[ dgprime ] in eq .
[ vvv ] , that @xmath91 eq .
[ vvvv ] informs us that whether or not helicase unzips dsdna depends solely on whether @xmath92 or not . for @xmath92 ,
the drift velocity of the helicase - plus - junction is positive , corresponding to the helicase unzipping the dsdna .
for one base pair , we have @xmath93 , while for the hydrolysis of one atp molecule , we have @xmath94 , so indeed the helicase has plenty of free energy to do its work .
in fact , energetically , one atp hydrolysis cycle could unzip up to about 5 base pairs .
in fact , beautiful , single - helicase experiments @xcite suggest that the simple brownian ratchet mechanism of helicase dna - unzipping activity , presented here , should be refined by incorporating both a softer repulsive potential between the helicase and the ds - to - ss junction than the hard - wall potential implicit in our discussion , and suitable free energy barriers between different microstates of the helicase and junction @xcite .
appropriate choices of the potential and the barriers permit the helicase to unzip dsdna faster than would occur in the case of a hard - wall potential . a force ( @xmath95 ) , that tends to unzip the dna ,
can be incorporated by replacing @xmath22 with @xmath96 and @xmath23 with @xmath97 .
the mechanism by which actin or tubulin polymerization exerts a force also a brownian ratchet @xcite and is schematically illustrated in fig . [ actin ] . in the case of a load , @xmath95 , applied to a cell membrane , the cell membrane is in turn pushed against the tip of an actin filament , which usually prevents the addition of an additional actin monomer ( g - actin ) of length @xmath98 to the tip of the actin filament ( f - actin ) .
however , with probability specified by a boltzmann factor , the membrane s position relative to the tip , @xmath99 , occasionally fluctuates far enough away from the filament tip ( @xmath100 ) to allow a monomer to fit into the gap .
if a monomer does indeed insert and add to the end of the filament , the result is that the filament and therefore the membrane move one step forward , doing work against the load force . repeating this many times for many such filaments gives rise to cell motility against viscous forces . in class
we also show movies showing cells moving as a result of actin polymerization @xcite , and _ listeria monocytogenes _ actin `` rockets '' @xcite . ) , applied to a membrane against which the polymerizing actin filament ( f - actin ) abuts . only if the gap , @xmath99 , between the tip of the actin filament and the membrane exceeds the length , @xmath98 , of a g - actin monomer is it possible for the filament to grow .
, scaledwidth=49.0% ] similarly to eq .
[ dxj ] and eq .
[ dxh ] , we can write down an expression for the mean displacement of the filament tip in a time @xmath52 in the absence of a nearby membrane : @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the concentration of g - actin , @xmath98 is the length of an actin monomer , @xmath66 is the actin on - rate , and @xmath67 is the actin off - rate .
however , if the membrane is nearby , it is only possible to add an actin monomer if the distance between the filament and the membrane is greater than @xmath98 .
assuming that the time - scale for membrane fluctuations is much faster than that for adding actin monomers , if the probability , that the membrane - filament tip distance is greater than @xmath98 , is @xmath81 , then eq . [ actinx ] is modified to read @xmath103 and the drift velocity of the tip is @xmath104 but application of the boltzmann factor informs us that , when the force on the membrane is @xmath95 , the probability that the gap is greater than @xmath98 is @xmath105 so that @xmath106 this is the force - velocity relationship for an actin @xcite or tubulin @xcite filament . although the load , @xmath95 , is applied to the membrane , the velocity is constant .
therefore , according to newton s third law , as the students know , there can be no net force on the membrane .
we may deduce that the load is balanced by an equal and oppposite force , generated by the polymerization ratchet .
three , interrelated biologically - relevant examples of biased random walks were presented .
first , we presented a model for dna melting , modelled as dna unzipping , which provides a way to illustrate the role of the boltzmann factor in a venue well - known to the students .
second , we discussed the activity of helicase motor proteins in unzipping double - stranded dna , for example , at the replication fork , which is an example of a brownian ratchet . finally , we treated force generation by actin polymerization , which is another brownian ratchet , and for which we can determine how the velocity of actin polymerization depends on actin concentration and on load . in each of these examples , building on an earlier coverage of biased random walks , biology and pre - medical students in an introductory physics sequence at yale were lead to the realization that a physics - based approach permits a deeper understanding of a familiar biological phenomenon . | three , interrelated biologically - relevant examples of biased random walks are presented : ( 1 ) a model for dna melting , modelled as dna unzipping , which provides a way to illustrate the role of the boltzmann factor in a venue well - known to biology and pre - medical students ; ( 2 ) the activity of helicase motor proteins in unzipping double - stranded dna , for example , at the replication fork , which is an example of a brownian ratchet ; ( 3 ) force generation by actin polymerization , which is another brownian ratchet , and for which the force and actin - concentration dependence of the velocity of actin polymerization is determined . a |
recently it has been widely recognized that orbital degree of freedom plays an essential role for the understanding of novel magnetism in transition metal oxides @xcite .
a typical material is manganese oxide , exhibiting remarkable colossal magneto - resistance phenomena @xcite . due to competition and interplay among spin , charge , and orbital degrees of freedom ,
rich phase diagram has been revealed @xcite , but a recent trend is to unveil further new phases both from experimental and theoretical investigations . in fact , even in undoped rmno@xmath2 ( r = rare earth lanthanide ions ) , a novel antiferromagnetic ( af ) phase called the `` e - type '' spin structure has been reported as the ground state for r = ho @xcite .
here we follow the definitions of spin structure in ref .
the origin of the e - af phase has been clarified theoretically @xcite based on a band - insulator scenario in the @xmath3-orbital systems @xcite . it should be noted that the ground state of undoped manganites was just considered to be well understood , since for most r - ions , the a - type af insulating phase appears with the c - type ordering of the @xmath4@xmath5@xmath6- and @xmath7@xmath5@xmath6-orbitals @xcite .
moreover , also for the half - doped manganite @xmath8 , a charge - ordered ferromagnetic ( fm ) phase has been found in experiments @xcite , as predicted theoretically @xcite .
these facts clearly indicate the importance of both experimental and theoretical efforts to unveil new phases in manganites in addition to the explanation of the complex phases already observed .
such efforts have also been made to find new phases in other transition metal oxides , for instance , ruthenates @xcite and nickelates @xcite . a trend to seek for new magnetic as well as
superconducting phases has been also found in the @xmath9-electron system , which is another type of spin - charge - orbital complex . among many kinds of @xmath9-electron materials , in recent years , @xmath9-electron compounds with hocoga@xmath0-type tetragonal crystal structure [ see fig .
1(a ) ] , frequently referred to as `` 115 '' , have been intensively investigated both in experimental and theoretical research fields of condensed matter physics .
such vigorous activities are certainly motivated by high superconducting transition temperature @xmath10 observed in some 115 compounds .
especially , amazingly high value of @xmath10=18.5k has been reported in pucoga@xmath0 @xcite and the mechanism has been discussed theoretically @xcite . among 115 compounds , interesting magnetic properties have been reported for utga@xmath0 , where t is a transition metal ion @xcite .
in particular , neutron scattering experiments have revealed that uniga@xmath0 exhibits the g - type af phase , while updga@xmath0 and uptga@xmath0 have the a - type af state @xcite . note that g - type indicates a three - dimensional nel state ,
while a - type denotes a layered af structure in which spins align ferromagnetically in the @xmath11 plane and af along the @xmath12 axis @xcite .
it is quite interesting that the magnetic structure is different for u-115 compounds which differ only by the substitution of transition metal ions . .
schematic views of magnetic structures composed of magnetic moments of np ions for ( b ) npfega@xmath0 , ( c ) npcoga@xmath0 , and ( d ) npniga@xmath0 . for npfega@xmath0 ,
magnetic moments at fe sites are also depicted . ] quite recently , 115 compounds including neptunium have been skillfully synthesized and several kinds of physical quantities have been successfully measured @xcite . especially , the de haas - van alphen ( dhva ) effect has been observed in npniga@xmath0 @xcite , which is the first observation of dhva signal in transuranium compounds . for npcoga@xmath0 ,
the dhva oscillations have been also detected and a couple of cylindrical fermi surfaces are found @xcite . for npfega@xmath0 , the magnetic moment at fe site has been suggested in neutron scattering experiments @xcite and it has been also detected by @xmath13fe mssbauer spectroscopy @xcite .
interestingly enough , the magnetic structure of np-115 compounds also depends sensitively on transition metal ion @xcite : c - af for npfega@xmath0 , a - af for npcoga@xmath0 , and g - af for npniga@xmath0 , as shown in figs .
1(b)-(d ) .
note that for npniga@xmath0 , the g - af structure is composed of canted np moments and the peak in the neutron scattering intensity grows @xmath14 the fm transition occurs @xcite . in any case , it is characteristic of u-115 and np-115 compounds that the magnetic properties are sensitive to the choice of transition metal ions .
the appearance of several kinds of af states reminds us of the magnetic phase diagram of manganites and thus , we envisage a scenario to understand the complex magnetic structure of actinide compounds based on an orbital degenerate model similar to that of manganites .
however , one must pay close attention to the meanings of `` spin '' and `` orbital '' in @xmath9-electron systems . since they are tightly coupled with each other through a strong spin - orbit interaction ,
distinguishing them is not straightforward in comparison with @xmath15-electron systems .
this point can create serious problems when we attempt to understand microscopic aspects of magnetism and superconductivity in @xmath9-electron compounds .
thus , it is necessary to carefully define the terms `` orbital '' and `` spin '' for @xmath9 electrons in a microscopic discussion of magnetism and superconductivity in actinide compounds . in order to overcome such problems ,
we have proposed to employ a @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme to discuss @xmath9-electron systems @xcite . here
we stress the advantages of the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme .
first , it is quite convenient for the inclusion of many - body effects using standard quantum - field theoretical techniques , since individual @xmath9-electron states are clearly defined .
in contrast , in the @xmath16 coupling scheme we can not use such standard techniques , since wick s theorem does not hold .
second we can , in principle , include the effects of valence fluctuations . in some uranium compounds ,
the valence of the uranium ion is neither definitely u@xmath17 nor u@xmath18 , indicating that the @xmath9-electron number takes a value between 2 and 3 . in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme
this is simply regarded as the average number of @xmath9 electron per uranium ion . in this paper , we attempt to explain the complex magnetic structure of np-115 based on the effective two - orbital model , which has been constructed from the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme in order to understand the magnetic properties of u-115 compounds @xcite .
we depict the fermi surfaces of the kinetic term of @xmath19 electron based on the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme in comparison with those obtained from the dhva experiments .
the agreement seems to be fairly well , but the present itinerant picture should be critically discussed .
then , we apply the exact diagonalization technique to the model in a small 2@xmath202@xmath202 cube to obtain a clue to understand the complex magnetic structure of nptga@xmath0 .
the phase diagrams are found to include g- , a- , and c - type af states , consistent with experimental observations in np-115 .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in sec . 2
, we will introduce an effective hamiltonian , called the @xmath21 model , for actinide 115 systems . in sec . 3
, we show the calculated results of the model hamiltonian .
the fermi - surface structure is discussed in comparison with dhva experimental results .
we show numerical results for the magnetic structure obtained by using exact diagonalization technique . finally , in sec .
4 , future developments are discussed and the paper is summarized . throughout the paper ,
we use units such that @xmath22=@xmath23=1 .
in this section , we show an effective model based on the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme for np-115 compounds , which is the same as the model for u-115 @xcite .
we emphasize that the model with orbital degree of freedom is applicable to actinide 115 materials in common . in order to construct a microscopic hamiltonian for @xmath9-electron systems ,
it is necessary to include simultaneously the itinerant nature of @xmath9 electrons as well as strong electron correlation and the effect of crystalline electric field ( cef ) . for the purpose ,
we have proposed to use the so - called @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme @xcite . as shown in fig . 2 , we include the spin - orbit coupling so as to define the state labeled by the total angular momentum . for @xmath9 orbitals with @xmath24=3
, we immediately obtain an octet with @xmath1=7/2(=3 + 1/2 ) and a sextet with @xmath1=5/2(=3@xmath51/2 ) , which are well separated by the spin - orbit interaction .
in general , the spin - orbital coupling is as large as 1ev in actinide elements and thus , in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme , we consider only the @xmath1=5/2 sextet . in actual compounds , due to the electrostatic potential from ligand ions surrounding the actinide ion ,
the six - fold degeneracy of @xmath1=5/2 is lifted , as shown in fig . 2 .
note that in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme , it is enough to define the one - electron potential , which is deduced from the cef level scheme of corresponding @xmath25-electron system .
first we consider the one @xmath9-electron state in the aucu@xmath2-type cubic crystal structure , since this is the mother structure of hocoga@xmath0-type tetragonal compound .
the effects of tetragonality will be discussed later . for the case of cubic symmetry
, we identify two eigen energies as @xmath26 for the @xmath27 doublet and @xmath28 for the @xmath21 quartet , where @xmath29 is a cubic cef parameter . for the following discussion
, it is quite convenient to introduce `` pseudospin '' to distinguish the degenerate states of the kramers doublet and `` orbital '' to label the different kramers doublets in @xmath21 quartet . in fig .
3(a ) , we show the shape of the wavefuction of two @xmath21 orbitals , @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
-electron state in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme .
the @xmath1=5/2 sextet is split into several kramers doublets due to cubic or tetragonal crystalline electric field effect.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] in order to proceed with the discussion , we need to know which is lower , @xmath27 or @xmath21 , in the one @xmath9-electron picture . for some crystal structures ,
it is possible to determine the level scheme from intuitive discussions on @xmath9-electron wavefunctions and the positions of ligand ions .
however , this is not the case for the aucu@xmath2-type crystal structure . for this case
we invoke certain experimental results on cein@xmath2 , a typical aucu@xmath2-type ce - based compound , where @xmath27 and @xmath21 have been reported as ground and excited states , respectively , with an energy difference of 12mev @xcite .
thus , we take @xmath27 to be lower for the present considerations , as shown in fig .
3(b ) . in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme for uga@xmath2 and npga@xmath2
, it is necessary to accommodate three or four electrons in the one - electron energy states @xmath27 and @xmath21 .
we immediately notice that there are two possibilities , i.e. , low- and high - spin states , depending on the hund s rule interaction and the splitting between the @xmath27 and @xmath21 levels . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , the effective hund s rule interaction becomes small in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme and thus , the low - spin state should be realized , as shown in figs .
3(c ) and ( d ) .
we emphasize that the low - spin state is consistent with the @xmath16 coupling scheme . in the electron configuration shown in figs .
3(c ) and ( d ) , the @xmath27 level is fully occupied to form a singlet .
if this @xmath27 level is located well below the @xmath21 , the occupying electrons will not contribute to the magnetic properties .
thus , we ignore the @xmath27 electrons in the following discussion . as for details to validate the suppression of @xmath27 level
, readers should refer ref .
we also mention another theoretical effort based on the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme , in which the dual nature , itinerant and localized , of @xmath19 electron has been emphasized @xcite . and
@xmath32 , in the @xmath21 model .
level scheme for ( b ) cein@xmath2 , ( c ) uga@xmath2 , and ( d ) npga@xmath2 based on the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme .
here we assume trivalent actinide ions as u@xmath17 ( @xmath33 ) and np@xmath17 ( @xmath34 ) .
it should be noted that up and down arrows denote pseudospins to distinguish the states in the kramers doublet .
note also that for npga@xmath2 , a couple of electrons in @xmath21 orbitals form a local triplet , leading to @xmath35.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] as shown in fig .
1(a ) , since 115 compounds have the tetragonal structure , we need to include the effect of tetragonality . in the tetragonal structure , the quartet @xmath21 is further split into two doublets , @xmath36 and @xmath27 , as shown in fig . 2 . namely , there appear three kramers doublets with one @xmath36 and two @xmath27 .
note that two @xmath27 states are obtained from the mixture of @xmath27 and @xmath30 in the cubic symmetry .
however , for simplicity , we ignore the change of wavefunctions from cubic to tetragonal systems , since we believe that the existence of orbital degree of freedom is a key issue to understand the complex magnetic structure of actinide compound . for the purpose to improve the present theory from the quantitative viewpoint
, it may be important to include also the deformation of local @xmath9-electron wavefunction , but we postpone such a study in the future . in this paper , we consider the splitting energy between @xmath21 orbitals , in order to take into account the tetragonality in the 115 compounds . after tedious calculations
, we obtain the hamiltonian including @xmath21 orbitals in the form of @xcite @xmath37 where @xmath38 denotes the kinetic term of @xmath19 electrons , @xmath39 is the cef potential term , and @xmath40 indicates the coulomb interaction term among @xmath21 electrons .
concerning the kinetic term , one traditional way is to consider the hybridization process between @xmath9 and conduction electrons . for 115 systems , from the band - structure calculations @xcite , @xmath41 electrons of ga ion play an important role to form conduction band .
however , based upon a picture that @xmath19 electrons are itinerant , we can consider another way to construct the kinetic term for @xmath9 electrons within a tight - binding approximation .
in actual compounds , there should occur several processes through other ligand ions , in addition to the direct process of @xmath9 electrons .
however , when we include correctly the local symmetry of relevant @xmath9 orbitals , it is believed that we can grasp qualitative point of kinetic term of @xmath9 electrons , even within the simple tight - binding approximation .
this point will be discussed elsewhere in future .
here we do not consider the hybridization process .
then , the kinetic term is given in the tight - binding approximation for @xmath9 electrons as @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the annihilation operator for an @xmath9 electron with pseudospin @xmath44 in the @xmath45-orbital at site @xmath46 and @xmath47 is the @xmath9-electron hopping matrix element between @xmath45- and @xmath48-orbitals along the @xmath49 direction .
indices @xmath50 and @xmath32 denote the @xmath51 and @xmath52 orbitals , respectively . in the @xmath53 plane and along the @xmath54-axis , @xmath47
is given by @xmath55 for the @xmath56-direction , @xmath57 for the @xmath58 direction , and @xmath59 for the @xmath60 direction .
note that @xmath61=(3/7)@xmath62 , where @xmath62 is a slater - koster overlap integral between @xmath9 orbitals through @xmath44 bond . in the following
, @xmath61 is taken as an energy unity .
remark that we introduce another hopping amplitude along the @xmath54-axis . in antga@xmath0 ( an = u and np ) , anga@xmath63 layer is sandwiched by two anga@xmath2 sheets , indicating that the hopping of @xmath9 electron along the @xmath54-axis should be reduced from that in anga@xmath2 .
however , it is difficult to estimate the reduction quantitatively , since it is necessary to include correctly the hybridization with @xmath15 electrons in transition metal ions and @xmath41 electrons in ga ions .
thus , in this paper , we consider the effective reduction by simply treating @xmath64 as a parameter . for a practical purpose
, we introduce a non - dimensional parameter @xmath65=@xmath66 .
we point out that the hopping amplitudes among @xmath21 orbitals are just the same as those for the @xmath3 orbitals of @xmath67 electrons @xcite .
readers can intuitively understand this point from the shapes of @xmath21 orbitals shown in fig .
3(a ) , which are similar to @xmath3 orbitals .
mathematically , this is quite natural , if we recall the fact that @xmath21 is isomorphic to @xmath68 , where @xmath69 indicates @xmath70 representation for the orbital part and @xmath36 denotes the spin part .
note , however , that the agreement between @xmath9- and @xmath15-electron hopping amplitudes is due to the choice of special axis directions .
if we take the ( 1,1,0 ) direction in an fcc lattice , @xmath9-electron hopping amplitude becomes complex , leading to the stabilization of octupole ordering in npo@xmath63 @xcite .
the cef term is given by @xmath71 where @xmath72= @xmath73 , @xmath74=@xmath75 , and @xmath76 is the level splitting , which expresses the effect of tetragonal cef , as discussed above .
we note that in actuality , @xmath76 should be related to the value of @xmath65 , since both quantities depend on the lattice constant along the @xmath54 axis .
however , the relation between @xmath65 and @xmath76 is out of the scope of this paper and thus , here we simply treat them as independent parameters .
the coulomb interaction term is expressed by @xmath77 where the coulomb interactions @xmath78 , @xmath79 , @xmath80 , and @xmath81 denote intra - orbital , inter - orbital , exchange , and pair - hopping interactions among @xmath21 electrons , respectively , expressed by using the racah parameters @xcite .
note that the relation @xmath78=@xmath79+@xmath80+@xmath81 holds , ensuring rotational invariance in pseudo - orbital space for the interaction part . for @xmath15-electron systems ,
one also has the relation @xmath80=@xmath81 .
when the electronic wavefunction is real , this relation is easily demonstrated from the definition of the coulomb integral .
however , in the @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme the wavefunction is complex , and @xmath80 is not equal to @xmath81 in general . for simplicity , we shall assume here that @xmath80=@xmath81 , noting that essential results are not affected .
since double occupancy of the same orbital is suppressed owing to the large value of @xmath78 , pair - hopping processes are irrelevant in the present case .
now let us show our calculated results based on the two - orbital model .
first we discuss the electronic properties of @xmath38 in the non - interacting limit by focusing on the fermi - surface structure , in order to gain an insight into the interpretation of dhva experiments on np-115 compounds .
next the magnetic properties are discussed .
we attempt to understand the appearance of three kinds of magnetic phases based on the orbital - based scenario similar to that of manganites . tight - binding model for ( a ) @xmath82=2 , @xmath65=1 , @xmath76=0 , ( b ) @xmath82=2 , @xmath65=0.1 , @xmath76=@xmath83 , ( c ) @xmath82=1.5 , @xmath65=1 , @xmath76=0 , and ( d ) @xmath82=1.5 , @xmath65=0.1 , @xmath76=@xmath83 .
the bounding box indicates the first brillouin zone for a simple cubic lattice .
the @xmath84 point is located at the center of the box , while the apices denote r points.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] let us consider the structure of fermi - surface sheets of the @xmath21 tight - binding model @xmath38 . in the following ,
we define @xmath82 as the number of @xmath9 electrons included in the @xmath21 state .
namely , the local @xmath9-electron number per actinide ion is @xmath82 + 2 , by adding @xmath27 electrons . as shown in fig .
3(d ) , in our picture , there are two @xmath21 electrons in trivalent neptunium ion .
then , it is quite natural to consider first the case of @xmath82=2 .
the results for ( @xmath65 , @xmath76)=(1,0 ) and ( 0.1,@xmath83 ) are shown in figs .
4(a ) and ( b ) , respectively . for the cubic case with @xmath65=1 and @xmath76=0 ,
there exist two kinds of cube - like fermi surfaces .
one is centered at @xmath84 point , while the center of another cube is r point . when we change @xmath65 and @xmath76 to consider the tetragonality , cubes gradually change to cylinders . as shown in fig .
4(b ) , we can clearly observe two kinds of cylindrical fermi surfaces .
note that the fermi - surface structure does not sensitively depend on the value of @xmath76 , as long as the absolute value is not so large as @[email protected] .
it is important to have quasi orbital degeneracy , to reproduce a couple of cylindrical fermi surfaces .
it is interesting to recall the dhva experiment on npcoga@xmath0 , which has revealed two kinds of cylindrical fermi surface @xcite . in the relativistic band - structure calculations for the paramagnetic phase
, it has been difficult to understand the appearance of a couple of cylindrical fermi surfaces @xcite .
note that the folding of the magnetic brillouin zone can not explain the discrepancy between the experimental results and the band - calculation ones for npcoga@xmath0 .
a direct way to understand the dhva experimental results is to improve the band - structure calculation method , but as shown in fig .
4(b ) , even in a simple tight - binding model for itinerant @xmath19 electrons , we obtain two kinds of cylindrical fermi surface due to the effect of @xmath21 orbital degree of freedom .
we do not claim that the dhva results can be understood only by the present simple calculations , but a hint to understand the electronic structure of np-115 is believed to be hidden in the construction of our model with @xmath21 orbital degree of freedom .
we point out that in actual np-115 compounds , the number of @xmath82 is not definitely determined . especially , due to the change of transition metal ion , the number of @xmath82 seems to be changed effectively .
in fact , in the relation between superconducting transition temperature @xmath10 and the ratio of lattice constants @xmath87 , the curve of @xmath10 vs. @xmath87 for solid solution ( u , np , pu)coga@xmath0 is similar to that for another solid solution pu(fe , co , ni)ga@xmath0 @xcite .
namely , in actinide 115 materials , the effect of the change of @xmath9-electron number due to the substitution of actinide ion seems to be similar to that of the substitution of transition metal ion .
thus , when we consider the change of the magnetic structure among nptga@xmath0 ( t = fe , co , and ni ) based on the effective two - orbital model , there is no strong reason to fix firmly @xmath82=2 . in figs .
4(c ) and ( d ) , we show the fermi - surface sheets for @xmath82=1.5 , in which the number of @xmath9 electrons is slightly decreased .
we can observe that the fermi - surface structure is not changed so much , although the cylinder centered at the @xmath84 point becomes slender .
thus , as long as we are based on the simple tight - binding model , it is concluded that the structure of the fermi - surface sheets is not changed sensitively by the number of @xmath82 around at @xmath82=2 .
this result suggests that it is possible to change the value of @xmath82 to consider the magnteic structure of np-115 compounds .
now we consider the magnetic properties of the @xmath21 model . among several methods to analyze the microscopic model , in this paper we resort to an exact diagonalization technique on a 2@xmath202@xmath202 lattice .
although there is a demerit that it is difficult to enlarge the system size , we take a clear advantage that it is possible to deduce the magnetic structure by including the effect of electron correlation . in order to discuss the ground - state properties , it is useful to measure the spin and orbital correlations , which are , respectively , defined by @xmath88 with @xmath89=@xmath90@xmath5@xmath91 , and @xmath92 with @xmath93=@xmath94@xmath5@xmath95 . here
@xmath96 is the number of sites .
= 2 , @xmath79=5 , and @xmath80=0 as a function of ( a ) @xmath76 for @xmath65=1 and of ( b ) @xmath65 for @xmath76=0.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] first let us consider the case of @xmath82=2 , which is corresponding to the trivalent np ion . in fig .
5(a ) , we show the spin correlation as a function of @xmath76 for @xmath79=5 , @xmath80=0 , and @xmath65=1 . at @xmath65=1 and @xmath76=0 ( cubic system ) , local triplet composed of a couple of @xmath9 electrons
is formed at each site and the g - type af structure is stabilized due to the so - called superexchange interaction . as easily observed , even when @xmath76 is introduced as the tetragonal cef effect ,
the g - af structure remains robust for @xmath97 .
when @xmath85 is larger than unity , two electrons simultaneously occupy the lower orbital , leading to the non - magnetic state composed of local @xmath98 , irrelevant to the present study to consider the magnetic phase . in fig .
5(b ) , the spin correlation is shown as a function of @xmath65 for @xmath76=0 . again
, the g - type af structure is stabilized , but we find that the spin correlation of @xmath99=@xmath100 comes to be equivalent to that of @xmath99=@xmath101 with the decrease of @xmath65 , since the af structure is stabilized in each @xmath53 plane due to superexchange interaction and the planes are decoupled for small @xmath65 . at the first glance
, it seems difficult to understand the variety of magnetic phases observed in nptga@xmath0 , when we consider only the trivalent np ion .
however , there is no _ a priori _ reason to fix the valence as np@xmath17 , as mentioned in the previous subsection . in nptga@xmath0
, @xmath15-electron band originating from transition metal ions may significantly affect the valence of np ion .
in addition , we also stress that the actual compounds exhibit af metallic behavior . in the band - structure calculation , the average number of @xmath9 electrons at np ion is easily decreased from four .
thus , we treat the local @xmath9-electron number as a parameter .
we may consider another reason to decrease effectively the number of @xmath9 electron from @xmath82=2 in npga@xmath2 . in the present two - orbital model ,
the g - af structure is robust , which is natural from the theoretical viewpoint within the model .
however , in the experimental result on npga@xmath2 , the low - temperature ground state is ferromagnetic , although the af phase has been observed around at @xmath102@xmath10360k @xcite .
in order to understand the occurrence of the fm phase in the two - orbital model , it is necessary to inject some amount of `` hole '' in the af phase , since the double - exchange mechanism works to maximize the kinetic motion of electrons , as will be discussed later in the main text . it is difficult to determine the amount of doped holes to obtain the fm phase , but at least qualitatively , the effective decrease of @xmath82 seems to be physically meaningful in npga@xmath2 as well as in nptga@xmath0 .
now we consider the case of @xmath82=1.5 .
as discussed in the previous subsection , the fermi - surface structure does not change so much from that of the case of @xmath82=2 , when @xmath85 is not so large . in fig .
6(a ) , we show the ground - state phase diagram in the @xmath104 plane at @xmath82=1.5 for the cubic case with @xmath65=1 and @xmath76=0 . at @xmath80=0 , a g - type af structure
is stabilized due to superexchange interaction in the same way as the case of @xmath82=2 .
however , the g - af structure is immediately changed to a c - af structure only by a small value of the hund s rule interaction . with increasing @xmath80 , the magnetic phase changes in the order of g - af , c - af , a - af , and fm phases , except for the c - af phase in the large @xmath80 region .
the spin structure of each phase is shown in fig .
this result is quite natural , since we are now considering the magnetic structure based on the two - orbital model , in which the fm tendency is due to the optimization of kinetic motion of electrons
. plane for @xmath82=1.5 , @xmath65=1 , and @xmath76=0 .
( b ) spin structures in the g - type af , c - type af , a - type af , and fm phases.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in order to understand the underlying mechanism of the appearance of various magnetic structures in addition to the g - af structure for @xmath82=1.5 , we consider the case of @xmath80=0 . in fig .
7(a ) , we show typical results of the spin correlation as a function of @xmath76 for @xmath79=5 , @xmath80=0 , and @xmath65=1 . at @xmath76=0 ,
the dominant component of @xmath105 appears at @xmath99=@xmath101 , indicating the g - type af structure . on the other hand , in the region of positive small @xmath76 ,
the spin correlation of @xmath99=@xmath100 turns to be dominant , indicating the c - type af structure .
this phase is defined as c - af(i ) .
concerning the orbital correlation , we find no remarkable structure in the c - af(i ) phase , as shown in fig .
note that in the g - af phase with positive @xmath76 , the orbital correlation of @xmath99=@xmath106 has a significant value in comparison with other regions , since electrons tend to doubly occupy lower @xmath30 orbitals .
this g - af phase is called g - af(i ) . on the other hand , in the g - af phase with negative @xmath76 ,
there is no indication of the development of the orbital correlation of @xmath99=@xmath106 , since the lower @xmath31 orbitals are singly occupied .
we label this g - af phase as g - af(ii ) to distinguish it from g - af(i ) .
it is interesting to see different types of the g - af phases due to the change of the orbital state .
let us now discuss the reason of the appearance of the c - af(i ) phase in the region of positive small @xmath76 . for @xmath76@xmath1070 , the energy level of @xmath30 is lower than that of @xmath31 by definition .
then , the @xmath30 orbital is first occupied by one electron at each site .
the rest of electrons are accommodated in @xmath31 orbitals to avoid the effect of intra - orbital coulomb interaction when @xmath76 is not large so much .
the electrons in @xmath30 orbitals hop to the @xmath30 orbital at the nearest - neighbor site , since the @xmath31 has higher energy .
since the electrons in @xmath30 orbitals move only in the @xmath53 plane , the af structure is stabilized in each @xmath53 plane independently due to superexchange interaction , as schematically shown in fig .
on the other hand , the electrons in @xmath31 orbitals can move itinerantly within the network composed of @xmath31 orbitals due to the existence of holes in @xmath31 orbitals .
since the hopping amplitude along the @xmath54 axis is dominant in the region near @xmath65=1 , the motion of @xmath31 electrons causes an fm spin arrangement of @xmath30 electrons along the @xmath54 axis to gain kinetic energy .
namely , even though localized @xmath108 spins do not exist in the present case , the so - called double - exchange mechanism is always active in the two - orbital model .
note that the c - af structure disappears for large @xmath76 , since all the electrons tend to occupy @xmath30 orbitals and the double - exchange mechanism is no longer active in that situation .
for @xmath82=1.5 , @xmath79=5 @xmath80=0 , and @xmath65=1 .
( c ) schematic view of the electron configuration in the c - af phase in the region near @xmath65=1 .
( d ) ground - state phase diagram of the magnetic structure in the @xmath109 plane.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] after calculations of the spin and orbital correlations for several parameter sets , we obtain the ground - state phase diagram in the @xmath109 plane , as shown in fig .
it is found that the c - af(i ) phase discussed above extends to a wide region of @xmath65@xmath861 in the phase diagram .
note that for small values of @xmath65 , another c - af phase , which we call c - af(ii ) , appears in the region of negative small @xmath76 , in which the spin correlations of @xmath110 and @xmath111 are dominant . for small @xmath65 and large negative @xmath76
, there appears yet another g - af phase , called g - af(iii ) , due to the same reason as that for the occurrence of g - af(i ) phase for positive @xmath76 , but the occupied orbital is changed from @xmath30 to @xmath31 . in any case , for @xmath80=0 , we can observe several kinds of c- and g - af phases , but a - af phase does not occur
. plane for @xmath82=1.5 , @xmath79=5 , ( a ) @xmath80=0.5 and ( b ) @xmath80=4.,scaledwidth=90.0% ] although we increase the value of @xmath80 as @xmath80=0.5 , no new phases appear in the phase diagram for @xmath82=1.5 , as shown in fig .
there are three phases , but they are two c - af and one g - af states .
as labelled explicitly in the phase diagrams , c - af(i ) , c - af(ii ) , and g - af(i ) are the same as those in the phase diagram of fig .
due to the effect of @xmath80 , g - af(ii ) and g - af(iii ) disappear , since the number of fm bonds should be increased to gain the kinetic energy . as shown in fig .
8(b ) , when we further increase the value of @xmath80 as @xmath80=4 , the g - af phase completely disappears and instead , we observe the a - af phase sandwiched by two c - af phases .
as described above , due to the double - exchange mechanism in the two - orbital model , the a - af phase is considered to appear , when @xmath80 is increased .
in this paper , we have proposed an effective model with active orbital degree of freedom to understand the magnetic structure of neptunium 115 compounds from the microscopic viewpoint . by analyzing the model with the use of the exact diagonalization technique
, we have obtained the ground - state phase diagrams including three kinds of af phases corresponding to nptga@xmath0 . in the experiments for nptga@xmath0 ,
c- , a- , and g - af magnetic phases have been found in npfega@xmath0 , npcoga@xmath0 , and npniga@xmath0 . here we have a question : what is a key parameter to understand the change of the magnetic structure ? in the case of utga@xmath0 , it has been claimed that the level splitting @xmath76 is important to explain the difference in magnetic structure as well as the magnetic anisotropy for a fixed value of @xmath82=1 @xcite . roughly speaking ,
@xmath76 is positive for t = fe , small positive for t = co , and negative for t = ni . among utga@xmath0 with t
= ni , pd , and pt , when we assume that the absolute value of @xmath76 is increased in the order of ni , pd , and pt , it is possible to understand qualitatively the change in the magnetic anisotropy , in addition to the change in the magnetic structure of g - af for t = ni and a - af for t = pd and pt .
it has been found that the value of @xmath65 is not so crucial to explain qualitatively the magnetic properties of u-115 based on the two - orbital model for @xmath82=1 . for @xmath82=2 , as emphasized in the previous section
, we always obtain the g - af phase . however , for @xmath82=1.5
, we have observed three kinds of af magnetic structure in the phase diagrams .
let us summarize the change in the magnetic structure for a fixed value of @xmath65=0.8 .
note that this value is larger than @xmath65=0.1 , which we have considered to reproduce two kinds of cylindrical fermi - surface sheets of np-115 .
however , in the small - sized cluster calculations , it is difficult to compare directly with the values in the thermodynamic limit . thus , we do not discuss further the quantitative point on the values of @xmath65 here . as shown in fig .
7(d ) , for @xmath80=0 and @xmath65=0.8 , we see the change in the magnetic structure as g - af ( @xmath76@xmath860 ) , c - af(0@xmath86@[email protected] ) , and g - af ( @[email protected] ) . for @xmath80=0.5 and @xmath65=0.8 , as shown in fig .
8(a ) , the c - af phases are always observed , but they have different orbital structures . finally , for @xmath80=4 and @xmath65=0.8
, we observe c - af ( @xmath76@xmath86 - 0.15 ) , a - af(-0.15@xmath86@[email protected] ) , and c - af ( @[email protected] ) , as shown in fig .
in order to understand the appearance of three types of the af phases , we may consider an explanation due to the combination of the changes in @xmath76 and @xmath82 .
for instance , by assuming that @xmath80=4 for nptga@xmath0 and the change in @xmath76 for nptga@xmath0 is just the same as that for utga@xmath0 , we consider that @xmath82@xmath1122 with @xmath76@xmath860 for t = ni , @[email protected] with @xmath76@xmath1120 for t = co , and @[email protected] with @xmath76@xmath113 for t = fe .
then , it seems to be possible to relate our theoretical af phases with the experimental observations in nptga@xmath0 .
however , it is difficult to claim that the above parameter assignment for three np-115 materials is the best explanation for the magnetic structure of np-115 , since in actual compounds , there are other important ingredients which have not been included in the present model .
for instance , we have never discussed the direction of the magnetic moment of np ion .
especially , the canted af structure can not be considered at all for the g - af phase of npniga@xmath0 .
thus , we need to recognize some distance between the actual magnetic states and the theoretically obtained phases . our theory should be improved by taking into account other ingredients of 115 structure . in summary
, we have analyzed the orbital degenerate model appropriate for nptga@xmath0 by using the exact diagonalization technique .
our phase diagram includes c- , a- , and g - af phases .
we have proposed the manganite - like scenario to understand the appearance of three kinds of af spin structure in np-115 .
namely , the double - exchange mechanism works also in some actinide compounds based on the model with active orbital degree of freedom .
we believe that the present model can grasp some important points of the actinide compound by regarding it as charge - spin - orbital complex .
the authors thank d. aoki , y. haga , h. harima , y. homma , f. honda , s. ikeda , s. kambe , k. kaneko , k. kubo , t. maehira , t. d. matsuda , n. metoki , a. nakamura , y. nuki , h. sakai , y. shiokawa , t. takimoto , y. tokunaga , k. ueda , r. e. walstedt , f. wastin , e. yamamoto , and h. yasuoka for discussions .
this work has been supported by grant - in - aids for scientific research ( no .
14740219 ) of japan society for the promotion of science and for scientific research in priority area `` skutterudites '' ( no . 16037217 ) of the ministry of education , culture , sports , science , and technology of japan .
the computation in this work has been done using the facilities of the supercomputer center , institute for solid state physics , university of tokyo .
99 k. okuda and s. noguchi , in _ physical properties of actinide and rare earth compounds _ , edited by t. kasuya , t. ishii , t. komatsubara , s. sakai , n. m@xmath114ri , and t. saso , jjap series 8 ( publication office , jjap , tokyo , 1993 ) , p. 32 .
y. nuki , d. aoki , p. winieski , h. shishido , s. ikeda , y. inada , r. settai , y. tokiwa , e. yamamoto , y. haga , t. maehira , h. harima , m. higuchi , a. hasegwa , and h. yamagami , acta phys . pol .
b*32 * , 3273 ( 2001 ) . | in order to understand a crucial role of orbital degree of freedom in the magnetic structure of recently synthesized neptunium compounds nptga@xmath0 ( t = fe , co , and ni ) , we propose to discuss the magnetic phase of an effective two - orbital model , which has been constructed based on a @xmath1-@xmath1 coupling scheme to explain the magnetic structure of uranium compounds utga@xmath0 . by analyzing the model with the use of numerical technique such as exact diagonalization
, we obtain the phase diagram including several kinds of magnetic states .
an orbital - based scenario is discussed to understand the change in the magnetic structure among c- , a- , and g - type antiferromagnetic phases , experimentally observed in npfega@xmath0 , npcoga@xmath0 , and npniga@xmath0 . |
spectral energy distributions ( seds ) have long been the primary method of understanding stars .
colour magnitude diagrams , which can be quickly made from photometric data , enable one to explore various facets of stellar populations , such as stellar mass and evolutioanry state . however , these does not present the information at its most basic physical level : the stellar temperature and luminosity .
these represent the fundamental ideals of stellar modelling , and are theoretically free from biases introduced by photometric calibration , interstellar reddening and similar phenomena .
while transformations to these parameters can be achieved through colour temperature relations and bolometric corrections , these are limited in scope .
most importantly , the wavelength coverage of the observations means that well - defined solutions do not always exist for these relations ( e.g. for very red stars , or for observations only covering wavelengths longer than the sed peak ) .
using the entire wavelength coverage available allows better determination of stellar temperature when a wide temperature range is present among a stellar sample .
this also allows finer control of data quality .
all - sky surveys are , in particular , prone to contain some poor - quality data due to the large flux range they are required to cover , which leads to the saturation of bright sources , and the volume of data , which limits the ability to match photometric routines to particular situations ( e.g. in areas of high stellar density or nebular emission ) .
stellar variability can also cause improper colours to be reported , which can be reduced by using multiple epochs or , equivalently , multi - wavelength data . in this manner
, we can provide more - robust estimates of parameters for individual objects , allowing them to be placed on the true , physical hertzsprung
russell ( h r ) diagram .
perhaps the greatest benefit , however , is the ability to detect excess flux at a particular wavelength , by providing a reference model flux against which fluxes in individual photometric filters can be compared .
this is particularly helpful in the infrared , where colour magnitude diagrams based on only part of the sed can fail to identify sources exhibiting emission in addition to the stellar photosphere .
predominantly , these sources are either very young stars ( pre - main - sequence t tauri stars or herbig ae / be stars ) , rapid rotators ( classical be stars ) , or evolved stars . this latter group is mostly comprised of mass - losing red and asymptotic giant branch ( rgb / agb ) stars , on which we focus our discussion .
previously , only colour magnitude diagrams have been used to interpret our closest stellar neighbours ( e.g. @xcite ) .
we are now able to take the data returned by the _ hipparcos _
satellite @xcite and match it with other all - sky surveys to produce a true h
r diagram of the local solar neighbourhood . in doing so
, we can identify and characterise stars with weak infrared excesses which may be otherwise missed by conventional colour cuts . while this has been attempted previously ( @xcite ; we later discuss these papers in context ) , this work represents the first time such a process has been applied to the entire _ hipparcos _ dataset and in the context of the stars absolute , fundamental parameters .
l@r@r@r@r@r catalogue & wavelength & beam size & + & ( @xmath1 m ) & ( @xmath2 ) & original & combined & final + & & & data & catalogue & catalogue + _ hipparcos _ & 0.528 & @xmath30.5 & 117956 & 109661 & 107616 + _ tycho _ & 0.420 , 0.532 & @xmath30.5 & 118924 & 109624 & 107586 + sdss & 0.3540.623 & @xmath40.5 & 32253 & 30368 & 27420 + denis & 0.7862.20 & @xmath40.5 & 60083 & 2856 & 2762 + 2mass & 1.252.20 &
@xmath40.5 & 104324 & 104297 & 104111 + _ msx _ & 4.2921.3 & @xmath518.3 & 7663 & 7336 & 3153 + _ akari _ & 10.5 , 18.4 & 2.4 , 2.3 & 48078 & 48013 & 47762 + _ iras _ & 12 , 25 & 106 , 106 & 19728 & 16001 & 15533 + _ wise _ & 3.3522.1 & 5.811.8 & 64192 & 64102 & 63883 + + the new _ hipparcos _ ( @xmath6 ) / _ tycho _ ( @xmath7 , @xmath8 ) reduction @xcite was used as the primary astrometric and photometric catalogue , to which the other catalogues were matched .
additional data was sourced from the following surveys : = 1em sloan digital sky survey ( sdss - iii ) data release 8 @xcite : @xmath9-band optical data were included .
these data are heavily affected by saturation for the _ hipparcos _ sample .
the @xmath10-band photometry were left out entirely , and bad data from the @xmath9-bands were identified as described in [ badsect ] .
denis consortium 2005 data release : @xmath11-band data were included for sources where @xmath12 mag .
@xmath13-band near - ir data were used only when 2mass data were not available ( see below ) .
2mass all - sky catalog of point sources @xcite : @xmath14-band near - ir data were included .
all photometry was initially included , regardless of data quality : bad data was later removed as described in [ badsect ] . _ msx _ infrared astrometric catalog @xcite , incorporating six bands ( @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) covering 418 @xmath1 m . note that , at @xmath518@xmath2 resolution , these data exhibit problems from source blending . the _ akari hipparcos _ cross - correlated catalogue @xcite , covering 9 and 18 @xmath1 m , hereafter _ akari _ [ 9 ] and [ 18 ] .
_ iras _ catalogue of point sources , version 2.0 ( psc ; @xcite ) , and faint source catalog , @xmath21 , version 2.0 ( fsc ; @xcite ) , both limited to the 12- and 25-@xmath1 m bands , hereafter _ iras _ [ 12 ] and [ 25 ] . at @xmath51@xmath22 resolution , these data also exhibit problems from source blending
the _ wise _ premiminary data release @xcite , incorporating four bands ( @xmath23 through @xmath24 ) covering 3.522 @xmath1 m .
as the surveys cover a large range of wavelengths and have very differently - sized point - spread functions ( psfs ; table [ catstable ] ) , one must be conservative in declaring two detections as arising from the same source .
denis , 2mass and _ akari _ detections were considered to be matched with _ hipparcos _
detections when their co - ordinates matched to within 1@xmath2 , sdss and _ wise _ data were matched when within 3@xmath2 , and _ msx _ and _ iras _ data were matched within 5@xmath2 . due to the differing depths and similar wavelength coverages of the near- and mid - ir catalogues , substitutions were made to choose only the most discerning data .
specifically , where possible , _ msx _ and _ iras _ data were replaced by higher - resolution , greater - sensitivity _ wise _ and _ akari _ data ; also denis photometry was replaced by 2mass photometry , which is less prone to saturation .
these substitutions were performed as follows : = 1em @xmath23 and @xmath25 replace _ msx _ @xmath15 and @xmath16 , respectively ; _ akari _ [ 9 ] replaces _ msx _
@xmath17 ; @xmath26 and/or _ iras _ [ 12 ] replaces _ msx _ @xmath18 and @xmath19 ; @xmath24 and/or _ akari _ [ 18 ] replaces _ msx _ @xmath20 ; 2mass @xmath27 and @xmath28 replaces denis @xmath27 and @xmath28 ; _ iras _ fsc data replaces _ iras _ psc data .
sdss bands were dropped under certain conditions , namely : = 1em @xmath29 was dropped if @xmath30 mag ;
@xmath31 was dropped if @xmath32 mag ; @xmath33 was dropped if @xmath34 mag ; which correspond to ranges beyond which the sdss data ( which is prone to saturation for the _ hipparcos _ stars , most of which are comparatively bright ) can not be matched in simultaneity with the _ tycho _ data to any stellar model .
the resulting initial input catalogue contains 109661 _ hipparcos _ stars with data from @xmath29-band to 25 @xmath1 m .
the source statistics for this combined catalogue are listed in table [ catstable ] .
the seds were fitted using the code initially described in @xcite and modified in the subsequent papers @xcite .
this code , hereafter referred to as getsed , is optimised to detect low - contrast infrared excess arising from circumstellar dust .
we have made some further revisions to the code as detailed below .
getsed works by minimising the @xmath35 statistic between the observed photometric data and a set of synthetic stellar spectra to determine stellar temperature and luminosity .
this requires user - defined stellar mass , metallicity and distance , and an interstellar reddening , and given appropriate filter transmission curves .
a grid of temperatures between 2400 and 60000 k is set up , in steps of 400 k. blackbodies of these temperatures are fit to the dereddened photometric data and the model with the lowest @xmath35 chosen .
a finer grid is set up and the blackbody temperature is iterated to the nearest 25 k. this temperature is then used to derive the stellar luminosity and surface gravity to first order . for this work , we do not know the mass or metallicity of our stars , which are required to select the correct set of synthetic spectra . nor do we know the interstellar reddening toward the stars .
we assume that the metallicity is solar and that the interstellar reddening is zero .
an assumption of solar metallicity is reasonable for nearby galactic stars : the true values scatter around the solar value of [ z / h ] @xcite , with the scatter imparting a @xmath363% error to the temperature fit for the majority of stars .
the magnitude of this error is similar to that imparted by good - quality photometry .
a larger error is imparted by interstellar reddening , which makes the star appear dimmer and cooler than it actually is .
this can be significant in the case of distant objects , or those in the galactic plane . in practice ,
stars which suffer from significant interstellar extinction tend to be the brighter giant stars , which also suffer from significant parallax errors .
bright giants are often subject to radial pulsations .
these can change the fractional contribution of cool and hot spots on the stellar surface to the star s total light , leading to changes in the astrometric centre of light .
these can impart substantial parallax errors @xcite , which can be sufficiently large that extinction is not the primary source of error in the placement of these stars on the h
r diagram .
as we do not know the mass of individual stars , we estimate it from the best - fit blackbody temperature and luminosity .
as this only affects the stellar gravity , which has a minimal effect on the overall sed , we need only to approximate the actual mass .
we estimate the stellar mass by assuming each star is either a main - sequence star or a giant .
giants are determined to be stars with : @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the determined effective temperature in kelvin and @xmath39 is the determined luminosity in solar units . for main - sequence stars ,
we use a mass temperature relation based on a solar - metallicity , zero - age main - sequence ( zams ) isochrone @xcite . we can not estimate the mass of giant stars so easily .
most stars below the rgb tip ( @xmath40 l@xmath0 ) will be the more - numerous , older stars of @xmath31 m@xmath0 .
more massive giants survive to much higher luminosities on the agb , thus we expect very luminous giants to be considerably more massive . based on the aforementioned isochrones @xcite , we assume a mass for the giant stars of @xmath41 , with limits placed at 1 and 20 m@xmath0 .
the first - order determination of temperature , luminosity and stellar gravity ( from the black - body fit ) , are used as the initial parameters for our synthetic spectra .
previously , we have used the marcs model atmospheres @xcite described in @xcite . for this work
, however , we instead use the bt - settl models of @xcite , as the temperature spacing of the grid models is finer in the 40006000 k region .
we have found this to reduce artifacts caused by interpolation between grid points for stars with poor - quality photometry .
getsed takes the model spectra grid and performs a linear interpolation in temperature and surface gravity ( and metallicity , if required ) .
the synthetic spectrum is convolved with the observed filter transmissions and reduced to a set of expected photometric fluxes .
these are then normalised to the observed photometric fluxes ( the constant of normalisation determining the luminosity ) and a @xmath35 is determined .
this process is first performed on the temperature gridpoint immediately cooler than the blackbody temperature .
getsed then calculates the @xmath35 for the neighbouring temperature gridpoints and continues until a @xmath35 minimum is detected .
the temperature corresponding to the @xmath35 minimum is used as a new starting point , a new surface gravity is calculated , and @xmath35 is determined for 128 k steps between the neighbouring models . a new @xmath35 minimum is determined , the temperature step is halved , and the process re - run until the temperature is fit to within 1 k. the calculated stellar effective temperature , luminosity , surface gravity and model photometric fluxes are written to disk . as with our previous uses of this code , we have only fit photometric data with short wavelengths ( here we require @xmath42 @xmath1 m ) .
circumstellar dust will still cause some opacity in the optical , but the obscuration must be relatively small for it to have been observed with _
hipparcos _ , and absorption of optical flux is relatively easy to identify when it is re - radiated in the infrared .
stars which are heavily extincted will have seds that become double - peaked . in these cases , getsed will not be able to fit a model spectrum to it
. the most - extincted stars ( e.g. irc+10216 ; @xcite ) may be sufficiently optically obscured that they do not feature in the _ hipparcos _ catalogue ( cf .
this becomes important in the removal of bad data ( see section [ badsect ] ) and we remind the reader that our h
r diagram is therefore incomplete , even at high luminosity .
each star now has a series of photometric datapoints for which an observed and a modelled flux is known .
the ratio ( @xmath43 ) of observed / modelled flux therefore gives the excess or deficit flux in that band .
we give this as a pure ratio , rather than in terms of an @xmath44-based excess , as we do not include the errors in the photometric data in our model . while this may appear surprising , the reported errors on photometric data are almost invariably much lower than the absolute error between catalogues .
such ` bad ' data can be incorporated into the sed for several intrinsic and extrinsic reasons , including ( in approximate order of overall severity ) : = 1em poor - quality raw data , e.g. saturated images or unflagged cosmic rays ; blending , particularly among catalogues which have integrated fluxes over different areas ( e.g. the point - spread function of _ hipparcos _ is a very different size to that of _ iras _ ) , affecting binary and multiple stars , and objects which are in the same line of sight as background objects with very red colours ( e.g. redshifted galaxies in infrared surveys ) ; poor background subtraction , which mainly affects infrared observations of sources at low galactic latitudes or in other regions of nebulosity ; intrinsic variability among stars ; inaccurate source matching due to large proper motions ; the accuracy of photometric corrections to each survey s base photometric system .
the issues become particularly problematic when comparing optical and mid - infrared catalogues : in the mid - infrared stars typically present fainter detections compared to higher backgrounds , and beam sizes are typically larger ( hence include more objects ) .
additional errors come from the model parameters which arise from our assumption that stars have solar metallicity , a given stellar mass and no interstellar extinction . bearing this in mind
, we have assumed that each photometric point has an arbitrary absolute error of 10% and computed a @xmath35-based goodness - of - fit measure based on this uncertainty
. we also do not give error estimates for our temperatures and luminosities , as they would essentially be meaningless .
the bad data in our combined multi - wavelength catalogue is mostly of sources which have saturated in the various input survey catalogues .
the _ wise _ catalogue , in particular , suffers from saturation .
some photometry flagged as good does not match detections in other bands ( e.g. hip24436 has @xmath25 = 1.987 @xmath45 0.009 mag , while @xmath46 = 0.739 , 0.001 and 0.030 mag ) .
conversely , some photometry flagged as uncertain does not decrease the goodness - of - fit of the model seds and is therefore sufficiently accurate for the purpose of identifying infrared excess .
we have so far included all _ wise _ data , regardless of its uncertainty and we must now remove the points we believe to be in error . unfortunately , this is a particularly recalcitrant dataset to remove bad data from : we wish to keep points which fit badly due to intrinsic variability ( as these will , on average , cancel out across the sed ) , but remove datapoints which have incorrect fluxes .
we have opted to apply a number of sequential cuts to remove bad quality data . since altering one band
affects the model fit of the others , we must carefully design these cuts to minimise errant removal of good quality data . at each step , we have visually examined the seds of the objects with the worst - fitting models and devised a cut which removes the dominant contribution of bad data .
the removed data was examined and the cut applied if it did not remove any plausibly accurate data .
the details of these cuts are given in the appendix .
while these cuts have not removed every single bad data point , they have removed the vast majority of bad data , providing a much cleaner data set with which we can work .
this has sadly meant removing stars where there was not sufficient data to provide a robust fit , meaning the original _ hipparcos _ catalogue has been reduced from 117956 to 107619 objects . now that we have removed bad data from our catalogue , we can calculate the amount of infrared excess present for each star .
having already performed sed fitting , creating a measure of infrared excess becomes a trivial exercise in comparing the fitted model with observations . providing the best metric(s ) to quantify infrared excess
is more difficult .
we adopt two techniques .
our first metric simply takes the ratio of observed to sed - modelled flux of all the data longward of 2.2 @xmath1 m ( @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 ) , and averages them together .
this provides a single number ( @xmath51 ) that describes the average excess in the 325 @xmath1 m region , relative to the underlying photospheric model , which can be described mathematically as : @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the observed and modelled fluxes at frequency @xmath55 ( corresponding to wavelength @xmath56 ) and @xmath57 is the number of observations at wavelengths @xmath582.2 @xmath1 m .
our second metric assumes that the infrared excess is due to reprocessed stellar light ( i.e. ignoring background infrared emission and foreground circumstellar extinction ) .
we approximate the amount of reprocessed light as being the integrated observed flux or @xmath59 . ]
longward of 2.2 @xmath1 m , minus the integrated model flux over the same region .
we can take this as a fraction of the underlying stellar flux , under the assumption that the total energy output ( in jy ) of the star is not affected by circumstellar reprocessing of light .
mathematically , we can then define the fraction of stellar light reprocessed into the infrared ( @xmath60 ) as : @xmath61 we also define a wavelength , @xmath62 , as where @xmath63 reaches a peak .
the precision with which we can define @xmath62 depends strongly on the amount of available data .
we are now in a position to list our data in a master catalogue containing the fundamental parameters of the _ hipparcos _ stars .
we do so in table [ hrdtable ] , which lists : = 1em column 1 : the _ hipparcos _ identifier for the object ; columns 2 & 3 : the co - ordainates of the object ; columns 4 & 5 : the parallax distance to the object and its associated fractional error ; column 6 : the modelled effective temperature of the object ; column 7 : the modelled luminosity of the object ; columns 8 & 9 : the shortest and longest wavelength for which we have data ; columns 1030 : the ratio of the observed to modelled flux at each wavelength , such that unity represents a perfect match to the model ; column 31 : @xmath64 , the number of observations at @xmath65 m ; column 32 : @xmath51 , the average excess at those wavelengths , as defined above ; column 33 : @xmath60 , the fraction of the object s luminosity reprocessed into the infrared , as defined above ; column 34 : @xmath62 , the wavelength at which the infrared excess reaches a peak , as defined above .
[ cols= " > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] figure [ giantxsfig ] shows that scatter on the giant branch generally decreases as we approach the agb tip , due to increased sensitivity on brighter sources .
we can also see the substantial number of sources which have scattered to lower temperatures and higher values of @xmath51 ( also figure [ itaxsfig ] ) , indicating reprocessing of optical light be circumstellar dust .
the amount of excess around these stars can be correlated with their dust - production rate and hence their mass - loss rate . by identifying and characterising individual stars which lie above the general scatter in figure [ giantxsfig ] , and including optically - obscured sources missed by _
, we can make a theoretically complete census of dust producing stars within 300 pc .
while that is beyond the scope of this paper , we do report on giant stars which are observed to have significant excess .
we define this by @xmath66 ( see also figure [ giantxsfig ] ) , which is chosen to identify excesses of @xmath67 at all luminosities .
we list these stars in tables [ giantstable ] ( luminous stars , above 850 l@xmath0 ) and [ giants2table ] ( stars below 850 l@xmath0 ) . in these tables , we have also listed common names and spectral classification from simbad , and variability information , sourced from either the gcvs ( @xcite ; denoted ` g ' ) or _ hipparcos _ ( denoted ` h ' ) catalogues .
variability periods and amplitudes ( either in the _ hipparcos _ band , denoted ` h ' ; johnson v - band , denoted ` v ' ; or as a photographic measurement , denoted ` p ' ; ) are shown where available .
variability types are listed as follows : mira = mira variable ; srv = semi - regular variable ; irr = irregular variable ; v = unclassified variable ; bin = ( eclipsing ) binary ; none = no appreciable variability .
the spectral classifications of any lrs and sws spectra of these sources are also given ( @xcite ; based on the classification method of @xcite ) .
table [ giantstable ] contains some well - known targets , which are known to have substantial mass loss .
the common se classification of the lws and sws spectra shows that most of these stars are known to have silicate features in their spectra and are therefore dust producers .
others , such as ss lep , @xmath68 car and @xmath69 her , are known to be binaries , therefore their seds may not be well - repesented by a single blackbody ( most giant stars , however , should outshine any companions at all wavelengths : note that @xmath69 her in particular is known to be dust producing ; @xcite ) .
several others without lrs or sws spectra are likely to be mass - losing stars , but without infrared spectra it is difficult to tell .
one outstanding example is present , however : that of eu del ( hip 101810 )
. figure [ eudelfig ] shows its sed .
literature photometry for this sed comes from the _ hipparcos _ , _ tycho _ , 2mass , _ akari _ and _ iras _ catalogues already mentioned .
further photometry was sourced from mermilliod s catalogue of homogeneous means ( @xmath70 ; vizier online data catalogue ii/168 ) , the carlsberg meridian catalogue ( @xmath71 ; @xcite ) , the catalogue of infrared observations , including the revised afgl catalogue ( 420 @xmath1 m ; @xcite ) , _ dirbe _
( 2.2100 @xmath1 m ; @xcite ) , and the _ akari _ fis catalogue ( 65 , 90 and 140 @xmath1 m ; vizier online data catalogue ii/298 ) .
literature spectroscopy for the optical @xcite , @xmath27-band @xcite , @xmath72-band @xcite and @xmath73-band @xcite are also shown , as is the _ iras _ lrs spectrum from @xcite .
@xcite classify eu del as a naked star , as it shows no silicate feature .
however , it is found to have substantial excess in both the _ iras _ 12- and 25-@xmath1 m bands and the infrared spectrum clearly shows a rise above a blackbody toward longer wavelengths .
@xcite place the star at a metallicity of [ fe / h ] = 1 , making it reminiscent of the featureless excesses we have previously found in metal - poor globular cluster giant stars @xcite .
we have previously attributed this to metallic iron dust on chemical and mineralogical grounds , however it is spectrally indistinguishable from amorphous carbon dust and silicate dust composed primarily of large grains ( cf .
@xcite ; @xcite ) .
eu del may therefore be a unique nearby testbed in which to determine which dust species is causing these unexplained featureless excesses .
table [ giants2table ] contains a few stars with suspected infrared excess , which we examine more closely , in order to identify the luminosity at which dust formation ( as traced by infrared excess ) begins .
we investigate these individually here .
= 1em ac cet : considerable excess exists in the _ akari _ 9- and 18-@xmath1 m bands , and the _ iras _ 12- and 25-@xmath1 m bands .
@xcite note that there is another evolved star within the _ iras _ psf , but the excess in _ akari _ suggests that ac cet does indeed have circumstellar dust .
@xcite classify the source as having a class ` c ' lrs spectrum , denoting a 11-@xmath1 m sic feature , however this feature is tentative in this source , at best .
ru pup : _ akari _ , _ wise _ and _ iras _ data all show considerable excess at wavelengths longer than 4 @xmath1 m .
there is significant scatter in the optical photometry , which leads to a poor estimation of the temperature and luminosity for this star .
this may be partly due to its carbon - richness and partly due to its variability .
@xcite place this star via two means at 2680 or 2875 k and 455 or 610 pc , which makes it considerably cooler and more luminous ( 1715 or 3649 l@xmath0 ) than we model .
this is corroborated by its long period ( cf .
it therefore probably suffers from the pulsation - induced distance errors we describe in section [ fitsect ] .
rs cam : this star also shows excess in the _ akari _ , _ wise _ and _ iras _ data .
its short period suggests its luminosity is correctly determined ( cf .
the lrs spectrum shows weak silicate emission @xcite .
hr 4091 : this source is modelled using _
dirbe _ and _ iras _ data only .
it shows marginal excess between 4 and 21 @xmath1 m , and considerable excess in the 25-@xmath1 m _ iras _ band .
it is at very low galactic latitude ( @xmath74 ) and thus suffers from considerable contamination from surrounding sources .
we therefore do not believe this excess is real .
tz car : the 8- to 25-@xmath1 m data for this star show considerable excess .
reprocessing of the _ hipparcos _ data by @xcite suggest the distance for this star is roughly correct . at a galactic latitude of @xmath75
, tz car may suffer from some extinction , but it is likely that the excess and parameters are sufficiently correct to say that this star is losing mass .
ru crt : a known mass - losing star , this star shows moderate excess in the _ akari _ bands and substantially more excess in the _ iras _ bands . at 132 pc ,
it is possible that more - extended emission is missed by _ akari _ : sources up to roughly this distance may have some emission outwith the _ akari _ beam at 25 @xmath1 m ( see section [ groensect ] ) .
hd 105822 : this star is in a region of high projected stellar density ( @xmath76 ) .
the amount of excess for this star is inconsistent across the infrared data , varying among the surveys and bands .
a dubious @xmath27-band flux probably suggests more infrared excess than is truly present .
the apparent infrared excess in this case is likely due to source blending and confusion , coupled with poor - quality short - wavelength photometry .
68 uma : this star is mistakenly classified as excessive due to a mismatch between the _ hipparcos / tycho _ magnitudes and those from the sdss , which differ by approximately a magnitude , despite no variability being detected by _
hipparcos_. this has lead to an excess being determined incorrectly . by using a variety of combinations of photometry
, we estimate that a correct temperature and luminosity of around 4000 k and 400 l@xmath0 would me more appropriate for this source , and that it has no substantial reddening .
hr 5464 : the determination of infrared excess for this star is based solely on _ iras _ data , in which excess is relatively weak ( 86% at 12 @xmath1 m , 50% at 25
@xmath1 m ) .
_ dirbe _ data suggest there is little or no infrared excess for this source .
bd peg : a known mass - losing star , @xcite note that silicate emission is present in this object and @xcite confirm its infrared excess . with the exception of the carbon star tz car
, we therefore find no detectable dust production by any object below the luminosity of ru crt ( 681 l@xmath0 ) .
we therefore conclude that this represents the luminosity at which dust production by agb stars begins in earnest in the local neighbourhood .
this corroborates very well with the @xmath5700 l@xmath0 we have previously found in galactic globular clusters @xcite .
we now turn our attention to the work of @xcite .
this paper identifies several low - luminosity _ hipparcos _ stars with infrared excess which groenewegen attributes to weak dust emission .
these stars have much lower lumionsities ( 50350 l@xmath0 ) than those we find excess around , as groenewegen was examining rgb stars for dust excesses much smaller than we have deemed accurately determinable in this work .
the stars from @xcite which have survived our data quality cuts are shown on figure [ giantxsfig ] .
groenewegen purposely targetted stars with low ( @xmath77 ) colours , thus his sample does not include stars from with high values of @xmath51 .
it is notable , however , that all 52 stars common to our datasets lie within the scatter of points with no unusual infrared excess .
also , groenewegen s dusty stars appear to have no more infrared excess than his dustless stars .
the reasons behind this are not immediately obvious , but can be understood by examining the subtle differences between our analyses .
the most striking of these is the choice of input data .
we have included data from _ wise _ , _ akari _ ( 9 and 18 @xmath1 m ) and _ iras _ ( 12 and 25 @xmath1 m ) .
groenewegen includes data from _ akari _ ( including the far - infrared 60- and 90-@xmath1 m fis bands ) and _ iras _ ( including the far - infrared 60- and 100-@xmath1 m bands ) .
the choice of whether or not to include the far - infrared data is a balance of gaining sensitivity to cold dust and acquiring systematic errors due to contamination in the line of sight .
the issue with the _ akari _ fis and _ iras _ data we have excluded is the beam size ( 37@xmath2 and 39@xmath2 for _ akari _ fis 60 and 100 @xmath1 m , respectively ; @xmath78 for _ iras _
12@xmath1 m ; @xcite ) .
these are much larger than the beam sizes for the other infrared data ( 5.6@xmath2 for _ akari _ irc 8.6 @xmath1 m ; @xmath79 for _ wise _
11.6@xmath1 m ) and much larger than the optical photometry ( typically 12@xmath2 ) .
a large point - spread function full - width half - maximum ( psf fwhm ) means there is a substantial issue with contamination from unrelated sources in the line of sight , from diffuse background emission , or from ism headed by the star .
equally , if a giant star has a spatially - extended wind , this may be missed by only considering data with a small psf .
groenewegen has been careful to exclude sources with strong cirrus contamination , which is the main contaminant in the _ iras _ photometry . however , his exclusions are based on the 100-@xmath1 m images , whereas ecliptic dust is a greater contaminant at 25 and 60 @xmath1 m .
these sources would therefore not be identified as contaminated .
on examining the individual stars which @xcite claims are dusty , we find that the comparatively - large psf size of _ iras _ and ( in some cases ) _ akari _ fis appears the primary cause of the difference between our datasets . typically , the _ iras _ 12- and 25-@xmath1 m flux is systematically in excess of the modelled stellar photosphere compared to the smaller - psf _ akari _ irc and _ wise _ photometry . as an example , we model hip 44126 ( fz cnc ) to have moderate excess in _ iras _ ( 52% and 35% at 12 and 25
@xmath1 m ) , but little excess in _ wise _ ( 8% and 6% at 11.6 and 22.1 @xmath1 m ) . by only taking the _ iras _ data , groenewegen naturally models this star as having reasonable infrared excess . in this particular
instance , the contaminating source can be clearly identified as poorly - subtracted emission from warm dust in the ecliptic plane in the original _ iras _ photometry .
the same is true of hip 53449 , though here is the _ akari _ fis data that suffers from contamination from the ecliptic .
not all of groenewegen s dusty sources can be explained so easily , however .
hip 67605 and 67665 ( aw cvn ) are both identified as dusty by @xcite .
they lie quite close to each other ( 15@xmath80 apart ) but are resolved in the _ iras _ images by several beam widths .
they do not suffer from substantial contamination .
they are covered by _
akari _ and _ iras _ , but not the _ wise _ preliminary catalogue .
both sources have excess at _ iras _ 12 and 25 @xmath1 m but not _ akari _ 9 and 18 @xmath1 m . like the majority of groenewegen s targets ,
these stars lie at around 200 pc . at this distance
the _ akari _
8.6-@xmath1 m psf has a fwhm of 1120 au , or 20004000 stellar radii . assuming the dust temperature approximately follows a @xmath81 law , and a stellar temperature of @xmath53700 k , this implies that dust falling within
the _ iras _ beam but outwith the _ akari _ irc beam should emit with a peak wavelength of @xmath82 @xmath1 m
. it should therefore not emit significantly at 818 @xmath1 m to cause the discrepency between the _ akari _ nir and _ iras _
12-@xmath1 m fluxes . nevertheless , the infrared excess groenewegen finds may still be real , and still be related to a wind eminating from the star .
two situations may cause this .
the first case is that a cooler , detached shell surrounds the star and emits only at longer ( 60100 @xmath1 m ) wavelengths ( cf .
y cvn ; @xcite ) . in the second case
, the emission would be produced not by the star , but instead interstellar dust swept up in a bow shock around the astropause @xcite .
this has been seen in other nearby agb stars @xcite and could be the source of the excess emission at longer ( 60100 @xmath1 m ) wavelengths that groenewegen finds in several cases .
we also acknowledge that variability may also play a rle in this analysis .
neither groenewegen s nor our determinations of infrared excess take into account the variability of stars .
as @xcite uses some different optical data to us , we may find that some stars in both studies appear to have infrared excess simply because their optical photometry was observed when the star was at photometric minimum .
conversely , excess may be missed if observations were carried out at photometric maximum .
@xcite and this work probe subtly different datasets with subtly different techniques .
it should therefore not be surprising that we find different results , though we would argue that our analysis should be better suited to finding ongoing dust production by stars .
on the basis of the above discussion , we advise caution when investigating small infrared excesses in such cases and note the benefits of phase - matched , high - resolution infrared photometry ( see also @xcite ) .
in this work , we have demonstrated the use of spectral energy distribution fitting to determine the fundamental parameters of the _ hipparcos _ star sample .
we have further used this information to quantify excess flux over the entire optical , and near- and mid - infrared region of each sed .
we have combined these excesses to determine those stars showing an excess of infrared flux , and cross - correlated literature identifications to examine the cause of that excess over different regions of the h
r diagram , comparing our results to the key studies of @xcite and @xcite .
we find we can not reproduce the infrared excess and dust production claimed by the latter paper .
our analysis has focussed on the _ hipparcos _ data catalogue : data which is now over 20 years old and , despite showing its age , provides the best estimate of distances to nearby stars we have . the launch of _ gaia _ , and the completion of further all - sky surveys such as pan - starrs , sdss and _ wise _ , will allow a similar analysis to be performed on many times more objects .
automated techniques , building on the kind demonstrated here , will be necessary to analyse and classify the objects which come from these surveys , in order to gain a full and comprehensive understanding of our corner of the galaxy and its inhabitants .
we thank martin groenewegen for his invaluable input into the comparison with his published works and his help in resolving the differences between our results . this research has made extensive use of the simbad database , vizier catalogue access tool and aladin , operated at cds , strasbourg , france .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac infrared science archive , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
hipparcos_/tycho catalogues are a result of the _ hipparcos _ space astrometry mission , undertaken by the european space agency .
funding for sdss - iii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s .
department of energy .
the sdss - iii web site is http://www.sdss3.org/. the denis project has been partly funded by the science and the hcm plans of the european commission under grants ct920791 and ct940627 .
it is supported by insu , men and cnrs in france , by the state of baden - wrttemberg in germany , by dgicyt in spain , by cnr in italy , by ffwfbwf in austria , by fapesp in brazil , by otka grants f-4239 and f-013990 in hungary , and by the eso c&ee grant a-04 - 046 .
jean claude renault from iap was the project manager .
observations were carried out thanks to the contribution of numerous students and young scientists from all involved institutes , under the supervision of p. fouqu , survey astronomer resident in chile .
this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation .
this research made use of data products from the midcourse space experiment .
processing of the data was funded by the ballistic missile defense organization with additional support from nasa office of space science .
this publication makes use of data products from the _ wide - field infrared survey explorer _ , which is a joint project of the university of california , los angeles , and the jet propulsion laboratory / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration .
this research is based on observations with _
akari _ , a jaxa project with the participation of esa .
we describe in this appendix the sequentially - applied cuts we use to remove bad data from our catalogue .
the first cut was designed to remove extremely cool sources and sources with distinctly double - peaked seds from the sample .
these tend to be heavily - enshrouded or heavily - extincted objects which we can not accurately model .
stars were removed from the main catalogue if they had at least two mid - infrared ( 3.525 @xmath1 m ) bands brighter than all their optical / near - ir ( @xmath83@xmath28-band ) data .
this cut removed 241 objects from the catalogue , of which 98 objects have no @xmath84-band data , leaving 109436 .
the second cut was designed to remove unphysically low values from the _ wise _ data , which are much too faint to come from a stellar object detectable by _
hipparcos_. a _ wise _
photometric datum was removed from the combined catalogue if its flux was below 100 @xmath1jy . in this way , _ wise _ photometry was deleted from 281 objects . the third cut acts to remove more underluminous @xmath23 and @xmath25 data . to assist in this , we define two fluxes , @xmath85 and @xmath86 : @xmath85 is the 10-@xmath1 m flux defined by ( in order of preference ) the @xmath26 , _ akari _ [ 9 ] or _ iras _ [ 12 ] flux , and @xmath86 is defined similarly by the @xmath24 , _ akari _ [ 18 ] or _ iras _ [ 25 ] flux .
this cut applies to all stars where @xmath87 and stars where no @xmath85 measurement exists .
this requirement prevents the selection of dusty sources where the sed reaches a minimum between 3 and 8 @xmath1 m but where dust emission is insufficient to be picked up by cut # 1 .
@xmath23 and/or @xmath25 are removed if it their fluxes are less than 40% of both the 2mass ( or denis , where substituted ) @xmath28-band and the @xmath85 fluxes . where no measure of @xmath85 is available , @xmath86 is used instead .
the fourth cut removes more underluminous @xmath23 data .
this cut detects objects where the flux in @xmath23 is @xmath8840% of the flux in @xmath25 , provided the flux in @xmath25 is : ( 1 ) non - zero , ( 2 ) greater than the flux in @xmath26 and ( 3 ) less than the flux in @xmath28 ( where @xmath26 and @xmath28 fluxes exist ) .
the cepheid x sgr ( hip87072 ) is excluded from this cut as a special case .
this removes 38 bad @xmath23 datapoints from the catalogue . at this point , sources were also removed from the catalogue if they had data in five or fewer of the observed bands .
this removed 1479 objects , leaving 107957 .
most of the deletions were either detected by _
hipparcos _ and _ iras _ , or _
hipparcos _ and sdss . for each _ hipparcos _ object , we determine the worst - fitting filter out of those listed in the previous paragraph , i.e. the filter with the greatest value of @xmath43 or @xmath89 . if this value is five times greater than the next largest @xmath43 or @xmath89 , it is removed . for example ,
if @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the two worst - fitting filters , @xmath90 and @xmath91 then the @xmath27-band datum will be removed , whereas if @xmath92 it will not .
the sixth cut was done manually to remove five stars where ir photometry is clearly confused due to blending , variability or background .
these stars are hip 60782 , 80057 and 88267 ( all binaries ) , and hip 82850 and 82611 .
this left 107952 unique catalogued objects .
the seventh cut removes _ msx _
@xmath15 and/or @xmath16 data when these data have a higher flux than than the @xmath28 filters and one of the @xmath26 , @xmath49 [ 9 ] or @xmath50 [ 12 ] filters . while in principle this could remove points from seds peaking between 2.2 and 12 @xmath1 m , no objects seem to be affected by this .
dustless stars tend to peak at wavelengths shorter than 2.2 @xmath1 m , while dusty stars with double - peaked seds tend to have their second peak at wavelengths longer than 12 @xmath1 m .
data was removed from 244 objects , though this affected only fraction of these , as @xmath48 data is only used when wise data is unavailable .
there were 13 objects removed during this stage because they had insufficient photometry , leaving 107939 unique objects .
the eighth cut is designed to remove underluminous sdss data from saturated sources .
sdss @xmath31- and/or @xmath33-band data are removed if they are recorded to have less flux than the @xmath94 and @xmath95 @xmath7 and @xmath8 fluxes .
this affects 7058 objects , though most of these were already rejected in [ datasect ] .
an additional 224 points were manually removed from 147 objects , mainly consisting of errant @xmath23 and @xmath25 fluxes .
a further 39 objects were rejected for having insufficient data , leaving 107900 unique objects .
the ninth cut repeats cut # 5 , removing datapoints which have a goodness - of - fit more than a factor 2.5 ( instead of 5 ) worse than the next worst - fitting point .
this cut was performed in two interations , the first removing a point from 647 objects , the second removing a point from 59 objects .
a final 120 points from 112 objects were edited out by hand . following this , objects with less than five photometric points at @xmath888 @xmath1 m were rejected , leaving 107619 unique objects in the final catalogue .
f. , guillot t. , ludwig h .-
, hauschildt p. h. , schweitzer a. , alexander d. r. , ferguson j. w. , 2003 , in brown dwarfs , e. martn , eds .
, iau symp .
211 , brown dwarfs .
soc . pac .
, san francisco , p. 325
m. a. c. , esa , eds .
, 1997 , esa special publication , vol .
1200 , the _ hipparcos _ and _ tycho _ catalogues .
astrometric and photometric star catalogues derived from the esa _ hipparcos _ space astrometry mission .
esa , noordwijk . | we derive the fundamental parameters ( temperature and luminosity ) of 107619 _ hipparcos _ stars and place these stars on a true hertzsprung russell diagram .
this is achieved by comparing bt - settl model atmospheres to spectral energy distributions ( seds ) created from _
hipparcos _ , _ tycho _ , sdss , denis , 2mass , _ msx _ , _ akari _ , _ iras _ and _ wise _ data .
we also identify and quantify from these seds any infrared excesses attributable to circumstellar matter .
we compare our results to known types of objects , focussing on the giant branch stars .
giant star dust production ( as traced by infrared excess ) is found to start in earnest around 680 l@xmath0 .
[ firstpage ] stars : fundamental parameters solar neighbourhood stars : mass - loss circumstellar matter infrared : stars hertzsprung russell and colour magnitude diagrams |
the interest in equilibrium and dynamical properties of flux arrays in type ii superconductors originates both from their technological importance and the rich variety of behavior these systems exhibit under different physical conditions . in a classic paper abrikosov in 1957 @xcite showed that for applied fields @xmath5 such that @xmath6 , the magnetic field penetrates in the form of quantized flux tubes ( @xmath7 ) , which in the absence of disorder form a triangular lattice . in conventional low temperature superconductors , this flux line lattice ( fll ) was believed to exist at all temperatures upto @xmath8 . with the discovery of high @xmath9 superconductors , it was realized that , due to much higher transition temperatures , reduced effective dimensionality and short coherence lengths , fluctuations play an important role in deciding the structure and dynamics of flls @xcite .
one of the most significant consequences of enhanced thermal fluctuations on the fll is its melting into a flux liquid phase via a first order transition @xcite .
disorder arising from vacancies and interstitials , twin boundaries , grain boundaries and columnar pins also modify the structure and dynamics of the vortex lattice .
the presence of strong static disorder is technologically relevant , for it leads to effective pinning of vortices thereby leading to high critical currents @xcite .
it also can lead to novel glassy phases such as the vortex glass and bragg glass for the case of _ random _ quenched disorder @xcite .
columnar defects i.e. linear damaged tracks in the material caused by heavy ion irradiation have emerged as very effective pinning centers @xcite . in order to model the effect of columnar pins on the fll
, we exploit the mapping of 3d interacting flux lines onto bosons in ( 2 + 1)d @xcite . in the mapped quantum problem
, the columnar defects naturally map onto a time - independent random potential for bosons @xcite .
the irreversibility line can be interpreted as a phase transition where the vortex liquid at high temperatures freezes into a _ bose glass _ ( bg ) of vortices pinned by columnar pins at lower temperatures .
path integral monte carlo simulations @xcite find a low temperature bg with patches of ordered region with positional _ and _ orientational order which melts into an entangled defected liquid at high temperatures .
also , when the vortex density and defect densities are equal ( at the matching field @xmath10 ) , each flux line is attached to one pin , leading to a mott insulator ( mi ) phase@xcite .
such a mott insulator has been observed in magnetization relaxation experiments @xcite . in this paper , we study , using numerical exact diagonalisation on small lattices , the different phases of flux lines with columnar pins for various densities of vortices and disorder strengths .
we consider a lattice of @xmath11-sites with @xmath12 vortices , interacting via a hard core potential .
we model disorder in two ways : ( a ) pinning disorder where a finite fraction of attractive pins , each of strength @xmath1 , are placed randomly ; and ( b ) a random disorder potential at each point . in case ( a )
, we find that an entangled vortex liquid is stable against weak pins . for high pinning strengths ,
a mott insulator is realised when the number of vortices is equal to the number of pins at the matching field @xmath10 .
signatures of a strongly pinned bose glass and a weakly pinned bose glass are also seen as the vortex density is tuned across @xmath10 . in case ( b ) , we find two phases in the density - disorder plane . at low disorder an entangled vortex liquid which localizes into a pinned bose glass with increasing disorder .
we find that the critical disorder strength required to pin the vortex liquid increases with increasing vortex density .
this implies that the temperature required to depin the vortices is reduced with increasing fields ( see fig .
[ fig:7 ] ) .
we organize the paper in the following way . in section
[ sec : model ] we give the details of our model . in section
[ subsec : pin ] we discuss our results for pinning disorder , where we can access different phases of vortices including the mott insulator . in section [ subsec : box ]
we discuss our simulations for the case where each site has a random disorder potential and conjecture an interesting experimental implication of our phase diagram .
consider a system of @xmath13 flux lines in 3d in a magnetic field ( @xmath14 ) aligned with the @xmath15-axis , described by their 2d trajectories @xmath16 as they traverse a sample of thickness @xmath17 with @xmath18 columnar pins .
their free energy @xcite is given by @xmath19 \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
+ \sum_{k=1}^{n_p } v_p [ { \bf r}_i ( z ) - { \rho}^{\rm pin}_k ] \right\}. \label{eq : free - energy } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term in eq .
( [ eq : free - energy ] ) is the line tension term with tilt modulus @xmath20 .
the second term denotes the interaction energy of all vortex pairs on a constant @xmath15-plane , where @xmath21 and @xmath22 the inter - vortex potential .
the last term denotes @xmath18 columnar pins ( @xmath23 ) , modeled by @xmath15-independent potential @xmath24 placed on randomly distributed positions @xmath25 .
the classical statistical mechanics of eq .
( [ eq : free - energy ] ) is equivalent to the quantum mechanics of interacting bosons interacting with a potential @xmath22 in 2d with a random static potential @xmath26 .
the partition function is determined by the ground - state energy of a fictitious quantum hamiltonian @xcite . using this mapping ,
the thermal fluctuations of the 3d - vortices get mapped onto the effective quantum fluctuations of bosons in two spatial dimensions and one imaginary time dimension . in this mapping ,
the temperature of the vortex system @xmath27 plays the role of the planck number @xmath28 .
the bending energy @xmath20 of the flux lines is equivalent to the mass @xmath29 of the bosons , so that like a lighter particle , a softer flux - line can wander more .
the length of the vortices is equivalent to the inverse temperature _ of _ bosons so that in order to simulate a thick sample @xmath30 one considers the ground state of the quantum hamiltonian given by @xcite , @xmath31 where , operator @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) annihilates ( creates ) a boson at site @xmath34 , @xmath35 is the number operator and @xmath36 is the chemical potential at site @xmath34 .
@xmath37 is the measure of quantum fluctuations of bosons .
@xmath38 has two parts : a uniform part @xmath39 which fixes the flux line density and @xmath40 which represents site disorder .
the inter - vortex potential can be written as @xmath41 , with the modified bessel function @xmath42 as @xmath43 , and @xmath44 for @xmath45 .
the energy scale is set by @xmath46 , where @xmath7 and @xmath47 the london penetration depth . in the low density limit
i.e. when the inter - vortex separation ( @xmath48 ) is large compared @xmath47 , the long range part of @xmath22 dominates . in the absence of disorder , at low temperatures ,
the vortices form a triangular lattice . in the high density limit ( @xmath49 ) ,
the short ranged part of @xmath22 decides the structure and elastic properties of the flux array . in the presence of columnar pins at low density ,
individual vortices get pinned whereas at high density , vortex bundles are pinned and the system breaks up into patches of ordered regions @xcite .
we use a simplified model and describe the inter boson interaction by a hard core interaction . in the low density limit , these bosons describe individual vortices whereas in the high density limit they describe the renormalized bundles of vortices .
we fix @xmath37 to be unity and , disorder @xmath40 is introduced in two ways : ( a ) _ pinning disorder _ : attractive pins of strength @xmath1 are introduced at randomly chosen 25% of the sites , and ( b ) _ box disorder _ : random disorder potentials at each lattice site chosen either from a uniform distribution of width @xmath50 $ ] or from a gaussian distribution of width @xmath51 .
we work on a @xmath52 square lattice with periodic boundary conditions , and use exact diagonalization techniques ( such as lanczos @xcite ) to compute the ground state properties of ( [ eq : bosehubbard ] ) .
our aim is to understand the combined effects of the strong intervortex hard core interaction and columnar disorder on the phases .
the bosons described by eq .
( [ eq : bosehubbard ] ) can exist in three different phases @xcite : ( a ) kinetic energy dominated superfluid phase for bosons that is equivalent to a high temperature entangled flux liquid in the vortex problem , where flux lines are delocalised and can hop freely from one columnar pin to another .
( b ) disorder dominated bose glass phase for bosons with a vanishing superfluid density @xmath53 , that is equivalent to a bose glass vortex phase with a diverging tilt modulus @xmath54 .
( c ) interaction dominated gapped mott insulator phase for bosons corresponds to the phase when the vortex density matches the density of columnar pins in the vortex problem .
as opposed to a bg , the mi is incompressible since the vortex density remains locked to the density of pins over a finite range of external fields @xcite and behaves like a meissner phase with @xmath2 instead of @xmath55 .
on a @xmath52 square lattice , we randomly choose a fixed fraction ( say 25 % , @xmath56 ) of sites to be pins , each of strength @xmath57 . in fig .
[ fig:5 ] , we plot the superfluid density @xmath58 , which is a measure of the stiffness of the phase of the order parameter , as a function of density @xmath59 , for several values of @xmath60 .
since we work on a lattice , @xmath61 as @xmath62 , and the repulsive local interactions give rise to a mott insulator for any values @xmath1 .
in addition , for large @xmath60 , the superfluid density goes to zero at a special mott insulator point when @xmath63 ; _ the matching condition _ where each columnar pin traps exactly one vortex .
the distribution @xmath64 , of local density @xmath65 , follows a bimodal distribution , with a peak at 0 and another peak at 1 .
note that the origin of this mott insulator ( for @xmath2 ) is different from the mi obtained in the jamming limit ( @xmath62 ) .
this mott insulator can be viewed as a meissner phase for vortices at the matching field instead of zero field @xcite .
= for high @xmath1 ( say @xmath66 in fig . [ fig:5 ] ) , we note that @xmath67 implying the vortices are more entangled above the matching condition , than below .
alternatively , in fig . [ fig:6 ]
we plot binding energy per vortex defined as @xmath68 it is clear that above the matching field ( @xmath10 ) vortices are less bound by disorder than below .
so depending upon the induced @xmath69 , compared with @xmath10 , we find three phases within the bg , namely a strongly pinned bose glass ( sbg for @xmath3 ) , a mott insulator ( for @xmath2 ) , and a weakly pinned bose glass ( wbg for @xmath4 ) , consistent with ref . @xcite . in the sbg phase , vortices are collectively pinned by columnar pins @xcite , whereas in the wbg phase , one has patches of ordered regions @xcite .
it is interesting to see that calculations on such small systems , do exhibit signatures of these distinct glassy phases .
= to further illustrate the effect of disorder on the fll , we now present our results for the case where each site @xmath34 on the lattice has a random potential @xmath70 chosen from a uniform distribution of @xmath71 $ ] . in fig .
[ fig:2 ] we plot the inverse tilt modulus @xmath72 as a function of @xmath51 for a fixed density of vortices ( @xmath73 ) . for small @xmath51
, @xmath74 has a finite value ( the entangled phase of vortices ) and for large @xmath51 it tends to diverge ( the bose glass phase of vortices ) . in the thermodynamic limit
, it is expected that @xmath75 with @xmath76 in 2d , where @xmath77 is the correlation length exponent , and @xmath15 is the dynamical exponent @xcite . however , in a finite system , the transition is rounded . as an indicator of the critical disorder strength @xmath78
, we choose the point of maximum slope of @xmath79 ( shown on the dotted curve at the bottom in fig [ fig:2 ] ) . a locus of @xmath78 for different densities @xmath59 gives us the phase boundary between the superfluid and the bose glass ( see fig . [ fig:1 ] ) . for zero disorder
, @xmath58 differs from unity , which is a consequence of broken galilean invariance .
the kinetic energy per particle along the direction of the twist was shown to be an upper bound to @xmath58 @xcite .
we plot @xmath80 as a function of @xmath51 in the same figure . near @xmath81
the kinetic energy per particle is exactly equal to the superfluid density and with increasing disorder it serves as an upper bound but being a local quantity , it fails to pick up the transition@xcite .
= a quantity of interest to probe the spatial extent of the wavefunction is the inverse participation ratio defined as @xmath82 where , @xmath83 is the ground state wavefunction of eq .
( [ eq : bosehubbard ] ) . for a localized state
, @xmath84 has a finite value , whereas for an extended state , @xmath85 . in fig .
[ fig:3 ] we plot @xmath84 as a function of @xmath51 for @xmath86 and 0.50 .
@xmath85 till @xmath78 and starts rising above @xmath78 indicating localization or pinning of vortices . for high disorder , the states are localized for all densities . though it should be noted that , such a numerical scheme _ can not _ really distinguish between an extended state and a localized state with large localization length ( say for low @xmath51 ) .
the degree of wandering of a flux line transverse to its length due to thermal fluctuations , can be obtained from the properties of the ground state wavefunction @xmath87 in the mapped problem @xcite by , @xmath88 we plot the transverse wandering length per vortex in fig .
[ fig:4 ] for @xmath89 and @xmath90 . till @xmath78
, @xmath91 is constant ( almost equal to the clean case ) . for @xmath92
, @xmath91 reduces , thereby marking localization of vortices due to disorder .
= the locus of critical disorder strength @xmath78 , estimated from the behaviour of quantities discussed above as a function of @xmath51 , for various densities ( @xmath59 ) gives us the phase boundary between the superfluid ( entangled liquid ) and the bose glass ( pinned ) in the density - disorder ( @xmath93 ) plane shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] .
another measure of the critical disorder strength @xmath78 ( for a given @xmath59 ) is the disorder at which a finite fraction of _ incoherent _ sites occurs on the lattice . in a superfluid
, phase coherence is achieved due to tunneling of bosons between different sites leading to fractional occupancies on sites .
the long wavelength excitations are gapless , but due to the phase rigidity , local phase rotations cost a finite energy .
we call a site _ coherent _ if the occupancy of that site is fractional . on the other hand , at high @xmath51 , bosons are localised due to disorder . in this disorder dominated regime , local phase rotations do not cost any energy at a site which is integer occupied .
we call a site _ incoherent _ if @xmath94 or 1 , where @xmath95 corresponds to a single vortex pinned on the site @xmath34 all along its length
. a locus of @xmath96 based on the emerging of an incoherent site concurs with the phase diagram shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] . the phase diagram , is re - entrant due to particle - hole symmetry about half filling ( @xmath97 ) . at a mean field level
, it has been shown that the system becomes localized before clusters of nearly - incoherent sites percolate on the lattice @xcite .
= in this mean field theory , it is known that a bose glass can never be accessed , because , a truly incoherent site with @xmath98 can be obtained only at @xmath99 @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , by modeling the disordered boson problem as a network of random resistors , it was argued that in order to stop the flow of the current ( or destroy superfluidity ) , a line of resistors perpendicular to the direction of the flow must be cut .
in this perspective , we note that , our criterion acts as a _ precursor _ to the actual sf - bg transition .
the true sf - bg transition would lie above our @xmath78 and below the percolation transition ( @xmath100 ) described in ref .
@xcite .
the results presented above are for bounded disorder . for the case of unbounded ( gaussian ) disorder
, we find the same qualitative results as above . in some cases
, @xmath78 is marginally reduced relative to the @xmath78 for the bounded disorder , since one can get large disorder values from the tails of the distribution .
now we discuss an interesting experimental implication of our phase diagram .
we see from fig .
[ fig:1 ] that for a higher density of vortices a higher disorder strength is required to prevent entanglement and wandering of the flux - lines .
this happens because with increasing density ( @xmath59 ) , the disorder is effectively screened by vortices ( strongest attractive sites are occupied first ) and a new vortex introduced sees a weaker disorder landscape ; thus is weakly pinned .
therefore , we conjecture that , _ the transition temperature @xmath0 , for a transition from a pinned bose glass to an entangled liquid , will reduce with increasing vortex density_. = this conjecture is valid in two regimes in the @xmath101 plane . ( a ) at low fields , where the pinning energy dominates over interaction energy . for example , when the applied field is less than the matching field @xmath10 , columnar pins outnumber vortices and the pinning energy ( @xmath102 , where @xmath103 is the diameter of the columnar pin and @xmath104 the coherence length ) dominates over the magnetic repulsion @xcite .
we show this @xmath0 by a solid line in fig .
[ fig:7 ] .
the transition line we conjecture has a similar shape to the nelson - le doussal line @xcite _ above _ which point - defects play no role in deciding the structure of vortices .
the physical reasons for the origin of nelson - le doussal line and our @xmath0 are very different .
point defects promote " flux line wandering and entanglement , whereas correlated disorder inhibits " wandering and promotes localization . and
it is precisely this role of columnar pins which leads to the new @xmath0 at low fields .
( b ) at high fields , where vortex bundle pinning dominates over individual vortex pinning @xcite . in our model , since we neglect the long - range part in the inter - vortex interaction , we do not see signatures of vortex bundle pinning at high densities . for the case of vortex - bundle pinning , the screening argument would still hold , and hence the topology of @xmath0 would be the same at high fields .
= at intermediate fields , the re - entrant nose " ( shown by the dashed line in fig . [ fig:7 ] )
was predicted by nelson @xcite and has been experimentally verified @xcite .
we do nt capture this re - entrant part in our simulations since we use an approximate form of the inter - vortex potential . to conclude , we conjecture a double re - entrant phase diagram . upon decreasing the field near the nose "
the vortex liquid localises into a glass where vortex bundles are pinned due to disorder and then delocalizes again into an entangled liquid . at lower fields ,
individual vortices are pinned by columnar defects , giving rise to another disorder dominated glassy phase .
finally we note that , the bosonic hubbard model is a paradigm for studying quantum phase transitions @xcite , in systems such as @xmath105 on random substrates , superconducting disordered thin films @xcite , magnets and josephson - junction arrays @xcite . the phase diagram in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , for example is consistent with the field induced superconductor - insulator ( si ) transition observed in coupled josephson - junction arrays @xcite . in low magnetic fields , vortices at @xmath106 are pinned by disorder introduced via random offset charges . with increasing fields , the vortex density increases and at some critical density , vortices bose - condense@xcite .
this vortex superfluid leads to an inifinite resistance , giving way to an insulator .
we thank k. sheshadri , shobho bhattacharya and arun grover for interesting discussions .
an acknowledges financial support from csir , india and would like to thank the tata institute of fundamental research , mumbai for hospitality where part of this work was done .
an and dk also gratefully acknowledge partial financial support from indo - french centre for the promotion of advanced research ( new delhi)/centre franco indian pour la promotion de la recherche avance .
k. m. beauchamp , t. f. reosenbaum , u. welp , g. w. crabtree and v. m. vinokur , phys .
rev . lett . * 75 * , 3942 ( 1995 ) ; e. r. nowak , s. anders , h. m. jaeger , j. a. fendrich , w. k. kwok , r. mogilewsky and d. g. hinks , phys .
b * 54 * , r12 725 ( 1996 ) . c. wengel and u. c. tauber , phys . rev .
lett , * 78 * , 4845 , ( 1997 ) have argued that such a mott insulator phase is seen only for short range interactions and is taken over by a weakly pinned bose glass phase with finite or long range interactions .
since we consider strictly local interactions in the hard core limit we access the mott insulator .
t. v. ramakrishnan in _ order and disorder : prospect and retrospect in condensed matter physics _ , edited by v. srivastava , a. k. bhatnagar and d. g. nagule , aip conf .
286 ( aip press , ny , 1994 ) ; n. trivedi in _
computer simulation studies in condensed matter physics v _ , edited by d. p. landau , k. k. mon and h. b. schtler ( springer , berlin , 1993 ) . | we study the phase diagram of flux lines in superconductors with columnar pins . based on numerical exact diagonalisation simulations on small clusters ,
we get two phases of vortices : a low temperature pinned glass with diverging tilt modulus and a high temperature delocalised entangled vortex liquid . for random potential disorder
we find a new phase transition temperature @xmath0 from a pinned bose glass to an entangled liquid that reduces with increasing vortex density .
this occurs primarily because vortices screen the disorder potential and generate an effective weaker random potential with increasing vortex density . for a fixed fraction of randomly placed attractive columnar pins of strength @xmath1
, we find a mott insulating phase when the vortex density exactly matches the number of pins ( @xmath2 ) .
we also find a transition from a strongly pinned bose glass for @xmath3 to a weakly pinned bose glass for @xmath4 as the vortex density is varied .
0.065 in pacs numbers : 74.60.g , 05.30.j 2 |
in distributed storage systems , repair cost metrics include repair locality @xcite , repair bandwidth @xcite and disk - i / o @xcite . recently , locally repairable codes ( lrcs ) introduced by gopalan _
_ @xcite have attracted a lot of interest .
the @xmath7th symbol @xmath17 of an @xmath3 $ ] linear code @xmath4 over the finite field @xmath18 is said to have _ locality _
@xmath0 if this symbol can be recovered by accessing at most @xmath0 other symbols of @xmath4 .
coding techniques are then introduced in distributed storage systems to reduce the storage overhead , while maintaining high data reliability .
maximum distance separable ( mds ) codes can be used as erasure codes in distributed storage systems and any symbol can be recovered by accessing any @xmath19 other symbols . in order to reduce the repair costs in distributed storage systems
, the locality parameter @xmath20 is often demanded , which implies that only a small number of storage nodes are involved in repairing a failed node .
the code is called a @xmath2-ary @xmath21 lrc with all symbol locality @xmath0 or a @xmath0-local lrc for brevity if all the @xmath22 symbols have locality @xmath0 .
the singleton - like bound of the minimum distance @xmath23 for an @xmath24 lrc @xcite said that @xmath25 where @xmath26 denotes the ceiling function .
the codes meeting the above bound ( [ singleton ] ) are called optimal @xmath0-local lrcs .
various constructions of optimal @xmath0-local lrcs were obtained recently , e.g. , @xcite , @xcite-@xcite , @xcite . to the best of our knowledge ,
for a given finite field with size @xmath2 , the code length @xmath22 was not larger than @xmath2 in all the known constructions except the ones in @xcite where the minimum distance @xmath27 or @xmath28 .
cyclic lrcs were studied very recently .
goparaju and calderbank @xcite constructed new families of binary cyclic codes that have an optimal dimension for given minimum distance @xmath23 and locality @xmath0 , including @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
@xcite analyzed the locality of many traditional cyclic codes , e.g. , hamming code , simplex codes , and bch codes .
constructions of optimal cyclic codes in terms of the dimension for given distance and length over small field were discussed in @xcite .
tamo , barg , goparaju and calderbank @xcite focused on the cyclic lrcs in terms of their zeros . a class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic lrcs with length @xmath12 were then constructed by analyzing the structure of zeros of reed - solomon codes and cyclic lrcs .
they also studied the upper bound of the locality parameter @xmath0 for the subfield subcodes of cyclic lrcs , which was equivalent to estimate the dual distance @xmath31 .
when some of the @xmath0 repairing symbols are also erased , the @xmath0-local lrc can not accomplish the local repair , which leads to the concept of @xmath1-locality .
@xcite addressed the situation of multiple device failures and gave a kind of generalization of @xmath0-local lrcs . according to @xcite , the @xmath7th symbol @xmath17 of a @xmath2-ary
@xmath3 $ ] linear code @xmath4 is said to have @xmath5-locality ( @xmath32 ) if there exists a punctured subcode of @xmath4 with support containing @xmath7 , whose length is at most @xmath8 , and whose minimum distance is at least @xmath9 , i.e. , there exists a subset @xmath33\triangleq\{1,2,\ldots , n\}$ ] such that @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 . the code @xmath4 is said to have @xmath5 locality or be a @xmath1-lrc if all the symbols have @xmath1 localities . a generalized singleton - like
bound was also obtained in @xcite , which said that the minimum distance @xmath23 of a @xmath5-lrc is upper bounded by @xmath37 the codes meeting the above bound ( [ eq_generalizedsingleton ] ) are called optimal @xmath1-lrcs .
note that when @xmath11 , the notion of locality in @xcite reduces to the notion of locality in @xcite . in @xcite ,
a class of optimal @xmath5-lrcs with length @xmath38 were obtained for @xmath39 , and there exist optimal @xmath5-lrcs when @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
an algebraic construction of optimal @xmath5-lrcs with @xmath42 was proposed in @xcite based on polynomial evaluations . by studying the structure of matroid represented by the optimal lrc s generator matrix
, optimal @xmath5-lrcs were obtained in @xcite with @xmath43 .
the existence conditions and deterministic construction algorithms for optimal @xmath5-lrcs with @xmath44 were given in @xcite .
based on a known optimal @xmath5-lrc , @xcite obtained more optimal @xmath5-lrcs by lengthening or shortening . to the best of our knowledge , the existing results on cyclic @xmath5 lrcs are limited to the special case of @xmath11 or the cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs stated in the last paragraph .
there are also other generalizations of @xmath0-local lrcs , e.g. , the vector codes with locality @xcite-@xcite , and the @xmath45-available-@xmath0-local or @xmath46 lrcs @xcite-@xcite .
however , this paper will be limited to the @xmath1-lrcs .
there has been a famous problem for a long time related to the mds conjecture @xcite : for the given finite field size @xmath2 and dimension @xmath19 , find the largest value of @xmath22 for which there exists a non - trivial @xmath2-ary mds code with length @xmath22 .
although there is no answer to it up to now , the evidence seems to suggest that the largest value of @xmath22 is actually @xmath15 @xcite .
cyclic mds codes , especially the cyclic reed - solomon codes with length @xmath47 and the berlekamp - justesen codes with length @xmath15 @xcite , are among the most important mds codes .
the similar situation seems to lie in the area of optimal lrcs . as stated above ,
tamo , barg , goparaju and calderbank @xcite constructed a class of @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs with length @xmath12 based on the cyclic reed - solomon codes . in this paper , this elegant result is firstly generalized to the cases of @xmath1 lrcs . in fact
, we obtain a class of optimal cyclic @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) with length @xmath12 .
moreover , we obtain a class of new optimal cyclic @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) with longer length @xmath13 based on the berlekamp - justesen codes , while the case of @xmath11 indicates the @xmath0-local lrcs with length @xmath13 . comparing with the corresponding mds codes
, it seems difficult to obtain optimal cyclic lrcs with length larger than @xmath15 . to the best of our knowledge , in all the known optimal constructions of lrcs ,
the length @xmath22 is not greater than the given size @xmath2 of finite field @xmath18 when the minimum distance is larger than @xmath16 .
therefore , the proposed optimal constructions address the problem of constructing longer optimal lrcs restricted by the size of the alphabet , and could provide optimal lrcs with length @xmath14 greater than @xmath2 for any given finite field with size @xmath2 .
the rest of paper is organized as follows .
section ii gives some preliminaries on cyclic codes , mds codes and some results of cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs in @xcite . in section [ q-1 ] , by generalizing the construction of optimal cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs in @xcite , we construct a class of optimal cyclic @xmath5-lrcs with length @xmath47 and its factors . in section [ q+1 ] ,
we firstly give constructions of optimal cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs with length @xmath13 for even and odd @xmath2 , respectively , then further generalize them to construct a class of optimal cyclic @xmath5-lrcs with length @xmath13 .
finally , section [ conclusion ] concludes the paper .
let @xmath18 be a finite field with size @xmath2 , where @xmath2 is a prime power .
a cyclic code is an ideal of the ring @xmath48/(x^n-1)$ ] , where @xmath49 @xcite .
let @xmath50 be the order of @xmath2 modulo @xmath22 , that is , the least number of @xmath7 such that @xmath51 .
let @xmath52 be the splitting field of @xmath53 .
let @xmath54 be a primitive element of @xmath52 and @xmath55 be a primitive @xmath22-th root of unity .
let @xmath4 be a @xmath2-ary @xmath56 $ ] cyclic code with generator polynomial @xmath57 , where @xmath58 .
it is well known that every cyclic shift of any codeword of @xmath4 is still in @xmath4 and @xmath59 .
the zeros set @xmath60 of @xmath57 is called the _ complete defining set _ of @xmath4 . the next result is the well - known generalized bch bound of cyclic codes @xcite .
[ bchbound ] let @xmath4 be a @xmath2-ary cyclic code with generator polynomial @xmath57 , and @xmath61 be a primitive @xmath22-th root of unity . if @xmath57 has @xmath62 among its zeros , where @xmath63 and @xmath22 are relatively prime and @xmath64
. then the minimum distance of @xmath4 is at least @xmath9 .
the well known examples of cyclic mds codes over @xmath18 are the reed - solomon codes of length @xmath47 or its factors . based on reed - solomon codes , tamo _ et al . _
@xcite constructed optimal cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs with length @xmath12 .
roth and seroussi @xcite showed that nontrivial cyclic mds codes of length @xmath2 over @xmath18 exist if and only if @xmath2 is prime .
berlekamp and justesen @xcite introduced a class of cyclic mds codes of length @xmath15 ( @xmath65 ) , which can also be found in @xcite .
but there is a small mistake in @xcite which says that a similar construction exists for odd @xmath2 and arbitrary @xmath19 .
actually , due to the results in @xcite , when @xmath2 is odd and @xmath22 is a factor of @xmath15 , nontrivial cyclic @xmath3 $ ] mds codes over @xmath18 do not exist if both @xmath22 and @xmath19 are even .
these cyclic mds codes with length @xmath15 were the known nontrivial constructions with largest length for a given @xmath2 . although cyclic mds codes with length @xmath13 over @xmath18 can be regarded as subfield subcodes of a reed - solomon code with length @xmath66 over @xmath67 , the structure of zeros of the cyclic mds code with length @xmath13 over @xmath18 is of much interest and should be carefully divided into several cases , which is listed in detail as follows .
let @xmath68 be the extension field of @xmath18 and @xmath54 be a primitive element of @xmath68 .
let @xmath13 and @xmath69 be a primitive @xmath22-th root of unity . then for any positive integer @xmath7 ,
it is easy to see that @xmath70 .
note that @xmath71 , and for a @xmath2-ary cyclic code with length @xmath22 , @xmath72 is its zero if and only if @xmath73 is also its zero .
when @xmath2 is even , @xmath22 has to be odd and the roots of @xmath74 can be formulated as @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath77 .
furthermore , @xmath78 where @xmath79 are irreducible quadratics over @xmath18 . for any @xmath80 ,
the consecutive zeros of @xmath57 can be seen in table i to obtain @xmath56 $ ] cyclic mds codes .
when @xmath2 is odd and @xmath22 is odd , for any @xmath80 , the consecutive zeros of @xmath57 can be taken as the previous case .
when @xmath2 is odd , @xmath22 is even , and @xmath19 is odd , the zeros of @xmath74 can be formulated as @xmath81 .
furthermore , @xmath82 the consecutive zeros of @xmath57 can also be seen in table i to obtain @xmath3 $ ] cyclic mds codes .
these structures of zeros of cyclic mds codes are crucial for the constructions of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic lrcs in the following sections .
[ table1 ] .*cyclic mds codes over @xmath18 with length @xmath13 * [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ]
in this paper , we have studied the constructions of optimal cyclic @xmath1-lrcs which meet the generalized singleton - like bound ( [ eq_generalizedsingleton ] ) . inspired by works of tamo , barg , goparaju and calderbank @xcite
, we firstly generalize their cyclic reed - solomon - like @xmath0-local lrcs to the cases of @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) , and obtain a class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) with lengths @xmath12 .
then , based on the berlekamp - justesen codes , we construct a new class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs with lengths @xmath13 and a new class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) with lengths @xmath13 .
the proposed optimal cyclic lrcs with lengths @xmath13 exist only for certain parameters ( see table ii and table iii ) , it is interesting to study whether the constructions for other parameters exist or not .
related to the famous mds conjecture @xcite , one could also consider the following problem : for given @xmath2 , @xmath19 , @xmath0 and @xmath9 , find the largest value of @xmath22 for which there exist @xmath2-ary optimal cyclic @xmath5-lrcs with length @xmath22 .
the results of this paper give a step forward .
future works might also include finding more optimal cyclic lrcs with respect to other bounds , e.g. , ones given in @xcite .
i. tamo , d. s. papailiopoulos , and a. g. dimakis , `` optimal locally repairable codes and connections to matroid theory , '' in _ proc .
inf . theory ( isit ) _ , istanbul , turkey , jul .
2013 , pp .
18141818 .
n. prakash , g. m. kamath , v. lalitha , and p. v. kumar , `` optimal linear codes with a local - error - correction property , '' in _ proc .
theory ( isit ) _ , cambridge , ma , u.s.a . , jul .
2012 , pp .
27762780 .
w. song , s. day , c. yuen , and t. li , `` optimal locally repairable linear codes , '' _
ieee j. selected areas comm .
_ , vol .
32 , pp . 69256934 , 2014 .
d. s. papailiopoulos and a. g. dimakis , `` locally repairable codes , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _ ,
10 , pp . 58435855 , oct . 2014 .
a. s. rawat , o.o .
koyluoglu , n. silberstein , and s. vishwanath , `` optimal locally repairable and secure codes for distributed storage systems , '' _ ieee trans .
inf . theory _
1 , pp . 212236 , jan .
2014 .
a. s. rawat and d. s. papailiopoulos , a.g .
dimakis , and s. vishwanath , `` locality and availability in distributed storage , '' in _ proc .
inf . theory ( isit ) _ , honolulu , hi , usa , jul .
2014 , pp . 681685 . | a code is said to be a @xmath0-local locally repairable code ( lrc ) if each of its coordinates can be repaired by accessing at most @xmath0 other coordinates .
when some of the @xmath0 coordinates are also erased , the @xmath0-local lrc can not accomplish the local repair , which leads to the concept of @xmath1-locality .
a @xmath2-ary @xmath3 $ ] linear code @xmath4 is said to have @xmath5-locality ( @xmath6 ) if for each coordinate @xmath7 , there exists a punctured subcode of @xmath4 with support containing @xmath7 , whose length is at most @xmath8 , and whose minimum distance is at least @xmath9 .
the @xmath5-lrc can tolerate @xmath10 erasures in total , which degenerates to a @xmath0-local lrc when @xmath11 .
a @xmath2-ary @xmath1 lrc is called optimal if it meets the singleton - like bound for @xmath1-lrcs . a class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs with lengths @xmath12 were constructed by tamo , barg , goparaju and calderbank based on the @xmath2-ary reed - solomon codes .
in this paper , we construct a class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) with length @xmath12 , which generalizes the results of tamo _ et al .
_ moreover , we construct a new class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath0-local lrcs with lengths @xmath13 and a new class of optimal @xmath2-ary cyclic @xmath1-lrcs ( @xmath6 ) with lengths @xmath13 . the constructed optimal lrcs with length @xmath14
have the best - known length @xmath15 for the given finite field with size @xmath2 when the minimum distance is larger than @xmath16 .
shell : bare demo of ieeetran.cls for ieee journals distributed storage , locally repairable codes , singleton - like bounds , maximum distance separable ( mds ) codes , optimal cyclic lrcs . |
the model of a crystal of point - like charges immersed in a uniform neutralizing background of opposite charge was conceived by wigner @xcite to describe a possible crystallization of electrons .
these wigner crystals of electrons have much in common with coulomb crystals of ions with the uniform electron background .
the model of the coulomb crystal is widely used in different branches of physics , including theory of plasma oscillations ( e.g. , @xcite ) , solid state physics , and works on dusty plasmas and ion plasmas in penning traps ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
moreover , coulomb crystals of ions , immersed in an almost uniform electron background , are formed in the cores of white dwarfs and envelopes of neutron stars .
the properties of such crystals are important for the structure and evolution of these astrophysical objects ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
in particular , the coulomb crystal heat capacity @xcite controls cooling of old white dwarfs and is used to determine their ages ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
crystallization of white dwarfs can influence their pulsation frequencies .
it can thus be studied by powerful methods of asteroseismology @xcite .
microscopic properties of coulomb crystals determine the efficiency of electron - phonon scattering in white dwarfs and neutron stars , and , hence , transport properties of their matter ( such as electron thermal and electric conductivities , and shear viscosity , e.g. , @xcite ) as well as the neutrino emission in the electron - ion bremsstrahlung process @xcite .
many - body ion correlations in dense matter produce screening of ion - ion ( nucleus - nucleus ) coulomb interaction and affect nuclear reaction rates in the thermonuclear burning regime with strong plasma screening and in the pycnonuclear burning regime ( when the reacting nuclei penetrate through the coulomb barrier owing to zero - point vibrations in crystalline lattice ) .
the description of various nuclear burning regimes and observational manifestations of burning in white dwarfs and neutron stars are discussed in refs .
@xcite and references therein .
the manifestations include type ia supernova explosions of massive accreting white dwarfs , bursts and superbursts , deep crustal heating of accreted matter in neutron stars . since the late 1990s certain astrophysical applications have been requiring a comprehensive study of coulomb crystals in strong magnetic fields .
the topic has become important due to the growing observational evidence that some very intriguing astrophysical objects , soft - gamma repeaters ( sgrs ) and anomalous x - ray pulsars , belong to the same class of sources called magnetars ( see , e.g. , @xcite and reference therein ) .
these are thought to be isolated , sufficiently warm neutron stars with extremely strong magnetic fields
@xmath0 g. for instance , the magnetic field of sgr 180620 , inferred from measurements of its spin - down rate , is @xmath1 g @xcite .
magnetars are observed in all ranges of the electromagnetic spectrum .
they show powerful quasipersistent x - ray emission , bursts and giant bursts with enormous energy release . during giant bursts
, one often observes quasi - periodic x - ray oscillations which are interpreted ( e.g. , @xcite ) as vibrations of neutron stars ( involving torsion vibrations of crystalline neutron star crust ) .
it is likely that the activity of magnetars is powered by their superstrong magnetic fields .
thus the magnetars can be viewed as natural laboratories of dense matter in magnetic fields . in order to build adequate models of magnetar envelopes and interpret numerous observations , it is crucial to know the properties of magnetized coulomb crystals .
the main goal of this paper is to study in detail coulomb crystals in an external uniform magnetic field .
( the results reported here were partially presented in @xcite . )
the coulomb crystals in question consist of fully ionized ions with charge @xmath2 and mass @xmath3 arranged in a crystal lattice and immersed into the rigid electron background ( in this case , rigid means unpolarizable or incompressible , i.e. constant and uniform ) .
the effect of the magnetic field @xmath4 on the ion motion can be characterized by the ratio @xmath5 where @xmath6 are the ion cyclotron frequency and the ion plasma frequency , respectively ; @xmath7 is the ion number density , while @xmath8 is the speed of light .
it is expected that the magnetic field modifies the properties of the ion crystal at @xmath9 ( see , however , figs.[b - c ] and [ u1um1 ] below ) . in a strong magnetic field
the approximation of rigid electron background is a bigger idealization of the real situation in neutron star crust matter , since higher densities are required to achieve full ionization and suppress the polarizability of the electron background
. the higher densities ( and @xmath10 ) imply smaller @xmath11 .
however , the effective ion charge approximation turns out to be successful for analyzing partially ionized systems ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the quantity @xmath11 ( also equal to @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the alfvn velocity , @xmath14 being the mass density ) is , actually , independent of the ion charge .
hence , one can consider large @xmath11 in coulomb crystals at not too high densities having in mind the effective ion charge approximation . despite that
, the effect of the polarizability of the compensating electron background has to be studied separately .
the closely related problem of magnetized wigner crystals of electrons was studied in the early 1980s by usov , grebenschikov and ulinich @xcite and by nagai and fukuyama @xcite .
usov et al .
@xcite obtained the equations for crystal oscillation modes , studied qualitatively the oscillation spectrum , and diagonalized the hamiltonian of the crystal for a proper quantum description of the oscillations in terms of phonons .
in addition , the authors investigated asymptotic temperature and magnetic field dependences of the specific heat , rms electron displacement from the respetive lattice site , and magnetic moment of the crystal .
they obtained a soft phonon mode with the frequency @xmath15 near the center of the brillouin zone .
it resulted in a rather unusual low - temperature specific heat behavior ( @xmath16 ) instead of the standard debye law ( @xmath17 ) .
also , the authors mentioned the dependence of the crystal energy on the magnetic field direction as well as the increased stability of the crystal due to a suppression of electron vibration amplitudes .
in addition , usov et al .
@xcite considered the dielectric function of the crystal and studied the effect of the electromagnetic field induced by the electron motion .
their main results were , however , of semi - qualitative nature , limited to various extreme cases , whereas the present paper focuses mostly on quantitative results , pertaining to coulomb crystals of ions , with an eye to astrophysical implications .
nagai and fukuyama @xcite calculated phonon spectra of magnetized body - centered cubic and face - centered cubic ( bcc and fcc ) wigner crystals and compared the energies of these crystals at zero temperature as a function of the magnetic field .
the crystal energy was calculated as a sum of the electrostatic ( madelung ) energy , and the zero - point energy of crystal vibrations .
the effect of the anharmonic and exchange terms was neglected .
the electrostatic energy is independent of the magnetic field ( as long as the field does not alter the lattice structure ) .
the vibration energy does depend on the field because the field modifies phonon modes . at zero field
the energy minimum is realized by the bcc structure , both with and without zero - point vibrations ( in general , it is not true for polarizable background , e.g. , @xcite ) .
the authors showed that for a sufficiently strong magnetic field and at relatively high densities [ @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the standard density parameter , @xmath20 , and @xmath21 is the bohr radius , @xmath22 being the electron number density ] the full energy is minimized by the fcc structure . it is worth mentioning that the authors did not consider the dependence of the zero - point energy on the magnetic field direction and performed all calculations for a fixed direction ( along one of the high symmetry axes of the crystals ) .
however , this choice of the field direction for the bcc lattice was not optimum , as far as the lattice energy was concerned .
moreover , the energy gain obtained by choosing the optimum direction is of the same order of magnitude as the difference between the zero - point energies of bcc and fcc lattices .
nagai and fukuyama @xcite investigated an analogous structural transition between bcc and hexagonal close - packed ( hcp ) electron wigner lattices .
the hcp lattice was found energetically favorable for a sufficiently strong magnetic field at @xmath23 .
this result seems more robust since the energy difference between bcc and hcp lattices is several times larger than the energy gain obtained by choosing the optimum direction of the magnetic field in the bcc lattice ( the field direction adopted in @xcite was the same as in @xcite ) .
in addition , nagai and fukuyama @xcite described the behavior of all 6 phonon modes of the hcp lattice in the magnetic field .
also , they analyzed quantitatively the behavior of transverse and longitudinal electron displacements from the equilibrium positions for bcc and hcp lattices ( at zero temperature ) and concluded ( qualitatively ) that in strong magnetic fields the crystals became significantly more stable in the transverse direction and somewhat more stable in the longitudinal direction .
the present paper is organized as follows .
section [ eqs ] discusses equations for coulomb crystal oscillations in the magnetic field .
section [ spectrum ] focuses on the phonon spectrum of such a crystal with a simple lattice ( i.e. , one ion in the primitive cell ) .
the hamiltonian of the system is diagonalized in sec.[diag ] , which allows one to express the ion displacement operator via phonon creation and annihilation operators .
section [ thermodyn ] presents numerical calculations of thermodynamic functions of the coulomb bcc crystal for a wide range of densities , temperatures and magnetic fields . in sec .
[ crust_ex ] these results are applied to the real physical system found in magnetar crust .
section [ rms ] is devoted to an analysis of the rms amplitudes of ion vibrations and to the debye - waller factor of the magnetized coulomb crystal .
finally , sec.[moments ] considers the dependence of phonon spectrum moments on the magnitude and direction of the magnetic field .
the results will be parameterized by the quantum parameter @xmath24 ( where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are temperature and ion plasma temperature , respectively ) , and by the coulomb coupling parameter @xmath27 . in this case , @xmath28 is the ion sphere radius .
the boltzmann constant is set equal to @xmath29 .
let us consider a coulomb crystal of ions in a uniform magnetic field @xmath30 .
the lagrangian of an ion is @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the ion velocity , @xmath33 is the vector potential , and @xmath34 is the potential energy of the ion ( @xmath35 being the scalar potential ) . choosing the vector potential acting on the @xmath36-th ion as @xmath37^\alpha/2 = \varepsilon^{\alpha \beta \gamma } b^\beta u_i^\gamma/2 $ ] ( where @xmath38 is the @xmath36-th ion displacement ) , the lagrangian of the ion system can be written as : @xmath39 in this case , @xmath40 is the unit vector along the magnetic field , @xmath41 is the total number of ions , and @xmath42 is the field - free lagrangian .
introducing the same collective coordinates as at @xmath43 , @xmath44 one can rearrange the lagrangian as @xmath45 in this case , @xmath46 is a wavevector in the first brillouin zone , index l enumerates direct lattice vectors @xmath47 , @xmath48 is the number of ions in the primitive cell ( @xmath49 for simple lattices ) , and index @xmath50 goes from 1 to @xmath51 . summations in eqs .
( [ uofa-2 ] ) and ( [ aofu-2 ] ) are over all wavevectors in the first brillouin zone and over all direct lattice vectors , respectively . in the thermodynamic limit , with @xmath52 being interpreted as generalized coordinates of the system , one obtains the following euler equation : @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the dynamic matrix of the lattice at @xmath43 .
the fourier - transform @xmath55 yields the algebraic equation @xmath56 that can be solved if the ion vibration frequency @xmath57 satisfies the dispersion equation below @xcite @xmath58 due to the presence of the third term on the left - hand side , eq.([omegeuler-2 ] ) does not represent the eigennumber problem for a hermitian matrix , and the respective polarization vectors are not orthogonal .
this complicates the reduction of the hamiltonian to the sum of hamiltonians of independent oscillators .
the proper procedure will be discussed in sec .
there are @xmath59 oscillation modes for a given vector @xmath46 in the first brillouin zone .
the frequencies of these modes satisfy the generalized kohn s sum rule @xmath60 @xcite . at small @xmath61
the behavior of phonon frequencies is more complex than without the field .
it depends substantially on the direction of @xmath46 with respect to @xmath30 .
we restrict ourselves to @xmath62 .
it is possible to obtain the exact asymptotes of @xmath57 at small @xmath63 ( cf . ref .
@xcite ) . in this limit ,
the dispersion equation ( [ secular-2 ] ) can be written as : @xmath64 where @xmath65~ , \label{bb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath66 , while the coefficients @xmath67 and @xmath68 are the same as in the field - free dispersion equation @xcite : @xmath69~ , \nonumber \\ 256 \pi^2 f_0 & = & ( ka_{l})^4 [ ( \beta + \gamma_2)^2 + 2 ( \beta + \gamma_2 ) ( \gamma_1 - 3 \gamma_2 ) ( \hat{k}_x^2 \hat{k}_y^2 + \hat{k}_y^2 \hat{k}_z^2 + \hat{k}_z^2 \hat{k}_x^2 ) \nonumber \\ & + & 3 ( \gamma_1 - 3 \gamma_2)^2 \hat{k}_x^2 \hat{k}_y^2 \hat{k}_z^2]~. \label{c0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constants @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and @xmath72 characterize the crystal at @xmath43 .
they were defined and calculated in ref .
@xcite , and were recalculated for bcc and fcc coulomb lattices in ref .
they are reproduced in table [ constants ] , along with the lattice constant @xmath73 , for completeness .
the subscripts @xmath74 , @xmath75 , and @xmath76 refer to the cartesian coordinate system aligned with the main cube of the respective reciprocal lattice .
the asymptote of the smallest frequency @xmath77 at @xmath78 can be derived by dropping the @xmath79-term and choosing the smallest root of the remaining quadratic equation : @xmath80~. \label{ass - o1}\ ] ] at sufficiently small @xmath63 , @xmath81 .
then , for the phonons , propagating strictly perpendicular to the magnetic field , @xmath82 , and the phonons are acoustic .
if , on the other hand , @xmath83 , then @xmath84 at small @xmath63 , in contrast with the linear dependence at @xmath43 . as the angle between @xmath46 and @xmath30 decreases , the quadratic asymptote of @xmath77 becomes valid for wider range of @xmath63 .
neglecting angular dependences and numerical factors in eqs .
( [ bb ] ) and ( [ c0 ] ) , one can estimate the lowest phonon frequency as @xmath85 for propagation perpendicular to the field , and as @xmath86 for @xmath87 . in both cases , at @xmath88 , the mode typical energy is inversely proportional to the field strength .
@xmath89 [ constants ] the asymptote of the biggest frequency @xmath90 can be found by dropping the last term in eq .
( [ sec - ass-2 ] ) and choosing the maximum root of the remaining quadratic equation : @xmath91~. \label{ass - o3}\ ] ] at small @xmath63 this yields @xmath92 + o(k^2)~. \label{ass - o3-k0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in general , at any @xmath46 and at @xmath93 , the biggest frequency @xmath94 .
this corresponds to the conventional cyclotron ion motion .
consider @xmath95 .
then @xmath96 for phonons propagating perpendicular to the field . from the sum rule
, it follows that the intermediate frequency @xmath97 becomes 0 at @xmath95 . because @xmath98 , it is clear that @xmath99 for @xmath100 . if , on the other hand , the phonon propagates along the magnetic field , then at @xmath95 one has @xmath101 , and , hence , @xmath102
. therefore both maximum and intermediate frequency modes are optical .
as the angle between @xmath46 and @xmath30 decreases from @xmath103 to 0 , the value of @xmath97 at @xmath78 increases from 0 to @xmath104 , whereas the value of @xmath90 at @xmath78 decreases from @xmath105 to @xmath106 .
obviously , eq .
( [ sec - ass-2 ] ) can be solved analytically without neglecting any terms .
however , at very small @xmath63 analytical schemes become numerically unstable .
the thermodynamic properties of coulomb crystals at low temperatures require integration of functions containing the phonon frequencies near the center of the brillouin zone . under these conditions and especially at high magnetic fields the asymptotes given here become helpful . in natural ( a ) and logarithmic ( b ) scales
. slowly growing mode @xmath107 at @xmath108 is not shown in panel ( a ) .
magnetic field and wavevector @xmath46 orientations are defined in the text ; @xmath109 is the ion sphere radius.,height=275 ] figure [ spectinb ] shows the phonon spectrum of the bcc lattice ( in natural and logarithmic scales ) in the direction of @xmath46 determined by the polar angle @xmath110 and the azimuthal angle @xmath111 [ angles @xmath112 and @xmath35 are defined with respect to the same cartesian reference frame as the @xmath113-subscripts in eqs .
( [ bb ] ) and ( [ c0 ] ) ] .
the magnetic field is parallel to the direction from an ion towards one of its nearest neighbors ( @xmath114 , @xmath115 ) . for @xmath116 ,
analytic asymptotes discussed above are used ; at higher @xmath117 , exact calculations are performed .
one can observe the quadratic dependence of the lowest frequency on @xmath63 near the brillouin zone center .
the dependence becomes linear closer to the brillouin zone boundary ( at @xmath118 ) .
the polarization of the electron background in the absence of the magnetic field converts the optical mode with a frequency @xmath119 into an acoustic mode in the vicinity of the brillouin zone center ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the background polarization effects in a magnetized crystal will be investigated elsewhere .
a similar conversion effect can be expected in this case as well , except that one of the modes must remain optical close to the center of the zone , with a frequency @xmath120 .
this is so , because the coefficient of the @xmath121-term in the dispersion equation ( [ secular-2 ] ) , that determines the sum of the squares of all frequencies , will continue to contain @xmath122 , whereas in the field - free case at @xmath78 the @xmath121-term tends to zero for polarizable background .
in this section the hamiltonian of the coulomb crystal in the magnetic field is represented as a sum of hamiltonians of independent oscillators .
the derivation follows that of ref.@xcite , but some additional details are provided . consider the cartesian reference frame with the axes directed along the eigenvectors of the matrix @xmath123 ( again @xmath124 ) .
then the lagrangian ( [ lofagen-2 ] ) has the form @xmath125 in this case , @xmath126 is the phonon frequency at @xmath43 . omitting the constant equilibrium electrostatic energy term @xmath127 and turning to the hamiltonian @xmath128 , one has @xmath129 where @xmath130 . in the quantum formalism , @xmath131 and @xmath132
become operators with the usual commutation rules @xmath133 = i \hbar \delta^{\alpha \beta } \delta_{\bm{k}{\bm { k'}}}$ ] .
however , the operators @xmath134 and @xmath135 do not commute at @xmath136 : @xmath137 = i \hbar \omega_b \varepsilon^{\beta \gamma \alpha } n^\gamma \delta_{{\bm { k } ' } , -\bm{k}}$ ] .
consequently , the creation and annihilation operators , defined in the same way as at @xmath43 , but with @xmath134 in place of @xmath138 , do not satisfy the required commutation relationships . in this situation one constructs the creation and annihilation operators as linear combinations of the operators of generalized coordinates and momenta ( e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) , @xmath139 where @xmath140 and @xmath141 are constant coefficients ( and summation over @xmath142 is implied ) .
they can be determined from the equation @xmath143 = \hbar \omega_{\bm{k } } \hat{a}^\dagger_{\bm{k}}$ ] ( e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . using eqs .
( [ hb ] ) and ( [ anz - a+ ] ) , one arrives at @xmath144 or @xmath145 so that @xmath146 the system ( [ eq - for - al ] ) can be solved only if the quantities @xmath147 satisfy the dispersion equation ( [ secular-2 ] ) , i.e. , if they are the eigenfrequencies of the oscillation modes with the wavevector @xmath46 .
therefore , there are three possible solutions for the operator @xmath148 , corresponding to the three generally different frequencies @xmath149 , @xmath150 : @xmath151 . evidently , the equations for the coefficients @xmath152 and @xmath153 coincide .
thus from now on index @xmath46 will be omitted where possible .
the solutions of the system ( [ eq - for - al ] ) are sets of the cofactors to any of the rows of the matrix @xcite @xmath154 ( these sets are proportional to each other ) .
now one has to normalize these solutions together with the operators @xmath155 , so that @xmath156 = 1 $ ] .
accordingly , @xmath157 & = & \alpha_s^{\lambda \ast } \alpha_{s'}^{\lambda ' } i \hbar \omega_b \varepsilon^{\lambda ' \gamma \lambda } n^\gamma \nonumber \\ & + & \alpha_s^{\lambda \ast } \alpha_{s'}^{\lambda } \hbar \omega^2_{\lambda } \left ( \frac{1}{\omega_{s } } + \frac{1}{\omega_{s ' } } \right ) \nonumber \\ & = & \alpha_s^{\lambda \ast } \alpha_{s'}^{\lambda } \hbar \left ( \frac{\omega^2_{\lambda}}{\omega_{s } } + \omega_{s ' } \right)~ , \label{ort - gen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where eq .
( [ eq - for - al ] ) was employed .
now consider the following sequence of equations , @xmath158 \nonumber \\ & = & \alpha_{s'}^{\lambda}\ , \alpha_s^{\lambda \ast } ( \omega^2_{s } - \omega^2_{\lambda } ) + \alpha_{s'}^{\nu}\ , \alpha_s^{\nu \ast } \frac{\omega_{s}}{\omega_{s ' } } \ , ( \omega^2_{\nu } - \omega^2_{s ' } ) \nonumber \\ & = & \alpha_{s'}^{\lambda}\ , \alpha_s^{\lambda \ast } \left(\frac{\omega_{s}}{\omega_{s ' } } -1 \right ) ( \omega^2_{\lambda } + \omega_{s } \omega_{s ' } ) \label{aux-2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ where eq .
( [ eq - for - al ] ) was used twice ] .
thus the right - hand side of eq .
( [ ort - gen ] ) vanishes , if @xmath159 .
this property is analogous to the orthogonality condition for the polarization vectors at @xmath43 . at @xmath160 , eq .
( [ ort - gen ] ) determines the normalization of the coefficients @xmath161 : @xmath162 all the other commutators of the operators @xmath163 and @xmath164 vanish automatically . owing to the equality @xmath165 = \hbar \omega \hat{a}^\dagger$ ] and the normalization relationships obtained above
, the hamiltonian ( [ hb ] ) can be rewritten in the canonical form @xmath166 moreover , with the help of eqs .
( [ hb ] ) and ( [ anz - a+ ] ) , it is possible to prove the relationships : @xmath167 multiplying @xmath168 by @xmath169 , and @xmath170 by @xmath171 , summing over @xmath172 , subtracting the second expression from the first one , and also using ( [ o1 ] ) and ( [ o2 ] ) , one obtains @xmath173 the above formula is instrumental in calculations of such crystal properties as the debye - waller factor and the rms ion displacement from a lattice site in the magnetic field .
these results are reported in sec .
phonon thermodynamic functions in the magnetic field are calculated using the same general formulas ( e.g. , @xcite ) and numerical integration schemes ( e.g. , @xcite ) as in the field - free case .
the phonon free energy ( with phonon chemical potential @xmath174 and neglecting zero - point contribution ) reads @xmath175 } \nonumber \\ & = & v \sum_s \int_{\rm bz } \frac{{\rm d } \bm{k}}{(2 \pi)^3 } \ln{\left[1-\exp{\left(-\frac{\hbar \omega_{\bm{k}s}}{t}\right ) } \right]}~ , \label{fph}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath176 is the volume , and the integral is over the first brillouin zone .
the phonon thermal energy @xmath177 and heat capacity @xmath178 are then given by @xmath179 in the magnetic field , there are two new parameters , @xmath180 and the field direction . a study of frequency moments of the phonon spectrum in sec.[moments ] will show that the dependence of these moments on the field direction is rather weak .
this allows one to expect that the dependence of thermodynamic functions on the field direction is also weak .
thus , in the present section the consideration is restricted to the field direction , which corresponds to the minimum zero - point energy of the crystal . for the bcc lattice , it is the direction from a lattice site to one of its closest neighbors . the calculated phonon heat capacity per one ion is presented in fig .
[ b - c ] in logarithmic and linear scales [ panels ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively ] as a function of @xmath181 for several values of @xmath11 . in fig .
[ b - c](a ) one can clearly see the change of the low - temperature asymptote from @xmath17 to @xmath16 due to the appearance of the soft mode @xmath15 for non - zero @xmath4 .
also , this easily excited mode ( e.g. , at @xmath182 ) is responsible for a relatively high specific heat @xmath183 all the way up to @xmath184 . at these temperatures the field - free specific heat is already down by 6 orders of magnitude . in strong magnetic fields ,
higher temperatures are required to achieve the classical regime as compared to the field - free case .
this is so , because the classical regime occurs when many phonons are excited in _ all _ modes . in a strong magnetic field
, there is the high - frequency ( cyclotron ) mode , @xmath94 ( sec.[spectrum ] ) .
hence , the classical regime is realized if @xmath185 , in contrast to the conventional criterion @xmath186 at @xmath187 .
this is illustrated in fig .
[ b - c](b ) .
for instance , for @xmath188 the classical value @xmath189 is reached only at @xmath190 .
-@xmath4 plane .
the point , where all straight lines cross , corresponds to @xmath191.,height=275 ] the energies of three phonon modes are spaced far away from each other in strong magnetic fields .
the minimum frequency @xmath192 , the maximum frequency @xmath94 , and the intermediate frequency @xmath193 ( sec . [ spectrum ] ) .
this gives rise to the pronounced staircase structure of the heat capacity seen in fig .
[ b - c](b ) at @xmath194 and @xmath195 .
this discussion is further illustrated by fig .
[ tb - diag ] , where one can assess qualitatively the behavior of the specific heat in various domains of the @xmath25-@xmath4 plane . at high temperatures ,
the crystal is classic and the specific heat reaches its maximum value of 3 . in strong magnetic fields ( @xmath88 )
when the temperature drops below @xmath196 , the cyclotron phonon mode is frozen out and @xmath197 . as the temperature drops further , below @xmath198 , the intermediate mode @xmath97 freezes out in large portions of the brillouin zone , and the specific heat , now mainly due to the fully - excited soft mode , approaches 1 .
by contrast , in a non - magnetized ( @xmath118 ) crystal , the two lower modes deviate from being acoustic only in the very vicinity of the brillouin zone center , while the third one is @xmath199 .
hence , when @xmath25 drops below @xmath198 in such a crystal , the debye law @xmath200 is recovered .
finally , at any @xmath11 , when the temperature is so low , that only the least energetic mode contains any heat and the @xmath15 law is probed , @xmath201 behavior results .
( a ) and phonon entropy per ion ( b ) for the bcc lattice as functions of temperature for several values of the magnetic field .
inset in panel ( b ) shows @xmath202 in the linear scale at @xmath182 .
the magnetic field is directed towards one of the nearest neighbors.,height=275 ] in fig .
[ b - se ] phonon thermal energy and entropy @xmath203 are plotted . in the case of energy ,
plotted in the linear scale in fig .
[ b - se](a ) , one observes again the staircase structure .
though less pronounced , it occurs for the same reason as for the specific heat .
the classical harmonic oscillator limit @xmath204 is naturally reproduced . at low temperatures ,
the magnetic field gives rise to the @xmath205 dependence of the energy instead of the @xmath206 field - free asymptote .
for sufficiently low temperatures , the thermal energy is dominated by the zero - point energy , determined by the spectrum moment @xmath207 and discussed in sec .
[ moments ] .
the numerical calculations of the entropy are shown in fig .
[ b - se](b ) . in this case , as for the specific heat , the familiar field - free @xmath17 asymptote is replaced by @xmath16 in the quantum magnetized crystal . in the classical regime ,
the entropy depends on temperature logarithmically and is insensitive to the magnetic field .
this asymptote is discussed in some detail in sec .
[ moments ] .
when drawn in linear scale , the entropy , as a function of @xmath208 , also shows an atypical structure at @xmath88 [ inset in fig .
[ b - se](b ) ] . in this case ,
the dependence becomes piece - wise linear with several slope changes , corresponding to the sequential excitation of the three phonon modes .
clearly , magnetized crystal thermodynamics , constructed in this section , can not be described by the well - known in solid state physics debye model ( e.g. , @xcite ) . on the other hand , at @xmath88 , partial thermodynamic quantities due to the cyclotron mode @xmath90 ,
can be represented with high accuracy by the simple einstein model ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
as a practical application of the previous section results , consider fully ionized iron plasma in neutron star crust ( sec .
[ introduct ] ) .
typical values of @xmath112 and @xmath11 at @xmath209 and @xmath210 g can be estimated from fig .
[ fe - phys ] .
the curve @xmath211 shows the melting line of the classical coulomb crystal at @xmath212 .
the line @xmath213 represents typical electrostatic energy per ion ( and separates the regions of a free ion gas above the line , and a strongly coupled ion system below the line ) .
the electron degeneracy temperature is shown by dotted lines marked @xmath214 , @xmath215 , and @xmath216 for three values of the magnetic field , @xmath187 , @xmath217 , and @xmath210 g , respectively .
finally , @xmath218 and @xmath219 are the electron ground - state energies of one - electron iron ion for @xmath209 or @xmath210 g , respectively .
these energies are calculated using rescaling of equivalent hydrogen energies @xmath220 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and the fitting formula @xcite for the energy of the @xmath221 state in the hydrogen atom .
the assumption of full ionization in the degenerate plasma can be used if @xmath222 ( for a given magnetic field ) . at @xmath223 ,
the electron gas is nearly incompressible , and the rigid electron background model is very well justified . at @xmath224
the plasma can not be treated as fully ionized , but even in this case one can use present results for estimates by employing the effective ion charge approximation .
fe matter .
@xmath211 is the classical crystal melting line . @xmath225 and @xmath226 mark electron degeneracy temperature and electron - ion binding energy ( see text for details ) .
subscripts 0 , 15 , and 16 refer to the magnetic field values @xmath187 , @xmath217 , and @xmath210 g , respectively . note , that @xmath227 k.,height=275 ] figure [ iron_spec_heat ] demonstrates the phonon and electron specific heat ( per ion ) of fully ionized @xmath228fe plasma as a function of density ( a ) and temperature ( b ) at @xmath187 and @xmath229 g. the electron contribution is calculated using standard formulas for strongly degenerate relativistic fermi gas . for @xmath230 g under the displayed conditions the plasma electrons fill the lowest landau level only ; the next landau level would be occupied at @xmath231 g @xmath232 , and the plasma would become partly ionized at @xmath233 g @xmath232 ( cf .
[ fe - phys ] ) .
the temperature dependence of the electron specific heat is linear , and near coincidence of two electron lines in fig .
[ iron_spec_heat](b ) is largely accidental . for the ions to crystallize
, the temperature must be below the melting temperature , which is @xmath234 k in the density range considered ( cf .
[ fe - phys ] ) .
fe matter versus density ( a ) and temperature ( b ) at @xmath187 and @xmath235 g. for the @xmath236 case , @xmath237 in panel ( a ) ; @xmath238 k and @xmath239 in panel ( b).,height=275 ] the phonon contribution at @xmath187 , recalculated here , reproduces the results of @xcite . at @xmath240 g
the results of the present work are plotted . as seen from fig .
[ iron_spec_heat ] , phonons dominate electrons in the specific heat in a wide range of temperatures and densities .
the magnetic field provides an extra boost to the phonon specific heat , especially at lower temperatures ( in the quantum regime ) due to the easily excited soft mode .
using eqs . ( [ uofa-2 ] ) and ( [ aofa-2 ] ) , one can derive the expression for the operator of the ion displacement from its equilibrium lattice position : @xmath241 then the rms ion displacement @xmath242 can be calculated as @xmath243 [ cf .
( [ norma ] ) ] , where @xmath244 is the mean number of phonons in a mode @xmath245 .
in addition , it is possible to find the rms ion displacement @xmath246 in the direction along an arbitrary unit vector @xmath247 , @xmath248 in the field - free case , @xmath249 is isotropic ( in the bcc crystal ) , but in the magnetic field it becomes anisotropic .
-axis ( @xmath250 ) is parallel , @xmath251-axis ( @xmath252 ) is perpendicular to @xmath253 .
@xmath250 and @xmath252 are in units of the distance to the nearest neighbor .
the solid , dash - dotted , long - dashed , dotted , and short - dashed curves correspond to @xmath254 , and 0.01 , respectively .
the distance between the origin and a point on a chosen curve is equal to the rms ion displacement @xmath255 in that direction .
, height=340 ] amplitudes of ion oscillations are depicted in fig .
the ion equilibrium position is at the origin .
the @xmath256-axis is parallel to @xmath30 and to the direction towards one of the nearest neighbors .
there is symmetry in the plane azimuthal with respect to @xmath257 ( the plane perpendicular to the @xmath256-axis ) .
hence , the @xmath251-axis indicates an arbitrary direction orthogonal to @xmath257 .
the distance between the origin and a point on a chosen curve is equal to the rms displacement @xmath249 in the given direction .
the distance is expressed in units of the spacing between the nearest neighbors , @xmath258 ( for bcc lattice ) .
solid , dash - dotted , long - dashed , dotted , and short - dashed curves correspond to @xmath254 , and 0.01 , respectively .
the 6 panels of fig .
[ dw ] are for the 6 values of the quantum parameter @xmath112 , from @xmath259 to @xmath260
. the ion displacement at a different @xmath261 ( for given @xmath112 and @xmath11 ) can be found by straightforward scaling per eq .
( [ r2 t ] ) .
the quantity @xmath249 is related to the debye - waller factor @xmath262 : @xmath263 . the thermal averaging yields @xmath264}~. \nonumber \ ] ] thus , @xmath265 . as shown in fig .
[ dw ] , the ion displacements at @xmath266 are insensitive to the magnetic field ( all 5 lines merge ) and isotropic . at @xmath267
the displacement along the field remains essentially the same as at @xmath187 , whereas the transverse displacements shrink .
the net effect will be an increase of the crystal stability and melting temperature .
the anisotropy of displacements in a quantum , strongly magnetized crystal , at @xmath268 , @xmath88 , becomes much larger .
the ion displacements are strongly suppressed in the transverse direction and are mildly reduced along the field ( see also @xcite ) .
these effects are important for accurate computations of nuclear reaction rates in a strongly magnetized crust of a neutron star ( sec .
[ introduct ] ) .
the strongest effect is expected to occur at sufficiently high densities and not too high temperatures in the pycnonuclear burning regime . in that regime ( e.g. ,
@xcite ) the main contribution to the reaction rate comes from the closest neighbors in a crystalline lattice due to their zero - point vibrations . in the field - free case
, the rate depends exponentially on the squared ratio of the equilibrium distance between the closest neighbors and the average amplitude of their displacements .
the ratio is typically large , and the reaction rates are exponentially small ( but increase with the growth of stellar matter density ) . although the reaction rates in magnetized crystals have not been studied yet , one can expect a similar result , involving now the average displacement ( [ u2q ] ) in the direction of closest neighbors .
if so , the rates would become extremely sensitive to the orientation of the magnetic field .
if the field is not directed towards one of the nearest neighbors , the reactions will be significantly slowed down by greater tunnelling lengths .
even if the magnetic field is directed towards one of the nearest neighbors then , in addition to the reduction of the longitudinal displacement , there will be a geometrical effect . in a bcc lattice
every ion has 8 nearest neighbors , of which only 2 will be located along the magnetic field line .
the reactions with the other 6 neighbors will be quenched .
according to the well - known bohr - van leeuwen theorem , the classical partition function is not affected by the magnetic field . for instance , the classical asymptote of the entropy @xmath269 has the form : @xmath270 therefore , the quantity @xmath271 , where average over all phonon modes in the first brillouin zone is implied , _ should not depend _ on the magnetic field .
this statement is easy to prove directly . by inspecting eq .
( [ secular-2 ] ) one concludes that its @xmath272-term can not contain @xmath4 at any @xmath46 . on the other hand , this term is equal to @xmath273 , which proves the point .
phonon frequency moments @xmath274 depend on both the field strength and direction @xmath40 .
the moment @xmath275 diverges , while the moment @xmath276 .
consider the moments @xmath207 and @xmath277 .
their dependences on the field strength are shown in fig .
[ u1um1](a ) for the field direction corresponding to the minimum of the zero - point energy . at strong magnetic fields
both moments behave in the same way , proportional to @xmath11 , although under the effect of different modes .
the main contribution to @xmath207 comes from the mode @xmath278 , whereas the major contribution to @xmath277 is due to the mode @xmath279 ( near the center of the brillouin zone ) . and @xmath277 on the strength of the magnetic field directed towards one of the nearest neighbors .
( b ) : the dependence of phonon spectrum moment differences @xmath280 and @xmath281 on the magnetic field ( see explanation in the text).,height=275 ] the dependence of the phonon frequency moments on the magnetic field direction turns out to be rather weak . in fig .
[ u1um1](b ) the differences @xmath282 and @xmath283 are shown , where @xmath284 is the magnetic field direction towards one of the nearest neighbors , while @xmath285 is the direction towards one of the next order nearest neighbors .
the behavior of @xmath280 is of special importance because it determines zero - point energy gain @xmath286 resulting from the crystal rotation with respect to the magnetic field . in weak fields @xmath287
, the difference @xmath280 scales approximately as @xmath288 . in strong fields , @xmath280 saturates at a value @xmath289 , depending on the field direction .
the difference @xmath281 scales as @xmath290 for low magnetic fields , and as @xmath11 for strong magnetic fields .
the coulomb crystal of ions with incompressible charge compensating background of electrons in constant uniform magnetic field has been studied .
the phonon mode spectrum of the crystal with bcc lattice has been calculated for a wide range of magnetic field strengths and orientations ( fig .
[ spectinb ] ) .
the phonon spectrum has been used in 3d numerical integrations over the first brillouin zone for a detailed quantitative analysis of the phonon contribution to the crystal thermodynamic functions , debye - waller factor of ions , and the rms ion displacements from the lattice nodes for a broad range of densities , temperatures , chemical compositions , and magnetic fields .
the characteristic parameter that determines the strength of the magnetic field effects in the crystal is the ratio of the ion cyclotron frequency to the ion plasma frequency , @xmath180 .
even a very strong field ( @xmath88 ) does not alter the partition function ( hence , thermodynamic functions , melting etc . ) of a classical crystal , i.e. a crystal at a temperature significantly exceeding the energy of any phonon mode ( @xmath291 for strongly magnetized crystal ) .
strong magnetic field dramatically changes various properties of quantum crystals , especially at @xmath292 .
low - temperature phonon specific heat , entropy , thermal energy increase by orders of magnitude ( e.g. , figs .
[ b - c ] , [ b - se ] ) .
the thermodynamic functions exhibit peculiar staircase structures , brought about by the vastly different energy scales of the crystal phonon mode .
ion displacements from the equilibrium positions become strongly anisotropic ( fig .
[ dw ] ) , and so does the debye - waller factor . these results can be applied directly to real physical systems found in the crust of magnetars ( neutron stars with superstrong magnetic field ) .
in particular , the heat capacity of the magnetized coulomb crystal composed of fully ionized @xmath228fe has been analyzed ( sec .
[ crust_ex ] ) .
it has been shown that in the magnetic field ( as in the field - free case ) the phonon heat capacity dominates the electron one in a wide range of densities and temperatures ( fig .
[ iron_spec_heat ] ) . in accordance with sec .
[ thermodyn ] , magnetic field is responsible for a significant boost of phonon heat capacity , which may be important for simulations of magnetar cooling .
since ion displacements are suppressed , one can expect increased crystal stability in the magnetar crust associated with an increase of the melting temperature in the quantum regime .
finally , one expects a reduction of the pycnonuclear reaction rates due to increased tunnelling lengths .
the rates are likely to become very sensitive to the orientation of the magnetic field ( sec .
[ rms ] ) .
the dependence of thermodynamic functions on the magnetic field orientation within the crystal turns out to be weak , at least for the bcc lattice , but finite .
the energy gain , achieved by reorienting the crystal with respect to the magnetic field , can be estimated using fig .
[ u1um1 ] . | the body - centered cubic coulomb crystal of ions in the presence of a uniform magnetic field is studied using the rigid electron background approximation .
the phonon mode spectra are calculated for a wide range of magnetic field strengths and for several orientations of the field in the crystal .
the phonon spectra are used to calculate the phonon contribution to the crystal energy , entropy , specific heat , debye - waller factor of ions , and the rms ion displacements from the lattice nodes for a broad range of densities , temperatures , chemical compositions , and magnetic fields .
strong magnetic field dramatically alters the properties of quantum crystals . the phonon specific heat increases by many orders of magnitude .
the ion displacements from their equilibrium positions become strongly anisotropic .
the results can be relevant for dusty plasmas , ion plasmas in penning traps , and especially for the crust of magnetars ( neutron stars with superstrong magnetic fields @xmath0 g ) .
the effect of the magnetic field on ion displacements in a strongly magnetized neutron star crust can suppress the nuclear reaction rates and make them extremely sensitive to the magnetic field direction . |
the apparently simplest model of space - time beyond minkowski space is de sitter space .
its high ( maximal ) degree of symmetry makes it the typical framework to investigate quantum field theory outside flat space .
+ one of the essential ingredients of quantum field theory are the various green functions of the fields . for the scalar field on de sitter space ,
the first work on the subject is , in our knowledge , the paper of ghniau and schomblond @xcite .
these authors have used the harmonicity property of de sitter space , i.e. the possibility to solve klein - gordon equation by a function depending only on the geodesic distance , to obtain the expression of the pauli - jordan propagator @xmath0 .
soon after , cahen , ghniau , gnther and schomblond @xcite have obtained the expression of the analogous green function @xmath1 for the spinorial field .
their method consisted essentially to compute @xmath1 first with @xmath2 fixed at the origin of a coordinate patch , and then , to generalize the expression so obtained for an arbitrary couple of points by using parallel transport .
later , schomblond and one of the authors of this work ( ph.s ) have obtained a fock space description of the scalar @xcite , spinorial and vectorial @xcite propagators by computing them as mode sums . the main result in @xcite was that by imposing invariance conditions ( with respect to the isometries of the space ) and fixing the behaviour at short distances of the propagator , a uniqueness theorem holds .
all ambiguities about the definition of particles , expressed by arbitrary bogoljubov s transformations , are resolved . at the same time
, candelas and raine @xcite obtained a similar result using the harmonicity properties of the space to write a schwinger representation of the feynman propagator depending only on the geodesic distance and satisfying a regularity boundary condition ( imposed on the kernel of the schwinger representation ) .
+ let us emphasize that , for the massless scalar field ( @xmath3 ) , it is impossible to obtain a fully de sitter invariant vacuum state .
this result was first noticed by spindel @xcite and independently rediscovered in 1982 by vilenkin and ford @xcite .
it has been discussed in details by allen and folacci @xcite .
allen has also obtained explicitly de sitter invariant representations for the green functions of the spinorial , vectorial and gravitational fields @xcite , under the assumption a priori that these green functions could be expressed in terms of products of functions of the geodesic distance with maximally symmetric bispinors or bitensors .
+ a drawback of this geometrical construction of the green functions is that we have no information about the existence of an underlying fock space , i.e. a vacuum state such that expectations values of fields products with respect to it give the corresponding green functions .
actually , for the gravitational field , the situation is the same as for the massless spin 0 field @xcite : there exists de sitter invariant green functions , but no corresponding vacuum state .
representations of these green functions have been obtained by allen and turyn @xcite and by antoniadis and mottola @xcite . both results , which differ only by gauge choice ,
are obtained as analytic continuation of green functions built on the euclidean 4-sphere .
a direct evaluation of the gravitational propagator as mode sums in physical space ( de sitter space ) has been done by tsamis and woodard @xcite .
their construction leads to a result analogous to the one already obtained for the massless , minimally coupled scalar field : there is no de sitter invariant vacuum state for the massless spin 2 field .
+ in this note , we shall perform the calculation of the propagator for the massive spin 2 field " . more precisely , we consider the gravitational perturbation field equations introduced by lichnerowicz @xcite , which corresponds to a mixture of spin 0 and spin 2 fields . in section 2 , we summarize the field equations and remind the mode sums representations of the various propagators . in the third section ,
we specialize the field equations on ( 3 + 1 ) de sitter space and solve them explicitly on a half de sitter space .
we then obtain the propagators by summing modes . in section 4 ,
we establish coordinate - free and manifestly @xmath4 invariant representations of the propagator . in section 5,we
discuss quickly the analytic continuation of the modes and propagators on the full de sitter space .
following lichnerowicz @xcite , we write the equations of motion for massive metric perturbations " on an einstein background space @xmath5 as @xmath6 where @xmath7 ( * h * ) denotes the terms linear in the components of the tensor * h * in the expansion of the ricci tensor evaluated on the metric * g* = * g * + * h*. the factor @xmath8 on the right hand side of eq.([1 ] ) is related to a mass term as @xmath9 . this definition of mass is meaningful because @xmath10 corresponds to pure gravity . hereafter , we shall denote by @xmath11 the eigenvalues of the quadratic casimir operator @xmath12 considered by brner and drr @xcite who have used the notations @xmath13 and @xmath14 ( see eq.([46 ] ) ) . from the bianchi identities , written for the metric * g*
, we deduce that solutions of eq.([1 ] ) satisfy automatically the de donder conditions : @xmath15 in these equations , as in the rest of this paper , we have introduced the einsteinian conjugate tensor @xmath16 , and the covariant derivatives refer to the levi - civitta connection built on the metric @xmath17 which is used to lower and raise the indices .
consequently , eq.([1 ] ) is equivalent to the system constituted by eq.([2 ] ) and @xmath18 a particular solution of eqs ( [ 2],3 ) is given by : @xmath19 when @xmath20 satisfies the scalar field equation :
@xmath21 this scalar field is proportional to the trace : @xmath22 and describes the spin 0 content of @xmath23 , which is a mixture of spins 0 and 2 . + equation ( [ 1 ] ) can be derived from the lagrangian : @xmath24 which is unique , up to trivial transformations ( rescaling and addition of divergences ) . from it
we deduce the expression of a conserved current , a sesquilinear form on the space of complex solutions of eq.([1 ] ) : @xmath25 and , by integration on a cauchy surface @xmath26 , a symplectic structure : @xmath27 if @xmath28 is a complete set of positive frequency modes , labelled by the index @xmath29 , and satisfying the relations @xmath30 we may obtain as mode sums the usual green functions of the quantum field @xmath31 associated to the classical field @xmath32 .
the pauli - jordan propagator @xmath33 , defined by the commutator @xmath34 $ ] , is given by : @xmath35 while the symmetric ( often called hadamard ) propagator @xmath36 , defined as the vacuum expectation value of the anti - commutator @xmath37 , is : @xmath38 and the feynman propagator @xmath39 : @xmath40 \ ; , \label{11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath41 according as the point @xmath42 is in future or the past of @xmath2 .
the four dimensional de sitter space @xmath43 can be seen as the homogeneous coset space , i.e as the sphere of equation : @xmath44 imbedded in a five dimensional ( flat ) minkowski space @xmath45 . using the parametrization : @xmath46
the metric induced on @xmath47 reads as @xmath48 de sitter space - time is a space of constant curvature : @xmath49 , the relation between the cosmological constant @xmath50 and the radius @xmath51 of the space being : @xmath52 . on de sitter space eq.([3 ] ) becomes equivalent to @xmath53 hereafter we shall in a first step restrict ourselves to the chart @xmath54 , which covers only one half of the full de sitter space .
it is the domain corresponding to the causal past of a physical observer ( region @xmath55 on fig.1 ) .
+ to solve the system of equations ( [ 17 ] ) we have found useful to use the rescaled quantities introduced in @xcite : @xmath56 and to pass to the fourier transformed variables : @xmath57 where @xmath58 .
moreover it is natural to express these fourier components in a local frame adapted to the vector @xmath59 to this aim , we introduce the four vectors @xmath60 whose components with respect to the natural coordinate frame @xmath61 are : @xmath62 they satisfy the orthogonality relations @xmath63 we shall also make use of the projector on the spacelike directions orthogonal to @xmath64 : @xmath65 once expressed in this frame , the components of ( [ 19 ] ) split into longitudinal and transverse parts : @xmath66 conversely , the components of ( [ 19 ] ) with respect to the natural frame read @xmath67 in terms of these variables eq.([2 ] ) splits into : @xmath68 where we have denoted by dots derivatives with respect to @xmath69 and by @xmath70 the trace of @xmath71 : @xmath72 eqs ( [ 17 ] ) written with @xmath73 become : @xmath74 summing the appropriate equations ( [ 34 ] , [ 37 ] , [ 39 ] ) we recover with the help of eqs ( [ 30 ] , [ 31 ] , [ 32 ] ) the trace equation ( [ 5 ] ) written in terms of its fourier transformed variable : @xmath75 the general solution of this equation is given by a combination of hankel functions ( see @xcite ) : @xmath76 \label{41 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath77 and @xmath78^ * \ ; , \label { 43}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath79 are the usual hankel functions defined in @xcite . from eqs (
[ 4 ] , [ 5 ] ) and eq.([34 ] ) we obtain ( assuming @xmath80 , see comment after eq.([plus ] ) ):
@xmath81 where @xmath82 is the general solution of the homogeneous part @xmath83 of eq.([34 ] ) : @xmath84 \label { 45}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and here @xmath85 from these solutions and eq.([30 ] ) we obtain algebraically the @xmath86 component : @xmath87 \ ; . \label{47 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the same way eq.([31 ] ) gives immediately @xmath88 - { \lambda^2 \over 3 ( m + 4 ) } \left [ { 1 \over \lambda } \dot k - ( p^2 + { m + 3 \over \lambda^2 } ) k \right ] \ ; . \label { 48}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equation ( [ 36 ] ) is decoupled from the others .
its general solution is : @xmath89 \ ; .\label { 49 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath90 and @xmath91 are 3-vectors orthogonal to @xmath92 and @xmath93 is again given by eq.([46 ] ) .
this leads directly , thanks to eq.([32 ] ) , to @xmath94 finally it remains to solve eq.([39 ] ) for @xmath95 .
the general solution of the homogenous part is still given by a combination of hankel functions of the same index @xmath93 ( see eq.([46 ] ) ) : @xmath96 \ ; , \label { 51 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] while a particular solution can be expressed in terms of @xmath82 and @xmath70 , leading to the general solution : @xmath97 \label{52}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the integration constants @xmath98 ( and similarly @xmath99 can be expressed with the help of the projector ( [ 22 ] ) as : @xmath100 where @xmath101 is arbitrary .
this form insures that @xmath102 is transverse to @xmath64 and traceless in order to verify eq.([29 ] ) . to be complete we have still to check that the longitudinal components ( [ 47 ] , [ 48 ] , [ 50 ] ) , obtained from the divergence equations , are really solutions of the second order equations ( [ 35 ] , [ 37 ] and [ 38 ] )
they are !
now we may write a complete set of modes , solutions of eqs ( [ 2],[17 ] ) as : @xmath103 however instead of considering their natural components it is more useful to split the modes according to their spin contents .
indeed , such a decomposition leads automatically to orthogonal modes and it will just remain to normalize them .
so we shall write the general complex solution of the field equations as @xmath104\ ; \label{55}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the index @xmath105 runs over six values corresponding to the spin 0 and spin 2 content of the field ( see appendix for the explicit form of the modes ) .
if we assume that the amplitudes @xmath106 are operators obeying usual canonical commutation relations : @xmath107 & = & \delta_{ii^{\prime } } \delta ( \vec p - \vec p^{\ , \prime } ) \nonumber \\ \left [ b_i ( \vec p ) , b_{i^{\prime}}^{\dagger } ( \vec p^{\ , \prime})\right ] & = & \delta_{ii^{\prime } } \delta ( \vec p - \vec p^{\ , \prime } ) \nonumber \\ \left [ a_i ( \vec p ) , a_{i^\prime } ( \vec p^{\ , \prime})\right ] & = & [ b_i ( \vec p ) , b_{i^{\prime } } ( \vec p^{\ , \prime } ) ] = [ a_i ( \vec p ) , b_i ( \vec p^{\ , \prime } ) ] = ... = 0 \quad , \label{56}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the modes @xmath108 have to be normalized to @xmath109 . anticipating on the discussion of section v , we impose now that all modes depends only on @xmath110 functions , with their various `` @xmath111 '' coefficients equal to 1 .
this choice is compatible with the commutation relations ( [ 56 ] ) .
it results from the requirements that @xmath112 ) the green functions are de sitter invariant @xmath113 ) they have the same short distance behaviour as in flat space .
the coefficients of normalization of the modes with respect to the scalar product ( [ 9 ] ) are displayed in the appendix . inserting these modes in the general expression of the green functions ( [ 11 ] )
we obtain @xmath114 where @xmath115 \label{63}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and a similar representation for @xmath116 and @xmath117 where @xmath118 is replaced respectively by : @xmath119 \label{63b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath120 the occurrence of the factor @xmath121 in eqs([63],[63b ] ) implies that the special values of @xmath122 need a special analysis .
these values of the index of the modes correspond to eigenvalues of the laplace - beltrami operator on the 4-sphere @xmath123 , i.e. situations where the analytic continuation of the propagators built on @xmath123 onto de sitter space fails @xcite . in these cases
it does nt exist de sitter invariant states ; the invariant propagators describe expectations values of the field with respect to a density matrix .
the @xmath124 coordinates ( [ 13 ] ) cover only one half of de sitter space corresponding to the causal past of a physical observer ( region @xmath55 on fig.1 ) .
this domain is bounded by a future event horizon ( @xmath125 in eq.([13 ] ) ) and is invariant under a seven parameter subgroup of the full de sitter group o ( 4 , 1 ) .
this group is isomorphic to @xmath126 , as it is obvious from the writing ( [ 14 ] ) of the metric .
it consists of the @xmath127 euclidean motions preserving @xmath128 in eq.([14 ] ) and the dilatations @xmath129 . on this domain
we may express the green functions in terms of obviously geometrically invariant quantities .
let us consider two points ( @xmath130 ) belonging to @xmath55 and denote by @xmath131 and @xmath132 their coordinates in the embedding @xmath45 space .
the tangent vectors at the ends of the unique geodesic in @xmath55 joining them are : @xmath133 where : @xmath134 the components @xmath135 of the vector @xmath136 parallely transported from @xmath137 are @xmath138 and @xmath139 when the geodesic is a null one @xmath140 we deduce immediately from this the expression the @xmath45 components of the tensor of parallel transport from @xmath141 to @xmath82 : @xmath142 in @xmath124 coordinate , with @xmath143 , the components of these objects read : @xmath144 and @xmath145 following allen @xcite we have to consider the five invariant bitensors defined by : @xmath146 using the previous expressions of the components of @xmath147 and @xmath148 and expliciting the action of the derivatives in eqs ( [ 57 ] ) to ( [ 62 ] ) we obtain by identification invariant expressions of the green functions .
the details of the calculations are very tedious and we do nt reproduce them here . to illustrate the method , we shall consider only the case of the massive vector field .
it has been demonstrated in @xcite that the @xmath149 component ( in the coordinates system ( [ 13 ] ) ) of the feynman propagator , defined by the equation @xmath150 is given by : @xmath151\label{truc}\qquad .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] with : @xmath152 the others components are given by similar expressions ( differential operators acting on invariant functions of @xmath153 , see @xcite ) .
on the other hand , the most general maximally symmetric invariant bitensor with the same index structure as the vectorial propagator reads as the combination : @xmath154 so , the vectorial invariant feynman propagator @xmath155 can be written as : @xmath156 for some functions @xmath157 .
equation ( [ truc ] ) can be reexpressed as a function of @xmath153 and @xmath158 : @xmath159 \delta ^f _ \sigma ( p)\nonumber\\ & & = -\frac 1{r^2 m^2}\left [ 3\xi \frac d{dp}-\xi(2p-\xi-\xi^{-1})\frac{d^2}{dp^2}\right ] \delta ^f _ \sigma ( p)\end{aligned}\ ] ] thanks to eq.([p ] ) . comparing this expression with the @xmath160 component of eq.([combi ] ) ,
in which the terms are grouped together according to their powers of @xmath161 , we may identify the coefficients @xmath162 and @xmath163 of the decomposition : @xmath164 \delta ^f _ \sigma ( p ) \quad,\\ \beta ( p)&=&\frac 1{m^2r^2}\left [ 3(1-p)\frac d{dp}+(1-p^2)\frac{d^2}{dp^2}\right ] \delta ^f _ \sigma ( p ) \quad,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and possibly use the other components of the propagator to check the results .
they are in agreement with those given in @xcite . + + a similar calculation involving only two types of components : @xmath165 allows to determine the invariant form of the propagator : @xmath166 with : + + @xmath167 \delta _ \nu ^f - p\left [ 2(m+6)(p^2 - 1)+8\right]\delta _
\nu ^{f\prime}}{2(p^2 - 1)}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \left .
+ \frac{\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(m^2 + 5m+9)-m\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^f+\left [ p(p^2 - 1)(2m+3)-4p\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^{f\prime}}{p^2 - 1}\right\}\\ \beta ( p ) & = & \frac 2{3(m+4)(m+6 ) } \cdot \nonumber \\ & & \left\ { \frac{-(m+6)\left [ ( m+8)(p^2 - 1)-20p-28\right ] \delta
_ \nu ^f+\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(2p(m+6)+10(m+2))-112p-80\right ] \delta _ \nu ^{f\prime}}{p^2 - 1}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left
. + \frac{\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(m^2 - 16m)-2m(10p+14)\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^f+\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(8mp-48p+4m-64)-80 - 112p\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^{f\prime}}{p^2 - 1}\right\ } \nonumber\\ \\ \gamma ( p ) & = & \frac 2{3(m+4)(m+6)}\left\ { \frac{(m+6)\left [ 3(p^2 - 1)(m+8)-4\right ] \delta _
^f+\left [ ( p^2 - 1)6p(m+6)-16p\right ] \delta _
\nu ^{f\prime}}{4(p^2 - 1)}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \left.-\frac{m\delta _ { \nu _ 0}^f+4p \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^{f\prime}}{p^2 - 1}\right\}\\ \delta ( p ) & = & \frac{2\,\varepsilon(p^2 - 1)}{3(m+4)(m+6)}\left\ { \frac{-(m+6)\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(m+8)+12\right ] \delta _
\nu ^f-\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(m+6)2p+48p\right ] \delta _
\nu ^{f\prime}}{2(p^2 - 1)}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \qquad \qquad \qquad \qquad \left.+\frac{m\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(m-1)-6\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^f+p\left [ ( p^2 - 1)5m-24\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^{f\prime}}{p^2 - 1}\right\}\\ \epsilon ( p ) & = & \frac{2\,\varepsilon(p^2 - 1)}{3(m+4)(m+6)}\cdot \nonumber\\ & & \left\ { \frac{(m+6)\left [ 3(p^2 - 1)(m+8)-20p-4\right ] \delta _ \nu ^f+\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(6p(m+6)+10(m+2))-16(p+5)\right ] \delta _
\nu ^{f\prime}}{4(p^2 - 1)}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left.+\frac{-m(1 + 5p)\delta _ { \nu _ 0}^f+\left [ ( p^2 - 1)(m-16)-4(p+5)\right ] \delta _ { \nu _ 0}^{f\prime}}{p^2 - 1}\right\}\nonumber\\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath168
in ref @xcite we have shown that the green s functions of the scalar field equation on the domain @xmath169 : @xmath170 can be written as a superpositions of modes expressed in terms of hankel functions : @xmath171 e^{i \vec p. \vec
x } \nonumber \\ \nu_0&= & i \sqrt{m^2 r^2 - { 9 \over 4 } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath172 the last conditions resulting from the normalisation condition @xmath173 these conditions are not sufficient to fix the vacuum ( the positive frequency modes ) .
if we impose the vacuum to be invariant with respect to the 7-parameter isometry group of @xmath169 , extra ( necessary ) conditions appear .
the coefficients @xmath174 and @xmath175 have to be constant .
the resulting green functions still depend on three parameters .
definite values of these parameters are obtained by imposing that the short distance singularities of the feynman propagator are the same as in flat space : @xmath176 then one obtains : @xmath177 because the phase of @xmath111 becomes irrelevant .
the feynman propagator for @xmath178 , is given by : @xmath179 while for @xmath180 one obtains @xcite : @xmath181 \nonumber \\ & & - { i \over 4 \pi r^2 } \varepsilon ( \lambda - \lambda^\prime ) ( \delta ( p - 1 ) + \theta ( p - 1))\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is only @xmath182 invariant . we plan to discuss the physical significance of this choice of modes in a forthcoming publication @xcite .
up to now , all the expressions of the modes that we have considered where defined only on @xmath55 .
if we extend the definition of @xmath69 and @xmath183 by eq.([13 ] ) on the full de sitter space ( excepted on the horizon @xmath184 , i.e. the 3-surface @xmath185 ) we may analytically continue the modes by considering the behaviour of a wave packet near @xmath184 .
typically , such wave packet behaves as : @xmath186 the kirchoff ( poisson ) formula giving the solution of the massless scalar wave equation in flat space insures that this expression remains finite on the horizon , despite the presence of the divergent factor @xmath187 .
the continuation of the modes across the horizon is obtained by looking in the region @xmath188 which combination of hankel functions have an asymptotic expansion that matches with the one used in eq.([wp ] ) .
this leads us immediately to an expression of the modes valid on the full de sitter space : @xmath189 \frac { e^{i \vec p. \vec
x}}{(2\pi)^{\frac 3 2 } } \ ; . \end{aligned}\ ] ] inserting this expressions of modes in integrals like those considered in eqs ( [ 63 ] , [ 63b ] ) , we conclude that the expression ( [ 76 ] ) is valif on whole de sitter space , with @xmath153 still given by eq.([p ] ) whatever are the signs of @xmath190 and @xmath191 note that the region @xmath192 is isometric to @xmath55 but with time running in the opposite way .
this is in accord with the fact that it is precisely the hankel function @xmath193 which is coupled to @xmath194 , these two functions being of opposite frequences on both @xmath55 and @xmath195 . finally ,
note also that by the continuation @xmath196 we obtain invariant expressions of green functions on anti - de sitter space .
we would like to thank r.brout , c. de mol , r. parentani and s. massar for helpful discussions during the elaboration of this paper .
one of us ( cl.g . ) would like to thank the universit de mons - hainaut and the fonds national de la recherche scientifique for financial support .
we have collected in this appendix the explicit expressions of the modes we have used to obtain the propagators .
they are expressed for each @xmath64 in the base @xmath197 .
they read as : where : @xmath198 these modes are orthogonal for the scalar product ( [ 9 ] ) . in order that they satisfy the orthonormalization condition ( [ 10 ] ) , their coefficients must be chosen , up to a phase , as : @xmath199 zzzz ghniau j. and schomblond ch . , acad .
, * liv * , @xmath200 srie , 1147 , ( 1968 ) cahen m. , ghniau j. , gnther m. , schomblond ch .
i.h.p . , * xiv * , a,4 , 325 , ( 1971 ) schomblond ch . , spindel ph . ,
ann . i.h.p.,*xxv * , 1 , 67 , ( 1976 ) schomblond ch . ,
spindel ph .
belg . , cl .
des sc.,*lxii * , @xmath201 srie , 124 , ( 1976 - 2 ) candelas p. , raine d.j .
d*12 * , 4 , 965 , ( 1975 ) spindel ph . , _ quantification des champs en relativit gnrale _ , phd thesis , universit de letat mons , ( 1978 ) vilenkin a. , ford l.h . ,
rev . d*26 * , 6 , 1231 , ( 1982 ) allen b. , phys .
rev . d*32 * , 12 , 3136 , ( 1985 ) allen b. , folacci a. , phys .
rev . d*35 * , 12 , 3771 , ( 1987 ) allen b. , jacobson th .
, commun . math .
phys.*103 * , 669 , ( 1986 ) allen b. , lutken c.a . ,
phys.*106 * , 201 , ( 1986 ) allen b. , turyn m. , nucl .
b*292 * , 813 , ( 1987 ) allen b. , phys .
rev . d*34 * , 12 , 3670 , ( 1986 ) antoniadis i. , mottola e. , j. math.phys.*32 * , 4 , 1044 , ( 1991 ) tsamis n.c . ,
woodard r.p .
phys.*162 * , 217 , ( 1994 ) lichnrowicz a. , _ propagateurs , commutateurs et anticommutateurs en relativit gnrale _ , in relativity ,
groups and topology , eds b. dewitt and c. dewitt , gordon and breach , new york , 823 , ( 1963 ) brner g. , drr h.p .
, nu.cim , * lxiv * a , 3 , 669 , ( 1969 ) abramowitz m. , stegun i.a . , handbook of mathematical functions , dover publications , inc .
new york , 358 , ( 1972 ) gabriel c. , spindel ph . , physical significance of de sitter vacua ( in preparation ) hawking s.w . and
ellis g.f.r . ,
_ the large scale structure of space - time _ , sec . * 5.2 * , cambridge university press , cambridge , ( 1973 )
penrose diagram of de sitter space @xcite .
region @xmath55 ( @xmath54 ) corresponds to the causal past of observers @xmath202 .
their common future event horizon @xmath203 is the boundary of the two coordinate patches @xmath204 .
dashed lines represent @xmath205 world lines . | we compute the pauli - jordan , hadamard and feynman propagators for the massive metrical perturbations on de sitter space .
they are expressed both in terms of mode sums and in invariant forms .
october 1996 umh - mg-96/01 3.cm * massive spin 2 propagators on + de sitter space * 27.mm cl .
gabriel , ph .
spindel + 1 cm _
mcanique et gravitation _
+ _ universit de mons - hainaut _ ,
+ _ 15 , avenue maistriau , b-7000 mons , belgium _ 1 cm 3 cm pacs : 04.62 + v |
while properties and origin of the au - scale structure in the cold neutral medium ( cnm ) are still under debate , a possibly related new population of cnm clouds has been dicovered recently . using the westerbork radio telescope ,
braun & kanekar ( 2005 ) detected very weak hi absorption lines toward three high - latitude sources .
along each line of sight multiple absorption lines were detected , with the peak optical depth of only 0.1 to 2% .
stanimirovic & heiles ( 2005 ) used the arecibo telescope to confirme the existence of these low - optical - depth cnm clouds in directions of two of the sources .
they also emphasized that these clouds have hi column densities among the lowest ever detected for the cnm , @xmath2 @xmath1 .
we will therefore call these clouds the ` low-@xmath3(hi ) ' clouds
. how atypical are low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds ? from the theoretical point of view , the traditional cnm clouds have a typical size of 2 pc and @xmath4 @xmath1 , the lowest expected column density being @xmath5 @xmath1 ( mckee & ostriker 1977 ) . from an observational point of view
, the recent survey by heiles & troland ( 2003 , ht03 ) suggested a typical @xmath6 @xmath1 for cnm clouds .
while column densities of low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds are 3050 times lower than theoretical and observational expectations , these densities are close to what is measured for the tiny scale atomic structure ( tsas ) , @xmath7 to @xmath8 @xmath1 ( heiles , sins ) . in figure
[ f : size_density ] we illustrate graphically how low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds compare with tsas and cnm clouds by plotting the typical linear size and hi volume density for these three types of objects .
low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds occupy the region in this diagram between tsas and cnm clouds , the regime that is currently observationally probed only with optical observations of globular clusters ( e.g. meyer & lauroesch 1993 ) . in this contribution
we focus on two particular questions regarding the low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds : ( 1 ) how common are these clouds in the ism , and ( 2 ) how are these clouds related to the traditional spectrum of cnm clouds ? in section [ s : obs ] we summarize our recent search for the low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds with the arecibo telescope .
we describe our results in section [ s : results ] and discuss physical mechanisms responsible for the production of low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds in section [ s : discussion ]
to search for new low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds we have recently obtained hi emission and absorption spectra in the direction of 22 continuum sources with the arecibo radio telescope .
about half of the sources were chosen from ht03 as being without detectable cnm after @xmath9 minutes of integration , the remaining sources were selected from catalogs by dickey et al .
( 1978 ) and crovisier et al .
none of the sources in our sample had previously detected cnm .
the observing strategy was the same as in ht03 and stanimirovic & heiles ( 2005 ) , however the integration time per source was significantly longer ( 1 to 4.5 hours ) .
the final velocity resolution of hi spectra is 0.16 .
the final rms noise level in the absorption spectra is @xmath10 over 0.5 channels . for sources with newly - detected cnm we used the technique developed by ht03 to estimate the spin temperature .
however , this technique turns out to be unreliable for our data as most of the cnm clouds have a very low optical depth and occupy a solid angle significantly smaller than the arecibo beam . for cnm features presented in this paper we have chosen @xmath11 .
this is a safe assumption that probably over - estimates our @xmath12 as ht03 found that majority of their cnm clouds had @xmath13 .
out of 22 sources in this study 10 show clear cnm features , and in many cases multiple lines along the line of sight were detected . in total , we have detected at least 18 new cnm features with the peak hi optical depth in the range @xmath14 to @xmath15 . _
the detection rate in this experiment is surprisingly high , suggesting that clouds with low optical depth are quite common in the ism . _
figure [ f:3c ] shows hi emission and absorption spectra for two sources in our survey , 3c264.0 ( left ) and 3c190.0 ( right ) . for each source ,
the top and bottom panels show the hi emission and absorption spectra .
we detected two cnm clouds in the case of 3c264.0 and one cloud in the case of 3c190.0 .
the peak optical depth is @xmath16 and @xmath17 for clouds in the direction of 3c264.0 , and @xmath15 for the cloud in the direction of 3c190.0 .
the velocity fwhm for the three clouds is 3.5 , 1.5 , and 1.4 , respectively .
clearly , these are cold hi clouds , with @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 @xmath1 , respectively .
the hi peak brightness temperature in these directions is only about 2.5 k and @xmath21 k , with the total @xmath3(hi ) being @xmath22 @xmath1 and @xmath23 @xmath1 , respectively .
the ratio of the cnm to total hi column density , @xmath24 is only about 5% and @xmath25% , respectively . in total
, our current sample has 21 low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds : 18 from this study , and three from stanimirovic & heiles ( 2005 ) .
two thirds of the clouds have @xmath26 @xmath1 . in comparison
, ht03 had 20 clouds with @xmath26 @xmath1 out of 143 cnm components . in comparison to the millennium survey by ht03
, we have almost doubled the number of clouds in the lowest column density bin .
the median properties for the whole population are : @xmath27 , fwhm=2.4 , and @xmath28 @xmath1 .
the next obvious question to ask is how do low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds relate to cnm clouds with higher column densities ?
heiles & troland ( 2005 ) investigated statistical properties of the cnm components detected in their millennium survey and found that the probability distribution of the cnm column density closely follows @xmath29 over two orders of magnitude , from @xmath30 @xmath1 to @xmath31 @xmath1 .
we have added column densities of our 21 low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds to @xmath32 from heiles & troland ( 2005 ) and the resultant histogram is shown in figure [ f : pdf ] .
the solid line in this figure represents the @xmath29 fit obtained by slightly extending the lower limit to @xmath33 @xmath1 .
surprisingly , a single function fits well both sets of objects .
this suggests that low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds may not belong to a separate class of interstellar clouds , but could simply be _ the low column density extension of the cnm population_. in figure 4 we show @xmath34 vs @xmath35 for all cnm components found in the ht03 survey ( shown with triangles and crosses ) and in our survey ( circles ) .
ht03 noticed that cnm clouds in their survey followed almost a linear trend up to about @xmath36 @xmath1 , while sources without the cnm clearly stood out as a potentially distinct class of objects .
most low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds have @xmath37% which is suggestive of the cnm being embedded in large warmer envelopes that contain most of the hi and provide a protection against evaporation .
if we assume that low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds are at the standard ism pressure of @xmath38 k @xmath39 , then their estimated hi volume density is @xmath40100 @xmath39 .
the line - of - sight size of these clouds is then given by @xmath414000 au .
if the clouds are however overpressured and @xmath42 k , then @xmath434000 au , even closer to the traditional tsas . in any case , low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds are most likely small , with sizes in the range of a few hundreds to a few thousands of aus .
this is larger than the ` canonical ' tsas but still significantly smaller than the traditional pc - size cnm clouds .
another constraint on cloud sizes comes from direct interferometric imaging by braun & kanekar ( 2005 ) who reported hi emission clumps with sizes of @xmath44 au . in any case
, it appears that low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds could be an extension of the traditional population of cnm clouds , bridging the gap between cnm clouds and tsas .
physical mechanisms responsible for the production of cold clouds with very low column densities are not well understood .
there are three potentially interesting theortical avenues that await a closer comparison with observations .
_ conductive heat transfer _ occurs between the cnm and their surrounding warmer medium , forming an interface region through which heat flows between the two phases . in the case of the least intrusive interface , cnm to wnm with the intercloud temperature of @xmath45 k , the expected lower limit on the column density of the interface region
is quite low , @xmath46 @xmath1 ( mckee & cowie 1977 ) . in this case the expected critical radius for cnm clouds ( at which clouds are stable and neither evaporate nor condense ) is @xmath47 au .
cnm clouds smaller than @xmath48 evaporate but are surprisingly long - lived , their typical evaporation timescale is of order of @xmath49 yr ( see stanimirovic & heiles 2005 for details ) .
similar timescales were reached recently by nagashima , inutsuka , & koyama ( 2006 ) based on 1-d numerical simulations .
our low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds have sizes below the critical cloud radius even in the case of the least - intrusive wnm .
these cnm clouds , protected from ionization by large wnm envelopes , should be evaporating but over long timescales , and hence could be common in the ism .
_ condensation of wnm into cnm triggered by the collision of turbulent flows _ is capable of producing a large number of small cnm clouds with low column densities , as seen in simulations by audit & hennebelle ( 2005 ) and hennebelle ( 2006 , sins ) .
the cnm clouds produced in simulations are thermally stable and embedded in large , unstable wnm filaments , their typical properties are : @xmath50 @xmath39 , @xmath51 k , @xmath52 pc .
the number of cold clouds , as well as their properties , depend heavily on the properties of the underlying turbulent flows . _
general ism turbulence _ envisions interstellar clouds as dynamic entities that are constantly changing in response to the turbulent `` weather '' , a picture very different from the traditional approach . numerical simulations of turbulent ism , for example vazquez - semadeni , ballesteros - paredes , & rodriguez ( 1997 ) show a lot of clouds with very small sizes and low column densities ( @xmath53 @xmath1 ) .
these clouds are out of dynamical equilibrium and probably very transient
. _ cnm destruction by shocks _ in simulations by nakamura et al .
( 2005 ) can also produce a spray of small hi ` shreds ' that could be related to low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds .
these shreds have large aspect ratios , up to 2000 , but further comparison with observations awaits inclusion of magnetic field .
the cnm clouds with @xmath54 @xmath1 are easily and frequently detected with deep radio integrations .
these clouds are very thin along the line of sight , @xmath554000 au , and could be related to tsas .
they are evaporating very fast , unless being surrounded by a lot of mild wnm , @xmath56 k , in which case could last for up to @xmath25 myr .
the cnm fraction relative to the total hi column density also supports the existence of large wnm ` envelopes ' which contribute up to 95 - 99% of the total @xmath3(hi ) .
the combined histogram of @xmath12 for ` classic ' cnm clouds and low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds can be fitted with a single function , @xmath57 .
this suggests that low-@xmath3(hi ) clouds are , most likely , a low column density extension of the cnm cloud population . | we have obtained deep hi observations in the direction of 22 continuum sources without previously detected cold neutral medium ( cnm ) .
18 cnm clouds were detected with the typical hi column density of @xmath0 @xmath1 .
our surprisingly high detection rate suggests that clouds with low hi column densities are quite common in the interstellar medium .
these clouds appear to represent an extension of the traditional cnm cloud population , yet have sizes in hundreds to thousands of aus .
we present properties of the newly - detected cnm sample , and discuss several theoretical avenues important for understanding the production mechanisms of these clouds . |
blazars are radio - loud active galactic nuclei characterized by polarized , highly luminous , and rapidly variable non - thermal continuum emission ( angel & stockmann 1980 ) from a relativistic jet oriented close to the line of sight ( blandford & rees 1978 ) . as such ,
blazars provide fortuitous natural laboratories to study the jet processes and ultimately how energy is extracted from the central black hole . the radio through gamma - ray spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of blazars exhibit two broad humps ( figure 1 ) .
the first component peaks at ir / optical in `` red '' blazars and at uv / x - rays in their `` blue '' counterparts , and is most likely due to synchrotron emission from relativistic electrons in the jet ( see ulrich , maraschi , & urry 1997 and references therein ) .
the second component extends from x - rays to gamma - rays ( gev and tev energies ) , and its origin is less well understood .
a popular scenario is inverse compton ( ic ) scattering of ambient photons , either internal ( synchrotron - self compton , ssc ; tavecchio , maraschi , & ghisellini 1998 ) or external to the jet ( external compton , ec ; see bttcher 1999 and references therein ) . in the following discussion i will assume the synchrotron and ic scenarios , keeping in mind , however , that a possible alternative for the production of gamma - rays is provided by the hadronic models ( proton - induced cascades ; see rachen 1999 and references therein ) .
red and blue blazars are just the extrema of a continuous distribution of seds .
this is becoming increasingly apparent from recent multicolor surveys ( laurent - muehleisen et al .
1998 ; perlman et al . 1998 ) , which find sources with intermediate spectral shapes , and trends with bolometric luminosity were discovered ( sambruna , maraschi , & urry 1996 ; fossati et al . 1998 ) . in the more luminous red blazars the synchrotron and ic peak frequencies are lower , the compton dominance ( ratio of the synchrotron to ic peak luminosities ) is larger , and the luminosity of the optical emission lines / non - thermal blue bumps is larger than in their blue counterparts ( sambruna 1997 ) .
a possible interpretation is that the different types of blazars are due to the different predominant electrons cooling mechanisms ( ghisellini et al .
1998 ) . in a simple homogeneous scenario , the synchrotron peak frequency @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the electron energy determined by the competition between acceleration and cooling .
because of the lower energy densities , in lineless blue blazars the balance between heating and cooling is achieved at larger @xmath1 , contrary to red blazars , where , because of the additional external energy density , the balance is reached at lower @xmath1 .
blue blazars are ssc - dominated , while red blazars are ec - dominated . while there are a few caveats to this picture ( urry 1999 ) , the spectral diversity of blazars jets can not be explained by beaming effects _ only _ ( sambruna et al .
1996 ; georganopoulos & marscher 1998 ) , but require instead a change of physical parameters and/or a different jet environment .
correlated multiwavelength variability provides a way to test the cooling paradigm since the various synchrotron and ic models make different predictions for the relative flare amplitudes and shape , and the time lags .
first , since the same population of electrons is responsible for emitting both spectral components ( in a homogeneous scenario ) , correlated variability of the fluxes at the low- and high - energy peaks with no lags is expected ( ghisellini & maraschi 1996 ) .
second , if the flare is caused by a change of the electron density and/or seed photons , for a fixed beaming factor @xmath2 the relative amplitudes of the flares at the synchrotron and ic peaks obey simple and yet precise relationships ( ghisellini & maraschi 1996 ; see however bttcher 1999 ) .
third , the rise and decay times of the gamma - ray flux are a sensitive function of the external gas opacity and geometry in the ec models ( bttcher & dermer 1998 ) .
fourth , the rise and decay times of the synchrotron flux depend on a few source typical timescales ( chiaberge & ghisellini 1999 ) .
fifth , spectral variability accompanying the synchrotron flare ( in x - rays for blue blazars , in optical for red blazars ) is a strong diagnostic of the electron acceleration versus cooling processes ( kirk , riegler , & mastichiadis 1998 ) .
when cooling dominates , time lags between the shorter and longer synchrotron wavelengths provide an estimate of the magnetic field @xmath3 ( in gauss ) of the source via @xmath4 ( takahashi et al . 1996 ; urry et al .
1997 ) .
* the role of rxte . * with its wide energy band coverage ( 2250 kev ) , rxte plays a crucial role in monitoring campaigns of blazars , since it probes the region where the synchrotron and compton component overlap in the seds ( figure 1 ) , allowing us to quantify their relative importance in the different sources .
its high time resolution and good sensitivity are ideal to detect the smallest x - ray variability timescales , study the lags between the harder and softer x - rays , and to follow the particle spectral evolution down to timescales of a few hours or less , pinning down the microphysics of blazars jets .
one of the best monitored red blazars is 3c279 . from the simultaneous or contemporaneous seds in figure 1a ,
it is apparent that the largest variations are observed above the synchrotron peak in ir / optical ( not well defined ) and the compton peak at gev energies , supporting the synchrotron and ic models .
the gev amplitude is roughly the square of the optical flux during the earlier campaigns , supporting an ssc interpretation ( maraschi et al .
1994 ) or a change of @xmath2 in the ec models , while in 1996 large variations were recorded at gamma - rays but not at lower energies ( wehrle et al .
1998 ) . during the latter campaign
, the rapid decay of the gev flare ( figure 2a ) favors an ec model ( bttcher & dermer 1998 ; wehrle et al .
note in figure 2a the good correlation , within one day , of the egret and rxte flares , which provides the first evidence that the gamma - rays and x - rays are cospatial ( wehrle et al . 1998 ) .
= 7.5 cm = 7.5 cm another candidate for future gamma - ray monitorings is bl lac itself . in 1997
july it underwent a strong flare at gev and optical energies ( bloom et al .
the gamma - ray light curve shows a strong flare possibly anticipating the optical by up to 0.5 days ; however , the poor sampling does not allow firmer conclusions .
contemporaneous rxte observations showed a harder x - ray continuum ( madejski et al .
1999 ) than in previous asca measurements .
the sed during the outburst is best modeled by the ssc model from radio to x - rays , while an ec contribution is required above a few mev ( sambruna et al .
1999a ) . a similar mix of ssc and ec is also required to fit the seds of pks 0528 + 134 ( sambruna et al .
1997 ; mukherjee et al .
1998 ; ghisellini et al . 1999 ) .
mrk 501 , one of the two brightest tev blazars , attracted much attention in 1997 april when it underwent a spectacular flare at tev energies ( catanese et al .
1997 ; aharonian et al .
1999 ; djannati - atai et al .
this was correlated to a similarly - structured x - ray flare observed with rxte ( figure 2b ) , with no delay larger than one day ( krawczynski et al .
these results are consistent with an ssc scenario where the most energetic electrons are responsible for both the hard x - rays ( via synchrotron ) and the tev ( via ic ) .
figure 1b shows the seds of mrk 501 during the 1997 april tev activity , compared to the `` quiescent '' sed from the literature .
an unusually flat ( photon index , @xmath5 ) x - ray continuum was measured by sax and rxte during the tev flare ( pian et al .
1998 ; krawczynski et al . 1999 ) , implying a shift of the synchrotron peak by more than two orders of magnitude .
this almost certainly reflects a large increase of the electron energy ( pian et al .
1998 ) , or the injection of a new electron population on top a quiescent one ( kataoka et al .
later rxte observations in 1997 july found the source still in a high and hard x - ray state ( lamer & wagner 1998 ) , indicating a persistent energizing mechanism . an interesting new behavior was observed during our latest 2-week rxte - hegra monitoring of mrk 501 in 1998 june ( sambruna et al .
1999b ) , when 100% overlap between the x - rays and tev light curves was achieved ( figure 3a ) .
a strong short - lived ( @xmath6 two days ) tev flare was detected , correlated to a flare in the very hard ( 2050 kev ) x - rays , with the softer x - rays being delayed by up to one day . as in 1997 , large x - ray spectral variations are observed , with the x - ray continuum flattening to @xmath7 at the peak of the tev flare , implying a similar shift to @xmath8 50 kev of the synchrotron peak ( figure 3b ) .
however , while in 1997 the tev spectrum hardened during the flare ( djannati - atai et al .
1997 ) , as it did in the x - rays , we did not observe significant variability in the tev hardness ratios during the flare ( figure 3a , panel ( e ) ) ; instead the spectrum softens 1 - 2 days later .
the correspondence between the x - ray and tev spectra is no longer present during the 1998 june flare .
x - ray monitorings of blue blazars are a powerful diagnostic of physical processes occurring in these sources . this is because in these objects the x - rays are the high - energy tail of the synchrotron component where rapid and complex flux and spectral variability is expected depending on the balance between escape , acceleration , and cooling of the emitting particles ( kirk et al .
1998 ) .
an ideal target for x - ray monitorings is pks 2155304 , one of the brightest x - ray blazars ( treves et al . 1989 ; sembay et al .
1993 ; pesce et al .
interest in this source was recently revived due to a tev detection ( chadwick et al .
1999 ) during a high x - ray state ( chiappetti et al .
asca and sax observations detected strong x - ray variability , with the softer energies lagging the harder energies by one hour or less ( chiappetti et al .
1999 ; kataoka et al . 1999b ; zhang et al .
1999 ) , and are consistent with a model where the electron cooling dominates the flares .
this implies magnetic fields of @xmath9 gauss ( for @xmath10 ) , similar to mrk 421 ( takahashi et al .
1996 ) .
a new mode of variability was discovered during our rxte monitoring of pks 2155304 in 1996 may , as part of a larger multifrequency campaign ( sambruna et al .
the sampling in the x - rays was excellent ( figure 4a ) , and complex flux variations were observed , with short , symmetric flares superposed to a longer baseline trend .
inspection of the hardness ratios ( the ratio of the counts in 620 kev over the counts in 26 kev ) versus flux shows that different flares ( separated by vertical dashed lines in figure 4a ) exhibit hysteresis loops of opposite signs , both in a `` clockwise '' and `` anti - clockwise '' sense ( labeled as c and a in figure 4a , respectively ) . applying a correlation analysis to each flare separately , we find that the c loops corresponds to a soft lag ( softer energies lagging ) and the a loop corresponds to a hard lag ( harder energies lagging ) , of the order of a few hours in both cases .
two examples are shown in figure 5b for the may 18.520.2 and 24.226.9 flares , respectively .
we interpreted the data using the acceleration model of kirk et al .
( 1998 ) . here
loops / lags of both signs are expected depending on how fast the electrons are accelerated compared to their cooling time , @xmath11 . if the acceleration is instantaneous ( i.e. , @xmath12 ) , cooling dominates variability and , because of its energy dependence , the harder energies are emitted first , with c loops and soft lags .
if instead the acceleration is slower ( @xmath13 ) , the electrons need to work their way up in energy and the softer energies are emitted first , with a loops and hard lags predicted .
a close agreement between the rxte light curve and the model is found by increasing @xmath14 by a factor 100 going from a c to an a loop , when @xmath14 becomes similar to the duration of the flare , and by steepening the electron energy distribution ( see sambruna et al .
1999d for details ) .
thus we reach the important conclusion that we are indeed observing electron acceleration , and together with cooling this is responsible for the observed x - ray variability properties of pks 2155304 .
the complex spectral behavior of pks 2155304 in 1996 may is in contrast to the remarkable simplicity observed in earlier x - ray observations of this source ( e.g. , kataoka et al .
1999b ) and of other objects .
figure 5 summarizes two epochs of rxte monitoring of another bright blue blazar , pks 2005489 , which has an sed very similar to pks 2155304 and is a tev candidate ( sambruna et al .
1995 ) . during 1998 september ,
our rxte monitoring detected a general trend of flux increase of 30% amplitude in 3.5 days ( figure 5a ) . despite gaps in the sampling ,
it is clear that the variability at harder energies is faster than at softer energies , consistent with cooling dominating the flares .
this is confirmed by the analysis of the hardness ratios versus flux , where only clockwise loops are observed .
a consistent behavior was also observed one month later ( figure 5b ) during a much larger , longer - lasting flare , when spectral variations occurred on timescales of a few hours ( perlman et al .
recent multiwavelength campaigns of blazars expanded the current available database , from which we are learning important new lessons .
detailed modeling of the seds of bright gamma - ray blazars of the red and blue types tend to support the current cooling paradigm , where the different blazars flavors are related to the predominant cooling mechanisms of the electrons at the higher energies ( ec in more luminous sources , ssc in lower - luminosity ones )
. however , several observational biases could be present which can be addressed by future larger statistical samples , especially in gamma - rays .
in particular , it will be important to expand the sample of tev blazars , which currently includes only a handful ( 5 ) of sources , with only two bright enough to allow detailed spectral and timing analysis .
a promising diagnostic for the origin of the seed photons for the ic process is the shape of the gamma - ray flare .
this awaits well - sampled gamma - ray light curves , which will be afforded by the next higher - sensitivities missions ( glast , agile in gev and hess , veritas , magic , cangaroo ii in tev ) .
broader - band , higher quality gamma - ray spectra will also be available , allowing a better location of the ic peak , a more precise measure of the spectral shape at gamma - rays , and its variability .
more correlated x - ray / tev monitorings are necessary , in which rxte and sax have crucial roles , to add to the current knowledge of the variability modes . finally , the current data show that acceleration and cooling are the dominant physical mechanisms responsible for the observed variability properties from blazars jets .
we are starting to study these processes well in the x - rays for blue blazars , where rxte has the potential to determine the shortest x - ray variability timescales and lags , probing into even more detail the jets microphysics .
it would also be interesting to perform similar studies in the optical for red blazars , to compare the nature of the acceleration and cooling in the two subclasses .
this work was supported by nasa contract nas38252 and nasa grant nag57276 .
i thank laura maraschi for a critical reading of the manuscript , felix aharonian and the hegra team for allowing me to report the 1998 tev data of mrk 501 , and lester chou for help with the rxte data reduction . | results from recent multiwavelength observations of blazars are reviewed , with particular emphasis on those involving the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _
( rxte ) .
i discuss blazars spectral energy distributions , their correlated variability at various energies , and the insights they offer on the physical processes in the jet .
new results on mrk 501 , pks 2155304 , and pks 2005489 are highlighted .
# 1 # 2 _ mem .
soc .
astron .
it . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ the messenger _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astron .
nach . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astron .
astrophys .
_ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astron .
astrophys .
lett . _ * # 1 * , l#2 # 1 # 2 _ astron
. astrophys .
rev . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astron .
astrophys .
suppl .
ser . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astron .
j. _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ ann .
rev .
astron .
astrophys . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astrophys .
j. _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astrophys .. j. lett . _ * # 1 * , l#2 # 1 # 2 _ astrophys .
j. suppl .
_ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ astrophys .
space sci .
_ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ adv .
space res .
_ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ bull .
astron .
inst .
czechosl . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ j. quant .
spectrosc .
. transfer _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ mon . not .
r. astr .
soc .
_ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ mem .
r. astr .
soc . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ phys .
lett .
rev . _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ publ . astron
. soc
. japan _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ publ .
astr .
soc .
pacific _ * # 1 * , # 2 # 1 # 2 _ nature _ * # 1 * , # 2 epsf.sty |
recently , the miniboone collaboration reported its results of searching for @xmath7 oscillations @xcite . in the experiment , the @xmath8 energy spectrum has a peak centered at 700 mev and extends to 3000 mev . for the oscillation range @xmath9 mev where @xmath10 is the energy of the produced neutrino , no significant excess of events is found .
this result excludes sizable appearance of @xmath11 via two neutrino oscillation and disfavors the previous lsnd measurement @xcite .
however , they observed that outside of the oscillation range , there is a clear peak of the electron - neutrino - like events ( @xmath12 events ) lying above background at @xmath13 mev .
although the origin of the excess is still under investigation , we may assume that they are indeed electron neutrinos at present .
the beam is completely composed of @xmath14 and the oscillation can only produce @xmath11 with the same energy , therefore the observation would be a serious challenge to the present theories .
namely a reasonable explanation about the appearance of the low energy @xmath11 is needed . to answer this question ,
there are some interesting proposals , for example , in @xcite the authors suggest a ( 3 + 2 ) neutrino oscillation scenario where two sterile neutrinos are introduced into the game to explain the miniboone results and bodek@xcite considered the internal bremsstrahlung as an alternative source of the excess @xmath11 events . instead , in this work
, we are looking for possible mechanisms other than the neutrino oscillation , supposing that there are only standard model ( sm ) neutrinos . an explanation that @xmath14 may decay into @xmath15 where @xmath4 denotes some possible light products , seems reasonable .
definitely , neutrino decay must be realized via interactions beyond the sm .
the possible candidates of @xmath4 could be @xmath16 , light bosons ( for example axion etc . ) and the unparticle which we are going to explore in this work .
in fact , the idea of neutrino decay is not new .
it has been put forward by some authors @xcite .
the basic idea is to introduce a heavy , unstable neutrino ( usually assuming a sterile one ) which decays into light neutrino or antineutrino plus a scalar particle .
the interactions between the scalar particle and neutrinos are described by a lepton flavor violating effective lagrangian which depends on the details of various new physics models .
instead , we suggest an alternative scenario , namely the heavier @xmath1 which is a mass eigenstate and a component of the flavor eigenstate @xmath14 , is the constituents of the beam and decays into a light neutrino @xmath2 and a scale - invariant unparticle proposed recently by georgi @xcite .
it is well known that at very high energy scale , the unparticle physics contains the sm fields and a sector of banks - zaks field ( defined in @xcite ) with a non - trivial infrared fix point .
below an energy scale @xmath17 which is of order of tev , the banks - zaks fields are matched onto a scale invariant unparticle sector .
the unparticle is different from the ordinary particles as it has no mass since the mass term breaks the scale invariance , but the lorentz - invariant four - momentum square needs not to be zero , @xmath18 .
the scale dimension of unparticle is in general fractional rather than an integral number ( the dimension for a fermion is half - integers ) .
this special characteristic brings us a natural explanation of the shape of low energy @xmath11 bump observed by the miniboone collaboration .
if @xmath19 decays into a @xmath2 and a real scalar particle where @xmath20 are neutrino mass eigenstates , it is a two - body decay where the energy - spectrum of the produced @xmath11 should be discrete .
it is in contrary to the observation where the energy spectrum of the produced @xmath11 is continuous .
indeed , the incident @xmath14 beam has an energy distribution which can result in a natural energy spreading for the produced electron - neutrino , however , it demands that the shape of @xmath11 spectrum must be similar to that of the incident @xmath14 beam . instead ,
if the produced @xmath4 is an unparticle , the energy spectrum of @xmath11 would naturally spread and it may be more consistent with the present measurements .
the interactions between the unparticle and the sm particles are described in the framework of low energy effective theory and lead to various interesting phenomenology .
there have been many phenomenological explorations on possible observable effects caused by unparticles @xcite and much more are coming up .
the miniboone results indicate that the energy of the events of excess is about a half of the peak position at the energy spectrum of the muon neutrino .
as discussed above , we suggest a decay mode @xmath21 where @xmath22 denotes the unparticle and a consequent transition @xmath23 might be observed , namely @xmath14 and @xmath11 are not physical eigenstates , but are that of weak interaction and can be caught by detector as an appearance of @xmath11 at lower energy .
as indicated in @xcite , the unparticle stuff with scale dimension @xmath24 can not be `` seen '' directly , it would manifest itself as a missing energy .
when the scale dimension @xmath24 is not very large , the energy spectrum of electron neutrino can fall into the allowed range of the miniboone measurements .
this process has also been considered in @xcite .
a transition into a three - body final state @xmath25 is also a possible process to explain the miniboone data .
the two decay modes : @xmath26 and @xmath25 are both lepton flavor violating processes and can only occur via new physics mechanism beyond the sm .
if the mechanism proposed above can explain the observed peak which depends on its decay width , the possible detection rate of the number of @xmath11 is roughly @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the muon neutrino number , @xmath29 is the lifetime which should be calculated in the aforementioned scenario and @xmath30 is a detection rate which is also very small , say , @xmath31 or even smaller .
t is the flight time from the source to the detector and since the speed of the beam neutrino is very close to the speed of light , @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the distance and approximately 500 m in the miniboone experiments .
in addition the ratio would be further suppressed by the time dilation factor @xmath34 .
since @xmath33 is only of several hundred meters , to make a sizable ratio which can be observed , @xmath29 must not be large .
we will obtain its value by imputing all the concerned model parameters which are fixed by fitting data of other experiments into our numerical computation . as is well - known
, neutrino oscillation had been observed in the solar , atmospheric , accelerator neutrino experiments and the present theoretical studies almost completely confirm the msw mechanism .
the relevant mixing parameters and the mass - square differences are determined by fitting the data , even though the absolute values of the neutrino masses are still not fixed yet .
while theoretically determining the parameters , possible neutrino decays are not taken into account seriously . how to reconcile the neutrino decay with the present theoretical works on the neutrino oscillation is an open question , namely , one should explore if there exists discrepancy between the theoretical predictions and data .
obviously if the decay rate is sufficiently small , one does not need to modify the present theoretical framework about the neutrino oscillation , but if the decay rate is not too small , the data fitting should be re - considered , therefore the miniboone result indeed provides a new challenge to the neutrino physics and we will return to this topic in our next work @xcite .
we start with a brief review of the unparticle physics .
first let us consider an unparticle @xmath22 with scale dimension @xmath24 and momentum @xmath35 .
the unparticle momentum satisfies the constraint @xmath18 . according to @xcite
, the unparticle stuff can be viewed as a tower of massive particles with mass spacing tends to zero .
scale invariance provides the most important constraint on the properties of unparticles .
the two - point function of scalar unparticle field operator @xmath36 is written as 0|o_(x ) o^_(0)|0=e^-ipx with momentum @xmath35 and the phase space factor is vector unparticle field @xmath37 , we have 0|o_^(0)|pp|o_^(0)|0(p^2)= a_d_(p^0)(p^2)(-g^+p^ p^/p^2)(p^2)^d_-2 , where the transverse condition @xmath38 is required .
the lorentz structure of unparticle can also be tensor @xcite or spinor @xcite . in this study
, we restrict our discussions to scalar and vector unparticles .
obviously similar analysis can be done for the tensor and spinor unparticles . about the virtual effects ,
the propagator of the scalar unparticle field is given as d^4 x e^ipx0 |to_(x)o_(0)|0&= & i e^-i(d_-2 ) , and for the vector unparticle field , the propagator is d^4 x e^ipx0 @xmath39 at the denominator implies that the scale dimension @xmath24 can not be integers for @xmath40 in order to avoid singularity .
the phase factor @xmath41 provides a cp conserving phase which produces peculiar interference effects in high energy scattering processes @xcite and cp violation in b decays @xcite . in this study
, we will discuss interactions between the unparticles and neutrinos .
the framework which describes these interactions is a low energy effective theory . for our purpose , the coupling of unparticle to neutrinos ( @xmath8 and @xmath11 )
is given in the form as _
eff=| _ _ ( 1-_5)_^o _ + | _ _ ( 1-_5)_o_^+h.c . . here
, we have used the @xmath42 type current as in the sm .
the @xmath43 and @xmath44 are dimensionless coefficients .
the @xmath45 and @xmath46 are weak eigenstates with different flavor numbers @xmath47 and @xmath48 . as in @xcite , the neutrino decay is conveniently represented in the basis of mass eigenstates @xmath20 ( i=1,2 , we only consider two generations in this case ) .
the interactions between unparticle and neutrinos are rewritten by | _
j_(1-_5)_i o_^+h.c . .
the relation between the coupling coefficients @xmath49 and @xmath50 can be obtained from neutrino mixing matrix . for a simple case , considering two neutrino mixing ,
( c _ e + _ ) = ( cc cos & -sin + sin & cos ) ( c _ 1 + _ 2 ) , the coefficients in the mass basis are related to those in the flavor basis by c_s(v)^_1_2=cos^2 c_s(v)^__. for a maximal mixing where @xmath51 , @xmath52 . the coefficients in the different basis differ by a constant factor . assuming two generation neutrinos and the heavier one is @xmath1 and lighter is @xmath2 , the decay of @xmath26 is realized via the transition @xmath21 which is a typical lepton flavor violating process and its feynman diagram is depicted in fig .
[ fig1 ] . here
, it is natural to assume that the basis of the interaction between unparticle and neutrino is the same as the weak interaction , namely @xmath11 and @xmath14 are the eigenstates of the interaction .
the final unparticle is invisible and behaves as a missing energy .
the decay @xmath21 seems to be a two - body process .
but it is different from the common case with two final particles whose momenta are single - valued and fixed . for the unparticle case ,
the energy of @xmath2 depends on the momentum square of unparticle @xmath53 which only is constrained by the condition @xmath18 .
namely , one can expect that @xmath53 can vary within a range @xmath54 where @xmath55 would be determined by the momenutum conservation in @xmath14 decay .
thus the varying @xmath53 causes a continuous energy spectrum of @xmath56 and it is a characteristic effect of the unparticle . [
cols="^,^ " , ]
motivated by the new measurement of the miniboone collaboration , which observed an excess of electron - like events at low energy , it motivates us to search for a possible mechanism beyond the sm to explain this phenomenon ,
so the first idea which hits our mind is that @xmath1 might decay into @xmath2 accompanied by some other very light products .
we should testify if this scenario can produce results which are theoretically plausible and can explain the data
. there may be several possible modes , the first one is @xmath57 which is a three - body decay , the second one is @xmath58 where @xmath59 is a single boson particle , for example an axion etc . , and the third one is @xmath60 where @xmath22 represents an unparticle .
all the three possibilities can not be realized in the framework of the sm , so new physics beyond the sm is necessary .
the first one was numerically estimated in this work and our results indicate that the decay rate determined by the three - body decay mode is too small and is ruled out immediately .
the second mode is a two - body decay , therefore the spectrum of the electron neutrinos is discrete and it is not consistent with the measurement of the miniboone .
even though we consider the energy spreading of the incident muon neutrino beam , the shape of the resultant electron neutrino bump can not be well understood in this scenario .
therefore the third candidate is the most favorable . in this work ,
we work out the formulations of neutrino decays within the framework of unparticle physics .
the formulations in the laboratory frame are given for the first time .
the smallness of the decay width given by our numerical results indicates that the unparticle scenario may not explain the excess of electron neutrinos at low energy .
the life time predicted in the unparticle model is qualitatively consistent with the the cosmological constraint @xcite which is about @xmath61 sec . by eq .
( 1 ) , we know the suppression of @xmath62 with @xmath63 sec . , would kill any possibility of observing a decay event .
the reasons are : ( 1 ) very tiny neutrino mass ( 2 ) very weak interactions between the unparticle and neutrino .
since our numerical results are consistent with the cosmology constraints and the results by other authors @xcite , we can be convinced that the calculation is right , but the proposal does not work here .
thus in this work , we definitely obtain a negative conclusion that the peak of electron - neutrino at lower energy observed by the minimoone collaboration can not be explained by the neutrino decay . on other aspect ,
the phenomenon is there and demands theoretical explanations , so that we propose another scenario which might overcome the aforementioned restrictions which forbid the appearance of electron neutrinos to appear at low energy for the miniboone experiments .
we will present the scenario in our next work .
this work was supported in part by nnsfc under contract nos . 10475042 , 10745002 and 10705015 and the special foundation of the education ministry of china . | in a new measurement on neutrino oscillation @xmath0 , the miniboone collaboration observes an excess of electron - like events at low energy and the phenomenon may demand an explanation which obviously is beyond the oscillation picuture .
we propose that heavier neutrino @xmath1 decaying into a lighter one @xmath2 via the transition process @xmath3 where @xmath4 denotes any light products , could be a natural mechanism .
the theoretical model we employ here is the unparticle scenario established by georgi .
we have studied two particular modes @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
unfortunately , the number coming out from the computation is too small to explain the observation .
moreover , our results are consistent with the cosmology constraint on the neutrino lifetime and the theoretical estimation made by other groups , therefore we can conclude that even though neutrino decay seems plausible in this case , it indeed can not be the source of the peak at lower energy observed by the miniboone collaboration and there should be other mechanisms responsible for the phenomenon . |
the intermittent small - scale dynamics of fully developed turbulence at very large reynolds numbers is believed to be more or less scale - invariant within the so - called inertial range , the latter being bound by the integral length scale @xmath0 and the dissipation length scale @xmath1 .
consequently , both experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite efforts largely concentrate on scaling exponents , which are deduced from structure functions of the velocity field .
however , `` scaling exponents are not everything '' as they represent for sure the simplest , but at the same time also the most insensitive observables characterising multi - scale processes .
because of this insensitiveness any heroic effort to derive the observed multi - scaling directly from the navier - stokes equation @xcite remains somewhat incomplete as some physics might have been lost with the applied approximations and assumptions .
also , due to the finiteness of the real - world inertial range and the limited statistical sampling , the experimental procedure to extract multi - scaling is not unequivocal and quoted values for scaling exponents beyond sixth order should not be overemphasised . for these reasons and also in view of the quest for universality in the up - to - now unreachable limit @xmath2 , additional observables other than scaling exponents are needed . in order to explain this philosophy , `` scaling exponents are not everything '' , in more detail
, we discuss heuristic multiplicative cascade processes and show that with a clever subclass of additional observables more can be learned about the intrinsic cascade dynamics than only from scaling exponents . following richardsons historic metaphor of large eddies decaying into successively smaller and smaller eddies ,
a multiplicative cascade process phenomenologically describes the turbulent redistribution of energy flux from large to small scales and is able to reproduce the observed scaling exponents of the surrogate energy dissipation field @xcite , which are related to those of the velocity structure functions by the refined similarity hypothesis @xcite .
originally intended to directly access the multiplicative weight distribution associated to the energy cascade generator distributions of so - called multipliers or break - up coefficients @xcite have been extracted from very large taylor - scale based reynolds number atmospheric boundary layer and wind tunnel flows recently @xcite ; see also ref .
it was found that within the upper part @xmath3 of the inertial range these multiplier distributions do in fact become scale - independent .
however , they do depend on the relative position of parent and daughter domain ; this non - homogeneity of the breakup leaves a subsequent extraction of scaling exponents inconsistent @xcite and indicates the presence of correlations between successive multipliers , as has been confirmed by studying multiplier distributions conditioned on the value of the ( scale- ) previous multiplier @xcite .
the observed correlations appear to be in conflict with the simple multiplicative cascade models , where the cascade generator is assumed to be identical and independent at each breakup .
as has been convincingly demonstrated in refs .
@xcite this apparent conflict can be resolved : introducing non - conservative cascade generators with a positively skewed weight distribution and restoring euclidean homogeneity of the ultrametric cascade models , the multiplier distributions resulting from a discrete binary multiplicative cascade become a scale - independent fix - point due to small - scale resummation and are in good qualitative agreement with the experimentally deduced distributions , including all observed correlation effects .
originally not anticipated , these multiplier distributions represent one of those wanted clever subclasses of additional observables , from which more can be learned about the relevance of cascade processes in turbulence and about the intrinsic cascade dynamics than only from scaling exponents . the experimental analysis
@xcite reveals that unconditional multiplier distributions are observed to be scale - independent within the range @xmath4 . in view of the findings of ref .
@xcite we call this the visible cascade range . since due to small - scale resummation it takes about three binary scale steps for the multiplier distributions to converge to the scale - independent fix - point the lowest part of the true cascade range @xmath5 is not visible .
a further conclusion from this line of reasoning would be that below @xmath6 dissipation dynamics sets in and modifies the scale - independent cascade dynamics .
besides this interpretation about the scope of cascade processes in turbulence , also more details about the intrinsic cascade dynamics can be learned from multiplier distributions @xcite .
not every weight distribution , associated to a binary cascade generator and reproducing observed scaling exponents within experimental error bars , qualifies to yield the correct distributions of multipliers and their correlations .
it has to come with a positive skewness .
weight distributions of log - normal or certain asymmetric binomial type share this property , whereas , for example , a log - poisson weight distribution @xcite does not .
all those conclusions have been drawn from binary discrete multiplicative cascade processes in connection with base - two ( @xmath7 ) multiplier distributions .
multiplier distributions referring to other scale steps have not been looked at . in this respect
it is of interest to find out whether the latter do again reveal a scale - independent fix - point behaviour with additional correlations or whether they are simply artefacts of the binary discrete cascade model implementation .
not only this aspect is of relevance to find answers , the impact of cascade model implementations with scale steps other than @xmath8 , i.e. @xmath9 or @xmath10 , has to be studied for the multiplier phenomenology : do multiplier distributions resulting from different model implementations differ or not ? put in other words : are different cascade model implementations distinguishable or indistinguishable on the level of multiplier observables ?
theoretically the scale step @xmath11 associated to the cascade generator is not fixed . due to the present lack of a derivation of cascade models from the navier - stokes equation ,
no specific choice is favoured for @xmath11 , except for personal taste .
only if the last question can be answered with yes , we can consider multiplier distributions as a clever subclass of additional observables .
the organisation of the paper is as follows : in sect .
ii we sketch the implementation of general multiplicative cascade processes and briefly summarize previous work on ( @xmath12)-multiplier distributions resulting from a discrete ( @xmath8 ) model implementation .
iii concentrates on discrete ( @xmath13 ) implementations of multiplicative cascade processes and presents multiplier distributions referring to scale steps @xmath14 .
a quasicontinuous implementation of random multiplicative cascade models is used in sect .
iv to study respective multiplier distributions referring to various scale steps .
so - called log - stable weight distributions @xcite are considered in sect .
v and , although leading to correct scaling exponents @xcite , shown not to reproduce the observed multiplier distributions .
several conclusions are presented in sect .
vi , the most important being that it does not matter how multiplicative cascade models are implemented ( discrete or continuous ) , since the multiplier observables are indistinguishable .
the following one - dimensional implementation of multiplicative cascade processes is designed to model the energy cascade from large ( @xmath0 ) to small ( @xmath6 ) length scales : the initial energy flux density field at the integral scale @xmath0 is set equal to @xmath15 without any loss of generality . for an intermediate length scale @xmath16 we introduce a so - called weight field @xmath17 where the index function @xmath18 represents a subdomain of length @xmath19 .
each random weight @xmath20 is independently drawn from a scale - independent probability distribution @xmath21 with mean @xmath22 . the energy density field @xmath23 at the smallest scale @xmath6
is then constructed as a multiplication of weight fields belonging to a hierarchy of different intermediate length scales @xmath24 , where @xmath25 .
let us discuss the special case for @xmath26 , so that it is sufficient to consider the fields only in the domain @xmath27 .
the implementation ( [ two3 ] ) can then be understood in terms of a binary cascade generator : the energy density @xmath28 of a domain of length @xmath19 is redistributed onto a left and right subdomain of length @xmath29 with energy densities @xmath30 and @xmath31 , where the random weights are drawn from the splitting function @xmath32 the successive application of this cascade generator from the large scale @xmath0 down to the small scale @xmath6 leads to the field ( [ two3 ] ) .
the splitting function ( [ two4 ] ) is not in its most general form as it does not need to factorise .
however , it has been noted in ref .
@xcite , that because fully developed turbulence is a @xmath33 dimensional process , the observational reduction of a more - dimensional multiplicative cascade process to one dimension leads to a splitting function which factorises almost completely .
the standard observable of multiplicative cascade processes are scaling exponents representing the intermittency corrections .
they are deduced from a scale - invariant moment analysis of the synergetic field ( [ two3 ] ) ; a naive derivation gives @xmath34 with scaling exponents @xmath35 where the independence of the @xmath36 weights @xmath37 , , @xmath38 has been exploited .
this deduction is not in full accordance with the analysis of experimentally measured fields ; those are recorded at the finest resolution scale @xmath39 , then averaged over larger length scales @xmath19 , @xmath40 and are not identical to the model field evolved from scales @xmath0 to @xmath19 @xcite , i.e.@xmath41 the scale dependence of moments @xmath42 of the backward field are different from ( [ two5 ] ) and do not show rigorous scaling at the very small scales @xcite . only in the large - scale asymptotic
scaling exponents can be extracted unambiguously and coincide with the expression ( [ two6 ] ) . originally proposed in ref .
@xcite and applied in refs.@xcite the method of random multipliers ( or break - up coefficients ) aims at directly accessing scaling exponents via respective distributions of the former . in its most general form multipliers
are defined as @xmath43 where @xmath44 represents the averaged energy density over an offspring interval of length @xmath45 and with its centre shifted by @xmath46 with respect to the parent interval .
we distinguish three special cases for the shift parameter @xmath47 : for @xmath48 , @xmath49 we call @xmath50 centred , right- and left - sided , respectively .
for very large reynolds number turbulent flows it has been found experimentally @xcite that the unconditional multiplier distributions @xmath51 , which are sampled over @xmath52 , do not depend on the scale @xmath19 within the regime @xmath53 .
however , a dependence on the shift parameter @xmath47 was noticed ; this `` nonhomogeneity of the breakup '' obscures the relationship between multiplier and weight distribution and the once intended extraction of scaling exponents @xcite .
actually the @xmath47-dependence hints to the existence of correlations between successive multipliers .
these correlations have been observed in conditional multiplier distributions @xmath54 with left / right - sided ( @xmath55 ) @xcite and centred ( @xmath48 ) @xcite shift parameter , respectively , and with the emphasis on base - two ( @xmath7 ) scale steps .
these latest findings appear to contradict the simple multiplicative cascade processes with independent breakups . however , this statement is not true !
the studies in refs .
@xcite with nonconservative binary ( @xmath26 ) random multiplicative cascade models have given a new interpretation to multiplier distributions : unconditional multiplier distributions represent a scale - independent fix - point due to small - scale resummation ; the `` nonhomogeneity of the breakup '' is also naturally explained along this line .
once the sampling of multipliers is allowed over all and not only dyadic positions the correct multiplier correlations have been obtained from positively skewed weight distributions ; for example , a log - normal weight distribution does qualify whereas a log - poisson distribution does not qualify .
these results show that multiplier distributions do reveal more information about the underlying weight distribution than might be extracted from approximate scaling exponents .
for discrete multiplicative cascade models with binary splittings the scale step entering into the construction of the energy density field ( [ two3 ] ) is set equal to @xmath26 .
furthermore , we choose @xmath56 .
the length of the field configuration is set equal to @xmath57 , mimicking a long time series . as weight distribution
we choose the binomial distribution @xmath58 with parameters @xmath59 , @xmath60 ; this choice has the correct skewness @xmath61 in order to reproduce conditional base - two multiplier distributions @xcite .
other , non - binomial weight distributions , such as of log - normal or pearson - iii type , are also able to provide a positive skewness and lead to more or less identical base - two multiplier distributions @xcite , all being in qualitative accordance with experimental findings @xcite . also multiplier distributions different from base - two do not distinguish the aforementioned weight distributions .
hence , we will only show results for the weight distribution ( [ three1 ] ) .
due to small - scale resummation @xcite the base - two multiplier distributions are scale - invariant in the regime @xmath62 ; for @xmath63 the distributions converge to the scale - independent fix - point and for scales very close to the integral length scale deviations from scale - invariance set in because of the finiteness of @xmath0 .
figure 1(a2 ) shows simulation results for left - sided multiplier distributions ( @xmath64 ) at scale @xmath65 : the unconditional multiplier distribution @xmath66 comes close to a beta - distribution parametrisation @xmath67 with @xmath68 , which has been extracted from very large reynolds number atmospheric boundary layer turbulence @xcite .
once conditioned on the respective parent multiplier , correlations are observed : the distribution @xmath69 with a large parent multiplier becomes broader than the unconditional distribution and its average is shifted to a value larger than @xmath70 .
the opposite holds for the conditional distribution @xmath71 with a small parent multiplier ; it is more narrow than the unconditional distribution and its average is shifted to a value smaller than @xmath70 .
the positive correlation between left - sided daughter and left - sided parent multiplier is a consequence of the homogeneous sampling of multipliers over all @xmath52-positions , which is not restricted to dyadic cascade positions .
respective multiplier distributions of right / right combinations are identical to these left / left combinations . a negative correlation between daughter and parent multipliers
is revealed for identical left / right and right / left combinations ; their respective distributions are mirror images of those for left / left and right / right combinations , i.e. @xmath72 .
this explains that conditional distributions , which are averaged over all four daughter / parent combinations , are again symmetric around @xmath73 ; these distributions have been shown in refs .
@xcite .
left - sided multiplier distributions for scale steps different from @xmath7 are shown in figs .
1(a1+a3 ) .
for @xmath74 the unconditional multiplier distribution converges to a fix - point for @xmath75 ; its maximum is shifted towards smaller values since its average amounts to @xmath76 .
a conditioning on a left - sided parent multiplier again reveals correlations between successive multipliers : the distribution @xmath77 is broader than the unconditional one , whereas @xmath78 is more narrow .
also multiplier distributions of base step close to one , e.g. @xmath79 , show fix - point behaviour in the regime @xmath75 . in view of the discrete ( @xmath26)-steps used in the cascade evolution
this result appears unexpected on first sight , but again it is small - scale resummation , which explains this result on second thought .
the unconditional left - sided distribution comes with an average of @xmath80 close to one .
the respective conditional distributions @xmath81 and @xmath82 both deviate from the unconditional distribution , but contrary to the @xmath12 and @xmath83 cases , the former has now become broader whereas the latter turns out to be more narrow .
closer inspection reveals that this tendency has been reversed at around @xmath84 .
centred multiplier distributions for scale steps @xmath74 , @xmath85 and @xmath86 do qualitatively show the same behaviour as the respective left - sided multiplier distributions depicted in figs .
1(a1)-(a3 ) .
all centred distributions are more narrow than their respective left - sided counterparts , reflecting again the `` nonhomogeneity of the breakup '' .
this is also illuminated in fig . 2 , where the @xmath87-dependence of the two exponents @xmath88 and @xmath89 of the beta - distribution ( [ three2 ] ) , fitted to the respective unconditional left - sided and centred multiplier distributions , are shown . since
according to ( [ three2 ] ) we have @xmath90 , the two exponents are related by setting @xmath91 .
conditional multiplier distributions of base step different from @xmath12 have not been looked at in refs .
hence , we consider our respective simulation results as predictions . most often discrete multiplicative cascade models are chosen with scale steps @xmath26 .
now we will consider @xmath92 and @xmath93 and investigate the resulting multiplier distributions . within the implementation ( [ two1])-([two3 ] )
the parameters are chosen as @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
again for demonstration , the binomial weight distribution ( [ three1 ] ) is picked with new parameters @xmath96 , @xmath97 for @xmath92 and @xmath98 , @xmath99 for @xmath93 . according to the expression ( [ two6 ] ) the two parameter settings yield an acceptable intermittency exponent @xmath100 , but
actually have been fitted to reproduce the experimentally deduced unconditional left - sided base - two ( @xmath7 ) multiplier distribution ( [ three2 ] ) with @xmath68 in the fix - point scale regime @xmath101 . for both cases
the resulting unconditional and conditional left - sided fix - point multiplier distributions of bases @xmath74 , @xmath7 and @xmath102 are almost indistinguishable from the respective distributions shown in figs .
1(a1)-(a3 ) for the binary discrete multiplicative cascade implementation with @xmath26 .
the same holds for centred multiplier distributions . for parameter choices
@xmath103 , @xmath104 , resulting in a negative skewness of the binomial weight distribution , the shape of the resulting unconditional left - sided fix - point multiplier distribution turns out to deviate from the symmetric beta - distribution parametrisation to some small , but noticeable extend .
moreover , the correct effects observed in the conditional multiplier distributions can not be reproduced .
on the contrary , well adjusted log - normal weight distributions come again with the correct positive skewness and almost identically reproduce all unconditional and conditional multiplier distributions derived from the good binomial weight parametrisations .
a discrete implementation of random multiplicative cascade processes is often opposed by the question `` why discrete ? '' .
it is true that a continuous implementation leads to nicer mathematics in terms of log - infinite divisible and log - stable distributions @xcite , but since the relationship of the random multiplicative cascade processes to the navier - stokes equation is unclear for the moment we prefer to consider discrete and continuous versions on an equal footing .
as far as the numerical implementation is concerned a continuous random multiplicative cascade process will always be quasi - continuous .
hence , eqs .
( [ two1])-([two3 ] ) do apply with a quasi - continuous scale step @xmath11 close to one ; we choose @xmath105 , which compared to a binary cascade corresponds to an eightfold scale - densification .
other parameters are set equal to @xmath106 and @xmath95 .
due to scale - densification the binomial weight distribution ( [ three1 ] ) now comes with rescaled parameters .
the setting @xmath107 , @xmath108 comes from a fit of the resulting unconditional left - sided base - two multiplier distribution to the expression ( [ three2 ] ) with @xmath68 ; see fig .
using eq .
( [ two6 ] ) it also yields an intermittency exponent of @xmath109 .
because of small - scale resummation all multiplier distributions become again scale - independent fix - points in the range @xmath110 ; to be more concrete , the simulations reveal a lower bound of approximately @xmath111 .
the unconditional left - sided multiplier distributions of base - scale @xmath74 , @xmath85 and @xmath86 , which are shown in figs .
1(b1)-(b3 ) , are hard to distinguish from those obtained from a scale - discrete cascade implementation , which are illustrated in figs .
. a similar statement can be made not only about the respective left - sided conditional distributions , but also for all unconditional and conditional centred multiplier distributions .
this finding demonstrates that multiplier distributions in the fix - point regime do not distinguish discrete and continuous versions of random multiplicative cascade processes ; again , the reason for this is small - scale resummation .
other suitable parameter settings of the binomial weight distribution quite easily reproduce all unconditional multiplier distributions shown so far .
even with a different - signed skewness , as for example with @xmath112 , @xmath113 , the correlation effects observed in the resulting conditional multiplier distributions go in the right direction , but are reduced by a factor of about @xmath85 in magnitude .
another interesting parameter setting is @xmath114 , @xmath115 . in the limit @xmath116 with @xmath117
the weight distribution comes with a large negative skewness @xmath118 and leads to the infinite divisible log - poisson cascade model of refs .
all unconditional multiplier distributions shown so far are again reproduced , but only very weak correlation effects are observed in the resulting conditional multiplier distributions .
this demonstrates that although the log - poisson cascade model is capable to reproduce scaling exponents with no doubt , it fails to describe the correlation systematics of multiplier distributions .
these findings suggest that in order to reproduce unconditional as well as correct conditional multiplier distributions the weight distribution has to possess a positive skewness , irrespective of the chosen scale - step-@xmath11 implementation of the underlying multiplicative cascade process . for the binomial weight distribution ( [ three1 ] )
we note that for the qualitatively best parameter choices , i.e. ( @xmath103 , @xmath104 ) @xmath119 ( @xmath120 , @xmath121 ) , ( @xmath122 , @xmath123 ) , ( @xmath124 , @xmath125 ) , ( @xmath126 , @xmath127 ) for @xmath128 , @xmath85 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 , respectively , the resulting skewness almost coincides at a value around @xmath131 . here a more quantitative analysis , driven by very large reynolds number data , would certainly deserve future consideration .
multiplier distributions resulting from a meticulously tuned log - normal weight distribution @xmath132 are also practically indistinguishable from the results shown in fig . 1 .
qualitative best parameters for the implementations with @xmath128 , @xmath85 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 are @xmath133 , @xmath126 , @xmath134 , @xmath135 , respectively , reflecting an approximate , but obvious log - normal dependence @xmath136 .
contrary to the case of the binomial weight distribution , the skewness of the respective log - normal distributions is not identical ; it increases with increasing @xmath11 and stays positive for all four cases .
the multiplier statistics of continuously implemented multiplicative cascade processes appears to be indistinguishable from their discrete counterparts .
this poses the question to what degree a continuous multiplicative cascade process might be described by an effective discrete multiplicative cascade process .
for the translation of a continuous into a discrete multiplicative cascade process it is important to deal with the forward field . in analogy
( [ two3 ] ) the energy density field is evolved from integral down to the intermediate binary target length scales @xmath19 and @xmath29 , respectively , i.e.@xmath137 with @xmath138 , @xmath139 and the scale - densification @xmath140 .
we restrict the @xmath52-regime to @xmath141 .
the averaging @xmath142 with discrete positions @xmath143 , @xmath144 is principally different from the backward averaging of eq .
( [ two7 ] ) and leads to the binary weights @xmath145 sampling over all discrete positions leads to a binary splitting function @xmath146 , which still might depend on the scale @xmath19 . for the numerical simulations of a concrete quasi - continuous cascade process
again an eightfold scale - densification ( @xmath147 ) has been chosen together with the binomial weight distribution ( [ three1 ] ) with parameters @xmath148 , @xmath149 . the effective binary splitting function @xmath146 with effective weights ( [ fourb3 ] )
is illustrated in fig .
3a for an intermediate length scale .
for @xmath150 it is practically scale - independent ; only at the very large scales a weak scale - dependence is observed .
the projected weight distributions @xmath151 and @xmath152 are identical and come close to a log - normal distribution with a positive skewness .
observe in fig .
3b that the projected weight distribution is not simply a @xmath153-fold convolution of the binomial weight distribution ( [ three1 ] ) ; the modification is a result of the multivariate implementation ( [ two1 ] ) of the weight fields .
note also , that the effective splitting function does not strictly factorise ; a small correlation between the two effective weights @xmath154 and @xmath155 exists as the relative entropy @xmath156 turns out to be negative .
so far the continously implemented multiplicative cascade process has been directly translated into a ( @xmath26)-discrete multiplicative cascade process with an effective splitting function @xmath146 . for consistency
we still have to check , whether this effective ( @xmath26)-discrete multiplicative cascade process leads to identical results for the multiplier statistics . the discrete implementation ( [ two1])-([two3 ] ) with @xmath26 and @xmath146 instead of eq .
( [ two4 ] ) leads to the multiplier distributions shown in figs .
1(c1)-(c3 ) .
qualitatively there is no difference to the distributions illustrated in figs .
1(a1)-(a3 ) , ( b1)-(b3 ) and quantitative differences remain very small .
in this section we want to demonstrate again , that `` scaling exponents is not everything '' . in view of renormalisation
theory so - called log - stable distributions represent mathematically very attractive parametrisations for the weight distribution @xmath21 , leading its way to the denotation `` universal multifractals '' @xcite . in connection with
the energy cascade in fully developed turbulence they have already been discussed in refs.@xcite , where the expression @xmath157 has been derived for the scaling exponents ( [ two6 ] ) . with an intermittency exponent of @xmath158 and a stable index of @xmath159
the experimentally deduced scaling exponents @xcite are reproduced remarkably well .
focusing on multiplier distributions , we will now reveal limitations of log - stable weight distributions .
concentrating first on a discrete implementation of multiplicative cascade processes , where according to ( [ two1])-([two3 ] ) the parameters are set as @xmath26 , @xmath56 and @xmath160 , the associated log - stable weight distribution @xmath21 is constructed by noting that @xmath161 is distributed according to a stable distribution @xcite .
the skewness parameter has to be set equal to @xmath162 and the scale and shift parameters @xmath163 and @xmath164 are fixed by the scaling exponents @xmath165 and @xmath158 . for various stable parameters @xmath166 the respective log - stable weight distributions are illustrated in fig.4a .
depending on @xmath167 these distributions possess different asymmetries with respect to the average @xmath168 ; in fact the skewness @xmath169 , which should neither be confused with the skewness parameter @xmath170 nor with the notation @xmath171 of the stable distributions , amounts to @xmath172 , @xmath173 , @xmath174 , @xmath175 for @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 . if a correct skewness is really a good criterion to reproduce unconditional as well as conditional multiplier distributions , then according to what we now know from the previous sections it should be around @xmath180 for @xmath26 .
this would limit the stable index @xmath167 to a regime close to @xmath85 .
the unconditional left - sided base - two multiplier distributions resulting from the log - stable weight distributions with a given index @xmath167 are again scale - independent in the scale range @xmath62 and are illustrated in fig .
since the log - stable weight distributions have already been fitted to the scaling exponent @xmath181 , there is no further free parameter left to adjust to the observed unconditional left - sided multiplier distribution ( [ three2 ] ) with @xmath68 . for @xmath182
the agreement is acceptable .
notice especially the extra contributions at @xmath183 and @xmath184 for small values of @xmath167 .
this is a consequence of the algebraic tails of the stable - distributions , which lead to excess contributions at @xmath185 in the corresponding weight distributions ; consult again fig .
the conditional multiplier distributions @xmath186 are also shown in fig . 4b , where over all four possible left / right - sided daughter / parent multiplier combinations has been averaged .
for @xmath187 a conditioning on a small parent multiplier , i.e. @xmath188 , leads to a distribution more narrow than the unconditional distribution and a conditioning on a large parent multiplier , i.e. @xmath189 , leads to a broader distribution .
this is in qualitative agreement with the experimental findings of ref.@xcite . for @xmath190
this tendency has almost vanished , for @xmath191 it has vanished and for @xmath192 it has even been reversed . a very similar behaviour is observed in the conditional centred base - two multiplier distributions , which are depicted in fig .
4c ; only for @xmath167 very close to 2 they are in qualitative agreement with the experimental findings of ref .
this outcome also confirms our conjecture from above that a correct positive skewness is needed for the weight distribution in order to reproduce the multiplier distributions .
a quasi - continuous implementation of multiplicative cascade processes with log - stable weight distributions leads to multiplier distributions , which are identical to those shown in figs .
4b+c for the discrete implementation .
hence , we arrive at the conclusion that although scaling exponents are well fitted by log - stable weight distributions with index @xmath193 @xcite the observed systematics of the multiplier distributions rules out such a stable index value . the log - normal limit @xmath194 reproduces the multiplier distributions much better .
discrete and continuous implementations of geometric multiplicative cascade processes are both able to model multifractal characteristics observed in the surrogate energy dissipation field of fully developed turbulence . since their relation to the navier - stokes equation remains unclear neither form of implementation is principally favoured over the other .
although perhaps somewhat unexpected , this indistinguishability remains once a specific class of observables , going beyond scaling exponents , is employed : multiplier distributions referring to various scale - steps , discrete or quasi - continuous , do not care whether they result from discrete or continuous versions of nonconservative multiplicative cascade processes .
the reason for this is that the multivariate model implementation implies a small - scale resummation leading to scale - independent fix - point distributions . from an analysis point of view
a discrete or continuous multiplicative cascade process with no correlations between the various branchings appears as a continuous multiplicative cascade process with correlations .
there is more to learn from these fix - point multiplier distributions : not every weight distribution associated to the cascade generator , which matches scaling exponents within experimental error bars , qualifies to reproduce the observed multiplier correlations .
the weight distribution has to possess a positive skewness .
for example , so - called log - stable distributions with a stable index not close to @xmath187 do not share this property and are unable to reproduce the observed conditional multiplier distributions .
this leaves us with a speculation : the original idea to directly access scaling exponents via unconditional multiplier distributions does not work due to the observed correlations between multipliers .
however , these correlations help to restrict the broad class of cascade weight distributions , which all reproduce the observed lowest - order scaling exponents , to those having a positive skewness . a further restriction of this subclass appears to be possible with yet additional observables to be derived from the full analytic solution of the multivariate cascade characteristic function @xcite .
then , by directly accessing the cascade weight distribution , it is tempting to study its dependence on the reynolds number and on the flow configuration , and , thus , to check for universality . | the multiplier statistics of discrete and continuous nonconservative multiplicative cascade models , employed to describe the energy cascade in fully developed turbulence , is investigated .
it is found to be indistinguishable due to small - scale resummation and restoration of spatial homogeneity .
only the subclass of positively skewed weight distributions , associated to the cascade generator , qualifies to describe observed unconditional as well as conditional multiplier distributions qualitatively ; popular log - poisson and log - stable weight distributions do not share this property . |
for most of the life of a massive star cluster , two - body relaxation is the dominant physical mechanism driving its evolution ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
that is , the cumulative effects of long - range gravitational interactions between stars act to alter their orbits within the cluster .
these interactions push the cluster toward a state of energy equipartition in which all objects have roughly the same kinetic energy .
consequently , the velocities of the most massive objects decrease , and they accumulate in the central regions of the cluster .
similarly , the velocities of the lowest mass objects increase , and they are subsequently dispersed to wider orbits .
this mechanism , called mass segregation , also contributes to the escape of stars from their host cluster across the tidal boundary , with the probability of ejection increasing with decreasing stellar mass .
therefore , two - body relaxation acts to slowly modify the radial distribution of stellar masses within clusters , and can cause very dynamically evolved clusters to be severely depleted of their low - mass stars ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
energy equipartition is an idealized state that should arise after the cumulative effects of many long - range interactions . in a real star cluster with a full spectrum of stellar masses ,
however , equipartition may not actually be achievable ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
as mentioned , the tendency towards energy equipartition reduces the velocities of the heaviest stars , causing them to sink in to the central cluster regions . here ,
they are re - accelerated by the central cluster potential and gain kinetic energy .
as this process proceeds , it leads to a contraction of the core and subsequently a shorter central relaxation time ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
a shorter relaxation time leads to a faster rate of energy transfer from heavier to lighter stars .
eventually , this makes the heaviest stars evolve away from equipartition .
this was first demonstrated by @xcite using analytic techniques and a number of simplifying assumptions .
@xcite adopted a two - component system with masses @xmath1 and @xmath2 ( where @xmath3 ) , forming sub - systems with total masses @xmath4 and @xmath5 . provided that @xmath6 , spitzer derived the conditional requirement for a cluster to achieve energy equipartition in equilibrium . based on this ,
spitzer argued that energy equipartition could not be achieved in a cluster with a realistic mass spectrum , since there should always be enough mass in the heavier species for it to form a sub - system in the central cluster regions that decouples dynamically from the lighter species .
this is commonly called the spitzer instability ( e.g. * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
a particularly compelling example of the spitzer instability involves stellar - mass black holes ( bhs ) in globular clusters ( gcs ) .
@xcite first argued that bhs formed from the most massive stars should rapidly segregate into the core where they decouple dynamically from the rest of the cluster to form a distinct sub - system .
three - body scattering events then lead to the formation of bh - bh binaries , which in turn encounter other bhs and bh - bh binaries .
these 3- and 4-body interactions are sufficiently energetic to eject the bhs from the cluster . in the end
, most bhs are expected to be ejected , leaving only a handful behind .
this picture has recently been challenged in the literature . in particular ,
several authors have argued that the spitzer instability should break down before most bhs are ejected ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , and that the time - scale for all bhs to be ejected could exceed a hubble time in some clusters ( e.g. * ? ? ?
this view is supported by recent claims in the literature that stellar - mass bhs may be present in gcs in surprising numbers . for instance , @xcite recently reported two flat - spectrum radio sources in m22 , which appear to be accreting stellar - mass bhs .
this suggests that this cluster could contain on the order of @xmath7 stellar - mass bhs .
if bhs were indeed efficiently dynamically ejected , this , in turn , would suggest that a more substantial population of bhs once existed in m22 , and likely other gcs as well .
the emerging picture for the formation of massive gcs involves multiple episodes of star formation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in this context ,
@xcite recently considered the implications of the mass growth of bhs formed from massive progenitors belonging to the first generation due to accretion from the interstellar medium .
the authors argued that , in principle , bhs could deplete a significant fraction of the available gas reservoir within @xmath8 years .
if bhs were indeed to accrete efficiently from the ism , they should not only grow in mass , but their velocities should also decrease due to conservation of momentum .
this should preferentially accelerate the process of mass segregation for the bhs , causing them to rapidly accumulate in the central regions of the cluster if they did not form there in the first place .
this could accelerate the dynamical decoupling of the bh sub - population from the rest of the system , and hence the phase of dynamical bh ejections due to the spitzer instability . in this paper ,
we consider how accretion from the interstellar medium affects the rate of mass segregation in a star cluster .
we are especially interested in the implications for bhs in primordial gcs .
thus , we re - visit spitzer s two - component model to derive an accretion - modified relaxation time .
we argue that the rate of mass segregation should be affected by accretion in the following way .
first , assuming the accretion rate increases with the accretor mass , accretion acts to increase the range of any initial mass spectrum , driving the heaviest members to higher masses the fastest .
second , accretion acts to reduce the velocities of the accretors due to conservation of momentum , and it is the heaviest members whose velocities are reduced the fastest .
both of these effects exacerbate the spitzer instability , and should accelerate the rate of mass segregation in a primordial star cluster . in order to better quantify this qualitative picture
, we present our adapted version of spitzer s two - component model in section [ method ] .
specifically , we derive an accretion - modified relaxation time , as well as the critical accretion rate at which the rates of mass segregation due to both two - body relaxation and accretion are equal .
we present our results in section [ results ] for several different assumptions regarding the total cluster mass and accretion rate . in section [ discussion ] , we discuss the implications of our results for both star formation and stellar remnants in primordial globular clusters . we summarize our results in section [ summary ] .
in this section , we present our analytic derivation of an accretion - modified relaxation time for a two - component model star cluster , and derive the critical accretion rate required for the mass segregation timescales due to two - body relaxation and accretion to be equal .
we begin by summarizing briefly the relevant background related to both two - body relaxation and accretion .
consider a two - component model for a star cluster with component masses @xmath9 and @xmath10 , such that @xmath11 .
the populations for these two species have total masses @xmath12 and @xmath13 with @xmath14 .
we let @xmath15 denote the initial mean square speed of _ both _ species , since at birth the cluster is not in a state of energy equipartition .
the e - folding time for the tendency to equipartition bears a striking resemblance to the relaxation time @xcite .
thus , to order of magnitude , the relaxation time can be approximated by calculating the time required for the mean square speed of the heavier species to fall from @xmath15 to a value @xmath16 .
if the potential well of the lighter species is modelled using a parabolic profile , then equipartition will lead to the heavier species being confined to a region of size @xmath17 @xcite .
the total mass of the heavier species within this region is @xmath12 , whereas that for the lighter species is @xmath18 . at this point
, however , it is not clear whether or not the lighter species remains the dominant mass component in this region .
if not , the heavier species becomes increasingly affected by its own self - gravity , and can decouple dynamically from the remainder of the system .
consequently , it may only be possible to achieve equipartition provided @xcite : @xmath19 this is known as spitzer s criterion .
in general , the half - mass relaxation time approximates the rate of two - body relaxation throughout the entire cluster . in gcs , it ranges from roughly a few hundred million years to the age of the universe or longer , and is approximated by @xcite : @xmath20 = 1.7 \times 10 ^ 5[r_{\rm h } [ pc]]^{3/2}n^{1/2}[\bar{m } [ m_{\odot}]]^{-1/2},\ ] ] where @xmath21 is once again the half - mass radius , @xmath22 is the total number of stars within @xmath21 , and @xmath0 is the average stellar mass .
we assume that the value of @xmath21 remains constant in time .
this is reasonable since simulations have shown that @xmath21 changes by not more than a factor of a few over the course of a typical cluster s lifetime @xcite . the timescale for mass segregation due to two - body relaxation for an object of mass @xmath23 is then approximately @xcite : @xmath24
a strict theoretical upper limit for the accretion rate is given by the bondi - hoyle limit @xcite .
in this approximation , the accretion is spherically symmetric , and the forces due to gas pressure are insignificant compared to gravitational forces .
the background gas is treated as uniform and either stationary or moving with constant velocity relative to the accretor .
this assumption gives reasonable accretion rates in the low - density , low - angular momentum regime .
that is , provided the properties of the gas are such that the density , velocity , and total angular momentum are low , at least in the vicinity of the accretor , the bondi - hoyle limit approximately describes the true accretion rate ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for large accretor masses and high gas densities , the bondi - hoyle rate can become extremely high . here , pressure forces could play an important role in reducing the accretion rate .
indeed , this occurs if the outward continuum radiation force balances the inward gravitational force .
this limit , called eddington - limited accretion , gives considerably more modest accretion rates in the high gas density regime @xcite .
the eddington rate should also be much closer to the true accretion rate if the gas contains significant angular momentum , and accretion proceeds mainly via angular momentum re - distribution within a disk ( e.g. * ? ? ?
in general , theoretical studies have shown that the exact accretion rate can deviate substantially from the idealized cases described by bondi - hoyle and eddington - limited accretion .
for example , when an accretor is radiating at above the eddington luminosity , significant amounts of gas can be expelled at high velocities due to the intense winds that are initiated ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
this contributes to a reduction in the overall accretion rate . on the other hand , at very high accretion rates , photon - trapping can occur .
this makes accretion disks radiatively inefficient and provides a means of circumventing the eddington limit @xcite .
numerical studies have also revealed the sensitivity of the accretion rate to small - scale gas dynamics .
recent work by @xcite considered gas accretion onto point masses in a supersonically turbulent medium characterized by background density and velocity distributions that vary in both time and space .
the authors show that in this regime , the accretion rate can either be described by the classical bondi - hoyle approximation , or a vorticity - dominated flow . in the latter case
, the accretion rate can be significantly reduced relative to what is predicted by the bondi - hoyle limit @xcite .
even more recently , @xcite studied the growth and luminosity of bhs in motion with respect to their surrounding medium using two - dimensional axis - symmetric numerical simulations .
the authors show that the accretion rate can actually increase with increasing bh velocity , contrary to the naive predictions of simple analytic theory @xcite . in summary
, theoretical work has shown that a wide range of accretion rates are possible .
we will use the bondi - hoyle and eddington limits for the accretion rate ( combined with an accretion efficiency parameter ) since these provide two different dependences on the accretor mass .
however , the derivation presented in the subsequent section can be used to model other mass - dependences for the accretion rate as well .
we are interested in the mass segregation timescale due to two - body relaxation for the heavier species in the two - component model described in section [ relax ] . to first order ,
this is approximated by : @xmath25 where @xmath26 denotes the half - mass relaxation time obtained by using the total number of objects @xmath27 and average object mass @xmath28 in equation [ eqn : t - rh ] .
we calculate the time - dependence for the mass of an object belonging to species @xmath29 as follows .
first , assuming an object of initial mass @xmath30 accretes at a rate @xmath31 for a total time @xmath32 , we have : @xmath33 for the accretion rate , we assume a mass - dependence of the form : @xmath34 where @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 are all free parameters . the power - law exponent @xmath37 decides the mass - dependence for the accretion rate .
the accretion coefficent @xmath36 is derived according to the physical assumptions that decide the rate of accretion .
for example , adopting the bondi - hoyle approximation implies @xmath38 , and ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) : @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the particle number density , @xmath41 is the sound speed , and @xmath15 is the root - mean - square speed .
similarly , assuming eddington - limited accretion implies @xmath42 , and @xcite : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the speed of light , @xmath45 is the accretion yield from unit mass , and @xmath46 is the electron scattering opacity .
we take @xmath47 @xmath48 g@xmath49 , which assumes a hydrogen mass fraction of @xmath50 .
we further adopt @xmath51 , which is reasonable if the accretors are bhs since this parameter quantifies the amount of energy radiated away during accretion .
the accretion efficiency parameter @xmath35 , on the other hand , is left as a free parameter in our model . in order to solve for the accretor mass as a function of time , equation
[ eqn : mass - time ] can be re - written such that the integral is with respect to mass .
provided @xmath52 , this gives for the mass of an object belonging to species @xmath29 at time @xmath32 : @xmath53 similarly , for @xmath42 , we have : @xmath54 we arrive at the mass segregation timescale due to two - body relaxation for the heavier species by substituting either equation [ eqn : mass - time2 ] or equation [ eqn : mass - time3 ] for both species 1 and 2 into equation [ eqn : tau - seg - time ] .
in addition to two - body relaxation , accretion should also affect the stellar velocities via conservation of momentum . provided the accretion rate increases with increasing accretor mass
, this will reduce the kinetic energy of the heavier species faster than the lighter species , in rough analogy with the effects of two - body relaxation .
thus , accretion - induced changes in the stellar velocities should _ accelerate _ the rate of mass segregation .
we calculate the time needed for accretion to change the velocities of the heavier species from a root - mean - square speed of @xmath15 to a value of @xmath55 .
this corresponds to the time for accretion to affect the velocities of the heavier species by roughly the same amount as is done by two - body relaxation over a single relaxation time . for a given accretion rate and initial masses ,
we calculate the time needed for the mean square speed of the heavier species to reach a value @xmath56 using conservation of momentum , from an initial value @xmath57 . the time needed for the heavier species to reach equipartition via accretion
can then be written : @xmath58 where the final mass is @xmath59 by conservation of momentum . substituting @xmath60 into equation [ eqn : tau - acc ]
, we arrive at the timescale needed for accretion to push the heavier species into approximate equipartition : @xmath61 for @xmath52 .
similarly , for @xmath42 or eddington - limited accretion , we obtain using equation [ eqn : mass - time3 ] : @xmath62 we consider accretion rates with a mass - dependence such that @xmath63 , since this includes both bondi - hoyle and eddington - limited accretion , as well as intermediate and even steeper mass accretion rates .
the total rate ( taken to be the inverse of the total mass segregation timescale @xmath64 ) at which the heavier species achieves mass segregation can be written as the sum of the rate of two - body relaxation and the rate at which accretion pushes the heavier species to equipartition .
re - arranging this equation , we arrive at the total accretion - modified mass segregation timescale for the heavier species : @xmath65 to derive the critical accretion rate @xmath66 at which two - body relaxation and accretion drive the mass segregation process at the same rate , we set @xmath67 and solve for @xmath36 as a function of @xmath37 , @xmath35 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath68 .
this gives for @xmath52 : @xmath69 the procedure is similar for @xmath42 , except we use equation [ eqn : tau - acc3 ] instead of equation [ eqn : tau - acc2 ] .
this gives for eddington - limited accretion : @xmath70 in section [ results ] , we will use equation [ eqn : delta2 ] and equation [ eqn : delta3 ] in order to study the interplay between our assumptions regarding the gas properties , which affect the accretion rate , and our assumption for the total cluster mass , which determines the rate of two - body relaxation .
given our limited understanding of the precise physics of accretion onto a bh , it is not possible to reliably define a functional form for the accretion efficiency parameter @xmath35 . in principle , any realistic accretion model should include a _ time - dependence _ for @xmath71 . in equations [ eqn : tau - acc2 ] and [ eqn : tau - acc3 ] .
] for example , fluctuations in the local gas density due to turbulence , a gradual or even sudden depletion of the available gas reservoir , or dynamical interactions between accreting objects may cause the accretion efficiency to vary over time .
our analysis is easily modified to treat time - dependent accretion rates by substituting an appropriate choice for @xmath71 into either equation [ eqn : tau - acc2 ] or [ eqn : tau - acc3 ] , and then solving for @xmath72 .
plausible choices for @xmath71 may either oscillate or decline ( steadily or abruptly ) in time .
the first case , i.e. an oscillating accretion efficiency , is more easily understood , because under these circumstances , our analysis can simply be interpreted as discussing the _ time - averaged _ accretion efficiency parameter .
thus , in the subsequent sections , we assume an oscillating ( or constant ) accretion efficiency parameter , and discuss only the time - averaged value . for example , the function @xmath73 oscillates between 0 and 2 with a frequency of @xmath74 . in this case , the time - averaged value for @xmath71 is equal to 1 , so that the time - averaged value for @xmath72 remains the same as for a constant @xmath75 .
accretion efficiency parameters that oscillate in time should be suitable to cases where the accretors have alternating `` on '' and `` off '' phases
. this may well be the case with accreting bhs , since the radiation emitted due to accretion can heat the surrounding gas , which in turn decreases the accretion rate ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in this case
, the source of energetic photons responsible for heating the gas is turned off , allowing the gas to cool and accretion to re - start in a `` feedback regulated '' loop ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
accretion efficiency parameters that decline in time should be appropriate to cases where the available gas reservoir is depleted over time .
this could arise gradually if the gas is used to form stars , or if significant quantities of gas are accreted by bhs .
alternatively , the gas reservoir could be depleted suddenly , e.g. due to , energy injected from supernovae , stellar winds , or winds from accreting compact objects . in either case , equations [ eqn : tau - acc2 ] and [ eqn : tau - acc3 ] should include the explicit time - dependence for the accretion efficiency parameter .
this will contribute to an increase in @xmath72 with time , since the decreasing gas mass should translate into a decreasing gas density , and hence accretion rate . in section [ results ] , we will assume that the amount of gas lost from the system is negligible over the calculated mass segregation timescales , and our interpretation of @xmath35 as a time - independent quantity remains valid .
this is reasonable provided the mass segregation timescales due to accretion are much less than the timescale for gas depletion . as we will show in section [ results ] , the current picture for the formation of globular clusters and their multiple populations is consistent with this scenario ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in this section , we present the results of our analytic two - component model for an accretion - modified two - body relaxation time .
our aim is to quantify the relative rates at which two - body relaxation and gas accretion drive a star cluster towards mass segregation , as a function of our assumptions for the gas properties , component masses , and total system mass . to this end , we present the time evolution of all three mass segregation timescales , namely @xmath72 , @xmath76 , and @xmath64 , and discuss the critical accretion rate required for the mass segregation timescales due to two - body relaxation and accretion to be equal as a function of the mass - dependence for the accretion rate .
we begin by quantifying the relative rates of mass segregation due to two - body relaxation and gas accretion for different model assumptions .
specifically , we consider several different mass ratios and total system masses for our two - component model , as well as different mass - dependences for the rate of accretion .
this is meant to quantify the sensitivity of the two different mass segregation mechanisms to the cluster and gas properties that decide their rates .
first , we describe our assumptions for the two - component model star cluster , which are needed in order to calculate @xmath76 .
we adopt @xmath77 m@xmath78 for the lighter species , but consider two different masses for the heavier species , namely @xmath79 m@xmath78 and @xmath80 m@xmath78 .
we assume a population size of @xmath81 for the heavier species , but vary the population size of the lighter species by considering the values @xmath82 . the component masses and population sizes
are chosen to represent reasonable mass ratios between the average stellar and bh masses , and to ensure that the spitzer criterion ( i.e. equation [ eqn : spitzer - criterion ] ) is initially satisfied .
we adopt a half - mass radius for our model cluster of @xmath83 pc , and note that assuming a lower value for the half - mass radius would only shorten the calculated mass segregation timescales .
next , we describe our assumptions for the properties of the accreted gas , which are needed to calculate @xmath72 , and therefore @xmath64 .
we assume a uniform time - independent gas density throughout the cluster , so that the accretion rate changes only with the stellar mass .
we further assume that the gas is always at rest relative to the accretor when calculating the final accretor velocity using conservation of momentum . for the accretors
, we adopt a root mean - square - speed of @xmath84 km s@xmath49 , which is guided by the relation @xmath85
@xcite for a total cluster mass @xmath86 m@xmath78 . for the gas
, we assume a sound speed of @xmath87 km s@xmath49 , and a particle number density of @xmath88 @xmath89 . these assumptions should be reasonable for what is expected in a massive primordial gc for the first @xmath90 years ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we show our results for two different mass - dependencies for the accretion rate .
the left panels in figure [ fig : tau - seg - bh ] show our results assuming @xmath38 in equation [ eqn : acc - rate ] , which corresponds to bondi - hoyle accretion .
we use equation [ eqn : mdot - bh ] for @xmath36 , and @xmath91 for the accretion efficiency parameter . the panels to the right in figure [ fig : tau - seg - bh ] show our results assuming eddington - limited accretion , which means that @xmath42 in equation [ eqn : acc - rate ] and we use equation [ eqn : mdot - edd ] for @xmath36 . the main conclusion to be drawn from figure [ fig : tau - seg - bh ]
is that , for all but the least massive clusters and the lowest accretion rates considered here , the rate of mass segregation due to accretion can actually exceed the rate due to two - body relaxation .
the timescale at which this occurs is on the order of @xmath90 years .
interestingly , this timescale is similar to the total time thought to be required for multiple episodes of star formation to occur in primordial gcs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
thus , our results suggest that accretion from the ism could significantly affect both the spatial and velocity distributions of the heaviest objects in a primordial gc _ before _ the gas reservoir is depleted . for a typical primordial gc , this should be the case provided the average accretion rate is greater than @xmath92% of the eddington - limited rate , assuming the mass - dependence for the accretion rate is linear .
similarly , if the accretion rate scales with the square of the accretor mass , then accretion from the ism is non - negligible as long as the average accretion rate is greater than 1 - 10% of the bondi - hoyle rate . in this section ,
we calculate the critical accretion rate required for the rates of mass segregation due to two - body relaxation and gas accretion to be equal .
our aim is to quantify the relative importance of the different parameters for the cluster and gas properties in establishing a balance between the competing effects of two - body relaxation and accretion . in figure
[ fig : delta - crit ] , we show the critical accretion rate @xmath66 as a function of the mass of the heavier species @xmath1 . these results are calculated using equations [ eqn : delta2 ] and [ eqn : delta3 ] , which correspond to bondi - hoyle ( blue ) and eddington - limited ( red ) accretion , respectively . in both cases ,
we assume a constant mass for the lighter species of @xmath77 m@xmath78 , a constant population size for the heavier species of @xmath81 , and a constant accretion efficiency parameter @xmath93 . in order to vary the rate of two - body relaxation without affecting the rate of mass segregation due to accretion , we consider three different population sizes for the lighter species , namely @xmath82 .
at which the mass segregation timescales due to two - body relaxation and accretion are equal , shown as a function of the mass of the heavier species @xmath1 .
the blue curves show the results assuming bondi - hoyle accretion , whereas the red curves are for eddington - limited accretion .
the dashed , solid , and dash - dotted lines correspond to @xmath94 , respectively . for both sets of curves , we assume a constant mass for the lighter species of @xmath77 m@xmath78 , and we set @xmath93 for the accretion efficiency parameter . [
fig : delta - crit ] ] figure [ fig : delta - crit ] shows that for the case of eddington - limited accretion , the critical accretion rate increases with increasing accretor mass .
this is because , as the accretor mass increases , the mass segregation timescale due to two - body relaxation decreases faster than the mass segregation timescale due to accretion . in the case of bondi - hoyle accretion
, however , the critical accretion rate depends only very weakly on the accretor mass , which is due to the fact that the accretion rate scales as the square of the accretor mass .
we emphasize that with the exception of the eddington - limited rate at large accretor masses , the critical accretion rates are comparable to , or even smaller than , those observed in nearby star - forming regions ( e.g. * ? ? ?
in this section , we discuss the implications of our results for mass segregation in primordial globular clusters , in particular with regards to black holes . one of the key conclusions arising from our analysis is that accretion should accelerate the rate at which a star cluster becomes mass segregated compared to two - body relaxation alone . in fact , accretion can dominate over two - body relaxation in massive clusters for accretion rates that are below the bondi - hoyle or eddington - limited rates by one or even two orders of magnitude .
this is because the relaxation time increases with the cluster mass , whereas the mass segregation timescale due to accretion is independent of the cluster mass ( assuming that the gas properties are independent of the cluster mass ) .
our results suggest that two - body relaxation should dominate the mass segregation process in low - mass primordial clusters with global relaxation times @xmath95 years and hence total cluster masses @xmath96 m@xmath78 , provided that our models assumptions are valid . in this regime
, accretion should only have a small effect on the rate of mass segregation , and long - range gravitational interactions should alter the accretors velocities faster than they are reduced by the accretion process . in more massive clusters , however , the damping effects of accretion could play a significant role in accelerating the rate of mass segregation .
our assumption of a two - component model serves to demonstrate the effects of accretion from the ism on a cluster s dynamical evolution .
the qualitative nature of our results should hold if a realistic mass spectrum is adopted instead .
accretion can modify the distribution of velocities on relatively short timescales in gas - embedded clusters .
how exactly the velocities become modified depends on several parameters , in particular the mass spectrum , the total cluster mass , the properties of the gas , and the accretion rate . in general
, we expect accretion to amplify or exacerbate the spitzer instability .
this is due to the mass - dependence of the accretion rate , and the fact that typically @xmath97 in equation [ eqn : acc - rate ] ( i.e. the accretion rate ) , which causes the more massive component to grow in mass the fastest .
thus , according to equation [ eqn : spitzer - criterion ] , spitzer s criterion should typically break down sooner as a result of accretion .
however , accretion also acts to reduce the velocities of the accretors due to conservation of momentum , and this should most strongly impact the most massive objects due once again to the mass - dependence of the accretion rate . this can actually serve to combat the effects of the spitzer instability by inhibiting the most massive objects from decoupling dynamically from the rest of the system once they have segregated to the central regions of the cluster .
clearly , a more sophisticated treatment will be needed in future studies in order to properly quantify these effects and their implications for the spitzer instability , and a cluster s ability to achieve energy equipartition .
we stress that our results depend sensitively on our assumption for the accretion rate , which is poorly constrained , both theoretically and observationally .
indeed , the accretion efficiency parameter @xmath35 adopted in equation [ eqn : acc - rate ] is needed to account for the many sources of uncertainty in the gas properties , and hence the accretion rate .
for example , our assumption of a uniform , time - independent gas density is an over - simplification .
for one , stellar winds and supernovae could create over- and under - densities in the form of sheets and/or filaments , and the efficiency of these processes should fluctuate in time given the presence of a realistic mass function combined with stellar evolution and the cluster dynamics ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these effects could contribute to a reduction in the accretion rate by increasing the relative velocity between the gas and the accretors , or by reducing the gas density along the trajectories of the accretors .
realistic hydrodynamical simulations of star cluster formation will be needed in order to properly quantify these effects and their implications for the accretion rate .
our results can be used to guide the parameter space relevant to these future studies . in particular , we have placed a lower limit on the minimum accretion rate required for accretion to significantly affect the distribution of stellar velocities on timescales shorter than the relaxation time , as a function of the cluster and gas properties . specifically , the results of our simple model suggest that , for a typical primordial gc , the average accretion rate can not be much less than @xmath92% of the eddington - limited rate , assuming the mass - dependence for the accretion rate is linear
. similarly , for our model assumptions , the average accretion rate can not be much less than @xmath98% of the bondi - hoyle rate if the accretion rate scales with the square of the accretor mass .
we have adopted the same root - mean - square speed for all models , independent of the total cluster mass .
this is a reasonable assumption since the root - mean - square speed scales as @xmath99 , and @xmath21 itself depends weakly on the total cluster mass .
thus , in total , the root - mean - square speed depends only very weakly on the total cluster mass .
nevertheless , if the accretion rate scales inversely with the velocity of the accretor , as is the case with the bondi - hoyle approximation , then the dependence of the root - mean - square speed on the total cluster mass should contribute to a decrease in the accretion rate with increasing cluster mass .
a proper treatment of this effect is beyond the scope of this paper , however , it should certainly be considered in future studies .
the results presented in this paper are especially relevant for black holes in primordial globular clusters , since they should be the most massive objects in the cluster within a few myrs of its formation .
evidence suggests that there should be a substantial gas reservoir in gcs for the first @xmath90 years ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , albeit perhaps intermittently , and that nearly all bhs should form from the most massive cluster members within the first few myrs ( e.g. * ? ?
it follows that the bhs could have on the order of @xmath100 years to accrete gas from the ism .
additionally , since any bhs formed from progenitors more massive than @xmath101 m@xmath78 are only slightly less massive than the progenitors themselves and do not experience natal kicks @xcite , these bhs should have both the shortest mass segregation timescales due to two - body relaxation and the highest accretion rates ( ignoring bh winds and/or compton heating ; see below ) .
the key point is that accretion should act to reduce the mass segregation times of bhs in primordial gcs , and that this effect could be dramatic . beyond this ,
more detailed modeling will be needed to determine the fates of the bhs .
in particular , should the increased rate of mass segregation contribute to accelerating the onset of the hypothesized phase of dynamical bh ejections ? or could the damping effects of accretion be so dramatic that the bhs are driven to merge ( e.g. * ? ? ?
if so , the formation of an intermediate - mass bh ( imbh ) could be the inevitable result .
alternatively , it could be that black hole winds are sufficiently powerful to eject the bulk of the gas from the cluster .
another possibility is that the gas in the immediate vicinity of the bhs becomes very hot due to , for example , compton heating @xcite , such that the accretion rate becomes drastically reduced and bh growth is severely limited ?
a better understanding of how the presence of significant quantities of gas modifies the black hole dynamics in a primordial gc could help to constrain the initial cluster conditions .
for example , if massive bhs should inevitably merge in the presence of gas but no imbhs are observed in present - day gcs , does this necessarily imply that the bhs never formed in the first place ?
if so , this would suggest that stars with masses @xmath102 m@xmath78 must have been rare
. this could be the case , for instance , if massive primordial gcs were assembled from the mergers of many low - mass sub - clumps , as opposed to a single monolothic collapse .
this is because the mass of the most massive cluster member correlates with the total cluster mass ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and hence the massive stellar progenitors of the most massive bhs are unlikely to form in low - mass clusters .
in this paper , we have considered the effects of accretion from the interstellar medium on the rate of two - body relaxation in a star cluster . to do this , we derived an accretion - modified relaxation time by adapting spitzer s two - component model to include the effects of accretion .
we considered several different mass - dependencies and efficiency factors for the accretion rate , as well as different mass ratios for the two components of the model .
we have shown that accretion acts to increase the rate of mass segregation .
this is because the relaxation time is inversely proportional to the average mass , which increases due to accretion .
there are two additional effects that accelerate the mass segregation process , assuming that the accretion rate increases with the accretor mass .
first , accretion acts to increase the range of any initial mass spectrum , quickly driving the heaviest members to even higher masses .
second , accretion acts to reduce the velocities of the accretors due to conservation of momentum , and it is the heaviest members that are affected the most . using our two - component model , these effects have been quantified as a function of the accretion rate , the total cluster mass , and the component masses .
we have discussed our results in the context of the dynamical evolution of primordial globular clusters and their black hole sub - populations .
we kindly thank an anonymous referee for helpful suggestions that improved our manuscript , as well as cole miller for useful discussions . as is supported by nserc .
baumgardt h. , makino j. 2003 , mnras , 340 , 227 baumgardt h. , de marchi g. , kroupa p. 2008
, apj , 685 , 247 binney j. , tremaine s. , 1987 , galactic dynamics ( princeton : princeton university press ) blaes o. , warren o. , madau p. 1995 , apj , 454 , 370 bondi h. , hoyle f. 1944 , mnras , 104 , 273 conroy c. , spergel d. n. 2011 , apj , 726 , 36 conroy c. 2012 , apj , 758 , 21 davies m. b. , miller m. c. , bellovary j. m. 2011 , apj , 740 , 42 de angeli f. , piotto g. , cassisi s. , busso g. , recio - blanco a. , salaris m. , aparicio a. , rosenberg a. 2005 , aj , 130 , 116 de marchi g. , paresce f. , pulone l. 2007 , apj , 656 , l65 de marchi g. , paresce f. , portegies zwart s. 2010 , apj , 718 , 105 dercole a. , vesperini e. , dantona f. , mcmillan s. l. w. , recchi s. 2008 , mnras , 391 , 825 downing j. m. b. , benacquista m. j. , giersz m. , spurzem r. 2010 , mnras , 407 , 1946 dopita m. a. , smith g. h. 1986 , apj , 304 , 283 eddington a. s. 1926 , the internal constitution of the stars ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) eddington a. s. 1930 , mnras , 90 , 279 fall s. m. , zhang q. 2001 , apj , 561 , 751 foglizzo t. , ruffert m. 1999 , a&a , 347 , 901 fryer c. l. , kalogera v. 2001 , apj , 554 , 548 fryer c. l. , belczynski k. , wiktorowicz g. , dominik m. , kalogera v. , holz d. e. 2012 , apj , 749 , 91 fryxell b. a. , taam r. e. 1988 , apj , 335 , 862 gieles m. , heggie d. , zhao h. 2011 , mnras , accepted gratton r. , carretta e. , bragaglia a. 2012 , astronomy & astrophysics review , in press ( arxiv:1201.6526 ) harris , w. e. 1996 , aj , 112 , 1487 ( 2010 update ) heggie d. c. , hut p. 2003
, the gravitational million - body problem : a multidisciplinary approach to star cluster dynamics ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) heggie d. c. , giersz m. 2008 , mnras , 389 , 1858 heggie d. c. , giersz m. 2009 , mnras , 397 , 46 henon m. 1960 , annales dastrophysique , 23 , 668 henon m. 1973 , dynamical structure and evolution of dense stellar systems , ed . l. martinet & m. mayor ( geneva obs . ) pringle j. e. 2006 , mnras , 373 , l90 hoyle f. , lyttleton r. a. 1939 , in proceedings of the cambridge philosophical society , 35 king a. r. , pounds k. a. 2003 , mnras , 345 , 657 kirk h. , myers p. c. 2011 , apj , 727 , 64 kirk h. , myers p. c. 2012 , apj , 745 , 131 krause m. , charbonnel c. , decressin t. , meynet g. , prantzos n. , diehl r. 2012 , a&a , 546 , l5 krause m. , charbonnel c. , decressin t. , meynet g. , prantzos n .. 2013 , a&a , accepted ( arxiv:1302.2494 ) krumholz m. r. , mckee c. f. , klein r. i. 2004 , apj , 611 , 399 krumholz m. r. , mckee c. f. , klein r. i. 2005 , apj , 618 , 757 krumholz m. r. , mckee c. f. , klein r. i. 2006 , apj , 638 , 369 leigh n. w. , umbreit s. , sills a. , knigge c. , glebbeek e. , sarajedini a. 2012 , mnras , 422 , 1592 leigh n. w. , bker t. , maccarone t. j. , perets h. b. 2013 , mnras , 429 , 2997 maccarone t. j. , zurek d. r. 2012 , mnras , 423 , 2 maeder a. 2009 , physics , formation and evolution of rotating stars .
berlin : springer - verlag marks m. , kroupa p. , baumgardt h. 2008 , mnras , 386 , 2047 marks m. , kroupa p. 2010
, mnras , 406 , 2000 mckee c. f. , ostriker e. c. 2007 , ara&a , 45 , 565 moody k. , sigurdsson s. 2009 , apj , 690 , 1370 paczynsky b. , wiita p. j. 1980 , a&a , 88 , 23 park k. , ricotti m. 2013 , apj , submitted ( arxiv:1211.0542 ) phinney s. e. , sigurdsson s. 1991 , nature , 349 , 220 piotto g. , bedin l. r. , anderson j. , king i. r. , cassisi s. , milone a. p. , villanova s. , pietrin- ferni a. , renzini a. 2007 , apj , 661 , l53 portegies zwart s. f. , baumgardt h. , hut p. , makino j. , mcmillan s. l. w. 2004 , nature , 428 , 724 ruffert m. 1994 , apj , 427 , 342 ruffert m. 1997 , a&a , 317 , 793 rybicki g. b. , lightman a. p. 1979
, radiative processes in astrophysics ( new york : wiley - interscience ) spitzer l. jr .
1969 , apj , 158 , 139 spitzer l. jr .
1987 , dynamical evolution of globular clusters ( princeton , nj : princeton univ . press ) strader j. , chomiuk l. , maccarone t. j. , miller - jones j. c. a. , seth a. c. 2012 , nature , 490 , 71 tremaine s. d. , ostriker j. p. , spitzer l. jr .
1975 , apj , 196 , 407 tutukov a. v. 1978 , a&a , 70 , 57 vesperini e. , heggie d. c. 1997 , mnras , 289 , 898 vishniac e. t. 1978 , apj , 223 , 986 von hippel t. , sarajedini a. 1998 , aj , 116 , 1789 webb j. j. , harris w. e. , sills a. 2012 , apj , 759 , 39 yuan f. , xie f. , ostriker j. p. 2009
, apj , 691 , 98 zonoozi a. h. , kupper a. h. w. , baumgardt h. , haghi h. , kroupa p. , hilker m. 2011 , mnras , 411 , 1989 zhang q. , fall s. m. 1999 , apj , 527 , 81 | we consider the effects that accretion from the interstellar medium onto the particles of an n - body system has on the rate of two - body relaxation . to this end
, we derive an accretion - modified relaxation time by adapting spitzer s two - component model to include the damping effects of accretion .
we consider several different mass - dependencies and efficiency factors for the accretion rate , as well as different mass ratios for the two components of the model .
the net effect of accretion is to accelerate mass segregation by increasing the average mass @xmath0 , since the relaxation time is inversely proportional to @xmath0 . under the assumption
that the accretion rate increases with the accretor mass , there are two additional effects that accelerate mass segregation .
first , accretion acts to increase the range of any initial mass spectrum , quickly driving the heaviest members to even higher masses .
second , accretion acts to reduce the velocities of the accretors due to conservation of momentum , and it is the heaviest members that are affected the most . using our two - component model , we quantify these effects as a function of the accretion rate , the total cluster mass , and the component masses .
we conclude by discussing the implications of our results for the dynamical evolution of primordial globular clusters , primarily in the context of black holes formed from the most massive stellar progenitors .
[ firstpage ] globular clusters : general stellar dynamics stars :
formation black hole physics . |
high-@xmath0 partons , produced in dense qcd matter , are expected @xcite to suffer a significant additional medium - induced energy degradation prior to hadronization in the vacuum .
models based on this picture @xcite account for the main modifications of high-@xmath0 hadron production in nucleus - nucleus collisions at rhic , namely the strong suppression of single inclusive hadron spectra , their centrality dependence @xcite , the corresponding suppression of leading back - to - back correlations @xcite , and high-@xmath0 hadron production with respect to the reaction plane @xcite .
to further test the microscopic dynamics of medium - induced parton energy loss , two classes of measurements are now gradually coming into experimental reach @xcite : first , high-@xmath0 particle correlations @xcite , jet shapes and jet multiplicity distributions @xcite will test the predicted relation between the energy loss of the leading parton , the transverse momentum broadening of the parton shower , and the softening of its multiplicity distribution .
second , the relative yields of identified high-@xmath0 hadrons will test the prediction that medium - induced parton energy loss depends on the identity of the parent parton .
hard gluons lose more energy than hard quarks due to the stronger coupling to the medium @xcite , and the energy loss of massive quarks is further reduced @xcite due to the mass - dependent restriction of the phase space into which medium - induced gluon radiation can take place . in the present work
, we calculate the nuclear modification factor for single inclusive high-@xmath0 spectra of charmed and beauty mesons , supplementing the perturbative qcd factorized formalism with radiative parton energy loss .
we also calculate the ratio of nuclear modification factors of heavy - flavored mesons to light - flavored hadrons ( `` heavy - to - light ratios '' ) .
in general , heavy - to - light ratios are sensitive to the following medium - induced effects : 1
. _ color charge dependence of parton energy loss : _ + in contrast to charmed and beauty mesons , light - flavored hadron spectra receive a significant @xmath0 dependent contribution from hard fragmenting gluons .
gluons are expected to lose more energy due to their stronger coupling to the medium .
this increases heavy - to - light ratios at all @xmath0 .
mass dependence of parton energy loss : _ + massive quarks are expected to lose less energy in a medium than light quarks .
this further enhances heavy - to - light ratios as long as the parton mass is not negligible compared to the partonic @xmath0 .
3 . _ medium - dependent trigger bias due to @xmath0 spectrum of parent parton : _ + up to rather high transverse momentum , the partonic @xmath0 spectrum of massive quarks is less steep than that of light quarks . for a more steeply falling spectrum
, the same parton energy loss leads to a stronger reduction of the nuclear modification factor @xcite .
this enhances heavy - to - light ratios .
_ medium - dependent trigger bias due to fragmentation of parent parton : _
+ heavy quark fragmentation functions are significantly harder than light quark ones .
the same parton energy loss leads to a stronger reduction of the nuclear modification factor if the fragmentation function is harder @xcite .
this reduces heavy - to - light ratios .
our aim is to establish for the kinematical ranges accessible at rhic and at the lhc the relative importance of these contributions to heavy - to - light ratios . in this way
, we want to assess the potential of such measurements for further clarifying the partonic mechanism conjectured to underlie jet quenching in nucleus - nucleus collisions .
the theoretical framework of our study is introduced in section [ sec2 ] , and results for the nuclear modification of heavy quark spectra at rhic and at the lhc are given in sections [ sec3 ] and [ sec4 ] , respectively .
we then summarize our main conclusions .
the nuclear modification factor @xmath6 determines the modification of the production of a hadron @xmath7 in a nucleus - nucleus collisions @xmath8@xmath2 compared to an equivalent number of proton - proton collisions , @xmath9 here , @xmath10 is the average number of inelastic nucleon
nucleon collisions in a given centrality class .
it is proportional to the average nuclear overlap function @xmath11 , which is defined via the convolution of the nuclear thickness functions @xmath12 as an integral over the transverse plane at fixed impact parameter @xmath13 , @xmath14 . to calculate the yield of the hadron species @xmath7 from a parent parton @xmath15 ( a massless or massive quark or a gluon ) produced at rapidity @xmath16 with transverse momentum @xmath0
, we start from a collinearly factorized expression supplemented by parton energy loss @xcite , @xmath17 here , @xmath18 and @xmath19 denote the nuclear parton distribution functions for partons @xmath20 carrying momentum fractions @xmath21 , @xmath22 in the colliding nuclei @xmath8 , @xmath2 , respectively .
the total energy of the produced parton is denoted by @xmath23 , its medium - induced parton energy loss by @xmath24 .
the produced hadron carries a fraction @xmath25 of the transverse momentum @xmath26 of the parent parton .
the hard partonic scattering cross section for the production @xmath27 reads @xmath28 .
the fragmentation function @xmath29 maps the parton @xmath30 onto the hadron @xmath7 .
we work at @xmath16 where the parton energy is comparable to the parton transverse momentum , @xmath31 .
this sets the factorization and renormalization scales which are implicitly present in ( [ 2.2 ] ) .
the final state medium - dependence enters ( [ 2.2 ] ) via the probability @xmath32 that the parton loses an additional energy fraction @xmath33 due to medium - induced gluon radiation prior to hadronization in the vacuum .
this so - called quenching weight depends on the in - medium path length of the hard parton and on the density of the medium , parametrized by the variables @xmath34 and @xmath35 . for charm and beauty quarks
, it also depends on the quark mass .
details of the definition of the model parameters and of the calculation of @xmath36 are given in appendix [ appa ] and section [ sec2b ] below .
to establish the baseline for the nuclear modification factor ( [ 2.1 ] ) , we calculate first the high-@xmath0 particle yields ( [ 2.2 ] ) for identified light and heavy - flavored hadrons in the absence of final state medium effects . without medium , the quenching weight takes the form @xmath37 and eq .
( [ 2.2 ] ) reduces to the standard collinearly factorized leading order perturbative qcd formalism . for this baseline ,
we rely on the pythia event generator ( version 6.214 ) @xcite , paralleling the approach used in ref .
@xcite for light - flavored hadrons . as input ,
we use cteq 4l parton distribution functions @xcite with eks98 nuclear corrections @xcite .
all partonic subprocesses @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 and gluon splitting @xmath42 are included in pythia ( option @xmath43 ) .
pythia also accounts for the possibility that a @xmath44-pair is created by ( vacuum ) gluon radiation from the primary partons created in the hard collision .
this effect becomes significant at the lhc but is negligible at rhic .
the splitting @xmath45 requires a high virtuality gluon ( @xmath46 ) which corresponds to a short formation time .
hence , we shall assume later that heavy quark pairs from such a secondary @xmath45 production process have the same in - medium path length as those produced directly in the hard scattering process .
= 8.7 cm = 15.7 cm our parameterization of the fragmentation functions in ( [ 2.2 ] ) is based on the string model implemented in pythia . in particular , we generate with pythia pp events which contain charm ( or beauty ) quarks and we force the semi - electronic decay of corresponding heavy - flavored mesons . from these events we extract the heavy quark yields and the probabilities for a quark @xmath30 of transverse momentum @xmath26 to fragment into a hadron @xmath7 with @xmath47 [ and further into an electron with @xmath48 .
these probabilities will be used as fragmentation functions . for rhic energy , @xmath49 , charm production in pythia
was tuned to reproduce , in shape , the experimental data on the @xmath1 meson @xmath0 distribution in d
au collisions measured by the star collaboration @xcite .
this baseline for charm production at rhic is presented in fig .
the @xmath0 distribution of @xmath1 mesons traces closely that of their parent @xmath50 quarks , but the distribution of electrons is considerably softer .
this complicates attempts to study heavy quark parton energy loss on the basis of single inclusive electron spectra @xcite .
nuclear modifications of the parton distribution functions are seen to affect the @xmath0 spectra at most by @xmath51 at low @xmath0 . for lhc energy , @xmath52
, we use a tuning of pythia @xcite that reproduces the shape of the @xmath0 distributions for charm and beauty quarks given by pqcd calculations at next - to - leading order @xcite with cteq 4 m parton distribution functions , @xmath53 and factorization and renormalization scales @xmath54 for charm , and @xmath55 and @xmath56 for beauty , where @xmath57 .
medium - induced parton energy loss depends on the in - medium path length and the density of the medium .
it is characterized by the medium - induced gluon energy distribution @xmath58 radiated off the hard parton .
this defines the probability distribution for medium - induced energy loss ( `` quenching weight @xmath36 '' ) , entering the cross section ( [ 2.2 ] ) for medium - modified high-@xmath0 hadron production .
further details of this procedure are given in appendix [ appa ] .
the dependence of parton energy loss on density and in - medium path length can be characterized in terms of the time - dependent bdmps transport coefficient @xmath59 which denotes the average squared transverse momentum transferred from the medium to the hard parton per unit path length .
numerically , one finds that the effects of a time - dependent density of the medium on parton energy loss can be accounted for by an equivalent static medium , specified in terms of the time - averaged model parameters @xmath35 and @xmath34 , @xmath60 for light quarks and gluons , the quenching weights @xmath61 have been calculated in ref .
@xcite and they are available as a cpu - inexpensive fortran routine . for the purpose of this work ,
we have extended this calculation to the case of quenching weights @xmath62 for massive quarks , starting from the medium - induced gluon energy distribution determined in ref .
results for these quenching weights are given in appendix [ appa ] and they are publicly available as a cpu - inexpensive fortran routine accompanying this paper @xcite .
we sample the positions @xmath63 of the parton production points in the transverse plane of a nucleus - nucleus collision @xmath8@xmath2 with the probability given by the product of the nuclear thickness functions @xmath64 . for these thickness functions , we choose woods - saxon parameterizations of nuclear density profiles @xcite . for a hard parton with production point @xmath63 and azimuthal propagation direction @xmath65 , the local transport coefficient along the path of the parton is defined as @xcite : @xmath66)\ , .
\label{2.6}\ ] ] here , the constant @xmath30 sets the scale of the transport coefficient .
this defines @xmath35 and @xmath34 in ( [ 2.4 ] ) and ( [ 2.5 ] ) .
all values of transport coefficients used in this work characterize time - averaged properties of the medium their numerical value is determined by the established relation @xcite between parton energy loss in a dynamically expanding and a static medium .
partons that lose their entire energy due to medium effects are redistributed in our formalism according to a thermal distribution @xcite , @xmath67 for the following results , we use @xmath68 . by varying @xmath69 between 5 and @xmath70 ,
we have checked that the choice of @xmath69 affects the nuclear modification factor ( [ 2.1 ] ) only for @xmath71 .
the reasons why the present parton energy loss formalism is not reliable at such low transverse momenta have been mentioned repeatedly @xcite .
accordingly , the main conclusions drawn from our study will be for significantly higher transverse momentum .
recent model studies of the nuclear modification of light - flavored hadrons in au au collisions at rhic favor a time - averaged transport coefficient @xmath72 @xcite . to account for the significant systematic uncertainties of this favored value ,
we calculate here the particle yield ( [ 2.2 ] ) for @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 .
the corresponding nuclear modification factors are shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] for @xmath1 mesons , @xmath50 quarks and for electrons from charm decay . to illustrate the mass dependence of parton energy loss
, we compare the calculation for a realistic charm quark mass @xmath53 to the hypothetical case that the charm quark loses as much energy as a light quark .
the ratio of the two nuclear modification factors thus obtained is shown in fig .
one sees that the mass dependence of final state parton energy loss leads to a significant change of the nuclear modification factor of @xmath1 mesons up to transverse momenta of @xmath76 .
this is consistent with the general observation that the mass dependence of parton energy loss is a function of @xmath77 and becomes negligible for @xmath78 @xcite . in fig .
[ fig2 ] , one also sees that the ratio of the realistic nuclear modification factor to the one for @xmath79 has a maximum around @xmath80@xmath81 , and drops slightly below unity for very small @xmath0 .
this is a generic consequence of the fact that parton energy loss redistributes charm quarks towards the softer region in transverse phase space .
if the depletion at high @xmath0 is less significant due to a finite parton mass , then the resulting enhancement at small @xmath0 is also less significant and this depletes the ratio of nuclear modification factors .
however , at smaller transverse momentum , @xmath82 , soft hadron production or non - perturbative hadronization mechanisms in the medium like recombination or coalescence @xcite ( and the possibility of thermalization @xcite and collisional energy loss @xcite ) have to be considered @xcite to account for the sizable particle species dependence of the nuclear modification factors @xcite . here , parton energy loss alone can not be expected to provide a reliable description .
this complicates the analysis of heavy meson spectra and their decay products at low @xmath0 @xcite . as a consequence ,
the following discussion will mainly focus on the region @xmath83 . as explained in the introduction , the mass dependence of parton energy loss displayed in fig .
[ fig2 ] is only one of several parton species dependent modifications of parton energy loss .
other modifications result from the dependence of parton energy loss on the color charge of the parent parton , and from trigger bias effects related to the partonic @xmath0 spectrum and the parton fragmentation function . to disentangle the relative strength of these effects , we plot in fig .
[ fig3 ] the heavy - to - light ratio @xmath84 ( @xmath7 referring to light - flavored hadrons ) for model calculations in which the above mentioned mass - sensitive medium dependences have been switched off selectively .
parametrically , the mass dependence of the medium - induced parton energy loss and of the trigger biases becomes negligible at high transverse momentum where @xmath85 .
in contrast , the difference between quark and gluon energy loss stays at all @xmath0 due to the ratio of the casimir factors @xmath86 .
hence , at the highest @xmath0 , the color charge dependence of parton energy loss dominates the difference between the nuclear modification factor for light - flavored and heavy - flavored hadrons . in agreement with this argument , fig .
[ fig3 ] shows that the color charge dependence accounts for the dominant deviation of @xmath87 from unity for @xmath88 . at such high transverse momentum ,
charm quarks start to behave like light quarks and the heavy - to - light ratio of @xmath1 mesons becomes mainly sensitive to the color charge dependence of parton energy loss .
however , at rhic energies , the corresponding signal is rather small , see fig .
[ fig3 ] . in combination with the small high-@xmath0 cross sections ,
this may limit a quantitative study of this interesting kinematical regime .
= 11.7 cm medium - dependent trigger bias effects due to the mass dependence of the partonic @xmath0 spectrum and due to the fragmentation function largely compensate each other .
they go in the directions indicated by the general arguments in the introduction , but they are negligible over the entire @xmath0 range displayed in fig .
[ fig3 ] .
the mass dependence of parton energy loss dominates the deviation of @xmath87 from unity for @xmath89 .
however , as discussed above , the particle species dependence of @xmath90 for @xmath91 @xcite makes the application of parton energy loss questionable .
thus , to assess the mass dependence of parton energy loss with the heavy - to - light ratio @xmath87 at rhic , one should focus on the kinematical region , @xmath5 .
even in that region , the color charge effect is sizable and has to be taken into account in a quantitative analysis , see fig .
to calculate the nuclear modification of high-@xmath0 particle yields in pb
pb collisions at lhc energy @xmath92 , the density of the produced matter has to be characterized , e.g. by the bdmps transport coefficient @xmath93 , see section [ sec2 ] .
this transport coefficient is proportional to the particle multiplicity in the collision . in refs .
@xcite the relative increase of the event multiplicity from rhic to lhc has been taken to be @xmath94 @xcite , but other more recent estimates give a significantly smaller increase @xmath95 @xcite . here , we scan a very wide range of the model parameter space by varying @xmath93 between a low estimate at rhic energies and the highest estimates for lhc energies , @xmath96 , @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
= 11.7 cm at the lhc as at rhic , a significant mass dependence of the nuclear modification factor of @xmath1 mesons and of their decay electrons is limited to transverse momenta below @xmath99 , see fig .
however , at the lhc , there are arguments that non - perturbative hadronization mechanisms such as recombination may dominate the medium modification of identified particle yields up to even higher transverse momenta than at rhic @xcite .
thus , the mass dependence of parton energy loss will dominate the deviation of the heavy - to - light ratio of @xmath1 mesons from unity only in a rather small kinematical window , if at all . at higher transverse momenta , @xmath100 ,
the charm mass dependence of parton energy loss becomes negligible since @xmath85 , see fig .
remarkably , however , even if charm mass effects are neglected , the heavy - to - light ratio @xmath87 shows for realistic model parameters a significant enhancement @xmath101 in a theoretically rather clean and experimentally accessible kinematical regime of high transverse momenta @xmath102 , see fig .
[ fig8 ] ( upper panels ) .
the reason is that parton production at mid - rapidity tests values of bjorken @xmath103 which are a factor @xmath104 smaller at lhc than at rhic . at smaller bjorken @xmath103 , a larger fraction of the produced light - flavored hadrons
have gluon parents and thus the color charge dependence of parton energy loss can leave a much more sizable effect in the heavy - to - light ratio @xmath87 at lhc . in summary ,
charm quarks giving rise to @xmath1 mesons in the kinematical range @xmath102 behave essentially like massless quarks in pb
pb collisions at the lhc .
but the significant gluonic contribution to light - flavored hadron spectra in this kinematical range makes the heavy - to - light ratio @xmath87 a very sensitive hard probe for testing the color charge dependence of parton energy loss .
= 11.7 cm at the higher lhc energies , the higher mass scale of @xmath4 quarks can be tested in the corresponding nuclear modification factors and heavy - to - light ratios for @xmath2 mesons and for electrons from @xmath4 decays . as seen in figs .
[ fig8 ] and [ fig7 ] , for transverse momenta @xmath102 , the mass dependence of parton energy loss modifies the nuclear modification factor by a factor 2 or more .
it dominates over the color charge dependence .
as for all spectra discussed above , the medium - dependence of trigger bias effects is rather small for beauty production at the lhc [ in fig .
[ fig8 ] , these trigger bias effects account for the small but visible differences between @xmath87 and @xmath105 in the model calculation in which the mass dependence of parton energy loss has been neglected . ] .
we conclude that the heavy - to - light ratio @xmath105 in pb
pb collisions at the lhc provides a very sensitive hard probe for testing the parton mass dependence of parton energy loss in the theoretically rather clean and experimentally accessible kinematical regime of @xmath102 .
the mass dependence of parton energy loss and its phenomenological consequences for heavy - to - light ratios have received significant interest recently @xcite , since they provide a tool to test the conjectured microscopic dynamics underlying the phenomenon of high-@xmath0 hadron suppression at rhic . here , we have shown that heavy - to - light ratios are not solely sensitive to the mass dependence of parton energy loss , but also to its color charge dependence . the task for both experiment and theory is to identify and to disentangle both effects .
this issue is of fundamental importance since the more precise understanding of the dynamics modifying a hard probe is a prerequisite for the more precise understanding of the properties of what is probed , namely dense qcd matter .
previous proposals to search for the color charge dependence of parton energy loss either tried to exploit the weak @xmath0 dependence of the quark - to - gluon ratio of parent partons in light - flavored hadron spectra @xcite .
alternatively , they focused on proton - to - antiproton ratios at high @xmath0 @xcite .
since antibaryons receive a larger fragmentation contribution from gluon parents , parton energy loss predicts an increase of the @xmath106 ratio with increasing @xmath0 .
however , the kinematical range for studying proton - to - antiproton ratios is rather restricted due to experimental limitations on measuring identified baryons at high-@xmath0 , and due to the anomalous baryon - to - meson ratio which complicates the physics interpretation at intermediate @xmath0 ( @xmath91 ) .
similar caveats apply to the ratio @xmath107 .
this baryon - to - antibaryon ratio may have the experimental advantage that it can be measured via topological reconstruction to higher @xmath0 than the @xmath106 ratio .
however , its sensitivity to the medium - modification of parton dynamics remains to be assessed , and may be complicated due to our limited knowledge about @xmath108 fragmentation functions .
compared to these measurements , the heavy - to - light ratios of @xmath1 mesons have significant experimental and theoretical advantages . in particular , in pb
pb collisions at the lhc , they show a high sensitivity to the color charge dependence of parton energy loss in a kinematical range @xmath102 in which charm quarks behave like light quarks and other medium modifications are expected to be negligible , see section [ sec4 ] . thus , they provide a unique way to `` tag '' a light quark ( namely the charm quark ) since they can be characterized experimentally by cross - checking several relatively clean decay channels . on the other hand ,
the heavy - to - light ratio of @xmath2 mesons in the same kinematical regime @xmath102 at the lhc is expected to be predominantly sensitive to the mass dependence of parton energy loss , showing significant enhancement factors of the order @xmath109 , see section [ sec4 ] .
thus , a combined analysis of open charm and beauty mesons at the lhc provides the means to quantify and to disentangle the characteristic differences of the strength of the parton energy loss for the different identities of the parent parton . in nucleus - nucleus collisions at rhic ,
the task of identifying and disentangling the color charge and mass dependence of parton energy loss is more challenging , since a significantly smaller kinematical range of high transverse momentum is experimentally accessible .
in particular , the region up to at least @xmath91 can only provide circumstantial evidence to this end , since it is known to receive significant additional particle species dependent non - perturbative contributions . in view of the present study ,
the first use of rhic heavy meson spectra in the context of testing parton energy loss is to test the _ combined _ effect of the mass and color charge dependence of parton energy loss in the kinematical range @xmath5 where @xmath87 is expected to be gently but visibly enhanced above unity , see section [ sec3 ] .
we finally note that correlation measurements may provide important complementary information for elucidating the influence of parton identity on final state parton energy loss .
for example , requiring that a high-@xmath0 trigger hadron at forward rapidity is balanced by a recoil at mid - rapidity , one may be able to study medium - modified hadron production in a configuration which enriches the contribution of gluon parents . both at rhic and at the lhc , the class of correlation measurements with this potential is large .
it includes many as yet unexplored observables such as three jet events which in large acceptance experiments at the lhc may give access to the study of well - separated samples of quark and gluon jets .
these correlations lie outside the scope of the present work . to the best of our knowledge
, it is an open question whether some of them have a similar or even higher sensitivity to the mass and color charge dependence of parton energy loss than the ratios of particle identified single inclusive hadron spectra studied here .
* acknowledgment : * we thank peter jacobs for helpful discussions .
in this appendix , we give details of how to calculate the probability @xmath110 that a quark of mass @xmath111 and initial energy @xmath23 loses an energy fraction @xmath112 due to medium - induced gluon radiation .
we start from the medium - induced distribution of gluons of energy @xmath113 and transverse momentum @xmath114 , radiated off the hard massive quarks due to multiple scattering in the spatially extended medium @xcite @xmath115\ , .
\label{a.1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the strong coupling constant @xmath116 and casimir operator @xmath117 determine the coupling strength of gluons to the massive quark .
the physical interpretation of the internal integration variables in ( [ a.1 ] ) has been explained elsewhere @xcite and plays no role in what follows . for numerical calculations ,
we use @xmath118 .
( [ a.1 ] ) resums the effects of arbitrary many medium - induced scatterings to leading order in @xmath119 .
the parton mass dependence enters the gluon energy distribution ( [ a.1 ] ) via the phase factor @xmath120 $ ] @xcite , where @xmath121 is defined as the difference between the total three momentum of the initial quark ( @xmath122 ) , and the final quark ( @xmath123 ) and gluon ( @xmath30 ) , @xmath124 the medium - dependence enters ( [ a.1 ] ) via the product of the time - dependent density @xmath125 of scattering centers times the strength of a single elastic scattering @xmath126 . in what follows
, we work in the multiple soft scattering approximation @xmath127 where the path integral in ( [ a.1 ] ) can be evaluated in a saddle point approximation .
this approximation is known to lead to results which are physically equivalent @xcite to other approaches . for a hard parton which transverses a time - independent medium of length @xmath128
, we have @xmath129 . for the realistic case of an expanding medium @xcite
, the radiation spectrum is the same as that for an equivalent static medium of appropriately rescaled transport coefficient .
this dynamical scaling law is used to define in ( [ 2.4 ] ) and ( [ 2.5 ] ) the only medium - dependent parameters @xmath35 and @xmath34 . in fig .
[ figa1 ] the medium - modified part of the @xmath114 integrated gluon energy distribution ( [ a.1 ] ) is plotted for different values of @xmath77 and @xmath130 where @xmath131 .
the probability that in the parton fragmentation process of the hard massive quark , an additional amount @xmath24 of the initial quark energy is lost due to multiple medium - induced gluon radiation , can be modeled by a poissonian process @xcite , @xmath132 \label{a.4}\\ & & \quad \times \delta\left(\delta e -\sum_{i=1}^n { \omega_i } \right ) \exp\left [ - \int { { \rm d}}\omega \frac{di^{\rm med}}{d\omega}\right]\ . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we calculate this probability distribution via its mellin transform as described in ref .
it has a discrete and a continuous part @xmath133 the discrete contribution @xmath134 is plotted in fig .
[ figa2 ] .
it denotes the probability that the hard parton escapes the collision region without further interaction @xcite .
accordingly , this probability decreases with increasing density or increasing in - medium path length . for sufficiently large in - medium path length or density , @xmath135
, the discrete part @xmath134 also increases with @xmath77 this is consistent with a mass - dependent reduction of parton energy loss .
the continuous part of ( [ a.5 ] ) denotes the probability that the hard parton loses an additional energy @xmath24 due to medium - induced gluon radiation . as seen in fig .
[ figa3 ] , this part increases with increasing in - medium path length or increasing density , since it depends on @xmath136 .
also , for sufficiently large @xmath137 , the probability of losing a large energy @xmath24 is seen to decrease with increasing mass , as expected for a mass - dependent reduction of parton energy loss .
in contrast , for the parameter range @xmath138 , the relation between parton energy loss and mass dependence is more complicated and not monotonic , see fig .
[ figa3 ] for details .
the latter case is of little practical relevance since it corresponds to very small medium effects , see also @xcite . the quenching weight @xmath110 is a generalized probability which is normalized to unity .
we have checked that the numerical results presented in figs .
[ figa2 ] and [ figa3 ] satisfy the normalization condition @xmath139 our starting point , the gluon energy distribution ( [ a.1 ] ) , is derived in the eikonal limit and holds to leading order in @xmath119 . in this high energy approximation , it is possible that for a finite parton energy @xmath23 , the quenching weight has support in the region @xmath140 .
this is clearly an artifact of the formalism .
we correct it by assuming that a parton which is predicted to lose more than its total energy has lost all its energy in the medium . to this end , we truncate @xmath141 at @xmath142 but we ensure the normalization ( [ a.6 ] ) by adding a @xmath143-function @xcite @xmath144 the corresponding monte carlo implementation is : sample an energy loss @xmath24 and set the new parton energy to 0 if @xmath145 . the size of the remainder term @xmath146 has been used @xcite to estimate the systematic theoretical uncertainties in this formalism .
these uncertainties increase with increasing parton energy loss and they decrease with increasing transverse momentum . for the nuclear modification factors @xmath90 of both light - flavored and heavy - flavored hadrons , they amount to typical uncertainties of @xmath147 at @xmath148 and @xmath149 at @xmath150 .
99 m. gyulassy and x. n. wang , nucl .
b * 420 * ( 1994 ) 583 .
r. baier , y. l. dokshitzer , a. h. mueller , s. peigne and d. schiff , nucl .
b * 484 * ( 1997 ) 265 .
b. g. zakharov , jetp lett .
* 65 * ( 1997 ) 615 .
u. a. wiedemann , nucl .
b * 588 * ( 2000 ) 303 .
m. gyulassy , p. levai and i. vitev , nucl .
b * 594 * ( 2001 ) 371 .
x. n. wang and x. f. guo , nucl .
a * 696 * ( 2001 ) 788 .
x. n. wang , phys .
b * 579 * ( 2004 ) 299 .
a. dainese , c. loizides and g. paic , eur .
j. c * 38 * ( 2005 ) 461 .
k. j. eskola , h. honkanen , c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , nucl .
a * 747 * ( 2005 ) 511 .
m. gyulassy , i. vitev and x. n. wang , phys . rev
. lett . * 86 * ( 2001 ) 2537 .
a. drees , h. feng and j. jia , arxiv : nucl - th/0310044 . i. vitev and m. gyulassy , phys .
* 89 * ( 2002 ) 252301 .
t. hirano and y. nara , phys .
c * 66 * ( 2002 ) 041901 .
k. adcox _ et al . _
[ phenix collaboration ] , phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 022301 .
s. s. adler _ et al .
_ [ phenix collaboration ] , phys .
c * 69 * ( 2004 ) 034910 .
c. adler _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
* 89 * ( 2002 ) 202301 .
j. adams _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 91 * ( 2003 ) 172302 .
b. b. back _ et al . _
[ phobos collaboration ] , phys .
b * 578 * ( 2004 ) 297 .
i. arsene
_ et al . _
[ brahms collaboration ] , phys .
* 91 * ( 2003 ) 072305 .
c. adler _ et al .
_ [ star collaboration ] , phys .
* 90 * ( 2003 ) 082302 .
j. adams _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 252301 .
u. a. wiedemann , j. phys .
g * 30 * ( 2004 ) s649 .
a. majumder and x. n. wang , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 014007 .
a. majumder and x. n. wang , arxiv : hep - ph/0411174 .
a. majumder , e. wang and x. n. wang , arxiv : nucl - th/0412061 . c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , phys .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 042301 .
s. pal and s. pratt , phys . lett .
b * 574 * ( 2003 ) 21 .
n. armesto , c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , phys .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 242301 .
n. armesto , c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , arxiv : hep - ph/0411341 .
y. l. dokshitzer and d. e. kharzeev , phys .
b * 519 * ( 2001 ) 199 .
n. armesto , c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 114003 .
b. w. zhang , e. wang and x. n. wang , phys .
* 93 * ( 2004 ) 072301 .
m. djordjevic and m. gyulassy , nucl .
a * 733 * ( 2004 ) 265 .
r. baier , y. l. dokshitzer , a. h. mueller and d. schiff , jhep * 0109 * ( 2001 ) 033 .
a. dainese , eur .
j. c * 33 * ( 2004 ) 495 .
t. sjostrand , l. lonnblad and s. mrenna , arxiv : hep - ph/0108264 . h. l. lai _ et al . _
[ cteq collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 12 * ( 2000 ) 375 .
k. j. eskola , v. j. kolhinen and c. a. salgado , eur .
phys . j. c * 9 * ( 1999 ) 61 .
a. tai [ star collaboration ] , j. phys .
g * 30 * ( 2004 ) s809 .
j. adams _ et al . _
[ star collaboration ] , arxiv : nucl - ex/0407006 .
s. batsouli , s. kelly , m. gyulassy and j. l. nagle , phys .
b * 557 * ( 2003 ) 26 .
x. y. lin , arxiv : hep - ph/0412124 .
n. carrer and a. dainese , arxiv : hep - ph/0311225 . m. l. mangano , p. nason and g. ridolfi , nucl . phys .
b * 373 * ( 1992 ) 295 . c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 014008 .
the fortran subroutine for quenching weights of massive quarks can be downloaded from http://www.pd.infn.it/@xmath151dainesea/qwmassive.html .
c. w. de jager , h. de vries and c. de vries , atom .
data nucl .
data tabl .
* 14 * ( 1974 ) 479 .
z. w. lin , r. vogt and x. n. wang , phys .
c * 57 * ( 1998 ) 899 .
m. i. gorenstein , a. p. kostyuk , h. stocker and w. greiner , phys .
b * 509 * ( 2001 ) 277 .
a. andronic , p. braun - munzinger , k. redlich and j. stachel , phys .
b * 571 * ( 2003 ) 36 .
z. w. lin and d. molnar , phys .
c * 68 * ( 2003 ) 044901 . h. van hees and r. rapp , arxiv : nucl - th/0412015 .
g. d. moore and d. teaney , arxiv : hep - ph/0412346 .
p. romatschke and m. strickland , arxiv : hep - ph/0408275 .
m. g. mustafa , arxiv : hep - ph/0412402 .
j. adams _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . rev
. lett .
* 92 * ( 2004 ) 052302 .
s. s. adler _ et al . _
[ phenix collaboration ] , phys .
* 91 * ( 2003 ) 172301 .
s. s. adler _ et al .
_ [ phenix collaboration ] , arxiv : nucl - ex/0409028 .
k. j. eskola , k. kajantie , p. v. ruuskanen and k. tuominen , nucl .
b * 570 * ( 2000 ) 379 .
n. armesto , c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , phys .
* 94 * ( 2005 ) 022002 .
a. accardi _ et al .
_ , arxiv : hep - ph/0310274 . i. p. lokhtin , l. i. sarycheva , a. m. snigirev and k. y. teplov , eur .
j. c * 37 * ( 2004 ) 465 .
b. w. zhang , e. k. wang and x. n. wang , arxiv : hep - ph/0412060 . m. djordjevic , m. gyulassy and s. wicks , arxiv : hep - ph/0410372 . w. c. xiang , y. x. mao , j. liu , h. t. ding , d. c. zhou and d. rohrich , arxiv : hep - ph/0501041 .
r. thomas , b. kampfer and g. soff , arxiv : hep - ph/0405189 .
q. wang and x. n. wang , arxiv : nucl - th/0410049 .
x. n. wang , phys .
c * 58 * ( 1998 ) 2321 .
c. a. salgado and u. a. wiedemann , phys .
* 89 * ( 2002 ) 092303 .
r. baier , y. l. dokshitzer , a. h. mueller and d. schiff , phys .
c * 58 * ( 1998 ) 1706 . | the ratio of nuclear modification factors of high-@xmath0 heavy - flavored mesons to light - flavored hadrons ( `` heavy - to - light ratio '' ) in nucleus - nucleus collisions tests the partonic mechanism expected to underlie jet quenching .
heavy - to - light ratios are mainly sensitive to the mass and color - charge dependences of medium - induced parton energy loss . here
, we assess the potential for identifying these two effects in @xmath1 and @xmath2 meson production at rhic and at the lhc . to this end , we supplement the perturbative qcd factorized formalism for leading hadron production with radiative parton energy loss . for @xmath1 meson spectra at high but experimentally accessible transverse momentum ( @xmath3 ) in pb
pb collisions at the lhc , we find that charm quarks behave essentially like light quarks . however , since light - flavored hadron yields are dominated by gluon parents , the heavy - to - light ratio of @xmath1 mesons is a sensitive probe of the color charge dependence of parton energy loss .
in contrast , due to the larger @xmath4 quark mass , the medium modification of @xmath2 mesons in the same kinematical regime provides a sensitive test of the mass dependence of parton energy loss . at rhic energies , the strategies for identifying and disentangling the color charge and mass dependence of parton energy loss are more involved because of the smaller kinematical range accessible .
we argue that at rhic , the kinematical regime best suited for such an analysis of @xmath1 mesons is @xmath5 , whereas the study of lower transverse momenta is further complicated due to the known dominant contribution of additional , particle species dependent , non - perturbative effects .
1.5 cm |
recently , the h1 @xcite and zeus @xcite collaborations at hera presented data on the differential cross section @xmath5 of inclusive @xmath0 production in low-@xmath6 collisions , where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the rapidity and transverse momentum of the produced @xmath0 mesons in the laboratory frame , respectively .
these measurements extended up to @xmath9 gev . these data were compared with next - to - leading order ( nlo ) qcd predictions in the so - called massless - charm scheme @xcite and good agreement was found . in the massless - charm scheme ,
the charm - quark mass @xmath10 is neglected , which should be a reasonable approximation for @xmath11 . in this approach
, charm is considered to be one of the active flavours in the same way as the lighter @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 quarks .
then , the collinear singularities corresponding to the @xmath15 terms in a scheme where the charm - quark mass is finite and only three active flavours are taken into account , are absorbed into the charm - quark parton density functions ( pdf s ) and into the fragmentation functions ( ff s ) of charm quarks into @xmath0 mesons .
thus , in a nlo analysis , the following ingredients are needed : @xmath16 the hard - scattering cross sections for the direct- and resolved - photon processes calculated in the massless approximation ( @xmath17 ) with @xmath18 active flavours and with the initial- and final - state collinear singularities , including those of the charm quark , subtracted ; @xmath19 the pdf s of the proton and the resolved photon , where charm is treated as a light flavour ; @xmath20 the ff s characterizing the hadronization of the massless partons , including the charm quark , into @xmath0 mesons .
( similarly , the bottom quark is treated as a massless parton above a certain threshold , leading to @xmath21 . )
this massless approach was originally considered in @xcite as a possibility to make predictions for large-@xmath8 heavy - quark production , and it was first applied to the production of large-@xmath8 hadrons containing bottom quarks in @xmath22 collisions @xcite .
subsequently , it was employed to study charm - quark production in @xmath4 @xcite , @xmath23 @xcite , and @xmath24 collisions @xcite . in order to obtain definite predictions for @xmath0 production cross sections in the massless - charm scheme ,
one obviously needs the pdf s of the charm quarks in the proton and the photon , which do not enter the massive calculation , as well as the ff s for @xmath0 mesons .
both the pdf s and ff s are basically non - perturbative input and must be determined by experiment .
this offers the possibility to use the data of @xmath0-photoproduction experiments in regions where the massless - charm approach is a good approximation , to obtain information on the charm pdf s of the proton and the photon and on the ff s of the quarks , in particular the charm quark , and the gluon into @xmath0 mesons .
the ff s of the @xmath0 mesons can be determined from measured cross sections of @xmath0 production in @xmath1 annihilation . in these experiments ,
the centre - of - mass ( cm ) energy @xmath25 of the electron - positron system is large compared to @xmath10 , so that the massless - charm approach is well justified in this case .
then , one is left with the task of constraining the charm components of the proton and the photon .
the photon pdf s enter , for instance , the resolved - photon cross section of inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction in @xmath4 collisions . in a previous work by two of us with spira @xcite
, it was found that , at moderate @xmath8 , the resolved - photon cross section is of the same order of magnitude as the direct - photon cross section .
furthermore , the additional charm component in the proton turned out to only contribute marginally to the cross section of inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction .
therefore , the study of this cross section offers an ideal possibility to specifically learn about the charm component of the photon , on which not very much is known from other experiments .
the traditional place to investigate the charm pdf of the photon has been fully inclusive deep inelastic charmed - hadron production in @xmath26 collisions . unfortunately ,
very little is known experimentally so far @xcite .
several nlo parameterizations of the charm component of the photon exist in the literature @xcite , and we shall use them for our predictions in the following .
the point to be made is that these charm pdf s have not yet really been tested against experimental data which are particularly sensitive to it . in the previous work on @xmath0 production @xcite
, we considered several approximations for the fragmentation of charm quarks into @xmath0 mesons , including also the @xmath6 evolution to higher scales .
the most realistic description was by the peterson ff @xcite with evolution , which was also used for the comparison with the h1 @xcite and zeus @xcite data .
apart from the overall normalization , the distribution of peterson et al .
, which is used as input at the starting scale @xmath27 , depends only on one parameter , @xmath2 .
the value of @xmath2 was taken from the work by chrin @xcite , which is a phenomenological analysis of data on charmed - meson production ( not necessarily restricted to @xmath0 production ) in the petra - pep energy range of @xmath1 annihilation . in the meantime ,
much better data , specifically on @xmath0 production , have been made available by the aleph @xcite and opal @xcite collaborations at lep1 .
these data should give us an excellent handle on the @xmath0 ff s , so that we need not rely on chrin s value for the @xmath2 parameter any more .
it is the purpose of this work to improve the description of the charm and bottom ff s into @xmath0 mesons by fitting to the aleph and opal data on the basis of nlo evolution equations .
these ff s will be tested against @xmath0 production data at lower cm energies @xcite coming from petra @xcite , pep @xcite , and doris @xcite .
they will also be used to make theoretical predictions for inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction at hera , following the earlier work @xcite .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section 2
, we shall briefly describe the nlo formalism of charm - quark fragmentation including the transition from massless to massive factorization of final - state collinear singularities also employed in @xcite .
in this section , we shall specify the @xmath0 ff s at the starting scale @xmath27 , adopting two different functional forms .
we shall consider not only charm - quark fragmentation , but also bottom - quark fragmentation which is needed to describe the lep1 data .
finally , we shall present the resulting nlo predictions for @xmath0 production in @xmath1 annihilation and compare them with data from aleph and opal used in the fits , and with the other @xmath1 data at lower cm energies . in section 3
, we shall confront our predictions for @xmath28 based on the two forms of ff s with the zeus data @xcite .
our conclusions are summarized in section 4 .
to construct lo and nlo sets of ff s for @xmath0 mesons , we make use of the new lep1 data from aleph @xcite and opal @xcite . in hadronic
@xmath29-boson decays , charmed mesons are expected to be produced either directly through the hadronization of charm quarks in the process @xmath30 or via the weak decays of @xmath31 hadrons produced in @xmath32 , with an approximately equal rate .
charmed mesons from @xmath30 allow us to measure the charm - quark ff .
the main task of both experimental analyses was to disentangle these two main sources of @xmath0 production at the @xmath29-boson resonance .
in the two papers @xcite , a number of different techniques are used to tag @xmath0 mesons from @xmath31 decay .
the @xmath0 mesons are reconstructed in the decay chain @xmath33 and @xmath34 , which allows for a particularly clean signal reconstruction .
the results of the two measurements are separate , differential yields for @xmath0 mesons from @xmath35 and @xmath36 decays , normalized to the total number of multihadronic @xmath29-boson decays , as a function of @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the measured energy of the @xmath0 candidate .
the contribution due to charm - quark fragmentation is peaked at large @xmath39 , whereas the one due to bottom - quark fragmentation has its maximum at small @xmath39 . for the fitting procedure ,
we use the @xmath39 bins contained within the interval @xmath40 $ ] and integrate the theoretical functions over the bin widths , which is equivalent to the experimental binning procedure . as in the experimental analyses , we sum over @xmath41 and @xmath42 mesons . as a consequence ,
there is no difference between the ff s of a given quark and its antiquark .
we take the starting scales for the @xmath0 ff s of the gluon and the @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath43 quarks and antiquarks to be @xmath44 , while we take @xmath45 in the case of bottom .
the ff s of the gluon and the first three flavours are assumed to be zero at the starting scale .
these ff s are generated through the @xmath46 evolution , and the ff s of the first three quarks and antiquarks coincide with each other at all scales @xmath47 .
for the parameterization of the charm- and bottom - quark ff s at their respective starting scales , we employ two different forms : @xmath16 in our standard set ( s ) , the ff s of the charm and bottom quarks are both assumed to be of a form usually used for the ff s of light hadrons , namely , @xmath48 where @xmath49 . here and in the following
, we skip the index @xmath0 , since we only consider @xmath0 production throughout this paper , e.g. , @xmath50 denotes the ff of the charm quark into @xmath0 mesons , etc .
@xmath19 in the so - called mixed set ( m ) , we use for the bottom - quark ff the form of ( [ standard ] ) and for the charm - quark ff the peterson distribution @xcite , @xmath51 ^ 2}.\ ] ] the peterson form is particularly suitable to describe ff s that peak at large @xmath39 . since the bottom - quark ff has its maximum at smaller @xmath39 values , we obtain intolerably bad fits if we also use ( [ peterson ] ) in the case of bottom .
this is the reason for choosing the bottom - quark ff at @xmath45 in set m to be of form ( [ standard ] ) .
obviously , the functional form ( [ standard ] ) has more flexibility , since , apart from the normalization factor @xmath52 , it depends on two parameters , @xmath53 and @xmath54 , whereas there is just a single parameter , @xmath2 , in the peterson distribution . the cross section of inclusive @xmath0 production in @xmath1 annihilation , @xmath55 is calculated from the same formula as for any other hadron , @xmath56 here , the sum extends over all active partons ( @xmath57 ) , @xmath47 is the renormalization scale of the partonic subprocesses , and @xmath58 is the fragmentation scale . at nlo , @xmath58 defines the point where the divergence associated with collinear radiation off parton @xmath59 is to be subtracted .
this applies to the @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 quarks as well as for the @xmath43 and @xmath60 quarks , the masses of which are neglected . to nlo in the modified minimal subtraction ( @xmath61 )
scheme , the cross sections of the relevant subprocesses are given by @xmath62\right\ } , \nonumber\\ \frac{1}{\sigma_{tot}}\,\frac{d\sigma_g}{dx}\left(x,\mu^2,m_f^2\right ) & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&2\frac{\alpha_s(\mu^2)}{2\pi } \left[p_{q\to g}^{(0,t)}(x)\ln\frac{s}{m_f^2}+c_g(x)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath63 are the effective electroweak couplings of the quarks @xmath64 to the @xmath29-boson and the photon including propagator adjustments , and @xmath65 are the lo timelike splitting functions , which may be found in the appendix .
the @xmath66 functions are given by @xcite @xmath67\delta(1-x ) -\frac{3}{2}\left(\frac{1}{1-x}\right)_+ + 2\left[\frac{\ln{(1-x)}}{1-x}\right]_+ + \frac{5}{2}-\frac{3}{2}x \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
4\frac{\ln x}{1-x}-(1+x)\left[2\ln x+\ln(1-x)\right]\right\ } , \nonumber\\ c_g(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & c_f\frac{1+(1-x)^2}{x}\left[2\ln x+\ln(1-x)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath68 , @xmath69 , and the plus distributions are defined in the appendix .
we evaluate @xmath70 using the two - loop formula with @xmath21 flavours .
we identify @xmath71 , so that , in ( [ xsection ] ) , the terms involving @xmath72 vanish .
up to this point , the formalism is identical to the one for describing the fragmentation into light hadrons based on the @xmath61 factorization scheme . for the fragmentation into heavy particles ,
we take one further step . as in the previous work @xcite ,
we adjust the factorization of the final - state collinear singularities associated with the charm and bottom quarks in such a way that it matches the massive calculation .
we achieve this by changing the factorization scheme .
specifically , we substitute in the hard - scattering cross sections ( [ xsection ] ) @xmath73 , where @xmath74_+\right .
\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}-{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left.(1+x)\left[1 + 2\ln(1-x)\right]\right\ } , \nonumber\\ d_{qg}(x ) & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&-p_{g\to q}^{(0,t)}(x)\ln\frac{\mu_0 ^ 2}{m_q^2 } , \nonumber\\ d_{qq}(x ) & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&d_{q\bar q}(x)=d_{q\bar q}(x)=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath49 and @xmath75 .
the @xmath76 functions emerge by charge conjugation .
these functions are extracted from @xcite .
note that @xmath77 and @xmath78 do not yet enter ( [ xsection ] ) at nlo .
the same substitutions must also be performed in any massless hard - scattering cross sections that are to be convoluted with our ff s , in particular with those of inclusive particle production in @xmath4 collisions , which will be studied in the next section .
this change of factorization must be regarded in connection with our assumptions concerning the ff s at the input scale , which refer to massive charm and bottom quarks .
this means that , without this change , we would proceed as in the case of fragmentation into light hadrons and obtain somewhat different parameters for the input distributions .
the ff s in ( [ sigx ] ) are parameterized at the starting scale @xmath79 by the anstze ( [ peterson ] ) and/or ( [ standard ] ) , depending on whether set m or s is considered .
once we know the ff s at the scale @xmath27 , the @xmath46 evolution is ruled by the altarelli - parisi ( ap ) equations @xcite .
our task is thus to determine the parameters of the distributions ( [ standard ] ) and ( [ peterson ] ) at the starting scale @xmath27 in such a way that the evolved ff s , when convoluted with the hard - scattering cross sections , fit the aleph @xcite and opal @xcite data at @xmath80 . in the case of form ( [ standard ] ) , the ap equations can be easily solved with the help of the mellin - transform technique , since the moments of the starting distribution ( [ standard ] ) are simple .
further details are given , for example , in our earlier work @xcite .
in the case of the peterson form ( [ peterson ] ) , the computation of the moments in mellin space is numerically rather complicated ; see @xcite for the corresponding formulae .
in this case , we find it more convenient to perform the evolution of the ff s in @xmath39 space by iteratively solving the ap equations in their integral form , @xmath81 where @xmath82 . the first term on the right - hand side of ( [ ap ] ) is the distribution at the starting scale @xmath27 . as a check for the numerical stability of our procedure , we compared both methods of evolution at lo and nlo for forms ( [ standard ] ) and ( [ peterson ] ) , and found good agreement .
the nlo timelike splitting functions @xmath83 , which enter ( [ ap ] ) , may be extracted from the literature @xcite . since , to our knowledge
, there is no reference where all these functions are presented in a convenient form , i.e. , with the coefficients of the delta functions and plus distributions explicitly displayed , we collect them in the appendix . in the case of set s
, we need to fit @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 in ( [ standard ] ) for the charm- and bottom - quark ff s , while , in the case of set m , we need to determine these parameters for the bottom - quark ff as well as @xmath52 and @xmath2 in ( [ peterson ] ) for the charm - quark ff .
both aleph @xcite and opal @xcite extracted the total @xmath0 momentum distribution as well as the individual contributions due to the @xmath84 and @xmath36 channels . in the case of aleph
, we received the individual @xmath85 and @xmath86 data sets in numerical form via private communication @xcite . in the aleph analysis , the branching ratio of @xmath34 ( or the charge - conjugated final state ) was taken to be 0.0371 .
since this value has been superseded by the value 0.041 @xcite , which was also used in the opal analysis , we rescale the aleph data with the factor 0.9049 . in our lo ( nlo ) analysis
, we use the one - loop ( two - loop ) formula for @xmath70 with @xmath87 mev ( 227 mev ) as in our previous work on inclusive pion and kaon production @xcite . at first sight ,
the value @xmath87 mev of our lo fit may seem unrealistically low ; this is , however , inconsequential because a higher value can easily be accommodated by slightly modifying the other fit parameters without damaging the quality of the fit .
the starting scales are chosen to be @xmath44 with @xmath88 gev for all ff s except for the case of bottom , where it is taken to be @xmath45 with @xmath89 gev .
the values of @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath2 resulting from the combined lo and nlo fits to these data are displayed in table [ pars ] .
the parameter @xmath2 appears only in the case of the charm - quark ff s of set m. in the case of the charm - quark ff s of set s , we have @xmath90 , as is expected for a distribution peaked at large @xmath39 . on the other hand , @xmath91 for the bottom - quark ff s , which have their maxima at smaller values of @xmath39 .
the parameters of the bottom - quark ff s of sets s and m are very similar , i.e. , the data fix the charm- and bottom - quark ff s independently of each other . in figs .
[ aleph]a and b , we compare the aleph data @xcite with our fits according to sets s and m , respectively . in figs .
[ opal]a and b , we do the same for the opal data @xcite . in each case , we show both lo and nlo results . except for very small @xmath39 ,
the lo and nlo curves are very similar . at small @xmath39
, we observe large differences between lo and nlo , indicating that , in this region , the perturbative treatment ceases to be valid . in this region ,
also the massless approximation is not valid anymore .
this may be understood by regarding the phase - space boundary for the production of @xmath0 mesons .
since @xmath0 mesons have mass @xmath92 gev @xcite , they can only be produced for @xmath93 . at @xmath94 ,
one has @xmath95 .
this is just the region where our nlo results turn negative .
therefore , our results are meaningful only for @xmath96 .
consequently , we exclude the first bin of the opal data ( @xmath97 ) from our analysis . note that this phase - space boundary is not only theoretically motivated , but does also turn up in the measurements , which give values
consistent with zero whenever @xmath98 .
this is not only true for the opal data , but also for data taken at lower energies , e.g. , those from argus @xcite . in figs .
[ aleph]a , b and [ opal]a , b , we have plotted the fully normalized cross section of ( [ sigx ] ) , which also includes the gluon contributions in nlo .
the shown charm and bottom contributions include terms with @xmath99 and @xmath100 in ( [ sigx ] ) , respectively , as well as the term with @xmath101 distributed to the charm and bottom terms in proportion to @xmath102 , which is motivated by ( [ xsection ] ) .
the contributions from @xmath103 are negligible in size ; they add up to less than 2% of the total integrated cross section and mostly contribute at small @xmath39 .
this procedure approximately produces the quantities that should be compared with the aleph and opal data . for the time being , we ignore the effect of electromagnetic initial - state radiation , which has not been corrected for in the data . the quality of the fit is measured in terms of the average @xmath104 for all selected data points . in table
[ fit ] , we list the @xmath104 values obtained with sets s and m at lo and nlo for the aleph and opal data , and their combination .
we also specify the individual results for the @xmath84 and @xmath36 samples of aleph and opal .
we observe that the @xmath84 samples yield worse @xmath104 values than the @xmath36 samples .
the opal data tend to give better @xmath104 values than the aleph data . especially in the case of aleph , set
s leads to better @xmath104 values than set m , which is not surprising if one recalls that set s has six degrees of freedom while set m has only five .
the integrals of the charm- and bottom - quark ff s into @xmath0 mesons over @xmath39 give the branching fractions of these transitions .
for the reasons given above , we restrict our considerations to the region @xmath105 , with @xmath106 , and define @xmath107 where @xmath49 . experimentally , the contribution from the omitted region @xmath108 is close to zero with a large error .
it is interesting to study @xmath109 for @xmath49 at threshold @xmath110 and at the @xmath29-boson resonance @xmath111 . in table
[ branching ] , we present the results for sets s and m at lo and nlo .
we observe that these branching fractions are changed very little through the evolution from @xmath112 to @xmath113 , and they are almost equal for charm- and bottom - quark fragmentation .
the branching fractions at the @xmath29-boson resonance can be compared with the experimental numbers reported by the opal collaboration @xcite , which are @xmath114 and @xmath115 , with errors of approximately 25% .
these results , which are obtained from independent fits to all experimental data , are consistent with our fits . at lo ( nlo ) ,
the charm to bottom ratio of the branching fractions at @xmath111 is 0.92 ( 0.94 ) for set s and 1.07 ( 1.01 ) for set m. this agrees well with the experimental results @xmath116 @xcite and @xmath117 @xcite .
another quantity of interest is the mean momentum fraction , @xmath118 where @xmath49 . in table
[ xav ] , we collect the values of @xmath119 for @xmath49 evaluated with sets s and m in lo and nlo at @xmath120 .
the differences between sets s and m and between lo and nlo are minor .
however , the effect of the @xmath46 evolution is significant , e.g. , @xmath121 moves from approximately 0.7 at @xmath122 down to about 0.5 at @xmath111 .
our results for @xmath123 should be compared with the experimental numbers reported by aleph @xcite and opal @xcite , @xmath124 respectively .
we conclude that our fits are in reasonable agreement with the independent determinations in @xcite .
next , we test whether the ff s constructed from the aleph and opal data , after evolution to lower scales , lead to predictions for @xmath0 production by @xmath1 annihilation that are consistent with experimental data taken at lower cm energies .
a number of measurements at lower energies were performed , e.g. , at doris , cesr , pep , and petra ; for a compilation , see @xcite .
these data have much lower statistics than the data from lep1 . for the comparison
, we selected the data from argus @xcite at @xmath125 gev , from hrs @xcite at @xmath126 gev , and from tasso @xcite at @xmath127 gev .
the tasso collaboration measured two decay channels of the @xmath128 meson , namely , @xmath129 and @xmath34 .
the latter decay channel also allowed measurements at lower values of @xmath39 ; we shall denote this data set by tasso 2 and the other one by tasso 1 . for consistency
, we corrected the hrs and tasso data by updating the values of the branching ratios of @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath129 according to the 1994 tables of the particle data group @xcite , which were also used by opal @xcite .
this leads to correction factors of 0.702 for tasso 1 and 0.677 for tasso 2 . in the publication by hrs @xcite
, the cross sections are not given separately for the different decay channels , so that we can only approximate the required correction by an overall factor of 0.877 . in fig .
[ comp ] , we compare the argus , hrs and tasso data on the cross section @xmath132 of @xmath133 with our respective lo and nlo predictions based on set s. the theoretical results are calculated according to ( [ sigx ] ) with @xmath21 quark flavours ( except for the case of argus , where @xmath18 is used ) ,
i.e. , also the contributions due to gluon and light - flavour fragmentation are consistently included .
we only show our results for @xmath134 . for completeness ,
[ comp ] also includes the comparison of the opal data @xcite on the dimensionless cross section @xmath135 with our lo and nlo predictions according to set s. as can be seen from fig .
[ comp ] , the agreement between our predictions and the data is satisfactory .
this nicely demonstrates that the data indeed exhibit the scaling violation predicted on the basis of the lo and nlo ap evolution equations for the ff s .
in fact , the change in the shape of the differential cross section with @xmath46 is mainly due to the bottom quark .
the argus data @xcite are taken off the resonance , at @xmath125 gev , where the bottom quark is not yet active .
the inclusion of the bottom - quark contribution leads to a softening of the distribution , as may be seen in the case of the hrs data @xcite at @xmath126 gev and the tasso data @xcite at @xmath127 gev .
the evolution from 29 gev to 34.2 gev has no discernible effect .
going to the @xmath29-boson pole at @xmath136 gev further increases the relative importance of the bottom - quark fragmentation and leads to an even softer spectrum . for @xmath137 ,
there is little difference between the lo and nlo cross sections .
the successful comparisons in fig . [ comp ] make us confident that our @xmath0 ff s , although constructed at @xmath94 , also lead to useful descriptions of @xmath0 fragmentation at other scales . in the next section
, we shall exploit this property together with the universality of fragmentation to make predictions for inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction at hera .
in this section , we compare our nlo predictions for the cross section of inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction in @xmath4 scattering at hera with data from the zeus collaboration @xcite .
the calculation of this cross section proceeds as in the previous work @xcite , except that we now use the ff s constructed in the last section . for the calculation of the cross section @xmath5
, we adopt the present hera conditions , where @xmath138 gev protons collide with @xmath139 gev positrons in the laboratory frame .
we take the rapidity to be positive in the proton flight direction .
the quasi - real photon spectrum is described in the weizscker - williams approximation by the formula given in @xcite .
this spectrum depends on the photon - energy fraction , @xmath140 , and the maximum photon - virtuality , @xmath141 . in the zeus experiment @xcite , where the final - state electron is not detected , @xmath142 gev@xmath143 and @xmath144 , which corresponds to @xmath23 cm energies of 115 gev@xmath145 gev .
we adopt these kinematic conditions in our analysis .
we work at nlo in the @xmath61 scheme with @xmath18 flavours . for the proton and photon pdf s
we use set cteq4 m @xcite with @xmath146 mev and set grv ho @xcite converted to the @xmath61 factorization scheme , respectively .
we evaluate @xmath147 from the two - loop formula with this value of @xmath148 .
the @xmath148 values implemented in the @xmath0 ff s and photon pdf s are 352 mev , which corresponds to the value @xmath149 mev quoted in the previous section , and 200 mev , respectively .
we identify the factorization scales associated with the proton , photon , and @xmath0 meson , and collectively denote them by @xmath58 .
we choose the renormalization and factorization scales to be @xmath150 and @xmath151 , respectively , where @xmath152 is the @xmath0 transverse mass .
whenever we present lo results , these are consistently computed using set cteq4l @xcite of proton pdf s , set grv lo @xcite of photon pdf s , the lo versions of our sets s and m of @xmath0 ff s , the one - loop formula for @xmath70 with @xmath153 mev , and the lo hard - scattering cross section .
the photoproduction cross section is a superposition of the direct- and resolved - photon contributions . in our nlo analysis
, the resolved - photon contribution is larger than the direct one for moderate @xmath8 .
this statement depends , however , on the factorization scheme ; only the sum of both contributions is a physical observable and can be compared with experimental data .
the bulk of the resolved - photon cross section is due to the charm component of the photon pdf @xcite .
we first consider the @xmath8 distribution @xmath154 integrated over the rapidity interval @xmath155 as in the zeus analysis @xcite . in fig .
[ zeus]a , we compare the respective zeus data @xcite with our lo and nlo predictions based on sets s and m. the theoretical results are multiplied with the factor 1.06 to account for the fact that opal @xcite used the @xmath0 and @xmath128 branching fractions of @xcite , while zeus @xcite used those of @xcite .
the nlo distributions fall off slightly less strongly with increasing @xmath8 than the lo ones .
it is remarkable that there is hardly any difference between the set - s and set - m results ; in fact , the lo - s and lo - m ( nlo - s and nlo - m ) curves almost coincide .
this means that the details of charm - quark fragmentation are very tightly constrained by the lep1 data , and that the considered variation in the functional form of the charm - quark ff at the starting scale has very little influence on the @xmath8 distribution .
the nlo curves should be compared with fig .
8c in @xcite , where the charm - quark ff at the starting scale @xmath156 gev was taken to be of the peterson form with @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
this corresponds to @xmath159 .
we recall that , in the case of set nlo m , we have @xmath160 , @xmath161 , and @xmath162 ; see tables [ pars ] and [ branching ] .
we observe that the result for @xmath163 in fig .
8c of @xcite is somewhat smaller than the nlo results of fig . [ zeus]a , but has a similar shape .
the agreement with the data is good , even at small @xmath8 , where the massless approach ceases to be valid . in fig .
[ zeus]b , we compare the @xmath7 line shape of @xmath5 , integrated over the @xmath8 interval 3 gev@xmath164 gev , with the respective zeus data points @xcite . as in fig . [ zeus]a , we consider the four cases lo s , nlo s , lo m , and nlo m. again , the lo - s ( nlo - s ) results almost perfectly coincide with the lo - m ( nlo - m ) results , i.e. , the functional form of the charm - quark ff at the starting scale is of minor significance .
the agreement between theory and experiment is reasonable . if we compare the nlo results of fig .
[ zeus]b with the result for @xmath163 in fig .
9c of @xcite , we see that the latter is somewhat smaller , but has essentially the same shape . in @xcite , the cross section @xmath5
was also measured at three different values of @xmath165 . to this end
, @xmath7 and @xmath8 were sampled in the intervals @xmath155 and 3 gev@xmath164 gev , respectively . in fig .
[ zeus]c , we show the @xmath165 dependence of @xmath5 , integrated over these @xmath7 and @xmath8 intervals , and compare it with the corresponding zeus data @xcite . similarly to figs .
[ zeus]a and b , we consider sets s and m at lo and nlo . within the rather large experimental errors ,
all four predictions agree reasonably well with the data . in @xcite ,
such a figure was not presented , but it can be found in the zeus publication @xcite .
again , we observe that the input assumptions , encoded in sets s and m , have practically no influence on the result . when we fitted to the lep1 data , we also had to take into account @xmath0 production by bottom - quark fragmentation , as it gives a sizeable contribution at the @xmath29-boson pole . in @xmath4 collisions , however , the bottom quark does not contribute at all to inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction below the threshold at @xmath166 .
in contrast to @xmath1 annihilation , the bottom quark does not contribute significantly even above the threshold . to elucidate this point
, we repeat the analysis of fig .
[ zeus]a for @xmath21 with and without the bottom - quark ff and plot the ratio in fig
. [ ratio ] .
we see that , in all four cases , the relative contributions due to the bottom - quark ff s are below 5% and decrease with increasing @xmath8 .
this may be understood by observing that , in the case of @xmath0 photoproduction in @xmath4 collisions , the main contribution to the cross section arises at large @xmath39 , typically at @xmath167 , where @xmath168 because the bottom - quark ff s have a soft spectrum .
for the same reason , also the contributions of the @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 quarks are negligible .
we have seen that our theoretical predictions for @xmath0 photoproduction at hera are very insensitive to the specific form of the input distribution of the charm - quark ff , and that the influence of the other quark flavours is marginal .
when the ff templates of sets s or m are fitted to the most accurate data , we obtain an almost unique prediction for the charm - quark ff .
in fact , the largest remaining uncertainty in the calculation of the @xmath0 photoproduction cross section is related to the charm content of the resolved photon .
this offers us the possibility to employ our well constrained ff s to extract information about the charm distribution in the photon .
it is well known that the most sensitive distributions to study such dependences are those differential in rapidity .
this fact has been previously exploited , e.g. , in @xcite , where we emphasized the potential to determine the gluon pdf of the photon by accurately measuring the inclusive charged - particle rapidity spectrum in photoproduction . to illustrate the sensitivity to the charm pdf of the photon , we repeat the nlo - s analysis of fig .
[ zeus]b with this pdf switched off , and compare the outcome with the full calculation in fig . [ charm ] . for comparison ,
also the direct - photon contribution is shown .
we observe that 73% to 100% ( 50% to 89% ) of the resolved - photon ( full ) cross section is induced by the charm content of the photon , which is most important in the backward direction . inspired by this observation
, we now repeat the nlo - s analysis of fig .
[ zeus]b using in turn the nlo photon pdf sets of @xcite , which we denote by gs ho and acfgp , respectively .
the authors of @xcite considered both massless and massive charm quarks . in their massive - charm set
, the charm - quark pdf is implemented with the boundary condition of @xcite at threshold .
we observe a significant variation of the cross section , especially in the backward region , where our predictions for set grv ho @xcite and acfgp ( massive @xmath43 ) @xcite differ by more than a factor of two !
unfortunately , the data are not yet accurate enough to rule out any of the available sets . of course , in order to reliably constrain the charm pdf of the photon , it would be preferable to have data with an increased low-@xmath8 cut , since our massless charm - quark theory is more reliable in the large-@xmath8 region
. however , this is a very interesting measurement that has a vast potential for improving our knowledge about the charm pdf of the photon .
in this paper , we determined new sets of @xmath0 ff s at lo and nlo from fits to precise cross - section data obtained in @xmath1 annihilation by aleph and opal at lep1 .
our analysis was based on the massless - charm factorization approach recently developed in @xcite . in these lep1 data ,
the fragmentation of charm and bottom quarks into @xmath0 mesons was disentangled , so that the respective ff s are separately constrained . for the description at the charm - quark ff , we used two different anstze at the starting scale , namely , the three - parameter standard form conventionally used for light - meson production and the two - parameter peterson form .
it turned out that both prescriptions lead to excellent fits of the lep1 data , and that the charm- and bottom - quark ff s are each tightly constrained . with this method ,
the fragmentation at any other scale is predictable via the ap evolution , which we performed both at lo and nlo .
this enabled us to check our ff s against @xmath1 data at lower cm energies .
in particular , we found very good agreement with data from tasso @xcite , hrs @xcite , and argus @xcite , which demonstrates that the scaling violation encoded in the ap equations is consistent with the data .
we stress that the results for the starting parameters are correlated with the starting scale . in the case of the peterson description for charm - quark fragmentation at lo ( nlo )
, the epsilon parameter and @xmath3 branching fraction at the starting scale @xmath44 were found to be @xmath169 ( 0.0204 ) and @xmath170 ( 0.232 ) , respectively .
this corresponds to an @xmath39 mean value of @xmath171 ( 0.754 ) .
while @xmath172 is relatively stable under evolution to @xmath111 , @xmath121 is appreciably lowered , down to @xmath173 ( 0.556 ) .
we emphasize that the @xmath0 ff s thus obtained are universal and may be used to make predictions for inclusive @xmath0 production in any other high - energy experiment .
we exploited this fact by calculating the cross section of inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction at hera , which we compared with the latest data from the zeus collaboration .
we found that the bottom - quark contribution is marginal , and that the results do not depend on whether we use the standard or peterson - type charm - quark ff s , which shows that we have good control over the fragmentation aspect of @xmath0 photoproduction . under the condition that more precise experimental data , in particular in the large-@xmath8 region , will be collected at hera
, this will allow one to constrain other non - perturbative input information such as the charm - quark pdf of the photon , which is still poorly known .
* note added in proofs * after the completion of our manuscript , a related paper @xcite has appeared .
the authors of @xcite determine @xmath0 ff s by separately fitting @xmath1 data from doris and lep1 .
in contrast to our procedure , they also include the @xmath174 functions of ( [ dij ] ) in the evolution , and treat the bottom quark on the same footing as the @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 quarks , i.e. , they only take the charm - quark ff to be non - vanishing at the starting scale . *
acknowledgments * we are grateful to paul colas for making available to us the aleph data on the charm and bottom contributions to @xmath0 production @xcite , and to carsten coldewey for providing us with the zeus data on @xmath0 photoproduction @xcite prior to their official publication
. one of us ( gk ) thanks the theory group of the werner - heisenberg - institut for the hospitality extended to him during a visit when this paper was finalized .
although the nlo timelike splitting functions have been calculated by various groups @xcite , we are not aware of any paper where they are presented in a way ready to use , i.e. , with the coefficients of @xmath175 and @xmath176 displayed explicitly . for the reader
s convenience , we shall do this here .
let @xmath177 , @xmath178 , and @xmath179 be the ff s of the gluon @xmath180 and @xmath181 quarks @xmath64 and antiquarks @xmath182 ( @xmath183 ) , respectively , into some hadron with momentum fraction @xmath39 at fragmentation scale @xmath47 .
the @xmath46 evolution of these ff s is conveniently formulated for the combinations @xmath184 as @xmath185 , \nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\frac{\mu^2d}{d\mu^2}d_g(x,\mu^2 ) = \int_x^1\frac{dz}{z}\left[\frac{1}{2n_f } p_{g\to q}^{(t)}\left(\frac{x}{z},\alpha_s(\mu^2)\right)d^{(+)}(z,\mu^2 ) + p_{g\to g}^{(t)}\left(\frac{x}{z},\alpha_s(\mu^2)\right)d_g(z,\mu^2)\right ] , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath186 are the timelike @xmath187 splitting functions . @xmath188 and @xmath189 are decomposed into valence ( non - singlet ) and sea ( pure - singlet ) components as @xmath190 all these splitting function have perturbative expansions of the form @xmath191 the lo coefficients read @xmath192 , \nonumber\\ p_{q\to\bar q}^{v(0,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&p_{q\to q}^{s(0,t)}(x)=0 ,
\nonumber\\ p_{q\to g}^{(0,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&c_fp_{fg}(x ) , \nonumber\\ p_{g\to q}^{(0,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&2tn_fp_{gf}(x ) , \nonumber\\ p_{g\to g}^{(0,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & \left(\frac{11}{6}c_a-\frac{2}{3}tn_f\right)\delta(1-x ) + 2c_a\left[\left(\frac{1}{1-x}\right)_++\frac{1}{x}-2+x - x^2\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the nlo coefficients read @xmath193 + c_fc_a\left[\frac{17}{24}+\frac{11}{3}\zeta(2)-3\zeta(3)\right]-c_ftn_f \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}\times{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
\left[\frac{1}{6}+\frac{4}{3}\zeta(2)\right]\right\}\delta(1-x ) + \left\{c_fc_a\left[\frac{67}{9}-2\zeta(2)\right ] -\frac{20}{9}c_ftn_f\right\}\left(\frac{1}{1-x}\right)_+ \nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & c_f^2\left\{-5(1-x)-\frac{1}{2}(7 + 3x)\ln x+\frac{1}{2}(1+x)\ln^2x + p_{ff}(x)\ln x \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}\times{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
\left[\frac{3}{2}-2\ln x+2\ln(1-x)\right]\right\ } + c_fc_a\left\{\frac{1}{18}(53 - 187x)+(1+x)[\zeta(2)+\ln x ] \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
\frac{1}{2}p_{ff}(x)\ln x\left(\frac{11}{3}+\ln x\right)\right\ } + c_ftn_f\left[\frac{2}{9}(-1 + 11x)-\frac{2}{3}p_{ff}(x)\ln x\right ] , \nonumber\\ p_{q\to\bar q}^{v(1,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & c_f\left(2c_f - c_a\right)\left[2(1-x)+(1+x)\ln x+p_{ff}(-x)s_2(x ) \right ] , \nonumber\\ p_{q\to q}^{s(1,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & c_ft\left[4\left(-\frac{5}{9x}-2+x+\frac{14}{9}x^2\right ) -\left(5 + 9x+\frac{8}{3}x^2\right)\ln x+(1+x)\ln^2x\right ] , \nonumber\\ p_{q\to g}^{(1,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & c_f^2\left\{\frac{1}{2}(-1 + 9x)+\left(-8+\frac{x}{2}\right)\ln x + 2x\ln(1-x)+\left(1-\frac{x}{2}\right)\ln^2x+p_{fg}(x ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}\times{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
\left[-8\zeta(2)+4\ln x\ln(1-x)+\ln^2(1-x)-8s_1(x)\right]\right\ } + c_fc_a\left\{\frac{1}{9}\left(62-\frac{35}{2}x \right.\right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}-{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
44x^2\right)+2\left(1 + 6x+\frac{4}{3}x^2\right)\ln x-2x\ln(1-x)-(4+x)\ln^2x + p_{fg}(x ) \nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}\times{\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & \left[\frac{17}{18}+7\zeta(2)-3\ln x-\frac{3}{2}\ln^2x-2\ln x\ln(1-x ) -\ln^2(1-x)+8s_1(x)\right ] \nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
p_{fg}(-x)s_2(x)\right\ } , \nonumber\\ p_{g\to q}^{(1,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & c_ftn_f\left\{-2 + 3x+(-7 + 8x)\ln x-4\ln(1-x)+(1 - 2x)\ln^2x + 2p_{gf}(x ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}\times{\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & \left[-5 + 6\zeta(2)+\ln x-\ln(1-x)-\ln^2x-2\ln x\ln(1-x)-\ln^2(1-x ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left.\left .
8s_1(x)\right]\right\ } + c_atn_f\left\{\frac{2}{9}\left(-\frac{20}{x}-76 + 83x\right ) -\frac{4}{3}(1 + 19x)\ln x+4\ln(1-x ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & 2(1 + 4x)\ln^2x + p_{gf}(x)\left[\frac{178}{9}-14\zeta(2)-\frac{4}{3}\ln x+\frac{10}{3}\ln(1-x ) -\ln^2x \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left.\left . 8\ln x\ln(1-x)+2\ln^2(1-x)-16s_1(x)\right]+2p_{gf}(-x)s_2(x)\right\ } \nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & ( tn_f)^2\left\{-\frac{8}{3}-\frac{8}{3}p_{gf}(x)\left[\frac{2}{3}+\ln x + \ln(1-x)\right]\right\ } , \nonumber\\ p_{g\to g}^{(1,t)}(x)&{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}={\hspace*{-2.5 mm } } & \left[c_a^2\left(\frac{8}{3}+3\zeta(3)\right ) -c_ftn_f-\frac{4}{3}c_atn_f\right]\delta(1-x ) + \left[c_a^2\left(\frac{67}{9}-2\zeta(2)\right ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}-{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left . \frac{20}{9}c_atn_f\right]\left(\frac{1}{1-x}\right)_+ + c_ftn_f\left[4\left(\frac{23}{9x}-1 + 3x-\frac{41}{9}x^2\right ) +
2\left(\frac{8}{3x}+5 \right.\right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left.\left .
7x+\frac{8}{3}x^2\right)\ln x+2(1+x)\ln^2x\right ] + c_atn_f\left[\frac{2}{9}\left(-\frac{23}{x}+29 - 19x+23x^2\right ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}-{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
\frac{4}{3}(1+x)\ln x-\frac{8}{3}p_{gg}(x)\ln x\right ] + c_a^2\left\{-\frac{1}{18}(25 + 109x)-2\zeta(2 ) \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}\times{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
\left(\frac{1}{x}-2+x - x^2\right ) + \frac{1}{3}\left(-\frac{44}{x}+11 - 25x\right)\ln x-4(1+x)\ln^2x \right.\nonumber\\ & { \hspace*{-2.5mm}}+{\hspace*{-2.5mm}}&\left .
p_{gg}(x)\ln x\left[\frac{22}{3}-3\ln x+4\ln(1-x)\right ] + 2p_{gg}(-x)s_2(x)\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath194 is riemann s zeta function , with values @xmath68 and @xmath195 , and we have used the auxiliary functions @xmath196 ^ 2}{x(1-x)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath197 where @xmath198 is the dilogarithm . in the case of the colour gauge group su(@xmath199 ) ,
the casimir operators of the fundamental and adjoint representations have the eigenvalues @xmath200 and @xmath201 , respectively .
the trace normalization of the fundamental representation is @xmath202 .
g. curci , w. furmanski , r. petronzio : nucl .
b175 , 27 ( 1980 ) ; w. furmanski , r. petronzio : phys . lett . 97b , 437 ( 1980 ) ; p.j .
rijken , w.l .
van neerven : nucl .
b487 , 233 ( 1997 ) ; m. stratmann , w. vogelsang : nucl .
b496 , 41 ( 1997 ) | we present new sets of fragmentation functions for @xmath0 mesons , both at leading and next - to - leading order .
they are determined by fitting lep1 data on inclusive @xmath0 production in @xmath1 annihilation . in one of the sets , we take the charm - quark fragmentation function to be of the form proposed by peterson et al . and
thus obtain updated values of the @xmath2 parameter and the @xmath3 branching ratio .
the new fragmentation functions lead to an excellent description of other @xmath1 data with centre - of - mass energies between 10 and 35 gev .
they also nicely agree with recent hera data on inclusive @xmath0 photoproduction in @xmath4 collisions , which may be considered as a test of the universality of the fragmentation into @xmath0 mesons .
pacs numbers : 13.60.-r , 13.85.ni , 13.87.fh , 14.40.lb 16.cm 22.cm
@=11 tempcntc citex[#1]#2@fileswauxout tempcnta@tempcntb@neciteaciteforciteb:=#2citeo#1 citeotempcnta > tempcntbciteacitea , tempcnta = tempcntbtempcnta @=12 |
data compression is performed in all types of data requiring storage and transmission .
it preserves space , energy and bandwidth , while representing the data in most efficient way [ 1 - 4 ] .
there are numerous coding algorithms used for compression in various applications [ 1 - 3,5 - 18 ] .
some of them are optimal [ 4,19 ] in all cases , whereas others are optimal for a specific probability distribution of the source symbols .
all of these algorithms are mostly applied on @xmath0-ary data source .
however , most of the universal compression algorithms substantially increase their coding complexity and memory requirements when the data changes from binary to @xmath0-ary source .
for instance , in arithmetic coding , the computational complexity difference between the encoder and decoder increases with the number of source symbols [ 2 ] .
therefore , it would be beneficial if binarization is perfomed on @xmath0-ary data source before compression algorithms are applied on it .
the process where binarization is followed by compression is most notably found in context - based adaptive binary arithmetic coding ( cabac ) [ 20 ] which is used in h.264/avc video coding standard [ 21 ] , high efficiency video coding ( hevc ) standard [ 22 ] , dynamic 3d mesh compression [ 23 ] , audio video coding standard ( avs ) [ 24 ] , motion compensated - embedded zeroblock coding ( mc - ezc ) in scalable video coder [ 25 ] , multiview video coding [ 26 ] , motion vector encoding [ 27 - 28 ] , and 4d lossless medical image compression [ 29 ] .
there are many binary conversion techniques which are , or can be used for the binarization process .
the most common among all is binary search tree [ 30 - 32 ] . in this
, huffman codeword is used to design an optimal tree [ 18 ] . however , there are two limitations to it .
first , the probability of all the symbols should be known prior to encoding that may not be possible in all the applications .
although there are methods to overcome the above problem , they come at an additional cost of complexity . for example , binary search tree is updated with the change in incoming symbol probabilities .
second , as with the huffman coding , the optimality is achieved only when the probability distribution of symbols are in the powers of two .
apart from binary search tree , there are other binarization schemes like unary binarization scheme [ 20 ] , truncated unary binarization scheme [ 20 ] , fixed length binarization scheme [ 20 ] , golomb binarization scheme [ 9,20,33 - 34 ] , among many [ 5 - 13,20,30 - 34 ] .
all of them are optimal for only certain type of symbol probability distributions , and hence , can only conserve the entropy of the data for that probability distribution of the source symbols .
currently , there is no binarization scheme that is optimal for all probability distributions of the source symbols which would result in achieving overall optimal data compression .
this paper presents a generalized optimal binarization algorithm .
the novel binarization scheme conserves the entropy of the data while converting the @xmath0-ary source data into @xmath1 binary strings .
moreover , the binarization technique is independent of the data type and can be used in any field for storing and compressing data .
furthermore , it can efficiently represent data in the fields which require data to be easily written and read in binary form .
the paper is organized as follows .
section 2 describes the binarization and de - binarization process that will be carried out at the encoder and decoder , respectively .
the optimality proof of the binarization scheme is provided in section 3 . in section 4 , the complexity associated with the binarization process is discussed .
lastly , section 5 concludes by stating the advantages of the presented binarization scheme over others , and its applications .
the binarization of the source symbols is carried out at the encoder using the following two steps : 1 .
a symbol is chosen , and a binary data stream is created by assigning 1 where the chosen symbol is present and 0 otherwise , in the uncompressed data .
the uncompressed data is rearranged by removing the symbol chosen in step 1 .
the two steps are iteratively applied for @xmath1 symbols .
it needs to be explicitly emphasized that the binarization of symbol occurs on the previously rearranged uncompressed data and not on the original uncompressed data . here , the algorithm reduces the uncompressed data size with the removal of binarized symbols from the data , leading to the conservation of entropy .
after binarizing every symbol , there are @xmath1 binary data streams corresponding to @xmath0 source symbols .
it is because the @xmath2 binary string would represent @xmath2 and @xmath3 symbols as 1 and 0 , respectively .
the binarization scheme demostrated here is optimal i.e. , the overall entropy of binarized data streams is equal to the entropy of original data containing @xmath0-ary source .
the proof of optimality is provided in section 3 .
after binarization , the binarized data streams can be optimally compressed using any universal compression algorithm , including the algorithms that optimally compress only binary data ( for example : binary arithmetic coding ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] table 1 shows the binarization process through an example . a sample input data aabcbacbbaccabacb is considered for the process and as can be seen , it contains three source symbols a
, b , and c. in table 1 , binarization order states the sequence in which the symbols are binarized .
for instance , in abc binarization order , a is binarized first , followed by b , and then finally by c. the row data shows the uncompressed data available to be binarized after each iteration . below the data row
is the binarized value of each symbol .
as can be seen in each first iteration , the symbol that has be binarized is marked 1 , while others are marked 0. in the next iteration , the symbol that was binarized in the current step is removed from the uncompressed data .
although shown in table 1 , the binarization process does not require to binarize last symbol , because the resultant string contains all 1 s that provide no additional information and is redundant .
it also needs to be noted that each binarization order results in different sets of binary strings . at the decoder ,
the decoding of the compressed data is followed by de - binarization of @xmath0-ary source symbol .
the order of decoding follows the order of encoding for perfect reconstruction at minimum complexity . with the encoding order information ,
the de - binarization can be perfectly reconstructed in multiple ways other than the encoding order , but the reordering of sequence after every de - binarization will increase the time as well as the decoder complexity .
the de - binarization of the source symbols is also carried out in two steps shown below , and these steps are recursively applied to all the binary data streams representing @xmath0-ary source symbols : 1 .
replace 1 with the source symbol in the reconstructed data stream .
2 . assign the values of the next binary data stream in sequence to the 0 s in the reconstructed data stream .
an example of de - binarization process is shown in table 2 .
the de - binarization order follows the same order as of binarization process . in table 2
, the row data represents the reconstructed data at each iteration .
the value 1 is replaced by the symbol to be de - binarized in the respective iteration , while 0 s are replaced by the binary string of the next symbol to be de - binarized . finally , after the last iteration
, the original input data aabcbacbbaccabacb is losslessly recovered for all binarization and de - binarization order .
let the data source be @xmath4 , and @xmath5 be the binary source for each source symbol .
the entropy of a @xmath0-ary source @xmath6 is defined as , @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the probability of @xmath9 source symbol .
subsequently , the entropy of @xmath0-ary data source @xmath6 with length @xmath10 is @xmath11 .
similarly , @xmath12 is the entropy of binary source with data length @xmath10 .
as explained in the binarization algorithm , the uncompressed data is rearranged after the binarization of the previous symbol / s to @xmath13 data length i.e. , the length of the original data subtracted by the length of all the previously binarized source symbols .
hence , the overall entropy of the @xmath0 binarized strings is @xmath14 . here ,
@xmath0 binary strings are considered for mathematical convenience . to achieve the optimal binarization of @xmath0-ary source ,
the entropy of @xmath0-ary source data must equal the total entropy of binary strings .
therefore , rcl h(y^n ) & = & _ i=1^m h(x_i^n(1-_j=1^i-1p(y_i ) ) ) + n h(y ) & = & _ i=1^m n(1-_j=1^i-1 p(y_i ) ) h(x_i ) the probability distribution of the binary source @xmath15 is the probability distribution of @xmath0-ary source @xmath16 when the first @xmath17 source symbols have already been binarized i.e. , removed from the original data .
thus , @xmath18 can be rewritten in terms of @xmath16 in the following way : rcl h(y ) & = & _ i=1^m ( 1-_j=1^i-1 p(y_j ) ) h ( ) + h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m ( 1-_j=1^i-1 p(y_j ) ) ( ) + & & ( ) - _ i=1^m ( 1-_j=1^i-1 p(y_j ) ) + & & rcl h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m p(y_i ) ( ) + & & - _ i=1^m ( 1 - _ j=1^ip(y_j ) ) ( ) rcl h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m p(y_i ) ( ) + & & - _ i=1^m ( _ j = i+1^mp(y_j ) ) ( ) rcl h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m ( p(y_i ) p(y_i ) - p(y_i ) ( _ j = i^mp(y_j ) ) ) + & & - _ i=1^m ( _ j = i+1^mp(y_j ) ) ( _ j = i+1^mp(y_j ) ) + & & + _ i=1^m ( _ j = i+1^mp(y_j ) ) ( _ j = i^mp(y_j ) ) rcl h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m p(y_i ) p(y_i ) + & & - _ i=1^m ( _ j = i+1^mp(y_j ) ) ( _ j = i+1^mp(y_j ) ) + & & + _ i=1^m ( _ j = i^mp(y_j ) ) ( _ j = i^mp(y_j ) ) rcl h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m p(y_i ) p(y_i ) + & & + ( _ j=1^mp(y_j ) ) ( _ j=1^mp(y_j ) ) + h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m p(y_i ) p(y_i ) + 1 1 + h(y ) & = & -_i=1^m p(y_i ) p(y_i ) the reduction of equation 2 to equation 12 ( also equation 1 ) proves that the binarization scheme preserves entropy for any @xmath0-ary data source .
the computational complexity of the presented method is the linear function of the input data length .
the binarization and de - binarization process only acts as a filter , assigning or replacing 0 s and 1 s , respectively , for an occurrence of a source symbol without any additional table or calculation , that is created or performed for the other binarization techniques .
suppose , the length of input data is @xmath10 , @xmath0 is the number of source symbols , and @xmath6 is the source .
for the first symbol , the length of the binary string would be @xmath10 .
the length of binary string for the second symbol would be the length of all the symbols , except the first symbol ( see table 1 ) .
likewise , the length of @xmath19 binary string would be the length all symbols yet to be binarized .
mathematically , the length can be written as @xmath20 , where @xmath8 is the probability of @xmath19 symbol .
the total number of binary assignment would be @xmath21 .
as can be seen , the computational complexity of the binarization and de - binarization process is linear in terms of the input data length .
the proposed binarization scheme has the following advantages over others .
firstly , it is optimal for every data set . as proved and shown in this paper , the binarization scheme conserves entropy of @xmath0-ary data source .
secondly , the proposed method eliminates the need for knowing the source symbols at all .
it works optimally without the knowledge of source because the binarization of the source symbols can occur in any order as shown table 1 , and all orders conserve @xmath0-ary source entropy , which can be inferred from the derivation shown in section 3 .
thirdly , adding to the previous point , the coding is independent of the occurrence of the source symbols .
in other words , any source symbol can be encoded in any order subject to the constraint that decoding is performed in the same order .
the optimality is independent of the source order in the data set .
fourthly , unlike variable length codes , there is no need to know the probability distribution of the source symbols beforehand .
it can be updated as the symbols occur . however , even without the knowledge of probability distribution , the presented method is optimal .
lastly , it has low complexity that is feasible for practical data compression .
one of the immediate usage of the presented binarization technique is in cabac used in video and image compression .
in addition , cabac with the proposed binarization scheme can potentially replace context - based adaptive arithmetic coding used in various image compression standards [ 35 ] , including jpeg2000 [ 36 ] .
furthermore , the binarization scheme can be applied to all the universal compression algorithms that have less complexity and resource requirements for binary data , than @xmath0-ary data .
v. sanchez , p. nasiopoulos , r. abugharbieh , efficient 4d motion compensated lossless compression of dynamic volumetric medical image data , in : proc .
conf . on acoustics , speech and signal process . ,
las vegas , nevada , usa , 2008 , pp .
549552 .
k. ong , w. chang , y. tseng , y. lee , c. lee , a high throughput low cost context - based adaptive arithmetic codec for multiple standards , in : proc .
symp . on circuits and syst .
, vol . 1 , 2002 , pp . | the paper presents a binarization scheme that converts non - binary data into a set of binary strings . at present
, there are many binarization algorithms , but they are optimal for only specific probability distributions of the data source . overcoming the problem , it is shown in this paper that the presented binarization scheme conserves the entropy of the original data having any probability distribution of @xmath0-ary source .
the major advantages of this scheme are that it conserves entropy without the knowledge of the source and the probability distribution of the source symbols .
the scheme has linear complexity in terms of the length of the input data .
the binarization scheme can be implemented in context - based adaptive binary arithmetic coding ( cabac ) for video and image compression .
it can also be utilized by various universal data compression algorithms that have high complexity in compressing non - binary data , and by binary data compression algorithms to optimally compress non - binary data .
binarization , source coding , data compression , image compression , video compression , binary arithmetic coding , context - based adaptive binary arithmetic coding ( cabac ) . |
generalized parton distributions ( gpds ) @xcite ( see also @xcite for a recent review ) provide a means of parametrizing hadronic contributions to both exclusive and inclusive processes .
they reduce in certain limits to form factors and to ( forward ) parton distributions . for a review on the nucleon axial structure see @xcite and for spin - dependent parton distributions consult @xcite .
gpds depend on three independent kinematic variables and are therefore far more difficult to extract from experiments than forward parton distributions .
lattice simulations provide a general , model - independent way to compute their moments directly .
first results for spin - independent gpds have been presented in @xcite .
these papers , however , concentrate on rather large quark masses .
it is imperative to extend these studies down into the chiral regime . in this talk , we will present a first study of spin - dependent gpds , both with wilson fermions at large quark masses and with staggered sea and domain - wall valence fermions at intermediate quark masses .
spin - dependent gpds are specified by @xmath1 and @xmath2 , defined via @xmath3 the upper index f denotes the quark flavor , @xmath4 is the average longitudinal momentum fraction of the struck quark , and @xmath5 the longitudinal momentum transfer .
the total invariant momentum transfer squared is given by @xmath6 , with the four - momentum transfer @xmath7 .
the average hadron momentum is denoted by @xmath8 .
we also use the short - hand notation @xmath9 . by taking moments with respect to @xmath4
, we end up with a tower of local matrix elements of the form @xmath10 * 3c|c + + num & & @xmath11 + @xmath12 & & @xmath13 + @xmath14 & & @xmath15 + @xmath16 & & @xmath17 + + + num & @xmath18 & @xmath19 & @xmath11 + @xmath20 & @xmath21 & @xmath21 & @xmath22 + + @xmath20 & @xmath21 & @xmath23 & @xmath24 + these matrix elements can then be computed by a lattice simulation .
the parametrization of these matrix elements follows from their lorentz - structure in the continuum and is expressed in terms of the generalized form factors ( gffs ) @xmath25 and @xmath26 .
for example , for @xmath27 : @xmath28 the moments of @xmath29 and @xmath2 are polynomials in @xmath30 with @xmath31 and @xmath32 as coefficients , @xmath33 the reconstruction of the gpds is therefore possible by an inverse mellin transform .
we use five samples of unquenched gauge field data in our simulations .
the parameters of the lattices are presented in tab .
[ tab : latt - pars ] . as valence quarks we use wilson fermions on the sesam lattices and domain wall fermions with a height of @xmath34 and @xmath35 on the milc lattices . in the latter case we also use hyp - smearing @xcite with @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
with @xmath38 for @xmath39 , @xmath40 .
the form factors have been normalized to one at @xmath41 and fitted by a dipole form . ]
the domain - wall masses have been adjusted to keep the pseudoscalar lattice mass in the region of the lowest corresponding staggered one . for the wilson fermion
renormalization constants we use the perturbative one - loop results quoted in @xcite .
the renormalization constants for the domain - wall case are not yet calculated , so we use the tree - level value .
hence , our results are preliminary . .
] . ]
we concentrate on the quark flavor combination u - d since the resulting matrix elements are free from disconnected contributions .
the gff @xmath42 corresponds to the axial form factor , while @xmath43 is the first gff which is not directly accessible experimentally .
both gffs are plotted with normalization @xmath44 for the heaviest quark mass in fig .
[ fig : atilde - n ] .
the curves provide dipole fits to the data points with the error bands representing one standard error .
it is apparent that the dependencies on the parameters @xmath4 and @xmath45 of @xmath46 do not factorize , a result that is very similar to the spin - independent case @xcite .
however , the difference between the two moments appears to be smaller in the spin - dependent case . the axial coupling as a function of the quark mass is plotted in fig .
[ fig : axialcoup ] .
one should note , however , that this quantity is highly sensitive to finite - volume effects @xcite . at least at the lightest mass ,
a couple of simulations at larger lattice volumes need to be performed to achieve a conclusive result for the chiral behavior .
the first moment of the forward parton distribution @xmath47 is displayed in fig . [
fig : atilde - forw ] .
although the measured values decrease in the chiral regime toward the experimental value , this result needs to be corroborated with better statistics .
in this talk we have presented first results on spin - dependent generalized parton distributions . in the forward case
we have presented preliminary results for light quark masses which eventually should allow us to bridge the gap to the chiral regime .
99 d. mller , d. robaschik , b. geyer , f.m .
dittes and j. horejsi , fortsch .
* 42 * ( 1994 ) 101 .
ji , phys .
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 610 .
radyushkin , phys .
d * 56 * ( 1997 ) 5524 .
m. diehl , arxiv : hep - ph/0307382 .
v. bernard , l. elouadrhiri and u.g .
meissner , j. phys .
g * 28 * ( 2002 ) r1
. y. goto _ et al .
_ [ asymmetry analysis collaboration ] , phys .
d * 62 * ( 2000 ) 034017 .
m. glck , e. reya , m. stratmann and w. vogelsang , phys .
d * 63 * ( 2001 ) 094005 .
j. blmlein and h. bttcher , nucl .
b * 636 * ( 2002 ) 225 .
m. gckeler _ et al . _
[ qcdsf collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ph/0304249 .
p. hgler , j.w .
negele , d.b .
renner , w. schroers , t. lippert and k. schilling [ lhpc collaboration ] , phys . rev .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 034505 .
a. hasenfratz and f. knechtli , phys .
d * 64 * ( 2001 ) 034504 .
d. dolgov _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 034506 .
negele _ et al .
_ , these proceedings , arxiv : hep - lat/0309060 .
hemmert and a. schfer , private communication . | we present a lattice measurement of the first two moments of the spin - dependent gpd @xmath0 . from these
we obtain the axial coupling constant and the second moment of the spin - dependent forward parton distribution .
the measurements are done in full qcd using wilson fermions .
in addition , we also present results from a first exploratory study of full qcd using asqtad sea and domain - wall valence fermions . |
it is well known that the exclusive diffractive higgs production provides a very convenient tool for higgs searches at hadron colliders due to a very clean environment unlike the inclusive production @xcite .
a qcd mechanism for the diffractive production of heavy central system has been proposed by kaidalov , khoze , martin and ryskin ( durham group ) for higgs production at the lhc ( see refs .
@xcite ) . below we will refer to it as the kkmr approach . in the framework of this approach the amplitude of the exclusive @xmath12 process
is considered to be a convolution of the hard subprocess amplitude describing fusion of two off - shell gluons producing a heavy system @xmath13 , and the soft hadronic factors containing information about emission of the relatively soft gluons from the proton lines ( see fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] ) . in the framework of the @xmath14-factorisation approach
these soft parts are written in terms of so - called off - diagonal unintegrated gluon distributions ( ugdfs ) .
the qcd factorisation is rigorously justified in the limit of very large factorisation scale being the transverse mass of the central system @xmath15 . _ the qcd mechanism of diffractive production of the heavy central system @xmath16._,scaledwidth=35.0% ] in order to check the underlying production mechanism it is worth to replace the higgs boson by a lighter ( but still heavy enough to provide the qcd factorisation ) meson which is easier to measure . in this respect
the exclusive production of heavy quarkonia is under special interest from both experimental and theoretical point of view @xcite .
verifying the kkmr approach against various data on exclusive meson production at high energies is a good test of nonperturbative dynamics of parton distributions encoded in ugdfs .
recently , the signal from the diffractive @xmath17 charmonia production in the radiative @xmath7 decay channel has been measured by the cdf collaboration @xcite : @xmath18 nb .
assuming the absolute dominance of the spin-0 contribution , this result was published by the cdf collaboration in the form : @xmath19 indeed , in the very forward limit the contributions from @xmath6 vanish due to the @xmath20 selection rule @xcite .
this is not true , however , for general kinematics @xcite .
in particular , it was shown in ref .
@xcite that the axial - vector @xmath10 production , due to a relatively large branching fraction of its radiative decay , may not be negligible and gives a significant contribution to the total signal measured by the cdf collaboration .
the same holds also for the tensor @xmath3 meson contribution @xcite .
recent durham group investigations @xcite support these predictions .
the production of the axial - vector @xmath10 meson is additionally suppressed w.r.t .
@xmath21 in the limit of on - shell fusing gluons ( with non - forward protons ) due to the landau - yang theorem @xcite
. such an extra suppression may , in principle , lead to the dominance of the @xmath3 contribution over the @xmath10 one in the radiative decay channel @xcite .
off - shell effects play a significant role even for the scalar @xmath8 production reducing the total cross section by a factor of 2 5 depending on ugdfs @xcite .
the major part of the amplitude comes from rather small gluon transverse momenta @xmath4 .
this requires a special attention and including all polarisation states @xmath6 .
our present goal is to analyze these issues in more detail in the case of tensor charmonium production at the tevatron , to study its energy dependence and to compare with corresponding contributions from scalar and axial - vector charmonia .
the paper is organized as follows .
section 2 contains the generalities of the qcd central exclusive production mechanism , two different prescriptions for off - diagonal ugdfs are introduced and discussed . in section 3
we derive the hard subprocess amplitude @xmath22 in the nonrelativistic qcd formalism and consider its properties .
section 4 contains numerical results for total and differential cross sections of @xmath17 cep and their correspondence to the last cdf data . in section 5
the summary of main results is given .
the general kinematics of the central exclusive production ( cep ) process @xmath12 with @xmath16 being the colour singlet @xmath24 bound state has already been discussed in our previous papers on @xmath8 @xcite and @xmath10 @xcite production . in this section
we adopt the same notations and consider the matrix element for exclusive @xmath3 production and its properties in detail . according to the kkmr approach
the amplitude of the exclusive double diffractive color singlet production @xmath25 is @xcite @xmath26 where @xmath27 are the momentum transfers along the proton lines , @xmath28 is the momentum of the screening gluon , @xmath29 are the momenta of fusing gluons , and @xmath30 are the off - diagonal ugdfs ( see fig . [
fig : fig1 ] ) .
traditional ( asymmetric ) form of the off - diagonal ugdfs is taken in the limit of very small @xmath31 in analogy to collinear off - diagonal gluon distributions ( with factorized @xmath32-dependence ) @xcite , i.e. @xmath33 with a quasiconstant prefactor @xmath34 which accounts for the single @xmath35 skewed effect @xcite and is found to be @xmath36 at the tevatron energy and @xmath37 at the lhc energy ( for lo pdf ) , @xmath38 are the effective gluon transverse momenta , as adopted in ref .
@xcite , @xmath39 is the proton vertex factor , which can be parameterized as @xmath40 with @xmath41 @xcite , or by the isoscalar nucleon form factor @xmath42 as we have done in ref .
below we shall refer to eq .
( [ asym - off ] ) as kmr ugdf . our results in ref .
@xcite showed up a strong sensitivity of the kmrs numerical results @xcite on the definition of the effective gluon transverse momenta @xmath43 and the factorisation scales @xmath44 .
this behavior is explained by the fact that for @xmath45 production the great part of the diffractive amplitude ( [ ampl ] ) comes from nonperturbatively small @xmath46 .
it means that the total diffractive process is dominated by very soft screening gluon exchanges with no hard scale and extremely small @xmath31 . in principle , the factor @xmath34 in eq .
( [ asym - off ] ) should be a function of @xmath47 and @xmath48 or @xmath49 .
in this case the off - diagonal ugdfs do not depend on @xmath47 and @xmath50 ( or @xmath51 ) , and their evolution is reduced to diagonal ugdfs evolution corresponding to one `` effective '' gluon . in general , the factor @xmath34 can depend on ugdf and reflects complicated and still not well known dynamics in the small-@xmath52 region . in order to test this small-@xmath52 dynamics and estimate the theoretical uncertainties related to introducing one `` effective '' gluon transverse momentum instead of two ones in eq .
( [ asym - off ] ) , in refs .
@xcite we have used more generalized symmetrical prescription for the off - diagonal ugdfs . actually , it is possible to calculate the off - diagonal ugdfs in terms of their diagonal counterparts as follows , @xmath53 arguments must be omitted . ]
@xmath54 where @xmath55 this form of skewed two - gluon ugdfs ( [ skewed - ugdfs ] ) is inspired by the positivity constraints for the collinear generalized parton distributions @xcite , and can be considered as a saturation of the cauchy - schwarz inequality for the density matrix @xcite .
it allows us to incorporate the actual dependence of the off - diagonal ugdfs on longitudinal momentum fraction of the soft screening gluon @xmath47 and its transverse momentum @xmath50 in explicitly symmetric way . as will be shown below , these symmetric off - diagonal ugdfs lead to results which are consistent with the tevatron data .
however , trying to incorporate the actual dependence of ugdfs on ( small but nevertheless finite ) @xmath47 we may encounter a problem .
the kinematics of the double diffractive process @xmath12 does not give any precise expression for @xmath47 in terms of the phase space integration variables .
from the qcd mechanism under consideration one can only expect the general inequality @xmath31 and upper bound @xmath56 since the only scale appearing in the left part of the gluon ladder is the transverse momentum of the soft screening gluon @xmath57 . to explore the sensitivity of the final results on the values of @xmath47 , staying in the framework of traditional kkmr approach
, one can introduce naively @xmath58 with an auxiliary parameter @xmath59 @xcite . in our earlier papers @xcite we considered the limiting case of maximal @xmath47 ( with @xmath60 ) .
however , it is worth to compare the predictions of the underlying qcd mechanism for smaller @xmath59 against the available experimental data in order to estimate typical @xmath47 values
. we will analyze this issue in greater detail in the results section .
projection of the hard amplitude onto the singlet charmonium bound state @xmath61 is given by an 4-dimentional integral over relative momentum of quark and antiquark @xmath62 @xcite : @xmath63.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the function @xmath64 is the momentum space wave function of the charmonium , the clebsch - gordan coefficient in color space is @xmath65 the trace of @xmath32-matrices is @xmath66 , and the projection operator @xmath67 for a small relative momentum @xmath68 has the form @xmath69 since @xmath70-wave function @xmath71 vanishes at the origin , we may expand the trace in eq .
( [ amplitude - diff ] ) in the taylor series around @xmath72 , and only the linear terms in @xmath73 survive .
this yields an expression proportional to @xmath74 with the derivative of the @xmath70-wave radial wave function at the origin @xmath75 whose numerical value can be found in ref .
@xcite . the general @xmath70-wave result ( [ amplitude - diff ] )
may be further reduced by employing the clebsch - gordan identity which for the tensor @xmath76 charmonium states reads @xmath77 taking into account standard definitions of the light - cone vectors @xmath78 and momentum decompositions @xmath79 and using the gauge invariance property ( gribov s trick ) one gets the following projection ( for any spin @xmath80 ) @xmath81 since we adopt here the definition of the polarization vectors proportional to gluon transverse momenta @xmath82 , then @xmath83 it shows that gluon transverse momenta are necessary to get a nonzeroth diffractive cross section .
summarizing all ingredients above , we get the vertex factor @xmath22 in the following covariant form @xmath84 polarization tensor of @xmath76 satisfies the following relations ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite ) @xmath85 one can check that it may be represented in the following general form @xmath86\right)\\ \nonumber & & + \frac12\delta_{1|\lambda|}\big(i[n_2^{\mu}n_3^{\nu}+n_3^{\mu}n_2^{\nu } ] \pm[n_1^{\mu}n_3^{\nu}+n_3^{\mu}n_1^{\nu}]\big ) \\
\nonumber & & -\frac12\delta_{2|\lambda|}\big(i[n_1^{\mu}n_2^{\nu}+n_2^{\mu}n_1^{\nu } ] \pm[n_1^{\mu}n_1^{\nu}-n_2^{\mu}n_2^{\nu}]\big ) \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath87 are light - like basis vectors satisfying @xmath88 ( with @xmath89 ) , and @xmath90 are the @xmath3 meson helicities . to our best knowledge , there is no explicit decomposition of the meson polarisation tensor @xmath91 in terms of basis vectors @xmath92 like eq .
( [ poltens ] ) in the literature . in practical calculations below it is convenient to use it in a different representation : @xmath93 + \frac{\sqrt{6}}{4}(2-|\lambda|)(1-|\lambda|)n_3^{\mu}n_3^{\nu}+\\ \nonumber & & + \frac14\lambda(1-|\lambda|)[n_1^{\mu}n_1^{\nu}-n_2^{\mu}n_2^{\nu}]+ \frac14i|\lambda|(1-|\lambda|)[n_1^{\mu}n_2^{\nu}+n_2^{\mu}n_1^{\nu}]+\\ \nonumber & & + \frac12\lambda(2-|\lambda|)[n_1^{\mu}n_3^{\nu}+n_3^{\mu}n_1^{\nu}]+ \frac12i|\lambda|(2-|\lambda|)[n_2^{\mu}n_3^{\nu}+n_3^{\mu}n_2^{\nu } ] \ ; .\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly to what has been done for @xmath10 production in ref .
@xcite , in the c.m.s .
frame we choose the basis with collinear @xmath94 and @xmath95 vectors ( so , we have @xmath96 ) as a simplest one @xmath97 note , that we choose @xmath98 to be transverse to the c.m.s beam axis ( see fig . [
fig : cms ] ) , while @xmath99 are turned around by the polar angle @xmath100 $ ] between @xmath101 and the c.m.s .
beam axis . in the considered basis @xmath102
we have the following coordinates of the incoming protons @xmath103 the gluon transverse momenta with respect to the c.m.s .
beam axis are @xmath104 where @xmath105 are the components of the gluon transverse momenta in the basis with the @xmath106-axis collinear to the c.m.s .
beam axis . from definition ( [ protons ] )
it follows that energy of the meson and polar angle @xmath107 are related to covariant scalar products in the considered coordinate system as @xcite @xmath108 furthermore , we also see that from @xmath109 and @xmath110 we have @xmath111 relations ( [ epsi ] ) and ( [ x1x2cos ] ) show that the interchange of proton momenta @xmath112 is equivalent to the interchange of the angle @xmath113 , i.e. @xmath114 and @xmath115 simultaneously .
the last permutation also provides the interchange of the longitudinal components of gluons momenta @xmath116 .
conservation laws provide us with the following relations between components of gluon transverse momenta and covariant scalar products @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the meson transverse momentum with respect to the @xmath106-axis .
the appearance of the factor @xmath119 guarantees the applicability of ( [ rel_comp ] ) for positive and negative @xmath120 . note that under permutations @xmath121 implied by bose statistics the components interchange as @xmath122 and @xmath123 . in our notations
the quantity @xmath124 plays a role of the noncollinearity of meson in considered coordinates .
a straightforward calculation leads to the following vertex function in these coordinates @xmath125\times{\bf n}_1|\,(1-|\lambda|)\,\mathrm{sign}(\sin\psi)\,\mathrm{sign}(\cos\psi)+\nonumber\\ & & 2\,|[{\bf q}_{1,t}\times{\bf q}_{2,t}]\times{\bf n}_3|\,(2-|\lambda|)\big\}-\big[2q_{1,t}^2q_{2,t}^2+(q_{1,t}^2+q_{2,t}^2)(q_{1,t}q_{2,t})\big ] \big\{3m^2(\cos^2\psi+1)\lambda(1-|\lambda|)+\nonumber\\ & & 6me\sin(2\psi)\,\lambda(2-|\lambda|)\,\mathrm{sign}(\sin\psi)\,\mathrm{sign}(\cos\psi)+ \sqrt{6}\,(m^2 + 2e^2)\sin^2\psi\,(1-|\lambda|)(2-|\lambda|)\big\}\biggr ] \ ; , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath126\times{\bf n}_1|=\sqrt{q_{1,t}^2q_{2,t}^2-(q_{1,t}q_{2,t})^2}\,|\cos\psi|,\\ & & |[{\bf q}_{1,t}\times{\bf q}_{2,t}]\times{\bf n}_3|=\frac{e}{m}\sqrt{q_{1,t}^2q_{2,t}^2-(q_{1,t}q_{2,t})^2}\,|\sin\psi|.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the amplitude ( [ chi2-fin ] ) explicitly obeys the bose symmetry under the interchange of gluon momenta and polarizations due to resulting simultaneous permutations @xmath115 , @xmath114 and @xmath127 .
it follows from the conservation laws that @xmath128 let us consider first the limit of the `` coherent '' scattering of protons @xmath129 , so @xmath130 the production vertex ( [ chi2-fin ] ) in this limit has the form @xmath131 \big\{3m^2(\cos^2\psi+1)\lambda(1-|\lambda|)+\nonumber\\ & & 6me\sin(2\psi)\,\lambda(2-|\lambda|)\,\mathrm{sign}(\sin\psi)\,\mathrm{sign}(\cos\psi)+ \sqrt{6}\,(m^2 + 2e^2)\sin^2\psi\,(1-|\lambda|)(2-|\lambda|)\big\}\biggr ] \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see that in contrast to the axial - vector case considered in ref .
@xcite , the diffractive amplitude of @xmath3 production does not turn to zero in this `` coherent '' limit for @xmath132 . in the forward limit @xmath133 (
which is a particular case of the `` coherent '' one ) the amplitude turns to zero at any meson rapidities @xmath134 .
indeed , we have @xmath135 and @xmath136 and the amplitude turns into @xmath137 - 2\,|\lambda|\,q_{0t}^xq_{0t}^y\ , \mathrm{sign}(\cos\psi)|_{\psi\to0,\pi}\big\ } \nonumber \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the imaginary part of this vertex function turns out to be antisymmetric w.r.t .
interchanging @xmath138 , whereas its real part is antisymmetric w.r.t .
changing the sign of @xmath139 or @xmath140 component , i.e. @xmath141 since in this case @xmath142 in the forward limit , then the double integral in the diffractive amplitude has an antisymmetric integrand and turns to zero in the symmetric limit @xmath143 this explicitly confirms the observation made in refs .
@xcite .
very recently , when our paper was almost complete , a paper by l. harland - lang , v. khoze , m. ryskin and w. stirling ( hkrs ) @xcite appeared where the hard subprocess amplitudes @xmath144 ( based on formalism by kuhn et al for @xmath145 @xcite ) including the gluon virtualities were listed for different spins including the tensor @xmath3 : @xmath146,\label{hkrs - j0}\\ v_{j=1,\lambda}^{\mathrm{hkrs}}&=&-\frac{2ic}{s}p_{1,\nu}p_{2,\alpha}\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\epsilon_{\beta } \big[(q_{2,t})_{\mu}q_{1,t}^2-(q_{1,t})_{\mu}q_{2,t}^2\big],\label{hkrs - j1}\\ v_{j=2,\lambda}^{\mathrm{hkrs}}&=&\frac{\sqrt{2}cm}{s}\,\epsilon^{\mu\alpha } \big[s(q_{1,t})_{\mu}(q_{2,t})_{\alpha}+2(q_{1,t}q_{2,t})p_{1,\mu}p_{2,\alpha}\big ] , \label{hkrs - j2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the constant prefactor is @xmath147 the first amplitude @xmath148 ( [ hkrs - j0 ] ) is the same as the expression obtained in ref .
@xcite ( up to a factor of 2 coming from different normalisations of the hard part @xmath149 in our case and @xmath150 in ref .
@xcite ) , where the major role of the gluon virtualities in the hard subprocess amplitude of quarkonia production was claimed to be crucial . in particular , it was shown that an account of the gluon virtualities reduces the previous kmrs result in ref .
@xcite for on - mass - shell gluons @xmath151 by a factor of 2 3 . the second amplitude , @xmath152 , looks different from our previous result , obtained in ref . @xcite .
however , one can directly check that the difference between the amplitudes ( [ hkrs - j1 ] ) and ( 2.12 ) in ref .
@xcite turns to zero when fixing the coordinates in the c.m.s .
frame of reference as in eq .
( [ protons ] ) ( see also fig . [
fig : cms ] ) and the meson polarisation vector @xmath153 with the basis as in eq .
( [ basis ] ) .
due to the covariant structure of these amplitudes , the last observation means that they are the same in any frame of reference .
the calculations proving this equality are rather involved , and we do not show them explicitly here . very similar situation holds for @xmath3 production amplitudes .
namely , the amplitudes ( [ hkrs - j2 ] ) and ( [ vgen - chi2 ] ) turned out to be the same under fixing the coordinates as in the previous section . therefore , under the kinematical relations our results for the hard subprocess amplitudes are in complete agreement with the corresponding hkrs results .
let us now turn to the discussion of numerical results .
results for the differential cross sections @xmath154 of the diffractive @xmath17 meson production at the tevatron energy @xmath155 gev for different ugdfs are shown in table [ table : dy0 ] . in the last column
we show the results for the expected signal in the @xmath156 channel summed over all @xmath45 spin states ( and all polarisation states of @xmath6 mesons ) @xmath157 which can be compared with the corresponding value measured by the cdf collaboration @xcite : @xmath158 nb . in refs .
@xcite is was assumed that the nlo corrections factor @xmath159 in the @xmath160 vertex is the same as in the @xmath161 width implying that @xmath162 . in general ,
such corrections depend on spin of @xmath163 resonance .
so , the diffractive cross section for each @xmath164 has to be multiplied by not necessarily the same factor @xmath165 , as shown in eq .
( [ sig ] ) .
this can be done , however , only for @xmath166 and @xmath167 states , and the corresponding nlo qcd radiative corrections are well - known @xcite : @xmath168 due to the landau - yang theorem the decay of the axial vector charmonium @xmath169 to on - shell gluons is forbidden , and there are no reliable calculations of the nlo qcd corrections to its coupling with off - shell gluons . in the following we take naively @xmath170 .
this leads to an additional uncertainty of the model predictions . as has been claimed in refs .
@xcite the absorptive corrections are quite sensitive to the meson spin - parity .
this was studied before in the context of scalar and pseudoscalar higgs production in ref .
we adopt here the following effective gap survival factors , calculated in ref .
@xcite for different spins including eikonal and so - called enhanced contributions : @xmath171 the contribution of the scalar @xmath8 cep , which was initially assumed to be the dominant one @xcite , is reduced by a very small branching ratio of its observable radiative decay @xcite . in turn
, the strong suppression of the @xmath10 central production in both the on - mass - shell limit of fusing gluons ( due to landau - yang theorem @xcite ) and the forward scattering limit of outgoing protons ( due to the so - called @xmath20 selection rule @xcite ) may be partially compensated by its much higher branching ratio to the observed @xmath156 final state @xcite .
analogously to the axial - vector case , the suppression of the tensor @xmath3 cep is likely to be eliminated by its large decay branching ratio @xcite , and the resulting value of the radiative decay signal is under our special interest .
.[table : dy0 ] differential cross section @xmath172 ( in nb ) of the exclusive diffractive production of @xmath17 mesons and their partial and total signal in radiative @xmath156 decay channel @xmath173 at tevatron for different ugdfs , cuts on the transverse momentum of the gluons in the loop ( @xmath57 ) and different values of the auxiliary parameter @xmath59 controlling the characteristic @xmath47 values in the symmetric skewed ugdfs prescription ( [ skewed - ugdfs ] ) ( denoted as `` sqrt '' ) .
nlo skewedness factor @xmath174 for the kmr asymmetric prescription ( [ asym - off ] ) ( denoted as `` @xmath175 '' ) , nlo correction factors ( [ knlo ] ) and absorptive correction factors ( [ s2eff ] ) are included .
contributions from all polarisations are incorporated . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in the case of the kmr ugdf , we observe quite substantial dependence of the predicted observable signal w.r.t
. variations of the infrared cut - off on small transverse momenta of the gluons in the most internal loop ( see fig . [
fig : cutdep ] ) . from table [
table : dy0 ] we see that the shift of @xmath176 from the value @xmath177 used in ref .
@xcite down to the minimal perturbative scale of the integrated grv94ho distributions @xmath178 @xcite leads to increase of the cross section by a factor of about 3 , approaching the cdf data . for comparison ,
decrease of the @xmath179 from @xmath180 down to @xmath178 leads to increase of the cross section by a factor of 6 . since we can not estimate the nonperturbative contribution coming from below @xmath178 ,
this allows us to conclude that perturbatively motivated kmr ugdf leads to infrared unstable result in the case of relatively light charmonium cep .
it is clear that the essential part of the qcd dynamics comes from the nonperturbative region of transverse momenta below the hkrs cut - off @xmath177 @xcite .
ks and gbw ugdfs allow to incorporate some unknown physics even below the minimal grv scale @xmath181 , avoiding ambiguities in defining the effective gluon momenta . applying the kmr s asymmetrical off - diagonal ugdf according to eq .
( [ asym - off ] ) ( `` @xmath34 '' prescription ) in the case of the gbw models we get strongly overestimated observable signal at tevatron , which means that in this case it is crucial to take into account the @xmath47-dependence of off - diagonal ugdfs when going deeply into the infrared region of small @xmath182 s .
the @xmath47-dependent `` sqrt '' prescription , introduced in eq .
( [ skewed - ugdfs ] ) , leads to observable signal , which is much closer to the experimental data .
the `` sqrt '' prescription , introduced in eq .
( [ skewed - ugdfs ] ) , provides an agreement with the data ( within a factor of 2 in overall theoretical uncertainty between different ugdfs ) with the ks ( with rather small @xmath183 ) and gbw models giving the cross section @xmath184 ( see table [ table : dy0 ] ) .
this practically means that the smaller @xmath57 comes into the game , the smaller @xmath47 w.r.t .
@xmath185 is required to get the data description , providing one more argument about importance of nonperturbative effects in charmonia cep .
the relative contributions of different charmonium states in the @xmath156 channel ( including absorption effects ) in the case of , e.g. , ks model are found to be : @xmath186 they are not affected by smaller @xmath47 or nonlinear effects in this model . as the normalization point we took the contribution of the @xmath8 meson cep as was done in ref .
@xcite . _
distributions @xmath187 in rapidity of @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) mesons for different ugdfs at the tevatron energy @xmath188 = 1.96 tev .
the dash - dotted line corresponds to the ks ugdf @xcite in the symmetrical `` sqrt''-prescription with @xmath189 , solid line
kmr ugdf @xcite with @xmath190 , @xmath191 and grv94ho pdf @xcite , and short - dashed line represents result with the gbw ugdf @xcite ( @xmath189 ) .
absorption effects are not included here._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] _ distributions @xmath187 in rapidity of @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) mesons for different ugdfs at the tevatron energy @xmath188 = 1.96 tev .
the dash - dotted line corresponds to the ks ugdf @xcite in the symmetrical `` sqrt''-prescription with @xmath189 , solid line
kmr ugdf @xcite with @xmath190 , @xmath191 and grv94ho pdf @xcite , and short - dashed line represents result with the gbw ugdf @xcite ( @xmath189 ) .
absorption effects are not included here._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] _ distributions @xmath187 in rapidity of @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) mesons for different ugdfs at the tevatron energy @xmath188 = 1.96 tev .
the dash - dotted line corresponds to the ks ugdf @xcite in the symmetrical `` sqrt''-prescription with @xmath189 , solid line
kmr ugdf @xcite with @xmath190 , @xmath191 and grv94ho pdf @xcite , and short - dashed line represents result with the gbw ugdf @xcite ( @xmath189 ) .
absorption effects are not included here._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] in table [ table : dy0 ] we also presented results with the linear kutak - stato model based on the unified bfkl - dglap framework and the nonlinear one based on the balitsky - kovchegov equation @xcite .
it turned out that incorporation of the nonlinear effects responsible for the gluon recombination in this model reduces the @xmath192 cep cross sections by 30 - 50 % .
we see that the nonlinear effects play a crucial role in diffractive quarkonia production effectively decreasing the characteristic values of @xmath47 ( controlled by @xmath59 ) . however , reliable predictions including the nonlinear effects require the exact knowledge of the triple pomeron vertex at nllx accuracy , which is yet unknown .
it is also interesting to compare the diffractive production of @xmath45 states at different energies . as an example , in table [ table : edep ] we present the integrated ( over full phase space ) cross sections of @xmath17 production at rhic , tevatron and lhc energies .
the results show similar energy behavior of the diffractive cross section for different ugdfs as well as for different @xmath45 states .
_ distribution in @xmath27 of @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) for meson cep for different ugdfs .
the meaning of curves here is the same as in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy]._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] _ distribution in @xmath27 of @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) for meson cep for different ugdfs .
the meaning of curves here is the same as in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy]._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] _ distribution in @xmath27 of @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) for meson cep for different ugdfs .
the meaning of curves here is the same as in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy]._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] finally , let us turn to differential distributions . in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy ] we show the differential cross section @xmath193 in rapidity @xmath134 for all @xmath45 states . in this figure and in the following ,
all helicity contributions for @xmath6 cep are taken into account . here and below
we show only bare cep cross sections for gbw , ks and kmr ugdfs . in the last case
, we present the results computed with the hkrs cut - off parameter @xmath177 @xcite .
we see that the shape of the curves is rather similar , however , they have substantially different maxima . the biggest cross section for the @xmath21 states
is obtained with the ks ugdf , whereas for @xmath10 the ks and kmr ugdfs give quite similar cross sections . in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dt ] we present corresponding distributions in @xmath194 or @xmath195 ( identical ) , again for different ugdfs . except of normalisation
the shapes are rather similar .
this is because of the @xmath196 and @xmath197 dependencies of form factors ( describing the off - diagonal effect ) are taken the same for different ugdfs .
_ distribution in relative azimuthal angle @xmath198 between outgoing protons for @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) meson cep for different ugdfs .
the meaning of curves here is the same as in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy]._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] _ distribution in relative azimuthal angle @xmath198 between outgoing protons for @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) meson cep for different ugdfs .
the meaning of curves here is the same as in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy]._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] _ distribution in relative azimuthal angle @xmath198 between outgoing protons for @xmath8 ( left panel ) , @xmath10 ( middle panel ) and @xmath3 ( right panel ) meson cep for different ugdfs .
the meaning of curves here is the same as in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dy]._,scaledwidth=130.0% ] in fig .
[ fig : chic012-dphi ] we show the correlation function @xmath199 in relative azimuthal angle @xmath198 between outgoing protons for different @xmath45 states .
the shapes of the distributions are somewhat dependent on ugdfs .
it is interesting to note here that the ks and kmr ugdfs lead to very similar angular dependence of @xmath199 for all @xmath45 states . in the case
when energy resolution is not enough to separate contributions from different states of @xmath45 ( @xmath8 , @xmath10 , @xmath3 ) , which seems to be the case for tevatron , the distribution in relative azimuthal angle may , at least in principle , be helpful .
the fact that the angular distributions are not simple functions ( like @xmath200 , @xmath201 ) of the relative azimuthal angle between outgoing nucleons is due to the loop integral in eq .
( [ ampl ] ) which destroys the dependence one would obtain with single fusion of well defined ( spin , parity ) objects ( mesons or reggeons ) @xcite .
our results can be summarized as follows : we have derived the qcd amplitude for central exclusive production of tensor @xmath3 meson .
this amplitude vanishes in the forward limit of outgoing protons , as demanded by the @xmath20 selection rule .
our numerical results show the importance of non - forward corrections , including all polarisation states of @xmath3 and nonperturbative contributions to the @xmath3 cep .
inclusion of all the ingredients leads to a noticeable contribution of the @xmath3 meson in the observable radiative decay channel depending on ugdf .
we have observed the importance of the @xmath9 state @xmath10 cep and @xmath202 states for @xmath3 cep at @xmath5 0 , whereas the total cep cross section is dominated by maximal helicity contributions . the main contribution to diffractive charmonium production comes from small gluon transverse momenta @xmath203 leading to quite substantial sensitivity of the corresponding cross section on the infrared cut - off in perturbatively modeled kmr ugdf .
alternatively one could use ugdfs like kutak - stato and gbw models , which by construction can be used for any values of the gluon transverse momenta .
we have tested the symmetrical prescription for off - diagonal ugdfs , following from positivity constraints and incorporating @xmath52 , @xmath182 dependence of both participating gluons , against the present cdf experimental data . a rather good quantitative agreement with the cdf data on charmonium cep in the radiative decay channel
is achieved with the nonlinear kutak - stato ugdf model giving the cross section @xmath204 nb without imposing extra normalisation conditions beyond the qcd framework .
such a description is achieved by incorporating very soft screening gluons with @xmath205 .
we have also calculated total cross sections of @xmath45 cep at different energies ( rhic , tevatron and lhc ) , as well as differential distributions in three phase space variables @xmath206 .
overall theoretical uncertainty of the qcd mechanism under consideration is rather high but hard to estimate due to large unknown nonperturbative contributions coming into the game and not well known higher - order qcd corrections to the hard subprocess @xmath207 ( especially , in the axial - vector case ) .
also , absorptive corrections may depend on ugdf used in the calculation , and there is no reliable estimation of such a sensitivity in literature . in the present paper we kept the strategy to study different distinct options and analyze the sensitivity of the final results with respect to the ugdfs choice , prescriptions for skewed ugdfs , nonperturbative cut - off parameter and characteristic @xmath47 variations , etc .
then a comparison with experimental data would allow to select the most reliable option .
however , we observe a variety of such `` good '' options , namely , description of the data ( with , however , pretty large theoretical uncertainties related , in particular , with unknown nlo corrections ) can be , in principle , achieved for a few ugdfs ( gbw , ks and kmr ugdfs , see table [ table : dy0 ] ) .
each of them pick up some essential qcd dynamics .
further constraints can , in principle , be settled by experimental measurements of separate @xmath192 contributions , the energy dependence of the cross section and the shapes of differential distributions .
useful discussions and helpful correspondence with mike albrow , sergey baranov , rikard enberg , wodek guryn , lucian harland - lang , gunnar ingelman , valery khoze , francesco murgia , mikhail ryskin and wolfgang schfer are gratefully acknowledged .
this study was partially supported by the polish grant of mnisw n n202 249235 , the russian foundation for fundamental research , grants no . 07 - 02 - 91557 , 08 - 02 - 00896 , 09 - 02 - 00732 and no .
09 - 02 - 01149 .
m. g. ryskin , a. d. martin , v. a. khoze and a. g. shuvaev , j. phys .
g * 36 * , 093001 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0907.1374 [ hep - ph ] ] ; j. l. pinfold , int .
j. mod .
a * 24 * , 351 ( 2009 ) ; c. royon , arxiv:0904.2217 [ hep - ph ] .
r. s. pasechnik , a. szczurek and o. v. teryaev , pos eps - hep9:335 , 2009 [ arxiv:0909.4498 [ hep - ph ] ] . l. a. harland - lang , v. a. khoze , m. g. ryskin and w. j. stirling , arxiv:0909.4748 [ hep - ph ] .
v. a. khoze , a. d. martin , m. g. ryskin and w. j. stirling , eur .
j. c * 35 * , 211 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0403218 ] .
m. a. kimber , a. d. martin and m. g. ryskin , phys .
d * 63 * , 114027 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0101348 ] ; a. d. martin and m. g. ryskin , phys .
d * 64 * , 094017 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0107149 ] .
a. g. shuvaev , k. j. golec - biernat , a. d. martin and m. g. ryskin , phys .
d * 60 * , 014015 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9902410 ] .
v. a. khoze , a. d. martin and m. g. ryskin , eur .
j. c * 18 * , 167 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0007359 ] .
p. hagler , r. kirschner , a. schafer , l. szymanowski and o. teryaev , phys .
d * 62 * , 071502 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0002077 ] ; + ph .
hagler , r. kirschner , a. schafer , l. szymanowski and o. v. teryaev , phys .
d * 63 * , 077501 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0008316 ] .
j. h. kuhn , j. kaplan and e. g. o. safiani , nucl .
b * 157 * , 125 ( 1979 ) .
r. barbieri , m. caffo , r. gatto and e. remiddi , nucl .
b * 192 * , 61 ( 1981 ) ; + w. kwong , p. b. mackenzie , r. rosenfeld and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 37 * , 3210 ( 1988 ) ; + m. l. mangano and a. petrelli , phys .
b * 352 * , 445 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9503465 ] .
landau , dokl .
akad . nauk .
60 * ( 1948 ) 207 ; + c.n .
yang , phys . rev .
* 17 * ( 1950 ) 242 .
v. a. khoze , a. d. martin and m. g. ryskin , eur .
j. c * 19 * , 477 ( 2001 ) [ erratum - ibid .
c * 20 * , 599 ( 2001 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/0011393 ] .
c. amsler et al .
( particle data group ) , phys .
b667 * 1 ( 2008 ) and 2009 partial update for the 2010 edition . | we discuss central exclusive production ( cep ) of the tensor @xmath0 meson in proton-(anti)proton collisions at tevatron , rhic and lhc energies .
the amplitude for the process is derived within the @xmath1-factorisation approach .
differential and total cross sections are calculated for several unintegrated gluon distributions ( ugdfs ) .
we compare exclusive production of all charmonium states @xmath2 and @xmath3
. equally good description of the recent tevatron data is achieved both with martin - ryskin phenomenological ugdf and ugdf based on unified bfkl - dglap approach . unlike for higgs production , the main contribution to the diffractive amplitude of heavy quarkonia comes from nonperturbative region of gluon transverse momenta @xmath4 . at @xmath5 0 , depending on ugdf
we predict the contribution of @xmath6 to the @xmath7 channel to be comparable or larger than that of the @xmath8 one .
this is partially due to a significant contribution from lower polarization states @xmath9 for @xmath10 and @xmath11 for @xmath3 meson .
corresponding theoretical uncertainties are discussed . |
for physicists physics is a permanent inspiration for new discoveries .
however , non - physicists often consider physics as a boring and old discipline , detached from everyday life .
public often fails to realize the consequences of research in everyday applications , so it often considers the academic research as a waste of financial resources .
but research is tightly connected to the development even if it is not strongly focused toward applications .
this can be best illustrated by the well known statement that the light bulb was not discovered by optimizing a candle@xcite .
the apparent non - relevance of physics for the everyday life is often caused by the choice of topics taught during the lectures , which are usually old from the point of young students , since even the most recent topics - fundamentals of modern physics - are more than a hundred years old @xcite .
in addition , traditional teaching very often considers idealized examples and , worst of all , present experiments as a prooffor theoretical explanations .
the physics education research has pointed out several of these problems and the physics education in general has advanced tremendously in the last twenty years @xcite . but topics that introduce a part of the frontier research into the classroom , showing the students that the physics is not a dead subject yet , are still extremely rare . in this paper
we present a topic , liquid crystals , which is one of rare examples , where such a transfer is possible .
the community occupied by the research on liquid crystals counts several thousands of researchers .
we all experience the consequences of research on liquid crystals every day ; every mobile phone , every portable computer and almost every television screen is based on the technology using liquid crystals .
the physics of liquid crystals is not very simple but there are several concepts that can be understood by non - physics students as well , especially if the teaching approach is based on gaining practical experiences with liquid crystals . in addition , for advanced levels of physics students , liquid crystals may serve as a clear illustration of several concepts especially in thermodynamics and optics .
a serious interest of researchers for an introduction of liquid crystals into various levels of education was first demonstrated at the international liquid crystal conference ( ilcc ) in krakow , poland , in 2010 .
ilcc is a biennial event gathering more than 800 researchers studying liquid crystals from a variety of aspects . in krakow ,
one of four sections running in parallel was called _
liquid crystals in education_. the audience unexpectedly filled the auditory to the last corner and after lectures lengthy discussions developed @xcite . a similar story repeated at the education section at the european conference on liquid crystals in maribor , slovenia , in 2011 , and at ilcc in mainz , germany , in 2012 . at present , some of the physics of liquid crystals is usually briefly mentioned at various courses at the university level , but there is no systematic consideration from the education perspective about the importance of various concepts and teaching methods . to our best knowledge ,
there exist no example of a model teaching unit . in this contribution
we report on a teaching module on liquid crystals , which is appropriate for the undergraduate level for non - physicists .
the module can be extended to the lab work at more advanced levels .
most of the module can also be used in courses related to thermodynamics and optics as demonstration experiments or lab work accompanied by more rigorous measurements and calculations , which are not considered in detail in this contribution .
the paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we consider the prerequisites for the introduction of new modern topic into education . before designing a module we had to consider several points , not necessary in the same order as quoted here :
what outcomes do we expect of the teaching module ? which are the concepts that students should understand and be able to apply after the module ? where in the curriculum should the topic be placed , or equivalently , what is the knowledge students need to be able to construct new knowledge about liquid crystals ? which teaching methods are most appropriate for the teaching module ? and
finally , do we have all the materials like experiments , pictures , equipment and facilities to support the teaching module ?
in section 3 we report the pilot evaluation study of the teaching module , which was performed in 2011 . in section 4
we conclude and discuss several opportunities that the new teaching module offers to the physics education research in addition to the new knowledge itself .
when we consider a new topic which is a part of contemporary research with applications met every day , and we want to adapt it for teaching purposes , the literature search is not much of a help .
a thorough literature search did not show any theoretical frameworks on this topic .
one can find theoretical frameworks for various approaches to teaching and discussions about students motivation and understanding of various concepts .
we have found few examples of introduction of new topics like an introduction of semiconductors into the secondary school or introduction of more advanced concepts with respect to friction only @xcite .
there are also examples of introduction of concepts of quantum mechanics into high school @xcite .
all authors reported similar problems with respect to the existing theories and results in physics and science education research ; they had to build the units mostly from the personal knowledge , experience and considerations .
on the other hand , several approaches for analytical derivation of already treated concepts , several suggestions for demonstrations and lab experiments for teaching purposes are published in every issue of the american and european journal of physics .
this simply means that the physics community is highly interested in the improvement of the teaching itself , but the motivation of the researchers , being also lecturers , lies more in the area of developing new experiments than in thorough studies of their impact .
therefore , a lot of material for teaching purposes for any topic , old , modern or new is available , but one further step is usually needed towards the coherent teaching module . with the above mentioned problems in mind , we begin by brief discussion on what liquid crystals are and then give a short overview of the existing literature regarding the introduction of liquid crystals into teaching .
then we focus on the teaching module : we define our goals , consider the pre - knowledge on which the module should be built and finally describe details of the module .
liquid crystals are materials which have at least one additional phase between the liquid and the solid phase .
this phase is called the liquid crystalline phase and it has properties of both the liquid and the crystalline phase : a ) it flows like a liquid , or more fundamental , there is no long range order in at least one of directions , and b ) it is anisotropic , which is a property of crystals , or , again , more fundamental , there exists a long range order in at least one of directions .
the name liquid crystal is the name for the material , which exhibits at least one liquid crystalline phase @xcite .
liquid crystalline phases differ by the way of long range ordering . in this contribution
we will discuss only the simplest type of ordering that is typical for the nematic phase .
its properties are applied in a liquid crystalline screen . the molecular order in the crystalline phase
is shown schematically in figure [ fig : fig_1 ] ( a ) , in the nematic liquid crystalline phase in figure [ fig : fig_1 ] ( b ) and in the isotropic liquid phase in figure [ fig : fig_1 ] ( c ) .
one can see that , in the liquid crystalline phase , there exists some orientational order of long molecular axes .
such a material is anisotropic , the physical properties along the average long molecular axis obviously being different from the properties in the direction perpendicular to it .
there are several liquid crystal phases made of molecules having rather extravagant shapes .
however , we shall limit our discussion to the simplest case of nematic liquid crystal made of rod - like molecules without any loss of generality of the phenomena studied within the teaching module . when liquid crystal molecules are close to surfaces , surfaces in general tend to prefer some orientation of long molecular axes .
using a special surface treatment one can achieve a well - defined orientation of long molecular axes at the surface , for example , in the direction parallel to the surface or perpendicular to it . in liquid crystal cells , which are used in liquid crystal displays ( lcds ) ,
surfaces are usually such that they anchor the molecules by their long molecular axes in the direction parallel to the surface ; however orientations of molecules at the top and bottom surface are perpendicular . molecules between the surfaces tend to arrange with their long axis being parallel , however due to the surface anchoring their orientation rotates through the cell ( figure [ fig : fig_2 ] ( a ) ) . because in the anisotropic materials the speed of light depends on the direction of light propagation and on the direction of light polarization , liquid crystals organized in such a special way rotate direction of light polarization .
if such a cell is put between two crossed polarizers whose transmission directions coincide with the direction of surface anchoring , the cell transmits light @xcite .
= 0 ) the cell transmits light ; ( b ) the dark state : when voltage is applied to the two glass plates molecules rearrange and the cell does not transmit light . ]
liquid crystals are also extremely useful in discussing different competing effects that determine the molecular arrangement .
application of an external magnetic or electric field changes the structure in the liquid crystal cell described above , because the electric or magnetic torque tends to arrange molecules in the direction parallel or perpendicular to the external field , depending on the molecular properties .
rotation of molecules in the external field changes the optical transmission properties of the cell .
this is a basis of how lcds work : with the field on ( figure fig : fig_2 ( b ) ) , light is not transmitted through a cell and the cell is seen to be dark ; with the field off ( figure [ fig : fig_2 ] ( a ) ) , light is transmitted through the cell and the cell is seen to be bright .
because of their unique physical properties several authors have already considered the introduction of liquid crystals into the undergraduate university studies . a mechanical model of a three dimensional presentation of liquid crystals phases
is presented in @xcite .
the historical development of the liquid crystals research and their application is given in @xcite .
in @xcite the same authors point out that liquid crystals are an excellent material to connect some elementary physics with technology and other scientific disciplines . the procedures to synthesize cholesteric liquid crystals ( nematic liquid crystals in which the average orientation of long molecular axes spirals in space ) in a school lab at the undergraduate university level are given in @xcite together with the methods to test the elementary physical properties of liquid crystals .
in the appendix to hecke_2005 an experiment to determine refractive indices of a liquid crystal is discussed @xcite .
the anisotropic absorption of polarized light in liquid crystals is presented .
liquid crystals that are appropriate for the education purposes are thermotropic ; their properties change with temperature .
the colour of cholesteric liquid crystals changes if temperature increases or decreases , so they can be used as thermometers @xcite .
they are also sensitive to pressure .
reference @xcite contains worksheets for an experiment in which students discover the sensitivity of cholesteric liquid crystals mixtures on pressure and temperature . in @xcite a simple experimental setup is presented by which students can detect and record the light spectra , study and test the concept of bragg reflection , and measure the anisotropy of a refractive index in a cholesteric liquid crystal .
a series of simple experiments that can be shown during lectures and can bring the science of liquid crystals closer to students is described in ciferno_1995 .
the experiments are used to introduce the concepts of optics , such as light propagation , polarization of light , scattering of light and optical anisotropy .
liquid crystal can also be used to describe light transmission through polarizers @xcite . when an external field is applied to a cell
, a threshold value is required to rotate molecules in the direction preferred by the field .
this effect is called the freedericksz transition and an experiment for the advanced physics lab at the undergraduate level is presented in @xcite .
the procedure to prepare a surface - oriented liquid crystal cell is given @xcite where the procedure to synthesize a nematic liquid crystal 4-methoxybenzylidene-4-n - butylaniline ( mbba ) is provided as well .
several experiments that illustrate optical properties of liquid crystals are shown .
one learns how to design a cell in which molecules are uniformly oriented and what is observed , if this cell is studied under the polarizing microscope . a detailed description of phase transitions between the liquid
, liquid crystal and crystal phases is given .
exercises are interesting for undergraduate students because they synthesize the substance which they use for other experiments , e.g. measurements of the refractive indices .
there are several advanced articles which give advice on the inclusion of liquid crystals into the study process at the university , both undergraduate or graduate , level .
an experiment for the advanced undergraduate laboratory on magnetic birefringence in liquid crystals is presented in moses_2000 , measurements of order and biaxiality are addressed in low_2002 . in @xcite defects in nematic liquid crystals are studied by using physics applets @xcite .
liquid crystals are not used only in displays but also in switches . in @xcite a liquid crystal spatial light modulator is built and used for a dynamic manipulation of a laser beam .
when discussing an introduction of a new topic into education , the team should be aware of the goals as well as of limitations .
there are no general criteria established about the concepts that student should learn and comprehend , when a new topic is introduced .
therefore , for liquid crystals , we had to rely on our understanding of the topic ; we had to neglect our personal bias toward the matter as two of the authors are also active researchers in the theoretical modeling of liquid crystals .
being an expert in the research of liquid crystals may also over or under estimate the concepts that are important for students .
we hope that we managed to avoid these personaltraps .
the aim of the teaching module is to explain how lcds work and what is the role of liquid crystals in its operation .
we also believe that some basic understanding of lcds is a part of a general public knowledge , because it is an important example of the link between the academic research and the applications , which follow from it .
if non - physics students meet such an example at least once during their studies , they might not consider the academic research that has no immediate specific application as obsolete . according to our opinion
students should obtain and understand the following specific concepts : * they should be able to recognize and identify the object of interest - the pixel - on an enlarged screen ; * they should be aware of the fact that liquid crystals are a special phase of matter having very special properties ; * they should become familiar with the following concepts : anisotropy , double refraction and birefringence ; * they should be aware of the fact that liquid crystals must be ordered if we want to exploit their special properties ; * they should know that liquid crystals are easily manipulated by external stimuli like an electric field ; and finally * they should link the concepts mentioned above in a consistent picture of pixel operation . before constructing the teaching module we have thus set the goals stated above .
the next steps are : a ) to consider the required knowledge before the students start the module , b ) to position the topic in the curriculum , otherwise teachers will probably not adopt it and c ) to choose the methods , which will be the most successful for constructing the new knowledge .
as liquid crystals are materials which form a special liquid crystalline phase , students should be familiar with a concept of phases .
they should be aware of a phase transition that appears at an exact temperature .
students very often believe that mixture of ice and water can have any temperature as they often drink mixtures of ice and water , which are not in a thermodynamically stable state yet .
the next important concept is the speed of light in a transparent medium , its relation to the index of refraction and snell s law .
if students are familiar with the concept of polarized light and methods of polarizing the light , it is an advantage .
however , polarization of light can also be nicely taught when teaching the properties of liquid crystals .
students should also know , at least conceptually , that materials electrically polarize in an external electric field and that the material polarization ( not to be confused with polarization of light ! ) is a consequence of structural changes of a material in the electric field
. considerations of the required preliminary students knowledge also give some hints about the placement of the topic on liquid crystals in the curriculum : * when teaching thermodynamics or , more specifically , phases and phase transitions , additional phase can be visually shown by liquid crystals , since the appearance of liquid crystals in their liquid crystalline phase is significantly different from their solid or liquid state .
this is not the case for other materials , for example , a ferromagnetic material or a superconductor looks exactly the same when the phase transition to the ferromagnetic or superconductive phase appears at the transition temperature .
the phase transition has to be deduced from other properties .
* when snell s law is introduced and prisms are discussed , a rainbow is often added as an interesting phenomenon that is observed because the speed of light depends on its wavelength .
similar phenomenon , i.e. a dependence of the speed of light on light polarization can be discussed by a phenomenon of a double refraction .
* one picture element ( pixel ) is formed by confining lc between two conducting plates .
one pixel is thus a capacitor with a dielectric material ( liquid crystal ) between the plates .
when voltage is applied to the cell surfaces ( capacitor plates ) , the material between the plates polarizes .
electric polarization leads to changes in structural properties of the materials , in this case to the reorientation of molecules , which affects the transmission of light through the cell .
thus a lc pixel can be used to consider electric polarization of other materials that can structurally change due to the reorientation of molecules . from the above
we clearly see that liquid crystals can provide a motivational _ file rouge _ through several topics . on the other hand , by showing several phenomena related to liquid crystals , teachers can motivate students to remain interested in various topics in physics and link them together in the explanation of how one pixel in a liquid crystal display works .
teachers can choose to teach about liquid crystals as a separate topic aiming to establish a link between a current fundamental research topic and consequences of the research applied and used every day by everybody .
the last question that remains to be answered is a choice of methods for the teaching intervention .
liquid crystals are a new topic for students .
they are mostly only slightly familiar with the name and have practically no associations connected to the name except a loose connection to displays , as will be shown later .
therefore the topic should be introduced from the very beginning . due to several concepts that must be introduced and the structure of understanding that students have to build without any pre - knowledge , traditional lecturing seems the most natural choice . however , from the literature and our experiences we are aware that the transfer of knowledge to relatively passive students is not as successful as one would wish for .
therefore we decided to use a combination of a traditional lecture accompanied by several demonstration experiments , where most of the fundamental concepts and properties are introduced , a chemistry lab , where students synthesize a liquid crystal , and a physics lab , where they use their own product from the chemistry lab to study its various physical properties by using an active learning approach .
the lab work allows students to construct and to comprehend several new ideas that are all linked together in the application , a liquid crystalline display .
the teaching module gives the basic knowledge about liquid crystals , which we assessed as necessary for the understanding of liquid crystals and liquid crystal display technology for a general citizen having at least a slight interest in science and technology .
the teaching module has three parts : lecture ( 1st week ) , lab work at chemistry ( 2nd week ) and lab work at physics ( 3rd week ) .
the estimated time for each part is 90 minutes . within the teaching module we wanted the students to assimilate the following concepts : a ) a synthesis of a liquid crystals mbba @xcite , b ) an existence of an additional phase and phase transitions , c ) polarization of light and d ) optical properties of liquid crystals related to anisotropy @xcite .
below we present the module , its aims , its structure and a short description of activities in each part of the teaching module .
the lecture in duration of 90 minutes provides the fundamental information about liquid crystals , about their properties and how they are used in applications .
the method used is a traditional lecture accompanied by several demonstration experiments that are used for motivation , as a starting point for discussion and as an illustration of phenomena discussed .
after the lecture students should be able to * list some products based on the liquid crystal technology ; * recognize the additional liquid crystalline phase and phase transition ; * describe and illustrate the structure of liquid crystals on a microscopic level ; * recognize the properties of liquid crystals , which are important for applications : birefringence , resulting from the orientational ordering of molecules , and the effect of an electric field on molecular orientation ; * describe how a lcds work ; * know that liquid crystals are also found in nature and that they are present in living organisms .
in addition , a short part of the lecture introduces polarizers and their properties , since most of the students have not heard of the concept of polarization and polarizers during their previous education .
the lecture starts with a magnification of a lc screen as a motivation ; it is explained that at the end of the module students will be able to understand how the display works .
the lecture continues with a description and a demonstration of the new , liquid crystalline , phase , the macroscopic appearance of which is similar to an opaque liquid .
all three phases ( crystalline , liquid crystalline and isotropic liquid ) are shown while heating the sample .
the microscopic structures of all three phases are presented by cartoons and the orientational order is introduced . the molecular shape which allows for the orientational ordering is discussed .
the concept of light propagation in an anisotropic material is introduced and double refraction is shown by using a wedge liquid crystalline cell .
colours of an anisotropic material ( scotch tape ) between crossed polarizers are demonstrated and explained .
when polarized light propagates through an anisotropic material , the polarization state of light , in general , changes from the linearly polarized to elliptically polarized .
the state of elliptical polarization is defined by the wavelength of light , the birefringence of the anisotropic material ( i.e. the difference between the refractive indices ) and the thickness of the material .
the understanding of how polarized light propagates through a birefringent ( optically anisotropic ) material is crucial for understanding the pixel operation . in the lcds
the electric properties of molecules are very important so they have to be introduced in the lecture .
the effect of the electric field on the molecular orientation is discussed as well .
molecules are described as induced electric dipoles that are rotated by the external electric field .
because the anisotropic properties depend on the structure of the liquid crystal in the cell , the transmission depends on the applied electric field .
this leads to the structure of a pixel and to how liquid crystal displays work . at the end of the lecture
some interesting facts are mentioned , such as liquid crystals being a part of spider threads and cell membranes in living organisms .
the aims of the lab work in chemistry are the following : * students are able to synthesize the liquid crystal mbba .
* students realize that the product of the synthesis is useful for the experiments showing the basic properties of liquid crystals .
students synthesize the liquid crystal mbba in a school lab from 4-n - butylaniline and of 4-methoxybenzaldehyde @xcite .
due to the safety reasons , the synthesis has to be carried out in the fume hood .
this part of the teaching module can be left out if the laboratory is not available and the lab work in physics could extend to two meetings of the duration of 90 minutes , which allows for more detailed studies of phenomena .
four experiments that are carried out during the lab work in physics provide students with personal experiences and allow them to investigate the most important liquid crystalline properties .
* experiment 1 : an additional phase and phase transition * aims : * students know that the liquid crystalline state is one of the states of mater .
* students are able to describe the difference between the melting temperature and the clearing temperature . *
students are able to measure these two temperatures and use them as a measure of the success of the synthesis . if both temperatures are close to the temperatures given in the published data , the synthesis was successful .
students use a water bath to heat the test tube with a frozen liquid crystal mbba .
they measure the temperature of water assuming that the small sample of liquid crystal has the same temperature as the bath .
they observe how the appearance of the substance changes ( figure [ fig : fig_3 ] ) while heating the water bath .
they measure the temperature at which the sample begins to melt .
this temperature is called the melting temperature and it is the temperature of the phase transition from the crystalline to the liquid crystalline phase .
students heat the water bath further and measure the temperature at which the milky appearance of the sample starts to disappear .
this temperature is called the clearing temperature and it is the temperature of the phase transition from the liquid crystalline phase to the isotropic liquid . *
experiment 2 : polarization * aims : * students know what polarizers are and how they affect the unpolarized light . * students know how light propagates through the system of two polarizers . *
students are able to test , if the light is polarized and in which direction it is polarized by using the polarizer with a known polarizing direction .
* students are able to test if the substance is optically anisotropic by using two polarizers .
students use two polarizers and investigate the conditions under which light propagates through two polarizers or is absorbed by them .
they compare the transmitted light intensity as a function of the angle between the polarizing directions of polarizers . by this part of the activity they learn how to use a polarizer as an analyzer .
they also verify that the reflected light is partially polarized .
students observe various transparent materials placed between crossed polarizers and find that light can not be transmitted when ( isotropic ) materials like water or glass are placed between the crossed polarizers . when some other material like a scotch tape , cellophane or cd box is placed between the crossed polarizers ,
light is transmitted .
colours are also often observed ( figure [ fig : fig_4 ] ) .
such materials are anisotropic .
students can investigate how various properties of anisotropic materials ( thickness , type of material ) influence the colour of the transmitted light .
the activity provides an experience that is later used for observations of liquid crystals in a cell .
* experiment 3 : double refraction * aims : * students know that birefringence is an important property of matter in the liquid crystalline state . * students are able to make a planar wedge cell and find an area where liquid crystal is ordered enough that the laser beam splits into two separate beams .
the beams are observed as two light spots on a remote screen .
* students know how to check light polarization in a beam by a polarizer .
students manufacture a wedge cell from a microscope slide , a cover glass , a foil for food wrapping or a tape and the liquid crystal mbba pavlin_2011 .
a special attention is given to the rubbing of the microscope and cover glass , which enables anchoring of the liquid crystal molecules .
the rubbing also prevents the disorder of clusters of molecules with the same orientation of long molecular axis ; such clustering results in scattering of light and opaqueness .
students direct the light on the wedge cell ( they use a laser pointer as the light source ) and find the area of the cell where the laser beam splits into two beams . by rotating the polarizer between the cell and the screen they verify light polarization in the beams ( figure [ fig : fig_5 ] ) . then students heat the wedge cell with the hair - dryer and observe the collapse of the two bright spots into one at the phase transition to the isotropic liquid . *
experiment 4 : colours * aims : * students are able to fabricate a planar cell , i.e. a cell with parallel glass surfaces .
* students know that liquid crystals are optically anisotropic and that light is transmitted if a cell filled with liquid crystal in its liquid crystalline phase is placed between two crossed polarizers.they know that under such circumstances colours may also appear when the sample is illuminated by white light .
* students know that the colours observed under perpendicular and under parallel polarizers are complementary .
* students are able to mechanically order molecules in a planar cell .
students manufacture a planar cell filled with the liquid crystal mbba from a microscope slide , a cover glass and a foil for food wrapping or a tape @xcite .
they observe the planar cell under a polarizing microscope ( a school microscope with @xmath0 or @xmath1 and two crossed polarizing foils ) . at this point
students should remember the descriptive definition of optically anisotropic materials and find out that liquid crystals are their representatives .
then they rotate the polarizing foils and observe how colours change ( see figure [ fig : fig_6 ] ) .
this experiment also illustrates a concept of complementary colours @xcite .
afterwards students heat the cell and observe colour changes .
an experiment where molecules are ordered is done next .
students make micro notches on a microscope slide by rubbing it by a velvet soaked in alcohol .
molecules orient with their long axes parallel to the surface and the rubbing direction .
a similar process is used in the fabrication of liquid crystal displays .
they observe the cell with the ordered liquid crystal under the polarizing microscope .
finally , the cell is heated by a hair - dryer and students observe the phase transition that appears as a dark front moving through the sample ending in a dark image when the liquid crystal between crossed polarizers is in the isotropic phase .
the lab work is concluded by a discussion of how one pixel in the lcd works , relating the changes of the liquid crystalline structure due to the electric field to the transmission rate of the pixel . at this point
the fact that colour filters are responsible for colours of each part of the pixel is also emphasized .
the aim of our study was development of a teaching module for non - physics students , which could also be implemented for the high school students .
our goal was to give future primary school teachers basic knowledge about liquid crystals , so that they will be able to answer potential questions of younger students when they will be teachers themselves .
therefore , the teaching module described in the previous section was preliminary tested by a group of 90 first year students enrolled in a four - year university program for primary school teachers at the faculty of education ( university of ljubljana , slovenia ) in the school year 2010/11 . in this section we present the evaluation of the module as regards the efficiency of teaching intervention : which concepts do students assimilate and comprehend and to what extent ?
first - year pre - service teachers ( future primary school teachers ) were chosen for testing the teaching module .
they were chosen , because their pre - knowledge on liquid crystals is just as negligible as the pre - knowledge of students from other faculties and study programs ( see section 4 ) .
in addition , the pre - service teachers do not have any special interest in natural sciences , but they have to be as scientifically literate as everyone else who has finished high school . and most important ,
the pre - service primary school teachers form the only homogeneous group that has physics included in the study program and is , at least approximately , large enough to allow for a quantitative study . in the group of @xmath2 , @xmath3 were male and @xmath4 female students .
they were on average @xmath5 years old ( @xmath6 years ) . on average
, they achieved @xmath7 points out of @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) on the final exam at the end of the secondary school .
the average achievement on the final exam in slovenia was @xmath10 points out of @xmath8 and a total of @xmath11 candidates attended the final exams in spring 2010 .
the studied group consisted of predominantly rural population with mixed socio - economics status .
the data collection took place by a pre - test , classroom observations of the group work , worksheets and tests .
the pre - test had 28 short questions .
the first part ( @xmath12 questions ) was related to a general data about a student : gender , age , secondary school , final exam , residence stratum and motivation for science subjects . the second part ( @xmath13 questions )
was related to liquid crystals , their existence , properties and microscopic structure .
the pre - test was applied at the beginning of lecture related to liquid crystals .
those students who did not attend the lecture filled in the pre - test before the beginning of the compulsory lab work in chemistry .
the worksheet for the lab work in chemistry includes a procedure to synthesise liquid crystal mbba , a reaction scheme , observations and conclusions regarding the synthesis and questions from chemistry related to liquid crystals and the lab work .
the worksheet for the lab work in physics presents properties of polarizing foils and optically anisotropic materials and experiments with the liquid crystal mbba .
test @xmath14 includes @xmath15 short questions related to the knowledge obtained during the lecture and lab work .
test @xmath14 was held immediately after the end of the physics lab ( in may 2011 ) .
test 2 was a part of an exam held @xmath16 weeks later ( june 2011 ) .
it has @xmath15 questions that , again , cover the contents of the lecture and lab work .
questions on test @xmath17 were similar to questions given on the pre - test and test @xmath14 .
the study provided an extensive set of data but in this paper we will focus only on students comprehension of new concepts .
results of the pre - test show that @xmath18 of students have already heard of liquid crystals .
the percentage is so high , because we were testing students informally obtained knowledge about liquid crystals as a part of another study held at the beginning of the academic year .
one student said : when we got the questionnaire at the beginning of the academic year i was ashamed because i did not know anything about liquid crystals .
when i came home i asked my father and checked on the web what they are .
these experiments definitely bring them closer to me .
such an interest is a rare exception , however , most of the students remembered the term liquid crystals , which was a central point of the questionnaire that they filled in at the beginning of the academic year 2010/11 . since lectures are not compulsory only @xmath19 students attended the lecture .
150 students attended compulsory laboratories .
they worked on the synthesis a week after the lectures and another week later on experiments with liquid crystals at the physics lab .
students worked in groups of @xmath20 or @xmath16 in the chemistry lab and in pairs in the physics lab .
however , the whole data ( tests and worksheets ) was collected only for 90 students , therefore we present only their achievements .
all the groups made the synthesis successfully according to the procedure written in the worksheets .
@xmath21 syntheses out of @xmath21 were successfully carried out which was confirmed by measuring the melting and clearing temperature of the synthesized liquid crystal mbba . on average @xmath22 of worksheets
were correctly filled in ( @xmath23 ) .
all the experiments described in section 2.4.3 were successfully carried out in the physics lab .
the only difference was that students did not prepare the wedge cell by themselves . due to the lack of time cells
were prepared in advance . on
average 84 % of worksheets included correct answers to questions and observations ( @xmath24 ) . on the pre - test students on average achieved @xmath25 of all points .
their achievements show that their prior knowledge about liquid crystals was limited , as expected . on test 1 that was held immediately after the physics lab
, students on average achieved 68.1 % ( see table [ table : tablei ] ) .
test @xmath17 was a part of a regular exam in physics .
on test @xmath17 students on average achieved only @xmath26 points . the reduced performance on test 2
can be explained by the research on memory and retention , which suggests that many standard educational practices , such as exams and a great emphasis on the final exam , which encourages studying by cramming , are likely to lead to the enhanced short - term performance at the expense of a poor long - term retention @xcite . .
students achievements on tests [ cols= " < , < , < , < , < " , ] to conclude , the results from the testing of informally gained knowledge at the end of the secondary school of the pre - service teachers and the students from different faculties on average do not differ : in both samples the lack of knowledge about liquid crystals was detected .
based on the research of prior knowledge it can be said that students that are interested in natural sciences and technology would assimilate at least as much knowledge about liquid crystals from the teaching module as the pre - service teachers did . since the results of prior knowledge show statistically significant differences between the knowledge of male and female students one can even dare to conclude that the male students would achieve better results on testing of the module as female students .
one can therefore safely conclude that a general audience would achieve at least as good results as the group of students involved in this study .
it must be stressed that we have designed the module in which students acquire new knowledge relevant to liquid crystals and their applications , as confirmed by the implementation and the evaluation of the module .
module can also be used as a teaching module at more specialized physics courses .
of course there are still opened issues that we intend to explore . since we know that the module is appropriate for students that are not motivated in science we will work on the adaptation of module for students motivated in natural sciences .
the module presented in this paper can be readily used in the introductory physics courses , and with appropriate modifications it can also be used at lower levels of education .
evaluation of the model raised several questions that need to be addressed in the future : how do practical experiences influence the knowledge about liquid crystals ?
, how does a new learning environment influence the knowledge ?
, how do the chosen teaching methods influence the study process ? , etc . however , the whole study and its evaluation show that it is worth an effort to develop new modules on topics related to the current scientific research and everyday technology .
99 ghidaglia j m june 2009 high - performance computing is going to save research _
la recherche _ 3 butterworth
j 27 july 2010 sarkozy shares his enlightenment vision with high - energy physicists _ the guardian _ ( see : http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/blog/2010/jul/27/sarkozy-high-energy-physicists-ichep ) repnik r , cvetko m and gerli i 2011 development of some natural science competences in undergraduate study by training visualization skills on subject liquid crystal phases and structures _ mol .
cryst . _ * 547 * 24954 | the paper presents a teaching module about liquid crystals . since
liquid crystals are linked to everyday student experiences and are also a topic of a current scientific research , they are an excellent candidate of a modern topic to be introduced into education . we show that liquid crystals can provide a _
file rouge _ through several fields of physics such as thermodynamics , optics and electromagnetism .
we discuss what students should learn about liquid crystals and what physical concepts they should know before considering them . in the presentation of the teaching module that consists of a lecture and experimental work in a chemistry and physics lab , we focus on experiments on phase transitions , polarization of light , double refraction and colours .
a pilot evaluation of the module was performed among pre - service primary school teachers who have no special preference for natural sciences .
the evaluation shows that the module is very efficient in transferring knowledge .
a prior study showed that the informally obtained pre - knowledge on liquid crystals of the first year students on several different study fields is negligible . since the social science students are the ones that are the least interested in natural sciences it can be expected that students in any study programme will on average achieve at least as good conceptual understanding of phenomena related to liquid crystals as the group involved in the pilot study . |
following the main text , the evolution operator associated with the embedding hamiltonian @xmath90 can be implemented via 4 control-@xmath91 gates ( @xmath92 ) , and a single qubit rotation @xmath93 .
these gates act as @xmath94 with @xmath95 , and @xmath96 . the indices @xmath97 and @xmath98 indicate on which particle the operators act .
the circuit for the embedding quantum simulator consists of a sequence of gates applied in the following order : @xmath99 simple algebra shows that this expression can be recast as @xmath100 explicitly exhibiting the equivalence between the gate sequence and the evolution under the hamiltonian of interest .
the evolution of the reduced circuit is given by a @xmath93 rotation of qubit @xmath16 , followed by two consecutive control - z gates on qubits @xmath51 and @xmath12 , both controlled on qubit @xmath16 , see fig .
[ fig : sm1 ] ( a ) .
these logic operations are experimentally implemented by devices that change the polarization of the photons , where the qubits are encoded , with transformations as depicted in fig .
[ fig : sm1 ] ( b ) . for single qubit rotations , we make use of half - wave plates ( hwp s ) , which shift the linear polarization of photons . for the two - qubit gates , we make use of two kinds of partially - polarizing beam splitters ( ppbs s ) .
ppbs s of type @xmath51 have transmittances @xmath101 and @xmath102 for horizontal and vertical polarizations , respectively .
ppbs s of type @xmath12 , on the other hand , have transmittances @xmath103 and @xmath104 . their effect can be expressed in terms of polarization dependant input - output relations with the transmitted mode corresponding to the output mode of the bosonic creation operators as @xmath105 where @xmath106 ( @xmath107 ) stands for the @xmath97-th input ( output ) port of a ppbs with transmittance @xmath108 for @xmath109-polarized photons .
our circuit is implemented as follows : the first @xmath93 rotation is implemented via a hwp oriented at an angle @xmath110 with respect to its optical axis .
the rest of the target circuit , corresponding to the sequence of two control - z gates , can be expressed in terms of the transformation of the input to output creation operators as @xmath111 where @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 denote the creation operators acting on qubits @xmath16 , @xmath51 , and @xmath12 , respectively .
these polarization transformations can be implemented with a probability of @xmath115 via a @xmath22-fold coincidence detection in the circuit depicted in fig .
[ fig : sm1 ] ( b ) . in this dual - rail representation of the circuit , interactions of modes @xmath116 and
@xmath117 with vacuum modes are left implicit .
the @xmath118 and @xmath119 single qubit gates in fig .
[ fig : sm1 ] ( b ) are implemented by hwp s with angles @xmath120 and @xmath16 , respectively . in terms of bosonic operators ,
these gates imply the following transformations , @xmath121 according to all the input - output relations involved , it can be calculated that the optical elements in fig .
[ fig : sm1 ] ( b ) implement the following transformations @xmath122 if events with @xmath16 photons in some of the three output lines of the circuit are discarded .
thus , this linear optics implementation corresponds to the evolution of interest with success probability @xmath123 .
given the probabilistic nature and low efficiency of down - conversion processes , multi - photon experiments are importantly limited by low count - rates . in our case ,
typical two - photon rates from source are around @xmath124 khz at @xmath74 pump ( two - photon rates are approx . linear with pump power ) , which after setup transmission ( @xmath125 ) and @xmath126 success probability of one controlled - sign gate , are reduced to about @xmath127 khz ( @xmath51 khz ) at @xmath74 ( @xmath72 ) pump .
these count - rates make it possible to run the two - photon protocol , described in the main text , at low powers in a reasonable amount of time .
however , this situation is drastically different in the three - photon protocol , where we start with @xmath128 hz of @xmath39-fold events from the source , in which case after setup transmission , @xmath115 success probability of two gates , and @xmath129 transmission in each of two @xmath12 nm filters used for this case , we are left with as few as @xmath130 mhz ( @xmath131 mhz ) at @xmath74 ( @xmath72 ) pump ( @xmath39-fold events reduce quadratically with pump ) .
consequently , long integration times are needed to accumulate meaningful statistics , imposing a limit in the number of measured experimental settings .
to estimate the effect of power - dependent higher - order terms in the performance of our protocols , we inspect the pump power dependence of extracted concurrence from both methods .
[ fig : sm2 ] shows that the performances of both protocols decrease at roughly the same rate with increasing pump power , indicating that in both methods the extracted concurrence at @xmath72 pump is close to performance saturation .
the principal difference between the two methods is that in the three - qubit protocol one of the photons originates from an independent down - conversion event and as such will present a slightly different spectral shape due to a difficulty in optimizing the phase - matching condition for both forward and backward directions simultaneously . to reduce this spectral mismatch , we used two @xmath12 nm filters at the output of the two spatial modes where interference from independent events occurs , see fig .
[ fig : sm3 ] .
note that not identical spectra are observed .
this limitation would be avoided with a source that presented simultaneous high indistinguishability between all interfering photons . | measuring entanglement is a demanding task that usually requires full tomography of a quantum system , involving a number of observables that grows exponentially with the number of parties .
recently , it was suggested that adding a single ancillary qubit would allow for the efficient measurement of concurrence , and indeed any entanglement monotone associated to antilinear operations .
here , we report on the experimental implementation of such a device an embedding quantum simulator in photonics , encoding the entangling dynamics of a bipartite system into a tripartite one .
we show that bipartite concurrence can be efficiently extracted from the measurement of merely two observables , instead of fifteen , without full tomographic information .
entanglement is arguably the most striking feature of quantum mechanics @xcite , defining a threshold between the classical and quantum behavior of nature . yet
its experimental quantification in a given system remains challenging .
several measures of entanglement involve unphysical operations , such as antilinear operations , on the quantum state @xcite , and thus its direct measurement can not be implemented in the laboratory . as a consequence , in general , experimental measurements of entanglement have been carried out mostly via the full reconstruction of the quantum state @xcite . while this technique
called quantum state tomography ( qst)has been widely used when dealing with relatively low - dimensional systems @xcite , it is known to become rapidly intractable as the system size grows , being outside of experimental reach in systems with @xmath0 qubits @xcite .
this difficulty lies in having to measure an exponentially - growing number of observables , @xmath1 , to reconstruct @xmath2-qubits
. such constraint can be relaxed somewhat by using , for example , multiple copies of the same quantum state @xcite , prior state knowledge in noisy dynamics @xcite , compressed sensing methods @xcite , or measuring phases monotonically dependent on entanglement @xcite . however
, measuring entanglement in scalable systems remains a challenging task .
an efficient alternative is to embed the system dynamics into an enlarged hilbert - space simulator , called embedding quantum simulator ( eqs ) @xcite , where unphysical operations are mapped onto physical transformations on the simulator .
the price to pay , comparatively small in larger systems , is the addition of only one ancillary qubit and , usually , dealing with more involved dynamics .
however , measuring the entanglement of the simulated system becomes efficient , involving the measurement of a low number of observables in the eqs , in contrast to the @xmath1 needed with full tomography . in this letter
, we experimentally demonstrate an embedding quantum simulator , using it to efficiently measure two - qubit entanglement .
our eqs uses three polarization - encoded qubits in a circuit with two concatenated controlled - sign gates .
the measurement of only 2 observables on the resulting tripartite state gives rise to the efficient measurement of bipartite concurrence , which would otherwise need 15 observables .
+ _ protocol .
_ we consider the simulation of two - qubit entangling dynamics governed by the hamiltonian @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the z - pauli matrix written in the computational basis , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 is a constant with units of frequency . for simplicity ,
we let @xmath7 . under this hamiltonian ,
the concurrence @xcite of an evolving pure state @xmath8 is calculated as @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the complex conjugate operator defined as @xmath11 . and
@xmath12 evolve via an entangling hamiltonian @xmath13 during a time interval @xmath14 , at which point quantum state tomography ( qst ) is performed via the measurement of @xmath15 observables to extract the amount of evolving concurrence .
( b ) an efficient alternative corresponds to adding one extra ancilla , qubit @xmath16 , and having the enlarged system the embedding quantum simulator ( eqs)evolve via @xmath17 .
only two observables are now required to reproduce measurements of concurrence of the system under simulation.,width=283 ] notice here the explicit dependance of @xmath18 upon the unphysical transformation @xmath10 .
we now consider the dynamics of the initial state @xmath19 . under these conditions
one can calculate the resulting concurrence at any time @xmath14 as @xmath20 the target evolution , @xmath21 , can be embedded in a @xmath22-qubit simulator .
given the state of interest @xmath23 , the transformation @xmath24 gives rise to a real - valued @xmath22-qubit state @xmath25 in the corresponding embedding quantum simulator .
the decoding map is , accordingly , @xmath26 .
the physical unitary gate @xmath27 transforms the simulator state into @xmath28 , which after the decoding becomes @xmath29 .
therefore , the action of the complex conjugate operator @xmath10 corresponds to the single qubit rotation @xmath27 @xcite .
now , following the same encoding rules : @xmath30 , with @xmath31 an observable in the simulation . in the case of @xmath32
, we obtain @xmath33 which relates the simulated concurrence to the expectation values of two nonlocal operators in the embedding quantum simulator .
regarding the dynamics , it can be shown that the hamiltonian @xmath17 that governs the evolution in the simulator is @xmath34 @xcite . accordingly , in our case , it will be given by @xmath35 .
our initial state under simulation is @xmath19 , which requires , see eq .
( [ eq : tosim ] ) , the initialization of the simulator in @xmath36 . under these conditions , the relevant simulator observables ,
see eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) , read @xmath37 and @xmath38 , from which the concurrence of eq .
( [ eq : csim ] ) will be extracted .
therefore , our recipe , depicted in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , allows the encoding and efficient measurement of two - qubit concurrence dynamics . to construct the described three - qubit simulator dynamics ,
it can be shown ( see supplemental material ) that a quantum circuit consisting of @xmath39 controlled - sign gates and one local rotation @xmath40 , as depicted in fig .
[ fig:2](a ) , implements the evolution operator @xmath41 $ ] , reproducing the desired dynamics , with @xmath42 .
this quantum circuit can be further reduced if we consider only inputs with the ancillary qubit in state @xmath43 , in which case , only two controlled - sign gates reproduce the same evolution , see fig . [ fig:2 ] ( b ) .
this reduced subspace of initial states corresponds to simulated input states of only real components .
controlled - sign gates and one local rotation @xmath44 implement the evolution operator @xmath45 , with @xmath42 .
( b ) a reduced circuit employing only two controlled - sign gates reproduces the desired three - qubit dynamics for inputs with the ancillary qubit in @xmath46.,width=245 ] _ experimental implementation . _
we encode a three - qubit state in the polarization of 3 single - photons .
the logical basis is encoded according to @xmath47 , where @xmath48 and @xmath49 denote horizontal and vertical polarization , respectively .
the simulator is initialized in the state @xmath50 of qubits @xmath16 , @xmath51 and @xmath12 , and evolves via the optical circuit in fig .
[ fig:2 ] ( b ) .
figure [ fig:3 ] is the physical implementation of fig .
[ fig:2 ] ( b ) , where the dimensionless parameter @xmath52 is controlled by the angle @xmath53 of one half - wave plate . the two concatenated controlled - sign gates are implemented by probabilistic gates based on two - photon quantum interference @xcite , see supplemental material .
in order to reconstruct the two three - qubit observables in eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) , one needs to collect @xmath54 possible tripartite correlations of the observable eigenstates . for instance
, the observable @xmath55 is obtained from measuring the @xmath54 projection combinations of the @xmath56 states , where @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 and @xmath60 are their orthogonal states , respectively . to implement these polarization projections
, we employed glan - taylor prisms due to their high extinction ratio .
however , only their transmission mode is available , which required each of the @xmath54 different projection settings separately , extending our data - measuring time .
the latter can be avoided by simultaneously registering both outputs of a projective measurement , such as at the two output ports of a polarizing beam splitter , allowing the simultaneous recording of all @xmath54 possible projection settings .
thus , an immediate reconstruction of each observable is possible . our source of single - photons consists of four - photon events collected from the forward and backward pair emission in spontaneous parametric down - conversion in a _
beta_-barium borate ( bbo ) crystal pumped by a @xmath61 mhz frequency - doubled mode - locked femtosecond ti : sapphire laser .
one of the four photons is sent directly to an avalanche photodiode detector ( apd ) to act as a trigger , while the other @xmath22 photons are used in the protocol .
this kind of sources are known to suffer from undesired higher - order photon events that are ultimately responsible of a non - trivial gate performance degradation @xcite , although they can be reduced by decreasing the laser pump power .
however , given the probabilistic nature and low efficiency of down - conversion processes , multi - photon experiments are importantly limited by low count - rates , see supplemental material .
therefore , increasing the simulation performance quality by lowering the pump requires much longer integration times to accumulate meaningful statistics , which ultimately limits the number of measured experimental settings . as a result of these higher - order noise terms ,
a simple model can be considered to account for non - perfect input states .
the experimental input @xmath62-qubit state @xmath63 can be regarded as consisting of the ideal state @xmath64 with certain probability @xmath65 , and a white - noise contribution with probability @xmath66 , i.e. @xmath67 .
since the simulated concurrence is expressed in terms of tensorial products of pauli matrices , the experimentally simulated concurrence becomes @xmath68 . in fig .
[ fig:4 ] , we show our main experimental results from our photonic embedding quantum simulator for one cycle of concurrence evolution taken at different pump powers : @xmath69 mw , @xmath70 mw , and @xmath71 mw referred as to @xmath72 , @xmath73 , and @xmath74 pump , respectively .
figure [ fig:4 ] ( a ) shows theoretical predictions ( for ideal pure - state inputs ) and measured fractions of the different projections involved in reconstructing @xmath55 and @xmath75 for @xmath72 pump at @xmath76 . from measuring these two observables , see eq .
( [ eq : c ] ) , we construct the simulated concurrence produced by our eqs , shown in fig .
[ fig:4 ] ( b ) .
we observe a good behavior of the simulated concurrence , which preserves the theoretically predicted sinusoidal form .
the overall attenuation of the curve is in agreement with the proposed model of imperfect initial states .
together with the unwanted higher - order terms , we attribute the observed degradation to remaining spectral mismatch between photons created by independent down - conversion events and injected to inputs @xmath16 and @xmath12 of fig .
[ fig:3]at which outputs @xmath12 nm band - pass filters with similar but not identical spectra were used .
we compare our measurement of concurrence via our simulator with an explicit measurement from state tomography .
in the latter we inject one down - converted pair into modes @xmath16 and @xmath51 of fig .
[ fig:3 ] . for any value of @xmath14 , set by the wave - plate angle @xmath77 , this evolving state has the same amount of concurrence as the one from our simulation , they are equivalent in the sense that one is related to the other at most by local unitaries , which could be seen as incorporated in either the state preparation or within the tomography settings .
figure [ fig:5 ] shows our experimental results for the described two - photon protocol .
we extracted the concurrence of the evolving two - qubit state from overcomplete measurements in quantum state tomography @xcite .
( blue ) , @xmath73 ( green ) , and @xmath74 ( red ) pump powers .
the corresponding curves indicate @xmath78 , with @xmath79 the maximum extracted concurrence for a given pump power ( pp ) : @xmath80 , @xmath81 , and @xmath82 .
errors are estimated from monte - carlo simulations of poissonian counting fluctuations . ] a maximum concurrence value of @xmath83 is predicted in the ideal case of perfect pure - state inputs .
experimentally , we measured maximum values of concurrence of @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 , for the three different pump powers , respectively . for the purpose of comparing this two - photon protocol with our embedding quantum simulator ,
only results for the above mentioned powers are shown .
however , we performed an additional two - photon protocol run at an even lower pump power of @xmath84 mw ( @xmath85 pump ) , and extracted a maximum concurrence of @xmath86 . a clear and pronounced decline on the extracted concurrence at higher powers is also observed in this protocol .
however , a condition closer to the ideal one is reached .
this observed pump power behavior and the high amount of measured concurrence suggest a high - quality gate performance , and that higher - order terms larger for higher pump powers are indeed the main cause of performance degradation .
while only mixed states are always involved in experiments , different degrees of mixtures are present in the @xmath22- and @xmath12-qubit protocols , resulting in different extracted concurrence from both methods .
an inspection of the pump - dependence , see supplemental material , reveals that both methods decrease similarly with pump power and are close to performance saturation at the @xmath72 pump level .
this indicates that in the limit of low higher - order emission our @xmath22-qubit simulator is bounded to the observed performance .
temporal overlap between the @xmath22 photons was carefully matched .
therefore , we attribute the remaining discrepancy to spectral mismatch between photons originated from independent down - conversion events .
this disagreement can in principle be reduced via error correction @xcite and entanglement purification @xcite schemes with linear optics .
_ discussion .
_ we have shown experimentally that entanglement measurements in a quantum system can be efficiently done in a higher - dimensional embedding quantum simulator .
the manipulation of larger hilbert spaces for simplifying the processing of quantum information has been previously considered @xcite . however , in the present scenario , this advantage in computing concurrence originates from higher - order quantum correlations , as it is the case of the appearance of tripartite entanglement @xcite . the efficient behavior of embedding quantum simulators resides in reducing an exponentially - growing number of observables to only a handful of them for the extraction of entanglement monotones .
we note that in this non - scalable photonic platform the addition of one ancillary qubit and one entangling gate results in count rates orders of magnitude lower as compared to direct state tomography on the @xmath12-qubit dynamics .
this means that in practice absolute integration times favor the direct @xmath12-qubit implementation
. however , this introduced limitation escapes from the purposes of the embedding protocol and instead belongs to the specific technology employed in its current state - of - the - art performance .
this work represents the first proof - of - principle experiment showing the efficient behavior of embedding quantum simulators for the processing of quantum information and extraction of entanglement monotones .
this validates an architecture - independent paradigm that , when implemented in a scalable platform , e.g. ions @xcite , would overcome a major obstacle in the characterization of large quantum systems .
the relevance of these techniques will thus become patent as quantum simulators grow in size and currently standard approaches like full tomography become utterly unfeasible .
we believe that these results pave the way to the efficient measurement of entanglement in any quantum platform via embedding quantum simulators .
we thank m. a. broome for helpful discussions .
this work was supported by the centre for engineered quantum systems ( grant no .
ce110001013 ) and the centre for quantum computation and communication technology ( grant no .
ce110001027 ) .
m. p.
a. acknowledges support from the australian research council discovery early career awards ( no .
de120101899 ) .
a. g. w. was supported by the university of queensland vice - chancellor s senior research fellowship .
j. c. acknowledge support from the alexander von humboldt foundation , while r. d. c. , j. s. p. , and e. s. from basque government it472 - 10 ; spanish mineco fis2012 - 36673-c03 - 02 ; upv / ehu ufi 11/55 ; upv / ehu phd fellowship ; promisce and scaleqit eu projects .
+ + _ note added._we recently learned of a related paper by chen et al @xcite .
10 r. horodecki , p. horodecki , m. horodecki , and k. horodecki , rev .
mod .
phys . * 81 * , 865 ( 2009 ) .
w. k. wootters , phys .
rev .
lett . * 80 * , 2245 ( 1998 ) .
a. osterloh & j. siewert , phys .
rev .
a * 72 * , 012337 ( 2005 ) .
d. f. v. james , p. g. kwiat , w. j. munro , and a. g. white , phys .
rev .
a * 64 * , 052312 ( 2001 ) .
h. h@xmath87ffner , w. h@xmath87nsel , c. f. roos , j. benhelm , d. chek - al - kar , m. chwalla , t. k@xmath88rber , u. d. rapol , m. riebe , p. o. schmidt , c. becher , o. g@xmath89hne , w. d@xmath89r , and r. blatt , nature * 438 * , 643 ( 2005 ) .
x .- c .
yao , t .- x .
wang , p. xu , l. he , g .- s .
pan , x .- h .
bao , c .- z .
peng , c .- y .
lu , y .- a .
chen and j .- w .
pan , nat .
photon * 6 * , 225 ( 2012 ) .
t. monz , p. schindler , j. t. barreiro , m. chwalla , d. nigg , w. a. coish , m. harlander , w. hansel , m. hennrich , and r. blatt , phys .
rev .
lett . * 106 * , 130506 ( 2011 ) .
s. p. walborn , p. h. souto ribeiro , l. davidovich , f. mintert , and a. buchleitner , nature * 440 * , 1022 ( 2006 )
. o. jimnez faras , c. lombard latune , s. p. walborn , l. davidovich , and p. h. souto ribeiro , science * 324 * , 1414 ( 2009 ) .
d. gross , y .- k .
liu , s. t. flammia , s. becker , and j. eisert , phys .
rev .
lett . * 105 * , 150401 ( 2010 ) .
j. c. loredo , m. a. broome , d. h. smith , and a. g. white , phys .
rev .
lett . * 112 * , 143603 ( 2014 ) .
r. di candia , b. mejia , h. castillo , j. s. pedernales , j. casanova , and e. solano , phys .
rev .
lett . * 111 * , 240502 ( 2013 ) .
j. s. pedernales , r. di candia , p. schindler , t. monz , m. hennrich , j. casanova , and e. solano , phys .
rev .
a * 90 * , 012327 ( 2014 ) .
j. casanova , c. sabn , j. len , i. l. egusquiza , r. gerritsma , c. f. roos , j. j. garca - ripoll , and e. solano , phys .
rev .
x * 1 * , 021018 ( 2011 ) . t. c. ralph , a. g. white , w. j. munro , and g. j. milburn , phys .
rev .
a * 65 * , 012314 ( 2001 ) .
j. l. obrien , g. j. pryde , a. g. white , t. c. ralph , and d. branning , nature * 426 * , 264 ( 2003 ) .
t. c. ralph , phys .
rev .
a * 70 * , 012312 ( 2004 ) .
t. j. weinhold , a. gilchrist , k. j. resch , a. c. doherty , j. l. obrien , g. j. pryde , and a. g. white , arxiv:0808.0794 ( 2008 ) .
m. barbieri , t. weinhold , b. lanyon , a. gilchrist , k. resch , m. almeida , and a. white , journal of modern optics * 56 * , 209 ( 2009 ) .
j .- w .
pan , z .- b .
chen , c .- y .
lu , h. weinfurter , a. zeilinger , and m. zukowski , rev .
mod .
phys . * 84 * , 777 ( 2012 ) .
j. l. obrien , g. j. pryde , a. g. white , and t. c. ralph , phys .
rev .
a * 71 * , 060303 ( 2005 ) .
x .- c .
yao , t .- x .
wang , h .- z .
chen , w .- b .
gao , a. g. fowler , r. raussendorf , z .- b .
chen , n .- l .
liu , c .- y .
lu , y .-
j .
deng , y .- a .
chen , and j .- w .
pan , nature * 482 * , 489 ( 2012 ) .
j .- w .
pan , s. gasparoni , r. ursin , g. weihs , and a. zeilinger , nature * 423 * , 417 ( 2003 ) .
b. p. lanyon , m. barbieri , m. p. almeida , t. jennewein , t. c. ralph , k. j. resch , g. j. pryde , j. l. obrien , a. gilchrist , and a. g. white , nat phys * 5 * , 134 ( 2009 ) .
c .- y .
lu , d. e. browne , t. yang , and j .- w .
pan , phys .
rev .
lett . * 99 * , 250504 ( 2007 ) .
b. p. lanyon , t. j. weinhold , n. k. langford , m. barbieri , d. f. v. james , a. gilchrist , and a. g. white , phys .
rev .
lett . * 99 * , 250505 ( 2007 ) .
m-.c .
chen , d. wu , z .- e .
su , x .- d .
cai , x .-
l .
wang , t. yang , l. li , n .- l .
liu , ch .- y .
lu , and j .- w .
pan , phys .
rev .
lett . * 116 * , 070502 ( 2016 ) . |
symbiotic systems ( ss ) are generally composed by a white dwarf ( wd ) , a red giant ( rg ) star , and by circumstellar and circumbinary nebulae .
gas and dust radiation from the nebulae appear throughout a large frequency range , from radio to x - rays .
z andromedae ( z and ) binary system consists of a cool giant of spectral type m4.5 and a hot compact component with a temperature of @xmath0 1.5 10@xmath1 k. many periods of activity have been reported during more than 100 years , in 1915 , 1939 , 1960 , 1984 , and 2000 as nonuniform eruptions of classical outbursts .
sokolowski et al . (
2006 ) claim that the _ outbursts sometimes come in pairs ( as in 1984 and 1986 ) _ , or in a series of eruptions with decreasing maximum brightness and different shapes , separated in time by periods slightly shorter than the orbital one ( kenyon & webbink 1984 ) .
the main characteristics of the 1984 - 1986 event are the two maxima which appear in the profile of the visual magnitude ( fernndez - castro et al .
1995 , hereafter fc95 , fig .
1 ) leading to the ambiguous interpretation of the outburst as a double or a disturbed single one .
fc95 suggested , on the basis of the line ratio analysis , that a drop in the wd radiation flux could provoke the observed trend of the light curve in 1986 .
they claim that a shell of material was ejected during each of the _ two outbursts _ at 1984 and 1986 .
the brightness of the 1984 - 1986 event was exceptionally low ( leibowitz & formiggini 2008 , fig .
nevertheless , it was monitored at very close dates by the spectral observations of fc95 .
the spectra are rich enough in number of lines to allow a detailed modeling of z and physical conditions . in this paper
we revisit z and system focusing on the physical conditions in the nebulae and their fluctuations in the 1984 - 1986 years .
our aim is to reveal unpredicted episodes by the detailed modeling of the spectra . in z and ,
the stellar wind of the cool giant has a velocity of @xmath0 25 ( sequist et al .
bisikalo et al ( 2006 ) claim that varying the wind velocity from 25 to 30 changes the accretion regime from disk to wind accretion .
this is accompanied by a jump in the accretion rate , increasing the hydrogen burning rate .
an optical thick wind forms from the wd . this wind is revealed e.g. by the observations of uv and optical spectra during the 2000 - 2002 outburst ( e.g. sokoloski et al 2006 , tomov et al 2008 ) .
the shocks which derive from wd and rg wind collision yield an increase in the luminosity of the system .
this hypothesis is strengthened by fc95 who did not find evidence for an accretion disk at the 1984 - 1986 epoch but suggested collision episodes .
collision of the winds ( girard & willson 1987 , bisikalo et al 2006 , angeloni et al 2010 , contini & angeloni 2011 ) leads to two shock fronts between the stars : the strong one , dominating the spectrum , propagates in reverse towards the wd , while the weakest one propagates towards the rg .
moreover , a shock front expands out of the system throughout the circumbinary medium .
we calculate the line spectra in sect . 2 in the frame of the wind collision model , adopting the code sumamarcel / suma / index.htm ] , which accounts consistently for shocks and photoionization .
the input parameters are : the shock velocity , the preshock density 0 , the preshock magnetic field 0 , the colour temperature of the hot star , the ionization parameter @xmath2 relative to the black body ( bb ) flux reaching the nebula .
the geometrical thickness of the emitting nebula @xmath3 , the dust - to - gas ratio @xmath4 , and the abundances of he , c , n , o , ne , mg , si , s , a , fe relative to h are also accounted for . 0=10@xmath5 gauss is adopted .
the observations at different epochs of the continuum spectral energy distribution ( sed ) are reproduced in sect . 3 by models constrained by the fit of the line ratios .
the adjustment factors determine the distance of the nebulae downstream of shock fronts from the system center , providing a detailed picture of the z and components .
discussion and concluding remarks follow in sect .
the trend of the spectral observations between 1978 and 1993 ( fc95 , figs .
4,5 ) gives a first hint about the 1984 - 1986 outburst in the frame of a longer activity period .
we notice that : \1 ) the 1984 - 1986 outburst lies upon an event which developed about at 1979 and ended at 1988 .
if this long event depends on the wd activity , then the temperature of the wd will not show dramatic changes in the 1984 - 1986 period .
\2 ) the oi 1305 resonance line is most probably blended with an upper ionization level line because its behaviour is similar to that of high level lines the oi line is most probably emitted from a different nebula with conditions close to those of the ism .
\3 ) the systematic decrease and increase of the cii 1336 line , whose trend is opposite to that of the high ionization lines , indicates that the cii minimum is strongly correlated with the trend of the physical parameters , e.g. the ionization parameter , and the shock velocity .
the role of the wd temperature is less prominent .
fc95 in their table 3 report an optical spectrum in july 1986 , observed at the same epoch as the uv spectrum presented in their table 2b , row 34 .
we start by modeling the uv - optical combined spectrum observed at 11 july 1986 which is constrained by a relatively large number of lines from various ionization levels .
this reveals the physical conditions in the emitting nebulae at that time .
such conditions will be adopted as a first guess in the modeling of the uv spectra in the next epochs . [
cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] @xmath6 2440000 + 3 ) : red ; ( in units of 10@xmath1 k ) : blue ; @xmath2 : green .
dotted black lines define the outburst.,scaledwidth=98.0% ] 3 ) : red ; ( in units of 10@xmath1 k ) : blue ; @xmath2 : green .
dotted black lines define the outburst.,scaledwidth=88.0% ] the visual light curve ( fig .
1 ) covers a frequency band accounting for lines and continuum in the optical range .
the strongest lines are generally heii 4686 , , [ oiii]5007 , 4959 , etc . , while the optical spectrum ( fc95 ) shows relatively low forbidden lines .
so we consider that the main contributors to the visual band are heii 4686 and , which depend strongly on the wd temperature and on the ionization parameter . and
@xmath2 affect the spectra in the same way .
namely , when they decrease , the high level lines decrease relatively to the low level ones .
the increase of at the epochs of the peaks and the decrease at minima would indicate that the active phase is characterised by two different bursts . on the other hand , if does not change significantly and only @xmath2 changes , a disturbing dynamical and/or morphological event between the radiation source and the nebula is most likely the source of the visual curve minimum .
the uv band accounts for lines from different levels which are variously modified by and @xmath2 fluctuation .
moreover , the shock velocity and the compression downstream affect the stratification of the ions and , consequently , the line ratios .
fc95 show that lines from different ionization levels have different trends throughout the 1984 - 1986 time period .
we predict that the uv light curve throughout the outburst , would have a profile different from that reported in fig
. 1 . in fig .
2 we present the physical parameters obtained by modeling the spectra throughout the 1984 - 1986 outburst .
the profiles of the physical conditions are rather unexpected if compared with the visual light curve ( fig .
the sudden increase of the density on april 1984 , accompanied by the sudden increase of the velocity , indicates that collision of the wd wind with a shell ejected from the red giant is occurring .
the nebula downstream of the reverse shock is heated and ionized by both the shock and the photoionization flux from the hot star . in the next days
the density and the shock velocity have opposite trends in agreement with conservation of mass at the shock front ( n1v1=n0v0 , from the rankine - hugoniot equations ) . in the meanwhile the temperature of the hot star is slightly increasing from @xmath0 120,000 k to a maximum of 170,000 k , corresponding to the outburst maximum , in agreement with fc95 .
the drop of @xmath2 on 1984 toward july 1986 shows that the spectra during that epoch are dominated by a relatively strong shock , i.e. the reverse shock , which vanishes at a certain time , depending on the outburst characteristics ( chevalier 1982 ) .
the second density peak at december 1985-january 1986 reveals that collision of the wd wind with another rg shell has occurred .
the ionization parameter drop by more than two orders of magnitude after june 1985 , accompanied by the simultaneous variation of the dynamical parameters and 0 , suggests that the shock front has suddenly shifted farther from the wd .
the matter downstream of the reverse shock front is fragmented by richtmyer - meshkov and kelvin - helmholtz instabilities .
high density fragments between the stars eventually prevent the black body flux from reaching the nebula .
however , the decline of the bb flux by fragment obstruction could indeed reduce the ionization parameter , but less sharply than predicted by the calculations .
so , the whole picture is most likely explained by an unexpected disturbing episode such as the ejection of a new shell from the rg atmosphere and its collision with the wd wind at a relatively large distance from the wd ( sect .
the gas composition at the epochs of collision with the shells reveals that the calculated siiii]/niv ] line ratios would better reproduce the data adopting si / h relative abundances lower than solar by a factor of 4 for models m@xmath7 , m@xmath8 and of @xmath0 10 for models m@xmath9 , m@xmath10 , m@xmath11 , m@xmath12 .
this indicates that silicate grains are present after collision of the wd wind with the first rg shell . on the other hand si
is in the gaseous phase with a solar si / h relative abundance at the epochs corresponding to models m@xmath13 , m@xmath14 , m@xmath15 , m@xmath16 .
the grains had not enough time to form at collision with the next shell .
grain formation time scales ( gail et al 1984 , scalo & slavsky 1980 ) are as long as @xmath0 1 year . however , in circumstellar shells the chemical equilibrium and consequently grain formation is disturbed by the uv radiation from the wd and by the velocity field ( gail et al .
3 we compare the observed continuum sed with model calculations .
we refer to the sed of the continuum flux presented by fc95 in their fig .
we have used the data in the uv and in the radio range presented by fc95 tables 2a and 4 , respectively .
the dates corresponding to observations in the radio and those in the other frequency ranges are not exactly coincident , e.g. we adapted the radio fluxes observed in october 1986 to data observed in july 1986 .
each diagram of fig .
3 presents the free - free + free - bound fluxes emitted from the nebula at a certain epoch .
they are calculated by the same models ( table 2 ) which lead to the best fit of the line spectrum ( table 3 ) . moreover ,
the bb flux from the rg corresponding to a temperature of 3200 k ( fc95 ) , and the bb flux corresponding to the wd which was derived by modeling the line spectrum are also shown .
reprocessed radiation of dust within the nebula calculated consistently with gas emission is added in fig .
3 diagrams .
this flux is mostly hidden by the bb flux from the rg if dust - to - gas ratios of 10@xmath17 by number ( 4 10@xmath18 by mass for silicates ) are adopted .
actually , the dust - to - gas ratios are constrained by the data in the mid - ir .
3 shows that the emission from the nebula appears in a small frequency range between the optical and the near - uv ( @xmath0 1 - 3 10@xmath19 hz ) , depending on the epoch .
there are no data in the soft x - ray range and beyond it .
we can predict that bremsstrahlung from the nebula downstream of shock fronts with @xmath20 160 would be the x - ray source . for lower velocities
the sed in the soft x - ray range is the summed flux of bremsstrahlung from the nebulae and bb flux from the wd .
the contribution to soft - x - rays up to the x - ray domain of bremsstrahlung from shocked nebulae was suggested for the symbiotic system ag dra by contini & angeloni ( 2011 ) .
the fit of calculated to observed data is good enough to confirm a strong self - absorption of free - free radiation from the nebulae for frequencies @xmath2110@xmath22 hz .
finally , fig .
3 diagrams show that the bb flux from the rg and from the nebula dominate the sed in the visual , while the flux from the wd appear in the uv and soft x - ray range .
this indicates that strong variations in the wd temperature that generally accompany the outbursts can not be directly revealed by the visual light curve presented by fc95 , but only indirectly by the spectra emitted from the nebula . in previous works on ss ,
e.g. ch cyg ( contini et al 2009b ) , ag dra ( contini & angeloni 2011 ) , etc .
we calculated the distance r of the nebulae from the center of the ss adjusting the continuum fluxes calculated by the models at the nebula to those observed at earth .
we defined the adjusting factor @xmath23 by r@xmath24=10@xmath25 d@xmath24 , where is the filling factor and d the distance to earth . adopting a distance of z and to earth of 1.12 kpc ( viotti 1982 ) ,
the best fit to the data of the bremsstrahlung calculated from the nebulae downstream of the shock front , gives r= 1.9 10@xmath26 cm at april 1981 , r=1.4 10@xmath26 cm at april 1984 , r=9.4 10@xmath19 cm at december 1985 , and r= 2.7 10@xmath26 cm at july 1986 .
the distances were calculated by a filling factor = 1 .
considering that : @xmath27 ( r@xmath28/r)@xmath24 = @xmath2 n c ( where @xmath27 is the flux from the wd , r@xmath28 is the radius of the wd , n is the density of the gas and c the speed of light ) , the results suggest that the drop of the ionization parameter @xmath2 between november and december 1985 most probably derives from the sudden increase of the distance from the hot source .
this is explained by the ejection of the next shell in the rg atmosphere .
the collision between the wind from the wd and the two shells from the rg occurred within less that 2 years , from march 1984 to november 1985 .
the shock front has therefore expanded from @xmath0 2 10@xmath26 to @xmath09 10@xmath19 cm , by an average velocity of @xmath0 130 , in rough agreement with the observations .
the 1984 - 1986 outburst of z and is revisited by a detailed modeling of the spectra . comparing the visual light curve of z and during the 1984 - 1986 outburst with those in other epochs from 1895 up to 2007 september , the 1984 - 1986 event is remarkable for its double peaked structure and for its low brightness .
we explain the burst double structure in the light of red giant pulsation , by the collision of the wd wind with two ejected shells .
the minimum of the light curve between the two peaks is accompanied by the dip of the ionization parameter which is constrained by the detailed modeling the uv line spectra at november - december 1985 .
the sharp drop of @xmath2 is due to the sudden increase of the distance between the wd and the downstream nebula reached by the wd black body flux , namely , the collision of the wd wind with a new shell in the rg atmosphere .
since the shell was recently formed at the time of observations , the grains did not have enough time to develop .
this is revealed by the solar relative abundance of si / h .
we suggest that the outburst did not attain its maximum luminosity because the collision of the wind network was distorted by the oncoming of the next shell .
the small peaks in the light curve before and after the 1984 - 1986 burst are most probably due to rg shell ejections .
the periodicity of the maxima is in fact of @xmath0 300 - 400 days . during the 2000 - 2002 outburst of z and , broad wings ( up to 2000 ) developed in the line profile ( tomov et al 2008 ) .
moreover , collimated bipolar jets appeared and disappeared throughout the 2006 outburst ( skopal et al 2009 ) .
broad lines were observed in other ss , e.g. ch cyg , bi cru , ag dra , etc .
they originate from the high velocity matter accompanying the outbursts .
exceptionally broad and line profiles were explained by wd explosion ( contini et al .
2009 a , c ) , while collimated jets at some epochs reveal the presence of the accretion disk . both broad lines and jets
were not observed during the 1984 - 1986 outburst of z and .
we are grateful to sharon sadeh for helpful advise .
angeloni , r. , contini , m. , ciroi , s. , rafanelli , p. 2007 , a&a , 471 , 825 angeloni , r. , contini , m. , ciroi , s. , rafanelli , p. 2010 , mnras , 402 , 207 bisikalo , d.v . ,
boyarchuk , a.a . ,
kilpio , e. yu , tomov , n.a . ,
tomova , m.t .
2006 , astron .
, 50 , 722 chevalier , r.a . , 1982 , apj , 259 , l85 contini , m. 2003 , mnras , 339 , 125 contini , m. , angeloni , r. , 2011 new astr . , 16 , 199 contini , m. , angeloni , r. , rafanelli , p. 2009a
, a&a , 496 , 759 contini , m. , angeloni , r. , rafanelli , p. 2009b , an , 330 , 816 contini , m. , angeloni , r. , rafanelli , p. 2009c
, mnras , 396 , 807 fernndez - castro , t . , gonzlez - riestra , r. , cassatella , a. , taylor , a.r . , seaquist , e.r
. apj , 1995 , 442 , 366 gail , h .-
p . ; keller , r. ; sedlmayr , e. 1984 , a&a , 133 , 320 gail , h .-
p . , gauger , a. ; goeres , a. ; henkel , r. ; sedlmayr , e. 1987 , mitag , 70 , 365 girard , t. , willson , l.a . , 1987 , a&a , 183,247 kenyon , s.j . , webbink , r.f .
1984 , apj , 279 , 252 leibowitz , e. m. ; formiggini , l. 2008 mnras .
385 , 445 nussbaumer , h. , schild , h. , schmid , h.m . ,
vogel , m. 1988 , a&a , 198 , 179 osterbrock , d.e .
1988 in astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei , university science books scalo , j.m . ,
slavsky , d.b .
1980 , apj , 239 , l73 saquist , e.r . ,
taylor , a.r . , button , s. 1984 , apj , 284 , 202 skopal , a. et al .
2009 , apj , 690 , 1222 sokoloski , j.l .
2006 apj , 636 , 1002 tomov , n.a . ,
tomova , m.t . ,
bisikalo , d.v .
2008 mnras , 389 , 829 viotti , r. , giangrande , a. , ricciardi , o. , cassatella , a. 1982 in the nature of symbiotic stars , ed .
m. friedjung and r. viotti ( dordrecht : reidel ) , 125 | the visual magnitude profile of the symbiotic system z and during the 1984 - 1986 activity period appears double peaked and the flux intensity is low compared to outbursts in other epochs .
the detailed modeling of the observed spectra , accounting for the shells ejected by the red giant star , shows that the outburst is intrinsically single but distorted by the collision at different phases of the white dwarf wind with two close shells .
binaries : symbiotic - stars : individual : z and |
ultraluminous infrared galaxies ( uligs ) are the most luminous objects in the local universe ( their bolometric luminosities @xmath3 ) .
the uligs are undergoing major dissipative collapses , which are probably triggered by mergers ( clements et al .
1996 ; murphy et al . 1996 ) .
whether the uligs are powered by starbursts or active galactic nuclei ( agn ) has remained unknown since their discovery because of huge amounts of internal extinction along our lines of sight to their centres ( for a review see sanders & mirabel 1996 ) .
however , recent mid - infrared spectroscopic work ( genzel et al . 1998 ) suggests that the major energy sources of most local uligs are nuclear starbursts .
this provides an important motivation for studying the star formation in the centres of uligs in detail .
the nearest and best - studied ulig is the star - forming ( genzel et al .
1998 ) galaxy arp 220 ( far - infrared luminosity @xmath4 ) at a distance of 74 mpc ( assuming @xmath5 = 75 km s@xmath6 mpc@xmath6 and @xmath7 ; de vaucouleurs et al .
detailed imaging of the centre of arp 220 with the _ hubble space telescope _ has revealed a number of super star clusters ( sscs ; shaya et al .
1994 , scoville et al .
these nuclear sscs appear to be a generic feature of luminous merging galaxies ( lutz 1991 ; ashman & zepf 1992 ; holtzman et al .
1992 ; zepf & ashman 1993 ; surace et al . 1998 ; surace & sanders 1999 ) .
surace et al . (
1998 ) and surace & sanders ( 1999 ) evaluated the luminosities of sscs in warm uligs and concluded that the combined contributions of the all the individual detected circumnuclear sscs to the bolometric luminosities are small .
they also showed that for some warm uligs the de - reddened luminosities of putative nuclei are not able to account for the bolometric luminosity and that a large fraction of the bolometric luminosity must arise from sources undetected at both optical and near - infrared wavelengths . in this paper , we compare the observed optical and near - infrared spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of the arp 220 sscs with the starburst99 model seds of leitherer et al .
( 1999 ) and estimate their ages , masses , and luminosities , along with the internal extinction along our lines of sight to them .
this is the first attempt to analyse by sed fitting methods the properties of sscs in the centre of arp 220 , which is colder ( sanders et al .
1988 ) than the uligs studied by surace et al .
these results will let us evaluate how much of the very substantial amount of star formation currently happening in arp 220 is in the sscs , at least in the ones which are not completely invisible at optical and near - infrared wavelengths due to internal extinction .
recently , soifer et al . ( 1999 ) presented the images of arp 220 from 3.45 to 24.5 @xmath8 m . since genzel et al .
( 1998 ) derived the value of @xmath9 mag based on the mid - infrared hydrogen recombination lines ( br@xmath10 @xmath11 2.17 @xmath8 m , br@xmath12 @xmath11 4.05@xmath8 m and pf@xmath12 @xmath11 7.46 @xmath8 m ) , the mid - infrared sources observed by soifer et al .
( 1999 ) must be highly obscured objects .
this suggests that what surace et al .
( 1998 ) found to be true in the warm uligs , specifically that the contribution of the observed clusters to the bolometric luminosity is small , is also true in arp 220 .
we now investigate this in detail by studying the energy outputs of the sscs themselves .
the _ hubble space telescope _ images of the core of arp 220 show eleven sscs at optical ( @xmath13- , @xmath14- , and @xmath15-band ) wavelengths ( shaya et al .
1994 ) and twelve sscs at near - infrared ( @xmath16- , @xmath17- , and @xmath18-band ) wavelengths ( scoville et al .
1998 ) . in this paper
, we call the f110w filter ( 1.1 @xmath8 m ) as @xmath16 filter , though the standard @xmath16 filter is at 1.25@xmath8 m .
we combine these datasets in order to obtain a set of sscs that are detected at all wavelengths .
this allows us to sample the seds over as wide a range in wavelength as possible .
three sscs are located in the outer regions of the core we expect dust extinction to be smallest here , so that these sscs should be seen at all wavelengths . given the published coordinates , there is a slight offset between the near - infrared and optical positions of these sscs ( see the left panel of figure 1 ) . however , if we rotate the near - infrared images by @xmath19 around the nuclear ssc associated with the western nucleus , the positions of the star clusters in the two images are almost coincident ( see the right panel of figure 1 ) .
given the probable low extinction along these lines of sight , we regard this astrometrical solution as likely to be the correct one . in addition , given this astrometry , we then find that three nuclear sscs ( hereafter n1 , n2 , and n3 ) are coincident in the optical and near - infrared images , in addition to the three circumnuclear ones ( hereafter c1 , c2 , and c3 ) . in figure 2 , we show the observed seds of the six sscs .
we use the photometric data published by shaya et al .
( 1994 ; @xmath20 bands ) and by scoville et al .
( 1998 ; @xmath21 bands ) for ssc n2 n3 and c1 c3 . in the case of ssc n1
, we have used @xmath22 archival data to measure the optical fluxes using the same 0.92 arcsec @xmath23 0.58 arcsec aperture used by scoville et al .
( 1998 ) for the near - infrared measurements ( shaya et al . used a smaller aperture in their analysis ) .
the magnitudes of ssc n1 are 21.96 mag and 19.36 for @xmath14-band ( f702w ) and @xmath15-band ( f785lp ) respectively .
this ssc was not detected in the @xmath13-band ( f555w ) .
all three nuclear sscs show a peak at 1.6 @xmath8 m , whereas all three circumnuclear sscs have seds that rise towards bluer wavelengths .
this is a very important difference and is immediately suggestive of far more dust extinction along the lines of sight to the nuclear sscs than along the lines of sight to the circumnuclear ones .
we now compare the seds with the starburst99 spectral synthesis models of leitherer et al .
one of the advantages of the starburst99 is that it tell us the evolution of the strength of co index which is useful to constrain the range of ages .
when fitting model seds to observed ones in the presence of internal extinction , there are several parameters that we need to consider : 1 ) the mode of star formation .
for example , the star formation may occur continuously ( the constant star formation , or csf model ) , may occur in a short , almost instantaneous , burst ( the instantaneous starburst , or isb model ) , or may occur in a way that varies with time in a complex manner .
for the blue circumnuclear sscs , there is no evidence that star formation has been ongoing in these isolated clusters for any considerable time , and we adopt an isb model for describing star formation in these systems . on the other hand , the nuclear star - forming regions of arp 220 are probably at least 10@xmath24 years old ( mouri & taniguchi 1992 ; prestwich , joseph , & wright 1994 ; armus et al .
1995 ; larkin et al .
yet there still appear to be ionizing sources in the nuclear region ( larkin et al .
1995 , kim et al .
1995 , and goldader et al . 1995 ) .
therefore an isb model will not work here , and we approximate star formation in the nuclear sscs by a csf model . on the other hand , there is a possibility that the nuclear sscs are not the ongoing starburst discussed in the above papers but post - starburst and we also consider an isb model for the nuclear sscs , although we regard the csf one as the more likely ; 2 ) the stellar imf .
we adopt a salpeter imf with an upper mass cutoff of @xmath25 and a lower mass cutoff of @xmath26 .
we note that @xmath27 might be larger in a violent star - forming region ( see e.g. goldader et al .
1997 ) and investigate the effect of the imf on our results in the next section ; 3 ) the initial gas metallicity .
we assume solar metallicity ( @xmath28 ) .
since the metallicity of galactic centre may be larger than the solar value , we also study the case of @xmath29 ( see the next section ) ; 4 ) the age at which we observe the star clusters .
we leave this as a free parameter in the range of @xmath30 yr to @xmath31 yr ; 5 ) the effect of extinction .
the total extinction can be regarded as the sum of two parts : 1 ) extinction from dust in arp 220 along our line of sight to the sscs , and 2 ) extinction from dust _ within _ the sscs .
the relative importance of these two regimes can be tested as follows .
a screen model may be used to describe extinction along our line of sight to the sscs , and the onion - skin " model of surace and sanders ( 1999 ) may be used to quantify the extinction from dust within the sscs .
this comparison is made in appendix a , where we show that ( 1 ) is the more important regime .
we consequently adopt a screen model and leave the absolute value @xmath32 of the extinction in the @xmath13-band as a free parameter to be fit to the data , but impose the constraint that the extinction must vary with wavelength according to the extinction curve of cardelli et al .
( 1989 ) ; 6 ) nebular emission .
starburst99 includes the nebular continuum emission which is proportional to the flux of ionizing photons .
if all of the lyman continuum photons are used to ionize the surrounding gas , the equivalent width of h@xmath12 can reach 1000 and the @xmath14-band flux becomes twice as large as that from the continuum .
however , the _ measured _ equivalent width of the h@xmath12 emission line in arp 220 is only 20 30 (armus et al .
1989 , veilleux et al .
if the equivalent width of h@xmath12 emission of each ssc is the same as the total ones , the contribution of emission lines to the broadband photometry is then negligibly small .
we neglect it here ; 7 ) dust emission .
hot dust emission was required to interpret a @xmath18-band flux excess in previous studies ( surace & sanders 1999 for warm uligs ; mazzarella et al .
1992 for the nuclei of arp 220 ) . however , there is little @xmath18-band flux excess for our sample .
we ignore the hot dust emission in our models .
using maximum likelihood techniques , we determine the best - fitting model seds to the observed ones for the six sscs . the likelihood is defined as @xmath33 ^ 2 \right\}\ ] ] where @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 are the observed flux , the template flux , and the uncertainty of the observed flux of @xmath37-th band .
the uncertainty of the photometry we adopted is @xmath38 mag for shaya et al .
( 1994 ) and @xmath39 mag for scoville et al .
a scale factor @xmath40 is obtained as @xmath41 from the condition of @xmath42 .
the results are summarized in table 1 and the seds of best - fitting models are presented in figure 2 .
figure 3 is a summary of the region of plausible parameters in the @xmath32 - age plane for the nuclear sscs .
the results for the csf model are shown in figure 3 ( a ) - ( c ) and those for the isb model are shown in figure 3 ( d ) - ( f ) . the hatched region is the region of plausible parameters at the 99 % confidence level .
we immediately see that the extinction @xmath32 along our lines of sight to the nuclear sscs is very large ( @xmath43 mag ) .
these values are slightly larger than those evaluated by shaya et al .
( 1994 ) while slightly smaller than those of scoville et al .
these differences can be attributed to the extinction curves adopted in the analyses [ shaya et al .
use the extinction curve of savage & mathis ( 1979 ) , while scoville et al .
use that of rieke & lebofsky ( 1985 ) ] . on the other hand , it is difficult to determine the age of sscs , due to strong parameter coupling with the extinction .
a small change in @xmath32 mimics a substantial change in age in the sense that both shift the sed towards redder wavelengths .
we explain the rough shapes of the relevant parameter space as follows
. if the stellar populations are very young ( age @xmath44 yr ) , @xmath32 must be very large , since the intrinsic slope of the continuum is very blue and a great deal of extinction is required to make it as red as is observed . for stellar populations older than several @xmath45 yr , the allowed values of @xmath32 do not vary strongly with age since the slope of continuum does not vary with the age of the stars . at the age of @xmath46 yr in the isb model , the plausible value of @xmath32 becomes small temporarily due to the presence of a large number of red supergiants at exactly this age . therefore , we can not determine the ages of the nuclear sscs this way .
we must use additional measurements .
for n1 , there exists an independent constraint on the mass of the ssc from radio and millimetre observations .
the mass of n1 as determined by the sed fit represents a locus of points in the @xmath32-age plane , and is shown in figure 3 ( the dashed line ) .
the position of n1 corresponds to the western nucleus observed to exhibit radio continuum , 1.3 mm dust continuum and the co ( 1 - 0 ) and ( 2 - 1 ) lines ( scoville et al .
1997 ; downes & solomon 1998 ; sakamoto et al . 1999 ) .
millimetre spectroscopy ( of co lines ) can be used to determine both a dynamical mass ( from the line widths ) and a molecular gas mass ( from the line luminosities ) . from the results of downes & solomon ( 1998 ) and
sakamoto et al . ( 1999 ) , we estimate a dynamical mass of this nucleus of @xmath47 and a gas mass of @xmath48 [ adopting the inclination parameter of scoville et al .
( 1998 ) ] .
the mass of the stellar component must be less than the difference between these two masses , which is @xmath48 .
if there are other ( highly obscured ) stellar components present within the region , this number is an upper limit ; if all the mass of n1 is in gas and observed stars , then this is an equality .
the dashed lines in figure 3 ( a ) and ( d ) show the locus of sscs with the mass of @xmath49 .
the region of plausible parameters is now restricted to that to the left of the lines .
the upper limits on the age of n1 are now @xmath50 yr for the csf model and @xmath51 yr for the isb model .
the reason why we can set an upper limit of age is that the luminosity - to - mass ratio of the stellar cluster becomes smaller as it gets older and consequently a more massive cluster is required to radiate the observed flux .
the dynamical masses of n2 and n3 have not been measured .
although the eastern nucleus of arp 220 has been detected in co , the position of it corresponds to neither n2 nor n3 .
instead it is an entirely different object ( hereafter we call it as n4 ) , coincident with the nuclear source se in the near - infrared images of scoville et al .
based on the fact that n1 and n4 only exhibit non - thermal radio continuum , thermal dust continuum , and molecular gas , scoville et al .
( 1998 ) suggested that these two objects represent the most substantial mass concentrations in the centre of arp 220 .
we now consider yet another way to constrain the range of ages of the nuclear sscs .
the strength of co absorption index at 2.29 @xmath8 m constrains the ages since it is sensitive primarily to the presence of red k supergiants , which are stars with a narrow age distribution , particularly in the isb models .
the co index of the centre of arp 220 is known to be strong : @xmath52 mag ( goldader et al .
1995 ) , @xmath53 mag ( shier et al .
1996 ) , and @xmath54 mag [ armus et al .
( 1995 ) for the central @xmath55 arcsec@xmath56 .
although the co indices of each ssc are not individually observed , if we assume that all three nuclear sscs have a co index larger than 0.20 mag , then we get following additional constraint on the ages : @xmath57 for the isb model , or @xmath58 for the csf model . in the case of the isb model ,
the co index is 0 mag until the age of @xmath59 yr and become strong rapidly at later times , reaching 0.2 mag at the age of @xmath60 yr , which corresponds to the main - sequence lifetime of the stars with mass of 25 @xmath61 , the main progenitors of the k supergiants .
after that , the co index decreases gradually and becomes smaller than 0.2 mag at @xmath62 yr .
in the case of the csf model , since newly formed red supergiants keep the co index strong , the co index continues to be larger than 0.2 mag for a longer time than for the isb model .
the strength of the co index is modified slightly by dust as follows .
since the continuum level is determined on the blue side of co band , dust extinction has the effect of causing us to underestimate the continuum and therefore to underestimate the co index . ignoring dust emission at 2.3 microns
has the same effect since the sed of the dust component is rising towards longer wavelengths .
if the intrinsic value of co index is larger than we think , then the upper limit of the age of sscs become smaller . ignoring the effects of dust
therefore does not invalidate the upper limits we present .
rieke et al .
( 1985 ) reported that the equivalent width of h@xmath10 absorption within the central 2.5 arcsec of arp 220 is 4 .
this value of the balmer absorption is incompatible with such a strong co index for single stellar cluster .
probably this discrepancy arises because the balmer feature originates from old foreground ( possibly progenitor galaxy ) stars that happen to lie at low optical depth and are quite unrelated to the sscs .
the flux of the nuclear region of arp 220 at very blue wavelengths is therefore likely to be dominated by foreground stars at low skin - depth .
recall that the nuclear sscs were not observed in the @xmath13-band so the extinction at these short wavelengths is probably quite high .
we can now estimate the maximum bolometric luminosity emitted from the nuclear star clusters from the above results .
for the isb model , the maximum bolometric luminosities of n1 , n2 , n3 are @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
the sum of these luminosities is @xmath66 which is about one - tenth of the bolometric luminosity of arp 220 ( @xmath67 , sanders et al .
1988 ) . for the csf model , the maximum bolometric luminosities of n1 , n2 , n3 are @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
the sum of these is @xmath71 which is about one - fifth of the bolometric luminosity of arp 220 .
we can therefore state with some confidence that if most of the total bolometric luminosity of arp 220 arises from the nucleus , more than four - fifths of it arises from highly obscured starbursts ( or possibly an agn ) .
the results depend on the imf as follows
. a steeper imf decreases the implied ages of the star clusters .
for example , imf with ( @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 ) decreases the maximum ages derived from the stellar mass ( @xmath75 ) to @xmath76 yr for the csf model or @xmath77 yr for the isb model . on the other hand , a truncated imf increases the ages .
for example , an imf with ( @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath74 ) increases the upper limits on the ages to @xmath80 yr for the csf model and @xmath81 yr for the isb model .
the evolution of co index also depends on the imf , since the number of red supergiants per unit total stellar mass at any time is a function of the imf .
if we adopt the steeper imf as above , the range of ages when the co index is larger than 0.2 mag is @xmath82 for the csf model or @xmath83 for isb model . for the truncated imf , it is @xmath84 for the csf model or @xmath57 for the isb model .
the bolometric luminosity emitted from the nuclear star clusters also depends on the imf , since we have imposed a constraint on the mass .
the bolometric luminosity ranges between @xmath71 ( csf model with standard imf ) and @xmath85 ( isb model with steeper imf ) ; the basic conclusions are unchanged .
the metallicities of many luminous elliptical galaxies ( the probable fate of ultraluminous galaxies like arp 220 ) are often considerably higher than solar ( faber 1973 ) .
it is therefore important to investigate how the results change if the metallicity is increased to twice solar ( section 3.1 , p.10 ) , comparable to the values in the most luminous ellipticals ( faber 1973 ) . for the sed fitting , the larger
metallicity causes only a very small change , but the length of time when the co index is strong is considerably longer .
the range of ages when the co index is larger than 0.2 mag is @xmath86 for the csf model or @xmath87 for the isb model .
the maximum bolometric luminosities are @xmath88 for csf model and @xmath63 for isb model ; the basic conclusions are also unchanged .
it is also useful to estimate how much of the difference between the total bolometric luminosities and the luminosities of the observed sscs can be made up if one includes the contribution from n4 , the se nucleus seen in the near - infrared but not the optical images . from sed fitting , we derive a value of @xmath89 mag ( figure 4 ) , much smaller than the value of @xmath90 mag evaluated by scoville et al .
this discrepancy comes from the fact that we use all three of the @xmath16- , @xmath17- , and @xmath18- band fluxes for sed fitting , whereas scoville et al .
use only the @xmath91 colour .
if , as for n1 , we assume that the maximal mass of n4 is the dynamical mass minus the gas mass , and assume that the strength of the co index is greater than 0.2 mag , we derive a maximum intrinsic luminosity of n4 of @xmath92 for isb model or @xmath93 for csf model .
adding these values to the summation of the bolometric luminosities of n1 - n3 , we derive a maximum bolometric luminosity emitted from the nuclear sscs of @xmath94 for the isb model and @xmath95 for the csf model .
these values are still much smaller than the total bolometric luminosity of arp 220 .
again , this result is essentially not affected by the imf or metallicity .
therefore the conclusion that most of the bolometric luminosity we see originating from the nucleus of arp 220 comes from heavily obscured star formation seems unavoidable . at optical and near - infrared wavelengths
we see only a small fraction ( less than one - fifth ) of it .
the fact that the total luminosity of observed sources can not account for the bolometric luminosity is similar to those derived for the putative nuclei of warm uligs ( surace & sanders 1999 ) .
figures 3 ( g ) - ( i ) summarize the allowed regions on the @xmath32 - age plane for the circumnuclear sscs .
the data require total extinctions of @xmath96 mag , far less than for the nuclear sscs .
because of this low extinction , the cluster ages , masses , and luminosities are much better constrained by the sed fits than for the nuclear clusters .
we find that the upper limits on the ages of the sscs are @xmath97 yr , @xmath98 yr , and @xmath99 yr for c1 , c2 and c3 .
these results are very different from those of scoville et al .
( 1998 ) , who suggests that they may be as old as ( @xmath100 years ) the central globular clusters of ngc 5128 ( frogel 1984 ) , because of the similarity of near - infrared colours .
we attribute this slight redness of the star clusters to a little amount of dust rather than to a very large age .
we also mention that since the near - infrared colours of star clusters mainly depend on the colours of red supergiants and red giants , the evolution of near - infrared colours is small for the age larger than @xmath46 yr . on the other hand , the optical colours , which mainly determined by the colours of the upper main sequence stars , evolve gradually from blue to red for the hubble time .
it is therefore useful to use the optical colours to determine the age of sscs .
we summarize the best - fitting parameters for the circumnuclear sscs in table 1 .
the masses of the sscs are about @xmath101 , similar to the masses of galactic globular clusters .
maybe these are the globular clusters hypothesized to form during mergers by zepf & ashman ( 1993 ) , who note that elliptical galaxies ( thought to be merger remnants ) have higher specific globular cluster frequencies than spiral galaxies ( thought to be merger progenitors ) , and that the metallicity distributions of the globular clusters in the ellipticals are bimodal .
the luminosities of the sscs are about @xmath102 .
therefore c1 - 3 contribute negligibly to the total bolometric luminosity of arp 220 .
this result is unchanged if we consider the other circumnuclear sscs which are detected only at near - infrared wavelengths .
we would like to thank bob joseph for his useful comments and suggestions on an earlier version of our manuscript .
ys thanks the japan society for promotion of science ( jsps ) research fellowships for young scientist .
nt thanks the pparc for financial support .
this work was financially supported in part by grant - in - aids for the scientific research ( nos . 07044054 , 10044052 , and 10304013 ) of the japanese ministry of education , science , sports and culture .
armus l. , heckman t. m. , miley g. k. 1989 , apj , 347 , 727 armus l. , neugebauer g. , soifer b. t. , matthews k. 1995 , aj , 110 , 2610 ashman k. m. , zepf s. e. 1992 , apj , 384 , 50 baan w. a. , haschick a. d. 1995 , apj , 454 , 745 cardelli j. a. , clayton g. c. , mathis j. s. 1989 , apj , 345 , 245 clements d. l. , sutherland w. j. , mcmahon r. g. , & saunders w. 1996 , mnras , 279 , 477 de vaucouleurs g. , de vaucouleurs a. , corwin h. g. , jr . , buta r. j. , paturel g. , forqu p. 1991
, third reference catalogue of bright galaxies ( springer - verlag ) downes d. , solomon p. m. 1998 , apj , 507 , 615 faber s. m. 1973 , apj , 179 , 731 genzel r. et al .
1998 , apj , 498 , 579 goldader j. d. , joseph r. d. , doyon r. , sanders , d. b. 1995 , apj , 444 , 97 goldader j. d. , joseph r. d. , doyon r. , sanders d. b. 1997 , apjs , 108 , 449 holtzman j. a. , et al .
1992 , aj , 103 , 691 kim d .- c . , sanders d. b. , veilleux s. , mazzarella j. m. , soifer b. t. 1995 , apjs , 98 , 171 larkin j. e. , armus l. , knop k. , matthews k. , soifer , b. t. 1995 , apj , 452 , 599 leitherer c. et al . 1999 ,
apjs , 123 , 3 lutz d. 1991 , a & a , 245 , 31 mouri h. , taniguchi y. 1992 , apj , 386 , 68 murphy t. w. , armus l. , matthews k. , soifer b. t. , mazzarella j. m. 1996 , aj , 111 , 1025 prestwich a. h. , joseph r. d. , wright g. s. 1994 , apj , 422 , 73 rieke g. h. , cutri r. m. , black j. h. , kailey w. f. , mcalary c. w. , lebofsky m. j. , elston r. 1985 , apj , 290 , 116 rieke g. h. , lebofsky m. j. 1985 , apj , 288 , 618 sakamoto k .. scoville n. z. , yun m. s. , crosas m. , genzel r. , tacconi l. j. 1999 , apj , 514 , 77 sanders d. b. , mirabel i. f. 1996 , ara & a , 34 , 749 sanders d. b. , soifer b. t. , elias j. h. , madore b. f. , matthews k. , neugebauer g. , scoville n. z. 1988 , apj , 325 , 74 savage b. d. , mathis j. s. 1979 , ara&a , 17 , 73 scoville n. z. et al .
1998 , apj , 492 , l107 scoville n. z. , sargent a. i. , sanders d. b. , soifer b. t. 1991 , apj , 366 , l5 scoville n. z. , yun m. s. , bryant p. m. 1997 , apj , 484 , 702 shaya e. , dowling d. m. , currie d. g. , faber s. m. , groth e. j. 1994 , aj , 107 , 1675 soifer b. t. , neugebauer g. , matthews k. , becklin e. e. , ressler m. , werner m. w. , weinberger a. j. , egami e. 1999 , apj , 513 , 207 surace j. a. , sanders d. b. 1999 , apj , 512 , 162 surace j. a. , sanders d. b. , vacca w. d. , veilleux s. , mazzarella j. m. 1998 , apj , 492 , 116 zepf s. e. , ashman k. m. 1993 , mnras , 264 , 611 | we investigate the photometric properties of six super stellar clusters ( sscs ) seen in both the optical and near - infrared hubble space telescope images of the local ultraluminous starburst galaxy arp 220 .
three of the sscs are located in the central 0.5 kpc region .
the remaining three are in the circumnuclear region between 0.5 kpc and 2.5 kpc from the centre . comparing the observed spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of the sscs with the starburst99 models of leitherer et al .
, we confirm that all the three nuclear sscs are heavily obscured ( @xmath0 mag ) .
considering the results from this comparison in conjunction with measurements of the near - infrared co absorption index and of millimetre co line widths and luminosities , we estimate the ages of the nuclear sscs to be @xmath1 yrs .
the bolometric luminosity of the three nuclear sscs is at most one - fifth of the total bolometric luminosity of arp 220 . on the other hand ,
the circumnuclear sscs have little internal extinction ( @xmath2 1 mag ) .
these contribute negligibly to the total bolometric luminosity .
galaxies : individual ( arp 220 ) galaxies : starburst stars : formation |
in recent years , the theoretical and experimental use of quantum systems to store , transmit and process information has spurred the study of how much of classical information theory can be extended to the new territory of quantum information and , vice versa , how much novel strategies and concepts are needed that have no classical counterpart .
we shall compare the relations between the rate at which entropy is produced by classical , respectively quantum , ergodic sources , and the complexity of the emitted strings of bits , respectively qubits . according to kolmogorov @xcite
, the complexity of a bit string is the minimal length of a program for a turing machine ( _ tm _ ) that produces the string .
more in detail , the algorithmic complexity @xmath0 of a string @xmath1 is the length ( counted in the number of bits ) of the shortest program @xmath2 that fed into a universal _ tm _ ( _ utm _ ) @xmath3 yields the string as output , i.e. @xmath4 . for infinite sequences @xmath5 , in analogy with the entropy rate , one defines the _ complexity rate _ as @xmath6 , where @xmath1 is the string consisting of the first @xmath7 bits of @xmath5 , @xcite .
the universality of @xmath3 implies that changing the _ utm _ , the difference in the complexity of a given string is bounded by a constant independent of the string ; it follows that the complexity rate @xmath8 is _ utm_-independent .
different ways to quantify the complexity of qubit strings have been put forward ; in this paper , we shall be concerned with some which directly generalize the classical definition by relating the complexity of qubit strings with their algorithmic description by means of quantum turing machines ( _ qtm _ ) . for classical ergodic sources , an important theorem , proved by brudno @xcite and conjectured before by zvonkin and levin @xcite ,
establishes that the entropy rate equals the algorithmic complexity per symbol of almost all emitted bit strings .
we shall show that this essentially also holds in quantum information theory .
for stationary classical information sources , the most important parameter is the _ entropy rate _ @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the shannon entropy of the ensembles of strings of length @xmath7 that are emitted according to the probability distribution @xmath11 . according to the shannon - mcmillan - breiman theorem @xcite
, @xmath12 represents the optimal compression rate at which the information provided by classical ergodic sources can be compressed and then retrieved with negligible probability of error ( in the limit of longer and longer strings ) .
essentially , @xmath13 is the number of bits that are needed for reliable compression of bit strings of length @xmath7 .
intuitively , the less amount of patterns the emitted strings contain , the harder will be their compression , which is based on the presence of regularities and on the elimination of redundancies . from this point of view , the entropy rate measures the randomness of a classical source by means of its compressibility on the average , but does not address the randomness of single strings in the first instance .
this latter problem was approached by kolmogorov @xcite , ( and independently and almost at the same time by chaitin @xcite , and solomonoff @xcite ) , in terms of the difficulty of their description by means of algorithms executed by universal turing machines ( _ utm _ ) , see also @xcite . on the whole ,
structureless strings offer no catch for writing down short programs that fed into a computer produce the given strings as outputs .
the intuitive notion of random strings is thus mathematically characterized by kolmogorov by the fact that , for large @xmath7 , the shortest programs that reproduce them can not do better than literal transcription @xcite . intuitively , one expects a connection between the randomness of single strings and the average randomness of ensembles of strings . in the classical case , this is exactly the content of a theorem of brudno @xcite which states that for ergodic sources , the complexity rate of @xmath14-almost all infinite sequences @xmath5 coincides with the entropy rate , i.e. @xmath15 . quantum sources can be thought as black boxes emitting strings of qubits .
the ensembles of emitted strings of length @xmath7 are described by a density operator @xmath16 on the hilbert spaces @xmath17 , which replaces the probability distribution @xmath11 from the classical case .
the simplest quantum sources are of bernoulli type : they amount to infinite quantum spin chains described by shift - invariant states characterized by local density matrices @xmath16 over @xmath7 sites with a tensor product structure @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is a density operator on @xmath20 .
however , typical ergodic states of quantum spin - chains have richer structures that could be used as quantum sources : the local states @xmath16 , not anymore tensor products , would describe emitted @xmath21qubit strings which are correlated density matrices .
similarly to classical information sources , quantum stationary sources ( shift - invariant chains ) are characterized by their entropy rate @xmath22 , where @xmath23 denotes the von neumann entropy of the density matrix @xmath16 .
the quantum extension of the shannon - mcmillan theorem was first obtained in @xcite for bernoulli sources , then a partial assertion was obtained for the restricted class of completely ergodic sources in @xcite , and finally in @xcite , a complete quantum extension was shown for general ergodic sources .
the latter result is based on the construction of subspaces of dimension close to @xmath24 , being typical for the source , in the sense that for sufficiently large block length @xmath7 , their corresponding orthogonal projectors have an expectation value arbitrarily close to @xmath25 with respect to the state of the quantum source .
these typical subspaces have subsequently been used to construct compression protocols @xcite .
the concept of a universal quantum turing machine ( _ uqtm _ ) as a precise mathematical model for quantum computation was first proposed by deutsch @xcite .
the detailed construction of _ uqtms _ can be found in @xcite : these machines work analogously to classical _ tm_s , that is they consist of a read / write head , a set of internal control states and input / output tapes .
however , the local transition functions among the machine s configurations ( the programs or quantum algorithms ) are given in terms of probability amplitudes , implying the possibility of linear superpositions of the machine s configurations . the quantum algorithms work reversibly .
they correspond to unitary actions of the _ uqtm _ as a whole .
an element of irreversibility appears only when the output tape information is extracted by tracing away the other degrees of freedom of the _
uqtm_. this provides linear superpositions as well as mixtures of the output tape configurations consisting of the local states @xmath26 and blanks @xmath27 , which are elements of the so - called _
computational basis_. the reversibility of the _ uqtm _
s time evolution is to be contrasted with recent models of quantum computation that are based on measurements on large entangled states , that is on irreversible processes , subsequently performed in accordance to the outcomes of the previous ones @xcite . in this paper
we shall be concerned with bernstein - vazirani - type _ uqtms _ whose inputs and outputs may be bit or qubit strings @xcite .
given the theoretical possibility of universal computing machines working in agreement with the quantum rules , it was a natural step to extend the problem of algorithmic descriptions as a complexity measure to the quantum case .
contrary to the classical case , where different formulations are equivalent , several inequivalent possibilities are available in the quantum setting . in the following
, we shall use the definitions in @xcite which , roughly speaking , say that the algorithmic complexity of a qubit string @xmath19 is the logarithm in base @xmath28 of the dimension of the smallest hilbert space ( spanned by computational basis vectors ) containing a quantum state that , once fed into a _ uqtm _ , makes the _ uqtm _ compute the output @xmath19 and halt . in general , quantum states
can not be perfectly distinguished .
thus , it makes sense to allow some tolerance in the accuracy of the machine s output . as explained below , there are two natural ways to deal with this , leading to two ( closely related ) different complexity notions @xmath29 and @xmath30 , which correspond to asymptotically vanishing , respectively small but fixed tolerance . both quantum algorithmic complexities @xmath29 and @xmath30 are thus measured in terms of the length of _ quantum _ descriptions of qubit strings , in contrast to another definition @xcite which defines the complexity of a qubit string as the length of its shortest _ classical _ description .
a third definition @xcite is instead based on an extension of the classical notion of universal probability to that of universal density matrices .
the study of the relations among these proposals is still in a very preliminary stage . for an approach to quantum complexity based on the amount of resources ( quantum gates ) needed to implement a quantum circuit reproducing a given qubit string
see @xcite .
the main result of this work is the proof of a weaker form of brudno s theorem , connecting the quantum entropy rate @xmath31 and the quantum algorithmic complexities @xmath29 and @xmath30 of pure states emitted by quantum ergodic sources .
it will be proved that there are sequences of typical subspaces of @xmath17 , such that the complexity rates @xmath32 and @xmath33 of any of their pure - state projectors @xmath34 can be made as close to the entropy rate @xmath31 as one wants by choosing @xmath7 large enough , and there are no such sequences with a smaller expected complexity rate .
the paper is divided as follows . in section 2 , a short review of the @xmath35-algebraic approach to quantum sources
is given , while section 3 states as our main result a quantum version of brudno s theorem . in section 4 ,
a detailed survey of _ qtm_s and of the notion of _ quantum kolmogorov complexity _ is presented . in section 5 ,
based on a quantum counting argument , a lower bound is given for the quantum kolmogorov complexity per qubit , while an upper bound is obtained in section 5 by explicit construction of a short quantum algorithm able to reproduce any pure state projector @xmath34 belonging to a particular sequence of high probability subspaces .
in order to formulate our main result rigorously , we start with a brief introduction to the relevant concepts of the formalism of quasi - local @xmath35-algebras which is the most suited one for dealing with quantum spin chains . at the same time
, we shall fix the notations .
we shall consider the lattice @xmath36 and assign to each site @xmath37 a @xmath35-algebra @xmath38 being a copy of a fixed finite - dimensional algebra @xmath39 , in the sense that there exists a @xmath40-isomorphism @xmath41 . to simplify notations ,
we write @xmath42 for @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
the algebra of observables associated to a finite @xmath45 is defined by @xmath46 .
observe that for @xmath47 we have @xmath48 and there is a canonical embedding of @xmath49 into @xmath50 given by @xmath51 , where @xmath52 and @xmath53 denotes the identity of @xmath54 .
the infinite - dimensional quasi - local @xmath35-algebra @xmath55 is the norm completion of the normed algebra @xmath56 , where the union is taken over all finite subsets @xmath57 . in the present paper
, we mainly deal with qubits , which are the quantum counterpart of classical bits .
thus , in the following , we restrict our considerations to the case where @xmath39 is the algebra of observables of a qubit , i.e. the algebra @xmath58 of @xmath59 matrices acting on @xmath60 . since every finite - dimensional unital @xmath35-algebra @xmath39 is @xmath40-isomorphic to a subalgebra of @xmath61 for some @xmath62 ,
our results contain the general case of arbitrary @xmath39 .
moreover , the case of classical bits is covered by @xmath39 being the subalgebra of @xmath58 consisting of diagonal matrices only .
similarly , we think of @xmath49 as the algebra of observables of qubit strings of length @xmath63 , namely the algebra @xmath64 of @xmath65 matrices acting on the hilbert space @xmath66
. the quasi - local algebra @xmath55 corresponds to the doubly - infinite qubit strings .
the ( right ) shift @xmath67 is a @xmath40-automorphism on @xmath68 uniquely defined by its action on local observables @xmath69}\mapsto a\in\mathcal{a}_{[m+1,n+1]}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 \subset \mathbb{z}$ ] is an integer interval .
a state @xmath71 on @xmath55 is a normalized positive linear functional on @xmath68 .
each local state @xmath72 , @xmath73 finite , corresponds to a density operator @xmath74 by the relation @xmath75 , for all @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the trace on @xmath78 .
the density operator @xmath79 is a positive matrix acting on the hilbert space @xmath80 associated with @xmath81 satisfying the normalization condition @xmath82 .
the simplest @xmath79 correspond to one - dimensional projectors @xmath83 onto vectors @xmath84 and are called pure states , while general density operators are linear convex combinations of one - dimensional projectors : @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 .
we denote by @xmath88 the convex set of density operators acting on a ( possibly infinite - dimensional ) hilbert space @xmath89 , whence @xmath90 .
a state @xmath91 on @xmath55 corresponds one - to - one to a family of density operators @xmath74 , @xmath92 finite , fulfilling the consistency condition @xmath93 for @xmath94 , where @xmath95 denotes the partial trace over the local algebra @xmath49 which is computed with respect to any orthonormal basis in the associated hilbert space @xmath80 .
notice that a state @xmath71 with @xmath96 , i.e. a shift - invariant state , is uniquely determined by a consistent sequence of density operators @xmath97 in @xmath98 corresponding to the local states @xmath99 , where @xmath100 denotes the integer interval @xmath101\subset \mathbb{z}$ ] , for each @xmath102 .
as motivated in the introduction , in the information - theoretical context , we interpret the tuple @xmath103 describing the quantum spin chain as a stationary quantum source .
the von neumann entropy of a density matrix @xmath19 is @xmath104 . by the subadditivity of @xmath105 for a shift - invariant state @xmath71 on @xmath55 , the following limit , the quantum entropy rate , exists @xmath106 the set of shift - invariant states on @xmath55 is convex and compact in the weak@xmath40-topology .
the extremal points of this set are called ergodic states : they are those states which can not be decomposed into linear convex combinations of other shift - invariant states . notice that in particular the shift - invariant product states defined by a sequence of density matrices @xmath107 , @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is a fixed @xmath110 density matrix , are ergodic .
they are the quantum counterparts of bernoulli ( i.i.d . )
most of the results in quantum information theory concern such sources , but , as mentioned in the introduction , more general ergodic quantum sources allowing correlations can be considered . more concretely , the typical quantum source that has first been considered was a finite - dimensional quantum system emitting vector states @xmath111 with probabilities @xmath112 .
the state of such a source is the density matrix @xmath113 being an element of the full matrix algebra @xmath114 ; furthermore , the most natural source of qubit strings of length @xmath7 is the one that emits vectors @xmath115 independently one after the other at each stroke of time . is a vector in a hilbert space and a ket @xmath116 is its dual vector . ]
the corresponding state after @xmath7 emissions is thus the tensor product @xmath117 in the following , we shall deal with the more general case of _ ergodic _ sources defined above , which naturally appear e.g. in statistical mechanics ( compare 1d spin chains with finite - range interaction ) . when restricted to act only on @xmath7 successive chain sites , namely on the local algebra @xmath118
, these states correspond to density matrices @xmath16 acting on @xmath17 which are not simply tensor products , but may contain classical correlations and entanglement .
the qubit strings of length @xmath7 emitted by these sources are generic density matrices @xmath119 acting on @xmath17 , which are compatible with the state of the source @xmath71 in the sense that @xmath120 , where @xmath121 denotes the support projector of the operator @xmath119 , that is the orthogonal projection onto the subspace where @xmath119 can not vanish .
more concretely , @xmath16 can be decomposed in uncountably many different ways into convex decompositions @xmath122 in terms of other density matrices @xmath123 on the local algebra @xmath124 each one of which describes a possible qubit string of length @xmath7 emitted by the source .
it turns out that the rates of the complexities @xmath29 ( approximation - scheme complexity ) and @xmath30 ( finite - accuracy complexity ) of the typical pure states of qubit strings generated by an ergodic quantum source @xmath125 are asymptotically equal to the entropy rate @xmath126 of the source .
a precise formulation of this result is the content of the following theorem .
it can be seen as a quantum extension of brudno s theorem as a convergence in probability statement , while the original formulation of brudno s result is an almost sure statement .
we remark that a proper introduction to the concept of quantum kolmogorov complexity needs some further considerations .
we postpone this task to the next section .
+ in the remainder of this paper , we call a sequence of projectors @xmath127 , @xmath108 , satisfying @xmath128 a _ sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors_. [ theqbrudno ] ' '' '' let @xmath129 be an ergodic quantum source with entropy rate @xmath31 . for every @xmath130 , there exists a sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath131 , @xmath108 , i.e. @xmath132 , such that for @xmath7 large enough every one - dimensional projector @xmath133 satisfies @xmath134 moreover , @xmath31 is the optimal expected asymptotic complexity rate , in the sense that every sequence of projectors @xmath135 , @xmath108 , that for large @xmath7 may be represented as a sum of mutually orthogonal one - dimensional projectors that all violate the lower bounds in ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) for some @xmath130 , has an asymptotically vanishing expectation value with respect to @xmath71 .
algorithmic complexity measures the degree of randomness of a single object .
it is defined as the minimal description length of the object , relative to a certain machine
( classically a _ utm _ ) . in order to properly introduce a quantum counterpart of kolmogorov complexity
, we thus have to specify what kind of objects we want to describe ( outputs ) , what the descriptions ( inputs ) are made of , and what kind of machines run the algorithms . in accordance to the introduction , we stipulate that inputs and outputs are so - called ( pure or mixed ) _ variable - length qubit strings _ , while the reference machines will be _ qtm_s as defined by bernstein and vazirani @xcite , in particular universal _ qtm_s . let @xmath136 be the hilbert space of @xmath137 qubits ( @xmath138 ) .
we write @xmath139 for @xmath20 to indicate that we fix two orthonormal _ computational basis vectors _ @xmath140 and @xmath141 .
since we want to allow superpositions of different lengths @xmath137 , we consider the hilbert space @xmath142 defined as @xmath143 the classical finite binary strings @xmath144 are identified with the computational basis vectors in @xmath145 , i.e. @xmath146 , where @xmath147 denotes the empty string .
we also use the notation @xmath148 and treat it as a subspace of @xmath145 . a ( variable - length ) _ qubit string _
@xmath149 is a density operator on @xmath145 .
we define the _ length _ @xmath150 of a qubit string @xmath149 as @xmath151 or as @xmath152 if this set is empty ( this will never occur in the following ) .
there are two reasons for considering variable - length and also mixed qubit strings .
first , we want our result to be as general as possible .
second , a _ qtm _ will naturally produce superpositions of qubit strings of different lengths ; mixed outputs appear naturally while tracing out the other parts of the _ qtm _ ( input tape , control , head ) after halting .
in contrast to the classical situation , there are uncountably many qubit strings that can not be perfectly distinguished by means of any quantum measurement .
if @xmath153 are two qubit strings with finite length , then we can quantify their distance in terms of the trace distance @xmath154 where the @xmath155 are the eigenvalues of the hermitian operator @xmath156 . in subsection [ subqac ]
, we will define quantum kolmogorov complexity @xmath157 for qubit strings @xmath19 . due to the considerations above
, it can not be expected that the qubit strings @xmath19 are reproduced exactly , but it rather makes sense to demand the strings to be generated within some trace distance @xmath158 .
another possibility is to consider approximation schemes ,
i.e. to have some parameter @xmath159 , and to demand the machine to approximate the desired state better and better the larger @xmath137 gets
. we will pursue both approaches , corresponding to equations ( [ berthdelta ] ) and ( [ berth ] ) below .
note that we can identify every density operator @xmath160 on the local @xmath7-block algebra with its corresponding qubit string @xmath161 such that @xmath162 .
similarly , we identify qubit strings @xmath149 of finite length @xmath163 with the state of the input or output tape of a _ qtm _ ( see subsection [ basicdefqtmsec ] ) containing the state in the cell interval @xmath164 $ ] and vice versa . due to the equivalence of various models for quantum computation
, the definition of quantum kolmogorov complexity should be rather insensitive to the details of the underlying machine . nevertheless , there are some details which are relevant for our theorem .
thus , we have to give a thorough definition of what we mean by a _ qtm_. bernstein and vazirani ( @xcite , def .
3.2.2 ) define a quantum turing machine @xmath165 as a triplet @xmath166 , where @xmath167 is a finite alphabet with an identified blank symbol @xmath27 , and @xmath168 is a finite set of states with an identified initial state @xmath169 and final state @xmath170 .
the function @xmath171 is called the _ quantum transition function_. the symbol @xmath172 denotes the set of complex numbers @xmath173 such that there is a deterministic algorithm that computes the real and imaginary parts of @xmath174 to within @xmath175 in time polynomial in @xmath7 .
one can think of a _ qtm _ as consisting of a two - way infinite tape @xmath176 of cells indexed by @xmath177 , a control @xmath178 , and a single
read / write head @xmath179 that moves along the tape .
a ( classical ) configuration is a triplet @xmath180 such that only a finite number of tape cell contents @xmath181 are non - blank ( @xmath34 and @xmath137 are the state of the control and the position of the head respectively ) .
let @xmath182 be the set of all configurations , and define the hilbert space @xmath183 , which can be written as @xmath184 .
the transition function @xmath158 generates a linear operator @xmath185 on @xmath186 describing the time evolution of the _
qtm_. we identify @xmath149 with the initial state of @xmath165 on input @xmath119 , which is according to the definition in @xcite a state on @xmath186 where @xmath119 is written on the input track over the cell interval @xmath187 $ ] , the empty state @xmath27 is written on the remaining cells of the input track and on the whole output track , the control is in the initial state @xmath169 and the head is in position @xmath188 .
then , the state @xmath189 of @xmath165 on input @xmath119 at time @xmath190 is given by @xmath191 .
the state of the control at time @xmath192 is thus given by partial trace over all the other parts of the machine , that is @xmath193 . in accordance with @xcite , def .
3.5.1 , we say that the _ qtm _ @xmath165 _ halts at time @xmath190 on input @xmath149 _ , if and only if @xmath194 where @xmath195 is the special state of the control ( specified in the definition of @xmath165 ) signalling the halting of the computation .
denote by @xmath196 the set of vector inputs with equal halting time @xmath192 .
observe that the above definition implies that @xmath197 is equal to the linear span of @xmath198 , i.e. @xmath199 is a linear subspace of @xmath145 .
moreover for @xmath200 the corresponding subspaces @xmath199 and @xmath201 are mutually orthogonal , because otherwise one could perfectly distinguish non - orthogonal vectors by means of the halting time .
it follows that the subset of @xmath202 on which a _ qtm m _
halts is a union @xmath203 . for our purpose ,
it is useful to consider a special class of _ qtms _ with the property that their tape @xmath176 consists of two different tracks , an _ input track _ @xmath204 and an _ output track _ @xmath205 .
this can be achieved by having an alphabet which is a cartesian product of two alphabets , in our case @xmath206 .
then , the tape hilbert space @xmath207 can be written as @xmath208 . ' '' '' a partial map @xmath209 will be called a _ qtm _ , if there is a bernstein - vazirani two - track qtm @xmath210 ( see @xcite , def .
3.5.5 ) with the following properties : * @xmath206 , * the corresponding time evolution operator @xmath211 is unitary , *
if @xmath212 halts on input @xmath119 with a variable - length qubit string @xmath213 on the output track starting in cell @xmath188 such that the @xmath214-th cell is empty for every @xmath215 $ ] , then @xmath216 ; otherwise , @xmath217 is undefined . in general , different inputs @xmath119 have different halting times @xmath192 and the corresponding outputs are essentially results of different unitary transformations given by @xmath218 .
however , as the subset of @xmath219 on which @xmath165 is defined is of the form @xmath220 , the action of the partial map @xmath165 on this subset may be extended to a valid quantum operation on the system hilbert space @xmath89 , see @xcite . ] on @xmath221 : [ lemmaqtmsareoperations ] ' '' '' for every _ qtm _ @xmath165 there is a quantum operation @xmath222 , such that for every @xmath223 @xmath224 * proof .
* let @xmath225 and @xmath226 be an orthonormal basis of @xmath199 , @xmath227 , and the orthogonal complement of @xmath228 within @xmath145 , respectively .
we add an ancilla hilbert space @xmath229 to the _ qtm _ , and define a linear operator @xmath230 by specifying its action on the orthonormal basis vectors @xmath231 : @xmath232 since the right hand side of ( [ eqonb ] ) is a set of orthonormal vectors in @xmath233 , the map @xmath234 is a partial isometry .
thus , the map @xmath235 is trace - preserving , completely positive ( @xcite ) .
its composition with the partial trace , given by @xmath236 , is a quantum operation .
the typical case we want to study is the ( approximate ) reproduction of a density matrix @xmath237 by a qtm @xmath165 .
this means that there is a quantum program
@xmath238 , such that @xmath239 in a sense explained below .
we are particularly interested in the case that the program @xmath119 is shorter than @xmath19 itself , i.e. that @xmath240 . on the whole ,
the minimum possible length @xmath241 for @xmath19 will be defined as the _ quantum algorithmic complexity _ of @xmath19 .
as already mentioned , there are at least two natural possible definitions .
the first one is to demand only approximate reproduction of @xmath19 within some trace distance @xmath158 .
the second one is based on the notion of an approximation scheme . to define the latter
, we have to specify what we mean by supplying a _ qtm _ with _ two _ inputs , the qubit string and a parameter : [ defencoding ] ' '' '' let @xmath159 and @xmath242 .
we define an encoding @xmath243 of a pair @xmath244 into a single string @xmath245 by @xmath246 where @xmath247 denotes the ( classical ) string consisting of @xmath248 @xmath25 s , followed by one @xmath188 , followed by the @xmath249 binary digits of @xmath137 , and @xmath250 is the corresponding projector in the computational basis and @xmath251 . ] . for every _
qtm _ @xmath165 , we set @xmath252 note that @xmath253 the _ qtm _
@xmath165 has to be constructed in such a way that it is able to decode both @xmath137 and @xmath119 from @xmath245 , which is an easy classical task .
[ defqk ] ' '' '' let @xmath165 be a _ qtm _ and @xmath254 a qubit string .
for every @xmath255 , we define the _ finite - accuracy quantum complexity _ @xmath256 as the minimal length @xmath241 of any quantum program @xmath257 such that the corresponding output @xmath217 has trace distance from @xmath19 smaller than @xmath158 , @xmath258 similarly , we define an _ approximation - scheme quantum complexity _ @xmath259 by the minimal length @xmath241 of any density operator @xmath257 , such that when given @xmath165 as input together with any integer @xmath137 , the output @xmath260 has trace distance from @xmath19 smaller than @xmath261 : @xmath262 some points are worth stressing in connection with the previous definition : * this definition is essentially equivalent to the definition given by berthiaume et .
al . in @xcite .
the only technical difference is that we found it convenient to use the trace distance rather than the fidelity . * the _ same _ qubit program @xmath119 is accompanied by a classical specification of an integer @xmath137 , which tells the program to
what accuracy the computation of the output state must be accomplished . *
if @xmath165 does not have too restricted functionality ( for example , if @xmath165 is universal , which is discussed below ) , a noiseless transmission channel ( implementing the identity transformation ) between the input and output tracks can always be realized : this corresponds to classical literal transcription , so that automatically @xmath263 for some constant @xmath264 .
of course , the key point in classical as well as quantum algorithmic complexity is that there are sometimes much shorter qubit programs than literal transcription . *
the exact choice of the accuracy specification @xmath265 is not important ; we can choose any computable function that tends to zero for @xmath266 , and we will always get an equivalent definition ( in the sense of being equal up to some constant ) . + the same is true for the choice of the encoding @xmath267 : as long as @xmath137 and @xmath119 can both be computably decoded from @xmath245 and as long as there is no way to extract additional information on the desired output @xmath19 from the @xmath137-description part of @xmath245 , the results will be equivalent up to some constant . both quantum algorithmic complexities @xmath30 and @xmath29 are related to each other in a useful way : [ lemrelation ] for every _ qtm _ @xmath165 and every @xmath159 , we have the relation @xmath268 * proof .
* suppose that @xmath269 , so there is a density matrix @xmath270 with @xmath271 , such that @xmath272 for every @xmath159 .
then @xmath273 , where @xmath267 is given in definition [ defencoding ] , is an input for @xmath165 such that @xmath274 .
thus @xmath275 , where the second inequality is by ( [ encoding_length ] ) .
the term @xmath276 in ( [ eqrelation ] ) depends on our encoding @xmath267 given in definition [ defencoding ] , but if @xmath165 is assumed to be universal ( which will be discussed below ) , then ( [ eqrelation ] ) will hold for _ every _ encoding , if we replace the term @xmath277 by @xmath278 , where @xmath279 denotes the classical ( self - delimiting ) algorithmic complexity of the integer @xmath137 , and @xmath264 is some constant depending only on @xmath165 . for more details
we refer the reader to @xcite . in @xcite
, it is proved that there is a universal _ qtm _ ( _ uqtm _ ) @xmath3 that can simulate with arbitrary accuracy every other machine @xmath165 in the sense that for every such @xmath165 there is a classical bit string @xmath280 such that @xmath281 where @xmath282 .
as it is implicit in this definition of universality , we will demand that @xmath283 is able to perfectly simulate every classical computation , and that it can apply a given unitary transformation within any desired accuracy ( it is shown in @xcite that such machines exist ) .
we choose an arbitrary _ uqtm _ @xmath283 which is constructed such that it decodes our encoding @xmath245 given in definition [ defencoding ] into @xmath137 and @xmath119 at the beginning of the computation .
like in the classical case , we fix @xmath283 for the rest of the paper and simplify notation by @xmath284
as already mentioned at the beginning of section [ secergodicquantumsources ] , without loss of generality , we give the proofs for the case that @xmath39 is the algebra of the observables of a qubit , i.e. the complex @xmath59-matrices . for classical _ tm_s , there are no more than @xmath285 different programs of length @xmath286 .
this can be used as a counting argument for proving the lower bound of brudno s theorem in the classical case ( @xcite ) .
we are now going to prove a similar statement for _ qtm_s .
our first step is to elaborate on an argument due to @xcite which states that there can not be more than @xmath287 mutually orthogonal one - dimensional projectors @xmath2 with quantum complexity @xmath288 .
the argument is based on holevo s @xmath289-quantity associated to any ensemble @xmath290 consisting of weights @xmath291 , @xmath292 , and of density matrices @xmath293 acting on a hilbert space @xmath89 .
setting @xmath294 , the @xmath289-quantity is defined as follows @xmath295 where , in the second line , the relative entropy appears @xmath296 if @xmath297 is finite , ( [ eqholevologdim1 ] ) is bounded by the maximal von neumann entropy : @xmath298 in the following , @xmath299 denotes an arbitrary ( possibly infinite - dimensional ) hilbert space , while the rest of the notation is adopted from subsection [ basicdefqtmsec ] .
[ countingargument ] let @xmath300 , @xmath301 such that @xmath302 , @xmath303 an orthogonal projector onto a linear subspace of an arbitrary hilbert space @xmath299 , and @xmath304 a quantum operation .
let @xmath305 be a subset of one - dimensional mutually orthogonal projections from the set @xmath306 that is , the set of all pure quantum states which are reproduced within @xmath158 by the operation @xmath307 on some input of length @xmath308 .
then it holds that @xmath309 * proof .
* let @xmath310 , @xmath311 , be a set of mutually orthogonal projectors and @xmath312 . by the definition of @xmath313 , for every @xmath314 , there are density matrices @xmath315 with @xmath316 consider the equidistributed ensemble @xmath317 , where @xmath318 also acts on @xmath319 . using that @xmath320 , inequality ( [ eqholevologdim3 ] ) yields @xmath321 we define a quantum operation @xmath322 on @xmath323 by @xmath324 .
applying twice the monotonicity of the relative entropy under quantum operations , we obtain @xmath325 moreover , for every @xmath326 , the density operator @xmath327 is close to the corresponding one - dimensional projector @xmath328 . indeed , by the contractivity of the trace distance under quantum operations ( compare thm .
9.2 in @xcite ) and by assumption ( [ delta_distance ] ) , it holds @xmath329 let @xmath330 .
the trace - distance is convex ( @xcite , ( 9.51 ) ) , thus @xmath331 whence , since @xmath332 , fannes inequality ( compare thm .
11.6 in @xcite ) gives @xmath333 where @xmath334 .
combining the two estimates above with ( [ dim_estim ] ) and ( [ chi_estimate ] ) , we obtain @xmath335 assume now that @xmath336
. then it follows ( [ constr ] ) that @xmath337 .
so if @xmath338 is larger than this expression , the maximum number @xmath339 of mutually orthogonal projectors in @xmath340 must be bounded by @xmath341 .
the second step uses the previous lemma together with the following theorem ( * ? ? ?
it is closely related to the quantum shannon - mcmillan theorem and concerns the minimal dimension of the @xmath342typical subspaces .
[ qaep ] let @xmath129 be an ergodic quantum source with entropy rate @xmath31 .
then , for every @xmath343 , @xmath344 where @xmath345
. notice that the limit ( [ eqboltzmann ] ) is valid for all @xmath346 . by means of this property
, we will first prove the lower bound for the finite - accuracy complexity @xmath30 , and then use lemma [ lemrelation ] to extend it to @xmath29 .
[ cor1 ] ' '' '' let @xmath129 be an ergodic quantum source with entropy rate @xmath31
. moreover , let @xmath300 , and let @xmath347 be a sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors .
then , there is another sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath348 , such that for @xmath7 large enough @xmath349 is true for every one - dimensional projector @xmath133 .
* proof . *
the case @xmath350 is trivial , so let @xmath351 . fix @xmath108 and some @xmath300 , and
consider the set @xmath352 from the definition of @xmath353 , to all @xmath2 s there exist associated density matrices @xmath354 with @xmath355 such that @xmath356 , where @xmath357 denotes the quantum operation @xmath358 of the corresponding _ uqtm _
@xmath3 , as explained in lemma [ lemmaqtmsareoperations ] .
using the notation of lemma [ countingargument ] , it thus follows that @xmath359 let @xmath360 be a sum of a maximal number of mutually orthogonal projectors from @xmath361 .
if @xmath7 was chosen large enough such that @xmath362 is satisfied , lemma [ countingargument ] implies that @xmath363 and there are no one - dimensional projectors @xmath364 such that @xmath365 , namely , one - dimensional projectors @xmath366 must satisfy @xmath367 . since inequality ( [ eqcountargused ] ) is valid for every @xmath368 large enough , we conclude @xmath369 using theorem [ qaep ] , we obtain that @xmath370 .
finally , set @xmath371 .
the claim follows .
[ cor2 ] ' '' '' let @xmath129 be an ergodic quantum source with entropy rate @xmath31 .
let @xmath347 with @xmath372 be an arbitrary sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors .
then , for every @xmath373 , there is a sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath348 such that for @xmath7 large enough @xmath374 is satisfied for every one - dimensional projector @xmath133 .
* according to corollary [ cor1 ] , for every @xmath375 , there exists a sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath376 with @xmath377 for every one - dimensional projector @xmath378 if @xmath7 is large enough .
we have @xmath379 where the first estimate is by lemma [ lemrelation ] , and the second one is true for one - dimensional projectors @xmath380 and @xmath368 large enough . fix a large @xmath137 satisfying @xmath381 .
the result follows by setting @xmath382 . in the previous section
, we have shown that with high probability and for large @xmath383 , the finite - accuracy complexity rate @xmath384 is bounded from below by @xmath385 , and the approximation - scheme quantum complexity rate @xmath386 by @xmath387 .
we are now going to establish the upper bounds .
[ propupperbound ] ' '' '' let @xmath129 be an ergodic quantum source with entropy rate @xmath31 . then , for every @xmath300 , there is a sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath388 such that for every one - dimensional projector @xmath389 and @xmath383 large enough @xmath390 we prove the above proposition by explicitly providing a quantum algorithm ( with program length increasing like @xmath391 ) that computes @xmath34 within arbitrary accuracy .
this will be done by means of quantum universal typical subspaces constructed by kaltchenko and yang in @xcite .
[ kaltc ] ' '' '' let @xmath392 and @xmath393 .
there exists a sequence of projectors @xmath394 , @xmath368 , such that for @xmath7 large enough @xmath395 and for every ergodic quantum state @xmath396 with entropy rate @xmath397 it holds that @xmath398 we call the orthogonal projectors @xmath399 in the above theorem universal typical projectors at level @xmath31 .
suited for designing an appropriate quantum algorithm , we slightly modify the proof given by kaltchenko and yang in @xcite .
* let @xmath400 and @xmath401 .
we consider an abelian quasi - local subalgebra @xmath402 constructed from a maximal abelian @xmath403block subalgebra @xmath404 .
the results in @xcite imply that there exists a universal sequence of projectors @xmath405 with @xmath406 such that @xmath407 for any ergodic state @xmath14 on the abelian algebra @xmath408 with entropy rate @xmath409 .
notice that ergodicity and entropy rate of @xmath14 are defined with respect to the shift on @xmath410 , which corresponds to the @xmath411-shift on @xmath55 .
the first step in @xcite is to apply unitary operators of the form @xmath412 , @xmath413 unitary , to the @xmath414 and to introduce the projectors @xmath415 let @xmath416 be a spectral decomposition of @xmath417 ( with @xmath418 some index set ) , and let @xmath419 denote the orthogonal projector onto a given subspace @xmath420 .
then , @xmath421 can also be written as @xmath422 it will be more convenient for the construction of our algorithm in [ subsubconstr ] to consider the projector @xmath423 it holds that @xmath424 . for integers
@xmath425 with @xmath102 and @xmath426 we introduce the projectors in @xmath427 @xmath428 we now use an argument of @xcite to estimate the trace of @xmath429 . the dimension of the symmetric subspace @xmath430 is upper bounded by @xmath431 , thus @xmath432 now we consider a stationary ergodic state @xmath71 on the quasi - local algebra @xmath68 with entropy rate @xmath433 . let @xmath434 . if @xmath411 is chosen large enough then the projectors @xmath435 , where @xmath436 , are @xmath437typical for @xmath71 , i.e. @xmath438 , for @xmath439 sufficiently large .
this can be seen as follows .
due to the result in ( * ? ? ?
3.1 ) the ergodic state @xmath71 convexly decomposes into @xmath440 states @xmath441 each @xmath442 being ergodic with respect to the @xmath403shift on @xmath68 and having an entropy rate ( with respect to the @xmath403shift ) equal to @xmath443 .
we define for @xmath444 the set of integers @xmath445 then , according to a density lemma proven in ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.1 ) it holds @xmath446 let @xmath447 be the maximal abelian subalgebra of @xmath448 generated by the one - dimensional eigenprojectors of @xmath449 .
the restriction of a component @xmath442 to the abelian quasi - local algebra @xmath450 is again an ergodic state .
it holds in general @xmath451 for @xmath452 , where we set @xmath453 , we additionally have the upper bound @xmath454 .
let @xmath455 be a unitary operator such that @xmath456 .
for every @xmath452 , it holds that @xmath457 we fix an @xmath458 large enough to fulfill @xmath459 and use the ergodic decomposition ( [ erg_decomp ] ) to obtain the lower bound @xmath460 from ( [ erg_comp ] ) we conclude that for @xmath7 large enough @xmath461 we proceed by following the lines of @xcite by introducing the sequence @xmath462 , @xmath439 , where each @xmath462 is a power of @xmath28 fulfilling the inequality @xmath463 let the integer sequence @xmath464 and the real - valued sequence @xmath465 be defined by @xmath466 and @xmath467 .
then we set @xmath468 observe that @xmath469 where the second inequality is by estimate ( [ dim_estimate ] ) and the last one by the bounds on @xmath464 @xmath470 thus , for large @xmath383 , it holds @xmath471 by the special choice ( [ l_m ] ) of @xmath462 it is ensured that the sequence of projectors @xmath472 is indeed typical for any quantum state @xmath71 with entropy rate @xmath397 , compare @xcite .
this means that @xmath473 is a sequence of universal typical projectors at level @xmath31 .
we proceed by applying the latter result to universal typical subspaces for our proof of the upper bound .
let @xmath474 be an arbitrary real number such that @xmath475 is rational , and let @xmath476 be the universal projector sequence of theorem [ kaltc ] .
recall that the projector sequence @xmath477 is _ independent _ of the choice of the ergodic state @xmath71 , as long as @xmath478 . because of ( [ eqtraceissmall ] ) , for @xmath383 large enough , there exists some unitary transformation @xmath479 that transforms the projector @xmath477 into a projector belonging to @xmath480 , thus transforming every one - dimensional projector @xmath481 into a qubit string @xmath482 of length @xmath483 . as shown in @xcite , a _ uqtm
_ can implement every classical algorithm , and it can apply every unitary transformation @xmath484 ( when given an algorithm for the computation of @xmath484 ) on its tapes within any desired accuracy
. we can thus feed @xmath485 ( plus some classical instructions including a subprogram for the computation of @xmath484 ) as input into the _ uqtm _ @xmath283 . this _ uqtm _
starts by computing a classical description of the transformation @xmath484 , and subsequently applies @xmath484 to @xmath485 , recovering the original projector @xmath486 on the output tape .
since @xmath487 depends on @xmath71 only through its entropy rate @xmath126 , the subprogram that computes @xmath484 does not have to be supplied with additional information on @xmath71 and will thus have fixed length .
we give a precise definition of a quantum decompression algorithm @xmath488 , which is , formally , a mapping ( @xmath489 is rational ) @xmath490 we require that @xmath488 is a short algorithm in the sense of short in description , _ not _ short ( fast ) in running time or resource consumption .
indeed , the algorithm @xmath488 is very slow and memory consuming , but this does not matter , since kolmogorov complexity only cares about the description length of the program .
the instructions defining the quantum algorithm @xmath488 are : * read the value of @xmath383 , and find a solution @xmath491 for the inequality @xmath492 such that @xmath411 is a power of two .
( there is only one such @xmath411 . ) * compute @xmath493 . *
read the value of @xmath489 .
compute @xmath494 . *
compute a list of codewords @xmath495 , belonging to a classical universal block code sequence of rate @xmath496 .
( for the construction of an appropriate algorithm , see ( * ? ? ?
* thm . 2 and 1 ) .
) since @xmath497 @xmath498 can be stored as a list of binary strings .
every string has length @xmath499 .
( note that the exact value of the cardinality @xmath500 depends on the choice of @xmath495 . ) during the following steps , the quantum algorithm @xmath488 will have to deal with * rational numbers , * square roots of rational numbers , * binary - digit - approximations ( up to some specified accuracy ) of real numbers , * ( large ) vectors and matrices containing such numbers .
a classical _ tm _ can of course deal with all such objects ( and so can _ qtm _ ) : for example , rational numbers can be stored as a list of two integers ( containing numerator and denominator ) , square roots can be stored as such a list and an additional bit denoting the square root , and binary - digit - approximations can be stored as binary strings . vectors and matrices
are arrays containing those objects .
they are always assumed to be given in the computational basis .
operations on those objects , like addition or multiplication , are easily implemented .
the quantum algorithm @xmath488 continues as follows : * compute a basis @xmath501 of the symmetric subspace @xmath502 this can be done as follows : for every @xmath7-tuple @xmath503 , where @xmath504 , there is one basis element @xmath505 , given by the formula @xmath506 where the summation runs over all @xmath7-permutations @xmath119 , and @xmath507 with @xmath508 a system of matrix units in @xmath448 .
+ there is a number of @xmath509 different matrices @xmath510 which we can label by @xmath511 .
it follows from ( [ eqwillberational ] ) that these matrices have integer entries .
+ they are stored as a list of @xmath512-tables of integers .
thus , this step of the computation is exact , that is without approximations . * for every @xmath513 and @xmath514 , let @xmath515 where @xmath516 denotes the computational basis vector which is a tensor product of @xmath140 s and @xmath141 s according to the bits of the string @xmath517 .
compute the vectors @xmath518 one after the other .
for every vector that has been computed , check if it can be written as a linear combination of already computed vectors .
( the corresponding system of linear equations can be solved exactly , since every vector is given as an array of integers . )
if yes , then discard the new vector @xmath518 , otherwise store it and give it a number . +
this way , a set of vectors @xmath519 is computed .
these vectors linearly span the support of the projector @xmath520 given in ( [ eqjoin2 ] ) . *
denote by @xmath521 the computational basis vectors of @xmath522 .
if @xmath523 , then let @xmath524 , and let @xmath525 .
otherwise , compute @xmath526 for every @xmath527 and @xmath528 .
the resulting set of vectors @xmath529 has cardinality @xmath530 .
+ in both cases , the resulting vectors @xmath531 will span the support of the projector @xmath532 . * the set @xmath529 is completed to linearly span the whole space @xmath533 .
this will be accomplished as follows : + consider the sequence of vectors @xmath534 where @xmath535 denotes the computational basis vectors of @xmath533 .
find the smallest @xmath214 such that @xmath536 can be written as a linear combination of @xmath537 , and discard it ( this can still be decided exactly , since all the vectors are given as tables of integers ) .
repeat this step @xmath538 times until there remain only @xmath539 linearly independent vectors , namely all the @xmath540 and @xmath541 of the @xmath542 . *
apply the gram - schmidt orthonormalization procedure to the resulting vectors , to get an orthonormal basis @xmath543 of @xmath533 , such that the first @xmath544 vectors are a basis for the support of @xmath532 .
+ since every vector @xmath540 and @xmath542 has only integer entries , all the resulting vectors @xmath545 will have only entries that are ( plus or minus ) the square root of some rational number . up to this point
, every calculation was _ exact _ without any numerical error , comparable to the way that well - known computer algebra systems work .
the goal of the next steps is to compute an approximate description of the desired unitary decompression map @xmath484 and subsequently apply it to the quantum state @xmath485 . according to section 6 in @xcite , a _
uqtm _ is able to apply a unitary transformation @xmath484 on some segment of its tape within an accuracy of @xmath158 , if it is supplied with a complex matrix @xmath546 as input which is within operator norm distance @xmath547 of @xmath484 ( here , @xmath548 denotes the size of the matrix ) .
thus , the next task is to compute the number of digits @xmath549 that are necessary to guarantee that the output will be within trace distance @xmath550 of @xmath34 . *
read the value of @xmath137 ( which denotes an approximation parameter ; the larger @xmath137 , the more accurate the output of the algorithm will be ) .
due to the considerations above and the calculations below , the necessary number of digits @xmath549 turns out to be @xmath551 .
compute this number .
+ afterwards , compute the components of all the vectors @xmath543 up to @xmath549 binary digits of accuracy .
( this involves only calculation of the square root of rational numbers , which can easily be done to any desired accuracy . ) + call the resulting numerically approximated vectors @xmath552 .
write them as columns into an array ( a matrix ) @xmath553 .
+ let @xmath554 denote the unitary matrix with the exact vectors @xmath545 as columns .
since @xmath549 binary digits give an accuracy of @xmath555 , it follows that @xmath556 if two @xmath557-matrices @xmath484 and @xmath546 are @xmath558-close in their entries , they also must be @xmath559-close in norm , so we get @xmath560 so far , every step was purely classical and could have been done on a classical computer .
now , the quantum part begins : @xmath485 will be touched for the first time . *
compute @xmath561 , which gives the length @xmath562 .
afterwards , move @xmath485 to some free space on the input tape , and append zeroes , i.e. create the state @xmath563 on some segment of @xmath383 cells on the input tape . *
approximately apply the unitary transformation @xmath484 on the tape segment that contains the state @xmath564 .
+ the machine can not apply @xmath484 exactly ( since it only knows an approximation @xmath546 ) , and it also can not apply @xmath546 directly ( since @xmath546 is only approximately unitary , and the machine can only do unitary transformations ) .
instead , it will effectively apply another unitary transformation @xmath420 which is close to @xmath546 and thus close to @xmath484 , such that @xmath565 + let @xmath566 be the output that we want to have , and let @xmath567 be the approximation that is really computed by the machine . then
, @xmath568 a simple calculation proves that the trace distance must then also be small : @xmath569 * move @xmath570 to the output tape and halt .
we have to give a precise definition how the parameters @xmath571 are encoded into a single qubit string @xmath119 .
( according to the definition of @xmath29 , the parameter @xmath137 is not a part of @xmath119 , but is given as a second parameter .
see definitions [ defencoding ] and [ defqk ] for details . )
we choose to encode @xmath383 by giving @xmath572 1 s , followed by one 0 , followed by the @xmath573 binary digits of @xmath383 .
let @xmath574 denote the corresponding projector in the computational basis .
the parameter @xmath489 can be encoded in any way , since it does not depend on @xmath383 .
the only constraint is that the description must be self - delimiting , i.e. it must be clear and decidable at what position the description for @xmath489 starts and ends .
the descriptions will also be given by a computational basis vector ( or rather the corresponding projector ) @xmath575 .
the descriptions are then stuck together , and the input @xmath576 is given by @xmath577 if @xmath383 is large enough such that ( [ eqlogtrqm ] ) is fulfilled , it follows that @xmath578 , where @xmath301 is some constant which depends on @xmath489 , but not on @xmath383 .
it is clear that this qubit string can be fed into the reference _ uqtm _ @xmath3 together with a description of the algorithm @xmath488 of fixed length @xmath579 which depends on @xmath489 , but not on @xmath383 .
this will give a qubit string @xmath580 of length @xmath581 where @xmath582 is again a constant which depends on @xmath489 , but not on @xmath383 .
recall the matrix @xmath484 constructed in step 11 of our algorithm @xmath583 , which rotates ( decompresses ) a compressed ( short ) qubit string @xmath485 back into the typical subspace .
conversely , for every one - dimensional projector @xmath481 , where @xmath584 was defined in ( [ eqtypicalprojector ] ) , let @xmath585 be the projector given by @xmath586 .
then , since @xmath583 has been constructed such that @xmath587 it follows from ( [ eqlength ] ) that @xmath588 if @xmath383 is large enough , equation ( [ upperzero ] ) follows .
now we continue by proving equation ( [ upperdelta ] ) .
let @xmath589 .
then , we have for every one - dimensional projector @xmath481 and @xmath383 large enough @xmath590 where the first inequality follows from the obvious monotonicity property @xmath591 , the second one is by lemma [ lemrelation ] , and the third estimate is due to equation ( [ upperzero ] ) . _
proof of the main theorem [ theqbrudno ] .
_ let @xmath592 be the @xmath71-typical projector sequence given in proposition [ propupperbound ] , i.e. the complexities @xmath386 and @xmath593 of every one - dimensional projector @xmath594 are upper bounded by @xmath595 .
due to corollary [ cor1 ] , there exists another sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath596 such that additionally , @xmath597 is satisfied for @xmath598 . from corollary [ cor2 ] , we can further deduce that there is another sequence of @xmath71-typical projectors @xmath599 such that also @xmath600 holds .
finally , the optimality assertion is a direct consequence of the quantum counting argument , lemma [ countingargument ] , combined with theorem [ qaep ] .
classical algorithmic complexity theory as initiated by kolmogorov , chaitin and solomonoff aimed at giving firm mathematical ground to the intuitive notion of randomness .
the idea is that random objects can not have short descriptions .
such an approach is on the one hand equivalent to martin - lf s which is based on the notion of _ typicalness _
@xcite , and is on the other hand intimately connected with the notion of entropy . the latter relation is best exemplified in the case of longer and longer strings : by taking the ratio of the complexity with respect to the number of bits , one gets a _ complexity per symbol _ which a theorem of brudno shows to be equal to the _ entropy per symbol _ of almost all sequences emitted by ergodic sources .
the fast development of quantum information and computation , with the formalization of the concept of _ uqtms _ , quite naturally brought with itself the need of extending the notion of algorithmic complexity to the quantum setting . within such a broader context , the ultimate goal is again a mathematical theory of the randomness of quantum objects .
there are two possible algorithmic descriptions of qubit strings : either by means of bit - programs or of qubit - programs . in this work ,
we have considered a qubit - based _ quantum algorithmic complexity _ , namely constructed in terms of quantum descriptions of quantum objects .
the main result of this paper is an extension of brudno s theorem to the quantum setting , though in a slightly weaker form which is due to the absence of a natural concatenation of qubits .
the quantum brudno s relation proved in this paper is not a pointwise relation as in the classical case , rather a kind of convergence in probability which connects the _ quantum complexity per qubit _ with the von neumann entropy rate of quantum ergodic sources .
possible strengthening of this relation following the strategy which permits the formulation of a quantum breiman theorem starting from the quantum shannon - mcmillan noiseless coding theorem @xcite will be the matter of future investigations . in order to assert that this choice of quantum complexity as a formalization of quantum randomness " is as good as its classical counterpart in relation to classical randomness
, one ought to compare it with the other proposals that have been put forward : not only with the quantum complexity based on classical descriptions of quantum objects @xcite , but also with the one based on the notion of _ universal density matrices _ @xcite . in relation to vitanyi s
approach , the comparison essentially boils down to understanding whether a classical description of qubit strings requires more classical bits than @xmath31 qubits per hilbert space dimension .
an indication that this is likely to be the case may be related to the existence of entangled states . in relation to gacs
approach , the clue is provided by the possible formulation of quantum martin - lf tests in terms of measurement processes projecting onto low - probability subspaces , the quantum counterparts of classical untypical sets .
one can not however expect classical - like equivalences among the various definitions .
it is indeed a likely consequence of the very structure of quantum theory that a same classical notion may be extended in different inequivalent ways , all of them reflecting a specific aspect of that structure .
this fact is most clearly seen in the case of quantum dynamical entropies ( compare for instance @xcite ) where one definition can capture dynamical features which are precluded to another .
therefore , it is possible that there may exist different , equally suitable notions of `` quantum randomness '' , each one of them reflecting a different facet of it .
this work was supported by the dfg via the project `` entropie , geometrie und kodierung groer quanten - informationssysteme '' and the dfg - forschergruppe `` stochastische analysis und groe abweichungen '' at the university of bielefeld . a. k. zvonkin , l. a. levin , `` the complexity of finite objects and the development of the concepts of information and randomness by means of the theory of algorithms '' , _ russian mathematical surveys _ * 25 no .
6 * 83 - 124 ( 1970 ) | in classical information theory , entropy rate and algorithmic complexity per symbol are related by a theorem of brudno . in this paper , we prove a quantum version of this theorem , connecting the von neumann entropy rate and two notions of quantum kolmogorov complexity , both based on the shortest qubit descriptions of qubit strings that , run by a universal quantum turing machine , reproduce them as outputs . |
a fractional brownian motion @xmath0 with hurst parameter @xmath2 is a continuous zero - mean gaussian process in @xmath3 with stationary increments and covariance function @xmath4 = \tfrac{1}{2 } ( |t|^{2h } + |s|^{2h } - brownian motion , but a fractional brownian motion is not a semimartingale for @xmath5 . in this paper , we restrict ourselves to the case @xmath6 , in which the corresponding fractional gaussian noise @xmath7 exhibits long - range dependence . in recent years , a lively interest in integration theory with respect to fractional brownian motion has emerged ( see , e.g. , the monographs by mishura or biagini _ et al . _
one of the extensions of the it integral beyond semimartingales is the fractional wick it integral .
it is based on the wick product @xmath8 , which has its origin as a renormalization operator in quantum physics . in probability theory ,
the wick product with ordinary differentiation rule imitates the situation of ordinary multiplication with it differentiation rule ( cf .
holden _ et al . _
@xcite ) . actually , this makes it a natural tool to apply for extending the it integral .
we first consider the fractional dolans dade sde @xmath9 , @xmath10 , in terms of the fractional wick it integral .
the well - known solution , @xmath11 , is the geometric fractional brownian motion , also known as the wick exponential of fractional brownian motion .
note that the wick exponential has expectation equal to one and can therefore be interpreted as a multiplicative noise .
moreover , the ordinary exponential can be obtained from the wick exponential by a deterministic scaling .
neither process is a semimartingale for @xmath12 .
the name `` wick exponential '' is justified by the fact that it exhibits a power series expansion with wick powers @xmath13 instead of ordinary powers .
more generally , we consider a linear system of sdes , @xmath14\\[-8pt ] \mathrm{d}y_{t } & = & ( b_{1}x_{t } + b_{2}y_{t } ) \,\mathrm{d}^{\diamond}b^{h}_{t } , \qquad y_{0 } = y_{0}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can obtain wick power series expansions for the solution of this system , too . our goal is to approximate these wick analytic functionals of a fractional brownian motion . to this end , we require an approximation of a fractional brownian motion and an approximation of the wick product .
there are several ways to approximate a fractional brownian motion .
one of the first approximations was given by taqqu @xcite in terms of stationary gaussian sequences .
we refer to mishura @xcite , section 1.15.3 , for further approaches to weak convergence to a fractional brownian motion .
sottinen constructed a simple approximation of a fractional brownian motion on an interval for @xmath15 by sums of square - integrable random variables in @xcite .
he used the wiener integral representation of a fractional brownian motion on an interval , @xmath16 , for a suitable deterministic kernel @xmath17 , due to molchan and golosov , and norros _ et al .
_ @xcite . for this purpose
, he combined a pointwise approximation of the kernel @xmath18 with donsker s theorem .
this approach was extended by nieminen @xcite to weak convergence of perturbed martingale differences to fractional brownian motion .
we shall utilize sottinen s approximation with binary random variables throughout this paper .
the main problem of applying the wick product on random variables with continuous distributions is that it is not a pointwise operation .
thus , an explicit computation of the wick
it integral is only possible in rare special cases .
but this is precisely the advantage of the binary random walks .
in such a purely discrete setup , we apply the discrete counterpart of the wick product as introduced in holden _ et al . _ @xcite . starting from the binary random walk , one can build up a discrete wiener space , and the discrete wick product depends on this discretization .
this wiener chaos gives the analogy to the continuous wick products . for a survey on discrete wiener chaos
, we refer to gzyl @xcite .
however , we will introduce the discrete wick product in a self - contained way in section [ approxsection ] .
we can now formulate a weak euler scheme of the linear system of sdes ( [ lineare_system ] ) in the wick it sense , @xmath19\\[-8pt ] y^{n}_{l } & = & y^{n}_{l-1 } + ( b_{1}x^{n}_{l-1 } + b_{2}y^{n}_{l-1 } ) \diamond_{n } \bigl(b^{h , n}_{l / n } - b^{h , n}_{(l-1)/n } \bigr ) , \nonumber\\ y^{n}_{0 } & = & y_{0},\qquad l = 1 , \ldots , n,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath20 is the discrete wick product and @xmath21 are the increments of the disturbed binary random walk . as a main result , we show that the piecewise constant interpolation of the solution of ( [ linearesystemwick ] ) converges weakly in the skorokhod space to the solution of ( [ lineare_system ] ) .
this is the first rigorous convergence result connecting discrete and continuous wick calculus of which we are aware . as a special case , ( [ linearesystemwick ] ) contains the wick difference equation @xmath22 as a consequence , the piecewise constant interpolation of ( [ simplewickdiffeq ] ) converges weakly to a geometric fractional brownian motion , the solution of the fractional dolans dade sde .
this was conjectured by bender and elliott @xcite in their study of the wick fractional black scholes market . in @xcite
, sottinen considered the corresponding difference equation in the pathwise sense , that is , with ordinary multiplication instead of the discrete wick product : @xmath23 the solution is explicitly given by the multiplicative expression @xmath24 by the logarithmic transform of ordinary products into sums and a taylor expansion , one obtains an additive expression for @xmath25 which converges weakly to a fractional brownian motion . in this way
, sottinen proved the convergence of @xmath26 to the ordinary exponential of a fractional brownian motion @xcite , theorem 3 .
this approach fails for the solution of ( [ simplewickdiffeq ] ) since , in a product representation , analogous to ( [ sottinendiffsolasprod ] ) , the discrete wick product @xmath20 appears instead of ordinary multiplication .
there is , however , no straightforward way to transform discrete wick products into sums by application of a continuous functional .
however , the solution of ( [ linearesystemwick ] ) exhibits an expression which is closely related to a discrete wick power series representation .
therefore , the convergence can be initiated explicitly for the wick powers of a fractional brownian motion , which fulfill the hermite recursion formula .
we obtain a discrete analog to this recursion formula for discrete wick powers of disturbed binary random walks . actually , the weak convergence of these discrete wick powers is the key to the proof for our euler scheme .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ wickexpsection ] ,
we give some preliminaries on the wick it integral with respect to a fractional brownian motion and introduce the wick exponential and other wick analytic functionals .
we then define the approximating sequences and state the main results in section [ approxsection ] .
section [ wickdiffsec ] is devoted to some @xmath27- estimates of the approximating sequences .
we prove convergence in finite - dimensional distributions in section [ secconvfd ] and tightness in section [ sectightness ] .
in this section , we introduce the wick product and the wick it integral , and describe the hermite recursion formula for wick powers of a zero - mean gaussian random variable .
we then obtain the wick power series expansions for the solutions of sdes ( [ lineare_system ] ) .
we consider a _ geometric fractional brownian motion _ or the so - called _ wick exponential _ of a fractional brownian motion @xmath28 . for @xmath29 ,
this is exactly a geometric brownian motion , also known as the stochastic exponential of a standard brownian motion . for all @xmath2 and @xmath30 , it holds that @xmath31 $ ] and thus the wick exponential generalizes the stochastic exponential .
it is well known that @xmath32 solves the dolans dade equation @xmath33 where the integral is an ordinary it integral .
actually , the wick exponential of fractional brownian motion solves the corresponding fractional dolans dade equation @xmath34 in terms of a fractional wick it integral ( cf .
mishura @xcite , theorem 3.3.2 ) .
we want to approximate solutions of similar sdes .
let @xmath35 and @xmath36 be two zero - mean gaussian random variables .
the _ wick exponential _ is then defined as @xmath37 \bigr).\ ] ] for a standard brownian motion @xmath38 and @xmath39 , it holds that @xmath40 forcing this renormalization property to hold for all , possibly correlated , @xmath35 and @xmath36 , leads to the definition of the _ wick product _
@xmath8 of two wick exponentials : @xmath41 the wick product can be extended to larger classes of random variables by density arguments ( cf .
@xcite ) . for a general introduction to the wick product ,
we refer to the monographs by kuo and holden _ et al .
_ @xcite and hu and yan @xcite .
note that the wick product is not a pointwise operation .
if we suppose that @xmath42 , then we have , by definition , @xmath43 , @xmath44 and the recursion @xmath45 observe that it holds that @xmath46 \biggr ) \bigg|_{x = 0 } \\ & = & ( \phi- x\sigma^2 ) \exp\biggl(x
\phi- \frac{1}{2}\mathbf{e } [ |x\phi|^2 ] \biggr ) \bigg|_{x = 0 } = \phi.\end{aligned}\ ] ] suppose we have @xmath47 for all positive integers @xmath48 .
then , with @xmath49 , @xmath50 , we get @xmath51 we now obtain , by differentiation and the leibniz rule , the following wick recursion formula : @xmath52 \biggr ) \biggr ) \bigg|_{w = 0 } \nonumber\\ & = & ( \phi - w\sigma^2 ) \frac{\mathrm{d}^n}{\mathrm{d}w^n}\exp\biggl(w\phi- \frac{1}{2}\mathbf { e } [ |x\phi|^2 ] \biggr ) \bigg|_{w = 0}\nonumber\\[-8pt]\\[-8pt ] & & { } + n(-\sigma^2)\frac{\mathrm{d}^{n-1}}{\mathrm{d}w^{n-1 } } \exp\biggl(w\phi- \frac { 1}{2}\mathbf{e } [ |w\phi|^2 ] \biggr ) \bigg|_{w = 0}\nonumber\\ & = & \phi\phi^{\diamond n } - n\sigma^2\phi^{\diamond n-1}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] define the _ hermite polynomial of degree @xmath53 with parameter @xmath54 _ as @xmath55 the series expansion
@xmath56 then holds true .
the first hermite polynomials are @xmath57 , @xmath58 . by the leibniz rule
, we obtain the hermite recursion formula @xmath59 by the equivalent first terms and recursions ( [ recursiononwickpower ] ) and ( [ hermiteoriginrecursion ] ) , we can conclude that for any gaussian random variable @xmath42 and all @xmath53 , we have @xmath60 by ( [ wickexpsoalsreihe ] ) , we additionally have @xmath61 the fractional wick it integral , introduced by duncan _
@xcite , is an extension of the it integral beyond the semimartingale framework .
there are several approaches to the fractional wick it integral . essentially , these approaches are via white noise theory , as in elliott and von der hoek @xcite , and hu and ksendal @xcite , by malliavin calculus in als _ et al . _ @xcite , or by an s - transform approach in bender @xcite .
in contrast to the forward integral , the fractional wick it integral has zero mean in general .
this is the crucial property for an additive noise .
it integral is based on the wick product . for a sufficiently good process @xmath62}$ ] , the fractional wick it integral with respect to fractional brownian motion @xmath63}$ ] can be easily defined by wick
riemann sums ( cf .
duncan _ et al .
_ @xcite or mishura @xcite , theorem 2.3.10 ) .
if we suppose that @xmath64 with @xmath65 for @xmath66 , then @xmath67 if the wick products and the @xmath68-limit exist . for more information on wick it integrals with respect to fractional brownian motion , we refer to mishura @xcite , chapter 2 . by the fractional it formula ( cf .
@xcite , theorem 5.3 or @xcite , theorem 3.7.2 ) , we have @xmath69 for the wick exponential @xmath70 we obtain , by summing up the identity ( [ wickpowerchainrule ] ) , the fractional dolans dade equation , @xmath71 for any analytic function @xmath72 , we define the _ wick version _ as @xmath73 from the recursive system of sdes ( [ wickpowerchainrule ] ) , we obtain sdes for other _ wick analytic functionals _ of a fractional brownian motion @xmath74 recall the linear system of sdes ( [ lineare_system ] ) , @xmath75 the coefficients of the solution , @xmath76 can be obtained recursively via ( [ wickpowerchainrule ] ) to be @xmath77 note that it holds that @xmath78 for a @xmath79 .
this is according to the recursive derivation of the coefficients and it ensures that the wick analytic functionals @xmath80 and @xmath81 are square - integrable ( cf . the proof of proposition [ fdmaintheorem ] ) .
here , we present the approximating sequences and discuss the main results . more precisely , we introduce the donsker - type approximation of a fractional brownian motion and the discrete wick product , and obtain wick difference equations , which correspond to the sdes .
we shall work with a fractional brownian motion on the interval @xmath82 $ ] , but all results extend to any compact interval @xmath83 $ ] .
we first consider the following kernel representation of a fractional brownian motion on the interval @xmath82 $ ] , based on works by molchan and golosov @xcite , @xmath84 for @xmath15 , the deterministic kernel takes the form @xmath85 with the constant @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the gamma function ( norros _ et al .
_ @xcite or nualart @xcite , section 5.1.3 ) . in order to simplify the notation
, we think of @xmath1 as fixed from now on and omit the subscript @xmath88 in the notation of the kernel . for an introduction to some elementary properties of fractional brownian motion
, we refer to nualart @xcite , chapter 5 , mishura @xcite or biagini _ et al .
_ @xcite .
we apply sottinen s approximation of a fractional brownian motion by _ disturbed binary random walks_. suppose @xmath89 is a probability space and , for all @xmath53 and @xmath90 , we have independent and identically distributed symmetric bernoulli random variables @xmath91 with @xmath92 . by donsker s theorem ,
the sequence of random walks @xmath93 converges weakly to a standard brownian motion @xmath94}$ ] @xcite , theorem 16.1 .
the idea of sottinen @xcite is to combine these random walks with a pointwise approximation of the kernel in representation ( [ fbmalswiener ] ) .
define the pointwise approximation of @xmath95 as @xmath96 the sequence of binary random walks @xmath97 then converges weakly to a fractional brownian motion @xmath98}$ ] in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] @xcite , theorem 1 .
a major advantage of the binary random walks is that we can avoid the difficult wick product for random variables with continuous distributions .
we approximate this operator on the binary random walks by _ discrete wick products_. for any @xmath53 , let @xmath100 be the @xmath101-tuple of independent and identically distributed symmetric bernoulli random variables for the binary random walk @xmath102 .
the _ discrete wick product _ is defined as @xmath103 where @xmath104 .
we denote by @xmath105 the @xmath106-field generated by the bernoulli variables .
define @xmath107 clearly , the family of functions @xmath108 is an orthonormal set in @xmath109 .
since its cardinality is equal to the dimension of @xmath110 , it constitutes a basis .
thus , every @xmath111 has a unique expansion , called the _
walsh decomposition _
, @xmath112 where @xmath113 .
the walsh decomposition can be regarded as a discrete version of the chaos expansion . by algebraic rules ,
one obtains , for @xmath114 and @xmath115 , @xmath116 furthermore , the @xmath27-inner product can be computed in terms of the walsh decomposition as @xmath117 = \sum_{a \subseteq\{1,\ldots , n\}}x_{a}^n y_{a}^{n}.\ ] ] there exists an analogous formula for the wick product on the white noise space via chaos expansions that justifies the analogy between the discrete and ordinary wick calculus ( cf .
kuo @xcite ) . for more information on the discrete wick product ,
we refer to holden _
more generally , the introduction of a discrete wiener chaos depends on the class of discrete random variables @xmath118 .
we refer to gzyl @xcite for a survey of other discrete wiener chaos approaches .
the representation @xmath119 is the walsh decomposition for the binary random walk approximating @xmath0 in @xmath109 .
note that @xmath120 .
thus , we can consider @xmath121 as a process in discrete time .
we can now state our first convergence result .
[ dattheo1 ] suppose that : 1 .
@xmath122 exists for all @xmath123 ; 2 .
there exists a @xmath124 such that @xmath125 for all @xmath126 .
the sequence of processes @xmath127 then converges weakly to the wick power series @xmath128 in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] .
the proof is given in sections [ secconvfd ] and [ sectightness ] .
consider now the following recursive system of wick difference equations : @xmath129 for all @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
this is the discrete counterpart of the recursive system of sdes in ( [ wickpowerchainrule ] ) .
we observe that @xmath132 and @xmath133 , but @xmath134 thus , in contrast to the continuous case in ( [ wickpowerchainrule ] ) , the discrete wick powers are not the solutions for ( [ recursivesystemwickdifferenceforwickpowers ] ) if @xmath135 .
however , we can prove a variant of theorem [ dattheo1 ] , based on the system of recursive wick difference equations , whose proof will also be given in sections [ secconvfd ] and [ sectightness ] .
[ extendedmaintheorem ] under the assumptions of theorem [ dattheo1 ] , define @xmath136 as the piecewise constant interpolation of ( [ recursivesystemwickdifferenceforwickpowers ] ) .
the sequence of processes @xmath137 then converges weakly to the wick power series @xmath128 in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] . for @xmath138 , @xmath139 for @xmath140
, we have @xmath141 observe that by summing up the recursive system of wick difference equations ( [ recursivesystemwickdifferenceforwickpowers ] ) , we obtain @xmath142 for @xmath130 , where @xmath143 .
hence , the piecewise constant interpolation of ( [ thediffeq ] ) converges weakly to the solution of the fractional dolans dade equation ( [ sdeforwickexponential ] ) .
the reasoning of the previous example can be generalized as follows .
[ approxlinearsdewithdrift ] suppose @xmath144 , @xmath145
. then @xmath146 , where @xmath147 is the solution of the wick difference equation @xmath148 converges weakly to the solution of the _ linear sde with drift _
@xmath149 in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] .
first , observe that for @xmath150 and @xmath151 , we obtain , by theorem [ extendedmaintheorem ] , that @xmath152 with the choice @xmath153 and @xmath154 we observe by ( [ recursivesystemwickdifferenceforwickpowers ] ) that @xmath155 satisfies @xmath156 consider now the piecewise constant function @xmath157}$ ] determined by @xmath158 and @xmath159 by this well - known euler scheme , @xmath160 } \longrightarrow s_{0 } ( \exp(\mu t ) ) _ { t\in[0,1]}\ ] ] in the sup - norm on @xmath82 $ ] .
the product @xmath161 \biggl(1+\frac{\mu}{n}\biggr)w_{l-1}^{n}\\ & = & \biggl(1+\frac{\mu}{n } \biggr)v_{l-1}^{n}w_{l-1}^{n } + \sigma v_{l-1}^{n}w_{l-1}^{n } \diamond_{n } \bigl(b_{l / n}^{h , n } - b_{(l-1)/n}^{h , n } \bigr),\\ v_{0}^{n}w_{0}^{n } & = & s_{0},\qquad l = 1 , \ldots , n,\end{aligned}\ ] ] satisfies the wick difference equation ( [ discretelinearwickdifferencedrift ] ) for @xmath162 . the multiplication by the deterministic function @xmath163 is continuous on the skorokhod space .
thus , with ( [ winl2conv ] ) and billingsley @xcite , theorem 4.1 , we obtain @xmath164 } = ( \widetilde { v}^{n}_{t}\widetilde{w}^{n}_{t } ) _ { t \in[0,1 ] } \stackrel { d}{\longrightarrow } s_{0 } ( \exp(\mu t ) \exp^{\diamond } ( \sigma b^{h}_{t } ) ) _ { t \in[0,1]}\ ] ] in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] . as @xmath165 solves the sde ( [ wicklinearsdedrift ] ) ( cf .
mishura @xcite , theorem 3.3.2 ) , the proof is complete . theorem [ approxlinearsdewithdrift ] holds with additional approximations @xmath166 .
theorem [ approxlinearsdewithdrift ] was conjectured by bender and elliott @xcite in their study of the discrete wick - fractional black scholes market .
they deduced an arbitrage in this model for sufficiently large @xmath101 .
although the arbitrage or no - arbitrage property is not preserved by weak convergence , this model showed that it is even possible to obtain arbitrage in this simple discrete wick fractional market model . in a recent work @xcite
, valkeila shows that an alternative approximation to the exponential of a fractional brownian motion by a superposition of some independent renewal reward processes leads to an arbitrage - free and complete model .
we refer to gaigalas and kaj @xcite for a general limit discussion for these superposition processes .
[ examplelinearsystemofsdes ] the piecewise constant interpolation @xmath167 for the solution of the linear system of wick difference equations @xmath168 converges weakly to the solution @xmath169 of the corresponding linear system of sdes ( [ lineare_system ] ) in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})^2 $ ] .
analogously to ( [ linearsdesystemsolution ] ) , we obtain , by the recursive system of wick difference equations for @xmath170 in ( [ recursivesystemwickdifferenceforwickpowers ] ) , the coefficients for the solution of the systems of difference equations @xmath171 recursively by @xmath172 we define the upper bound @xmath173 suppose that @xmath174 are arbitrary . by the linear system and ( [ recursivesystemwickdifferenceforwickpowers ] ) , the sequence of processes @xmath175 fulfils the conditions in theorem [ extendedmaintheorem ] with @xmath176 thus , we obtain the weak convergence @xmath177 the cramr
wold device ( billingsley @xcite , theorem 7.7 ) can now be used to complete the proof .
theorem [ examplelinearsystemofsdes ] can be extended to higher - dimensional linear cases .
it also holds for an additional approximation of the coefficients @xmath178 and @xmath179 for @xmath66 .
the piecewise constant interpolation of @xmath180 converges weakly to the solution of the linear system @xmath181 the process @xmath182 . by theorem [ dattheo1 ] ,
it can also be approximated by the discrete wick version functional @xmath183 .
in this section , we give the walsh decompositions for the approximating sequences and obtain some @xmath27-estimates . a key to the approximation results
will be the convergence of the @xmath27-norms of the discrete wick powers of @xmath102 to the corresponding @xmath27-norms of the wick powers of @xmath184 .
recall the walsh decomposition @xmath185 .
define @xmath186 for @xmath130 .
note that @xmath187 , @xmath188 , for @xmath189 and that the increment has the representation @xmath190 recall the recursive system of wick difference equations , @xmath191 for @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
[ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] for all @xmath126 and @xmath192 , we have the walsh decompositions @xmath193 or @xmath194 .
we prove ( [ walshforu ] ) by induction as follows . for all @xmath195 and all @xmath131 , it is obvious that @xmath196 and @xmath197 , as in formula ( [ walshforu ] ) .
suppose the formula is proved for all positive integers less than or equal to a certain @xmath198 and all @xmath192 .
furthermore , for @xmath199 , suppose the formula is proved for all positive integers less than or equal to a certain @xmath200 .
for @xmath199 and @xmath201 , we compute , by the difference equation ( [ dassystemderdiffeq ] ) and the induction hypothesis , @xmath202 note that @xmath203 for all @xmath204 . thus , by the induction hypothesis , @xmath205 thanks to equations ( [ inuwalsheq1 ] ) and ( [ inuwalsheq2 ] ) , we obtain ( [ walshforu ] ) .
in particular , @xmath206 for all @xmath207 . we now compute the @xmath198th wick power of @xmath208 as follows : @xmath209 in particular , @xmath210 for all @xmath207 .
this yields ( [ walshforbinaryrandomwalk ] ) .
the telescoping sum yields @xmath211 and thus we get @xmath212 equation ( [ walshforthedifference ] ) is , thus , implied by ( [ walshforu ] ) and ( [ walshforbinaryrandomwalk ] ) . in the following propositions , we obtain some elementary estimates for the @xmath27-norm of discrete wick powers of @xmath102 . [ dasheiligewort ] for all @xmath213 $ ] and @xmath214 , @xmath215 we estimate @xmath216 since @xmath217 , @xmath218 and @xmath219 observe that @xmath220 = \mathbf{e } \biggl[\sum_{i_{1 } , i_{2 } = 1}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } b_{t , i_{1}}^{n } b_{s , i_{2}}^{n}\xi _ { i_{1}}^{n}\xi_{i_{2}}^{n } \biggr ] = \sum^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor}_{i = 1 } ( b_{t , i}^{n } b_{s , i}^{n } ) .\ ] ] by nieminen @xcite , we thus get , for any @xmath221 $ ] , the following convergence : @xmath222 & = & \sum^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor}_{i = 1 } n \int^{i / n}_{(i-1)/n}z \biggl(\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor } { n } , u \biggr)\,\mathrm{d}u \int^{i / n}_{(i-1)/n}z \biggl(\frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } , u \biggr)\,\mathrm{d}u \nonumber\\[-8pt]\\[-8pt ] & \longrightarrow & \int_{0}^{1}z(t , u)z(s , u)\,\mathrm{d}u = \mathbf{e } [ b^{h}_{t } b^{h}_{s } ] .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , we have , by the cauchy
schwarz inequality , the upper bound @xmath223 & = & \sum^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor}_{i=1 } \biggl(\sqrt{n } \int^{i / n}_{(i-1)/n } \biggl(z\biggl(\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } , u\biggr)\,\mathrm{d}u - z\biggl(\frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } , u\biggr ) \biggr)\,\mathrm{d}u \biggr)^2\nonumber\\ & \leq & \sum^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor}_{i=1 } \int^{i / n } _ { ( i-1)/n } \biggl(z\biggl(\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } , u\biggr ) - z\biggl(\frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } , u\biggr ) \biggr)^2\,\mathrm{d}u\\ & = & \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ walshpropevoll ] for all @xmath224 in @xmath82 $ ] and all @xmath225 such that @xmath226 , we have @xmath227^{n } + \mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{s})^2 ] ^{n } - 2\mathbf{e } [ b^{h , n}_{t } b^{h , n}_{s } ] ^{n}\nonumber \\ & & { } - \frac{1}{n!}\mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl ( ( b^{h , n}_{t } ) ^{\diamond_{n } n } - ( b^{h , n}_{s } ) ^{\diamond_{n } n } \bigr)^2 \bigr ] \\
\nonumber\\&\leq & 2c_{h}^{2 } n^2 t^{2h ( n-1 ) } n^{-(2 - 2h)}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , @xmath228 = \mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl ( ( b^{h}_{t } ) ^{\diamond n } - ( b^{h}_{s } ) ^{\diamond n } \bigr)^2 \bigr].\ ] ] as @xmath229 , we get , making use of proposition [ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] , ( [ l2norminwalshterms ] ) and ( [ covarianceforbinaryramdomwalk ] ) in remark [ remarkonboundedness ] , @xmath230\nonumber\\ & & \qquad= \frac{1}{n!}\mathbf{e } \biggl [ \biggl(n!\mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq \{1 , \ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = n } b_{t , c}^{n}\xi_{c}^{n } \biggr ) \biggl(n!\mathop{\sum _ { c \subseteq \{1 , \ldots , \lfloor ns \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = n } b_{s , c}^{n}\xi_{c}^{n } \biggr ) \biggr]\nonumber\\ & & \qquad= n!\mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq \{1 , \ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = n } b_{t , c}^{n}b_{s , c}^{n}\\ & & \qquad= \sum_{i_{1 } , \ldots , i_{n } = 1}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } b_{s , i_{j}}^{n } ) - \mathop{\sum_{i_{1 } , \ldots , i_{n } = 1 } } _ { \exists k , l \dvtx i_{k } = i_{l}}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } b_{s , i_{j}}^{n }
) \nonumber\\ & & \qquad= \mathbf{e } [ b^{h , n}_{t } b^{h , n}_{s } ] ^{n } - \mathop{\sum_{i_{1 } , \ldots , i_{n } = 1 } } _ { \exists k , l \dvtx i_{k } = i_{l}}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } b_{s , i_{j}}^{n } ) .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we have @xmath231^{n } + \mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{s})^2 ] ^{n } - 2\mathbf{e } [ b^{h , n}_{t } b^{h , n}_{s } ] ^{n}\nonumber\\ & & \qquad{}- \frac{1}{n!}\mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl ( ( b^{h , n}_{t } ) ^{\diamond_{n } n } - ( b^{h , n}_{s } ) ^{\diamond_{n } n } \bigr)^2 \bigr]\nonumber\\[-8pt]\\[-8pt ] & & \quad= \mathop{\sum_{i_{1 } , \ldots , i_{n } = 1 } } _ { \exists k , l \dvtx i_{k } = i_{l}}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \biggl ( \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } ) ^2 + \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{s , i_{j}}^{n } ) ^2 - 2\prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } b_{s , i_{j}}^{n } ) \biggr)\nonumber\\ & & \quad= \mathop{\sum_{i_{1 } , \ldots , i_{n } = 1 } } _ { \exists k , l \dvtx i_{k } = i_{l}}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \biggl(\prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } ) - \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{s , i_{j}}^{n } ) \biggr)^2 \geq 0.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , the left - hand side of the inequality in ( [ l2normestimateofthedifference ] ) follows . by proposition [ dasheiligewort ] , ( [ covarianceforbinaryramdomwalk ] ) and ( [ zurboundednessnorm ] ) in remark [ remarkonboundedness ] , as well as @xmath232
, we obtain @xmath233^{n-1 } n^{-(2 - 2h ) } \leq2c_{h}^{2}n^2 t^{2h ( n-1 ) } n^{-(2 - 2h ) } \rightarrow 0\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for @xmath66 . the representation of wick powers of @xmath184 by hermite polynomials , as in ( [ propwickpowersarehermitepolynomials ] ) , their orthonormality ( cf .
kuo @xcite , page 355 ) and the polarization identity collectively yield @xmath234 = n!\mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h}_{t } ) ( b^{h}_{s } ) ] ^{n}$ ] ( cf
. also @xcite , lemma 1.1.1 ) .
thus , we have , by ( [ estimatefornormconv ] ) , @xmath235 - \mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl ( ( b^{h}_{t } ) ^{\diamond n } - ( b^{h}_{s } ) ^{\diamond n } \bigr)^2 \bigr]\nonumber\\ & & \quad= n ! \bigl(\mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{t})^2 ] ^{n } - \mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h}_{t})^2 ] ^{n } + \mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{s})^2 ] ^{n } - \mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h}_{s})^2 ] ^{n } \nonumber\\ & & \qquad\hphantom{n ! \bigl ( } { } - 2\mathbf{e } [ b^{h , n}_{t } b^{h , n}_{s } ] ^{n } + 2 \mathbf{e } [ b^{h}_{t } b^{h}_{s } ] ^{n } \bigr ) \\ & & \qquad { } - n ! \mathop{\sum_{i_{1 } , \ldots , i_{n } = 1 } } _ { \exists k , l \dvtx i_{k } = i_{l}}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \biggl(\prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{t , i_{j}}^{n } ) - \prod_{j = 1}^{n } ( b_{s , i_{j}}^{n } ) \biggr)^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying the convergences ( [ restefornorm ] ) and ( [ nieminenconvergencefornorms ] ) yields @xmath236 - \mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl ( ( b^{h}_{t } ) ^{\diamond n } - ( b^{h}_{s } ) ^{\diamond n } \bigr)^2 \bigr ] \rightarrow 0.\ ] ] [ remarkonnormofwickpowers ] in particular , we obtain , by ( [ zurnormestimate ] ) , ( [ zurboundednessnorm ] ) and @xmath232 , @xmath237 \nonumber\\[-8pt]\\[-8pt ] & \leq & \frac{1}{n!}\mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{t } ) ^2 ] ^{n } \leq\frac { 1}{n ! } \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h n } \leq\frac{1}{n ! } t^{2h n}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the next proposition estimates the difference between the approximating sequences in theorems [ dattheo1 ] and [ extendedmaintheorem ] . [ propzumdiffconvrate ] under the assumptions of theorem [ dattheo1 ] , there exists a constant @xmath238 such that for all @xmath213 $ ] , @xmath239 and @xmath240 , @xmath241 \leq k n^{1 - 2h}\ ] ] for the approximating processes in theorems [ dattheo1 ] and [ extendedmaintheorem ] .
recall that @xmath242 . by ( [ zurboundednessnorm ] ) in remark [ remarkonboundedness ]
, we obtain @xmath243 thus , we have @xmath244 for all @xmath245 . hence , we obtain , as the sum in ( [ x_teleskopsumme ] ) telescopes , for @xmath246 , @xmath247 by ( [ walshforthedifference ] ) , ( [ anestimateforzidinger ] ) , ( [ boundedness_norm ] ) and since @xmath248 , we obtain , for @xmath249 , @xmath250\\ & & \quad\leq \mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\}}}_{|c| = k } \biggl ( n^{-h } ( k-1 ) \mathop{\sum_{c ' \subset c } } _ { |c'| = |c|-1 } b_{t , c'}^{n } \biggr)^2\\ & & \quad\leq n^{-2h } ( k-1)^2 \mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = k } ( k-1 ) \mathop{\sum_{c ' \subset c } } _ { |c'| = & & \quad\leq n^{-2h } ( k-1)^3 \bigl ( \lfloor nt \rfloor-(k-1 ) \bigr ) \mathop{\sum_{c ' \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c'| = k-1 } ( b_{t , c'}^{n } ) ^2 \leq\frac{(k-1)^3}{(k-1)!}t^{2h ( k-1 ) } n^{1 - 2h}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath251 in theorems [ dattheo1 ] and [ extendedmaintheorem ] , and @xmath252 are zero for @xmath253 and orthogonal for different @xmath198 by proposition [ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] and ( [ l2norminwalshterms ] ) , we get @xmath254\\ & & \quad= \sum_{k = 2}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } \mathbf{e } \biggl [ \biggl|\frac{a_{n , k}}{k ! } \bigl ( ( b_{t}^{h , n } ) ^{\diamond_{n } k } - \widetilde{u}^{k , n}_{t } \bigr ) \biggr|^2 \biggr ] \leq \biggl(\sum_{k = 2}^{\infty } c^{2k } \frac{(k-1)^3}{(k-1 ) ! } t^{2h(k-1 ) } \biggr ) n^{1 - 2h}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as the series on the right - hand side converges uniformly in @xmath255 $ ] , the assertion follows .
we first prove that theorems [ dattheo1 ] and [ extendedmaintheorem ] hold with weak convergence replaced by convergence of the finite - dimensional distributions . to this end , we first approximate the wick powers of @xmath184 by induction .
we then combine these convergence results to approximate the wick analytic functionals @xmath256 .
finally , we conclude that convergence in finite dimensions holds in theorem [ extendedmaintheorem ] .
we observed in section [ wickexpsection ] that @xmath257 and that the hermite recursion formula @xmath258 ) .
[ lemma_hermite ] for all @xmath259 and @xmath213 $ ] , @xmath260 ( b^{h , n}_{t})^{\diamond_{n } ( n-1 ) } + r(b^{h , n}_{t},n),\ ] ] with remainder @xmath261 and @xmath262 \leq16 c_{h}^{4 } n!n^3 n^{-(4 - 4h)}.\ ] ] in particular , we will use the fact that the discrete hermite recursion ( [ hermite_discrete ] ) converges weakly to hermite recursion ( [ hermiterekursionfbb ] ) for @xmath66 . by proposition [ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] , we get @xmath263\\[-8pt ] & = & b^{h , n}_{t } ( b^{h , n}_{t})^{\diamond_{n } n } - \mathop{\sum_{a \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |a| = n } \sum_{i \in a } n ! b_{t , i}^{n } b_{t , a}^{n } \xi^{n}_{a}\xi^{n}_{i}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the second term in the last line in equation ( [ hermite_reste ] ) , by ( [ covarianceforbinaryramdomwalk ] ) in remark [ remarkonboundedness ] and proposition [ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] , we obtain @xmath264 - n !
\mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { which yields ( [ hermite_discrete ] ) and ( [ r_rest ] ) .
thus , thanks to proposition [ dasheiligewort ] , remark [ remarkonnormofwickpowers ] and @xmath217 , we obtain @xmath265 & = & ( n!)^2 \mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = n-1 } ( b_{t , c}^{n})^2 \biggl(\sum_{i \in c } ( b_{t , i}^{n } ) ^2 \biggr)^2\\ & \leq & ( n!)^2 \frac{1}{(n-1)!}t^{2h ( n-1 ) } \bigl((n-1)4c_{h}^2 n^{-(2 - 2h ) } \bigr)^2\\ & \leq&16c_{h}^{4 } n !
n^3 n^{-(4 - 4h)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ dastheoallewickschwach ] for all @xmath225 , @xmath266 the proof proceeds by induction on @xmath267 . by sottinen s approximation , @xmath268 .
suppose that equation ( [ wickpowerfd ] ) is proved for some @xmath269 .
assume that @xmath131 and @xmath270 for @xmath271 , @xmath272 and @xmath273 $ ] are chosen arbitrarily . by the pointwise convergence @xmath274 \rightarrow|t|^{2h}$ ] and the generalized continuous mapping theorem ( billingsley @xcite , theorem 5.5 )
, the induction hypothesis implies that @xmath275 ( b^{h , n}_{t_{j}})^{\diamond_{n } ( n-1 ) } \bigr)\\ & & \quad\stackrel{d}{\longrightarrow } \sum_{l = 0}^{n } \biggl(\sum_{j = 1}^{k } r^{l}_{j}(b_{t_{j}}^{h})^{\diamond
l } \biggr ) + \sum_{j = 1}^{k } r^{n+1}_{j } \bigl(b^{h}_{t_{j } } ( b_{t_{j}}^{h})^{\diamond n } - n since @xmath15 , ( [ restinl2 ] ) yields @xmath276 in @xmath277 .
thus , by slutsky s theorem @xcite , theorem 4.1 , and the hermite recursions ( [ hermiterekursionfbb ] ) and ( [ hermite_discrete ] ) , we obtain @xmath278 by the cramr wold device ( billingsley @xcite , theorem 7.7 ) , we have @xmath279 and the induction is complete .
[ fdmaintheorem ] in the context of theorem [ dattheo1 ] , convergence holds in finite - dimensional distributions . by billingsley @xcite ,
theorem 4.2 , it suffices to show that the following three conditions hold : @xmath280,\qquad \lim_{m \rightarrow\infty } \limsup_{n \rightarrow \infty } \mathbf{e } \biggl[\biggl|\sum_{k = 0}^{n}\frac{a_{n , k}}{k ! } ( b_{t}^{h , n } ) ^{\diamond_{n } k } - \sum_{k = 0}^{m } \frac { a_{n , k}}{k!}(b^{h , n}_{t})^{\diamond_{n } k}\biggr| \wedge1 \biggr ] = 0;&\qquad \\ \label{geomwconvstraffganz3 } & \displaystyle\sum_{k = 0}^{m } \frac{a_{k}}{k ! } ( b^{h}_{t})^{\diamond k } \stackrel { fd}{\longrightarrow } \sum_{k = 0}^{\infty } \frac{a_{k}}{k ! } ( b^{h}_{t})^{\diamond k } \qquad\mbox{as } m \rightarrow\infty.&\end{aligned}\ ] ] condition ( [ geomwconvstraffganz1 ] ) follows directly from theorem [ dastheoallewickschwach ] and the generalized continuous mapping theorem ( @xcite , theorem 5.5 ) . for the second condition
, we compute @xmath281 \\ & & \quad= \mathbf{e } \biggl [ \biggl(\sum _ { k = m+1}^{n } \frac{a_{n , k}}{k!}(b_{t}^{h , n})^{\diamond_{n } k } \biggr)^{2 } \biggr]\\ & & \quad= \sum_{k = m+1}^{n } \biggl(\frac{a_{n , k}}{k ! } \biggr)^2 \mathbf{e } [ ( ( b_{t}^{h , n})^{\diamond_{n } k } ) ^{2 } ] \leq \sum_{k = m+1}^{n } \biggl(\frac { c^{k}}{k ! } \biggr)^2 k !
t^{2hk},\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying the estimate of remark [ remarkonnormofwickpowers ] . here , we used the fact that discrete wick powers of different orders are orthogonal .
thus , we even obtain @xmath282 and , for all @xmath213 $ ] , a stronger result than condition ( [ geomwconvstraffganz2 ] ) , @xmath283 = 0.\ ] ] by the orthogonality of the different wick powers , we have @xmath284 = \sum_{k = m+1}^{\infty } \biggl(\frac{a_{k}}{k ! } \biggr)^2 \mathbf{e } [ ( ( b^{h}_{t})^{\diamond k } ) ^2 ] \leq \sum_{k = m+1}^{\infty } \biggl(\frac{c^{2k}}{k ! } \biggr ) t^{2h k } \rightarrow0\ ] ] for @xmath285 , which implies that condition ( [ geomwconvstraffganz3 ] ) even holds in @xmath277 . in view of proposition
[ propzumdiffconvrate ] and slutsky s theorem , the previous proposition also implies the following .
[ fdvondiff ] in the context of theorem [ extendedmaintheorem ] , convergence holds in finite - dimensional distributions .
we now show the tightness of the sequences in theorems [ dattheo1 ] and [ extendedmaintheorem ] by the following criterion , which is a variant of theorem 15.6 in billingsley @xcite .
[ lemmabillsatz ] suppose that , for the random elements @xmath286 in the skorokhod space @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] and @xmath287 in @xmath288,\mathbb{r})$ ] , @xmath289 and for @xmath290 in
@xmath82 $ ] , @xmath291 \leq l \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h},\ ] ] where @xmath292 is a constant .
then @xmath286 converges weakly to @xmath293 in @xmath99,\mathbb{r})$ ] .
let @xmath39 in @xmath82 $ ] . by the cauchy
schwarz inequality , @xmath294\\ & & \quad\leq ( \mathbf{e } [ |y^{n}_{t } - y^{n}_{s } |^2 ] ) ^{1/2 } ( \mathbf{e } [ |y^{n}_{u } - y^{n}_{t } |^2 ] ) ^{1/2}\\ & & \quad\leq l \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{h } \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nu \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{h } \leq l \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nu \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor } { n } \biggr|^{2h}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath295 , we have , since @xmath296 and @xmath297 , @xmath298 and thus @xmath299 \leq l2^{2h } ( u - s ) ^{2h}.\ ] ] if @xmath300 , then we have either @xmath301 or @xmath302 and so the left - hand side in ( [ dieglstraffschwexp ] ) is zero .
thus , the inequality ( [ dieglstraffschwexp ] ) holds for all @xmath39 . by the convergence of the finite - dimensional distributions and @xcite , theorem 15.6
, we get the weak convergence of the processes . for the application of this criterion to the discrete wick powers , we need two lemmas .
[ dasskalardings ] let @xmath303 be a real inner product space and @xmath304 the corresponding norm on @xmath305 .
then , for all @xmath306 and @xmath259 , @xmath307 it holds that @xmath308\\ & = & \frac{1}{2^{n-1 } } ( \|x \|^{2 } + \|y \|^{2 } ) ^{n}\\ & & { } - \|x - y \|^{2}\frac{1}{2^{n-1 } } \sum_{k = 0}^{n-1 } \pmatrix{n\cr k } ( \|x \|^{2 } + \|y \|^2 ) ^{k } ( -1 ) ^{n - k-1 } \|x - y \|^{2(n - k-1)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , we get @xmath309 since @xmath310 , the first line on the right - hand side of ( [ indemtollenlemma2 ] ) can be treated as follows : @xmath311\\[-8pt ] % & & \quad= \frac{1}{2^{n-1 } } \sum_{k = 1}^{n-1 } \pmatrix{n\cr k } \biggl(\frac { \|x \|^{2n } + \|y \|^{2n}}{2 } - \|x \|^{2k } \|y \|^{2(n - k ) } \biggr).\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath312 , we now collect the corresponding summands in sum ( [ nochsonegleichung ] ) for @xmath313 .
we obtain , by the mean value theorem with @xmath314 } \bigl(\lambda\|x \| + ( 1-\lambda ) \|y \| \bigr ) = \max\ { \|x \| , \|y \| \}\ ] ] and since @xmath315 , @xmath316 analogously , we obtain , for @xmath317 , @xmath318 plugging these estimates into ( [ nochsonegleichung ] ) and recalling that @xmath319 , we obtain @xmath320 for the term in the second line on the right - hand side of ( [ indemtollenlemma2 ] ) , we observe that , by the triangle inequality , @xmath321 applying @xmath322 and ( [ dasistdaslemmaundach ] ) to ( [ indemtollenlemma2 ] ) , we have @xmath323 ( \|x \| + \|y \| ) ^{2(n-1 ) } \|x - y \|^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by a short calculation and induction , we obtain @xmath324 [ lemmazutight ] for all @xmath325 in @xmath82 $ ] , we have @xmath326 \leq 8^n \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}.\ ] ] for @xmath327 , the inequality is fulfilled by ( [ zurboundednessnorm ] ) in remark [ remarkonboundedness ] . for @xmath328 , we consider the cases @xmath329 and @xmath226 separately . for @xmath330 , we have @xmath331 . hence , proposition [ walshpropevoll ] and remark [ remarkonnormofwickpowers ] imply that @xmath326 = \frac{1}{n!}\mathbf{e } [ ( ( b^{h , n}_{t})^{\diamond_{n } n } ) ^2 ] \leq \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h n}.\ ] ] since @xmath332 , @xmath333 and @xmath334 , we obtain @xmath335 since @xmath336 for @xmath332 and @xmath337 , we obtain @xmath326 \leq3^n \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor } { n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}\ ] ] for all @xmath338 . recall that , by proposition [ walshpropevoll ] , for @xmath339 , @xmath340 \\ & & \quad\leq\mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{t})^2 ] ^{n } + \mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{s})^2 ] ^{n } - 2\mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{t})(b^{h , n}_{s } ) ] ^{n}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath53 , we can rewrite @xmath341 = \sum_{i = 1}^{n } b_{t , i}^{n}b_{s , i}^{n}\ ] ] as an ordinary inner product on @xmath342 of the vectors @xmath343 and @xmath344 .
thus , the application of lemma [ dasskalardings ] with @xmath345 $ ] gives @xmath340\\ & & \quad\leq 2^{n+1 } \bigl(\mathbf{e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{t})^2 ] ^{1/2 } + \mathbf { e } [ ( b^{h , n}_{s})^2 ] ^{1/2 } \bigr)^{2(n-1 ) } \mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl((b^{h , n}_{t } ) - ( b^{h , n}_{s } ) \bigr)^2 \bigr]\\ & & \quad\leq 2^{n+1 } 2^{2(n-1 ) } \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h } \leq8^n \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath346 , then the left - hand side of the assertion vanishes .
the proofs for a fractional brownian motion on some interval @xmath83 \subset\mathbb{r}$ ] follow by a straightforward modification .
as @xmath347 \leq t^{2h}$ ] for @xmath348 $ ] and @xmath349 we obtain the previous lemma for @xmath350 in @xmath83 $ ] as @xmath326 \leq ( 8 t^{2h } ) ^n \biggl|\frac
{ \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}.\ ] ] we are now able to prove the weak convergence to the wick analytic functionals of a fractional brownian motion . proof of theorem [ dattheo1 ] we apply theorem [ lemmabillsatz ] .
the convergence of finite - dimensional distributions was shown in proposition [ fdmaintheorem ] .
let @xmath351 in @xmath82 $ ] .
recall @xmath251 .
then , by the orthogonality of @xmath352 for different @xmath198 and lemma [ lemmazutight ] , we have @xmath353\\ & & \quad= \sum_{k=0}^{n } \biggl(\frac{a_{n , k}}{k ! } \biggr)^2 \mathbf{e } \bigl [ \bigl((b^{h , n}_{t})^{\diamond_{n } k } - ( b^{h , n}_{s})^{\diamond_{n } k } \bigr)^2 \bigr ] \leq\sum_{k=0}^{n } \frac{c^{2k}}{k ! } 8^{k } \biggl| \frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor } { n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath354 , we have @xmath355 \leq l \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}.\ ] ] the alternative approximation , stated in theorem [ extendedmaintheorem ] , follows similarly , as we shall now see . proof of theorem [ extendedmaintheorem ]
let @xmath351 in @xmath82 $ ] . recall that @xmath356 only if @xmath357 .
thus , by proposition [ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] , we can write @xmath358 observe that , by the telescoping sum in ( [ x_teleskopsumme ] ) , we have @xmath359 thus , due to the orthogonality of @xmath360 for different values of @xmath198 , proposition [ theowalshdiscretewickpowers ] and estimate ( [ tightwickexp ] ) , we obtain @xmath361\\ & & \quad= \sum_{k = 0}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } a_{n , k}^2 \mathop{\sum_{c \subseteq\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = k } \biggl(\mathop{\mathop{\sum _ { m : c \rightarrow\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { \mathrm{injective}}}_{\exists u : m(u ) > \lfloor ns \rfloor } \prod_{l \in c } d_{m(l),l}^n \biggr)^2\\ & & \quad\leq\sum_{k = 0}^ { \lfloor nt \rfloor } a_{n , k}^2 \mathop{\sum_{c \subset\{1,\ldots , \lfloor nt \rfloor\ } } } _ { |c| = k } ( b_{t , c}^{n } - b_{s , c}^{n } ) ^2 \leq l \biggl|\frac { \lfloor nt \rfloor}{n } - \frac { \lfloor ns \rfloor}{n } \biggr|^{2h}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the result follows from proposition [ fdvondiff ] and theorem [ lemmabillsatz ] .
the authors thank jens - peter krei for interesting discussions . | we approximate the solution of some linear systems of sdes driven by a fractional brownian motion @xmath0 with hurst parameter @xmath1 in the wick
it sense , including a geometric fractional brownian motion . to this end
, we apply a donsker - type approximation of the fractional brownian motion by disturbed binary random walks due to sottinen .
moreover , we replace the rather complicated wick products by their discrete counterpart , acting on the binary variables , in the corresponding systems of wick difference equations .
as the solutions of the sdes admit series representations in terms of wick powers , a key to the proof of our euler scheme is an approximation of the hermite recursion formula for the wick powers of @xmath0 . |
irc+10216 (= cw leo ) is a dusty , embedded carbon - rich long period variable presently undergoing an episode of intense mass - loss up to @xmath1m@xmath2/yr @xcite .
it is the nearest object of its type ( 110 - 135pc ; * ? ? ?
* ) and brightest in the thermal - ir , and is generally believed to be in transition between the latest stellar and the earliest planetary nebula phases
. this fortuitous combination of factors has led to intensive study across the spectrum resulting in an extensive and rich literature , making irc+10216 the textbook example for objects in its class .
although studies of molecular lines ( eg . * ? ? ?
* ) and deep imaging in scattered galactic light @xcite reveal the outer parts of the mass - loss nebula to contain a series of spherical shells , the innermost regions show a bipolar structure @xcite . as the physical processes driving the transition from spherical to bipolar symmetry
are not well understood , there has been much interest in imaging and modeling this system at the finest scales as a prototype addressing one of the outstanding problems in the latest stages of the stellar life cycle . the ability to recover diffraction - limited images in the infrared with a large - aperture telescope
has delivered a detailed picture of the central regions of irc+10216 @xcite .
the bright core is shown to be highly clumpy and inhomogeneous , and with studies now spanning some years , evolution of the material with apparent brightening , fading , and proper motion makes for considerable complexity in the immediate circumstellar environment . here
we present the highest angular resolution images yet made , spanning the near infrared _ h , k , _ and _ l _ bands .
using the techniques of aperture masking interferometry , images of irc+10216 at a range of near - ir wavelengths were obtained from data taken at the 10 m keck i telescope .
these observations formed a somewhat distinct component of a program which also comprised the 7-epoch _ k _ band imaging study presented in paper i. this paper is concerned with an intensive study of irc+10216 made over only two observing runs in 1997 december and 1998 april , during which images were made in 5 separate near - infrared wavebands .
the bandpasses of the filters used are given in table [ tbl - filters ] while an observing log showing the dates , aperture masks and filters can be found in table [ tbl - log ] .
lcc & 1.657 & 0.333 + kcont & 2.260 & 0.053 + ch4 & 2.269 & 0.155 + pahcs & 3.083 & 0.101 + pah & 3.310 & 0.063 + cllll 2 & 1997 dec 16 & annulus & h , kcont & 1.23 + 2 & 1997 dec 16 & golay21 & kcont , ch4,pahcs & 1.23 + 2 & 1997 dec 18 & golay21 & kcont , pahcs , pah & 1.23 + 3 & 1998 apr 14 & golay21 & ch4,pahcs & 1.41 + 3 & 1998 apr 15 & annulus & h , ch4,pahcs , pah & 1.41 + in contrast to paper
i which was concerned with changes of the morphology of the dust shell between the separate epochs , here we have averaged together data taken over two separate runs .
this was done to enhance the signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratio of some of the maps , and to compensate for the fact that there was no single observing epoch which yielded high quality maps at all the observing wavelengths of interest .
although the two epochs chosen were only 4 months apart , measurable changes in the relative locations of components in the inner dust shell were shown to occur in paper i. however , the fastest moving component would be displaced only @xmath38.5mas in this interval ( see paper i ) averaging together maps with such small shifts should produce no great bias in the results . the golay and annulus aperture geometries from table [ tbl - log ] are described in detail in @xcite , which contains a thorough description of the experimental methods . although the two masks employed did differ in performance for the various levels of source flux and seeing conditions encountered , comparisons proved that there were no systematic differences in the final maps produced allowing them to be averaged together by observing wavelength alone .
as absolute positional information is not recovered from our closure - phase based techniques , maps to be averaged were registered with respect to each other by maximizing the cross - correlation before being summed .
this section presents the major observational findings of this paper .
diffraction - limited image reconstructions , visibility curves and additional supporting data are presented and discussed .
reconstructed images of irc+10216 from data taken in 1997 december through two different filters , kcont and ch4 , are given in figure [ 2kmaps ] . as is apparent from table [ tbl - filters ] , the kcont and ch4 filters have similar central passbands , but their bandwidths differ by a factor of 3 .
the two images of figure [ 2kmaps ] do , however , exhibit a high degree of similarity to each other , with no significant departures beyond those to be expected at the lowest contours near the level of the noise .
this is not surprising given that the emission process concerned is thermal radiation from warm dust which exhibits a fairly featureless spectrum across the near - infrared .
the findings from this comparison , and other maps presented later in the paper , confirm that rapid changes in morphology with wavelength were not seen .
images such as those of figure [ 2kmaps ] also present a useful yardstick for measuring the fidelity of the image reconstructions .
the level of agreement shown is typical for maps taken with different aperture masks and on different nights with varying seeing conditions .
such external consistency checks have allowed us to determine that structures above a certain level , in this case about 3% of the peak , are very well established experimentally . a qualitative model of the appearance of the dust shell around irc+10216
was given in paper i. we repeat this description here , together with a ` cartoon sketch ' labeling the features given in figure [ cartoon ] , which also gives the `` a , b , c , d '' nomenclature of @xcite . the brightest feature in the maps of figure [ 2kmaps ] , appearing as a sharp spike at the map center , we denote as the core ( `` a '' ) . surrounding the core is a roughly elliptical region of emission elongated along a position angle of @xmath4 which we label as the southern component .
the shorter north arm starts from a location 100mas nw of the core , and extends approximately 150mas to the nnw ( `` c '' ) .
perpendicular to it runs the prominent north - east arm ( `` b '' ) , running over 200mas and forming the brightest structure outside the southern component . displaced 150mas from the core to the ne is a region containing multiple weaker features , labeled as the eastern complex . within this region ,
the brightest feature , which consists of a roughly circular patch somewhat less than 100mas across , has been tagged as cloud ec1 ( `` d '' ) . for further clarification of these assignments ,
see figure 2 of paper i. the different nomenclature employed compared to other workers is necessitated by the higher angular resolution , so that the simple blobs reported in earlier work are resolved into clumpy or filamentary structures here .
cartoon diagram of features identified in high resolution images of irc+10216 ( see also figure 2 from paper 1 ) . features discussed in the text are labelled and registered against the peak of the bright core of the southern component ( denoted by the symbol + above ) .
the `` a , b , c , d '' nomenclature of @xcite is also indicated .
, width=377 ] maps of irc+10216 spanning four near - infrared wavebands , representing a noise - weighted average of data collected over 1997 december and 1998 april are given in figure [ hkllmaps ] .
unfortunately , the s / n and image fidelity was never as high for maps outside the _ k _ band . for shorter wavelengths ,
a combination of lower intrinsic flux from the star together with the greater role played by the atmospheric seeing were probably to blame for this loss .
for the observations at wavelengths greater than 3@xmath5 m , the intrinsically lower system angular resolution probably contributed to enhanced difficulties with the mapping , although it is likely additional unidentified factors were also at play .
for these reasons , the contour levels in figure [ hkllmaps ] , chosen to be near or above the noise , are more conservative than for figure [ 2kmaps ] . despite this precaution
, it can be seen for the map at 3.310@xmath5 m ( pah filter ) resulting from an average of only two somewhat noisy maps , that the lowest contours do show the effects of noise . in examining maps for systematic differences as a function of observing wavelength ,
the reader is cautioned to bear in mind that the four images of figure [ hkllmaps ] all have different angular resolutions and noise levels .
maps follow a similar basic shape , with the dominant features such as the core , north and north - east arms , and ec1 being identifiable at all wavelengths .
however , it is apparent that changes in appearance do occur across the near - infrared . in order to visualize these changes , figure [ colormaps ] shows color maps produced by differencing the h - k and k - pahcs images . as might be expected in a source with such complexities of morphology where opacity , temperature and scattering all play varying roles
, interpreting such maps is not straightforward . of the bright high - snr features
, the core exhibits the bluest ( hottest ) spectrum in k - pahcs .
however , in the h - k map , this region exhibits a flat spectrum , neither relatively blue nor red , although the bluest feature in the map does lie quite nearby toward the dark lane . even more puzzling is the behavior of the north / north - east arm and ( to a lesser extent ) ec1 , which are among the reddest features in the h - k map , yet appear markedly blue in k - pahcs .
it is important to point out that among the many other physical properties which need to be modeled to understand these maps , there is also a strong molecular absorption feature due to @xmath6 and @xmath7 @xcite which coincides with the pahcs filter bandpass .
further discussion of the colors and sizes of features , particularly the core , is given later , however we prefer to do this based on simple models fit directly to the observed visibility data themselves .
this is because the reconstruction of an image from a set of visibilities and closure phases is a complex and nonlinear process , and can be subject to biases introduced by the deconvolution process . where possible , quantitative interpretation of the data is often best achieved by fitting to the measurements rather than proceeding by the intermediate step of a reconstructed image .
simple quantitative brightness models were fit directly to the calibrated visibilities .
figure [ viscurves ] presents azimuthally averaged visibility data for irc+10216 at four near - infrared wavelengths . at all wavelengths ,
the visibility curves exhibit a common basic form .
a rapid drop from high visibilities at the origin occurs over a spatial frequency range 0.5@xmath8rad@xmath9 , denoting that most of the flux comes from well - resolved large scale structure .
this component has been modeled by fitting a circular gaussian disk to the visibility data , the results of which are shown in figure [ viscurves ] .
intermediate spatial frequencies ( 0.5@xmath8 2.0@xmath8rad@xmath9 ) carry much of the signal which results in the asymmetric form of the maps . owing to this known complexity , no attempts were made to fit to azimuthally averaged visibilities on these intermediate baselines . at high angular resolutions ( 2.0@xmath8rad@xmath9 ) visibilities for all wavelengths
appear to follow a simple functional form corresponding to a partially resolved , circularly symmetric , compact component .
a uniform disk model has been fit to these data , and best fits are overplotted on the figure .
we proceed by identifying the uniform disk component fit to the long baselines as due to the core .
however , this identification requires careful argument and justification .
the idea that the core is responsible for the highest spatial frequency structure is to an extent confirmed by the appearance of the recovered images , which show this to be by far the dominant compact feature .
furthermore , based on the physical assumption that the core may indeed be the star , it is not unreasonable to expect that it is able to dominate the high - angular - frequency spectrum over flux coming from extended dust , which is less likely to have sharp structure on fine scales . in this case , mapping confirms the assumption to be reasonable , however there may be some non - core contamination of visibilities at intermediate baselines , a difficulty which only higher angular resolution can cure .
a second important caveat concerns the high - resolution asymmetry noted to be associated with the core @xcite , which could cause difficulties in fitting to azimuthally averaged data ( which assumes circular symmetry ) .
the elongation was not as great at these epochs as it later became @xcite , and tests were performed where data were grouped in sectors according to the orientation of the baseline .
the spread of values found for these core diameter fits was incorporated into the error term for the final diameters given in figure [ viscurves ] .
the purported location of the stellar photosphere within the irc+10216 nebula has been discussed in various studies starting with @xcite .
however , the complexities of the dust shell , and the absence of an unambiguously distinct bright compact component have caused continuing uncertainty over identifying which , if any , feature corresponds to the star itself .
this has led to fundamental uncertainties over the structure of the dust shell , and determining the location of the star is essential to further progress . in paper
i we argued that the core of the southern component ( `` a '' ) consisted of emission from the stellar photosphere with the possible addition of some flux from hot dust on the inner wall of a cavity or torus , tilted into the line of sight in the south . while this bright core , with an angular diameter of 50mas , was the prime candidate to be the stellar photosphere , the possibility that the star itself lay completely obscured behind the central dark dust lane was also advanced .
@xcite suggested an alternate interpretation , that the star itself lies within the bright knot at the end of the ne arm ( component `` b '' ) .
evidence supporting this view came from color maps , from observations of changes in shape of the core , and particularly from attempts to trace the point of origin of the polarization field .
an ambitious series of papers built on this interpretation , including detailed radiative transfer modeling @xcite and the results of a further observational campaign @xcite .
detailed models interpreting the southern component as a cavity in a bipolar structure ( `` a '' ) with the star at the location of the north - east arm ( `` b '' ) were produced which gave reasonable fits to both the spectral energy distribution and the high resolution imaging .
however these models were quite complex , incorporating @xmath1020 free parameters describing many different shells of varying symmetry and density profile .
based on this analysis , the authors rule out the possibility that the star can either be at the southern core , or that it was completely hidden behind the dust @xcite . despite this , there remain a number of simple arguments against the view that the star is located in the north - east arm . at the higher resolutions afforded by the keck imaging
, the north - east arm is seen to be a linear structure with almost uniform brightness along a ridge with no dominant compact knot .
furthermore , the north - east arm was found to be elongating and fading with time ( paper i ) , and in the most recent keck observations ( publication in preparation ) , almost absent entirely .
similar findings of the disappearance of the feature they previously identified as the star were explained by @xcite who invoke a recent and dramatic increase in mass - loss rate which has had the effect of burying it beneath a thickening dust shell .
however our higher angular resolution keck observations show that the north - east arm is actually lengthening and separating from the southern component , while it gradually fades out . the observed proper motion , with tentative acceleration detection @xcite ,
would not be expected from the identifications of @xcite of these two components as a part of the circumstellar torus and the stellar photosphere .
recent lunar occultation measurements @xcite have been able to shed some light on this question with extremely high angular resolutions ( 0.8mas ) attained in one - dimensional profiles .
the core of the southern component was found to be well fitted by a compact gaussian profile with fwhm 35mas contributing 6% of the total flux in _ k _ band .
the close agreement with the expected angular size of the photosphere for the star , as well as the finding of a component of similar size and position in the _ h _ band profile , led these authors to identify the southern core ( `` a '' ) as the stellar disk , although not with sufficient confidence to rule out alternative hypotheses . by fitting only the longest baselines as shown in figure [ viscurves ]
, we were able to discriminate between the compact core and the well - resolved nebula , revealing a partially - resolved component giving measurable visibility signal at even the longest baselines .
for the four different bandpasses depicted ( 1.65 , 2.26 , 3.08 & 3.31@xmath5 m ) , uniform disk fits yielded diameters of 40 , 52 , 60 & 65mas with relative flux contributions of 10 , 10 , 7 & 6% of the total respectively .
our _ k _ band uniform disk diameter of 52mas is in close agreement with the lunar occultation measurements of @xcite whose 35mas fwhm gaussian model would correspond , in the partially resolved case here , to a uniform disk diameter of 56mas . the observed variation in angular diameter with wavelength across the near - ir is not necessarily strong evidence that the feature is a dust clump . to the contrary , it has become apparent that opacity changes due to various molecular and atomic species in the atmospheres of evolved stars lead to precisely such large apparent diameter variations , at least for m - stars @xcite .
we turn now to examination of the apparent color of the compact core . from the uniform disk fits above , the same relative contribution from the core was found in _
h _ and _ k _ band ( both 10% ) , but significantly less at the longer wavelengths ( 7 & 6% at 3.08 & 3.31@xmath5 m respectively ) .
this finding is in good accord with the color maps presented in figure [ colormaps ] which found the core to be neutral in h - k and blue in k - pahcs .
if the core is indeed the star , the simplest expectation is that the hottest effective temperature component of the system should present the bluest colors .
the evidence here is somewhat equivocal : the core is blue in k - pahcs , and adjacent to the bluest part of the h - k map , but clearly there are more complicated effects going on . to understand the color maps further
, the complexities of scattering and reddening in an inhomogeneous environment must be more carefully modeled .
lastly , we subject the hypothesis that component `` a '' is the stellar photosphere to a final quantitative test . assuming the _ k _ band 52 mas core is the stellar size , and if we adopt a reasonable effective temperature of 2000 k , the unreddened stellar flux density can be calculated
. this flux density can be reddened by amorphous carbon dust @xcite , and the resulting sed compared to the photometry of component `` a '' derived from the keck aperture masking frames ( calibrated using the contemporaneous interferometric calibrator and the visibility decomposition from figure [ viscurves ] ) .
figure [ coresed ] shows the results of reddening the stellar spectrum with mrn dust @xcite using the standard dust size range ( 0.005@xmath5m@[email protected]@xmath5 m ) , as calculated using dusty code @xcite .
the _ k _ band flux density of `` a '' is well - fitted using @xmath12 , although the reddened spectrum is too red to fit the _ h _ band and l - band core photometry . by including somewhat larger grains ( 0.005@xmath5m@[email protected]@xmath5 m ) , all the near - ir photometry of `` a '' is well - fitted ( also , @xmath12 ) .
this result is not sensitive to the adopted stellar effective temperature .
this simple test does not prove that component `` a '' is the star , however the hypothesis does gain credence .
furthermore , our results that @xmath0 and the finding that the photosphere contributes 10% of _ k _ band emission is remarkably close to the estimate of @xcite who found @xmath13 from sed modeling and a photospheric contribution @xmath312% confirmed by dilution of first - overtone co absorption lines .
lastly , this line - of - sight dust absorption is consistent ( within factor of two ) with the mid - infrared _ emission _ modeled by @xcite , based on fits to the mid - ir spectrum and long - baseline interferometer ( isi ) visibility data .
although these arguments can certainly place the idea that component `` a '' is the star in a favorable light with respect to the known properties of the system , they can not be turned around to rule out the alternate hypothesis that it is a dust clump .
the observed color temperature , given a number of plausible opacity and scattering geometries , could certainly fit with cool circumstellar material .
indeed , the finding that the core is non - circular would seem to imply that at least some of the light arises from asymmetric circumstellar material , and/or that there are strong opacity gradients in the line of sight to the star . in conclusion
, although complicated models in which the star is obscured and eventually buried in the northern regions can not be ruled out , the simple alternate hypothesis that core component `` a '' is highly - reddened , direct photospheric light can naturally explain the observed properties of the compact core including : a ) its angular size , b ) its _ k _ band flux density , c ) its color temperature , d ) its persistence over multiple epochs , e ) the observed dilution of near - ir photospheric absorption lines , f ) the general level of mid - infrared emission , and g ) the magnitude of proper motion between the core and north - east arm ( `` a '' and `` b '' ) .
we encourage detailed radiative transfer modeling constrained by the latest multi - wavelength imaging to explore the physical structure of this fascinating source .
devinder sivia kindly provided the maximum entropy mapping program `` vlbmem '' , which we have used to reconstruct our diffraction limited images .
this work has been supported by grants from the national science foundation and the australian research council .
the data presented herein were obtained at the w.m .
keck observatory , which is operated as a scientific partnership among the california institute of technology , the university of california and the national aeronautics and space administration .
the observatory was made possible by the generous financial support of the w.m .
keck foundation . | high angular resolution images of irc+10216 taken at various bandpasses within the near - infrared _ h , k _ & _ l _ bands are presented .
the maps have the highest angular resolution yet recovered , and were reconstructed from interferometric measurements obtained at the keck 1 telescope in 1997 december and 1998 april , forming a subset of a 7-epoch monitoring program presented earlier ( * ? ? ?
* paper 1 ) .
systematic changes with observing wavelength are found and discussed in context of present geometrical models for the circumstellar envelope . with these new high - resolution , multi - wavelength data and contemporaneous photometry
, we also re - visit the hypothesis that the bright compact core of the nebula ( component `` a '' ) marks the location of the central carbon star .
we find that directly measured properties of the core ( angular size , flux density , color temperature ) are consistent with a reddened carbon star photosphere ( line - of - sight @xmath0 ) . |
castelnuovo - mumford regularity ( or just the regularity ) is something of a two - way study in the sense that it is a fundamental invariant both in commutative algebra and discrete geometry .
the regularity is a kind of universal bound for measuring the complexity of a considered object ( a module , a sheaf or a simplicial complex ) .
our interest here is to compute or provide better bounds for the regularity of rings associated to graphs .
we are primarily concerned on the computation of the regularity of the edge ring ( or equivalently the stanley - reisner ring of the independence complex ) of a given graph . one way to attack such a problem goes by translating the underlying algebraic or topological language to that of graph s .
such an approach may enable us to bound the regularity of a graph via other graph parameters , and the most likely candidate is the induced matching number . by a theorem of katzman @xcite , it is already known that the induced matching number provides a lower bound for the regularity of a graph , and the characterization of graphs in which the regularity equals to the induced matching number has been the subject of many recent papers @xcite . during his search on the complexity of the induced matching number , lozin @xcite describes an operation ( he calls it as the _ stretching operation _ ) on graphs , and he proves that when it is applied to a graph , the induced matching number increases exactly by one .
his operation works simply by considering a vertex @xmath0 of a graph @xmath1 whose ( open ) neighborhood splitted into two disjoint parts @xmath2 , and replacing the vertex @xmath0 with a four - path on @xmath3 together with edges @xmath4 for any @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( see section [ section : reg - lozin ] ) .
one of the interesting results of his work is that the induced matching problem remains @xmath7-hard in a narrow subclass of bipartite graphs .
we here prove that his operation has a similar effect on the regularity : [ thm : lozin+reg ] let @xmath8 be a graph and let @xmath9 be given .
then @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the lozin s transform of @xmath1 with respect to the vertex @xmath0 .
theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] implies that the computational complexity of the regularity of arbitrary graphs is equivalent to that of bipartite graphs having sufficiently large girth with maximum degree three .
one of the main advantages of theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] is that we are able to prove that the regularity of any graph can be bounded above by a function of its induced matching number .
moreover , we also show that the regularity of a graph is always less than or equal to the sum of its induced matching and decycling numbers .
we further employ the language of graph coloring theory by introducing a gallai type graph @xcite associated to any given graph in order to describe a new class of graphs in which the regularity equals to the induced matching number .
the organization of the paper is as follows . in section @xmath12
, we fix our notations needed throughout , recall definitions and basic properties of the regularity of simplicial complexes and graphs .
the section @xmath13 is devoted to the proof of theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] , where we also analyze the topological effect of lozin s transformation on the independence complexes of graphs . in the final section ,
we provide various bounds on the regularity as promised .
let @xmath14 be a simplicial complex on the vertex set @xmath15 , and let @xmath16 be any field . then the _ castelnuovo - mumford regularity _ ( or just the _ regularity _ ) @xmath17 of @xmath14 over @xmath16 is defined by @xmath18;{\bbbk})\neq 0\;\textrm{for\;some}\;s\subseteq v\},\ ] ] where @xmath19:=\{f\in { \delta}\colon f\subseteq s\}$ ] is the induced subcomplex of @xmath14 by @xmath20 , and @xmath21 denotes the ( reduced ) singular homology .
note that this definition of the regularity coincides with the algebraic one via the well - known hochster s formula .
some of the immediate consequences of the above definition are as follows .
firstly , the regularity is dependent on the characteristic of the coefficient field ( compare example @xmath22 of @xcite ) .
secondly , it is not a topological invariant , and it is monotone decreasing with respect to the induced subcomplex operation , that is , @xmath23)\leq { \textrm{reg}}_{{\bbbk}}({\delta})$ ] for any @xmath24 . in most cases ,
our results are independent of the choice of the coefficient field , so we drop @xmath16 from our notation . even if the regularity is not a topological invariant , the use of topological methods plays certain roles . in many cases
, we will appeal to an induction on the cardinality of the vertex set by a particular choice of a vertex accompanied by two subcomplexes . to be more explicit ,
if @xmath0 is a vertex of @xmath14 , then the subcomplexes @xmath25 and @xmath26 are called the _ deletion _ and _ link _ of @xmath0 in @xmath14 respectively .
such an association brings the use of a mayer - vietoris sequence of the pair @xmath27 : @xmath28 [ prop : induction - sc ] let @xmath14 be a simplicial complex and let @xmath9 be given .
then @xmath29 suppose that @xmath30 , and let @xmath31 be a subset for which @xmath32)\neq 0 $ ] . if @xmath33 , then @xmath34
so that @xmath35 , that is , @xmath36 . therefore , we may assume that @xmath37 .
we set @xmath38 $ ] , @xmath39 $ ] and @xmath40 $ ] , and consider the mayer - vietoris sequence of the pair @xmath41 : @xmath42 observe that @xmath43 and @xmath44 . now , if @xmath45 , then @xmath46 so that @xmath47 , since @xmath48 by our assumption .
thus , @xmath49 .
this proves the claim .
we next review some necessary terminology from graph theory . by a graph @xmath8
, we will mean an undirected graph without loops or multiple edges .
an edge between @xmath50 and @xmath51 is denoted by @xmath52 or @xmath53 interchangeably .
a graph @xmath8 is called an _ edgeless graph _ on @xmath15 whenever @xmath54 . if @xmath55 , the graph induced on @xmath56 is written @xmath57 $ ] , and in particular , we abbreviate @xmath58 $ ] to @xmath59 , and write @xmath60 whenever @xmath61 . in a similar vein , we denote by @xmath62 the graph on @xmath15 having the edge set @xmath63 whenever @xmath64 .
the _ complement _ @xmath65 of a graph @xmath8 is the graph on @xmath15 with @xmath66 if and only if @xmath67 . throughout @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70
will denote the complete , cycle and path graphs on @xmath71 vertices respectively . given two nonempty graphs @xmath72 and @xmath73 on disjoint sets , then their _ disjoint union _
@xmath74 is defined to be the graph @xmath75 . for a given subset @xmath76 ,
the ( open ) neighborhood of @xmath56 is defined by @xmath77 , where @xmath78 , and similarly , @xmath79:=n_g(u)\cup u$ ] is the closed neighborhood of @xmath56 .
furthermore , if @xmath80 is a subset of edges of @xmath1 , we write @xmath81 $ ] for the set @xmath82 $ ] , where @xmath83 is the set of vertices incident to edges in @xmath84 .
a subset @xmath85 is called an _
independent set _
whenever @xmath86 $ ] is an edgeless graph .
the set of all independent sets of @xmath1 forms a simplicial complex @xmath87 , the _ independence complex _ of @xmath1 .
the largest cardinality of an independent set in @xmath1 is called the _ independence number _ of @xmath1 and denoted by @xmath88 .
let @xmath1 be a graph .
regularity _ of @xmath1 is defined by @xmath89 . when considering the complex @xmath87 , the deletion and link of a given vertex @xmath0 correspond to the independence complexes of induced subgraphs , namely that @xmath90 and @xmath91)$ ] .
therefore , the following is an immediate consequence of proposition [ prop : induction - sc ] , which is also proven in algebraic setting in @xcite .
[ cor : induction - sc ] let @xmath1 be a graph and let @xmath92 be given
. then @xmath93)+1\}.\ ] ] we say that @xmath1 is @xmath94-free if no induced subgraph of @xmath1 is isomorphic to @xmath94 .
a graph @xmath1 is called _ chordal _ if it is @xmath95-free for any @xmath96 , and a graph is said to be _ cochordal _ if its complement is a chordal graph .
a subset @xmath97 is called a _
complete _ of @xmath1 if @xmath98 $ ] is isomorphic to a complete graph , and the largest cardinality of a complete of @xmath1 is called the _ clique number _ of @xmath1 and denoted by @xmath99 .
recall that a subset @xmath100 is called a _ matching _ of @xmath1 if no two edges in @xmath101 share a common end .
moreover , a matching @xmath101 of @xmath1 is an _ induced matching _ if it occurs as an induced subgraph of @xmath1 , and the cardinality of a maximum induced matching is called the _ induced matching number _ of @xmath1 and denoted by @xmath102 .
let @xmath1 be a graph , and @xmath103 be a family of graphs .
the @xmath103-_cover number _ of @xmath1 is the minimum number of subgraphs @xmath104 of @xmath1 such that every @xmath105 and @xmath106 . in particular , we denote by @xmath107 , the _ cochordal cover number _ of @xmath1 ( see @xcite ) .
[ thm : im - reg - cd ] the inequality @xmath108 holds for any graph @xmath1 .
both bounds are far from being tight even for connected graphs .
we have constructed in @xcite a connected graph @xmath109 for each @xmath110 such that @xmath111 ( see proposition 3.12 of @xcite ) . for
the lower bound , let @xmath112 be the graph obtained from @xmath113 disjoint five cycles by adding an extra vertex and connecting it to exactly one vertex of each five cycle ( see figure [ fig - reg - im-1 ] ) .
then the equality @xmath114 for any @xmath110 follows from corollary [ cor : induction - sc ] .
.,width=297,height=96 ] the graph @xmath112 is also interesting for one other reason that we explain next .
a vertex @xmath0 of @xmath1 is called a _ shedding vertex _ if for every independent set @xmath20 in @xmath115 $ ] , there is some vertex @xmath116 so that @xmath117 is independent . a graph @xmath1 is called _ vertex decomposable _ if either it is an edgeless graph or it has a shedding vertex @xmath0 such that @xmath60 and @xmath115 $ ] are both vertex - decomposable .
[ thm : vd - reg ] if @xmath1 is a @xmath118-free vertex decomposable graph , then @xmath119 .
the bounds of theorem [ thm : im - reg - cd ] can be tight if the graph lies in a specific graph class .
[ prop : chordal - reg ] if @xmath1 is a chordal graph , then @xmath120 .
the existence of vertices satisfying some extra properties is useful when dealing with the homotopy type of the independence complexes of graphs .
[ thm : hom - induction ] if @xmath121 , then there is a homotopy equivalence @xmath122 . on the other hand ,
if @xmath123\subseteq n_g[v]$ ] , then the homotopy equivalence @xmath124)$ ] holds , where @xmath125 denotes the ( unreduced ) suspension of @xmath126 .
an edge @xmath53 is called an _ isolating edge _ of @xmath1 with respect to a vertex @xmath127 , if @xmath127 is an isolated vertex of @xmath128 $ ] .
[ thm : isolating ] if @xmath129)$ ] is contractible , then the natural inclusion @xmath130 is a homotopy equivalence . in particular
, theorem [ thm : isolating ] implies that @xmath131 whenever the edge @xmath132 is isolating .
this brings the use of an operation , adding or removing an edge , on a graph without altering its homotopy type .
we will follow @xcite to write @xmath133 ( respectively @xmath134 ) to indicate that we add the edge @xmath135 to ( resp .
remove the edge @xmath135 from ) the graph @xmath1 , where @xmath127 is the corresponding isolated vertex .
this section is devoted to the proof of theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] .
we begin with recalling the definition of the lozin s transformation on graphs @xcite .
let @xmath8 be a graph and let @xmath9 be given .
lozin s transform _
@xmath11 of @xmath1 with respect to the vertex @xmath0 is defined as follows : * partition the neighborhood @xmath136 of the vertex @xmath0 into two subsets @xmath137 and @xmath138 in arbitrary way ; + * delete vertex @xmath0 from the graph together with incident edges ; + * add a @xmath139 to the rest of the graph ; + * connect vertex @xmath140 of the @xmath141 to each vertex in @xmath137 , and connect @xmath142 to each vertex in @xmath138 .
when the decomposition @xmath143 is of importance , we will write @xmath144 instead of @xmath11 .
it should be noted that we allow one of the sets @xmath137 and @xmath138 to be an empty set .
furthermore , if @xmath0 is an isolated vertex , the corresponding lozin s transform of @xmath1 with respect to the vertex @xmath0 is the graph @xmath145 . throughout
we will follow the convention made in @xcite to use special notations for some particular classes of graphs : + @xmath146 , the class of @xmath147-free graphs , + @xmath148 , the class of @xmath149-free graphs , + @xmath150 , the class of graphs with maximum degree @xmath13 , + @xmath151 , the class of bipartite graphs , + where the graph @xmath152 is depicted in figure [ fig - h ] .
.,width=240,height=76 ] lozin proves in @xcite that his transformation increases the induced matching number exactly by one .
[ lem : lozin - inmatch ] for any graph @xmath1 and any vertex @xmath153 , the equality @xmath154 holds .
furthermore , any graph can be transformed by a sequence of lozin transformations into a graph in class @xmath155 with any integer @xmath156 and @xmath157 .
we next prove that the lozin s transformation has a similar effect on the regularity . in order to simplify the notation
, we note that when we mention the homology or homotopy of a graph , we mean that of its independence complex , so whenever it is appropriate , we drop @xmath158 from our notation .
[ prop : reg+isolating ] let @xmath53 be an isolating edge of @xmath94 with respect to the vertex @xmath127 . if @xmath127 has a neighbor @xmath0 of degree two , then @xmath159 . without loss of generality
, we may assume that @xmath160 .
we let @xmath161 , and assume that @xmath162 . let @xmath163 be a subset satisfying @xmath164)\neq 0 $ ] . we suppose that @xmath20 is maximal in the sense that @xmath165)=0 $ ] for any @xmath166 .
if @xmath167 or @xmath168 , we clearly have @xmath169\cong g[s]$ ] .
thus , we may assume that @xmath170 . in this case ,
if @xmath171 , then @xmath169\simeq h[s]-e\cong g[s]$ ] , since @xmath132 is then an isolating edge of @xmath169 $ ] .
so , suppose that @xmath172 .
if @xmath173 , we conclude that @xmath169\simeq h[s]-v\cong g[s\backslash \{v\}]$ ] , where the homotopy equivalence is due to the inclusion @xmath174}(x)\subseteq n_{h[s]}(v)$ ] ( see theorem [ thm : hom - induction ] ) .
it follows that we may further assume @xmath175 .
we then define @xmath176 , and consider the mayer - vietoris sequence of the pair @xmath177,x)$ ] : @xmath178-n_{h[s^*]}[x])\to \widetilde{h}_{m-1}(h[s^*]-x)\to \widetilde{h}_{m-1}(h[s^ * ] ) \to \cdots.\ ] ] note that @xmath179)=0 $ ] by the maximality of @xmath20 .
moreover , since @xmath180-x\cong h[s]$ ] , we need to have @xmath179-x)\neq 0 $ ] .
therefore , we conclude that @xmath179-n_{h[s^*]}[x])\neq 0 $ ] .
but , @xmath180-n_{h[s^*]}[x]\cong h[s\backslash \{u\}]$ ] and @xmath181\cong g[s\backslash \{u\}]$ ] so that we have @xmath182)\neq 0 $ ] . as a result
, we deduce that @xmath183 .
assume now that @xmath184 , and let @xmath31 be a maximal subset satisfying @xmath185)\neq 0 $ ] .
similar to the previous cases , we may assume that @xmath186 and @xmath187 .
suppose first that @xmath37 .
then , @xmath188\simeq \sigma(g[w]-n_{g[w]}[u])$ ] , since @xmath0 has degree one in @xmath188 $ ] and @xmath50 is its only neighbor .
it follows that @xmath189-n_{g[w]}[u])\neq 0 $ ] .
we define @xmath190 . since @xmath132 is an isolating edge in @xmath191 $ ]
, we have @xmath191\simeq h[k]-e$ ]
. however , the vertex @xmath50 is of degree one in @xmath191-e$ ] and @xmath0 is its only neighbor ; hence , @xmath191-e\simeq \sigma((h[k]-e)-n_{h[k]-e}[x]))$ ] by theorem [ thm : hom - induction ] . on the other hand , we have @xmath192-e)-n_{h[k]-e}[x]\cong g[w]-n_{g[w]}[u]$ ] so that @xmath193)\neq 0 $ ] .
finally , suppose now that @xmath33 .
as in the previous case , we let @xmath194 , and consider the mayer - vietoris sequence of the pair @xmath195,x)$ ] : @xmath196-n_{g[w^*]}[x])\to \widetilde{h}_{n-1}(g[w^*]-x)\to \widetilde{h}_{n-1}(g[w^ * ] ) \to \cdots.\ ] ] again , we have @xmath197)=0 $ ] by the maximality of @xmath198 .
since @xmath199-x\cong g[w]$ ] , the group @xmath197-x)$ ] is nontrivial that implies @xmath197-n_{g[w^*]}[x])\neq 0 $ ] .
however , @xmath199-n_{g[w^*]}[x]\cong g[w\backslash \{u\}]$ ] and @xmath200\cong h[w\backslash \{u\}]$ ] so that we have @xmath201)\neq 0 $ ] . as a result
, we deduce that @xmath202 .
this completes the proof .
we next verify that the homotopy type of lozin s transform can be deduced from the source graph .
[ lem : lozin+stable ] let @xmath8 be a graph and let @xmath9 be given .
then @xmath203 for any two distinct decompositions @xmath204 and @xmath205 of @xmath136 .
to prove the claim , it is enough to verify that for a given decomposition @xmath143 and a vertex @xmath206 , the complexes @xmath207 and @xmath208 have the same homotopy type .
however , moving the vertex @xmath50 from @xmath138 to @xmath137 corresponds to the sequence of isolating operations @xmath209 and @xmath210 in @xmath144 ; therefore , the claim follows from theorem [ thm : isolating ] .
[ prop : lozin+stable ] let @xmath8 be a graph and let @xmath9 be given
. then @xmath211 . in view of lemma
[ lem : lozin+stable ] , it is sufficient to show that @xmath212 .
in such a case , we set @xmath213 and note that @xmath214 so that @xmath215 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath216 , while the latter graph is clearly isomorphic to @xmath217 , where @xmath218 is induced by the edge @xmath219 .
it then follows that @xmath220 as required .
[ lem : lozin+reg ] let @xmath8 be a graph and let @xmath9 be given .
then @xmath221 for any two distinct decompositions @xmath204 and @xmath205 of @xmath136 .
we proceed as in the proof of lemma [ lem : lozin+stable ] .
so , let a decomposition @xmath143 and a vertex @xmath206 be given .
we claim that @xmath222 .
if we set @xmath223 , then the edge @xmath224 is an isolating edge of @xmath94 with respect to the vertex @xmath225 , while @xmath225 has a neighbor @xmath226 of degree two .
therefore , proposition [ prop : reg+isolating ] applies , that is , @xmath227 .
on the other hand , @xmath228 is also an isolating edge in @xmath94 with respect to @xmath226 , and the vertex @xmath226 has a degree two neighbor , namely @xmath225 .
thus we have @xmath229 .
so the claim follows .
given a subset @xmath97 .
assume first that @xmath175 .
if we define @xmath230 , it follows that @xmath231\cong g[s]\cup k_2 $ ] , where @xmath218 is induced by the edge @xmath232 .
therefore , the complex @xmath233)$ ] is homotopy equivalent to the suspension of @xmath234)$ ] .
suppose now that @xmath173 .
in such a case , we consider @xmath235 , and write @xmath236 $ ] and @xmath237 $ ] .
note that the lozin s transform @xmath238 of @xmath94 with respect to the partition @xmath239 is exactly isomorphic to @xmath240 .
therefore , we have @xmath241 by proposition [ prop : lozin+stable ] , which implies that @xmath242 . for the converse , by lemma [ lem : lozin+reg ] , it is sufficient to show that @xmath243 .
so , set @xmath244 .
then we have @xmath245)+1\}.\ ] ] by corollary [ cor : induction - sc ] .
however , the graph @xmath246 is isomorphic to @xmath247 so that @xmath248 .
moreover , the graph @xmath249 $ ] is isomorphic to @xmath250 in which @xmath142 is an isolated vertex .
it means that @xmath251)={\textrm{reg}}(g - x)\leq { \textrm{reg}}(g)$ ] .
therefore , we conclude that @xmath252 as claimed .
a special case of lozin s transformation can be obtained by taking one of the sets in the partition of @xmath136 as a singleton . in other words , for a given @xmath253 , we consider the operation @xmath254 .
observe that the resulting graph can be obtained from @xmath1 by replacing the edge @xmath255 in @xmath1 by a path @xmath256 , which is called the _
triple subdivision _ of @xmath1 with respect to the edge @xmath255 . following theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ]
, we may readily describe the effect of a triple subdivision on regularity .
[ cor : lozin+edgesubdiv ] let @xmath1 be a graph and let @xmath53 be an edge . if @xmath257 is the graph obtained from @xmath1 by the triple subdivision of @xmath132 , then @xmath258 .
in this section , we provide various upper bounds on the regularity of graphs as an application of theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] .
we first recall that a @xmath259-(vertex ) coloring of a graph @xmath8 is a surjective mapping @xmath260 such that if @xmath261 , then @xmath262 , and the chromatic number @xmath263 of @xmath1 is the least integer @xmath264 for which @xmath1 admits a @xmath264-coloring .
moreover , a graph @xmath1 is called _ perfect _ if @xmath265)=\omega(g[a])$ ] for any @xmath266 . for a given graph @xmath1 with at least one edge
, we define a graph @xmath267 , whose vertices are the edges of @xmath1 , that is , @xmath268 , and if @xmath132 and @xmath269 are two edges in @xmath1 , then @xmath270 if and only if @xmath271\cong 2k_2 $ ] .
we remark that the graph @xmath267 constructed here is exactly the complement of that introduced in @xcite .
furthermore , the induced matching number of @xmath1 equals to the clique number of @xmath267 , i.e. , @xmath272 , and under suitable restrictions , we can say more : assume that @xmath275 , and let @xmath276 $ ] be a proper vertex coloring of @xmath267 .
we consider color classes @xmath277 and denote by @xmath278 , the subgraph of @xmath1 with @xmath279 for any @xmath280 $ ] .
we then claim that each @xmath278 is a cochordal subgraph of @xmath1 .
observe first that the graph @xmath278 can not contain @xmath281 for any @xmath282 , since @xmath1 is triangle - free .
moreover , if @xmath278 contains @xmath283 , then @xmath1 must contain a chord that in turn creates a triangle in @xmath1 which is not possible . on the other hand ,
since the set of edges of @xmath278 corresponds to a color class in @xmath267 , it is necessarily @xmath284-free .
therefore , the family @xmath285 is a cochordal edge cover of @xmath1 ; hence , @xmath286 .
suppose now that @xmath287 , and let @xmath288 be a cochordal edge covering family of @xmath1 .
we then define @xmath289 $ ] by @xmath290\colon e\in e(w_j)\}$ ] , and claim that @xmath291 is a proper coloring of @xmath267 . for this ,
if @xmath270 for some @xmath292 , there exists no @xmath293 $ ] for which @xmath294 , since @xmath295 is cochordal .
we therefore have @xmath296 .
this proves that @xmath297 . by theorem [ thm : chromatic - cochord ]
, we note that the inequality @xmath298 holds for any graph @xmath1 containing at least one edge .
furthermore , the followings are also immediate from theorem [ thm : chromatic - cochord ] : one of the important problem in graph coloring theory is to provide an upper bound on the chromatic number of a graph in terms of its clique number . under certain conditions on the source graphs ,
we next show that such a bound is possible for their associated graphs .
for any given integer @xmath301 , we denote by @xmath302 , the class of graphs contained in @xmath303 .
we proceed by an induction on the size of @xmath1 .
we first note that if @xmath1 is a forest , then @xmath306 by proposition [ prop : chordal - reg ] ; hence , @xmath307 by theorem [ thm : chromatic - cochord ] .
so , we may assume that @xmath1 contains at least one induced cycle , say @xmath308 , of order at least @xmath309 .
_ proof of claim 1 .
_ if the induced cycle @xmath308 contains at most one vertex of degree three , we can clearly construct such a path on @xmath308 . on the other hand ,
if @xmath311 are two vertices having degree three in @xmath1 , then all vertices ( except possibly @xmath0 and @xmath140 ) on the shortest path in @xmath308 connecting @xmath0 and @xmath140 must have degree two , since @xmath1 is @xmath312-free .
moreover , the length of such a path is at least @xmath313 which proves the claim .
we sometimes write @xmath330 for the graph obtained from @xmath1 by applying @xmath259 lozin s transformations on @xmath1 such that @xmath331 where @xmath332 .
the following is an immediate consequence of corollary [ cor : bound - m ] and theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] . in the rest of this section , as an another application of theorem [ thm : lozin+reg ] , we show that the regularity of a graph is always less than or equal to the sum of its induced matching and decycling numbers .
to achieve this , we first verify that the whiskering of a graph with respect to a decycling set results a vertex decomposable graph which will be of independent interest .
we recall that a vertex @xmath9 is called a _ leaf _ if it has only one neighbor in @xmath1 , and a _ pendant edge _ in @xmath1 is an edge which is incident to a leaf .
the _ whisker _ @xmath334 of a graph @xmath8 with respect to a given subset @xmath335 is the graph constructed from @xmath1 by @xmath336 and @xmath337 . in particular , we abbreviate @xmath338 by @xmath339 ( see @xcite ) . for a graph @xmath1 and @xmath340 ,
if @xmath341 is acyclic , i.e. , contains no induced cycle , then @xmath342 is said to be a _
decycling set _ of @xmath1 .
the size of a smallest decycling set of @xmath1 is called the _ decycling number _ of @xmath1 and denoted by @xmath343 ( see @xcite ) .
suppose @xmath346 is a minimum decycling set of @xmath257 , and let @xmath347 be the resulting path obtained after the triple subdivision of @xmath132 .
note that @xmath348 , since @xmath20 is minimal . if @xmath349 , then @xmath20 is a decycling set for @xmath1 .
so , assume that @xmath350 .
in such a case , the vertices @xmath50 and @xmath51 can not both belong to @xmath20 , since otherwise the set @xmath351 would still be a decycling set for @xmath257 .
therefore , we may assume @xmath167 without loss of generality .
however , it then follows that @xmath352 is a decycling set for @xmath1 .
thus , the inequality @xmath353 holds .
consider @xmath173 , and let @xmath354 be the leaf neighbor of @xmath0 in @xmath334 .
we note that the vertex @xmath0 is clearly a shedding vertex of @xmath334 and @xmath355)-\{u'\colon u\in n_g(x)\}=w_{s\backslash n_g[x]}(g - n_g[x]).\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , the sets @xmath356 and @xmath357 $ ] are decycling sets for graphs @xmath60 and @xmath115 $ ] respectively ; hence , both graphs @xmath358 and @xmath359}(g - n_g[x])$ ] are vertex decomposable by the induction on @xmath360 .
it then follows that the graphs @xmath361 and @xmath362 $ ] are vertex decomposable , since the vertex @xmath354 is an isolated vertex of @xmath361 , and similarly , @xmath363 is a set of isolated vertices in @xmath362 $ ] .
we let @xmath365 be a graph obtained from @xmath1 by a necessary number , say @xmath366 , of triple subdivisions on @xmath1 so that it is a @xmath118-free graph .
we first recall that @xmath367 by proposition [ prop : edge - sub - div - decy ] .
assume that @xmath20 is a minimal decycling set for @xmath365 .
by proposition [ prop : whisker - vd ] , the graph @xmath368 is vertex decomposable .
we therefore have @xmath369 by theorem [ thm : vd - reg ] , since @xmath368 is also @xmath118-free .
now , it follows that @xmath370 so that @xmath364 as required
. we remark that theorem [ thm : reg - decycling ] is particularly useful when the graph has a small decycling number . having this in mind , we recall that a graph @xmath1 is called _ unicyclic _ provided that it has exactly one cycle .
we follow the proof of theorem [ thm : reg - decycling ] and write @xmath365 for the graph obtained from @xmath1 by @xmath259-triple subdivisions on @xmath1 so that @xmath365 is @xmath118-free . now , the set @xmath373 is a decycling set for @xmath365 so that @xmath374 is vertex decomposable by proposition [ prop : whisker - vd ] . therefore , we have @xmath375 . however , the graph @xmath374 can be constructed from @xmath339 by @xmath259-triple subdivisions on the same edges of @xmath1 , that is , @xmath376 .
thus , we have @xmath377 so that @xmath378 . on the other hand , the equality @xmath379 can be easily verified . | we prove that when a lozin s transformation is applied to a graph , the ( castelnuovo - mumford ) regularity of the graph increases exactly by one , as it happens to its induced matching number . as a consequence , we show that the regularity of a graph can be bounded from above by a function of its induced matching number .
we also prove that the regularity of a graph is always less than or equal to the sum of its induced matching and decycling numbers . |
long before the development of cryptography and encryption , one of humankind s best techniques of secretly delivering a message was to hide the fact that a message was even delivered at all . a well - known example of this is from ancient times where one person would shave another s head and write a message on it .
it was only after waiting for their hair to grow back that they would then be sent to the intended recipient , who would again shave the scalp to reveal the message .
this is historically one of the first - known examples of covert communication , i.e. , the ability to communicate without being detected @xcite . today
, even though advanced encryption techniques are available , there is still a need to hide the fact that communication is taking place from malicious eavesdroppers , e.g. , secret government operations .
modern approaches of such covert communication exist from digital steganography to spread spectrum communication and more @xcite .
another approach consists of hiding information in the naturally occurring thermal noise of optical channels , such as additive white gaussian noise ( awgn ) channels @xcite .
a natural quantum generalization of the awgn channel is the lossy bosonic channel ; a beam splitter mixing the signal with a vacuum state ( pure - loss channel ) or a thermal state .
the lossy bosonic channel is a good model of losses for quantum - optical links used in quantum communication .
covert transmission in this case has been considered both from the point of view of a classical channel with a powerful quantum hacker @xcite , as well as recently , an all - quantum channel and hacker @xcite .
understandably , refs .
@xcite concluded that a pure - loss channel can not be used because there is no way to stealthy hide the information , i.e. , when the hiding medium ( thermal noise ) is absent .
surprisingly , the situation does not get much better if the signal is mixed with a thermal state . in refs .
@xcite it was shown that the asymptotic rate of covert communication is zero and , worse , the probability of a decoding error does not vanish for realistic photon detectors . in this paper
, we show that in fact no concealing medium or object is needed at all in order to hide quantum information transfer at large distances .
this counterintuitive result relies on the machinery of relativistic quantum mechanics
quantum field theory @xcite .
specifically , we show that covert quantum communication is possible using the intrinsic resource of time - like entanglement present in minkowski vacuum @xcite .
this is similar to the entanglement of minkowski vacuum that can be mined at space - like distances as pioneered by @xcite following early insights from @xcite .
cosmological and other consequences of space - like entanglement were investigated in @xcite for observers equipped with an unruh - dewitt ( udw ) detector @xcite and following various trajectories @xcite . in our case
the local measurements of two temporally and spatially separated parties induce a quantum channel whose asymptotic rate of quantum communication supported by the two - way classical communication is in fact nonzero . we have calculated an upper bound on the communication rate and interpreted it as the ultimate covert communication rate . our results offers significant differences from previous work relating to both relativistic quantum information protocols and non - relativistic quantum protocols .
it was shown in @xcite ( also following @xcite ) that quantum key distribution could be achieved without actually sending a quantum signal by exploiting the concept of time - like entanglement .
however , the authors of @xcite did not consider the application of covert quantum communication and also considered the use of continuous variables @xcite as the substrate .
our approach based on discrete variables allows us to do away with the shared coherent beam needed to synchronize the local oscillators ( needed for homodyne detection ) that could eventually blow the cover .
another problem with the oscillator mode may be its delivery especially for participants below the horizon or at large distances .
our construction avoids this problem while reaching similarly large distances for quantum communication . for our protocol as well as for
@xcite the parties have to independently solve the problem of how to covertly exchange classical messages . in general , we can not do away with classical communication at large spatial distances but we did find instances where no classical communication is needed at all . this paper is structured as follows .
[ sec : entgen ] is the technical part of the paper where we introduce two inertial observers both equipped with an unruh - dewitt detector .
we analyze the response of the detectors to the fourth perturbative order and extract the quantum state of the two detectors after the scalar field has been traced out as the main object of our study . in sec .
[ subsec:4thorderdm ] we present the quantum state for zero spatial distance of the two observers subsequently generalized to a nonzero spatial distance in sec .
[ subsec:4thorderlnonzero ] .
this is our main object of study and we interpret it from the quantum information theory point of view in sec .
[ sec : keyrate ] .
this enables us to calculate and present our main results in sec .
[ sec : results ] .
we conclude by mentioning open problems in sec .
[ sec : discussion ] .
alice and bob are in possession of two - state detectors whose energy levels can be made time - dependent .
tunability of energy levels can be achieved , e.g. , by using a superconducting system .
thus bob s detector obeys the schrdinger equation @xmath0 , where @xmath1 has a constant spectrum .
it can be turned to a standard schrdinger equation in conformal time @xmath2 , defined by @xmath3 .
this coordinate change is equivalent to a change of the coordinate system of an inertial observer to the system of an observer undergoing uniform acceleration .
thus , bob s detector effectively couples to rindler modes in the future ( f ) wedge .
similarly , we setup alice s detector so that it effectively couples to the rindler modes in the past ( p ) wedge , by tuning the energy levels so that they correspond to the hamiltonian @xmath1 in conformal time @xmath4 , where @xmath5 .
both detectors couple to ( distinct ) vacuum modes which we model by a real massless scalar field @xmath6 . for an introduction to such concepts see @xcite . moreover , we are interested in the case where alice and bob are separated by a distance @xmath7 . for definiteness ,
let @xmath8 for alice , and @xmath9 for bob .
if alice s ( bob s ) detector clicks at time @xmath10 ( @xmath11 ) , then the proper time between the two clicks is @xmath12 we expect the maximal correlations in the vicinity of the null line connecting the two events . in terms of their respective conformal times , this condition can be written as @xmath13 .
for definiteness , we choose the rhs to be @xmath14 ( similar results are obtained for any other choice ) .
thus , if alice s detector performs a measurement at @xmath15 , then optimally , bob s detector will perform its measurement at bob s conformal time @xmath16 , where @xmath17}.\ ] ] the standard way of evaluating the interaction between a field and udw detectors is perturbatively in the interaction picture .
a realistic udw detector is described by the following term @xmath18 where @xmath19 is a real scalar field where @xmath20 is a four - momentum , @xmath21 is a window function , @xmath22 a smearing function we set to be a delta function in this work , @xmath23 are the atom ladder operators and @xmath24 stands for the energy gap .
the evolution operator for observer @xmath25 reads @xmath26}\big\ } } \nn\\ & = 1-i\int_{t_0}^t{\mathrm{\,d } t_1}h_a(t_1)- \frac{1}{2}\mathsf{t } \bigg ( \int_{t_0}^t{\mathrm{\,d } t_1 } h_a(t_1 ) \bigg)^2 + \frac{(-i)^3}{3!}\mathsf{t } \bigg ( \int_{t_0}^t{\mathrm{\,d } t_1 }
h_a(t_1 ) \bigg)^3 + \dots .\end{aligned}\ ] ] considering the initial state of the field and detectors to be @xmath27 we calculate from @xmath28 ( we label the time coordinate in the future / past wedge by @xmath29 ) the following density matrix of the two atoms after we trace over the field degrees of freedom @xmath30 where the bar denotes complex conjugation .
we further denote @xmath31 , where @xmath32 stands for the lower ( upper ) atom level .
the state @xmath33 is a two - qubit density matrix . indeed , in the unruh - dewitt model the atoms are two qubits as the ladder operators commute : @xmath34 . using the notation ( time ordering and tensor product implied ) @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
we write for the detectors density matrix @xmath38 and we obtain @xmath39 therefore [ eq : upto4thorder ] @xmath40 { |0_m\rangle } + \dots\\ b_2 & = { \langle0_m| } |a_+|^2 \big [ 1 - \frac{1}{3 } ( a_+a_-+ 3b_+b_- ) \big ] { |0_m\rangle } + \dots\\ c_2 & = { \langle0_m| } a_+^\dg b_+ \big [ 1 - \frac{1}{6 } ( a_+a_-+ 3b_+b_-)^\dg - \frac{1}{6 } ( b_+b_- + 3a_+a_-)\big ] { |0_m\rangle } + \dots,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where e.g. @xmath41 means @xmath42
. we will need the following standard results @xcite @xmath43 where @xmath44 stands for the feynman propagator and @xmath45 denotes a four vector .
following @xcite , the ff ( and @xmath4 for pp ) propagator reads @xmath46}}\ ] ] and the fp propagator takes the following form @xmath47}}.\ ] ] propagators eqs .
( [ eq : propagffandpp ] ) and ( [ eq : propagfp ] ) can be further simplified using the identities @xmath48 we obtain @xmath49 and ( note that we can set @xmath50 here right away ) @xmath51 the matrix entries needed for up to the second order read [ eq : mtrxelmns2ndorder ] @xmath52 for the fourth order in the next section we will also need @xmath53 to evaluate the integrals we adopt the results from @xcite where one of the investigated window functions is a gaussian profile @xmath54},\ ] ] where @xmath55 tunes the coupling strength .
the matrix elements ( [ eq : mtrxelmns2ndorder ] ) are thus given by integrals of the following four types : @xmath56}\int_{-\infty}^\infty{\mathrm{\,d } \tau'}\,\exp{\big[{-{\tau'^2\over\s^2}}\big]}e^{i\d(\tau'\pm\tau ) } \sum_{n=-\infty}^\infty{1\over(\tau-\tau'-2i\ve+2\pi in / a)^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath57}\int_{-\infty}^\infty{\mathrm{\,d } \eta}\,\exp{\big[{-{\eta^2\over\s^2}}\big]}e^{i\d(\eta\pm\tau ) } \sum_{n=-\infty}^\infty{1\over(\tau-\eta-2i\ve+\pi i / a ( 2n+1))^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] integrals @xmath58 and @xmath59 are integral ( 50 ) in @xcite ( for @xmath60 ) . conveniently , this integral has sort of a closed form . following @xcite , the inner integral splits in two expressions according to whether the poles are positive ( @xmath61 ) or not ( @xmath62 ) leading to @xmath63}.\ ] ] then , we get the following expressions @xmath64}\ups_{+}(n)\nn\\ & = { \la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=-\infty}^0\big[2+\sqrt{2\pi}\exp{\big[{(2n\pi/(a\s)+\s\d)^2\over2}\big]}(2n\pi/(a\s)+\s\d ) \big(1+\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{2n\pi/(a\s)+\s\d\over\sqrt{2}}\big]\big)\big]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath65}\ups_{-}(n)\nn\\ & = -{\la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=1}^\infty\big[{-2}+\sqrt{2\pi}\exp{\big[{(2n\pi/(a\s)+\s\d)^2\over2}\big]}(2n\pi/(a\s)+\s\d ) \big(1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{2n\pi/(a\s)+\s\d\over\sqrt{2}}\big]\big)\big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that ( [ eq : int1minus]),([eq : int1plus ] ) and all other matrix elements we calculate will be expressed in terms of certain dimensionless parameters such as @xmath66 and @xmath67 . to get
@xmath68 we swap @xmath69 for @xmath70 in ( [ eq : innerint ] ) but we must also shift the sums limits because the poles in ( [ eq : integral23 ] ) are vertically shifted by one : [ eq : int2plusminus ] @xmath71}((2n+1)\pi / a+\s^2\d ) \big(1+\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{(2n+1)\pi / a+\s^2\d\over\s\sqrt{2}}\big]\big)\big]\nn\\ & = -{\la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\nn\\ & \times\sum_{n=-\infty}^{-1}\big[2+\sqrt{2\pi}\exp{\big[{((2n+1)\pi/(a\s)+\s\d)^2\over2}\big]}((2n+1)\pi/(a\s)+\s\d ) \big(1+\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{(2n+1)\pi/(a\s)+\s\d\over\sqrt{2}}\big]\big)\big].\\ \eui_{2}^-&=\la^2{\s^2\over8\pi^2}{\pi\over\s^3}e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\nn\\ & \times\sum_{n=0}^\infty\big[{-2\s+\sqrt{2\pi}\exp{\big[{((2n+1)\pi / a+\s^2\d)^2\over2\s^2}\big]}((2n+1)\pi / a+\s^2\d ) } \big({1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{{(2n+1)\pi / a+\s^2\d\over\s\sqrt{2}}}\big]}\big)\big]\nn\\ & = { \la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\nn\\ & \times\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\big[{-2}+\sqrt{2\pi}\exp{\big[{((2n+1)\pi/(a\s)+\s\d)^2\over2}\big]}((2n+1)\pi/(a\s)+\s\d ) \big(1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{(2n+1)\pi/(a\s)+\s\d\over\sqrt{2}}\big]\big)\big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , the plus version of eq .
( [ eq : integral23 ] ) is called @xmath72 : @xmath73}\int_{-\infty}^\infty{\mathrm{\,d } x}\exp{\big[{-{x^2\over2\s^2}}\big ] } \sum_{n=-\infty}^\infty{1\over(x-2i\ve+\pi i / a ( 2n+1))^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be written as @xmath74 where [ eq : int3plusminus ] @xmath75}\big(1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{(2n+1)\pi\over\sqrt{2}a\s}\big]\big)}\big]\nn\\ & = { \la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=0}^\infty \big[{{-2}+{(2n+1)\pi\sqrt{2\pi}\over\s{a}}\exp{\big[{(2n+1)^2\pi^2\over2(\s{a})^2}\big]}\big(1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{(2n+1)\pi\over\sqrt{2}a\s}\big]\big)}\big],\\ \eui_{3}^-&={\la^2\over8\pi } e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=-\infty}^{-1 } \big[{-2-{(2n+1)\pi\sqrt{2\pi}\over\s{a}}\exp{\big[{(2n+1)^2\pi^2\over2(\s{a})^2}\big]}\big(1+\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{(2n+1)\pi\over\sqrt{2}a\s}\big]\big)}\big]=\eui_{3}^+ . \ ] ] by taking only the zeroth and second order contributions from eqs .
( [ eq : upto4thorder ] ) the @xmath76 expressions reveal the density matrix up to the second perturbative order : [ eq:2ndorderentries ] @xmath77 the result coincides with @xcite and has been rederived in the timelike scenario as well @xcite .
the second order is insufficient for our purposes since the ` outer ' density matrix @xmath33 is negative unless @xmath78 . in order to evaluate the coefficients from eqs .
( [ eq : upto4thorder ] ) we first calculate the plus version of eq .
( [ eq : integral14 ] ) @xmath79}\int_{-\infty}^\infty{\mathrm{\,d } x}\exp{\big[{-{x^2\over2\s^2}}\big ] } \sum_{n=-\infty}^\infty{1\over(x-2i\ve+2n\pi i / a)^2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we split it into two parts @xmath80 calculated as [ eq : int4plusminus ] @xmath81}\big(1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{n\pi\sqrt{2}\over\s{a}}\big]\big)}\big]\nn\\ & = -{\la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\d\s)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=0}^\infty\big[{{-2}+{2n\pi\sqrt{2\pi}\over{a\s}}\exp{\big[{2n^2\pi^2\over\s^2a^2}\big]}\big(1-\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{n\pi\sqrt{2}\over\s{a}}\big]\big)}\big],\\ \eui_{4}^-&=-{\la^2\over8\pi^2}\sqrt{2\pi}\s e^{-{(\s\d)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=-\infty}^{-1 } \big[{-{\sqrt{2\pi}\over\s}-{2n\pi^2\over\s^2a}\exp{\big[{2n^2\pi^2\over\s^2a^2}\big ] } \big(1+\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{n\pi\sqrt{2}\over\s a}\big]\big)}\big]\nn\\ & = -{\la^2\over8\pi}e^{-{(\d\s)^2\over2}}\sum_{n=-\infty}^{-1}\big[{{-2}-{2n\pi\sqrt{2\pi}\over{a\s}}\exp{\big[{2n^2\pi^2\over\s^2a^2}\big ] } \big(1+\mathrm{erf\,}\big[{n\pi\sqrt{2}\over\s{a}}\big]\big ) } \big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we notice at once that @xmath82 equals @xmath83 without the @xmath84 term . to proceed we use the following four - point correlation function identity as the simplest case of the wick theorem @xcite : @xmath85 as a result , from eqs .
( [ eq : upto4thorder ] ) we get [ eq : higherorderomab ] @xmath86 note that similarly to the second perturbative order in eq .
( [ eq:2ndorderentries ] ) the trace of @xmath33 assembled from ( [ eq : higherorderomab ] ) equals one without a renormalization
. the timelike entanglement would be hardly useful for covert quantum communication if the stationary sender and receiver were forced to be stationed at the same spatial coordinate .
fortunately , the timelike entanglement of the scalar massless particles persists over nonzero distances . in order to quantify how much entanglement survives
we take the two - point correlation function eq .
( [ eq:2pointcorr ] ) and by fixing @xmath87 we have for the receiver ( see fig . [
fig : timelike ] ) @xmath88 by setting @xmath89 propagator ( [ eq : propagfp ] ) then becomes @xmath90}-{a^2l^2\over4}\exp{[-a(\tau+\eta)]}}.\ ] ] we removed the @xmath91 prescription as no pole lies on the real axis and after rescaling @xmath92 and @xmath93 and plugging eq .
( [ eq : propagfpdistance ] ) the integrals @xmath94}-{a^2l^2\over4}\exp{[-(\tau+\eta)]}}\ ] ] converge without the need to regularize .
we have @xmath95}$ ] , the integrals are dimensionless and @xmath96 is used . after changing the variables
to @xmath97 we obtain @xmath98 looking at eqs .
( [ eq : higherorderomab ] ) we notice an interesting fact . the off - diagonal elements @xmath99 are invariant with respect to @xmath100 ( possibly up to a sign change )
this means that if @xmath101 there ca nt be any entanglement the state @xmath33 is ( nearly ) ppt invariant .
so in order to have entanglement ( keeping in mind that the ppt non - invariance is a necessary but not a sufficient condition ) we need @xmath102 .
we now find out when this is possible .
we have @xmath103 switching to @xmath104 we get @xmath105 after shifting @xmath106 , we obtain @xmath107 turning to @xmath72 , we have ( after shifting @xmath108 ) @xmath109 the ratio is @xmath110 each integral can be written explicitly in terms of error functions as follows .
let s set @xmath111 and write it as a fourier transform ( omitting an overall factor ) : @xmath112 the integral in @xmath106 needs to be closed in the upper half plane if @xmath113 , and in the lower half plane if @xmath114 .
thus for @xmath115 , only @xmath116 contributes , and for @xmath117 , only @xmath113 contributes .
therefore , @xmath118 we deduce ( after re - scaling @xmath119 ) @xmath120 clearly , @xmath121 . as @xmath122
, we have @xmath123 .
so for large @xmath124 , @xmath125 . if the symmetry between @xmath126 and @xmath127 remains even for an arbitrary perturbative order , only under this condition we may expect the creation of entanglement with the help of two udw detectors .
the straightforward but crucial observation we will use is that the state @xmath33 can be interpreted as a choi state representing a completely positive map ( quantum channel @xmath128 ) using the choi - jamiokowski representation @xcite .
recall that given a choi matrix @xmath129 we find the channel action via the following isomorphism : @xmath130,\ ] ] where @xmath131 and @xmath132 denotes transposition in the canonical basis .
choi states are routinely used to evaluate the secret key rates in virtually all dvqkd protocols and as we will see it is arguably one of the best channel representations to perform various capacity calculations or estimates .
this often consists of calculating the eigenvalues of the choi matrix and its marginal states .
the reducible form of @xmath133 plays into our cards : the eigenvalues of both @xmath134 and @xmath33 are easy to calculate .
the former can be directly read out from @xmath135}$ ] and for @xmath33 we get a familiar expression for all four eigenvalues : @xmath136 .
let s see how useful this representation is . given a quantum noisy channel @xmath137 , the question of the highest achievable rate at which two legitimate parties can asymptotically establish secret correlations using one - way ( @xmath138 ) classical ( public ) communication was answered in @xcite .
it is given by the private channel capacity which is equivalent to the one - way channel secret key rate @xmath139 .
the secret key rate is hard to calculate , though .
fortunately , a number of lower bounds are known .
one such a bound is the coherent information @xmath140 , where @xmath141 and @xmath142 $ ] is the von neumann entropy ( @xmath143 is to the base two throughout the paper and the symbol @xmath144 stands for defined ) .
hence , the coherent information is optimized over an input state @xmath145 to the channel @xmath128 but evaluated on the output states @xmath134 and @xmath33 .
we are led to the following chain of inequalities @xcite : @xmath146 where @xmath147 and @xmath148 are the single- and multi - letter quantum capacity formulas , respectively . in short
, quantum capacity can be operationally interpreted as the rate at which maximally entangled states can be distilled using one - way classical communication and local operations ( one - way locc ) .
hence , it provides a natural lower bound on the one - way secret key rate since any quantum or classical correlation ( namely a classical key a secret string of bits ) can be teleported once maximally entangled states are available . unfortunately
, the regularization makes @xmath149 and @xmath139 practically incalculable for plenty of interesting channels .
a noteworthy peculiarity that we will encounter for other measures as well , is the inability to optimize @xmath150 over the channel input state @xmath145 to get @xmath151 .
this is because there is no accessible input state in the first place . in quantum shannon theory ,
the state @xmath145 ( or its purification @xmath152 ) is a quantum code chosen such that the entanglement generation rate ( or , equivalently , quantum communication rate ) is the best possible .
here we have only an image of such a state and we can assume that the input purified state @xmath152 is maximally entangled .
then the output state @xmath33 is a choi state as we interpreted it .
we could take a different point of view and decide that @xmath33 is an image of any input state in which case it is formally not a choi state .
but by this we would deprive ourselves of being able to use the secret key rate estimates introduced further in this section .
there , the choi matrix plays a crucial role .
so let s adopt the following convention : in the expressions to come , c the state @xmath153 or @xmath33 means a generic bipartite state . if we need to stress that we interpret @xmath153 as a choi - jamiokowski matrix of a channel @xmath128 we will write @xmath129 instead . one - way classical communication is a strictly weaker resource for quantum communication than two - way ( @xmath154 ) classical communication . as a matter of fact , the problem of calculating the two - way secret key rate ( or quantum / private capacity ) recently received a lot of deserved attention @xcite drawing on early results from @xcite .
the two - way quantities of a general quantum channel are equally hard to calculate unless the channel possesses certain symmetries @xcite .
the secret key rate is lower bounded by the two - way distillable entanglement . in order to decide whether the two - way key rate is nonzero it is thus sufficient to check whether @xmath33 is entangled ( see @xcite , sections xii.d , xii.f and xiv.a for an all - in - one overview )
this can be decided via the ppt criterion which for @xmath155 is a sufficient and necessary condition .
currently , there also exists only a few upper bounds .
the upper bounds are harder to evaluate : to the authors knowledge , none of them are tight and as we will see , they often require a non - trivial optimization step .
the first quantity we mention is the squashed entanglement introduced in @xcite @xmath156 where @xmath157 is a ` squashing ' channel and @xmath158 is the conditional mutual information defined as @xmath159 squashed entanglement was adapted in @xcite to define the squashed entanglement of a quantum channel @xmath128 @xmath160 where @xmath152 is the channel s input state ( recall our convention of @xmath33 being the choi matrix of @xmath137 ) and the following inequalities hold @xmath161 the last inequality ( cf .
@xcite ) is computationally the most relevant .
the rhs is called the entanglement of formation ( eof ) and was introduced in @xcite @xmath162 where the optimization goes over the decomposition @xmath163 .
the eof is normally difficult to calculate except in our case where a closed formula is known due to wootters @xcite .
another notable bound is the regularized relative entropy of entanglement @xcite @xmath164 where @xmath165 is a separable state and @xmath166\ ] ] is the quantum relative entropy @xcite .
again , the regularization is an obstacle for its direct evaluation .
recently , the authors of @xcite , influenced by seminal @xcite , introduced the regularized relative entropy of entanglement @xmath167 of a channel @xmath128 where @xmath129 is its choi matrix .
they showed that for a large class of channels ( so - called ` teleportation covariant ' ) the following inequality holds @xmath168 where @xmath169 are all adaptive strategies and @xmath170 is a separable state .
it turns out that the following inequalities hold : @xmath171 note that @xmath172 holds as well ( see @xcite ) . finally , the authors of @xcite defined the max - relative entropy of entanglement of a quantum channel @xmath128 as @xmath173 where @xmath152 is the channel s input state and in general we have @xmath174 the states @xmath170 are chosen from the set of separable states and the max - relative entropy @xmath175 is defined as @xcite @xmath176 where @xmath177 is the greatest eigenvalue of @xmath178 .
the max - relative entropy of entanglement was shown to satisfy @xmath179 looking at the above definitions it does not come as a surprise that the upper bound could be difficult to find as well and so a simplified upper bound ( on the upper bound ) was devised @xcite : @xmath180 where @xmath170 is a separable state representing a choi matrix of an entanglement - breaking channel . comparing ( [ eq : maxreechnl ] ) and ( [ eq : maxree ] ) with ( [ eq : choieb ] )
we see that we removed one optimization step that we would not be able to perform anyway as discussed earlier in this section .
ultimately , our goal is to maximize the secret key rate and distance for the physical parameters of the unruh - dewitt detectors such that they are reasonably realistic .
this is a hard problem as the integrals from eqs .
( [ eq : j23forl ] ) must be solved numerically which itself is a rather time - consuming process if we want to make sure that the values we get can be trusted .
hence we choose the following strategy : for realistically chosen atomic parameters we made an educated guess and showcase our results by calculating the best rates we could find at the expense of a relatively small ( but still respectable ) distance and the best distance for a smaller but positive secret key rate . especially here
we got to an impressive distance in the order of thousands of kilometers so let s start with this case .
we set the parameters introduced in eqs .
( [ eq : udwhint ] ) and ( [ eq : gaussianprofile ] ) to be @xmath181 and @xmath182 .
the eof of the corresponding state @xmath33 is depicted in fig .
[ fig : ratelada ] .
we can see that it quickly decreases for @xmath183 but remains positive for more than a thousand kilometers indicating the presence of entanglement at large distances that can be used for two - way quantum communication . as discussed in the previous section ,
as long as @xmath33 is entangled the two - way secret key rate is strictly positive .
but we do not know the actual rate of covert communication except with one truly remarkable exception . for the immediate vicinity of @xmath184 the one - way quantum capacity is nonzero : @xmath185 for @xmath186 . this result is useless for covert communication for large distances but nonetheless conceptually important
@xmath187 provides not only an achievable lower bound on the one - way secret key rate as indicated in eq .
( [ eq : ineqchain1 ] ) but mainly we can exploit @xmath188 @xcite .
that is , the participants do not have to classically communicate at all .
they have to initially agree on a decoding strategy without the need to talk again in order to quantum communicate .
one could wonder why the channel is not an identity for @xmath189 .
this is because @xmath184 does not mean a measurement at the same time and especially on the same system .
it rather corresponds to the situation depicted in the left panel of fig .
[ fig : timelike ] .
the information is sent to the future where it is received at the same spatial position but by a completely different observer ( in his own lab that could have been built in the meantime ) . by tuning the detectors parameters we can increase the eof ( and most likely the rate as well ) .
the eof is plotted in fig .
[ fig : ratel ] for the following set of parameters : @xmath190 and @xmath191 . for @xmath184
we get a better result compared to fig . [
fig : ratelada ] but it drops to zero .
this is the area marked by an arrow in fig .
[ fig : ratel ] .
the zero point coincides with @xmath192 becoming separable . as in the previous case ,
the dimension of the detectors state @xmath33 makes it easy to find an upper bound via the eof but it is also a good opportunity to test how tight bounds we would have gotten if we could not rely on the calculable eof .
first , we plotted the unoptimized squashed entanglement eq .
( [ eq : squashedent ] ) where @xmath193 was set ( see the blue dashed curve ) .
it is clearly an inappropriate bound which is not surprising given the trivial squashing channel . to get a better upper bound we numerically optimized over the system @xmath194 such that @xmath195 using the tools from @xcite
this provides a better estimate and surprisingly , sometimes ( for @xmath184 ) even better than the one given by the eof .
another plotted estimate is the simplified upper bound on the max - relative entropy of entanglement eq .
( [ eq : choieb ] ) we calculated numerically ( green curve ) .
overall , it grossly overestimates the eof but provides a better estimate when @xmath129 is becoming separable .
the third of the mentioned estimates , eq . ( [ eq : reestretch ] ) , is not known to be applicable to our channel .
we can also study how the coupling strength @xmath196 affects the rate .
for the parameters @xmath197 , and @xmath198 ( we set @xmath184 ) we plot the eof against @xmath196 in fig .
[ fig : ratelam ] . as expected , with a decreasing coupling constant @xmath196
the rate goes down as well until the state becomes so weakly coupled that it is separable and the rate is zero .
we will comment on an interesting problem of what eavesdropping actually means in our situation .
no quantum signal is exchanged between the communicating parties and so an eavesdropper can not take direct advantage of the qkd paradigm of how the security is analyzed : normally , any kind of channel noise is attributed to the eavesdropper and the value of the secret key rate reflects the fact whether under this assumption information - theoretic security can be achieved . in our opinion
there are two possibilities of how eve can interact with the system held by the legitimate parties and none of them affects the obtained results .
eve could gain access to the labs and tamper with the detectors .
but this is really an out - of - the - scope attack , something more similar to a side - channel attack in qkd where an eavesdropper manipulates the detector s efficiency by sending laser pulses @xcite .
a more relevant attack would be eve setting up her own detectors at various spacetime points . in principle
she could be in possession of a multipartite entangled state @xmath199 or even a purification of the state shared by the sender and the receiver .
but this does not help her at all since she can not manipulate the marginal state @xmath33 . as a matter of fact
, this is precisely the assumption in the security of qkd an eavesdropper holds the purification @xcite ( or the complementary output of the channel @xcite ) and the secret key rate is calculated or estimated under these most advantageous conditions for the eavesdropper .
we developed a truly fundamental covert quantum communication protocol by exploiting the properties of minkowski vacuum .
contrary to the previously introduced schemes , the covert communication does not need to be hidden in the environmental ( thermal ) noise and is not limited to a particular model of an optical quantum channel .
what makes our results fundamental is that the rate of covert communication in the asymptotic limit of quantum communication is in fact strictly positive ; where previous results tended towards zero in the same limit . in our scheme
no quantum signal is exchanged at all which is possible due to intrinsically quantum properties of minkowski vacuum essentially offering preshared entangled states at large spatial distances .
we tapped into this resource by equipping two inertial observers by specially crafted unruh - dewitt detectors ( following @xcite ) and calculating their response up to the fourth perturbative order .
we found that the detectors are entangled and we analyzed the meaning of this entanglement from the quantum communication point of view .
we found that for suitable parameters and using two - way quantum communication , that a positive secret key rates can be achieved over thousands of kilometers .
the main open problem is whether we can avoid classical communication altogether for greater distances .
we have shown that quantum information can be covertly sent to the same place in the future without the need to classically communicate whatsoever .
this is possible because of the positive value of the coherent information for the corresponding quantum channel . to answer this question we would need to go well beyond the fourth perturbative order a strategy that would bring the answer to another open problem : what is the actual non - perturbative channel ? if @xmath33 is interpreted as a choi - jamiokowski matrix
as was advocated here , then its form strongly resembles a qubit pauli channel .
this hardly can be true for an arbitrary value of the detector parameters since in order for it to be a pauli channel the first and last diagonal elements @xmath33 must be equal .
but perhaps in some regime or limit this could indeed be the case .
the authors thank nathan walk and timothy ralph for comments . | we present truly ultimate limits on covert quantum communication by exploiting quantum - mechanical properties of the minkowski vacuum in the quantum field theory framework .
our main results are the following : we show how two parties equipped with unruh - dewitt detectors can covertly communicate at large distances without the need of hiding in a thermal background or relying on various technological tricks .
we reinstate the information - theoretic security standards for reliability of asymptotic quantum communication and show that the rate of covert communication is strictly positive .
therefore , contrary to the previous conclusions , covert and reliable quantum communication is possible . |
since the suggestion of @xmath0 suppression as a signal of quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) formation by matsui and satz @xcite in 1986 the problem of quarkonium dissociation in hot and dense strongly interacting matter has played a key role for qgp diagnostics in relativistic heavy - ion collision experiments .
the original idea was that in a qgp the string tension of the confining potential vanishes and the residual one - gluon exchange interaction undergoes a debye screening by the color charges of the plasma .
when the temperature dependent debye radius @xmath1 ( the inverse of the debye mass @xmath2 ) becomes shorter than the bohr radius of the charmonium ground state ( @xmath0 ) then the mott effect @xcite ( bound state dissociation ) occurs and the corresponding temperature is @xmath3 .
this simple idea grew up to a multifacetted research direction when not only in the first light ion - nucleus collisions at the cern na38 experiment , but also in proton - nucleus collisions at fermilab @xmath0 suppression has been found so that there is not only a qgp but also a cold nuclear matter effect on charmonium production , see @xcite for a recent review . if one wants to explore the question of screening in a plasma more in detail then a variety of approaches is available in the literature , from the original debye - hckel approach @xcite applicable to any vacuum potential ( for example the cornell potential ) , over the thermodynamic green functions approach to the ab - initio studies of heavy - quark potentials in lattice qcd . with
the obtained medium - dependent potentials one can then study the bound state problem by solving the thermodynamic @xmath4 - matrix for quarkonia @xcite , or the equivalent schrdinger - type wave equation where medium effects are absorbed in a plasma hamiltonian @xcite .
on the other hand one may calculate proper correlators directly from lattice qcd and extract from them spectral functions @xcite .
there is an intriguing disagreement between the mott temperatures deduced from these spectral functions and those of the potential models : from the lattice data for quarkonium correlators one has extracted @xmath5 while in potential model calculations @xmath6 .
this problem has lead to the discussion of the proper thermodynamical function to be used as a potential in the schrdinger equation , see @xcite and references therein . in this contribution
we follow the recently suggested @xcite modification of the standard one - loop calculation of the debye mass in thermal quantum field theory @xcite in the framework of the poyakov - nambu - jona - lasinio model , now widely used for a microscopic qcd - motivated description of mesons in quark matter @xcite .
we then solve the schrdinger equation for charmonium and bottomonium states with the plasma hamiltonian @xcite corresponding to the screened cornell potential @xcite and obtain the mott dissociation temperatures of these states .
given the static interaction potential @xmath7 , @xmath8 , the statically screened potential is given by a resummation of one - particle irreducible diagrams ( `` bubble '' resummation = rpa ) @xmath9~ , \label{vsc}\ ] ] where the longitudinal polarization function @xmath10 in the finite @xmath11 case can be calculated within thermal field theory as @xmath12~.\ ] ] here @xmath13 are the bosonic and @xmath14 are the fermionic matsubara frequencies of the imaginary - time formalism .
the symbol @xmath15 stands for traces in color , flavor and dirac spaces .
@xmath16 is the propagator of a massless fermion coupled to the homogeneous static gluon background field @xmath17 .
its inverse is given by @xcite @xmath18 where @xmath17 is related to the polyakov loop variable defined by @xcite @xmath19 the physics of @xmath20 is governed by the temperature - dependent polyakov loop potential @xmath21 , which is fitted to describe the lattice data for the pressure of the pure glue system @xcite . after performing the color- , flavor- and dirac traces and making the fermionic matsubara summation , we obtain in the static , long wavelength limit @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the debye mass , the number of degrees of freedom is @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 is the quark distribution function @xcite . for the discussion of imaginary parts of the polarization function and their relation to kinetics see , e.g. , @xcite . in comparison to the free fermion case @xcite the coupling to the polyakov loop variable @xmath20 gives rise to a modification of the debye mass , given by the integral @xmath27 the temperature dependence of @xmath20 is taken from ref .
@xcite . in the limit of deconfinement ( @xmath28 ) ,
the case of a massless quark gas is obtained ( @xmath29 ) , while for confinement ( @xmath30 ) one finds that @xmath31 .
taking as the unscreened vacuum potential the one - gluon exchange form @xmath32 , the fourier transform of the debye potential results as statically screened potential , @xmath33~.$ ]
in order to calculate the temperature dependence of the two - particle energies @xmath34 for charmonium and bottomonium states in a pnjl quark plasma , we solve the schrdinger equation @xmath35 for the hamiltonian @xcite @xmath36 with the screened cornell potential @xcite @xmath37~ , \label{potential}\ ] ] where parameters are fitted to the vacuum spectroscopy of heavy quarkonia by @xmath38 , @xmath39 and the heavy - quark masses @xmath40 gev , @xmath41 gev .
here we use the debye mass of the previous section with the temperature dependence of @xmath20 taken from a nonlocal pnjl model @xcite . note that the hamiltonian ( [ h - pl ] ) contains a temperature - dependent shift of the continuum edge due to the hartree selfenergies of the heavy quarks in the potential ( [ potential ] ) , which results in a definition of the dissociation energies as @xmath42 and of the mott temperatures as @xmath43 .
[ h ] , compared to the available thermal energy of medium particles @xmath44 . for discussion , see text . , scaledwidth=90.0% ] , compared to the available thermal energy of medium particles @xmath44 . for discussion , see text .
, scaledwidth=90.0% ] in the upper panels of fig .
[ fig : debye ] we show the temperature dependence of the two - particle energies ( masses ) of the lowest heavy quarkonia states at rest in the medium together with the corresponding two - particle continuum edge for charmonia ( left ) and bottomonia ( right ) .
the coupling to the polyakov loop potential leads to a suppression of the quark - antiquark excitations responsible for the screening of the heavy - quark potential in the present model .
this entails a stabilization of the bound states ( solid lines ) relative to the case without that coupling ( dashed lines ) . in the lower panels we show the corresponding binding energies @xmath45
comparison with the available thermal energy of medium particles ( @xmath44 ) shows that mott dissociation by thermal activation @xcite is possible well below the mott temperatures estimated from the solution of the schrdinger equation .
for more detailed discussions of the dissociation kinetics of heavy quarkonia , see the recent review @xcite and references therein .
we have applied the methods of thermal field theory to estimate the effects of debye screening on heavy quarkonia bound state formation . in order to account for residual effects of confining color correlations in the deconfined phase ,
we have used the pnjl model in the evaluation of the one - loop polarization function . as expected ,
a stabilization of bound states in the vicinity of the critical temperature for @xmath46 is obtained .
we have solved numerically the schrdinger equation to derive the mott criterion for bound states of the statically screened cornell potential and obtained mott temperatures in good agreement with previous results from nonrelativistic potential models exploiting lattice qcd singlet free energies as potentials in the schrdinger equation for heavy quarkonia .
this agreement with previous results ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) includes also higher quarkonia resonances . for these states
the stabilization effect is most pronounced since their mott temperatures lie in the region of temperatures where the suppression of quark - antiquark excitations due to the polyakov - loop potential is the largest .
due to the lowering of the dissociation energies for heavy quarkonia states , their dissociation become possible by thermal activation already well before the mott temperatures are reached . according to the present work , even the tightly bound bottomonium ground state @xmath47
may get `` boiled away '' at temperatures @xmath48 mev , well accessible already at rhic .
the detailed discussion of the heavy quarkonia dissociation kinetics and its relationship to imaginary parts of the heavy - quark potentials @xcite is beyond the scope of the present contribution .
d. cabrera and r. rapp , phys .
d * 76 * 114506 ( 2007 ) ; + c. y. wong , phys . rev .
c * 72 * 034906 ( 2005 ) .
w. ebeling , w .- d .
kraeft , d. kremp , g. rpke , _ quantum statistics of charged many - particle systems _ , plenum , new york ( 1986 ) .
m. asakawa _ et al .
. part .
phys . * 46 * 459 ( 2001 ) ; + a. jakovac _ et al . _ ,
d * 75 * 014506 ( 2007 ) .
h. satz , j. phys .
g * 32 * r25 ( 2006 ) .
j. jankowski and d. blaschke , arxiv:0903.1263 [ hep - ph ] .
h. hansen _ et al .
_ , phys . rev .
d * 75 * 065004 ( 2007 ) .
f. karsch , m. t. mehr and h. satz , z. phys .
c * 37 * , 617 ( 1988 ) .
d. blaschke _ et al .
_ , yad . fiz . * 71 * , 2012 ( 2008 ) .
g. rpke _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 202 * ( 1988 ) 479 ; phys .
d * 38 * , 3589 ( 1988 ) . | we investigate the mott effect for heavy quarkonia due to debye screening of the heavy quark potential in a plasma of massless quarks and antiquarks .
the influence of residual color correlation is investigated by coupling the light quark sector to a temporal gauge field driven by the polyakov loop potential .
this leads to an increase of the mott dissociation temperatures for quarkonia states which stabilizes in particular the excited states , but has marginal effect on the ground states .
the temperature dependence of binding energies suggests that the dissciation of the charmonium ( bottomonium ) ground state by thermal activation sets in at temperatures of 200 mev ( 250 mev ) . |
graphene , a two - dimensional ( 2d ) crystal of carbon atoms tightly packed in a honeycomb lattice , is at the center of an ever growing research effort , due to its potential as a platform material for a variety of applications in fields ranging from electronics , to food packaging @xcite . in particular , in optoelectronics , photonics , and
plasmonics graphene has decisive advantages , such as wavelength - independent absorption , tunability via electrostatic doping , large charge - carrier concentrations , low dissipation rates , high mobility , and the ability to confine electromagnetic energy to unprecedented small volumes @xcite .
these unique properties make it an ideal material for a variety of photonic applications @xcite , including fast photodetectors @xcite , transparent electrodes in displays and photovoltaic modules @xcite , optical modulators @xcite , plasmonic devices @xcite , microcavities @xcite , ultrafast lasers @xcite , just to cite a few .
therefore , understanding the microscopic interactions between light and matter is an essential requirement to progress these emerging research areas into technological applications .
when light arrives on a graphene sample it creates a highly non - equilibrium `` hot '' electron distribution ( he d ) , which first relaxes on an ultrafast timescale to a thermalized ( but still hot ) fermi - dirac ( fd ) distribution and then slowly cools , _ via _ optical and acoustic phonon emission , eventually reaching thermal equilibrium with the lattice .
pump - probe spectroscopy is a very effective tool to study the non - equilibrium dynamics of hot carriers and has been extensively applied to a variety of graphene samples and other carbon - based materials @xcite .
there is consensus in the literature on the fact that the time scales of the thermalization process , primarily controlled by electron - electron ( e - e ) interactions , are extremely short , of the order of tens of femtoseconds .
indeed , early theoretical calculations @xcite based on the _ equilibrium _ many - body diagrammatic perturbation theory for an interacting system of massless dirac fermions ( mdfs ) all pointed to ultrashort e - e inelastic carrier lifetimes , with a sensitive dependence on doping . of electron states .
light - gray and dark - gray shaded areas denote occupied states .
these plots correspond to a non - equilibrium hot - electron distribution .
arrows mark electron transitions from initial to final states .
the electron population in each band is conserved in ( a ) and ( b ) , but not in ( c ) and ( d ) .
( c ) and ( d ) represent `` auger processes , '' which can only take place when the wave vectors of the initial and final states are _
[ fig : scatteringprocesses ] ] the theory of the _ non - equilibrium _ dynamics of hot carriers in graphene has also been extensively investigated @xcite .
previous works , however , heavily relied on numerical analysis and did not address the following issues . when electrons in graphene are described by the low - energy 2d mdf model @xcite , a special class of two - body scattering processes poses a serious conundrum . these are `` collinear '' events , in which incoming and outgoing momenta of the scattering particles lie on the same line @xcite ( see fig . [
fig : scatteringprocesses ] ) . on one hand , due to the geometrical nature of these events , one
is very tempted to conclude that they are irrelevant , since they lie on a one dimensional ( 1d ) manifold embedded in a 2d space , i.e. a set of zero measure . as we will see in sec .
[ ssec : coulombkernel ] , this intuitive statement can be formally proven by employing conservation of energy and momentum .
thus , the phase space for collinear scattering events vanishes in the case of 2d mdf bare bands . on the other hand , when e - e interactions are taken into account going beyond the single - particle picture
, several interesting things happen .
i ) mdfs moving in a collinear way along the same directrix `` spend a lot of time together '' since they travel with the same speed @xcite , the fermi velocity @xmath1 .
they thus interact very strongly through the non - relativistic coulomb interaction . a simple analysis based on the fermi golden rule shows that this yields @xcite logarithmically - divergent quasiparticle decay rates and transport coefficients , such as viscosities and conductivities .
ii ) interactions ( even at the hartree - fock level @xcite ) are responsible for deviations of the energy - momentum dispersion relation from linearity .
the renormalized quasiparticle spectrum , controlled by the real part of the quasiparticle self - energy , displays a concave curvature @xcite , an effect that suppresses collinear scattering .
iii ) the broadening of the energy - momentum dispersion , which follows from the finiteness of the quasiparticle lifetime ( an effect beyond the hartree - fock theory ) , opens up the phase space for collinear scattering , as thoroughly discussed in sec .
[ sect : auger ] .
the broadening of the quasiparticle spectrum is controlled by the imaginary part of the quasiparticle self - energy , a quantity directly probed by angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy @xcite .
iv ) the situation is further complicated by the role of _ screening _ , a key phenomenon in systems with long - range coulomb interactions @xcite . as we will discuss in sec .
[ sect : screening ] , static screening does not have a detrimental effect on collinear scattering .
the opposite occurs when dynamical screening is considered at the level of the random phase approximation ( rpa ) .
v ) non - linearities and anisotropies in the band structure beyond the mdf model ( such as `` trigonal warping '' @xcite ) may affect the efficiency of screening .
these issues were recently addressed in ref . by means of the equilibrium many - body perturbation theory , as we will discuss in sec .
[ ssec : screeningmodels ] .
all these issues raise the following question : is collinear scattering relevant or irrelevant to understand quasiparticle dynamics and transport in graphene ?
collinear ( or forward ) scattering plays a special role in the dynamics of quasiparticles @xcite and photo - excited carriers in graphene @xcite . the finiteness of the quasiparticle lifetime on the mass shell @xcite can be traced back to the divergence of the density of electron - hole pairs in the collinear direction . in this case , it is the only configuration in which `` impact ionization '' ( imi ) and `` auger recombination '' ( ar ) processes are possible @xcite ( see fig . [
fig : scatteringprocesses ] ) .
imi and ar ( which we will refer to with the generic term `` auger processes '' ) have been studied since the later fifties @xcite . in recent years they attracted attention in the context of semiconductors @xcite and quantum dots @xcite .
imi and ar are of fundamental interest because they strongly influence the relaxation dynamics of a he d .
e.g. , ar in optically - pumped 2d electron systems in the quantum hall regime is responsible @xcite for emission from states with energy higher than those optically pumped , and thwarts the realization of a landau - level laser , i.e. a laser that would operate under the 2d landau quantization , with population inversion in the landau levels @xcite .
most importantly , auger processes can be exploited to design solar cells @xcite or other photovoltaic devices that can overcome fundamental limitations @xcite to photocurrent production by relying on `` carrier multiplication '' ( cm ) .
we reported evidence of auger processes in graphene @xcite , proving the existence of imi and cm in a short transient following ultrafast photo - excitation in the optical domain @xcite .
the excess energy of photo - excited electrons can also be transferred to secondary electron - hole pairs by intra - band scattering , _ without _ cm from the valence to conduction band .
this process , also recently experimentally demonstrated @xcite , proceeds by promotion of electrons from below to above the fermi energy and does not involve processes b)-d ) in fig .
[ fig : scatteringprocesses ] . on the other hand , refs . , by probing the non - equilibrium dynamics of mdfs by time- and angle - resolved photo - emission spectroscopy , found no evidence for cm .
we note , however , that refs . operated in a regime of pump fluences @xmath2 where cm is not expected on the basis of calculations relying on static screening @xcite .
moreover , both experiments lacked sufficient time resolution to observe cm .
indeed , the higher the pump fluence , the shorter is the time window in which cm exists @xcite .
e.g. , for a pump fluence @xmath3 as in ref .
, cm exists in a time window @xmath4 ( substantially larger than the time resolution in ref . ) .
refs . used much higher pump fluences , i.e. @xmath5 and @xmath6 , respectively .
ref . reported strong evidence of population inversion in graphene after intense photoexcitation , similar to what reported in ref .
, where evidence of stimulated emission was seen for pump fluences @xmath7 . because of the large fluences in refs .
, the existence of population inversion can not be ascribed to the absence of auger processes . in semiconductors , imi ( ar )
creates ( annihilates ) an electron - hole pair and takes place when the energy transfer to ( from ) one electron is sufficient to overcome the band gap . since graphene is a zero - gap semiconductor , the scattering rates of auger processes are generally larger than in most other common semiconductors , as discussed in ref . .
however , ref . did not address the issue of the vanishing phase space for 2d mdf bare bands .
moreover , the imi and ar rates calculated in ref .
refer to fd distributions [ eq . ( 20 ) in ref . ] , thus do not apply to generic non - equilibrium situations .
finally , ref . did not discuss the role of dynamical screening , now known to play a pivotal role in the electronic and optoelectronic properties of graphene @xcite .
here we analyze in detail the interplay between collinear scattering and e - e interactions in the context of the non - equilibrium dynamics of photo - excited electrons .
we first show that electron lifetime effects open up a finite phase space for collinear scattering processes , thereby regularizing the pathologies mentioned above . here
we consider the broadening of the energy - momentum dispersion , but we neglect its deviations from linearity due to e - e interactions . although these two effects could be treated in principle on an equal footing ( since they are described by the imaginary and real part of the quasiparticle self - energy , respectively ) , changes in the dispersion due to the real part of the quasiparticle self - energy are relevant only for low carrier densities @xcite . while our theory is general , the numerical calculations we present in sec .
[ sec : results ] are focused on a regime with large density of photo - excited carriers , @xmath8 .
this is a value that is typically used in experimental time - resolved techniques for mapping the relaxation dynamics of electron distributions @xcite .
we then discuss the contribution of collinear processes to the coulomb collision integral in the semiclassical boltzmann equation ( sbe ) , which determines , _ together _ with electron - optical phonon ( e - ph ) scattering , the early stages ( sub-@xmath0 ) of the time evolution .
most importantly , we go beyond the fermi golden rule , by introducing screening at the rpa level .
contrary to what happens in a conventional 2d parabolic - band electron gas @xcite , the introduction of _ dynamical _ screening brings in _ qualitative _ new features . on one hand ,
rpa dynamical screening represents the most natural and elementary way to regularize @xcite the logarithmic divergences of quasiparticle decay rates and transport coefficients @xcite . on the other hand , due to a @xmath9 divergence that arises in the polarization function @xcite @xmath10 of 2d mdfs when the collinear scattering condition @xmath11 is met , rpa dynamical screening
completely suppresses auger processes .
this article is organized as follows .
[ sec : hamiltonian ] describes the model mdf hamiltonian and the sbe for the coupled dynamics of electrons and optical phonons .
it also reviews the typical timescales , as set by e - e and e - ph interactions .
[ sect : collinearscattering ] introduces the isotropic sbe and discusses in detail the treatment of collinear scattering in the coulomb collision integral .
the role of screening is considered in sec .
[ sect : screening ] .
[ sec : results ] presents our main numerical results for the electron and phonon dynamics , as obtained from the solution of the isotropic sbe .
finally , sec .
[ sec : conclusions ] , summarizes our main conclusions .
carriers in graphene are described in a wide range of energies ( @xmath12 ) by the mdf hamiltonian @xcite , @xmath13 where the field operator @xmath14 annihilates an electron with 2d momentum @xmath15 , valley @xmath16 , band index @xmath17 ( or @xmath18 , @xmath19 for conduction and valence band , respectively ) , and spin @xmath20 .
the quantity @xmath21 represents the mdf band energy , with a slope @xmath22 .
mdfs interact through the non - relativistic coulomb potential @xmath23 with the following 2d fourier transform @xmath24 where @xmath25 is an average dielectric constant @xcite calculated with the dielectric constants @xmath26 and @xmath27 of the media above and below the graphene flake .
intra - valley e - e interactions are described by the following hamiltonian ( in the eigenstate representation ) : @xmath28 where @xmath29 is 2d electron system area and the delta distribution imposes momentum conservation .
the matrix element of the coulomb potential reads @xmath30 where @xmath31 / 2 $ ] is the so - called `` chirality factor '' @xcite , which depends on the polar angle @xmath32 of the wave vector @xmath33 .
the following dimensionless coupling constant @xcite controls the strength of e - e interactions ( relative to the typical kinetic energy ) : @xmath34 the distribution function @xmath35 represents the probability that a given single - particle state with quantum numbers @xmath36 is occupied .
the equation of motion ( eom ) for this distribution function in the presence of e - e interactions is given by @xcite : @xmath37~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the right - hand side of the previous equation is the collision integral and the dirac delta distributions enforce conservation of momentum and energy in each e - e scattering event .
the quantity @xcite @xmath38 in the collision integral includes a direct ( hartree ) and an exchange ( fock ) term , non - vanishing if two colliding electrons have parallel spins ( @xmath39 ) .
this expression for the kernel in the collision integral corresponds to the second - order hartree - fock approximation @xcite . if spin - flip processes are absent ( as in the case considered here ) , the distribution function does not depend on the spin label , which can be dropped .
the summation over @xmath40 in eq .
( [ eq : eescattering ] ) can be performed explicitly , obtaining the spin - independent kernel @xmath41 in agreement with ref . .
electrons scatter with lattice vibrations and lose ( gain ) energy by emitting ( absorbing ) phonons . only optical phonons in the neighborhood of the @xmath42 and @xmath43 points of the brillouin zone ( bz ) matter for electrons with energy of several hundred @xmath44 above the fermi energy . at each point , both the transverse ( t ) and the longitudinal ( l ) phonon modes are considered .
the distribution function of the @xmath45-th phonon mode with @xmath46 and 2d momentum @xmath47 is denoted by the symbol @xmath48 .
the electron - phonon ( e - ph ) contribution to the eom for the electron distribution is @xcite @xmath49\nonumber \\ & & + \frac{2 \pi}{\hbar } \frac{1}{a}~\sum_{\bm q}\sum_{s',\ell ' , \nu } { \cal a}_{0 } |g^{(\nu)}_{{\bm k } + { \bm q},\ell ' \to { \bm k},\ell}|^{2 } f_{{\bm k } + { \bm q},\ell ' , s ' } ( 1 - f_{{\bm k } , \ell , s } ) \nonumber \\ & & \times \left[\delta ( \varepsilon_{{\bm k } , s } - \varepsilon_{{\bm k } + { \bm q } , s ' } + \hbar\omega^{(\nu)}_{\bm q } ) ( n^{(\nu)}_{\bm q } + 1 ) + \delta ( \varepsilon_{{\bm k } , s } - \varepsilon_{{\bm k } + { \bm q } , s ' } - \hbar\omega^{(\nu)}_{\bm q } ) n^{(\nu)}_{\bm q } \right]~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath50 is the area of the elementary cell of graphene s honeycomb lattice .
the terms proportional to @xmath51 represent electronic transitions from the single - particle state with quantum numbers @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 , to the state @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 .
the transition is suppressed if the value @xmath58 of the distribution function in the final state is close to unity ( pauli blocking ) .
the terms proportional to @xmath59 correspond to absorption of phonons , while the terms proportional to @xmath60 correspond to emission of phonons .
the latter coefficient is larger than the former ( bose enhancement ) because phonons , being bosonic excitations , experience bunching .
the kernels @xmath61 can be written as : @xmath62 \nonumber \\ & = & \langle g_{\gamma}^{2 } \rangle [ 1 - \cos{(\theta_{{\bm k } , { \bm q } } + \theta_{{\bm k } + { \bm q } , { \bm q } } ) } ] \nonumber \\ & = & \langle g_{{\rm k},1}^{2 } \rangle \nonumber \\ & = & \langle g_{{\rm k},2}^{2 } \rangle [ 1 + \cos{(\theta_{{\bm k } , { \bm k } + { \bm q}})}]~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 denotes the angle between the wave vectors @xmath52 and @xmath47 and @xmath64 are the electron - phonon couplings ( epcs ) @xcite .
phonons at the @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) point are responsible for intra - valley ( inter - valley ) scattering only .
the complete eom for the electron distribution is the sum of eqs .
( [ eq : eescattering ] ) and ( [ eq : electronphononboltzmann ] ) , i.e. : @xmath65 finally , the sbe for the phonon distribution is : @xmath66 \nonumber \\ & & - \frac{\gamma_{\rm ph}}{\hbar } \left [ n^{(\nu)}_{\bm q } - \frac{1}{\exp{(\hbar\omega^{(\nu)}_{\bm q } / ( k_{\rm b } t_0 ) ) } - 1 } \right ] ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the right - hand side of the previous equation includes a phenomenological decay term which describes phonon - phonon interactions ( due to the anharmonicity of the lattice ) . indeed anharmonic couplings play an important role in the graphene lattice @xcite and , in principle , the decay coefficient @xmath67 could be calculated by means of atomistic monte carlo simulations based on a realistic description of interatomic interactions @xcite .
the decay term induces relaxation of the phonon distribution towards the equilibrium value , given by a bose - einstein distribution at the temperature @xmath68 of the lattice .
accurate calculations of relaxation timescales in e.g. semiconductors pose a challenging problem of great theoretical and practical relevance @xcite . in graphene ,
three stages of the time evolution have been identified @xcite , which follow the creation of a he d due to the action of a laser - light `` pump '' pulse promoting a certain density of electrons from valence to conduction band . in the first stage ,
@xmath69 , the initial he d thermalizes to a hot fd distribution and the two bands are characterized by different chemical potentials .
recently , we were able to track this initial stage with sufficient time - resolution to directly measure the transition from a non - thermal to a hot fd distribution @xcite .
cooling of the hot fd distribution and equilibration of the chemical potentials between the two bands take place in the second and third stage , where the dominant process is phonon emission .
the second stage , @xmath70 , is dominated by the emission of _ optical _ phonons @xcite , which in graphene are associated with an unusually large energy scale ( @xmath71 ) @xcite and are moderately coupled to the electronic degrees of freedom .
this cooling channel experiences a bottleneck when the phonon distribution heats up @xcite . the third stage , which occurs when the bulk of the electron distribution lies below the optical - phonon energy scale , is characterized by the emission of _ acoustic _ phonons @xcite .
these processes take place for @xmath72 , but can experience a substantial speed - up ( @xmath73 ) in the case of disorder - assisted collisions @xcite .
since here we focus on the electron relaxation dynamics in the sub-@xmath0 time scale , we neglect the contribution of acoustic phonons in our sbe formulation . throughout the relaxation dynamics ,
phonons dissipate energy into the lattice by means of phonon - phonon interactions .
in this section we simplify eqs .
( [ eq : summingrates])-([eq : phonon ] ) by assuming that the electron and phonon distributions are _ isotropic_. while this assumption does not apply _ during _ the application of the pump pulse ( since this couples anisotropically @xcite ) , it has been shown that e - e interactions restore isotropy in the very short time scale of a few fs @xcite .
hence , our assumption applies to the thermalization and cooling stages of the time evolution , i.e. what we aim to study here .
the electron distribution @xmath74 is therefore assumed to depend on the wave vector @xmath52 only through the energy @xmath75 .
similarly , the phonon distribution @xmath76 is assumed to depend only on the magnitude @xmath77 of the phonon wave vector @xmath47 .
since the slope of the phonon dispersion @xmath78 is negligible with respect to @xmath79 , we drop the momentum dependence and use constant values @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
equations for isotropic distributions can be obtained by performing the angular integrations in the collision integrals of eqs .
( [ eq : summingrates ] ) and ( [ eq : phonon ] ) .
we now outline our approach in the case of a single summation over a wave vector @xmath52 , involving a generic function @xmath82 , which depends on the direction of @xmath52 and another wave vector @xmath47 , and a functional @xmath83 $ ] , which depends only on the isotropic quantities @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
we have @xcite : @xmath86 \nonumber \\ & & = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } d\varepsilon ' \ , \int_{-\infty}^{\infty}d\varepsilon '' \ , { \cal f}[\varepsilon',\varepsilon '' ] { \cal q}[\varepsilon',\varepsilon'']~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the kernel @xmath87 = \sum_{\bm k } \delta ( \varepsilon ' -\varepsilon_{{\bm k},s } ) \delta ( \varepsilon '' - \varepsilon_{{\bm k } + { \bm q},s ' } ) g({\bm k } , { \bm q})$ ] depends now only on isotropic quantities . the calculation of the isotropic kernels in eqs .
( [ eq : summingrates ] ) and ( [ eq : phonon ] ) is summarized in the following .
this approach is convenient from a computational point of view since it reduces the number of variables in the integrations that have to be carried out numerically ( see app .
[ ssec : numerical ] ) .
most importantly , it also allows us to handle analytically the contribution of collinear scattering to the e - e interaction in the boltzmann collision integral .
the final results for the e - ph contributions are : @xmath88 \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } d\varepsilon f_{\ell}(\varepsilon)[1-f_{\ell'}(\varepsilon^{(\nu,-)})]{\cal q}^{(\nu,-)}_{\ell,\ell'}(\varepsilon , q ) \nonumber \\ & - & n^{(\nu)}(q ) \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } d\varepsilon f_{\ell}(\varepsilon)[1-f_{\ell'}(\varepsilon^{(\nu,+ ) } ) ] { \cal q}^{(\nu,+)}_{\ell,\ell'}(\varepsilon , q ) \bigg\ } - \frac{\gamma_{\rm ph}}{\hbar } \left [ n^{(\nu)}(q ) - \frac{1}{\exp{(\hbar\omega^{(\nu ) } / ( k_{\rm b } t_{0 } ) ) } - 1 } \right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath89 \int_{0}^{\infty } dq ( \hbar v_{\rm f})[n^{(\nu)}(q ) + 1]~{\cal i}^{(\nu,-)}_{\ell,\ell'}(\varepsilon , q ) \nonumber\\ & - & f_{\ell}(\varepsilon)[1-f_{\ell'}(\varepsilon^{(\nu,+)})]\int_{0}^{\infty } dq ( \hbar v_{\rm f } ) n^{(\nu)}(q)~{\cal i}^{(\nu,+)}_{\ell,\ell'}(\varepsilon , q ) \nonumber \\ & + & f_{\ell'}(\varepsilon^{(\nu,+ ) } ) [ 1-f_{\ell}(\varepsilon)]\int_{0}^{\infty } dq ( \hbar v_{\rm f } ) [ n^{(\nu)}(q ) + 1]~{\cal i}^{(\nu,+)}_{\ell,\ell'}(\varepsilon , q ) \nonumber \\ & + & f_{\ell'}(\varepsilon^{(\nu,- ) } ) [ 1-f_{\ell}(\varepsilon ) ] \int_{0}^{\infty } dq ( \hbar v_{\rm f } ) n^{(\nu)}(q ) ~ { \cal i}^{(\nu,-)}_{\ell,\ell'}(\varepsilon , q)\bigg\}~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the shorthand @xmath90 . in eqs .
( [ eq : phononsisotropic])-([eq : electronsphononsisotropic ] ) , we introduced the following functions : @xmath91\ ] ] and @xmath92 with @xmath93 \equiv \theta(x_{0 } - |x_{1 } - 1| ) \theta(x_{1 } + 1 - x_{0 } ) \nonumber \\ & & \times \frac{2 x_{0}}{\sqrt{4x_{1}^{2}-(x_{0}^{2}-x_{1}^{2}-1)^{2 } } } \nonumber \\ & & \times { \cal f } \left ( x_{1},\arccos[(x_{0}^{2 } - x_{1}^{2 } - 1)/(2 x_{1 } ) ] \right ) ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath94 is the heaviside distribution and the quantities @xmath95 are dimensionless . for notational convenience ,
we write the wave vector dependence of the e - ph kernel @xmath96 in the form @xmath97 , where @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
finally , the e - e contribution reads @xmath100 [ 1 - f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{2})]f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{3 } ) f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{4 } ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & - \left .
f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{1 } ) f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{2 } ) [ 1 - f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{3})][1 - f_{\ell}(\varepsilon_{4 } ) ] \right \rbrace~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the coulomb kernel @xmath101 , with physical dimensions @xmath102 , represents a two - particle scattering rate .
the energies of the incoming ( with indexes @xmath103 and @xmath104 ) and outgoing particles ( with indexes @xmath105 , @xmath106 ) are fixed .
the total energy @xmath107 is conserved and , finally , @xmath108 . simplifying eq .
( [ eq : eescattering ] ) along the lines of eq .
( [ eq : haugtrick ] ) leads to the following expression for the coulomb kernel : @xmath109 here , the wave vector @xmath110 has modulus @xmath111 , while its direction can be fixed at will ( i.e. along the @xmath112 axis ) because the final result @xmath113 is scalar under rotations .
the total wave vector @xmath114 is conserved in all scattering processes . in the summation over @xmath115 and @xmath116 ,
the dirac delta distributions ensure that only scattering configurations that are compatible with the choice of incoming @xmath117 and outgoing @xmath118 energies are considered . moreover , the three delta distributions restrict the 4d integral to a 1d integral ( at most ) , after the usual continuum limit @xmath119 is performed .
we choose to reduce the summations to an integration over the modulus @xmath120 of the total momentum , in terms of which we are able to represent with clarity the phase space available for coulomb scattering ( see fig . [
fig : integrationdomain ] ) .
we stress that in eq .
( [ eq : coulombkernel ] ) we introduced an _ infinitesimal _
quantity @xmath121 in the argument of one of the delta distributions .
as we will see in the next section , if the limit @xmath122 is taken _ before _ calculating the 4d integral in eq .
( [ eq : coulombkernel ] ) , collinear scattering processes do not contribute to @xmath113 .
we introduced @xmath121 to slightly relax the condition of energy conservation .
the latter is recovered only in the limit @xmath122 .
we can justify this by considering the following physical explanation .
the delta distribution of conservation of energy in eq .
( [ eq : eescattering ] ) originates from the so - called `` quasiparticle approximation , '' applied to the kadanoff - baym equations ( kbes ) , from which the sbe is derived @xcite .
more precisely , the kbes involve the true quasiparticle spectral function , which has a finite width . in the quasiparticle approximation
, the spectral function is substituted with a delta distribution , which is a reasonable approximation when the width of the quasiparticle spectral function can be neglected . as we will see in this section ,
in the quasiparticle approximation applied to 2d mdfs an entire class of two - body collisions ( collinear processes ) yields vanishing scattering rates .
our procedure takes effectively into account the fact that quasiparticles have a finite lifetime @xcite , thereby allowing for a finite collinear scattering contribution to the coulomb kernel .
we first calculate the coulomb kernel with a finite @xmath121 and then apply the quasiparticle @xmath122 approximation at the end of the calculation . to make analytical progress , we now introduce elliptic coordinates for the evaluation of the coulomb kernel @xcite .
this is most natural because , for every fixed value of @xmath115 , the equation @xmath123 for the total energy defines a conic section in momentum space .
more precisely , if @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) , the vector @xmath126 lies on an ellipse ( hyperbola ) with focuses located at @xmath127 and major axis of length @xmath128 .
elliptic coordinates @xmath129 are related to the cartesian coordinates @xmath130 by the transformation @xmath131 , @xmath132 , with area element @xmath133 \ , du \ , dv$ ] . in these coordinates ,
@xmath134 $ ] and @xmath135 $ ] , so that non - linear combinations between integration variables in eq .
( [ eq : coulombkernel ] ) disappear .
elliptic coordinates are also extremely useful to prove that imi and ar can only occur when @xmath136 are collinear ( see figs .
4a and b in ref . ) . carrying out algebraic manipulations , we rewrite eq .
( [ eq : coulombkernel ] ) in the following simplified manner : @xmath137[(\hbar v_{\rm f } q)^{2 } - e_{1,{\rm min}}^{2 } ] \right \rbrace ^{1/2 } } \frac { ( e_{3,{\rm max } } + \eta)^{2 } - ( e_{3,{\rm min } } - \eta)^{2 } } { \left \lbrace [ ( e_{3,{\rm max}}+\eta)^{2 } - ( \hbar v_{\rm f } q)^{2}][(\hbar v_{\rm f } q)^{2 } - ( e_{3,{\rm min } } - \eta)^{2 } ] \right \rbrace ^{1/2}}~. \nonumber \\ % \end{aligned}\ ] ] we stress that this is the most important analytical result of this article . note that the integrand in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) is given by the product of the kernel ( [ eq : matrixelementsummed ] ) and a complicated expression arising from the phase space of the e - e scattering processes , the term in the second line of eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) . in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) , @xmath138 and the dependence of @xmath33 on @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath139 , and @xmath120 is left implicit for the sake of simplicity .
the primed sum symbol indicates summation over the available configurations of vectors @xmath140 , @xmath116 , and @xmath141 . to identify these configuration ,
one may proceed as follows .
when @xmath117 , @xmath118 , @xmath139 , and @xmath120 are given , the lengths of all the sides of the two triangles @xmath142 and @xmath143 are uniquely fixed .
these two triangles , which share the side of length @xmath120 , can be drawn on the same half - plane ( with respect to a line containing the vector @xmath115 ) or on opposite half - planes .
thus , four geometric configurations for the wave vectors @xmath140 , @xmath116 , and @xmath141 are available in total . however ,
when all vectors @xmath33 are collinear , the triangles are degenerate and only one configuration is possible . finally , in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) we also introduced @xmath144 , @xmath145 , and @xmath146 let us first discuss the case in which @xmath121 is set to zero before carrying out the integral in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) . in this case
, one can prove that @xmath147 by using the triangular and reverse triangular inequalities , @xmath148 .
when the previous inequalities turn into equalities , the length of the vector @xmath115 is fixed at @xmath149 , @xmath150 , and the integration domain vanishes . ) for the variable @xmath120 in the integral ( eq.[eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) . the regions labeled by i ,
ii , and iii identify the values of the parameters @xmath151 and @xmath152 for which intra - band , inter - band , and auger processes take place , respectively . at @xmath149 collinear
scattering takes place .
this value is the maximum ( minimum ) of the integration domain in region i ( ii ) .
the minimum ( maximum ) of the integration domain in region i ( ii ) is shown in the color scale , in units of @xmath128 .
[ fig : integrationdomain ] ] fig .
[ fig : integrationdomain ] plots the integration domain relative to the variable @xmath120 in eq .
( [ eq : integrationdomain ] ) , as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath118 , in the case @xmath153 . in region
i , @xmath154 implies @xmath155 ( if the total energy is negative , all the inequalities are reversed ) .
all the particles are either above ( @xmath156 ) or below ( @xmath157 ) the dirac point .
region i , therefore , pertains to intra - band scattering events .
similarly , one concludes that regions of type ii pertain to inter - band scattering ( two electrons are in opposite bands before and after the scattering ) .
finally , regions of type iii pertain to imi and ar . in these regions
the integration domain [ and , therefore , @xmath158 in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) vanishes .
we note that classification of regions i , ii , and iii holds true for arbitrary values of @xmath121 .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) is extremely helpful since it can be used to solve the sbe ( [ eq : summingrates ] ) with arbitrary non - equilibrium initial conditions , more so since analytical expressions for the coulomb kernel of 2d mdfs such as that in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) were not reported before , to the best of our knowledge .
we now proceed to calculate @xmath159 in regions of type iii . in this case
, a finite value of @xmath121 restores a non - vanishing integration domain for imi and ar and a finite contribution to @xmath159 due to these processes .
note that the sign of @xmath121 should be chosen such that @xmath160 .
let us consider , for the sake of definiteness , the region of type iii where @xmath161 .
we have @xmath162 .
the integrand in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) factors into two portions , one that depends smoothly on @xmath120 and can therefore be evaluated at @xmath163 and taken out of the integral , and another singular at the boundaries of the integration domain .
the integral of the latter part must be carefully evaluated and is : @xmath164^{1/2 } } = \pi~.\ ] ] note that the result of the previous integral does _ not _ depend on @xmath121 , therefore remains finite in the limit @xmath122 .
the final result for the auger contribution to the coulomb kernel , valid in _ all _ regions of type iii , can be written as : @xmath165 where the convention for @xmath166 and @xmath33 has been introduced after eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) . the term on the second line of eq .
( [ eq : augerresult ] ) comes from the smooth portion of the integrand in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) .
we stress that eq .
( [ eq : augerresult ] ) follows from the general expression ( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) without _ a priori _ restrictions to collinear scattering configurations .
although eq .
( [ eq : augerresult ] ) mathematically coincides with eq . ( 14 ) of ref . , ref .
does not report any discussion on how to bypass the vanishing phase space problem for 2d mdfs . here , the finiteness of imi and ar contributions to the coulomb kernel , as for eq .
( [ eq : augerresult ] ) , originates from electron - lifetime effects .
incidentally , since the value of the integral in eq .
( [ eq : abeautifulintegral ] ) does not depend on the value of @xmath121 , the precise mechanism ( e - e interactions , electron - impurity scattering , etc . )
responsible for the broadening of the delta distribution in eq .
( [ eq : eescattering ] ) into a finite - width quasiparticle spectral function is unimportant .
finally , we emphasize that imi and ar scattering rates were calculated in ref . for fd distributions only , as seen in eq .
( 20 ) of ref . .
on the contrary , eqs .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) and ( [ eq : augerresult ] ) can be used to solve the sbe ( [ eq : summingrates ] ) with _ arbitrary _ non - equilibrium initial conditions .
we finally consider @xmath159 in regions of type i and ii .
the integrand in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) diverges as @xmath167 for @xmath168 , which coincides with the upper @xmath169 or lower @xmath170 boundaries of the integration domain for regions of type i and ii . when @xmath168 , intra - band or inter - band scattering occur in a collinear fashion .
this strong divergence of the integrand physically arises from the expression for the phase space of e - e scattering , while @xmath171 is well behaved .
therefore , @xmath159 diverges for both intra - band and inter - band scattering processes .
a possible way to cure this divergence @xcite is to introduce an ultraviolet cut - off @xmath172 , which yields a coulomb kernel @xmath173 .
logarithmic enhancements for 2d fermions with a linear dispersion were discussed in ref . , and allow one to find a sbe solution in the form of an effective equilibrium distribution , with parameters depending on the direction of motion @xcite .
peculiar properties of mdfs , which are sensitive to collinear scattering , include a finite conductivity in the absence of impurities @xcite and an unusually low shear viscosity @xcite . a different way to treat this divergence is to invoke _ screening _ , which suppresses the kernel @xmath174 and regularizes the behavior of the integrand in a neighborhood of @xmath149 .
this approach is discussed in the next section in great detail .
the sbe is a second - order expression in the _ bare _ coulomb potential @xmath175 and describes e - e interactions at level of the fermi golden rule @xcite .
this approximation neglects many - body effects , and most importantly electronic screening .
formally , screening can be taken into account @xcite by substituting the bare coulomb potential @xmath176 with a _ screened _ potential @xmath177 . when the 2d mdf system is out of equilibrium , the screening properties change in time and the screened potential depends on time @xmath178 as well .
it has been pointed out @xcite that screening may preempt the strong collinear scattering singularity mentioned above and suppress auger processes .
indeed , the rpa dynamical dielectric function at equilibrium @xmath179 diverges for collinear scattering configurations for which @xmath11 ( see sec . [ ssec : dielectric ] ) . when substituted into eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) , the screened potential @xmath177 vanishes like @xmath180 , thereby compensating the aforementioned divergence arising from the expression of the phase space .
the integral in eq .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) is then finite , while the contribution to the coulomb kernel due to auger processes vanishes .
the matrix element of the screened potential is obtained by the replacement : @xmath181 where @xmath182 is defined in eq .
( [ eq : matrixinteraction ] ) and @xmath179 is the dynamical dielectric function @xcite
. here , @xmath183 and @xmath184 are the momentum and energy transferred in the scattering process , respectively .
we stress that the prescription ( [ eq : screenedpotential ] ) must be applied only to the first term on the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) , i.e. to the _ direct _ term . in principle , one could apply eq .
( [ eq : screenedpotential ] ) to screen both direct and exchange contributions in eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) .
the latter procedure was previously used in refs . to compute scattering rates , but has a major drawback : it is easy to see that the corresponding sbe does _ not _ conserve the particle number . in other words , the approximation obtained by screening both direct and exchange terms in eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) according to eq .
( [ eq : screenedpotential ] ) is not conserving in the sense of kadanoff and baym @xcite . on the contrary , retaining the direct term only corresponds to the well - known shielded potential approximation " @xcite , which is conserving in the sense of kadanoff and baym .
this is the approach we follow below , setting @xmath185 in eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) . in the rpa
, the dielectric function is given by @xcite @xmath186 where @xmath175 is the bare coulomb potential , defined in eq .
( [ eq : coulomb ] ) , and @xmath10 is the non - interacting polarization function @xcite ( or lindhard function ) for 2d mdfs : @xmath187 where @xmath188/2 $ ] and the factor @xmath189 accounts for spin degeneracy .
it is intended that @xmath179 and @xmath10 depend _ explicitly on time _ @xmath178 through the time - dependence of the distribution function @xmath74 .
one route to include screening in the sbe calculations is to compute @xcite the polarization function @xmath10 at each time @xmath178 according to eq .
( [ eq : polarization ] ) and use it to evaluate the expressions ( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) and ( [ eq : augerresult ] ) for the coulomb kernel . in this article , however , we prefer to use a more analytical approach , which turns out to reduce dramatically the computational costs associated with solving the sbe with screening . since thermalization occurs on a very fast time scale @xcite , we calculated the polarization function analytically by employing the following _ thermal _ ansatz for the distribution function @xmath74 in eq .
( [ eq : polarization ] ) : @xmath190 where @xmath191 } + 1}\ ] ] is the usual fd distribution . in eq .
( [ eq : distrotwomu ] ) , @xmath192 and @xmath193 are chemical potentials in conduction and valence band , respectively , and @xmath194 is the temperature .
the values of the three parameters @xmath192 , @xmath193 , and @xmath194 can be obtained at each time @xmath178 by fitting eq .
( [ eq : distrotwomu ] ) to the he d derived by solving the sbe . in writing eq .
( [ eq : distrotwomu ] ) we assumed that conduction- and valence - band electrons thermalize at the same @xmath194 .
this approximation is certainly valid for times longer than @xmath195 ( see sec . [
ssec : timescales ] ) , because energy equilibration between the two bands sets in on the time scale induced by e - e interactions . at earlier times , the estimate of @xmath194 and @xmath196 obtained by fitting the profile ( [ eq : distrotwomu ] ) to the he d is certainly not precise , but can be improved _ a posteriori _ by extrapolating to @xmath69 the results of the fits obtained at later times .
although a common @xmath194 between the two bands is established in the very early stages of the dynamics , carrier equilibration between the two bands , on the contrary , is mainly due to phonon - assisted inter - band transitions , which act on a much longer time scale ( @xmath197 ) . assuming two different chemical potentials is thus essential to obtain a correct representation of screening in the non - equilibrium dynamics after photo - excitation .
our analytical approach to the calculation of @xmath10 allows us to describe well the rapidly changing dielectric function and , at the same time , to determine analytically its behavior for collinear configurations , crucial to the issues discussed in sec .
[ ssec : divergencies ] .
in the rest of this section we outline the calculation of the polarization function of a photo - excited 2d mdf fluid .
we start by noting that the polarization function @xmath10 as obtained from eq .
( [ eq : polarization ] ) with the thermal ansatz ( eq.[eq : distrotwomu ] ) physically represents the polarization function @xmath198 of a 2d mdf fluid with _ two _ chemical potentials @xmath192 and @xmath193 , at a finite @xmath194 . to the best of our knowledge
, this function is unknown .
we therefore proceed to calculate @xmath198 following a well - known procedure due to maldague @xcite .
this route allows us to write this polarization function in terms of an integral involving the well - known lindhard function @xmath199 of a 2d mdf fluid at zero @xmath194 and at a fermi energy @xmath200
the final result is : @xmath201 \nonumber \\ & & - \left .
\pi_0(q,\omega)\right|_{\varepsilon_{\rm f } \to 0 } \left [ f(0;\mu_{\rm c},t ) - f(0;\mu_{\rm v},t ) \right ] ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath202 note that @xmath199 is particle - hole symmetric ( therefore identical for positive and negative values of the fermi energy @xmath200 ) and that @xmath203 is the lindhard function of an undoped 2d mdf system @xcite .
here we have @xmath204 .
eq . ( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) is the main result of this section and reveals that the thermal polarization function @xmath198 naturally decomposes into the sum of two contributions stemming from each band .
however , the extra correction in the second line of eq .
( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) needs to be taken into account at finite @xmath194 .
the following three identities are necessary to derive eq .
( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) : i ) @xmath205 , ii ) @xmath206 f(\varepsilon;0,0)$ ] , and iii ) @xmath207 illustrative plots of the real and imaginary parts of the polarization function ( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) are reported in figs .
[ fig : chi2d],[fig : chicuts ] . in these plots
we rescaled @xmath208 with the conduction - band fermi energy @xmath209 , @xmath210 and the wave vector @xmath77 with the conduction - band fermi wave number @xmath211 . in eq .
( [ eq : fermienergyconduction ] ) , @xmath212 is the spence s function @xcite .
we note that the reactive part of the polarization function manifests a singularity along the `` light cone '' @xmath213 , entirely inherited from @xmath199 .
the dissipative part displays a striking difference with respect to @xmath214 $ ] : the usual triangular region above the light cone where both intra- and inter - band particle - hole pairs are suppressed @xcite is not present in fig . [
fig : chi2d](b ) .
moreover , above the light cone and for @xmath215 , a region where the imaginary part of @xmath216 is _ positive _ appears .
fig03(2,60)(a ) fig04(2,60)(b ) fig05(2,60)(a ) fig06(2,60)(b ) here we approximate the time - dependent polarization function @xmath10 in eq .
( [ eq : polarization ] ) as : @xmath217 in this article we focus on the following three screening models : \i ) _ dynamical screening_. in this case the polarization function @xmath216 in eq .
( [ eq : finalapproximation ] ) is evaluated on shell " , i.e. at @xmath218 , which is the energy transferred in the two - body scattering process .
as mentioned above , in this case inter - band and intra - band scattering rates are finite while the auger contribution ( [ eq : augerresult ] ) to the coulomb kernel vanishes .
static screening_. in this case the polarization function @xmath216 in eq .
( [ eq : finalapproximation ] ) is evaluated at @xmath219 .
this approximation is justified when the energy @xmath218 transferred in the two - body scattering process is significantly smaller than the energy @xmath220 , necessary to excite a plasmon @xcite . in the static screening approximation ,
inter - band and intra - band scattering rates diverge and can be regularized by employing an infrared and an ultraviolet cutoff @xcite ( further details are reported in the appendix ) .
we find , however , that the resulting non - equilibrium dynamics does not depend on the values of these two cutoffs .
the reason is the following .
intra- and inter - band scattering processes are responsible only for redistributing energy , rapidly driving the two bands towards thermal equilibrium .
therefore , for @xmath151 and @xmath152 varying in regions of type i and ii ( see fig . [ fig : integrationdomain ] ) the quantity in curly brackets in eq .
( [ eq : finalboltzmann ] ) vanishes . in the static approximation the auger contribution ( [ eq : augerresult ] ) to the coulomb kernel is finite .
\iii ) _ regularized screening_. finally , we introduce a `` regularized '' screening model @xcite in which the polarization function @xmath216 in eq .
( [ eq : finalapproximation ] ) is evaluated on shell , but its singularity around the light cone @xmath213 is _ smeared _ by means of a cutoff @xmath221 ( see app .
[ ssec : numerical ] for more details ) . in the limit
@xmath222 this model reduces to dynamical screening , as described at point i ) above .
various physical mechanisms can smear the singularity of the polarization function on the light cone , including many - body effects beyond rpa ( as suggested in ref . ) or single - particle effects beyond the 2d mdf model , e.g. trigonal warping ( as suggested in ref . ) . in our regularized screening model
the auger contribution ( [ eq : augerresult ] ) to the coulomb kernel is finite and , in particular , its magnitude is intermediate between that evaluated within the dynamical and static screening models .
in this section we summarize our main numerical results , obtained from the solution of the isotropic sbe within the three screening models listed in sec .
[ ssec : screeningmodels ] .
we compared the outcome of a closely related approach with our experimental measurements in ref . .
there we applied screening to both direct and exchange terms in eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) .
the data that we present in this section are in agreement with our previous results in ref . , therefore fully support the interpretation of the experimental data given there . more precisely ,
very good quantitative agreement is found for the static and dynamical screening models , which do not depend on free parameters .
there are some differences , however , between the dynamical behavior illustrated in ref . and that discussed in this section , when the regularized screening model is used .
although the mathematical definition of the cutoff @xmath221 here is analogous to the definition of @xmath172 in ref . , the equations of motion induced by the regularized screening models differ .
as repeatedly stressed above , in the present paper we never screen dynamically the exchange contribution to eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) .
moreover , here we mostly focus on undoped samples , although some results for @xmath223-doping are presented in fig .
[ fig : maximumtransmission ] . on the other hand , ref . reported experiments and calculations for a @xmath224-doped sample . even though ref .
already allowed us to conclude that rpa dynamical screening is not capable of explaining the experimental results , in this article for sake of completeness we will present a comparative study of all screening models listed in sec . [ ssec : screeningmodels ] . as initial condition for the solution of the sbe we use a distribution function which is the sum of a fd distribution , with chemical potential @xmath225 and temperature @xmath68 , and two gaussian - shaped peaks ( one below and one above the dirac point ) : @xmath226}\nonumber\\ & - & g_{\rm max } \exp{\left[-\left(\frac{\varepsilon + \hbar \omega_{\rm p}/2}{\hbar \delta \omega_{\rm p}/2}\right)^2\right]}~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the initial distribution function is identical in both @xmath16 valleys .
the choice ( [ eq : initialstate ] ) is motivated by pump - probe spectroscopy experiments on graphene , where electrons are promoted from valence to conduction band by using a laser light pulse . before the pump pulse
is applied , the electronic subsystem is at equilibrium with the lattice at a given @xmath194 , say @xmath227 ( room @xmath194 ) .
the momentum transferred by the laser light to the electrons is negligible , hence the transitions are `` vertical '' in momentum space , from energy @xmath228 in valence band to energy @xmath229 in conduction band . the width @xmath230 of the light pulse determines the width of the resulting he d .
consistent with our recent experiments @xcite , and for the sake of definiteness , we take @xmath231 , @xmath232 , and @xmath233 .
we point out that these parameters correspond to a strongly non - equilibrium distribution , obtained by shining a light pulse with fluence @xmath234 .
finally , we note that , although in general the light - matter coupling is anisotropic , the he d has been shown to relax to an isotropic profile in @xmath235 @xcite . as we mentioned above ,
the description of these very early stages of the non - equilibrium dynamics , which comprise the buildup of the he d , is beyond the scope of the present article . here
, we study the time evolution of the isotropic initial state ( [ eq : initialstate ] ) , as dictated by the sbe .
the energies of the phonon modes are @xcite @xmath236 and @xmath237 .
the epc of the @xmath238 phonon at the brillouin - zone center ( @xmath42 point ) , associated to the @xmath239 peak of the raman spectrum , is taken from ref . :
this value , which we use in our numerical calculations , is in good agreement with experimental results @xcite . on the other hand ,
the value of the epc relative to the transverse mode at the @xmath43 point has been debated @xcite .
the value calculated by density - functional theory @xcite is @xmath241 , but e - e interactions renormalize this value by a factor @xmath242 @xcite . in our numerical calculations
we take @xmath243 .
the epc of the longitudinal phonon mode at @xmath43 point is taken to be @xmath244 , as in ref . .
following ref . , we take @xmath245 for the phenomenological phonon decay rate in eq .
( [ eq : phonon ] ) .
fig07a(2,60)(a ) fig07b(2,60)(b ) fig08(2,60)(c ) fig09(2,60)(a ) fig10(2,60)(b ) we start by discussing the role of different screening models , and choose a strength of e - e interactions @xmath246 , appropriate @xcite for graphene on a sio@xmath247 substrate , see eq .
( [ eq : fsc ] ) . the corresponding sbe solution for undoped graphene
is shown in panels ( a)(c ) of fig .
[ fig : evolutiondistro ] for static , regularized , and dynamical screening , respectively . in all cases
we see that the peak ( dip ) of the he d above ( below ) the dirac point shifts rapidly towards the dirac point .
there is however a striking difference between panels ( a),(b ) and panel ( c ) : in dynamical screening , panel ( c ) , a much larger electron ( hole ) population persists in conduction ( valence ) band even at times as long as @xmath248 .
the reason is that dynamical screening suppresses ar events , thus delays equilibration of the electron populations across the two bands .
indeed , in the initial stage of the time evolution , auger processes are the most important processes for the equilibration of the electron populations . on a longer time scale ,
relaxation by phonon emission allows the system to reach inter - band equilibrium .
however , in this case , the existence of a substantial inverted carrier population around the dirac point at times as long as @xmath249 is due to the suppression of ar processes .
we point out that thermal equilibrium between the two bands , on the contrary , mainly occurs _ via _
inter - band scattering , and is reached after a much shorter time @xmath195 . a more quantitative analysis of the inter - band equilibration dynamics is shown fig .
[ fig : thermalization ] . here
we also report numerical results based on the regularized screening model .
a fd distribution with time - dependent temperature @xmath250 and chemical potential @xmath251 [ @xmath252 in conduction ( valence ) band can be fitted to the numerical results from the solution of the isotropic sbe for @xmath253 .
@xmath250 remains well above room @xmath194 for @xmath254 . in the absence of ar processes , a much faster cooling of the initial he d occurs , at the price of a larger chemical potential @xmath251 in conduction band .
the energy stored in the electronic degrees of freedom is then transferred to the phonon modes and dissipated into the lattice by means of phonon - phonon interactions , responsible for the phenomenological decay term proportional to @xmath67 in eq .
( [ eq : phonon ] ) .
eventually , equilibration with the lattice at room @xmath250 is achieved ( data not shown ) . figs .
[ fig : evolutiondistro ] , [ fig : thermalization ] indicate that different screening models strongly affect the he d time evolution . per unit cell area and energy obtained from the numerical solution of the isotropic sbe as a function of energy @xmath255 ( in units of @xmath256 ) .
black curves refer to @xmath257 .
gray curves to @xmath248 .
different line styles refer to the three screening models : static ( dashed lines ) , regularized ( solid lines ) , and dynamical ( dotted lines ) .
the initial state at @xmath258 ( dash - dotted line ) was divided by a factor @xmath105 to fit into the frame of the figure.[fig : evolutiondensity ] ] time evolution of the differential transmission @xmath259 as calculated from the numerical solution of the sbe .
different line styles refer to the three screening models : static ( dashed line ) , regularized ( solid line ) , and dynamical ( dotted line ) .
the data in this figure refer to a probe energy @xmath260 .
each curve is normalized to have maximum @xmath261 .
note that dynamical screening gives a much slower time evolution since it completely suppresses auger scattering . ] in fig .
[ fig : evolutiondensity ] we illustrate the dependence of the electron density per unit cell area and energy , @xmath262 on the energy @xmath255 .
note that @xmath263 has dimensions @xmath264 . in eq .
( [ densityversusenergy ] ) @xmath265 is the 2d mdf density of states as a function of energy . the quantity @xmath266 represents the valley degeneracy .
the energy at which @xmath263 peaks strongly depends on the screening model .
the optical properties of the mdf system are very sensitive to the time evolution of @xmath263 since light absorption is strongly inhibited ( pauli blocking ) when the corresponding electronic transitions are towards states with a larger occupation . by shining a probe laser pulse with frequency @xmath267 through the sample
one can measure the time evolution of the electron distribution , a procedure enabled by pauli blocking . a viable experimental route to directly measure the impact of screening is thus available , provided that short enough probe pulses of appropriate frequency are used @xcite .
the propagation of the probe pulse through the sample can be quantified by calculating the differential transmission @xcite ( dt ) @xmath268~ , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath269 is the fine - structure constant and @xmath225 and @xmath68 are the chemical potential and temperature of the electron system before the pump pulse is applied .
the time evolution of the normalized dt is shown in fig .
[ fig : transmission ] for the three screening models , at a fixed value of the probe energy @xmath270 .
the much slower dynamics in the absence of auger processes ( dynamical screening , dotted line ) is clearly seen .
the time @xmath271 at which the dt peaks is a convenient measure of the speed of the electron dynamics .
below we discuss the dependence of @xmath271 on various relevant parameters , see fig .
[ fig : maximumtransmission ] . as a function of wave vector @xmath272 ( in @xmath273 ) and time @xmath178 ( in units of @xmath274 ) , showing the distribution function @xmath275 for the transverse phonon mode at @xmath43 ( @xmath276 ) .
the inset shows the same quantity at @xmath248.[fig : evolutionphonon ] ] although the focus of the present article is on the time evolution of the electron distribution function , for the sake of completeness in fig .
[ fig : evolutionphonon ] we illustrate the time evolution of the distribution function of the transverse optical phonon mode at @xmath43 , i.e. the mode most strongly coupled to the electronic subsystem @xcite . in a sub-@xmath0 time
a large population accumulates in the mode ( with respect to the equilibrium population ) and remains steady up to the maximum time @xmath248 considered here .
this hot phonon distribution @xcite cools on a longer time scale as outlined in sec .
[ ssec : timescales ] by anharmonic phonon - phonon interactions , which dissipate the thermal energy into the lattice .
thus , electronic screening is responsible for qualitative modifications of the dynamics in the sub-@xmath0 time scale , which were not unveiled previously to the best of our knowledge .
this early stage of the dynamics is temporally decoupled from other relaxation channels ( phonon and radiative emission ) , thus the effects of electronic screening do not modify the hot - electron relaxation picture as outlined in sec .
[ ssec : timescales ] . at later times
, our numerical results broadly agree with previous theoretical works @xcite .
fig14(2,60)(a ) fig15(2,60)(b ) fig16(2,60)(a ) fig17(2,60)(b ) we now show that the results presented in the previous section are robust with respect to changes in parameter space .
we find that , to a large extent , the speed of the relaxation dynamics in the sub-@xmath0 time range is controlled by the particular screening model one chooses .
[ fig : maximumtransmission](a ) plots @xmath271 as a function of @xmath277 for two choices of the largest epc , @xmath278 , gray - shading the region in - between . the largest epc ( then used in all other figures ) yields the smallest @xmath271 , i.e. a faster relaxation dynamics .
this is due to the fact that a larger coupling of the electrons to the phonon bath allows a more efficient dissipation of the excess energy .
the dt peaks later for smaller energy , reflecting the shifting of the peak of the electron density @xmath263 towards the dirac point ( see fig . [
fig : evolutiondensity ] ) .
the three screening models give quantitatively different results , with static screening remaining in the sub-@xmath0 range , and dynamical screening showing a much more pronounced dependence on electron energy .
most importantly , there is very limited overlap between gray - shaded regions , meaning that the three screening models yield distinctly different relaxation speeds , even if the epc is increased by a factor @xmath104 .
these results are robust with respect to doping : fig .
[ fig : maximumtransmission](b ) , e.g. , illustrates essentially unchanged results for an @xmath223-doped sample , with a finite positive chemical potential @xmath279 . fig .
[ fig : effectsee ] compares the time evolution of the electron density @xmath263 as calculated for @xmath246 , with results obtained for @xmath280 ( describing graphene on hexagonal boron nitride @xcite ) and @xmath281 , the maximum value corresponding to a suspended graphene @xcite .
as expected , the broadening of the initial photo - excited electron distribution is faster for larger @xmath282 ( due to enhanced coulomb repulsion ) but , in general , @xmath263 at a given @xmath178 depends weakly on the e - e interaction strength . using regularized dynamical screening instead of static further reduces the effects of increasing @xmath282 .
this behavior can be understood by recalling that electron thermalization takes place in a sub-@xmath283 time interval , as pointed out earlier @xcite .
this means that the electron distribution rapidly reaches the form of a quasi - equilibrium fd distribution which nullifies the intra- and inter - band contributions of the collisional integral ( eq.[eq : finalboltzmann ] ) , as remarked in sec .
[ ssec : screeningmodels ] as well .
variations in the the e - e coupling constant , which multiplies the collisional integral , contribute minor corrections to the dynamics in the collisional regime . and _
static screening_. black ( gray ) lines refer to @xmath284 ( @xmath285 ) .
solid ( dashed ) lines refer to results without ( with ) the exchange contribution to the scattering amplitude , second term in eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) .
the initial state at @xmath258 ( dash - dotted line ) is divided by a factor @xmath105 to fit into the frame of the figure.[fig : effectsexchange ] ] finally , fig .
[ fig : effectsexchange ] shows the role of the exchange term @xmath286 in eq .
( [ eq : hf ] ) , by treating screening statically to ensure a particle - number - conserving collision integral . in this case
@xmath287 is calculated at @xmath288 for the direct term and at @xmath289 for the exchange term . as clearly seen in fig .
[ fig : effectsexchange ] , the exchange term is responsible for small corrections to the electron density @xmath263 , although it is expected @xcite that larger corrections may arise in a fermi liquid when perturbations are applied close to the fermi surface .
we studied the non - equilibrium dynamics of a high - density photo - excited electron distribution in graphene .
we used the massless dirac fermion model and a semiclassical boltzmann equation approach , which includes electron and optical phonon degrees of freedom .
our approach neglects light - matter interactions in the very early stages of the dynamics ( before the electron distribution becomes isotropic ) , quantum effects ( coherences ) , and non - markovian memory effects .
a quantitative analysis of these effects is beyond the scope of this work .
taking into consideration light - matter interactions allowed us to describe the buildup of an anisotropic he d .
calculated that the electron distribution evolves to an isotropic profile on a 10-fs timescale .
we therefore decided for computational convenience to consider an isotropic distribution as initial condition for the semiclassical boltzmann equation , without loss of generality .
we also assumed the pump pulse , which creates the initial he d , to be sufficiently short to neglect phonon - scattering - induced dephasing .
indeed , it was experimentally shown @xcite that the latter effect should be considered when applying pump pulses with duration comparable to the electron - phonon scattering time , which exceeds the @xmath0 time scale of our present work .
the effect of phonon - scattering - induced dephasing is to broaden the initial he d .
we checked that our results are very stable with respect to changes of this type .
the coulomb - scattering - induced broadening of the he d in the initial @xmath290 is much larger than the broadening due to phonons .
we took into account both electron - electron and electron - phonon scattering during the whole time evolution , and showed that electron - phonon scattering does indeed play a minor role also in the initial , coulomb - scattering - dominated , stage of the dynamics .
intra- and inter - band coherences were previously considered @xcite in the framework of the density - matrix formalism ( semiconductor bloch equations " ) . in the range of parameters we used here
, the solution of the semiclassical boltzmann equation agrees with these results . taking coherences into consideration gives minor oscillations of the electron density ( analogous to the rabi oscillations in a two - level system @xcite ) , which damp out quickly due to dephasing induced by electron and phonon scattering .
genuine quantum kinetic effects @xcite affect the dynamics on time scales of a few fs . to the best of our knowledge , quantum kinetic theory was never applied to ultrafast electron dynamics in graphene .
although quantum kinetic effects are fundamental to describe the _ coherent buildup _ of screening @xcite , here we targeted the role of screening in the time window @xmath291 .
the effects of screening on this time scale are a dominant contribution to the dynamics , and it is unlikely that a more precise description of the buildup of screening can substantially alter this picture .
indeed , it is known @xcite that quasi - classical theories can be used to fit coulomb quantum kinetics on a timescale longer than @xmath283 .
we also point out that it is an extremely difficult task to estimate _ a priori _ the short initial transient in which the coherent buildup of screening takes place . in an equilibrium state ,
basic consideration of the screening dynamics @xcite suggests that the buildup of screening , on a given length scale , should take place on a time scale comparable with the period of the plasma oscillations at the corresponding wavelength .
this implies that coherent screening buildup is faster in systems with a large carrier density ( several hundreds @xmath44 ) , which corresponds to the parameters that we use in this work .
however , the initial state that we consider is strongly displaced from equilibrium and the relation between coherent buildup of screening and carrier density is less clear .
it is arguable that electron - electron scattering is much more effective in a non - equilibrium state than in a thermal state , thus the electron - scattering - induced dephasing further reduces the time span where coherent buildup of screening plays a relevant role .
a second outcome of quantum kinetic theory is the ability to describe memory ( or non - markovian ) effects , which could play in principle an important role on ultrafast time scales . as discussed in ref .
, the general effect of using a quantum kinetic equation is to introduce oscillations in the response of the system on very short timescales , typically of the order of @xmath274 in solid state systems .
we focused here on the time window @xmath292 , where memory effects which survive for a few @xmath274 only are likely to be irrelevant .
moreover , memory effects seem to be very important in systems with long - range coulomb interactions @xcite . in our system , instead , electron - electron interactions are well screened since we are studying the dynamics of a high - density droplet of excited carriers . in the case of effectively short - range interactions ,
memory effects are much less pronounced @xcite and seem to be more important at low energies @xcite . in graphene the density - of - states vanishes at low energies , therefore further suppressing them .
thus , although our theory does not apply down to the few-@xmath274 time scale , where the coherent buildup of screening and memory effects take place , these effects do not change the dynamics in the window of interest , @xmath291 . in this time window
we demonstrated that it is of utmost importance to have an accurate description of screening , which dominates the relaxation dynamics .
an analytical treatment of the coulomb collision integral distinguishes our work from previous ones @xcite . in this respect , our main result , eq . ( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) , expresses the coulomb collision integral in terms of a compact and computationally - convenient 1d integral over the modulus @xmath120 of the total momentum of a two - particle scattering process .
this approach allows us to carefully deal with _ all _ the singularities that arise in the limit of collinear electron - electron scattering .
different screening models have been analyzed , and their impact on the collinear scattering singularities elucidated .
we also proposed a computationally - efficient way to take into account screening in eqs .
( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) , ( [ eq : finalapproximation ] ) , which is fully quantitative after thermalization occurs .
solving numerically the semiclassical boltzmann equation , we concluded that the particular form of screening one uses largely controls the speed of the relaxation dynamics in the sub-@xmath0 time range .
different screening models yield markedly different time evolutions in a large portion of parameter space .
our semi - analytical approach can be easily generalized to other carbon - based materials , such as bilayer and trilayer graphene and carbon nanotubes .
we thank denis basko , annalisa fasolino , misha katsnelson , frank koppens , leonid levitov , allan macdonald , jairo sinova , justin song , and giovanni vignale for very useful and stimulating discussions .
this work was supported by the italian ministry of education , university , and research ( miur ) through the program `` firb - futuro in ricerca 2010 '' grant no .
rbfr10m5bt ( `` plasmograph : plasmons and terahertz devices in graphene '' ) , erc grants nanopot and stratus ( erc-2011-adg no .
291198 ) , eu grants rodin and genius , a royal society wolfson research merit award , epsrc grants ep / k017144/1 , ep / k01711x/1 , ep / go30480/1 and ep / g042357/1 , and the cambridge nokia research centre .
we have made use of free software ( www.gnu.org , www.python.org ) .
the electron energy states are discretized on a uniform mesh @xmath293 , centered around the dirac point .
we take up to @xmath294 , with step @xmath295 .
the wave vectors of the phonon modes are discretized on a matching mesh @xmath296 with @xmath297 .
the phonon energies are approximated to a multiple of the energy step .
the total number of variables , including spin and valley degeneracy for the electrons and the four phononic modes , is then @xmath298 .
the sbe are first - order differential equations which are solved using a standard fourth - order runge - kutta algorithm @xcite , with a time step @xmath299 as small as @xmath300 .
the kernels ( [ eq : phononkernels ] ) of the e - ph interactions are computed at the beginning of the time evolution .
the largest computational burden is the evaluation of the coulomb kernel ( [ eq : coulombkernel ] ) , which scales cubically with the number of states @xmath301 .
the coulomb kernel is updated at a variable rate , depending on the stage of the time evolution . for @xmath302 , when the system has not reached a thermal state yet , we update the kernel each @xmath303 .
we use @xmath304 in the early cooling stage @xmath305 and @xmath306 afterwards .
we checked that the numerical results do not depend on the specific choice of these parameters . before updating the coulomb kernel at time @xmath178
, we estimate @xmath194 and @xmath196 of the electron population in the two bands . to this end
, we define the two functionals @xmath307
\equiv \int_{0}^{\infty } d\varepsilon \varphi(\varepsilon)$ ] and @xmath308 \equiv \int_{0}^{\infty } d\varepsilon \varphi(\varepsilon)^{2}$ ] .
the values of the two functionals applied to the fd distribution can be computed exactly : @xmath309 & = & - k_{\rm b } t \ln{f(\mu;0,t ) } \nonumber \\ \phi_{2}[f(\varepsilon ; \mu , t ) ] & = & k_{\rm b } t \left [ f(\mu;0,t ) - 1 \right ] + \mu \nonumber \\ & & - k_{\rm b } t \ln{f(-\mu;0,t)}~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we tabulated these values on a mesh of @xmath225 and @xmath194 . then
, during the time evolution , we evaluate @xmath310 $ ] and @xmath311 $ ] .
we then find the values @xmath225 and @xmath194 on the mesh which minimize @xmath312 - \phi_{i}[f(\varepsilon ; \mu , t)]|$ ] .
this procedure yields our estimate for @xmath194 and @xmath313 , @xmath314 , with the advantage that can be applied automatically during the time evolution and is more robust than a standard fitting procedure .
the consistency of the estimate for @xmath315 and @xmath194 is checked at the end of the time evolution using a more precise fitting procedure for the electron distribution .
the values of @xmath196 and @xmath194 are used to compute @xmath216 , according to eq .
( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) .
the polarization function is evaluated on a 2d mesh for the modulus of the transferred wave vector @xmath77 [ with step @xmath316 and maximum value @xmath317 and frequency @xmath318 ( symmetric about @xmath219 , with @xmath319 ) .
the integration over @xmath320 in eq .
( [ eq : lindhardtwomu ] ) is performed over a rather rough mesh with @xmath321 points up to @xmath322 using rectangles rule .
this is sufficient to capture the effects of @xmath194 to good accuracy , as we tested by reproducing with this method the lindhard function at equilibrium @xcite .
the procedure of regularization of the polarization function introduced in sec .
[ ssec : screeningmodels ] is implemented by replacing @xmath216 with @xmath323 when @xmath324 $ ] below the light cone ( and similarly above the light cone ) .
special care has to be taken when @xmath325 in the proximity of the origin . in this article we used @xmath326 .
finally , the coulomb kernel is computed according to eqs .
( [ eq : kernelintegralsimplified ] ) and ( [ eq : augerresult ] ) . for each choice of the energies of the incoming and outgoing particles , and
the modulus @xmath120 of the total momentum ( only one value is possible for auger processes ) the closer values for the transferred wave vector and frequency are matched on the mesh for the polarization function .
for intra - band and inter - band terms , the integral over the total momentum is performed using the standard simpson rule @xcite mesh with @xmath327 points . before performing the integration ,
a change of variables is performed to an effective angle variable @xmath328 given by @xmath329 \cos\phi$ ] , to improve the precision of the integral at the extremes . to numerically avoid the collinear divergence we restrict the integration variable in the interval @xmath330 $ ] , where we take @xmath331 ( different choices over a few orders of magnitude do not contribute substantial changes to the results ) .
the speed in solving the sbe with this method can be increased substantially by reducing @xmath301 , and the final results are qualitatively correct even with @xmath332 and @xmath333 although , in this case , the different phonon energies are not resolved .
d. brida , a. tomadin , c. manzoni , y.j .
kim , a. lombardo , s. milana , r.r .
nair , k.s .
novoselov , a.c .
ferrari , g. cerullo , and m. polini , nature commun .
( in press ) and http://arxiv.org/abs/1209.5729[arxiv:1209.5729 ( 2012 ) ] .
j. mertens , a.l .
eiden , d.o .
sigle , a. lombardo , z. sun , r.s .
sundaram , a. colli , c. tserkezis , j. aizpurua , s. milana , a.c .
ferrari , and j.j .
baumberg , http://arxiv.org/abs/1305.5367[arxiv:1305.5367 ( 2013 ) ] .
s. bae , h. kim , y. lee , x. xu , j .- s .
park , y. zheng , j. balakrishnan , t. lei , h.r .
kim , y.i .
song , y .- j .
kim , k.s .
kim , b. zyilmaz , j .- h .
ahn , b.h .
hong , and s. iijima , http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nnano.2010.132[nature nanotech .
* 4 * , 574 ( 2010 ) ] .
echtermeyer , l. britnell , p.k .
jasnos , a. lombardo , r.v .
gorbachev , a.n .
grigorenko , a.k .
geim , a.c .
ferrari , and k.s .
novoselov , http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/ncomms1464[nature commun .
* 2 * , 458 ( 2011 ) ] .
s. winnerl , m. orlita , p. plochocka , p. kossacki , m. potemski , t. winzer , e. mali , a. knorr , m. sprinkle , c. berger , w.a .
de heer , h. schneider , and m. helm , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.107.237401 [ , 237401 ( 2011 ) ] .
s. winnerl , f. gttfert , m. mittendorff , h. schneider , m. helm , t. winzer , e. mali , a. knorr , m. orlita , m. potemski , m. sprinkle , c. berger , and w.a .
de heer , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0953-8984/25/5/054202[j .
phys . : condens .
matter * 25 * , 054202 ( 2013 ) ] .
walter , a. bostwick , k .- j .
jeon , f. speck , m. ostler , t. seyller , l. moreschini , y.j .
chang , m. polini , r. asgari , a.h .
macdonald , k. horn , and e. rotenberg , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.84.085410 [ , 085410 ( 2011 ) ] .
johannsen , s. ulstrup , f. cilento , a. crepaldi , m. zacchigna , c. cacho , i.c.e .
turcu , e. springate , f. fromm , c. raidel , t. seyller , f. parmigiani , m. grioni , and p. hofmann , http://arxiv.org/abs/1304.2615[arxiv:1304.2615 ( 2013 ) ] .
t. li , l. luo , m. hupalo , j. zhang , m.c .
tringides , j. schmalian , and j. wang , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.108.167401 [ , 167401 ( 2012 ) ] ; j. zhang , t. li , j. wang , and j. schmalian , http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.7014[arxiv:1303.7014 ( 2013 ) ] ; j. zhang , j. schmalian , t. li , and j. wang , http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.6902[arxiv:1303.6902 ( 2013 ) ] .
elias , r.v .
gorbachev , a.s .
mayorov , s.v .
morozov , a.a .
zhukov , p. blake , l.a .
ponomarenko , i.v .
grigorieva , k.s .
novoselov , f. guinea , and a.k .
geim , http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nphys2049[nature phys . * 7 * , 701 ( 2011 ) ] .
ferrari , j.c .
meyer , v. scardaci , c. casiraghi , m. lazzeri , f. mauri , s. piscanec , k.s .
novoselov , d. jiang , s. roth , and a.k .
geim , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.97.187401[phys .
lett . * 97 * , 187401 ( 2006 ) ] .
a. grneis , j. serrano , a. bosak , m. lazzeri , s.l .
molodtsov , l. wirtz , c. attaccalite , m. krisch , a. rubio , f. mauri , and t. pichler , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevb.80.085423[phys .
b * 80 * , 085423 ( 2009 ) ] . c.r .
dean , a.f .
young , i. meric , c. lee , l. wang , s. sorgenfrei , k. watanabe , t. taniguchi , p. kim , k.l .
shepard , and j. hone , http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nnano.2010.172[nature nanotech . * 5 * , 722 ( 2010 ) ] .
a. leitenstorfer , a. lohner , t. elsaesser , s. haas , f. rossi , t. kuhn , w. klein , g. boehm , g. traenkle , and g. weimann , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.73.1687[phys .
73 * , 1687 ( 1994 ) ] . | we present a combined analytical and numerical study of the early stages ( sub-@xmath0 ) of the non - equilibrium dynamics of photo - excited electrons in graphene .
we employ the semiclassical boltzmann equation with a collision integral that includes contributions from electron - electron ( e - e ) and electron - optical phonon interactions . taking advantage of circular symmetry and employing the massless dirac fermion ( mdf ) hamiltonian , we are able to perform an essentially analytical study of the e - e contribution to the collision integral .
this allows us to take particular care of subtle collinear scattering processes processes in which incoming and outgoing momenta of the scattering particles lie on the same line including carrier multiplication ( cm ) and auger recombination ( ar ) .
these processes have a vanishing phase space for two dimensional mdf bare bands .
however , we argue that electron - lifetime effects , seen in experiments based on angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy , provide a natural pathway to regularize this pathology , yielding a finite contribution due to cm and ar to the coulomb collision integral . finally , we discuss in detail the role of physics beyond the fermi golden rule by including screening in the matrix element of the coulomb interaction at the level of the random phase approximation ( rpa ) , focusing in particular on the consequences of various approximations including static rpa screening , which maximizes the impact of cm and ar processes , and dynamical rpa screening , which completely suppresses them . |
throughout this paper every graphs are simple .
let us consider the following recursion of a graph polynomial .
let @xmath2 and assume that @xmath3 satisfies the following recursion formula @xmath4 where @xmath5 denotes the following graph .
we delete the vertices @xmath6 and @xmath7 from @xmath1 and replace it with a vetrex @xmath8 which we connect to those vertices of @xmath9 which were adjacent to exactly one of @xmath6 and @xmath7 in @xmath1 . in other words , we connect @xmath8 with the symmetric difference of @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
the @xmath12 refers to the symmetric difference in the recursive formula .
let @xmath13 be the empty graph on @xmath14 vertices and let @xmath15 .
this completely determines the graph polynomial @xmath3 by induction on the number of edges . on the other hand ,
it is not clear at all that this graph polynomial exists since we can determine @xmath3 by choosing edges in different order and we have to get the same polynomial .
it will turn out that this polynomial indeed exists and it is a specialization of the tutte polynomial .
let us call this graph polynomial co - adjoint polynomial until we do nt find a better name . what motivates this recursive formula of @xmath3 ?
let us consider the following three graph polynomials .
let @xmath16 be the ( modified ) matching polynomial @xcite where @xmath17 denotes the number of matchings of size @xmath18 with the convention @xmath19 .
then @xmath20 satisfies the following recursive formula : let @xmath2 then @xmath21 where @xmath22 denotes the following graph .
we delete the vertices @xmath23 from @xmath1 and replace it with a vertex @xmath8 which we do not connect with anything .
let @xmath24 be the chromatic polynomial @xcite .
it is known that it satisfies the following recursive formula .
let @xmath2 then @xmath25 where @xmath26 denotes the following graph .
we delete the vertices @xmath23 from @xmath1 and replace it with a vertex @xmath8 which we connect with the _ union _ of @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
let @xmath27 be the following graph polynomial .
let @xmath28 be the number of ways one can cover the vertex set of the graph @xmath1 with exactly @xmath18 disjoint cliques of @xmath1 .
let @xmath29 the graph polynomial @xmath27 is called adjoint polynomial @xcite ( most often without alternating signs of the coefficients ) . then @xmath27 satisfies the following recursive formula .
let @xmath2 then @xmath30 where @xmath31 denotes the following graph .
we delete the vertices @xmath23 from @xmath1 and replace it with a vertex @xmath8 which we connect with the _ intersection _ of @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
now it is clear that the co - adjoint polynomial is the natural fourth member of this family .
this paper is organized as follows . in the next section
we prove that the co - adjoint polynomial is a specialization of the tutte polynomial . in the third section we concern with the corollaries of this result . in the last section we study the co - adjoint polynomials of complete graphs and balanced complete bipartite graphs .
the tutte polynomial of a graph @xmath1 is defined as follows .
@xmath32 where @xmath33 denotes the number of connected components of the graph @xmath34
. in statistical physics one often studies the following form of the tutte polynomial : @xmath35 the two forms are essentially equivalent : @xmath36 both forms have several advantages .
for instance , it is easy to generalize the latter one to define the multivarite tutte - polynomial .
let us assign a variable @xmath37 to each edge and set @xmath38 note that the chromatic polynomial of graph @xmath1 is @xmath39 the main result of this section is the following .
[ tutte ] let @xmath1 be a simple graph and let @xmath3 be the co - adjoint polynomial , @xmath40 be the tutte polynomial of the graph @xmath1 then @xmath41 it is known that the tutte polynomial satisfies the following recursive formulas : @xmath42 if e is neither a loop nor a bridge and @xmath43 if @xmath44 is a bridge and @xmath45 if @xmath44 is a loop .
this formulas provide a straightforward way to prove theorem [ tutte ] by induction .
we will not follow this route since whenever we use these recursive formulas we have to distinguish some cases according to the edge being a bridge or not .
after some steps the proof would split into too many cases .
instead we use the simple form provided by the polynomial @xmath46 .
let @xmath47 and let us write @xmath48 and @xmath49 set @xmath50 we have to prove that @xmath51 for all graph @xmath1 .
we prove it by induction on the number of edges of @xmath1 .
if @xmath1 is the empty graph on @xmath14 vertices then both polynomials are @xmath52 and we are done . by the recursive formula
@xmath53 we have @xmath54 for an arbitrary edge @xmath44 .
now let us consider @xmath55 .
let @xmath44 be an arbitrary edge .
clearly , in the sum corresponding to @xmath55 the sets @xmath56 s not containing the edge @xmath44 contribute @xmath57 to the sum . by induction @xmath58 .
now let us consider a set @xmath56 containing the edge @xmath44
. then one can consider @xmath59 as a set of edges in @xmath60 for which @xmath61 whence we get that these sets contribute a sum @xmath62 ; note that @xmath63 , but @xmath60 has only @xmath64 vertices so the divison and multiplication by @xmath65 cancels each other and only the term @xmath66 remains from the term @xmath67 .
hence @xmath68 thus we only need to prove that @xmath69 so far we did not use anything about @xmath5 . observe that @xmath5 is nothing else but the graph obtained from @xmath60 by deleting the multiple edges .
let us consider the multiple edges @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
assume that for some edge set @xmath56 of @xmath60 not containing @xmath72 we have @xmath73 .
then @xmath74 as well and they contribute to the sum @xmath75 hence we can delete the multiple edges from @xmath60 without changing the value of @xmath76 : @xmath77 by induction we have @xmath78 .
hence @xmath79 by the recursive formula @xmath80 it is easy to prove that the coefficients @xmath81 have alternating signs . on the other hand ,
it is not clear from the expressions @xmath55 .
a surprising corollary of theorem [ tutte ] is that @xmath82 or @xmath83 and it is @xmath83 if and only if the graph is eulerian , i.e. , all degrees are even .
it follows from the fact that @xmath84 counts the nowhere-@xmath85 @xmath86-flows ( note that the flow polynomial is also a specialization of the tutte polynomial ) . since nowhere-@xmath85 @xmath86-flow is simply a flow taking the value @xmath83 on all edges , this immediately implies the claim .
in the introduction we considered four graph polynomials : the matching polynomial , the chromatic polynomial , the adjoint polynomial and our new graph polynomial , the co - adjoint polynomial . surprisingly , they all belong to a very special class of graph polynomials , the so - called exponential type graph polynomials .
we say that the graph polynomial @xmath87 is of exponential type if for every graph @xmath88 we have @xmath89 and @xmath90 satisfies that @xmath0,x)f(g[v\setminus s],y)=f(g , x+y).\ ] ] note that gus wiseman @xcite calls these graph polynomials _ binomial - type_. one can deduce from the definition that the chromatic polynomial is of exponential type . for the matching polynomial and the adjoint polynomial
this follows from theorem [ exp - b ] below .
this is a structure theorem for the exponential type graph polynomials proven in @xcite . for the co - adjoint polynomial this is simply the special case of the following much more general statement .
@xcite for the multivariate tutte - polynomial @xmath91 we have @xmath92}(q_1,\underline{v})z_{g[v\setminus s]}(q_2,\underline{v})=z_g(q_1+q_2,\underline{v}).\ ] ] the following theorem characterizes exponential type graph polynomials , see theorem 5.1 of @xcite .
@xcite [ exp - b ] let @xmath93 be a function from the class of graphs to the complex numbers .
let us define the graph polynomial @xmath94 as follows .
set @xmath95 where the summation goes over the set @xmath96 of all partitions of @xmath97 into exactly @xmath18 non - empty sets .
then let @xmath98 where @xmath99 .
then \(a ) for any function @xmath93 , the graph polynomial @xmath100 is of exponential type .
\(b ) for any exponential type graph polynomial @xmath87 , there exist a graph function @xmath93 such that @xmath101 .
more precisely , if @xmath102 is the coefficient of @xmath103 in @xmath90 then @xmath104 . for the matching
polynomial take @xmath105 @xmath106 and @xmath107 otherwise . for the adjoint polynomial
consider @xmath108 for complete graphs @xmath109 and @xmath110 otherwise .
this proves that the matching and the adjoint polynomials are indeed of exponential type . by the method of alan sokal @xcite one can prove that the root of @xmath3 of largest modulus has absolute value at most @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the largest degree and @xmath113 alan sokal proved this statement for the chromatic polynomial . on the other hand , one can simply copy his argument to prove this statement for the co - adjoint polynomial .
alternatively , theorem 1.6 of @xcite or the paper @xcite provide a weaker , but still linear bound .
in this section we give the co - adjoint polynomial of some small graphs .
@xmath114 @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117 @xmath118 @xmath119 @xmath120 @xmath121 clearly , the coefficient of the the term @xmath103 in @xmath3 is @xmath122 by theorem [ tutte ] .
it is known that @xmath123 counts the number of alternating permutations on @xmath124 elements .
let @xmath125 .
the graph polynomial @xmath3 is of exponential type , applying this observation to the complete graphs we obtain that @xmath126 hence the polynomials @xmath127 are binomial - type and we know that @xmath128 where @xmath129 the exponential generating functions of the alternating polynomials is known , we only need to integrate it since the coefficients are translated : @xmath130 the sequence of the coefficients of @xmath103 seems to be very interesting . note that not only these numbers are @xmath137 , but the values of @xmath138 are also these numbers .
the same phenomenon occurs at @xmath139 and the coefficients of @xmath140 .
in fact , these are known results .
the latter one is quite well - known , but both results are very special cases of the main result of @xcite which asserts that under some condition @xmath141 although we do not give the condition of their theorem here , but we note that the complete graphs and complete bipartite graphs satisfy the conditions if @xmath142 is an edge . *
* we are very grateful for mikls bna for various useful comments .
we are also very grateful for the authors of @xcite for including a table about @xmath143 into their paper , it was crucial for us to make the right guess about the studied graph polynomial .
b. jackson , a. procacci , and a. d. sokal : _ complex zero - free regions at large @xmath146 for multivariate tutte polynomials ( alias potts - model partition functions ) with general complex edge weights _ , journal of combinatorial theory series b * 103*(1 ) ( 2013 ) , pp .
21 - 45 a. d. scott and a. d. sokal : _ some variants of the exponential formula , with application to the multivariate tutte - polynomial ( alias potts model ) _ , sminaire lotharingien combin . *
61a * ( 2009 ) , article b61ae , 33 pp . | in this note we study a certain graph polynomial arising from a special recursion .
this recursion is a member of a family of four recursions where the other three recursions belong to the chromatic polynomial , the modified matching polynomial , and the adjoint polynomial , respectively .
the four polynomials share many common properties , for instance all of them are of exponential type , i. e. , they satisfy the identity @xmath0,x)f(g[v\setminus s],y)=f(g , x+y)\ ] ] for every graph @xmath1 .
it turns out that the new graph polynomial is a specialization of the tutte polynomial . |
understanding the physical mechanisms leading to heating of the solar atmosphere is one of the primary questions in solar physics and a long - standing puzzle . in recent years , the importance of partial ionization for the processes in solar plasma is becoming clear .
it has been shown that the current dissipation enhanced in the presence of neutrals in the plasma not entirely coupled by collisions can be essential for the energy balance of the chromosphere @xcite . in the latter paper
it was shown how the dissipation of static currents in non - current - free solar magnetic flux tubes allows to release a large amount of energy into the chromosphere , potentially able to compensate its radiative losses , @xcite .
solar atmosphere is far from stationary .
it is filled with waves and rapidly varying flows , and pierced by dynamic magnetic structures , originating in the solar interior .
as it has been demonstrated @xcite , the magnetized plasma motions in the solar photosphere create an electromagnetic ( poynting ) energy flux sufficient to heat the upper solar atmosphere .
a significant part of this flux is produced in the form of alfvn waves @xcite .
these waves are notoriously difficult to dissipate if an ideal plasma assumption is employed . in the present study
we extend the analysis by @xcite including time - dependent oscillatory perturbations . magnetic waves ( fast magneto - acoustic and alfvn waves )
produce perturbations in the magnetic field .
these perturbations create currents at all times and locations in the magnetised solar atmosphere . similarly to static currents , the currents produced by waves in a partially ionized magnetised chromosphere can be efficiently dissipated due to the presence of ambipolar diffusion .
this would provide a constant and efficient influx of energy into the chromospheric layers .
it was long known that the presence of neutral atoms in partially ionized plasmas significantly affects excitation and propagation of waves @xcite . the relative motion between the ionized and charged species causes an increase of collisional damping of mhd waves in the photosphere , chromosphere and prominence plasmas , in a similar way that any electro - magnetic wave is dissipated in a collisional medium .
these mechanisms were investigated for high - frequency waves and were shown to be important for frequencies close to the collisional frequency between the different species @xcite . in the cited works the damping was analyzed in terms of the damping time of waves .
here we study the energy input due to this damping .
in the solar chromosphere the collisional coupling of the plasma is still strong @xcite . in this case , it is convenient to use a single - fluid quasi - mhd approach i.e , including non - ideal terms not taken into account by the ideal mhd approximation instead of solving full multi - fluid equations .
the conservation equations for the multi - species solar plasma with scalar pressure and no heat flux can be written as follows : @xmath0 @xmath1 @xmath2 , \ ] ] where the internal energy @xmath3 is computed from the scalar pressure according to the ideal equation of state : @xmath4 the rest of the notation is standard ( for details see * ? ? ?
this system of equations is closed by the generalized ohm s law , where we only include ohmic and ambipolar terms : @xmath5 = \eta\vec{j } - \eta_a\frac{[(\vec{j } \times \vec{b } ) \times \vec{b}]}{|b|^2}\ ] ] with resistivity coefficients ( in units of @xmath6 ) defined as @xmath7 @xmath8 where @xmath9 in these equations the inter - species collision frequencies @xmath10 are those between electrons and ions of the specie @xmath11 ( @xmath12 ) , between electrons and neutrals of the specie @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) and those between ions and neutrals of different species ( @xmath15 ) . these frequencies ,
together with the densities @xmath16 , the electron number density @xmath17 , and the neutral fraction @xmath18 are calculated according to @xcite .
we do not include the rest of the terms in the generalized ohm s law as these terms either do not contribute to the energy balance , as hall term , or can be considered small for the solar atmospheric conditions @xcite .
nevertheless , it should be noted that the battery term can potentially increase the current and , therefore , the dissipation , as it was demonstrated by @xcite .
finally , the induction equation reads as : @xmath19}{|b|^2 } \right].\ ] ] the physical magnitude of @xmath20 is too small to produce a measurable effect .
we used a numerical analog of the @xmath20 , denoted as @xmath21 ( hyperdiffusion ) .
the value of @xmath21 is allowed to vary in space and time according to the structures developed in the simulations , so that it reaches larger values at places where the variations are small - scale @xcite .
@xmath21 , together with the grid resolution , defines the maximum reynolds number of the simulations .
the effective magnetic reynolds number due to @xmath21 in the simulation presented in this paper ( as computed directly from the derivatives of physical quantities entering its definition ) varies between @xmath22 and @xmath23 , with the smallest values localised in narrow layers at the regions where the gradients are strongest , i.e. at the shocks .
@xmath24 , however , can reach values significantly larger than @xmath21 decreasing the effective _ physical _ magnetic reynolds number to @xmath25 in the layers above 1200 km , where @xmath24 is large . the equations above are solved by means of the code mancha @xcite .
we evolve @xmath17 in time via the saha equation .
the simulations are done in full 3d .
we use 10 grid points perfectly matched layer ( pml , * ? ? ?
* ) boundary conditions on the side and top boundaries . at the bottom boundary a time - dependent condition for all variables
is provided to drive waves into the domain . ,
red ) , and plasma @xmath26 sufraces ( grey ) at the simulation time t=240 sec.,width=302 ]
a single 3d schlter - temesvary - like axisymmetric self - similar magnetic flux tube , embedded into the valiiic solar atmospheric model @xcite , similar to the one in @xcite , is used as the initial equilibrium model in the simulation ( see fig . [ fig:3dview ] ) .
the components of the magnetic field are calculated as follows : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is a piecewise - parabolic function with the dimension of @xmath29 , describing the opening of the magnetic flux tube .
@xmath30 is chosen so that it decreases with height , similar to the gas pressure .
this choice allows to avoid negative values of gas pressure within the magnetic flux tube , while keeping plasma-@xmath31 low .
the magnetic field components were used to recalculate ( using the magnetohydrostatic equation ) the pressure and density to obtain a 3d magnetohydrostatic configuration . the simulation box is set to have physical dimensions of 4@[email protected] @xmath33 , with a uniform resolution of 10 km .
the bottom boundary of the simulation box is located in the deep photosphere .
the parameters of the magnetic field are chosen such that the magnetic field strength at the axis of the magnetic flux tube is @xmath34 at the bottom ( @xmath35 ) and @xmath36 at the top ( @xmath37 ) of the domain .
this leads to the plasma @xmath38 height of about @xmath39 at the axis of the tube .
self - consistent periodic perturbations of the velocity vector , pressure , and density are introduced according to @xcite . for the simulations described here we used the driving frequency of @xmath40 mhz .
the choice of the driving frequency was motivated by the results of @xcite who showed that alfvn waves with such periods can be generated in intergranular magnetic flux tubes by turbulent convective motions . to break the symmetry ,
the acoustic pulse was placed at @xmath41 off the flux tube axis in the field - free atmosphere and was limited in horizontal extent by a gaussian of @xmath41 fwhm .
the perturbation amplitude was set to 500 .
the duration of the simulation was @xmath42 . in order to understand the effect of plasma oscillations on chromospheric heating ,
we perform three simulation runs with exactly the same numerical parameters , but different driving . in the first run ( denoted as @xmath43 below )
, we include the ambipolar term as a perturbation .
this case is analogous to @xcite . in the second run ( denoted as @xmath44 ) , we include only the wave driving , with no ambipolar term . in the third run ( denoted as @xmath45 ) ,
we include both the wave driving and the ambipolar diffusion term . in the @xmath43 run , the ambipolar term alone acting on a static flux tube produces dissipation of its static currents , which creates perturbations in all thermodynamical parameters and , in particular , in temperature . in the @xmath45 case ,
both wave and ambipolar drivings produce variations of temperature and therefore it is difficult to separate the effects of waves from the effect of static current dissipation . for that we perform a flatfield - like procedure . in order to determine the heating caused by the current dissipation of the currents produced only by the waves , we subtract from @xmath45 case the heating produced in the @xmath43 case , as well as the variations due to waves produced in the @xmath44 case .
the acoustic pulse set in the field - free atmosphere generates essentially acoustic ( fast ) waves .
these waves gradually enter the flux tube , cross the @xmath46 level and generate fast and slow magneto - acoustic waves and alfvn waves via the mode transformation .
the latter waves propagate in the magnetic flux tube and create perpendicular currents , which then dissipate due to ion - neutral friction ( see fig . [ fig:3dview ] ) .
this process is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig : ambiheating ] , where the logarithm of the ambipolar diffusion heating term @xmath47 is shown . in the first column ,
the heating term is shown for @xmath48 of simulation time . at this time
, the perturbation has not reached the upper layers of the domain above @xmath49 .
the heating term values are below @xmath50 , with the location of the largest values at the top of the domain .
the values of @xmath24 reach their maximum in the interior of the flux tube , while the static currents are largest at the flux tube boundaries . as a consequence ,
the heating by dissipation of static currents is strongest at the tube walls .
note that the wall heating is present at all heights , but is largest in the upper part of the domain , as a consequence of the strong increase of @xmath24 with height ( see similar case in * ? ? ?
at @xmath51 the situation changes .
the wave perturbations reach the upper part of the domain , and the maximum of the heating term is localised in the regions around the chromospheric shocks . further on , at @xmath52 ( third column of fig . [
fig : ambiheating ] ) , the ambipolar diffusion heating rate reaches @xmath53 , which is two orders of magnitude higher than for the case of dissipation of static currents ( first column of the figure ) .
the high heating rate region is now not confined to the chromospheric shock anymore , and occupies the whole upper part of the domain above @xmath54 height .
in order to separate the different modes in the atmosphere where @xmath55 , and study their behavior and relation to heating , we projected the velocities in the computational domain onto the three characteristic directions , defined by the following vectors @xcite : @xmath56 ; \label{eq : projections1}\ ] ] @xmath57 ; \label{eq : projections2}\ ] ] @xmath58 .
\label{eq : projections3}\ ] ] here , @xmath59 is the inclination and @xmath60 is the azimuth of the magnetic field .
the first vector @xmath61 is directed along the magnetic field lines .
the second vector @xmath62 gives the direction perpendicular to @xmath63 in the plane containing the field lines and gravity .
the third vector is perpendicular to the first two .
these projections allow to separate the fast wave in the @xmath64 projection and the alfvn wave in the @xmath62 projection .
this was used to analyse the relative influence of slow and alfvn waves on the perpendicular current , and , subsequently , on the ambipolar heating in the simulation .
[ fig : core ] shows the occurrence plots of the perpendicular current @xmath65 versus the magnetic field fluctuations along @xmath62 ( alfvn wave , left panel ) , and along @xmath64 ( fast wave , right panel ) .
clearly , alfvn waves have a stronger effect on the chromospheric non - ideal plasma heating .
furthermore , the perpendicular current increases with the increase of alfvn wave perturbation in the magnetic field , while the occurrence plot shows no significant dependence of the perpendicular current on the fast wave magnetic field perturbation amplitude .
slow waves , aligned with @xmath61 , are also produced by the oscillatory source in our simulations .
however , they do not perturb the magnetic field in the perpendicular to the field line direction , therefore have only a minor effect on the energy balance in the modelled chromosphere . through the heating term in the energy equation eq .
[ eq : energy - single - p ] associated with @xmath24 , the wave energy is converted into thermal energy . this process is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig : energy - in ] . in this plot , the time dependences of the volume - averaged thermal ( black curve ) , kinetic ( blue curve ) and magnetic ( red curve ) energy densities per unit volume are shown .
the averaging of the energy density values is carried over the volume around the tube axis , extending in the simulated chromosphere between @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
the volume boundaries lie within the plasma @xmath68 surface , which also coincides with the region where @xmath24 is maximal . in the left panel of this figure ,
it is straightforward to see that the thermal energy density in the @xmath43 simulation increases over time due to the dissipation of static currents in the initial non - current - free magnetic field configuration .
correspondingly , the magnetic field energy density decreases over time . the right panel of fig .
[ fig : energy - in ] shows the difference between the corresponding energy densities in the @xmath45 simulation and @xmath44 simulation .
the energy densities from the @xmath43 run ( left column of fig .
[ fig : energy - in ] ) were also subtracted .
it is evident from the plot that the dissipation of the currents induced by the oscillatory source leads to the decrease of the kinetic and magnetic energy density , as the magnetic energy gain due to the source action is the same in the ambipolar and ideal simulations , while the additional dissipation present in the ambipolar simulation decreases the magnetic field energy and converts it into the thermal energy .
the average thermal energy per unit volume being deposited to the low-@xmath31 chromospheric plasma due to wave dissipation is about 10 - 20 times greater than the one deposited due to the dissipation of static currents .
the computed spatially - averaged thermal energy density difference due to dissipation of the perpendicular currents caused by waves corresponds to the additional temporally - averaged thermal energy flux of @xmath69 through the magnetised chromosphere , assuming uniform heating distribution for simplicity ( similar to @xcite ) . while this estimate is about one order of magnitude less than generally accepted value required to compensate the radiative energy losses ( @xmath70 , *
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the poynting flux in our simulations at the chromospheric level ( @xmath71 ) is equal to @xmath72 , which is also nearly an order of magnitude less than that value
. therefore , our result suggests that waves , produced by photospheric motions , are an important energy source to provide heating of the solar chromosphere .
further evidence is provided by the measurements of poynting flux absorption .
the left panel of fig .
[ fig : pf - ratio ] shows horizontally - averaged poynting flux in the simulations with the oscillatory source and with ( black curves ) and without ( red curves ) ambipolar diffusion .
the averaging is carried out over a narrow region within @xmath73 range around the tube axis .
the poynting flux in the @xmath44 simulation decreases with height due to the tube expansion out of the averaging region boundaries , and does not behave differently from the @xmath45 simulation in the lower solar atmosphere . starting from @xmath74 height , the ideal and non - ideal simulation curves diverge .
the decrease in the poynting flux by the factor of up to 0.8 is produced by ambipolar diffusion only .
the poynting flux absorption dependence on height is shown in the right panel of fig .
[ fig : pf - ratio ] .
the spatially averaged absorption coefficient is @xmath75 for the tube axis region .
in this paper we investigated chromospheric heating by oscillations in the chromospheric magnetic fields .
an initial study was performed using a single magnetic flux tube , rooted in the photosphere in magneto - hydrostatic equilibrium .
a monochromatic oscillatory perturbation was placed off the tube axis in the deep photosphere to generate magneto - acoustic oscillations in the magnetic flux tube . the currents , corresponding to fast magneto - acoustic and alfvn waves , have been shown to be dissipated by the ambipolar diffusion mechanism in the simulated chromosphere .
it has been shown that for a source amplitude of @xmath76 , which mimicks photospheric motions , the heating due to the perturbation is two orders of magnitude larger than that due to the static currents dissipation .
the perturbation we used generates all types of mhd waves in the magnetic flux tube .
it has been shown , however , that the alfvnic perturbation component has a stronger effect on the heating .
generally , it is expected that oscillations with higher ( @xmath77 ) frequencies are more efficiently dissipated into heat compared to lower ( similar to the ones used in this paper ) frequency oscillations ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
on the other hand , a power law is expected for the velocity power spectrum in the solar photosphere , including its high - frequency part , currently not observed @xcite , leading to less power at higher frequencies .
consequently , it is currently difficult to draw a unique conclusion on a sole mechanism for the chromospheric heating based on a single simulation .
nevertheless , this study should be understood as an initial proof of concept of the chromospheric energy balance based on mhd wave absorption in non - uniform three - dimensional magnetised chromospheric plasmas , with a more detailed study of the absorption on the source frequency , amplitude and simulation resolution to follow .
furthermore , as the simulation has to resolve the smallest spatial and temporal scales in the system , which in the case of frequencies of the order of @xmath78 is defined by the oscillation wavelength and period , an extremely high spatial resolution of the order of few hundred meters would be necessary to directly test high - frequency currents dissipation .
therefore , even with currently available computational resources some extrapolation would be required .
ek was partially supported by the spanish ministry of science through projects aya2010 - 18029 , aya2011 - 24808 , and aya2014 - 55078-p .
this work contributes to the deliverables identified in fp7 european research council grant agreement 277829 , `` magnetic connectivity through the solar partially ionized atmosphere '' .
this research was supported by the solarnet project , funded by the european commission s fp7 capacities programme under the grant agreement 312495 .
this research was undertaken with the assistance of bsc - cns marenostrum facilities , the resources provided at the centre for astrophysics & supercomputing of swinburne university of technology ( australia ) , nci national facility systems at the australian national university through the national computational merit allocation scheme supported by the australian government , and at the multi - modal australian sciences imaging and visualisation environment ( massive ) . , e. & collados , m. 2012 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol .
463 , second atst - east meeting : magnetic fields from the photosphere to the corona . ,
t. r. rimmele , a. tritschler , f. wger , m. collados vera , h. socas - navarro , r. schlichenmaier , m. carlsson , t. berger , a. cadavid , p. r. gilbert , p. r. goode , & m. knlker , 281 | in this paper , we show a `` proof of concept '' of the heating mechanism of the solar chromosphere due to wave dissipation caused by the effects of partial ionization .
numerical modeling of non - linear wave propagation in a magnetic flux tube , embedded in the solar atmosphere , is performed by solving a system of single - fluid quasi - mhd equations , which take into account the ambipolar term from the generalized ohm s law .
it is shown that perturbations caused by magnetic waves can be effectively dissipated due to ambipolar diffusion .
the energy input by this mechanism is continuous and shown to be more efficient than dissipation of static currents , ultimately leading to chromospheric temperature increase in magnetic structures . |
purcell s widely - used ` model _ e. coli _ ' has a prolate ellipsoidal cell body bearing a single left - handed helical flagellum at one pole @xcite .
its motion is described by three kinematic parameters : the swimming speed , @xmath0 , the body angular speed , @xmath3 , and the flagellum angular speed , @xmath17 : @xmath18 with @xmath19 .
the drag forces and torques ( @xmath20 ) on the body ( subscript ` @xmath21 ' ) and flagellum ( subscript @xmath22 ) are given by @xmath23 where @xmath24 , the solvent viscosity .
requiring the body and flagellum to be force and torque free , we find @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 are viscosity - independent geometric constants .
equations [ omega_omega ] and [ v_omega ] predict that @xmath28 but underdetermine @xmath29 .
` closure ' requires experimental input , in the form of the relationship between the torque developed by the motor , @xmath30 , and its angular speed , @xmath31 , where @xmath32 measurements have repeatedly shown @xcite that @xmath33 displays two regimes , fig .
[ loadline ] , which we model as : @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the absolute slope of @xmath33 when @xmath36 . for our purposes
later , it is important to realise that eq .
[ motor ] implies an equivalent @xmath37 relation , with associated @xmath38 and @xmath39 . between the flagellum motor torque , @xmath30 , and its angular speed , @xmath31 .
intersection with a load - line determines the operating condition .
the @xmath37 relation has the same form ( cf .
eq . [ motor]).,width=192 ] equations [ omega_omega ] , [ v_omega ] and [ torque_a]-[torque_b ] completely specify the problem .
we can now predict @xmath3 and @xmath40 , the observables in this work , as functions of solvent viscosity by noting that the motor torque is balanced by the drag torque on the body , i.e. , @xmath41 equation [ load ] specifies a ` load line ' that intersects with the motor characteristic curve , fig .
[ loadline ] , to determine the ` operating condition ' . for a prolate ellipsoidal cell body with semi - major and semi - minor axes
@xmath42 and @xmath21 , @xmath43 , so that : @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the absolute slope of the @xmath37 relation ( cf . fig .
[ loadline ] ) in the variable - torque regime .
recall that bt equated @xmath46 scaling with newtonian behavior @xcite .
the above results show that this is true in the constant - torque regime ( @xmath47 ) of the motor .
our experiments demonstrate that this is _ not _ the only relevant regime .
sd used ` pvp k-90 , molecular weight 360,000 ' @xcite , which , according to current standards @xcite , has a _ number averaged _ molecular weight of @xmath48 kd , and a weight - average molecular weight of @xmath49 kd .
we show in the online si that sd s polymer probably has somewhat lower @xmath50 than current pvp 360kd .
we used four pvps ( sigma aldrich ) with stated average molecular weights of @xmath51 kd ( no k - number given ) , 40 kd ( k-30 ) , 160 kd ( k-60 ) and 360 kd ( k-90 ) .
measured low - shear viscosities , which obeyed a molecular weight scaling consistent with good solvent conditions , yielded ( see online si for details ) the overlap concentrations @xcite , @xmath52 and @xmath53 wt.% ( in order of decreasing @xmath7 ) , fig .
s2 and table s1 .
static light scattering in water gave @xmath54 kd for our pvp360 , well within the expected range @xcite , and @xmath55 nm , table s2 .
we also used ficoll with @xmath56 70k and 400k from sigma aldrich ( fi70k , fi400k ) .
we measured the motility of _ e. coli _ in polymer solutions using two new high - throughput methods ( see materials & methods and online si ) .
differential dynamic microscopy ( ddm ) , which involves correlating fourier - transformed images in time , delivers , _ inter alia _ , the mean swimming speed @xmath57 @xcite . in dark - field flicker microscopy ( dfm ) , we average the power spectrum of the flickering dark - field image of individual swimmers to obtain the mean body angular speed , @xmath58
. cells suspended in a phosphate motility buffer were mixed with polymer solution in buffer to reach final desired concentrations , and loaded into sealed capillaries for ddm and dfm .
the concentrations of cells were low enough to avoid any cell - cell interaction , including polymer - induced ` depletion ' aggregation @xcite the absence of the latter being confirmed by microscopy .
separate experiments confirmed that oxygen depletion is negligible over the duration of the measurements .
( black circles ) and body angular speed @xmath59 ( red squares ) _ vs. _ dialysed pvp concentration ( in weight percent ) at four molecular weights , with @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
the blue stars in ( a ) are the swimming speeds from sd @xcite normalised to the values at their lowest polymer concentration.,width=312 ] the measured @xmath62 curves for all four pvp ( fig .
s3 ) and ficoll ( fig .
s4 ) solutions are all non - monotonic .
the peak we see in pvp 360kd ( fig .
s3 ) is somewhat reminiscent of sd s observation @xcite for _
e. coli _
( see also fig .
interestingly , all @xmath63 are also non - monotonic except for pvp 360kd ( fig .
s3 ) . the initial rise in @xmath57 and @xmath58 upon addition of native polymers ( figs .
s3 , s4 ) are somewhat reminiscent of the way swimming speed of _
e. coli _ rises upon adding small - molecule carbon sources ( see the example of glycerol in fig .
s5 ) , which cells take up and metabolise to increase the proton motive force .
pvp is highly efficient in complexing with various small molecules @xcite .
we therefore cleaned the as - bought , native polymers by repeated dialysis using membranes that should remove low - molecular - weight impurities ( see materials & methods ) , and then repeated the @xmath8 and @xmath64 measurements , fig . [
fig : normalised_cp ] , now reported in normalised form , @xmath65 and @xmath66 , where @xmath67 and @xmath68 values at @xmath69 ( buffer ) .
the prominent broad peaks or plateaux seen in the data for native pvp40k and pvp160k have disappeared .
( the same is true for fi70k and fi400k , fig .
a small ` bump ' ( barely one error bar high ) in the data for pvp10k remains .
given the flatness of the data in pvp40k and pvp160k , we believe that the residual peak in pvp10k , whose coils have higher surface to volume ratio , is due to insufficient cleaning . on the other hand , a small peak ( @xmath70 increase ) in @xmath71 remains for pvp 360kd .
for now , what most obviously distinguishes the pvp 360kd from the other three polymers is that the normalised @xmath62 and @xmath63 for the latter coincide over the whole @xmath1 range , while for pvp 360kd they diverge from each other at all but the lowest @xmath1 . versus swimming speed @xmath57 for dialysed pvp and ficoll solutions at molecular weights as indicated ( there are @xmath72 datasets per each pvp and one dataset for each ficoll ) .
the line is a linear fit to all data ( except pvp 360kd ) , giving @xmath73 in eq .
[ purcell ] .
the inset shows the probability distribution of @xmath74 for all data sets except pvp 360kd .
the diamonds are for pvp 360kd averaged over two datasets with the errors bars being standard deviations .
the stars linked by the full curve is the predicted @xmath75 for pvp 360kd , according to a model in which the body experiences the full low - shear viscosity of the polymer solution , and the flagella experiences the viscosity of pure buffer , @xmath76.,width=288 ] to observe @xmath77 , fig .
[ fig : normalised_cp](b)-(d ) , we require @xmath78 , i.e. that eq .
[ purcell ] should be valid .
this is directly confirmed by fig .
[ fig : v_body ] : data for pvp10k , 40k and 160k collapse onto a single master proportionality at all concentrations .
data for two dialysed ficolls also fall on the same master line .
the good data collapse shows that there is only very limited sample to sample variation in the average body and flagellar geometry , which are the sole determinants of @xmath74 in eq .
[ purcell ] .
the slope of the line fitted to all the data gives @xmath79 ( cf .
@xmath80m@xmath81 in @xcite ) .
the constancy of the ratio @xmath82 is also be seen from the strongly - peaked distribution of this quantity calculated from all individual pairs of @xmath62 and @xmath83 values except those for pvp 360kd ( inset , fig .
[ fig : v_body ] ) .
physically , @xmath74 is an ` inverse cell body processivity ' , i.e. on average a bacterium swims forward a distance @xmath84 m per body revolution . the implication of fig .
[ fig : v_body ] is that swimming _
e. coli _ sees all our polymer solutions except pvp 360kd as newtonian fluids .
interestingly , bt cited the proportionality between @xmath3 and @xmath85 ( rather than @xmath3 and @xmath0 ) as evidence of newtonian behavior in ficoll .
we show the dependence of body rotation speed normalised by its value at no added polymer , @xmath86 , on the normalised fluidity @xmath87 ( where @xmath76 is the viscosity of the solvent , i.e. buffer ) for our four pvps and two ficolls in fig .
[ fig : body_fluidity ] , together with the lines used by bt to summarise their mc and ficoll data . our data and bt s mc results ( which span @xmath88 ) cluster around a single master curve , which , however , is not a simple proportionality .
equations [ omega_a ] and [ omega_b ] together predict such non - linear data collapse , provided that the cell body geometry , @xmath89 , and the motor characteristics , @xmath90 , remain constant between data sets .
the larger data scatter in fig .
[ fig : body_fluidity ] compared to fig .
[ fig : v_body ] suggests somewhat larger variations in motor characteristics than in geometry between samples . versus fluidity ( @xmath91 ) , normalised to the fluidity of the motility buffer ( c=0 ) , for all polymer solutions we studied .
full and dashed lines are those used by bt to summarise their mc and ficoll data respectively .
note that bt s mc data spanned a smaller interval ( @xmath88 ) than ours.,width=288 ] of all the polymers contributing to fig .
[ fig : body_fluidity ] , pvp 360kd gave the most extensive coverage over the whole range of fluidity , fig .
[ fig : w_vs_fluidity ] . equations [ omega_a ] and [ omega_b ] apply to the low and high fluidity regimes of these data respectively .
equation [ omega_a ] depends on a single motor parameter , @xmath92 , and predicts a strict proportionality .
our lowest fluidity data points suggest that at the highest polymer concentrations reached , we are indeed operating in this regime . using @xmath93 and @xmath94 ( average values from microscopy ) to fit eq .
[ omega_a ] to the lowest fluidity data gives @xmath95 pn.nm , fig .
[ fig : w_vs_fluidity ] ( blue ) , which agrees well with previously measured stall torque @xcite .
the majority of the data away from the lowest fluidities are clearly non - linear , and need to be fitted with eq .
[ omega_b ] .
doing so with the above value of @xmath92 gives @xmath96 s@xmath81 and @xmath97 s@xmath81 , fig .
[ fig : w_vs_fluidity ] ( pink ) .
given that @xmath98 , eq .
[ motor ] , we expect @xmath99 . our ratio of @xmath100 compares reasonably with @xmath101 for a different strain of _ e. coli _ at same temperature ( @xmath102c ) @xcite . thus , eqs .
[ omega_a ] and [ omega_b ] give a reasonable account of the data in fig .
[ fig : w_vs_fluidity ] .
we conclude that pvp 360kd solution is newtonian as far as body rotation is concerned . given the above conclusion , the non - linear @xmath103 for pvp 360kd , fig .
[ fig : v_body ] , suggests a non - newtonian response at the flagellum . in a minimal model ,
the flagellum ` sees ' a different viscosity , @xmath104 , than the cell body , which simply experiences the low - shear viscosity of the polymer solution , @xmath105 . making explicit the viscosity dependence of the resistive coefficients in eqs .
[ bodyfn ] and [ helixfn ] by writing @xmath106 , etc .
, force and torque balance now read : @xmath107 solving these gives @xmath108-\hat{b}^2}{\left(\frac{\eta}{\eta'}\right)\hat{d}_0 \hat{b}}.\ ] ] , in the range @xmath109 .
pink curve : fitting the linear - torque result , eq .
[ omega_b ] , in the range @xmath110 .
the thickness of the line / curve indicates uncertainties associated with choosing the boundary between the two kinds of behavior .
inset : a log - log plot to show that eq .
[ omega_b ] alone does not fit the data.,width=288 ] equation [ theanswer ] makes an interesting prediction .
if we take @xmath111 and use previously - quoted flagellum dimensions for _ e. coli _ @xcite to calculate @xmath112 , it predicts nearly perfectly the observed non - linear @xmath103 relationship for pvp 360kd , fig .
[ fig : v_body ] .
details are given in the online si , where we also predict the observed peak in @xmath62 , fig .
[ fig : normalised_cp ] ( fig .
s7 ) . to check consistency ,
we proceed in reverse and treat the flagellum as a nano - rheometer . given the measured @xmath62 in pvp 360kd , we deduce the viscosity seen by the flagellum , @xmath104 , at shear rate @xmath113 ( details in online si ) , fig .
[ nanorheology ] , where we also show the low - shear viscosity of pvp 360kd solutions measured using conventional rheometry . indeed , over most of the concentration range , we find @xmath114 .
( note that the highest @xmath1 data points are subject to large uncertainties associated with measuring very low swimming speeds . )
thus , our data are consistent with the flagellum ` seeing ' essentially just the viscosity of the pure solvent ( buffer ) .
macroscopically , this corresponds to extreme shear thinning .
is this a reasonable interpretation ? for a helical flagellum of thickness @xmath115 and diameter @xmath116 rotating at angular frequency @xmath17 ,
the local shear rate is @xmath117 ( we neglect translation because @xmath118 ) . for an _ e. coli
_ flagellar bundle , @xmath119 nm , @xmath120 nm and @xmath121 rad / s @xcite , giving @xmath122 s@xmath81 in the vicinity of the flagellum .
the zimm relaxation time of a polymer coil is @xmath123 , where @xmath124 is the thermal energy . using @xmath125 pa@xmath126s , @xmath127 nm
, we find @xmath128 ms for our pvp 360kd at room temperature .
since @xmath129 , the cell body does not perturb significantly the polymer conformation .
however , @xmath130 , so that the polymer may be expected to shear thin in both dilute ( @xmath131 ) @xcite and semi - dilute ( @xmath132 ) @xcite solutions . low - shear rate data collected using rheometry and high - frequency microrheological data collected using @xmath133 m beads and interpreted using the cox - merz rule @xcite ( see online si for details ) show that there is indeed significant shear thinning of our pvp 360kd polymer , figs .
[ nanorheology ] and s8 , though not as extreme as thinning down to @xmath76 .
anisotropic elastic stresses @xcite and shear thinning @xcite have been proposed before as a possible cause of non - newtonian effects in biological swimmers . however , in the usual sense , these are continuum concepts arising from experiments on the mm ( rheometry ) or @xmath134 m ( microrheology ) scale .
neither is obviously applicable to a @xmath135 nm segment of flagellum moving through somewhat larger polymer coils ( @xmath136 nm ) .
one of the very few explorations of the ` probe @xmath137 polymer size ' regime to date found a highly - non - linear time dependent response with a shear - thinning steady state that matched bulk rheometry data , albeit with quite stiff polymers ( @xmath138-phage dna ) @xcite .
the relevant physics may be similar to , but perhaps more complex than , the active microrheology of colloidal suspensions using ` probes ' that are approximately the same size as the colloids @xcite . a qualitative picture fig .
6 ( inset ) may be as follows .
a section of the flagellum travelling at @xmath139 m/s takes @xmath140 to traverse @xmath141 .
thus , polymer coils in its vicinity are strongly stretched as quasi - stationary objects and the flagellum effectively carves out a @xmath142-wide channel practically void of polymers .
each flagellum section revisits approximately the same spatial location with a period @xmath143 ms ( because the translation per turn is low ) .
although this time is larger than the single chain relaxation time @xmath144 , the time required for collective relaxation and diffusion of a large number of strongly stretched polymer chains is significantly larger than that .
effectively , then , the flagellum moves inside a channel with viscosity @xmath145 .
moreover , under strong local elongation of the kind we have suggested , it is also possible that polymers may break @xcite .
this is a separate , but related , mechanism for change in mechanical properties of the solution around the flagellum . )
; micro - rheology data obtained using 980 nm beads at @xmath146 ( ) ; @xmath147 deduced from swimming data ( ) .
lines are best fits ( see online si ) .
inset : schematic showing three snapshots of a section of a flagellum ( sphere , @xmath148 nm ) cutting through a solution polymer coils ( @xmath149 nm ) ( with a circular path )
. coils , which are initially in the path of the flagellum section ( grey ) , become stretched out ( red ) , leaving a coil - sized channel of solvent , width=288 ] .
[ nanorheology ] we note that previous experiments of _ e. coli _ swimming in mc @xcite used polymers and worked in concentration regimes where shear thinning effects are insignificant .
there is already indirect evidence of this in fig .
[ fig : body_fluidity ] , where data from bt @xcite collapse onto a newtonian master curve for @xmath150 . more directly , these previous studies used methyl celluloses with ` viscosity grade ' around 4000 cp in the range 0 - 0.3 wt.% @xcite and at 0.18 wt.% @xcite .
the shear thinning of such polymers have been measured ( polymer am4 in @xcite ) and fitted to a power law : @xmath151 ; at @xmath152 wt.% and 0.5 wt.% , @xmath153 and 0.961 respectively .
thus , at the concentrations used before @xcite , shear thinning is very weak or absent , and the solutions behave as newtonian .
we have measured the average swimming speed and cell body rotation rate in populations of _ e. coli _ bacteria swimming in different concentrations of solutions of the linear polymer pvp ( nominal molecular weights 10kd , 40kd , 160kd and 360kd , these probably being number - averaged values ) and the branched polymer ficoll ( 70kd and 400kd ) .
we dialysed each polymer to remove small - molecular impurities that can be metabolised by the cells to increase their swimming speed .
the collapse of data for all polymers except pvp 360kd onto a single proportionality relationship between swimming speed and body rotation rate , @xmath103 , fig .
[ fig : v_body ] , demonstrates that these solutions behave as newtonian fluids as far as _ e. coli _ propulsion is concerned .
significant non - linearities in @xmath103 were found for _
e. coli _ swimming in pvp 360kd solutions .
further analysis showed that the motion of the cell body remained newtonian : the measured @xmath150 can be fitted to results derived from newtonian hydrodynamics ( eqs .
[ omega_a ] and [ omega_b ] ) , fig .
[ fig : w_vs_fluidity ] .
thus there must be non - newtonian effects at the flagellum .
the observed deviations from newtonian behavior can be quantitatively accounted for by a simple model in which the flagellum ` sees ' the viscosity of pure buffer .
this is consistent with significant shear thinning observed at the micron level in pvp 360kd solutions using microrheology , although we suggest that molecular effects must be taken into account because the polymer and flagellum filament have similar , nanometric , dimensions .
note that the effects we are considering , which arise from high shear rates , are absent from experiments using macroscopic helices as models for viscoelastic flagella propulsion @xcite .
shear thinning is not the only possible effect in the vicinity of a flagellum creating local deformation rates of @xmath154 .
higher molecular weight polymers that are more viscoelastic than pvp 360kd will show significant elastic effects .
interestingly , it is known that double - stranded dna could be cut at a significant rate at @xmath155s@xmath81 @xcite .
e. coli _ swimming through high molecular weight dna solution should therefore leave behind a trail of smaller dna and therefore of lower - viscosity solution , making it easier for another bacterium to swim in the wake .
this may have important biomedical implications : the mucosal lining of normal mammalian gastrointestinal tracks and of diseased lungs can contain significant amounts of extracellular dna .
exploration of these issues will be the next step in seeking a complete understanding of flagellated bacterial motility in polymeric solution .
we cultured k12-derived wild - type _
strain ab1157 as detailed before @xcite . briefly
, overnight cultures were grown in luria - bertani broth ( lb ) using an orbital shaker at 30@xmath156c and 200 rpm .
a fresh culture was inoculated as 1:100 dilution of overnight grown cells in 35ml tryptone broth ( tb ) and grown for 4 h ( to late exponential phase ) .
cells were washed three times with motility buffer ( mb , ph = 7.0 , 6.2 mm k@xmath157hpo@xmath158 , 3.8 mm kh@xmath157po@xmath158 , 67 mm nacl and 0.1 mm edta ) by careful filtration ( 0.45 @xmath134 m hatf filter , millipore ) to minimize flagellar damage and resuspended in mb to variable cell concentrations .
_ native _ : pvp and ficoll from sigma - aldrich were used at four ( 10k , 40k , 160k , 360k ) and two ( 70k and 400k ) nominal molecular weights respectively .
polymer stock solutions were prepared and diluted with mb .
_ dyalisis _ : the polymer stock solutions were dialyzed in tubes with 14 mm diameter and 12 kda cut - off ( medicell international ltd ) against double - distilled water .
the dialysis was performed over 10 days with daily exchange of the water .
the final polymer concentration was determined by measuring the weight loss of a sample during drying in an oven at @xmath159c and subsequent vacuum treatment for 6h .
polymer solutions at several concentration were prepared by dilution using mb .
@xmath160 bacterial suspensions were gently mixed with the polymer solutions to a final cell density of @xmath161 cells / ml . a @xmath162 deep flat glass sample cell was filled with @xmath163 of suspension and sealed with vaseline to prevent drift .
immediately after , two movies , one in phase - contrast illumination ( @xmath137 40s - long , nikon plan fluor 10@xmath164ph1 objective , na = 0.3 , ph1 phase - contrast illumination plate at 100 frame per second and @xmath165 pixels ) and one in dark - field illumination ( @xmath16610s - long , nikon plan fluor 10@xmath164ph1 objective , na = 0.3 , ph3 phase - contrast illumination plate , either 500 or 1000 frame per second , @xmath165 pixels ) were consecutively recorded on an inverted microscope ( nikon te300 eclipse ) with a mikrotron high - speed camera ( mc 1362 ) and frame grabber ( inspecta 5 , 1 gb memory ) at room temperature ( @xmath167c )
. we image at @xmath168 away from the bottom of the capillary to avoid any interaction with the glass wall .
we measured the swimming speed from the phase contrast movies using the method of different dynamic microscopy ( ddm ) as detailed before @xcite .
the dark field movies were analysed to measure the body rotation speed using the method of dark - field flicker microscopy ( dfm ) , in which we fourier transform the power spectrum of the flickering image of individual cells , and identify the lowest frequency peak in the average power spectrum ( fig .
s9 ) as the body rotation frequency as in previous work @xcite ; the difference here is that dfm is a high - throughput method ( see online si ) .
we measured the low - shear viscosity @xmath10 , of polymer solutions using a ta instruments ar2000 rheometer in cone - plate geometry ( 60 cm , 0.5@xmath169 ) .
passive micro - rheology was performed using diffusing wave spectroscopy in transmission geometry with 5 mm thick glass cuvettes .
the used set - up ( ls instruments , switzerland ) uses an analysis of the measured mean square displacement ( msd ) of tracer particles as detailed before @xcite .
tracer particles ( 980 nm diameter polystyrene ) were added to the samples at 1 wt@xmath170 concentration .
the transport mean free paths @xmath171 of the samples were determined by comparing the static transmission to a reference sample ( polystyrene with 980 nm diameter at 1 wt@xmath170 in water ) .
the shear rate dependent viscosity @xmath10 was obtained from the frequency dependent storage and loss moduli using the cox - merz rule @xcite .
the work was funded by the uk epsrc ( d071070/1 , ep / i004262/1 , ep / j007404/1 ) , eu - fp7-people ( piif - ga-2010 - 276190 ) , eu - fp7-esmi ( 262348 ) , erc ( adg 340877 physaps ) , and snf ( pbfrp2 - 127867 ) .
99 j. a. voynow and b. k. rubin .
mucins , mucus and sputum .
chest 135 ( 2009 ) , 505 - 512 .
m. a. mcguckin , s. k. lindn , p sutton , and t. h. florin .
mucin dynamics and enteric pathogens .
microbiol . 9
( 2011 ) , 265 - 278 .
x. druart .
sperm interaction with the female reproductive tract .
reproduction in domestic animals 47 ( 2012 ) , 348 - 352 .
s. schreiber , m. konradt , c. groll , p. scheid , g , hanauer , h .- o .
werling , c. josenhans , and s. suerbaum .
the spatial orientation of _ helicobacter pylori _ in the gastric mucus .
usa 101 ( 2004 ) 5024 - 5029 .
s. sanchez and c. l. hofacre , m. d. lee , j. j. maurer , and m. p. doyle .
animal sources of salmonellosis in humans .
j. am . vet .
assoc . 221
( 2002 ) , 492 - 497 .
a. hourya , m. gohara , j. deschamps , e. tischenko , s. aymerich , a. gruss , and r briandet .
bacterial swimmers that infiltrate and take over the biofilm matrix , proc .
usa , 109 ( 2012 ) , 13088 - 13093 .
v. m. k. ndesendo , v. pillay , y. e. choonara , e. buchmann , d. n. bayever , and l. c. r. meyer . a review of current intravaginal drug delivery approaches employed for the prophylaxis of hiv / aids and prevention of sexually transmitted infections , aaps pharmscitech , 9 ( 2008 ) , 505 .
e. lauga and t. r. powers .
the hydrodynamics of swimming microorganisms .
phys . , 72 ( 2009 ) , 096601 . e. lauga .
propulsion in a viscoelastic fluid .
fluids , 19 ( 2007 ) , 083104 .
j. teran , l. fauci , and m. shelley .
viscoelastic fluid response can increase the speed and efficiency of a free swimmer .
lett . , 104 ( 2010 ) , 038101 .
h. fu , t. r. powers and c. w. wolgemuth .
theory of swimming filaments in viscoelastic media .
, 99 ( 2007 ) , 258101 . a. m. leshansky . enhanced low - reynolds - number propulsion in heterogeneous viscous environments .
e. , 80 ( 2009 ) , 051911 .
b. liu , t. r. powers , and k. s. breuer .
force - free swimming of a model helical flagellum in viscoelastic fluids .
usa 108 ( 2011 ) , 19516 - 19520 .
schneider and j. doetsch .
effect of viscosity on bacterial motility , j. bacteriol . , 117 ( 1974 ) , 696701 .
h.c . berg and l. turner .
movement of microorganisms in viscous environments , nature , 278 ( 1979 ) , 349351 .
y. magariyama and s. kudo . a mathematical explanation of an increase in bacterial swimming speed with viscosity in linear - polymer solutions , biophys .
j. , 83 ( 2003 ) , 733739 .
m. rubinstein and r. h. colby .
_ polymer physics_. oxford university press ( oxford : 2003 ) e. m. purcell . the efficiency of propulsion by a rotating flagellum .
usa , 94 ( 1997 ) , 11307 - 11311 .
y. sowa and r. m. berry , bacterial flagellar motor , q. rev .
, 41 ( 2008 ) , 103 - 132 .
v. bhler , kollidon : polyvinylpyrrolidone for the pharmaceutical industry , 4th edition , basf ( 1998 ) .
wilson , v.a .
martinez , j. tailleur , g. bryant , p.n .
pusey , and w.c.k .
differential dynamic microscopy of bacterial motility , phys .
lett . , 106 ( 2011 ) , 018101 .
martinez , r. besseling , o.a .
croze , j. tailleur , m. reufer , j. schwarz - linek , l.g .
wilson , m.a .
bees , w.c.k .
differential dynamic microscopy : a high - throughput method for characterizing the motility of microorganisms , biophys .
j. , 103 ( 2012 ) , 1637 - 1647 . j. schwarz - linek , a. winkler , l.g .
wilson , n.t .
pham , t. schilling , w.c.k .
phase separation and rotor self - assembly in active particle suspensions , proc .
usa , 109 ( 2012 ) , 4052 - 4057 .
s. chattopadhyay , r. moldovan , c. yeung , and x. l. wu .
swimming efficiency of bacterium _
escherichia coli_. proc .
usa 103 ( 2006 ) , 13712 - 13717 .
r. g. larson .
the rheology of dilute solutions of flexible polymers : progress and problems . j. rheol . 49 ( 2005 ) , 1 - 70 .
huang , r. g. winkler , g. sutmann and g. gompper .
semidilute polymer solutions at equilibrium and under shear flow .
43 ( 2010 ) , 10107 - 10116 .
cox and e.h .
correlation of dynamic and steady - flow viscosities .
28 ( 1958 ) , 619 - 622 .
t. d. montenegro - johnson , d. j. smith and d. loghin .
physics of rheologically enhanced propulsion : different strokes in generalized stokes .
fluids 25 ( 2013 ) , 081903 .
j. r. velez - cordero and e. lauga , j. non - newt .
fluid mech . 199
( 2013 ) 37 - 50 .
j. a. cribb , p. a. vasquez , p. moore , s. norris , s. shah , m. g. forest and r. superfine .
nonlinear signatures in active microbead rheology of entangled polymer solutions
. j. rheol .
57 ( 2013 ) , 1247 - 1264 . t. m. squires and j. f. brady . a simple paradigm for active and nonlinear microrheology . phys .
fluids 17 ( 2005 ) , 073101 .
m. m. caruso , d. a. davis , q. shen , s. a. odom , n. r. sottos , s. r. white and j. s. moore .
mechanically - induced chemical changes in polymeric materials .
109 ( 2009 ) , 5755 - 5798 .
n. c. darnton , l. turner , s. rojevsky and h. c. berg . on torque and
tumbling in swimming escherichia coli , j. bact .
189 ( 2007 ) , 1756 - 1764 .
y. edelby , s. balaghi and b. senge .
flow and sol - gel behavior of two types of methylcellulose at various concentrations , proc .
polymer processing society 29th annual meeting pps-29 nuremberg ( germany ) , paper number s21 - 634 .
r. e. adam and b. h. zimm .
shear degradation of dna .
nucleic acids res .
4 ( 1977 ) 1513 - 1537 .
g. lowe , m. meister , h.c .
rapid rotation of flagellar bundles in swimming bacteria .
nature 325 ( 1987 ) , 637 - 640 .
t. g. mason . estimating the viscoelastic moduli of complex fuids using the generalized stokes - einstein equation .
29 ( 2000 ) 371 - 378 .
we have calculated the predicted dependence of swimming velocity on polymer concentration using the theory of magariyama and kudo @xcite , fig .
s[theory ] , and show that , as they claimed , there is a peak .
however , we also show a calculation that they did not report , namely , the predicted dependence of body rotation frequency as a function of polymer concentration .
the latter is a rapidly increasing function , which is clearly unphysical , and contradicts observation by berg and turner @xcite , as well as data shown here ( fig . 4 , main text ) .
the viscosity of a polymer solution at low concentrations can be written as a virial expansion of @xmath10 in @xmath1 : @xmath172c+k_h[\eta]^2c^2+ ... \right)\ ] ] where @xmath173 $ ] and @xmath174 are the intrinsic viscosity and the huggins coefficient respectively , and @xmath76 is the viscosity of the solvent , here motility buffer .
the linearity at low @xmath1 can be expressed in two different ways : @xmath175+k_h [ \eta]^2 c \;\;\;\mbox{(huggins ) } \label{eq : huggins}\\ \frac{\text{ln}(\eta/\eta_s)}{c } & = & [ \eta]+(k_h-\frac{1}{2})[\eta]^2 c \;\;\;\mbox{(kraemer ) } \label{eq : kraemer}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these two linear plots should extrapolate to @xmath173 $ ] at @xmath69 .
the intrinsic viscosity measures the volume of a polymer coil normalised by its molecular weight , so that @xmath176^{-1}$ ] .
a modern text names this as the best experimental method for estimating the overlap concentration @xcite .
we first re - graph the @xmath105 data given by schneider and doetsch @xcite as huggins and kraemer plots , fig .
s[scaling](a ) .
( note for here and below that concentrations in wt% and g / dl are interchangeable at the sort of concentrations we are considering . )
it is clear that their lowest-@xmath1 data point must be inaccurate .
discarding this point gives the expected linear dependence in both plots , and a uniquely extrapolated value of @xmath173 = 1.055 $ ] at @xmath69 , giving @xmath177 g / dl .
reference to our @xmath11 values below suggests that sd s pvp 360 kd has somewhat lower molecular weight than our material with the same label .
according to current industry standards @xcite , pvp 360 kd should have viscosities of @xmath178 mpa.s and @xmath179 mpa.s at 1 wt.% and 10 wt.% in water respectively .
sd s reported viscosities at 1 and 10 wt.% , 2.5 and 249 pa.s respectively , are lower than these values , again consistent with their material having lower molecular weight than our pvp 360 kd .
we have characterised all four pvps used in this work by measuring their low - shear viscosity in motility buffer as a function of concentration .
for k-90 at 1 and 10 wt.% , we found @xmath180 and 370 mpa.s , agreeing well with the published standards @xcite .
we now graph the measured viscosities of our four pvps at low concentrations as huggins and kraemer plots , fig .
s[scaling](b)-(e ) . in each case
, the expected behavior is found ; the extrapolated values of @xmath173 $ ] and the overlap concentrations calculated from these are given in table [ table : rheodata ] .
the scaling of @xmath173 $ ] vs. @xmath7 is consistent with a power law , fig .
s[scaling](f ) , @xmath173 \sim m^a$ ] with @xmath181 . since @xmath173 \approx r^3/m$ ] ,
so @xmath182 with @xmath183 .
we find @xmath184 , which is consistent with the renormalization group value of @xmath185 for a linear polymer in a good solvent .
we performed static and dynamic light scattering ( sls @xmath186 dls ) experiments to measure the radius of gyration , @xmath187 , the molecular weight , @xmath50 , the second virial coefficient , @xmath188 , and the hydrodynamic radius , @xmath189 , of pvp360k in water and motility buffer .
@xmath189 was measured by dls , and @xmath187 , @xmath50 , and @xmath188 using the zimm plot of sls data .
results are summarised in table [ table : zimmdata ] .
the positive @xmath188 is consistent with our conclusion above that water is a good solvent for pvp .
there may be a mild degree of aggregation in motility buffer ( larger radii and slightly smaller @xmath188 ) .
figure s[fig : u_v_cp](a ) shows @xmath57 and @xmath58 versus polymer concentration , @xmath1 , for as - bought , or native , pvp360k . while @xmath63 decays monotonically , a peak is observed in @xmath57 at @xmath190 , or roughly @xmath11 for this molecular weight . the latter ostensibly reproduces sd s observations @xcite their data are also plotted in fig .
s[fig : u_v_cp](a ) . in native pvp160k ,
s[fig : u_v_cp](b ) , the peak in @xmath8 broadens , and now there is a corresponding broad peak in @xmath63 as well . these peaks broaden out into plateaux for native pvp40k and pvp10k , fig .
s[fig : u_v_cp](c - d ) .
we also performed experiment with native ficoll with manufacturer quoted molecular weights of 70k and 400k , and observed similar non - monotonic , broadly peaked responses in both @xmath8 and @xmath64 ( fig .
here we show @xmath62 for _ e. coli _ swimming in glycerol solutions of a range of concentrations , fig .
s[smallmol ] .
the plot is indeed reminiscent of what is seen for native pvp10k and pvp40k .
indeed , we suggest that the increases at low concentrations in all four polymers have the same origin as the increase observed at low glycerol concentration the availability of a small - molecule energy source .
the decrease at high glycerol is an osmotic effect ( as observed for other small - molecules , e.g. sucrose @xcite ) , while that seen in the 10k , 40k and 160k polymers can be entirely accounted for by low - re newtonian hydrodynamics ( polymeric osmotic effects at our concentrations are negligible ) .
swimming speed and body rotation frequency as a function of concentration is shown for two purified ficolls in fig .
here we outline the procedure used to calculate the rotation rate of the cell body for a bacterium swimming in shear - thinning pvp360k solution as a function of the swimming speed .
we assume that the flagellum ` sees ' a viscosity @xmath191 that is different from the low - shear - rate viscosity @xmath10 experienced by the bacterial body .
this is partly motivated by bulk and microrheological measurements , fig . 6 in the main text ,
showing that at the shear rates generated by the flagellum , shear thinning can be expected at least down to the @xmath134 m scale .
empirically , the low- and high - shear viscosities plotted in fig
. 6 of the main text can be fitted by : @xmath192 where @xmath1 is in wt% and @xmath10 in mpa@xmath126s . in this two - viscosity model ,
the force and torque balance equations solve to eq . 13 in the main text : @xmath108-\hat{b}^2}{\left(\frac{\eta}{\eta'}\right)\hat{d}_0 \hat{b}}. \label{omega_theory}\ ] ] the friction coefficients in eq . ( [ omega_theory ] )
are given by @xcite @xmath193 where @xmath194 and @xmath195 .
here , @xmath196 m and @xmath197 m are the total length and pitch of the flagellum , correspondingly , @xmath198 is the angle made by the flagellar filament with the flagellar axis , @xmath199 nm is the estimated radius of a the composite filament in a flagella bundle , and @xmath200 is the lighthill constant .
all parameters are taken from a previous experimental paper @xcite , where this set of parameters were shown to be consistent with the purcell model . using the measured values of @xmath63 for pvp360k , @xmath201 , @xmath202 , and eq .
( [ omega_theory ] ) is sufficient to calculate the corresponding @xmath203 .
results show good agreement with the measured values ( fig . 3 in the main text ) , thus predicting a peak in the swimming velocity upon an increase in the viscosity of the polymer solution . for a better illustration ,
we compare the predicted and measured values of @xmath57 as a function of the viscosity experienced by the body ( @xmath204 ) in fig .
s[v_vs_eta ] .
our theory is successful in predicting a peak in the swimming velocity in the right position and of the right shape .
now we relax our previous assumption that @xmath191 is equal to the viscosity of the solvent , and use eq .
( [ omega_theory ] ) to extract the viscosity of the fluid surrounding the flagellar filament . using the measured values of @xmath63 and @xmath62 , eq.([omega_theory ] ) can be solved for @xmath191 .
the results are shown in fig . 6 in the main text .
indeed , for most of the concentration range studied , @xmath114 .
under dark - field illumination , the image of a swimming bacterium appears to flicker . by calculating the power spectrum of the spatially localised time - dependent intensity fluctuations of low - magnification images of a quantised pixel box ( containing @xmath137 1 cell ) , and then averaging over all cells in the images , we are able to measure the body rotational frequency @xmath205 averaged over @xmath15 cells based on a @xmath206 s movie .
this method is similar to what was done by lowe et al .
@xcite , who measured the power spectrum of single swimming cells .
however , here we use low - magnification dark - field imaging which allows high - throughput measurement of @xmath205 .
dark - field movies were recorded ( nikon plan fluor 10@xmath164ph1 objective , na = 0.3 , ph3 phase - contrast illumination plate ) at either 500 or 1000 hz on an inverted microscope ( nikon te300 eclipse ) with a mikrotron high - speed camera ( mc 1362 ) and frame grabber ( inspecta 5 , 1 gb memory ) at room temperature ( 22 @xmath207 @xmath208 @xmath169c ) .
the images correspond to an area of @xmath209 , containing around @xmath210 bacteria .
approximately 4000 frames were captured , at a resolution of 512 @xmath164 512 pixels . to process a video sequence ,
each frame was divided into square tiles of side length @xmath211 ( typically 5 pixels ) , and the pixel values in each tile were summed to give a single number .
this process was repeated for every frame in the video sequence , yielding intensity as a function of time for each tile .
the power spectrum of this data was calculated for each tile separately , before averaging over all tiles to give smoothed data for the whole video sequence .
the power spectrum is then normalised by the frequency squared to remove any contribution from brownian motion due the non - motile cells , inherently present in the bacterial suspensions .
an example is shown in fig .
we identify the first peak as the body rotational frequency @xmath205 in line with previous studies @xcite .
the viscosity of pvp 360kd measured using conventional rheometry and dws micro - rheology ( see materials & methods ) at different concentrations are shown in fig .
there is reasonable overlap between the two methodologies at intermediate shear rates .
c c c c c + table s1 & @xmath173 $ ] ( dl / g ) & @xmath174 & @xmath11(g / dl or wt@xmath170 ) + + + pvp360k & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + pvp160k & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + pvp40k & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + pvp10k & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + + sd @xcite & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + c c c c c + table s2 & @xmath50 ( g / mol ) & @xmath188 ( mol.l / g@xmath212 & @xmath187 ( nm ) & @xmath189 ( nm ) + + + pvp360k in water & 840@xmath213 & 3.0@xmath214 & 56 & 30 + + pvp360k in mb & 1500@xmath213 & 2.6@xmath214 & 79 & 37 + + | it is widely believed that the swimming speed , @xmath0 , of many flagellated bacteria is a non - monotonic function of the concentration , @xmath1 , of high - molecular - weight linear polymers in aqueous solution , showing peaked @xmath2 curves .
pores in the polymer solution were suggested as the explanation . quantifying this picture led to a theory that predicted peaked @xmath2 curves . using new , high - throughput methods for characterising motility , we have measured @xmath0 , and the angular frequency of cell - body rotation , @xmath3 , of motile _ escherichia coli _ as a function of polymer concentration in polyvinylpyrrolidone ( pvp ) and ficoll solutions of different molecular weights .
we find that non - monotonic @xmath2 curves are typically due to low - molecular weight impurities .
after purification by dialysis , the measured @xmath2 and @xmath4 relations for all but the highest molecular weight pvp can be described in detail by newtonian hydrodynamics . there is clear evidence for non - newtonian effects in the highest molecular weight pvp solution .
calculations suggest that this is due to the fast - rotating flagella ` seeing ' a lower viscosity than the cell body , so that flagella can be seen as nano - rheometers for probing the non - newtonian behavior of high polymer solutions on a molecular scale .
he motility of micro - organisms in polymer solutions is a topic of vital biomedical interest .
thus , e.g. , mucus covers the respiratory @xcite , gastrointestinal @xcite and reproductive @xcite tracks of all metazoans .
penetration of this solution of biomacromolecules by motile bacterial pathogens is implicated in a range of diseases , e.g. , stomach ulcers caused by _
helicobacter pylori _ @xcite .
oviduct mucus in hens provides a barrier against _ salmonella _ infection of eggs @xcite .
penetration of the exopolysaccharide matrix of biofilms by swimming bacteria @xcite can stabilise or destabilise them _ in vivo _
( e.g. the bladder ) and _ in vitro _
( e.g. catheters ) . in reproductive medicine
( human and veterinary ) , the motion of sperms in seminal plasma and vaginal mucus , both non - newtonian polymer solutions , is a strong determinant of fertility @xcite , and polymeric media are often used to deliver spermicidal and other vaginal drugs @xcite .
micro - organismic propulsion in non - newtonian media such as high - polymer solutions is also a ` hot topic ' in biophysics , soft matter physics , and fluid dynamics @xcite . building on knowledge of propulsion modes at low reynolds number in newtonian fluids @xcite , current work seeks to understand how these are modified to enable efficient non - newtonian swimming .
in particular , there is significant interest in a flapping sheet @xcite or an undulating filament @xcite ( modelling the sperm tail ) and in a rotating rigid helix ( modelling the flagella of , e.g. , _ escherichia coli _ )
@xcite in non - newtonian fluids .
an influential set of experiments in this field was performed 40 years ago by schneider and doetsch ( sd ) @xcite , who measured the average speed , @xmath5 , of seven flagellated bacterial species ( including _ e. coli _ ) in solutions of polyvinylpyrrolidone ( pvp , molecular weight given as @xmath6kd ) and in methyl cellulose ( mc , @xmath7 unspecified ) at various concentrations , @xmath1 .
sd claimed that @xmath8 was always non - monotonic and peaked .
a qualitative explanation was suggested by berg and turner ( bt ) @xcite , who argued that entangled linear polymers formed ` a loose quasi - rigid network easily penetrated by particles of microscopic size ' .
bt measured the angular speed , @xmath3 , of the rotating bodies of tethered _
e. coli _ cells in mc solutions .
they found that adding mc hardly decreased @xmath3 .
however , in solutions of ficoll , a branched polymer , @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the solution s viscosity , which was taken as evidence for newtonian behavior . in mc solutions , however , bt suggested that there were _
e. coli_-sized pores , so that cells rotated locally in nearly pure solvent .
magariyama and kudo ( mk ) @xcite formulated a theory based on this picture , and predicted a peak in @xmath2 by assuming that a slender body in a linear - polymer solution experienced different viscosities for tangential and normal motions in bt s ` easily penetrated ' pores .
this ` standard model ' is widely accepted in the biomedical literature on flagellated bacteria in polymeric media .
it also motivates much current physics research in non - newtonian low - reynolds - number propulsion .
nevertheless , there are several reasons for a fundamental re - examination of the topic .
first , polymer physics @xcite casts _ a priori _ doubt on the presence of _
e. coli_-sized pores in an entangled solution .
entanglement occurs above the ` overlap concentration ' , @xmath11 , where coils begin to touch .
the ` mesh size ' at @xmath11 , comparable to a coil s radius of gyration , @xmath12 , gives the maximum possible pore size in the entangled network . for 360kd pvp in water , @xmath13 nm ( see below ) , well under the cross section of _
e. coli _
( 0.8@xmath14 m ) .
thus , the physical picture suggested by bt @xcite and used by mk @xcite has doubtful validity . + + secondly , sd s data were statistically problematic .
they took movies , from which cells with ` the 10 greatest velocities were used to calculate the average velocity ' @xcite .
thus , their ` peaks ' in @xmath2 could be no more than fluctuations in measurements that were in any case systematically biased .
finally , while mk s theory indeed predicts a peak in @xmath2 , we find that their formulae also predict a monotonic increase in @xmath4 in the same range of @xmath1 ( fig .
s1 ) , which is inconsistent with the data of bt , who observed a monotonic decrease .
we have therefore performed a fresh experimental study of _
e. coli _ motility using the same polymer ( pvp ) as sd , but varying the molecular weight , @xmath7 , systematically .
high - throughput methods for determining @xmath0 and @xmath3 enabled us to average over @xmath15 cells at each data point . using polymers as purchased , we indeed found peaked @xmath2 curves at all @xmath7 studied .
however , purifying the polymers removed the peak in all but a single case .
newtonian hydrodynamics can account in detail for the majority of our results , collapsing data onto master curves .
we show that the ratio @xmath16 is a sensitive indicator of non - newtonian effects , which we uncover for 360kd pvp .
we argue that these are due to shear - induced changes in the polymer around the flagella .
below , we first give the necessary theoretical and experimental background before reporting our results . |
understanding leading particle production is crucial to understand forward physics at hadron colliders and also cosmic ray physics @xcite .
indeed , the interpretation of cosmic ray data is strongly dependent on the accurate knowledge of the leading baryon momentum spectrum and its energy dependence ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite ) . moreover , particle production at forward rapidities and high energies probes the qcd dynamics at very small - @xmath6 , where non - linear effects associated to high gluonic density in the target are expected to contribute significantly @xcite .
this new regime of the qcd dynamics is a field of intense activity and the exclusive production of vector mesons in @xmath7 collisions and in ultraperipheral hadronic collisions is one of the most promising observables to constrain the main properties of the theory ( see , e.g. refs .
@xcite ) . leading neutron production has been investigated in @xmath8 collisions at hera , from where we have high precision experimental data on semi - inclusive @xmath9 processes @xcite as well as on exclusive @xmath3 photoproduction associated with a leading neutron ( @xmath10 ) @xcite . in these processes
the incident proton is converted into a neutron via pion emission . in refs .
@xcite we proposed an unified description of inclusive and exclusive processes with a leading neutron , based on the color dipole formalism , and we have demonstrated that the available experimental hera data on the @xmath11 ( feynman momentum ) distribution of leading neutrons can be very well described in this approach .
an important property of our approach is that its main elements are constrained by the hera data on processes without a leading neutron . as a consequence ,
our analysis of leading neutron data has put limits on the magnitude of the nonperturbative absorptive corrections and on the models of the pion flux ( which describes the pion emission by the incident proton ) .
moreover , we were able to present parameter - free predictions for the inclusive and exclusive processes with a leading neutron at the energies of the future @xmath8 colliders @xcite .
unfortunately , in view of the construction schedule of the these new colliders , these predictions will only be tested in a distant future .
given the impact of leading neutron production in forward physics , it is fundamental to consider alternative ways to learn more about this process ( see . e.g. refs .
@xcite ) . in this paper
we propose the study of the leading neutron production in the photon - hadron ( @xmath12 ) interactions , which are present in hadronic collisions @xcite .
in particular , we will consider exclusive vector meson production associated with a leading neutron in @xmath13 interactions at @xmath0 and @xmath1 collisions .
recent theoretical and experimental studies have demonstrated that hadronic colliders can also be used to study photon - hadron and photon - photon interactions in a new kinematical range and that several open questions in the theory of strong interactions can be investigated by analysing different final states produced in these reactions ( for a recent review see ref .
@xcite ) . as we will demonstrate below , such conclusion is also valid for leading neutron processes . in what follows we will investigate the exclusive @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 production associated with a leading neutron in @xmath0 and @xmath1 collisions at rhic and lhc energies and present our estimates for the total cross section and rapidity distributions of these distinct final states .
our goal is to demonstrate that the experimental analysis of these processes is feasible and that they may be used to study leading neutron physics as well as to study exclusive vector meson production .
this paper is organized as follows . in the next section we present the main concepts in photon - induced interactions and discuss exclusive vector meson production associated with a leading neutron . in section [ res ]
we present our predictions for the rapidity distributions and total cross sections for exclusive @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 production associated with a leading neutron in @xmath0 and @xmath1 collisions at rhic and lhc energies .
finally , in section [ conc ] we summarize our main conclusions .
in this section we will present a brief review of the formalism needed to describe the vector meson production associated with a leading neutron in photon - induced interactions at hadronic collisions .
we refer the reader to our previous papers @xcite for a more detailed discussion . at high energies ,
the incident charged hadrons ( proton or nuclei ) generate strong electromagnetic fields , which can be represented in terms of an equivalent photon flux . as a consequence , in a hadronic collision ,
a photon stemming from the electromagnetic field of one of the two colliding hadrons can interact with one photon coming from the other hadron ( photon - photon process ) or it can interact directly with the other hadron ( photon - hadron process ) @xcite . in this paper
we will focus on the latter .
a basic property of these photon - induced interactions is that the cross section can be factorized in terms of the equivalent flux of photons ( from the hadron projectile ) and the photon - target cross section , with the photon flux being well known .
consequently , the cross section of a photon - induced process in hadronic collisions is a direct probe of the photon - hadron cross section .
therefore , the study of these processes in hadronic colliders can be considered complementary to the analysis performed at hera , as demonstrated by recent results on exclusive vector meson photoproduction in @xmath2 collisions . the main difference in comparison to hera and future @xmath8 colliders , is that photon - induced interactions are characterized by real photons , while in @xmath8 colliders it is possible to investigate vector meson production at different photon virtualities .
we will extend the formalism used to treat photon - induced interactions to the description of the leading neutron processes . exclusive vector meson production associated with a leading neutron
will be represented by the diagrams in fig .
[ diagramas ] , which can be seen as a sequence of four factorizable subprocesses : i ) a photon is emitted by one of the incident hadrons ; ii ) this photon fluctuates into a quark - antiquark pair ( the color dipole ) , iii ) the color dipole interacts diffractively with the pion , while the proton remains intact , and iv ) the vector meson and the leading neutron are formed .
the final state will be characterized by two rapidity gaps , one associated to the photon exchange and another to the colorless system exchanged between the dipole and the pion , as well as by a pion produced at large rapidities and by a leading neutron .
the corresponding rapidity distribution will be given by @xmath14}{dy } = \left[\omega \frac{dn}{d\omega}|_{h_1}\,\sigma_{\gamma h_2 \rightarrow v \otimes \pi + n}\left(\omega \right)\right]_{\omega_l } + \left[\omega \frac{dn}{d\omega}|_{h_2}\,\sigma_{\gamma h_1 \rightarrow v \otimes \pi + n } \left(\omega \right)\right]_{\omega_r}\ , \label{dsigdy}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath15 corresponds to the initial hadron ( @xmath16 or @xmath17 ) which has emitted the photon , @xmath18 is the rapidity of the vector meson @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) in the final state , which can be determined by the photon energy @xmath21 in the collider frame and by mass @xmath22 of the vector meson [ @xmath23 .
the symbol @xmath24 represents a rapidity gap in the final state and @xmath25 and @xmath26 denote photons from the @xmath16 and @xmath17 hadrons , respectively . in our study
we will assume that the equivalent photon spectrum @xmath27 of a relativistic proton is given by @xcite , @xmath28 \left ( \ln{\omega } - \frac{11}{6 } + \frac{3}{\omega } - \frac{3}{2 \,\omega^2 } + \frac{1}{3 \,\omega^3 } \right ) \
\label{eq : photon_spectrum}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the notation @xmath29 $ ] , @xmath30 \approx ( \omega/\gamma_l)^2 $ ] , @xmath31 is the lorentz boost of a single beam and @xmath32 is the c.m.s energy of the hadron - hadron system .
the equivalent photon flux of a nucleus is given by @xcite @xmath33\ , \label{fluxint}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath34 , @xmath35 are the modified bessel functions of second kind and @xmath36 .
one of the main differences between the photon fluxes for the proton and for the nucleus is that the latter is enhanced by a factor @xmath37 .
this implies that the rapidity distribution of the vector mesons produced in @xmath1 collisions will be asymmetric and determined by @xmath13 interactions , with the photon coming from the nucleus .
in contrast , the rapidity distribution for @xmath0 collisions will be symmetric with respect to @xmath38 . following refs .
@xcite we will assume that the absorptive corrections associated to soft rescatterings @xcite can be approximated by a constant factor @xmath39 , which implies that the total cross section for the process @xmath40 can be expressed by _
n ( w^2 ) = dx_l dt f_/p ( x_l , t ) _ v ( ^2 ) [ crossgen ] where @xmath41 is the center - of - mass energy of the photon - proton system , @xmath11 is the proton momentum fraction carried by the neutron and @xmath42 is the square of the four - momentum of the exchanged pion .
moreover , @xmath43 is the flux of virtual pions emitted by the proton and @xmath44 is the cross section of the interaction between the photon and the pion at center - of - mass energy @xmath45 , which is given by @xmath46 . as discussed in detail in refs .
@xcite , the precise form of the pion flux is still a subject under investigation .
in what follows we will assume that the pion flux is given by f_/p ( x_l , t ) = ( 1-x_l)^1 - 2 ( t ) [ f(x_l , t)]^2 [ genflux ] where @xmath47 is the @xmath48 coupling constant , @xmath49 is the pion mass and @xmath50 is the regge trajectory of the pion . in particular , we will consider that the form factor @xmath51 , which accounts for the finite size of the nucleon and of the pion , can be expressed as follows @xcite f(x_l , t ) = , ( t ) = ( t ) _ [ form3 ] where @xmath52 ( with @xmath42 in gev@xmath53 ) and @xmath54 gev@xmath55 .
as demonstrated in ref .
@xcite , this model ( denoted @xmath56 in @xcite ) reproduces well the hera data on the exclusive @xmath3 photoproduction associated with a leading neutron . in order to describe the @xmath57 cross section , in ref .
@xcite we extended the color dipole formalism ( widely used in exclusive @xmath13 processes ) to @xmath58 interactions .
consequently , we assumed that @xmath59 can be expressed by @xmath60 with the scattering amplitude being given by @xmath61.{\mbox{\boldmath $ \delta$ } } } \,\ , ( \psi^{v*}\psi ) \,\,2 { \cal{n}}_\pi(\hat{x},{\mbox{\boldmath $ r$}},{\mbox{\boldmath $ b$ } } ) \label{sigmatot2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath62 denotes the overlap between the real photon and exclusive final state wave functions , which we assume to be given by the gauss - lc model described in ref .
the variable @xmath63 @xmath64 is the longitudinal momentum fraction of the quark ( antiquark ) and @xmath65 denotes the transverse momentum lost by the outgoing pion ( @xmath66 ) .
the variable @xmath67 is the transverse distance from the center of the target to the center of mass of the @xmath68 dipole and the factor in the exponential arises when one takes into account non - forward corrections to the wave functions @xcite .
moreover , @xmath69 is the imaginary part of the forward amplitude of the scattering between a small dipole ( a colorless quark - antiquark pair ) and a pion , at a given rapidity interval @xmath70 .
this quantity is directly related to the qcd dynamics at high energies @xcite . as in refs .
@xcite we will assume that @xmath71 can be expressed in terms of the dipole - proton scattering amplitude @xmath72 , usually probed in the inclusive and exclusive processes at hera , as follows @xmath73 with @xmath74 being a constant .
moreover , we will assume that @xmath75 is given by the bcgc model proposed in ref .
@xcite : @xmath76 & \mbox{$r q_{s , p } > 2 $ } \end{array } \right .
\label{eq : bcgc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath70 and @xmath77 , where @xmath78 is the lo bfkl characteristic function @xcite .
the coefficients @xmath79 and @xmath80 are determined uniquely from the condition that @xmath81 , and its derivative with respect to @xmath82 , are continuous at @xmath83 . in this model ,
the proton saturation scale @xmath84 depends on the impact parameter : @xmath85^{\frac{1}{2\gamma_s}}. \label{newqs}\ ] ] following @xcite we will assume in what follows that @xmath86 , @xmath87 gev@xmath55 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 . as demonstrated in ref .
@xcite , this phenomenological dipole reproduces quite well the hera data on exclusive @xmath3 and @xmath5 production .
moreover , the results from refs .
@xcite demonstrated that this model gives a good description of the recent lhc data on exclusive vector meson photoproduction in @xmath0 and @xmath91 collisions .
the main assumptions in our approach for inclusive and exclusive leading neutron processes are that i ) the absorptive corrections can be represented by a @xmath92 factor , which is assumed to be energy and @xmath11 independent and ii ) the dipole - pion amplitude can be related to the dipole - proton one by a constant factor @xmath74 .
both assumptions surely deserve more detailed studies ( for more discussions see refs .
@xcite ) . however , the results presented in refs .
@xcite demonstrated that these assumptions are supported by the available hera data .
in particular , in ref .
@xcite we have assumed @xmath93 , as expected from the additive quark model , and we have used the experimental hera data on @xmath94 @xcite to constrain the range of possible values of the @xmath39 - factor . in the calculations of the exclusive vector meson production associated with a leading neutron in photon - induced interactions we will also assume that @xmath93 and we will use the values of the @xmath39 - factor in the range determined in ref .
@xcite . as a consequence ,
the predictions to be presented in the next section are parameter free .
therefore , the analysis of this process in hadronic colliders , which have cross sections larger than those studied at hera , will be very useful to test our approach and its underlying assumptions .
[ cols="^,^ " , ] f. gelis , e. iancu , j. jalilian - marian and r. venugopalan , ann . rev .
nucl . part .
sci . * 60 * , 463 ( 2010);e . iancu and r. venugopalan , arxiv : hep - ph/0303204 ; h. weigert , prog . part .
phys . * 55 * , 461 ( 2005 ) ; j. jalilian - marian and y. v. kovchegov , prog .
phys . * 56 * , 104 ( 2006 ) ; j. l. albacete and c. marquet , prog . part .
phys . * 76 * , 1 ( 2014 ) . c. a. bertulani and g. baur , phys
. rep . * 163 * , 299 ( 1988 ) ; g. baur , k. hencken , d. trautmann , s. sadovsky , y. kharlov , phys .
rep . * 364 * , 359 ( 2002 ) ; v. p. goncalves and m. v. t. machado , mod .
a * 19 * , 2525 ( 2004 ) ; c. a. bertulani , s. r. klein and j. nystrand , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 55 * , 271 ( 2005 ) ; k. hencken _ et al .
_ , phys .
rept . * 458 * , 1 ( 2008 ) .
l. n. lipatov , sov .
j. nucl .
* 23 * , 338 ( 1976 ) ; e. a. kuraev , l. n. lipatov and v. s. fadin , sov .
jetp * 44 * , 443 ( 1976 ) ; _ ibid . _ * 45 * , 199 ( 1977 ) ; i. i. balitsky and l. n. lipatov , sov .
j. nucl .
* 28 * , 822 ( 1978 )
. w. schafer and a. szczurek , phys .
d * 76 * , 094014 ( 2007 ) ; a. rybarska , w. schafer and a. szczurek , phys .
b * 668 * , 126 ( 2008 ) ; a. cisek , w. schafer and a. szczurek , phys .
b * 690 * , 168 ( 2010 ) ; phys .
c * 86 * , 014905 ( 2012 ) . | in this paper we study leading neutron production in photon - hadron interactions which take place in @xmath0 and @xmath1 collisions at large impact parameters . using a model that describes the recent leading neutron data at hera , we consider exclusive vector meson production in association with a leading neutron in @xmath2 collisions at rhic and lhc energies .
the total cross sections and rapidity distributions of @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 produced together with a leading neutron are computed .
our results indicate that the study of these processes is feasible and that it can be used to improve the understanding of leading neutron processes and of exclusive vector meson production .
lu tp 16-xx + may 2016 |
it was suggested long ago by witten@xcite that fundamental superstrings ( f - strings ) of macroscopic length could be observed in the form of cosmic strings .
after the discovery of @xmath4-branes@xcite , it is natural to expect that a similar role could be played by other extended objects of string theory such as @xmath5-branes wrapped around internal @xmath6-cycles .
it is interesting that brane inflation@xcite generically predicts the formation of such objects , whereas the formation of point - like or wall - like extended objects is suppressed@xcite .
various aspects of the dynamics , formation and evolution of cosmic @xmath7 and @xmath0strings have been discussed in @xcite .
needless to say that a possible observation of these objects would provide a direct window into string theory .
thus , both from an observational as well as from the fundamental point of view it is important to understand the precise nature and structure of the _ stringy _ cosmic strings .
this is the motivation that led to the present work .
we shall derive non - singular bps string solutions which resemble many of the features of the @xmath0strings .
following the conjecture in @xcite , which we review below , we interpret our solutions as the @xmath0strings of string theory . independently from the conjecture the solutions presented in this paper are new bps objects which have interest of their own : they are the first example of finite energy cosmic strings coupled to an axion field . in trying to understand the @xmath2 picture of the @xmath0strings , it is useful to consider their description in terms of sen s tachyonic vortices formed on the worldvolume of a higher dimensional unstable @xmath0brane - anti-@xmath0brane ( @xmath8 ) pair@xcite .
for example , a @xmath9-brane in ten dimensions can be viewed as a tachyonic vortex on the worldvolume of a @xmath10 pair .
this vortex originates as follows .
the gauge symmetry of the system consists of two @xmath11 s belonging to the worldvolume theories of the @xmath12 and @xmath13 respectively .
the tachyon ( @xmath14 ) , which is an excitation of an open string stretched between the two branes , is charged under the diagonal combination of the two @xmath11 s .
when the branes annihilate , the tachyon condenses and this gauge symmetry is higgsed .
since the tachyonic vacuum is topologically non - trivial @xcite , there are topologically stable vortex configurations , analogous to abrikosov - nielsen - olesen @xcite flux tubes , which carry magnetic flux of the higgsed @xmath11 .
these flux tubes are the @xmath15strings . in this picture
we can understand their ramond - ramond ( rr ) charge as originating from the wess - zumino coupling on the @xmath16 worldvolume .
] , @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the rr two - form and @xmath19 denotes the field strength of the diagonal @xmath11 gauge field .
after compactification to four dimensions @xmath15strings become cosmic strings .
since in ten dimensions @xmath0branes preserve half of the supersymmetries , in @xmath2 it should be possible to find some kind of cosmic @xmath4-strings which are still bps saturated objects .
it is therefore natural to ask whether there are such solitons in @xmath2 supergravity . in @xcite
it was shown that the only bps gauge strings in supergravity are @xmath4-term strings .
these are the strings that are formed by higgsing a @xmath11 gauge symmetry due to the presence of a fayet - iliopoulos ( fi ) @xmath4-term .
because of this fact , it was conjectured that @xmath4-strings , if they have any solitonic counterpart in the effective four dimensional field theory description , must be represented by some form of bps @xmath4-term strings .
the `` _ @xmath4-string @xmath4-term - string equivalence _ ''
conjecture leads to the conclusion that the energy density stored in an unstable @xmath20 pair is a @xmath4-term associated with the fi term of the worldvolume @xmath11 that is higgsed by the tachyon . therefore , in the ten dimensional limit
, the effective potential for the tachyon is schematically , @xmath21 where the ellipses stand for all the other charged fields in the system .
these fields have positive mass squared and vanish throughout the annihilation process .
it follows from ( [ dterm1 ] ) that the fi term @xmath22 is related to the @xmath12 brane tension by @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the @xmath12 tension and @xmath25 is the @xmath11 gauge coupling constant .
in the ten dimensional limit , the annihilation proceeds solely through the tachyon condensation , which compensates the fi term in ( [ dterm1 ] ) .
the resulting @xmath0strings are purely tachyonic vortices , carrying ten dimensional rr charge . under the term
_ purely tachyonic _
what is meant here is that the only winding phase responsible for the topological stability of the string , and consequently for the existence of the magnetic flux , is the phase of the tachyon . from eq .
( [ wz1 ] ) it follows that the electric rr charge of the @xmath15brane arises from the quantized magnetic flux carried by the vortex . the effect of compactification on the above system is rather profound .
first , after dimensional reduction we are left with the zero mode of the rr two - form , @xmath18 , which in four dimensions is dual to an axion field @xmath26 . in a supersymmetric scenario the axion has a scalar partner @xmath27 .
is related to the dilaton and the volume modulus .
in general the axion of the four dimensional theory arises from the zero mode of a ramond - ramond field @xmath28 with two of the indices in the large dimensions . ]
dualizing the two - form one generically obtains the following term in the action @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 is the four dimensional planck mass . from this
we see that the wess - zumino term ( [ wz1 ] ) gauges the shift symmetry of the axion . from eq .
( [ axiondual ] ) it is also clear that after compactification , the worldvolume @xmath11 symmetry is always in the higgs phase , even when the tachyon vacuum expectation value ( vev ) is set to zero .
the mass of the gauge field of course vanishes in the infinite space limit , as @xmath32 .
another effect of the compactification is that the @xmath4-term potential ( [ dterm1 ] ) aquires an @xmath27-dependent contribution , @xmath33 notice that this correction too dies off in the decompactified limit .
this fact is consistent with the picture that in ten dimensions @xmath4-strings are purely tachyonic vortices whose tension is set by the fi term @xmath22 .
previous attempts to derive solutions for @xmath4-strings as bps solitons in four - dimensions were in the following directions . as we have already mentioned , in @xcite smooth bps @xmath4-term string solutions were derived in the presence of a fi term @xmath22 , but the dilaton - axion multiplet was not included in the solution .
notice however that this is consistent with supersymmetrically removing this multiplet as shown in @xcite . in @xcite
axionic string solutions were studied in a model in which the @xmath11 anomalies are cancelled by green - schwarz ( gs ) mechanism .
although this model is primarily motivated by the heterotic @xmath34 compactification , it nevertheless shares some similarities with the type ii string compactifications that are our main interest .
the low energy effective actions are very similar , with the crucial difference that in the heterotic theory the existence of a dilaton - independent part of fi term @xmath22 is not obvious and was not included in @xcite . as a result ,
the string solutions found in these models are either singular or break all the supersymmetries . in this paper
we show that the presence of the @xmath22 term in ( [ dterm2 ] ) allows us to construct smooth bps @xmath0string solutions .
other than being new interesting bps objects , their existence provides an additional support for the conjecture of @xcite .
some complementary string theoretic evidence for this conjecture was also provided in @xcite , where @xmath0term strings were identified in intersecting brane systems
. a discussion of @xmath0term strings in the context of wrapped branes has also appeared in @xcite .
let us also mention that , while we only study in detail supersymmetric strings , the bps properties of @xmath0strings on a background such as flux compactifications @xcite or the deformed conifold @xcite may be lost . in the present work we focus on explicit field theoretic solutions for @xmath0strings and then interpret them in the framework of @xmath0brane systems .
actually we find two different types of smooth bps cosmic string solutions , both of which have an interpretation in string theory : + + + the first type of solutions , which fits all the features of the @xmath4-strings , is the tachyonic vortex . in this case
the magnetic flux is induced by the winding of the tachyon phase , and not by the axion . at large distances from the core
the asymptotic values of the fields for this solution are , @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the angular coordinate in the plane perpendicular to the string . as we will show the asymptotically infinite value of @xmath27 is the only way to avoid the logarithmic divergence of the energy in this case .
such a divergence would be incompatible with the bps condition .
since @xmath27 represents a combination of the dilaton and the volume modulus , the space gets decompactified ( or the @xmath2 effective coupling goes to zero ) at large distances from the core .
this effect however happens very slowly since @xmath27 depends only logarithmically on the distance .
+ + + in the second class of solutions the tachyon vev vanishes at infinity , and the magnetic flux is induced by the winding of the axion .
@xmath27 now goes asymptotically to a constant in such a way to compensate the @xmath22 term in the potential ( [ dterm2 ] ) .
these strings can be interpreted as the vortices produced by higgsing the @xmath11 group of a @xmath1 pair by compactification , as opposed to tachyon condensation .
thus , far away from the string core the tachyon mass is zero and the branes do not annihilate .
the tachyon may only develop an expectation value in the core of the string .
the existence of a bps configuration on a background with a @xmath16 pair may come as a surprise , because in ten - dimensions this background breaks all the supersymmetries ( for an exception see @xcite ) .
however , the identification of the @xmath16 tension with the @xmath4-term energy density suggests that tachyon condensation may not be the only way for restoring part of the supersymmetries once the effects of the compactification are taken into account . instead
, the fi term may be compensated by the dilaton @xmath27 .
the corresponding bps strings are then the @xmath3strings . +
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we describe the supersymmetric models that we will be considering . in section 3
we derive the bogomolnyi equations for the string configurations . in section 4
we give a detailed description of the two types of cosmic string solutions in global as well as local supersymmetry . in section 5
some new features of the string solutions are discussed . in section 6
we interpret our solutions within the context of string theory .
we end with some conclusions and future directions .
for the globally supersymmetric case the effective @xmath37 lagrangian that we will consider takes the following form in superspace ( we follow the conventions in @xcite ) , @xmath38 + \int d^2\theta ~\frac 1 4 f(s ) w^\alpha w_\alpha+ h.c . \label{lagrangian}\ ] ] @xmath39 are chiral fields with integer @xmath11 charges @xmath40 . since the @xmath11 symmetry is linearly realized on the @xmath39 for simplicity we will consider the minimal khler potential for this superfield .
the axion is contained in a chiral superfield @xmath41 whose lowest component is @xmath42 where @xmath27 is ( loosely speaking ) the dilaton .
invariance of the action under a constant shift of the axion demands that the khler potential @xmath43 is a function of @xmath44 .
this shift symmetry is gauged under the @xmath11 . in the string
motivated models that we have in mind one typically finds khler potentials of the form @xmath45 $ ] ( up to a numerical coefficient ) so we will study this case in detail even though most of our results hold for any @xmath46 . as far as the string theory motivation is concerned , we will use ( [ lagrangian ] ) as the prototype lagrangian describing interactions of the open string tachyon @xmath14 ( represented by lowest component of one of the @xmath39 ) and the complexified rr axion @xmath47 in type ii compactifications with @xmath1 background .
we shall show that these fields are sufficient to describe non - singular bps @xmath4-string solutions .
it is important to stress that ( [ lagrangian ] ) is not the complete low energy action , because a @xmath1 system contains other light fields , e.g. , such as the brane - separation mode .
however , these additional fields can be consistently ignored .
note that the action above is similar to the one of @xmath34 heterotic string compactifications in which the @xmath11 anomalies are cancelled by the green - schwarz mechanism , but with the important difference that we include a constant ( moduli independent ) fi term @xmath22 . for type ii compactifications ,
such constant term is necessary in order to account for the @xmath1 tension , which should survive in the ten - dimensional limit . as we shall show
this term is crucial for the existence of non - singular bps @xmath4-string solutions . in this respect
our action differs from the one considered in @xcite in which no @xmath22 term was included , and consequently no smooth bps string solutions were found .
we do not include a superpotential , since bps requirement demands that @xmath48-terms must be identically zero on the string solution@xcite . in components
the bosonic part of the action is , @xmath49 with the covariant derivatives given by , @xmath50 under a gauge transformation the bosonic fields transform as , @xmath51 from the last equation we deduce that the periodicity of the axion is , @xmath52=4\pi \delta .
\label{periodicity}\ ] ] depending on the charges @xmath40 we can distinguish two cases . when the @xmath53 the matter sector of the lagrangian is anomaly free .
gauge invariance of the action then fixes @xmath54 to be a constant and @xmath55 to be arbitrary .
when the sum of the charges is different from zero the theory has mixed anomalies . in any consistent theory all the gauge anomalies must vanish . in this case
the anomaly can be cancelled by the green - schwarz mechanism applied to four dimensions @xcite by choosing the gauge kinetic function @xmath56 .
the axion has a universal coupling of the form @xmath57 . under the gauge transformation the axion shifts and
generates a contribution to the anomaly which cancels the one of the matter sector .
clearly this implies severe restrictions on the representations which are automatically satisfied in string compactifications
. in heterotic string compactification one finds for example independent fi term in heterotic string theory . on the other hand in type ii theories
the fi term should account for the energy density of the @xmath1 pair .
] , @xmath58 for the main part of this paper we will focus on the scenario with constant gauge kinetic function , @xmath59 and @xmath60 $ ] which is relevant for type ii compactifications .
the pseudo - anomalous case requires only minor modifications .
the vacuum manifold corresponds to the zeros of the @xmath0term in ( [ action ] ) , @xmath61 due to the fact that the axion shifts under the @xmath11 gauge transformation the theory is always in the higgs phase in any vacuum . in general
the gauge boson eats a linear combination of the axion and of the phase of the higgs field while the orthogonal combinations remain massless .
the mass of the vector boson is given by , @xmath62 with @xmath27 and @xmath63 lying in the vacuum manifold ( [ vacuum ] ) .
in the supersymmetric vacuum the gauge boson belongs to a massive @xmath37 multiplet .
we consider solitonic string solutions with the fields only varying in the transverse plane @xmath64 .
remarkably for _ any _ khler potential of the form @xmath46 the energy density of this configuration can be organized in the bogomolnyi form , @xmath65 where we have integrated by parts assuming that the boundary term at infinity is zero and is understood that the signs are chosen so that the energy is positive . from this
we can directly read off the bogomolnyi equations , @xmath66 where the covariant derivatives are given in ( [ covariant ] ) .
when the bogomolnyi equations are satisfied the tensions of these solutions is minimal and proportional to the magnetic flux through the string , @xmath67 the minimization of the energy guarantees that the equations of motion are also satisfied . generically in a supersymmetric theory the bogomolnyi energy bound signals that the solution leaves a fraction of the supersymmetries unbroken , i.e. it is a bps state .
the same holds here .
a configuration of the fields preserves some supersymmetries if the variations of all the fermions is zero for some projection of the supersymmetry parameters .
the transformations of the fermions under supersymmetry evaluated on the bosonic background are given by , @xmath68 where @xmath69 and @xmath70 are the fermionic partners of the scalar fields and @xmath71 is the gaugino .
it is straightforward to check that , when the bogomolnyi equations ( [ bogo ] ) are satisfied , the solutions leave half of the supersymmetries unbroken , so as expected these are bps states .
this guarantees their stability even quantum mechanically .
supersymmetry immediately explains why the bogomolnyi equations do not depend on the khler potential ( except through the @xmath0term ) , giving a rationale for why it was possible to rearrange the energy in the simple bogomolnyi form ( [ bogoenergy ] ) .
it is also easy to see considering the supersymmetry variations , that in the presence of a non zero @xmath7term all the supersymmetries must be broken .
therefore only @xmath0term strings can be bps objects @xcite .
the only exception to this statement is when the superpotential generating the @xmath7term is chosen such that the system has @xmath72 supersymmetry because in this case there is no distinction between @xmath48 and @xmath4 terms @xcite .
however this mechanism does not seem viable in supergravity because it appears to be impossible to construct supersymmetric actions with constant fi terms in @xmath72 supergravity with charged hypermultiplets @xcite .
it is important to stress that when the bps equations are satisfied the tension is equal to the constant fi term @xmath22 times the magnetic flux .
this shows that any attempt to find smooth bps configurations with a field dependent fi term is bound to fail because this configuration would have zero energy and therefore it can only be the vacuum .
of course this leaves the possibility to build singular bps string solutions .
in this section we present the bps string solutions of our model for the relevant case @xmath73 $ ] . for simplicity we first consider the globally supersymmetric case ( here we set @xmath74 ) . we find two classes of string solutions , the ones created by the higgs field @xmath14 and the ones created by the dilaton @xmath27 which have rather different properties .
we consider in some detail the case with constant gauge kinetic function ( corresponding to no anomalies ) .
the case where anomalies are cancelled by the gs mechanism is slightly more complicated but leads to qualitatively similar results that are briefly reported in section [ pseudo ] .
finally we show that our solutions can also be coupled to supergravity preserving their bps nature .
these are the solutions where one of the fields @xmath63 goes to a finite value at infinity . in order to solve the bps equations for a string configuration we take the following ansatz for the fields ) . ] , @xmath76 we assume for simplicity that all the scalar fields except @xmath77 are equal to zero .
one could construct more general bps strings where several @xmath63 s are different from zero . in fact
our solutions are reminiscent of semilocal strings @xcite and the relation will be clarified in section [ discussion ] .
notice that , while it is consistent with the bps equations ( see below ) to set the other chiral fields to zero , @xmath27 can not be a constant in a supersymmetric configuration because in the bps equations the dilaton is sourced by the gauge field . using the ansatz above for the fields the bps equations read ,
@xmath78 where we have assumed @xmath55 and @xmath22 to be positive and we have set @xmath59 . in general the first two equations
imply the following relation between @xmath27 and @xmath79 , @xmath80 where @xmath81 is an arbitrary integration constant related to the size of the core of the defect . taking into account the fact that close to the origin @xmath82 ( which follows from the first equation in ( [ bps ] ) ) and that @xmath79 goes to a constant at infinity one derives , @xmath83 at infinity
@xmath27 always goes to infinity unless the winding of the axion is @xmath6 times the one of the phase of the tachyon . in this case
, there is family of solutions labeled by the asymptotic value of @xmath79 . in all other cases the boundary conditions at infinity are @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
restrictions on the possible values of @xmath86 and @xmath87 can be derived from eqs.([asymptotic]).in any configuration with finite energy the dilation @xmath27 should never cross zero . also , @xmath88 corresponds to strong coupling in our effective theory so we would not trust our solutions in that regime . requiring that @xmath27 is always positive leads to , @xmath89 which fixes the charge @xmath6 to be positive .
if @xmath6 is much bigger than one the only bps solution is with the axion not winding , @xmath90 .
when @xmath55 is negative ( the sign is determined a priori when the @xmath11 symmetry is anomalous ) solutions can of course still be found but in this case we need to choose a field with negative electric charge and @xmath22 to be negative . in a given theory
the string solutions can only exist if @xmath55 and @xmath22 have the same sign so in principle the coupling to the axion multiplet might destroy the bps solutions . in figure [ fig1 ]
we plot the string profiles for @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
[ fig1 ] the asymptotic expansion for the higgs and the gauge fields can be derived by solving the linearized equations of motion at infinity . to leading order one finds , @xmath93 these expansions
should be compared with the ordinary abelian higgs model where the fields approach their asymptotic values exponentially fast . in comparison to the abelian higgs model , where the energy is localized an scales comparable to the inverse higgs mass , here the energy is spread on larger scales ( depending on @xmath81 ) .
asymptotically our solutions resemble axionic strings but the bps equations guarantee that the energy remains finite .
the tension of the string is given by , @xmath94 as this formula shows the tension depends only on the winding of the higgs field @xmath14 and not on the winding of @xmath26 .
very different solutions can be obtained when the string is supported by the field @xmath27 going to a constant . in this case
the ansatz for the fields is , @xmath95 this is almost identical to the previous case with the only difference that the winding of the gauge field is now linked to the one of the axion field .
the bps equations become , @xmath96 from the first two equations it follows that , as in the previous case , @xmath27 and @xmath79 are related by @xmath97 .
this equation now requires that @xmath79 goes to zero at infinity since @xmath27 goes to a finite value .
the other boundary conditions which can be deduced from the bps equations are @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
numerical solutions are shown in fig.([fig2 ] ) .
the tension of the @xmath3strings is given by , @xmath100 in general the tension of the @xmath3strings is @xmath101times the one of the @xmath14 strings .
the tension now depends only on the winding of the axion and we have degenerate solutions with different values of @xmath86 .
let us consider the asymptotic expansion of these solutions .
if @xmath102 the linearized equations for @xmath27 and @xmath103 are identical to the ones for the abelian higgs model so the fields approach the asymptotic values exponentially . for @xmath104 differently from the @xmath75strings the fields approach the asymptotic values power like , @xmath105 as for the @xmath75strings the relation between @xmath27 and @xmath79 leads to restrictions on the values of @xmath87 and @xmath86 , namely @xmath106 ( this simply follows from the fact that since @xmath27 goes to a constant @xmath79 must go to zero ) . in the special case @xmath107
, the @xmath14 and @xmath3strings have the same tension .
in fact for these values of the parameters the two string solutions become degenerate and it is possible to construct more general solutions with the fields approaching any point of the vacuum manifold ( [ vacuum ] ) .
finally let us turn to the pseudo - anomalous case .
at least in some compactification the axion acquires an effective coupling , @xmath108 where @xmath109 runs over some gauge group factors @xmath110 .
the existence of such a coupling signals that the fermion content of the theory has a mixed @xmath111 anomaly , which is cancelled by the green - schwarz mechanism .
the coupling ( [ ffdual ] ) has a double effect on the @xmath4-strings solutions in question .
first , it modifies the structure of the @xmath4-term potential , and secondly , because of instantons , it may lead to the attachment of the domain walls to the strings .
the @xmath4-term potential is modified , because in the case of gs anomaly cancellation @xmath56 . using the same ansatz for the fields as in the previous cases the first two bps equations remain unchanged while the last equation becomes , @xmath112 where @xmath86 is the winding of the phase of the tachyon or of the axion for the @xmath75strings and for the @xmath3strings respectively .
let us first briefly discuss the @xmath75strings .
the vacuum manifold is the same as in ( [ vacuum ] ) plus the point @xmath113 ( for any value of @xmath79 ) .
@xmath27 diverges at infinity for the same reasons explained in section [ phi ] .
this would in principle still allow @xmath79 to go to a constant different from one at infinity .
however this is incompatible with the equation above since there are no solution where @xmath103 is bounded unless @xmath114 ( this can easily be shown using the fact that @xmath115 asymptotically ) .
the solutions of the bps equations are qualitatively very similar to the ones with constant gauge kinetic function .
in fact to leading order the asymptotic behavior of the solutions is as in ( [ asymptotic2 ] ) . for the anomalous @xmath3strings the situation appears even simpler .
since @xmath27 goes to a constant at infinity the solutions are almost identical the ones in section [ s ] .
let us turn to the issue of the domain walls now .
the instanton effects may generate a potential for the axion and the tachyon phase .
for instance , in the presence of the coupling ( [ ffdual ] ) , the instantons in question may be the gauge theory instantons in one or more of the @xmath110 groups .
the precise nature of the potential is model dependent , but the important
fact is that the potential is only generated for the gauge - invariant combination of phases @xmath116 thus , only the strings for which the combination @xmath117 winds at infinity can potentially become boundaries of the domain walls . for the heterotic @xmath48-strings the possibility of becoming boundaries of domain walls
was suggested by witten@xcite and for the @xmath4-strings such a possibility was discussed by copeland , myers and polchinski@xcite .
presumably , the same physics that generates the potential ( [ phasepot ] ) will also lift @xmath118 flat direction .
in such a case our @xmath75 and @xmath27-string solutions will acquire a logarithmically divergent energy , and will become boundaries of the usual axion type domain walls .
flat direction is not lifted by the axion - potential .
in such a case the domain walls should `` dissolve '' at infinity , because the potential should vanish in either of the two limits @xmath119 and for @xmath120 .
this follows from the fact that in both of these limits the physical gauge invariant axion becomes ill - defined . ] in this section we briefly show how the string solutions presented in the previous sections can be coupled to supergravity .
localized lumps of energy with codimension two create an asymptotically conical space - time with a deficit angle at infinity proportional to the tension of the object . at first sight
this suggests that all supersymmetries must be broken when gravity is dynamical because covariantly constant spinors can not be defined on a conical space .
this is the same problem faced and solved in the case of the pure abelian higgs model vortices @xcite ( see also @xcite for related work ) . in the presence of a fi term the gravitino and the supersymmetric parameter @xmath121
become charged under the @xmath11 gauge symmetry so that the gravitino supersymmetric variation has an extra contribution proportional to the gauge connection which cancels exactly the one due to the deficit angle . in this section
we generalize the analysis of the pure abelian higgs model to a scenario with an arbitrary khler potential and show that in general a bps string configuration in global supersymmetry remains bps when supergravity is ( weakly ) coupled .
we follow closely the analysis in @xcite and refer the reader to this paper for the details of the derivation .
we take the following ansatz for the metric , @xmath122 in most general case @xcite one can consider several chiral fields @xmath123 transforming under the @xmath11 symmetry where the transformation corresponds to an isometry of the scalar manifold . in a bosonic background the variations of the fermions read , @xmath124 where @xmath125 are the covariant derivatives of the scalar fields in the theory which can be expressed in terms of the killing vectors of the scalar manifold . for a general khler potential the current @xmath126
is given by , @xmath127 it is important to observe that since the gravitino is charged under the @xmath11 its supersymmetric variation contains a piece proportional to the gauge connection .
this is what allows to define killing spinors in an asymptotically conical space .
the supersymmetry transformations of the matter fields are as in flat space with suitable factors of the metric .
the bps equations then become , @xmath128 since the first equation does not depend on the metric explicitly , for the model considered in this paper the same relation between @xmath27 and @xmath79 found in ( [ sf ] ) holds .
supersymmetry is unbroken by the background if the killing spinor equations @xmath129 admits solutions .
these equations imply the integrability condition @xcite , @xmath130 where @xmath131 is the two dimensional laplacian .
this equation determines the conformal factor @xmath132 , therefore what remains to be checked is that this equation is consistent with the einstein s equations for the metric .
this is indeed the case as one can check that ( [ ein00 ] ) is simply the @xmath133 einstein equation for the metric when the bps equations ( [ gravbps ] ) are imposed .
the other equations of motion are also satisfied as the energy can still be cast in the bogomolnyi form ( [ bogoenergy ] ) ( with appropriate metric factors ) .
this concludes the proof that the bps string solutions studied in this paper can be lifted to supergravity . at large distance from the core of the string
( [ ein00 ] ) can be easily integrated since ( @xmath134 ) go to zero faster than @xmath135 ( this assumption is necessary to write the energy in the bogomolnyi form and is satisfied in our model ) .
one finds that @xmath136 .
after a simple change of variables to polar coordinates the metric becomes , @xmath137 which as expected is the metric of a conical spacetime with deficit angle @xmath138 .
in this section we wish to describe some of the physical properties of the @xmath14 and @xmath27 strings presented in the previous section .
these are rather different from the ordinary abelian higgs model strings .
the large @xmath139 dependence of our solutions has a simple and important physical origin .
the contribution to the energy from the angular derivatives is given by ( @xmath74 ) , @xmath140\ ] ] where @xmath141 is the phase of the tachyon . with our choice of normalization
the two phases of the problem @xmath141 and @xmath26 have periodicities equal to @xmath142 and @xmath143 respectively .
it is then clear that for generic windings of @xmath87 and @xmath86 it is possible to cancel both gradient terms at infinity only if we allow the factors @xmath144 or @xmath145 to go to zero .
in fact this is the behavior of the fields required by the bps equations but we would like to stress that the argument only relies on the finite energy condition .
we therefore have three different asymptotic strategies to find finite energy solutions .
we can cancel the gradient energy associated with the tachyon field by choosing the gauge field appropriately and consequently have @xmath146 as @xmath147 .
these are the @xmath14-strings .
if the axion does not wind ( @xmath90 ) the dilaton goes to a constant at the core implying , contrary to the standard abelian higgs model , that the gauge symmetry is not restored there .
the bps equations however force the fields to be away from the vacuum at the core . at infinity
the gauge symmetry is higgsed by the tachyon field instead . on the other hand
, we can choose the gauge field such that it cancels the gradient term for the axion forcing @xmath148 as @xmath147 .
these are the @xmath27-strings .
these solutions resemble in some ways the stringy cosmic strings studied in the early nineties @xcite which are also relevant for the description of the @xmath149brane@xcite . in that case
the only field is the complex dilaton @xmath150 and finite energy supersymmetric configurations are achieved by using the @xmath151 invariance of the action .
the solution for @xmath41 is a holomorphic function of the transverse coordinate @xmath152 .
close to the core , @xmath153 which is the same asymptotic solution as for the @xmath3strings .
the divergence of the dilaton at the core was interpreted in @xcite as decompactification of the space or weak coupling . as we will see in the next section
a similar understanding will be very useful to interpret our solutions as the @xmath0strings of string theory .
the last possibility to achieve finite energy is to tune the winding numbers of the two fields in such a way that both gradients are canceled and therefore the string solutions can approach any point of the vacuum manifold at infinity .
the reader might have also noticed close similarities between the strings of this paper and semilocal strings ( see @xcite and refs . therein ) . in the simplest semilocal strings
there is a complex higgs doublet with equal @xmath11 charges .
string solutions can be found for example by setting one of the components of the doublet to zero . in the bogomolnyi
limit the strings can also be made supersymmetric . in this case the stability of the strings is not guaranteed by the topology of the vacuum manifold which is @xmath154 since @xmath155 .
the same holds in our solutions .
even though the vacuum manifold @xmath156 in our case appears different at first sight , we still have @xmath157 .
the axion phase becomes not well defined when @xmath146 so the winding of the axion can be undone by taking @xmath158 without leaving the vacuum manifold .
these solutions are stable because of supersymmetry not because of topology .
another typical feature of the semilocal strings in the bps limit , is the presence of zero modes @xcite beside those due to the breaking of spacetime symmetries .
this is also present in our case since our solutions depend on an arbitrary integration constant @xmath81 which controls the size of the string core .
it is interesting to notice however that this does not lead to extra localized zero modes at least for the @xmath14-strings . to compute the effective action of the string
we promote the integration constant @xmath81 to a field depending on the coordinates of the string . considering the asymptotic expansion of the dilaton for the @xmath75strings ,
@xmath159 it is easy to see that the kinetic term for @xmath81 is badly divergent ( power - like ) .
this implies that this mode is frozen , it can not be excited with any finite energy excitation
. it would be interesting to test numerically whether this mode can be excited in a collision of two strings or whether due to the power divergence of the kinetic term it is always frozen .
for the @xmath3strings the situation is different since @xmath79 approaches the vacuum as a power law and therefore seems to be possible ( and model dependent ) to have an integrable bosonic zero mode in this case .
finally , we should also mention the presence of localized fermionic zero modes . in the globally supersymmetric scenario
there are at least two fermionic zero modes localized on the string due to partial supersymmetry breaking .
these modes are the supersymmetric partners of the translation modes living on the string .
their profile can be obtained as usual by acting on the string background with the broken supersymmetry generators . in supergravity
the story is rather different because , according to a well known argument due to witten @xcite , unbroken supersymmetry does not guarantee fermi - bose degeneracy .
in fact it can be seen @xcite that the fermionic zero modes become non - normalizable when gravity is dynamical so they are projected out of the spectrum of the worldsheet theory .
in this section we argue that the string solutions studied in this paper have a natural interpretation in terms of string theory solitons . to begin with let us review the key argument behind the conjecture of @xcite .
according to this conjecture , in four dimensions any non - singular bps solitonic representation of @xmath4-strings ( admitting an asymptotically locally flat space ) must be some sort of a @xmath0term string .
this can already be argued in a globally supersymmetric limit , but supergravity gives the following general argument ( see section [ supergravity ] ) .
any finite tension ( more precisely @xmath160 ) codimension two object , _ irrespective _ of its core structure , creates a conical angular deficit at infinity .
covariantly constant spinors can not be defined on a conical spacetime , so generically all the supersymmetries are broken .
the only way to avoid this conclusion is if the gravitino is charged under the @xmath11 responsible for the string magnetic flux , because in this case the gravitino variation contains a piece proportional to gauge connection .
the @xmath11 in question is therefore a gauged @xmath161symmetry . in @xmath2 supergravity
the necessary and sufficient condition for the gravitino to carry a @xmath11 charge is the presence of a constant fi term @xmath22 .
this gives the gravitino a charge @xmath162 thus , if bps @xmath4-strings admit a @xmath2 solitonic description , they should be seen as @xmath0term strings with a fi term .
this is the key point of @xcite .
what is the physical origin of this fi term ?
we have seen , that in theories with gs anomaly cancellation there always is a dilaton - dependent contribution to the fi term .
one may naively hope to convert this into a constant fi by stabilizing @xmath27 .
however , there is an obvious reason why such a program can not work@xcite .
even if one imagines that there can be a susy - preserving dynamics that stabilizes @xmath27 , the same dynamics should also get rid of fi term at low energies .
this is because @xmath27 becomes part of a massive vector supermultiplet , and if we supersymetrically integrate out @xmath27 , consistency demands that the whole vector field is integrated out leaving no @xmath0term at low energies .
thus , the constant fi term responsible for the bps @xmath4-strings must be there `` from the beginning '' .
the natural candidate is the tension of the @xmath163 system .
this conjecture passes several consistency checks , in particular it reproduces the correct relation between the @xmath0brane tensions .
however , the solution presented in @xcite was incomplete as bps @xmath0strings should also be charged under ramond - ramond fields which were not included in that solution .
because of this , the above conjecture left some puzzling questions , which our solutions clarify .
+ + + in ten dimensions @xmath164branes are supersymmetric objects carrying a quantized charge of the @xmath165 ramond - ramond gauge field .
upon compactification to four dimensions a @xmath5-brane can generate strings by wrapping a non trivial @xmath101cycle of the internal manifold .
these strings are will be charged under the two - form arising as the zero mode of the rr field to which the @xmath166brane couplesstrings will remain charged under the four dimensional rr two - form is model dependent as some zero modes may be projected out by the compactification @xcite .
here we imagine a compactification where the relevant zero modes are not projected out . ] . in four dimensions
a two - form is dual to a scalar so the @xmath0string should be an axionic string .
this naively leads to a puzzle because if the string carries an axionic charge @xmath55 , the energy density of the long range field should be @xmath167 which produces a logarithmic divergent energy per unit length .
while the formally infinite energy of a single global string can be acceptable phenomenologically when several strings are included ( such that the total axion charge is equal to zero ) the infinite contribution to the energy of the axion would certainly destroy the bps nature of the solutions .
this would seem to contradict to the expectation that @xmath4-strings are bps saturated objects .
the string solutions found in this paper have precisely the correct properties to solve this puzzle . to be concrete let us consider @xmath9-strings produced in @xmath16 annihilation . when the two branes are far apart , that is at a distance greater than the string length @xmath168 , this system breaks all the supersymmetries
. in the worldvolume description supersymmetry
is broken by the positive energy density of the branes . according to our description ,
this breaking is reproduced in the low energy effective action by a constant fi term .
the normalization is given by ( in string frame ) @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the string coupling and @xmath171 ( we follow the conventions of @xcite ) .
when the branes come closer than @xmath168 a complex tachyon develops in the spectrum of the open strings stretching between the brane - anti - brane pair , signaling an instability of the system .
this is the origin of the tachyon @xmath14 in our effective action .
as explained earlier the gauge symmetry of the @xmath16 pair is @xmath172 and the tachyon is charged with respect to the diagonal subgroup .
the annihilation proceeds through tachyon condensation in which the tachyon compensates the positive energy density restoring the supersymmetric vacuum without @xmath173branes .
this is the essence of sen s tachyon condensation @xcite . in the annihilation process codimension
two objects are produced which are @xmath0strings . in our picture
the strings produced in the annihilation are simply the @xmath75strings created by the winding of the phase of the tachyon .
one can see that the tension has the same scaling as in string theory . in our solution ,
@xmath174 comparing with eq .
( [ t3 ] ) this implies the relation @xmath175 .
this formula has the correct scaling between the yang - mills and string coupling .
the numerical coefficient is also reproduced for @xmath176 .
let us now discuss the rr charges .
the gauge field on the worldvolume of a @xmath12-brane couples to the rr two - form @xmath18 via the wess - zumino coupling , @xmath177 this coupling means that a magnetic flux tube carries the rr charge of @xmath18 in ten dimensions , or in other words it is a @xmath15brane . in the @xmath16 system branes
have opposite rr charges so that @xmath18 couples precisely to the same linear combination under which the tachyon is charged . by compactifying to four dimensions only the zero mode of @xmath18
is kept , leading to an effective action of the form , @xmath178 \label{action2}\ ] ] up to numerical factors and coupling to the dilaton . in order to connect our solutions with the string theory picture
it is useful to dualize the axion @xmath26 to a two - form @xmath18 in the lagrangian ( [ action ] ) .
the duality transformation is given by , @xmath179 through which the action takes the form ( [ action2 ] ) .
one can deduce that the axionic charge under the @xmath11 scales as @xmath30 which as expected vanishes in the large volume limit .
the four dimensional rr charge of the string solutions is given by , @xmath180 where the integral is taken over a circle surrounding the string . using eq .
( [ duality ] ) one can see that in all our solutions this integral is zero at infinity signifying that the rr charge , as measured with respect to the zero mode of @xmath18 , is always completely screened at large distances .
notice however that the integral is not zero at finite distances signaling the presence of an effective rr charge .
this behavior , beside being forced by finite energy , has a natural interpretation in the full string theory .
after compactification the four dimensional field @xmath27 is a combination of the radius modulus and the ten dimensional dilaton .
@xmath27 going to infinity therefore corresponds to decompactification of the space ( or alternatively the string coupling going to zero ) .
this is similar to the effect advocated in the stringy cosmic strings @xcite which also plays a crucial rle in the f - theory @xcite .
since the space is opening up new dimensions at large distances it is not surprising that the rr charge goes to zero as measured with the zero mode of the two - form @xmath18 .
similar arguments can be used for the @xmath181 system where @xmath6 dimensions are wrapped on the internal manifold . in this case
@xmath5 objects will be produced , which from a four dimensional point of view are just @xmath0strings .
@xmath5 branes couple to a @xmath182 form . upon
dimensional reduction the @xmath0strings will couple to a two - form arising as a zero mode of @xmath182 so the analysis above can be repeated almost verbatim in this case .
let us now turn to the @xmath3strings .
the above discussion set the stage for a simple interpretation of our @xmath27-string solution in the form of a bps @xmath183 bound state . in the @xmath27-strings
the @xmath1 energy is not compensated by the tachyon , but by the dilaton field .
since the tachyon is not condensed in the vacuum , this suggests that the branes do not annihilate but rather form some sort of boundstate . in ten dimensions the @xmath163 system is unstable but
this is not inconsistent with our findings since compactification is crucial in this case .
in fact even in ten dimension a @xmath184 pair can be made supersymmetric by switching on a constant electric field on the worldvolume @xcite .
in our case it is the magnetic flux that stabilizes the configuration so it would be interesting to investigate the relation between the two solutions .
we should also mention that since asymptotically @xmath27 goes to a constant of order one , it might be that the effective theory breaks down due to strong coupling .
even though we have focused on the @xmath185 system we believe that our @xmath27-type string solutions are more generic and will exist in any compactification in which there is at least one surviving @xmath186-brane with the wess - zumino type coupling @xmath187 between the worldvolume @xmath11 field and the bulk rr @xmath188-form .
the topological reason for the existence of such strings is that in the effective @xmath2 theory the @xmath11 symmetry is higgsed , provided the zero mode of @xmath189 form is not projected out .
this topological argument was already noticed in @xcite and @xcite but no smooth solutions were found . from above it follows that the tachyon plays an irrelevant role for the existence of the @xmath27-strings and its vev can consistently be set to zero .
the purpose of this paper was twofold .
first , we tried to find explicit bps - saturated string solutions in the supersymmetric abelian higgs model coupled to an axion - dilaton multiplet . these are new bps string solutions which arise in string motivated four dimensional models which have interest of their own .
secondly , we gave evidence that the strings in question have the basic features to describe the @xmath4-strings arising from unstable @xmath1 systems in type ii theories . in making this connection
our guidelines were : _ 1 ) _
sen s picture in which a @xmath5 brane can be thought of as a vortex of the complex open string tachyon of a @xmath190 pair ; _ 2 ) _ the conjecture @xcite that in @xmath2 the bps @xmath4-strings are the @xmath0term strings formed by higgsing the @xmath11 gauge symmetry due to the presence of a constant fi term .
one important result , supporting our string theory interpretation , is that finite energy bps solutions can only exist in the presence of a constant fi term in the effective action .
any field dependent fi term in isolation , for example those generated in heterotic string theory compactifications , can not support smooth bps strings because these configuration would have zero energy .
the difference between the two cases arises from the fact that a field dependent fi term is generated from the gauging of the shift symmetry of the axion while the constant fi term only affects the potential ( in global supersymmetry ) .
we have also shown that the finiteness of energy forces the bosonic partner of the axion to vary along the radial direction .
this behavior has a simple physical explanation .
an infinite straight axionic string in four dimensions is analogous to an electric charge in 2 + 1 dimensions so it would naively have a logarithmically divergent energy per unit length .
the only way to avoid this conclusion is if the charge is screened at large distances .
this precisely achieved by the variation of the dilaton .
the charge as measured from the flux goes to zero at large distances from the string so that the charge becomes completely screened .
we have found two qualitatively different classes of bps string solutions which we have dubbed the @xmath75strings and the @xmath3strings depending on whether the solution is supported by the tachyon field @xmath14 or the dilaton @xmath27 .
for the @xmath75strings the magnetic flux tube of the string is induced by the winding of the phase of the tachyon while for the @xmath3strings what is relevant is the axion winding .
for special values of the windings the two solutions merge into each other .
the coupling to supergravity was also discussed generalizing previous studies of @xcite .
under very general assumptions we have shown that bps string solutions in flat space ( with any khler potential for the chiral fields ) remain supersymmetric even after the coupling to supergravity .
as usual a finite energy configuration with codimension two produces an asymptotically conical space with deficit angle proportional to the tension of the object . the possibility to define killing spinors in this space relies on a remarkable cancellation between the deficit angle and the aharonov - bohm phase as first noticed in 2 + 1 dimensions in @xcite
we have shown that this effect is generic .
the main motivation for this work was the study of the connection between @xmath4-term strings and stringy @xmath0strings along the lines of @xcite .
@xmath0strings carry rr charges so it was our goal to clarify how to couple the @xmath0term strings to the rr fields .
a string couples electrically to a two - form which is dual to an axion in four dimensions . in this paper
we have shown that it is indeed possible to couple the abelian higgs model strings to an axionic multiplet preserving their bps nature .
the relation between @xmath0strings and gauge theory strings has interesting consequences for string cosmology and phenomenology such as the fact that brane - anti - brane energy is represented by an fi @xmath0term of the worldvolume theory .
this observation relates @xmath0term inflation @xcite to @xmath0brane inflation@xcite .
we hope to return to this and related issues in a future publication .
also having explicit solutions could be useful for a better understanding of the reconnection probability of cosmic @xmath4-strings and differentiating between ordinary gauge theory cosmic strings and the stringy ones@xcite . in this paper we heavily relied on supersymmetry and bps properties for two main reasons . on one hand we wished to obtain exact solutions at least in some approximation . on the other hand , supersymmetry was an useful tool for `` tagging '' the solutions in the @xmath2 theory and tracing their origin in full string theory picture . in the real world
, of course , supersymmetry is broken , and this breaking is expected to affect some properties of our solutions .
for example , dilaton stabilization may create a divergent tension . in this case
the strings will acquire some properties of global axionic cosmic strings , with an unusually small coupling to the axion . due to this smallness , the dynamics of such strings will still be dominated by their core structure .
it is a pleasure to thank s. chang , g. gabadaze , a. iglesias , r. kallosh , j. polchinski , a. van proeyen , n. weiner for useful discussions on related topics .
b - p . is supported by the james arthur fellowhip at nyu .
the work of g. d. and m. r. are supported in part by david and lucile packard foundation fellowship for science and engineering , and by the nsf grant phy-0245068 .
g. r. dvali and s. h. h. tye , `` brane inflation , '' phys .
b * 450 * , 72 ( 1999 ) , [ hep - ph/9812483 ] ; g. r. dvali , `` title : infrared hierarchy , thermal brane inflation and superstrings as superheavy dark matter , '' phys . lett .
b * 459 * , 489 , ( 1999 ) , [ hep - ph/9905204 ] ; g. r. dvali , q. shafi and s. solganik , `` d - brane inflation , '' [ hep - th/0105203 ] ; c. p. burgess , m. majumdar , d. nolte , f. quevedo , g. rajesh and r. j. zhang , `` the inflationary brane - antibrane universe , '' jhep * 0107 * , 047 ( 2001 ) , [ hep - th/0105204 ] ; s. kachru , r. kallosh , a. linde , j. maldacena , l. mcallister and s. p. trivedi , `` towards inflation in string theory , '' jcap * 0310 * , 013 ( 2003 ) , [ hep - th/0308055 ] ; k. dasgupta , c. herdeiro , s. hirano , r. kallosh , `` d3/d7 inflationary model and m - theory , '' phys
. rev .
d*65 * , 126002 ( 2002 ) , [ hep - th/0203019 ] .
g. dvali and a. vilenkin , `` formation and evolution of cosmic d - strings , '' jcap * 0403 * , 010 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0312007 ] ; g. dvali and a. vilenkin , `` solitonic d - branes and brane annihilation , '' phys .
d * 67 * , 046002 ( 2003 ) , [ hep - th/0209217 ] .
a. a. abrikosov,``on the magnetic properties of superconductors of the second group , '' sov .
jetp * 5 * , 1174 ( 1957 ) [ zh .
fiz . * 32 * , 1442 ( 1957 ) ] ; h. b. nielsen and p. olesen,``vortex - line models for dual strings , '' nucl .
b * 61 * , 45 ( 1973 ) .
m. dine , n. seiberg and e. witten , `` fayet - iliopoulos terms in string theory , '' nucl .
b * 289 * , 589 ( 1987 ) ; j. j. atick , l. j. dixon and a. sen , `` string calculation of fayet - iliopoulos d terms in arbitrary supersymmetric compactifications , '' nucl .
b * 292 * , 109 ( 1987 ) ; m. dine , i. ichinose and n. seiberg , `` f terms and d terms in string theory , '' nucl .
b * 293 * , 253 ( 1987 ) .
j. d. edelstein , c. nunez and f. a. schaposnik , `` supergravity and a bogomolny bound in three - dimensions , '' nucl .
b * 458 * , 165 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9506147 ] ; j. d. edelstein , c. nunez and f. a. schaposnik , `` bogomolnyi bounds and killing spinors in d=3 supergravity , '' phys .
b * 375 * , 163 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9512117 ] .
m. hindmarsh , `` existence and stability of semilocal strings , '' phys .
lett . , 68 , 9 , 1263 , ( 1992 ) ; r. a. leese , `` the stability of semilocal vortices at critical coupling , '' phys .
d * 46 * , 4677 ( 1992 ) .
s. b. giddings , s. kachru and j. polchinski , `` hierarchies from fluxes in string compactifications , '' phys .
d * 66 * , 106006 ( 2002 ) , [ hep - th/0105097 ] ; t. w. grimm and j. louis , `` the effective action of n = 1 calabi - yau orientifolds , '' nucl .
b * 699 * , 387 ( 2004 ) , [ hep - th/0403067 ] .
j. polchinski , `` string theory .
2 : superstring theory and beyond , '' cambridge , uk : univ . pr .
( 1998 ) 531 p. l. leblond and s. h. h. tye , `` stability of d1-strings inside a d3-brane , '' jhep * 0403 * , 055 ( 2004 ) [ hep - th/0402072 ] ; + g. r. dvali , unpublished .
p. binetruy and g. r. dvali , `` d - term inflation , '' phys .
b * 388 * 241 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9606342 ] ; e. halyo , `` hybrid inflation from supergravity d terms , '' phys .
b * 387 * 43 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9606423 ] . | in this work we derive non - singular bps string solutions from an action that captures the essential features of a @xmath0brane - anti-@xmath0brane system compactified to four dimensions .
the model we consider is a supersymmetric abelian higgs model with a @xmath0term potential coupled to an axion - dilaton multiplet .
the strings in question are axionic @xmath0term strings which we identify with the @xmath0strings of type ii string theory . in this picture
the higgs field represents the open string tachyon of the @xmath1 pair and the axion is dual to a ramond ramond form .
the crucial term allowing the existence of non - singular bps strings is the fayet - iliopoulos term , which is related to the tensions of the @xmath0string and of the parent branes . despite the presence of the axion ,
the strings are bps and carry finite energy , due to the fact that the space gets very slowly decompactified away from the core , screening the long range axion field ( or equivalently the theory approaches an infinitely weak @xmath2 coupling ) . within our @xmath2 effective action
we also identify another class of bps string solutions ( @xmath3strings ) which have no ten dimensional analog , and can only exist after compactification . |
to explain the cosmic acceleration found by the observations of type ia supernovae ( sne ia ) in 1998 @xcite , we usually introduce an exotic energy component with negative pressure to the right hand side of einstein equation .
this exotic energy component which consists about 72% of the total energy density in the universe is dubbed as dark energy .
although the cosmological constant is the simplest candidate for dark energy and is consistent with current observations , other possibilities are also explored due to the many orders of magnitude discrepancy between the theoretical estimation and astronomical observations for the cosmological constant .
currently we still have no idea about the nature of dark energy .
in particular , the question whether dark energy is the cosmological constant remains unanswered .
for a recent review of dark energy , please see ref .
@xcite .
one way of studying the nature of dark energy is though the observational data .
there are many model - independent studies on the nature of dark energy by using the observational data @xcite .
in particular , one usually parameterizes the energy density or the equation of state parameter @xmath7 of dark energy .
the most used parametrization is the chevallier - polarski - linder ( cpl ) parametrization @xcite with @xmath8 . because of the degeneracies among the parameters @xmath3 , @xmath2 and @xmath0 in the model ,
complementary cosmological observations are needed to break the degeneracies .
the measurement on the cosmic microwave background anisotropy , the baryon acoustic oscillation ( bao ) measurement and the sne ia observations provide complementary data . on the other hand ,
a minimally coupled scalar field @xmath9 was often invoked to model the quintessence @xcite , and the phantom @xcite . for a scalar field with a nearly flat potential , there exist approximate relations between the equation of state parameter @xmath10 and the energy density parameter @xmath11 @xcite . by using the generic relations
, we can break the degeneracy between @xmath7 and @xmath12 .
furthermore , @xmath7 can be approximated by the cpl parametrization with @xmath0 expressed as a function of @xmath2 and @xmath13 , so the two - parameter parametrization was reduced to one - parameter parametrization @xcite .
the cpl parametrization with analytical relations among the model parameters helps tighten the constraints on the model parameters . in this paper , we derive two particular cpl models with @xmath0 proportional to @xmath1 , and study the effects of the degeneracy relations between @xmath0 and @xmath2 by using the following data : the three year supernova legacy survey ( snls3 ) sample of 472 sne ia data with systematic errors @xcite ; the bao measurements from the 6dfgs @xcite , the distribution of galaxies @xcite in the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) and the wigglez dark energy survey @xcite ; the seven - year wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap7 ) data @xcite ; and the hubble parameter @xmath14 data @xcite .
for scalar fields satisfying the slow - roll conditions , @xmath15 a general relationship between @xmath16 and the energy density @xmath17 was found @xcite , @xmath18 ^ 2\nonumber\\ \times\left[\frac{1}{\sqrt{\omega_{\phi0}}}-(\omega_{\phi0}^{-1}-1)\tanh^{-1 } \sqrt{\omega_{\phi0}}\right]^{-2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the above result does not depend on the specific form of the potential @xmath19 and holds for thawing models @xcite with the potentials satisfying the slow roll conditions ( [ slow1 ] ) . following refs .
@xcite , we first approximate the energy density @xmath11 as @xmath20^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and we get @xmath21^{-2}\nonumber\\ \times\left[\sqrt{1+(\omega_{\phi 0}^{-1}-1)a^{-3}}-(\omega_{\phi 0}^{-1}-1)a^{-3}\tanh^{-1}[1+(\omega_{\phi 0}^{-1}-1)a^{-3}]^{-1/2}\right]^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in other words , we now consider a scalar field with @xmath22 given by equation ( [ wzeq1 ] ) . if we taylor expand @xmath23 and @xmath22 around @xmath24 , we get @xmath25,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath26 therefore , we derive the cpl parametrization with @xmath0 determined by @xmath2 and @xmath13 starting from equation ( [ eq15 ] ) .
we call this model as sslcpl model .
in particular , we get @xcite @xmath27 } { \omega_{\phi 0}^{-1/2}-(\omega_{\phi 0}^{-1}-1)\tanh^{-1}(\sqrt{\omega_{\phi0}})}.\ ] ] when @xmath28 , we get @xmath29 which is consistent with the numerical result @xmath30 obtained in @xcite . for the sslcpl model
, we only have two model parameters @xmath3 and @xmath2 for the spatially flat case and three model parameters @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2 for the spatially curved case . next we approximate @xmath11 by the model with constant equation of state @xmath31 , @xmath32 the taylor expansion around @xmath24 gives @xmath33\}^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting the result ( [ tphiw ] ) into equation ( [ eq15 ] ) , we then obtain , @xmath34(1-a ) } { \omega_{\phi 0}^{-1/2}-(\omega_{\phi 0}^{-1}-1)\tanh^{-1}(\sqrt{\omega_{\phi0}})},\end{aligned}\ ] ] so again we get cpl parametrization with @xmath35 } { \omega_{\phi 0}^{-1/2}-(\omega_{\phi 0}^{-1}-1)\tanh^{-1}(\sqrt{\omega_{\phi0}})}.\ ] ] we call this model as sswcpl model . for the sswcpl model , we only have two model parameters @xmath3 and @xmath2 for the spatially flat case and three model parameters @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2 for the spatially curved case . for both the sslcpl and sswcpl models , we find that @xmath36 , so the models are automatically consistent with @xmath4cdm model with @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
we apply the sne ia , bao , wmap7 and the hubble parameter @xmath14 data to test the effects of the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) and ( [ twa ] ) on the constraints of @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2 .
the snls3 sne ia data consists of 123 low - redshift sne ia data with @xmath39 mainly from calan / tololo , cfai , cfaii , cfaiii and csp , 242 sne ia over the redshift range @xmath40 observed from the snls @xcite , 93 intermediate - redshift sne ia data with @xmath41 observed during the first season of sdss - ii supernova survey @xcite , and 14 high - redshift sne ia data with @xmath42 from hubble space telescope @xcite . for the fitting to the snls3 data ,
we need to add two more nuisance parameters @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
the bao data @xcite consists of the measurement at the redshift @xmath45 from the 6dfgs @xcite , the measurements of the distribution of galaxies at two redshifts @xmath46 and @xmath47 @xcite in the sdss and the measurements of the acoustic parameter at three redshifts @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 from wigglez dark energy survey @xcite . for the bao data , we need to add two more nuisance parameters @xmath51 and @xmath52 . for the wmap7 data
, we use the measurements of the shift parameter and the acoustic index at the recombination redshift @xcite , and we need to add two more nuisance parameters @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the hubble parameter @xmath14 data consists of the measurements of @xmath14 at 11 different redshifts obtained from the differential ages of passively evolving galaxies @xcite , and three data points at redshifts @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 , determined by taking the bao scale as a standard ruler in the radial direction @xcite .
the @xmath14 data spans out to the redshift regions @xmath56 . after obtaining the constraints on the model parameters , we reconstruct @xmath7 and apply the @xmath57 diagnostic @xcite to detect the deviation from the @xmath4cdm model
@xmath58 is defined as @xmath59 where the dimensionless hubble parameter @xmath60 .
we first consider the effects of the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) and ( [ twa ] ) on @xmath3 and @xmath2 , so we take the spatially flat case @xmath61 . fitting the sslcpl model to the observational data , we get the marginalized @xmath5 constraints @xmath62 and @xmath63 with @xmath64 . by using the degeneracy relation ( [ waeq1 ] ) and the correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath2 , we derived the marginalized @xmath5 constraint @xmath65 .
we show the marginalized @xmath5 and @xmath66 contours of @xmath3 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figure [ fsslcpl ] . by using the correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath2 ,
we reconstruct the evolutions of @xmath7 and @xmath58 in figure [ fsslcpl ] . and @xmath66 constraints on the flat sslcpl model .
the upper panels are for the @xmath5 and @xmath66 contour plots of @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the lower panels show the reconstructions of @xmath7 and @xmath58 by using the constraints on @xmath3 and @xmath2 .
[ fsslcpl],scaledwidth=60.0% ] fitting the sswcpl model to the observational data , we get the marginalized @xmath5 constraints @xmath69 and @xmath70 with @xmath64 . by using the degeneracy relation ( [ twa ] ) and the correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath2 , we derived the marginalized @xmath5 constraint @xmath71 .
we show the marginalized @xmath5 and @xmath66 contours of @xmath3 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figure [ fswlcpl ] . by using the correlation between @xmath3 and @xmath2 ,
we reconstruct the evolutions of @xmath7 and @xmath58 in figure [ fswlcpl ] . and @xmath66 constraints on the flat sswcpl model .
the upper panels are for the @xmath5 and @xmath66 contour plots of @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the lower panels show the reconstructions of @xmath7 and @xmath58 by using the constraints on @xmath3 and @xmath2 .
[ fswlcpl],scaledwidth=60.0% ] fitting the cpl model to the observational data , we get the marginalized @xmath5 constraints @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 with @xmath75 . we show the marginalized @xmath5 and @xmath66 contours of @xmath3 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figure [ fcpl ] . by using the correlations among the parameters ,
we reconstruct the evolutions of @xmath7 and @xmath58 in figure [ fcpl ] . and
@xmath66 constraints on the flat cpl model .
the upper panels are for the @xmath5 and @xmath66 contour plots of @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the lower panels are the reconstructions of @xmath7 and @xmath58 by using the constraints on @xmath3 , @xmath2 and @xmath0 .
[ fcpl],scaledwidth=60.0% ] these results are summarized in table [ table1 ] . comparing the results from three models , we find that all three models fit the observational data well because they give almost the same value of @xmath76 . in terms of the akaike information criterion ( aic ) @xcite or bayesian information criterion ( bic ) @xcite , the sslcpl and sswcpl model fit the observational data a little better than the cpl model does .
all three models are consistent with @xmath4cdm model at the @xmath5 level , as shown explicitly by the @xmath7 and @xmath58 plots in figs .
[ fsslcpl]-[fcpl ] . from the contour plots for @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figs .
[ fsslcpl]-[fcpl ] , we see that the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) for the sslcpl model and ( [ twa ] ) for the sswcpl model are consistent with that for the cpl model and the variation of @xmath7 is constrained much tighter .
the effects of the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) and ( [ twa ] ) on @xmath3 are minimal .
the @xmath5 errors of @xmath2 for sslcpl and sswcpl models are reduced around 30% with the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) and ( [ twa ] ) compared with that in cpl model . .the marginalized @xmath5 constraints from observational data . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table1 ] now we consider the impact of @xmath6 . fitting the curved sslcpl model to the observational data , we get the marginalized @xmath5 constraints @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 with @xmath64 . by using the degeneracy relation ( [ waeq1 ] ) and the correlations among @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2 , we derived the marginalized @xmath5 constraint @xmath80 .
it can be seen that the curvature @xmath6 has little effect on @xmath2 .
we show the marginalized @xmath5 and @xmath66 contours of @xmath3 and @xmath6 , @xmath3 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figure 4 . by using the correlations among @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2
, we reconstruct the evolution of @xmath7 in figure [ csslcpl ] . fitting the curved sswcpl model to the observational data , we get the marginalized @xmath5 constraints @xmath81 , @xmath82 and
@xmath83 with @xmath84 . by using the degeneracy relation ( [ twa ] ) and the correlations among @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2 , we derived the marginalized @xmath5 constraint @xmath85 . and @xmath66 constraints on the curved sslcpl model .
the upper and the lower left panels are for the @xmath5 and @xmath66 contour plots of @xmath86 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the lower right panel is the reconstruction of @xmath7 from the curved sslcpl model .
[ csslcpl],scaledwidth=60.0% ] again the curvature @xmath6 has little effect on @xmath2 .
we show the marginalized @xmath5 and @xmath66 contours of @xmath3 and @xmath6 , @xmath3 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figure [ cswlcpl ] . by using the correlations among @xmath3 , @xmath6 and @xmath2 , we reconstruct the evolution of @xmath7 in figure [ cswlcpl ] . and @xmath66 constraints on the curved sswcpl model .
the upper and the lower left panels are for the @xmath5 and @xmath66 contour plots of @xmath86 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the lower right panel is the reconstruction of @xmath7 from the curved sswcpl model .
[ cswlcpl],scaledwidth=60.0% ] fitting the curved cpl model to the observational data , we get the marginalized @xmath5 constraints @xmath72 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 and @xmath89 with @xmath90 .
we show the marginalized @xmath5 and @xmath66 contours of @xmath3 and @xmath6 , @xmath3 and @xmath2 , and @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figure [ ccpl ] . by using the correlation between @xmath2 and @xmath0 , we reconstruct the evolution of @xmath7 in figure [ ccpl ] . and
@xmath66 constraints on the curved cpl model . the upper and the lower left panels are for the @xmath5 and @xmath66 contour plots of @xmath86 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the lower right panel is the reconstruction of @xmath7 by using the constraints on @xmath2 and @xmath0 from the curved cpl model .
[ ccpl],scaledwidth=60.0% ] the addition of @xmath6 has little impact on @xmath3 for all three models , but it increases the @xmath5 error on @xmath2 for cpl model . on the other hand , the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) and ( [ twa ] ) help reduce the @xmath5 error on @xmath6 .
these results are summarized in table [ table1 ] . at the @xmath5 level ,
@xmath4cdm model is consistent with the observational data as shown explicitly by the @xmath7 plots in figs .
[ csslcpl]-[ccpl ] . from the contour plots for @xmath2 and @xmath0 in figs .
[ csslcpl]-[ccpl ] , we see that the degeneracy relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) for the sslcpl model and ( [ twa ] ) for the sswcpl model are consistent with that for the cpl model .
from the relationship ( [ eq15 ] ) for thawing models with a nearly flat potential , we derived the sslcpl and sswcpl models which break the degeneracies among @xmath13 , @xmath2 and @xmath0 .
the two models reduce to the cpl model with only one free parameter @xmath2 . the proposed degeneracy relations for @xmath2 and @xmath0 are consistent with that found for the original cpl model , so the sslcpl and sswcpl models are self consistent .
both models give almost the same minimum @xmath76 as the original cpl does when fitting to the observational data . in terms of aic or bic ,
the models fit the observational data a litter better than the original cpl does . with the help of relations ( [ waeq1 ] ) and ( [ twa ] ) ,
the @xmath5 error bar of @xmath2 is reduced about 30% and 50% for the flat and curved cases respectively , and the @xmath5 error bar of @xmath6 is reduced about 25% . since the parameters @xmath3 and @xmath2 have little change for the sslcpl and sswcpl models when we consider the curved case , this effect is unexpected and further understanding of it needs to be studied . both sslcpl and sswcpl models have only one free parameter and they help tighten the constraint on @xmath6 , so they can be applied to probe the curvature of the universe .
this work was partially supported by the national basic science program ( project 973 ) of china under grant no .
2010cb833004 , the nnsf of china under grant nos .
10935013 and 11175270 , and the fundamental research funds for the central universities .
53ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1086/300499 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1086/307221 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0253 - 6102/56/3/24 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2004.08189.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2004/06/008 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2007.03.021 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2007/08/011 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.67.063521 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0370 - 2693(01)00072 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1046/j.1365 - 8711.1999.02997.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1046/j.1365 - 8711.2002.05612.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2007/09/004 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1086/383196 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.86.1939 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.80.083515 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.80.101301 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2010/04/012 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2009.15851.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.80.121302 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2010/01/019 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2010/04/019 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0264 - 9381/27/15/155015 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2011.18846.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2011/07/011 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2010.10.044 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.84.103519 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2004.05.008 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1142/s0218271801000822 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.90.091301 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop * * , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.80.043521 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/0550 - 3213(88)90193 - 9 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.37.3406 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.80.1582 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0370 - 2693(02)02589 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.77.083515 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.78.067303 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2011.09.034 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.251301 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1088/0067 - 0049/192/1/1 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2011.19250.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2009.15812.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2011.19592.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0067 - 0049/192/2/18 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2009.15405.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2010/02/008 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.141301 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0067 - 0049/185/1/32 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1086/510378 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.71.123001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.78.103502 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1109/tac.1974.1100705 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1214/aos/1176344136 [ * * , ( ) ] | we analytically derived two models which reduce to the familiar chevallier - polarski - linder parametrization with @xmath0 proportional to @xmath1 .
the two models have only one free parameter @xmath2 , which helps us eliminate the degeneracy among @xmath0 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 , and makes the models automatically consistent with the @xmath4cdm model . with these degeneracy relations ,
we test their effects on the constraints of cosmological parameters .
we find that : ( 1 ) the degeneracy between @xmath2 and @xmath0 for the two models is consistent with that found for the original chevallier - polarski - linder model ; ( 2 ) the degeneracies have little effect on @xmath3 ; ( 3 ) the @xmath5 error of @xmath6 was reduced about 25% with the degeneracy relations ; ( 4 ) the @xmath5 error of @xmath2 was reduced about one half with the degeneracy relations . |
networks with randomly distributed single walled carbon nanotubes ( swcnts ) are emerging as novel materials for various applications , particularly as electronic materials .
@xcite this creates a need for the accurate determination of their fundamental electrical properties .
swcnt networks can be viewed as a two - dimensional network of conducting one - dimensional rods.@xcite these rods are either metallic or semiconducting with large dimension ratio(length / diameter @xmath2 ) , which leads to the following interesting behavior.@xcite since the nanotube - nanotube junction resistance is much larger than the nanotube resistance itself,@xcite such a network can be seen as a system with randomly distributed barriers for electrical transport . for a sub - monolayer network ,
the junction resistance will dominate the overall resistance and the network resistance shows percolation behavior with nonlinear thickness dependence.@xcite for swcnt networks with thickness in the tens of nanometers , e.g. with tens of layers of swcnts , the conductance through the metallic tubes will dominate the conduction , and leads to metallic behavior of the overall resistance.@xcite the frequency - dependent and electric - field - dependent conductivity have been investigated for individual swcnt@xcite and some types of swcnt networks.@xcite burke and co - workers measured the microwave conductivity of individual swcnts and investigated their operation as a transistor at 2.6 ghz.@xcite for swcnt networks with 30 nm thickness , our previous work finds the ac conductivity is frequency - independent up to an onset frequency @xmath3 of about 10 ghz , beyond which it increases with an approximate power law behavior.@xcite for thicker films with thickness in the range of tens of micrometers , p. peit _
_ found that conductivities at dc and 10 ghz are almost the same.@xcite m. fuhrer _
_ observed the nonlinearity of the electric field - dependent conductivity of relatively thick nanotube networks , and they claimed that the charge carriers can be localized by disorder in the swcnts with an approximate length scale @xmath4 of 1.65@xmath5m.@xcite v. skakalova _
_ studied the current - voltage(_i - v _ ) characteristics of individual nanotubes and nanotube networks of varying thickness , and discussed the modulation of _ i - v _ characteristics by a gate - source voltage.@xcite however there is a lack of frequency and electric field dependent conductivity investigation for systematic variation of network densities , and also there is no correlation study between the onset frequency @xmath0 and the length scale determined from nonlinear transport .
the frequency- and electric - field - dependent conductivity investigation of different network densities is not only helpful to build a comprehensive understanding of the electrical transport properties of swcnt networks , but is also important for the sake of applications of these networks.@xcite for example , when using swcnt networks to construct high speed transistors , or as transparent shielding materials , knowledge of their frequency dependent electric transport properties are required .
also use of swcnt networks as inter - connects in circuits requires understanding of their electric field - dependent properties . in this paper
, we investigated the frequency- and electric - field - dependent conductivity for swcnt networks with systematically varying densities .
we find that the onset frequency @xmath0 extracted from the frequency dependence measurement increases with the film thickness , while the length scale extracted from the electric field dependent measurement decreases at the same time .
using the measured @xmath0 and the extracted length scale @xmath1 for different films , we developed an empirical relation between the two transport measurement methods .
swcnt networks on polyethylene terephthalate ( pet ) substrate are prepared by the spraying method.@xcite arc - discharged nanotube powder from carbon solution inc .
was dispersed in water with sodium dodecyl sulphate surfactants .
the tubes were purified with nitric acid and left with a variety of functional groups.@xcite after the nanotubes were sprayed on the substrate , the samples were rinsed in water thoroughly to wash away the surfactant .
the network density , defined as the number of nanotubes per unit area , was controlled by the solution concentration(0.1 - 1 mg / ml ) and the spraying time(10 - 60 seconds ) .
the nanotubes formed bundles with size of 4 - 7 nm and length of 2 - 4 @xmath5m.@xcite the thicknesses of the films range from submonolayer to 200 nm corresponding to room temperature sheet conductance ranging from @xmath6 to @xmath7 s / square .
fig.[fig : figuresample ] shows sem images of films with two different coverage densities .
it is convenient to characterize the films by their sheet conductance rather than conductivity , because of the inhomogeneous nature of the conducting pathways and thus the difficulty in assigning a film thickness , particularly for submonolayer films .
= 2.5 in = 3.8 in the corbino reflectometry setup , which is ideal for broadband conductivity measurements of resistive materials,@xcite was used to investigate the conductivity of the swcnt networks .
the measurement procedures are similar to our previous work.@xcite in order to measure the conductivity in as broad a frequency range as possible , two test instruments are used , the agilent e8364b network analyzer ( covering 10 mhz to 50 ghz ) and the agilent 4396b network analyzer ( covering 100 khz to 1.8 ghz ) , giving five and half decades of frequency coverage . the electric field dependent conductivity was measured with a standard 4-probe method in a well - shielded high precision dc transport probe.@xcite
the data of conductance vs. frequency are shown in fig.[fig : figurecond](a ) .
the films decrease in thickness from sample 1 ( 200 nm ) to sample 5 ( sub - monolayer ) .
for all the films , the real parts of the conductance keep their dc value up to a characteristic frequency and start to increase at higher frequency .
this kind of behavior has been widely observed for disordered systems.@xcite similar behavior has been found for carbon nanotube polymer composites close to the percolation threshold , in which the extended pair approximation model was applied to describe the observed phenomena.@xcite the carbon nanotube networks in fig .
[ fig : figurecond](a ) have densities well above the percolation threshold .
however , since the junction resistances between different tubes are much larger than the resistance of the tubes themselves,@xcite swcnt networks above the percolation threshold can still be seen as systems with randomly distributed barriers for electrical transport . in this case
the extended pair approximation model can be used to describe the real part of the ac conductance : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the dc conductance , @xmath10 , @xmath11 is a constant and @xmath0 is the onset frequency.@xcite = 3.2 in = 4.8 in the obtained frequency dependent conductance in fig.[fig : figurecond](a ) fit well to the extended pair approximation model . fig .
[ fig : figurecond](b ) shows the relation between the fit film onset frequency and the dc sheet conductance .
the onset frequency changes from @xmath12 to @xmath13 rad / sec as the sheet conductance increases from @xmath6 to @xmath7 s / square .
the onset frequency of the ac conductance increases as the dc conductance increases .
the solid line fig.[fig : figurecond].(b ) has slope one , implying a linear relation between the onset frequency and their dc sheet conductance , or @xmath14 , over about 4 decades .
we also measured the frequency - dependent conductance of ultra - thin sub - monolayer nanotube networks , which are fabricated via the filtration method.@xcite we choose chloroform as the solvent instead of water to avoid the washing steps which can easily destroy the sub - monolayer film structure .
the network density is controlled by the concentration and volume of the solvent used.@xcite the conductance of these films are measured by a 4284a precision lcr meter , covering the frequency range from 20 hz to 1 mhz . for these films just above the percolation threshold , their frequency dependent conductance also fit well to the extended pair approximation model . in fig .
[ fig : swcntfig4 ] , we plot the onset frequency versus their dc sheet conductance . for comparison , we also present results of kilbride _
et al._,@xcite for polymer - nanotube composites as well as the data from fig.[fig : figurecond](b ) for our films prepared by the spray method .
the three solid lines in fig .
[ fig : swcntfig4 ] all have slope one ( @xmath15 ) . here
an interesting result is that although the intercepts are very different , the slopes of the three different samples are essentially the same .
the difference in intercept is due to the different types of nanotubes .
different carbon nanotube sources have different bundle sizes and lengths , which causes the conductance difference .
the polymer - cnt composite has much smaller dc conductance than the other two , due to the separation of swcnts by polymer that leads to charge transfer barriers . despite these differences in detail
, there is a universal relationship between onset frequency and dc conductance .
= 3.4 in = 2.8 in the linear proportionality @xmath16 is one of the characteristic features of ac conductance of disordered solids.@xcite for disordered systems , the universality of ac conductance has been studied by many researchers since its discovery in the 1950 s , and is usually referred to as taylor - isard scaling .
@xcite this inspires us to investigate the scaling behavior of the conductance and frequency for swcnt networks .
similar to kilbride _
s work@xcite , taking the dc conductance @xmath9 and the onset frequency @xmath0 as scaling parameters , we plotted the ac conductance data for all samples in fig .
[ fig : swcntscaling ] .
the data show a scaling behavior with all data sets falling on the same master curve described by @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
= 3.4 in = 2.8 in in order to explain the observed onset frequency change with the swcnt volume fraction for polymer - nanotube composites close to percolation threshold , kilbride _
defined a characteristic length scale , the `` correlation length '' @xmath19.@xcite for our samples , which are well above the percolation threshold , we can similarly define the correlation length @xmath19 as the distance between connections in the sample , i.e. , the distance between junctions of the multiply - connected swcnt network .
when one measures the conductance at a given frequency , there is a typical probed length scale . at low frequencies ( corresponding to long time periods )
, the carriers travel long distances in one - half ac cycle and the experiment investigates longer length scales . at high frequencies , the carriers travel short distances in one half ac - cycle and
the probed length scale is shorter . in the absence of an applied dc electric field , and assuming a random walk , the probed length scale @xmath20.@xcite for low frequency , @xmath21 , the probed length scale spans multiple junctions of the swcnt network .
the junction resistances between different tubes are much larger than the resistances of the tubes themselves .
@xcite hence the conductance is small and equal to the dc conductance . as the frequency increases , @xmath22 becomes smaller than @xmath19 , @xmath23 , and the junction resistances have less contribution to the total resistance .
the intrinsic properties of the swcnt then dominate the measurement .
therefore the observed conductance increases as the frequency increases .
the transition frequency is expected to be that where carriers scan an average distance of order of the correlation length .
@xcite the swcnt film can be treated as a random walk network , in which the probed length scale at a given frequency goes as @xmath24 . then with the onset frequency @xmath0 of samples we are able to estimate their correlation length @xmath25 . as the density of the swcnt networks increases , there are more junctions and the average distance between connections , the correlation length @xmath19 , becomes smaller and thus the onset frequency @xmath0 increases .
this is consistent with the behavior shown by the data in fig .
[ fig : figurecond ] .
from the measured frequency dependent conductivity , we observed that the correlation length @xmath19 varies as the thickness of the film increases .
due to the large resistance of junctions between different tubes , the carriers in the swcnt networks are easier to move on small length scales than on larger length scales .
this phenomenon inspires us to investigate whether the transport properties are nonlinear as a result . according to the works of m. s. fuhrer _
_ , the localization behavior of a swcnt network can be studied by measuring the electric field dependent nonlinearity of the conductivity .
@xcite generally , increasing both the temperature and the electric field reduces the effects of localization .
hence a system typically displays a characteristic electric field at which nonlinear conductivity begins to appear . through measurement of the characteristic field
@xmath26 one can determine a length scale of the system : @xmath27 where @xmath1 corresponds to the size of the regions with good conductivity , and @xmath28 is the energy gained by a carrier in one conducting region on average.@xcite .
for our swcnt films @xmath29 depends on the average distance between connections and thus should vary with sample thickness . for relatively thick
films(@xmath30 ) with low sheet resistance , fuhrer _ et al .
_ found a temperature - independent length scale @xmath31 m in a swcnt film.@xcite here we investigated the electric field - dependent conductance for a different class of films .
the studied samples were cut into rectangular pieces with length @xmath32 mm and width @xmath33 mm .
gold contact leads , which completely cover the width of the samples , were deposited on the surfaces of the samples to form a standard four probe pattern .
the measured swcnt networks have dimensions of @xmath34mm@xmath353 mm , between the two voltage leads . because swcnt films have a large in - plane thermal conductivity , @xcite and the probe used to perform the measurement
was specially designed to reduce heating effects@xcite we believe that the heating effect can be ignored in our measurement range .
this was confirmed by observing the voltage response of pulsed current input of several samples in the time domain with an oscilloscope .
= 3.2 in = 4.8 in the dc resistance vs. electric field of a submonolayer film(sample 5 ) at different temperatures is shown in fig.[fig : swcntfig5](a ) .
we can see clearly that there is nonlinear behavior even at room temperature . as sketched in fig.[fig : swcntfig5](a ) , we extracted @xmath26 for each temperature , which is the characteristic electric field at which nonlinear conductance begins to appear.@xcite fig.[fig : swcntfig5](b ) shows the extracted @xmath26 vs temperature for this sample . as temperature increases ,
@xmath26 also increases .
roughly , @xmath26 and temperature have a linear relationship and satisfy the equation @xmath36 , with @xmath37 .
note that this is much larger than the @xmath4 obtained in ref.@xcite .
this suggests that a different mechanism for hindering transport is active here , namely poor contacts between bundles of swcnts . to investigate the dependence of @xmath29 on the film thickness , we measured the electric field - dependent conductance for samples with various thicknesses .
we found that the nonlinear behavior strongly depends on the thickness of the film . at low temperature ,
all the samples show nonlinear behavior of resistance on electric field , and the critical field @xmath26 is larger for thicker samples and smaller for thin samples . at room temperature ,
all the other samples are purely ohmic(linear ) in electric fields up to 100 v / cm , except for the thinnest sample , sample 5 , which showed electric field - dependent conductance at all temperatures . through the critical field @xmath26
, we extracted the @xmath29 for different density films , shown in fig.[fig : swcntfig6 ] as red - dots .
clearly @xmath29 depends on the density of the swcnt networks . for the thicker film with larger swcnt density , which has larger sheet conductance ,
the @xmath29 is smaller .
the lower density films with larger average distance between the junctions has larger @xmath29 .
= 2.6 in although the localization behavior may be affected by the properties of individual swcnts @xcite , the above result shows that the observed behavior is more likely a consequence of poor electric conduction through inter - bundle junctions . as the thickness and density increase , there are more and more connections , which decreases the length scale @xmath29 , as shown in fig.[fig : swcntfig6 ] . when the film thickness increases to a large value , the density of the swcnts and connections of the film will finally saturate and stop increasing . for those very thick swcnt films ( also called mats ) , their correlation length @xmath19 , and also the length scale @xmath29 , as well as the onset frequency ,
will be independent of the thickness , but depend on the properties of individual bundles , which include both the disorder of the individual nanotube and also the geometry of the bundles .
hence the difference of swcnt sources and purities can change the onset frequency .
we believe this is the reason that our previous work found that the ac conductivity follows the extended pair approximation model with an onset frequency @xmath0 about 10 ghz , while peit _
_ found that swcnt networks have the same conductivities at dc and 10 ghz for swcnt networks with thickness in the range of tens of micrometers.@xcite
the frequency dependent conductivity shows that the onset frequency @xmath0 increases with the sample thickness and gives an estimation of the correlation length @xmath19 of the sample , @xmath38 .
@xmath19 and @xmath39 decrease as the sample thickness increases .
the dc nonlinear conductivity measurement shows that the length scale @xmath29 of the samples also decreases with increasing sample thickness .
qualitatively @xmath39 and @xmath29 have the same dependence on the sample thickness . based on the above consideration
, it is reasonable to expect some correlation between the onset frequency @xmath0 and the length scale @xmath29 , and we proposed the following relation , @xmath40 where @xmath41 is a fitting parameter , which can be obtain from our experiment data , @xmath42 .
fig.[fig : swcntfig6 ] shows the comparison of the nonlinear transport length scale @xmath29 measured directly through electric - field dependent dc conductance measurements(red - dot ) and the right - hand side of eq .
[ eq : emperequation ] from the frequency dependent measurement(black - star ) .
they are consistent with each other . in this way we obtain an empirical relation between the frequency - dependent and the electric field - dependent conductivity .
the parameter @xmath41 should depend on the diffusion properties of carriers in the swcnt films.@xcite writing @xmath43 , where d is a diffusion constant and @xmath44 is the corresponding time scale , we take @xmath45 . assuming the einstein relation @xmath46 , we can estimate the mobility of carriers on the swcnt network , which is on the order of @xmath47 .
this is much smaller than that of the individual single walled carbon nanotube , which can be on the order of @xmath48 at room temperature.@xcite in the swcnt networks , due to the randomly distributed barriers for electrical transport , the mobility is expected to be much smaller than the swcnt itself .
the carbon nanotube film - based transistors have reported mobilities on the order of @xmath49,@xcite which is consistent with our estimation . to get a deeper physical understanding of these networks , more investigation and theoretical work are needed .
for example , measuring the temperature dependence of the frequency - dependent conductivity for swcnt networks with various densities would be one approach.@xcite
to conclude , we systematically studied the frequency and electric field dependent conductivity of swcnt films of various thicknesses .
we found the poor interbundle junctions affect the transport behavior of the carriers in the swnct films , which causes strong thickness dependence of characteristic length scales .
a thinner film has larger correlation length @xmath19 and length scale @xmath29 , so it has a smaller onset frequency @xmath0 , whereas a thicker film with smaller correlation length @xmath19 and length scale @xmath29 , has a larger onset frequency @xmath0 .
an approximate empirical formula relating the onset frequency @xmath0 and nonlinear transport length scale establishes contact between the frequency and the electric field dependent conductivity , which helps us to understand the electric transport properties of the swcnt films .
+ the authors would like to thank m. s. fuhrer , c. j. lobb , weiqiang yu and bing liang for their help and discussions on this work .
this work has been supported by center for nanophysics and advanced materials of the university of maryland and the national science foundation grant nos .
( dmr-0404029 ) , ( dmr-0322844 ) , and ( dmr-0302596 ) . | we present measurements of the frequency and electric field dependent conductivity of single walled carbon nanotube(swcnt ) networks of various densities .
the ac conductivity as a function of frequency is consistent with the extended pair approximation model and increases with frequency above an onset frequency @xmath0 which varies over seven decades with a range of film thickness from sub - monolayer to 200 nm .
the nonlinear electric field - dependent dc conductivity shows strong dependence on film thickness as well .
measurement of the electric field dependence of the resistance r(e ) allows for the determination of a length scale @xmath1 possibly characterizing the distance between tube contacts , which is found to systematically decrease with increasing film thickness .
the onset frequency @xmath0 of ac conductivity and the length scale @xmath1 of swcnt networks are found to be correlated , and a physically reasonable empirical formula relating them has been proposed .
such studies will help the understanding of transport properties and benefit the applications of this material system . |
in an aqueous solution , the hydrophobic parts of amphiphilic molecules tend to separate themselves from water molecules by forming aggregates , such as micelles and microemulsion droplets .
the simplest amphiphilic structure occurs if the polar and hydrophobic parts of the amphiphilic molecule are well separated into head and tail regions .
motivated by the structure of sphingolipids and glycolipids ( fig .
[ figglycolipid ] ) , we will refer to this type of molecule as ` lipids ' ( although we note here that this generic structure is not common to all classes of lipid ) . for molecules such as those in fig .
[ figglycolipid ] , micelles consist of a polar outer surface and a hydrophobic core which contains all the tails . by contrast ,
amphiphilic species whose polar and hydrophobic regions are distributed over the entire molecule , rather than being clearly separated , aggregate to form more general assemblies for the purpose of minimizing the hydrophobic area per molecule exposed to the aqueous phase . we will refer to this general category of mixed hp molecules as ` amphiphiles . '
poly(n - isopropylacrylamide ) , a polymer belonging to this class , exhibits a phase transition at a lower critical solution temperature ( lcst ) from a homogeneous solution , where the polymers are completely soluble , to a system of two separated phases @xcite . at an upper critical solution temperature ( ucst ) the organic phase disaggregates , and above this temperature the amphiphilic molecules are again soluble due to entropic effects @xcite .
substitution of polar by hydrophobic monomers in amphiphiles of given length leads to alterations of the critical solution temperatures which depend on the size of hydrophobic surface regions @xcite . ) , with one non - polar hydrocarbon tail ; ( b ) a glycolipid ( @xmath0 ) , with two tails .
the relatively large , polar head - groups contain in addition oxygen and nitrogen atoms . ,
width=264 ] micelle formation , and the aggregation of amphiphilic molecules in general , may be treated as a phase separation occurring at a critical micellar concentration ( cmc ) which describes the density of amphiphiles where the system enters the two - phase region @xcite . above the cmc ,
amphiphilic molecules in aqueous solutions self - associate , forming small aggregates to decrease the net contact between their hydrophobic surfaces and the surrounding solvent .
a small fraction of the lipid molecules remains free in the solution , with a concentration close to the cmc value .
as the concentration increases , the onset of a semi - dilute regime is found , where the system may be considered as a solution of relatively few water molecules dissolved in an amphiphilic medium @xcite . for lipid molecules ,
the cmc decreases as the length of the hydrophobic chain increases @xcite , indicating a stabilization of aggregates as a consequence of the stronger net repulsion between the tail and the surrounding water .
for the same reason , the lcst is thought to decrease as the tail grows , as suggested in ref .
one means of probing the nature of the phase diagram and the effective hydrophobic interactions would be by systematic alteration of the polarity of the amphiphilic polymers in solution .
many theoretical and experimental studies have been conducted to describe the various aggregation phases of amphiphilic molecules in aqueous solutions @xcite .
however , no comprehensive investigations have yet been performed concerning the influence of the distribution of polar groups in amphiphiles on the aggregation phase diagram , or concerning the mechanism underlying the process of self - aggregation .
the aim of this study is to substantiate experimental results indicating a decrease in lcst as the degree of hydrophobicity increases , and to analyze the dependence on density and hydrophobicity of the aggregation phase diagram .
we will conclude that the principal properties of amphiphiles in aqueous solutions are solvent - induced , in that they are explained by alterations in the structure of liquid water in the vicinity of the hydrophobic regions of solute particles .
we begin by introducing a simple hydrophobic - polar ( hp ) description ( sec .
[ sechpmodel ] ) of amphiphilic solute particles ( sec .
[ sechpmodelmic ] ) on a cubic lattice , and then extend the model to describe lipid particles of varying tail length ( sec .
[ seclipid ] ) . in sec .
[ secresultsmic ] we investigate the changes in the phase diagram associated with an increasing proportion of polar groups in amphiphilic molecules and with changes in their distribution .
[ secresultslipid ] presents a similar analysis for the formation of lipid micelles in aqueous solutions . in sec .
[ secdiscussion ] we discuss the implications of our results and provide a brief conclusion .
the solvation of amphiphiles in aqueous solutions and their self - association into micellar aggregates are genreally considered as a consequence of the effective hydrophobic interaction between polar water and the non - polar regions of the solute molecules @xcite .
the unique properties of the aqueous medium which generate this interaction arise from the ability of water molecules to form strong hydrogen bonds both among themselves and with the polar groups of solute molecules .
the formation and disruption of extended hydrogen - bonded networks leads directly to the delicate balance of enthalpic and entropic contributions to the solvent free energy which is responsible for the existence of a closed - loop aggregation regime in many solutions of polar molecules .
this behavior is encapsulated in an adapted version of the model of muller , lee and graziano ( mlg ) @xcite , whose key features are as follows : consideration of a coarse - grained system whose sites contain clusters of water molecules of a size which matches that of the solute particles ; a bimodal distribution of water clusters reflecting `` ordered '' sites with mostly intact hydrogen bonds , and `` disordered '' sites with relatively fewer intact hydrogen bonds ; a further subdivision into `` shell '' sites neighboring the solute particles and `` bulk '' sites which are not disrupted by proximity to a polar surface ; a set of microscopic energy and degeneracy parameters for these sites whose sequences are determined by the fact that breaking of hydrogen bonds increases site enthalpy but simultaneously raises the site degeneracy ( number of orientational degrees of freedom of the water molecules ) , as represented in fig . [ figmlg ] .
full details of the foundations and qualitative properties of the model can be found in refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
= ordered shell ( cage conformation ) , @xmath1 = disordered shell , @xmath2 = ordered bulk , and @xmath3 = disordered bulk.,width=245 ] the microscopic origin of the energy and degeneracy parameters for the four different types of water site ( ordered / disordered and shell / bulk ) in the adapted mlg model , based on both experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite analysis , is discussed in detail in refs .
@xcite . here
we highlight the competition of enthalpy and entropy terms using only the example of the ordered states .
although the insertion of a hydrophobic molecule leads to a destruction of local hydrogen - bonding , at low temperatures the water molecules are found to rearrange in a cage - like structure around the solute molecule , which because of the orientational effect of the polar surface is formed by stronger hydrogen bonds .
the consequent net energy reduction results in dissolution of the solute particle @xcite . at higher temperatures , however , the additional entropic contributions available from the bulk solvent favor a minimization of local water restructuring , which drives the aggregation of hydrophobic solute particles to minimize their total surface exposed to water . while it is possible to find perfect cages of hydrogen bonds for small hydrophobic particles , the formation of complete cages around large solute particles is prevented sterically .
however , such large solute particles , and also their aggregates , may instead be surrounded by a number of partial cages , depending on their shape and surface roughness @xcite .
atomic groups exposed at the surfaces of large molecules and aggregates present locally curved surface structures @xcite which allow for a confined formation of partial cages .
the lipid molecules we analyze ( see fig . 1 ) have a characteristic lengthscale of order 0.3 nm for the diameter of the chain and any side groups , 0.5 nm for the polar head , and a maximum length of 2 - 3 nm for the longer chains .
the chain and head diameters are the lengthscales which determine the curvature of the molecule , and thus the possibility for cage formation .
the considerations of the previous paragraph , specifically low - temperature solution , are then expected to remain valid for amphiphilic and lipid molecules , and this is confirmed by the success of models based on these concepts in describing large molecular species @xcite . that the analysis is applicable for solute particles with a certain degree of curvature and surface roughness does not appear to be a significant restriction for molecules in the size range of most interest for amphiphilic and lipid characteristics . returning to the parameters of fig .
[ figmlg ] , we stress that the properties of the sysytem are critically dependent on the sequences @xmath4 of energy levels and @xmath5 of the corresponding degeneracies , which describe the entropy .
these sequences are confirmed by a range of experimental measurements , and indeed if they are not maintained the solution does not exhibit a closed - loop aggregation regime .
however , the results of the calculations to follow are not particularly sensitive to the exact values of the differences between these parameters , and are of course independent of their absolute values . we have used the energy values @xmath6 , and @xmath7 , which are thought to be qualitatively representative for aqueous solutions , and which have been successful in describing different types of solution @xcite .
the respective degeneracies , normalized to a non - degenerate ordered shell conformation , are taken to be @xmath8 and @xmath9 @xcite .
these relative values have been found to be appropriate for reproducing the phenomenology of hydrophobic interactions @xcite , protein denaturation @xcite , swelling of biopolymers @xcite , and cosolvent effects on solubility of hydrophobic particles @xcite .
precise values of the microscopic parameters may in fact be refined by comparison with experimental measurements to yield semi - quantitative agreement for different solutions @xcite .
the energy scale is correlated directly with a relative temperature scale , which we define as @xmath10 . to include not only purely hydrophobic solute particles but also amphiphilic molecules with varying conformations of polar and non - polar regions , as in the experiments of ref .
@xcite , we represent the particles as cubes on which each face may be either polar or hydrophobic . a neighboring water site , which is homogeneously polar , interacts only with the side of the particle which is oriented in its direction .
if this side represents a polar group , the neighboring water site is in a bulk state , whereas if the side is hydrophobic the water site is considered a shell state .
thus polar sides and water are considered as having the same effect on neighboring water molecules . however , polar faces do not contribute to the free energy . in this coarse - grained model ,
one side of a site may represent more than one chemical group , and thus corresponds to a net characterization of the surface area of the solute molecule under consideration .
+ hydrophobic solute particles are generally larger than water , and thus a water site in the model consists of a group of molecules . on a lattice where
each site has @xmath11 nearest neighbors , the energy of a system of @xmath12 sites , occupied either by amphiphiles ( @xmath13 ) or by water ( @xmath14 ) , is given by the potts - like hamiltonian @xmath15=\\ \nonumber & & \sum_{i=1}^{n } \frac{n_i}{z } \!\left[\ !
( e_{os } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{os}}\!+\!e_{ds}\tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{ds}})\!\sum_{\langle ji \rangle } ( 1\!-\!\lambda_{i , j(k ) } ) \right.\\ & & + \left.(e_{ob } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{ob}}\!+ e_{db } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{db } } ) \sum_{\langle ji \rangle } \lambda_{i , j(k ) } \right ] , \label{ham}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath16 is a side variable depending on each of the nearest neighbors @xmath17 of site @xmath18 , and takes the value @xmath19 if the neighboring side of site @xmath17 is a polar side of a solute particle or water , and @xmath20 otherwise .
the variable @xmath21 takes values from @xmath19 to @xmath22 , where @xmath22 enumerates all equivalent orientations of site @xmath17 . on a cubic lattice ,
the total number of sides of a solute particle is @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the number of hydrophobic cube faces .
thus for the cubic lattice @xmath25 for water and for solute particles with @xmath26 , @xmath27 for @xmath28 , @xmath29 for @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) if the two polar ( hydrophobic ) sides are opposite to each other , @xmath32 for @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) if they are adjacent , @xmath33 for @xmath34 if the three polar sides are are all adjacent to each other , and @xmath32 for @xmath34 if two of them are opposite to each other . because a water side may be in one of @xmath35 different states , @xmath36 is @xmath19 if it is in one of the @xmath37 ordered shell states and @xmath20 otherwise , and @xmath38 is @xmath19 if it is in one of the @xmath39 disordered shell states and @xmath20 otherwise .
analogous considerations apply for the bulk states .
we note that for completely hydrophobic solute particles ( @xmath40 ) eq .
( [ ham ] ) is not equivalent to the hamiltonian in ref .
@xcite , because the sites are treated differently . in eq .
( [ ham ] ) each face of a water site @xmath18 contributes to the free energy , and a sum is performed over all pairs of faces in contact with each other , as opposed to over individual sites . the representation in terms of cube sides
is adopted here for consistent description of lipid molecules in sec .
[ seclipid ] .
however , we will find in sec .
[ secresultsmic ] that the qualitative differences between the two hamiltonians for fully hydrophobic solute particles are small . to determine the canonical partition function ,
a sum is performed over the state configurations @xmath41 . by taking into account the possible orientations of the amphiphilic particles through the variable @xmath21
, the canonical partition function of the system of @xmath12 sites may be expressed as @xmath42 where @xmath43 for the shell ( @xmath44 ) and bulk ( @xmath45 ) states of pure water sides .
the grand canonical partition function of the system for variable solute particle number is then @xmath46 } , \label{eq : gczmic}\ ] ] where @xmath47 represents the chemical potential associated with the insertion of water and @xmath48 denotes the number of water sites .
although the explicit terms of the model describe solely the states of water molecules in solution , it contains implicitly all multi - particle interactions between hydrophobic solute molecules @xcite .
the coexistence regions are characterized by measuring the ucst and the lcst for various numbers @xmath49 of polar sides per particle . to investigate variations in the effective hydrophobic interactions due to changes in polarity of the solute particles , we increase systematically the number of polar sides per particle and determine the coexistence region in each case .
the extent of aggregate formation in the system is determined from the number density of contacts between two hydrophobic cube sides , @xmath50 , between two polar sides , @xmath51 , and between a polar and a hydrophobic side , @xmath52 . the number of contacts in a randomly distributed system with the same particle density @xmath53 is also calculated for comparison . in a random solution of solute particles with @xmath49 polar faces ,
whose positions and orientations are completely independent , these probabilities are given in the thermodynamic limit by @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the probability that a cube face is hydrophobic , @xmath56 is the probability that it is polar , and by symmetry @xmath57 . in a random system ,
the probabilities of occurrence of the different faces are independent of the neighboring sites , and are simply @xmath58 if the contact densities @xmath50 and @xmath51 , are larger than their probabilities of random occurrence , and @xmath52 , is correspondingly smaller , the system has formed aggregates which reduce the number of hydrophobic sides exposed to water .
micelles are generally formed by amphiphilic molecules , referred to here as lipids , which are composed of two distinct regions , the polar head and the hydrophobic tail .
the length of the tail , which is typically composed of one or more hydrocarbon chains , is normally rather greater than the size of the polar head ( fig . [ figglycolipid ] ) .
experimental observations @xcite suggest that lipids with tails shorter than @xmath59 carbon atoms are highly soluble in aqueous solutions , while those whose tails exceed approximately @xmath60 carbon atoms are almost completely insoluble . for those molecules with tail lengths in the intermediate range , which show the widest variety of surface - active properties , the tails are on average some three to five times longer than the dimensions of the polar head .
( in lipids composed of two or more tails , this ratio is generally smaller . ) as an example , the head size of the glycolipid in fig .
[ figglycolipid ] is close to one third of the length of the 14-atom tail .
we define an effective tail length @xmath61 as the ratio between the tail length and the head size of the lipid , so that a typical lipid is represented by @xmath61 values between two and five , which may also be fractional . for simple geometrical reasons ,
the total repulsion between such a tail and the water molecules surrounding its sides is significantly stronger than that for the small tail tip of the chain .
we adapt the model described in sec .
[ sechpmodelmic ] to include this aspect by assigning different energy levels to shell water clusters in contact with the sides of a solute particle compared to those in contact with the tip . because the number of shell water molecules interacting with one side of a hydrophobic tail is approximately @xmath61 times that of those interacting with the tip , the energy associated with a site representing all of these water molecules is taken to be @xmath61 times that for a tip site . a cubic solute particle in the lipid model [ represented in fig .
[ figmicpart3d](a ) ] consists of a polar head ( p ) and a hydrophobic tail , which in turn is divided into the moderately hydrophobic tip ( h ) , situated opposite the polar head , and the long , strongly hydrophobic sides of the tail ( s ) . in the coarse - grained model , both the tip and each long side of the tail
are represented by a face of the cubic particle , but the sides interact more strongly with a neighboring water site than does the tip .
the hamiltonian of a system of @xmath12 sites on a cubic lattice , which are occupied either by water ( @xmath14 ) or by a lipid molecule ( @xmath13 ) , is then @xmath62=\\ \nonumber & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\sum_{i=1}^{n } n_i[(e_{os , h } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{os , h}}\ ! + \ !
e_{ds , h } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{ds , h}})\frac{1}{z}\sum_{\langle ji \rangle } ( 1\!-\!\lambda_{i , j(k)}^2 ) \\ \nonumber & & \!\!\!\!\!\!+(e_{os , s } \tilde\delta_{i,\sigma_{os , s}}\!+\!e_{ds , s } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{ds , s}})\sum_{\langle ji \rangle}\!\frac{1}{2z } \lambda_{i , j(k ) } ( 1-\lambda_{i , j(k)})\\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!+ ( e_{ob } \tilde\delta_{i , \sigma_{ob}}\!+\!e_{db } \tilde\delta_{i,\sigma_{db}})\sum_{\langle ji \rangle}\frac{1}{2z } \lambda_{i , j(k)}(1\!+\!\lambda_{i , j(k ) } ) ] , \label{hamilt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where again @xmath16 depends on the orientation state @xmath21 of the particle at each nearest - neighbor site @xmath17 of @xmath18 .
however , for the lipid model @xmath16 takes the value @xmath19 if the neighboring face is polar ( _ i.e. _ water or the relevant side of a solute particle ) , @xmath20 if it represents a slightly hydrophobic tail tip h , and @xmath63 if it represents a strongly hydrophobic tail side s. @xmath21 varies again from @xmath19 to @xmath22 , where @xmath25 for water and @xmath27 for lipid particles . because a polar side @xmath18 may be in one of @xmath35 different states , @xmath64 is @xmath19 if site @xmath18 is occupied by a polar face in one of the @xmath37 ordered shell states of a h face and @xmath20 otherwise , and @xmath65 is @xmath19 if it is occupied by pure water in one of the @xmath39 disordered shell states of a h face and @xmath20 otherwise .
analogous considerations apply for s faces and for the bulk states .
we stress here that the hamiltonians in eqs .
( [ ham ] ) and ( [ hamilt ] ) provide a full description of the microscopic states of the amphiphilic and lipid systems .
the macroscopic , thermodynamic behavior is contained implicitly in these microscopic states @xcite , and the differences for such properties as the phase boundaries for varying chain length enter through the microscopic energy and degeneracy parameters . + as in sec .
[ sechpmodelmic ] only water sites contribute to the free energy , and a polar face is considered having the same effect on a neighboring water site as water .
we define @xmath66 , \\
\nonumber { \cal s}_s & = & -\frac{1}{\beta } \ln \left [ q_{os , s } e^{-\beta e_{os , s } } + q_{ds , s } e^{-\beta e_{ds , s } } \right ] , \\ { \cal b } & = & -\frac{1}{\beta } \ln \left [ q_{ob } e^{-\beta e_{ob } } + q_{db } e^{-\beta e_{db } } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] for a system of @xmath12 sites ,
the canonical partition function may be expressed as @xmath67}\!\ ! , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] whence the grand canonical partition function for a system where the lipid density is not fixed is @xmath68},\ ] ] with the effective , grand canonical hamiltonian @xmath69 & = & \sum_{i=1}^{n } \sum_{k=1}^{n_{c , j}}[n_i ( { \cal s}_h \frac{1}{z}\sum_{\langle
ji \rangle } ( 1-\lambda_{i , j(k)}^2 ) -\mu)\\ \nonumber & & + { \cal b } n_i\sum_{\langle ji \rangle}\frac{1}{2z}\lambda_{i , j(k ) } ( 1\!+\!\lambda_{i , j(k ) } ) \\ & & + { \cal s}_s n_i\sum_{\langle ji \rangle}\frac{1}{2z}\lambda_{i , j(k ) } ( 1-\lambda_{i , j(k ) } ) ] .
\label{eq : heffmic}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to measure the formation of aggregates in the lipid system , the number of contacts between different faces is again determined and compared with the number of contacts in a randomly distributed system of the same particle density @xmath53 . in a random solution of solute particles , whose positions and orientations are completely independent , these probabilities are given in the thermodynamic limit by @xmath70 where @xmath71 . here
@xmath55 is the probability that the adjacent side of the nearest neighbor is slightly hydrophobic , @xmath56 the probability that it is polar , and @xmath72 the probability that it is strongly hydrophobic .
the probabilities are given in general by @xmath73 although henceforth we will consider only the values @xmath74 , @xmath75 .
aggregate formation has occurred in this system if @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath76 are larger than their random expectation values , and @xmath52 and @xmath77 are correspondingly smaller .
the absolute energy levels and the degeneracies of water sites facing s sides are higher because this site represents the number of water molecules contained in a shell site of h multiplied by the factor @xmath61 . the effective energy of a s shell site is thus obtained from that for a h shell site , for both ordered and disordered states , using @xmath78 where @xmath79 ( @xmath80 ) is the energy of an ordered ( disordered ) water site in the shell of the tip ( h ) and @xmath81 ( @xmath82 ) that of an ordered ( disordered ) shell water site of the tail side ( s ) . under the assumption that neighboring water sites are rather independent , the total number of configurations for two sites may be approximated by the product of their numbers of configurations .
thus , the number of configurations of a s shell site is related to that of a corresponding h shell site by @xmath83 the parameter values of the energy levels , and the degeneracies of bulk water and h shell sites , are chosen as described in sec . [ sechpmodel ] .
our interest is focused on the orientation and location of amphiphilic molecules in solution , which may be captured by molecular - level simulations .
we thus restrict our considerations to monte carlo studies , because the processes involved depend strongly on local , spatial effects which are neglected in mean - field calculations . as in ref .
@xcite , we use monte carlo simulations to detect the aggregation of amphiphilic solute particles as a function of temperature and solute concentration .
we work with a system of @xmath84 sites on a cubic lattice with random initial particle distributions and periodic boundary conditions , using a metropolis algorithm for sampling of the configuration space .
the numbers of relaxation ( @xmath85 ) and measurement ( @xmath86 ) steps are similar to those in our previous studies @xcite .
the closed - loop coexistence curves in the @xmath53-@xmath87 phase diagram are obtained from the transitions determined by increasing the temperature at fixed chemical potential ( grand canonical sampling ) , which results in a sudden density jump at the transition temperature , and from the corresponding solute particle densities .
analysis of the properties of a lipid - water system at the molecular level is possible by similar monte carlo simulations using the model of sec .
[ seclipid ] .
however , the procedure described above must be redefined in one respect . in the metropolis algorithm , the relative transition probability to a configuration @xmath88 from a previous one @xmath89 depends on the difference in free energy of the two configurations according to @xmath90 - h_{\rm eff}^{\rm gc}[\{n_i\}])}.\ ] ] the free - energy difference must be calculated for two states with the same number of molecules .
one step of the simulation procedure consists either in rotation of a solute particle or in a site exchange between two randomly chosen sites .
the only contributions to the difference in free energy are then the energy change of the sites concerned , and of their nearest - neighbor sides .
if a side changes from p to s or vice versa , the bulk and shell states of neighboring water sites must contain the same number of water molecules to be comparable . in this case
, we attribute the bulk energies @xmath91 , @xmath92 , and the respective degeneracies @xmath93 , @xmath94 , to the relevant water sites when calculating the probability @xmath95 . the index s refers to the comparison of this bulk site with a s shell site .
-@xmath87 phase diagram for micelle formation in the 3d , hp model for different numbers of polar sides per solute particle .
the coexistence region is reduced , and aggregation suppressed , as the number of hydrophobic sides substituted by polar sides increases . at a given dimensionless temperature @xmath96 the system is homogeneous for solute particle concentrations below the cmc ( @xmath97 ) , while above this value it separates into two phases of densities @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
, width=321 ] we begin by attempting to capture the qualitative behavior of amphiphilic molecules with varying conformations of polar and non - polar regions .
[ figboulemichp ] shows the @xmath53-@xmath87 phase diagram obtained from the simple model of sec .
[ sechpmodelmic ] for different numbers of polar sides per particle .
the densities represent volume fractions , and are therefore dimensionless . in the coexistence regime the amphiphilic particles aggregate , minimizing the contact of their hydrophobic regions with water and with polar solute segments . outside this region
the amphiphiles are soluble at all densities below the lcst and above the ucst . for temperatures between these values ,
the amphiphiles are soluble only at very low densities , while at the cmc , @xmath97 , the particles aggregate and the system separates into two phases : nearly pure water ( of particle density @xmath97 ) and an amphiphilic phase of density @xmath98 . with increasing polarity , the solubility of the solute particles is enhanced and the cmc increases .
as expected , the coexistence region is reduced as the number of polar sides increases @xcite .
if the system represents a solution of purely hydrophobic particles ( @xmath40 and @xmath26 ) , the coexistence curve is almost identical to that found in the hp model in ref .
@xcite ( see sec .
[ sechpmodelmic ] ) .
substitution of one hydrophobic side per particle by a polar side ( @xmath99 and @xmath28 ) leads to a decrease of the ucst and a slight increase of the lcst , and to a small overall suppression of the temperature and density range of the coexistence region . in this case , which may be taken to represent simplified lipid molecules ( discussed in sec .
[ secdiscussion ] ) , the effect is rather moderate .
however , substitution of a second hydrophobic side per particle ( @xmath100 and @xmath30 ) reduces the coexistence region dramatically ( fig . [ figboulemichp ] ) . when substituting three or more hydrophobic sides by polar ones , the solute particles become soluble at all temperatures and no aggregation phase transition
is observed .
= 5.5 cm = 5.5 cm = 5.5 cm = 5.5 cm figures [ figsnapshotmichp0p1p ] and [ figsnapshotmichp2p ] illustrate the nature of the aggregated phase using `` snapshots '' of two - dimensional ( 2d ) systems at @xmath101 , obtained in the coexistence region for solute particles with different numbers of polar sides .
the snapshots are taken after allowing the system to relax for @xmath86 steps , where every @xmath102 step is an attempt to exchange two sites and the others are attempts to rotate a particle .
systems containing primarily hydrophobic particles ( @xmath40 and @xmath99 ) form mostly compact clusters , which minimize the number of hydrophobic surfaces exposed to the solvent . for lipid - like solute particles with @xmath99 [ fig .
[ figmicpart2d](a ) ] , the formation of perfect micelles with a hydrophobic core and a polar surface is prevented by the nature of the square lattice , which causes frustration on the edges of the micelles : an edge particle is forced to expose one of its hydrophobic sides to water .
the model allows a lipid particle to occur in the core of micelles , where its polar side is in direct contact with the polar side of another lipid particle , because no distinction is made between a group of water molecules and the polar face of a particle .
incorporating this distinction into the description could be expected to generate more realistic micellar structures , albeit within the confines of the cubic geometry .
amphiphilic solute particles whose surface is half polar ( @xmath103 in 2d ) show differing behavior depending on the polarity pattern of the sides . if the polar sides are adjacent on the square , small micelles consisting of four solute particles can be formed , which is energetically the most favorable configuration because no hydrophobic sides are exposed to water ( fig . [ figsnapshotmichp2p ] ) .
short , diagonal lines of molecules , which may be considered to represent condensed bilayers , can also be formed , although their ends are hydrophobic , and this configuration is therefore less favorable than are `` circular '' micelles of four solute particles .
these configurations are expected from the construction of the sites , which is shown in fig .
[ figmicpart2d ] , to appear as the ground states .
solute sites with two adjacent polar sides may be considered to represent sections of circular micelles [ fig .
[ figmicpart2d](b ) ] , with the formation of small micelles as a consequence . in contrast , if the polar sides are opposite each other , the only possibility to avoid hydrophobic sides being in contact with water is to form lines of particles , although again the hydrophobic ends remain exposed to water .
these squares may be taken as schematic representations of cross - sections of a bilayer [ fig .
[ figmicpart2d](c ) ] . .
the contact densities between sides are normalized to the values expected in a random system for @xmath104.,width=321 ] the contact densities @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 , are shown in fig .
[ figmicrho024 ] for a system of solute particles with one polar side ( @xmath105 ) as a function of relative temperature .
the results are normalized to the probability of these contacts in a randomly distributed system with the same particle density , @xmath106 . at low temperatures ,
the solute particles are clearly soluble , because @xmath107 , @xmath108 , and @xmath109 .
this reflects the formation of strongly hydrogen - bonded , partial cage - like structures of water molecules around the hydrophobic parts of the amphiphilic particles when entropy effects are minor . at temperatures higher than the lower critical temperature for density @xmath53 ,
increasing entropy effects favor a screening of hydrophobic faces from polar ones , and the solute particles aggregate to form micelles . in this regime @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and the density of polar - hydrophobic contacts
is suppressed , @xmath112 .
the effect on @xmath113 is more pronounced than @xmath114 because the number of polar sides in the system is higher than the number of hydrophobic ones .
changes in @xmath50 then lead to a larger relative effect , and in fact the majority of @xmath115-@xmath115 contacts are intact even in the dissolved phase due to the high number of water molecules . for low particle densities ,
the relative effect is larger still because fewer @xmath116-@xmath116 contacts are possible .
finally , at high temperatures , the entropy becomes dominant and the contact densities approach their respective random values as complete mixing is obtained .
we note that at high temperatures the contact densities do not recross the value @xmath19 to recover the low - temperature phase of single - particle dissolution ( fig .
[ figmicrho024 ] ) .
instead their values simply converge to unity , implying that the complete miscibility takes the form of a truly random particle / water distribution .
-@xmath87 phase diagram illustrating micelle formation in the extended 3d , hp model for lipid molecules of varying tail length .
@xmath61 represents the relative length of the hydrophobic tail compared to the size of the head ( fig .
[ figglycolipid ] ) .
the coexistence region is enhanced as the length of the hydrophobic tails increases , and aggregation is promoted .
, width=321 ] we have performed monte carlo simulations for lipid molecules in water on a cubic lattice for varying lengths @xmath61 of the hydrophobic tail , as described in secs . [ seclipid ] and [ secmethods ] , to investigate the stability of their aggregation as a function of hydrophobicity ( @xmath61 ) and density . the @xmath53-@xmath87 phase diagram ( fig
[ figboulehpx ] ) shows clearly that the coexistence regime is enhanced significantly with increasing tail length @xmath61 , which can be attributed to the stronger effective repulsive interaction between the longer hydrophobic tail of the lipid molecule and the surrounding water .
the ratio @xmath61 can be taken as the important quantity to characterize the degree of hydrophobicity of a lipid molecule .
comparison with fig .
[ figglycolipid ] indicates that for a typical polar head , @xmath117 corresponds to a tail containing approximately four carbon atoms .
[ figboulehpx ] shows that for lipid molecules with a tail containing approximately @xmath118 carbon atoms ( @xmath119 ) there is already an enhancement of the coexistence region .
the aggregation of solute particles with a tail composed of approximately @xmath120 carbon atoms ( @xmath121 ) is reinforced very significantly . within our simplified model , at relative temperature @xmath122 lipids with @xmath123
are basically insoluble , forming a completely separated phase , and thus perfect micelles , for all densities , in rather good qualitative agreement with expectations based on experiments @xcite .
the aggregation may be analyzed in more detail by studying the density of side contacts as a function of temperature .
the thermal evolution of the density of contacts between the different sides in a system of lipid particles of tail length @xmath124 in water is shown in fig .
[ fighpxproba ] .
the results are normalized to the corresponding probability of these contacts in a randomly distributed system with the same particle density , @xmath125 . at low temperatures @xmath126 , @xmath108 , and @xmath127 , while @xmath128 , @xmath129 , and @xmath130 , meaning that the solute particles are clearly dissolved as a consequence of partial cage formation around the hydrophobic tails . at temperatures higher than the lower critical temperature for density @xmath53 ( fig .
[ figboulehpx ] ) , the lipid particles aggregate to minimize their total exposed surface , whence @xmath110 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 , while @xmath112 and @xmath133 . because of the much stronger effect of an s face than of an h face on its neighboring water site , the normalized contact density of two s faces is highest in the aggregation phase and lowest below the lcst .
a higher relative contact density is observed between s and h faces than between two h faces for the same reason , while below the lcst water sites prefer to form the solvation shell of s faces rather than of h faces . at high temperatures
the contact densities converge , in fact rather abruptly ( fig .
[ fighpxproba ] ) to their random values , indicating complete mixing . .
the contact densities between sides are normalized to the values expected in a random system for @xmath125 .
, width=321 ]
amphiphilic molecules in aqueous solutions can form different types of micelles depending on their concentration and on the distribution of polar regions at their surfaces .
our initial investigation of the qualitative properties of micelle formation in a hydrophobic - polar model involved systematic substitution of the hydrophobic sides of cubic solute particles by polar ones .
we determined the @xmath53-@xmath87 phase diagram for different surface patterns and found closed - loop coexistence curves ( fig .
[ figboulemichp ] ) , in accord with experiments using hydrophilically modified copolymers of poly(n - isopropylacrylamide ) @xcite . with increasing polarity , the coexistence region
is reduced as the solubility of the model amphiphiles increases .
this tendency was confirmed by the same experiment , where the lcst of purely hydrophobic poly(n - isopropylacrylamide ) p3 was observed to increase from @xmath134c at atmospheric pressure to @xmath135-@xmath136c when approximately @xmath137 of the monomers were substituted by polar species ( cp2 and cp3 ) . in our model
we observe the same quantitative increase of @xmath138-@xmath139 in absolute temperature from @xmath140 for purely hydrophobic solute particles to @xmath141 for amphiphiles with one polar side , which represents @xmath142 of the particle surface .
thus the crude cubic model appears to yield good agreement with available data at this level of comparison . for particles with two polar sides the coexistence region
is reduced dramatically .
this is not surprising , considering the fact that two polar sides represent one third of the total particle surface , and the attractive interactions with water are rather strong . in amphiphilic molecules
the polar region is usually rather small compared with the hydrophobic surface area .
the solubility of the molecules thus increases considerably on substitution with polar monomers , leading to a decrease in ucst and an increase in lcst and cmc . in the cubic model
no significant difference in the size of the coexistence region is observed for different distributions of the two sides on the solute cubes .
any further substitution of hydrophobic faces by polar ones results in molecules which are at least half polar : the solubility of such particles is always high , and thus no aggregation is found .
possible schematic interpretations of the various surface patterns of cubes representing solute particles in the hp model are shown in fig .
[ figmicpart3d ] .
the model is applicable for any surface pattern and density of solute , with the premise that one site may contain one amphiphilic molecule or a group of solute molecules .
a given surface distribution of polar groups on a polymer may be characterized by a corresponding arrangement of polar sides on the surface of a cubic solute molecule .
a single lipid molecule with a clear distinction between a polar head and a hydrophobic tail may be represented by a cube with one polar face [ @xmath99 , fig .
[ figmicpart3d](a ) ] .
a small section of a cylindrical micelle would be represented by a cube with two adjacent polar sides [ @xmath100 , fig .
[ figmicpart3d](c ) ] , while a particle with two opposite polar sides corresponds at the same level of approximation to a cross - section of a bilayer [ fig .
[ figmicpart3d](b ) ] . for
the formation of `` spherical '' micelles , each site must have three adjacent polar sides [ @xmath143 , fig .
[ figmicpart3d](d ) ] ; if two of the three sides are situated opposite each other [ fig .
[ figmicpart3d](e ) ] , the site may again be considered as a section of a cylindrical micelle .
although by construction @xmath144 should give small spherical or cylindrical micelles , depending on the distribution pattern at the surface of each site , in fact the solubility is too high to find aggregates .
micellar structures occurring in 3d simulations are difficult to display . to confirm the formation of different micelle types depending on the surface pattern of the solute particles , we have considered snapshots of an analogous 2d system ( figs .
[ figsnapshotmichp0p1p ] and [ figsnapshotmichp2p ] ) . here
the square solute particles may be interpreted in a manner similar to the 3d case ( fig .
[ figmicpart2d ] ) , and the formation of small micelles and layers is found in the coexistence region . during the relaxation process , micelles grow from initial dimers to larger entities .
although the solute particles may rotate at a given position , they can be trapped in a configuration which disables the construction of perfect micelles or extended layers . because there is no preference for growing a layer in one direction rather than in the other ,
short line segments are formed which are incompatible with others , resulting in a network of short layers . in the model
, no distinction is made between the polar side of a water molecule and that of a solute particle , and a @xmath115-@xmath115 contact contributes the same energy independent of the molecules to which the sides under consideration belong .
such contacts between the polar sides of solute molecules are found in the interior of a micelle , which also influences the formation of perfect micelles .
the non - zero temperature in the coexistence region , and the observation that the upper critical density is much smaller than unity , might further imply the formation of imperfect micelles .
in fact the extent to which the upper critical density is significant remains unclear , because shell water sites in the model may be considered as belonging to the micelle phase rather than to the pure water phase , which would explain the low density of the organic phase even for perfect micelles containing no water molecules .
we have extended our analysis to describe lipids , which represent a particular type of amphiphilic molecule .
lipids are distinguished by a special partition of the polar and hydrophobic segments along the molecule : a typical lipid molecule consists of a polar head and one or two hydrophobic tails . to incorporate these geometrical features in the model
we have adapted the energy levels and their degeneracies according to the tail length @xmath61 , where a typical lipid molecules exhibiting surface - active properties would be represented by values @xmath145 @xcite . as expected from experiments @xcite ,
monte carlo simulations of lipids of increasing length illustrate a significant enhancement of the coexistence region ( fig .
[ figboulehpx ] ) .
lipids with a longer tail have more pronounced characteristics of hydrophobic solute particles than do lipids where the polar head represents a considerable fraction of the molecule .
the solubility of long - tailed lipids is therefore lower than that of short - tailed ones , causing a decrease in lcst , an increase in ucst , and a decreased cmc at any given temperature as the tail becomes longer . for the parameters used in the model
we find that an increase from @xmath117 to @xmath119 already enhances the coexistence region substantially , and for that @xmath123 the system is completely separated into pure water and essentially perfect micelles of density @xmath146 over a wide temperature range , which is fully consistent with experiment @xcite . a quantitative measure of micelle formation in amphiphilic and lipid systems is provided by the contact densities @xmath147 and @xmath148 , normalized by the corresponding probabilities of the contacts in a random system ( figs . [ figmicrho024 ] , [ fighpxproba ] ) .
we have found fewer contacts between hydrophobic faces and more hydrophobic - polar contacts than would be expected for a random distribution below the lcst , indicating highly dissolved solute molecules . above the lcst
this picture is inverted , thus confirming the aggregation of amphiphiles and lipids , and the separation of the solution into two phases . from a knowledge of the system geometry and densities , the values of the contact ratios may also be used to confirm the extent of solution or aggregation , and also the effective `` purity '' of the micelles which form for different polar distributions on the solute molecules . at temperatures in excess of the ucst , the solution approaches a random mixture due to dominant entropy effects ; in monte carlo studies the relative contact densities approach unity continuously , rather than undergoing a sharp transition .
we close by emphasizing again the limits of our analysis .
we have formulated a model for an aqueous solution using a minimal set of assumptions ; we have used an extremely crude representation of amphiphilic molecules , and have considered only a cubic system as the foundation on which our `` micelles '' are constrained to form .
nevertheless , we have obtained a realistic set of aggregation phenomena and a surprising degree of agreement with the available experimental results .
there are , however , several examples of phenomena which are beyond the reach of the model at its current level of refinement .
a solution of lipids in water may produce a lamellar phase of bilayers at low temperature and rather high densities @xcite .
bilayer formation requires the possibility of smooth curvature and high flexibility @xcite , and is precluded in the monte carlo simulations by geometrical constraints presented by the lattice .
for the same geometrical reasons it is also difficult to find well - formed micelles in the more general case of amphiphiles in water .
a further limitation is that the model considers explicitly the energy states of water sites , and therefore no distinction is made among p - p , h - h , s - h , and s - s contacts . because there is also no difference between a group of water molecules and the polar face of a solute particle , the model a llows amphiphiles to occur in the core of micelles , where their polar sides are in direct contact with those of other amphiphiles . for lipids , an s - h contact which is formed during the monte carlo simulation is as favorable as an s - s contact , although it is more likely to be broken in a later step .
in addition , the orientation of a lipid molecule is irrelevant for the formation of an s - s contact , which prevents efficient alignment of the heads and may further hinder the formation of extended bilayers .
the incorporation of these distinctions in a more sophisticated description of the lipid solution may be expected to reproduce further detailed properties of real systems . in summary , we have extended the mlg framework to include the solvation of amphiphilic solutes in water . within a cubic hp model
we have found the aggregation of solute particles , and the formation of various types of micelle as a function of the distribution of hydrophobic regions . by successive substitution of hydrophobic sides by polar ones
, we have studied the aggregation behavior and the influence of the degree of hydrophobicity on the upper and lower critical solution temperatures .
we have refined this model to describe lipid molecules of varying length , by adapting the interaction of the hydrophobic tail to include a corresponding number of neighboring water molecules , and have demonstrated the enhanced stability of aggregates with increasing tail length ( increasing hydrophobicity ) .
we have shown that primary features of micelle formation , which are often attributed solely to the amphiphilic nature of the solute particles under consideration , are reproduced by our extension of the solvent - based mlg model to describe alterations of water structure in the vicinity of the different surface regions of dissolved amphiphiles . | we investigate the aggregation of amphiphilic molecules by adapting the two - state muller - lee - graziano model for water , in which a solvent - induced hydrophobic interaction is included implicitly .
we study the formation of various types of micelle as a function of the distribution of hydrophobic regions at the molecular surface .
successive substitution of non - polar surfaces by polar ones demonstrates the influence of hydrophobicity on the upper and lower critical solution temperatures .
aggregates of lipid molecules , described by a refinement of the model in which a hydrophobic tail of variable length interacts with different numbers of water molecules , are stabilized as the length of the tail increases .
we demonstrate that the essential features of micelle formation are primarily solvent - induced , and are explained within a model which focuses only on the alteration of water structure in the vicinity of the hydrophobic surface regions of amphiphiles in solution . |
the quantum algorithms work much more efficiently than their classicalcounter parts due to quantum superposition and quantum interference .
for example , consider the search of an item in an unsorted database containing @xmath0 elements .
classical computation requires @xmath1 steps to carry out the search .
however , grover showed that search can be carried out with only @xmath2 steps @xcite .
thus , grover s algorithm represents a quadratic advantage over its classical counterpart .
grover s algorithm has been realized using many physical systems like nmr @xcite , superconducting qubits @xcite and atom cavity qed systems @xcite .
superconducting qubit cavity qed is an attractive approach for quantum information processing due to their strong coupling limit in microwave cavity as compared to atoms in cavity qed @xcite .
squids have attracted much attention among the superconducting qubits , due to their design flexibility , large - scale integration , and compatibility to conventional electronics * hanx , ich , mooj*. recently , dicarlo et al . demonstrated the implementation of two - qubit grover and deutsch - jozsa algorithms @xcite and preparation and measurement of three - qubit entanglement @xcite using superconducting qubits .
the goal of this work is to implement three - qubit grover s algorithm using four - level squids in cavity - qed .
we consider a three - qubit phase gate , that reduces the number of quantum gates typically required for the realization of grover s algorithm .
three - qubit grover s algorithm is probabilistic wlyang , as compared to two - qubit grover s algorithm .
therefore , to achieve high success probability , we have to implement basic searching iteration several times .
implementation of three - qubit grover search is much more complex as compared to two - qubit case . in our scheme , two lowest energy levels @xmath3 and
@xmath4 of each squid represent logical states .
the scheme is based on resonant , off - resonant interaction of cavity field with @xmath5 transition of squid and application of resonant microwave pulses .
our scheme does not require adjustment of squid level spacing during the implementation of grover s search iteration , thus , decoherence caused by the adjustment of level spacing is suppressed .
we do not require identical coupling constants of each squid with the resonator and direct coupling between the levels @xmath4 and @xmath6 @xcite .
grover s iteration time becomes faster due to resonant and off - resonant interactions as compared to second order detuning or adiabatic passage .
grover s iterations based on three - qubit quantum phase gate employed here , considerably simplify the implementation as compared to conventional gate decomposition method @xcite .
more importantly , it reduces the possibility of error in comparison with a series of two - qubit gates .
we also consider the effect of spontaneous decay rate from intermediate level @xmath7 and decay of cavity field during the implementation of grover s iterations .
the basic idea of grover s algorithm is as follows ; we prepare input basis states in superposition state @xmath8 by applying walsh - hadamard transformation .
first we , invert phase of the desired basis state through unitary operator ( called oracle ) and then invert all the basis states about the average .
we consider the implementation of grover s algorithm in terms of quantum logic networks as shown in fig
. 1 . any quantum logical network can be constructed using quantum phase gates and single - qubit quantum gates .
the single - qubit quantum gate for @xmath9 qubit can be written in dirac notation as @xmath10for @xmath11 and @xmath12 , we have @xmath13 . here
@xmath14 is the pauli rotation matrix whose function is to flip the state of qubit such that @xmath15 and @xmath16 for @xmath17 and @xmath18 , we have @xmath19 which transforms each qubit into superposition state i.e. , @xmath20 and @xmath21 @xmath22 the transformation for three - qubit quantum controlled phase gate can be expressed by @xmath23where @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 stand for basis @xmath6 or @xmath4 of the qubit and @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 are the kroneker delta functions .
thus , three - qubit quantum phase gate induces a phase @xmath30 only when all three input qubit are in state @xmath31 .
three - qubit quantum phase gate operator for @xmath32 can be written in dirac notation as @xmath33 the three - qubit controlled phase gate can be used instead of involving series of two - qubit gates .
this method not only simplifies the implementation but also reduces the probability of error . figure .
[ fig1 ] shows the circuit diagram of three - qubit grover s algorithm based on three - qubit phase gate and two - qubit gates @xcite .
consider that the initial state of three qubits is @xmath34 .
grover s algorithm can be carried out using the following three steps : _ _ part 1 _ _ * * ( w ) * * : apply walsh - hadamard transformation @xmath35 on each qubit .
the resultant state is therefore given by @xmath36 _ part 2 _ ( * c * ) : in this step , consider the unitary operator @xmath37 ( called oracle ) which changes the sign of target state @xmath38 .
the operator @xmath39 performs the unitary transformation which can be implemented using three - qubit phase gate @xmath40 and single - qubit gate @xmath41 @xmath42 as shown in fig .
the sign change operators for eight possible target states are given by @xmath43now oracle applies one of @xmath44 operators on state given in eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) and changes the sign of target state .
for example , our target state is @xmath45 , then by applying @xmath46 on state ( [ eq4 ] ) , we obtain the change of phase on target state @xmath47 i.e. , @xmath48 _ part 3 _ ( * n * ) : in this step , our goal is to find out the marked state @xmath45 .
this can be accomplished through inversion about mean using the operator @xmath49 .
it is clear from fig . fig1
that the operator @xmath50 can be written in terms of single - qubit gate and three qubit quantum phase gate @xmath51the combined operator @xmath52 is called grover s operator . when @xmath53 is applied to initial state @xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath56 times ,
then the probability of searching target state becomes maximum @xcite .
here , we consider rf - squids as qubits that consist of a single josephson junction enclosed by superconducting loop .
the corresponding hamiltonian is given by @xcite @xmath57where @xmath58 and @xmath59 are junction capacitance and loop inductance , respectively .
the conjugate variables of the system are magnetic flux @xmath60 threading the ring and total charge @xmath61 on capacitor .
the static external flux applied to the ring is @xmath62 and @xmath63 is the josephson coupling energy . here , @xmath64 is critical current of josephson junction and @xmath65 is the flux quantum .
the squids are biased properly to achieve desired four - level structure as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] by varying the external flux @xcite .
the single - mode of the cavity field is resonant with @xmath66 transition of squids 1 and 2 .
the evolution of initial state @xmath67 and @xmath68 under the effect of hamiltonian ( [ eq8 ] ) can be written as @xcite @xmath69where @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) is vacuum ( single photon ) state of the cavity field and @xmath72 ( @xmath73 ) is the coupling constant between the cavity field and @xmath74 transition of the squid @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
the cavity field interacts off - resonantly with @xmath66 transition of squid 3 ( i.e. , @xmath77 as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] . here , @xmath78 is the detuning between @xmath66 transition frequency @xmath79 of squid 3 , @xmath80 is the frequency of resonator and @xmath81 is coupling constant between resonator mode and @xmath66 transition . in the presence of single photon inside the cavity ,
the evolution of initial state @xmath82 and @xmath83 are given by @xcite @xmath84it is clear that phase shifts @xmath85 and @xmath86 are induced to states @xmath87 and @xmath88 of squid 3 , respectively .
however , states @xmath89 and @xmath90 remain unchanged .
a classical microwave pulse resonant with @xmath91 ( @xmath92 ) is applied to each squid .
the evolution of states can be written as @xcite @xmath93where @xmath94 is the rabi frequency between two levels @xmath95 and @xmath96 and @xmath97 is the phase associated with classical field .
it may be mentioned that resonant interaction between pulse and squid can be carried out in a very short time by increasing the rabi frequency of pulse .
three squids shown in fig . [ fig2 ]
are initially prepared in state @xmath98 . for notation convenience ,
we denote ground level as @xmath4 and first excited state as @xmath6 for squid @xmath99 as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] . _ _ part 1 _ _ * * ( w ) * * : _ _ _ _ to accomplish _ _ part 1__of grover s algorithm , we apply single - qubit gate @xmath100 to each squid as shown in fig .
the single - qubit gate @xmath101 is carried out through two - step process that involves an auxiliary level @xmath102 via method described in ref @xcite .
we need two microwave pulses of different frequencies resonant to @xmath103 and @xmath104 transitions .
the desired arbitrary single - qubit gate ( see eq . ( 1 ) ) can be achieved by choosing a proper interaction time ( i.e. , @xmath105 ) and phase @xmath97 of classical microwave pulse resonance to @xmath104 transition .
we achieve @xmath101 by choosing @xmath106 and @xmath107 as a result we obtain state given by eq .
( [ eq4 ] ) . _
part 2 _ ( * c * ) * : * in order to implement @xmath108 apply single - qubit gate @xmath41 @xmath109 by choosing @xmath110 and @xmath12 as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] . then apply three - qubit quantum controlled phase gate .
the procedure for realizing the three - qubit controlled phase gate is described as follows : initially , cavity is in a vacuum state @xmath70 and levels @xmath111 and @xmath88 of each squid are not occupied .
_ step 1 . _
apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath112 and phase @xmath113 , where @xmath114 is pulse duration ) resonant to @xmath115 transition of the squid @xmath75 to occupy level @xmath116 cavity field interacts resonantly to the @xmath117 transition of squid @xmath75 for time interval @xmath118 such that the transformation @xmath119 is obtained .
the overall step can be written as @xmath120 .
however , the state @xmath121 remains unchanged .
_ apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath122 and phase @xmath123 ) to the squid 1 while a microwave pulse ( with @xmath124 and phase @xmath18 ) to the squid 2 . as a result transformations @xmath125 for squid 1 while @xmath126 for squid 2 are obtained .
_ after the above operation , when cavity is in a single photon state @xmath127 , only the level @xmath87 of squid 2 is populated .
the cavity field interacts resonantly to @xmath128 transition of squid 2 for time @xmath129 we then obtain transformation @xmath130 while states @xmath131 , @xmath132 and , @xmath133 remain unchanged
. then apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath134 and phase @xmath113 ) to squid 2 to transform state @xmath135 to @xmath136 .
the overall step can be written as @xmath137 .
however , states @xmath138 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 remain unchanged .
the evolution of the system after above three steps is given by @xmath141 it must be noted here that we have shown the evolution of only four initial possible states out of eight states ( see eq .
( 4 ) ) since the evolution of other four states i.e. , @xmath142 and @xmath143 is trivial .
_ step 4 . _
apply microwave pulse with @xmath144 and phase @xmath18 to squid 3 to obtain transformation @xmath145 @xmath146 . after the above operation
only level @xmath111 of squid ( 3 ) is populated , when cavity is in a single photon state .
now the cavity field interacts off - resonantly to @xmath147 transition of squid 3 .
it is clear from eq .
( [ eq10 ] ) that for @xmath148 , state @xmath149 changes to @xmath150 .
however , states @xmath151 , @xmath152 and @xmath153 remain unchanged .
_ step 5 . _
apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath144 and phase @xmath123 ) to squid 3 , as a result state transformation @xmath154 is obtained .
_ perform reverse of the operations mentioned in step 3 .
apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath134 and phase @xmath155 ) to squid 2 .
wait for time @xmath156 given in step 3 , during which cavity field interacts resonantly to @xmath157 transition of the squid 2 .
over all transformation can easily be written as @xmath158 .
however , states @xmath159 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 remain unchanged .
the evolution of the system after applying steps 4 - 6 is given by @xmath160 _ step 7 .
_ apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath122 and phase @xmath123 ) to squid 2 while a microwave pulse ( with @xmath161 and phase @xmath18 ) to squid 1 .
the transformations @xmath162 for squid 2 while @xmath163 for squid 1 are obtained .
_ now perform reverse operation of step 1 .
first wait for time interval @xmath118 during which resonator interacts resonantly to the @xmath164 transition of squid 1 .
then apply microwave pulse ( with @xmath165 and phase @xmath113 ) to squid 1 .
the overall step can easily be written as @xmath166 .
however , state @xmath167 remains unchanged .
after applying steps 7 - 8 , the system evolves as @xmath168 after the application of three - qubit phase gate , the state given by eq .
( eq4 ) evolves to @xmath169 next apply single - qubit gate i.e. , @xmath41 @xmath170 which completes the part 2 ( c ) of the implementation scheme .
_ part 3 _ ( * n * ) : in order to implement operator @xmath50 , apply single - qubit gate @xmath171 , then apply three - qubit quantum controlled phase gate by repeating the above mentioned 8 steps . finally , apply single - qubit hadamard gate @xmath172 .
it is clear that grover s operator @xmath173 for eight objects ( @xmath174 ) can be implemented using four - level squids coupled to superconducting resonator .
it may be pointed out that in order to implement a three - qubit phase gate using conventional decomposition method , it requires twenty five basic gates , i.e. , six two - qubit phase gates , twelve single - qubit hadamard gates , and seven single - qubit phase shift gates @xcite .
if we assume that the realization of each basic gate requires a one - step operation only , then twenty five steps are required for a three - qubit phase gate .
whereas in our scheme total number of eight steps are needed to implement three - qubit phase gate . as a result
our proposed implementation scheme for grover s search algorithm which is based on three - qubit phase gate is faster than one based on two - qubit phase gate . after performing the required gate operations for grover s algorithm
, we need to readout the computational results .
this can be done by jointly detecting the states of the three qubits @xcite .
the readout for flux qubit can be done by measuring the josephson inductance of a squid that is inductively coupled to the qubit @xcite .
there are some interesting schemes to perform joint dispersive readouts for superconducting qubits @xcite .
the implementation of our scheme also requires such joint dispersive readout for three squids .
here , we discuss different types of imperfections which can arise during the implementation of grover s algorithm . the relevant parameters during the implementation are coupling constant @xmath175 decay rate @xmath176 of level @xmath88 and cavity decay rate @xmath177 we consider spontaneous decay from the intermediate level @xmath102 , during resonant interaction of cavity field with @xmath178 transition of squids 1 and 2 .
here , we assume that under the condition that no photon from spontaneous emission is detected , the conditional hamiltonian for the evolution of system is given by @xcite @xmath179 the hamiltonian given by eq .
( [ eq13 ] ) is valid as long as the decay rate of level @xmath111 is much smaller than @xmath180 the decay rate @xmath176 of squid 1 and 2 can affect the performance of three - qubit phase gate .
suppose each squid is initially prepare in generic state @xmath181 now the state of three qubits becomes @xmath182 where the coefficients @xmath183 @xmath184 @xmath185 and @xmath186 , satisfy the normalization condition .
if we consider @xmath187 , then the state of the system after phase gate operation becomes @xmath188 however , if the decay of level @xmath102 is included during phase gate then the expression for @xmath189 becomes rather complex , therefore it is not reproduced here .
the fidelity of three - qubit phase gate is given by @xmath190 here , @xmath191 with @xmath192 , @xmath193 , and @xmath194 in order to realize the effects of decay on the performance of three - qubit phase gate , average fidelity over all possible three - qubit initial states is calculated using the following : @xmath195 after carrying out integration , we obtain @xmath196 next , we show the plots of average fidelity as a function of @xmath197 in fig .
it can easily be verified that for @xmath198 one has @xmath199 which leads to @xmath200 it is clear from fig .
[ fig3 ] that average fidelity decreases due to the increase in the cavity decay rate .
we also calculate the success probability of three - qubit phase gate which is given by @xmath201 if we consider @xmath202 then corresponding success probability of three - qubit phase gate reduces to @xmath203 of three - qubit controlled phase gate as a function of coupling constant @xmath204 , width=3 ] we take into account success rate of three - qubit phase gate ( eq . [ eq14 ] ) and grover search itself .
we consider @xmath205 without loss of generality and perform simulation for finding the target state for @xmath206 ( ideal case ) , @xmath207 , and @xmath208 here , we consider the success probability for target state @xmath209 as shown in fig .
[ fig4](a ) .
it is clear from fig .
fig4(a ) that success rate becomes closer to the ideal case when decay rate is sufficiently smaller than coupling constant i.e. , @xmath210 typical decoherence rate for squid is of the order @xmath211 while coupling constant can be achieved upto @xmath212 @xcite .
this shows that for these parameters , three - qubit controlled phase gate and grover s iterations can be performed with high fidelity .
probability of success is highest at @xmath213 iteration for ideal case .
however , we should prefer @xmath214 iteration in the presence of dissipation because it has the highest value of fidelity .
the effect of level decay on the fidelity of search state during iteration is shown in fig . [ fig4](b ) .
it is clear from fig .
[ fig4](b ) that the fidelity of state to be searched decreases much rapidly for the case of larger decay rate as compared to smaller decay rate as the number of iterations increase . from intermediate level @xmath215 ( a ) probability of finding the target state @xmath216 in case of @xmath217 , @xmath207 , and @xmath208 ( b ) fidelity of the state searched for @xmath218 and @xmath208,width=3 ] next we consider the effects of cavity decay during the implementation of grover s algorithm . during the implementation of three - qubit phase gate ( sec .
iv ) , transition of squid 1 from level @xmath88 to @xmath219 would result in the emission of one photon ( see step @xmath75 in sec .
then transition of squid 2 from level @xmath87 to @xmath88 would absorb this photon with unit probability in step @xmath99 and vice versa for step @xmath220 and @xmath221 in the absence of cavity decay the occupation probability of level @xmath87 and @xmath88 of squid 1 and 2 should be exactly one .
however , if cavity relaxation is taken into account , then the occupation probabilities are expected to decay exponentially . under the assumption that no photon actually leaks out during implementation time , we can write the conditional hamiltonian as @xcite @xmath222 where , @xmath223 is the cavity decay rate and @xmath72 is the coupling constant .
for @xmath224 we only need to focus on time evolution of the system governed by conditional hamiltonian ( eq .
( [ ch ] ) ) under the assumption of strong coupling limit .
the fidelity and corresponding success probabilities for three - qubit phase gate can easily be obtained , which are given by @xmath225 and @xmath226 for @xmath227 , we have @xmath228 the success probability of target state @xmath229 for ideal case and in the presence of cavity decay is shown in fig . [ fig5](a ) .
it can be seen that the probability of finding target state decreases in the presence of cavity decay rate .
the effects of cavity decay rate on fidelity of grover s search iteration is also shown in fig . [ fig5](b ) .
it is clear from fig .
fig5(b ) that the fidelity of grover s search decreases as a function of iterations much rapidly for higher cavity decay rate . (
a ) probability of finding the target state @xmath216 in case of @xmath230 , @xmath231 and @xmath232 ( b ) fidelity of the state searched for @xmath233 and @xmath232,width=3 ] we have separately discussed the effects on fidelity from spontaneous decay and cavity decay , however , in a general case the system involves both these decays .
thus we also consider the effect of these decays simultaneously .
the results of our numerical simulation for corresponding average fidelity are shown in fig .
it is clear from figs .
[ fig4]-[fig6 ] that our proposed grover s iterations can be performed with high success probability and fidelity as long as cavity decay rate and decay rate of the intermediate level @xmath88 is small enough .
the typical values of cavity decay rate is @xmath234 ( @xmath235 ) @xcite .
it may be mentioned that more rigorous analysis is required for the case of very low @xmath236 resonators . of three - qubit controlled phase gate as a function of cavity and level decay , width=3 ]
we have discussed the implementation of 3-qubit grover s algorithm using 4-level squids subjected to quantized and classical microwave fields .
grover s algorithm involves three - qubit phase gates and single - qubit gates . here
, we briefly estimate the total operational time for three - qubit controlled phase gate .
the total implementation time is the sum of all interaction times involved in three - qubit controlled phase gate operation i.e. , @xmath237 on substituting the values of interaction times given in sec .
@xmath238 we obtain @xmath239here , we consider without loss of generality @xmath240 which is the same as given in ref han .
choosing @xmath241 , @xmath242 , the operational time for three - qubit phase gate comes out to be @xmath243 .
the operation time for single - qubit gate is about @xmath244 @xcite which can be applied to each qubit , simultaneously .
therefore , the estimated time for the implementation of three - qubit grover algorithm performing two iterations is approximately @xmath245 .
we have considered the effect of decay for level @xmath246 under the assumption that the decay rate of level @xmath247 is much smaller then level @xmath246 .
the typical values of the decay time for levels @xmath246 and @xmath248 are @xmath249 and @xmath250 0.16 ms as discussed in ref .
@xcite . during the steps 1,2 , and 3 in phase gate operations
level @xmath247 of squids 1 and 2 is occupied through the application of squid - pulse resonant interaction and squid - resonator resonant interaction as discussed in sec .
operation time @xmath251 for squid 1 and @xmath252 for squid 2 , in these steps is equal to @xmath253 and @xmath254 , respectively , which can be shortened by increasing the rabi frequency @xmath255 and coupling constants @xmath256 and @xmath257 . for the typical choice of parameters as given in ref @xcite , we have @xmath258 , which is much shorter than @xmath259 .
the squids can also be designed to have long relaxation time for level @xmath247 .
thus decoherence due to relaxation of level @xmath111 can be negligibly small .
as far as the decay of level @xmath260 is concerned , it may be pointed out that in our scheme direct coupling between levels @xmath261 and @xmath262 is not needed . the potential barrier between levels @xmath260 and @xmath262 can also be adjusted such that decay of level @xmath260 is negligibly small @xcite .
therefore , storage time of each qubit can be made much longer .
when levels @xmath111 and @xmath88 are manipulated by microwave pulses , resonant interaction between cavity field mode and @xmath263 transition of each control squid is unwanted .
this effect can be minimized by setting the condition @xmath264 for squids 1 and 2 . during the application of microwave pulse , off - resonant interaction of cavity field with @xmath263 transition , in the presence of single photon inside
the cavity is unwanted .
it induces an unwanted phase which can effect the performance of the desired gate .
this effect can be negligible under the condition @xmath265 for squid @xmath99 .
however , if this effect is included during the steps @xmath266 and @xmath267 for three - qubit phase gate , then the corresponding fidelity can easily be obtained . here , we do not present the expression for @xmath268 owing to its complexity , however the fidelity is given by if off - resonant interaction during step @xmath266 and @xmath267 is not considered , then we have @xmath277 @xmath278 and@xmath279 which leads to @xmath280 the plot of the average fidelity as a function of rabi frequency @xmath281 is shown in fig . [ fig7 ] . we choose @xmath282 for this plot .
it can be seen that the average fidelity increases as a function of rabi frequency @xmath283 applied to target squid .
@xmath284it is clear from fig .
[ fig7 ] that for @xmath285 , we have @xmath286 when slowly changing rabi frequencies are applied to satisfy the adiabatic passage , gate times becomes slow
i.e. , of the order of 1 ms to a few microseconds @xcite . however , in our scheme we do not require slowly changing rabi frequency during the implementation of three - qubit phase gate , thus gate is significantly faster i.e. , of the order of 13ns .
the fast pulses may introduce new imperfections , for example , accurately designing of the duration of pulses might not be easy .
it may be mentioned here that adiabatic process is not always slow as an interesting proposal based on controllable stark - chirped rapid adiabatic passage has been proposed in a recent study @xcite . here
, we would like to mention that the physical implementation of three - qubit grover s algorithm in cavity quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) has been proposed in a recent study by yang _
et al _ @xcite .
the scheme is based upon the resonant interaction of three rydberg atoms initially prepared in a coherent superposition state traversing through a single - mode microwave cavity . as compared to the flying qubits , here we have considered stationary qubits defined through two lowest level of four level squids .
our scheme is based on the generation and absorption of single photon in high q cavity using squids .
the generation of single microwave photon in superconducting qubit have been reported , experimentally in some recent studies _
et al_. @xcite . in conclusion ,
we have proposed a scheme for the realization of three - qubit grover s algorithm based on three - qubit phase gate using four - level squids coupled to a single - mode superconducting resonator . in this proposal ,
adjustment of level spacing during the operation , slowly changing rabi frequencies ( to satisfy adiabatic passage ) , and the use of second - order detuning ( to achieve off - resonance raman coupling between two relevant levels ) are not required .
thus , implementation time is significantly faster and has operation time of the order of nanoseconds .
the coupling constants of each squid with the resonator are different .
thus , an unavoidable non - uniformity in device parameters can be accommodated .
we consider the effect of imperfections in the system which include the decay of the cavity field and the relevant level .
we also incorporate the influence of unwanted off - resonant interaction during the gate implementation .
our results show that the marked state can be searched with high fidelity even in the presence of imperfections in the system which is quite interesting .
yang , c. p. , chu , shih - i .
, han , s. : quantum information transfer and entanglement with squid qubits in cavity qed : a dark - state scheme with tolerance for nonuniform device parameter . phys .
lett . * 92*(11 ) , 117902 ( 2004 ) ; leek , p. j. , filipp , s. , maurer , p. , baur , m. , bianchetti , r. , fink , j. m. , gppl , m. , steffen , l. , wallraff , a. : using sideband transitions for two - qubit operations in superconducting circuits .
b * 79*(18 ) , 180511(r ) ( 2009 ) .
wallraff , a. , schuster , d. i. , blais , a. , frunzio , l. , huang , r .- s . , majer , j. , kumar , s. , girvin , s. m. , schoelkopf , r. j.:strong coupling of a single photon to a superconducting qubit using circuit quantum electrodynamics .
nature ( london ) * 431 * , 162 - 167 ( 2004 ) .
dicarlo , l. , chow , j. m. , gambetta , j. m. , bishop , l. s. , johnson , b. r. , schuster , d. i. , majer , j. , blais , a. , frunzio , l. , girvin , s. m. , schoelkopf , r. j. : demonstration of two - qubit algorithms with a superconducting quantum processor .
nature , * 460 * , 240 - 244 ( 2009 ) .
dicarlo , l. , reed , m. d. , sun , l. , johnson , b. r. , chow , j. m. , gambetta , j. m. , frunzio , l. , girvin , s. m. , devoret , m. h. , and schoelkopf , r. j. : preparation and measurement of three - qubit entanglement in a superconducting circuit .
nature * 467 * , 574 - 578 ( 2010 ) .
he , xiao - ling . , yang , c.p .
, li , s. , luo , j. y. , han , s. : quantum logical gates with four - level superconducting quantum interference devices coupled to a superconducting resonator .
rev . a * 82*(2),024301 ( 2010 ) .
yang , c. p. , chu , shih - i .
, han , s. : possible realization of entanglement , logical gates , and quantum - information transfer with superconducting - quantum - interference - device qubits in cavity qed . phys .
a * 67*(4 ) , 042311 ( 2003 ) .
blais , a. , huang , r. -s .
, wallraff , a. , girvin , s. m. , schoelkopf , r. j. : cavity quantum electrodynamics for superconducting electrical circuits : an architecture for quantum computation .
a * 69*(6 ) , 062320 ( 2004 ) .
filipp , s. , maurer , p. , leek , p. j. , baur , m. , bianchetti , r. , fink , j. m. , gppl , m. , steffen , l. , gambetta , j. m. , blais , a. , wallraff , a. : two - qubit state tomography using a joint dispersive readout .
lett . * 102*(20 ) , 200402 ( 2009 ) .
zhang , p. , wang , z. d. , sun , j. d. , sun , c. p. : holonomic quantum computation using rf superconducting quantum interference devices coupled through a microwave cavity .
a * 71*(4 ) , 042301 ( 2005 ) .
wang , h. , hofheinz , m. , ansmann , m. , bialczak , r. c. , lucero , e. , neeley , m. , oconnell , a. d. , sank , d. , wenner , j. , cleland , a. n. , martinis , j. m. : measurement of the decay of fock states in a superconducting quantum circuit .
lett . * 101*(24 ) , 240401 ( 2008 ) . | we present a scheme for the implementation of three - qubit grover s algorithm using four - level superconducting quantum interference devices ( squids ) coupled to a superconducting resonator .
the scheme is based on resonant , off - resonant interaction of the cavity field with squids and application of classical microwave pulses .
we show that adjustment of squid level spacings during the gate operations , adiabatic passage , and second - order detuning are not required that leads to faster implementation .
we also show that the marked state can be searched with high fidelity even in the presence of unwanted off - resonant interactions , level decay , and cavity dissipation .
keywords : quantum phase gate ; grover s algorithm ; superconducting quantum interference devices ( squids ) |
coherent photoproduction of neutral pions on nuclei , when the target nucleus remains in its ground state , are widely used in meson - nuclear physics .
firstly , these reactions allow obtaining nuclear structure information . since the incident photon probes the entire nuclear volume , the cross section directly depends on the nuclear density distribution .
an important advantage of reactions involving neutral pions is that they are not complicated by the coulomb interaction , so that the description of the final state becomes more simple . among the recent works one can mention ref.@xcite , in which the dependence of the cross section for @xmath2li@xmath3li on the @xmath4li parameters was explored .
generally , the results obtained from the photoproduction reactions seem to be of comparable quality to that provided by other processes , for example , by elastic particle - nuclear scattering .
the second important aspect , related to the coherent meson photoproduction , is the investigation of the photoproduction mechanism .
the case in point are the spin - isospin selection rules provided by the quantum numbers of the target nucleus .
these rules make it possible to identify the contributions of individual components of the photoproduction amplitude .
recently , experiments were carried out in order to study partial transitions in nuclei proceeding when the meson is produced @xcite .
such experiments became possible due to significant improvements in detection of the mesons .
this allowed one to overcome difficulties in identifying individual nuclear transitions , which were the main obstacle of using nuclear reactions to study meson photoproduction dynamics . in the present work we consider coherent photoproduction of two neutral pions @xmath5 the corresponding single nucleon process @xmath6
is still not very well understood .
there are significant deviations between the analyses provided by different groups ( see , for example , the discussion in ref.@xcite ) . as a rule they give an acceptable description of the available data , although the partial wave content of the corresponding amplitudes may be rather different . the complete experiment , which may resolve this ambiguity , appears to be extremely difficult when two mesons are produced @xcite .
some results for photoproduction of @xmath0 on protons are obtained only in the low energy region @xcite where one can effectively use a truncated expansion of the amplitude over partial waves .
the information which may be obtained on the elementary amplitude is usually considered as a main motivation for studying coherent photoproduction on nuclei .
there are , however , difficulties arising from a rather strong sensitivity of the coherent cross section to different model ingredients , like off - shell behavior of the elementary amplitude , effects of the final pion - nuclear interaction , role of two - nucleon production mechanisms , _
etc_. these problems seem to be unavoidable at least within the models in which the impulse approximation is used as a basic zero - order approximation .
hence , more or less firm quantitative conclusion can be drawn only as long as sophisticated microscopic models are adopted . at the same time , in the @xmath0 case where even the general partial wave structure is rather poorly known , already qualitative results may provide very useful information .
here we are mainly focused on the isospin structure of the @xmath0 photoproduction amplitude .
the corresponding selection rules provided by the charge of the nucleus enable us to get information about the role of isoscalar and isovector transitions in this reaction .
the numerical calculations are performed on the deuteron and @xmath1he .
our main purpose is to study the presumably strong sensitivity of the cross section to the isospin of the target .
the results are expected to be important as a firm testing ground for our knowledge on the two - pion photoproduction dynamics .
the formalism , which we used to calculate the cross section ( [ 10 ] ) , was partially considered in our previous work @xcite on coherent photoproduction of @xmath7 pairs .
the cross section for coherent photoproduction of two mesons on a nucleus @xmath8 with spin @xmath9 is given in the center - of - mass frame by @xmath10 where the matrix element @xmath11 determines the transition between the nuclear states with definite spin projection .
the energy of the incident photon and the initial and the final energies of the target nucleus are denoted respectively by @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 . as independent kinematical variables we took the invariant @xmath15 mass @xmath16 , the spherical angle @xmath17 of the final nucleus momentum @xmath18 and the spherical angle of the momentum @xmath19 of one of the two pions in their center - of - mass frame .
the photon polarization index @xmath20 will be omitted in subsequent expressions . in order to calculate the amplitude @xmath21 we used the impulse approximation taking the operator @xmath22 as a superposition of operators @xmath23 for photoproduction on free nucleons @xmath24 where the summation is performed over all nucleons in the target .
the spin structure of the single nucleon operator has the well known form @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the pauli spin operator , and the amplitudes @xmath27 and @xmath28 describe transitions with and without flip of the nucleon spin .
both amplitudes depend on the photon polarization index @xmath29 and on the kinematical variables as described above . for @xmath23 we adopted the phenomenological analysis @xcite for @xmath30 .
the analysis contains the resonance @xmath31 whose parameters were taken from the particle data group listing ( pdg ) @xcite and were not varied .
other partial amplitudes having the spin - parity @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , as well as a possible contribution in @xmath35 ( in addition to @xmath31 ) were taken in the form @xmath36g_{\delta}f_{\delta\to
\pi n}\,.\ ] ] here the first term in the brackets corresponds to the background , which is assumed to depend smoothly on the energy , whereas the second term containing possible contributions from baryon resonances in the @xmath37-channel , can undergo rapid variation with energy .
the factors @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the @xmath40-isobar propagator and the @xmath41 decay vertex function .
the details of parametrization of the terms @xmath42 and @xmath43 are described in ref.@xcite .
the parameters were adjusted to the angular distributions of the incident photons in the frame , in which the @xmath44-axis was taken along the normal to the final state plane .
the latter contains the momenta of all three final particles in the center - of - mass system .
the predictions of this fit for the total cross section are presented in fig.[fig1 ] ( the solid curve ) . in the same figure
we show the contributions coming from only the spin independent part @xmath28 and the spin - flip amplitude @xmath27 .
the amplitude ( [ tjp ] ) was fitted to the proton data . to calculate the photoproduction on nuclei one needs information about the reaction on a neutron @xmath45 .
the contribution of @xmath31 to @xmath46 was determined by the pdg values of the corresponding helicity @xmath47 amplitudes @xmath48 and @xmath49 @xcite . to fix the isotopic structure of other contributions we used the following simple prescription . in the isotopic spin space of the nucleon
the operator @xmath23 is given by @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the @xmath44-component of the nucleon isospin operator @xmath52 .
the coefficients @xmath53 and @xmath54 in eq.([28 ] ) determine transitions to the final @xmath55 state when the initial nucleon absorbs a photon having isospin @xmath56 and @xmath57 , respectively .
therefore , the amplitudes of @xmath0 photoproduction on the proton and on the neutron read @xmath58 a consequence of eq.([32 ] ) is that proton and neutron amplitudes are related to each other as @xmath59 where the parameter @xmath60 is the ratio of the isoscalar part @xmath53 to the proton amplitude @xmath61 it determines the relative contribution of the isoscalar @xmath62 and the isovector @xmath63 photons to the reaction . in the general case its value is energy dependent .
however for our qualitative estimations we took it as constant . to obtain @xmath60 we used experimental data for the total cross section of @xmath64 , presented in ref.@xcite .
since the cross section is proportional to the square of the modulus of @xmath65 , the value of @xmath60 can not be unambiguously determined .
in particular , the data @xcite for @xmath46 in fig.[fig1 ] may be described both with @xmath66 and @xmath67 . however , since the major part of the resonances in the energy region considered are excited by the isovector photons and , therefore , the larger value 0.75 seems to be rather unlikely , we used @xmath68 as is noted above , to calculate photoproduction of @xmath0 on nuclei we used impulse approximation .
the kinematic in the @xmath69 subsystem was fixed using the prescription of ref.@xcite in which the elementary amplitude @xmath70 is frozen at some mean value of the initial nucleon momentum @xmath71 determined in the overall center - of - mass frame as @xmath72 where @xmath8 is the nuclear mass number , @xmath73 is the photon momentum , and @xmath74 is the three - momentum transferred to the nucleus .
the energy @xmath75 of the nucleon is fixed by the on - mass - shell condition @xmath76 .
the four - momentum @xmath77 of the final nucleon was then determined by the energy - momentum conservation at the single - nucleon vertex @xmath78 where @xmath79 , @xmath80 , is the four - momentum of the @xmath81-th pion .
the invariant @xmath69 energy @xmath82 in ( [ tjp ] ) was calculated as @xmath83 if the prescription ( [ 49 ] ) together with the mass - shell condition for the initial nucleon are used , the final nucleon turns out to be very close to its mass - shell . the difference @xmath84 , where @xmath85 and @xmath86 are defined according to ( [ ef ] ) and ( [ pf ] ) , does not surpass 4 mev in the whole kinematic region considered .
this is quite important in our case since our amplitude ( [ tjp ] ) is of pure phenomenological nature and is determined in a relatively narrow energy region @xmath87mev . in sect.[results ] we also discuss sensitivity of the results to the prescription for fixing the single nucleon kinematic .
using for @xmath60 the value in ( [ alpa ] ) we firstly calculated the cross section for quasifree photoproduction of @xmath0 on the deuteron .
the results shown in fig.[fig2 ] demonstrate rather good agreement with the data which is achieved within only the impulse approximation , without much need for rescattering corrections .
a direct calculation of the nucleon - nucleon rescattering shows that this effect leads to a slight increase of the total cross section in the whole energy region ( compare dashed and solid lines in fig.[fig2 ] ) . to include the neutron - proton interaction in the final state we used the standard formalism described , for example , in ref.@xcite and
we would like to refer the reader to this paper for more details .
one important point is in order .
as is noted above , the incoherent cross section appears to be rather insensitive to the model ingredients .
for example , the dominant contribution to incoherent photoproduction on a deuteron , provided by the impulse approximation , is proportional to the incoherent sum @xmath88 , folded with the momentum distribution of the nucleons in the deuteron . as a consequence ,
if a realistic nuclear wave function is used in conjunction with the elementary photoproduction operator adjusted to the single nucleon data then already the impulse approximation provides a rather good description of the unpolarized cross section on a nucleus .
the mechanisms involving more than one nucleon , like final state rescatterings , meson exchange currents , nuclear isobar configurations _ etc _ , are important in rather narrow kinematical region where the cross section is , as a rule , rather small . at the same time , in the coherent channel the reaction amplitude is proportional to the absolute square of @xmath89 @xmath90 so that not only the moduli but also the relative phase between @xmath91 and @xmath65 play a role
. the nature of this phase may be rather complicated .
even if the reaction is dominated by the single resonance excitation , the nontrivial phase may appear due to large background contributions in those channels to which the @xmath0 channel is coupled through the unitary relations .
this should primarily be the single pion channel @xmath92 which will generate a dressing of the bare vertex for resonance photoexcitation @xmath93 , thus leading to an energy dependent electromagnetic coupling @xmath94 whose phase may be different for neutrons and protons . in the case of @xmath95 photoproduction
this question was addressed rather detailed in ref.@xcite . in the present work
we do not calculate these effects , since , as we believe , their impact on our qualitative results is not crucial .
the amplitudes @xmath91 and @xmath65 , obtained as described above , were then used to calculate the cross sections of the coherent reactions @xmath96
@xmath97 for the ground states of deuteron and @xmath1he we adopted the phenomenological wave functions from refs.@xcite and @xcite , respectively .
these functions describe the corresponding form factors in the whole momentum transfer region , as covered by the energy region considered here .
since the deuteron has zero isospin , only the isoscalar part @xmath53 in eq.([28 ] ) contributes to the reaction ( [ 46 ] ) . using in eq.([15 ] ) the deuteron quantum numbers and taking into account
only the spherically symmetric part in its wave function one obtains the approximate relation @xmath98\,.\ ] ] here the notation @xmath99 means averaging over the nuclear momentum distribution , available for a given energy .
the lower index `` 0 '' in @xmath100 and @xmath101 relates to the isoscalar part of these amplitudes in ( [ 24 ] ) . according to the analysis outlined above the isoscalar part @xmath53 in eq.([28 ] ) amounts only 8@xmath102 of the absolute value of the proton amplitude @xmath91 .
therefore , the cross section of the reaction ( [ 46 ] ) is expected to be extremely small . from the same considerations
one can conclude that the cross section for @xmath1he should be at least one order of magnitude larger than that on the deuteron .
indeed , since the isospin of @xmath1he is 1/2 , the corresponding cross section within the same approximation as in eq.([52 ] ) reads @xmath103\,.\ ] ] taking @xmath104 according to ( [ alpa ] ) and taking into account the approximate relation @xmath105 as follows from the calculations presented in fig.[fig1 ] , we obtain @xmath106 our results for the cross sections ( [ 46 ] ) and ( [ 48 ] ) are plotted in fig.[fig3 ] .
as one can see , their ratio is in rough agreement with the estimation ( [ 62 ] ) . at the energy @xmath107mev the value of @xmath108 comprises about 46 , at @xmath109mev it reaches 31 and at @xmath110mev it decreases to 13
thus , the cross section for coherent @xmath0 photoproduction should demonstrate a strong dependence on the isospin of the target .
this is primarily due to the smallness of the isoscalar part @xmath53 of the @xmath0 photoproduction amplitude as is predicted by our calculation .
it is worth noting , that the smallness of the cross section for @xmath111 makes it possible to measure the @xmath0 production on a neutron as a difference of the total inclusive cross sections on a deuteron and the free proton . indeed , using closure for the inclusive ( coherent plus incoherent ) cross section on a deuteron , one obtains @xmath112 where , as in the previous expressions , the notation @xmath99 means averaging over the fermi momentum distribution .
@xmath113 is a kinematical factor whose exact form is insignificant for the present discussion .
the last term , proportional to the deuteron scalar matter form factor @xmath114 , depending on the transferred three - momentum @xmath115 , is generally rather small as may be seen from fig.[fig2 ] , where it is plotted by the dash - dotted line .
it is also interesting to note one special property of photoproduction of two neutral pions on @xmath1he which is well seen in eq.([56 ] ) .
namely , within the approximation , in which only the spherically symmetric spatial part of the @xmath1he nuclear wave function is taken into account , the protons form a correlated pair with total spin @xmath116 .
therefore , the production of mesons with a nucleon spin - flip can proceed on the neutron only .
otherwise we will have in the final state two protons with the same orbital and spin momentum , contradicting the pauli exclusion principle .
this property is clearly manifest in eq.([56 ] ) , where the spin dependent part is proportional to @xmath117 .
this means , that one can use the ratio of helium to proton cross sections as a measure of the nucleon spin - change probability in @xmath0 photoproduction .
using the results presented in fig.[fig3 ] one can make a rough estimate of the cross sections for @xmath0 photoproduction on @xmath4li . within a simple shell model this nucleus
is described as a system , containing a core , which is built up from four nucleons with the total isospin @xmath118 , and three valent nucleons .
because of smallness of the isoscalar part @xmath53 of the amplitude @xmath70 the contribution of the core should be small , and the major part of the cross section is expected to come from the valent nucleons . in this respect the cross section for @xmath2li@xmath119li may be estimated according to @xmath120 with @xmath121 ^ 2d\omega}{\int \big[f_{^3\mbox{\scriptsize he}}(q)\big]^2d\omega}\,,\ ] ] where @xmath115 is the momentum transfer , and @xmath122 are the corresponding nuclear matter form factors .
the notation @xmath123 means that for @xmath4li only the contribution of the @xmath124-orbit is taken into account .
the integration is performed over the phase space available for each reaction . to estimate the ratio @xmath125 we used for a ground state @xmath4li wave function
a simple oscillator shell model , which gives for the form factors the well known expressions : @xmath126 @xmath127 taking @xmath128fm and @xmath129fm for @xmath1he and @xmath4li , respectively , one obtains for @xmath125 the value close to @xmath130 at @xmath131mev which decreases to @xmath132 at @xmath133mev . in fig.[fig3 ] we present the cross section calculated with the double - well @xmath4li wave function from ref.@xcite .
the latter gives rather satisfying description of the @xmath4li charge form factor in a wide range of momentum transfer .
as one can see , our results are in general agreement with the estimation @xmath134 , obtained as discussed above .
since the emphasis of our calculation for @xmath2li@xmath119li plotted in fig.[fig3 ] was on demonstrating insignificance of the four - nucleon core , we do not touch here upon some complications like , e.g. , the role of the first excited @xmath4li level @xmath135 with @xmath136mev . since in the data ,
to which the @xmath4li wave function in ref.@xcite was fitted , its contribution was subtracted , it also does not enter our results . at the same time , due to obvious difficulty of separating this level in @xmath0 photoproduction , it should be taken into account if comparison of the theoretical results with the data is intended .
expression ( [ 28 ] ) together with the smallness of the isoscalar part @xmath53 indicates that the isotopic structure of @xmath0 photoproduction is similar to that for @xmath95 photoproduction in the @xmath137 region . in the latter case , according to the results of refs.@xcite the value of @xmath60 is close to 0.1 . due to the same reason the cross section for coherent @xmath0 photoproduction on nuclei should have much in common with that for @xmath95 photoproduction . in particular , the process @xmath138 is known to be suppressed on the nuclei with zero isospin .
for example , direct calculations within impulse approximation as described in refs.@xcite and @xcite , give for the ratio @xmath139 in the region of @xmath137 the value about 20 .
the experimental results for the @xmath140 and @xmath141he@xmath142he cross sections @xcite indicate , that this ratio is likely to be essentially smaller , about 4 .
this difference is primarily due to larger value of the deuteron cross section in comparison to that predicted by the model of @xcite in which the possible nontrivial phase between the neutron and the proton amplitudes is neglected ( see discussion after eq.([42 ] ) and in ref.@xcite ) . since our @xmath0 amplitude has a relatively large resonance part @xmath43 , as defined in eq.([tjp ] ) , it should be sensitive to the variation of the @xmath69 invariant energy @xmath82 . as a consequence , the nuclear cross sections should strongly depend on the prescription of choosing the @xmath82 value when the single - nucleon operator is embedded into the nucleus .
quite apparently , this dependence brings uncertainty into our calculations . to demonstrate the extent to which the results are affected by this uncertainty we present in fig.[fig3 ] the cross section for @xmath143he@xmath144he which was calculated directly via integration over the nucleon momentum @xmath145 without resorting to the prescription ( [ 49 ] ) .
the value of @xmath82 was fixed using the so - called blankenbecler - sugar choice ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) , corresponding to the assumption that all three nucleons in the initial state of @xmath1he share equally its energy , that is @xmath146 where @xmath147 is the energy of the active nucleon in the @xmath1he rest frame .
the corresponding result is shown on the left panel of fig.[fig3 ] by the dash - dotted line .
one readily notes that for coherent @xmath0 photoproduction it is rather important how the single nucleon kinematic is fixed .
this is obviously a trivial consequence of rather strong energy dependence of the elementary amplitude ( [ tjp ] ) .
additional uncertainty comes from the assumption that @xmath60 ( [ 38 ] ) is energy independent in a rather wide energy region . for the estimations presented in this paper
this point is perhaps not very crucial .
however , better quantitative level of the calculations requires more detailed knowledge of the isotopic structure of the elementary amplitude . obviously ,
for this task we need new data for @xmath0 photoproduction on a quasifree neutron with better than in ref.@xcite statistics , wherever possible .
in this paper we present our predictions for coherent photoproduction of @xmath0 pairs on the two lightest nuclei , @xmath148 and @xmath1he .
the calculations are based on the available information about photoproduction on the nucleon , as well as on the physically reasonable assumption , that in the second resonance region the @xmath0 pairs are photoproduced primarily by isovector photons . as our model shows , if these assumptions are correct , the cross sections on protons and neutrons should be of an almost equal size . in this case
one should observe a relatively strong @xmath149 transition on @xmath1he and a rather weak transition on the deuteron .
this situation is very similar to that in @xmath95 photoproduction in the @xmath137 region , where the isovector photons make the dominant contribution .
one of the motivations for the present paper was to encourage experimentalists to study the coherent @xmath0 photoproduction on nuclei .
the cross section of the process ( [ 48 ] ) has appreciable value , about 0.4 @xmath150 and in principle can be measured with reasonable statistics .
such measurements could be a good test of our knowledge about the spin - isospin structure of the amplitude @xmath151 .
the authors acknowledge support from the dynasty foundation , the tpu grant lru - fti-123 - 2014 and the mse program nauka ( project 825). | coherent photoproduction of @xmath0 on the deuteron and @xmath1he is calculated .
the isoscalar and isovector parts of the elementary photoproduction amplitude was determined by fitting the measured total cross section on protons and neutrons .
the dependence of the cross section on the isospin of the target nucleus is discussed . |
the concept of @xmath0 topological insulator was first introduced in a model for graphene @xcite , in the presence of both intrinsic and extrinsic ( rashba ) spin - orbit interactions ( called hereafter , kane - mele model ) @xcite .
the origin of @xmath0 symmetry lies naturally in the time reversal invariance of the underlying spin - orbit interactions , i.e. , in the existence of kramers pairs . in the continuum limit ,
the intrinsic spin - orbit interaction is represented by a so - called topological mass term ( of size @xmath3 , opening a spin - orbit gap @xmath4 ) , encoding quantized spin hall effect .
the latter occurs when fermi energy is in the gap , and implies the existence of a pair of counter - propagating gapless states at the sample boundary with opposite spins , often dubbed as _
edge modes @xcite .
the idea of `` @xmath0 '' topological insulator stems from the observation that these helical edge modes are robust against weak perturbations , such as the extrinsic rashba spin - orbit interaction ( coupling strength : @xmath5 ) .
thus , non - trivial topological nature of a @xmath0 topological insulator is often attributed to the existence of such edge modes , protected by kramers degeneracy .
this paper , on the contrary , highlights its _ bulk _ property .
since real materials always have disorder , we investigate its transport property _ under doping _ using the framework of standard weak localization theory . of course
, the magnitude of spin - orbit interactions has always been questioned in graphene @xcite , leading to search for @xmath0 nature in a system of larger spin - orbit coupling @xcite .
the existence of helical edge modes was first experimentally shown in a two - dimensional hgte / cdte heterostructure @xcite .
recall that in graphene two doubly degenerate dirac cones appear at @xmath1- and @xmath2- points in the first brillouin zone @xcite , in contrast to a single pair of dirac cones appearing at the @xmath6-point in hgte / cdte qauntum well .
the first estimate of @xmath3 and @xmath5 in the original paper of kane and mele : @xmath72.4 k , and @xmath8 0.5 mk for a typical strength of perpendicular electric field @xmath9 50 v/300 nm , provides a favorable condition for @xmath0 non - trivial phase @xcite .
this estimate was later shown to be too optimistic ( for the occurrence of @xmath0 phase ) due to the specific geometry of @xmath10 and @xmath11 orbitals in graphene . according to refs .
@xcite , the estimated value of @xmath3 ( @xmath5 ) is much smaller ( larger ) than the original estimation of ref .
@xcite : @xmath70.01 k , and @xmath8 0.13 k for the same electric field of @xmath9 50 v/300 nm . on the other hand
, a recent first - principle calculation suggests that @xmath12-orbitals play a dominant role in the gap opening at @xmath1 and @xmath2 points @xcite . as a result
, the actual value of @xmath3 might be somewhat intermediate between the previous estimates of @xcite and @xcite , namely @xmath70.28 k , @xmath8 0.23 k per v / nm .
the concept of @xmath0-topological insulator has also been extended to three space dimensions @xcite . a recent spin - arpes study on bi@xmath13te@xmath14 reports on the experimental observation of a spin - helical two - dimensional surface state in such three - dimensional @xmath0-topological insulator @xcite .
localization properties of the doped kane - mele @xmath0 insulator have been studied numerically @xcite .
ref.@xcite deduces a phase diagram in the @xmath15-plane ( @xmath16 : energy , @xmath17 : strength of disorder ) , in which a metallic domain appears in valence and conduction bands with a finite width in @xmath16 . as disorder
is increased , these two extended domains in both bands approach to each other , and eventually merge and disappear .
a more subtle issue is the nature of the metallic state next to the @xmath0 insulating phase .
it has been claimed @xcite that the system s @xmath0 symmetry leads to an unconventional symmetry class . however , an extensive study on the critical exponents @xcite has suggested that the weak anti - localization behavior of the doped @xmath0 insulator belongs to the conventional symplectic symmetry class . this paper addresses the basic mechanism how doped @xmath0 insulators acquire such unique localization properties . as a simple implementation of @xmath0-topological insulator
, we consider kane - mele model , and in contrast to the numerical works of refs .
@xcite , we restrict our study to the limit of weak disorder . on the other hand , we pay much attention to the existence of _ valleys _ in graphene , since localization properties are much influenced by the presence or absence of scattering across different valleys in the brillouin zone .
the later is determined by the range of the impurity potential @xcite .
this paper is organized as follows .
the kane - mele model is introduced in sec .
then , we apply the standard diagrammatic approach to weak localization to the doped kane - mele model . in sec .
iii we consider the case of vanishing rashba soi .
particular attention will be paid to different types of the mass term , ( a ) and ( b ) , together with the presence / absence of @xmath1-@xmath2 scattering . here
, we will focus on unitary behaviors , which appear as a consequence of a finite lifetime acquired by cooperons . breaking or
preserved effective time reversal symmetry will be the main issue of this section .
iv is devoted to study on the effects of rashba spin - orbit interaction . in the final section
, we will summarize our results , and give interpretation to them in terms of the number of _ active _ species of effective spins @xcite . in order to distinguish active and inactive spins ,
we introduce ( pseudo ) trs operations @xmath18 , defined in the subspace @xmath19 , such that @xmath20 where @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 .
their explicit representations are , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is complex conjugation .
@xmath27 represents the genuine trs operation .
effective trs of the system is , therefore , determined by the transformation property of the mass term ( see table [ ptrs ] ) . when a mass term is odd against trs
, the system shows the unitary behavior . if some ( pseudo or genuine ) trs exists in the system , its weak localization property is determined by the number @xmath28 of the activated spin degrees of freedom .
one can verify @xmath29 if @xmath28 is even , whereas @xmath30 if @xmath28 is odd .
the former ( latter ) corresponds to the orthogonal ( symplectic ) class in the random matrix theory @xcite , and leads to constructive ( destructive ) interference between two scattering processes transformed from one to the other by @xmath18 .
the above symmetry arguments allow for a slight generalization of our localization phase diagram ( see fig .
[ venn ] ) . recall that in sec . iv a , we have chosen the mass to be @xmath31 .
results of this analysis are consistent with the symmetry consideration . in fig .
[ venn ] , we further conjecture based on the symmetry consideration that a similar analysis for an ionic mass term @xmath32 leads to the absence of wl ( unitary behavior ) .
thus , the four minus signs in table [ ptrs ] correspond to four unitary phases in fig .
we also point out that in terms of symmetry , ripples plays the same role as the ionic mass .
we mention that the results of our analyses summarized in table [ summary ] and fig .
[ venn ] are also relevant to _ intrinsic _ single valley systems @xcite , such as the one realized in hgte / cdte quantum well @xcite . in the latter system , a single pair ( kramers pair ) of dirac cones appear , in contrast to graphene ( cf .
graphene has two pairs of dirac cones ; they appear at @xmath1 and @xmath2 points ) .
note that two dirac cones ( kramers pair , with real spin @xmath33 and @xmath34 ) , described in the model introduced in ref .
@xcite , have the _ same _ sign for their mass term , implying ( superficially ) the ordinary ( ionic ) mass case in our language .
however , they have also different chiralities , and by a simple linear transformation ( exchange of rows and columns ) , they can be mapped , and indeed corresponds to the topological mass case , studied in sec .
iv a. our diagnosis ( see table [ summary ] , and also fig . [ venn ] ) suggests that the single - valley hgte / cdte system shows a crossover from unitary to orthogonal ( wl ) symmetry class , on activating the real spin degrees of freedom by a ( rashba - like ) off - diagonal interaction between real spin @xmath33 and @xmath34 sectors .
what is then essential to the al behavior characteristic to the doped kane - mele model ?
as can be guessed by the analysis relying on the number @xmath28 of active spin species , the combination of rashba interaction and the @xmath1-@xmath2 scattering makes @xmath35 . in other words ,
the al results even in the absence of the topological mass term , or even in the case of the ordinary mass term . in this sense ,
the al is not a peculiar property of the doped @xmath0 insulator .
the hallmark of the doped @xmath0 insulator becomes manifest in the absence of the rashba interaction .
namely , the robustness of the unitary behavior against the range of the disorder potential is a fingerprint of topological mass term .
the unitary behavior is closely related to the quantized spin hall effect in the undoped case . finally , we comment on the role of the channel index @xmath36 which is a quantum number associated with a relative momentum of electrons before and after the scattering by an impurity .
see eqs.([gamma012 ] ) and ( [ gamma_l ] ) for its definition . as we have already seen in the body of the paper , to identify the singular channel @xmath36 greatly helps to determine the weak localization property . in the case of long - range scatterers ,
the two valleys are decoupled , and we can safely focus on , say , the @xmath1-valley . then , in sec .
iii and iv , we have seen that the @xmath37 singularity appearing in the @xmath38(even ) channel leads to wl , whereas in the @xmath38(odd ) case , the same singularity leads to al , this situation is reversed in the presence of @xmath1-@xmath2 scattering : even @xmath36 leads to al and odd @xmath36 to wl according to table ii .
the above selection rule on the singular channel @xmath36 is superficially dependent on the choice of the spin part of the wave function . in sec .
ii and iii , we have chosen to use a single - valued two - component spinor for describing ab sub - lattice spin eigenstates , which were naturally extended to the single - valued four - component spinor in the presence of rashba spin - orbit interaction . if one choose a double - valued spinor instead of eq.([pseudo ] ) , pretending that the ab - sublattice spin realizes a real spin , then the selection rule is shifted by one .
this shift , however , is the same for all cases in table ii .
hence if we take the difference of @xmath36 relative to the graphene limit , for example , the wl or al behavior does not depend on the choice of the spin eigenstates . as we have seen in secs .
iii and iv , the value @xmath36 of singular channel does not change in the presence of @xmath1-@xmath2 scattering , the value of @xmath28 is , on the other hand , increased by one , in switching on the @xmath39 valley spin @xmath40 . since @xmath40 flip does not involve @xmath41 variables , the value @xmath36 of the singular channel remains the same .
however , the nature of the channel does change by the @xmath1-@xmath2 scattering .
namely , switching on of the valley spin appears as an additional minus sign in particle - particle ladders . in conclusion
, we have constructed a poor man s phase diagram of the doped and disordered kane - mele model . in order to characterize the @xmath0 nature of the model , we considered a doped case in contrast to the more familiar topological insulator phase .
we also characterized the @xmath0 nature from its _ bulk _ properties , instead of its _ edge _ properties , to which the @xmath0 nature is often attributed .
@xcite our analysis is restricted to the weak ( anti-)localization level , and can be used for constructing an effective @xmath42-model description of the same model .
the basic mechanism discussed here will be also useful for the understanding of different types of topological insulators .
the sign of topological mass is taken to be opposite to the original kane - mele opaper @xcite .
this is only for later purpose of making phase diagrams more concise .
physically , the sign of @xmath3 is determined by the the sign of next - nearest neighbor imaginary hopping , which is irrelvant to the localization properties .
a similar circumstance occurs in the convetional analysis of weak anti - localization la ref .
when one considers scattering due to spin - orbit coupling , @xmath43 type isotropic term leads , as is well - known , to weak anti - localization . on the contrary , if one keeps only @xmath44 component , then the system is known to stay , in this case , orthogonal ( in our case the system stays unitary when @xmath45 ) . | localization properties of the doped @xmath0-topological insulator are studied by weak localization theory .
the disordered kane - mele model for graphene is taken as a prototype , and analyzed with attention to effects of the topological mass term , inter - valley scattering , and the rashba spin - orbit interaction .
the known tendency of graphene to anti - localize in the _ absence _ of inter - valley scattering between @xmath1 and @xmath2 points is naturally placed as the massless limit of kane - mele model .
the latter is shown to have a unitary behavior even in the absence of magnetic field due to the topological mass term .
when inter - valley scattering is introduced , the topological mass term leaves the system in the unitary class , whereas the ordinary mass term , which appears if a and b sublattices are inequivalent , turns the system to weak localization . the rashba spin - orbit interaction in the _ presence _ of @xmath1-@xmath2 scattering
drive the system to weak anti - localization in sharp contrast to the ideal graphene case . |
the positron source for the international linear collider ( ilc ) is based on a helical undulator @xcite . before collisions , the accelerated electron beam passes the superconducting helical undulator and creates an intense circularly polarized multi - mev photon beam .
the photons hit a positron target and create in an electromagnetic shower longitudinally polarized positrons ( and electrons ) .
this method was suggested by balakin and mikhailichenko @xcite and has been successfully tested with the e-166 experiment @xcite .
the baseline parameters of the ilc positron source afford a positron polarization of 30% .
the distribution of polarization within the photon beam depends on the radial position of the photons , so it is possible to increase the average polarization of positrons by collimation from 30% up to 50 - 60% .
however , the collimation of the photon beam causes huge thermal load in the collimator material . in this paper ,
a photon collimator design is discussed which is based on studies of the dynamic load in the collimator material . in section [ sec : e+source ] the ilc positron source is described , the photon collimator system is presented in section [ sec : colli ] . the thermal load as well as the cooling are discussed in section [ sec : heatload+cool ] ; potential problems due to cyclic maximum load and degradation are considered in section [ sec : problems ] .
finally , in section [ sec : alternative ] ideas for alternatives of the photon collimator design are presented which could overcame the drawback of the design presented here .
the ilc technical design report ( tdr ) @xcite describes the machine parameters to get electron - positron collisions at centre - of - mass energies of 500gev , 350gev and 250gev and also 1tev .
trains of 1312 bunches ( high luminosity option : 2625 bunches ) with 2@xmath210@xmath3 electrons / positrons per bunch are repeated with a frequency of 5hz .
the scheme of positron production is shown in figure [ fig : source - sketch ] .
the superconducting helical undulator has a period of @xmath4 mm and is located at a distance of 400 m upstream the positron target .
depending on the electron beam energy and the desired polarization , the undulator k value varies from @xmath5 up to @xmath6 .
the length of the undulator is determined by the requirement to generate 1.5 positrons per drive beam electron and amounts up to 231 m maximum .
[ ilc_target_wheel ] the degree of photon polarization depends on the angular distribution of the photons .
the intensity of the undulator radiation has the maximum around the beam axis . by cutting the outer part of the radial symmetric photon beam with a collimator
, the positron polarization is increased by contemporaneous decreasing the positron yield .
the yield of 1.5e@xmath7/e@xmath8 can be recovered by increasing the active length of the undulator and choosing @xmath9 .
table [ tab : e+pol ] illustrates the relation between undulator - k values , collimator aperture , active length of the undulator and expected degree of positron beam polarization using a flux concentrator as optical matching device with parameters described in the tdr @xcite .
depending on the electron beam energy and the k value , the positron polarization approaches 29% for @xmath10 mm up to 50 - 60% if the photon beam radii are collimated to @xmath11 mm ( see also @xcite and table [ tab : collpar ] ) .
.expected positron polarization , @xmath12 , for different undulator k values and photon collimator iris radii at @xmath13gev , high luminosity . the active undulator length , @xmath14 ,
is adjusted to achieve the positron yield of 1.5e@xmath7/e@xmath8 for the nominal luminosity corresponding to 1312 bunches per train .
the undulator period is @xmath15 mm . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
a high degree of positron polarization is desired for physics studies and can be achieved by collimating the undulator photon beam . due to the close correlation between energy of the electron beam which passes the helical undulator , photon beam intensity , collimator iris and degree of polarization , the photon collimator system must be flexible .
further , it has to withstand huge heat loads without breakdown during a long operation time .
the multistage collimator design presented in this paper represents a solution to collimate the photon beam at the ilc positron source . for centre - of - mass energies up to 500gev ,
the material loads stay within acceptable limits taking into account an additionally safety margin against failure due to fatigue stress .
depending on the centre - of - mass energy , one , two or all three stages are used to collimate the photon beam .
the system is water - cooled , the principal parameters of the cooling system are given .
the presented solution can be adopted to electron beam energies up to 500gev . however ,
further simulation studies are recommended to optimize the design taking into account the special material properties as swelling of pyrolytic graphite or potential change of properties of the material due to long - term irradiation .
this will further improve the reliability of the final design .
99 c. adolphsen _ et al .
_ , _ the international linear collider technical design report - volume 3.i : accelerator & in the technical design phase _ , http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/1306.6353[arxiv:1306.6353 ] [ physics.acc-ph ] ; c. adolphsen _ et al .
_ , _ the international linear collider technical design report - volume 3.ii : accelerator baseline design _ , http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/1306.6328[arxiv:1306.6328 ] [ physics.acc-ph ]
. v. e. balakin and a. a. mikhailichenko , _ conversion system for obtaining highly polarized electrons and positrons _ , http://www-project.slac.stanford.edu/lc/local/polarizedpositrons/doc/classicalpapers/preprint_balakin-mikhailichenko_inp79-85.htm[inp-79-85 ] .
g. alexander _ et al . _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nima.2009.07.091[nucl .
instrum .
a * 610 * ( 2009 ) 451 ] , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:0905.3066[arxiv:0905.3066 ] [ physics.ins-det ] ] ; + g. alexander _ et al . _ ,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.100.210801[phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 210801 ] .
a. ushakov _ et al .
_ , _ production of highly polarized positron beams _ , proc .
ipac , san sebastian , spain ( 2011 ) , http://accelconf.web.cern.ch/accelconf/ipac2011/papers/tupc006.pdf[997 ] .
j. pappis and s.l .
blum , _ properties of pyrolytic graphite _ , http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1151-2916.1961.tb11664.x/abstract[j .
. soc . * 44*(1961)592 ] .
d. yao and b. kim , http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/s1359431102001916[applied thermal engineering * 23 * , ( 2003 ) 341 - 352 ] .
m. maslov , m. schmitz , v. sychev , _ layout considerations on the 25gev / 300kw beam dump of the xfel project _
, http://flash.desy.de/sites2009/site_vuvfel/content/e403/e1642/e1132/e1129/infoboxcontent1791/fel2006-05.pdf[tesla-fel 2006 - 05 ] , desy , august 2006 .
n. simos , h. g. kirk and k. t. mcdonald , _ experimental study of radiation damage in carbon composites and graphite considered as targets in the neutrino super beam _ , http://accelconf.web.cern.ch/accelconf/e08/papers/mopc093.pdf[conf .
c 0806233 ( 2008 ) mopc093 ] .
b. j. marsden ( editor ) , _ irradiation damage in graphite due to fast neutrons in fission and fusion systems _ , http://www-pub.iaea.org/mtcd/publications/pdf/te_1154_prn.pdf[iaea-tecdoc-1154 ] ,
september 2000 .
s. riemann , p. sievers , a. ushakov , _ status of target and photon collimator work for polarized positrons _ ,
http://agenda.linearcollider.org/event/6389/session/9/contribution/248/material/slides/[talk ] given at the international workshop on future linear colliders ( lcws14 ) , belgrade , serbia , october 2014 . | high energy @xmath0linear colliders are the next large scale project in particle physics .
they need intense sources to achieve the required luminosity .
in particular , the positron source must provide about 10@xmath1 positrons per second .
the positron source for the international linear collider ( ilc ) is based on a helical undulator passed by the electron beam to create an intense circularly polarized photon beam . with these photons a longitudinally polarized positron beam is generated ; the degree of polarization can be enhanced by collimating the photon beam
. however , the high photon beam intensity causes huge thermal load in the collimator material . in this paper the thermal load in the photon collimator is discussed and a flexible design solution is presented . |
the development of waveguide optical amplifiers based on rare earth ( re ) doped silicon based matrix is of great interest for the semiconductor research community@xcite .
erbium ions are particularly interesting due to an optical transition at @xmath9 which coincides with the maximum of transmission in optical glass fiber@xcite . however , in the case of erbium this transition involves the ground level , which may limit the achievable gain due to reabsorption mechanisms@xcite . to overcome this critical issue , neodymium ion has been recently proposed because its emission scheme makes it more suitable for achieving higher gain@xcite . in such a system , the amplification is commonly achieved through re level population inversion by an appropriate optical pumping .
one main drawback of re ions is their low absorption cross section .
however this can be overcome by the use of sensitizers that are characterized by a larger absorption cross section .
those sensitizers have shown an efficient transfer of energy to re ions in their vicinity .
several sensitizers of re have been proposed in literature .
et al _ @xcite shows the sensitization of @xmath1ions by different kinds of sensitizers such as ytterbium ions , metal ions and silicon nanograins ( si - ng ) .
the work of macdonald _ et al _ @xcite presents the sensitization of @xmath0ions by si - ng .
in this paper we present a comparative study of waveguides with an active layer containing si - ng and doped either with erbium or neodymium ions .
the typical composition and structure of such waveguides is presented in section [ description waveguide ] .
the electromagnetic field and level populations of si - ng and re ions have been computed using an algorithm published in a previous paper @xcite and briefly detailed in section [ calculation method ] . in section [ rare earth ] , we describe levels populations equations associated with si - ng , erbium ions and neodymium ions . for the two re ions , due to their different transition time properties , two particular ways of calculation will be detailed . in section
[ results ] , we present for both re population inversions , population map and optical gain as a function of optical pump power .
we conclude by the comparison of the optical gain of two waveguides doped either with erbium or neodymium ions as a function of the pump power . or @xmath1ions.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] the waveguide is composed of three layers ( fig .
[ waveguide ] ) .
the bottom cladding layer is composed of pure silica . in order to ensure optical confinement of modes , this layer is about 5 to 8 @xmath10 m thick in a typical experimental waveguide doped either with @xmath0ions @xcite or @xmath1ions @xcite . in this modeling method
the thickness of bottom cladding layer was taken equal to @xmath11 in order to limit the use of memory .
the @xmath12 active layer constituted of silicon rich silicon oxide ( srso ) contains si - ng and re ions .
a pure silica strip layer is stacked on the top of the srso layer . the static refractive index (
_ i.e. _ refractive index which remains constant with wavelength ) of the active layer ( @xmath13 ) has been chosen greater than the one of the strip and bottom cladding layers ( @xmath14 ) to ensure the guiding conditions . in order to investigate which is the most suitable re between @xmath0and @xmath1for achieving high gain ,
both waveguides are pumped continuously ( cw ) by the propagation in the active layer of a pump mode at 488 nm .
a signal mode is co - propagated in the active layer in order to investigate the achievability of amplification by stimulated emission .
this signal corresponds to a transition occurring between electronics levels of re , either at 1532 nm for erbium ions or at 1064 nm for neodymium ions@xcite .
the waveguide dimensions are identical for erbium or neodymium ions and according to the experimental conditions we propagate the fundamental transverse electric mode ( @xmath15 ) for the pump and signal along z direction .
the calculation and the injection of mode profiles in ade - fdtd method for all wavelengths considered here are described in our previous paper@xcite .
the electromagnetic fields ( @xmath16 ) and poynting vector ( @xmath17 ) as well as re and si - ng populations in steady state are computed by the algorithm described by fafin et al@xcite .
this algorithm is based on finite - difference time - domain method ( fdtd ) and auxiliary differential equations ( ade ) .
the fdtd method consists in the discretization in time and space of the electromagnetic fields@xcite according to the k. yee algorithm@xcite .
the ade makes the link between electromagnetic fields and absorption and emission processes by the use of a set of polarisation densities @xmath18 following a lorentz electronic oscillator model@xcite . a typical polarisation equation ( eq .
( [ polarisation ] ) ) between two level populations @xmath19 and @xmath20 is described below : @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the transition linewidth including radiative , non - radiative and de - phasing processes@xcite , and @xmath23 is the resonance frequency of this transition .
@xmath24 used in @xcite depends on the transition lifetime @xmath25 and on the optical index n. the time evolution of levels populations for each emitter ( re , si - ng ) is described by a rate equation which depends on polarisation densities of considered transitions , lifetimes , transfer coefficient and levels populations . since in visible wavelength range
, the electromagnetic field has a characteristic time of the order of @xmath26 s and the levels populations of emitters have characteristic lifetimes as long as a few milliseconds @xcite , a classical ade - fdtd calculation is impossible in a reasonable time@xcite .
indeed with the classical ade - fdtd method the equations of populations are calculated simultaneously with the electromagnetic field leading to about @xmath27 iterations .
we have recently overcome this multiscale issue @xcite after splitting the classical ade - fdtd single loop into two interconnected loops separating short time and long time processes .
the electromagnetic fields and polarisation densities are calculated in the short time loop and the rate equations in the long time one .
this method allows us to reduce drastically the number of iterations from @xmath27 to @xmath28 and consequently reduces the calculation time to more reasonable duration ( 7 days for the present waveguide at bi - processors quad - core intel nehalem ep @ 2.8 ghz ) .
moreover , in order to minimize phase velocity error and velocity anisotropy errors inherent to the fdtd method , the algorithm was set up with the time and space steps introduced in our previous paper @xcite .
in this section we describe the excitation mechanism of the erbium and neodymium ions and the numerical calculation of the levels populations at the steady state . we model silicon nanograins ( si - ng ) as a two levels system ( fig .
[ schema excitation ] ) where the ground and excited levels populations ( respectively @xmath29 and @xmath30 ) are given by the rate equations eq .
( [ eq_si_0 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq_si_1 ] ) . due to a low probability of multi - exciton generation in a single si - ng @xcite
, we assume the excitation of one single exciton by si - ng , therefore the si - ng population will correspond to the exciton population .
after non - radiative transitions in the conduction band , the exciton may either radiatively recombine or excite an emitter in its vicinity .
this energy transfer may occur if the energy gap between conduction and valence band of si - ng matches the energy gap between the re fundamental level and an upper level leading to a possible emission . according to literature @xcite the lifetime of excited level @xmath30
is chosen at @xmath31 . since few papers studied the energy transfer coefficient in si - ng and erbium ions @xcite and to our knowledge
no study was made on this coefficient in si - ng and neodymium , this energy transfer coefficient between si - ng and both re is assumed identical and taken equal to @xmath32 .
we took the same concentration of si - ng equal to @xmath33 for both active layers doped either with @xmath1or @xmath0ions . in order to simulate a realistic absorption and emission cross section equal to @xmath34 the linewidth @xmath22 and the number of polarizations @xmath35
are respectively fixed to @xmath36 and 2756 according to the method explained in @xcite .
these parameters are reported in table [ silicon parameters ] .
@xmath37 @xmath38 .parameters levels of silicon nanograins [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ neodymium parameters ] we aim at calculating levels populations in steady states in a fast and convenient manner .
consequently , the preferred method would be an analytical calculation of populations by setting @xmath39 .
however , this is only applicable in case of neodymium levels equations .
moreover , the up - conversion term in erbium rate equations leads to equations that are hardly analytically solvable . in that case
, the steady states of population levels are reached by a finite difference method .
this calculation was possible using a reasonable time step of @xmath40 ten times lower than the shortest lifetime ( @xmath41 ) considered in this model .
the calculation time is then no longer negligible but does not rise up significantly the global calculation time of our ade - fdtd method .
the solution of eq . ( [ eq_si_0 ] ) to eq .
( [ eq_nd_0 ] ) gives the levels populations in their steady states .
we define for @xmath42 transition the population inversion ( section [ populations inversion ] ) as the ratio ( @xmath43 ) over the total population number ( @xmath44 for re or @xmath45 for si - ng ) .
we deduced also the optical gain ( section [ optical gain ] ) at @xmath46 for @xmath0and @xmath47 for @xmath1 .
these values are computed for a pump power ranging from @xmath2 to @xmath3 .
we present in this section the spatial distribution of population inversion in waveguides doped either with erbium or neodymium ions for a pump power of @xmath48 in a longitudinal section view along the propagation axis ( fig .
[ populations re ] ) . for both waveguides
the plots show a decrease of population inversion with direction of propagation which can be attributed to the coupling between rare earth ions and silicon nanograins . ,
title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.0% ] , title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.0% ] for erbium ions , the population inversion remains positive over a length of @xmath49 . beyond this length ,
the population inversion becomes negative witnessing the threshold effect occurring with three - level system . for neodymium ions the population inversion remains positive along the whole structure .
indeed , in this four - level system , the level 1 is depopulated quickly to the ground level leading to @xmath50 .
we now consider the population inversion distribution of si - ng presented in longitudinal section view in fig .
[ populations si ] for both re .
this decrease of population inversion of si - ng shows an identical behaviour with direction of propagation as the one observed with re .
this is characteristic of the pump strong absorption due to the presence of the nanograins as shown in our previous paper @xcite . ,
title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.0% ] , title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.0% ] from fig .
[ populations si ] we extract a particular set of values of the population inversion of si - ng along the direction of propagation recorded at @xmath51 and @xmath52 ( center of the xy section of the active layer ) ( fig .
[ populations si z ] ) . on this figure
, we observe along the whole length of the waveguide a larger si - ng population inversion with erbium than with neodymium . since the si - ng modeling is the same with both re , the population inversion difference is due to each specific si - ng / re interaction .
this interaction is governed by the transfer coefficient k , which is the same for both re , but also by specific transitions lifetimes of each re .
the larger population inversion observed for erbium than with neodymium is consequently due to the difference of lifetimes between these re ( table [ erbium parameters ] and [ neodymium parameters ] ) .
this observation leads us to the conclusion that re excitation occurring from si - ng is more efficient in the case of neodymium than in the case of erbium ions due to the specific time dynamics of transitions in different re . and
@xmath52 ( center of the xy section of the active layer ) for a pump power equal to @xmath53,scaledwidth=80.0% ] figure [ population_inversion ] shows the influence of pump power on population inversion for the erbium and the neodymium ions as well as for the si - ng .
we observe that the population inversion occurs above a threshold pump power ( @xmath54 ) for erbium .
this behaviour is typical of a three - level system . for neodymium ions ,
we observe a positive population inversion for the whole pump power range which is characteristic of a four - level system . for high pump power ( @xmath55 )
, both populations inversions reach a comparable value witnessing the saturation of the excitation mechanism .
finally , we plot ( dotted lines ) the population inversion of si - ng as a function of pump power . whatever the pump power , this inversion is higher for erbium than for neodymium ions .
this evidences a more efficient transfer from si - ng to neodymium ions than to erbium ions . )
recorded at @xmath51 and @xmath52 ( center of the xy section of the active layer ) and z=0 ( beginning of the waveguide),scaledwidth=80.0% ] from population levels @xmath56 we deduced the local gross gain per unit length @xmath57 ( eq .
( [ gain ] ) ) at the signal wavelength : @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are respectively the higher and lower levels of the considered transition and @xmath61 and @xmath62 are absorption and emission cross sections .
for erbium ions , we make the link @xmath63 and @xmath64 and for neodymium ions @xmath65 and @xmath66 and we assume equal emission and absorption cross sections for one re .
the local gross gain per unit length recorded at @xmath51 and @xmath52 ( center of the xy section of the active layer ) and @xmath67 ( beginning of the waveguide ) is plotted in fig .
[ figure gain ] .
( open circle ) and a waveguide doped with @xmath1(open square ) recorded at @xmath51 and @xmath52 ( center of the xy section of the active layer ) and @xmath67 ( beginning of the waveguide ) .
losses found by pirasteh _
et al _ @xcite are represented ( dashed line).,scaledwidth=80.0% ] for @xmath1doped waveguide , we find that , above a threshold pump power of @xmath68 , a positive gross gain is reached which increases up to @xmath5 for the highest pump power simulated in our study . in order to estimate the net gain , we must account for the background losses such as those found by navarro - urrios _ et al _
@xcite on comparable samples ( @xmath69 at @xmath9 ) .
we can conclude that it is not possible to reach a positive net gain in this range of pump power .
however navarro - urrios _ et al _ found a positive net gain equal to @xmath70 , this small difference with our modelling result may be explained by higher pump power that was used in the experiment ( @xmath71 to @xmath72 ) . for @xmath0doped waveguide
, we find that the optical gain remains positive over the whole power range .
it increases up to @xmath4 for the highest pump power of @xmath73 .
we can also estimate a net gain taking into account background losses of @xmath74 found by pirasteh _
et al _ in a similar system@xcite .
figure [ figure gain ] shows that for a pump power above @xmath75 the losses ( dashed line ) can be compensated leading to a net gain . the gross gain per unit length obtained for @xmath0remains higher that the one obtained for @xmath1whatever the pump power range . the gross gain per unit length difference ( between @xmath0and @xmath1doped waveguide )
is all the higher as the pump power increases .
this feature may be due to the difference in si - ng / re transfer efficiency ( section [ populations inversion ] ) linked to the levels dynamics as well as to the difference in absorption / emission cross section ( @xmath76 against @xmath77 ) .
the three categories of commercially available optical amplifier on c - band ( edfa , edwa and soa ) present a gain level about 20 to 25 db with a working length ranging from cm to few meters for edfa and for a power consumption mainly dedicated to optical or electrical pumping of about few watts @xcite . since we found a low gain and a short length of positive population inversion by modeling of @xmath1doped based waveguide on the broad range of pump power .
we conclude to the impossibility of achievement of an optical amplifier with this configuration of co - propagating pump and signal which would compete with commercially available systems .
the gross gain per unit length reachable with @xmath0 , about one order of magnitude larger than the one obtained with @xmath1 , could lead a significant amplification . to our knowledge
, there is no commercially available comparable optical amplifier based on nd3 + emission bands . however , @xmath0doped aluminum oxide channel waveguide amplifiers developed by yang _
et al _ show a maximal internal gain of 6 db / cm for a pump power of 45 mw@xcite .
our algorithm based on ade - fdtd method previously used for modeling steady states of fields , population levels and gross gain per unit length for @xmath0doped waveguide has been extended with success to the case of erbium ions doped waveguide .
we have demonstrated that the neodymium ions are more suitable than the erbium ions to obtain a net positive gain per unit length in silica based waveguide containing silicon nanograins . the theoretical maximum gross gain per unit length of @xmath5 at 1532 nm ( @xmath73 ) does not compensate background losses experimentally estimated to @xmath78 . on the contrary
, the use of neodymium ions leads to a gross gain per unit length of @xmath4 at 1064 nm ( @xmath73 ) .
moreover the background losses are compensated above a pump power threshold of @xmath75 .
this theoretical demonstration of a large gross gain per unit length for a @xmath0doped active layer may justify further experimental work in order to achieve @xmath0doped silicon based waveguide optical amplifier or laser . in order to investigate the possibility of achieving larger gain
further studies may be performed with other concentrations of rare earth and si - ng , other rare earth and other pumping configurations .
this method may be applied to study the electromagnetic fields and levels populations distribution in steady states of systems with other kind of emitters ( quantum dots , quantum wells ... ) and in other configuration ( vcels , down - converting layers ... ) .
the authors are grateful to the french nation research agency , which supported this work through the nanoscience and nanotechnology program ( daphnes project anr-08-nano-005 ) and centre de ressources informatiques de haute - normandie , ( crihan france ) for computing facilities . | we present a comparative study of the gain achievement in a waveguide whose active layer is constituted by a silica matrix containing silicon nanograins acting as sensitizer of either neodymium ions ( @xmath0 ) or erbium ions ( @xmath1 ) . by means of an auxiliary differential equation and finite difference time domain ( ade - fdtd )
approach that we developed , we investigate the steady states regime of both rare earths ions and silicon nanograins levels populations as well as the electromagnetic field for different pumping powers ranging from @xmath2 to @xmath3 .
moreover , the achievable gain has been estimated in this pumping range .
the @xmath0doped waveguide shows a higher gross gain per unit length at 1064 nm ( up to @xmath4 ) than the one with @xmath1doped active layer at 1532 nm ( up to @xmath5 ) . taking into account the experimental background losses we demonstrate that a significant positive net gain can only be achieved with the @xmath0doped waveguide .
10 n. daldosso and l. pavesi , nanosilicon photonics , " laser photonics rev . * 3 * , 508534 ( 2009 ) . g. p. agrawal , ( john wiley & sons , 2010 )
. o. lumholt , a. bjarklev , t. rasmussen , and c. lester , rare earth - doped integrated glass components : modeling and optimization , " j. lightwave technol . *
13 * , 275282 ( 1995 ) .
a. podhorodecki , j. misiewicz , f. gourbilleau , j. cardin , and c. dufour , high energy excitation transfer from silicon nanocrystals to neodymium ions in silicon - rich oxide film , " electrochem . solid - state lett .
* 13 * , k26k28 ( 2010 ) .
a. polman and f. c. j. m. van veggel , broadband sensitizers for erbium - doped planar optical amplifiers : review , " j. opt .
. am .
b * 21 * , 871892 ( 2004 )
. a. n. macdonald , a. hryciw , quan li , and a. meldrum , luminescence of nd - enriched silicon nanoparticle glasses , " opt . mater . * 28 * , 820824 ( 2006 ) .
a. fafin , j. cardin , c. dufour , and f. gourbilleau , modeling of the electromagnetic field and level populations in a waveguide amplifier : a multi - scale time problem , " opt .
express * 21 * , 2417124184 ( 2013 ) .
p. pirasteh , j. charrier , y. dumeige , y. g. boucher , o. debieu , and f. gourbilleau , study of optical losses of nd@xmath6 doped silicon rich silicon oxide for laser cavity , " thin solid films * 520 * , 40264030 ( 2012 ) .
n. daldosso , d. navarro - urrios , m. melchiorri , c. garcia , p. pellegrino , b. garrido , c. sada , g. battaglin , f. gourbilleau , r. rizk , and l. pavesi , er - coupled si nanocluster waveguide , " ieee j. sel . topics quantum electron . * 12 * , 16071617 ( 2006 ) .
w. l. barnes , r. laming , e. j. tarbox , and p. r. morkel , absorption and emission cross section of er3 + doped silica fibers , " ieee j. quantum .
electron .
* 27 * , 10041010 ( 1991 ) .
e. o. serqueira , n. o. dantas , a. f. g. monte , and m. j. v. bell ,
judd ofelt calculation of quantum efficiencies and branching ratios of nd3 + doped glasses , " j. non - cryst .
solids * 352 * , 36283632 ( 2006 ) .
a. taflove , .
( artech house , boston , 1995 ) .
k. yee , numerical solution of initial boundary value problems involving maxwell s equations in isotropic media , " ieee trans .
antennas propag .
* 14 * , 302307 ( 1966 ) .
a. s. nagra and r. a. york , fdtd analysis of wave propagation in nonlinear absorbing and gain media , " ieee trans .
antennas propag .
* 46 * , 334340 ( 1998 ) . c. dufour , j. cardin , o. debieu , a. fafin , and f. gourbilleau ,
electromagnetic modeling of waveguide amplifier based on nd@xmath6 si - rich sio2 layers by means of the ade - fdtd method , " nanoscale res .
lett .
* 6 * , 15 ( 2011 ) .
a. j. kenyon , c. e. chryssou , c. w. pitt , t. shimizu - iwayama , d. e. hole , n. sharma , and c. j. humphreys , luminescence from erbium - doped silicon nanocrystals in silica : excitation mechanisms , " j. appl .
phys . * 91 * , 367374 ( 2002 ) .
b. j. ainslie , s. p. craig , r. wyatt , and k. moulding , optical and structural analysis of neodymium - doped silica - based optical fibre , " matter .
lett .
* 8 * , 204208 ( 1989 ) .
m. govoni , i. marri , and s. ossicini , carrier multiplication between interacting nanocrystals for fostering silicon - based photovoltaics , " nat .
photonics * 6 * , 672679 ( 2012 ) .
f. priolo , g. franzo , d. pacifici , v. vinciguerra , f. iacona , and a. irrera , role of the energy transfer in the optical properties of undoped and er - doped interacting si nanocrystals , " j. appl . phys . * 89 * , 264272 ( 2001 ) .
d. pacifici , g. franzo , f. priolo , f. iacona , and l. dal negro , modeling and perspectives of the si nanocrystals - er interaction for optical amplification , " phys .
rev .
b * 67 * , 245301 ( 2003 ) .
v. toccafondo , s. faralli , and f. di pasquale , evanescent multimode longitudinal pumping scheme for si - nanocluster sensitized er@xmath7 doped waveguide amplifiers , " j. lightwave technol .
* 26 * , 35843591 ( 2008 ) .
s. l. oliveira , d. f. de sousa , a. a. andrade , l. a. o. nunes , and t. catunda , upconversion in nd@xmath6-doped glasses : microscopic theory and spectroscopic measurements , " j. appl .
phys . * 103 * , 023103 ( 2008 ) .
j. yang , k. van dalfsen , f. ay and m. pollnau , high - gain al2o3 : nd3 + channel waveguide amplifiers at 880 nm , 1060 nm , and 1330 nm , " appl .
phys .
b * 101 * , 119127 ( 2010 ) . a. e. siegman . .
( university science books , 1986 ) .
h .- s .
han , s .- y .
seo , j. h. shin , and n. park , coefficient determination related to optical gain in erbium - doped silicon - rich silicon oxide waveguide amplifier , " appl . phys .
lett . *
81 * , 37203722 ( 2002 ) .
n. daldosso , d. navarro - urrios , m. melchiorri , l. pavesi , f. gourbilleau , m. carrada , r. rizk , c. garcia , p. pellegrino , b. garrido , and l. cognolato , absorption cross section and signal enhancement in er - doped si nanocluster rib - loaded waveguides , " appl .
phys .
lett . *
86 * , 261103 ( 2005 ) .
d. navarro - urrios , f. ferrarese lupi , n. prtljaga , a. pitanti , o. jambois , j. m. ramirez , y. berencen , n. daldosso , b. garrido , and l. pavesi , copropagating pump and probe experiments on si - nc in sio@xmath8 rib waveguides doped with er : the optical role of non - emitting ions , " appl .
phys .
lett . * 99 * , 231114 ( 2011 ) .
d. r. zimmerman and l. h. spiekman
amplifiers for the masses : edfa , edwa , and soa amplets for metro and access applications , " j. lightwave technol . *
22 * , 63 ( 2004 ) . |
manipulating spin degrees of freedom of electrons in addition to charge degrees is at the forefront of current materials science @xcite . by utilizing the spin hall effect ( she ) @xcite and the inverse spin hall effect ( ishe)@xcite ,
a variety of novel phenomena are envisioned @xcite .
for example , the spin current in magnetic materials can be generated by the temperature gradient , the spin seebeck effect ( sse ) @xcite .
unlike the conventional seebeck effect , the sse also exists in magnetic insulators ( mis ) @xcite in which the spin current is mediated by spin waves or magnons .
not only in a ferromagnetic ( fm ) insulator or a ferrimagnetic insulator , the spin transport is possible through an antiferromagnetic ( afm ) insulator @xcite .
further , magnetic excitations can be used for the transmission of the electrical signal through mis @xcite .
conventionally , these phenomena have been analyzed based on excitations or fluctuations from magnetic ordering @xcite .
however , recent studies demonstrate such phenomena even above magnetic transition temperatures : spin current generation @xcite and the sse @xcite .
thus , a new or extended concept which does not require magnetic ordering needs to be developed .
once this is established , it would extend the current scope of spintronics , allowing for example the transmission of electrical signals through _ paramagnetic insulators _
( pm insulators or pmis ) mediated by some form of magnetic fluctuations , which is appealing for both fundamental science and applications because it allows the transport of magnetic quanta for efficient information technologies . in this paper , we provide a simple description of the performance of a pmi / nomal metal ( nm ) interface by evaluating the spin current through the interface and the spin current conductance inside the pmi using auxiliary particle ( ap ) methods , some of which allow access to both pm and magnetic states . we find that the spin current injection at a pmi / nm interface is sensitive to temperature below a magnetic transition temperature @xmath0 [ @xmath1 for ferromagnet ( fm ) and @xmath2 for afm ] but weakly dependent on temperatures above @xmath0 .
the spin conductance due to magnetic fluctuations is found to be maximized around @xmath0 .
these findings suggest that a mi could function as a spintronics material even above its magnetic ordering temperature .
we consider mis described by the heisenberg model with the nearest neighbor ( nn ) exchange coupling @xmath3 and spin @xmath4 , @xmath5 with the negative sign for a fm and the positive sign for an afm . in order to describe mis below and above their magnetic transition temperature , we employ ap methods , schwinger boson ( sb ) as well as schwinger fermion ( sf ) mean - field ( mf ) methods @xcite .
our main focus is on the finite temperature properties of a simple model , not exotic properties at low temperatures such as spin liquids .
thus , we consider the simplest _ anstze _ for mf wave functions which do not break the underlying lattice symmetry .
these ap methods are suitable for magnetically disordered states because mf order parameters are defined on `` bonds , '' not on `` sites . ''
further , sb methods can also deal with magnetically ordered states because condensed sbs correspond to the ordered moments . here
, we briefly review ap mf methods . in these methods , spin operators
are expressed in terms of aps as @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath8 , with @xmath9 being the creation ( annihilation ) operator of an ap with spin @xmath10 at position @xmath11 . using these expressions and operator identities , the spin exchange term in eq .
( [ eq : hj ] ) is written as @xmath12 for schwinger bosons and @xmath13 for schwinger fermions @xcite . here
, constant terms are neglected , and @xmath14 and @xmath15 represent short - range magnetic correlations . then , the mf decoupling is introduced as @xmath16 .
thus , the negative sign in front of the operator product is essential , distinguishing the different interaction , fm or afm , and the statistics of the ap , boson or fermion .
consequently , the sb mf method for fm and the sf mf method for afm can be formulated in parallel , and the mf hamiltonian is given by @xmath17 here , @xmath18 is a unit vector connecting a nearest neighbor site in the positive direction , and constant terms are neglected .
@xmath19 is the lagrange multiplier enforcing the constraint for aps , @xmath20 ( for sfs , @xmath21 ) , and @xmath22 is the bond order parameter .
this mf hamiltonian is diagonalized to yield the dispersion relation for aps as @xmath23 , where @xmath24 .
similarly , the sb mf hamiltonian for an afm is given by @xmath25 here , the mf order parameter is @xmath26 .
the excitation spectrum is given by @xmath27 with @xmath28 .
since we are dealing with non - interacting particles under the mf approximation , it is straightforward to compute the green s functions of aps .
the green s function for fm sbs or afm sfs is given by @xmath29 .
in the matsubara frequency , @xmath30 for sb and @xmath31 for sf , this is expressed by @xmath32 the green s function for af sbs is given using the nambu representation by @xmath33 with @xmath34 . in the matsubara frequency
, this is expressed by the matrix @xmath35 \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{-1em}=\frac{1}{2 \omega_{\vec q } } \sum_{s = \pm 1 } \biggl(\frac{s}{i\nu_n - s \omega_{\vec q}}\biggr ) \left [ \begin{array}{cc } i\nu_n + \lambda & -i j\delta \gamma'_{\vec q } \\
i j\delta \gamma'_{\vec q } & -i\nu_n + \lambda \end{array } \right ] \hspace{-0.3em}. \label{eq : d2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in principle , mf order parameters , @xmath36 for fm sb and afm sf and @xmath37 for afm sb , must be fixed by solving self consistent equations .
however , it is known that there appear fictitious phase transitions above which order parameters disappear . in three - dimensional bosonic systems , this happens simultaneously with the disappearance of the boson condensation @xcite .
to avoid such fictitious phase transitions , we treat @xmath36 and @xmath37 as constants .
this approach may correspond to an effective mass approximation used in literature , but here the underling lattice with the discrete translational symmetry is maintained .
it should also be noted that these parameters would introduce additional temperature dependence at high temperatures because @xmath38 or @xmath39 roughly corresponds to @xmath40 .
since we are interested in the behavior of mis both below and above their transition temperatures , we focus on three - dimensional systems throughout this paper . , the electron reflection accompanied with the spin flip causes the spin flip for aps , resulting in interfacial spin current @xmath41 .
( b ) opposite process in which the reflection of aps accompanied with the spin flip causes the spin flip for electrons .
@xmath42 is the splitting in the chemical potential between up and down electrons ( aps ) in ( a ) [ ( b ) ] .
process ( b ) is also called spin extraction .
( c ) feynman diagram representing the spin current injection .
solid lines are propagators for electrons , while wavy lines are for aps .
dots represent @xmath43 . ]
_ spin - current injection at pmi / nm interfaces_. for the interfacial magnetic interaction , we consider the following exchange coupling : @xmath44 here , @xmath45 is the coupling constant and @xmath46 is the annihilation operator of an electron inside a nm with spin @xmath10 .
the summation over the momenta @xmath47 is taken independently assuming a rough interface , where the transverse components of momenta are not conserved .
there are two cases . when the splitting in the chemical potential @xmath48 exists for electrons in the nm region , this represents the electron reflection at the interface by exchanging spin with the pmi , transferring one spin quantum to the pmi region , fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] ( a ) .
@xmath49 corresponds to the spin voltage due to the spin accumulation induced externally by means of , for example , the spin hall effect @xcite . when the splitting in the chemical potential exists for aps in the pmi instead , this represents the reflection of aps at the interface by exchanging spin with the nm , transferring one spin quantum to the nm region , fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] ( b ) .
the former corresponds to the spin injection and the latter the spin extraction as discussed in ref .
@xcite . for concreteness
, we consider the spin injection by the spin splitting for electrons in the nm region [ fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] ( a ) ] . by the equation of motion for the spin moment inside the pm region , the interface spin current operator
is given by @xmath50 \nonumber \\ & = & \!\ ! -i j_{eff } \hspace{-0.7em } \sum_{\vec q , \vec q ' , \vec k , \vec k ' } \hspace{-0.7em } \bigl ( a_{\vec q \uparrow}^\dag a_{\vec q ' \downarrow } c_{\vec k
\downarrow}^\dag c_{\vec k ' \uparrow } - { \rm h. c. } \bigr ) \label{eq : eom}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , computing the spin current injected at an interface between a pmi and a nm is reduced to computing the following correlation function @xcite : @xmath51 $ ] .
the correlation function @xmath52 is conveniently computed by the analytic continuation of the imaginary - time correlation function with the bosonic matsubara frequency @xmath53 as @xmath54 with @xmath55 . using the wick theorem ,
this is reduced to @xmath56 with its diagrammatic representation shown in fig .
[ fig : cartoon ] ( c ) . here ,
@xmath57 and @xmath58 are the normal green s functions for conduction electrons and aps , respectively .
note that the anomalous green s function @xmath59 does not appear even for the afm sbs and this expression holds for all the cases considered here .
this is because @xmath60 involves the additional momentum dependence proportional to @xmath61 , and its contributions disappear by the @xmath62 integral . when the spin splitting is for aps in the pm region , the expression for the interface spin current , @xmath41 , is not changed , but the sign is reversed as seen from the equation of motion for the spin , eq .
( [ eq : eom ] ) . using the matsubara green s functions for conduction electrons @xmath63 with @xmath64 and
aps @xmath65 in eq .
( [ eq : d1 ] ) , it is straightforward to obtain @xmath66 [ n_b(\omega_{\vec q ' } - \omega_{\vec q } - \delta\mu ) \mp n_x(\omega_{\vec q ' } ) ] [ n_x(\omega_{\vec q } ) - n_x(\omega_{\vec q } + \delta\mu ) ] , \label{eq : jint1}\ ] ] for the fm sbs and the afm sfs . here , @xmath67 is the energy of a conduction electron with momentum @xmath68 .
@xmath69 for fm sbs and @xmath59 for afm sfs , and @xmath70^{-1}$ ] is the bose - einstein / fermi - dirac distribution function . as usual
, we approximated the momentum integral for electrons in the nm region by the energy @xmath67 integral near the fermi level assuming the constant density of states @xmath71 .
typical energy scales for @xmath72 and @xmath49 are much smaller than the electron fermi energy , allowing the replacement of @xmath73 by @xmath74 . by further taking the limit of @xmath75 , we arrive at @xmath76 , \label{eq : jint3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath77 . for the afm sb case , a similar calculation leads to @xmath78 [ n_b(s ' \omega_{\vec q ' } - s \omega_{\vec q } - \delta\mu ) - n_b(s ' \omega_{\vec q ' } ) ] [ n_b(s \omega_{\vec q } ) - n_b(s \omega_{\vec q } + \delta\mu ) ] .
\label{eq : jint4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , by expanding @xmath79 at @xmath80 and taking the limit of @xmath75 , we obtain @xmath81 .
\label{eq : jint5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] .
@xmath82 for fm sbs and afm sfs , while @xmath83 for afm sbs . for sbs , solid lines are for @xmath21 , broken lines @xmath84 , dotted lines @xmath85 .
the sf result is shown by a dash - dotted line .
bose condensation occurs at a temperature @xmath0 indicated by a triangle , below which all curves overlap because the temperature is scaled by @xmath36 or @xmath37 . ] in contrast to the magnon contribution discussed in ref .
@xcite , the above formulas involve additional bose or fermi factors as well as energy differences representing the exchange of spin between aps inside the pm region or electrons inside the nm region .
this is because the time - reversal symmetry is maintained even below the bose condensation temperature . as a consequence , for the fm case
, the spin injection is proportional to @xmath86 at low temperatures .
this can be easily seen as follows : first , momentum integrals @xmath87 are replaced by energy integrals @xmath88 with some upper cutoff and the sb density of states @xmath89 . then , the energy is rescaled as @xmath90 . at low temperatures , @xmath91 integrals
can be taken from 0 to infinity because of the bose - einstein distribution function , arriving at the leading term proportional to @xmath86 in eq .
( [ eq : jint3 ] ) .
by contrast , the @xmath92 behavior is predicted for fm insulator / nm interfaces by magnon contributions @xcite and similar behavior is experimentally confirmed for fm metal / nm interfaces @xcite . since the @xmath92 behavior is for the configuration where injected spin is parallel or antiparallel to the ordered moment , the current temperature dependence might be realized when the injected spin is perpendicular to the ordered moment .
the numerical results for the spin current injection @xmath41 are presented in fig .
[ fig : injection ] ( a ) for the fm model given by eq .
( [ eq : jint3 ] ) and fig .
[ fig : injection ] ( b ) for the afm model given by eq .
( [ eq : jint5 ] ) . for the afm model
, we plot both sb results with different @xmath4 and a sf result with @xmath21 . for the fm case
, @xmath41 rapidly decreases with decreasing temperature below the magnetic transition temperature indicated by a triangle .
this behavior is consistent with the analysis using a spin wave theory except for its power law . importantly
, this does not seem to depend on the sign of interaction , fm or afm , the methodology , sb or sf , or even the presence of magnetic ordering . at high temperatures , the results depend on the detail of the model and method , but
the qualitative behavior is again rather universal ; @xmath41 depends on temperature very weakly . for the afm sf , @xmath41 is flat above its characteristic temperature , @xmath93 , below which the afm correlation is increased .
the weak temperature dependence of @xmath41 comes from the competition between the factor @xmath94 originating from @xmath95 and the energy window available for exchanging spin , i.e. , the factor @xmath96 , whose contributions also increase with temperature . the temperature dependence for afm
sb is somewhat stronger than the other cases . this is because the pairing of sbs suppresses the spin fluctuation more efficiently .
_ spin conductivity_. the performance of devices consisting of a mi connected with nm electrodes does not only depend on the spin current injection discussed in the previous section but also on how injected spins transfer inside the mi or from one electrode to the other electrode through the mi .
this problem might require the treatment of nonequilibrium conditions including both nm regions and a mi region .
however , this treatment is so far only available at very low temperatures @xcite . here
, instead we discuss the spin conductivity of bulk mis .
combined with the spin injection discussed in the previous section , this should provide important insights into the performance of mi / nm systems .
we start from deriving the bulk spin current by the equation of motion for @xmath97 . under the mf approximation ,
the spin current on the bond ( @xmath98 , @xmath99 ) is expressed as @xmath100 for the fm sb and the afm sf cases and @xmath101 for the af sb case . in a momentum space ,
these spin current operators in the small-@xmath62 limit become @xmath102 for the fm sbs and the afm sfs and @xmath103 for the afm sbs .
the spin conductivity @xmath104 is obtained by using the standard kubo formula @xcite . for sb cases
, care must be taken for the condensed components of sbs , which represent the ordered moments not superconductivity @xcite .
while the condensed components could introduce novel spin superconductivity @xcite , this requires an additional theoretical or experimental setup , the planer spin anisotropy for fm or an external magnetic field for afm , and the analyses on the dynamics of the condensed components , which is beyond the scope of our study .
thus , we focus on the contribution from the fluctuating components to the spin conductivity , which is given by the analytic continuation of @xmath105 with @xmath106 . for fm sbs and afm sfs , the current - current correlation function @xmath107 has the well known form @xmath108 . for afm sbs ,
this is given by @xmath109 $ ] .
these correlation functions are diagramatically shown in fig . [
fig : bubble ] . without disorders and interactions ,
the conductivity consists of a delta function located at @xmath110 with the amplitude @xmath58 , i.e. , drude weight . for fm sbs and afm sfs , this is given by @xmath111 and for afm sb we find @xmath112 figure [ fig : conductance ] shows the numerical results for @xmath58 for the fm model ( a ) and the afm model ( b ) . for the afm model ,
both sb and sf results are shown . at high temperatures
, @xmath58 increases with decreasing temperature for all the cases .
but for sbs , @xmath58 is cutoff at the bose condensation or magnetic ordering indicated by triangles because the fluctuating components decrease rapidly ( the maximum of @xmath58 is located slightly above @xmath0 ) . these @xmath58 become zero at zero temperature , which is consistent with the results using the spin wave theory @xcite .
such a temperature behavior is analogous to that of the uniform magnetic susceptibility , maximizing or diverging at @xmath0 , as magnetic systems become most susceptible against external ( magnetic ) perturbations .
by contrast , the spin conductance does not diverge even for a fm .
this is because the spin current operator and the magnetic moment have the different momentum dependence or the form factor , see eqs .
( [ eq : j1 ] ) and ( [ eq : j2 ] ) , and only thermally populated sbs contribute to the spin conductance . within the mf approximation used here ,
afm sfs behave as non - interacting fermions .
thus , the conductance shows the standard behavior due to the thermal broadening . at finite temperatures
, @xmath58 decreases with increasing temperature roughly proportional to @xmath113 in all the cases .
in fact , @xmath114 is proportional to the mf order parameter , @xmath36 or @xmath37 , which should also have the @xmath115 dependence in principle .
since @xmath38 or @xmath39 is related to @xmath116 , roughly proportional to @xmath117 , @xmath58 is expected to be scaled as @xmath118 at much higher temperatures than the ordering temperature . when the effect of disorder or the gilbert dumping @xcite is to introduce a finite lifetime for aps , @xmath119 ( @xmath120 stands for quasiparticle ) , @xmath104 becomes a lorentzian as @xmath121 $ ] , and the dc conductivity becomes finite .
for the afm sb case , there appears additional continuum at finite frequencies extended up to @xmath122 because of the two particle creation / annihilation processes , which is analogous to the result of the spin wave theory @xcite .
we computed @xmath123 for afm sb with @xmath21 using the green s functions eq .
( [ eq : d2 ] ) analytically continued to the real frequency as @xmath124 with @xmath125 representing the finite self - energy .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig : conductance_w ] .
the low - frequency drude feature follows the temperature dependence of @xmath58 in fig .
[ fig : conductance ] ( b ) . at temperatures above @xmath126
, the continuum moves to high frequencies because the gap amplitude in the sb excitation spectra increases . within the theoretical model , the ap lifetime
would be induced by the particle - particle interactions and beyond mf effects .
the former might give a temperature dependence similar to that of the magnon lifetime due to the magnon - magnon interactions at low temperatures : inversely proportional to @xmath127 ^ 2 $ ] for fm , and inversely proportional to @xmath128 with @xmath129 a numerical constant for afm @xcite .
the lifetime due to the beyond mf effects and that due to the particle - particle interactions at elevated temperatures have not been evaluated .
but in analogy to the argument for doped mott insulators @xcite , these are expected to be a decreasing function of @xmath115 .
thus , the maximum near @xmath0 would remain in the spin conductance , but the sharp peak could broaden . for the spin conductance @xmath130 as a function of temperature for the fm cases ( a ) and the afm cases ( b ) .
@xmath131 for fm sbs and afm sfs , while @xmath132 for afm sbs .
triangles indicate the magnetic transition temperatures , @xmath1 for fm and @xmath2 for afm . ] for the afm sb with @xmath21 as a function of @xmath133 at various temperatures indicated .
afm ordering occurs below @xmath134 . here
, the finite imaginary part of the sb self - energy is introduced as @xmath135 . ]
now we discuss the implication of our results to related experiments .
shiomi and saitoh measured the inverse spin hall voltage @xmath136 of la@xmath137nimno@xmath138/pt devices and found that @xmath136 is peaked around @xmath1 for fm la@xmath137nimno@xmath138 which generates spin current by spin pumping @xcite . meanwhile ,
et al . _ performed a similar experiment on y@xmath139fe@xmath140o@xmath141/coo / pt devices , where afm coo is inserted as a spacer , and found that @xmath136 is peaked around @xmath2 for coo @xcite . in the latter experiment
, it was argued that the enhancement of @xmath136 comes from the temperature dependence of the spin conductance in coo .
our results on the spin conductance strongly support this conjecture .
the additional strong suppression of @xmath136 at low temperatures might come from the temperature dependence of the spin injection at interfaces with afm coo . on the other hand ,
it was argued that a similar enhancement is due to the broadening of the microwave resonance shape as there is no spacer layer between the spin current generator la@xmath137nimno@xmath138 and the detector pt in ref .
our results suggest that both the spin conductivity in la@xmath137nimno@xmath138 and the spin injection at the interfaces contribute to @xmath136 especially at high temperatures as the generated spin current has to propagate inside la@xmath137nimno@xmath138 and from la@xmath137nimno@xmath138 to pt .
et al . _ also measured the dependence of @xmath136 on the the microwave frequency @xmath142 for the spin pumping . at @xmath2 , @xmath136
is reduced by a factor of 4 from @xmath143 ghz to @xmath144 ghz . assuming @xmath144 ghz corresponds to the inverse of the sb life time @xmath119 , one estimates @xmath145 mev .
since the typical magnetic coupling is 10100 mev , it is reasonable that only the drude feature is detectable in the ghz range . in ref .
@xcite , wu _ et al .
_ report that the voltage response due to the pm sse is proportional to @xmath146 with @xmath1474 .
our results indicate that a part of this temperature dependence is from the intrinsic temperature dependence of the spin conductivity in a pmi and the spin injection at the interface .
however , detailed analyses for this experiment require even more information , such as the temperature dependence of order parameters , the lifetime of aps due to disorder , particle - particle interactions , and the interactions with phonons . as related subjects , there have appeared some theoretical proposals to detect novel electronic states of spin liquid systems by interfacing with conventional systems .
references @xcite proposed a similar experimental setup , the injection of spin current into a mi , to detect spinon or magnon excitation spectra inside the insulator .
their focus is the voltage dependence of the spin injection through a clean interface at low temperatures . on the other hand ,
our focus is rather the temperature dependence of the spin injection through a rough interface where momentum transfer is not conserved .
thus , it should be experimentally more easily accessible .
reference @xcite considered a junction consisting of a spin liquid insulator sandwiched by two fms .
they proposed that a spinon fermi surface could induce a characteristic oscillatory behavior in the magnetic coupling between the two fms as a function of the thickness of the spin liquid spacer . in our case ,
a magnetic coupling between nm and pmi is rather dynamical , the injection of spin current in or out of pmi .
further , we focused on the universal behavior of pmi described by both bosonic and fermionic aps , which do not necessarily have a fermi surface .
in contrast to metal- or semiconductor - based magnetic interfaces as widely discussed in the literature @xcite , mi / nm interfaces do not necessarily accompany the charge accumulation inside a magnetic region when injecting or extracting spins . instead ,
when the interface spin accumulation exists , the lagrange multiplier or the local chemical potential , enforcing the local constraint @xmath148 , may have to be fixed accordingly using techniques developed for inhomogeneous magnetic systems @xcite .
one of the interesting directions is combining techniques developed in refs . @xcite and applying them to nanostructures with the spin injector , detector , and a magnetic / pm insulator ; similar structures are originally proposed in ref . @xcite .
such nanostructures might be useful to measure the spin diffusion length in magnetic / pm insulators .
to summarize , we have presented rather simple descriptions to understand the spin current injection at a paramagnetic insulator / normal metal interface and the spin current transport inside a paramagnetic or magnetic insulator based on the schwinger boson and schwinger fermion mean - field theories .
both the spin current injection @xmath41 and spin current transport @xmath58 show rather universal behaviors irrespective of the sign of the magnetic coupling , fm or afm , and methodology : @xmath41 depends on temperature rather weakly above magnetic transition temperature , while it decreases rapidly with decreasing temperature below the transition temperature .
similarly , @xmath58 decreases with increasing temperature above the transition temperature , and rapidly decreases with decreasing temperature below the transition temperature .
these findings suggest that there is an optimal temperature window for the performance of a magnetic insulator / normal metal junction around the magnetic transition temperature of the constituent magnetic insulator .
such a device would potentially function even above the magnetic transition temperature .
the current results support the conjecture of ref . @xcite
the enhancement of @xmath136 around @xmath2 is mainly due to the spin - current transport by thermal magnons inside an afm spacer and suggest that a similar mechanism contributes to the enhancement of @xmath136 around @xmath1 of a fm insulator used for the spin current generator without a spacer @xcite
. it would be also interesting to analyze nonequilibrium situations in which a magnetic insulator is sandwiched by two normal metals @xcite with different spin accumulations and temperatures .
our approach would provide some useful insights into the phenomena reported in ref .
@xcite . finally , further experimental tests for the frequency - dependent spin conductance , as also predicted in ref .
@xcite , would be desirable , but experimental techniques remain to be developed . s.o .
thanks a. bhattacharya , s. takahashi , n. nagaosa , s. maekawa , d. xiao , d. hou , z. qiu and e. saitoh for fruitful discussions .
the research by s.o . is supported by the u.s .
department of energy , office of science , basic energy sciences , materials sciences and engineering division .
m. i. dyakonov and v. i. perel , phys .
a35 * , 459 ( 1971 ) .
j. e. hirsch , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 1834 ( 1999 ) .
s. zhang , phys .
* 85 * , 393 ( 2000 ) .
s. murakami , n. nagaosa , and s. c. zhang , science * 301 * , 1348 ( 2003 ) .
j. sinova , d. culcer , q. niu , n. a. sinitsyn , t. jungwirth , and a. h. macdonald , phys .
* 92 * , 126603 ( 2004 ) . | we investigate the spin injection and the spin transport in paramagnetic insulators described by simple heisenberg interactions using auxiliary particle methods . some of these methods allow access to both paramagnetic states above magnetic transition temperatures and magnetic states at low temperatures .
it is predicted that the spin injection at an interface with a normal metal is rather insensitive to temperatures above the magnetic transition temperature . on the other hand below the transition temperature ,
it decreases monotonically and disappears at zero temperature .
we also analyze the bulk spin conductance .
it is shown that the conductance becomes zero at zero temperature as predicted by linear spin wave theory but increases with temperature and is maximized around the magnetic transition temperature .
these findings suggest that the compromise between the two effects determines the optimal temperature for spintronics applications utilizing magnetic insulators . |
the imaging atmospheric cherenkov technique ( iact ) was developed at the fred lawrence whipple observatory ( flwo ) resulting in the first very high energy ( vhe ; e @xmath0 100 gev ) detection of the crab nebula in 1989 @xcite . in the twenty years since that first publication
there have been vhe detections of over 100 objects including pulsars , blazars , pulsar wind nebula , supernova remnants and starburst galaxies . since vhe photons
do not penetrate the atmosphere , iact telescopes measure the cherenkov light generated by particle showers initiated by the primary photons interacting with our atmosphere .
this cherenkov light appears as a two dimensional ellipse when imaged by an iact telescope camera .
the shape and orientation of the ellipse in the camera indicate whether the shower was initiated by a gamma ray or by a cosmic ray which can also cause a particle shower .
the current generation of iact instruments involve arrays of telescopes .
the addition of multiple telescopes allows for a more accurate determination of the shower parameters .
one of the most powerful aspects of this technique is that the light pool of the shower defines the collection area ( @xmath1 ) which is more than adequate to compensate for the low flux of vhe gamma rays .
currently there are four major experiments in operation , hess , an array of four iact telescopes located in namibia , magic , an array of two telescopes located in the canary islands , veritas in southern arizona and cangaroo in australia .
magic just completed a major upgrade by adding a single telescope and stereo trigger and hess is in the process of building an additional very large telescope .
this contribution details part of the ongoing upgrade program being undertaken by the veritas collaboration .
veritas @xcite is an array of four 12 m diameter iact telescopes located in southern arizona at the flwo at an altitude of 1268 m. veritas detects photons from astrophysical sources at energies between 100 gev and 30 tev .
the veritas telescopes consist of four identical alt - az mounted davies - cotton reflectors with an f number of 1.0 .
the mirror area is approximately 106 m@xmath2 . mounted in the focal plane
is a camera made up of 499 pixels consisting of 28 mm photonis phototubes .
veritas has a three level trigger , the first at the pixel level , the second is a pattern trigger which triggers when any three adjacent pixels trigger . finally , an array trigger fires if any 2 or more telescopes trigger within a set time frame . for more details on the veritas hardware ,
see @xcite . for historical reasons , telescopes 1 and 4
were erected in close ( @xmath335 m ) proximity . even though veritas met all of its original design specifications , this resulted in a significant collection area overlap and increased background due to cosmic rays and local muons .
in fact , all of the published veritas analysis included a cut that rejected events that only triggered telescopes 1 and 4 .
simulations performed in the summer of 2008 suggested up to a 15% improvement in sensitivity if telescope 1 was moved @xmath3200 m eastward from its initial position . assuming that telescopes 1 and 4 are redundant and can be considered a single telescope , a 1/3 improvement is expected by adding an additional telescope .
based on these data , it was decided to relocate telescope 1 to a more ideal location providing a more symmetrical layout to the veritas array ( see figures [ fig : layout ] and [ fig : layout - schematic ] ) .
it was decided to relocate telescope 1 instead of telescope 4 to allow for the refurbishment of the oldest telescope in the array which was originally installed at the flwo as a prototype in 2002 .
the relocation of telescope 1 is part of an ongoing upgrade program @xcite which recently included an improvement in the optical point spread function ( psf ) @xcite .
the improvement in the optical psf was accomplished using a novel mirror alignment system which resulted in a 25 - 30% improvement in the psf .
this optical psf improvement also contributes to the enhancement in sensitivity discussed here and can not be disentangled from the overall results .
the move of telescope 1 combined with the improvement in the optical psf has resulted in making veritas the most sensitive vhe telescope array in the world capable of detected a 1% crab nebula signal in less than 30 hours .
since veritas does not operate during the summer months ( approximately july through august ) , the move of telescope 1 was scheduled to take place during this time to minimize the impact on the observing program .
telescope 1 was shutdown 6 weeks early ( may 4 , 2009 ) so that it would be operational by the first of october .
the move was completed on september 4 , 2009 and is estimated to have taken 2600 person hours of labor .
ten days later on the @xmath4 scheduled operations began with the full array , over two weeks earlier than expected . by september @xmath5
normal operations had resumed . in total , veritas only lost 6 weeks of full four telescope operations and these were with the old array layout .
the final array layout , while not entirely symmetric , is a much better layout for a vhe instrument .
figure [ fig : layout ] shows an aerial view of the veritas array with the old layout shown in blue and the new layout in red . while the old layout had inter - telescope distances ranging from 35 m to 127 m , the new layout distances range from 81 m to 127 m. figure [ fig : layout - schematic ] shows a schematic representation of the array viewed from directly above . also shown as a black arrow is the relocation of telescope 1 .
veritas data are calibrated and cleaned initially as described in @xcite . after calibration
several noise - reducing cuts are made .
the veritas standard analysis consists of parametrization using a moment analysis @xcite and following this , the calculation of scaled parameters are used for event selection @xcite .
this selection consists of different sets of gamma - ray cuts , determined _ a priori_. depending on the strength and expected spectral index of a source , different cuts are chosen .
for example , a source with the strength of the crab would use a looser set of cuts than a week source at the 1% crab flux level .
these two sets of cuts are called loose and hard cuts .
additionally , soft and standard versions of these cuts are used for soft ( approximately spectral indices of 3 and above ) or standard ( crab - like 2.5 spectral index sources ) .
the choice of which cuts to use are determined prior to the analysis .
figure [ fig : time ] shows the observation time needed to detect an object at the 5 standard deviation ( @xmath6 ) level . before the relocation of telescope 1 , a 1% crab flux source could be detected in 48 hours while after the move it only takes 28 hours loose cuts .
similarly , it takes 72 seconds to detect the crab nebula after the move with hard cuts , as opposed to 108 seconds before the move . level vs. that source s flux in units of the crab nebula s flux .
this is shown for the original array layout and for the new array layout with two different sets of event selection cuts .
note that it would take 48 hours to detect a 1% crab source with the original array layout and only 28 hours with the new array layout.,width=245 ] another way of looking at the sensitivity of vhe instruments is to calculate the integral flux sensitivity above a energy threshold .
shown in figure [ fig : sensitivity ] are the integral flux sensitivity vs. energy threshold for several different instruments . in red
is the original veritas layout while the new veritas layout is shown in black ( based on crab observations ; the dashed sections are under evaluation ) .
the integral flux sensitivity of veritas above 300 gev is @xmath7 better after the move .
this corresponds directly to a 60% reduction in the time needed to detect a source ( for example , a 50 hour observation before the move is equivalent to a 30 hour post move observation ) . for comparison
are shown the initial hess sensitivity @xcite shown as the blue dashed line ( note that this is the original hess sensitivity curve before any mirror reflectivity degradations ) .
the integral sensitivity of a single magic - i telescope is shown as the green dashed line .
another thing to note is that the sensitivity of veritas has slightly degraded at the lower end due to the loss of sensitivity to the lowest energy showers .
is shown as the green dashed line .
note that the integral flux sensitivity improvement of veritas above 300 gev is @xmath7.,width=245 ] figure [ fig : resolution ] shows the energy resolution of the veritas array as well as the angular resolution .
these two features are similar to the numbers calculated for the original veritas array layout .
both plots are for observations at 70 degrees elevation . the angular resolution and energy resolution change for observations undertaken at different elevations .
the veritas collaboration relocated telescope 1 and dramatically improved the optical psf during the summer of 2009 as part of an ongoing upgrade program .
these studies indicate that the upgrades have improved the sensitivity of veritas by 30% resulting in a 60% change in the time needed to detect a source .
the higher sensitivity achieved with veritas allows the detection of more objects in a shorter amount of time , effectively doubling the observation time .
the ability to detect marginal sources such as m82 and to do deep observations of known objects has drastically improved .
in addition to the telescope relocation and optical psf improvements , there are several other upgrade plans being discussed which are described in @xcite and are planned to be implemented in the next few years .
these upgrade plans include the installation of higher efficiency photon detectors which would result in a 17% improvement in the sensitivty of the array and/or the installation of a topological trigger which would consist of transmitting image parameters from the camera directly to the array trigger allowing for real - time event classification for gamma / hadron separation .
in addition to these baseline upgrades , the expansion of the array by adding more telescopes or an active mirror alignment system is also possible .
this ongoing upgrade program , beginning with the optical psf improvement and the relocation of telescope 1 will continue to make veritas competitive in the coming decade .
this research is supported by grants from the u.s .
department of energy , the u.s . national science foundation , and the smithsonian institution , by nserc in canada , by pparc in the uk and by science foundation ireland .
the veritas collaboration acknowledges the hard work and dedication of the flwo support staff in making the relocation of telescope 1 possible .
j. holder , v. a. acciari , e. aliu , t. arlen , m. beilicke , w. benbow , s. m. bradbury , j. h. buckley , v. bugaev , y. butt , et al .
, in american institute of physics conference series , edited by f. a. aharonian , w. hofmann , and f. rieger ( 2008 ) , vol .
1085 of american institute of physics conference series , pp .
657 - 660 .
m. k. daniel , in international cosmic ray conference , edited by r. caballero , j. c. dolivo , g. medina - tanco , l. nellen , f. a. snchez , and j. f. valds - galicia ( 2008 ) , vol . 3 of international cosmic ray conference , pp .
1325 - 1328 . | the first veritas telescope was installed in 2002 - 2003 at the fred lawrence whipple observatory and was originally operated as a prototype instrument . subsequently the decision was made to locate the full array at the same site , resulting in an asymmetric array layout .
as anticipated , this resulted in less than optimal sensitivity due to the loss in effective area and the increase in background due to local muon initiated triggers . in the summer of 2009 ,
the veritas collaboration relocated telescope 1 to improve the overall array layout .
this has provided a 30% improvement in sensitivity corresponding to a 60% change in the time needed to detect a source . |
the discovery of the first extrasolar planetary system stands as one of the key scientific and philosophical advances of the twentieth century . while the existence of other planetary systems had been postulated for several centuries ( dick , 1998 ) , and
could even be regarded as likely , particularly following the detection of circumstellar disks around young stars ( see sargent & beckwith , 1993 ) , mayor & queloz ( 1995 ) radial velocity measurements of 51 pegasi marked a definitive transition from speculation to observation . the relatively short time interval which has elapsed since that initial discovery has seen the identification of a plethora of additional systems , notably by marcy , butler and collaborators . taken together ,
those systems provide sufficient numbers for a statistical comparison of the characteristics of stars with planetary - mass companions against the overall distribution of properties of the local galactic disk .
the results of such a study have obvious implications for estimating the likely frequency of extrasolar planets ( esps ) , particularly potentially habitable systems .
comparative studies of this type must pay due regard to several important caveats .
first , it is clear that most of the esp systems discovered to date bear little resemblance to our own solar system : 51 pegasi - like systems feature ` hot jupiters ' , jovian - mass planets in sub - mercurian orbits , while over half of the current esp catalogue have orbital eccentricities comparable to , or exceeding , that of mercury and pluto .
those circumstances , however , may at least partly reflect observational selection ; these systems have relatively short periods and relatively high velocity amplitudes , and are therefore the easiest to detect .
all of the ` hot jupiter ' esps have reflex motions of tens of ms@xmath3 , and it seems likely that we have a fairly complete census of these objects .
however , it is only now that observations are achieving both the requisite velocity precision and the decade - plus time baselines which are required for the detection of jovian analogues , and systems bearing a closer resemblance to the solar system are starting to emerge amongst the most recent discoveries ( vogt _ et al . _ , 2001 ) .
thus , it is possible that the properties of the current esp catalogue may reflect extreme , rather than characteristics , systems . by the same token
, it seems likely that the present catalogue includes only a subset of extrasolar planetary systems in the solar neighbourhood .
studies estimate that between 3 and 5% of f , g - type stars have currently - detectable esp systems ( marcy & butler , 2000 ) .
tabachnik & tremaine ( 2001 ) , in particular , have used maximum - likelihood analysis to estimate that current observations indicate a planetary frequency of 3% amongst solar - type stars , but that the frequency might be as high as 15% if the companion mass function is extrapolated to terrestial - mass systems .
thus , the observed detection frequency may well underestimate the true frequency of solar - type stars with planetary systems , and possibly provides a biased sampling of their characteristics .
nonetheless , the current dataset offers a first cut at determining the conditions required for the formation of planetary systems .
how are the esp primaries distinguished from the average local field star ?
studies to date have focused on chemical abundance , with strong indications that stars known to have planets tend to have solar or super - solar metallicity ( gonzalez , 1998 ; santos et al , 2001 ) . while this may indicate a requirement on the initial conditions at formation ,
there have also been suggestions that these higher abundances are a consequence of planet formation ( lin _ et al .
_ , 1996 ) , reflecting pollution of the stellar atmosphere by migrating gas giants ( gonzalez , 1997 ; laughlin , 2000 ) .
placing this result in the broadest context requires consideration of both correlations which might exist with other properties of the planetary host stars , and comparison against data for a reliable reference sample of representative disk stars .
the latter criterion is not met in some recent analyses . in this paper
we re - examine the abundance distribution of the esp hosts , matched against similar data for an hipparcos - based , volume - limited sample of fgk stars .
we also compare the kinematics of esp hosts against the velocity distribution of local disk stars .
the paper is organised as follows : the following section presents basic data for the esp host stars ; section 3 discusses abundance calibration and the metallicity distribution ; section 4 examines the kinematics of the sample ; and section 5 summarises our main conclusions .
table 1 lists basic photometric and parallax data for stars currently known to possess at least one planetary - mass companion
. we shall refer to those stars as esp host stars . in compiling this list ,
we follow the geneva convention ( _ http://obswww.unige.ch/ udry / planet/ _ ) of setting an upper mass limit of m@xmath4m@xmath5 , where m@xmath5 is the mass of jupiter .
there are only four systems where m@xmath6 exceeds 10m@xmath5 .
the parameters listed for the planetary systems are taken from the extrasolar planets encyclopedia maintained by j. schneider at _ http://cfa - www.harvard.edu / planets/_. since we only measure m@xmath6 for most of these systems , there is clearly potential for the inclusion of higher - mass companions on low - inclination orbits , either low - mass stars or brown dwarfs .
indeed , there may well be an overlap between the upper mass range of planets and the lower mass - range of brown dwarfs , leading to an inherent ambiguity in interpretation . since those two classes of objects may have different intrinsic properties , it is important to conside the likely level of cross - contamination .
the degree of contamination depends on the prevalence of brown dwarfs as close companions to solar - type stars .
few unequivocal examples of such systems have been detected , leading both to the postulation of a ` brown dwarf desert ' at @xmath7 a.u .
( marcy & butler , 2000 ) , and support for the hypothesis that the low mass ( m@xmath8m@xmath5 ) companions that _ are _ detected are not a simple extension of the companion mass function at higher masses . on the other hand ,
there have been counter suggestions .
both heacox ( 1999 ) and stepinski & black ( 2000 ) have pointed out the similarity between the orbital properties of planetary - mass systems and stellar binaries , although that might reflect similar dynamical evolution rather than similar origins .
more directly , han _ et al . _ ( 2000 ) and gatewood _ et al .
_ ( 2000 ) have analysed radial velocity data in tandem with hipparcos intermediate astrometric data , and claim that in many cases the best - fit orbits have low inclination , and correspondingly high true masses in the brown dwarf or even stellar rgime .
_ result has been scrutinised intently and generally found wanting .
statistically , the scarcity of systems with m@xmath9 m@xmath5 demands a rather unlikely observational conspiracy , with orbital axes aligned within a few degrees of the line of sight . under a random distribution of inclinations
, one would expect several hundred systems with brown - dwarf mass companions for each planetary - mass system ; not only are the latter systems not observed , but there are not sufficient g dwarfs in the solar neighbourhood to meet the numerical requirements .
the amplitudes of the derived astrometric orbits are comparable with the uncertainties in the hipparcos iad measurements , and pourbaix ( 2001 ) has shown that the low inclinations found by han _
are largely an artefact of the fitting technique used .
pourbaix & arenou ( 2001 ) conclude that @xmath10 crb is the only system where the data merit interpretation as a near face - on orbit , but hst astrometry by mcgrath _
( 2001 ) sets an upper limit on the semi - major axis at @xmath11 milliarcseconds ( mas ) corresponding to m@xmath12m@xmath5 , rather than the 1.5 mas and @xmath13m@xmath14 suggested by gatewood _
et al . _ ( 2000 ) .
current estimates of the companion mass function are generally in good agreement , finding approximately equal numbers per decade in mass ( @xmath15 ) for @xmath16m@xmath5 , with a sharp drop at higher masses ( jorissen _ et al .
_ , 2001 ; zucker & mazeh , 2001 ; tabachnik & tremaine , 2001 ) .
indeed , astrometric observations have shown that many of the candidate brown dwarf companions are , in fact , low - mass m dwarfs ( halbwachs _ et al .
_ , 2000 ) , further enhancing the brown dwarf desert .
based on these results , we expect little contamination ( @xmath175% ) in the esp sample listed in table 1 .
nonetheless , one star deserves comment . as discussed later ,
hd 114762 is one of the most metal - poor stars in the sample .
the measured stellar rotational velocity suggests that the star is being viewed close to pole - on , implying a low inclination for an equatorial orbit . in that case , the companion , detected by latham _
( 1989 ) is a candidate for the first brown dwarf identification .
all of the stars except bd -10 3666 were observed by hipparcos , and most have trigonometric parallaxes measured to an accuracy of better than 5% .
the bv photometry listed in table 1 is also taken from the hipparcos catalogue ( esa , 1997 ) , although we use the literature data cited therein in preference to tycho photometry , given the systematic offset ( and occasional large random errors ) between the latter system and standard johnson data ( bessell , 2000 ) .
bd -10 3666 has ubv photometry by ryan ( 1992 ) but no measured trigonometric parallax , and the absolute magnitude listed in table 1 is based on an estimated photometric parallax . since both this
star and hd 4203 were selected for observation based on the known high metallicity , neither plays a role in the statistical comparison discussed in the following sections .
the photometry and astrometry listed in table 1 allow a detailed assessment of the distribution of the esp host stars in the hr diagram .
figure 1 makes that comparison , where the reference main sequence is provided by data for stars within 25 parsecs which have accurate photometry and trigonometric parallaxes measured to a precision of @xmath19 .
all of the latter stars are members of the galactic disk .
three features are immediately noticeable : 1 .
g dwarfs contribute the majority of planet detections , with gl 876 still the only m dwarf known to have planetary - mass companions . to a large extent ,
the distribution likely reflects the continuing observational focus on solar - type stars .
the current sample includes a significant number of evolved stars .
at least six stars lie at the base of the subgiant branch , while four have evolved a considerable distance from the main sequence .
these stars are identified in table 1 .
the esp host stars are distributed throughout the full width of the main sequence .
this is important since chemical abundance is the dominant factor which governs the location of single stars on the main sequence - at a given colour , metal - rich stars are more luminous than metal - poor stars .
thus , the observed distribution points to a range of metallicity amongst stars with planets which is at least comparable to the abundance distribution amongst the underlying local disk ( thin+thick ) population . the last point is particularly pertinent given the recent emphasis laid on the high metal abundance measured for at least some of the esp primaries ( gonzalez _ et al .
_ , 1999 , 2001 ; santos _ et al .
_ , 2001 ) .
many of those abundances are significantly higher than the value usually taken as the median for the galactic disk .
most previous studies , however , treat the metallicity distributions of the esp hosts and of the disk as separate entities .
the following section places the former in the context of the latter , and considers how the high chemical abundances are reconciled with the distribution evident in figure 1 .
the metal content of stellar atmospheres can be measured using a wide variety of techniques . in general , the accuracy of the final measurement is at least inversely proportional to the difficulty of the observation .
analyses based on high - resolution spectroscopy are usually more reliable than those which utilise broadband colours , but photometric data are obtained much more readily than echelle spectra . thus , any statistical analysis requiring a dataset of even modest dimensions must balance two factors - availability and accuracy . as a further complication , comparative studies must ensure that data drawn from different analyses are tied to a consistent system .
different measurement techniques not only have different random uncertainties , but can also exhibit systematic discrepanciesin scale and/or zeropoint , as discussed in the context of globular cluster distance determination by gratton _
_ 1997 ) and reid ( 1998 ) . apart from differences in the choice of standard stars
, we note that the solar iron abundance was re - calibrated relatively recently , revised downward from a(fe)=7.67 to a(fe)=7.54 ( biemont _ et al .
_ , 1991 ) , where a(fe ) is the logarithmic abundance on a scale where a(h)=12 .
while most abundances are measured differentially , this re - calibration might lead to a systematic offset depending on how and when the abundances of the standard stars were determined .
this issue is a concern since , while nearly all of the esp host stars have recent high - resolution spectroscopic abundance measurements , most estimates of the underlying field - star metallicity distribution rest on lower resolution techniques .
( 2001 ) have addressed this problem to some extent by providing high - resolution spectral analyses for 43 g dwarfs in 42 systems drawn from the volume - limited sample of stars with ( b - v)@xmath20 and @xmath21 parsecs .
that sample is scarcely sufficient in size , however , to provide an adequate mapping of the distribution of disk properties .
we adopt an alternative strategy in this paper .
strmgren uvby photometry provides a relatively simple means of determining abundances for f , g and early k - type stars ( strmgren , 1966 ) .
data are available for most solar - type stars brighter than 10th magnitude .
indeed , both gimnez ( 2000 ) and laughlin ( 2000 ) have applied those measurements to studying the esp host stars .
metallicities are determined by measuring the differential line - blanketting via the m@xmath22 and c@xmath22 indices , where @xmath23 and @xmath24 the latter index is also gravity sensitive , allowing discrimination between dwarfs and subgiants .
the literature contains several calibrations of the strmgren indices against metallicity .
gimnez adopts that given by olsen ( 1984 ) ; we follow laughlin in using the more recent calibrations derived by schuster & nissen ( 1989 ) .
they provide two calibrating relations , @xmath25_{uvby } & = & 1.052 - 73.21m_1 + 280.9m_1(b - y ) + 333.95m_1 ^ 2(b - y ) - 595.5m_1(b - y)^2 \\ & & + [ 5.486 - 41.61m_1 - 7.963(b - y ) ] \times \log{(m_1 - [ 0.6322 - 3.58(b - y ) + 5.20 ( b - y)^2])}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for f stars , ( @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 \le 0.2 $ ] ) , and @xmath25_{uvby } & = & -2.0695 - 22.45m_1 - 53.8m_1 ^ 2 - 62.04m_1(b - y ) + 145.5m_1 ^ 2(b - y ) \\ & & ( 85.1m_1 - 13.8c_1 - 137.2m_1 ^ 2)c_1 \end{aligned}\ ] ] for g stars ( @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 \le 0.4 $ ] ) . apart from bd -10 1366 and gl 876 , where strmgren data offer little useful information , only hd 177830 ( hip 93746 ) lacks uvby photometry .
table 2 lists ( b - y ) , m@xmath22 and c@xmath22 colour indices , taken from hauck & mermilliod s ( 1998 ) catalogue , and the resulting [ fe / h]@xmath34 for the remaining stars , together with the metallicities derived from high - resolution spectroscopy .
as expected , there is a systematic offset to lower abundances in the strmgren calibration .
the results are compared in figure 2 , where the upper panels plot the full dataset ( see also figure 1 in laughlin , 2000 ) .
we note that residuals tend to increase among early - type k stars , ( b - y)@xmath350.5 , where both methods become more problematic .
we have quantified the comparison using the datasets from santos _
( 2001 ) and gonzalez and collaborators , which provide two internally consistent datasets of moderate size .
based on the twenty - two esp host stars observed by santos _
( 2001 ) , we derive @xmath36 \ = \ [ fe / h]_{uvby } - [ fe / h]_{sp } \ =
\ -0.117\pm0.095\ ] ] where the uncertainties quoted are the rms dispersion about the mean .
the formal standard error of the mean , @xmath37 , is 0.020 dex and the median offset is -0.13 dex .
the twenty - two stars in the gonzalez dataset give an almost identical result , @xmath36 \
-0.118\pm0.113 , \quad \sigma_\mu \ = \ 0.024\ ] ] the median offset is -0.10 dex .
combining both datasets with forty field stars from the santos _
reference sample gives @xmath36 \
-0.083\pm0.118 , \quad \sigma_\mu \ = \ 0.013\ ] ] the median offset is -0.07 dex .
this is in excellent agreement with gratton _
et al.s_ independent analysis of 152 stars spanning a much larger range of metallicity , where they derive @xmath36 \ = \
-0.102\pm0.151 , \quad \sigma_\mu \ = \ 0.012\ ] ] given uncertainties of @xmath38 dex in the santos _
et al . _ and
gonzalez spectroscopic measurements , the measured dispersion indicates that the strmgren data have typical uncertainties of @xmath39 dex at near - solar abundances , sufficient accuracy for present purposes .
based on this comparison , we conclude that the strmgren abundance scale is offset by -0.1 dex from the most recent calibrations .
we note that the offset is intriguingly similar to the re - calibration of the solar abundance , although that similarity may be coincidental . rather than attempt to correct the metallicity measurements , we base our analysis on the _ uvby _ scale ; in effect , we adopt the somewhat paradoxical definition @xmath40_{uvby } ( \odot ) \ =
\ -0.1\ ] ] since we are considering the comparative distributions of field star and esp host star abundances , consistency is more important than the numerical value chosen for the fiducial zeropoint .
defining a suitable reference sample is crucial to assessing how the properties of the esp host stars map onto the overall field star distribution .
complete , volume - limited datasets offer the most reliable comparison , but have generally not been available to previous studies .
( 2001 ) have attempted to turn hipparcos data to this end , with a reference sample defined by selecting hd stars with @xmath41 mas and @xmath19 .
however , the colour - magnitude diagram for this dataset ( figure 1 in murray & chaboyer , 2001 ) is clearly biased strongly towards f - type and early g - type dwarfs , partly reflecting sampling in the hipparcos catalogue at @xmath42th magnitude , and partly reflecting the fact that the hd catalogue was selected from blue photographic plates .
the resulting dataset therefore provides a biased subset of nearby disk stars .
et al.s_ metallicities are taken from the cayrel de strobel ( 1997 ) catalogue , and therefore represent an amalgam of heterogenous sources . thus , this dataset is not suitable as a local reference .
several other analyses ( e.g. gonzalez , 1999 ; butler _ et al .
_ , 2000 ) have relied on the nearby - star sample defined by favata _
( 1997 : f97 ) to represent the abundance distribution of local disk stars .
that sample , however , is severely flawed in several important respects , as illustrated in figure 3 .
the f97 abundances are derived from high - resolution spectra , and a comparison with strmgren abundances gives @xmath36 \ = \
-0.05\pm0.15 , \ { \rm 69 \ stars}\ ] ] somewhat less than the offsets derived in the previous section .
the full sample of 90 stars includes both components of several binaries , giving those systems double weight in the abundance distribution , and spans a substantially larger colour range than esp host stars ( excluding gl 876 ) .
finally , and most significantly , the sample is neither complete nor volume - limited .
( 1996 ) constructed the original sample by taking a randomly - selected subset of 200 stars with @xmath43 from the second catalogue of nearby stars ( gliese , 1969 ; gliese & jahrei , 1979 : cns2 ) .
ninety - four of those stars were observed spectroscopically .
unfortunately , while the cns2 has a nominal distance limit of 25 parsecs , subsequent hipparcos astrometry has shown that a significant fraction of the stars lie at much larger distances .
figure 3 shows that at least 40% of the f97 dataset lies beyond 25 parsecs .
our analysis demands a more reliable reference dataset .
figure 4 shows the ( m@xmath18 , ( b - v ) ) colour - magnitude outlined by the 1549 stars in the hipparcos catalogue with formal trigonometric parallax measurements exceeding 40 mas ( @xmath44 parsecs , ( m - m)@xmath45 ) . as in figure 1
, we use the literature bv photometry in the catalogue in preference to tycho data .
we have not applied any cut based on parallax precision , but use different symbols to identify the 1477 stars with parallaxes measured to a precision of better than 20% .
nearly all of the stars lying below the main - sequence in this figure have inaccurate parallax measurements .
the box superimposed on figure 4 isolates 488 stars with @xmath46 and @xmath47 , matching the colour / magnitude range of the bulk of the esp host stars .
the limiting magnitude for completeness in the hipparcos catalogue is @xmath48 so the 25-parsec sample is effectively complete over the whole sky for m@xmath49 ( the dotted line in figure 4 ) .
the full catalogue is @xmath50 incomplete for stars with @xmath51 , but should be significantly more complete for nearby stars , since all stars suspected of being within 25 parsecs were included in the input catalogue - as emphasised by the large numbers of m dwarfs in figure 4 . indeed , jahrei & wielen ( 1997 ) argue that the hipparcos catalogue is essentially complete to m@xmath52 for stars within 25 parsecs of the sun .
thus , the f , g and k stars isolated in figure 4 effectively represent a complete , volume - limited sample .
we identify these stars as the fgk25 hipparcos dataset .
note that the sample includes 20 known esp hosts from table 1 . as noted in the previous section ,
strmgren photometry is now available for a substantial number of bright f , g and k stars , and is readily accessible through the catalogue compiled by hauck & mermilliod ( 1998 ) .
we have cross - referenced the fgk25 hipparcos dataset against that catalogue and located photometry for 419 of the 486 stars - 86% of the sample .
those stars are identified as solid squares in figure 4 .
the sample includes members of binary systems , but only one star per system .
it is clear that almost every star with ( b - v)@xmath170.8 has photometry , while the late - g and k dwarfs which lack strmgren measurements are distributed over the full width of the main sequence , interspersed with stars which have uvby photometry .
we conclude that the abundance distribution deduced from these data is characteristic of the parent population(s ) of the esp host stars .
the overwhelming majority of the stars in the fgk25 sample are members of the galactic disk .
five stars , however , lie significantly below the main sequence .
these are hip 57939 , 62951 , 67655 , 79537 and 79979 .
two of these stars , hip 62951 and hip 79979 , are in binary systems where the companion has affected the parallax determination ; fabricius & makarov ( 2000 ) have reanalysed the hipparcos data for hip 62951 and find @xmath53 mas .
these are the only two stars in the fgk25 sample with @xmath54 ( there are only 6 other stars with @xmath55 ) , and we exclude both from our sample .
the remaining three subluminous stars are _ bona - fide _ metal - poor subdwarfs .
hip 57939 is hd 103095 , or groombridge 1830 , the well - known intermediate - abundance ( [ fe / h]@xmath34=-1.4 ) subdwarf ; hip 67655 , or hd 120559 , has [ fe / h]@xmath34=-0.94 ; and hip 79537 is hd 145417 , [ fe / h]@xmath34=-1.25 .
the presence of three such stars in this volume - limited sample suggests a somewhat higher density normalisation ( @xmath56 relative to the disk population ) than usually adopted for the local galactic halo . before comparing these results against other recent analyses , we should emphasise the limited nature of the present study .
the question addressed here can be stated as follows : + based on current statistics , and given a sample of stars drawn from the galactic mid - plane near the sun , what is the frequency of esp systems as a function of metallicity .
our goal in constructing the reference sample of field stars , therefore , is not an unbiased estimate of the present - day metallicity distribution of the galactic disk - a parameter used to constrain disk star formation histories . that undertaking requires limiting analysis to stars with main - sequence lifetimes older than the age of the disk , avoiding possible bias through a disproportionate contribution from recent star formation episodes .
moreover , given a potential correlation between metallicity and velocity , one should weight each star s contribution by its w - velocity to allow for the residence time in the mid - plane and convert volume density to surface density .
the latter is not an option for the present sample , since over 25% of the stars lack radial velocities .
moreover , our ( b - v ) limits , modelled on the known esp systems , include early - type g and late - f stars , whose main - sequence lifetimes are shorter than 10 gyrs .
thus , our field star sample is tailored to provide a local snapshot of the present - day abundance distribution in the mid - plane , rather than an integrated history of star formation in the disk .
we have compared the abundance distribution of the fgk25 dataset against results from two other studies : the favata _
( 1997 ) analysis , described above , and the recent study by haywood ( 2001 : h2001 ) . in both cases , we consider volume - limited samples ( i.e. the distribution is not weighted by w velocity as in figure 3 of f97 ) .
haywood s analysis _ is _ aimed at determining an unbiased estimate of the disk abundance distribution , so while his initial sample is selected to have m@xmath57 , ( b - v)@xmath350.25 and @xmath58 mas ( based on hipparcos data ) , the final analysis is limited to 328 stars with @xmath59 ; that is , main - sequence dwarfs with lifetimes longer than the age of the disk .
abundances are derived primarily from geneva photometry , supplemented by strmgren data , with the metallicity scale effectively adjusted to the high - resolution ( santos / gonzalez ) system .
figure 5 compares the abundance distributions derived in those studies against our own results . for consistency , we have adjusted all of the metallicity scales to match [ fe / h]@xmath34 .
all three distributions peak at values close to the solar abundance , with a substantial fraction of the sample ( 45% in the fgk25 dataset ) having super - solar metallicities . as discussed by haywood , this represents a significant revision of previous analyses , and may reflect a bias against metal - rich stars in samples selected based on spectral type rather than distance / colour .
we note that only a small fraction of the local disk have abundances of less than @xmath60 solar : only 25 stars ( 6% ) in the fgk25 sample . if @xmath61 of the local stars are members of the thick disk , as suggested by kinematic analyses ( reid , hawley & gizis , 1995 ) , then the mean abundance of that sub - population lies much closer to the solar metallicity than the value of [ fe / h]=-0.6 adopted in some galactic models .
both the f97 and h2001 samples show a more extended distribution towards higher abundances than the fgk25 dataset .
this is somewhat surprising , since the latter sample , extending to stars brighter than m@xmath62 , should include a higher proportion of younger stars which are likely to be more metal - rich .
the discrepancy may originate from the abundance calibrations .
figure 6 shows the metallicity distribution as a function of ( b - v ) colour for the h2001 and fgk25 datasets .
the former shows a clear trend of increasing metallicity at redder colours , suggesting a possible systematic bias in the abundance calibration of geneva photometry .
further observations are required to verify this hypothesis . for present purposes ,
the most significant point is that the metallicities discussed here for both field stars and esp host stars are derived from a single source - strmgren photometry , as calibrated by schuster & nissen ( 1989 ) .
thus , the comparison between the two abundance distributions described in the following section is internally fully self - consistent . before comparing metallicities ,
figure 7 matches the ( m@xmath22 , ( b - y ) ) and ( c@xmath22 , ( b - y ) ) distributions of the esp host stars and the fgk25 hipparcos sample .
we have distinguished between main sequence stars and potential subgiants in the former sample .
as previously noted by gimnez ( 2000 ) , a significant fraction of the esp host stars have high c@xmath22 values , suggesting low gravities and a mildly evolved status . in some cases
, however , the colours reflect high metallicity rather than low gravity ; thus , both hip 43587 ( 55 cnc ) and 79248 ( hd 145675 ) lie well above the ( ( b - y ) , c@xmath22 ) sequence at ( b - y)@xmath630.42 , but their location in the ( m@xmath18 , ( b - v ) ) plane demands that both are main - sequence dwarfs .
spectroscopy indicates that both are super - metal rich ( table 2 ) .
nonetheless , the fraction of subgiants amongst known esp hosts ( @xmath64 ) is at least a factor of three higher than that in the volume - limited sample .
this may reflect an observational selection effect , since evolved stars are intrinsically more luminous , and therefore more likely to be included in the radial velocity monitoring programs .
the reddest star in the sample is the k2 subgiant , hd 27442 ( hip 19921 ) .
this lies beyond the formal limits of the schuster & nissen ( 1989 ) abundance calibration , at ( b - y)=0.65 ; however , the derived metallicity , [ fe / h]@xmath34=0.26 , is not inconsistent with the spectroscopic determination of [ fe / h]=+0.22 , so we have retained the star in the sample . we have excluded both bd -10 1366 and hd 4203 from the statistical comparison . as noted above , those stars were added to the keck / lick radial velocity program because they were known to be extremely metal - rich .
the m dwarfs , gl 876 , is also excluded , but we include hd 177830 , adjusting its abundance from [ fe / h]=0.36 to [ fe / h]@xmath34=0.26 .
the sample of esp host stars is not volume - limited , particularly given the fact that the original target list was constructed before the availability of hipparcos data , and is therefore subject to the type of distance errors illustrated in figure 3 .
there may therefore be underlying biases reflecting the initial selection of which stars to monitor .
those effects can be quantified once the full dataset is available .
nonetheless , it is not unreasonable to hope that the current catalogue of esp host stars provides a representative subset of stars with currently - detectable planetary systems ; that is , stars with relatively massive ( super - jovian ) companions on relatively short - period ( @xmath17 few years ) orbits .
figure 8 plots the abundance distribution of both the esp host stars and the reference fgk25 hipparcos dataset .
the subgiant contribution to the former distribution is shown as the shaded histogram and is consistent with the overall distribution .
as emphasised in 3.1 , these data are all on the strmgren system , [ fe / h]@xmath34 , placing the sun as -0.1 dex , at the mode of the local abundance distribution .
visual comparison clearly confirms previous suggestions that the abundance distribution of the esp host stars is weighted more heavily towards super - solar metallicity than the field distribution . to quantify that comparison
we have combined the distributions by scaling the upper distribution to match the observed fraction of esp hosts amongst the volume - complete sample . as noted above , 20 of the 486 stars in the fgk25 sample , or 4.1% ,
are known to have planetary - mass companions .
this fraction is broadly consistent with previous estimates ( e.g. marcy & butler , 2000 ) .
we have used this factor to scale the metallicity distribution in the uppermost panel of figure 8 , and the two lowest panels in figure 8 show the fraction of esp host stars , @xmath65 as a function of metallicity .
there is an obvious trend with abundance , with f@xmath66 rising to near unity at the highest abundances ; both of the stars in the highest - metallicity bin of the fgk25 sample are known to have planetary - mass companions . however , even at an abundance of @xmath67th solar , @xmath1 of f , g and early - k stars are predicted to have jovian - mass planetary companions .
hd 114762b , the likely brown dwarf , contributes the spike at [ fe / h]@xmath34=-0.7 dex .
finally , we have compared the properties of the individual planetary systems against the abundances derived from the strmgren data .
figure 9 shows the results , where we identify separately systems with multiple components ( including the sun , represented by jupiter and saturn ) .
there is no obvious correlation between [ fe / h]@xmath34 and any of the observed characteristics .
is the correlation with metallicity evident in figure 8 a selection effect ?
metal - rich stars are more luminous than their metal - poor counterparts , and therefore , like subgiants , might be expected to be better represented in a target list which is partly magnitude limited .
however , it seems unlikely that this type of bias could account for the smooth trend evident in the observations , particularly given the identification of planetary companions to bd -10 1366 and hd 4203 , stars specifically added to the keck program because they were known to be super - metal - rich .
thus , the simplest interpretation of figure 8 is that the correlation represents a real physical phenomenon .
the explanation for this phenomenon is somewhat less clear . perhaps appropriately , the two mechanisms proposed to account for the observed correlation mirror the classic nature _ versus _ nurture debates of biological behavioural sciences . under the first hypothesis , planetary systems ( at least those with giant planets ) form more readily in the dustier environment likely to be present in high - metallicity circumstellar disks .
under the alternative hypothesis , gas giants migrate inwards due to dynamical friction with residual disk material and are absorbed into the stellar envelope .
the enhanced metal content of the planet ( solar system giants are likely to have z@xmath68 ) enriches the metallicity of the outer convective envelope , leading to a higher measured chemical abundance .
one question mark hanging over the planetary pollution hypothesis centres on the details of the enhanced metal content of jovian planets .
in astronomical terms , ` metals ' encompass all elements except hydrogen and helium - but not all metals are created equal .
metallicity measurements for f , g and early k - type stars are primarily measuring blanketting due to heavy elements , notably iron .
the giant planets are known to have non - cosmic inter - element abundance ratios , but if the additional ` metals ' are ices ( c , n , o ) rather than minerals ( fe , si , ni ) , as suggested by the possible absence of a rocky core in jupiter ( guillot , 1999 ) , then planetary pollution will have little effect on the apparent metallicity of the stellar envelope .
these two competing scenarios are discussed extensively by , amongst others , gonzalez ( 1997 , 1999 ) , laughlin ( 2000 ) , murray _
( 2001 ) and santos _ et al . _
a major prediction of the pollution hypothesis is that the degree of metallicity enhancement should increase with increasing mass of the parent star .
this follows from the corresponding decrease in mass of the convective envelope ; adding high - z material gives a proportionately larger increase in metallicity .
both laughlin and murray & chaboyer ( 2001 ) have argued that this effect is present , although the latter authors note that a similar trend is present in their reference sample , and both analyses are based on a subset of the current catalogue of esp hosts . santos _
( 2001 ) , in contrast , arrive at the opposite conclusion based on analysis of more than 60 systems . in their analysis
, they rightly place more emphasis on the location of the upper envelope of the abundance distribution as a function of mass , rather than the mean metallicity .
all three of these analyses use theoretical tracks to deduce masses for individual esp host stars .
figure 10 shows an alternative , more empirical approach .
we have separated the current sample into main - sequence stars and subgiants based on location in figure 1 , and plot the abundance as a function of ( b - y ) . for the main - sequence sample , ( b - y ) effectively traces mass , and the absence of any strong trend in the location of the high - metallicity boundary , in particular , a decrease in [ fe / h]@xmath69 at redder ( b - y ) colours , supports the conclusion reached by santos _
_ moreover , the latter authors point out that as stars evolve onto the subgiant branch , the convective envelope increases in size , diluting the effect of any planetary pollution .
it is clear from figure 10 that the evolved stars can be as metal - rich as the main - sequence dwarfs ; indeed , the k2 subgiant hd 24427 ( hip 19921 ) is amongst the most metal - rich stars in the sample .
thus , these results suggest that planetary systems are born metal - rich , rather than having high metallicity thrust upon them .
the age distribution of the esp host stars is clearly an important parameter for understanding the galactic origins of these systems .
two techniques have been used to estimate ages for individual stars : isochrone fitting ; and the level of chromospheric activity , as measured through emission at the ca ii h & k lines .
both methods can be applied to individuals , but both have limitations .
isochrone fitting provides reliable ages for relatively f and early - g stars , but becomes less accurate for longer - lived , later - type stars .
chromospheric ages , quantified using the @xmath70 index ( soderblom _ et al .
_ , 1991 ) , are more readily derived , but are also less reliable since there is a considerable dispersion in activity amongst individual stars with similar ages ( see figure 10 in soderblom _
et al . _ ) .
moreover , variability is an issue ; as henry _
( 1996 ) point out , the sun s age could be estimated as anywhere between 2.2 and 8 gyrs depending on when the observations are taken during the solar cycle .
finally , both of these techniques become significantly less reliable at ages exceeding @xmath71 gyrs ( as evidenced by continuing uncertainties in the galactic star formation history ) .
nonetheless , both of these methods provide useful insight into the age distribution , and both have been applied by gonzalez and co - workers ( gonzalez & laws , 1998 ; gonzalez , 1999 ; gonzalez _ et al .
_ , 2001 ) to estimate ages for 33 of the systems listed in table 1 .
a comparison between the different estimates emphasises the inherent uncertainties , most dramatically for hd 217107 and hd 222582 , where both have chromospheric age estimates of 5.6 gyrs , but isochrone estimates of 1.2 and 11 gyrs , respectively . averaging the results for all 33 stars ,
we derive a mean age of 5.6 gyrs ( @xmath72 gyrs ) .
space motions can not be used to provide age estimates for individual stars . however ,
stellar kinematics offer an alternative means of comparing the _ average _ properties of diverse groups of stars .
velocity dispersion increases with age , probably through the mechanisms of orbital diffusion ( wielen , 1977 ) and scattering due to molecular clouds ( spitzer & schwarzschild , 1953 ) .
a comparison between the velocity distributions of the esp host stars and the local disk can test whether there is a significant difference in the mean age of the two samples .
we have calculated space motions for the esp hosts using astrometric data from the hipparcos catalogue and the available radial velocity measurements .
table 3 lists those data and the resulting ( u , v , w ) motions , where u is positive toward the galactic centre , v positive in the direction of rotation , and w directed toward the ngp .
all of the fgk25 stars have accurate proper motions and parallaes from hipparcos , but only 60% have published radial velocities , rendering the sample unsuitable as a reference . however , the volume - complete m - dwarf sample from the pmsu survey of nearby stars ( reid _ et al . _ ,
1995 : pmsu1 ) gives a ready alternative , providing an unbiased representation of the kinematics of local disk stars .
( 2002 : pmsu4 ) have revised the original dataset to incorporate more recent astrometric data , notably from hipparcos , besides including higher - accuracy radial velocities from echelle observations summarised by gizis _
( 2001 : pmsu3 ) .
the final sample is comparable in size to the fgk25 dataset , with 436 systems lying within m@xmath73-dependent distance limits ranging from 10 to 20 parsecs .
figure 11 compares the velocity distributions of the two datasets .
the left - hand panels plot the two - component velocity distributions ; the right - hand panels show probability plots of the ( u , v , w ) distributions . as originally discussed by lutz & upgren ( 1980 ) , these diagrams plot the cumulative distribution of a sample , c(x ) , against the difference with respect to the mean value , @xmath74 , in units of the standard deviation . a normal distribution , @xmath75 , gives a straight line , slope @xmath76 , in this plane .
figure 11 plots three empirical velocity distributions : data for the esp host stars ; for the full pmsu m - dwarf sample ; and for the pmsu dme dwarfs , with h@xmath77 emission exceeding 1 equivalent width . as discussed by hawley _
( 1996 ; pmsu2 ) , chromospheric emission is an age - dependent phenomenon , so the last dataset is characteristic of a moderately young stellar population , @xmath78gyrs .
it is clear from figure 11 that the velocity distribution of the esp host stars is more closely matched to the full m dwarf sample than to the dme sample .
quantitatively , linear fits to the central regions of the probability plots ( @xmath79 ) give @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the overall velocity dispersion .
applying the same technique to the m dwarf samples gives @xmath82 for the emission line dwarfs and @xmath83 for the full sample .
based on this comparison , we conclude that the current sample of f , g and k - type esp hosts is younger , on average , than the overall disk population , but includes stars significantly older than typical of the dme sample .
quantitatively , if we assume diffusion with @xmath84 , then @xmath85 suggesting an average age of 3 - 4 gyrs for esp host stars for an approximately uniform star - formation rate in a 10-gyrs - old disk .
this younger mean age is not unexpected , given the higher proportion of metal - rich stars amongst the esp sample .
the average metal abundance of the galactic disk is expected to increase with time , as successive generations of star formation contribute additional nucleosynthetic debris to the interstellar medium , so a sample biased toward high metallicities is also likely to be biased towards stars that are younger than average .
the previous section considered the overall distribution of velocities of the esp host stars .
we can also look for correlations using velocities for the individual stars , correcting the observed heliocentric data for the solar motion with respect to the local standard of rest ( lsr ) .
for the latter parameter , we use the values derived by dehnen & binney ( 1998 ) , @xmath86 where these values give the motion of the sun with respect to the lsr .
thus , the sun is moving towards the galactic centre , towards the direction of rotation and towards the ngp , and the observed velocities must be corrected accordingly .
we denote the corrected velocities as ( u , v , w ) .
figure 12 plots velocities for the esp host stars as a function of abundance .
we also indicate the location of the sun on these diagrams . there is no obvious correlation between metallicity and either the ( u , v , w ) component velocities or the total motion with respect to the lsr , v@xmath87 .
the highest metallicity stars in the sample span essentially the same range of velocities as the solar - abundance and sub - solar abundance esp host stars .
several previous studies have commented on the relatively low velocity ( @xmath88 kms@xmath3 ) of the sun with respect to the lsr .
gonzalex ( 1999 ) , in particular , has invoked the weak anthropic principle ( barrow & tipler , 1988 ) in conjunction with this property , arguing that the small offset from co - rotation minimises excursions into the potentially dangerous environment ( supernovae , gravitational interactions ) of spiral arms , therefore providing the long term quiescence which may be necessary for advanced life forms to develop .
we can make two points in this context : * first , it is clear from figure 12 than @xmath89 of the known esp host stars have velocities , v@xmath87 , within a few kms@xmath3 of that of the sun .
indeed , the transiting system , hd 209458 , has a space motion with respect to the lsr which is almost identical with that of the sun , while hd 114783 has a relative motion of only 6.2 kms@xmath3 .
( 2001 ) derive age estimates of 3 gyrs ( isochrones ) and 4.3 gyrs ( activity ) for the former star .
hd 114783 is too red to allow reliable an isochrone - based age estimate , but vogt _ et al . _
( 2001 ) note that hd 114783 is chromospherically inactive , @xmath90=-4.96 , or @xmath91 gyrs for the donahue ( 1993 ) calibration .
both stars are therefore likely to have ages similar to that of the sun . *
second , the weak anthropic principle ( wap ) can be expressed in two ways : as a positive concept , in that the planetary environment must permit the development of advanced lifeforms ; or as a less restrictive , negative concept , in that the environment should not be inimical to the development of advanced lifeforms . whether one chooses to express the wap as a positive or a negative concept depends on other issues , notably belief in the likelihood of life developing elsewhere in the universe . in either case , with a current sample of one known inhabited planet , the wap should be given the same scientific weight as its converse , the copernican principle ( `` we re not special '' )
. both are interesting philosophical concepts , which may have explanatory power ; neither carries any evidentiary weight in the present context . finally , we have compared the distribution of properties of the extrasolar planetary systems against the systemic velocities to search for possible trends or correlations . the only potentially significant result is shown in the uppermost panel of figure 13 , plotting m@xmath92 against velocity perpendicular to the plane .
the data suggest that , with the exception of hd 114762 , higher - mass companions tend to be found in systems with low w velocities .
the result is statistically marginal , but might indicate a correlation with the mass of the parent circumstellar disk . clearly more data are required to confirm whether this effect is real .
over sixty stars with planetary - mass companions are now known . while these stars neither constitute a volume - limited sample nor , probably , a complete sampling of the full range of planetary systems , they provide sufficient numbers for a preliminary investigation of the characteristics of the parent stars . in this paper we have compared the chemical abundance distribution and kinematics of those stars against data for representative samples of the local disk .
our metallicities are based on strmgren photometry , using the calibration derived by schuster & nissen ( 1989 ) .
we have shown that the resulting metallicity scale is offset to lower abundances with respect to recent high - resolution spectroscopic measurements .
this discrepancy is not important for our purposes , since strmgren photometry is available for 86% of our reference sample - an hipparcos - selected sample of 486 f , g and k stars within 25 parsecs of the sun .
the abundance distributions derived for both datasets are therefore internally consistent , although the solar abundance on this scale is @xmath93_{uvby } \sim -0.1 $ ] dex . comparing the abundance distributions of the two datasets , it is clear that , as noted in previous studies , systems currently known to have extrasolar planets are heavily weighted to high metallicities .
we have used the fraction of known esp systems in the volume - complete sample ( 20/486 , or 4.1% ) to set the two distributions on a common scaling , and compute the observed frequency as a function of chemical abundance .
the results show a strong trend with abundance , with effectively 100% frequency at @xmath93_{uvby } > 0.3 $ ] .
however , even at abundances of less than @xmath94 solar , 1 to 2% of stars are likely to have planetary - mass companions in the mass / semi - major axis / eccentricity range detectable using current techniques .
clearly , these statistics represent a lower limit to the actual frequency of extrasolar planetary systems .
how rare are solar - abundance f , g , and k stars with planets ?
note that while the frequency of esp hosts increases with [ fe / h ] , the absolute number of systems declines rapidly at high abundances .
thus , planetary systems with parent stars of near - solar abundance contribute a significant fraction of the total current sample .
based on the full fgk25 hipparcos dataset , the local number density of stars with metallicities within @xmath0 dex of the solar abundance is 0.0044 stars pc@xmath95 .
the corresponding number density of esp host stars , based on the data plotted in figure 7 , is 0.00018 stars pc@xmath95 .
consider an annulus centred on the solar radius , @xmath96 kpc .
, diameter 50 parsecs .
extrapolating from the local sample , we expect @xmath97 esp host stars within this very limited subset of the galactic disk .
casting the net wider , consider a wedge , thickness ( perpendicular to the plane ) 50 parsecs , between galactic radii of 7 and 9 kiloparsecs , a range which encompasses relatively minor changes in mean abundance and stellar number density . based on our calculations , we would expect a total of over 900,000 solar - type stars with jovian - mass planetary companions .
we have also compared the kinematics of the esp host stars against the local galactic disk via observations of a volume - limited sample of m dwarfs .
the planetary hosts exhibit a velocity distribution which is relatively well matched to a gaussian in each component , but with lower dispersions than in the field - star sample .
this suggests that the average age is only @xmath2 that of a representative subset of the disk
. this may reflect the higher proportion of metal - rich stars in the esp host sample .
individual stars , however , span a wide range of motions , with velocities of up to 50 - 60 kms@xmath3 with respect to the local standard of rest , and no obvious correlation between kinematics and abundance .
i would like to thank geoff marcy for providing radial velocity measurements for several stars in advance of publication ; david trilling , for useful comments ; and david koerner , for interesting discussion and sparking my initial interest in this topic .
the research for this paper made extensive use of the simbad database , maintained by strasberg observatory , and of jean schneider s ` extrasolar planets encyclopedia ' .
rrrrcrrrrl & bd -10 3166 & 5.5 : & 0.84 & 12@xmath98 4 & 0.48 & 0.05 & 3.49 & 0.00 & 1 + 522 & hd 142 & 3.65 & 0.52 & 39.00@xmath98 0.64 & 1.36 & 0.98 & 338.00 & 0.37 & + 1292 & hd 1237 & 5.36 & 0.75 & 56.76@xmath98 0.53 & 3.31 & 0.49 & 133.82 & 0.51 & + 3479 & hd 4208 & 5.21 & 0.67 & 30.58@xmath98 1.08 & 0.80 & 1.70 & 829.00 & 0.04 & + 3502 & hd 4203 & 4.22 & 0.73 & 12.85@xmath98 1.27 & 1.64 & 1.09 & 406.00 & 0.53 & 1 , subgiant + 5054 & hd 6434 & 4.69 & 0.60 & 24.80@xmath98 0.89 & 0.48 & 0.15 & 22.09 & 0.30 & + 6643 & hd 8574 & 3.90 & 0.58 & 22.65@xmath98 0.82 & 2.23 & 0.76 & 228.80 & 0.40 & + 7513 & hd 9826 & 3.44 & 0.54 & 74.25@xmath98 0.72 & 0.71 & 0.06 & 4.62 & 0.03 & @xmath99 and , 2 + 8159 & hd 10697 & 3.73 & 0.67 & 30.71@xmath98 0.81 & 6.59 & 2.00 & 1083.00 & 0.12 & subgiant + 9683 & hd 12661 & 4.59 & 0.72 & 26.91@xmath98 0.83 & 2.83 & 0.78 & 264.50 & 0.33 & + 10138 & hd 13445 & 5.98 & 0.77 & 91.63@xmath98 0.61 & 4.00 & 0.11 & 15.78 & 0.05 & + 12048 & hd 16141 & 4.00 & 0.71 & 27.85@xmath98 1.39 & 0.21 & 0.35 & 75.82 & 0.28 & subgiant + 12653 & hd 17051 & 4.22 & 0.57 & 58.00@xmath98 0.55 & 2.26 & 0.92 & 320.10 & 0.16 & @xmath100 hor + 14954 & hd 19994 & 3.31 & 0.57 & 44.69@xmath98 0.75 & 2.00 & 1.30 & 454.00 & 0.20 & + 16537 & hd 22049 & 6.19 & 0.88 & 310.74@xmath98 0.85 & 0.86 & 3.30 & 2502.10 & 0.61 & @xmath101 eri + 17096 & hd 23079 & 4.42 & 0.58 & 28.90@xmath98 0.56 & 2.54 & 1.48 & 627.30 & 0.06 & + 19921 & hd 27442 & 3.14 & 1.08 & 54.84@xmath98 0.50 & 1.43 & 1.18 & 423.00 & 0.02 & subgiant + 20723 & hd 28185 & 4.82 & 0.71 & 25.28@xmath98 1.08 & 5.60 & 1.00 & 385.00 & 0.06 & + 24205 & hd 33636 & 4.77 & 0.58 & 34.85@xmath98 1.33 & 7.70 & 2.60 & 1553.00 & 0.39 & + 26381 & hd 37124 & 5.07 & 0.67 & 30.08@xmath98 1.15 & 1.04 & 0.58 & 155.00 & 0.19 & + 26394 & hd 39091 & 4.35 & 0.60 & 54.92@xmath98 0.45 & 10.37 & 3.34 & 2115.30 & 0.62 & + 27253 & hd 38529 & 2.80 & 0.74 & 23.57@xmath98 0.92 & 0.81 & 0.13 & 14.41 & 0.28 & subgiant + 31246 & hd 46375 & 5.22 & 0.86 & 29.93@xmath98 1.07 & 0.25 & 0.04 & 3.02 & 0.02 & + 33212 & hd 50554 & 4.40 & 0.53 & 32.23@xmath98 1.01 & 4.90 & 2.38 & 1279.00 & 0.42 & + 33719 & hd 52265 & 4.06 & 0.54 & 35.63@xmath98 0.84 & 1.13 & 0.49 & 118.96 & 0.29 & + 40687 & hd 68988 & 4.36 & 0.62 & 17.00@xmath98 0.96 & 1.90 & 0.07 & 6.28 & 0.14 & + 42723 & hd 74156 & 3.57 & 0.54 & 15.49@xmath98 1.01 & 1.56 & 0.28 & 51.61 & 0.65 & 3 + 43177 & hd 75289 & 4.05 & 0.58 & 34.55@xmath98 0.56 & 0.42 & 0.05 & 3.51 & 0.00 & + 43587 & hd 75732 & 5.46 & 0.87 & 79.80@xmath98 0.84 & 0.84 & 0.11 & 14.65 & 0.05 & 55 cnc + 45982 & hd 80606 & 5.10 & 0.72 & 17.13@xmath98 5.77 & 3.41 & 0.44 & 111.78 & 0.93 & + 47007 & hd 82943 & 4.35 & 0.59 & 36.42@xmath98 0.84 & 0.88 & 0.73 & 221.60 & 0.54 & 4 + 47202 & hd 83443 & 5.05 & 0.79 & 22.97@xmath98 0.90 & 0.35 & 0.04 & 2.99 & 0.08 & 5 + 50786 & hd 89744 & 2.79 & 0.49 & 25.65@xmath98 0.70 & 7.20 & 0.88 & 256.00 & 0.70 & + 52409 & hd 92788 & 4.76 & 0.69 & 30.94@xmath98 0.99 & 3.80 & 0.94 & 340.00 & 0.36 & + 53721 & hd 95128 & 4.36 & 0.56 & 71.04@xmath98 0.66 & 2.41 & 2.10 & 1096.00 & 0.10 & 47 uma , 6 + 59610 & hd 106252 & 4.49 & 0.64 & 26.71@xmath98 0.91 & 6.81 & 2.61 & 1500.00 & 0.54 & + 60644 & hd 108147 & 4.07 & 0.50 & 25.93@xmath98 0.69 & 0.34 & 0.10 & 10.88 & 0.56 & + 64426 & hd 114762 & 4.26 & 0.52 & 24.65@xmath98 1.44 & 11.00 & 0.30 & 84.03 & 0.33 & 7 + 64457 & hd 114783 & 6.02 & 0.91 & 48.95@xmath98 1.06 & 0.99 & 1.20 & 501.00 & 0.10 & + 65721 & hd 117176 & 3.71 & 0.69 & 55.22@xmath98 0.73 & 6.60 & 0.43 & 116.60 & 0.40 & 70 vir , subgiant + 67275 & hd 120136 & 3.53 & 0.48 & 64.12@xmath98 0.70 & 3.87 & 0.05 & 3.31 & 0.02 & @xmath102 boo + 68162 & hd 121504 & 4.30 & 0.59 & 22.54@xmath98 0.91 & 0.89 & 0.32 & 64.60 & 0.13 & + 72339 & hd 130332 & 5.68 & 0.75 & 33.60@xmath98 1.51 & 1.08 & 0.09 & 10.72 & 0.05 & + 74500 & hd 134987 & 4.40 & 0.70 & 38.98@xmath98 0.98 & 1.58 & 0.78 & 260.00 & 0.25 & + 77740 & hd 141937 & 4.63 & 0.60 & 29.89@xmath98 1.08 & 9.70 & 1.49 & 658.80 & 0.40 & + 78459 & hd 143761 & 4.19 & 0.61 & 57.38@xmath98 0.71 & 1.10 & 0.23 & 39.47 & 0.03 & @xmath10 crb + 79248 & hd 145675 & 5.38 & 0.90 & 55.11@xmath98 0.59 & 3.30 & 2.50 & 1619.00 & 0.35 & 14 her + 86796 & hd 160691 & 4.23 & 0.70 & 65.46@xmath98 0.80 & 1.97 & 1.65 & 743.00 & 0.62 & subgiant + 87330 & hd 162020 & 6.63 & 0.96 & 31.99@xmath98 1.48 & 13.73 & 0.08 & 8.43 & 0.28 & + 89844 & hd 168443 & 4.03 & 0.70 & 26.40@xmath98 0.85 & 7.20 & 0.29 & 57.90 & 0.54 & 8 , subgiant + 90004 & hd 168746 & 4.78 & 0.69 & 23.19@xmath98 0.96 & 0.24 & 0.07 & 6.41 & 0.00 & + 90485 & hd 169830 & 3.11 & 0.48 & 27.53@xmath98 0.91 & 2.96 & 0.82 & 230.40 & 0.34 & + 93746 & hd 177830 & 3.32 & 1.09 & 16.94@xmath98 0.76 & 1.28 & 1.00 & 391.00 & 0.43 & subgiant + 94076 & hd 178911 & 3.29 & 0.63 & 20.42@xmath98 1.57 & 6.29 & 0.33 & 71.49 & 0.12 & subgiant + 94645 & hd 179949 & 4.09 & 0.51 & 36.97@xmath98 0.80 & 0.84 & 0.05 & 3.09 & 0.05 & + 96901 & hd 186427 & 4.55 & 0.66 & 46.70@xmath98 0.52 & 1.50 & 1.70 & 804.00 & 0.67 & 16 cygb + 97336 & hd 187123 & 4.46 & 0.61 & 20.87@xmath98 0.71 & 0.52 & 0.04 & 3.10 & 0.03 & + 98714 & hd 190228 & 3.34 & 0.75 & 16.10@xmath98 0.81 & 4.99 & 2.31 & 1127.00 & 0.43 & subgiant + 99711 & hd 192263 & 6.30 & 0.94 & 50.27@xmath98 1.23 & 0.76 & 0.15 & 23.87 & 0.03 & + 100970 & hd 195019 & 4.05 & 0.64 & 26.77@xmath98 0.89 & 3.43 & 0.14 & 18.30 & 0.05 & + 104903 & hd 202206 & 4.75 & 0.71 & 21.58@xmath98 1.14 & 14.68 & 0.80 & 258.97 & 0.42 & + 108859 & hd 209458 & 4.29 & 0.53 & 21.24@xmath98 1.00 & 0.69 & 0.05 & 3.53 & 0.00 & + 109378 & hd 210277 & 4.90 & 0.77 & 46.97@xmath98 0.79 & 1.28 & 1.10 & 437.00 & 0.45 & + 111143 & hd 213240 & 3.75 & 0.61 & 24.54@xmath98 0.81 & 3.70 & 1.60 & 759.00 & 0.31 & + 113020 & gl 876 & 11.81 & 1.60 & 212.69@xmath98 2.10 & 1.98 & 0.21 & 61.02 & 0.27 & 9 + 113357 & hd 217014 & 4.56 & 0.66 & 65.10@xmath98 0.76 & 0.47 & 0.05 & 4.23 & 0.00 & 51 peg + 113421 & hd 217107 & 4.71 & 0.72 & 50.71@xmath98 0.75 & 1.28 & 0.07 & 7.11 & 0.14 & + 116906 & hd 222582 & 4.59 & 0.60 & 23.84@xmath98 1.11 & 5.40 & 1.35 & 576.00 & 0.71 & + rrrrrrrr 522 & 0.04 & 10 & 0.332 & 0.168 & 0.416 & -0.06 & -0.10 + 1292 & 0.11 & 1 & 0.459 & 0.289 & 0.300 & -0.06 & -0.17 + 3479 & -0.24 & 9 & 0.413 & 0.213 & 0.285 & -0.22 & 0.02 + 3502 & 0.22 & 9 & 0.467 & 0.288 & 0.392 & 0.22 & 0.00 + 5054 & -0.55 & 1 & 0.384 & 0.159 & 0.274 & -0.54 & 0.01 + 6643 & -0.09 & 11 & 0.362 & 0.169 & 0.378 & -0.22 & -0.13 + 7513 & 0.12 & 2 & 0.346 & 0.176 & 0.415 & -0.02 & -0.14 + 8159 & 0.16 & 3 & 0.440 & 0.238 & 0.379 & 0.08 & -0.08 + 9683 & 0.35 & 3 & 0.448 & 0.267 & 0.398 & 0.25 & -0.10 + 10138 & -0.20 & 1 & 0.484 & 0.337 & 0.287 & -0.14 & 0.06 + 12048 & 0.15 & 1 & 0.422 & 0.213 & 0.378 & -0.02 & -0.17 + 12653 & 0.25 & 1 & 0.357 & 0.188 & 0.364 & 0.08 & -0.17 + 14594 & 0.26 & 1 & 0.361 & 0.185 & 0.422 & 0.00 & -0.26 + 16537 & -0.07 & 1 & 0.504 & 0.430 & 0.263 & -0.28 & -0.21 + 17096 & & & 0.369 & 0.179 & 0.330 & -0.14 & + 19921 & 0.22 & 12 & 0.651 & 0.513 & 0.406 & 0.26 & 0.04 + 20723 & 0.24 & 1 & 0.443 & 0.264 & 0.352 & 0.15 & -0.09 + 24205 & -0.13 & 9 & 0.378 & 0.177 & 0.324 & -0.20 & -0.07 + 26381 & -0.41 & 3 & 0.421 & 0.202 & 0.280 & -0.37 & 0.04 + 26394 & & & 0.371 & 0.193 & 0.363 & 0.09 & + 27253 & 0.39 & 1 & 0.471 & 0.278 & 0.437 & 0.23 & -0.16 + 31246 & 0.21 & 3 & 0.502 & 0.401 & 0.337 & 0.01 & -0.20 + 33212 & 0.02 & 11 & 0.366 & 0.179 & 0.347 & -0.12 & -0.14 + 33719 & 0.24 & 1 & 0.360 & 0.190 & 0.404 & 0.08 & -0.16 + 40687 & 0.24 & 9 & 0.405 & 0.244 & 0.387 & 0.36 & 0.12 + 42723 & 0.13 & 11 & 0.375 & 0.181 & 0.390 & -0.06 & -0.19 + 43177 & 0.27 & 1 & 0.360 & 0.191 & 0.405 & 0.10 & -0.17 + 43587 & 0.45 & 4 & 0.536 & 0.357 & 0.415 & 0.10 & -0.35 + 45982 & 0.43 & 5 & 0.470 & 0.312 & 0.361 & 0.20 & -0.23 + 47007 & 0.33 & 1 & 0.386 & 0.217 & 0.390 & 0.27 & -0.06 + 47202 & 0.39 & 1 & 0.488 & 0.349 & 0.368 & 0.18 & -0.21 + 50786 & 0.30 & 3 & 0.338 & 0.184 & 0.451 & 0.14 & -0.16 + 52409 & 0.31 & 3 & 0.433 & 0.253 & 0.376 & 0.22 & -0.09 + 53721 & 0.01 & 6 & 0.391 & 0.202 & 0.343 & 0.02 & 0.01 + 59610 & -0.16 & 11 & 0.390 & 0.187 & 0.341 & -0.13 & 0.03 + 60644 & 0.20 & 1 & 0.346 & 0.177 & 0.391 & -0.01 & -0.21 + 64426 & -0.60 & 6 & 0.365 & 0.125 & 0.297 & -0.74 & -0.14 + 64457 & 0.33 & 9 & 0.521 & 0.458 & 0.309 & -0.17 & -0.50 + 65721 & -0.01 & 6 & 0.446 & 0.232 & 0.351 & -0.07 & -0.06 + 67275 & 0.32 & 7 & 0.318 & 0.177 & 0.439 & 0.13 & -0.19 + 68162 & 0.17 & 1 & 0.381 & 0.189 & 0.361 & -0.02 & -0.19 + 72339 & 0.05 & 3 & 0.475 & 0.305 & 0.316 & -0.02 & -0.07 + 74500 & 0.32 & 3 & 0.435 & 0.256 & 0.374 & 0.22 & -0.10 + 77740 & 0.16 & 11 & 0.388 & 0.225 & 0.346 & 0.24 & 0.08 + 78459 & -0.29 & 6 & 0.394 & 0.178 & 0.337 & -0.27 & 0.02 + 79248 & 0.50 & 8 & 0.537 & 0.366 & 0.438 & 0.13 & -0.37 + 86796 & 0.28 & 10 & 0.432 & 0.244 & 0.393 & 0.20 & -0.08 + 87330 & 0.01 & 1 & 0.579 & 0.534 & 0.244 & 0.11 & 0.10 + 89844 & 0.10 & 3 & 0.455 & 0.233 & 0.377 & -0.06 & -0.16 + 90004 & -0.06 & 1 & 0.435 & 0.223 & 0.342 & -0.09 & -0.03 + 90485 & 0.22 & 1 & 0.328 & 0.177 & 0.446 & 0.09 & -0.13 + 94076 & 0.28 & 13 & 0.403 & 0.219 & 0.378 & 0.16 & -0.12 + 94645 & 0.22 & 14 & 0.346 & 0.183 & 0.384 & 0.08 & -0.14 + 96901 & 0.07 & 7 & 0.416 & 0.226 & 0.354 & 0.09 & 0.02 + 97336 & 0.16 & 8 & 0.405 & 0.224 & 0.365 & 0.17 & 0.01 + 98714 & -0.24 & 1 & 0.482 & 0.264 & 0.306 & -0.27 & -0.03 + 99711 & -0.03 & 3 & 0.541 & 0.493 & 0.275 & -0.20 & -0.17 + 100970 & 0.16 & 15 & 0.419 & 0.204 & 0.362 & -0.11 & -0.27 + 104903 & 0.37 & 1 & 0.435 & 0.253 & 0.390 & 0.24 & -0.13 + 108859 & 0.04 & 3 & 0.361 & 0.174 & 0.362 & -0.15 & -0.19 + 109378 & 0.23 & 1 & 0.466 & 0.285 & 0.369 & 0.16 & -0.07 + 111143 & 0.16 & 1 & 0.387 & 0.190 & 0.399 & -0.02 & -0.18 + 113357 & 0.21 & 3 & 0.416 & 0.233 & 0.371 & 0.18 &
-0.03 + 113421 & 0.39 & 1 & 0.456 & 0.299 & 0.376 & 0.28 & -0.11 + 116906 & -0.01 & 16 & 0.406 & 0.202 & 0.345 & -0.08 & -0.07 + rrrrcrrrrrrl 522 & 39.00 @xmath98 0.64 & 575.2 & -39.9 & 2.6 & 2 & -58.2 & -37.2 & -12.1 & 58.0 & + 1292 & 56.76 @xmath98 0.53 & 433.9 & -57.9 & -5.8 & 1 & -33.0 & -16.6 & 2.7 & 27.5 & + 3479 & 30.58 @xmath98 1.08 & 313.5 & 150.0 & 55.4 & 2 & -53.1 & -5.2 & -55.9 & 65.0 & + 3502 & 12.85 @xmath98 1.27 & 125.2 & -124.0 & -14.1 & 7 & -16.5 & -59.3 & -25.2 & 57.3 & + 5054 & 24.80 @xmath98 0.89 & -169.0 & -527.7 & 23.0 & 1 & 85.4 & -66.6 & -3.4 & 113.5 & + 6643 & 22.65 @xmath98 0.82 & 252.6 & -158.6 & 18.9 & 1 & -44.3 & -37.0 & -30.3 & 52.1 & + 7513 & 74.25 @xmath98 0.72 & -172.6 & -381.0 & -28.3 & 2 & 28.5 & -22.1 & -14.6 & 42.7 & + 8159 & 30.71 @xmath98 0.81 & -45.0 & -105.4 & -43.5 & 1 & 35.6 & -26.7 & 15.0 & 55.0 & + 9683 & 26.91 @xmath98 0.83 & -107.8 & -175.3 & -52.2 & 6 & 55.1 & -31.7 & -0.1 & 70.6 & + 10138 & 91.63 @xmath98 0.61 & 2092.8 & 654.5 & 56.6 & 1 & -97.5 & -75.9 & -28.5 & 114.4 & + 12048 & 27.85 @xmath98 1.39 & -156.9 & -437.1 & -53.0 & 2 & 85.8 & -41.0 & 2.4 & 102.7 & + 12653 & 58.00 @xmath98 0.55 & 333.7 & 219.2 & 15.5 & 2 & -31.2 & -16.7 & -7.3 & 24.1 & + 14594 & 44.69 @xmath98 0.75 & -209.6 & -69.2 & 18.3 & 2 & 2.9 & 9.0 & -28.2 & 28.5 & + 16537 & 310.74 @xmath98 0.85 & -976.4 & 18.0 & 15.5 & 2 & -3.3 & 7.2 & -20.0 & 19.1 & + 17096 & 28.90 @xmath98 0.56 & -193.6 & -91.9 & -22.2 & 8 & 29.1 & 29.6 & 1.4 & 53.2 & + 19921 & 54.84 @xmath98 0.50 & -48.0 & -167.8 & 29.3 & 2 & 15.1 & -22.1 & -19.3 & 32.5 & + 20723 & 25.28 @xmath98 1.08 & 80.8 & -31.1 & 50.3 & 1 & -49.2 & -15.2 & -11.7 & 40.7 & + 24205 & 34.85 @xmath98 1.33 & 180.8 & -137.3 & -1.0 & 6 & 5.8 & -28.2 & 11.1 & 33.3 & + 26381 & 30.08 @xmath98 1.15 & -79.8 & -420.0 & -12.0 & 2 & 21.6 & -47.4 & -44.4 & 64.4 & + 26394 & 54.92 @xmath98 0.45 & 312.0 & 1050.2 & 9.4 & 2 &
-82.9 & -46.4 & 0.5 & 84.1 & + 27253 & 23.57 @xmath98 0.92 & -80.1 & -141.8 & 28.9 & 2 & -12.6 & -24.8 & -33.7 & 33.0 & + 31246 & 29.93 @xmath98 1.07 & 114.2 & -96.8 & 4.0 & 2 & 6.0 & -21.5 & 8.8 & 27.9 & + 33212 & 32.23 @xmath98 1.01 & -37.3 & -96.4 & -3.9 & 1 & 3.6 & -10.0 & -11.5 & 15.0 & + 33719 & 35.63 @xmath98 0.84 & -115.8 & 80.3 & 53.8 & 1 & -52.2 & -21.0 & -8.7 & 45.1 & + 40687 & 17.00 @xmath98 0.96 & 128.3 & 31.7 & -69.5 & 7 & 75.1 & -21.0 & -10.6 & 86.6 & + 42723 & 15.49 @xmath98 1.01 & 25.0 & -200.5 & 3.8 & 1 & 28.8 & -51.7 & -18.4 & 61.5 & + 43177 & 34.55 @xmath98 0.56 & -20.5 & -227.7 & 9.3 & 1 & 20.9 & -12.5 & -21.8 & 34.9 & + 43587 & 79.80 @xmath98 0.84 & -485.5 & -234.4 & 26.6 & 2 & -36.5 & -18.2 & -8.1 & 29.5 & + 45982 & 17.13 @xmath98 5.77 & 47.0 & 6.9 & 3.8 & 1 & 6.9 & 2.9 & 11.4 & 26.5 & + 47007 & 36.42 @xmath98 0.84 & 2.4 & -174.1 & 8.1 & 1 & 10.3 & -19.8 & -8.9 & 25.0 & + 47202 & 22.97 @xmath98 0.90 & 22.4 & -120.8 & 28.8 & 1 & 20.0 & -30.4 & -12.1 & 39.4 & + 50786 & 25.65 @xmath98 0.70 & -120.2 & -138.6 & -6.5 & 2 & -10.5 & -29.7 & -14.1 & 25.4 & + 52409 & 30.94 @xmath98 0.99 & -12.6 & -222.8 & -4.5 & 1 & 16.1 & -22.2 & -20.9 & 34.0 & + 53721 & 71.04 @xmath98 0.66 & -315.9 & 55.2 & 12.6 & 2 & -24.6 & -2.6 & 2.1 & 17.5 & + 59610 & 26.71 @xmath98 0.91 & 23.8 & -279.4 & 15.5 & 1 & 28.8 & -43.4 & 0.3 & 54.9 & + 60644 & 25.93 @xmath98 0.69 & -181.6 & -60.8 & -5.1 & 1 & -30.4 & -11.6 & -13.9 & 22.4 & + 64426 & 24.65 @xmath98 1.44 & -582.7 & -2.0 & 49.9 & 2 & -81.8 & -69.9 & 59.0 & 117.0 & + 64457 & 48.95 @xmath98 1.06 & -138.1 & 9.6 & -12.0 & 7 & -15.5 & -2.8 & -8.7 & 6.2 & + 65721 & 55.22 @xmath98 0.73 & -234.8 & -576.2 & 4.9 & 2 & 13.3 & -51.8 & -4.0 & 52.1 & + 67275 & 64.12 @xmath98 0.70 & -480.3 & 54.2 & -15.6 & 2 & -33.5 & -19.0 & -6.3 & 27.2 & + 68162 & 22.54 @xmath98 0.91 & -250.6 & -84.0 & 19.5 & 1 & -27.6 & -52.0 & -1.4 & 50.3 & + 72339 & 33.60 @xmath98 1.51 & -129.6 & -140.8 & -12.5 & 1 & -9.3 & -26.2 & -10.7 & 21.2 & + 74500 & 38.98 @xmath98 0.98 & -399.0 & -75.1 & 3.4 & 2 & -21.6 & -39.6 & 20.3 & 45.5 & + 77740 & 29.89 @xmath98 1.08 & 97.1 & 24.0 & -3.0 & 1 & 2.8 & 13.3 & -8.7 & 22.6 & + 78459 & 57.38 @xmath98 0.71 & -196.9 & -773.0 & 18.4 & 2 & 54.7 & -35.4 & 20.8 & 76.7 & + 79248 & 55.11 @xmath98 0.59 & 132.5 & -298.4 & -13.9 & 1 & 23.8 & -12.2 & -16.3 & 35.6 & + 86796 & 65.46 @xmath98 0.80 & -15.1 & -191.2 & 9.0 & 2 & 2.9 & -14.4 & -7.6 & 15.8 & + 87330 & 31.99 @xmath98 1.48 & 21.0 & -25.2 & -27.5 & 1 & -27.7 & 2.7 & -1.0 & 20.4 & + 89844 & 26.40 @xmath98 0.85 & -92.2 & -224.2 & -48.7 & 1 & -29.7 & -57.9 & -6.1 & 56.2 & + 90004 & 23.19 @xmath98 0.96 & -22.1 & -69.2 & -25.6 & 1 & -19.4 & -22.3 & -2.9 & 19.8 & + 90485 & 27.53 @xmath98 0.91 & -0.8 & 15.2 & -17.2 & 1 & -16.9 & 1.1 & 4.0 & 14.6 & + 93746 & 16.94 @xmath98 0.76 & -40.7 & -51.8 & -74.0 & 2 & -23.8 & -72.1 & -7.0 & 68.2 & + 94076 & 20.42 @xmath98 1.57 & 47.1 & 194.5 & -40.4 & 1 & -58.3 & -19.7 & 1.4 & 51.2 & + 94645 & 36.97 @xmath98 0.80 & 114.8 & -101.8 & -24.7 & 7 & -26.6 & -12.9 & -11.0 & 18.7 & + 96901 & 46.70 @xmath98 0.52 & -135.1 & -163.5 & -27.1 & 2 & 17.8 & -29.6 & -1.7 & 37.4 & + 97336 & 20.87 @xmath98 0.71 & 143.1 & -123.2 & -17.5 & 3 & 2.3 & -16.0 & -43.4 & 39.7 & + 98714 & 16.10 @xmath98 0.81 & 104.9 & -69.8 & -50.2 & 1 & -20.0 & -47.3 & -35.6 & 51.6 & + 99711 & 50.27 @xmath98 1.23 & -63.4 & 262.3 & -10.8 & 1 & -16.4 & 10.1 & 19.8 & 31.8 & + 100970 & 26.77 @xmath98 0.89 & 349.5 & -56.9 & -92.7 & 2 & -72.3 & -77.3 & -36.5 & 99.6 & + 104903 & 21.58 @xmath98 1.14 & -38.2 & -119.8 & 14.6 & 1 & 22.5 & -19.2 & -10.0 & 35.5 & + 108859 & 21.24 @xmath98 1.00 & 28.9 & -18.4 & -14.8 & 1 & -5.6 & -15.6 & 0.6 & 13.7 & + 109378 & 46.97 @xmath98 0.79 & 85.5 & -449.8 & -20.9 & 3 & 4.3 & -50.2 & -6.2 & 47.1 & + 111143 & 24.54 @xmath98 0.81 & -135.2 & -194.1 & -0.5 & 1 & 25.6 & -29.9 & 23.1 & 52.9 & + 113020 & 212.69 @xmath98 2.10 & 960.3 & -675.6 & -1.8 & 5 & -12.5 & -20.0 & -11.5 & 15.5 & + 113357 & 65.10 @xmath98 0.76 & 208.1 & 61.0 & -31.2 & 2 & -14.9 & -28.0 & 14.7 & 31.9 & + 113421 & 50.71 @xmath98 0.75 & -6.1 & -16.0 & -12.1 & 4 & -1.1 & -7.8 & 9.3 & 19.0 & + 116906 & 23.84 @xmath98 1.11 & -145.4 & -111.1 & 12.1 & 7 & 36.6 & -0.3 & -11.5 & 46.4 & + | we consider the metallicities and kinematics of nearby stars known to have planetary - mass companions in the general context of the overall properties of the local galactic disk .
we have used strmgren photometry to determine abundances for both the extrasolar - planet host stars and for a volume - limited sample of 486 f , g and k stars selected from the hipparcos catalogue .
the latter data show that the sun lies near the modal abundance of the disk , with over 45% of local stars having super - solar metallicities .
twenty of the latter stars ( 4.1% ) are known to have planetary - mass companions . using that ratio to scale data for the complete sample of planetary host stars , we find that the fraction of stars with extrasolar planets rises sharply with increasing abundance , confirming previous results
. however , the frequency remains at the 3 - 4% level for stars within @xmath0 dex of solar abundance , and falls to @xmath1 only for stars with abundances less than half solar .
given the present observational constraints , both in velocity precision and in the available time baseline , these numbers represent a lower limit to the frequency of extrasolar planetary systems .
a comparison between the kinematics of the planetary host stars and a representative sample of disk stars suggests that the former have an average age which is @xmath2 of the latter . |
_ iscsi _ is a protocol designed to transport scsi commands over a tcp / ip network .
+ _ iscsi _ can be used as a building block for network storage using existing ip infrastructure in a lan / wan environment .
it can connect different types of block - oriented storage devices to servers .
+ _ iscsi _ was initially standardized by ansi t10 and further developed by the ip storage working group of the ietf @xcite , which will publish soon an rfc .
many vendors in the storage industry as well as research projects are currently working on the implementation of the iscsi protocol .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ " the small computer systems interface ( scsi ) is a popular family of protocols for communicating with i / o devices , especially storage devices .
scsi is a client - server architecture .
clients of a scsi interface are called " initiators " .
initiators issue scsi " commands " to request services from components , logical units , of a server known as a " target " . a " scsi transport " maps the client - server scsi protocol to a specific interconnect .
initiators are one endpoint of a scsi transport and targets are the other endpoint .
the iscsi protocol describes a means of transporting of the scsi packets over tcp / ip , providing for an interoperable solution which can take advantage of existing internet infrastructure , internet management facilities and address distance limitations .
" draft - ietf - ips - iscsi-20 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ hyperscsi _ is a protocol that sends scsi commands using raw ethernet packets instead of the tcp / ip packets used for _
iscsi_. thus , it bypasses the tcp / ip stack of the os and does not suffer from the shortcomings of tcp / ip .
_ hyperscsi _ focuses on turning ethernet into a usable storage infrastructure by adding missing components such as flow control , segmentation , reassembly , encryption , access control lists and security .
it can be used to connect different type of storage , such as scsi , ide and usb devices .
_ hyperscsi _ is developed by the _ modular connected storage architecture _ group in the network storage technology division of the data storage institute from the agency for science , technology and research of singapore @xcite .
enbd is a linux kernel module coupled with a user space daemon that sends block requests from a linux client to a linux server using a tcp / ip connection .
it uses multichannel communications and implements internal failover and automatic balancing between the channels .
it supports encryption and authentication . + this block access technology is only useful with a linux kernel because of the linux specific block request format .
+ it is developed by the linux community @xcite under a gpl license .
the following hardware was used to perform the tests : * _ test2 _ : + dual pentium 3 - 1 ghz + 3com gigabit ethernet card based on broadcom bcm 5700 chipset + 1 western digital wd1800jb 180 gbytes + 3ware raid controller 7000-series * _ test11 _ : + dual pentium 4 - 2.4 ghz ( hyperthreading enabled ) + 6 western digital wd1800jb 180 gbytes + 3ware raid controllers 7000-series or promise ultra133 ide controllers + 3com gigabit ethernet card based on broadcom bcm 5700 chipset * _ test13 _ : + dual amd mp 2200 + + 6 western digital wd1800jb 180 gbytes + 3ware raid controllers 7000-series or promise ultra133 ide controllers + 3com gigabit ethernet card based on broadcom bcm 5700 chipset * iscsi server : eurologic elantra
ics2100 ip - san storage appliance - v1.0 @xcite + 3 scsi drives all the machines have a redhat 7.3 based distribution , with kernel 2.4.19 or 2.4.20 .
+ the following optimizations were made to improve the performance : sysctl -w vm.min-readahead=127 sysctl -w vm.max-readahead=256 sysctl -w vm.bdflush = 2 500 0 0 500 1000 60 20 0 elvtune -r 512 -w 1024
/dev / hd\{a , c , e , g , i , k } two benchmarks were used to measure the io bandwidth and the cpu load on the machines : * _ bonnie++ _ : v 1.03 @xcite + this benchmark measures the performance of harddrives and filesystems .
it aims at simulating a database like access pattern .
+ we are interested in two results : _sequential output block_ and _sequential input block_. + bonnie++ uses a filesize of 9gbytes with a chunksize of 8kbytes .
bonnie++ reports the cpu load for each test .
however , we found that the reported cpu load war incorrect .
so we used a standard monitoring tool ( vmstat ) to measure the cpu load during bonnie++ runs instead . * _ seqent_random_io64 : _ + in this benchmark , we were interested in three results : * * _ write _ performance : bandwidth measured for writing a file of 5 gbytes , with a blocksize of 1.5 mbytes .
* * _ sequential reading _ performance : bandwidth measured for sequential reading of a file of 5 gbytes with a blocksize of 1.5 mbytes . * * _ random reading _ performance : bandwidth measured for random reads within a file of 5 gbytes with a blocksize of 1.5 mbytes . +
this benchmark is a custom program used at cern to evaluate the performance of disk servers .
it simulates an access pattern used by cern applications .
_ vmstat _ has been used to monitor the cpu load on each machine .
the server was the eurologic ics2100 ip - san storage appliance @xcite . the client was _ test13 _ , with kernel 2.4.19smp .
two software initiators were used to connect to the iscsi server : ibmiscsi @xcite and linux - iscsi @xcite .
we used two versions of linux - iscsi : 2.1.2.9 , implementing version 0.8 of the iscsi draft , and 3.1.0.6 , implementing version 0.16 of the iscsi draft .
the results are given in the table below : [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] _ comments : _ softwareraid delivers more bandwidth than hardwareraid , but at a higher cpu cost .
i would like to thank all the people from the it / adc group at cern for helping me in this study and particularly markus schulz , arie van praag , remi tordeux , oscar ponce cruz , jan iven , peter kelemen and emanuele leonardi for their support , comments and ideas .
1 ietf ip storage working group + http://www.ietf.org/html.charters/ips-charter.html mcsa hyperscsi + http://nst.dsi.a-star.edu.sg/mcsa/hyperscsi/index.html enhanced network block device + http://www.it.uc3m.es/~ptb/nbd/ eurologic elantra ics2100 + http://www.eurologic.com/products_elantra.htm bonnie++ + http://www.coker.com.au/bonnie++/ ibmiscsi + http://www-124.ibm.com/developerworks/projects/naslib/ linux - iscsi + http://linux-iscsi.sourceforge.net/ | we report on our investigations on some technologies that can be used to build disk servers and networks of disk servers using commodity hardware and software solutions .
it focuses on the performance that can be achieved by these systems and gives measured figures for different configurations .
it is divided into two parts : iscsi and other technologies and hardware and software raid solutions .
the first part studies different technologies that can be used by clients to access disk servers using a gigabit ethernet network .
it covers block access technologies ( iscsi , hyperscsi , enbd ) .
experimental figures are given for different numbers of clients and servers .
the second part compares a system based on 3ware hardware raid controllers , a system using linux software raid and ide cards and a system mixing both hardware raid and software raid .
performance measurements for reading and writing are given for different raid levels . |
Subsets and Splits